To ot'kTOmeJIbCTBo, liTO ct. 148 tl\ npe.zr.ycMaTpHBaeT aM-
i\1elll.eHHe TOJIbKO nOJI02KllTeJIbHOrO YllI.ep6a, BbI3bIBaeT COMHeHlUI,
TaK KaK 3TllM HapyrnaeTcH 06ll1.ee nOJIO}l(eHlle CT. 117 fl(, npllToM
6e3 .zr.OCTaT01J.HbIX K TOMY oCHoBaHllH, B Ylll.ep6 HHTepecaM Tex,
I{TO 51BJIHeTCH He.zr.eecnoc06HbIM, a nOToMy HY2K.zr.aeTcfI B OC060H
3alll.HTe. .
06bI1J.HO nOBe.zr.eHHe .zr.eecnoc06Ho't0 Y1J.aCTHHKa c.zr.eJIKH .zr.OJI}I(HO
6bITb KBaJIH<pHIJ.HpOBaHo KaK BHHOBHoe: JIH60 OH gaKJII01J.HJI c.zr.eJI-
KY, 3HaH, 1J.TO ero KOHTpareHT Hecnoc06eH KO BCTynJIeHHIO B rpa2K-
.zr.aHcKo-npaBoBble OTHorneHHH, - H Tor.zr.a ero BHHOBHOCTb npHHH-
MaeT <POp MY YMbICJIa, JIH60 OH XOTfI H He 3HaJI, HO Mor H .zr.OJI2KeH
6bIJI 3HaTb 06 3TOM, - H Tor.zr.a OH .zr.eHcTBOBaJI HeOCTOp02KHO. Ho
.zr.a}j{e eCJIH ero nOBeJl.eHHe He 6bIJIO BHHOBHO, Ha Hero Bce paBHO
.zr.OJI2KHa 6bITb B03JIO}l(€Ha 06H3aHHOCTb B03MeCTHTb Ylll.ep6, npH-
1J.HHeHHbIH He.ll..eHCTBHTeJIbHbIM .zr.orOBopOM, TaK KaK B 3TOM npOHB-
"JIHeTCH pacnpe.ll..eJIHTeJIbHaH <PYHKIJ.HH npaBa. Ymep6 HaCTynHJI,
KTO-TO .ll..OJI2KeH ero nOKpbITb, He3aBHCHMO OT Toro, KTO HMeHHO
nOHec ero Henocpe.zr.CTBeHHO. CnpaBe.zr.JIHBO, 1J.T06bI ero nOKpbI.1J
.zr.eecnoc06HbIH KOHTp'areHT, a He JIHIJ.O He.ll..eecnoc06Hoe (.zr.a2Ke
eCJIH no npOTHBOpe'lHT 06ll1.€MY Ha'laJIY 060cHoBaHHH OTBeTCT-
BeHHOCTH BliHOH npH'lHHHTeJIH).
B JIHTepaType BbICKa3bIBaIOTCH no 3TOMY Bonpocy HHble cY2K-
.zr.eHHH. 12 TaK, .It M. reHKHH YTBep2K.zr.aeT, 1J.TO .zr.eecnoc06HblJ-J
y1J.aCTHliK c.zr.eJIKH OCB0602K.zr.aeTCfI OT oTBeTcTBeHHocTH, eCJIH .zr.oKa-
2KeT, 'iTO OH He 3HaJI H He Mor 3HaTb 0 He.ll..eecnoc06HOCTII KOH-
TpareHTa, TaK KaK no 06ll1.liM Ha'iaJIaM .zr.JIH OTBeTCTBeHHOCTli Tpe-
6yeTcH BHHa. C 3TlIMH YTBep2K.zr.eHHHMH COrJIaCHTbCH HeJIb3H. Co-
BeTCKoe rpa2K.zr.aHcKoe npaBO 31weT CJIY'laH oTcTynJIeHHH OT nplIH-
IJ.Hna OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH TOJIbKO npH BliHe, eCJIH .9TOrO Tpe6YloT
Ba}l(Hble C006pa2KeHHH. 13 B .ll..aHHOM c.'IY'iae .ll..JIH .9TOrO HMeIOTCH
.zr.OCT'aTO'iHble OCHOBaHHfI, He rOBopH 0 TOM, 1J.TO .9TOMY COOTBeT-
cTByeT TeKCT 3aKOHa (CT. 148), nOCKOJIbKY OH Tpe6yeT B03Melll.e-
HHH Bpe.ll..a B 6e30rOBOpO'lHOH <popMe, B TO BpeMH KaK CT. 151 fK
npe.zr.ycMaTpliBaeT B03Melll.eHHe Bpe.ll..a TOJIbKO OT CTOpOHbI, OTBeT-
CTBeHHOH 3a 3a6JIY2K.zr.eHHe.
7. CT. 151 fl( B Bonpoce 0 B03Melll.eHHH KOHTpareHTY YIl{ep6a
B cJIytJae cOBepmeHHH C.ll..eJIKH no.ll.. BJIHHHHeM cymecTBeHHoro 3a-
6JIY2K.n:.eHHfI .ll..OJI2KHa 6bITb nOHHMaeMa TaK, 'iTO OHa pa3JIH'iaeT
T'PH CJIY1J.aH: a) 3a6JIY2K.zr.eHHe npOlI30rnJIO CJIY'iaHHO; 6) OHO
6bIJIO BbI3BaHO npocToH HeOCTOp02KHOCTbIO O.zr.HOH H3 CTOpOH;
B) OHO 6'bIJIO BbI3BaHO rpy60H ee He6pe2KHOCTbIO.
o nepBoM CJIY1J.ae CT. 151 fl( He ynoMHHaeT, HO H3 ee co.zr.ep-
:>KaHlIH M02KHO npllHTll K BbIBO.zr.y, lITO eCJIH HH O.il,Ha 113 CTOpOH He
M02KeT 6bITb np1l3HaHa OTBeTCTBeHHOH 3a 3a6JIY2K.zr.eHHe, TO HI-!
12 CM.: }J. M. r e H K Ii H B yqeOHHKe «COBeTCKOe rpa1K.LJ;aHCKOe npaBO»,
1950, CTp. 236; B. A. PH C e H 1\ e B. J1eK1\HH Ha TeMY «CJleJIKH.. .», CTp. 33.
13 CM. O. C. 11 0 <p <p e. OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb no COBeTCKOMY rp3}l{.LJ;3HCKOMY
npaBY, CTp. 29.
162

OAHa HS HHX He BnpaBe npeADBTh K ApyroH CTopOHe Tpeoo-
BaHHe 0 BOSMemeHHH nOHeceHHoro elO ymepoa. K TaKOMY BhtBOAY
MO)KHO npHHTH nOTOMY, lITO CT. 151 rK (B lLIL 2 H 3) BosaraeT
oosaHHocTh BOSMeCTHTh BpeA Ha OAHY HS CTOpOH TOJIhKO B TOM
CJIYIJ:ae, eCH nOCJIeAH IBeTC OTBeTCTBeHHOH; «OTBeTCTBeH-
HOCTh» )Ke OSHaIJ:aeT «BHHOBHOCTh», HOO OTBeTCTBeHHhIM MO)KeT
6hITh TOhKO HU.O BHHOBHoe (eCH HHoe He YKasaHO B saKOHe).
YCTaHoBeHHe OCOOOH, nOBhIllleHHOH OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH npH rpy-
OOH HeOpe)KHOCTH (IJ:. 3 CT. 151) OSHaIJ:aeT, IJ:TO OTBeTCTBeHHOCTh
AO)KHa OhITh MeHhllleH, KorAa HeOpe)KHOCTh MeHee SHaIJ:HTeh-
Ha. 14 OpH 3TOM J{ npHMeHeHH IJ:. 2 CT. 151 rK TaK)Ke TpeoyeTcH
BHHa,15 HO He B tPopMe rpYOOH Heope:>KHOCTH, a B tPopMe npo-
CTOH HeOCTOpO)KHOCTH. TaKHM 06pasoM, IJ:. 2 CT. 15! rK nOAe)KHT
OTrpaHHIJ:eHHIO OT OTCYTCTBH BHHhI, C OJ{HOH CTOpOHhI, H OT rpy-
60H He6pe)KHOCTH - C ApyrOH.
OpH saOY)KAeHHH npOTHBonpaBHOCTh nOBeAeHHH Hu.a, OT-
BeTCTBeHHoro sa saOY)KAeHHe, He CTOJIh SHaIJ:HTebHa, IJ:TOOhI
OHO mIlllHOCh Hs-sa 3Toro npaBa Ha oopaTHoe nOYIJ:eHHe Bcero
HM HcnOHeHHoro no CAeKe. TeM He MeHee, OYAYIJ:H Bce )Ke BH-
HOBfthIM, OHO OOHsaHO BOSMeCTHTh ApyroH CTopOHe YIlI.epo, nOHe-
ceHHhIH elO BceACTBHe AorOBopa.
CoraCHO CT. 151 rK OTBeTCTBeHHhIM sa saoY)KAeHHe MO)KeT
OhITh H caMO nOTepneBlllee HU.O, T. e. caM saOY)KJ{aBlllHHC.
DOJIbllle Toro, HMeHHO OHO npeAnoaraeTC OTBeTCTBeHHhIM sa sa-
6Y)KAeHHe. Eho OCHOBhIBaeTC Ha TOM, IJ:TO BCKHH YIJ:aCTHHK
rpa)KJ{aHCKoro 060pOTa oOHsaH npoBTh HeOOXOAHMYIO OCMO-
TpHTehHocTh, oCTeperach TOro, IJ:TOOhI nOAnacTh nOJ{ BHHHe
JIO)KHhIX npeACTaBJIeHHH. 16 LL BOSO)KeHH Ha ApyrylO CTO-
POHY OOHsaHHOCTH B03MeCTHTh YIlI.epo HeOOXOAHMO, IJ:TOOhl npeA-
nOO)KeHHe 00 OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH saOY)KAaBlllerOCH OhIO onpo-
BeprHYTO H IJ:TOOhI BMeCTe C TeM Ohma AOKasaHa BHHa BTOpOH
CTOpOHhI. ECH )Ke OTCYTCTByeT BHHa KaK OAHOH, TaK H J{pyroH
CTOpOHhI ( BHHa saOY)KAaBlllerOCH onpOBepmYTa, a BHHa APY-
. roro YQ8CTHHKa CAeKH He AOKa3aHa), HHaQe rOBopH, KorAa sa-
6Y)KAeHHe HacTynHO CYIJ:aHHO II TeM caMhIM npOIICllleAlllHH
ymepo HIIKOMY B BHHY nOCTaBeH OhITb He MO)KeT, Ka)KAhIH HS
YIJ:aCTHHKOB CJ{eKH AO)KeH HeCTH CBOH YOhITKH caM.
8. rpyoaH HeOpe)KHOCTb BHHOBHOH CTOpOHhJ AO)KHa OhITh AO-
KasaHa. Aa)Ke eCH OTBeTCTBeHHOCTh npeslOMHpyeTcH, KaK TO
HMeeT MeCTO B OTHOllleHHH He6pe)KHOCTH saOY)KAaBllleroc. ECH
rpyoaH HeOpe)KHOCTh AOKasaHa, BosMemeHHIO nOAe)KaT He TOh-
1m nOO)KIITehHhIH ymepo B HMymecTBe, HO 11 Bce YOhITKH, Bhl-
14 CM. o. C. Ii 0 cjJ cjJ e. COBeTCKoe rpa>KAaHCKOe npaBO. CTp. 33.
15 Y'le6HlIK «COBeTCKoe rpa>KAaHCKOe npaBO» (T. I, 1959, CTp. 177) TaK>Ke
AonycKaeT o6H3aHHocTb B03MeIlteHlIH BpeAa rrpll HaJlll'lllll BlIHbI B cYIlteCTBeH-
HOM 3a6J1Y>KAeHlfH.
16 TOT >Ke npllH[\lI11 npoBoAlITCH rrpllMeHHTeJlbHO K KynJle-npOAa>Ke
CT. 195 rK
11*
163

:iB311l1ble TeM, IJTO ,I1,OfOBOp SaKJIlOIJeH, HO He MO)!{eT 6bITb HCnOJI-
lIell BCJIe.D.CTBIIe t;fO He,l1,eikTBIITeJIbHOCTII (IJ. 3 CT. 151 fK). 3TO
o:maIJaeT, tITO B YKasaHHblx CJIYIJaHX pasMep y6bITKOB orrpe,l1,eJIHeT-
CH no CT. ] 17 fK, KaK H npn HeIICnOJIHeHIIH ,I1,OroBOpHbIX 06Hsa-
TeJIbCTB, C B03MeI.IJ,eHIIeM He TOJIbKO nOJIO)!{IITeJIbHOrO YllI.ep6a, HO
H ynYllI.eHHOH BbIrO.D.bL B OCT3JIbHbIX )!{e CJIYIJ3HX OTBeTCTBeHHOCTI1
3a 336JIY)!{lleHIIe, B CIIJIY npHMoro YK333HIIH 33KOH3 (lJ. 2
CT. 151 fK) B03Mew.aeTCH TOJIbKO nOJIO)!{I1TeJIbHbIH yw.ep6.
H3,11,O nOJI3raTb, IJTO CCbIJIK3 B IJ. 3 CT. 151 rK H3 OTBeTCTBeH-
HOCTb CTOpOHbI K3K 3a HeHcnO.fmeHHe ,I1,OrOBopa OTHOCHTCH TOJIbKO
K pa3Mepy y6bITKOB, TOr.D.a KaK OCHOB3Hl1eM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTI1
BCer.D.a 6Y.D.eT npHIJIIHeHHe yw.ep6a Henp3BoMepHbIM BIIHOBHbIM
.D.eikTBIIeM. HeJIb3H, KaK y)!{e YKasbIBaJIOCb, CTaBHTb B3blCKalIHe
y6bITKOB B 3aBIICI1MOCTb OT HeIICnOJIHeHHH ,I1,orOBOpa, eCJIH HCnOJI-
HeHI1e ero He .D.OnYCKaeTCH Cl1JIOlO 3aKOHa H caM .D.OrOBOp aHHYJIH-
pOBaH.
TeKcT CT. 151 fK He MO)KeT 6bITb npl13HaH y,l1,OBJIeTBOpHTeJIb-
HbIM, TaK KaK OH OCTaBJIHeT OTKpbITbIM pH.D. BonpOCOB. TIOMIIMO
Toro, IJTO saKOH ,I1,OJI)!{eH ,I1,aTb 06w.He YKa3aHIuI 06 OTBeTCTBeHHOCTlI
B CJIYIJ3HX, npe,l1,YCMOTpeHHbIX He TOJIbKO CT. 151 rK, HO H CT. CT.
147, 149, 150 rK, He06xo,l1,HMO YTOIJHHTb TeKCT caMOH CT. 151 rK.
TaK, ,I1,OJI)!{HO 6bITb KOHKpeTII3IIpoBaHo nOHHTlIe y6bITKOB, BbISBaH-
HbIX CTOpOHOn. «KaK He IICnOJIHI1BllIen. .D.OrOBopa» B OTJIIIIJIIe OT
y6bITKOB, «nOHeceHHbIX BCJIe,l1,CTBHe .D.OrOBopa» (eCJIIi Bo06w.e Ta-
Koe pa3JIIIIJIIe ,I1,OJI)!{HO 6bITb coxpaHeHO B 3aKOHe). CJIe,l1,yeT TaK-
:tKe paCKpblTb nOHHTIIe «OTBeTCTBeHHOCTII 3a 3a6JIY)!{,I1,eHHe», no.D.-
IJepKHYTb, IJTO BO Bcex CJIYlJaHX OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb .D.onYCKaeTCH
JIHIllb npH IIaJIIIIJlIII BHHbL HaKOHelI., )!{eJI3TeJIbHO 06CY.D.HTb BO-
npoc, npaBIIJIbHO JIII B OTHOllieHIIII CJIyIJaeB 3a6JIY)!{,I1,eHI151 OTCTY-
naTb OT 06W.IIX nOJIO)!{eHIIH, II3JIO)!{eHHbIX B CT. 117 fK Ii CT. 403
fK, onpe,l1,eJIH51 OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb B pa3HoM 06"beMe B 3aBliCliMOCTIi
OT CTeneHI1 BIIHbl.
Ha caMOM .D.eJIe TaKoe oTCTynJIeHlle He Tpe6yeTC51. HaJIIIIJlIe
BliHbI B JIl060H ee <popMe ,I1,OJI)!{HO O.D.IIHaKOBO npllBO,l1,IITb K 0651-
3aHHOCTI1 B03Mew.eHlIH y6bITKOB, a no.D. y6bITKaMII Ha,l1,O nOHlIMaTh
He TOJIbKO nOJIO)!{IITeJIbHbIH yI..IJ,ep6, HO II ynYIlJ,eHHYlO BblfO,l1,y, II60
IlHaIJe 6b1JI 6bl HapYllieH TOT nplIHlI.lIn nOJIHorO B03MeI..IJ,eHlIH, KO-
TOpbIH II3BeCTeH COBeTCKOMY rpa)!{,I1,aHCKOMY npaBy. 17 KOHKpeT-
HbIH 06"beM npI1lJIIHeHHbIx, a nOTOMY nO.D.JIelliaw.IIX B03MellI.eHIIlO
y6bITKOB BCer.D.a onpe,l1,eJIHeTC51 CY,l1,OM, KOTOpbIH npIIHIIMaeT BO
BHI1MaHlie <paKTlIlJeCKlie 06CT051TeJIbCTBa, HO He ,I1,OJI)!{eH 6bITb JII1-
IlleH B03MO)!{HOCTII B3bICKIIBaTb TaK)!{e II ynYllI.eHHYlO BbIrO,l1,y.18
9. fpalli,l1,3HCKIIH KO,l1,eKC YMaJIIJHBaeT 0 pacnpe.D.eJIeHI1II y6bIT-
17 06 3TOM npnHnlle CM. O. C. 11 0   e. OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 1I0 COBeT-
CKOMY rpa}\{JlaHCKOMY npaBY. CTp. 25.
18 C. B. 3aHKOBCKa5! (YK. aBTopeepaT, CTp. 15) npeJlJlaraeT B3blCKJlBaTb
BO Bcex CJlY'Ia5!X TOJlbKO nOJlO}\{HTeJlbHblM Ylllep6.
164

KOB B np01.JlIX CJIY1.JaHX np1l3HaHlIH C.n.eJIKlI He.n.eHCTBlITeJIbHOH.
Bonpoc 3TOT .n.OJI)KeH n03TOMY pa3pelllaTbCH Ha OCHOBe 06IIlllX
nOJIO)KeHlIH rpa)K.n.aHcKoro npaBa, 06H3bIBalOIIlllX B03JIaraTb OT-
BeTCTBeHHocrb Ha Tex JIlIU, KOTopble npll1.JlIHlIJIlI YIIlep6 .n.pyroMY
BlIHOBHblMlI npOTlIBonpaBHblMlI .n.eHCTBlI5!MlI.
B Tex CJIY1.Ja5!X, Kor.n.a He.n.eHCTBlITeJIbHOCTb c.n.eJIKlI 06YCJIOBJIlI-
BaeTC5! ee npOTlIB033KOHHOCTblO H He.n.OJI)KHO nOJIyqeHHOe nOCTY-
naeT B .n.OXO.n. rocy.n.apCTBa, Ka)K.n.aH 113 CTOpOH OTBeqaeT nepe.n.
rocy.n.apCTBOM 11 nepe.n. TpeTbllMlI JIlIuaMlI 3a y6b1TKlI, npllqllHeHHble
elO JIlIqHO, 11 06e CTOpOHb OTBeqalDT COJIlI.n.apHO 3a y6blTKlI, npll-
41H1eHHble COBMeCHIO 3aKJIIOqeHlIeM lIJIlI lICnOJIHeHlIeM npOTlIl30-
33KOHHOH c.n.eJIKH. CTOpOHbl B c.n.eJIKe, nOCKOJIbKY OHlI 06e .n.eHCT-
BOBaJIlI BlIHOBHO, He lIMelOT npaBa Tpe60BaTb .n.pyr OT .n.pyra B03-
MeIIleHBH nOHeceHHbIX HMH y6bITKOB.
ECJIlI npB COBepllleHHH c.n.eJIKH npOTlIB03aKOHHO 11 BHHOBIIO
JJ,eHCTBOBaJIa TOJIbKO o.n.Ha H3 CTOpOH (CT. CT. 149 H 150 rK), OHa
TepHeT npaBO Ha B03BpaIIleHlIe em HCnOJIHeHHOro no c.n.eJIKe 11
BMeCTe C TeM .n.OJI)KHa B03MeCTHTb CBH3aHHble co c.n.eJIKOlD y6bIT-
KlI - KaK nOTepneBllleMY yqaCTHlIKY c.n.eJI, KlI TaK 11 TpeTbllM JIlI-
uaM, nOCTpa.n.aBlllllM B CBH3H co c.n.eJIKOH. BMeCTe C TeM BlIHOB-
HbIH .n.OJI)KeH HeCTlI caM BbInaBllllle Ha ero .n.OJIIO y6blTKlI 11 HH 01'
Koro B03MeIIleHlI5! lIX OJIm.n.aTb He MO)KeT.
B Tex CJIY1.JaHX, Kor.n.a 3aKOH npe.n.YCMaTpllBaeT lIJIlI cy.n. npl-
MeHHeT .n.ByCTOpOHHIOIO peCTHTYUlllO, y6blTKlI .n.OJI)KHa B03MewaTb
OTBeTCTBeHHaH (BlIHOBHaH) CTopOHa no npllMepy TOro, KaK 3TO
YKa3aHO B CT. 151 rK npllMeflHTeJIbHO K 3a6JIY)K.n.eHlIlD O.n.HOH 113
CTOpOH. fIpll 3TOM BlIHOBHaH CTopOHa .n.OJI)KHa B03MeCTlITb y6blTI<H
He TOJIbKO .n.pyrOMY yqaCTHlIKY c.n.eJIKlI, HO 11 TpeTbHM JIHUaM.
He HCKJIlOqeHa B03MO)KHOCTb Toro, qTO 06e CTOpOHbl .n.eHcTBo-
B3JIH BlIHOBHO JI1I60, Ha060poT, 06e .n.eHcTBOBaJIFI HeBHHOBHO. 19
B 3THX CJIY4aHX HeT OCHOBaHflH B3blCKHBaTb y6blTKlI C O.n.HOH CTO-
pO/lbl B nOJIb3Y .n.pyroH. TOT, KTO caM .n.eHcTBOB3JI BHHOBHO, He
MO)KeT npeTeH.n.OBaTb Ha B03MeIIleHHe eMY y6blTKOB; TOT, KTO .n.eH-
CTBOBaJI HeBflHOBHO, He .n.OJI)KeH HeCTFI OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a 1.JY)Kfle
y6blTKlI. LITO KaCaeTC5! OTBeTCTBeHHOCTFI CTOpOH nepe.n. TpeTbflMfI
.nHuaMfI, TO H 3.n.eCb Ha.n.o, HCXO.n.5! ll3 06IIlllX nOJIO)KeHHH, npH-
.LI.ep)KlIB3TbC5! Toro, 'ITO HeBlIHOBHble Y'IaCTHHKfI c.n.eJIKfI nepe.n.
HHMlI OTBe'IaTb He MorYT, a BHHOBHble yqaCTHlIKfI ,LI,OJI)KHbl Hel fH
COJIlI,LI,apHylD OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb, eCJIlI BlIHOBHbl OHlI 06a, JI1I60 3TY
OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb ,LI,OJI)KeH HeCTlI TOT 113 KOHTpareHTOB, KOTOpblH
O,LI,MH TOJIbKO 11 MO)KeT 6blTb npH3HaH BHHOBHbIM.
ECJIlI c.n.eJIKa npH3HaeTCH He,LI,eHCTBHTeJIbHOH 1I3-3a Toro, qTO
OHa 3aKJII01.JeHa 6e3 He06xo,LI,HMOrO Ha TO CorJIaClI5! TpeTbero
JIlIua, TO BHHOBHblH KOHTpareHT ,LI,OJI)KeH B03MeCTlITb y6blTKlI He
TOJIbKO ,LI,pyrOMY yq3CTHlIKY ClIeJIKlI, ,LI,eHCTBOBaBllIeMY HeBlIHOBHO,
19 HanpHMep, CTOpOHbl JJ.orOBOpHJlHCb He OcpOpMJlSlTb c.neJlKH B HOTapHaJlb-
110M nopSl.nKe HJlH, Ha060pOT, OHM ee He OcpOpMMJlH, HaXOJJ.SlCb 06a B HeBeJJ.eHHH
OTHOCMTeJlbHO Toro, 'ITO TaKoe ocpopMJleHMe no saKoHY 06S1SaTeJlbHo.
165

HO H TOMY JIHll.Y, npaBa H HHTepeCbl KOTOpOrO HapyrneHbI C.neJIKOH.
DpH BHHe 06eHX CTOpOH, OHH .nOJI>KHbI OTBe1JaTb CO"1H.napHO nepe.n
nOTepneBrnHM TpeTbHM JIHll.OM.
ECJIH C.neJIKa npHSHaeTCH He.neHCTBHTeJIbHOH nOTOMY. 1JTO no-
BepeHHbIH BbIrneJI sa npe.neJlbl CBOHX nOJlHOM01JHH, OTBeTCTBeH-
HOCTb sa BOSHHKrnHe BCJle.nCTBHe 3Toro y6bITKH .nOJI>KeH HecnI
B nepBYIO 01Jepe,nb nOBepeHHbIH. Do OTHorneHHIO K .nOBepHTeJIIO -
3TO OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb .nOrOBopHaH (noCKOJIbKY pe1Jb H.neT 0 .noro-
BOpHOM npe.ncTaBHTeJIbCTBe), no OTHorneHHIO K .npyroH CTopOHe
B c.neJIKe, eCJIH nOCJIe.nHHH .neHcTBOBaJIa .n06pocoBecTHo, - 3TO OT-
BeTCTBeHHOCTb BHe.noroBopHaH. KOHTpareHT, .neikmoBaBrnHH He-
.n06pOCOBeCTHO, He MO>KeT npeTeH.nOBaTb Ha BOSMemeHHe nOHe-
ceHHbIX HM y6bITKOB, a npH onpe.neJIeHHbIX YCJIOBHHX (B 1JaCTHOCTH
npM SJIOHaMepeHHOM COrJIarneHHH t nOBep.eHHbIM) .na>Ke 06HsaH
HeCTH OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb nepe.n .npyroH CTOpOHOH (T. e. nepe.n .11.0-
BepHTeJIeM) no CT. 403 fK cOJIH.napHO C nOBepeHHbIM. TaK >Ke
onpe,neJIHeTCH OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb no OTHorneHHIO K TpeTbHM JIHIJ:aM.
OTBeTcTBeHHocTb nepe.n ,noBepHTeJIeM 060HX 06HsaHHbIx JIHIJ:
(noBepeHHoro H Y1JaCTHHKa c.neJIKH), HecMoTpH Ha paSJIH1JHe OCHO-
BaHMH (CT. 253 fK .n.JIH o.n.Horo. CT. 403 rK .n.JlH .n.pyroro), Bcer.n.a
.nOJI>KHa 6bITb cOJIH.n.apHoH, nOCKOJIbKY iPaKTH1JeCKHH COCTaB npH-
MeHHTeJlbHO K .n.eiicTBHHM, npl1Be.nlllHM K HI;\CTynJleHHIO Bpe.na,
O.nHH H TOT >Ke. LleHCTBHH 3TH COBeprneHbl COBMeCTHO, a Bpe.n,
HMM npM1JHHeHHbIH, HBJIHeTCH Hepas,neJlbHbIM. DpM TaKMX YCJIO-
BHHX YCTaHOBJIeHHe COJIM.n.apHOH OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH, HesaBMCHMO OT
pa3JlH1JMH ee OCHOBmmH (.n.OroBOP B OTHorneHHH o.n.Horo HS HMX,
npH1JHHeHHe BHe,norOBopHoro Bpe.n.a B OTHorneHHH .n.pyroro), npe.n.-
CTaBJIHeTCH e.n.HHCTBeHHO npaBMJIbHbIM perneHMeM Bonpoca. DpH-
MeHeHHe ,nOJIeBOH JIH60 cy6CH.n.HapHOH OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH npHBO-
.n.HJIO 6bI K HenpaBHJlbHbIM peSYJIbTaTaM H .n.a>Ke Bo06UJ.e BPH.n.
JIH 6blJIO 6bl ocyrueCTBHMO.
166

rJIABA v
HCKOBAH ABHOCTb no EnAM
o HEEDcTBHTEnbHOCTH CEnOK'
1. [JpHMoro OTBeTa Ha Bonpoc 0 npHMeHeHlUI .n:aBHOCTH no .n:e-
JIaM 0 npH3HaHHH c.n:eJIKH He.n:eikTBHTeJIbHOH B 3aKOHe HeT. [Jo-
3TOMY OH .n:OJILKeH 6bITb pa3perneH B COOTBeTCTBHH C 061I1HMH
npHHuHnaMH, YCTaHOBJIeHHbIMH B rK.
LITO KacaeTCH HaqaJIbHOrO MOMeHTa TeqeHHH .n:aBHOCTHoro
cpOKa, TO, COrJIaCHO CT. 45 rK, TeqeHHe ero HaqHH3eTCH co BpeMe-
HH, Kor.n:a B03HHKaeT npaBo Ha npe.n:'bHBJIeHHe HCKa. [JOCKOJIbKY
npaBo Tpe60BaTb npH3HaHHH c.n:eJIKH He.n:eHcTBHTeJIbHOH (o.n:HHa-
KOBO, KaK CJI.eJIKH HHqTOLKHOH, TaK H c.n:eJIKH ocnopHMOH) B03HH-
KaeT C MOMeHTa ee COBeprneHHH, TO C 3TOro HMeHHO MOMeHTa
.n:OJILKHO HaqHHaTbCH TeqeHHe cpOKa .n:aBHOCTH.
CaMbIH CpOK .n:aBHOCTH, PYKOBO.n:CTBY5ICb CT. 44 rK, COMHeHHH
BbI3bIBaTb He .n:OJILKeH. HH .n:JI5I ocnapHBaHH5I c.n:eJIKH, HH .n:JIH Tpe-
60BaHHH 0 npH3HaHHH He.n:eHCTBlneJIbHOH c.n:eJIKH HHqTOLKHOH, cne-
lJ.HaJIbHbIe CpOKH He YCTaHOBJIeHI; n03TOMY HCKH no.n:06Horo po.n:a,
OqeBH.n:HO, .n:OJILKHbI no.n:qHHHTbCH .n:eHCTBHIO 061I1HX CpOKOB"- TPH
ro.n:a .n:JI5I cnopOB, r.n:e XOTH 6bI o.n:Ha H3 CTOpOH 5IBJI5IeTC5I rpaLK.n:a-
HHHOM, H nOJITOpa ro.n:a, Kor.n:a 06e CTOpOHbI HBJI5IIOTCH COlJ.HaJIH-
CTHqeCKHMH opraHH3alJ.HHMH.
LI.JI5I ocnapHBaHH5I c.n:eJIOK ocnopHMbIX, 6bIJIO 6bI npaBHJIbHO
YCTaHOBHTb OC06bIH, COKpalIleHHbIH CpOK, B lJ.eJI5IX CKopeHrnero
pa3perneHH5I Cy.n:b6bI c.n:eJIKH, B OTHOIlleHHH KOTOpOH MOLKeT 6bITb
B036YLK.n:eH cnop. 3TOT OC06bIH, COKpalIleHHbIH CpOK CJIe.n:yeT HC-
QHCJI5ITb CO .n:H5I, Kor.n:a 0 COBeprneHHH c.n:eJIKH CTaJIO H3BeCTHO
JIHlJ.Y, ynpaBOMOqeHHOMY Ha ee ocnapHBaHHe, HO BO BC5IKOM CJIY-
qae B npe.n:eJIax 061I1HX CpOKOB HCKOBOH .n:aBHOCTH.
2. 3HaqHTeJIbHO 60JIee CJIOLKHbIM HBJI5IeTC5I Bonpoc - BO Bcex
JIH cJIyqa5Ix Tpe60BaHHe 0 npH3HaHHH c.n:eJIKH He.n:eHcTBHTeJIbHOH
norarnaeTCH HCKOBOH .n:aBHOCTblO. CJIe.n:yeT nOJIaraTb, qTO B Tex
CJIyqaHX, Kor.n:a peqb H.n:eT 0 c.n:eJIKe, npoTHB03aKoHHoH no CT. 30
rK,'H B CB5I3H C 3THM 0 B3bICKaHHH He.n:OJILKHO nOJIyqeHl-IOro no
167

CJ1,eJIKe B J1,OXOJ1, rOCYJ1,apCTBa, )].aBHOCTHbte CpOKH npHMeHeHHSI H-
XO.lUITb He ,lI,OJDKHbI. DpOTHBosaKOHHaSI C,lI,eJIKa I-mqTOLKHa C ca-
Moro HaqaJIa, 11 HHKaKoe llCTeqeHHe cpOKa He MO>KeT rrpeBpaTHTb
ee B ,lI,eikTBHTeJIbHYIO, cnoc06HYIO nOpO.lU1Tb Te HJIH HHhle npaBO-
OTHOllIeHHSI. 11 MYII1,eCTBO, nO,lI,JIe}KaII1,ee BSblCKalUllO B ,lI,OXO,lI, ro-
CY,lI,apCTB8, npHSH8eTC5I, KaK YKaSbIBaJIOCb BbIllIe, c06CTBeHHOCTbfO
rOCYJL8pCTBa, 8 Ha Tpe60BaHlUI rOCYJLapCTBa 0 BbIJL8tIe npHHaJLJIe-
>K8II1,erO eMY HMYIIl.eCTBa ,lI,aBHOCTHble CpOKH, K8K HSBeCTHO, He
pacnpOCTp8HHfOTCH. 3TOT nopHAOK npaBHJIbHO rrpHMeHHTb He
TOJIbKO K BHH)1.HK8U;I10HHblM HCK8M, HO TaK>Ke H B Tex CJIYQa5IX,
KOr)1.a peqb HJLeT 06 06SISaTeJIbCTBeHHo-npaBoBwx Tpe60BaHH5IX,
OCHOB8HHblX Ha HeOCHOBaTeJIbHOM 060r8meHHH CTOpOHbl B C.lJ.eJIKe.
Bo Bcex OCT8JIbHX cJIyqa5Ix HHqTO>KHOCTH C,lI,eJIKH 8BHOCTh
,lJ,OJI}J(Ha 6blTb npHMeHeH8 Ha 06II1,HX OCHOBaHHSIX - H TOr,lI,8,
Korpa CpeJIK8 HHqTO>KHa BCJIe,lI,CTBHe H8pyrneHHH 06SI3aTeJIb-
HOM OpMbI llJUi BCJIe.n.CTBlie cOBeprneHHH ee C JUIHOM HeAee-
cnoc06HblM, H60 3.lI.eCh B KOHeqHOM HTore .lI.eJIO CBO.LI.HTCH K HMy-
IlJ,eCTBeHHbIM Tpe60BaHHSIM yqaCnmKOB C.lI.eJIKH, HMeIOIll.l'IX rrpa-
BO Ha 06paTHoe nOJIyqeHHe HCnOJIHeHHOro HMH no C.lI.eJIKe. BBH.lI.Y
::noro HeT rrpH1.lHH .lIOnycKaTb aHHYJIHpOB8HHe CLLeJIKH 33 npelle-
u
JI8Mli CpOKOB liCKOBOH .lJ.aBHOCTH.
JJ.aBHOCTb n0.LI.JIe}KHT npHMeHeHHIO H B Tex CJIyqaHX, KOr.LI.a sa-
KOH npe.lI.YCMaTpHBaeT OJ1.HOCTOpOHHIOIO HJIH J1.BYCTOPOHHIOIO pe-
CTHTYHIO (CT. CT. 32 H 33 fK, C nOCJIeJICTBHHMH no CT. 148, 149,
150 H 151 rK), KaK II BO Beex npOtlHX CJJyqa51X, KOf.n-a c.n-eJIKa He
IHI1.lTO}KH8, a ocnopHMa. ECJIH saKOH CTaBHT ocnapHBaHHe C.l1,eJIKH
B saBHCIiMOCTb OT YCMOTpeHHH rrOTepneBllIero, 3TOMY YCMOTpeHMIO
J1.0JImeH 6bITb nOJIOlKeH rrpeJ1.eJI BO BpeMeHH nYTeM npHMeHeHHH
06II1,HX .n.aBHOCTHbIX CpOKOB (eCJIH B saKOHe He 6y.n.YT YCT8HOBJIeHbI
crreu.HaJIbHblE' COKpameHHbIe CpOKH). 3TOMY He npOTI1BOpeqlIT H
T9, qTO saKOH npe.n.YCMaTpI-IBaeT npH onpe.n.eJIeHHblX YCJIOBH5IX
(CT. CT. 149 II 150 fK.) BOSMO}KHOCTb HS'bHTHH HCnOJIHeHHoro BH-
HOBHOM CTOpOHOH B 1I.OXO.ll rocY1I.apCTBa, H60 npHMeHeHHe Kapa-
TeJIbHblX C8HKII.HH. B YKas8HHbiX CJIyqaHX HOCHT Boo6lD.e YCJIOBHbIH
xapaKTep, He 51BJISIeTCSI HeHS6e>KHbIM nOCJIe.lI.CTBHeM He6JIarOBH.lI.-
Horo nOBe1I.eHIUI BHHOBHoro JIHl.{a, a saBHCHT OT Bos6Y>K.QeHlUI
cnopa rrpOTHB C1I.eJIKH co CTOpOHbI nOTepneBlllero, KOr.lJ.a, KaK YI<a-
saHO, npe,lJ.'bSIBJIeHHe HCK8 He MO}KeT 6blTb HS'bSITO H3-nO}.I. .n.eikT-
u
BHH HCKOBOH ,lI,3BHOCTH.
LIaBHocTb no.n.JIemHT npHMeHeHHIO T3Kme BO Bcex Tex CJIYQ8HX,
KorJ].a cnap npoTl-lB CJ1eJIKH MO}J(eT 6blTb B036Y}K)leH nocTopoH-
HHMH, He YQ8CTBOBaBrnHMI1 B C.lI.eJIKe JIHll.8MII, H60 H,. B 3TOM CJIY-
4ae .QJIH Cy6'bCKTOB, ynpaBoM04eHHbiX Ha ocnapHB8HHe CAeJIKH,
.lI.OJI)KHO 1I.eikTBOBaTb o6IlI,ee nOJIO}KeHHe 06 YTpaTe npaBa Ha HCK
no J1CTe1.leHHH cpoKa .lI.aBHOCTH.
CaMO C060M paSYMeeTcSI, lITO CpOK P8BHOCTJ1 Bcer.n-a MO}I(eT
6blTb BocCTaHOBJIeH, eCJIM nponycK ero BbI3BaH YBamJ1TeJIbHbIMH
npH4HHaMH (CT. 49 [I(). I( Tpe6oB3HI1SIM saHHTepeCOB8HHOM CTO-
168

pORbI 0 BOCCTaHOBJIeHHH nponyrn.eHHOrO CpORa Cy.u.bI JI.OJDKHbI OT-
HOCHTbCfI C OC06bIM BHHMaHHeM B TeX CJIyqaSIX. KOrJI.a peqb H!leT
OJ
o C.u.eJIKaX, ROTOpbIe HOCflT pe3KO aHTHCOlI.HaJIbHbIll XapaKTep
(HanplIMep, KOrJI.a C.u.eJIKa 6bIJIa 3aKJIIOqeHa nOJI. BJIHSIHHeM yrpo3,
06MaHa H np.).
2. Ha Bonpoc 0 npHMeHeHHH .n;aBHOCTHbIX CpOKOB K .u.eJIaM
o rrpH3HaHHH C!leJIKH He.u.eHcTBHTeJIbHOH cY!le6HaSI npaKTHKa He
.n.aeT SICHoro OTBeTa. TaR, B OAHOM cJIyqae BepxoBHbIH Cy.n. CCCP
He OCTaHOBMJ1C5:I Ha nponYCKe .n.aBHOCTHoro cpOKa no ll.eJIY
... ...
o npH3HaHHH C!leJIKH HeJI.ellCTBlITeJIbHOH BBHJI.Y HapyrneHHSI ero
06f13aTeJIbHOH, noJI. CTpaXOM He.lI.eHCTBHTeJIbHOCTH, £}JOPMbI. I
B .lI.pyroM CJIyqae OH YKa3aJI H3 TO. qTO HeB036Y:>KJI.eHHe B Te.
... "
qeHHe ceMlI neT cnopa npOTlm C.lI.eJIKH, HeJI.eHCTBllTeJIbHOlI no CT.
30 rK C I10CJIe.n.CTBHSIMH no CT. 147 rK. He MO:>KeT CJlY*IITb OCHO-
BaHHeM JI.JIfi OTKa3a 4>HHOTJI.eJIY B MCKe. 2 B HHbIX CJIyqaSIX OR
llpH.n;aeT 3HaLfeHHe nponYCKY cpOKa Ha npe.u.'MIBJIeHHe HCRa 0 npH-
.. ...
3HaHHH He.lI.eHCTBHTeJIbHOCTll C.lI.eJIKH, COBeprneHHOH C Hapyrne-
HHeM CT. 64 fK. 3 HanpaBJIeHHOH Ha HesaKOHHbIU 06MeH lKMJIOH
TIJIorn.aJI.H -t- llJIIl COBeprneHHOH .u.OMaIlIHIIM nOpflJI.KOM BMeCTO 065I-
SaTeJIbHOrO ocpopMJIeHHSI B HOTapHaJIbHOM nOpSIJI.Ke. 5
3Tl-J OT.lI.eJIbHble onpeJI.eJIeHHSI, XOTfi OHH II He BCerJI.a nOCJIe.lI.O-
BaTeJIbHbI H nO.lI.p06HO He MOTHBIIpOBaHbl. n.alOT OCHOBaHHe no-
JIaraTb, LITO BepXOBHbIH Cy.lI. CCCP HaX0.lI.HT B03MO)KHbIM nplI-
"
MeHHTb CpOKI1 I1CKOBOH .u.aBHOCTH no .lI.eJIaM 0 npH3I1aHlUI C.lI.eJIKH
... ...
He.n.eHCTBHTeJIbHOH sa HCKJIIOt.IeHHeM Tex CJIyqaeB, Kor.u.a peLfb H)J,eT
o npH3HaHlIH C)leJIKH He.neHCTBIITeJIbHOH no CT. 30 fI( BBH.ny ee
npOTIIB03aKOHHOCTII. Ho pet.Ib lIJJ.eT TOJIbKO 06 OT.lI.eJIbHbIX, 60JIee
...
IIJIH MeHee CJIYLIaHHbIX YKa3aHllHX, npHTOM He BCer.lI.a np5lMO BbI-
pa)KeHHbIX, a TOJIbKO npe)lnOJIaraeMbIX, a HHor.a.a H npOTliBOpe-
LIIIBbIX.
Me)l{,n,y TeM Bonpoc 0 nplIMeHeHHH HCKOBOH .u.aBHOCTH no )le-
...
JIaM, CB5I3aHHbIM C He.lI.eHCTBHTeJIbHOCTblO C)J,eJIOK, HMeeT He TOJIb-
KO TeOpeTHqeCKOe, HO II npaKTHqeCKOe 3HaLIeHHe. n03TOMY Heo6-
XOJ1,HMO, lJ.To6bI nJIeHYM BepXOBHoro Cy.n.a CCCP llaJI PYKOBOJUI-
rn.He YKasaHHSI, KOTopbIe YCTpaHHJIH 6bI KOJIe6aHHH B IlpaKTHKe
CyJI.OB H pa3HopeLIlIBbIe cy:>KJI.eHH5I B JIHTepaType.
I OnpeJI.eJIeUHe BepXOBHoro CYJl.3 CCCP OT 28 cl>eBpaJIR 195,1 r. no HCKY
Ky6aHeHllIBHJIH K UOMaH (CYJI.e6HaH npaKTfIKa BepxoBHoro CY.ll.C:I CCCP, 1951,
N 10, CTp. 28).
20npeJI.eJIeHHe BepXOBHoro CYJI.a CCCP OT 30 ceHTH6pH 1952 r. no HCKY
q,HHaHcoBoro OTJI.e.r. K MaKpHHoBY (Cy.n:.eoHaH npaKTHKa BepxoBHoro CYJJ.a
CCCP, 1952, N2 12, CTp. 21).
30npeJI.eJIeHHe BepxoBHoro CYJl.3 CCCP OT 30 HIOHH 1951 r. no HCKY IlIe-
JlyxHHa H .n:.pymx K THlllHHOM (CY}l.e6HaH npaKTHKa BepxoBHofO CYAa CCCP,
1951, .N2 9, CTp. 31).
40npeJl.eJIeHHe BepXOBHoro CYJl.a CCCP OT 14 HIOHR 1943 r. no HCKY
3JIH8Ba I{ K06aXHJl.3e (C60pHHK nOCTaHOBJIeHHH flJIeHYMa H onpe.n:.eJIeHHH KOJI-
JIerHH BepxoBHoro CYJl.a CCCP 3a 1943 f., CTp. 166).
5 CM. onpe.neJIeHHe BepXOBHOfO Cy.na CCCP OT 26 anpeJIH 1950 f. no .n.e.rry
ry6HHbIx (CYJI.e6H3H npaKTHKa BepxoBHoro Cy.n:.a CCCP, 1950, N!! 10, CTp. 30).
169

PYKOBO.lI.CTBYSICb npHBe.n.eHHbIMH Bblilie C006pa>KeHHHMH, npe.lI.
u
CTaBJIHeTCH npaBHJIbHbIM YCTaHOBHTb CJIe.n.YIOI.I{HH nOp51J(oK:
I) K .lI.eJIaM 0 npH3HaHHH c.n.eJIKH He,AeikTBHTeJIbHOH H 0 CBH
38HHbIX C 3THM TpeooBaHHSIx CpOKH HCKOBOH ,AaBHOCTH .n:OJDKHbI
nOJIYLJ8Tb npHMeHeHHe Ha 06lI.(HX OCHOBaHHHX.
2) O.n.H8KO JI.JIH Tpe60BaHHSI 0 npH3HaHHH c.n.eJIKH HHLJTOLKHOH
BBH.lI.Y ee npOTHBo3aKoHHocTH B CHJIY CT. 30 rK, a TaK)Ke .lI.JIH
CBSI3aHHblX C 3THM Tpe60BaHHH 06 H3'bSITHH HMym.ecTB8 B JI.OXO)I.
u
rocYJI.apcTBa CpOKH MCKOBOH JI.aBHOCTH He JI.OJDKHbl HaXOJI.HTb npM-
MeHeHHSJ., TaK JKe KaK BO Bcex CJlyqaHX, KOrJI.a npeJI.MeTOM c.n.eJlKH
HBJI51eTCSJ. rOCY.lI.apCTBeHH8H coocTBeHHocTb.
3) H8qaJIbHbIM MOMeHTOM TeqeHHH cpOKa HCKOBOH JI.8BHOCTH
.lI.OJDKeH 5lBJIHTbCSI MOMeHT cOBepIIIeHHH C.lI.eJIKH; MOMeHT ee HCnOJI-
HeHHSI 3HaqeHHH HMeTb He MOJKeT, nOCKOJIbKY HCnOJIHeHHe npOH3-
" .
BOJI.HTCSI Ha OCHOBaHHH c.n.eJIKH, aHHYJlHpOBaHHe KOTOpOH B03MOLK-
.
HO TOJlbKO B npeJI.eJI8X cpOKa HCKOBOH AaBHOCTH, CQHT8H C MO-
MeHTa ee 3aKJIIOQeHHH.
4) )KeJI8TeJIbHO YCTaHoBHTb oco6ble CpOKH llJIH ocnapHBaHHSI
C)J,eJIOK ocnOpHMb[X, CQHTaSI 3TH CpOKH C Toro MOMeHTa, KorA8
ynpaBOMOlleHHOMY Ha ocnapHB8HHe c.n.eJIKH JIHIJ.Y CT8JIO H3BeCTHO
06 ee cOBepllIeHHll, HO BO BCSIKOM cJIY'lJae - B npe.n:.eJIax 06llJ,HX
...
CpOKOB HCKOBOH )J,aBHOCTH.
.
170

"
OrJIABJ1EHHE
r JI a B 8<.1) npHpoAa
CAeJlOK .
CeJlOK H HX sneMeHTbI. HeJJ,eiicTBHTeJlbHOCTb
. . . . . . .
3
r JI 3 B a II. OCHOBaHHR npH3H3HHH C.u.eJIKH He.u.eiicTBHTeJIbHOH . .. 22
 I. HenpaBoMepHoCTb co.u.ep}KaHHR BonH, Bblpa>KeHHOH B
c.n.eJIKe . . . . ... _ ......
 2. COBepllleHHe c.u.enOK He.u.eecnoco6HbIMH JIHIJ.aMH .. 57
 3. H3BpameHHe nO,U.JIHHHOH BOJIH CTOpOHbI . . '. 62
If 4. nOpOKH cl>OpMbI . . . . . . .' .. 75
 5. HecooTBeTcTBHe BOJIeH3'bSlBJIeHHR BOJIe cy6"beKT3. 84
 6. OTcYTCTBHe Tpe6yeMoro no 33KOHY cor JIaCHH TpeTbHX
JIHIJ. ." . . .' .,. 95
r JI a BIlL OCJIeCTBHH HeeHCTBHTeJlbHOCTH CAenOK 110
 I. 06ll1.He BonpocbI . . . " . .
 2. Cnoco6bI H3"bHTHR He.n.OJI>KHO nOJIyqeHHOrO no HeAeH-
CTBHTeJIbHOH C)I.eJIKe . . . . . . . . . . " 115
 3. 06'beM Tpe6oB3HHii, CBH33HHbIX C H3"bHTHeM He)I.OJI>KHO
nOJIyqeHHOrO HMymecTB3 . . . . . . .. . 130
 4. OnpeeJIeHHe cY.lI.b6bI H3'bHTOrO HMYllleCTB3 . ., 133
r JI a B a IV. PacnpeAeneHHe y6b1TKOB npH npH3HaHHH C)J.enKH HeAeH-
D
CTBHTeJlbHOH
. . .
156
r JI a B a V. HCKoBaH AaBHOCTb no
CJJ,eJlOK
.n.en8M
o HeAeHcTBKTenbHocTH
. .
.. ....
167
171

Pa6UH08UtJ H ai)ei)a BeHUaMUH08Ha
HeeHCTBHTenbHOCTb CenOK H ee nOCneCTBHH
PeAaKTOp A. A. BOftbmaK08
TeXHlPleCKHH peA8KTOp E. r. )l(YKOBa
I<oppeKTOp 11. T. 3eMCK08a
--  ---- - ------
CA8HO B Ha60p 22/VI 1960 f. M-26930.
floJ1,nHc8Ho K net[8TH 23 XI 1960 r. Yt[._
H3A. JI. 11,62. neq. JI. 10,75. BYM. JI.5,37.
cDopMaT 6YM. 60 X 92 1 / 16 _ THpa>K 3500
.3K3. 38K. .N2 1019. .[(eHa 7 py6., C 1/1-
1961 t. u.eHa 70 Kon.
OmeIJ3T3HO C Ha6op3 2-H 4>36pHKH
AeTcKoH KHHfH B THTIOrpa<pHH J10J1rT.
J1emmrpaJ1" B_164,
YHHBepcHTeTcK3H Ha6.. 7/9.
.

11""'1 7 pyli. .
L 1.1-1961 r LI"Ha 70 K_