/
Текст
AKA,!\EMHH HA YK CCCP
OpfJena Tpya08oao Kpacnoao 3H.aMeHU
uncmumym apxeo/Loauu
CRII cDO-CIIBIiPCHlIll
3BEPIIHbIM CTIIJIb
B IICHYCCTBE
HAPO OB EBP A31I1I
!
Jf aaame/tbCmeU «H ay a»
:\!OCKea
1976
C60puUI> cO{)epJICUT OOl>.I!aObt TpeTbeu I>OU-
g;epeu1.fuu no cI>uifJo-cu6upcr;ou apxeOAoeuu,
nocCRUfeuuou cne1.fua.l!bUO cI>uifJo-cu6upcI>0-
.uy 3cepuuOMY CTU.I!lO. PaCCMOTpeHO npouc-
xOJICoeuue CI>uifJo-capMaTCKoeo 3cepuuoeo
CTU.l!R, ceo C01.fua.l!bHbte U pC.I!UeU03UbtC OC-
HOCbt, AOKa.l!bUbtC capUaUTbt cI>uifJcI>oeo UC-
KYCCTca, nOl>a3aUO 3ua'lCUUC CI>UifJCKOU I>YAb-
Typbt O.l!R UCI>YCCT8a !Jpe8ueu PyCU. BO.l!b-
UlOU UUTCpCC npCOCTaC.I!RlOT ny6AUKa1.fUU,
nOC8RUfcUUblC HOCbtM uaxoo"aM 3CCPUUOeo
CTUAJJ.
Co,u;epmaHue
IIpeAHCJIOBHe.
B. A. HltbUnCIWJ£.
COBpeMeHHoe COCTOJIBHe upo6JIeHH CKHtpCItOro 3BepBBO-
ro CTHJIH
5
9
B. B. Blt3 .
OTCCTCT8CUUbtC pcoaKTopbL
Kon{}uoaTbt UCTOpU'leCKUX uaYK
A. If. MeltlO 06a u M. r. MOlU o6a
R BOIIpOCY 06 HCTOKax CKHcJ.>o-capHaTCKoro 3BepHHoro
CTHJUl
30
A. M. Xaaano6,
A. H. m yp o.
COD;IIaJIbHhle H peJIIU'JI03BL1e OCHOBLI CKHtpCKOro HCKYc-
CTBa 40
E. E. Kyab.MUlw.
CKII«pcKoe IICKYCCTBO KaK oTpa eJDIe HHpOB033peHBJI
OAHOR II3 rpYIIII HHAoIIpaHD;eB 52
H. A. Onaii o.
3BepIIHbIM CTIIJIb II aHTH'IHhlR MHp CeBepHoro
TIpH'IepHOMOpbfl B VII-IV BB. AO H. a.
66
K. C/J. C.MUpno6.
CaBpOMaTo-capMaTCKHH 3BepIIHbIR CTIIJIb
74
A. If. m ypl>O.
o JIOliaJIhHbIX pa3JIH'IHflX B IIcKyceTBL"JIeCOCTenHoH
CIiIHpHH 90
A. If. M eJl,I01>06a.
K BOIIPOCY 0 B3aIIMOCBfl3flX CKII«pcKoro H tppumHcKoro
llCKYCCTBH 106
3. B. H 06en1>o.
TIpe!\MCTbI 3BepIIHoro CTHJIfl B paHHecKH«pcKHX naHJlTHH-
Kax KpbIMa 128
fl. If JIu6epo6.
C 10602-165 t33-76
042 (02) -76
e J1a aTenLnBo .U.YKlIt, t976 r.
JIOliH.-II,H hie oc06eHHOCTII 3BepllHoro CTHJIJI cpeJJ;HeAOH-
CIwii Ky.-lbTyphl H OTpaJIWHIIe CBfl3eR C BHeIIUIHM MHpOM 138
3
B. B. Bunozpaaoe.
R xapaKTepBCTBKe K06aHCKoro
6RpCKOM 3BepBHOM CTBJIe
BapBaHTa B CKB -
147
IIPE)J.MCJIOBME
B. B. Tex08.
o HeKoTOp:r.rx npeAMeTaX cKBcpcKoro 3BepBHoro CTBJIII 113
naMflTHBKOB IOmHoro CKJIOHa rJIaBHOrO KaBKa3cKoro
xpe6Ta 153
A II. Manlfe8U'l.
Haxop;Ka B 3anOpOJRCKOM KypraHe (K Bonpocy 0 CJl6Bp-
CKoii KOJIJIeKI.\RR TIeTpa I) 164
B. A. mpaMlw.
TpeTbfl BcecoI03Hafl KOHcpepeHIJ,Rfl no
Clmcpo-capMaTcKou apXeOJIOrBB, npo-
BCxop;RBllIafl B ocKBe B p;eKa6pe
1972 r., B OTJIB'IBe OT IIepBLIX P;BYX,
6LIJIa IIOCBflIll,eHa TOJIbKO OP;HOR, HO
BaJRHOH IIp06JIeMe - CKBCPO-CB6RPCKO-
MY 3BepRHOMY CTRJIIO. Bhl60p TaKOU
TeMbI 6LIJI OIIpep;eJIeH B pe30JIIOD;RB,
IIpRHflTOH BTOpOH KOHcpepeHD;ReH no
CKRcpo-capMaTcKoH apXeOJIOrnB.
I1HTepec K RCKYCCTBY Hapop;oB EBpa-
3RR B cKlIcpo-capMaTCKYIO :moxy 06-
YCJIOBJIeH, C OP;HOH CTOpOHLI, HaKOIIJIe-
HReM 60JIbllIOrO HOBoro MaTepRaJIa, a
C P:Pyrou - OB BLI3BaH TeM, 'ITO no
cpaBHellHIO C OCTaJIbHLIMR IIp06JIeMaMR
CKRcpo-capMaTcKoH apXeOJIOrRB 3BepH-
HOMY CTRJIIO, rOCIIop;CTBOBaBllIeMY B
RCKYCCTBe MHorRX Hapop;OB EBpa3BR
B I TLIC. P;O H. a., B cOBeTcKoH apxeoJIo-
ruqeCKOH HaYKe y.n;eJIflJIOCb ropa3p;0
MeIILllIe BHRMaHRfl. AKTyaJIbHOCTb R
" 3IIaqRMOCTb TeMaTRKR KOHcpepeHD;IIB
nO)ITBepJRp;aIOTCfl IIPBCYTCTBReM Ha 3a-
ceAaHRflX OKOJIO 150 apxeOJIOrOB R RC-
KYCCTBOBep:OB R3 pa3JIR'IHLIX ropop;OB
Haweii CTpaHbI. Bcero 6LIJIO 3aCJIYllIaHO
30 :.(OKilap;OB IIO 06Il1,RM R 'IaCTHLIM
BonpocaM, BLI3BaBllIBX aKTBBHoe 06-
CYm;:T.eHRe. 06CTOflTeJIbHafl RHcpopMa-
l.\I1i1 0 HRX, HaIIRcaHHafl B. II. R03eH-
Konoii R Hep;aBBO ony6jIRKOBaHHaJI',
InoaB:IileT Hac OT He06xop:RMOCTR OCTa-
HaB.LRBaTbCfl Ha 0630pe p:OKJIap:OB R
P:IfCKYCCRH IIO HRM. OTMeTRM JIRllIb
HaR60JIee BaJRHLIe MOMeHTLI R OCHOB-
HOBLIe Haxop;KII Ha BeJIbCKOM ropoAJUD;e B HeKOTOpLl:e
BOIIpOCLI cpOpMRpOBaHlifl R ceMaBTBKBo6pa30B 3HepB-
Horo CTRJIfl 194
E. K. MaKCu.MOe.
HOBLIe Haxop;KR caBpOMaTcKoro 3BepBBoro CTJlJIS
B IIOBOJIJRbe
210
M. A. /{ae.lter.
o npORCXOJRp;eHlm MRBYCBHCKBX amypHLl:X noscHl>lX
IIJIaCTRH 219
JI. C. K.lteun.
CapMaTCKRH TapaHp;p R BOIIpOC 0 npOBCXOJRp;eBBB cap-
MaTOB 228
JI. M. II./terneea.
IIpep;MeTLI 3BepRIIoro CTRJIfl B Cpep;HeM IIpR06be 235
I A. ll. CMupnoe. \
PeMRHHClI,ellll,RR C KHcpcKoro 3BepRHoro CTHJIfl 242
r, K. Bamep.
Cyp:b6LI 06pa30B :mepRHoro CTRJIJI B p;peBBepyccKoM
HCKYCCTBe 250
iI. A. JIe./teKoe.
Hac:Iep;ue 3BepHIIoro CTRJIfl B RCKYCCTBe cpep;BeBeKOBLS
II ,[(peBHeii PYCH 258
CnnCOK COKpaIll,el!I1rl
(
,
271
HLIe BTorn pa60TLI KOHcpepeHD;RB. 3TO
He06xoABMO Cp;eJIaTb B CBfl3R C TeM,
'ITO B HacTOflIll,RH C60PHRK BOIlIJIB He
Bce p;OKJIap;LI, npO'lRTaHHLIe Ha 3ace-
p;aHRflX. PflP; aBTopOB, K COJRa.'IeHBIO,
Be npep;CTaBRJIR CBOR PYKOIIRCR P;JIS
ny6JIRKaD;RR. MeJRP;Y TeM, B HeKOTopLIX
B3 p;OKJIap;OB, OTCYTCTByIOIlI,RX B c60p-
HRKe, nOp;HRMaJIRCb BonpOCLI nepBOCTe-
IIeHHOH 3Ha'lRMOCTH.
OP;BOU B3 OCHOBHbIX R C.'IOJRHLIX B
R3yqeHRR CKRcpcKoro ;mepRHoro CTIIJIfl
np06JIeM flBJIfleTCfl npo6.lIeMa IIpORC-
xomp;ellHfl R cpOpMRpoBaHHfl 3TOro BB-
p;a BCKYCCTBa. IIoaToMY no npaBY STO-
MY BOIIPOCY 6LIJIO yp:eJIeHO oc06eHBO
60JIbllIOe BHRMaHHe Ha KOHcpepeHD;RR.
B p;OKJIap:e B. A. I1JILHIICKOll, KOTO-
pLIM OTKpLIBaeTCfl HaCTOflIll,Rll c60p-
HBK, IIOp;BOp;flIll,eM HTorR HCCJIep:OBaHR-
flM Bcex OCHOBHbIX BonpOCOB CKR KO-
ro RCKYCCTBa Ha COBpe leHHOM aTaIIe,
XOpollIO IIOKa3aHa P:HCKYCCHOHHOCTb CY-
IlI,eCTBYIOilI,RX HLme rnnOTe3 OTHOCR-
TeJIbHO reHe3Rca 3BepIlIIoro CTHJIfl, RX
CRJIbHbIe R CJIa6Lle CTOpOHLI. Pa3HbIE'
II03Rl.\HR B pellIeHlllI noii np06.'IeMbI
BLIflBRJIRCb B Cnel.\lla.lhIJLIX ;:J;OKJIap:ax
R BbICTYIIJIeHlIilX yqaCTIJIJKOB KOIIcpe-
peHl.\RR. II pRMepIIO O;,\IIHaIWBOe qRCJIO
CTOpOHHRKOB IIMe.1II ;lBr oc06eHHO IIO-
IIYJIflpHLIX fIIIIOTe3LI: 1) rrepep;Hea3II-
aTCKoro R 2) l.\eHTpaJIbHOa3UaTcKoro
IIpORCXOJRp:eHRiI OCI!(I/IHbIX IOTIIBOB
3BepRHofo CTR.iIiI. IIepnail II3 3TIIX rR-
llOTe3 IIOJIY'IRJIa Halloo.lee IIO.1Hoe BLI-
5
pameHlIe II 060CHOBaHIIe B ,IJ;OKJIap;e
3. A. fpaHToBcKoro «3BepIIHbIM: CTIIJIb
II 3arrap;HbIM: 11 paH (p;oaxeMeHIIp;CKIIM:
nepHOp;»). )J;OKJIap;'lIIK rrplIBeJI MHoro
HHTepeCHbIX IICTOpll:'IeCKHX p;aHHbIX OT-
HOCIITeJIbHO p;peBHeHpaHCKIIX rrJIeMeH
B IIepep;HeM: A31I1I II I\OCHYJICH rrpep;Me-
TOB 3BeplIHoro CTHJIH 113 apxeOJIornqe-
CKIIX KOMIIJIeKCOB C TepplIToplI1I 3a-
nap;Horo MpaHa.
Y6emp;eHHbIM CTOpOHHIIKOM IJ;eHTpaJIb-
Hoa311aTCKOM: rilIIOTe3bI rrpOHcxomp;e-
HIIH CKlIcpCKoro llCKYCCTBa BbIcTynlIJI
A. M. TepeHomIUIH. B p;OKJIap;e «IIo-
3p;HeKIIMMeplIM:CKIIM: opHaMeHT» II B
npeHIIHX rro PHP;Y 3aCJIymaHHbIx P;OK-
JIap;OB OH pemlITeJIbHO OTBepraJI P;OBO-
)Il>I 8. A. fpaHToBcKoro II P;Pyrnx IIC-
CJIep;OBaTeJIeM: B IIOJIb3Y nepep;Hea3IIaT-
CKoro rrpOlIcxomp;eHIIH 3BeplIHoro CTII-
JIH, HaCTalIBaH Ha TOM, 'ITO HalI60JIee
paHHlIe 06pa3IJ;bI 3BepilHoro CTHJIH no-
HBIIJIIICb Ha BOCTOKC EBpa31I1I II oTTyp;a
pacrrpOCTpaHIIJIllCb RMeCTe C npop;BII-
meHlIeM CKlIcpOB R II Im'IepHoMopbe. B
Ka'IeCTBe OP;HOro H:! OCHOBHbIX apryMeH-
TOB A. 11. TepCHOml\HH npIIBOp;IIT rrpcp;-
MeTbI 3BeplIHoro CTHJlH H3 KypraHa Ap-
maH B TYBe, OTIIOCHIJ erOCH, rro ero MHe-
HHIO, K VIII-VII HB.1W H. a., Korp;a Ha
p;pyrHx TeppHToIHU1X H3p;eJIIIH TaRor/)
pop;a ern;e He cyU\CCTHORaJIO. B aToii: CBH-
31I B03HIIKJIa omHlweHHaH p;IICKyceHH,
BblHBIlBIllaH pa3J1H'll!blC TO'IKII 3peITIIH
OTHOCIITeJIbHO p;aTbI RypraHa ApmaH
(06 aTOM llHTepCCIIOM rraMHTHIIKe pac-
CKa3aJI M. II. rpH:1II0B) II reHe3Hca
rrpe)J;MCTOB 3BepHHoro CTllJIH, HaM:p;eH-
HbIX B HeM. PaHIIHH ilaTlIpOBKa Kypra-
Ha He rrOJIY'lIIJla Brpoorn;ero rrplI3Ha-
HllH, HaK H rnIlOH'.la 0 rrepBOHa'IaJIb-
HOM rrOHBJleIlHII IIIH';I leTOB 3BeplIHoro
CTII.'IH B IJ;eHTpa.''',J'O[1 A:JHH.
B BblcTyrrJIeIllH1 ;1. C. PaeBCKoro 6bI-
JIa OT'IeTJIllBO C.qH111\IY:lllpOBaHa HHTe-
peCHaH lbIC.'Ib OTII(lr'ITe.'lbHO B03MOm-
HbIX 3arrMCTBOBallll'" xyp;omecTBeHHbIX
06pa30B 1I3 pa:Jllh' \ HCTO'lHIIHOB nplI
CJIOmeHlI1I CIUlCPO-CII6IIpCKOro 3BepHHO-
ro CTIIJIH. COrJIaCHO aToM: rnnOTe3e, op;-
Hll 06pa3l>I II CTIIJIHCTH'leCKlIe oc06eH-
HOCTII MOrJIII 6bITb 3alIMCTBOBaBbI 11.3
IICKYCCTBa Hapop;OB IJ;eHTpaJIbHOll A.3IIR,
p;pyrlIe MOTIIBbI 6bIJIII BocrrplIHHTbI 1I3
IIepep;HeM: A31I1I. CrrJIaB pa3HbIX aJIe-
MeHTOB, nop;BepraBmlIXCH MeCTHOM: rre-
pepa60TKe II p;OrrOJIHHBmIIXCH MeCTHbI-
MII aJIeMeHTaMH, npHBeJI K cpOpMlIpOBa-
HIIIO oplIrlIHaJIbHOrO 3BeplIHoro CTIIJIH
Ha 60JIbmOM: TepplIToplI1I EBpa31I1I.
C. C. qepHIIKoB, II. )J;. JIII6epoB II
p;p. npop;OJImarrlI HaCTalIBaTb llCKJIIO-
'IIITeJIbHO Ha MeCTHbIX KOpHHX CKlIcpO-
CII6IIpCKOrO IICKYCCTBa, B03BOP;H ero K
HeOJIHTII'IeCKOM: arroxe II BHP;H rrpo06pa-
3bI 3BeplIHoro CTIIJIH B p;epeBHHHOM:
CKYJIbnTYpe IIIlIrnpcKoro TOpcpHHIIKa.
B. B. BJIaK BIIJVlT IICTOKII CKII.pO-CH-
6IIpCKOrO 3BeplIHoro CTIIJIH B IICKYC-
CTBe xeTTO-XYPpIITCKoro Kpyra. Op;I1a-
KO aTa rlIrrOTe3a He nOJIY'IIIJIa pe30HaU-
ca Ha KOHcpepeHIJ;IIII.
B IITOre )J;IICKYCCIIII 0 rrpolIcxom,rre-
HHII IICKYCCTBa 3BeplIHoro CTIIJIH 6bIJIO
rrpH3HaHo, 'ITO IIII Y OP;HOM: 1I3 cyrn;ecT-
BYIO IlX B HacTOHrn;ee BpeMH TO'ICK
3peJillH HeT p;OCTaTO'IHO BeCKIIX OCHO-
BaUIIM:, 'IT06bI C'IIITaTb Bonpoc OKOH'Ia-
TeJIbHO pemeHHblM. Op;HaKo KOH.pepCH-
IJ;IIH nOMOrJIa BbIHCHHTb n03HIJ;1I1I 'CTO-
pOH II HaMeTIITb rrYTII, rro KOTOpbIM
p;OJImHbI IIP;TII rrOIICKII pemeHIIH. Co-
BepmeHHo O'ieBIIp;HO, 'ITO rrpep;cToHT
ern;e O'IeHb 60JIbmaH pa60Ta B HarrpaB-
.'IPHHII H3Y'IeHllH OTP;CJIbHbIX CIOmeTOB
II MOTIIBOB, IIX rrpolIcxom)J;eHIIH, TIIJ;a-
TeJlbHOR pa3pa60TKII XpOHOJIOrnlI II p;e-
TaJlbHbIX corrOCTaBJIeHHR 6JIII3KTIX rrpo-
H3Bep;eHIIM: Ha pa3HbIx TeppHTOpllll.\.
HeKoTogoe OTHomCHHe K rrp06.'ICMC
cpOpMlIpOBqplIH 3BeplIHoro CTIDII H fel'T
;:(oRJIap; A. '1\1. Xa3aHoBa II A. 11. IIlKyp-
1-;0, rroMern;eHHbIH B HacTOHrn;eM C60pHH-
IW. B KOTOpOM IIcCJIep;yeTcH euw OAHI!.
;:(0 CIIX rrop ern;e COBepIlleHHO He 1f3Y-
'leHHbIM: aCileKT CKlIcpChoro IICRYCCTBa.
OCHOBHbIe nOJIOmeHHH ero, B KOTOpbIX
3BeplIHbIll CTIIJIb paeCMaTplIBaCTCH HaK
« HCpaC'IJIeHeHHOe ep;IlHCTBO xyp;omecT-
BeHHoro, COIJ;lIaJIbHOrO n peJIllrH03Horo
1If0MeHTOB» He BbI3BaJIII B03pameHBH.
BHIIMaHIIH II rrop;p;epmKII 3aCJIymlIBaeT
TaKme MbICJIb aBTopOB 0 TOM, 'ITO 3Be-
plIHbIll CTII.'Ib rrpe)J;CTaBJIHeT c060M: HO-
Bo06pa30BaHIIe, HaK II BCH c.KlIcpcKaH
HY:IbTypa.
KaK 1I3BeCTHO, 'He TOJIbKO B rreplIo)J;
cpOpMlIpOBaJillH, HO II B npOIJ;ecce pa3-
BIITIIH CKlIcpCKoro IICKYCCTBa 3BepIIHO-
ro CTIIJIH IIMeJIII MeCTO BHemHlIe BJIIIH-
HIIH II 3aIIMCTBOBaHIIH. K COmaJIeHlIIO,
aToM: TeMe B pa60Te KOHcpepeHIJ;HH He
6bI:1O yp;eJIeHO p;OJImHoro BHIIMaHIIH.
JIlImb B p;OKJIap;e H. A. OHaM:KO rrO-HO-
BOMY paCCMaTpHBaJICH Bonpoc 0 pOJIII
rpe'IeCKOrO IICKYCCTBa B IICTOplI1I pa3-
BIITllH CKlIcpCKoro 3BeplIHoro CTIIJIH B
CeBepHOM IIpH'lepHoMopbe. Op;uaKO
TO'IKa 3peHIIH H. A. OHaM:KO He 06cym-
p;&JIaCb BbIcTyrraBmlIMH Ha KOHcpepeH-
IJ;IIII II rrOTOMY He nOJIy'lIIJIa )J;OJImHOM:
On;CHKII.
)J;OKJIap; A. M. MeJIIOKOBOM: 6bIJI rro-
CBHIIJ;eH B3aIIMop;ellCTBIIHM CKlIcpCKoro
IICKyccTBa C cppaKHllCIUlM. B rrpeHIIHx
A. II. MaHn;eBII'I ynpeKHYJIa )J;oKJIap;-
'IIIKa B TOM, '1TO OHa CJIlImKOM YCJIom-
HllJIa rrpon;ecc, rrpep;rrOJIaraH C03)J;aHlIe
pH)J;a npOlI3Bep;eHlIll 3BepilHoro CTIIJIH
BO <DpaKIIII no CKll.pCKIIM 06pa3n;aM, a
3aTeM 06paTHoe B03p;ellCTBlIe yme cppa-
RlIRCIUlX 06pa3D;oB Ha CKlIcpCKlIe.
B CBH31I C IIrrTeHCIIBHbIM HaKOrrJIe-
HHeM MaTeplIaJIOB B Te'IeHHe rrocJIe)J;-
HIIX p;ecHTII - rrHTHa)J;D;aTII JICT BCC HC-
Hee CTaHOBHTCH oco6eHHoCTil JIOKaJIb-
HblX rpyrrrr CKlIcpCKoro 3BeplIHoro CTll-
JIH II IIX apeaJIbI. Pa60Ta apxeOJIOrOB
B aTOM rrarrpaBJIeHlI1I nOJIy'lII.'Ia P;OBOJIb-
HO rrOJIHOe OTpameHlIe Ha KOHcpepeH-
I\HlI. MHorHe 1I3 p;OKJIap;OB Ha aTY TeMY
BOUIJIH B cocTaB HaCTOH ero C60pHHEa
(A. M. IIIKYPKO, K. <D. CMlIpHoBa,
8. B. HKoBeHKo, B. B. BIIHorpa)J;oBa.
6
B. B. TexoBa. II. )J;. JIlI6epoBa, JI. M.
IIJIeTHeBoii). IIo nlIM MbI MOllieM cy-
p;lITb 0 JIOKa.'IbHbIX OTJIH'IIIHX, CIOllieT-
HDlX II CTIIJIIICTH'leCKIIX, B rrCKYCC TBe
pHp;a rrJIeMeHHbIX 06pa30BaHIIll B Ce-
BepHOM IIplI'IepHO lOpbe, Ha KaBKa3e,
B HeKOTopbIX 06JIaCTHX CH6IIplI. K co-
llia.lIeHII10, B C60pHIIKe He rrpep;CTaB.lIe-
HbI IIHTepeCHbIe p;OK.'1a)J;hl A. )J;. fpa'ia
« II pOII3Bep;CHIIH CIUlcpo-clI6lIpc Koro IIC-
KYCCTBa B rrpep;e.lIax aTHoKy.'IbTypHbIX
30H a3naTCIillX CTeneM:» II M. II.
rpH3HOBa (,8THll'IeCh"Be BaplIan;1l1I CKH-
cpo-clI6npCKoro CTHJIH B CaHHO-AJITae».
O'IeHb BamHble P;JIH rrOJillMaJillH oc06eH-
HOC Tell n;eHTpa.'1bHOa3IIaTCKOro IICKYC-
CTBa 3BeplIHoro CTIIJIH. OTCYTCTBYIOT
TaI,me CTaTblI, rrOCBmn;eHHbIe xyp;ome-
CTBeHHOMY TBOp'IeCTBY caKOB, Torp;a
KaK Ha KOlIcpepeHn;HII aTa Te [a 6bIJIa
rrpep;CTaBJIeHa P;OBOJIbHO nOJIHO B P;0K-
.'1ap;ax O. A. BlImHeBCKOH, 11. KomCM-
6epP;bIeRa, A. K. A6cTeKOBa.
Pa3pa60TKa JIOKaJIbHLIX BaplIalITOB
3BeplIHoro CTIIJIH nplI3HaHa 6eccrrop-
HbIM )"\OCTllmCHlIeM B pa60Te ROHcpepeH-
I\IlH. BMeCTe C TeM B pe30JIIOI\HII OTMe-
'leHa Hc06xoP;lIMOCTb YCTaHOB.'1eHIIH 60-
:Iec orrpep;eJIeHHOII CBH31I OTp;eJIbHbIX
.1I0I,aJIbHbIX BaplIaHTOB C aTHlI'IeCKIIMH
rpyrrrraMII p;peBHero HaCeJIeHIIH CCCP.
CepHH p;OKJIap;OB HOCIIJIa lIucpopMa-
I\IlOHHbIll .xapaKTep. TaKlIe p;OKJIap;hI
:JlIaKmm.'Ill c06paBllIIIxcH C rra fHTHrr-
r;a m :1ReplIHoro CTlIJIH, Hep;aBHO Hall-
lIelIIIbIMH II ern;e He nOJIY'IIIBmIIMII OT-
IHlrtil'IITIH n JlHTepaType, a TaKme C
HaX0,lI\aMll, lIep;OCTaTO'IHO 1I3BeCTHbIMII
rro rrYU,'IIIKaI\HHM. Cpe)J;.ll HHX oc06eH-
lIoe I\Hn lal!lIe nplIB.lIeKJIO C006IIJ;eHlIe
E. B. Mal\Cll !OBa II B. A. IIIpaMho,
Bl;:I10'leIIHOe B IIaCTOHrn;lIir C60PHI!K.
B rTilTbe A. II. MaHI\CBll'I pa36lIpa-
JOTC II 1I0Bble Haxop;KII rrpep; feTOB 3Be-
pUlioro CTII.'IH B KypraHe y r. 3ano-
pOllih(' Ii R CBH31I C HIlMII nepeCMaTp!I-
BaCTOl Bonpoc 0 npOHCXOmiJ,CHIm: CXO-',-
IIb1X n pon:melIeHlIll, BomelIllIIIX B T :II.
7
Ha3hIBaeMYlO CR6RPCKYlO KOJIJIe RIO
TIeTpa I. CKJIOHHHCb K MhICJIR 0 cppa-
KllllCKOM f\eHTpe IIpOR3BO)J;CTBa TaKRX
BeIIJ.:ell, aBTOp, O)J;HaKO He paCilOJIaraeT
y6e)J;llTe bHOll aprYMeHTaf\Rell )J;JIH 06-
OCHOBaHIHI cBoero BhIBO)J;a. BMecTe C
TeM HeJIb3H He OTMeTRTb, qTO rrpe)J;IIO-
JIOmeHRe A. TI. MalI.I\eBRq OTHOCllTeJIb-
HO HeO)J;HopO)J;Horo COCTaBa CR6RpCKOll
KOJIJIeKf\llll R B03MomHOM IIOIIa)J;aHllR
B Hee pH)J;a IIpe)J;MeTOB, Haii eHHhIX He
B Cll6llpll, a Ha YKpallHe, IIpe)J;CTaBJIH-
eTCH OqeHb cepbe3HhIM.
HeKOTophIe )J;OKJIa)J;hI 6hIJIR IIOCBH-
ll\eHbl paCCMOTpeHRIO OT)J;eJIbHhIX MO-
TllBOB Ha IIpOR3Be)J;eHRHX 3BepOHoro
CTIIJIH. HOBYIO TpaKTOBKY R306pame-
lIIiHM Ha 6JIHXaX R3 CR6RpCKOH KOJI-
.'IeKf\llu IIeTpa I IIpe JIOmRJI JI. C.
H:leftH, )J;OKJIa)J; KOToporo BKJIlOqeH B
UaCTOHll\llll C60pHHK. CJIe)J;yeT, O)J;HaKO,
3aMeTRTb, qTO C)J;eJIaHHbIe aBTopoM RC-
TOpllqeCKlle BhIBO)J;bl IIpe)J;CTaBJIHIOTCH
HHM Hey6e)J;llTeJIbHhIMll. TIpem)J;e Bcero,
nbI3bIBaeT COMHeHlle CTOJIb KaTeropR-
'IeCKOe YTBepm)J;eHRe JI. C. KJIellHa 0
II pOllcxom)J;eHRR Cll6llpCKOll KOJIJIeKf\llR
IIeTpa I .'IRlllb ll3 paii:oHoB IIpllRpTbI-
lllbH II TIoRllIHMbH. CocTaB ;JToft KOJI-
.'IeKI\llll 60JIee CJIOmeH R IlIRpOK Tep-
pIITOplla.'IbHO. HeB03MoIKH0 TaIDKe IIpll-
HHTb II MbICJIb OTHOCRTeJIbHO 06llTaHRH
rrpe)J;KOB aopCOB B IOmHoii: CR6RPll, BbI-
Cha3aHH)'1O JIlllllb Ha OCHOBaHRR IIpO-
)J;BllmeHHH O)J;HOro e)J;RHCTBeHHoro MO-
TIIBR 3BepIIHoro CTII.'IH ll3 3a6aii:KaJIbH,
A."ITaH II IIplfiIllIHMbH B )J;OHCKRe CTeIIll
B TeqeHIIe rrHTll - llIeCTR BeKOB. Becb
oCTa:ILHoii: apXeOJIOrIIqeCKllB: MaTepll-
a:l, rrpollCXOMIIJ.:llii: C YKa3aHHhIX Tep-
pllTOpllii:, He IIO)J;TBepm aeT 3TY rllrro-
Te3Y JI. C. KJIeii:Ha.
J(OK."Ia;:J: JI. H. Ma.,OBRf\Koii:, He rrpe)J;-
CTRB.,eHHblii: )J;.1:H rry6JIllKaf\Rll, 6hIJI
1I0CBHll\eH 06pa3Y cpaHTaCTllqeCKoro
xIIll\HllHa B rrpoR3Be)J;eHllHx capMaTcKo-
ro IIcKyccTBa. ABTOPY Y)J;aJIOCb HaMe-
TIITb oc06eHHoCTll, xapaHTepHble )J;JIH
rrepe)J;aqll 3Toro 06pR3a B pa3HhIe IIe-
B. A. MJIbHHCKaH
pRO)J;hI RCTOpllll capMaToB, HaqRHaa
C VI - V BB. )J;O H. 3. )J;O rrepBhIX Be-
KOB H. 3.
HaKOHef\, IIOCJIe)J;HHH rrp06JIeMa, CTO-
HBlllaH Ha KOHcpepeHI\llII, HaCaJIaCb Ha-
CJIe)J;llH CKllcpO-Cll6llpCKoro 3BepRHoro
CTRJIH B llCKYCCTBe rrOCJIeAYIOIIJ.:RX Ha-
pO)J;OB EBpa3llR. B )J;OKJIa)J;ax f. K.
BarHepa, A. A. JIeJIeKOBa, B. TI. MOK-
phIIIllHa 3Ta TeMa 6hI!Ia paCKphITa IIPR-
MeHllTeJIbHO K IICKyCCTBY ApeBHeii: Py-
CR R HapO)J;OB cpe)J;HeBeKoBoro THHb-
llIaHH. B c60pmme OTCYTCTByeT )J;O-
KJIa)J; B. TI. MOKphIHllHa, IIOCBHIIJ.:eHHhIH
MOTRBaM 3BepRHoro CTllJIH B cpe)J;HeBe-
KOBOM RCK)"CCTBe THIlb-llIaHH, BhI3BaB-
mRii OmRBJIeHHYIO )J;llCKYCCRIO. B TO
me BpeMH B C60PHIIK BK.1llOqeHa IIOCJIe)J;-
HHH CTaTbH A. TI. CMIIpHOBa, CIIeD;RaJIb-
HO HaIIllcaHHaH )J;JIH Hero, Ho He cHa6-
meHHaH llJIJIIOCTpaf\IIHMll.
Ha KOHcpepeHf\llll He 6hIJIO pH)J;a )J;o-
KJIa)J;oB, 3aHBJIeHHblX B Te3Rcax. K HHM
OTHOCllTCH, B qaCTHOCTll, )J;oKJIa)J; E. E.
KY3bMRHOll, rrpe)J;CTRBllBllIeii: ero )J;JIH
rry6JIllKaf\IIR B c60pmiKe. OH IIOCBH-
ll\eH Bamnoii: TeMe OIblC.1:0BOro cO)J;ep-
maHRH 06pa30B 3BcpllHoro CTRJIH, )J;o
CllX IIOp cJIa60 pa3pR60TaHHOB: B HaYKe
II MaJIO 3aTpoHYTOll Ha KOHcpepeII.I\RR.
B f\eJIOM HaCToHll\III"I C60PHRK BKJIIO-
'IaeT 21 CTaTblO. TIo "IIM MomHO CY)J;llTb
o MHorllX, HO, K coma.'IeHlllO, He 0 Bcex
aCileKTax rrp06JIeMLI CKllcpO-Cll6RpCKO-
ro 3BepUHoro CTRJIH, 06cym)J;aBmllXCH
Ha KoncpepeHf\llii II OTpamalOIIJ.:RX CO-
BpeMeHHoe COCTOHHlW u3yqeHllH TeMhI.
TIO)J;roTaB.1:llBaH COOpHRK H IIeqaTR,
Mbl CTaBll.1:II cBoeH :Ia;:laqell coxpaHllTb
B IIOJIHOM 06'be fe BC(', qTO 6hIJIO IIPll-
CJIaHO HaM aBTOpa !II. AllcKyccROH-
HOCTb OT!k:lbHbIX I\OrrpOCOB, BhIHBllB-
llIaHCH B 10iJ,e pa60TbI KOHcpepeHf\llll,
a TaKme Hallle Hecor.,RClle C HeKOTopbl-
MR BbIBO)J;a Ill MbI CTRpamlCb OTpa3llTb
B )J;aHHmi BCTyrrJIeIlrrII.
t B. lJ. K03e1t1Weu. I II BcecolO3HaH KOH<p e -
peH I1H IIO clm<f>o-cclr IaTC"oll apxeoJIo-
rIll!. -CA, 1974. ."'" 4.
COBPEMEHHOE COCTOHIDIE IIPOBJIEMbI
CHlIcDCHOrO 3BEPlIHOrO CTIIJIH
O)J;HOH R3 aKTyaJIbHhIX rrp06JIeM cOBpe-
MeHHoro cKRcpoBe)J;eHllH OCTaeTCH IIp06-
JIeMa CKllcpCKoro 3BepllHoro CTll;IH, ero
npollcxom)J;eHHH R pa3BllTIIH. B HaCTOH-
IIJ.:eii pa60Te MhI He CTaBll I CBoell 3a)J;a-
'Ieii: RCqepilhIBalOll\ee OCBell\eHlle Bcex
B3rJIH)J;OB, BhICKa3aHHLIX rro 3TOMY BOII-
POcy B IIeqaTR, TeM 60.'Iee. qTO B pH)J;e
pa60T RMelOTCH )J;OCTaTOqHO rrO)J;p06HhIe
6R6JIROrpacpRqeCKlle CBO)J;KII!. B HalllY
aa)J;aqy BXO T R3JIOmeHlle CYIIJ.:HOCTR
rJIaBHhIX HailpaBJIeHllll, OCHOBHhIe 3Ta-
nhI R COBpeMeHHoe COCTOHIme )J;llCKYC-
CRR, a TaKme IIorrhITKa orrpe;:\e.1:IITb HaR-
60JIee CYll\eCTBeHHhIe rrYTII rrOIICKa.
OcpopMJIeHlle CKllcpOJIOrIIll KaK Bam-
HOii: OTpaCJIll OTeqeCTBelIlIoii IICTOpllll R
apXeOJIOrllll CBH3ano C TpYAaMII BhI)J;alO-
m;erOCH PyccKoro yqelIoro aKa)J;eMRKa
M. II. POCTOBf\eBa. C IIMelIeM POCTOBf\e-
Ba II ero yqeHllKa f. 11. BopoBHa CBH3a-
HO TaKme HaqaJIO ll3yqeHIIH CKllcpcKoro
3BepllHoro CTlliIH - oc060ro BIIAa IIpll-
KJIa)J;Horo RCKYCCTBa, COCTaBJIHBmerO
HeOT'beMJIeMYIO qaCTb KY:lbTypHoro
KOMIIJIeKCa MHorllX HapO;:J.OB EBpa3llR B
I ThlC. )J;O H. 3.
B3rJIHAbI M. 11. POCTOBI!('Ba Ha CKRcp-
CKoe llCKYCCTBO II3.-IOmel!hI IIM B He-
CKOJIbKllX pa60Tax 2 II 11<1 upoTHmeHRR
BpeMeHR, OT paHHRx I; 6o.lee rr03)J;HllM
IIpeTepileJIR cYIIJ.:eCTBeHllble ll:nleHeHRH.
B 06IIJ.:eM CMhICJIe OHU OpnlllRqeCKR CBH-
3aHbI C ero 06IIJ.:ell KOIJI\l'lIl\lIeii:, CorJIa-
CHO KOTOpOii: CKllcpbl 6bJ."I11 11 paHI\hI, C03-
)J;aBmRe B IOmHoll POCCIIII CII.'IbHOe ro-
CY)J;apCTBO C IIpaBHIIJ.:eii rpYIIIIoii: BOOpy-
meHHhIX Bca)J;HHKOB, opraHR30BaHHhIX
IIO-BoeHHOMY R xpaHRBmRX KOqeBoii:
06pa3 mll3Hll 3. 06JIaCTb CKRcpCKoro ro-
cY)J;apCTBa IIpllHRMaJIaCb llM OqeHb pac-
mRpRTeJIbHO OT YpaJIa )J;o Byra, a II03-
me - )J;o AYHaH. B OCHOBe B3rJIH)J;OB Po-
CTOBD;eBa JIemRT Te3RC e)J;RHCTBa KYJIb-
TYPhI, TeppRTopRR R 3THll'leCKOrO CO-
CTaBa HaCeJIeHRH.
POCTOBf\eB CqRTaJI, qTO CKllcpCKoe RC-
KYCCTBO 6hIJIO IIpllHeceHO rpyrrIIoii: KO-
qeBhIX Op)J; Ha Py6eme VII-VI BB. )J;O
H.3. B CJIOmRBmeMCH Bll)J;e, 6e3 KaKllX-
JIR60 Tpa)J;RD;Rll B MeCTHblX liYJIbTypax
3rrOXR 6pOH3bl. «COBepmeHHo HeomR-
)J;aHHo,- IIRmeT OH,- B KOHD;e VII B.)J;O
H. 3. IOmHaH POCCRH 6bIJIa HaBO)J;HeHa
orpOMHbIM 60raTCTBOM BbICOKOXY)J;ome-
CTBeHHbIX IIpe)J;MeTOB oc060ro II opllrll-
HaJIbHOrO CTllJIH. HeT COMHeHllll, qTO
3TOT IIOTOK IIpllmeJI R3BHe» '. OH OTMe-
qaeT TaKme, qTO (<RpaHCI;aH KYJIbTypa
B 3IIOXy ee IIpRBHeceHllH Ha lOr POCCIIII
HOCRJIa yme CMemaHHbIii: xapaKTep, IIpll-
qeM qym)J;oe B 3Toii: KYJIbType, l;aK BO-
CTOqHoe. TaK R rpeqeCKOe, JIer'le Bbl)J;e-
.'lHeTCH, qeM HeCOMHeHHO HMeIOll\eeCH B
HaJIll'lllll MeCTHoe R caM06bITHoe '.
B 60JIee paHHRX pa60Tax n;ncpCKRH
KyJIbTypa IIpe)J;CTaBJIHJIaCb eMY KaK
llpaHCKaH, KOTOpylO OH rOTOB 6hI.1I rro.'I-
HOCTblO oTom)J;ecTBJIHTb C IIepCll)J;CKOll.
BJIllmaii:llIlle aHaJIOrHll :noll ca 106bIT-
HOii: rpyrrrre CKRcpCKoro llCHYCCTBa OH
YCMaTpHBa.1: B IIaMHTHllKax apXaHqeCKO-
9
ro 3,lallIa, llCKYCCTBO IWTOpOrO CqllTaJi
pO,qOHaqa.TJbHllKOM llpaHcKoro llCKYCCT-
Ba Bo06m;e. B TO me BpeMH POCTOBn;CB
OTMeqaeT, qTO CKll.pCImR 3BepllHbIM:
CTllJlb pe3RO OTJlllqaeTCH OT rpeqeCROro
MaJlOa311M:CROrO, n: B HeM qYBCTBYIOTCH
aJlellIeHTbI caMOCTOHTeJlbHoro TBOpqe-
CTBa, qymp;oro aCCllpO-BaBllJlOHCROMY
MIlPY. ROJIe6JIHCb B CBOIiX B3rJlHp;aX,
POCTOBn;eB rrilCaJI, qTO aTOT CTllJlb CO-
CTaBJIHeT n03p;HllM: oqepl\. aJIapO,IJ;HM:CRO-
ro (TO eCTb ypapTCRoro) llCRYCCTBa, a
TaRme, qTO aTO HCKYCCTBO MOrJlO 6bITb
npliHeCCHO IlIa 101' POCCIlIl KHMMepllM:-
n;aMH, OT KOTOpbIX ero BOCrrprrHHJIR
CKH.pbI 6 .
C TeM me HanpaBJIeHHeM B3rJlHp;OB
MbI BCTpeqaeMCH B P;PyroR pa60Te POC-
TOBI\eBa, rp;e OH nllmeT: «TaM (Ha rllrro-
TeTHqeCKOM: pOp;IlHe. - B. If.) 6bJ.1l
llpaHCKllM: Hapop; caKll, Haxop;IlBrnllM:CH
B HerrpepbIBHbIX CHorneHIlHX C ACCllpll-
('ii, OH Bblpa60TaJi 3nepllHbIM: CTIlJlb, RO-
TOpbIR 3aTeM rrpllHec C C060R Ha lOr
POCCIlII» ", TO eCTb .paRTllqeClm OH rrpcp;-
rrOJIaraJl, qTO CKIl.pCKIlM: 3BepllHblM
CTIl.TJb CJlOmliJICH B 30He CKIl.po-aCCllpllM:-
CRIlX ROHTaKTOB.
B pa60Te «CKIl.pIlH II Bocrrop» POC-
TOBn;eB rOBopllT 06 OC060R pOJIIl IlpaHO-
xeTTClillX KOHTaKTOB B npollcxom,qeHIlIl
CKll.pclwro IlCKYCCTBa. B03pamaH rrpo-
THB 113BeCTHOR KOHn;errn;1l1l HOHIiMCROro
rrpolfcxom,qeHIlH CRIl.pcRoro 3BepilHoro
cnr.'Ul. BbI,qBIlHYTOM B. B. <DapMaRoB-
CRHM. OR rrllrneT: «Ha IOrc POCCHII aTOT
CTll'1 [, I\aprrT nO'ITIl 6e3pa3,qt'JlbiiO II YK-
pamaCT rrpll aTOM rrpe,qMCTbI, HpaHO-XCT-
TCJ\OC rrpOllcxom,qCHlle KOTOpblX HBJIH
eTCH 60.1ee qeM BepOHTHbIM», II aJlec:
« I1MCRHO aTllrrpe,qMeTbl, YKpaUIcHRble B
opIIrllUaJlbHOM, HerroBTopliMOM B Tal\OM.
n;eJlbHOCTIl II OpraHllqHOCTH 3BCpllHO 1
CTIlJle, ,qalOT TOH BCeM: TOM: CMemaRHOH
RyJlbType, KOTopaH rrpe,qCTaBJICRa B 60-
raTblX RypraHHbIX rrorpe6cRllHx IOra
POCCllH, HaqllRaH C VII ,qo I II II. ,:(0
II. a.» 3Ta cRIl.pcKaH KYJIbTypa IlIIChYC-
CTBO I1pep;CTaBJlHJlIlCb CMY IlCKJlIO'III-
TCJlbiiO «B acrrel\Te RYJlbTYPbI BepxHIIx
rocrrop:cTBYIOm;IlX CJlOeB 06m;eCTBa» 8.
OC06bIM rrHTepec npep;CTaBJIHeT p;aJib-
Henmce pa3BIITile B3r.TJHp;OB POCTOBI\eBa
B ero 60.1ce rr03p;HeR pa60TC, crren;lla.lb-
RO IIOCBHm;eHHOM: 3BepllROMY CTIlJlIO. B
::JTO I TpY,J;e OH pernllTeJlbHO OTKa3bIBa-
eTCH OT nepBOHaqaJIbHoro MHeHIlH, qTO
pO,qIIROM: CKH.pCKoro llCRYCCTBa Mor.'lil
6bITL 3CM.1Il BJlllmHero BOCTOKa: Accrr-
pIIH, BaBII.10H, <DllHIlKIlH, XOTH p;peBHe-
BOCTOqHblIT CTIlJlb II OKa3aJl BJlllHHlle Ha
palIHeClm.pCKoe IlCKYCCTBO B IOmHoR
POCCIIll. «CKH.pCKHM: 3BepllHblM: CTHJIb,-
rrlImeT OR,- 60JIee npllMIlTIlBeH, 60Jlee
aHeprll'leR, MeHee qIlCTbIM:, qeM 3Bepll-
IIbIii CTIl.'Ib BJillmHerO BOCTOKa B I TbIC.
,qo II. a....»"
OH He BIlP;IlT aTHX RopHeR B IlCRYC-
CTBe Axe leHIlp;CKoro 11 paRa npemp;e
Bccro B cmry TOro, qTO lIepCIlH Bocrrpll-
IIH.TIa IIaC:Ie,qlle 6J1llmHeBOCTOqHOrO CTIl-
:rH. Em;e leHbme OCHOBaHIlM: IlCKaTb pO-
,qrmy CRH.pCRoro CTIlJIH B 110HIlM:CKOM:
fpCI\IIII, XOTH ee IlCRYCCTBO 0I>a3aJlO
oo:rLUIoe B.IHHHIlC Ha cKH.pcImH 3Be-
plTHLlii CTIIJlb.
ECIIf paHbme POCTOBn;eB 6bI.'l CRJlO-
lIeR IIChaTb ROpHIl CKIl.pCROro IlCKYC-
CTBH B Tpap;Iln;IlHX xeTTCRoro II RaBRa3-
CROI'O MllpOB, TO B aToM: pa60Te OH OTMe-
'1aeT I1pIIHI\llrrllaJlbHOe OTJlll'lIIe KaB-
J\a3Choro IlCRYCCTBa OT IOmHopYCCJ\oro
IT. rrplfxop:rrT K 3aRJIIO'ICRIIIO, qTO «MbI
BLlI!ym)'(eHbl rrpll3HaTb pa3.I11qHOC rrpo-
!!l':\o»qcmIC 3TllX ,qBYX :meplIUbrx CTII-
.1('11»10.
1'0cTOBI\eB OTMC'IaeT, '1TO rrpOllcxom-
:i('HnC 3BeplIHoro CTHJJH He romeT 6blTb
CRH.IHTIO C 3eMJlHMH, ROTopbIe oKpyma-
lOT JOmRYfO POCCHIO C IOra II 3arrap;a,
11('1\."1 rO'laCT;aRmc ceBCp. r;ie 3BCpllHble
\IOTI!Bbl, rro ero MHCHIfIO, RC opllfHHa.'Ib-
111.1. a 3an ICTBOBaHbI OT Chlf.pOB. CorJla-
,1111 TIOBOlr ero ROHI\errI\lflI, CRH.pCJ\IlR
<I"'I"lIlblii nH.'lb Mor nplfiiTIl TO.'lbKO C
1<'1(' ror;a II.III ceBepO-BOCTOha II.
Yme B rrpep;rneCTBYIOm,IlX pa60Tax
POCTOBI\eB Onle'la.lI OJIR30CTb CRIl.pCRO-
ro 3BepilHoro CTIIJlH R 3arra,qRO-CIl6Ilp-
CJ\OIllY 12. B HOBOM pa60Te POCTOBI\CB
rOBopllT 00 aTOM 60JIee orrpep;eJIeHHO,
no,q'lepRIlBaH TeCHoe CXOP;CTBO xyp;ome-
CTBeHHoro CTII.'lH MllJIyCIlHCJ\OR J\OTJlO-
BIlHbI II lIpn'lcpHoMopbH. TIpll nOM,
op;HaRO, 011 He C'IIITaJi CJ\Il.pCKHH 3Bepll-
HbIIT CTII.'Ih 3HBIICIIlllbIIII OT cll6llpcJ\oro II
HaoaopOT. n porr3Bep;eHllH III11HYCIlHCKO-
ro IlCKYCCTBa, no ero MHeHI'IlO, 60Jlee
rpyable, IIHepTHbIe, OrpaHllqeHHbIe
JIHmb HeKOTopbIlIIH MOTIlBalllll. OTclOp;a
M. 11. POCTOBn;eB p;eJIaeT BbIBOP;: II B Cll-
61lpb II B CCBcpHoe TIpllqepHOMOpbe aTO
IlCKYCCTBO obr.TJO rrpllHeceHO 113 HeRoero
06m,ero I\CIlTpa, HaXOp;IlBrnerocH rp;e-To
B IJ;eHTpa.1LROR A31l1l, B MecTe, OT KO-
TOporo Kah IOmuaH Cll6llpb, TaR II TIpll-
qepROMOpl,C lOr.IH 6bITb Op;IlRaKOBO P;O-
cTyrrHbrMlL B Ka'leCTBe rllrrOTeTllqeCRIl
B03MomRoro panOHa OH Ha3bIBaeT Typ-
KeCT:JH, HC HCK.lIlOqaeT AJiTaH, OTMeqaH,
qTO .paYIIa :mepllRoro CTIlJlH C ee 0611-
JIH(' I O:I('I1hJ!X Chopee YKa3bIBaeT Ha
3e I.IIO rop II JleCOB, HemeJlH Ha paBHIl-
HbI r, n.TIOi.\opO,qROM: rrOqBOR II CTapbIMIl
palloHaMIf arpllKYJIbTypbI. «HocHTeJIIl
3BepHHoro CTIf.lIH 6bIJlIl OXOTRHRaMIl II
KO'leBHfII<a IH. HO He KpeCTbHHe II 3eM-
JIe)'(CJI!.I\bI» 13.
HaM KamCTCH. qTO B OqepKaX rro IlC-
TopnIl C,,"(pCKOrO IlCKYCCTBa Hepep;KO
BCTpe'lHCTCH Op:HOCTOpOHHHH II yrrpo-
m;cnnaH OJ\CJlKa B3rJIHp;OB M. 11. POC-
TOlJliCBd 1;11 R OCHOBOrrOJlmKHIIRa If no-
60pnIf Wl IJrpe;IHea3IlaTCROM KORn;en-
I\IIJI. II TII BpC IH RaK aTO COBcpmeHHO
He Tal,. ()cym,eCTBIlB pa3JIII'IHble Ha-
npaB.IcnUH I10IICKOB (SJlaM. MeconoTa-
MUll. JlypnCTan. xeTTO-RaBKa3CKIlH II
llpaHo-nrpCn;rCKJIM: Mllp), OR pemn-
Te.IbHO OTKI13a.ICH OT nepe,qnea311aT-
CROll "OI!JI(' I1I\IlII II BbICKa3aJlCH B I10Jlb-
3Y CaMnOblTRbn H OpHfl'lHaJlbHbrX OC-
IIOB CI\U(fJCRoro IICKYCCTBa, He3aBIICllMO-
1'0 B CROIIX HCTORax OT KaRllX-.1JIl60
10
n;eHTpOB p;peBHeBOCTOqHbIX n;IlB .1I1l3a-
n;llrr: «ECJIII HaM CJIY'IIlTCH HaiiTII B
CRll.pCKIlX MOmJlaX Bem;H, ROTOpblC YK-
parneHbI B OC060M CTIlJle, ROTOpbIll He
MomeT 6blTb OO'bHCHeH KaK llMIIOpT IIJIR
no,qpamaHlle, MbI YBepeHHO :\lome 1 CRa-
3aTb, '1TO IlMeeM rropa311TeJlbROe rrCRYC-
CTBO, KOTopoe MomeT 6bITb Ha3BaHO
CRll.pCRllM» to.
TIpllqllHa pHp;a )'(OIlyrrreHHbIx
M. 11. POCTOBn;eBbIM ornH60R CTaROBIlT-
CH BnOJIHe OqeBIlp;HOR, RaK TO.1JbRO MbI
KOCHeMCH oT60pa II pa3pa60TKII II I KOH-
RpeTHoro MaTepllaJIa. B I\eRTpC cro BHIl-
MaHIlH OKa3aJIIlCb Ke.'lep:\leCCKue II
MeJIbryHoBcKIlR RypraRLI. B KOTopbrx:
rJlaBHOe BHHlllaHlle OH yp;e.1HeT 30.'lOTbIIII
oplleHTaJIIl30BaHRbIM Bem,a l. II Kypra-
HbI TeMllp-fopa II IJ;YKyp-Jhmau. B
COCTaB Hall60JIee apXaIl'leChllX ROM-
rrJIeKCOB 11111 Omn60qHO BI\:IJO'IaIOTCH rra-
MHTHIlRIl KOHn;a VI-Ra'la:IH V B. ,qo
H. a., TaRlle RaR llIYMefmollclmii KYP-
raH Y JIbCKIlR KypraH 2 (190Q 1'.), BHTO-
Ba MorllJIa, Orrllrn.'lHIIK3. rac IJallp:eHbI
CKIl.pcRlle 1l306pameHIlH. Y)f{e I10)'(Bep-
raBrnlleCH orrpe,qeJIeHHOi" aJlTII'Inoi! rrc-
pepa60TKe. 3a rrpep;eJlamI BIIlDlaHHH
IlCCJIep;OBaTeJIH .paRTII'ICCRIf OCTa.'lHCb
1l3p;eJIIlH 113 6pOH3bI II pe3 noif I<OCTH, BCH
cepllH npoIl3Bep;eHIlM: HCK 'CCTIJi\ IJ:! I\YP-
raHOB paHHecKIl.pcRorfl Bpe!>IeIJIJ B .1Jeco-
cTerrll, MHO rile 113 KOTOpbIX 011 OTnec R
rr03)'(Hen nope. Bce JTO. eCTCCTfleHno,
IlCRall,aJlO rrpc,qcTaB.lIcnIIe 00 oc IJOBIIOM
COCTaBe paHrrecKH.pcIOIX XYJ10a\CCTBeH-
HbIX 06pa30B II rrplfCMax IE CTII.'l1f3a-
n;IlH. STO TeM 60Jlee CYlI\eCTfI('III!O. '1TO
B3r.lIHp:Ll M. 11. POCTOlJnCflil III,a3aJlll
60JlbIIIOe B.lI11HlIlle Ha lIcc.1C'.lnRHTc.IeH
CRll.pCROH I1p06JIeMbI. fI TO\! '1IH',l(' H B
p;aHHOM BOIlpoce.
BOJlbrnOn BRJIap; B JnyqcJ!J!(' CKIl.p-
CKoro IlCRyccTBa BHCC r. H. £;oJ!0flRa IS.
3HaqeHHe ero Tpy,rra 1[!J;.110'laeTCH
rrpemp:e Bccro B M061f.11T1iln"" !I I 01'-
pOMHoro .paI\THqeCKOrO :\!3TCp1Jil:lil. pac-
cMoTpcnHc KOToporo OJ! U(':11'T lIapa.'I-
11
JIeJIbHO rro TpeM rpyrrrraM: CKmIniH, Cll-
6Hpb, ITpHKaMbe (ceBepHaH JIeCHaH
aOHa). B CBoell 06m;ell KOHn;errn;HH Bo-
pOBKa B OCHOBHOM CJIep;OBaJI POCTOBn;e-
BY. Op;HaKO B OTJIHqHe OT rrOCJIep;HerO
OH rrpHp;aBaJI 60JIblIIee 3HaqeHHe MeCT-
HhIM 3:Ie teHTaM B CKH«pCKOll KYJIbType.
CqHTaH CKH«pOB HpaHn;aMH, rrpHlIIep;nm:-
MH C BOCTOKa, OH B TO me BpeMH rrOJla-
raJI, qTO CKH«phI B IT pHqepHOMopbe
BKJlIOqHJIH OC}aTKH CTaporo, B TOM qHC-
JIe KHMMepHHCKoro, HaCeJIeHHH. OTMe-
-qaH, qTO CKH«pCKaH liYJIbTypa HcrrhITbI-
BaeT pa3.1HqHhIe I1HO;JeMHhIe BJIHHHHH
<lH p;YMa.l, qTO cym;eCTBOBaJI HeKHll P;O
MH HpYIOm;IIB: MeCTHbIH 3JIeMeHT, KOTO-
PhI oc06eHHO HpliO rrpOHBJIHJICH B xy-
p;omeCTBeHHOM CTIme paHHero BpeMeH.Ji
nplIHeceHHOM CKH«pa m C C060ll. iho
CTHJIb C caMoro Haqa.TTa OTJIHqaJICH OT
.lICKYCCTBa fpen;HH, Ma.l0ll A3HH, Meco-
nOTaMHII, ITepclIH, H:aBKa3a. f. If. Bo-
pOBKa Tm;aTeJIblIO rrpOCJIemHBaeT 06pa-
3hI OJIeIIH, JIOCH, rO.l0BhI XHm;HOll rrTH-
IJ;hI, H306pamcIIHH IWmaqbero XIIm;HHKa,
Mep;Be):\H - KOTopbIe 011 CqHTaeT HaH60-
JIee xapaKTepHbHm J .lH Bcex Tpex BhI-
p;eJIeHHbIX HM rpyrrrr.
B Borrpocax XpolIo.l0rHH BopoBKa
6hIJI rru.1HOCTblO 3aBHCHM OT POCTOBn;e
a, a Tali liaK XpOHO.I0fHH rraMHTHHKOB
H6Hpli II aHaHbllHCKOH KYJIbTYPhI Tor-
p;a em;e rre 6bIJIll )J,OCTRTOqHO pa3pa60Ta-
HhI, B CBOIlX rrOCTpoeIIIIHX OH HCXOP;HJI
B OCHOBlI? I 113 CTIUIICHIqCCKIIX corro-
CTaB.leHUII. iho rroc.-I -i1;UJIO rrpHqHHOll
pHp;a )J,orrym;eHHbIX II \I OIU1l60K TaK
HarrpIHlep, OH nepeOL\CHH.l 3H qeHH
o6pa:!a !e;.jBe)J,H II c"nfli(' IWM llCliYCCTBe,
rre oT e.1II.l ero OT '(11I1{UHKa BOiIq bell
rro p O .
O,'lhI. oa 3TII MOTII Ba, HecoMHeHIIo
ceBepHoro rrpOllCXOil\,J('HlIH, OH C'lHTa
HCXO)J,HbDIII )J,:IH fp -lIlIbI KOirraqbHX
XHm;lIHI>OB B ChIIqi(' 1>' ' I IICKYCCTBe
BU):\H B 3TfnI pe3Y.'lbT.1 r IOiKHoro BJTIIH
HIIH 'b.
hal; HblHe YCTaHoIUl' 110, 06pa3 «BO,l-
Qbero XIIm;HIIlia II pitC II pOCTpaHHJICH B
CKH«po-capMaTCKOll KYJIbType He rr03p;-
Hce KOHL\a VI B. p;o H. 3. 17.
XOTH B n;eJIOM f. If. BopOBKa H
He cr:paBHJICH rrOCTaBJIeHHOll HM rrepep;
C060H 3ap;aqeH, op;HaKo rrpOp;eJIaHHhIll
HM orrbIT THrrOJIOrHqeCKoH cHcTeMaTH3a-
n;HH MOTHBOB 3BepHHoro CTHJIH B XpOHO-
JIOfllqeCKOII rrOCJIep;OBaTeJIbHOCTH B rrpe-
p;eJIax Kamp;Oll H3 OCHOBHhIX JIOKaJIbHhIX
rpynn ClGI«pCKoro HCKYCCTBa HBJIHeTcH
MeTOp;HqeC KH npaBHJIbHhIM H 3aCJIyJIm-
BaeT caMOH rrOJIOmHTeJIbHOll On;eHKH.
IfHTepeCHhI 06m;He xapaKTepHCTHKH
p;aHHhIe f. If. BOpOBKOll rrpOH3Be):\eHII
HM paHHeCKH«pCKoro HCKYCCTBa, 3aK.llO-
qalOm;HM B ce6e, KaK OH rrHlIIeT, YHII-
KaJIbHO: npOTHBOpeqHe: COqeTaHHe
CTporOH CTHJIH3an;HH C BeJIHqalllIIHM
rrpaBp;orrop;06HeM. OH yrroTpe6JIHeT Ta-
Koe orrpep;eJIeHHe, KaK «rrpHMHTHBHbIii
HMrrpeCCHOHH3M», OTMeqaH rrpH 3TOM
3aMeqaTeJIbHhIll TaJIaHT p;eKo p aTHB rr '.
C i. Y} OII
THJIH3an;HH . aTH OP;HH H3 rrepBhIx rro-
rrhITOK On;eHKH paHHeCKH«pCKHX rrpoH3-
Bep;eHHH C TOqKH 3peHHH HCKYCCTBOBC-
p;eHHH 3aCJIymHBalOT p;aJIbHellillero BIIII-
MaHHH H pa3pa60TKH.
ITo MHeHHIO f. If. BOPOBKH, rpeqe-
CKoe BJIHHHHe Ha CKH«pCKoe HCKYCCTBO
OKa3aJIOCb p;eCTpYKTHBHhIM, pa3pYllialO-
m;HM ero nepBOHaqaJIbHhIe OCHOBbI
«fpeqeCKOe HCKYCCTBO,- IIHllieT OH
'" 6bIJIO TeM He MeHee qym):\bIM' H
He COOTBeTCTBYIOm;HM u306pameHIIHM
CKH«pCKoro CTHJIH. HaqHHaH C \.
110 H. 3. MbI BHP;HM, KaK rro)J, )J,aBJIeHHe
rpe.:eCKoro BJIHHHHH MeCTHbIll 3Be p ir-
HblII CTHJIb BHHeT H H)J,eT K vrra)J,Ky» 19
ITO)J,06HhIM me HeraTHBHhI 06pa30
0L\eHHBaeT OH B03)J,eHCTI!lle rrpaHCliOro
I1Ch')'CCTBa, rrpOCJIemHBaH ero rro cH6np-
CRIIM Ma 5>HaJIaM.
r BOJIblII Iro1 3HaqeHHe HMelOT B3rJIH.lbI
. If. OpOBKH Ha rrpOlIcxom)J,elIIIe
CKH«pCKoro 3BepHHoro CTH.1H. «.IJ:Ba ,0-
BepUIeHHO qymp;hIx II rrpOTHBOrrOJTOa;-
IIbIX II/Hpa CTOJIKHYJIHCb B IOmHOH POC-
CIIH.- rrHilleT OH,-C O)J,HOH CTOpOlIbl.
rpeqeCKHll H HpaHCKHll MHp, CBH3aHHhIll
06m;eR OCHOBOR B p;peBHOCTH, C
p;pyroH - MHp CKH«po-capMaTCKllX rrJIe-
MeH, rrop;HHBlIIHXCH H3 HeH3BeCTHhIX 3e-
MeJIb BOCTOKa H pacrrpOCTpaHHBlIIHXCH
Ha 3arrap;» 20-". TIo ero MHeHHIO, pOP;H-
HOR 3BepHHoro cTHJIH HBJIHJIaCb CH6HPb,
rp;e XOTb H CMYTlIO, lIO rrpOCJIemHBaeTCH
3BOJIIOn;HH OT 6pOH3hI K meJIe3Y. BMeCTe
C TeM OH He HCKJIlOqaeT B03MomHOCTH
BKJIlOqeHHH B 3TOT apeaJI 06JIaCTH AJI-
TaH. TIOP;OCHOBY HCKyccTBa 3BepHHoro
CTHJIH f. If. BopOBKa, KaK H3BeCTHO, yc-
MaTpHBaJI B HCKyccTBe ceBepHhIX OXOT-
HHqbHX HapO)J,OB JIeCHOR rrOJIOChI.
B Hailiell HCTopHorpa«pHH HMeeTCH
TeHp;eHIJ,I1H pe3KO npOTHBorrOCTaBJIHTb
B3rJIHp;hI M.If. POCTOBn;eBa H f. If. Bo-
pOBKH KaK rrpeP;CTaBHTeJIell P;BYX pa3-
JIHqHhIX, B3alIMOIlCKJIlOqalOm;HX HarrpaB-
JIeHHR. Op;HaKO P;JIH 3Toro HeT p;OCTaTOq-
HhIX OCHOBaHHH. STO JIornqeCKHe 3BeHbH
op;Horo HCCJIe)J,OBaTeJIbCKOrO HarrpaBJTe-
HHH. Pa3JIHqHH Memp;y B3rJIHp;aMH HOCHT
qaCTHhIB: xapaKTep. 06a HCCJIep;OBaTe.iIH
CqHTaJIH, qTO HCKyCCTBO 3BepHHoro CTH-
JIH CJIOmHJIOCb 3a rrpep;eJTaMH CKH«pHH,
rp;e-TO K BOCTOKy I1JIII ceBepO-BOCTOliY
OT Hee. 06a OTpHn;aJIH ero pO)J,CTBO C
I1CKYCCTBOM TIepep;Hell A3HH. 06a yc-
MaTpHBaJIH 6JIHmalllIIYlO CBH3b HCKyc-
CTBa CKH«pHH II CH6HPH, TOJIbKO M. 11.
POCTOBn;eB rrpep;CTaBJIHJI cym;ecTBoBa-
HHe 06m;ero, e)J,HHoro )J,JIH 060Ilx ape a-
,10B n;eHTpa, Torp;a KaR f. If. BopOBlia
OT,'IaBaJI rrpep;rrOqTeHHe JTeCHOH 30ne
CII6HpII.
BOT liaK pe3lOMHpyeT OCHOBHOll Rb!-
BOil CBoero Tpyp;a caM f. If. BopOBKa:
« B03Momrro, HaH60JIee BamlIbIM H3 pC-
3y.lbTaTOB, KOTopble H rrO.1yqHJT, HB.1H-
eTCH 3aK.llOqeHHe, qTO TY3eMHbIll 3.1e-
MeHT, HII rpeqeCKHll, HH IIpaHCKIIll, HO
CrreIJ,II«pHqrrO CKH«pCKHll, lIrpaJT 3HaqII-
Te.lbHO 60.1ee BhIp;alOm;ylOcH pO.lb B
liY.lbType CKH«pHH, HJIH rro KparrHerr Ie-
pe B ee I1CKyccTBe, qeM no )J,O CHX rrop
rrpe)J,cTaB.IH.10Cb )J,ame B KOHn;eIIllIIII
12
M. If. POCTOBn;eBal) 22. If B nOll On;eHKe
OTHOlIIeHHH CBoero Tpyp;a K TPYP;y M. If.
POCTOBn;eBa f. If. BopOBKa COBeplIIeHHO
rrpaB.
B qHCJIe rrpep;CTaBHTeJIeB: Toro me Ha-
rrpaBJIeHHH, qTO II f. If. BopOBKa, 06hIq-
HO Ha3hIBalOT E. MHH3a II .IJ:. H. S)J,HHra.
B CBoell 06m;err pa60Te E. MHH3 OTMe-
qaeT, qTO CKH«pcKoe HCKYCCTBO xapaK-
TepHo caMO IIO ce6e. ECJIH HCKJIIOqHTb
Bce HH03eMHhIe BJIllHHHH, B CKH«p CKOM
HCKyccTBe OCTaHeTCH HeqTO, HH Ha qTO
He rroxomee, OCHOBa Bcero ero pa3BH-
THH 23. STOT TY3eMHbIll 3JIeMeHT - OCHO-
BY, BO Bcell ero qHCTOTe E. MHH3 BHP;HT
B 6accellHe BepXHero EHilceH, C n;eHT-
pOM B MIIHYCHHCKOM Kpae.
Knoll TeMe E. MHH3 06pam;aeTcH
BHOBb R CBoell Crren;HaJIbHOll pa60Te"'.
OC06ylO pOJTb OH OTBOP;HT 06pa3Y O.leHH
B CKH«pCKOM HCKyccTBe, CqIlTaH ero ce-
BepHbHI OJIeHeM. CorrOCTaBIIB IOmHhIe
rrpe)J,eJIhI pacrrpOCTpaHeHIIH ceBepHoro
OJIeHH C apeaJIOM, B rrpep;e!Iax KOToporo
BCTpeqalOTCH H306pameHIIH CKH«pCKHX
OJIeHell, OH YCTaHOBHJT, 'ITO 3Trr 30HhI
C6JIHmalOTCH Ha TeppHTopIIH CH6npH H
oTclO)J,a c)J,eJIa.l BbIBOP;, qTO pO)J,HHOH
H306pameHHll OJIeHH, a c.1e)J,oBaTe!IbHO,
II BCCro CKH«pCKOro HCKyccTBa 6hI.la CH-
6Hpb, oTKyp;a 3TOT MOTHB II pacrrpoCTpa-
HHJICH 3aTeM K 3arra)J,y H lOry.
IToCTpoeHIIH E. MHH3a He BbI;.jepmH-
BalOT I;pIITIIKII. Crren;Ha.IIIICTaMH-300JIO-
raMH YCTalIOB.leHO, qTO B CI{II«pCKO ! HC-
KYCCTBC (fmrYPHpyeT 6JIaropo)J,HbIll. a He
ceBeplIblif O.IIeHb 25. Ifcc.le)J,OBaTe.1HMH
lIC I;YCCTBR C1I6Hpll BhICKR3aHO IHeHHe,
qTO ofipa3 OJIeHH ne COCTaBJiHCT TaM
)J,pIc'RHeiimeH rpyrr, rrbI a OTHOCIITCH K
KOIIL\Y V I - Haqa:IY V B. ;.j0 H. 3. 26 , He
rOBopH YiKe 0 TOM, qTO Borrpoc 0 rrpOHC-
XOiK)J,P !llIrr CKH<pCKoro 3BeplIHoro CTIIJIH
He.lb:!H pemaTb Ha OCHOBi1HlIlI o':lHoro
OTae no R3HToro 06pa3a.
HOBbIii TO.IIqOI; K rrOIICKY leCTHbIX
KopHeii O;H«pCKoro HCKYCCTBa aa.1II HC-
C.l£'.lOIlR 1111 H ypa.lbCI;HX TOP«PHHIII;OB,
13
ocy eCTBJIeHHI.Ie B 3O-x rr. A. H. 3.n;BH-
rOM. 3):\eCb B CJIOHX n03):\Hero HeOJIBTa
6hIJIli Hall):\eHhI ):\epeBHHHhIe II pOI'OBhIe
CKYJIbnTyphI JIOCH, Me):\BeAH, Bo):\onJIaBa-
IO ell rrTllI:(hI, HaIIIe):\IIIlle orrpe):\eJIeH-
RbIe COOTBeTCTBIiH B 300MOpqJHOM 6pOH-
30BOM JIIiTbe cellMllHcKO-Typ611HcKoro
TlfIla B IIpllypaJIbe Z7. AHaJIIl311PYH aTIl
CKYJIbrrTyphI, ,lJ;. H. 3.n;BHr OTMeqaeT BX
peaJIll3 [, HO peaJIll3M OC06hIll, npll KO-
TOpOM oT6llpaIOTCH HaB60JIee cy ecT-
BeHHbIe rrpll3HaKil mIlBOTHhIX: JIaKO-
HB3M, OTCYTCTBlle .n;eTaJIB3aI:(HlI, rrepe-
XO):\ K YCJIOBHOCTll, T. e. HMeHHO Te
CTBJIllCTnqeCKBe aJIeMeHThI, KOTophIe B
60JIee pa3BllThIX npOHBJIeHllHX COOTBeT-
CTBYIOT paHHeCKBcpCKOMY BCKYCCTBY.
«IKIlBOTIIoe nepeCTaeT 6hITb caMo.n;OB-
.'leIOlI\eii TeMOll, OHO CTaHOBIiTCH OCHO-
BOH ):\.'IH BapllaI:(IlH 113 pH.n;a KaK 6hI Ka-
HOHIl311pOBaHHhIX .n;eKopaTllBHhIX aJIe-
!>feHTOB» 28.
IIOJIeMIl311PYH C A. M. TaJIbrpeHOM,
OTpllI:(aIO IlM pOJIb BCKYCCTBa OXOT-
Hllqbero HaCeJIemm JIeCHOll nOJIOChI EB-
ponbI B cpOpMllpOBamrll CKllcpCKoro 3Be-
pllHoro CTllJIH B CllJIY OTCYTCTBIiH B HeM
opHaMeHTaJIbHOCTll, a TaKme oc060ro
COCTaBa BhIcoKoropHoH cpaYHhI, A. H.
S):\llm' y6e):\IlTeJIbHO IIOAqepKHYJI, qTO
«nllI\aI\I1e pe.'Ibecp B cpaYHa He c03):\aAyT
xy):\omeCTBeHHoro CTBJIH BHe3aIIHO, BO
BceopYilmn xapaKTepHhIX oc06eHHO-
cTeii»". hCTaTll, OT:MeTBM, qTO opHa-
MeHTa.1hllaH HaChIlI\eHHOCTb 60JIee CBOH-
CTBerrHa cpe):\HeMY rrepllO):\Y CKllcpCKoro
I1CKYCCTBa, HemeJIIi ero paHHeMY JTarry.
fllrrrrre3a rrpOllcxom):\eHllH ):\peBHell
OCHOll[,[ CI<llcpCKoro 3BepilHoro CTIlJIH OT
I1CHYCCToa HapO):\OB JIeCHOll rrOJIOChI
rrO:I1IOCTbIO lIe rrO):\TBep):\IlJIaCb. O):\HaKO
e:.(IH1 .111 lOmHO COMHeBaTbCH B TOM, qTO
IDlem[O 1I3 noro Kpyra Be):\YT CBoe rrpo-
I1CXOffi.11'l!ne H306pameHllH 1\Ie):\BeAH II
BO.'1qbl'fO XlllI\HllKa B aHaHbllHCKOll
KYJIhT\'pe IIpIiKaMbH, IIOJIyqllBIIIlle 3a-
TeM pacrrpOCTpaHeHlle B rraMHTHIlKax
("!-;H<pC1;oro I;pyra Ha Cpe):\HeM ,lJ;OHY II
caBpOMaTO-CKBcpCROM MBpe, a TaKme
06pa3 JIOCH, CTOJIb ):\peBHBH B llCKyccTBe
ceBepHhIx Hapo.n;oB. MecTHoe npollC-
xom.n;eHlle 06pa3a JIOCH B CKllcpCKoM
llCKYCCTBe He OTBepraeTCH ):\ame TaKB-
Mil CTOpOHHIlKaMIl nepe):\Hea311aTCKOH
KOHI(enI:(IlIl, KaK M. M. ApTaMOHOB II
H. JI. qJIeHOBa 30.
OCTaHOBIiMCH KpaTKO Ha TaK Ha3hIBa-
eMOM aHTllqHOM HarrpaB;WHllll B CJIO-
meHllll CKllcpCKoro llCKYCCTBa, B qllCJIe
npe):\CTaBllTeJIeH KOToporo yrroMHHeM
A. <DYPTBeIITJIepa, B. B. <DapMaKoBCKO-
ro, M. 36epTa, R. lIIecpOJIb):\a 31.
OTJIllqBe OT r. M. BOpOBKll, KOTO-
phIli YCMaTpliBaJI B rpeqeCKOM BJIllHHllll
rJIaBHhIll cpaKTOp pa3pYilleIlllH OpIiTII-
HaJIbHOll rrepBOOCHOBhI CKllcpCKoro llC-
KYCCTBa, aTIl yqeHhIe, Ha060pOT, Bll):\e-
JIB B HeM rJIaBHOe TBOpqeCKOe HaqaJIO,
nOCJIymllBillee OCHOBOll cpOpMllpOBaHIiH
3BepilHoro CTIiJIH CKllcpOB IIpllqepHO-
MOpbH. He OTpllI:(aH IIaJIllqllH MeCTHhIX
caM06hITHhIX nepBOHaqaJIbIIbIX cpOpM
CKllcp Koro BCKYCCTBa, OHIl CqllTaJIIi IIX
60JIee llJIIi MeHee aMopcpHhIMIl II MaJIO-
3HaqllTeJIbHhIMll, rro.'IyqllBIIIIlMIl CBoe
3aROHqeHHOe II HpKoe BhIpamenlle JIllillb
B pe3YJIbTaTe conpliKOCHOBeHllH C llC-
KYCCTBOM 1l0mrHCKIlX rpeKOB, Oc06eHHo
rraTpliOTllqIIO B OTHOIIIeHHIl pOJIIi rpe-
'IeCROrO BCKyCCTBa BbICKa3hIBaJICH
B. B. <DapMaKoBcKllll. ITo em MHeHlllO,
Bce llCKYCCTBO CKllcpOB n pnqepnOMOpI.H
QhIJIO C03):\aHO B rpeqeCKIlX IWJIOHIlHX,
npeBpaTllBIIIllX rrpemllile «yoorne a,'Ie-
MeHTbI» B «rrepJI co:qaHIIH» "".
3HaqllTe.'1bHI.IM arrII30):\OM B pa3BIlTHII
cKllcpoBe):\eHllH HBll.;raCh paoOTa R. IIle-
cpOJIb):\a 0 3BepilHOM CTH.:!e. OCHoBHhIe
rrOJIOmeHIlH :nOll pa60ThI OI,IJIIi TlI\a-
TeJIbHO (paccMOT[H'III.I H peI:(eH311II
H. H. IIoJpe60Boll, .'HIBIIIPii OO'heKTllB-
HyIO OI:(eIfKY KaK rrO:JO,HIITP;[ I,HbIX CTO-
pOH, TaK II cYw.ecTBeHIlbl\ I1e):\ocTaT-
KOB 32. K. IIlecpOJIb):\ rOTOB Ghl.'1 cJIe):\o-
BaTb cOBepIIIeHHo n paB[J.II,jIOll rrpo-
rpaMMe, COrJIaCHO HOTOpoil pa3BIITile
OCHOBHhIX 06pa30B CKBcpcKoro IICKYCCT-
Ba cn:e):\yeT oCBe aT? Ha OCHOBaHli1i
ToqHo ):\aTllpoBaHHhIx naMHTHllKOB. Ok
HalW aBTOp He 6hIJI CneI:(llaJIIiCTOM-CKll-
4>OBe):\OM B lie 6hIJI nOArOTOBJIeH K npa-
BllJIbHOMY caMOCTOHTeJIbHOMY aHaJIll3Y
apxeOJIOrBqeCKBX llCTOqHllKOB. CJIe):\YH
M. 11. POCTOBI:(eBY II orrllpaHCb B OCHOB-
HOM Ha .n;aTllpOBKH rraMHTHIIKOB no
aHTllqHhIM Be aM, OH CMeillaJI Mem):\y
C060ll pa3HOBpeMeHHhIe rrpOIl3Be):\eHIIiI,
He CYMeJI BhIAeJIllTb OCHOBHYIO qaCTb
rrpe):\MeTOB CKllcpCKOH apxaliKII, a no
coOTBeTCTBeHHO CKa3aJIOCb Ha rrOHllM3-
Hlill oc06eHHOCTell BCXO):\HhIX II rrOCJIe-
P;YIOllI;IlX aTarrOB CRllcpCKoro IICKyccTBa.
B CBoeR KOHI:(enI:(BB R. lIIecpon:bA Ma-
JIO oplirBHaJIeH. IIo ero MHeHIIIO, pau-
Hlle cpOpMhI CKllcpCKoro CTIiJIH 3apO):\Il-
.TIllCb Ha ceBepO-llpaHCKOH pO):\IIHe CKII-
(f)oB, He.n;aJIeKO OT MecorrOTaMllll II B
rOTOBOM Bll):\e 6hIJIli rrpliHeceHbI B IIpn-
qepHOMOpbe, r):\e OHIl rro.'IyqllJIIl OKOH'.Ja-
TeJIbHOe ocpopMJIeHlle rro):\ peIIIaIOu IBI
BJIllHHlleM llCKyccTBa 1l0HIlllCKIIX rpe-
ROB. 113 IIpllqepHOMOpI.H no IICKYCCT-
BO pacrrpOCTpaHllJIOCb B EBpa3IIll, na
ceBepe, II B CIl611pll.
TaKIiM 06pa30M, MI.I Bll):\llllI, 'IT 0
oI:(eIIKa 3HaqeHllH BJIllHHllH rpeqeCKOrO
UCRYCCTBa Ha CKllcpCKIiH 3BeplllII.Iii
CTIiJIb B Tpy):\ax npe):\CTaBllTe.'IeH pa3-
.TIHqHhIX HarrpaB.'IeHlliI OKa:1aJIaCh rrpH\1O
rrpOTIlBOrrOJIOmHOll. O):\Hll Bll):\HT B He,!
pa3p 'IIIaIOllI;IlH, ):\Pyrue - C03II):\aIOII\1I1I
4>aKTOp. 11 ):\e.'IO 3):\eCb. I;QUeqHO, Ill' IJ
:)MOl\IlOHaJlbHbIX BocrrpIlHTUHX. flIrrOTl"
3a 06 aHTllqIIhIX UCTOKax cpOP\lIIpOBit-
HHH CI;llcpcKoro IICHYCCTBa B I1itCTOHIIH'P
BpeMH HIIKe [ He rrO.1):\epa;rIBaeTCH.
O):\HaKO 3HaqeHile rpeqeCI;Oro B.'IIH11JI1H
Ha rrOCJIe):\YIOw.ee pa3BIlTile nCKYCc.TBiI
CKllcpOB IIpIIqepHOMOpbH rrpe):\CTan;I;J-
eTCfI HeCOMHeHHbIlIL OqeBlI.J;IIO, IIp<11\
f. BopOBKa II BbICKa3aBIIIaHCH B TO I ;I e
HarrpaBJIeHIIll H. H. ITorpeOOBH. 'I TO
KOHTaKT C rpeqeCKIiMll I'D.1l0IIIlH\!1! ('
I;OHl\a VI B. ):\0 H. a. rrpllBe:r H ObleT J .n.
14
MY paCIla):\y.. ):\peBHeHIIIeH, Hall60JIee
opllrIIHaJIbHOII rpyrrrrhI 06pa30B CKllcp-
CKoro llCKYCCTBa. B TO me BpeMH COBep-
IIIeHHO HCHO, qTO B pe3YJIbTaTe Herro-
cpe):\CTBeHHhIX rpeKO-CKllcpCKIiX KOHTaI
TOB B V B. .n;o H. a. CI\JIa):\hIBaeTCH HOBbIII
BapnaHT llCKYCCTBa CKllcpOB IIpllqepHO-
MOpbH, CTaBIIIllll cBoe06pa3HhIM «BeKOM
6apPOKKO» CKllcpCKoro 3BepilHoro CTIiJUI.
IIOHBIiJIIiCb HOBhIe opBrllHaJIbHhIe BbI-
COKOXYAomeCTBeHHhIe npOll3BeAeHBfI,
OT"IIIqaIO lleCH MHoro06pa3HOH ):\eKopa-
TllBHOll HaChI eHHOCTbIO, CMeJIbIM BC-
rro.lb30BaHlleM pa3Ho06pa3HhIX 300-
MOpcpHhIX aJIeMeHTOB B MOTBBOB rpe-
qeCKOrO opHaMeHTa, 0611JIlieM «300-
r.lOpcpHhIX IIpeBpa eHllll». B nOT
rrepno):\ B03HllKaIOT oIIpe):\eJIeHHhIe IIIKO-
JIb! II rrpoll3BoACTBeHRbIe I:(eHTphI, TaR
qTO pa3pYIIIeHile apXaBqeCKIiX cpOpM
rrpIIBeJIO K pomAeHIlIO HOBoro BapliaHTa
CKllcpCKoro llCKYCCTBa. K COmaJIeHllIO,
HB,'IeHllH aToro rrpOI:(ecca rrOqTll He 3a-
TPOUYThI crreI:(llaJIbHhIMIl llCCJIe):\OBa-
HllHMIl.
,lJ;aJIbHellillee 113yqeHlle CKllcpCKoro
3BepilHoro CTIlJIH OpraHllqeCKIl CBH3aHO
C pa3BllTileM CKllcpOBe):\eHllH B rrpe):\-
BoeHHI.Ie II oc06eHHo rrOCJIeBOeHHbIe
rO):\b!. E):\Ba JIll HymRo rOBopllTb, KaRoe
60.,bIIIoe 3HaqeHile llMeJIa XpOHOJIOrn-
qeCKaH rrpopa60TKa MeCTHhIX aJIeMeHTOB
CI;ncpCKoro KOMrr.leKca, HaqaTaH pa60-
TamI B. H. fpaKOBa II B. 3. Pa611Ho-
BUqa 33. B pe3y.'IbTaTe Hee oKa3aJIOCb
YTOqIIeHO BpeMH MHornx paHHecKIIcp-
hIlX rraMHTHIlROB, r.;raBHbIM 06pa30M II
OU.laCTIl Cpe):\Hero IIolJ,HerrpoBbH, II Te !
Ca !hIM BBe):\eHa B HayqHOe 06pa eHIIe
!acc a paHee ne llCrroJIb30BaBIlIllXCfI
IIjW.1MeTOB paHHecImcpcKoro llCKYCCTBa.
BamHellIIIee 3naqeHile I1MeJIII pac-
KOrIHIl KapMllp-BJIypa II llCCJIe):\OBaHlle
b. B. IIllOTpOBCHHM Ky.lbTypbI II llCKYC-
CTBa YpapTY"'. B. B. IIIIOTpOBCKlill y6e-
;J:IlTe.'1bHO rrOKa3aJI, qTO MHorlle ApeBHe- .
BOCTOqHhIe aJIeMeHThI B paHHecKllcpcRIIX
KypraHax llMeIOT caMYIO Herrocpe):\CT-
15
BeHHyIO CBJl3L C HCKYCCTBOM BaHCKOrO
n;apCTBa. TeM CaMLlM OH npaKTHqeClHl
060CHOBaJI MLlCJIb, BLlCKa3aHHYIO B CBOe
BpeMJI em;e M. M. POCTOBn;eBLlM, a rro-
3AHee rrOMepmaHHyIO M. M. MaKCHMO-
BOH, P. fHpillMaHOM, C. C. qepHHKoBLlM
o cym;ecTBoBaHHH oc06L1x MaCTepCKHX,
B KOTOpLlX XYAomHHKH-peMeCJIeHHHKH
pa3HLlX CTpaH TPYAHJIHCb HaA c03AaHH-
eM ille.n;eBpOB IOBeJIHpHOro npOH3BOACT-
Ba AJIfl CKH«pCKHX n;apeH.
HaXOAKH Ha RapMHp-BJIype CKH«p-
CKHX Bem;eR B 3BepHHOM CTHJIe, OTHOCH-
ID;HXCfl KO BpeMeHH em;e AO rraAemlfl
TeHille6aHHH, nOATBepAHJIH AaTHpOBKY
uaH60JIee paHHHX npeAMeTOB noro CTII-
JIfl BpeMeHeM KOHn;a VII, py6ema VII-
VI BB. AO H. a.
BamHLle HCCJIeAOBaHHfl 6L1JIH ocy-
m;eCTB.TIeHLI Ha TeppHTopHH AJITaH
M. II. rpfl3HOBLlM H C. M. PYAeIlKo"'.
OTKpLlTHe H HCCJIeAOBaHHe IIa3L1pLlK-
CKHX KypraHoB AaJIO B03MomHOCTb
rrpeACTaBHTb HCKYCCTBO HapoAoB AJI-
Tafl V B. AO H. a. BO BceM ero 60raTcTBe
H MllOro06pa3HH; BOOqHIO nOKa3aJIo, Ka-
Koe 3HaqeHHe B HCKYCCTBe 3BepHHoro
CTIIJIH HMeJIa pe3b6a no AepeBy, H3Ae-
JIIIH 11:3 KomH H BOHJIOKa, BLlillHBKH, arr-
rrJIHKa HH H MHoroe APyroe II3 rrpe)J,-
MeTOB 06HxoAa, oCTaBillHXCfl HeH3BeCT-
HLIMII B rraMflTHHKax CKH«pCKOn: KYJIb-
TYPbI.
MaTepIIaJJI>I aTHX KypraHoB rrOKa3aJIII
cBoe06pa3He rrYTeH pa3BHTHfl HCKYCCT-
Ba HapO)WB AJITafl rro cpaBHeHIlIO co
CKH«PCKHM. B CBOHX pa60Tax C. 11. Py_
AeHKo y6e)J,IITeJIbHO rrOKa3a,'I 60JIbillOe
BJIHflHlle Ha AJITan: HCKYCcTBa aXCMe-
HHAcI\Oro 11paHa, cLlrpaBillero, oqeBnA-
HO, 3)J,ecb Ty me pOJIL, KOTOpyIO )J,JIH
CKH«POB IT pHqepHOMopbfl cblrpa.'I1I rpe-
KH 36. M. II. rpH3HOBLlM 6blJIH Bb[)J,e.TIe-
HLI lIa A.TITae rraMflTHIIKII Maj,bMlJp-
CKoro :JTarra co cBoe06pa.1l!bIMII rrpo-
flBJIeHIIHMII 3BepHHoro CTIIJIH, OTI!OCH-
m;erOCH K VII, VII-VI BB.)J,O H, 3. n ,
A pxeO.TIOrHqeCKHe HccJIeAOBaHIIH B
CTerrHOM IIoBoJImbe H IOmHOM IIpH-
ypaJIbe, ocym;eCTBJIeHHLle II. ,n:. Pay,
B. H. rpaKoBLlM, a B AaJIbHeHilleM
R. <D. CMHpHOBLlM H M. r. MOillKOBOH
BBeJIU B HaYKy npeACTaBJIeHHe 0 caB-
pOMaTcKo-capMaTcKoR KYJIbType "'.
R. <D. CIIIHpHOB B CdlOHX TpYAax YAeJIHJI
60JIbillOe BHHMaHHe BonpocaM HCKYCCT-
Ba caBpollIaToB Hero OC060MY MecTY
cpeAII APyrHx rpyrrrr paHHero 3BepHHo-
ro CTIT.ifl. «(IIpH 06m;eM CxoAcTBe CKH«p O -
cH6HPCKoro 3BepHHoro CTHJIfl,- nHilleT
OH, - BLlAeJIflIOTCfl H JIOKaJIbHLle OCO-
6eIlHocTH. TaK, HanpHMep, 3BepHHLlR
CTHJIb CeBepHoro IIpHqepHOMopbfl H
II plmy6aHbH B 3HaqHTeJIbHOH CTerreHH
OTJIIIQaeTCfl OT 3BepHHoro CTHJIfl IOm-
HOI[ Crr6IIpH KaK rro MOTHBaM, TaK H rro
CTH:JIICTIIqeCKIIM rrpH3HaKaM. BecbMa
Bblpa:3IITeJIbHO 6L1JIO 300MoP«PHoe HCKyc-
CTHO al!aHbHHCKHX rrJIeMeH IIpHKaMbJl.
II Ypa:la» 39. CaBpOMaTaMH B VI-V BB.
AO H. a. 6L1JIa TaKme c03AaHa oc06afl
JIOKa.'lbHafl rpyrrrra 3BepHHoro CTHJIfl.
HacaHcb Borrpoca 0 npoHcxom.n;eHIIII
CKII«PCI\Oro HCKyccTBa, R. <D. CMHPHOB
OTMeQaeT, qTO TeppHTopHeH ero OKOH-
qaTt':lbIJOro CJIOmeHHfl flBJIflJIHCb IOm-
Uble paiioHLI EBpa3HH - (<01' CTeUe!f
YKpaIIllb[ AO CpeAHen: A3IIH H IOmHorr
Cllon pH, BKJIIOqafl AJITaH. BemrID;YIO
POJIb B «POpMHpOBaHHH aToro CTHJIJI
Hrpa:1IJ He TOJIbKO CeBepOqepHOMopCKIIe
CKH«PbI. HO H APyrne HapoAbI, oc06eHIlO
caKCI;UC IIJleMeHa CpeAHeH A3HH» .'.
IIOCToHlTHoe 06m;eHHe orrpe.n;eJIIIJIO
00:lb11l0C CXOACTBO 300MOP«P HLI X MOTH-
HUH II CTlIJIH lIa BceM TeppHTOpITH.
U!lpe.:.r,e.TIeHHLlll narr B H3yqeHnn
He 1< 'CCTBa HapOAoB CH6ITPH COCTaBIIJI
TPYA C. B. I{HceJIeBa, B KOTOpOM 60JIb-
mOrl pa3Ae.'l rrOCBflm;eH KapacyKcKo-Ta-
rapCI\O [J:lHCKYCCTBY ". C. B. KII em>B
npllxo;(Hf K BbIBOAY, qTO ocrrOBon )J,Rfl
pa3B!lTIIH TBOpqeCTBa XY)J,omHHKOJ!
C'I<lHfJO-TarapCKoro BpeMeHH HBIIJIOCb HC-
I\YC('THO 3rroxII KapaCYKa. OTMeqafl rra-
pa.TIC:IJI:J}[ TarapCKoro H CKII«pCKoro
16
HCKYCCTBa, OH BMeCTe C TeM rrOAqepKH-
aeT 3HaqIITeJIbHYIO caMOCTOflTeJlbHOCTh
6eHX aTHX 06JIaCTeii. B KaqeCTBe ApeB-
HeHllIHx MOTHBOB TarapcKoro HCKycCT-
a RM BLlAeJIHIOTCfl Ka6aH, MeABeAb H
:OPHLIH K03eJI, CTOHlI\lIll C 3aKIIHYTLlMH
poraMH,- MOTIIBLI, He xapaKTepHLI
AJIfl CKH«pCKOH apXaHKIT. C APyroll
CTOpOHLI, PflA 1II0TIIBOB paHHe KH«pCKoro
HCKyccTBa - O.TIeHb, KOillaqHII XHm;HHK,
opeJI co CIllIpaJIbHbIM KJIIOBOM - IlOflB-
JIflIOTCJI 3AeCb JIHillb B KOHn;e VI - Ha-
qaJIe V B. AO H. a. Bce no He .?03BOJIflel'
CTaBHTb CKlI«pCKHH 3BepHHLlII CTHJIb B
reHeTHqecKyIO 3aBIICHMOCTb OT CH6l'1p-
CKoro H Ha060pOT.
C. B. KIIce.'leB CqIlTaeT, qTO CKH«pCKoe
HCKYCCTBO H c1l6IIpCKoe HCKYCCTBO pa:1-
BHBaJIHCb rrapaJIJIe.1bHO II HX 06m;HOCT
3aBRCHT He TOJIbKO OT 6JIII3KIIX YCJIOBHH
B03HHKHOBeHHfl, HO II OT B3aHMHoro
npOHHKHOBelIHH HOBbIX 06pa3n;OB H MO-
THBOB. HeCMOTpH Ha TO, qTO AJIfl 3arraA-
HOH 06JIaCTl! CI{If«pCKoro 3BepHHoro CTH-
JIfl HeH3Bf'CTHa l\peBHflfl MeCTHafl rroAoc-
HOBa, 06HapymeHHaH Ha EHHcee AJIfl CH-
6HpCKOro IIcKyccTBa, C. B. KHCeJIeB rro-
JIaraeT, qTO «eCTh Bce OCHOBaHHfl HC-
KaTb HaqaJIO CI\HcpcKoro 3BepHHoro op-
HaMeHTa He TO.lbKO B CKpem;eHHII
xYAomeCTBeHHblX R.'lHflH H a CHpO-Ba-
BRJIOHCKoii IT xeTTo-xyplIlICKOII IIepe;:\-
HeM A31111. 3arraAIIoro 11paHa H ypapr-
CKOro KaBKH3a, lIO II B lIIeCTHOM TBOp-
qeCTBe MHCTepoB py6emaII IIITbIC.AO
H. a.,).2 3TO rroc .'leAHee rrO.TIOmeHITe
OCTaeTCH rrOI<H IICAoI<a3aHHbIM, II IICTO-
[m CKII«pcKoro :3BeprrHoro CTII:IH BepoflT-
lIee Bcero C.WAver HCI<aTb r)J,e-To Ha 06-
IIIlIpIIbIX rrpo Tpa I!CTBaX Cpe)J,HeH n
IJ;eHTpaJlbllOii A:HI!!.
3a !I rroc.-w;U Il' rO)J,LI rrOflBrrJICfl pfl;:!
pa60r, rrOCBHIIU'lIllbIX 113yqeHIIIO or-
)J,e.ibHLlx Rrllu,ji II MOTIIBOB 3BepHHoro
CTII.lH. K I1X Qllr:I T OTHOCHTCfl CTaTbl'l
M. 11, Mal,CII JO!lO[1 0 3epKa.TIe II pllT He
H:3 KeJIep\!cca ", H, H. IIorpe60BoII 0
CKI1«pCKOM rplI<{Hll!e", M. 11. BH3bllIll-
THHOH 06 H306pameHHflx Ha ma60T 1!
CKHX rrJIaCTRHax. 5 , H. JI. qJIeHOBOn <)
CKH«pCKOM OJIeHe .., HaillH CTaTbII 0 IIC-
1\OTOpbIX 06pa3ax paHHeCKH«pCKoro 3Bl'-
.7 b A 11 lllK" I )hO
pHHoro CTIIJIfl ,CTaT n ., J
II C. C. CopOKHHa 0 CBepHYBille [OI
xHID;HHKe .., 8. B. HKOBeHKO 0 BO qbe [
xHID;HHKe .'. Bce aTH pa60TLI B TOIl II;!!!
HHOH Mepe rrOCBflID;eHLI H3yqeHHIO HCTO-
KOB rrpoHcxomeAeHHJI pa3JIHqHLlX 3Be-
pHHLlX 06pa30B B CKH«pCKOM HCKYCCTBe,
A. II. MaHn;eBH'I H A. M. MeJIIOKOBa
pa60TaIOT B 06JIaCTH H3yqeHHH B3aHM -
CBfl3eH HCKyccTBa CKH«pHH H <DpaKHn .
B HaCTOflID;eH CTaTbe HeT B03MomHOCTIl
KOMMeHTHpOBaTb nH pa60TLI, oAep -
m;He MHoro HHTepeCHLlX, rropoll HCKY l -
CIIOHHbIX MLlCJIeH H rrO.TIOmeHIIII.
B 40-x r. B MHCTHTYTe HMeHrr PeIIlI-
Ha 6L1JIa 3am;Hm;eHa KaHAHAaTCKa,1
AHccepTan;Hfl M. B. IIecTpm,oBo:!
«CKH«pCKoe HCKyCCTBO oAHerrpoB[':I
VI-III BB. AO H. a.» B ;)TOH pa60Tc aR-
TOpOM 6L1JI nOCTaBJIeH Borrpoc 0 Ha:I1I-
qHIT JIOKaJIbHLlX KYJIbTypHLlX rpy-rrl!
3BepHHoro CTHJIfl H BblCKa3aHO .1I!I1:-
He 06 OTJIllqll1l xY)J,omeC'TBPHIIbIX 00-
a30B CTerrH II JIeCOCTerrH. IIOCKOJIbl, '
11. B. IIecTpflKoBa HCKYCCTBOBeA, a 1:"
apxeOJIor, OHa OKa.1aJIaCb HeAOCTa:ro t.
HO opIIeHTHpOBaHa B XpOHo.TIOrIlH C'1\I11I ' -
CKHX rraMflTHH[WB H B TOM, qTO OCIlOB
Hoe KOJIHqeCTBO rrorpe6eHHM: CKncpct:OII
apxaHKH cocpeAOTOqeIIO B JIeCOCTPIIll,
XpOHOJIOrHqeCKHe pa3JIHqnH Ob!:m I1pll-
HflTbI eIO 3a JIOKaJIbHble. ,
HeMHoro rr03AHce B. r. neTpl'II''''
BLlCKa3aJIa MbIC.ib 0 .'lOKa.11,1!0C'TI! OT-
AeJIbHbIX BapHalITOB OpJIIIHblX HI 101\
V B. AO H. a., rrb!TaflC'b rro)J,QI'!J1,II'T'.
aTRM 060c06JIeHHOCTb KYJIbTyphl I'WIIII
H JIeCOCTerrH 51. O)J,HaKO, Kal, BblHCIIl1
JIOCb rroA06HbIe rO.TIOBKII H3BerTII hI 1\
rraM THHKax CTerrHoro KpbIMa_ 1>1 pi ,1-
Hax y KpHBoro Pora II rro)J, HIlI,o,till"
BOM.
HOBYIO rrOrrbITKY B 3Tm[ lIarrp,IH,I,'
HRH rrpeArrpHHfl.'l B. A. III pa lI<o ])",
17
pamaH npOT1IB BhIAeJIeHHhIX HaMIl II30-
6pameHIIii KOHCKIIX rOJIOBOK Ha KOCTH-
HhIX nCaJIIIHX, OH TpaKTyeT HeKOTophIe
II3 HIIX KaK II306pameHIIH JIOCH, ,qpy_
rIle - KaK II306pameHIIH KOmaqberO
XIIm;HIIKa II OTCIOAa AeJIaeT BhIBO)J; 0
JIOKaJIbHOCTII II306pameHIIii JIOCH B
JIeCOCTenHoii nOJIoce II pe,qKOM II306pa-
meHHII KOHH ". AYMaeTCH, qTO
B. A. IIIpaMKo He npaB. MaHepa CTIIJIII-
Puc. 1. Ha06paxeuUJ1, 30./l0eo.: ':OUR e Uc.:yc-
cree aeepuH030 CrU./IR Eepaauu:
1-8 - Ha KOCTRHLlX nCaJIHRX nOCYJIhR; 9-16_
Ha 6POH30BLlX H KOCTHHLlX HO>KaX 113 CII6HpH
(no B. A. foponnOBY, C. B. HHCeJIeBY, H. .1. 'lJIe-
HOBOII); 9, 11-15 - 6poH3a; 10, 16 - KOCTh, por;
17 - Ha PYKOHTH 6poH30Boro ROffia 113 (cMOrUJIhI
CJIOHa», AHbHH
.
o e=-::::::
o
1
3aD;IIII rOJIOBOK KOHH C BhITHHYTOii Bnc-
peA MOPAOii II npIImaThIM YXOM HBJIHeT-
CH 06m;eii AJIH Bceii rpynnhI CKIIcpCKIIX
II TarapcKIIx II306pameHIIii. B oTAeJIb-
HhIX CJIyqaHx Ha rOJIOBe KOHJI II306pa-
meHa Y3Aa (pIIC. 1).
MaHepa CTII.1JII3aD;IIII rOJIOBhI JIOCH co-
epmeHHO APyraH. TIOMIIMO KpYTO nepe-
JIOMJIeHHOii MOPAhI, npII3HaKOM JIOCJI
HBJIJlIOTCH cpaBHIITeJIbHO KopoTKIIe, OT-
TonhIpeHHhIe OT rOJIOBhI YIDH (pIIC. 2),
II 3TOT 3JIeMeHT HenpeMeHHO nO)fiep-
KIIBaeTCJI ApeBHHMII MaCTepaMH KaK
AOCKIIcpCKOro, TaK II cKIIcpcKoro BpeMe-
HII. qYTKIIe, npIImaThIe K 3aThIJIKY,
AJIIIHHhIe ymII II BhITHHYTaJi MOPAa co-
BepmeHHO HecBoiicTBeHHhI MaHepe ne-
pen:aqII JIOCH.
'0
o
<:>
2
..
3
4
.<:>
9 c:::>'
6
o
7
8
8 \ \\$\\\#' r
11
12
:
15
: °o
16
13 '_
o
r-= 0
17
18
r
4 0
5
HepeAKO apXaIIqCCKlIe II306pameHBJI
JIOCH TpaKTYIOT KaK ,JIOKaJIbHO JIeco-
CTenHhIe. OAHaKo, aTO He TaK. To, qTO
aTOT 06pa3 BXOAIIT B OCHOBHOll COCTaB
CIOmeTOB paHHecKIIcpcKoro 3BepIIHoro
CTIIJIH nOATBepmAaeTCH II306pameHIIJI-
)Ul .1JOCH Ha KeJIepMCCCKoii ceKIIpe. BJIII-
Puc. 2. Ha06paxeHue ./IOCR e c.:ur/'Jo-ca,:c':OM
uc.:yccree u uc.:yccree Hapoooe ceeepa:
I, 2 - Ha K3MeHHhIX H3neJIBJIx. HapeJIHH; 3 - Ha
PYKORTH 6poH30Boro HO>Ka, CellMa; 4 - KOCTlIHaR
rOJIOBKa 83 Baa3UXH, Caoapb; 5. 6. 7 - Ha nna-
CTHHHax H3 ffia6oTHHa; 8. 8a, 86 - H3 OPOH30BOM
3epKane D3 KypraHa 21 ¥lIrapaKa; 9 - nRTLlIl na-
3blpblHCHl-di: KypraH, Bblpea3HO 83 HOlliS; 10-
6poH30BaR 6JIRXa H3 KypraHa 7 y r. JR;J.aHoBa;
11 - 6POH30B3R 6JIRXa H3 KypraHa y c. HOBaH
P033HOBK3
3
8
6
8a
7
86
maiimyIO napaJIJIeJIL JIOCHM Ha ma60-
TIIHCKIIX nJIaCTIIHKaX AaIOT rpaBllpOBaH-
HhIe II306pameHIIH Ha 6pOH30BOM 3ep-
KaJIe II3 KypraHa 21 YifrapaKa. II3o-
6pameHIIe JIOCH B TpaKTOBKe, 06hIqHOii
AJIH V B. ,qo H. a., BCTpeqaeTCH B CTen-
HhIX KypraHax y HOBo-Po3aHoBKII II nO;rJ;
MapIIynOJIeM (pIIC. 2, 8) 53. B 06m;eM
nOKa HeT oCHoBaHIIii rOBopIITb 0 HamI-
qIIII JIOKaJIbHhIX oc06eHHocTeii CKIIcp-
CKoro IICKYCCTBa B npe,qeJIax OCHOBHhIX
TeppIITOpIIaJIbHhIX rpynn. CKIIcpCKoe HC-
KYCCTBO TI pH'lepHOMOpbH 6hIJIO e,qIIHhIM
no COCTaBY 3BepIIHhIX 06pa30B, qepTaM
CTIIJIII3aD;IIII II OCHOBHhIM aTanaM aBO-
JIIOD;IIII .
B. H. rpaKOB He 3aIIIIMaJICH cne-
D;IIaJIbHO CKIIcpCKIIM IICKyCCTBO !. EMY
10
f9
UpllHa,l:\JIemaT mlIUb OT,l:\eJIbHbIe BbICKa-
3bfBaHlIJI no 310MY Bonpocy. OH B03pa-
maJI IIpOTHB flmOTe3bI ceBepHoro HJIH
cH6HpCKoro IIpOHCXom,l:\eHHa ClGIiPCKO-
ro HCKYCCTBa, CqHTaa 3BepHHbIll CTHJIb
ceBepHbIX HapO,l:\OB H CH6HPH 3aBHCH-
MbIM OT CKHtPCKoro. B. H. rpaKOB IIpep;-
IIOJIaraJI, qTO qeHTp iPOPMHpoBaHHa
CKHiPcKoro 3BCpHHoro CTHJIa Mor Haxo-
,l:\HTbca Ha Ry6aHH, OTKY,D;a OH IIpOmeJI
B MpaH, a TaKme B CTeilb H JIeCOCTeilb
CeBepHoro IIpHqepHOMOpba ".
IIO,l:\06HO POCTOBD;eBY, B. H. rpaKOB
CqHTaJI CKHtPCKoe HCKYCCTBO IIpeHMY-
r.qeCTB.eHHO llCKYCCTBOM apHCTOKpaTH-
qeCKoH BepXYUIKIT. COBepmeHHO 060c-
HOBaHIlO B03pamaa IIpOTHB aToro IIOJIO-
memIa, C. 11. Pyt\eHKO IIHCaJI: «CKHtP-
CRoe UCKYCCTBO 6bIJIO IIpHHap;JIemHO-
CTblO He TOJIbKO BepxHero CJIoa 06m;e-
CTBa, lie TOJIbKO IIpHP;BOpHbIM 0tPH-
!.\lla.lbHbIM llCKYCCTBOM MHOrOqHCJIeH-
ITbIX CTaBOK IIJIeMeHHbIX Bomp;eH - aTO
HCKYCCTBO 6bIJIO 06m;eHapop;HbIM H
06m;e,l:\ocTynHbIM. B arOM 6bIJIa ero CH-
JIa, aTu ! 06'baCHaeTca ero ep;HHCTBO
Ha orpOMlIOH TeppHTopHH OT RaBKa3a
Hil lOre ;\0 .'TeCHOrr nOJIOCbI lIa ceBepe
OT KapnaT Ha 3anap;e p;o AJITaa H
BOCToKe» ".
06m;en:meCTHO, KaKoe 60JIbiliOe 3Ha-
qellue ,'1..H CKUiPCKOH np06JIeMbI cbIrpa-
JIO OTKpbITue B 1947 r. CaKKbI3cKoro
K..ap;a II..II Kla,'1a 3HBHe B BOCTO'IHOM
KYP,'1IfCTa He, KOTOpbIH Tenepb C no.'1-
BhU! OC"OBallUe ! 1I1OmHO Ha3BaTb KOllIn-
JIeK;O 1 ReIIleii IT3 paHHeCKuiPcROH
I POO!!!lll/'[ IWIIl.\a VII, Py6ema VII-
V[ RIL : O H. J. 56 OTI\phITlle aTO
nlloBb Bo:mY,l:\IWO rJIy60Kllll IIHTepec K
pa!! !!eCl-dIlfICKOMY 3BepllHoMy CTII.'11O
nOC"O.lb"Y B COCTaBe Haxop;OK OKa3a
;'!IICb npou:me::\eHUH aToro CTll.JJH. KO-
TopMe !!epBolla'Ja.lbHO 6bl.'1U OTHece-
Hbl " nepROH nO..OBUHe VII B. ,'10 H. iI.
ITapa...le..bHO C 31HM BailtHeHillee
:JHaqellllP IB[e.l0 OTKpbITHe pH,l:\a apxau-
'Jec"l1\ norpe5eHITii: C npep;MeTaMll
,l:\peBHecaKCKoro HCKYCCTBa B Ka3ax-
CTaile II TYBe. MbI HMeeM B BHAY
IIaMaTHHKH TaCMOJIHHCKOll KYJIbTypbI
QeHTpa:rbHoro Ra3aXCTaHa, OTKpbITOH
M. R. Rap;bIp6aeBbIM 57, qllJIllKTUHCKUH
Kypr H 58, .rIpeBHeHmylO rpynny norpe-
6eH MOrnJIbHHKOB YHrapaK IT Tarnc-
KeH 80 ' paHHecaKCKHe naMHTHITKIT Ty-
BbI , 3aMe'IaTeJIbHbIe OTKpbITllH B KYP-
raHe ApmaH", HOBbIe HCCJIe,l:\OBaIHIlI
B BOCTOqHOM Ra3aXCTaHe 82
3 .
_ TH tPaKTbI H OTKpbITlla HaXO,l:\HTCrr
celI'J c B D;eHTpe BHllMaHHH llCCJIe,'10Ba-
TeJIeH CKHtPCKOro llCKYCCTBa, Bbl3bIBaH
MilOrOqHCJIeHHbIe p;llCKYCCllU. O,l:\Hll 1
H3 nepBbIX B HailieH CTpaHe Ha OTKpbI-
THe rp06HuqbI 3IIBue OTK.1UKHYJICH
B. B. II OTPOBCKllii: 63. Ol.\e.HUB 311aqe-
Hlle aTOll HaXO,l:\KII, OH c,l:\eJIa.JJ BbIBO ,
'ITO CKHtPCKue aJIeMeHTbl B 3UBlle _ pp_
3YJIbTaT npOHHKHOBeHHa C"HiPCKO O
BJIHHHHa, CBa3aHHoro C npe6bIBaHlle !
CKHtPO B IIpUYPMUHCKOM parrOHe IIa
IOmHOR rpaHHqe CTpaHbI MaHa. ITo Bpe-
Mrom H XY,l:\OmecTBeIlHOMY CTU.'[IO CKIItP-
CKaa rpyniia H306pameHllH 113 3UBile
OqeHb 6JIH3Ka KeJIepMeCCKUM II !e..bry-
HOBCKHM. ITorpe6eHue H3 3HBife ucc..e-
p;OBaTeJIb OTHOCUT K "OHl.\Y VII II:III 'la-
me Py6emy VII - VI BB. ,'10 II. J. '
M3BecTllblH BOCToKOBe,l:\. O,'1HII 1f3 Be-
P;yr.qHX llCCJIep;OBaTe.'1eH CaKKbl3cKoro
KJIap;a, P. rllpiliMaIl, I1epBoHa'JaJIbHO
p;a TllpOBaJI ary rp06IHIl.\Y C paBnlITeJIb-
HO paHHHM BpeMeHeM 6'. HO B IIoc:[e;:\ylO-
m;HX pa60Tax OH npllHa.'1 l\aTV. npe;:\.10-
m 62 eHHYIO P. BapHeToM. R . npeJJ:e..ax
5-600 rr. 65
P. rHpiliMaH rOBopHT 00 !/:J;:\e.lUHX
113 3HBlle Kal{ 0 IIOBO ! Bap!!allTe I1CKYC'-
CTBa, CJIOmllBilleMCH R cenepo-:Jana,l:\Hoii:
qaCTu rUpaHCKoro IIaropbH !!:J aCCII-
po-ypa.\jttCKUX If C"HtPCKIIX nCTOlJHllKOB
o.H BllAuT B HUX CIIM6uo:j BOCTo'JHoro
II CKlliPCKOro UCKYCCTRa C rrpe05.1a;:\a-
HHeM ypapTcKoro Haqa:[a H rrepepa60T-
Ke CKlltPCKIIX !OTIIBOR. OnlPlJilH 3Ha-
qeHHe pa60T B. B. IT!!OTpOBC"oro,
20
P. fHpiliMaH UHmeT, 'ITO MOI'HJIa 3HBHe
JIyqIIle Bcero 1I0p;TBe6 P;l1tJIa BblBO)J;bI CO-
BeTCKHX apxeOJIOrOB .
K aHaJIOrH'IHblM BbIBOP;8.M 110 1I0BOp;y
xyp;omeCTBeHHblX IIpOH3Bep;eHHH H3 3a-
BRe IIPHXOP;HT C. C. qepHHKoB, YTBepm-
p;aIOID;Hii: Ha OCHOBaHHH Haxop;OK B qH-
RRKTHHCKOM KypraHe, 'ITO «KOqeBHHKH
1I0aBHJIHCb B IIepep;Heii: A3HH C p;OCTa-
TOqHO BbIpa60TaHHbIM xyp;om6CTBeH-
HbiM BKYCOM H Tpap;HD;HHMH, K KOTOpbl'd:
B 60JIbIIleii: HJIH MeHbIIleii: CTelleHH
IIpHXOP;HJIOCb IIpHCIIOCa6JIHBaTbCH ac-
CHpHHCKHM, ypapTcKHM, MaHHeii:cKHM,
MUP;HHCKHM, a 3aTelll H rpe'IeCKHM Mac-
'TepaM 67.
It <1>. CMHpHOB OTMe'IaeT, qTO Ha-
xop;Ka B 3HBHe BbIrJIap;HT opHrHHaJIbHO
11 qymp;o Ha 061D;eM iPoHe HCKyccTBa aB-
'TOXTOHHbIX Hapop;OB BJIHmHero BOCTO-
Ka B VII-VI BB. p;o H. a. H He ,'10Ka3b1-
BaeT, qTO CKHiPCKHH 3BepRHbIii: CTHJIb
CJIOmHJICa Ha BJIHmHeM BOCTOKe 88.
Op;HaKO OTKpbITHe rp06HHD;bI B 311-
BHe Bbl3BaJIO H p;pyrylO KOHD;eIID;ulO,
corJIac.1ro KOTOpoii: cKHiPcKoe HCKYCCTBO
D;eJIHKOM ciPopMHpOBaJIOCb B IIepep;Herr
A3HH Ha p;peBHeBOCTO'IHOH OCHOBe H B
rOTOBOM BHp;e 6bIJIO IIpHHeceHo B IIPH-
qepHOMOpbe H3 CeBepo-3anap;Horo Mpa-
Ha. 3TO MHeHHe 6bIJIO BbICKa3aHO pap;o,!
3apy6emHblx yqeHbIx - A. fop;apo !,
II. AMaHp;pH, M. IIOTpaD;eM 89. B co-
BeTCKOH HayRe ary TOqKY 3peHllH nOIJ;-
p;epmHBaJI H pa3BHBaJI M. 11. ApTaMa-
HOB 70. ORa me JIemtlIT B OCHOBe llCC.'W-
p;OBaHllH H. JI. qJIeHOBOH 71.
B CBOHX BblBop;ax M. M. ApTaMOHOB
HCXOP;HT H3 CJIep;yrom;HX OCHOBHbIX 110-
JIOmeHHH: rp06HHD;a B 311Bue cop;epmllT
MBTepHamd 3a pomp;alOmerOCH CKUtPCKO-
ro 3BepHHoro CTllJIa II OT.HOCUTCH [,
KOHD;y VII B. P;O H. 3. 3TII xyp;omecTBerr,
Hble rrpOH3Bep;eHlIa aBJIalOTCH rra\!HT-
HllKOM p;peBHero llpaHCKoro IICKYCCTBa.
B03HHKIIIero Ha oCHOBe p;peBHeMeco-
1I0TaMCKoro xyp;omecTBeHHoro HBC,'1P-
p;llH. OCBoeHHoro Mup;aHaMII H 1I0p;KJIIO-
qHBilillMllca K HHM cKHiPaMH B VII B.
P;O H. 3. J(peBHeHiliHe H3p;eJIHa CKH<pCKO-
ro II caKO-CH6HpCKoro 3BepHHoro CTH-
JIa OTHocaTca K 60JIee 1I03p;HeMY Bpe-
lIWHH H Bep;yr CBoe IIpOHcxomp;eHHe OT
,l:\peBHero HpaHCKoro HCKyccTBa, IIpU-
'JeM B CeBepHoe IIpH'IepHOMOpbe 3TO
ITCKYCCTBO IIpHBHeceHO elD;e B OTaro-
r.qeHHOM MeCOIIOTaMcKo-ypapTcKHMH
ClOmeTaMH BHp;e, Torp;a KaK B CH6Hpb H
Cpep;HIOIO A3HIO OHO IIpOHHKJIO OC06bIM
nYTeM, Hellocpep;CTBeJlHO OT MHp;aH «B
CBOOO,l:\HOM OT c06CTBeHHO CKHiPCKHX
rrpUBHeceHHH BHp;e» 72. KaK cKHiPcKaa
KYJIbTypa, TaK H HCKYCCTBO, IIpHHeceH-
lIMe cKHiPaMH B IIpH'IepHOMOpbe H3
IIepe,l:\HeH A3HH, 1I0JIyqHJIH, 110 MHeHlllO
M. M. ApTaMOHOBa, paCllpOCTpaHemw
He paHee BTOpOH qeTBepTH VI B. p;o H. 3.
l\ qHCJIY 06pa30B, 3aHMCTBOBaH-
HMX H3 p;peBHeBOCTO'IHOrO HCKYCCTBa,
M. 11. ApTaMOHOB OTHOCHT Bce paH-
HecKlliPcKHe MOTHBbI, 3a HCKJIlOqeHHelll
H:J06pameHHH JIOca, KOTopbIe BOCllpn-
HliMBeT KaK MeCTHblH 06pa3, 1I0aBHB-
II1J1HCH B 1I0pap;Ke IIpHCIIOC06JIeHHH K
MeCTHOH cpep;e. «ClOmeTOB MeCTHoro
rrpOllcxomp;eHHa,- IIHilleT OH,- TaKHX,
EaK CBepHYBIIIHHca B KOJIbD;O 3Bepb,
..OCI" 6apaH, 6apaHO-IITllD;a,- B CKHtP-
C"OM UCKYCCTBe 6b1JIO HeMHoro, p;a II
olIn B KOHeqHOM CqeTe B OCHOBe CBoeH
ORB3b1BaIOTCa Bocxop;amHMH K p;peBHe-
BOCTOqHblM 06pa3qaM» 73.
ITo MHeHHIO M. M. ApTaMOHOB3.,
CYUU!OCTb CKHiPcKoro H caKO-CH6HP-
choro llCKyccTBa 3aKJIIO'IaeTCa B CTII-
."T!ICTUqeCKOH lIepepa60TKe 300MOPtP HblX
OOPB:JD;OB p;peBHeBOCTOqHOro llCKYCCTB3.
Ha 60JIee IIpHMIITllBHOH TeXHHqeCKoii:
OC /lORe 11 B p;pyroM MaTepllaJIe. OTCIO-
:ta :JaKOHOMepHblM aBJIaeTCa ero 3a-
I>:llO'leHJ1e. qTO (CB 113BeCTIIOH Mepe 6bIJIll
"paHbl B. B. <1>apMaKoBCKllH C erO
T('(lpnen HOHHHCKoro rrpoucxomp;elIlIfI
r /;J!(j"JCKoro UCKYCCTBa II M. 11. POCTOB-
rrPR C I1paHoM, KaK llCTO'IHllKOM ero
(jln[nr U ClOmeTOB)) H.
21
R 6mI3RHM BhIBO,D;aM npHXO,D;HT
H. JI. qJIeHOBa, KOTOpaa TaKme C'IH-
TaeT, 'ITO CKH«pCKOe H cH6HpCKOe HC-
KYCCTBO CBH3aHbI C ApeBHeBOCTO'IHhIM
HCKYCCTBOM CeBepHOM MeCOIiOTaMHH H
I1paHa, B 'IaCTHOCTH, C HCKyCCTBOM
JIYPHCTaHa H RepKYKa, 'IeM H o6'bac-
HHIOTCa HX 06r:qIIe 'IepTbI B 3BepHHOM
CTHJIe. AJIa CH6HpH 3Ta CBa3b He
Henocpep;CTBeHHaa, a IIepep;aHHaa 'Iepe3
IIO'ITH HeH3BeCTHoe HaM HCKYCCTBO
A«praHHCTaHa H MOHrOJIHH. .
CKH«pCKoe HCKYCCTBO OHa TaKme B03-
BOAHT K 3HBHe H C'IHTaeT CJIOmHBIDHM-
ca Ha OCHOBe 3THX me p;peBHeBOCTO'IHbIX
rpYlIn, npH'IeM Memp;y HCKyCCTBOM Rep-
KYKa, JIYPHCTaHa, C OP;HOH CTOpOHbI,
H 3HBHe - C APyroll, TaKme P;OJIHWH
6bIJI CYIIJ;eCTBOBan IIO KpaHHeH Mepe
eIIJ;e OP;HH npOMemYTO'IHbIll:, nOKa HeH3-
BecTHbIH naIl. BpeMa 3HBHe olipeAe-
JIaeTCa H. JI. qJIeHOBOii IIO cTapoii Aa-
Te rHplllMaHa, B IIpep;eJIax nepBOM
IIOJIOBHHbI VII B. AO H. 3. 15.
TaKHM 06pa30M, B np06JIeMaTHKe
CKH«pCKoro HCKyccTBa CeH'IaC 'IeTKO
OlIpep;eJIHJIHCb ABa HalipaBJIeHHa. IIep-
Boe H3 HHX MomHO Ha3BaTb caKO-CKH«p-
CKHM, eBpa3HllCKHM, a BTopoe - IIepeA-
Hea3HaTcKHM.
CJIeAyeT OTMeTHTb, 'ITO BHelllHe
CTpOllHaH KOHn;enn;Ha M. I1. ApTaMOHO-
Ba - CTOpOHHHKa BToporo HalipaBJIe-
HHa - cTpaAaeT MHOrHMH CYIIJ;eCTBeH-
llbIMH HeAoCTaTKaMH H IIpOTHBOpe'IHH-
MH.
IIpemAe Bcero 06parn;aeT BHHMaHHe,
'!TO M. I1. ApTaMOHOB IIpHp;aBaJI 60JIb-
moe 3HaqCHIre MHAHHCKOMY HCKYCCTBY
B IIpOHcxomAeHHH CKH«pCKOI'O H oc06eH-
HO caKO-CH6HpCKoro HCKYCCTBa. B TO me
DpeMa H no cell: AeHb MIIAIIMCKoe
HCKYCCTBO, oc06eHHO B IIpOHB.'ICllllflX
3BepHHoro CTHJIH, COCTaBJIHeT apxco.'lO-
rHqeCKYIO 3ara,i:\KY. HenOHaTHO, nOqeMv
M. I1. ApTaMOHOB C'IHTaeT, 'ITO M 1I,i:\ IIi.
CKoe HCKYCCTBO, C.'lOmHBllleeCH Ha ,i:\peB-
HeBOCTOqHOii OCHOBe, B OTmlqne OT
Clm«pCKoro, OKa3aJIOCb CBo60AHbIM OT
Meco oTaMcKo-ypapTCKoro BJIHHHHa,
TeM OOJIec, 'ITO lIMCHHO Ha ero OCHOBe,
KaK IIOAqepKHBaeT aBTOp, CJIOmHJIOCb
HCKYCCTBO axeMeHII,i:\CKOro I1paHa -
IIpHMOro HaCJICAHHKa ApeBHeBOCTOq-
HOM TpaAHn;HII.
OCTaeTCH HeHCHbIM, 'ITO CJIep;yeT no-
HIlMaTb IIOA cpeAHea3HaTCKHM H CH6Hp-
CKHM 3BepllHbIM CTH.'reM «6e3 c06CTBeH-
HO CKII«pCKIIX IIpHBHeceHHH . CJIep;yeT
HMeTb B BH,!:\Y, qTO KorAa pe'Ib HAeT 0
CKH«pCKml HCKYCCTBe, TO npemAe Bce-
ro IIpllHHMaIOTCH BO BHHMaHHe He H306-
pameHIIH Tex HJIH HHbIX mHBOTHbIX,
KaK TaKOBbIX, HO B IIepBYIO Oqepep;b
(lC06bIll, npIICYIIJ;Hll TOJIbKO AaHHOll:
rpYIIIIe IICI,YCCTBa CTHJIb, COOTBeTCTBY-
IOIIJ;Hll MHpOOIIJ;YIIJ;eHHIO, MHpOBOCIIpHJI-
THIO OIIpeAeJIeHHbIX HapOAOB. IIOA06Ho-
ro po;:ra xYAomecTBeHHoe MbIllIJIeHHe
aBJIHeTCH pe3YJIbTaTOM MHoroBeKoBoro
pa3BIITIIH II He MomeT B03HHKHYTb II
paClipOCTpaHHTbCH Y pa3JIH'IHbIX HU-
pOAOB, Ha orpOMHOll: TeppHTopHH 3a
KaKHC-HII6Y,i:\h 0AHO - ABa AeCHTHJIC-
THH. MHorne Hel 06pa30B CRH«pCKoro H
caKo-cn6l1pCKOfO 3BepHHoro CTHJIH BO-
06IIJ;C He IIMCIOT IIpOTOTHnOB B ApeB-
neBOCTOqHOM IlCKYCCTBe HJIH cOAepmaT
caMbIe ;:ra.IClmc, CTH.1:!HCTlI'JeCKH 060c06-
JIeHHbIC' ITa paJIJICJIII.
Ho r.laBHOC, KaK 3TO 'IaCTO 6bIBae'r
B apxeo.'lOrHII, elaKJIIO'IaeTCa B 0IlIH60l{-
RbIX XpOHo.'lOrnqeCIUIX COOTHOllIeHHHX.
CaKKbI3CKOC ITOrpe6eHHe, KOTOPOMY
n pn,l\a CTC R ITpIlHn;HIIllaJIbHO-HCXOAHoe
3HaqeTJITe. !JT!IfOAb He HBJIaeTCH ApeB-
RCllrnml B COCTaBe CKH«po-caKCKorr
rpYIIllhl IIpOJl3IJei CIIHM HCKYCCTBa. Bpe-
MR cro aKTnqeCKH COBlIaAaeT CO
BpeM{mC' 1 }-\r.1elnleca. IIpeA.'lOmeRHaH
J\I. :r;I'\[aKCIDtOROM AaTa noro naMHT-
BHKa lie !IO:I.'\I1ee nepBOll qeTBepTlI
VI B. :10 TJ. :1. OCTaBJIHeT B03MOmIIOCTh
AJIH 60.le(> l'ilRHcn ero p;aTHpOBKIl 76.
Ca t 'If. IT. ApTaMoHoB OTMCqaeT,
'{TO a fla:rOllllt, KOTopbIe IIpIlBOAIlT
22
110M Ra3aXCTaHe, B6JIH3H 'Y CTb- RaMe-
IIoropCKa. 84 I{ KOHn;y VII B. AO H. 3.
OTHOCHTca ma60TIIHCKHe IIJIaCTHHbI II
IIcamm HaHAeHHble B !WMIIJIeKCe C
, 85
ABYXlIeTeJIb'IaTbIMH YAHJIaMII .
CpeAH HaxOAoK B CaMTaBpCKOM MO-
rII.'IbHHKe B norpe6eHIIH 106 OKa3aJIIICb
06JIOMKH I'OJIOBKH rpH«p0-6apaHa Ii
KOHen; IICaJIHa C KOHCKHM KonbITn;eM
II opHaMeHTOM H3 BbIeM'IaTbIX TpeyrOJIb'
HHKOB KaK Ha nCaJIHH H3 iKa60THHa 88
(pHC. '4, 7, 8). Ro BTOpOll IIOJIOBIIHe
VII B. P;O H. 3. IIplIHaAJIemHT norpe6e-
M. I1. MaKcHMoBa, OTIIOCHTCH He TO.1:Ib-
}i:0 K Ha'IaJIY VI, HO II K, KOHn;y VII B.
AO H. 3. 77 . B IIOJIb3Y HeKOToporo YApeB-
IieHHH p;aTbI ReJIepMeCa B IIpeAeJIax
KOIln;a VII, py6ema VII - VI BB. AO
II. 3. BbICKa3aJIHCb, He3aBIICHMO APyr
oT P;Pyra, aBTopHTeTHelllllHe KaBKa30-
BeALl: A. A. I1ecceH, E. I1. I\PYIIHOB,
E. E. IIHOTpoBeKHll 78.
Cpe,D;H HaxoAoK H3 3HBIle HMeIOTC
BeIIJ;H paHHeCKH«pCKIIX 06pa3n;OB. 8TO
IIpemAe Bcero 6pOH30BbIC ,i:\BYXJIO-
IIaCTHbIe H TpeXJIOnaCTHbIC HaROHeq-
RHKH CTpeJI Ke.'lepMeCCIUIX THIIOB
(pHC. 3, 3) 79, IIpHiKKa-IIpOHH3b II3 Ka-
6aHbero KJIbIKa (pHC. 3, 2), IIOJIOBHHa
6poH30Boro IICamlH C TpeMH neTJIHMH
H OPJIHHOll: rOJIOBKOll (pHC. 3, 1) 80. 113
3TOll me MeCTHOCTII, XOTH H He B ROM IT-
.'lCKCe IIOrpC6eHlIH, npOlICXOAIIT IIa pa
COBepllIeHHO CKlI«pCKHX KOCTHIILlX nca-
mlii C rOJIOBKOll rpu«p0-6apaHa II KOIIbIT-
n;eM 8'. ::ho TaKme KpallHe CliMIITOMa-
TlI'IHO (pHC. 3, 4). Bce no rOBopHT B
IIOJIb3Y HeCOMHeHHOll XpOHOJIOrHqeCKOll
6JIH30CTH rp06HHn;Ll B 3HBIle II ReJIep-
Meca.
R 3TOll me IIope OTHOCIlTCfl 60.'lb-
llIaH 'IaCTb pe3HbIX Il3,i:\eJmii 1I3 ROCTH
1I3 paCKOIiOK RapMUp-BJIypa, BbIIIOJI-
HeHHbIX B CKH«pCKOM 3BeplIHOM CTIIJIe.
FHP; IIpep;MeTOB B 3BepHHOM CTHJIe H3
IIpHqepHOMOpbH HeCOMHeHHO BOCXOAlIT
K AOKeJIepMeCCKOMY H IIpeAllICCTBOBaB-
llIeMY BpeMeHH 3HBIlC IIepiiOilY. TO eCTb
K VII B. AO H. 3.
C 6pOH30BbBIH ; OCKH(!)C!\IHIII !ICa.lnH-
Mil CBH3aHa HaXO,i:\Ka MaxorncBClmx na-
ReplllHll: C «pHrypOII O.'1CRH !Ia ilia POBlIA-
I!O [ 6y6eHn;e (pIIC. 4, 4) 82. Ih !Orn.'1b-
HHKa Y XYTopa RyoaHcKoro uponcxo-
AHT 6pOH30BbJe IICa.IIIII C Tp 'G'[aTbI nr
BTy.'1KaMH H KOHUa !II. CItM\ICTpnq-
HO YKpallIeHHbBIII ro.loBRa 1J1 XUII{HbIX
nTUn; (pnc. 4, 6). TIIIT ITca.llIii - -,\OC-
I'\Il«pCKHll83. I1HTepeCTJO. 'IT.. II0:10GHbdi
iRe nCaJIHll 6bI.l Han:;:rcn TJ;1 .1i'\TO [ KOH-
u,e CRH«po-caKCKoro lTlpa - B BOCTOq-
Puc. 3. IIpe8.MeTbI. c llif;c oeo Tuna:
1-3 - npe)\MeThl CKu<l>cKoro Tuna us rp06BuIlhl
311Blle (no P. fUpllIMaBY); 4 - KOCTHBOit ncaJlull
113 ceJleBIIH 3uBKe (no E. nopalIa)
\ .....---/ I
", :
(OJ
" :
I I
I I
I I
I I
I I
I I
\ I
\--'
23
o
o
o
4
.
,.
lUle B KypraHe Ha TeMHp-rOpe 87 C pe3-
HLIMH H3 KOCTH npe,D;MeTaMH B BH,D;e
CBepHYBmeRCIl QJ1IrypKH KOmaQberO
XH HHKa H rOJIOBKH rpmpO-6apaHa.
HaH60JIee ,D;peBHIOIO HaXO,D;KY B IIpH-
qepHOMOpbe COCTaBJIlleT KOHHOI'OJIOBLIR
CKHneTp H3 MOrnJIbHHKa IIOA KIICJIOBO.n;-
CKOM, OTHOCIlIqRRCIl K VIII B. .n;o H. 3.
(pilC. 4, 2) 88.
PUC. 4. Apxau'tec"ue npeiJMeTIrl c"uif;c"020
31lepUn020 CTUA& C Cellepn020 /(all"a3a U Ba-
"all"a3bR:
1-3 - D3 I10rpe6eBBH 14 r. RBCJIOBOIiCKa; 4- -
113 KypraBa y CTaBBI\I>l MaxomeBcKoi! BB Ky6a-
HB; 6 - D3 I10rpe6eBBH 39 y xy-r. Ky6aBcKOro;
1, 8 - B3 I10rpe6eBBH 106 CaMTBBpcKoro MOrDJIb-
HHHa
E e 60JIee OTqeTJIIIBO ,D;peBHeifmIIU:
xy.n;OmeCTBeHHLIif nJIaCT BLIcTynaeT B
CTaBIII'IIX ilI3BeCTHldMil CpaBHlITeJIbHO
He.n;aBHO naMIlTHilKaX paHHeCaKCKOii
rpynIILI Ka3aXCTaHa H TYBLI. B IIX qHC-
Jle H3BeCTHLIif 30JIOTOif KypraH B .n;OJIH-
He qHJIHKTLI, co.n;epmaJ::ql!ii npOII3Be-
.n;eHilll paHHeCKH«pCKoro HCKyccTBa:
OJIeHb, CBepHYBmallCIl naHTepa, Ka6aH.
XH Hall llTIIn;a. BpeMIl 3Toro 3axopOHe-
HHII - He paHee KOHn;a VII B. .11:0
H. 3.- onpe.n;eJIlleTCIl HaXO,D;KOR .n;OKe-
JIepMeCCRnX, a .n;JIIl Ka3aXCTaHa - .n;o-
TaCMOJIIIHCKIIX HaKOHeqHIIKOB CTpeJI C
pOM6IIqeCKOif rOJIOBKOR. qIIJIHKTIIHCKHe
OJIeHil II CBepHYBmHeCIl XII HIIKII CTap-
me OJIeHeR II naHTep 3HBHe. Ho .n;amo
eCJIII .n;OnyCTIITb HX XpOHOJIOrnqeCI\YIO
I
I ,
I
a
2
4
6
1/' ::
I I
I
.' "
ffi] '
, ,
I
W
24
7
8
flll «S
6JIII30 C 'Fb, TO HeB03MomHO npe.n;CTaBHTb,
qTO II3 opIIeHTaJIII30BaHHbIX 06pa30B
3HBHe Mor B03HHKHyrb II.n;eaJIbHO
«CKII«pCKIIR» OJIeHb qHJIIIKTLI, He HMeIO-
w;IIn HHK3KIIX CJIe.n;OB .n;peBHeBOCTOqHO-
TO BJIHHHllH.
CTOJIb me cBoe06pa3HbIM II CTIIJIHCTII-
'1emill He3aBIICilMLIM IlBJIlleTCIl H306pa-
»\eHile «pIIrypOK Ka6aHa, nOJInyIO aHa-
.-rorilIO KOTOpLIM npe,D;CTaBJIIlIOT «pHryp-
PUC. 5. llpeiJMeTIrl paHHec"uif;c,!020 8IlepUHO-
20 CTUA& U3 Cu6upu U CpeiJneu A8UU:
1. 2 - B3 KypraBa 2 J c. Bepe30BKa; 3 - 6POB-
30Bi>li! KOTen B3 <I>epram.r; 4-1 - B3 KypraHa 55
v TarHcKena; 8 - SOJlOT3H HaKJla,ru(a Ha nepe-
HBBYIO 6JIHmKY B3 ypo'lBma Mai!3"Bp; 9, 10-
D3 KypraHa y lIep. IOillITep
KH Ra6aHa B IIaMIlTHilKaX Maif3MIIpCKO-
ro 3Tana AJITall 89.
K VII B. .n;0 H. 3. OTHOCIlTCIl 30JIOTLIe
HaKJIa.n;KII Ha .n;epeBIlHHbIe 6JIIlXII B BR-
.n;e CI3 p lJII): Il_ IIaHTep» II3 YROqII:,
3MIIp B BOCTOqHOM Ra3aXCTa-
He (pHC. 5, 8) 90. K aHaJIOTIIqHOMY (.n;o-
TaCMOJIHHCKOMY) BpeMeHil IIpIIHa.n;JIe"
maT H306pameRHIl «f>m'yp II IIpiiTOM KO-
maqbHX XII HIIKOB B Kypr3Hax 27 H
33 rpynIIbI YifrapaK II pa3BepHYTLIe
rOJIOBKH KOHeif Ha 6pOH30BLIX IIO;{-
npymHbIx npllmKax H3 KypraHa 5.5
rpyunLI TerHcKeHa (pilC. 5, 4, 5) 91.
B RYpraHe 2 MOrnJIbHlIKa Bepe30BKa
Ha 06II HaR.n;eH pOI'OBOR HaKOHeqHIIR
C rOJIOBKOif KOHli. TaM me Haif.n;eH Hom
c rpH60BII.n;HbIM HaBepmIIeM, no.n;06-
.'t
\
lj .
/;
t
3
"'i:i
e
, .', ",'
. ! I
4
flJb fijJ
I}/ 5
6 7
fffiJ
s;5J
.. . \\V;, , ," \W
9
10
25
HhlM HaBepllIlUlM KIfHmaJIOB VIII-
VII BB. AO H. 3. (pIfC. 5, 1,2) 92.
B YKpallIeHIIIf KOHCKOrr Y3AhI 3TOrO
BpeMeHIf, OC06enHO Ha nOAnpymHhlx
npllmKaX, 6pOH30BLle BhlcTynhl 06h1qHO
YKpallIeHhI CTllJIU30BaHHIJMIf B BUAe
CepAeqKa 11306pameHIfIlMIf KOHCKOrO
KOnhlTa. HIf q,OpMa II TIfn npeAMeTOB,
HIf CTIfJII, He IIMeIOT HIfqerO 06 ero C
nepeAHea3IfaTCKilMIf If306pameHIfIlMIf.
Ib06pamcHne IIpOTOMLI KOllIaqI,erO
XIf HIfKa Ha 6pOH30BOM Home If3 AepeB-
HIf IOnIfTep B Ka3aXCTaHe conpOBom-
aJIOCI, HaXO,iJ;norr AJIIfHHOpOM6IfqeCKIfX
CTpeJI He II03,iJ;Hee nepBorr nOJIOBIfHLI
VII B. AO H. 3. (pIfC. 5, 9, 10) 93. YnOMII-
HeM TaKme KOTeJI H3 l1>epraHhI C KOJII,-
n;eBIfAHIJMIf pyqKaMIf, YKpallIeHHhlMH
q,IfrYPKaMIl CTORW;IfX K03JIOB. 8TOT KO-
TeJI B. A. .JIllTBIfHcKHrr AaTIfpyeT
VIII B. ,iJ;0 H. 3. (pIfC. 5,2)94.
B 1971 r. 'f. II. rpll3HOBLlM If
M. X. MaHHaii-OoJI 6h1JIIf HaqaTIJ pac-
KOIIKIf 3aMe'laTeJII,HOrr paHHecaKcKoH
rp06HIfD;LI - l,ypraRa ApmaH B TYBe.
Cpe,iJ;If HaXO)JOK B HeM oc06eHHO Bam-
RhI ,iJ;JIH narncii TeMhI 6pOH30BLlrr KIfH-
)l\aJI C HaBeprnneM B BIfAe q,IfrypKIf Ka-
6alla, KOCTRrr R rOJIOBKa OCeAJIaHHOrO
KOHli, If3y mTe.1I,IIall no COBepllIeHCTBY
6pOHC10BaR 6.1Rxa B BIfAe cBepHyn-
llIerOCR XIfll\Hllna. PIIA Be err If3 KYP-
raHa ApmaH InlCIOT aHaJIOrIfIf B IIaMIIT-
HIfnax HC IIOC1;mee Haqa.1Ja VII, a OqeHI,
BepORTHo, II VIII B. AO H. 3. K HIfM
OTHOCRT(" R: IT(" a.'1IfIf qepHoropoBcKoro
TITIIa. HaIWf1f"ITIITI,If CTpeJI TIfIIa MaJIon
qIlM6a.lnil. jlyi)qaTLle KaMellHLle HaK-
JraAKII. 8TII Bt'l/[li Tom,iJ;eCTBeHHIJ naxoa;-
Ka f IIC1 «Kil\' \Il'pnITCnIlX» lIorpe6elflIR R
l,ypraHe I3J."''',,aR MorIf.1Ja B IIpIfAHeII-
pOBbE', cI;opee Bccro OTIIOCHII\IfXCII K
VIII - VIT BB. .10 II. 3. 95 .
HCCOMIIellllO. n r.'1y60qarrIlICii MeCT-
HOi! Tpa.ll1!!III! BOCXO.1HT If300pameHIfll
rO.l0BOn "o/[eI' B Cnllq,o-caKcKoM IfC-
"YC"CTBE'. !lno,,!! KOTOplJX MLI BCTpeqa-
e)1 B ni1 I(,II!lbIX HaBepmIfHx me3JIOB
ApeBHellMHorr KYJlI,TYphl If Ha naMell-
HIJX necTax-cKlineTpax C rOJIOBJ;aMil
IWHII 96 . Bce nIl AaHHLle onpoBepraIOT
Te3IfC 0 TOM, '1TO ApeBHerrrrme IIpOII3BC-
AeHIfIl caKO-C1l6l1pCKoro If CKIfq,CKoro
3BepIfHoro CTIf.1JI 1I0llBIfJllICI, B CeBepo-
3anaAHOM I1paHe BMeCTe C Bew;a;.m
CaKKhl3CKoro KJlaAa.
OTKphlTIfIl nOCJIeAHIfX JIeT AalOT B03-
MomHOCTI, AaTIfpOBaTI, IIa;.IRTHlinil
CKIfq,CKoro 3BepIfHoro CTIf.ll1 60.lee palf-
HUM BpeMeHeM. I1MeIO IfeCII IICTO'lHII-
KIf n03BOJIllIOT BLlAeJIIfTI, C.1Ie,iJ;YIOW;IfI
HaIfOOJIee paHHIfe MOTIfBhI canO-CKllq,-
CKoro IfCKYCCTBa, OOID;1Ie ,'{.1JH Bcen
eBpa3IfRCIWR TeppIfTopIfU: 3TO I1300pa-
meHHII OJIeHII, x!!!II;HIfKa KOllIa'lberr 110-
POAhI, rOJIOBKH II KOllhlTa KOHH. }J..ll1
co-6CTBeHHO CKuq,CKoro (lIpn'lepHO-
MopCKoro) IfCKYCCTBa B ;:IpeBHeIlllIlirr
'nepIfoA XapaKTepHLI Tanlle ,ICnIlIJC
MOTIfBhI, J{aK rOJlOBnll oapaHa If rpJl(IJO-
oapaHa. AJlII caKCJ{oro, J{a3axCTano-
CIfOIfpCJ{oro IfCKYCCTBa TIfIIIfqHbl BelIpb
, u
If ropHhlH K03eJI C 3aKHHYTIJMn pora-
MH. Jb IfCKYCCTBa ceBepHon .1ecnorr
30HIJ B CKHq,CKoe IICKYCCTBO B.ll1.1nCb
OOpa3h1 JIOCH, Me,iJ;BeAII II BO:J1lberO
. XU HIfKa.
B COBpeMeHHO;.1 Clmq,OBe;l£'HIIII e,iJ;Ba
JIIf Harr,uyTCII Hcc.1JeAOBaTc.1II, J{OTopLle
OTpIfn;a.1IIf OIJ 3HaqeHIfe ApeBHenOCTOq-
Horo IfCJ{yccTBa B npOD;ecce q,Op lIIpO-
BaRIfIl 3BepIfHoro CTIfJlII Clmq,OB Tlpll-
'1epHOMopI,Il. 3a CqeT ,!Toro B,ll1f1 111111, .
HeCOMHeHHO, c.leAyeT OTHeCTH IIOHB.:W-
HIfe MOTIIBa roplloro 1\03.1a C II07\;J,aTbl-
Mil HoraMIf If 1I0BE'(HIYTOii na:la;J, MOp-
AOR, TpaKTOBJ{y B ::!TOIl iHC no;w pH,iJ;a
ApyrIfx TpaBoH;J;HbIX mnllOTilbIX (.10CII,
IWHII, JIaHIf), MoTIfB rpIfq,OlJa JI .1p TIfX
cIf"dR,peTIfqecJ{Ifx '1y,iJ;ORlUH. rcpa.lb,iJ;II-
'1ec,/« conOCTaBJIeHHLlX JIbBOIJ. TlTIID; C
paCnJIaCTaHHI,BfIf nphl.lbR'III. ();llIaJ{o
BhlBOAIITI, Bce IIC"YCCTBO '3BPpllHoro
CTUJIII caKO-C nllq,Cnoro \111 pa 113
IfCKYCCTBa ApeBHero BOCTOI;;] IIp e .l-
CTaBJIlleTCII Ha,1 'Ipe3"leprrbI\I.
26
OqeBIfAHO B OJIIfmarrrrme rOAhI B
eHTpe BHIf";aHIfIl IfCCJIep';OBaTeJIeR 3TOR
npOOJleMLI OYAeT CTOIITI, YTuOqHeHIfe
xpOHOJIOrIfqeCJ{IfX COOTHOIIIeHIfH naMIIT-
HIfJ{OB npeAcKH!f>CJ{oro H paHHecKIf!f>-
cKoro BpeMeHll IIpIfqepHOMOpI,Il If ca-
J{O-CIfOIfpCJ{oro MIfpa, a TaJ{me npo-
AoJDKeHIfe H3)"1eHIfll JIOKaJIbHhlX rpynn
3BepIfHoro CTIfJIII: CJ{If!f>cKoro, caBpo-
MaTCKOro, aHaHI,HHCKoro, caKcKoro, CH-
6IfpCJ{oro, a TaKme BlJlICHeHIfe oOID;1Ix
1 C. 11. II H. J/. pyaen o. HCKYCCTBO CKIf-
<Po B AJITali. M.. 1969; H. JI. lJ.un08a.
fipoIfcxomAeHife If paHH1I1I IICTOpIfIi nJIe-
)leH TarapCKoH KYJIbTypbl. M.. 1967,
CTp. 110; M. 11. Apra.MOn08. CKIf<P0-CIf-
6IfpcKoe IICKYCCTBO 3BepIfHoro CTIfJIH.
fiCA. M., 1971, CTp. 24.
, f. 11. PoCr08/fe8. 3JIJIIfHCTBO If lIpaHcTBo
'ua lOre POCCifif. fir., 1918; on :J/Ce. CKIf<pIfIi
II Bocnop. J1., 1925; M. Rostoutze!f. lra-
niens and Greeks in South of RUSSIa. Lon-
don, 1922; M. Rostoutzeff. The. Ani al
Style in South Russia and Chma. Pnn-
ceton - New-York. 1929.
3 M. Rostoutzeff. The Animal Style...,
CTp. 21-22.
. TaM me, CTp. 20.
5 M. 11. POCr08/fe8. 3J1JI1IHCTBO If IIpaIICTBO...,
CTp.7.
6 TaM me. CTp. 43-45.
1 M. Rostoutzeff. lraniens and Greeks....
CTp. 193, 197.
s M. 11. PoCr08/fe8. CKIf<pIfIi II Bocnop,
CTp. 307-308.
9 M. Rostoutzeff. The Animal Style...,
CTp. 64.
10 TaM me, CTp. 64.
1 I TaM me, CTp. 65.
" M. H. Pocroe/ve. CWI<p"H II Bocnop,
CTp. 337.
13 .W. Rostoutzeff. The Animal Style...,
CTp. 66-67.
14 Ta)1 ;«P, CTp. 23.
15 G. Borouka. Scythian Art London, 1929.
16 TaM me, CTp. 42.
17 K. <P. C.MUpn08. CaBpO)laTbI. M..:, 1964,
Tp. 216; B. A. l1"bu11c aR. 00pa3 KO-
maqberO XJI HlIl{a B paUHeCJ;II<pcJ{O'ol JlC-
J{yccTBe. CA, 1971, N! 2, CTp. 54.
18 G. Borouka. YKa3. COq., CTp. 33, 37.
19 Ta)1 me, CTp. 68.
20-2\ TaM me, CTp. 66.
" TaM me, CTp. 5.
IfCXOAHIJX OCHOB If MeCTHhlX ocooeHHO-
cTeft; IfCCJleAOBaHue HKoHorpa!f>IfIf pa3-
JlII'IHLlX BapIfaHToB 3BepIfHIJX oopa30B,
BIJHCHeHIfe OCHOBHhlX cTyneHeR pa3BH-
TIIH IfCl;yccTBa BayTpIf oT,a;eJIbHhI
rpYllII, ollpe,iJ;eJlemlC HanpaBJIeHIfH
B3aIfMocBH3eii II J{yJII,TYPHIJX 3aHMCT-
BOBaHIfrr BHellIHIfX If BHYTpeHHIfx npIf-
'1IfH, oOYC.1JOBIfBIIIIfX cBoeoopa3Ife nYTeR
pa3BIfTIfH, a TaJ{me oO Ife 3aKoHoMep-
HOCTIf 3TIfX IIpoD;eccoB B n;eJIOM.
23 E. H. Minns. Scythians and Greeks. Cam-
bridge, 1913, CTp. 26t.
.. E. H. 1'rfinns. The Art of the Northern No-
mades. «Proceedings of the Brit. Ac.*,
XXVIII. London, 1942.
25 B. r. renr11ep U B. 11. I{a.. un. OJIeHif
CCCP. M., 1947, CTp. 66-81; H. JI. lJ .<eno-
ea. CJ{n<pcJ{IIH OJIeHb. MHA, M ti5, 1962.
CTp. 191. .
26 C. B. Kuce..e8. ApeBHlI1I IfCTOpIfIi IOmHOil
Cifonpif. M., 1951, CTp. 249-250; H. JI.
lJ..eltoea. CKIf<pCKIfH OJleHb, CTp. 170.
n If H. aaU112. Pe3IIali CKYJIbnTypa YpaJIa.
«TPYAbI fHM», Bbln. X. M., 1940.
28 TaM mC, CTp. 86.
29 Ta)1 me.
30 M. 11. Apra.\I0n08. YKa3. CO'l., CTp. 27;
H. JI. lJ..e11oea. K Bonpocy 0 nepBIf'lHblX
)IaTepna.1IlX 3BepllHoro CTIfJIIi. fiCA. M.,
1971. np. 213-214.
31 A. Furilciingler. Goldfund von Vettersfel-
de. 93 Bericht Winkelmann Program,
1883; M. Rbert. Siidrussland im Altertum.
Bonn \lnd Leipzig. 1921; K. Schefold. Del'
skythische Tierstill in Siidrussland. ES .
XII. Hplsinki, 1938; B. B. <Pap.Ma 08c"uU.
Apxan'l!'{'(;ni! IIeplioA B POCCIIIf.
MAP :'\1,. Cfii'i.. 1914.
32 if. 1/' flo2pe60ea. K Bonpocy 0 CKIf<PCKO {
3J1epllllO\l eTlIJIe. I{CHHMK, Bbln. XXXI .
M..I%O.
'" G. B. <1)l1p."(/ oec uii. 'YKa3. COq., CTp. 37.:
33 E. II. /"pa "08. ApeBIIOCTif H6JIOHOBCKOif
I;yprall\loii rpynilbI If3 c06paUIfH A. H. -
\1O"Bacolla. Tp. CA P AHHOH, T. I I. .,
1 )28. np. 69-80; B. 3. Pa6unoeu'l. a ;:I
TllpO""!' IIPJ;OTOpbIX CKIf<pCKliX KypraH 6
Cpp.11I1'rlJ flpnAHenpoBbfl. CA, M 1, 193 ,
CTp. 7(1,
" E r; 17110Tpoec uii. BaucKoe apcTBo. M.,
1ft),,: "" )/(e HC!; 'CCTBO YpapTY. J1., 1962.
" II. II TpRJ11oe. fiepBbIH fia3bIpblKcKIfH
;;yprHIl .:1.. 1950; C. H. pyaen o. KYJIbTY-
27
pa HaCeJIeHI!H ropHoro AJiTall B CI\!!<PCKO e
BpeMH. M.- J1., 1953; on :J/Ce. RYJIbTye a
HaCeJIeHI!H l(eHTpaJIbHOrO AJiTaH B CRUIp-
CRoe BpeMH. M.- JI., 1960.
3' C. H. u H. M. PyiJen"o. HCRYCCTBO CRI!-
<pOB AmaH. M., 1949; C. H. PyiJen"o. Hc-
fiYCCTBO AJITaH I! IJepeAHHH A3I!H. M.,
1961.
37 M. II. rpR.3noll. IJaMHTHI!RII MaH3MI!pCRo-
1'0 3Tana 3nOXI! paHHux ROqeBHHROB Ha
AJITae. RCHHMR, Bhlll. XVIII. M., 1947,
CTp.9.
38 P. Rau. Die Graber del' friihen Eisenzeit
im Unteren Wolgagebiet. 'Pokrowsk, 1929;
B. Grakow. Monuments de la culture
scythique entre la Volga et les monts
aural. ESA, III, p. 25. Helsinki, 1928;
On :J/Ce. Deux Tombeau.x de l'epoque sCY-
thique aux environs de la ville d'Oren-
bourg. ESA, IV. Helsinki, 1929; R. rtJ.
CMupnoll. CaBpoMaTbi. M., 1964; M. r.
M ouaolla. IJaMUTHI!KI! npoxopoBCKOH
KYJIbrypbl. CAH, l(1-10. M., 1963.
3. R. rtJ. CMupnoll. CaBpOMaTJ.I, CTp. 216.
'0 TaM llie, CTp. 242.
" C. B. Ruce.A.eIl. l(peBHHH I!CTOpl!H IOlliHoH
Cu6upl!. M., 1951, CTp. 172, 233.
.. C. B. Ruce.A.eII. Y"a3. COq., CTp. 250.
OJ M. H. Ma"cuMolla. Cepe6pHHoe 3epKaJIO H3
KeJIepMeca. CA, XXI, 1954, CTp. 281;
ona :J/Ce. PUTOH U3 KCJIepMeca. CA, XXV,
1956, CTp. 215.
.. H. H. IIoepe60lla. fpl!<pOH B I!CKyccTBe
CeBepHoro IJpJIqepHOMOpbH B anoxy ap-
xaUl\!!. RCHHMK, BJ.In. XXII. M.- JI.,
1948, CTp. 62.
os M. H. BR.3bMUruna. Pal!Hl!e naMHTI!I!KI!
CKI!<PCKOro 3BepHHoro CTI!JIH. CA, 1963,
M 3.
.8 H. JI. TJ.A.enOlla. CKI!<pCKI!H OJIeHb, CTp. 167.
" B. A. H.A.bUnC"aR.. HeKOTopble MOTI!BbI
paHHeCKI!<pcKoro 3Bepl!HorO CTI!JIU. CA,
1965, .N! 1; ona :J/Ce. 06pa3 KOmaqberO
XUll\HI!Ka B paHHeCKI!<pcKOM I!CKYCCTBe.
CA, 1971, .N! 2, CTp. 64.
.. A. H. m"yp"o. 06 1!306pallieHI!H cBepHYB-
II1erOCH B KOJIb O XUII\HHKa B HCKYCCTBe
:IeCOCTenHoH CKI!<pHII. CA, 1969, .N! 1,
CTp. 31; C. C. COpO"UH. CBepHYBml!RCH
3Bepb 1!3 3uBue. Cf3, Bbln. XXXIV. J1.,
1972.
I. 9. B. n"ollen"o. KJIJ.IKU C 300MOp<p H J.IMII
H306pallieHI!HMu. CA, 1969, .N! 4, CTp. 200.
'0 A. II. ManlfeIlU'l. a nJIaCTI!He H3 KypraHa
KaparoAeyamx. ACf3, JI6! 6. J1., 1964;
ona :J/Ce. BpoH30Bble IIJiaCTHHbI 1!3 BTOpO-
1'0 MacTIOrJIHcKoro KypraHa. ACf3,
BJ.In. 11. JI., 1969; CTp. 104-113; A. H. Me-
.t "'''0 Ila. CM. CTaTbIO B HaCTOHlI\eM c60p-
HURe.
51 B. r. IIerpen"o. IJpaB06epellihe CpeAHero
IJpuAHenpoBbH B V-III BB. AO H. 3. CAH,
l(1-4. M., 1967, CTp. 57.
5. B. A. mpaM"o. K Bonpocy 0 3HaqeHI!H
KYJIbTYPHO-X03HiicTBeHHJ.IX oc06eHHOCTeii
CTenHOH U JIeCOCTenHOH Cfill<pUH. IJCA.
CTp. 100.
53 6. B. TJ epnen"o. Cl<iif>CbKi KypraHu V CT.
AO H. e. n06JIU3Y 1. iKAaHOBa. ApxeoJIoriH.
T. XXIII. KUlB, 1970, CTp. 180; O. r. ma-
nOUJ.nu"olla. IJorpe6eHue CKu<pcRoro BOH-
Ha Ha p. HHrYJI. CA, 1970, .N! 3, CTp. 212.
5' B. H. rpa 06. CKU(f>W. M., 1971, CTp. 102.
5' C. H. U H. M. PyiJeltlW. YKa3. COq., CTp. 84.
'8 R. Ghirshman. Iran. Protoiranier, Meder
und Achameniden. !IIiinchen, 1964, CTp.
98-113.
57 M. R. KaiJwp6aell. IJa IHTHI!KU
CKOR KYJIbTYPJ.I. «l(peBHl!e
l(el!TpaJIbHoro na3axcTaHM.
1966, CTp. 375.
58 C. C. TJ epnu"OIl. 3ara;1fia 3oJIOTOrO KYP-
raHa. M., 1965.
59 C. II. TOA.croll, .If. H. ffruna. CaKU HI!-
30BbeB CJ.Ip-l(apbll. CA, 1966,.N! 2,
CTp. 151: O. A. BUUJ.HeIlC"aR., M. H. Hruna.
PaHHue caKU IJpnapaJIbH. IJCA, CTp. 197.
.0 MaTepuaJI lIe oIIyii.llIl<oBal!. JII06e3Hoe co-
061I\eHI!e aBTopa.
8! If. II. rpR.3nOIl, M. X. Mannau-oo.c. Pac-
. RonKU apcKoro KypraHa pal!l!eCKI!<pCRoro
BpeMeHU B TYBe. l{paTKlIe 'I'e3llCbI AOKJIa-
AOB K nJIeHYMY, IIocBHlI\el!HoMY UToraM
apxeoJIoruqecJ(nx IICCJIeAOBaHI!B. 1971 r.
J1., 1972.
82 rtJ. X. ApcA.anoea. HOBbie MaTepl!aJIbi
VII-VI BB. AO H. :J. 113 BOCTOqHOrO Ka-
3aXCTaHa. CA. 1972. .N! 1, CTp. 253.
.3 B. B. lluorpollc'ilIU. CKU<pbI I! l(peBI!I!H:
BOCTOK. CA, XIX, 1954, CTp. 156.
.1 R. Ghirshman. Le Tresor de Sakkez. Les.
Origines de l'art '.lede et les bronzes du
Luristan. Artibus Asiap, XIII, 1950.
65 R. Ghirshman. Iran..., CTp. 99, 327; On :J/Ce.
7000 ans d'art en Iran. Paris, 1961.
66 R. Ghirshman. Iran.., CTp. 113-116.
6; C. C. TJepnu,,08. ::JaraAKa 30JIOTOro Kypra-
Ha, CTp. 130.
68 R. rtJ. C;\tupHoe. CaBpOMaTJ.I, CTP. 242.
6. A. Godard. Le tre,or de Ziwiye. (Kurdi-
stan). Haarlem, 19:,0; on JlCe. A prop03 du
trf¥;or de Ziwiye Artibus Asiae, XIV, 3,
HI'5); J. A. H. Potratz. Die Scythen und
V derasien. Orient alia, 28. Roma, 1959;
P. A mandry. I.'art "kythe archaique. Arch.
Anzeiger, 196.1. \ 4. p. 891: on :J/Ce. Un
motif «sky then » "Il Iran et on Greece.
Journal of Ea<tern Studies, 1965, p. 42.
70 M. H. ApraMolioe. K Bonpocy 0 npol!c-
XO:Rl\eHlIu CR"<peI,nro UCl<yccTBa. «Omagiu
TaCMOJIUH-
KYJIhTyphl
AAMa-ATa.
28
lui George Oprescu.. Bucuresti, 1961,
CTp. 31-46; on :J/Ce. R npeAJ.ICTOpUI! CKI!-
<po-CI!6I!pCKOrO 3BepIIHOro CTIIJIH. «Melan-
ges offerts A. R. Michalowski.. Warsaw a,
1966, p. 239-251; on JlCe. IJpollcxolliAeHlIe
Cl<u<pcRoro UCRYCCTBa. CA, 1968, M 4;
on JlCe. CKI!<Po-cI!6npCROe IICfiYCCTBO 3Be-
pUHoro CTHJIH. IJCA, CTp. 24-35.
71 H. JI. TJ .A.enolla. IJPOJICXOlliAeHlIe 11 pallHHH
HCTOpHH nJIeMeH TarapCRoii I<YJIbTYPbl.
1\1., 1967, CTp. 110; Ona :J/Ce. n Bonpocy
o nepBIIqHblX MaTepUaJIax npe;1 leTOB
B 3Bepl!HOM CTI!JIe. IJCA, CTp. 208-217.
72 M. H. ApraMonoll. IJpolICXOm:lelllle CI<ll<p-
Cfioro I!CKYCCTBa, CTp. 44.
73 TaM llie, CTp. .
" M. H. Apra.MOnoll. Cfin<p0-cu6I1pcl<oe I1C-
KYCCTBO.., CTp. 34.
75, H. JI. TJ .A.enolla. IJpol!cXOlliAeHlIe II paH-
I!HH I!CTOpI!H.., CTp. 129; OHa J/Ce. CKll<p-
CKUH OJIel!b, CTp. 180.
18 M. H. Ma"cUMolla. Cepe6pHHOP 3epfiaJIO
1!3 ReJtepMeca, CTp. 281.
77 M. H. Apra.Monoll. IJponcxoaqeHue c,m<p-
CKOro I!CKYCCTBa, CTp. 43, 281.
78 A. A. Heccen. HeKoTopJ.Ie naMHTHllfili
VIIl- VII BB. AO H. 3. Ha CeBepHOM KaB-
"8.3e. BCCA. M., 1954, CTp. 112; E. H.
R p y nno II. iKeMTaJIl!l!CKIIH KJIa;1. M., 1952;
CTp. 28; B. B. IIuorpollc"uU. BaHCI,oc I1ap-
CTBO, CTp. 248-249.
79 R. Ghirshman. Iran..., CTp. 119, pllC. 165;
on :J/Ce. Village perseachemenide. MemOl-
res de la mission archeologiqlle pn Iran,
v. XXXVI. Paris, 1954, tab. XXIV.
80 R. Ghtrshman. Iran..., !'Tp. I O, pIle. 540.
8' E. Porada. The art of Ancipnt Iran. :\ew-
York, 1965, p. 132, fig. 73.
82 M. H. ApraMonoll. IJpollcxoaqelllle CI,mI'-
CKoro I!CKYCCTBa, CTIJ. 32, pue. 1.
83 H. B. AntfiuMoll. CJIO:ReHl!e MCOTChOii Ry.lb-
Typbl I! CBH311 ee co CTenlIbnlll ,"'.lhTypa-
MI! CeBepl!OrO IJpUqepHO lOpbH. flCA,
(,Tp. 175, puc. 4, 3.
'I J1I06e3Hoe co061I\eIIue <D. X. .\pc.lalloHoii.
8' l(IJ, Ill, CTp. 6, IJPII.10m.
86 P. A6paMUlUIlU.A.U. R Bonpocy. 0 AaTupon-
Ke naMHT.IlI!KOB anoXH n03AHeH 6pOH3J.I H
mnpoKoro OCBOeHI!H llieJIe3a, 06Hap}'llieH-
llbIX Ha CaMTaBpCKOM )lOrUJIbHufie. BeCT-
HUfi foc. MY3eH fpY3HU, T. XIXa - XXI B.
T6I!JIUCH, (957. .
87 IJorpe6eHHe AaTupyeTcH HaXOAKOI! pO-
;'\OCClW-MI!JIeTcfioro cocYAa He n03AHee ce-
pe;1l1HbI VII B. AO H. 3. (JI. B. Roneu"una.
P0;10CCKO-UoHuRcKaH OHHOXOH U3 Kyprana
TellUp-fopa. Bl(H, 1972, oN! 1, CT.p. 147).
88 B. B. BunoepaiJoll. l(e.IlTpaJIbHJ.IH H CeBe-
pO-BOCTOqHbIii KaBKa3 B CKI!<pCRoe BpeMI!.
fP03Hblii, 1972, CTp. 327, pl!c. 11; B. A.
ff.A.bunc"aR.. RYJIbTOBJ.Ie llie3JIJ.I CKU<pCROro
u npeACKI!<pcKoro BpeMeHI!. «HoBoe B co-
ReTcKoH apxeOJIOrI!H.. M., 1965, CTp. 205.
89 M. II. rpR.3noll. CeBepHblB. Ra3aXCT8.H B
3noxy paHI!HX KOqeBI!I!KOB. KCHHMR,
BJ.In. 61. M., 1959, CTp. 14, pl!c. 4, 6.
90 C. H. PyiJen"o. HCKYCCTBO CfiU<P0B AJI-
TaH..., CTp. 36, puc. 27.
91 B. A. H.A.bUnC"aR.. 06pa3 KomaqberO XU -
lIIIKa, CTp. 71, pl!c. 4; CTp. 73, pl!c. 5;
C II. TO.A.CrOIl, M. H. Hruna. CaKH HI!-
3 BbeB Cblp-l(apbl!, CTp. 160, puc. 'I, 9.
92 B. H. IIo.A.rOpalf"aR.. Morl!JIbl!l!K Bepe30B-
Ka 1. ACf3, BJ.In. 3. JI., 1961, CTp. 82,
pllC. 55, 1, 2.
93 C. C. TJepnu"oll. 3araAKa 30JIOTOro Kypra-
Ha, CTp. 60, 'pl!c. 9, 3; B. A. !1.A..A.tncr"a.
IJpo 6pOH30BI HaKOHeqHI!KI! CTplJI TaK 3Ba-
Horo llia60TI!HcbKoro i HOBOqepKaCbKoro
TliniB. «ApxeoJIoriH., BJ.In. 12. RI!IB, 1973,
CTp. 26.
.1 B. A. JIurlluHc"uU. IJaMuTHufiU 3nOX.Il
OpOH3b1 U paHHero lliene3a RaHpaK-RYMoB.
J(ymaH6e, 1962, CTp. 342, Ta6JI. 45, 14.
9; B. H. BUiJ3U.A.R., 9. B. n"Ollen"o. KI!MMe-
pl!B.CKUe norpe6eHHH BJ.ICOKOB. MOrI!JIbi.
CA, 1974, oN! 1, CTp. 142, pl!c. 5, 1, .9.
96 B. M. lJanu.A.en"o, M. M. m.Maz.A.f.u, IJpo
OAI!I! nOBopTHUII MOMeH B lCT?Pll eHeO-
JIiTUqHOrO HaCeJIeHHH IJIBAeHHOl EBponll.
«ApxeoJIoriH., Bun. 6. RIIIB, 1972, CTp. 4,
pnc. 1; H. JI. TJ A.8nOlla. K Bonpocy 0 nep-
BnqHJ.IX MaTepIlaJIax..., CTp. 212, pRC. 2,
8-10.
B. B. BJI3K
R BOllPOCY OB MCTOKAX
CIGI<DO-CAPMATCROrO 3BEPMHOrO CTMJUI
B CIIeD;HaJIbHOH JlHTepaType MHOro-
RpaTHO IIpOCJIemeHbI TeCHble CBII3H
CKH«pO-CapMaTCKHX KYJIbTYPbl II HCRYC-
C'fBa C llCKyCCTBOM: ,ZJ;peBHero BOCTO-
Ra '. I1pll 9TOM OTTeHeHbI RaK CBII3H
1pa D;IlOHHble, OCHOBaHHble Ha XapaR-
1 epHOH P;JIII p;peBHHX KYJIbTYP IIpeeMCT-
lIeHHOCTll «POpM 2, TaR H Herrocpep;CT-
JleHHble CBII311 H B3aHMOOTHomeHHII
CKH«po-capMaTcKoro H p;peBHeBOCTO'lHO-
ro HCRYcCTBa 3. BblCKa3aHO p;ame IIpep;-
IIOJIOmeHHe 0 cyrn;ecTBoBaHHH «OIIpep;e-
JIeHBOH '1aCTH CRH«PCKOro HaceJIeHlljJ) B
HH3MeHHblX pallOHax 3aIIaJQIoro 3aRaB-
Ra3b1l 4 . A B llCKyccTBe CeBepHoro RaB-
Ka3a (I1pIIRy6aHbll) OTMeqaeTCII CJIlllI-
Hlle KYJIbTYP MecTHoR, Tpap;IID;HoHHOH,
H IIpllmJIOR - ROqeBHlIROB-capMaT '.
Co II TblC. p;o H. '0. BIIJIOTb 'p;o Ha-
mell 9Pbl IIpOCJIemllBaIOTCII IIOCTOIIH-
Hble ToprOBble H KyJIbTypHble CBII31!
MemA)' 06JIaCTIIMH ,ZJ;peBHero BocTOKa II
BceM KOqeBblM MHpoM. MMeHHO B ny
9IIOXY pa3BHTOll H II03p;Hell 6pOH3b1 II
paHHero meJIe3a O'leHb YCllJUlBaIOTCII
B3allMoCBII311 CeBepHoro I1pIIqepHO-
MOpbll II Hllamero IIoBoJImblI, qepe3
CeBepHblll RaBRa3, C 06JIaCTIIMII, .1e-
malI\llMllIOmHee, IOrO-BOCTOqHee II IOfO-
3arrap;Hee,- ACCllplleii:, YpapTY, xeno-
XYPPIITCRIIM MHpOM H M paHOM. B rro-
CJIe):(Heil qeTBepTll VII B. ):(0 H. 3.
oc06eHHO IIHTeHcIIBHblM cTaHOBIITCH
BHe):(peHlle B BOCTOqHble II 3arra):(HbIe
tJaCTll IOiHHoro RaBKa3a (3aRaBRa3blI)
CRH«pOB. B COI03e, IIOIIepeMeHHO TO C
Mll):(llell, TO C ACCllpHeR B TeqeHlle
VII B. ):(0 H. 3. OHH IIpOHlIl\aIOT rpa6H-
TeJIbCKIIMIl IIoxop;aMH p;o MaJIoll A3HH
II I1a.'IeCTIIHbI 6.
He pa3 M. M. ApTaMOHOBblM,
B, B. I1IIOTpOBCKHM, P. ,ZJ;. BapTHepoM
II P. filpIlIMaHoM Ha OCHOBe COIIOCTaB-
JIeHll1i KOHRpeTHblX IIaMIITHHROB 6b1JIH
rrpOaHaJIII311pOBaHbI Te H306pa311TeJIb-
Hble «POpMbI II HOpMbI CIDI«pCKoro HC-
RYCCTBa, ROTopble IIop;TBepmp;aIOT He
TOJIbKO HeIIocpep;CTBeHHble, HO H rJIy-
6UHHbIe, ceMaHTll'leCI\1Ie CBII3H ero C
llCKYCCTIJOM ,ZJ;peBHero BOCTORa 7.
OqCIIb Har,'I1Ip;HbIMIl II qaCTO rrpllBop;H-
MblMII IIpIIMepaMH IIBJIIlIOTCII peJIbe«p-
HbIe tleKaHHble 11306pameHHII Ha 30JIO-
TblX 06R.1a):(Rax HomeH Meqell (aRHHa-
K{JB) II PYKOIITRe ceRHpbl llJIll TOIIopllRa,
a TaKiHe 3epRaJIe H 'lame 113 ReJIep-
MeCCKIIX I\ypraHOB II TaR Ha3blBaeMoro
Me.1brYHoBcKoro KJIap;a (JIIITOii: RYP-
raH) 8. MOTIIBbI (JIemalI\lle, IIP;YID;He,
Bepnec. mecTBYIOII\lle 6bIRll, R03JIbI,
OJIeIlII. XIIII\HIIKIl--IIaHTepbl (?), a TaR-
iHe qJaHTaCTl1qeCKHe rpn:«pOHbI, coep;II-
HIIJ()IJ IIe B OL\HOM 06pa3e qaCTll 6blIWB,
.%IJOIJ. Op.10B II pbl6, ORpblJIeHHble 60-
iHCCTBa II ):(peBO mII3HII), p;eRopaTIIB-
IIaH t'I!\Hepa IIX IIOp;a'lll, TpaRTOBKIl rrpII
IIOMO,tn1i '1eTRoro p;BOll1l0rO ROHTypa II
iHIIIJOlIlICHO pa3pa60TaHBoll B HeCROJIb-
1\11 X JI:laHax rpa«pllqeCKOll IIepep;aqH
60.1l'CO 11.111 IeHee RpyrrHbIx p;eTaJIell,
IW I IlOllOBKa 9TIIX MOTIIBOB rrOlIcaMll II
no )"copa.1b):(IIqeCROMY IIPllHD;IlIIY - Bce
30
31'0, p;ame 6YP;YQII coep;IIHeH?, C THIIH:-
BO rrO-CRll«pCRll TpaKTo aHHOll «pllrypOll
JIemarn;ero OHeHII (Ha 60ROBOM BblCTY -
rre Meqa H3 JIIITOro KypraHa), co Bcell
oqeBIIL\HOCTbIO p;eMOHcTpIIpye T BOCIIpHII-
TIle MHOrOBel\OBblX Tpap;IID;1l1l IIepe e-
a311aTcRoro IICKYCCTBa, B QaCTHOCTll,
HcRYCCTBa ACCIIpIIII II Ypapry. Op;Ha-
RO c.'1ep;yeT OTMeTIITb, '11'0 HMeeTCII
Ta me pllP; rrapaJIJIe.'Iell II306pa3HTeJIb-
HblM II opn:aMeHTaJIbHblM MOTIIBaM pac-
CMaTpllBaeMblX rraMIITHIIKOB Ha rpaBH-
pOBaHHblX rraHHO 6POH30Bbl IIOIICOB
BTOpOll rrOJIOBIIHbI II II rrepBOll qeTBep-
PUC. 1. rtJpa2MelITbl 0pllo."enTupo8a'H"wx
nORC08. Bponaa. ApMellllR, AxnaT, nep8aR.
'leT8epTb I TbIC. iJo 11.3.
Tll I TblC. p;o H. 3. C TeppllTOpllll 3al\aB-
Ra3bII - 113 CaMTaBpo B rpY3111I, Ce-
BaHcRoro pallOHa, TaIDIllCROrO MOrn:lb-
HIIRa, AXIIaTa H RllpOBaI{aHa B Ap [e-
HHII (pllC. 1) , 113 RaJIaKeHT a II
XOp;maJThI B A3ep6allp;maHe 9. TaI\OBbI,
HarrpllMep, IIJIeTeHRa, CIIMBOJIIl3HPYIO-
rn;all IIpep;CTaBJIeHHe 0 6eCROHeqHOCTII,
H opHaMeHTaJThHble rrOJIOCKH 1I3 HIIII-
caHHblX P;Pyr B P;Pyra yrJIOB. M B I\OM-
II0311D;HIIX MIITaHHHllCRIIX II XeTTCI\IIX
xyp;omHHROB eCTb IIop;06Hble p;eIwpa-
TIIBHO-CMblCJIOBble, O'leHb Bblpa311TC,lb-
Hble opn:aMeHTbI, IIOqTll B TOll me npo-
pllCOBRe, '11'0 H Ha IIpOIl3Bep;eHllIIX IlC-
RYCCTBa CRH«pOB, HaIIpllMep, Ha I\epa-
MllqeCROM aJITape H3 Te..1.TIb-Xa.,a<pa
( lllTaHHIIllCKOll rY3aHbI) '0, Ha 6a3e
.-...................-. ,
..-
, .
. ..-0 .
2
" \/-
I
31
IWJIOIlllbI R3 xeTTCKoro CaMaJIa (COBpe-
MeHHblii 3eH):(>KUpJIU, pUc. 2) " U xeTT-
CKUX ffie pe;Ibl'ipax U3 Cal\<Jere3Y Ii
KapKelollima (M8parua) ", H8 01\Hoii
'.13 xyppnTcKUX l{H.'1IIHAPuqeCKRX ne-
qaTeH JI ):(affie B J\el\ope MJITaHHHHCltRX
COCY):(OB H3 TeJI.'1b-ATqaHbI H TeJIJIb-
EUJIJIbI ...
He Bblpaffi8R COMHPHUii OTHOCUTeJIb-
HO nlI):(o-npaHCKoro npOIlCXOffiAeHHR
CJmipoB H He nO:leMU3upYR C aBTopaMU,
npUBOARm;IIMII OCHOB8TeJIbHbIe AOKa3a-
Puc. 2. XeTTc"aSl 6aaa "o.ltonnw. BaaaAbT.
Ha 3eiJ3ICupAu (iJpe6nuu CaMaA), O"OAO
IX 6. iJo n. 8.
TCJIbCTB3 reBeTUqeCKUX Ii KOHKpeTHbIX
BJIIlRlIUii KYJIbTypbI 06JIaCTCH HpaH-
CIWrO narOp.bH Ha CKH4>cKoe U CapMaT-
ClWC I'ICI(YCCTBO, IIOnbITaeMCH npoc:Je-
J\nTb B3allMOCBR3n u306pa3IITeJIbHOrO
TBOpqeCTBa CKn«pO-capMaTCKoro Mupa
n nepep;Hea3UaTCI(I'IX KYJIbTyp, KOTopbIe
pa3BIlBaJIIICb Ha Haropbe ApMRHCKOM,
B CeBepHOH CUpHU U Ha IIorryocTpoBe
MaJIaH A3uR. TaKJIM 06pa30M, IIp.HBJIe-
l(aR ruupol(Hii Kpyr npOU3BeAeHUll HC-
I,YCCTBa, nOCTapaeMCR Ha OCHOBe 06-
pa3HO-CTIIJIIiCTUqeCKoro COIIOCTaBJIeHHR
U aHaJm3a BbIRBHTb qepTbI OpraHHqe-
CKoro CTUJII!CTU'IeCKOrO CXOACTBa Meffi-
TI.Y IIaMHTHUJ\aMH CKH«pOB H capMaT H
xeTTO-XYPpUTCKoro MUpa, TO eCTb U3
..-.
o' C
41'"
- \. --
1 '
1'\1 . C'
k ".... . '... "
"
\\ '\ i . , ,- ..
.; ..
. ""
I! t-. .....
., ..
, t \ 4- .. \t , .
"'"'
.. ' . V
, ...
..
"-
, \
1 _[, f
32
ranOHOB CCBepa H ceBepO-3anaJ\<\ TIc-
A . ,.
p!JABel! .mu . .
He 8HaJm3upYR BonpOCbI, CBR3aBHbIe
e IIPOIlcxoffiAeHueM B CKU«po-capMaT-
C.KO I UCKYCCTBe TOro UJIII JIBOrO o6pa3a
(KoWaqbero XUm;HHKa, OJIeHR U .u;p.),
6YAeM KacaTbCR npUHIJ;IIIII'I8JIbHbIX
T OpqeCKII-U306pa3HTeJIbHbIX COOTBeT-
CTBun B rpynnax naMRTHnJ\OB C Ha3-
BaHHbIX TepPuTopUH. 3aMeTHM Bce me,
'Iro TO'lJ,a 3peBUH E. E. TIuoTpoBClwro,
It _\. 11JIbuHcKoH II C. C. qcpHul(oBa
lIa l!CKOHHO cKH«pCl(oe IIPOIlcxomp;eHue
I'H:n;a u306pa3IITeJIbHbIX MOTIIBOB U
npne IOB IlX KOMIIOHOBKH, a TaKffie ux
Tp8Hc«popMan;un KameTCH H8n60JIee
Jler HOll u.
n pIl cpaBHeHUU XapaJiTepa CIIJIY3TOB
n:lOopameHuH peaJIbHhlX n «paHTacTH-
'lI'CKl!X mlIBOTHbIX (6bIJ,a, J,Ol!H, JIbBa,
rpn«poHa) Ha TaKHX xapaKTepHhlX na-
MRTHHl(aX cKHcI>o-capMaTcKoro BBepu-
noro CTUJIIJ VI- V BB. jI,O H. 3. KaK, Ha-
IIpmlep, 6pOH30BbIe HaBepIlllIIJ U3
I>O.lbWOro ¥ JIbCKOrO U ReJIepMeCCKoro
"ypraHoB, 6pOH30Bbie me 6JIRXU H3
"ypraHa Y ceJIa iKYPOBKa U HaBeprrme
In hpaCHOKYTCKoro KypraHa 18 C CUJIY3T-
EbDi pemeHlIeM B npOCTpaHCTBe TaKUX,
Ill' lIIeHee TUnnqHhlX 06pa3D;OB IIJIaCTU-
laI xeTTO-XYPpUTCKoro Kpyra HaqaJIa
I TbIC. AO H. 9., KaK 6bI'1bH «purypa
\I IIoprHKe MUTaHHUHCKoro xpaMa-
.IBOpL\a B TeJIJlb-XaJIa«pe 11, «PurypbI
nplIBpaTHbI'i: U u306pameHHbIX Ha
1"'.1 he(paX ..bBOB H:1 pyun xeTTCJ\IIX
ap\UreKTYPHbIX aHCaM6JIeH B TeJIJIL-
.\ Ulape, Te:l!lb-AT'I:aHe (puc. 3, 1), H
1\:ipaTeHe 18, CTaHOBHTCR O'IeBIlp;HbIMU
"'1(:. 3. Hao6paxeHuSi Ab806:
I - eTTCHaR npHBpaTHaR cIIHrypa n"Ba. Baaam.'I'.
II. Te;). b-ATxaH"'. OROJlO IX B_ 1\0 H. B.; 2-
\hITBHHllilcKBA OPTOCTBT C Ha06p8.}f(eHHeM nbBa,
'drpblSBlOlliero OBIlY. BaaaJll>T. Ua xpaMa-I\BOPlia
IaJlR }\Bnapbl B Tenb-Xanaclle (l\peDHRJI ryaaHa),
1,-\'111 BB. 1\0 H. 8.
2 CI<lIc110-CH(jHpCHHA sBeplIHb,A CTHJlb
-,::
'J;1 .;'
r ( ...
,
4.)-
,;;
. "
. toto,
.
\. . fJ
,- '.
' -
1
..
':
I -...
. -
/ \
,
.....
..
"
..
'-
...
2
33
'. .l
'''' .
..; i.
. .:"
t
q.
--;.
I.-='
....
.....
r
lljHJHQIUlU8JIbHbie TBOpqeCKUl' C.OOT-
fleTCTBllH. TaR, HecoMHeneH e lIlIblii,
nO.1'IephIlYTo BLlpa3l1TeJILHLIH JIaIW-
nn3M 061l\llX oqepn\Hllii u306pailieHllii.
06pa3HO-CMLlCJIOBble «3a amI.H». CBJI-
3aRHbIa C Ha3HaqpHHeM BCCX npoH3Be-
ClIIIii, Tpe60BaJIU y6e:n;HTeJIbHOii TH-
nn3a Hn a6pHca Kam:n;oR '!aCTn TPJIa
.'11060ro iRHBOTHoro. Tal\aH CTIIJIIICTH-
qpCKaH Tpal\TOBKa B 06eHx rpYlinax
lla I.RTHnROB cOBepmeHHo o'!eBHJJ;Ho
CBH38n8 C 1\.IHOrOBeI\OBLIMlI TBop'!e-
Puc. 4. XeTTc"uil peAbetjJ ua 3;:uo"a c ua06-
paxeHUSU/.U clleH OZOTW Ha BenpSl U OAeHSI.
113ll£cTHSI". "oneq II rwc. 80 H. 3_
--
-
.. :.. .
ri"
. , ..l::
-;.,
.- -
---
,(
,.) '-at
1 \.
./ ""<
..
..
_""-i-
.
-,
'.
..
,
.
""" ",,::: J
.... V
"').
.. -
.:'.
CKHMH Tpa I1 lIRMII, 1I0Jl,Bepl'ill1lMIIC
OlIpe eJIeHHO" RaHOHII3a HII.
BJlJI30CTb CII:IY3THLlX, OCTpOBLIpa3n-
TeJIbHLlX pemeHuii, lomeT GLlTb, cnW
IlBCTBeHHee OIl\YIl{aeTCH npli cpaBne-
nUH KOMn0311 1Iii co Cilemnm Rana]!C-
HHJI peaJILHOrO IIJIn KpblJlaTOrO .'1bBa
na OJIeHJI, 6bma, Ilrnpmia, nalIpHMep,
lIa 30.iIOTOH 06Ii.13:n;KC KUJIQan8 H3 Ce-
Mn6paTHero KypraHa 11 lIa l{eJIOM PH-
e opTOCTaTOB 113 TC:I.lb-Xa.lalJ>a
(pHC. 3, 2) I.. 3TOT apaManlqec.nlfii
ClOmeT lIepe aH 1Ia n8MHTHIIRax 06e-
IlK rpYlIli B paBHoii Mepe onpe:n;eJIeHHO
II o.n;nHM H Te\( me nplWMO (: CllJrya-
TOM, cKyno oqep'!cnHl.IM, no Bl.mepeH-
lILiM HaCTO.'lbKO TOQnO, qTO OH BODJlo-
-:- ...
-
.
..r
c;-
lOt""""
--
--
....,......
....
-
.
-'..
.,.
.
-
.'
..
,
. .7
_ . roo
1-"- .,,:
,J'
....
. .;-.;r; ,.
.... -
'.'-::if .
.. -
....
..t.'-.
....
. -
.=
..
34
'puc- 5
,-.
. .
......
- ;.."
\
It
. '-i;
,.t> -..
'
:a
j
.,.
"<
"
J..
'.
'........
.
,
. )
, \i ,
... -
,
.'
'\'
!
'....
. .
.:.1 .
.t't.-.
,
..-t :. _ i::t
l.:k..":. '
.. '" it 4 .i'....".
. - ,. '- I
. - .. <.-.""' ": >..;\, :
_ .;. .v
. "
.'-
t' .
t
...
": f' .( \:...
;?'f. \., .'
-..,..f!, . . . .'
jr-: -4
'"
. - J..' '.i'
: ' L. .
......) .... .
,. ',;/'..'
p
;>
.... \\
t->;.
(
c.c
aeT npbUHOK U BrphI3aHlle XII HUKa
B CBOJO mepTBY. BJIarop;aplI TaKOMY
0606 e uJO CUJIyaToB CJOmeT, u306pa-
meHHhIU BnOJIHe KOHKpeTHO, Ha'IUHaeT
3BY'IaTb CUMBOJIU'IeCKU.
PUC. 5. KUMeHHble U8SUAHUA (c1'p.35):
I - MHTaHHHAcRaR 41HI'ypa nTHQJ>l Ha ROnOHH8.
Baaam.T. U8 XpBMa-lUIOpl\a l\apR Hanapw a
Temn.-XanaoJ>e (ApeBBRR rY8aHaJ, IX-VIII BB
AO R. 8.; 2 - YpaP'!'CRoe BaBepmHe ROneCBB
B BRAe ronOBW nomllAB. BpoBsa. Us HaPNHp-BIIY-
pa (ApeBBBA TeAmetl8.HHH), nepaBJI 'IeTBepTb
I TWC. AO B. 8.; 8 - oJ>Hrypa OWKa. BpoBsa. Ap-
MeBHR. AAPYN, VII-VI aB. AO B. 8.
P!;.C. 6. XerTcp>uil peAberfl C uil06paJ/CeHueM
iIPUHP>cu. BUBUAb1'. HB Kapp>eMUruu. HU'tUAO
TbiC. 80 H. a.
w-
.r'
It :-..-.. . ...-., I
. ...,:..,t.:.
""..;J'*' .._.'
':,ij .! Z ....__
-... . .",.- . -
:
, ,f.
"J'.-,"_
-.J ..
j: J .
. , .
?'"
.'
)
'7
-
--
"!7"
p
, :I"
:.'--,.,.
-':1;-:
,..1' ...
J ' _l
"
:1:""
:, '''if,.
, r' ;" ..
.'. -
('.y..'
f..
BOJIbmlHI IIJIU MeHbmall CTPneHb
p;c opaTnnHOCTn B npOpa60TKe p;eTa-
:JPII, Ha6:uo:n;aIO aJICII H pa3JJHQnhI'\(
lIaMHTIIImaX, CBII3aHa C UX pa3HOnpe-
MeHHOCTbIO, npOHCxomp;eHHeM U3 pa3-
HhlX lIynKTOB, a TaKme C TeM, 'ITO op;-
IIn BJ.Ino.lncnbI U3 KaMHH, a p;pyrne II3:
MeTaJIJIa. IIpu n me TpaKToBKH, 110-
p;aQn CHJIY3TOB Be3p;e OADH n TOT me.
B ep;lInOM nJIaCTH'IeCKOM pHTMe Co CII-
:Iy3Tlnm IfInryp BbInOJIHeHa U HCH IIX
nenK8: UOJIblllBMH 06'beMaMII H nnoc-
KOCTHMU, 'IeTKO BbIp;eJIeHHhIMII, CYM-
MapHo nepep;aJO MU rJIaBHYJO THnU'Ie-
CHYIO 'IePTY Kamp;OH qaCTH TeJIa: Kpe-
nOCTb H cnJIy Hor HJIH JIan, ynpyroCTL.
meH, BeCOMOCTb omeMoB TYJIOBH a.
'"
""';1""'.,.
,
.J'- y,
r. ;.,1
'.If
':'J . .:
.'-..
.1
.-;
;Y. J
.Eo i
A
.:
I ,
-
t
;.
.,.,
.. :
61'--
.r ...
w'l
. ,
. .:.,
- .. .J
--.;
'.
,
.\ I'
. .
"! .r
. L
,. --
'Co
J
- .
'1
"r
...;
1(
.
,
"'-
........ ,
:11
3TOT CTHJIb cKynbliTypHoro BOIIJIO e-
BUll 06pa30B mUBOTHbIX OTJIn'IHO npo-
C;IPmHBaeTCJI Ha IIp'IaHmUX 06pa3I\aX
CltIiiflCKOrO HCKYCCTBa - 30JIOTOii: ifllI-
rype naHTepbI, YKparueHun ID;HTa 113
l\eJIepMeCCRoro RypraHa R 30JIOTOH
iflurype OJIeHII, TaHme p;eKopnpOBaB-
meii HT, U3 KypraHa y CTaHBI\bI 1\0-
CTpOMCKOii (06e - IV B. AO H. 9.)20.
OAHaKO HeH3MeHHO TaKOBa iRe TpaK-
TOBRa iflop!,[bI H MHoroqnC:IeBHbIX xeT-
TCKHX, XYPpUTCKUX, ypapTcKIiX H 3a-
R8BKa3CKHX penbeiflHbIx II TpeXMep-
HbIX H306pameHHH. ]J;OCT8TO'IHO 06pa-
TIITLCH, RpOMe yme Ha3BaHHbIX BbIme
npllMepOB, XOTII 6bI K xeTTCKHM penbe-
iflaM C iflHrypoii BOHHa Ha ROHe H3 Bo-
ra3KeJI 2t HJIH CO cI\enaJl1n OXOThI Ha
Ka6aHa II OJIeHII 113 3llIOHa (pIIC. 4)22
RpynHoii iflllrype nTWJ.bI, )'BeH'lUB8JO-
meii KonOHHY, H peJIbccpHbI:\1 c:plIrypaM
cTpayca, COKOJIa U p;lIKOrO ryclI 113
TeJIm.-XaJIaifla (pHC. 5, 1)23, ypapTcKOH
6pOH30BOii rOJIOBe nomap;II, HaBepmUII
p;bImJIa KOJIeCITHI\bI H3 TCHme6aHHH
(l\apMup-Bnypa, pUC. 5, 2)"', 3aRaB-
Ka3cKOH nnaCTUKe BTOpOH nOJIOBH-
Hbl II H nepBoH 'IeTBepTU I ThlC. P;O
H. 9. , npep;CTaB:JeHllOH 6pOH30BbIMH
(!JnrypKaMH, nop;BeCHaJlIH H HaBepmn-
HMH H3 Tonopca, JI'I8meHa, AiipYMa
(pHC. 5, 3), IIapaBaHapa U ..morllx
p;pyrHx MecT".
Bce nepe'IHCJIeHHbIC' CRYJIbnTypbI B
CTRJInCTUqeCHOIII OTHowelIliH llpIlHap;-
nemaT K OAHOMY HanpanlIPHUIO nepep;-
uea3H8TCKoro HCI,YCCTn8, OCUOBaHHO-
MY Ha IIcnO.lb301J8Hnn .18ROHIl'IHO-BbI-
pa3UTeJIbHhJjX u.wopa:mTc.1LRbIX nplle-
1II0B: a) nOp;tlUHeHlHl '11OpMbI u306pa-
meHHH (CRnY3Ta II oo"e:\ra) ero Ha-
3Ha'IeHHJO; 6) 1I0C.le1\OlJaTe.lbBO I, MeT-
11IIQeCKH pa3'lepenno:\1. cnOI,OllHOM pac-
IIpep;eJIeHUll u306pa;I'I'IIIIii no OTHome-
HIIIO :n;pyr 1\ :JPyry. n) IW:\1Il0HOBKe
Bce'\( iflOP:\I lI:ioij (la ;1,1.' II nll IIO nplllII\H-
ny nJIaCTHqeClwro (lannOBeCHII; r) B
pllp;e cnyqaeB - npl'rIIBOIiOCTaBJIeHHO
pa3JIU'IHbIX qmryp no repaJIbp;H'IeCIW-
MY npHHIwny.
06pa3HO me CTHJIIICTH'IeCKHH CTpllll
3Ha'IllTeJIbHOrO KOJIHqeCTBa 06pa3I\OB
nJIaCTIIKH I1paHa OTJIH'IaeTCH 6o.ilce
n30 peHHO-Y30p'IaTbIMU pllTMaMU CR-
nyaToB, 3a'IaCTYIOp;eRopaTUBHO-BH 01l3-
MeHeHHbIMII iflopMaMH TeJI mHBOTHblX
H B I\eJIOM cnomHO p;eKopaTHBHbIM BOII-
JIO eHHeM KaK OTp;eJIbHhlX MOTIIBOB,
TaR II KOMn03WJ.uii, B ROTopbIe OIiU
BIWJO'IeHbI. B lIaJlllITHHKax 9Toro Rpyra
rOCllop;cTByeT cneI\lIif1n'IeCKOe, Oqellb
YTOH'IeHHOe, ;mHeapHO-OpHaJlIeIITa:Ib-
Hoe Ha'IaJIO. B paCCMaTpUBaeMYIO 3no-
xy OHO MHororpaHHo npOIlBnlleTCII U B
MHOrO'IHCJIeHHbIX cKynbnTypHhIX npo-
113Bep;eHHHX H3 6pOH3bI JIypllCTaHa X-
VII BB. P;O H. 9. 28 , H B rapMOHllqHeii-
meM no CBoeMY nJIaCTII'IeCKH-p;eKopa-
TnBHOMY pemeHHJO peJIl>eiflHOM oiflop)(-
nemIB IIcpccnO.lbcKOro p;BOpn3 (Yl-
V BB. P;O H. 9.)21. 3JIeMeHTbI TaRoro
nOAxop;a K TpaRTOBKe CHJIyaToB n
06'beMOB Ha6JIJOp;aJOTCJI U B 06nHKe 00-
pa3I\OB llJIaCTUKH U3 Xa3aHny I -
VIII BB. P;O H. B., HanpHMep, Ha 61'08-
30BbIX HaRnap;Kax B Bnp;e IITUI\ 28, a
TaKme B iflnrypax JIemaIqlIx JIbBOB 2..
I1CTOKH aToro CoTHJIHCTn'IeCKOrO C80-
e06pa3HII, xapaRTepHoro p;nH 60:IbmOll
rpYlilibI naMJITHHKOB HCKYCCTBa I1pa-
Ha, MOH\HO npOCoJIep;UTb no;nanuo.
BIIJIOTb P;O pocnllceH anaMCKOll Kepa-
MHI\H IV - Ha'Iana III TbIC. AO II. .J.
Mliorne upaHcKue naMHTHlinn xa-
paKTcpn3YJOTcH B CBII311 C H30ID;I1en-
HOCTblO TpaKToBRH oonY3TOB n .neI>0I'i\
:\lIIomeCTBeHIlOCTbJO IjJOp:\1 11 cryw,l'II-
IIOCTbJO B pacnpep;eneHHu 0PH8I11PRTOII.
I\poMe TOro, ux 06pa3Ho-cTII.1IICTII'Il'l-
KOIIIY CTpOIO CBollcTBeHHo npe06.13;J.a-
Hue repanbp;H'IeCKOH KOMIIOHOBl\n 1I.lOii
p8311Te.'1bHbIX MOTIIBOB, a TalOJ-;e (1'[111-
T8CTn'IeCKOrO 3.1eMellTa B 1l0 a'Je oopa-
JOB. COIlOCTaBJIeHUe CTH.1H nrnO.1W'-
HUll CKHiflo-capJllaTCKlIX n8J11HTHil h " (1
CO CTHJIHCTH'IeCRllMII 'IepT8J1II1 :\\ll"m \
37
HpanCKHX 6pOHJ HJ XaJaIIJIY II JIYPH-
CTana nOKaJbIBaCT TaKJf\e, qTO: a) CY-
m;ecTByeT 06 HOCTb ClOmeTOB - 1I: o6-
pameHbI OP;HH H TC mc pea.'1bHbIe II
«J>aHTaCTllqCCKHe mHBOTIIblC (ope.l, «J>a-
3aH, naHTcpa, OHarp, KOJe.'1, 6bIKO-
opeJI, 6bIKO-qeJIOBeK); 6) qTO B pHp;C
CJIyqaCB HCnOJIb3YlOTCII 6mIJKlle npue-
MbI o606 eHHH «J>Op 1 - BK.llOqelIlle
MHorHX 3JICMCHTOB «J>uryp pa3IIbIX mu-
BOTHbIX B OP;HY nJIaCTllqecKYIO Kmmo-
3Ho;HIO.
Op;HaKo CJIep;ycT IIarrOMHIITb, qTO
3TH qCPTbI B TaKoii: me Mepe rrpucym;H
II HCKYCCTBY xeTTO-XYPPllTOB, ypapToB,
aCCHpllRo;CB. .D;ocTaTOqHO naJBaTb «J>an-
TaCTHqeCKUX oxpaHIITeJIeif p;Bopn;oBb6c
BXOP;OB ACCHpllH - KpbIJIaTbIX 6bIKOB
C qeJIOBCqCCKHMH rO.'10BaMII IX-
VIII BB. p;o H. 3."°, C«J>IlHKCOB IIJ xeTT-
I B. B. lluorp08clwil. Kap I1Ip-BJIrp. AJIb-
GOAl C conpoBOAuTeJIbliOH craneii. J1.,
1970, CTp. 13, 1;', 17, 18; r. A. Me.wx:uw-
8UJtu. KYJIxa (113 ApeBlIeii IIcroplIlI IOm-
Horo 3aKaBI{a3bH). "ApeBHIIU IIlp». M.,
1962, CTp. 325; If. X. K y w Ita PI" 6(1. OG}ICH
II TOprOBJIIi 3aJ<alma;II,H B ilpl'BHocrH.
«KpaTIme Te3UCI,I AOKJIa;10B I{ CInIU03I1Y-
MY TeOpeTlI'Iec.I\Oro ceMIIllapa II eel,ropa
CpeAHeii A3II11 II KaBKa3a J10JIA AH
CCCP 22-24 MapTa 1972 r. l,OG lell II TOp-
rOMH B ApeBIIIIX oGII/pcrBax»». a., 1972,
CTp. 14-15.
'2 H. B. Hlfeltx:o. HCIiYC.CTBO CKII1>C!;IIX UJIe-
MCII CeBepnoro ITplI'IepHOMopbR. 'II1CTO-
pHH UCI(YCCTBa lIapo.lOB CCCP», r. I. M.,
197 I, erp. 119. .
· B. H. Apax:eo'lJllt. lIchyccrBO ApenlIcii Ap-
MCIIII!!. (,HCrOpHH IICJ<;yccrHa lIapo.loB
CCCP», T. I, c.rp. 207: E. n. [,"pynH08.
10 JIeT paGoTl>! CeBPpo-KaHKa3clwii apxeo-
JIorUqeCI<OH 3!(ClIelllII(II II n 'I l"IC 110-11 IIry-
mcrIIH. (,Tl'3IIcbl J\OJ(.la;1oB lIa 3ac I '.taIIIIHX,
uocBIIII:/eHHbIx IIrora [ nO.ll'RbiX IIcc.le.10-
BaHuii 1967 r.» M.. 1968, erp. 38; B. B. BlI-
nozpao08. TaiiHb! MIIIIYBIDIIX Bpe !CH. M.,
1966, CTp. 39-44: B. H. .tfap""611/{ CKII<p-
cJ{IIe KypralIbI y ce.lf'IIIIR I'oiin.r ('le'le-
Ho-HHrymeTIIII). CA. 1<16;;. ,\"2 2, l'Tj'. 172-
173: JI. H. Mao'l08 !I If/;aJJ. Cap laTr""fI 3Be-
pHHblH CTIWb. A BrOpf'<p. l;alI;i. :lIICC. ;rI.,
1967. erp. 15-16.
CKoro 3eHp;mllpJIH (CaKqere3Y) llJIH
HapKeMuilla (pIIC. 6) Toro mc BpeMe-
Hll 3" HaKOIICo;, o;eJIbIii: KOMnJICKC Ha-
qaJIa I TbIC. AO H. 3. nop;o6HbIX OJIUo;CT-
BopeHuii: BbICllIHX CU.1J IIJ TCJIJIb-XaJIa-
«J>a 3", B 06mIKe KOTOpbIX HCnpllHym-
p;eHHeii:llIe COqeTaIOTcH qaCTU nTU-
o;bI, JIbBa, 6bIKa, CKopnHOHa U qeJIO-
BCKa.
He BbIcKa3bIBaH, TaKIIM o6pa30M, nu
MaJIcii:mero COMHCHHH B cy ecTBoBa-
HHH MHororpaHHbIx CTUJIHCTHqCCI<HX
CBH3eif H COOTBCTCTBHH Mcmp;y CKH«J>O-
capMaTcKHM HCKYCCTBOM U HCKYCCTBOM
I1paHa, XOTCJIOCb 6bI o6paTuTb BHllMa-
Hlle Ha HCCOMHeHHOCTb nop;o6Horo me
CTllJIllCTllqCCKOrO ep;IlHCTBa 3Toro llC-
KYCCTBa C 60JIbmllM KpyroM 11306pa311-
TeJIbHbIX naMIITHUKOB CCBcpo-3anap;a
IIcpcp;HcH A31111.
· H. H. fIozpe608a. meJIe3Hlile Tonopbl
CKH<pcKoro THlIa B 3aKaBKa3Le. CA, 1969,
M 2, CTp. 186.
· JI. H. MaJt08ulfx:aJl. YKas. CO'l., CTp. 17-
18.
· M. n. Apra.MOuo8. ITpoHcxomAeHHe CKH<p'
CKoro HCKYCCTBa. CA, 1968, M 4, CTp. 30;
B. K. A!lianaCbe8a, E. B. Beil.MaJtb. KYJIb-
Typa H IICKYCCTBO ITepeAHeii ASHH B ApeB-
HOCTH. ITYTeBoAHTeJIb no IIOCTOIIHHOii BbI-
CTaBKe OTAeJIa BocToKa focYAapcTBeHHoro
opMHTama. J1., 1971, CTp. 9-10.
1 M. H. Apra.MOn08. YKas. CO'l., CTp. 27-
28; B. B. fIuorp08cx:uil. KapMHp-BJIYP. I.
EpeBaH., 1950, CTp. 95-96; on XI". Kap-
MHp-BJIYP. II. EpeBaH, 1952, CTp. 37; R. D.
Barnett. The Treasure of Ziwiye. Iraq,
v. XVIII, 2, p. 111; R. Ghirshman. IralI.
Protoiranier, Meder, Achiimeniden. Mi.in-
chen, 1964, S. 4, 58-59, 98-102, 301, 306.
5 n. B. Hlfel!X:o. YKas. CO'l., pHC. 142, 144-
149; M. n. Apra.MOn08. YKas. COq., CTp. 27;
On XI". COKpOBHII:/a CKH<pCKHX KypraHoB
B c06paHHII focYAapcTBeHHoro 3pMIHama.
IJpara - J1., 1966, pHC. 3-4, Ta6JI. 1-3,
6-:115. 17.
9 IIF. H. A.1tUpanaW8uJtu. HCTOpHH rpY3IIH-
CKoro IICJ{\TCCTBa. T6HJIHCII, 1950, Ta6JI. 15:
A. A. Mnalfax:anJin. CJIeAbl IIOKJIOHelIlIR
COJIH y (cOJIHe'lHOro KYJIbTa) B IIpeBIIPll
ApMeHHII IIO MaTepllaJIaM 3IIOXH 6pOH3bI.
Tv. fHMa, T. I, 1948, pilC. 1; A. A. Map-
38
rupOCRn. ApMeHlI1I B 3noxy 6pOHSIiI Ii
IIHCro meJIe3a. EpeBilH, 1964, pH.C. 55,
pa < 7 1 2 85' B. B. l/>ap.Max:06cx:uU. Ap-
9 .1, '" P MAP No 34
'aIl'lPcJ(IIii neplioA B OCCHH. , . - .
. , 1914 P HC 14' A A. H 6a n08CX:UU. ITo
Ilr., , . ,. V I M 1911
3al<aBJ{a3blO. MAK, Bbill. ..., ,
Ta6JI. 1. . 1 h t d a lt
,0 G R. Meyer. Durch vIer a I' au en e -
\" rderasiatischer Kultur. Berlin, 1962,
'b 16. B
tI O. Weber. Die Kunst del' Hethiter. er-
\in, s. a., Abb. 4 . . If M
,2 G R. M eyer. Ka3. CO'l., pilC. 3, . .
J. .q"OH06. ITpeAbicTopHIi ApMIIHCI{OrO Ha-
ropbR. EpeBaH, 1968, pilC. 38. 14
t3 fl. M. bJlx:on08. YKas. O'l., pHC. 3,.. .
,. G. R. Meyer. Altorientahsche Denkma er
'n Yorderasiatischen Museum zu Berhg'
lei zig 1965, KapTa Ha CTp. 2 II 3 0 -
'0){ J{I1;' 9. IJ,epen. BH6JIeiicKHe XOJIMbi.
"1 1866 KapTa Ha CTp. 227.
,. E" 5 lluorp06cx:uil. BaHcJ{oe apcTBo
.' 1969 25 " B A HJtb-
(Ypaprv). M., ,CTp.;)...
lIHC"aJl: 06pas Koma'iberO XIIII:/HHKa B
paIlIlecKH<pcKOM HCKyccTBe. CA, 19!
oM 2, CTp. 69, 70, 76, 78, 81; C. C. 'lep
IW8. 3araAKa 30JIOTOrO KypraHa. M., 1965,
erp. 130. 151 153
15 fl. B. Hlfenx:o. YKas. CO'l., pHC. , ,
164, 165. . " b ' 1951
t1 H. Th. Bossert. Altsyrwn. Tu lllgen, ,
Taf. 450. . L .
18 .1 Champdor. Kunst MesopotaIDwns. e!.-
. . 1964 Abb 125' Boilrex Ba.Map08cx:uU.
r;. 'K;I!,1 x rroB.' M.,' 1968; pilC. IIa pHC. 59
Ii 237; C. W. Ceram. A Hettitak Rl'glonye.
Budapest, 1964, Tab. XXXI.
19 H. If. ToJtcroil u H. H. KOHoax:06. . ryc-
CIUle ApeBHocTH B IIa IIITHIIKax IIn,yecT-
Ba Bbln. 2. J,(peBHocTH CKH<po-capMarcKllc.
CIT6., 1889, pilC. 102; M. F. OppenheIm.
Del' Tell Halaf. Leipzig, 1931, TaL 26a,
27b, 28 a, b. J,
20 M. H. Apra.MOn08. COKpOBIIII:/a CKIHl'CJ{;'X
KypraHoB B c06paHHil 3pMlIraiKa, raOJI.
22-24 62-64.
2' C. W. 'Ceram. YKa3. COq., raii:!. XI.
" O. Weber. YKa3. CO'l., pHC. O. . ..
23 G. R. Meyer. Tell Halaf.. ElllP RUinenstat:
te in Nordsyrien. BerlIn, 1958, Abb. 9,
M. F. Oppenheim. YKa3. COq., Ta6JI.
25 a, b. , s
2< «L'art Armi'mien de 1'0urartou a no
jours. Musee dps arts decoratifs. Octobre
1970 - janvier 1971». (Kara.lor BbiCTaB-
1m). Paris, 1970, fig. 72.
.. TaM me, pHC. 27, a, 6; 35a,; 40:, 8 , c. e.
.5 E. Pora a. Iran ncien. L art. a I ep u;
preislamlque. ParIs, 1963, fig. 54 5,
p. 76, 78. 207 210
27 G Ghirshman. YKa3. COq., pue. , -
212 216-220, 224-228.
28 E 'Porada. 'I{a;j. CO'I., CTf'. 41. 101.
29 R: Ghirshman. YKa3. CO'l.. pue. 28, 29..
30 E Strommenger. Art of Mesopotamia.
L ndon, 1964, p. 198. 199, 220, 221.
3t O. Weber. YKa3. COq., pm'. It6, 14
32 M. F. Oppenheim. Y"a3. 1'0'1;, TaOJI. 8b
10a b' 31a b' 32b' 33h: :'\;;a; 37a, 41a, b,
42a; 47a; 64.' ,
A. M. Xa3aHOB, A. 11. IIIKypKO
COQHAJIbHbIE M PEJIMfM03HbIE OCHOBbI
CKH CROfO MCRYCCTBA
He3aBlICIIMO OT TOrO, 1\Of): a KOHKpeTHO
B03HIIKJIO Y CKIIcpOB rOCYAapCTBO, eABa
JIll MOJRHO cOMHeBaTbCR:, qTO ocpopMJIe-
HlIe cKllcpClwro I!CKyccTBa B TOM BIIAe,
B KOTo ml lbI e50 3HaeM, COBIlaAaeT
C 3IlO OII KJIaCCOOOpa30BaHIIR:, llepeJRII-
Ba l011 CKlIcpCKll 1 OOlIJ,eCTBOM. ,l],YXOB-
HOII JRll3HII .-IID60ro 06m;eCTBa 3IlOXII
}(.'lacco06pa30IJ8111fR: IlplIcym;1l onpeAe-
JICHHble 06lIJ,lIe 3aKOHOMepHOCTII. K
qIICJIY.. BaJRHeiiWIIX TaKIIX 3aKOHOMep-
HUCTell OTHOCIITCR: CIIHKpeTII3M Bcex
c<pep 06II\C('TIIE-'1I110rO C03HaHllR:, B3a-
JIMOIlp0ll1I1\II0Bl'llHe pa3JIIIqHblX ::JJIe-
MCIITOB llP;CO:lOrIlH, peJIlIrIlll, IICKYCCT-
B8 II T. J\., C o;J,Hoii CTOpOHbl, II CIleD;II-
cpllqeCKIle qepTbI IlCIIXOJIOrllll, MbIIIIJIe-
HUH, 1l0BeW'HIIH, OTHOilieHIIR: K OKpy-
JRaIDII(eMY Mllpy, CBOHCTBeHHbIe qeJIO-
BCKY :)TOH :)!lOX 11. C J\PyroR '. Be3 yqe-
Ta 3TllX OUCTOHTe:lbCTB HeB03MOJRHO
IlOHR:Tb .1IOUO(' IICl-iYCCTBO 3rrOXII KJIaC-
coo6pa30BallllH. H TOM qlICJIe II CKII4-
Clwe.
MOiKBO 11 pt':UlO:laraTb, qTO Cl-ilIcp-
eKUC IIC "yee 1110 ObI:lO IlpeJ\CTaB.1eHO
pa3.1I1qllbI 1I1 ;J;'\lIpa 1l1. Op;HaKO J\O Ha-
lIIero Bpe lellll :10W.l0 TOJIbKO J\Ba: 1130-
6P83J1Tl>.lblltH' II (1)0:Ibl-i.10p. lJTO l,aC8-
eTCH QJO.1bKI<'pa. TO Ibl paCUUJIaraeM
JIlIlIIb I1C111.1 'III TC.1bHbI 11I orpblBKaMII
II3 Hero. COXl'aHIIBlIII1MCR: B OCHOBHOM
B IlP01l3BC;WIlIIHX fepOJ\OTa II JIYl-iIla-
a:. I, TmlY ,"t' B I1Cl-iaa;eHHOll rpeqec-
1-i0ll Ilepc;J,;I'It. 13 II:Joopa3lITeJlbHml JRe
IICI,YCCTBI'. O('t "-'t'IIHO B paHHIIR rreplloJ\.
HaII60JIee R:pKOe II AOMIIHIIpYIOII(ee IlO-
JIOJReHIIe 3aHIIMaeT 3BepIIHblH CTIIJIb,
KOTOPOMY n03ToMY B OCHOBHOM II IlOC-
BR:m;eHa Hama CTaTbR:.
Cpa3Y JRe oroBOpIIMCR:, qTO Mbl pac-
cMaTpIIBaeM CKlIcpcKoe IICKYCCTBO BOOO-
m;e II 3BepIIHblR CTIIJIb B qaCTIIOCTII
TOJIbKO B npeAeJIaX cTeIlHoll II JIeCOCTeIl-
HOH 30Hbl CeBepHoro IIplIqepHmlOpbl}
II IIpIIKy6aHbR:. Mbl CqlITaeM Ta IWH
IloAxoA IlOJIHe AOIlYCTIIMblM, TaK I\aK
3B plIHblll CTIIJIb, oc06eHHo B apxanqec-
KIIll rrepIIoA, C TOqKII 3peHIIH lIalUcll
TeMbl, He IIMeeT cym;ecTBeHHblX .101([\-
JIbHblX pa3JIIIq1IR.
HeTpYAHO y6eAIITbCR: B TOM, qTO
3BepIIHblR CTIIJIb B peaJIbHOH CKII<pCKOll
JRII3HII R:BJIR:JI C060H nepaCqJIeHeHHOe
eAIIHcTBO 3CTeTlIqeCKOrO, cOD;lla.lblIoro
II peJIIIrlI03Horo MOMeHToB, IlplIqe}1 JTO
eJ\IIHCTBO OTMeqaeTCR: C caMoro Haqa.'la
ero IlOR:BJIeHIIR: II Ilpoc.lIeJRllBaeTCH lIa
BceR TeppIITopIIII ero paCIlpOCTpaIlC-
HIIR:.
YJRe B 60raTblX Ilorpe6eHIIHX 113
3IIBIIe 06pa3bI CKlIcpCKoro 3BCpJlIIOrO
CTIIJIR: BblCTYIlalOT HapR:J\Y C acclJpni!-
CKIIMII, ypapTcKIIMII II MaIIHciicI;I1MII
KaKrpaBHOIlpaBHble B xYJ\OJReCTBPIIIIOM
o TH0JI.IeHII II. BKJIIDqeHHC 3.1e I(,IITOR.
BblIlfiJIHeHHblX B 3BeplIHOM CTIJ.W. B
TpaJ\IID;IIOHHble J\JIH IIepeJ\Hcii .\:m II
peJInrlI03Hble KOMIlO:JIID;1I1I (lIe "TO pa.1 b,
YKpameHlIe IlOHca II.1II Ha.lIyqbe) 2 I'OBO-
pIIT 0 TOM, qTO B 3TOM OTHOllieHIIIJ OHII
R:BJIR:JIIICb OpraHlIqeCKOH qaCTbID Tl'''CTa
40
(B ceMIIOTIIqeCKOM CMhICJIe CJIOBa). Ha-
KOHeD;, TO 06CTOR:TeJIbCTBO, qTO rrpeAMe-
TbI II3 3IIBlIe, YKpameHHhIe B 3BeplIHOM
cTlme, OqeBIIAHO, He R:BJIR:IOTCR: COD;II-
a.lbHO HeRTpaJIbHblMII, qTO OHII rro CBO-
eMY MaTeplIaJIY II cpYHKD;IIOHaJIbHOMY
W\3HaqeIlIIIO CBIIJ\eTeJIbCTBYIOT 0 nplI-
RaJ\JIeJRHOCTII IIX BJIaAe.1T D;eB K BoeH-
IIo- a pIICTOKpaTlIqeCKOMY COCJIOBIIIO IIJIII
;(a ffie , KaK 30JIOTaR: rreKTOpaJIb, R:BJIR:-
IOTCR: CIIMBOJIOM BJIaCTII, YKa3blBaeT Ha
rrpncym;IIR 3BepIIHOMY CTIIJIIO orrpeJ\e-
JleHlIblR COD;IIaJIbHhIR acrreKT.
8TII JRe qepThI 3BepIIHoro CTIIJIR: He
MeHee R:pKO npocTyrralOT B HeCKOJIbKO
60JIee IJ03AHIIX rrpeAMeTax II3 Ke:rep-
leCCKIIX II MPilbIYHOBCKoro KypraHoB
(IlapaAHble MeqII, ceKIIpa, 3epKaJIO) 3.
ITpll aTOM, na Ham B3rJIR:A, OHII npoc-
.1effiIIBaIOTCR: He TOJIbKO B KOMIl03IID;II-
OIIHO-CIOJReTHblX Cn;eHax, HO II B ep;II-
IIlIqHhIX II306paJReHIIR:X 3BepeR II rrTIID;.
o xYAOJReCTBeHHblX AOCTOIIHCTBax Ta-
KHX lIIeJ\eBpOB, KaK KeJIepMeCCKaR: IlaH-
Tepa, KOCTpOMCKOll: OJIeHb, YJIbCKOe Ha-
BepIIIlIe B BIIJ\e rOJIOBhI XIIm;HOR IlTIID;bl
Il.1II MeJIbrYHOBCKIIe OpJIhI, rOBoplITb He
IlPIIXOAIITCR:. 0 TOM, qTO OHII He qYJRAbI
COD;IIaJIbHOR CIIMBOJIIIKe, CBIIAeTeJIbCTBY-
eT YJRe xapaKTep II Ha3HaqeHIIe IlpeJ\Me-
TOB, AJIR: KOTOpblX IlpeAHa3HaqaJIIICb IlO-
;J;06Hble II306paJReHIIfI: m;IITbl, HaBep-
IIIIIH He BIlOJIHe R:CHOrO J\O CIIX IlOp
Ha3HaqeHlIfI, IlapaJ\Hble IlOR:Ca. HaKo-
lIeu" IlOCKOJIbKY Te JRe caMble OJIeHII II
IlaHTepbl, KOTOpblX rrOOJ\IIHOqKe Mbl
BCTpeqaeM Ha II3AeJIIIR:X II3 KeJIep-
Mecca, CTaHHD;bl KOCTpOMCKOH II MHO-
rlIx J\PyrlIx IlaMR:THIIKOB, npIICYTCT-
BYIOT Ha C.1I0JRIlbIX KOMIl03IID;IIflX pe-
.1rrrno:Jlloro xapaKTepa B 311 Bile. Mbl
BIlpaBe J\OIlYCTIITb, qTO II B3f1Tble B OT-
Ae bHOCTII ORII MOrJIII coxpaHflTb CBOH
pC.1IIflI03HblR xapaKTep.
hOHeqHO, aHaROrIIII C IlepeAHeBO-
CTOqHblMII KOMIl03IID;IIR:MII lIe HB.lf1IOT-
fR: IlOJIHOCTblO IlpeJ\CTaBIITe.1bHblMII,
UOTOMY qTO OHII IlpOBOJ\flTCR: MemJ\Y
pa3JInqHblMll, XOTH II 6:1l1 Ih:IIMII B p;aH-
HOM OTHOIIIelilI1i Ky.lIbTypaMli. Ho MIIO-
rocplIrypHble KOMIl03IID;IIll, B KOTOpblX
BCTpeqalOTCfI Te me mIlBOTHbJe n B TCX
me n03ax, qTO II B OJ\IIHOqHblX II306pa-
meHlIflx, II3BeCTHbl II B c06cTBeRHo
CKllcpCKOM IICKyccTBe. K B03MOJRHOMY
pe.1IlIrlI03IIoMY OCMblCJIeHlI1O HeKOTO-
pblX n3 HIIX Mbi 06paTIIMCR: J\aJIbille.
Ya;e OJ\IIH II3 IlepBblx Cepbe3IIblX IIC-
cJIeJ\oBaTeJIeii CKIIcpCKoro IICRyccTBa
M. II. PocToBD;eB cnpaBenJIIIBO OTMeqaJI
ero CBR3b C aplIcTOKpaTnqeCKIIM CJIOeM
CKu(pcKoro oom:ecTBa '. OAHaKo cpeJ\a,
B 1-i0Topoii IlOJIyqIIJIII npeIIMYII(eCTBeH-
Hoe paCllpOCTpaHeIllIe rrpeAMeTbl, Bbl-
IlOJIH('Hilble B 3BCpIIHOM CTIIJIe, Ha Haill
B3rJIflp;, UYJRp;aeTCfI B HeKOTopOR KOH-
KpeT ll3au,IIII II yrOqHeHIIflX.
ECJIII IIMeTb B BIIP;Y TOJIbKO cpeJ\Y 6bl-
TOBaHIIfI, TO rJIaBHblR aKD;eHT, OqeBIIA-
HO, CReJ\yeT AeJIaTb He Ha 3HaTHOCTII, a
Ha BoeIlHOM xapaKTepe Tex Ilorpe6e-
HIIR, B KOTOpblX peryJIR:pHO BCTpeqalOT-
CfI Ila IHTHIIKII 3BepIIHoro CTIIJIfI. HaJ\o
JIll rOBopllTb 0 TOM, qTO Y CKlIcpOB, KaK
H B .'II060M J\PyroM 06m;eCTBe, BOIIHaMII
CTaHOBllJIIICb OTHIOAb He TOJIbKO IlpeJ\-
CTaBUTe.'lH apIICTOKpaTIIII? I1MII 6hIJIII
TaRit<C .:IPYJRIIHHIIKII II qaCTb pR:AOBblX
CB06oJ\HbIX qJIeHOB 06Il\eCTBa, KOTopble
B pa HllIIii IleplIOJ\ CKlIcpCKOH llCTOpIIII
pery.1Hpno IlpIIHII [aJIlI yqacTlIe B BoeH-
Hb!" J1eiicTBHHX.
A pxeo.10rlIQeCKlIe MaTeplIaJIbI VII-
V BB. no H. 3. CBIIp;eTeJIbCTByIOT, qTO
aBepllRbIii CTIIJIb BCTpeqaeTCfI II B 6ec-
ClIO [HIO ;1 pllCTOKpaTlIqeCKIIX Ilorpc6eHII-
HX (In Bl1e, KeJIepMeCCKlIe, Y.lbCKIIe,
non p(l\ICJ;lle II MCJlbrYIIOBClmii I,ypra-
HbI). II IJ MOrIlJIbHIlKaX, J\PymIIHHbIH
xa P;q;TP p ROTOpbIX IlpeJ\CTaBJlR:eTCR:
OQeHh IIPpOHTIIblM (HeROTOpb!e MOrrrJIb-
Hlll;ll f!C)CY,lbfl II J\pyrlle) 5, a TaRme B
OT;W.lhIlI.IX apXalIqeCKIIX He60raTbIX no-
rpC"f llllfiX C IlpeJ\MeTa 11I BoopymcTlIIR:
11 ri"jp 'll 60eB01'O KOHH (Te llIp-ropa,
Il"I;yp:I1IMaH, C. KOHCTaHTIIHOBKa, KYP-
41
raH 2/3, r. KOHcTaHTHHoBCK Ha HHm-
HeM ,ZJ;OHY, HHmHue Ceparo3LI, HypraH
3/5 H ]J.Pyme) .. lIpo IIoxoponenHLIx B
3TH X MOrllJIaX JUIII. HeB03MomHO CHa-
3aTb, 6bJJUI JIH OHI! iwymHHHIIKa IH IIJIH
06LI'IHLIMII pR:;: OBLIMH 'IJIeHaMIl 06lIJ,e-
CTBa.
lIpaBAa, eAHHll'lHbIe IIpC]l.MCTbI, BbI-,
IIOJIHeHHLIe B apXaH'IeCHOM 3BepHHOM
CTHJIe, HaxoAfiT TamRe Ha noce:reHll-
fiX (KapMllp-EJIYP, HeMHpoBcHoe,
TpaXTeMllpOBCHoe II EeJIbCHOe rOp0]l.H-
III,a H ceJIIlIIl,e lIomapHafl EMma) 7. 0]1.-
HaKO 3TII HaXOAl\l! He OIIpOBepraIOT BJ.I-
]l.BHHYToro HaMil Te3llca, rrOTOMY 'ITO B
OCHOBHOM OHII rrpeACTaB.'1CHLI BCC Te-
Mil me npe]J.MeTaMIl HOHCIWH c6pyu II
- TeM caMLIM OIIflTb-TaHIl CBfl3aITbl C BO-
IlHCI\l!M 6LITOM. B TO me BpeMfi r.lIIHfI-
IILIe CPHrypHH mIlBOTHLIX, HaH::\CHHLIe
ITa pflAe nOCeJIeHIlH JIeCOCTeIIHOH CHH-
. cpllll II IIpeAIIOJIOmHTe.TlbHO OTHOCHlIJ,He-
CfI K HYJIbTOBOH IIpaHTIlHe, B nO]l.aBJIfI-
IOIII.eM 60JIbIIIHHCTBe CJIyq:aeB CTII.'!IICTII-
'IeCHH He IlMeIOT nHqero 06II ero co 3Be-
pHHbIM CTIlJIeM, CBIl]l.eTeJIbCTBYR. HaH
MaJIO IIpOHHKaJI IIOCJIe]l.HIIH B rYIIIY PH-
)'I;OBoro 3eMJIeAeJIb'leCIWro Hace:ICIIIIH.
CBfl3b apXall'leCHoro 3BepHIIoro CTII-
JlfI C BOHHCHOH cpe]l.OH H BOCHllhDI 6bl-
TOM CTOJIb me OT'IeTJIHBO IIpOflB.'1HeTCfI
II: B Ha60pe IIpeAMeToB, Ha I\OTopble rro-
MeIIl,aJIHCb 1l306pameHHH mUBOTIiLIX.
3]J.ecb MomHO BblAeJIHTb TPll OCHOBHLIe
rpYIIIILI: opymHe, IIpeAMeTbl c6pyn 60e-
BOro HOHfI II IIpe]l.MeTLI caKpa.1JbHOrO
H COIl.llaJIbHo-KYJIbTOBOro Ha3naQpIIIfH.
lIpHMe'laTeJIbRo, 'ITO IIa BeII ax IIiIBce-
]J.HeBHoro 06HXO]l.a H ]l.amc YKpallluHII-
fiX 3BepllHblH CTHJIb BCTpe'laeTCH :IIIIIII>
B eAHHll'lHbIX c.1Jyq:aHx.
,ZJ;ame B IIpOCTOM rrepeqHe ml1nOTlIl>lx.
60JIee HJIIl MeHce rrOCTOIIHHO cplIr 'pIJPY-
IOIII,IlX B 3BCpHHOM CTIIJIe, B "01 "pO 1
XIlIIl,HIlKIl II CHJIbHble TpaBOH]l.Hbl(' pe-
IIIHTeJIbHO IIpe06JIa]J.aIOT IIag i10 TiIIlIHH-
Mil, OT'IeTJIIlBO IIpOflBJTHeTCR c"II(jw Kllii
3CTe1'Il'leCKIlH ll]J.eaJI. KpacoTa --, Ill' ca-
M0Il.eJIb II He a6COJIIOT. KpaCIlBO TO, 'ITO
B HaH60JIbmeH CTeIIeHIl cIIoc06cTByeT
BLImHBaHHIO H II06e]J.e. KpaCIlBoe - 31'U
IIpemAe Bcero 6LICTpoe, CIlJIbHOe, CTP"-
MHTeJIbHoe. lIOAooHLIe B033peHIlfl B
60JIbIIIeH IlJIH MeHbIIIeH Mepe, o'leBHARU,
OLIJIH IIPHCYIII,H BceMY CI\'ll:CPCHOMY 06-
III,eCTBY, H Ha CPOpMIlpoBaHIDI IlX He
MOrJIH He CHa3aTbCfI YCJIOBllfl caMoH
mll3HH C ee nocToflHHOH BoeHHOH Ha-
IIpfllReHHOCTbIO, IIpO HOTOpyro CKllcpbI
B IIepeAa'le JIYHllaHa (ToKcapllc, 33)
rOBOpH.1JII: «Y Hac Be]l.YTCfI IIOCTOflHHLIe
BOHHLI, MLI IlJIH caMH HaIIa]J.aeM Ha ]J.PY-
rHX, HJIH BLI]J.epmllBaeM naIIaAeHHfI, 1l.'1H
BCTynaeM B CXBaTHll 113-3a IIaCT61lIIl, II
]l.06LI'I}[) .
PaaYMeeTCfI, 0 CHllcpCHOM 06II1,eCTBe
B II.eJIOM B AaHHOH CBfl31l MomHO rOBO-
pHTb BeCbMa YCJIOBHO, JIIlIIIb IIOCTOJIbHY,
nOCHOJIbHy 0110 6bIJIO CBfl3aHO, rrpflMO
IlJIH HOCBeHHO, C BoeHHLIM 6LITOM. lIo-
BHAIlMOMY, HMeHHO BOIlHCKafl cpeAa II
flBHJIaCb OIIpeAeJIflIOIII,eB:: B CPOpMllpOBa-
'HIlH 3CTeTIlQeCHHX IIpllHII.IIIIOB CKHcp-
CHOro HCHYCCTBa, HOTopLIe IIpOflBJIfI-
JIIICb ne TOJIblW B BLIoope CIOmeTOB, no
H B CTHJIIlCTIIHe ll306pameHIlB::.
lIpHMe'laTeJTbHO, 'ITO II B ]J.oIIIeAIIIHX
AO Hac OTpLIBHax CKllcpCHoro 3IIoca flB-
CTBeHHO rrpCB<lJIllPyeT BoeHHo-apHCTO-
KpaTH'IeCKOe na'laJIo. ,ZJ;OCTaTO'lHO Ha-
rrOMIIHTb paCCKa3bI TOHcapllca H3 O]l.HO-
IIMeHHOB: HOBeJIJIbI JIYKllaHa, flBIiO BOC-
XO]J.flIII,lle H CHHcpCHIlM IIpeAaHHflM, HJIH
CO]l.epmaIIl,eeCfI Y fepoAoTa rroBecTBoBa-
HIle 0 BOHIiC C ,ZJ;apHeM, BblAepmaHHoc
BIIOJTHe B ]l.yxe 3rrH'IeCHOH Tpa]l.HII.HIl.
,ZJ;ame B 3TlIoroHHtJecHoH JIereHAe, OCO-
oeHHo B «3JIJIHIICIWH) BepcllH, BoeHHoc
lIa'la.1JO IIPHCYTcTByeT yme B crroc06e
llCIIrITaIIllfl 6paTbeB. lIepBafl ee Bep-
CHfI,.J rro fepO]l.OTY, c06cTBeHHo CHHcp-
cKaK, KaK cTpeMH.1JCfI IIOHa3aTb 0AHH 113
aBTopOB 3TOH CTaTbH, OcpopMHJIaCb B
cpe]l.e II.apCHIlX CKHcpOB, 3aHHMaBIIIHX
rOCIIOACTBYIOIII,ce BoeHHO-IIOJIHTH'IeCHOC
rrOJIOmeHHe B CHHcpCKOM 06II1,eCTBe 8.
42
TaHHM 06pa30M, 3BepllHLIH CTHJIb H
CHlIcpCHoe IlCHYCCTBO Bo06II1,e B CBOHX
3CTeTH'IeCHHX IIpHHII.IlIIaX OTpamaIOT
BIIOJIHe OIIpe]J.eJIeHHLIe II.eHHOCTHLIe OPH-
eHTaIl.HH CHHcpCHOro 06II1,eCTBa, B HO-
He'lHOM C'IeTe OIIpeAeJIflBIIIlleCfI ypOB-
Re)I ero COIl.llaJIbHoro pa3BIl'llfl.
CKBCPLI, B AaHHOM cJIY'lae He 6b1JIIl
'IeM-TO H3 pfl]J.a BOH BLIXO]J.flIII,IlM. HaII-
pHMep, Y CHaHAHHaBOB B HOHII.e VI I 1-
Ha'laJIe IX B., B Ha'laJIe 3IIOXII BIlKHH-
roB - BpeMeHIl B CTaJl.llaJIbHOM OTHOIIIe-
HHIf cpaBHIlMOM C 3IIOXOB:: IIepe]I.HeBO-
CTO'lHLIX IIOXOAOB Y CKllcpOB, Tome 6LI-
npo B03HHHaIOT HOBLIe BIl]J.bI IlCHYCCT-
Ba - II033HfI CHaJIbp;OB II opHaMeHTaJIb-
HO-H306pa3HTeJIbHLIH CTIlJIb, B HOTOpOM,
KCTaTH, rocIIoACTBYIOIII,IlM MOTIlBOM 6LI-
:10 1I306pameHHe mIlBoTHLIX, OTJIIl'laB e -
meecfI :mcrrpeCCIleB:: II JI.IlnaMIl3MOM .
I10]l.061Ible rrapaJIJIeJIIl, IIpH'IeM IIHOr-
]l.a He TOJIbHO CTaJl.llaJIbHLIe, OTHIOAb He
IlC'IepIIblBaIOTCfI 1l306pa3HTeJIbHLIM IlC-
KYCCTBOM. fJIfI]J.fI Ha 1l3BeCTHble 11306-
pamellHR OpJIOB Ha IIOflCHblX 6JIflxax ll3
MeJlbrynoBCKoro HypraHa HJIIl 60JIee
n03)\IIHe - H3 iKypOBHIl H 30JIOTOrO
KypraHa 10, Ha IIaMflTb IIpHxoAllT OIIIl-
caRlle XllIIl,HOB:: IITIlIl.LI BapraH - 0AHO-
ro 113 nepeBOIIJIOIIl,eHHH BepTparHLI B
AneCTe:
"XeamlOufeu cltuay 806b1'lY I>OZrRMU,
li'<IOIOIIle" ee ceepxy,
Ha ecex nrutf 6b crpeUUl.eu,
llpoeoplleUUl.eu 113 .A.eraIOUfux» It.
130 II:J6CmaHHe B03MomHoro He]J.OIIO-
HIIMaHHH OroBOpIlMCfI, 'ITO B AaHHOM
CI\"laC Mbl HMeeM B BHAY TOJIbRO
x \';lomrCTBeHHO-CTIlJIHCTUQCCHJlII rra-
p;l:ue,lI1:JM. I1pflMoe OTom)J,eCTBJIeHHe
1,011 I,PCTHbIX IIepcorrameii ABCCTbl C 06-
pa:I<lMII :mcpIIlloro CTl!.lH B {CTO]l.OJIO-
fll'ICClWM OTHOIIICHIIII rrpe;J;cTan.'1f1eTCH
IIcnpnCM.'1eMblM, TaH HaH 0 CKIlcpCKOH
I'e:11I1'I111 ]!.1BeCTHO CJIIlIIIHOM Ma.'lO.
II [Ji1IHI.lhrrOe rrOHHMaHHe COIl.IlaJTbHOH
ClIP :lhl nrrpe]l.eJIflBIIIeH ceMallTH'IeCHlle
n xYAomeCTBemlble OCIIOBLI CKIICPCHoro
IlCHYCCTBa, flBJIfleTCfI CPyrrAaMeliToM ]l.JIJI
peIIIeHHfI MHomx BOIIpOCOB ero HCTO-
pllH. C 3TIlX II03HII.HH, HarrpIIMep, CJIe-
]J.yeT IIOAXOJI)ITb H IIp06JIeMe UpOHcxom-
)J;eHllfl, IlJIIl TO'lHee, cpOpMHpoBaHIlH
CHHcpcHoro 3BepllHoro CTIlJIfI.
CKHcpCHIlH 3BepHHLIll CTH.lb, ITa HaIII
JiarJIflA. B CBoeH OCHOBe flBHJICfI HOBO'
06pa30BaHlleM, HaH HOBo06pa30BaHHeM
6LIJIa BCfI CKHcpCHafl HYJIbTypa, a B 1'13-
JieCTHOB:: Mepe II IlAeOJIOrnfi - H]l.eOJIO-
rnfl HO'leBHIlHOB, B OOIIl,eCTBe HOTOpLIX
pa3BIIBaJIHCb IIpOIl.eCCLI HJIacco06pa30-
BaHHfI, Y KOTOpLIX HHAIlBIlA BIIepBLIe
Ha'laJI npOTIlBOIIOCTaBJIflTb ceOH 06-
III,eCTBY.
fOBOpH 0 HOBo06pa30BaHIIH, (bl OT-
HIOAb He XOTIlM IIpHYMeHbIIJaTb pOJIb
IIepCAHeaallaTCHoro HCHYCCTBa B pom-
AeHT1ll CHllcpCHoro 3BepHHoro CTHJIfi. Ho
eCJIIl Te ROITHpeTHLIe 06pa3b1, KOTOpJ.Ie
CHHCPLI, B03MomHO, 3aHMCTROnaJIII Ha
lIepe]l.HeM BOCTOHe OLIJIII. no Y]l.a'lIlO-
MY BLIpameHllIO B. f. JIYKUJIIlJla. «II.Il-
TaTaM,H» 12, TO caM TeKCT, TO CCTb CI'HCP-.
CRHB:: 3BepHHLIH CTIIJlb, Ubl:1 C03AaH
CHHcpaMH II flBJIfiJICH OTpamClllleM HO-
BLIX nOTpe6HOCTeH CHHcpCKoro, a lie JIIO-
60ro ll3 IIepe]l.IIea3IlaTCKIIX 061J eCTB.
3TIl II.IlTaTLI 6J.IJIII He TOJIbl>G BbipBaHLI
H3 'IymAoro HorrTcKcTa, 110 It I1CpeBe]l.e-
HLI Ha APyroH fl3blK.
BepHeMcfI H cOunaJlbHOii OCIIOB
CHllcpcHoro HCHyccTBa. Ma.lo CKa3<1Tb,
'ITO 3BCpllHLIll CTHJTb KaK 0;1.110 113 r:laB:
HLIX AOIIIeAIIIHX AO Hac ero npoHB.leIlllH
CBfl3all C BOllRCKOll cpe;1.oJI. O'lcrrh Bail{-
HO BbUleJIlITb Te COlUla':lbHI,II' rp 'rrIlbl,
HOTOpbIe flB:1H:mCb OCHOHIIJ,I\I!I I10Tpe-
6HTeJTH m npe)J.MeTuB. Bbllll):lIICII I1blX
B 3BcpnrroM CTH;ll'. a IJ PiI.l'> (':I "laeB II
rrpHMblMII 3al,a3'1 I1Ha llI.
Be]l.YIII,aH pMIb B co:mHIIIIII upnrH-
HaJIbllblX CIO,ReTOil II o6pa:wl\ 3BepltllO-
ro CTIIJTH ]l.O.lmrra ObIT" CRIJ:I,lIJa C apll
CTOI<paTHeii:. Bo-rrcpBblX. 11\11'11110. II 60-
raTeJIIIIIIX IIorpe6crrnHx Tlina ne:lep-
43
MeCCKII:. II Y JIbCKHX KypraHoB BCTpeqe-
HbI HaIIOOJIee COBepmeHHbIe B xy.n;ome-
CTBeHHOM OTHOllleHIIH rrpOH3Be.n;eHHH
3BeplIHoro CTHJIH, K TOMY me He B e.n;H-
HllqHbIX aK3eMrrJIHpaX, a B 60JIbmOM KO-
JI qeCTBe pa3Ho06pa3HbIX ClOmeTOB H
o pa30B. MHorHe H3 HIIX rrOCJIymHJIH
06pa3I1,a m .n;.TIH rrOCJIeA)'lOm;ero RorrH-
pOBaHIIH II rro.n;pamaHIIH B 60JIee mHpo-
KHX CJIOHX 06m;eCTBa. 06m;eH3BeCTHa
pOJIb, KOTOPYIO CbIrpaJIH rrepBOHa qaJIb-
HbIe II300pameHHH OHeHH HJIH rraHTepbI
II3 uYHa3aHHbIX rraMHTHHKOB .n;JIH .n;aJIb-
HellIIIero pacrrpOCTpaHeHHH H rrorrYJIH-
pll3aIl.Hil B CKH<PHH 3THX ClOmeToB. Ho
Oc06eHHO HarJIHMo B pOJIH ;naJIOHOB
BblcTyrralOT !HOrOqHCJIeHHbIe ROCTH-
HbIe rrpC;:(MeTbI KOHCKOB: C6PYH C H306-
pamellllHMII rOJIOBOK 6apaHOB H rpH-
tPo H o-6apaHOB, Heo.n;HOKpaTHO rrOBTO-
peHHbIe 3aTeM C rrOCTerreHHOB: YTpaTOB:
xy.n;omeCTBeHHbIX lI;OCTOHHCTB Ha rrca-
JIHHX JIeCOCTerrHOR Y KpaHHbI.
BO-BTOPbIX, 3HaqHTeJIbHaH qaCTb Tex
IIIe.n;eBpOB 113 60raTbIX KypraHoB, ROTO-
pbIe CJrymIIJIll 06pa3I1.aMll, 6bIJIa H3ro-
OBJIeI!a Il3 30JIOTa - MeTaJIJIa, B CKOJIb-
\0-HIl6y.n;b 6oJIbmOM KOJIHqeCTBe .n;o-
cTyrrHoro JIllmb orpaHHqeHHOMY Kpyry
JIUII.. TeM rrpHMeqaTeJIbHee q TO
C ' H B
paIJHIITC.,bHO He60raTbIX KypraHax MbI
BCTpeqaeM IIHor.n;a OT.n;eJIbHbIe He60JIb-
II1e H3!.\eJIIIH lla 30JIOTa, YRpameHHbIe
. 3BepllrrOM CTHJIe. OqeBHMO, rro.n;pa-
aBHe. apl!CTOKpaTHH B orrpe.n;eJIeHHbIX
Kpyrax pacrrpOCTpaHHJIOCb He TOJIbRO
Ha 1!300pameHHe, HO H Ha MaTepHaJI.
B-TPPTbllX 06pam;aeT Ha ce6H BHll-
MaBIle rrapa.n;HbIii: xapaKTep MHornx
npeLlMeTOB, BbIIIOJIHeHHbIX B 3BepHHOM
CTIIJle. T O.TIbKO B 60raTbIX KypraHax
B TpeqaIDTCH MeqH B 30JIOTbIX HomHax
OOJIOmeUHbIe 30JIOTbIMH rrJIaCTHHaMH ro
pllTbI II ),o.TITIaHbI, rrapa.n;HbIe rroHca H T
Bce 310, u 1,0HeqHO, He CJIyqaRHO. Be'.n;
3BeplllIbIiI CTllJIb B03HHK IIMeHHO Tor.n;a
Iwrua. BhI.n;eJIIIBmaHCH CKH<pCKaH 3HaTb'
KaK Bcer::r:a II nclOA)' B arroxy KJIacco06
pa30BaHHH, CTpeMHJIaCb rro.n;qepKHYTb
CBOIO 060c06JIeHHOCTb OT OCTaJIbHoro 06-
m;eCTBa BceMH cpe.n;cTBaMII B TO
, M qHC-
JIe H H.n;eOJIOrnqeCRHMH. J1MeHHO B aT
rroxy BbIpa6aTbIBa1OTCH BHeIIIHHe aTpi-
YTbI BJIaCTH - Oc06bIe Y K p am e
rrpHqeC HHH,
KH, o.n;em.n;bI, B03HHKaeT OC06bIB:
pHTyaJI rrOBe.n;eHHH rro OTHOIIIeHlI1O K
P HOCHTueJIHM. Y CRH<pOB, B03MomHO 3
HHbIll CTHJIb iBblrrOJIHHJI rr '
<PYHKII,HH. TaKHe
MbI CTpeMHJIHCb rrOKa3aTb qTO HBJI n
HCb rr e ' 11-
P HMym;ecTBeHHO apHCTOKpaTlI'Ie-
CKHM, 3BepHHbIB: CTHJIb rrpOHIIKaJI, O.n;Ha-
KO, H B 60JIee mHpORHe CJIOH 06m;eCTBa
O.n;Ha H3 rrpllqHH aTOrO HBJIeHHH, rrO-BH
MOMY, aaKJIlOqaJIaCb B TOM, qTO rrpo-
CCbI KJIacco06pa30BaHHH B CKll<pCKmr
o m;eC.:rBe, BO BCHROM CJIyqae B apXaI;-
qeCRHll rre p llO" errr 6
IT M, ......e He bIJIll 3aBepme-
bI. I-\pyraH,- qTO 3BepllHOMY CTHJIIO
bIJIa rrpHcym;a em;e o.n;Ha CTopOHa - pe-
JIHrHOaHaH, B 3HaqHTeJIbHOR CT6UeHH
e HaH .n;JIH Bcero 06m;eCTBa.
r BOPH 0 peJIHrn03Ho r acrreKTe
CKH,*,CKoro llCKYCCTBa, Mbl XOTHM cpa3Y
me rro.n;qepKHYTb, qTO He rrpn.n;aeM pe-
JIHr u H03HbIM rrpe.n;CTaBJIerrllHM pemalO-
m;ell pOJIH Hll B CJIOmeHUll 3BepHHoro
CTHJIH KuaK II.eJIOCTHon: CUCTeMhI, Hll B ero
.n;aJIbHellIIIeM P a3BHTHll Ha
fl, KOrreIl"
HCqe3HOBeHHll. B TO me BpeMH peJIll-
rH03HaH CTopOHa 6bIJIa H3HaqaJIbHO
rrpHcym;a 3BepllHOMY CTllJIIO yme rro-
CTOJIbKY, rrOCKOJIbKY OHa HBJIHJIaCb
HeOT'beMJIeMOII qaCTblO MHpoB033peHHH
BapBapCKoro OOm;eCTBa B .TIID6bIX ern
rrpOHBJIeHIIHX 13. J1CXO)J,H 113 ,noro rrpHH-
II,Hrra MbI II rro.n;xo M K pacOIOTpeHlllO
BoaMomH IX rrpOHBJIeHIIR pe.1IIrll03HbIX
B033peHlln CKHcpCKoro 0611IeCTBa B ero
HC CCTBe.
aIIIen: .TIHTepaType 113BCCTlIoe pac-
npo TpaHeHlle rroJIyqlIJIO 'I I!CIIlle 0
rrepemHTKax TOTeMll3Ma I<al, OCHOBe
CRH<pCKOro 3BepllHoro CTII!lII'" Oco60e
::HMaHlle B 3T0B: CBH311 YiJ.e.,HeTCH e.n;-
JIH He caMOMY rrorrYJIHpIJO I ' 06pa3Y
44
II CKHCPCKOM, cpe.n;Hea3HaTcKoM H CH6HP-
GKOM 3BepHHOM CTIIJI - 06pa3Y OJIe-
gH. CJIOBO «caKa», HBJIHBmeeCH caMO-
ga3BaHIIeM !HOrHX po.n;cTBeHHblx CKH-
tfJaM rrJIeMeH KOqeBHHKOB, rro MHeHHIO
B. A. A6aeBa, TaRme 03HaqaeT «OJIeHb»,
H KaK COCTaBHaH qaCTb OHO BXO.n;HT
BO MHorHe CKH<pCRHe HMeHa I'. lloa-
TOMY CqHTaeTCH, qTO OJIeHb, CHMBO-
JlHaHpYIO B: cRH<poB, HBJUIJICH B
npomJIOM HX TOTeMOM.
IIo cym;ecTBY, aTO e HCTBeHHoe KOH-
KpeTHoe .n;OKaaaTeJIbCTBO, ROTopoe MbI
gaxo.n;IlM y CTOpOHHHROB TOTeMHCTHqe-
CKOft TeopHlI, B OCTaJIbHOM 6aaHpylO-
m;eftcH Ha YM03pHTeJIbHbIX paccym.n;e-
gHHX 0 .n;JIHTeJIbHOCTH H mHByqecTH TO-
TeMH3Ma H 0 HerrpeMeHHOB: CBH3H C HHM
.TII06bIX aHHMaJIHCTHqeCKHX HarrpaBJIe-
HIIR B HCKYCCTBe .n;ORJIaCCOBhIX 06m;eCTB.
Ho TOTeMH3M RaR II,eJIOCTHaH CHCTeMa
peJIllrn03HbIx BepoBaHHii xapaKTepeH
JIHmb .n;JIH paHHHX aTarrOB paaBHTHH qe-
JIOBeqeCTBa. CRH<pbI me lI;aBHO HX MIIHO-
BaJIH. IIoaToMY B JIY'lmeM CJIyqae Mom-
HO TOBOp<HTb 06 OT aJIeHHbIX rrepemHT-
Kax TOTeMHaMa, H TO CKopee Bcero B re-
geTHqeCROM mIaHe, rrepemHTKax,
rrepBOHaqaJIbHOe aHaqeHHe KOTOpbIX
6bIJIO .n;aBHO rrepeOCMbICJIeHO II 3a-
6bITO 16.
TOTeMHqeCRaH TeopHH He B COCTOH-
HHII 06'bHCHHTb cBoe06pa3He 3BepHHoro
CTHJIH, ero no.n;qepKlIYToe BHHMaHHe
JIHmb K OT.n;eJIbHbIM qaCTHM TeJIa, ero
CTpeMJIeHHe YTpHpOBaTb HX H YCllJIIITb,
.n;orrOJIHHTb lI;pyrHMH, HaKOHeIl" .n;ame
oT60p npe.n;MeTOB, KOTopbIe 60JIbIIIe
.n;PyrHx YKpamaJIHCb B 3BepHHOM CTll-
JIe - opymHH H c6py:n 60eBoro KOHlI,
TO eCTb rrpelI;MeTOB, mll3HeHHO BamHblx
lI;JIH CRH<pOB B 6010.
B xapaKTepe pacrrpOCTpaHeHHH OT-
lI;eJIbHblX MOTHBOB 3BepHHoro CTHJIH
TaIURe HeT HHKaRHx YKa3aHIIB: Ha CBH3b
C TOTeMHqeCRHMH rrpe.n;cTaBJIeHIIHMIl.
B JII060M JIORaJIbHOM paB:OHe CKllIimll
MbI BCTpeqaeM rrpaRTH'IeCKll O H II TOT
me Ha60p 06pa30B. MMelOIII,HeCH me
oc06eHHOC,TII (HarrpHMep, 60JIee IlUIpO-
Koe pacrrpocTpaHeHHe H306pameHHB: JIO-
CH II Me.n;Be)J,H B JIecocTerrHOB: CKH<p HH
HJIU 6bJCTpOe HCqeaHOBeHHe a.n;eCb 06pa-
aa ropHoro KOaJIa) 06'bHCHHIOTCH CKopee
reorpacplIen: pacrrpocTpaHeHHH Tex HJlH
IIHbIX mIIBOTHbIX. II pHMeqa TeJIbHO, qTO
II B OT.n;eJIbHhIX KypraHax H MOrHJlbHH-
Kax, KOTopbIe rrpe.n;rrOJlOmHTeJlbHO Mom-
HO CBH3bIBaTb C ceMeRHo-polI;CTBeHHbI-
Mil rpyrrrrnpoBKaMH, Hen03MomHO OTMe-
TIlTb qeTlW BblpameHHoe rrpe]J.IIOqTeHHe
KaKOMY-JIH60 O)J,H0MY ClOmeTY. HaRo-
HeIl" Ha.n;o HarrOMHHTb, qTO 3THMOJIOrIIH
CJIOBa «caKa» .n;aJIeKO em;e He BbIHCHe-
Ha, a rrpe.n;JlOmeHHaH B. M. A6aeBbIM
TpaKTOBKa He HBJIHeTCH 06m;errpHaHaH-
HOn: cpe upaHHCTOB 17.
Ha Ham B3rJlH.n;, rrpHBepmeHHoc'Tb
CKHcpOB Ha06pameHHHM mHBOT:abIX
Bo06m;e, paBHo RaR HX npRCTpacTHe
JIHmb K orrpelI;eJIeHHblM MOTHBaM, aHa-
qllTeJIbHO JIel"Ie 06'bHCHHTb TeM, qTO
3BepllHbIR CTHJlb HMeeT B CBOeB: OCHO-
Be He TOTeMHqeCKHe, a MarHqeCKHe
rrpe.n;CTaBJIeHHH. 3TO yme .n;OBOJIbHO
.n;aBHo rrpe.n;rroJIaraJlOCb HeKOTopHMlI
llCCJIe.n;oBaTeJIHMH \8.
Xopomo HaBecTHo, qTO corJIaCHO
rrpaBHJIaM MarllH, H306pameHHe orrpe-
.n;eJleHHbIX mHBOTm>IX HJIH OTlI;eJlbHbIX
qaCTeR llX TeJla crroc06cTByeT rrepeHe-
CeHII.IO Ha 06JIa.n;aTeJIeii: TaKHX H306pa-
meHllii rrpHcym;Hx aTHM mHBOTHbIM
qepT 19. Bce aTO H xapaKTepHo JI,JlH
CKllcpcKorn 3BepHHoro CTHJIH, ClOmeTbI
KOTOpOro rroqTH Bcer.n;a oTpamaIOT
IInCaJI BOIIHa. 300MOp<pHbIe rrpeBpam;e-
HUll .n;OJImHbI 6bIJIH eIIl,e 60JIee ycn.-
.TIIITb MarH'IeCRHe qepTbI, 3aJIOmeHHbIe
B rrepBOHaqaJIbHOM 06pa3e. TaKoe
CTpeMJIeHHe YBeJIHqllTb ero a<p<peKTHB-
nOCTb yiKe caMO no ce6e rrORa3bIBaeT,
"HK pacrrpocTpaHeHa 6bIJIa Bepa B ox-
p" IIIITeJIbHbIe CHJIbI 3BepHHoro CTHJlH.
Bo:nromHo, aTO B CBOIO Oqepe.n;b crro-
C06CTBOBaJIO 6bICTpOR rr06elI;e B HeM
45
apHa eHTaJIH3Ma H cxeMaTH3Ma. AmI
I\c,1:eu MaDIii BIlaJIHe AaCTaTaqHa 3a-
MeHHTb I\eJIbHbIH H peaJIHCTHqHbIH 0.6-
pa3 ero YCJIaBHaH cxeMaH.
TpYAHee Bcera pemHTb, HaCKaJIbKa
a6pa3bI 3BeplIHara CTHJIfI CBfl3aHbI
1'?IIR p eTlIbnm 6o.mecTBa?UI cRH<P<;Rar
IlaHTOOlIa lIJIII rrpeACTaBJIflBIl1HXCfI 60.-
meCTBeHHbIMlI KOCMHqecRIIMH CIlJIaMII
Tm,ylO Ba3 !OmHOCTb rrpeArra.TIaraeT pfld
HOCJIeAaBaTeJIeB: 2., H lIaM TaKme aHa
KameTCfI BrraJIHe BepaflTHan:. OAHaJ\a
!bI CKJIaHfleMCfI K T aM Y """' 6
, ' uv bI Aarry-
CIWTb CKopee rraJIHCeMaHTillqec v "
P aK "HU xa-
-rep <lTall CBfl31II, q M aAH03HaqHYIO
3aBHCHMaCTb.
B TT U
"aHHaH CBfl3H HaM XaTeJIaCb 6bI
CHaBa a6paTHTb BHHMaHn.e Ha fI
Ba3MamHbIX rrapaJIJIeJIeH H aHaJIa t
caAepma llxCfI B ABeCTe. JbBeCTHa'
HaIIpHMe p qT A '
(<p ) ' a, rra BecTe, xBapH
apH - HeKae 6amecTBa, HHcxa-
AfI ee Ha TTa pe U
...., H, mpeI\aB H re p aeB
CIIMBaJIH31l py IO e '
e I\apCTBeHHaCTb
BeJIHqHe H Mary ec,TBa, crraca6Ha rrpn.:
HMaTb a6J1J!K pa3JIHqHbIX mHBaTHbIX
aK, B HUlTe (19, 68) rrpo XBapH ra
BapHTcfI, qTa «HAeT... B a6JIHKe KaHfI
HAeT B a6JIIlKe Bep6JIIOAa HTTCT n a 6
JIHKe M y m 21 B ' "
a). APyrHx MeCTax
XBapH BbIcTyrraeT B a6JIHKe a p JIa H
Ka3JIa.
B TO. me BpeMfI BamHa IIaAqepKHYTb
6 qTa rraHflTRe a XBapHe - (<He6eCHaa
JIaroAaTH» - 6
nMeeT a eHpaHc,Kae
rrpaHcxamAeHHe. B qaCTHacTH
HMeJIaCb . '" ' aHa
Y CRIl'i'aB, a qeM CBHAeTeJIb-
CTB eT Ha.TJlI'Ille MHaIaqnCJIeHHbIX
CKH'i'a-CapMaTCKnx HMeH BRJIlOqaB-
Il1IIX B ce6 ",'
fI CJIaBa 'i'apH HarrpIHlep
n. !fI n;apfl CaiiTa<papH 22.' .,
TIa3TaM Y eTTB a 6
" JIH YAeT CJIH IIII ' aM
CMeJIbIM ' ,
. rrpe]J.rrOJIameHne, qTa y CRn-
<paB mlllJaTRbIe (rrpHTaM pa3JIII'IHbIe)
a pa3bI KaTDpblX rrpeACTaBJIeHbI B 3Be
p HaM CTnJIe, IOrJIH HaXa]J.HThCfI B
CBfl31l C u rrpe CTaBJIeHnflMH a 6DmE'-
CTBeHHaII 6JIara TT aTH He .
". HCKTJlOqeHD.
qTa cpaBHHTeJIblia Il1l!paRae pacrrpa-
cTpaHCIUI.e a6pa3a 6apaHa B apXaHqe-
CRaM cmeplIHaM CTHJIe, HeCRaJIbI{Q BbI-
rraAalO ee H3 TeHAeHI\HH aT6apa mH-
BaTHbIX, TaI\me CJIeAyeT a6'LflCHflTL.
HaJI qHeM B CKH<pHH rrpeACTaBJIeHHK
a <papHe. HaR rraKa3a:I B · JI
. . :1c. IITBHH-
5 KIIlI , 6apaH Y npaHCKIIX HapaAOB:
abIJI a]J.HIIM R3 ero BarrJIa eHHll: 23
A fI AB CTbI H Aame 6aJIee rra3 HIlX
3apaaCTpIIIIChIIX rraMflTHIIRaB _
0.6 e Ba
ru. xapaKTepHa BarrJIa eHHe
rrpeACTaBJIeHHlJX B HHX 6amecTB B 0.6-
pa3ax mlfBaTHbIx, rr p HqeM C U
CTa ' aAHaa
paHbI, aAHa H TO. me 60mecTBa Barr-
.'Ia aeTc B pa3JIHqHbIX mHBaTHbIx, It.
C APyroll - mHBaTHbIe aAHaro H Taro.
me BHAa MarYT CJIymllTb AJIfI BarrJIa-
eHHfI pa3.1:IIqHbIX 6ameCTB. HarrpH-
Mep, BepTparna - 6ameCTBa rra6e]l.bI
rrepeBaIIJIDII(aeTCfI B 6eJIara KaHfI Ka'
6aHa, XIlru;HYIO rrTHTT Y H T TT B ' -
B 6 ...., ...... TO. me
peMfI eJIblI! KaHb, HapflJI.Y C rrpeKpac-
HbIM nflT!IaAD;aTHJIeTHHM IOHameB:
3JIaTapal'II:M ObIKaM, flBJIHeTCfI aAHH=
H3 rrepCBan.TJ eHnH CBepKalO eH
3Be3AbI TIIIIITpUfI. Ana.1:arHqHaC flBJIe-
Hne aTMe 1 raeTCfI HOCJIeAaBaTeJIflMH II
A.1: PUI'BC;.\bI, rraMflTHHKa, Aa H3BeCT-
Han CTerreHII aTpamalO ero a6 He
IlHADIIpaHChIIe IIpeACTaBJIeHHfI ".
TIa-BH]J.II !OMY, HeqTa rraAa6Hae HMe-
_1:0. MeCTa II Y CKH"' aB H e v
'i" "aTapbIM
rroATBepm;wHIIeM 3TaMY CJIymHT BbI-
]J.e.TJeHHafl R · U JI U
. :1.. J'1 bnHCKaH rpVIIrra
rrpeAMeTaB ;mE'pIIHara CTHJIfI a TMe '
HbI . , qeH-
x p :j]IIJ.:HbIMII BapIIaHTaMH 3naRa,
I\OTapbll! DIJI,lqHD CBfl3bIBalOT C Ca.TJfI _
I!bI III "V.1:bTi! \!I I 25 O TT HIIM P
. . ." H reM me
10 CymCCTB\ ca.lHpHbIM 3HaKaM aTMC-
IeRbI lI:wfipameHIIH pa:3.TJHqHbIX mlf-
BaTIIbr: a."II'HR, XIl HIIKa, apJIa, JIa-
Ula lI: }'aplj(Jro Ra3JIa. )];JIH Hac B AaH-
!TOil Hln H;lmHa rra.:IqepKIIYTb, QTO
pa3.11!'lFIhlC' ;I:irBOTHble flBJIfllOTCfI Ban-
.TJalI\eHrrp r (':!IIDrD H Taro me KymTa.
, B TO. ; ,(' H pt'\1H Ha6JII01l'aeTCfI n 0.6-
paTHair hi! pn! na. Ha H3BeCTHaM 6pDn-
46
3aBaM HilBepIl1HIl H3 )];HcnpaneTpaB-
cKai'! aOJIacTIi, rro. rrpaBAana]J.aouuMY
upe]J.naJIameHHIO B.' H. fpaKaBa 26,
u3a6pameH llarran. Bar H3a6pameH n
oKpymeHHIl rrapfl Hx apJIaB, KaTapble
TeM caMbIM rrpeAcTalOT rrepeA HaMH B
lIaBaM Bll]J.e: yme He B KaqeCTBe Barr-
;Iaro;eHHfI CaJIflpHaro KYJIbTa, a KaK
aTp1l6YT BepxaBHaro Mymcharo 6ame-
CTBa. TaKaH TpaKTaBKa a6pa3a rra]l.-
TBepm]J.aeTCfI rraflBJIeHIIeM Tex me ap-
JIaB K TaMY me 6JIH3K1lX B CTIIJIIICTH-
,
'1eCKaM aTHameHHII, HD yme De3
llarrafl, Ha ilHaJIarnQHDM 6paH3aBaM
lIaBepIl1HII H3 AJIeRCaHAparraJIb-
CKara Ryprana 27. Ha apJlI!HbIe rOJIaB-
I'll H3DopameHbI TaKJ£e Ha apHaMeH-
TaJIbHaH KaMrra3H HIl Ha a6HBKe
AepeBHHHarD caCYAa 113 KypraHa Hapa-
ra]J.eyaIl1X 28, B ceMaHTIIQeCI;DM aTHa-
Il1eHIlH, DqeBHAHD, 6JIIl3Kall K ]l.peBY
mH3HH, KaTDpae flBJIflJIaCb CIIMBaJIaM
meHcKDro 6amecTBa. TaT me ClOmeT
Ha rrJIaCTRHhe H3 IKYPDBJ;ll 29 TpaKTa-
BaH B BII]l.e c,THJIH3aBaHHbIX par DB aJIe-
HH. TaKHM D6pa3aM, H D.leHb BblCTY-
naeT He TOJIbKa B CDJIHpIlDM, Ha H B
UHbIX I,YJIbTax.
Eru.e DAHH rrpllMep. Ha 3aJIaTaM Ha-
JI06HHRe H3 qH.M6a_1:DBDii }lOrHJIbI 3.
3MeeHarafl 6arnHH II3a6paaWHa BMeCTe
C DPJIHHD- H JIbBHHaraJIDBblMH rpH<P DHa -
MH, TaqHee C IlX roJIDBa\lli. B TO. me
BpeMH Ha ]J.pyroM 3aJIDTa}1 HaJIa6HHKe,
113 KYprana 1 y c. Bo.maHllbI rpH<p aHbI
1l3a6pameHbI B a;J.Hall J;aMna3HI\IIH C
MymcKIIM 6apD[\aTblM ()DJ£eCTBaM 31.
TpYAHa AaTb a6'hflCHeIIl!H BceM nIDI
HBJIeHHflM, HC 1l'alIYCl\aH, 'I TO. D]J.HIl II
Te me mllBaTHbIe CJIYmII:11I )lJIfI aJIHI\e-
TBapeHIIfI pa3JIn.QHbIX 6mhl'CTB.
llaJllICe}1 aHT nqIIDCTb pc.TJUrna3HDII
CTDpDHbI 3BepllHara CTU:I fI \lOrJIa BbI-
CTYIlaTb Tal\me B \1 II II I'U:iHa'iHaCTII
era <pYHK IIaHa:1 hHOii "" I PY31;11. ECJIII
CY1l'IlTb rra ABeCTe, IJa !HTHnKY, B Ka-
TapaM B KaIWH-Ta CTl'lJCHII aTpa31l-
JIHCb a6 eHpaHCIml' I\l'pOBaHIIfI, TO.
mIIBaTIIbIe BblcTynaJIH H ItaK urraCTaCIl
pa3JIIlQIlblX 6ameCTB, II KaK HX aTpu6y-
TbI (crrYTHHKl!:), H KaK caMDCTDHTeJIb-
HbIe rrepcaHamH.
CJIeAyeT HMeTb B BlLJI.Y TO. BamHDe, Ha
qaCTa yrrycKaeMDe H3 BII]l.y a6CTaflTeJIb-
CTBa, qTa CKII<pbI 6bIJIIl IlpaH ilMH He
TaJIbKa no. fl3b1KY, Ha II rrD arrpeAeJIeH-
HaB: KYJIbTYPHa-IlCTapHqeCKDi! Tpa-
]J.l'!I\HH. HaCJIeAHe 3TaH TpaAIln;IlH, yxa-
]J.flru.eB: CBaHMH KapHflMH Ba BpeMeHa
HpaHCKaB: n. e e rJIy6me - IlHAa-llpaH-
CKaB: D6ru.HaCTlf, flBCTBeHHa alI\Y aJIOCb
Aame Ba BpeMeHa fepaADTa (pa3HDBu]J.-
HaCTb KYJIbTa xaaMbI-caMbI, rrpe]l.CTan-
JIeHlIH a <papHe, rrpeAaHHe 0.6 yrraBlIIl1X
C He6a CBfI eHHblX ]l.apax 6amecTBeH-
Haro rrpDHcxDm]J.eHHH) . 3BepHHblii
CTIlJIb, HBJIeHHe 6DJIee rra3AHee, qeM
flApa peJIHrna3HD-MH<PoJIarHqec,KarD
KaMlIJIeKCa CKII<paB, KaK 6bI HaCJIaHJICfI
Ha rraCJIeJI.Hllll. OqeBHAHa, arrpeAeJIeH-
HDe BpeMfI rrpaHcxaAIlJI rrpa ecc (<IIaA-
raHKn,), H B aTaT rrepHaA peJIHrHa3Hafl
rraJIHCeMalITIIqHDCTb 06pa3DB 3BepH-
Hara CTIIJIfI KameTCfI HeH36emHaH.
Harne rraHHManHe peJIllrna3Hall: CTa-
paHbI, caAepmam,eii:cH B 3BepllHaM CTH-
JIe, BrraJIHe rrpHMeHlIMD II K C,KH<pCKDMY
3rracy, KOHKpeTHo, K 3THarDHHqeCKIlM
JIereH]J.aM. Be3YCJIaBHa rrpHcYTcTBYIO-
afl B HHX peJIUrHa3HaH CTDpaHa
He flBJIfleTCfI CaMDn;eJIblO, a CJIymHT
]J.JIfI ca3]J.aHHfI MaAeJIH Mllpa, aCMbICJIe-
HHfI II aCBH eHHfI racrraACTnYIO IlX B
HeM caIIIIa!lbHa-lIaJIHTnqCCRIIX DTHaIl1C-
HIIB:.
)];0. CIIX lIap MbI raBapIIJIn rrpeIIMYIIle-
CTBeHHa 0.6 apXallqeCKaM 3BepllHaM CTII-
JIe n IlPIICY H.X eMY ac06eHHDcTHX. 0[\-
HaI\O B V II aca6eHHD B IV - III BB. ]1.0.
H. 3. CKII<p<;i\De HCKYCCTBD BaD5 e "
3BepIIHblll CTHJIb B QaCTHaCTH rrpeTep-
neBalOT cy ecTBeHHbIe II3ME'HeHIIH.
aTpaJ£aBIIme BHYTpeHHIIe IlepeMeHbI B
CKH<pCKaM a6 eCTBe. HpaMe Taro. B
3BepHHDM CTHJIe, KaK H B [\pyrnx BII1l'ax
IlCRYCCTBa, YCHJIRBalOTCH BIIemHIIe -
47
rpCqeCKHe, <l>paKHHcKUe, aXeMelIHACKHe
H CapMaTCKHe BJIHR:lIWI, rrpHqeM aTH
BJIHR:HHR: rrpOR:BJIR:IDTCR: C pa3JIHqHOH
IlHTelICIlBHOCTbID Ha pa3JIIlqHbIX Tep-
pIlTOpWIX. ITo rrOHR:THbIM rrpHqHHaM B
J1;aHHOH CTa1'T,e MbI MOmeM OCTaHOBHTb-
CH TOJIbKO Ha CaMbIX CYII(eCTBelIHbIX, C
HaIllen TOqKH 3peHIlR:, MOMeHTaX.
HaH60JIee XapaKTepHOB: qepTOB: 3Be-
plllIoro CTHJIR: aT oro BpeMeHH R:BJIR:-
eTCR: YCHJIeHHe oplIaMeHTaJIH3an;HH
iI cxeMaTH3an;Hll, rrpIlBOAR:II(ee K yTpa-
Te Tex qepT YCJIOBHOrO H 0606II(eHHora
peaJIH3Ma, KOTopbIe 6bIJIll rrpHCY H eMY
B apXallqeCKHB: rrepHOA. HapR:AY C aTHM
rrOR:B.lIR:eTCR: 'IeTKo BbIpameHHoe HaTY-
paJIIlCTH'leCKoe HarrpaBJIeHHe, BO MHO-
rmI CBR:3aHHOe C BJIIlR:lIHeM KJIaCCHqe-
Clwro rpeqeCKOra HCKyCCTBa. ,l];JIR:
060RX 113 OTMeqelIHbIX HarrpaBJIeHHH
xa paKTeplIO paCIDHpelIlle Rpyra HCrrOJIb-
3yeMLIX 06pa30B.
B IV -III BB. AO H. 3. rrpOHCXOAR:T
If:3MeHeHIDI B cpeAe 6bITOBaHllR: rrpOH3-
BeAeHHll 3BepllHora CTHJIR:. IIpHMeqa-
Te.rlbHO, OAHaKO, 'ITo OHH HOCR:T JIOKaJIb-
!1bIll xapaKTep. B CTerrHOB: CKll<l>llll
OCHOBlIafl Macca rrpeAMeTOB 3BepHHoro
CTIlJIR: cocpeAOTOqelIa B IIorpe6emmx
BbICIllIlX CJIOeB 06 eCTBa, B rrepByID
O'IepeAI> - apHCTOKpaTII.n, B TO BpeMR:
RaK B MHOraqHCJIeHlIbIX rrorpe6eHHR:X
pR:AOBoro HaCeJIeHllR:, B TOM qHCJIe H B
TaKIlX, B KOTOpbIX BCTpeqeHO opymlle,
3BeplllIbIH CTHJIb rrOqTIl rrQ.1IHOCTbID OT-
CYTCTByeT. Ho B JIeCOCTerrH, rro cpaBHe-
BHID C rrpeAIlleCTBYIDrr IlM BpeMeHeM,
I!:JMeHelIIlH He BbIrJIR:AHT TaKHMH pe3-
I,II III.
13 IV - III BB. AO H. a. B CKH<I>HH
rYlI eCTBeHlIbIe 1l3MelJeHIlR: Ha6JIIDAa-
JTCH TalOKe B lIa60pe IIpeAMeTOB,
'l\pamelIHbIX B 3BepHHOM CTIlJIe, H
11\ IaTepllaJIe. CooTHomeHlle 30JIOTa H
fi pOH3bI 1l3MeHR:eTCR: B rro.TIb3Y 30JIOTa,
hUCTb Bo06II(e IlCqe3aeT. YBeJIHqHBa-
eTCH KO.'!llqeCTBO HamIIBHbIX 6JIR:IlleK II
Il:raCTIlH )VIR: YKpameHIIJI oAemAbI rr
rOJIOBlIOra y60pa, a OTlIOCHTe.'!blIoe qHe-
JIO rrpeAMeToB KOHCKOR C6pYH YMeHb'
IDaeTCR:. KpoMe Toro, rrpeAMeTbI 3Bepll-
Horo CTHJIR: 3HaqllTeJIbHO qaII(e, qeM
paHbIlle, BCTpe'IaIOTCH B rrorpe6eHIlR:X
3HaTHbIX meHII(HH. Bce 3TO cBIlAeTeJIb-
cTByeT 0 TOM, qTO B03paCTaeT rrapaAHo-
AeKopaTllBHaR: <l>YHKn;IIR: 3BepllHoro CTH-
JIR:, a era CBR:3b C qrrCTO BoeHHbIM 6LI-
TOM YMeHbIllaeTCR:.
TaKHM 06pa30M, B IV - III BB. AO
H. a., C OAlIOll CTOpOHbI, lIa6JIIDAaeTCJI
cymellHe TOR COn;lla.TIbHOB: cpeAbI, B
KOTOpOB: rrpoAOJImaeT 6bIToBaTb 3BepH-
HLIB: CTIlJIb, C APyrofI - H3MeHR:eTCR:
OTHOIlleHRe K HeMY CO CTOpOHbI era
TpaAHn;HOHHbIX rroTpe6IlTeJIeB:. ,l];ame y
HHX OH yme lIe R:BJIR:eTCR:, BepOR:THO,
AOMHlIIlPYID !!M BItAOM H306pa3H-
TeJIbHOro HCKYCCTB1\. PacTeT rrorryJIR:p-
HOCTb aHTporroMopqmblx 06pa30B H
cIDmeToB, lIe cocTaB:IHID IlX, oAHaKo,
eAHHoro CTHJIHCTIl'IeCIWrO HarrpaBJIe-
HllR:. PacrrpOCTpaHR:IDTCR: maHpoBbIe
'Cn;eHbi., OqeBHAHO, cBH3aHHbIe C repoH-
qeCKHM arrOCOM. YBemI'IHBaeTCR: BOC-
rrpHHMqHBOCTb K co6cTBeHHo rpeqeCKO-
MY HCKYCCTBY, CBR:3alJlIaR: C pacTy eH
3JIJIHHH3an;Hell CImcpCIWll 3HaTH. EII(e B
V B. AO H. 3. CKIl.l, rrOrrJIaTIlBIIIHB:CR:
mll3HbID 3a CBoe aJIJIImo<l>HJIbCTBO, 6bIJI
IlCKJIIDqelIlleM. Ho yme B IV B. AO H. a.
cpeJI,:I'I rrpH6JIIlmelInblx ATeR: HaIDJIHCh
TaKHe, KO"T'upble BbIpa;.naJIIl YAOBOJIbCT-
BHe no rroBoAY nrphl aaXBaqeHlIOrO B
rrJIeH 3HaMeHnToro rpetIeCKora <l>JIeB:-
TIlCTa HCMeHIlR:, H nCR.TIID'IelIlleM rrpn:
3TOM 6bI.'! cKopee caM n;apb, 3aR:BIlB-
IllIl.if, qTO rrpeAnOqiITaeT CJIymaTb pma-
lIne KOHH.
HMeHHO cpe;.\H nO;!OOHbIX .'llln;, Bepo-
R:THP, pacrrpOCTpa III):IIIC h ropIITbI co
Cn;e¥Mll II3 mIt3HIl A:x.n.rma, cepbm C
H30 ameHIleM /\(llnllbl ITaJIJIaAbI n:
MHoriIe Apyrne. '11100 rpeqeCKlle CID-
meTb!. Bo.-ree Il30111IH'lfEIOMY BKYCY Ta-
KIlX .1IOAeil II L\O.HHlIhl Obl.TIll OTBe'IaTE
lIOBbIe BeHlJllH B nO:::lIlPCKIt<l>CKOM 3Be-
48
HHOM CTHJIe, pa<pHHHpOBalIHOlI, rrOL\-
ac Aame BLIqYPHOM" OTJIHqaBIlleMCR:
TaKHM H3R: eCTBOM II rapMOHIl'IlIOCTbID
II TalUlM me rrOJIHLIM OTCYTC!BIIeM pea-
JIHCTIl'IeCKllX qepT, Co OAlIOH CTOpOHI:I'
H paCTyID;HM HaTypaJIH3MOM, C APyroll.
XOTR: AeKopaTHBHo-opHaMeHTaJIbH08
H KOHKpeTHo-HaTypaJIHCTHqeCKOe Ha-
rrpaBJIeHHJI B rr03AHeCKH<pCKOM 3Bepll-
RoM CTHJIe KamyTCR: AllaMeTpaJIbHO-rrpo-
THBOrrOJIOmHbIMH, B ceMaHTII'IeCKOM
OTRomeHHII aTO He 60JIee, qeM ABe CTO-
pOHbI OAHOH MeAaJIH. Pa3JIHqIIH Kaca-
IDTCR: B OCHOBHOM JIIlIllb <pop Ia.1blIoll
CTOpOHbI. COAepmaHlle me 060nx 3TIIX
HarrpaBJIeHHH OTxoAHT Ha 3aAHitII II.1IaH
rr rrOAMeHR:eTCR: CTpeMJIeHHeM R Kpacn-
BOCTIl KaK K CaMOn;eJIIl - 6YAb TO ;r:c-
RopaTHBHbIH y30p IlJIH HaTypa.1IICTllqe-
CKaR: IlAHJIJIHR:.
ROHeqHO, TeHAelIn;HR: K <pop IaJIIl3a-
n;llH, CBJI3aHHaR: C rrpHKJIaAHbIM xapaK-
TepoM 3BeplIHora CTIIJIR:, 6bI.TIa eMY
rrpHcy a BcerAa. Ho COn;HaJIblIble CABIl.-
I'll crroc06CTBOBaJIH TOMY, qTO ona
BbIcTyrraeT Tenepb Ha rrepBoM rrJIaHe.
JJ:aJIbHeB:IDHH pOCT COn;HaJIbHOll CTpaTIl-
cpIlKan;HH, YKperrJIeHHe rocy;r:apCTRR
11 yCHJIHBIDaR:CR: aJIJIHRIl3an;IlH CKllcp-
CKOB: apHCTOKpaTIl.H COrJIaCHO rrpllBe II
R TOMY, qTo 3BepHHbIll CTIlJIb, B CBoell
OCHOBe OTpamaBIllIlB: HAeaJIbI Ba pBa p-
CKora 06 eCTBa arrOXH KJIacco06pa30-
B<\HHR:, K IV-II I BB. AO H. 3. yme
nepeCTa.rI 6bITb :maMeHlleM Bpe I(,1IJ1.
OCTaBIIIHeCR: eII(e 3a HHM COn;rra.1bHble
CPYH IlH 6bIJIH yme CBR:3aHbI He CTO.1b-
KO C OTpameHlleM IIOHR:THOll Bce IY 00-
II(eCTBY aKCHOJIOmM, CKOJIbKO C :::teKop;l-
TIlBlIbIM Ha3Ha'ielJHeM AoporllX BellII'll.
rrOAlIllMaBIDIlX IlX BJIaAeJIbn;a B r:fa:\;!\
OOII(eCTBa.
ROHe'IHO, 0 BKycax He crropHT. I/o
IbI rrOJIaraeM, 'ITO H rr03AHnII 3B('pii-
HbIH CTIlJIb B 060llx CBOIlX HarrpaB.-I(' II 11-
HX HMeeT BbICOKlle XYAomeCTBPllllblP
;r:OCTOllnCTBa. OAHaKO, eCJIIl paBblllC "II
6bIJI HerrocpeACTBelIlIO CBH3alI C I1J,eO:IIJ-
meH Bepy RX 06 ecTBeHHLIx CJIOeB,
TO Terrepb aTa ero CTopOHa CHJIbHO npH-
rJIYIlle Ha.
B IV - III BB. Ao H. a., O'leBHAHO,
YMeHbmHJIOCb 11 3HaqeHIle peJIBrH03-
HOII CPYHI_n;HII 3BeplllIoro CTHJIR:. IToc-
JICAI!('e He YAIlBIlTeJIbHO. no Mepe
yrJIy6.1eHIlR: rrpOn;eCCOB KJIacco06pa30-
BaHllR: rrpemAe eAIlHaR: CHCTeMa pe-
JIHrll03HbIX rrpeACTaBJIelIllB: rrpn06pe-
TaeT TeHAeHn;HID K orrpeAeJIeHHOH
All<P<I>epeHn;Han;IlH, B qaCTHOCTH, peJIII-
m03lIaR: CHCTeMa H rraHTeOH rocrroAcT-
ByIDII(HX BepxoB yme He COBnaJ1;RIDT
rrOJIlIOCTbID C BepOBaHHR:MH pR:AOBLIX
CJIOeB HaCeJIeHHR: 32. Co 3HaqHTeJIbHOH
AOJIeB: BepOR:THR: MomHO rrpeAIIOJIOmllTb,
qTO y CKH<pOB K IV B. AO H. a. AaJIeIW
3aIDJIH aHaJIOm'IHbIe npOn;eccbI. fepo-
AOT, rrO-BHAHMOMY, 3aCBHAeTeJIbCTBO-
Ba,'!, qTO yme B V B. H. 3. rrpOHCXOp;BJIO
CJIOmelIlle o<pIln;llaJIbHOrO rraHTeOHa,
KOTOpbIB: rrYCTb C HaTR:mKaMH II 01IIH6-
1\a III, Bce me MomHO 6bIJIO corrC>eTaImTb
C rpe'IeCKIlM.
1l0Ka3aTeJIbHo TaKme HaJIH'IHe oco-
601'0 60ra y rrOJIIlTllqeCKIl rocrroACTBYID-
II(IlX n;apCKHX cKH<I>OB.
YBeJIHqeHHe KOJIHqeCTBa aHTpOIIO-
MOP<pHLIX H306pameHHH, xapaKTepHoe
AJIR: IV B. AO H. a., KOCBeHHO TaKme
MomeT CBHAeTeJIhCTBOBaTb 0 TOM, qTO
peJIHrH03HbIe OCHOBbI 3BepHHoro CTII-
.rIR:, OTpamaBIllHe B033pellHJI YXOAH-
II(eII 3rrOXH, K IV - I II BB. AO H. 3. 6bI-
JIll ;r:JIR: CKH<I>CKOH apllCTOKpaTHH yme
BqepaIllHHM AHeM. OAHaKO MarI!-
'IeCKaR: CTopOHa 3BepllHoro CTHJIH, Be-
pOHTHO, COXpalIR:.rraCb 11M ;:1;0 caMoro
KOHn;a.
If Bce me rrOCJIeAOBaBmee B II I B.
;(0 H. 3. 6bICTpoe II IIOJIHOe Ilcqe:\-
1I0BeHIle 3BepllHoro CTIlJIR: KameTCH
Tpy.1H006"LR:CHIIMbIM KaK C 'IIICTO uXYL\O-
meCTBelIHOH, Tan II C COn;lla.1bHorr CTO-
pOlIbI, rrOTOMY qTO II B TOM, 11 B :Ipyro I
C.1\,qae lIe lIa6J1IOL\aeTCH KapAHna.1bHbIX
Ha IeHeHIlH rro cpaBHeHIlID C rrpeAIlleCT-
49
BYlOll\lIM BpCt.WneM. B03MOmHO, o6'bflc-
BCBHe Ha O IICKaTb B lIOJIHTHqeCKIIX lIO-
TpnCeHlIHX, ROTOpbIe B 3TO BpeMfI IICIIbI-
TbIBana CRUcpllH II KOTOpbIe, BepOHTHO,
IIpepBaJIlI !:HOrIIC Tpa Hn.HU B pa3BIITII1I
I Z. Barbu. Problems of Historical Psycho-
logy. ?\ew-York, 1960; A. H. rype8U'l. llH-
AIIBIIA B 06 ecTBo B BapBapcKllx rocy-
AapcTBax. rIHAO, KB. 1. M., 1968.
· A. Godard. Le tresor de Ziwije (Kurdis-
tan). Haarlem, 1950, tabl. 48; R. H. Dy-
son. Iran 1956. «University Museum Bul-
letin , vol. 21, 1957, N 1, p. 34, ill. 25.
3 M. H. ApraMOIt08. COl,pOBIIU\a CKII<pCI(HX
KypranOB. npara - J1., 1966, pilC. 2, 8;
TaOJI. 1-3,6-19, 29-33.
.. M. Rostoatzeff. The Animal Style in South
Russia and China. Princeton, 1929, p. 67.
· A. H. .If e..tIOI>08a. Boi1cKO II BoeHHoe IIC-
KYCCTBO CKII<p0B. HCHHMK, XXXIV, 1950,
CTp. 31-32; B. A. H..tbUItCl>aR. CKII<pbI
ABenpoBcKoro JIeCOCTClllIoro J1eB06epemMI.
KlleB, 1968, CTp. 179.
'0 «OAK 3a 1870-1871 1'1'.», CTp. XX; I1AK,
Bbln. 63, 1917, CTp. 31; II. If /1u6epo8.
KypraH y c. KOHCTaHTIIBOBKa. KCI1HMI\,
Bbill. XXXVII, 1951, CTp. 141; B. H. KURUl-
1>0. PaCI\OnKlI KOHcTauTlllloBcKoro llOCeJIP-
Him. «AO 3a 1968 1'.» M., 1969, CTp. 106;
I1:AK, BbIn. 19, 1906, CTp. 84-85.
'.7 E. E. IIuOTpo8C/'i:1l11. BaHcKoe apcTBo
(YpapTY). M., 1959, p"C. 242; «ApxeoJIoria
YKpaiHcKoi PCP», T. II. KIIIB, 1971,
CTp. 96, pllC. 29; CTp. 79, pllC. 24, 8, 9;
E. H. rpaIt08. CKII<pbI. M., 1971, CTp. 159;
r. T. lC08naltelt/'i:o. TIJIeMeHa cKi<pcbcKoro
qacy na BopcKJii. KIIIB, 1967, CTp. 55,
pllC. 21, 22. 23.
'8 A. M. Xaaalt08. CKII<pCIma ;.TlIorOIlIl'lCCI(aH
JIereHija (r pOAOT, IV, 5-7). «XV HaYlw.
Ba I\oH<pepeH ia iHCTIITYTy apxeoJIorii.
Te311... Oi\ecca, 1972.
,8 A. H. rype8U'l HaqaJIo 3noxII BlfKHBrOB
(npoo.'1eMbi AYXOBBOH ma3HII CKaIIAIIHa-
BOB B IX BeKe. <DaKTbI H rHllOTe3b1).
«CKaIli\II1faBCKHII COOPHIII\'), BbIll. Xlr. Ta.'1-
JIIIII, 1967.
"1.0 M. H. ApTaMolw8. COKpomm a C-KlI<pCI\IIX
I(ypraHoB, pRC. 5, TaOJI. 74; B. r. [JeTpeH.-
Ito. D paBooepcmbe CpeAHero DpuiJ:IIe-
npOBbH B V-III BB. AO H. 3. CAH, AI-4.
M., 1967, nOJI. 31, 4.
-11 BapxpaH-HmT, 19-20. rIepeBoA E. 3. Bep-
TeJIbCa C i\onOJIlIeHllaMII H. C. BparllHcRo-
ee JICKycCTna. llrrpOqeM, He nCKJIlOqCUO,
qTO n rr03,l1UeCKHcpCKOM n.apCTBe n
KpbIMY II con.uaJIbHOe pa3BHTHe mJIO
yme B pyroM HarrpaBJIeHHH 33.
roo CM.: If. C. EpaeUHCItUu. l1:a IICTOpll1l
Ta):{mlII\CIWii II nepcHAcKOH JIIITepaTYp. M.,
1972, CTp. 78.
12 B. r. /1Y"OItUH. HCKYCCTBO ApeBHero Hpa-
Ha (OCHOBHble ,nanbl). «HCTOpllll IIpaH-
CIWro rOCY;1apCTBa II KYJIbTypbI . M., 1971,
CT]L 107.
t3 C. A. TOliape6. rIp06JIeMbI ooU\ecTBeHHoro
C0311alIlIH ;1oK, accoBoH 3nOXH. «OXOTHIfKII,
coollpaTe. If, pbI60JiOBbI . J1., 1972.
H C. C. gepHlIl>o6. 3araAI<a 30JIOTOrO Kypra-
IIa. ill., 1965, CTp. 56, 136-137; H. /1. CJ,Jte-
IW611. f1polIcxo;KAeulle 11 palll1aa IICTopila
ll, l' ICIl TarapCl<oD: I<YJIbTYPbI. M., 1967,
CTp. 129.
" B. 11. A 6ae6. OceTIIBCKHD: a3bIK II <pOJIb-
I\JIOp, T. I. M.- J1., 1949, CTp. 37, 179,198.
'6 C. A. TOliape6. PaHBlle <pOpMbI pCJI\trll1l II
I1X pa3BIITHe. M., 1964, CTp. 76-77.
!1 W. Brandenstein, M. Mayrhofer. Hand-
bud, des :\ltpersischen. Wiesbaden, 1964,
S. 142.
16 K. Schefold. Del' Skythische Tierstil in
Siidrlls land. ESA, XII, 1938, S. 64; B. H.
rpalio8. CKi<pII. KlliB, 1947, CTp. 37.
19 C. A. TOl'iape8. CYII\HOCTb II npollcxomAe-
I1l1e larBII. TH3 [B. c.], T. LI. M., 1959,
CTp. 15.
20 B. H. rpaKoe. CKII«pbI, CTp. 86; M. H. Ap-
TaMOllo8. CKB<p0-CII6I1pcKoe IICKYCCTBO
3BeprIHoro CTHJIH (OcHoBHbIe aTanbi II Ha-
npaR. pnlla). MHA, M 177. M., 1971,
CTp. :\3; B. A. 1..t..tiHcbl>a. 30JIOTi llpllKpaclI
CJ(iqwhKoro apxaiqHoro yoopy. ApxeoJIo-
rill, 111m. 4. KIIIB, 1971, CTp. 71.
2. E. A. Eepre..tbc. I1cToplla nepCII):{CKo-TaA-
mllKCKOII . IITepaTypbl. M., 1960, CTp. 37,
55, 60, 215.
22 9...1. rpaItT06CI>UU. PalIBaa IIcToplla
upalIClUlX nJIeMeH rIepe):(HCH A3111I. M.,
1970. CTp. 157-158.
23 E. .1 /11tT611ltCI>UU. KaHrJOHCKo-capMaT-
1;1!ij ipapIl. AymaHoe, 1968.
.. q'IIrBena. H30paHHbIe rllMBbi. nepeBolI,
I\\I'HTapI!H II BCTynnTe;IbHaH CTaTba
T. II E.m3apeHKoBoH . M., 1972, CTp. 47.
25 B. ..1 l.u.iH.cbl>a. npo cKi<pcbKH BaBepm-
lll1lill ApxeoJIoria, T. XV. KlliB, 1\J63;
olia YCe. Ky. bToBbie me3JIbI CKH<pCKoro II
np(':!nm<pcRoro BpeMeBII. «HoBoe B co-
50
Bl'TCKOH apXeOJIOrHIu. M., 1\165, CTp. 200;
oHa xe. 30JIOTi opuKpaclI CI,i(l)cbI,oro ap-
xaiQBoro y60py. «Apxeo!1oriH", Bno. IV.
KIIIB, 1971, CTp. 73.
26 E. H. rpal>08. CKi<pB. I{IIiB, 1947, cry. 57.
27 If. H. ApTa..Wlt08. COl,poBn a cKlllpcImx
'KypraHOB, Ta6JI. 191.
26 A. [1. Maltlj.e8U'l. AepeBHllHbIe cocYllbi
CKII<pCKOD: anoxlI. ACf3, BbI!!. 8. J1., 1966,
CTp. 35, PIlC. 7, 12.
29 A. [1. Maltlj.e8U'l. AepeBHIlHbIe COCY;1bI,
CTp. 29, p"C. 7, 12.
30 M. H. ApTaMOlt06. C<)KpoB" a CKI\<pCKHX
KypraHoB, TaUJi. 186.
31 ArI, T. II. KneB, 1899, TaOJi. XXIII.
,. Ha CJiaBaIIClW \ MaTepnaJle 3TO aBJleHHe
ObIJIO UJiCCTaU\c HCCJICAOBaHO B. B. HBaHO-
BbIM II B. H. TOOOPOBbI!1 (B. B. l/6a1t08 II
B. H. Tonop06. CJIaBaBCKlle a3J,JKOBbIe
!lOAeJIHpYIO He ceMIIOTllqeCKlIe cnCTeMbI.
M.,1965).
33 A. M. Xaaalt08. 0 xapaKTepe pa60BJlaAe-
IIHI( y CKII<p0B. BAll, 1972, oM 1. np. 170.
E. E. RY3bMHHa
CHM CHOE MCHYCCTBO
:KAH OTP A1REHME MlIPOB033PEHMH
O,Il;HOM M3 fPYI111 MH,II;OMP AHQEB
Borrpoc 0 rrpollcxomp;emm: caM06bIT-
HOrO CTIlJUI CKHcpCKOrO IlCKYCCTBa p;o
CIlX rrop OCTaeTCH 3arap;J>OH. ECJIIl op;-
HII IlCCJIep;OBaTeJIlI rrOJIaralOT, qTO OH
B03HIlK Ha MeCTe, TO P;Pyrlle, HarrpO-
TIlB, rOBOpHT 0 MeXaHnqeCKOM 3a1lM-
CTBOBaHll1i Ha ApeBHe)I BocToKe 06pa-
30B, He rrOHHThIX II IlCKameHHhIX CKIl-
cpaMIl.
HaM KameTcH, qTO JIH pemeHIlH
«CKIlCPCKOH 3ara)J;l\ll}) He06xop;IlMO rre-
peRTIl OT qllCTO cpO P)IaJIbll hI X corro-
CTaBJIeHIlH p;eTaJIeH I1;!06pallicHllii K
IIorrbITKe BCKphITb I1X cOAepmaHlle.
lIcKyccTBo Bcer)J.a BbIpalliaeT IIp;eoJIo-
rllIO c03p;aBmero ero 06III;ecTBa, II
cpopMa CJIymllT JIllmb cpep;cTBoM 1Toro
BhIpameHIlH. 1103TOMY 1IIICTO cpop-
MaJIbHbIe rrollcKIl, Kal> 6hI OHII. HII 6hI-
JIll IlHTepeCHhI II rrOJIe3HbI caMIi rro ce-
6e, He MoryT rrpllBeCTII I> IICqeprrhI-
BalOIII;eH II I1paBIIJIbHOI[ OllCHKe xyp;o-
meCTBeHHoro HBJIeHlliI. TO.IbIW pac-
KpbITlle IIp;eHHOro CO;:Iepm<1 IIIIH rr03BO-
JIHeT 06'bHCHIITb CPop)II!pOn3Hlle xyp;o-
meCTBeHHoro CTTIJIH C TInOpIlqeCKIlX
II0311D;llll.
110CJIeiJ;HIIe rop;hI 03na I eHOBa:IIlCb
B03pocmllM IlHTepeCOM IICCJJep;OBaTe-
JIeR K ceMaHTIlKe p;peBHero nCKYCCTBa
IlpaHOH3bIqHb[X HapO;IOB. OT,f(eJIbHble
acrreKThI nOH TeMhI OCBeITliJ.1IICb B pa-
60TaX B. f. JIYKOHHHa. 1O. A. Parrrro-
IIopTa, B. A. JIIlTBIIHCJ>oro. D:. C. PaeB-
GKOro, B. A. J1JIbllHChOII. E. E. HY3b-
MHHOH II p;pyrnx 1. O.lTla"O Ha 3TOM
nyTIl IlCGJIep;OBaTeJIeU mp;eT Y:HomeCT-
BO Tpyp;HOCTeH. He]J.apOM KpyrrHeR-
mllH 3HaTOK IlCTOpll1l IlpaHCKOR peJIIl-
rllll iK. AIOmeHb- fllueMIlH BhIcTyrrHJI
C KpIlTIlKOii: IlHTeprrpeTaD;1l1l cop;epma-
HHH 06pa30B II CIOmeTOB p;peBHellpaH-
CKoro IlCKyccTBa II y6ep;IlTeJIbHO rrOKa-
3aJI HeCOCTOHTeJIbHOCTb D;eJIoro pH)J;a
corrOCTaBJIeHIlH C ABeCTOH 2.
IIpep;cTaBJIHeTcH, 'ITO HaqllHaTb pa-
60TY rro H3yqeHIlIO ceMaHTIiKIl IlCKYC-
,cTBa IlpaHOH3bIqHbIX Hapop;oB 60JIee
D;eJIeco06pa3HO He C IlHTeprrpeTaD;1l1l OT-
p;eJIbHhIX CIOmeTOB, IIPII KOTOpOU Mom-
HO BrraCTb B Oillll6KY II rroMaTbcfI
YBJIeqeHIlIO, a C IIOrrbITKH peKOHCT-
PYKD;1l1l BceR CHCTeMbI MIlpOB03speHHH
IlpaHOR!3bIqHbIX Hapop;OB, KOTOpoe Ham-
JIO OTpameHlle B IlX xyp;omeCTBeHHOM
TBOpqeCTBe II rrpep;OIIpep;eJIIlJIO crreD;ll-
cpllqeCKlle 'IepTbI HX IlCKYCCTBa, BbI3-
BaB K mll3HIl caM06bITHbIR CTIlJIb.
QT06hI 1l'36emaTb omll6KIl ITpli JI3Y-
qeHll1l P;YXOBHOR KYJIbTyphI CI\IIcpOB,
D;eJIeco06pa3HO IIp;TIl OT 06III;ero K
'IacTHOMY II rrpOBOp;BTb IlCCJIe)J.oBaHlie
Kamp;oro CIOmeTa II 06pa3a rrocJIep;o-
BaTeJIbHO Ha pa3HbIx ypOBHflX, BbIHB-
JIflH rrepBOHaqaJIbHO 06III;eqeJIOBeqeCKHe
rrptJ,lICTaBJIeHIlH, KOTopbIe Hell36emHO
)J.O+HbI 6hIJIIl OTpa31lTbCfI II B CKIIcp-
CKOH cliCTeMe; 3aTeM BbI)J.eJIfifi 06III;e-
IlHp;OeBporreHCKHR IIJIaCT. B nOM Han-
paBJIeH1l1l 60JIbmaH pa60Ta yme rrpop;e-
JIaHa iK. AIOMe3IlJIeM, B. B. J1BaHo-
BbIM, B. H. TOIIOpOBhIM II )J.pyrnMII,
52
Bb!}\ £III BIIIIlMIi 06III;eIlHp;oeBporreRCKlle
101ll<pbI, KYJIbThI II CIlMBOJIhI.
A.TIn BblflCHeHllfi CrreD;llcpllKII CKllcp-
cKoii IIp;eOJIOrllqeCKOH CIlCTeMbI OqeHb
naa\Ho BhIp;eJIeHlle IlHp;OllpanCKoro
ypOBHH rrYTeM corrOCTaBJIeHIlH PIIrBe-
bI, ABeCThI, CBIlp;eTeJIbCTB rrllCbMeH-
HLIX nCTOqHIIKOB 0 peJIllrll1l II IIp;eoJIo-
rHIl CKllcpOB II nepCOB, peKOHCTPYRD;Ilii:
na OCHOBe 60JIee rr03)J;llIlX p;aHHhIX 3rro-
ca II H3hIKa, KaK 3TO yme rrpOp;eJIaHO
110 oceTIIHCKIiM MaTepllaJIaM II qaCTHq-
HO - ITO caKCKIlM. HaM KameTcfI, qTO
TO.TIbJ>O rrpll TaKOM KOMrrJIeKCHOM rrop;-
xO;Ie pa60Ta OKameTCH rrepcrreKTIlB-
HOH, a rrpep;JIOmeHHhIe peKoHcTpYKD;1l1l
p;OCTaTOqHO y6ep;BTeJIbHbIMIl.
HecoMHeHHo, qTO MeXaHllqeCKIl rrpll-
BJIel\aTb P;JIfi IlHTeprrpeTaD;1l1l CKHcpCKIlX
IaTPplIaJIOB CIOmeTbI IlJIIl MllcpOJIOrn-
1IeCI>IIe rrepcoHamll, coxpaHeHHble B
PllrBe)J.e, ABecTe, HapToBcKIlX CKa3a-
HIlHX HJIIl BOCTOqHOllpaHcKoM CPOJIb-
Klope, cOBepmeHHo HerrpaBOMOqHO.
B pa3.lllqHhIX 06JIaCTHX IlHp;OllpaHCKO-
TO lIIpa cYP;b6a Kamp;oro KOHKpeTHoro
CJOllieTa II 06pa3a pa3BIlBaJIaCb rro-
cBoe IY. Op;HaKO IlCrrOJIb30BaTb MaTe-
plIa.l PB:rBep;hI II ABecThI P;JIH pe-
l\OIICTPYKD;1l1I CIlCTeMhI MhImJIeHHfI II
Kpac To.1JbHhIX rroHflTIiR CKllcpCKOR
l;oc !OrOHHIl II MllcpOJIOrHII BnOJIHe
3aJ>oIloMepHo. lICCJIep;OBaTeJIHMIl p;aBHo
YCTaHOBJIeHO, qTO He TOJIbKO BamHeii:-
IUIiP TlOHflTllfi II 'CIOmeThI, IlMeHa 60rOB
II repoeB, HO II MHO rile 06pHP;OBhIe
Jl,eiicTBIiH, rr03TIlqeCKIIe 06pa3hI II
pIlT 'a.lbHble CPOPMYJIbI O)J.JIHaKOBO xa-
paliTE'pHbI II P;JIfi ABeCTbI II P;JIH Pllr-
BP:tbl. B 3TOM rrpOHBJIfieTCH 06III;ee
HaLle .lne 3. CJIep;OBaTeJIbHO, 3Ta CIlCTe-
Ma [bImJIeHllfi 6hIJIa rrpllcyrn;a BceM
IIIUOrrpaHCKIlM Hapop;aM, II CKHcpbI
:lO:lit;]!bI 6bmll coxpaHHTb ee. TaKoe
II pe .1rrOJIOmeHlle 1I0p;TBepmp;aeTCfI rrpll
arra.llI3e oceTIlHcKoro 3rroca. RaK
YCTiTHOBJIeHO IlCCJIep;OBaTeJIfiMIl, B Hap-
TOBCI,TIX CKa3aHIIHX OTpameHbI ap-
XallqHhIe 06III;ellpaHCKlle IIOHflTIIfI II
rrpep;CTaBJIeHIlH, KOTophIe COXpaHIIJIUCb
y oceTIlH KaK HaCJIep;Ue IIp;eOJIOrllll
eBpa31lHCKHX CTerrHbIX IWqeBHIIKOB
I ThIC. p;o H. 3.'. Bce 3TO CJIymlIT
OCHOBaHlleM rrpOBO)J.IlTb COBMeCTHoe
IlCCJIep;OBaHlle TaKIlX IlCT01lHIIKOB, KaK
PllrBe,lla, ABeCTa, HapTOBCKlle CKa3a-
HIlH II BOCTOqHOllpaHCKllll cpOJIbKJIOp C
D;eJIbIO Bblp;eJIIlTb B HIIX TOT p;peBHeii:-
lllllR Kpyr BepOBaHIiR II npep;CTaBJIe-
HIlR, KOTOphIH 6hI.TJ. ITPIICYIII; BceM
IlHp;OllpaHD;aM B 3noxy I1X KOHTaKTOB II
JIer B OCHOBY cpOpMHpOBaHIiH MllpO-
B033peHIlH OTp;eJIbHhIX IIHp;OllpaHCKIIX
Hapop;OB, B TOM qllCJIe II CKllcpOB.
B CBeTe IlHp;OllpaHc.J>IIX p;aHHbIX OT-
PhIBOqHbIe CBep;eHllfi 0 ;:tYXOBHOR KYJIb-
Type CKHcpOB, coxpaHellHbIe B rrHCb-
MeHHbIX IlCTOqHIIKaX, rrOMaIOTCH
p;OCTaTOqHO Hap;elliHO![ IIHTeprrpeTa-
D;1l1l II rr03BOJIHIOT pehOHCTpYHpOBaTb
B 06III;IlX qepTaX MbIlll.'ICHlIe CKllcpOB II
HX MllcpOJIOrllqeCKYIO II KOCMorOHII-
qeCKYIO CIiCTeMY.
PO.llb Mazuu. PllrBE':13 II ABeCTa 5
OTpamaIOT He CTporo J>iT TlOHIl3I1pOBan-
HYIO peJIllrllIO, a MH<pOJIornqeCKYIO
CIlCTeMY B MOMeHT ee CTaHOBJIeHIlH.
Bo MHorOM 3TO eIII;e (,Kopee Marn-
qeCKafl, HemeJJII pe.1JIirn03Hafi CIlCTe-
Ma. MarllqeCKUe )J.ellCTBIiH II 06pflP;bI
IlrpaIOT orpOMHYIO pO.'Ih B mll3HIl 06-
III;eCTBa. C D;eJIbIO Bo:!;\ellCTBllfi Ha 60
meCTBa II YMepllllIX upe,lKOB COBep-
maIOTCfI mepTBorrpIIHOlllE'TlIIfI II rrpOIl'3-
HOCHTCH Marll1lerhne :!aKJIIiHaHllfl 6 .
lRepTBbI ITOCBHUJa [(,T H n.leHllfiM ITPIl-
POAbI. rrepcoHII<pIIITllpOBaHHbIM 60ra-
Mil; 06'beKTaMIl nOJ>.lonrnIIH HB.'IflIOTCH
TaKme HeKOTopble iRIIHOTHbIe - KOHlI
Aap;XIIKpa II TapKillhIl (PnrBep;a - p;a-
JIee PB. IV. 44; X. 171'1. CRflIII;eHHbIe
rrpep;MeTbl. rryqKII f);q,coMa, BhI3bI-
BaIOIII;lIH 31\CTa3 COJ> xaO fhI (COMhI) 7.
Te me qepTbI ITpllC 'IIJIT n\llcpCKOR pe-
JIIIrnll. [epOAOT (I '-. lill-62) co06-
III;aeT, 1ITO CKTIcpbl [fI'ITHOCHT lliepTBbI
53
BceM CeMH OOraM (jBOCrO IlaHTeOHa,
1I0XOpOHbI l\apR: TalOKe COilpOBOm-
aIOTCR: 60raTbIMH mepTBOIlpHHOlle-
ILlIHMH. B peJIHrlfH CI\H<p OB , Kal{ B
PyrHx HH OHpaHl\eB, OrpOMHOe 3Ha-
'IeHHe BMelOT IlpHBeAeHHe IIpOpHl\a Te-
:[eH B 3RCTaTH'IeCKoe COCTOR:HHe, CBR:-
eHHbIe IlPYTbR: 6apCoM «(6apec-
MaD» ), KOTOpbIMIl mpel\bI IIOJIb3yroT-
CR: IlPH raAaHHH (fepoAoT, IV, 67,71).
06'beKTaMH IlOKJIOHeHHH Y CKH<pOB 6bI-
JIB: TaKme CHMBOJIbI l\apCKOB: BJIa-
CTH - 30JIOTOe R:pMO, ceKHpa B 'lalla
(fepoAOT, IV, 5, 7).
CUM60,//,U3M MbllU,//,eH,UR. K 'DICJIY
OTJIH'IHTeJIbHbIX oc06eHHocTeii MB-
pOB033peHHR: IlHAoHpaHl\eB, 3a<pHK-
cnpoBaHHblX B MOMeHT c03AaHBR:
Pil, rBeAbI OTHOCIITCR:, IlO 3aKJIIO'IeHBIO
T. fl. EJIIl:li!JWHKOBOll, CHMBOJIH3M
MbIUlJIeHIlH 8.
To me eilpaBeAJIIlBO B OTHOlleHHU
ABeCTbI. R3bIK PHrBeAbI B ABecTbI 06-
pa:JCH H MPTa(jJOJJII'Icu. .1J:JIR: MHorllX
Co'!{)B xapaKTcpllbl CilMBOJIH3M II aM6H-
BaJIeHTHOCTh ( !II01'03Ha '1I10CTb). Ta K,
COMa - <JTO II l'arTPlllle II BblmllMae-
Mblii 1l:J Hero uaIIifTOK, 'H 6eCCMepTHe,
aBaeMoe :JT([\J HaUHTKOM. C Pyroii
CTOpOllbI, II II ABeCTe, II B PHrBe e
IlIIlI)()['O paCllpOCTpaHeHbI KCHHH-
rll -- IIIIocr;a:JanHH: (IBH R:Il H lIepBbIM
:lapK») - 3TO nCTyx. (ICo epma ee 1.10-
.1IlTBbl» - rO.'lOl1a". II lIecYlI(llii y6lIHy
rpOMa,) - Hll pa H TaK a,'Iee. YIIQ-
Tpe6JleHHe M IIOro'l l1ell uHbIX CHMBOJIOB
C,laeT IIO;1T1I4l'CKYIO pe'lb O'!ellh
c.'!omHoii If IlfJlIHTHoii JIUlib TeM, y
Koro CUMBO.l"! Bbl3bIBalOT COOTBCT-
CTBYKJII\IlC aCCO([ II alUfH. T aK, j:\OHHaR:
nOpOBa ,'\O.TJ;j{II;t aCCOl\llllpOBaTbCR: C
om eBoii TY'Ieii. KOJIeco - C COJIHl\eM,
ynpHmb - C iI{PI'TBorr 10. qacTo B poml
CHMBo.1a BbICT."'liJeT cpaBHeHrre. J1Hj:\-
pa TO CpaBHI1BaeTCH C 6bIKOM, TO Ha.,-
BaH 6bIKOM; AlIlB!lHbI TO cpaBHHBaIOT-
CR: C KOHR: m. 1 n OTomj:\eCTBJIR:IOTCR: C
IJ(!MIf. Y IIOTPt"-'.-lflIOTCH U <p0pMy.rlbl-
CJIOBOCO'IeTaHHR:, HaIlpHMep, KOHb-
CO:IHl\e. CHMBOJIH'IeCKOe 3Ha'leHHe
HMelOT H 3IlHTeTbI ABeCTbl H PHrBej:\bl.
3a 3IlnTeTOM «j:\paKoHoy6rrii:l\a» j:\JIR:
j:\peBHUX CKpbIBaJICR: BeCb MH<p 0 60Pb-
6e J1Hj:\PbI HJIB BepeTparHbI e j:\paKO-
HOM 3a oCB060mj:\eHHe BOj:\ II Bo06 e'
CHJI IIJIOj:\OpO)J;llH IlPHPO)];bI II. 3IlilTeT
CJIymHT CBepHYTbIM MH<pOM. TalmM
06pa30M, R:3bIK, IIOJIHblii CHMBO.TIOB, OT-
pamaeT cBoe06pa3HYlO <POPMY Mbllll-
JIeHHR:.
HeCOMHeHHO, '1TO MbIllJIeHHe CKH-
<p OB , TaK me KaK H j:\pyrBx HHj:\onpaH-
l\eB, 6bIJIO Tome He CTOJIbKo a6CTpaKT-
1I0-JIOrH'IeCKHM, CKOJIbKO 06pa3Hb1M, B
IWTOpOM Kaml];bIii 06pa3 Hec ceMaHTll-
'1eCKYIO HarpY3Ky. 06 3TOM O'leHb R:p-
Ko rOBopBT IIepej:\aHHbIH fepoj:\oTOM
(IV, 131-132) paCCKa3 0 j:\apax
CI\H<pCI\HX n;apeii, IIpHCJIaBllHX .1J:aplllO
IITHl\Y, Mblllb, JIR:ryIllKy H IIR:Tb CTpeJI
'ITO j:\OJImHO 6bIJIO 03Ha'laTb Ta KOH
OTBeT CKH<pOB: «ECJIH BbI, IlepCbI, [{al\
nTHl\bl, He YJIeTHTe B He60, nan MbIl!ln
Ile 3apoeTecb B 3eMJIIO, nJIn naK .TJH-
rYUII\iI, lIe IlOCKa'leTe B 60JIOTO, TO He
BepHeTeCb Ha3aj:\, IlopameUllble 3THMU
CTpeJIaMII».
CUH,KpeTU3M 06paa06 U nO'//'uce.ltall-
TU3M. B PHrBe,IJ;e 60rll MbIC,1R:TCH IIJII-f
a6CTpal{THO, UJIH aHTpoiloMOP<PHO, I1.TJII
300MOp<p HO . I1epemlITKH O'leHb npll-
MHTIIBilbIX IIpe,IJ;CTaBJleHllii 0 BOIIJIOII\C-
HUR:X 60mecTBa B mllBOTHoe eIl\c CIf:!b-
IIbI B C03HaHHH TBOPl\OB Purne;!!,!.
Tan, I1ymaH TpaHc<popMupyeTcH B
r;o:lJIa, MaTI, Ma PYTOB - B !\OpOBY.
:\paKOH BpHTpa - B l;a6aHa. HHor.13
OAHH nepCOHam BbICTynaeT B HeC[W.l (,_
KHX 06pa3ax: J1HApa IlpeACTaeT H 1<11-
Ae bIKa, 6apana, IWHH If KO.,.-"l":
AllBWHbl IlpeACTaBJIR:IOTCH TO 101111111;1-
lIf Ira nO.1eCHIlL\e. TO KOBH IIr. TO "1>_
.TaMII, BJIenYID;IiMH Ko.rleCHIIlI ' (I'll I.
118, 4, 5). Eor CO.'IHIIa C 'PbH II ,0< II
OrHR: ArHH BbIcTynalOT B oupa:w I,IIIIH
(PB, X;, 168). J1 B TO me BPC [H .11111-
54
ilWllbC CYPbH IlO Heuy cpaBIIHBaeTCH
-c nOJIeTOM opJIa (PB VU, 63, 5), COJIH-
v. e MHoroKpaTHo na3bIBaeTCR: u TO nTH-
i\eii, TO KOHeM, TO KOJIeCHHn;eB, TO KO-
;leCOM, TO rJIa30M MHTpbI-BapYHbI
(PB VI, 51, 1; IX, 71, 9; IX, 97, 33;
X 302; X, 55, 6).
'Tal\oii CHHKpCTII3M - xapaKTepneii:-
maR: 'lepTa MbIIllJIeHIlR: C03j:\aTeJIefl
PITrBe H R:IllTOB ABeCTbI. qTO Kaca-
eTCR: j:\peBHHX HpaHqeB, TO, no co06-
rneHHIO fepoAoTa (I, 131), nepCbI-axe-
leUH,IJ;bl He IIpe,IJ;CTaBJIR:IOT CBOHX 60roB
-qeJIOBeKOIlOA06HbIMH, !{aK 3TO j:\eJIalOT
JIJIIIHbI.
Bonpoc 05 06pa3e 60roB ABecTbI
(JCTaeTCR: CIlOpHbIM. B ABecTe eCTb Ae-
TaJIbHOe OIlHcaHlle TOJIbKO OAHOii 60-
rllHH - AHaxHTbI (ApABHCYP-R:illT, 30),
HO II OHO, BBAHMO, R:BJIR:eTCR: II03AHeii-
lieu IiHTepnOJIHn;neii. Bce j:\pyrBe 60rn
H repOH aBeCTHB:CKOrO naHTeoila HC
fiMelOT yCToHBllerOCR: KaHOHH'IeCKOrO
o6mma, IlO3TOMY CTOJIb HeYAa'lHbI Bce
nOlIbITKn CBR:3aTb B306pameHHR: ua
npOIi3BeAeHHHX IlpaHCKOro BCKYCCTBa
KOHKpeTHbIMH aBeCTHll::CKHMH IIepco-
HamaMH.
B RillTax OIlHcaHbI pa3Ho06pa3HbIe
nepeBOIlJIOID;eHlIR: 60rOB H repoeB,
QOJIbIllaR: '1aCTb KOTOpbIX 300MOp<pHa.
Hali p ilMep MllTpa MbICJIHTCR: TO IOHO-
, 13
weH, TO BcaAHHKOM, TO KOHeM .
B MIIXp-R:llTe (X) OH npeACTaBJIeH Ha
KOJIeCHHl\e C 6eJIbIMli KOHR:MH H 0AHHM
I;OJIeCOM - COJIHII,eM. BepeTparHa -
Gor rpoMa n nOOe,IJ;bI - HMeeT He-
CI;O.lbKO BOIIJlO eHIIH (aBaTapoB). 3TO
oeJIbIii KOHl" IlTlln;a (opeJI, COKOJI), Ka-
6aH, Bep6JIIOA, 6bIK, 6apaH, K03eJI,
Bca,IJ;HHK H BeTep (EexpaM-R:illT, 8).
J1HnapHal\Hll <papHa (YAa'lll, CJIa-
BbI) - KOHl" XHID;HaR: I1THl\a, Bep6JIIO,IJ;,
6apaH, pbI6a, BOITH (3aMbR:j:\-R:llT, 34-
38, 51, 68). feporr THillTpHR:, OTOm,IJ;e-
CTBJIR:eMbIii co 3Be3):\oii CHPHYC H no-
CbIJIalOID;Hii Ha 3eM.110 BOAb!, BbICTYIIa-
eT TO B 06pa3e IOHOllH, TO B 06pa3e
6eJIora IWHH, cpamalO Croc.H C l1:eMo-
HOM 3acyxll AlIaoIlla, IlpeACTaBJIR:e-
MOM B 06JIHKe '1epHOrO KOHR: (THllTp-
HIllT,14,9).
TaKIlM oopa30M, MbIillJIeHHe c03Aa-
Te.rleii R:WTOB ABeCTbI 61>WO IlpOHHK-
UYTO CIlMBO:II13MOM H IlepemHTKaMH
a pXaH'IHbIX 300JIaTpIT'IeCKIIX KYJIbTOB.
)J;.1R: ABeCTbl, KaK II AJIR: PllrBe,D;bI, xa-
paKTepHbI CIlHKpeTH3M H IIOJIHCeMaH-
TH3M 06pa30B, KorAa 0AHH H TOT me
ITepCOHam lIMeeT neCKOJIbKO TpaHcqJOp-
Mal\Hii II BMeCTC C TeM OJ:\HH 06pa3
CIiMBO.TJIl3IlpyeT HeCI\OJIblW 60roB II
repoeB. Ta[.;, 1,0111, - no MHTpa, CIlH-
BYill, BepCTparHa, BaiilO, <DapH, THIll'
TpHR:; Bep6.11OA - BaB:lO, BepeTparHa,
<DapH; CoKO.'1 H 6apan - BepeTparJIa
II <DapH.
Te cBej:\euIlH, KOTopbIe cOXpaHHJIHCb
o peJIllrHll CKH<pOB, MaJIO j:\alOT ,IJ;JUI
cymAeHHR: 0 TOM, KaK CKllcpbI IlpeACTaB-
JIR:JIH CBOlIX 60roB H repoeB. TOJIbnO
OTHOCIlTeJIhl!O Apeca fepoAoT (IV, 62)
rOBoplIT, 'ITO eMy IlOK,lOHR:JIIICb B BIl e
a [01HaHa. ;horo 60ra Il03me aJIaHbI no-
'1IlTaJlIl, IIO c.BHAeTeJIbCTBY AMMllaHa
Mapl\eJIHlIa (31, 2, 23), B Bll,IJ;e Me'la,
a OCCTllllbl -- me.1JC3Horo IlpYTa.
BOJ!ec IlO:wo6HO H306pallieHa POAO-
lIa'HI.1hllllL\a CI\H<pOB - IlOJIYAeBa, no-
:IY3MeR: (I'CPOAOT, IV, 9). 06pa3 ee
6JIll3nO pOACTBeH 06J1HKY MaTepB
HapTOBCKoro repOR: EaTpa,IJ;;Ja - BOAH-
Hoii AeBe. IlPll!{p1>lBalOlI(eiicH na Aeilb
I..omeii pe4 !loii '1epeIlaXH ". I1epemIlT-
i\1l :Joo.TaTplllf OT'ICT.'IHBO BbIcTynaroT
B OCCTIIIIC 1;o 1 <pO.1b!{.10pe. B HapTOB-
CKHX CKina IIlIR:X repOH '1aCTO Tpan-
C<P0JHIUPYIOTCH B mHBOTHbIX IfJIII IIpe -
MeTb! H HB.'!CHHH IlpHpOAbI. Bce 3TO
aeT THep:u,!e OCHOBaHHR: IlpeAIlo:!a-
raTh. 'ITO II :[.fH MbIIIIJIeHHR: CKH<pOB 61,1-
JlH XapaKTf'pllbl CHMBOJIH3M H 06pa3-
HOCTb If 1II'(':Ic.TaBJIeHHe 0 300MOP<PHhIX
lIepcBon.-I('lllI'IIHHX, l\aK 3TO 6bIJIO B
II)l.CO.l0 rill , IICPX ApyrHx BH,IJ;OHpaHCKHX
HapOAoB.
55
CY)J;fI rro IlaMflTHIlKaM 1l306pa31lTeJIb-
1101'0 IlCKYCCTBa, aHTpOrrOMOp<I>1l3aIl,llfl
oorOB II repoeB CKIl<I>HU HaqaJIaCb
TOJIbKO B IIOCJIeapXalI'leCKYIO 3rroxy II
;mlllb rroA BJIllflHlleM IlCKYCCTBa l1pa-
na II fpeIl,IlIl.
II ap/fua.llbnaR MaZUR. OT JIllqllTeJIb-
Hafl qepTa MIlpOB033peHIDl IlHAo:npaH-
CKIlX HapoAoB - rrepem:nTKIl rrapIl,llaJIb-
HOB Marl'lIl. l1 peACTaBJieHlle 0 TOM,
'1TO 'laCTb 3aMeHfleT II,eJIoe, HalllJIO
BblpameHlle B fl3blKe PllrBeAbl II ABec-
Tbl - B 6paXIlOJIOrHll, T. e. cOKpa eHIlIl
II03TlPleCKOB <I>0PMYJIbl, IlporrycKe rroA-
pa3YMeBaeMblx CJIOB; B yrroTpe6JIeHIlll
(<cBepHYTblx 3IlIlTeTOB», rrepeAalO llx
0AHIlM CJIOBOM cOAepmaHlle II,eJIoro MIl-
<I>a I", a TaKme B yrroA06JIeHIlll qaCTIl
IlpeAMeTa II,eJIOMY: HarrpllMep (PB VI,
39, 4; IX, 86, 45; MIlXP-fllllT, X) BMe-
CTO «KOJIeCHIlIl,a» rOBopllTCfI «KOJIeCO>t.
3Ta qepTa IIpllcYl..II,a II oceTIlHcKoMY
<I>O.'1bKJIOPY: BOJIllle6Hafi KOJIecHIlIl,a
HapTOB «caMOJIeTKa» Ha3blBaeTCfI «Ko-
JIeco Bapcara 16. Oc06eHHO flpKO rrpllH-
I\IIIIbl rrapIl,llaJIbHOH Marl'lIl BblpameHbl
B rrpaKTIlKe mepTBorrpllHOllleHIlR Bcex
JlHAOllpaHII,eB. TaK, Ilpll B03rommeHHll
a:ITapfl BapYHbl B mepTBY rrpllHOCIlJICfI
lUll KOHb, IlJIIl TOJIbKO KOHCKafl rOJIOBa,
HJIIl, HaKOHeIl" JIllmb rJIIlHflHOe 1l30-
6pameHIle rOJIOBbl I'.
l1oA06Hble IlpeACTaBJIeHllfl B eBpa-
.mHcKIlX CTeIIflX CYl..II,eCTBOBaJIH yme B
III TblC. AO H. 3. II <I>IlKCIlPYIOTCfI H3.-
XUJI;I,aMIl qepeIlOB KOHeR II 6blKOB B flM-
HblX rrorpe6eHHflX 18. 9Ta rrpaKTIlKa CO-
XpaHIlJIaCb II B CKIl<I>CKYIO 3IlOXY, a B
6bITY oceTIlH AOiImJIa AO cOBpeMen-
HOCTII 19.
KY.llbT npe8/'W6. OrpOMHYIO pOJlb
B PllrBeAe If B ABeCTe IlrpaeT KYJIbT
npeAKOB.
l1epBbIR qeJIOBeK - OH me rrepBbIR
llapb IlpaHII,eB flllMa (HcHa, XXX, 3)
I1MeeT rrapaJIJIeJIb B PllrBe,IJ;e (X, 10)-
RMY. flHMa II HMa rrOCJIe cMepTIl
CTaJIII II,apflMH 3arp06Horo II,apCTBa II
CJIymaT IlpOBoAHIlKaMll YMeplllllx Ha
BepxHee He60, Ha Be'lHbIe rracT61l a,
rAe 061lTalOT IlpeAKIl '0. B qeCTb YMep-
llIllX rrpeAKoB IlHAoHpaHII,bl cOBepllialOT
CJIOmHbIe pllTyaJIbI, IlbIlllHbIe rrOMHHKR
II mepTBoIlpllHollleHllfi.
B IlCTOqHIlKaX 0 peJIUrll1l CKIl<I>OB HeT
cBIlAeTeJIbCTB 0 KYJIbTe IIepBoro
'1eJIOBeKa. OAHaKo KyJIbT rrpeAKoB, II
B oc06eHHocTIl IIpeAKoB II,apeR, II Y CKIl-
<I>OB IlrpaJI BamHeRlllYIO pOJIb. HeAapoM
OHII coopyma:nr caMbIe rpaHAIl03Hble
B Mllpe KypraHbI, a KJIflTBa 60raMIl II,ap-
CKoro oqara C'IIlTaJIaCb oc06eHHo CBfI-
l..II,eHHoR (fepo.r\oT, IV, 68) II He AapOM
II,apb CKIl<I>OB l1)J;aH<I>llpC B OTBeT JJ:aplllO
rOBopHT: (< Y Hac eCTb OTeqeCKlle MO-
rHJIbI. HaH]UlTe IlX II IlOIIp06YRTe pa3-
PymllTb, II TorAa Y3HaeTe, CTaHeM JIll
MbI cpamaTbCfI 3a aTll MOrnJIbI 1l.1l! HeT»
(fepoAoT, IV, 127).
HeKoTopbIe AeTaJIIl cKIl<I>CKOrO IIO-
rpe6aJIbHOrO u6pflAa MOryT 6blTb IlCTOJI-
KOBaHbl TOJIbKO B CBeTe IlHAOHpaHCKIlX
MaTepHa:IOB. repoAoT (IV, 71-72)
co06!II,aeT, '1TO rrpll rrorpe6eHIlll II,apfl
CKIl<I>bI IlpllIIOCRT B mepTBY KOHeH, a
lIa IlO IHHl(aX '1epe3 ro;:{ y61lBalOT el..Il,e
IIflTbAeCflT Konen, a IlX '1yqeJIa rrplIBfI-
3blBalOT K meCTY, YBeHqaHHOMY rro-
JIOBIlHOH KOJIeca. KOHR <I>llrypllpOBaJIIl
TaKiHC n aaYIlOKORHOM KYJIbTe II,apeH
aXeMeJlH.r\CKoro l1paHa. CTpa60H (XV,
3, 7) II AppHa!! (<<IIoxo;:{ AJIeKCaHApa»,
VI, 29, 7) COOOIl\aIOT, qTO AYXY rroKoR-
HOro l\apH Hnpa MarH emeMeCflqHO Y
ero rp06HHl\J.1 IlpIlHOCIlJIIl B me 1 BY
I\OHfI. iKepTBO!!pIlHOIIIeHue KOHfI CO-
IlpoBoiIqa:lO Tit "me Ilorpe6eHIle 3Han;:
Y BeAlI'IPCKHX a plleB. l1HTepecHO, qTO
Tel,CT fI1MII<1 !lit rrorpeoeHHe KOHfI B
PHIt3e;J;e (X. ;>6) IlepeKJIIlKaeTCfI C
pe'l oax<I>a .1J;IlCara - rrOCBflTIlTeJIfI
KOHfI Ha rrorp('6eHIIH y oceTHH 21, qT(
YI{a3blBaeT Ha 60;IbIITyIO ApeBHOCTb II
06 lle HCTOKIT 06ellx Tpap;RII,IlR. KOHb
B aTOM 06pIl.1C CJIymIlT rrocpeAHHKOM
JIIem)J;Y MIIPO ! JIIOAeR H He60M II AOJI-
56
Ji\eH rrOMOqb X03f1IlHY COBepllillTb TPYA-
Hbl H IlYTb B 061lTeJIb rrpe,!\KOB, Ha He6ec-
able IIaCT61l a. BMecTe C TeM, KOHb Y
HH)J;ollpaHII,eB - mllBoTHoe, CBfl3aHHoe
C cOJIHII,eM II HaAeJIeHHOe CBepX"beCTe-
CTBeHHbIMIl CIlJIaMIl, cIloc06HOCTbIO
IIepeAanaTb 6eCCMepTIle II,aplO. 8-:0
oc06eHHo flCHO rrpOflBJIfleTCfI B IlHAHll-
CKOM 06pflAe mepTBorrpllHOllleHllfi 6e-
!loro KOHfI- amBaMeAxe (PB, I, 162,6).
AmBaMe a rrp:nypoqeHa K COJIflpHOMY
KaJIeHAaplO, OHa BocrrpllHIlMaeTCfI KaK
ClIIepTb II B03pomAeHIle II,apfl, KOTOpO-
MY IIpllHeceHHblR B mepTBY KOHb co06:
w;aeT 6eccMepTlle; TOJIbKO rrOCJIe aTOH
D;epeMoHIlIl II,apb rrOJIyqaeT IIOJIHOTY
II,apCKoR BJIaCTIl 22. l1pll 3aKJIHHaHIlll
KOHfI IIpllBfl3blBaJIIl K llleCTY, CH !BOJIIl-
31lpOBaBilleMY ApeBO m1l3HIl, Ha Beplllll-
He KOTOp01'O rrOMel..Il,aJIIl KOJIeCO - CUM-
BOJI COJIHII,a. 8TIl AeTaJIIl pIITyaJIa IlpfiMO
IlepeKJIIlKalOTCfI co CKIl<I>CKIlM pUTyaJIOM
iI\epTBOrrpllHomeHllfl KOHeli Ha II,apCKIIX
IloxopOHax, rrpllqeM CJIeAyeT rrO.r\'1epK-
HYTb, qTO 3aKJIaHIle KOHfI Y Bcex HH)J;O-
IlpaHII,eB rroA06aJIo TOJIbKO JIIIII,a ! BbIe-
lllllX COIl,llaJIbHbIX paHrOB, B IlepBYIO
OqepeAb - II,aplO 23. KOHb B 3TOM oopfiAe
6bIJI He CTOJIbKO cpe)J;CTBml AOCTHrllYTb
0611TeJIIl rrpCAKOB, CKOJJbKO cinE 1I0.10M
6eCCMepTIlfi II,apfi.
J(ya.lluCTU'leCI'WR IwnlfenlfuR 60pb6bt
oo6pozo U 3.1lOZ0 na'la.n.a.
KpaeyrOJIbHblM KaMHeM Bcex IIHAo-
HpaHcKllx TpaAHII,IlR 6bIJIO Ilpe):\lTilB.le-
Hlle 0 KOCMo1'OHHqeCKOM alae TBopeHHfI
KaK II06eAe MIIpoBoro rrOpfl)1ha HaA
xaocoM, CBeTa HaA MpaKO I, Terr.-Ia HaA
XOJIOAOM, BJIarll HaA 3aCYXOR 11 T. A.,
'1TO B KOHeqHOM IlTOre elDIIIOJIn::mpyeT
rr06eAY mll3HIl HaA CMepTblO 2'.
fJIaBHafi <I>YHKD;HfI lla.r\onparrCKIlX
60rOB - IIO.r\AepmaHlle lllpOBOrO IlO-
pfiAKa, 60Pb6a C TeMHbI !11 CIl:la 1Il II
IlooeAa HaA H1l1ll1l 2 '. l1paneKIIii MIlT-
pa - He TO.TlbIW 601' COJiana, rro IT 601'
AoroBopa, rropflJ(Ka, I{aK IT ITrr;\lIiicKHli
MIlTpa-BapYHa 26 . f.TIa RII afT (lIYIIKnHfI
UHornx APyrnx 601'OB - Tome 60pb6a
C TeMHbIMIl CHJIaMIl. l1MeHHo 3TOT 3rrll-
;lOA cJIYmllT OCHOBHbIM cOAepmaHlleM
rIlMHoB, rrOCBflI..II,eHHbIx l1HApe. B pOJIR
OOPIl,OB BblcTYIlalOT BepeTparrra, Tpll-
Ta - Tpa3TaoHa, Kepecacrra, BalilO,
II APyrne 60rll II 60mecTBeHHble re-
pOR Z7.
l10 rrpeACTaBJIeHll10 IlHAOllpaHII,eB,
II,apb 6blJI 3eMHbIM BOrrJIOl..II,eHlleM 60ra,
HOCIlTeJIeM 60mecTBeHHoR CIlJIbl 28.
l103TOMY OCHOBHoe Ha3HaqeHIle II,a-
pfl - BeCT1I rr06eAOHOCHyJO 60pb6y C
BparaMIl II CJIep;RTb 3a rrOMepmaHlleM
IIopfiAKa, qTO CJIymllT rapaHTlleB 6JIa-
1'OrrOJIyqllfi Bcero HapOAa.
fJIaBHblR IIpa3)J;HIlK JilHAOllpaHII,eB -
HOBblR 1'OA COJIflpHOrO KaJIeHAapfl,
IIpllypOqeHHbIH K BeceHHeMY paBHO-
;:JeHCTBIlIO. 8TO AeHb II06ep;bl COJIHna
HaA MpaKOM II XOJIOAOM; B IlpaHCKOH
TpaAIlIl,ll1l 3TO TaKme AeHb rr06ep;bl 60-
llieCTBeHHoro repofl HaA Bpamp;e6Hb1M
3m.me II JIIOAflM 3MeeM AmllAaxaROR, KU-
TOpblR HaCJIaJI MpaK, XOJIOA II 3acyxy,
IlCCYlllHJI KOpHIl pacTeHIlR, 3aXBaTIlJI B
IlJIeH meHI..II,IlH. l106eAa repofl rrpllBo-
;:I;llT K oCB060mAeHIlIO CIlJI rrJIOAOpOAllfl
IIpllpOAbI II K HapoAHoMY rrpOIl,BeTa-
HlllO. I'epofl Bbl61lpalOT Ha II,apCTBO. Ta-
KRM 06pa30M, B HOBo1'OAHeM IIpa3wm-
he CJIIlBalOTCfI Boep;RHO KYJIbTbl COJIHII,a,
IIJIOAOPOAllfi II IIOqllTaHllfl II,a pfl 29.
8Ta Tpa)J;IlD;llfl BOCXO)J;RT K rJIy60KoR
iIHAOllpaHCKOH ApeBHOCTIl. B 11 paHe
OHa <I>IlKCllpyeTcfI yme B 3IlOXY Axe-
leH1IAoB: arraAaHa l1epcerroJIfI 6bI.la
rrocTpoeHa HaK MeCTO IlaHapllHeKTIX
HOBoroAHIlX <I>eCTIlBaJIeR, KYAa Bce Ha-
POAb! p;epmaBbI IIpIlXOp;RJIH IlOAHecTiI
IloAapKIl B AeHb HOBoro rOAa II,aplO,
BbIcTYIlaBllleMY B pOJIIl rr06eAoHocHoro
iJomecTBeIIHo1'O repofl. Pe.lbe<I>bl arra-
::JaHbl 1l306pamalOT rr06eAoHocHYIO 60-
pb6y II,apfi H Ha pOAII1.Ie IIpOIl,eCCHII B
J;eHb HOYPY3a 30.
B l1paHe na Tpap;RII,HfI COXpaHflJIaCb
BIIJIOTb AO XIX B. H HOBoroAHHe <I>eCTiI-
57
BamI 6hIJIIl B TO me BpeMH rJIaBHhIM
)J;IlHaCTlIqeCKIlM rrpa3)J;HIlKOM, Kor)J;a
maxy )J;eJIaJIIlCb D;eHHhIe rrO)J;HomeHIlH 31.
B MH)J;IlM 06PH)J; «KopOHaD;IlIl» D;apH -
AllIBaMe)J;xa - Tome 6hIJI rrpllypOqeH K
)J;HIO paBHO)J;eHCTBIlH, a BCTpeqa HOBO-
ro rO)J;a II y eOBpeMeHHhIx HH)J;HB:CKHX
HapO)J;OB, IlcrroBe)J;YIOm;llx 6paxMaHll3M,
OCTaeTCH O)J;HIlM 113 rJIaBHhIX rrpa3)J;HIl-
KOB. ITo MHeHll10 HeKoTophIX yqeHhIX,
I'IfMHhI PllrBeW>I COCTaBJIeHhI )J;JIH HOBO-
rO)J;Hero <pecTIlBaJIH, rrpll'leM rJIaBHOe
MeCTO 3aHIlMaeT paCCKa3 0 60Pb6e II
rr06e)J;e MH)J;phI II Boc.cTaHOBJIeHHIl KOC-
MIl'leCKOrO rropH)J;Ka 32.
K COmaJIeHIlIO, B rrllCbMeHHhIX IlC-
ToqHIlKaX 0 CKIl<pax HeT HIlKaKIlX CBe-
)J;eHIIB: HII 06 IlX KaJIeH)J;ape, HII 0 rrpa-
3)J;HOBaHlIll HOB oro ra)J;a, HII Bo06m;e 0
CIlCTeMe HX KOCMOrOHllqeCKHX rrpe)J;-
CTaBJIeHlllr. O)J;HaKO, rrpllBe)J;eHHhIe HH-
)J;OllpaHCKlle MaTepllaJIbI rr03BOJIHIOT rr;y-
MaTb, qTO II Y CKIl<pOB ll)J;eH 60pb6bI 6b1-
JIa KpaeyrOJIbHbIM KaMHeM IlX KOCMO-
rOHIlIl. B rrOJIb3Y 3TOll: mrrOTe3hI CBU)J;e-
TeJIbCTByeT TO, qTO )1;yaJIIICTINeCKaH
KOHI errD;HH 60pb6I.1 rrpOTHBOrrOJIOmHbIX
CIlJI JIemHT B OCHOBe Bcex HH)J;oeBpo-
rreaCKIlX Tpa)J;IlD;IlB:, II y Bcex HII)J;oeB-
pOrreB:CKIIX HapO)J;OB rrpa3)J;HIlK BeCHbI
BocrrpllHIlMaeTCH KaK rr06e)J;a CBeTa II
TerrJIa Ha)J; MpaKOM II XOJIO)J;OM, II corrpo-
Bom)J;aeTCH BeCbMa CXO)1;HhIMIl 06pH-
)J;aMil.
CY)J;HTb 0 TOM, CBH3aH JIll 6bIJI Y CKH-
<pO B IIpa3)J;HHK COJIHD;a II rrJIoJ\opoJ{lIH C
f' IIlld, ,;; , I'''.:' ''''''''.II l Id";J\. i ll\
u;apell. l,a";)TO 6bIJIO y ApyrHx HII;'\O-
HpaHu;eB, !WI'(a lie IIpe)J;CTaB.'lHeTCH BO:)
MomubIM,
TaKIlM 06paaOM, paCCMOTpeHIIe OT-
PbIBOqHbIX CBH)J;eTeJIbCTB, coxpaHenHbIX
IIHCbMeHHbIMrr ?:CTOqHHKaMH 0 pe.'1urllll
CKIl<pO B , IIa llIHpOKOM cpaBIIIITe,lb-
HO-HCTOpnqeCHOM HH)J;OHpaHCHOM OHe
rr03BO.'IHeT IIpeAnO;laraTb, 'ITO MHpOB03-
3pefIHe CKIf<pOB, KaK II )J;pyrrrx HH;:J:O-
IlpaHu;eB, 6bT.'lO )J;OBOJIbHO npHMIlTIIBHO.
CKH(paM 6bIJIH npIlCY H IlepeamTKH:
rrapD;lla.'1bHOll: Mamll, BepOBaHIIH B Ia-
rHqeCKlIe )J;ellCTBIlH II 06PH;:J:bl, <peTII-
IIIIlCTCKoe rrOKJIOHeHlle OT;:J:e;JbHbI
npe)J;MeTaM H mIlBOTlibIM, rrepemHThn
300JI,npnIf. MbIlII.TleHlle ChIl<pOB Obl.l0
ne aunpaKTHO-JIOrllqeChIlM, a o6paa-
HbIM II CIIMBO.'1llqecKIlM, xapaKTepn-
3YIOII IIMCH CIlHKpeTIl3MOM II rrO:IIlC e-
MaHTIl3MOM 06pa30B, 60JIbmen '1aCTbIO
300MOP<P H bIX.
B pe:mrIlH CI\Il<pOB orpOMHYIO pO:I1
IfrpaJI I_YJIbT rrpe)J;KOB. B OCHOBe llX
KOCMOrOHllqeCKHX rrpe)J;CTaBjIeHIlB: 6bI-
.'1a )J;yamICTllqeCKaH ll)J;eH 60pb6hI rrpo--
TIfBoIIo.TJOmHbIx CIlJI B rrplIpo,!\e.
ECJIIT IIpHHU;llrrllaJIbHO BepHa rrpo)J;e-
JIaHHaH IIorrbITKa peKoHcTpynpoBaT
!HpOB033peHlle CKH<pOB, TO ','lTO J);aeT
B03MO)f0l0CTb IIepeB:TIl K anaJIIl3Y lJ)J;eii-
Horo cO)J;epmaHIIH rraMHTHIlKOB CKIl«p-
CKoro IfcKyc.cTBa.
OCIIOBliaH oc06eHHOCTb CKH<pCKOro
H306pa;IIITeJIbHOrO TBOpqeCTBa - 3JJepH-
IIbIii CTII.7Jb - 3TO OTpameHHe npe,!\-
naB.TJPIIIlH 0 300MOP<PHhIX rrepeBorr.'1o--
lI{eHIfHX repOH31lpOBaHHhIX rrpe)J;KOB H
60rOB. nepCOHu<pIlD;IlPYIOlI\IlX HB.'1eHIlH
npHpOAhl.
Cnpnl1qJIIKa CKIl<pCKoro 3BepnHoro
("Tllill!. !I03BOJIHIOm;aH raBopUTb 0 HeM:
I;aI, 0 COBeplIIeHHO OC060M xY;:J:omecT-
BPHIIO" HB.'IeHHIl )J;peBHera lIlpa, CO-
CTOI1T B CII IIKpeTH3Me II OC 060ll ;:J:I1Ha-
mfl\e lI;jo6pameHIlB:, nepeJ\alOm.nx 0;:J:-
1I0BPI'\!PHHO lIeCKOJIbKO 06pa30B B
\1O I('ill '-'iJ[lJ.Ohl II IIOpblHlIl'Turo :IBII-
;J\CHII H H MeHHO 3Ta CTII:mCTUqeCKaH
'lepTa " "1I CKoro 3BepHHoro CTH.iH BbI-
;\C:!HP [' ('["0 II:J Bcex J\pyrHX CIICTe}1
113fJOP",<lITc.1LHoro TBOpqeCTBa. BhIpa-
OOT,l!1 II loIX (xy)J;ommmaMII )J;peBHOCTil.
OONI< III'IIII,! me JTIlX CTOpOH CKII<pCKO-
10 11<'1;,\ <'CTBa COCTOHT He B oCOOeHHG-
CTHX \ ';lOmeCTBeHHbJX BKYCOB CKII OB,
a IT (' 11.'ulI<pUqeCKIIX tlepTax HX IIIpO-
BO:I:q><'IIIIH II peJIHrIlIl.
npiJl'yro.1bHbIM KaMHeM KOC IOrOHIUt
58
II MH<pOJIOmII CI\H<pOB II )J;pyrllx I1H)J;O-
npanIJ,eB HBJIHJIOCb np'e)J;CTaBJIeHHO 0
MHOrOqllCJIeHHbIX nepeBOrrJIOrn;eHIlHX,
1I1II_apHaU;IlHX H pa3.1IIqHbIX IlnOCTaCHX,
B KOTOpbIX rrpeACTaeT Kam)J;oe 60meCT-
BO. J1MeHHo 3TIl ll)J;eOJIOrnqeCKlle npe)J;-
CTaBJIeHIlH 06YCJIOBII.iIn cIlHKpeTIl3M 06-
pa30B IlX IlCKYCCTBa. ITbITaHcb 1l306pa-
31lTb O)J;HO 113 60mecTB cBoera rraHTeo-
Ra, CKH<pCKllll MaCTep 6bIJI BbIHym)J;eH
cHa6maTb ero aTp1l6YTa IIl pa3JIIlqHbIX
-cym;ecTB, B KOTopbIe rrOCJIe)J;OBaTeJIbHO
BonJIOm;aJIOCb 3TO 60mecTBo. ITOCKOJIb-
KY Y Bcex HH)J;olIpaHu;eB, B TOM qllCJIe
y CKH<pOB, 6bI.'lO pacrrpocTpaHeHo rrpe)J;-
-CTaBJIeHlle IIa pJ IIaJIbHOB: Marllll 0 TOM,
qTO qaCTb BblpamaeT D;eJIoe, B CKIl<p-
'CKOM IlCKYCCTBe BIIO.1I1e 3aKOHOMepno
rro IIpllHU;llny pa rs pro toto rrOHBHJIIlCb
1I'306pameHIIH JIIIllIb qaCTII 06pa3a-
He rrTHU;bI, a JIIIIlIb ee raJIOBbI, I\JIIOBa
llJIIl KOITH, He KOIIH, a JIlllIIb era qaCTH,
XOTH 6bI TO.lbKO IWIIbITa H T. )J;. O)J;uaKO,
Ram)J;bIH 3TOT ;)JIeMeHT 6bIJI CTporo
oT06paH MaCTopOM H rrO)J;qllHeH 06rn;eH
ll)J;ee KOMrrO:3HU;IfII, IIpe)J;CTaBJIJIIOm;eB:
'OT)J;eJIbllbIii CIIIII;peTHqeCImB: 06pa3 HJIIl
D;eJIbIH Mn OJIOrlI'leCKIIB: ClOmeT.
CKH<pbI ne 3auMCTBOBa,11l Ha )J;peB-
HeM Boc.ToKe HH MIl<pO,JOI'H'le.cKlle CIO-
meTbI, UII CHIIKJH'TUqeCKHe 06pa3bI, HII
KOMII031il{IIH - Bce ;)TO 6blJI0 cneU;Il<p Il -
qeClnI CKII<pCKHM. BOCXOWIIU;IlM K rrpa-
I1paIlCKIl If)J;CO.l0rnqeCKilM rrpe)J;cTaB-
JIellJIHM; OJIH ;HJ HMCTBOBaJIIl JIlllIIb OT-
L{e,'1bHhIe 3.TJeMC'IITbI CTHJIIlCTIIqeCKOH
TpaJ;TOBI;n Tora. qTO Tpp60BaJIO BbIpa-
meHHH B COOTHI'T\'TBlIll C IIX c06cTBeII-
HbIMII 1)('.111 rITr ':1 H O-KOCMOJIOrnqeCKHM If
I;OIlU;e[[[.\IIH lII,
B ::JTO'I OTIIOIIICHlill OqeHb rrOKa:!a-
Te.lbBbl 110m II [,1 Meqa II3 KeJIepMeca,
'OT.TJHqaIOIl\JlCCH IIopa3HTe.ThHbIM 3KJIen-
Tn:J IOM, :\lIiI:lfJfnqHbIe HOmHM 6bIJIIT
HaiiAelILI H \It ',I hrYHOBCKOM Kyprane.
Ha I10mII,n IIp'';"'\cTaBJleH OJIeHb, aH-
TaCTII'leC"JIl' ,'\'1 I lPCTBa y ::\peBa mll:JHH.
TpaKTOBaHIII.I(' B ;lCCnpllB:CKo-y?apTCI;oH
MaHepe, HO BbIpamalOm;lle IlpaHCKYIO (II
o6IIJ,eqeJIOBeqecKYIO) ll)J;elO rrJIO)J;opO)J;IIH
(ceMaHTIlKa IIX rrpeKpaCHO IlCCJIe)J;OBa-
Ha); )J;aJIblIIe Il)J;YT <paHTaCTllqeCKIlO cy-
lI eCTBa C IIpOTOMaMIl qeJIOBeKa C JIYKOM
B pYKax, TYJIOBOM pbI6bI, HoraMH C IW-
IIbITaMIl II KpbIJIbHMIl Ha crrHHe. OT-
i-\eJIbHbIe 3JIeMeHTbI 3TIlX <paHTaCTHqe-
CKHX cym;ecTB, KaK H CTIlJIllCTllqeCKaH
TpaKTOBKa, TllnllqHhI )J;JIH ac.cllpHHcKoro
II ypapTcKoro HCKYCCTBa, HO rrpHMblX
aHaJIornB: rrpe)J;CTaBJIeHHbIM CIlHKpeTll-
qeCKHM cym;ecTBaM HeT. Kora me BH)J;eJ!
CKH<pCKIlll: 3aKa3qllK B 'ilTIlX IIPpCOHa-
max? B 3aMbH)J;-HmTe (34-38, 51, 68)
orrllCbIBalOTCH IlHKapHaD;1l1l XBapHa
(<DapHa) -nepcoHIl<pIlKaU;HH II06eJ\bl.
CJIaBbI. <DapH BOnJIOrn;aeTCH B 6apana,
B XHm;HYIO IITIlU;Y BapraH (cOKo.TJa-Op-
JIa), B pbI6y, B KOHH, B Bep6.'1IO)J;a, HaIW-
neu;, B BOIlHa. ITO-BIl)J;IlMOMY, B aIlTa-
CTllqeCKIlX cym;ecTBax, YKpalliaIOII\HX
HomHbI IreJIepMec.cI\Oro Meqa, MomBO
BIl)J;eTb rrorrbITKY MaCTepa 1l306pa3HTh
3TOT rJIaBHell:mllll: rrepCOHam HpaHcl\Oi"r
peJIllrnll, Ha)J;eJIHB era qepTaMIl, xapal\-
TepHbIMIl )J;JIH 60JIbmeB: qaCTll nepeBD
IIJIOrn;eHIlB: <DapHa.
B03MomHo, qTO B rrorrYJIHpnOM H
CKIl<pCKOM IlCKYCCTBe 06paae 6apall0-
rpll<pona, COqeTalOm;eM 3JIeMeHTbJ XlIlI -
HOH IITIlD;hI, 6apaHa II KOHH, Tanme CJIC-
)J;yeT BIl)J;eTb H306pameHIle <DapHa If.'111
CBH3aHHora C HIlM ceMaHTHqeCKII 60ri1
rpuMa II II06e)J;bI BepeTparHbJ, IIOAaTP.'IH
CJIaBbI (BaxpaM-HlIIT). Bce TPII 3.1eMCH-
Ta CHHKpeTlIqeCl\Oro 06pa3a oapalIo-
rpll<poHa - XHm;naH rrTHua, 6ap&1I 11
KOHb - B lIpaHcKoH Tpa)J;llUIfIf HB.'TfJ 10T-
CH BOIIJIOIu;eHIIHMIf H aplla II 111'[ll'-
TparHbI 33.
fepO)J;OT IIlIqerO He co06l1\al'T II II 0
KYJIbTe <DapHa, HH 0 Ky.'lbTe BI' IH'Ti'iI f-
HbI Y CKII OB. OAHaKO .iI. ;{, ,(I;I'
IIpHBO)J;IlT D;e.1hlll pH)J; TCO<pOPlIhIX II\(.'!I
C ((<papH», KOTopbIe OH IIO .11IIIfBIJl"TII'le-
CKIlM co06pameHIfHM CqlITaCT !Ie ?;ii' \1-
CTBOBaHHbIMIl H3 nepCH)J;CKoro. "'11; 110-
59
JIaraeT B. l1.. A6aeB 3S, a aBTOXTOHHbI-
Mil. BOJIbiliall nonYJIlIpHOCTb aTlIX IIMeH
CBIIp;eTeJIbCTByeT 0 TOM, 'ITO IIO'IIITaHlIe
cDapHa 6bIJIO IIHlpoRO pacIIpocTpaHeHo B
I1pll'IepIIOMopbe. qTO KacaeTCIl Bepe-
TparIIbI, TO II RYJIbT 60ra rpOMa II II06e-
P;bI TOiKe, MOiKHO P;YMaTb, cy ecTBOBaJI
Y CKll<p0B. B nOJIb3Y aToro roBOplIT TOT
<paIn, 'ITO 1\YJIbT BOCXOP;:UT K rJIyGo'Ian-
IlleR IIHp;OllpaHcRon p;peBHocTII: <PYHR-
qllll aBeCTlInCKOrO BepeTparHbI COBIIa-
)'(alOT C <PYHRqIIIIMII Bep;II'IeCRoro l1.H-
P;PbI, 3IIIITeT ROTOpOro <<II06ep;OHoc-
HbIii» - BpTparaH - IIpeBpaTIIJICIl B
IIMII IIpaHCROrO 60ra 3..
Ha IIO'IIITaHlIe BepeTparnbI eBpa3IIn-
CJ{BMll CTeIIHhIMII KO'IeBHHKaMII YKa3bI-
HalOT II p;aHHbIe oceTIIHCROI'D <pOJThKJIO-
pa; llMIl II06ep;OHOCHoro repoll HapTOB
BaTpap;3a HeIIocpep;CTBeHHO B03BOP;IITCII
K llMeHll BepeTparnbI", HapTOBCRlIn
BaTpap;3, IIOp;OGHO CBoeMY p;peBHeMY
:mOHllMY, IIepeBOIIJID aeTCIl B ROHII II
B Berep 38. CJIeP;yeT TalORe HMeTb B BII-
)'(y, 'ITO B Hap;IIIICII AHTlIoxa I KOMMO-
rena, rp;e 60rll IIpaHCROro IIaHTeOHa
OTOiK,[I,eCTBJIeHbI C rpe'IeCRIIMII, BepeT-
parna corrOCTaBJIeH C t'epaKJIOM II Ape-
COM". 0 RYJIbTe iKe IIOCJIe)J;HIIX Y CRII-
<pOB IIpllMO roBOplIT repo.n;oT (IV, 59).
TaRllM 06pa30M, MOiKHO IIOJIaraTb, 'ITO
IJ CKIJ.<pCKOii cpep;e, B KOTopon BoeHHall
A06JIeCTb IIO'IIITaJIaCb rJIaBHOii p;oGpo-
AeTeJIblO, a 06 ecTBeHHoe IIOJIOiKeHlIe
II )'(aiRe P;OJIII B p;oGbI'Ie OIIpep;eJIIIJIHCb
IJOIHlCI\lIMll 3acnyraMII (repop;oT, IV,
li4, 66) rrO'IllTaJIll BoeHHYIO CJIaBY II IIO-
uc)'(y. 810 06"bIlCHlleT 60JIbIIIYIO IIOIIY-
.1 HpHOCTb B CKR<pCIWM Mllpe ll3p;eJIlIii C
!l306paiKeHlleM rJIaBHbIX IIHKapHaqlln
cDaplIil II BepeTparHbI.
B CBeTe llH)'(OllpaHCKUX MaTeplIaJIOB
YL\aCTCIl pCKOHCTpYllpOBaTb II CUMBOJIH-
I>Y HeKOTopbIX I!306paiKeHllii COJIHqa B
[' hllfh "OM IICKYCCTBe. B Mll<pOJIOrllII
J1 H iIOlIpaHqeB, KaR II Bcex IIH)'(oeBpo-
noii lll' B, COJIHqe IIpe)'(cTaBJIIIJIOCb )'(BII-
FI, 'lrll'\ICIl rro He6y Ha KOJIeCHlIqe, 3aII-
pHmeHHoii: 'IeTbIpbMH 6eJIbIMII ROIIH-
Mil '0. B II03TII'IeCKOM H3bIKe 'IaCTO'
YIIOTpeGJIHJIOCb YIIoL\06JIeHlIe COJIHqa'
TOJIbKO ROJIeCHlIqe IIJIll ROJIecy IIJIII RO-
HIO (MIIXp-HIIIT, X; PB. VI, 51,1), ROHb-
COJIHqe - <lTO YCToii'IllBaH <popMy.'Ia-
CJIOBOCO'IeTaHlle u. rJIaBHall xapaRTe-
plICTIIKa ROHeii COJIHe'IHOii ROJIeCHII-
qbI - «6bIcTpbIe», a IIOCTOHHHbIii 3IIII-
TeT COJIIlI\a - «GbIcTpoRoHHoe». ABH-
iKeHlIe COJIHe'IHbIX ROHeii cpaBHIIBaeTCH
C IIOJIeTOM II'I IU bI, a 'IaCTO IITlIqbI (op-
JIbI) BbICTYIIaIOT BJIeRy mUl ROJIeCHll-
qy <2 (PB, VII, 63,5; IX, 71,9; IX,
97,33; X, 30,2; X, 55,6). 8Ta COJIHpHaH
CHMBOJIIIRa xapaRTepHa P;JIH Bcex mrp;o-
IIpaHCKRX HapO)J;OB, 'ITO )'(aeT OCHOBa-,
HlIe IIpoeqlIpoBaTb ee II Ha CRII<PCRYIO'
MH<pOJIOrnIO. B P;Pymx llH)'(oeBpoIIen-
CRIIX Tpap;:uqlIHx B Ra'IeCTBe COJIHe'IHOn
IITlIqbI <plIryplIPyeT TaKiKe JIeGep;b, IIO-
CROJThRY B EBpoIIe nplIJIeT JIeGep;en
3HaMeHOBaJI BecHy ". CooTBeTcTBeHHo,
1I30GpaiKeHHH JIe6ep;eii, OpJIOB, ROHeii B
CRII<pCK6M IICKYCCTBe MOryT paCCMaT-
plIBaTbCH RaR CIIMBOJIII'IeCROe BOIIJIO-
eHlle COJIHqa H. TO'IHO TaK me MOryT'
TpaRToBaTbcH II HeROTOpbIe cllHRpeTII-
'IeCRlIe 06pa3bI, rp;e rro 3aKOHaM rrap-
qlIaJThHoii MarIIII rrpe)'(cTaBJIeHbI JIIIIIIb.
'IaCTII YIIop;06JIHeMbIX COJIH Y IIpep;Me-
TOB II cy ecTB: II306paiReHHH KpbIJIa-
TblX ROHen, ROHeii-opJIOB, l\OJIeca II 'Ia-
CTII IITlIqbI (IIaIIpIIMep, p03eTKR, XBO-
CTI). IIJIII rOJIOBbI opJIa) " H «cernepoBa'
ROJIeca» - ROJIeCa C 'ICTbIpbMH ROHCKII-
Mil rOJIOBaMII B BllxpeBO I IJlliKeHllII '8.
O,ruraRO, KaK YiRe rOBOpIJ..'IOCb, P;JIH IIH-
p;olIpaHqeB 6blJI xapaKTcpen IIOJIIICe-
MaHTH3M, II ope.'l, II "OIl I> ObI.'lll aTpll6y-
TaMil HC TO;IbKO CO,lHIla. 110 II MHorllX
P;Pyrllx 60IjC>B II repocn, B 'IaCTHOCTII,
6JIII3He q OB-,IIIBllHOB 17, 'ITO CJIep;yeT'
Y'IllTbIBaTb IIPll UHTepnpt'TaqulI RaiK-
P;OI'D I\OHKpeTIWrO H:wopila'CHIJ.II. B 1\a-
'IeCTBe 6eccrropHoro CO.'lIlCqHOI'D CIIM-
BOJIa MOiKeT 6bITb rrpIJ.3IWIIO, rroiKaJIyii,
TOJIbKO cerHcpOHO KO.le',I). nOCROJIbKY
3TOT CIIMBOJI OIIlIcaH B PlIrBep;e II B
ABecTe. ,
B rrpep;CTaBJIeHHII IIHp;olIpaHqeB r.laB-
HaH oc06eHHOCTb COJIHqa - 6bICTpOTa
era p;BlIiKeHIIH. B II03TII'IeCKOM 1I3bme
3TO HamJIO BIJ:pameIme B C03 aHilII IIO-
CTOHHHoro 3IIHTeTa COJIHqa «6bICTpO-
ROHHoe» <8. B II30Gpa3IITeJIbHOM TBOp-
'IeCTBe Ta iKe ocooeHHOCTb BbIpa3ll.TIaCb
B 06pa3e KOHH, IIpep;CTaBJIeHHOrO B
CTpeMIITeJIbHOM p;BlImeHIIII, B JIeTIIIII,eM
raJIorre. TaRIIM 06pa30M, )'(aiRe TaKall
'lepTa Xyp;OiKeCTBeHHOI'D CTIIJIII CKII<pOB,
RaR JIeTHIII,IIn raJIOII, 06YCJIOBJIeHa Bccii
CIICTeMoii IIX MlI<pOJIOrn'IeCKllX rrpe)'(-
CTaBJIeHlIn.
B OCHOBe KOCMOrOHl'IlI IIH)'(OlIparrqeB,
B TOM 'IIICJIe, BIIP;:UMO, II CRII<pOB, JIeiRf!-
JIa p;yaJIIICTII'IeCKaH ROHqeIIqIIII 60pbUbl
IIpOTIIBOIIOJIOmHbIX CIIJI B IIpllpo)'(e II otJ-
eCTBe. OTCIOp;a - CIOmeT 60pb6bl B
CRII<pCKOM IICKYCCTBe. AJIH Borr.TIOIIl,eHIIII
op;Hoii 1I3 rJIaBHbIX TeM CBoell MII<pO.'lO-
rIIII CRII<pbI IICIIOJIb30BaJIII ROMrr03II IIIO,
C03p;aHlIYIO Ha p;peBHeM BOCTOKe 3a)'(0.'1-
ro AD IIX IIOHBJIeHHH Ha IICTOpll'IeCKOll
apeHe.
¥ 3eMJIep;eJIb'IeCRIIX Hapop;OB I1epcp;-
Heii A3HII IIOTpe6HOCTII X03IIllCTBa BbI-
3bIBaJIH HeoGxOp;IIMOCTb B IIpep;CKa3aHll-
HX IIO 3Be3p;aM HaCTYIIJIemm ce30Ha
p;OiKp;en:, II03TOMY YiKe B rny60KoH iIpeB-
HOCTII IIX 3HaHIIH B 06JIaCTll aeTpOHO-
MIIII 6bIJIII BeCbMa OCHOBaTe.'lbllbBIlI.
BbIJIO 3aMe'IeHO, 'ITO IIOHBJIeHnC H ole-
Ha Ha HeGoCRJIOHe C03Be3,"(llll IDtelOT
qIIKJIII'IeCRlIii xa paRTep. BeCHOH. B !lOPY
Ha'IaJIa IIOJIeBbIX pa60T, cO:1Be3AlIe .-hna
3aKpbIBaJIO Ha He6e C03Be3AIII' f1,Wfl;:l
(IIO-illYMeplIiicKll - «3Bc3p;a [;1>11>:1» )
II c03Be3p;IIe KacclIorrerr (IIo-mpl('i'lIii-
clm - «3Be3p;a OJIeHII»). 8TO HB.WIIIII' B
II306pa3IITeJIbHOM TBOp'leCTne ncpe:llle-
a3IIaTCRIIX Hapop;oB Borr.lOTII.10Cb II ['Ile-
He Tep3aHlIH 6bIJ\a If.TIII O.'H'HH ,11"'.O 1.
B aCClIplIn:CRYIO II aXeMCHII;:ICKYj(, .'BOXY
JTa cqeHa, HaplI,'(Y C rtCTpa:lloi/ bnl.
IIplI06peJIa II coqlla.TIbHbIii OIbIC.1: :leB
60
CTaJI paCCMaTplIBaTbCH RaR CllMBOJI IIO-
6ep;OHOCHora qapH, II, HaRoHeq, IIOHBII-
JIaCb ROMII03llqlIH, rp;e qapb IIoGeiKp;aeT
.TIbBa, YTBepiKp;aH CBoe Mory ecTBo '..
MeHHJIb P;IO BIOIICCOH IIpep;.TIaraeT
)'(PyryIO TpaRTOBRY :JTora aCTpaJIbHOrO
ClOiKeTa, paCCMaTplIBaH ero RaR II306pa-
iReHlle CMeHbI P;HH II HO'III so. ITo MHe-
HllIO iKe AIOmeHb-rlIn:eMIIHa, CIIMBO.rrII-
'IeCROe 3Ha'ieHlIe 3TOn: ROMII03IIqHB lIIe-
HIIJ'IOCb Ha IIpoTHiKeHllII BeROB II Y pa3-
HbIX Hapop;oB, a B axeMeHIIp;cRoM IICRYC-
CTBe cqeHa TpaRTOBaJIaCb RaR IIoGep;a
qapH Ha HOYPY3e st.
C YTpaTon: HeIIocpep;CTBeHHoii: CBH3II
Tpap;IIqlIoHHon KOMII03lIqIIII B IICRYC-
CTBe C IIopop;rrBillllMII ee aCTpaJIbHbIMII
IIpep;CTaBJIeHIIHMII Ha MeCTe JIbBa CTaJIH
nOHB.TIHTbCH P;PyrlIe XIIIII,HHKR, Ha lIIeCTe
6bIKa - p;pyrne ROIIbITHbIe. MMeHHO Ta-
Kall TpaRTOBRa xapaRTepHa P; H CKII<p-
CRoro II306pa3IITeJIbHOro TBOp'IeCTBa,
rp;e IIepBOHa'IaJIbHaH CIIMBOJIIIRa YiKe
Ha'IIICTO 3a6bITa II HapHP;Y C peaJIbHbIlII1I
mlIBOTHbIMII IIOHBJIHIOTCH <paHTaCTlI'Ie-
CKlIe CIIHRpeTII'leCRlIe cy ecTBa, C03-
p;aHHbIe <paHTa3IIen: CRII<pCKRX MaCTe-
pOB. HeT B03MomHOCTH Cyp;:uTb, BOC-
nplIHHMaJIII JIll CRII<pbI 3TY xapaRTep-
HeiimyIO P;JIH IIX II CRYCCTB a cqeHY
Tep3aHlIH 52 RaK ROCMOJIOrn'IeCKlln aRT
TBopeHIIH 'Iepe3 YHII'ITOmeHHe, aIIo<pe03
BeCHbI II Ha'IaJIO COJIHe'IHOrO rop;a UJIII
l\aR II06ep;y 60iKecTBeHHoro repoH, If.TIII
era 3aMeCTIITe.'1H - qapH. CRopee Bcero,
I!MeJIa MeCTO IIop;MeHa MaRpOROCMoca
II IIIIIKpOROCMoca, CIIHTe3 HaTypaJIIICTII-
'IeCROrO II coqllaJIbHOrO CIIMBOJIII3Ma,
'ITO Bo06II1,e O'ICHb CBOHCTBeHHO P;JlH 1II1-
pOBOCIIplIlITIIII Bcex llparrOlI3bI'IHbIX Ha-
pOp;OB.
ECJIII coqlla.1bHbrii acrreKT cqeHbl TCp-
laHIIH IIp06J'IC1IaTII'IeH, TO B CRll<pCKOM
nCRYCCTBe eCTb 6eccrropHbIe II306pame-
nllH rr06ep;bI 60fa II.1II qapH Ha)'( XIIW;RII-
KOM ll;III 'Iyp;OBllIIl,eM S3. TpaRTOBKa 3TO-
ro CIOiKeTa TaKiRe BOCXO)'(lIT R IIepe)'(He-
a3IIaTCROMY llCRYCCTBY s', HO II)1elI
61
.oeI'O - CKII<pc.l<aH II 06 ellpaHCKaH.
TIpep;CTaBJIeHHbIR rrepconam, rro MHe-
Hino B. H. rpaKOBa, T'epaKJI-TaprH-
Tall - pOp;ORa'IaJIbIIIIK CIUI<p0B. CKii<p-
cmiR TapnnaR lIapaJIaTa - 3'1'0
rrpHMaH rrapaJIJIeJIb aBeCTUB:c,KOro Xao-
IIIbHHxa (XOIIIaRra) llapap;aTa - rrep-
Boro n;apH llpaHn;eB, OCHOBaTeJIH rreIIIp;a-
P;HTCKOU p;HHaCTHH 50. To me OT-
ROCHTCH II K XaOIIIbHRY, K Tap-
rHTaIO 56.
B HpaRCKoii MH<pOJIOI'l'IH orrllCI>lBa-
.eTCH cpameRlle Xomarrra C TllpaROM
.lJ:axaKoR, rrpeBpaTHBIIDIMCH B 'IYP;OBll -
1I0ro 3MeH. IJ,apb 6POCllJI B 3MeH Ka-
MeRb, KaMeRb BhIceK llCKpy II 3arOpeJICH
orORb. B 'IeCTb rr06e,ll;bI X()IIIaRra Rap;
p;paKOROM Amll .lJ:axaKoii II pa Rn;hI
CrrpaBJIHIOT rrpa3p;R'HK orRH Cap;a, Kor-
p;a u;apb 3amHraeT orRll 57.
K COmaJIeRllIO, B llCTO'IrrHKax 0 CKll-
<pax neT RHKaKllx CBep;eRllB: Rll 0 cpa-
meRHll TaprllTaH, RH 0 rrpa3p;RllKe 3a-
mHraRllH qapeM OrlIeB:. Ho Momrro rro-
JIaraTb, '1'1'0 CXOP;RhIB: Mll<pOJIOrll'IeCKllii
ClOmeT II 06PHP; cy ecTBOBaJIll y C.KH-
4>OB. B rrOJIb3Y 3Toro cBllp;eTeJIbCTByeT
cpep;Hea311aTcKllU MaTepllaJI: rro co06-
ll:\eHlllo HapIIIaxH, rrpa3p;HllK Cap;a 0'1'-
Me'IaJIH B Byxape 58. llo cBllp;eTeJIbCTBY
fepop;oTa (IV, 68), CKll<phI rrO'IHTaJIll
QrOHb qapcKoro O'lara. Ho caMbIM Bam-
HblM a pryMeRToM HBJIHeTCH CKH<pcKoe
11306pa3HTeJIbHOe TBOp'IeCTBO: B ux llC-
KYCCTBe 6hIJI He TOJIbKO 06pa3 repOH,
cpamaIO erOCH (: 'Iyp;OBll eM, RO II 1130-
6pameHue TpeXrJIaBOI'O 3MeH 59, rrOJIHO-
CThlO COOTBeTCTBYIO ee orrllcaRHIO B
1 B. r. J]y'Wltllll. KY.1lbTypa caCa[[[[IIC"oro
HpaJ1a. M., 1969; /0. A. Pannonopr. H3
IfCTOpHH pCiIlIruH ipeBHero Xopc3Ma. M.,
1971; B. A. J]ur8,mc,wu. KanrlOiiCKO-
capMaTcHIiR <papH. I1ymaH6c, 1968; Olt :!ICe.
pcBIIile I;o<U'BIIII"" «KpblmH Mllpa». M.,
1972, CTp. 142; /(. C. Pae8C1>UU. CHII<pclmii
III<poiIOrn'ICCKlli[ C[ ,meT B I1CIiYCCTBC II
1I):\cO.1l0rnn napCTRa ATell. CA, 1970, M 3;
Olt :!ICe. 0 CC IaHTHKe OLlHoro 1I3 oopa30B
ABeCTe: «3 IeR .lJ:axaKa C TpeMH rraCTH-
MH, C TpeMH 6aIIIKaMll» (3aMbHp;-HIIIT,
37).
TaKllM 06pa30M, He TOJIbKO HeKOTO-
phIe CTHJIHCTH'IeCKHe oc06eHHOCTll CKll-
<pCKom HCKyc.CTBa (3BepHHhIB: CTHJIb,
CHHKpeTH3M 06pa30B, JIeTH IlB: raJIorr),
HO U OTp;eJIbrrhIe CIOmeThI II KOHKpeTHble
rrepCOHamH Haxop;HT llCTOJIKOBaHHe rrpll
paCCMOTpemm CKll<pCKOB: Mll<pOJIOrllll
Ha <pOHe 06 eHpaHCKllx H IIIHpe - 06-
eapHiicKHX BepoBalIHii II rrpep;CTaBJIe-
Hllii.
Op;HaKo, KaK yme rOBOpllJIOCb, HeJIb3H
omHp;aTb, 'ITO KamD;oMY rrepcoHamy
CKII<pcKoro IlCKYCCTBa yp;acTcH HaB:Tll
CooTBeTcTBYIO lle llHp;ollpaHcKlle rra-
pa.TIJIemr. HeAb B pa3HhIX 06JIaCTHX HH-
p;OHpaRCKoro MHpa B KORKpeTHhIX llC-
TOpH'IeCKHX YCJIOBHHX Kamp;hIB: CIOmeT
rrpuo6peTa:J cBoe06pa3RYIO OKpaCKY u
rrO)JBepraJICH TpaHc<popMaqllu. K TOMY
me rraMIiTHIfKH, KOTOphIMU MhI pacrro-
.'1araeM p;JIiI peKoRcTpYKq:Ull,- Plll'Bep;a
H ABecTa - cop;epmaT pa3HOBpeMeRHbIe
'IaCTH U OtJeHb C.lIomHhI P;JIH HHTeprrpe-
TCll\HIf.
HaKOIIeI . H PHrBep;a U RIIIThI
ABec.ThI !l:pCBHee Tex co06 eRHB: 0 p;y_
XOBHOB: KYJI bType CI\lltPOB, KOTophIe
OCTaBJIellbI rpe'IeCI\UMH llCTopllKaM:U.
TI03TOMY rrOrrblTI\a corrOCTaBJIeHHB: II
rrepeHOC Ha C.I\Il<pCI\HB: MaTepllaJI p;aH-
RbIX 0 MllpOBO;J3peIIHll p;pyrnx UHP;O-
upaHIJ,eB lOrYT 6bITb crrpaBep;JIllBhI
JIHWh rrpn peI\OHCTpYKqHH OCROBHhIX
pc.'rnrno3J!o-KooIOrOHU'IeCI\HX KOHu;eu-
U;HR H OC-OOPIIHocTeR MhIIIIJIeHHH.
Hascplliue co BcaLlIIIII;aMII 113 AareCTaHa.
CA, 1973, M 2, CTp. 188-189; olta '!!'e. Ce-
.\IaHTIlIia 1I306pamcIIIIII na cepeopllHoM
):\IICKe II HCI>OTOpbIe sorrpOCLI IIIlTegrrpeTa-
HH aMYLlapbHHcl;oro KJlaAa. «COOpllIIK
rraMIiTH B. B. lIaB.1Iosa». 1\1., 1976.
< I. Duchesne-Guillemin. A la recherc es
d'un art mazdeen. «V Congress of iranIan
Art and Archaeology.. Teheran, 1972,
p. 265-270.
J H. Oldenberg. Die Rcligionen des Veda.
Berlin, 1894, S. 29.
, B. CPo MUAAep. 'IepTbI cTapHHbI B CKaaa-
IIHIIX H 6bITe oceTIiH. JKMHI1, 1882,
T. CCXXI!, M 7-8; B. H. A6ae8. OCeTlIH-
CKHII lIabiR Ii <pO.1lbIiJIOp. M.- J1., 1949;
ON xe. AOxpHcTHaHcIiall peJIHrHII aJIaH.
«XXV MemLlYHapoLlHbIR KOHrpecc BOCTO-
KOBeAoB. AOKJIaLlbi Lle.'lCra HH CCCP.. M.,
1960, CTp. 2; Olt Xe. KY.1lbT ceMII 60r?B
y CRI!<PoB. «ApeBHIIII MHp.. M., 1962,
CTp. 445-450.
5 fOBOpll 06 ABCCTC, Mbl OYACM IIMeTb B BII-
AY B rrepBYIO O'IepC;1b lie faTbI, oTpamalO-
He MOpaJIbJ10-3TH'IeCIiIlC II a6cTpaKTHo-
<pHJIOco<pclme rrOllRTUR, rrpOIiJIaMHpOBaB-
lliHeCIi 3apaTymTpoll, a HlliTbI, KOTopbIe
6bIJIH COCTaSJICHbl rrOCJIe rrporrOBeLlII «rrpo-
pOIia.), 110 LlOIICCiIll OTrOJIOCKII 60JIce ap-
XaHqHbIX BepOBaHHI[, coxpaHIIBlliHxSII
BOCTO'IIIOHpalicKoii cpeLle C r.1lYOOIiOII
LlpeBIIOCTli.
· ABCCTlliic"oc BbIpa;J;l'III1C, ynoTpeOJIIIl'MOe
B 3HaQl'I1IflI «MOJIllThl'H), «llOQUTaTb» )];0-
CJIOBHO 0311aqaeT «npHIIOCIITb mCPTBY,)
(C. H. C01>n..08. fLu,[I< ABecTbI. J1., 1964,
CTp. 13). CJIona ";!;paTb», «mepTBa!,
«"'PCIl» CBHaaHbl BO [1I0rHX HHLloeBporren-
CKHX 113bmax (I. Casabona. Recherches
sur la vocabulaire dcs sacrifices en grec
de l'originc a la fin dc l'ep09ue classique.
Aix-en-Provpncp, 1966, p. 2,,); E. Benve-
niste. Relations Lexicales entre la Perse
ct la Grece ancienlI('. «La Persia e iI mon-
do grcco-romano». Homa, 1966.
7 T. H. E..U30peli"n80, I'lIrBcAa. I1epeBoll II
"omleHTaplfii. :\1., 1 I'i , CTp. 4 ; 1. Web!!.r.
Indische StmliclI, .\" I. LelpzIg, 1813,
S. 217: S. Leu;. I." doctrine du sacrificc
dans lcs Brahman", Paris, 1898, p. [33-
134; V. Henry. La IlIa ic dans I'Incle an-
tique. Paris, 1904: F Henvelllste. es Ma-
ges dans l'Ancipnt Iran. PublicatlO!ls dc
la societe dc" etu.!',- iranicnncs, b. Pa-
ris, 1938: ,If. .11nl.' Hilnel et cschatologie
dan Ie maz.!,"'-II:", «:'-lumen., 1960,
v. 7/2-3; M .II ok I ,dte. my the et histoi-
rc dans la ,'(;Iigioll .I,. ("Iran. Paris. 1963;
1. Duchesne-GI/ill. '1. Symbols and Va-
lues in Soroa triall.-IJ1. Ncw York, 1966.
C!;IUPC (;om nc ":-'CCTBa. «HoRoe B apxeo-
.'lOrrTl!» 1\1 1972: B. A. H..bllnC1>aR. Ha-
ReIH!II[ !I t J\1aIIHOrrCI<Oro II HOBOqCpKaC-
('!;oro '\';H'IR. CA. 1967, M 4: olia :JICe.
h '.lhT(JH'.". ,!;f'a,ll>l CI;II<pcl;oro H rrpeA-
('!;[I(!"'/iI"" BpCMcnll. MHA, M 130. M.,
196,1: F: F f(Y3b.<tulia. IJ,fIiIlIHAPH'IeCKall
lIe'Ii1TI, II.< \!l'f)BCIiOro oa3nca co C[\CIIOII
£,:111110 0 01" Illil. dfcTOpHIl IIpancIioro rocy-
i!apCTIH' II !;YJIbTypbP'. M., 1971; olta :JICe.
62
8 T. H. E..1l3apelt1>08a. 'Kaa. COq., CTp. 65,.
67.
9 ll. r. replfeli6epz. Mop<pOJIOrlI'IeCKall
CTpYKTypa C.1IOBa B LlpeBHeHpaHcKHx lIabI-
Kax. J1., 1972, CTp. 23, 29.
10 L. Renou. Etudes vediques et pannineen-
nes, t.. V. Paris, 1939, p. 45; f:. Reno/l. a
langue et la religion dans Rigveda. «DIe
Sprache., 1949, N 1.
11 E. Benveniste, L. Renou. Vrtra et Vrvrag-
na. Paris, 1934.
IZ T. H. EAU3apelt1>08a. YKa3. COq., CTp. 46-
47; E. Benveniste, L. Renou. YRaa. COq.,
CTp. 194. . .
tJ F. Cumont. Textes et monuments flguree
relatifs aux mysteres de Mithra. Paris,
1896; I. Gershevit.ch. The Avestian Hymn
to Mithra. Cambndge, 1959, p. 4.
,. r. IlIaltae8. IIa oceTIIHCKHX CKaaaHHR 0
HapTax. «C60pHI!R cBeLleHHII 0 KaBKa3CKHX
rop ax., BbIII. IX, OTLleJI I I. TH<pJIHc, 1876,
CTp. 1-6; B. CPo MUA..ep. 'IepTbi CTaplI-
IIbI.., CTp. 199-200; E. E. f(Y3bM.u,:a. Ce-
MallTH"a Ha06pameHHII Ha cepeoplllloM
LlHCRe.
t5 T. H. E..u3apen1>08a. YKaa. COq., CTp. 72.
18 r IlIaltae8. YKaa. Coq., CTp. 8.
17 s: Levi. YKaa. Coq., CTp. 133-134.
18 E. E. liY3bM.Una. PaCilpOCTpanCHilC 1;oIlC-
BOLlCTBa H KYJIbTypa ROHII Y IIpa1l01l3bl'l-
HbiX UJIeMeH CpeLlHeR A31I1i H AP»TIIX lIa-
pOLlOB CTaporo CBeTa. «l1CTOplI (o-Iiyiib-
TypHoe HaCJIeLllle HapoLloB CpeAHeII A311"').
M., 1976.
19 H. lJypcun. OceTHHbI. «lOro-OCCTIIII'),
BbiU. 1. TII<pJIHc, 1926.
ZO A. Christensen. Le premier homm et Ic
premier roi dan l'hi oire Iegen aIre d<cs
Iraniens. «Archlv d etudes orIentaleL»,
Uppsala, 1917, N 14; .1934, N 27; U. SchneI-
der. Jama und Jaml (Rv X, 10). «Indo-
Iranian Journah, 1967, V. 10, N 1.
ZI B. rarue8. CyeBepHIl H IIpcApaccYAIiIl y
OCCTHH. «C60pHHK cRe):\clIHii 0 "aBKaa !;IIX
ropl\ax», T. IX. TH<pJillc, 1876; E. E. 11 y.,b-
M.ulta. PacnpocTpaneIIlIe l;onCBOAcTBa..
zz B. B. H801t08. ApeBHelIliLllIiicImc pn ya.lh-
IIbIe H MII<p0JIOrllqec[;r!c Tep I11I!LI. oopaao-
BaHHblC OT asva - IiOlfb. «npOO:Ie [bl IfC-
TOpHH 113bIIiOB " Ky.lbTypbI HapoAoB Ii 11-
LlHH. naMIlTH B. C. BopoGbPBa-)J,ecIlToR-
CKOro». M., 1974, CTp. 75-138: P. J)/lmont.
L'Ashvamedha, dcscription du sa fI fr<:c
solennel du cheval dan lc culle VcdH{11e
d'apres Ie textes dll Jajur\'eda blanc. Pa-
ris, 1927. . ... I
2J H Guntert. Del' arische "'eltkol1lg \lnl
H iland. Halle, 1923, S. 367: C J)un/ont
Homo hierarchicus. Paris, 1966: ,I. 1I.,:'th,
The Religion and Philosophy of tJ.p \ ed;)
63
and Upanishads, v. II. Cambridge, 1925,
p.845.
H H. NlIberg. Questions de cosmogonie et
de cosmologie mazdeennes. «Journal Asia-
tique), t. CCXIX, N 1-2, 1931; W. Brown.
Theories of Creation in the Rig Veda.
JAOS, 1965, v. 85; I. Duchesne-Guillemin.
La religion de l'Iran ancien. Paris, 1968,
p. 268-269.
25 G. Dumezil. Aspects de la fonction guer-
riere chez les Indo - Europeens. Paris,
1956; H. Lammel. Del' arische Kriegsgott.
Frankfurt, 1939; V. V. Ivanov, V. N. To-
porov. Le mythe indoeuropeen du dieu de
l'orage poursuivant Ie serpent. Melanges
G. Levi Strauss. Paris, 1969.
26 P. Thieme. Mitra and Aryaman. «Transac-
tions of the Connecticut Academy of
Arts and Sciences), 1957, N 41; H. Lii-
ders. Voruna, I. Gottingen, 1951; I. Ger-
sh.evi ch. YKa3. COq.; L. Campbell. Mith-
ralC Iconography and ideology. Leiden,
1968.
., T. H. EA.U3apenKo8a. YRa3. COq., erp. 43-
45; E. E. [(ysbMuHa. IJ;HJIIIHAPUqeCRall IIe-
qaTb.., CTp. 184-185; E. Benveniste, L. Re-
nou. ¥Ka3. COq., CTp. 187-195; H. Nyberg.
Die Religionen des Alten Iran. Leipzig,
1938, S. 283; S. Wikander. Vayu. Uppsa-
la - Leipzig, 1941, S. 131.
28 G. Widengren. The Sacral Kingship of
Iran. «La Religita Sacra.. Leiden, 1959,
p. 242-258.
29 [(. A. Hnocrpan/{e8. CacaIlIIAcKllii IIpa3;J;-
HI!K BeCHbi. «1KI!BaH CTapIIHa,), CI16.,
Bblil. II-III. 1909, H. Masee. Le livre de
Gerchasp. Paris, 1951; P. Diba. No-Rouz,
Ie Nouvel an iranien. Un mithe de l'eter-
nel retour. «Actes de la XVII rencontre
assyriologique internationale*. Bruxelles,
1970, p. 93-96; P. Diba. No-RoUl the New
Year - a Mithe of Eternal Retour. «VI
Congress of Iranian Art and A rchaeolo-
gyt. CambridgE', 1973, p. 15; E. Porada.
Aspectes of Iconography of the King in
Achaemenid Art. «VI Congress of Iranian
Art and Archaeology,), p. 62.
30 I. Deshayes. Origine et signification des
repr sentations symbolique a Persepolis
«MaJalla-1 daneskade-c adabi \"at va
ulum-e insani, Tehran') 14e annce N 4
(1965), p. 12; I. Duches e-Guille min: A Iii
recherches, p. 268; F. Bode. Symbolic Ele-
ments of Achaemenian architectural Or-
nament. «VI Congress...., p. 9. J. fep -
<peJIbA CqIlTaJI, qTO B I1epceno.le 1!306pa-
meH APyroII oOIQellpaHcKllii CO. RpHblii
npa3AHI!K - mithrakan (E. Herzfeld. The
Persian Empire. Wiesbaden, 1968. p. 18).
11 H. A. [(UC.tRK08. HeRoTopbIe ITpaHCRlIe 110-
BepbH I! npa3AHI!KI! B onRcaHIIJIX 3anaAHO-
eBponeHcKlix nYTemecTBeHHHROB XVII B.
«MI!<pOJIOrIiH I! BepOBaHBJI HapoAoB Bo-
CTO'lHOH II IOmHoII A31!1!). M., 1973,
CTp. 180-183.
32 F. Kuiper. The Ancient Aryan Verbal
Contest. «Indo-Iranian Journab, 1960,
N 4, p. 4.
3' HOCI!TeJIeM <papHa Cql!TaeTCI! n a Bap-
raH I!JII! CeHMypB (A. Carnoy. Iranian
Mythology. Boston, 1917, p. 289-290).
BOT IIOqeMy mJIeMbi I! KOpoHLI I!parrCKIiX
I! cpeAHea31!aTCKI!X npaBI!TeJIeH YKpame-
Hbi IITJIqLI!MI! nepbHMIl (E. Herzfeld. Iran
in the Ancient East. London - New York,
1941, p. 296; B. H. BauH6epa. PaHHJIJI xo-
pe3MI!IICKaH MOHeTa 1!3 co6parrilli CaMap-
KaHAcKoro MY3ell I! HeKoropble BonpocbI
I!CTOpl!1! AOKymaHcKoi XOpe3MI!HCROi qe-
KaHKI!. BAM, 1962, 1<12 1, CTp. 1Z7-128).
.. L. Zgusta. Die Personennamen griechi-
scher Stiidte del' Nordlichen Schwarzmeer-
kiiste. Praha, 1955, S. 141, 184, 197, !36-
239. OAHaKo B pa60Te «J1l!qHble I!MeHa B
rpeqeCKHX ropoAax CeBepHoro I1pl!qepHo-
MOPbH) (Co06IQeHI!I! qeXOCJIOBa KI!X Opl!-
eHTaJII!CTOB. M., 1960, CTY. 104) J1. 3rycTa
rOBOpI!T, qTO IIOHHTl!e ««papH) 6b1JIO 3a1!M-
CTBOBaHO CKII<paMI! y nepcoB.
35 B. H. J\6ae6. App.BHenepcl!AcKl!e 3JIeMeH-
Tbi B oceTIIHCKOM H3b1Ke. «MpaHI!Ka),
Bblil. 3. M.- J1., 1945.
'8 E. Benveniste, L. Renou. YKa3. COq.,
CTp. 194-195.
37 JI. r. rep/{eH6epa. Xiimici Fyrt. «AKTyaJIb-
Hble BOIIpOCbI I!paHI!CTI!KJiU. M., 1970,
CTp. 37.
'8 r. illaHae6. YKa3. Coq., CTp. 9.
.9 I. Dumezil. Jupiter, Mars, Quirinus. Pa-
ris, 1941, p. 63. B CaCaHI!ACKOM HpaHe
BepeTparHa Tome aCCO l!lIpOBaJICH C fe-
paKJIOM (Ph. Ackerman. Verthraghna Ava-
t rs. «Iranica antiqvM, IV (1), p. 61).
'0 A. Roes. L'animal au signe solaire. ('Re-
vue archeologiquet, 1938, v. 12, p. 164;
R. Pettazoni. L'onniscienza di Dio. Tori-
no, 1955.
U JI. r. rep/{en6epe. Mop<poJIomqecKall
CTpYKTypa, CTp. 117.
U B. B. H8aHo6. OIIblT I!CTOJIKOBaHI!II...
H I.-P. Vernant. My the et pensee chez les
grecs. Pari 1965.
H B KaqeCTBe OJIHpHOrO CI!MBOJIa B eBpa-
311IICKIIX dfeIIllx YiloTpe6JIliJICH TaKme
OJIeHb. Ho pa360p CJIOmHOII ceMaHTHKII
3Toro 06pa3a BblXOAIiT 3a paMKH AaHHoii
pa60Tbi.
.5 [(. CPo CMupno8. CaBpoMaTbi. M., 1964,
CTp. 219, pHC. 77, 78.
.6 B. A. H.tbuncKaR. KYJILTOBbie me3JIbI..,
pliC. 4; M. I. Artamonov. Goldchatz der
Sky then. Praque - Leningrad, 1970, fig.
127; Laszlo Gyula. L'art des nomades. Bu-
dapest, 1972, fig. 11.
" B. B. H 6aH06. OTpameHl!e IIHAoeBponei-
CROII TepMI!HOJIOrl!1! 6JIII3HeqHoro KYJIbTa
B OaJITl!lICKI!X H3b1Kax. «BaJITO-CJIaBHH-
CRIIII c60pHI!K). M., 1972, CTp. 199; E. E.
[(ysbMuHa. KOHb B peJIl!rl!1! I! IICKYCCTBe
caROB I! CKI!<pOB (B neqaTI!); I. Przyluski.
Les asvin et la gran de deesse. «Harvard
Journal of Asiatic Stulies), vol. I, 1936,
p. 132-133.
U B. B. H6aH08. MCilOJIb30BaHI!e AJIII 3TI!MO-
JIOrHqeCKIiX I!CCJIeAOBaHlI1I coqeTaHHII OA-
HOKopeHHblx CJIOB B II033111! Ha ApeBHl!x
IIHAoeBpOlielICKI!X H3b1Kax. «3TI!MOJIOrI!H,
1967.. M., 1969, CTp. 54.
.9 W. Hartner, R. Ettinghausen. The Con-
guering Lion, the Life Cycle of a Symbol.
«Oriens), 1964, v. 17, p. 161-170.
50 «Le Comte du Mesnil du Buisson. Le
my the oriental des deux geants du jour
et de la nuit). «Iranica AntiqvM, VIII,
1968, p. 1-33. 3Ta TpaRToBKa COMHI!TeJIL-
Ha.
51 I. Duchesne-Guillemin. A la recherche
d'un art, p. 268-269.
52 M. I. Artamonov. ¥Ka3. COq., Ta6JI. 116,
118; 120--122; 132; 159--170; 185; 237;
64
3 CKHto-cB6IIJICKHA 3Bepll1lHA CTJIJIh
242-246.
.. TaM me, Ta6JI. 153-155; 184; 292-294;
M. H. Pocro6/{e8. CKII<pIIH I! BOCilOp. CI16.,
1925, CTp. 447; B. H. rpaKo8. CKH<pCKIiH
repaKJI. RCMMMK, Bblil. XXXIV, 1950,
CTp. 12-17; M. H. ApraMoHo6. AHTPOIIO-
Mop<pHble 60mecTBa B peJIllrll1l CKH<pOB.
ACf3. J1., 1961, CTp. 78-79.
5. E. Herzfeld. Die Kunst des zweiten Jahr-
tausends in Vorderasien. Archiiologische
Mitteilungen aus Iran, Bd. VIII, Heft 3,
1927; Bd. IX, 1938. Berlin; H. Gaterbock.
Narration in Anatolian, Syrian and Assy-
rian Art. «American Journal of Archaeolo-
gy), 1967, v. 61, N 1, 63-69;
E. E. [(ysbMuna. IJ;IIJIHHAPJl'leCKali lie-
qaTb.., CTp. 180-189.
55 A. Christensen. YKa3. COq., CTp. 133-140,
164.
56 9. A. rpaHro8cKui1. (<<MHAo-l!paHCKl!e Ka-
CTbI y CKI!<pOB. AOI<JIaAbI AeJIera 1!1! CCCP
Ha XXV MemAYHapo;:\HoM KOHrpecce BO-
CTOKOBeAOB». M., 1960) cql!TaeT, qTO CbI-
HOBbH TaprllTall 6bI.1U OCHOBaTeJIHMII Ka-
CTOBoro CTpOIl CKII<poB.
57 H. A. KUCARK08. YK33. CO'l., CTp. 187-
189.
58 M. Hapwaxu. MCTOplI1I Byxapbl. TamKeHT,
1897, CTp. 37.
59 M. I. Artamonov. YKa3. COq., Ta6JI. 143.
H. A. OHaHKO
(MeJIl,rYROBCKIlii, KYJII,OGCKHii, AJIeI-;-
CaHp;pOnOJII.CImii, qepTOMJIbIJ\ II p;p.)
03HaMeHOBaJICH rJIaBHbIM oGpa30M orr-
pep;eJIeHHeM 3THH'IeCJ\oii HX npIIHa;:l-
JIemHOCTH, a TaJORe onpep;eJIeHHe ! 31-
RH'IeCJ\oii npHHa,ll;JIemHOCTH ManopOB
H QeHTpOB npOH3Bop;CTBa 30JIOTbIX xy-
p;omeCTBeHHbIX H3p;eJIHll:, oGHapYiKCH-
HbIX B 3THX J\ypraHax. Op;HaJ\O, eC.ll! rro
nepBOMY Bonpocy Bce HCCJIep;OBaTc.'lH
BbICJ\a3aJIIICI. ep;I!Hop;ymHO 3a rrpIIHa)I-
JIemHOC'fI. 3TlIX COJ\pOBHII\ CJ\lIcpa !, TO
110 OCTaJII.HbIM BonpocaM cpa3Y ;I,l' IIa-
MOTHJIOCI. HOCROJII.KO TOqeI( :1J)('IlniI.
TaJ\. M. E. 3aGeJIIIH, JI. CTeqlaHII,
H. ll. KOHp;aJ\OB, M. M. TOJICTOi\: II pHg
P;PyrHX IICCJIep;OBaTeJIeii QeHTpOM npOl!3-
Bop;CTBa paCCMaTplIBaeMOI'O I(pyra ne-
lI\eii c.'IHTaJIII A<pHHbI. CTOpOHHlIhl! :1py-
roii, GOJIee rr03p;Heii TOqRlI :!PClIIIfI-
A. <DYPTBeHrJIep HerO rrOCJIe)IOmne.'lH
-.A. H. illBapQ, B. It Ma.TjL IGCpr,
M. 8GepT, B. B. <DapMaRoncRni\: BhICKa-
bIBaJIHCb 3a 1I0HIIiicRoe rr[JOIICXf);('JJ:e-
HHe 3THX BelI\ell. ITplI 3TO ! ITpC.lno.la-
raJIOCb, 'ITO rrog06HbIe 1I');!C.1IIH "'r.T3
H3rOTaBJIlIBaThCH I! nil lOre POCCIII! aT-
TH'leCJ\HMH (It IlIBa6e, 13. fpeq) H.1H
HORHllClm 1.. MaCTepa !II (<D. BIIIITCp).
HeJ\OTopbIe' pelI\lI, I,aK HarrpII ep. OOIIB-
KH HomeH y.'Ib06cKoro Meqa. OTHOCII-
.'IIICb J\ H3p;eJIlIHM CKllcpCI\lIX lacTf'I")R '.
HeCMOTpH !Ia 3TY rreCTpOTY IIJCHrrfi,
GbIJIO Bce me OqeBIIp;HO. 'ITO ITI'0n:me-
p;eRHH rpe'IeCKIIX !aCTepOB :ja II" \I.l.1Il
B COJ\pOBHlI\ax CKH<pCKHX J\ypraHoB
BIIp;Hoe MeCTO. BMeCTe, C TeM, cpep;H
RHX BbIp;eJIHJIHCb BeII\H, COBepmeHHO He-
xapaJ\TepHbIe P;JIH rpe'IeCKorO HCKYC-
CTBa, II BelI\I1, cop;epmalI\I1e CMemaH-
RbIe, rpeKO-BapBapCKHe 3JIeMeHTbI p;e-
Iwpa. B HHX HamJIH OTpameHHe 3.'leMeH-
TbI coGcTBeHHO HCJ\YCCTBa 3BepIlHoro
CTIIJIH, HCKYCCTBa p;peBUeBOCTO'IHbIX Q1I-
BIIJIH3a.n;Hii H rpe'IeCKoro HCKYCCTBa.
Bce ::!TO nepep;aBaJIOCI. K TOM)' me rro-
pOlO B YCJIOmHeHHbIX, B nepepaGoTaH-
RbIX nO-CBoeMY xyp;omecTBeHHbIX <pop-
Max, 3aTpyp;HHIOII\HX II rro ceB: p;eHb
pacKpbITHe Hp;eiiRoro 3aMbICJIa ClOmeTa,
ero Ha3Ha'IeHHH II 3THII'IeCKOB npH-
Ha,ll;JIemROCTH MacTepa.
OcoGeHRo MROro HRTepeCYlOlI\HM Hac
BorrpOCOM 3aHHMaJICH M. M. POCTOBQeB.
Ero nepy npHHap;JIemaT crreQHaJIbHbIe
paGoTbI, nOCBm:n;eHRbIe H3Y'IeHHIO 3Be-
pHHOrO CTHJIH, a TaJORe OTp;eJII.HbIe
3J\CRypCbI 0 HeM B <PYHp;aMeHTaJII.HbIX
nCCJIep;OBaRHHX no CeBepO'IepHOMOp-
CJ\oii npoGJIeMaTHKe. CaMII Ha3BaHHH
TaJ\HX ero paGoT KaK «8JIJIHHCTBO
n HpaHCTBO Ha lOre POCCIIH», «CKHcpIIH
H Bocnop» yme rOBopHT 0 TOM, RaRoe
GOJII.mOe 3Ha'IeRIIe M. M. POCTOBD;eB
rrpHp;aBaJI 3THM BamHeiimHM HCTOpHRO-
J\YJII.TYPRbIM BJIHHRIIHM, xapaKTepHbIM
P;JIH CeBepROrO llpH'IepHOMopI.H. MMeH-
HO eMY npIlHap;JIemHT 3aCJIyra B rrmpo-
KOB rrOCTaHOBKe Bonpoca 0 CBH3HX gpeB-
Reii I1CTOpHH 3TOll oGJIaCTII C I1CTOpIIell
MIIPOBOll KYJIbTypbI BooGlI\e H C IICTO-
plIell aHTH'IROrO Mllpa B 'IaCTHOCTII".
KacaHCI. B3aHMOCBH3II CKHcpCKoro II
MaJIOa3lIITCROro 3BepIIHOrO CTIIJIeH.
M. M. POCTOBQeB nOJ\a3aJI CYlI\eCTBeH-
Roe pa3JIH'IIIe Memp;y HIIMH B TeXHIIKP
II xyp;omecTBeHHOB: TpaRTOBKe 06pa30B.
MOHlIllCKoe IICKYCCTBO He !OiKeT 06'b-
HCHHTI. II rJIaBHbIe MOTIIBbI HalI60.'Iee
paRHero CKB<pCKoro 3BepIlHoro CTIIJIH.
MCXOP;H H3 3TOro, I1CCJIep;OBaTeJIb rrplI-
meJI J\ BbIBOP;Y, 'ITO MbICJIb 06 IIoHlIrr-
CJ\OM rrpOHcxomp;eHBH ::!Toro CTIIJIH He-
3BEPIIHbIH CTIIJIb
II AHTl1qHbIM: MI1P CEBEPHOrO llPIIqEPHOMOPbH
B VII-IV BB. .IJ:O H. 8.
TaK Ha3bIBaeMbIll: CKH<pCKHii 3BepHHbIB:
CTHJII. rrOJIy'IHJI IIIHpOKoe pacrrpOCTpa-
HeRHe B IICRYCCTBe MHornx Hapop;OB.
CeBepHoe IT plI'IepROMOpI.e rrpep;CTaB-
JIHeT OP;HY 1I3 60JII.mlIX oGJIaCTell:, rp;e
3TOT CTIIJIb rrpOllleJI p;JIIITeJIbHbIH II CBoe-
oGpa3HbIll rryn pa3BlITHH, CTaB OP;HOll
I13 ocoGeHHocTell IICJ\YCCTBa oGIITaBmHX
TaM MHOl'O'IIICJteHHbIX fiOqeBbIX rrJIeMeH.
B CHJIY IICTOpIIqeCRII CJIOmIlBmIlXCH
YCJIOBIIll B CeBepHOM IT pH'IepHOMOpI.e
3BeplIHbIll CTH.'Ib pa3BIIBa.'lCH rrop; CIIJII.-
HbIM B03geltCTBlIeM IICJ\YCCTBa rpe'Ie-
CRIIX rOpO,i\OB, I\QTopoe, B CBOIO O'Ie-
pep;b, IIcrrbITa:IO B 1I3BeCTHoii Mepe BJIII-
HHBe IICKYCCTBa RO'IeBHIIJ\OB.
M3Y'1eHlIe norrpoca 0 B3aHMop;ellCT-
BlllI rpe'IeCKOrO IICJ\YCCTBa .H 3BepIIHO-
1'0 CTII.1H CeBepHoro ITpHqepHOMOpbH
IIMoeT MliorO.'ICTIIIOIO IICTOplIlO. Op;HaRO
crreD;I1a.TJbHhIX pa60T no 3TOMY Bonpo-
cy, RaK II paOUT, rrOCBHlI\eHHbIX rrpo-
6JIeMe B3arr lOoTHOIIIeHlIii rpeROB H J\O-
'IeBHIIROB B IIe.10 !, rroJ\a HeT. HaIIGo-
JIee HpKOC BblpaiKeHlIe B3alI !O)IellCT-
BIle rpe'IeCJ;oro IICKYCCTBa II 3BepIIHOro
CTIIJIH HaIII.10 B ceBepOrrpH'IepHOMOp-
CRHX xy;wiKeCTBeRRblX H3;I,eJIIIHX H3
)!eTaJIJIa, qTO OTpamaeT p;aBHIOIO Tpa-
,i!,IID;1I1O MeTa.l.1006pa6aTbIBalOlI\erO pe-
leCJIa KaI\ \' I\O'IeBblX rrJIeMeH 3TOt! oG-
.1aCTII, TaK II IIoce.1IIBIIll!XCH 3p;eCb rpe-
KOB.
ITeplIO:1 (,TI;PbITIIH rrepBbIX 60raTbIX
I\ypraHoB 11 CeBepHOM ITpH'IepHOMOpbe
66
060CHOBaHHa 3. BMeCTe C TeM, OR nop;'Ie-
pKnyJJ P;OMHHHPYIO IO pOJII. HOHHii-
Clmx 3JIeMeHTOB B I1HBeHTape GoraTI.IX
CKII<pCJ\HX norpeGeHHii'.
BOJII.mOe 3Ra'IeHHe rpe'IeCKOMY 3JIe-
MeHTY B CKH<pCKOM HCKYCCTBe npIlp;a-
BaJJ f. BopOBJ\a. CCbIJIaHCb Ha C. Peii-
HaRa, OH npIl3RaBaJI «rrOpa3IITeJIbRoe»
CXOP;CTBO HeKOTOpbIX 3JIeMeHTOB CKH<p-
CKoro I1CKYCCTBa C J\pIlTO-MHReHCKHMII,
OTMeTHB, 'ITO 3TO COOTBeTCTBHe OCTaeT-
CH rroJ\a 3arap;KOll 5. MHTeHCHBHoe rpe-
'IeCKOe BJII!HHHe Ha ceBepOnpH'IepHO-
MopCKoe CKH<pCKoe I1CKYCCTBO OR oG'b-
HCHHeT TeCRbIMH CBH3HMH rpe'IeCKHX ro-
pOP;OB C nJIeMeRaMH KO'IeBRHKOB, OCO-
6eHHO B oGJIaCTII KepqeRcKoro npOJIHBa.
3ac.'lymHBaeT H3BecTHoro BRHMaRHH
rrorrbITJ\a K. IDe<p0JIbp;a p;aTI. TIInOJIO-
rrr'IeCfiYIO J\JIaCCII<pIIKaQIIIO II CTHJIHCTH-
'IeCJ\IIB: pa3Gop xapaJ\TepHbIX P;JIH Ce-
BepHoro llpH'IepHOMOpI.H oGpa30B 3Be-
pIIHoro CTHJUI.. K. ille<pOJII.AY yp;aJIOCI.
rrORa3aTI. oGlI\ee HarrpaBJIeHHe pa3BH-
TIIH 310ro CTHJIH, a TaKme Cp;eJIaTI. pHP;
BaiKHbIX HaGJIIOp;eHHB P;JIH ero xapaKTe-
pIICTIIKH. OTMeTHB HaJIII'IlIe pa3JIH'IRI.IX
xygOlliecTBeHHbIX MOTHBOB B p;eKope
rrpep;MeTOB 3BepHHoro CTHJIH, K. IDe-
cpOJILP; OTBeJI GOJII.mOe MeCTO B HHX rpe-
qeCKHM. OH, KaK H P;PyrlIe HCCJIep;OBa-
Te.'IlI, C'IHTaJI, 'ITO rpeKH BbInOJIRHJIH
TaIOHe pOJII. HOCH'fe;Ieii nepep;Hea3HaT-
CEoro BJIHHHHH B CIGI<pHII. OTMe'IaeT-
C H paHHlIii npoQecc 3JIJIIIHH3aQIIH 3Be-
pIIlloro CTHJIH P;JIH KyGaHcJ\oii oGJIaCTH.
lIe BbI3bIBaeT COMHeHHB: rrpaBIIJII.HOCTI.
.1C1TIIpOBOR MHornx BelI\ell.
II. H. ITOrpeGOBa B cBoell peQeH3HH
na CTaTblO K. ille<pOJIbp;a YKa3aJIa, 'ITO
paccMoTpeRHe 3BepHHoro CTHJIH 3THM
JlCc.TJC OBaTeJIeM C rr03HD;I1ll JIl!IIII. rpe-
qeCROrO HCKyccTBa rrOMeIIIaJIO eMY npa-
Brr:lbHO rrOHHTI. BnyTpeHHlIe 3aKOROMep-
nOCTII pa3BHTIIH ::!Toro CTIIJIH. He Y'IH-
TbIBa.TJ K. ille<poJIbp;, KaJ\ 3aMeTHJIa
H. H. ITorpeGoBa, CBH31I 3THX HBJIeRHii
]I C ROHJ\peTRoii HCTOpH'IeCKOii H reor-
67
3.
pa<{J.II'IecKoii cpep;oii 7. Op;HaKO, crrpa-
Bep;JI.IIBO yrrpeKHYB K. llie<pOJIbp;a B
<pOpMaJIbHO-CT.IIJI.IICT.II'IeCKOM aHaJI.II3e
3Bep.IIHOrO CT.IIJIII, H. H. IIorpe60Ba TO-
me p;orrYCKaeT Offi.II6KY .lITeM caMblM
rrpOT.IIBOpe'I.IIT ce6e. STO npOT.IIBOpe'IIIC
3aKJIIO'IaeTCII B TOM, 'ITO rrp.II3HaBall
BHYTpeHH.IIe rrpoqeccbl pa3BlIT.IIII 3Be-
p.IIHOrO CT.IIJIII HeJIb311 .IICKaTb rrpH'I.IIHY
yrrap;Ka aToro CT.IIJIH B TBOp'IeCKOii
p;eIlTeJIbHOCT.II rpe'IecK.IlX MaCTepOB Ce-
BepHoro TIp.II'IepHOMopbll. B aTOM CKa-
3aJIOCb BJI.IIlIH.IIe B3rJIIlp;OB r. BOPOBKI'I,
KOToporo He .II36emaJIa .II B. A. I1JIb.IIH-
CKall 8.
OTKpblT.II1I B 3l1B.IIe nOCJIym.IIJI.II TOJI-
'IKOM K Harr.IICaH.IlIO 60JIbffiOrO 'I.IlCJIa pa-
60T, B KOTOpblX 3aTpanIBaIOTCH aHaJIO-
rH'IHMe ceBepOrrp.II'IepHOMOpCKI'Ie KOM-
rrJIeKCLl, a B CBII3.II C aT.IIM, eCTeCTBeH-
HO, .II rrpep;MeTbI rpeKo-BapBapCKoro
.IICKYCCTBa, cop;epma .IIeclI B aT.IIX KOM-
rrJIeKcax. TIpaBp;a, OTHOC.IITeJIbHO rro-
CJIep;H.IlX He Bee .IICCJIep;OBaTeJI.II rrplI-
p;epm.IIBaIOTCII ep;.IIHOrO MHeH.IllI. TaK,
TI. AMaHp;p.II, Harrp.IIMep, aHaJI.II3.IIpYII
KeJIepMeCCR.IIe .II MeJIbryHoBCK.IIe Be .II,
P;OBOJIbHO CRenT.II'IeCKI'I rOBOp.IIT 0 rrp.II-
Hap;JIemHOCT.II p;.Ilap;eM, 3epKaJIa .II pIlTO-
Ha K rpeRO-BapBapCKI'IM .II3p;eJIIIIIM. Ha
aTOM OCHOBaH.II.II OH rrplIffieJI K BblBOP;Y
o TOM, 'ITO rpe'IeCKOe IICKYCCTBO B EB-
porre He CblrpaJIO H.IIKaKOii pOJI.II Ha aTOB:
CTap;lI.II pa3B.IITlIII 3Bep.IIHOrO CT.IIJIH.
B TO me BpeMH, COrJIaCHO .IICTOp.II'IeCKI'IM
<paKTaM, OH He OTp.IIqaeT B03MomHOCTlI
rrpOHIIKHOBeH.II1I aJIeMeHTOB rpe'IeCRO-
1'0 IICRYCCTBa B CKII<pCKoe eIl\e P;O ero
rrOIlBJIeHlI1I B IOll\HOH POCCIIII. 8TO
BrrOJIHe corJIacyeTclI C rrplI3HaHlIeM
TI. AMaHp;plI TOH CJIOmHOCT.II OTHOIIIe-
H.IlH B 06JIaCT.II .IICKYCCTB, KOTopali .IIMe-
JIa MeCTO B rreplIOp; <pOpM.IIpOBaH.II1I 3Be-
p.IIHOrO CTIIJIII 9. Y6ep;.IITeJIbHblM rrplIMe-
pOM KOHRpeTHblX B03MomHOCTeD: )J,JIII
3a.IIMCTBOBaHlIH .II rrepepa60TKlI rro c06-
cTBeHHoMY BKYCY OTp;eJIbHblX 06pa30B
m.IIBOTHblX CJIym.IIT npOaHaJI.II3IIpOBaH-
HMH aTIlM IICCJIep;OBaTC.1IeM TaR: Ha3bl-
BaeMblii CKI'I<pCKI'IH MOTIIB JIema ero
mllBoTHoro C rrop;orHYTblMII HOraM.II '0.
CBII3IIM Memp;y IICRYCCTBOM pa3JI.II'I-
HblX Hapop;OB, xyp;omecTBeHHoe TBOp-
'IeCTBO ROTOpblX rrop;rOTOB.IIJIO rrO'IBY
P;JIII rrOIIBJIeIDIII 3BeplIHoro CT.IIJIII, yp;e-
JIlIeTCII 60JIbiliOe BIDIMaH.IIe B pa60Tax
P. rlIpiliMaHa. OH OTMe'IaeT, 'ITO B Ha-
CTOIIIl\ee Bpe)I1I MomHO I'OBOplITb .'l.IIIIIb
o ClIM61I03e RYJIbTypbl CRII<pOB, MIIP;.IIii-
qeB .II RIIMMep.IIHqeB. B CBOIO O'lepep;b
B IICRyccTBe MIIp;.Illl:qeB MOrJI.II CMeillaTb-
CII BO BTOpOD: rrOJIOBIIHe VII B. 11,0 H. a.
ypapTIID:Clme, aCCilplID:CKI'Ie, MeCTHLle
MaHHeHCKI'Ie II, B03MomHO, .IIOH.IliiCK.IIe
'IepTbI. B pa:mIIT.II1I me rpe'IeCKoro .IIC-
KyccTBa CRa3aJIlICb <pIIHIIKIIHCKoe II
ClIplIiicRoe BJI.IIIIH.IlII, a TaIORe BJI II 11-
Hilii XypiiTCROrO .IICKyccTBa. 31IBlIe-
rrplnwp CMeilieIDIII pa3JI.II'IHblX KYJIb-
TYp. IKIITeJIII YpapTY .II I1paHa, KaK
nOJIaraeT P. rIIpiliMaH, C03p;aJI.II «KOH-
Ha» B MCTaJIJIe. 8TO(<ROHHa» Ha 3arrap;e
.II Ha ceBepc corrplIRaCaJIOCb C rpeRaM.II,
KOTopble B IICp.IIOP; CTaHOBJIeH.II1I YpapTY
rrpOHIIRaJIII na 6epera MaJIoii A31I1i. Ra-
callCb CBII3ell: 3arrap;a C I1paHOM, P. r.IIp-
IIIMarr BbI)J,e.1IIeT TPII qeHTpa, ROTopLle
HaXOp;lIJIIICL Ha rrYTII p;OCTaBK.II B rpe-
qlIlO BOC TO'IHbIX TOBapoB: BOCTO'IHaH
rpel(rrii (CaMOC, S<p ec ) , RPIIT, Ro-
p.IIHcp. Orr )J,orrycRaeT TaRme HaJI.II'I.IIC
CB1I3ei1: 3TPYCROB C .IIpaHIJ;aM.II tt.
B 1964 r. BbliliJIII B CBeT CTaTb.II
B. . E aBaTcKoro 0 B03p;eiicTBlIlI aH-
TII'II!OH ],y.1LTypbI Ha CTpaHbl CeBcpHo-
1'0 T1pn'lepHmwpbH. RacalIcb xY)J,ome-
CTnenllLI x IIO)J,e.'10R B 3BeplIHoM CTIIJIe
rpe'lCCKII\ )!aCTepOB, B. . E.'!aBaT-
CRIIi! BhICI,a:Ja.'1 MblCJIb 0 TOM, 'ITO (<3T.II
1I3)J,e.'!IIf1 .1ni:rreHbl CTporOH rrpOCTOTbl
meiIeBpoB )! TO-CKlICPCROrO MaCTepCT-
Ba. II !IX nIIKaR He.lb311 rrp.II3HaTb CY-
meCTBeI!IILD! BRJIap;O}! B xyp;omecTBeH-
Hoe Tn0I"leCTBO CeBepHoro TIplI'IepHO-
MOpLH. OUpa3qOM TaKHX rraMIITHIIKOB
Moa;eT c.lya;.IITb cplIrypa OJIeHII .II3
RYJIb06cKOro KypraHa...» 12. STY TO'I-
KY 3peH.Il1I pa3p;eJIIIJIII B CBoe BpeMII
.II MLl ".
B rrOCJIep;IDIe rop;.bl 60JIbllIOe BHIIMa-
H.IIe BorrpocaM rrpO.IICXOmp;eH.II1I .II pa3-
B.IIT.IIII, .IICKYCCTBa 3BeplIHoro CT.IIJIII,
a BMeCTe C TeM .II pOJIII B HeM rpe'IeCKoro
IICKYCCTBa yp;eJIIIJI rroKoiiHblii M. 11. Ap-
TaMOHOB. RaK .II MHOr.IIe .IICCJIep;OBaTe-
JIll, OH rrOJIaraJI, 'ITO CBII3.II CKII<pOB II
rpeKOB MOrJIII OCYIl\eCTBJIIITbCII e e B
rrep.IIOp; IIX BJIap;bl'IeCTBa B TIepep;Heii
A311.II. IKIIBOTHble C B.IICIIIl\IIM.II HOraM.II
II CBepHYBIII.IIeCII B KOJIbqO, TaK Ha3bl-
BaeMhre - rrepeRpY'IeHHble mIIBOTHble-
CTaHp;apTHble MOTIIBbl MIIKeHCKoro .IIC-
KYCCTBa. M. 11. ApTaMOHOB YKa3blBaJI
TaRme Ha CBII3b 6apaHo-rrTlIqbl C xeT-
TCKIIM, ypapTclOIM II rpeKO-IIOH!ID:CR.IIM
rplIcpOM ". 06paIl\alI B3rJIllp; Ha 06 IIH
xop; pa3B.IITilII 3BeplIHoro CTIIJIII B Ce-
BepHOM TIplI'IepHOMOpLe, M. 11. ApTa-
MOHOB Bblp;eJIIIJI P;JIII 3TOii 06JIaCT.II TPII
OCHOBHLlX xy p;omeCTBeHHO-CT.IIJIIICT.II-
'IeCKHX Te'IeHIIII, rrp.II3lIaB, 'ITO «E. B.
<DapMaROBCRIIll: C ero TeoplieH .IIOH.IIH-
CROro rrpOlIcxom)J,eH!I1I CR.IIcpCKOro .IIC-
KYCCTBa If M. 11. PocToBqeB C I1paHOM
RaR IICTO'IHIfROM ero cpOpM .II ClOmeTOB
B 1I3BeCTHOH Mepe 6blJl.Il rrpaBbl» 15.
M. 11. ApTaMOHOB OTMe'IaJI TaRme YC-
TOi!'IIIBOCTL IIp;eOJIOr.II'IeCROrO cop;epma-
HIIII 06pa30B, YKa3blBali Ha .IIX RaHO-
H.Il'IHOCTb II rrOBToplIeMOCTb 16.
KpoMe OTMe'IeHHbIX 06Il\IIX pa60T,
B ROTOpblX B Toil 1I.1I1 IIHOH Mepe 3aTpa-
r.IIBaIOTCII BorrpOCLI B3alIMOOTHOIIIeHlIII
rpe'IeCROrO I! }!CCTHOro IICRYCCTB B Ce-
BepHOM TIpn'ICpHOMOpLe, .IIMeeTCII plIP;
CTaTeii, rrOCBII!I CnIIbIx aHaJI.II3Y OTp;eJIb-
HblX BeIl\eil. TaK, eIl\e B 20-x 1'1'. BbllUJIa
CTaTbli K. !\1a.1KI!IIOH, B ROTOpOH pac-
CMaTplIBaeTcli 3no.llOqlIlI II 3JI.1IIHII3a-
qlIlI MOTIIBa norn mIIBoTHoro 17. 06pa-
3Y rPlIcpa B IICKYCCTBe CeBepHoro TIpII-
'IepHOMOpLfI II()CBIIIl\eHa CTaTbll H. H.
TIorpe60Boii 18 .
EO.'1bIIIIIM COOLITIIeM B .II3)"IeH.Il1I pac-
68
CMaTp.IIBaeMOro Borrpoca IIB.IIJICR BblXOP;
B CBeT cTaTeii M. 11. MaKC.IIMOBOH 0 Ke-
JIepMeCCKlIx 3epKaJIe II p.IITOHe 19. B HIIX
p;an TIl\aTeJIbHblii .IICRYCCTBOBep;'IeCRIIH,
a TaRme B .II3BeCTHOH Mepe IICTOpIIKO-
KYJIbTYPHblH aHaJIlI3 3T.IIX Be ei!, CBII-
p;eTeJIbCTBYIO .IIii 0 rpeRO-BapBapCKOM
.IIX rrpO.IICXOmp;eH.IIII.
IIp.IIp;epm.IIBallcb rrpIIHIITOll: TO'IRII
3peHlIH 0 rpe'IeCKOM rrpo.IICXOmp;eHIIIi
30JIOTblX 06KJIap;OK HomeH paHHlIx Me-
'Ieii .II3 TIplI,IT.HerrpOBblI, H. A. OHaHRO
BbICRa3aJIa MLlC.JIb 0 rrpO.II3BOp;CTBe
3T.IIX 1I3p;eJI.IIii Ha Eocrrope, rrOKa3aB
rpeKO-BapBapCK.IIH lIX xapaRTep 20.
M. 11. ApTaMOHOB rrpOaHaJIlI3IIpOBaJI
1I306pameH.Ile RYJIb06cKOro OJIeHII, rrop;-
TBepp;lIB paHee BLlcKa3aHHYlO TO'II,y
3peH.IIII r. BOpOBKII .II p;pyrlIx 0 rpe-
'IeCKOM ero rrpolI3Bop;cTBe. RacalIcL xa-
paKTeplICTIIK.II TBopqa 3TOro rrpolI3Be-
p;eH.IllI, M. 11. ApTaMOHOB rrOJIaraJI, 'ITO
rpe'IecKI'Ie MaCTepa 6blJI.II CJIIIIUROM p;a-
JIeK.II (<aT rrOH.IIMaH.II1I CTIIJIII c06CTBeH-
1I0 CK.IIcpCKoro .IICKYCCTBa»21.
11 TaK, .IICTOp.II1I 1I3Y'IeHIIII B3aIlMOOT-
HOIIIeH.IIH rpe'IeCROrO II BapBapcr;oro
IICKYCCTBa B CeBepHOM TIplI'IepHO-
Mopbe, CBII3aHHaii rJIaBHbIM 06pa:JlJM C
.IICCJIep;OBaH.IleM 3BeplIHoro CTIIJIII, JlO-
Ka3blBaeT, 'ITO Ha RaRIIX-TO paHJIHX
3Tarrax cpOpMlIpOBaH1I1I 3Toro CTII.'!H.
eIl\e B YCJIOB.IIIIX TeCHbIX IwnTa KTOB
rrepep;Hea3lIaTCRlIX CTpaH, rpe'lCCKOe
IICRYCCTBO He OCTaBaJIOCb B CToponc OT
3TOro npoqecca. TIpaBp;a, aTOT cpar;T He
CJIep;yeT rrepeoqeHIIBaTb, HO II HP:\O-
oqeHRa ero TaRme rrOBJIeKJIH ObI :;a l"U-
60H He06'beKTIIBHYIO xa paRTCpIlCTJ1 KY
pOJIII rpe'IeCROrO IICRyccTBa n pa:!BII-
T.II.II 3Bep.IIHOrO CTIIJIII. 11, BO:IMOIKIIO,
6blJI rrpaB M. 11. PocToBqeB, r;oTopbJii
e e 50 JIeT Ha3ap; rrlIca:I: « B \" I J J rr
VII BB. 11,0 H. 3. rpe'IeCRlIll rCl!llii B
MaJIOH A31I1I yme BbIKOBaJI II:! CT<ll'hl x
3reHCRlIX 3JIeMellTOB B CO'IeTanJ1n C :1.\-
p;omeCTBeHHblM TBOp'IeCTBO)! BOCr()j'i
CBO.II HOBbIe qeHHocTII, IIORa Ha" }lil.lO
G'J
eru;e 1I3BeCTHhIe»2>. B aTOM OTHOilieHIIII,
noma;rryH, e e MHoroe MOryT p;aTb HaM
caMhIe paHHHe CRII<pCKHe ROMrrJIeKCbI,
BhI3BaBlmm rrOBbIIIIeHHbIH IIHTepec B
CBII3H C OTRphITHIIMH B 3IIBlIe.
TeCHaH CBR3b rpe eCRoro IICKyccTBa
H CKH<pCROro 3BepHHoro CTHJIII B Ceaep-
HOM TI pR'lepHOMOpbe GOJIee eM oqe-
BII,IT.Ha. 3p;eCb OHa 6bIJIa oc06eHHO
aRTHBHOH. Hailia 3ap;aqa - ROHKpeTII-
3lIpOBaTb H oG'beKTIIBHO On;eHIITb TO
ElaCJIep;lIe B ceBepo epHOMopCROM IICKYC-
crne, ROTopoe OCTaIllIJIa HaM aHTlIq-
Hall n;HBHJIH3au;nll. B HaCTOIlrn:ell CTaTbe
MhI 1I0lILlTaeMCII XOTII 6hI CXeMaTlIqHO
HaMeTHTb OCHOBHhIe aTarrhI B3am.!O!l:ell-
CTBHII rpe ecRoro II BapBapCRoro IIC-
KYCCTB. OcoGoe BHIIMaHlIe nplI aTO:'o1 IbI
yp;eJIIIM BonpocaM, RacaIOru;HMCH OOII\ell
xapaKTeplICTIIKH aToro IIpOn;eCca, CCbI-
JIallCb Ha XOpOiliO 1I3BeCTHhIe <paKTb!.
TIepBhIe rrplI3HaKH CIIM6II03a rpeqe-
CROH H BapBapCKOll RYJIbTYP B CeBep-
HOM TIplI epHOMopbe HaMeqaIOTCiI yme
BO BTOpOH 1I0JIOBlIHe VII- Haqa.'1e
VI BB. p;o H. a. (coBMeCTHbJe HaXO)!,KII
rrpep;MCTOB 3BeplIHoro CTIIJIH C po,rrOC-
CKO-IIOHIIRCROH RepaMlIKoH II rpeqeCKII-
Mil xyp;omecTBeHHbIMII II3)!,eJIIIH 1II II3
MeTaJIJIa). B rrepBOH 1I0JIOBlIHe VI B. p;o
H. a. 1I0IIBJIllIOTCII II3p;eJIIIH CMeIIIaHHoro
rpeKo-BapBapc,Roro CTIIJIH (ReJIep !ec-
CKoe 3epKaJIO II pIITOH), II3rOTOB.1CH-
HbIe cRopee Bcero B O!l:HOM II3 pamIIIX
CJ;eHTpoB A3IIaTCKOro Bocrropa ". Coc-
!l;IIHeHlIe pa3JIlIqHbJX xy)!,omeCTBCI!HhJX
:IJOpM B OP;HOH BeII\II xapaKTepl!O II
!l;JIH ROMIIJIeKCa II3 3IIBIIe 2<. Ho B Ha-
1II1IX rrop;oGHbIx KO m:IeKCaX, 11<1 pH.1Y
: IlMIJOpTHbIMII BOCTOqHbJ !lJ II rpet;o-
BOC.TO HbIMII 1I3p;eJIIIHMH yme rrOHB.liI-
EOTCII rpe ec.KlIe rrOlJ:pamaHJ1iI, xa paK-
repHhIe p;JIII c.eBeporrOHTlIllcRoro t;pyra
lCyp;omec.TBeHHbIX II3)!,e.1I!ll 113 !eT".l.l<1.
[loaTOMY MomHo c.qIITaTb, 'ITa TBOp'le-
:Rall p;eIlTeJIbHOCTb rpeKOB, a TaKfKe
)JIII3KHX R HIIM BapBapCKIIX II.l(' IeH
B C03p;aHIIH rpeIW-BapBapCKIIX IIpc::me-
TOB TopeBTHKH B CeBepHOM IIpH epHo-
Mopbe, Ha HHaeTc.1I IIMeHHO C aToro Bpe-
MeHH, a He 1I03p;Hee, RaR 1I0JIaraIOT
HeROTophIe HCCJIep;OBaTeJIII.
Bo BTOpOH nOJIOBHHe VI - Ha aJIe
V BB. p;o H. a. BbIpaGaThIBaeTc.R THII
rpeRO-BapBapCRHX 3epRaJI C HCIIOJIb30-
BaHlIeM MOTIIBOB 3BeplIHoro CTHJIII,
a TalORe cBoe06pa3HbIe ROCTHHhIe H 30-
JIOThIe nJIac.THHbI C cxeMaTH eCRHM
II30GpameHHeM RJIIOBa nTHn;hI 25, OTHO-
CII lIeCII R IIpOH3BOp;c.TBeHHOH p;eRTeJIb-
HOCTn OJIbBHII 26. HaMeTHBmallCII CBoe-
ro pop;a c.nen;HaJIII3an;1I1I 110 npOH3BOP;-
CTBY MeTaJIJIII ec.RIIX H3p;eJIHH, B TOM
qlIc.JIe H cBoeoGpa3HbIx rpeRO-BapBap-
C.KIIX, IIpop;OJImaeT pa3BlIBaTbCII C HO-
BOll: CIIJIOH Ha BoclIope H IIpHJIeraIO-
ru;IIX R He MY TeppliTopHIIX (30JIOThIe
06HBRII Homen Me'leH H 6pOH30BhIe
IIpep;MeTbI ROHCIwro yGopa) 27. B xyp;o-
meCTBeHHOH oGpaGoTRe H3p;eJIHH e e
rrpeoGJIap;aeT MeXaHHqeCROe coe)J;HHe-
HHe rpeRo-eapBapCRHX aJIeMeHTOB.
B V H IV BB. p;o H. a., B neplIOp; yCH-
JIIIBmerOCII IIpon;ecca B3a1IMop;ellcTBHII
rpeRO-BapBapCROH RyJIbTyphI B CeBep-
HOM TI pH'IepHOMOpbe, 3p;ec.b IIOIIBJIHIOT-
CII yme OTp;eJIbHbIe JIORaJIbHbIe BaplIaH-
TbI rrop;oGHhIx II3!1:eJIIIH.
B OTJIII lIe OT OJIbBHII, B xyp;omecT-
BeHHOM TBop eCTBe Bocrropa C ero CMe-
IIIaHHbIM pa3HOaTHIIqHbIM Hac.eJIeHlIeM
ocoGeHHo IIpRO BbIc.TYlIaIOT pa3JI11I HhIe
TeHp;eHn;IIII. I1crrOJIb3YII RJIaCCH ec.RlIe
Tpap;Hn;IIH, GocrrOpc.RlIe TopeBThI c.03p;a-
Jill HOBYIO BeTBb aJIJIIIHc.Roro IICRYCc.TBa,
KOTopall rrORa .'1yqme Bcero rrpOCJIemlI-
BaeTc.1I Ha mlIpOKOM Rpyre xyp;omec.T-
BeHHblX ll3p;eJIlIH TlIlIa qepTOMJIhID;KOH
Ba3bI. 113 HOB.EVX 1I0cTyrrJIeHHH R HIIM
CJIep;yeT OTHed 'IaIIIY H3 faHMaHOBoH
!OmJIbI 28 II rre,hOpaJIb 1I3 TOJICTOH MO-
rlIJIbI 29.
LJ;pyroe me HarrpaBJIeHHe, IIp;ym;ee
aT KeJIepMeccKo-YJIbCROro Rpyra Be-
ell, HaHGOJIee IIpRO OTpameHHoe B
oGIIBRax HomeH Me eH H 1I03p;Hee Ha-
nOMHHaBIIIee 0 c.eGe B TpaRTOBRe RYJIb-
oGcRoro OJIeHII, H3Y'JeHO Hep;OCTaTO HO
IIOJIHO. 11 ocoGeHHo nJIOXO MhI IIpep;-
CTaBJIlleM ero B Mac.COBhIX IIITaMIIOBaH-
HhIX II JIHThIX H3p;eJIHIIX, IIOJIY'JHBIIIHX
IIIHpORoe paClIpOCTpaHeHHe B CeBep-
HOM TIpH'lepHOMOpbe B V H IV BB. p;o
H. a. B OTJIH'lHe OT IIpep;MeTOB TlIlIa
KYJIbOGCROro OJIeHII, rp;e rpeRo-BapBap-
CKHe aJIeMeHThI e e, RaR B paHRlui: ne-
pHOP;, MexaHII eCKH co eTaIOTCII, B aTO
BpeMII 1I0IIBJIIlIOTC.1I H3p;eJIlIII, B ROTO-
pbIX HaGmop;aeTc.1I TeCHoe nepenJIeTe-
HlIe, CiIHIIHlIe aTHX aJIeMeHTOB. TIop;oG-
HhIe H3p;eJIIIII Hepep;RO HCRJIIO aIOT B03-
MOmHOc.Tb OlIpep;eJIHTb, IIMeeM JIH MhI
p;eJIO c. rrpOlI3Bep;eHHeM MecTHoro MaCTe-
pa, BOClIplIHIIBmero aJIJIIIHCRYIO RYJIb-
Typy, HJIIII me C npOlI3Bep;eHHeM rpe e-
CRora MaCTepa, ROTOphIH B TOH nJIH
IIHOH Mepe BOIIIeJI B MIIpOB033peHHe II
xyp;omec.TBeHHYIO RYJIbTYPY BapBapOB.
K paHHHM IIpOII3Bep;eHHIIM nop;oG-
Hora pop;a MhI GhI OTHeCJIH II TaR Ha3hI-
BaelllbIe OJIbBHHCKHe 3epRaJIa, ocoGeH-
HOCTH xyp;omecTBeHHoro o<popMJIeHHII
ROTOphIX P;O CHX rrop BbI3hIBaIOT cnophI:
Op;HII IIX C'lHTaIOT rpe eCRHMH, p;py-
me - C.KH<pCKHMII. STOT <paRT CBIIp;e-
TeJIbCTByeT 0 HaJI.H IIII rpeRO-BapBap-
CRoro «koivr\», IIMeBmero MeCTO B paH-
lIee BpeMII II B OJIbBHllCROM oRpymeHHII.
ITbITallcb paCRphITb IIc.TopH eCRYIO
pOJIb B3aIIMop;ellCTBIIII rpe eCRoro H
BapBapCRoro IICRYCCTB, IICCJIep;OBaTeJIH
qaCTO YTBepmp;aIOT, TO rpeKH IIBH-
:mCb Tall pa3pYIIIIITeJIbHOll C.IIJIOR, IIOP;
BJIHHHlIeM ROTOpOH 3BeplIHbIll CTIIJIb
rrOTepHJI caMoGbITHOC.Tb xyp;omecTBeH-
Hall <pOpMbI H IIp;eHHOro ee cop;epma-
HIIH, TaR RaR rrpep;CTaBHTeJIH BbI-
COKOH n;IIBIIJIH3an;1I1I IIROGhI He IIOHR-
Ma.TH BapBapCRoe HCRyC.CTBO II Hp;eOJIO-
mlO. TaR JIll aTo? 11 MomHO JIH Bo06ru;e
C TaKHX 1I03Hn;IIH p;aBaTb On;eHRY aTOMY
CJIOmHoMY IIC.TOpIIKO-RYJIbTypHOMY IIB-
JleHIIIO, ROTopoe ObIJIO pe3YJIbTaTOM Tec-
Horo aROHOMH'leCRoro COTpyp;lUPIecTBa
,0
rpeROB c. BapBapc.KIIM oRpymeHHeM,
chIrpaBIIIIIM GOJIbIIIYIO pOJIb B IIOJIIITII-
eCROll II !l:YXOBHOll mrr3HH Hapop;OB Ce-
BepHoro TI plf'IepHOMopbll?
q TOGbI nOHIITb HallIe 3aG;rrymp;eHHe,
HaIIOMHiBM, 'ITO pa3HIIn;a B COI1;'lIaJIbHO-
aROHOMH eCROM II RYJIbTypHOM pa3BII-
THH rpeROB II c.eBepOqepHOMOpCKHX Be-
p;ym;HX nJIeMeH 6bIJIa cpaBHIITeJIbHO
HeBeJIHRa, II MIIpOB033peHHII aTHX fQ!YX
oG ecTB GbIJIII 6JIII3KIIMII, Oc.oGeHHo B
nepHO,!!; c.03p;aHIIH rpeRO-c.IIHp;O-MeOT-
CROro rocyp;apcTBa, Korp;a cym;ecTBeH-
HO MeHIIJIaCb IIp;eOJIOrIIH Tex H ,!!;py-
mx 3". I13BecTHO, 'ITa rpeKH YMeJIO H
TOHRO npOHIIKaJIII B IIp;eOJIOmIO II p;y-
IIIeBHbIll Mllp p;pyrlIx Hapop;OB, c.03p;a-
BM IIIep;eBpbI B ropa3p;0 GOJIee pa3BII-
TOM HCRYCCTBe, qeM nCKYCCTBO c.eBepo-
epHOMopClmx IIJIeMeH. OHII C03p;aJIII
3aMeqaTe.lbHbIe peJIbe<phI TIepc.errOJIII,
BOIIJIO all B HIIX rrpeRpaCHbIe oGpa3bI
rrepCIIp;c.KIIX BOIIHOB II IIpaBHTeJIeH.
LJ;eBIITb p;eCiITbIX MaCTepOB plIMCROro
1I0pTpeTa 6bIJIII rpeKa!<m. HII ero He-
rrpeOp;OJIHMOrO P;JIiI rpeKOB He 6hIJIO n
B CeBepHO ! TIpllqepHOMopbe. 11 3!1:ecb
OHII TaRme xopomo rrpOHIIRJIHCb IIp;eo-
JIOrlIeH rr.le:'o1eHHOrO MlIpa, RaR JIerRO
BOmJIII B IIpaHCKOe MIIpoB033peHIIe B
TIepclIH II n03p;Hee B I1TaJIIIII. HpKOH
HJIJIlOCTpaD;He:ii: 9TOMY IIBJIIlIOTCII MHO-
rO IICJIeHHbIe rrpolI3Bep;eHIIII Gocnop-
CROll TopeBTIIKII Epyra qepTOMJIbln;ROH,
RYJIbOGC.ROii. BoporremCKOH Ba3, OGIIBOR
ropliTOB II HomeR !eqeII TlIrra MeJIIITO-
rrOJIbCKlIX II T. IJ:. EC.'1II ObI BapBapbI He
rrOHIIMa.1II 9TllX J! TIO!l:OOHbIX IIM II3p;e-
JIIIH, OHn ObI IIX lie rlO KyrraJI ll. A Bep;b
MHorHe In 9THX ncru.l'iL p;ame c. qlICTO
9JIJIllHCKII m ClOmeTaMII, mTaMrrOBaJIIIc.b
H npOp;aB<1.1llCb leCTHbI:'o1 rrJIeMeHaM B
60JIbiliOM };OiIHqrCTBe.
Pa)!,ll 9KOIlO 11!4eCKIIX BbIro)!, rpeRII
CTpeMIIJIIICb CJlaOfKaTb rrJIeMeHHYlO
3HaTb II pa3.1IIqlIOrO pOlJ:a rrop;pamaHIIH-
MII B 3BepllHOM CTll.Tle. Y'JTII, R TOMY
me, OOJIbUJoe IIX IIfJlICTpac.TlIe K yeTaJI-
71
JIY, B KOTOpO I :\OOMOp<t!Hble II306pame-
HIlJI uamJill nalIOO;!ee HpKoe Bblpame-
Hlle. H.CTOpUJI CeBepOqepnOMOpCKoro
3BepIIrroro CTII JI 3HaMerryeT IJ; HTe b-
Hblii II c:wmf1hTii: IIpo ecc pa3BIITIIJI
pa3 IIqnLIX 06pa30B, C031J;aBaBIIIHXCK
rpeqemGlMJI II BapBapCKHMII MaCTepa-
Mil. Ho OTHOCIITb YTpaTY caM06blTUOCTII
3a CqeT HerrOHIIMarrlIJI rpeKaMII 3Toro
CTII JI 3Ha'lIiT OTpII aTb ero caM06blT-
HOCTb, 3HaqllT IJ;orrycKaTb, qTO Bap-
Bap - 1I0TpeOIITe.TIb IIpelJ;MeTOB IJ;aHHO-
ro IICKYCCTBa - rrO:Ib30Ba CK rJIY60KO
qymALI m elory xYIJ;OmeCTBeHHLIMB IIpO-
II3BelJ;eHIIJIMII.
,l.( JI ceBeporrOHTlIiicKOro 3BeplIHoro
CTIIJIJI. Iml, II A JI MeCTHOrO 06 eCTBa
B rr;eJIOM. CBOUCTBeHHDI He TO bRO BHem-
l:me BJIlIJI, HllJI HO II CBOII c06CTBeHHLIe
BUYTpeI;:I1Ie rrpOrr;eCCbl pa3BIITIIJI. Yme
Ha CaMh!X paHHIIX 3Tarrax IIOHB eHIIK B
CeBepUI) I IIplIqepHOMOpbe TaK Ha3bl-
Bae?oIOro CKlHpCKOro 3BepHHOrO CTIIJIJI
na ero II31J;8.TIlIJIX MomHO OTMeTI1Tb OT-
K OHeHIIII B TpaKToBKe IIa06pameHlIii,
KOTOpbIe !fa oo.:xee rr03 llX Be ax Ml>I
IIpIIBJ,n;.lII rrpIIrrIICbIBaTb rpeqeCROMY
«HerrOHn raHrrIO» xYIJ;OmeCTBeHHoii tPop-
MbI II rOlJ;epmaHJm 06pa3a. rpeKII me,
CTpeMJICh yrOJ IITb 3HaTII, e e B IV B.
v H. d. rrpe.'J;.'"rJraIOT eii II300pameHIIK
B cTaphIx TpaAIIrr;IIOHHbIX cxeMax I\ap-
Ba pCROI'O rrCRYCCTBa, HarrplIMep, II30-
6paiReHIIe CBepHYBTIIerocrr B KO:Ib O
bBa.
B rrpon:mOIJ;CTBe CeBepOqepHOMOp-
CKoii TopeBTlIKII OTqeTmmO BblcTyrralOT
TPH ocrrOBHbIX TeHAeHrr;HlI. ITepBaK
naXO):\lIT OTpameUlIe B rrp01I3BeAe-
UlIHX, .!aBe;IO IO B03HIIRmlIX B Bap-
BapcKoii cpC;XC. rrpOlI3BelJ;eHIIJIX MeOT-
CKora II CIHI(P Koro 3BeplIHOrO CTII K.
BTopall n pC;J:CTaB:IeUa rpeqeCKIIMII II3-
IJ;e.T[I1H I!J. Rn1 OpbIe B IIOJIuoii Mepe YIJ;O-
B.1eTBopH:lJr 3arrpOChI MeCTHoro HaCeJIe-
HIIH. ira.1elW He OrpaHlIqlIBalO erOCJI
c06CTBe II ULBIII rrpelJ;MeTaMIl 3BeplIHoro
CTlI.1H.
TpeTbR TeHlJ;eHrr;IIK HaxOAIIT CBoe Bbl-
pameIIlIe B rpeKO-BapnapCKI1X II3IJ;e II-
HX, IIOAqepKIIBalO IIX 6eCKOHeqHO pa3-
IIo06pa3IIbIe xYAomeCTBeHHble BKYCbI
3aRa3qlIKOB II IICIIOJIHIITtmeii: KaK pe-
3Y bTaT C OmeHIIJI nCTOplI'IeCRIIX IIpO-
eCCOB, IIpOIICXOW'lBIIIHX B rpeKO-MeOTO-
CKlItPCKOM Mllpe. HII OW'lH BIIA ceBepo-
qepHOMopCKOro IICKyCCTBa He OCTa-
BIIJI HaM CTO bKO IIaMJITHIlKOB, CBII-
AeTe bCTBYIO IIX 06 3TOM, KaR TO-
peBTIII{a.
060raTIIB CBOIO KY bTYPy HOBbIMH
06pa3aMII II ClOmeTaMII II3 mlI3HII
MeCTHbIX II eMeH, C031J;aB B CeBepOqep-
HOMOpCKOB: TopeBTIIKe HOBYIO BeTBb
3JIJIIIHCI\Oro IICKyccTBa, JIBIIBmYIOCJI pe-
3YJIbTaTOM TeCHblX 3KOHOMIIqeCKIIX
ROHTaRTOB II rrO Horo IIOHIIMaHlIJI IIAeo-
orHH IIoc eAHIIX, rpeKII crrocoocTBoBa-
Jill TeM caMblM YCII elllIlO CO IIa bHO-
3KOHOMIIqeCKOrO pa3BIITIIJI 3TIIX rr e-
MeH. IT03TOMY IICTOplIqeCKaJI pO b rpe-
qeCKoro IICJ\YCCTBa B IIAeO OrIIII Bap-
BapOB IJ;OJImHa orrpeAeJIJITbCJI He TeM,
HaCKO bKO rpeKII rrOBIIHHbI B YTpaTe
IIepBOHaqa bUOll xYIJ;OmeCTBeHHOR tPop-
MbI BbIpameHIIJI BaJKHbIX B IIX pe II-
rlI03HbIX IIpeAcTaB eHIIHX 3BepHHblX 06-
pa30B, a TeM, K KaKIIM rroc.1eIJ;CTBIIJIM
IIplIBe Tex II IJ;PYr:ux 3TOT TBOpqeCKIIii:
CIIHTe3 3J1eMeUTOB IIX KY bTypbl. TaK
IIJIII lIHaqe, B pe3YJIbTaTe ClIMolIo3a rpe-
qeCKOrO II BapBapCKoro IICKYCCTB ObIJI
C031J;aH rr;eJIblll PJIA rrepBOI-;.TIareHblX rra-
MJITHIIKOB IICKYCCTBa, YKa3blBBIOmIIX ua
cocy ecTBoBaHlIe B HlIX OT):\eJIbHbIX,
pa3mrqHbIX rro CBoeMY rrpolIcxomAeHIIIO,
3JIeMeUTOB 1I30opameulIH. Hallla 3aAa-
qa - HalIOOJIeC I10JIHO BbIHBrrTb, qTO
IIMeHHO CAe aHO PYKaMil ca lIIx BapBa-
pOB II rpeKOB lIf HaKouerr;. TOro «koivrp>,
rAe, KaK B PII ROM 1l0pTpeTc. C;J;eJIaH-
nOM B 1'1T a JIll II, rraCTO.1bKO BCI' I1t'perrJIe-
TaeTCJI, qTO OqeHb TpYAHO YCTaHOBIITb
3TUIIqeCRYIO rrplIHaAJIemHOCTb MaCTe-
pOB.
1 BII6JIIIorpacl>mo no aTOMY BOIIPOCY eM.:
H. A. Onaii./w. ABTII'IHblli HMilOpT B I1plI-
AHclipoBbe II I106ymbe B IV-II UB.
AO H. 3. CAlf, )];1-27. M., 1970, CTp. 6.
2 M. H. P"C1'08/fe8. 3JIJIHHCTBO 11 HpaHCTBO
Ha lOre POCCIIII. M., 1918, CTp. 6.
3 M. H. POCr08/fe8. CKH<p1I1I H BOCilOp. J1.,
1925, CTp. 338.
I. TaM me, CTp. 340; on xe. The Animal
Style in South Russia and China. Prin-
ceton, 1929, p. 24.
5 G. Boroffka. Del' Skythische Tierstil. AA,
1926, 3/4, S. 369.
· K. Schefold. Del' skythische Tierstil in
siidrussland. ESA, XII. Helsinki, 1938,
S. 3. CM. pe eH3lIIO Ha 3TY CTaTblO H. H.
I1orpe60BoII K BOIIPOCY 0 CnU<pCKOM 3Be-
plIHOM CTHJIe». KClflfMK, BbIli. XXXIV.
1950, CTp. 129.
1 H. H. Ilozpe608a. K BOIIPOCY 0 CKH<PCKOM
3BepHliOM CTIIJIe, CTp. 134, 140.
8 B. A. H.I£bUnCIWH. HeKOTopbIe MOTHBbI
paHHeCRI!<pCKoro 3BepIIHorO CT1IJIII. CA,
1965, .M 1. CTp. 105.
t P. A man dry. L'art scythe archaique. AA,
1965, Heft 4, p. 89f.
10 P. Amandry. Un motif scythe en Iran et
en Grece. INES, v. XXIV, july, 1965, N 3,
p.149.
11 R. Ghirschman. Perse. Paris, 1963, p. 33f.
12 B. 11.. BA.aRarcKuii.. B03AeiicTBHe aHT1IQHOII
KYJIbTypbl Ha cTpaHbI CeBepHoro I1pllqep-
HOMOpbli (IV B. AO H. 3.- III B. H. 3.). CA,
1964, .M 4, CTp. 27.
13 H. A. Oltaii.Ko. YKa3. COq., CTp. 86.
11. M. H. ApraMono8. I1poHcxomAeHlIe CKH<p-
CKOro HCKYCCTBB. CA, 1968, M 4, CTp. 27.
15 M. H. ApraMono8. CKH<P0-CH6HpcKoe HC-
KyCCTBO 3BepIfHoro CTIIJIII. I1CA. M., 1971,
C Tp. 34.
18 M. H. ApraMo/to8. COKpOB1I a caliOB. M.,
1973, CTp. 218.
11 K. Malkina. Ein Motiv aus dem skytischen
Tierstil. IDAl, XVI, 1926, Heft 3/4, S. 176.
18 H. H. Ilozpe608a. fpH<pOH B IICKYCCTRC Ce-
BepHoro I1pHqepHOMOpbll B IIOXY apxalI-
KH. KClflfMK, BbIIl. XXII, 1948, CTp. 62.
Ai,
72
11 M. H. MaKCUM08a. Cepe6pHHoe 3epKaJIO H3
KeJIepMeca. CA, XXI, 1954, CTp. 281;
vna :J/Ce. PRTOH 1I3 KeJIepMeca. CA, XXV,
1956, CTp. 215.
20 ". A. Onaii.Ko. a eHTpax IIpOH3BOACTBa
30JIOTbIX 06KJIaAOK HomeH H PYKOIITOK
paHHHx CKH<pCKHX leqelI, HalIAeHHblX B
I1pHAHelipoBbe. KAM. M., 1966, CTp. 159.
2t M. H. ApraMono8. KYJIb06cKHII OJIeHb.
AlfKCI1. J1., 1968, CTp. 9.
22 M. H. Pocr08/fe8. CKU<pHH H BOCIIOP,
CTp. 305.
23 M. H. MaKCu.M08a. Cepe6pHHoe 3epKaJIO 1I3
KeJIepMeCa; ona xe. PHTOH II3 KeJIepMe-
Ca; B. 11.. BA.a8arCKUU. B03AelICTBile aH-
THqHOII KYJIbTYPbI.., CTP. 26.
21. A. Godard. Le Tresor de Liwiye (Kurd i-
stan). Haarlem, 1950; R. Ghirshman. No-
tes Iraniennes IV. Le Trisor de Sakkes;
Le Origines de l'art Mede et les Bronzes
du Luristan. Artihus Asiae», XIII, 1950.
25 C. H. l(anowuna. I1aMIITHHKII 3BepHHoro
CTHJIII 1I3 OJIbBHII. KClflfMK, BbllI. XXXIV,
1950, CTp. 43, pilC. 5-7.
26 B. B. <PapMaKo8cKuii.. ApXaHqeCKlI1I IIe-
pllOA B POCCHII, CTp. 30, pHC. 8; O. E. Ilpy-
Ule8CKaH. XYAomecTBeHHall 06pa60TKa Me-
TaJIJIa (TopeBTHKa). ArCI1, T. I. M.- J1.,
1955, CTp. 328; B. M. CKyono8a. CKII<p CKlIB
3epKaJIa H3 apXalIqeCKOrO HeKpOIIOJIII OJIb-
Bilil. TT3, T. VII. J1., 1962, CTP. 5.
27 H. A. Onaii.Ko. a eHTpax IIpOH3BOACTBa..,
CTp. 159.
28 B. I. BioaiA.H. )];oCJIil\meHHIl falIMaHoBoi
MOrHJIII. ApxeoJIorill», BHII. 4. KHIB, 1971,
CTp. 44, pHC. 8-1 f.
29 B. H. MOaOA.e8cKuii.. KypraH TOJICTali Mo-
rHJIa 6JIH3 c. OPAmOHIIKHA3e Ha YKpailHe.
CA, 1972, M 3.
30 H. H. COKO.l£bCKUii. II 11.. B. IIIeA.08. lfCTO-
pHqeCKaH pOJIb aHTlIqHblX roCYAapCTB Ce-
BepHoro I1pHqepHOMopbli. I1lfCI1A3. M.,
1959, CTp. 48; B. 11.. BA.a8arcKuii.. Apxal!-
qeCKRII BOCilOp. MlfA, M 33, 1954, CTp. 11;
on xe. B03AelIcTBile aHTH'IHOII KYJIbTypbl
Ha cTpaHbI CeBepHoro I1plI'IepnOMOpbll
(B VII-V BB. AO H. 3.), CTp. 19.
Horo CTHJIII. OH BbIpOC, Be pOHTIIO, II3
Tex me HCTOqHlIIWB, qTO II 3BepllHbIH
CTHJIb CRIHIJlIH, CeBepHoro KaBKa3a,
IOmHOR CII6IIpH H CpeAHeu: A31I1I, TaR
RaR B ero OCHOBe JIeiKaT 06 lIe 300-
MopqlHbIe 06pa3bI, MOTIIBbI II IIplIeMbI
CTUJlII3aQHII. ITpoMelliYTOqHOe IIOJIOiKe-
RHe IToBOJImCKo-YpaJIbCI,nX CTeileR OII-
peAeJIIIJIO ero TeCHbIe CBH3II II 3aBHCII-
MOCTb, C OAHOR CTOpOHbI, OT 300MOp<p-
Horo HCRyccTBa CRII<p1I1I II IT plIKy6aHbll,
C APyroR qOpOllIbI - OT aIIaJIOTIPlHOrO
CTHJIII Ka3axcTaHa II IOiKlJOR CII6IIpH.
ITaHTepo06pa3HbIll (IWUIa%eII IIOpoAbI)
H rplI<poHo06pa3HbIll XIIUII!ITIill, pacII03-
HaBaeMbIe Ha HalI60JIee paHHlIx caB pO-
MaTCRIIX Be ax, CBepHYBIIIIIH:CII B ROJIb-
QO XIIIl(HHK il3 caBpOMaTCI,oro IIorpeoe-
HBII rpYIIIIbI Tpex 6paTLeB IIOA 3JIlIc-
TOR (pIIC. 1,1) 2; 6.'IHIlIKi\ C IIplIIIaBIlIIIM
K 3e lJIe ROIllaqbHM XIIIl(IIIIl,OM H3 CyceJI
(pIIC. 1, 6) 3, rOJIOBa «.'IhBiI» IIB ROCTJ1-
HOM HaBepIlIIIII II3 BIIIll-OOLI (pIIC. 2,
5) '; 30JIOTaH 6JIHiliKa B Bll)l,e rOJIOBbI
opJIa IIJIII rplI<poHa 113 HBaHoB hii
(pHC. 3, 9) 5 CJIYIKaT llO)J,TBepiK)I,eHHeM
:nOR B3aIIM03aBIICII}IOCTII.
CaBpOMaTo-capMaTCKllll 3BeplIHbIH
CTIIJIb )l,eJIIITCH na ABa OC!!OBHbIX 3TaIIa:
I 3Tall (VI-IV BB. AO H. :J.) CBH3aH C
caBpoMaTaMII; :nall (III B. AO H. 3.--
II B. n. 3.) OTHOCIITCH KO BpeMeHII CJIO-
iKeHIIH HOBbIX BoeHHO-llO.11ITllqeCKi!!X CO-
1030B capMaTOB II IIX pacce:WHIIII Ha 3H-
IIaA BIIJIOTb )1,0 AYHaIICKIIX rrpOBIIHQIIR
PIIMC KOR IIMlleplIlI.
CaBpOMaTbI . YRpaIIIaJIII CBOII BeIl\II
(ROCTIOM, opymHe..H ROHCKYIO C6pyIO,
npeAMeTLI TyaJIeTa H RaMeHHbIe mepT-
BeHHHKi!!) CTIIJIII30BaHHbIMII 1I300pame-
HHIIMII iKHBOTHbIX. 06pa3bI rKIIBOTHbIX,
6e3 COMHeHIDI, HaBellHbI llepeiKilTIWMII
TOTeMR'leCKi!!X IIpeACTaBJIeHIIll, IIO rJlaB-
HbIR CMLlCJI caBpOMaTcRoro 3BepIIHoro
CTIIJUI, KaK BIIpOqeM II CKII<p0-CII6IIpCRO-
ro 3BepHHoro CTIIJIII Bo06 e - CaI,paJIb-
HO-MarnqeCKIIR. CaBpOMaTCKi!!H: MaCTep
oc060 BbIAeJIlleT II IIOAqepKilBaeT Te op-
raHbI mIIBOTHbIX, KOTopbIe CllMBOJIII3H-
pOBaJIII 30pROCTb II OcrpOTY CJIyxa,
CIIJIY, JIOBROCTb II CMeJIOCTb B 60pb6e -
rJIa3, YXO, pora, 3y6aCTY1O IIaCTb, RJIIOB,
KOITHCTbIe JIailbI. TeJIo 3BepH ilHorAa
3aIIOJIHlleTCII <pHrypaMII IKIIBOTHbIX HJIII
HX qaCTIIMII (pIIC. 1, 20; 4, 1, 6) II
CXeMaTHqHOR fOJIOBOR XIIIl(1I0U: TITIB-IbI
(pHC. 4, 2, 8, 9), OTMeqalOTCH MYCRYJIbI
m;eK H IIJIeqa (pIIC. 4, 1, 2; 5,1, 2). Bce
nepeqlICJIeHHbIe oc06eHHocTII CTIIJIII
B IIpHHQHIIe Te me, qTO II B CRII<po-cn-
6HPCROM CTIIJIe Bo06 e. 8TO .'lIIIlIHIIR
pa3 IIoATBepmAaeT 06 lIe KOpilii llpOIIC-
xomAeHHII 300MOp<pHOH: CTil.'II13aQIIH
Ha orpOMHbIX IIpOCTopax EBpa3lIlI, B03-
HHKlIIeR II pa3BIIBiliellcII y MnOrIIX IIJIe-
MeH C 6JIH3RIIMII IIAeOJIornqeClillMII II
CaKpaJIbHO-MarlIqeCRIIMII IIpe ,'ICT aBJIe-
HHIIMH.
,l],OBOJIbHO qaCTO OT,'Ie.lbHble qaCTII
mHBOTHoro HJIII IITIII.IbI (.'lalla, KorOTb,
Hora C KOilbITOM, RJIIOB, XBOCT llTIII.IbI,
fJIa3 II IIp.) BOCilpIIHIIMa.lrrCL !;i1K I.IeJIoe
(pHC. 1, 24-39), CIIMBo.ln3rrpYH oIIpe-
AeJIeHHOe RaqeCTBO. 01I1I IJ.lol'ipaiKaJIIICb
KaR OTAeJIbHbIll: llpe)l,MeT (11O;\BeCRa,
6JIIIIIIKa, 06K'laAI{a, H3BeplJIlie IIpeA-
MeToB).
Ha MeCTHOll IIOqBe 3TOT CTn:lI, IIPI1-
06peJI yme B VI B. ,'10 II. :1.. ,Bopo6pa3-
Hble qepTbI, Kor)l,a IICIIO:Ii,:JOH,UIJCb 06-
pa3bI mIIBOTHbIX leCTlloii IfJi1YHbL
B pe3YJIbTaTe CTII.'I1I3aUII!! ''''CHI 6bIBa-
eT TPYAHO paCllO:';HaB3Tb DIU ;KIIBOT-
HbIX. CpeAH 300MOP<pHbIX I):IOI>]li\ ;1,eHilII
H. <D. C!\HIPHOB
CABPOMATO-CAPMATCHWH 3BEPWHbIM CTMJIb
:::peAll ,'IpeBHero IIpHJ\JIaAHOrO HCKYCCT-
3a EBpa31I1I, TaR Ha3blBaeMoro CRH<p0-
1I6IIpCKOrO 3BeplIHoro CTHJIII, AOBOJIb-
110 qeTKO BbIAeJIlleTCII ero IIOBOJImCKO-
y"pa:rbClillH: BapHaHT', CBII3aRHbIll B OC-
IIOBHOM C IIpaHO-1I3blqHbIMH KOqeBRH-
l,a 1lI - HOCIITeJIIIMH caBpOMaTCROR
apxeo.'IOmqeCROll RYJIbTypbI. C03AaTe-
IIHMII era 6bIJIII caBpOMaTbI repOAOTa,
1\0qeBaBIlllIe B CTeIIIIX 3aAOHbll, ITo-
I!OJliKhH II pOACTBeHHbIe IIM llJIeMeHa
10,I\I1OrO ITplIypaJIbll. B A!lJIbHeRilleM
lIa oa:1O 06elIx rpYilil CJIOiKlIJIIICb pa3-
:mqllble c06CTBeHHO capMaTCRlIe IIJIeMe-
a aopCOB, ClIpaROB, pOKCOJIaHOB H
aJIaHOB.
ITOI!O.liKCKo-ypaJIbCRHll BapHaHT CKH-
tPo-cnonpCRoro 3BepHHoro CTIIJIII OROH-
qaTe.lhllO CJIOiKIIJICH, CYAII IIO apxeOJIO-
rHqpC J,IBI MaTeplIaJIaM, He II03me
cept';lHHbI VI B. AO H. 3. OH He IIMeJI
IWplll'ii Y HerrocpeACTBeHHbIX IIpeAIlIeCT-
IWII!!III;OB II llpe)l,KOB - IIJIeMeil II03AlIe-
CpYl'lI0ti II II03AHeaHAPOHOBCROll RYJIb-
TYp. ]{oneqHO, 300MOp<pHbIe IIpeACTaB-
.'IeH!!!!. IIepeiKlITRil TOTeMII3Ma II JIereH-
:J;bl. ClIH3aHHbIe C iKlIBOTHbIM MlIpOM,
\ 'IIll'CTBOBa.11I y 3TIIX rrpe)l,IWB; OHII
ObI:lll CBorrCTBeHHbI BceM ,'IpeBHIIM Hapo-
Aa 1. O;J;HaIW B IIX MaTeplIa.TlbHOll RYJIb-
TYPt'. BO BCHKOM CJIyqae Ha llpe)l,MeTax,
J.\OIIH';uunx ,'10 Hailiero Bpe}leHil, He CO-
xpn !In.10Cb HII OAHoro 300MOp<pHoro
H:lo;;pa;KeHIIH, KOTopbIe MOiKHO 6bIJIO 6bI
pacoli1TpIIBaTb, XOTII 6bI qaCTlIqHO, RaR
npoT{jTIIllbI AJIII CaBpOMaTCKOrO 3BeplI-
74
IIepBoe MeCTO 3aHIIMa1OT XH HIIRII IW-
IlIa beH: IIOPOAbI (qaCTO <pa CTlIqe-
CRlle) (pIIC. 4), oc06eHHo qaCTO BOJIR
H MeABef(!> (pIIC. 1; 2), a TaIDIW XII -
Hall IIT'lIQa OpJIIIHOll IIOPOAbI HJIH <paH-
TaCTlIqeCI,'lI.ll OpJIIIHOrOJIOBbIll rPH<pOH
(pHC. 3), a 3aTeM yme OJIeHb (pIIC. 5, 2,
4, 6, 8), JIOCb (pHC. 5, 1), Ra6aR
(pIIC. 4,-7; 5,11), RYJIaH (pIIC. 5,3),
ropHbIll R03eJI H 6apaH (pIIC. 5, 10, 17 -
21, 23), Bep6JI1OA (pHC. 5, 7, 9), call-
raK (pIIC. 5, 15), JIOIlIaAb (pHC. 5, 12,
14, 22) H 6apaH (pIIC. 5, 13). Y caB pO-
MaTOB, IIOBTopHeM, Hau60JIee H3.TII06JIeH-
Hble 06pa3bI MecTHoll <PaYHbI - BOJIR If
MeABeAb, BepollTHo, 6bIBiliHe HelwrAa
TOTeMaMII pHAa pOAOB H IIJIeMeH. qepTbI
3TIIX iKlIBOTHbIX IIplIAalOTCII II qaCTbIM
aHTaCTlIqeCKIIM 06pa3aM.
IKIIBOTHbIe TpaRTOBaHbI C 60JIbiliOll
3RCilpeCClIeH:: CBHpeilbIe, OCRaJIeHHbW
MOPAbI Y XII HHROB C ROITIICTbIMII JIa-
IIaMH (pIIC. 1) II rp03Hble MaCCHBHbIe
RJIIOBbI Y OpJIOB-rpH<pOHoB (pHC. 3),
qaCTO 1I306paiKeHHbIe C 3y6aMII (pIIC. 3,
16, 28-30), cBepHYBIIIlIeclI B IWJIbQO
XII HIIRII (pIIC. 1, 1-5) HJIH llpHIIaB-
IlIlIe R 3eMJIe, RaR 6bI qTO-TO BbIIIIOXII-
BaIOIIJ,lIe II rOTOBbIe R IIPbIiKRY (pIlC. 1,
6-12). IToc:reAHIIII II03a BeCbMa XapaI{-
TepHa Ha caBpoMaTcRHx IIpeAMeTax. cI>lI-
rypbI TpaBOIIAHbIX (KOilbITHbIX) IIepe-
AaHbI B II03e CTOII IIX (pIIC. 5, 7-10,
23), KaK HHorp;a IIepe,u;aHa II II03a XIIm;-
HIIROB, HJIH JIemam;HX mHBOTHbIX (pilC. 5,
1-5), HO B pllAe CJIyqaeB IIM IIpIlAaIOT-
CII qepTbI XHIIJ;HHRa. TaK, HeIWTopbIe
TpaBOHAHble (OJIeHb, JIam,) lIMe lOT Iwr-
TilCTble .1ailbI (pIIC. 5, 5), BbITHIIYTble
BIIepe;J;, KaK y JIemaIl(IIX X}lInIlHKOB
(pIIC. 5, 2). ITplI3HaRII IIOJIIIMOp<pH3Ma
IIPIICYTCTBYIDT II B TpaKTOBKe OfiP0308
XII IIIIKOB (poraTble BOJIK II MeABeAb)
(pIIC. 1, 7; 2, 1) II ocooeHHo <POIlTO-
CTlIqeCKIIX ;J;paKOHo06pa:3HbIx CYUI<'CTB
(pIIC. 4, 1, 2). HHor,'la IKilBOTIlhIC IJ;JO-
6paiKe!lbI B 60Pb6c II.11I llpe)l,CTiln:IP!lhT
CI.IeHbI Tep3aHIIH IT 60pbOU lliliBOTllbIX,
75
qTO H3BeCTHO JIHmb Ha IIpeAl\IeTaX H3
IOllmoro TIpHypaJIbH: ABa 60plOII1;nXCfl
Bep6mOAa H3 I llHTHMapoB ( JIIc. 5,
7) ., opeJI, Tep3aIOII1;HH TpaBoHAHoe Il\li-
BOTHoe H3 HOBoro KYMaKa (pHC. 3, 3) 7,
6JIHmKH B BHAe ABYX roJIOB XIIII1;HllKOB,
0AllH H3 KOTOpbIX 3arJIaTblBaeT APyroro
(I TIHTHMapbI H HOBbIH KYMaI" pllC. 4,
12, 13) 8,
RooMe H306pameHHH OTAeJIbHblX <pII-
ryp mHBOTHOrO HJIH ero qaCTen, B IOm-
HovpanbCIWH rpYIIIIe H3BeCTRO II Re-
'WJIbKO KOMII03HqHH 113 pHAa mil BOT-
JHJX. Bonee IIo3AHHe capMaTCI>IIe Ma-
eTepa 06bIqHO YCIIemHO CIIpaBJIHJIIICb
C IIOA06HbIMH KOMII03HqHHMll, rAe ne-
peIIJIeTeHHbIe B 60Pb6e ffiIIBOTHble
IIpeAeTaBJIHJIll eAHHoe qeJIoe II OqeHb
YAaqHO BIIHCbIBanHCb B <POPMY npeA-
MeTa. OAHaRO Ha caBpO !aTCImx
KOMII0311qHHX ::ITOrO eII1;e HeT: caBpOMaT-
eKHU MaeTep, KaK ::ITO BllAHO Ha Ka-
MeHHOM mepTBeHHHKe H3 XYT. HpbIJIOB-
CKOro (pile. 1, 12, 23) HJIll Ha IIJIaCTII-
He H3 pora JIOCH H3 I IIHTilMapoB.,
paCCTaBJIHJI <pllrypbI mllBOTHbIX KaK
6bI IIpOH3BOJIbHO, IIpoIIopullrr MeffiAY
OTAeJIbHbIMH mHBOTHbIMlI He COOJIIO/I,a-
JIHCb.
CaBpOMaTCKlle MaCTepa ;J.QC rllrJIH
60JIbmOro HCKYCCTBa B xYAoa,ecTBeH-
HOH o6pa6oTKe KOCTH H pora. Pe3b6a
IIO 3THM MaTepHanaM - XapaI>TepHeU-
mall 'lepTa MecTllblX MaCTepOB :JOOMOp<p-
PUC. 2. rOA.oeb1. XUUflWKoe Ita lIf'piJMeTax
caepoMarcKou "'Y.f.brypbL'
1, 17 - BnlOMeH<I>eJIbll (UBeTO'lHbliU: ,,- ROBbI-
;IOBKa; 3, 18-21- HODO-llpllBDJIbHUt', 4 - CTa-
pHl\a: 5 - bllw-Doa; 6, 8 - I1HTII lal'bl I; 7-
KJIHCTHI\Koe: 8a, 9 - BOBb/it f\YMaI< IOpO<i; 10-
JIHnoBHa 11 -- Cooo.'1enCHaH BD.l0CTL: 12 - A6pa-
MOBKa: 13 - MaH'lHaF! ropa IOpeHoypr' 14 - Yw-
RIOM: 15 - T{epHHI'OBCHH«' CMarHHTnrO!', I: 16-
EHc-06a (BnarOCJIOneHcKHi1:); 22 - .\}-;. !'HOBCHUii;
23-24 - Mo:p.laHOBHa 25 - 1\ PbDOi} , I-\niL 26,
27 - IIoKpoBHa: 1, 2, 5-7, 8rJ., 9. J] 1.! - HOCTb
H por; 3, 4, 8, 10, 11-24 - 6p'}H:j . 13-16,
25 - KaldeHb; 26, 27 - 30nOTO
:g
<>
..
HUIKHee flOllOAHlfJe
2
"
: .
- !.
o
IOHfHoe npUypOA"
\;
I
\
,
I 5
I
I
I
I
\
I
"
,.
::0
,.
;;
::0
..
4
C)1;: ,
. . -=" .
'_;. . " """ u!.d -...-',
, -
80
6
I e
- .
o--==
" ". ........" -
'. ,
. ,.. "."' .."
7
8
) C-
-==--=s'1'i) 4
9
10
Jl
11
L.o.....W-LJ
.,
11
\
3
cr .
:1
14
O '.-O
12
" -p
,.
::0
,. 18
;;
"
.. 17 fj!
:; 15 16
..
<>
..
"
.. 20 21
..
'" 22
::0
.. ;
lU 19 1 -
=f:7 25 26 27
I 24
23
78
.. .. 'go.
5 -
"'...,
o -
= - '"
'" c
0"" ...
" -'
< t
.... g
...; I
:a ,-
ca.. t;
::J) :G (,) C
F- i%I
Qc:)
; ...
';:1 :Ii '"
o >0 ..
I;!;"'-
r...:t:s:
..
= g
I
: ;;I;
:i:;1
'" I._ :::
Q) COo) 0-
..
4>"31 a
u.. ('I)
"I '" I '" I
g
It
<!
;::il:=
fi 5
b"l g
E- I COo) "'" 0
Q) .. ...
8 . I
:! 1={!'o-
tJ ;;fE "
c::s e» 0
::1 teI:G ..;
Q;j Co 0<::1
::i :s\o;'@,...
Q); I=: I ::- """
>CI..., ",- I
':::1 I '"' '" I :;
.J: C>.I :G:G ...
Et ,-;g f5
"!i
C,) ,Q P. 0
\O 50
I I
;:: '" I "'...,
C':S 01:: t;
; -.- ..
o81
-;; := ;;
Co;: is:
, E-4 :3;'; "
c:<.f! 5
3
:G <::;)-C'? Is:: I=:
I '" I Ii
Q. ...,..; to- i:: ;!;
'"
..,
'"
"
::::
"
"
'"
<:>
'"
!IE
:::
'"
'"
<:>
..
<:>
t::::
'e . \1.
-- 1
'"
..
'"
"
""
nHnHmnr OJ "OH
IIJ8nmsiHd(l9J
nHflHmnr a¥wac H anmBDundlJ
'-
"
"
-
" '
"
_ J "0
'"
co
'"
co
flHnk'mnx an'mJen n an'mlluwJ
">
'"
d ;;;
G
rn i; D I
Q @3 I
Gt
,Q. '-"" J
') -
"-"'
--.,
(S "
<:>
. ">
'"
'"
i';
o
($1F
QO
I
-1
..o¥a'n HDH Xf4HW08n.,. nU,JDh
Horo IICKYCCTBa. HeKOTOpbIe 6pOH30BbIe
rrpeJ\MeTbI 3BepIIHOrO CTIIJIH BbIHBJIHIOT
IIX npHMyIO 3aBIICIIMOCTb OT KOCTOpe3-
HOrO MaCTepCTBa (CM. 6pOH30BbIe rroJ\-
BeCKII OT Y3J\e'IKII II3 TIHTIIMapOB
(pIIC. 4, 10, 11) 10. IIcKycHo BbIpe3aH-
HbIe Ka6aHbII KJIbIKII-rroJ\BecKII C II30-
6paiKeHIIeM XIIm;HIIKOB II C reoMeTpR-
'IeCKIIMII MOTIIBaMR - JIY'lmRe 06pa3-
nbI 300MopiPHoro CTIIJIH caBpoMaToB
IIoBo.'IiKLH (pIIC. 4, 1-3, 6, 7) "; OHII
B OCHOBHOM Orrpep;eJIHIOT oc06eHHOCTII
rrOBO.TJiKC'Koro JIOKaJILHOrO BapIIaHTa.
HpO IC Toro, B 3BeplIHOM CTIIJIe rro-
BOJIiKCKOii rpyrrrrbI eCTL MOTIIBbI II
oc06eHHoCTII TpaKTOBKII, CBH3aHHbIe c
CeBepHbIM KaBKMoM R CKlIqJIIeR, oco-
6eHHo co CpeJ\HIIM OHOM (6YP;IIHbI?).
B IIpIIypaJIbcKoR rpyrrrre 3BepRHoro
CTIIJIH, 6JIII3IWR K caKo-MaccareTcKoR,
rrpep;CTaBJIeHHOR Bem;aMR II3 TarncKeHa
II Yiirapap;a 12, a TaKme pOJ\cTBeHHoR
Ka3axcTaHcKOR (TaCMOJIRHCKa1I KYJILTY-
pa) JJ II AJITaRCKOR (rra3bIpbIKcKaH
Kym,Typa) 1\ 3BeplIHbIR CTIIJIL pa3HO-
06pa:mee TIOBOJIiKCKOR rpyrrrrbI rro Ha-
60py qJaYHbI, rr03aM II nplIeMaM CTIIJIII-
3anIIII. CpeJ\II mlIBOTHbIX 3J\eCL xopomo
rrpeACTaB.'IeHbI Bep6JIIOJ\, ropHbIR K03eJI,
apxap II caRraK (pIIC. 5, 7, 9, 10, 17-
21, 23), HexapaKTepHbIe P;JIH rrOBOJIiK-
CKIIX caBpoMaToB. MOTIIBbI apxapa
II K03.TJa, rrpelIMym;ecTBeHHO BbIpaiKeH-
HMe n 6poH3e II 30JIOTe, 6e3YCJIOBHO,
3arrMC'TBOBaHbI C IOra, II3 ropHbIX o6JIa-
cTeii lOnmoii: CII6IIpii II CpeJ\HeR A3RII.
.D:JIIl I1plIypaJIbCKOH rpynrrbI TaKme xa-
paKTrpHbI KOHTypHbIe cxeMa TII'IHbIe
ll300rW;!,emUI Horii JIOma)1H, rOJIOBbI op-
.'1a n rl'o KOrtH, rrpeJ\CTaBJIeUHbIe Ha 30-
.'10TbIX OOI\.'1ap;KaX J\epeBHHIIbIX Ky6KOB
II3 I I1HTlIMapOB (pIIC. 1, 31, 39; 3,
23) IC, II Ha 6JIHmKaX OT KOHCKOR Y3J\e'I-
1m (1'0.'10Ba opJIa) II3 pHAa IOiKHO-
yp;u hC Krrx MOrnJILHIIKOB parrHIIX KO-
QPBIII!I,OB (pRC. 3,24, 33, 34) 16.
HCI;QTOpOe cBoe06pa3IIe caBpOMaT-
CROro ;meplIHoro CTII.TJH orrpep;e.TJHJIOCb
TaKiKC ero TeCHoR CBIl3bIO C 300MOPiP-
HbIMR II306paiKeHRHMII anaHblIHCKOH
KYJILTypbI TIplIKaMLH II CpeJ\Hero Ypa-
JIa 17, 'ITO oc06eHHO XOpOIIIO rrpep;CTaB-
.'leHO meJIe3HbIM KO.'I'IaHHbIM KpIO'IKOM
II3 JII06IIMOBKlI (pIIC. 3, 17) C rr.'IOCKIIM
II306paiKeHIIeM rOJIOBbI XIIm;HOR nTlInbI,
C 6pOH30BOR IIHRpycTan:Heii: ee ,a:eTa-
JIeR 18 (TIplIypaJIbCKaH rpyrrrra) IIJIII
II306pameHIIeM rOJIOBbI Mep;BeJ\H B iPac,
C KorTHMII nepeJ\HllX .larr OI,OJIO MOPJ\bI
mlIBOTHoro (pIIC. 4. 6) rra Ka6aHbeM
KJThIKe II3 HOBO-IIpIIBo.lbHoro (IIo-
BOJDKCRaH rpyrrna).
Ha6JIIOp;aeTCH 3Ha'IIITe.TJbHaH rrpeeM-
CTBeHHOCTL MemJ\Y caBpoMaTcKIIM 3Be-
plIHbIM CTIIJIeM II 300MOpiPHbIM CTIIJIeM
60JIee rr03J\HlIx cap Ia TCKIIX rrJIeMeH.
B npoxopoBCKOR Ky.TJbType 300MOpiPII3M
Ha Bem;ax npeJ\CTaB.leH :ma'IllTeJILHO
cJIa6ee, HacTyrraeT KaK 6bI ero BpeMeH-
HbIR ynaJ\OK. OH HBHO 3aBIICIIM OT npep;-
IDecTBYIOm;ero CTIIJIH, CYAH IIO 300MOPiP-
HbIM M0,TIIBaM, rrpeAcTan.-IeIIHbIM Ha
6pOH30BbIX II KOCTHnhIX 6JIHIDKaX
(pRC. 6, 3, 4), nOJ\BeCKax II HaBepmlI1IX
(PRC. 6, 8-10), rra Tya.'lCTlIbIX JIOiK-
Kax (pnc. 6, 11, 12). 3J\ecb MOTIIBbI
6JIR3KII caBpoMaTcKIIM, no 3na'IIITeJILHO
6ep;Hee.
COBepmenHo HOBLnI HB.'IenHeM, B03-
HRKIDIIM B rrpoxopoBCKOR KYJILType,
HBJIHIOTCH rrpHMoyrOJIbHbIe amypHLIe
Puc. 3. </JUZypbl U ZOJl08bl 0pJla U zpuif10lla
Ita npeDMeTax ca8poMaTc"ou "YJlbTYPbl,'
1 - CTapHu,a; 2 - I<HIlle IPeMOHTlloe); J, 4a, 20,
26, 28-30, 32 - HOBhIA KYMaH IOpCH); 4, 6, 23,
27, 33 - IIRTHMaphl I; 5 - Co60.1eBcKaa BOJIOCTb;
7, 19, 31 - AJ1e5aCTpOBa fopa IIIe"'''HCHn!!); 8-
Ca30HHHH 6yrop; 9 - IlBalIUDh-a; la, 13-
BmoMeH<!>eJ1 h n JUBeTO'!HbIl11: 11, 14 - HOBO-rrpll-
BOJIbHOe; 15 .Jt.KceHOBct\nn 16 - EaiHDl'aH;
17 - JIanacliHa '(JII0611 IOBha). is - A '1aHnCl(Oe:
21 - qepHHrOBcKHtl CMarHHTorOpCK); 22 - Ta-
Map-YTHYJIb; 24, 34 - IIRTIDtapr.r II: 2:5 - I<PhI-
JIOBCKUti: 1-4, 6, 7, 1n-15. 1')-:"')1. 24, 26) 27,
31-34 -. 6poH3a; 4a, 5. 16 - HI_" Tl. M.'1U por; 8,
9, 23, 28-30 - 30.iOTO; :).j t\il:\I .Hh; 17 - ffie-
JIe30
80
I -4J!J!)
-: - g
1 b1
-O
17 20 21
8 .>. JJ. -.' '.
22 <; _, -;. \
,'i 0 _ 23 0 ,. . -
(J..J ,\ '1" \\', 1
- 27 . ;;\,: 24
26 ',- - @ ,r3)a-"'" O "; b
<.: -I
n ' c:D ' -" 33 ---' ,
. u ' 1
-- 1LJ;tjf 34
29 30 31 '
HUMHee ,Ooeo"...
"
I:
"
..
:os
}
"
..
.
U
:os
;;
2
..
"
'"
"
'6.
"
:}
"
.
"
E
"
@
1
8 11
. I
1 1'JJ
14 V
15 16
'"
:r
"
..
..
"
..
'U
25
28
IOMHoe Opuypo".e
rr
l
3.J1.
.i
J
40
, I
6
7
19
32
,
rrpHmKR (6pOH30BbI e) C HerrOJ\BRmHbIM
H3bIqKOM. B cepeJ\IIHe IIX rrpeJ\CTaBJIeHbI
JIema IIH Bep6JIIOJ\ (pRC. 6, 13) 19 R CKa-
qY IIll XII HRK (TIIrp?) (pRC. 6, 14).
TaKme J\OBOJIbHO qaCTo BCTpe'laIOTCH
KOCTHHbIe HaBepmRH rpe6HeH C Kom.Ka-
MII (pRC. 6, 15-23) B BIIJ\e CXeMaTR'I-
HOll roJIOBbI JIomaAII II J\Pyrnx HerrOHHT-
HbIX mIIBOTHbIX R rrTHIJ;, RHorJ\a 3y6a-
PUC. 4. Ha06paxeH.UR 200406 XUUfH.UX06 H.a
noo6ecxax ua Xa6aH.bUX Xo4bLX06 U H.a UX Me-
TaAAU""..CXUX U XOCTRH.bLX UMUTa/fURX ca6po-
MaTCXOU XYo4bTypbL:
1-3; 9 - BJIIOMeatl!eJlbJt (IJ;BeTO'lBI>lit) ; 4 _ oI>PH-
)1eHOepr (MHpaoe); 5 - BepelHaOBKa; 6, 1 _ Ho-
Bo-rrpHBo.m.aoe; 8 - Bapaa; 10-12 - rrllTlD4a-
Phi I; la - HOBW KYMaK (OpcK); 14 _ MeqeT-
cat!; 1-8. 14 - KOCTb H por; 9-12 -l5poH3a
CTbIX, BeJ\Y IIX CBoe rrpOIIcxomJ\eHne,
BepOHTHO, OT rrpemHIIX caBpOMaTCKIIX
rpIIiPoHoB 20. CapMaTCKoe KOCTOpe3Hoe
IICKYCCTBO, KaK MI.I BIIJ\IIM, e e CBH3aHO
C caBpOMaTCKIIM 3BepIIHbIM CTRJIeM, HO
OHO J\aeT 300MopiPHbIe 06pa3bI BHa'lR-
TeJIbHO cyme - CXeMaTII'IHbIe R reOMeT-
pR30BaHHbIe.
TIOHBJIHIOTCH YiKe B rrpoxopOBCKoe
BpeMH II MeTaJIJIIIqeCKHe (30JIOTbIe)
rpIIBHbI II 6pac.1JeTI.I C iPIIrypOH RJIH ro-
JIOBOH XII HIIKa (pIIC. 6, 7), 'IaCTO iPaH-
TaCTII'IeCKoro. OilII oc06eHHO xopomo
II3BeCTHbI B capMaTCKRX rraMHTHHKax
py6ema H. 3., RorJ\a 3TH rrpeJ\MeTbI TO-
peBTHKH YKpamaIOTCH Ha KOIID;ax iPR-
rypOH IIJIII roJIOBOH He TOJIbKO xn HR-
Ka, HO TaI,me JIOCH, JIomaAII, 6apaHa
(pilC. 7, 5, 6). fpIIBHbI II 6paCJIeTI.I C 30-
OMOpiPHI.IMII OKOHqaHIIHMil He 6I.lJIII xa-
paKTepHbI J\JIH caBpOMaTCKorr TopeBTII-
KR - 3J\eCb HOBoe BOCTOqHOe II IOrO-BO-
CTO'lHOe BJIHHHIIe, KOTopoe IIMeJIO CBOII
RCTOKII e e B axeMeHHJ\CKOM IICKYCCTBe
CpeJ\HeH A3lIH (AMYJ\apbIIHCKIIH KJIaJ\)
R TIepcRII V-IV BB. J\O H. 3. OrrpeJ\e-
JIeHHO C 3THM IICKYCCTBOM CBH3aHbI II
rr03bI HeKOTopbIX mIIBOTHI.IX -'BbITHHY-
TbIe 3aJ\HIIe HorII H corHYTbIe B KOJIeHHX
nepeJ\HHe Horn, II rrOJ\qepRrrBaHIIe pe-
6ep II MYCKYJIOB Te:Ia B Rrr:a;e YrJIy6JIeH-
HbIX H'IeeK, KOTopbIe 3arrO.'IHHJIIICb ro-
JIY60H 6RpI030ll IIJIII IJ;BCTHOH rraCTOH
(6paCJIeTbI R3 CaJIaMaTIIHa, pIIC. 'J_ 5) 21
R BepxHero TIorpoMHoro 22. TIpOTOTR-
rraMR pHJ\a rpIIBeH II 6pac."IeTOB rrocJIY-
HUJlfHI" flOtlOAHfbe
mIIJIII TaIme axeMeHIIJ\CKIIe BeIIJ;H, RaK,
HarrpIIMep, HeKOTopbIe rrpeJ\MeTbI AMY-
J\apbIIHCKoro KJIaJ\a 23 IIJIII 30JIOTaH
rpIIBHa II3 HOBo-KYMaKcKoro MOrIIJII.-
HIlKa paCKorrOK 1971 roJ\a 2'.
HOBbIll paCIJ;BeT 300MopiPHoro rrpII-
KJIaJ\Horo RCKYCCTBa Ha6JIIOJ\aeTCH Ha
Py6eme H. 3. R B rrepBbIe J\Ba BeRa
H. 3!S, KorJ\a capMaTbI BMeCTe C IWyrII-
MII HapOJ\aMII IOra BOCTO'lHOH EBporrbI
)J;OCTIIraIOT BbICOKoro MaCTepCTBa B TO-
peBTIIKe II IOBeJIHpHOM J\eJIe. B capMaT-
CKOM rrpRKJIaJ\HOM RCKYCCTBe IICrrOJII.-
3yeTcH orrbIT J\peBHIIX MaCTepOB Cpe:a;-
Hell A3RR (B TOM 'IIICJIe II axeMeHII:a;-
CEoro BpeMeHH, a TaKme fpeKo-BaKT-
pIIllCKoro IJ;apCTBa II TIapiPIIR) II MeOTOB
TIpIIKy6aHMI. KpoMe Toro, capMaTCKIIe
IOHiHo. npUfpOA..
"
.,
"
'"
:;-
"
..
."
"
"
'S-
"
..
"
."
"
"
"
..
;;
"
., 2
"
'"
"
.,
"
.,
" "
'"
., if
.., "
" ..
.} '"
c "
c ..
"
..
;;
. ,-- .
. c ':", . :.. . .
-- .
. .
- ,.
.-
5
n...j
i
pt V'
10 1 0 13 \1! )
14
q
9
I
83
82
cf ;;
\0 '"
o :g
..;I
:g ...
-
CIi
;1:;Q.C-
'"
; I g
;:g
Be :e
c: oC5: - I
2
'" .,,- T
o I I
. I.. ... 0 0-
ao o..a E-o
"'- .... 0
...._... r:::
i o..a 8.
.,.. I
0<>=
,Q
I g "
-< :to "'1
...-ll ;::-
"'1 C\I::: "
'"
<>
fi I g -& : ...
t-.. I:: 9 8.
-Ilitt
... ao
f2 OJ I ::a
ia;; < I
'" 0 I '"
Pot .. '1$ .....
!'i I @ ....
cv;)::C; u ...
;:: ._ I I f2
:e;:fQ
" :Q.- == '"
oC5: .- =,i;j
o (Ij
.,t°'gctSs'
:0 = ;:g >-
8 E-<
ci t:i 5 1-0
",,,;S==.,I
5 I "'1
.....
:0 C\I :to .:.:.:.:
'" »",-< ';j ';j
._ I \5 13
\Q - ==
a I :Q '"
ar,; :::: 5
.. 8-
;:3 E-o r:::
....- g.
-0..
::
'"
"
"
..
"
'"
'"
S?
""
o
,.
'"
..
..
,
,.
:i
. 1):-
: b\IJ -
I -vdw JfI'mfHD;/<iJu / i1 qHeIl09
1111', aMI/lien;)
a/flHe" 09D d
.W anmba9 n
on'mIlDW:;
'"
"
"-
..
"
'"
,.
Si1
'"
::!
'"
""
<:>
'"
'r.>
..;
.
.,
c
..
.
..
,
X,QHeIJ09Vd
UJ /qsovvj
1 ,(
c).
-
<'<
\3?
D
<'<
<'<
,
.- -""
o'
-.,
()
. 0
" , ....r " "-
. -
X/QH(!1I09V./W BOIIOt
a(!n.. f' IIltflltlrC]
Puc.6
'<
.. "
...
.. :;:
.. "
:; '<
.. "
" '<
""
iItI
::f't)ba
"
:;
"-
'"
..
" <-
'< "
"
"'
- "
t:
!;
<>
"
""
'<
'"
'"
'"
;;-
'"
Puc.7
. HUHfHee fl080AHfbe
IOTKHoe flpuypaAbe
cO
} ,
;
2 ,(j
6
a4
4
7
C:=
oo ,_ " c_ ;--
-c- 3:
' bQ " j
I 9 10
1 ()= - - C
;
t;J
Q
13--- 2:>-D
r .' I
' ' (!)
--= - " - '
17 r f /8
J
, " r
I
5
.-
w
,/
9
'j. -)
23
;,
.-
3
8f
4
I I
MaCTepa B 3IIa'BITeJIbHOH CTCrreHII OPII-
eHTIIpYIOTCH Ha xyp;omecTBeHHOe peMeC-
!1eIIIIOe rrpOII3Bop;CTBO rOpOp;OB CeBep-
HOrO IIpII'IepHOMOpbH, OC06eHHO Boc-
IIOpClWro n;apCTBa.
B rrpIIKJIap;HOM IICK)'CCTBe CapMaTOB
rrO-rrpemHeMY rrpaKTIIKYIOTCH 300MOpq,-
Hble MOTIIBbI. OHH IIpep;CTaBJIeHbI 'Iam;e
BCerO Ha rrpep;MeTaX TOpeBTIIKII - B 30-
JIOTe II cepe6pe: Ha 6paCJIeTaX II rpIIB-
IIaX (pIIC. 7, 5, 6) 26, rrpHmKaX II 6JIHill-
KaX OT Op;emp;bI (pIIC. 7, 2-4), Ha rrpep;-
MeTax KOHCKoro y60pa - rrCaJIIIHX II
KonCKIIX q,aJIapax (pIIC. 7, 1) 27, a TaK-
me Ha aJIe6aCTpoBbIX TyaJIeTHbIX COCY-
p;IIKax (pIIC. 7, 9) II Ha pY'lKax MeTaJI-
!1IIQeCKIIX COCYP;OB - Ha 30JIOTbIX KY6-
Kax II HeKOTopbIX Mep;HbIX KOTeJIKaX
(pIIC. 7, 11). 06bI'1HO py'lKII aJIe6aCTpo-
BbIX COCyp;IIKOB CXeMaTII'IHO BocrrpOII3-
BOP;HT JIemaIIJ;IIX (<IIpIIIIaBillIIX K 3eMJIe»
XIIm;HIIKOB (JIbBOB?) B caBpOMaTCKOM
p;yxe.
B YKpameHIIII rrpep;MeTOB TopeBTIIKII
rrpC):\llO'lTeHIIe OTp;aeTCH XIIIIJ;HIIKaM II
p;paKoHo06pa3HbIM CYIIJ;eCTBaM C CIIJIbHO
II30rHYTbIMii Te.llaMII, 'IaCTO C «BbIBepHY-
TblM 3ap;OM», KaK 3TO rrpep;CTaBJIeHO
B 60JIee paHHeM IICKYCCTBe peBHero
+-
Puc. 6. 300M.opoifJH.ble MorU8bl IIpoxop08-
c"uu "YAbrypbl:
1. 16, 17 - I-;amlHoBKa; 2 - JJ:>KamaJIa; 3, 4,
2.1 - CTaphIe 1-\ nllIllHU; S, 6 - CaJIaMaTllHO; '1,
3 - rrpOXopoBKa; 9. 10 - EJIeM6eTOBO; 11. 14-
CTapnna; 12 - JII05u OBH:a; 13 - xyT. BeceJlbIfi;
15, ':!:J - 15-fi noce:101\; 18, 21- 3an.rraBHoe; 19,
20 - YeaTOBO; 1. 2, 4. 11, 13. 14 -6pOH3a; 3,
8-10, 12, 15-23 - HOCTb llnll par; 5-7 - 30nOTO
Pur. 7.. BeUfu 38epU1£020
do }f. .1-//8. H. 3.:
1 - l103.:tBllffiCHCHoe; 2, 6 - JIa.!I.Oit\CHaa; 3, 4.
7 - T"<jJ:meCKaR; 5 - YCTL-."Ia6IfHCKaR; 8 - P;MI!-
TI'I!PBKa; 9 - CYC.lbJ; 10 - Tn<IJ.lnccBaH; 11 -
BClrXHlfIl HH1:fCHHOB; 1, 8, 10, 11 - 6poH3a; 2-5,
i - f'poH3a II 30nOTO; 6 - 30!IOTO: 9 - a.TIcoacTi>
crUM' I 8.
AJITaH rra3bIpbIKCIWll: KYJIbTypbI 28. My-
CKYJIbI mIIBOTHbIX QaCTO rrOp;'IepKHYTbI
n;BeTHbIMII BCTaBKa lII (rraCTOll:, 6IIpIO-
30H II p;pyrIIMII KaMHH I.II), rrpep;CTaB-
JIHH II3YMIITeJIbHYIO IITPy n;BeTa 29. Cn;e-
HbI 60pb6bI mIIBOTHbIX, Tep3aHIIH XIIIIJ;-
HIIKOM TpaBOHp;HbIX IICKJIIO'IIITeJIbHO p;II-
HaMII'IHbI (pIIC. 7, 7). OHII HpKO rrpep;-
CTaBJIeHbI B CII6IIpCKOH: 30JIOTOll
KOJIJIeKIJ;IIII IIeTpa I 30, rp;c cop;epmaTCH,
BepOHTIIO, II rrpep;MeTbI capMaTClwro
IIpOII3Bop;CTBa. 3TII Cn;eHbI Tep3aHIIH II
60pb6bI BOCXOP;HT eIIJ;e I, CilBpOMaTCKO-
MY BpeMeHII IOmHoro IIpIIypaJIbH II,
BepOHTHO, CBH3aHbI c 3llII'IeCKIIMII
CKa3aHWlMII, OTpamaIOIIJ;IIMII aKTIIBHYIO
MemrrJIeMeHHYIO 60pb6y II rrOCTOHHHbIe
BOHHbI Mem capMaTCI-;IfMII rrJIeMeH-
HbIMII 06'bep;IIHeHIIHMII 31.
B Te'leHIIe rrepBbIX BeKOB H. 3. cap-
MaTCKIIH 3BepIIHbIH CTII,TJ.b, BOCXOp;Hrn;IIll
K caBpOMaTCKOH 3rroxe, 3aMeHHeTCK rro-
JIIIXpOMHbIM CTIIJIeM, B I\OTopml 300MOp-
q,HbIe 110TIIBbI rrOCTeIH'HHO BbITeCHH-
IOTCH reOMeTpII'IeCKIIMII, XOTH 300MOpq,-
HOcTb coxpaHHeTCH P;O KOHl\a caMOCTOK-
TeJIbHOrO rrOJIIITIIqeCKOrO rOCIIop;CTBa
capMaTOB B CTerrHX BOCTOqHOll EBporrbI,
'Iarn;e Bcero Ha pyqI-;ax r.1HHHHbIX CO-
CYP;OB. <1>IIrypKII mUBOTHbIX Ha HHX
rrpep;CTaBJIeHbI BeCbMa pca.1llCTII'IHO mIH
O'leHb CXeMaTII'IHO. IIocy,'J,a C 300MOpq,-
HbIMII pY'lKa 1II rrOHBII.1aCb y capMaTOB
B caMOM KOHn;e I TbIC. p;o H. 3. II pac-
rrpOCTpaHIIJIaCb B rrepBLle BeI-;a H. 3. 32,
BepOHTHO, rrop; B,TmHIII1C 1 HeKOTopbIX
q,OpM ceBepOKaBI\a ClwiI II OT'IaCTII
cpep;nea3IIaTCKoii Kepa mnm; 06bI'IHO
TaKlle PY'lI-;I1 paCOlaTjlIIRilIOTCH KaI-;
06eper, B03 IOiKHO, hal, IIP,IHOH3bIQHbIll:
q,apI! 33. ,lJ,Y laeT(, II, qT<) "epa mI-;a C 30-
OMOpq,lIbIMd pyql,amI TO:lbI-;O OTqaCTII
3aBllCeJIa 0'" 3Bepn nor" '."1"II,lH, rocrrop;-
CTBoBaBruero B TeqClIlW I'H; a CTO;reTIIll:
B rrpHK1a)Jllml IICJ;YU r 1\(' caBpOMaTOB
II cap laTOB. coxpaBHH I< o'.1I0BHOM .caI-;-
paJIbHO-MarIIqeCKUii II OT'laCTII II op-
uaMeHTaJIbHbli'i xapa!,n'p.
88
I K. ([>. CMUP1£08. CaBpOMaTbi. \\f., 1964,
CTp. 216.
If. B. CUnUlfbl1£. TIaMHTHIfKII HIfmHero llo-
BOJImbIl CKII<po-capMaTcKoro BpeMeHif.
«TpYAbI CapaToBcKoro 06iIacTIIoro MY3eIl
KpaeBeAeIfWI. ApxeoJIorlI'leCKIfll C60pHIfK ,
Bbill. 1. CapaToB, 1956, CTp. 34-37;
pliC. 12, 1.
3 II. C. Pbl»08. CYCJIOBCRIIH RypraHHbIll MO-
rIlJIbHIIR. .YqeHbIe 3anliCKif CapaToBcKoro
roc. YHIIBepcIITeTa_, T. IV, BbIn. III. Ca-
paToB, 1925, CTp. 29 II puc. 17.
. M. H. Pocr08lfe8. KypraHHbIe HaxollKII
OpeH6yprcKoII 06JIaCTli 3IIOXII paHHero If
n03AHerO 3JIJIIfHII3Ma. MAP, M 37. llrp.,
1918, Ta6JI. VII, pliC. 4-
5 K. ([>. CMUP1£08, B. r. IIerpe1£"o. CaBpOMa-
TbI llOBOJImbJl II lOmHoro llpIfypaiIbIl.
CAM, Al-9. M., 1963, Ta6JI. 26, pliC. 3.
8 K. ([>. CMUp1£08, B. r. IIerpe1£"o. YKa3.
COq., Ta6J1. 21, pliC. 6.
7 TaM me, pliC. 4, 5.
8 TaM me, Ta6JI, 17, pliC. 51.
. K. ([>. CMUP1£08. CaBpoMaTbI, CTp. 326, 327,
pliC. 33; pliC. 371, pliC. 80, 1.
10 K. ([>. CMUP1£08. B. r. IIerpe1£"o, YKa3.
COq., Ta6JI. 17, pliC. 56 II 64.
11 B. N. Grakov.Monuments de la culture
scythique entre Ie Volga et les monts
aural. ESA, III. Helsinki, 1928.
12 C. II. TOAcr08. llo ApeBHIIM AeJIbTaM OKca
U HRcapTa. M., 1962, CTp. 185, pliC. 106;
on :J/Ce. CpeAHea311aTcRife CRII<pbI B CBPTe
HOBellmlix apxeoJIorUqeCKIiX OTKpbITIIrr.
BAI1, 1963, M 2, CTp. 38, pIfC. 11; C. ll.
TOAcr08, M. A. Hru1£a. CaKIi HII30Bben
Cblp-Aapbu. CA, M 2, 1966, pliC. 7, 15, 16,
17, 18.
13 A. X. MapeYAa1£, K. A. A"UlUe8, M. b:.
Kaoblp6ae8, A. M. 0p036ae8. ApeBHlI1I
RYJIbTypa eHTpaiIbHoro Ka3a:o.:cTalla.
AJIMa-ATa, 1966, CTp. 303.
.. C. H. Pyoe1£"o. KYiIbTypa HaCeJICllIIII for-
Horo Ail Tall B CKIf<pCKoe BpeMIi. M.- .1..
1953; 01£ :J/Ce. KYiIbTypa HaceiIellllIl QPHT-
paJIbHOrO AJITaIl B CKIf<pCKoe Bre [II. .1..
1960.
IS K. ([>. CM.UP1£08, B. r. llerpell"o. YI;a:o.
COq., Ta6iI. 26, pliC. 16, 18, 21, 24.
18 M. r. MOlU,,08a. llaMIlTHIiKIl IIPOXOPOR-
CKOll KYJIbTypbI. CAI1, Al-10. M., 1963.
CTp. 234, pliC. 6, 81'; K. C/J. CM.UPII08. B T.
IIerpe1£"o, YKa3. COq., Ta6JI. 17. pIIC. 27.
42, 49, 63.
17 A. B. 36pye8a. I1CTOpifIl HaceiIellHII !lllll-
RaMbIl B aHaHbllHCKYIO 3noxy. \\fHA, ;N; :\0.
1952, CTp. 136.
IS K. ([>. CMUP/l,08. HOBbIe capMaTCEIIP na-
MIlTHIiKIt Ha BY3YJIYRe. KCMA, M 89. ,I.
1962, CTp. 86, pIfC. 32, 5.
\9 M. H. Apra."01£08. PaCKOII!{If KypraHoB Ha
p. MaHbIqp B 1937 r. CA, T. XI, 1949,
CTp. 321, pIfC. 18.
00 M. r. MOlU"08a. Y"a3. COq., Ta6JI. 26,
pIfC. 13-18.
21 OAR, 1902 r. CII6., 1904, CTp. 138, 139,
pilC. 246-252; H, Bepxu1£ (3acelf»aSl).
CapMaTcKoe norpe6eHife y c. CaJIaMaTIiHo.
Cf3, T. XV. J1., 1959, CTp. 37-41.
00 B. II. illUA08. llorpe6eHifIl capMaTcKoH
3HaTif I B. AO H. 3.- I B. H. 3. cr3, T. IX.
J1., 1956, CTp. 42-45.
" O. M. Dalton. The Treasure of the Oxus.
London, 1964, pI. XX, fig. 136, 137.
" K. ([>. CMUP1£08. 3araARli OpCKIiX Rypra-
HOB. «HaYKa U mII3Hb», 1971, .N! 12,
CTp. 94-96 ( BeTHaIl BCTaBKa); K. ([>.
CMUp1£08, T. H. Ca8eJl.be8a. BiIIfiKHeBOCToq-
HbIe ApeBHocTIi Ha lOmHoM YpaJIe. BAM,
1972, M 3, CTp. 116, pHC. 6.
25 A. H. MaA08Ulfc"aSl. CapMaTCKlill 3Bepll-
HbIll CTlliIb. ABTOpe<p. KaHA. AIICC. J1., 1967.
28 A. II. CMUP1£08. HOBbIlI CapMaTCRlIll Mo-
rllJIbHIIK B BopOHe)I(CKOII 06JIaCTU. BAM,
1940, M 3-4, CTp. 363-366; H. Bepxu1£
(3acelf"aSl). YRa3. COq., CTp. 37-41; B. II.
illUJl.08. YKa3. COq" CTp. 42-45.
27 A. CnUlfbl1£. <I>aiIapbl lOmHoII POCCIIU.
MAK, Bbln. 29. Cll6., 1909, CTp. 18-53;
C. H. KanOlUU1£a. QeHHbIe HaxoAKIi apxeo-
JIOrOB B palloHe HOBOqepKaccRa. BAH,
M 3, 1963, CTp. 128-130; O1£a :J/Ce. A. Sar-
mati an Royal Burial Grave at Novocher-
kassk. «Antiquity», vol. XXXVI, 1963,
pp. 256-258.
28 C. H. PyfJe1£"o. KYJIbTypa HaCeJIeHIIJI rop-
Horo AJITaIl.., CTp. 102, pliC. 55; CTp. 139,
pliC. 82-83; CTp. 275, pliC. 158, 159; Ta6JI.
I, 3; IX, 8, 9; XII, 2; CXl, 01£ :J/Ce. KYJIb-
Typa HaceiIeHIfH eHTpaJIbHorO AnTaIl..,
CTp. 46, pIIC. 21; CTp. 47, pliC. 22; CTp. 265,
pIfC. 136; Ta6iI. XCVII, 4.
09 P. A., BbIn. III. Cll6., 1890, CTp. 134-140,
pliC. 152-158, 169, 164; S. I. Kaposhina.
YKa3. COq.
30 C. H. Pyden"o. CIf6HpCKaIl KOiIiIeK 1I11
lleTpa I. CAI1, A3-9. M.- J1., 1962.
'I M. II. rpR3/1,08. ApeBHellmlle naMHTHIfKIf
repOllqeCKOrO 3IIoca HapoAoB lOmHoII CIf-
6Ifpll. ACf3, BbIlI. 3. JI., 1961.
32 K. M. C"aA01£. I1300pameHife mUBOTHbIX
Ha Kepa !lIKe capMaTcKoH RYJIbTypbI.
T0I1llK3, T. I. J1., 1941; M, II. A6paM08a.
a KepaMIfKe C 300 lOp<pHbIMIi pyqKaMif.
CA, 1969, x 2.
33 B. A. lIur8u1£c"uu. KaHrlOlIcKo-capMaT-
cKIIB: <papH. AymaH6e, 1968.
89
A. M. IIIRypIW
o JIORAJIbHbIX P A3JIJ;IqJ;U-IX
B J;ICRYCCTBE JIECOCTEIIHOI1 Cllli<Dllll
BI.HlBJIeHHe JIOKaJII.HLlX oc06eHHocTeii:
B IICKYCCTBe rrJIeMeH CeBepHoro TIplI-
qepHOMOpI.H H TIplIKy6aHI.H HaqaJIOCI. B
50-I' roAM. TIpHMeHIITeJII.HO K TepplITO-
pHH CTerrHoro H JIeCOCTerrHoro TIoAHe-
rrpOBI.II 3Ta rrpOOJIeMa 6hIJIa BrrepBLle
paccMoTpeHa B AHCCepTan;HH M. B. IIe-
CTpHKOBOii: '. CAeJIaB PIIA n;eHHLlX Ha-
6moAeHHii: 0 xapaKTepe pacrrpOCTpaHe-
HIIH OTAeJII.HLlX MOTIIBOB R rrpe eTOB
HCKYCCTBa, aBTOp rrpeYBeJIHqlIJIa CTe-
rreHI. pa3JIH'IHii: B 3BepHHOM CTIIJIe CTerr-
HOii: H JIeCOCTeIHIOii: CKHqmH, oc06eHHO
;a:JIII VI - V BB. AO H. 3.
AHaJIH3 300MOP<PHLIX yKpameHIIR
rrpeAMeTOB KOHCKOii: c6PYH H3 IIpHKY-
6aHI.II rrpHBeJI A. K. KOPOBIIHY K BLlBO-
lI:Y 0 cy ecTBoBaHlm; 3AecI. C V B. ;a:o
H. 3. oc060ro JIOKaJII.HOro BapliaHTa
CKH<PCKOro 3BeplIHoro CTIIJIH 2.
IbyqeHIIC rraMHTHHKOB iPpaKHii:cKoro
HCKYCCTBa, B oc06eHHOCTH CKlIiPo-<ppa-
KHii:cKoro 3BeplIHoro CTIIJIH B CeBepHOM
IIplIqepHOMOpI.e, rr03BOJIIIJIO e e 60JIee
OTqeTJIIIBO BLlHBIITI. oc06eHHOCTII IIC-
I\YCCTBa CTeIlHoiI CKlIiPIIII IV - II I BB.
):\0 H. 3. 3
MLlCJIb 06 H3BeCTHOM cBoe06pa3IIII
3BeplIHoro CTIIJIH JIeCOCTerrHI.IX 06JIa-
cTeii: B V - III BB. ):\0 H. 3. II ;a:ame B
rreplIo;a: apxalIKH rrarryqlIJIa qaCT Hoe
pa3BIITIIe B pa60Tax B. f. IIeTpeHKo 11
B. A. IDpaMKO '.
TaKIIM 06pa30M, B HaCTOH ee BpeMH
MomHO rOBoplITb 0 cy ecTBoBaHIIII B
CKlIiPCKOM 3BepHHOM CTIIJIe Tpex Kpyrr-
HLIX JIOKaJII.HLlX BapHaHTOB: rrpHKy6aH-
CKoro, CTeIIHoro II JIeCOCTerrHoro. O;a:Ha-
KO, pa3JIIIqlIH MeiKJQT HHMH rrO-HaCTOII-
eMY IIpOHBJIHlOTCII TOJII.KO B rreplIo;Q;
V -III BB. ):\0 H. 3. 5 TeppHTopHH JIeco-
cTeIIHoii: CKIIiPIIH 60raTa rraMHTHIIKaMB
3BeplIHoro CTIIJIH, xopomo rrpe):\CTaB-
JIHlO IIMII BeCI. rryTI. 3TOro cBoe06pa3-
Horo IICRyc.cTBa C KOHn;a VII ;a:o
III B. ;a:o H. 3. <1>YH):\aMeHTam.HaH 06-
pa60TKa Bcex HaKOrrJIeHHLlX MaTeplIa-
JIOB, IIpO;J;eJIaHHaH B. A. MJIhRHCKOR,
f. T. KOBIIaHeHKo, II. .[1;. JIH6epoBLlM,
A. M. l\fe.llOKoBoii:, B. f. IIeTpeHKo,
B. A. I1IpaMKo ;a:JIII OT):\eJII.HLlX BapH-
aHTOB Ky.lbTypLl JIeCOCTerrHOR CKB<p HH ,
;a:aeT rrpeKpacHYIO B03MOmHOCTI. AJIII
cpaBHennH rraMHTHIIKOB xYAomeCTBeH-
Horo TBOp'IeCTBa MeCTHLlX rrJIeMeH C
n;e.'lbJO BbIHBJIeHnH JIOKam.HHX pa3JIH-
qUIr.
113BeCTno, qTO y rrJIeMeH JIeCOCTerr-
Hoii CImcj')J!II rrpe eTLI 3BeplIHoro CTII-
JIH rro yqnJIII ;a:aJIeKO He paBHOIJ;eHHoe
yrroTpen:ICllIle. OHII rrpaKT eCI\II OT-
CYTeTIJ 'I{jT B IIa IHTHRKaX CpeARero
II O;J;II pcr jlOBbH, e.1J:a60 rrpe;a:cTaBJIeHLI B
IIouymbP n Ha CeBepHoM .[I;oHIJ;e, OTHO-
cnTe.'lblin laJIOqIICJIeHHLI Ha BOpCKJIe.
3TO IIe rro3Bp:rHeT rrpOBeCTH Harne cpaB-
HIITem,IIOC .I IICc.le;a:OBaHlIe B TOqHOM
COOTBPTlTHnfl: C BLI):\eJIHeMLlMII B .'leCO-
CTerrII .10KaJIbHbIMII KYJII.TypaMH 6.
II pe.:Ie T.I B.l H eTCH IJ;eJIe.co06pa3HI.IM
B3HTL .<;1 OCHOBY Tpii HalI60JIee rrpe;a:-
CTaBIITe.lhnbIX paROHa: IIpaBo6epem-
90
Hoe JIeCOCTerrHoe IIo;a:HeilpOBI.e, JIeBo-
6epemHoe JIeCOCTeilHoe IICI;a:HerrpOBI.e
(rrpem;a:e Bcero IIocym.e) II Cpe;a:Hee
IIo;a:oHI.e.
B ROHn;e VII II B VI BB. ;a:o H. 3. 3Be-
pIIHLlii: CTIIJII. OTCYTCTByeT B rraMHTHII-
Kax CpeAHero TIO;a:OHI.H, B IIo;a:HerrpOBI.e
MeCTHhIe pa3JI IIH BbIpameHhI e e
cJIa60. 06pa3 KOmaqbero XHIIJ;BHKa
rrOHBJIlleTCH B 060lIX paii:oHax rryTeM
3alIMCTBOBaHHH IICXO;a:HbIX iPOpM B rra-
MHTHHKax KeJIepMeCCKO - caKKLl3CKO-
ro Kpyra, qTO oc06eHHO OqeBII;a:HO ;a:JIH
H306pameHHii: CBepH)'BmerocH 3_Be-
pH 7. Ha rrpoTHmeHilll VI B. B pa3pa-
-ooTKe MOTIIBa Ha6JIJO;a:aeTcH HeKOTopoe
cBoe06pa3lIe. B IIocYJIbe CTaHOBIITCH
R3JI106JIeHHLlM CJOmeT oT):\eJII.Hoii: 1'0-
JIOBKH XII HIIKa, Tor):{a RaK B IIpa-
B06epemI.e rrpe):\CTaBJIenbI H n;eJILle
iPlIrypLl.
M306pameHIIH IJ;eJIon iPlIrypLl rrplI-
rraBmero K 3eMJIe XII HnKa II3BeCTHLI
TOJIhKO f:VIH IIpaB06epeiKI.H 8 II OTJI a-
JOTCH B pH;a:e e;rY'IaeB CTpeMJIeHlIeM K
HaTypaJIII3MY, IIpII;:(aHne 1 KOmaqI.eMY
XIIIIJ;BHKY Me):\BemblIX qepT
(pHC 1, 1, 2).B JIeB06epemI.e OHR rro-
IIBJIHIOTCH TOJII.KO B KOHIJ;e VI - Ha-
qaJIe V B. ;a:o H. 3. B Bn,!]:e pa60T, OTMe-
qeHHhIX yJRe rpeqeCKIIM BJIIIHHlIeM 9.
IIo-pa3HOMY TpaHT}lOTCH B 060lIx
paROHax II306pamenIIH oT;a:eJII.HOR ro-
JIOBKII. B IIocy.'lbe rocIIo;a:cTByeT TIIII
C TOpqa IIM BB8pX :1aOCTpeHHLlM YXOM
II Tyrroii: MOp):\OH, Ha i>OTOpOR BLI;a:eJIH-
lOTCH C.IIMMCTpII'InO paeIIOJIOmeHHLle
H03;a:pH n rraCTb '0. n oe.le):{HIII' rrepe;a:a-
HLI cOBepmcHHo o;umaKOBO B BII):\e
OBa:IbHHX BbmYR.10lTPfI C RpyrJIOR
AMPOqKOrr II :umeiTnon rrpOpe3I.lO rro
cepe):\IIHe (pIIC. 1. .9. 10) ". BcpmlI-
HOR oplIrnHa.lhHoeTil B TpaRTOBKe CJO-
meTa MOryT C.1J:Y;IHITI, r;OCTHHbIe CTOJI-
6IIKB H3 Kypran<l y C. BYP;KII
(plIc.1, 8). IIpaBoGepp;I;Hble 06pa3IJ;LI
(pHC 1, 3, 4) 3naqlITe.lbHO 6JIIIme Ke-
JIepMCCCKIIM IIpOTOTIIn;t !. OHII coxpaHH-
lOT cep.n;n;eBII;a:HYlO <POPMY yxa, KpyrJIYJO
H03;a:plO II ;a:ame, B O;a:HOM CJIY'lae, 3Y-
6aCTYlO rraCTI. - rrpHMoe rro;a:pamaHIIC
BOCTOqHLlM rOJIOBKaM JIhBOB. B KOHIJ;C
VI B. 3;a:eCI. rrOHBJIJUOTCII Ha KOCTHHLlX
rrcamrax COBepmeHHO cBoe06pa3HLlc
H306pameHHII, BI.IIIOJIHeHHhIe B 0606-
eHHO-rrJIaCTlIqeCKOR MaHepe (pIIC. 1,
5). OqeHI. BLlpa3IITeJIhHLle H opHrR-
HaJII.HLle, OHH IIpKO CBII;a:eTeJIhCTBYJOT 0
TBOpqeCKoii: caMOCTOHTeJII.HOCTH 1011'-
CTHLIX MaCTepOB.
M306pameHHII rpB<p0-6apaHoB H 6a-
paHOB rrpeACTaBJIeHhI B AOBOJII.HO 6JI1I3-
KOii: TpaKToBKe Ha ROCTHHblX rrCaJIHHX,
B MeIThmeii: Mepe - Ha cToJI6IIKaX II
HaBepIIIHHx. HecoMHeHHa BX CBH3I. C
rOJIOBKaMH H3 KeJIepMeCCKHx RypraHoB,
KapMlIp-BJIypa H TeMlIp-fopLl 12. CTII-
JIIICTlIqeCKOe eARHCTBO II306pameHIIii:
rpHiPo-6apaHa Ha Bceii: TeppHTopIIII
pacrrpGcTpaHeHHH cKHiPcKoro 3BepIIHO-
1'0 CTHJIII CBH.n;eTeJII.CTByeT, Ha Ham
B3JIIIA, 06 OTHOClITeJIhHOR KpaTKOBpe-
MeHHOCTH 6bIToBaHHH 3Toro MOTIIBa: B
OCHOBHOM B rrpeAeJIax rrepBoR rrOJIOBII-
HLI VI B. ;a:o H. 3. IIpH 3TOM rrOCYJII.CKlIe
06pa3IJ;LI, 3a O;a:HIIM IICKJIJOqeHReM 13,
KamYTCII 60JIee rr03;a:HIIM II , p;aJII.me
CTOHIJVlMH OT lOmHblX rrpOTOTlIrrOB, qeM
rrpaB06epemHLle (pHC. 1, 6, 7, 17,
12) ".
XpOHOJIornqecrorii MOMeHT rrpoHB-
JIHeTCII TalORe II B HeKoTopLlX oc06en-
HOCTHX TpaKToBKII rOJIOBOK 6apaHa: II:'!
52 II3BeCTHLlX HaM H306pameHIIR R
JIcB06epembe TOm.KO y ;a:BYX coxpanII-
JIRCI. YIIIH, 06H3aTeJII.Hble Ha rOJIOBJWX
6apanOB II3 KeJIepMeca. MHTepecno
OTMeTIITI., qTO B IIpaB06epembe ymn
II306pameHLI y rrHTH II3 ;a:eBHTH ro.'lO-
BOK.
B HaII60.'lee peaJIIICT eCKHX 06pa:'!-
n;ax 3aMeTHO CTpeMJIeHlIe IIplI):\aTb oa-
paHY xapaKTepHble qepTLI JIOCH (pne. 1,
13) 15. IIpe;a:cTaBJIHeTcH, qTO IIcxo;a:nLIfl
06pa3 ropHOro 6apaHa 6L1JI qym;a: na-
eeJIeHlIlO .1J:eCOCTerrHoii: 30HLI II TpaR-
91
TOBaJICH MeCTBbIMII MaCTepall1II KaK
AOMamHHii: 6apaH HJUI JIOCe-6apaH 16.
3H8qRTeJThHO Hpqe II c8r.w6bITHee
npeACTaBJIeH B TIoCYJIbe MOTHB ROHCKOE:
rOJIOBhl 17 . Bo BTOpOii: IIOJIOBUHe VI B.
AO H. 3. SAeCb Bhlpa6aTbIBaeTCH COBep-
meHHo OpHrnHaJIhHhIii: TRII BbITHnyroH
BnepeA ronoBbI ROHH C ,/I.nunnbIM IIPB-
maThIM YXOM. XapaKTepnoii oco6enno-
CTblO HBJIHeTCH opHaMeHTanbnaH paapa-
60ma Hos)Weii:, rJIaa R paROBldn ymeE:
(pRC. 1, 14, 15). Hur,/l.e B coceJI.HBx
paE:OHaX lIB'Iero IIo,/l.06noro neT. 3aTo
B TIocYJIhe VI B. AO H. a. IIpaRTRqeCKII
OTCYTCTBYIOT H306pameHHH OJIeRH -
MOTHBa, TpalJ,llIUiOHHoro ,/I.JIH CKIiCI)CKO-
ro UCRyccTBa. TaR, COBepmeHHO He R3-
BeCTHbI ap;eCb 30JIOTbIe II.'18CTIlHRU C
H306pa7KenneM OJIeneii: B R aCCffqeCKOE:
n03e 4CJIeTHID;ero raJIOIIal), CTOJIb 06hI'l-
HoE: B ITpaBo6epembe 18. DpHIJ. JIB aTO
CJI}"IaHHOCTb, Be));b B IIOCY;Ibe II3BeCT-
HO 60nee 200 apXanqeClm:x ROMIIneR-
COB. ROHeqaO, 06paa onew! IIMeJI MeCTO
B HCRyccTBe JIeB06epembH. no HBHO He
nOJIb30BaJICH nonYJUlpllOCTblO. TIapa
myr.unD,ux H8Bepmuii 113 POMCHCKBX
Rypr8nOB AaeT HaoGpameHlle MOnop,LIX
6eapornx oneneii: HRB naneR, 60JIee
TBlmqnbIX lJ,JIH p,ynaucRoii rpYIIIIbI Ha-
Bepmuii ". BepOHTno, cpe II aooMop4>-
HhlX KOCTHHbIX I1ca.1I1en Tome MOryr
6h1Tb rOJIOBRR 6eaporux OReneD nJIH
JIaneD, HO BbI,i],eJIRTb nx OqCHb TPYWlO.
3TO Bce, qTO MOffillO Ha3f18Tb 20. IIoKa-
aaTeJIbllO, '1TO CXO,/l.HOe III'.lmRPHne cox-
paHHeTCH B TIocYJIbe 11 B V B. AO H. a.
MOTRB JIocllnoii ro.1omiII MomHO
npe,/l.IIOJIaraTb H8 pH;:J,C UOJl .1 bClillX RO-
CTHHbIX IIca.1HeB, Tp:unOIWIIIlbIX 0606-
m.eHn(l. 6e3 qeTKOll: llepCl....HJ BII,/I.OBbIX
'IepT lliI::BOTnOIV' pIlC. 1. Iri. 17) 2'. He-
KOTopble IIa nux, RpO\l(' y:\a, HMelOT
eID,e oJ:\un BblcTyn Ha :I6 . lIaIlOMRHalO-
m.nii: nepe,/l.Huii OTpOCTOR III)IOB. XapaR-
TepeH TaRme IIJIaBmlii RnIlT p C xapaR-
TepHOD rop6unRoii H OTBlIl:.lIIl'ii HII7KHeD
ry60iL Ha IIpaB06epe<l;I... 11306pame-
lIllH JIOCH H3BeCTnbI TOJIbRO B BR,/I.e
I.{eJIhIX 4>uryp Ha nJlaCTUIIR8X R3 BTO-
poro ma60TI:IHCKOrO KypraHa py6ema
VII-VI BB. AO H. 3. 2Z .
TOJIbRO B JIeB06epem:be BCTpeqa-
IOTCH u306pamenHH 6bIR8 23 . I1HTepecnbI
meCTb rOJIOBOR Ha ROCTJIIlhlX ncammx
(pRC. 1,18,19) u. HecMoTpH na OTCYT-
CTBRe pOroB, 6hI'lbI:l 'IepTbI OTqeTJIHBO
BbICTYII810T B ua06pamemm RpynHoH
MaCCI:IBHOH roJIOBbI C nOKaTbIM JI60M II
TynoH MOp,ll;OD. BepoHTHo, nOHBJIenRe
aToro 06pa3a na nCaJIUHX CBH3aHO C
yrroTpe6JIeHBeM B ITocYJIbe ruyMHII\HX
HaBepmnif Tuna HaHAeHHhIX B CTapmoii:
MoruJIe, o4>opMJIeHBe ROTOphIX rOJIOB-
ROD 6bIRa, B CBOIO O'lepe,ll;b, npOB30lliJIO
no,ll; BJIBJIHUeM RaBRaaCRBX U cpeAIIe-
aaRaTCRRX 06pa3n;OB Z5.
llonyJlHpnOCTB pa3JIII'InbIX MOTHBOB
B 060RX paiionax IIo,ll;HenpoBbH B pH,II;e
CJIyqaeB COOTBeTcTByeT II! npe,ll;IIO'lTe-
HUe, OT,II;annOe OT,II;eJIbHhlM K8TeropRHM
,/I.eRopHPO'eMbIX npelJ,MeToB. IIocYJlbc
HBJIHeTCH OCHOBHbIM paii:oHoM yuoTpe6-
JIeHHH U npoH3BO,ll;CTBa 6pOH30BbIX my-
MJIII.{RX HaBepIIllIH U TonopRKoB-cKHneT-
pOB, ROCTHHhlX aooMop4>nbIx nCaJIIIeB
R cToJI6RKOB-npoHu30R OT KoncRon
c6pyu, Ha KOTOpbIX TaK JlpRO BbIpa-
3BJIOCb cBoe06paaue MeCTnoro 3BepI:lIIO-
ro CTHnJI.
POJIb KOCTH RaR MaTCpnaJIa, B ROTO-
pOM npOHBJIHJIHCb caMo6bITnble 'IepTbI
paIlHeCKJI4>cRoro aBepI:lIIOl'O CTn.\UI,
, .. "."- ,..- .
' ':''i . .
t". '.
ft i:.j;{l i 11. 'pI &>
. . 'I' ) .,
.' . r:- :";". . . .
- ---..-- I:.
2 8
C? . f '13
. .\ '\
J 4
5 9 '0
1!f °DY , .J
-
' ,
(!)" , '
1/
6
;
7 " '2 13
A
1"-'
.
.
cr
11
:
14
16
PIlC. 1. fla."RTHuXU 36epuH020 CTUAR CpelJ-
Heao flodHenp06bR VI 6. 80 11..3.
1 - c. ryJUdl-ropon. Rypr. 38; I-c. lXapLeBRa
(j.;I1I3 IIlnO;JbI, Rypr.; 8 - HueBCR3R r}'(j.. TO..-
Bee Be 113BeCTpoe; 4 - c. BepeCTH>ITU, R}pr. 6;
5 - c. Pallropc.1. Rvpr. 1; 6 - c. MenbBIu<oBKa.
Hypr.; 7 - IfeNupoBCRoe roponll1Ile: II -
c. Byn,m. Hypr.; 9, 11- C. BOJU<OBqbI, Rypr. Z
(1880 r.); 10, 12 - C. .A1<cIOTIIHUhI, H}'pr. CTap-
man MorllJia; 13 - c. AHCIOTUHI\bI. Hypr 2; 14,
15 - C. By;J.HU. U3 RypraooB; 16, 19 - c. BO.;tHOB-
IU>I, H}pr. 478; 17, 111- C. BOJlKOBI\bI, Hypr. 9;
1, 3. 5-19 - KOCTb; 2 -lUUoIeHh; 4 - (jpOB3a
lc1
\.
1
o
@
o
19
'5
92
OTMe'laJlaCl, pH OM HCC.1Ie1l;OD8TeJIeii: 26.
IfHTepeCHO, 'lTO :'ITa oc06eHHOCTb, HMelO-
lI\aH 1I;1IfI CHII<pClwro HCHYCCTBa 06lI{1IR
xapaHTep, IIpOfIBJlHeTCH JIOH8JIbHO. Pe3-
HafI HOCTb HeJIepMeCCIOIX, ma60THH-
CIOIX, nOCYJIbClillX, HHmnep;OHCIOIX H
RpblMCIOIX IIaMKTnlIROB VII-VI BB. 11;0
n. 3. ne TOJIbHO OplIrnnaJlbna, no H CBoe-
06p83na B Ram;n;OM CJIy'lae. If na060pOT,
06IIJ;eclOI4>cHlIe 06pa3hI 3BepHnoro CTH-
JIH 60JIee YCTOii:'lIIBhI B MeTaJlJIe. OTCYT-
CTBHe B ap anqeCROM SBepnnOM CTRJIe
IIocYJIbfI HeHOTOpLLX RJIaCCK'lecIOIX 06-
paSOB 'laCTH'lHO MomeT 6blTb CBfIsaHO
C Hepa3DHTOCTblO 3J);eCb rrpoH3DoACTD8
30JIOTbIX TIICHeHblX nJIaCTIIH. OIIpe1l;e-
JleHHOe 3Ha'leHIIe Mor HMeTb H XpOHO-
JIOrn'leCHlIll }fOMeHT. IIpe1l;cTaBJIfIeTcfI,
'lTO 60JIee paHHee (c ROHIJ;a VII B. 11;0
n. :I.) IIORB:IeHlIe Ha IIpaB06epembe
300Mop4>noH xy;n;omecTBeHHoR Tpa;n;H-
HH 06YCJlOBlIJlO S1I;eCb 60JlbDIee npen-
CTaBHTeJlbCTBO MOTHBOB H 4>OPM, THIIH'l-
HbIX AJIH CJm4>cRoro 3BepBHoro CTHJlfI
B elIOM. Tal{lIx, HaIIpHMep, RaR HSO-
6pameHIIe ROma'lberO XHII\HHRa B 060HX
II03ax, OJleml B «JleTfIIII;eM raJlOIIe»,
';:1IIIJ;Boii IITn[{f.I, Ra6ana, a TaRme yma-
CThIX rOJlOllOI;: 6apanoD H rpH<p0-6a-
paHOD.
HaMCTIIBmneCfl 'lepnJ JIORaJlbHorO
cBoe06paSIIH B SDepHHOM CTHJle II01l;He-
npOBbfI IIO;YY'laIOT nOBoe pas BlITHe B
V D. no II. :I. 3TO 6hIJl IIepHO;n; CYlI\eCT-
neHHhIX nS I('ncHllif B Clill4>CROM JICRYC-
CTBe: SII8'lllT<':-!LHO BospaCTaeT B;IIIHHIIe
rpe'lenmro nn,YCCTB8, 'lTO, no MHerrlllO
ueHOTopMX JlCC:rJC,!I;OBaTe:IeR, npllBOnlIT
I{ IIOHD:H'nHlfl nOBoro CI,mpO-rpe'leCRorO
:X:Y1I;0H\eCTBC'IIIIOrO CTII.1IfI 21; lIC'leSaIOT
MHome Tpa.'1l11lUOIIIIhIe apXaK'leCRlle 06-
P8ShI; na C\fI"ny IIM IIpHXO]U1T MOTHBbl,
IIpeH\Ae Dcero CBRJaHHble C TeHAen lIeR
pacnaAa I1".lhD. OpraHH'leCKH,,{ <pOpM
SBeplIHoro TC'.la na OT;n;eJlbHbIe caMOCTO-
KTeJIbHbIC 'l:Inn, nOABepralOIqlleCH sa-
TeM nepepar'OTHC B JJYxe opnaMeHTaJIIIS-
Ma; pacnBC'T:ll'T 1I;OnOJIHIITelIbHaH 300-
Mop<pn8R opnaMeBTau,HfI KaK 01l;BO K3
OCIIOBHblX xY1I;0H\eCTBCHHhIX Cpe1l;CTB CO-
3;n;8HHfI 06pa38.
Bo BTOpOR nOJIOBHHe V B. 11;0 H. 8.
npOHCX01l;IIT o<popltlJleHHe JIOKaJIbIIhIX
BapHaHTOB na Bceii: TeppHToplllI pac-
npOCTpaHeHHfI clOI4>cKoro 3BepnHoro
CTlIJlfI. B JIeCOCTeIIHOR CKB4>lIlI CKJla-
1I;hIBalOTCfI ABa cBoeo6pasHhIX Y1I;0H\e-
CTBeHHbIX l\eHTpa: IIpaB06epemnbIR II
JIeB06epemHbIii. 06a OIIepHpYIOT np8K-
TH'leCIOI O;n;HHMH MOTIIBaMII, HO B Ram-
;n;OM OpHrHHaJIbHO onpe;n;eJIKIOTCfI CIO-
meTHoe H KOMIIOSHIJ;HOHnOe pemeHHe,
xapaRTepHbIe npneMbl CTHJIH3anIIH. Pac-
CMOTpHM naH60JIee BhIpaSHTeJIbHble
llpBMepbI.
MOTHB xnntflOii: IITHIJ;bI npII06peTaeT
601IbmylO nonymrpnocTb. B II paB06e-
pembe OH npe1l;cTaBJIen IIso6p8mennHMII
MnOrO'lHCJIeHHblX OT;n;eJIbnblX ro.'IOBOK,
eJIoii <PHrypbl opJIa, napRl ero IIJlH
RJIIOIOIIJ;ero pbl6y 28. OcnOBHafI 'laCTb
IIs06pamenpii: BblllOlInena na SOJlOTbiX
mTaMnOBaIIHbIX H 'leKaHIIhIX II.1IaCTII-
Hax. Oc06eHHo opHrlIHaJlbHhI H Bhlpa-
SHTeJIbHhI KOHTypHhIe OpJIHHhIe rOJIOBKH
HS RypraHa OCTpaH MorHJI8 Y c. flGJIo-
HOBKa H H3BeCTHaH cepHH nnaCTHnOR
H3 KypranoB 4 II 5 y c. BepeCTllfIrH
(pIIC. 2, 1-2). Ha nOCJleABIIX B 06bl'l-
nylO cxeMY I'OJlOBbi CKH4>CROro opJIa
fr,
Q) I." ItC
\.. , .-"0
.
\iVi
,'\, - c
.' o....:...
. .'
E
.'\ :.
... '-'
7
"J
PJ.0
'1
PUC. 2. naMRTH.UICU 3BepUH.Oao CTUAS/ CpeiJ-
H.eao noiJH.eflpOBbR V B. iJo H.. 3.
1 - c. H6nosoBHa, Hypr. I; 11- I<aseBcHlln yeaJl..
cn)""altsaJI saXOJl.Ha; 8 - c. H\ypoBKa, Hype. B;
4 - r. rpnweHIthI. rp)'BTOBblR PJI0rHnbHItH. no-
rpel!. 7; :; - C. T)"PbJI, H)"pr. 459; 6 - CMena,
Hype. 522; 7 - c. MaHeeBHa, lIypr. 491; 8 - c. my-
poBKa, Hypr. 398; 9 - POMeBcHHIt yeaJl.. 113 HYP-
rBHOB; 10 - c. AYClOTnHlUoI, YPo""lI!e CTanHHB
BellX, Rypr. 2; 11;}3 - C. AHCIOTHHIlbi. YPO"HlI!e
CTaAKHB Bepx, r. 12; 12 - C. AKC, IOTIIHI1b1
Hype. 2 (1883-1885 rr.); 14 - POMeHcKHn ye3J1.,
sa HypranoB; 1:; - C" EaCOBlla, lIypr. 499; 16-
c. BonllOBlUoI, Hypr. 2 (1897 r.); 11 - C AKeIO-
THHIUoI, YPO"iHlI!e CTailHJIH Bepx, Hypr. . 18-
c. BOJIROBIUoI, lIypr. (,; 19 - C" I<PJI'lROBK3. ""pr.;
1,2 - BOJIOTO; 8-19 - 6POH33
"...'::C'
J ' ':' :I
... '--'-:..-.
.:"..1'" ":..:.t:
",,., . j
C' .... - ,
:- .:l
,' ::.!.
.
16
94
2
I
.
9 .-
n
O. ."\;
TO
o
C\
'3
:.a-
... t
"'(':
t" <
. '
:,01 "','
...-
,
\
17
3
fCP
6
B
14
. .
15
19
BnllcaHO erqe 1I306pameHIle JJ;eJIOR <p1I-
rypbl BO]J,OnJIaBalOrqeR nTIID;bI, XapaK-
TepHOR ]J,JUI raJIl.mTaTCKoro IICKYC-
DTBa 29. HlIr]J,e 60JIee 3TOT ClOmeT He
BCTpe'leH B TaKon KOMn031ID;1I1I. Ha]J,o
npe]J,nOJIaraTl. MeCTHoe npOII3BO]J,CTBO
3TIIX nJIaCTIIHOK, XOTJI P;JIJI pJI]J,a p;pyrnx
H:306pameHHR OpJIIIHbIX rOJIOBOK BnOJIHe
BepOJITHO OJIl.BIIHCKoe rrpolIcxom]J,e-
HlIe 30.
IlllIpoKO pacnpOCTpaHeHHblM XY]J,O-
meCTBeHHbIM nplIeMOM JIBJIJIeTCJI ]J,eKO-
:>aTIIBHo-opHaMeHTaJIl.HOe o<popMJIeHlIe
aaTbiJIKa II mell rOJIOBKII py6'IHKOM,
naJIl.MeTKOR, BOJIlOTaMII II 3aBIITKaMII,
KOTopble '1aCTO TpaKTYlOTCJI KaK BTO-
pOll, nepneH,ltlIKYJIJIpHbIll K OCHOBHOMY
KJIlOB (pIIC. 2, 3). BOJIl.IIIHHCTBO 1I306-
pameHIIR XlIrqHOR nTHD;bI 1I3 IIpaB06e-
peml.JI IIMelOT npJIMbie aHaJIOr1I1I B IIplI-
Ky6aHl.e II CTenJIOR CKII<p 1I1I 3'.
3Ha'llITeJIl.HO CKpOMHee II 0p;Ho06pa3-
Hee npe]J,CTaBJIeH JTOT MOTIIB B JIeBo-
6epeml.e. Mbi BII]J,IIM TOJIl.KO rOJIOBKII
XlIrqHOH nTIIJJ;bI, npelIMym;ecTBeHHO
YKpamalOm;ne 6pOH30Bble 6JIHllIKII. Ha-
JIIID;O MeCTHbill TlIn ymacToR rOJIOBKII,
pemeHHbIH npOCTO II JIaKOHlI'IHO (pIIC.
2, 9) 3%. Bce 1I306pameHlIJI TaK 6JIII3KII
APyr APyry, '1TO 3aCTaBJIJIlOT npep;nOJIa-
raTl. OP;Hy MaCTepCKYlO. IIpJIMOll aHa-
JIorlIlI B ]J,pyrnx panoHax CKII<p1I1I IIM
HeT. XapaKTepHo OTCYTCTBlIe nbImHOR
):\ono;lHIITeJIl.HOH opHaMeHTaD;lIlI.
TaK me OT'IeTJIIIBO pa3JIII'IIIH ]J,BYX
palloHoB IIop;HenpoBbH npOJIBJIHlOTCH Ha
npm.lepe 1I306pameHIIJI rOJIOB rplI<po-
HOB. l1.JIJI npaB06epemHbIX KOMnJIeKCOB
06bl'leH 1I3BeCTHbiR BaplIaHT nepepa60T-
KII rOJIOBbI rpeKO-BOCTO'lHOrO rplI<poHa
(pIIC. 2, 4), IIMelOm;nn npJIMbIe aHaJIO-
rIIII B CTenHOll CKII<p 1I1I 33.
Ha '1eTbIpeX 6pOH30BbIX HaHOCHIIKax-
rrpOTOMax 1I3 IIOCYJIbJI MbI BII]J,IIM p;py-
rOll BaplIaHT nepepa60TKII Toro me
IICXop;HOro 06pa3a: B pacKpbIToM KJIlOBe
rplI<pOHa JI3b1K p;aH He nO]J,HJITbiM BBepx,
a CBepHyTblM B KJIy60K. 06m;nR xapaK-
Tep CTIIJIII3aD;IIII npIIBeJI K 3aMeHe pea-
JIIICTII'IeCKIIX <PO pM npOTOTHna 0606-
rqeHHo-opHaMeHTaJIbHbIMII. XapaKTep-
Hbi KpyrJIbie 60JIbmIIe rJIa3a, p;JIlIIOIbIe
TOp'lam;ne YlIII1, rpe6eHb B BIIp;e npOCTO-
1'0 Py6'1IIKa. IIoTepJIB MorqHblH 3y6a-
CTblR KJIlOB, rpII<poH npeBpaTHJICJI B Ka-
Koe-TO MlIpHoe, ]J,ame maJIKOe cyrqecT-
BO (pIIC. 2, 10) 3'. AHaJIOI'II'IHbIR HaHOC-
HIIK 1I3 KypraHa 383 y c. fpymeBKa os
CKopee Bcero HBJIHeTCJI IIMnopTOM 1I3
IIocYJIbJI. B p;pyrnx paii:oHax CKII<pKH
OHII He 1I3BeCTllbi. BepOJITHO, B IIOCYJIl.e
6bIJI D;eHTp npOll3BO]J,CTBa HaHoCHIIKOB
3TOro BII]J,a B nepBOll rrOJIOBIIHe V B.
P;O H. 3. l1.JIH BTOpoii: nOJIOBIIHbI CTOJIe
TIIJI 1I3BeCTHbi HOBbie BaplIaHTbI MeCT-
HOR nepepa60Tlm II nepeOCMbICJIeHIIJI
3Toro me ClOmeTa (pIIC. 2, 12) 38.
COBepmeHlIO oplIrlIHaJIbHO BblrJIJIp;JIT
nonblTKII JIeB06epemHblX MaCTepOB C03-
]J,aTl. <paHTaCTII'IeCIme 06pa3b1 Ha OCHO-
Be 06b1'1HbIX II306pameHlIR peaJIl.HbIX
mlIBOTHbiX (JIOCH, XlIIl m!Ka) nYTeM
«YCIIJIeHIIJI" IIX py6'1aTbiM rpe6HeM, xa-
paKTepHblM ):\JIH OTMe'leHHbIX BbIIIIe 1'0-
JIOBOK rplI<pOHOB (pIIC. 2, 11) 37.
TaK me tJeTKO pa3JIII'IalOTCJI 1I306pa-
meHIIH rOJIOBbi JIOCH. B npaB06epeml.e
3TOT MOTIIB npep;CTaBJIeH 3Ha'IHTeJIl.HO
JIp'le, xYJIOmcr.TBCHHO pa3Ho06pa3Hee.
IbBecTHo HeCKOJIbKO THnOB 1I306pame-
HIIR: MaCCIIBHaH 6e3pOraJI roJIOBa B reo-
MeTp1I31IpOBa11H0ii: cxeMe 38, Te me 6e3-
porne, HO 60.'Iee 1I3mn;Hble II ffilIBbIe 1'0-
.'IOBKII B napnoii KOMn031ID;1I1I 39 II, HaKO-
Hen;, HalI60.'!ee pacnpOCTpaHeHHbIn TIII!
]J,OBOJIbHO ):\elwpaTIIBHOR rOJIOBKII C ]J,BY-
MH CllMMeTpI1'IHbIMII BeTBJIMII porOB,
OKaHtJIIBalOlI\I1XCH OpJIIIHblMII rOJIOBKa-
MII II naJIb [eTKOn MemAY HIIMII (pIIC.
2, 5). Bce 11::r6pameHIIJI 1I0CJIe]J,Hero
TlIna '0 yKpami\jH 60JIbmlIe 6poH30Bble
6JIHXII, cTll.ln ntJecKII 6JIII3KIIe ):\pyr
):\pyry, OTpa;J;;norqIIe O]J,IIH IIOP;XO]J, K lIe-
pe):\atJe 06pa;w. AHaJIOrnlI IIM xopomo
u C ,f-. ..
npe):\cTaB:lf'IIj,I B CTelIHOII KII'J!IIII.
B IIeCKO.'Ibl;O ynporqeHHOM BII):\e TaKaJI
6JIJIxa BCTpe'leHa B KypraHe 2 y C. BOp3-
Ha Ha l1.ecHe ". 8TO e):\IIHCTBeHHaH Ha-
XO):\Ka B JIeB06epembe - BepoHTHbiR pe-
3YJIbTaT BJIIIHHIIH npaB06epemHoro xy-
]J,omeCTBeHHoro n;eHTpa.
B IIooYJIbe B JTO me BpeMJI CJI01K1lJI-
CJI CBOR TII.II JIOCIIHOR 6e3 POroR roJIOBKII,
OTJIII'IalOrqeRcH MeHbmlIMII pa3MepaMII,
60JIbilllIM JIaKOHlI3MO ! II YCJIOBHOCTblO
B lIepep;a'le xapaKTepHbIx 'IepT (pIIC.
2, 13). IIOJIHOCTblO OTCYTcTByeT 3JIe-
MeHT p;eKopaTIIBHoCTn. IICIIOJIb30BaHlIJI
opHaMeHTaJIbHblX MOTnBOB rpe'leCKoro
ffcKyccTBa. BY]J,Y'l1I 3;:\eCL npep;CTaBJIeH
TOJIbKO B P;BYX KOMIIJIeKCaX ", 3TOT TIIII
]J,aeT IIpJIMYlO aHaJIomlO Ha Cpe,ItIIev
l1.oHy u.
M306pameHIIH rO.'IOBbI Ka6aHa p;o-
BOJIbHO pe]J,KII B IIoAlIenpoBbe V B. ]J,O
H. 3. IJ.eJIbie <plIrypbI Bo06rqe OTCYTCT-
BYlOT. B IIpaB06epembe K JTOMY ClOme-
TY MomHO npep;nOJIOmIITeJIbHO OTHeCTII
TOJIbKO OP;HY 6JIHillKY II3 KypraHa 446
y c. IIacTblpcKoro ". 113 KypraHoB Po-
MeHCKoro ye3):\a IIpOIICXO]J,JIT meCTl.
6pOH30BblX 6JIHilleK B BII):\e rOJIOBOK Ka-
6aHa, OTMe'leHHbIX BbICOKIIMII XY]J,O-
meCTBeHHbIMII CBORCTBa 1II II HeCKOJIl.KO
a pXalI3IIpOBa HHOR Ma!lepOR IICnOJIHe-
HIIJI (Ta6JI. 2, 14). TaK me KaK II MeCT-
HbIn TIIII rOJIOBOK JIOCH, IIX OTJIII'IalOT
1I3BeCTHbIR JIaKOHII3M II 0606rqeHHocTl.
<PO PM, OTCYTCTBlle ):\eKopaTIIBHOR pa3pa-
60TKII p;eTaJIen, nO):\'IepKHYTaH amyp-
HOCTb - nplI3HaK, xapaKTepHblR P;JIJI
MHorlIX 6pOH30BhIX npe):\MeTOB 3BeplI-
Horo CTIIJIH B ITOCy.'IhP ".
Bce 1I3BeCT!lbIe aHa;romli 1I3 HlIM-
<peRCKIIX II ceMII6paTIIHX KypraHoB IIplI
06rqeM CXO):\CTBe CaMOIT cxeMbI 1I306pa-
meHIIH cyrqecTBeHHo OT.'III'IalOTCH Ma-
Hepon IICnOJIHeHIlH, CO'IPTalOrqen '1aCTO
peaJIIICTll'leCKYlO nepe.laqy 0AHlIX ):\eTa-
JIeI! (r.la3, yxo, Ch.'Ia.ll>II BepXHeR ry6b1
lIa):\ K.1bIKOM) r OpB,,"e!lTa.'IbHo-):\eKO-
paTIIB!lOn TpaKTOBlwn lpymx (mepCTb
Ha mee II 3arpIIBKP)" HMeHHO TaKaJI
CTII.TIII3an;IIH TIInII'I!I .l:IH npOII3Bep;e-
96
4 Cl-al$o-cH6I1PCI{l1lJ 3BI'rHH!.>lfi CTn Tb
HIIR CKII<pCKoro 3BeplIHoro CTIIJIJI, OTMe-
'1eHHblX CIIJIbHblM BJIIIJIHlIeM rpe'leCKO-
1'0 IICKYCCTBa II '1aCTO BbllIOJIHeHHblX
B aHTII'IHbIX MaCTepCKIIX. MMeHHO ara
rpYlIlIa 1I306pameHIIR MomeT 6bITl. Ha-
3BaHa xapaKTepHOR P;JIJI CKII<po-rpe'le-
CKoro Te'leHIIJI B IICKYCCTBe CKII<p1I1I
V-IV BB. ]J,O H. 3.
BblHBJIeHHbIe pa3JIII'IIIJI He 1I03BOJIH-
lOT HaM BCJIe]J, 3a B. A. MJIblIHCKOR C'IH-
TaTb pOMeHCKlIe rOJIOBKII IIMIIOpTOM 1I3
aHTII'IHblX JJ;eHTpOB BoclIopa '8. Ha060-
pOT, OHII IIpe]J,CTaBJIJIlOTCH TIIIIII'IHblMII
P;JIJI MeCTHoro xY]J,omeCTBeHHoro JJ;eHT-
pa. 8TII me ]J,Ba 1I0p;xo]J,a K xapaKTepy
CTIIJIII3aD;1I1I 06pa3a 3aMeTHbi II IIplI
cpaBHeHlI1I 1I306pameHIIH rOJIOB Koma-
Ql.erO xIIrqHIIKa 1I3 060lIx paROHoB IIo]J,-
tlelIpOBl.JI. IlllIpoKo 1I3BeCTHbI 6pOH30-
Bble OJIHXII B BIIp;e rOJIOB JIl.BOB II JIbBIID;,
1I306pameHHbIX B IIP0<pIIJIl. II <pac, II3
KYpraHOB 400, 401 Y c. mYPOBKII, 491
Y c. MaKeeBKa II 4 Y c. BepeCTHJIrlI '9.
STO TIIIIII'IHbIe 06pa3JJ;bI cKII<po-rpe'lec-
Koro Te'leHIIJI B 3BeplIHOM CTIIJIe V B.
P;O H. 3. qacTl. 1I3 HIIX, B03MomHO, II3rO-
TOBJIeHa B OJIl.BlI1I 50.
RaK He pa3 OTMe'laJIOCb ]J,JUI IIpe):\Me-
TOB 1I3 IIpaB06epeml.JI, aHaJIOrnli nM
Haxo]J,JITCJI B cTelIHoR CKII<p1I1I 5.. 3]J,eCb
me YIIOTpe6JIJIJIlICl. II TpeXMepHbIe
CKYJIl.IlTypHbIe rOJIOBKII JIl.BOB (pIlC.
2, 6) 52.
HeCOMHeHHO, '1TO 1I0p;06HbIe BbICOKO-
xyp;omecTBeHHbIe 1I3]J,eJIIIJI OKa3bIBanII
B03]J,eRCTBlIe II Ha MaCTepCKlIe JIeBo6e-
pembH. O]J,HaKO MeCTHaH xyp;omecTBPH-
HaH mKOJIa rrO]J,BepraJIa JTII 06pa3bI
cyrqecTBeHHOR lIepepa60TKe. BpolI:w-
Bble 6JIHmKII 1I3 KypraHoB 499 y C. b,1-
C<!-6Ka, 505 y c. BpoaapKII II 1 (1886 r.)
Y c. AKClOTIIHJJ;bI (pIIC. 2, 15) 53 nOKa-
3b1BalOT, KaK B pe3YJIbTaTe 60JIee JIaKO-
HII'IHOll II YCJIOBHOR TpaKTOBKII JleTa-
JIeR (H03p;plI, yxa, rJIa3a) YTpa'lIIBlleTCH
He TOJIbKO peaJIlICTlI'IeCKaH BbIpa3IITe.lb-
HOCTb, HO II BII]J,OBaH OlIpe]J,eJIeHHOCTb
3BeplIHoro oopaaa. B JTIIX II306pame-
97
HIIJiX MOmHO BIIp;eTb op;HOBpeMeHHO
3BepJi II ROrna'lbeii, II BOJI'Ibeii, II Mep;-
Bembeii rrOpOp;bI.
BoraTCTBO II pa3Ho06pa3lIe CIOmeT-
HbIX II CTIIJIlICTII'IeO.KIIX perneHIIll: rrpa-
B06epeIKHblX MaCTepCKIIX p;eMOHCTplI-
pyeT I\eJIbIH pJiP; rrpe-AMeTOB 3BeplIHoro
CTIIJIJi, IIpaKTlI'IeCKII OTCYTCTBYIOII\IIX B
JIeB06epembe. 8TO CeplIJi 3HaMeHlITblX
HaJI06HbIx qmrypHbIx 6J1Hx 1I3 .Kypra-
HOB Y C. lliypoBKII II MaKeeBKlI C 1130-
6pameHIIeM JIbBIII\ IIJIII rraHTep, rpyrrna
6pOH30BbIX Ham;e'lHIIKOB B .popMe 3Be-
plIHOro yxa, OTp;eJIbHbIe 6JIJiXil B BIlge
Horn IIJIlI KorrbITa OJIeHJi (JIOCJi), a TaK-
me K{)l'Teii XHII\Hoii rrTIII\bI". BOJIb-
IIIlIHCTBO 1I3 HIIX HMeeT rrpJiMbIe aHaJIO-
rlIlI B cTerrHoii: CRII.p1I1I II TIplIKy6a-
Hbe 55. JIeB06epemHbIe MaCTepa, Ha060-
pOT, HeKOTopbIe 06II\eCKII.pCKlIe MOTH-
BbI V B. rrepe aBaJIII TaR opIIrlIHaJILHO
II 1I306peTaTeJIbHO, '1TO OHII BblrJIJi)];RT
KaK caMOCTOHTeJIhHbIe. TaK, ClOmeT
3ap;Heii: '1aCTII TYJIOBlIlI\a JIbBa C P;BYMII
HoraMII B mare TpaliTyeTCJi CTporo
rrpo.pIIJIbHO, B KOMilaKTHOll: cxeMe II
rrpeBpalI\aeTCJi B IITore B IIJ06pameHrre
OP;HOll: KOHe'lHOCTII (pIIC. 2,16) 56. 1:130-
6pameHlIe CTOJilI\ero XlIlI\HIIKa B .pac,
KOTopoe B TIpaB06epembe rrepep;aeTCJi
cRYJIbrrTYpBo, Haxop;IIT B TIocy.'lLe co-
BepmeHHO cBoe06pa3Hoe, BO MHorOM
rpa.pII'IeCKOe pemeHlIe (pIIC. 2, 7, 17).
OrrYlI\errHaJi rOJIOBa 3BepII B 3TOll cxe-
Me KaK 6bl IIpoeIJ.lIpyeTCJi IIa IIepep;nlle
JIarrbl, CIDIBaJiCb C IIX IWIITypOM. Kol'-
TIICTaJi .Tlarra XlIrr HOll IITIII\bl Ha EOI1-
I\ax 6pOH30BblX rrCaJIrreB 1I3 j,ypra-
HOB 484 Y c. TI.rraBIIHlIlI\lI 57 II 4 v
C. BOJIKOBI\bl (pliC. 2,18) IIcno:I1ICn:1
B Kam OM cJIY'Iae cOBepmeHHo I1H,1I1-
31I yaJIbHO, IIOKa3bIBaJi BbICOKYIO X '-
[J;omecTBeHHYIO KyJIbTYPY IIX C03)];aTe-
lell. lfMeHIIo B 6poH3e IIOCYJIbCKlle f;l-
Tepa V B. o H. 3. p;OCTlIr.'11I Hau6o.ll.-
IIIIIX TBOp'leCKIIX p;OCTlImeHIIU. Ka" n
}BOIO O'lepep;b IIX rrpep;meCTBeHBIIKn -
B pe3b6e rro IOOCTII. H3BeCTHYIO pO.l!> B
nOM MOrJIJI IIrpaTb CBJi31I C 6ocrrop-
CKIIMII I\eHTpaMIl rrpOII3Bop;CTBa rrpep;-
MeTOB 3Bep:nHoro CTIIJIJi, oAHaKo HeT
cepbe3HbIX OCHoBaHnii: C'IIITaTb Bce BbI-
l;OKoxyp;omecTBeHHbIe 6pOH3bI ROHCRO-
1'0 y60pa 1I3 .KypraHoB TIOCYJIhH 1I3rO-
TOBJIeHHbIMII Ha Bocrrope 58.
tlaKOHeI\, neJIh3Ji He OCTaHOBIITbCJi
Ha rpyrrile cBoe06pa3HbIX 6pOH30BbIX
6JIRmeK B BIIp;e KIICTII PYKII '1eJIOBeRa.
8TOT aHTpOilOMOp.pHbIii: MOTIIB iKlIBeT B
nO HerrpOBbe OrpaHH'IeHHOe BpeMR
(cepep;IIHa V B.) II rrpe CTaBJIeH paB-
HOMepHO B 060lIX paii:oHax 59.
O HaKO, eCJIII B JIeB06epembe 3TO
p;ell:CTBIITeJIbHO KlICTb PYRII C BbIp;eJIeH-
HblM 60JIbmlIM IIaJlbI\eM, TO B TIpaB06e-
pembe - cKopee JIarra 3BepJi (pIIC. 2,
8,19).
lfTaK, B V B. o H. 3. TIpaB06epem-
Hoe II JIeB06epemHoe JIeOOCTerrHoe
TIpep;HerrpOBbe IIpep;cTalOT KaK p;Ba
cBoe06pa3IIbIX B xyp;omecTBeHHoM OT-
HomeHHII paii:oHa C caMOCTOKTeJIbHbl-
Mll xyp;om!!CTBeHHbIMII n;eHTpaMII, orre-
PIIPYIOII\IIMII B rrplIHII;lIrre OP;HIIMII II Te-
MII me 06II\eCKII.pCKIIMII MOTIIBaMlI, HO
B KamAoM cJIY'lae cBoe06pa3Ho oIlpe-
p;e.'1JiIOII\IIMII KOHKpeTHbIii: ClOmeT II Ma-
IIepy IICrrOJIHeHIIK. 3BeplIHbIii: CTIIJIb JIe-
cocTeilHoro TIpaB06epemLJi O'leHb 6JI11-
30K 'IIO TpaKTOBKe 60JIbIIIHHCTBa 06-
pa30B IICKyecTBY CTeilHoro ITplI'Iep-
HOMOpbK II TIplIKy6aHbJi II CBK3aH C rro-
c.'1ep;H!IM 061I\eu TeHp;elII\lIeii: pa3BIITIIJi,
npIlBO)];JilI\ell: K IIOIIBJIeHHIO B V B. p;o
II. ;). 1I0Boro CI\II.po-rpe'lecKoro Te'leHIIJi
B CKII.pCKOM 3BepliHOM CTIIJIe. l'ICKYCCT-
RO JIeB06epembJi OTJIII'IaeTCJi 60JIbilleii:
xyp;omecTBeHHoII 3f\MKIlYTOCTblO II ca-
M06bITHOCTblO, XOTII eMY Tome He qym-
)];0 BJIIIJiHlIe rp '1eCKOrO IICKYCCTBa. By-
)];Y'lrr 60JIee orlalIlIqeHHblM B ClOmeT-
HOM peilepTyajffi, B IIplIMeHeH1I1I HOBbIX
CTII.'1IICTII'IeCKlIX rrplIeMOB IT cpe CTB,
:JBepIIHbIii: CTII.Th 3Toro paifoHa aeT
plI rJIy60Ko cBoe06pa3HbIx 06pa30B,
oTpamalOIII;Hx MecTHYIO, neCKOJIhKO ap-
Xa1I3IIpOBalIHYIO JIITIDUO BOCrrplIJITIIH
300MOp.pHbIX .pOpM.
TIo-rrpemHeMY Ha6mop;aeTcH pa3JIlI-
'IIII' B BbI60pe KaTeroplIii: yKpamaeMbix
rrpep;MeTOB. B JIeB06epembe 3Bep1IHhIll:
CTIIJIb '1alI\e IIplIMeHJieTCJi Ha 6pOH30BblX
HaBepilllIJiX, CKlIrreTpax, rrCaJIIIJiX II
6paCJIeTax. B TIpaB06epembe - Ha 30-
JIOTblX 6JIJiillKaX OT I'OJIOBHbIX YOOPOB,
O,'lemiJ;bI, p;epeBJiHHbIX COCY OB, a TaK-
me Ha 6pOH30BblX 6J1HillKaX, yKpaillaB-
illIIX napap;HbIll: IIOJiC, HalI\e'lHIIKaX II
Ha:I06HIIKax. OAHaKO, B OTJIlI'IlIe OT
VI B. p;o H. 3. cBoe06pa3HbIe '1epTbI
MeCTHoro 3BeplIRoro CTIIJIJi MeHbme
CBII3aHbI C TIIIIlI'IHbIMII JIJi p;aHRoro
paiioHa KaTeroplIIlMH rrpe)1.MeTOB.
B V B. O H. 3. rrOJiBJIJiIOTCJi rraMJiT-
Hm>II 3BeplIHoro CTIIJIK B CpeJJ,ReM IIo-
)];OBbe, CJIep;YJi 3a pacrrpOCTpaHeRHeM
3 eCb 06bI'IHOrO P;JIH JIecocTerrlI KYP-
raHHoro 06pJip;a IIorpe6eHlIH C HpKO BbI-
pameHHbIM BoeRRo-p;PYiKlIHHbIM xapaK-
TepOM. KOJIlI'IeCTBO 1I306pameHIIll: 3TOro
BpeMeHII He BeJIIIK 0, OHH rrpoIICXO T
Bcpro 1I3 '1eTbIpeX-IIHTII KOMrrJIeKCOB.
OAlI(mo B3JiTbIe BMecTe, OHII BeCbMa
nOEa3aTeJIbHbI e IIHcTBOM CTIIJIlICTII'Ie-
CKIIX .pOpM II 06pa30B C rraMKTHHKaMII
JIec.OCTerrHoro TIOJJ,RerrpOBbJi, oc06eHHo
JIeB06epemLJi (pIIC. 3.) KaR BII O 1I3
cpaBHlITeJIbROll: Ta6IDII\bI, HeROTopbIe
cpeJ,IIep;OHCRlIe 1I306pameHIIJi ycryrra-
TOT CBOliM IIplIAHerrpOBCKlIM aHaJIOraM
B TOqHOCTII IIepep;a'llI ClOmeTa, '1TO MO-
iKeT IIBJIIITbCII pe3YJlbTaTOM MHorOKpaT-
norn !>OIlIIpOBaHIIK 60.
n O).IllMO 3aIIa HOClUI.pCKIIX .pOpMO-
OOP;l;YIOII\lIX CBJi3ell: B IICKYCCTBe Cpep;-
Iwro AOHa V B. O H. 9. He 3aMeTHO
B.1IIHImII CO CTOpOHbI pyrlIX coce -
1111 \ Ey.'1bTYP II CTIIJIeii:. OqeBII HO, '1TO
:JH!'["JllIIbIi'r CTIIJIb 3Toro paii:oHa JIeCO-
nl'rIHOII CKII.p1I1I He IIMeeT JIOKaJIbHO-
I'll nwe06pa3lIJi, eCJIII 3a TaKOBoe He
11I"11I1I !aTb COqeTaHlIe R HeM .pOPM,
"iI(li1 KTepHblX ;IJIJi 060lIX xy omecTBeH-
11101\ IJ,eHTpOB TIoAHeIIpOBbJi. B YCJIO-
98
BIIJiX aKTIIBHoro .pYHKI\IIOHlIpOBaHITH
repO OTOBCKoro ToprOBoro rrYTII 3TO
BilOJIHe eCTeCTBeHHO 6\.
TIOJIOmeHITe MeHJieTCJi B IV B. o
H. 3. Ha Cpe eM ,l],oIlY O'leHb 6bICTpO
CKJIap;bIBaeTCH oplIrlIHaJIbHOe, HeCOM
HeHHO MeCTHoe IICKYCCTBO, Torp;a RaK
B CpeP;HeM llop,neIIpOBbe IIpOIICXO IIT
ynap;OK c06CTBeHHoro xy;wmecTBeHHoro
TBOp'leCTBa. OrpOMH)'1O pOJIb B nOM
IIrpaeT MOIJ:{Hoe HIIBe:mpYIDlI\ee B03Aeii-
CTBlIe IICKyccTBa cTenHoii: CKII.p1I1I II
Bocrropa. B TIo HeilpOBbe IICqe3aeT CTa-
paJi Tpap;IIII,HJi II306pameHIIJi KOlIIa'lb-
ero IIJIII BOJI'IberO XrrlI\HIma, Ka6aHa II
JIOCH. focrrop;cTByeT II306pameRlIe
JIbBa, rplI.pOHa II OJIeBfl B OroIHO'lHbIX
ROMII031II\IIJiX J1.1I1I B cIJ,eHax Tep3aHIIK,
rrepe)J;aBaeMblx B '1IICTO rpe'leCKoii: IIJIII
rpeKO-CKlI.pCKoii: MaHepe. 8m ClOmeTLI
rrpeIIMym,eCTBeIIHO YKpalllaIOT aOJIOThIa
rrJIaCTHH.K1I OT rrapa Hoii: oAemJI;b!, OC-
rrex, rrOrpe6a.JIbHbIX 110KpblBaJI, epe-
BHHHbIX COCY OB, FOTOpb!e CTaHOBKTCK
OCHOBHOii: KaTeroplIeii: )];eKOplIpyeMbIx
rrpep;MeTOB. TIOJiBJIIIIOTCII aHTporro-
Mop.pHbIe 1I306pameHIIII, cpeM ROTO-
pbIX BbIp;eJIJieTCJi cBoe06pa3HaJi ceplIK
rrOCYJIbCKlIX 30JIOThIX 6JIJimeR B BIIAe
meHCKIiX rOJIOBOK C IIbImHOll: rrplI'lec-
KOii: 82. lfx MeCTHoe IIpOII3BO CTBO BIIOJl-
He BepOJiTHO, oco6eHHO B CBeTe Haxo-
.n;OK '1aCTeii: lllTaMIIOB Ha BeJIbCKOM
II KaMeHCKOM ropo)J.I1Inax .3. Ha MeCTe
1I3rOTaB:l1IBaJIaCb II KaKalI-TO 'laCTb 30-
JIOTbIX 6JIJillleK CO 3BepnHI,I m ClOmeTa-
MII, B rrepBYIO OqCpe;Ib OBIe'ieHHbIX 1I3-
BeCTHbIM yrrpOlI\eHlle).! KJIf\CCH'leCKlIX
.pOpM II IIplIMI1'l'IIBlI3anI1eii 06pa30B .'.
B KOHCKOll c6pye parnpOCTpaHJiIOTCJi
6pOH30Bb!e 6.'1Jilll!m B HII.1C «Me Bemb-
IIX JIan» II «IIeTYIIlKoR». 3lIaM:eHYlOlII.He
rrO:lHyro II06e)J.Y )];eKOpa nmHoro opHa-
MeHTaJIlI3Ma B CKn<pCKo 1 3BeplIHoM
CTIIJIe. O.popMJIeHne :JTI1.\ lOrnBOB CBJi-
3aHO C xY)J.omeCTBeBJ!I>r [JI !aCTepCKII-
Mll CTeIIHOll 30Hb!.
B 9TIIX YCiIOBlIlIX B I1\!\YCCTBe Cpe -
99
4
Hero TIop,HenpoBbH IV-III BB. AO H. a.
BhI,!I;eJIHIOTCH TOJIbRO OTJWJIbHbIe cBoe06-
pa3HbIe .pOPMbI. TIOMIDIO OTMe'leHHblX
m:eHCKIiX rOJIOBOK n3 TIOCYJIbH, YRa-
m:eM Ha 0pllrHHaJIbHbIe TIiUbi roJIOBOR
lImn; Ha 6pOH30BbIX HaHOCHHRax. Ha
IIpaB06epembe OHII BbIrJIHAHT AOBOJIbHO
peaJIHCTH'lHO, B TIocYJIbe - 60JIee BbI-
'1ypHO II CXeMaTII'IHO (pIiC. 4, 1-4) n.
o npoAOJImeHIIH AeHTeJIbHOCTIi MeCT-
HbIX MacTepcKnx cBIIAeTeJIbCTByeT ne-
pemHBaHHe pHJW. TpaJI;III(IIOHHblX 06pa-
30B V B. (pIiC. 4, 5, 6). B npaB06e-
pemHOM paiioHe nOHBmJeTCH HOBbIn Ba-
pliaHT 11306pameHllH JIanbi SBepH,
)TAaJIeHBO BanOMHHalO 6mlIInm
[JpeAJlleCTByro ero BpeMeBH (pIiC. 4,
7, 8; pliC. 2, 8) II.
,l.J;pyrylO KapTIiHY npeACTaBJIHIOT na-
IIHTHHIm 3BepliHoro CTIIJIJI CpeABero
[10AOHbJl, nOJl;p06BO paccMOTpeHHbIe
[1. ,l.J;. JIII6epOBbIM 17. Ero BblBOAbl 0
rny60KoM cBoe06pa31111 MHOmx 06pas-
o;OB MecTHoro IICKYCCTBa, 0 JIOKaJIbHOB
neQJI.pHKe nOCJIeAHerO B paMKax CKH.p-
KOro 3BepHBoro CTlIJIJI He BbI3bIBalOT
OMHeHIIB. ::ha cnellm IIKa BblpamaeTCJI
He TOJIblW B C03AaHIIII caM06blTHbIX 06-
pa30B H cBoe06pa3IIoii TpaRTOBRe pJlAa
o6 ecKII.pcKIiX CIOHWTOB, HO n B oco-
60D MaBepe CTH.1JIJaQIIII, npllcym;eB
MBOrHM 06pa3QaM cpcAHeAoBcKoro HC-
KyccTBa IV-III BB. ;10 H. 3. (pllc.5).
C HOCTb 3Toro XY;101KeCTBeHBoro Me-
rOAa 3aKJIIO'laCTCH, na Ham B3nI B CQ-
'1eTaHIIH mlIBoro JI IIcnOCpeACTBeBHoro
BOCnpHJlTIIJI 06pa33 3BepJl C BaTypaJIII-
CTII'IeCRIrM npIIMIITIIBII3\fOM n 113BeCT-
HOll C"\.eMaTU3aUlicii ero nepeAa'lli.
XapaKTeplIbl aMol'(fIiJaH, nJIOCKOCTBaH
MOAe;mpOBKa Te.'1<J. IITCYTCTBlie n3J1 -
HblX H JIaKOIIII'lHhn l'OHTypOB, opHa-
MeHTaJIbHO-rpa4>n'leCKaH TpaKTOBKa Ae-
TaJIen. BO.lbIlJIIHCTRO '\IIITIHnKOB TepHeT
CBOB rp03HbI.ii, ynpamalOlI\HB BIIA,
npeBpa aHCb B fIlnKOllHbIX, MUPOJIIO-
6HBbl'i mUBOTHbIX (pilC. 5, 1-3, 5, 9).
MO HbIll open, HI'KorAa Tep3aBmllii
nonMaBBYIO pbl611HY, Tenepb cnOKOllnu
'IIiCTIiT KOM'U (pIiC. 5, 6) 18. Oc06eHBO
HaUBHblMU II KaKIIMII-TO 6eCIIOMO HbI-
MIl BblrJIHAHT roJIOBKH JIOmaAeii (?) Ba
6p0H30BblX HaJl06BIlliaX (pIiC. 5, 7, 8).
CTOJIb me OplirBHaJIbBbI no TpaKToBRe
ClOmeTa II 'MaHepe IICnOJIBeBJUI MHorue
11306pam.eBIiH OJIeHH (pIiC. 5, 9-12).
CTpeMJIeHne K eCTeCTBeBHOMY nOHlIMa-
BIiIO reOMeTpll'leCKHX .pOpM O'leBb Ha-
rJlHAHO BblpameHO Ba 6JIJlIDKe 113 RYP-
raHa 9 y c. ,l.J;ypoBKa (pIiC. 5, 4), rJle
MecTHbIii MaCTep npeBpaTIiJI a6cTpaKT-
HOro (meTymKa) BO BnOJIHe peaJIblIbIii:.
XOTH II opHaMeBTaJlbHO TpaKTOBanliblll
MOTIIB KOBcKon rOJIOBKH.
B QeJlOM sBepum.m CTBJIb CpeABero
,l.J;oHa IV-III BB. AO B. a. npOTHBOCTO-
liT rOCIIOACTByro eii. B CKII.pCKOM IICKYC-
CTBe JlHHnU pa3BHTHH, BeJJ;yITJ;eii. R pac-
naJl,y OpraBH'leCKHX .pOpM II AeKopaTIIB-
Bon opHaMeHTaJIHsaQIIII. TIpaBllJIbHee
6YAeT paCCMaTpHBaTb ero RaK ocooblii
BapHaBT CKH.pCKOro 3BepliHoro CTIIJIH,
paBH03Ha'ldMH, HanpUMep, IICKYCCTBY
CHBAo-MeOTCKHX nJIeMeH TIpHKy6aHbH
3Toro me BpeMeHH. Oc06eHHOCTH ml'
xYAomeCTBeHBoro MeTOAa 11306pamCIIIIH
mliBOTBblX y WIeMeH CpeABero TIo-
ABenpOBbH He BblXOAHT sa paMKH reHe-
paJIbBOB Jl'HHIIB pa3BIITIIJI CRII4>CKOro
3BepHHoro CTIIJIH. OTMe l leHUbie pa3J111-
'111J1 MemA)' npaB06epemHOB II JlCBO
6epemHon rpynnaMIi u306pa3UTe.lb-
Hbix naMJlTHHROB npeACTaBJIHIOTCH na!>!
\
0.:-
,
8 t\in
Puc. 9. CpatlHUre.ltbHall ra6Au/Ja naMJ/rHU
"06 36epUHoao crUAA V 6. iJo H. 3. U3 CpeiJ-
Heao noiJoHbA U CpeiJHeao noiJHenp06bJ/:
1 - c. BaCOBK8, Kypr. U9; 2, 4, 6 - _tIacThI"
H}prao....' non BopOOeH<OM. Kypr. 7; 3 - C 1I.',,-
BHOOU{H, Kypr. 108 .l .5 - C_ 'IIaHeeBKa, Hypr 91.
7 - c. BonomaR HOnOBOBlia, MoronbBHIi .[{. K)"pr
198; 8 - .'I8CTh1e praKhh', Kypr. ; 9 - C. Ah-
CIOTHOIIH, ypo CTafiHoo Bepx, HYI,r I:'
10 - _'-I8CTh1e Kypr8Bh1., Kypr. 1010; 11. I -
POMeocKofI ye8n. 08 KypraOOB; 12, 14 - .'{acThI"
Hypr80...., Kypr. 7; 13 - C BepecToRrH. Hypr
16 - .'-I8CTh1e Kypr80"''', Hypr. 37,15; 1-16-
(jP0088
- ..r"
'..,
.-- 'J
..-
""
19
14
100
' t
f! >Of
......)
5
B
9
-
o
11
& 0,
.. \
- .... t""
-- -
3
-#
,
I ' :;' . \ _'
It. "..-
\-
..ti
6
(fl8{
10
O( )
?'
,
¥
12
15
16
pe3YJIbTaTOM -pymU-lHOUHPOBaHHH B
anlX paii:omlx P;BYX xyp;omecTBeUIIblX
l.(eIITpOB HJIH IIII\0JI.
TaKHM 06pa30M, npH3HaBaH peaJIb-
BOCTb cym;ecTBOBaHUJI B necocTenHoii:
30ue Tpex nOl\aJIbBHX paeOHOB 3Bepu-
Horo CTunH, cnep;yeT pa3nU'IaTb IlX no
CTeneHU xyp;omecTBeHHoe caHOCTOH-
Te.:IbHOCTIl, no OTHomemno R OCHOBHOMY
nanpaBJIeHHIO pa3BIlTHJI CIGI:<pCl\oro RC-
KYCCTBa. TIpaBHnbHoe onpep;enmme rny-
6UHbi H XapaI(Tepa paann'lIIll: Memp;y
JIOKanbHblMR rpynnaMu U BapHaHTaMU
CKII<PCI\Oro HCKYCCTBa B03MomHO Tonb-
1\0 npH 0606m;emm H aHaJIB3e Bcero
u306pa3BTenbHoro HaTepRana UB Ce-
BepHoro TIpH'IepHOMOpbH, 'ITO He BXO-
IIIIJIO B 3a,p;a'lY p;aHHOH CTaTbH.
tL
.II:
f.<
;
"'"
\
,,).
..'
...- .' ".Q
;9__,
-
:2
<.
.... ""b
.Q ''''''J . :; ,
. ':
"\
-. '\
:.8,
..... ."
6
Puc. 5. Xapa"repHl e (JOpM 86epUnOi!0 cru-
All Cpei}nezo llOOOHbJl IV-HI 66. i}o H. 3.
J. 6. J2 - (,qaCThIe KypraObl>'. I<ypr. 1 (BYAK);
2 - ,,'IaCTLIe KypmBLI.. I<ypr. 1112; 8 - c. Pyc-
CKaH TpoCTHHl<a, Kypr. 10; 4 - c. p;YPOBKa.
Kypr. II; S - "qacTLIe l<ypraHhI.. Kypr. \I; 7-
C. PYCCKaH TPOCTJlOKa. Kypr. 14; 8 - c. MacTIO-
rROO, Kypr. 1 (11108 r.); 9 - c. MacTlOI"HBo. Kypr.
3 /39; JO, IJ - c. MacTlOrooo, COOpLi A. A. CUR-
ItLI08 11105 r.; J-8, JJ, J2 - OpOB3a; 9 - KOCTb;
JO - aO"'OTO .
Puc.5
,q'
fd . .
..
'
.
:-
:2
-+
J
Puc. 4. lIaMJlrnu"u 36epUHOZO CrUAJI Cpeo-
neao 1I0i}nenp06bll IV-HI 66. 00 H. 3.
J - c. UaCThlJlCKDe. YPD'IHIIle ranyIlIRHo. Kypr. 2;
S. 8 - c. mypoBK8, Kypr. "'; S. 4. 6 - c. Bon-
KODItLI. Kypr. 1 (18117 r.); S - c. Mamn-JIIIJI.LI-
IRR'lD. J<ypr.; '1- c. HomeB8Toe. Kypr.:
J-8 - OpoHaa
9
7
102
"'C
: :.. 'K1i
s
IJ
4
9
I
.
10
.i
"
.J
)ff"' . . - .
.
.- " ,
. ii A
.'.. "v'
" 4
9 .
7
'0
B
I H. B. fleCrpsuw8a. CIUI<pCKOe IICKYCCTBO
IIoAHenpOBbH VI-III BB. AO H. 3. ABTO'
pe<p. KaHA. AIICC. J1., 1956.
2 A. [{. [{ 0p08Ul<a. K BOIIPOCY 06 B3yqeHIIII
Ce III6paTHlix KypraHoB. CA, 1957, N2 2,
CTp. 185.
3 A. H. Me.<l0"08a. K Bonpocy 0 B3aIlMOCBH'
3HX CKB<pCKOrO II <ppaKIIIICKoro IICKYCCTBa
3BepilHoro CTIIJIIi. (Te311CbI AOKJIaAOB I II
BcecolO3HoII KOH<pepeH 1I11 IIO BOlIpoca I
CKII<po-capMaTCKOB apXeOJIoruB». M., 1972.
< B. r. flerpel<"o. npaB06epembe CpeAuero
npliAHelIpOBbH B V-III BB. AO H. 3. CAI1,
BbIn. A1-4. M., 1967, CTp. 57; B. A. mpa....
"0. K Bonpocy 0 3HaqeHilil KYJIbTYPIlO'XO-
3HUCTBeUHblX oc06eHHocTeII CTelIHOU II .1Ie-
cocTelIHou CKII<pBB. (IIp06JIeMbi CKII<pCKOU
apxeoJIol'llIl». M., 1971, CTp. 100-102.
5 HeAaBHO II. A. J1116epoB BbiCTYlIliJI 3a BbI-
AeJIeHlle lIaMHTHIlKOB 3BepBHoro CTIIJIH
CpeAHero nOAOHbH B oc06yIO JIOKaJIbHYIO
rpYlIny (fl- If JIu6ep08. ApeBHHH IICTO'
pliH HaCeJIeHIIH IIOAOHbH. ABTOpe<p. AOKT.
AlIcc. M., 1971, CTp. 37).
6 (ApXeOJIoriH YKpaiHcKoi PCP», T. II.
/:." KlliB, 1971, CTp. 76, KapTa 2.
I 71A. H. m"yp"o. 06 u306pa/KeHUU cBepHYB'
'--/ merOCH B KOJIL O XII HUKa B IlCKYCCTBC
JIeCOCTelIHOII CKU<pUU. CA, 1969, oN! 1,
CTp. 33.
6 CMeJIa, I, Ta6JI. XII; CMeJIa, II, CTp. 132,
puc. 12, 13; CTp. 136, pUC. 21; A. H. Te.
peI<OJK"ul<. IIpeAcKu<pcKIlII neplioA Ha
AHerrpOnrT:rm IIpaDoO"!''';!;be. KueB, 1961,
CTp. 136, pliC. 90, 2.
9 B. A. H..f.bUI<CKaJl.. 06pa3 KOmaqLero XlIm'
HUKa B paHHeCKB<pCKOM UCKYCCTBe. CA,
1971, M 2, CTp. 78-80, pllC. 7, 1; 8, 1. 3;
CMeJIa, III, Ta6JI. XI, 3.
'0 B onpeAeJIeHIlU 1I0pOAbI nIIX mUBOTHbIX
MbI pa3AeJIHeM MHeHue II aprYMeHTa IIIO
B. A. llIpaMKo (B. A. mpaM"o. K BOIIpO'
cy 0 3HaqeHIIII..., CTp. 102).
11 CM. TaKme: B. A. H..bUI<C"aR. CKU<pbI AIle.
IIpoBcKoro .1IeCOCTenHoro J1eB06epemhH.
KHeB, 1968, TaOJI. XIV, 17; nOJI. XXXIV,
2,3.
IZ A. A. Heccel<. HeKoTopble IlaMHTlIllIiIl
VIIl- VII BB. AO H. 3. Ha Ce"PIHIO I KaB-
Ka3e. BCCA. M., 1954, CTp. 114, pliC. 2. 3:
G. Borovka. Scythian Art. London, 192R.
tabl. 32, A, F, G.
13 C leJIa, III, Ta6JI. VII, 5.
I< C I. TaKme KOCTHHbIe nca.-IIIH 113 l;ypraHa
407 y C. mYPoBKa (HAI\, BbIn. 14, 1905.
CTp. 33, pUc. 76).
15 C L TaKme: HAR, BblII. 17. Cn6., 1905.
CTp. 87, pUC. 131; B. A. Il.!bUIIC1WR. CIiU-
<pbI.., Ta6JI. XIV, 19; XXXV, 18.
16 B. A. I1.'1bnHCKaH nOKa3a.'1a Ha JIerOCTen-
110M MaTepUaJIe aHaJIOrllqHYIO TpaHC<pOp-
Ia IlIO 3allMCTBOBaHHOro 06pa3a ropHoro
"03.11a B 11306pameHIIH, 6JIU3KUe JIomaAB
llJIII JIOCIO (B. A. H..f.bUI<C"aR. HeKoTopble
IOTIlBbI paHIlecKII<pcKoro 3BepuHoro CTU-
.-JH. CA, 1965, oN! 1, CTp. 97).
11 IlIlIpoKoe' paciipocTpalieHlie nol'o MOTB-
Ba B apXaBQeCKOM CKU<pCKOM 3BepilHoM
CTIIJIe He pa3 OTMeqaJIOCb B. A. I1JIbBH-
CKOU, XOTH II C HeKOTopblM npeYBeJIllqe-
HueM (B. A. H..f.bUI<C"aR. HeKoTopble 1010-
TIfBbI..., CTp. 89; ol<a JKe. KYJIbTOBbie me3-
.-JbI CKII<pcKoro U npeAcKII<pcKoro BpeMeHB.
(,HODOe B cOBeTcKoB apxeoJIorllu». M., 1965,
CTp. 206; Ol<a JKe. 30JIOTi IIpllKpaCB
cIiiq)cbKoro apxaiQHoro y60PY. (ApxeoJIo-
riH", Blln. 4. KUlB, 1971, CTp. 73.
18 C Ie.1la, I, Ta6JI. VI, 11; CMeJIa, II, Ta6JI.
XIII, 4; CMeJIa, III, Ta6JI. XVIII, 2; I1AK,
Bbln. 14, CTp. 34, pUC. 79.
19 B. A. H..f.bUI<C"aR. CKU<pbI.., CTp. 156, 159,
pUC. 42, 5.
'0 I1peACTaB.1IHeTCH cnopHblM OTHeceHue K JIe-
B06epemHblM lIaMHTHUJ{aM 30JIOTOII <puryp-
KIl OJIeHH MUHyclIHcKoro TUlIa, 0IIy6JIUKO-
BaBHOII M. 36epTOM KaK npoucXOAHmeB
Il3 IIoJITaBcKOII ry6epHuu (RLV, XII,
Ta6JI. 39 F, B). OHa 0lIy6JIUKOBaHa BlIep-
DbIe X. llIMUATOM KaK aKcnOHaT Ape3AeH-
Clioro AJIbDepTuHuYMa 6e3 yRa3aHUH Me-
CTa HaxobKu (PZ, Bd. 18, Heft. 1-2, Ber-
lin, 1927, S. 80, taf. 7, 2).
21 B. A. HAbUHCKaR. CKII4JhI.., Ta6n. IV, 6,
.9; B. A. mpaM"o. ApeBHocTu CeBepcKoro
AOH a. XapbKoB, 1962, CTp. 182, 184,
puc 1, 21.
G' .1[. fl. BR3bMurul<a. PaHHue lIaMHTHBKU
CKII<pCKorO 3BepuHoro CTUJIIi. CA, 1963,
oN! 2, CTp. 158.
23 B. A. H.ltbUnCKaR. CKu4JhI'h' CTp. 44, puc.
22, 2; Ta6JI. III, 3, 4.
4 TaM me, Ta6JI. XX, 11; XXXV, 16; XXXIX,
4.
-' B. A. l....illcb"a. IIpo cKi<pcbKi HaBepmHu-
Iill. (ApxeoJIoriH», T. XV. KUlB, 1963,
np. 55.
'.; G. Borovka. Scythian Art, p. 65; K. Sche-
fold. Del' skythische Tierstil in Siidruss-
land. ESA, XII, 1938, p. 65-70; B. A. H..f.b-
IIHCIIaH. HeI;OTopbIe IOTUBbi paHHecKII<p-
n;oro 3Be p II,oro CTII.1IH. CA, 1965, N2 1,
np. 86.
" B. A. H..bUI<I<aR. CKII, <pbl... CTp. 111.
1r.\K, Bbm. 14, 1905, CTp. 27, puc. 65;
B. r. II erpel<"o. npaBooepembe CpeAHero
I1pUi1HenpoBbH..., Ta6.11. 19, 24.
I a l me, CTp. 57; B. A. IJI.-JiHcbKa. IIpo
'Iii<pcbKi HaBepmHuKu..., CTp. 56, puc. 7.
.,.. (" H. [{a nOUlUIla. a CKH<pCKIIX 3JIeMeHTax
B KYJIbType OJIbBIIU. MI1A, oN! 50, 1956,
CTp. 183-184. .
31 M. H. ApraMol108. COKpOBlIma CKII<pCKUX
KypraHOB. npara. 1966, pUC. 35, 77, Ta6JI.
74, 92, 115, 194, 231, 321; C. If. [{anowu-
I<a. iKa3. COq., CTp. 185, pUC. 23, 1-4;
A. M. J1ecKoB. HOBbie COKPOBllma Kypra-
HOB iKpaIIHbI. J1., 1972, Ta6JI. 12, 13, 34;
A. ll. Mal<lfe8u_. AepeBHHlIbIe COCYI(bI
CKU<pCKOft 3nOXII. ACf3, BbllI. 8. J1., 1966,
CTp. 29, pliC. 4, 14 U 28, 11 U 18.
31 B. A. IJ.!bllllc"aR. CKII<pbI..., Ta6JI. XXVIII,
10; XLVII 8; B. A. IJ..bUI<C1>aR. na IHT'
HIIKII CKII JCKOro DpeMelI1I B 6acceuBe
p. ncna. CA, XXVII, 1957, CTp. 235,
pIIC. 1. 5; CMe.1la, III, Ta6JI. X, 4.
33 B. r. lleTpel<"o. BpoH30BaH 6JIHXa C 1'0.110,
BOB rpu<pOHa. KCI1A, BbllI. 89, 1962,
CTp. 54; H. M. Bo"uu. Apxeo.1l0mQeCKIIe
pa60Tbi IIa KIfpoBorpaAmUlIe B 1968 r.
«Apxeo.lorIlQeCKIIe uccneAoBaHUH Ha YK-
pallHe B 1968 1'.», BbllI. III. KueB, 1971,
CTp. 156. pilC. 1, 2.
.. B. A. IJ.tbUI<C"aR. CKU<pbI..., Ta6JI V 5'
CMeJIa, III, TaDn. X, 6; A", VI, T GJI.' II:
409.
35 I1AK, BbIlI. 4, 1902, CTp. 42, puc. 15.
36 B. A. l1.tbUIlc"aR. CKU<PbI..., Ta6JI. LVI, 2.
37 TaM me. Ta6JI. XXVIII, 12; ol<a ;}ICe. IIa-
MHTIIlIIiII CKu<pcKoro BpeMeHu B 6acceiiIIe
p. IIcna, np. 237, puc. 2, 12.
38 G. Borot'ka. YRa3. COq., Ta6Jl. 32, E.
39 I1AK. BbIn. 14, CTp. 13, puc. 24; CTp. 26
pIIC. 59.
<0 I1AK, BbIn. 14, CTp. 15, pUC. 33; B. r. ller-
pel<"o. I1paBoDepembe CpeAHero IIpuAHe-
npOBbH. TaO.1l. 31, 5, 9, 12. 19.
<I E. B. lJepl<ell"o. IIorpe6eHue C opymlleM
II3 IIeKpOnO.1lH HIIM<peH. (ApeBIIOcTu Bo.
CTOqHOrO l\pbIMa». KlIeB, 1970. CTp. 195,
pIIC. 3; If. B. Hlfel<"o. CKU<pUH VII- V Be-
KOB 110 lIampu :Jpbl. M., 1959, CTp. 59,
n6JI. V. 4: O. r. manOWI<U"08a. I1orpe-
oPHlle CIiIl(jJcIIoro BOIIHa Ha p. I1HrYJI. CA,
1970. .\, 3. CTp. 212, pllC. 5.
lot B. A. 1I.l/JIJII.CKaR. CRu4JhI..., Ta6Jl. XXXI,
11.
., Ta 1 ;!;!'. Ta6.11. X, 7 II Ta6JI. XXVIII, 11.
.. ll. 1f,. .711liep08. IIaMHTHuKIl CKII<pcKOro
Bpe IPIIII lIa CpeAHeM AOHY. CAI1, BbIn.
A1-31 \1. 1965, Ta6.11. 24, 2.
., B. r. T/rTpelt"o. IIpaB06epembe CpellHero
IIpll:Illr'npOBbH, Ta6.11. 27, 25.
<6 B. A. lI.fbllI<C"aR. CKU<pbI.., TaO.1l. XVI, 4;
XXVIII. 3-6; XLIV.
47 G. Bor0/'ka. Yl\a3. COq., Ta6JI. 17 1 C, lI., e.
_8 B. A If.ThllH.fIWR. CRI1(pbI..., CTp. 133.
.. B. r. T/prpell/w. YKa3. COq., Ta6.11. 31, 8;
37. 5 II 17: E. B. fJepl<el<"o. CKII<pCKUB
Aocnex hIleB, 1968, CTp. 67, pUC. 36.
104
'0 H. A. Ol<au"o. AIlTllqllbIii IDmopT II lIpu-
AlIelIpOBbe II n06Ymbe B VII- V BD.
AO H. 3. CAI1, BbllI. A1-27. M., 1966,
CTp. 33.
51 G. Borovka. Ylia3. COq., Ta6JI. 16, a, ]1.;
E. B. fJ epnen"o. YKa3. COQ., CTp. 68,
pliC. 37.
52 liAR, BhIII. 54, 1914, CTp. t01, puc. 2; B. r.
flerpel<"o. YKa3. COq., Ta6JI. 26, 22.
53 B. A. H..f.bUI<C"aR. CKU<pbI..., Ta6.11. XVII,
9 II XXVIII, 7; B. A. H..bUIlC/iUR. [[a IRT-
IIUKII CKu<pcKoro BpeMelln B oaccelIlIe
p. IIce.1l, CTp. 237, pliC. 2, 11, 13.
" B. r. llerpel<"o. YI;a3. CO''-, Tau.l. 29, 15,
19, 20, 27; Ta6JI. 30, 7, 8, 11, 14-21.
55 M. H. ApraM01<08. COKPOBIfma CIiI!!jJCKIiX
KypraHoB, prrc. 20, Ta6JI. 75, 125, !'t5, 186,
187; H. B. H1Iel<"0. CKII<pcKIIe llorpe6e-
HUH 6JIU3 HorallCKa. BA", 1956, oN! 1,
CTp. 159, pilC. 2; I1AK, BbIn. 56. 1914,
CTp. 226, plIC. 14.
58 BpOH30BaH 6JIHXa U3 Kyprana I (1886 r.)
Y C. AKcIOTnH bI IIOKa3hIBaeT eIl\!' n[1o IP'
mYTOqHbIII IOMeHT B COII lCmeHIIII 06ellx
JIalI (B. A. H..f.bUI<C"aR. CKII<pbI..., Ta6JI.
XVII, 11. Cp.: CMe.1la, III, CTp. 130,
pUC. 68).
57 TaM /Ke, Ta6JI. XLIX, 3.
58 TaM /Ke, CTp. 120.
59 B. A. H..f.bUI<C"aR. CKU<pbI..., CTp. 135,
Ta6JI. V, 19; CMe.1la, III, T36.11. X, 13: B. r.
llerpel<"o. YKa3. COq., Ta6.11. 30, 9, 10.
60 B. B. lluorp08c"uU. I1CKYCCTBO YpapTY.
J1., 1962, CTp. 120; A. H. m"ypKO. 00 1130'
6pa/KeHUU CBepHYBmerOCH B KO.%I\O XUm-
IIUKa..., CTp. 37.
61 B. H. rpa,,08. '-III Ma.1la O.lblliH TOprOIlP.1Ib-
Hi 3HOCUIIII 3 IIOBOJImHM i 11 p"ypa.1HM B
apxaiqHY Ta K.1IaCCUQHY eno:\u? (,Apxeo-
JIorill», I. KUIB, 1947, CTp. 3:\: K. (/). CMUP-
1<08. CaBpOMaTbI. M., 1964, np. 2S9-261.
82 B. A. H..blIl<CKaR. CIiH<PbI.... np. 143,
Ta6JI. XXXIII, 16-21; XXXVII. 1-11.
63 B. A. mpa.""o. 06 113rOTOII.11' 11 II II 30.110-
TbiX YKpameHIlU peMeC!lPJ!III!Ii \111 CKII-
<PUU. CA, 1970, oN! 2, np. 27. _
6< CMeJIa, I, TaOJI. X. .9: C II''-Ia !!. TanJI. X,
6; A", II, Ta6.11. XXIV, No Wii. '.1 1. 414;
Ta6JI. XXVI, oN! 440.
65 AI1, II, TaO.1l. XVIII, ,N', 31 : ,lIl. VI,
Ta6JI. II, N. 40'; II TafJ.l. IV. J\, "I n: B. r.
llerpel<"o. 'Ka3. COq., Tali.l. :> . 7. 7R.
66 All, II, Ta6:I. XIX, N.320(a).
67 ll. 1f,. JIu6ep08, ApeBIIHH TlCTO!<i'" 1I {"l'JIe-
fllIH IIOAOHbH..., CTp. 29-:\7.
68 B. H. rpaK08. 3aMeTliIl 110 {"IiIl'J>" cap IaT-
CKOU apxeo.l0rllII. (,HOROP " c'<i"'T. "Oll ap.
xeOJIorllll». MI1A, oN! 1:\0. 195.',. np. 215.
A. n. MeJ1IOKOBa
CH, HO HCCJIC,lI;OBaTC;IIJ TIC nplqaIOT IIM
CKOJIbKO-HH6Y;J.b 60JIbmOrO 3H3 t WHHH
H HC nbITaIOTCH nOKa3aTb, B qeM HMeH-
no OHH npOHBHJIHCb.
I10HCKH ncpe,ll;Hca3HaTCKHX KOpHCK
p:JIH <ppaKHKCKoro HCKYCCTBa, Bncp-
BblC rrpC,lI;npHHHTbIe II. BeHC,lI;HKOBbIM,
npcp:CTaBJIHIOTCH BCCbMa nJIop:OTBOp-
IIbIMH n HHTcpeCHbIMH. PHP: rrpOH3Be-
):\eHHii, BblnOJIHCHHbIX <ppaKHKCKHMH
MaCTcpaMH, ):\eKCTBHTCJIbHO 6JIH30K K
ncpcp:HC&auaTcKHM HJIH BOCXO,ll;HT K
1111101. OlJ.HaKO p:aJIeKO HC BCC H3,l1;CJIRH
<pp,umiiCKoro lICKYCCTBa CBH3LlBaIOTCH
no npOHCXOm,ll;CHHIO C ncpep:Hca3HaT-
C!mMII. IIMCCTCH lI,CJIaH cepHH rrpcp:MC-
TOB, YKpamCHIIbIX B 3BCpHHOM CTHJIe,
rrOHBJ"ICHlJe KOTOpbIX BO <DpaKHH 1010-
mCT 6blTb 06"bH.CHeHO JIHmb BJIIJHHlICM
CKII<pCKoro IICKYCCTBa. C ):\PyroK CTO-
pOlIbI, B HaCTOH ec BpeMH CTaHOBHTCH
Bce 60JIce OqCBIIP:HblM B03p:enCTBHe
<ppaKIIffCKoro nCKYCCTBa IIa HCKYCCTBO
CTeIIHblX CKIJ<pCKRX rrJIeMeH, oc06eHHo
B I V B. p:o H. 3. BbIHcrreHIIIO B3aUMO-
B;IHHIIIIK B IICKYCCTBC 3BepIIIIOro CTII-
JIH Tex II P:Pynn nJIeMeIl II 1I0CBHH,eIIa
3Ta CTaTMI.
Ha Te pP IJ'1(opHII p:peBIIeK <DpaKnR,
B paiiOHax, .iJ:P:C 06RTaJIII r."IaBIIbIM
oopa10M renIn Op:pHCbI, u:-meCT!!O 60-
.lee 20 MccToHaxomp:cHlIii: npeil. IeTOB.
BbIrrO."IHCllIIbIX B eTHJIe. 6.'TIJ1KOM K
CI\II<PCKOMY. HeKOTopbIe 113 HRX Haff;1e-
HbI C:IyqaKHo, BHe KOMrrJIeKeOB, p:pyrae
rrpOIlCXOp:RT 1I3 60raTbIX KypraHoB
MCCTHOK 3HaTH HJIIi KJIap:OB H JIHmb
HCMHomc 6bIJIII HaKJI,CHbI B norpe6e-
HHHX pH,lI;OBbIX <ppaKHKD;cB.
HaH60JIee paHHHC npOH3BeJl,eHHH
3BepnHoro CTHJIH nOHBHJIHCb BO <Dpa-
KHH, BH,lI;HMO, BO BTOpOK nOJIOBH-
He VI B. Jl,0 H. 3. Ha aTO yKa3bIBaIOT
Haxop:KH KOCTHHbIX nCaJIHCB B IICTpHH
H TapHBep,ll;e 8 H KOCTHHOH pyqKH 3ep-
KaJIa B Op:HOM H3 norpc6CHHK HCKpono-
JIH IICTpHH 9 (pHC. 1, 1-3). I1calIHH
CTOJIb 6JIH3KlI K cCBepOnpHqCpHOMOp-
CKH [, qTO MOrJIH 6bITb JIH60 npHBe3CH-
HbIMH H3 CKH<pHH, JIH60 CKonHpOBaH-
HbIMH co CKH<pCKoro 06pa3D;a. PyqKa
3cpKana HC UMCCT npHMbIX aHaJIOrlIB
B CKH<pCKHX ,lI;pCBHOCTHX CCBepHor 1
I1pHqCPHOMOpbH, HO OHa 6JIHme Bcero
rro ):\eTaJIHM H306p:nR( lm!'! rpH<pOllb ii
rOJIOBKII R JP.'1C;IH)';,I, BbInOJI'H"IHbIM
1](' cImqW,.;[,,,: O(.ra3D;aM B KdprraTO-
YHallCK"M panOHC 10.
I1pHv-aH 3>i HHCHMOCTb OT CKH<pCKHX
<pOpl II 00:1 billaH 6JIH30CTb K HHM npo-
C'lIPmIJr-3IOTCR H n03p:HCC ( B V - IV BB.
J'.') H. 3.) B o<popMJIeHHH iIaBepillHK Me-
'IeH H3 AraToBo ", r03HHD;bI I" )J;cBcHe
BpaqaHCKO 13 (pHC. 1, 4-7). JIHmL
MCJIKHe ,lI;CTaJIIJ OTJIHqaIOT HX OT O):\HO-
BpCMCHHbIX HM CKH<pCKHX aKHHaKOB
e HaBcpmHHMH B BH,lI;e Korrcn: XH -
HOn: nTHD;bI, KaK Ha MCqaX AraToBo H
f03HIID;bI, HJIR C rOJIOBKaMH OpJIOB Ha
KOHD;ax aHTCHH, KaK Ha MeqC H3 ACBC-
HC BpaqaHCKO, BbI):\aBaH PYKY MceT-
HbIX MaeTepOB (pHC. 1,8-11).
¥mc B KOHlI,e VI HJIH B V B. ):\0 H. J,
Ha TeppHTOpIJII <DpaKHH nOHBJIHIOTeH
IIpOII3Bep:eHUH 3BepHHoro CTHJIH e HpKO
BbIpameHHbIMH MeCTHbIMII OC06CH-
HoeTHMH. STO 6pOH30BbIK BOTRBHbIff
aI\HHaK H3 Me):\mH):\RH ", 3HaMeHIJTaH
rapqHHOBCKaH rrJIaCTHHa - MaTpHua I>,
HaBcpmHC H3 e. PacKan:D;bI B Mo.'1):\a-
BHIJ (PlJc. 2, 2) 16.
)J;. Bcpqy B nOCJIclJ.HeH CBocn pa60Tc
rrbITaeTCH o6'hHeHRTb 3BepHHbIH CTI!JIb
BOTIIBHoro aKIJHaKa H3 Me,ll;mH,lI;HH, lIe-
R BOnpOCy a B3AIIMOCBH3HX CHI1<1>CROro
M <1>PARI1MCHOrO MCHYCCTBA
r ,lI;eKopaTHBHOM HeKyceTBc <ppaKHH-
CI\HX IIJICMCH 3HaqIITeJIbIIOe MeCTO 3a-
!IHMaIOT npOH3Bcp:eHHH, BblnOJIHCHHbI<J
B 3BepHHOM CTHJIe. M. 11. POCTOBD;cB
CqHTaJI HX CKH<PCHHMII 110 npOHcxom-
,lI;eHHIO I, K. IIIc, <poJIb):\ pa3):\e;rHH ary
TOqKY 3peHHH, no;raraJI ,lI;amc,
qTO <ppaKHn:cKHe ):\HHaeTbl nOKynaJIH
ynpHmb, YKpameHHYIO 6JIHXaMlI,
HCnOJIHCHHbIMH B .;mcpIlHOM CTHJIe, Ii
rpeKo-cKH<pCKIIX MaCTepCl'liX Ha IOrc
POCCHH 2. B. <DIJJIOB, IIarrpOTHB, lIa-
CTaHBaJI Ha caMoeTOHTe.'1bIIOM, He3a-
BHCHMOM OT ChlI<peIwro, npOIJCxomp:e-
lIHH H pa3BlITliH 3BCpU 1101'0 eTHJIH B
HCKYCCTBe <ppaKIIlicKIiX I1.leMeH 3. To'l-
KY 3peHHH E. <DUJIOB3 rr03):\Hec nop:-
,lI;cpmaJIH A. MIIJIqCB' II A. II. AH-
MHTpOB 5.
B nOCJIe):\HlIC rO):\bI BhIlI!.'TO HeCKOJIb-
KO pa60T, B KOTOp!.IX Borrpocy 0
npoRcxom):\enHII II pa3B!ITIIH <ppaKHn-
CKoro HCKyccTBa Yile:li1I'TCH MHoro
BHHMaHHH. H HMeIO B IHlil.Y npcm):\e
neero cepRIO eTaTeH II. BeHefJ:IIKoBa.
H HHHry J]:. Eep'lY '. ()'lil ilBTopa, npn3-
HaBaH H3BeCTIIoe CXO:ICTBO 3BepIIHoro
CTHJIH B IIC!iYCCTBC eliJlljHIB II <ppaKIJK-
D;eB, CKJIOHHIOTCH K MbIc:m E. <DIJJIOBa.
CXOP:CTBO OO"bHCHHeTCH ()umn ! HCTOq-
HRKOM npOIlCXOmil.eIlIIH. !iOTOPbIK 06a
aBTopa BIIiJ:HT B rrpc .1,1'i:e reHHil.CKOM
R axeMeHll;lCKOM IIC!;yrnBL' II paHa, a
TaKmc rrapa.1."IeJIbrrf,I 1 pa3BlITIIcM
HeKyccTBa CKII<pOB I! <!JpahIIKCKRX
nJIeMCH. B1JaIJMOBJIIIHII 11 fT !10IIycKaIOT-
106
XO):\H HCK,1IIO'I1ITl'JIbHO H3 ncpep:Hea3H
3TCKoro IICKyccTBa, KaK H nonap:aHHe
K <ppaKIJiiD;aM ca {Qii <pOpMbI aKIIHa-
Ka ". Op:HaKo rrpOTIfB nCpCl!HCa3HaTcKo-
ro npoHcxom).\eHlIH aI\HHaKOB BO <Dpa-
KHH HeHO CBHp:CTeJIbCTByeT <popMa npe).\-
MCTa H3 Mcp:mlIp:lIlI. AKHHaK ncpcp:aH
BJIOmeUHbDI B IIomHbI, HC IDreIO HM
paCrrmpeHIJH H3 KOHII.C. Mem):\y TCM
,lI;JIH nepcnp:eIOIx aKIlHaKoB pacmHpcHHc
Ha KOl!lI,e HOmel! - 06H3aTCJIbHaH ):\C-
Tam" CBH3aHliaH co crroc060M HomCHHH
3Toro LII;1a opymIIH rrepeHp:CKIJ m BOII-
HaMH t8. CpcP:1! 1I0meH CKIJ<pCKIJX aKH-
naJiOI! II11\eCTllbI 6JIH3KHe K nepclJ.He-
1I.3I1aTeKIDI, I!O rrpC06JIap:aIOT HomHbI
oe pacumpeHliH ua KOHD;C, nOBTopHIO-
1lI,IIC <POp IY K."IIiHKa t9. TOJIbKO C HIIMH
H MomHO conOCTaBHTb HomHbI, ncpe-
,lI;aHUbIe lIa rrpe):\MeTe H3 MClJ)I(HJl,IIH
(pHC. 2, 1).
Hcy6ciUITe.'!bIlbIMII rrpc):\cTaBJIHIOTCH
apryMcHTbI )J,. Bepqy, npHBep:cHHblC B
nOJIb3Y rrepe"IIea3HaTcKoro npOHcxom-
,lI;eIIHH opHaMCIITaJIbHOrO Y30pa. B 3BC-
pHHOM cnme 3II.eCb IIeT HH oJI,IIoro 1010-
THBa, ue H3BeCTIIoro CKH<PCKOMY HCKYC-
CTBY VI - V HR. p:o H. 3., C xapaKTep-
HOK ,lI;JIH Hero MaHcpOH HCnOJIHeHHH.
OHII JIIIIllb 1I0-CBoeMY nOHHTHbI H ncpc-
pa60TaHbI <ppaKHHCKHM MaCTcpOM.
OTqeTJIHBO BbIpameHHLIii nepClJ.Hca3H-
aTcKHii: xapaliTCp HMCIOT TOJIbKO H306-
pamCHHH hO;WOB lIa ncpCKpCCTbC Meqa.
Op:HaKO II 01111 He BbIXOJI,HT 3a paMKH
paHHeCIiIl(jJC!iIl x IIpOIl3Bcp:eHIlD: 3BepH-
Horo CTlI:IH {" rrepep:rreBOCTOqHbIMII 3.'1e-
MelITa 10111. Cllllpa.'lIl, rrOJIOCbI rrpHMoii H
!WCOff UlT pI! X"BIiIi, IJerrOJIb30BaHHble B
EaqeCTBe 1I.001O:IIIIITeJIbHOrO Y30pa, na-
pH):\Y C Hl'I;OTOPbIMII OC06CHHOCTHMII
CTIJ:mCTH'!PC !ioii TpaKToBKII 3BeplIIIbIx
oopa30B OT:III'I;\IOT 3TO rrpoII3Bep:eHRc
OT Hall!t(>!\I!f,1 \ H CKIJ<p1I1I H p:pyrIJx paII-
OHa.\: pacnpo("Tp3IIeHIJH CKH<pCIwro 3Be-
pliHoro CTII:IH.
He MCH hili YIO 3aBHCHMoeTb OT CKR<p-
clioro HCfiyrcTHiI IOmHO BIJ):\eTb Ha 3Ha-
107
PI/C. 1
2
. (.
, ,.
(
:i.
.I
-
8
.'1; (....\
-, 3
$-'
t i'. ',.
, - i )
, .
4 ).
... '0
'
'"
$..
Cr ?
"l ...
,(
r
1 I
6
II!
\
10 /I
5
... .
,
h
H
, }
l
!It
n
\ f l
f
1
3
9
II"
MeHUTOH 6pOH30BOH WIaCTHHe-MaTpllI.\e
U3 fapllUHOBO 10, KOTOpyro If. Bene}1J1-
KOB C'IUTaeT xapaRTepnbIM IJIpaKlla-
CKHM npou3Bep;eHBeM, ucnonneHHblM
nop; BJIBHHUeM aXeMeHBp;CKOrO llCKYC-
CTBa. H. C1>eTTux p;aTUpOBan 3TY
MaTpHI{Y VI B. p;o H. 3.", It llle-
1JI0nbA - nepBOH lIeTBepTbIO V B. .11.0
H. 3. u, n. Benep;JIKOB npe1J;JIaraeT OT-
HOCHTb ee K KOHny V - na'lany IV B.
.11.0 H. 3. IS IIocJle.n;nHH AaTllpOBKR. Ha
Barn B3fJIH.o;, BaUMeBee BepOHTRa 113
npeAliomeBBLlX, nOCKonbKY ORa BbTD.BB-
nYTa aBTopOM JIBmb B CBH3H C ero 06-
ID;eH KOBD;eDJ: ueH TpaKToBKH MaTpHnbI.
IIo MHeBBIO H. BeBe.o;nKoBa, MaTpHD;a
6bIna npe.n;nasna'leHa AnH THCHeHllH
BepxBefo cppusa cepe6pJIHRbIX Ky6KOB
TaKoH me cpOpMbI, KaK mmeCTRble B
pHp;e naMHTBBKOB BOJIrapllB H PPlhI-
BUB. IIoc.KOJIbKY Te us HH , KOTOpbJI!
yKpameBbI SOOMOP«lJHb1M1l B306pRme-
HHHMB, p;aTupyIOTCH IV B. .11.0 B. 3., TO
U M8.TpBD;a U3 fap'IBHOBa He ;1O:mUla
6bITb MHOro CTapme nocnenRIIX. On-
uaKO, UCXOAJI us «O'leRb xopomero HC-
nOJI1leHBH M8TPUD;bIl), uccnenOBaTP.'1b H
AonYCKaeT B03MOH<HOCTb OTReceBIIH ee
1( KORIU' V - Ba'lany IV B. no B. 3."
CpaBHeBBe co CKU«lJCKUMB npeBROCTJI
MU rrOKaSb1BaeT, 'ITO HaH60JIPp Bep-
UOH us npeAJIOmeHHbIX CJJenyeT (,'IH-
TaTb jJ.aTY It illet'f?onbAa.
H He 6epYCb CY1I,BTb 0 TOM. npaR IIJlJl
HeT 11.. BeHe.o;nKOB B orrpene.TJemJJl nR3-
R8'1eHUfl 6p0H301!0H rrJlaCTlIH}.! \WTPJI-
."
PUC. 1. ftJpalCuua.ue u ClCU<fiO>llf! '.IIIR
8 B8epuHOM crUAe Vl- V 88. iJn 1/
1- BC'I"])RR; z - TapHBepne; .1 - HH-q.onO:Jb
HCTpBB; 4 - fOSHHl\a; . 6 - A33TOBO ; - .lIe-
Beae BparBBCHO; 8 - faNapB"; 9 - YP' ;01 y
C. )f(yp&BKa; 10 - fpHIl\ealU>l: 11 ' .. 1'1 2
Y c. BOJl](OBI\1>l
PUC. 2. BpOlulO6Ne U30e..<IIR . 8 J.
1 - sOTHBHbIA 8HHB8l( iJ8 MeJUIBIJ.IUI.
mBe B3 C. PacKall1\»l
'!.IBf'P-
109
I
"," ('
. '
f 1
' ,
..
--,
t )
,
" } "
. ,
..L
,
,
..
(
"-
1\
..(\
..1.
,
r... .
.... .
:-..;
-'
t'
2
bI n3 fa p'IHHOBO, 'ITO me RacaeTCH op-
HaMeH'\'a HH, TO no Tpal{TOBKe H MaHe-
pe HcnOJIHeHHII 300MopljlHble H306pame-
HHH Ha Ky6Kax IV B. ,L\O H. 3. O'IeHb
,L\aJIeKH OT H306pameHH:H Ha rap'IHHOB-
CKon nJIaCTHHe, KaK H OT npOH3Be,o;eHH:H,
BblnOJIHeHHblX B CKHIjICKOM 3BeplUIOM
CTHJIe. COBepmeHHO O'IeBH,o;HO, 'ITO Ma-
CTepa HJIH MaCTep, HCnOJIHIIBmHe Ky6KH
H3 KYpraHa B A,o;mHrnOJIe HJIH CJIY-
'IaHHO Ha:H,L\eHHbln Y iI\eJIe3HblX BO-
JOT ", pa60TaJIH B cOBepmeHHO HHO:H Ma-
Hepe, '1eM MacTep, c,L\eJIaBmH:H rap'lH-
HOBCKyIO rrJIaCTHHY. M eCJIH Ha Ky6Kax
TaK me, KaK B H306pameHnJIX Ha plI,L\e
PyrHX Be eii H3 <DpaKHH TaKHX Ha-
IIpHMep, RaR Ha IDJIeMaX 3 A,o;m rno-
IIII, Ko oljleHH, H3 MY3eII B ,l];eTpO:HTe 26,
Ra 6JIIIxax n3 JIeTHH bI 27 HJIH H3 TIaHa-
rIOpHmTe 28 Ha rrepBbIH rrJIaH BbIcTyrraeT
cBoe06pa3He IjIpaIUIBcKoro HCKYCCTBa H
qepTbI, CBII3bIBaIO He 3TO HCKYCCTBO C
rrepelJ.Hea3HaTCKHM, TO IIJIaCTHHa-MaT-
JH a OTpamaeT rrpem,o;e Bcero crre H-
PHKY 3BepHHoro CTHJIII, XOTR H HeceT
EIa ce6e THrrn:'IHO IjIpaIUI:HCKHe 3JieMen-
fbI. B 3TO:H CBR3H Bce CKaaaHHoe 0 rap-
qHHOBCKO:H mraCTillHe-MaTpHn.e H. <DeT-
rnXOM 29, K. IIIeljloJIb,o;oM JO H ,o;pyrnMH
fICCJIe,L\OBaTeJlJIMH, c6JIHmaBIIInMH ee C
IpOH3Be,o;emllIMH cIUIIjICKoro 3BepnHO-.
'0 CTHJIII VI - V BB. ,0;0 H. 3., rrpe,L\CTaB-
meTCII MHe ropa3,o;o 60JIee y6e)J,llTeJIb-
IbIM, 'leM 3aKJIIO'IeHHe M. BeRe,L\HKOBa.
XO'IeTCII B03pa3HTb H rrpOTHB rrpe,L\-.
IOmeHnOH 3THM HCCJIe,upBaTeJIeM H,L\eH
) MeCTHOH, IjIpaKHBcKon OCHOBe )J,lI1I XY-'
(OmeCTBeHHoro BOIIJIO eHHII Ha MaTpH-
(e 06pa3a OJieHR H IITH . TIp UBO)J,llMbIe ,
L BeHe,L\HHOBbIM B Ka'leCTBe IIpo06pa-
iOB IjIpaIUI:HCKne rrpOH3Be,o;eHHII reOMeT-
'H'IeCKOro CTHJiR VII ,0;0 H. 3. He MorYT
ibITb p;ame OT,o;aJIeHHbIMH rrpOTOTunaMH
IJIII H306pameHHB Ha rap'IHnOBCKOH
maCTHHe ". OHH CTOJIb me ,L\a.'IeKII OT
IHX, KaK 30mIOpljlHbIe H306pameHUII,
anpHMep, K06aHCKoro HCKyc.c.TBa 0'1'
KHIjICKHX.
B 1\a'IeC'\'Be cne HIjIII'IeCKH IjIpal\H:H-
CKoii 'lepTbI, IIK06bI OTCYTCTBYIO eH B
CKUIjlCIWM I1CI\yCCTBe H CBHp;eTeJIbCTBY-
IO eH 0 CBII3H H306pameHHrr Ha rap'III-
HOBCROH IIJIaCTHHe C reOMeTpH'IeCKHM
HCKYCCTBOM IjIpaKHB eB VII- VI BB. ,0;0
H. 3., HCC,"le,L\OBaTeJIb OTMe'IaeT HaJIlrqHe
pe6pa B TpaKTOBKe ryJIOBU a OJIeHII n
JIbBa. OMaHO, cKopee Bcero 3Ta 'lepTa
Hp;eT OT MaHepbI rrepe,o;a'IH ljIuryp IIIH-
POKUMH rrJIOCKOCT!IMH B paHHeCKH<p-
CKOM HCKYCCTBe 3BepHHoro CTHJIJI (meR
KeJIepMeCCKoii naHTepbl UJIlI KOCTPOM-
CKoro o.lIeHII). Ha HeKOTopblX 6JilIxax
V B. ,L\O H. 3. BCTpe'IaeTCII pe6po n Ha
TYJIOBH e IjIHryp, H8.rrpnMep, Ha 6JIII-
xax H3 JRypOBKH 32.
ITpOCJiemHBaeMbIe 11. BeHe)];llKOBbIM
'IepTbI CXO,L\CTBa C nepeIJ.Hea3HaTCKnM,
aXeMeRJI,L\CKHM 1:ICKyCCTBOM 6e3YCJIOB-
HO rrpHcyrcTBYIOT B CTHJIHCTH'IeCKOM
01jl0pMJIeHH1:I 06pa30B, nepep;aHHblX Ha
rrJIaCTHHe. Op;HaKO OHn BbIpameHbI
3,o;eCb B TOM, me rrpeJIOMJIeHHII, 'lTO 1:1 B
rrpOH3BeAl'HHIIX CKHljlcKoro nCKyecT-
na V B. JiO H. 3., TaKHX, KaK, HarrpHMep,
yrroMIIHYTble BbIme 6pOH30Bble 6JIIIXH
1:13 mypOBKH HJIH 1:13 KypraRa y c. 3a-
HTbl 33. Ha 30JIOTOH 06HBRe HomeH H:t
KypraHa I Y c'\'. EJIH3aBeTOBCKOB: pac-
RonOR 1910 r. 3' H ,o;p.
Por .11bBHHOro rpnljloHa, CTOR ero
C3aAH O.'IelllI, COCTORIIJ.H:H n3 CHMMeT-
pH'IHO pacnOJIOmeHHbIX OTpOCTKOB, 3a-
BepmalOn\TfXCII rrTH'IbHMH rOJIOBI{aMH,
11. BenelllIKOB CKJIOHeH BbIBOA1:ITb rrplI-
IO 113 IIf'fJCTf;J:CKOro HCRyCCTBa. C'IIiTalI,
'1TO :1.'1 II ('J;IIIjIClwro 3BepilHoro CTHJIII
nO,L\OOHhle II306pameHHR He CBOll.CTBeH-
IIbl. H 0 :no neBepHo, rrocKo.llbKy Mbl
BH,L\H TaKoH me pa3f(BOBHHbI:H por
C rpnqJOllhIHm (rOJiOBKaMH 1Ia 30JIO'\'OH
0611BI<(, :l.rpeBIIU;oro cocYAa H3 KypraHa
!101 . r. lKypoBKa 35. fll,e por BbIpaCTaeT
I1:J ."lii" TIH\BOII;J.HOro mIlBOTHoro.
Bo:",IUYro CTUJIHCTH'IeCKYIO H CIOmeT-
nylO G.-m30cTb H306pameHHll Ha rap'l'IfI-
HOBCl;oii n."laCTIIHe C rrpou3Be;xeHHIIMIr
CKHIjICKOro RCKyccTBa V B. AO II. 3.
HeJIb3R 06'bIICHIITb 06mHM BJIUIIHHeM
Ha cKIIljlcKoe II IjIpaKII:HCKoe HCKYCCTBO
HpaHcKoro I1CKYCCTBa, KaK rrOJIaraeT
11. BeHeAHIWB. 3TOMY rrpeIIIITcTByeT
TO 06CTOIITeJIbCTBO, '1TO cKIIljlcKoe nc-
KYCCTBO K V B. ,L\O H. 3. rrpomJIO 3Ha'IH-
TeJIbHbIlI rrYTb pa3BHTHII, H HMeHHO B
TaKOM BH,o;e OHO 6bIJIO BOCrrpllHlITO IjIpa-
KIII:HCKlIM MacTepoM, c,o;eJIaBmHM rap'lH-
HOBCKYIO MaTpH Y. KOHe'IHO, H )J,lI1I
V B. AO H. 3. cpe,L\l! rrpOH3Be,L\eHHIT
CKHljlcKoro 3Bepunoro CTHJIII HeT n3,L\e-
JIllii, BO BCe [ CXO,L\HbIX C mraCTHHoii-
MaTpml,eii. Ho OTJIlI'lHR Om.IICHJIIOTCII
xYJl,OmeCTBeHHblMJI cKJIOHHOCTIIM:H Me-
CTHoro MaCTepa, BHecmero MHoro CBO-
HX 3JIeMeHTOB B oljlopMmeHHe H TpaR-
TOBKy 3BepHHblX 06pa30B. O'leHb xa-
paKTepHa «6CJJI3Hb rrYCToro rrpOCTpaH-
CTBa», He CB01ICTBeHHaR CIUIIjICKOMY HC-
KYCCTBY, ocooeHHO AJIR VI - V BB. ,0;0
H. 3. CaMH cpnrypbI ROMrr03H HOHHO
rrJIOXO CBII3alIhl ,L\pyr C Jl,pyroM H 60JIee
MOJIyMeHTaJIbHbI. CBoe06pa3He rrpH,o;a-
eT H opnaMeHT B BHAe BepeBO'IKH, 06-
paMJIIIIO eii meIO H Horn eHTpaJIbHblX
IjIHryp. IToc.1eJ:\HIIII 'lepTa HMeeT 6JIH3-
KHe rrapamle:m Ha 30JIOTblX H306pame-
HHIIX OJIeHII 113 TorrHoceHMapTOH 1:1
30JIhAxa:IO lIIymTbI B BeHrpn:n 36. M30-
6pameJme 0."le1l1I H3 30JIbAXaJIOMrrymTbI
cOBrraf(aeT C rap'IHHOBCImM e e H rro
rrOJIOiKCHll 10 1I0r R rroBopoTY rOJIOBbI,
'1'1'0, BH;J,IBIO. MomeT yKa3bIBaTb na
e,L\HHY!O XY:IOn,eCTBeHHYIO mKony AJIII
;)THX IIpoH3Be:WHII:H.
EIIJ e 60Jlce O'IeBHAHO CBII3b CO cKHq1-
CKHM IICI< 'I'('TBO 1 3BepHHoro CT1:IJIH
BbIcTynaeT H HaBepmHH H3 c. PacJ{oiiu,bl
(pHC. 2,2) :n 110 06II.1,e:H cxeMe OHO IIOB-
'i'OplIeT XOJWIIIO I13BeCTHbIe B CKHqmH
B VI - V BB. .10 H. 3. 6pOH30BbIe naBep-
IIIHII B BII"[(' Op."lHHOrr mIll rpncPoHbell:
rOJIOBKU, '1'1111<1 Haa,L\eUHbIX B KypraHax
Y JIbCKOro ;1 \.'IiI 38. Oc06eHHOCTbIO ero
IJI!JilIeTCH "":lhIllOll: cxeMaTH3M H reo-
MeTp1:l3aIUlH l,aK 06II.1,eii 1jI0pMbl HaBep-
110
lIlHH, TaK H ,o;onOJIHHTeJIbHOrO opHaMeH-
Ta. 3TO R rr03BOJIReT C'IH'FaTb HaBepmne
c,o;e.TlaHHbIM B O,o;HOll: H3 IjIpaKIIllcKHX
MaCTepCK1:IX, BocrrpRHIIBmHx clmcPcRRll:
3Bep1:lHbIii CTHJIb.
B KOH e V H oc06eHHo B IV B. ,L\O
H. 3. BO <DpaIUIH rrOJIy<IHJIH pacrrpOCTpa-
HeHHe Y3,o;e'lHbIe YKpameHHII B 3BepH-
HOM CTHJIe, 6JIH3KHe K CKHIjICKH 1 rro
COCTaBY B Ha60pe, 1jI0pMaM H CIOiKeTaM
l!306pamemlB:, a TaKme rro xY,L\ome-
C-TBeHHO:H MaHepe HCrrOJIHeHUII. TIo.Tlllble
KOMIIJIeKTbI TaKHX YKpameHHI"1 113 cepe6-
pa 1:1 30JIOTa, COCTOII lle R3 HaJIOOUHK3
HJIH HaHOCHHKa, rrapbI Ha e'IHHKOB ff
6JIIIX ,o;JIR rrpHKpbITHII peMeHHbIX Y3.TlOB,
BXO,o;IIT B COCTaB KJIa,o;OB, TaKHX. IWK.
KyrrJIeHHbIH B KpaiioBe 39 RJIH Hall:AeH-
RbIB: Y C. JIYKOBHT '0. Cepe6plIHble II
6pOH30BbIe H3,o;eJiHII BCTpe'IeHbl U B
HeKOTopbIX RypraHax <ppaKnHCKoii :ma-
TH, r,o;e HMeJIHCb corrpOBom,L\aBmHe rror-
pe6eHHbIX KOHCKHe rrorpe6eHllH (y
CC. A,o;mHrnOJIb B ,lJ;06py,o;me <t II Bpau,
B CeBepHon BOJIrapnH 42), a Tal;l!,e B
MOrHJIaX 3HaTHbIX BOHIIOB Cpef(H nOJIO-
meHHoro B rp06HH bI HHBeHTaplI (Bpe-
30BO, Be,o;HIIKOBO, OpH30BO, Me:Jeli, TIa-
HarIOpH Te H ,o;p.).
M. BeHe,o;HKOB, B OTJIH'llle OT CHOHX
rrpe,o;meCTBeHHHKOB, TpaKTyeT TI 3TH
YKpameHHII KaR THrrH'IHO MeCTHhIC H:!-
f(eJIHII, He HMeBmHe OTHomenHII K CKHqJ-
CKHM <s. fJIaBHbIM apryMeHToM B TIO.Tlb-
3Y TaKoro BbIBO,L\a IIBJIlIeTCII TO OiJeTOII-
Te.TlbCTBO, 'lTO BO <DpaKHH yme R \"1 I 1-
VII BB. ,0;0 H. J. CYIIl,eCTBOB;I.1II 11":100-
E1:IKH H 6JIIIXII (11. BeHe1l,1II;01\ lIa:3W:-
BaeT HX <paJIapaMH) reoMeTjJlJ'l('CI;nX
cPOpM. I1MeHHo U3 HUX, no )lIIeIIlIiO IIC-
c,le,o;oBaTeJIII, 1jI0pMHPYIDTCII n V II. AO
H. 3. rro;I.l, BJIHIIHIIe 1 nepe,L\I1ca:m;nnwro
IfCKYCCTBa YI,pameHUII KOIICKojj \':JJJ:bl
B 3BepHHOM CTIIJIe. Talm 1 01'i';!:30 I,
BaJIKaHCKHH no.TlYOCTPOB, IIO \11If'IIII!O
IICCJIe,o;OBa TeJIII, U !Or 6hlTh pi '.'[11 !lOll
cPpaKHll:CKHX yKpameHHa :P;'Ihl 1\ :18e-
pHHOM CTHJIe.
111
fIlIIOTe3a 0 IIepepaCTaHIlIl reOMeT-
pIl'IeCKIIX YKpamem1ii: B 300MopqJHbIe,
C eJIaHHbIe B 3BepHHOM CTIlJIe IIO BJIIlR:-
BHeM axeMeHIl CKoro HCKYCCTBa, Ha
Ham B3rJIR: , Be HMeeT OCTaTO'IIlliIX
OCHOBaHHH. AxeMeHH CKHe npOTOTHnbI
JIR: HHX OTCYTCTBYIOT, KaKJiIe-lliI60 De-
pexogm,re <pOpMbI cpe H DpOIl3Be eHHH
<ppaKIlHCKIlX MaCTepOB Tome HeH3BeCT-
HhI. B TO me BpeMH caMIl Il3lJ,eJIHR: H3
<ppaKHHCKHX naMHTHHKOB, KaK HaM
npep;CTaBJIR:eTCR:, OTpamaIOT iVIHTeJIh-
HbIH IIPOU.ecc pa3BHTHH, IIpOH)];eHHbIll:
CKII<pCKIIM HCKYCCTBOM 3BepHHoro CTH-
JIH K KOHU.Y V - Ha'IaJIy IV BB. )];0 H. a.
CIOmeTHbIe H CTHlliICTH'IeCKHe OTJIK-
'IHR:, HMeIO He MecTO B o<popMJIeHHIl
CKH<pCKIIX H <IJpaKHRcKHX Y3lJ,eIJHbIX
YKpameHHH, CKopee Bcero MomHO 061.-
HCHHTh oc06eHHOCTR:MH xY)];OmeCTBeH-
HbIX illKOJI - cKII<lJCKOH, C O)];BOH CTO-
pOHbI, H <ppaKHHcKoH, C fWyroll:. B oc-
HOBe me IIpoR3Bep;eBBH 06eIlx mKOJI,
BHAHMO, JIemaJIH OlJ,HH H Te me 06pa3-
IJ.I>I, CBOll:CTBeHBbIe CKH<PCKOMY HCKYC-
CTBY 3BepHHoro CTllJIR: VI - V BB. )];0
H. a. B aToH CBR:3H Y3)];e'IHbIe YKpame-
HHR: H3 CKII<pCKHX H <ppaKHHcKlIx na-
MR:THHKOB, rJIaBHbIM 06pa30M I V B. p;o
H. a., MbI MomeM paCCMaTpRBaTh KaK
P;Ba BeTBH, pa3BHBIDHeCR: II3 OlJ,HHX H
TeX me CKIl<IJCKIIx IIpOTOTHnOB. I10-
CTOJIHHO BJIHR:R: )];Pyr Ha )];Pyra, OHH IIC-
IIbITbIBaJIH BMeCTe C TeM B03 e{!CTBHe
rpe'IeCKOrO II aXeMeHH)];CKoro IICKYCCT-
Ba. Ho OIJ;eHKa pOJIH TOro R i\pyroro B
CKH<pCKOM H <ppaKHHCKm! IfCKYCCTBe
BbIXO HT 3a paMKH HaCTOilll\cii: naThR.
PaccMOTpIH! KOHCKHe YKpanH'IIJIiI no
KaTeropHR:M. HaHOCHRKIl 11,111 I1a:106Hn-
KH C BhlcTyna!O eH cKy.lbnTypl!OH ro-
JIOBKOH mHBOTHorO Ha lJ,.lIIHIIUii wee II
IIepe HIlM HTKOM, I\OTOpbJ(' omHO
paCCMaTpHBaTh KaK npOTOTUllhl C,KRI{!-
CKHX H <ppaKRHCKHX Ha,100HlI/;OB V-
IV BB. )];0 H. 3., Ha'IaJIH ynoTpeo.1HTbCR:
B CeBepHOM ITpR'IepHOMOpbe C KOHlJ;a
VI B. )];0 H. 3. qa e i!pyrnx IOTllBOB
Ha HHX IIepe aBaJIIlCh 06pa3bI OPJIHHO-
ro rpH<pOHa (KypraH 383 y c. rpymeB-
Ka ", CTapmaR: MOniJIa 45 (pIlC. 3, 1, 3)
HJIH JIhBHHOroJIOBOro XII HHKa (KYP-
raH 491 y c. MaKeeBKa (pHC. 3, 2) ie.
3TH me MO'fHBbI 6bIJIH rocnop;cTBYIO Il-
MH H B IV B. lJ,0 H. a., HO O<pOpMJIHJlHCh
OHH COrJIaCHO Tpe60BaHHR:M HCKYCCTBa
Toro BpeMeHIl, p;aJIH MHOro pa3Ho06paa-
HhIX BapHaBToB, CTHJIHCTH'IeCKIIx H JIO-
KaJIhHhIX.
Ha TeppHTOpHH cDpaKHIl IIpe06JIalJ,a-
JIR Te me caMbIe CIOiKeTbI, 'ITO H B CKH-
<pHH, IIPH CXOP;HOH <popMe IIpelJ,MeTOB.
HeKO'fOpbIe H3 HHX oc06eBHo 6lliI3KH K
paHHeCKIl<pCKHM no DpoCToTe H CTHJIIl-
CTII'IeCKHM )];a HHhIM , XO'fR: H He IIMeIOT
DpR:MbIX aHaJIOniH B CKIIiPcKIIX lJ,peBHO-
CTR:X. MbI IlMeeM B BHAY 6pOH30BbIe
JIHTbIe HaJI06HHKII H3 qepBH Bp1.X
JIOMCKO ", OpH30BO U H B)TRhOBHIJ;H
OpR:XOBCKO 4. (pHC. 4, 1-3). O)];HaKO
DO)];aBJIR:IO ee 60JIhmHHCTBo Be eH
3TOH KaTeropHH H3 cDpaKHH OTJIH'IaeT-
CR: 60JIhmeh CJIOmHOCThIO H cBoe06pa-
3HeM B ClOmeTHOM o<popMJIeHllH H TpaK-
TOBKe )];eTaJIeii:, a HHOr)];a H B Bhl60pe
caMHX MOTHBOB. BMecTe C TeM HX reHe-
TH'IeCKaR: CBR:3h C 60JIee IIpOCTbIMH H3
cDpaKHH H C 60JIee paHHHMH CKII<pHH,
Ha Ham B3r.1JR:i!, COBepmeHHO O'IeBll)];Hil.
cDpaKHHCKHe MaCTepa JIHmh rrO-CBoeMY
pa3pa6aTbIBaJIH H o<IJOPMJIJlJIH ClOmeTbI,
H3BeCTHbIe HM IIO CKH<pCKHM 06pa31J;aM,
lJ,OIIOJIlIR:JlH IIX HOBhIMH MOTHBaMII H
C03lJ,aJIH TaKllM 06pa30M cepHIO Ha:I06-
HHKOB, IIpeRMy ecTBeHHO H3 cepe6pa,
BbIDOJllIeHHbIX B )];yxe <IJpaKIIHcKoro
HCKYCCTBa. HeKoTopbIe H3 HllX,
TaKIIe, KaK Haiip;eHHbIe y c. CBHlI\apbI
2
5
6
r
Pue. 3. KONc"ue .Jt,aA06nu"u (nanoCl"''''')
U3 "yp20n06 Ce1#pn020 IIpu'lepnoMopbR:
1 - Aypr. 383 y c. fpyweBAa; 2 - CTa!!A"" Bepx.
A)'pr. 2; 3 - Aypr. 9i )' c. MaAeeBAa; 4. 7-
TOJJCTaR MOfl.l.,'1a y 1'. OpnmOBHHHn3e; 5 - t.J bI-
peBa MOrHJJa; 6 - 1<ypraH Kose,)". 8 - 1.fej)'TO-
MHbU<; 9 - AneKcaH,nponOJlb
112
PltC. l'
PUC. 4. HOltc,we HRA06/tLlKLI ('IO/tOCltLIIW)
ua rPpa,wr1c,;ux 'WMnAe"co6
1 _ qepHM BP'bx JIOMCKO; 2 - EYKbOBHQ1t; J-
OPH30BO; 4 - TeTeBeR; 5, 10, 11 - AJI>RBI'DOm.;
5 _ JIYHOBIIT; 7 - HpalloBa; (J - Epe30BO; 9-
BeABHHOBO
PUC. 5. Honc"ue IU1Ao6H.u"u (ltaHOCIII""')
ua rPpa"uuc"ux 'WMn.Ae"co8:
1 - MeaeK; J/ - CBMmap...; (J - JIYHOBHT: 4 -
HpalloBa; 5 - Bpau
lI.cnepnxl "0 (pne. 5, 2) '" nml B Kyprano
y c. Me.Je" (pIlC. 5, 1) " B B KJIa)J;e
y c. JIYKOBHT (pnc. 4, 6; 5, 3) 52, CTOJIb
cBoe06pa3Hb1, qTO CTBJIBCTUqeCKaH U
l"HJHWTHaH C.BH3b co CKU.pCKHMU B nnx
YTpaqena. B ]l.pyrnx naJI06mlKaX-na-
uocmmax, nponcxonmD;ux B3 KJIa]l.a B
KpalloBe 53, n3 KYpraHoB Bpan;" B A/l.-
<lmrllOJIb ", B3 norpe6eHBH B Be;n;HHKO-
Br ,. (pRC. 4, 7-11), :na CBHSb Xopo-
ruo BB;n;na.
"fa }lie 3aBHCRMOCTb no npOHcxomn e -
1.1110 OT clmtl>cKnx tl>OpM B ClOmeTOB
IIpor.'leiHIIBaeTCH H Ha Ham;eqHBKaX 1t3
III paKHllCKllX naMHTHIIKOB. B CKBtI>JlII
B C3M-OM R!I'laJle V B. ]1.0 H. 8. IlOHBK-
:!DCb 6pOH30BbIe 6JIHXIl ]l.JIH YKpameHBH
IoIIHCliIJX yaneqeK, BocnpORaBOnH Hf'
,
.\ -. .
., '. ' - "
......
- t
'1.'
2 .
- .' 4
@ .-
&
-:c .r't".
,I,
. ..) \
....-r. . )
8 9 I .
.. i-
f
, . ,
i . , ..
....
'7 O. \
-:,. .... \.'
{; , r "-
I
I ) .
I . r ':
I 10 11 _-..1 ...
, " 5
L _J
. , .'" -
II.')
2
"
;,;,:
7T"
6e po II napy Hor XIIIQHIIKa I1JIII KonbIT-
Horo mIlBOTlIOro ". B TeqeHHe V II
IV BB. o II. a. aTOT MOTIIB nOJIyqHJI
OqeHI, IllIlpoKoe pacnpocTpaHeHIIe H
IlpIlMeHeHIIe, B TOM qIlCJIe 3aKpenIlJICH
b:aK xapaKTepHbIH JIH KOHCKHX HaIQeq-
RIIKOB. PaHHIIe 06pa3D;bI BbInOJIHeHbI
;:\ocTaTOqHO peaJIHCTIIqHO (pIlC. 6, 1-
4, 7). B IV B. I1306pameHIIH npeBpaIQa-
IOTCH B qIlCTO ;:(eKopaTIIBHyID cxeMY,
;:(OBOJIbHO aJIeKYID OT HCXO HbIX (pIlC.
6, 10, 11; 7). EIQe B V B. IW H. 3. Ha
lJeKOTOpbIX 6JIHXaX C aTIIM CIDmeTOM
nOJIBJIHeTCJI H306pameHIIe XHIQHOO: nTII-
II,bI - rJIa3 II KJIIOB - nOJIY'l1'IBmHM
cBoe06pa3Hoe O OpMJIeHlIe H pasBIITlIe
Ha HaIQeqHIIKaX IV B. p,o H. 3. (pIIC. 6,8,
9; 7).
<DpaKHD:CKHe HaIQeqHHlill, 6poH30BbIe
II cepe6pHHbIe, TaKme BOCXOMT }{
CKII CKIIM, HalI60JIee paHIUlM 1I3 aTOO:
ccpIln. HaIQeqHIIKU I13 Bpe30Ba H Pa-
IJ:IOBeHe (pIlC. 8, 1-3) HMeIDT BnOJIHe
peaJIlICTlIqecKyro TpaKTOBKY, XOTH II
OTJIlf'IalOfCJI OT CKH CKUX V B. no e-
IWpIlpOBKe, BbInOJIHeHHOH B xe pll.-
I,lIllcKoro I1CKyccTBa. OCTaJThHbIe nepe-
alOT JIIImb YCJIOBHylO cxeMY, B KOTO-
poD: TOJThKo yrap,bIBaeTCH IICXo aJI
<popMa (pIIC. 8, 4-12). Ha 60JIbm1IH-
CTBe HameqImKOB I13 <DpaKIIII, KaK II
Ha CKII CKIIX, npIlcyTcTByeT IIs06pamc-
HlIe roJIOBbI IIJIH roJIOB OpJIHHOro rplI-
<poHa, I1HorlJ:a KaKIIX-To )qJyI'HX aHTa-
CTlf'IeCKIIX cymeCTB. Ha HeKoTopbIX MO-
nIB p,OBep,eH IJ:O KpallHero cxeMaTII3Ma,
r;Ie B amypHbIX II IIJIOXO nOHJITHbIX I1-
rypax JIIIIDb npu COIIOCTaBJIeHIIII C 60-
-[PC R:CHbIMII opMaMII MomHO pacno-
!HaTb I1CX01l:HYIO CXCMY 6eIJ:pa H 3a1l:-
flUX Hor XIImHIIKa (AlJ:mlIrIlOJIb, Op1I30-
BO, RpaHOBa, pIlC. 9, 2, 3, 5). BnOJIHe
HBeqaJI HopMaM CKH CKoro 3BeplIHoro
:TUJIH IV B. o H. a., HameqIUlKH BMe-
:Te C TeM 06JIap,a1OT oc06eHHOCTJIMII,
:BoHcTBeHHbIMII .1UIDb paKHHcKoH xy-
IomecTBeHHoH IDKOJIe. <DpaKIID:CKIIe
l[aCTepa IDIIpOKO lICnOJTh3YIOT nOJIOCM
IIITpIlXOBKII, KOTOpMMII nO]1;qepKUBaIDT
;:(e raJIH I1JIII 06paMJIR:IOT I1306pameIUlH,
I1JIII HCnOJIb3YIDT I1X B qIlCTO eKopaTHB-
HbIX D;eJIHX, p,alOT CBOIO, HO Tome yer-
JIOBHylO TpaKToBHy rpIl OHbIlX rOJIOBOK
II pyrnx aHTaCTIIqeCKIIX mIlBOTHbIX.
B pe3YJIbTaTe paKHHCKIIe HaID;eqIUlKH
B 3BepHHOM CTIIJIe B II,eJIOM OTJlHqaIDT-
CH oT CIill<pCKIIX, KaK II HaHOClD!lKH.
CKII CKIIe KOpIIII, BII lIMO, HMeIDT
H amypHble 6JIR:Xrr-CBaCTIIKII, KOTopbIe
11. BeHe;:(I1KOB CKJIOHeH BbIBOp,IITb H3
reOMeTpIlqeCKIIX raJIbIDTaTCKIIX p03e-
TOR. B CeBepHOM I1pIl'lepHOMOpbe 6JIH-
XII-CBaCTIIKII B 3BepHHOM CTIIJIe nOJIBB-
JIIICb B KOHI:(e VI B. o H. a. (pIIC. 10,
2) 58. HeKOTopble rr3 paKBHCKHX 6JIHX
aToro TlIna ):IaIDT TOqHO TaKyro me cxe-
MY II TOT me ClOmeT, qTO H 6JIHIDKH 1I3
KypraHa 8 y C. BOJIKOBn;bI,- YCJIOBHO
TpaKTOBaHHYIO ro.1JOBKy KOHJI B npo-
lIJIb (pHC. 11, 1, 5). J];pyrne ropa3-
IJ:O lJ:am,me OT HIIX, I1MeIDT He qeTbIpe,
a TpH JIY'ia, paCXOIJ:R:ID;HeCJI OT D;eH-
TpaJIbHOH p03eTI\lI HJIII Kpyra, co;:(ep-
maT CXeMaTIJ3I1pOBaHHbIe I1306pamelD!lJI
OpJIIIHbIX I1.:m rpII<p0HbIlX rOJIOBOK, TaK-
me B npo I1m, (pIlC. 11, 2,3,7,9'--11),
a IJHor;:(a BMeCTO 300MOp HOH opHa-
MeHTaII,III1 - CJIOmIlbIll: Y30P 1I3 3aBIIT-
KOB, BOJIIDT II KplIBI.IX JIHHIIH (pIIC. 11,
6, 8). Ha 6!HIXaX ll3 MeaeKa nepep,aHbl
JIbBIIIIbIe rO.10BKH B ac Ha AJIHHHbIX
IDeJIX (pIIC. 11, 4). Bcc 6JIHXII-CBaCTII-
Kif, H83aBlfCIIMO OT CIDmeTa, COlJ:epmaT
rrOJloCbI UITPllXOHKII B KaqeCTBe ;:(onOJI-
HlITeJIbHOrO II )lPI;opaTIIBHoro aJIeMeH-
Ta, CTOJIb xapaHTPpHI.Ie p,JIH npOIl3Be-
)leHlIli pa KlinChHX MaCTepOB.
r
I
I
6
PUC. 6. [fouc""l,6MiIU U uaUfe'lIlUItU UB
CK"rjJCKUX "ypza 8:
1. 2, 9 - OCTpall Monua: 3 - Kypr. 6 y c. B06-
pnI1a; 4 - ypO II111e fa.1YlllHHO. Kypr. 3; 5-
Kypr. y C. I\ollleBaToc: G - qMbIpeBa MOrHJJa; 7-
Kypr. 5 y c. Eepe('Tl!l!rll: 8 - COJIoxa; 10 - falt-
"aHOBa Morn.'8; 11 - Kypr. y r. AP 8;
12 - Kypr. 459 y (' TYPbR
116
3
2
,
5
7
9
B IV B. ):1;0 H. 3., CKOpee OKOJIO cepe-
):I;IIHhI 3Toro CTOJIeHUI, KOHCKlie YKpame-
HIIR: B 3BepliHOM CTIIJIe, cepe6pR:HhIe
II 6POH30BhIe, BhIrrOJIHeHHhIe <ppaKIlii-
CKIlMIi MaCTepaMIi B MaHepe <ppaKIlii-
CK ro IICKYCCTBa, rrOR:BJIR:IOTCR: B CTerr-
HOII CKII<pIIII. EIIJ.e E. MaJIKIIHa OTHeCJla
K IIX qlICJIY BaIIJ.e'IHIIKII II3 OrY3a
II qMhIpeBoii MOrnJIhI (pIiC. 8 13' 9 1 )
6 6 ' , , ,
BaJIO HIIK II JIR:mKY C TpeMR: rOJIOBKaMIi
Pue. 7. [(one,we naUfe'lnu,tu U3 e1tUlfte"ux
"ypzanoe:
1 - E06PHQa, HypraH 63; 2-4, 6 _ qepTOMJThlI<"
5 - IJ;HM6aJIKa; 7-8 - TOJIC"I"all MOrHJIa' 9 _ K '
sen; 10, II - raliMaHOBa MOrHJIa; 12-14 _ K a:
HOKYTCKHIi HypraH p
2
XlllI HIIKOB B <pac II3 OrY3a 59. B naCTOfl-
I.l(I)C Bpe fR: crrIICOK BeIIl,ell II3 Cl'II<p IIII ,
KO:OpbIe YBepeHHO MOiKHO CqlITaTb <ppa-
KIIJICKIiMIl, 3Ha'IIITeJIbHO B03pOC. ll3
KypraHa (,XOMIiHa MOrnJIa» paCKOIIOK
B. H. M030JIeBcKoro B 1970 r. rrpolIcxo-
):I;IIT IJ;eJIhIii Y3):1;eqBhID: Ba60p cepe6pH-
I1bI'X YKpameHIID:, OqeBII):I;HO, C):I;eJIaHHhIX
B O):l;HOII II3 <ppaKIIHcKIiX MacTepcKlix
(pIIC. 9, 4) 60. BMeCTe C TeM CJIe):l;yeT OT-
MeTIITb, 'ITO qlICJIO rrplIB03HhIX <ppaKIlH-
clmx II3):1;eJIIIH B rraMR:THIiKaX CeBepHoro
ITprr'IepHOMOpbR: Bce iKe He O'IeHb BeJIII-
KO, II 'ITO He OHII orrpe):l;eJIR:IOT B3aIIMO-
CBR:;m feiK):I;Y CKIl<pCKIiM II <ppaKIlHCKIiM
IICKYCCTBOM IV B. ):1;0 H. 3. rOpa3):1;O 60JIb-
mylO B KOJIlIqeCTBeHHOM OTBomeHlI1l
rpyrrrry KOIiCKIIX YKparnelllIH COCTaBJIH-
IOT rrpe):l;MeThI, IICIlOJIHeHHhIe B MaCTep-
CKIIX CeBepHoro ITprrqepHOMOpbR:, HO CO-
));epiKaIIl,IIe 'IepThI, 'xapaKTepHhIe ):I;JIH
<ppaKlIllCKoro IICKYCCTBa. TaKlie YKpa-
meHrrJI KOHCKOD: Y3W>!, rJlaBBhIM 06pa-
30M cepe6pR:HhIe, a TaKiKe II3 30..0Ta rr
6pOH3bl, 6biJIli B yrrorpe6JIeBIIII Y Hace-
JIeIlIIR: JllImb CTerrHOH 30HhI CeBepHoro
IT pII'IepHOMOpbR: II II3BeCTHhI HaM rro
lIaXO;J;K,BI B KypraHax CKII<pCKoft 3Ha-
TII, rrpeIIMYIII,eCTBeHHO II3 KOHCKIlX rro-
rpe6clluiJ:, corrpOBOiK):I;aBrnliX 3HaTHbiX
BOIIHOB (B KypraBax qepTOMJIhlK, Ro-
3eJI, RpaCHOKYTCKlIii:, MeJIlITOrrOJThCKIIII,
raihlaIlOBa MOrnJIa, TOJICTaR: MOrlIJla 11
B pfl;J;e ):I;pyrnx). BrrepBhIe oc06eBHOCTII
YKparneIlIIH KOHCKOii Y3):1;bI n:! rraMR:T-
HIIIWB HlIiKHero IIplI):I;HerrpOBbR: 6biJIll
orrpe):l;eJIeHhI M'. B. Hu;eIllw eIIl,e B
1956 r. 6 . O):l;HOH II3 HIIX olla C'lIITaJIa
IlPIICYTCTBlie BeIIl,eH, CTrrJlJICTlI'IeCKII
6J1II3KIIX K <ppaKIlHCKIiM. O):l;HaIW B TO
BpeMJI eIIl,e He rrpeJI,CTaBJIR:JlOCb B03MOiK-
HhIM ):I;aTb orrpe):l;eJIeHHbIH OTBCT Ha BO-
npoc, 06"bJICBR:eTCR: Jill 3Ta 6J1II30CTb
BJIIIR:HlIeM, II):(YI:IQIM II3 tDpaKIIlI, IIJIII,
Ha060pOT, II3 CKII<prrli BO tDpaKIIIO.
HaKOrrJIeHlIe II lly6J1IIKaIJ,IlH <ppaKIIii:-
CKIIX ):I;peBHOCTeii, YTO'lIleIlIlC l aTllpOBOK
CKII<pCKlIX II <ppaKIID:CKliX Hmlrr;IeKCOB
rr03BOJlR:IOT rrplI3HaTb, 'ITO ):\eKopaTHB-
BbIe 3JIeMeHThI, C6JIIIiKalOIIwe MeiK-
):I;Y C060H <ppaKIlIICKne II CTerrHhIe
I
I
5 I 14
I
6 i
I
1 12 13
118
119
5
6
11
3
CKH«pClille YKpaIIIeHHII KOHCKOH Y3Ahl
IV - III BB. 11.0 H. <I.,. BHAHMO, HMeIOT
«ppaKHHcKoe llpoHcxomAeHHe. IToA
BHHIIHlleM llpoll3BeAeHHH «ppaKHHcKoro
HCKYCCTBa B CKH«pHH H3rOTaBJIHBaJIH
cepe6plIHbIe, 30HOThle H 6poH30BbIe Ha-
JI06HHKH, Ha eqHHKH H 6HlIxH-cBac'fH-
KH, ITa KOTOpbIX 60HbIIIoe MeCTO 3aHH-
MaeT Y30P B BHAe 3aIIITpHxoBaHHbIx 1I0-
JIOC H BOHIOT, TpaAHn;HOHHbIH AHII iPpa-
KHlln;eB II He llpHMeHIIBIIIHHCII cKlliPaMH
BnHOTb 11.0 IV B. 11.0 H. <I. BMecTe C TeM
llOKa em;e HeHb3II C YBepeHHOCTbIO oll-
peAemITb npoHcxomAeHHe OTAeHbHbIX
MOTHBOB, HMeBIIIHX MeCTO Ha «ppaKHll-
CKHX H CKH«pCKHX YKpaIIIeHHlIx Y3AeqeK,
a TaKme HeKOTophlX npHeMOB CTII.TIH3a-
n;HH 06pa3n;OB mHBOTHhlX. TaK, Tpy AHO
peIIIHTb CKll«pcKoe HHH «ppaKHHcKoe IIpO-
HcxomAeHHe HMeeT H306pameHlle B «pac
rOHOBbI XH HHKa HHH TaKOH me rOHOBbI,
HO KaK 6bI llOHOiReHHOB Mem llPOTJI-
HYTbIX Hall Ha llepeAHeM IIJ;BTKe HaHOC-
HHKOB H3 CKH«pCKHX llaMIITHHKOB IV-
III BB. 11.0 H. <I., H H3 HeKoTopbIX «ppa-
KHHCKHX KOMllJIeKCOB. B YCHOBHo-cxe-
MaTHqeCKOll MaHepe <lTOT CIOmeT
llpeAcTaBHeH Ha Bcex 6e3 HCKHIOqeHHII
30HOTbIX H cepe6plIHbIx HaHOCHllKax co
CKYHbiiTypHbIMH rOJIOBKaMH HbBHHoro
rpH«poHa, HaHAeHHbIx B n;apCKHX CKH«P-
CKHX KypraHax (pHC. 3, 4-9). Ha Ha-
HOCHHKe H3 qMbIpeBoB MorHHbI, BHAH-
MO, rpeqeCKOH pa60TbI, C rOHoBKoH
.'IbBlln;bI IIHII llaHTepbI Ha BblcTynaIO eH
qaCTH <!TOT me MOTHB llepeAaH B peaJIll-
CTllqeCKOH MaHepe (pHC. 3, 5) .2. OnH-
paHCb HMeHHO Ha AaHHYIO Be b, MbI
Mome I 06'bIICHllTb CIOmeT H306paiReHHii:
Ha Bcex OCTaHbHbIX HaHOCHllKax <lTOll
rpYIIllbI, rAe cxeMaTH3M AOBeAeH 11.0
KpaHHero npeAeJIa. HeAaBHo n KvpraHe
4
8
13
PUC. 8. }(o1towe 1taUfe 1tu}w U3 rPPOKUUCKUX
KOMn.<eI>Coe U U3 Kypzana TJMliI.peeO M03UJla:
1, 2 - Epe30BO; 3 - Pa)(IOBCRe; 4-6 - Ee:\H>II<o-
BO; 7. 8 - A)(>fmrHOJlb; 9-11- RpaiioBa; 12-
IIanarlOpHIIITe; 13 - 'IMbIpeBa !\lorHJla
«ToHcTaH MorllHa» noli. r. 0PAmoHHKHA-
3e Ha YKpallHe 6bWO HaHAeHo qeThlpe
6pOH30BbIX HaHOCHIIKa C TeM me CIOme-
TOM, HO B HeCKOHbKO HHOH TpaKTOBKe
(pHC. 3, 4) .3. BOHbIIIHM THIIOHOrnqe-
CKHM H CTllHllCTIIqeCKHM CXOACTBOM
HMeHHO C HIlM 06HaAaeT OAllH H3 HaHOC-
HHKOB Il3 KypraHa B AAmHrHOJIe (pHC.
4, 10) .'. HeCKOJIbKO AaHbIIIe OT CKH«p-
CKllX CTOllT APyroll HaHOCHIIK H3 AAmH-
_ rHOHH, Ha m;IITKe KOToporo BOCllpoH3Be-
AeHa B «pac rOJIOBa :IbBa C rpHBoll, KaK
6hl paCqeCaHHOll Ha llplIMOH np060p
(pHC. 4, 11) .', hah Ha HaHOCHHKe 83
qMblpeBoii MorIIHhl. 06a HaHOCHHKa H3
AAmllrIlOJIH IIpeACTaBJIIIIOTCII BbInOH-
HeHHbIMH IeCTHbIM «ppaKHHCKllM XY-
AomHIlKOM no CKH«PCKOMY 06pa3qy H
CKopee Bcero HMeHHO TaKOMY, KaK Ha-
HOCHllK rpeqeCKOH pa60TbI H3 qMbIpe-
BOH MOrll:IbI. MeCTHbIH XYAomHHK
llO-CBoeMY BocnpOH3BeH B CKYJIbiiType
!'OHOBKY llaHTepbI HJIH HbBHn;bI, cHa6-
WlB ee Ha Chll«pCKHH MaHep peHbe«pHbIM
KaHTO 1 IJo!{Pyr rOJIOBbI.
Ha BTOpOM HaHOCHHKe C TaKHM me
CIOmeTOM Ha HTKe «ppaKHHCKHB XY-
AomHHK BocnpOH3BeH BMeCTO rOHOBKH
HbBllHoro rpll<pOHa, BHAHMO, He COBceM
IIOHHTHOll eMY B TpaKTOBKe CKH«pCKoro
MaCTepa, ro.10BKY Me,L\Be,L\II C OTKpbITOH
IIaCTbID. B IIpO«pHJIb OHa OqeHb HaiiOMH-
HaeT rpll«pOHbH !'OHOBKH Ha CKH«p-
CKHX HaHOCHllKax. TaKHe me rOJIOBKH
H306pameHbi Ha 6.'IlIxax H3 nol'o me 3a-
XOPOH€'HllH, a TaKme Ha HaHOCHllKax H3
MC3c!>;) (pIIC. 5, 1), He HMeIO II'X 6mt3-
KIlX na pa.1.1e.'Ieii: Cpe,L\H C!>H«pCKllX...
B npH lOll CBH3H C onllcaHHbIMH Ha-
I10CIIIIJ;aMII H3 CKH«pHH H A,lIiKHrH-
(J.TIbCI;OrO !>ypraHa cHeAyeT, BHAHMO,
paco! [I TpllnaTb H HaHOCHllKH 1I3 BeA-
HHIWR[I (pIlC. 4, 9), rAe MOTIIB JIbMH-
HOli rO:IOBbl B «pac Ha llepeAHeM IIT-
Ke nepe;IaH KpaBHe CXeMaTlIqHO.
OCT,LlI.tlbIe HaHOCHHKH H3 <DpaKHH,
6.1II';I;lIe no 06m;eMY BHAY co CKll«p-
CKITMIL ;IaIOT IIHoe o«popMJIelfHe
121
7
2
IIepe!{HerO m;HTKa, C!{eJIaHHOe B Met;T-
HhIX <ppaKHiicKHX TpaIJ.HD;HHX (pHC. 4,
7, 8), TaR me, KaK H HaHOCHilKH co
CKYJIbiiTypHhIMH rOJIOBKaMH rpIHpoila
(pHC. 4, 4-6). CKa3aHHoe RaR 6YJ].TO
II03BOJIReT rOBopHTb 0 CKH<PCKO ! rrpo-
IICXOm!{eHHH MOTHBa, HMeBfuero IeCTO
Ha CKH<pCKHX H <ppaKHllcKIIX HaHOC.-
HlIKax. GJ].llaKO 3Ta J].OBO.'IbHO CTpoii.
Haa KapTHlla HapymaeTcH HeCOOTBeT-
CTBHHMH B !{aTHpOBKe llaMHTHUKOB.
QMhIp8Ba MOrHJIa H Bce J].pyme CKH<p-
CKHe D;apCKHe KypraHhI, KOTophIe AaJIlI
HanOCHHKH paccMaTpHBae !Oii rpYIIIIhI,
. OTHOCHTCR KO BpeMeHH He panee cepe-
!{HHhI - BTopon IIOJIOBHHhI IY B. J].O
H. 3. I1x neT B rraMRTHHKax 6o."Iee paH-
HHX, TaKHX, HaIIpHMep, RaR Co.'Ioxa.
A!{mHrHOJIbCKlIe me HaxoARII, RaK H
caM KypraH, J].aTHpYIOTCH ero lICCJle!{o-
BaTeJIeM HaqaJIOM IV B. !{O H. 3. (OKO-
JIO 400 r.) 67. ECJIH TaKaH !{aTa npa-
BHJIbHa, TO Tor!{a, BH!{H IO, C ."Ie!{yeT
!{yMaTb 06 06paTHon 3aBHCHMOCTl! MO-
THBa H IIORBJIeHHH ero B CI\H<pHH H3
<1>paKHH. 3aMeTHM, O!{HaKO, 'IT0 OIIpe-
J].eJIeHHe BpeMeHH KypraHa B A;tmHrH-
OJIe, !{aHHOe lJ,. Eepqy Ha OCHOl1aHHH
KpacHo<pHrypHOU: HepaMHRII, BbL\hIBa-
eT HeKoTopoe COMHeHHe. KpacHorjmryp-
IIaR pOCIIHCb KphImKH JIeRaHbl BhIIIOJI-
HeHa B 6erJIOM CTHJIe H IJ Toii W1Hepe,
(cxeMaTH3M B IIepe!{aqe rOJlOBhII !{e-
BymKH H KphIJIbeB 3poTa. HC'6pem-
HOCTb B naHeceHHH OB H Bcero pnCYH-
Ka), KOTopaH CKopee rOIJOpIlT 0 JJpeMe-
HH He paHee cepC';J.HHbl IV IJ. ;to II. ;).6..
Ha 60JIee rr03J].HIOIO il,aTY. qeM
i
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
<--
Puc. 9. [( ouc/'we uaUfe'lH.U /'w 11.1 rfip" ,;" 11C1<u:t
u C1<u!fjC1<UX nO."RTIlIl1<OfJ:
1 - OrY3; 2, 5 -l\paAoBa; J - OpaaoBo; 4-
XO HHa MOrHJIa; 6, 7 - Bpa[{: 8 -:i l.;nl',llT
PUC. 10. BARxll 113 Ce6epll"'" Ilr""rpllo-
-'WpbJl: , I
1- OJIhBHH; 2 - K)'pr. 8 y {' U".lkOB b1 .
3 - Kypr. H03eJI; 4 - KpaCII(H";:YTCl\uii l-\ypraH
123
2
rg
..0..
4
Ha'laJIO IV B. ,[10 H. ;:I., RaR 6Y,[ITO YKa3hI-
BalOT iI!I aM«p0phI, ROTophIe, CYWI IIO iIl3-
,[Ia Hll 10 , JIBJUIlOTCJI llJIll «pacoCCKl1MII
6llROHll'leCRllMll rpYIIIIhI B, IIO
M. B. 3eecT, IIJIll repaRJIenCRllMll, rro-
,[IpamalO l1Ml1 «pacOCCIrnM. Te II ,[IPY-
me ,[IaTllpOBaIDICb ROmr;OM IV -
III B. ,[10 H. 3. 69 , a B IIOCJIe,[lHee Bpe-
MJI - Cepe,[lllHOii IV - Ha'laJIOM III B.
.n;o H. 3. 70 TaRllM 06pa30M, eCTb OCHO-
BaHllJI nOJIaraTb, 'ITO KypraH B A,[Imll-
rnOJIe O,[lHOBpeMeHeH UIDI OqeHb 6JIll-
30K no BpeMeHIl u;apCKllM CKll«pCKIlM.
KypraHaM, ,[IaBmllM pa306paHHhIe BhI-
me ROHCKlle HaHOCHllRIl.
ECTb e e O,[lHa Haxo.n;Ra ll3 <1>pa-
Rllll, KOTOpaJI n03BOJIJIeT .n;onYCKaTb
MhICJIb 0 «ppaKlliicKOM rrpOllCXOm,[leHllR
paCCMaTpllBaeMoro ClOmeTa. MMeeTCJI
B Bll.n;y cepe6pJIHhIH HaHOCHllK ll3 Bpe-
30Ba co CKYJIbIITypHOK roJLOBKOn JIhBa
II JIbBllHOii Mop.n;oii B «pac Ha IIepe.n;HeM
IITKe (pl1c. 4, 8) 71. OH BhIrrOJIHeH B
OC060H CTllJIllCTII'IeCROH MaHepe, OT-
JIll'IHOK OT llCrrOJIHeHllJI RaK «ppaRllH-
CKllX, TaR II CKH«pCRllX npOll3Be.n;eHllH
3BepllHoro CTllJIJI. BII.n;UMO, rrpaB
M. BeHe.n;llKOB, conOCTaBJIHJI TpaKTOB-
RY JIbBIIHhIX rOJIOB Ha 3TOM HaHOCHll-
Ke C ll306pameHllJIMll B axeMeHll.n;CKOM
llCKYCCTBe. ,D,aTllpoBRa 3TOH Be ll, RaK
II Bcero ROMrrJIeKCa ll3 Bpe30Ba, KOH-
U;OM V IIJIll Ha'IaJIOM IV B. ,[10 H. 3. He
BbI3hIBaeT B03pameHllH. TIoRa3aTeJIb-
HO, o.n;HaRO, TO 06CTOJITeJIbCTBO, '1TO
CTllJIllCTll'IeCKaJI TpaKTOBKa JIbBIIHhIX
rOJIOBOR Ha H"HOCHllRax ll3 A,[ImurlI-
OJIJI 6JIllme K CKll«pCKllM, '1eM K H;J06-
pameHllJIM Ha 6pe30BCKOM HaHOCHITKe.
3TO rr03BOJIJIeT rOBopllTb 0 TOM, qTO
6pe30BCKllH HIDI eMY rro.n;06HhIe HaHOC-
HHKH He MOrJIH 6hITb IIpJIMhIM npOTO-
THIIOM a,[lmn:rIlOJIbCWlM. CJIe.n;OBaTe.'Ib-
HO, eCJIII II ,[IOrrYCKaTb MhICJIb 0 npITXO-
.n;e CIOmeTa II3 <1>paKHu, TO CTllJIIICTII-
qeCKaJI ero nepepa60TKa, no BceR Be-
pOJITHOCTH, npHHa,[lJIemHT C Kll«pCRHM
MaCTepaM.
BOJIee YBepeHHO MomBO rOBopllTb 0
lppaKl1HCl\OM npOllCxOm,[leHlll1 MOTII-
BOB, llcrrO.'Ib30BaHHhIx ,[IJIJI opHaMeH-
TaIJ,llil cepe6pHHhIx Ha eqHl1KOB 113
KpaCHOKYTCKoro KypraHa (pl1c. 7, 12),
II3 faHMaHoBoii MOrHJIbI (pnc. 7,
10-11) 11 KypraHa K03eJI (pHe. 7,9).
n paB,[Ia, I13 Haii.n;eHHhIx BO <1>paRHIl
TOJIbKO Ba eqHllKll 113 A,[ImHrnOJItl
oc06eHHO 6.'Ill3Kll JIllmb R o.n;Hoii rrape
RpaCHOKYTCKHX (puc. 8, 7-8). O,[lHaKO
rro oe06eHHOCTJI I CTHJIJI Bce OHII BIIOJI-
He COOTBeTCTBYIOT ,[Iyxy «ppaKIIKcKoro
llCKYCCTna IT rro 3TOMY npH3HaKY OTJIH-
'IaIOTCH OT 60JIbmHHCTBa cepe6pJIHhI,X,
6pOH30BhIX II 30JIOThIX Ha e'IHHKOB H3
u;apCKIIX KypraHoB, 06hI'IHO COCTaB-
JIJIBmITX KO mJIeKChI BMeCTe C pac-
CMOTpeI1HhI 1U BhIme HaHOCHllKaMH
(pIlC. 7, ;? -4, 6 -8) .
B KaIWH-TO CTerreHll IIepeKJIllKalOTCJI
C rrpOIl3Be,[leHHJIMIl «ppaKlliicKIIX Mac-
TepOB 11 cepe6pJIHhIe Ha eqH;iIKIl H3
KpaCIlOI{YTcKoro KypraHa C H306pame-
HIIHMIl rIUlrrOKilMnOB (pHC. 7, 14). O.n;-
HaKO :!J\CCh OT «ppaKIIKu;eB, BllJ(HMO,
ll,[leT .'1Hlllb o«popMJIeHlle ClOmeTa rrOJIO-
ca 1iI LHTplIXOBKIl II BOJIIOTaMIl - 3a-
IHlTKaMII, TOr,[la KaK caM CIOmeT He
II leeT 11l1aJIOrIIii BO «ppaKHiicKOM Mllpe,
a, BII.[(I1MO, 6hIJI BOCrrpllHJIT CKII«paMU
ILl rpeqec!{oro IICKyccTBa. KOMrr03HU;HJI
11306pail,ClmH TaKme CBJI3aHa CO CKII«p-
CKl1 1\I npOIT3Be.n;eHIIJIMH, TaKHMIT, KaK
Ha Hame'mrrKax ll3 KypraHa IJ;IIM6aJIKa
(pilc:7. 5) u.:rl1 H3 KypraHa 63 y c. B06-
pllIJ,a (pIIC. 7, 1) 72. <1>paKHncKlle Ha-
lI\cqnur;" c. I1:306pameIIIIJIMH rraphI op-
JIlIH hI X !'JJJI«pOHOB H3 JIYKOBllTa llJIII
JIbBOB 11:1 Bpau;a (pIlC. 9, 7, 8) He ftMelOT
npH lb!X II a pa.'meJIeii cpe.n;II CKII«pCKITX
APPBHOCTl'ii.
9 'o..J7
"( i
o :!._W
7
u
10
(
I
Pl/C, 17 /;,IR.1'I' l/3 rfipar.uucrwx r.O.M.nJlep;-
coe:
1-3. ,;, fi - /;II3IloBa; 4 - Me3et<; 7, 10 - A)J.)RH-
fHO:tb: 8 - {:PC30BO; 9 - EparBHQeBO; 1 J - Bpau
, 'I
124
,.
" .' . .
';' " ''' , ' , ::
. ./;
,. .:', /,.
e
2
5
6
qTO KaCaeTCII CBaCnHWOOpa3HhIX
6JIIIX, TO BCe HaXO,a;Kll llX, C,].eJIaHHhIe
B HeKOTOphIX CKH«pCKlIX n;apomx KYP-
raHaX (RpaCHOKYTCKOM, hO:3.1e, Ory-
3e (pllC. 10, 3, 4), a TaKme 6poH30Ba'I
6JIIIxa 113 OJIbBllll (pllC. 10, 1), 6e3Yc-
JIOBHO, OqeHb 6JIll3Kll K «ppalmllcKllM
IIO cIOmeTy II BceM ,a;eTaJIHM opHaMeH-
T an;Bll (pllC. 11), XOTH IIpe;J.rnecTBeH-
RllKaMll IIOCJIe,a;HllX 6hIJIll, KaK rOBopll-
JIOCb BhIIIIe, cKH«pcKlle 6.1I1xII-cBaCTll-
KB KOHn;a VI B. ,a;o H. 3. He IIOJIyqllB
pa3BllTllII Ha CKH«PCKOll IIOqBe, 3TOT
BB,a; Y3,a;eqHhIX YKpaIIIemIii pa:Jpa6aTbI-
BaeTCII ,a;aJIbIIIe II o«pop laHeTclI Ha
CBOll MaHep «ppaKBHn;aMll. B TaKOM Bll-
,a;e OH BOCIIpBHllMaJICH CKlI«pCI<IlMB TO-
l'eBTaMll IV B. AO H. 3., 110ApamaBIIIll-
Mll «ppaKllnCKIfM 06pa;3n;a 1 II llMeHHO
TeM 113 HllX, KOTopbIe, OqeIlIlAHO, 60JIb-
me ,a;pyrnx COOTBeTCTBOBa.111 OCTaJIb-
HbIM IIpe,a;MeTaM, BxoAllBIII11M B rapHH-
TYP Y3,a;eQHbIX YKparneHIIH (I{paCHO-
KYTCKHR KypraH, KypraH J{03eJI).
B 3TOR CBII311 CJIe,a;yeT :uHleTllTb, QTO
B CKH«pCKHX KOMl1JIeKCax HeT 6JIHX C
paCTHTeJIbHbIM Y30PO I, TaImX, KaK
HaR,a;eHHbIe B KJIaAe 11;1 hpaROBbI,
· M. Rostovtzell. Iranians and (;reeks. Ox-
ford, 1922, CTp. 88.
"2 K. Schelold. Del' Skythische Tierstil in
Siidrusland. ESA XII 1936 S 3:;
3 B. l1>uA.oe. fIaMfiTIII!l(1I II pa "ifcI<OTO
1I31,YCTBO. 111JAJJ.. VI, 19 I . ("fp. 30.
Heanoe Ar. "'fuJI ee. 8T!1I14('('';IIP II Iiy.1b-
TypHblC CBf"'!! MCml\y <pp<lI"liiua !!I II CKIf-
<paM" R VIII-VI liB. ;10 II. .. ABTOpe<p.
Allcc. J1., '1949.
, /!,. fl. /!,u.M.urpoe. Mawplla:IIIi\T<I I;YJIbTypa
U II3IiYCTBOTO na TpalillTl' "pe:J pallllaTa
eJiIfHIfCTIfqeCiia erroxa. (, A pXl'o:JOI"IfqeCI<If
OTKpblTIfIi II B"bJII"apllll", C0<pIIH, 1957,
CTp. 64.
.. H. BeneaU/we. TIpel\axe I('1I1I.1C1-al HpaH 11
TpalillH. HAl1. XXXI. 'I\iW. CTp. 5-43;
on J/Ce. TopeBT!llia B ""BqJOIICTOqHa
TpaKIfH. HHMB, T. IV 1\ 1:\). BaplIa,
1968, CTp. .3-45; I. Venerlil.,,,. L'art thra-
ce et I'art achemenide. .\,'1,,, /.Iu premier
Congres international d,', ,'I"deO' balkani-
ques et sud-est Europeenll"'. \'01. II. So-
B Bpe30Be llJIll JIYKOBHTe (pHC. 11, 6,
8); He IIpllMeHHJIllCb H 6JIIIXII C TpeMII
rOJIOBKaMll OpJIllHbIX rpll«pOHOB B IIpO-
«pllJIb, TaKlle, KaK Hall,a;eHHLle B Bpan;e
llJIll AfJ,JRllrnOJIe (pHC. 11, 10, 11).
Bce CKa3aHifoe BbIme IIOBBOJUleT
npHHTH K 3aKJIIOQeHHIO, QTO IIOIIBJIeHHe
BO <1>paKHll plI,a;a IIpe,a;MeTOB, BCIIOJI-
HeHHhIX B 3BepHHOM CTllJIe, 6bIJIO
BbI3BaHO II CTHMYJIllpOBaJIOCb B03p;eHcT-
BlleM cKH«pcKoro llCKYCCTBa, npOIIIe,a;-
IIIero K TOMY BpeMeHH yme 3HaQHTeJIb-
HbIR IIyTb pa3BllTlllI. B IV B. AO H. 3.,
CKopee OKOJIO cepe,a;HHbI CTOJIeTHII,
Ha6JIIO,a;aeTCII 06paTHhIR npon;ecc -
BJIHIIHHe Ha CKH«pCKHe IIpOB3Be,a;eHHR
«ppaKHRCKoro xy,a;omeCTBeHHoro TBOp-
QeCTBa.
B3allMOCBII311 Mem,a;y CKH«PCKHM 11
«ppaKHRCKllM llCKYCCTBOM 3BepHHoro
CTHJIII He CJIYQallHbI, a BIIOJIHe 3aKO-
HOMepHbI. OHB 06"bIICHIIIDTCII TeCHbIMH
KOHTaKTaMH ,a;BYX coce,a;HHX Hapo,a;OB,
6JIH3KHX IIO ypOBHIO COn;llaJIbHOrO II
3KOHOMhQeCKOrO pa3BHTHII. 3TH KOH-
TaKTbI OTpa311JIllCb He TOJIbKO B HCKYC-
CTBe, HO 11 B MaTepllaJIbHOll II ,a;YXOB-
HOR KYJIbType CKB«pOB B «ppaKHRn;eB.
.. D. Berciu. Arm traco-getica, p. '18, f. 2-6.
IS N. Fettich. Del' Skythische Fund von
Gartschinowo. AH, XV, 1'934.
'6 r. A. HyaeJlb.M.an II 9. A. PUK.M.Qn. HaBep-
mile I! KJIaJJ; cepe6pIIHblx YKpaI1IeIfl!ii
CRI!cpCKOro BpeMeHif 1!3 MOJIJJ;aBifif.
HM<PAH, oM 4(31). KllmIfHeB, '1956, CTp.
129, Ta6JI. t.
'7 D. Berciu. Arta traco-getica, p. 26-32.
16 A. Godar. Umetnost Irana. Iugoslavija,
Beograd, 1965, pI. 106.
19 A. If. MeA. 10 Koea. BoopymeHne CKU<PoB.
CAH, BbIrr. Al-4, 1964, Ta6JI. 5; 15, 6; 17;
19, ]-6.
,. N. Fettich. YI<a3. COq.
"' N. Fettich. YKa3. COq., CTp. 50.
-. K. Schelold. Del' Skythische Tierstil in
Siidrusland. ESA, XII, 1936, S. 40.
" H. BeneaUKoe. TopeBTIfKa B ceBepifOCTOq-
Ifa TpaKIfIl, CTp. 10.
!It TaM me.
U D. Berciu. Arta traco-getica, p. 26-33, 66.
26 TaM me, pllC. 10, 11; 55-65.
27 «113JIom6a TpaKIfiicI>o 1!3RYCTBO . COcpIfll,
1972, '1303; D. Berciu. Arta traco-getica,
fig. 68-70.
.. df3JIOJK6a TpaKl!iicKO H3KYCTBO . p. 131a.
2' N. Fettich. Y"a3. COq.
3. K. Schelold. YI<a3. COq.
3\ H. BeneaUKoe. TopeBTI!Ra B ceBepOIfCTOq-
ITa TpaI<IfIl, CTp. 8-10.
32 M. H. Apra.M.onoe. CI<pOBIfII\a CI<If<pCKIIX
I<ypraHoB. TIpara - J1., 1966, TaaJI. 76-77.
33 H. M. BOKiu. HOBi l!aM'IITI<If cKi<pcbKoro
3BepIfHoro CTIIJIIO 3 KipOBorpaJJ;II\IIIfif. Ap-
xeoJIorill, T. XXII I. KniB, '1970, pIfC. 2.
,. M. H. AprQ.M.onoe. COI<pOBUII\a CKIf<pCIiIfX
KypraIfoB, Ta6JI. 323-325.
" B. r. flerpenKo. TIpaB06epembe CpeJJ;Hero
TIpIlJJ;HerrpoBbli B V-II! BB. AO H. 3. CAH,
BbIn. Al-4. M., 1967, Ta6JI. 16, 6.
36 H. JI. g .#.enoea. CI<If<pCI<Ifii OJIeIfb. MHA,
oM 115, 1962, Ta6JI. III, 29, 30.
37 r. A. HyaeA.b.M.an, 9. A. PUK.M.an. YKa3.
COq., CTp. 129, pllC. 2.
3. M. H. Apra.M.oltoe. COI<pOBIIII\a CI<U<pCI<IIX
I<ypraIIoB, Ta6JI. 6t.
39 H. Schmidt. Skythischer Pferdegeschirr-
schmuck aus einem Silberdepot unbekan-
tel' Herkunff. PZ, XVIII, 1927; K. Malki-
na. Zu dem Skythischen Pferdegeschirr-
schmuck aus Craiova. PZ, XIX, 1928,
S. t. 2.
100 II.. ll. /IUMurpo8. Yha3. COq., CTp. 64-67.
" D. Berciu. Arta traco-getica, p. 33.
" H. BeneaUKoe. HOBOOTI<pIITO TpaKIIHcl;O
MOrllJIHO rrorpeoeHIIe B"bB Bpa a. «Ap.
xeOJIOrIIlI BAH,>, I<1l. 1, 1966, CTp. 7.
43 T. Venedikov. YHa3. COq., CTp. 382.
U B. r. llerpenKo. YHa3. CO'!., Ta6JI. 29, 22.
.. B. A. IJIJIiHcbI<a. KypraH CTapma Morn-
fia, 1969 (archeologie, historie de l'anti-
quite artes). Te JKe lIJJ;ell rrOJIyqIfJIIf oTpa-
JKelllle B KHllre: H. BeneaUKoe, T. repacu-
.M.oe. TpaKnifcKoTo 113KYCTBO CO<pIfIl,1973.
7 D. Berciu. Arta traco-getica. Bucure ti,
1969.
8 D. Berciu. ;'\Ieue Skythische Funde aus
Rumanien und Bulgarien, PZ, XLI, 1963,
S. 190, Ab. 1.
. P. Alexandrescu et V. Eltime. Tombes
thraces d'epoque archaique. «Dacia», III,
1950, p. 152, fig. 10.
.. M. Pardncz. Le cimitiere hallstatticn de
Szentes- V ekerzug I! I. AA, VI, Budapest,
1955, p. 7, fig. 3.
1\ Ar. MUJI<lee U H. [(oea ee. He06HapoJJ;Ba-
IIU l!a IRTJtrr 11 OT CeBJIIfeBcIw. «ApxeoJIo-
mil EAIIf', 1967, oM 2, CTp. 40, puc. I, 2.
12 P. Donue. HOBOOTKpllTif naMfiTHIIl\II OT
meJI"b3IIa el!oxa B B"bJIrapIIII. HAH, V,
1929, puc. 143.
13 Bozaan HUKOA.Oe. TpaKIfiicI<If rraMIITHI!I\1!
B"bB BpaqaHCKO HAH, XXVIII, 1965, p. 11.
126
JIa - rraM'RT1\a apx<li'IIIOi CUII<pii. «Apxco-
JIorill'>. KifiB. 1951, CTp. 208, Ta6JI. \', 3.
..8 B. r. nerpeN O. Yl\a3. CO'!., Ta6JI. 29, 26.
" T. repacu.M.oe. ABI' lIaXOJJ;IHI C"bC 6pO!l30BII
YI>pacll OT CCBeplla G"bJIrapuli. l1Al1, XVII,
1950, CTp. 256, puc. 192.
.. /!,. IJ.on'lee. AUT!!'!ua MOrIfJIHa rpoa!lu a
I!pll OpIl30RO. fll.UIflJI, I, 1948, CTp. '15,
pIfC. 8.
.. H. BeJlKOe, X. /!,al/oe. HOBOOTI<pIfTif cTapIf-
If If. HAH, XII, 1939, c. 435-440, pIfC. 223.
,. «113JIom6a TpaI<U[ICiiO U3J;YCTBO», pIIC. 122.
" H. BeJlKoe. Pa;U;OnI<UTP o\;OJIO Me3eI< II
rapa CBI!JIenrpa;:\. IIEAH, XI, 1937, CTp.
135, pI!c. 123.
52 If n. IIUMIlTp08. Ylia3. COq., CTp. 66.
" D. Berciu. 'Iia3. co'!., CTp. 139, pllC. 100.
.. «OKp"bmeH IICTOpU'!CCIilI MY3eii Bpa a.
CTapo 113I<YCTBO». C0<pIIII, 1968, pIfC. 67.
" D. Berciu. Ylia3. co'!., pI!C. 18, 3, 4, ]0, ]4;
43; 44, ]. 2.
58 B. (/JUA08. 'Ha3. COq.! CTp. 30, pnc. 28.
>7 B JIIITepaType ux 4aCTO ua3bIBalOT «MeJJ;-
Bemlle JIal!bl». C l.: B. A. HA.bUnCKQR.
CI<II<pbl Auel!ponu;oro . eCOCTeI!HOrO JIeBO-
oepembll. KueB. 1\168, CTp. 132-133.
,.. B. A. HAbUI/CKQSI. CliI!<pbI JJ;!lerrpORClwro
JIeCOCTel!UOro .1I'BOOCpembll, CTp. 130,
TaOJI. XXXV, 9.
59 E. "falkina. YI,a:L roq., CTp. 160.
6. B. H. Jf03o.'eeCIiI/lI. Clm<pCline I!orpefie-
Hnll y c. Ilaropllo" ".1U3 r. OpJJ;iIiOIlIII<IfA-
31'. (,Clm'l>clille ;q'('BIIOC-TII». KIIeB, 1973,
CTp. 213, pIlC. 27, 2R.
6' H. B. HlfenKo. 0 CBRJRX CTerrIIblX ClilI<pOB
C COCeAII!DIII n.1I'\[('lIaMI!. AOKJIaA na KOH-
cpepel!l\Uu IIIIMK .\11 CCCP, rro rrp06JIe-
MaM C!iu'IJO-cap\laTc-lioif apxeoJIol"!m B
'1952 r. (lie onyfi.lul;oBall). KpaTKoe 113JIO-
merrne e o 01.: /I If. n02pe6oe . COCTOII-
Hife I!pO()JII' 1 rlil[((JO-capMaTCI<OR apxeo-
JIor!!!1 I; 1;01[(1)('11('11111111 HHMK AH CCCP
1952 r. BCC:\ !II.. 1\1.'54, CTp. 27.
62 MAlt RI>ITL 19. Cllo" 1906, pnc. 46-47.
63 B. If. ilfo31J.1eeC/i'/I11. Kyprall TOJIcTafi MO-
I"[[. a aml3 r. Op.I>l;011l1!;IIA3P Ha YI;paIlIlP.
CA, 1972. .M 3. np. 294, pUC. 29, 3.
610 D. Berc{u. YIifLL r04., pliC. 18, 14.
., TaM me, pllC. IR. 6.
.. D. Bneill. Y,;a:1. C04., puc. 18, 9, 10.
d7 D. Berciu. 'l-\a:-\ roq.. CTp. 76, 95.
6. T. Heal/oe. ..\UTII'llIa l;ppaMnlia OT IIPlipO-
1!0JIa I!a Ano:loIIIIA. "AnOJIOIIIIII». C0<pIIII,
1963, CTp. 14"-1 \-,. Tafi" . 64-65.
6. H. B. 3eecr. 1;('1'" \llIqeCiiali Tapa Bocl!opa.
M 11:\ , M 83. 1%(1. T. IX.
7. 10. r. BUI/O?paO,.H. l-\epa mqeCKife Ii.leibla
oCTpoBa cDacora In. T. X, 1972, CTp. 16.
71 I. VenedikoL'. 1",;;,:1. COq., c. 39 p.18-19.
72 B. F. lleTpel0;o 1-\83. COq., TaOJI. 27, 6.
8. B. HKoBeHKo
eCTb reOMeTpU'IeCKHe ,meMeHTbI. OAHa-
KO OCHOBHoe MeCTO B CKH<pCKOM AeKO-
paTUBHO-rrpUKJIaAHOM UCKYCCTBe 3aHH-
MaJi 3BepHHbIR CTUJIb, KOTopbIn CKU<pbI
UpUHeCJIH C C060R B CeBepHoe IlpH'lep-
HOMopbe yme B 3HaqHTeJIbHOR CTerreRI{
C<P0pMupoBaHHbIM, C YCTOIIBIIIHMUCII
KaHOHaMU. PaHHue 06pa3n;bI 3TOro CTU-
Jill rrpOUCXO,lJ;IIT U3 OCHOBHoro 1I0rpe6e-
HUll Ha TeMHp-fope U XOpOIIIO U3BeCT-
HbI no rry6JIHKan;UIIM B pllAe TPYAOB z.
He OCTaHaBJIUBallCb Ha BceM CKa3aH-
HOM 06 3TUX BeIIJ;,ax, OTMeTUM JIHilib He-
KOTopbIe'MoMeHTbI.
,lJ;aTupoBKa, rrpUHIITaII B HaCTOIlIIJ;,ee
BpeMII B aHTUqHOn apxeOJIOrUH ,lJ;.1IfI po-
AOCCKO-MUJIeTCKUX Ba3 K.'laCCa KaMu-
pa,- BTopall qeTBepTb - cepeAHHa
VII B. AO H. 3.",- II03BOJIlleT YTBepm-
AaTb, '1TO KOMrrJIeKC U3 KypraHa Ha Te-
mp-fope, B KOTopbIn BXOAHT TaKaH
Ba3a, CTapIIIe HaXO,lJ;KH H3 3HBHe rrO'lTU
Ha rrOJICTOJIeTUII. Il03TOMY MHeIlIIe HC-
CJIeAOBaTeJIeR 0 HaqaJIe <POp lITpOBa-
HUll CKH<pCKoro AeKopaTIIBHO-nplmJIaA-
Horo UCKYCCTBa B lIepHO)J; 3UBlle' HaM
KameTCII He060CHOBaHHbBI. O'IrBfI,lJ;HO,
3TOT rrpon;ecc lIpOlICXO,lJ;lI.'l ropa3AO
paHbIIIe, TaK KaK yme B Te Ilfp-rope
MbI CTaJIKUBaeMCII C HCKYCCTBO I. rrpo-
IIIe,lJ;IIIHM K ql')pe)J;HHe VII B. ;'\0 TI. 3.
AJIUTeJIbHIdR IJyTb 3 BOiIlOIJ;nll .
o BLICOKOrI. YPOBHe pa3BHTflR 1I30-
6pa3UTeJIbHbIX cpe)J;CTB B IIC "YCeTBe
CKH<pOB CBUAeTe.1IbcTByeT npem;'\r Bcero
rOJIOBKa rpH<p0-6apaHa 113 I;OCTU
(pUC. 1), UCrrOJIHeHHaII B KpyrJIoii
CKYJIbrrType. 3acJIymuI;!alOT BHIlMaHUII
,lJ;orrOJIHHTeJIbHIde u306pameHHII mUBOT-
HbIX Ha HeR. MHoroqUCJIeHIfbIe rrapaJI-
JIemI, llHorAa rrO'ITU rrOJIHbIe aHaJIOrIlH,
KoropbIe MId HaXOAllM 3TUM u306pame-
HHIIM B pe3Hoii KOCTH VI B. ,lJ;0 H. 3.,
HaIIpHMep, cpeAu KOCTIIHbIX rrCamIeB
IlOCYJIblI" rr03BOJIIIIOT C AOCTaTOqHOii
,lJ;OJIeH BepolITHoCTU YTBepmAaTb, qTO
ABa u306pameHUII rrpeACTaBJIlIlOT JIO-
IIIall,b a OAHO, cpeAHee - JIOCII (pIlC. 2).
COqeTaHUe 06pa30B JIOIIIaAll U JIOCII C
06pa30M rpu<p0-6apaHa YKa3bIBaeT Ha
Kpyl' COJIlIpHOH CUMBOJIHKU, XOpOlliO
u3BecTHoR Ha MHornx rrpe)J;.MeTax paH-
HecKH<pcKoro 3BepKHoro CTUJIII 6.
l1HTepecHa U KOMrr03Un;UII <pHrypOK
KOHli H JIQCII - 3TO mHBOTHoe C O)l.Hoii
roJIOBOR U II,BYMII TYJIOBIlIIJ;aMH
(pHC. 2, 4). MaJIOBepOIITHo, qTO TaKaII
I\OMrr03Hn;UII - pe3YJIbTaT rrpocrol'O
3aUMCTBOBaHHII U3 rrepeAHeBOCTOqHOrO
KCKyccTBa, JIu60 rrpueM, npOAlIKTOBan-
HbIR <pOpMOR rrpeAMeTa, KaK lIHca.'I B
CBoe BpeMII M. H. AP'I'aMoHQB. Ilpe)J;-
CTaBJIlIeTCII, '1TO OHa IIBJIlleTCII OTpame-
HlIeM orrpeAeJIeHHbIX UAeOJlOrn'IeCKIIX
rrpeACTaBJIeHUR, B OCHOBe KOTOpbIX JIe-
mHT oAHa U3 AyaJIIlCTUqeCKHX u,:reii.
06pa3en; TaKon KOMlI03Un;UH BCTpe'Ieli
B KOMrrJIeKCe VII B. AO H. 3. B Yiira-
paKe (paCKorrKH O. A. BUlllHeBclwi"l) -
u306pameHbI ABa JIOCII C OABOll rD.'IO-
BOll 7. 60.11ee rr03AHIOIO pa3pa60TKY 1111<1-
.1I0rIlqHOll TeMbI MbI BCTpe'IaeM cpeaH
IIaMIITHlIKOB VI- V BB. ,lJ;0 H. 3. 1\<1
A.TlTae H B CU6UpH 6. BTopoe pr:llloe
YKpallleuHe H3 TeMlIp-fopbI lIpe)lCTlIlJ-
JllleT OAlIH H3 JlY'lmlIx 3K:,eMII:lRpOH
ClIeIJ,Il<plIqeCKu CKu<pCKon HOMnO:!II UII II
cBepHYBilieroclI XHlQIIlIKa (pm. 3). 11.1.:
BeCTHO IHoro 6J1H3KlIX eMy y"pallielllll1
B KOCTIl, 6poH3e II 30JIOTe 9. O,:rIl<1h!l
XlIlQHlIK U3 TeMup-foPbI rrpeBOCXOiUIT
IlX qeTKOCTblO, rrpeAe.TlbHoii :raKOllll'l-
I10CTbTO U BblCOKUM ypOBHeM lIcnO.lfl(>-
JlJIfI. XY,lJ;OmHHK-pe3'IHK, urpaHII'Il'II-
IIPE,I(METbI 3BEPllHOrO CTllJUI
B PAHHECIDI<DCRllX IIAMHTHllRAX RPblMA
IlaMIITHHKH CKII<pCKon apxaUKU HMe-
lOT rrepBOCTerreHHoe 3HaqeHUe AJIII
peIIIeHIlII BOlipOCOB 0 rrpOUCXom,lJ;e-
HUH H pa3BHTIlH CKH<pCKoro UCKYCCTBa
B 3TOT lIeplIO,lJ; rrpe)J.MeTId CKH<pCKoro
3BepuHoro CTII.'III elQe coxpaHlllOT CBOIO
caM06bITHOCTb, KOTopaII rr03me TeplI-
eTCII 3a MHomeCTBOM rrpHBHeceHUH B
pe3YJIbTaTe aKTHBHoro 06lQeHUII CKH-
<pOB C aHTIl'IHbIM MUpOM. Il03TOMY
KOMlIJIeKCbI cepeAUHId VII - Ha'laJI8
V BB. ,lJ;0 H. 3., OTKpbITbIe Ha TeppHTO-
pUH KpbIMa, lIpe,lJ;CTaBJIIIIOT oc06bIn
UHTepec. HeOIOTplI Ha MaJIOqUCJIeH-
HOCTb, KpbIMCKall KOJIJIeKn;UII rrpeAMe.'
TOB 3BepHHoro CTHJIII pa3Ho06pa3Ha rro
ClOmeTHbIM Km.m03Hn;HIIM, MaHepe HX
UClIOJIHeHlIfI H IaTepuaJIY. OHa OTpa.
maeT B AOCTaTO'IHO rrOJIHOM 06'beMe OC-
HOBlIbIe narrbI pa3BUTUII HCKYCCTBa
3BepUHoro CTn:rII Ha Bcen TeppUTopUD
CKH<pIIH.
K MOMeHTY rrOIIBJIeHHII CKH<pOB B
CeBepHOM IT pn'IepHOMOpbe 3AeCb roc-
nOACTBOBa.l CTlI.'lb reOMeTpHqeCKOn
opliRMeHTaT.\llll C pa3Ho06pa3Hon pa3-
pa60TKOR CO.lllpHOR CHMBOJIHKlI. Ha.
r,'IfI,i.\Hall TO IY lIJIJIIOCTpan;HII - Ha60p
pe3Hon KOCTIT IT3 KHMMepuncKoro rro-
rpe6eHlIII y c. 30JIbHOro rroA CHM<pepO-
nOJIeM '. CI;mpbI Tome 6blJIU 3HaKOMbI C
reoM(,TplI'Ien;IT I cTH.'leM, B apXalI'Ie-
choe Bpe lil OIl IlIHpOKO rrpHMeHfIJiCII
):\.'111 ):\eKopa CTO.10BOR rrOCY,lJ;bI; H3BeCT-
RbI OT)Ie.lhllhle npe):\MeTbI H3 KOCTH 1I
6pOH3bl. B opHaMeHTan;HU KOTOpbIX
128
5 CKH$O-CH6HPCI-ndi .'lnepIlHbIA CTlLlb
Hbln <popMon rrpeAMeTa, CYMeJI IlCrrOJIb-
30BaTb rrOJIIIOCTblO BCIO IIe6uJIblllYlO rro-
BepXHOCTb, rapMOIIHqHO paClIpe eJIHB
IIa HeR mHBOTHoe C MlIHUMaJlbIIOII 3aT-
paTOll 1I306pa3HTeJIbHbIX cpeACTB.3AeCb
HeT HIlqerO JIUIIIHerO, RUKaKUX A06a-
BOqHbIX clOmeToB, oT06paHbI TOJIbKO
OCHOBHbIe BUAoBbIe rrpU3HaKH.
VI B. AO H. :3. 3HaMeHyeTcII B CKU<p-
CHOM HCKYCCTIJe, C OAHon CTOpOHbI,
AaJIbHenIIlJIM pa3BHTHeM U rrepeOCMbIC-
JlelIHeM yme 3HaKOM"bIX 06pa30B H KOM-
II03HqIln u, C )J.PyroR,- rrOIIBJIeHUeM
ROBbIX ClOmeTOB. K KOHn;y ero Bce
CnJIbIIee oru;ym;aeTclI BJIUllliIIe rpeqe-
CKoro UCKYCCTBa. CKH<pCKHe rraMIITHu-
1m KpbIMa :3TOro rrepHoAa 0006eHHO
IIllTepeCHbI, TaK KaK 3AeCb CKll<pbI
llenocpeACTBeHHO H aKTIlBHO KOHTaKTH-
pOBamI C mUTeJIIIMH aHTlI'IHbIX ropOAOB
CeBepHoro IlpU1JepHOMopblI. OTpame-
HIleM rpeKO-CKH<pCKUX B3aHMOCBII3eR
HBJlIlIOTCII 1I0Ka elQe HeMHoroqHCJIeH-
IIbIe HaXOAKH B apXaHqeCKHX CJIOIIX
OOClIOpCKUX rO])OAOB. KOIIIJ,OM VI B.
;1,0 H. 3. AaTHpyeTclI 'IaCTb mITeimoK
q>OpMbI U3 IlaHTHKaueII (pHC. 4, 1).
II. ,lJ;. Map1JeHKO peKoHcTpyupoBaJia
IICIO <POPMY KaK u306pameHue ABYX KO-
II W'I blIX XHlQHUKOB B «repaJibAUqe-
cKoil» 1I03e 10 (puc. 4, 2). 3TOT MOTUB,
:,aHMCTBOBaHIIbIII C BOCTOKa, H3BeCTeH
II CeBepHoM Ilpu1JepHoMopbe B He-
ChOJlbKlIX KOMrr03IlIJ,1I0HHbIX BapHaH-
Tax. CaMbIll paHHHR a:) HlIX - 6JllIxa
UYKYP JIHMaHa - CBII3aH C xy/.(omeCT-
1H'IIHbIMlI 6pOH3aMlI JIyplICTaHa H Karr-
IIa.10KlIli ". IlaHTHKanl'iicl\aII JIllTPIlHaII
t!mpMa lIpe)J.CTaBJIlleT 3!1TII'IHYIO pa3pa-
tiOTKY AalIHoii KOMlIo:mIJ;HlI. OHa HIITe-
peCHa AJIfI Hac KaH CBH,lJ;eTeJIbCTBO
illITlI'IIiOro lIpOH3BOACTBa rrpeAMeTOB
!BeplIIloro CTH:III, paC'C'IlITaHHOro Ha
H "yCLI CKH<pCKoro ol,pymeHHII rpeqe-
('i,IIX ropOAOB. <DopMa n03BOJIIIeT npeA-
IIO.'laraTb CYlQeCTBOBallHe B ro])o,:rax
rJOCIIOpa crren;naJIH:mpOBaHHbIX MaCTep-
<'Jiax IIO rrpoH3BOfjCTBY rrpe,lJ;MeTOB
l !j
...
.
?' f
. . ...
.
'.,
't l .
,
"I'
-...:
....,
..
I
2
t'
0.: ;Vf
" :
"
I
C'.
ip
3
-I
aBepHlioro CTnJUI ynw B KOHne VI B.
:1,0 H. J.
BepoHTHo, B aTHX MaCTepCKHX IUI'O-
TOBJleHbI II OpoH30Bble YI\palIIeHIIfl IU
c. AOJIHHHOro (I\ypraH 2 [RYJIaKOB-
cl<oro L norpc6eHlle 3) ". HecKoJlbKO
CJIOB 0 JJ,aTlIpOBKe Bcero KOMllJteKCa
(puc. ;). bO:lblIIYIO 6pOB30BYlO 6mIXY
B3 :noro KypI'aHa f. BopoBKa JJ,BTllpO-
Ban VIl- VJ BB, JJ,O B. 3. 13 . M. 11. ApTB-
MOHOB OTIIl'C norpeoeUBe K cepeJJ,HIIe
V B. JJ,O 11. ,." T. H. TpOBI{KaH rrpeJJ,no-
IKKJIa BOBYIO JJ,aTY - BTopaH nonOBIiHa
VI B. JJ,O H. 3. - py6em VI-V BB.
110 H. 3,15. IIocJIe)J;HHH ABTBpOBKa
npe)J;CTaB.1ReTCII Hall60nee y6e)J;KTeJIb-
noil, Ee 1I0JJ,KpenJIHIOT K 6poH30BbIn
CKIUICTp (pile. 5,3). BMelOII\Hn npHMYIO
aHaJIOrHIO B KypraHe 15 y C. AKCIOTBH-
I{bl'. (pnc. 5, 4), B 6poH30Bble H8KO-
He'lRIIKU CTpeJI, O)J;HOTBIIHble C ROJI'IaH-
UbIM ua60po}1 83 I\yprBHB 3 {)060BB'Ia 17.
Ha 60.lblIIOil 6JIHXe npe)J;CTaBneHa
Tp",I(lInl,l0llBaR KOMn03 BH - CBep-
HYBlIIHilcH XU HBK (pBC. 6). Ho 01'
rrp£>ihReii TeMbI co'tpaHBJIOCb TOJIbI\O
IBorHYTOl' KOJIbnOM TYJIOBBlI\e. OCBOB-
noii 06p;];\ nepeOCMblcneH, Korna'IBii
Xl'lmUHI{ 3a}leReH BOJl'lbBM.
BOJIqnii XBID.HHK nOHBJUle1'CH B
CKH«pCI{O t ;mepBROM CTBJIe B KOHI{e
VI B. AO II. J. RaK yme roBOpBJIOCL ",
OR 3al'lMCTI\OBaR B3 aHaBbBBcKOro IIC-
KYCCTBa '1epe:J IIocpeACTBO caBpOMaT-
CR'I'IX 11.....\1('11. OJJ,uaKO, OCJIB H8 pe3HbiX
IOIbll,;\'( II 6pOll30BbIX IIMK1'aI{BRX
COX pi! n R I' 'T" 11 onpCJJ,eJIeB.Hblf' CTn-
.'ml"nl'!!"I;II!' ocooeHIIOC1'1I anaHbHII-
('1(01'0 11 1''''''' pa:Ja - OBa.'1bHOe YXO, KOM-
no;mnnOIlIl" CBR:JaHRoe c. rJIa;IO\I.
.
"\.
. .
r----
I
J
I
I
,
I
I
I
,
"
(
pur. T r " " -Tapa. /(oCTJIH.a/i lOAOtla lplt
tfio-6apaltD
PILC. ? T,''''/ p-Topa. llpopltCotJKa ilono."""
U,fb"bU ,.15paxenuu lia ZOAotJe lPUifJO-
6apana.
1 1. 4 1-. "t.: _' - .."lOeb
130
BOJIlOT006p8:JH81I JIlfllHH pT8, qaCTO
nepeXO,l(HID.aH B roJIOBItll nTlUl; II JJ,p.,
TO HB 6nHXe 113 C. .D:O.'1HHHOro BO!!K
Jl306pameH B aHTWIHoii: nepepa60TI\(,.
BOJIqbe yxo npB06peJIo y)J;JIKlIeURO-
TpaneI{neBH)J;nylO «POPMY II He CBH3ano
c rJIa30M, MOPAa - C rop61JnKoi-i Ha
HOCY. Bce 1'YJIOBHlI\e )J;el<opnpoBaHo 11.0-
6aBOqllbIMB lIa06pameHI'IIIMJI. 3,!1,eCb
MomHO BH,I(eTb rneC1'b IITll'lblfX rO.'10BOI\,
ro:IOBY JIOCH B «pBrypRY KOIIbITHoro.
BCH _!WM_n03!'!l\IIH _ ):!QI!26'peT 1' alKyp-
I!Q.c.!!>, x8pBKTepB Y ,l(JIH _ pe,l(MeTOB
3BepuHoro CTII M rpeqeCKoro IIpOit3-
BO)J;CTB8. ROULITHOO-mHBoTHoe. TpilK-
TOBaJIOCb HeKOTOpbnMK Bccne)J;oB8Te!lR-
1.111 KBK K03eJI C 06palI\eHHoii: m\3aJJ;
rOJIOBOn fl. HaM KameTcH, '11'0 31'0 Iwn",
aRaJIOrBqHbIn «PllrypK8M 83 fJIaJJ,K{\B-
II\BHbI, CIIHHBKH B ,l(pyrnx KOMn.'1{,K-
COB '.. Y cl»UrypOR KOaJIOB, HaqHHalI 01'
HenepMeCCKBX B306pameH1Iu VI B. )'10
H. :3., pora 06H3BTeJILHO npBlloJJ,IIRThI
HB,I( JIBHBen B30rHyroii mell It yXO
H306pameBo oT)J;eJIbHo". Ha ,'J.aRIIO\l
H306pBmeHBB py6qaTaH .11IRI'IH, Ol,aii
MJI1IlO1I\81I melO H BKJIlOq8IOID.aH yXO.
HBJIHeTCH cKopee rpOBOi'1 KORff. 'Il' '
pOI'OM K03na.
BTOpBH 6JIHxa 113 c. .D:OJIHrrllo!'
nepeAaeT elI\e O,I(Hy p83pa6oTKY a nil
JIorllqHoii KOMII03lfI{HH (Pl'lc. 7). llit
HeR 11306pameB CBepHYBllIl!ilCfI KOlIli'
qllR X HHK C 4(BblBBXHYTLIM» Ty.10
Bl'IlI\eM. no Jd:HenlilO MHorHX Hcr:1(' 10
BaTeneii 31'01' B306pa3HTeJIbHbIU UP"!'"
:JaHMCTBOBaH 113 nepe,l(RPBOCTO'lIlOr ll
HCKYCCTB8", oc060e pacnpocTpanClIIlI'
OR IIonyqBJI B V - IV BB, Y Har0;!II"
CH6HpB n AJIT8H. CqHTaJlOCI,. '1TO F1
CeBepHoM npBqepOO1.lOpbe nOJ\onJl,lR
PUC. 3, TeAlup-Fopa. KOCT!!Na!! lip.'," .
C uJ06pa3lteHUeM Ctlt'pliytJwelOCR IUlli"/i1.
PUC, 4. llureiiHQJI. ifJop..ur 1'-' 1I1/1IT1","" ,
1 - coxpaHHBwanCH 'IaCTb: - p t"UIiI TPYJ';UU I
,no H. A. Map'IeHl<o)
131
5.
l
--
3
r-
&&
AA
2
. , .
.,.
\,
..
, \
)
.
,O r
\ \. lit. C
J
KOMn031I HJI 6LIna U3BeCTHa nlImb C
cepeAlIHbI V B. 11.0 H. 3., nOCKOJIbKY
nplIHHManUCb 130 BBHMaHlIe TOJIbKO XY-
AOmeCTBeBHbIe 6pOB3b1 83 CeMH6paT-
lllIX KypraBoB "'. BJIJlxa U3 C. AOJIHB-
HOrO BeCKOJIbKO YApeBBJlCT BpeMJI
nOHBJIelDUl B306pamcmIii C «BI>IBBX-
ByrblMt TYJIOBIIIIJ;eM.
Oc06o cn:eAyeT OTMCTHTb MaJIOpaC-
npOC1'paBCBBblH nplICM fBblBHXBYTo-
CTlIt nepeABcii: JIanbl, 06b1'1HO
nOBepHYTOii 13 OABY CTOpoBY C roJIOBon
mlIBoTBoro. BepollTBo, np006pa3 KOM-
n03lIItBlI Ha 6JIJlxe H3 C. AOJIHBBOro
BOCXOAIIT K 1I306pameHlIIO mHBoTBoro
C «BblBHXBYTOHt 3aABeii: JIanOn H no-
BepHYTOH Ba3aA roJIOBoii. BOJIee
n03)J;BHe BapHaBThI T8.RHX H306pame-
HIIH H3BeCTHbI cpeAH ACpCBHBBblX
YRpameHlm TIa3LIpLIKcKUX Kypra-
BOB u.
He COBCCM 06L1'lBO nepeAaBa BHm-
BHJI "IaCTb JIaD KOma'lbcro XHII{BUKa -
JI'IeUcTbJe yrny6JIeHUJI, B1dAeJIHIO e
KOrru. TaRlIe JI8IIL1 U3BCCTHbI JIHmb Y
ROma'iblIX X UROB - Ba 6pOH30BblX
YRpamCHHHX TarapcRoii RYJIbTypbl 21.
TYJIOBUlI1;e muBOTBOro, RaK U Ba 6onb-
moB: t>mn::e, YRpamCBO A068BO'lHJJDfU
1I306pamCHUHMlI - ABYMJI ronoBRaMU
nTII .
EII:\e 01J.HB npC)J;I4CT Toro me Bpe-
MeHB npOBCX01J.HT ua pa3fpa6JICHnOrO
norpc6eHHH B HypraBe 3 B 6b1BmCM
HMeHIIU TaJIBeBOB: .II. iho pe3HOIt RJThIK,
Y ROTOpOro Ba JIHIteBOH CTopOHe mlI-
pORoro ROB Ita H306pamcH8 ronoBa
BOJma (puc 8, 1). ROMn03HI{UOHHO
ARHHOC 1I306p8mcHRe aH8nOI'H'IHO BO:l-
..,
. ,.
#'
t"
.'
.
'-
......
,.c-
* ,
.
-
- .
..
-
.I.!"
Puc. 5. HHlltlnTapb n02pe6eHuA !J II "IIP2. 2
II c. POAUHHOJ:
1 - CnaRQ.eBwl ocenoll; II - I\pouaoBl>le Bal<OBeq-
BHI<H CTpe.n; '-l\poBBOBl>ln TOnOpHI<-CllltneTp;
4 - aB8JIOrR'IBhItI eMY TonopHII HB AIICIOTIfBeq
Puc. 6. BOAbWnsl 6pOH301l011 6AAxa U3 c. JJ.0-
AUHH020
132
IJ.bUM XUIl\HHKaM Ha KnbIKax TIpIIAHe-
npOBCKOH cepun u. OCTpbIll KOHert
KnblKa, no MBCHIIIO T. H. TpOnI{KOii,
npCACTaBJIHeT C060H ronoBY Ka6aHa.
OAHaKo ROpOTlwe, IJ.YTb TOp'larqee yxo
H MaccuBBLlH rop6aThIH BOC cKopee
n03BOJUIlOT Bn}J.eTb 3JI,ecb ronoBY nocJI.
TIOA06HbIC JIOCBBbIe ronoBKH oe3 nblm-
BOH amypHOH KOpOHbI pOroB xap8KTCp-
HbI AJIJI C06CTBCHHO C1{H4>CKOro 3BCplI-
Horo CTUnJi.
A.HTU'lBYIO nepcpa60TKY :'!Toro 06-
pa3a MbI BCTpC'laeM Ha 6pOH30BOii
6nHxc U3 KypraHa I\apa-McpKHT
(Tenepb c. KamTaHoBKa) : BblCOKHii
rop6aTblB: HOC C BomoTo06pa3Hoii JIH-
HRCB: pTa II pa3BeTB.'1eHHbIC pora,
YBeB'laHIU.le p03eTKoii II ro.l0BKOH
nTHItbl 28 (pBc. 8, 2). TaKlIc 1R306pamc-
HUH JIOCK mnpORO H:iBeCTHbI Ba BCCB:
TeppHTOpUII CKn<}JUII. HaqUnaH C V B.
11.0 B. 9. B aTOM me KOMnnCKCC Haii:-
ACHbI 30JIOTblC HaKna,lJ){H HB COCY}J.bI C
u306pamcBBeM nTRlJ.beii ronoBbI U Co-
AJIII{CI'O onCHH %I. OHII TaWfCC xapaRTe-
PU3YIOTCJl npocYll\eii rpe'leCROB TpaK-
TOBRc }J.CKOpaTIlBHOCTblO C BKJII01JCHUCM
paaCTOR U BonlOT.
Haxo1J.1Gl 03 I\Ypranl1. l\apa-MepKHT
OTpamalOT oc06eBllOCTO 3BCpBHOro
CTBJIH Ba'lana V B. 11.0 H. a. OCBOBBOC
BanpaBnCHlIC ero P,13BUTIIH 13 9TOT
rrcpoo}J. - aKTIlBHaH aHTnqHBJI rrcpc-
pa60TKa UCKonno CHIt<}JCKUX U rrpUBBe-
CCBHbIX C 3anaAa It I10CTOKa ClOmCTOB.
MHTCpCCBa 13 aTOll CB1I3H KOCTJIH8H
ronoBRB nbBB R3 MlIJ1 leKI1H 3D (V B. AO
H. 9.). OHa BbIITO."lll"n8 13 rpe'lCCROB:
PUC. 7. MOAnsl. 6POH80'W." 6.(J!xa U3 c. po-
AUHH080
Puc. 8. npeiJ."en./ ,UPUH020 C7'UAA
us ltpNMCp;oii Ko""""elilfll/i
1- peBRoA 300"OPcJiHLlii ".IL'" 113 I<ypr. 3 B I\I>IB-
meM H'feHJ'l1t Ta."IaeBort. ' - CipooBoBaH rOJIOn3
nOCH 83 AI<-MeqeTCI<Oro Im",n.,eRca; 3 - I(OCTH-
BaR rO.:IOBKa RbB8 1':3 !\h'p'H.I{ R
133
MaHepe (pnc. 8.3). OnHalw pe3qHK
DLlTanCR CJleJ\OBaTl, oopa3n;aM qym,D;oro
tJMY MeCTHOI'O ;\BepliHoro CTII.1H. B
pe3YJlhTaTe OCKaneHHaH naCTh XHlL\-
HHKa C f13h1IWM npl'BpaTfi:IaCh B Mano-
nORJITHYIO opHaMeRTa.'1hHYIO ,n;eTanh.
::.ho oc06eRil0 XOpOIIlO ; aMeTHO npn
cpaBHeHHH Ml1pMeKHiiCl,OH ronOBKH C
l'aHHllMB H;106pameIlBHMi'I, HanpllMep,
c I'OJIOBKOH BO.ll\a ua I'OCTHHOM <PYT
JIHpe H3 b.n:IO}IPHcPe:ILJ\a ".
TaJ{YIO jf;p aHTB'IHYIO nepepa60Tl{y
ClOmeTOB 3BepHHoro CTHnfl MLl a8XO,D;HM
B a860pe YKpaIllPHBH B3 30noTQro
CHMcpepononhCKOl.O I<ypraaa >to BpOB-
30BaH JIhBII 8.. ll.'laKUpOBaHHaH 30no-
TOM, IIcnO.'1HeHa B rpeKO-BOHIIHCROH
MaHepe. 06 TOM CBII,D;eTeill>CTBYIOT II
CTaTH'lHaH nO;Ja qJlIryphl C BIICflID.IIMll
nanaMII, II nOBepHYTRfI I! «pac. BMeCTe c
nepeAHHMII JIaIl3MB ronoBa, Tor.J\,a RaR
<l8,D;H.lIe naIlLI IIPIJPJ\3HLl B np0<pIIJU,. B
.J\,ononHeHlle \;0 BceMV. qTO CKa38.HO 06
3TOM 1I306p3nH'IUUI' B. H. IlJIbllH-
CKOH ". XO'leTCA 06P8.TI'ITb BHIIM8HHe
fla .J\,el,op Ty.IOBB111:J JIbBHIJ;h1. BCTaBIul
C f1qeiiEiHIII :I.If! '\la!11'I BhlrJIfI,n;HT He-
CIWill>I\o rpyiio II II.IOXO YBfl3LlBaeTCH C
06ll\IIM PPIJ!PflI1P\1.
BpOn;3nlli1A ro.10BKa rplI<poaa npe,n;-
CTaBnHeT ,'/lBPPlIlPHIiO HOBhlH ,!I;JUI
CKlIcPcIwro .\BI'pI'IHOrO CTIIJIH CIOH\eT,
3aHMCTBoBallHbrii IU rpeqeCKOH TopeB-
TIlhll. fpBQJOH 61,[.1 O)l.HIIM H3 nonynHp-
HeHIIIHx MUQJO:IOI.'J'IeCKIIX 06pa30B Ha
Bocnope. ero nO\Io'JllanH Ha MOHeTax,
OH CTan CB')f'OOl''' IlIblM CIIMBOJIOM bOC-
nopnwro I"on' :I,' I" TB8.. fplI<pOH r
\OXO;IKOM II j : \" 'I "1"0 l'ypr8.Hi1, C HI.'-
OO;JhIIHIM cTnH'I11\1 nUhOM n A068.Bo'l-
HhiM 11306p"'hPllllt'\1 nTnqhen I'OnOBI{"
nO.IHOCTbfD "'" f HI' I "TByeT u;w6pamp-
HIHnl Ha MAOIII\ -"".IIOPCI'IIX 1I3,!1;e!IHHX.
B Tahoii ;1'" 1111'IflOii nepepa60TKP
npP1I:eTaB;I"U I! "I". I npemJ\e Beero 06
BTO}I rOBfJl'ill "10 D033- rOJlOBa
n ;Ianhl I: '01" .';"lIbl B npo<pBJI b.
TY.-IOBBID.e II q '" B QJae. iho o6h1'1-
HhlB rpeqeCHSH MOHI.'THbIii THn n:J06pa
meHJilH; DO,D;06HLIe cPHrypKJiI opnoB If;!
BeCTHhl, nanplIMep, Ha MOUeT8.X 0:1 \,-
Bill! J<. Ec.n:lI cpaBHRTh opJIa Jil3 30.10TO-
10 KypraHa C Hs06pa>KeHneM aToH nnl
D.hI IfS MeJIbryHoBcKoro I,yprana
IVI II. AO H. a.). TO nepBoe OTJIllqaeTCI1
OT BTOpOro MHoro'lHCJIeHHbIMR AP06Hbi
MI'J ,!I;eTanJiMlI, OTCYTCTB)'IOID.lIMJI B pan
lIeCKH<pCHOIl 3BepHHOM CTBJle. Tp8.AII
l.{IIOHHaR YCJIOBHOCTh If JI8:KOHB'lHOCTI.
B H306p8.JKeHHII H\lIBOTHhlX RAeeh nO.1
HOCThlO YTpa'lIfBaeTCR.
3Ha'lMTc.lhHoe CIomeTHO-I,O m03JnJ;H-
IIHHoe nep£>pOiK,!I.eHRe 3Bepnnoro CTHJIfi.
npe06Jla,n;aHIH' aTITHqHOH 11300pa3HTe!Ih-
noM: J.lanephI nar.1H,n;HO H.'T.'TIOCTPHPYIOT
H HaXOAKJiI 113 Kyprana y c. H:lhllQeBO
naq8.JIa V B. )1.0 H. a. 35. lIa 30.'TOTOH n.'Ta.
cTime OT ro.n:OBHoro y60pa B lJ,eHTpe ne-
pCAaHa rO.iIOBa JIOCH, m;e,n;po JI,el,OpHpO-
BRHRaH 3aBIITymli:aMH porOB. rO.'IOBIW-
\((( nTIIII; H p03eTI,a.,.m. Cpe;m nHX
OIlO.1JRHTe!ILHLIX AeTaJIeH, n.l0THO 3a
1I0;IHlIIOJJJ;HX BCIO nOBepxuocTh fipe;!
leTa, JIOCh nOTepflJIeH. OR nO'ITII
He3aMeTeH (pIlC. 9).
Puc. 9. 30AOT4R "4LUUBliaR 6.J1.RI4 U3 c Jf.'bU-
lj 8D
PilC. 10. Bt!p:OLJUf IlnCTb 3o.AOroii KO.(Ilt1UUOl7
1{,,,.utnih'ill U3 c. lfJf.bllfl tJO
..
i
.. '" ...
" 4
.' , ..
....... ,: . ,
- , \ .
....
(.
,
..') ... ...
'I
,,
"". t . Wi' "
, '"-
......
.......,
.. )' . ,<:' ,fci
l. . ..
'-
,
--=- -
.-
J r
". ,1
. \
<I
....:11
---
1::V,
EIIII' OO:I1'P TIOI;a;1i1Te.ll hila Il.lar nlIw
OT 1\0:1'1 all "- CO ClJ;1.'1I0H 11'1':!<l1t111l
(PllC. Ill). 'Lume C1omeTIILI1' 1,1\}IIII\;m-
UII!! ("1'111'1111\1'11110 He XapaETI'I'IIJ,1 .1.111
qen,oro II :WI,OIlH'lROrO paIlH1'cl;llIjICl;n
ro :!RPpIlIlOro CTIIJIlI, r.!l,p a,IIROTIlf,\f'
n:Joiipi1a;a.HICL OOLf'IHO }JH:\M HII:IY ,1:1 f,
110. R C1IOI,oiillOii n03e. B cPlII'y!W I\.WIIII
r.1JIl!Il;n r }IHOro re.TImx Al'Tiupii. :qw-
OI1lIlIlX IIP:lhIlOCTh H306paml:'IIIIH - y\O
C. l'yii'ldTOii 6axro lOii. 1'O.'TOlIl\il TITIIIlI.I
IIfJ:1 IIlDI. oupa I:leHlle IUPlI 113 pyii'l"-
"OR II ropOIllMR. 1,0RhlTR I'J XIIOCT. I\PIl'I
,rPln 111'011<1 IIHbl£> ronORI,aMH nTMIl. Iln-
;J."J"II 'TI.((, HOrl\ O:JCHfi nOTf"pH:m 11:-111-
1I[(.cn'" 1'1 npOIIOpII,I'IOH8..1hHOCTb. IIP"-
CY!llnO paHHI'I 1 n306paa{pnnl1}1. Olin
./
."
"
- ' I '
/
. ... .-
, ,\",s
......
..: '
i\
oJ
-l';))
'"
J- -
C.'1I1IIIKOM TOHKH no cpaBHeHBID C Kpyn-
HbIM TYJIOBIUD.eM. TaKme HeHaTypaJIbHO
BbIrJIlI)I,lIT pora, 3aBHTKB KOTOpbIX CO-
CTaBJIeHhi H3 60JIbIIIHX nTlI'IbHX rOJIOB.
Pora KaK 6hi BBCIlT Ha)l, OJIeneM 6e3
BCIIKOll CBII3H C raJIOBOll. 81'0 nOJIHOe
IIC'Ie3HOBeHHe KOMn03HD.HOHHoro PHT-
Ma B <plIrype OJIeHIl C nO)l,OrHYThiMH HD-
ra m - O)l,Horo H3 OCHOBHbIX MOTHBOB
paHHecKII<pcKOrO 3BepHHoro CTllJIIl-
lIall60JIee nOJIHO OTpa3H.'IOCb B 3HaMe-
IIJ1TOM Ky.'1b06cKOM OJIeHe 36.
TaKJKe HeeCTec'l'BeHHbI H OCTaJIbHhie
I1306paJKeIIHII IfJIbH'IeBCKOll nJIaCTBHhi.
XIIIIJ.HHK, CYM no aTpIl6YTaM,- <popMe
yxa H rpHBe - H306pamaIDIIJ.HB: JIbBa,
CKopee HanOMHHaeT BOJIKa. HeeCTeCT-
BellHa H n03a 3Men, y KOTOpOll TlIJ.a-
Te.lbHO nepe):laHa 'Iernyll. TaIDRe p;e-
Ta:rbHO H306pameHO onepeHHe opJIa, KO-
TOpbIll CJIHIIIKOM CTarn'IeH, HeCMOTpll
Ha TO, 'ITO aBTOp npe)l,Ha3Ha'IHJI eMY
"ep3aTb Kpyn OJIeHIl. If BOO 61IJ. e, KpOMe
3MeH, )l,eHCTBHe Koropoii nOp;'IepKHBaeT
OCKaJI 3y60B H JKaJIo, Bce mHBoTHble,
Jl306paJKeHHbIe n3 9TOll nJIaCTllHe, Bhif-
.'1f1)1,IIT )l,OBOJIbHO 6e3pa3JIH'IHblMH K npo-
I1Cxo)Ulll\eMY Tep3aHHID. HeCOMHeHHO,
'ITO BCII KOMn03HD.HIl KOJI'IaHHOB: nJIa-
CTlllIhi BbIllOJIHeHa Ha BbICOKOM TeXHH-
'IeCKOM ypoBHe. O):lHaKO B CIDmeTHO-
CTIIJIHCTH'IeCKOM OTlIomenHH OHa errOBT
rOpa3)1,O mIJKe MHOfHX 06pa3D.OB 3Bepn-
Horo CTHJIII npe)l,IIIeCTBYIDIIJ;,ell nopbl.
C IeHa CIDJKeTOB H u306pa3HTeJIbHOH
"aJlepbI B I1CKYCCTBe CKII<pHH Ha Py6e-
:+it' VI - V BB. ):10 H. 9. 6hiJIa BhI3BaHa
IICTOpll'IeO;Oll cHTyau;uell, CJIOJKHBmeB:-
CR I{ 3TOMY BpeMeIlH B CeBepHOM TIpH-
tlC'pilOMopbe.
HTaK, KpbIMCKl!e HaXO)l,KH n03BOJIII-
lOT nOKa3aTb oc06eHlIOCTH CKH<pCKoro
,lHepHHoro CTlI.'I1I B VII- VI BB. H VI-
\. BB. )1,0 H. 9. Ec.111 ):I.1fI nepBoro nepH-
op;a MomHO rOBopUTb 0 c06cTBeHHo
CKB<pCKOM BCKYCCTBe B ero p;OCTaTO'IHO
'lHCTOM BHp;e, TO C KOIIu;a VI B. p;o H. 9.
IlCHO npOCJIeJKIIBaeTCIl ero TpaHC<pOp-
MaU;HIl, npOHCXO)l,UBlUall no)l, BHeIIIHHM
B03p;ellCTBHeM. Onpe)l,eJIlllOLD;lIM B 9TOM
npou;ecce 6b1JIO BJIUIIHlle IICKYCCTBa aH-
TH'IHOra MlIpa, oc06eHHO B CBII3H C TeM,
'ITO MaCCOBoe npOll3BO)l,CTBO YKpaIIIe-
HBH. 3BepBHoro CTRJIfI, BII)I,RMO, nepexo-
P;HT B 91'0 BpeMII K fpe'IeCKHM MaCTep-
CKlIM. Y Hac HeT OCHOBaHIIn COMHeBaTb-
CII B npOHCXOJK)I,eHlI11 OOJIbIlIHHCTBa XY-
p;omeCTBeHIfbIX 6POH3, 30.10ThlX YKpa-
meHHll, napa)l,Horo 0PYJKIIII H T. 11:.-
OHB BblIIIJIH H3 ropo)l,OB Bocnopa. .D:e-
'l"aJIbHOe HCCJIe)l,OBaHIIe 9Toro npOH3BOp;-
CTBa - p;eJIO 6y)l,yLD;ero.
8JIJIHHH3aD.HfI 3BepIlHoro CTHJIIl, Ha-
6JIIDp;aeMall B KOHu;e CKH<pCKOll apxaHKH,
n06YP;HJIa B. A. HJIbHHCKYID npe,lI,JlO-
mHTb ,lI,JI1l Hero C V B. p;o H. 9. HOBblB:
TepMHH - «(rpeKO-CKlI<pCKoe BCKYCCT-
BO» 37. Ha,M KaJKeTCII, 'ITO TaKoe Ha3Ba-
HHe HeCKOJIbKO CYJKaCT paMKH ropa3p;0
60JIee IIIHpOKoro IIBJIeIllI1I (0 'IeM Heop;-
HOKpa, HO IIHCaJia ca Ia B. A. IfJIbHH-
CKall) 38.
B 91'01' nepHO):l, "pOMe rpe'IeCKOrO,
6hiJiH )l,OBOJIbHO CIIJIbJlbI )l,pyrHe BJiHIl-
HI1I1: C 3ana):la - CTPYII <ppaKHB:CKOrO
HCKYCCTBa 39, a C BOCTOKa - BJIlIlIHHe
HCKYCCTBa HapO)l,OB CII6HpH H AJiTall;
O'IeHb 3IIa'IJlTe.1bHbn! CTaHOBIiTCII H
BKJIa):l ceBepllbIX napO)l,OB - 06HTaTe-
JIell JIeCHOll II .1eCO-CTenHOll 30H. IfM
3BepHHbill CTII.'1b oOfl:Jan 06pa3aMH BOJI-
Ka H Me)l,BeAII. IT03TOMY onpe)l,eJIeHHe
«rpeKO-CKII<pCKoe I1CI;YCCTBO», OXBaThi-
BaIDlIJ.ee TO.'lbI;O !\B<1 COCTaBHhiX ero
KOMnOHeHTa, He COBCC 1 TO'IHO. MOJKeT
6bITb, TepMIIiI «3RepIlIlbIii CTIWb CeBep-
Hora TIpH'Iep;'mlOpbIl ') OKaJKeTCII 60JIee
yp;a'IHbIM.
· A. A. lIJ,cnullC/'wii. IIorpe6cHIte uaqaJIa
mCJIe3HOrO BeJ;a y Cm'<pcpono.'1J1. KCHA,
BbIII. 12, 1962, CTp. ';,7. '
Z OAK aa 1870-71 rr., CTp. XX-XXI; 1If. H.
Apra.woHoB. K BOIIPOCY 0 npollcxomAeHlIII
CKII<pCKOro IICJ;yccTBa. Omagill lui Geor-
ge Operscm. Bucuresti, 1961; B. A. H..b-
UHc"aR. HeKoTopble MOTIIBbI paHHeCJ;II<p-
CKOro aBeplIllOro CTlliIlI. CA, 1965, .N2 1,
CTp. 102.
3 H. A. CuBopoBa. ApXaIIqeCKali J;epaMIiKa
lIa IIaHTIiRaneJl. MIlA, .N2 103, 1962, CTp.
95-97.
M. H. Apro.1IolloB. YJ;a3. COq., CTp. 42-46.
B. A. [.uillcb"a. CJ;i<pcbKa BY3Aa VI CT.
AO H. 3. ApxeOiIoriJl», T. XIII, 1961.
8 B. A. H"bUHc"aR. KYJIbTOBbIe meaJlbl
CKII<pCKoro II npeACJ;II<pCl<oro BpeMeHIl.
MHA, .N2 130, 1965, CTp. 209-211.
7 J1I06eaHali IIH<popMa 1I11 B. A. I1iIbIIHCKOII.
8 C. H. U H. M. PyBCH"O. HC',YCCTBO Clm<poB
AJITali. M., 1949, Ta6JI. VII I.
· B. A. H"bUHC"OR. 06paa KOmaqberO XII -
HIiKa B paHHecIm<pcKoM nCJ;YCCTBe. CA,
1971, .N2 2, CTp. 72-75.
.0 H. 11.. Map'lcll"o. J1nTeHHaJi (pOpMa KOH a
VI B. AO H. ;). 113 IIaIITIIKaIIeH. KCHA,
BblII. 89, 1962, CTp. 51.
\I E. O. Up YWCBc"aR. POAoccI,aJl Ba3a II
6poH30Bble Be 1I 1I3 MorlliIhI "a TaMaH-
CKOM IIOJIYOCTpOBe. IIAK, RbIIT. 63, 1917,
CTp. 48.
12 OAK 3a 1895 1'., CTp. 17-18.
13 G. Borovka. Scythian Art. London, 1928,
p.95.
U M. H. ApraMoHoB. COI;pORIIII\a CKII<pCKIIX
KypraHoB. IIpara.- J1., 1966, CTp. 30.
15 T. H. Tpoulf"aR. CHII<pcKIIe J;ypraHbI B
KpbIMY. HKOBfO, CUM<PPPO!!OiIb, 1951,
CTp. 68.
18 B. A. H..bUIlC"OR. CKII<p..I :1IIPnpOBcKoro
JIeCOCTenHoro J1eRooepembH. KneR, 1968,
CTp. 155, Taoil. XI, 13.
17 P. Rau. Die Griiber der friihen Eisenzeit
im Unteren Wolgagebipt. Pokrowsk, 1929,
Tar. V.
18 9. B. n"OBCH"O. KJI"'J;I1 C 300 lOp<pHbIMIi
lIa06pameHIIJI III. CA, 1964, M 4. CTp. 205-
207.
136
19 M. H. AprOMoHoB. COKpOBII a..., CTp. 30.
20 «ApxeoJIorili YKpaiHcbKoi PCP., T. I I.
KniB, 1971, CTp. 165, pIlC. 47, 5; CTp. 145,
pilC. 38, 1.
21 M. N. ApraM01l0B. COKpOBn a..., Ta6JI. 18,
31, 58 II AP.
22 B. A. H"buHc"aR. Oopaa KOmaqberO XII -
mma..., CTp. 83.
23 M. If. ApraMoHoB. COKpoBII a.., CTp. 34,
pliC. 60.
2< C. H. PyBCH"O. KYJIbTypa HaCeJIeHlI1I rop-
Horo AJITali B CKII<pCKoe BpeMIi. M.- J1.,
1953, m6JI. LXII, 2.
25 H. /1. g ..CHOBO. IIPOlIcxomAeUIIe II paH-
UIIII IICTOpll1i IIJIeMeH TarapCKOII KYJlbTY-
pLi. M., 1967, Ta6JI. 17,1-3.
26 OAK 3a 1892 r. XpaHlITcli B foc. 3pMII-
Tame, IIHB. M Kp. 1892 3/4.
27 9. B. n"OBCH"O. RnIOKIi C aooMop<pHblMIi
lIa06pameHIIIIMII, CTp. 204, pliC. 1.
28 XpaHIlTCIi B foc. 3pMIITame, IIHB. .N2 Kp.
1885, 1/5.
29 M. H. ApraMoHoB. COKpOBII a CKII<pCKIIX
KypraHoB, Ta6JI. 70, 72.
30 H. /1. rpa'l. J1bBIiHali rOJIOBKa "3 paCKO-
nOK MlipMeKIIII. Cf3, Bbln. XX. J1., 1961.
31 K. (/J. CMUpHOB. CaBpOMaTbi. M., 1964,
pliC. 11 B, 31.
32 M. H. ApraMoHoB. COKpOBII a CKII<pCImx
KypraHoB, m6JI. 73-75.
33 B. A. H..bUHCMR. 06paa KOmaqbPrO XII -
HIIKa.., CTp. 81-83.
.. A. H. 3oepatfi. AeHem.u:oe 06pa eHlle II
MOHeTHoe AeJIO CeBepHoro IIpIlqepHO-
MOpbli. ArCII, 1958, CTp. 150, 151, pliC. 4,5.
3. A. M. /1CC"OB. BoraToe CKII<pCKoe IIorpe6e-
Hile lIa BOCTOqHOro RpLIMa. CA, 1968, oM 1.
36 M. H. ApraMoHoB. KYJIb06CKHII OJIeHL.
AHKCII, 1968.
37 «ApxeoJIorili YKpaiHcbKoi PCP», T. II,
CTp. 166.
38 B. A. HAbUHc"aR. HeKOTopbIe MOTIIBbI
paHHCCRll<pCIIOro 3BepilHoro CTIfJIIi. CA,
1965, .N2 1; OHa xc. 06paa KOma%ero XII -
HIIKa...
39 A. H. MC"IO"oBa. K BOIlPOCY 0 R3aIIMOCBII-
311X CKII<pCKOro II <ppaKIIIICKoro IICKYCCTRa.
Te3I1CbI J!oKJIaAOB Ha ceCCIiH HA AH
CCCP R 1970 1'.. T611JIliCII, 1971.
rrOCTO;JbKY Ha OCHOBe <lTHorpaqmqeCKHX
me AaIIIU>lX nYTeM peTpocneKTHBHoro
ana;1II3a rrpeACTaBJUIIDTCH IDHpOKlle
B03 wmHOCTH AJUI: H3)"1eHHH TaKHX
CTYllelleii rrepB06bITHOro 06 ecTBa, KO-
TOpbIe <PHKCHPYIDTCH TOJIbKO Ha OCHOBe
MaTcpna.TJbHOii KYJlbTypbI.
B ;)TOM IIRa!!e, HaM rrpe CTaBJIlIeTCH,
c,leAyeT rroAoihH H K paccMoTpeHHIO
IIPOO;WMbI B03HIIKilOBeHHII H pa3BHTHII
aoo lOp<pIIoro HCKyccTBa H rrp06JIeMbT
CKllqJO-CHI'JHPCKOro 3BepHHoro CTHJIII.
13 iIOCOBCTCKHll: II cOBeTcKliH rreplioAbI
110 npoo.1lCMC Clm<p0-CII6I1pCKOrO 3BepH-
Horo CTUJlH B HaYKe CJlomHJIOCb, rrpIl-
ICpIlO, TPIl narrpaBJleilIlH: 1). TIepBoe
113npan.'lelIlIe paccMaTpIIBaeT rrpoIlc-
xom).(ellIle CKII<pcKoro :mepHHoro CTIIJlH
KaK peay.1JbTaT rrpoIlliKHoBeHIIII H BJIIIH-
IIIIH rpelW-1I0HUiicKoro H rrepeAHea3I1-
aTCKoro 1I306pa3I1TeJlbHOrO I1CKYCCTBa.
0110 Obl.lO BbI).(BliHYTO e e M. If. Poc-
TOBUCBblM II AO rrOCJleAHerO BpeMeHH
1I0:I.lC'pmHBa.lOCL M. If. ApTaMoHoBbI l,
K010pbIii XOTH II rrpIl311aBaJI <pOpMIIpO-
Baillie JeCTlIbIX <pOpM :mepuHoro CTIIJlJI
1I0:! HIlPlUnU 1 B.1UIIHlIeM, JIO III' Aorry!;-
l;n.1 BO:JMOmHOCTil I1X caMOCTOHTeJlbHOrO
pi1\1II1TIIH B (IIpc).(lliecTRYlo ce BpeMH.
2). BTopoe IIPrrpaBJIenlle HC XOAII.'IO R;J
T"I ". 'ITO Ch-fI<pO-CIIOHpClmii 3BepllHbIll
nlili. B03rrIlK H3 6a3e KOqeBOrO X03Hll-
nl<,\ 113 lliIIpOKOll TeppllTopllii CTerrell:
hll':UIIII II paCCMaTpIIBaJIOCb KaK e)I,II-
111.11" CTlI.lb 6e3 rrOlIblTfiH Bbqe.1IlTb B
11"\1 hi1KlIe-JIII60 .10fia.lbHblC BapIlaHTbI.
OHO 6bIJIO BLI lBliHYTO C. If. PYAeHKO.
qaCTlIqIlO K I1eMY rrpliMbIKaJl B. H. fpa-
KOB, rrOCKO;[hfiY. IIO ero MHeHIIIO, CRH<pO-
cII6I1pnmii :meplllIbItl CTliJIb IIMeeT 00-
YIO OCIIOBY IlpOllcxomAeHIIH 113 u;eIIT-
paJlLHoii A3I1I1. MI,l rOBopHM «qaCTHq-
HO» rrOTOMY, qTO, rro B. H. fpaKoBY II
MHorIIM APyrn I IIcc.lIeAOBaTeJlHM, npo-
Hc.xomAeIlIIC 3BepHHoro CTHJlH CBH3ano
r.1J3BlIbIM oopa30M C pa3BHTlieM JlOKaJlL.
HbIX oc06eHnocTeii CKH<p0-CII6HpcKoro
3BeplIHoro CTll.lIlI.
3) HaKoHeu;, TpeTbe HarrpaBJleHIIe B
I13yqeHlIn nCTopIlli I1306pa3HTeJIbHOrO
HCKYCCTBi\ nCXOAIIT II3 pa3BIITliH npem-
Ae Bcero MeCTHbIX <lJleMeHTOB I1306pa-
menuii milBOTHbIX, XOTII He OTpIlu;aeT
U Ha.1Uqlle I! HeM BHeIDHHX BJIIIHHIIH R
npouliKilOBenIIH HpKO BbIpameHHblX
qyme3eMHbIX <I.leMeHTOB. MeCTHble <lJle-
MeHTbI 11306pa31!TeJlbIlOrO I1CKYCCTBa
CBOIIMIl KOpIlHMIl YXO)I)lT B 3rroxy 6pOH-
3bI II ellle 60Jlee lllllpOKO rrpOHB.lHlOTCH
B 3rroxy neO.lIlTa. TaKoe HarrpaBJleHlle
IIOA!!epiKlIBaJIOCb <1>. f. BOpOBKOll II
11.. It 3l1.I1HrOM OTHOCI1TeJlbHO UCKYCCT-
Ba Cu611pn n BOCTOqHOll EBporrbI,
E. H. M1l1I/l30M II C. B. RIICeJleBbIM-
OTiIOCIITe.lbIlO I1306pa3HTeJIbHOrO HC-
KYCCTBa CII611 pII. 3a rrOCJleAHUe ro)!.bl
<lTO HarrpaBJleHlIe rroMepmHBaeTcH Bce
60JlblllIlM '!lIC.lOM COBeTCKHX I1CCJIeAOBa-
TeJlerl (H. H. TIorpe60Ba, R. <1>. CMIIP-
1I0B. C. C. LICpllUKOB HAP.).
TaKIIM o6pa30M, eCJlII rrepBoe II BTO-
pOI' HalIpaB.lelllfH He BII)I)lT MeCTHbIX
IICTOfiOB 1I306pameHlIH mliBOTHbIX, AaB-
llillX HonyIO <PopMY B BH)!.e 3BepilHoro
CTlJ.TIfI B :moxy paHHero meJle a, TO
TpeTLe HanpaB.leUIIe I1CTOqHIIKOM HOBbIX
<pOp 1 1I:!OopameHIIll mliBOTHblX IIpeA-
IIo:taraCT u:!06pameHIIH mUBOTHbIX
IIpeiIIlleCTBYlOlIleii 3rrOXII. TpeTbe Ha-
IIpaB.Wlllle lie OTBepraeT TaKme II rrpo-
HlI i>HOBeJlIlH qymeaeMHbIX 3.le IeHTOB
3BCp1l1l01"(1 CTII.HI B MeeTHYIO epeAY
CKWPC i>orli lUpa Hero oKpymeHIIH,
IIOC i>O.lbl; 0110 AOCTaTOqHO oqeBH).(HO.
n. l1.. JIu6epoB
JIORAJIbHbIE OCOBEHHOCTI1 3BEPI1HOrO CTHJI.R
CPE HE OHCROll RYJIbTYFbI
H OTP AmEHI1E CB.R3Ell C BHEIIIHI1M MHPOM
Ib06pameIIIIH iKHBOTHbIX npOIDJIH
AJlIITe.lbHbIll II CJlOmIIbIll nYTb I1CTOpH-
iJ:ecKoro pa3BIITliH. B nepBOHa'laJIbHOii
<popMe OIlli B03HIIKaIOT Ha 6a3e TOTeMH-
CTllqCClmx IIpe)!.cTaBJleHIIll BMeCTe C
B0311IlKHOBeHIIeM pOAa H pa3BHBaIDTCH B
npou;ecce pa3BIITIIH pOAO-nJIeMeHIIbIX
OTHOllieUllll BrrJIOTb AO nOCJIeAHero 3TII-
na rrepB06bITH006 HHHoro CTpOII. TIo-
:JTOMY MomHO CKa3aTb, qTO TaK me KaK
Bce qeJIOBeqeCTBO npOIDJIO qepe3 3TY
<POPMY 06llI,eCTBeHHoro pa3BIITIIII, TaK
H TOTe lI!qeCI;lIe rrpeACraBJIeHHII, KaK
<popMa lIAeOJIOrHlI rrepB06bITHOrO 06u e-
CTBa HeU36emHO conYTCTBOBaJlIl ero
pa3BIITlilO. TOTeMoM pOAa CqIlTa.lCH
0AIIR 113 BIIAOB IKHBOTHbIX, peme pacTe-
Hlill I1JIII HBJleHHH npIlpo)!.bI. B Ka'lC-
CTBe pO OHaqaJlbHHKa pOAa 11.1111 rpyrrlILI
JIIOAeii OH 6bIJI 1'1'0 P;PyroM II 3a HTHII-
KO I II COOTBeTCTJleHHO rrOqIlTaJlCII: II
060mccT BJlH,lCH.
B IIpou;ecce pa3BIITIIH IIepBofiblTllOrO
06l1\ccTBa pa:3BIIBaJlOCb II MllpOB03:3pC'-
RIle :IIO)!.ell'- I1AeoJlorHR, pemlrll0311bIc
npeACTaBJleHIIH II TOTeM l..:aI": IIepBOHa-
'Ia.lbnaH <pop la HAeoJIOnm; Ha nOC.lel1-
HeM ;narre cy ecTBoBaHIIH IIcpB06b1T-
Horo 06llI,eCTBa TOTeM IIpilIlIUla.l aHTpo-
rrOMOP<PHYID <POPMY, rAe po).(onaqa.1I,-
HHfiO I pOAOBOH rpyrrrrbI CTaHOBlL"lCfI
npeAOI..:-qe.lOBeK. If rrOCIW.lbKY lIIoro-
'UlC.lIeHIIble rrpliMepbl 3THorpac"(JIlI!
nOKa3bIBaIOT HepaBHOMepHOCTb 06llI,rCT-
BeHHoro, JKOHOMII'IeCfiOrO II fiy.1LTypno-
ro pa:JBIITllfI IIepB06bITIloro OOUlrCTB:1.
138
3TII 'l)'iKe3eMHbIe <lJIeMeHTbI IIml BOC-
IIpUHIIMaJlHCb B TOM me BII)!.e, IIJIII CBoe-
06pa3I10 nepepa6aTbIBaJllICb rrplIMeHH-
TeJl bHO }{ MeCTHblM YCJlOBJlIIM. OAIIaKO
TPY)!.IlO rrpe)!.cTaBHTb, qT06bI BOCII plIHT'lIe
'lyme3eMHblx <lJleMeHTOB II IIX IIepepa-
60TKa 6bIJIR 6bI B03MOiKIJI,I 61'3 )!.JIIITem.-
Horo rrYTH pa3BHTliH MeCTHoro IICKYC-
CTBa B BHAe H306pameHIIii mIlBOTHbIX.
Ha060poT, CJle)!.yeT rrpeAlIo.lIOmIITb, 'ITO
HCKYCCTBO I1306pameHilii mIlBOTlIbIX B
CTOJlb Hpl\O BbIpameHHon .lOi..:a.lblloH
<popMe, KaKoe MbI Ha6mo;:J.aeM y reCT-
Horo HaCeJleHIIH CII6IIpn II BOCTOqHOH
EBporrbI B 3rroxy paHHero meJIP:!a, I1Me-
JIO CBOID rrpep;bIcTopliID II 6bl.lO Bb13Ba-
HO HOBbIM YPoBHeM pa3BIITilfI laTepll-
aJIbHOii H l\YXOBIIon JRJI3HII 06mecTBa.
Yme B CTaTbe «TIpoIlcxo£i":;:J.eHHe
CKII<pCKoro HCKycCTBa» M. H. A pTaMo-
ROB crrpaBeAJlHBO YKa3a.l 113 un 1I00Jlee
paHHHe npe;D;MeTbI, HallAeHIIble B CeBep-
HOM TIpIl'lepHOMOpbe, KOTOpbll' Hil rro
(popMe (pe3wa no KOCTII) " IIII IIO BII-
AaM I1306pamaeMbIX mllBoTHbIX (JIOCb,
OJIeHb, K03eJI. 6apaH, HTIIu;a). IIII TeM
60JIee XpOHOJlOrnqeCKH He COOTBeTCTBY-
lOT nOHBJIeHIIID Ha TeppliTopllIl CJ..:II<pIIH
rrepeWIea3I1aTCKHX 3J1eMeIlTOB I1Ch-YCCT-
Ba. TIpIl3HaB HX rrOHBJlellllC no BpeMfI,
rrpeAllieCTBYIO ee B03BpaU\eIlllliJ CKII-
<pOB 113 TIepeAHell A3IIII II Enpolly z,
M. If. ApTaMOHOB 06'bHCHIIJI ClTOT <paKT
TeM, qTO OHII rrOlIaJlIl CIO!!a ILl TIepeA-
Hell A3I1H OT rrepe;J:llea:UlaTCJ;\lX Cl":I1-
<pOB, KOTopbIe YCBOII,lII Ta [ XY:lomCCT.J
HeII1!bIe CIDmeTbI If cpOpMLl 'j. I'd.l ' feeT-
CH, HeT HHKaKliX ,ITOl\a:JaTr:lhC [1\. onpo-
BepraIOrn;IIX CBH311 MemiIY .110.1bMII,
YIDeAIllIIMi! B TIepe;:I.HIOIO .'\3111" II OCTaB-
llIHMIICH B CKII<pIIII, a C:IC.10H,ITr,lbIl0,
H B03MomIlOCTII npUBIIeCPIIlln ,\, .10me-
CTBeHHbIX CIOmeTOB II <poP [ IL1 Ilepel1.-
Rell A3IIlI, KaK HeT II OOpaT\lI.\' ;I.Ofia-
3aTe.lbCTB, KOTopbIe onpol!C'/,' ,un ObI
MeCTHoe IIX IIpOIlexom/H'IIJ1(' (J [II a KO K
TO ry, qTO yme YKa3aHO :\1. I r. . \ pTaMO-
HOBblM B KaqeCTBe rrpeAnO:tilrHI' I"IX Me-
139
CTHbfX !f>OPM 11306pameHIIH mIiBOTHLlX
Ha pe3HOii KOCTH II B TOM lfllCJIC Ha KO-
CTJIHblX llJlaCTlIHaX 113 KypraHa 2 Y
c. ma60THHo, MomHO A06aBIITb rrpe-
RpacHYIO KOCTJIHYIO IIJlaCTIiHY C pe3HLlM
H306pameHlleM 9 OJIeHeH II 1 XII HIIKa
Romalfbeii rropoll;bl, HallAeHHYIO B rrorpe-
6eHIIH Ha rrOCeJIeHIIII Y rop. KOHcTaH-
TIIHOBCK '. ABTOp pacKorrOK AaTIfpyeT
aTO rrorpe6eHUe VIII-VII IIJIII, MomeT
6blTb, VII BB. AO H. a.\ 'lTO OTHOCIITCJI
R 60JIee paHHeMY BpeMeHlI, 'leM rroxOII;
CKII!f>OB B fIepeAHIOIO A311IO, orrllcaH-
HLIH repoll;oToM.
,n:. H. 3)J;HHr BLlCKa3bIBaJI B03Mom-
HyIO CBJI3b CRH!f>0-cII6I1pcKoro 3BepIlHO-
ro CTHJIH EBpa3HII C 11306pameHIIJIMH
mliBOTHbiX JIeCHLlX paHoHoB BOCrolfHOH
EBporrbf II On611pll B BlIAe JIIITLIX rrpe)];-
MeTOB 113 6pOH3L1 (ceii:MIIHcKHH KIIH-
maJI C JIoma,!l;b'M1i II ryp611HCKHH Hom
C 6apaHaMH) 6 H3 pe3Horo lI;epeBa (rop-
6ynoBCKaJI II llIlIrllpClmH CTOJIHIill).
C. B. KiH{;eJIeB BlIII;eJI CBJI3b 11306pame-
HUii: mliBOTHLlX 3rroxli rr0311;Heii: 6pOH3L1
(RapaCYKCKaJI KYJIbTypa) C Jlloxoii: paH-
Hero meJIe3a (TarapCKaJI I{YJIbTypa)'.
B pe3YJIbTaTe pa60T l.J:e60KcapCKOH
HOBOCTpOe'lHoii: 3KCrre)J;HD;1l1l OTKpLlTa
npeRpaCHaJI KOCTJIHaJI 1'O.1JOHKa JIOCJI,
HCnOJIbsyeMaJI, BepOJITHO, B KalfeCTBe
HaBepmllJI, KOTOpaJI AaTllpYCTCJI IICCJIe-
)];OBaTeJIJIMIi paHIfeii: ;moxoll 6pOH3bl
(III-II BB. AO H. <J.) 8. B c.1Joe 3rrOXH
lI03)J;Hell 6pOH3bl AJIahcl\Oii rre epLl
fIe'lepCKOro KpaH Haii: eIl() 1I306pame-
HIll' 3MOII Ha HOCTHIIml rrlJl' MeTe 9.
B pe3YJIbTaTe pa60Tbf BepXHeBOJIm-
CKOR 3KcrrCAUD;IlII I\PPMHPBhIe Ii KOCTJI-
Hble !f>nrYPKIl rrT 1Il\ , II300pamaIOID;He
TeTepHY, YTKY, ryCH II :1p.. !laii.'reHbl Ha
BOJIOCOBCKOM rroce.1JeIllIlI (,CTpe.'IHa» Y
,n:ep. PbI6I1HO, fIaJIexo;oro p-Ha, lIBa-
HOBCI;oII 06.TJaCTIl 10. <1>llrYPhlI MeABeM,
pLl6b1, rrTIID;, 3Mell, Hai1."\l'I1HbIC Ha
rrOceJIe !III II CaxTbIm I Toii ;({(' 06.'lacTII,
'OTHOCHTCH KO BpeMPlII1 I1O.\;lllerO Heo-
..TJIITa II paHHell 6pOH:Jbl ".
CpeAIi pJIAa HpeMHeBLlX, rJIIIHJIHLlX II
KOCTJIHbIX !f>lIryPOK 113 rraMJITIIrIlKOB Bo-
CTO'lHOII EBporrbl C. B. CTY)];311D;RaJI
rrpIlBO)J;HT rJIIIHJIHyIO !f>HryJ>RY Me)J;Be-
mOHKa H KOCTJIHYIO !f>lIryPKY 606pa 113
BaJIMCKoii: CTOJIHKII, KOTopLle, rro orrpe-
AeJIeHllIO IICCJIeIl;OBaTeJIJI, 6L1JIII CTIIJI:H-
CTrr'leCKIi 6JIII3KII 11306pameHUJIM !f>lIry-
pOK C BOJIOCOBCKOH CTOJIIIRII 12.
TaKoB AaJIeKO He rrOJII1bIii pJI)]; Haxo-
AOK 11306pameHIIH mHBOTHLlX IIpe e-
CTByIO ell: 3rroXll. He lIpHXO)J;HTCJI COM-
HeBaTbCJI B TOM, 'lTO HX ROJIHlfeCTBO II
KalfeCTBO 6L1JIO 6L1 ropaaAO BbIIIIe, eCJIH
6L1 lIpllpO)J;HLle YCJIOBHH 6LIJIH 6JIaro-
lIpliJITHLlMIi )];JIJI coxpaHeHHH H306pa-
meHIIH Ha )];epeBe, no IIpll"Mepy rop6y-
HOBCKOH II llIlITHpCKOH CTOJIHOK llJIH
AJITaHCKlix RypraHOB.
OTCYTcTBlie pe3Horo )];epeBa - OAHa
113 caMLlX BamHLlX eCTeCTBeHHLlX rrpll-
lfliH cy eCTBYIO ero XpOHOJIOrnlfeCKO-
ro pa3pLlBa MemAY H306pameHIIJIMli
mHBOTHhIX 3rrOXH 6pOH3L1 II paHHero
meJIe3a.
BTOpaJI lIplllfliHa pa3pLIBa, rrO-BII)J;H-
MOMY, 3aKJIIOlfaeTCH B HC CCTBeHHOM
y)];peBHeHHII apXeOJIOrlilfeCIillX lIaMJIT-
HIIKOB. TaK, HalIpHMep, lIO O. H. Ba)];e-
py YKa3aHHLle CeHMHHCRo-Typ6HHcKHe
na'MJITHllIill )];aTHpYIOTCH XVI -XIV BB.
AO H. 3. 13 , TOr)];a RaR no C. B. RHceJIeBY
OHII OTHOCJITCH K XII B )];0 H. 3. u . fIoc-
JIe)];HJIJI lI;aTa, RaR HaM RameTCJI, 6JIlime
K HCTHHe. TaKHM 06pa30M KamY IIHCJI
60JIbmOH pa3pLlB Mem,n;y rraMJITHIiKaMIi
3lIOXli 6pOH3L1 II paHHero meJIe3a COKpa-
aeTCJI Ha pJI)]; BeROB. O)J;HaKO IIpH pe-
meHRII Borrpoca 0 lIplI'IHHaX pa3pbIBa
MemAY 11306pa3l1TeJIbHbIM IICHYCCTBOM
3rrOXli 6pOH3bl H paHHero meJIe3a Ha
Cpe)1;HeM ,l],oh II, BepoJITHO, Ha II;Pyrux
TepPRTOpllJIX;CJIell;yeT yqecTb HeKOTO-
pLle oc06eHHOCTli TeppliTopllll CpeAHe-
ro ,l],oHa. OHII CBOMTCJI K CJIeIl;YIO eMY:
1. Ha Cpe)J;HeM ,n:oHy He 113BeCTHbl
IICTOlfHIIKH Mell;lI II 6POH3bl, 'lTO rrOAT-
BepmAaeTCJI cpaBHHTe.TJbHO MaJIbfM KO-
JIIIlfeCTBOM MeAHblx II 6pOH30BLlX H3)];e-
Jlllii: B 3rroxy 6pOH3L1 B. TaKIiX KYJIbTY-
pax, KaK KaTaKO'M6HaJI, cPy6HaJI II
a6ameBCKaJI, mlipORO pacrrpOCTpaHeH-
HblX I1a TeppliTopllH TIOII;OHbJI.
2. lICrrOJIb30BaHlie 113I1;eJIIiH 113 lI;epe-
Ba II, COOTBeTCTBeHHO, pe3b6L1 rro lI;epeBY
B arroxy 6poH3L1 B fIOII;OHbe II;OKa3L1-
BaeTCJI HaJIll'llieM lI;epeBJIHHOH rrocYALI,
rrpCCJIemliBaeMoii: rro OCTaBmllMCJI Me)];-
HLIM llJIIi 6pOH30BblM rrJIaCTHHaM, CJIy-
mllBmllM OKOBKOH 15. fIoA06HaJI rrocy)];a
IICrrOJIb30BaJIaCb e e mllpe B 3rroxy
paHHero meJIe3HorO BeKa, CYII;JI rro MHO-
rO'lllCJIeHHLlM OCTaTKaM 30JIOTLlX, ce-
pe6pJIHLlX H 6pOH30BLlX OKOBOK, a TaR-
me rro IIIHPOK8MY pacrrpocTpaHeHHIO
rrpeKpacHLlx IIITaMrrOBaHHLlX Be eii: Ha
6a3e pe3b6L1 rro AepeBY II KOCTH. fIoc-
JIell;Hee, lIO-BIIJl.lIMOMY, YXOJI.IIT CBOIIMII
KOpHJIMIi B arroxy 6pOH3L1. B rrpoTIIBHOM
cnyqae TpYII;HO rrpe)];CTaBHTb CTOJIb BLI-
COKIIH ypoBeHb 1I306pa3HTeJIbHoro HC-
RyccTBa B alloxy paHHero meJIe3a Ha
TeppliTopliH EBpa3lIH, II B TOM 'lllCJIe
Ha ,l],oHy.
HeT He06xo)];IIMOCTH OCTaHaBJIHBaTb-
CJI Ha pa3BepHYTOH xapaKTepliCTHRe JIO-
RaJIbHbIX oc06eHHocreH H306pa3HTeJIb-
Hora IICKyCCTBa Ha ,l],OHY H rrpomlliHO-
BeHIIJI lfyme3eMHbIX 3JIeMeHTOB B MeeT-
HyIO cpe,n;y, rrOCKOJIbKY OHa lI;aHa B
Hamell AliccepTaD;IIH H orry6JIliHOBaHa
B aBTope!f>epaTe 18.
3aAa'la HaCTOJIll\ero 1I;0KJIall;a CBO-
II;IITCJI JIlimb K rroKa3y OCHOBHLlX 'lepT
C Te I, 'lTo6L1 paCCMOTpeTb HX JIa !f>OHe
<JTHorpa!f>II'leCKlIX rrapaJIJIeJIeH II rrOCTa-
BIITb 11306pameHIIJI /KHBOTHLIX fIOII;OHbJI
B orrpe,ll;eJIeHBYIO IICTopHlfeCKyIO 3aBH-
CIiMOCTb. Hamil IICCJIell;OBaHHJI rrOKa3L1-
BaIOT, 'lTO:
1). 3BepllHblii CTIiJIb fIO,ll;OHbH 06-
.1a,D;aeT He TO.TJbKO JIpKO BbfpameHHblMIl
JIOKaJIbHLlMH rrpll3HaKaMH, HO H 3Ha-
'lIlTe;:JbHoii: rrpIIMeCbIO lfyme3eMHblX 3JIe-
MeHTOB (113 fIepeAHeH A31111 H aHTH'lHO-
ro Mllpa), KOTopble HMeIOT pJIII; aHa:'IO-
140
rliH B CHII!f>CKOM Mllpe (1I306pameHIIJI
rraHTep, JIbBOB, Op.'1I1HbfX II JIbBIIHbl!1.
rpII!f>OHOB II lIX repaJIb)J;HlfeCKOe pacrro-
JlOmeHlle; 11306pameHlIJI oJIeHeii, CTll-
.'1113aD;IlJI OTAC.ll,lIbIX 'laCTeii: mllBOTHblX
II II;P');
2). CBoe06pa311e II .'10KaJIbHbfe oco-
6eHHOCTlI 3BepIIHoro CTIIJIJI fIOII;OHbJI
3aKJIIO'laIOTCH II B TOM, 'lTO 60;:JbmIlH-
CTBO Ii306pameIlllii mliBOTHLlX OTpama-
eT MeCTlIYIO !f>aYHY (Me)];Be)JJ>, Ka6aH,
BOJIK, O.leHb-JIOCb, .10mall;b 6apaH, c06a-
Ka, 3aHD;, rrTlIl\a, pbI6a II II;P'), XOTJI ill B
CTHJIII30BaHHOM HIlAe. B 3TOM OTHome-
HIIII oc06eHHo Bbl,::J;e.'1JIIOTCJI 11306pame-
HIIJI mllBOTHbIX I1a rrOJICHLlX II rropTY-
rreiiHblX l{pIOtihaX, 06'be)J;HHJIIO IIX )J;Ba,
IIHorAa Tpll BlIAa mliBOTHLlX II rrTIID; Ha
OAHOM rrpe,ll;MeTe (pIiC. 1, 1);
3). fIpe06.'IaAaIllle lI;eRopaTIIBHblx
lfepT B 11306pameIllIIi mIiBOTHbIX, Yh-
pamaBmllX AocrrexlI KOHHoro II rremero
BOIIHa, Y311;e'lKll, oll;emll;Y II T. 11;. ,n:eKo-
pa'l1HBHOCTb 1I306pameHIIH lIpHBO)J;HT K
HeKoTopoii: CTllJIll3aD;HII mIiBOTHLlX;
4). 3Ha'lUTeJIbHaJI 'laCTb yRpame-
Hllii:, B TOM 'l1lf.'IC C 11306pameIlllJIMH mll-
BOTIIbfX, CII;e:I<lII<I 113 meJIe3a, rrOKpbITO-
ro D;BeTHbIM MeTa.1JJIOM (30JIOTO, 6pOH3a).
TaHIlM 06pa30M, OTMe'laJI xapaKTep-
Hble lfepTbl )WrTlibiX H306pameHIIH mH-
BOTHbIX B JIIoxy paHHero me.'1e3HOrO
BeKa B fIOJIOHhe, BMeCTe C TeM Mbl Ha-
6JIIOJIaeM 3;1e(' h 11 lfyme3eMHble 3JIeMeH-
TbI 1I306pan;l'III1II. KOTopbfe IIHOr,ll;a B
rrpoD;ecce npliCIIOC06JIeHIIJI IIX H MeCT-
HOR CTHJIlleTllqeCKOH !f>opMe Bce me
coxpaIlH.l11 Clwii 06.'IHK. TaHoB. Hanpll-
Mep, IIOHcnrdi I;PIOlfOK, COCTOH IIR lI3
meJle3I1oii O('IIOBbl, lIOKpblTOii 30JIOTOM,
Ha HOTOpOM I1306pameH KJIIOB XII 1I0ii:
rrTIiUbl. II. nO-BIiIl;IIMOMY. rraHTepa
(pIiC. I, 3) B CBOIO O'lepell;b, B:mHIlIIe
cpe)JIIeil,onc ,,\IX II306pameHIIR mllBOT-
HbIX, npp.lcTaB:reHHblx rrOHCHbnnI
J{pIO'IKa 1II IJ IIHorll;a OKOBKa}!1I )Jepe-
BHHIIbIX C{)(\'.10B (pIiC. 1, 2, 4), npoHB-
.IHPT('f! na JlllIpOHOH TeppliTopIIll Boc-
141
TOqHOH EBpOrrhI B COCeAHHX KYJIbTY-
pax, TaKIIX J;aJ; CIHl<pCKaJI, caBpOMaTO-
capMaTCKaJI, ropOAeU;KaJI H anaHbHHC-
KaJI (AJIeJ;CaIlAPorrOJIbCKHH KypraH,
EailmraH, qypaqrrRCI{!IH KypraH, AHa-
HbIIIIO 1I ;r:p.).
Yme rraJUlqIIe H306pameHHH mIIBOT-
HhIX, B03ITlIKaIoru;IIX H pa3BHBaBmHXCJI
Pue. 1. 11306pa:m:eHUR :m:u80rHb!X Ha pa3-
'<U'lHb!X npeOMerax:
1 - HOCTIIHOJI HpIO'IOH H3 norpeoeHHIl HypraHa
3 /39 y c. lIIacTIOrlIHo; 2, 4 - H300pameHHil nTII-
D;nI Ii OJ1eHa (oRoBKa ;u;epeBRHHoro cocy;u;a B 30-
nOTe) 113 HypraHa 11/2 B ypO'IHll1e ,,'IacTble HYP-
raBbI»): 3 - me:Ie3HblA HPIOQOK, OOHTbI:A: 30JIO-
TOn nnaCTJlHoJl (cnY'IaJlHall HaXOI\Ha Ha HH>lmeM
AOHY)
I
' < 'V"" "
.:t...,..,. ""
c . I '
.
";". -. - - ;-
- ' -----"
- -- -..
.: - .-=- ---
- .
C : ,-"_ '. . _', .:-""_ _
'
1 - - .'.j/';;,:- .--.
I
I
I
I
i
I
I
L
Ha MeCTHOH OCHOBe B CBocoupa3Hoii
CTIIJIHCTH'IeCKOH <popMe, He3aBlIcrrMO OT
BJIIIJIHHJI rrpOHHKaBIlliIX qya\C3eMHhIX
3JIeMeHTOB, Tpe6yeT BhIJICHeIIUJI I.opcrr-
nbIX COU;UaJIbIIO-3I;OHOMIP!CC I.!IX II
KYJIbTypno-peJIIIrII03HbIX rrpll'!JIIl, BhI3-
BaBmnx IIX B03HIIKHOBeHlIe II pa3BIITlIe
Ha MeCTe. TImJTOMY MbI C'lIlTaeM qTO
XOTJI B naCTOJIru;ee BpeMJI rreB03 I mHO
pemIITb rrp06JIeMY 3Bepnuoro CTHJIJI
TOJIbKO C TOqRII 3peIlIIJI rrpllBlIeCeHIIJI
II306pameHHll mHBOTHhIX OTI;Y;:Ia-TO II3-
BHe, Bce me, B CBJI3I1 C Hal;OmIeHlIeM
HOBhIX MaTepIIaJIOB, mIIpOKIBI pa3BlITII-
eM 3THorpa<pIIqeCKOH HaYKlI, ;:J.aBmeii
rrpeKpaCHoe orrIIcaHIIe pJIAa rr.leMeH II
HapoAOB B IIX IICTOpIl'!CCI;O I, COU;IIaJlb-
RO-3J;OHOMlIqeCKOM II KYJIbTypUUM pa3-
BIITlIlI, pemeHlIe AaHH0i! rrp06JIC lbI Me-
TOAaMII peTpocrreRTIIBHoro cpaBHeIlIIJI
MomeT 6bITb peaJIbHO rrpH6JIIImeHO.
C 3TOil u;e.TIbIO MhI IlCrrOJIb3yeM IleIiO-
TophIe rrpIIMepb! II3 xapaKTepIlCTI!Ii.I!
ceBepO-3arraAHhIX IlJIeMeH I!Il;:J.eiiu,eB
CeBepnOH AMepHRII, AeTaJIbHO orrucaH-
HblX 10. TI. ABeplmeBOH ". XapaKTe-
PII3YJI ypOBeHb 06ru;eCTBeHHoro, 3KOIlO-
MUqeCKOrO II COU;IIaJIbHOrO pa3BIlTIIJI,
06pJIAbi II 06bI'Ian 3TIIX rrJIe leIl, 10 II.
ABepIilIeBa YCTaHaB.TIIIBaeT y HUX 3Tarr
BOeHHOll: AeMOKpaTIIH, a Y HaII60.1ee Ile-
peJl,OBOrO rrJIeMeHrr HYTKa pO;:lOBbIe
CBJI3II K cepeAIIHe XIX B. YCTyrranII
MeCTO TeppIITOplIaJIbHbIM, coCe;:lClwiT
Q6ru;HHe.
OJl,IlaKO H 3AeCb qepThI pOAOBblX
OTHomeHIIH eru;e YAepmIIBa.1Ilcb 18.
Y Jl,pyrRX, 60JIee OTCTa.'IhIX mle Iell, Ta-
KHX KaK TJIHHKIITbI, xaIIAa H U;IBIUllIHHC,
CTOHBmHX Ha CTaAIIH CTaHOBJICllnJI
paHUeKJIaCCOBLIX oTHomeHIIH II OTU;OB-
CKoro rrpaBa, aBTOp BIIAIIT ClIJIbHhIC nc-
pemnTKH MaTepnllCiioro pOAa 19.
Y IlJIeMeHII me J;BaKIIIOT.1Cii. CTOHR-
mIIX B 06ru;eCTBeHllOM pa3BnTnn IC}I{JJ.Y
rrJIeMeHeM HyTKa H T.TInHRlITa !II. «He
6bI.'IO em;e rrpoTIIBorro.'10iliUbIX Kl<1C-
COB, HO HaqaJICJI yme rrpou,ec.c 060c06-
JIeHIIJI HMym;ei\: BepxymRII OT rrpOCTblX
06ru;HRHHKOB U rrpeBpanlelIIiH ec B
R.'Iacc, 3KCrrJIyaTIIpYK)ilIlIH He TO:I h[;O
paGoB, HO II CBOlIX OUU\IIlIIIIIROB') 'J'.
HeCMOTpJI na ::IT 0, y rr.'leMeHII HYTR<1
II oc06eHHO y APynIX. 60JIee OTCTa.1J.l:\
1I.'leMen (RBaIUlIOT.'lII, T.'IIIHliUTbI II ;[p.)
60.1bIIlaJI 'IaCTb 06PJI.'I0R en\p X 1:\ B.
I10ClI.'la JIpKUe qepTbI TOTCMJ[O!"O 1; ':lh-
Ta 21. Ii eCJlII y KBaI;lIlOTJIeH. il Till,n;e
y ceBepHblX II.'le leH npe.'IOJ;-'[P:'"IH'"
CJIIIBaJICJI eIlle C TOTeMHblM ilinR(JTllhlM
II Ha6JIIOAaJIOCb OIemelllIe aHTIH'[JO-
MOp<p HbIX n 300 IOp(pHbIX qepT. I'll Y
rr:le reHlI HYTJ;a rrpon301ll.10 OT .WIt '1111 e
'Ic.'lOBeKa-rrpeAKa OT <pnrypbI 1U1"\1111'-
TO iKIIBOTHOro 22.
")
:oj
c"j
"
"
j
.,
142
CYMMIIpYJI BCC 3TIl AanHbIC oG 06.
ru;ecTBeHHoM, COIlIIaJIbHOM H KYJIbTYP'
IlOM pa3BHTIIH ceBepo-3arraAHblx aME:-
pllKalicKIIx IlHAeilu;eB, CJIeAyeT CKa-
3aTb, qTO:
L CeBepo-3arraAHhIe ar.wpHKaHcKHe
rrHAeiiU;hI naXOAlIJIUCb Ha 3Tarre pa3JIO-
meHIlJI rrepBo6hITH006ru;IIHlIoro CTpOJI,
06pa30BaHIIJI KJIaCCOBbIX OTHomeHllii H
pa3BIITIIJI BoeHHoH AeMoKpaTIIH, YCKO-
pJIIOIIlllM rrpoU;eccoM KOTOpLIX JIBJIJIJIaCb
J;0:IOHII3aU;IIOHHaJI IlO.TInTIIRa eBporreii-
u;eB.
2. PeJIIIrII03HbIe rrpeACTaBJIeHIIJI oc-
HOBalihI na TOTeMII3Me, CBJI3aHHOM C
rrOqnTanIIeM mIlBOTHhIX, pacTeHIIll H
T. A., rrepexO)J,JIru;eM y 60JIee pa3BIIToro
IlJIeMeHII (HYTRa) B KYJIbT IlpeAKoB II
aHTponoMop<p u3a U,UIO 6omecTB. Ha6JIIO-
AaIOru;IIeCJI <paKTbI MHoroo6pa3HJI TOTe-
MOB B OJI,HOM pOAe cBHAeTeJIbCTBYIOT 0
CJIIIJIHIIII B HeM pa3HhIX pOAOB C IIX TO-
TeMaMil 23. OTMeqaeTCJI pIITyaJIbHblH
xapaKTep AepeBJIHHbIX 6moJl, C II306pa-
meHHeM TOTe MOB, KOTopble rrepeAaBa-
:mCb no naCJIeAcTBY".
3. I1cKyccTBo cCBepo-aanaAHhIx IIII-
Aeiiu;eB CeBepHoil AMepHKH OrpaHHqlI-
BaeTCJI, KaK rrpaBIIJIO, pe3b6oii rro Ae-
peBY. OHO OTpamaeT TOTeMHCTHqeCI,ne
rrpeACTaBJIeHIIJI B BnAe II306pameHIIii
«TOTeMOB pe3b6oH na AOMOBbIX cTo.TI6ax,
rrOJl,rrupaIOm;IIX 6aJIRlI, Ha TOTeMHhIX
cToJI6ax, Ha AepeBJIHHbIX rOJIOBHblX
y6opax, Ha rraHU;IIpJIX, Ha opymIIII,
0pYJI,lIHX II YTBapn... B BIIAe pllcymwB
na O:IemJl,e, lIa .TIlIU;e, Ha <pacaAe A0-
MOB» 25.
CpaBHIIBaJI 06ru;eCTBeHHhIii II MaTp.-
pIIa.lbHO-KYJIbTYPHbIII ypOBeHb pa3Bu-
TIIJI rrJIeMeH CpeAuero ,l],oHa, a paBHO
II CliII<pIIII C COOTBeTCTBYIOru;IIM pa3Bll-
TIIe 1 ceBepO-3aIlaAHblX HHAeilU;eB
CeBepHoii AMepIIKII B XIX B., MbI rrpn-
XOAIHI Ii BbIBOAY 0 TOM, qTO OH 6bl."I Y
rrepBbIXBblille. 'IeM y BTOpbIX.
V - IV BB. JJ.O H. 3. CIHI(pCRniI MIlP;
nO-BIlrIIIMOMY, 3aBepmaJI 3Tarr BOeHIToil
143
AeMOKpanH! II nepB06bITH006 lIHHh1X
OTHomeHIIH, rrepemHBaJI nepliOA pac-
IJ;BeTa MeTaJIJIyprHII; 3aMeTHO mlipOKO
HCrrOJIb30BaJIHCb MemrrJIeMeHHble H
MemAYHapoAHble ToprOBble OTnome-
HHJI C nepeAOBblMIi CTpaHaMH EBpa3HH.
B aTO BpeMJI B 3BepliHOM CTHJIe nOJIyqll-
IlH AOCTaTOqHOe pa3BIITlie AeKopaTHB-
HOe H opHaMeHTaJIbHOe I1anpaBJIeHHH,
KOTopble, Ha Ham B3rJIJIA, OTMeqaIOT no-
CJIeAHHH aTan cy ecTBoBaHIiH TOTeMII-
CTllqeCKIIX npeACTaBJIeHIIH.
B CBJI311 C 3THM CJIeAYeT nOAqepK-
HyTb OAHH 113 BblBOAOB M. 11. ApTaMO-
HOBa, pa3AeJIJIeMblll HaMH, 0 TOM, qTO
«CKmpbl, KaK II ApeBHHe repMaHIJ;bl, Ha-
XOAMJIHCb Ha nOCJIeAHeH CTaAHH pa3BH-
THJI pOAOBOro CTpOJI, Ha 9Tarre pa3JIO-
meHHJI, KOTOpblH 3HreJIbCOM HMeHyeTCJI
«BOeHHOH AeMOKpaTHeH» 26. B APyroii:
pa60Te M. 11. ApTaMoHoB YTBepmAaJI,
qTO B cKmpcKoH cpeAe «ropa3Ao 60JIb-
mliM pacrrpocTpaHeHBeM, a CJIeAOBa-
TeJIbHO, H nOqHTaHHeM rrOJIb30BaJIHCb
He aHTponoMopqJHble, a 300Mop!f>Hble
06pa3bl 60rOB, BOCX0roIm;lIe K TOTeM-
HblM npe)J.KaM, KOTopble Ha R3BeCTHOM
3Tarre B pa3BIITHH peJIHrH03HOrO Mblm-
JIeHHJI npeBpaTHJIHCb B OJIBIJ;eTBopeHHe
CTHXIIHHblX JIBJIeHHH, B 06pa3bl KOC-
MHqeCKOrO 3HaqeHHJI. 3BepHHbIii: rraH-
TooH CKH!f>CKOH peJIHrHH MHoro 60raqe
aHTponOMop!f>I10ro H npHTOM B OCHOB-
HOH cBoeii: qaCTH HeCOMHeHHO MeCTHa-
ro npOHcxOmAeHHJI He TOJIbKO B OTHO
IIIeHHH cOAepmaHIIJI, HO H no !f>opMe.
I1MeHHo B HCM HamJIO CBoe BblpameHHe
JIpKOe caM06bITHoe CKH!f>cKoe IICKYCCT-
BO» 27. E. H. fpaKOB 28 H M. 11. ApTa w-
HOB CqllTaJIIi 11306pameHHe OJIeHJI KaK
pOAOBoro 3HaKa B 3noxy paHHero meJIe-
3a TOTeMHblM nepemHTKOM. OAHaKO
M. 11. ApTaMOHOB CBJI3blBaeT H306pa-
meHHe nOA06Horo TOTeMa C npHBHeceH-
HblMH H3 I1paHa 29. JIbIOHC f. MopraH
TaKiKe co06rn.aeT, qTO ,(IB anoxy OTKpbl-
THJI AMeplIKII eBponeii:IJ;aMH Bce HH-
eHCKHe nJIeMeHa 6blJIH opraHH30BaHbl
B pOAbl, C 0603HaqeHlIeM npollcxomAe-
HIIJI no meHCKOH JIIIHIIII. TOJIbKO Y He-
KOTOpblX n.'1eMeH, KaK, HanpliMep, y
0)Vl\1I6Ba, O}laqa II Maii:JI Ha IOKoTaHe,
npOIlCXOm)l;eHlle CTaJIO CqIlTaTbCJI He no
MaTepH, a no OTIJ;Y. II08CI08y y TyaeM-
lfe8 A. eplllw p08 nOJ£Y'luJ£ C80e U,MR
OT JlCU60T1i0i!0 UJ£U OT lie08YUJ,e8J£enIi0-
20 npe8. leTa, 1i0 lie OT 'leJ£08el'Oa (KYP-
ClIB MOll - II. JI. ). B aTOM paHHeM CO-
CTOHIIIIII oorn.eCTBa OT)I;CJIbHOe JIHIJ;O
BnOIlJIe nor:IOrn.aJIOCb POAOM» 30. B co-
06rn.elllllI MopraHa npeACTaBJIJIeTCJI
OqeHb BamHon MblCJIb 0 TOM, qTO HHAeH-
clille n,'1eMeHa AMepHlill B rrepHoA ee
OTKpblTIiJI :\OCTHrJIH He TOJIbKO nepBOH
cTyneHII BapBapCTBa, rAe CqeT pOACTBa
HAeT no }laTepHHCKOH JIHHIIH, HO II
BTOpoii - c ee CqeTOM pOACTBa no Mym-
CKOii: mIlum.
B IIIJTepeCYIOrn.en Hac np06JIeMe oco-
60e BIIHMallne 06pa aeT Ha ce6JI H TO,
qTO, HeCMOTpH na pa3Hble cTyneHII pa3-
BIITIIJI aMcpIlKaHCKHX POAOB, Bce OHH
nOJIyqllJJII CBoe IIMJI OT iKHBOTHoro HJIH
IIeO)l;YIIIeB."leHIIOrO npeAMeTa. CJIeAOBa-
TeJIbHO, IIX peJIllrll03Hble npeACTaBJIe-
I1I1JI 6blJIli TOTeMIiCTHqeCKHMH. 3TH TO-
TeMIICTllqeCKlie npeACTaBJIeHHJI H CBJI-
3aHIIoe C HIIMII H306pa3HTeJIbHOe HC-
KyCCTBO ceBepO-3arraAHblx aMepHKaH-
CKUX IIJI,!J.CIII eB OTHOCJITCJI K 60JIee
paHHcn cTyneHII BapBapCTBa, qeM Ta,
KOTOpOH )l;OCTllrJIO HaCeJIeHHe IIO)l;OHbJI
H CKH!f>lIlJ, rAe H306pameHHJI mHBOT-
IIblX 3aHH.ll1 CTOJIb 6oJIbmoe MeCTO B
HCKYCCTBC,
TaKaJI OTIIOCIITeJIbHaJI nOCJIeAOBa-
TC."lbIlOCTh :nanOB pa3BHTHJI, BepOJITHO,
nO; TBCpn;;Ial'TCJI, Bo-nepBblX, HaJIHqlleM
BoellHOH ,1P !OKpaTHH Ha TOll H ApyrOH
cTynclllIx CC ,pa3BIITHJI; BO-BTOPbIX, cy.
eCTBOBaHIIe!t 06blqaJI y nJIeMeH ceBe-
pO-;3ana; !Ij,!x"HH)I;ellIJ;eB CeBepHOll AMe-
plllill. 3a I>:!lOqa BIIIeroCJI B TOM, '1TO npH
06"bC:\IIIIPHIIU HeCKOJIbKHX pO,!J.OB B
0,!J.I111 PO) B 06"be)l;HHeHHOM pOAe nOqH-
Ta."lIlCb Bee TOTCMbl, KOTopbIe cy ecTBo-
BaJIIi B pOAax )1;0 06"be)l;HHCHlIJI, TorAa
KaK y rrJIeMeIl BOCTO'IJIOll EBponbl H B
TOM qllCJIe B IIo,!J.oHbc B '3noxy paHHero
)KeJIe3a aTOT rrpllHIJ;lln, rrO-BII)I)IMOMY,
HaIIIeJI C"Boe OTpameHlIC B 11306pameHH-
JIX HeCKOJIbKIIX mliBOTHblX Ha OAHOM
npe)l;MeTe (nOHCHble KPlOq];II Cpe)l;Hero
,lJ;oHa, B03MomHO, 30nOTaH 6JIJIxa C
H306pameHHC}1 O.'1CHH H3 KYJIb-06bI H
AP.); B-TpeTbllX, eeJlIl y n."lCMeH ceBe-
BepO-3ana)l;HbIX II lI,!J.eIIIJ;eB CeBepHOH
AMCpllKIi CYll CCTBOBa:I 06bl'1all rrepeAa-
'111 no HaCJICJJ.CTBY pUTyaJIbHblX Aepe-
BJIHHblX 6J1IOA C II306pameHlleM COOT-
BeTcTByIO nx pOJJ.Y TOTeMOB, TO y BTO-
pblX 3TII AepeBHHIIble 6JIIOJJ.a H MIICKH
yKpalllaJIIiCb n;\OopaiIWHIIH}1!I O.TJeHJI H
rrTHIJ;bl (ypoqnrn.e LJacTble KypraHbl) 31,
pbl6bl H OJICHII (I;ypraH COJIoxa) 32 H
pbl6bl (ApxaHre.'IbCI,aJI cJI060)l;a) 33.
TaKHM 06pa30M, nplI3HaBaH KaK !f>aKT
HaJIH'lHe qyme3eMHbix 3JIeMeHTOB B 3Be-
pHHOM cTlwe y II.'leMeH BOCTOqHOii:
EBponbi H B TOM qnClle Cpe)l;HerO ,lJ;oHa
H 0c06eHHO CKlI!f>IIII, Mbl 06pa aeM
BH}lMaHHe B nepBYIO OqepeAb Ha B03-
1 M. H. ApraMono., I1POIICXOml\eHlle CKII<p-
, CKOro IICJ;ycCTBa, CA. 1968, M 4, CTp. 27.
2 TaM ;I<e, YKa , co,!" CTp. 30.
3 TaM me, YKa3, co,!" CTp. 42.
· B, H. KUR III "o. PaCJ;OIIlm KOHcTaHTIIHoB-
CKOro I10Cl'JIeIlIlH. AU 1968 r. M" 1969,
CTp. 105-106, pile
5 TaM me, YKa3, co'!., CTp. 106.
6 11.. H, :Jehua, PC I1aH CKYJIbiiTypa YpaJIa.
M., 1940, CTP, 78-80, pliC. 76-79,
7 C. B. Kuee,M'. ,QPl'lHlHH IICTOpIIII IOmHoii
CII6IIpll. M., 19;;1. np. 234.
8 r, lJ, o4pxuno., II C Baenep, B. ([J. Ka-
xo.e"uu, 10, A. "'paeno. U ()p. Pa60Tbi
'Ie601;capcJ;ofi ""Cl1e;1I1 IIII. «AO 1971 1'.1)
M., 1972, CTp. 178 II pliC.
· 11.. A, KOllu.ell, l'afioTbi B TIeqepCKOM
TIPIIIIOJIHPI,P, (c\() 1'171 f.') M., 1972, CTp.
6-7 II pile.
1011., o4. Kprl/lllo6, (I p300Tax BepXHeBOJIm-
CKoii 3KCflP;1I1UIIII. ",,\0 1969 r.» M., 1970,
CTP, 32-34 II pll"
II 11., o4. KPOUI/n6 11"C:Iel\oBaIlIlH BepxHe-
BOJImCKOR J;CIIP.1.lIullll, «AO 1971 f.» M.,
1972, CTp. 48-49.
144
HHKHOBenHe ero Ha 6a3e MeCTHoro IIC-
KyccTBa H306pamenllll: TOTeMHblX mlI-
BOTnblX e e 3aAoJIro AO rrOHBJIemIH
qyme3C}!II0rO 3BepliHoro CTIIJIJI. B 3rro-
xy paHllero meJIe3a 3TII H306pamellIlH
mliBOTllbIX Ha MecTHoH OCHOBe AaJIII
TOT 3BepllHblii CTIiJIb KOTOpblll Ha6JIIO-
AaeTCJI Ha BCell: TeppHTopHIi EBpa311IL
B )llOXY 6pOH3bl B CIIJIY He)l;OCTaTOqHOro
pa3BIITliH MeCTHoii MeTaJIJIyprllil B ]{a-
'1eCTBe MaTepllaJIa )l;JIJI 11306paiReHilII
mIIBOTnblX, nO-BII)I;IIMOMY, IIcnO.TJb30Ba-
JIOCb B OCHOBHOM pe3Hoe AepeBO II TO.TJb-
KO OTqaCTIi KOCTb. Pe3Hoe AepCBO na
I13yqae}IOH TeppnTopIIII B 3noxy 6POIl-
3bl H paHHero meJIe3a He OCTaBIIJIO C:IC-
AOB. Ho MbI MomeM CYAHTb 0 BbICOKO}!
I1CKYCCTBe pe3b6bl rro AepeBY no IIITaM-
naM Ha 30JIOTbIX, cepe6pJIHbIX II 6pOH30-
BblX n.TJaCTHHax. IIpHMepbI HCnOJIb30-
BallHJI pe3Horo )l;epeBa AOCTaTOqHO B"I-
pa311TeJIbHO npeACTaBJIeHbl Kal> B nc-
KyccTBe TOp!f>JIHHKOBbIX naMJITllmWB
3nOXH 6pOH3bl Ha YpaJIe, TaK II B aJl-
TaHCKfIX KypraHax B 3noxy paHHem
meJIe 3a.
12 C. B. CrY{)3U/f"aR, OTpameHne 3TIIII'IC-
CKIIX IIpo eCCOB B MeJIKOii I1JIaCTlu;e
I\peBHelImero HaCeJIeIlll1I ceBepa EBpO-
IIeiicKOII qaCTIl CCCP. «HCTOpBII II KYJIb-
Typa BOCTOqHOii EBpOIlbI IIO apxeO;lOfIlq -
CKIIM l\aHHblM». M., 1971, CTP, 23-4;:,.
pIlC. 2, 2, 5.
13 O. H. Ba{)ep. ,QpeBIIeiirnaH MeTa.uypfHf!
TIpIIypaJIblI. M., 1964, CTp. 143; Oil JlCe,
BpOll30Bblii Hom II3 CeiiMbI C JIOIlIa;1b I II
Ha HaBepmlIlI. KCHA, BbIII. 127. 1971,
CTp. 98; on xe. MOrllJIbHIIKIl TypfiIIHCJ;OIO
TIIIIa, IIX B03paCT II CBH3b C I10ceJIPII!U!-
Mil. ACf3, 1964, M 6, CTp. 103.
" C. B. Kuce..e6. Y"a3. COq., CTP, 178-17!1,
" E. K. Ma"euM06. TIaMIITHIIK 3I10XII fipoll
3bI y CTaH IIII KapaMblm, CapaToBcIwii
06JIaCTII. «ApxeoJIOrll'!ecKIIii COOPIIII"»
CapaToB, 1956, CTP, 121, pliC. 69; B. II
mu..o.. TIp06JIeMbI OCBOeHHf! CTl',,<'fi
HllmHero TIOBOJImbH B I10XY fipOIl "L
ACf3, 1964, M 6, CTP, 95-97, I'"" ". I
16 II. 11.. lJu6ep06. ,QpeBHIIH IICTOpllf! II ac 1"-
JIeHll1I TIOI\OHblI. ABTOpe<p. AOJ;T. ;J;lIrl'.
M., 1971, CTp. 29-37.
145
17 EO. II. A8ep/(Ue80. Pa3JIOmCHIle pOIlOBOII
06 IIHbI II <pOpMlIpOBalllle pallueWlacco-
BbiX OTllomCHllii B 06 eCTBe 1I"lI:eii eB
ceBepO-aaUall:1I0ro u06epembli CeBepnOII
AMepIlKII. TH3, HOBali ceplllI, T. LXX,
1961.
.8 TaM me, CTp. 201.
t 9 TaM me, CTp. 46.
20 TaM me, CTp. 46.
21 TaM me, CTp. 187.
22 TaM me, CTp. 190.
., TaM me, CTP. 63-64, 79-80.
24 TaM me, CTp. 73-74.
2> TaM me, CTp. 23.
26 M. 11. AprOJltOno8. a 3eMJIeB.la;\eHlIII U
3eMJlell:eJIbqeCKO I upa311:uIIhC Y CWI«pOB.
Y3J1fY, BblII. 15. J1., 1947, CTp. 19.
27 M. If. AprOJltOno8. AiiTpoumIOpqJHbIe 00-
B. B. BIIHOfpaJJ;OB
iKeCTBa B peJIlIrIIn CI<II<P0B. ACf3, BbiU. 2,
1 !)61, CTp. 83.
28 B. H. rpOX08. Clii<pu. KnIB, 1947, CTp.
81-82.
29 M. 11. AprOJltOno8. CKIl«jJo-CII6IIpCKoe IIC-
KYCCTBO aBep""0ro CTUJIIi. rrCA, M., 1971,
CTp. 33.
30 IhlOUC r. M opzon. IIepB06b1TIIOe 06 eCT-
BO. CII6., 1900, CTp. 85.
31 II. /1,. lIu6e p08. IIaMIiTIlHRIl CKIl<pchoro
BpeMelI1l Jla Cpell:lIeM JJ;OIIY. CAH, BbIU.
J],1-31. M., 1965, CTP. 95-97, TaOJl. 28,
9, 10; Ta6JI. 29, 4.
32 fl. 11. Bece"o8clwU. PaCIWUKIl hypralIa
«CoJIoxa . OAK, IIrp., 1.918, CTp. 104,
pllC. 193, a, 6.
33 A. M. lIec/(o8. HOBbie CORpoBII a Kypra-
II0B Y"paIIIILI. AJlb60M. JI., 1972, C1'p. 34,
pllC. XV; CTP. 56, pIlC. 31-32.
R XAPARTEPIICTIUm ROBAHCROrO BAPIIAHTA
B CRll<DO-CIIBIIPCROM 3BEPIIHOM CTllJIE
"Yme 60JIee BeRa B ROJIJIeKD;HH na-
MHTHIIfiOB IJ;eHTpaJlbHOrO II OTqaCTH
CeBepo-BoCTOqHOrO KaBRa3a CRII<pCRO-
1'0 BpeMeHH, OTHOCJIIQHXCJI R rrpOCJIaB-
;IOHHOH R06aHcRoii KyJlbType, yBeJlH-
'InBaeTCJI qIlCJlO rrpe));MeTOB, BbIrrOJlHeH-
IIblX B TaR Ha3bIBaeMOM CRII<p0-CII6HP-
CI;OM 3BepIllIOM CTIIJIe. CBoe06pa3He
nOItOTOpblX 113 HIIX 3aMe'IeHO H I1HTep-
npeTlIpOBano IICCJle));OBaTeJlJIMII (A. A.
HecceH', E. TI. AJleRCeeBa" O. A. Ap-
TaMoH0Ba-TIOJITa B lI. eB a 3, B. B. BHHO-
rpa));OB H A. M. IIIRypKO \ B. B. Te-
XOB '). B OP;HOH I13 CBOHX pa60T MbI
nOlibITaJllICb 060CHOBaTb cYIQeCTBOBa-
Hlle Ha CeBepHOM KaBRa3e oc060ro
lIapHaHTa CKH<P0-CII6HpCKOro CTHJlJI 8.
.n:aulIaJI CTaTbJI c.1ymliT pa3BHTHIO
llblCKa3alilibIX panee H));eH.
Ana,11I3 H3BeCTHblX cerO));IIJI COOTBeT-
CTBYIOIQIlX 300MOP<PHbIX H306pameHHH
nOKa3b1BaeT, qTO He rr03p;Hee BTOpOH
nO/IOBHHbI VII B. P;O II. 3. HaCeJleHHe
Trx 06J1i1CTOI! IJ;eHTpaJlbHorO H CeBepo-
BOCTO'1II0ro KaBKa3a, 'ITO BXOP;IIJlll B
apeaJI 1<o6alICKOll KY:!bTypbI, rr03HaRO-
MIIJlOCb C CIomeTaMn, <popMaMH H CTII-
,'IIICTH'IeCIUlMII rrpIleMa [II 1I0BOro KO-
'IOBIHI'IeCKOrO HCRYCCTBa (CKH<pO-CH-
unpCKoro 3BepHHoro CTII.TUI), HMeIO II-
ml. cor:lacno pa3));e.1JIeMOH HaMH B D;e-
.IO ! TO'IJ;e apOnHJI, B OCIIOBHOM ));peBHe-
BOCTO'IHOe npOHcxomp;eHlIe '. C Tex rrop
II Bn.10Tb P;O Konll.a IV B. ));0 H. 3. clOp;a
II pOHIIh'a.1H npep;MeTbI, BbIrrOJlHeHHbIe B
n;JJ<p0-CH6HPCHOM 3BepHHOM CTHJle. TIO));
nx BJlIDIHIIeM MeCTnble MaCTepa (IOBe-
JlIIpbI, ROCTope3bI, opymeHHIIKH) caMH
CTaJlIi II3rOTaB,lIlBaTb rrop;06HbIe rrpe));-
MeTbI, rropOH KonIlpYJI InmopTHbIe 06-
pa3D;bI, 'IaIQo me - npUnopaBJlIIBaJI ce-
BepHbIe Mop;e.1II K c06cTBeHHbIM BRY-
caM, H306pa3nTe,lblIoii MaHepe, HCROH-
HbIM TpaJI.IIlI.IIHM.
<DOHP; 30mIOP<PllbIX 11306pameIllIll
IIHTepSCYIOIQero Hac Itpyra Ha HCCJle-
p;yeMoii TeppIITOplll!, OTMe'leHHbIX rre-
qaTblO aRTHIJHbIX KOIITafiTOB C 06I1Ta-
TeJlJIMII IOmlIopyccIiIIX cTeneH VII-
IV BB. ));0 H. 3., ymo ,"\OCTaTO'IHO rrpell-
CTaBHTeJlen (60Jlee 100 06pa3l1.0B),
pa3Ho06pa30II II nOCTOHHHO pacTeT. 3TO
n03BQ.'"!HeT eo 3Ha'lIlTe:lbHOH ));oJleii p;o-
CTOBepnOCTH npe.'Ul(HIHIITb rrorrbITKY
BbI));eJleHIIJI II xapal>Tl'lmCTIIKH rrpem)];e
OCTaBllIerOCJI B TOIIII Hpep;KaBRa3CKoro
BapnaHTa CKII<pCI-,OrO 3IJepHHoro CTIIJlJI,
J;OTOpbIH C nO.1HbDI npaBOM MomHO
IDlenOIJaTb EOOaIlCI>II I BapnaHToM.
HaqIIeM C pH:Ia I>oHcT,lTall.HII. TIep-
BbIe 06pa31\hI 311rl1ll IIoro ('TII:III IW'leIJ-
HII'JeCKoro 00:111 I> a nOHB:IHIOTCJI H a
CeBepHoM KaIJI>a3r ('II\l' B VII B. p;o II. J.
II CBH3aHbI npelI I 'I!\eCTBrImo C c06-
CTBelll!O HO'IeRIIII'Il'( nlIMM norpe6eHHJI-
MI! (A,lOKc('('IJcI>ni'l. I IaJIh'IllKCI;nH, fy-
;lep {eCCKllii II :IPYIIIl' KypraUbI) 8 HJlII
J;O !rr.lenCaMIl. onl("I('IIHbIMH mMBbIMn
IWHTaJ;TaMM C I;O'Il'BIIII'IeCKHMH Ky.1b-
TypaMI! (\IfJ:qOI>l'I:IIH, Ky6aHcKHII.
T.l II HCI.;n11 , (DaCl;aYCI>IIH H ));pyrne a60-
pnreHHbIe !Orll:I1,IIIIl;Il) 9. MaTeplla-
147
PUC. 1. XpoltoJl,oauJl npeaMeTo8 I>OfiOIlCKOW
8apuaHTa C1turfio-cu6upcKoao 38epUltOW CTll-
.foR, 8 naMR,TItU1taX Ce6epltoao l(1I8Kaao:
1 - c. JIJIXoA-MOXH; 2 - c. lIIaJIYlln<a; .1. -" I,a-
1f(UraH; 4 - c. Happac; 5 - c. MYnill'lIl (:1 )To-
Boel; 6 - C. MY1f(uq" (.'IyroBoe); ;- - r. Baalll-
raH; 8 - r. HHCJIOBOIiCH; 9-10 - noe. HOBorpoa-
Hblii; 11 - CT. HUHOJIaeBCHaR; 12 - CeBepuaR
OceTHR; 13 - CBRTUJIBlI\e PeHOM; 14 - CT. HlIIlO-
JIaeBCHan; 15 - C. MY1f(llqll (JIyroDoe); 16 -
C. .A.IIJIepoli; 17 - ,!J:uropHR; 18 - c. B. H06aHb;
19 - C. l'aJIHaT (<I>acHay); 20 - c. Hy:mPR; 21-
c. MaMaliHa; 22 - CT. TnXOpelJHaR; 2.1 - c. Illa-
JIH; 24 - noc. HOBorpoaHblll; 25 -- r. I-iIlC. OBO;\<:H:
26 - C. l'aJIUaT (<I>acHayJ; 27 - noc. HOBorpoa-
Hblii; 28 - c. XauaIia; 29 - C. COBtTCHOe \:LIHY-
Tbl): 30 - C. Ha36eH; 31- c. BCTll-Cy; .12-
r. CTanpOnOJIb: 3.1 - c. l'aJIHaT «T>uHay); .14-
c. A;llIepotl; 35 - CenepHa>l OCCTIIH: .JT; - C l\a3-
Gel<: 37 -I". MaJIrooP,l( 38 -- c. Hy tij :lTa. .J!!-
C. !\1ymHqU (JIyroDoe); 40 --- ('. I'aJlllaT ,,1>;1(";;, Y) ;
41 - C. 'Ypyc-MapTaH (AIUf-Bp301: J!.- ,. Xa-
6a3; 43 - 1'. MUHPpa!1bHbIe an!IbI: H - ," l"Y:J"P-
Mec: 45 - r. h!!('JIOnOIiCH; 46 - (. IILI.I 'IIIHa:
47-49 _. c. BepxHRR P)'Txa; 50. I ,. ,H I Pill
(.'1yronoe); 51-52 - c. I'on.rl>[; ,j.> -. f' "'"yc-
MapTaH (AHH-Bp30): 54 -- c. I,ap,,'(f'. >0-
G. RYMOYJITa; 56 C, OTpanHoe; 5i - (' l'a:HlaT
(<1>acKay); 58 - c. Ba1f(nran; 59 - r lIa:II>'IIlH:
60 - C. HH1f(HHIi '{ereM; 61 - CT. .\:'"I<'....."CH">I;
2 - c. HHH<HHIi 'lere.\!; 1, 11. H. j.) ",,':Ieao:
r, 8. 9, 28, 34, 37, 43, .51. 52 - HOCTh: 5fi --.5:1 -
rnttH:l; 20 -. 30JIOTO: OCTa:IhllhIe - 6pl\H:',!
Aama
IV B. AO H.3.
VB. AO H. 3.
VI B. AD H. 3.
VII B. AO H. 3.
Hao6paIHeHUII xUUJ,H"'x /J.'nul(
u
Q
.,.
w
11
8
L..J
15
16 ] l) :.4 w
I.....J
17
, ;;
19
""
Hao6p0}/(eHUII XUUI,H"'x IHUeOtnH"'x
2
--
I
22
r
I
- --------------- ---- - ----- - -- -- -..
45
Hsoopa}/(eHUII Hon",mH6IX }/(USomH6IX
$
w
46
ii
'--'
48
---'-7-
/..... I I
f \ __L
1\ I oj)
1,\ /
III (
1\
(c
"'
111/'
"II"
1111
..
55
'-'
£8
I
!
5@6 J w 2 w@ .
€I 30 ... . 32" '-' 33 0
12 . 35 27 ' _ -
,.; O 26 36, w, '4 #J w - i ; 1J
- _\\. '( H' - - -40 -.,...
13 38 L.....J : '-'
37 39 41 j 53 ''''''' -';''::--......
I I 1"'-:/ /r i.
44 '-
51
52
I
57 u
60_
(
o g w
--- ---------------
-----------------------
61
62 -
JlhI VI B. l1.0 n. 3. na I1CCJIell.yeMoH Tep-
pliTOpHIi CKpOMHbI II KaK 6Yl1.TO ne l1.a-
lOT OCnOBaH:H:H l1.JIH MHellllH 0 paCD;BeTe
;noro nanpaBJIenUH B UCKycCTIJe K06an-
CI,IIX ImeMelI, XOTH rCj pb YlRe HeCOM-
HeHHO, 'ITO 60JIbIIIaH 'laCTb naHl1.eHHbIX
3BeplillhIX 11306pameHIIii IIpOIlCXOl1.IIT
II3 K06aHCKliX IIaMHTlIIIKOB H MorliJIb-
1IliKOB MeCTHbIX r;YJIbTYP CeBepo-3a-
naAnoro KaBI,a3a. IIoc.TJell.Hee, BIIpO-
'leM, CKopee Bcem CJIell.CTBlie 11.IICIIpO-
aopll,lIu B IIO:ICBO{I n3Y'leHHOCTIi IIaMJlT-
IUlKOB a60pHreHOB II HOMaAoB CKH<p-
CKoro BpeMeHII Ha CeBepnOM KaBKa3e.
0c06aH rWIIYJIJlpHOCTb CKH<pCKoro 3Be-
pHnoro CTHJIJl q,IIKcHpyeTCJl KaK 6YATO
6bI lIa'IUUaH C py6ema VI- V H na npo-
TJlmenHII Bcero V B. 11.0 n. 3. (na na-
MHTnHKII norD OTpe3Ka BpeMeRB na-
11.aeT 60Ree 70 % Bcex n3BeCTnbIX 06-
pa3D;oB), TOrll.a KaK B IV B. AOCTaTO'IHO
CKOpOTe'lHaJl MOll.a 3aTyxaeT y K06an-
D;eB, OCTaBaHCb 3aMeTHOH B KOqeBHH-
'IeCKHX KypraHax UJIOCKOCTH (UJaJIYLU-
Ka, Bamuran, HYJIapbI) '0. TIpHJIarae-
MaJl K CTaTbe Ta6JIIID;a AaeT narJIJlARoe
rrpell.CTaBJIeHUe ° 11.HHaMliKe 3Toro na-
rrpaBJIeHUH II K06aHCI\HX rraMJlTHHKaX
CeBepHom Kall[,a3a (pHC. 1) II.
Bce IIpell.MeTbl 3BepHnoro CTIIJIJl, nall-
JlellHhIe B aone pacnpOCTpaHenllJl KO-
6aHclwll KYJIbTyphI II CMemHbIX C nelO
CTeIIHblX paHOJlOB, no CBOHM MOTHBaM
;\e.TJHTCH lIa TpU 60JIbIIIHe rpynIIbI:
IJ:!06pameHI1H X!lII HOR IITIID;hI, 11306pa-
meHlIH XllIIl,llIlKOB H H306pameHlIJl KO-
nbITHhIX mIlBOTHbIX, 'ITO COfJIacyeTCJl
C rpyrrna 1TI ClomeTOB II Ha OCTaJIbHbIX
TeppllTOp!lHX Clmq,0-cH6HpcKoro 3Bepll-
Horn CTlDH. IhnecTIIhI 3l1.ecb II 11306pa-
meHUJl IJ.C;'IhlX q,uryp (3TO oc06eHHo
OTHOCIITCH K \1I1I\HbIM II KonbITHblM mu-
BOTHbIM). 11 It .\OopaiKeHIIJl IIX 'IaCTeH
(roJIOB. HOT'. .1<1 J/. IWITeH, rJIa3). B co-
OTBeTCTBII!I C OObl'IaeM (<300MOpq,HbIX
IIpeBpamclJuii » oo.T{bIIIaH 'IaCTb H3BeCT-
nbIX 06pa3!10B l\aeT nepenJIeTemW B
H306pameHIfH pa3.1II'InbIX mlIBOTHbIX
HJIH amBOTHhIX II XHIlI,HOR nTHIJ;hI. Ib
<paHTaCTU'leCKHX XHIII,HHKOB pa3Ho06-
pa3HbIMli llIIOCTaCHMH IIpel1.CTaBJIenhI
I'OJIOBbI rpII<p0H()B.
BbIJIBJIJlIOTCH 06Il\lIe 3aKoHoMepnocTII
H B CTHJIHCTHKe. TaK, H3AeJIIIJl VII-
VI BB. 11.0 n. 3. B ocnOBHOM npOJlBJIJlIOT
6JIII30CTb II 3aBliCHMOCTb OT HCKYCCTBa
HaCeJIenlill CeBepHoro IIpn'lepnOMopbH
(JIeCOCTennOR H CTeIIHOH 30n YKpaIIHhI,
KphIMa, TIpHRy6aHbH). C py6ema VI-
V H BIIJIOTb AO KOHD;a IV B. l1.0 H. 3.
<pllKcHpyeTcll npe06JIaAalOIII,aJl 3aBIICII-
MOCTb OT ceBeponpHKaCnIlRCI\HX, cpe;:\-
HeAonCKHX H 60JIee BOCTO'lHhIX 06pa3-
D;OB, a nepeIIJIeTeHUe Bcex 3THX CTIUIU-
CTII'IeCKHX BJIIIJlHIIll: C IICKOHHO MeCT-
nbIMli H306pa311TeJIbHhIMli Tpa/I,HD;nHMII
nopOml1.aeT oc06ylO CJIOmHOCTb U BbI-
'IYPIIOCTb, KOTOpyro npH06peJIn MHorlle
3BeplIHhIe H306pamenIlJl IJ,eHTpa.'lbI/Oro
II CeBepo-BoCTO'IHOrO KaBKa3a.
AmI xapaKTepHCTIiKH c06CTBenl10 1\0-
6anCKoro BapHaHTa cKH<p0-cn6upCl;oro
3BepHHoro CTHJIJl HallMeHbIIIee 3na'le-
HHe IIMelOT HMnopTHLIe H3l1.eJIUJl. Itx
pOJIb ne BblXO/I,HT 3a paMIm KOIICTaTa-
D;HII ne06LI'IafIH0 IIIlIpOKOll pacnpOCTpa-
nennOCTH 06pa3D;oB 3BepHHoro CTIIJIJl.
MomHo paCCMaTpHBaTb IIX II KaK BHeIII-
HHll IIMnYJIbC, cnoco6CTBOBaBIllnlI
npOHHKHOBeHHIO II YTBepmll.eHlllO B 6hl-
TY qymAhIx IIJleMeH IIH03eMHOH MOgbl.
GARaKO B nameM c.1Y'Iae )J.eJIO Ill' or-
paHII'IHBaeTCJl rrpOCTbIM I1M rropTml.
TBOpqeCKH 6eCnJIO):\HbIM R llnopO:\/JOII
cpeAe H He 3aTpaflIBalOIll,IlM CYTif 1l'CT-
Horo HCKYCCTBa, pa3BHBalOIIJ,eroc fI no
CBOIIM c06CTBeHIIblM, B J\opHe OT."JIi'l-
HbIM 3aKOHaM.
B naMJlTHnl\aX Iw6aucI\Oll "y.1hTypbI
KOJIII'IeCTB «'lnCTbIX 3aIfMCTBOBfI /I II II»
06pa311,OB ,lOmHopYCCKoro 3Repn /lOfO
CTIIJIJl He BeJIIfl\O. iho cepfUl ('o.lJ.llnil-
CKIIX» 3epKa.T{ 12 II, BepO.ffTIIo. TilF'!lC
6J1I13Klle KO'IeBHH'leCKOR K:raccm;p Be-
III,H, KaK ry)J.epMeCClmH HaI\OIl("",nK
HomeH co CBepHYBIIIeHCH II iJ/i TP 1'011.
148
opHaMeHTlIpOBaHHbIfI Ka6aHIIii KJILU,
113 HOBOrp03HeHCKoro MOrlIJIbHIIKa I",
KIICJIOBOACKlIii KOCTJIHOii rrca.mii to,
6pOH30BLIe 6JIJIIllKII OT KOHCKOii c6pyn
B rrorpe6eHIIII 64/128 JIyroBoro
MOI'IIJIbHHKa II 6JIJImKa 113 JIyroBO-
1'0 MOI'IIJIbHIIKa B BIIAe opJIa, KJIIO-
lOillero pLI6y 15, 6JIJIIIIKa 113 CTaBpO-
rrOJIbCKoro KypraHa 1883 rOAa 16, ma-
JIymKlIHCKaJI nO,IJ;BeCKa B BIlAe OJIeHbeii
rOJIOBLI I", rrcaJIHII 113 foiiTIIHCKnx 18 II
HeKOTopLIX APyrlIX KypraHoB ", HeKO-
TopLIe 113 MeqeH C KOl'TeBII;:J,HbIM Ha-
BepIIIHeM 20. OHII COCTaB.'1JIIOT He 60JIee
8-10% 06m;ero '1IICJIa IICCJIeAyeMLIX
06pa3D;oB, II He orrpeAeJIJIIOT CKIIq,OIIA-
HOro HaIIpaBJIeHIIJI B MeCTHO { IICKYCCT-
Be. HapJl,JQ' C HIIMII, Ha'lIIHaJI C py6e-
ma VII - VI BB. AO H. s. 3AeCb rrOJIBJIJI-
IOTCJI B 60JIbIIloM KOJIlPIeCTBe BeCbMa
cBoe06pa3HLIe 1I306pameHIIJI mil BOT-
HLIX (ncamlD 113 <DacKay, HaKOHeqHIIKII
HomeH 113 HlImHe-qereMcKoro, K06aH-
CKoro II JJ:lIropCKIIX MOI'IIJIbHIIKOB), KO-
TopLIe HeJIb3JI 6e30roBopO'lHO rrplIqlIc-
JIUTb K KPYry rraMJITHIIKO'B co6cTBeHHo
CKIIq,CKOro IIJIII JII060ro A1'yroro 113
pop;CTBeHHLIX eMY nCKYCCTB (JIeCOCTeII-
Horo TIplIABerrpOBbJI, C1'e;:J,Hero TIo-
AOHbJI, CeBepHoro TI1'IIKaCIIIIJI, TIplI-
Ky6aHbJI II T. A.), XOTJI CBH b IIX co
CKHq,CKIIM 3BeplIHLIM CTIIJIe 1 ne BbI3LI-
BaeT cOMHeHlIii. TIOJIB.'IeHlIe STOro 01'11-
rlIHaJIbROrO HaIl1'aB.'IOHIIJI B IICKyccTBe
aBTOXTOHHLIX I1JIeMeH He1'a31'bIBHo CBJI-
3aHO C BJIIIJIHlIeM COCO;:J,HIIX IeOTCKIIX,
MeOTO-CKIIq,CKIIX 21 II CaIJpOMaTCKIIX
n.'J:eMeH 22, a '1epe3 IIX 110CP('J,CTBO - II
60JIee yp;aJIeHHbIX 06IITaTe,wii EB1'a-
31111, BII.'IOTb AO lOamoii Cn611[JII II AJI-
TaJI. TIoqBoii P;JIJI 3alI ICTBOBaITIiJI pJIp;a
IIp;efl CI\lIq,C'-CII6II1'CKOrO 3BPpnITOro CTII-
.'IJI I1OCJIym'l'!:IO BbIC-OKOpa3BJlTOO I13001'a-
3I1TeJIbHOe IICKYCCTBO Koaa lIo;oii Ky.'1b-
TypLI. MeCTHbIe MaCTepa O'iellb 6bICT1'O
I1epeHJI.'I1I ocnOBHbIe CXe {bI n CTII.'IIiCTII-
qeCKlIe IIplIeMbI lIC-h-YCCTBa CBOliX ce-
BepHLIX coce;:J,eii, '1aCTb KOTr'pbIX K TO-
MY me 06IITaJIa B HeIlocpeACTBeHHOll:
6JI1130CTil - B CTenJIX TIpeAKaBKa3bJI II
Ha paBillmax CeBe1'Horo KaBKa3a. B
pe3YJIbTaTe B3alIMOAeiicTBIIJI Ha3BaH-
HbiX TeHp;eHD;IIH II B03HIIK CIIeD;IIq,H'le-
CKIIH BaplIaHT B CKIIq,0-CII6IIpCKOM 3Be-
plIHOM CTIIJIe, OTMeqeHHbIll: TeM, qTO
I1pe CTaBJIJIlOilllle ero 1I3AeJIHJI AalOT
He CJIerroe I10ApaJKaHlIe KOqeBHlIqeCKOii
KJIaCCIIKe, a 3aMeTHYlO TBOpqecKylO
I1epepa60TKY MOTIIBOB, cxeM II I1plIeMOB.
BaJKHO 3aMeTIITb, qro 3Ha'lHTeJIbHaJI
qaCTb 300MOpqIHLIX ClOmeTOB <pIIKcn-
pyeTCJI Ha npeAMeTax IICKOHHO MeCT-
I1LIX TIIIIOB (npJIJKKH, 6pOH30BLIe I10JI-
ca, I1ocYAa, YKpameHIIJI II T. n.), II 110
cpaBHeHlI10 C c06cTBeHHo KOqeBHII'Ie-
CKIIMII ApeBHOCTJIMH apceHan AeKoplI-
poBaHHLIx 1I3AeJIlIH TYT 3HaqlITeJIbHO
IllII1'e. 06paillaeT Ha ce6JI BHIIMaHlIe
I10JIHOe rr1'e06JIaAaHIIe CJIyqaeB BOIlJIO-
illeHIIJI ClOmeTOB CKII<Po-CII6IIpCKoro
3BeplIHoro CTIIJIJI B 6poH3e - 1I3JI106-
JIeHIIOM MeTaJIJIe K06aHD;eB. JJ:(>(;TaTOq-
HO peAKlIe I10Ka HaxoAKII KOCTJIHLIX II
poroBbIx I1peAMeToB, BLIIIOJIHeHHbIX B
3BeplIHoM CTIIJIe (MIIHepanbHLIe BoJJ.I>I,
KIICJIOBOACK, MaJIr06eK, fORTbI, TJIII,
AJIJIe1'Oll, HOBOrp03HLIii), CTIIJIIICTlIqe-
CKII JIII60 60JIee Bcero 6JI1I3J{1I KOqeB-
HlIqeCKIIM STaJIOHaM II rrplIeMaM p;eKopH-
pOBKII, JIII60 AeMoHcTplIPYIOT HalI60JIee
CJIOmHOe I1epeIlJIeTeHlle 1I306pa3IITe.'Ib-
HbiX I11'lIeMOBII TpaKToBoK pa3HbIx Ba-
plIaHToB CKuq,CKoro IIcKyccTBa.
BecbMa I10Ka3aTeJIeH II caM COCTaB
300MOP<PHbIX 06pa30B, xapaKTe1'HbIx
P;JIJI CKIIq,OIIP;HLIX 1I306pameHIIii CeBep-
Horo KaBKa3a. 3p;eCb IIJIII BOBce HeT
MHOI'll X MOTIIBOB 3BeplIHoro CTIIJIJI, IIO-
I1YJIJIpHbIX IIJIII XOTJI 6bI 1I3BeCTHbIX y
I11'lIqe1'HOM01'CKlIX CKII<P0B (K03e.'I. JIeB,
1'bI6a, JIOrna)J,b-MYJI), caB1'OMaTOB (:reB,
JIomap;b, Be1'6JIIO)J;, caiira, pbI6a), HO-
c-IITeJIeii TarapcKoll KYJIbTY1'bI (K03eJI
JIomap;b, OCeJI-KYJIaH, Bep6JIIOp;, calI-
raK), 1I.'11I OHII I11'ep;CTaBJIeHbI JIIImb
ep;IIHlIqHbBIil Haxop;KaMII (.'IaHb -1,
149
TYP -1, JIOCb -1, Berrpb -2, MeA-
BeAb -2). B CyIqHOCTH me D;eJIble <pII-
rypbl H rOJIOBbI 300MOP<pHbIX ClOmeTOB
AalOT CTporo OrpalIH'IeHHblH Kpyr H306-
pameHHH. XIIIQHaJI nTHD;a (qaCTO C
<paHTaCTHqeCKHMH npH3HaKaMH rpH<p0-
Ha), 6JIar(\poAHbIH OJIeHb, naHTepa
(6apc), BOJIK H BOJIK006pa3HblH XHIQ-
HHK (6apcO-BOJIK) - BOT Ha60p OCHOB-
nblX MOTHBOB, 6e3pa3AeJIbHO rocrrOA-
CTBOBaBIIIHX B CKH<POHAHOM 3BepilHOM
CTHJIe IIpeAKaBKa3bJI. Bbl60p 3TOT OT-
HIOAb He CJIyqaeH. OH He TOJIbKO COOT-
BeTcTByeT MeCTHOH <paYHe - OJIeHb, KO-
rnaqIlH XHID;HHK H XHIqHaJI nTHD;a 6blJIII
rocrrOACTBYIOIIJ;JIMH TpaAHD;HOITITbIMil
MOTII"BaMH B K06aHCKOM II KOJIXITACKOM
HCKYCCTBax. II. C. YBapOBa, HarrplIMep,
cnpaBeWIHBO OTMeqaJIa, qT(\ «3BeplIHbIii
OpHaMeITT» K06aHH «CBOAHTCJI eAHHCT-
BeHIIO K nJITH 3K3eMnJIJIpaM mIlBOTHoro
D;apCTBa: 6JIaropo)I,Horo OJIeHJI, rraHTe-
pbl, JIOIQaAH, pbl6bl H 3MelI, rrpHqeM
nOCJIeAHITe TPH npeACTaBlITeJIJI... Ha-
CTOJIbKO pe;L(KH, qTO HX MomHO rrepeIT-
MeHOBaTb no 3K3eMrrJIJIpaM» Z3. K :)TOM\,
CJIeAyeT A06aBHTb, qTO H 06pa3 XIIIQllOii
nTHD;bl, qaCTO OTMeqeHHoii <paHTaCTIT-
qeCKIIMH qepTaMH (nTHD;a C rOJIoBoii
6apaITa), 6blJI CBOHCTBeH paHHeH 1\0-
6aHH". LITO me KaCaeTCJI CTpaIllloro
3BepJI (6apCO-BOJIKa), TO ero npOTOTIl-
nOM, HeCOMHeHITO JIBJIJIeTCH TaK lIa3bl-
BaeMblH «<paHTaC;HqeCKIIii XITII HIII;» I1a
Torropax, rrpJIiKKaX IT APyrnx 6pO\l30-
BbIX H3AeJIIIJIX HaqaJIa I TbIC. 110 II. :).
Ero 06JIHK rrOpOAHJI pa3lIOrJIaCIlH B
Kpyrax apxeOJIOrOH II HChYCCTBOBCJlOB
(II. C. YBapoBa, E. 11. KpYIIIlOB.
O. A. ApTaMoHoBa-TIOJITaBT:\eBa C'''ITa-
lOT, qTO 3TO KOIIIaqITH XITlllHIII,; III. H.
AMITpaHaIIIBllJIIl - BOJIK, A. A. MfI:l-
JIep - c06aKa, B. B. Eap;:raBemCBC-
c06aKO-BOJIK). B caMOM ,Je:re, 3HC]1I.
06'beAITITlleT B ce6e 'IepTbI BCe\ H a3Hall-
HbIX XITID;HIIKOB, nOA06Ho Gapco-no.1E\,
Ha 300MOP<PHbIX H3AeJIITJIx yme CI;lllI)-
CKOro BpeMeHH.
113 II3JII06JIeHHblX MeCTHblX MOTHBOB
paHee Bcero 06pa60The nOA CKll<pCKHM
H03AeiicTBHeM nOABeprCJI OJIaropo;L(-
HblH OJIeHb, qTO XOpOlliO <pllKclipyeTCJI
B naMHTRITKaX BTOpoii nO.'IOBITllbI VII-
lIaqaJIa VI B. AO H. 3. (M03AOK, HHm-
HIIH LIereH, JI06Ko-MaxIT). Ho cneD;H-
<pITKa K06aHcKoro BaprraHTa OTpa3HJIaCb
He TOJIbKO B oT60pe mH3Hecnoc06HblX
B MecTHOH cpeAe MOTlIBOB. Ero CBoe-
06pa3ITe BblpamaeTCIl npemAe BCer(\ B
coxpaneHlIIT H OpraImqeCKOM HCnOJIb-
30BaHITIT (BrrpOqeM, HHorAa II B <pop-
laJIbHoM) HeKoTopbIX 3JIeMeHTOB KO-
oaHCKoro HCKyccTBa, JIpKO BbIcTynaIO-
ID;RX B pa3pa60TKe n03bl, TpaKToBKe OT-
AeJIbHblX AeTaJIeU H opHaMeHTIIKe H306-
pameHHJI mHBOTHblX. TaK, OqeBHAHO,
IICKOHITblM AJIJI CeBepHoro KaBKa3a
MomHO CqHTaTb n03Y OJIeHJI «Ha nyaH-
Tax.), 3a<pHKCHpOBaUIIYIO ;L(JIJI Bcex 6e3
ITCKJIlOqeITHJI <pHryp CTOJIm;HX OJIeHeH
(PITc. 1, 53), BblnOJIITeHHbIX 3;L(eCb C
;1.leMeI;lTaMH CKH<pCKOH CTHJIH3aD;HH.
ToqIlo TaK me TYT, KaK HHr;L(e 60JIee,
npe06JIaAaJOT H306pameHHJI MeHJI, ro-
:\OBa KOToporo nOBepnYTa Ha3aA, ony-
ll\eHa EHII3, JIH60 pa3MeIQeHa em;e KaK-
UIT6YAb He06blqITO WIJI haHOHOB 3BepH-
1I0ro CTlIJIJI IOra POCCHH (OJIeHH H3
I'oHTbl, PYTXH, <DacKay, AHH-Mp30,
pITC. 1, 47 -52, 55). 06e 3TH qepTbl 'HMe-
lOT MeCTHbIe npOTOTITrrbI, H3BeCTHble B
lIaMJITHITKaX K06aHCKoro H KOJIXHACKO-
fO HCKYCCTB rrpe;wreCTBYlOru;HX BeKOB.
1\ aBKa3CKHe TpaAHl\ITII 3aMeTHbl B npo-
1I0Pl\ITHX TeJI IIO'ITII Bcex CKIT<P0IIAllblX
lIa06pameHITH OJIellCH IJ;eHTpaiIbHoro
\[ CeHepo-BoCTO'IHOrO KaBKa3a, qTO
oblJIO nOAMeqeHO M. 11. ApTaMOHO-
BblM Z5. BIIAHbl 3TH TpaAITD;HIT H B Ae-
hOpaTIIBH 0<p0pM.ICHHII 300MOp<pHbIX
11306pameJlnii (amYPHocTb a6COJIIOTIlO-
1"0 OO.'lbIIIITHCTBa H3Ae.lIIH, opnaMeITTa-
!llIJI TpeyroJIbHITKaMII, crrITpaJIJIMIT, Ha-
CeqKaMll, 3aIIITprrxoBanHbIMH JIHHHJIMII;
nOAqepRHYToe I1300pameHITe IIIepcTH
na TeJle IT T. A.).
1.')0
C APyroii CTOpOHbl. BCCbMa Bblpa3I1-
Te.TIbHblII BIIA I1ehOTOpbIM, II300pameHII-
JIM rrpIl;J;aeT COqeTaIIIIe 3JIeMeHTOB, xa-
paI\TepHbIX II.TIH pa3JIIIqHblX BapnaHTOB
CKII<po-cnOllpCl,oro 3BepHHoro CTllJIJI
EBpa3I1n. IIOA06HbIii CllHKpeTH3M rrpll-
t:YIQ MIIonlM caMbl 1 IIpKlIM MeCTlIblM
IIaxOAI\a !. cneIwaJIbHO rrpOallaJIIT31IpO-
BalIHblM B .TJIITepaType (3aKyrbl, AHH-
Ifp30, :\Ia:IrooeJ>, A:I:lepO!I, HOBorp03 l
HbIU II T. II. (pIiC. 1) Z6.
IIo;:J;'Iac IexaHII'IeCKII flCnOJIb3YJI Te
UJIIT IIHble 3aITMCTBOBaHHble cxeMbl H
CTITJIITCTII'IeChITe rrplle Ibl CKH<p0-CH6HP-
CKoro 3BepIIHoro CTII.lJI, MeCTHble Ma-
CTepa .JorrYChaJIH BOJIbHOCTH II npHAa-
BaJlII n300pameHIlilM H BOBce He06bl'I-
HbIii, IIHorJ\a Aame BbrqYPHbIrr BH;L(, KO-
TOpblii xapahTepll3yeT TaKHe rneAeBpbI
R06alIcJ>oro BapITaHTa, RaK HaKOITeqHH-
:Jill nomelI 113 MIIHepaJIbHblX BOA, 3a-
KYTOB (CoBeTcKoe), AITH-I1p30 (B noc-
JH'AHe 1 c:TY'Iae II 06hJIaAKH PYKOJITKH),
rOHTTHlcKHC rpe6HH, IIIanyIIIKIIHCKHe
ncamIl!. <pachaycchYIO rrpJImKY, MaJI-
r06cKchYlO II aJIJIepOeBcKyIO PYKOJITH
Homeii II T. A. IIepeI,pyqeITHOCTb He
3a)T.I1eii. a rrepelllleH qaCTII TYJIOBIIru;a
ann -lIpaoiiclioro IT 60.TIbIIIOro rOIITHH-
CKOro a.leHeh 2', He06bIqHOe pa3Meru;e-
TIIlC nor .TIaHII na Ma.rIOM rOHTIIHCKOM
rpe6ne. ;T.BC rrapbI ywerr y MHHepaJIO-
BO)T.c!\oii naHTepbI, pa3Mem;eHHe 6apco-
BOJI\{()H na rr:TOCKOCTII KpbIJIbeB OpJIO-
BII)T.JlbI\ o:THX, TlJIIa HaiiAemIOrr B I1CTH-
Cy, Op.lllllblP rO.IOBbl BMeCTO XBOCTOB
y «C!,peG 'u Il\CH» fi06aHcfiIlx no 06JIH-
Ky XIlll\H[[hOB IT3 Ka36eKCKoro K.TIaAa,
HaT;O!!(>Il. OpllrIIHa.lbHaJI TpaKToBr;a l\e-
JIoii rp .llnbl ceBepo-oceTHHCKIIX OJIe-
HeiL- \lOT AaJIeKO He rrOJIHbIH CHOA Bbl-
HB:ICl!llbl\ IlpIl aHa:TII3e ITCXOAHOro Ma-
TepIIa.lil hil3YCOB, CBITAeTeJIbCTBYIOIQHX
o TO I. 'ITO III II POKlI!1 apeaJI 3aII ICTBO-
BalIHll Ol' 1 II rrpIle IOB CTlliIII3anITIl B
CO'leTii II II II C pa3BIITbIMH MeCTIlbIMll
Tpa:aIlUlH !II 300MOp<pHOH nJIaCTIIhIT )T.a-
l\iI.l 00:1 hlllOii rrpoCTop .JJIJI HeCTaH)JapT-
HbTX perncHHH B pacKpbTTIIII rroIlYJIHp-
HblX MOTHBOB, cTporo KaHOHIT3UpOBan-
rrbTX B OCHOBHblX 06JIaCTHX 6bIToBaHIIH
C KII<p0-CH6ITpCKOrO 3BepilHoro CTIIJIII.
OAHoBpeMeHno nIl OTKJlOHeIlIIH OT HOp-
Mbl qaCTO JIBJIJIJIHCb CJIeACTBIleM rpy6blx
olUu60K H HenOHHManITIl I!CTIlHIlOro co-
;L(epmanHJI Torr MOAeJIH, hOTOpYK) hO-
nHpoBaJI HJIH KOToporr nOApama.l haB-
Ka3CKIlH IOBeJIHp, opyme!IHur; n:m
KOCTope3.
HaCI\OJIbKO CeHqaC Momno CY;T.IITb,
C03AaTeJIJIMH paCCMaTpllBaeMoro BaplI-
aHTa CI\H<p0-CH6HpCKoro 3BepHHoro CTII-
JIJI 6blJIH K06aHCRHe rrJIeMena, r.TIaBHbIM
06pa30M nJIOCKOCTHblX IT npeArOpITbiX
pa!IOHOB, H mHBIIIHe BrrepeMemI\y C HU-
MH CTenHJIRH - OCKO.TIKIT ehIT<pClmx oPA
V B. AO H. a. H aBaHrap;T.Hble rpyrrrrbi
caBpOMaTOB 28. TIaMJITHITha 1 ropIlbIX
K06aHu;eB no 060IlM CKJIOHaM f.laBHoro
KaBKa3CIwro xpe6Ta CI\Il<pOIlAHble
H306pameHIIJI npHCyrIJ,H MeHLIIlC (y
HIIX Ha npOTJImeHHII Bcell cr;Il<pChorr
3nOXil COXpaHJIIOTCJI Tpa)T.IIl\11li IIChon-
HO MecTHoro HeKYCCTRa, )T.oIIICAnme AO
Hac B MaCCOBbIX HaxOAr;ax hOOi1J1CKOH
aHTporrOMop<pHOH H 30mlOp<pHoii rrJIa-
CTIlKII). B03MOmITO, 'ITO 60JIblUaH 'IaCTb
H3 HIIX rrocTyrraJIa OT CCBepnbl\ POAII-
qeH - mITTe.leii rrpeArOp!!H II paB!!ITH 29.
MHorHe BbIcOKoropHbIe 06pa31 bl (IT3-
AeJIlIJI Ka36eKcKoro h:T, a;T,a :\lOrn:lbTIlI-
ROB TJIIT, <Dachay, PYTXfI) eme rIlJILHee
OTJInqalOTCJI OT hO'ICBIIIi'IPCIWii Ii:laCCH-
KII: B IiHX JlIlIIIb C TPY)T.OM yra;T.bIRaeTCJI
ee BJIIIHHlle.
IIOCT-XapaqOeBCRHe n.le I(>\I,' IOro-
BOCTO'IHOii LIe'IHII (1141\Cpllll) ol\aaa-
JIIICb <paI\THqeCJ>IT B CTOpollC 0 r UflBOl1
MO}I.bI, B IlX na IJITHITKa\ 06P":Hlbl ChI!-
cPo-CI!6ITpChOrO 3BepilHom CTlI:1 H II nOA
pamalOIQITe HM Il300pilrr;(>IIl\H 1;!laiine
peAJ>IT IT XY.JOiKeCTBeHHO la:I"I<I.\pa31I-
TeJIbHbT, 3a ITCh.'IIO'IeHI!e 1 TP \ r.lyqa-
eB, KorAa peqb HAeT 00 H3;le.-'llflX. rro-
rraBlUHX cIO.Ja OT J>ooancr;I1\ "(Jce.Je!I
(HarrpIIMep. nTIIl\eBIl,JIIble 1I(I}lCllbIe
151
6JHIXH H3 XapaqOR, IJ,a-BeAeHO, XaT-
TYHH) 30. B Aa1'eCTalle HrnOJIb30BaHHe
a60pH1'eHa1.UI CRHq,0-CH6npCKoro 300-
Mopq,H01'O HCRy,CCTBa IllJIO HeCROJIbRO
HHbIMH nYTRMH, qeM Y K06aHn;eB 31.
HOBbIe pacKoIllilI naMRTIIHKOB CRII<p-
, A. A. Hecceu. CeBepO-l<aBIla3CI<JIe COCYAbl
C 1I306pameHlIeU OJIeHJl. Cf AI1!\1K, 1931,
T. 2, CTp. 14-18; au :!/Ce. !\103P:OKCKlIll MO-
rlIJIbHIIK B PIiAY lIa [JlTHIII<OB CeBepHoro
KaBKaaa. «M03AOKCKuii MOrIIJIbHlIK . JI.,
1940, CTp. 46.
2 E. II. AJl.el>ceeea. TI03;J,HcKoGalicKall KYJIb-
Typa qeHTpaJIbHOrO KaBl<a3a. Y3JIry,
Bblil. 13, 1949, CTP. 103.
3 O. A. ApTaM.OIlOea-IIo.1TaelJeea. KYJIbTypa
IIJIeMeH CeBepo-BoCT0'1I10ro KaBKaaa B
CKII<pCKlIH rrepnoA. CA, T. 14. M.- J1., 1950.
I B. B. BUIlozpaiJoe. Cap [aTbI CeBepo-Bo-
CTOqHOro KaBKa3a. I'P03I1bIii, 1963; B. B.
BUIlozpaiJoe, A. H. m "YPl>O. a HeKoTopblX
npeAMeTax 3BeplIHoro CTIIJIJl 1I3 qeHT-
paJIbHOrO IIpeAJ;aBKa3bll B CKII<pcKoe Bpe-
MJl. «C60pHIIK i\OKiIaAoB Ha VI 11 VII
BACK». M., 1963.
5 B. B. Texoe. a HeKoTopbIX IIpeilMeTax aBe-
plIHoro CIHI<pCKOro CTI[. Jl JI3 lIaMJlTHlIKOB
IOmHoro CllJiOUa f:lalllIoro KaBKaacKoro
xpe6Ta. «Tp3I!CbI 1I0J;:Jai\OB III BcecolOa-
HOII KOIl<pepeUl\IIII 110 UCCA . M., 1972.
· B. B. BuuoepaiJoe. I.(cIITpaJIbHbIii: 11 CeBe-
pO-BOCTO'1HbIll KallJ;a3 II Cli.ll<pcKoe BpeMJl
(VII-IV Bll. i\0 II. ;}.). fP03HbIlI, 1972,
CTp. 140-180.
1 M. H. ApTaM.Ol/oe. IIPOUCXO;I;;1eHlIe CKII<p-
CKOro IICKYCCTBa. CA, 1968, .'12 4, CTp. 27.
· B. B. BUIlozpaiJoe. I.(PHTpaJIbHbIII II CeBe-
pO-BOCTO'1HbIll KaBKa3.., CTp. 31; ou :lICe.
HOBbIe Haxoi\KII IJpell leToB CKII<pO-CII-
6lIpCKoro 3BepllHoro l'TII.1Jl B 'Ie'1eHo-HlI-
rYIIIeTIIII. CA, 1974, :'\; 't. CTp. 258.
9 E. H. Kpynlloe. ppnURJl I1CTOpIIJl CeBep-
Horo KaBIla3a. M., 1960; B. B. Texoe.
TJIlIllCKlIll MorU.lblll!l1 II IJp06.1e la xpOHO-
JIOrlIII KYJIbT 'p l(ellTpa.%Horo KaBKa3a.
CA, 1972, N. 3, CTp. 18; H. B. A Il!fjuMoe.
CJIOmeHne MeOTClloii I\y.lbT 'pbI II CBJl31I
ee co CTeIlHJ,[ 1U Ky.lbTypa 1I! CeBepHoro
IIplI'1epHoMopbJl. nc \ \1., 1"7[, CTp. 170.
,0 B. B. BUI/ozpadoe. 1["IITpa.%HbIll II CeBe-
pO-BOCTOqHJ.lii l\aBlld.L, CTp. 140.
11 B 3TY IJ0;1001'1IY lIauoo:lee JlpKlIX 06pa3-
OB 3BepHHoro eTlUII liP BK.llOqeHbI Ma-
TeplIaJIbI C IOmHoro <' II.lOlia KaBKaacKoro
CR01'O BpeMeHH CeBepHoro HaBRa3a pac-
IlIHpRlOT H ROHRpeTH3HpYlOT Hallill
lIpeACTaBJIeHHSI 06 oplIrn:HaJIbHOH rpyn-
lIe MeCTHbIX lIpeAMeToB 3BepHHo1'O CTlI-
JISI, ROTopaSI BbI)WJIReTCR HblHe.
xpe6Ta, Clle lIaJIbHO 1ICCJIeAyeMbie E. B.
TexoBbl31.
12 CBOAKY CM.: B. B. BUIlozpaiJoe. IJ;eIIT-
paJIblIblll 11 CeBepo-BoCToqHblH KaBIIa3..,
CTp. 135-138.
13 B. B. BUIlozpaiJoe. HOBbie HaxoAKlI.., CTp.
259, plIC. 1, 2, 4.
U E. H. Kpynno8. YKa3. cotJ., Ta6JI. 14, 9.
IS P. M. M YIl'laee. JIyroBoH MOrIIJIbIIIIK.
A'IH. M., 1963, puc. 7, 1-2; plIC. 29, 13,
16,17.
16 B. B. BUIlozpaiJoe. qeHTpaJIbHblH U CPBC-
pO-BOCTOqHblH KaBKa3.., plIC. 3, 7.
17 TaM me, pllC. 4, 2.
18 B. H. Mapl>OeUil. CKlI<pCKue KypraHbl y
CeJIeHlIli fOHTbI. CA, 1965, .M 2, CTp. 165.
19 B. B. BUIlozpaiJoe. qeIITpaJIbHbIiI u CeBe-
pO-BOCTOqHblii: KaBKa3.., CTp. 130-135.
20 TaM me, CTp. 106-107.
21 B. H.,rpa,,06. CKIIq.LI. M., 1971; H. B. An-
!fjuM.oe. K BOIIPOCY 0 aBeplIHoM CTlIJIe y
MeOTOB. «Te3lIcbI )J;OKJIaAOB II I BceCOI03-
HOff KOH<pepeH lIlI 110 BCCA . M., 1972,
CTp. 14-15.
22 [(. (/J. CMUp1t06. CaBpoMaTbI. M., 1964.
23 II. C. Yeaposa. MOrlIJIbHIIKH CeBeplioro
KaBKaaa. MAK, T. 8. M., 1900, CTP. 42.
24 E. H. [(pynn06. YKaa. CO'I., Ta6JI. 5, 49,
II AP.
25 M. H. ApTaMoJt08. ¥K33. COtt., CTp. 31-32.
26 CM. pa60TbI E. II. AJIeKCeeBoii:, O. A. Ap-
TaMoHoBoH-IIoJITaB eBoH, B. E. BlIHorpa-
. AOBa, A. H. illKypKO, HaaBaHHble B Haqa.le
C.TaTblI.
27 Ha CapaTOB lIHe lIaBeCTHO 6JIlI3110e 1130-
6pameHIIe OJIeHJl, OTMe'leHHOe 'lepTa 1I1
BJIIIJlHlIJl KaBKa3CKoro IICKYCCTBa.
28 B. B. BUIlozpaiJoe. IJ;eIlTpaJIbHblii II Cr--
Bepo-BoCTO'lHbIll KaBKa3.., CTp. 39-40.
29 K aIlaJIOrlI'lHOMY BblBOAy IIpIIIIIeJI II E. R.
TexoB (CM.: B. B. Texoe. a HeKoTopblX
IIpeAMeTal'L., CTp. 40).
30 B. B. Bu¥zpa{}oe. qellTpaJIbHbIii II Ccne-
PO-BOCTO>IrIbIff KaBKa3.., CTp. 264-283.
31 O. M. /f,aeyiJoe. 3BeplIHblii CTIIJIb B HCI<YC-
CTBe AarecTaHa 3110XlI paHHero meJIe3a II
pOJIb CKlI<pOB B ero <pOpMlIpoBaHlIlI. «Te-
311Cbl )];OKJIaAOB III BcecolO3Holl Il0ll<pe
peH RlI 110 BCCA». M., 1972, CTp. 24.
B. B. TeXOB
o HEROTOPbIX lIP E,IJ;MET AX
CRM<DCROrO 3BEPI1HOrO CTlfJUI
113 IIAMHTHI1ROB IOJKHOrO CRJIOHA
r HOrO RABKA3CROrO XPEBTA
llJIeMeHa HaB:Ka3a, IJ,eHTpaJIbHoro B oco-
6eHHOCTH, B I'OHD;e II H Ha'IaJIe I TbIC.
AO H. '<I. 6bIJIH H3BeCTHbI RaR HCKYCHbIe
MaCTepa lIO H3I'OTOBJIeHHlO pa3Ho06pa3-
HbIX 6POH30BbIX 1I3AeJfHff, ROTopbIe
YRparnaJIHCb 601'aTbIMH, lIOpOIO CJIom-
HbIMH, OpHa'MeHTaJIbHbIMH MOTHBaMH.
CpeM HHX HeMaJIo H306pameHHH CTH-
.'I1I30BaHHbIX HJIH <paHTaCTK'IeC:KHX mH-
BOTHbIX (pHe.. 1).
OC06bIM 601'aTcTBoM H CJIOmHOCTblO
opHaMeHTaJIbHbIX MOTHBOB BbIp;eJUIIOTCSI
6poH30BbIe 60eBbIe TOlIOpbI, <PH6YJIbI,
npSImRH, lIORca H3 JIHCTOBOH 6pOH3bI,
1I0mHbIe ROJIbn;a H T. A. Ha aTHX npeA-
MeTax TeJIO H306pamaeM01'O 3BepH qa-
CTO nOKpbIBaeTCSI IIeCKOJIbRlIMH BII,L\aMII
Y30pa, cpeAH KOTOpbIX AOMHHHpYlOlQee
MeCTO 3aHHMaeT eJIoqRa. H'MeIOTcR TaR-
iKe H306pameHHR He6eCHbiX CBeTH.'I,
nOMonWHHbIx KaR Ha Tonopax, TaR II
lIa nOHcax. lJacTo Te.'IO OCHOBlIOtI'O iKH-
BOTlioro nOKpblBiJeTCSI <pHrypaMII II.1IH
qaCTSIMH Te.TJa APyrlIx mHBOTHbIX. Bre
anI H306pameHHR COCTaBJISIIOT KaBKa3-
nmiI 3BepHHbIli CTIWb. H VII B. AO H. a.
B RYJIbType 1I.1eMeH IJ,eHTpa.'lbH01'O
haBKa:la nORB,lHIOTCH HOBbIe aJle reIlTbI
CTIIJIH3al\IIH mHBOTHbIX, B q,opMnpOBa-
HUH KOTOpbIX MeCTHaH nO'IBa Cblrpa:Ja
;maqHTe.lbHYW POJIb. KOMnOHeHTbI aTO-
[0 CTII.IR OKa3a:IHCb OqeHb 6JIH3fIHMlI
" CKHq,CROMY ;IBepHHO IY CTHJIIO. O;:J,Ha-
KO HX HeJIb3H CqHTaTb qHCTO Clillq,-
CKHMH; OHH TeCHO CBSI3aHbI C H306pa-
3HTeJIbHbIM IICKYCCTBOM lIpeAIIIeCTBYIO-
m;ero nepHoAa.
IIORBIIBIIIlIliCH C VII B. AO H. a. I3Be-
plIHblii CTII:Jb pa3BHBaeTCSI B :KaBKa3-
CROff cpeAe H lOmeT HaHTH 06'bRCHe-
lIHe B pa3BIITIIH KaBRa3CROH lI03,II,He-
6p01l30BOll j,y.lbTypbI. IIpeAMeTbI, CO-
AepmaBllilIe 1I306pameHHSI CKH<pCR01'O
THna, I13roTOB.leHbI, 6e3YCJIOBHO, PYRa-
MH MeCTlIbIX MaCTepOB, ROTopbIe 6bIJfH
XOpOIiiO 3IIal((} IbI C HCRYCCTBOM coceA-
HHX HapO,L\OB, B TOM 'IHCJIe H CRHq,OB.
IIp06.1e Ia CRlIq,CI\Oro 3BepHHoro CTH-
JIR 3aTparHBa aCb MHOrHMH Cnen;HaJIH-
CTa fIl KaK O;:J,Ha II3 CTOpOH 06IQeH
CKIlq,n;oii np06.1eMbI. OHa HalliJIa CBoe
OTpameHlle ne TOJIbRO B TpYAax HCCJIe-
AOBaTe.leii CenepH01'O IIpH'IepHOMopbR,
Cpe,L\neii A3I1II 11 CU6HPH, HO H B pa-
6oTax, rrOCBHlQellHbIX CeBepHOMY KaB-
Ka3Y n :18.I;ilBf;a3blO.
B IICTOPII'f(>('fIOH .1HTepaType Heo;::(-
lIohpaTno npnnO;J:I1JIOCb C006IQeHHe re-
P0;:{OTiI ° Tn l. 'ITO CRHq,bI, COBeprnaR
rBon nO\O;lhf B IIepe;:J,HIOIO H Ma.rryro
A3IIIO. fIPO [l' !eOTO-hOJIXHACROll ):(OPO-
rII II rrYTIf III) lIo6epea\blO KacnHllCflO1'O
IOpH. nl) lJ.ep6eIlTChO IY npOXO,L\y, HC-
rrO.lb:lona:1 If If lIellOTopbIe APyrn:e rrYTH
r.lanlloro ]{ ilRha3CKoro xpe6Ta, B tJaCT-
1I0rT!! II r){):,\O:ILI l\eHTpaJIbHOll qaCTH
BO;fbIlloru ])"aIlRa3a '. O,L\HaRO npO,L\Bn-
lli('IIIfe Chl[(I'OB no aTHM nYTRM B Ha-
CTOHlllee Rpe IH He;:J,OCTaTOqHO no,L\-
TBepiK.leIfO :liHlHbIMII apXeOJIorn:H. aTO
153
oc06ellHO 3aMeTHO rro MaTepUaJIaM IOm-
Horo CKJlOna, I'): e BbU! B.rleHO He3HaqlI-
Te:rbHoe KOJIUqeCTBO 3JIeMeUTOB CKH<p-
cI,oro 3BepilHoro CTIIJIH, HaCTOJIbKO
neperr:IeTeHHbIX C 06pa3aMil II opHaMeH-
rMIbHbIMIl MOTIlBaMH MeCTHbIX KaBKa3-
C};HX n.rIeMeH, qTO HX TpYiJ.HO BbI)I;eJIRTb
B caMOCTOHTeJIbHyJO rpyrrrry. TeM He
leHee IICCJIe)l;OBaTeJIJIM p;peBHero rre-
pllop;a IICTOpll1l CeBepHoro KaBKa3a II
3al;aBI.;a3bH yp;aJIOCb HaiiTU OT)I;eJThHble
3.'leMeRTbl CKH<pCKoro 3BepUHoro CTIIJIH
lIa 06IIIIIpHOii TeppllTopIIII ApMerrHII,
A3ep6aiip;maHa, rpY31I1I U ceBepHoro
CI;.'lOlla rJIaBHOrO KaBKa3cKoro xpe6Ta.
OnICTUM, O)l;HaKO, qTO rraMJITHHKaM
ropHblX paiIOHOB IJ;eHTpaJIbHOrO KaBKa-
3a II306pameHIIJI CKII<pCKOro TlIrra rrplI-
cyrn.u MeHbIIIe, TaK KaK 60raTbIe Tpa-
p;rr 1I1I MecTHoro 1I306pa3IITeJIbHOrO HC-
KYCCTBa B TeqeHlle BeKOB COXpaHJIJIII
CBOIO mlIByqecTb KaK B MeJllioo6'beMHoii,
TaK U B 300MOp<pHOii IIJIaCTIlKe II rpa-
<pH'leCKOM UCKYCCTBe. Ho HeCMOTpJI Ha
:.IT 0, rop bI IJ;eHTpaJIbHOrO KaBKa3a B
KOH e II II B nepBoii nOJIOBIlHe I TbIC.
;\0 H. 3. He MOrJIII OKa3aTbCH B CTopOHe
OT BJIIIJIHIIJI KaK 3aKaBKa3CKoii H ne-
jJl','J,Hea3HaTCKoii IIBIIJIII3a lIii, TaK H
IICKOTOpblX 06pa30B CKII<pCKorO 3Beplil-
!loro CTRJIJI.
Ern.e B 1914 r. B 6b1BIIIIIH KaBKa3-
Cl\IIii MY3eii (HblHe rocy apCTBeHHbIii
[Y3eii rpY3IIH IIMell1l aKa)];eMHKa
C. H. ,l],mallaIIIlIa) 1I3 BbICOKo1'OpHoro
Cf':W PYK (IOro-OceTuH) rrocTyrrlIJIII
;tBiI npe)l;MeTa, O)l;II11 1I3 KOTOpbIX npe)];-
naBJIHeT c060ii 6pOH30BbIII HaKOlIeqHHK
lIOiReH C BnlIcaUHbIM B Hero 1I306pame-
IIIIL'M cBepllYBIIIerocH B nOJIYKOJIbll,O
XlIlIlHoro mllBOTHoro KOIIIaqbeH nopo-
.1 hi (pnc. 2, 1). OrrlIcbIBaH 310T npe)l;-
IL'T. B. A. KY<PTIlII Ha3bIBaeT ero 6POH-
:!<lBbIM HaBepmlIeM II OTHO<:IIT K paHHe-
Clm<pcI{OH 3noxe 2. OH cpaBHHBaeT ero
L' OpOH30BblM HaBepmueM U3 C. <DacKay,
y"parneHHbIM 1I306pameHIIeM CBepHY-
101'0 B nonyKOJIbIJ;O XIIrn.HIIKa KOrnaqbeii
nOpO)];bI, Ha Clllllle KOTOpOro 1I0Mern.ell<l
rOJIOBa XIIrn.Horr rrTII bI (opJIa) 3.
Ha CeBepROM l-laBl,a3e nOil,06HaH Ma-
Hepa CTRJIII3a 1I1I 6b1JIa pacrrpOCTpaHe-
Ha B TeqeHUe il,o.'I1'Oro BpeMeHII, no
KpaiiHeiI Mepe P;BYX CTOJIeTIIII, HO He
HBHJIaCb rocnop;CTBYIOrn.eii. B naMHT-
HIlKax IJ;eHTpa.'lbHOrO KaBKa3a, TaK llie
KaK II BOCTOqHOrO I1pe)];KaBKa3bH, Kah:
OTMeqaeT B. B. BUHorpa,'J,OB, 1I306pa-
meHlleM 1'O.'lOB XUrn.HbIX rrTn qarn.e
YKpaIIIaJIIICb II:Wqn II 6e;rpa lliIIBOT-
HbIX . 3TH rOJIOBKIl IICnOiJ:b30BaJIIICb B
KaqeCTBe )];OnOJ"IIIIITeJlbHOrO II306pame-
HIIJI Ha OCHOBHOM 300MOp<pHOM 06'beKTe.
no CJIOBaM M. 11. ApTa IOIIOBa, MaCTe-
pa CTpeMIIJIIICb Ha)l;eJIHTb 06pa:J mIlBOT-
Horo, nOMHMO ero c06cTBeHHblx Ka-
qeCTB, ern.e II )l;PyrnMII, ,'J,onO.'lHIITeJIbHbI-
MH CBoHcTBaMIl II TeM caMbIM YBeJIlIqlITb
ero anorponeUqeCKYJO CIW:Y'.
HaKOHeqHHK HomeR H:J C. PYK COIIO-
CTaBJIJIeTCH TaI;a.;e C rrpe)l;MeTOM II:J
JIYBPCKOro MY3eH, HB."IHlOn IIMCJI acclI-
,
plllICKIlM no rrpOlIcxomp;eHIIJO H CqlI-
TalOrn.IIMCJI PY'lKOH cocyp;a. Ha HeM
1I306pameH .'leB, Tep:1aJOIIJ;IIH roJIOBY
K03JIa ..
3a nOCJIe)l;HIIe rop;bI B HeKOTopbIX na-
MJITHIlKaX IOllilIoro CI,.TIOHa KaBKa:J-
cKoro xpe6Ta BbIHBH.'!UCb HOBbIe MaTe-
pllaJIbI, CBH3amibIe He TO:lhl{O C l,aBKa3-
CKIIM 3BeplIllbiM CTUJIeM, HO II c.
06pa3 aMIl CKH<pCKoro :meplIlIo1'O CTII-
.!IH, allaJIII3Y KOTOpbIX IIOCBHrn.eHa )l;aH-
HaJI CTaTbH.
Cpe)J;lI MaTepllil:/OB \- II - VI BB. )];0
H. 3. TJIIIIICKOro MorlI.1bHIIKa MHOro
meJIe3HbIX aIillIIilIiOH n n:1OrnYTbIX HO-
llieii. IIOqTII lIiI Beex 3K3eMrrJIJIpaX
., . ,.....'tf1,..
- ,.,
12
. "'1;r, . .
,f.. .. .
13 ".
16
17
21
lDJ 22
r
Puc. 1. HJJ6paJf(CIlIiJi .WII8'JTllbIX H.a 6poH.-
306blx npl'aMeTax 1I T./IIIIC1(OcO MOZUAbHU-
/>(1;
1-11- H306pallieHIHI q,;tflT.1t TII'-IeCHIIX }f(HBOTHbIX
Ha JIOnaCTHX 6POH30Bbl'\ T('j]OPOB; 12-30 - HaG-
6pameHHR co6aKlI Ha npHi"1IJbl'X 'lfaCTRX 6poFl30-
BbiX nyroo6paaHbIx $116,':]
26
27
154
14
g /
:
19 20
24 25
- .. 'l'
f B
23
29
28
30
cpnKOOPYIOTCH CJICAhI Aepena, HBJIHIO-
J:l\HeCH UCTaTRSMH 1l0mCH. XOTH c,BeAe-
mIii: 0 HIIX OqeHb 1o.Ia.-1O 7, nOCROJIbRY BII
B OAHOM KOMnJIeKCe Af'peBHHHhIe nomllbI
He COXpaHIIJIHCb nOJIHOCTbIO, Mom no
Bce-TaRII HOUCTaTHpOBaTh, qTO nOqTII
Bce OUII nORphIBS.'lIlCb CBCPXY Komeo:.
B OTAeJIbU},L"{ CJIyqaHx HomUhI 3aBep-
mSJIHCb HaKOHeqllIIKaMlI, U3rOTOBJIeH-
HhIMR 113 6pOH3hl II KOCTII.
B aTOll CBH311 MbI OCTaUOBIDICH na
Tpex HaKOUeqUIIKSX meJIe3UbIX aKlUIa-
ROB, 06HapymeuIlhIx B norpe6eHllHx
164, 216, II 1130rnyToro meJIeSHOrO no-
ma 113 norpe6emul 258. Bee Tpn '<lK3eM-
nJIllpa KaR no cpopMe, TaK II no IIMCIO-
Il{IIMCH Ha HIIX 11306pameuuHM 011.-
HO!'lInHhI. Pa3BIITcH OHn TOJIbKO no
JdaTeplla.ny: HaKOHe'lURK II3 norpe6eHIIH
164 IIsroTOBJIeH 113 6pOH3hI (pIIC. 2, 2),
a OCTaJIhHhIe ABa - B3 KOCTH (puc. 2, 4
II 5). Ha Bcex TpeX HaKOHeqJIHKaX
11306pameH CBepHYBIDHii:eH B KOJThI.{O
XIIJI:\HIIK ROmaqbeii: nopOAhI (namepa).
TIpR BHIIJdRTenhHOM aHanl!3e MomBO 3a-
MeTIITb, '1TO XOTH OHII II 0AHOTIIUHLI,
HO pa3Jll1'1aIOTCH no p,eTaJIHM. :ho Ka-
eaeTCH rnaBIfLIJd 06pa30M CTIIJIIICTUqe-
eKIlX oc06euHoeTeii: H306pamaeMoro na
HaKOBeqHRKaX HomeH mHBOTHoro.
Ha 6pOll30BOM naKOneqmme (pur. 2,
2) Y XUJI:\IlUKa roJIOBa KpynHee, 60JIee
KpynUblMlI KpymOqRaMII u306pameHbI
II rJIa3a. Horn K01f1laIOTCH He60JIbmn"m
oRpyrJIeHHHMII, npnqeM nepeAlllIe :ra-
nbI oKpyrJIeHLl CUJIbUee, qeM 3aAIIlIC.
XBoeT mUBoTHoro 3aIi:anqIIBaeTCH IipIO-
Ro06pa3HbIM 3aru60M, 1I0!J;Be)J;CHII bnl
6:mme K MOPAe mlinoTnoro. Men<iU.
ROIl4.nKOM XBOCTa U MOP;J;Oii: na 11011\0-
HC4.HDl\e IIMeeTCH I\pyr.1.0e OTBepCTlH',
CJIymllBlIIee, BIiAIIMO, A:IH npIIHpen."H'-
HIIH ero K UomuaM.
[hopoii: UaKOUC'IUnR (norpcuelllle
216, pIlC. 2, 4) COXpaHrI:ICH XYiI,C.
O)J;Ha era CTopOHa CII.1.bUO 1I0BpeiI'Acn01,
BTopaH COXpaHIIJIaCb y OB:reTBopllTe:rb-
HO. I13v6pameHUhIll: XlllqHIIR nMeeT T<1-
li}"lO me nlt3Y, '1TO II ollIlcanuLill Bblme.
.TJanLI II\lCIOT liO:lb'laTbIe OKOllqSnUH.
XnocT Jar>all'lIIBaeTCH KpymOqKOM, B
IJ,CIITpe IWToporo - I<pyrJIaH BAaBJIeH-
liaR T04.I,a. He60JIblllOR Kpymo'ieK llMe-
eTCR U McmA)' nepeJUIIIMIi II 3aAuDMII
llO[,<I I1I.
TpCTIIll nal\OneqUIIK COXpaHIIJlCH XO-
pomo. BnncaHHhIll B Hero XIUIJ;HIIK OT-
:rIl'laeTCR OT APymx TeM, qTO KOHqRKIi
:ran, a TaKme XBOCTa liMe lOT no cepe-
,[Iuue IIO OAIIOMY ne60JlbmOMY Kpymo'l-
I<Y. 3aAUIle Borll mIfBoTHoro CIIJIbUO
BbmpHMJIeUbI R npllnOAuHThI nOqTII AO
ClnIHbI, a nepewme qfTb corUYThI. lle-
peAHlle JIHmIm XIUIJ;HUKa CIIJIbUO BhI-
cTynaIOT 3a upeAeJIhI no.nyKpyra HaKO-
neqHIlKB II npeBp8lI\aIOTCIl B AonomUf-
TeJIbuyIO CPIlI'YPKY, cua6meUHyIO C
06eRx CTOpoH Her.ny60KIIMR HMO'lroU,IR,
n..lOopamaIOJI:\RMIi rJIa3a. 3Ta cpnrypKa
npCACTaBJIHeT C060R roJIOBY opJIa-rpH-
cpa C ue COBceM qeTKO nop.qepRHYThIMIi
K'iIOBOM II naCTbIO. HaKOneqHIIK COCTO-
lIT 113' ABYX nonoBRHOR, 06pa60TaHHblX
l\am a.JI B OTAeJIbHOCTII, a 3aTCM CRpen-
:ICIIIIbIX APyr C APyroM TpeMIl 6POU30-
HbIMU rB03AIIHaMII. M306pameHHbIIT
:\Illl(UIlH UMeeT COBepmeuuo OAIIHaKO-
BLle HOBTypbI Ha 06eRX llJIOC,ROCTHX
1I<lIWHeQUIIKa. I\OHTYPbI npeACTaBJIeUbl
1m" caMOCTOHTeJIbULle cpllrypLl, UO
Cl<penJIeUUhIe APyr C APyroM ABe no-
.101JI1UKII UaHOUe'lRHKa 06pa3YIOT eAII-
110e I1306psmeUlle CBepHYBmerOCH XHIll;-
IIlma. t.:fT06L1 npllAaTb n306pameUJUlM
oiieIIX nOJIOBRHOK OlipeAeJIeuuyIO ca-
MtlCTOHTeJIbUOCTb, XYAomUHH BbIpe3aJI
Hil IlaKOUC'IHIIKe ABa XBOCTa XIIJI:\HIIRa.
, \)
. '\
J4-_-
.,,- .......
C.) ...-
., .....
2
<i -t
. g
.: , ,\
:; ..
.' - -
I
Z ..
.
J ;
,il
S lJ,
0
.tf
'-.J> ..
0
5
. ..-\
"
.-.
I
,c til ,. " !:
., - _. f(' '_ . ..._h"
. -
-@
rile 2. Rlf"30Bble U ';OCTR"ble npC8.MCTU
3BepIlH'JZo UAR Cl>uifJc"oeo Tuna
_ - fipo",oBbie H3ROHe1:JHHl{11 Homeu; 8 - RO-
I Tt11laR rO:JOB}\3 rpal)ooa; 4-5 - ImCTRHble BaRD-
H' -111111<11 ROmeu; 6 - I-iOCTRHOn H3KOHe"maK HD-
-1.I"tI B BJUte ro.'10BJ.\H rpH oHa; l-H3 c. PYK:
- 6 - 113 T:IHIlCJ<oro Morll. bBII"a (IOII<B3J1 Oce-
6
"'
156
B TO BpeMH RaR '1eTbipe JIaIlbi IlO,!!;eJIe-
Ubi UOPOBHY: ,!!;Be ua O,!!;HOll CTOpOHe R
,!];Be Ha ,!!;PyrOH. TO'lHO TaR me Ilo,!!;eJIe-
ua H rOJIOBa 3BepH. Ha OAHOll CTopOHe
HaROHe'lHRRa, Mem,!!;y JIaIloii IlepeAHeH
Horn R ROHqRROM XBOCTa, RMeeTCH ,!!;O-
IlOJIH:llTeJII,HLIH Y30P B BRAe C,!!;BoeUHOH
CIlRpaJIR (pRC. 2, 5). TaKllM 06pa30M,
Bce TPR R306pameHRH mIIBOTHoro He-
60JII,mRMR ,!!;eTaJIHMR OTJIRqaIOTCH ,!!;pyr
OT ,!!;pyra.
BbIpe3aHHbIe Ha :nux U3;J;eJIRHX mlI-
BOTHlde HBJIHIOTCH, BRA.JIMO, rraHTepaMll,
II306pameHRe ROTOpOll CqUTaeTCH 0,0;-
HRM R3 HaR60JIee xapaRTepHbIx ,!!;JIH
c06cTBeHHo CRRtPcRoro IICRYCCTBa. 1130-
6pa3RTeJII,HoMY RCRYCCTBY IIepe,!!;HeH
A3RR R306pameHRH rraHTepI,I IIeR3Be-
CTUbi 8. BuepBbIe OHR IIOHBJIHIOTCH B
CaRRbI3CROM RJIa,!!;e, Ha Bel/laX ROTOpO-
ro RMeIOTCH tPRryPbI, 6.rnI;IKRe R R30-
6pameHHHM ReJIepMeCCKIIX II3,!!;eJIHH 9.
BMecTe C TeM, RaR OTMeqaeT M. H. Ap-
TaMOHOB, ReJIepMeCCKaH rraHTepa OTJIR-
'1aeTCH OT HUX lIe TO.'lbl\o CROIIM CTR-
JIeM, HO U IIe06bIqIIbiM ,!!;JIfI ROCTO'lHOrO
RCKyCCTBa ,!!;OIIOJIIIRTe.'lhIlh! 1 ua06pame-
UReM TOro me, 110 CRepHYBmerocH
ROJII,II;OM 3BepH, rrOMen\ellHOrO Ha JIa-
IIax II XBOCTe OCIIORl!oii tPRrypbI 10.
IIpR,!!;aHRe me TeM II.'lii APyrnM qaCTHM
II306pameHUH mRBOTlIoro caMOCTOH-
TeJII,HI,IX 3BepRHbIX 06pa:JOB HBJIHeTCH
xapaRTepHOH oc06ellHoCTbIO CRRtPCRoro
IICKYCCTBa ".
BbimepaCCMOTpeHHhIe lIaKOHeqHRRR
HOmel!, 6eayc.'lOBHO. He CBo60AHI,I OT
BJIIIHHIHI CKlItPCKoro HCI;YCCTBa, no
CqlITaTb IIX 'IlICTO CKII(pCl,mm I1:JAeJIIIH-
MR, RIIAIIMO, He npnXO:IIITCfI, TaK RaR
Ha HRX HMeIOTCH OTiIe,'JhIlblC ,!!;eTaJIH,
CBH3aIIHbie C IICKYCCTBml KaBRa3CRRX
IIJIeMeH :mOXR IlO:J.1.lIerl ('j}OH3bI. 3TH
IIaROHCqI!lIKI1, IIO-BlliIlnJ() IY. II:JroTOB-
JIeHI,I I1a MeCTe ,llO:Ih 111. I->0TOpbIe 6I,I.'l1l
XOpOUlO 3Hal\OMbl C 1I;!Oopa:JI1Te:l[,HbI I
RCRYCCTBOM TIepe.'lIleii A:Hlil. C RCRYC-
CTBOM IIpallClmx rr:le !PII. R qlICJIO RO-
TOpbIX B VII B. BXO,D:HJIH RaR CRRtPbI,
TaR R MR,lI)IHe. Ha TeppRTopRIO 3aRaB-
Ra3I,H IIe MOrJIO He UPOHRRHYTI, BJIRH-
HRe ,!!;peBHeRpaHCRoro RCKyCCTBa. B03-
MomHo, qTO RMeHHO CRHtPbI 6bIJIR
pacIIpocTpaHRTeJIHMR ero, TaR RaR R
VII B. ,!!;o H. 3. MR,!!;HHaM y,!!;aJIOCI, R3-
rHaTI, RX R3 IIepe,!!;Hell A3RR. IIpO,!!;BR-
raHCI, IIO TeppRTopRR 3aRaBRa3I,H, CRR-
tPI,I He TOJII,RO OCTaBRJIH 3,!!;ecb CJIe,D:bI
RpaHCROH RYJII,TypbI, HO caMR 3HaRO-
MRJIRCI, C RYJIbTYPOH MeCTHbIX a60pR-
reHOB. MHOroe OHR MOrJIR BOCIlpRHHTb,
a 3aTeM RCIlOJII,30BaTI, B CBoeH IIpOR3-
Bo,!!;cTBeHHoH ,!!;eHTeJII,HOCTR, B TO me
BpeMH OHR IIpRBRBaJIR 3JIeMeHTbI CBoe-
ro c06CTBeHHoro R306pa3RTeJII,HOrO UC-
RYCCTBa IIJIeMeHaM, IIpomRBaBIIIHM B
3aRaBRa3I,e ,!!;O rJIaBHoro KaBRa3CRoro
xpe6Ta U Ha ceBepHbIX ero CRJIOHax.
OT,!!;eJII,HbIe rpYIlIlbI 3TIIX CRHtPC1\llX
IIJIeMeH, B03MomHO, OCTaJIRCL Ha 3TOll
TeppRTopRR R IIOCTeIleHHO CJIHJIRCI, C
IlJIeMe aMR HeRpaHcRoro IlpORcxom,!!;e-
HRH, IIOTepllB CBOIO 6bIJIYIO RH,!!;RBR;l:Y-
aJII,HOCTb. TOJII,RO 3TRM MomHO 06'bHC-
HRTI, CTOJII, He3Ha'lRTeJII,HOe qIICJIO
meJIe3HblX Ilpe)1.MeTOB R 06pa30B U3\)-
6pa3RTe.'lLHOrO RCRYCCTBa, CBH3aHIIbIX
C TaR Ha3I,IBaeMbIMR CRRtPCKllMR <pop-
MaMII, B OCHOBe CBoeH BOCXO,!!;HIIlRMII I,
ApeBHeBOCTO'lHbIM 06pa3lIaM. B ;l:peB-
HeBOCTOqHOM RCKyccTBe I13 qeTBepOlIo-
rnx XRIlI,HRROB 06I,lqHO H306pama.'lCH
IIeB. 06pa3 IIaHTepbI B03IIul\aeT, Repo-
HTHO, TaM, r,!!;e 3TOT 3BepI, RMeJI HalI-
60JILIIIee paCIlpOCTpaHeHue, TO ecn, 1\
ropHbIX 06.'laCTHX HpaIIa R KaBI;aail,
3aMena .'lI,Ba IlaHTepOll IIPOR:10III.la,
KaK rro:JaraeT M. H. ApTaMoHoB, IDIPII-
HO B :HRX 06JIaCTHX, XOTH TpaAUlIIIon-
HbIH 06pJ1:J JII,Ba IlpOAOJIma.'l roc-
IlO,!!;CTBOB1}II, B HRX R B Aa.'lbIIeiilUp(,'
BpeMH 12.
B VI I VI BB. 110 H. 3. HaKOHeqUIIKIi
Homell fiIIHmaJIOB R aRUHaKOB, y"pa-
lIIeHHble R306pameHRHMU XHIlI,HI,IX mn-
BOTHbIX, ObIJllI XOpOIIIO R3BeCTHI,l nil
CeBepHOM KaBRa3e. O'IeHI, 6JIR3RHMR MeCCROM HaROHe'lHIIKe HomeH, CTI'IJIR-
aHa:loraMR ,!!;JIH TJIHll:CI}HX H306pame- CTRqeCRR COBIlaAaeT C HeROTopbIMH
Hili! Ha naROHeqllR"aX HomeH MorYT II306pameHRHMU TarapCROlr RYJII,TY-
C:lymllTI, pOroBOll (KOCTHHOii?) HaRO- pbI 16. Yme B VII B. iIO H. 3. B paUHe-
neqllllK 113 MRHepaJIOBOAcROro MOrIIJII,- C,lill<pCRml RCfiYCCTBe II306pamBHRH
IIIIfia 13 R 6pOH30BbIll R3 RypraHa Y CBepHYBIIIRXCH 3Bepeii BCTpeqaIOTCH B
r. fy,!!;epMecca, 06a CRRtPCKOH 3IlOXR. ROCTR, opOH3e II 30.1JOTe ". IIpIlMepOM
fYJIepMeCCRRll HaROHeqHRR HomeH :noro HBJIHIOTCH BbllIIepaccMoTpeHHbIe
o<popMJIeH B BR,!!;e cBepHYBlIIerocH XRIlI,- R306pameHUH 113 TJIllirCKliX ROMrrJIeR-
HOro mRBOTHoro - IlaHTepbI. CpaBHR- COB, BbIIlOJIHeHHble 1111 ROCTR R 6pOH3e.
BaH ero C R306pameHIIHMR, RMelOllI,llMR- CJIe,!!;yeT OTMeTIlTb, qTO HeROTopbIe op-
CH Ha HaROHeqHHKaX 1I0meH TJIUllCRHX HaMeHTa.'lbHble ;J,eTaJIH, IIMelOllI,HeCH Ha
aIillHaROB, CJIe,!!;yeT OTMeTRTI, HeROTopoe paCCMOTpeHHblX BbllIIe HaROHeqHllRaX,
pa3JIRqRe B ROHtPHrypaII;RR mRBOTHO- HaXO,!!;HT aHaJIOrIlII Ha U3AeJIRHX CRHtP-
roo Ha HaROHe'lHRRe HomeH ry,!!;epMec- CRoro HCRYCCTBa CPBepHoro IIpRqepuo-
CKoro aRHHaRa MbI HaXO,!!;RM THIlRqHO MOpI,H. TaR, HallpIIMep, ,!!;BollHbIe CIlR-
CRlItPCRRH 06pa3eII; 3BepRHoro CTRJUI. paJIR Ha ROCTHHOM HaROHeqHRRe Homeu
Y cBepHYBlIIerocH B ROJIbII;O 3BepH R3 Ilorpe6eHRH 258 OqeHb 6JIR3RR R
A.1RHHoe BbITHHyroe TYJIOBRllI,e, KOJII,- TaRRM me 3HaliaM, rrOMelll,eHHblM Ha po-
qaTble XBOCT R JIaIlbi. OHO CBepHYTO rOBOM HaROHe'!III1Ke B BHAe rOJIOBRR
HaCTOJII,RO CRJII,HO, qTO Mop,!!;a IlJIOTHO IlTRII;bI MOrIIJIbl;) KypraHa II I R3 HRm-
IlO,;:(Be,!!;eHa R OCHOBaHRIO XBOCTa. HHTe- HRX Cepor03 ". OqeHI, 6JIlI3ROe CXO,!!;-
peCHO, '1TO 3aAHHH IlOJIOBRHa IlaHTepbI, CTBO IlpOCJIemlIBaeTCH R Ha RocTHHOII
oc06eHHo HorR R XBOCT, BbiBepHYTbI H'l IlpRBecRe, 11300pamaIOIlI,eH roJIDBRY
CIIllHY, Tor,!!;a RaR Y TJlHHCRRX R306pa- rpRtPoHa. OHa IIPOUCXOAHT U3 norpe6e-
melrnH OHR IlO,!!;OrnyTbI IlO,!!; mRBOT. IIe- HRH 216 TJII!ircKoro MOrUJIbHIIKa
peAHIle JIaIlI,I ry,!!;epMeccl\OH IlaHTepbI (pRC. 2, 3) R rrpe,!!;CTaBliHeT C060ll na-
rnlelOT 60JIee BI,IIIpHMJIeHHOe IlOJIOme- BeplIIRe RaKoro-To IlpeAMeTa. Ona IlOq-
Illle U IlO'lTR BIlJIOTHYIO IlO,!!;Be;l:eHbI R TR ROIlIIpyeT TaKYIO me Belll,I, R3 Rypra-
XBOCTY R 3aAHRM JIaIlaM. H306pameuRe B Ha III HRmHIIx Cepor03, C TOll: JIRlIIb
lIe,lOM Ilpe,!!;CTaBJIHeT C060ll: ROMIl03R- pa3HHlIen, qTO I1a T.1UHCKOH rrpHBeCRe
lIRIO, IlOCTpoeHHYIO IlO TOMY me IlPHH- OTCYTCTBYIOT iIHoiiHble CIiRpaJIH, BOC-
lIRIlY, '1TO R ,!!;PyrRe CRRtPCRRe R306pa- IlpOR3BO,!!;HIlI,Ue CXCMaTu:!upOBaHHbIe ro-
meHIIH, CBepHYBlIIerOCH B ROJIbII;O mR- JIOBRH B TOM IIX BR;J;e, B KOTOpOM OHH
ROTHOro, OTHOCHIlI,HeCH R VI B. 110 paCIlpOCTpaHHIOTCH B CKU<pCKOM HCKYC-
n. 3. fOBOpH 0 I;oJIbqaTOM OROHqaHHR CTBe. haK I13BeCTHO, B CaRRbl3CROM
.1aIl, IHOrHe Hcc.1eAoBaTeJIR CqRTaIOT K.'laAe 19 j\BoiiHble Clmpa.1JH, a TaKme
JTY <POPMY H:106pameHRH B CRRtPCROii KpY}J\O'II;U rrepe;WIOT, XOTH II B n'OMeT-
!;y.'lbType IICKOHIIOH II nillpORO paCIlpo- pn'leCKOM BHile. pea.1J/lCTH'IeCKHe qepTbl
CTpaHeHHoii. Olla me IlpRMeHHeTCH B IITHlI. l'poMe Torn, y HumHecepor03-
YII B., a Il03;:IHee xapaRTepH3yeT 60JIb- cKoii IITU'Iheii rO:IOBKR BepXHHll: KOHell
IIlRHCTBO qIICTO CKRtPCRRX 3BepIIHbix K.1IOHa 3arHYT "HR3Y H :.JTRM caMbiM
II306pamelIHii VI B. AO H. 3.' HapMY CIIJIbHO Hall(' 1 II HaeT 06pa3 OpJIUHOrO
C amypIlI,IM KO;lh'laTbIM OKOHqaHHeM [J rpu<pOHa. Y TIJ ;.J;l' r;acaeTCH TJIHHCROII
:no BpeMH B IIpH'IepHOMOpI,e CYllI,eCTBY- rOJIOBKIl rplltf)()II<1, TO Y Hee ROHqIlK
lOT R R306pameRIIH CBepHYBIIIRXCH K.1JIOBa 3arIlYT hHt'PXY H oopa3yeT Rpyr
3Bepen, JIRlIIeUllble BCHRoro amypa 15. C oTRepCTIJl' 1 110 II;ellTpy rQ.'lOBKlI
11306pameHHe, IIoMelll,eHHoe Ha ry,!!;ep- I1aBepWnH IIi! Ill'ceH e,10'lHbIH Y:30p.
159
158
COC,TOHllI,FlR 113 IIHTII pHiJ;OB. TIa-CTb 1"p'H-
<pOHa CRJIbHO pa<;RpbITa. 3arnYTbIR
BBepX I{JIIOB HaIlOMIlHaeT x060T MaJIeHb-
Roro CJIOIleHRa, iJ;a H IlaCTb TOme, FI
Ilo<nOMY B c,Boe BpeMH aTa rOJIooma
HeIlpaBFlJIblIO 6bIJIa BOCllpHHHTa HaMFI
RaK l'OJIOBKa CJIOHa 20. TIpH iJ;aJIbHeRlIleM,
60.'1ee n;eTaJIbIIOM 1213yqeHFlH Ilorpe6aJIb-
Hb!X KOMIlJIeKCOB VII-VI BB. iJ;0 H. a.,
BblHCHFlJIOCb, qTO HaBeprrme u3 Ilorpe6e-
HFlI! 216 Fl306pamaeT rOJIOBKY opJIa-
rpFl<poHa FI HFlqero 06IIJ;ero He FlMeeT
C l'OJIOBHOR c,JIOHa.
COBceM FlHaH RapTFlHa Ha6JIIOiJ;aeTCH
Ilpll paCCMOTpeHFIFI rOJIOBRH IlTFln;bI H3
Ilorpe6eHFlH 246. OHO TaIOKe Fl3roTOB-
JIeHa Il3 KOCTFI FI cHa6meHa MOIIJ;HbIM,
aarHYThIM B KOJIeqRO RJIIOBOM. BOJIb-
1Il0H, 06BeiJ;eH!lhIR iJ;BYMlI KOHn;eHTpH-
qec.KlIMII KpymOqRaMFI rJIa3 CFlJIbHO
BbICTY!laeT 3a JIFlHFlIO ROHTypa l'OJIOBbI
(pIlC. 2,6). ,D;aHHaH roJIOBKa, 6e3Yc-
.TIOB!lO, BblIIOJIHeHa B CTHJIe CKFI<pCROro
Fl306pa3F1TeJIbHOrO FlCRyc,CTBa FI HallO-
MFlHaeT I'JIaBHblM 06pa30M roJIOBRY
IlTIII hI. RMeIOIIJ;YIOcH Ha ROHI e OiJ;ROrO
Fl3 pOI'OBbIX TpeXiJ;blpqaTbiX IlCaJI.RR Fl3
maOOTlIHCKOro RypraHa 2 ZI. HHTepecHo
OTMeTIITh, qTO KOHen; BToporo IlCaJIFlH
YKpa IIIl'lI Il306pameHFleM ROHCKorO RO-
IIblTa II :JTFlM caMbiM OqeHb 6JIH30R
TPl'Xll.bIpqaTbIM pOl'OBbIM IlCaJIFlHM H3
rrorpeoeHl'IH 68 TJIFlll:cRoro MOrFlJIbHFI-
Ka 22. ;\ TaKme IlCaJIHHM 113 MorFl.TIhHFlKa
hPllill! c.... TI TIIqbFl ro.TIOBKFI c. BbICTYIla-
101lU! 1 r:la:WM I1MeIOTCH B CaKKbI3CROM
h.lall.l' II 'laCTO BCTpeqaIOTCH B HCKYCCT-
Be Cl'IJPplioro TIpFlqepHOMOphH ".
PaCnUlTpIlBaH IlpOIlCXOm.iJ;8Hl!e FI
pa 11111010 I1CTOpUIO Il.leMeH TarapCKOR
"y.lbT 'pbI, H. JI. Q.1IeHOBa OqeHb IlOiJ;-
pOOHO oCTaHaBJIFlBaeTCH Ha Ilp06.TIeMe
IIfHHIcxomn;eHFlH MFlHYCFlHCKoro 3BepFl-
Horo nll.1H. TIo IlOBOiJ;Y ro.10BOK XFlIIJ;-
IIblX IlTIII OHa 3aMeqaeT, qTO IlTFlqbH
rO:IOII;! C BbIc.TYIlaIOlII;IIM r.la30M IlpeiJ;-
nalJ:IHPT C060R CKFI<PCKYIO Ilepepa60T-
I>Y 1!1'1I01lHToro 06pa3a .TIbBa Ha JIYPIl-
CTaHCRIIX HaBeplIlFIHx, IlpFl ROTOpOR
BepxHHH qeJIIOCTb 3BepH IlpeBpaTFlJIaCb
B llTIlqIlI! KJIIOB, Kpyril B03JIe rJIa3 - B
3allOJIHHIOIIJ;FlH: roJIOBY KPilBOJIHHell:HbIll
opHaMeHT, a B03BbllIlaIOIIJ;eeCH HaiJ;
roJIOBOH yxo - B rJIa3, BbIcTYIlaIOIIJ;JIll:
Fl3 roJIOBbI BBepx. 06JIIIK aT OR llTIIqb-
eR rOJIOBRH OHa BhIBOiJ;FlT Fl3
CTpaH BJIFlmHero BOCTOKa, riJ;e OH
H3BeCTeH B rJIIIllTIIKe xeTTOB FI MFlTaH-
IlFlRn;eB 25.
YllOMHHYTaH BbilIle l'OJIOBa XIIllI,HOR
llTIIn;bI CTllJIFlc,TFlqeCKII nIlqero 06IIJ;el'O
He HMeeT C rOJIOBKaMI! JIhBOB JIYPIl-
CTaHa. B iJ;aHHOM cJIyqae MbI I1MeeM
peaJIHCTFlqeCROe Fl306pameHIIe roJIOBbI
XFlIIJ;HOl'O opJIa-rpH<pOHa, FI MaCTep, RO-
TOpbIll I13rOTOBFlJI ee, XOTeJI Fl306pa3F1Tb
TOJIbKO IlTFlqbIO rOJIOBY, 6e3 BCHKOR
CBH3I1 C rOJIOBOR JIbBa.
To me caMoe MomHO CKa3aTb FI 0
iJ;Pyrnx rOJIOBRaX XFlIIJ;HbIX IlTFln;, CBH-
3aHHbIX co CKFI<pCKFlMFI Ila IHTHFlKaMII
VII B., iJ;0 H. a. B aTOll CBH3F1 HeJIb311
He OTMeTIITb MHeHIle M. 11. ApTaMO-
HOBa, paCCMaTpIIBaIO!l(ero :!TIT IlTIIqbH
roJIOBbI KaK IlpoMcmYTOq 1I0e 3BeHO
CTFlmI3arr;FlU, BeiJ;yllI,eiI I{ COl>paIl(eHHO-
MY 06pa3Y IlTFlrr;bI, COCTOHII(CMY Bcero
TOJIbRO Fl3 6oJIblliOrO l{pyr.'loro I' JIa3a
FI iJ;ame IIp!RHIIMaIOII cro HIln; D;BORHOR
CIlIlpaJIU 26.
Ha HeKOTOpb!X C 1\I!<pCI;n x IlpeiJ;Me-
Tax, rJIaBHbIM 06pa:WM Ha IIaBeplIlFlHX,
o pa:J XUI1.(IIOH IlTI!!\hl C IW !UHHupOBaH
C 6apaHO !. HaIlpU lep. Tla poroBOM
rraKOHeqUilKe 113 TC lIIp-rOphI II 6pOH-
30BOM IIiIBepWIIII 11:1 I,ypr;!Tla 476 113
Be.'lIlKIIX Byn;QI, I1 ICIOTCH II306pame-
HFlH He TO.lhKO OJ,lIoro oIlI'C.le.leHlIoro
cym;ecTBa, a XRllI,HOiI 111'11111.1 B coen;n:-
HeHIIl! C (oapaHOM. H i\ YI>a:1aHHhIX
llpeiJ;MeTa¥ MbI BIln;I1 1 Cl> .. brrTypHYIO
ro.'lOBKY oaparrO-rrTrrlll.I. II p<'.lCTaB.1JHIO-
IIJ;YIO <paHTaCTUqeCKilII oopa:1, TeCHO
CBH:1aHHbIR C rpIl<p0ITO". : ho oc06elIHO
XOpOlliO rrpoc.'lemFlBaCTC II II it HaBeplIlFl-
HX Fl3 C. Be.1IlKFle By.1KIi. I'.ll' B IlPFlOT-
KpbITOM KJIIOBe rpFl<pOHa IlOKa3aH D;JIIIH-
HbIii H3bIK 21.
TIo;:(06HaH <popMa II306pameHlIH
rpFl<pOHa Bc,TpeqaeTCH B aCCIlpO-BaBFI-
JIOHCKOM, ypapTcROM II rpeKO-IIOHFlii-
CKOM FlCRYCCTBe 28. B CKFI<pCKOM IlC-
KYCCTBe H306pameHFle 6apaHO-IlTFlrr;bI
BCTpeqaeTCH Ha y3n;eqHbIX IlpOHIl3Kax
FI Ha KOHrr;ax llCaJIFlll:, KaK, HaIlplIMep,
Ha llpeiJ;MeTax KeJIepMeCc,Koro Kypra-
Ha, pac,ROIlaHHoro H. M. Bece,lOB-
CKHM 29.
MOTFlB H3bIRaToro rpFl<poHa 6bI.'I Fl3-
BeCTeH B HCRYCc,TBe RaBKa3CKIlX Il.le-
MeH eIIJ;e iJ;0 yCTaHOBJIeHFlH TeCHbIX
ROHTaKTOB CO cRH<paMII. 06 a10 ! CBFI-
p;eTeJIbCTByroT MHoroqHCJIeHHbIe 300-
MOp<pHbIe H306pameHFlH, FlMeIOIIJ;FleCH
lIa 6POHWBbIX Fl3iJ;eJIFlHX Il03iJ;He6pOH-
30BOR RyJIbTypbI IJ;eHTpaJIbHOrO KaB-
Ra3a. TIo MHeHHIO B. B. BFlHorpaiJ;OBa,
Ha IJ;eHTpaJIbHOM KaBRa3e caMa !bIC.1Jb
FlCIlOJIb30BaTb H306pameHFle roJIOBbI op-
JIFlHOrO rpIl<pOHa iJ;JIH iJ;eROpa HaKOrreq-
HFIROB HomeH MorJIa 6bITb IlOiJ;CKa3alIa
MeCTHb!MH YCJIOBFlHMFl 30 . B Ilorpe6c-
HIIHX HIImHe-qereMcRoro MOrFlJIhllIll,a,
a TaRme cpe MaTepHaJIOB 3axopOIlC-
IIFIR CRH<pCROro BpeMeHFI I13 Allropl1l1 JI
H KooaHH 32 ORa3aJIFlCb 6pOH30BbIe lIa-
IWHeqHFlRFI KHHmaJIbHhIX HomeH, Tpa!,-
TOBaHHbIX yme B BFliJ;e rOJIOB H3b1KaTbI:\:
rpFl<p OHOB 33.
MHTepeCHO OTMeTFlTb, qTO YKpamCII-
Hble R306pameHFleM rOJIOBbI fiapallu-
rpFl<pOHa 6pOH30Bbie TpexneTC.lbqaThlf'
IlCaJIFIFI C KOHCI{FlM KOIIbITO ! IIi) IWIII\l'
HaRp;eHbI B MorFlJIblIFlKe <DacKay R 1'0-
llpOBomiJ;eHFIFI meJIe3HbIX CTpC ICIJIU-
JlhlX Y;I.HJI".
Y3iJ;eqHbIe llpOHFl3RII C rO.7JOIJHa JlI
mIlBOTHbIX FlJIFI llTFlrr; I13pej.l,Ka Ha:\:O HT-
CH B MpaHe FI MaJIoR A3F1F1, HO 11:100-
pameHFlR 6apaHO-IlTFlI(bI BHe BOCTO'I
HOR EBpOIlb! Fl3BeCTHO Bcero ;:(Ba-
On;HO Ha porOBOM Ilca.1FlFl I13 c. 311-
Hllue 3\ .n;pyroe - na HaKOrreQHll]{p II.
TeRlIle6aIlll1I 36.
160
6 CHH4Jo-cH6HpcHnA. 3BepuHbiit CTn:IL
B. B. TIFlOTPOBCKFlll: llOJIaraeT, 'ITO
oopa3 rpFl<pOHa B CKFI<pC,ROM FlC,KYCCTBC
IIOHBIlJICH IlOn; BJIHHHFleM iJ;peBHeBO-
CToqIIorO FlC,RYCCTBa FI FlCRyCCTBa Ma-
.10ll A3F1F1. Ha CKFI<pCROH llOqBe OH llpe-
TepIleJI HeROTopbIe <popMaJIbHbIe H3Me-
IICHFlH, TaR KaR BMeCTO YllieR llOHBH-
.1IICb pora, FI poraTbIR rpFl<pOH C,T aJI
TilIlFlqHbIM 06pa3rr;OM CRII<pCRoro HC-
KYCCTBa 37.
. CJIen;yeT OTMeTFlTb, qTO )VIH CRH<p-
C.Koro HCKycCTBa 6bIJI xapaRTepeH He
TOJIbKO poraTbIll rpFl<pOH, HO H rpFl<pOH
Oe3pOmll:. TIpFlMep aTOM)' - BbIlIleOT-
IeqeHHaH rOJIOBRa Fl3 llorpe6eHFlH 246
T.1FliicKoro MOrFlJIbHFlRa, OqeHb 6JIII3-
KaH llO cBoeR KOHCTPYRII;FIFI R rOJIOBRe
rpIl<poHa Fl3 IlOMeIIJ;eHFlH 4 KapMFlp-
B,lypa 38. TIO-BFliJ;FlMOMY, 06pa3 rpH<pO-
6apaHa B CKH<pCROM I1306pa3F1TeJIbHOM
IlCKyccTBe HBJIHeTCH BIlOJIHe caMOCTOH-
TeJIbHbIM, Fl60 iJ;JIH iJ;peBHeBOc,TOqHOro
FlcRyccTBa 6bIJIFI xapaRTepHbI JIbBIIHbIe
II opmIHble rpFl<pOHbI, HO OTC,YTCTByIOT
06pa3rr;bI, B KOTOpbIX COqeTaJIHCb 6bI
rrpFl3HaRFI opJIa FI 6apaHa 39.
KpoMe Toro, llpOHHRlliFle Ha KaBRa3
OOpa3b1 BOCTOqHOro rpH<poHa pe3Ro OT-
:rnqaIOTCH OT c06cTBeHHo CRFI<pCRHX
06pa30B. TITIIrr;bI, BCTpeqaIOIIJ;FleCH B
IlcKyccTBe iJ;peBHero BocTORa, llO MHe-
lIIiIO H. H. TIorpe60BOll:, pemFlTeJIbHO
OTJIFlqaIOTCH OT Fl306pameHFlH CRFI<p-
CKOR XFlIIJ;HOR llTFlrr;bI-OpJIa, HBJIHIOII(eR-
CH 06pa3rr;OM BIIOJIHe caMOCTOHTeJIh-
HbIM, yXOiJ;HIIJ;FlM CBOFIMFI ROpIDIMH B
;:(,weKoe IlpOlIlJIOe '0.
PaccMOTpeHHble BbIme 6pOH30BbIe II
KOCTHHble llpei(MeTbI (HaKOHeqll1IKFI HO-
meH FI HaBepIIIlIH B BFliJ;e l'OJIOBbI rpFl-
<pOHa) He lIBJIHIOTCH xapaRTepHbIMFI
;I.1H KYJIbTYPbi IJ;eHTpaJIbHOrO KaBRa3a.
O;IHaKO '3TO BOBce He rOBopHT 0 TOM,
qTO OHFI HBJIHIOTCH llpFlB03HbIMFI. TIo
CTFlJIFlCTFlqeCRIIM oc06eHHOCTlIM Fl306pa-
n<eHHbIe Ha HaKOHeqHFlKaX HomeH mn-
BOTHbIe, RaK OTMeqaJIOCb BbIlIle, OTmI-
qaIOTCH OT aHaJIOrFlqHbIX Fl306pameHFlll:
161
CKH<pCKHX H3AeJIHH, H IIO::JTOMY MOmHO
IIOCTaBHTb BOIIpOC 0 MeCTHOM rrpOHC-
XOmp;eHHH paCCMOTpeHHhIX IIpep;MeTOB
H HMeIOIJ:J,HXCJI Ha HHX opHaMeHTaJIb-
HhIX MOTBBOB. ::ho TeM 60JIee BepOJIT-
HO, qTO B KYJIbType rrJIeMeH lJ,eHT{liaJIb-
HOro KaBKa3a C KOHI a II TbIC. P;O H. a.
mHpOKO 6bIJIll paCIIpOCTpaHeHhI II306-
pameHHH mHBOTHhIX H IITHII;hI, B TOM
qHCJIe <paHTaCTH'leCKHX cym;ecTB, KO-
Topble HrpaJIH pO JIb 06eperOB, aIIOTpo-
IIeeB H BorrJIOIJ:J,aJIH B ce6c p;06phIe H
3JIhIe KOCMnqeCKHe CHJIbl, HarrOJIHJIBlllHe
MHp H TaK HJIH HHaqe BJIHJIBmHe Ha
cyp;b6y '1eJIOBeKa EaK IIpH mH3Im, TaK
H B 3arp06HoM MHpe u.
rOBOpJI 0 CKHcpOHP;HOM 3BepHHoM
CTHJIe TIpep;KaBKa3bJI, B. B. BHHorpa-
P;OB OTMeqaeT, '1TO KomaqHB: XHIJ:J,HHK,
OJIeHb If XHllI,H3JI IITHII;a 6blJIH IIOrry-
JIJIpneB:mHMH Tpa,II;Rll,HOHHhIMH MOTH-
BaMH B I«J6aHcKoM H KOJIXHP;CKOM HC-
KYCCTBe 42. CJIep;yeT OTMeTHTb, qTO B
K06aHcKoR H KOJIXHP;CKOB: 6poH3e, p;eR-
CTBHTeJIbHO, IIpe06JIap;aIOT H306pame-
ImJI mHBOTHhIX, Tpap;Hn.HOHHhIM H3
KOTOphIX JIBJIHeTCH H306pameHHe co-
6aKH, a He KOmaqberO XHIJ:J,HHKa, a
TaKme OJIeHJI, JIOmap;H, phI6bl, 3MeH.
B Eo e 11- Ha'laJIe I TLIC. p;o H. a.
Ha 6pon30Bblx TOIIopax IIOJIBJIHIOT-
CJI H306pameHHJI cpaHTaCTHqeClmX cy-
IJ:J,eCTB C qepTaMH CHJIbHOro cxeMaTH3Ma
(pHC. 1), KOTophIe H IIOCrrymHJIH rrpo-
TOTHIIaMH H300pameHHH KOmaQbero
XHIJ:J,IIHKa llUCJwp;yJOIJ:J,ero llepHop;a, xo-
TJI OTMeTHM, qTO Hel<OTophIe HCCJIeII;O-
BaTeJIH <JTH paHHHe H306pameHHH pac-
1 E. H. [{pynlloB. a rrOX0lI.ax CKlI<pOB qepe3
KaBKa3. BCCA. M., 1954, CTp. 186-194;
Olt :J/Ce. ApenHlI1I IICTOpll1i CCBepHoro KaB-
Ra3a. M., 1960, CTp. 64-66; B. E. BUllo-
epaiJoe. a CKII<pCRHX 1I0XOAax qepp3 KaB-
Ra3 (IIO IIIICbMeHHblM IICTOqHlIKaM). Tp.
qMHHM, T. IX. fP03HbllI, 1964, CTp. 21-
48; Olt ;){Ce. a IIYTIIX ApeBHux I;y. bTYPHbIX
cBII3eH QeHTpaJIbHOrO II CeBepo-Bono'!-
Horo KaBI;a3a C IOmHM rlI 06:JaCT!H!lI B
l'MaTpUB3IOT ltaK 06pashl KOlllaqberO
XHIJ:J,HHI\a '", a p;pyrHe rrpH3HaIOT B HHX
J!lroo Bo.'1I,a", Jm60 c06aKy 45, JIu60
cooaIW-BO:!Ka ,. II p;ame 3BepJI, 06'bep;H-
HHIOIJ:J,ero B ('06e 'IepTbl Bcex Ha3BaH-
HblX XIIllI,RIIKOB ".
Kali 6bl TO UH 6b1JI0, HO JICHO, qro
MacTepa JJ.CUTpa.'1bHOrO KaBKa3a, HC-
rrOJlbsy H UeJiOTOpble 3aHMCTBOBaHHJI
B CTH.'1IICTII '1CC ROii. rrpopa60TKe BemeR,
i-\OrrycKa:m OTIi,10UeHIIJI H npHlI;aBaJIH
IIs06pa1KeIIIIH 1 60.'1ee BhIqypHblR BHp;.
)J;orrYCiiaH HOIioTopble OTKJIOlleHIIJI OT
HOIJMbl. IecTllblii. opymeB:HIlli II;Ill
KOCTOpC:J ,rr,orro.'1HJI,'I cyIJ:J,eCTBOBaBIIme
opHaMcIITa.'IhHble MOTIIBhI CBOHM c06-
CTBeHHbDl rroqepKOM, '1TO HHorp;a IIPH-
BOP;IIJIO I; HeROTopLlM HeroqHOeTJIM II
01llH6KaM B 11306pa3HTeJThHOM HCRYC-
CTBe. HeOIOTpJI na ::JTO, H306pameUHJI
60.11('e n03D-Hero nepHop;a OTJIHQaIOTCJI
peaJ!lf: MOM B rrepep;a'le HX xapaKTep-
HLIX rrpIISHaKOB.
BbIIIH' paCCMOTpeHHhIe MaTepHaJIbi
COCTaBJI"HIOT CaMOCTOJITeJIbHhIB: BapHaR'!'
SBeplIIIoro CTII:m, lIMeIOT MeCTHhIe Oco-
6eHUOCTII. OT,lHqaIOllI,He HX OT qHCTO
CKH<pCIUfX IIs06pa3UTeJThHhIX MOTH BOB.
OHII ('BH)1<'Te:lbCTBYIOT Ta1Ol\e 0 BsaH-
MOCBJI3HX. cymecTBoBaBIIIlIX Memp;y
rr.1e leUa 1JJ lJ,ellTpaJIbHOrO KaBKa3a II
HpaIlOJI:H,(llllbIMH CKlIcpaMH, YCTaIlO-
BHBIIIIIMII TCCHbJe I\OHTaKThI C KaBI\a-
:IOM (' I;OI!l a VIII B. p;o II. ::J. 3TH fWH-
Tal,Tbl OTpaSII.1HCb He roJIbKO B H30-
6pa:HITC.'lhIJOM nCKyCCTBe, HO H B MaTe-
pnH.1bHoii H P;YXOBHOii. KYJIbType
B006I1\p.
IJepII.3eHllmBIIJIU». TUUJIHCH, 1966, np. 42;
/0. C. rae/l.ouru. A.1allbI II BonpOCbI :HIIO-
rPHe3a oceTIIII. TunmIcrr, 1966, CTp. 228;
Olt :JICe. 3T1lOrel!e3 OCCTI!II IIO lIa1111 bUI
IIlICbMelIHbIX IICTOqll IIIWB. «OPOIICXOm)1C-
IIlle oceTIIHcKoro IIapo)1a».OpllmOlIuKII;13e,
1967, CTp. 71-73.
2 E. A. Ky!jjrult. ApxeOl10rrl'IeCIiali Iapm-
pYTHali 3KClIeII.II IIII 1945 rO;1a B lOro-Oce-
TlIIO II MMepeTliIO. TOII.1IICII, 1%9, CTp. 25,
TaU;!. V, 1.
3 n. C. Yeapoea. MOrn.1bHIII;II CeBepHoro
naBKa3a. MAK, BLIII. VIII. M., 1900, CTp.
276, Ta6JI. CXV, 6.
4 B. E. BultozpaiJoe. IJ,eHTpaJIbIIbIH II CeBe-
pO-BOCTOqllblH KaBIia3.., CTp. 152.
, Jf. /1. Apra.Molwe. OpOlIcXom)1eHlIe CI;II<p-
CIioro IICRycCTBa. CA, 1968, M 4, CTp. 36.
e E. A. [{y!jjruH. Y"a3. COq., CTp. 25, pilC. 5.
1 B. A. llureultcKuu. Opymile HaceJIeHIIII
I1a lIIpa II <DepralIbI B caRCRoe Bpeuli.
«MaTepHaJibHali "YJIbTypa TalI.mHRIICTa-
Ha», BMI!. 1. AymaH6e, 1968, CTp. 83.
8 M. If. Apra.MOHoe. OpOIICXOm)1eHIIe CI;II<p-
CKoro IICKYCcTBa, CTp. 28.
9 Ta 1 me.
to M. H. Apra.MOHoe. COl;pOBH a CKII<pCKliX
l;ypraHoB B c06paHIIlI fOCYAapCTBeHHoro
3pMHTama. Opara - J1., 1966, pIIC. 9,
Taun. 22.
11 M. H. Apra.Moltoe. IlPOIlCxom)1eH"e CI;"<p-
cl;oro IICI{yccTBa, erp. 28.
.. JI. H. Apra.Moltoe. IlpOlIcXOmAeIIlIe CI;lI<p-
CKoro IICKYCCTBa, CT]J. 32-33.
t3 E. fl. [{pynll.oB. Apc!\!l!lII IICTOplI1i CeBep-
1I0ro I{aBKa3a, CTp. ::!05; B. E. Bultozpa-
iJoe. QeHTpaJIhHbIiI II CeBepo-BonOqHblli
KaRha3.., CTp. 154-1.i6, pliC. 13, 1.
" C. B. [{uce/l.ee. ApeB1I1I1I IICTOpIlIi lOmHOH
ClIUliplI. M., 1958, CTp. 240.
15 Ta [ me, CTp. 247.
16 Ta 1 me, Ta6J1. XXII. 2.
17 Ta l il\C, C'fp. 246--2 7.
t8 JI. H. AprO.MOHoB. IIponcxom;!.eHIIe C1ilI<p-
('(;oro IICKyccTBa, np. 36, pIlC. 6.
19 Ta)l ;Ke, CTp. 37.
20 E. B. Te:roB. I'au,OIIl,1I TJIlIilCl;oro IO-
rnm,IlIIl,a. AO. 1 I()R r. M., 1969, CTp. 39.i.
21 M. If. AprO.MOIiOB. IlpOIlCXOm;J.PI!IIe Ci>H<p-
CI;OrO I1CI;YCCTlla, np. 41, pllC. 12.
2 B. B. Texoe. PaCIiOIll;(1 TJIIIIICKoro MO-
rn.1bHIIKa B 1960 r. CA. 1963, M 1, CTp.
170, CTp. 6, 3-5.
23 r. ,po ro6eiJ:J/('III11RIl.!/J. ApXeOJIOrll'!('CI>Ife
1 Tbll'. ;l<J 11. :1. «C60PHIII{ )].OKJIaAOB lla V
BCPCOk).Jlloii CTY)1eHqeCROH apxeo. orllqe-
CI,oii hOIl,liepCHI.\IIH». M, 1960, CTp. 24-25;
011 :J/('('. II.Ji\ITpaJIhHbIlI 11 CeBepo-Bonoq-
IIhIii Ka ""' R CKII<pcKoe BpeMIi. fP03HbIH,
1972. nl'. 11-16; E. B. Texoe. CKIHI)CKIIe
3;!l' H'IIT"1 II laTCpIIaJIhHOH RYJIbType lOro-
OC('TIlII. "!;OI!POCbI I1CTOplIlI HapolloB KaB-
I;a:Ja. IO,-"ueiI£lbIlI COOpHIIR, 1I0CBH eH-
IIb!!1 ,0-.I"T\l1O co AIIII pom)1eHIlIi H. A.
162
paCKOIIKH B COBeTcKoII fpY3HIf. T6I1J111CII,
1952, CTp. 100, Ta6JI. XLVI, 2.
2' B. A. If.n.buHCKaR. HeKOTOpbIe MOTIIBbI
paHlieCKIf<pCIwro 3BcpIfHoro CTIIJIIi. CA,
1965, M 1, CTp. 103, pilC. 13.
25 ll. ll. g/l.eHoea. I1poIICxom)1eIIHe II paH-
HIIII IICTOpIIII IIJIeMeH TarapcKoII Ky.1hTY-
pbI. M., 1967, CTp. 124. .
26 M. If. ApraMoltoe. I1poIICXOmlI.eHlle n;J(<p-
CIWro IICKyccTBa, CTp. 40.
27 TaM me, CTp. 34, pilC. 4 II 5.
28 TaM me, CTp. 35; H. H. lloepe6oea. fpIl-
<pOH B IICKyccTBe CeBepHoro I1pIl'!elmo-
MOpbli B 31I0XY apxallKII. KCI1lIMK,
BblII. 22, 1948, CTp. 62; E. E. lluorpoB-
CI>UU. BaHCKoe apcTBo. M., 1959, CTp.
248-254, Ta6JI. 50; Olt :JICe. MCRYCCTBO
YpapTY. JI., 1962, CTp. 72.
29 M. If. Apra.Moltoe. COKpoBH a CRlI<pCKIIX
KypraHoB.., Ta6JI. 22, pilC. 7.
30 B. E. BultozpaiJoe. QeHTpaJIbHblli II Ce-
Bepo-BoCTOqHblli KaBRa3.., CTp. 146.
3 n. C. Yeapoea. ¥K83. COq., Ta6Jl. 115, 4-
5; E. If. [{pynltoe. )J;peBHIIII IICTOpIfIi Ce-
BepHoro KaBKa3a, TaUJI. 75, 2-5.
31. n. C. Yeapoea. YK83. eo'!., eTp. 83, pnc. 80.
33 B. E. BultozpaiJoe. QeHTpaJibHblli H CeBe-
pO-BOCTOqHblli KaBKa3.., CTp. 143.
.. TaM me.
J> M. H. Apra.Moltoe. I1polIcxomAeHlle cIm<p-
CKOro IIcRYCCTBa, CTp. 36.
36 B. B. lluorpoecKuii.. KapMIIp-BJIYP, I. Epe-
Ball, 1950, CTp. 96, pHC. 64.
37 TaM me, CTp. 96-97.
38 TaM me, CTp. 64.
39 B. A. HAbuJtc"aJ£. ¥Ka3. COq., C.Tp. 100.
'0 H. H. Ilozpe6oea. ¥Ka3. COq., CTp. 62.
4' M. H. Apra.Moltoe. I1poHcxomlI.eHlle CKII<P-
CKoro IICKYCCTBa, CTp. 45.
" B. E. BultozpaiJoe. QeHTpaJIbHblii II CeBe-
PO-BOCTOqHblH KaBKa3.., CTp. 179.
43 ll. C. Yeapoea. ¥Ka3. COq., CTp. 42.
.. lli. H. A.Mupaltazu.eu.n.u. HCTOpIlIi rpy ""-
CROro IICKYCCTBa, T. I. M., 1950, CTp. 42-
43.
" A. A. MU/l./l.ep. M306pameIlIle coual>!! R
IIpeBIIocTIiX KaBRa3a. HPAHMK, T. IT.
Orp., 1922, CTp. 287-324.
.. B. B. BapiJaee/l.uiJae. ApeBIIeiimllP !'f':I11-
rll03Hble BepOBaHlIli II 06pll)1oBoe rpa(fm-
'!eCKoe IICRYCCTBO rpY3IfllcKIIX lIiIeMCII.
TOUJIIfCII, 1957, CTp. 47-53.
" B. E. BultozpaBoe. QeHTpaJIbHbIH II Cpne-
PO-ROCTOqlIblli KaBRa3.., CTp. 179.
A. 11. MaJIL\eBU'I
IIpO.o;yRTOB l\Opp031111. ActPopMHpoBali-
HLle H nOBpemp;ellHLlC '1aCTH BblIIpJIM-
:IeHLI, a TaKme npOIIHTaHLI H CKJleeBLI
CIIIITeTH'leCKOB: CMOJIOH (nOJlHBHllHJI-
6YTepaab fia cnupTY). YTpa'leBHLle
:\ICCTa lIa P;BYX n:laCTHHax C 06paTHoii:
CTOpOULI aaIIO.1Henbl uacTHKoII (H3-
:\IC.:IbQeHHOe me:IC30, CMemaUHoe C no-
:IHBllHUJI-6YTepaJIbllblM RJIeeu).
ITo npcp;JlomeUIIlO 3anopomclmro
l\paeBeP;'IeCRoro MY3eJI nepe'lIlCJleu-
llble npep;MeTbI DOC:le peCTaBpal.{IIU 6bI-
.111 nepep;aHbI lIa:\1 P;JlJI uayquoro onll-
CaIlIiJi II 1l3Y'IefiUll. PC3YJlbTaTaM 3TOll
pa60Tb1 U IIOCBJIll\Cua uaCTOHm;aJI CTa-
TbJI.
Ihal\, Haxo a C.OCTOHT H3: 6pacJIe-
Ta, JJ;BYX IIOJICHLIX nJlaCTHH ua meJIe3-
HOB: ocuOBe, meCTII KpyrJlblX 6J1JImeK
na 6pOU30BOH OCIrOBe - Ylipameuuii: ya-
e'Ilm, If JJ;BYX 6:mmeK ua meJIeaHoii
ocnOBe, KOTOpblC ORa3aJlHCb ROHqaMIf
ffie.1e.H1blX IICaJInll.
rnC3p;a, ROTOpLlC uCI<orp.a 6bIJIIl 3anOJI-
BeBbl lIUI{PYCTaII;lfeii:. IlleH mUBOTUO-
ro BXO,qIIT B m1.'JI06'IaTbIH 1l0JICOR llIH-
puuoii 7 MM, l\OUII;bI ROTOpOro CIIaJIUbI
ua BUYTpeHHen CTopOBe 6paC:IeTa.
RamJJ;aJI H3 roJlOBOR H3roTQBJIeBa
mTaMIIOM, CIIaJIUa H3 P;BYX nOJlOBHB;
ua :I6y II Ba mee CHH3Y xopomo
BHP;HbI t.ieCTa coep;uBeHHH nOJlOBHB.
rOJIOBbI 3anOJIHeBbI nopomRoBHp;HLlM
BeI:I\eCTBOM ceporo II;BeTR (OBO npop;oJl-
maeT BIdCbIIIaTbCH H B BaCTo ee Bpe-
MJI). AHaJlH3 3TOro Bem;eCTBa IIORa-
3aJI, '1TO paCCIdIIalOm;aHCH CBeTJlaH
Macca B OCBOBBOM COCTOHT H3 H3Bec-
TH, aaTBopeBHOH Ba OpraBH'IeCROU
6eJllie (TBopor HJln HH'IBbIH 6eJIOR) t.
HAXO,D,KA B 3AIIOPOJ-KCROl\I HYPfAIIE
(R Bonpocy 0 Crr6npChOii hD.TVIehU.UII IIeTpa I)
Ha ceCCHII IIHcTHTYTa ApxeoJIorIlli
AKap;eMHH HayK CCCP B anpeJIe 1 g6g
rop;a B JIeHHBrpaAe COTpYP;BlIK 3a-
nopomcRoro KpaeBeJJ;'leCRoro MY:JCJI
B. <1>. IIemauoB cp;eJIaJl COOOI:I\eHlH' 0
paCRonRax UOrBJIbIlURa, Ilpon:IBene1l-
UbIX B Ronu;e 1968 roJJ;a Ha OKpmIHC
r. 3anopombe. B TOM me 1968 r. B no-
ceJllte RH'lKaC 6blJI p;OCJlep;OBaH pa3py.
meBBbIH KypraH BbiCOTOH 2 M, Haxo-
AHBIllHHCH B 150 M OT Morn:lI.Hm,d.
,lJ;oCJlep;OBaHHe npOU3Bop;U.l OLlBwnii
COTpYAHRK 3anopomcl\oro l'paCBC;J;'IC-
CKOro My3eJI A. r. IlllIpJIeB. ITa 1.'1'0
CJlOBaM, OB 06fiapymUJI JIMY r."ly6unoii.
2 u, B ROTOpoii Ha 0,25 M BblJlJI.' ypOB-
BH MaTepHKa HaHp;eHbl aO.lOIble npe;\-
MeTbI C HBRpycTaqneii:: 6pac.JeT C JIoma-
P;HHbIMH rOJlOBaMH Ba ROBu,ax (pliC. 1,
1, 2), JJ;Be IIJIaCTIIHbl co Cl.{CHaml 60pb-
6bI 3Bepcft (pHC. 2; 3; 4) II noce IL
KpyrJfbIX tPaJIap na 6pOB30BOii II ffi('-
JIe3ll0H OCilOBe (pHC. 5, 6), tPa.lapa 11I 1Ia
me,"le3BOll: OCHOBe OIUUOOQHO I1,IJFJ,IJIIo'
YKpameHUJI IICaJlUI.'B. B. cD. Oem<lllOI!
OTuec KOMIlJIeKC K paHHeMY :HallY no-
JlBJIeBliH capMaT B CeBCpIW\1 II p1l'I(,p-
HOMopbe.
B tPeBpane 1971 r. naxo,J.l'U nqll':J,;1
Rbi p;JlJI O'IHCTKII Ii peCTaBpaQllII R r 0-
CYAapCTBeHRbrii 3pMnTam. Pen;\IIpa-
l.{UIO npOlIaBO):{H:m r.'IaBBbliI pPCT;lnpil-
TOp rOCYJJ;apCTBeHHoro lp 11I1 ;1;1,11
O. B. BaCHJlbeBa. Ona COOt.IlIn.lit. 'I ro
Bce npeJJ;MI.'Tbi O'lIIll(l.'lIbl \11''\<11111'11"-
CRnM cnoc060\.[ OT H8c."lOenni', :W\I.III II
- '. . -
.?-::."
.... ....
'"
<t'
Onucanue
1. 30;>IOTOii OpaCJIeT Cp;eJlaB 11.\ Mac-
CIIBHoro CTepffiIlJI C YTOJIl.ltPBJIblMn
I,oHqaMu C. 1). Ha RamAOM l\OHu,e
Hap;eTa ro Bl\a mlliJOTHoro. MeffiJJ;Y
yma:\1II m BOTlIoro nMelOTCJI ABa 6y-
ropl\a, 06paMneBIIbIe IlOHCKOM 3epmI,
3TO - OCTaTRH pOroB. Ao peCTaBpaI{IIII
ro.10Bl\U CB060l\HO Bpall(aJIHCb Ha CTep-
il\He; B HaCTOJIll(el.' BpeMH OHB 3aRpcn-
.-.:eHbI l\."'Il.'e:\1. B r.la3ax H ymax nYCTLlC
"---
J
....
164
PIlC. 2. 3anopo:J/tcltuil Itypza". .Tllll..eeaS&
Il 06opoT"as& CTOpOltbi npaeoil nORcltoil n..a-
CTUltbi (CTp. 166)
PUC. 3. 3anopo:J/tcltuil Itypza". .I1ulfeeaS&
Il 060pOTltaS& CTOpOltbi Aeeoil nORc"oii nAa-
CTIlHW (CTp. 167)
-.
PUC. 1. 3anopoxcltuil ItypzaH. BpaCAeT.
1 - BRA cBepxy; t - BRA c60J<Y
,
105
Pllc.2
.,.
-' .
. t
J .
-' ,
-'"
- 1':::.. ,II
--. .. . ,..
. f, .:'
.
-IT&1 ': V""I -,'"
)
,.
....'
'ffo
1.-
\
"'
. .\
,
.
.-"
<:
i
.........
.
f J '
.,-
..
f
. fJ
"IIC. 3.
....1.
,
"
. -.a..
".. ..
)J
r "
f
,
.11 '
, .. i '-
,
- i - ..
........... " I.
!;
..:,
. -.
,.
.
h
...
.....
f
,<'"'
ff
.
"
. '" - ....
'-'\ '
'I
....
"
-.
.
. I-
. '" \.....
- .7"-;
... - , ... -'
,.." ' '.' ,
" /" ..."\.:..
)',. '. -- )' '
. - " . .
T . ..: ...
OI'''''
,
.,.. -.
, I
,
.. .
.. .
-'
--
\..
t J.-r
......,. .
l ,....t_
. ,.
.-1 ,.
.}oI.
.. "'"
..- r .ca
.. of ,
' "
:, .
..
J.
.
.' .
p
.. ..
.
,
.... .-
,. '\.
.--,
/
)
BpaCJIeT XOpOIIIO OTnO.:mpOuan.
CpeAIIHH '1aCTb CTepmHH, 60JICC TOlmaH,
IIMeeT mepOXOBaTYIO nOBepXIIOCTl, II
HeCKOllitKO 3aay6pIlH. BpaCJIeT 6bIJI 11.1'-
<pOpMlIpOBaH H B HaCTOHII.J.ec BpeMa
paCnpaBJleH. B peaYJIbTaTe AJIIITe:IbHO-
ro ynoTpe6JIeHHH I'OJIOBKH Ha BHCIIIHeu
CTopOHe CTepTbi II nOMHTbI, y rJIaa
HMelOTCH JIaKYHbI. ,D;HaMeTp 6pacJIe-
Ta -7,7 X6,7 CM. TOJIII\HHa CT('pm-
HII - 3,5 MM. AJIHHa I'OJIOBbi - 3,5 CM.
Bee 6paeJIeTa - 63,97 rp. ·
llOJIHaH aHaJIOmH 6paC.JleTY HeIl3-
BeeTHa. illeHHble rpHBHbI HJIH opac!le-
TbI, 3aKaH'lHBalOlI\lleCIl I'OJIOBa 11I IIJIIl
I\eJIb[MH <pHrypaMH mHBOTHbIX, 60raTO
npeACTaBJIeBbl B KypraHax cKIHIJO-cap-
MaTCKOH :mOXH, a TaKme B 6bIBmell
KOJIJIeKqHD. KYHcTKaMepbI TIeTpa I,
HbIRe BXOp;HlI\eH B COCTaB coGpaHliH
rocyp;apcTBeHHoro 3pMHTama. B 3TOE
KOJIJIeKI(HH HMeeTCH HaKOHeqBHK
O'leHb 6JIH3KOH <pOpMbI (pHC. 7. 2) 3.
RaK npaBIlJIbHO OTMeTIiJI KIl3epl1I\-
KHH, I'OJlOBa mHBOTHOI'O Ha 3TO\{ Ha-
KOne'lHHKe HanOMIiHaeT peJIbc<I>nylO
roJIOBY KOaJIa Ha nJIaCTIiHe 113 TOro me
c06paHHH (pIlC. 7, 1) 6. AeiicTBlITCJIb-
HO, 6yropKIl HaA rJIaaa!llll lcmAY
ymeH, 06paMJIeHHbIC llIaplllm lII. IlMe-
1OlI\lIeeH Ha 6paCJIeTe H Ha Ilai\one'l-
HHKe, MorYT TpaKTOBaTbCH Hal, OCTaT-
KH porOB. 3TO, B CBOIO Oqepe;:J:b, YKa-
3bIBaeT Ha TO, '1TO nepell. lIa I1I na06-
pameHluI I'OJIOBbI K03JIa, a III' :IOIUajlII.
Pora KOaJIa Ha Il.'mCTlmc Ta i\ilil' 00-
paMJIeHbI, HO He maplnmMIl, a HaCeq-
KaMIi.
lloxomIl na aanopomCliUP II 1I0JIbIe
rOJIOBKH mHBOTnblX (no OnpCjll'.mnIlIO
K. M. CKaJIOIl- JlomaAn) na ABYx
6pacJIeTax H3 ApMaBHpa. (pnc. 8),
YKpameHllbIe rne3,!];aMIi n3 flyfi:ICHOII
.
Q L -,
v)D
.
..
.. -
.
CJ
lfll
..
Q
.
....
. .c@
PIlC. 4. llPOpuco8Ka uao6paxell'"i ..u n.lta-
CTUHaz ua 3anOp03/CCK020 Kyp20lW (ebInO.lt-
HeHa zyiJ03tCHIl'>OM-pecTa8paTop" fa A. B.
BpS&Hqe8UM)
rrpoBOJIOKIi. Ho, CY)J,H no CTHJIIO, OHH
npIIHaA.1:emaT K 60JIee n03AHeMy Bpe-
MeHH.
2. TIapa cliMMeTpHqHblX aOJIOTLIX
IIJIaCTIlH e Ha06pamcHHeM CI\eHbI 6opL-
6bI P;BYX poraTbIx XIIlI\HHKOB, A06bf1IeH
KOTOpblX OK83aJICH 6h1K (pHe. 2-4).
B RlmmeH '1aCTIi nJIaCTIIBLI HMelOT
npHMOYI'OJILHYIO <POPMY; BepxHHH KpaH
IIX '1aCTblO llpHMOll, '1aCTblO aaKpyr-
JIeHHblli. no <popMe OHII aHaJIOmqHbI
napHLllI rrJIaCTlIHaM 113 6b1Bmeii KOJI-
JIeKI\1fll KYHCTKaMepLI lleTpa I. TIpa-
Baa nJIaCTIlHa HMeeT y JleBOro KpaH
MaCCIlBHbIH aOJIOToii nnm C paCHJIe-
rraHHlJM KOHI\OM, TaK me KaK Y Bcex
naplIhlx npaBbIX nJIaCTHH 113 neTpOB-
CKOH KOJIJIeKI\IIH (pIiC. 3).
TIJIaCTHHbI '1eKaHHbIe, HHKPYCTIlPO-
BaHbI O,!J;OHTOJIHTOM (oKaMeHeBmHH ay6
MaMOHTa, oKpameBlIbIii OKIICblO MeAD)
ro.ny6oro, eep03eJIeHOrO H ROpH'IHeBo-
ro I\BeTa". BHYTPH peJILc<p aanOJIHeH
TeMHoii CMOJIIiCTOH MaccoH CO :maqll-
TeJILHOii npHMeCLIO nCCKa (pC3YJIbTa-
TbI aHaJIIISa nOKaaaJIII, '1TO 3anOJIHII-
TeJIb npeAcTaBJIHeT c060ii CMOJIY opra-
HH'leCKoro npollcxomAeHIIH - 6I1TYM) '.
Macca sTa, OqeBIiAHO, Toro me cocTaBa,
qTO H CMOJIIiCTOe Bem;ecTBo «Tllna ca-
rromHoro napa., no onpeAcnenulO
C. M. KanoIDHHoH, KOTopoe aanOJIHH-
JIO peJIbe<p KpyrJILIX 6JIHx, HauAeHHbIx
B CaAoBoM Kyprane 6JIHa HOBo'iepRac-
r,Ha 8.
PeJILe<p 6bIJI naJIomen na mCJIC3nylO
nJIaCTllnqaTYIO OCHOBY TOJIlI\IIHOU 2 MM.
npaH 30JlOTOro peJIbc<pa aarnYTbI II
HaXOJ!HT na OCHOBY. Ha OCHOBe '1CTbI-
pe me.1:e:JllbIe nCTJIB mllpunoii 5 MM;
ABe JI3 IIB"\{ naXOARTCH Y Bepxncro H
ABe y HHmnero RpaH, KamAafl C Hpyr-
JIbIM OTBepCTIleM ADaMeTpOM 4 MM. B
OTBepCTllH coxpaHIIJmCb CJIeALI Komll B
BllAe CBeTJloii pmaBqHIIbI.
BOI;:pyr neTeJlb, OCTaTRII KOTOpLIX
Ha JIeBOn nJiaCTIiHe 3aMeTHbi JIY'I-
me, Bn;J:I1bI nHTHa TaKoii me CB£'T.'10H
169
..,
.. Ir ' '
..
..
,
, ,
5
....
\
.'"
.
. (
2 { \
\t
I ""'"
-
....... -
.......... " ,
r 6
(, '""" ",
...{.:.. tf- :,
. ' 1'1
r'"
P4
f\
.
.,
..
.
.
3
....
,
l "'\\
- ft'
7 -
<4
- .- .
.
.Y"'
J_ ,
"
".
. ..
'" ,
. 4
.,.
; "!' "'.-I
. c;;Jr .
2
.'"
, ...
3
.;...
n, ....
- '\
( . ""
..,
., "
<4
pmaBqllllbl, oOBepXHoCTb KOTOpOH nepe-
AaeT CTPYKTYPY Komo. TIeTJlH 6b!JlH
pacnO:lOmeHbI ropIlaOIlTaJibnO, TaR qTO
opo,!];eTbIe B HHX peMemRH HaXOAJImICb
B BepTllRaJlbHOM nOJlOmeHHH. Pa3Mepbl:
npaBaH OJiaCTHHa - AJIHHa 10,7 CY,
mHpll1Ia - 6,6 CM; TOJIII:\HHa -1,8 CY.
JIeBaH n.'1aCTHHa: A:IIIHa - 10,5 CM,
mHpIlHa - 6,8 CM, TOml\HHa -1,8 CY.
TIpaBaH nJiaCTlIHa 6b!Jla pa3J10MaHa Ha
ABe qaCTU H CKJleeHa; Ha MeCTe H3.:'10-
Ma BBepxy H BIDI:3Y YTpaqCHa qaCTb
KpaH caMOll nJiaCTHBbI H ee meJle3HOK
OCHOBbl. B HeROTOpblX rne3Aax HHKpy-
CTal\lIR IIOTpeCRaJIaCb, B APyrnx (B 13)
OHa OTC lTcTByeT. iKelle30 MeCTaMU OT-
ClIOH.10Cb; neTJIH 06J10!l(aHbI H noqnr
nOJIHOCTblO YTpaqeHbI, Yl\eJIeJIH OCTaT-
RII BepxHeii neTJIH Ha JIeBoii nllaCTIIHe.
BepxllIiH U HHmHHH RpaJI ee nopy6-
JIeHb!, npn aTOM BepXHHH - CHJlbHee.
rOJlOBa OAHOI'O 3BepH nOMRTa; 3aoo.'1-
HHBillaH ee Macca, a TaKme MeCTaMH H
30JlOTaH 060JlO"lRa YTpa'ielTbl. I1nKpy-
CTal\lIR B HeRoTopblX I'He3Aax oOTpec-
KaJlaCb, B ApyrHX (B 20) olla OTCYTCT-
ByeT. iKeJle3BaH OCHOBa CJIOMaHa II
C-KJIeella. .
HO\fIJ03HI\HIO COCTaBJlHIOT TPH !fJurr-
pbl: Ha 6bIKa (y Hero I1:106pam£'I1 TO.:'lb-
KO 0.[\1111 POI:) HanaJI C3aAu pOl'aTb!ii
XH11\1I Ii K; APyroii TaRoii me XIill\HHR,
CTOH na 3aABDx Jlaoax. nepeJ],HHMH !Ia-
I1aMli Bl\eOHJICH B ro:IOBY ubIRa II B
cm"HY I1epBOrO XDII\IIUKa, a 3y6aMH-
B lIlelO nOCJleAHero (pHC. 4)_
Y :\IfUiBHROB Kam.!1{)e OTBeTBlIenIle
pora :JaKaHqIlBaeTCJI I'O.-IOBOM ymacToii:
!fJauTaCTIIqeCKOii OTlfUbI - rpIl!fJa.
Pue. 5. rJ>nJlapw ua 3anopoxeKozo "ypzalla:
J-G - . MLJeB3R CTOpoB8; 7 - oIJpaTH3R CTOPOH8
Pue. 6 ea lIaltOHeOlHUKll neaAuee ua 3ano-
P03ICCMdO "ypZUHa:
1-2 .lMLleB3R cTopoBa; 3-4 - oIJpaTu8R CTo-
IJOH;]
171
. .....
. , \
' .
" f"
:> \ , I
,
, "
'La.'" ".
.
t J.: II I :(
II {;
"'" ...
,f'J
, : j)W UUl!ti
"Ii
-.
-
(
.t. .. .
... . »>.; ....)
...
TaKmc B BHJ];e rO;IOBbI rpmpa 1f306pa-
meHbl XBOCTbI XDIl\HHKOB. Pacnono-
meHnbie CHMMeTpll'lHO B PR]!;, 3TH 1'0-
nOBLI C03p:aIOT 06paMJIeHUe BepAHero
KpaR DJIaCTHHbI. KpOMe Toro, Ha JI6y
3BepR npeACTaBJIena ronoBa 3BepLKa C
OCTpOH MOPAOM, RpyrJIbIMH rJIa3aMH H
TOp'laIItHMH ymaMH H TYJIOBHll\eM B
BHAe '1JIeHHKOB. XBOCT He 0603Ha'leH.
OC06CHHO '1eTKO 3Ta cImrypa BbIAenHeT-
CR Ha npaBoft nnaCTHHe (pHC. 3, 4).
Pc6pa y oARoro XHIl\HHKa H JIanbI y
060llx nepeAaHLI B BHAe Tpex rHe3]!; B
cI>opMe KanJIH. TaRoll me «PoPMbI rHes-
PUC. 7. llAacTuHa (I) U HaJl:OHe'4HUJI: (2) ua
6t.t8Weu. Jl:OAAeJl:lfIlU Jl:yncTJl:aMepw lleTpa 1
]!;a 1I306pamalOT YUIll I1TUI\. fna3a nx
HMeIOT BIIA Kpyrnblx rHC3A. I-\onbITa
6b1Ka OTMe'lelfbI rne3,!];allUl B cI>opMe
pOM60B. BMeCTc C ROrfHCTbIMn JIaDa-
MH 3Bepen onll COCT3BJIHIOT HHmHee
06paMJleHHe nnaCTHHbI. Ra TYJIOBHll\e
6LIKOB 060sHaQeua ]!;JIIIHHaH mepCTL;
ona nepeAaHa neCI>O:IbliIlMII rIleSAaMH
B .popMe KaDJIH HellIHoro Bblme KOIlblT
(ua npaBOB nnaCTlIne nx ceMb, Ha ne-
Bon - BoceML) .
TaKoB me 6hIK, Tep3aeMbIB opnOM,
1I306pameH Ha nape apMnTamHbIX nna-
CTHH, UHKpYCTnpOBaUHbIX 6HpIOSOii:
(puc. 9) t. Ra 06ellx napax DJIaCTIIU
CKopee Bcero nepeAan 6bIK TOM nopo-
AbI, 0 KOTOpoii COOOll\aeT TIaBcaHHiI.
Do CBHAeTenbCTBY noro aBTopa, B TIe-
OllllIl (BepxHlUI qaCTb AonmILI peKU
ARCJIH, BLme BapAap B M3I;:e;\OHIID)
BOAlinliCb 6bIKII oco6oii nopo]].bI: «ORH
IIOKphITbI no BceMY TC.1Y rYCToii ruep-
CTLIO, no oc06euHo rycTa olla lIa rpy-
All n nOA H.HmHeii ry60ii» '0.
Ra JIeBoii: 3anOpOmC1\OII nJIi\CTIIRe y
nepBoro XHIl\HH1\a mepcTL H3 nepeA-
IInx mmax peTylllupoBaH3 KOCbIIIIH :111-
HHHMII (puc. 2 n 4). hOT nplleM, xa-
paRTepnbIB ]!;JIH Hs]!;e:mii cap1laTcKOH
anOXD, npllMeHeli na 30:IOTOU IIJIaCTII-
ne I13 C. BepxRee TIorpoMHo£' {puc.
PUC. 8. BpacAeT (ApMa8up, nOKynKa):
1, 11- BHP. COOllY; II - BUA cBepxy
l-
LO, 3) ", lIa ynoMllHaBmeiicH yme nJla-
CTHue liS KOJIJIC1\I\Iill TIeTpa I (pHC.
7, 1), Ha APyrHx I1.'l3CTIIUax 113 TOll mc
KOJlJIe"I\I1n tpUC. 10, 1, 2) .., Ha HOBO-
qepI>accKofi ABaAeMe (pnc. 11), Ha ce-
pe6pHRoM DORce, KYllneUIIOM B Maii-
KODe (puc. 12, 1) 13, a TaKme Ha nnac-
TUBe (puc. 12, 2) 1< H meHubIx rpuB-
Hax apMuTamuoro c06pauHH (puc. 13,
14) n.
TIopoAa pOraTbIX xn BHKOB Xopo-
IlIO uaM 3HaKOMa 110 us06pameHHfIM
Ba Dape nnaCTBH, xpaHIIII{BXCH B 3p-
MIlTame (puc. 15) 18, r]!;e poraTbIll
3BepL B TaROM me ]I;BumeHHU cnymuT
06paMneHneM mnpoKoro HOHD;a '1eTLI-
pexyroJILHOn nJIaCTUBbI. Ero pora sa-
KaH'lHBalOTCIl Be ABYMII, HaK Ha sano-
...
\.
, .
.I.i -
. '. .- _,\.I
'-A: .. . .
"- - -
.,
.. .
. ."
".
f' 'j
2
,
J
,
--
,( ': j """' \i ': It f
""1 : . .
. : f. . .14"
..... - -
-
l' "
....
3
172
\
r.
,
173
pomcKoii:, a TpeMH I'OnOBaMU rpu!fIa.
JIaIILI TaIDKe C TpeMH KOITHMH, a IlOA-
IIHTLlll: XBOCT HMeeT BHA I'OJIOBLI rpu-
!fIa. Ha 06enx IIapax IlJIaCTHH KOMIIO-
3H1 HlO COCTaBJIHIOT TPH !fIUryphI, JIHillL
(j TOIO pa3HHn;eii:, '1TO Ha 3pMUTam-
HOll: - 06a XHID;HKKa TepaalOT Ao6Ll'lY
BMeCTe.
110 3aMLlCJIy eID;e 6JIIDKe K 3anopom-
CKHM APyraH napa nJI8CTHH C H306pa-
meHHeM OpJI8 H 6LIKa (puc. 9): nomH-
palOm;nH 6L1Ka opeJI B CBOIO O'lepeAL
OKa3aJICH caM A061J'1eii THrpa. CJIep,yeT
YKa3aTL em;e Ha OARY AeTam., KOTopaH
PUC. 9. lIAacTul/4 us 6b16IUei1 ItOAAeltlfuu
ltyncTltaMepbl IIeTpa 1
>:
' tr :( / . ,
"I (...u
.. ," ...
"\ '."\.
06'Lep;H1l1leT 3anopomcRYIO H 3pMHTam-
HYIO n.1aCTnHLI U Hurp;e 60JILme He
BCTpeqaeTCH, 3TO - npHMoyroJILHaH
!fIopMa I1HKpYCTan;lUl TYJIOBHID;a 3BepL-
Ka, II.306pamenHoro Ha roJIOBe BToporo
Xn IlIIRa, u KpLlJILeB opJIa 17.
KO\l.I103Ul\HH Cn;eH Ha onHChlBaeMLlX
n:IaCTIIHax BLlnOJIHeHa CBo6op;Ho, C
60JIbWmi }laCTepCTBOM U nOJIHa :mc-
npeCCIIII, XOTH U He BLlXOAHT 3a npep;e-
JILl 3a allHoii TpaAHl\llOHHOH cxeMLI
nOHCHblX nJIaCTUH. <DnrypLl 3BepeR
'Ipe3BLI'IaUIIO DJlaCTUqHLl, ux rOJIOBLI
BLlp;enCIILI BLICOItDM pe.'1be!floM; naAqep-
KHYTLI I1HKpYCTaD;llen Kpynlffile JIan],!
C 60.'1LWIUm KOrTHMH, TaK me KaK D
rJIa3a, ymll, pora, KOrTU. Heo6xaADMI)
OT:lleTllTb npn 3TOM, 'ITa llapHp;y C !fIaH-
TaCTlIqeCIiIlM ;).le}leIiTOM, npaCYll\llM
TpaKTOBnC XIlll{I1UKOB,' rO:IOBa y6nToro
6L1Ka C OCJi:aJIeHllbllllII 3y6a m nepep;aHa
BnO:me pCaJIUCTII'IHa.
3anopamCKue 1I.1aCTnUbI XOTH n COC-
TaB:1HIOT napy, llO OT.1IlqaIOTCH p;pyr aT
npyra n no. MaTeplIaJIY, n no HCnOJIHe-
unlO, npn 3TOM a6e OIIB HBJIHIOTCH npa-
IT3Bep;eHUHMll l,pynHbl1. xYAomHnKOB:
.'1eBaH U31'OTOB:IeUa U3 6.lep;Ho1'O 3eJIe-
lloBaTo1'O 30:JOTa (pIiC. 3 H 4), 8 npa-
BaH - 113 30:IOTa TenJIa1'O, meJITo1'O TO-
Ha (pIle. 2 H 4). Pe.:Jbe!fl :IeBOii: nJIaCTH-
HbI nMeeT Tm;aTe.'1bHLlD H 'IeTlmn
pnCYBOK, aH KaK 6L1 OTa.pBaH OT rJIy60-
Koro !fIoHa (pITc. 3). ABTOp npaBaft
nJIaCTUnbl (puc. 2) npeKpaCHO B:lap;eeT
TexHIIIwii, CTII.1e 1 II IICRYCCTBaM Ji:OM-
n0311l\Hn, BO nO'IePR Y Hero nHoii: OH
60.'lbWe mnBollilcen; n He CTpeMUTCH K
Ta'lHOii nepep;a'le apnrnHaJIa BO Bcex
ero AeTa:IHx. TaK, HanpuMep, Ba Te!Ie
3BepbRa Mac.Tep nOMOCTIl:J TPH BCTaBKII
BlIreCTO P;BYX, a p;.'UHEIYIO mepCTb 6L1Ka
aH nepep;a., ceMblO BCTaBK8MR BMeCTa
BaCb lIl; COEceM nnVCTn.'1 KOCLle JInHUU
a6a3lH\'1alOll\Ue KO;ITYP nepep;HH JIa
BToparo xlluUllma.
ITpaBaH n.'laCTnUa (puc. 2), MameT
f)blTb, RB.1HeTCH p;o,J,eJIKOH B3aMeu yrpa-
qpHl!oii, "an 61,1 ee Konuen, ecnu TOJIL-
1<;0. 1I10mHO rOBopuTb a Ronun H apn.rll-
ua.'!e, Ror.na pe'lb IIJ];eT a nape CHMMeT-
(JU'lIIbIX npe,l!>leTOB. 0p;uH8KaB Y Hnx
TO.1bKII xapanTep mmpYCTan;HH. Op;Ha-
KO Ill' Uc.IW.IO'leHa II APY1'Oe npeADOJIO-
meHne, a II!lIf'HHO. 'ITa. 06e n!IaCTURLI
n31'OTaB.1H.'nCb B annou MaeTepc.Koii:
nRY IH \l3CTCp;nm O;I;HOBpeMeHBO.
BnepBbIe :JO.'OTaH n.,aCT1Ula aHaJIa-
rU'Illoii (}JOp ILI II Ua3Ha'leHUfl, BLlno:r-
HeHIHlH R :1Rf'pIlUO!l1 CTU.,e, 6bI.'Ia Han-
nena B 19;-,4 1'. B. IT. IDHJIaBLlM npu
rUCT£'\laTU'lf'C"UX paCKonKax MarnJIb-
HHlW fi:l\J:J L Hepxnee l1arpoMRoe,
Ba.'l'orp<1J1,cn"ii oo.laeTn. Haxo]:lRa 3Ta
npeJl,CTan.1HPT "COObIU uRTepec, TaK RaK
. (. \
""", ." ( L) )
1\' .... . J,
.h(/ -;.. -:.::;:-: t
':; ( -....... " "-'
.". :. ::"14;" ... "\t\..,' /'
. .tll'I . ,.
. . ... "..1\ ,[ .J-;. I" ........_
. ,)r-"'II ", - "
Jl \\ $ _C\ : 0 '. ; ! t ' J I
V'I?/ -:- -'.t::T -
/"' '..... --"."' ,,"' -
, I r ; I ';: ;"'" . .... .x)'
,r-, u.. .... ,..
r... >: '\ ' V;"'; "';
I
1
174
alIa aTKpbITa Cne4HaJIHCTOlll n BxaAIlT
B cae TaB K{)MnJIeKCa, AaTlipaBannoro
I B. 11.0. H. 3. 18. 3Ta - n.'1ac.TllHa C WIl-
nOM, HpaBaH '1aCTL nOHClIon 3aCTem"lI
(pIlC. 10, 3). l1apHaH en OTcyrcTByeT.
IT.'IaCTUHa peCTaBpnpaBaHa B p;peRIIOC-
TH, upn 3TaM 6bIJIa BLlHYTa ee epeIlllHH
'IaCTb, a OCTaBmHeCH 60RoBLle '1aCTn
coeAHHeHLI Memp,y co60u UpH na!llOll{n
3aKJIenOK. B pecTaBpupoBaHHaM Biine
Olla B nonaJIa B MarHJIY.
3anopomcKHe nJIaCTHBLI - YHIII\a.'b-
HbIH cJIY'laii HaXOAKH B narpe6ellIUI
nOJIuaro KaMnJIeKTa 30JIOTLIX naHCllblX
YKpameBHii: 3BepUHOl'O CTHJIH cn6up-
CKora THna, H npH aTOM B KOMnJIel,c.e
C p;pyrnMu npep,MeTaMH TOro me CTlI-
JIH - 6paCJIeTOM H KOHCKUM y60pOM,
XOTn KypraH H aKa3aJICH pa3pymcR-
RLIM.
I1JIaCTnBLI aHaJIorn'lHOH !fIOPM bl,
Ji:aTOpLle TaKme CJIYmHJIH nOHCllblMlI
YKpameBBHMR nJIH 3aCTemKaMII, coc-
TaBJIHIOT 6aJIbmylO qaCTL 6L1Brueii l\aJI-
JIeK4RH RyncTKaMepLl ITeTpa I I..
B 3pMHTame HMee-rCH Bcero AeCHTb nap
TaKHX nJIaCTUR H TpU nJIaCTUHbI, )"Te-
pHBmHe CBOIO napy. RaJIJIeKD;HR cOp'ep-
milT em;e '1eTLlpe napLl nJIaCTHH C CIIM-
MeTpH'IBOH KOMn03Hn;HeH, no. BKJIIO'l!'I1-
naH B npRMoyroJIbnyIO paMRY.
Ha nJIaCTHHax apMHTamnOH 1\0.1:ll'1,-
n;un n306pamenLl pa3mIqHLle ClOm(>TLI:
no OAUOMY - Cn;eHLI OXOTLI H aT,,\Llxa
BcaAHIIKaB, BO ua 60JIbmUHCTBe 11.1 \lUX
upep;CTaBJleHa 6opL6a !fIauTaCTIl'll'l"I,U"\:
3BepeH, nopaAY KOTapLlx anpe'll':IIITb
BeB03MomHO. ::ho xapaKTepuaH 11("11-
6eHHacTL 3BepuBaro CTHJIH cap Ii1T...,()ii
3110XH, KorAa nopoAa mIfRoTlloro IIC
llHTepeCOBaJIa xYAamRuKa, a {f)\11 YI'LI
mueLlX cyrn;ecTB 6LIJIli npl'lJpallt('IILI
B opHaMeUT.
):\.'1H U3yt1eHIIH 3dnapOmCRUX Il.Iac-
TUR UHTepec B IW.'.,eRQIIII 3(1\lIlTa<l'iI
npe)J;CTaBJIHIOT p;Be napb! 11.1 a \"1 1111,
npHBeJ{eHHblC BMwe: BbIpe.lllblP. (" 11.10-
6pameRHeM ap:Ja U npH lOyr(J:II.1I 101('
175
PUC. 10
....,.,
---\,
.. -..cr
--
.. \'
,- .... . .
I ...
." " .
: "'."
..
1 2
(pilC. 9 II 15). Oun CTapllll' 3anopom-
Clinx, 0 qeM cBHp;eTe;'II.CTByeT 60JIee
peaJIlICTlIqeCliaa TpaKTOBlia (IJHryp,
'JI'Tl\.OCTb l\.Ololl103H nII, uaIWlleJ..\, Jl,06-
pOTllOCTb calolliX npeJl,MeTOB. XOTH Ha
3anopomCRnx llJIaCTlHJax I'mI' npop;OJI-
a,alOT mIlTb CTapbJe Tpap;n InJ, 110 p;o-
paron MCTaJI:I y HUX Jl,onOJIHeH MaCTH-
lion D me.ae30M 20.
f:"laBIIOe, qTO poJl,JIIIT 3anopomCKne
IL apr.mTamHl>Ie llJIaCTHllbJ, 3TO Tpa.J.II-
...-
PI/C. 10. lloRclible n..aCrl/libl:
1, 11- Da I!HBmelt I<OJInel<QBH RyIICnfaMeplil
neTpa I; 3 - D3 C. BepXHee norpo'lHoe
Puc. 11. ;:(uaoeMa U3 "ypzalla XozJla'l
."
f
-",
. ,
"J.\ :
. ,
.
..
"
.;
I \:.
,.. .
.
,.-
,
"
(
\ \
--
....
..
-.
3
r
I
,
,
t
&
t
,
4 '
. J
01;
QIIOUlioe CTper.I.'II'IIIH' X YJI,OmHlll>G II
C03.!{anaTL 06pa3bI !fJaHTaCTnqecl\nx
:JHepeii )[ [,<Hi. UbI 1,OppeKTllponaTt.
npUpOJl,Y. Ha.1I'.1f1f1 XIIIJ1HTIlWB pora lII,
a nTIIL{ OI'pmlllbJMII YillaMll, 80TOpbl
1\e:18.1n JIX 00.11'1' cn.1bJlLUIIJ., a C:ICJI,O-
naTe.'IbHO, B nx npe.1CTao.1cHIIn, 60.111'1'
COBPPIlIPIlIiLDIII.
AH8:IOrII'IHOe f1B:IPlille lIa6.'lIOJI,aeTCfI
na naMflTHUKax lIoiyccTna CHH«pClWii
anOXII eru;e B V - 1\" BB. )];0 H. o. Pora
O.'lClfH 3,II..aJl'lIIIJaRITfH rO.lOBaMII XJHU-
HblX nTUL{ JI<i 30.10TbIX n.18CTILHaX-8n-
DJInK8Quflx .:!ppelHmublx COCyp;OB II::
KypraaoB t.}urupIIucKoro II AKMeqeTu.
H8 cocyp;e co CL{eUa IU OXOTbI U3 CO.10-
XU MOll\b .1bBIIL{bl YCII.1cua DpnJl,aIillbI-
MH en pOralolII 1\.03.la.
- ",
f
( ""
. .,
....
.....
......ti ,
'r. .
.
177
I
..
,; )i .:.
J .fr" . t I, .
.. ..1) "f;:" J
. I .
" .
...
, ,
' -.
"
j ,
Q ',\ ',-
.,.".It .... .'
_ J. ._!. ....! ". .. "'....' .. ,'" to ..
r'
--....
. -"'-. .:
,
4- '. a-
, "l
.. . .
t J!" I t"f I
!
( .
],OIlCHllii yoop 113 3arrOpOmCHOrO
';YIH'aua COCTOIIT 11.3 mCCTlI YI>pamCBDU
pC lIIeii n ny'( y"palllCllnii nCft:meB.
;-3. lllecTb I>pyr.'1bIX BblIIYli:lhIX 6JIH-
1IIt'1i lIa OpOII30ROii OCHOBe, COCTaBJIHB-
llIiIX YI_pameJllIH y.I.:U''IHbIX pCMneii, CO-
A('pmaT pe.'1b('<fJIIble II;106pamemm l\03JIa
IlIIpaRO. 11ft OOOpOTC nplInaHlIO n.'1aCTUB-
'IaTOC YUIKO. j],naMeTp 6JIHX - 3,7 CM,
I1bICOTa - 1.3 CM. UlupuHa yuma-
6 CM. To:n lII1a ymi>a - 0,5 MM (puc. 5).
t1Jurypa IW3:m JanOJInHeT BCIO no-
BepXHOCTb 6.'IHmHU, 06paMJIeHHOD: mry-
TOM B BDAe l\OChIX BaCC'leR. iRuBoTBoe
npen;CTaB:IerrO RaH 6bI paCIIJIaCTanHhIM:
ro.lOBa B <fJac nOMeLQeH3 Mem,ay nOABJ'I-
TblMII BBepx UepeAHRMII noraz.m; TY-
.'IOBiIlI e n306pameHO B npocpUJIb, IIpU-
'II'" RlI)J.lla TO.1bRO o;J:IIa 3ap,HJ'IH nora.
Pora, Jaliall'IUBaIOlImeCH mapUI>aMU,
n XROCT DI.IJ\I':IeHbI "PYIIBhIMD mTpu-
xaMU. Me:I1uullI nnpuxaMU nepeAana
ml'pCTb Ha 1I0rax. b.1JIII1l(U DBRPYCTB-
pOBallbl: B Rpyr.abl.X rne3AaX-rJIa3aX
nCTaB:IeBO _e:IToc npoJpa'lnoe CTeRJIO;
n TllC'3)J.ax R (IJOp le RanJIU B ymax U na
n.'Ie'lax - lI('TaBRH roJIy60ro CTeHJIa;
TIII>"H »>!' IICTaB"a B rHe3Ae nO;>IYOBaJIb-
Hoii IfJOPMbl I1a 3aAHCH Bore.
no CpallIll'lInIO co CTllJIeM IIOHCHbIX
IIJH\C, TlUI CTII.lb 6J1HmeK 60JIee rpy6hlD,
npH IIITiIBiI"'lii, peMeC.1eHHbIii:.
TexlllUw. bJlHm"lI OTTHCBYThI no
OAlIoii IpOp'>I l'. 3aTeM OT PYHU na HHX
I1a lIeCPHII peTYlllb. C 06paTHoii CTO-
pOiIbl pe.-lI.I'({J 3anO:IHCH TeMnoii Mac-
coii. OI>paIIII'IIIIOiI OImCblO upon.lbI. TIo-
RI'(lX [;1CCJ,( IIII.lomerra 6pon30naH nJIa-
CTlllllia-1I01IiJHJ,[IRa. KpaJ'I 30.iIOTOB:
O:IHIIII;n 31HIIyTbl H HaxoAHT Jla 6pon-
.lOilYIO nOJ."-lilJ.KY.
D.1HlIII;1I IiPl'IIII.iIUCb Ha pe Ille npH
nO'>WU\1I nI'Te:lb. lfx I>OHI\hI 6bl.1H IIPH-
namlbI y "p.lH. liaR Y OJIHlIIeR TOro me
na:lllrt'lelllllI. IIl1ii;(eHHbIx B RypraHe y
3YUOlIl'''''I'O x Topa z'.
COXPIII/I/IJ(,Tb. B.1J1mIill nOMHTbI,
ocoo£'lwn II '\ UI'HTpa:IbHaH 'laCTb, r,[le
naXO IITCH rO,10na H03JIa. Ha OAHOii
umIlllKe rOJIona CIIJlIOru;eBa, na ,[Ipy-
roD: - BAaBJIeHa nora R03JIa; 60.1blllafI
'IaCTb IIHKpycTaQnn YTpa'ICHa. :y Tpl'X
6mIUIeR 'IaCTH'IHO yrpa'lCHa OpOlIJO-
naH OCBOBa. Y Bcex OTCyrCTB)'£'T neT-
.1H, JIumb y Anyx 6:IHlllCK Yl\e:IC.1a HI'-
60JIbmaH ee 'laCTL, y APynlx - 3a'II'T-
HbI cJIe}J,bI ee IIpIIKpeIIJIeHHH. BpOH311
ORnCJIeHa.
Ha60p YRpameHuii Y3AC'l"U H3 6.1H-
meR-cpaJIap C H306pameHucM Any\. qm-
cpoHon HanAeH B IIepnoM Rypralle y
3y60BCRoro xYTopa (pIIC. 16, 1-6) ".
Toro me CTUJIH B cpOpMLl y60phI Baii e-
HbI B iRyrOBCROM n U CaAonoM KVpra-
nax 24. TaRBM me y60paM npunaJ:v;ema-
JIB ABe 6JIHmRn-cpaJIapa C 1I306pamenn-
I'M cnepnYBmerOCH xnmnnKa H3 "ypra-
na KYPAmUIICHOH CTaHIIl\bI; OHR IIHRPY-
crnponaHLl 6np103011; Y OAHoii - 00-
06paMJICnne B BUAe mrYTa C HOCbI m
naCeTfRaMU (puc. 16, 7, 8) zo. XapaHTep
CTnJIH, Tm,aTeJlbHOe HCIIo.aHeHHe II Ha-
JIB'lBe ,6UPI03hI (a He CTelwa) YKa3L1-
BaIOT Ba 60JIee paHHIOIO ,[IaTY KYPk
mUIICRUX 6JIHX IIO cpaBlleHlllO C 3ano-
pomCRllMU. BOJIee paHIlIIe II OOJI£'e
pOCRomllLIe BapuaHTbI TaIUlX Y3;:J.eQ-
HhIX y60pOB mupOKO IIpeACTaR,'1NlbI B
6hIBmeii ROJIJIeKl\IlR neTpa I, nanpll-
Mep, 'leTbIpe cpaJIapa co nCTaBKIIMII 113
araTa (puc, 17, 1-4).
Ho Han60JIee 6JIU3KOii II HIInOrT1I'ii
3alIopomcRHM 6JIHXaM HB.l1ICTCH 6:uuu-
KB JleCROlIbRO MenLmero pa3M£'pa. lIall-
AeHHaH B 28 Kyprane (pa:lrpilo.lI'lI-
Hm-I) CTaHHT{bI "YcTb-JIa6nllcRoii (puc.
17, 5) ze. Ha neii: u306pamell "O.le.l B
TOM me IIOJIOmenIUI, 'lTO n Jill {j.IJI'(a\.
U3 3arropomMI: rOJlona B (par. Ty.l0-
nnm,e B IIpOCPH,'1b, 110 TpaKTOBlI1I on 00-
JIee CYMMafJHo. OTCYTCTByeT y n.TJHm-
RII U paMK:f060AOI\ C nace'lKiBl1I
30JIOTOH HaROHe'IIIRK, opllam'IITllpf.-
BanJIbIH B TOM me CTII.1P II TI''\JIII''P. Yl:-
pamaeT HomHhI Me'Ia II:I "yprana Pn-
maBa Apamna B BO:Irapnn (pIlI' _ 1 R. 2).
178
113AaTe.1II I10mCII ]:\aTllpYIOT IIX Bpe [e-
nCM He II03]:I,IICC II B. II. 3. 21. Ha na-
IwnC'IBHKC 11306pameB oJI'eHb C rOJIonoii
B cpac H Ty.'IOBnm.e [ n npocpHJIb. Pa3-
1I11Qa B IWMn03IH!.IIn 06YCJIOBJICna TeM,
'ITO cpnrypa mIIBoTlIoro 3alIOJIHfIeT ne
KpyrJIoe, a KBap;paTHoe rrpocTpaHcTBo.
fHe3Aa C 3MaJIbIO UJIH CTeKJIHHHOn na-
CTOB: TaKoD me cpOpMhl, RaK Ha 3aIIO-
pomcKux 6JIHXaX, pa3Mem,eHhI na TYJIO-
Bum,e, ROIIbITaX n rJIa3aX OJIeHH. HaRo-
He'lHHK 06paMJIHeT e<mHYp. U3 IIpoBO.'10-
KU C naCe'lRaMIJ, TaR me, RaR U Haii,[len-
IIhIe TaM cpaJIapbI n cpaJIapLi P,Pyroro
RoncHoro y60pa, IIPOUCXOAHm,ue U3 KYP-
raHa Y 3y60BCROro XYTopa (pnc. 19) ",
BOJIrapCRaH BaxoARa YRa3LlBaeT, 'ITO
BCTO'lHnROM IIpeAMeTOB IIOJIIIXpOMHoro
..
- ,
t
.r
\ .
.,..... '4;":
a,:t't . , ..:!'
J-
"
...
..
--
.
"'\
, -
"' (;\.a
-.. .....fi':!Ii'
-, \ -..
" .
":. .,
- '\
- -......_ I
\.
1' '
'\. .
2
--
PIiC. 13. 11lel;I<ble ZpU6HU 113 6bl6/Ueii. KO,t-
.le'Hluli K!/IIcrKo."l'pbl llerpo 1 (crp. 180)
PIiC. 14. llieiiHas zpu6Ha U3 6bl.6/Ueii KO.lf-
.lrKIII/Ii Ky"crKO.Alepbl llerpo 1 (crp. 181)
o - OUIl\Un D":\ (j - Jl,eT8Jlh
Puc. 15. lloscHas n.'-aCTUHa U3 6bl6weu KO.I-
.1l'KII/1/ Ky"crKOMepbl lleTpa I (crp. 181)
Puc. 12. Hosc U 1IAaCTUHa:
J - 113 Malh<ODa (DOllynRal; B - 113 fihlBweR 110:1-
neIlD'"1 II )"BCTllaJlepH neTpa I
h
(C!' \
......
......
.. . ). f. -'
. . ..;. .
. "I,. ... .
.. ... .-
.,)" ,"
A If "....
... ,
: '\;.}'
J
I
I
o
"""
(11 .\", ...
"-
,. .
11 1
"ItC 1.'/
..
' 'Y
.' '-
...
-
a
,.,
. -
...
6
.
£.....
.
",
,
,
" '.
.
-;' -
'->
...
..... _.
. " --:
.
.
----J
..
I,, '"
, , - .
A-
t: -
Puc. 14, 15
",
,.
, '..,\ -
!..:
-
\
"
. ,
.
:II:
"""
. - ..
' " -
':
,.... trr."- .. ,
Cl .
-r,,- "'P'
6- -
... .. .
.
- .
. .. . .. ".
'...
.
t &. '-.
".
!l. '
6
r,, _"\....
... ...," '? ;i.
'-""-..
-.... .
":....."".
_-..-1fl
0.... .,' '""'
io
..,
""
,. ... l - ,
It,
" " ' \
-......
"'. .;t '\
- - .' ' ' . (
-
"
,
3BepUHoro CTll.'IH MOr;m 6bITb 061IJIb-
HaH p:parol\eIlHbl't1ll MeTaJIJIar.m CTpa-
na C OOraTbiMlI xy omecTBeHHbIMIi II
TeXnlI'JeCIiIlMII Tpap;U lIHMII, oTHy.na B
CeBepHOe TIplIqepHOMOpbe 1I0cTynaJIII
npep;MeTbI TOpeBTURU B CapMaTCRYIO
snoxy, TaH me HaH U B npep;bIp;yll\ylO
CKH<I>CHYIO 3noxy. IOmnoe npoucxom-
p;enue HonCRUX y60pOB nOJIUXpOMHoro
3Bepunoro CTUJIH nop;TBepmp;8IOT TaR-
me u306pamenIIH 6apca llJIlI JIbBUI(bI II
Puc. 16. llepsNu "ypMH Y 3y6oBCKOlO
xyropa. f/JaAopN:
1-6 - 83 1 ilypr8Ba y 3yOoBciloro xyropa;
1-8 - D3 ilypr8a8 HYPJJ.IKBnc; 5-6 - JJ.eTaJl8
CI1l'pIlYBIucrOCH JIbBa Ha 6JIHIUKax-<I>a-
.lill'ax Tom HiC na3UaqCIIIIH 113 Kypra-
HOII n) )hHnCROro (pIiC. 20, 1) II
Ca!1oBoro (j)IIC. 31. 1-'1).
4. j],BC lipyrJThIe 30JIOTbIe 6.'lHIIllm n8
;KeJlC31 UU ocnOBe C peJIbeI}JuhIM 1130-
opamellner.[ p03eTHU C p;eBHTblO JIcne-
cn,ar.m (puc. 6), 06paMJIeHHoii: Ba:IlI-
IWM C KOChIMU naCeqRaMU B BII.[(C
mnypa, COCT8BJIHJIn pacmnpem[bIe
liOHl\bI nca."lUeB. B l\CHTpe p03eTOli-
lipyrJIOC rHe3p;0 C BbInYRJIOU BCTaBIWII
cepo-ro.ly60ro CTelUla. Kpau 6JIHIlIeK
3arHYT; Ha 06paTnoii CTopone on na-
XOAUT Ha meJIe3HYlO ocnOBY. Y H8mp;0ii:
o;rHillRll 3arnYT ii: Hpaii: RMeeT BhIpe3
B TOM MeCTe, rp;e ona COeAHnHJIaCh co
CTepilmm[ nca:IlIf1. B naCTOHI..l\Ce Bpe-
MH oOJIQ}[annbIM. .
Y 06enx U:lfllliCii ne p;OCTaeT 'laCTIi
KpaH. CTeli."lO npmmpyeT, me."le30 CIIJIb-
DO Oli1lC:lenO; y O HOii: 6JIHmRJI YTpa-
qeDa OOJIbillaH qaCTh meJIe3HOn OCRO-
BbI. J],ua reTp 6:IHmeR -3,8 UI, BbICO-
Ta - 1,1 ot.
AHaJIOrUqllhIe 30JIOThIe YRpameHIIH
IIca:meB naiip:eHhI B Ca.[(oBoM Kypralle
(puc. 20. 2-3) U B Kyprane y 3y60B-
CHom xyropa (plIC. 19, 8-9); OTJUl'la-
IOTCH OHII TO:IbKO TeM, '1TO RMelOT BhI-
PIlC_ 17. lJi'Tblpe tfia..apa II 6ABUlKa-tfiaAap:
1-4 - 113 Oblomen ilOJI."leilQ8D ily&CTil8.MepLi lIeT-
pa I; S - 83 CT8aDIILI YCTb-JI80HBCil8R
... !t ""'-
--- - " -\, >
" \
.... . ...
I ' , ... .
.. ""- /
] , 4 -.
... "
Ib]
"
l. \
. I f
. .
- !!t
" .,
, - 0.. ._
-
-r
" \\,
i ""- " 2
'"
\'.
.t
183
. .. ,
-, it
,
. ,. f
.. .:1 '"
.A" , /
6 .,4!(
, f.
I' t
\ ff, I
'fl ,V
" ,. , i l .,
,,' ! . I
..
.. .,1"
1 8
C E./f) 2
_I
t
s
cTyn - 30JIOTYlO TpYUOqliY, B IWTOPYIO
BXOAI'IJI meJIe3DbIU CTepmCHb nCi\.lIIH .g.
Ha ay60BcHux lICaJIlIHX, Tali )l\C IWR II
na Y3p;e'lUhIX <I>aJIapax APyroro nauopa
B TOM me KypraHe (puc. 21, 1-4) U
lIa HomHax Me'la U3 BOJlrapDu. npll IC-
neua 0ADuaIWBaH OlianTOBKa D3 npo-
BO."lOKIi C naCeqRaMlI U rHe:J,TIa C nll-
HpycTaI.{Heii:. TaHoro me TlIna ifie:le.l-
UbIe ncaJIUU, JlUIIlb UliRPYCT1IpOBaHllbIC
30JIOTOM, HaUneHhI B TOM me 3YOOBC-ROM
KypraHe 30. Ho 6JIDmaiimeu ana:rorlIeii
p03eTH8M 3anopomcHux DcaJllIeB CJIy-
maT meCTh <I>aJIap ll3 ByepoBou Moru-
JIbI (pRC. 19, 1-7) 31.
P03eTHR, no CTUJIIO 6JI1I31me R 3a-
nopomCKllM, m 06pameHbI na o.1JHm-
,
......
'-
--
\..--
-
'io
-W. i '"-
3 __
-
,.
\"\
t t- )
,
.
Kax - YRpall1eHUHX nOUIIIeB 113 AJleR-
CaHp,pOIIOJlbc.lmrO liypraHa ", Y3p,e'IlibIC
y60pbl IWTOpOro npeACTaB:lHIOT nepp-
Xop,HyIO cTyneHL Memp,y y60paMu
CKHIj;>ClWii II CapMaTc.KOll :mox.
ItlTaR, Bce Boc.e)lb 6.'lHmeli-lj;>aJl3p 113
3a11opombH IIpU11ap,JlemaT KonCROMY
y60py, nop,oono HaiiJJ;eBBblM B Kypra-
Bax capMaTClioii :)I10X11 - CaJJ;OBOM,
iRYTOBCROM. YCTb-JIa6HHcliOM, I{ypp,-
munCROM, 3y60Bclioro XYTopa, a T3K-
me npep,CTaBJlC11HbI"l B liOJlJICRI.\I111
KYHCTKaMepbI.
EC.JlH 3a'\:opOllClIIIC Y3 e'IKJ1I BMeCTC
C 'IeJIOBel,OM 11 HII.1HCTCH C11MBOml'IeC-
KUM 3axopoHe1111C"1 IWlIn, TO ep,Ba :m
CJIe.n;yeT B 3T01>1 OObI'Iae B11AeTb (lca-
MDIB: npKJ1IB: nOIla3aTe.1L rpeKo-capMaT-
choro YKJlap,a» 33. OObl'Iaii: npOAIIKTO-
BaB 3KOHOMU'Iec.RII)1!I co06pamennHMII
Ii OTnIOp,b He CBR.IaB C rpeqeCl\UM yK-
JIap,OM.
nOJI1IXpOMllblU :iBl'pUllbIH CTnJIb no-
JIY'IaeT CBoe BbIpait\CnUe B CKYJIblITY'
pe 3HaqnTeJlbliO pe",c, qeM B peJIbelj;>e..
B 3TOM CMbICJIe oc060 BamHblM IIaMHT.
HlmOM fIBJIfICTCH IWMII.:IeI:C Kyprana
XOXJIaq, fAe B pe:IbelIJc 3TOT C.TUJIb
npenCTaBJIeU lIa Uf'.lO)1 pn.n;e IIpep;Me-
TOB, n TOJIbI:O 11[\ 0:1110:'1 cocYAe MI.l BU-
AllM RpymyIO CI>y.lbIITYPY -Ij;>urypy
mnBOTnoro, lWTopan c:rymHT PY'lKOll
cocyp;a (puc. 22, 1). 311aQCUUe HOBO-
'Iep"aCCRoro cocY;la ycn:mBaeTcn n
TeJoI OQCTOHTC.lhCTIIO)I. 'ITO an3JIorueii
eMY l\aK II OTIIOIIIl'lIl111 r}Jop)ILI, TaK II
CTIIJIfI C,l\"m11T l1:lUl'CTlIbIii )mrY.JI11Il-
mmii cocy C pY'lIioii B BlI;!C t}JI;rYPbI
XIIIqHIIl\a (?) _ :iT'> - IITopoii 113 lIe
MHOI'llX 06pa.I\\01I I'I;Y:lbIITypbI IIO:UI:-
xpOMHoro 3Bl'pllllOff) CTTI:1H 113 30.!JOT3
Puc. 18. HaKoHe "/I.- " "lCelt .lte a u tjJaAap
U3 Kyp2alta POIIU/611 . If' IUlHa (BoA2apull)
f'uc. 19. CPa.1II plJ
ncaAUC6 (8-91
XYTOpa
i) It HaKOHe HIIKII
. .'f/Ha Y 3y606CK020
,r'
-..
, <r;....
,"\. .
:J.V
'" \ 1\
'-.1 in
, . J"
\...., ;t"
.
.,.. ;.
...'-' - '1 '
':If' .
\ ..... .' A
' -
--
'\'1
2
{ . ...
t -
,.. \- i"
.
,{ .
r J ) ..... - ."i. \.. '1
......_ .1."/'
"j
, oj.
-, .
C
i
. . 'I
I .
,
':..
5
184.
...:.......
.
't
r
,..
1)\-<0
. .
\;e
.' ..(
.4 ,\
.I.
#
.
, .
) ..... '"
. ..
. "......
3
'.
.
'-
:<
6
f
," f
;,
.
-,
--
4
-:: .
.j",
; .
- -..,
'-.
.
,
'-j
. :'-'-
. {:,
. '::
7
-,
\.
\ .
8 Q
(pIiC. 22, 2). Ha OOOIlX Wc.YAax I1n-
KpycTaqneU (ee OC06eHHO Mllom na
cfmrype Xll1l\HnKa) BbIAeJIeHbI r:Ja-
:13, ymrr. oeApa. Ho )lIIrY:JnHCKIIii: co-
CYI\ elIW rr)leeT HaAnllCb C IIMeHeM Mac-
Tepa ".
£C.'111 cpaBHHTb 3anopomCime n.'Iac-
TllllbI C 060lIMll COCYAalollI, TO CTaHeT
HCIIO, '1TO Bce OIm npllHaAJIemaT OJ{HO-
y Y;I;omeCTBeHHOMY Kpyry.
113 npHBeAeHHJ.n: conOCT3BJIeHHii:
D1I1\1I0, 'ITO ynHKaJIbHbIll 3anopomClmii
PIlC. 20. t1Ja.l/.ap (6epzHuu) U Ha"OHe"HU"U
nca.tUe6 U3 CaiJo6ozo "ypzaHa
PUC. 21. t1JaAapN U3 Byepo6ou .VOZUAN
IWMnJIeKC IIcpm p),Jnnu ("[\Juan. C O;I;Hon
CTOpOllbI, C XOpOlllU ':l<ITII pOBarrnbIMIi
norpe6eHIIHMII, TaIiIlMII. IiaI> l\ypraHbI
XOXJIa'I, Y 3y60RCI>Oro YTopa, fKYTO-
BO, a C APyroii CTOpOIIbI, - C 6bIBIlleiI
KOJIJIe Heii nCTpa I. 3a)leTIOr, oJ{na-
KO, 'ITO eCJIH CIUrBOJIII'leCiiOe 3axopo-
HemIe KOHH BCTpe'laeTCH B pHAe na-
MHTHIIKOB, TO nOHCllbl(' n.'IaCTIfHbI TBna
CH6HPCRHX npf'I\CT3B.lellbI TOJILI;:O B
KaJIHHIIHCKOM n 60JIec nO:IHO - n 3a-
nopomCROM KOMnJIeI\Cax. 3TO 06CTOH-
TeJIbCTBO HBJIHeTCH Qpe3BbI'IanHO Bam-
HLlM «I>aKToM B pemf'II1m Bonpoca 0
HeCTe H3rOTOBJIeHlfH 60JIbmnHCTBa
npep;MeTOB CH611pCROii I;:O:JJIeRQIIH BHe
3aBHCIIMOCTH OT MeCTa II}, HaxOAIUI, ne
roBOpH yme 0 TOM, 'ITO 33nopOmCIUIf'
n:mCTIIHbI TO'lHO onpe,g;e:JHIOT «I>ym;:-
1{1I1O napIIbIX nJIaCTIIH CIIOlfpCl\OU KO.TI-
JICI;:QIIII. PemaIOIl{HM MOMenT01\! HBJIH-
eTCH TaKme CXOACTBO CTII:IfI y"pame-
HrrH 30JIOTOrO HaROHe'lHnKa 1I0men Me-
qa - ann.'1llRaI.\HH ll3 POlliaBa L{para-
Ha (pHC. 18, 2) 35 He TOJIbKO C Y:I;{(''lnbI-
Mil 6JIHIllKaMH ll3 3alIopombH n 3YOOll-
C.ROro KypraHa, HO 11 C p;pynnr )"3jJ.eQ-
HblM Ha60pOM, IIHRPYCTIIpOBaUHbIM
BeTHLTMII CTeKJIaMII 113 Tom me 3y-
60BCRom KypraHa (pIIC. 19) 38. II Ha
HaROHe'IHHKaX 113 PomaBa L{parana, 11
Ba lIaXOARi:n;: If:! .JyfioBcKoro KypraHa
p3)umii CJIymaT «I>lfJIilrpanHblC :mCTllKII
n.lI01l\a II TaMrooopa3HLIC 3n3KII.
IIpOlIc omJ{eHHe ROJIJIeIH{HII KYHCT-
Ra)repbl IIeTpa I HeIl3BCCTII0, XOTH
06bI'lHO ona Ha3LIBaeTCH clIunpcKoii
Ha TOM OCHOBaHHH, 'ITO HeCKO.'1LRO 30-
.ilOTbiX npep:MeTOB npllHec B Aap EKa-
TepHHe B 1715 r. B CBH3H C pOmp;eHIlf'M
HaCJIeJ{HHKa BJIaAeJIe TarnJILCKOrO
3aBOAa L{e)r p:flD. 3Ha'IIITeJILHOe KOJIll-
'IeCTBO IIX B CJIep;yIOII{eM, 1716 r. npll-
C;IaJI neTpy I, IICnOJIBHH YKa3 apH,
cn6HpcKHii ry6epHaTop rarapHH 31.
CpeAB nepBblx nocTynJIeHnii: 6J.IJTII
II."IaCTIIHbI C H306pameImeM clleH OT-
p;bIxa nop; AepeBoM II OXOTbi Ha Ka6a-
If \, II
.
.5 ' L '--
t
" . I i I
A .... ...... ....
) . .,
G \.
, 't.
. I
J) ...
V . ....J
" -
, f
!.
I
to' """-,
.. .J
'., -- .
. ..
-...
,. .. (" ('"-
--s l"-
t 1
.... r ,
\ I I...
,
( );,
4
2
186 18/
PUC. 22. COCyiJN U3 "ypzaHo6 XOIAa" (1)
U craHulfN Muzy.l/.uH.C"OU (2)
Ha J8, If XOTH MHOrUe 30JIOThIC npep;MeTLI
nocTynllJm B KYHCTl\aMepy yme nOCl[e
CI>lepTU IIeTpa I, op;naHO cp8I\T nop;HO-
meHUH 30JIOTa AeMlfp;oBhIM U farapH-
HbIM He nOMemaJI IICCJIep;OBaTeJIHM BCIO
HOJIJIeIDJ,HIO 6hIBmeH KyncTHaMepbI
IIeTpa I onpep;CJIDTL HaH CU6UPCHYlO J8.
B Cu6IIpn, np8.Bp;a, 6hIJIll Hanp;eHhI B
norpe6eHUHx nJIaCTIIHhI nop;06HoH cpop-
MhI U3 6pOB3hI U p;epeBa n u306pame-
nUH 60pL6hI 3BepeH, HO nx CTHJIL He-
CHOJILHO UBOH u, a 30JIOTLIX npep:MeTOB
nop;06HoH cpopMLI U CTUJIH B CU6lIplI
nOHa HeT. Yme 11. 11. TOJICTOH U
H. II. KOHP;8HOB llHCaJIU, "liTO te...Bcero
HCHee npe1];CTaBJIHeTCH... pOP;CTBO xyp;o-
meCTBeHlloro (3BepUHoro? - A. M.)
CTUJIH npep;MeTOB, naHp;eHHhIX B Hyp-
raHax CH6upu U CHUCPCHRX Hypra-
HaX& ".
M. 11. POCTOB.qeB, YHa3hIBaH Ha
TeCHeHmyro 6JU130CTL HOBO'IepHaCCHux
U CR6upCIQIX npep,MeTOB, B TO me Bpe-
MJI OTMe'laJI, 'lTO teCu6RpCHoe nponc-
Xomp;eHUe... TaH Ha3hIBaeMhIX cu6up-
clmx Bell\eH 3pMUTama... p;aJIeHO He
neCOMnenno.., XOTJI B 0611\eM U Bepo-
JlTnQ) u.
BOJIee onpep;eJIeHHO no 9TOMY BOnpO-
cy BbICHa3aJICH H. 11. BeceJIoBCKllii.
IIo ero MneHulO, CU6IIpCHOe npouc-
xomp;eHlIe HOJIJIeHQuu IIeTpa I onpo-
BeprnYTO IpaHTU'leCHRM MaTepuaaOM.
YHa3bIBaH na CXOP;CTBO HaXop;OH U3
HOBO'lepI\3cn\a, 3y60BCHIIX U TaK n8-
3bIBaeMbIX cR6upCHUX, aBTop 3aHBJIHeT,
'lTO olin ne npe1];CTaBJIJlIOTCH npIIHap;-
JIemalQ"'rI1 CU6RPU u. IIo nOBO.[(y
CXop;CTBa B TpaKToBHe mnBOTHL[X,
nanpUMep, na HOB01iepKaCCKOl>r cp:laKO-
He H U Ha CIl6IIpCKOH MHxe" OH nII-
meT: «l\IO;J;HO P;YMaTL, 'lTO Benw BbI-
mJIR H3 PYK op;Horo MaCTepa» u.
KaK 6bIJIO OTMe'leno BLnne, 30JIOTbIe
llJIaCTIIBbI nop;o6Bon cpOpMLI II CTll.'H
B Hypranax Cu6upu p;o C!lX nop He
BCTpe'la.'liCL. 3aTo na eBponeiicKoii
'laCTU CCCP B Hypranax cap aTcKofl
:mOXII BUOBL oonapymeHhI Bb[p;alOlI\uc-
CH npe IeTbI nOJIBXpOMHoro 3BepliHoro
CTUJIJl: 0.'113 HOBO'lepn:acCna B 1962 r. n
II 6J1I[3 ceJIa iKyrOBO B 1964 r. I8 .
C. 11. t\anomUHa cnpaBe1];JIIIBO C'lUTaeT,
'lTO 6e3 orOBopKH TepMIIH «Cu6HpCKaH
f\OJIJIeKl\nJl) yuoTpe6JIHTb neJIb3H (8.
Cpep;lI IHornx naxop;OH, C eJIaHHbIX
nOCJIe Bb[XOn;a B CBeT pa60T H. 11. Be-
CeJIOBclioro u A. A. CnuQhIn3, BamHeu-
meft, 6eccnopHO, HBJIHeTCH 3allOpOm-
CHaH, 6.'l3rO apH HaJIU'lB1O B neH 6JIJIX
nOHclIOro Ha60pa. CXOP;CTBO ee C npe,!];-
MeTal>IlI t\YHCTHaMephI U HOBO'lepK3C-
CIlIum, 3 'Iepe3 nRX If C MHryJIllnCKH)r
cocyp;m.r He BhI3hIBaeT COMneHUH B
nplIn3;J;:leif\HOCTU UX OAHOMY xyp;o-
meCTBCIIH011Y f\PYry. IIo nameMY Mne-
HnIO, ::JTOT lipyr naXO,!);UTCH Ha ceBepe
B3JIII311CliOro nOJIYOCTpOBa, 0 'leM CBU-
p;eTe.'lbCTBYIOT nomnhI Me'la U cp8JIap
113 POW3Ba AparaHa. II paBp;8 , 9Ta
naxop;lia Ta)I nOHa HBJIJIeTCH eABnn'l'
Hon, 110 npll'lRna 9TOro HpOeTCJI B ne-
n;OCTaTO'lHOll u3yqeHHoCTH TeppUTopnn
DOJIrapnn.
M. II. PocToB.qeB na ocnOBannH
CXOn;CTlI<I lIaxo.[(OI\ n3 HypraHa XoxJIa'l
I[ fIplII,yiiaHbH npHmeJI K BLIBOP;Y, 'lTO
)[eCTO 1 113rOTOBJIeHHH MnrYJIIInCHOro
cocY;:la (ib1.' IIanTunaneH. Op;naHo aB-
TOp nenpaBII.-lbHO nCTOJIHOBaJI na'lep-
T3HHYlO Ha cocyp;e H3,!J;nUCb C P;BYMH
(IlpaImiicliH){u IIMenaMII, 1I3 HOTOpblX
O 1I0 - TapYJIac - HBJIHeTCH UMeneM
[aCT(>pa. 011 BbICKa3bIBaeT npep;nOJIO-
)!wnuc. 'lTO COcyP; 1l3rOTOBII.'lII B IIan-
TIII,alJee Herpe'leCHne mUTeJIII CTOJllIQbI
DOC I/O!',] «(( ICCTHLle 3JIJInHD3IIpOB3H-
JlLIC II,UTe.-I1}» nJIU «MeCTELle cppalmii-
Ubi)) S0.
H. II. BeCeJIOBClmii TaKme C'lllTa:1
fIaIlT[II,i1 Iii QeHTpmI 113rOTOBJIeHIIH
npeUll'TUB DOJIHxpoMHoro 3BeplInoro
CTI[.ll!. ., liOTOphIM npHHa;:J;.'lCmnT II
lJIrY:lllllclinil cocyp;, U 'ITO :nu 1I3;te-
.lnll - p,1I10Ta He B8pnapOB, a HapO;:J;a
ALlcnl.nll "y.'bTypbI 51. B TOT me Hpyr
188
..........."........,r.. ............1..
\,."" .Ai "' '''C' ''
.-... II A ... £4 "
'- ..,..... ,.. .r ...
naMHTHRIWD OH BI';.11I04a.-l n C1I6IIpCKYIO
liOJIJIeHQUIO '2.
Ho B IIaETIIf\anee He 6bl.'I0 HII pa3-
BIiTOrO xyp;omecTBeIiHoro pe)wcJIa, nll
YCTaHoBUBmDXCJl Tpa;lllIJ,nii, a rJIaBlIOe,
He 6blJIO p;parouenHoro CbIpbH - OCHOB-
nOB npep;nOCbInKIi n Jl nOJlBJIeHIlH p -
MeCJIa n cpOp!olIIpoBaHlIH Tpa,qn.qnu.
I13yqeHIIe p;epeBHnHblx cocynoB CKUcp-
Puc. 23. HO:JICHbL Me..a 113 Crapoii. 3azopbL:
1 - 06II1HA BRIt; 2 - neTa:rb
,
....-.-
..
-.
. .
J'J
\ .
I -'.A'
" oO.
. .
, . .
. t- -
- . -J
-
2
..,
.L
,,.
. ..
Clioii :moxli lIo:mo:IJIJlO 113M C l'.[i1T1,
nbIBOp;, 'ITO II )lJIryJllIHClUIii, II nonG-
'lepliacclmii COCy.n;bI U3 rOT OBJIe II LI na
ceBcpe BaJIKaEcKoro nOJIYOCTpOBa, r;J;e
6bIJlIl n HaJIR'lllJl Bce He06xop.lIMblC
liOMnoneHTbI JI,JIH TaHoii npep;nOCbIJI-
lill '3. 3TO DOJIOmeHUe nop;TBepm,!J; eTcH
nap;nIlcblO MacTepa CeBTa 113 IIanara-
pbI n3 ,!J;pyroM npOU3Bep;eHuu Topen-
TIiKIr Toro me BpeMeHH - cepe6pHHLL\
HomHax: Me'la U3 CTapOH 3arO bl
(pRC. 23) u. TpYP;HO p;onYCTUTL, 'lTOUbl
)raCTepa C cpp8lUIHCKIlMH llMeIla)1I!
\
..
..
189
I J
.JI
.I
- .} .
f
-tI
.
't
...
.,-
'\
oJ
.
"I ...-
...I
",.,.-
. ...
.
.. A
..
.. y-
"
-....
w -\
lI.JrOTOBJI1IJIII 30JIOTble II Cepe6pHHbIe
IIpeAMeTbI rl\e-111100 B nHOM IeCTe
pOMe cBoeD 60raToH cTpaHbI. HeJIb3
lIe COrJIaCUTbCH C C. 11. KaIlOIllllHOD:,
'1TO (maMHTlllllW, UJIU3KUe IIO CTUJIIO
no PHI\Y npu3HaKoB IIpBHa.D;JIema
OAHOMY xyp;omecTBellHoMY KPyry, MOl'-
:I1I IIpOIICXOP;UTb 113 OAIIOTO xyp;omecT-
BeHHoro lleHTpa& ".
Hap;IIHCb Ha MIIrYJIllHCKOM cocY1:t;e
naTIIpOBaJIaCb B. B. JIaTbImeBbIM
II B H. a. '.. O'leBUp;HO, U CTIIJIIICTII'leC-
1\11 CX01:t;HbIe C COCYJIOM lIJIaCTIIHLI 113
3alIopombH, KaK U BCH Haxop;Ka, MOryT
JIaTllpOBaTbCH TeM me BpeMeHeM. 06
3TOM me rOBopHT II IIpDBep;eHHLIe BhIIIIe
aHaJIoruil Be aM II D306pameHDJIM Ha
BUX.
3a UCI\JIIO'leHlIeM yx 6JImneK (po-
3eTI\II) Bce llpep;MeTbI 3alIopomcKoD
Haxop;1OI BblllOJIHeHLI B eWlHOM IIOJIU-
XpOMHOM 3BepunoM CTUJIe, HO Ha'JeCTBO
IIX IICIlOJIHeHIIH pa3J1H'lH0: Ha nepBOM
MeCTe CTOUT 6paCJIeT, 3aTeM IIOHClILle
IIJIaCTI/nbI H na IIOCJIeAlleM MeCTe-
U3.n;emIe peMeCJIeHHHl\a - Y3p;e'lHbIn
y60p U3 6JIHmel\ C 11306pameHueM H03-
na U ncanlleB C p03eTHaMU.
06bf'lHO 3TOT CTUJIb Ha3bIBaeTCH
capMaTCHIiM 57. OJl.HaHO (lTOT TepMIIH
CJIep;yeT nOHUMaTb B 3Ha'leHUn BpeMe
II" 6bITOBaHIIH CTIIJIH, a He HaH npo-
.n;YHT TBOp'leCTBa capMaTCIUIX nneMeH.
TIpll'lIlHbI 3TOro UblJIH YHa3aHbI BLIme.
. Kpyr lIaMHTHnKOH, npHBep;eHHbIX B
l{a'JeCTBe aHanornH 3alIopomCHOD Ha-
:xo.n;lte, - XOXJIa'l, MuryJIUHCHaH, Hypn-
mUIIC, YCTb-JIa6I1HCKaH. BepXHee TIo-
rpOMHoe, Haxo.n;KU B HypraHax Cano-
BOM II iI\yTOBCKOM, a TaKme HomeH
Me'la II npyrnx IIaMHTHUHOB B PomaBa
L{paraHa qBu.n;eTe.m.CTBYIOT, 'lTO B cap-
MaTCKYIO "iJ/1oxy ocym;ecTBnHJIIICb CBH-
3n MeCTH6ro HaCeJIeHUH CeBepHoro
TIpU'lepHO\l:OpbH II TIpDKy6aHLH C TIo-
;lYllaIJbCM II.'IlI 'WPC.J lIero C CCBCpOM
Ea.'Il\aHcl\oro no.'Jyoc pOBa. HpI,;aJl
l,;apTlllJa .:nnx CBH3en Ba MaT!.'pnaJIe
mpo,J,lI111 Hllmnero L{Hcnpa HapnCOBa-
lJa 1\1. it. BH3bMllTIIHOD '8.
3BepllHbIii CTn.lb C npnMeH!.'II1Ielll
lJIll,;pYCTaL\nn, KOTopaH cnoc06CTBOBa.la
npeBpalllellIIIO ero B opnaMenT, ObITO-
Ba.;!, lla'lUHaH C nOCJIe.D;BIIX Bel\OB p;o
Hamen 3PbI, II AaJIee, B nepBbIe BeHa
IlamCII 3PM. TI03AHee BOIIlJIU B MOp,y
HOBbie MaTepnaJThI, 6bI:Ia OCBoeHa U
.n;OBe.1eHa AO cOBepmeHcTBa TeXHUHa
06pauoTKH rpaHaToB II CTeHJIa. 30JIOTO
II cepeupo YTpaTn:ll1 CBOIO pOJIb BeJ),y-
lIJ,IIX MaTepUaJIOB. OHH OHa3aJIDCL
,;mllIb oCHoBon Jl,JIH CnJIOmHOn JlHKpyC-
TaL\lHI U3 TOB'lanmJlX rpaHaToBbIx IIpO-
:Jpa'iHblX IIJIaCTUHOK OTJIII'lIlOD: mJIII-
<}JOBI\", BIWIO'leHHbIX B rne3J),a CO
CJlOaiHbIMH KOHTypa!>lIl. £IOHBHJICH HO-
BbIll, TaH Ha3b1BaeMbID: roTClGln CTIIJIL.
06pa3lJ,bI TaHoro CTDJIH II TeXHmm-
naxo.n;1U1 IV-VI BB.: MOpCHOH qy-
JICK '"0 KYJ),DBeToBo "0, CHJIell B Kep'in
400 ro.n;a.t, 3aTeM BaXOJ),KU VII-
VI II BB.: TIepelI\!.'ITHHO oz, fJIo.n;occa 83
II np} rue.
110 He cpa3Y Hacrymm nepe:IOM, He
I _-\I13.'ID3 npOHaBeAeu aaB. xm(. na60paTo-
pile" J10 I1A AH CCCP 11. B. EorAaHO-
lIoii-Eepe30BCKon.
fhol'iIIIIBaHlie nponaBeneno B XB)L JIa60-
paTopnlI f3 XIIMIII<Q)( R fl. BnHorpaAo-
lIoii 2.\"1 1971 r.
3 11110. f3, CII 1727 I 141. II. II. TO;JCTOn R
I L n_ KOB;J,a"on. PYCC"I\(' ApeBBocTR B
lIiBIJITBUKaX nCIiYCCToa. OLm. 3. cno.,
IR IO. CTp. 49. puc: .:;2. C. II. PYJIen"o npa-
IIII.lbilO BU;(UT B He}1 ronOBY OJIeBH (C. H.
f'yi'leHlto. CnoupcKaH IiO;JJlI'K I1H TIeTpa I.
(-_\II, Dbm. ;:(3-9. 1962, CTp. 43).
III1R. n cn 1727 1/210; /1_ H. TOACTOa
/I H. ll. h"oHOaIt06. }'Ka3. CO'l., CTp. 45,
II\IC_ 44.
1100;\nKa 1904 r. lIuB. r3 234311-2.
" I ;T- JfaHlfe6u". CepbrlI n3 CTaHH bI
I\I'hl\lCKon. -\cra, 1961, N! 2, CTp. 154,
1-. 1-160.
_\lIa.1113 npoll3BeAeH 11. B. Eor;tanOBoii-
r,"peaoBcKoii.
PUC. 24. PyltoRTlta H03/ta II nepCTeHb U3 61>16-
weu Ito.ueltlfuu ItYHcTIta.Mepb1 lleTpa 1
19lJ
cpa;!}" 6bl:l 3a6hIT B:la.n;enllluii Booopa-
meHueM XYJ),omHllI\OB llO'lTlI Tpn 'Il'T-
BepTU TbICH'le.1CTIIR CTllJlb TCPOlllOp<fJ-
HLIll. Ha 3ana;I.e em OTUJIeCKII )lOmHO
BIIp;eTb BO BTOpO!>1 K.la,1;C CII.1Jl>H,J,billOM-
JIliO C pro 3HalllelllITbllIIII <}Jlloy.'Jalllll,
JlCIIO:J:HeHHbI\lll 'l8CTII'Ino B 3BepUHOM,
a 'laCTU'lIiO B rOTChml CTIIJIe.' nJIn B
tPII6YJIax C ABOihlOll npOTOMon OJIeIIR
U3 Kep'lII.', II.'III Ha pbI6e-nTlIL\e n3
KOHlJ,eillT B Mo.l,J,aDllll II. 06pa3lJ,ml
CMemaHHoro 3BepIlllo-rOTChoro CTIIJIfi
MomeT C:IymuTL II 6pac.leT, naH;J;eHHbIll
Ba Ta!.l3HU B 1854 r.. ' A nOHB."IeHIIe
HOB oro CTUJIH IIeperopOiJ;'JaTOH I1HI>Py-
CTa UII MomBO Bu.n;eTb ellle B KOMIIJIeK-
ce HypraHa XOXJIa'l: 3TO - tPJIaKOH C
eIIO'llmfI, nOBepXIIOCTb IWToporo «B
BIIJ),e pemeTO'lKU» nOKpblTa «K}TOqiia-
Mil CMa.lbThI rO:ly6oro, 6UplO30Boro n
p030BOro llBCTOB& II. TaKIIM 06pa30M,
II0JIY'IaIOT 06'LHCHeHIIC II BXOJI,HII\IIe B
COCTaB CU6UPCKOii KOJI:Iel, Un TaKlle
TUIIU'lnWe npen\(eTbl rOTCKoro CTIIJIJI.
HaK PYROJITHa Homa.. UJIH IIepCTeHb
C UHHpYCTa I1eH (puc. 24) 70, a TaHme
II pH.n; npyrnx npe;:Y!>leToB. ana.'lorn'l-
HbIX Haii:.n;eHHbIM Ha TeppUTOplIJi Beur-
pIlJl, '-lexBu, BOJIrapnn_
B C. H. h"anoWllHa. Ll,I'lIlIbll' HaXO;(IiU ap-
XeOJIoroB B pa"OIH' 1I0uo'II'llIiacc"a. BAIl
1963, N, 3, CTp. 128-130; S. I. Kaposh;-
na_ A Sarmatian Ronll Burial at Novo-
cherlassk. Antiquity: '-01. XXXVII, :oJ 148,
December, 1963, p. z;,t)- :J8; OHa 3/te. fla-
)fHTlllllm Cap}IaTCI;oro .111. 1'IIII0ro CTIIJlIIIIJ
Ca;J,ORoro l>ypraHa_ t l"j I. I' honnCL, CTp.
I. U"'paa;alO r.1Y;;0I;y 1 ii:lllrolapHOCTb aR-
TOp ;Ja BO,J)!OmIlO"TI. II .II<II;O}!lITbCH C pa-
OOTO" II pa 3 pl'lIII: III II' Olly;;.ll1IiooaTL He-
lI;qallllLlii CI'OTOCIIII}IIII._
· n.laCTIIHbI C U.JOiil'iI;!;\'IIII..)1 opJIa II «Hlia>'
n leK)T BCT8BI\1I OIl)'ln--II.1 I\ I, n!loc."ne, Tal,
II RbIllYIi.lbW_ . 11.10' '"'' IIpOnll'(I.leIIbI OT-
oepCTUH. 1i0To)".I" Yl:iI'IoIJlillOT lIa BTOPlIq-
Hoe nCn0:1b30IU\II\11' IT" \ " ('O lIiOB unJuo-
aLl. lIepOOUaQa_1LIlII '_I ;I;I[III11I1X npOHII-
3H)11I 11:111 nO:IRN" 1,.1 \III
'0 Pall . IX. 21, 2.
.. B. n. WIlA06_ IIOII"'''''IIIIH Cap}IaTCIiOii
3uaTli I B. ;(0 IL ,,_-- I 1'- II. ;). (npe;(BapII-
191
Te;IblIoe cooG enlle). Cf8, BbIli. IX. J1.,
1956, pllC. Ha CTp. 44.
12 MHB. f3 CM 1727 1/5 II 1/6.
13 3TOT 1I0f!C nClipaRII."IbIiO OlipelleJIeH A. A.
MecceliOM l,aK 1I0;1i\eJII,a (C}I.: A. A. Hec-
ce n. Tal, na3bJRae}Iblii «}IaHI<OIlCKnll
rrOIlC». ACf3, 1961, oM 2, CTp. 163-177).
" MHB. f3 CM 1727 1/150. OGbIqHO 3Bepb,
Jl306pameHIIbllI Ha lI.laCTJlHe B 60pb6e co
3MeelI, CqIITaeTCf! <paHTaCTlIqeCI<IIM. B i\ell-
CTBIITeJIbHOCTII ;I,e OH 60JIbme Bcero 110-
xOm Ha pea.%I1oro GapcYKa C ero 3aOCT-
peHHoll KaGallbel1 MOPIIOii II KOrTJICTbnm
JIalla}I1I. 3TO ;rmROTJlOe paclipocTpaHeHo
110 Bcell EBpoile. K TOMY me 6apcYK IIB-
JIlleTCf! Bparml 3}lerr (CM.: A. 9. Ep3M.
iKII3Hb mIIROTHJ,lX, T. I. Cll6., 1893, CTp.
677, 681, 682, 685 [«6apcYKY 60JIbme Bce-
1'0 HpaBf!TCf! ra;110KII»]). MbICiIb 0 TOM,
qTO Ha llJIaCT!lHe 11306pameH 6apCYK, BbI-
CKa3alla HbIHe nOKonHOII B. <1>. IIlTeHH
B CTa Tbe «30;:rOTbTe cII6IIpCKIIe llJIaCTIIUbi
c I130GparI,(lrrn(l r «I,a6aHa), OOtHIToro
3}Wen» (<<C!!O!!PCKIIU apxeoJIOrlIqeCKlIn
C60PHHK». HOROCn6IIpCK, 1966, CTp. 259-
264).
!5 HHB. f3 CI1 1727 1/62 II 1/67. H. H. TOk
crail, H. ll. [{OHaO/W6. YKa3. COq., CTp. 48,
plIC. 50; C. If. pyaelt"o, YKa3. COq., Ta6JI.
XVIII, 8.
16 I1HB. f3 CI11727 1/159 JI 1/160. H. H. TOk
crail, fl. ll. f{rJ//aa,,06. YKa3. COq., CTp. 51,
pIIc.56.
,7 I1HB. f3 CI1 1727 1/3. C. n. Pyoenl>o.
YKa3. COq., Tao.l. I, 4.
18 B. ll. mU.WB. llorpe6eHIIII capMaTCKOll
3I1aTII...
19 C. H. Pyoeltl>o. YKa3. COq.
lO B l,a.ll1HoBCI;o11 uaXOAKe i\0 Toro, KaIi
olla 1I0llaJia B lIorpe6eHlle, I<pOMe «YKO.'
pO'IPI[[[f!» H.laCT!!!Ibl, 6h1JIa 113"bf!Ta cpei\-
HHH 'lacn, opac:wTa II 1I0.l0BIIHa rpuBHbI
(B. ll. mU.10B. na.lI1HOBCKlIll l<ypraHHMii
MOfllJIbllllK MIL\. J',! 60, 1959, CTp. 463-
1,64. pile. 51).
21 I1AK, RbIn. 1. CIlG., 1901, CTp. 95, pIIC. 1.
HHOii CHoroo I:PPII:IPHHf! Ii pP IHIO Y OJIH-
IIIt'Ii II:J Ca:lllllolO Kypraua, Ha ooopoTe
y IIUX UpUllaHJlI,1 :<Re BepTIIKa.lbHblC 110-
,lOCK!! OpOIIJI,I. "OTophie BCTaBJIf!mICb B
Uai\pC3 PP [[[H It pa3rII6aJIIICb.
22 '-!PTblpe :m:!(' -,U.1Hpa 1I0naJIII B c06paHIIe
8pMIITa;lia. JIIII!. f8 2234/25. MAK, Bblii. 1,
Ta 1 mP. pll<" a. 0; IIf!Tblil - B AHTuKRa-
puple R Eep.l'"jl' (.4. Greifenhagen. Eins-
kythisches Zinr-tiick.- «AA 1969» Heft.
I,S.49-52..\i,b 1-4). '
23 He II3;:\an.
" S. I. KaposhinQ Op. cit., pI. XXIX, b. c.
" JIHB. r3 Hy I ," 6 1/95, AliaMeTp 2,8 CM:
UHB. Ky 1896 1/94, Al1aMeTp 2,2 CM (0"\1>,
1896, CTjJ. 64, pllC. 305 JI 306, CTp. 1.,.:;,
pllC. 519 U 520).
26 I1I1B. r3 2239/1 (OAK, 1902, CTp. 78, pile.
164: 3HaqllTCH «OT nOllca»).
27 11.. fluI>0.A.06 U Xp. EYIOI>.A.Ue8. TpaKlIllCl<1I
MOrllJIHII rp060Be OT 'IaTam;a, CTap03a-
ropCI<O. <,ApxeoJIorlIli EAI1», 1967, JI.! 1,
CTp. 25, puc. 9.
26 CJIei\yeT 3aMeTIITb, qTO 1I0JIIIXpOMIIf! B
3BepIfHOM CTIIJIe capMaTCIWII 3110XIf f!B-
JIf!eTCIi JIlImb B03pOmAeHIIeM Tpai\IIl\IIU,
CIIOllCTBeHHblX TopeBTIIKe VII II VI BR. 06-
pa3 aMII nOJIIIXpOMHoro CTIIJIf! Toro Bpe-
MeHII CJIYmaT, HaliplIMep, YKpameHIlf! TpO-
Ha, AllaAeMbi II lIaHTepbI II3 ne.'lepMeCa,
OJIeHb cTaHII bI KOCTpOMCI<Oll, HOmilbI
TOKMaKoBKII, Cepbl'II CTaHII bl KpblMcr;oll
II T. A. Bce OHII IIHKPycTlIpoBaHbI 611p10-
30II II cepi\OJIIIKOM IIJIJI IIX HellpoqHblMII II
60JIee AemeBbIMII 3aMeHIITeJIliMII -
3MaJIbIO, IIHTapeM, remlIpoM, lIaCTon, B
HaCTOf!Il\ee BpeMIi 1I0qTJI 1I0JIIIOCTbIO YT-
paqeHHbIMII.
29 HAK, BblII. 1, CTp. 95-96, pllC. 3. Omll-
6oqHO Ha3BalIbI, KaK II APyrlle 6JIHmKII,
IIplIHaAJIemaBmlle Y3AeqKe, <'OKOHeqHIIKa-
MJI nOllca». HHB. 2234/5.
30 TaM me, CTp. 98, plIC. 16. HHB. 2234/24.
31 AlIal1eTp 5, 6 (CM. HHB. Eyep. Mol'. 45.
OAK, 1870-71, CTp. IX); M. If. Pocr06-
/fe8. CKII<p1I1I II Eocnop. J1., 1924, CTp. 550.
32 AfC. ATJIaC, Bblii. 1. Cll6., 1866, Ta6JI. VII,
12.
33 M. H. PoCr08/fe6. YKa3. COq., CTp. 616.
3< M. If. POcr08/fe6. HaAlllIcb na :JOJIOTO I
cocYAe II3 CT. MurYJIIIHcIwii:. lIAK, Bbm.
63. llr., 1917, CTp. 107; H. H. CMUpHn8.
BOCTOqHOe cepe6po. Cll6., 1909, Ta6JI. X,
27.
35 11.. HU"0.A.08 II Xp. EYIO".A.Ue8. J'r;a3.
COq., plIC. 11.
36 HAR, BLIIJ. 1, TaOJI. I I.
37' A. A. CnU/fbLIt. CII6IIpCKali IWJIJIeK1111 f!
KYHCTKaMepbl. <,3an1ICKII OTi\P.ijelllIf! pyr-
CKOII II CJIaBf!IICKOii apXeOJIOrlIH PYC(".[;OfO
apXPOJIOrllqeC-KOro 06IqeCTBa», T. 8. Rloln. 1.
CIIo., 1906, CTp. 4.
'8 H. H. TO.A.croil U H. ll. [{onao"n8. y"WI.
COq., CTp. 50-63, pliC. 69-71.
39 C. H. Pyoenl>o. YKa3. COq., CTp. 11-12.
'0 G. Borovfa. Scythian Art. London, 1 <)26.
p. 1, 61,18, 74; A. B. l1.a8bla060. H RO-
npocy 0 HCKJlX xYi\OmeCTRCHHblX 0['011-
3ax. CA, 1971, oM 1, CTp. 173, pllC 5: ,"I r.
Ca8un08. llorpe6eHile C 6p01l30ROii: 0.1f!-
xoii B eHTpa.lbHolI TYBe. KUlA. "I.III.
119, 1969, CTp. 106, pllC. 51.
" H. H. TO.A.croil U H. ll. [{OltaO"08. ''-'';11.
COq., CTp. 43.
42 M. ll. Pocr08/fe8. CIm<pIff! II EOCIIOp,
CTp. :>83. , "
" H. II. BeCe.A.08Cl>uii.. KypraHbI Ky6aHcKoJl
06JIaCTif B lIepllOi\ PIf}!CKOrO BJIai\bIqeCTBa
ua CeBepHoM naBKa3e. «TpYAbI 12 AC»,
T. I. 1\1., 1902, CTp. 362-365.
.. H. II. TO.A.crou U H. ll. Konoa,,06. "Ka3.
COq., CTp. 136, plIC. 158.
45 Ta)1 ine, CTp. 54, pnc. 5L
<6 H. If. BeCe.A.08Cl>uil. YKa3. COq., CTp. 362-
365: «MaHepa B IIpopa60TKe mliBOTHbIX Ha
cII611pCKIIX 6.ijHXaX Ta me, qTO Ha II3i\e-
:I1If!X HOBOqepl<aCCKoro KJIai\a (Tal< Bece-
.10BCKIfll Ha3b1BaeT KypraH Xox.'laq.-
A. JI.!.) II Ha 30JIOTbIX rryroBKax, HalllleH-
HhIX Ha Ky6aHII B 1901 II 1902 rr.»
'7 C. H. [{anOULuna. eHHble HaXOi\KII ap-
xeOJIOrOB B pallO He HOBOqepKaCCKa, CTp.
128-130; S. I. Kaposhina. Op. cit.,
p. 256-258, pI. XXIX-XXXII.
.. He II3i\aHbI.
09 C. lJ. [{anoULuna. lla}IIITHIIKII capMaTcKo-
1'0 3RepllHoro.., CTp. 18.
50 M. lJ. POCr08/fe8. CKII<pJlII II EOCIIOp, CTp.
584-585; on :J/Ce. HaAnlIcb Ha 30JIOTO}1 co-
cyAe.., CTp. 108-110; A. ll. Man14e6U'l.
AepeBf!HHble COCYAbI CKII<pCKOii 3110XII.
ACf3, BbIn. 8. J1., 1966, CTp. 30.
51 H. H. BeCe.A.08C"uu. YKa3. COq., CTp. 343.
'2 TaM me, CTp. 372. C. H. KanomllHoii: pa-
Hee ObIJIO BbICKa3aHO MHeHlIe, qTO Y3l1eq-
HbIll naoop !f3 CaAoBoro Kypralla TaKa\e
I13rOTOBJIeH Ha Eoc-IIope (CM. ee CTaTbIO
«IJ,eIIHble uaXOAKII...», CTp. 130), npif TOM
OHa npaBIIJIbHO OTMeTIIJIa, qTO MJlrYJIIIII-
CKllii II HOBOqepKaCCKlIii COCYAbi «GblJIII
c03AaHbI Ha 6a3e pa3BIIToro XYAOffieCT-
BeHHoro peMeCJIa C YCTaHOBliRmIIM!!CH XY-
AOmeCTBeHHblMII TpaAII IIf!MII» (<<Ila)If!T-
HIII<!!...», CTp. 27). B HaCTOHIqee RPP}IH.
KaK Blli\HO 113 ee AOKJIaAa B J101IA R
IIIOHe 1971 1'., B3rJIliA C. M. KarromlIHoii
na fiCi\YIqYIO pOJIb Eocllopa Kar; I1PIITpa
113roTORJIeHIIII npei\}ICTOB TopeRTm,!! He-
n;O.'blW 113MeIlIIJICf!.
192
7 CKJUllo-ca6apcKait soepDHbllt CTIIJlb
" A. II. Man/fe6U'l. YKa3. COq., CTp. 30, 37,38.
" Xp. EYIOI>.A.Ue8, M. l1.uMurp08, 11.. HllliO-
.A. a 8. Ohp"baiel! Hapoi\elI MY3eH CTapa 3a-
ropa. CO<pIIf!, 1965, CTp. 135, pllC. 31-32.
55 C. lJ. [{anOUlltlta. llaMf!THIIIOI.., CTp. 30.
56 H. lJ. BeCe.A.08Cl>uil. J'Ka3. COq., CTp. 347.
>7 S. I. Kaposhina. Op. cit., p. 257; A. Sal-
many. A Sarmatian Gold collected by Pe-
ter the Great. «Gazette des Beaux Arts»,
VI, ser. XXXI-XL, 1947-1952; M. H. Po-
cr08lleB. CI<II<pIIf! II EOCIIOp, CTp. 616.
56 JI.!. lJ. BR3b.1<Uruna. fopoi\IIIl\a HllmHcro
AHPilpa py6c;Ka H. 3. II IIX CBf!3If. C llpII-
I\YH a rrCI(iIM II CTpaHa}I1I. <,StudlCn zur
Geschichte und Philo sophie des AIter-
tums". Budapest, 1968, s. 247-250.
,. If. lJ. TO.A.crou. U H. ll. [{onOal>08. YKa3.
COq.. CTp. 141, plIC. 166-170.
60 Ta 1 me, CTp. 143, pJlc. 172-173. "
6' A. A. CnU/fbllt. BeIl\II C IIHKpycTa IIeif II"
KepqeHCKIIX l<aTaKoM6 1904 r. I1AK, 17.
CllG.. 1905, CTp. 115-126.
62 H. A 3ape14"uil. KJIai\, HaiiAcHHbIii IIpli
ceJIe \laJIaf! llepeIl\elllIHa, KOpOTOII!(CIW-
1'0 \"03;:\a llo.'lTaBCKOll ry6epHIIII. «TpYi\bI
llo:iTaRc oii YqeHOn ApXJlBHOii KOAI!IC-
CIIII". IlbIli. 9. llOJITaBa, 1912, CTp. 3-28 II
Taf).1nQa.
6' A T. ('.KU.A.en"o. fJIOAOCbKII cImp6II. KlIiB,
1965. CTp. 65, Ta6JI. I-IV, VI-VII. .
6< N. Frttich. Del' zweite Schatz von SZIlagy-
sOlnly6. «Archaeologia Hungarica», XIII.
Budape,t, 1932, Tal. II, V.
65 CKJIe!! 1904 r. f3, IIHB. 1820/649-650.
A. A. ('nu/fbLn. YKa3. COq., CTp. 118, plIc.4.
oB HIIR. f3, 2160/39.
6' f3, IIBB. 2070/1. H. M. C"a.A.on. H306pa-
;[{('I!IIH :<paKoHa B IICKyccTBe IV-V BB.
cr::1. Bbm. XXII. J1., 1962, pJlc. Ha CTp. 43.
66 lJ. II. TO.A.crou. U H. ll. [{onoa,,06. YKa3.
CO'1.. CTp. 139, plIC. 162.
6. (' If f'yaelt"o, YKa3. COq., Ta6JI. XXIII,
.9?.'-n.
:, Tn" ;liP. TaOJI. XXI, 47.
B. A. IlIpaMKO
HOBbIE HAXOAH11 HA BEJIbCHOM rOPOAI1llI,E
11 HEHOTOPbIE BOIIPOCbI <DOPMI1POBAHI1H
11 CEMAHT11H11 OBP A30B 3BEP11HOrO CTI1JIH
B xo.n;e paCKonOR Ha BeJIbCKOM ropo-
iJ,Hm,e H B npHMbIRalOm,eM K HeMY MO-
rHJIbHHKe sa nOCJIe}I,HHe roAbI y.n;aJIOCb
06HapymHTb 60JIbllIOe ROJIH'leCTBO pas-
Ho06pa3HbIX OCTaTKOB, TaK HJIB HHa'le
OTpamalOm,HX peJIHrH03HbIe BepOBaHHII
mCTHoro HaCeJIeHHH B pa3JIH'lHbIX xy-
iJ,OmeCTBeHHbIX 06pa3ax. Ha ropo.n;Hm,e
naniJ,eHbI OCTaTKH CBHTHJIHm, C mepT-
BeHHHRa m, 300 [op<pHbIMH, OpHHTO-
MOP<pHbmH H aHTponOMop<pHbIMH CTa-
TyaTRaMH, pa3J\H'IHbIMH h"yJIbTOBbIMH
npe.n;MeTaMH B BHiJ,e rJIHHHHbIX JIene-
IlleK, MOiJ,eJIen 3epeH, BOTHBHbIX npe.n;-
MeTOB, MHHHaTlOpHbIX cOCy.n;HKOB H,
HaKOHen;, pa3Ho06pa3HbIe xY,IJ;omeCT-
BeHHbIe H3.n;eJIllH H3 ROCTH, 6POH3bI,
meJIesa H 30JIOTa, yRpameHHbIe H306pa-
meHHHMH B 3BepHHOM CTHJIe. llocJIeiJ,-
lIHe, RaR H3BeCTHO, RpaMe Bcero rrpo-
qero, HrpaJIH onpe.n;eJIeHHYIO RYJIbTO-
oYIO pOJIb, H [CH MarH'IeCROe 3Ha'leIlHe.
XapaRTep HOBbIX lIaXOiJ,OR n03BOJIHeT
paCCMOTpeTb HeROTopbIe 06pa3bI 3BepH-
Horo CTHJlH B He06bI'IHOM acneKTe H
yTO'lHHTb HX <pOpMHpOBaHHe, ceMaHTH-
KY H COH3b C orrpe.n;eJIeHHOB aTHII'Ie-
CROB rpynnon.
MHome npeiJ,MeTbI 3BepHHoro CTIIJlH,
HaBiJ,eHHbIe Ha lOre BOCTO'lHon EBporrbI,
JIH60 HBHO OTHOCHTCH R npOiJ,YKD;HH
iJ,peBHeBOCTO'lHbIX, rpeRo-HoHHncRIIx,
<ppaRIIBcKIIX II.'1ll ceBepOrrpHqepHo !Op-
CKIIX aHTH'IHbIX MacTepcKlIx, JIII60
npIIHaAJlemaT K 'IHCJIY Bem,en, H: ro-
TOBJlenHe ROTOpbIX B aTHX MacTepcKIIx
iJ,OCTaTO'lHO BepoHTHo '. lJ,pyrne npe.n;-
[eTbI aToro CTIIJlH XOTH H lOrYT 6bITb
OTHeceHbI K npo.n;YKI.\HH peMeCJIeHHH-
ROB MeCTHbIX rrJIe [eH, HO '1aCTO He 06-
JIa.n;alOT '1eTRIBIlI npu3HaKaMH, n0300-
JIIIIOII.\IIMII CBH3bIBaTb HX C onpe.n;eJleH-
HbIMH rrpOH3BOiJ,CTBeHHbIMII n;eHTpaMH.
Bce 3TO CHJIbllO aaTpYAHlIeT BbIHcneilHe
BRJIaiJ,a Tex II.TIII I1HbIX nJIeMeH CRH<p Hll
B cO:JiJ,anHe II pa:JBIITIIe BOCTO'lHOeBpO-
neBcRoro :I0epIIHOro CTHJIH, ROTOpbIB
06bI'I1l0 lIa3bIBalOT CKH<pCRHM, XOTH
c06cTBeilHo nm<pbI npH'IepHOMOpCKIIX
cTenen 6bI.1JH l\a.1CKO He e.n;HHCTBeHlIbI-
MH ero C03AaTc.lH III, HOCIITeJIHMH H
pacnpOCTpaHIITe.'IHMH. TO'lHO TaR me
cym,eCTBOBaOIIlHe y [eCTHoro HaCeJle-
IUlH 06paabl :\BepllHoro CTHJlH I1eJIbaH
06'bHCIIHTh TO:lbKO IIPH nOMOm.u CRII<p-
CKOll: pe;mnllI II 1Il<pOJIOrHH, T. R. OIiU
OTpamalOT pe:JYJlbTaTbl CJIOmHoro B3aH-
Mo.n;enCTBIIH lIn,co.10mII pa3JIH'IHbIX nJle-
'MeH II umpomn j>Y:lbTypHO-HCTOpH'IeC-
KHX CBH:ICII.
BamllYIO pO.lb B H3yqeIlHH aTIIX
BorrpocoB ;IO.1JRIIbI CblrpaTb HCCJleAOBa-
HIIH rrpOII:JBO;J.CTBellllbIX l.\eHTpOB, B KO-
TOpbIX IOJRIIO oonapymHTb .1JUTell:HbIe
<pOpMbl. IllTa [lIbI II iJ,pyrue OCTaTRH, CBH-
aaHllbIe tf leCTllbnl 1I:lrOToo.'IeHHe [ BC-
m,ell: 3Be'-1ll0rO CT 11.1 H. TaKIIX HaXOiJ,OR
nORa O'leHb Ma:lO. lJacTb IIX onHTb-TaRII
CBH3a!la c ilIITJl411bnm ropOiJ,aMII CeBep-
Horo OpIl4C[HlmIOpbH 2 , a '1aCTb, KaK
IllTaMITbl 1\' H :10 H. J. H3 KaMeHclwr
rOpOiJ,HllIiI '. IITI!OCIITCH R cpaBHHTe.'Ib-
194
DO n03.n;HeMY BpeMeHH. JIHTelIHwe <pop-
MbI .n;JIH OTJIHBRH 6.'IHllIRII C ro.l0BKon
J1bBa HS AAmHrHo.1JbCROrO (l\[apllUbIH-
cl<oro) MorH.1JbHIII>a (V1- Y OB. AO
H. ;).) H iJ,JIH OTJIIIOKII HaHOCHilKa B BII-
.n;e rpH<pOHa H3 rrorpe6eHIIH Y B. iJ,0
H. 3. B RypraHe 2 y C. AKCIOTIIHl.\bI'
1'py.n;HO 6eccnopHo CBH3aTb e "aRHM-
PItC. 1. llpeOMerb! 600PYJlceH/I.Q. y"paweH-
H e u306pa:JICeHURMII 6 36epllHo.1t CTUAe:
1 - OOJIOMOR TJIKHRHOil JlHTeilHoft <!IOP"LI nJIJt OT-
."1HBKIt YKpameHHR w,HTa B BH,t1e IPurYPbI o.'1eHR;
2 - He6oJIbmoit 06J10MOK rJIHHHROn ..iuTefiHoit
4»OPMbI; 3 - OOTRHYTaR 30,,'OTO:\1 p)'HoRTHa ffie-
..:'"Ie3HOrO Me'la. MecTa HaxonoH: 1-2 - BOCTOQHOe
BeJIbCKOe roponHw,e; 3 - Hypr. 4 B OrItJIbHItKe
QCHRTH
o 2 CM
L.-...L.......-
J1H60 ROHRpeTHbIM rrpOH3BOiJ,CTBeHHbIM
u;eHTpOM BBHiJ,y Toro, '1TO OHH oOHapy-
meHbI B MOrHJlax.
IIo:3TOMY HaXOiJ,KII Ha BeJIbCKOM ro-
pOAHm,e VII-III BB. .n;o H. 3. rrpe;ICTaBJ
.1HIOT OC06bIn HHTepeC B CBH3II C TeM,
'1ro yme B apXaII'IeCRYIO 3noxy 3iJ,eCb
CKJIaAbIBaeTCH RpyrrHbIn rrp01l3BO.n;CT-
BeHHbIn u;eHTp, riJ,e mHJIH MHOrO'lIICJIeH-
HbIe peMeCJIeHHHKH, 3aHHMaBllIUeCH iJ,0-
6bf'len H 06pa60TKon MeTaJIJIOB 6. B AaH-
HOM CJIY'lae BamHbI 06HapymeHHbIe
3AeCb 6pOH30JIIITenHbIe MaCTepCRIIe, OA-
Ha lI3 KOTOpbIX, HaXOiJ,HBmaHCH B IOm-
Hon '1aCTH BOCTO'lHOrO YRperrJIeHlIH,
<pYHRn;HOHHpOBaJla B KOHn;e VI - na'la-
.1Je V B. AO II. 3. B nOMem,eHHII 3T0B
MacrepCIwii (DaCRon XIX 1969 r.) HaII-
(] ,
:..'.'
. . -'
j :-
2
3
7*
195
p;eBbl OCTaTKII nJlaBIIJlbBOii neqKII, BO-
Kpyr KOTOpOH nOqBa 6L1J1a BaCLI eBa
KYCKaMII mJlaKa C BKpanJleBIIJIMII 6pOH-
aLl, CJlIITKaMII 6pOB3L1 II 06J10MKaMH
6pOB30BblX KOTJlOB, KOTopLle IICnOJlb30-
BaJIIICb B KaqeCTBe BTOPllqBOro CLlpbJI,
cpparMeBTaMH rJIIIBJIBbIX nJlaBIIJlbBLlX
TJITJlen, KycOqKaMII p;peBecBoro yrJlJI
II np.
3p;eeb me OKOJlO ne'iKlI Banp;eBo 87
60Jlee IIJIII MeHee KpynBLlx 06J10MKOB
PUC. 2. Paa.4U'lHWe HaxoiJ"u Ha Ee.4bcJ>oM
aopoiJuUfe U aHa.4oauu:
1 - fiPOB80BI>IA ROTeJI, BallAcBBI>IA Ba 3an3JJ.BoM
BenbCROM ropoABIIte; Z - ronOBRB rnml1lBolt 4%>8-
rYPI>I MYII<CKOrO fiOIl<CCTBB. BOCTO'llloe Bem.CRoe
ropo B1l.(,e; 3 - BaBenOBCKB.R rnBBHB8JI Mone.m.
neqeB8 AJUI r8.A8.HIIII
- \,;
..-
\Ji
q.
:.. '. .-...t\
\
'" \
,;-"
..
""\,. ,..
... .
.. ...' .....
-_.
..
,
"\
r:IlJIIIJIlhIX :UlTeHH.bIX cpOpM, n03BOJlJI-
IOUlIIX B p;eTaJlJIX IIpoe.'1ep;IITb TeXRO:IO-
0110 Ml'eTHoro JlIITeHHOrO npOIl3Bop;crBa.
113 aTliX 06J10MKOB OqeOb IlHTepeeHhI
:Isa. npep;lla3HaqeHHLle P;JlJI OT.IIllBKH
rrpe;:{\H'TOB, YKpameHRLlX B 3BepnHOM
CTlI."le. Op;llB 06J10MOK HCBI'JlIIK (4X
X5 eM) II CIIJThHO nOBpemp;eH. Ha Her.r
eOXpaUIIJlaCb Jlllmb Be60JlbmaJI qaeTb
1I306pailH'HIIJI KaKorO-TO mllBOTHoro
(pne. 1,2). Apyroii: 06J10MOK IIMel'T pa3-
Iep 9.2X6 CM II coxpaBIIJlcJI Jlyqme. OR
IIpe;:{CTaBJlJIeT c060ii qaCTb rJlIIBJIBOH
."lllTeHHOn CPOpMLI (pIlC. 1, 1), B KOTO-
PO" IIpOll3Bop;llJlaCb OTJlIIBKa 60JlbIIIO
II \laeellBHon 6J1JIXII B Bllp;e O:IeHJI. AJln-
Ha Bcelr cpllrYPLl 6L1J1a. BIlP;IIMO. 60Jlee
30 01. C op;Ron CTOpOHLI CPOp lbI coxpa-
IIunaCh Il30fllYTaH 3aKpalIlla mlIpnHOll
JW 18 MM. Y,:J.epi!mBaB aJI l,pblmKY Ton-
IL\IIIWU {j m. TO.'1 lIlla OCIIOBaHIIJI
4>OpMLI 15 MM. fJlIIIIa, II3 KOTOpoii: olla
Bbuell."leHa, li!\leJIa IHOro paCTIITeJlb-
IIhlX IIpll [(>ceii. KOTopble IIpn 06»mre
Bblropl'."l1I II e03p;a.:m He06xoP;IH.IYIO p;.rrJI
nponYCKa ra30B noplIcToCTb. fJl)'6IIoa
peJlbe4>a C lI:mupamelmeM (4-4.5 101M)
nm;a3hlBaI'T. qTO OT.1IlIBKa 6b1J1a IIraCCIIB-
HOn. BII;:lIll\IO. <ITa 4>lIrypa, KaK II OJleBh
II3 Kypralla Y CT. hOCTPOMCKOii:', c.'1Y-
H\1I."la YKpaWl'IIlleM ;:t;.'1JI IITa.
Ha OO:.ImIKe Bll;:llla qaCTb MOpP;LI oJle-
llJI C r:Ia3ml. qaCTbIO yxa n CTIIJlII30-
BaHRbHIII porallllI. TIoCJlep;Hlle OcpOPM-
JleRLI B Blue UTlIqbnX rOJlOBOR. CTIIJlII-
3aI:IIIJI IIpOCTaJI, 6e3 lIeperpymeRRocTli
Me.'lKII m ;:t;I.'TiU H 11111. HalI60JIee 6J1II3Kli
no OcpOp I:IeHlllO K 6eJlbCKOn cpop re pO-
ra O.rrCHH lIil OI>OBKe li3 KypraHa 401 Y
iRYPOBKII 8, ImTOpaJI OTROCIITCJI K KOH-
IIY VI - Haqa."lY Y B. p;o R. a. TIoxome
II OcpOPM!ICIIIIC porOB OJlelIH Ra lIJ1a-
cnnme 11;1 I10rpC6CIIIIH V B. p;o H. a.,
liOTopoe fh,uo paClmnaHo C. A. Ma:1a-
paKII B l,yprallC 2 y C. AKCIOTIIH bll,
110 3Ta 4)lIrypa lI\1eeT yme 60JlbIlle Ae-
RopaTllllllblX J.R'MeHTOB. CTpanupa(IJlI-
'Ie(,I>1I Hallla naXO;:J;Ra 1II0meT 6b1Tb p;aTII-
pOlJana Ha'Ia.10M V B. p;o H. a. ::ha JlII-
Tl.'llHaH 4>op I3 AaeT 6eCCilopBoe p;oKa-
3aTl'JlLCTSO TOI 0, qTO yme B Ha'laJlC V B.
;':10 II. a. [;£>.lI.ClmC ropOp;ll e 6L1.'10 op;-
!111M 113 Pl'M("'.leIlUblX eUTpOB II3rOTOB-
."lPIIIHI leTa.-J:lII'll.'eKIIX Be en, OilJOPM-
:I!'IIUhIX IJ :1J"'pllllO 1 CTHJlC.
nOnf"III0. 11'.10 DC orpanlIqllBaJlOCb
TO."lbl,O V.lUX,DIII ;:J:."lJI IqIlTOB. Ha EeJlh-
(hOM r"JI" 1111111. II B IIlOrHJlLRIIKe Ha":Ie-
Uhl II Jpyn,,' IIpP!D!eTbl 3BeplIHoro CTII-
.'1fT, IHIl'!Olltli p 0pIIITIHaJlbROe ocpop\f.'le-
nne. liClT"p.... \[OffieT YKa3b1BaTb Ha HX
leCTHOl' 11.'(", I "B:leHlle. R TaKlIlI1 BeWa\f
OTROCIITOI " Boeoopa3Bblii: 6pOH30BLIll
ImTe.l CI""I" I,oro TlIlla, y KOToporo ;':IBe
n3 qeTLlpp-, 1I1'I'TIiKa:IbBLlX pyqeK o4>op-
I."I£>HI,llIlIn 11' rlillryp K03J10B (pile. 2,1),
....
-..
-......
2
:..
- .j-J' M " ...
;.. .., .. - . _.,...
: . 1$-. "' I ' .
c' '" .. . .. -m
. w:1, -'<. 'ot. . .. ,
..;..1:' "...... .
,"-'l
.. ,
3
1\-16
OTJlIITblX BlllCCTe C Ropllyco r 110 BO(I>O-
BOll 1II0P;CJlII 10. Cpep;n p;pyrux \Il'Ta.'1-
JllIqeCKIIX II KoeTHRLlX 1I3,J,eJlllii 3Bl'pJ,J-
1I0ro CTIIJlJI qaIqe Bcero BCTPCq,1JOH,JI
06pa3LI TaKoro IIreCTHoro amBOTHoro,
KaK .TlOCb. fO.'lOBbi li KOllhlTil aToro ni1l
BOTH oro IIMelOTCJI na KOCTJIHhlX lI(a."lH-
HX (pIIC, 3, 1-7) II Ha 3aroToBKC ,:J.JlJI
IICa.'l1lH (pIIC, 3, 2). TIpeKpacHaH npOTO-
lira JlOCH YRparuaeT 6pOH30Bblii !lilIlUC-
HIIK RORCHOH Y3p;eqKD (pue. 3, /9).
CpeAII ,[{pyrllx KOCTRHblX 1I3;:re:mi! IO;I{-
RO OTMeTIITb npHH\KY P;JlJI nepel>pt'II\It-
BaIOIqllXCJI peMBell yap;eqKlI, oplla \ll'II-
TlIpoBaHllYIO 1I306pamelIIIeM CII.1b1l0
CTIIJlII30BaHHoii roJlOBbl H\IIIJOTIIOro
(pIlC. 3, 15), pyqKY BOH\a e .1LBIIIlOii ro
JlOBKOR (pIIC. 3, 22), 300MOp!jJUYIU 1I0,'{
BecKY (pIIC. 3, 17). Ha H\1'.ll'3!1uH PY'l-
Ke op;Roro 113 HOmen BbmOBalia CTII:III.IO-
BaRHaH rOJlOBKa x.lIl.L\lloii UnIl.{LI (jllll'. 3,
9), TITlIqbll roJlOBLI YKpaIllalOT II 1I1'hO-
TopbIe 6poH30Bble HaIloelIlIKD (pilI". 3,
20-21). I1l1TepeceIl 6pOliJOBbllr m'l'c-
reHb, ocpopMJleRllblii B BII}J,e .nll'iilnI
(pIIC. 3, 18). TI peABapnTe."lhlI 1.11' alla-
.'1lt.lLl UpOIldOBbI:\. 1I3}J,C."lDll YKa3hIHclltlT
Ila cBoe06pa311e IIICCTUblX CnnalJ"B", a
BMeCTe c HaXOp;I>a m 6pOllJOJllITI'ii 1II.u..
MaCTepCI,.lIX Bce "3TO nop;TBepmlar r. 'I TO
IIO KpaHueii llrepe \fnOnIP 11.1 1II'IIll'ii
3BeplIUOI'O CTIIJlJI, ynoTpeO.'111 B 11111 Xl' H
mlITeJlHMII EeJlbCKorO ropO;U111«I. 11.11'0-
TaBJlIIBaJlIlCb 3p;ecb me.
l\IecTHLle MaCTepa 3ann ra!IIICL II "0-
pa60TKoii: 6J1arOp0P;IlhIX leTaJl.101l. :{!III
Xapal{TepllCTlIKII 3Toro npOII.IBO II'TlI '
BaH\Ha Baxo}J,Im IIlImHen 'IaCTIl "1"'11-
30BOro mTaMlla ;:J;JlR TllCI"'HlUl ,I" I" n,lX
OJlJIX 12, CJleP;yeT HanO\1 nllTb T ,,1;;1>1',
qTO B KypraRe 4 CBH3aIlfloro C I """,lll-
IL\c:\r J\rorll.lhIllll,a OCIInrn lIajj.I"" ,(;C-
."le3HLIii Meq 1\ B. ;\0 II. :J.. p 1,"1111;;1
KOToporo 06TJIIlYTa 30JlOTO\1 n. :1",hIlO-
TpeyrOJlhllOe nepeKpeCTlIe )IC'I" """ a
!\reRTlIpOBaIlO 4>IIrypo" XlJlllllll I., hIJ-
maqbeil nopop;b1. a lIasepWIIC : 1'.111-
30BaHIIbHUI KOITR\lIl II r.1a:!a 11I 1IIIIlj
197
(pl1C. 1, 3). Me'll! C aHaJlOrl1qHhlMI1 py-
I{oHTHa fIt BCTpeqalOTCH B CTenllblX H
JlCeOCTellHbIX KypraHax B npe;J:C:lax Ce-
Beplloro IIpH'IeprrOMopbH. Oc06eHBo
OJUUKne aHaJlOrHH AalOT PYI;OHTI;11 Me-
qeii: 11:1 "ypraHa COJloxa II 11:1 hypraHa
10 y CT. EJlli3aBeToBcKoll". CDop Ia py-
IWHTO" IIpe;(cTaBJlHeT C06011 3ahoHoMep-
noe pa:lBHTl1e 60Jlee paHIIIlx IeCTHbIX
MC'lell C aHTeHHblM IIaBeplllrreM. TpaK-
TOBaHHOM B :mepHHoM CTIme ". a TeXHI1-
Ka XYJ OllieCTBeHHoii: "OBI;]] llie.le3a 61,1-
Jla XOpOllIO oCBoeHa KY3Hel\a 1I! CKI14>HH
H Illl!pOKO rrpHMeHHJlaCb 3AeCb rrpH H3-
roTOBJleHHH 0PYlliIIH, 1I0llieli, ;J:eTaJleH
KOHCKOH ynpHllili. B03MOlliHO. HeKOTO-
pble Mf'qu II 1I0llin, y"palIlelilIblC 30JlO-
TOM, AeiicTBUTeJlbHO Ae.T1a m[(' I, H IIaHTn-
Harree" IIJln BO CDpa hI! II I;. 110 JTOT
Borrpoc Iryil\HO pelllaTb B l;alli;J:O 1 CJIY-
qae OTAf'JlbHO. HaXOAKa B MorlI.lbllllKe
OCIIHrli He AaeT OCHOBaHnii ;\JlH TaKoro
yTBeplliAennH. 30JlOTble 06K.'laAhl1 :woro
MC'Ia He HMelOT CaMOCTOHTPJlbHrlrO 3Ha-
'1CnnH. OHn HaJlOllienbI Ha PyqhY rOTO-
BOl'O Meqa, rrpu6nTbl K lIeii II rrpOCTO
IIOBTOpHIOT opllaMellTal 1110 llie.le:\IIOH
pyKOHTI;IL TOHI\lIe 30:IOTbIC n.laCTHliKU
IInqCM He CKpelIJIeHbl II C c:nlOro Haqa-
HR O'lClib IlJIOXO AepmllJlIICb lIa PYKOHT-
I\C. TaKoe YKpallleHI1e 1Or.l0 6bITb
rrpeAIIa;lIIaqeHO JllIlllb AMI YBe:lHqeHIIH
I1bIIIIIIOCTn rrorpe6a.lhlioro 06pH;J:a. CJle-
AOBaTf':lbIlO, B AaIlllo I CIY'I<IC 11 :10JlO-
TaH OOIi.'laA"a Meqa HB:IHPH'H J('CTHbIM
U3AeJlIJeM.
Ee.'1hC"Oe rOpOAIIII\C III1Tl'pCCliO em;e
TPM, 'ITO 3AeCb 06HIIPYil\PIIbl U:> TOJlb-
"0 061.1'1111,1(' Mera.'I,lll'/PC/iIH' II I;OCTH-
IIhle IIpei\MCTbl 3HepilHOHJ CTIIJIH, HO
II MHOllieCTBO rJlIIIlHllblX :\OO roP<PHbIX,
OpllIiTOMOp<pllblX II allTIHlflmropqJIlblx
1!:J06pallieHlIu. 3TH 06paJllbi r.luHHHOll
"YJlbTOBOii cKy.'1bnT 'pbl. IDlelOIl\lIe y
:!eCOCTeIIHbIX 1I.1eMen (PH'ltb ;J:peBHHe
"OpHII. IJOCXOAHUIIiP no 1;I',dinerr Mepe
I; qep"o.'leccKoii II ('(':If'I11Y:I:OIJChOll
"y.lbTypaM ". 001,1'1110 paCI'\1:1TpIIBaIOT-
eH BHe CBH3H C c06CTBeHHo 3BepHBblM
CTIIJleM, IIMelOm;IIM IIHoe IIpOHcxomAe-
Hne 19. 3Ta 1I30JlHl\IIH He COBceM IIpa-
BOMepBa, T. K. pe'lb IIAeT 0 IIaMHTHII-
Kax IICKyceTBa, 6blTYlOIl\IIX y OAHOro
I! Toro llie BaCeJleHIIH. HaXOAKn Ha
EeJlbeKOM ropOAIIm;e KaK pa3 IIOKa3b1-
BalOT, '1TO MecTHaH rJlIIHHHaH CKYJlbIITy-
pa O'leHb BalliHa AJIH IIOHIIMaHIIH IIAe-
OJrorlI'leCKOll 06eTaHOBKII, B KOTOpOll
IIpOlIeXOAIIJIO pa3BIITIIe 3BeplIHoro CTII-
JlH, II AJIH BbIHCHeHIIH poJlH, KOTOPYID
IIrpaJlII 06pa3bI 3BeplIHoro CTIIJlH B pe-
JlIIrH03HbIX BepOBaHIIHX MeeTHoro Hace-
JleHIIH. HeKOTopble 113 BIIX BOCXOAHT
eIl\e K AOCKII4>CKOMY IIepIIOAY.
IIo Ko.ll1'1eCTBY HaXOAOK IIpeAMeTOB
rJlIIHHHOH KYJlbTOBOH IIJlaCTHKn EeJlb-
CKoe ropoAIIm;e IIpeBbIlllaeT Bce ;a;pyrlIe
IIOCeJleHIIH eKII4>cKoll 3IIOXII, '1TO Be-
COMHeBno CBIIAeTeJlbcTByeT 0 ero Baif\-
HOM 3HaqeBIIII KaK peJllIrH03BOro l\eHT-
pa JleCOCTenHOll CKH4>IIH. Em;e nplI
paCKOIIK<lX B. A. fopOAl\OBa Ba 3aIIaJ{-
BOM YKpeIIJleHlI1I 6bIJlO Hall;a;eHO Be-
CKOJlbKO 06J10MKOB opHaMCHTlIpOBaIlHO-
1'0 rJlIIHHHoro lliepTBeBHIIKa II rJlIIBH-
Hble 4>lIrYPKII llilIBOTBbIX II qeJlOBeKa 20.
C Tex nop KOJlII'IeCTBO BaxoAoK pe3KO
BO:JpOCJlO, II eeii:qac 1I3BeCTHO Ha 3a-
IIaAHOM II BOCTOqHOM YKpeIIJleHIIHX
60.'1bIllOe 1\0.'1lIqeeTBO opHaMeHTnpOBaH-
HblX n HeopHaMeHTlIpOBaHHblX lliepT-
BeHHIIKOB, OKOJIO 200 CTaTYJTOK II IIX
qaCTeii:, a TaKllie MHOllieCTBO APYrux
hy.lbTOBblX npeAMeTOB (pIIC. 4-7).
PilC. 3. XyoO:JN:eCT6ennb!e u30e.'!uR, noii.oen-
Itwe Ita Be.'!bclwM 2opoouUfe u e OKpeCTHO-
CTRX Kyp,ono:
1-8 - ncaJIIIH OT YJ\HJI; 9 - HO>l<; 10-11 - oY-
.lasHH; 12, J.3 r 6YCbl; 14 - qaCTb pyqKH OT 3ep-
HaJla; 15 - np!t)f{Ha OT ya.neQKH; 16 - 6J1RllIl\a
OT COPYII; 17F- nOJ\BecKa; 18 - nepCTellb; 19-
21 - HaHOCHHHH OT ya.neQKH; 22 - qaCTb PY'lIHH
110>1< a: 1-7, 15, 17, 22 -KOCTb; 8, 10, 11, 14, 18,
18-21 - 6poH3a; 9 - meJle30; 12 - 30.rIOTO; 13-
naCTa. :\1ecTa Haxo.nOlC 10-14 - MOrHJlbHHK CHO-
po6op; 19-21 - MOrHJlbHHK OCHRrH, OCTaJlbHhle -
Be.ibcHoe rOponHI1{e
198
o
o
a 0
o
o
o
5
4
, ,',0
0'0
15 V'
14 I
10 11
(Jo
o 2 CM
(!J
12 0 <D
E)-O
13
17
18
22
{,I"
P 3MC pLI o Hoii CTaTLl1 He Il03BOJUl-
10'1' !laTL lIoJ\p06HYJO Xapal\TepIlCTIU<Y
lice X HaXO;.lOJ;, a HCI,OTopLle 113 HIIX yn<e
ooYO.'1I11;OBaIlLI 2I . 110aTOMY lbI orpa-
lIH'! IDICR aIlaJ1U30 I .'111lIIb OCHonHLIX
C IOrJ,CTOB r:IllHHlIoii 1l.'JaCTlIK1l.
B UO:ILlIIuHcTBe CJIY'laeB aooMop<p-
IILIC C"Y:lbIlTypLl O'WHL CXeMaTlI'lHO
lIepe;lalOT 'lCpTbI qCTBepOHororo llillBOT-
lIoro, BIl;:J,onylO rrpIIHaAJ1elliHOCTL HOTO-
pOl'O ycrallOBIITL TPYAHO. JIlImL HeIW-
TopbIe cJ{Y:lbrrTYpw lIMelOT )J;OCTaTOqBO
xapal;TcpnLle rrp1l3Bal<H. Tal<, B paCHO-
rre 1 19fiO r. Ha BOCTOqHOM EeJIbCI<OM
ropo;mme nallAelIw ABe 4>lIrYPl<ll: 0AHa
11306paa{aeT 1<03Y (puc. 4, 1), Y 1<0'1'0-
pp J\OCTaTOqHO HCHO 0603HaqeHO BbI-
M"» t. ('ocJ{a II1, APyraH (pIlC. 4,2) 1130-
Gpail{aCT 1,03JIa C HaTypaJIllCTllqeCKIl
rrepp;J.allllhIMII rrp1l3Hal<aMII' rro.la. 110-
Aoulla» cTaTy3TJ;a llillBOTHoro C IIpIl-
3i"u;a 1I1 MYlliCHoro rrOJ1a HaRp;eHa II Ha
aOJlblllll;ax cemuII;a CKlltPcHoro BpeMe-
HI1 y c. CTapble BaJIl<ll B Xapbl<OIlCI<OH
06.11. (pnc. 4,22).
O;UIH OO.'JO-"IOH, Hai'IAeHHhlii Ha 80-
CTOqHOM ECJILCIWM ropOAlIllIe, HarrOMll-
HaCT rO:IOB} MeABeAH (pllC. 4,14). CJIe-
) YCT O"OleTHTb, qTO Ha O)J;IIOll I13 6eJIb-
eRlfX n lIT '.)TOJ{ XOpOlIIO 3a Mf>THLI CJIel\bI
Kpac Hoii "paClai (pllC. 4. 13), CllM-
BO:!!!:!!II" j('II ell, BIIA"MO, I<pOBL lliepT-
Belliloro il\IIROTHoro. Hel<OTOpLle 113
I'JI1111H III,J \ c:raTY3TOJ{ He TOJILKO yrroT-
pCii:IH.'11 "IHI l{aKHX-TO I<YJILTORhIX 06-
pH:lII\. II', II lIOCUJ1I! B l,aqeCTBf' aMYJIe-
TOB. h' 11\ 'IIIC:I} OTHOClITCH 4>lIrypl<a,
IIilI'f<\IIII! ,llOlIlaH JIOlIIaAb, HaiiJ\eHHaH
1111 ,'('.'1111\(' Y c. OCTpoBCpXOm{a
(pile. . ll). OHa ll feeT Ha mee OTBep'
CT!\[' :I:IH 1I0ABemllBaHlIH.
i I1aTq\a.lIlCTI1'leCl<fI rrepeAaHHLle rrpll-
a$aJ;J; ""HI na pHAe CTa:rY3TOK CBllAe-
T JII.I'TI\\ '''T 0 TOM. <{TO ;JTII tPllrypbI
I1Mf'lm ""!H.rpf'!1CTBeHHYIO CBH3h C RY-
;IIoTf'\1 !' ,. ,:wpo:nlH. He cJlY'JaiIHo. oqe-
111/1,'11(.. II TIJ. qTO CpCAH 30mloptPHbIX
CTI\T\' . I "'; HI.I.leJlHIOTCH 4>"rypKII 1<03-
P ", : r;;1
, >Y 22
20 21
.Jtod
24W 26"' l'
o 2 CM
I I
JlOB, HOCKOJILl,y 3TH a{UBOTHhle accoIl,lI-
llPYIOTCH C HYJlLTml rrJlOAOpOAIIH. Harr-
pllMep, 4>lIrYPbI Iw;mOB OI<OJIO ApeBa
Jf\H3HII II306pameHLf Ha rreKTopa.llf
VII B. )J;O H. 3. 113 311BURe II Ha Ie-
qe II Torrope II:! Me.'1bfYIIOBCKoro I;YP-
raHa 22.
3Tll rrpe)J;CTaBJlCIIIIH BOCXOAHT K OO.'Iee
mlIpOHOMY I<pyry rrepe)J;Hea311aTCKIIX
peJIIIrll03HbIX HYJILTOB rr.'10AopO.l11H. Ha
O)J;HOll 113 aCCllplIRCKllX rreqaTei'1 I1306pa-
llieHIIH K03JIOB Y )J;peBa lliU3HII tPIIry-
PllPYIOT B Cn;eHe rrOKJIOHeHllH 60rllHe
HmTap 23, KOTOpyro HCI<OTOpbIe IICCJIe-
)J;OBaTeJIll OTOiK)J;eCTBJIHIOT CO CKlItPCROII
ApI'IIMrraCOH ".
Ellie 60JIee IIHTepeCHo rrOHB.leHlIe
cpeAII rJIllHHHbIX CI<YJlbrrTYP 1I306pallie-
HHR opmIHOrOJIOBbIX rpntP0HoB C 3a-
rHYTbfM BrrepeA porOM, 'lIIaMII II c.'Ja60
BbIpallieHlIblM 113-3a ocooeHllocTel1 Ia-
TeplIaJIa, HO Bce llie aaMeTHbIM rpe6Hc 1
H3 rrepLeB (pIIC. 5,13-15). Y OAHOll
113 JIY'jme coxpaHllBmllXCH rf)l[rypoK
BH)J;HbI II KpbIJIbH (pllC. 5,14). TaKIIM
06pa30M, rplltPoHbI 11306pallicIILf co Bce-
MH )J;eTaJIHMII, KOTOpbIC xapalncpHbl ::\JlfI
aCCllpnllCI<OrO n rrepClIACIwro IICI\YCCT-
Ba. EOJIee yrrpollleHIILlf' I1300pamemm
rOJIOB rplltPoHoB Ha iJ\eHbI na ce.'lll-
ru;e IV -III BB. AO n. 3. y c. Ma.1Lle
l1pOXOALI (plfC 5, 16-17). fpncpOlILI -
3TO Yllie COBepmeHIIO HOBL!ii oGpa3 B
rJIIIHHHOll CI<YJILrrType naCeJIPlIflH JIc-
C Tcrrll. 110HnJICHlIe f'ro JI(,(,O IIIPHHO
CBH3aHO C BJIllHHlleM nCKycCTBa IT III-
tP0JIOrllll cooCTBeHHo CI;JI(PCI;IIX npaHO-
H3blqHbIX rrJIeMeH. 3TOT 06pa3. haK If
)J;pyrlle oopa:ILI CKlltPclwro IICI; 'CCTBa,
rrpllBIIJICH Ha MeCTHOll noqllP. BIIA"MO,
.<::J
,,(:3
14
r
Puc. 4.... rJlllJlIufb1,e 3r)O.\(OpifJHhll' rTi!Ty.JTKll
U ux OO.fl,o.,, :
1-5, 7-18 - BOCT01.{HOe [) '.1"('1)c)(' ropo;:tuw:e:
6 - 3ana.nHoe EeJ1bCHOe rOpO..1I1Il"" ,',-,!n - ce-
J1HI1{C BepXHHR BHIllHHHb; ::1 - n'.-:IHW' OCTPO-
BepxoBKa; 22 - ce.TJHllle CTapble B:1:nm. :'1-27-
CeJlHI1{e MaJIble IIpOXO.Il.bI
/5
16
17
200
l
.,'?":,..
. I .
t .... /.
3 - --:. -
D
. <
\,'
/)1
8 9
GJlarOAapH TOMY, qTO cKII4>Cl\aH II MeCT-
HalI :3er.IJIeAeJIbqeCl\aH MIl4>OJIOrliH TeC-
110 IIepeIIJIeTaJIIICb, a MeCTHbIe oomeCT-
Ba IIO CBOllM 4>YHlW;IlHM JIerKO COIIO-
CTaBJIHJIIICb co CKIl4>CKIIMU. TpYAHO IIO-
I\a CKa3aTb oIIpeAeJIeHHO, ImKYIO pOJIb
UrpaJIll rpll4>oHbl B MeCTlIOH r.m4>OJIO-
nUl, HO CKopee Bcero OHII 6blJI1l KaK-TO
CBH3aHbI C Ky.'1bTOM II.'10AOPOAIIH. Bo
BCHKOM CJlyqae ell\e B .'1ypIICTaHCKIIX
OpOI!:!aX VII I VII BB. 11.0 II. 3. OHII
II!1eACTaB.'1eHbl B haqeCTBe aTpll6YTOB
oorllHll IIJIOAOPOAIIH 25, Ha aCCllpllllCKOll
U;RJ111IlAPllqeCKOll IIeqaTU OHII 11306pa-
menbl PHAOM C oorllHell I1mTap 29. Bce
:no rrpllBOAIIT Hac K CKIl4>CKOll A4>po-
AHTP - AprllMIIace, 06pa3 KOTOpOR
CJ1lIBaeTCH co 3MeeHoroii 60rllHeii: - po-
AOllaqaJIbHIIu;ell CKIl4>OB 27.
Ha 113BeCTHOM naJI06HIIKe 113 IlM-
6amm napa 3MellHo06pa3HbIX Hor nOR
60nnm 3aKaHqllBaeTCH rOJIOBaMII Op.TIll-
1I0ro rpll4>oHa 28. B CBH311 C nllM cJIeAY-
eT oTMeTIITb, qTO 11306pameHlle 3Mell
3a4>HKcHpoBallo 1Ia rJlIIIIHlIbIX 1I3AeJIIIHX
DeJIbCKorO rOp0)11111\a (pllC. 6, 14-15)
II na yrroMHHYTOM Bbllne nepCTHe
(puc. 3, 18). r.'llIHHHble CKYJIbnTypbl -
3TO HaCTOHll\ue npoll3BeAeHIIH HapOA-
IIoro TBOpqeCTBa. ECJIH HaxoAKa MeTaJl-
.111qCChOro YKpailleHIIH B Kyprane llJIlI
I!a rroce.'1eHllII MomeT OTHOCIITbCH II h
npuHo3HbiM BPIu;aM, KOTopble C)1.PJ1aHbl
'Iymlnl MaCTepOM II MoryT He 6bITb op-
ralll\'IeCKII CBH3aTlbi C MeCTHOII lIIIeo.'10-
rlleH, TO HaxoAKa r.TIHHHHOll CKYJIbrrTyp-
1\Il, npeAHa31H1'IeHHOll TOJIbKO AJIH Me-
CT 1I0ro yrroTpeOJICHlIH, Hpl\O CBII;J:eTe.'1h-
cTByeT 0 L'Iy611HP rrpoHlIhHOBell!l H Tex
llJIll lIHbIX 00pa30B B peJIIIrIl03IIbie
rrpeAcTaB.'IeHIIH aWTeJIell .'1eC{)CTeIlfIOTI
CI,lI4>II11.
B 1972 r. H1\ BOCTOqHOM YKpeIlJleHllI1
Be.'lbCKOrO rOpOAIIll\a YAaJlOCb OOHapy-
mllTb OCTaTKII CBHTllmnD;a VI - V BB.
11.0 H. 3., B l\OTOpOM COBepmaJlIICb 05PH-
AbI, C BH3aHHbIe C KY JIbTOM paCTllTe.'1b-
HOCTll II I1.'10AOPO;Um. B oo.lbmOM pa-
CKOIle XX II I (rr.l011\a)J.b 1891 l\B. M)
06napymcHa P;0BO:lbHO 'IJICTaH I1.'1011\aAb
6e3 06blql\OH 11aCCbI 6LITOBbIX II xo-
3HllcTBeIlHbIx OCTaTKOH II coopymc-
IIllH.
B IOro-BOCTO'lIlOii qaCTll HaXOAUJlOCb
CBHTllJIlIll\e, B hOTOpOM Ha I1pOTHmeIllllI
70 M Obl.l0 7 }hepTBeJllmKOB, 113 KOTO-
pbIX 6 pacrro.l0meHbl B OCHOBHOM I10
.111111111 ceBep - KIf. a 7 -if - K BOCTOKY
OT Hee. PHP;O I 1I le.l0Cb TPII 60JIbmllX
KPyr.TIblX H ILI. Bbl:WII.leHHLle II:! f.1H-
HbI na :Je I:IHnOM B03BblmelUIll mepT-
BeHHUKll llMe.1U cPOPMY Kpyra p;lla-
MeTpOM 40-50 C l. TIOJlOmeHHbll1 Ha
3eMJIIO CJIOII r.ll!Hbl TOJIll\IlHOR 3-3,5 01
6blJI Tll\aTe.'1bHO 3arJIameH, 060mmeu 11
I106eJIen. BblCOTa mepTBeHHIIKOB 30-
40 CM. BOKpyr HaHAeHo cOBepmeHHo
He6bIBaJIOe KO.llI'leCTBO CAeJIaHHbIX II;!
rJIIIHbl Ky.TIbTOBbIX I1peAMeToB: :100-
Mop4>Hble II aHTp0I10Mop4>HbIe cTaTY-
3TKU (B u;e:IOM BilAe II B 06JIOMKax),
l\y.TIbTOBJ.le :WI!C, I!I!,II COCYAbI, CBeTII.lb-
IIImu, r.'IIIHHH hlC IOAe.l11 qaCTeH TeJI1\
mHBOTllblX A:IH ra;\aHlIH (pIIC. 6, 7, 8,
IV, 17-19).
Cpe;\ll CTaTYJTOh IIMelOTCH I10AJIIIlI-
HbIe meiJ;eBpbl I,YJIbTOBOR rJIlIHHnOl1
I1.1aCTlllill CK!l(TJCI>On 3I10Xll. Cpe)111 :100-
MOP4>Hhl\ cTaTY:IToK BblAeJIHPTCH ea-
MaH oo.lbUlaH I10 pa3MepaM, 1l:106pa-
malOll\aH 1O:lOiwro 6bf'lKa. Y MeJIO Bbl-
.1el/.1Iella 1'O,10Ha C VillaMIl H 6yropl\a 1ll
I10HB'lHIOIl'II\CH po"rOB (B03MomHO, :-JTO
KOMO.laH rropo)1a). MOll\Hblif KopIlye,
1I0rll e P;LI!lBOellUbIMU KOIlbITa-
)ill (pIle. 7. J). O'leHb Bblpa:HfTP.lhna
TaI,me (fwry l'iI .1 pyroro milBOTHoro. B
Puc. 5. r,,,tl/5<'"'''' aNrponoMopifilib1e cra-
rY:JTKll It U.Jfl';pa.JI('fHllR 2purjjoHoe:
1-4 CHY:UJrT) IIbl oT:le."1bHbJX rOJIOBOH; 5-1:!-
meHCHJH' (.TaTY,THII H OOJIo:'-U(1I CTaTY3TOH 13-
17 - - n:w6I,.lai/'1I11 H rpIHbOHOB l\fecTa Haxo.J.oH:
1. .3. 1.5 - lan;):lIfOe Ee:IbCliOe rOpO!l.HI1{e: 2. 4,
6-11. 11-14 -. I{0('To l IHoe Ee lbCHoe rOI)o:xnIIle
5 _ ropo;J.Hwe 1;".IP,)6(\H; 12, 16-17 - ce.'III1{e
)la.'bl" TI1'{\,\o D.I
202
2
.....-:::-
"A Itf'-,
( " 7 ('"/ "
- ..
3
7
10
.- -
(a, J3
5
8
11
q
12
-r>
ISLJ U
:7
16
KOTOpOM yrap;bIBaeTCH pbICb: oI,pyr.lafl
MOPl1:a C OCTpbIMIl YUlaMU (IWII'HInli
OOJIOMaHbr), XapaI'TepHblC Oal,CUOap:lbI
u p;amc XOpOllIO nepl';J.alllIaH Iwma'lbH
HOXOARa (puc. 7, 2). <Dury pa .10C H
(pIlC. 7, 3-4) coxpaHU:WCb HL' nO.1BO-
GTLIO, IlO OHa nplnWqaTeJIblIa TeM, qTO
j aCT npCp;CTaBJIeHIll' 0 COBeprnl'HHO HO-
BOM, I1eIIaBeCTHO 1 ;:1,0 CIIX IIOp TIIIW
I'YJIbTOBOH rJIIlHHHOii nJIaCTlIhlI CWIcp-
Clwii ,moxa. ]J;eJIo B TOM, qTO iKilBOTHoe
nOI,aaaHO B TOM BII;J.e, B KOTOpm! OHO
UbIJIO npllHeceHO B mepTBY. Y Hero
BCKpbITa rpyp;b II BHYTPII qeTHO 0003Ha-
qeHbI HeKOTopbIe aHaTOMIlqeCKlie AeTa-
JIll CTpoeHIlH TeJIa mliBOTRoro (pue. 7.
4). HCTaTII, BMeCTe C 3TIlMII tPIIrypr-:a-
Mil lIaiip;eHbI II r.1IlHHHbIe MOAe:m qa-
CTeH TeJIa iI\IlBOTI!LIX (pIlC. 6, 17 -18).
Op;Ha n3 BIlX Il306pamaeT, BIlJllnro, 111'-
qelIb C yqaCTKaMII, 0603HaqeH!lbIMH
/l:BYMH pHAaMII KpyrJIbIX HMOI\ (pUL fi,
18). 3Ta HaxOAKa CTaneT nOIIHTHa, PC.l!!
ee conOCTaBIITb C rJIlIHHHbIMI! MO;J.e.1H-
MU AJIB: rap;alIIIH B nepejJ.nea;maTClmx
"YJIbTax. lIaBecT!!O, HarrpUMep, '[TO R
J1aBIlJIOHIlU cpep;u rrpOqIlX BlljlOB ra!).a-
HIIH 6bI.'IO OqeHb pacnpOCTpaneHO ra.la-
Hue no BHYTpeHHOCTHM, Oe06PHI!O no
rrOqeHIl mIlBOTHbIX. Ilpii :HOM lIcrrO.l!.-
30BaJIlICL H rJIlIHHIlble MO)1o:m neql'f!l1
(pIIC. 2, 3), OqeHb HanOMllllilIOII\IIe
Ol':lbCI,YIO lIaXOA"Y, lIa I\OTOpbIX npu
rrOMolIIU JIUIIUH II HMOK oGo:\uaqa:f\lo,
Y'IaCTHII. IlMCBllIIIO !).ame C lIeUlIa:lbl1hll'
ua:millIliH. OTcIO;J.a :)Ta TeX!lIII,a IiI.1;1
HHH rrpOlIIlRJJ3 B ERpony 29.
AHTponOMoptPlIbIe cTaTy:nlil1 11.111
OT)10.'IhHO BbIJIenJIeHHbIe rOJIOBIW cpeJf1
r.TJIIHHHbIX CKY.1JbrrTYP B JIeco("Tc/[lIoii
CRlHIHIII BCTpeqaIOTCH I'l'.l[;O
(pIIC. :i. 1-12). OAlla tPurypha CH.1}}-
m;pii mPHm;IlHbI 6bI.la n3H)1eHa /1;1
OP:ILCRml ropO)1Um;e R 1958 r.. a IJ CHH'
TU.ITnm;e 06Ha pymeHo en e meCT h HOB"I \
3K:Je !II.1HpOB (pIIC. 5. 4, 6-71). EO:II.
UIIIHCTBO meUCKliX cTaTy:nor; 113001';'-
maeT meHm;IIHy- [aTb. IlplI3HiHaI Of'I'"
G @) 0 8
ta
13 14
H'IlHoii: meIlIl\UHbI qaCTO crreQHa.TJblIO
!IOJ:('wpImyTbI. B f!I1IHe OAHOH H3 TaI,I1X
CTa TY3TOl, 3aMeqeiIbI OTrreqaTI\II Bblro-
peBIIIllX npll 06mllre 3epeH rrpoca. Ilo-
RUP;HMOMY, 3TII CTaTY3TKIl H306pama:IH
oorllHb, IIORpoBHTe.lbcTBoBaBllIllx 3eM-
:Icp;eJIIIIO, nO 1OraBrulIx pomAeRIlIO xo-
pornero ypomaH. IlomaJIYII, 3T0 MOrJIII
6bITb II306pameHIIH AnTI, conOCTaB.1JHe-
lOii fepoAoToM (IV, 59) C rpeqeCKOH
oOfllilelI 3eMJIIl feeil:. B )J;aHHOM CJIyqae
PCqb )Ior."Ia IlP;TIl 0 fee KaprrotPopoc
(Il.l0p;OHOCHOH), KOTopaH nOQIlTaJIaCb
I,aI, IIop;aTe.1JbRIlQa ypomaH.
COBeprueHHo YHIlKaJIbROH BO Bcell
3TOll ROJIJIeKQIlIl HBJIHeTCH fJIIlRHHaH
tPHrypa MymcRoro 60mecTBa, CBH3aH-
Horo C tPaJIJIllqeCKilM KYJIbTOM IIJIOAO-
pOAIIH (pIlC. 8). 3TOT 60r Il306pameB
CIIp;Hm;HM Ha HaKO]\I-TO He60JIbmOM B03-
BbuneHIIII. PYKH ero 06JIOMaHLI, RO, BlI-
P;UMO, 6bIJIH npOCTepTbI BIIepeA. CJIerRa
Y:[bI6aIOm;eecH JIIlIW 06pam;eHo BBepx
(pIlC. 2, 2). HecMoTpH Ha rpy60BaTocTb
Ch:YJIbnTypbI, OHa AOJImHa 6bIJIa, 6JIa-
ro;r,apH rrp0/l:YMaHUOCTII OCHOBITbIX Ae-
Ta:reH, rrpOIl3BOp;IITb fJIy60R\)e BlIe-
'laTJIPHIle Ha BepYIOm;ero 'IeJIOBeKa.
lI\epTBeHHIlKH Er.1JbcKa - HIl3KHe, II
I!pH6JIHmaIOm;IlHCH K HlIM qeJIOBeR
(,MOTpeJI Ha Il306pameHlIe 60meCTBa
cBepxy. Il03TOMY H JIIlI.\O tPlIfYPKII 06-
pam;PHO BBepx.
KOMY me npIlHa:-(JIemaJIO CBHTIlJIIIm;e
[)e.rrbclwro ropOAHm;a? 3TO He MOrJlH
ObITb CKlItPbl. fepOiIOT COBepmeiI-
UO Rep;BYCMbICJIeHHO rOBopHT, qTO .
Clm\fK>B lIeT 06hIqaH B03p;BIlraTb 60ra I
6
5
-t
PIlC. 6. r.WlIRlIbZe "y.1bTOBble npea.MeT',':
1-4 - BOTHBHhIe COCy.nHKll; 5-7 - npe MeTbt r:
POII<l'RMII; 9-16 - JIeneulKlI: 11-12 - MOl\eJIH 3e-
peR: 13 - KYJII.lOBhlll MO;JOTOK: 14 - rJIHRJJHbl1i
npenMeT B BJAe HpbIIUetJHJI C Jl3o(ipameHHeM
;1 (en; 15 - o6noMoK CTeHHH cocy,u.a C H306pame-
HU£,:,\( 3Men; 16 - HoJIeCHHO QT KyJIbTOBOA nOBQ3-
J{IJ: 17-18 - qaCTll TeJIa iRJlBOTHbIX, npen.Ha3Ha-
'-IeRHbJe .nJIfI ra.naHllJI; 19 - no,nCTaBHa (Bce Bewn
Hatl:!teHbI Ha BOCTO'lHO\t EeJIbCHOM ropO.!1uu e)
17
204
g
, I
\....- - -,,'
4
o
I
o
12
11
16
M
19
o 2 CM
t J
CTaTYIl, mCpTBeIlIIIU\II II XpaMbI (I V,
59). TOJIbKO B 'lCCTb Apcca YKJIa].\bIBa-
lOT ORU 60.'Ibmne I,Y'lil XBOpOCTa, na
BepmURe KOTOpblX Yhperr.TIJIIOT CTapIIR-
Hblll Me'l (IV, 62). ConnB mcpTBCHBblX
mnBOTIIbIX Ee.1bcKoro ropo].\lIlI\a TaKme
YKa3b1BaeT, 'lTO 3].\CCb mllJm He CKmpbl,
KOTopble, COr!IaCHO repO OTY, IlpnBOCII-
Jill B mepTBY pa3J1I1qllbiX mIlBOTRblX, BO
TOJlbKO Be CBnlleii (IV, 60-62) .
B )f<CpTBOlIpJlHOmeHIIRx EeJIbCRa KOCTH
CBHBbH He TO.'lbKO OUbI'l.HbI, lIO ].\ame
npe06J1a)J;aIOT. KpmIe Toro, B mepTBY
IlpHHOCHJlH IW.I u:m OBel.{, KpYIIHblH
PUC. 7. r .AIIHRHble nRTY3T1>U XU60THblX.
BOCTO'lHOe Bl'.AbCkOl' 2"poiJIIUfe:
1 - t5b1K; f - pbU."b; 3-4 - norb
2
porHTbIll CIWT, JlOllla].\en H C06aK no-
IIHTb BCe 3TII OC06elIBOCTI1 pCJIllrll03-
IIblX 06pH].\OB EeJIbCKOrO rOpO)J;HJJ:{a, KH"
II BeC.b OCTaJIbBOll apxeOJlOrll'IecKnii
MaTepIla:l, MOmliO TOJlbKO B TOM CJlY'Iae,
eCJIU MbI 6YAeM C'lUTaTb, 'lTO 3TO ropo-
].\lIll.{e IIpe)J;CTaBJIJIeT C060ll OCTaTKn ro-
pO)J;a feJlORa, KOTOpbIll 6bIJI, I<pOMe BCe-
ro npO'lero, KPYIIHblM peJIHrrr03Bbl!\I
l.{eBTpOM, nplI'leM QeBTpOM cBoe06pa3-
HbIM. HanOMRHM. 'lTO B ropo)J;e fe:10He
I1MCJIUCb CBHTII.fIHma C mepTBeBHllha!\1II
II cTaTymm (IV, 108). Kam)J;bIe Tpn
ro].\a MeCTObIe mHTeJIU ClIpaB.1H.1I1
rrpa3].\lIeCTBa B 'leCTb 60ra paCTHTc.1bHO-
CTH H IlJlO)J;0P0)J;HH, I<OTOpOro fepO.101
OTom)J;eCTBJIHeT C AnooIIcoM. BrrpO'Ie\I.
aTO n .neHCTBnTeJIbOO Mor ObITb KH-
l\oii-TO MeCTllblH BapIIaHT l\YJIbTa Auo-
IlIIca. IWTOpbIii 6bl:1 mIl,pOKO pacnpOCT-
paneH n ].\pCHIICM lompe II, B 'laCTnOCTn,
BO <Dpal\rril II CRmplIII (fepo)J;oT, IV,
79; V, 7 II )J;p.). Ha TeppIITopnu !/l'CO-
cTelIHoll CRII<pHII CBHTIIJlUI.qe Ml'CTnOrO
AIIooHca Y)J;H.10Cb 06uapymlITb BlIep-
BbIe, II )J;aJICI\O Re Bce TYT ceif'lac HC.HO.
O].\HaRo, BamHO TO, 'lTO Bce 06napymeH_
IIble BaXO)J;KII O'leOb xopomo YBH3bI-
BHIOTCH C U3BeCTObIMII HaM M1f<paMII 0
AIIOBHce 30. BeJlbCKHll BeCe!IbIll 60r
IIeCOMBenHO HBJIHeTCJI 60mecTBoM IlJlO-
PllC. 8. rAUHRHOA t}jU8YPkO MYXCk080 60-
xeCT60, Hoii.iJeHHoR Ha BOCTO'lHOM Be. bckO.1<
80poiJuUfe
..... ..- .w.-
-.
3
,\
,
f
206
2
]l0POAUH. 011. KaK II AIIOHIIC, Mor rrepe-
HOrrJIOI1WTbCH B pa3JIII'lBbIX mUBoTHblX,
CTaTY3TKil KOTOpbIX Ball)J;eBbi B CBHTI1
:lllI.qe. CpeAII ann: cTaTyaToR 110 pa3Me-
paM II Bblpa3IITeJILBOCTI1 oc060 BblAe-
:meTCR 11306pamenne 6b1Ka, l\OTOpLIii
I1rpaJi oc06ylO pOJIL H B KYJIbTe AHOffif-
ca. B CBI1Te 1I0CJIe)J;Bero 6b1JIH BeCeJlble
TaBQYlOll.{lIe MeBa].\bI (BaKxaORH), II
CpC.!{11 menCKIlX cTaTyaTOl\ CBJITI1JIH.lI\a
mreeTCH o.nBa (pHC. 5, 10), H306pa-
maIOll.{aH TaIIQYIOm;ylO men.lI\HOY B
pa3BeBalOll.\C fCH IIJlaTLe.
AmI rrOJIBOTbl 061I\eH RapTIIBbi He06-
XOJlIIMO OTMeTIlTL em;e O)J;RO cBoe06pa3-
HOe norpl'6eHIIe VI B. )J;O O. 3., 060a-
PymeHlwe B 1965 r. B Kypraoe 2 CBH-
3aBBoro C ropO].\IImeM MOrHJIbHHKa
CKOPOOOP ". B lolOrHJle 6b1na noxopOReoa
meHII..\I1IlH, CKopee Bcero mpHl..\a, CBH-
3HnnaR C 3P IJIc.neJIb'lecI\IIM KYJIbTOM
n.1o,wpO,lItR. Ha 3TO YKa3blBaIOT 06pH
lIorpe6!'I11IR II Ball)J;eoobIe B lolOrnne
Bellnt: inl'JIC3Hblii Rom, OCTaTIm ROCTen
OT }I,l'PTBCIIBOii 1I1I1l.{II, ABe 6POll30BbIX
rB03.nCIIIIAllbI\: 6YJlaBRH, 30JIOTbie 6YCbI,
ollcep 11.1 rraCTbI, 'lepOOJlOmenbill 'lep-
llan. "Y<"nn CCpbl If peaJlLrapa 11 6POH
.IOBOC .lI'pI\a.10 C PY'lKoii, YltpameRnOll
(fmrypoii naHTepbI (pllC. 3, 10-14).
O"OJlO tnrll:IbI Ha ypoBRe 1I0rpeueRHoii
nO'IlIL1 OI,H a.'IOCL orpOMHoe IwcTpnlI\e.
B .10:le "OToporo Haii):(eHbI OCTaTlm
{'omml'lIl1oii ("OJlOMbl II <lepeB IlmCHl1l..\bl.
nq\lPllfi. pilm. OBca, 6000BbTX, a TaRme
"y.II.TOllhll' 1O].\eJlII 3cpeR 11:1 rJlIlUbI,
nOJ\oollJ.1C oonapymeHHbnl pance na
mellTselIII lIJ>e ropO):(Hm a KapaBaH 32.
r.1nnRII"II' roAcnH 3epeII II3BCCTfIbI II
lIa Ep.II,climI ropO.nHme. 3.!{eCb me 6bI
.111 Co;na>t:HbI II "aRlIe-TO iKlIBOTIfble,
T. J>. 1111 ii '{ellbI KaJlLQHHllpOBallllble OC-
THT"II II \ "OCTeR II )J;ame rryqhll oecro-
PCHIIJPII 1l0.1nOCTLIO mepCTn. Bce 3TO
JI BIW 1"I1II.\CTe!ILCTByeT 0 conepmeOlln
,,,,r,orlJ-TO 06pH)J;a, CBJI3aolioro C KYJIb-
TO\I 1I.1fI,1nPOJlHH. B CBH3" C 3Tll!\1
npllllii"I'TaeT oc060e 30a'leOIle naXO Ka
207
D .\lOl'lIJIe mpllI.l,bI 3epRaJIa, YRpameIllH.-
1'0 B 3BepllHOM CTIIJIe. OHa MOrKeT L;JIY-
mllTb ell.\e O)J;HIIM lIop;TBepm,ll.eHlIeM
BbICRa3aHHoro M. II. ApTaMOHOBbIM
MHeIIllH 0 TOM, qTO 3epRaJIO HBJIHeTCH
OP;HIIM II3 aTpll6YTOB CKllIpCROH 60rllHlI
iIlo6BlI II lIJIOP;OpOP;IIH AprllMJIaCbI 33,
OTomJ.\eCTBJlHeMOH C A!jJPO)J;IlTOH.
TaKllM 06pa30M, apxeOJIOrnqeCRIIP
MaTepllaJlbI EeJILCRoro ropo,!.\IIIlI,a II CBH-
3aHHbIX C HIIM MOrllJlbHIIROB lIORa3bI-
BaK)T, qTO pa3BlITlIe IICRYCCTBa 1I peJIII-
rim MeCTIIoro 3eMJIep;eJIbqeCROrO nace-
JleHIHI .TlecocTelIlI BOCTOqHOll EBponLI
lIpOIlC XO,!.\IIJIO yme B HaqaJIe CRII!jJCROR
3nOXlI B TeCHOM B3aIlMop;eRCTBIIII
H nop; BJIIIHIDIeM CRII!jJCROR peJIII-
rllII n 3DepllHoro CTlI.1IH. EJIarop;a-
pH 3TO IY B JIec.oCTelIlI He TOJILRO lIOJlY-
'raIOT IIIlIpORoe paClIpOCTpaneHlIe Me-
TaJIJllIqeCRlIe II ROCTHHblC 1I3)J;eJlIUl,
I ftf. JI. M a"CUMo8a. Cepe6pJIHOe 3epKaJIO 1I3
KeJIepMeca. CA, T. XXII, 1954, CTp. 304;
E. O. IIpYuteBc"as£. XYAomecTBeliHaJI 06-
paooTKa MeTaJIJIa (TOpeBTIIKa). AfCII.
M.- J1., 1955, CTp. 329; B. B. IIuorpo8-
c"u U. CKII bI II ApeB1I1I1I BOCTOK. CA,
T. XIX, 1954, CTp. 144; M. fl. ApraMonoB.
K Bonpocy 0 npollcxomAeHll1l CKII<pcKoro
IICnYCCTBa. Cf3, XXII. J1., 1962, CTp. 32;
M. H. ApraMono8. IIpOllcxomAeHlle CKII<p-
CJ;oro IICKYCCTBa. CA, 1968, oM 4, CTp. 42;
H. A. Onau1\:o. a eHTpax npoll3BoAcl'Ba
30.l0TbIX 06KJIaAOR 1I0meH II pyROJITOK
CI;IIcJ.>CnTlX Me'lelI, HalIAeHHbIx B IIpIiAHe-
npOBbe. KAM. M., 1966, CTp. 159; A. II.
Mall'tr8tl . 30JIOTOII BelIe 113 KypraHa Ha
p. ha.1I!TBe (n Bonpocy 00 ara<pllpcax).
HAH, T. XXII, 1959, CTp. 74; A. II. Man-
4eetl.,- IIapaAHbIlI Meq 113 KypraHa COJIO-
xa. ".:::\peBHIIe <ppaKIIII bI B CeBepHOM IIpll-
qPPHO)lOpbe». M., 1969, CTp. 113.
2 E. O. IIpyute8c"aH. YKa3. CO'l., CT . 331,
plIC. 8; H. 11.. Map en1>o. J1I1TeU:HaJI 1p0pMa
Konrra VI B. AO H. 3. 113 llalITIlKaneJI.
I-iCIL\. BblII. 89. 1962, CTp. 51.
3 E. fl. I'pa1>08. KaMeHCnoe ropOAII e Ha
JIH'npe. !IIHA, M 36. 1954. CTp. 134; B. A.
Wpa"<lw. 05 1I3rOTOB.leHI!II 30JIOTbIX YKpa-
IIJ(,I!IfII pe)IeCJIeHHIIKa)1II CKII<p1II1. CA,
uno. M 4, CTp. 217.
· M. Ebert. A usgrabungen a \If dem Gute
O(I)Op [.TleHllbIe B 3BepllHo 1 CTIIJlC, no II
o6pa3bI lIOCJIep;IIero lIpolllu-;aIOT B MeCT-
HYIO rJIlIHJlHYIO CI-;YJlblITYPY. CaM 3Be-
pllHbIH CTIIJlb o6oram;aeTcH 3a CqeT HO-
BOR TpaRToBlm o6pa30B II3DeCTHbIX pa-
Hee mllBOTHbIX II paclIpocTpaHeHIIJI
Il'306pameIDIll: MeCTHbIX ffiIIBOTBbIX,
oco6eHHo JlOCH. B3aIlMonpOHII"KHOBeBlIe
xyp;omecTBeHHbIx 06pa30B, IIMeBmllX
RYJIbTOBOe 3HaqeHlIe, cBUAeTeJlbCTByeT
II 0 C6J1l1meHIIII II B3aIl !O;:rPIICTBIIII pe-
mIrllo3HOR MII!jJO:IOrIllI CTelIHbIX II JIe-
COCTelIHbIX lIJIeMeH 0 CYII\eCTBOBaHIiIl
Y HlIX o6Il.\Hx l\Y. bTOD.' AHTpOlIOMOp-
!jJ1I'3aU;IIH 60mecTD D CruHlnIll B03HII-
I{aeT, KaR lIOl{a3blBaIOT HaXO;Jl\II, paHb-
me, qeM 3TO npe;:mo.lara,locb p;o CIIX
lIOP", HO lIepDOnaqa,lhlIO anTpolIo-
Mop!jJHbIe 1I306pameHIIH IIOHBJlHIOTCH
Y JleCOCTeUHbIX lIJle [eH.
1l0JITaBCI;oii ryo. B 1906 r. (,TpY;1bI XI\'
AC», T. II I. M., 1911, Ta,6.'1. III, 4.
" A. H. Me.1/{)"o8a. Boopya;ellile cl;m!>oB.
CAH, BLIII. A1-4. M., 1964, mOJI. 20, 6;
A. II. MalllfeBU'l. llapaAlIbIii )!Cq 113 I; 'p-
rana COJIoxa, CTp. 98-102, pile. 4, 5.
15 A. II. Me.,/{)"o8a. 'Ka3. COq., CTp. 56.
16 H. A. Onau"o. YKa3. COq., CTp. 173.
17 A. II. Man4e8u . llapaAHbIlI Meq 113 I; 'p-
rana COJIoxa. CTp. 113-115.
16 A. If. TepenoJIC"un. IIpe;1cnll<pcKllii Ill"
PIIO;1 Ha AlienpOBCKO)1 IIpaB06epe;nLe.
KneB, 1961, CTp. 71-72, plIc.)6, 2; 47, 1;
C. C. Bepeaancb/w. I{epa)lina oi.lorpy.
AiBcbKoi KYJIbTYPIl. (,Apxeo.lorilJo>, T. XVI.
KIIIB, 1964, CTp. 65, pilC. 18.
19 M. H. ApraMono8. K Bonpocy 0 IIpOIlC-
XOmAeHIIII.., CTp. 27.
20 B. A. rOp00408. YKa3. COq., TaG.l. II, 21,
23-24 II CTp. 151, pliC. 112.
21 B. A. IDpaM"o. I1cCJIeAOBaHIIH Be.1LCKoro
ropoAII a. AI1HY B 1968 1'., BbII!. III.
KlleB, 1971, CTp. 52-53; B..1. Wpa."liO.
AocJIiAmenHH naM'HTO" B oacceiinax Ci B.
AilI JI i BOPCKJIII. AAHY B 1969 p., Bill!.
IV. KlIiB, CTp. 128-129.
22 M. H. ApraMonoB. COKpOBIIII\a CnllcJ.>CnllX
"ypraHoB, Ta6JI. 1, Ta6JI. 17-19; A. Go-
dard. Le tresor de Ziwiye (Kurdistan).
Haarlem, 1950.
23 M. 9. MaTbe, B. K. AifjUllGCbeea, 11. Jf.
11.bH"ono8, B. r. llY1>onun. HCI;YCCTBO
ApeBllero BocToRa. M., 1968, pilC. 263 B.
Maritzyn, Gouv. Cherson. PZ, b. V, 1913,
S. 9-i t.
5 B. A. HAbunc"aH. CKII<pJ.! ;\lIenpoBcKoro
JIeCOCTenlloro J1eB06epembH (KypraHbI llo-
CYJIbJI). KlIeB, 1968, Ta6JI. XVI, 9.
8 B. A. IDpaM1>o. Be;IbCKoe ropoAII e-
BamuelImnii: nOJIHTllqeCKII II II 3KOHOMII'Ie-
CKIlIi eHTp CKII<pCRoii: 3I!OXII B BOCTOq-
HOII EBpone. «XV HayKoBa KOH<pepeH iJI
fA AH YCCP. Te3!1». OAecca, 1972.
7 M. H. ApraMono8. COI;pORIIIHa CKII<pCKIiX
KypraHOB. IIpara - J1., 1966, Ta6JI. 62.
8 A. A. Bo6punc1\:uu. OneT 0 paCKonKax,
,:,pOH3Be;1eHHbIX B 1903 r. B 'lllmplllicKoM
ye3Ae KlIeBcKoII ry6. MArl, Bbill. 14. C1l6.,
1905, CTp. 13-19.
9 B. A. JI.tbllnC1>aR. 'I;a . CO'!., CTp. 37.
10 B. A. IDpaM1>O, O. M, IIrrptllfeH"o, ll. O.
CO.<H4ee, ll. 11.. CPo.llill. OoxOllmeHIIJI i
TexHiKa ClIITTH 6pon oHllx Iia3aHiB paHHbo-
1'0 3aJIi3IIoro BiKY. dIapllCII 3 iCTopii
npllpOA03HaBCTBa i TeXHil,n.>. BbIn. XII.
KlliB, 1970f
\I B. A. IDnJ."'1>o. PaGon] B 6accelIHax
BOpCKJIbI ;r CeBepHoro ;loillra, AO 1971 r.
M., 1972, CTp. 329.
" B. A. IDpa...lio. 06 H roTOII.WHIIH 30JIOTbIX
YKpamenulI.., CTp. 2ti.
13 B. A. ropo8408. L(HPHI1I1I; apxeo.'10rIIqe-
CKIIX IICC.le;1oBaHnii. \I :j"nbKoBCKOM y.
208
" C. A. )J{e6e.Ae8. fpP0;10T " CInI<pCKue 00-
;r;eCTBa. «Ceul'IJlIOP IIpll'lepHOMOpI.e».
,I. - .'1., 1953, CTp. 35.
" R. Ghirshman. Iran protoiranier, meder,
achiimeniden. \\Iunchcn, 1964, pI. 52.
6 J/. 9. MaTbe, B. H. AifJanacbeea, H. ilf.
l1.bR"ono8, B. r. .7YliOHUH. '1;a3. COq., pllC.
2636.
07 Jf. If. Apra.'lOlio8. .-\IITpOnO)lOp<pHbIe 00-
meCTBa II pe:mmn C""<pOB. ACf3, Bbill. 2.
J1., 1961, CTp. 64-65.
08 Jl. H. ApraMono8. COI,pOBn a CKII<pCKUX
KypraHoB, TaOJI. 186.
-Q C. A. To"ape8. PeJIl!rllH B IICTOpll1l II a-
pOAOB mipa. M.. HJ64, CTp. 313.
,v TpeH enll-Ba'<bdanrPe.tb lIMpe. MII<p0.10-
mJI. \\I., 1959, CTp. 54; 3. II. CO"O.<08a.
KYJIbT ,KUIIOTllbIX B pe.ll1rIIHx. M., 1972,
CTp. 188.
31 BbIcoTa Kyprana 1,6 )1, Al!aMeTp 37 M. 1\I0-
rrrJIbnaH HMa (150X OO CM) C nepeKpbI-
TlIml 1!3 ABYX pH;10B I!;IaX yrJIy6.'1ella
HII,I,P IIorpe6eHnoii nO'IRbI Bcero Ha 50 CM.
iRenII\lIlla cpe;1HIIX .1eT IIOJIOmeIla B BbI-
THnYTO)1 nOJIoa;enlln Ha CI!lIlIe, rOJIOBa
opllellTIIpOBaHa na 3anaA.
30 B. A. IDpaM"o. CJIeAbI 3eMJIeAeJIbqeCKOrO
"YJIbTa y JIeCOCTenHblX nJIeMeH CeBepHO-
1'0 IIpll'lepHOMOpbJI B paHHeM ,KeJIe3HOM
BeKe. CA, 1957, oM 1, CTp. 189, pilC. 8.
33 M. H. ApraMono8. AIiTponoMop<pHbIe 60-
meCTBa B peJIllrll1l CKIlq>OB, CTp. 64.
3i TaM me, CTp. 59,
E. R. MaKCHMOB
BOM, HHYTPIL KOTOpOro BbIpeaaHa roJIO-
Ba JIOOl C rop6aTbIM HOCOM, pTOM, C
OqepqellllbDm OTBIICJlbIMII ry6aMll,
KalweBlI::\HbIM rJIaaOM II YXOM B 4>OpMC
CHJlbHO BblTIIHYToro TpeyrOJIbHIIKa.
H a.l\J>.'IIOBbe IITIIU,bI peaKO OqepqeHO
H lIaCeqeHO roplIaOHTaJIbHbIMII JIIIHHH-
Mil. r.la3 Bb!nOJIHeH B BII.l\e meCTII.'Ie-
neCTnOBoii poaeTKII. ITplI'IeM, rJlaa-
poaPTKa OXBaqeH CIIJIbHO lIaOrHYTbIM
KJ1IOBO 1 BToporo lIa06pameHHH lIT HU,bI ,
rOJlona. l'OTOPOH paCIIOJIOmeHa HilmI'
rJl3aa-po3eTKII. Y BTOpOH nTIIu,bI pe3-
IIblMII :IIIHHHMII IIOKa3aHbl Ha)J;KJlIO-
IIhC II no.'IyOKpymHocThlO C TOqKOH B
IlenT!)!! - r.1a:3a.
Cpe:UfilH qaCTb KJlbIKa yKpaIIIeIIa
4>nry poii O.-WIIH, CTOHm;ero B (t II blO llle II
n03e». h1\K 6bI Ha u,bIIIOqKax. Ero cnH-
Ra Bblrn /Ta, nepe.l\HHH qaCTb TYJlOBHIlla
IIblRepnYTa. a rOJIOBa onym;eHa
BHII:I n lIaXO.l\HTCH Mem.l\y IIepe)J;HII m
If :WJIIIDIII RoraMH. Mopp;a OJleIIH He-
CKO.'II,r;o Y;:\.lHHeHnaH, ry6bi o60:lHaqe-
/lbi ;J;t':lo6r-;0 r co C.1erKa paClllHpeHHbI l
RIlYTI'I'!JIIIDr I\Onu,OM, r.'1a:J KanJleBnJ-
Ilblii. ':\o B 4>OpMC CIIJIbHO BbITHHYToro
Tpeyro.l b IlIIK a, 06pam;eHIIoro OCTpbIM
yr.TJO\1 RRepx, npHmaTO K IIIee. Pora
O.fW!lH IwfBlICTbIe H KOHU,bI HX IIpeg-
CT311.]HI"T Xe:'daTlIqeCKHe op.rrlIHbIe ro-
.10Rhl!. . fiOTOpbIX IIpopa60TaIIbI Kpyr-
:Ib!e l.la3a H poroBHu,a IIa.l\KJIIOBbH.
06(> ];l.llIIle HorlI OJIeHH IIJIOTHO nplIma-
HI (UI!<l r-; .:IpyrOH. ITpep;n.rreqbe nepe.l\-
III!\ 11('1" YCII:TeHO roJIOBOH c.aHrlI. 11306-
pameHlIe caHrn .l\ano pe3HbDI KOHTypOM.
tJeTKo BbI.l\eJIen KaII.'1eBII.l\IlbIii rJIa3,
IIOqTH C.'1HTbIIl C JI06HOii qaCTblO, HOC
HaBlIcaeT Ha.l\ HHmHell ry60ii. Ha pore
JIOMaHbIMH IIHHIIIIMH IIOKa: aHbI YTOJI-
m;eHIIII, IIpHcym;ne callrar-;aM-caMu,aM.
Ha 3a.l\Hell Hore HMeeTCII 1I306pameHHe
1I30rHYToII .'1eCTIIHqKH.
Ha IIIlIpOKO 1 KOHu,e KJIblKa BbIpe3aHa
4>lIrypKa KaoaHa, R IIOJIHbIrr pOCT, CTOH-
m;ero Ha KOHqIlKaX KOIIbIT «<Ha U,bIIIOq-
Rax»). fOJIOBa ero OIIym;eHa, IIaCTb,
BoopymeHHafI OCTpblM KJIbIKOM, C.llerKa
HOBbIE HAXO,D}Uf CABPOMATCHOrO
3BEPHHOrO CTHJUI
B rrOBOJIllibE
B 1965 r. B CapaToBcKlIll 05JIaCTHOll
:MY3ell KpaeBe.l\eHllJI IIOCTYlll1JI1I CBe)J;e-
HIIH 0 pa3pymeHIIII KypraHa y c. Ho-
BOllpnBOJIbHoro POBeHcKoro paiioHa Ca-
paToBcKoii 05JIaCTII. ITpoBe.l\eHHoe HaMil
06CJIe.l\OBaHHe IIOKaaaJlO, qTO OKOJIO
ceJIa HOBOIIplIBOJIbHOe lI.l\eT IIHTeH-
CIIBHoe paapymeHlIe JIeBOro 5epera
BOJIrH. ITO.l\MbIBaeMbIH BOJIrOrpa)J;CKIIM
BO.l\OXpaHIIJIIIm;eM BblCOKlIii 6eper 60JIb-
illlIMII rJIHHIICTbIMII rJIbI6aMII IIa.l\aeT
B BOAY. TaK 6bIJI pa3pYIIIeII II Haxo-
)J;IIBIIIHii:c II Ha IIepBOH KopeHHOH Tep-
pace KypraII. ITplI HalI50JIbIDeM crra.l\e
BO.l\bI Ha 06IIameHHOM 6IIqeBHJIKe
06HapymeHbI OT.l\eJIbHbIC 'IeJIOBeqeCIHIP
}WCTH H HaH.l\eH pH.l\ IIpeAMeToB B
3BepHI!OM CTIIJIe. O)J;HaKO HaIIIH 06cJIe-
)J;OBaIIHH MeCTa HaXO)J;KH He .l\alOT B03-
MOif<IIOCTH rOBoplITb, npH.Hap;JIemaT JIll
npe.l\MeTbI O.l\lIOMY IIJIIl HeCI{{)JIblmM
IIorpe6a.1bHbIM KOMn.rreKcaM.
C06paHHaH KOJIJIenu,1I1I rrpe.l\MeTOB
caBpmWTcr-;oro 3BeplIHoro CTHJlH BeCb-
Ma CBoeoopa3Ha H IIHTepeCHa. OHa ("0-
CTOHT JI;! Ra6aIIbHX KJIbIKOB C pe:mbIIIIII
u306pam(>HIIHMH, 6POH:WBbIX lICaJlHll II
50JIbIIIOrO KOJIlIqeCTBa 6POII:WBbIX .1IIL-
TbIx 6.uHIIIeK OT KOIICKOro y6paIICTB3.
Ra6aHblIX KJIbIKOB Hall.l\eHO TplI: )],Ba
illlIpOKlIX - 60JIbIIIOH H Ma.'IbIH II cpeA-
HeH Be.'1HqIIHbI Y3KHll KJIbiK. BOJIbIIIoi'I
KJIbIK, ;:{.'1lIIIOIO 16 CM, IIMeeT TPII pe3-
HbIX H306pameHIIH ITa OAHoii CTOpOHC
(pIIC. 1, 1). Y3KIIH KOHell o4>opMJIen B
BH)J;e rO.'10Bbl IITIIU,bI C BbITIIHYTbIM r-;.'IIO-
Puc. 1. f(a6aHbll ';;lbl'W c pe3HblMII 1l306pa-
:HCeHUHMU
IIpIIOTKpbITa, mITaqOK IIJIOCKlIii, rJIa3
KaIIJIeBIIAlibIll, lIe60JIbIIIOe yxo B BH.l\e
3aBHTKa. Ha .16y II XOJIKe BepTHKaJIbHbI-
Mil IIITplIxa m 1I306pameHa w,eTIIHii.
IIpeAnJIeqbe yCIIJIeHO 11306pameHHl')!
rOJIOBKII opJla C Kpyr.'lblM rJIa30ll! H 3,1['-
nyTbIlI! KJIIOBOM. OopaTHalI CTOpOll<!
KJIbIKa rJIaAKaH, C OTBepCTlIell! Ha IlO-
JlOM BHYTPII llllIpOKOM KOHu,e.
MaJIbIii Ka6aHHll RJlbIK (pIIC. 1, 2)
C JIIIu,eBoii CTOpOHbl Ha KOHu,ax HMeeT
pe3HbIe 1I306pameHIIH. C 06paTHoii
CTOpOHbI OH rJIa.l\KlIii, C OTBepCTlielli
6JIIIa KpaH mlIpoKoro KOHu,a, IIOJIOrO
BHYTPII. AJIHHa IIpeAMeTa 13,5 01.
YaKlIii KOHeu, 3TOro KJIbIKa YKparnen
rOJIOBOII Ka6aHa C TYIIbIM IlHTaqKO I.
J
t.._ .
211
210
nplIOTKpbITblM pTOM C TOpqaIl\HM H
fIPM KJIbIKOM, TpeyrOJIhHbIM r.la30M C
nOAqepKHYTbIM cBepxy BeKO I H yxmI
n BHp;e 3aBHTKa-CIIHpaJIIl. Ha .'l06HOll
qaCTII BaJIIIKOM C TpeMH 30HaMH TpOU-
HbiX Hape30K llOKa3aHa Il\eTHHa.
IIIllpOKH:U: KOHen; 3aKaHqlIBaeTCH rOJIO-
Boa XHll1.HIIKa C paCKpblToii rraCTblO,
KOTopaH OqepqeHa BbIllyKJIbIM Ba.1IIIW 1.
BHYTpli llaCTII Bblpe3aHbl ABa ;:(.1HITIIbI"
KJIbIKa, MeJIKHe 3y6bI H H3blh. 3a
llacTbID BblllYKJIOH llaJIbMeTKOH nOKa3a-
BbI MbImn;bl. H03APII (B03MOiKHO, YCbI)
BbIIIOJIHeHbI B Bll)J;e llY'lKa pe3HbIx Il30r-
HYTbIX JIIIHHH. fJIa3 pe3HOH, KaIIJIeBH)J;-
Puc. 2. BpOU80Bb1.e nca/luu
UbIii:. ¥xo B 4>opMe clUIpa.leBIIAIIoro Ba-
:.I II Ka -3aBHTKa.
TpeTlIH, Y3KI1:U: """lbll, (puc. 1, 3) op-
!la leHTupOBaH C ABYX CTOpOH. PllCYHOK
Jmn;eBoii: CTOpOHbI IIOBTOpOH Ha TbIJIb-
ROH, HO ne C TaK01", Tll1.aTeJIbHOCTblO.
IIIHpOKH:U: KOHen; R.lbIKa IIOJIbI:U:, C OT-
RepeTIleM Ha 06paTHOH CTopOHe. AJIllHa
KJIbIKa - 13,5 CM. llIHpOKH:U: KOHen;
o4>opMJIeH B Bll)J;e rOJIOBbI XIIll1.HllKa C
pa3HHYTO:U: llaCTblO, YKparneHHO:U: KPYll-
HblMH KJIbIKaMII. IIaCTb 06Be)J;eHa peJIb-
e4>HblM 60PTHKOM, KOTOpbIll: BHII3Y
OKa:U:MJIHeT HlliKHlOlO ry6y, a BBepxy
Ha MeCTe H03Apii IIepeXO)J;IIT B H306pa-
iKeHlIe rOJIOBbI opJIa C 3arHYTbIM KJIlO-
BOM H rJIa30M-ToqKOIL B HHiKHlOlO qe-
JllOCTb BIII1CaH peJIbe4>HbIll PHCYHOK
rOJIOBbI .10CH C MaCCUBlIbIM rop6aTbIM
IIOCOM, OTBIICJIO:U: ry601I, r.lla30M-TOqHOII
II TOpqaIl\IBI He60JIbrnrrM YXO 1. f.'l,na
XIIIl\llm,a IIOI,a3aHbI )J;BYMH, BIIIIcaUUbI-
1lI APyr B )J;Pyra OKPYiKlIOCTH I!l.
BIIemUHH OKpYiKHOCTb UMeeT 60KOBbIe
qepTO'JhII-e.1e3HHlI,bI. Y XO BbIIIO.1l1eIlO
B BH)J;e 3aBIlTKa C HaCeqKaMI1 H .liaUO III-
HaeT 6apaHIlII por HJIU paKOBHHY ymlT-
KII. HIIa>e yxa IIaJIbMeTKO:U: IIOKa3aHbI
!\lbllIIn;bI ,
Cpe.1HlOlO qaCTb H.lbIKa YKparnaeT
peJIbeq1HOe 11306paiKeHlle rOJIOBbI Me)J;-
BeAH B <pac. fJIa3a 3BepJl BbIrrOJIHeHbI
HpyiKI;amI, He60JIbillne ymKH )J;aHbI B
BU)J;e 3aBIITKa. HOHell, IOp)J;bI oXBaqeH
rrepe;UlIum JIalla m C KorTHMII, HaMe-
qeHHbDIII ropIl30HTa.'1bHbIMH JIHHIIHMH.
BCH OCTaJIbHaH llOBepXHOCTb OT rO.10-
BbI xUIl\HIIKa AO KOHlI,a Y3KO:U: qaCTH
opHa leHTHpOBaHa 4>ecToHaMH C Tpey-
ro.lbHrrHa fII, HlliKHHH qaCTb KOTOpbIX
3allO.lnena KOCblMII KpeCTIIKaMII, a Bep-
1IIllHbI :JaI;aHqHBaIOTCH TO'lKaMIl. B eoe-
TaB HOlIeKOro y60pa BXO)J;HT Tpn uca-
.1JIlH II 18 O.1HX.
Bpo[[:JOBbIe IIca.'Illrr IIpo)J;cTaBJIeHbI
1\BYMH THIIaMII. O)J;IIH llCaJIIIll S-BII)J;-
ROll qwpMbl (pIIC. 2, 2) , )J;JIHHa-
10,6 01, )J;BYJJ;hIpqaTbIll, KOHn;bI CJIerKa
paeIIIII reHbI II HarrOl\I1IUalOT KOHCKHe
HOllbIl iI. ABa )J;pyrIle rrCaJIIIH rrapHbIe II
()T.1I1TJ.I II AByxcoCTaBHoll 4>opMe. IIea-
.11111 II \ll'IOT BUn; qeTbIpeXrpaHIforo IIPy-
Ta t' :IBY !H pacwupellHflMIl II OTBep-
enI}1 \111 B cpeAIIei", qaeTlI (pile. 2, 1).
B Ci"'.lIIell qaeTII :m IeTHbI C.'IeAbI me-
.1C:W "T YAH.l. HOHubI rrca'lIlII YKparne-
HbI I' '.lIJBKaMII XHIl\HI,IX 3Bepell, IIPH-
qC I (,:\IIa rOJIOBa e .1.'IIlHHOII MOPAOH,
;p T"fI C KOpOTKOH. TpaKTOBKa 06e-
llX 11)1' 'R 0AIlHaKOBaH: eeprro06pa3Hoe
)"XIJ. HLIIIOiIIIeHHoe peJIbe4>HbIM Ba:.IH-
I,mI. pC' 1 HOII I;all.1eBIl.1HbIll r.la3, llaeTb
o(iRf'.I.."a Ba.l11KO I. 3aKaHqIlBalOIl\II IeH
3aBIIll'(i\l-HOeOM. Y )J;BURHOMOp;1:l0rO
X!lIIIIIIII'a B IIaCTll ABa CO)!hHYTbIX H
,, "" '" '''<'- ' .c.:..""- - ,.... r,.,,'-...-. - <r- :
I -" . "'. . ,- .. "'
I .. 2 ' .'.C.L
.
"', _ " ". ;) l ;:< ',_ _
. ... " '. '.., O.
I " .
I
' -' I
.. I -I,: .
I
- - .
O "'- O "
- ':-.--- '?--
.,£.-' -::'2- "' ' ,'
2
'--
212
OAMH OTAe!lbHO eTOHIl\IIll r-;:lbIK, y IW-
pOTKoMopp;oro - ABa CmIRuYTbIx K.'Ibl-
Ka. AmlHa !{aiKAOH: JIeaJIIIII - 24,9 nl.
Bee 6ilHXlI OTJIHTbI rr3 6pOH3bl IlllMe-
lOT Ha 060pOTe BepTur-;a!lbilYlO II.ln ro-
plI30HTaJIbHYlO MaeeuBHYIO rreTJIIO )J;JIH
I,peIIJIeHIlH. ABe 6:IHXM II300paiRalOT
BO.-IRa B rro;'!Hbli1 pOCT B IIpoqm,'b (pilC.
3, 2, 3). B.1JHXIl llapHble: o;.(na 4>rrrypa
UOBepHYTa rO:.IOBOIO BIIpaBO, ;1:IpyraH-
BJIeBO. CTrrJIHeTHqeeKrr ooe 4>HrypbI
BbIIIOJlHeHbI O)J;IlHaHOBO: uaCTb oHai1M-
.1eHa BaJIHKO !, Kpyr.lbIll II.10CKIIII r:Ia3
O'lepqeH pe.1:be4>Holl OKpYiKHoeTbIO,
KanJIeBUAHOe yxo AaHO Ba.lnKmL IIoA
YXOM I,pyr.l01! BbIIIYH.'1HIIOII 110l-.:a3aH3
eKYJIOBaH Mblmn;a. JIaIIbI 331,aHqHBa-
IOTCH peJIbe4>HblMII AY)Ima 1II II BHYTpn
IIX - KorTII. AJIllHa 4>HrypHH - 3,5 CM.
ABe APyrIle, TOiKe IIapHble OJIHXn
11306paiKalOT Me)J;Be)J;H (pnc. 3, 1) II
llOJIHbIH: pOCT, B IIp04>H.TIb co CJIerKa
OllYll1.eHHOll: rOJIOBOll H paC1>pIrITOll lla-
CTblO C 3y6aMII. fo.10Ba JIIlIpOKaH, JIO-
6aCTaH, e MaJIeHbKII I YXO I. BIrIIIOJIHeH-
HbIM KpyrOBbIM Ha.'IIIr-;OM. DarTb 3BepH
OqepqeHa B3.1IIKOM, :JaI\anqIIBaIOIJ\HMCH
3aBHTr-;OM Ha HOCY. l'.liU Tpa1\TOBaH B
BH,1e He60JlblIIoi1 BbIII '!{.'JOCTIl B peJIb-
e4>HOM 060AHe. PeJIbe4>HhDIU OHPYiKHO-
eTHMIl IIOK33aHbI XO.1Ka II rrpeAIIJIeqbe
IIepeAHIlX JIaII. JIaIIbI :{ar-;aHqHBaIOTCH
pe:Ibe4>HbIMn n;yiKI;a\!IL RHYTPII KOTO-
pbIX BaJIIIKOM IIOKalaIIbI KOTTH. XBOCT
:!BepH ;:J;.1IlllIIbIH, 3aRCp[[ 'TJ,IO Ha Konn:e
B r-;OJleqKO. n.ITIlHa O.lHIlIJ;II -- 3.1 CM.
He60JIbIJIaJI 6pO!l'JORaH o.'IHIIIKa BbI-
IIo.1HeHa B BilAe ro:rOBLI I;OWaqbero
XHIl\IIIlI;a B IIPO<pII.1!, 8.1('111) (rIlC. 3, 8) .
<DopMa 6JIHXII oKpyr.laH II IoPAa 3BepH
I;opOTI;aH. 3Bepb Il.'306pa a,en C pa3IlHY-
TOil IIaeTblO. IIaCTb O'lep'leIIa Ba.1IIlKOM,
HHiKIIIlll: KOHeu KOToporo TIMIlTIlpyeT
HIIa>HlOlO ry6y, a BepxnIlii - paernHpH-
eTCH II e.'lIlBaeTCH C ,1 0('11 0 j'I qaCTblO.
BHYTPIl IIaCTII AaH!>1 RToporr. MeHee
pe.lhecpIIbIH KOHTYP II An}] IIOrrepe'lRbIX
KilbIKa. Ha .10Y IIP0'lerqplT haIIJIeBHA-
213
Ilb!ii r,la3, 110 II OT.1I1'IlIe OT IIOP;OOHhIX
l1a06pamemdi Xl1lqHIIKOB Ha Ka6aHbHX
KJIbiKaX, oc-Tpoii qaCTblO (CJle3111Il\eii)
HanpaBJlelI KO JlOY, a ne K IIOCY. Yxo
Tome KaIiJICBII,J.HOt', OCTpbm yrJIOM Ha-
IIpaB.'leHO KHI13Y, 110 BbirrO.1HeHO pe!Jb-
elf/HbIM BaJUmml. gJII1Ha 6:IHXI1 IIO CO-
pU30HTaMlI - 2,4 CM.
ABe 6JIHXII H.!oopamalOT B np041l1JIb
nOBepHYTYIO BJ1eBO rOJIOBY 3BepH (puc.
3, 5, 6) C HeCliO.1hIiO BbITHHYTOH MOp-
p;oii. no TeXHllliC II TpaKToBKe 06e 6JIfI-
XII O)J.IIHaKOBbI. liOlITYP IlX OKaiiMJIell
peJIbelf/nbIM Ba.llll\O'II. TeM me npueMOM
p;alIbl 11 p;eTa.1H: lIaCTb, r.laa, YXO. rJIa3
nOKa3aH oKpymnocTblO C OCTpbIM BI>I-
CTYIIOM Hap; Iwii. Yxo p;aHO nOJIY-
oKpymHocTblO. B pacKpbIToH naCTU IIO-
Ka3aHlJ K.'lbIKII. A.luna IIpep;MeToB IIO
3,2 CM.
TpeThH IIo o6uoro TUlia 6JlJlXa Be-
CKOJII>KO KpynHee II IIOBepnyTa Mopp;oii
BIl!>al1O (pne. 3, 4). TexHHKa n TpaKTOB-
Ka - Kat> Y npeAh1iIYmnx 6JIHX, no OT-
JllI'lUC B TOM. <iTO yxo nOl\a:ullIo IIOJIHoii
oRpymHllcTblO, 1I0e - llCCKOJIbKO Mal
CHEIIC\.'. H:uma - ,5 CM.
I1I1Tl'peCII<l i).-IHIlIKa C u300pameuueM
fO,IOOb! 80.llia 8 If/ac (puc. 3, 9).
PacHmpPllllau .1ouuaH qaCTb 1'O,lOBbI
IIMeeT YMCPCIIIIO paeCTaB:IeHHb!t' peJlb-
elf/IIMC Ylllll-"o.Ie'u,n II CJIaaa, ol\aiiM-
.[eHlIbl£' BaJlIII,'nl. :\[oPAa newmnni1u.
eJlenm CY"'f'lIl1dR RIIlIay. AnlIHa
OJIfIIllKIl no R£'pTlIl,a.lrl - 2,4 CM.
Hcom.lbliO CliCJcoopa3HbI [UlTb 6.I[H-
meT, C u:Joiil'aFKCHlieM 3BepH, npH
naRlllcro lIa I1Cpl'.JElie nanb[ (BnIJ; clIe-
pe.JII). 11. 06p'''hCHlle CU.abHO CTIf.IlI30
Bauo. \[O[l.J1I XlilitHIII';a npeilCTaBJIl'Ha R
OU)];l' rTcp"'IIH 1I.1i111"1I C ,J.BYMH Kpyr-
:IhI m, O1wihl.lenIlLI\rIf Ro:rb[(eBrI;IHbIM
Ba.l)H\(I [ 1'.1.1.1.1 \III. Hail KOTopbIMn TOp-
qaT ne60:IJ,(IlII(' OKp)TJIbie YUIH. B Hnm-
Heii 'ICICTII pf'.ll"" fI(Jii Ayroii C KOITHMII
nOl\aai1f1hl .1.111101 (pur. 3, 16). Apyrne
llleCTb o.lHlIJel; nO;looHoii CXeMbI OTml-
qalOTCn OT oliliCilUHbIX TeM, qTO Ha
BcpTHKac1blIOH n.lallKe BBepxy II BTJlI3Y
II.JOopameHbl OAHl! JIalIb! (pIlC. 3, 13).
Bce npeAMeTb) 1,0 -1,5 CM AJUInOIO
no Bl'pTHKaJIII.
HOnbITHI>[e mllBOTHbIe, KpOMe ynoMH-
HYTbIX Ha Ka6aHI>IIX K.TIbJKaX, npeACTaB-
JIeHbJ eme oAnon 6JIHmKOH C n306pa-
meHlIeM 1'OJIOBbi JIOCH B tlJac
(pHC. 3, 10). AJIlIHa 6J1HlllKll no BepTl!-
KaJIH - 2,7 CM. Ibo6pameHIle np('k
CTaBJUleT BepTHKaJlbnylO Y3h")'10 IIJIaH-
KY, CJIerna 3aI{pyrJIeHHYIO H pacmnpeH-
HYIO B HlImHeii qacm II IlIl1pOKYIO B
BepxHeii. Ha nmpOKOM BepXHeM 1\0HlW
KanJIeBH)J;HbIMH YCJIy6neHlIHMH AaH'"
60JIbmlIe rna3a, HaA KOTOpbIMII P;BYMH
penbl'4JHbIMlI neTeJIbKaMU C yr.1y6JIe-
!lIIHMH BOYTpn BblIIOJIHenbJ ymn.
nTlIQe06pa3HbIe 1I306pamenbT na
]J;BYX 6nHxax. OAHa 6nHxa P;OBOJIhUO
RpynnaH (wmnOlo 4 CM), B nnllc 1'0.10
Db[ ymacTo1'O rplllf/oHa B rrpo-
tIJlIJIb (pnc. 3, 7). HOnCI\ K;JIOna .11'1
ruYT,B cnupanb. Do KpalO naAKJIJOllhn
naCCqeBbi 3y6bl. rJla3 BbmOJlnN! H
BHp;e RPYCJIOH BbInYKJlflHbI r pe.lbl'tl'
}lbJM 060AROM. C3aAII rJIa:la III'OO:IMnr,,'
uKpyrnoe yxo. Hume Cna.ia pe.1 be(
1100 Jr306pamCHHc opmmoii: rO.-IOBLI C
.\lOIqllbIM KnIOBO 1. BTopaH o.luxa II.IO
6pamaeT POJIony YlllacTou IITlIIlhI
TO)l<C B npolf/HJIb (pIlC. 3, 12). 1\.1K111
,larnYT. rna3 Aall pe.mblM I;O.-le'mmI,
:\i1 [{QTOpbIM B Rllj{e OTI}()CTJ;a C yr.lyfi-
"WHHl'M - yXO. 1I0A rna30M R IlIJiHIlf'ii
qaCTII 6nHxH pl':moii aanllTOK. A:lllila
npCAMeTa - 2,4 01.
II, HaKoncn, eHIC O..'IIIa o.lJJXa II 1111;(1'
naJlbMCTh""l1 Tpl'} ro.lblwii (f1()I' Ihi {' III'
epooopa:mo pacXOAHmlJl'fllll'H Pf':IbP'I.-
HbIMIl nonocaMII lI.i oCTpOro )T.'I1I. JI. III
Ha UJIRXI( 4.;; C\I (pnc. ; . II).
l\poM nllcaHHbIx, 6bI.1If rofipil II '" II
;(pyrlIe 6poll30BbIe npeAMl'ThI: 0,111,'
no.1YlllapHaH 6!JHxa e K[lp("Toonl'a.lnll
paCIIOJIOmeHHbIMII Bhl nyl;JIrln1l 1II. II II TI,
rJIaIJ;KIIX nonymapHbJX 6JIRX. IW.W'IHI1
.111TbIe, cTpeMeBllIJ;nbIe. 008.1b"loIl' II
t4
pue. 3. lJpoll306ble 6_fRW1'01l 6 36eplllto...
CTIlAe
ct)
4
.'
()o
. . _.
.«:["W
. ,
tmaZ)
1
.
5
., . '-
q) ' ,
.', Q ..9,
r ':.
,."c
o
,I. .f.
. : l .-
1
8
-o -.>
' (
\
0 0 ' ..
..+ j
3 .
6
9
,,: "jt "I:
. i (}
"'
Q}1!JO:
16
' (
17
" E
KOJW'IKII MeJIKlIe 1I3 YlIJIOru;eHIIOii 6pOH-
30BOH npOBOJIOKII.
HOBOnplIBOJIbHeHCKaH lIaxOiIKa no
60raTCTBY lIpe,a;MeTOB He YCTYlIaeT 1I3-
neCTIIOMY KOMnJIeKCY Beru;eii B 3RepII-
Hml CTUJIe 1I3 BJIIOMeH«peJIb,a;CKoro KYP-
rana A 12 1 , a no pa3Hooopa3lIIO 1I300-
l_'ameulln ,a;ame npeBocxo,a;IIT.
Bce 1I300pameHlIH Ha KJIbIKaX, nca-
:WHX II OJIHXaX MomHO pa3,a;eJIllTb Ha
rpII rpynnbI: KonbITHble mlIBoTHbIe,
XII11\HbIe 3BepH II nTIID;eoopa3HbIe. IIpH-
'leM ;I.TH c03 aHIIH Toro IIJIII IIHoro 1I300-
pameHIIH caBpOMaTCKlI"U: MacTep HC-
no.1b:wBa.TI npelIMyru;ecTBeHHo 00pa3hI
lIpe cTaBHTeJIell MeCTIIoro mlIBOTHoro
MI!pa. ham,a;bIll c03,a;aHHblll 00pa3 IIMe-
eT mlIBOCTb II BbIpa3lITeJIbHOCTb, a II300..
paif;eulle ero YAaqHO COqeTaeTCH C ,a;e-
lwpaTIIBlIbIMH TpeoOBaHnHMH. PeaJIH-
CTlIqHOCTb II co,a;epmaHne He nplIHece-
I1bl B il\epTBY «popMe npe)J;MeTa, KaK
J1'O xapaKTepHO AJIH n03,a;Hero neplIo,a;iI
:JpepllHoro CTIIJIH.
hOlIblTHble mlIBOTHbIe nil HOBorrplI-
BO.ThneUCKIIX npe,a;MeTax rrpe,a;CTilBJIeHbl
lI:w6pamenHHMH l\aoaHa, JIOCH, callrlI
II O.TeHH. ylaoopameHIIH KaoaHa BCTpe-
qeU"I ,a;Bam,a;bI. Ha OOJIbillOM KJIbIl\O
WIOI1H 1I300pameH B nOJIHbIH pOCT
(pIlC. 1, 1). H alIOOJIee OJIlI3KOH aHaJIO-
rlICrI HOBOnplIBOJIbHeHCKoll «plIrype HB-
JlHIOTCH BbIpe3aHHl>Ie 1I:J 30JIOTOll <poJIb-
rI! InoopameHFIH KaoaROB H3 tJlI.TIIK-
TIIHClwro KypraHa 5 II BOCTOqHOM Ka-
I1XCTI1He 2 II «pHrypa CTOHru;ero :JBepH,
""Ipe:!I1HHOrO Ha KpbIIllKe capKO<pa-
rl1-KO.TOAbI BTOp01'O BaIllaAapCKoro KYP-
rl1l1l1 '. M3BeCTHbI 1I300pameHlIH 1\30a-
Hon II B lIaMHTHIIKax CKII«pC1wro IICKYC-
nRI1. B BepXHeH qaCTII 30JIOTOH 001ma,a;-
hIT I!OmeH Meqa 1I3 EJIlI3aBeTOBCKoro
K\"rraHa V B. ,a;o H. 3. BbIIIOJIHeHa «pH-
ryra KaoaHa H H,a;yr:nero 3a HIIM JIbBa 4.
ThoopameHHH rOJIOBbI Ka6aHa. no-
:I('(,Horo IIcno.TIHeHHOMY Ha Y3KOM KOH-
liI' 111.TIOrO RJIJdKa (pIIC. 1, 2) pacnpOCT-
pa I!CllbI ,a;OBO.'lbHO IllHpORO. CpeAII
CKII«pCKIIX ApeBHocTel1 Momno YKa3aTb
na Y3AeqHbIe O.'IHlIIKII II3 -4 CeMII6paT-
Hero KypraHa, HeKpOrrOJIH HIIM<pell
(KypraH 24) ., ;(aTilpye lblx lIepBoll no-
JIOBIIHOll V B. ,a;o H. 3. 1\ 3TOMY me Bpe-
MeHII OTHOCHTCH II aHa.'IorIIqHbIe BO,Tm-
CKOMY 1I300pameHlIH rO.'IOBbl KaoaHa
Ha OpOH30BOll 6.THiliKe rr:J hypraHa 7
II na ROHD;e OpaCJIeTa II3 KypraHa 11 MO-
rlIJIbHIIKa «tJacTbIe KypraHbI» 6.
BeCbMa CBoeoopa3Ha o.THlIIKa B BII-
,a;e rOJIOBbI JIOCH B <pac (pnc. 3, 10).
3TO mlIBoTHoe, RIIAUMO, XOpOiliO ObI.TIO
H3BeCTHO II CKI!<pa I, II caBpoMaTaM.
Ero H300pameHlIe I1eO HOKpaTHo BCTpe-
'laeTCH Ha npeAMeTax. BbIIIOJIHeHHbIX
n 3BeplIHoM CTII.'Ie, HO B IlOAOOHOll TpaK-
TOBKe oOHapymello BnepBbIe. IIPO«pIIJIb-
Hoe 1I300pameHlIe rO.TIOBbl .TOCH BbIpe3a-
HO BUYTPH IlTIID;bI na Y3KOM KOHl\O
OOJIbillOrO I\JIbIKa (pilC. 1, 1) II Ha HlIm"
Hell qeJIIOCTH XHru;HIIKa ua Y3KOM KJIbIKe
(pHC. 1, 3). 06e rO.TIORKII peaJIIICTlIqHbI,
HX BbIpa3lITeJIbHOCTb He lIplIHeceHa B
iI\epTRY <popMe. TboopameHlIe JIOCH
lie 'IYiI\;(O caRpO laTClw IY IICKYCCTBY
II BCTpeqaeTCH B KOMn.TIeKCaX 1I3 Kypra-
HOB IOmHoro TIplIypa:lbH.
MOTIIB caHrn 1I3BeCTCII B ,a;peBHOCTH'C
fopnoro AJITaH H MnlI 'cIIHcKoro ORPY-
ra . B naMHTHIIKax CI\II<po-caBpoMaT-
CKoro Kpyra OH RCU:JBCCTeH. TI03TOMY
1I300pameHHe rO.TOBbl canrn Ha npe,a;-
IIJleqbe O.TeHH (pne. I. J) nel'bMa npn-
Me'IaTe.TLUO.
yh u:JoopameHIIII I;OIlLITlibIX HalI-
OOJIbnmll IIHTepec rrIH'.lCTI1 B.THeT «plIry-
pa OJIeHH B cpe.THcn 'laCTJI Oo.TIbillOrO
I\JJbma. B no,a;ooIlon IIO:\C. co cBoe06pa3-
HbIM H3fliOOM lIepe;lHeii qaCTII II YCIIJIe-
HHeM rrpe.\llI.Te'If,H rO:JOBKOH rpH«p oHa
nOKa3aH O.lljJHb na IllBL'C,THOM HaKOHe'I-
HJII>e HaileR \leq;1 II:! KypraHa y
c. Ypye-MapTaH Ha CpBepHOM KaBKa-
3e 8. TIPO<pII.TbHoe ILwiipaa\eHHe 3BepH
e orrym:eHHOH ,a;o Cil lOiI W'!JIII rOJIOBOH
BCTpeqaeTCH Ha IlOIlI'II},IX KpIOqRaX,
O;TlIIIIKax, HaBepIIJIIHX J,l1HmaJIOB Ha
,I:(OHY, B CHOHplI II TIpnKaMbe 9, no
BO.TIiRCKOe II RaBKa:JCKoe, 1I300pamenmi
O.'leHH OTJIlIqaIOTCH OT Hnx 60JJbIIIeli
ail\ypHOCTbIO, IlRon CTII.1I1CTWICCKOii
TpaKTOBKOll, He CBOllcTBeHHolI II na IHT-
HHKaM CKII«pCRoro I1CKYCCTBa. O,a;IIIWKO-
BaH KOMn03HD;HH, OT,a;eJIbHbIe CTII.'IlICTII-
qeCKHe npHeMbI OOOIIX OJIeHeii: eru;e pa3
yoe,a;IITeJIbHO rOBopHT 0 B:JaIIMOCBH3HX
H B3alIMOBJIlIHHHHX HaCeJIeHIIH CaBpo-
MaTIIH H CeBepHoro KaBKa3a B CKIl<p-
CKoe BpeMH.
M300pail\eHlIH XIIru;HbIX 3Bepell Hit
HOBOnpIIBOJIbHeHCKnx npe,a;MeTax "eneI'
pa3Hooopa3HbI. M300pameHlIH rO.TOBbI
XHru;HHKa C pa3lIHYTOll naCTbIO B pa:3-
HbIX BaplIaHTax IllIIpOKO paCilpOCTpaHe-
HbI B naMHTHIIKax CKH«p0-ClI6npC!;or'.J
3BeplIHoro CTHJIH. Cpe,a;1I HOBonpIlRo.Th-
HeHCKIIX 1'OJIOBOK HeCKOJIbRO BbIIIa;:raeT
H3 ooru;ero Haoopa OJIHiliKa R BIIAe II IW-
IIJIbHOH rOJIOBKH hOIlla'IberO XlIll\llIl-
Ra - JIbBa (pHC. 3, 8). OHa OT.lII'IaeTCH
11 COCTaBOM MeTaJI.Ta. TaKlle OJJHlIIKII,
xapaKTepHbIe ,a;JJH \'1- V BB. AO II. :J..
GOJIee Bcero BCTpe'IaIOTCH Ha TeppIlTo-
pHII coocTBeHHo CKJI<p1I1I (C reJIa. il\y-
pOBKa, l.JlIrHpHHO, 30JIOTOIl 1\yprl1n) 10,
13 KepqeHCKOM HeKpolIo.TIe ". M3 O.TIb-
BHII 1I3BeCTHa «pop la ,a;JIH OT.'1I1BI'H lIO-
P;OOHbIX OJIHX 12. BIIiI;IIMO, lI3 KaKorO-TO
ceBepOnplIqepHOMOpcKoro pe lrc .Tell-
Horo D;eHTpa nona.TO JTO YKpamelIIIe
11 Ha oepera BOJIrlI.
BOJJee cBoe06pa:mbI lIilT" ii.T II !!Ie;;
(pHC. 3, 16), M300pamalOlI lIc B (IJilc .'!C-
maru;ero XJIru;HIIKa C RbITHIIY'fhl\llI .'1i1 rra-
Mll H nO.TomelIHoii lIa HHX rO.TOBOIO :me-
pH. Haxo,a;KII lIOII:06HblX lIO cxe"c YK-
pameHlIll e;:rIIHlIqHbI. BJJII:nme fip01130-
BbIe OJIHIllKII ObIJIU HaH ellbl R lIepBcnf
IIorpeoeHlI1I KypraHa 51 y C. CTa plIna
ACTpaxaHcKoll oo.TaCTn 13. TaI(J1p mC
npOHcxo,a;HT H 1I3 KypraHon B pl1iiOlIe
r. MaHKona ". B. D. TTTJI.10B. l1CC:IC:lO-
BaBIllHll cTaplID;KIIe KyprallbI. C'IIITilCT
HaH;(eHHbIe O.TIHIDhlI II30opa)J"'IJJlp !
CTHJIH30BaHHoro mlIBOTHoro cllepxy".
216
C JTIIM HeJIb3H eOrJIaCHTbCH. Ha 1I30-
opamellIlHX CTaplII KlIx n MallKOlIcKHX
ii.THilleR OTCYTCTBYIOT Ha,a; rJJa3aMH TOp-
'la11\lIe YlIIII. CxeMa 3BepH eru;e OOJIee
yrrporu;eHa, HemeJIII Ha HOBOnpIIBOJIb-
lIellCKOM npe,a;MeTe, HO 3TO Ta me TpaK-
TOBKa nplInaBIlle1'O K 3eMJJe xlIru;HllKa.
B IIII0M CTII.'Ie Bblpe3aH lIpHIIaBililIll:
" :JeM.'Ie 3Bepb B cepe,a;IIHe Y3Koro KJIbI-
I;a (pIIC. 1, 3). OH BeCbMa peaJIIICTlIqerr
n B HeM cpa3Y MomHO Y3HaTb Me,a;BeAH.
8TO 1I300pammme COJIIImaeTCH C H30-
6pameHHHMlI 3BepH Ha 30JIOTbIX OJIHIll-
Kax V B. ,a;o H. 3. II3 KypraHa 2 y
C. IIoKpoBKH B TIplIypaJIbe 16. OcooeH-
110 OJIlI3Ka OJIHillRa oOJIee KpYIIHoro
pa3Mepa.
B caBpoMaTcKoM CTHJIe 1I300pameTI
'le!];Be,a;b Ha npHMoyrOJIbHOH n.TIaCTlIne
C BepxlIen KaMbI. TaKoe 1I300pame1me.
IlHor,a;a ,a;Boll1lOe II TpoHHoe, IIOHBJIHeT-
ell B IIplIKaMbe B n03,a;HeaHaHblIHCKoe
BpeMH 17. BepoHTHo, caBpoMaTcKali
TpaKToBKa Me,a;Bep;H ObIJJa n03aIIMCTRO-
BaHa aHalIblIHl\aMII II B IIHOM o<popMJIe-
!tUII npncnOCOOJJeHa K cyru;ecTBYIOru;eM '
y HIIX KYJJbTY Me,a;Be)1H.
fOJIOBa 3BepH B <pac lIMe eTCH H Ha
O:IHIIIKHX COOCTllellHO CKII«pIIH, HaIlpII"
\fep, lIa 30JJOTbIX OJIHiliKaX 1I3 l.JHrlIpIIH-
ChHX KypraHoB, Ha KaoaHbeM KJIbIKe II:!
H ueBCKoro HCTOplIqeCKo1'O MY3eH, H30-
opameHlIe IIa IWTOpOM TaKme CBH3aHO
C l\pyroM aHaIlbHHCKIIX IIaMHTHlI1\OB B
Me,a;BeAb 1I10opama.TICH caBpO laTaMIl
He TOJIbKO R <pac. ABe napHbIe O.TIHIIIKl1
(pIIC. 3. 1) nOKa3blBaIOT 3Toro 3BepH B
rro.TIHblll pOCT. 1I300paiI\eHIIe O'IeRb
I\OMnaRTHO II eoxpaHHeT pH,a; 'IepT.
CBoHcTBeHHblx eBpa3HHcKoMY 3Repn-
HOMY CTIIJIIO. AHaJIOrJI'IHbIe OpOH30BLIe
ii.THiliKII B BH)]C CTOHru;HX 3Bepell, Harro-
""HaIOIIJIIX !C)1Rell:ell. ObIJIII HallAelIhI
B. TI. IllII.TIOBbBl Ha ACTpaxarrm:IIHe R
CTaplIuhoM K 'praHe 19. Cxe Ia :mepH.
TpahTOBKa OT;le.TbHbIX ;:reTa.'Ieft <PHrYPbl
CXO;:J,Hbl C H306pameHlIHMlI HOROlIpII-
BOJIbHeHCKHX ,re,a;Be,a;en. OqeHb OJiII1-
217
KOll H306paIReHHHM na rrOBOJIIRCKHX
6JIHllIKaX HB.1HeTCH «pHrypKa CTOHll\ero
MeABep;H Ha I1aBepllIHH 6pOH30BOrO 3ep-
KaJIa H3 CJIY'IallHOll HaXOp;RH B Maii:-
KOnCROM pallOHe, ony6JIHKOBaHIIoro
K. <1>. CMHpHOBbIM 20, ROTOpblH OTMe'la-
eT op;HHaKOBYID TpaKTOBRY Mep;BelRbHX
JIan Ha CTapH KHX H MallKonCKHX 3K-
aeMrrJIHpax.
HOBonpHBoJIbHeHcRHe Haxop;RH npep;-
CTaBJIHIDT opHrHHaJIbHbIll: H caM06blT-
Hblll: ROMnJIeRC caBpoMaTcRoro HCRYC-
CTBa B KOCTH H MeTaJIJIe KOH a VI-
I B. Grakov. Monuments de la culture scy-
thique entre Ie Volga et les aural. ESA
IV. Helsinki, 1929. '
2 C. C. TJCPH.Ul>06. 3araAKa 30JIOTOrO KYP-
raHa. M., 1965, CTp. 34-35, Ta6JI. XVII.
3 C. H. PYOCH.l>O. KYJIbTypa HaCeJIeHUH
eHTpaJIbHOrO AJITali B CKu<pCKoe BpeMH.
M.- J1., 1960, CTp. 51, pUC. 270.
· M. H. ApTaMOH.06. COKpoBH a CKU<pCI\IlX
KypraHoB. IIpara - J1., 1966, Ta6JI. 329.
TaM me, TaOJI. 93; G. Borovka. Scythian
Art. London, 1928, tabl. XVII.
6 C. H. 3aMRTH.UH.. CKU<PCKU" MOrUJIbHlII;
«'IacTble KypraHbI* nOA BopoHemeM. CA,
VIII, 1946, CTp. 32, pilC. 19, 2; CTp. 44,
pUc. 35.
7 C. H. PyoeH.l>O. YKa3. COq., CTp. 270.
6 B. B. BUH.Oepaoo6. CapMaTbI CeBepo-Bo-
CTOqHOrO KaBKa3a. Tp. 'IHHHH, T. VI.
fP03HbIR, 1963, puc. 7, 1.
9 C. H. 3aMSlT1tlw. Y"a3. COq. (puc. 2, 2; H.
1-4); A. B. 36pye6a. HCTOpll1! UaCCJIl'III1H
IIpllKaMbH B anaHbuHCKYIO JIIOXY. MHA.
30, 1952, Ta6JI. XXVI, 6, 13; Ta6JI. XXIX,
8; C. B. KuceAe6. ApeBHHH IICTOpll1! lOa;
HOR CH6npH. M., 1951, Ta6JI. XXV, 2, 3.
nepnOll rrOJIOBHllbl V BB. P;O H. 3. BeCbMa
XilpilRTepHO, qTO BCe H306paIReHHH ne-
peAalOT OAHIIO'lHblH 06pa3. 3AeCb HeT
Cl.\ell OOpbObl, CXBaTKH IRUBOTHbIX.
B lIeROTOpblX ROMrr03H HHX ell\e '1YBCT-
BY IOTCH rrpH3HaKH H npHeMbl paHHerO
:IBCpnIlOrO CTIIJIH II B TO IRe BpeMH no-
HB.1HIDTCH '1epTbl B03p;ell:CTBHH BHemHHX
E;:IHHIIHii:, HAYll\HX He H3 op;Horo, a H3
HeCKOJIbRHX pa3JIH'IHblX pall:OHOB,-
n pHypaJIbH, KaBKa3a H OT'IaCTH rpe'le-
CKIIX eIlTpOB CeBeplloro ITplI'IepHO-
lOpbH.
10 .If. H. ApTaMOH.06. YRa3. COq., pUC. 73, 81j
G. Borovka. Op. cit., tab!. XVI, b, C.
11 G. Borovka. Op. cit., tab!. XVI, d.
" B. B. <PapMa1>06Clwii. ApXaU'IeCKH" ne-
pUOA B POCCIIU. MAP, oM 34, 1914, CTp. 31,
pllC. 8; M. Ebcrt. Ausgrabungen auf dem
Gute Maritzyn PZ, V. Berlin - Leipzig,
1913, S. 9, Abb. 6.
\3 ApXUB I1A AH CCCP, A. 2380a, JI. 23.
" K. <P. CMUPH.06. CaBpoMaTbi. M., 1964,
pllC. 81, 3.
" OTqel B. II. illUJIOBa 3a 1961 r. APXUB HA
AH CCCP, A. 2380, JI. 144.
,. .If. H. POCT06IfC6. KypraHHble HaXOAKU
OpeH6yprcKoR 06JIaCTH 3IIOXU paHHero II
1I03AHero 3JIJIIIHII3Ma. MAP, oM 37, 1918,
CTp. 21-22.
11 A. B. 36pye6a. YKa3. COq., Ta6JI. XXXI,
12; A. A. CnUlfblH.. fJIHAeHOBcKoe KOCTII-
e. 3PAO, XII, 1-2. CII6., 1901, CTp. 242.
!8 J. B. n1>06en1>O. KnbIKIl C 300}IOplpHblM\t
lI:wopamellUI!MlI. CA, 1 \169, oM 4, CTp. 202-
203, puc. 1, 4.
" APXIIB HA AH CCCP, A. 2380a, JI. 23.
" K. <P. CMupno6. YKa3. COq., pUC. 81, 4.
M. A. ,l];3BJIeT
o IIPOI1CXOlli,I(EHI1I1 MI1HYCI1HCKMX AmYPHbIX
nOHCHbIX IIJIACTI1H
IT poo.le la 1I03P;HHX cyp;eo 3BepHHO-
TO CTH.'1H Ha BOCTOqHOll nepH«pepHH ero
apeaJIa ReOAHORpaTHO oocYlRl\aJIaCb B
HaY'IHOii .1llTepaType H Bbl3blBaJIa ca-
Mble pa3.11I'IUble cyIRAeHHH. OP;HH H3
BonpOCOB. BCTaIDll\HX npH paCCMOTpe-
IIIIU 3TOlI rrp06.1eMbl - Bonpoc 0 rrpo-
HCXOIRAemIH CHOHpCKHX 6pOH30BblX
nOHCHblX IwaCTIIH. AlRypHble 6JIHXH C
1I306pameHHHMll IRHBOTHbIX B npHMO-
yrOJIblIOll pa IKe B ROH e npOIlIJIoro
CTOJI8THH lIa PHP;Y C npO'lHMH xyp;o-
lReCTBeHRblMll MHHyCIIHCRIIMH opOH3a-
MH H;i c.lyqaii:llblx lIaxop;OK pa30llIJIlICb
no PHP;Y PYCCRUX H 3apy6eIRHblx MY3e-
en H qaCTllblX c06paHHll:. HecKoJIbKO
aK3CMrr.1HpOB lIJIaCTIIH 6bIJIH ony6JIH-
KOBaHhl B 189:1 r. B aJIb60Me <1>. Map-
THHa '.
ITpHCTa.lhlloe BHIIMaHHe R CHOHp.
CKHM amypTlblM 6JI1IXaM B 3apy6elRHOll:
.JIIITCpa Type 6bl.10 npHHJIe'leHO B 20-
30-x rr. TeRywero CTOJIeTHH B CBH3H C
HaXOAKa 1ll II Opp;oce.
XYAoiheCTllcllllble 6POH3bl, npoHcxo-
,D;Hll\He In c.-1 ''Iai'IHbIX HaXOAOR H rpa-
6I1TeJIbCKITX pacRonoK MOrHJIbHHKOB B
paii:olle Op:1Oca B 20-x fr., XJIblRYJIH Ha
aHTHKBa pHble enporrellCKHe pbIIIKH H
HaBOI\HII.1H !IX. BnIl I3HHe apxeOJIOrOB-
nOCTORORe;rOB lIpIlB.leR «paKT OJIH30CTH
xyl\OmeCTReHHbIX H3JJ;eJIHll: H3 OpAoca
1'1 lOmlJOl1 CnollpH. OAHaRO MIIHYCHH-
CKHe 6POH:\I,1 OhlJIH IT3BeCTHbI 3apyoem-
HblM :"1('111>'" IIpeIIMy ecTBeHHo no
nyo.'IliJ;81IIIH\1 B a.'1bOOMe <1>. MapTlIRa.
PilCyliKH H3 aToro aJIbOOMa ):\0 CHX rrop
neperre'laTblBaIDTcH Ha cTpaHH ax ;\a-
pyoelRHblx H3p;aHHH.
B 1929 r. aCCHCTeHT MY3eH BOCTOq-
HOI'O HCRyccTBa B Ke.'1hlle AJIb«ppe):\
Ca.lbMoHH, H3BecTlIblH 3HaTOK op;lOC-
CRHX p;peBHOCTell:, rrOCeTHJI HallIH l.\CHT-
paJIbHbIe H cH6HpCKHe MY3eu. PC:Jy:lb-
TaTOM aToll: noe31\RH HBHJIaCb CTaTbR
« M HHycHHcKHe 0 pOH30Bble rr.la CTII IIbI»)'
ITo MHeHHID A. CaJIbMOIIH, «B C03):\il1I1III
«pOpM, npHHHTblX Ha cenepllOM pyocme
0pl\Oca H npOHHRHYBIIIHX p;o BHYTpeH-
Hero KHTaH, 60JIbmYID pO.Tlb Cbl rpa.1II
«pOpMbI BepXOBbeB EHHceR». On TlO.la-
raJI, 'ITO alRypHble 6JIHXH, 3a IfCIOIID<Je-
HHeM nJIaCTHHbl C ApaRonml. 3aIDlCT-
BOBaIlbI Opp;oCCRHMn n.'1eMClIa IH y ihlI-
TeJIell: MHHYCHHCKOll: KOTJIOBIlllbI. floJJ;-
'IepRHBaH 3Ha'leHHe MHHyCHHCRIIX
MaTepHaJIOB ):\JIH pellIeHHH ROllpoca 0
B3aHMOOTHomeHHII CHOHpCRHX II Op,lOC-
CRUX n.'1eMeH, A. Ca.lhMOHIf OTMC'Ia.'I,
'1TO <!IIOJIe3HO 6blJIO ObI c06pan, HX
(IIJIaCTHHbI.- M. .) BMeCTP, 110 :)Ta
3aga'la HeJIerRaH, TaK KaK 13 T('<Jelllle
AeCHTHJIeTIIH MHorne Y'lpemJ,cIIJlH no-
JI)"IaJIH MaTepHaJlbl 11;\ MIIII TI'IICJ;a.
He Bce MY3eII Cnonpn. a Tai';Kl' '1 'leIl,
H I8ID He CII6npcRHe laTepIHllhl. JIle
H3BeCTHbI. Kpo le TOro, Mile He Jlinpc-
IIIHJIH «pOTorpa«pHpOBaTb B IY:H'" TOM-
CKoro YHHBepcHTeTa. 1I03Tm: ' IllIihe-
c.le):\YIDll\Hll: 0030P He lOn;eT 111"'TeH-
AOBaTb Ha nOJIHOTY'",
Pa60Ta A. CaJIbMORII 11.0 eTl' IIOp OC-
219
T<leTCH l'J\1I II CT lie II II bBI r 1Il'1(1Ii1."II,IILBI
HCCJICp;IIIII\I1l1eM. IIOCllflIlH'I1I1LDI n"H IO-
yroJII,IIbIM J1.TIaCTIIIII\M.
HORbIC lIaXO;\KII 01'0H.iOIJLJ:\ U:IJIX 1\
MorlI.1JhHbIX [,O!oIfl:Il'KCaX 11<1 Cpe IIC [
EnlIcee n.t paCIWIIOI, 1-\I'i\CIIOHPCIWll
3RCIIe,');I1l(HIi. nil Bepxm:m Enncee 3 II
B 3a6aiiIm:n,e '. a TI\Kme B COCTaRe Ko-
corO.'IbCIWrO Ima;Ia B Ymypn';O)I paiiorrc
KpacuoHpcKoro RpaH' :taCTaB:IHIOT
BHOBb BepIIYTbcH 1\ II\: pacoloTpeHlIIo.
Ha1t1II 6bI.1H c e.lalla IIOIIblT"iI rro 00.1-
MOH(HOCTII nO:IHO Y'IeCTh n.lf1CTnHbI JI:1
IY3eiiIIbIx c06pannn lIameii cTpaHbl,
BbIHBIITb no :II1TepHType \lflTcplla.'IbI,
XpaHH IJCCH II JapyueilmLlx IYJCHX.
cHcTeMaTIIJlIpOBI\Tb II ;J:ITilpORaTh II\:.
-
. .
,.
I
......
.,
....
.....
"
PIlC. 2. BJtRXU (' Sepll.ltlOda Nil Ii .lowadb.U'£
n P;Jf("('6D.fbCKOZO:
/-.1 - Opnoc; 4 - c. !>.I,IM; 5 - OP:IOC; 6_
.", l)C'iic-.me; 7-8 - :\fIlH}"CIIHCHUfi ORP}T; 1-J-
("OUP:1HIIP ."y: 4 - ::\lnlr}TIUICHllii M}3ei1: .5 - CO(j-
IlaHne ;:(aunn-neli.lb; 6-7 - roc. :-'p..UIT3H<; B-
JI}"3t"ii HapOADoro IICI<}C(TIJ.il (l'a n)}'pr)
PUC. 1. BJlRXU C 6blKDMU:
1 - Op:IOC; 2 - C. A15aKaHCI<oe; 3 - R)'3HeIlKHIt
ol<pyr; 1 - co15paHHe XeIlJl.Ta; 2-3 - TOMCKHB
roc. }HIIHepcHTeT
.-
-..- -
.
- \'.
\.
l'
-
..-
.....
\\ \
\.\. :\.1)
....
"'
..
-
.
-
...
-
...
220
PIlC.:!
II
. .
. .
/ ,." t
, ' " ,...
- r\:\
\ .
-
J
,
" . -
:- ' -.:
. ,
-'- (t-
.
\
\ ....
2
---
-
r
.....
:
\
-
.
..
...
..--
i.
3
-
.---
.
---
-- -
"'
:....,.:....- ..
-..
----.,...
'02 p.z-
...
.
3
. . , . .. .... (' ....
. .
.
. .. )
.
.
. . ......
"\
I '"
" .
. . .'
.
t"".
'
4
1..
. .,.
>;
, \
...
...-J
.f. .' t-
--
,
\
1''''.. J
Pile. 3. EARXU eo ellel/Oll 60pb6b1 Ky..aIl06 Ii
rUlp06 eo 3....ee..w:
I. 4 - Opl\oe; 2 - 1\. OaBa.;ell"aR; 8 - e. llIy-
rnenCltOe; .5 - II. Bepern; 6 - :\htH)TI1HCl-mn OK-
I'yr; 1 - 0pl\oe; 8 - l\IHIIYCII"CKHft oKpyr; 1-
eo15palille Jly; 4 - e06pallHe ,l{amu-Beft:lb; 2-8-
foe. 3pMHTaHl; 11- TOMeKHft foe. }""BepeHTeT;
6 - foe. UCTOpH'IeCKHft ",y3eft; 1 - e06paHHe
JIy; 8 - roc. 3pMHTaHl
r . ' I<t:I' - ·
- ..... ....
. .+---".' -..
"
"'j.. .A\'
" - #
iL'j _ -:t:- _-: d1
,
· I
,,- ...,
1 . ':
, -,.
..
,t ,;.# ._",
..
... . "
'"" - ,.......
oJ
T
Pue. 4. EARXU eo 3MeJ<.MU:
1 - Opl\oe; 2 - 1\. l\oKopeBa; 8 -1\. ChI:!a; 1-
eo15paBHe ,l{aBBI\-Bel!nb; 2 - roc. UCTOpH'IeeKH!i
>lY3eD; 8 - roc. 3PNHTBHI
,'" - ,
. , ..... - ...
.. "-
. ,.
. .. ..
.
- .,
',. , ,
.
, _....8 ..
- - - . , . .
- ...".
5
..
.... -,
. .
" I
J
"
oJ' ..;
-, -....- .
I>
"'....
..
... ... ,
I ....
.
. ",' . ., , l
, ---
." - .
-
'"--- --- II
Pue. 5. EARXU e 2eo.\lerpU'4eCKOIl pemerKoi1:
1 - Opl\oe; 2-8 -IIIHByeHBeKHft OKp}r; 1-
C06paBBe XeAI\TB; 2-8 - BeBrepClmft HallHo-
HanbBhll! MY3eA
"'
- - ,
"
" \
'10
4
2
-'- -'
....
3
a TalORe onpC;:J.C.'IIITb Ii" !>ICCTO Cpl';{11
ana.'iOrll'lllbIX lUll O,l{1I0TIInllbIX API'B-
HOCTClI Hcero apea.'1a. BCl'ro IIa!>111 Y'I-
TellO CBLIlile 80 n:laCTlln, xpaHHmllX-
CH B 6 COBCTCKHX H 2 aapy6emHLIX
AlY3eHx.
Cpc,!{1I MnUYCHIICKHX npHl\fOyrO:lb-
HbIX BmyplibIX IIpnmeK no ClOmeTY
!>wmno BLI,!{e.'lHTb c.'iell:YIOIJ Jle: n:mc-
THHbI C H306pameHHeM napLi npOTnBO-
CTOHmnx mnBOTHLIX - 6L1KOB (pHC. t),
Bep6JIIOAOB (pHC. 2, 1-4). KOHCii
(pnc. 2, 5-8). nJIaCTRHLI co CI1,CHB\1lI
50pL6bI ,l{BYX KYJIBHOB (pRC. 3, 1-6)
UJIH ,l{BYX KOma'lLHX XHII1,HllKOB co 3MC-
eM (pHC. 3, 7-8); IIJIaCTnHLI C pemeT-
'laTLIM opHaMeHToM - BOJIHHCTbIM (n:l-
1
,
"
\, t j J . ;
'.
L
t
. ......
,
-
-
-
-
-
. -..... -....
L.
,
..
J,
...
-.... - - ;;::.' -
-
-
2
- .;..:... '!t\o.
..,. -
'.
...
J._
A-
T
-
A .... _:.: :£:, ..:....... ,.
3
223
JIIIBalO IIeCH 3MeH) (pIIC. 4) HnH reo
ICTpl1.'IeCKIIM (BnHcaHlIbIC B paMKY
.'IOMalJ fe nIIHIIII) (pIlC. 5). EnHxH C
H306paif\eBIIHI\1H UpOTIIBOCTOH HX HKOB
H:JBeCTBbI H3 IOmBoll Cnoopo B Kono-
'leCTBe 15 ,m3eMUJIHpOB 8: 14 npoocxo-
;:tHT I13 MOHYCOHCKOii: KOTJIOBOHbI, op;-
Ha - 03 !{y;meQKoro oKpyra TOMCKOii
ry6epHOO. HMeeTCH TOJIbKO op;Ha 6JIHXa
C «ImrYPKaMO npOToBOCTOH OX Bep6nlO
.10B '. Bmlxo C «porypKaMII npOTHBo-
CTORIl\IIX JIOmap;Cll flpmCR3.'ILCKOrO 03-
PUC. 6. E.JI.RIU C iJyzoo6pa3HblM 3aeepr.ue-
HueM OiJHOU U3 CTOpOH:
1-2 - II. MapbRCOBa; 3 - C. Afiallanclloe; 1-3-
MIIRYCIIHCIIHfI MYBeft
, ;
",
..
--L--..J
'Y
. . .
...
..
.(.
e)
d
c.
,J
BCCTHbl n TpCX ;)1i.IC mJHlpilX 8. B:unH
C 1I:\IIi"il'ailil'IIIII' 1 OOphULI KY:laIiO/! 1101
Ellllcpe IIi\C'IIITbIBaIOTCH D KOJIH'IeCTne
12 ,Hi;le m.1HJlOB 9. IIJI3CTIIHa co cQeBoR
001'1,01.1 KOWa'lberO xII BIIKa co 3MceM
IIJIII ;:tpaKoHml TO.1bKO op;lla, npO'IeM
npe;:tCTIlBJIena «pparMeHTOM (JIeBaH no-
.10BIIH3 nJIaCTOHbI). flnaCTIIHbI C pe-
meTlWll n3 BOJIHIICTbIX JIHHIIll, 06pa30-
na IIlIhlX lI:mIlBalO IIMIICH TYJIOBII aMO
'IeThIpl'X 3 Ien, HaC'IIITbIBaIOTCH B KO-
,111'leCTBI' 14 ,m:ieMnJIHpOB 10.
H:lBeCTHO 12 aK3eMnJIHpOB npHMo-
yro.1hHblX nJIaCTOH C reOMeTplI'IeCKIIM
OpmL\It'HTO 1 ".
Ha PHP;Y C npHMoyrOJIbHbIMH amyp-
UblMII n.laCTIIHaMII K 3TOMY KPYry IIa-
IHTIIIIKOB lbI OTnOCIiM nJIaCTIIHbI C
;:tyrooopa3HbIM 3aBepmeHIIeM OP;BOH
cToponbI (pHC. 6).
fll'Pl'XOP;HYIO «POpMY Mem]\y 3TIIMII
rpynrra 1II npep;CTaBJIHIOT nJIaCTHHa C
amypliLIM opHaMeBTOM H3 nOMaBbIX Jm-
HlIll. 8rrIIcaHHbIX B paMKY, op;Ha 03 CTO-
pOll IWTOpOH o«popMJIeHa B BIlp;e YCTyn-
'1IIIWB n.'lT! :IeceHOR.
TI.liU'TrIll!.l C p;yro06pa:HIbiM 3aBep-
IlICIlIlf>\I OP;HOR H3 CTOpOB H reOMeTpn-
IjCl'RI1 1 opnaMeHTOM, COCTaBJIeHHbIM 03
BlIlICallll!.lX B paMKY JIOMaHLlX JIHHIIH,
n3/!el'THLI B KOJIH'IeCTBe P;BYX 3K3eMn
.1HpOR.
Cpe:ur n:13CTIIH C p;yro06pa3HbIM 3a-
/!epmCHIIeM OAHOR 03 CTOpOH B He60JIb-
1lI0\l 'I\IC:Ie BCTpe'IeHI.l IIJIaCTIIHbI C
II306pilHiPBIIeM mliBoTHoro, 3Meerrop;06-
HOl' l'ill'II.1.al'TaHBoe Ty;lOnmnc KOTOpO-
ro l'llepUYTO B ROJIbIJ;O BOI<pyr rOJIOBbI,
.1 .1ilTt'\I. rreTJIe06pa3HO II:lnITRaHCb, IIe-
p('XII.IIIT B "{BOCT ". RO lIIo:mQI!H O'IeHb
C:IO;liIlaR 0 Bbl'IypHaH, nOHRTHaH Be BO
IIl'f>" (PTa:fRX.
1 ""'fOTC, nJIaCTIIBbI, rAe 1i306pame-
11.1 TI '.1 !oKO rOJIOBa mIIBoTHoro, TynoBII-
11[1' "I "YTcTByeT, IIJIH me R.106pameImo
;.j,I1I1C1TIIOro Qe:roKOM IIOMeUleHo B paM-
I.y. "IIII'JC I TynoBIIlIIe npe:n;CTaBJIeHO
H 1I1',,,jlll.lb. a roJIOBa B ljJac.
2 ')'
--!
h n.;IaCTlllla 1 ;ITUll rpyullbi c.1.CA)'eT
OTHl'CTII Tal,me U.1HXY C aFKypnhiM 030-
6paa;CIlIICM p;paliOlia C onYll\enHOll ro-
.rrOBOll, KaCaIOll\eiir H nITiKIICii 'l3CTn
pal\llill, II 3aRIInYTLI 1 Ja CIIIIllY XBOCTOM,
CJIIlBalOIJ:{IIMCH C lIepxlleii 'IaCTLIO paM-
KH 13. B031\wmuo, 'ITO n03p;Heuwn.MII
pemIHRal\m aToro I1:1UOpamelIlIH HBJIH-
IOTCH 6.1.HXll, IIa o;mOll n3 ROTOpbIX, ;III-
llleHlroii npope;leii. C 06paM_'lCHlIe 1 II3
pHJ{a 6yropROB 110 };palO, npep;cTaBneH
3Bepb, AO;ImI\O GLITL, n3 cel\leiicTBa KO-
lIIa'IbIIX, C onYllI.clIHoii ro."lOBOH n 3aKII-
HYTLlM 3a cmm)" XBOCTOM ", Ha
p;pyroii - rrpopc3noii - 3Bepb C nop;-
HHTon ro.:IOBOII If 3aruYTI.lM neTJIeH
XBOCTOM.
B IICTOpOII C KIIlllo-ClI6lipcKoro IICRYC-
CTBa npHHiKIl B- II P-06pa3HI.lX o'Iep-
TaHlll1 xpono:rorU'IeCKIl IIpep;wecTBYloT
aaCTemKaM 'IeTLlpCX)TOJIbBOR «pOpMbI ".
Apca.1bl IIX, O'lcnIl.11l0, lIe COBllap;aIOT.
Ha Cpcp;IIe),I EUlIcec OTCYTCTBYIOT 3a-
cTeffiKII, alIa.1.0nI'IIlLIe c06paBHbIM B
RO.:I::JeRl\HII TIc'rpa I.
EPOII:108bl(' a;li)"pliblC npHmKn nony-
'lIIJIII pacrrpOCTpalll'nIIe na Cpep;BeM
EHncee B [I [ I nB. p;o n. a.. 0 'ICM
CBIT.1CTe:lbCTnYI'T Ha:m'mc p;aTllpyIO-
I1 llX BeU\eU B cunanc Kocoro.1.bCKOrO
1i:I3.13, a Ta limc IIaXo:n;KH 06.1.OMKnB
II.1.aCTlIll B noqll'i"ia.lbnbiX KOMn:leKcax.
AaTllpOBlm lIIl1ycIIllclarx n.laCTlIn
rrOC:IC;J.I1il 1ll 11l''',L\1II ncpBoro TblCH-
'Ie:IeTIIH ao II. ;). cor.rlacyeTcH C XpO-
nOJIOrIl'ICClm 1 onpC.1eJIeBHeM .Ja6aii
IH\1'I.Clmx II l'l'l1l'pOIiTI"fi\llCIUIX npH-
iKCR '8.
R 11a IHTI"II;a\ panrrcii IT cpcAneii
nopLI Tarapl'l,oii l;y.1.LTypbI MbI BC lIa-
XOP;II I rrpoToTIIIIOB aiKypHbIM 6.1HxaM.
Onll IIOHlln:....... I1a Cpep;Bel\1 EHlll'ee
Bfle3arruo n lIoc.lc.1neii 'IeTBepTII nep-
Boro TbICR'1l'.II'rlifi .10 B. a. H reHeTII-
'IeCKII HI' l'l\lIlilllhl C TarapCKHM 3Bepll-
Hbl 1 CTlI.'If>\I
MO.1e:IH 1l\ f,a Ii .1.1.H MIIHYCIIHCKHX,
TaR II .lA .I"i"iarrliaJILCKIlX n.laCTIlH
8 - Ct-:nq,o-nlf.u;.. 1.lIn 3BepHRbfI CTH.'-lh
Mor;1II llOCJIymIITb G.:IHXII, IIPOIICXOWl-
I1 IIC II3 paiiona OpAoca llJIn IiaIiUll-TO
apXl'lJ.;lOrn'IeCKII IIC n3BeCTlloii HaM
npOl\lCiKYTOtIlIoii TeppUTopIIll. Ib Up-
p;oca n BnYTpeHHeii MOHrollilIl npOIIC-
XOAIIT GOJIblIIaH cepllH G.aHX, ana.10fU'l-
IIbiX c1I6npCKHM, BO C GOJIec 'ICTRO
npopaOOTaHlIbIMH AeTaJIHMlI, B 'laCTUO-
CTII, apxaWlIIhIM JIrrCTOBIlp;UbIM oopa l-
.1.eBneM. HeKOTopbIe p;eTaJIll H3 IIIBY-
CIIHCRUx U:IaCTHHax Mbl MomeM pacIIo-
3HaTb .'IIIlllb IIPH cpaBHeIIlI1I IlX C op-
P;OCClillMIl, II306pameHOH Ha KOTOpbIX,
KaK rrpaBIIJIO, 3Ba'IIITeJIbHO 'leT'le II
HCHee.
OT."lIIBKa amypBLIX 6::JH"{ rrpOIl3B0.1U-
:raCb B rJIHHHHbIX «popMax C ynoTpe6-
.IeHneM B Ka'IeCTBe MOp;eJIell yme roTO-
BbiX 03p;emm. 10. C. fPOlIIIIH, B03pa-
maH rrpOTIlB MHeBHH 0 TOM, 'ITO OJIIlXil
OTJIIIBaJIOCb B OP;HHX 0 Tex me «popMax,
na npIIMepe npHMoyroJIbBI.lX 6.1H II
BHAe napbl CTOfl rrx 6bII\OB IIORa3a:l,
'1TO npII Cxo:n;CTBe p;aiKe MCJ.lb'IallllIllX
p;eTaJIeii y Kamp;oii: II:IaCTInn.I lOihllO
Ha6JIIOp;aTb pa3JIH'IIIYlO CTCIIeHb IIX
BbIpameHBOCTH: y 0AHIIX anI ;1cra:1II
BLIcTynalOT 60JIce OT'leTJIi.IIIO, ) ; pY-
nn.. - Me Bee, a y TpeTMIX Bl,lr.lIUHT
Ral< 6I.l COBceM CMa3aHnbiMil n .
flpep;CTaBJIHeTCH, 'ITO 00pa3QO\l ;J..lfl
OTJIO/!KIl C06IIpCKliX opon30BbiX 3 1l'1I-
HbIX nJIaCTIlII, CIIJIbiiO nepcpaUOTim
HbIM H nOTcpHBUln 1 rrepBOHa'ra.1Lllblii
peaJIH3M 0306pameH1IH, Mor.1.a C:IY-
mHTb Opp;OCCKafi 6JIHXa 11.1 1i0.l.lel\l1l111
Aaml'{-BeiiJIb (pHC. 6, 1). OOlJ\lIe
O'iepTanHJl MIIBYCIIHCIiOii n Op.1oCl"I,nii
GJIHX CXOp;HhI. B OT.1.II'lIle OT erri"iIlPI lill
ro BapIIaHTa rr."laCTIlIJ, fJ\P .IIII".I.!III
06pa3Bo II3BIIBaIOIQIICCH Ty.lIl1l1lI1lil 'II'
TI.lpeX 3Meii pac nO::JOilie II hI /! p;nllol' II
tIeTLlpe pHlI,a, na opJ{ncl'''oli ".111 \4'
npep;CTaB:IeBbl .1Mell, IIonapHO n"IIf'-
BHBlIIHeCH Mem:n;r c060H. Y RiI;l, loi',
napbI mOBOTHbiX rO:IOBLI II XIII."TLI
nanpaBnelffiI B npoTilBono.loiHllI.... ,'rn
pOHbI, Torp;a KaR Ha MIIHYCIlIII'I;II\
225
06pa3D;ax 3MeHHhle rOJIOBbI JIII60 He
BbI,a;eJIeHbI, JllI60 HanpaBrreHhl Bce B
O,a;HY CTOp01I)'. ECJIH Ha crr6npCKIIX
6rriIxax H306pameHHiI 3Meil B pa3ROH
Mepe CTHJIH30BaHbI H opHaMeRTaJIbHbI,
TO Ha llJIaCTHHe H3 Op,a;oca pearrHCTlI'l-
Hhl H, nomaJIYll:, ,a;ame HaT)'pamrCTIPI-
Hhl. Tm;aTeJThRO npopa60TaHhI Y Kam-
,a;oro mHBOTROl'O roJIOBa, rJIa3a, XBOCT,
pHCynOK Ha Kome.
llo MHeRHIO 300JIOrOB, 3,a;eCb rrpe,a;-
CTaBJIeHa 3Mell Kpall:T ll3 Ce IeHCTBa
ra 1JbHX, BCTpe1JaIOlI\alICII B IOro-Bo-
CTO'lHOll: A3HH. :=ha 3MeH, KaK H ,a;PY-
me mHBOTHhle, H306pameHHbTe Ra nJIa-
CTlIHaX (HKH, KyrraHhl, )J.RKllH Bep-
5mop;), He 06HTaIOT B rrpe,a;eJIax MHHY-
CHHCKOR KOTJIOBIIHhl. mIIBOTHbIe,
H305pameHHhle Ha MHHYCIIHCI\IIX 6JIH-
xax, HBJIHIOTCH THIIlI'lHbIMH npe)J;CTaBH-
TeJIHMII lJIaYHhl BHYTpeHHell MOrrrOJIHH
H llYCThlHII Opp;OC IS.
B Opp;oce BCTPe1JeHbI He TOJIbKO
llJIaCTIIKhl, Haxo,a;Hm;He 6.'ll1manillHe
aHaJIOrIIII BceM MHHYCHHCKII ! rrpHMO-
yrOJIbHhlM nJIaCTHHaM, HO II BapIIaHThl,
HMeIOm;He CTHJIHCTH1JeCI{IIe rr CIomeT-
Hhle OTJlH1JIIH. R npHMepy, 6.1iIXII C
rrpOTHBOCTOHID;HMH Bep6rrIO;(a)fl! B
paROHe Opp;oca IIMeIOTCH B Tpex CTHJIH-
CTH'leCKH pa3JIlI'lHhlX BapllaHrax, rrpII-
'leM B ,a;BYX CJIY1JaHX l'OJIOBbI Bcp6JIIO-
P;OB 3a.u;paHbI KBepxy. MRoro'IlICJIeH-
Hhl nJIaCTHHhI C pa3JIH1JITbIMII rCOMeT-
plI'leCKHMH y30paMII.
IJ;eJIhlR pH,a; CIOmeTOB II KO lilo:mD;Hrr,
HaJllI1JeCTByIOm;IIX B Op,a;oce, Ha EHllcee
OTCYTCTByeT; 3,a;eCb HMeeTCH PH;( 6.TIHX
C rrapon mIlBOTHbIX, corroera B.lcnHbIX
1 F.-R. Martin. L'age du bronze all musee
de Minoussinsk. Stockholm, 1893.
2 A. Salmony. Le plaquettes de bronze de
Minoussinsk. «Gasette des bpa !Ix-arts».
Janvier, 1934. Paris, 1934, np. 2
8 jJ. r. Ca8UHo8. IIorpe6eHue c [,pOIl30BOll:
6JIHXOll: B eHTpaJIbIIOll: TYBe. KCllA, 119,
1969, cTp. 104-108.
cnHRaMH, rOJIOBhl KOTOphlX 06pam;eRbI
K 60KOB'bIM cTopOHaM pa]'IKH; BCTpe1Ja-
IOTCiI nJIaCTHHhl C napOll: IITHD; C nepe-
BIIThlMII illeiIMH H llOJIOmeHHhlMH Ha
cnIIRY rOJIOBaMH HJllI me C JIarrol!
mHBOTHoro B KJIIOBe H MRome IWyrHe.
RaK H3BecTHo, 60JIbillmICTBO BelI\eii
TaK Ha3hlBaeMon Op,a;OCCKOll: 6pOH3bl
HMeeT XYRHcKoe npOHcxom,a;eHHe 19 .
llo npHBe3eHRbIM C BOCTOKa 06pa3Il,aM
B IOmHOll: CH6HpH MeCTHhIe MaCTepa
OTJIHBaJIII no,a;o6Hhle llJIaCTHKhl. HpKllM
,a;OKa3aTeJIbCTBOM TOMY HBJIHeTCH Ra-
xo,a;Ka KJIa,a;a y o3epa BOJThillOll: Roco-
rOJIb B YmYPCKOM pall:OHe. llpHHa,a;-
JIemHOCTb lwa,a;a MacTepy-mrreRm;nKY
He Bhl3hlBaeT COMHeHHR, TaK KaK B ero
COCTaBe, HapH)J;Y C TaKHMH BhlCOKOXY,a;O-
meCTBeHHbIMH npOH3Bep;eHHHMH HCKYC-
CTBa, KaK amypHhIe 6JIHXH, HaXO,AllJIHCb
6POR30BbIe CJIHTKH, cTpymKa, nOJIO-
MaHHhle H3,a;eJIHH.
AHaJllI3 MeTaJIJIa eHHceHCKHx nrra-
CTmI npOH3Be,a;eH B JIa60paTopHH cneK-
TpaJIbHOl'O aHaJllI3a JIOMA C. C. MHHH-
eBhlM. OH rrpOaHaJllI3HpOBaJI TaKme XIl-
MH1JeCKHll: COCTaB 6JIHX H3 ]J;epecTyii-
cKoro MOmJIbHHKa B 3a6aHKaJIbe.
rYHHCKHe H3,a;eJllIH co,a;epmaT 3Ha'lH-
TeJIbJJyIO npHMeCb cBHHD;a, Tor,a;a KaK
B MHHYCHHCKOll: KOTJIOBHHe 6JIIIXH OT-
mrnaJIHCb H3 MhlillbHKOBHCTOll 6pOH-
3b1, O,IJ;HaKO no cOCTaBY MeTaJIJIa HeKO-
TopbIe Han,a;eHHbIe Ha EHHcee 6JIHXH
MomHO C1JHTaTb npHB03HbIMH. rYIIH-
cKHMII.
IIpoHHKHoBeHHe Op,a;OCCKHX 6JIHX H3
EHHceft MomHO CBH3b1BaTb C KOHTpO-
.1eM XYHRY Ha,a; STOll TeppHTopIIeii.
pUC. 16; B. M. <P. opuJicr;uu.. IIepB06b1T-
IIbIe CJIaBHHe no IIaMHTH}lKaM nx AOUCTO-
pUqeCKOU mII3HH, q. I I, Bbln. 2. TOMcK,
1897, pUC. 126; J. Strzygows i. .Altai-
Iran und volkerwanderung. LeIpzIg, 1917,
Abb. 178; G. Borovka. Scythian Art. Lon-
don, 1928, pI. 53 - A; M. Ro tovtzef!. !he
Animal Style in South RUSSIa and Chma.
Princeton, 1929, pl. XXVIII, 7; N. Fett ch.
Bronzeguss und Nomadenkunst. Skythika,
II. Prague, 1929, pl. XI, 8; A. Salmony.
YKa3. COq., pHC. 5, B. II. JIe8aUJ.08a. H3
AaJIeKOrO npOillJIOrO IOmHOll: qaCTII Kpac-
HOlIpCKoro KpaH. KpacHoHpcK, 1939, Ta6JI.
X 3' C. B. KUCeJle8. )].peBHHH IICTOpll1i
IDm OII ClI6lIpn. M., 1951, TaM. XXII, 1
(pHCYHOK nepeBepHYT); D. Carter. The
Symbol of the Beast. The Animal Style
Art of Eurasia. New York, 1957, pl. 10;
10. C. fPUULUJi. IIpOlI3BOACTBO B Tarap-
CKYIO :moxy. MilA, oM 90. M., 1960, pilC.
15; H. B. HaUfer;uH. YKa3. COq., CTp. 163-
165; «Scythian, Persian and Centr l Asian
Art from the Hermitage CollectIOn. Le-
ningrad», Tokyo - Kyoto, 1969, pilC. 71.
7 H. TO./tCTOU. II H. KOJiOar;o8. YKa3. COq.,
pllC. 78; F.-R. Martin. YKa3. COq., Ta6JI.
20-15; J. Strzygowski. YKa3. COq., pilC.
178, 15; A. Salmony. YKa3. COq., pnc. 9;
C. B. KuceAe8. 'YKa3. COq., Ta6JI. XXI, 16;
D. Carter. YKa3. COq., Ta6JI. 10.
8 K. httmar. Die Fruhen Steppenvolker.
Baden - Baden, 1964, S. 77.
9 «OTqeT HMnepaTopcr;oro POCCIIHCKoro UC-
TOpIl'IeCKOrO MY3eII B MOCKBe 3a 1915 r.»
M., 1916, pilC. 46; G. Borovka. YKa3. COq.,
Ta6JI. 53, 8; M. H. POCT06lfe6. CpeAHRHali
A3UII, POCCIIH, KnTall: II 3BeplIHblii CTIIJIb.
IIpara, 1929, Ta6JI. III, 8; A. Salmony.
YKa3. CO'l., pilC. 1. i5; C. B. KuceAe8.
YKa3. COq., n6JI. XXI, 13; M. II. rpRBJi08.
)].peBHell:illlle naMHTHHKn repOnqeCKOrO
;moca lIapOAOB IOmlIOH ClI6lIpn. «Apxeo-
JIOrIl'IeCKIIH c60pHIIr;,), Bbin. 3. JI., 1961,
puc.4.
· A. B. jJa8"tOo8a. K Bonpocy 0 xYIIHcKnx
xYAomecTB,j'HlIblx 6poH3ax. CA, 1971, oM 1,
CTp. 93-1 .
5 H. B. HaUfer;uH. KOCOrOJIbCKIIll: K,lal\. AO
1966 1'., CTp. 163-165.
6 lJ. TO./tCTOU. II H. Kouoar;o8. Pycor;IIe
IIpeBlIocTIl B naMHTHIlKax IICKyccTBa,
BbIn. III. CII6., 1890, pilC. 77; Ta6JI. 29,
226
10 jJ. A. K./te.MeHlf. )].peBlIOcTIl MHHycuHCKO-
1'0 MY3eH. TOMCK, 1886, Ta6JI. VIII, 3;
F.-R. Martin. YKa3. COq., TaGJI. 30-17;
J. Strzygowski. YI,a3. COq., pUC. 106;
A. Salmony. Yr;a3. COq., pile. 14; .Y. Ega-
mi, S. JJizuno. Iuner !llongolia and the
Region of the Great Wall. «Archaeologia
Orientalis», B. Serie", \"01. I. Tokyo and
KyolO, 1935, q. II, pue. 76, 1, 2; H. B. Ha-
Ufer;UH. YKa3. COq., pne.
II F.-R. Martin. YKa3. COq., Ta6.1. 30, 18, 20;
J. Strzygowski. ha3. COq., pHC. 106;
N. Fettick. YKa3. CO'I.. Ta6JI. XII, 1, 2;
A. Salmony. Yr;a3. COq., puc. 13; N. Ega-
mi, S. Mizuno. YKa3. COq., pllC. 76, 3;
H. B. HaUfer;uH. YKa3. COq., CTp. 164, pilC.
12 F.-R. Martin. Yr;a3. COq., Ta6JI. 29, 13;
A. Salmony. 'Ka3. COq., puc. 16; J. Strzy-
gowski. YKa3. COq., puc. 178, 13; D. Car-
ter. YKa3. COq., Ta6JI. 10.
U F.-R. Martin. YKa3. COq., Ta6JI. 29, 19;
J. Strzygowski. YKa3. COq., pilC. 178, 15;
A. Salmony. YKa3. COq., pHC. 7; C. B. Ku-
ce./te8. YKa3. COq., Ta6.1. XXI, 18; D. Car-
ter. Yr;a3. COq., Ta6JI. 10.
U jJ. A. K./te.MeHe14. Yr;a3. COq., Ta6JI. VIII,
29; F.-R. Martin. YKa3. COq., Ta6JI. 29, 11;
A. Salmony. YKa3. COq.. pUC. 8; D. Carter.
YKa3. COq., Ta6JI. 10.
15 M. H. ApTa.MOHo8. hO\m03I1 lIn C JIaHA-
illa<pTO I B cr;II<p0-CUQUPCIWM IICKyccTBe.
CA, 1971, .N'. I, CTp. 88: 01> JlCe. COKpoBII a
caKOB. M., 1973, CTp. 128.
'8 A. B. jJa8btOo8a. Yr;a3. COq., CTp. 94.
17 10. C. fPUUJ.UH. YKa3. COq., CTp. 165.
18 M. A. jJ38./teT. a nOHCHbiX II pliMO)TOJIb-
HbiX amYPHbix nnaCTUHax C H306pame-
HlleM mllBOTHbiX H3 UelITpaJIbHOH A31I1I II
ClI6lIpu. «IIp06JIeMbI :HuorCHe3a HapoAoB
CII6Hpii II )].aJIb!IerO BonoRa» (Te3HcbI AO-
KJIaI\OB). IIOBOCII6Hpo;. 1973, CTp. 56-58.
19 C. H. pyaeHr;o. KYJIhTypa XYHIIOB U HOII-
HYJIIIHCr;Ue "ypraHbl. [- J1., 1962, CTp.
76.
JI. C. l{JIeMH
rrpaBJIeHlHO rOJIOB H300pameHRbIX ;Im-
BOTHhIX - npaBoro).
Ha u;eHTpaJIbHOM m;HTKe OO.'lbIllHX
«paJIapOB H300pameHa cu;elIa Tep:HIHlUI:
OpJIHHhIH rpH«POH H HeorrpeAe;IeIlHoe
1KHBOTHOe HallaJIH Ha KOIlla'lbero XIIID;-
1IJ{a (<<rraHTepy»). Ha KpaeBOM <ppH3e
;:J pa3 rrOBTopeHa rpyrrrra II;J ;) « "aH-
Tep'>, a rro caMOMy Bepxy <ppH3a "poxo-
AHT OOPAlOp H3 20 rOJIOB ymacTbIX rpH-
«POB (pHC. 1, 1).
EpocaeTcH B rJIa3a Heorrpl'AP.leII-
HOCTb '11 HeeCTeCTBeHHOCTb pHAa ;(eTa-
JIeH H30opameHHH, cBHAeTeJIbCTBYI<Hl(IU
o AerpaAaU;IIH 00pa30B, 3aTe IIICIIIHI
nepBOHa'laJIbHOro CMhICJIa ll300p<lme-
HHn H OTpbIBe MaCTepa OT UCTOKO!l IIKO-
IIorpa«pH'IeCKOH TpaAHU;HH. Y BCPX mH-
BOTHbIX Ha «paJIapax XBOCT .'IUDO UC'le:l,
.11100 HaMe'leH PY)J,HMeIITapHo. Yma-
CThIii: OpJIlIlIbIll rpu«poH iIumerr KpbI.1b-
eB. Y Bcex (liIaHTep» q,pII3a HeXIIaTaeT
u;epeAHHX JIan (ITa KamAYIO rpynny
H3 3 (<IIaHTep» AaHO no 6 .laIl). rO:IOBa
c.peAHeH «naHTepbI» B TaIwii rp '''ne
'1aCTO CJIHIIIKOM AaJIeKO OTCTOIlT OT TY-
JIOBIIm;a, KOTopoe npHcoe:JIIHHI'TC' H J{
COCeAlIeH rpYIIIIP Il T. A.
EOJIee paHHee II '1HCTOe ILJO'>pa;Iw-
HHe Toro 1f'e ClOiKeTa, '1TO Ha IlI'IITpa.lb-
HOM m;IITKj", uaXOAIIM B cuo"pc "oji 1;0.1-
.1eKU;HU rTeTpa I- Ha IIpHCIiHTllhIX fa-
rapHHbIM B AeKaope 1716 r. IIaIJllhlX :10-
JIOTbIX rrJIaCTlIlIaX-3aCTem1WX 2. "pH IO-
yrOJIbHbIH KOHTYP KOTOPb!\ nOnJO.1HeT
i!;aTHpOBaTb HX III-I BB. :10 II. 3. 3
(pHC. 1, 2). OpJIHHbIH rpHq,oH 3Aeeb
oOJIaAaeT KphIJIbHMII, KOIIIa'lHii: XIIm;HIIK
HMeeT '1epTbI TIHpa (rrOJIOCaTOCTb) II
JIbBa (rpIlBa), a TpeTbe mllBOTlIoe, Be-
pOHTrro, rrpeACTaB.'IHJIO COOOH TapaHApa
,n;peBHIIX aBTopoB - MH«pH'IeCKoro O.le-
HH, coeAlIlIHBiliero '1eTblpe pa3HbIX mlI-
BOTHbiX.
B i!;aIlHOM c;ry'lae y Hero JIbBllHbIe
JIarrhI II CTlIJIlI30BaHHbIH OJIeHHH pOI'.
OTpOCTKIl KOTOpOro OKaH'IHBaIOTCH ro-
JIOBKaMH rpll«pOB. RaK nOKa3hIBalOT
MHorHe OJIHXII CHOHpCKOH KOJIJIeKU;III1,
MaCTepa cTa paJIHCb TaK pacrro.'1araTb
«PHrYPbI, '1TOObI ::!TH roJIOBKH rpllq,OB
00pa30BaJIH OOPAlOp OJIHXH H (Ha oOJIee
paHHHX OJIHXax) no B03MomHOCTH JI;Y-
rooopa3HhIH. 3TOT npHHn;IIn C06JIIOAeH
H AOBeAeH AO JIOrH'IeCKoro 3aBepIIIeHIIH
Ha <paJIapax - OOPAIOP 00pa30BaJI Kpyr.
HO CBH:!b !'OJIOBOK C TapaHApoM 3,!1;ec!'
cOBepIIIeHHo yrpa'leHa, KaK H pora Ta-
paHApa BoOOm;e. BrrpO'leM, H Ha rara-
pHHCI\HX 3aCTemKax por HaCTOJIbl\O
CTIIJIH:iOBaH, '1TO OT'IaCTH HMeeT BHA
rpHBbI (TaKHe mHBOTHhIe rrOJ!Y'III.ll1 B
JIlrrepaType HaHMeHOBaUHe «MHOrol'O-
JIOBOrO BOJIKa»), a XBOCT, rrepBOrra'la.1b-
HO, BIIAHMO, 3arHYTbIH Ha crrHIlY, pa-
30pBaH MaCTepOM: Ha'laJIO rrOAmaTO IIO;!
I\pyrr. a OKOH'Ianne C rpH«pbeH ro.10Bon
rrpHpoc;IO K crrHHe.
Ha APyroH rarapHHCKOH 3aCTemKe
(H3 HHBapCKOll: rrOCbIJIKH 1716 1'.) , C
aHaJIOrll"fHbiM ClOmeTOM (60pboa Ta-
paH,!I;pa C THrpO:l[) 3arrryTblii: na CIIH"Y
XBOCT em;e OT'IeTJIIIBO BHAeH. H pora
H XBOCT OKaH'IHBaIOTCH rpllq,oHbllMil
rOJIOBKaMH. 3Tll 6.1HXI! IIMelOT P-oopa3-
HbIH KOHTYP, '1TO II03BOJIHeT OTHOCIITh
HX K 60JIee paHHeMY BpeMeIH! -
K IV-III BB. i!;0 H. 3. 5 (pHC. 1(3).
Em;e 60JIee '1IICTbIH H HCHhIH no
CMblCJIY rrpOTOTrrrr ClOmeTa rrpe;:J.CTaB.1PII
Ha 30JIOTOH 3aCTemKe (pHC. 1, 4) 11:1
YJIaH-YA3 (0. BepXHeY,IJ;IIHCKaH) 6. KO-
TOpylO MomHO ,!I;aTlIpOBaTb rrpn Iep"o
TeM me BpeMeHe:l1 (Ha!lOmeRlIe JIOIIO.l-
CAPMATCRllfi TAP AH,IJ;P
H BOITPOC 0 IIPOHCXOm,IJ;EHHH CAPMA TOB
PaCKorraHRbI{I B 1864 r. Ha OKpaHHe
HOBO'lepKaCCKa u;apcKHH KypraH Xox-
JIa'l, '1aCTII'IHO orpaOJIeHHbIll, Ha3bIBaJIH
«rJIaBHbIM IIa IHTHHKOM» capMaTcKoH
arroxlI Ha lore POCCHII. PacKorraHHbIH
B 1962 r. I1eIlOi!;a:reKY OT XOXiIa'la Ca-
,!I;OBbIH KypraH TaKme cOAepmaJI orpao-
JIeHHOe n;apCKoe norpeoeHHe pyoema
H. :J. 1 B 'faCnI KOMrrJIeKCa, yU;eJIeBIIIeii:
OT orpaGJIelIIIH, pllMCKHe HMlIopTHbie
Bem;1I (xY;:IOiI\eCTBeHHoe cepeopo II
opoH3a) IIpCBOCXOAHT rro ooraTcTBY
XOXJIa'l, a .\lCCTUble, capMaTcKHe u3Ae-
JIHH (;IOJIOTO) XOTH II MeHee OOII.lbHbI
'1eM IJ Xox:la'lp. ITO rrpe,n;cTaBJIHIOT ,!I;PY
rylO pa3HOBII;lHOCTb U;apcKoro rrorpe-
OaJIbHOrO I1I1BCHTaPfI: B OT.1I1'1HC OT
Xox.l 'Ia, I1orpeOeJllle :JAeCb III' ,HCII-
C-Koe, <I MYiI\CKoe.
CpeAu cap laTcKlfx H3,!1;eiIlIii CaAOBO-
1'0 "ypr<l"iI nepBoe MeCTO IIpHHaAJIe-
iKHT KOMWICIiTY H3 14 30JIOTbiX «paJIa-
pOB. HITI;I' '('TlipoBaHHblx OUplO30H H
,i.(PYI'IBIH ".1\IIIH 1I1. 30JIOTO Ha «pa.ldpax
IIMCeT BU.1 TOHI>I1X II.laCTHH, I;OTOPbIMII
OOTHHYTa Cf'peOpHHaH (B 4 CJIY'laHX
;IH'JIe;JHaH) OCHOBa «paJIapa, H Ha KOTO-
pbl\: 'I('I(;\III'II/,[ IiOM1I0311u;nn B :lBepu-
nOM CTn:IP. Ha .JBYX OOJIbIIIIIX <pa.lapax
I<OMIIO:lm(I1H COCTOUT H3 n;eHTpa.lbHoro
Kpyr:IOro II[lITKa II KpaeBoro <pplf3a BO-
Kpyr IUIITI;a. IIpU'IeM «paJIapbI 31IilIlTH-
MOPcPlJbI; I:.! la.lbIX «paJIapOB rrOBTopH-
lOT B yrrpolllPHROM BHAe H300pameHHH
eHTpa.lblloI'O II(UTKa O,!l;HOro H3 OO.'1b-
illrrx <pa.li] I'0B (eelii CYAIITb IIO Ha-
228
HIITe.1bHbIX q,HrypOI\ Ha OCHOBHoe
II:100pallieune HarrOMllHaeT KYJIbOOCKOro
0.1elm). B ocrrOBHOll KOMrrO;JIIU;HH 3AeCb
Bcero ;:IBa 3BepH. TapaII,!J;p BABoe OOJIb-
IIII' XBOCTaTorO XIIm;HIIKa, OH HMceT
.10ma,i.(UHoe TYJIOBHm;e, HOrH II MOPAY;
pOl' II XBOCT C rpHq,bHMH roJIOBKaMH
'1eTKO BblpaOOTaHbI. XHm;HHK OKa3aJICH
3i!;eCb :IleneI' onpeAeJIeHIThIM (oa pc?) .
M a.leUbKIIH XIIII(HllK, BrrHBalOlI(HHCH
B rop.10 orpO IHoro KorrbITHoro, 1I300pa-
men II Ha aHaJIOI'H'lHOH AepeBHHHOH 3a-
CTelliKe (pHC. 1, 5) H3 RaTaH,!I;HHcKOro
hypraHa KOHu;a V -IV BB. AO H. 3. 7 .
n ;J;leC b pora H XBOCT KOlibITHoro CHao-
llieUbl roJIOBKaMH rpH«POB, HO B XHm;HR-
Ke MOiI\HO pacn03HaTb CKopee MeABeAH,
'1e 1 Gapca, a B orpOMHOM KorrbITHOM -
.10CH, npn'leM y JIOCH 3Aecb em;e HeT
IIIII;aKIIX 3aAaTKOB XHll HIIKa. HaJIIIn;O
peHJIbIlbIii: rrpooopa3 capMaTCKoro Ta-
paIlApa (KCTaTH, H HaHOOJIee OJIH3KHH K
OIIIIC aHllHM ,n;peBHRX aBTopOB), npe).!;-
crall:leJlHbIH B na3bIpbIKCKOM OJIeHe C
0P:llIllb!:l1 IWlOBOM 8.
TaKm[ 00pa30M, rrpOCJIemHBaeTCH
PH;( :1TaIiOB rrOCJIeAOBaTeJIbHoro pa3BH-
TIIH !! i!;erpaAaI(JlH OAIIoro II TOro me
('!OiI\eTa 6opbObI 3BepeH C Y'lacTHeM Ta-
pa!!!lpa - OT RaTanAHHcKOH H BepxHe-
y;lI!11CKOj:'[ 3aCTemeK '1epe3 rarapHHcKHe
6.lHX!! cnoHpcKOH KOJIJIeKI HH K q,aJIa-
pa I Ca:JoBoro I\YpraHa. IIpou;ecc pacTH-
II ':ICH IIa 5-6 BeKOB, II a 3TO BpeMH
\IOTIIB IIepeABHHYJICH 113 3aOaHKaJIbH,
.\. ITaH II IIOlIillHMbH B iIOHCKile CTerrH
(pill'. :2).
B C 1>I1«PO-CHOHpCKOM IlCKYCCTBe Ha-
\,(\;IHTCH KOpHII H AP)'I'IIX ClOmeTUbIX II
-+
{'IIC. 1. 1I306pa:J/CenUR Tapanopa II ezo npo-
J'.Tlll1a 8 c1jenax TepaanUR: (CTp. 230-231):
1 - (It l.lap n3 Ca,II,OBOrO RypraH3; 2 - 6mn.:a-33-
';I'ii..H;l 113 :I,eRa6pbcRoi1: rrOCbI.iIHt rarapnHa; 3-
'-,.IT\.C1-3aCTeaUm H3 HHBapcKoft nOCbI:IKH rarapu-
J:.! ., - fJ:JHXa H3 YJIaH-¥,II,3: {) - n.epeBHHHaH
I-"J:I\.,I H3 HaTaH;nbI (CXe taTn3HpOBaHHbIe npo-
;011'11 1
:2:20
Pue.l
PIlC. I (OIWII'UIIIlIP)
3
(0
\
L ;.
5
2
CTIIJIIfCTll'IeCKIIX ;meMeHTOB 1f300paiKe-
JIlIii ua <paJIapax (repaJIb qeCROe npo-
TIIBOIIOCTaB.leHIIe ropII30HTaJIbHO pac-
1I0JIOiKeHRblX 3Bepell, «BbIBIIXUYTbIe ')
3a):lbI TapaH):Ipa II rpII<pOHa, I1HKpYCTa-
IfH :lOJIOTbIX <pIIryp upeIIMyrn;ecTBeIIHO
PUC. 2. PacnpocTpaHeHue u306pa:JICeHuii. Ta-
paH8pa U ezo npoToTuna. Pacnpe8e./teHue
n./te.MeH - npe8no./tO:JICUTe./tbHo no repo8oTY
(aa UC1>./tIQ'l.eHueM Cap.MaToe]:
a - MecTOHaXOJl{):\eHUJI 1I306pameHuii TapaH-
Apa Hero npOTOTRIla;
6 - paUOH C60POB ClI6BpCKOi KOJIJIeJ( UH;
6 - JIOJ(aJIU3a 1I1i llJIeMeH (110 fep"):\OTY)
ua ROHRpeTlIbIe oopa3bI II ClOiKeTbI
IICRYCCTBa, a TaKiKe rra RYJIbTYPHblii
II!fBenTapb n YTO'IRIITb Oqar O,lIIiKaii-
mera pO):lCTBa: HeIIOCpe):lCTBeHHblM IIC-
XO,J,UbI 1 paiiOIlOM OblJIIf ne AJITaii II H
Cpe;!HHH A3IIH, a IIOIIpTbIllIbe II IIo-
IIllIIIMbe - MeCTa COOpOB CIIOIIpCROll
ho.l.lel.aI,IiIi. BbIABllraJIlICb pa3:mqRble
06"bHCUeHIIH OTMeqeHHOrO CXO):lCTBa
l;y.lbTYP (3THIIqeCKOe pO):lCTBO, oOIII,lfii
IICTOqHlIK BJIIiHHlfll, TeCHbie KOHTaRTbI,
nepeCeJIeHRH). HblHe y*e He rrpIIXO-
,];IITCH COMHeBaTbCH B TOM, qTO ):IBHiKe-
IlIIe KYJIbTypHoro IIOTOKa 3,n;eCb llIJIO C
Re, O):lHaRO, BOIIpOC qepecqyp OOOOIII,eH:
IIpIIMeIlUTe.lbHO K ):IOHC'KUM CTeIIHM 11
YKa:JaHHoe 8peMH 3aCBII):IeTe.lbCTBOBa-
ITbl llCTOqJ[I1haMII ):IBe capMaTCIme rpYII-
IIRPOBKU: aopCbI II aJIaHbI, IIplIqe 1 aJIa-
HbI C leUII.1II aopCOB RaK PYROBOitHIII,aH
rpymIIIpoBRa, rrO-BIfWiMOMY, eIII,e BIB.
H. 3., TO eCTb B pa fJ(ax Toii iKe CYCJIOB-
CROll hY.lbTypbI. OTHOCIITe,lbHO ooeIIX
rpYIIIIupOBOR eCTb itaHHbIe, YKa3bIBalO-
III,lIe lIa TO. qTO OHll III' C<pOpMIIpOBa-
JIIICb Ha MeCTe, a IIpIIObIJIII C BOCTOKa:
aJIaHOB ImTallCKIIe IICTOqHIIKII 3ITalOT
nOC.le 12;1 r.):IO H. 3. IIO):l R leHeM
aJIaHbH liaR Bacca.TIOB COr):\lIiiCKOrO Be-
JIHKOrO xaRa (CTaJIO ObITb, aJIaHbI npo-
iK1IBa.1II Tor;:ra r):le-TO BOJIII3H ApaJIb-
CKoro IOpH), a 3THOHIIM aopCOB OTOiK-
):IeCTB.llleTCH JIIIHrBIICTaMII C TepMIIHOM
HIIb-uaii. ROTOpbIM KIITaiiII;bl 0003ITa qa-
JIIf rrpe:uueCTBeH!lIIKOB aJIaHOB B TIpII-
apa.lbC.
TaK haR aopCbl IIOCJIe rrpUObITHH
a.lallOB B II pIIqepHOMOpbe OT):IeJIbHO
yme He yrroMIIHaIOTCH, MOmHO IIOJIa-
ra Tb, qTO 3TII IIJIeMeHa ObIJIII O.lII3KO
p0):lCTBeUHbnm II IIO npIIObIT1f1f a.'1aHOB
B IIpIiqepROMOpbe CJIIIJIIICb.
Ec.m BepHa ):IaTIipOBKa YIIOMHITY-
TbIX napCl\l!x KypraHOB TIO,J,OHbH py6e-
iKO 1 HOBOii 3pbI, TO OITIf rrpe):lCTaB,lHIOT
cl;opee aopCOB, qeM a.laITOB.
!lOChO.lbl;y IIpIIBe):leITRbIe BbIllIe
apxeO.lnrll'lPCRlfe COIIOCTaB.leHIIH YRa-
3bI8alOT IIi! IOiKITYIO Cuonpb RaK ITa
pallOI! paHlrero OOIiTaHI1H rrpenROB
aopCOB. TO rrpe):lCTaBJIHeTCH I!IITepeCHoii
3a,J,aQ" OTbICI;aTb IIX cpe:ITI HapO):lOB,
pa3 IClJlHe lbIX B 3TIIX 3eM.TIHX repono-
TOM. 110 repO):lOTY. 3a TI.1CllITIBbIMII
apruIIlleH !II. iKIIB)'lIIIIM!I Y TIO,J,HOiKIfH
BI.ICOhIJX rop (TO ecn Ypa.l!\) 061fTa-
l()T TICC('.l()fIbl. 3a IiCCe:IOHa !H o,:QIorJIa-
:11.1(' .H'.lU apIIMaCIIbI, a 3a Te nl-
(, CTPI'''' rYlIllle 30JIOTO" rplfcPbl (Herod.,
1\'. ! :-:. :!f;). IIOIIYJIHpHOCTb oopa3a rpII-
cPa B ;LuallchoM IICRYCCTBe TI ITa.1IIqIIe
,11)('811[1\ 30.10TbIX IIp!IIICROB Ifa A.1Tae
6UP1030ii, BbI):IeJIeRlie ):IP06I1b1X ):11'-
Ta.leii II BbIIIYKJIbIX qaCTell cPuryp l HCT-
UbIMII BCTaBKaMII), a TaRiKC 8000111(>
npIIHII;IIIIOB II MOTif BOB Cap IaTCI;O[(1
3BepIIHoro CTllJIH (oc06eHHO IIplI !Cqa-
TeJIbHbI II306pameUIIH JIOCH - OTHIO:\I,
ITe CTenHoro iKIIBOTRoro - Ha LI.llaLI.e \("
1f3 XOXJIaqa).
MbICJIb 0 pO):lCTBe capMaTCKoro IIC.
KYCCTBa (CTII.1H II MOTIIBOB) Co CI;l!q)()-
CII6IIpCKIIM BbIc.Ka3bIBaJIaCb Re pa3 II
apxeOJIOrllqeCROll .1IlTepaType. TeIIPill,
MOiKHO pacnpOCTpaHIITb 3TO CYffi;J.CIJ I!l'
BOCTORa Ra 3arraT(, a OTMeqeHITOe pac-
\lll1peHUe COCTaBa IIepeMeIII,aBllIIIXCH
":IC leHTOB ):IeJIaeT Bce 60JIee IIpe;J;rrOq-
TI!Te.lbHbIM IIpe;I,LIo.loiKeHlIe 0 Mllrpa-
[Lilli.
B a pxeo.loJlfqeCKO 1 BbIpaiKeITIIII peqb
u: eT 0 CYCITo.,BCKOii KYJIbType (I B. ):10
II. :J.- I B. . 3.), ITa H3bIKe IICTO-
pllTI - 0 EJIaCClfqeCKOM BOilpoce: 061ITa-
:II! :J;J.ecb B capMaTCKoe BpeMH IIOTO I-
iiI! caBpmlaToB If.llf, KaI, 1I0JIara.1
\1. II. PocToB eB, HOBOI' Hace.leHIIe
[Ij1ll0bIJIO C BOCTORa. B TaKoll IIOCTaHOB-
.)'t.,
_.)-
II03BOJIIIJIlI C. 11. Py):leHKO IIOMeCTIiTh
«CTeperyrn;lfx 30JIOTO') Ra AJITac. Hx co-
ce):lell: apllMacIIoB, OTHIlMaBllIilX y !lUX
30JIOTO, Ha):lO pa3MecTIITb IIO COCC;:\CTBY,
B MCCTax ]];eiiCTBIITe.'lbHOrO OOIl.lIIH xy-
):IOiKecTBeHHoro 30JIOTa, rLI,e Il c06paRa
3HaqIITeJIbHaH qaCTb CuollpcRoii I;O.l-
JIeKII,III! - B IIOUpTblilibe. IblenoBaHI!e
IIX o):lIIOrJIa3bIMII, BI!):IIi !O, IDleeT rrepBO-
OCHOBOii KaKIIe-TO 06pa3bI IIX 60rOB 1I.1II
Mu<p0JIOrUqeCKIIX repoeB. B CBH3I1 C
3TIIM 06paIII,aeT ITa ce6H BRIBIaHlle pac-
IIpocTpaHeHITOCTb MeLI,lIbIX cPlIrYPOK
ypO):l eB (oMOrJIa3bIx. O):lROpyRIIX II
O):lHOITOr:IIX) cpeWi TIOpRCRTIX rr.le leH
VI-XI BB. IT. 3.9 A. X. Xa.llfKoB CBH-
3bIBaeT 3TIf cPl1rYPKII C ):IpeBIICTIOpRCI,II-
MIl TOTeMIIqeCKUMII .1ereIIil.a 1IJ 0 rrpo-
HCXOiK):IeHIfIf XYHHY OT 1f3ypOIl,OFlaIlIIO-
ro repOH. )J;eiicTBlfe 3TlfX .TIereH;\ rrpo-
IICXO):lIIT Mem,n;y A.1TaeM, Apa.l0M II
RaClllleM. O):lITOrJIa3bDIIJ II O;J:HOIIOrI!MII
npe]];CTaBJIHIOT CBOIIX JIeCHbIX LI,YXOB
«llIyp3JIe) ((HPbIMTbIK») 6aIlIRupbI lo .
C06CTBeHHO XYHHY KlITaHCl>lIX IICTOq-
HIIROB 06lfTaJIIf BIIJIOTb ]];0 I;OHII,a I I I B.
no H. 3. IOmHee 06JIaCTII, OTBO):lllMOll Y
repO):lOTa aplfMaCIIaM. IIO COCe):lCTBy C
HIIMII, II .TIlflIIb B rrOc.1C):IIIne BeRa ):10
H. 3. RaqaJIIf 6ypnylO 31,CTI!\nCHlO. Be-
pOHTHO, If B paHOl! apI1MaCIIOB, BOll H
B KOHTaRT C IICCe):lOHaMIf. I30:!MOmHO,
qTO If caMIf apl1MaCIIbl rrpTIUal.\.lema.1H
TaKiKe I_ TIOpKCKIfM IIaIJOita !.
l1cCeitOIIOB CBH3bIBa.llf I!(I C038Y'II!IO
C p. l1ceTb. ITo TO'II1n IY (,\[h\C.lY n3Be-
CTlfll rep0):lOTa, IfCCe:IO!lb[ ;J(I:liKHbl rra-
XO)i;IlTbCH Mem!!,y Ypa.lhChll\llI ropa lIf,
MaccareTaMII II apn !iJCmnlll. TO eCTb B
CTerrHX OT p. YpaJIa ].0 oacc('iiHOB peK
l1ceTu, ToooJIa If Hrnll !H. :ho !DleilIIO
Te MeCTa, r):le ObI,la co6pa 11;1 :Jarra,J,naH
qaCTb CI!6npCROII RO.l.1CI,1l1111 V - IBB.
):10 II. 3. II KYita yXO].HT I;{'I'III\ Cap)laT-
CKoro !1ChyccTBa py6er!;a II '. Ec:m llC-
ceitOHbl OCTaBa.lllch T;j 1 \1 I: Iloc.lcrepo-
):IOTOBclwe BpC IH, T{I 11\1('1111" I!CCP.10HbI
):IO.liKllhI CqlITaTbCH lli'e'.l";1\111 nopCOB II.
233
ObITb MOiKeT, TaKiKe aJIaHOB (oyp;ym,IIX
HCOB - OCeTIIHOB).
.u;. A. Ma'IlIHCKlIll nO)];MeTHJI, '!TO
3THOHIIM IICCeAOHOB IIC'Ie3aeT co CTpa-
HIIn; reorpaqm'!eCKIIX CO'IlIHeHHH He-
CKOJIbKO paHbme - KaK pa3 TOr)];a, Kor-
)];a nOHB.'1HIOTCR rrepBble yn()MIIHaHHH 0
CHpMaTaX-Cap}faTaX, B IV-III BB. AO
H. 3. OH BbiABlIraeT riinOTe3Y 0 TOM, 'ITO
HCCe)];?,HbI II CTa.'11I Ha3b1BaTbCH capMa-
TaMH . I1pe)];JIaraeMbie 3)];eCb cono-
CTaBJIeHIIH n03BOJIHIOT npe)];nOJIOiKIITb,
'ITO He TOJIbKO rrepBble capMaTCKHe nplI-
meJIblJbI Ha lJorry, HO II nOCJIep;yIOm,IIe
BOJIHbI capMaTClwro HameCTBIIH, B
'IaCTHOCTII aOpCbl, IICXO)];IIJIII Bce HS TOll
iKe OOJIaCTlI. repOAOTOBbiX HcceAOHOB.
Bce CBe)];eHIIH fepO)];OTa 00 aplIMac-
nax H rpIJ(pax, 110 ero npII3HaHHIO, BOC-
XO)];HT K IIcceAOHaM. CJIeAOBaTelIbHO, y
HcceAOHOB AOJIiKHbI ObiJIH ObiTOBaTb
npep;CTaB.1eRIIH 00 0)];HOrJIa3b1X coce-
)];HX. JIIOOOI1b1THO, 'ITO B HapTCKOM ano-
ce oceTlfHOB 110CT01lHHO q,IIrypHPYIOT
0)];HOrJIa3b1e Be.'1IIKaHbI «yaHrH» - coce-
An HapTOB, KOTopble HeHaBHCTHbi Hap-
TaM IIS-3a CBoero HeYBaiKHTeJIbHOrO OT-
HomeHIIH h iKeRID;HHaM. TaK nJIeMeHa
I JI. C. h'.,eltn. CaAOBLIH KypraR - HOBLlII
BLlAaIOIl\IIHCH lIaMHTHI!K capMaTCKOII 3rro-
XI!. «l3CCTUllh JleuilurpaJ.\CKoro yRI!Bepcll-
TeTa», 1962, M 20, CTp. 164-167; S. I. Ka-
poshina. A Sarmatian Royal Burial Grave
at No\'ocherka""k. «Antiquity», vol.
XXXVI, ='I 148, 1963, p. 256-258.
2 C. H. PyrJeluiO. CIl6lipcKali KOJIJIeK lill
neTpa I. C..\J!, :t 3-9. M., 1962, TaOJI.
II, 5, CTp. 42.
3 M. A. .1JBACT. \) I!pOIICXOmJ.\eHIlI! MI!HY-
CI!HCKIIX IIOHCl!h!X IIpHMoyrOJIbHLlX amyp-
HLiX rrpHmCI,. «Te3lIcbI J.\oKJIaAOB III Bce-
cOI0311orr KOIH!)Cp(,ll "II 110 BonpocaM CKII-
<po-cap laTcKoi"1 a pxeoiIorIIlI». M., 1972,
CTp. 50.
· C. H. PurJeHIi" YI;a3. COq., Ta6JI. VI, 3,
CTp. 43. -
JI. M. nJIeTHeBa
C CIIJIbHbIMII nepeiKlITKaMII MaTplIap-
xaTa MOrJIII BocnplIHIIMaTb nOBeAeHIIe
OOJIee naTplIapXaJIbnblX COCe)];ell. I1pe-
)];aHlIe 00 0,lUlorJIa3b1X COce,lVlx - 3TO
em,e OAHa HHTb, YBH3hIBaIOm,aH IIcce-
)];OHOB fepoAoTa C capMaTaMII - aop-
caMII - HcaMH - oceTIIHaMII.
EblJIO Obi O'IeHb 3aMaIPIIIBO OO"1>HC-
HIITb II3JIOmeHHhIMH cooopaiKeHIIH}[JI
JIOKaJIII3an;IIIO HCCe)];OHOB - 3CCe)];OHOB
y TaHaHca HJIII Ha KaBKase y 1103A-
HHX aBTopOB MeJIbi (Mela, I, 115) II
I1JIIIHIIH (Plin. N at. hist., VI, 21), 0)):-
HaKO, BnOJIHe B03MOiKHO, 'ITO SAeCb
pe3YJIbTaT Bcero JIlImb reorpaq,II'IeChOH
aoeppan;IIII, CBH3aHHblll C COBMem,eHlIe}1
YpaJIbCKHX H KaBKa3cKIIx rop II C
OTomp;eCTBJIeHHeM cpe,lUleaSlIaTCKHX II
KaBKa3CKIIX peK t2. EOJIee peaJIIICTlI'IHO
cooom,eHlIe AMMlIaHa Mapn;eJIIIHa
(Amm. Marc., XXX, 2, 3) 0 TOM, 'ITO
aJIaHbI HBJIHIOTCH nOTOMKaMII Maccare-
TOB. Te H APyrne HMeJIH B 3TO Bpe}(H
YiKe BeCbMa nmpOKoe pacnpOCTpaHe-
HlIe, O)];HaKO B03MOiKHO, 'ITO 3TO COOO-
m,eHHe roBOpHT 0 npOiKlIBaHlI1I aJIaHOB
IOmHee aopCOB )];0 npHXO)];a Tex II APY-
rnx B I1plIa30Bbe.
IIPE,II;METbI 3BEPI1HOrO CTHJIH
B CPE,II;HEM ITPHOBbE
I1pep;MeTbI, BhInOJIHeHHble B SBepHHOM
CTlIJIe, HailAeHbI B CpeAHeM 11 pliOObe
Ha nOCeJIeHHHX IDeJIOMOK I, IDeJIo-
MOK II, EacaHJJ;ailKa I, CaMycb II,
(P. TOMb), 3ape'IHaH fopha (p. qy-
JIblM). ECTb OHII II cpeJ\H CJIY'laiiHblX
Haxo,'J:oK Ha CTapOM MYCYJlbMaHCKOM
K'Ia)];OIIm,e, CaMycb I (p. TOMb), Y noc.
BypOIIHO (p. qYJIblM). Ocoooe MeCTO
3aHHMaIOT Bem,II, BXO)];Hm,IIe B COCTaB
TaK Ha3b1BaeMOH CTenaHOBCKOH KOJI-
JIeKIJ,H1I (p. TOMb, OKpeCTHOCTH r. TOM-
CKa). PaCCMOTpHM HeKOTopLie xapaK-
TepHble AJIH )];aHHOrO paHOHa CIOiKeTbi.
O.aeHU. 1. EpOHSOBaH peJIbeq,HaH
q,IIrypKa raJIOllHpyrom,ero OJIeHH (CTe-
naHOBKa). Pora B BIIp;e CJIIIBnmXCH
S-00pa3HLlx neTeJIb, C OTpOCTKaMII
BBepxy, HanpaBJIeHHblMII Bnepe)]; (4)
II HaSa)]; (1). Pora onlIpaIOTCH Ha cnlI-
BY. Mop)];a nO,lUlHTa. Horn nO,'J:iKaTbl H
nO.'IOiKeHbI O)];Ha Ha )];pyryIO (rrepeA-
HHH Ha 3aAHIOIO). Ha oopaTHoti CTOpO-
He eCTb neTeJIbKa (pHC. 1, 1). l1oA06-
HbIe 6mlIIIKII OTHeceHbI H. JI. qJIeHO-
BOH KO II rpynrre II )IaTlIpYIOTCH
V - IV BB. )];0 R. 3. t 113 HOBblX HaxoAoK
OTMeTlIM 6JIJIillKlI, HaHAeHHble B Cepe6-
pHKOBCKOM MOrHJIbHIIKe, B KypraHe
12, l.orn:JIe I (11-1 BB. AO H. 3.) 2 II B
HeKpaCOBCKOM - B KypraHe 2 3 .
2. BpoH30BaH q,IIrypKa O:IeHH HaH-
)];eHa Ha 110CeJ1eHIIII 3ape'IHaH fopKa.
Mop)Ia ero nO)];HHTa, yxo pa3ABoeHO.
HorlI rrO)];OrHYTbI, 06pa3YH ABe l1eTJIII,
pora Ra cnlIHY He onlIpaIOTCH (pIlC. 1,
· M. A. l1iJ8./ter. YKa3. co'!., CTp. 50.
· C. H. PyrJen,;o. ¥Ka3. COq., Ta6JI. I\", 2.
7 C. H. PyrJen1>o. KYJIbTypa HaCeJICHIlH fop-
Horo AJITaJl B CKIl<pCKoe Bpe IH. M.-.1.,
1953, CTp. 312, Ta6JI. XXX!!, 4.
· . TaM me, pl!c. 83.
9 A. CnUlfbln. ¥pOAJII!BLle Me;J;UbIe CTaTY3T-
KI!. MAK, 29. Cn6., 1909.
to A. X. Xa./tU1>08. MaKJIameeBCKaH Bca.1HII-
a. CA, 1971, .N'2 1.
" 11. A. Ma'tunc1>uil. a BpeMeHil lIepBoro 3K-
TI!BHOrO BLiCTYIIJIeHIlH capMaToB B nO:1I!e-
npoBbe no CBI!AeTeJIbCTBaM aHTIIqHblX
nl!CbMeHI¥>Ix IlCTOqHIlKOB. ACf3, BbIn. 13.
J1., 1971, c1P. 54.
12 JI. A. E./t"'-u,!1>uil. 3HaHIIH ApeIJlIlIX n ce-
BepHLIx CTpaHlJ.x. M., 1961.
2). BaHillKa ;:\aTlIpyeTcH V -IV BB. )];0
H. .J.'
3. II300paiKeHHe rrpOTOM P;BYX OJIe-
HeH, oopam,eHHblx r0J10BaMII B npoTH-
B0l10JIOffiHble CTOpOHbI (CTenaHoBKa,
opoH3a). Mop,'J:hl oJIeHeil pa3Hble, npa-
BaH MeHbme .'IeBoil, J1eBaH HanOMIIHaeT
XlOp,'J:y .'10CH. fJIa3a II H03)];PII Y 060HX
o:IeRen rrepe aHbI HMKaMII, )];JIIIHHOH
.1IIHlIen C 110nepe'IHblMII Hape3KaMH
IIOKa3aHbI BO:IOCbI Ha mee (pIIC. 1, 16).
CTIlJlb q,IIrypOK OJ1HSOK II306pameHIIHM
rr3 VII rpynnbl no KJ1aCclIq,IIKan;HH
H. JI. QJ1eHOBOH (BepoHTHaH )];aTa -
III B. AO, a.)', H() )];BOHHbIe q,IIrypKII
o elIen B TarapcKoH KYJ1bType He1I3Be-
I' TII bi.
J] oUlaou. 1. EpoH30BaH q,IIrypKa
.10ma;::(II B KO.'Ibn;e (IDeJ10MOK II). Yxo
110J1YKpyrJloe. fOJlOBa nplInO)];HHTa.
f.U3 rr H03,'J:pII YCHJ1eHbI peJIbeq,oM.
Horn BbiCOKlIe, CTpoHHble. XBOCT onIl-
paeTcH Ha KO.1bn;O. Ha cnlIHe IIMeeTCH
THiK, COe)];IIHHIOrrWH q,IIrypKY C KOJlb-
UOXI (pIIC. 1. 4). l1oA06Ha II306paiKe-
IIlIIO na rraBepmIIII HOiKa II3 MOrIIJ1bHII-
ha \1a.1aH MrrHyca (V B. AO B. 3.) 6.
. Pe.1beq,HaH q,IIrypKa CTOH eH
:I OIlIil All (CTenaHoBKa, 6poH3a). JIo-
rna,J.b HII3IWpOCJlaH, rplIBa rrepe)];aBa Ha
cmllle BaJiIIKOM, ymii CTOH'IHe. f.'Ia3 II
R03;l.]J1! BbirrO.1HeHbI B BH)];e HMOK. Ha
OOOP'JTIIOll cTopoHe IIMeeTCH rreTe.1bha
(pilI'. I. 3). ARaJ10rHII eH 1I3BeCTHbi B
KO IfI:leKce MOrnJ1bHIIKa MaJiaH l1HH, B
Kypr,lHe 3 (\"-IV BB. )];0 H. 3.) II B Ma-
235
Tep1'laJIax Jh,JCOB fop},] na He (V -IV
DB. JI,O II. a.) '.
/{ 03J1bl (Bce TPII lIai!: elIbl Ba CTena-
IIOIJKe). 1. PeJIbetPHan q,nrypKa K03.'Ia
C 1l0T\orUYTb1Mll HoraMH. f.'1a3 B BlUJ:e
HMKII, YXO oTAe.'IeHO OT porOB JIllHnell,
pora n306pamenbI n.'1ocKoii Ayroii, onll-
palOli.\ciicH na cnnBY. Ha 6eApe JIllBnn
B BIIAe nOJI)'Rpyra (puc. 1, 7), Ana-
:lOom n3BeCTna B TncYJIbCKOIlI MOrll.'Ib-
IfIlIW, B KyPraBe 7, MOI'JIjle 4 B.
2. Il.'1ocKaR <}JnrypKa CTOHIJ:{ero K03-
.la. l\Iop,a;a onyn eHa. Pora BbrllOJlHeHbI
,!O'roif, orrnparomeifclI Ha crrnBY. Horn
coe,a;IIHellbr. Ha 060POTHOii CTopOHe eCTb
neTeJlbKa (pltc. 1, 5). ABaJIOflUI. 113-
BeCTHa B MOmJIbUI'IKe HeKpaCOBO, B
Kyprane 1 9 ,
3. PeJlbetPHall <}JnrypKa CTOHmero
ropnoro K03JIa. MOPAa HaK.'IOHeHa K BO-
raM. Yxo nOJIYKPyrJIoe, rJIa3 - JlMKa.
nO:lbtWTble pora 3anpOKIIllYTbI Ha cnn-
RY. BMCCTO CKB03R"I:1\. OTBepCTDU - IIM-
Kli. Horn 3aKaHqllBaIOTCH Tome KOJIb-
IJ:a m (HMKaMU). XBOCT AIIHRHblii (pUC.
1. 6). TOtlHoii aBaJIOOIH aToH <}JnrypKe
Hen:mCCTIlO. HeCKOJIbKO rroxoman na
nel' IIaii[(ena B MOrHJIbllHRe TIaMHpcKan
I B "ypraIJe 1010, RO CTerraBOBCKan <}Ju-
ryp/w IJpon:JBO,lJ:lIT BneqaTJIellne He-
CI\O.-II."O Aerpa].(npoBaHnou.
l1306pa:J/CeuuR ,waAoe e pyee. ABe
ii.ll1l11l'11 IIaiiJlenbr na CTerraBGBKC (co-
1'J.IlIlCllllble no TpU), O].(Ha - Ba noce-
.1l'lI1ll1 HleJloJ',IOK I (pnc. 1, 8, 9). Ha
oJ.Jloj", ii./RlnI;:e n3 CTenanomm pora 1'1
nil:! /;o:J.TI8 '{anbl B BRAe KO:1bL(a C Ba-
("f"II,oji. 8 nCR tPRrypRa n306pamena
CXP\l;I1I1'1UO. Y me.10MOKCKOii n OAROi!:
113 C' n'lIilIIOBrI,IIX 6.'IHmeK pi:T lI\a 3y6-
'laT,IIL fTo;J.OOllbre <}JlIrypKII K03!lOB B
"pyn' Jl3BeCTHbr Ba lIaBeprulln noma,
nprJlIf\II: flUu'ro 113 CepefipHKOBCKoro
,o, 1I.11o/II/Ha, l\ypraH 4, '10111:13 21 . Ana-
.1nfll'lli ,I H <}JlIrypH8 onYU:/lIKOBaHa
.-\. ,1. Ta.lbrpeHm, 12. C:1\.f' [8TnqHbre
cpllr\ I'hll 1;:03:10B BCTpeqaroTcH Ha 06ym-
J;/1'1: '11'1;'}I10B 13 II Ba lliTaH;J.apTax ".
3ep1:aJla c rjJUlYP'WMU 1>03J10e ua
.'-tecre nereAe . Haii.'\cnbI lIa nocr:JeHlln
BacallAauI;:a I, lllC:lO 101\ I (pIlC. 2,
1-4). <DnrYPKll I1a 3epKa:1ax noce:Ie-
HHH III eJIOM 0 I;: lIeCKOJILI\O OTJIIItliHOTcn
OT 6acallAaiixcKlIx. OUlI AaHbr II CTa-
Tl!.qHOii noae, HO 11306paffiellilH. uo.lee
peaJIDCTU'lHbl. TIo;J.0611bre tl>nrypKIl ruu-
pOKO 6hlTYIOT B MIIHYCIlHCl\oii 1\0T;IOBn-
ue, B AqnnCKO-MapHIIIICKm( pallOHe,
ua 3epI{8JIaX, HaBepWllHX K!leBL(OB u
HomeR 15. OBII BCTpe'IerrhI na KOIIYCO-
oopa3HLIX HaBepwIlHx, npollCXoAHlLt;nX
H3 MOrlt.'lblUiRa HryHH 'B. 3epKa.'1a c
<}JnrypKaMlI R03JIOB C Eacan]\aiiI\B I
AaTnpYIOTcn V-IV BB. AO H. 3. 11 EOJlee
peaJIUCTIf'IHJ.IC 1'1306paffiruun cpnrypOK
R03J10B lIa WeJIOMOKCKllX 3epKaJIa x pa3-
pemaIOT IIpe].(IIOJIOmnTb, 'ITO AaTa aTnx
1I3].(eJIl(ji - He n03;J,Hee V B. AO H. a.
H.w6pa:J/Ceuull ceepnY61lle2ocR xUUf-
uu a, uaiJ.iJeuuoe e Crenauoe1>e. ITacTb
pacKpblTa, rJIaa B Bnne R'II\l1. 1I0].(ma-
TLie nepe].(HHe lIorlf KaC:\IOTCH YJOPT\J.I
n oHalitillBalOTcR KO:1bl\0 1. Ha TYJIOIIH-
me neCKO.'lbKO nOnepe'lIlbIX ,rmlIIIii u
JI,Be n PO[(O.II "" "1:1.. Ha 060poTlroii CTOpO-
ne nrTf'JlbKa (pHC. I. 11) _ ITo;IooIlbre
n;m6pamcIIIIH IUII(lOHO paClI(locTpanenbl
B Cnoupn n ITpn'lrpnmlOpJ,f'.
f/:Jo6pa:J/Ceuue CrU.fI.Il.306anlibiX epu-
rjJOUbU.X eOAoe. 1. BpOIl30I18H U.lRmKa
c ABYMH rpIl<}JoIlblnm rO.lOBa m (CTe-
naIloBKa). fO.'lOl3a C 1II('f'II n:laBIIO :Ja-
rHY":a n olillpacTrH n8 IIJ,mYH.lblr, "pyr
B L(eHT,Je 6.1Rwlm. I\:I/on IIpOtl('p'leH
ABYMH .'IU II II HM1T, r.l/13 nl,OllTypCII Ba-
JIJ(lWM (pHC. 2. 8). no CTlI.l10 IIcnOJlne-
IIIIH ona nOXOiIW Ita C',III(lO'faTCKlie
6.'IHUmIl 18.
-
" QiJ
o
7 .
-.
I1V
r
,
Puc_ 1_ EpoHdo6brc "pt"i.tI Tro,
J. 3. 6. 1. 9-12. 1S-17 - CT"II.,n"u(_I,aR t\o.a:.neK-
"HR 2. '4 - noce:u IIIIt.' ;:).31It'-lliol I rOpti3; 4. 8-
noce.:JeHlte llieno,"loti I], - I It''III1P BacaB-
.naAKa I: 13 - nOCe.:1CIlIU" .- 1'\1 1 I. II
16
236
VWJ-
5
12
"
,.
-
. ,c
. .:. 0
b o
'1
."1 I
17
o
2. TplI 6pOB30Dh1e 6JIHIDKlI D .popMe
CTBJIlI30DalIHbIX rplI.poBblIX ronOD. ADe
IIPOUCXO)J,llT U3 CTelIaBODKlI, oABa 1I3
IIOCeJIeB1'IH CaMYCL II (pIIC. 2, 5, 6).
IIoA06HbIe 6mrIDKlI BaH.n;eBh1 B Tyne y
ropC'Aa Rh13h1JITaB (KypraH A-6) 19.
3. EpoB30DaJl 6JIJlIIIR8 B BlIAe CTlI-
JIlI30BaBBlJX rplI.pOHblIX roJIOB 1I3 CTe-
naHOBKlI. Ha IIpaooD: U neDOB IIOJIODII-
Hax ee AaHO IIO 5 IIOJIyKpyrJIlJX JIIIHHH
(pIIC. 1, 13). IIOA06Hh1e IIpeAMeTh1 HMe-
IOTCJI B c06paHBHx MlInyCIIHclwro
MY3eH 20.
4. EpoB30BaH 6JIHIDRa C 1I306pame-
BHeM rOJIOB mlIBOTHh1X: J},Be cBepxy,
ABe CHlI3Y, 06pam;eHh1 ronODaMU APyr
K APyry. B QeHTpe - DbIIIYKnh1H Rpyr,
06'beAHBHIOm;nD: Bee u306pameHHJI.
YIDn, rJIa3a mIIDOTHh1X IIepe aHbI JI'I{-
KAMII (puc. 2, 7). IIo.n;06HaH 6JIHillKa
HaHp;eBa D RypraBe Y r. RbI3bIJIraH
(V-IV BB. AO B. a.) 21.
5. EpoB30DaJl 6mmrna C 1I306pame-
RlIeM CBepHynIDerocH XJJII{HlIRa, CYAJI
IIO .popMe, Morna CnymUTb HaDepIDneM
Homa. fJIa3 IICIIOJIBen B BRAe HMRH,
IIepeABlIe II 3aAHne HorR - ne60JIbIDlIe
OTpOCTRU. XDOCT 3aKaB1JIIDaeTCJI ADYMH
KOJIbQaMII (plIC. 1, 12). EJIJlIDKa H8-
IIOMlIBaeT BaDeplIIHH TarapCKlIX npe -
MeTOD 22.
llTUl-/.bt. 1. ABe 6pOB30DbIe JlIITbIe
CKYJIblITypLI IITRQbI 1I3 OTpHAa TeT pe-
DIIHbIY. fOJIODa IIOp;HHTa. fna3 - T01JKa,
KpbIJfbH 0603Ba1JeHbI peJIbe.pOM (CTe-"
IIaBOBRa) (pIIC. 1, 1 ). AHalIOrnn
He1I3DeeTBbI.
2. ADa 6pOB30BbIX TIJIOClmX 1I306pa-
meHRH IITln:!; C IIoDepHYToll Ha3aA ro.'IO-
BOH. Ha TYJIODllll\e TPII npOnOJIbBbIX n
ceMb nOlIepeqBbIX mmnir (EacaH)J;aIr-
Ka 1, CTenaBoBKa, pRC. 1, 10).
3. CKYJIbIITYpa nTIIQbI nOJIN'O JInTbH
C IIODepHYToB Ha3aA rOJIOBOH (Ban;J:eHa
Y CTenaBoDKll). RJIIOB onnpaeTeR HR
CIIBBY, rna3a - CIffi03Hbie OTBepCTlHl.
JIamm 3aKaH'IIIBaIOTCH KO:Ib O". Ha
TYJIOBUme IITUQbI ceMb CKBO.lRbIX npo-
pC3eii (pue. 1, 17). IIop;06BbIe B306pa-
",l'fiIIH Haii,'l:enbI B IIpllqepBOMOpbe II
D !\hmyc.nHclwH KOTJlODIIHe (V -IV DB.
iW B. a.) 23.
4. EpoH30BaH IInOCKaH .pnrypKa
IITIIlI.bI C IIODepHyTOH Ba3ap; rOnODOD:
(3apeqHaR fopKa). RmoB coeAHBeH co
cDlmoll. fJIa3 D BIIAe HMHn. Ha TYJIO-
Bmqe TPII npOAOJIbBbIX U TPII IIonepe1J-
HbIX IIOJIOCHlI. JIalIHII 3aKaH'llIBaIOTCR
I>O:IbIIOM (pIIC. 1, 14). TaKDe .plIrYPKII
;IaTirpYIOTCH V-IV BD. AO H. 3.
BpOH306aR nJl.aCTUHa C peAberfmb/.M
1l306pa:HCeHlle.M <mpllna6me30 Pi: ae.MJl.eIJ
XUUIItU10a (CTapoe MycynbMaHcKoe
l,"la.J:fiIlII e D r. TOMcHe). Xnm;HIIR
(Bo.'m?) II306pam.eH B IIpO.pIIJIb. Mop-
;J;a npUIIOnHHTa, TIaCTb pa3UnyTa. JIa-
nbl ,!{aHbI ;J;Be, C IIHTbIO ROITHMII Kam-
;I;BH. Han CIIIIHOH XIIIIJ;HIIKa TIO'MemeHa
lOp;Ia Kalwro-To mHBOTnoro C IIRTbIO
OTpOrTRaMII POroB. IIacTb XIIIIQIlIua H
3Depb Hap; roJIODOD: XJJII{HlIKa coep;UHe-
Rbi nJlacTlIHoii,OIlHpaIOm;eD:CH Ha IIepe -
lIIOIO JIany xlIlI{IDIKa (pIIC. 2, 9). Mo-
Tnn (<IIpnnaDmero K 3Cl'>mel> XlImHHRa
n nl'CTeB y caDpoMaToB. OAHa 6JIHmI(8
C nOI\06Hbnt 1I306pameHIleM HaHp;eB8
B 'IOnlJIbHIIKe CYCJIIJ (KypraH 5), APY-
raH IIPOUCXOAHT 1I3 pa3BeHHHoro nor-
P(,Ul'IIlJR Ha WOHe Y c. 30nOTymHHCKoe.
Ooe 1(8THpyIOTCH VI B. o H. 9. 16 B OT-
:InqllC OT OIDICh1BaeMOro IIaMR 1I306pa-
",ellllll, y C8DpoMaTCRlIX XUll\HHKOB ro-
JIOB8 onyrn;eHa BmI3, y O Horo nOA npH-
\lhI)1 yrJIO!>l, Y APyroro'- HeCKOJlbKO
DloITJJHYTII meH. TaK me, KaK II Y TOM-
CR"oro. y caBpOMaTcmn: XIIlI(HIlROB JlO-
n.ITEII YCHJIeHbI peJIbe.pOM. OAH8 peJIb-
eq'ww qmrYPl\a U3 A1JHBCROro OKpy-
ra (.flIIC8Ha H. JI. qJIeHOBOB, KOTopaH
c
I
";i
"iv..
.'
v
3
(
, .
t
,-
r
p"r .' EpoH308 e npeaMerbl.:
1 noce"leBlI1 BaCaBJ1aillla I; 2, ,,- nocene-
H;" ru"."lOMOII I; 5 - DOCeneHHe CaMYCb n; 8-
8 - rTPn:lHOBCllaR 1I0J1JleIlItBR; 9 - C'Tapoe MY-
r'. ".lnrHoe N.:talX15uDte B r. TONCRe; 10 - noce-
..,.. 1" I1h a ."10,"IOK II
9
j\
238
2
0J8
I
r:::::>
5
00
-==<g::= -
6
""...
.
4
if)}
,
... . .. ': :;'" --:-' .{ -
, '- '
..,. "... ;
. o\\"\,\.
&
Fi? .
.. ::.J?)
I
8
,
, . ,
R I A
10
C'IIITaeT ee «aJITaacKoii» no CTiU/o II
JWTllpyeT V B. )].0 II. 3. 25 TO IC!"UI n:Ja-
CTllIIa 6m13Ka :nOMY I1300pal!\eJ!IIIO no
nepe)].a'le n03bI 3BCpH. 3a IIC Ii.l/O'ICInIeM
rOJlOBbI.
CTHJIHCTU'IeCIGI 11306pal!\l'lIl1e ro.rlO-
Bbl TOMCKoro I!\I1BOTHOro 6:11131,0 rO:IOBe
XHll\HllKa, lIaii)].eHHoro T. II. TpollqKOii
B Morll.1JbHIlKe HOBbIII Illapan, B KYP-
raHe 6. ITo KOMnJler,cy lIaXO;J.OK KypraH
i-\aTllpOBaH T. H. TpOIlL\KOii \' - IV BB.
)].0 II. 3. 26 Ho lIa 6.1HIllKC II:! HOBoro
lllapana COBepllIeHIIO IIl1a'le no)].aHO
TyJloBHIqe 3BCpH. i:ho I1::\YIL\lIii XUII:\HIlK.
ITo)]. JlanaMlI p;aHa Y3KaH n.laCTlIHKa.
Y XHII:\HHKa 113 HOBoro lllapana rOJlo-
Ba nO)].HHTa KaK 11 y TOMClwro. ITpHMbIX
aHaJlOrllK 6J1HllIKe C IYC y.'lbMallCKoro
K.TJaA6IlIqa MbI He 3Hae I. OT Bcex YKa-
3aHIIblX anaJlOfIlH TO ICKaH OJIHllIKa
IlMeCT OTJlIl'lllH; Y XIIlL\HIIKa He 1130-
6pal!\eHbI yxo, XBOCT, B 'lCM BUAHO OT-
CTYI1J!eHlIe OT HKOIiOrpa<pII'lcCJ;oro 06-
pa3a KaK Jlel!\au\cro, Tali II H)].ymero
xlnqHIlKa.
Pe.TJbe<pHoe 1l300pal!\('lIl1e C MYCYJlb-
t.taHCI{OrO KJIall.6HIqa mm,CT OblTb AaTII-
pOBano no allaJlOrll1l C ('a II pmla TCKIlMIl
6J1HllmaMH II 6J!fllllKOii II:! HOBoro llIa-
pana VI-IV BB. ;:\0 II. ;).
BpoH306aR 6.!tRUUW 08HOr:TopoHHezo
.!tUTbR C u306paJ/CeHue.'>t .>iCU60THOZO,
II np,ma6lUe?O K 3e.II.!tf'i! (III e:IOMOK II,
pllC. 2, 10). rOJIOIIH lIi1 Ii:IOIIClla, rJla3
B BliAC KOJle'lKa. . ;t;1I110TllOrO nepe-
I ll. JI. '1.Jtel<oea. C"Il(jJCldlii O.lellb. MHA,
M 115, 1962, CTp. 170-171, raoil. 1, 4.
2 A. H. MapTbllwe. B. B. r;",jpe. Ccpe6plI-
"OBC-hUII )IOrll;",llllI;. (d I.'BPOUH iIaoopa-
TOplI1I apxPOJlOrnqeCI;II\ IlCL1PI\OBaHIIII»,
BhIII. 3. Ke lepoRo. 1"71. Tal..1. 74, 4.
3 KJ1AH. PaCIWlll;il ,\. 11. lapTbIHOBa B
HIli r.
· ll. JI. '1.<elfoeo. flpOIIC\O;!;.ll'IIne II paH-
IIHfl I1CTOpl!fl II.le)II'U '!""" pCiwii I;Y.1IbTY-
pbl. M., 1967, CTp. 13\\
5 H. JI. '1."lfoeo. CI;lIlj" "'Iii O.lCHb, CTp.
176, Tao.l. I, 21.
nano ).IHC rrorn, XBOCT I !e)JllII HHbIii , 3a-
Kan'lllBaeTCH nOJIYI{OJIbqOM. OnpeAe-
.111Tb 1!\1lBOTHOe TPY)].HO, aHaJlOrnH
I1CII3BeCTIIO.
JJ 306paJ/CeHue u8YUfezo XUUfHUKa
(60.!tK?) (Eyp6llHO). rOJIOBa onYIqerra,
naCTb pa3llHyraH, 3y6acTaH. Yxo cer-
MeHrOBll)].Hoe, rJla3 BI.InyK:JbIK. Horn
BblCOK!le C 1l1IIpOIGIMil JlanaMll, Ha Kal!\-
AOK 113 KOTOpblX Aallo no TPII naJlb a.
XBOCT p;.TJIfHHbIii, 3aKaH'IIIBaeTCH KOJlb-
OM. IT pHMblX aHa.TJOrllii HeIl3BeCTHO.
ITo)].06HbIe 1l306pameHIlH 6bITYIOT C
V B. AO H. <J. ".
IIpe)].MeTbI, BblllOJlHeHHbIe B 3Bepll-
HOM CTIlJle 113 Cpe)J.llero IT pn06bH, IlMe-
IOT aHaJlOrnll B MIlHYCIlHCKOK KOTJlOBIl-
He, Ha AJITae, B Ka3aXCTaHe II TYBC.
B TOMCKOM II Cpep;JIeM ITpll06be <JTI1
npeAMeTbl pacnpOCTpaHHIOTCH c VI B.
)].0 II. ;). Oc06eHil0 Mlloro IlX nOHBJlH-
eTCH B V B. AO H. 3. Haxo)].KI1 XY O-
meCTBeRHbIX npeAMeToB na noceJle-
HIlHX O'leHb BamllbI AJIH AaTllpoBKU
naMHTHKKOB. TaK, nanpllMep, OHII no-
Mora/OT YCTaROBUTb AaTY nOCeJleHIlH
llleJloMoK I, llIeJlOMOK II, EacaHAaa-
Ka I, CaMycb II.
IT pC)1MeTbI 3BepilHoro CTIIJlH CBlIlI.e-
TCJlbCTHYIOT 0 IIlllpOKIlX CBH3HX Hace-
.1enUH TOMcIwro ITpllo6bH, a TaKl!\e
Hace:ICIIHH, I!\IlBYIqerO no peKaM "4 y-
,TlbIMY II 06H, C I!\IlTeJlHMII AJlTaH, MIl-
HYCIIIICKOll I<OTJlOBllHbI II A'II1HcKo-Ma-
PllllHcIwro paiioHa.
12 A. 111. Tallgren. Catalogue de la collection
de M. Znamensi. «Antiquites de la Sibe-
rie occidentale conserveesan Musee, na-
tional de Finlande». Helsinki, 1917, pI. VI,
9.
u KJ1AH. <!JOHl\bI. MOrIfJIbHIIK HrYHlI, R. I
(V-IV BB. 1\0 H. a.). PacKonKII A. H.
MapTbIHOBa B 1967 r.
.. KJ1AH. <!JOHl\hI. MOrIfJIbHIIK HeKpacoBo,
K. I. Pac.KonKif A. 11. MapTblHoBa B 1971 r.
MOrIfJIbHIIK HryrrlI, K. IX, M. 2. PacKonKif
A. H. MapTblHoBa B 1967 r.
15 C. B. Kuce.1!e8. JJ:peBHIIH IfCTOpIfIi lOamoii
CIf6IfplI. MUA, N2 9, 1949, CTp. 140-141,
TaOJI. XXIV, 6; A. H. MapTblH.08. TIfCYJIb-
CKife RypraHhI. ! e lCpoBo, 1972, Ta6JI. f71,
1.
16 KJ1AH. <!JOHJ.{bI. MOrIfJIbHIfK HryrrH. Pac-
KonKif A. H. MapTblHoBa.
17 H. JI. '1./telf08a. flPOIICXO;Kl\eHl!e.., CTp.
83-84.
18 K. (/J. CMupnoe. CaBpoMaTbI. ,M., 1964,
CTp. 16, 23.
6 H. JI. '1./teI<080. IIPOlICXOinl\eHIfe... CTp.
1.58, N2 13, Ta6.11. 25, 19.
7 H. /1. '1./telfoea. fl POIICXOml\eHIfe.., CTp.
158. J'" 1, Taoil. 25,21.
8 KJ1AU. PacI;oIIKlI A. U. MapTblHoBa,
1971 r. r
· TaM ;.Ke.
10 A. H. EeTi-wTOM. HCToplmo-apxeO.1l0rnqe'
CI;I1e OqepKII eHTpaiIbHoro TflHb-IIIallfl n
fla mpo-AJIafl. MUA, N2 26, 1952, pile.
139, CTp. 314.
II A. H. MopTbll<oe, B. B. E06p08. ;I;a3.
COq., Ta6iI. 20, 7.
240
Cl<u<!>o-cB6UpCIIIIl 3BepuIIYI CTIIJlI>
!9 C. H. BoulfwTeul<. flaMflTHIfKII CKII<pCIwro
Bpe ICIJn B 3aIIailHoll TYBe. ¥3THI1HHJ1I1,
BhIn. III. KbI3bIiI, 1955, plIC. 2, 7.
20 /lH.. KY3I<elfoe-KpoCllORpCI'>UU. MIfHYCIIH-
CKife i\peBIJOCTII. TO IC", 1908, Bblil. 1,
Ta6JI. IV, 25.
21 C. H. BoulflllTeul<. ¥Ka3. COq., Ta6.11. IV,
80.
22 H. JI. '1./telfoeo. flpoIICXOml\eHlIe.., TaO.1l.
27, 19, 20.
23 H. JI. '1./te If{) ea. flpOlIcxom"eHlIe.., CTp.
164, M 7, Tao.l. 34, 37.
.. K. ([J. C.1wplfoe. Yha3, COq., CTp. 37, 225,
no.'!. 78. 1, 2.
25 H. JI. '1./telfoeo. flpolIcxom"eHIfe.., Ta6JI.
34, 47, C-Tp. 163, III, M 1.
26 T. H. TpOlllJ"OR. HOBOCIfOIfpCKoe IIpifoobe
B VII-IV BB. 1\0 H. a. «HaY'iHble TpYAbI
HOBOClIoIfpCI;oro fOCY;1apCTBeHHoro nel\a-
rOrlIqeCKOrO IJI!CTIITYTa», Bbln. 38. HOBO-
CIfOIfpCK. 1972, CTp. 13, pHC. 5a.
" H. JI. '1.1PHOeo. ITpoIICXOml\eHlIe.., CTp.
161, IV, No> 1-3.
meHlIH meHcRo1'O OOmeCTBa co CHH<I>-
CKHMH H IlHTepeCHO COnOCTaBJIeHa
CQeHa Ha rrJIaCTIlHe 113 RypraHa Kapa-
rop;eyamx co CII,ellaMH Ha pYCCHOM
nOJIOTeHQe '.
TeMaTHRa 1l300pameHlIH Ha pHp;e
aHTpono- H 300MOp<l>llI.IX <l>H6YJI Bo-
CTOqHOll EBporrbI, I,aR <JTO OTMeTIlJI
}J,. 8p;nHr, BOCXOP;IIT K CKH<I>CRIlM npo-
TOTllrraM 2. 0 CBH311 IiCRYCCTBa CJIaBHH
CO cKH<I>aMH rrllca:I JI. A. }J,HHQec 3. Ha
3TO me 06paTu:I BllIlMaHHe B. A. Pbl6a-
ROB'. He rrporne.'I !II MO <JToro Borrpoca,
1l3yqaH na [HTRI!I;!! IIpHypaJIbJl, H
A. B. IIIMHp;T '.
KOHe'lHo. He.Tb3H 1'OBOpHTb 0 Tom-
p;eCTBe Hp;eO:lOrn'leC 1\11 X npep;CTaBJIe-
Hlln, CBH3aHI1blX C npep;MeTaMH 3BepH-
Horo CTIIJIH B Te'lelllie CTOJIb P;JIHTeJIb-
Horo BpeMCHII. Cpe.\HcBeRoBble MaCTepa
HCrrOJIb30Ba.Tlf TO:lb[-;O <l>OPMY, BJIOmHB
IlHOe cop;epma!lll e B C BOil rrpOIl3Bep;e-
HHH. 8TOT BOnp()(' rrHTepeCHO pa306paH
E. A. PbIoahOBbDI. I;OTOPbIH, aHaJIH311-
PYH npHR.'W:(HOl' I!CI;YCCTBO )JJJeBHeii
PYCIl, COIIOCTaBII:! ero C Hapop;HbIM
<JnOCOM. CRa3Ka !lI !I BamHbIMH gJIH IlC-
TopHRa 3:Ie !eIITa !f! H:lbIqeCTBa, TeCHO
CBH3aHrrbIMil C xpllCTllaHCRllM Bepo-
Y'leHl1eM. ( 1 hITcpec lIO OTMe'leHlIOe
E. A. PbI [-;()BhD! pa3BIITlle 3BepHlioro
CTIIJIH Y PYCChIlX. . !;QTOpblX BCTpe'la-
eTCH 1l306p<\mellflf' pa3JIIl'lHbIX qy:(o-
BlllIl" nTlfI . nepl'll.ll'TeHHbIX paCTllTe.Tb-
HbDIil Y30p<\ rfl' f10-BIIr\IIMOMY, OH
rrpaB, 06'bHCHHH rroil B.'reHlie <JT01'O CTH.'IJI
meJIaHHeM rocnop;CTBYlOlII,erO RJIaCCa
06ooo6HTbcH OT npOCToHapogHo1'O IiC-
HYCCTBa c ero MllpHblMII ClOmeTa-
MH II YRpaCIiTb CBOH OJ\emil.bI Ii ;:1;OC-
nexlI YCTpamalOJIJ;HMIl 3BepIiITbDm 06-
pa3aMH.
B Ra'leCTBe npHMepa E. A. PbIoaRoB
IIpBBOP;IlT nOHC P;PyiRHHHIIl;a CeBep-
CKon 3eMJIII IX B. C Ii306pamclmeM
XHIQIIblX nTIIQ, Tep3alOlII,IIX :11O;:1;efI 7.
ECJIH B3HTb P;Pyrne 06JIaCTIf. HarrpIi-
Mep IIpllypaJIbe, TO Ta [ T,lI;me eCTb
B03MomHOCTb corrOCTaBIiTb <l>0:IbR.1l0P-
Hble p;aHHble C oTge.'IbHbD!II rrpOll3-
Bep;eHHHMH npmmap;Horo IlCh")'CC-TBa.
KOHe'lHO, HaH60JIee pacrrpOCTpaHeH-
HbIMH 6blJllI ClOmeTbl, OTBeqalOlII,lle
BKYcaM HaCeJIeHIlH. <DO.lbR':IOP Y;:1; [YP-
TOB cop;epmHT HeMa.TO rrpe:(aHIIll 0
nTHQax II 3BepHX, KOTopble B CBoell
QCHOBe BOCXOP;JlT R TOTeMrrqeCI;IJ [ rrpe,'];-
CTaBJIeHHHM. IIx <l>OJIblmOp HaCeJIllJI
JIeca qyp;OBHlII,aMIl, '!'TO HalIDO OTpame-
HHe B npHImap;HOM IlCh)'CCTBe cpeg-
HeBeROBbH. To me MomHO rro:( [eTIlTb
H Y HOMIl.
COBepmeHiIO eCTeCTBeHHO. qTO rrpo-
H3Bcp;eHHH rrpIIK.TIa gli oro IICIWCCTBa
elm<l>oB, mHpOIW pacnpOCTpa II 11 B'1I11I eCH
Ha TeppIITopliH EBpa:mn IT B hal;OH-TO
CTeneHIl OTBeqalOlII,lle pC:lIIrll03HblM
rrpep;CTaB.'1eHIlHM MeCTlloro lIaCP.TeIIIlH,
nOCJIYmHlliI rrpOTOTllrraMIi 11 .Ter.Tll B
OCROBY QeJIOH Cepf!II BeIl\e11. 8TII II3-
p;eJIHH COXpaHIlJIH pHr\ qepT. xapal;TCp-
HbIX p;.TIH CRlicPO-cI16I1pCI;oro :'!BepIIHo1'O
CTHJIH.' Op;IIaKo, cpaBHIlBaH cper\He-
BeKOBbIe MaTeplla:rbI co C!;l!cPCRllMH,
MbI P;OJIiI{RbI nOMHIITb (I oo.lbmoM
XpOHOJIOrllqeCKOM pa:'!pblBe. 00 OTCyT-
CTBIIH reHCTHqeC.IWH C.BH.m lemr\Y
CRllcPaMIl II 60nee n03:lHII [ II<\CC.1('HlleM
EBpa31l1l. Mbi r\a:H'IiIT (IT !hIC::IH
C'lHTaTb. qTO rYHHbI II TII >f'.'II'.TYIOIII,lle
BOJIHbI ROqeBHIIKOII 110.111(1( 1'1.10 nIeJIH
Bce Hace.leHIIe CTeTIIIofl '1;11''1'11. HecoM-
HeHHo, qaCTb Hace.TCI1IIH. (1I'lliieHrro Ha
rpaHIIII,ax eTeITeii II B .1ec 11101"( 1I<\:mcax,
I A. n. CMJlpHOB \
PEMI1HI1CQEHll;IU1
CKI1<DCROrO 3BEPI1HOrO CTn UI
CRllcPCRHH nepllop; B HCTOplllf EBpa31l1l
IlMeJI 60JIbmOe 3HaqeHHe B pa3BHTHH
KYJIbTypbl. CRllcPbl, ReJI:bTbI, cPpaKHHIJ,bI
II caRll CBH3aJIH ee HaCeJIeHHe C nepe
r\OBbfMll cTpaHaMH Toro BpeMeHH, Bo-
CTOROM H AHTH'lHbIM MHpOM, cbIrpaB-
mllM orpoMHYIO pOJIb B cPop rnpOBaHHIJ(
EBporreHCRoH QHBHJIH3aQHH. Op;HaHO
CKllcPbl 6bIJ11l He TOJIbRO nocpep;HHRaMH
Mem BOCTOROM, AHTH'IHblM MHpOM
n Enporroii, HO H caMH C03p;aJIH BbICo-
[-;YIO gJIH TOro BpeMeHIl HYJIbTYPY. OHH
OKa3aJIIl BJIIlHHHe He TOJIbRO Ha CBOHX
lIerrocpep;CTBeHHbIX cocep;ell H Ha OT-
;:1;aJIeHHble 06JIaCTli EB pa3llH. CRH<I>-
CRlIe Be pacrrpOCTpaHHJIIlCb Ha or-
pOMHOll TeppHTopllH, BI{JIlOqaH p;aJIeKHH
ceBep.
lIo CRll<l>CRIlM II aHTHqHblM npOTO-
THrraM MeCTHble MacTepa C03p;aBaJIH
CBOIl rrpOH3Bep;eRHH, p;aBmlle 3HaqH-
TeJIbHble <JBOJIIOII,Il0HHbIe PH:(bI Beru;ell,
1I03 Hlle CTa 1l ROTOpblX .J:OXOr\JIT P;O
HOBora BpeMenn. 8TO oc06eHHo HCHO
olIl,YII\aeTCH B TaRliX 06JIaCTHX, RaR
f1pIIypaJIbe, rp;e cyru;ecTBOBaJIa aHaHb-
IIHCKaH RYJIbTypa, pa3BIIBaB!IIaHCH nop;
HeI10Cpep;CTBeHHbl 1 B03p;ellcTBHeM caB-
pOMaToB.
B HaYRe yme neo;WoKpaTHo 06pa-
ru;a.'10Cb BHIlManne Ha CBH3b CRHcPcRoro
HCRyccTBa C 60JIee rr03.II:HIHI HCKYCCT-
BOM r\Pyrnx HapO,'];OB, He 06HapymHBa-
IOII\UX reHeTIl'leCROe pO,'];CTBO CO CRII-
cPaMII. TaR, B paDoTe B. A. rOpO.J:QoBa
TIpoC.TIemeHa CBH3b n03gHIIx H306pa-
242
COXpaHIlJIaCb II npop;OJImaJIa iRHT:b, pa3-
BUBaH cTapylO KYJThTYPY.
ECJIH Ha lOre TPYr\HO Dpuc e Tb B
JIaMHTHlIRax BTopon nOJIOBIIHbI I TblC.
;:1;0 B. <J. H B cpegHlle BeKa npoll3Bege-
HIIH HCRYCCTBa, ROTopble MOJRHO 6b1JIO
Dbl conOCTaBHTb co CKHcPCKIlMH, TO Ha
ceBepe, Ha'lIlHaH C 06JIacTII JIeCOCTenII.
peMHHlICQeIITI;IfH CRHcPCRoro HCKYCCTBa
qyBCTBYIOTCH COBepmeHHO HCHO. 3gecb
COXpaHHJIOCb CTapoe HaCeJIeHIIe, reHe-
Tll'IeCRlle ROpHII KOTQpOro MomHO rrpo-
CJIep;HTb C <JrrOXH paHHell 6pOH3bl. lIo-
<JTOMY COBepmeHHO eCTeCTBeHHO. '1TO
p;peBHlle <JJIeMeHTbl, B TOM '1HCJIe CRlIcP-
CRHe, coxpaHIlJIHC:b B KYJIbType nace-
.'1eHHH P;O O'leHb n03p;Hero BpeMeIIII.
CRllcPCRHfl 3BepillThIH CTHJIb xapaI;-
Tep1l3ye-rCH pJlP;OM CneQRcPHqeCRIIX
qepT, ROTopbIe HCIWIO'IaIOT B03MOiI;-
HOCTb omH60I, B era orrpep;eJIeHHIl.
PeaJIHCTIIqeCKHe nplleMbl nepe;J;aqll
B HeM BbIcTynalOT BeCbMa qeTRO. CO-
qeTaHCb CO cBoe06pa3HeM B nepep;aqe
rr03bl 3Bepen, C rro epRIlBaHlieM nJIe'la
II Rpyna, naCTIl H xapaRTepHbIX qepT
3BepH, CO cBoe06pa:UI!OH CTHJIH3aIlHeiL
1l3BeCTHOH geRopaTIlBHOCTblO, ROTopaH
xopomo qyBcTByeTcH B TaKHX BelIl,ax.
RaK ReJIepMeCCRaH naHTepa. 8TH OT-
geJIbH:bIe qepTbI B HeKoTopbIX paRoHax
coxpaHHIOTcH p;o n03p;Rero BpeMelIrr.
ECJIH rrpIlB.'Ie'lb p;peBHepyccRoe lICI;YC
CTBO, TO TaM MomHO BCTpeTIlTb rpJlcPo'
HOB H .'IbBOB. rr03a ROTOpbIX n TpaI;TOR-
Ra OTr\eJIbJlbIX qaCTen TeJIa HarrO I!II1a-
lOT CKIIcPCKIIe rrpOTOTHnbI.
B <JTO ! oTIIOIIIeHll1l 60raTbIll MaTcpIl'
aJi gaeT BJIa;1HMHpO-CY3gaJIbCI<oe 30.1-
qeCTBO. B 60raTellmeM p;eRope. IWTOPbli'r
HaCbIlI\eH xYr\omeCTBeHHbIMII 06pa3a 1II
TBOpqeCKOH cPaHTa3HH p;peBHepYCCRIIX
MaCTepOB, MomHO BCTpeTrrTb c.lOmeTbI.
rrepemegmne no HaCJIegcTBY H3 ,'];a.le-
Koro rrpom:TOro. 31J;eeb CJIe;rveT OTMe-
TilT I, rpIIcPOliOB II RpblJIaTblX 6apcOB.
:ThBOB. I1:!BeCTHbIX rro na IHTHIIRa 1
D:pcBIIei'1 PYClI C XI B. 8
243
9*
HeC OTpH Ha OrpOMHblii XpOHOJIOrU-
qeCI{UU paapbIB, HeJIb3J1 He OTMCTIITb
'11'0 06rqaJl rr03a mUBOTHbIX U TpaKTOB
Ka OT;J;CJIbHbIX 'IacTeii TeJIa HanOMUHa-
eT naMHTHUKU npUKJIap,Horo HCKYCCTBa
CKHcpOB. B CKUcpCKOM UCKYCCTBe Hepel];-
KH rpUcpOHbI C pacrrpOCTepiTbIMII KpbIJTh-
JlMII, COCTOJlIT{UMU U3 npOI];OJThHO TpaK-
TOBaHHbIX rrepbeB, II C nOJIypamq)bITOii
naCTbIO. TaKOBbI rpUCPOHbI Ha roJIOBHOM
y60pe U3 KypraHa BOJIl,maJl BJIU3HUI\a
B c eHe 60pb6bl BapBapOB C rpucpOHa-
MU . TaKoro me xapaKTepa u306pame-
Hue rpU<Ix>HOB, Tep3aIO x OJIeHJI, Ha
mlIpOKOnJIaCTlIfflJaTbIX 6paCJIeTaX U3
HYJIb-06bI '0. B 06IT{IIX '1epTax 3T1I
rpucpOHbI BecbMa CXO,!l,HLI Mem,!l,y c060ii
no caoeii TpaKToBKe.
HeCKOJIbKO rrO-IIHoMY, 60JIee ,!I,p06HO
;J;aHa pa3p,eJIKa KpbIJTheB Y rpucpOHa
Ha rrJIaCTIIHe H3 1'01'0 me KYPraHa
HYJIb-06a. HeJTh3J1 He OTMeTUTb rpHcpo-
ITa Ha HomHax qepTOMJIbI[{KOro Meqa.
llIupoKO pacrrpOCTepTLIe KpbIJIbJl ero
TpaKTOBaHbI B HlImHeii '1aCTII B BU;J;11
rrpO,!l,OJIbHbIX nOJIOC, a B epXHeH - B
BH,!I,e '1emyeK. MHTepeceH XBOCT rpucpo-
Ha, 3aKaH'IIIBaIOIT{HHCJI He60JThmOH
Th7 T " 11
nu" O'lKOI1 , BecbMa B03MomBO, rrpe,!l,-
meCTBeHHIIK ,!I,peBHepYCCKHX paCI\BeT-
mux XBOCTOB, KOTOpbIe BCTpeqaIOTcJI B
pa3JIU'IHbIX II306pameHHJlX B UCKYCCT-
Be p,peBBeH PYCII. CJIe,!l,yeT 3aMeTIITL,
'11'0 rrop,06HaJl TpaKToBKa KOHI\a XBOCTa
B BU,!I,e KUCTO'IKU. rOJIOBKU nTIII\bI IIJIII
rrpocTo YTOJIIT{eHIIJI 6bma mIIpoKo pRC-
rrpocTpaHeHa B ClmcpCKOM I!CKyccTBe.
MOiRHO BcnoMHIITb 6pOH30Boe HaBep-
liTIle 113 HpaCHOKYTCKoro KypraHa co
CKy.TIbnTypHOH CPUryPOH rpucpOHa, 30-
JIOTYIO IIJlaCTIIHy C peJIbecpHbnI u306-
paiReHueM .'IbBa, pa3,!1,UpaIO cro OJIeHH,
U3 CeMu6paTHeHCKoro KypraHa '", 30.'1:0-
Tble 6JIH III KII B BIIp,e ccpIIHKca 13
U KpbmaToro .l:bBa U3 KypraHa 17 y
H IBI(f>eH 1<.
BeCbMa nOKa3aTeJIbHa naHTepa Ha
nO KoBo06pa3HoR 6JIRxe 113 KypraHa
Y jf'YPOBKII, 06bPIHaJI ]J.JIH CKHcpCKOf()
UCI,ycc'TBa. XBOCT ee 3aKaH'IUBaeTCJI
P,BY IH CnIIpaJIJlMU 15.
C,IeJlyeT TaIDKe 01'MeTHTb AeKopa-
'Itn>HOCTb B TpaKTOBKe TeJIa iRIIBOTBbIX.
G:epTR :na Hau.TIIOp,aeTCH U B u306paa,c-
HIIII mlIBOTHbIX B UCKyccTBe ,!I,peBHeR
PYCII, HanpuMep, u306paiReHUJI rplIcpo-
Ha II nTIII\bI cupuHa Ha CTeHe feoprlI-
eBCI,oro c060pa. Op,uHaKoBa n03a, TaR
mc Tpal,TOBaHbI KpbIJIbJl B BII,!I,e npo-
;W.'IbllbIX liO.10C, UMUTlIpYIOIT{UX nepbJl.
G.'IegyeT OTMeTUTb Hape3KH U BOJIIOTbI
Ha 6ep,pe rpucpOHa U ero paCI\BeTmUR
XBOCT. Tar, me ,!I,eKOpaTuBHo npep,CTaB-
JleBa U liTIII\a CUpUH. B 1'011 me MaHe-
pe p,aH II KeHTaBp, 3BepuHoe TYJIOBIIIT{e
KOTopor 6 3anOJIHeHO pa3JIIIqHblMlI BO-
.'IIOTaMII . B PYCCKOM IICKy'ccTBe MOiR-
HO BCTpeTIITb U 3BepeR C nOBepHYToR
Ha3a.l ro.TIOBoii. IIoKa3aTe.'1eH JIeB
ITIIIpOl,O npe,!l,CTaRJIeHHbIii B apxlITeK
TYpc II OhlTOBbIX npe,!l,MeTaX ,!I,peBHei!
PYCII II B IICR)'CCTne HOBOro BpeMeHu.
B c'KllijJCKO 1 UCKYCCTBe JIeiRaIT{uR JIeB
(B03 lomIlo, IIaHTepa) B aHa.TIOrn'lHOii
MaHop" II3BeCTeH Ha 30JIOTOif pejJb-
ecpBoii 6:IHITIKe U3 YJIbeKOro aYJIa. Ero
n03a, rJIa3 II YXO, TparcroBaHHbIe B
BII;J;C Ilo:ryccpeplI'IecKoro yrJIy6JIeHUJI,
II XBOCT. 3al{aH'IIIBaIOIT{uRcH neTJIei!,
HanO!.IlIHaIOT ,!I,peBHepyccKHe CIOiReTbI.
B.TILn,a y.TIhCKOMY 6JIJlITIKa C JIeiRaIT{IIM
JThBO 1 1I3 KypraHa )J;opT-06a ". TaKoro
iRC xu pa KTepa 6.TIJlITIKH Ha KO.TI'IaHe U3
BiiTOBOii IOnIJIbl 18.
Pyrclwe nplIKJIa,!l,HOe UCKYCCTBO 3Ha-
CT cpIlrYPbI JIbBOB, JIeiRam;Re 6<JKOM
C ro.lo!HJii. nOBepHYToR K 3pUTCJIIO,
OCKaJIeHHoii naCTbIO U XBOCTOM, 3a-
6pOIIIl'H IIbnr 3a cnlIHY. IIoBepxlIocTb
TC.la I101;pbITa p,eKopaTUBIThIMII Y30pa-
!II. I<OTOphle( nO-BHro'IMO?tIY, 03Ha'laIOT
MhllIIl\l,l. ITfJi\05HbIe CPUryPbl MOiRHO
YI;a:JRTh B .\ KOpe feoprneBcKoro co-
60pa IS IOpbcBe.IIoJThcKoM. B TaKOR iRe
n03C :11,111,1 ::raHbl B )J;MIITpOBCKOM CO-
60pe Bo B:r, ap,Il?t[lIpe rp,e OHII nOMeIT{e-
HbI B nHTax apol, 19 II B IJ,epKBIi IIOKpO-
Ba-Ha-Hep.'II!. TaKoro mc xapaKTepa
JIbBbI coxpaUI!.'InCb p,o n03p,Hero BpC-
MeHU. OHI! II3ReCTHbI B apxllTeKTYP-
HOM y5paHCTBC KpeCTbJIHCKIIX ,!I,OMOB
BepxHeli BO.lfII B npcp,e.lax fOpbKOB-
CKOR 06.lacTII. A. A. B06plIHCKllM 1I3-
,!I,aHa 3BaqllTe.lhHaH cepliH TaKllX 1I306-
paiRCHIIII. On onllCbIBaeT ,!I,epCBJlHHbIe
cplIrypbI .1em,Ul\IIX JThBOB Y nO OiRIIH
KJIUpOCOB n3 II.lhIIHCKOiI I\epKBIi B Hpo-
CJIaBJIe. fO.TOllhl I1X rroBepHYTbI Ha3a,D;,
rpUBbI TpaKTOBaHbl B BIIp,e BO.1IIIIICTbIX
pHp,OB. B 60.1('1' cTporoiI ?t[aHepe IICnOJI-
HeHO II305paiRl'HIIC .1bBa 113 MY3CJI Te-
HRITIeBOI!. o n\" O:III KOBalIHoe A. A. Bo-
6pIIucKIBr 00. . Ihr me ony6JIRKOBaHa
cplIrypa CTOHll\Cro JIbBa, C TOR me
TpaKTOBKOII Tl':la ILl HOBropop,cKoii:
ry6epHIUI 0'. cTJlI ryphl .'JbBOB B APcBHe-
pyccKml II IIOBO I IICKYCCTBC pe3KO 01'-
JIIIqa[OTCH 01' CBORX CKlIcpCKIIX npoTo-
TlIrrOB c'Boeoopa3IIeM OCKaJIa MOp,!l,bI
H oc06eHII0 paCI(BeTIliIIM XBOCTOM. ECJIU
B CKlIcpCKO?t[ IIC I;YCCTBe 31'01' CIOiReT
TO!IbKO Ha?treqCIJ. TO B ,!I,peBHepYCCKOM
OH nOJIY'III.L cno!' ;{aJIbHellmee pa3BU-
TRe II npe;:\CTaB.'Jeli pJl,!l,OM lIapHaHTOB.
Oc06eHHO 60raTO I'! pa3Ho06pa3HO OH
Hcno.'1b30narr B PYCCIWM Hapop,HOM UC-
KYCCTBf' HOBorn Bpl' relIl!.
<Durypbl CToHn ux U.'IU UAYIT{UX
JIbBOB 6blJlJI O'!ClJb nonYJIJlpHbI B cpe -
BlIe BeKa. 11:1: \lOmiiO YI{a3aTb U B HC-
KYCCTBe )J;YH,tiirl\oii II BOml\CKOii Bo;r-
raplIII, r c II1HI'rTHhl nplIBecHhle neqa-
'III C 11306parl,ClJlIe 1 u,rr;yIT{ero JIbBa, C
paCIJ;BeTIIIl1\1 :\ 1I0CTmi. JIcB B UCKYCCT-
Be 3THX CTpa II II B.'JH:ICH roCY,!I,apCTBeH-
HOli :nI6.1f' !Oii F(':I1I B p,peBHelI Pycu,
He CBH3aRIIO(1 rCneTII'ICCKII?1U Y3aMlI
C IIpaHCKIBI \IIIPO I, Bce eIlIe coxpaHU-
.'1IICh pPBHITI' n(jpa3bI 3Bepeii B npu-
K.'1a;J:BO 1 nrl;\"'l'Tne, TO COBepITIeHHO
rrOHHTHO, '1T1, I ill;lIe CJIe;:\bl p,o.lmHbI
XOpOllIO liP(J('I,',J,IIIJaTbCJI B npIIK.'Ia,l-
110\1 IICKYCCTI\' , BO,lIKCKUX U )J;YHaii-
CK!!X 6YJJrilp. 1;"Topoe qepe3 capMaT-
244
clwe HaCJIep,Ue 6bIJIO TCCHO CBH3UII0 co
CKIIcpo-capMaTCKUM MlIpOM II. ero ueKYC-
CTBOM. 81'0 oe06eHHo IIHTepeCHO nOTO-
MY, '11'0 BOJI)HCKaH BOJIraplIH 6hI.'J<1
CTpaHOH MYCYJIbMaHCKoii II 11306paiRP-
HIIP mIIBOTHbIX U JIIOp,ell: 3p,eCh 3anpe-
IT{aJIOCb. II paBp,a, 31'0 3anpel.I\f'Hile He
6bIJIO a6COJIIOTHblM U 1I306pamf'HIIH ;r;n-
BOTHbIX npop,oJImaJIu 6bIToBaTh Ha BceM
npOTHiReHIIU UCTOplIU 6YJJrap. ITplI IIC-
CJIep,OBaHIIII ropo)J;uIT{a Be.1IIKIIe BOJlra-
pbI Heop,HOKpaTHO Haxop,II.'J1I pa3JIUqHble
rrpe,!l,MeTbI, B KOTOpbIX TOJIbKO OT,!I,a.'IeB-
no yraAbIBaJIOCb 1I306paiReilUe iRIIBOT-
Horo. B 3TOM OTHomeHIIII llHTepeCHa
PYKOJlTKa Homa. Ee 3anOJIlIpOBaHBaH
nJIaCTIIHa 6blJIa nOKpbITa P,BY IH pJIAa-
MII [{lIpR)'JIbHOrO opHaMeHTa, BMeCTO
rrOCJIe,!I,Hero KpymKa C,!I,e.laHO OTBepc-
THe. TOp[{OBaJl '1aCTb cBeAcua HCCKO.lb-
KO Ha yroJI. B [{eJIOM nJIaCTIIHa 3aCTaB-
:DIeT BcrrOMHUTb paHIIIIC II3AC:II1J1
CKHcpCKO 1'0 HCR)'CCTBa, r;J;e B 11.10C 1;01[
pe3b6e rrepe,!l,aeTCJI u306pamCBIIe OC-
KaJIeHHOll: 3BeplIHOH MOpp,bI. nCp€AI\O C
BbIBOpO'leHHL!MII ry6aMII. IT.'IaCTIIIII,a
II:! paCKorrOK BYJ'Irap 3 all: ?tIe l' B ::JTO\I
pHp,y nOCJIep,Hee MeCTO no CBOl'li I;paii-
Hei! YCJIOBHOCTU, Kor,!l,a p,eTaJIlI 3BepII-
Hoil MOpp,L! 3aMCHeHbl reOMeTpIIqf'CI>IBI
opHaMCHTOM.
HeCKOJIbKO ,!I,Pyroro xapaKTepa nJJac-
THHa C BbIpe3aHHoii: Ha Heii ro.'Jonoii:
ceBepHoro OJIeHJI. OHa Uhl.'Ia naii.lcIIa
B 1948 r. Ha BepXHeM nJIaTO ropO;\II-
IT{a U rro cTpaTlIrpacpUqeCIm\{ .la II III ,1\1
gaTupyeTcJI n03;J;ueii cTa;J:IIcH :W:WTI'-
OpW>IHCKOro rre, pUO,!l,a BepOHTHee !I(',,-
ro XIV B. 22 CaMa IlJIaCTIIHa lJeRl':III-
Ka - 2,5X2 CM. M306paiRCUHf' rn.lOBI.I
aHo B peaJIIICTUqeCKOii MaHepp, "'"10'
?t[IIHafI cTapbIe II3p,eJJIIH YpaJI<11110\ II
6pOH3bI II rOJIOBR)' .10CJI C ITIl;!,,')!< I:.)
1'0 1'0 pO,!l,1IIT{a, p,aTIIpycMYIO nbHJlO""P-
CKI!?t[ BpeMeneM. ITpaBAa. rrOCIf':lllll!'
OTHOCJlTCH K npoII3Be)J;eHIIH\1 Rbll'l't;III'(,
IIcKyccTBa. IIJIaCTilHa iRe, - HaiiY'IIII<lH
B BOJIrapax, OTHOCUTCH K qnc.1Y !,jl,!O-
245
3MX peMeCJICHHblX 113I1;eJIlIii. CaMblii
i{OIlTYP ee Bblpe3aH HOlliOM. HenYlli-
IbIC Y'IaCTKll KOCTII YII;aJIeHbI. Ha I1JIa-
TllHe COXpaHIIJIaCb Mopll;a C rJIa30M,
IIaHeCeHHbIM QlIpKYJIbHblM opHaMeH-
rOM. Pora IIAYT B ABYX HarrpaB::ICHU-
IX - Brrepell; II Ha3all;. CorrOCTaB:IIITb
H'O co CKII<pCKIIM HCKYCCTBOM lI;aeT I1pa-
BO TOJIbKO 60JIbmOe '1IICJIO II;Pyrnx Be-
QeH 6YJIrapCKOH KYJIbTypbl, BOCXOII;II-
QIIX K CI\JI<po-capMaTCKoii I<Y.lbType.
Cpell;lI HHX Hall;o YKa3aTb cpOp Ibl COCY-
II;OB H HX opHaMeHT, PY'IKH, TpaKTOBaH-
Hble B BlIlI;e <PlIrypoK 3BepelI, rrpIPIeM
IIMeIOTCIl <pllrypKII, lI;aTlIpyeMbIe :10JIO-
TOOpp;LIHOKHM BpeMeHeM. B l<aqCCTBe
aHaJIOrHlI 60JITapCKOMY I1306pa;r{rHIIIO
OJIeHH B CKlIcpCKOM IICKYCCTBe MOlliHO
YKa3aTb HaIl\IITHYIO 6JUlxy C pc.1becp-
IIb1M 11306pallielllIeM JIelliaIT rrO 0.1eHH
1I3 KypraHa 1 Y CTaRIITI!,1 I\oCTpoM-
cKoii 23. Y3KaH meH, BblTIIIIYTall lOp-
II; a , KPyrJIbrn rJIa3, pora B BIIJ,e J,RYX
3aBIITKOB, HarrpaBJIellHbIX BIIepPr\. II
OCTaJIbHbIX, rrepell;allHblX pH.!IOM BOJIIOT
rrpOTHHYTbIX BII;OJIb CIIIIHbl. B O:III31{oii
MaHepe TpaKToBaHbl pora O:leHH rra ;JO-
JIOTOH pe.1fbecpHoll 6JIIITH I<C 1I3 BToporo
CeMlI6paTHcro KypraHa. a TaKr/<C Ha
30JIOTOii HaIT IITI!OiI 6JIHXC [[3 KypraHa
RYJIb-06a. KYJIb060mn 0.1CHb rJT:Ili'la-
eTCH OT ceMlI6paTHcro TOJIbKO J,cI<opa-
TllBHOII pa3l1;emWll: I10BCpXHOCTIT Tc.'1a,
3arro.1JHelIITOll pa:J.1JHqIlbDIII (fm rypaMlI
3BepeR ". ITpIIBc):\eHHh[p BPIIIII HC.IIO
CBIIII;eTeJIbCTBYIOT 0 lIa.1!i'II1!1 napOII
CKII<pCKOii Tpall;lI! IIII. JWTOpaH \fJpOTIIO
rrpoc.1CllilIBaeTCIl H rr:raCTJllTa"l: !I B RII-
II;C 3BeplIIIoii MOPl!;bl C OCKa.'IPI!IInii rra-
CTbIO II B HIIII;e rO:IOBbl O:IPIIH.
CIUlcpoaIC Tpa):\llQIIII ObI.m I)<'Ch ra
CII:lbHbl II B AYHaiieKoii G'l.lfi\PlllI.
KpOMP BblIIIeYKa3aHTlOrO :Ihll.\ ,< "aqe-
CTBe rocy):\apCTBeHHoii "mOJIP'!!'1 !Olli-
110 HaIlOMHIITb 06,'10 J{)!{ r:I11I1HH"I'O CO-
CYII;a C 1I306pallieHlIe [ O.'Il'IIH ;!' ropo-
lI;a fopHa MOHaCTbJplIll\C' ().lenb
II306pallieIJ .'IelliaIl\HM C 110:101 !I 'TbIMII
1I0raMll, C ro.1JoBoii, 1I0BepHYTOH Ha3ap;,
II c poraMIL K COlliaJIeHHIO, 0 TpaKTOB-
l<e 1I0CJIell;HllX MI.l CYII;IlTb He MOllieM.
Cox paHllJIOCb TOJIbKO OCHOBaHlIe. B aTOM
OJIeHe Bce HarrOMIIHaeT CTapbIe CI<II<p-
CKlIe 06pa3b1: II 06Il\aH rr03a, II 110-
JIOllieHlIe Hor, II TpaKTOBKa KOllbIT.
I3 6YJIrapCKRX 3eMJUlX 3aMeTHO Ha-
CJIell;CTBO II CKlI<po-capMaTClwe, H <ppa-
l<IIllCKoe.
CoxpaHII.'IlICb rrepellilITKII CTaporo
CIUI<po-capMaTCKoro nCKYCCTBa II Y
cpIIHHo-yrOpCKIIX rrJIeMeH, HaCeJIHBmIIX
06JIacTb llplIypaJIbH. CJIe,lQ'eT 3aMe-
TIITb, qTO 1I311;eJIHH CTerrHHKOB 1I0CTY-
rraJIII Ha ceBep B IIpOp;OJDReHlIe Bcero
CKlI<po-capMaTCKoro rreplIolI;a. Mx MOlli-
HO HaHTlI II B IIplIKaMbe, H Ha 1I06e-
pellibe BeJlOro MOpH. OTII;em.Hble H31!;e-
.TIlIl lI;aHbl B xapaRTepHoii CKII<PCKOH
MaHepe, II OT CBOIIX rrpOTOTHrrOB OHlI
OTJIll'laIOTCIl TOJIbKO 60JIbmOH rpy60-
CTbIO.
M3 aTlIX rrpe)J;MeToB CJIeAYeT OTMe-
TIITb qJlIrYPY CTOIIrn;ero H03JIa, KOTOpaJl
YKpamaeT CTaJIbIIbIC I1JIaCTllllbl Kpeca-
.'1a. K03eJI CTOllT na Horax C rOJIOBOH,
rroBepHYToii lIa3all;. OIl;IIH por crrycI<a-
CTCH Brrepell;II. TeJIo rroKpblTo rrOJIOca-
MH II BOJIIOTaMII, KOTopbIe lIMllTIIPYIOT
MblIITD;bI. OH![ oc06eHHO '1eTKO rrOKa3a-
IIbI IIa rrJIeqe II Kpyrre. TaKlIe II311;eJIlIJI
BCTpeqeIIbl B lIaMHTHIIKax qerrQbI, Ha
ropoll;IIII\aX KaMbl II B llpII6aJITIII<e.
o II II . 1I;0CTaTO'IHO xopomo lI;aTlIpYIOTCJI
X B. II03J,nee lIa'lIIHaeTCH CTlIJIlI3aQlIII,
II BCH <pIIrypa rrpeBpaIl\aeTcH B opHa-
MeHTaJIbHb1ii Y30p. BJI1I3I<oii aHaJIomeii
HamHM K03JIaM B TpaKToBKe rOJIO-
Bbl, MbIlIIIl IOlliHO YKa3aTb rrapaAlIblH
TOIlOp 1I3 I\eJIepMeCCKoro KypralIa,
06ymoK KOToporo YKparnaIOT <pHrypHH
.'1elliaIl\IIX KOitlOB. lloBepHYTall Ha3all;
ro.10Ba, cIIycRaIOIl\IIll:CH por II BO.1IOTbI,
IIMlITlIpYIOIl\IIe MblmQbl, He OCTaB.'1HIOT
COMlleHIIII B 6JIH30CTII aTIIX BeIl\ell 26.
K03.'lbi B TaKoH llie 1I03e YKparnaIOT
KOJIqaH 113 BIITOBOH MOrHJIbi Ha BOpKC-
.'Ie 27. CKIIcpCKIIe IIpOTOTllIlbi BbIIlOJIHe-
Hbl B 60nec peaJIIICTll'leCKOii MaHepe H
J,aIOT rrpell;CTaBJIeHIIe 0 BblCOKOM IIC-
KycCTBe. ITpliKaMcKlIe cplIrypbl X B. BbI-
rrOJIHeHbl BeCbMa rpy60. O):\Hal<O CJIe-
;J:yeT oTMeTIITb, '1TO He TOJIbKO rr03a, HO
II ):\eTaJIll, KaK TO: rrepell;aqa MblmQ-
BeCbMa 6JIII3KlI CKlIcpCKIIM rrpOTOTHrraM.
CJIeJ,yeT OCTaHOBIITbCH Ha QeJIOR ce-
pIlII I1TllQ, BbirrOJIHeHHblX B pa3JIII'IHOH
MaHepe. Hall60JIee paHHlIe 1I3 HIIX OT-
IIOCIITCH K CKII<PCKOMY rrepHOAY, HaH6o-
.1ee I10311;HHe lI;aTHpYIOTCH BpeMeHeM
XI-XII BB. PaHHHe 3K3eMrrJIHpbl IIpO-
nCXO):\IIT 1I3 rJIIIII;eHOBCKoro KOCTH a,
J,aTllpOBKa KOToporo Bbl3BaJIa 60JIbDIHe
crropb!. qacTb IICCJIel!;OBaTeJIeii OTHOCHT
):\peBHeHmlIH ero llJIaCT K aHaHbHHCKOH
:moxe (VI - V BB. o. H. a.) Ha OCHO-
BaHIIII 06HapYllieHHblx B HeM CKH<p-
CI\IIX cTp.eJI II MIIHlIaTIOp, rrOBTopHIO-
II\IIX CKII<pCKHe H capMaTCKlIe 06pas-
I\bI 28 . K rrOCJIell;HIIM CJIell;yeT OTHeCTH
PHil; 1I306pallieHIIII, HarrOMIIHalOIl\IIX
n<Il<pCKlIe rrpOTOTlIrrbl. B rrepBYIO
()qepell;b BcrrOMHIIM cplIrYPbl rrTHQ H3
\1e.'IbrYHOBCKoro KJIa):\a 29. B aTIIX H30-
6pallieHHHX, lIepel!;aHHblX B peaJIIICTH-
'1eCKOB: MaHepe, MOlliHO BCTpeTIITb TOJIb-
KO He3Ha'illTeJIbHblP rrplI3HaKlI p;eKO-
paTIIBHoro a.'IeMeHTa. TaKoBa HemHpo-
Kall I10JIOCKa opHaMeHTa C rrOllepe'lHbI-
Mil HaCe'lKaMII 30. (hOT 06pa3 rrTHQbl
rrpocYIl\ecTBOBaJI BeCbMa 1I;0JIro II B He-
n:JMeHHOM BIIII;e, TOJIbKO B GoJIee rpy-
60ii rrepell;aqe 1I3BeCTeH cpeAR BeIl\eii
X B. H. a. 3\. OIl;Horo:IoBbIe rrTIII(bl, 3a-
rrMCTBOBaHHble 1I3 CKII<pcKoro IICKYC-
CTBa. ;tOBOJIbHO 6b1CTpO I1peTeprreJIH 1I3-
leHeHllH, rrOHBll,'IIICb J\eTaJIII, nOll;qep-
KIIBaIOIl\lIe XllIl\HbII[ cBlIpenblii xapaK-
Tep ;JToii rrTIIQbI. KpoMe Toro, Ha rpy-
;\II I1TIII(bI I10IIB.1JlIeTCIl 1I306pallieHlIP
.1I1Qa, qTO CBII3aHO C I1poQeccoM aHTpo-
110MopcplI3aQIIII 60lliecTB. STOT I1poQecc
B ITpnypaJIbe y rrpell;KOB YII;MypTOB H
J{OMII HaqaJICIl paHO, eIl\e B I TbIC.
o H. 3. 3aCJIYlliIIBalOT BHHMaHlI1I
246
llieHCKlie JIIII(a, KOTOph!C xopomo corro-
CTaBJIHIOTCH C 06pa30M Me):\YSbi. 3TlI
JIIII(a OBaJIbHOlr CPOPMbI C KpaCHBO
TpaKTOBaHHblMII r.1a3aMll, C 6POBHMH,
060SHa'leHIIbIMII O):\Hon JIIIHlIeH H OBaJIb-
HbiM pTOM. lIHor):\a 01i1I 6bIBaIOT OKpy-
llieHbI BOJI1l.IICTblMII .'IlIHIIHMH. HarrOMH-
HaIOIl\IIMH cpIlrypbI 3Mell:. TaKHe UJIa-
CTHHbI lI;aTlIpYIOTCH llblIH060pCKlIM Bpe-
MeHeM OT II B. 11;0 H. 3. 11;0 III-IV BB.
H. 3. 32 .
llOHBJIeHlIe \L\BYX- II TpexrOJIOBblX
rrTIIQ - HBJIeHlIe Yllie MeCTHoe, He CBH-
3aHHoe C IICKYcc'TBO [ CKHcplIII. Ho CJIe-
II;veT OTMeTIITb '1epTY, KOTopaH MOllieT
6b1Tb CBH3aHa CO CKIICPCKIIMII IIpOTOTII-
rraMH - sarro.1HeBile I1JIaCTIIH pa3JIlIq-
liblMH 06pa3aMlI rrTIIQ, 3BepeB, 3MeH, a
IIHorl!;a II remreTplI'ICCI<IIMII y30paMlI 33.
B CKII<pCKOM IICKYCCTBe lIMe eTCH ell\e
OIl;IIH 06pa3 XIIIl\HOii rrTIIQbI, pa3ARpal6-
Il\elI He60JIbIIIOe qCTBepoHoroe. B KYP-
raHe 4 CeMII BpaneB 6b1JIa HaHII;eHa
TpeyroJIbHall I1JIaCTIlIIa C II306pallieHH-
eM IITllQbI, Tepaa KJlI\eii 3aHQa". STa
TeMa B IT pIlypaJIbC I10JI)"'I1I.1a mlIpOl<oe
pacrrpOCTpaHeHlle. l\IolliHO YKa3aTb pHI!;
HaBepmlIii llblIHOOOpC!wro H JIOMOBa-
TOBCKoro BpPMeIIlI, Ha KOTOpblX rrpell-
CTaBJIeHbl liE-OOJI hlllITe 3BepbKlI H na
HIIX clIlI;HIl\lIe nTUUbl, pa311;lIpalOIl\llC
rrOBepllieHlIoe lliIlHOTIIoe 35. IIplIBell;eM
eIl\e cplIrypy C.01\0.1<1 C I10.'IYIIOII;HHTblMH
KpblJIbllMll, Bh!I1(J. IIICHIIYIO B peaJIIICTII-
qeclwii MaHepc II HOC X O):\IIIIIYIO , IIJO-BII-
II;IIMOMY, I, CKIHf)(' "" I npOTOTllrraM.
KpOMe 06paa<l IITIII\hl, OqeHb rroIlY-
JIlIpHOrO B npUK.li1JJIOM llCKYCCTBe Ha-
CeJIeHlI1I ITplII<aMhlI paHHero cpell;HeBe-
KOBbH, BOCXO IIJl(l' I'U h: TOTeMlIqeCKHM
npel1:CTaB.'ICIIITHM. <I '1<'.\1 MOlliHO CY.'I,IITb,
COIlOCTaBJIHH I1[w.I.\leThl I1pIIKJIa):\Horo
IICKYCCTBa C CP();! h".I('PH'bDIii ;J:aHHbIMII,
lOlliHO YKa3,lTh 1'111" \lP,IYIO ceplIIO 1I30-
6palliCHuii lliIIB<I I 111,1 \, ITpellill;e Bcero,
3TO cpllrYPbI II;\ 'lllil \ o:I8neii C poraMII,
I1pOTIIHYTbDIII 1I,lI1.11, T8.1a. Pora lI;aHbl
B BlIlI;e plIlI;a BO:""T. KOTopble xapal{-
247
TepHbI it:IH ClHIcPClw1'O lICI-;YCCTBa.
B Ka'lPCTBe iIpllMepa YKameM nOJIYIO
qIHrYPKY O;WHH 113 I eJIepMl'cCKoro KYP-
raRa 36, OJleliH 113 Kyp1'ana I\YJIb-06a
II pHAa APyrlIx 37. K COmaJIPRIlIO, AO-
BOJIbnO ne lHoroqIlC,'IennbIe npuypaJIb-
CKlle n:IaCTllIlhl OCTalOTCH ne aTlIpo-
BaRHLIMII.
PaCCMaTplIBall cPllrypKlil: 3Bepen H3
IIpllypaJIbll, Momno 3aMeTIlTb, 'ITO
TpaKTOBl\a rJT I':IbHLIX 'laCTen TeJIa BOC-
XOAHT K CI;I1cPCKMM npo06pa3a I. O'leHb
xa paKTepnbI OCl-;a.rJeHnble J\10p;J.bI C PH-
AOM 3y60B, M306pamennLIX B BIlAe Tpe-
yrOJIbnIlKOB, pe:mo O'lep'lelInble KJlblKll,
3aKpyrJIeHlIbiC Kpall paCKpbITon naCTH
O'lenb O:II1 lm C""'cPCKIlM. IIOBepXIIOCTb
IICIWTOPbIX cPuryp nOKpblTa naCe'lKa m,
lIanmIIIHalOlI IIMII BepeBO'lHbIll opRa-
MeHT na I\pecTo06pa3nbIX 6JIIIxax H3
OJIbBUll. Tal-; rKe xapaKTepHa II TpaK-
TOBKa TpeY1'OJIbRoro yxa 38. BecbMa no-
Ka3aTeJIbna cPlIrypa MeABeAII, H306pa-
mennoro B II POcPIlJIb, C ony eRnoii:
MOPAoR II il0'YTOM, npoxoJUl nM BAOJIb
CnllHbi. Koponme 1I0TII 3al\aH'IIIBa1OT-
CII l\OfTIICTI,I m :WllaMIl. Ha n.le'laX n
6ep;pax u:loopamPllbl cnIlpa.llI, I,OTO-
pLIe, 1I0-Bll;W:l10MY, nepeAalOT lbIIll bI.
B.111I31\0e n:J06pamenlle MeABeAIl MOmno
YKa3aTb na IwcTlInoii: PYKoHTKe noma
C ol(Tloro II.! BHTCfilIX ropOAll . TaM
MeABeAb II:JoGpamen npllceBmHM, no
ero I{OnT 'p. Tpal;:ToBKa MOPAb!, JIan H
lIIbIlllll, cOBepUiPHno llAenTH'lnbI. TaKali
me cPurYPI;i1 Jr.\BeAII C BOJIIOTaMIl, HO,
nO-BIIAIB((I 1 \. Gonce n03Anero BpeMenM
I1;\BeCTRa C f1'''I'IPbl. C.1e YPT :Ja IPTnTh,
'ITO PYI-;OHTI"1 1I0ma 113 KamMpCl\Oro
rop01J;IfIli<l " u.l06pamenHeM ro.TJOBb!
\ B. ..1. r"p. "" '8. ;:J:al,o-cap laTCl>lIe pe.ll -
rnO lIhlP :<:!"\lCnTbI n PYCCKO ( HapO;\HOM
THOpq"OBI' "TpYllbI fH1\h, BbIll. I. M.,
1926.
2 ll.. H. .C,:". ",'. AIITpOIIO- II 300 (OP<PHble
<pllOy.lbl !\',,'TO'lIIOll EBponbi. Y3HH3KB,
T. II. f. 1'1:'1').
3 .'1..1 -' 'i 'r.. ,. .J:peBHlle qepTbI B PYCCIWM
MeABeJUl C OCl-;aJIeliliOH naCTblO Tal,iRe
xopomo ConOCTaBJIlIeTCII Co CIWcPC"IIMU
u306pamenlIIIMIl no OCKaJIY lOp)1LI II
TpeyrOJIbnhIM 3y6aM. ::ha PYI,OHTI;a no
cBoe:ii. KORCTPYKI\1I1l C6JIIlit<aPTCH co
CI;I1cPCKIlMIl. Ha ee nllmHeR rpa 1111 C !l;e-
J!all npope3, KYAa BCTaBJIII.'1CII 'll'pCHOK
Homa R 3aKpen:I1IJICII 1'B03Allh:a 1II 19.
ITOA CKIl<PcKIlM BJIIlHlIHeJII C.'IO:+;lUCII
06pa3 CBepnYBlllerOCII B KJIy60h :+;11 BOT-
noro. 3AeCb, KpoMe ApaKoHa, IO;(;:HO
YKa3aTb ne60JIbmoro 3BepbKa, y "OTO-
poro 3aAnile nom conpllKacalOTcli C
MOPAoii:. B CKHcPCKOM IICKYCCTBe 0.111-
maBmllMM anaJIornHMIl IIB.'1IIIOTCII Y3-
Ae'lRbIe 6JIHXIl B BIlAe rOJIOBbi .1bBa 113
Kyprana y iKypaBKIl '0, B BIlAe CBep-
nYBmerocH KOJIbD;OM XIllII;lIIII,a n3 KYP-
rana RYJIaKOBcKoro'l, B BHAe peJlbecP-
non rOJlOBbI rpHcPona 113 30JlOT01'O I;:YP-
rana U II !l;pyrne YKpameRll1I Y3AeqHbIX
Ra60pOB '3. Becb MaTepllaJI, IWTOpblM
pacnOJIaraeT apXeOJIOrIlJl, CBIlAeTe.'1bCT-
ByeT 0' mllpolwM pacnpocTpallcRll1l
TpaAHI\IlIl CKMcPcKoro lICKYCCTBa. !{ PO-
Me ApeBlIeR PYCIl II IIpHKaMblI, lOmno
nplI6aBIlTb CeBepnblR KaBI;:a:J, :1a I<aB-
Ka3be, 06JIaCTlI CpeAnen A31111, r;w TIiK-
me PIiA ClOmeTOB CKHcPCK01'O HC "YCCTBa
II TpaKTOBKa 3TIIX 06pa:WB OpralllI'le-
CKIl Bn;re.'1IlCb II MeCTRoe lICKYCCTBO II
rrOCJIymllJIIl npOTOTlInaMIl AJIII 311<1'111-
TeJIbnhIX ceplln Be eB. XponOJIOrllqe-
CKIlB pa pblB H OTCYTCTBlle npmll';«Y-
TOqnhIX THnOB 3aTpYARIIIOT ana.TJILJ Ia-
TepRaJIa. ,r:(aJlhHeii:mee Ral\On.leRIJI' era
nO'IBOJm:T npOTlInYTb nOBbie lIMTl!. CBIl-
3blBaIO lle CKllcPCKoe MCKYCCTBO C TBOp-
'leCTBOM napOAOB CCCP.
llllll nep}ICIWrO 3Beplllloro CTIIJUI. I\IA3,
T. VI. J1., 1926.
· B. A. Pbl6aKo8. YKaa. .cO'l., CTp. 408.
7 Ta ! me.
8 B. A. Pb/UaK08. YKa3. COq., CTp. 408.
· M. H. ApraMOlto8. COI;poBIII a CI;II<pCKIiX
KypraHOB. npara - J1., 1966, TaOJI. 284.
.0 TaM me, TaOJI. 236, 237, 238.
\I TaM me, TaOJI. 185.
'2 TaM me, Ta6JI. 120.
13 TaM me, TaOJI. 99.
" TaM me, Ta6JI. 101.
15 ltf. lJ. ApraMOlto8. YI;a3. COq., TaOJI. ii.
\. B. A. Pbl6aKo8. nplIKJIallHOe IICKYCCTBO I!
CKY;JbIITypa. «I1cTOpliH RY:IbTypbl ,!\peB-
HeII PYCII9, T. II. M.- J1., 1951, CTp. 463,
pllC. 239.
17 M. H. ApraMono8. YKa3. COq., CTp. 71.
pllC. 136.
\8 B. H. rpaK08. CKH<pbI. M., 1971, Ta6JI. XX.
\. H. H. BopoltllH.. M. K. Kap2ep. ApxIITeK-
Typa. «HCTOpllH I;YJIbTypbl IIpeBIIeii: PyclI».
M.- J1., 1951, CTp. 311.
20 A. A. Bo6puncKuii.. HapOIlIlbIe Pyccl>lIe
}.(epeBIIHHble lIaAeJIIIII, BblI!. XI. M., 1913,
TaOJI. 133, pllC. 7; Bbill. XII. M., 1914.
Ta6JI. 190, pllC. 6-7.
21 A. A. Bo6puncKuii.. YKaa. co'!., BbllI. IX.
M., 1913, Ta6JI. 124, pliC. 13.
22 A. D. CMupno8. HOBbie apxeoJIOrllqeClme
lIaHHble 0 CJIOmeHlIIi I\YJIbT¥P BOJImCRI!X
60nrap. KCHHMK, BbllI. XL, 1951, CTp. _
2' M. H. ApraMon08. YKaa. COq., Ta6JI. 62.
24 TaM me, Ta6JI. 264.
(
IIapoAHoM IIiKycCTBe. (,HCTOpnH 1;,-."',TypbI
]:\peBHeii !!yCll», T. II. I\I.-JI. 18 )1. np.
465.
. B. A. Pb!6aK08. nplIK:IailIiOP flCI>YCl TIIO 11
CKYJIbiiTypa. «IIcTop1!H KYJIbTYl'bl :lpen-
IIeII PYCIf», T. II, CTp. 396.
5 A. B. IDMufJr. K BOIiPOCY 0 npollno;t,;1e-
" _1,
248
" «,-\PXPO:101'llH». BAIl, T. IV, 1m. . COcpIlH,
I !Iii:!. Il:J0opaii,cnne Ha TIITYJIbllOM .'meTt'.
I.i .11. J1. ApTaMoHoe. r[\a3. COq., TaOJl. 18.
-' B. H. rpa o8. CRII<phI, TaOJI. XX.
os A. D. C.I/UpI/08. O'lepRII .rrpeBIIeii II CPC;(-
neneIwnoii IICTOplilI HapolloB Cpe;(lwro
nOBOiDRbfl II IIpIlKaMbH. 1\111.-\, N2 2R,
195 , CT)I. 84.
", Ta I me, np. 85, Ta6JI. XVIII, pllC. 16, 17.
" Ta I a,e. plIC. 16.
" Ta ( ii;:e, np. 258, pllC. 1.
" .4. D. C.I1I1PI/08. AHTIIqIIbIe 3JIe ICIITbI B
"y.lbTYpC nace.leIIIlH CeBepa BOCTOqIIO!i:
EBponbI. I:_\M. M.. 1H66, CTp. 238.
" .4. D. CMUpI/Oe. O'leph11 ApeBlwll 11 cpc;r-
HeBeIioBorr nCTopli1i HapolloB CpellHero
nOnOJImbH II IIpIlKaMbH. MHA, N2 28,
1952. CTp. :!38, 259.
3. M. lJ. ApraMono8. YKa3. COq., Ta6JI. 118.
" A. D. CMllpno8. OqepKII IIpeBHeII II cpe,I:\-
HeBeKoBoli IICTOpllll.., CTp. 257, pliC. 1.
?O .If. If. ApraMono8. YKa3. CO'l., Ta6JI. 50.
" Ta ( il{e n6JI 264
38 A. 'D. C UPI/;8. OqepIm IIpeBlIeii: II cpeA-
lIeBelwBoll IICTOpllll.., CTp. 85.
" K. A. C.Wl/pI/08. ]:\bHKoncl,aH KFIbTypa.
«11; hHROBCI;aH KYJIbTypa». 1\1., 1974, CTp.
R2, T. III, 2.
;0 M. H. Apra.llOI/08. YKa3. COq., Ta6JI. 81.
.. T a ( iRe, pllC. 78.
" Ta ! iim, pllC. 73.
.1 E. H. rpaK08. CRII<pbI. M., 1971, Ta6JI.
XVIII.
l.....
:.....
r. R. Barnep
OCTQIW8UCb. npe."yiJpblu, /£0/£ 9oun,
IIpeo Crpu/<I'COM. C Ope8nelO aaeao/£ou.
A. B.A.o/£ «C/£Urpbl»
BIlHe npllMO naUle}l,Ona:1 II CKlIcPo-ca p_
MaTCRYIO xyp;OllieCTneHIIYIO RYJIbTYPY.
Bep;b OlIa norII6:Ia aa;(o.lro P;O Toro, RaK
oopa30na.'IIICb CII:II.IlbIe CiIaBIIHCRlle
J.\PYlliIIHbI, cnOCOOnI.Ie ee ycnOllTb. E e
MeHee BepOIlTIIO, '11'0 C\O;Ene lOTIIBbI n
cpep;HeBeROBOM CKlIcPo cap laTCROM II
p;penHeBOCTO'llIml I1CK "CCTBe 3apop;ll-
JIllCb II pa3Bn.'1IICI. KOIlBepreHTHO. CRO-
pee, I1X JllOlliIIO conOCTanIITb C TaK Ha-
3blBaeMbIJllII OOll\IBIii leCTaMII ;:moca,
1I0 II 31'0 HYlliAaeTCIl B ORa3aTeJIbCT-
Bax. MelliP;Y TeM, B paCIIoplIllieHlllI llC-
TopllRa CeH'IaC eCTb APyrne, oOJIee TOH-
Rlle, HemeJIll nepe'lIICJIeHHbIe, nop;xop;bI
R BonpocaM Ry.'IbTypHOro HaCJIep;OBaHIIJI
II cpeAII HIIX TO, '11'0 I\. IapKc lIa3bIBaJI
«BceMBpHO-llCTOpII'IeCKII m 3aRJIllHa-
RllllMll MepTBbIx) 2.
«3aRJIllHaHlle MepTBI.IX» - 31'0 eCTb
He '11'0 llHoe, KaI\ llcno.lb30BaHlle B
onpep;eJIelIlIbIX HCTOpIlqeCKIIX YCJIOBlllIX
«H3bIRa, CTpaCTeii II ll.'I.lI03HH», TO eCTb
«IIAeaJIOB II xYAomeCTBeHHhIX cPOPM»
npOillJIoro 3. K. MapKC OTMe'laJI, '11'0
(<Upll B3rJIIIp;e Ha 3TH Rce mpIIO-llCTO-
pll'leCKHe 3aRJIIIHallIIH lepTBbIX TOT'IaC
6pocaeTCH B rJIa3a pC3lwe pa3J1I1'1llC
Memp;y HllMll». B O):llmx CJIY'IaHX OHH
6bIJIll HanpaB.leHbl Ha TO, '1T06bI
«YBllJIbHYTb» 01' pa:JpCITIeHnll peaJIbHbIX
3aAa'l, a B P;Pyrllx - ):I.1H «B03BeJlll'le-
Hllil HOBOll GOpbOb!», ):I:III «B03BeJIII'Ie-
IIllll p;aHHOll :Jap;aqn II BooopameHllll» '.
IIpllMepbI nOCJIe;\I1pro OH BllAeJI B re-
pOll'leCRllX 3noxax. KaK Obi He 6bIJI IIX
repOll3 1 COD;lla.1hI!0 OrpaHII'IeH.
IIo CYll\eCTny rrcpe;l lIa !II HBJIeHlle,
Ha3blBalO eeCH aCCol\lIal\IJell no cxon:-
CTBY ll.'Ill reHepa.'III3al\lIeii. KaR ll3BeCT-
RO, reuepa.'Ill3aT:\IIH - 31'0 He npOCTO
oooo eHlle. a TaKoe 06061I\eHIIe, B ROTO-
pmI orrpe.1e.'IeIIIlOC C!10llCTBO 06"beRTa
:Ja lewaeT c06010 Rcer, nOl,eKT 5. IIpllH-
l(lln reHepa.11r:JalUIII Plue O'leHb cJIa60
pa3pa60TaH npmlellllTr.lhHO R llCTOpllff
llCKVCCTBa XOTH 011 n'.lIlT MHoroe.
II p lliAe B ero. 011 nO:<lJo:;HeT 60JIee TOH-
Cy,n:bBbI OBP A30B 3BEPMHOrO CTMJUI
B ,n:PEBHEPYCCROM MCRYCCTBE
OAHOll ll3 3arap;{)R CRllcPcRoro «C<pIIlI-
Kca» p;o CllX nop HBJIJleTCH ll3YMllTeJIb-
Hoe no eAIIHCTBY II HpROCTll llCRYCCTBO
3BepllHoro CTllJIH. IIO-BllP;llMOMY, nO'lTII
Bce p;peBHlle Hapop;bI npOillJIII TOT RYJIb-
TypHbIll 3Tan, Rorp;a CJIOmHellilllle OTHO-
WeHllJl Memp;y '1eJIOBeROM II npllpop;Oll
perYJIllpOBaJIllCb BepOll B '1yp;op;ellcT-
BeHHYIO CllJIY 3BepllHbIX oopa30B. OTCIO-
Aa - pa3BllTlle llX B ll306pa3llTeJIbHOM
HCRYCCTBe.
Ho OP;HO p;eJIo - 300MopcP ll 'leCROe
I1CRYCCTBO RaRllX-Hll6YP;b JIeCHbIX nJIe-
MeH, II P;Pyroe p;eJIo - 300MOPcPHbIe 06-
pa3bI B llCRYCCTBe p;peBHllX rocyp;apcTB
I1iIll RO'leBbIX Ha pOP;OB, TIIHY XCH K
rocyp;apcTBeHlIocTll. MemP;Y npO'lllM,
Hepa3JIll'leHlle 3TllX CTap;llaJIbUbIX IIBJIe-
Hllll p;o CllX nop CJIymllT RaMHeM
npeTRHOBeHllH B onpep;eJIeHllll 3Bepn-
Horo CTllJIH ClmcPo-capMaTcRoro llCRYC-
CTBa, a TaKme B BbIJlCHeHlIll ero llC-
TOKOB.
B npeA;IaraeMOM rre60JIbillOM 3TIOp;e
JIIbl 6yp;eM IICXOAllTb ll3 nOHIITllJl 3Be-
pll!Ioro CTll.llI RaI{ ROHRpeTHo-llcTOpll-
qeCKoro IIBJIeHlllI, CBollcTBeHHoro IIC-
KYCCTBY eBpa3llllcRllX RO'leBHllKOB Hn
I1lI1pORIIX npOCTpaHCTBax CTerrell 01'
BocToRa AO 3ana):lHoii EBponb!. 3Bepll-
Eblll: CTllJIb - 31'0 He npOCTO JII060Bb I,
Ii306pameHllIO 3BepeR, a P;OBOJIbHO-Ta-
Kll cneD;llcPllqeCKllll: llAeo:rorllqeCK1O!M
cPeHOMeH, Kor):la e e Hell3mllTbIH Mll-
cPo.'IOrH'IeCKIIll: 300MOPcPll3M B CIIJIY
OCOObIX llCTOpll'leCRllX 06CTOlITeJIbCTB
nOJIyqaeT rpOMa,'J,III.lii I1J1Il1YJIbC 01' 30-
OMOPcPllqecROM oopa3HOCTII pa3BIITbIX
IICRYCCTB II BblJIllBaeTCIl B He'lTO no-
llCTIIHe TOTaJIbHoe, B HeRoe 300MOPcP ll -
'1eCROe MllpOB033peHlle.
CKHcPQ.10rn no-pa3HOMY TpaRTYIOT
CRllcPO-CapJllaTCImft 3BepllHhIll CTllJIb-
TO RaR aBTOXTOllIIbIll, TO RaR B03HllJ(-
IIIR.ll nOA R.'1HHlIIleM IICRYCCTBa IIepep;-
HeH A3llIl. ,D;YJllaCTCII, '11'0 eCJIll CTllJIb
31'01' p;ellCTBIITe.'1bHO HeB03MomHO 06"b-
JlCHllTb KaRlIMll-JIllOO BJIIIHHHHMll TO
HeB03MOiRHO II CBeCTll ero R aBTOX OH-
HOCTll, nOTOJIIY XOTII 6bI, '11'0 B nOCJIep;-
HeM CJIY'Iae MI.l p;OJImHbI 6bIJIll 6b!
ll3"bHTb ll3 Hero MHOrO'lllCJIeHHbIe 06pa-
3bI rpllcPOI!OB, .1I.BOB II P;Pyrllx cP aHTa -
CTll'leCRllX II :J1,30Tll'leCRllX c eCTB,
6e3 ROTOpblX CKIIcPo-capMaTcRllll 3Bepll-
HMH CTll.lb, MOllieT 6blTb, II He npll-
06peJI 6bl CBoero Cl1en;llcPH'IeCROrO 06JIll-
Ra, a BMeCTe C I!II I II Ha3BaHIIJI. «,D;peB-
IIJlII 3ara;u;a C<f>lIImc a», KaR HaM npep;-
CTaBJIlIeTCH. B TO I II COCTOllT, '11'0 MM P;O
CllX nop xopomo He 3HaeM ceMaHTIIRll
CKHcPo-cap laTCKoro 3BepIlHoro CTIIJIII,
a relliAY Te 1 Iii! I rrpep;CTOllT llMeTb p;e-
JIO C p;pyroir 3;uan:KOll: nO'leMY O'leHb
CXOAHall 300 lop(IJ1IaH oopa3HOCTb 6blJIa
BeCbMa rr0l1y.1HpllOll B llCKYCCTBe eBpo-
nellcKoro Cp<!1I1PfJeKORbH, B qaCTHOCTll,
B .1p(,RHep .c<t;() 1 IICEYCCTBe.
II pH BCP I onn[JOlliHOM OTHomeHllll K
TeopIIII H('nORTn[J!I IOCTll 3THORYJIbTYP-
IIblX KpyroR I H[JH.1 .'Ill Bce me Mom-
HO rrpe):lno.-JaraTl,. '11'0 BOCTO'lHhIe CJIa-
250
KO nOAoiiTII R rrp06JIeMC TpaAIID;nii, 11('-
pe,!l,l;o npeBpall\aeMOll B HPKylO Bc('06-
ll\YlO OTMbI'IKY II rr03TOMY BbI3bIBal0-
ll\ell: 3aKOllUbilI CRenCllC. II pIIuD;lIn re-
Hepa.ln3,U I!II rr03BOJIlIe! rOBopUTb 0
C:-'OACTBe TaKIIX HBJIeHlIll, KOTOpble He
I1pe,!l,CTaB:IIIIOT Tpap;llII;I110 B nplI IOM
CMbIC.'Ie c:IOBa. JII060ll 1I3 06pa30B CTa-
poro I1CI>YCCTBa p;OCTaTO'lHO c.lomeH II
lI!ororpal' eH, no eCTb Y Hero TaKHe,
ocooeHHO II pKIW qepThI, B I;OT01H,IX !I
OCYll\eCTBJlHeTCIl ero rJIaBHall IlCTOpU-
'1eCI>alI cPy HRII;llll. ECTeCTBe UIIO, '1TO
3TH '1epTbI BceMepHO nOp;'1epKIIBaIOTCH,
06pa3HO aKD;eHTllpYIOTCH, OJIarO):lapH
'Ie MY 06paCTaIOT MHomeCTBOM mll3IIeH-
IIMX aCCOD;llaII;llll. ,D;OCTaTO'lHO 0P;1I01I II3
aCCOD;llaII;llll: 3aTponYTb co;maHue, Ral:
CTapbIH oopa3 ORa3blBaeTCil npel,pac-
IIbIM HOCllTeJIeM HOBMX IlCTOpIl'IeClmX
IIp;ell:, '1eM-TO pop;CTBeHHMX p;aBHO npoii-
p;eIIHOMY 3Tany. (hOT nCllXOJIOrIiqe-
CRllii, BepHee, nCllxO-llp;eOJIOrlI'IeCRliii
MexaHll3M II JIemllT B OCROBe reHepaJI!l-
3aD;llll. Be3 Hero 6bIJIO 6M HeB03Momno
nOHHTb 06pa30BaHIIe II npeeMCTHPII-
HOCTb CIIMBOJIllRll, '11'0 XOpOlIIO nORa3in
A. H. BeCeJIOBcRIrii: 6.
Mnorlle p;aHHMe rOBopliT 3a TO, '11'0
mIlpOKoe pacnpOCTpaHeHlle 300MOpq)-
nOH 06pa3HOCTll BOCTO'lHOro, B TOM '1llC-
.Tle II capMaTO-CRllcPOllp;Horo Tllna B llC-
. RYCCTBe cpep;HeBeROBOH EBporrbl BO
MHorOM 061I3aHO pacc roTpeHHO IY IIB.le-
HlllO. BOJIee Toro, B caMOM 3BepHHml
CTII.'IP CRllcP0-capMaTcKoro IICl{YCCTBa
3Tll 06pa3bI 6blJIll R CBOlO O'Iepe;v, r{'-
HepaJIll30BaHHbiMll npll nocpe.ICTBe IIC-
KYCCTBa 60:ree pa3BllTbl\ II;llBII.Tlll3iH\1I ii.
MomeT B03HllRHYTb Bonpoc: nO'IC IY
me B YCJIOBllIIX, RorAa ApeBl1epYCClwP
IICRYCCTBO nplloo .10Cb H 1!('.lIl1;o I '
aHTpono lOPcPll'lecRmIY IIC "YCCTIIY.
RO:JI1IIR.la He06xop;llMOCTb B rCllepa:lII-
3aD;IIII p;peBHllx 3BepllHbIX IOTnBOB':'
3;J;eCb He C.leAyeT ;JaObiBaTI. 1'01'0 oi)
CTOHTe.'IbCTBa, '11'0 ApeBnepYCCKOC 11('-
KYCCTBO OTHIOP;b He 6I.IJIO npO;lO,lllieHII-
251
M UU:laHTlIiicnoro. BCAL uCe ("pei U(,BC-
IWIJbIC BapBapbl, KaK ObI UIIU He ObI.1U
.OOH3anbI B CBOCH KYJILType aIITII'lIiOMY
.11 BII3aHTlIllCKOMY HaCJIe.n;mo, .n;omimbI
UbIJIII «Ha'lIiHaTb C Ila'laJIa» 7. B TmI
«Ha'laJIe» xpneTliaIlCRoe ell\e TeCRO CO-
IIpllRaCaJIOCb C JI3bIQeCKllM, IIpll'leM He
TOJIbRO B «H1I3aX», no II B (<Bepxax».
Tali '11'0 lIaJIIIQO 6bIJIH Bce yC:IOBliJI
.n;JIJI Toro, 'IT06bI B.n;OXIlYTb ROBYIO
mll3Hb B CTapble 06pa3bI 3BepllHoro
CTIIJIJI.
reIlepaJIH3aQIIJI, eCTeCTBeHHO, 06-
YCJIOBIiJIa KaR 6bl CKB03HOH XapaKTep
eCJIIi He BCe'X, TO IIs6paIlHbIX, Hl1II60-
JIee BbIpa311TeJIbHblX II aRTyaJIbHLIX
3BepllHbIx MOTIIBOB, Ila'lliHaH C .n;peBHO-
CTII II .n;o cpeABeBeROBbJI BKJIIO'lllTeJIb-
HO, a B HeKOTopbIX CJIy'laHX II ;JJ;a:Iee.
113 aToro 'IIiCTO BII3yaJIbliOrO <}>aliTa
IIlI0r.n;a .n;e.n;YQllpyeTcH IIOJIOaWInIC 0
ceMaHTIIQeCKO!l1 TomAeeTBe CRBO.3I1bl'\.
06pa30B, Ila OCHOBaHIIII '1ero CTpOJITCJI
CTPYKTypHbIe MO;JJ;eJIll. Ho '1UCTO BII3Y-
aJIbIlbIH 4JaRT - 31'0 .n;aJIeKO eme nc al\:-
CHO !l13 I
Ha'laTb C Toro, '11'0 IIpII renepaJIII3a-
I{llll, l,aK yme CKaaaHO, lIa6upaeTCH,
YCBaliBaeTCJI He Bee cO;JJ;epmaIllle rTa-
poro 06pa3a (06pa30B), a nall60.'Tcr
aKTyaJIbHOe ero (IIX) cBoiicTBO, rpam,.
cTopoHa. lloaToMY CCMaHTUl(a He 1110-
meT OCTaTbCJI BenpllKOCHOBemJOii, npo
IICXO)J;IIT ee paClIleIIJlenile II IHmenTll-
pOBKa renepaml3IIpyeMuii CTOPOITLI. C
'IeM CBJI3aHbI CYlIleeTBellHbIe II1!1ICII£'-
nllJI B manpe U CTIIJIe. J];OCTaTO'IIIO pac-
CMOTpeTb O;JJ;IlB TOJIbKO oopa:} rpnllJOlla
B IIeTopll1l .n;peBnero II cpe;JJ;HC'DCI-;OBoro
llCliYCCTBa, 'ITOObI yGe,!J;IITLcn B r II P'\
Be;JJ;JIIIBOCTU CRa3aBnoro.
HeKorAa MncpOJIOrll'leCKOe CYUlCCTIIII.
rpncpOH yme B aBTII'IRO" HCI-; CrT III'
IIpeBpaTIIJICJI B cnYTHIIKa, a 3aT('!l1 II B
<ITPIl6YT HOBOro aHTpono!lropqmoro 00-
meCTBa 8. TaKaJI me TpaRc<}>op!llanIJII
;JJ;peBBeH Mllcpo.rrorn'leCKOll Ce!lI<lHTllI>IJ
npolIc'xo)J;BJIa B IIepe;JJ;Rea3118TCKO!l1 nc-
li TCTBC, rj.\c oopa;! rplllIJOIIa CTaJI nplI-
OUPCTdTL CIlMBOJIlI'IeCROe aUa'Ielille 8.
T ilnll!ll OOpaJOIll, 8;JJ;anTlIpYJI B CBoe UC-
Ii}TCTBO 1I306pameHile rpmlJOHa (a
TilK,lie .aLBa ]I .n;p.), ClUlcpbI II capMaTbI
YCDilIIBa:m BOBce Be lomcpOJIOrll'lCCJwe
I1X co.n;cpmalilIe, a ellMBOJIIlQeCKoe.
CU!lIBo:m.3!\1 !\lor ymllBaTbCJI C OCTaT-
!iil!l\![ Marll'ICCKHX npeACTaB:IeIllIll Y
("Iill<110B, Aamc C TaR Ba3bIBae1llOH nap-
l!lIa.lbIIOll lIlarlleii '0, BO CIl!lIBOJI 6blJI
yaw He MII4JOJIOrneH. MHororpaHHOCTb
CII!lIBOJIa cnoc06CTBOBaJIa TOMY, '11'0 BbI-
lIIe 6blJIO 06p1lCOBaHO RaK 1136npaTeJIb-
Hoe a eBTllpOBaHlle. B .n;aBBOM cny-
'lae a eHTHpOBaJIlICb penpe3eHTa-
TlllIHOCTb II IlMnepaTIlBHOCTb 06pa3a
IIJlI<POHa, C '1C!\I aCCOIJ;nOpOBaJIaCb BeCb-
!Ita 3JI060AneBHaH n;JJ;eJI BOIIBCTBeHlIO-
CTn II Ben06e.n;I1!1IOCTIl. H. ll. HOBAa-
KOB Mor C rrOJIHbIM OCBOBaBlIeM YTBep-
a-;.J,aTb, '11'0 rpmpOH 6blJI CllMBOJIO!\l IIO-
fil' I.I BoeIlBoro roCY;JJ;apCTBa Ha.n; OKpy-
il,alOll\lIMIl lIJIeMeHaMII". He.n;apOM 11
Y onbBIIHcROro )J;B0PQa CRllcpeKoro
1I''11H CKIlJIa naXOAIlJIlleb CTaTYIi rpll-
II'OIlUB 12.
ITOCnOJIbKY 113 aHTn'lHOCTIl 06paa
rpII<IJOHa 6blJI nepeBeceH B paHHexpH-
I"TllallCRoe lICKYCCTBO, a 113 BOCTO'lBbI'\:
liy.lbTYP - B IICKYCCTBO BapBapOB, TO
I'\IY OTnpblBaJIaCb mnpOKaJI Aopora B
cpe HeBeKOBoe IICKYCCTBO, B KYJlbTYPY
II ObiT cpeo.n;aJIlI3llpyrolIleHCH EBponbI.
: 'TOT. npoQece O'leHb XOpOlIlO JlCCJIe;JJ;o-
DaH H. ll. HOH;JJ;aIWBbl!\l. J];o6aBIlM R
I'fO naumOAeHIIJIM TO.'1LKO TO, '11'0 OCTa-
IIICh IIHe BHllMaBIIH aBTopa.
Bo-rrepBbIX, CJIe;JJ;yeT OT!lleTIlTb Bam-
IIYIO pO.'lb 60JIrapenOii «rpIIcpOHOMa.
\ 1111>1, KOTOpaJI ecnH II He CMblKaJIaCb co
\ 1i\ll{>o-capMaTtKOH, TO pa3BMBaJIaCb,
1.'1-\ CRa3aTb,lro ee CBemlIM CJIe.n;aY.
['"mme anaHo-60JIrapnme npoIl3Be.n;e-
IIl1n 3BeplIHoro CTIlJIJI ;JJ;aTHPYIOTCJI
\. [II B. II BO MBorOM nO'i:omll Ha cKncp
I linc MOTIiBbI. TalioBa. RanpllMep, no-
,{<"lIaJI O.'lHllIna 1I3 Ca:ITOBCROro MonWb-
llilKa. II300pamaJoman opna C 3auQe\l
B :Jarrax (puc. 1, 1) 13.
B IX fl. B oO:IrapcRoll rpncpoRO!llaXnTI
IIOHB:IHIOTCIl UOBbIe CIOmeTbJ, B ROTOpblX
cTapbli't oupa3 BCTynaeT B BOBbIe CBJI-
311, '11'0 OblJIO B03MomBO TOJlbKO npn
YC.'IOBIIII reHepaJI1l3aII;lIll ceMaHTIIRIl.
PUC. 1. IIaoopaJICeHIISl a8epuHoao CTUASl Ha
apXIITePlITYP"bIX na.1(RTHUICax U 8 npuIC.(aiJ-
HO'" UCkYCCT8e:
I - Ope,. C' :matu.t" I. nORCH8H 6nJlxa. Ca.;ITOBCHM"A
MorunbHHI<: YIlI B.; 2 - fPUc!>OH. «Ppar"eHT pe3-
Boro JlapQa U8 Tepa'IJIBa, IX D.; II - fpnfIJolIY.
«Ppar>leHT p"CYHl<a ua T} pbeM pore H3 'lepHHro-
Ba. X B.: 4 - rpllc!>OH C naHbIO. PeJlbec!> QepKBU
IIOI'pooa H3 lIep.'H. 1165 r.
.
.,.
J
\'
,
-
A
-., . .., '" f
. f .... .. -..r '"
.. '
ni '.i'';:.
. .
'),-.)
_.1-
B repOn'IeCKIB. c enax Ha .n;epCnHllIIOM
pC.mOM napll,e 113 Tepa'lIma rpm\loll II0-
MOraeT CTpeJlbQY-JIyqnIInY B e:J;DHOOOI)-
CTBe C naRlIM-TO 'Iy.n;0B1nl e!l1 (pile. 1,
2) ".
13 X B. 06pa3 rpllcpona IIepeXO IIT B
AeKOp !lIOBYMeRTaJIbHOii ap nTCKTypbI,
COXpaRJIJI elIle CBOR arpeCCIIBDblll xa-
panTep ", a B Xl-XII BB. C!lICHHCTCH
06pa30!ll eIIoKoHHO cToH ero TI.'III IIAY-
mero rpIIcpoHa, ROTOpO!llY Tenepb yme
IIpeAOCTaBJleBO MeCTO na anTapHon npc-
rpaAe xpaMa 18.
B03MomBO, '11'0 60:IrapcKnir onblT
cnOCOOCTBOBaJI oc0600 nony.1Rp1lOCTU
rpll<}>oHoMaXHTI B ;JJ;pellIIep:,>.ccKO!l1 lIC-
KYCCTBe AOMOBrOJIbCK01I nop!.!. Qna
--
J · . r / 'V,..
..
-
r
l.\
" ,
."
)
...
r
r
; .
,
--a
. .) }
'. -It
\ ' ,.
r ':'
"
.
,
.........
2
253
npomJIa npHMel'HO Te me :JTlIrrLl, 'lTO 11
B EOJIrapHH. TIaMHTlillIilI J]:OxpHCTlIaH-
mille (X B.) TOme O'leHI, OJIH31ill R
CItHIiJCItHM MOTBBa l, 0 'leM MomHO CY-
Jl:HTI, no H306pameIIllIO CJ]:BoenHbIx rpH-
1iJ0HOB Ha cepe6pHHoii 06R.'laARe mHpo-
RO 1l3BeeTBoro TypLero pora Il3 qepHIl-
rOBa (pIlC. 1, 3) 17. Hu me 3TO paBBee
npoH3BeJ]:eHlle OKa3a)JoeI, TeCHO CBJl3aB-
HbIM C MeCTBLIM repOII'IeCRIlM 3nOCOM 18.
B J]:aJII,BeHmeM repOII'IeCKaH JIHHHJI B
1UJeBBepYCClmH rpIIIiJOHOMaXIIH Hapac-
TaJIa, 06pa30BaB BO BJIaJ]:HMHpO-CY.3-
AaJII,CKOH MonyMerrTa:II,HO-J]:eKopaTIlB-
BOO nJIaCTHKe 60.1I,IDHe IJ;HKJIbl 19 .
MAeH penpe3eBTaTUBBOCTH H HMnepa-
THBHOCTH eJIHJIllCI, 3AecI, C xpHCTllaB-
CKOll ceMaBTHRoii, liaR 3TO 6LlJIO H B
«EomeCTBeHHon RUMe;IIIH) ):(aHTe. Bce
3TO cnoc06CTBOBaJIO rrepexo 06pa3a
rpHliJoHa B aMOJIellfaTIlRY, a OAHOBpe-
MeRRO 11 B MeTaliJoPY.
MTaK, MHIiJOJIOrllH - peJIDTHH, CHMBO-
JIHKa, aM6JIeMaTBKa - Tal<DB 6LlJl CTep-
mem.. BORPYl' KOTOpOro pa3BepTLlBa-
JIaeI, BCTOpH'IeCKaH CrrBpaJII, reHepaJIH-
aaqBlI 06pa3a rpllliJoRa. OTAeJII,BLle
OTpe3KB aTOll crrHpa H. npIlXOAHII{He-
CJI (Jl:HaXpOHll'leCRI!) ;I pyr HaA J]:pyroM,
B 'leM-TO 6I,/JI1I nOXOiliII. B paCCMaTp11-
BaeMOM npHMepe IIX C6JIBmaJIB BAeH
penpe3eHTaTlIBHocTfI II HMnepaTIlBBo-
CTIl. Ho MLI CHOBa no epRHBaeM, 'lTO
aTO CXOJJ:CTBO reHPpR.1I,Hoe. He aMnHpll-
'IeCRoe.
IToRa3aTe)JbHO, '1TO nOJJ:06nyro reHe-
paJIB3al.\HIO nepeiliII.1II aJIeKO He Bce
oopa3hI JJ:peBnero .IBepnHoro CTIlJIH.
B CKH<}>CROM JlC.KYCCTBe ObI:IO npOHBJIe-
HO paOROJJ:YIITIIe R TaI<(I)IY JlpROMY 06pa-
3Y nepe!{nea311aTCKDrO lleKYCCTBa, KaK
'1eJIOBeRO-6I,IR «<.lR)I8CCY» H:IB «ille-
AY9). 06pa3bI cq,rrIIRca II KPHTaBpa TO-
me Be 6I,mll pa:mITTI,I B cKn<I>o-capMaT-
CKOM 3BepnHO\l nrr.le. B CBOIO O'lepeJJ:I"
B JJ:peBHepYCCKml llCliycCTBe COBceM Be
ObIJIO 06pa3a Tep:UHOIDero rpnliJoBa, ra-
.10nllpYIO ero O.lCTlII. ropnoro K03JIa.
He TOJII,RO 06pa3 rpll<}>oHa, HO H JJ:PY-
rIle OO'LeliTbl reHepaJIH3aIJ;nB npeTepne-
JIll O'lenb 3l\MeTBYIO TpaBc/fJopMaIJ;mu,
nplI06peTaH 1l0BLle JmHKpeTHbie 'lepTbI,
H, 'ITO call1Oe BamBoe, 06pa3YH Bce liV-
BLle Il BOBbie CIOmeTHLle cxeMbi II ffial:i
pOBLle ClIeTeM.bi. 3TO CJIymHT JIyqIDIBI
J]:oKa38Te:.JI,cTBoM Toro, '1TO celliaHTI1Kd
CKB03BbIX 06pa30B OTHIO)J.b Be 6bIJIa
CKB03HOll.
TenepI, AOJImHO 6LlTI, COBepmeHIIO
HCHbIM, '1TO reHepaJlH3aqlIJi Be TO I,RO
He IlCKJIIO'IaeT, BO rrpJlMO npcAno:mraeT
CTBJIHCTII'leCRYIO nepe pa60TKY. CKII/fJ-
CKlle H capMaTCKlle MaCTepa O'IeHI,
CBJII,BO nepepa60TaJIB CTIlJII, 3aHlIICTBO-
BaHHbIX rrepeJJ:Hea3HaTCKIlX 3BepHHbIX
IOTllBOB, YCH;;JnB Jl:HHaMIIRY, aKqeHTII
pOBaB BaH60JIee aKTyaJII,HbIe J]:eTaJill.
TaK me 06CTOJlJIO AeJIO H IIPB reHepa-
JIH3aqHH CKHIiJOHAHbIX 06pa30B JJ:peB-
BepYCCKHM HCKYCCTBOM.
ITepeBOJJ: 300MOp<}>HOO 06pa3HOCTIl C
npeAMetoB npBKJIaAHOrO IlCRYCCTBa Ha
CTeBLI MOUYMeBTaJII,HLlX 3JJ:8Hlfii, UpH
'leM HMeHBO Ha BepXBHe HX 'laCTn, He
COMHeHBO YBeJIH1lBBaJi BX penpe.lellTa
TUBHOCTL. TenepI, rpH/fJoH yme Be Tep-
3aeT CBOIO mepTBY, a CJIOBHO 6epemHo
HeceT ee B CBOHX MOm;HbIX JIanR"(
(pHC. 1, 4). <I>llrypbI rpllliJoHoB. JIbBOB,
6apcoB, no cpaBBeBHIO co cKHliJo-capMa-
TCKIlM BCKYCCTBOM, }'TepHJIH AIlHaMI1'I-
HO TI" aaTO rrpH06peJIH llMn03aHTnOCTI,.
I10A'IepKllBaeMYIO nOCTpoeIIHeM II R
AJIIlBHLle pJl]UJ (pBC. 2). 06 ee Co!{ep-
maHHe 3Toii 300Mop/fJnon I1JI8CTIIiiII .
ROHe'lHO, COBceM He BOllHCTBeBllOP. RO
'1TO OHa 6bIJIa HanpaBJIeHa Ha Bo:me.ln-
'lllBaHHe HOBOH 60pI,6M, <}>eoJJ:am,ny-,()
repOH3al.\llMt. B aTOM HeT HURaKoro CO-
\meHHJI. 3Tj' CTopOHa ee 6LlJIa xopom o
paCKpI,ITa K H. BopOHHHLIM ZO. H CJ(8-
:!aRTIoMY HaAo J]:06aBHTI" 'lTO nOIlIlHln
ll;:J:eii perrpe3eBTaTHBHocTH, R!I8JIn lI-
Po-cY3J]:aJIbCKaJl 3001lfOpliJHaJi rr,aCTIlK:J
rreCO'tfReBHO oTpa:IIl!Ia H HapoJJ:Hoe "III
pOBOCnpmITHe, B KOTOpOM em;c !\lIIoroe
cOXpaHHJIOeI, OT Jl3Ll'leCTBa. OABaRO,
aTa JIllUBH cB060ABee. pa3BHBaJIaCI,
IIMellHO B rrplIRJIaAHOM HCKyccTBe, rAe
BaMeTIIBmHeCH B n03ArreM cltHliJo-cap-
MaTCKOM 3BepIIBoM CTHJIe 'IepTLl opIta-
MeBTaJIDBOCTII npe06pa30BaJIIICI, B
CJIOmuyIO TepaTOJIOrllIO. CRHliJcKoe HC-
KYCCTBO npoToMbl, BepOJlTBO, CLlrpaJIO
3JJ:ecI, CBOIO poJIb, BO BMeCTO reBepaJIH-
3aqBlI T}'T HaAo npeAnOJIaraTI, 60JIee
CJIOmHYIO CBH3I" AO CIlX 1I0p elIte He BbI-
JICHeBnyIO 21.
JJI060IIbITHO, 'ITO 06e JlBHHll 300-
MOpcpHoii 06pa3HocTH ApeBBepYCCJ(oro
Puc. 2. rputfioHl u ..cr.8bl. Pe..cr.etfibl !JMur-
pue8cnoao co60pa 80 B..caiJUMupe 1194-
1197 a8.
.'. ...
.'1 ' .
- - Jj.
'.....
"'":.
, '
'.
.... :/
-...... .....
"
-\it
:"'IlLf 't ;
'\
. 'L,
..
, ''''''';-' . .
(-'\i\\\ j , ....
" ..,. ..,.
- . " .
,\\ '
. .(i
. "\)";;. ,
. f
" ...
'.
. t
...
...
\.
\.
\\
-.
.J t
254
nCliYCCTBa nepeCeRJIHCb yme nocne Ta-
T8pO-IIIOHrOJIJ,CRoro BameCTBIlH II Be
r;J.e-nu6YiJ;I" a IIMCHHO B TOM me BJIa)J,II-
IIlIIpO-CY3AanLCKOIlI llCKYCCTBe, Ba TaR
na3LlBaeMLlX «CY3JJ:aJII,CRIIX ABepHX).
3TO coeAnrrenue ABYX JIHHIIll npnBeJIO
R nOHBJIenUIO 3BepllHLlX MOTHBOB, ro-
pa3AO 60JIee CRI!/fJOHABLIX, Hemenu c06-
CTBeHHO BJIa nMIIpCKaJl TIJIaCTHRa ZZ. Ho
3TO 6I,IJI O'leBI, ROpOTKnii nepHOA, J(orAa
lIIem 3BcpnHbIlIIII MOTIIBaMH If Tepa-
TO:IOrnen 06pa30B8JIOCb BeRoe paBHOBe-
cue. RCiiope nOCJIe C03AaHHJI opHaMeH-
T8.,I,HOii palllI,I «CY3JJ:aJII,CKnX ;IBepeff)
TepRTo orHH B PYCCKOM opHaMeBTaJII,-
ROM nCKYCCTBe BOCTopmeCTBOBaJIa, AaB
CTnJTJ" e)!{8IIUln yme BHe Tp8AHl.\Hii
3BepHHoro CTn:JR.
.
., '" . - ,(
I
,I:'
· . -.,/ '"
. --,
'. .
"
\\
.
-: . .
"1) . ( \}
..\\' .
1\( '.
i
i-\(t\)
\.
')--
_.X)
MTaI\, Mbl npHXO,ilHM K BblBO,ilY, 'ITO
)InlBOll AIIaJIeKTH'IeCKIIH HCTOPHKO-XY-
p;OmeCTBeHHbIll npol].ecc reHepaJIH3al].HH
06pa30B 3BepIlHoro CTIJ.TUI HP-JIb'3H rrOHIl-
IaTb Hal; BOCllp01l3BOP;CTBO op;Hoii II
foii me CTPYKTYPbl, COCTOHm;eii 113 Tom-
;::(ecTBcliHblX 3."IeMeHTOB. B KpaTKo pac-
cMoTpeliHoM HaMll llCTOpH'IeCKOM PHP;Y:
MlI<po:lOnm - peJIllrIlH - CIiMBOJIII-
Ka - J f6JIe)1aTllKa, 300Mop<pH'IeCKaH
06pa3110CTb rrepemllJIa no H:paHHeu Me-
pe Tpli CTPYRTYPbl: OpraHH'IeCKYIO
(p;peBHeBOCTO'IHOe HCKYCCTBO), rrpHR-
JIap;HYIO (CKII<po-capMaTCKoe HCf{YCCT-
BO) II p;eKopaTHBHO-MOHYMeHTaJIbHYIO
(p;peBHepYCCKoe HCKYCCTBO). COOTHO-
meHIle IlX HeJIb3H orrpep;eJIHTb }{aK
3BO."IIOI].IIIO. CKll<po-capMaTCKHB: 3BepH-
Hblrr CTIIJIb BblrJIHp;1IT CKopee KaK OTpIl-
D.aHIlP ROCTO'IHOH OpraHH'IHOCTIl. ECJIH
3TO TaK, TO p;peBHepYCCKoe HCKYCCTBO
300Mop<pU'IeCRoro Kpyra BbIrJIIIP;HT KaK
OTpUlJ.aHHe OTpHD.aHHH. OTCIOp;a CJIeAY-
eT 3aKJlIO'IIlTb, 'ITO TaKoe CJIOmHOe p;H-
aJleKTIl4eCKoe COOTHomeHIle 6bIJIO H B
06:JRCTII ceMaHTIlKH.
Bce no 3aCTaBJIIIeT HacTopamHBaTb-
CII, Rorp;a rrpH ll'3yqeHllH xYJJ;omeCTBeH-
HblX IIBJIeHHH, nop;06HhIX paccMaTpH-
BaeMblM, 3axop;IlT pe'lb 0 MOAeJIllpOBa-
HHII MlIpa CaMo nOHMHe MOp;eJIH 3JJ;eCb
BblfJHIP;IlT HeYMeCTHbIM, nOCKOJIbKY HeT
HII opIlrIlflaJIa, HH Tomp;eCTBa HJIH aHa-
."Iorrrn C OpIlrHHaJIOM. B TaKllX YCJJO-
IJIlJIX rrOHHTIle «Mop;eJIHpOBaHUe) rrpeB-
p,ul,aeTCII B Ilrpy MOp;HbIM TepMHHOM.
rora p;o rrpaBHJIbHee rORopIITb 06 OT-
paa;enrm B IlCKYCCTBe «o6pa3a MH-
I (\1. I10;1pOOHO: JJ. H. ry.llu.J!e8. I1cKYCCTBO
n lTiIOC. «.D.eKopaTHBHoe IICRYCCTBO»,
1 'I'i . M 1, CTp. 36.
f{ .Ifapl<c II (/J. BH.Ze.J!bC. COq., T. 8, CTp.
I ()-
-r a \1 ;I;e, CTp. 120.
-r,,\\ ;I;e. CTp. 120-121.
<,'!111.10co<pcI;all 3 III;JiO!l(oi\ITH», T. 'I. M.,
1 (\f\11. np. 347,
pa» 2", 'ITO II p;eJIUJIIl em;e BII3aHTHHClme
MblCJIHTeJIII, HanpIIMep, Mal;CllM Mcno-
BeAHIIK. B 3BepHHOM CTllJIe CI-m<PO-cap-
MaTCRoro lICRYCCTBR «06pa3 mpa)
npep;CTaB."IfI."ICH IIpelIMym;cCTBcHHO B
300MOP<pHblX CllMBo."IaX, it B ,a:peBHe-
PYCCROM - B aHTpono fOp<p!lbIX, HO CO
3Ha'IIITeJIbHOH p;0.lIef1 30mIOp<pHOll: CIIM-
BOJIHKI!. Ha rrepBblll B3r."IH [, 3TO C6.'III-
maeT p;peBHepYCCKoe rrCI;YCCTBO C BO-
CTO'IHblM, HO TOJIbKO Ha nl'fJBblll B3rJIIIp;.
BOCTO'IHOe IICKYCCTBO em;e lie AOCTIlrJIO
BblCOT aHTll'lHOH rap !OIlIlll. ):qJeBHe-
PYCCKoe me, RaR II Bce cpe;:\lIeBeKOBoe
HCKYCCTBO, pa3BIlBaJIOCb nOCJIe pacnap;a
3TOB: rapMOHIlIl II Hp;ea:lbl ero 6hIJIH
P;PYrIIe. B :nOM npOHBII.'IaCb Ta ,lI;Hcrap-
MOHIlII, KOTopalI OTJIII'IaeT H «HOBO-
eBpOnell:CKHH JIIITepaTyplIbill D.IIKJl) ".
B 'IaCTHOCTII, 300MOp<pHilH 06pa3HOCTb
JJ;peBHepYCCKoro HCKYCCTBa COBepmeHHO
JIHmCHa KaKOrO-JIH6o !ll<pOJIOrH3Ma,
ee 06pa3bl HaXOAJITCH Ha nYTII K rr03TH-
'leCKOMY MeTa<popIl3MY: lIonoMY
HCrrOJIb30 aHHe B CIICTeMe BJIap;IlMHpo-
CY3p;aJIbCKOH CKYJIbnTypbl neKOTopbIX
BOCTO'lHhIX 6HHapHblX II TepnapHhIX
KOMn03IlD.Illl: JIIlmeHO p;peBHero CMhICJIa
H 06pa3yeT COBepmCHHO IIHOH maHp.
lIo cym;eCTBY 3TO 6bIJI KOHel]. Toro
«300/t03U'lecrw3o MllpOBO:I:!peHHII» ..,
KOTOpLIM KH'lHJIOCb npI!BH.lIerHpOBaH-
Hoe COCJIOBHe II KOTopoe, RaK H3BeCTHO,
rrpop;OJImaJlO IIHTaTh repa."Ib,'\IlKY. Ho
30olrwp<pHaII repaJIbp;IIHiI iibma yme He
xyp;omecTBeHHblM HanpaB."ICHIleM II He
HMeJIa HHKaKoro OTHomrnrrH K «oopa-
3Y MIlpa).
9 r. A. JlY2a eH."08a. fplI<pOIl B aIITII'III<BI II
cpep;HeBeIWB<B1 lICIiyccTBe Cpel\Heii .-\ HIII.
CA, 1959, M 2, CTp. 70. ,
to a CBII31I CRII<pcRoro IfCKYCCTBa C !lap.
lIaJIbHOii IarlIelI CM.: E. E. It'Y3b.lfIlNa.
a CIIIU;pCTIf3 1C oopa30B CRII<pCIwro lIC-
l;yccTBa B CBII3If C oc06eHHOCTH !1I pe:II1-
rlI03HblX npeACTaBJIeHlI1I IIpaIl eB. «Te3If-
CbI p;oRiIaiJ;oB III BceCOI03Hon ROH<pepeH-
ll!! no BOIIpOCa}1 CRII<po-cap laTcI;oft ap-
xeOJI0 r1IIf». M., 1972, CTp. 51-52.
1\ H. II. f{ OH.OaI>08. OqepKII Il 3aMeTI;U !l0
I1CTOplIlI cpe;J;HcBeI;oBoro IICKYCCTBa II
RyJIbTYPbl. llpara, 1929, CTp. 92.
12 B. /1.. E.J!a8aTCI<UU. I1CRYCCTBO CeBepHoro
fIplI'lepHOMOpbli B aHTlIqHYIO 3!10XY. 111.,
1947, CTp. 11.
13 C. A. II.J!eTH.e8a. aT KOqeBlIll K ropOAa l.
M., 1967, plIC. 40, 10.
I< H. Maepo()UH.08. CTapomJIrapCROTo II3-
KyCTBO. C0<pIIII, 1959, CTp. 75-76, pIlC. 69.
'" Taol ;1i O CTp. 213-214, plIC. 243.
16 TaM w. _ op. 217-218, }Inc. 253.
" E, A. £lbl.l '/l<c'8. .D.peRHocTll '-!epHIIroBa.
Ml1A. N. a !.i.-JI., 1949, CTP, 43-51,
6 A. H, Bece. 8CI<UU, IIlTOI'"'Il'CI;alI IIO;)TH-
118. J1., 1940: _pp. 51.
7 K, Map,;c Ut/(/J. 9N2C.,"C CO'!., T, 7, CTp.
360.
8 H. H, 1I0zpe608a, fpmp!>H II ero 1I 06pa-
mCHlIe B IICRYCCTBe CeBf'rHOrO llpHqepHO-
MOpbli B ;)!lOXY rpeqeCIiol' KO:IOHH3aIJ;UU.
APXIIB I1A AH CCCP. j'a-L1L'.1 2. M 340,
CTP, 15.
256
PUe. 20. .D.JIH CparlllL'llUH 01.: M. 11. _.J.pTa-
.1<01108, COI;pOBIIU\a CIilI<pCI;UX "ypraH()B.
llpara - J1" 190o, pllC. 129.
'8 E. A. Pbl.6aI<08. YIia3. COq., CTp. 49.
" r. Ii. BazH.ep. C"YJib!lTypa APcBHelI PyC!!.
BJia;111 IlIp. 1J0rOJIIOOoBO. M., 1969, CTp.
136.
" H. H. BopoH.uH.. 30 ecTBo CeBepo-BoCTOq-
HOII pycii XII-XV BB., T. 1. M., 1961,
CTp. 433.
" HaA 3TOII TeMOII pa60TaeT T. E. YX()Ba.
" r. K. BazH.ep. XYAoffiecTBeHHali CIfCTeMa
«cY3;J;aJIbCKIIX ABepen» II BOIIpOC 0 IIX p;a-
TlIpOBRe. CA, 1973, N2 1, CTp. 102. u
" lloRa3aTeJIbHO, qTO p;ame A. 3HillTeIlH, KO-
Topbln 60JIee qe 1 RTO 6b1 TO H!! 6b1JiO
II IP:I OCHOBaHlie rOBopllTb 0 MOp;eJIIIpOBa-
HIIII lIIpa, !lpeA!lOqIITaJI BbipameHlle « 6-
pa3 MlIpa» IIJIII «KapTIIHa MlIpa,) (A, BuH.-
UJ.TeUH.. C06palilie HayqHblX TPYAoB, T. IV.
M., 1967, CTp. 153).
.' r. 4. ralle8, iKH3Hb xyp;OmeCTBeHHoro
C03HaHIIII. M., 1972, CTp. 87.
::' K. Mapl<c II (/J. 9H.Ze.J!bc. COq., T. 1, CTp.
342.
JI. A. JIeJIelWB
pliCTaHCKIIe OPO'H3bI CTapaTeJIbHO' KOIUI-
PO'Bam1Cb B ;:hpYPilil II OpP;O'Ce. Cn.eHbI
Tep3aHIIH C rrO'pa3I1TeJIbHO'H YCTO'ft1m-
BO'CTbID BOCrrpO'H3BO'P;I1JIHCb BO' BCeX
yr?,JIKaX O'OHTaeMO'rO' MHpa. Boo rny6O'-
KO'll cOD;na.lbHO'R rrO'Tpe6HO'CTil <P<>PMY-
JIbI 3BepIIIIO'ro CTIIJIH, KO'HeqHO', He TII-
pa mpO'Ba.lrrCb 6bI B TbICHqaX rrO'BTO'pe-
Hllll. TeMbI, 00pa3bI II KO'MrrO'3I1D;I1O'H-
HbIe rrplle lbI 3BepIlHO'rO' CTHJIH CO' Bpe-
MeH QaTa.l-fyroKa II TeJIJIb-XaJIa<pa
CJIOJiUlJIIICb B O'Tpa6O'TaHHYID II, '1TO'
rJIaBHO'e, llH<pO'PMau;HO'HHO' eMKYID
CHCTeMY 011ncaHIIH Milpa. Be3 rrO'MO'ru;1I
pe'III, O'J\Hun TOJIbKO' CIDIO'R xYP;O'meCT-
BeHHO'rO' Oopa<3a CD;eHa Tep3aHHJI, Harr-
plHlep, BHywaJIa Kamp;O'MY, KTO' MO'r BH-
J\eTb, '1TO :nO'T Milp - apeHa BeqHO'H
6O'PbObI ,:wYX HaqaJI, I1CXO'WIm,llX I13
O'P;HO'\'O' IICTO'qmIKa. B peJIHrllO'3HO'R
CliCTeMe 30PO'aCTpH3Ma TY me Hp;eID
yp;a,lO'Cb aJ\eKBaTHO' IIepep;aTb JIIImb
JJ:eCHTKa UI CTPO'K, T. e. C MeHbmeii: CKO'-
PO'CTbID npl';I"hHBJIeHHH HH<pO'PMaD;HII.
Ta me CII,CHa Tep3aHIIH MO'ma B611-
paTh II COB leru;aTb caMbIe pa3!II1qHbIe
O'TTeHKII "rtCTpa:IbHO'-KaJIeHp;apHoii, CO'-
una.lbHO'I! II pe,lllrIIO'3HO'll: CHMBO'JIIIKil
Kal, TO HBCTs)"eT I13 peJIhe<pO'B IIepcerrO'
" ' KCTaTII rOBO'PJI, I1MeHHO' rrO'JIHO'Ta
O'OpalHoro oll}icaHllJI H 6bIJIa rrpnqllHO'H
TO'ro. 'lTo IIO(IITe.1H '1HCTO'r{) 3BepllfIO'rO'
C I .lH. I,d I, IIOJ\MeTllJIa .n;. KapTep 2,
O'OXO,\II:III("I> oe;J rrllCbMeHHO'CTli.
b.la \,(!;\d pH O'THO'CIITeJIbHO'll: OJJH<3O'CTII
COUIIa:1 1>110<) KOHO'MHqeCKllX YKJIap;O'B
B <3O'He K ceBepy O'T 30° napaJIJleJIlI, rp;e
pa3Mem,aJICH KO''IeBOR' MIIP, Be)J:ym,I1e
TllrrbI Hap;CTPO'eqHblX CTPYKTYP pa3JIII-
qaMCb MaJIO' O' H OT p;pyrorO'. IIO'::!TO'-
MY 6PO'H3bI Op,!\O'ca .1erKO' «'lIlT aJIII Cb»
Ha 3arrap;e EBpa<3IIII, 06m,ep;ocTynHO'CTb
II rrpo3paqHOCTb <PO'PMYJI 3BepHHO'rO'
CTIIJIJI 6bIJIa I1TO'rml ep;I1HO'rO' MII<P O'JIO' -
:nrqeCKil O'PIleHTilpOBaHHO'rO' MIIPO'CO'3ep-
n;aHIIH.
fpa {MaTnKa 3BepllHO'rO' CTIIJIH, T. e.
CrrO'CO'ObI rrepep;a'lu H3O'6pameHIIH, B
::mO'xy p;peBHO'CTli yeHHJIaCb cpaBHII-
TeJIbHO' Ma.1O'. JIeKcrrKa, T. e. 3HaqeHIIH
O'Tp;eJIbHbIX 3JIl'MeHTO'B, O'6JIap;aJIa 6O'JIb-
meR rIl6KO'CTbID. IIoJIHO'rO' TO'mp;eCTBa
B ceMaHTlIKe MC;.tqy 3TpYCCKHMlI II
O'PP;O'CCKIIMI! KorrlIHMH O')J:HO'ro JIY-
pHCTaHCKO'rO' O'PilrIlHaJIa, KO'HeqHO', 6bITb
He MO'rJIO', TaK Kal, OHII O'6pam;aJIHCb B
pa3HbIX peJIHTI103HO-MII<pO'JIOmqeCKIIX
CIICTeMax. OWIaKO' B CIIJIY TOro, 'lTO' XY-
p;O'meCTBeHHaJI rrprrpO'p;a 3TIIX KO'IIHH
CO'Brrap;aJIa, He O'CTaBaJIO'Cb MeCTa II )I,JUI
rJIy6O'KIIX pacxom;IeHIIH CMbICJIO'BO'rO'
cO'p;epmaHllJI. B II,e.l0M <3BepHHbIH CTHJIb
ObIJI ep;HHbI 1 rrO' Bceii EBpa3I1I1, rrpil Ha-
JIIIqrrll MeCTHO'rO' cBO'eO'6pa3HH B Kam-
P;O'B KyJibTypHO'-llCTO'PIIqeCKO'H 3O'He.
IbO'6pa3IITe.TIbIIbIl' <PO'PMYJIbI 3BepIl-
HO'rO' CTIIJIH J\aBHO II He 6e3 YCilexa
CO'rrO'CTaBJIJIIDTCH C cPlirypaMH rrO'BeCTBO'-
BaTe.lbHO'rO' 3rrO'Ca. CTO'JIb me ynO'PHP;O'-
qeHHbI 1H II eLlllHOOOpa3HO' CTIIJIII3O'BaH-
HbI m. B ,mO'ce Tome HeBeJIHK Ha6O'P
CIDmeTO'B, pOJIeH II 3lIlITeTO'B, rO'crrO'p;-
CTByIOT Te me ce"aHTHqeCKlIe O'rrrr0'3II-
n;IIU: mII3Hb - OWPTb, p;O'6pO' - 3JIO',
MlIp 3TO'T II lIIp IIHO'H, KaJIeBaJIa II
IIO'XhO':W, Hall pmll'p. fepoII ,mO'ca Bcer-
p;a 6eayrrpeqrrbI. II IIYTb IIX O'p;I1HaKO'B.
OHII BbIe3malOT 113 P;O'MY, rrpeO'p;O'JIe-
BaIDT IIO' 00.1 I,m 6! '1aCTII O'T Tpex P;O' ce-
ll rrperrHTCTIJ II ii 12 TO.lbKO' Y fepaK-
,1a - rrepl'CT 'r1<1IOT TIO'PO'r IIHOrO' MlIpa
H.Tm rpalIJr BonlO;+;HOrO' II BO'3Bparu;aIDT-
CJI C TPIlY lcPO'1. TaKO'Ba ca aH pac-
rrpoCTpaHeHlIan n(> la. HeCO'BepmeHHbIII
HACJIE,I1;Iffi 3BEPMHOrO CTMJIH
B MCKYCCTBE CPE HEBEHOBhH
II ,II;PEBHEfI PYCH
IIpep;rrO'CbIJIKil K <PO'PMHPO'BaHilID 3Be-
pIlHO'rO' CTIIJIH CKJIa,!\bIBaJIHCb B I1CKYC-
CTBe p;o HaCTIIqeCKO'H MeCO'IIO'TaMIIH
TpeMH TbICHqeJIeTIIHMil II03me <PIIryp
mIlBO'THO'rO' IIpeBpaTIIJIaCb B rJIaBHbIH
MO'TIIB I13O'6pa3I1TeJIbHO'ro TBO'pqeCTBa
EBpa3I1I1 O'T XyaHx3 P;O' 6acceBHa .n;y-
HaH. IIO'xO'me, qTO' 3TO' HBJIeHIIe 6bIJIO'
CBJI3aHO' cO' CTaHO'BJIeHlleM paHHerO' HO'-
Map;I13Ma KaK HO'BO'B CO'n;I1aJIbHO'-3KO'HO'-
MIIqeCKO'B CTPYKTypbI I.
B HeM BbIpa<3I1JIIICb Te apXaIlqeCKHe
<PO'PMbI O'6m;eCTBeHHO'ro CO'3HaHIIJI, B Ka-
KIIX Bce KO'CMIIqeCKHe H CO'II,HaJIbHbIe
CIIJIbI BbIcTyrraJIII B 3BepHHbIX O'6JIH-
'IbJIX. OXO'THIIqbH II TO'TeMHCTHqeCKaJI
MamH O'KpamilBaJIa TO'rp;a BCIO KapTilHY
MHpa. .n;ame 6O'meCTBeHHO'e MO'rym,eCT-
BO' H3O'6pamaJIO'Cb KaK BnaCTb Hap; 3Be-
peM - 3TO' BrrO'JIHe O'qeBHp;HO' Ha JIY-
pllCTaHCKHX 6pO'H3aX H CKH«pCKliX Hsp;e-
JIHJIX THrra cepe6pHHO'ro 3epKaJIa I13
Ke,lepMeCCKllX KypraHO'B. B rrpHCT-
paCTllH palIHIIX KO'qeBHIIKO'B K O'6pa3Y
3Be o PJI KaK CllMBO'JIY O'CHO'BHbIX rrpO'HBJIe-
HHII 6bITIIJI CKaaaJIaCb MaTepilaJIbHaH
II P;YXO'BHaH 3aBHCIIMO'CTb O'XO'THllKO'B II
CK TO'BO'P;O'B OT Bep;yru;IIX <pO'PM rrpHPO'p;-
HO'II mIl3HII. TImJTOMY TaR BbIpa3IITeJIb-
HbI. BO'OrrpO'1l3Bep;eHHJI 3THX <PO'PM D
I1CKYCCTBe ;JBepllHO'rO' CTIIJIH. IIO':nO'MV
TaK O'm,YTIIMa B .rryqrnHX U3 HllX rrpd-
qYBCTBO'BaHHaH 6IIO'JIO'rHqeeKaH IIVJIbCa-
II,HJI O'praHllqeCKO'H mH3HII. .
3BepHHbIll: CTIIJIb rrpeO'p;O'JIeBa.l KVJIb-
'TypHbIe H HaIl,HO'HaJIbHbIe Py6emH. 'JIy-
258
BllP; rJIarO'JIa, rrO' TO'HRO'MY Ha6JIIDp;eHllID
B. H. TIpO'rrrra " CO'3p;aeT O'm,ym,eIIIIe
TO'rO', qTO' p;eiiCTBile RaR 6bI 3aCThIJIO
rrepep; rJIa3aMil rreBII,a.
CO'BepmeHHO' TaR me BHe BpeMeHU
CBIIBaIDTCH B IWJIbIl,a CKII<pO'-CapMa-
TCKIle XIIm,HIIRil IIJIII BO'CrrpO'II3BO'):\HT
BeqHyIO CMeHY mIl3HeHHbIX II,I1KJIO'B
CII,eHbI Tep3aHllH. II 3p;eCb CIIMBO'.'IOB II
CIDmeTHbIX XO'P;O'B HeMHO'rO', O'HII LlaHbI
3apaHee B CYMMe RYJIbTYPHO'ii Tpap;II-
II,III1 II rrJIeHHIOT He HO'BII3HO'll:, a 3Kcrr-
peccIIeii: II HaCTO'HqIlBOCTbID YI-<a3aHIIH
Ha TO', '1TO' 3a O'6MaHqIlBbIM pa3HOO'6pa-
3I1eM BIIp;I1MO'rO' CTO'HT eJ\IiHCTBeHIIOCTb
6bITHJI.
B rrO'CJIeP;YIDlII;lIx <pa3ax pa:JBIITIUI
e B pa3I1B:CKO'rO' HCKYCCTBa, yme Ha ca-
MO'B: sape cpep;HeBeKO'BbH, 6bI.'Ible 3Be-
pIlHbIe O'6pa3bI BORJO'T B 6O'JIee c.'lom-
HbIe I1p;eO'JIO'rnqeCKIle rrpO'rpaM lbI. Ha-
II,eJIeHHbIe, O'p;HaKO', Ha rrepep;aqy TO'ii
me eJ\IiHCTBeHHO'CTH, T. e. 6O'meeTBeH-
HO'H O'6YCJIO'BJIeHHO'CTH Bcex <pO'PM 6bI-
TIIH. OCHO'BY xYP;O'meCTBeHHO'H IWHI\CII-
II,HII cpe)J;HeBeKO'BbH CO'CTaBJIH.'Ia Teo-
pHH I1epapXllqeCKH O'praHII3O'BaIIIIO'r(l
KO'CMO'Ca. A 3BepH II <paHTaCTII'IeCI-<lIl'
TBapH TmIa rpH<pO'HO'B, p;paKO'HOB, C(,II-
MypBO'B H3p;aBHa HaCeJIJIJIH nO'T RUC-
MO'C. IIpH cKH<pax H capMaTax OHII oe3-
pa3)J;eJIbHO' B HeM rO'CrrO'p;CTBO'Ba.1II.
TIO'3p;Hee O'HII YCTyrrHT rJIaBeHCTBYIOIIIl'l'
MeCT.O' aHTPO'IIO'MO'P<PHbIM 6O'meCTBiI'l jl
q('JIO'BeKY, HO' Bce me CO'XpaHHT BailOl\'IrJ
PO'JIb B cpep;HeBeRO'BOM CIIMIJOJIII3MP.
B O'WIO'M c.rryqae ll3O'6pameHHH 3Bepeii
6yp;Y'f O'6eperaMII, B p;pyrO'M - \'l,;llil-
HIIHMll Ha rrpeMYAPO'CTb CO' 3;1<1 II 1101'(1
TBO'PIl,O'M MIIpa, Ha MO'rym;eCTiJO (TW(I.
p;aJIbHbIX BJIa)J;bIK, B TpeTbeM -Ha 011'-
HY mH3HeHHbIX II,IlKJIO'B. Be3 oopn;1(1l!
HCKYCCTBa 3BeplIHO'rO' CTll.'IH He.1b H OI>l
JIO' C H a)J;JIem a ru;e ii IIOJIHOTO'II ClTO"P:;-
3HTb KapTIIHY MlIpa. HerrO'mIaH r;apTI!IIi1
Bcer:ra HeVOBeprneHHa. C"eAO'lJaTf':l1.n Cl .
O'Ha HHKaK He MO'nIa 06O'iiTIICb 0(':1 \/1
PO'rnO' BceM 3HaKO' lbIX, HaCbImellllbl \ ""
259
Il{CIIOIlHTlibIlo( CO Cpil(alll1elo( 300 lOp\I)-
BblX OUpa30B. 3a60Thl 0 1I0JlHOTe liap-
TUHhl Mllp03AannH, 0 Ba1l60;ree BIlHT-
BhlX CIlMBOJIll'leCKIIX ee oT06pameHllJIX
npOH1l3hlBaIOT JIIlTepaTypBYIO TpaAII-
llIO CpeABeBeROBLH. Jl.a OBO II Bo06rqe
TpaliTOBaJIO xYAOrKeCTBeBBYJO AeHTeJlL-
BOCTL liaR cnoc06 BarJIHABOro npIIOO-
m;emm K BblcnmM TaRBaM, 0 'leI\( B BII-
3aBTllIl nUcaJI I10aHH AaMaCKIIH, a B
CTpaHax llCJIaMa - Cy«pIIRCKlle nO;:!TLI.
AJIH HllX, nYCTL He B paBHoii "tepe,
MHp 6blJI IlH06LlTHeM 60rKeCTBa, B YCT-
pOD:CTBe BCeJIeHHOD: Kaa8J1CR O'leBU -
JILlM a6COJIIOTHLrii pa3}'M. 3Bepn H Apa-
JiOHLl C HeCOMHeHHOCTLIO npeAYCMaT-
pIIBaJIHCL TaRUM YCTpoiicTBO (' C03Cp-
aH HX npuqyJ(JIHBLIe u306paffiCRIHI.
JIIOAH fny6me ypa3YMeBaJIII CllCTeMY
Mup03AaHllR. ]J,JlH 60JlLmeii RCROCTU
CIlMBOJIU'3Ma CO'lIIHRJIHCb OC06LIC PYIW-
BOJJ;CTBa, 6eCTHapuu, rp;e MOffiHO 6bIJlO
nO'lepmrYTL He06xop;IIMLIe CBe;:J:CnIHI.
BeCTuapuu, Aa H BCH cpeJJ;HeBeIWIJUH
.l"UTepaTypa AalOT nOHHTb, HaCliO.-rhIW
BamHLIM 6LIJl P;JIR 06rqecTBeHHoro co-
3HaHIIH 06p8.3 3BepH UJIH nTU bI. B 6('c-
CMepTHLIX CTHxax XaitJU38 lIyma 110;)
1'a ynop;06JIeHa paiicl<Ou nTlIUC. 'lYffi
JJ;oii 3eMHblx meJlaRllH. B CReTe :JToii
!lICTal}>opLI H HeHC'lIICJIIIMOrO MIlOiIWCT-
Ba 6mrnRHx eii yrroJJ;06JIelIIIii na 1 .1Cf-
'le nOHHTL, 3a'lCM TaR 'laCTO I11('OpaH,a-
.-raCb nTu a B HIIMoe ua n.JAeJlllR:\. lip II
l\:JIa;:J:Horo nCKYCCTBa, loUlllItaTIOIHlhL\ II
'{ame CTeHax apXUTeRTypllbIX r{J{II' -"'\'
HlIH Pycu, BII3anTIfII, 3al,alll:a3"1/ II
Cpc;:J:Reii A3UH.
B HeC,JIOmHO!l( It:\ XOBnOM !oInpc C"II
rlJO-capMaTcKoH [WPM aj)\un'/('cl,lIi1
:moc H 3BepIIHLIii CTIIJlb xapa"TelHl.ln
BamlCL MOHYMCRTa.lbHoii IIP.,('TOTOii
CpeliHeBeRoBLe me no:mIOOIl:ro TOil""
fTIf TOJIKOBamfii, >.nTpocn.-leT<'RIIII
JlOmneHHOro cnMBo.1II3\fR, cor,;;I':' II1n
qeMY UOHBII.aHCL 3arrYTuRIIb!<' \1/10,
:}JleMeHTHbIe opRa leRTa. bnhlP "0\1111'
.IIIII,Hlf. Terrepb OT.J;e. flTh fYI!!" II ,.,
II\1C UT lenHIOrqerocH CTa.'III rro- rrOBO IY.
Jl,.lH JlHTepaTypbl YCJlOHmCHne P;YXOB-
Iloii mn3BH CII:838JlOCb B nOBbImeHHU
C. bHOro Beca JlereH1I.bI, CI,a3IiU, npHT-
'lII, al}>opH3Ma. 3TU MeJllme <pOpMbI rre-
CTpIIJIrr CTIIJIHCTU'lCCHHM pa3Hooopa3U-
e I, IIlOaHcaMII TOJIKOBaIIIIH H BapuaH-
TOB. 3aTeM OHU CHOBa coe.n;rlHfl.'IHCL Ha
60Jlee BLICOROM ceMaHTH'leCROM ypOBHe,
CRaiKeM, B II,UKJlax nOBeCTeu C 06paM-
.'1eIllieM u T. A., BnOJlHe aHaJIOrn'lIlhlX
pa3BIITLIM opHaMeHTaJILHLIM II,UHJlaM.
CTapLIe TporrLI U «pHrypLI OCMLICJlHJIUCL
3aHoBo, IIHorlia B CaTnpU'leCROlol nJlaHe.
]J,peBHen:maJI TeMa MHpOBOrO ApeBa II
6bIRa npII UCTO'ffiHRe rKUBOn: BOJ1,LI B
rrapitJJIHCROM pOMaHe «Bnc B PaMBH»
HeomIIJJ;aHHo 6bIJIa HCrrOJlL30BaHa p;m
OCMeHHUH RopoHoBaHHoro poroHoCII,a.
MCTOpIl'leCRBe rrOBeCTIl U arrORpul}>LI
npeJIOMJlHJlU apXaH'lecRYIO Mnl}>OJlOrnlO
B p;yxe rocnop;cTBOBaBIImX peJIHfHOO-
HLIX B033penun TaK, 'ITO He Bcerp;a
MOrKHO cpa3Y p;o6paTbCH AO .nepBon:cTO'l-
HnR8 nx MOTIIBOB. JIumb Hep;aBHo
B. H. TorropoBY yp;aJlOCL BCRpMTb nOli
naCJIOeHUHMH xpnCTHaHCRon: I}>pa3eOJlO-
rnn B rOJIy6uHoii HHnfe onucaHue PH-
TyaJIa 'leJlOBe'leCIWrO rKCpTBOnpuHome-
HBH, B CTPYKTYPHo-cCMaHTlPIeCRO!l1 ac-
neliTe TomAecTneHHoe 3HaMemlToMY
nalHY nypymaCYKTa B PurBep;e U TeR-
CTaM neXJIeBnn:CRoro BYHp;aXllmna',
Tc ra TBOpeITIIH HOCMoca H:1 TeJla no-
BepffieHRoro oora IJ fOJIy6uHOM RUlfre
2
, ,
. '/ -....... -
\
5
6
9
"
"
I '
) . JJ
PIlC. 1. P03AU'lJU>le 2epaAI>OU'leCI>ue u30()pa-
:JIteHUR Ab606:
I - IllYMepcJ<aH rmmTHKa nepB. nonoB. III ThiC
:10 R. 8.; !II - a'l:eMeRIInCKHII IIpaKTeaT; :1 - caca-
"HI\CKaH TopeBTiKa: 4 - penbe$ ,lJ;"'''TpHeBCKOTO
,'oliopa. XIII B_: S,J- IIpaRcKaR TopeBTIIKa. XIII B .
b - r:mllTlllla a all'/<,cKo(,O ,lJ;eype'lbR. IV TN('
1;0 H. 3_: 1-8 - paHH<,axe...eUBJJ.CKaR TopeeTHKa;
9 - .1}1JRCTaR. VIII-\ II ee_; 10 - Ty;JJ<Ta; rop-
IIbra \aTaii; II - I'Ipall. X II e.; 12. 13 - TepM<'3.
'\ I[ e_. 11-15 - Ma.,aR A?IIR. xln e.; 16 - na-
.uTIIHcllaR 118 II"-'na , 'X I[ n: 17-18 - .n;MIITpllee-
('I,m" CQ(iop. XII B.
J.I
11
liO
,:
"
.
J . 'S.
,\. :-
1
- .\
'::..'1.::. n
. ..
.. t ",
I. -
3
"'
..
;' -<!1'
....
, ,
.:.
'I -
,
. r
I
;
,I
,.
,
B
10
t
' .r ....J.\ · ,J
,- t'
12 . .. , . "c..t'0' .
/3 '. '
..,,'
/5
---.
. e: ,
" - ..
} ! 1
"".. V
...
'-
-'f:'
; ..
'. ,
18
CJIe yeT cpep;Heu pallCKUM II MaIIuxeH-
CKUM Mop;emIM, HO Clloc06 ee llOp;aqU
cpaBHUTeJIbHO p;aJIeK OT llepBOHaqaJIbHO-
roo (hoT me UHTepeCHeHIIIUll TeKCT B06-
paBIIIUll B ce6H Maccy apxaU3MOB pex-
TbICHqeJIeTHell aBHOCTH, co epmHT
llpHMeqaTeJIbHOe paccymp;eHue 0 TOM,
qTO Mo eT H306pamaTb CQeHa Tep3a-
HHH 3aHQa XHm;HOll llTUQell. KaK pas
caMbIH <paKT pa3MbImJIeHIIH Ha ClOme-
TOM BbI aeT B aHIIO ! KOHKpeTHOM CJIY-
qae OqeBHp;HOe 3a6BeHIIe p;peBHero CHM-
BOJIH3Ma, BocrrpIIHU !aBIIIerOCH Korp;a-TO
GOJIee HHCTIIHKTOM U aMOQuell, HemeJIU
paccyp;KOM.
TaKaH me CQeHa Ha CTeHax )J;MIITpH-
eBCKoro c060pa BO R'Iap;HMlIpe, KaK H
pyrHe ero peJIbe<pbI. II3p;aBHa BbI3blBa-
JIH aCCOQuaQIfU C rO.'Iy6uHOH KHHroH.
Hap;o CKa3aTb, qTO coGop He YCTYllaer
fOJIy6HHOll Killue B gpeBHOCT'H clOme-
TOB. MUHUMYM llIeCTHa QaTb II3 HHX
HaCqUTbIBaJIU K MOMeHTy llOCTpoeHIIH
xpaMa OKOJIO llHTU TMCHq JIeT Hellpe-
pbIBHoro CYIQeCTBOBaHUH B IICKYCCTBe
peBHero II cpep;HCBeKOBOro BocTOKa
oc06eHHO I1paHa. CIO;1.a OTHOCHTCH CQe
HbI Tep3aHHH, ep;llHoGopcTBa repOH CO
JIbBOM, pa:mUqllbIe rCpaJIbp;IJ.qeCKIIe CO-
qeTaHUR JIbBOB, B TO I qllCJIe U JIbBbI 06
Op;HOB: rOJIOBe. llCTOpUIO KOTOpbIX UHor-
a ype3alOT BllJIOTb ;1.0 Haqa:Ia cpep;:He-
BeKOBbH, H MHorne ;1.pyrue (pHC. 1).
TaK fOJIy6uHMI KHura II )J;MUTPll-
eBCKUll c060p H POBHOll Mepe HB.'IHIOT
B IIX ClOmeTHblX rrporpaMMax BTOPHq-
Hoe 0606m;eIII!e I1YXORHbIX IJ;eHHOCTeH
p;aJIeKOrO llpom.'IOro. rrop;BeprHYTbIX HO-
BOMY OCMMC;leHIIIO. TpY HO Ha3BaTb 60-
JIee RpKlle CIJ !BO.lhI IIpee !CTBeHHOCTU
P;YXOBHOll U xY;J.omccTBeHHoll KYJIbTY-
pbI peBHerrmlIx UIIB!!.'IU3aurrll B II30-
6pa3UTeJIbHOM I!('!;YCCTBe n JIIITepaTY-
pe cpe;J.HeBCKOBLH.
He TO:lJrl;O ro,' 'OI!HaH KHnra p;aeT
OCHOBaHUH npC;J.IIo:raraTL BTOpnqHOe
pa3BIITne CU !BO,II!:nla 300 !Op<pHbIX <p H -
ryp B !!HLIX !!CTOrll'leCKIIX YCJIOBIIHX.
o TOM me cBHp;eTeJILCTByeT BCH opHa-
MeHTUKa cpep;HUX BeKOB C HOBbIMU KOM-
ll03HQlIOHHbIMU II CTllJIIICTHqeCKlIMH
llpUHQUllaMH. IIpHBbI'IHbIe 06pa3bI.
YHaCJIep;OBaHHbIe or CKH<po-capMaTcKo-
ro llepIIop;a. Tellepb Tpe60BaJIHCb, qT05bI
llOBe aTb 06 HepapXHqeCKOB: CTpYKType
<peolIaJIbHOrO Mllpa, 0 TaB:HaX II Kpaco-
Te TBopeHHH, 0 llpeKJIOHeHHH TBapn lle-
pe C03 aTeJIeM. TaKoH YKJIOH CIBIBO-
JIHKII B CTOPOHY 3pHMbIX 06pasoB OTK-
pOBeHUH 6bIJI THllHqeH P;JIH BOCrOqno-
xpHcTHaHcKoro H MYCYJIbMaHCKoro I!C-
KYCCTBa, TeCHO llepellJIeTaBmUXCH H a
BJIHmHeM BocToKe H oc06eHHo 3aKaB-
Ka3be. A pOMaHcKIIll MHp B HTore MO-
HacTbIpcKHX H JIHTyprHqeCKllX pe<pop !
X - XII BB. OTBeJI 300MOp<pHbIM CII !-
BOJIaM llpeoGJIap;alOm;ee 3HaqeHHe OTpl!-
IJ;aTeJIbHOrO HaqaJIa, 3amll<ppoBaJI B HIIX
Y3KO p;Hp;aKTllqecKylO aJIJIeropHIO II
llpep;ocTepemeHHe rpemHHKY. ITO:ITO-
MY-TO eAHHCTBeHHbIM pOMaHCKIIM TCp-
MHH0M, JVUI Ha3BaHHH mHBOTHOro CTa.1
YHHqllmHTeJIbHbIB: aneJIJIHTIlB «OC-
CTua» '.
A B BHsaHTHII, cTpaHax BOCTOK8
U Ha PYCH oGpa3 3BepH llPH Bcex ero
nepeOCMbICJIeHHHX B OCHOBHOM coxpa-
HHJI ll03HTllBHO-MarHqecKYIO <PYHI;IJ;IIIO
CKu<po-capMaTcKHx BpeMeH H llpe06.'Ia-
p;alOm;ee 3HaqeHHe 6JIaroro HaqaJIa.
B atOll 30He He llpUBHJIHCb HH QepKOB-
HaH p;Hp;aKTHqeCKaH aJIJIerOpIIH HU
MOHCTpY03HbIe pOMaHCKIIe aClleKTbI
3BepHHorr TeMb!.
ITo CllpaBelVIuBOMY 3aMeqaHI!IO
A. fpa6apa, B BOCTOqHOB: EBpone II
IIa BJIUmHeM BOCToKe apXllTe!\Typa II
IOTUBbI p;eKopa BonJIOm;aJIll op;Hy II TY
;.Ke Hp;eOJIOrHqeCKYIO llporpaMMY, COB-
nap;alOm;y B ee IICXOP;HLIX npuH1m-
rrax, HecfoTpR Ha BepOIIcnOBe.1HbIC
pa3JIUqIIH .
B aTOB: rnraHTCKOH KYJIbTYPIIO-
IICTOpIIqeCKOll SOHe Bce - II MYC '.'(r
taHe, H XpllCTllaHe - npIIMepHO O.l!!Ha-
KOBO TOJIROBaJIH CIBIBOJIIIKY 300Moprfl-
262
lIbIX <puryp, HOCIIJIU o emAbI H3 Op;HHX
H Tex me TKaHell, YKpameHHbIX opJIa-
MH, JIbBaMU, rpll<pOHaMII, QeHllJIH
HHorp;a BeCbMa p;aJIeKIIe OT pOMaHCKHX
xyp;omecTBeHHbIe 06pa3bI Bpo e Xa<pH-
30BOH llTllQbI - CHpllH B HllM6e H KO-
pOHe. CHpHHbI H306pamaJIHCb Ha Bo-
CTOKe TbICHqaMll, CKameM, B O HllX
TOJIbKO apMHHCKIIX PYKOllHCHX, Ha Py-
Cll H Ha BaJIKaHaX - COTHHMIl. A Ha
pOMaHcKoM 3allap;e HX llOqTll HeT, "3a
CqUTaHHbIMH HCKJIIOqeHHHMH, p;a II TO
eBpOllellCKHe HCKYCCTBOBep;bI HMeHYIOT
HX rapllHHMH, T. e. CYIQeCTBaMH OTPH-
aTeJIbHOrO llJIaHa.
OP;HIIM CJIOBOM, BamHellmHM llpOHB-
n.eHHeM CTaporo CKll<po-capMaTCKoro
3BepUHoro CTHJIH B cpe HeBeKOBOM UC-
KyccTBe BJIUmHerO BOCTOKa H BOCTOq-
H ll EBpOllbI 6bIJIa llOJIOmHTeJIbHaH
CIIMBOJIUKa 300MOP<PHbIX 06pa30B, llPH-
:maHHe HX 6JIaroro CMbICJIa II OqeHb
BbICOKoro MeCTa B uepapXHH llpIIpOP;-
HbIX <pOpM. OTHomeHHH Mem 06pa-
'3aMH 3BepHHoro CTllJIH CIIMBOJIII3UpO-
BaJIH CYTb KOCMllqeCKHX H COQHaJIb-
HbIX OTHomeHIIll.
qTO me KacaeTCH eARHcTBa JIHTepa-
TypHOll II H306pa3HTeJIbHOll Tpap;HQHB:,
"0 OHO 6bIJIO OqeBHp;HO P;JIH caMoro
cpep;HeBeKOBbH. OHO HamJIO ce6e llpe-
BOcxop;Hoe BbIpameHHe llOP; llepOM Ba.
raYP; IIHa BeJIep;a, CY<PIIllcKoro MIlCTU-
Ra XIII B., CbIHa relIHaJThHOrO lloaTa
,LJ:meJIa;Iap;p;IlHa PYMH:
«H BUp;eJI, qTO KOMll03HQHR BUP;II-
MbIX <pOPM, COTBopeHHbIX 60rOM, 6bIJIa
1I0p;06Ha KOMll03HQHU CJIOB. PeqeHn-
-eM «,LJ:a 6yp;eTh> nopomp;eHO BCHKoe
TBopeHIIe. IT03TOMY BeCb (3pUMbI!I)
Mllp eCTb (CBH3HaH) peqb, BbI3BaHHaH
K 6LITUIO CP;UHbIM «,LJ:a Gyp;eT!»... TaK
Kamp;bIll p;eHL H... BHp;eJI H C03epn a ,1
:!TII CJIOBa Ero...» 7
He Mellee KpaCHOpe'lllBO onIIcaHlle
pe3Horo y6paHcTBa AXTaMapcKoro xpa-
Ma B apMHHcKHX xpOHHKax, rp;e p;peB-
HeMecolloTaMcKHH roH 3BepeH KaKUMII-
TO TaUHCTBeHHbI !H aCCOIJ;IIaQURMU CBH-
3aH C 06pa30M BToporo l1epycaJIIIMa.
MomHO JIll paCllpOCTpaHUTb p;aHHoe
TOJIKOBaHUe Ha H306pameHUR rOHa
3BepeH B ITaJIaTIIHCKOH KalleJIJIe - He
HCHO, HO B03MOiKHOCTb aToro He HCKJIIO
qeHa, llOCKOJILKY BeCb H306paSHTeJIb-
HLIll KOHTeKCT B aTUX llaMHTHHKaX p;0-
C-TaTOqHO 6JI1I30K. Bo BCJIKOM CJIyqae,
06pa3 II C.l0BO 3p;eCb B3aHM03aMeHH-
IOTCH 6e3 YCU;'IIIll, H60 OHH paBHO CJIY-
maT BeCb !a 3aMbICJIOBaTOMY UHOCKa-
aaHlIlO.
ITPIU,WP 06paTHbIX OTHomeHUll, Kor-
p;a JIHTepaTypHoe llpOII3Bep;eH H e C03-
p;aer OIl\YlI eHne opHaMeHTaJIbHOll KOM-
ll03HIJ;HH, MomeT 6bIJIb llOKa3aH Ha
llpHMepe CKa3aHIIll 0 pbIQapRX Kpyr-
:loro CTo.,a. OpHaMeHTaJIeH caM llPHH-
IJ;IIn llOCTpoeIlIIH ClOmeTa. OH HalJ;eJIeH
Ha BlleqaT:I8H!!e, KaKoe H3BJIeKaeTCH
II3 TepnC:IIlBoro 0603peHIIH opHaMeHTa.
JII060ll a.TIeMeHT MomHO JIerKO II3'bHTb
H3 nOBeCTBORaHIIH H llOJII060BaTbCR HM
OTp;eJIbHO. BaiKeH He <pIIHaJI IJ;HKJIa-
MaJIO KO IV 011 II3BeCTeH B p;eTaJIHX, a
Tp aIlC <P o P;WIJ;IIH allllqeCKllX 06pa30B,
npUqyp;:mBoe O!!JICTaHIIe IIX 3llllTeTa-
MIL Pap;u ::!Toro HaCJIamp;eHllH ll3bICKaH-
1I0ll BH3blO. <PaKTypOB:, a He CYTblO,
C06CTRCIIIIO, II 3aTeBaJICH paCCKa3 8.
KaK RIIp;UM. 06pa3Hoe BocnpuRTue
Mupa 6.TIII:mo c.'Iep;OBaJIO 3a peqeBbIMII
onllCaTeJ!hIlhIMn llpHeMaMII. CJIOBO II
xyp;omeCTHCHITbIB: H306pa3I1TeJILHbIB:
3HaK 6bUII IIOqTII BCelJ;eJIO aKBUBa,:WHT-
IILI B !Ipo!\eCcax ll03HaHIIH. CMbIC.TIO-
BLle. PUDI!IqCCKUe H p;ame nHTOHaQll-
OIlHLIe CO!IO;JqUHeHHH B 6aJI.'l8p;e II
CKa:JKe OTlH'qa.l!I CTOJIb me qeTKOii PllT-
M!II;e oplla MeHTaJILHbIX Kmm03llHuIi.
A BCeOOlI\i1H Bn!ICaHHOCTl, II COllpHmeH-
1I0CTl, :J.ICMCIITOB opHaMeHTa BTOpn.TIa
IIi\ce C BH:\a HIIOCTU Bcex npoHII.'leHlIB:
IJLlTIIH. Tal; CTpOllJIIICb YHuBepca.1LHl,IC
:1HaKORhI I ' ("IICTe fbI cpep;HeBeKoBoro 06-
Il\eCTBa - OT CYXOH up;eII K peqeBoi'i
!I.lll RII:!\"inhIlOB: <popMYJIe, npII3BaH-
263
Hon nHOCRa3aTC.lbHO, MeTCl<pOpIl'ICCmr
BHymuTb CITY IIAeIO He CJUlmROM HCRY-
mellIlbBI B TeOJIOrnqeCRllx TOilKOCTHX
Macca r. I1cRycCTBO RaR cpeACTBO AY-
XOBlloro BJIaAbI'ICCTBa HaA 3aBIICilMbIMil
COD,lla'lbHbIMII rpyrrrraMU 6bIJIO 3HaRO-
MO ern.e apXaII'IeCIwMy ABypeqbIO II,
KOHeqHo, CRll<paM, HO BepmIIH CBOIIX
ono ;J.OCTIlrJIO IIMeHHO R rreplIOAY 3pe-
noro cpeAHeBeROBbH, RorAa BCH COBO-
I":yrrHocTb II306pa:mTeJIbHbIX II JlInepa-
TypHbIX TeRCTOB, CIIoc06bI IIX rrOAaqII
II r..:Um;J;aH MeJIRaH rrOAPOOHOCTb MeTa-
(IJOpn'IecRIl B3bIBaJUI R TeMe BeqHOCTIl
hill..: BbIcmen: rrpaBAbI 6bITIlH.
0pHaMeHTIIRa 6bIJIa qaCTHbIM CJIY'IaeM
BhICOROopraHII30BaHHbIX IIAeRHO-CIIMBO-
:1 I! 'leeIHIX CTPYRTYP cpep;HeBeROBoro
mlpOC03epD,aHIIH. Ee rrpOHII3bIBaeT
rrpnHUiliI nOAqepRHYTon opraHII3a-
IUIII, OqeBIIAHbIR B APyrIIx aHaJIOrIlq-
I1bIX CIICTeMax - 11306pa:mTeJIbHbIX,
pl' q (' BbIX, peJIIII'H03HO-<pIIJIOCO<PCRIIX.
[Jpllnu;rrrr aTOT 3aROHOMepHO BbITeRaJI
U3 YIIIIBepCaJIbHOR MOp;eJIII MUpa, U3
oop,na IIepapXIIqeCRII YCTpoeHHOR Bce-
.Il'IIIIOn:. Pa3Mern.aH JIbBOB, OpJIOB II
rpllqJOHOB cpep;II paCTeHIIR BOJIIue6HO-
ro ca;I,a. pe3qIIRH ,LI,MIITpIIeBCRoro c060-
pa. rrO;106110 CBOIIM TepMC3CRIIM IIJIII
a II II iicKIIM c06paTbHM, maiRAaJIII BbI3-
IHITh Y 3pllTeJIH BHYTpeHHee Orn.Yrn.eHIIe
C():JH ''IIIH CO Bce06rn.IIM pIITMOM TBope-
IIIIH. He TaR ym BamHO, qTO aTOT pIITM
B ;[er..:ope TepMe3CRoro ABOpD,a rrYJIbCoII-
I)(Ii<il.1 HarrpHmeHHee II qarn.e, Bep;b ero
.id.\ilHII.la TaM ropa3p;0 60.'Ice 3pe.'IaH II
H. 'r" 11I U30rn.peHHaH D,IIBn .III3aD,IIH. Ky-
:1,<1 Beco,ree TO 06CTOHTeJIbCTBO, qTO P;JIH
III!pe;J;aqll OTBJIeqeHHon: IIp;ell Bce06rn.eR
'npoeHHOCTII II OP;YXOTBopeHHOCTll MII-
pil II TepMe3e II BO B.lap;IIMIIpe 6bIJI
1I1'I1U.lb3fJBaH Tom,'J;eeTBeHHblll Ha60p
.II''''IOP<PIIblX 06pa30B. R TO IY me opra-
mf.l0BaHHblIT rro OP;HOll cnCTe're. TaM II
T;I\I OB paBHo rrpoTIlBoeTorr:r lIJJ;ellHOMY
"":ITPJ..:CTY pOMaHcRorr cKY"brrTypbI Ha
TI' :"e ca'Tble Te lbr.
o BceoGrn.eii 0AymeB.'1eHHOCTIl Mupa
II B3aIIMorrpeBparn.elluHx era <POpM CRII-
<pO-CIIoupcRoe llCKYCCTBO rrpeArrO'IIITa-
J10 rOBopIITb oYKBa.lbHO, CO'IeTaH rrpII3-
HaRII pa3HbIx mIIBOTHblX B OP;HOM 11300-
pameHIIII IIJIII KO IOIIIIIIPYH mIIBOTHbIe
<pOPMbI C pacTIITe.'lbHbBIll. Ty me ap-
XaIIqecRYIO TeMY cpe;.(HeBeRoBbe TpaR-
TOBaJIO C He MeHbmU'1 rrpllCTpaCTIIeM,
HO, ROHeqHO, MHoro06pa3Hee, IIHhIM XY-
p;omeCTBeHHbIM H3b1Kml. OHO He OTRa-
3bIBaJIOCb OT II3Haqa.lbHbIX CBpa3IIR-
CRUX u306pa3IITe.lbHbIX nplleMOB, RaK
aTO JIerRO BIIAeTb B pe be<pax feoprII-
eBCRoro cooopa, rp;e <paHTaCTIIqeCRUe
p;epeBbH paCTY!' II3 nTUqbIIX XBOCTOB,
UJIU Ha p;peBHepYCCKml cepeope II MII-
HIIaTIOpax C TepllmlOp(pHbIMII rrJIeTeH-
RaMII, HO B 60JIbmeli CTeneHIl OTBeqaJIO
AYXy BpeMeHII B3amliiOC COIIOA'lIIIIeHIIe
<pIIryp 3BepIIHoro CTII.IH B 06mllpHhIx
opHaMeHTaJIbHhIX KO rrr031ID,IIHX, CIIM-
BOJIII'IeCRIIX aHa:rorax KapTIIHbI MIIpa.
o TaRIIX RapTIIHax I1a PYCII rOBopIIJIII,
qTO OHII «XIITpOCTbIO 113 le'ITaHbI». Ha
BocTORe CqIITaJIOCb, 0 qeM yme rrOBe-
Aa.1J rraM BaraYP;p;IIII Be.,ep;, qTO IIX 3a-
paHee rrpep;HaqepTa.l TBopeD,. BbIpame-
HilH pa3HbIe, RaK pa3.ln'IHa CTllJIIICTII-
Ra BJIaAIIMllpo-cY3JJ;a.,bcr..:oro II cpep;He-
a3IIaTcRoro AeKopa, HO lbICJIb op;Ha,
RaR eAIiHO cOAepmallIIe PyCCROR II BOC-
TOqHOif opHaMeIITIII<IJ.
Oorn.eCTBeHHoe C03I1a IIHe CRII<po-cap-
MaTcKlIx BpeMeH ne OT.lllqa.IO rrpIIpOAhl
OT ee 1I300pameIIIIH, eTO:lb iRe op;ymeB-
neHHoro, RaR IT ero rrpoTOTIIII. EP;IIHCT-
BO Mlipa IIorrIIMa.IOCh ncepbe3, C HaIIB-
HOII 6yr..:Ba.'lbHOCTbIO. Ocoooif Hymp;bl
B ITHOCRa3aHllil Tor:r,a Ill' B03HIIRaJIO.
Orro rrOTpeOOBa.IOCh IIi! :'Jape cpep;HIIX
BeROB II BbIpa311. 1 0Cb B YC:lOiRHeHHOM
ilAeRHO-Cu!:rjWJIII'IeCKU\1 nO;1TeRcTe Tpa-
p;I1u;nOHHhI:t <pOp ly.1 IHPpllHoro CTIIJIH.
CKll<po-cap raTCKOC 11.111 rppaKllll:CROe
IICRVCCTBO HB.'IH.lO c"ooii :tllaRoByIO CII-
CTe;IY rrpocTeiimero TI1 IIi!. 3HaRII-RO-
IIIIII Ha Typa.'111eTrrqeC "" HOC npOII3BOP;II-
264
JlU CTpyRTYPY 0603HaqaeMOrO upep;'le-
Ta. C II11MII cocyrn.eCTBOBaJIU 3I1aKll-IIH-
AeRCbI. OHII p;aBa.rm qaCTb BMeCTO c-
JIoro no rrplIHU;IIrry MeTOHlIMUU - op-
JIlHIblii I":'IIOB IIJIE: r.1Ja3, rrpOTOMa rpu<IJO-
Ha, BUTon 6apaHIIR por 3aMeHH.Ill IIO.I-
nyIO <pIIrypy mIIBOTHoro. A cpep;HeBe-
IWBbe rrpeBpaTIIJIO CIIJIyaT 3BepH B 3HaK-
CUMBO.'I, OTB'leqeHHbIR 00pa3 BeCb'la
CJIOmHOR MbICJIII. TIoBbIlIIeHHaH C.IOB-
HOCTb 00pa3a II BC1'aJIa Orn.YTll'I Il rpa-
UbIO Mem,Qy rrpIIpop;oR II ee Il300pame-
HUeM. CooTBeTcTBeHHo, Herrocpep;CTBeH-
noe aMOU;IIOHaJIbHOe BocrrpnHTlle CTa:IO
oTcTyrraTb rrepep; CXOJIaCTIIqeeKIlM y ro-
rrOCTlIraHIIeM, ORpaCIIBlIIIIJ\! paccym:Je-
Hue fOJIYOIlIIOR RIIIIrlI OTHOCIITe.lbIlO
cu;eHbI Tep3aHIIH.
K TOMY me HaqaJIa 06HapYiRilBaTb
ceOH rrp06rreMa IIHp;IIBIIAyaJIbHoro BOC-
npIIHTIIH, HeBeAoMaH apxaH'lecRmry
MHPY. B CKll<po-capMaTCRYIO arroxy He-
JIeno 6bIJIO 3ap;aBaTbCH BorrpoeOM: r,J;e
KOnqaeTCH oorn.eCTBO II Ha'IUHae:CH
JlHqHOCTb? Ho aBTopaM TOR me rOJIYOll-
HOll: RHHrII IIJIII TIoBecTII 0 pa3yMe 'Ie-
JlOBeqeCROM aTO ObIJIO yme Heoe3pa3-
rrUqHO. Aa II XYAomHHKll He CTpeMll.'1UC
60JIee rrop;pamaTb rrpIIpOAe, a<peMeplIoIi
II HecoBepmeHHoR, RaR BCHRml)' TBope-
HIIIO. MycYJIbMaHCRIIe rrpep;aHIIH rrpn-
rrIICbIBaIOT XYAomHIIRaM npeTen:mn nu
rrop;pamaHIIe TBOPU;Y, a He TBapII. B
TOM qTO xaAIICbI IICJIa Ma II Me:m rro:r CO-
OOR' HeROTopbIe oe.HOBaHIIH, yoea..:.1aeT
reOMeTpII3aU;IIH BOCTOqHOro OpHaME' Ta.
B nell: OTOOpa3IIJIOCb p;BHiHeIIIIC aoCT-
paRTHOR rr03HaIOrn.eii MbIC:I1L II 0 II LIT K,l
OTORTII OT ROHRpeTHoii pea.'hnOC H,
AaHHoii B orn.ym;eHIIII, K Cll IBU.lII'ler hO-
MY 06pa3Y 6bITIIH, AOCTYlIlIoro TO.l ""0
qIICTOMY J1.yxy.
TIpII BeeM TOM, B COOCTBeHIIO """""-
rpa<pllqeCROM rrJIaHe cpep;IIeBer..:OBI," oc-
TaJIOCb Bceu;e.1JO OOH:'JaHHhDI (:TapO\1\ IT
nerrpllTH3aTeJIbHOMY :'JBepIIIIO\lY CTIIIIO.
Hap;e.'IeHHbIe HOBon OlbIC:JOHOIl !lal r' -
ROR OpJIbI, JIbBhI II ceHMypBbI (pllt. -.
4-9) upoAOJImaJIII coxpaHHTb OqeBIIA-
Hue CXOP;CTBO C paHHIIMIl npoTOTIIuaMlr.
aTn apXan'IeCRlle CIiMBOJIbI EBpa3H1
mll'III B ThICHqeRpaTHhIX rrOBTopeHlIflX
OC B rn.eHHbrx Tpap;IID,IIi"r 06pa3U;0
I ? ) Co CTaHOBJIeHIICM 1Irorn.llb1X
,pIIC. .
pe'lee:JeIlHbIx U;eHTpoB cpep;HeBeRoBbH,
TaRllx, RaR PereHcoypr II JIIIMom na
3aua;J;e, BarAap;, PeR, <DycTaT Ha BOC-
TOKe. aTOT rrpOU;ecc OopeJI rIIraHTCRlle
OOrn.eMIIpOBbIe MaClIITaObI. Ero YCIIJIII-
Ba:Ja crreD,lIaJIH3aU;IlH. PaKRa TbICHqa-
MII: ep;IIHIIU; rrOCTaBJIHJIa pacrrIICHoe
CTeK.IO C HeII3MeHHbIM HaoopOM CIOme-
TOB. MaccoBbIii IIMrropT TaRoro CTeRJIa
B oacceRHe BaJITIIRCROro MOpH 3aCBll-
AeTe:JbcTBoBaH B xOAe apXeOJIOrII'Ie-
eRIIX llccJIeAOBaHIIR HOBropop;a u II MHO-
rllX IIIBep;cRIIx rraMHTHIIROB. Pell II Ka-
maH aRcrropTIIpOBaJIII RepaMIIRy, OCO-
oeHHo JIIOCTPOBYIO. AJIerrrro II MocYJI
nOCTaBJIHJIII BeJIIIROJIerrHbIe 00pa3U;bI
paoOTbI rro MeTaJIJIY, ocep;aBmIIe a-
<peApaJIbHbIX pII3HIIu;ax pOMaHcRolI B-
ponbI.
BOCTOqHbIe 00pa3U;bI, ocooeHHo TeR-
CTII.lbHhIe II IOBeJIIIpHbIe, CTapaTeJIbHO
3 e 9 K rr p IIlIIe-
RorrIlpOBaJIIICb Ha anap; .
B A<pIIHax II AaHU;IIre c03p;aBaJIIICb
; U;IIaJIbHbIe MacTepCRIIe rro IIMIITa-
u;mr apa60-rrepCIIACRIIX ROBpOB II TRa-
HeR qT06bI yp;OBJIeTBOpUTb cnpoc Ha
JIll; yp rIIqeCRlle OOJlaqeHIIH. He TOJIbRO
. . P HbIX meJI-
u;epKoBb HymAaJIaCb B y30
r - a x TRaHbIX Ha MHoropeMII3noM p;aJIb-
\ . . TI e Teo
HeBOCTOqHOM CTaHRe. pII ABOp -
i-IopUxa rrapap;HbIn CTOJI HaRphIB".JIII
CKaTepTbIO BaBll.IOHCKOR paOOTbI. Xpo.-
HIICTbI X-XI BB. rrOqIITaJIII CBoelI
oOH:'JaHHocTbIO rrop;p06HO rrepeqllCJIHTb
CIOrt..:eTbI Ha BOeTOqHblX TRaHHX. Ta1l1O-
meHHhIe rr p IIBllJIerlIll Ha BB03 apa6CRIIX
TO IIX ma-
KOBpOB 6bIJIll CTO.1Jb BaiRHhI, 'I
:JOBa:Ja Herrocpep;CTBeHHO <ppaHU;Y3CRaH
- P OHa 10. A OJIIImHeBOCTOqHbIe II cpe,'J;-
KO II3 rr e'lliH
Hea3IIaTCKHe TeKCTllJIblIhIe '" '3b1-
IOmHOpyccKoro TpalI3IlTa TaR II Ha.
Ba.IIICb BO <DpaHU;IlII XII-XIII BB.
265
«PYCCKJilMHt 11. CHa'laJIa HX Y30paM
rrOApamaJIH ApeBHepYCCKJile TKa'llI, rro-
TOM TeM me 06pa3n;aM CJIeAOBaJIH JIHOH-
CKHe. 3aHeceHHble KpeCTOHOCn;aMH B
EBpOrry 3MaJIH OpTOKHACKOH CHpHH
rrOpOAHJIH Maccy DOApamaHHH B Ma-
CTepCKHX JIBlwma.
T8K ApeBHHe CIOmeTbl B 06pa3bl 3Be-
pBHoro CTHJIH B X-XIII BB. HaBOp;HB-
JIH BeCL cpep;neBeKoBblH MBp H 06pa30-
BaJIlI oc06b1ii MemHan;uoHaJIbllbrH H::I06-
pa3HTeJIbHblH H3blK, rroHHTHblH OT TRHb-
IlIaHH AO CRaH,I{HBaBCIDIX I}>bOPP;OB.
CBoe06pa:moM)' B03pomAeHBIO 3BepB-
HOro CTHJIH ue MeHee BHemHBX crroc06-
CTBOBaJIH BnyTpeuHHe DpH'lHHbI. HOBble
COn;HaJILUO-rrOJIHTB'IecKJile BAeB 3rrOXH
nymAaJIHCb B aAeKBaTuoM BblpameHHB.
I10HHTDH rOcrrOACTBa B rrop;qHHeuHR,
repam.AH'leCRaH TeM8TBRa, peJIHI'Hoa-
HbIe CDMBOJIbl HCK8JIH ce6e 06ID;eAo-
cTyrrHoro H BMeCTe C TeM RpRoro oopa3-
Horo rrpeJIOMJIeHHH. q TOObl y6eAHTeJIL-
HO B03AeHcTBoBaTb Ha o6ID;ecTBo, OHH
He AOJImHbl 6blJID OTpblBaTbCH OT rrpo-
BLI'lHLIX cxeM H 06pa3n;OB, TaK, IITllD;bl
C nepeBHThlMlI meHMH (pHC. 3, 3-7),
MOTlIR ThlCJI1IeJIeTHeH AaBHOCTH, B BOC-
TO'lUOXplICTHaHCROM HCKYCCTBe AeMOH-
CTplIpOBaJIH HAeIO peJIHrH03HOii JIIOOBII
H RpOTOCTH. qTO OHB MOrJIH 03Ha'laTL
n 6YAAHHCKOM DJIlI CeJILAmYRHp;CKOM
BKoHorpa4JH'leCKOM perrepTY8pe -
OCTaeTCH TOJIbKO raAaTb. BepoHTuo, BC-
XOAHaH ApeBHeBOCTO'lUaR CHMBOJIBKa
ep;nHCTBa ABYX Ha'laJI COXpaHRJI8CL
3AeCL B 60JILmeH CTerreHB.
llpn HeCOMHeHHbIX pacxomAeHlUlx
'IaCTHOn CHMBOJIHKJiI H AeTaJTeH TOJIRO-
naHlIR TepBoMop4JHblH opHaMeHT K81<
ClICTeMa OhlJI n;eJIOCTHblM KYJILTypno-
lICTOpIIqeCKBM HBJIeHHeM. OH He HIIIT-
TlIpOBan 60JIee OpraHBqeCKOii mn3HI!,
KaK CKll4Jo-capMaTcKllH, B He f «ape-
JIOCL ueapHMOet. B nRAe npIlBbIqllLI\:
0AYmeB.1JeHHblX CYID;eCTB - :ILBOB. rpn-
I}>OHOB, cnpHHOB - MaTepna:IllaOBanllCL
HOBble OTBJIe'leHHble BAelI.
CBH:mhIH Haoop 3TBX HAeii H306pa-
31ITeJIhHO rrepeAaBaJICH Tal' HaablBae-
Moii opnaMeHTaJILHOii ceTRoii, cnCTe-
MOH na parrrropTHo-rrOBTopHIOID;OXCJI
3JIeMeHTOB 6e3 n;eBTpaHbBOB OCB CBM-
MeTplIH. Ha3Ba'leHHe STOB ceTKB-
oopaallo nOrrJIOTIfTL TeM)' 6eCKOne'lBO-
CTB n BaaMOCBH3aBBOCTB MHpa. PaH-
Bne ee THfIbI B3BeCTHbI eII(e Ba ypap-
TCKnx opOBaax B B 3DBHe. llo3me OHa
3BOJIIOn;1I0HHpOBaJIa B CHCTeMe orrJIe-
TaIOllWro KOBpOBoro apXHTeKTypHoro
AeKopa, He CBH3RHBoro C rrponopD;Bo-
BaJTLfIbIMlI 'lJIeHeHBHMH yRpamaeMHx
lIM rrocTpoeK. I1plUlepbl - BCR apXB-
TeKTypa BCJIaMa, 3aKaBKaaLH, BJIRAB-
MlIPO-CY3AaJILCKOii PYCII. POMaHcKoe
II Bn:JaHTuiicKoe 30p;qecTBo KOBpOBOro
AeI<Opa Be 3llaJIO.
HeAaBHO B Typn;BB OLIJI paClmnaH
ABopeu; XIII B. C MHoro4JHrypBLIMH
KepaMllqeCKHMB OOJIBD;oBKaMB fIH-
TepLepoB. I1KoHorpa4JH'leCRaH rrpor-
paMMa OpHaMeHT8m.Boro yopaHcTB8
B 3TO\f r:{BOpn;e COCTaBJIeHa B3 Tex me
3.TleMenTOB, qTO yRpamaJIH rrocTpoihm
CY3'18.1:hCKHX IUlH3eii, raaHeBHAoB
II ,tIllIlaCTBlI Apn;pynu. llpe06JI8AaIOT
Cn;errM Tep3aHBH, OXOTLI, JILBbI, OpJIbl,
onpnrrbI, H300pameHHH eAHH06opcTB,
My3MKHHTOB H T. A. .n:nopen; AJIR-S;(-
ABHa HeiiIm6aAa HBHO BXOT(HT B oAIIY
rpyrrrry c xpaMoM HpecTa HR AXTaMape:
J; . ,.-0
0'. - "
j
":' 2 '
"'-
., \ . '. 5
........ ...
4 5
I <
) ..t. .,;
. 't"
__A . ,
6
9
ro .". /I
..
'""'
'*
12
Q t'-
<.
15
14
Puc. 2. repaAbOU'leCr;ue CO'leTOHUJI Op./lOB,
AbBOB U ceHMgpBoB U TO:IICOeCTBeHHNe UM
11306pnJt(eHUJl B ucr;yccTBe pa3HNx ano:r
J - Cc"nf)paTuHA lIypraB 4; 1/ - xpa'\f rapeyca B
)y PYHC. II D. R. D. Tall JJ BOCT8U, VII B.; /1 - Ca-
CIIHII'UHIIR lfpau, Tall H BocTau, VI-VII BB.;
I - APPDHRH PYCb, XII B.; IS - BeurpJJR, IX-
X DB II (kceu, 1050 r.; 6 - cau,,) pDY JJ nTJJ"",
D pal"TI'- .Jy,uoA nneTeBlle; '1 - THaHb U3 Barna-
:\3 t OO '; 8-9 - ApeBURH PYCb. XII B.; 10-
lianIlTf':Jb U3 maM-RaJ1hl , :KymaHCI<8R BaR!'j)Bn:
1 I - pn"au(,HaH lIaIIBTeJIb, c%>paUI\RH XII D.; 111-
H,"'PIIII",R penbecjJ, Mocyn XII D.; 13 - axeMe-
IIII:Il"HaR TepeDTHlla (IlOJIneHI\HR c%>opyra); 14-
BpeDllaplI1! AmMOJIa, Am::IHH XII D.: lIS - f)mOJlO
\13 ."'!"Hl"Opa, ErRIleT XI B.
266
)J;Bop aMll B raaHII, IIancp [Q, Tcp-
Meae n )J;MHTpnenCKliM C060POM BO
BJIa)l;HMHpe. Bce BTII coopymeHIIH /1,e-
KOplIpOBaHhI OAHIIM n TC\I me na60-
pOM 3JIeMeHTOB no op;Hon me CHCTeMe
IIX HHTerpa 1I1I B e.rUTHoe Ce IaHTlf'le-
cKoe enoe.
06HJIHe CllMBOJIH'lCCKOrO 300MOPclt-
Horo 1(eKopa B TpOHHhIX aanax H06ap;a-
Puc. 3. 30oMopifmbl.u oump 6 ur;ol<ozpatfiuu
pa3AU'lHbl.X apXUre1<TypHblI 1<OMnAe1<Co6:
1- rnUnTHKa apX8U'IeCHOro ;(B)'peGLR. IV '''hIC.
no R. 3.; Z - TYBa, BTOp. nO:JOB. I TblC. no R. 8.
(HOJlJ1eHIU!R C. A. TennoyxoRaI: 8 - HoneacKuA
'laaTaC, VII-VIII BB.; 4 - UB:J.nR, X B,; IS-
MaprDBaJI apKRBCKOA PY1<onncn XII B.; 6 - He-
paMH'IeCH3Jt OIlJIHi\OBKa D3 no&l)j;a!ial\8. XIII B.;
7 - ,[J;MuTPueBcKHA cOllop XII B.
. " 't\
; Tr. C- ',",,' -3 "
x.
I. ..... - , '.;!i
.'<,
"- t io»"
.. ,.r
-S1f
( .
6
6ap;CKoro ABOPLla TOJIKyeTcH aBTOpaMH'
paCKOnOK KaK nOrrhITKa 06JIe'lb Ce bp;-
mYKnn;CROro CYJITana B OpCOJI ?mclto-
JIOrII'leCKOrO COJIHpnOro repOH no CTa-
phIM 06pa.ILlaM CTenHoro HCIiYCCTBa
p;omcp;mero co BpCMeH IIaabIpbIKa .2:
CXOP;HhIC HBJICHHH IIpOHCXOABJIII B PYC-
CKOM HapO)J;ROM 9IIoce, IIpCBpaTHBmCM
B apXaH'leCKHX COJIHpBldX repoeB Kpe-
CTllTC:rH PYCH n Manoa3HaTCKoro MY-
'leHHK8 reoprHH. IIcpBhIH HaahIBaJICH
B BIloce He HHa'le KaK HpaCHoe COJI-
HLlIIIKO, a Ha HKOHax C lIa06pameHIICM
II06cJJ;oHoc a 'laCTO B Kpyr II:{HTa BIlll-
ChIBaJIH COJIHpnyIO BM6JIeMY.
BBWIMO, H BCeBOJIOp;a III, aaKaa'lH-
Ka )J;MHTpllcBcKoro c060pa, cpeAH Ilpo-
'lIlX, B/1,OXIIOBJIHJIH OTHOCllTeJIbHO 6nH3-
".
.. -
i
........: . .
\; .., :-
..
if
2
.
)
,.
- "
5
r
I
'
:Jt
1
268
IillC n06ymJJ;ennJI. Pa3HHI\a MemJQ'
LlepKOBbIO H ABOp OM, CfTOJIb xapaKTep-
lIaH ;J;JIH pOMaHCKOro 3ana/1,a, Ha XPU-
CTlIHHCKO?t II BceM OCTam.HOM BocToKe
Ill' cym,CCTBOBaJIa. B apMHHCKOM
oIOBoynoTpe6JIennu TepMUH CTa-
'Iap9 - aIleJIJIHTUB axcMennJJ;cKoro npo-
IICXOmp;eRIIH - OaHa'laJI U 1(Bope ,
II I.\Cp'KOBb, II napaAHbIH 3aJI npu-
I:'MOB . He BccrAa IIPOBO]J.HJIOCb OT'lCT-
:IIIBOe paaJIlf'Iue MemJQ' xpaMoBhIM UH-
TepbepOM II uP;BOp OBhIMU IlOKOJIMU 1(a-
me B caMOIl BuaaHTuu, HaIIp1!:Mep, B
CTapbIX IlaJIaTaX BYKOJICOHa UJIH
B :\larHaBpc. 3TO 6hIJIU pUTyam.HhIe
;lI\OPLlOBhIe KOMIlneKChI C xpaMOBLUIU
(bYIlK nJIMll, TaKlIe me, KaK coopyme-
DIIH O:\IellJI/1,OB B )J;aMacKe U A66acuTJ,OB
B C.ufappc H Barp;aAc.
IICpC'lIICnCHRoc CP;HHCTHO CBeTCKoro
II CaKpaJIbCKOro Ha'laJI, CTOJTh THIIB'I-
Iloe A.1H 6JIllmneBOCTOqROB: IIBHJIHaa-
mIlI. cna6hIIII BXOM OT03BaJIOCb B ao-
O\fOpcltUQ.M p;eKopc )J;MllTPllcBcRoro co-
6opa. Bpamp;c6Hoe OTHomcnnc epKoB-
Doii J1CTOIIHCU K JTOMY IIaMJlTHHKY
.o:aCT IIOHHTb, 'ITO TaRoe BXO p;eB:CTBH-
Te.1bHO aB)"laJIO Ilpn BJIaJJ;HMupCKOM
nBopc II HaXOAIIJIO cc6c OTKJIUK. HapJI-
]J.y C ITOJ1TThIM Tom.o:CCTBOM uKoHorpa-
ITJIIQeCIillX nporpaMM H06aAa6aAcKoro
ilJlOpI1a II )J;MIITpIlcBcKoro c060pa, HX
n;\elmylO 6JIU30CTb B OTACJIbBhIX MO-
MPIITa \":, AaJICKO, KOHC'lHO, He BO Bcex,
ITOnTBCpmAalOT H IlOaBOJIHIOT c6mlmaTb
ITu:.nTITRRo-:\rarH'lCClmH IlOATCRCT P;C-
IiOpa If OTpII aTe.'IbHaH pCaKI111H pyc-
nwii I1epKIJIl.
IICTOI\II II:\ICHHO 300MopcltHoro ap-
XITTel,Typnoro ACRopa BOCXOAHT K IIap-
rlllIITCliIlM coopymcHIuTM XaTphI II B.
::to H. . TaM mc. Ha IIepCAnCM BocToKe
pll3RllncH II npHHI1I1IT paBHoMcpHoro
3J nOJIReITHJI II:IOCROCTIT opHaMeHTaJIb-
HOII cCTKon, RaH60.'Iec IlOJIHO BOIIJIO-
meHHbIn B Y30pe'lbC fcoprncBcKoro co-
iior a . BIlJ1CTenIJhIe B TaKYIO CCTKY 30-
mfOPcltHhIC CnMBOJIhI. HacnC,[J;HC ,[ij)CB-
HUX HBUJIIl3aQllll BOCTOKa II CIiH-
clto-capMaTCROll CTCrrHOll CTIIXIIII, CJIa-
raJIHCb B HOBhIe CCMaHTlIqCClille CIfCTC-
MhI, OTpamaBmIIe e.10iliBbIlI JJ;yXOBilhIH
MUp CpCp;HCBeROBbJI. OTTelIRlI IIX 3H3-
'IeHllll 6hImI oeCKOHC'lllhI. B KanpClwii
CpKBII CR. BapBapbI XI B. a:rTapIIaa
IIperpap;a BMeCTO mwrr IT.II1 :\pllCnIaH-
CKlIX BM6JICM ObIJ1a CII.I0llib I10KphITa
ceTKOH ua aooMopcltHbI\": U paCTlITCJIb-
HhIX Y30pOB. Ha BTOll ITpCrpaAe HalII-
nOCb MeCTO U P;J1H CI1en oopb6bI, OXOThI,
JI,JIJI IlJIJICYHOB I'I M)"JbIRaHTOB nOMIIMO
Tcpaamrii:, repaJIbJJ;lf'IeCKllX Ilap, IITU
Y UCTO'lHUKa Be'lHOCTll II rrpoQIlx Tpa-
,[J;UII;IlOBHhIX TeM. CJ1CAOBaTCJIbHO, CYM-
Ma 3THX 06pa30B B BCKOTOpbIX CJIy'laHX
MOrJIa Aamc HeIlocpe;J;cTBcHBO 06cny-
mUBaTb KyJIbT II JIllTyprlllO. AJITapna:I
npcrpaA3 B I1CpROBR(Y.I! IIHTCpbepe CllM-
BOJIHQeClm uJ06pama a c eIlY pan.
Pail B BHp;e BO:lmc61I0ro caAa n:m OXO'f-
HH'lbCrO IlapI>a, rranO.lITelIHoro 3Bcpn-
MU U nTllI1allIIl,- ;:J,peRlIlIH 06paa aBC-
CTHllCROll MIIt1>OJIorun. )J;pcBlIenpaH-
CKOC c.nOBO «rrapap;n.JII ITepBOIlaqaJIbHO
OaHa'la.'IO U:\(CIIITO O\":OTBll'luii Ilap!t,
MeCTO naHBLJCmerO u:!3meHCTBa BO-
CTO'lHbIX B:Ja::tJ.lK. IIepcnoc TcpMHHa
'lepca rpCQecRYIO neppna'lY H3 IIXCMe-
HH]J.CliOll IIepclfIl B pauHecpcp;HeBcRo-
BYIO ERporry ::\OCTaTUqnO flCHO rOBopuT
II 0 ,[\Bnmcnllll Jlncn IJ TOM me HarrpaB-
JICnIlH. COOTReTCTHPIIHO, II pYCCKoe
1l0RnTne. oqmr:\I.lPIIJloe CeIJPpOHpIlH-
CROB: CRce:\IofT « PI1II". p;O.'lmHO 6hIJIO
npniiTJI II3 TOro ,Ke IICTO"IITHRa, 'ITO II
aana;:\I!oe B pOlleik lioe ,< II a paAH3».
OQCBn;UlOe Ylia:W!llIe Ha paIICJ;YJO
TCMY B TlIITephep" lil1lIpCIWii u;epIi-
BU XI B.. TpaliTonanllOC rrOCpC;(CTBOllf
300:\fOpqmoii OpIHI\It'IITa.'IJ>IIOH ceTKH,
MomCT ;;J.TTL C JJ3J1Pf"TIThI\IH OCHOBaHIIH-
MH ITepCI!eceno IT:; CnCTe\IbI ]J.CKopa
B R06a::ta6aJIe. B.la:rll \lITpC II TepMeac,
nOCRo.1bK)' Hce Orlll TaI> UJIll HHa'le
1'I306partiauIT RO.II1IP(,III.JIr ca,[\ C cro 60-
rtiCCTBenITbDm II I1f''''III:\ITI 06IITaTc:1fI-
269
MIL OpTOJJ;OKCa.iIbHali n,epKOBb IIMeJIa
CBOe IWIIOIIIIqeCKOe IIpe):\CTaBJIeHIIe
o pae, IWrreqHO, IIpOIl3BO)VIOe OT o6m,e-
ro eBpa IIIICKoro, HO yme He VOBlIa):\aB-
mee CHID!. IT03TmlY OHa He O):\o6pHJIa
)];IIIIITpnOBCRIIll co6op KaK CIIMBOJI
CBeTcKoro I,I1HmeCKOro BeJIHqIlH II ):\aHb
eBpa:mlICRoii COJIHpHOH MII<pOJIOrIlIl,
YIIOPHO npo6IIBaBmeHCH I13-IlO):\ n;ep-
KOBHblS IIOKpOBOB B alloce, I1cKycCTBe
II ):\ame arnorpa<pIIII.
HCqe3HOBeHIIe 3 BepHH1JX 06pa30B
, M. Bussagli. Steppe Cultures. EW A, XIII,
1967, p. 380.
2 D. Carter. The Symbol of the Beast. N. Y.,
1957, p. 17.
3 B. H. JIponn. PycClmii; repOIIqeCKIIII aIlOC.
!.. 19.58, CTp. 541.
, B. H. Tonopo8. CTpYKTypa HeKOTopblX ap-
XaIl'lPCI,HX TeKCTOB, COOTHOCIIMbiX C KOH-
enU11eii {<)mpOBOro JJ;epeBa». Y3TfY,
BblII. 284. TapTY, 1970, CTp. 9-62.
5 E. Fuhrmann. Das Tier in del' Religion.
Miinchen. 1922, S. 67.
· ..1. Grabar. Byzance. L'Art Byzantine du
M yen Age. Paris, 1963, pp. 25, 55, 71, 78.
7 «Aspects of Islamic Civilization». London,
1964, p. 253.
8 E. 'inal"er. From '.fotive to Ornament.
113 apXIITeKTyplIOro ):\eIwpa B IIocxe-
MOInO."IbCKOM nepIIo):\e Tomo IlpOII30m-
JIO O):\HOBpeMeHHO Ha PYCII II B CTpaHax
BOCTOKa, Tor):\a Kal{ Ha 3arra):\e rr03;J:He-
roTIIqeCKIIe MOIICTpbI II XIIMepbI IlpO-
):\o.rrmaJIII CBoe cym,ecTBOBamIe. TaR
3aKaHQIlBaJIaCb I1CTOpIIH 6bworo 3Be-
pIlHoro CTIIJIH - B ypo;:J;:1IIBoll rpIDlace
BOIlJIom,eHIIH 3JIa, XOTH HaQIIHa:mCb OHa
IlpOC aBJIeHIIeM BeJIIIqIlH II HeIICTpe6H-
MOCTII mH3HII.
AfCII
«Medieval Literature and Folklore Stu-
dies». New Jersey, 1970, p. 147-1.53.
9 R. Bernheimer. Romanische Tierplastik
und Ursprunge ihrer Motive. Miinchen,
1931, SS. 84-85.
10 R. A. lairazbhoy. Oriental Influences in
Western Art. Bombay, 1965, p. 47.
\I M. B. $exnep. mem,oBhle TI>aHIi I>al> IIC-
TOqHIIK JJ;JIII lIayqenI1J1 :jJ,OIlO)l!IqeCI>IIX
CBllaell: JJ;peBHeII PYCII. dlcTopH" II I>Y.1lb-
Typa BOCTOqHOII EBpOIIbI lIO apxeO.lorll-
qeCKIlM JJ;aHHbIM». M., 1971, CTP. 209.
12 K. Otto-Darn. Bericht uber die Grabung
in ,Kobadabad. AA, 1969, HI. 4, S. 449,
478.
t3 H. A. Op6e.A.u. I1a6paHIIbIe TpYAbl, T. I.
M., 1968, CTp. 38.
AAHY
AHKCII
AI1HY
AO
AC
ACfa
BAH
AH
BCCA
fI1JIHM
J\I1C
All
WII1
iKMHII
3PAO
HAK
IIAI1
I1BAH
IIBAA
I1KOBfO
CUHCOK COKpa eHlIii
- AHTIPIHLIe ropoAa CeBepHoro
I1pllqepHOlowpbli
- ApxeoJIoriqHi AoCJIiAmeHHII
Ha YKpaiHi
- AHTII'IHali I!CTOPIIII II KYJIh-
Typa CpeJJ;lIaeMHOIowpbll I!
I1plPIepHOMOpbll
- ApxeoJIOrIl'IeCKlle IIccneJJ;OBa-
Hilli Ha YKpaHHe
- ApxeoJIOrllqeCKlle OTKpblTI!H
- ApxeoJIOrllqeCKIIU: C'beaJJ;
- ApxeoJIOrl!qeCKIIII c60pHIlK
focYJJ;apcTBeHHoro apMIITama
- BOJIrapCKali aKaJJ;eMIlIi HaYK
- BeCTHIlK AKaJJ;eMIlIl HaYK
- BonpOCbI CKII<po-capMaTcKOII
apXeOJIOrIIII
- fOJJ;l!illHIlK Ha I1JIOBJJ;I!BCKIlIi
HapOAHIl MyaeII
- ApeBHocTIl fepoJJ;oToBOII CKII-
<p 1I1I
- ApeBHocTIl I1pllJJ;HenpoBbli
- ApeBHocTIl '-IeqeHo-I1Hryme-
TIIII
- iKYPHan MIIHIfCTepCTBa
HapOJJ;Horo npOCBeII\eHIII!
- 3anllCKil pyccKoro apxeo.l0-
rllqeCKOrO 06II\eCTBa
- I1aBecTIlIi apxeO.1l0rll'leCIWii
KOMIICCllif
- I1aBecTIlIi Ha apxeOaOrIfQeCKIl
IIHCTlITYT npif BAH
- I1aBecTHIi Ha B"bJIrapCKIII! ap-
xeOJIOrlIqeCKIi I!HCTI!TYT
- I1aBecTIlIi Ha B"bJIrapCKOTO
apxeOJIorlIqeCI>O APYmeCTBO
- I1aBecTIlIi KpbIMcKoro OT;<e-
JIeHll1i BceCOIOaHoro feorpa-
<pIIqeclwro oi'iIl\PCTBa
I1l\N>AH
lIHMB
I1P AI1MK
RAM
KJIAI1
RCliA
I\CHI1MK
"'AR
'.IAP
'.mA
H3
OAK
nIICI1Aa
nIIAO
nCA
eA
CAlI
ef AIIMK
efa
271
- HaBeCTll1i MOJIJJ;aBCRoro <p1I-
JIllaJIa AH CCCP
- HaBeCTll1i Ha HapoAH1l1i
Myaefi: B BapHe
- I1aBecTIlIi POCCI!U:CROH aKaJJ;e-
Milil IICTOpIIII MaTepl!anbHOII
RYJIbTYploI
- KYJIbTypa aHTllqHoro Mllpa
- KeMepOBCKali JIa60paTOpilII
apXeOJIOrRqeCKIIX RccneJJ;OBa-
Hilii
- KpaTKlle C006m;eHIlIi 11 HCTII-
TyTa apxeOJIorll1l AH CCCP
- KpaTKlle C006m;eHIlII HHCTII-
TYTa IICTOpllII MaTepIlaJIbHOU:
RYJIbTypbI
- MaTeplIaJIbi IlO apXeOJIOr1I1I
KaBKaaa
- MaTepllaJIbi no apxeOJIorll1!
POCCIfIl
- MaTepllaJIbi II IICCJIeJJ;OBaHIIII
no apxeOJIorll1l CCCP
- HYMllaMaTIlKa II anlIrpa<pI!Ra
_ OTqeT apxeOJIOrIl'IeCKOII KO-
MIICCIIII
- I1poo.'1eMbi IICTOpll1l CeBepHO-
ro I1pIfqeplIOMOpbli B aHTJIq-
HYIO anoxy
_ I1p06JIeMbi IICTOpll1l JJ;oKanll-
TaJIIICTII'IeCKIIX 06II\eCTB
_ I1p06.1eMbI CKII<pCKOII apxeo-
.110 rllil
- COBeTCKali apXeOJIOr1l1i
- CBOA apXPOJIOrIlqeCKIfX
IICTOqHIIlWB
- C006II\eHIlIi fOCYJJ;apCTBeHHoii:
AKaJJ;eMIlII IICTO pif II MaTe-
pIfa!IbHOH KYJIbTYPbI
- COOOII\eHIIII rOCYJJ;apCTBeHHO-
ro 3pmITama
Tr3 - TpY;1bI rory;\apc.TBeHllOro
3pmITama
THrI1IUIJII1 - TYBIIHCKIlIi HayqIIO-IICCm'Ao-
BaTeJIbCKIIII llHCTHTYT HabIKa,
iIIITepaTypbI, IICTOpll1l
TI13 - TpYl\bI I1HcTliTYTa 3THorpa-
<p IIII
Tp. TORM - TpYAbI TOMCI;oro 06JIaCTHOro
RpaeBeAqeCKOro MyaeH
Tp. 'IHHI1I1- TpYAbI 'ICqpHo-I1HrymcKoro
HaY'rHO - IfCCJIeAOBaTCJIbCKOro
IIHCTIITYTa
Tp. CAPAHHOH - TpYAbi CeK 1I1I apxeoiIO-
rIIJI
Y3I1H3RB - YqeHbIe aarrIICKIl HHCTIITYTa
Ha IIOHaJIblibIX II 3THIIqeCKHX
KYJIbTYP BOCTOl;a
CRI1<t>O-CIIEIIPCRIIH 3BEPI1HbJH CTI1JIb
T3JIrY
- Y'ICHbIe aaIIIICI<II JIeHIIHrpaA-
("IWro rOCYAapCTBeHHOro YHII-
RepCI!TCTa
Y3THHHHJII1 - ¥qeHbIe aanlICKIl TYBIIIICIW-
1'0 HayqHO-IICCneAOBaTeJII,CI;O-
1'0 HHCTIITYTa 113b1Ra, JIHTepa-
TypbI II IICTOplI1!
- Archaeologischer Anzeiger
- Archaeologia Hungaricae
- Eurasia septentrionalis anti-
qua
- Journal of ='leal' Eastern Stu-
dies
-- Priihistorische Zeitschrift
Jahrbuch del' Deutschen Ar-
chiiologischen I nstituts
AA
AH
ESA
JNES
PZ
JDAI
J.' r6epJfC(lPUO x ne'ttaru Opoe'Ho' 'l'pyfJOBO.!O Rpacuozo 3ua.\!.?kU 11 Hrn(ryro \t apxeo.1.0ZUU Axaue.\tuu
><ay" CCCP
(
'Pe.naHTop U3i<lTt'":ILC'TBa C. H. Po:"ta'Hoea. Xy.n;OiHHUH T. B JI!/-.--,; >"...l'-4.
B. H. TUKllHf'tJ. TpXHIPJPCtiUe pe;.J.i.Hi.TOP'!,I T. H. l1().1.q lu'l 11 .1
n. A... llu]JRJec n .71. B. lIUCb, :(o
x Y;:WffiecTBeHHblfi peJIaHTOp
II. r ce8a. I,OppetiTOphl
CnaBO B Haoop 5)1119;6 r. IIo;:InncaH0 H neqanf 15/VI 19';'" r rJh'I'\I(IT iOX90:: 16 . EYMara Tunorpa<l>-
CliaR .:\'9 1. YC:I neq. ,. O.33. .q.-n3;:t. :1. O."j" Tl1paa, ;{ ;,rl T-rl 1 ,t. Tun. aaH. 3,0. IJ:eHa 1 p. 30 H.
H3;:IaTe.""lbCTBO (tHaYlia.). 103717 rCII, :!\<loclina, H-6 . IIt).1tOt'/-IIr"I-I11I nep.. 1. 2-R Tlfnorpa<l>HR
H3;:1aTe:IbCTBa .,}-}aYli31) 12109!1. MocHBa, 1'-99, lliyoRnClwi: rwp 1 n