HAY4HbiE 1.o13..QAHIt1R.QJlR IOPL-1CTOB


JUl. TY30B
A.A. We
weeB
3aKoHoAaTenbHbie aKTbl,
pernaMeHH1pYIOL.l.\l1e
OnepaTI1 BHo-pa3blcKHYIO
AeflTenbHocTb
B POCCI1I11CKOIl1 ct>eAe pal..\ 1111 ,
cTpaHax CHr 11 6aml111



"b
W
IOH..T..
iJii'""i""'f'Y




11.11. TY30B, A./J,. WeMWeeB
3aKOHOl\aTenbHbie aKTbl,
pernaMeHT"PYIO..e
OnepaT"BHO-pa3bICKHYIO l\eSITenbHOCTb
B POCC..iiCKOii <l>el\l!pa....,
CTpaHaX CHr .. 6anT....
nO)J,pe,qallL1l1ei1
3aCnYJKeHHOrO IOpl1CTa POCCIIII1,
I\OKTopa IOpl1J\l>t'4eCKIIIX Hayll, npol1:>eccopa M_A_ KnHMOBB
"oYoAH"'eCKHMljeHTpoM
,,y...e(jHI1K"Bf{a...eCTBeY4e(jHoronoCO(jI1S1
JIIIRCTyAeHTOBBblcwl1xy...e(jHbIX O(jY'fBlOll,IHXCR
no03050' "lOpHcnpYAefH..jI1R",
nO"BY4HOti'200'2"K
C}'H8RonepHSR"
"OHa1BIJbCnfMI1HCm1YTOM
f1J'1HaYKI1BKa<;eCTBeY4eOHoronoco0I1S1
JlllSiCTyAeHTOBBbJCWl1xy...e(jHbIX.O(jY'falOll,IHXCR
no03050' "1OpMcnpy,Qefiljml",
nO"aY4Hoti'2.00.'2"K
C}'THaRHaRfJ,BHTEJnbHOC1b"

W
IOHIITI1
iJii""iT"'V
3aKOH 11 npaBO. MOCKBa.2012

YDKJUI32(47+S7)(07S.8)
55K:IO.212_J2(2)7J
Pc ,-!C H C HTbI
:J<ICny><eHHbll! LleTcnb HaYK P<t>. OKTOp 1Op>til"eC" Hay"" flpO<]>ccCOP T K_ C,,W1tH
LlO",TOpIOPI\!IH"CC",HH"YK.npoI>c<.roPA_MM
rJT'HLTl\p.lmKTOpH31lOTeJTo.cT""H./13pua""",,,,
II'HllH1IiITIOpIIllII'fOCKHXHayKOKTOP"'KOHO"'H"ecKHxHayK,npocl>eecop.
JT.ypeaTnpeMHH np'TenbCTB' P<t>,,06JTaCTH HayKH HTe'HHIIH
TY30B,JIeBJIbBoBH'I.
T81 3aKOHo.mrreJ1bHb!e 8KTbl. pernaMeHTltpYIOWl1e OnepaT1t8HO-
pa3blCKHYlO ne.llTeJ1bHOCTb 8 PoccldicKOM (])enepam'llt. cl"paHaX
CHr It f)aJlTItI1: yqe6. noc06lte lUI.II C1)IJreHT08 8Y30B. o6yqalO-
IllI'IXCSI no CnelU'laJIbHOCTIt dOpl1CnpyneHUI'I.ll» / II.II. TY30B.
All. Wei-iwee8; non pen. M.A. KiJItMOBa - M.: IOHI1TI1-
DAHA: 3aKOH It npa80. 2012. - 176 C
L llJeiilUeeB. A3aMaT J],JKYMa6eKOBH'I.
ISBN 978-5-238-02361-8
AreHTCTBO CIP prE
nPO""lleHcpaBHa-rreLHblJ;3Ha.'H3'LHblX3KTOB.per.'a..eHTH-
PYIOIllII 0T1epaTHBHo-pa3b1C"HYIOLlere,'bHOCTb I! POCCHIlCIlOh 4JeliepaulIlI, Pec-
ny6JTlIe, Kblprl>l:JCKoR Pecny6,'Hlle IlPYrHCT):IaHaX CHr H fur1T
flu cryllCHTOB (I\VPC1HT011 H CJTYW"TeJlC;;), "cnHpHHTO (>U!-"KJHKTO),
IIpenQllllI!llTe;leA IIblCW>!X KJp.aH"CCKII" 06p2:i1011HTCJlbHbiX H flaY'IHO_
I1CCJTI$OBaTO.1bCIIHX Y'ipe>K!leHI1" a TaK>Ke npaKT..eCKI-IX p.160THHII0 np.ll1O-
oxpaHHTCJ1LHbIXOpraHOB
55K67AIO.212_J2(2)7J
ISBN 978-5-238-02368-1
@ J.131lATEJlbCTBO IOHJ.1TJ.1-D,AHA. 2012
npHH'lLU"'HT HCl<.llO'IHTO.UHOO np"oo HlI HCnOJ1.30'HHO H paenpOCTpilHel-lHe HUllHH"
(d>JM94_d>JOTIIHIOJ1,,1005r)
@OIJ>opwTcHlte.IOHJ.1TJ.1-DAHAo, 2012

BBeAeHlt1e
COBpeMeHH3S1 OU:'1eCTBeHHaSi TeopHSI onepBTHBHO-pa3bICKHOH lleSl-
TeJlbH()CTIt (OfD,) CTaJla $opMItpOBaTbCSI C I-Ja'laJI3 1960-x fOllOB, n()CJle
npl1HJlTI1J1 yronOHHo-npoueCCYaJIbHblX KOlleKcOB COlO311b1X pecny6!UlK,
fire BnepBble H3 :>3KOH01l3TeJlbHOM ypOime nOSlBI1J1CSI Tep),tI1H «O!1epa-
TI'IBHO-pa3bICIIHbre Mepbl", ()cywecTBJleHlte KOTOpblX fibUlO B03J10)KeHO
H8 opraHblllOJH3HHSl I .
B 1992 r. 6b!n npltHJlT 3alloH P<D «06 OnepaTItBHO-p03bICKHOfi
lleSlTeJlbHOCTrI B POCCI1HCIIOH <DeJ\epaL(lUN. a 3aTeM. B 1995 r.. (])eJ\e-
panbHblfi 3"KOH ..06 onepaTMBHo-p03b1CKHOfi .neJlTeJlbHOCTIt». C npl1-
HIITHe),t (])cllepaJIbHOrO JBKOH3 lIBHHblH BI111lleSlTCl1bHOCTM npaBooxpa-
HI1TeJlbHblX opraHoB nOJly"lltJ1 O(jJI1l.l113J1bHbIH CTaTyc fOcYllBpCTBeHHO-
npBBoBoH (jJOpMbI 6opb6br C npccrynHocTblO D,3HO onpelieneHl1e OPD,
C pacKpbITlJeM ee COllep>KBHI1J1, onpelleJleH!1CM OCHOBHblX 3aaB'I It
npltHUl'lnoB. C4JopMynl1poBaHbl ()CHOBHble nOJlO)KeHltJl. YCTaH3BJlH-
BBIOll.(!1C npaBQMepHOCTb, YCJ10BItJl It nopJlJlOK npOBeHItJl onepan1B-
HO-p33bICKHbIX Mep()npHIITItH. ItCn()Jlb30BaHlte HX pe3y.lbTaTOB B pac-
IIpblTlt1t npecTyrmeHltfi 3allpermeHb1 npaBa 11 o6113aHHocTM 1111U. CBSI-
33HHbIX C Ofl{. 3 TalOKe perJl3MeHTI1pOB3Hbi BonpOCbl ItX COlll1aJ1bHOi1
It npaBOBOW3all.(I1Tbl.
Heo6xoJllJMO Y4el:Tb, '1TO npOBelleHHf: OTJle!1bHb!X OnepaTIJBHO-
pa3blCKHbiX MeponpltJlTl'lfi 3aTpafltB31OT KOHU1fl)'llItOHHble npaB3 rp3)K-
lIBl1. npm.leHel1lte TBKJ1X BIfllOR MeponpltJlTI1H JlBJ1J1eTCJI OCODOH cnCUlt-
(jJItKOH B npouecce nellTenbHOCTM OnepaTItBHblX nOJlpameneHltit C :nOH
UeJ1blO 3aJWH onpelleJ1l1eT npBBORbre OCHOB3liltJl npOBClIeHItJI TBKItX Me-
pOnpltJlTI1H ItCK!1104ItTeJlbHO B ueJlJlx 38ll.(!1Tbl >KIt3HI1. :WOpOBbSi. C06CT-
BeHHOCTIt. fiOpb6bl C npecrynHocTblO It TonbKO B UTHOllleHlt1t JlItU
(rpynnbl .l1I1U). ODOCHOB3HHO n01lO3peBaeMbiX B COBepllleHl111 TSI>KKIJX 11
()c060 TSI>KKI'IX npecrynJleHI1H.
npOBeJ\eHHblH HaMIt CpBBHltTe!1bHbIH aH3!UI:> It3JIO)l(eH B BI1J],e pBJ-
JlINHblX Ta6.rll1u, crrpaAW.1Oll.(I1X OCHOBHble nOJlO)l(eHI1J1 3BKOHOllfITeJlbCT-
lIB, pemBMeHHtpylOwcro onepaTMBHo-pB3brCKH}'1O llellTeJ1bHOCTb POC-
CI1It. CTpaH CHr It EaJlTI1It. UeJlb npOBeJICHHoro I1CCJlellOaaHlt1l - 01-
I rOpJlUHfJ61< 1<., OrlwiHCl<"u B.C. CUIIfL_ r.1<. TeopHO! onep"THIIHO-pOJblCKHo>i .ne,,-
J1HOCTIf M ItH@PA-M.2012 Bo Bce 6blllWHX pecny6I1113X CCCP. HbIHe CTP"-
H"x CHr 11 6a.UHI1, 6blnot npItH>!T'" COOTBeT\."THYlOwlte 3<0110111>1, perJ]"MeItTHpyIOII\He
onepaTHHO-P"Jb!CIIHYIO Jle"TeJ1LHooTb. 3TH J3KOHbI mpaAGlJI" H"III'IOHaJIHo.re 000-
6cHHOCTH K3)!(!loR pccny6JJHKH, flO CyYb H l1a3HacHHC oncpaTHBHO-p;13b1CIIHOR DCII-
TeJlLHOCTH He "3MeH>L'"C

p3.3rITb CXOJ\CTBa It pa3JIIt'JItJ! B nOJ10)l(eHltJ!X 3allOHOB pa3HblX CTpaH.
BblJ!BltTb n03ltTMBHbie It HeraTItBHbie CTOpOHbl, 1<0TOpble I-JaH60JIee m)J]-
HO OTpa)l(81-OT COBpeMeHHble Tpe60BaH}lJ! B 60pb6e C npeCl)'nHOCTblO.
H3MeHeime 06meCTBeHHbIX OTHOmeHl'Ifi, HeCOBepmeHCTBO yroJlOB-
Horo 11 yrO,ORHo-npoueccyanbHoro JallOHOll3TeJlbCTBa RO MI10ro'" npe-
mnCTBYIOT pellleH}110 nOCTaBJ]eHHblX 3<U\a'J. Heo6xoJ\ItMO pa3HOCTopOH-
He nepeOueHl'ITb nOJMUltIt. lleHCTB}'lOllll1e KOHCTII1)'UItIt 11 JaIlOH())1a
TeJIbHble aKTbl. perm'MeHTl1PYlOmHf OPll npflBOOXpflHl1TeJ1bHbIX OpTa-
HOB POCCl'Il'I, CTpal-J CHr It 6annm, JlBJ]JllOTCSI nprlBOBOH OCHOBOH lIJIJI
H31160nee Onnl"'aJIbHOrO npltMeHel-UISI OnepaTItRI10-paJbICKHbIX Mep
Tpe60BaHI1.11 I< Ka'l.eCTBY ne.IITeJlbHOCTH onepaTMBHblX n01ljJa3.1leneHltfi
3aBMCSlT OT ypoBH.II paJBI1TItJI TeOpMIt It npal<TI<H onepaTMBHO-
PUbJCKHOH neJITenbHOCTI1 11 HaJIlt'JI1}1 :J.pel\T}1BHOrO npalJoBOro nonS! C
enMHOH MeT01l0JIOrM'IeCIIOH, OpraHItJaUltOHHO-TaI<TH'leCl<ofi OCHOBOfi
I]JyHIIUOHl1pOBaH(JJI.
npeIlnpl1H.IITble Illar B prop:.16on:e OCHOBHblX nOJlo)KeHl1fi Teopltlt
OPll B 06CTaHOBI<e OTKpblTOCTI1 C nelJ!:"Ol!O\I Ha JBKOHOJ\BTenbHoe pery-
J1l'1pOBaHlte OO3BOJlI1J111 npl1BJ]e'Jb I< ol'.icy)t;.1!el-uuo 11 onpelleJleHl'IlO ee Mec-
Ta B CI1CTeMe HaY'lHoro 3HBHltJ! npl1 310M ue'Jec006pa3HO ItCnOJIbJOBaTb
npaKTI1'JeCI<" onblT 11 npeeMcTBeHHocTb npe)KHItX I1CCJleJ\OBaH(JIl. Ha)"1-
HblX pa3pa60ToK TeOpMI1 Opn C Y"eTOM HOBblX I13MeHeHl'Ifi B o6wecme
B npouecce rlp"-IKTIf'JecKOH neSlTeJ1bHOCTrI B03HltKaeT PAJI BOnpOCOB. CBSI-
3<1HHbIX C perY.'1l'1pOBaHl1eJ.t 3aKOH0ll3TeJ1bCTBa. perneHl'Ie KOTOpbIx HeB03-
MO)KHO 6e3 I1CnOJlb30RBHltJ! HB}f'1HblX 3HaHltH He06}(Q[!1tMOCTb JBIIOHOIDI-
TeJ1bHOrO peryJlltpOBaHI1SI Opn o6ecne'JI1BaeT YCJlOBI1SI wm C03.!:WH(JR
CllHHOH MOlleJll'l .DOKYMeHTB, KOTOpblH 6yneT pema"leHTf1pOflBTb npouecc
opraHl13aLll11t 11 T.ucntKrI npoee.aeHI1SI onepaTI1BHQ-pa3bJCKHblX MepO-
npltJlTltH Ha TBPpl1TOp1111 B3BI1M().DeHCTB}'lOlUMX CTpBH (POCCMIt, CTpBH
CHr It EanTHIt) B 6opb6e C npecrynHOCTblO, a TBlOI<e C pa3JII1'IHbIMIt op-
raHI130BaHHblMI{ ee .popMaMI{ - Koppymrnefi. TeppOpl'l3MOM. 3KCTpe-
MI{3MOM, He3BIIOHHblM o6opuro\I Hapl<OTI1KOB l'I.DP
C Y4eTOM COlJpeMeHHblx ImrerpaUItOHHbIX npoueccoB If rlly6oKl1x
l13MeHeHl'Ifi B )I{!13H1{ 06meCTBa B03pacTaeT JHB'JI1TeJIbHBSI nOTpe6H()CTb
B J\aJlhHeHllleM npe06pa30BBH(J}I 3TOi1 c4Jepbl J\eSlTeJIhHOCTI1.

Ta6::II1Lla I
CyumOCTb onepa'IIEIIO-pablCKHOii llellTeJlbHOCTH. 3a$HKCHpoIIBIIILUI B
3aKOHOilaTeJlbHblX aKTaX CTpaH CHr 11 l)aJlTIII1. nQCBSlU{eHHbIX pemaMeH-
TIlI1HH:nOHIJI)IIKI1MIYroJ]oeHOHIOCTI1HIt

T361Ilfl.ta2
YClIOBHJI I1pOIIt'.1IeJlHOnepaTHBHO-pa3bICKHLlX MeponpHATHii.
TeJlbHbIMHaIlTaMH,pefJ]aMeHTHpYIOl.QHMHOPA
B crpaHax CHI" u 6a:nHH
M lJ01C);JlCfflUfi :w1COllCliJa111l!fl/;>H1;NX i!oKYMeH- HOUtIfl{QfI(]HUe :JOKO-
nln m08, npeiJ}'CtlOmpu8alOlI4ue }'c;/oouI/ npo8e- HoiJame,lbHblX OKm08.
i!eHUH onepomUflHo-p03WCKHbiX peao",eHmufl}'KJU1U1C
W!OfNIourJmuii op..n OPjJ
---J- 2 3
I HanpallJleHHOCTb OPM Ha onpe.I/:elJflIUL/lt
K vf06beKToB
rpa)KJ],aHCTBo. HRUIiOHal1bH()CTb, n()J]_ 4len:epanbHblWJaIlOH
MeCTO >KIfH:lIbCTBB, IfMYlllcCTBeHHoe, «060nepBTIfBHO-
.nO}DKHOCTHoe If COUMaJIbHOe nOJIo;+::eHlfe. pOJblCKHOn AeA-
npIfHa1lJlC;>KH()CTb K otiWCCTBCHHblM 06'!>- TeJIbHOCTW'
eJ\I'IHeHIfJlM, OTHomeHlfe K peJllfflf1f If
nOJlI'ITI'I'JeCKI'IM ytie)!(lJeHMJlM ()meJIbHblX
nlfll He J!BJlJlIOTCSI nperrnTcTBtreM JlJ1J!
npOBe.neHI'IA B OTHOmeHl'l1t MX aPM Hi!
-repprnopl'llf PocClfi1cIlOH <Depalllflf.
eCJ!1t mj()e He npe.nYCMOTpeHO <De.nepaJIb-
HblM JBKOHOM (a63. 1 CT 8)
rpBJKll8HCTBO, Hi!UI'IOHaJlbHOCTb, nOJ!, 311110H Pecny6J1ItIlI'l
!\.teCTO >KI'JTeJ!bCTBa. COl!aJlbHOe, IfMVll.[C- l)eJIapycb
cTBeHHoe 11 ll()J]>KHOCTH()e rIDJ!O)KeHMe. ..06 onej)<lTI'JBHO-
npI'JHaaJIe>KHOCTb K 06111ecTBeHHbI'" ome- P03blCilHOH J\CA-
.nHeHI1S1M. ()THOWeHIte K peJlltnm It no- TeJ!bHOCTItt'
lUJTH'JeCKllle ytiC)!(lJeHlfJ! OT.IIe.bHbIX ..u
He ABJI.IIIOTC.II npeIlATCTBIte'-t JlJ1A npOBe.ne-
HItA B OTH()WeHItIt ItX aPM t-Ja TepptlTO-
pl111 Pecny6J1I'1KI1 l)eJ1aPYCb, eCJlIf If Hoe He
OroBO eHO 3aKOHOM a63.lcT9
rpa)KJ],aHCTIJO. l-JalltrOHaJIbHOCTb, MeCTO 3aKoH Pecny6J1IfKI1
>KltTeJIbCTBa. COl[ltaJlbHoe. .nOJI>KH()CTHoe KaJa'lOCTil.H
11 I'IMYIl.lCCTBeHHoe nOJlO;>KeHlfC, nplfHaa- «06 onepaTBHO-
ne)KHOCTb K o6wecTBeHHbl'-t ()6bellItHe- pOJbICKHOHJ\CA-
HIfAM. OTHoweHIfSi K pCJllfflf1f If nOJlIfTIf- TeilbHOCTIt"
'JeCKlfe ytiC)!(lJeHlffl rpa)!(lJaH He JIBJlJlIOTCA
npellATCTBIteM JlJ1A npOBClletUm B OTHO-
lUeHl'l1f HIfX OPM Hi! TepplfTOpl11f Pec-
nytiJlltll11 KaJaXCTI1H. eCJ11t ItHOe He ()fO-
BopeHO JBKOHOM (n. I CT. 12)

rp--GlU\dHCTBO, HaLlIJOHMbHOC1D. nem, MeCTO
)l(lJreJlbCTBa.llO,COLllJaJ[bHoelt
ItMYWecTBeHHoe n0J10JKeHlfe. nJll1HaLIJ1eJK-
HOCTb K 06weCTBeHHbIM OO1,ellltHeHItHM,
OTHoweHIfJI II pe.r1lfr1f It no!1
y6e)l(1!eHItlI He JlB.IIIOT(;1I npemlT\."TBIteM DJHI
npoBelleHIJSI B OTHOWCHItIJ HMX OPM Ha
TI:f{JIlT(ipllIf KblptDl3CKOii: PITnyfu1lJK,
ec.llt ltHoe He oroBO H() 3JKOHOM (CT. 9)
MeponplfJITH onepaTIIHOI1 JlCSlTe!1bHO-
CT npOBODJITCSI HeJ.aBMCIJMO OT rpaJKD.aH-
CTB3. nona, HaUOHaJlbHOCTH, MeCTa npo-
)l(MBaHI1S1, 1'JO.Jp3CTII. oopa30BaHI-UI. COUH-
i1I1bHoro, CllYAte6Horo If IfMywecTBeHHoro
111"''''-1\.11'''' VI;:Jlml1UH"JA tUIJI>JllU", I,.m-
H3JL!1eJKHOCTI1 II napTI1HM KJ11f II IfHblM
o5wecTBeHHbiM OpraHI1J.aUIJHM. YnOMJlHY-
Tb!e 4JaKTOpbl He romKHbI BI1ItJ1Tb till. one-
paTHBHYIO lleSlTeJlbHOCTb, eC.1J :no oco60
He OrollO HO J<1110HOM (OJ S CT 4
\!ieKBanrocTbonep3TuBHO-paJblCKHblX
IITU". n HH3ltXn eHttH
npOrellCHl1e OPM. KUropb/C orpaHI'I'I111k11OT
KOHCTII1)'lJJIOHHbIe npaBa Ipa)KllaH Ha TIU1H)'
nepenliCKII. TI:JletJxlHHblx neperullOp<JH, no'l-
l£iIibI.'(, TI:JJerpmjmblX It IfHbIX CooOWeHltH,
IMnOCeTHM3I1eKlpH'1eCKOnlt
nO'lTOBOH CDSlJ, a TIUOKe npaIIO H:J HenpH-
KOCHOBeHHOCTb }l(tL"Ilfwa, OOIl)'CK8eTCJl H3
OCHOBaHI'WI cY.QcliHOro peweHIfSi ill111 HaJll1-
"1-UI11H4JopMault(aoJ.2CT.!j).
1.0 npM3HaKaX nO.QronIBI1ltBaeMoro, co-
BqJUJ8C\tOro KJ111 coaepWeliHOro npoTHao-
npaBHoro lleHHItJI. no lI01opOMY npolllllQlJ,-
CTB0CJ1eJlCTBIt.ll06S13aTe.l1bHo(ao3. 3 CT. 8).
2. 0 J1ItWIX nOllrOTaBJ1ItBaIOWI1X, OOBep-
WaoOIl!HX ItJlIf I:OeepWIfBWItX npOTIfBO-
npaBH()e .Qe.lll-me, no IIOTOPOMY npoltJ-
BOl1CTBO npcllaaplfTCJlbHoro CJICllCTRIIIH
o6S13aTeJlbHO a6J. 4 CT. 8 .
llpo()(u;JKeHue maM. 2
3aKOH Kblprb!3CKOH
Pecny5J1ItIlIJ
q060nepanlBHO-
P03b!CKHOn
.DeSlTe!1bHOCTW>
3aKOH
J1arBMficKOn
Pecny5J1ltlllt
q060nepaTIJBHu-
P03b!CKHOii
(]>e.Qep3JIbHbII133.KOH
..06 onepaTHBHo-
P03b!CKHOn
neSlTe!1bH()CTIt»

llpo()(u;JKeHue maM. 2
1 2 3
],0 006b/T1111x 11111{ neik;11\WIX, COWllOlllllX
yrp03y rocY.llapCTueHHoi1. BOeHHOW, :!KOHO-
MI1'1ec"oii 111111 ECiIJGnI'lOC"oij 6e30nacHo-
CTItPOCcltticKotiepaLlltl1(a03.5CTE).
npOBC!!CHItC onepaTH1IHOro 311cnepltMCHTa
.IlonycllaeTCR TonbKO (I UHX (I!>IHBJ1eHItH.
npcllynpC;t(}1eHI1H. npCCC'JeHI{H I{ pOCllpbl-
THR T.IDKKOro npccryl1J1eHlUI, a TaJOKC B
tieJlRX BbIRBJ1eHIUI 11 YCTaHOBJIeHItR Jlltti,
ItX nO!!fOTaBJ1ItBaIOIlUIX, COBepUJaIOWHX,
ItJIIt COBepWItBWl1x{a03. 9 CT. 8).
npl1 npOBC.lICHl111 OPM nO OCHOB3H(,]I'IM.
npC!!YCMOTpeHHbIMIt n. 1-4 It 6 OJ. 1 CT. 7
HaCTORlI.It:ro CDt:1lepaJ1bHoro JaKOHa, 33-
npewTCSI OCyweCTBJlCHHC nci'iCTRI1H, YKa-
J3HHb1X II n 8-11... I CT 6 H3CTOSIlliCrO
CDt:1lepaJIbHoro3aKoHa(a63.IOCT.8).
OPM. 06ecne<JltBalOlliHe 6e30rIaCHOCTb
opr.1HOB. ()CYlUeCTBJlRlOlliHX OPlI. npOBO-
MTCH e COOTBCTCTeHI'I C HfiCTOHWI'IM (]Je-
IlepMhHbIM 3.1llOHOM It ItCKJlIO'II1TC1IbHO B
npC!!C1I3X n01lHo},t0'lltii YK3a3HHblX opra-
HOB, YCTaHOBJ1eHHblX COOTBeTCTBYIOWltMIt
3KTaMIt POCCltiiCKoii 4IeJlepaLWII1.
nOOCHO!l[lHI1RM.H!>IMn S'l 2
CT 7 IWCTOHWCro 4ICllCpar1bHOro JaKOHa,
p<l3pelUaeTCSI ocyweCTBJISlTb lleWCTIjI'lSl, YKa-
33HHhle B n. 8-11 OJ. 1 CT. 6, 6e3 CYD,eOHOro
peweHl'l.ll npH HaJll1'I.l'Il1 cornacJ.UI rjXOK1WH B
nHCbMeHHoi1l)JopMe (dfu. II CT. 8).
CeeJ:IeHHR 00 ItCnOJlb3yeMblx 1t1l11 HCnOl1b-
JOB3HHbiX npH npcIBt:1leHHIt Her.naCHhIX
OPM CI1J13X, c. HCT04HltllaX, Me-
TOJl3X, m3Hax 11 peaYJlbT3T3X OPll, 0 JlI{-
uax, BHclIpeHHblx B Opr3HI130B<lHHbIC npc-
Cl)'IlHbJe rpynnbJ, 0 WTaTHb!X HemaCHbIX
cOlpynHHKax opraHoB, OCYlUeCTBJlHlOlliX
OPLl, 11 0 JJllllaX, ()KaJbIBalOlUX 11M cOlldt-
CT1I!1f: till KOHH.l\eHUl1aJ]bHOi1 OCHOBe, fI
TdKJKC 06 opraHItJaUl11t It 0 T3KTIJKe npo-
BelleH('jSl OPM COCTdBJIHIOT rOCYllapCTBeH-
HYIO TaiiHY It n0.lU1e>K3T paccellpC4ltB<lHHJQ
TO.I1bKO Ha OCH()f!3HI1It nQCTaHOWICHI1R PYK<>-
CSlT Ha, OCYWeCTBJISilOwero OPLl

npH npHMeHeHlt1t OnepaTl'lBHO po3blCKHblX
MeP, pa60nmK Onepan1BHbIX 1lQlq)-naeJJe-
Hl'IW OOSlJaHbl Y'II1Tb!BaTb ItX COOOBel'C11!He
crenCHl'I OOll!t:CTBCHHOH OnaCHUCT npe-
C1)'nHbIX nOCHraTeJlbCTB Ityrpo:>e ItHTepecat
06Il1CCTI!iIIt rocy.aapcn>a(a6a. 7 cr. 9).
OnepantBH()-po3b!CIIHble MCpbl. CBH3aHHbIC
C BpeMeHHblM OrpaHIt'iCHlteM npaB 'ieJlOBe-
Ka, I1pOBOINfCJI B UC;ISlX npClIOTBpalUeHI1S1
')}IA{KII npeo=ryru:reHHi1. I1X npece'1eHI1S1 11
pacllpb!nISl, po3b!Clla J1I1U, YKJ10HSlIOWl'IXCSI
OT O1f:ibiBaHl'I.II HaK,,3aHIUI l1.I1It 6eJ BeCTH
np0rnIsw}]x, npcce4eHHc pa3I\ellb1HaTb-
Ho-no.apbJIJHoii: neWreJIbHOC'TH nponm YK-
paltHb! B CJ1}"1ae onepaTHBHoW HCQ(i'dIDIt-
M()CTH He0Tl10JKH()ro ocYllleCTBJ1eHI1H 311ft
MCp onep'I'llIBHO-po3b!CIIHblC no.apa31JeJlc-
I\}].II ()5.113aHbl B Te'leHIte 24 '1aCOB coo6-
ll.[I1Th npOKypopy 0 npHJl,ICHeHHH 11 OCHO-
BaHl'I.IIX DJHI ItX npoBeJIeHI1S1 (003. 14 CT. 9).
&l3}'IIJ1bHQe Ha5.r1IOJ!CHlfe MOJKeT BeCT11Cb B
UeJ]S1X H llilHHblX 0 nl1ue 11 ero
CII!I35IX, e01H }]MCIOTCA $1KrbI, nQ!\TBep-
,'rrol1tl1lUIOB1f1U1l1.1I1'1COBeprne-
HO"IJIJKKQe npecryl1J1eHHe.aTIUoKeJIJISI nOlly-
::onPHJHaKI1
npoBClIeHlfe OPM. 3aIpareaIOWx TilHHY
nepenltCKH. TeJ1e4JoHHblx l'I It}jblX neperooo-
poB, Te.-pa.pHblx }] HHbIX coo6weHlfH,
JqJelIaBae\tbI).t n() TCXHH'leCKHM Kal-mrIaM
CIDI3. I-lenpHIIQCHoacHHoCTb }KHJlHll.[3. 1l0-
Jl}'CI<aeJCfI nltlUb DJ1.11 c50pa 1tH4JopIawm 0
nHl!3X, nOllrcrmRl1HBaIOIl{X HJ1H 1lOK}1U-DQ-
IUHXCSI Ha l'JI)I(I{qe npecryrlJIeHIUI. cOBep-
lUalOllUl n.roo COBepWI1BIl{!1X TIlJKKC npe-
C1)'l1J1eHI1S1ltlThlbKOC C3HIIUHIt f1POJ'."}']JCft1.
no MOTIIIBpoaaHHOMY nOCT3HOIL"I111O py-
KOBQII.IITt'.mI (JaMeCTIf)'e1JCM) COOTI!eI\.-rnyIO-
ll.[ero opnuia, ocymecTBI1J1lOllICro OPLJ,.
B CJ1Y'Jae BOJHltllHOBeHl'IJI JlBHOW yrp03bl
>KH3HH. 3lI0pOIJblO, co5<:TBeHHocTH OT-
,IlCJJbHb!X nltU, a TIlKJKe no 3aHRI1CHI11O }]J1l'1
C COrnaCltJ1 rpaJKJJ,aH llonycl<de'JaI np08e-
,IleHlte YKaJaHHblX OPM Ha ()CHOBaHIt1'I
nOCraHOBJ1eHI1JI, yTaepJK.IlCHHoro pyKOBO-
,WlRnCM (a3MeC11f1"e'lc).t) COOTBCTCTBYIO-
lUero opraHa. ocyweCTBJl.!lIomero OPLJ" C
051!3aTeJlbHbiM YIlCiIOMJleHHeM npoKypOpll
BTe'leHl'Ie 24'1 003.2 cr. 9
llpo()(u;JKeHue maM. 2
3
3allOH YKpaHHbl
« 06 OnepaTItBHO-
P03bICIlHOHlICJI-
TeJlbHOCTIt»
3aKOH Pecny5J1ItKI'I
EiCJlapycb
«060nepaTHBHO-
p03blCKHOH AeSl-
TeJ[bHOCTH

2
OPM. J:JTparl1BalOWHe ()XpaHSleMYIO a
IWHOM TaHHY nepenl1CKl'I, TeJIe4JoHHblx
neperooopOB, TeJ1erpai))Hb!X c006lUeHI1H
1'1 nO'JTOflblX OTnpaflJ1eHHH, a TaKJI<e He-
JlpI1KOCHOBHHOCTb )KI1JIl1wa, ocyweCTlI-
JImOTCH I1CK.'IIO'II1Te.'IbHOW]l1
- BbllUlJ1eHHSI npellynpe)l(,!{eHHH 11 pac-
KpbITI1H TIUKKI1X 11 oc060 TA)KKI1X npecry-
J]JleHI1H. a TdJOKe npeCTynneHI1i1, nOJlro-
T3Bm'lImeMblX 11 COBepwaeMblX npecryn-
HblMH rpynnaMI1 (... 4 CT. 12),
- n()JIY'leHI1S1 paJBeIlbIBJreQbHOf! I1H!j:JOp-
MaUHI1 Ii UeJ1S1X ()6eCne'leHI1S1 6eJOnacHo-
CT PecnyfuJl1KI1 Ka3a'OC'T.JH. BbISlBJIel-U'I.!l.
npellynpe;t(}1eHI1J1 11 npece'JeHI1S1 jXDBellN-
mrreJ1bHO-nOllpbIBHbIX nOCSIraTeJ1bCTB cne-
UI'la.rJbHbIX CJ1Y HHocTpm-JHblX rocy-
,W!pCTB 11 I1HocrpaHHblx opraHlnm.!I1H ('I 5
CT. 12). OpraHI1J3UHSI 11 TaKTI1K3 npOBI:}:Ie-
HeH13CHbIX QPM MOryr COCT3H11S1Tb
CII)'JKe6HYIO, BoeHHYIO KJ111 rocYlIapCTBeH-
HylO TaftHY B coorueTCTffim C llepe'JHeM
cBe.neHI1f1. n01l!1eJKJJl1I1X 3aCelq)e'II1BaHI1IO,
ymep)I(,QaeMbIM K,,6I1HeTOM MI1HHCrpOB
PecnyfuJHKI1 KaJOlXcT:1.H Ha ()CHOBaHim
38KOfJa ..0 J.aWI'lTe rocynapCTBeHHblx ceK-
peroH PecnyfuJHKI1 KaJ.a1[C"I'aH
'I.9CT 12
IlpoBe.QeHl1e DPM, J.arparlJBiIOIJ.U'IX oxpa-
J-meMble 3aKOHOM TaMH}' nepemtcKI1, m:-
$OHHbIX 11 I1Hb!X nepewoopoB, TeJ1erpa$-
IiblX 11 I1HblX co06meHI1i1. nepe,llaBaeMblX
no CeT}lM 3JleKTpl1'l.eCKOi1 11 rtO<ITOHOii cell-
:m. 2 TIllOKe npaBO 1i3 HenpI1KOCHOBeH-
HOCTh >K1tf1l11U3. .D()nYCKaerC.II J1l11Ub DJISI
coopa I1H$OpMau11 () J1I1Uax, nQl1WTaBJII1-
Bil.1OIUH'I( If n()IIYlUaIOIUI1XCSI Ha 1X>KKHe
npeCl)'JUleHI1.11. COBepWalOlUl1X 111160 CO-
BepWI1BWI1X TIDKKl1e npecryll1X'HIfSI. TO!1b-
KO C CaHIIUI11'I npoJ<ypopa no M01I1BItpO-
BaHHOMY nOCTaHOBJ1CHlUO OllHoro 113 PYKO-
BQ[!IrreTJeHweroopraHa,ocy-
IUeCTIiI1H1Owero OPll.
10
llpo()(u;JKeHue maM. 2
3
3aKoH PecnyfuJl1KI'I
Ka3axcr2H
..06 OnepaTI1BHO-
P03bICKHOHneJl-
TenbHOCTI1
3aKOH Kblprb!3cKOtl
PecnyfuJl1l1l1
..060nepflTI1BHQ-
P03blcKHoi1neJI-
TeJlbHOCTI1"

2
npl1 3TOM ()OCJICL!()BaHl1e >III1JI!'I" n()Me-
WeHI1W AonycKBe-rCJI II HCKI1fO'U'lTeJlbHb!X
CJlY4BSlX 11 TOJIbKO C C3HKL(I111 COOTBCTCT-
I1)'I011.1cro npoKypopa ('1.1 CT. 9).
B CJ1Y'lWlX, K010pbIe He Tepn.II.T oTJIara-
TeJ1bCTBa 11 Moryr npHllecn:! K COBepwe-
HHIOTqJpOpI'lCT<jecroaKl1lru1l1!mflep-
c"m, HB OCHOBaHl111 MOTI1Bl1pOBaHHoro
nOCTiIHOBJ1eHMH OIlHoro 11.1 PYKOBO!U1TeJleii
COOTBeTCTBVlOwero opraHfI. OCYlUeCTB-
nJllomcro OPll 1l0nYCKaCTCJI npOBCllCHHe
OPM, nepe'lHCJ1eHHbIX B '{aCTH BTOpOH
HiK:TOmlleii CTaTbl1. C He3aMeJlJ1I1TeJ1hHbIM
YBenOMlleHl1eM C()()TreTCTD}"Omero npOKY-
popa 11 n()CJ1eLIyJOlliHM nOJ1}"1CHHeM CaHI<-
Ulm II Te'lCHHe 24 'IaCOB ('J 3 CT 9)
B CJ1}"Jae B03HHIlHOBCHI1J1 yrp03bI }l(113HI1.
:W:OpOBblO, c06cTBeHHocTH O'rJ\e;IbHblX lUlL(
no HX 3aSlBJlCHl'IlO lliIH C 11X nI1CbMCHH()rO
COrJ1BCI1S1 paJpernaercSi npOCJ1YIllI1BaHl'IC
neperoeopOB, BeJlYLl.lI1XCSI C 11" rC}1e410HOB
111111 Jlpyrl1x nepefOBopHblX YCTpoiiCTI1. H3
OCHOBaHI1H nOCTBHOB.'ICHI1J1. }lTBep;KJICH-
H()rO PYIIOBOlll1TCJlCM opraHa, 0CYlUCCTB-
muowcro orn, C 06S1JBn:JlbHbl'" yflCllOM-
JICHI1CM COOTl!eTCTII}'lOllIcro npo"yp0p3. (I
Teo.ICH('je 24'1.. ('I. 4 CT. 9).
npl1 npoBCllCHHI1 OPM no oCHOBaHI1J1M.
npeIlycMOTpCHHbl).tH [J 1-3 11 S 'i 2 CT 8
HacTOSiwero 3m<OHa, J.anpewaeTCJI ocywe-
CTRI1eHl1e J!eHCTBI1H, YK3.3aHHbIX B n. 8-14
'I.. I CT. 7 HaCTO.II.wero 3aKoHa (II.. 5 CT. 9).
OPM. o5eCne'II1BalOWHe cufJcrBeHHYIO
6e30nflCHOCTb OBll. opTaHOB 5eJonaCH()-
CT, ynOJ1HOMOII.eHHoro rOCYJ!apCTBeHHO-
m Opr[lHii 8 c$epe KOHTpOJ1H HiipKOTI1-
KOB, uprflH()B ymJ1()BHO-I1CnOJ1HlITe.%HOH
CI1CTeMbl, npoBOJlH'lCJI B nopHIIKe, npeIIY-
cMOTpeHHOM 3aKOH0Ll3TCJ1bHblMI1 aKTam
Kblprbl3cKOH PecnyfuJl1KrI.
no OCHOBaHIfSIM. npenYCMOTpeHHblM n. 4
'I.. 2 CT. 8 pa3peUJaeTCH ()cywecTBJlJlTb
ncticTBHJI. YKa3aHHbie B n 8-14 'I. I
cr. 7 H8CTOHruero 3allOH8, 6e3 CBHIIUI1H
:;:0;JI611 c?aHI1Ha e
11
flpOI}(M:MCeHUe ma(jA. 2
3

J 2
MeponpS1T1U[ onepaTMBH()!:I AeSlTeJIbHOCll1,
11M I'IX npoBelleHI1S1. ()fj'beM H I1HTeHCI'IB-
HOCTb nOmKHbJ COOTBeTC1OOB.lTb BI11I,Y no-
CHraTeJlbCTBa 11 creneHI1 OnacHOCT. one-
parl1BHble 3MaHI'IJI HeOO.:«llllIMO BbJnOJl-
HJlTb, no B03MOJKHOCT "teHbwe I1MeWl'Il1a-
JlcbBcilJepynpaB'lCnOBeKa('1. 3 cr. 4)
3anpewaeTcSI I1CnOJIb30BaHI1e onepaTl'IB
H()n neSlTe.llbHOCTH IIHe CJIY>KeI5Hblx I1HTe-
peCOB (CT. 4)
npOBellemte OPM. .IrrrparHBalOll.ll1X OX-
paHJleMble 3"KOHOM TJMHY nepenl1CIII1.
TeJ1e,pOHHblX 11 I1HbIX neperOBopOB. TeJle-
rpa.pHblX co06meHHM, a TaIOKC npaBO H3
lienpHKOCHOBeHHOCTb )l(1'IJ111ll!8, JlonYCKa-
eTCSI JIl'IlUb lIJUi c60pa I'IH4>opMaUHH 0
nlruax, []()lU01aBJ1HBaIOUUlX I'IJ1H nOKY-
rualOWl1xcSI I-Ja Tfl>KKHe npecrynJleHI1.11.
C()eepWalOWl1x I1Jm COBepWHBWI1X TSI)I(-
Kl1e npecTynneHI1.11 ('t. I CT. 8).
OPM, 06eCne411BaIOUle 6e30naCHOCTb
.neSlTeJ1hHOCH'I OBlt. HaU110HaJ1bHoti 6e3-
()nacH()CT 11 060POHbl, npoBO,l\JfIUI B no-
p!L!\IIC, npC!!YCMorpeHHOM H8CTOHIl!I1M
3aIlOHO"1 'l. 4CT 8
3 I1IHllcaUHH no.arQT08KH II pe3ynbT8T08 ocy-
IJ.IeC1BJJeHIJI OnepaTHBHO-pa3b1CKHIoI" Mepo-
npIlHTKitBonepaTHBIIO-cIXHHHbIX
- ':n:H:: ca:;:mBalOllmX
IOCIHC11nyuHOHHble npaBa rpa;t(1laH I-Ja runHy
nepenl1CKI'I. TeJ\$HHbIX neperoBOpOB,
1lO'/1OObIX, Te.llerpa$HblX 11 I1HblX coo6ille-
I-mi1, nepe.ll.;JBileMblX no CtlSlM 3lIeKrp<je-
CKOi1 11 npoBoj{Hoi1 CBSl3, a TaJOKe npaBa Ha
HenpKOCHOBeHHOCTb )!(1V111ll!3, J\onYCKaeT-
S1 Ha OCHOBaHI1I1 cylK'fuJoro peweHI1S1 np
HaI1'-J11If I1H4JoPMamm 0 np3HaKax, 3(1-
4JI'IKCl'lpoBaHHbIX B MOTBpoBaHHOM no-
CTaH()BJ\eHI1I'1 PYIWBOJ\IITeJISI ()praHa, ocywe-
CTlWlIOLl\ero OPD 11 06OCHOBbIBalOillerO
nepej{cy.nor.IOnpeJ1OC1i\BJ1C-
HI'II1 p<I3peWeHl1S1 Ha npoaeJleHl1e A3.HHb!X
OPM
12
flpOOolJKf!tlue moth. 2
3
3aKoH J]aTBldtcKOj:j
PecnyfuJl1KI'I
..06onepaTI1BH()j:j
JleHTe.llbHOCTI1.
3aKOHJ]I1TOBCKOj:j
PecnyfuJl1KI'I
..06 onepaTI1BHOH
JleHTeJ1bHOCTI1"
3aKoH
PecnyfuJl1l1l1
MOJU\oBa
..060nepaTI1BHO-
P03b1CKHOMJ\eJl-
TenbHOCTW>
<DellepanbHblj:j
JaKOH
..06onepanIBHo-
p03b!CKHOi1
JleHTeJ1bHOCTI1

npH ()CYlUeCTB.I1eHI1I1 OPll BOJMOJl(Hbi
OTne.l1bHble Orpal-JWIeHI1S1 npaB 1'1 CB06011
'IeJ10BeIlH. fOplflll'l'leCIII'IX J11'1L! OHI'I HO-
CSiT HCKJ1IO'l.HTe11bHbIH 11 BpeMeHHblti xa-
paKTep 11 MOryT npl1MeHSlTbC.!I 1II1Wb C
C3HKUHI1 npollypopa 11 B OTHOWCHI1I1
11111..(3, B J\eHCTBHSlX 1I0TOporo I1MefOTCH
npI13HflKI1 npecTynneHI1.!1. 11 B cn}''I.flSlx.
npellycmTpeHHb]X 3aKOHO)1aTeJ1bCTBOM
YKpHI1HbI B L!lISlX 3HIl.!I1Tbi npaB H CBO-
60)\ llpyrl1x 11m.!. 6eJOnaCHOCTI1 06weCT-
Ba. TaKl1e onepaTHBH()-P03blcKHble Mepbl
npoDolllITCSI C CaHKU1'I11 npoKypopa B
ueJ1HX npel(OTBpHweHI1H TSI>KKI1X npecTY-
nJleHl'lif. I1X npeCe'leH1'ISI 1'1 pacKpblTI1S1.
p03blcKa 1111(.(, Y)(}]OHSlfOWI1XCH ()T OTObl-
lIaHI1H HHl<a3aHI1H I1nl1 61:3 ReCTI1 npo-
naBWHX. npeCe4CHI1S1 paJBel(blBarJlbHO-
n()llpblBHOif l(e.!ITe.l1bHOCTI1 npOTI1B YK-
pal1HbI (a63 5, 14cT 9)
np()BelleH1'Ie OPM, JaTparl1BaIOWI1X
yaifHY nepen1'lCKI1, TelIel)J()HHblX H I1HblX
neperOBopOB. TeJ1erpHI)JHbiX co06we-
I-mH. nCpellaBfleMblX no 'JeXHI1'1eCKI1M
KaHaJl::!).! CBSl311, HenpI1KOCH()BeHHOCTb
>KH.'mwa, ll()nYCKaeTCSI 1II1Wb W1S1 coopa
I1HI)JOpMflUl111 0 1IHutlX. nOllrOTaB11I1-
BalOWI1X Hnl'l nOKywmoumxCH Ha TSI>K-
Kl1e npecTynneHHSI. C()BeplllalOWI1X 111'1-
60 COBepWI'IBWI1X TH>KKHe npecTynnc-
HHSI 11 TOJ1bIlO C CaHKUl111 npOKypopa no
MOTHBl1pOBaHH()MY n()CTaH()BJleHHIO py-
KOBOllI1TJlH (JaMccTI1TCJlSI) COOTBQCT-
eylOwero opraHH. OCYllleCTBJlHfOwero
OPil(fl6J. 2CT_ 9)
13
llpo()(u;JKeHue maM. 2
3allOH YKpal1Hbl
,,06onepaTHBHo-
pOJbICKHOifneSl-
TCJlbHOCTW>
3aKOH PecnyfuJl1KI1
Ee11apycb
,,06 onepaTI1BHo-
P03b!CKHOH
lIeSlTeJlbHOCTW>

llpo()(u;JKeHue mUM. 2
OPM. 3f1TpaflJBalOll!('Ie oxpaHl1eMble 33.KO-
1i0M Tai1HY nepenHCKII, Te4>oHHbIX nepe-
TOaoPOB, TeJ1erpa4JHblX co06JJJ,eHl1ti 11 no'1-
TOHblX QTnpaHJ1eHl1ti. II TaKJKe HenpI1KOC-
HOBeHHOCTb JKIV1I1ll1a, OCYL1!eCTBJ1J1IOTCSI
I1CK.fTIO'1I1TeJlbHO llJ111 BblSlBJ1eHmI. npeay-
npeJKlleHmI H pactqJNTtm THJKKX 11 oc06o
lSDKK"" npecryrmeHI1H, nOllroTaBJ1I1BaeMblX
11 COoepruaeMblX npecrynHblMI1 rpynnro.m.
TOJIbKO C CaHKUHI1 npmcypopa. CaHKW110
Ha npoBeLleHl1e TIlKHX ).teponp"srrnti n()
nOCTaHOBJIeHl11O OpraH()B, l1C}'lUCCTBJlHIO-
IlIHX OPD., llaer reHep,L"IbHblti npoKypop
Pe<:ny6JJI1K K'Ua'OCT:Il111 ero 3<1MeCTI1RI1H.
BoeHHblfI npoKypop pecny6JJHKH. npOKY-
POPbI o6JJIICTefi H npHpaBHeHHb!e II H('JM
npOllypopbl ('I 4 cr. 11)
It1CKJ1IO'1I1TeJ1bH0llJ111 nQJ1}"1eHI1J1 pa3Bellbl-
BaTeJlbHoti ('JH4>OPMBUI1I1 B l(eJlSlX 06ecne-
<JeHI1J1 6e3QnacHOCTH Pecny6JJI1KH K:nax-
CTaH. BbISlBJ1eHI1J1, npe!lynlJC>l'LlCHmll1 npe-
Ce'1eHI1S1 pa3BellblBaTeJlbHO-nollpblBHblX no-
CHraTeJlbCTB cneumUlbHblX CI1yJK6 HH()-
clpaHHblx rocynapcTB 11 HlJ()crpaHHblx op-
rBHI13aUHH OPM. nepe>IHc.'IeHHble B n. 4
HaCTOHll]eti CTaTbII. MUf)'T OCYJJJ,eCTHJ1S1TbCSI
B nopHllKe, COrJ1BCOBaHHOM C npollypopoM
Pecny6JJHKH K'U1'<\."T,UJ ('t. 5 CT 11).
npl1 n0J1Y'1eH('J11 CI!HIIUI1('J HI! npOBeLle-
liue OPM, nepe'tI1CJIeHHbiX e n. 4 HI!-
CTOJIIUeti CTarbH. npoKYpopy npeJlCTae-
J1l1erC1 MBTep('JBJ1bl OCHOBaHI1J1 llJ1J.1 I1X
npOBeLleHI1S1. B 410pMe 11 no COLlep>KII-
IiI1IO I1CK.fT104HlOllIl1e B03MOJKHOCTb pac-
IUI141POBK('J CBeJleHI1H 0 l1('J<JHocnl rpa-
JK.l]aH. COTPYllHli<JlllOWHX liJIH COTPYlI-
Iil1<JaBIUHX liB 1I()Ii41H1leHUHBJIbHOH ()C-
1i0Be c ()prHHBMH. ocyweCTDJISllOllIl1X
OP,ll ('I. 8 CT. 11
3aKOH Pecny6JJI1KH
Ka3aXCTaH
..06 onepBTHBHO-
P03bICIIHOH1l eSl -
TCJIbHOCTW'
14

2
npoBeJ1eHl'le uPIVI'. 3aTp:JIl'IBalOIlII'IX oxpa
HlieMble 3aKOH()M TIlHY nepenl'lcKI'I. TeJ1e-
4>oHHblX H HHblX neperoBOpoB, Te!1erpa$-
HbJX 1'1 I'IHblX co06u.eHl'Ill. nepenaBdeN:blx no
CeTIlM 3I1eKT]JI'I'leClloiJ I1IlO'fJOBOH CBJl311. a
TdlOKe npaeo H3 HenpKOCHOBeHHOCTb }l(11-
1I111ll3, JJOnyclG1erCSI IUIWb J]JISI c60pa HH-
tlJoPMaL\lUI 0 lUIL[aX. nonrQT3B11I'1BaIOIlII1X 11
1l0KYWaJOWlRCP tfa TS!)I{!<l1e npecryr1.IJeHI1I1.
COBqJlllafOlWIX J1W)o COBePWHBllUJX UDKKl'le
npeC1)W1eHMJI. TOJlbKO C CaHKUH11 npoKYpo-
IX! no MOTBl1poBaHH()MY nOCT:JHOBJ1eHHIO
O1lHOro 113 PyoBOAllre.lldt COOTBeICTB)'IO-
lUefO oprnHa, OCYlIleCTBlISllowero OPD"
npl1 3TOM ()6C!lenOBaHl1e )1(11.111>1" Il()Me-
llleHl1ll nonYCKaeTCII B HCKJllO'II'ITe.llbHb!X
-:o I1n:: :; 9COOTBeTCT-
nqJe411CJ1eHHblC 8 CT. 6 H3CTOSlll{Cro 3a-
KOHa MepOnpl'lliTHII OTlepaTI'IBHOH JleJl-
TeJ1bHOCTI'I MO;KHO 0CYlUeCTBJlJlTb, B ()O-
llieM 11 oc06oM Bl'IliaX ('I. I CT 7).
MepOnpl1S1THIi onepanlBHoti neHTe.llbHO-
CTI'I npOB01UITC.II B o6weM BMe, ec.rm
npl1eMbl. tlJoPMa 11 06beM I1X npOBeJleH1111
CYllIeCTBeHHO He 3aTpan1lJaKH KOHcrTY-
UI1QHHblX npaB .n1'lL( K npOBt:.QeHI1IO 3"mX
Meponpl1lHHll npl1BJIeKaeTCSI LlomKHOCT-
!ioe JUlUO C CaHIIUl111 CBoero HenocpellCT-
BeHHoro PYKOOOIDlTCQJI ('I 2 C 7)
MepOnpl1S1TI'III ()nepanlBHoti neSlTe.llbH()-
CTH, B XOlle KOTOpblX 3arparHBalOTC.II KOH-
CTHTYUOHHbJe npaBa Jll1l1. npOBOlUlTCSI B
OC060M BHlle('I.. JCT. 7).
OneparnBHbI KOHTjXlJlb 33. Koppe<:noH.lleH-
lU1eif, nO.ll)'JeHlJe onepaTIJBHoi1 HH4JoPMa-
lU1HCIiCnOJ1b30BaHlieMTeXHIf'1eCKlncpeilCTB,
om:p;nIlIJHoe TI1HHoe npoc.r1YWIiHilHlie He-
ny6i1I1'JHbIX paJrOoopon (BKJ1IO'IlliIlt:jJ<]JOH-
Hble, 'ICpe3 CKIpOHHbIC lJ lJHOro nrurn
CpellCTBaCBSl3) Ii ()neparnBHoe npOHlJKHO-
BeHMe OCYIUCCTBIlSIlOTCSI TOJ1bKO ocOOblM
06pa30M M C CaHKl111 cy.nelt.
15
flpoiJo1)KfflUemafin.2
3
38KOH Kblprb!3CKott
Pecny6.rJIiKM
..060nepaTHBHO-
P03b!CKHOif
1leSlTeJ1bHOCTIi
3aKOH
JlaTBI1i1cIIOii
Pecny6.rJlilllJ
..06 oneparliBHoif
1leSlTe.llbHOCTIi

PaJpeweHm: HB npOIl<:lleHm: 3TX Mepo-
npl1S1TlJii onepaTI1BHofi JleSlTeJ1bHOCTIJ
MOJKeT 6blTb BbIJ{8HO H8 CpOK JlO 3 MecSI-
Llf:B 11 B cJ1)"me 060CHOll8HHOiJ He06xo-
JUJMOCT MOJKer 6blTb npOJ1.l1eHO, HO
TOJ1bKO H8 TO BpeM}!. noK1'l no OTHOllle-
luno K JImt)' npollOllKThCSI Onep8TI1BHruI
......J......60TKa 'I. 4 CT. 7.
TawHblfl OCMOTp )lmJ1()ro nm.teilleHI1S1.
npMeHettlJe Mo.ae;II1 npoee.aeHI1H. I1MI1TI1-
pYlOlllefi npecryr1HYIO .aeSlTCJ1bHOCTb, a
TIlKJKe onepanfBHblx Cpe.aCTB npoHI1KalO-
wero xapaKrepa caHKlll1oHI1pYIOTC.!I reHe-
pa.nbHblM npoKypopoM JlmoBCKoH Pecny6-
11111111 (J]]11 3aMewalO!l.[(JM ero 1II1UOM. Cy6-.,..
eKTOM onepanmH()HnellTeJ1bHOCTIJ II M()T-
IIItpOBaHHOM nOCTaH()BJ1eHI1I1 OTHOCI1TeJ1b-
HO nOJ1Y'1eHI1S1 C8HKll11 YKa3bIBaMCSI:
I) l]1aMI1J1I1S1 CJ1Y>K8wero, nOi\HBWero 33-
JlBJ1eHI1C.
2) ()nIfC8Hl1e06'beKTal1J1l1l]1aMI1J1I1S111I1Ua,
3" KOTOpblM 6Yl!eT ycr,lH0BJ1eH8 CJ1eJl(K1'I;
3) l]1aKTbI 060CHOBbiBalO1lll1e Tpe60BaHI1e
o nplJMeHeHl111 MeTOl!()B 11 cpenCTB npo-
HI1K:1lOwerO x8paKTepa;
4) onl1caHl1e CpellCTB:1 CBSlJI1, II KOTOPOMY
6yneT n()l!K.IO'ICH:1 CneUl'larJbH:1S1 reXHI1I1:1;
5) nonTBepJl(ileHl1e HeBOJ»tOJKHOCTI1 no-
JlY'teHI1S1 TaKow I1Hl]1opMaU1J11 c n()MUlllblO
06bl'l.HOH TeXHI1KI1 p8CCJ1ellOB8HI1.!1;
6) npellYCM8Tpl1BaeM8J1 npOllOJ1>KI1TeJ1b-
HOCTb npl1MeHeHHH MeTOl!OIl 11 cpeilCTe
npOllQJ1>KI1TeJ1bHorOXapaIlTepa;
7) AOCTl'lraeMblJ:l peJYJ1bTaT
no cOBepllleHl111 TaflHoro OCMorpa JKI1J10-
ro n()MellleHHH opnep 11 cnpaBKa () pe-
3yJlbTaT8X OCMOTpa II Te4eHI1e 14 'I H8-
npaMHIOTcH n:1BllleM)' C8HKUIJIO nOJ1JKHO-
CTHOMY JIl1ny
Opllep 0 npl1MeHeHl111 oneparI1BHO-Tex-
Hl1'JeCKI'IX cpellcTB IIbl1l8CTCJI Ha CpOK He
60J1ee 90 CyrOK C npOJJJ1eHl1eM KaJK.1\b!e
15crroKl!eJ:lCTBI1S1 ()n"nen:l.
16
npodOJIJ1CeHUe ma5A. 2
3
38KoHJll1ToeCKOH
Pecny6J1111111 «06
OnepaTI1I1Hoi1J],eSl-
TeJ1bHOCTI1t>

1 2 3
B CJ1Y'lae OTK333 npOllJll1Tb ()pnep "'"
I1CTe'l.CHI1S1 cpOKa ITO .o:eficTBI1J1 opllep
BOJapamaerc}[ 1l0JUf(HOCTHOMY J1111lY. Bb!-
lUmWCMY caHKUHIO.
F'a3p:furnHHaSI C)Ubet..TOM OnepaTIlB!-Ol n-
TeI1bHOC111MQ.1ICJ1b,I1MlmlpY}O-
l1..lIDI npeC'TYI1HYJO neJrTeJlbHOCTb, C'lHKU\IOHH-
:;:m ro::7::e KQ-
npoBenemte OPM. 3aTparHBafOlliHX ()X- 3aKoH PcnyfuJI1KH
paHJleMble JaKOH()M Tau-JY nepenHCIII1. M()!111()Da ,,06 onc-
TeJ1e<)JoHHbIX 11 HHblX neperOBopOB. TeJ1e- panll!HO-p03blcKHoJ:i
rpalJ)HblX cOOOlUeHI1t1. a TalOKe npaBO Ha lIeSlTeJlbH()CTH>'
Henpl1KOCHOBeHHOCTb >KI1.1IHrua, Il()nYCKa-
eTC$! JJl'IlUb DJ1J1 c60pa HH41opMflUHI1 0
JJI1LlaX, no.o:roTaBJ1I1SalOl.l.aJX "'" nOKY-
rnBlOl.1!l1XCSI "" TSI}KKI1C npcCTynJleHIHI.
coeepWBlOll!I1X 111m CQeepWl1l1WI1X TSI)I(-
KI1C npeCTynJ1eHMH. a Tall)l(C C CaHKLl11
npollypopa no MOTBl1pOBaHHOMY nocra-
H()8J]eHHIO OliHoro 113 pyKOBOllI1T!:J1d:; co-
OTBCTCTB)'IO!llCrO opraHa. ocywecTBJlJllo-
lUero OPlJ, nepe'1eHb KaTefUPHi1 TaKI1X
PYKOBOlli1TeJ1eJ:i YCTaHaBJU'lBaeTCSI HupMa-
TBHbIMI1 HKTaMH ('I.. I CT B).
OPM, 06ecne<ll1lJ<uollme 6e3onaCHOCTb .neSl-
Te.!1bHOCTI'IOElt, I-JaUHOHaJ1bHOI1 6e3onac-
HOCT 11 060JXIHbl, npCIBO!ll1TC>I e nop!lJlKe,
npe,lJ.yCMG1peHHbIM HacroAIl{M 3aKoHoM
'lACY. 8
3,2, B CJ1Y'JaSlX, KOTopble He TepnJlT OTJ1a- 4IellepallbHb!W3aIlOH
raTeJlbCTDa If MOryr nptmeCTIf I( COBepwe- «060nepanIBHO-
HlflO TH)!(I(OrO npecrylUleHI1S1, a TaJOKe npl'l P03b!CKHO
Ha.l'I';/1111 D,aHHbIX 0 C06bITl'l.lIX I1neCTBI'I- neSlTeJlbHOCTW>
EX. C()3.QaIOIl!HX yrp03Y roCYllapcTBeHHO.
BoeHHO. 3KOHOMH'teCI(O lUm 3KO.:Jorlll-
'tecI(O 6e30nacHOCTIJ POCCHilcKo 41l:l1e-
paUHI1 Ha OCHOBamUJ MOTHBMpOBaHHOrO
nOCTIlH()BJleHI1HOllH()rO 113PYIlOBOlll'lTeJ1ei1
opraHa, ()CYlUeCTBJlSllOwero OPlJ" Aonyc-
KaeTCH npOBelleHl1e OPM. npenYCMorpeH-
HblX 't. 2 HacTOJ.ul!e CTdTbH C 06!'!.>rrreJlb-
HblM YBe1l0MJ1eHHeM cYlla (CYllbl'l) B Te4e-
}lHe24't.
npoikM;w:eHue ma6,1 2
17

Z
B Te..eHl1e 48 'I C MO\feH'l:,j I-Ja'jarra [JpOBe-
.neHI1$1 OPM opraH, ero ocymeCTB/1}1I0-
ll!l1ti, ofu13aH nOJ1)"1I1Tb CYJle6HO perne-
lUle 0 npoBeJ:\eHlwI TBKOro OPM 111160
JlpeKpBTI1Tb ero npoeHl1e (a63. 6 CT. 8).
B CJ1Y'Jae B03HHKHOBeHmr yrp03bl JKH3HI1.
:mopOBbJO, co6cTBeHHoCT OTlleJIbHblX J1I1U,
a TalOKe n() 11" 3aHBJleHI11O 1'11111 C IiX co-
rnaCI11 e nl1chMeHHoii 410pMe pa3pewaeT-
C.II npOCJ1YWI1BBHl1e neperoBopoB. Be.llY-
IlII1XCSI C I1X TeJIe.pOHOB, HB OCHOB"HI1I1
JlOCTBHOll!1eHItH, }'TlIq)JlU)J:HHOro pyKORo-
,Wrrt:lJeM oprafia, OCYllleCTBJ1J1lOwerO opn,
c (){iH38TCJlhHbIM YDClI:O\I.II.CHHCM COOTBCT-
cTB}'lOlUero cy.na (CYllbH) B Te'leHl1e 48..
(., 3. 4 CT. 8 (]>3. 06 opn (003 7 CT. 8).
npoBepO'II-ID.II 3BKynKB 111111 KOHTpOJ1I1-
pycMaJi nOCTBBKa npellMeTOB. BeIJ.teCTB 11
npOllYIIL!HI1, cB06o,[!HBSI peaJUJ3aUI1J1 KO-
TOPblX JanpeweHB 111160 06opor KOTOPb!X
OrpaHI1'JeH, a TIlIOKC onepaTI18HblH KC-
nepl1MelH tin" ()nepaTHBHOe BHellpeHl1e
I\OJDKH()CTHbIX J1I1U opraHoB. 0CYlUeCTB-
l1J1lOllil1X OPD" a paSHO 11I1U, ()Ka3bIBalO-
IUI1X 11M C01!ei1cTBl1e. npoB01UITCH HB OC-
HOIJ"HI1I1 nOCraHOBJIeHlUl, yTBep)I(AeHHO-
JOeBojr:. 80.a. OCYllIeCTB-
B CJ1)"w.e ()nepaTHBH()H He06xolll1MOCTli
/ieOPJOJKHoro OCYlllecTRI1eHI1S1 Mep, orpa-
Hl1'Jl1BalOllIl'IX KOHCTI1TYUI1()HHble npaBa 1'1
l!06011bl rpaJK1WH, oncpaTlfflHO-p03b1CK-
Hble nOl!p3:u\elIeHI1S1 06S13aHbl B Tt'leH1'Ie
24 'IRC()B C0061l111Tb npOKYpoPY 0 np1'lMe-
HeHIUJ 3THX Mep H OCHOBaHIHI .IlIlSi I'IX
npoBelleHI'ISi (a63. 14 CT. 9)
B CJ1Y4ae B03HI111HOBeHlUi HIIHoii yrp03b1
JKIf3HI1. 31l0pOBblO, COOcTl!eHHOCTI'I ()T-
.l!eJ1bHbIX 111'1U. a TaKJKe no 3ID1B..eHI'IIO 111111
C comaclfSl rp8JKll8H .nonycKaeTcSI npoBe-
.neHlfe OPM. orpaHWII1BaIO!lUIX KOHCTI'I-
1"yUI10HHble npaBa 11 cBo6Q[[bl fp"UKJIaH Ha
OCH()BaHI1I1 n()CTaHOBJIeH1'ISi. ymep;fjleH-
HOro pyKOOOllI1Te,m:}.t (3aM. pyKOOOllI1TeJ1Ij)
OpraHi'!. ocymecTBI1J.llOl1!erO OPn" C 06!13a-
TC1IbHblM YOC!l()MlICHI1CM npollypopa B Te-
'IeHl'Ie24'1 J63. 2 CT. 12}
18
flpoikJu/ceHue ma6,1. 2
3
3allOH YKpal'lHbl
,,06onepaTIfBHo-
P03b!CKHO
lleHTel1bHOCTI1
3aKOH Pecny6.rJI1KI'I
l)el1apycb
..06 onepaTIfBHO-
P03b!CKHOiJ
lleflTeJ]bHOCTI1

2
B CJ1}"1ar: B03HlfKHOReHI'ISI yrp03b1 )l(113HI1,
:mopOlJblO. co6CTBeHHocTIf OT.l\fJ1bHbIX
J1HU C nHCbMeHHOfO cornaclfSI pa3peW3-
eTCSI npOCJlYWI1BaHl1e neperOBopOB. Be-
llYWI1XCSI C 11}( Te$OfiOB }]}II.] llpymx
neperOBopHblX yeJpOikTB HB OCHOBaHI111
nOCTflHOElJleHl1fl. }fTeep)K)]eHHoro PYKOBO-
llTeJleM upraHB, ocyweCTBJ1S1lOlUerO OPn.,
c 06S13BTI:;JbHblM YHellOI)1eHl1eM npOIlYpo-
paBTe4eHHe 24 '1.('1.. 6 CT. 12).
B C.IIY'U'lHX, He TepMllil'lx OTJ1arareJlbCTe 1'1
MOryllUlX npi'lBeCTH II cOBeprueHHIO rep-
popl'lCTH'leClloro HKTa, llHBepnm If .DPY-
rl1x nDKKl1X npecrynJ1eHIfH Hi'! OCHOBBH(']l)
MOTlflmpOlJaHHoro nOCTBHOBi1eH('jSl 01lHO-
fO H3 PYKOBOllHTl'Qei1 upral-la, oCYlUeCTB-
J]Jl}owero Opn., llonycKaeTcli npOBelleHHe
OPM, nepe'l.HCJleHHbiX B n. 4 HBCTOSlWd'i
naTb. C YBelloUleHl1eM npOK})JOpl. 11
n()CJ1ellYIOWI1M nOIlY'lelmeN CaHKUl111 B
Te'1eHl1e 24... (.. 7CT 12
B CJ1Y'J3J1X, IIOTopble He TCpmlT 0T11arB-
TenbCTOD 11 MOryT npl1BeCT" K COElepllle-
HHIO TeppOpI1CTIf'leCKOrO aJ<Ta IfJII'I 111'1-
DCpCI1I1. I-Ja OCH()BaHm MOTHBl1pODaHHO-
TO nOCTaHORJ1eHIUl OllH()fO In PYII()BOlll1-
IeJ1ei1 COOTBeTCTII)'IOwero upral-Ja, ocywe-
CTBJ1S1lOwerO opn. ll()nYCKaeTCSI npoEle-
lleHl1e OPM. nepe<lI1CJJCHHbIX B 'I 2 Ha-
CTOllmd:; CTaTbIJ, C He3aMeJUlIJTeJ1bHbIM
YBeJ1()M.eHI1CM COOTlleTCTE}'lOlUcro npo-
K}'pOPa 11 n()CJ1CllYlOlUMM nOJl)"JeHMCM
t:aHKllMM B Te'iCHMC 24 'i ('i. 3 CT 9)
B CJ1Y4ae B03HMKHOBeHIJR yrp03bl >KM3H('].
3ll0poBbJO, COOcTBeHHOCTM OTnCJlbHblX n(']u
no HX 3aSlBJ1CHHlO MJlM C HX nMCbMcHHOro
t:ornaCMSI pa3pcwaercSi npocJlYWI1BaHite
neperOBOpOB, BcnYl1!ll'U:JI C IJX TeJ1eOHOB
1'IJ111 npyrl1x nepcroBopHblX }ICTpOIiCTB, Ha
OCH()BaHI1I1 n()CTaHOBJICHl'ISI. yYBCP)l(}]CH-
H()rO pYIlOBOIUlrenCM opnma, OCYWCCTB-
nHlOmero OPn" C 06S13.aTCJlbHblM YBcnOM-
nCHI1CM COOTBeTCTB}'IOlUero npOKYpoP" e
TellCHl'IC24 'l. 'i.4CT.9
19
npoi'Jo1;HCfflue ma6,1. 2
3
3alloH PccnyfuJlJlIlJ
Ka3d.'<CT3H
..06 ()nepaTBHo-
P03b!CKHOH
JlCSlTCJlbHOCTW>
3aKOH Kblprb!3CKofi
PecnyfuJMKM
..06 onepaTHBHO-
P03b!CKHOH
neSlTeJlbHOCTIJ

B CJlY'13J1X, Tpe6YlOWl1X H33MellJ1I1Tnb-
HbIX JreHCTBI1H, B UeJUIX npellOTBpaWe-
HI1.11 n()C.IIraTeJlbCTB Ha Ba)KHbJe DJ1J[ ro-
t:YlWpCTBa I1HTepeCbl. TeppOpa I'IJlI1 aKTOB
.IlI1BepCHI'I, y6HiicTB I1Jm I1HblX nl>l<KI1X
npecrynJleHI1H. 8 Tall)Ke B TOM I:JlY48e.
KOrIm cyweCTBYeT peaJIbH8Ji yrpo3a >l<I'IJ-
HI1, J1l0pOBblO I'IJlI1 t:06CTBCHHOCTIJ nl1ua
11J111 ero 6J11131111X pO!!CTBeHHI1KOB. YKa-
3aHHbJe B '1. 4 HacTO!llllei1 CTaTbl1 Mepo-
npl1.llTlJJi ()nepaTBH()" neSlTeJlbH()CHI
Moryr OCYllleCTBJ1J1Tb 6e3 C8HIIUl111 cy-
Ilbl1. 06 3TOM B Te'leHl1e 14 'I He06xo-
IlMMO coo6wl1Tb npoKypopy. B Te'l.elffie
72 'I - nOJI)"JI1Tb t:aHIIUI1IO CYIlbl1 B npo-
TBHOM CJI}"111f' npOBeneHl1e Meponpl1J1-
TIJJ:I OnepaTHBH()j:j neSlTeJlbHOCTIJ t:JlellyeT
npeKp.TfIJTb ('1.5 (;T. 7)
B CJ1Y4ID1X, KOTOpbJe He TepmlT OTJl8ra-
TeJlbCTB 11 MOI)'T npl1BeCTIJ K COBepWeHl11O
TI!)KlIoro npeCTyn;'JeHI1S1. Ha ()CHOBaHI1i1
MOTI1BI1pOB3HHQro nOCT3H0BJ1eHI1S1 O.IJ.Horo
1'13 pyilOBollTeJleH COOTBeTCTBylOmero op-
raHa. ()CYllieCTBJ1JilOwcrO Of'D. nonYCKa-
eTCSI npOBelleHl1e Of'M C YBellOMJIeHl1eM
npo'--ypopa BTe'leHl1e 24'1 ('I 2c 8).
npl1 B03HI1KHOBeHI111 yrp03b1 >l<1J3HI1.
J1l0pOBblO. co6cTBeHH()CTI1 ()T,[(eJIbHbIX
nl'lu no I1X 33l1f1J1eHI1IO I1JJI1 C I1X nl1Cb-
MeHHoro COrJliiCI1S1 pa3pellIaeTCH npoCJ1Y-
WI1B"Hl1e neperoBopoB, BellYWMXt:S1 C I1X
TCJ1C!»OHOB 11J111 npymx neperoBopHbIX
YCTPOHCTB. H8 OCHOBaHMI1 nOCTIlHOBl1e-
HI1J1. yrBep)K[LeHHoro pyKoBOllIlTeJJeM op-
raHa. ()cy1UeCTBJ1J1lOwerO OPD, t: npello3-
pMTC:JIbHbIM YBellOMJleHl1eM npoKypopa
('I. 3eT. 8)
20
llpooo,J;JKeHuema6il.2
33KOH
J18TBl1i1cK0i1
Pecny6JJI'IKIJ
..06 ()nepaTI1BH()W
lleSlTeJIbHOCTI1
3aKOH Pecny6JJI1KI1
MOJ\JlolJa ,,06 one-
p3TI1BH()-P03bICIIHOJ:l
lleSlTeJlbHOCTW>

llpooo,J;JKeHuema6il.2
I 2 3
3.3. B CaJ-JKUI'II'I cynbl1 HeT He06xonl1M() 3aKoHJImoBcKon
CTI'I npl1 npOBeJleHl111 oco6oro emta Me- Pecny6.rJI'IH'I «06
ponpltSlTI'IH onepaTI'IBHOH lleJlTeJ1bHOCTIII onepanlDHoi1 HeH-
npoTi'm 3a.1lep;j(aHHblx, 06BI1HSleMb[x, co- TeJ1bHOCTI1»
CTOHIJ.!I'IX nOll CYliOM 1'1 OCYJK.L\eHHbIX 11I1L[
B n()MelJ.!eHI1J1X cy6"beKTOB ()nepaTBHoti
neSlTeJ1bHOCT ItJlI'I neHI'ITeHUI'IOpHhlX Y'l-
peJK.L\eHI'IH, , TaK;j((: . CJlyqOJlX, 1I0r.ua
cy6"beKT ()nepaTI'IBHOn n,eSlTeJ1bHOCTI'I .
COQTBeTCTBlJ1t C nl'lCbMeHHhlM 3<lHBJ1eHlteM
KOHllpeTH()rO J1l'1ua npoCJ1ywl'lBaeT pa3ro-
Bopb[ lToro J1Hua ('l. 2 CT. 176.1 YrO.l10B-
Ho-npouecCY3l1bHoro IIOl!eKCa 11I'1TBbl)
3A. OpraHbl. OcyL1{ecmnmOIJ.!H:e OPLl JUIJI 41ellcpanbHbIA3aKoH
perneHI1S1 JallB'l. B03J1();j(eHHblX "' ""' ,,060nepan'IBHo-
41e.r:!epa;IbHblM 3aKOHOM. MOI)"f C03JIaBaTb P03b!CKHOH
1'1 I1CnOJIb30BaTb I'IH$opM8UI10I-IHble CI1C- HeSlTeJlbH()CTIt»
TeMhl (063. I CT. 10)
OnepaTHBHble nunpa:me1JeHI1H Jl}1J1 Bb[- 3aKoH YKpal1Hbl
nOJIHeHI1J1 3arW'l OPLl. npl'l HaJIl'I'll1l1 yc- «06 OnepaTH:BHO-
11081'111. npellYCMOTpeHHblX CT 63aKOHa P03bICIIHOl1l1eJl-
05 OPLl. BnpaBe C03.QaBaTb 11 npl'lMeHJlTb TeJlbHOCTI'I»
8BTOMBTI'I3I'1pOBaHHhlf' I'IH4JopMOUI'IOHHble
CI'ICTeMbI (n. 17cT 8)
Bxolle npOBelleHI'IJI OPM I1Cn()JIbJyIOTCSI 3aKoH Pecny6.rJI1KI'I
I'It«)JOpMaIU10HHble Cl'lcreMbI, K010pble l)eJlopycb
opraHbl, OcyilleCTBJ1J1lOlJ.!l'Ie OPLl. Bnpafle ,,06 OnepaTf'IBHO-
C031l8BaTb B I1HTepec.:J1C: ()6ecne'leHI'IJI pe- P03bICKH()nAeJl-
rneHI'IJl3Q11.'I'I OPLl('I. JCT. 14) TeJlbHOCTI'I»
np" flbmO;JHeHI'lIt '",,"" QPn opraHbI, 3alloH Pecny6.rJ1'I1I1'I
ynOOH()MO'leHHble ee ocyweCTBJ1J1Tb, I1Me- Ka3a1[C'J,1H
w, npaBO C03JIaBaTb " I'ICnO;Jb30BaTb ,,060nepaTI'IIIHO-
onepaTI'IBHb[e Y'JeTb[ 1'1 I'IH4JopMaUI10HHble P03b[CKHOHACJI-
CI'ICTeMbI, ()6ecne'lI1BalOlJ.!l'Ie perneHl'le TeJlbHOCTW'
3JJ1!1'lOPLl(n "1I»'l I CT. 8)
21

OpraHbI, OCyJJ.J,eCTBJUllOlJ.!l1e OPLl, WIl1
pelUeHI1.11 ]aJ!a'l. BQ3JlOJKeHHb!X Ha HI1X
HacroSlwl1M 3aKOHOM, Moryr COJlIaBaTb H
HCn0.l1b30BaTb HHIJIOpMaUI10HHbie CHCTe-
"'bI('I I cT,13)
Y'ipe)lQ1eHI1.11 OnepanJBHOH AeJlTeJ1bHOCTI'I
npaBQMO'iHb! ocyweCT!!JUITb c60p. CI1CTe-
Manoaul'llO. amlJlI1J. xpaHeHHe H }"leT
O.pI1UI'I3.'IbHOii, J1era.bHoti 11 CeKpCTHOH
HHIJIOpJaUHI1 0 JIHUfiX. IJI"KTaX. C06b1TI'ISIX
H Aenax (nacCI1BHaSi 1JI0pMa Y'1eTa), He06-
XOllHMOi'i 11 I1MeIOWii 3Ha'leH(je J1)1J1 Bbl-
n()J]HeHHJI JaJ!a'( OnepaTI'IBHOii AeJlTeJ1b-
HOCTI1 11 yrOJl()I1H()ro npouecca. CTaBI1Tb
Ha OnepaTI1BHblii Y'1eT (aKTI1BHaSi lJIopMa
Y'1eTa) rpaJK,JJ,aH J]aTBI1HCKOH Pecny6.rJI1I1H
paJpeWeHO TOJlbKO 11 TOM CJ1}f'ffie, ecmJ
no OTH()WCHI1IO II HI1M npOBOlll1TCSI ()ne-
paTIJBHaJi pa3pa601Ka ('I. I CT. 23).
Cy61.eKTbI onep;rnuJHoii .neJlTeJlbHOCTIJ
o6S13aHbl c06l1paTb, HaKanJlI1BaTb, aHaJll1-
Jl1pOBaTb 11 peaJIl1JOBblBan I1HIJIOP"Ja-
U11l0. cBSl3aHHYJO C rocynapCTBeHHOt!
6JOnaCHOCTbIO. co clJlepoH H I1H<f1pa-
CTpyKfypoii npecrynHOCTI1.
Cy6'beKTbl OnepaTI'IBHOii .neSlTeJ1bH()CTI'I
BnpaBe BeCTI1 OnepaTI'IBHblH Y'1eT npol1c-
lUeCTBl1ii. 4>aKToB, npeAMeTOB. npyri1x
I1CT0'1HI1110D I1H4Jop",aUI'IH, 4>I1JI1'1CCIII1X
I1lOpl11ll1'1eCKI'IXnm..!(a63. 6'1. 2 CT. 6)
OpraHbI ynoJlHOMOlJeHHble OCYllleCTB-
JlJlTb OPLl. Bnpaee COJlIaDaTb 11 I1CnOJlb-
30BaTb I1H4JopMaUI10HHble CI1CTeMbl.
()6ecne<II1BaJOlJ.!l'Ie peWeHl1e opn (a63. ..c»
'I.ICTIJ)
22
llpooo,J;JKeHuema6il.2
3mWH Kblprb!3CKOH
Pecny6.rJI1KI'I
..06 OnepaTI'IDHO-
POThICIlHOHLleJI-
TeJlbHOCTW>
3aKOH
J]aTBIlli'iclloH
Pecny6.rJI1KI1
..06 onepaTI1RHOH
lIeHTe.l1bHOCTI1»
38KOH lhnOBcKOH
Pecny6.rJ111111 «06
onepaTHBHoHlICH-
TMbHOCTI1»
3aKOH Pcny6.rJI1KH
M()JllI()Ba,,06one-
paTI1BHO-p03b1CKHOH
lIeSlTe.l1bHOCTI'I&

3_5. Opr3Hbl, OCYIl.lecTBJUllOlJ.UJe OPLl,
llIISi plUeH('JH 33J\3<j B03J10)KHHblX H8
HI1X (])t:!!epanbHbI},t 381<0HOM, MOryr 38ao-
HI'ITb HeJla ()nepaTI1BH()ro Y'leT3 (a63 I
CT. 10)
[leJl3 OnepaTI1BH()rO }".reT3 38BOllHTCH npH
HaJll1'Il1l1 OCH()BaHI1f1, npe.ll.}'CMOl'peHHbIX
n. 1-6 'I. I CT. 7 HacToSlluero (])ellepanb-
HOro 33110tffl, B ueJlJlx C061'1paHI1J1 11 CI1C-
TeM8T1U8UI1I1 CaelleHI1H. npoaeplll1 H
OlleH1I11 pe3YJ1bTaTOB OPLl, 8 T3K)Ke npl1-
HJ1TIIIJI H8 I1X OCHOBe COOTBeTCTBYIOIU('JX
pelUeHI1H opr3H8M('J, OCYllleCTRJUIIOIJ.!I1Mi1
OPLl(a63. 2 CT. 10).
(])aKT 3aBt:!!eHI1.1111eJl8 OnepaTeHoro Y'I.e-
Ta He JlM.IIeTCSI OCHOe8HI1eM .DJIJI Orp"HI1-
'IeHf.IJI KOHCTIITYUI1OHHbIX np8B 11 CB06011.
a Tal()Ke 33KOHHbIX I1HTepeOOB 'teJlOBeKa H
rpa)K1!3HI1Ha(a63. 3 CT. 10).
LleJlo OnepaTI'IBHOrO Y'IeTa npeKpamaeTCSI
B cJI)"JaSix pelJ.!eHI1J1 KOHKPCTHblX 3311a't
OPLl, n(XllYCMOl'peHHbIX CT. 2 tfflCTOSIlUe-
ro (])ellepanbHoro 3aKOHa, a TaICKe YCTa-
HOIL"1eHI1J1 06CTOIITeJ1bCTR, CBl'IlleTJlbCT-
BYIOll.ll1X 06 06beKTI1BHOH HeB03MO)KHO-
CTpelJ.!eHI1J13TJJX38J1a<j (a63. 4 CT. 10)
Opl"aHbl, ocyweCTMJllOlJ.!l1e OPLl, /lJIJI
pelUeHI1H 33J1a<j. B03J10)KeHHblX HaCJOJl-
IlII1M 3allOHOM, Moryr 33aOlll1Tb llna
onepaTl1l1Horo Y4em ('I I CT. 13).
LleJla onep8TI1BHOrO Y'leJ8 38BOllSlTCJI npH
H8JlI1<j1111 OCHORaHI1H, npeIlYCMOl'peHHbIX
n. 1-6'l leT 8 HaCTOSlllIero 38110H8, B
l!eJlJlX C06I1P3H('JJI 11 C('JCT!:MBTI133UI1I1
coe.neHi1I1. nponepKH 11 OueHKI1 pe3ynb-
TaTon OPLl. a Tal()Ke npl1HJlTI'IJI HB f.IJ(
()CH()Be COOTBeTCTBVlOIlII1X pellleHI1f1 op-
raHBMI1. ()C)'llIeCTBnJliOIlIHMH opn ('t 2
CT. 13)
23
llpooo,J;JKeHuema6il.2
(])!:I1epanbHblti
3aKOH
«06 onepaTBHo-
P03b!CKH0f1
I1eSlTeJlbH()CTI1&
3aKOH Kblpn:ncKoH
Pcny6Jll1lI('j
«06 onepaTBHo-
P03bICKHOHACJI-
T!:JlbHOCJI1&

npoiJotlJK:eHUe maM. 2
-'-- - 2 3
B K<UIUI,O\l I:J1Y4ae HiU1I1<1I1J1 OCHOBaHI1M 3allOH YKpal1Hbl
MJI npOBelleHIDI OPLl 3"BOllHTCH onepa- «06onepanIBHO-
THBHO-pOJbICIIH()e AeJ1() nOCTBHOBJ1CHl1e p03bICKHOtil!f:l1-
o JBBelleHl111 Talloro llCJ1a nOllJ1e)KI'IT yr- TeJlbH()CTW>
Bep)l(J{eH111O Ha<liU1bHI1KOM OB11, H8I.!I10-
HaJ1bHOti 6e30naCH()CTH, nOrpaHl1<1HblX
BOt!CK, oxpaHbI Bb!CWI1X A()J1)KH()CTHbiX
1II1u(a63. (cT.9).
Ha 6e3 Becnl nponBBwee lIl-1UO, no.1lO3-
peaBeMoe a nOllroToBKe I1J1I1 cOBeplUCH1111
npecTynJleHHJI. CKpbIBalOlUCeCSI ()T ()pra-
H()B pacCJ1Cll()BaHI1J1 11J111 YKJlOHSIIOLlleecSi
 orobIBBHI1J1 yrOJlOBHOro HlIlla3aHHH.
BelleTC.!I TOJ1bKO OllH() ()nCpaTI1BHO-
pOJblCIlHOe AeJ1(). ECJ111 D Te>leHI1C wecn'l
f,leCHueE\ He YCTaHOBJ1eHbl llaHHble, YIl8-
3blBalOIl.!l1e H8 npl13Halll1 npecrynJ1CHI1I1 B
llet!cTBI1HX J111Ll3. B ()THOWeHI1I1 KOToporo
oCYLllecTBJlHJJI1Cb OPM, TaKOe llCJI() nOll-
lIC)I(l1T YHl1<1TOJKeHmO (a63. ] CT. 9).
npl1 npOBeplle J1I1U B CBHJI1 C I1X llonyc-
KOM K rocy.napcTBeHHoH. BoeHHOH 11 cny-
)Ke6H()j:j TaHHaM onepanIBH()-pOJblCKH()e
lleJ1()He 3BBOlII1TCSI (a63. 4CT 9)
OnCpaTI'IBHaH npOBepKa npoBOllHTCH. , 3aKoH Pecny6nI1KM
paJpeWeHI1H 11 non KOHTpOJIe,,! PYIIOBO- EieJIapycb
1l1'lTeJ1J1 (JaM PYIlOBOllI1TCJlH) OprBI'IB. ec «06 onepaTBHo-
ocyweCTBJHllOwero. Pe3YJ1bTBTbI npmle- P03bICIlHOHACH-
llCHHblX OPM ()Tpa)K3IOTCH B onepaTMB- TenbHOCTI1
HOooCJIYJKe6Hb1X AOKYMeHTax 11 CIICTeMaTH-
311pYIOTCH(a63 (CT. (0)
OnepaTI1I1H0-cJ1}'}Ke6Hble .1IOKYMeHTbl llOJl-
)KHbI 6blTb npellCTaBllcHbi npoKypopy npH
()cYLllecTBlIeHI1I1 H8llJopa I1JII1 llJI.!I n()J1Y-
<jCHI1J1 CaHKUl111 "' npOBeneHl1e OPM
(a63. 2 CT. (0)
24

2
npouecc oneparHBH()fj neSlTCJlbH()CTI'I
3TO BCC MCpOnpl'lHTlUI. npooolU'''tble
,IlOn)KHOCTHbIMH 1U1uaMH cy6'beIlTOa one-
paTHBHoi1 .neJITeJ1bHOCUI B yCTaHOBJ1eH-
HOM nup$lllKc. nOllo6Hble neHcTB1U1 1'1
pC3YJlbTaTbi 4II1KCl'lpyIOTCH B CJ1Y)Ke6Hb!X
llOKYMcHTax, Ha Koropblc pacnpocrpaHR-
eTCSI PC)!(HM crpororo}f'1eT8('I. I CT. 18)_
npollecc onepaTI1Hoi1 neSi-reJ1bHOCT MO-
)KeT Ha"IiITbCH 1I() OOJ6yJKueHI'IS! yrOJl()BHOro
Hena. ()H MOJKeT npoxOllTb BO BpeMSI CJ1C!l-
:IJ !r:=HC:'J 1nllf:)aTb-
..OnepaTBHbIM poJbICKOM C'II1TaeTC.II co-
BOK)'nHOCTb lICi1CTBI'I. He lpc6yJOwI'IX
CaHIIUI'IH reHepaJ1bHOrO npoll)'pOpl I1JJtI
:mMCl1[alOwero era lUn!a. B UeJ]RX peaJ1I13a-
U11 nepBHIJ:HOH l1t$opMaUl'll1 0 npecryn-
nCH"'''' H npeCT)'nHOH AeSlTe;'JbHOCTH (n 9
'I. 2 nOCraHOBJiCHmr BCpxoBHoro CODeTa
J]I1TOBCIIOH PecnyfuJHKH ..0 I1Bt:J\CHIWI B
.neikTBI1C 3aKOHa JIHTOBCKOH: PecnyfuulKH
ooonepaTI'IBH()H:llCSlTCJ1bHOCTI'I»)
..OnepaTI'IBHoe pi'ICCIX'J1OB:1Hl'le.. J!BJ1S1CTCSI
opraHl13allOHHO TaKT<jeClloj:j 4JOPMOi1
.uCATeJ1bHOCTIJ. ()UI"lTI.IBalOllleii onepmlB-
Hbre neHCTBrul npoHI1KaJOlUero xapa"repa
(n. II 'I 2 nOCraHOBJ1CHHSI Bepx..1DH()rO
CODeTa JlI'lTOBCIWi1 PecnyfuJI'I1I1'I ..0 OOCllC-
HHC 11 J{CiiCTBIIIC 3mmHa JIHTOBCKOfl Pec-
m-6.M1KI1 06 oneo.rrHHHOH .neSlTeJlhHOCTI1»
npu HaJU'I'D'l11 OCHOBaHI1H, HHblX
7 3aKOHa 06 opn, OpraHhl, ocywecre-
lIS1I0111He opn, BnpaBe npollQ!lJfTh onepaTIfB-
HYJO npoBepKY. (fJaKT ee r{JOIIf:a"HIm nQ/U1e-
)IHIT06snaTeJlbHoHpeIlIC1]XIIlI1"(<J. I cr. 9).
OnepaTI1DHim npoBepKa npoBOllH1CSI C
CflHIIUHH H noli 1I0HTpOJ1eM pyKOROlWlTe-
1111 OCYllleCTBJ1l1lOl1!ero ee op.-aH8 Pe3Yl1b-
TaTbl OPM Orpa>KaIOTCI1 B onepaTBHo-
CJ1y)t(e6Hblx nOKYMeHTax 11 CHCTeMaTH311-
PYIOTCI1 (OJ 2cr 9)
OneparnBHQ-CJJy)I(elJHh!e nOK}'MeHTbl !lOi1)t(-
Hbl 6bJTb npencrdBJ'leHb! npoKypoPY np
HCJpe6oo.aHHI1 CaHKUHI1 Ha npOBelleHl1e
OPM OJ 3cr.9
25
flpoi'Jo1JKeHUemal5.n.2
3allOH J]aTBHikKOii
Pecny6.rJHKH
..060nepaTHBH()fj
lIeSlTei1hH()CTW'
3"KOHJhITOBCKOk
Pecny6J1HIII1 «06
onepaTHBHoHlIel1-
TenbHOCTH
.:SaKOH Pecny6.rJI1KM
M011l10Ba ..06 om-
paTHBHO-P03b1CKHOH
.!\eSlTei1hHOCTH

2
3,6, CnelleHI1S1 ()6 I1CIlUJIb3}'eMblX 111111 HC
nOJlbJOBJ.HHbJX npl1 npOBelleHl111 Hernac-
HblX OPM CI'I;'JaX, cpellCTB<lX. I1CTO'IHI1Kax.
MeTO!JaX, I1JJaHax 1'1 pe3YJ1bTaTaX OPLl, 0
muwx. BHe.a.peHHbIX D upraHI'IJOBaHHble
npeCl)'nHbre rpynnbl, 0 LUTIlTHblX HerJ1aC-
HblX COTpyllHI1K.:n ()praHOB, OCYilleCTB-
J1J1IOLUHX OPLl. 1'1 0 JII'lUax, OKa3blBalOUlI'IX
11M COlieticTBH!: fia IWH$H..IJ.eHUI18J1bHOi1
OCHOBe, a TIlIOKe 06 opram'lJaulU'I 1'1 () TaK-
TlIe npOHelleHHH OPM COCTaWUlIOT rocy-
1lapCTBeHHyKl rai1HY 11 nOl1.l1e)l(aT pacceK-
pe'lI'lBaHl'1l0 TOJlbKO H3 aCHOBe nocraHoB-
lIeH('jH pyKOBOIU!TI:1JJ! opraH:!, OCVll\eCTB-
J1HlOme.-oOPLl a63. I CT. 11
OpraHI1JaUl1f1 1'1 TaKTHKa npOBeneHI'IH
aPM cocraBJUnOT rOCYllapcTBeHHYJO TaA-
Hy(a63. 7 CT. 5)
OpraHHJaUI111 1'1 TIlIITKa npOlleHI1J1
Herl1aCHblX OPM MOryr COcr3BJIHTb CJ1y-
JKe6HYlO, eoeHtiylO n:II1 rocy.napcTBeHHYIO
TaM"}' B COOTBeTCTBI1I1 C nepe'1HeM cae-
lleHHii, nOlU1e>KalJ.!l1X JJCeKpe'lI1B3HI1IO,
YTBepJKJJ,aeMblX Ka6HHeTOM MI1HI1CTpOB
Pecny6.rJI1KI'I Ka3aXCT1'IH Ha OCHoee 3aKO-
Wd 0 38I1lI1Te .-ocy1lapCTBeHHblx ceKperOB
PeCnV6J1I1KI'I Ka3dCnIH (n. 9 CT. 12
CBelleHI'IJI 06 I1cnOJlb3yeMblx lliIl1 I'ICnO!1b
JOBaHHblX npH np()BelleHIfI'l Her.naCHbIX
OF'M CIDJax,. I'ICTO'IHI1KaX. Me-
T01U\X, ruJaHax 11 pe3YJlbTaTax OF'lI:, () 111'1-
uax. BHelIPeHHblx B opraHI130BaHHble npe-
Cl)'nHble rpynnbl. 0 lliTaTHb!X HernaCHblX
C01pYllHl1KaX opraHolI, ocyweCTBJ1J1IOWX
OF'Ll, 11 0 1I1'IuaX. OKa3bIDat01ll1f1( 11M COllCH-
CTRl'le tfa 1I0H<1>lleHUI'I.3.!1bHOii OCHORe, a
TI1KJKe 06 opraHI13aUI'II'l 1'1 0 TI1KTIJKe npo-
BelleHI1S1 OPM COCTaI!J1J11OT rocynapCTReI1-
HYIO TI1HHY 1'1 noll.ll paccellpe41'1BaHl'lIO
TOlIbKO H3 OCHoae nOCTdHORl1eHI1S1 pyKOBD-
.nTeJI.II. opraHa, OCYllleCTRI1.11.lOurefO OPLl, B
=TfT;:C 1:0 Kblp-
26
flpOOOAJK:f?HUe maoil. 2
3
aJ1bHbltl3aKoH
06 onej)<lTHBHo-
P03b!CKHOI:!
.neSlTeJlbH()CTI'I&
3aKOH Pecny6.rJI1KI1
EieJlapycb
..06 onej)<lTHBHo-
P03bICKH()HAeJl-
TeJlbH()CTI'I&
3aKOH Pecny6.rJI1KI1
Ka3axcT:m
06 onepaTBHO-
P03bICKI10HlleSl-
Te.n:bHOCTI'I
3aKOH Kblprb!3CKoti
Pecny6.rJI'IKI1
06 onepaTBHo-
P03bICKH()HAeSl-
TeJlbHOCTIf&

OKOH'lOHUf! maM. 2
J 2 3
OpraH'I3aUI111, MeTOllHKa 11 TaKTI1Ka Me- 33KOli
pOnpl1S1TI1H onepaTHBHoti AellTeJlbHOCTI'I J1aTBI1HCKOM
IIBJlllJOTCSI cnyAe6Hon TaHH()n ('I. 3 CT. 8) Pecny6.rJ111111
06 onepanlBHoH
neSlTCJ1bHOCTI1
3,7. nnalil1e I11OCIiOCTIII CeCllClil1H 0 41encpaJ1bHb!H3aIlOH
nl1uax, BHellpeHHblX B OpraHI130BaHHbie ..06()nepaTBHo-
npeCTynHb]e rpynnbl. 0 WTaTHblX Hernac- pOJbICKHOnAell-
Hb]X COTpyllHI1Kax oprat-1OB, OCYllIeCTB- TeI1bHOCTW>
nmOllll1X orn, 11 0 11I1U3X, OK33blRalOIlII1X
"" cOlldicTBHC "' KOHIPI1lICHUHaJ1bHOH
OCHOBe. nonycKaeTCJI 11I1Wb C I1X c()rna-
CJ.m e nl1CbMeHHOH IPopMe 11 B cnY'la.llX,
npCllYCMOTPCHHblX IPcllep3J1bHblMI1 33KO-
HaMH (a63 2CT (2)
Cyne6Hoe peWeHI1C "' npaBO npOBelle-
HHJI OPM 11 M3TCpHaJ1b!. nocn}I)KHBWl1e
OCHOBaH('jeM M' np('jHIITI'I.II TaKOro pe-
weHI1S1, xpaHIITCli TOJ1bKO B opraHaX,
ocyllIeCTBJllltolllHX opn (a63 3 CT. 12)
OneparnblellOK}'\lel-ITbi. mpa-
)Katol.l.ll1e pe3)'l1bTaTbl opn, MOTyT 6blTb
npCllCT3B11eHbI opraHY ll03HRHI111, CJ1CllO-
BaTeJlJO. cynbe. DPyrl1M opraHaM. oCYl.l.le-
CTB1111JOI.l.lHM opn, B nopll.llKe 11 C11y<laSiX.
YCTaH()BJleHHbIM HaCTO.lllllHM 41ellepaJIb-
HblM 3aKOH01>l (a63. 4 CT. 12)
nOnO)KeHltll, lIacalOwliecli YCJ10BHIt npoBe1lt'HI1.11 OnepaTHBHO-paJbICK-
IIblxMeponpHSlTllit, npellYclllaTJIIIBaIOTCJ1ellYIOWlieCTaTbIlJaKOHOB,
CTaThH 8, 10. 12 4IeJ.IepalbHoro 3<1KOH3 ..06 OneparI1BHo-poJbICKHOH
.neSlTeJ1bHOCTI1".
CTaTbl1 9, 10, 14 3aKoHa Pecny6.rJI1KI1 EieJ1apycb «06 onepaTHBlio-
P03bICIIH()H.ne.llTeJlbHOCTI1»
CTaTbl1 8. 12 3aKoHa Pecny5J1111111 Ka3axcraH .Q6 onepaTHBH()-
P03blCilHOH .ne.llTeJ1bHOCTI1».
CT3Tbl1 7, 8, 9, 10, 13 3allOHa Kblprbl3Clloit PecnyUJll1l111 ..06 one-
paTI'IDHO-p03bICKH()H AeSlTeJ1bH()CTW>.
CTaTbl1 2. 4. 7. 8. 18 3aKoHa J1aTBI1HCKOH Pecny5J1I1KH ..06onepa-
TI1BHOH IleSlTCJlbHOCTW>.
27

npouecc OnepaUIBHOH lIeSlTe11bHOCTI1 MMeeT cnellYlOll.lMe CTanI'lM:
I) onepBTBHoe paccne;WBaHMe (CT. 9, 20);
2) OnepaTI1f1H311 npOflqJlla (CT. 21),
3) onepaTBHali pa3pa6OTKa (CT 22)
CnITbSl 9. OnepaTl'lBH()e paCCJ1ellOBaHl'le «()nepaTMBHblf1 ()npoc, one-
paTI'IBHOe l103HaHl'le, onepaTI1BHOe Bbll!CHeHMe).
OnepaTl'IBHoe paCCJ1!:.1I0BaHMe npe.1lCTBBJ11!eT C060H OTKpblT)'1O 1'1111'1
3aMacllMpoBBHHYlO .ueSlbHOCTb .uOJl>KHOCTHbIX JlI1U cy6'beKTOB onepa-
TMBHOH neSlTeJlbH()CTI'I. B xone KOTOpOH npl'l nOMOlUl'I ()nepaTMBH()ro
()npOca, OnepaTI'IBHOrO n03HaHRII 1'1 onepaTHBHoro Bbll!CHeHI'II! c06Hpa-
eTCII I'IHlJlopMauJ.m 0 4>a"rnx. Jll'luax 11... oneparl1BHOH neHTeJlbHOCTI1. II
xo.ae IIOTOPOH npl'l nOMOlUl'I onepBTl'lflHoro onpOCB. onepBTl'lflHoro 1I03-
HaHI'II! M onepaTMBHOfO Bbll!CHCHI'II! cotil'lpi}CTCII I'IH<f1opMauJ.m 0 $u--rn1{,
Jll'luax I'IlleJIaX.
OnepaTBHbIf1 ()npOC npOl'l3BOl1HTbC11 nyreM onpoca JlI'IU 06 I'IHTC-
pecylOll.lMX cy6beKT"x onepaTHBHoH lleUeJlbHOCTM 4>aKT"X.
OnepaTMBHoe .1I03HaHMe ocyllIeCTBJ1J1eTCSI n)'TeM c60pa MH4JopMaUMM
() KOHKpeTHblX JlI'IU3X. OnepaTHBHoe BblJ1CHeHl1e ocyweCTBJ1J1eTCII nyreM
n()J]}f'leHI'II! I1HlJlopMaUMI'I ()T JlI1U, eCJlI'I eCTb OCH()BaHI1S1 nOJlaraTb. 'lTO
AaHHali I1H4JOPMaUHI'I I1MeeTCII e pacnopSl)l(eHl111 coomercmytolUMX JlI'IU.
HO OHM He )I(C11iiIOT npe.1locraBMTb ee HenocpetlCTBeHHO.
CT3TbSl 20. OnepaTHBHoe pacCJ1el10BaHMe.
OnepaTBHOe pacCJ1el10BaHl'le I!BJllleTCSI .uel!TeJlbHOCTblO .1I0Jl>KHOCT-
HblX 'JI'IU Cy6'beKTOB ()nepaTI1BH()f1 .ueSiTenbHOCTI1 B ueJlSlx nOJlY4eHI1S1
()60CHOB"HJ.m D)UI HBl.jaJIB onepaTliBHoi1 npoBepKH I1nl1 OnepaTI'IBHof1
pnpa60TKM
B npouecce onepanll1Horo pacC,l1f:.!10BBHMJI MOryr npOBO.1lMTbCSI Me-
pOnpl'lJlTHJI oncpaTMBHOH neSlTeJlbHOCTI'I. ynoMJlH)'Tble B CT 9, II, 131'1
'l I CT 16 HaCTOSilUero 3allOHa B xOlle onepanJBHOrO pacCJlell()BaHI1JI
llru])KHbl C06J1IO.uaTbC" 'lpe60BaHI'ISI, ynoM.IIHyrble II It. 2 CT. 7 HBCTO"llIe-
fO 3aKOHR.
CTaTbSl 21. Onepan1BHaSi npOHepKa
Cy6'beIlT onepaTHBHoH neSlTeJlbHOCTH B CIJOnIeTC11jI'lI'l C() CBOI1MI1
3alJa'IBMI'I 11 cBoeH KOMneTeHWJeH npl1 npOBelleHl111 yn()MI!Hyrblx B CT 6
trecTOSilUero 3aKOHa MepOnpl'lSlTMH MO)l(eT npOlJ01ll1Tb onepaTMI1HYIO
npOBepllycQOTI!I:TCI1jYlOlUMX<]:>"KTOB.
OnepaTMflHaSl npOflepJ<a Ha'lMH3eTCSI C caHIlUMOHMpOBBHHoro PYIIO-
BOlII'ffeqeM Y<Jpe)!()\eHMJI onep3TMBHoti .1IeSlTeJ1bHOCTM nOCT3H0BJ1eHMJI M
()CYllleCTBJ11!eTC.II n()ll ero J<OHTpOJleM. n() J<a)!()\()H onepaTMBH()H npo-
BepKe .1I0Jl>KHO 6b11b BOOtiVA<LleH() .ueJlo 06 onepaTMBH()H npOBeplle CpOIl
J!eJlonpOM3BO.1lCTBB no 3TM J!eJU1M COCTBBJ1J1eT 2 MecSlU3. OH MO)l(eT
28

6bITb npO!lJ1CH C CaHKLlIH1 PYKOBOlll1TCJUI Y'1peJK.ltCHI1I1 OnepaTI1BHOH
AC.!!TeJ1bHOCTI'I
nOplilIOK ()nepan1BH()H npOBepKI'I YCTaHaBJII1BaeT PYKOBOlll'lTeJlb )"J-
pe)!(1!eHI1I1 OnepaTBHotlneSlTCJlbHOCTI1
OCHOBaHl1eM JIJ1H HB<laJ1a OnepBTI1BHOii npOBCpKI1 MO)KeT 6bJTb 11
peWCHI1C KOMnCTeHTHOrO .nOI1>KH()CTH()ro nlmB 0 Ha<laJIC paCC.I1ellOBa-
HI1H B YCTaH()BJlCHH()M YrOJl()BHO-npOueCcyaJ1bHbIM IIOllCIIC()M J]aTBI'II'I
nOpSlllKC.
CTaTb.!! 22. OnCpaTI'IBHa.!! pa3pa60TKa.
ECJ11'1 B paCn()pSl>KeHl'le cy5bellTa ()nCpaTI1BHOH nel1TeJlbHOCTI'I
I'IMeCTCSI I1H4JOPMaUI'lI'l () KOHllpeTHblX JlI1U2X (8 TOM <lI1CJ1C nOJlY'1CH-
HBSI 11 B PC3YJlbT3Te onCp3TI1BHOfi npOBCpKI1), 1I81OW3H 1IOCHITO'lHOe
()CHOBaHI1C 11.1111 n()1I()3peHI1I1 3H!X JlI1U B n()llrOTOBKe 11.111'1 COBepWC-
HI1I'1 npccTynJlcHl111 I'IJlI'I nOCHfaTCJlbCT8a Ha Ba)KHbIC DJ1H rOCYlIapCTDa
I1HTepeCbl, JlI160 OHI1 pa3bICKI1BaIQTCH 3a COBepWeHHoe npecTynne-
Hl1e, no OTHOWCHI1IO K :'ITI1M JlI1l!8M 1I0JDKHB 6blTb H3<1BT8 onepaTI1B-
HaH pa3pa6OTKa
OnepaTI1Rtill.S1 pa3palJun.;a HB<lI1H8CTCH C npl1HHTI1H peWCHl1l1, caHK-
Lll10H}lpyeMoro pyKOB01II'lTCI1eM Y4PC)l(,l],eH}lSI onepaTI1BHOii lICI1TeJ1bHO-
CTI'I 06 :'ITOM CTaBI1TCH B 113BeCTHOCTb npoKYpoP npl1 ()nepaTI1BHOfi
pa3pa6OTKe 1I0.l1>KH() 6blTb Bo3GY)KJ}eHO AeJl() 06 OnepaTI1BHOH pa3pa6oT-
lie, B JlI1UH, no OTHoweH1'l1O K KOTOpblM npOBOlll1TCH onepaTI'IBH3H paJ-
pa6OTKa, n()1IJ1e>KaT nOCTaHOBKe H8 onepaTI'IBHblH Y'1eT. B npouecce
()nepaTI'IBH()H pa:ip3GaJK" M()ryr 6bITb I1Cn0.l1b30BaHbi JllQ5b!e I'IJ YKa-
JaHHblX 8 CT 6 HacToHwero 3aKoHB MepOnpl'll1TI1H OnepaTI1BHOii neSl-
TCJ1bHOCTI1 11 J11Q60ii 113 ynOMI1H)'TbIX B CT. 7 BI1JI npOBtneHl111 3TI1X MC-
pOnpl1S1TI1H.
CpOIl onepaTMDHoM pa3pa50TIII1 n() 3TI1M ACJlaM C()CTaD.IISieT WCCTb
MeCHl.iCB, OH MOJKer 6bITb npO!lJ1eH ewe H8 weCTb MeCSILleB C CaHKLll111
pyKOB01lI1TeJ1f1 )"Jpe)l(,l],eHI1H OnCpaTrIBHoi1 lICSneJlbHOCTI1 nOBTopHoe
npO!lJ1CHI1C cpoKa BOJM()JKH() TO.llbKO C CaHKUl111 reHCpaJ1bHOrO npoKY-
popa I'IJlI'I CnCUI'laJ1bHO yn()JlHOMO"leHH()rO 11M npollypopa, HO He 60J1ce
<lCM till. cpOK 1IaBHOCTI1 Toro npecT)'nJleHI1H, B CBSl3rI C KOTOpbIM npOBo-
AMTC.!! OnepaTI1BHaH pa3pa60TKa.
CTaTbl1 8, 9 3all()Ha YKpal'lHbl «06 ()nepaTI'IBHO-p03b1CKHOH .nCSI-
TCJlbHOCTI1"
HCrnBCH()C npOHI1KHUIJCHI1C B >K11J1ble nOMCWeHI1H, BI1.JyaJIbHUe H8-
6nlQlICHI1C 0 HI1X, CHSlTC I1H4JOPMBUI'II'l C KaHaJ1()B CBSlJI'I, npl'lMeHCHI'IC
.DPYrx TCXHI1<1CCIII1X cpcncTB nOJl)"JcHI'ISI I'IH4JOPMBUI'II1 11 KOHTpOJlb
nO'lTOBO-TCJlCrpaijJHblx OTnpaBJICHI1i1 np0l13BOllSiTCH Kall I1CKlIIQ'1I1TeJlb-
Hhle Mepbl C C8HKlli'II'I rCHCp8J1hHoro npOl<ypopa YKpal1HbJ e CJ:y"l8C,
eCJ11'1 I1HblM cn()C060M HCBOJMO)KHO nOJl)"JI'ITb 4>"KTI1'lCCKI'IC naHHblC
29

.lIJ1J1 o6eCne..eHI1f1 3allll1TbI 06111eCTHa 11 rocy.napCTHa OT npecrynHhlx no-
CSiTaTeJlhCTB.
J.1CKJlIO'II1TeJlbHO B Ut:!IJlX nOJl)"leHI1S1 p33IJellhlBaTe;]bHO I'IH4>opMa-
UI1I1 .lIJ1f1 06eCne<leHI'IJI BHeWHei1 6e3QnacHQCTH Yllpal1HhI, npellynpe)l(-
JreHI1f1 11 npeCe..eHI1J1 pa3BeJ:\bIBaTeJ1hHO-nOJIPbIBHb!X nOCSlr1\TeJlhCTB
cneUCJ1Y)l(6 I1HocrpaHHhlX rOCYAapCTB 11 OpraHl'I3aUI{j:j YKa3aHHbJe Mepbl
MOTyr ocyweCTlJ.'JJlTbCJI B nOpJl1iKe, COrJ13COB3HHOM C reHepaJ1bHhlM
npOKypopmt YKp31'1Hbi ('I. n. III CT. 6)
CTaTbl1 4. 6, g 3aKOHa JlHTOBCKOIi PecnyfuJl1KI'I ..06 onepaTI1BHoi1
AeJlTeJ1bHOCTW'
CTaThl1 8, 9, 13 3aKoHa PecnyfuJl'IlIl1 MOJUlOB3 ..06 onepaTHBHo-
p03bICIIH0i1JreRTt':J1bHQCTI'I».

T361I11l.la3
flpaBOBIUI OCHOBa OnepaTHBHO-pnblcKHoil:.nesrrt'1JbIIOCT1l,
BClpIIHa'l:CHrHEiIlJlTIiH
Huutu'H08CIHue
M flpOOOOOR OCHOOU OP/l 1aKOHOikm'e.JbJlbIX
.", OKmOO, pei!..lO'JeH-
mu 'HJU(U.x OP/l
+'KOHCTH"IJI1"OIfIfWC  3
--=--- flpIIHOBYIO OCHOBY onepIlTIIIBHO-P03bICII- 4>cllepwlbHblH3aKOH
HOH nCSlTC!1bHOCTH COCTIIBJ1HIOT KOHCTH- ,,060nCpIlTHBHO-
"J'YUHJI POCCHHCKOH cJ)Cl!epaUHI1 po3brcKHoti
(a63 I CT 4) AeSlTeJ1bHOCTH..
flpllDOBYIO OCHOBY OnepIlTl'IDHO-p03bICK- 311KOH YKPIIHHbl
HOH .uCIITCJ1bHOCHJ COCTaD!1J1IOT KOHCTH- ,,060nepaTHBHO-
"J'YUI'IH YKpal1Hbl (CT 3) P03blcKHoH.uell-
Te!1bH()CTI'I&
flpllDOBYIO OCHORY OnepaTl'IDHO-p03bICK - 3111<0H Pecny6JJl'IlIl'I
HOHlleSlTe!1bH()CTH COCTaBJ1HIOT . KOHCTI'I- Ee!1apycb
T)'UI1S1 (OCH()BHOil: JaKoH) Pecny6JJl'IKI1 ..06 OnepllTBHO-
Eenapycb(a63. I CT. 6) P03blcKHoil:.uell-
Te!1bHOCTI1&
flpaBoBYIO OCHORY OnepaTl'IBHO p03brCK 3111<0H Pecny6JJI1Kl'I
H()t1neSlTe!1bH()CTH COCTIIBJ1HIOT.. KOHCTI1- KaTIXCTaH
T)'UI1H Pecny6JJI1KH Ka3<IXCTJ.H ..06 OnepllTBHO-
(n. I CT. 4) P03blcKHOHnCJI-
TC!1bHOCTH"
flpaBoBoil: OCHOBOil: onepaTI'IBHO-pOJbICK- 3aKOH KbrprblJ-
HOH.ueJiTClIbHOCTH JlBlIJleTC}(.. KOHCTHTY- CKOH Pecny6lIHKH
UJI KblprbucKoi1 PCCnv61I!1KH ..06 OnepIlTHIJHO-
(CT. 5) p03blCKHOti 1!CJI-
TCJlbHOCTH»
flpauoeylO OCHOHY onepaTHIJHoi1 neJlTClIb- 3aKOH
HOCTH COCTaBlIJlIOT .. CaTHepcMe, KOHCTI1- J18TBHtiCIlOti
TYUHOHHblti 3aKoH lliuBHticKoti Pecny6- Pecny6nHIII1
J1HII!1 «flpaBa H 06S1JaHHOCT 'IeJ10BCKa H «060ncpllTI1RHoil:
rpa>KllllHI'IH3» (n ICT3) neIlTeJ11.HOCTI'I»
Cy6DeKTbI onCpllTHBHOti .ueSITenbHOCT 3111<0HlIHToBCKoil:
pyKOOOllC're}'IOTCH BpCMCHHblM OCHOB- Pccny6nl'lllH ,,06
H1.IM 3aKOHOM (KOHCTHTYUHdi) ]]I1TOB- onepaTI'IRHOH
CKOH PeCnv61II'IKI'I (CT 2) neJlTeJ1bHOCTI1"
31

llpooo,J;JKI?HUI? mUM. 3
1 Z 3
flpaBoBoH OCHOIJOH OnepaTI'IBHO-pOJbICK- 3all()H Pecny6J111111'1
HOti J\eSlTI':J1bHOCTI1 JlBJIJlIOTCSI.. KOHCTI1- MOi1J\OBa
"I)'1.!11J1(n leT 4). ..060nepaTI1BHO-
P03blCKHOH
 .DeSlTeJ1bHOCTI1»
OJ.'e.aep3.1bHblll 13KOH 06 OP):{,
flpaBoeylO OCHOHY OnepaTI1HHO-p03bICK- 4>eJ1epMbHb!f1
HOti nellTenbHOCTI1 COCTaMJlIOT... 4>e.ae- 33KOH ..06 onepa-
pMbHblH 33KOH ..06 OP):{ (a63. I CT. 4) TBHO-p03bICIlHOti
l!eSlTeJ1bHOCTI1»
flpaBoBYIO OCHOBy onepaTHHHo-p03bICK- 3aKoH Yl<pal1HbI
HOti JleSlTeJ1bHOCTI1 COCTaBJ1J1IOT... 3aKoH ..06oneparI1BHO-
YI<p3i1HbI «06 OPll'> (CT. 3) P03bICKHOti.l\fJl-
TeJ1bHOCTI1»
flpaBoeylO OCHOHY onepaTI1BHo-p03bICK- 3aKoH Pecny6J1I1KI'I
HOti JleSiTenbHOCTI1 COCTRBJ1J1IOT... 3aKoH EeJ1RpyCb
Pecny6J1I1KI1 EeJ1Rpycb ..06 OPll.. ..060nepaTBHO-
(a63. I CT. 6) P03bICKHOti.l\fJl-
TeJ1bHOCTI1»
flp3BOByIO oclioey onepaTHHHO-p03bICK- 3allOH Pecny6J1111111
HOti JleSlTe;IbHOCTI1 COCTRBJ1J1IOT... 3aKOH K.t3a1{CTaH
Pecny6J1I1KI1 KaJaXCTaH ..060Pll.. ..060nepaTBHO-
(n I CT. 4) P03blcllHotiJlelj-
TeJ1bHOCTI1»
flp3HOBOH OCHOBOH onepaTHHHo-p03bICK- 3allOH Kblprbl3-
HOti J\eSlTenbHOCTI1 JlBJ1J1eTCJI. 3allOH CKOH Pecny6J1I1KIII
Kblpfbl3CKOH Pecny6nllKI1 ..06 OPll.. ..06onepaTI1BHO-
(CT. 5) P03blclIHoi'lJlelj-
TeJ1bHOCTI1»
flp3HOByiO OCHOII}I OTTqJ3TI1HHOH lIe>lTeJlb- 3aKoH JlaTHIIIHCKOn
HOCTH COCTaIlJlJlIOT. 3alloH .06 onepa- Pecny6J1111111
THHHOH JleSlTeJ1bHOCTIII» JlRTBl1iicKOti Pec- ..06 onepaTI113HOH
ny6nl1l1l1 (n. 1 CT. 3) Jle>lTeJ1bHOCTI1»
Cy6beKTbI onepaTI1IJHOH J\eSlTeJlbHOCTI1 3aKOHl111ToBCKoH
pyKOElOJlCT13YIOTCSI .. 3alloHoM JlI'ITOBCKOH Pecny6J1I'1KI1
Pecny6J1I1KI1 ..06 OnepaTI'IBHOH JleSlTeJlb- ..060nepaTI113HOH
HOCTIII.. (CT. 2) l!eSlTeJ1bHOCTI1»
32

llpooo,J;JKeHuema6il.3
1 2 3
npaDoBoH OCHOBOH OnepaTl'IDHO-p03bICK- 3at<OH PCcny6J11'1111'1
HOti J\eSlTJ1bHOCTI'I flRJ1J1f:TCJI... 3allOH MOJUIOBa
Pecny6J1I1KI1 MO.l1J\oBa ..06 onepaTI'IDHO- ..06 OnepaTI1BHO-
p03blCKHOH AeSlTeJ1bH()CTI1" (n I CT. 4) p03blCKHOR
AeJlTeJ1bHOCTI1
3 "', IIbHbleJ.aKOHbllln BOBbieaKTbI
npaHOHYIO OCIIOBY onepaTIIIHHO-p03bICK- <J>llepanbHb!ii
HOti .JIeHTCJ1bHOCTIII COCTaRJ1J1IOT.. Llpy'"< 3aKOH 06 onepa-
l]JeJlepanbHble 3aKOHbl 11 npl1HflTble B co- THBHO-p03bICKHOH:
OTBeTCTBI1I1 C H1'IMI1 I1Hble HOpMaTI1BHble AeSlTe.l1bHOCTI1"
npaBOBble 3KTbi l]JellepanbHblX opraHOB
rOCV.iWnrTBeHHoti RJ1HCTI1 "6, I CT. 4)
npaBoBYIO OCHOBY onepaTI'IBHO p03blCK 3aKoH YKjJal1HbI
HOHJ\eJlTeJIbHOCT COCTaRJ1J11OT 06 OnepaTI1BHO-
YrOJIOBHblH KOJ\eKC Yllpal'lHbI; P03blcIIHoHJ\eJl-
YffilloBHo-npoueccyanbHblti IIQ.I:IeIlC }<KpaJ1Hbl; TJIbHOCTI1»
3aKoH YKpal1Hbl 0 npoKypaType;
3aKOH YKPal1Hbl () ).111J1I1UI'II'I;
3at<OH YKpal'lHbl 0 CJ1Y>K6 HaUI'IOHaJIbHOH
6e30nacHocT;
3aKOH YKPal1Hbl 0 nurpaHI'I'JHblX BoflcKax;
3aKOH YKp,mHbl 06 YnpaB.I1eH1'I1'I ()XpaHbl
BblCW1'IX J\OJI>KHOCTHbIX nl'lu;
JlpyrrIe 3aKOHu.JId"fCijbHbie lIKTbl 11 -
HlipollHo-npaBOBble COrn3WeHI1H 11 J\oro-
BOpbl, Y'IaCTHI1KOM KOTOpblX J1RJ1J1eTCJI
YIID31'1H3 ,,'
npaBoeylO OCHOIIY onepaTHHHo-p03bICK- 3aKoH Pecny6J1I1KH
"0" neHTe;'JbHOCT co..-raRJ1J1lOT... 1'IHble EeJ1apycb
J.aKOHo.n;rreijbHble aKTbl PecnyfuJI'I1I1'I Ee- «06 OnepaTBHO-
napycb (863. I CT 6) P03bICIlHOHn e lj-
TJlbHOCTI1»
npaBoBYIO OCHOBY onepaTI'IBHO p03blCK 3at<OH PecnyfuJl1KI'I
HOH neJlTCJIbHOCTH COCT3RJ1J1IOT. npymc K333XCT3H
3aKOHbl If I'IH"'Ie HOpM8TlllflHbie HKTbl Pec- «060nepaTBHO-
ny6J1I'1KI1 Ka3txcTaH (n. I CT. 4) P03bICKHOH.l\fJl-
Te.l1bH()CTI'I"
flpaDoDofr OCHODOR Onep3TI'IDHO-p03bICK- 3at<OH Kblprbl3-
HOti J\eSlTeJlbHOCTI1 JlRJ1HIOTCH... .npyrl1e CKOH Pcny6J1I1KIII
HopMaTBHb!e npaBOBble aKTbl Kblprb!3- 06 OnepaTI1BHO-
CKOH Pecny5J1I'1KI'I (CT. S) P03bICKHOHneJl-
TeJlbHOCTI'I"
33

1 2 3
flpaBoBYIO ()CHOII)' onepaTI'IBHOA lIeSlTeJlb 3alloH naTBHncKol:!
HOCTHCOCraBJ1J1IOT Pecny6J11'11111
YroJ10BHO-llpOIlfXCVMbHbltiKOlleKcJlaTBm'l; ..06 onepaTI'IBHOH
npynJc 3a1lOHb[ 11 \le>K1l}'JJapOllHblC lloro- AeSlTeJlbHOCTW'
BOPb!, perJ1BMCHTl'lpYIOWHe Ja)la'JI'I. npaBa
11 06RJaHHOCTI1 cy&beKTOB no 06ecne4e-
HH rOCYJW.pCTBCHHOfi 6e30nacHOCTI1,
6;B:=;I::O e:.H;\TeTa
Cy6beKTbl onepaTI1BHOA .neSITenbHOCT 3aKOHJII1TOBCKOA
PYKOBt.")JlcwyKJI'CR.. npyrl1MI'I 3aKOHaMI'I, Pecny6J11'1111{ ..06
perneHI'IRMI'I 1'1 []()CTaHOB,,'JCHI1RMI'I flpaBI'I- OnepaTI'IBHOHneSl-
TCJ1bCTB3 JII'ITOBCKOH Pecm.6nI1KI'I IcT. 2) TCJJbHOCTW.
flpaaOBOH OCHOBOH onepaTIIIBHO-P03bICK- 3at<OH PCcnyfuJl'IKI:I
H()n lICHTeJlbHQCTI'I JlBJ1HIOTCSI.. npl1HI1- MOJ1!lOBa ..06 one-
MaeMble B C()(ITIJeTCfBWI C KOHCTI1TYLll1eti pan1BHO-
11 Yu.otimI Pecn}6'1ItKlf MOII.1\OBa «06 OPll- P03bICIIHOAJ\eH-
}:\1l\If111f' HOllO.l;[IlfiIlible BKTbI (n. I cr. 4) TCJ1bHOCTl1»
4 AKTbI, "3JUleaelltblC opraHaMH. OCyutCCTB-
_I :.II O:CCTM"IO!llHC OPI{, H311aIOT (J)eacpaJIbHblA
(I npellCJlBX caoltx nonHOMO'H1t'! BCOOT- 33KOH ..06onepa-
BnCTBm'! C JaKOHOJJJln:J1bCTBOM PocCI\ii- TBHO-p03bICIIHOj:j
ClWij C1>e.aepaum'l HOpM3TI1E1Hble aKTbl, .neSlTbHOCTI1>'
pemaMeHTl1pylOU\l1e opmHI13Bumo 11 TBK-
Bt:t\eHI1J10PM 363. 2CT 4
OpraHb!. oCYllieCTBJlJlIOU\l1e OPl{. B npe 3aKoH Pecny6JJI1KI'I
.neJ1ax cBoew KOMneTeHUl111 B COOTBeTCT- EeJ1apycb
BI'II1 c 3aKOHOM ..06 opn" 11 I1HblMI'I 3a- ..06 OnepaTBHO-
KOH01l3TeJ1bHbIMI1 allTaMI1 Pecny6J11'1KI1 p03blcKHofl.ne.!l-
EieJ1apycb MOryr 1131l3BaTb no com3COBa- TeJ1bHOCTI1f1
H1'I1O C feHepa,1bHb!M npoKypoPOM HopMa-
TI1BHble aKTbl. perJ13MeHTlllpYlOwl1e opra-
HnaLlI1IO 11 TaIlTI1I1} npOBeHI1H OPM
(a63. 1 CT. 6)
Opr3Hbi tffiJIOroBblX paCCJ1eJ:\oBaHI1H fJ13B-
HOH rocy.n"pCTBeHHOH HaJ10rOBOH
CneKLll111 MI1Hl1cTepcTBa $I1H3HCOB Pec-
ny6J1!1KI1 Eapycb opraHI13yer 11 ocyU\e-
CTBJlJler OPIt e COOTl!erCTIIl111 C HopMa-
TI1BHblMI1 aKTaMI1 MEn Pecny6JJI1KI'I Ee-
;M 6HT:l1la3.1111 C
flpoiJoVKeHue maan. 3
34

llpooo,J;JKeHuema6il.3
1 Z 3
OpraHbl, ocywecTBJlRlOillMe OPI{, 1'13!IIIIOT 3at<OH Pecny6J1I'1KI1
B npe!IeJl3X CBoeti KOMneTeHUlU'I H3 ()CH()- KII3aXCTaH
BIIHI1I1 311KOH3 ..06 OPD. HDpM3TMBHbie ..06 OnepaTBHO-
3KTb1, pern3MeHTMpylOIl.!l1e opraHM3aUI1IO p03bICKHO .neJl-
11 TaKTI1"Y npoBclleHl'Ili OPM (n 2 CT 4) TeJlbHOCTI'I»
He npenYCMorpeHO 3aKoH Kbrprbl3-
C"OH Pecny6J1I'1KH
..06 OnepaTI1BHO-
p03bIC"HO .neSl-
TeJlbHOCTI'I»
rocyAllpCTBeHHbre I1HCTTYUHI1, "OTDpbIM 3at<OH J13TBMHCKO!:j
Ja"OHOM npe.llOCTaRJIeHO npaBo HII OCy- Pecny6J1I1KI1
l1\eCTRJleHl1e onepaTI1BHOH }J,eHreJ1bHOCTI1, .<060nepaTI1BHoi1
B npe!IeJ13X cBoei'l KOMncreHUl'I1'I 1'1 B co- .nellTeJ1bHOCTI1»
OTBeTCTBl111 C HaCTOSll1\l1M 3at<OHOM 11:ma-
lOT HOpMaTl1eHbre 3KTbl... OHI1 oCTynmoT B
CKJlY TOJlbKO nocJle yrBep)l(J\eHI1H I1X re-
HepaJIbHblM npo"ypoPOM (n. 2 CT. 3)
Cy6beKTbl onepaTI1BHOH JleSlTeJlbHOCT 3at<OHJlI1TOBCKOH
pYKoeOJlCTBYIOTC.II... cOOTeeTcTBYIOWI1MI1 Pecny6J1I1KI1
HOpMaTI1BHb!"tI'I allTaMI1 11 I1HCTpyKUI1HMI1 ..06onepaTI1BHoi1
rocYJlapCTlleHHoi1 I1HCTI1TYUI1I1 (CT. 2) .neSlTeJ1bHOCTI'I»
OpraHbl, ocyu.reCTBJU1lOll.!l1e OnepaTI1BHO- 3a"oH Pecny6J1l1l1ll
p03bIC"H}'1O JleSiTelIbHOCTb, l1:t1\alOT B npe- MOJU\oB3
.neJlBXC(loei1 "OMneTeHUI1I1 BCOOTBeTCT- ..060nepaTI1(1HO-
DI'II'I C J.aKOHon:rreQbCTBOM 11 no cOrJJaco- p03brcKHoi1
BIIHI'lIO C BepxoBHblM CYA()M 1'1 Pecnywll'l- AeSlTeJlbHOCTI'I»
KIIHCKOH npOKypaT)1JOH BeJlOMCTBeHHbre
HOpM3TBHble 311Tbl, perJ13MeHTl1pylOlUl1e
opmHI1J.aL[lno, MeTOllbl 11 TaIlTIIY npoae-
.aeHI1S1 OPM (n. 2 CT 4)
lIpaBoBbIeocHoBbIOP.ll:.33l1pellJleHHbleBCJJeJJ..VIOUlIfCTaThS!X3aKOHOB,
CT<lTbSl 4 C1>e.aepaJIbHOrO 33KOHa ..06 opn»
CTaTWI J :hi<oHa YtqX\I1Hbl ..06 onepTIHBHo-poobIC1<HOH JleSlTeJlbHo.:m..
CTaTbJI 6 3a"OHa Pecny6J1H"M 5eJJapycb ..06 OnepaTI1BHO-p03blcKHo1l
.uemeQbHOCTH»
35

CraThJI 3 3alloHa Pecny6JII1K K.uaxcnrn ..06 onepaTBHo-p03bICKHOH
ne$lTeJlbHOCTI1".
CTarMl 5 JaKuHl1 KbIP.-bl3CK0f1 PecnyfiJII1KI1 ..06 onepaTMHHo-
P03b1CII-Hotl.neSlTeJ1bH()CTI1t>
CTarbSi 2 3axoHa JIaTBI1t1cKoti PecnyfuJl1KM..06 onepan:!BHoti neSl-
Tt':J1bH()CTI1»
CTarbSi 2 3aKoHa JlI1TOBCKOfi Pecny6J1I1KM ..06 onepan:!BHoH .neSl-
Tt':J1bIiOCTI1»
CTaTbSl 4 3aKOtffi Pecny6J1I1KI1 MOJl.1loea ...06 onepaTI1HHO-
P03bll:IIHOH neRTt':JlbHOCTI'I".

Ta6;11'1L1i14
3aKOII<maTei1bIlOe Onpei1,eJleHRe 'l OnepaTIlBIlO-pa]b(CIUIOii
.neRTeJlbHOCTH B OnepaTllllJlO-fIB]LfCKHblX ]aKOHaX CTpaH CHr II 6aJ1THH
HUU!l/eHOOUHUe 3UKO-
3udu'Iu OPJl Hodame,lbHbiX aKmOB,
pei!1aJ.u!HnHlPJTOIllUX
OP/l
2
BblHB.fTeHllellll'fC1)ll1JeHHH, YCTaHOBi1eHl'leJ1l'1l.l.l'Ix
1l0MOTaBJIIIBaIOUlHX. COBepUlalOUlHx ... c08ep-
BblHBi1eH1'Ie npecT)'n;'JeHidt. BbI.IIBi1eHl1e 11 YCTa c})ellepaJIbHbln ]aKOH
HOflJ1eHl'le J11'1U, 1'1)( nOllrOT8R,"lI'IBafOWI'IX. cOflep- «06onepaTlfBHO-
wa!Oll.[IfX 1fJ]1f COBepWIfBWIfX (a63 2 CT. 2 HI. I) P03b1CKHoii.neSlTeJ]b-
HOCTH
nOHCII 1'1 I)/I1KCaUl'I.II l)/aKTH'IeCKI'IX lJ,aHHbIX 0 3aKoH YKPal'lHbl
npOTI'IBonpaBHoH lICSlTC;'JbHOCTH OmCJ1bHbIX J1I'1U «06onCpaTI1BHO-
If rpynn B UeJ1HX npeCe'leHI1.11 npaBoHapyweHIfH p03bIcKHoi1.neSlTeJ1b-
. I1HTepecax Vro.OBHoro cYlionpOI1JBOllCTBa HOCTIf
" I)
BblHl\!1eHl1e npeCT)'nJIeHIfH (CT. 3) 3alloH Pecny6J1IfIlH
6eJ1apycb
«06 OnepaTBHO-
pOJblCIIHoi1.neSlTeJ1b-
HOCTH
Bbl.llflJ1eHl1e npeCTYJ1.l]eHI1t1 (003. 4 CT. I pam. I) 3aKOH Pecny6J1I1KI'I
Ka3aXCTi!.H
«06 onepaTHBHo-
p03bIcKHoti.neSlTeJ1b-
HOCTI'I
BblHBJIeHl1e npeCT)'nJIeHl'lti 1'1. SeT. 3) 3aKOH Kblprbl3cKoii
Pecny6J1HIlIf
..06 OnepaTlflJHO-
p03blCKHOii
neSlTeJ1bH()CTI'I"
BblHBI1eHl1e 1:0BepWlfBwlfX npecT)'lU1cHlfe 11lfU If 3aKoH JhnBIfHclloi1
1fC£04HI1KOIJ 1I0Ka3aTellhCTB (nolln. 2 n. I CT. 2) Pecny6l1l1KIf
«06 ()nepaTIfBHoti
neHT!:J1hHOCTW'
C60p I'IHl)/opMaUl111 B c4Jepe 1'1 1'IH4>paerpYKType 3aKOHlII1TOBcKoti
rocynapCTlJeHHblX npecryrmeHI1H . yro;'JoBHblX Pecny6l1l'1l1l1 «06
npecrynlleHl1ii (I:T I) onepaTIIIBHO .neH-
TellbHOCTIf
37

1
BblSlBI1eHl1e npeCTynHblx nOCSlraTbCTB (a63. I
CT. 2)
Cu op uH$upr.taUit Il. L......-<... _HUb'" .. ..IIM(
JledcTBJlA no ooecne'leHHIO 6e30nacHOCTH rocy-
IDI crea H 06WCCTBa
lloGblBHHl'le HHlJ>opMaUHH 0 COGblTHJlX I'IJ1H .uei1-
CTBHHX. C03llHIOWHX Y'-P03Y rocYllapcracHHOM,
OOCHHOfi, 3110HOMH'1eCKoti HJ1H 3K0J10r'leCKoi1
6onacHocTH POCCUMCKOH C1>eJ1epaUHI1 (a63. 4
cT2)
nm:!cK H IJ>I1I<CaUI1S1 lJ>aKTH'leCKI1X .DaHHbIX 0
Pa3Be1lUBaTeJlbH()-nOllpbIBHo!1 nC.IITeJlbHOCTH cne-
lll'laJ1bHblX CI1yJK6 I1H()CTpBHHbIX rocy.napCTB 1'1
opraHI1Jaufi B UCJI.IIX npece'JeHI1S1 npaOOHapy-
llIeHI'IH 11 B I1HTepecax yrOJ!()BH()rO CYAonpmJ3-
B01!CTBa, a TBlOKe nOJl}"1CHI1J1 IU-Jt]:>opMBUI11'1 B
HHTepecax 6e30rIaCHocTH
CO!!et1cTBHe H 06eCne<leHI'II1 6CJonacHOCTI1 06-
mccraa, rOCY.DHpCTBa Ii YKpenJleHl'le ero 3KOHO-
MWleCKoro nOTeHLlHaJ18 Ii OOopOHocnocooHOCTH
(a63.3cr.1)
BbIJ18I1eHI1e, npe1lynpe)l(J],fHI1C npeCe'leHHe
pa3Be1lblBaTeJlbH()-nOllpbIBHOH nC.IITeJlbHOCTl'l cne-
UI'laJ1bHbIX CI1yJK6 I1H()CTpBHHbIX rocy.napCTB H
pOIlHbIxOpraHI1JaUldj (a63. 6 CT. I).
06eCne'leHHe 6e30naCH()CTI1 npe:mlleHTB Pec-
nyfuJl1KH Ka3BxcrBH 11 npyrl'lx ()XpaHJleMbIX J1HU
(a63. 7CT I)
C:'H paHbl rocYlUIpCTBCHHOH rpaHI'I-
06eCneOleHl'le 6e30naCHOCTrI Kblprbuc"oii Pec-
ny6J1I'1KI1 1'1 COlleiiCTBl1e B peaJIl'I.J"UHH I'IHTepe-
COB rocYlIapCTBa Ha Ml'lpOBOii apeHe (ol. I CT. 3).
Bbl.1lMeHl1e, npeILynpeJK1leHl'le 11 npece'1etme pm-
BellbIBaTeJ1bHO-nOllPbIBHOii lIeHTe.llbHOCTH cne-
Ul1aJlbHblX c.IIy;.:6 I1HOCrp:lHl-JbIX rocynapcTB 11
MeJK11YHapOIlHblX opraHI'I3:1Ul'lii (ol. 2 CT. 3).
06eCne'leHl'le 6eJOrIaCHOCHJ 06'beKTOB rOCYllap-
cTBeHHoH ()XpaHbl ('I. 3 CT. 3).
06CCne'leHl'le oxpaHbl rocYlUIpCTBeHHOii rpaHI'I-
Ubi 'l 4 CT. 3)
38
flpoiJo1.JlW/uemafin.4
2
3allOH Pecny6J1I'1I1H
MO.lUlOBa..o6one-
paTI'IBHO-P03b1CKHOif
neSlTeJ1bHOCTI'I»
ellepa.rrbHb[£13aKOH
«06onepaTI1BHO-
p03blCKHOk
ne.llTeJ1bHOCTW'
3-U:OH YKpal'lHbI
..06 onepanlBHo-
p03blCKHOii
neSlTe.llbH()CTW'
3allOH Pecny6J1I'1I1H
Ka3axcTaH
«060nepaTBHO-
p03bICKH0i1
lIeHTeJ1bHOCTI'I
3aKOH Kblprbl3cKoi1
Pecny6J11'1111'1
,,06 Oneparl'lBHO-
p03blCKHOH
neSlTe.llbHOCTI'I»

llpooo,J;JKeHuemafiJl.4
1 2
n0J1Y4Hl1e. Hiillon)1eHl1e. iiH3J1I1J 11 I1CnOJ1b30- 3aKoHJ1aTBI1HclloA
B!lHl1e B YCTaHOBJleHHOM JaKOHOM nOpSlllKe 00- Pecny6)1111111
JlI1TM'IecKO, COUMaJ]bHO, BoeHHOn. 3KOHOMI1- ..06 onepaTI1BHOA
'IeCKoi:i, Hay'JHOH. TeXHl1'1eCKo£'l, KpI1MI1H3J1b- lIeSlTeJ1bHOCTI1»
HO" 11 .r:r.pyroH I1Hr!>0pMaUI1I1. CBSlJBHHOH co
CQ>epOH npecT)'[1HOCT 11 ee I1H<!>paCTpyKrypOH
I1n()CSlfaTe.%CTBB
nOJ1}'4eHl1e I1HIJ>Op"'BUI1I1 0 KOHllpeTHblX 1!(luax. 3aKOHJ1I1ToBCKoH
ecnl1 pernaercSi BOnpOC 06 (IX COOTE!eTC'TBBI1 pa- Pecny6J1I1K(I ..06
60TB Ha B<DKHblX rocynapcTBeHHblX nOCTax (I B OnepaTI'IBHO neSl-
I1HCTl'lryUMX 11160 0 Jll1uax., I1MeIOIlU\X nocryn II TenbHOCTI1»
rocynapcTBeHHblM 11)111 I1HblM oxpBHSleMblM 33-
KOHO ceKjJeT" (nonn. Ii n. I CT. 2)
n - _OM
npeJlynpeJKneHI1e npCTynJ1eHI1i (a63. 2 CT. 2) (]>eJlepanbHblH3aKoH
,06 OnepaTBHO-
p03blCKHO£'l
llCSlTeJ1bHOCTI1»
npeJlyrrpe)l(JleHlfe npeCTyrIJ1eHIfH (CT. 3) 3aKoH Pecny6J1I1KI'I
ECJ1apycb
..060nepaTBHO-
p03bICKHOJ:i ne.llTeJ1b-
H()CTM»
npeJlynpe)l(JleHl1e npeCTynJ1eHI1H (a63. 4 CT_ I) 3aKoH Pecny6J1I1KH
KB3aXCTJ.H
..06 onepaTBHo-
p03b1CKHOH neSlTJlb-
HOCTI1»
npeJlyrrpe)l(JleH1fe npeCTyrIJ1eHI1H ('i. 5 CT 3) 3BKOH Kblprbl3cKoA
Pecny6J1111111
..06 onepaTl1lJHO-
P03b]CKHO neSlTeJ1b-
HOCTM»
npO<!>I1J1aKTKa npecrynJ1eHI1H " "' npeJlOT- 3aKoH J1.rnIllHclloiJ
BpaIUeHl1e(n()Jln. 2 n I CT. 2) Pecny6J1I1K
..06onepaTMBHOI1
neSiTenbHOCTI1
39

llpo()(u;J(Cl!Hue maM. 4
1 2
npeJIynpe)K.[leHHe npeCTynneHltfi (003. 1 CT. 2) 3allOH Pecny6nltlllt
MOJ1JJ,OBa«060ne-
paTHBHO-P03bICKHOfi
.ueITeJ1bHQCTH"
upece'leHHeI1jJeCT)'1UIeHItIt
npeCe'leHlte npeCl)'nJ1eHItW (a63 2 CT 2) ellepa.rrbHblfi3aKoH
..06 onepaTBHo-
P03bICKH()J:illeSlTeJ1b-
HOCTH&
npeCC'leHl'le npaBOHapyweH1ffi (CT I) 3aKOH YKPa1fHbT
..06 onepaTHBHo-
P03bTcKHoJ:illenTeJ1b-
HOCTH"
npeCC'leHHe 1'1 npeCl)'nJ1eHHA (CT. 3) 3aKoH Pecny6nHKI'I
EieJ1apycb
..06 OnepaTI'IBHO-
P03bTCKHOMlleSlTeJ1b-
H()CTH&
npeCC'leHHe npecTynJ1eHltfi (a63 4 CT. I) 3allOH Pecny6nltllH
Ka3a"cTaH
..06 onepaTBHo-
P03blcKHoJ:illeSlTeJ1h-
HOCTH"
npeCC'leHl'le npecl)'nJ1eI-Ulw ('I SeT. 3) 3aKoH KbTprbl3CKoW
Pecny6nI'lK
..06 OnepaTl'lflHO-
P03bTCKHOW lleSlTeJ1b-
H()CTH&
npeCC'leHHe npeCl)'nJ1eHItH (a63. I CT. 2) 3alloH Pecny6nltllH
MO.lUlOBa«060ne-
paTIt13HO-p03bTCKHOM
.ueSlTeJ1bHQCTH»
PaexJlt>l1lK! J1ICCT)nnCHHH
PacKpbTTl'le npeCl1'nJ1eHI'IH (863. 2 CT 2) eJIepa.rrbHbIH 3aKOH
«06 onepaTHBHo-
po3bICKHOt!
JIeSlTeJ1bH()CTH&
40

llpo()(u;J(Cl!Hue maM. 4
1 2
PacKpblTl1e npeCT)'nJ1eHl1ti (CT. 3) 3aKoH Pecny6nl1l1l1
fieJ1apycb
«06 onepaTBHo-
pOJblCKHOHlleSlTCJ1b-
HOCTI1
PacKpblTl1e npeCT)'nJ1eHI1i1 (a63. 4 CT I) 3allOH Pecny6nl1KI1
KaTIxCTaH
«06 OnepaTBHO-
P03b1CKHotilleSlTCJ1b-
H()CTi1»
PacKpb1nle npecT)'nJ1eHl1fr ('I. 5 CT. 3) '3aKOH Kb1prbl3cKOt'l
Pecny6nl1KH
«06 OnepaTI1f1HO-
P03bIcKHOiinenreJ1b-
HOCTI1"
PaCK)JbITl1e npeCTyl1J1emJii (noon. 2 "- I CT. 2) 3aKOH J1dT1JJlfrcKoii
Pecny5J1111111
«060neparl1lJHofr
neSlTeJ1bH()CTI1"
PacKpblTHe npeCT)'nJ1eHl1fr (a63. I CT. 2) 3aKoH Pecny6nl1KI'I
MOJUlQBa «06 one-
paTl1eH()-p03bICKHOn
.uenT!:J1bHOCTW>
Oc:IJ..IeCTBJU:'HIlC :JI.ICKanHU
OcyweCTBJ1eIllJC po3b!CKa _QI111, cKpblBalOWl1xcJ/ cllepanbHblli3aJ<01I
(IT opraHoB Il03HaHI1S1. cnellCTBi1S1 Ii cYlla, YKJ]()- «06 onepaTIiBHo-
HSlIOWI1XCSI OT yr0J10flHOrO HHI<33aHI111, II TaK;KC pOJblCKHOi'lllcSlTCJ1b-
1XJ.JbICKa 6e3 BeCTi1 nlXmaBWi1X (a63. 3 CT. 2 HOCTI1»
POJbJCK CKpbWUU'IXCSI npCCT)'nHI1110B_ 6e3 IItCTH 3allOH Pccny6nl1l1i1
np0nHBU1I1X rpaJlUlaH (CT. 3) fieJ1apycb
«06 onepaTHBHo-
P03b1CKHotilleSlTCJ1b-
H()CTi1"
OcywecTBJ1eHl1e Mep no p03bICKY .I11111, Cllpbl- 3aKoH Pecny6nl1KI1
BalOWI1XCJ/ ()T opraHoB nU3H8HI1J1, CJlellCTBI1S1 11 Ka3aXCTaH
"Yw. YKJIOHJlIOWI1XCSI OT yrO;JOIlHOrO Ha1l83a- «06 onepaTlJflHO-
HI1J1, 6e3 BeCTl1 np0nHBWI1X rpaA;1I.1.H " I1HblX pOJbICKHOJ:! neJITe.b-
J11111 II CJI}"IaSlx, npcllYcMOTpeHHblx 3aKOHO1 HOCTi1"
a63. SCT. I
41

1
OcyweCTBJleHl1e po3bIcKa J1I1U. CKPbIBalOWI1XCH
()T opraHoB CJ1ellCTBI'ISI 11 cyna. YK.'JOHSIlOlllI'IXCH
or Yf0J10BHoro npeCJ1eJlOBD.HI1H, a TaK)I(e P03bl-
CKa 6eJ BeCTI'I npOnaBWl1x('I.. 6 CT. 3)
nOI1CK JII'IU, KOTopble B YCTHHOW1eHHOM nopSlll-
lie HBJlHIOTCH nO.ll()JpeBaeMbIMI1, 06BHHJleMblMH
HJ1H OCYJKJ1eHHbIMH 33 COBepweHHe npecTynfle-
HHj;! (n()lIn 3 n. I CT. 2)
nmlcK J1HU nponaBWMX 6e3 BeCTIf (no)ln S n. I
cr. 1
3auUITa H 33KOHI1..]1\ HHTe (I
3mUlITa npaB It 3a!mHH!>IX ItIlTepecon rpa)l:;ll:m
3aU.ll1Ta npaB Ii :'IaKOHHblX I1tITepeCOB rpaJKJ13H
(CT. 3)
3arUl'ITa )l(113HI'I, 31l0pOBbSl, np:m, CB0601l, 3a-
IIOHHblX HHTepeCOB rpaJK1JaH H coGcmeHHoCTH
(HeJ3BHCHMO OT 41opM) or npOTlIBonpaBHblX
nocnrarenbcTB(a63. 2eT. I)
He npCJlycr.'IOTpet'lO
3mmHa ]1I1U OT npeCT)'JlHblX nocnraTenbCTB
(nonn. I n. I CT. 2)
 roCYll:'pCTBellHblX ceKpeTOB
OxpaHa roc}'napcTBeHHbJX CeKpeTOB (CT. 3)
42
npoj')(nJKellue mOM. 4
2
3aKoH KbJprbl3CKoJ;J
Pecny5J1I'1I1H
06 onepaTltBHO-
P03bIcKHoii.nenrenb-
H()CTM"
3aKOHJlaTIIHi1c1l01l
Pecny6nl1KIt
..06onepaTHBHoii
neSlTei1bH()CTH"
ellepanbHb!ij3aKOH
POCCItI1CK0I14>!:.1Ie-
paUHI1 ..06 onepa-
THBHO-PO]bICKHO
lleSlTeJ1bHOCTW'
3alloH Pecny6nHIII1
EieJlapycb
«06 onepaTHBHo-
pOJblCKHOH llS1TJlb-
HOCTH"
3aKoH Pecny6nHKH
KaJaXCTaH
,,060nepaTBHO-
po3blCKHOW
lleSlTeJlbH()CTI'I"
1all011 Kblprbl3cKOW
Pecny6nHKH
,,06 OnepaTI'IBHO-
po3bICKHO
lleSlTeJlbHOCTI'I"
3aKoH J1aTBHwcKOn
Pecny6nl'lKI1
,,06 onepaTHBHoH
LlejjTeJ\bHOCTI'I
3aKOH Pecny6nl'lKH
EieJlapycb
,,060nepaTBHO-
po3blCKHOii
lleSlTeJ1bHOCTI'I"

06CCne>leHlJe COXpaHHOCTH Cl!elleHI1, COCH!(\-
JI!UOl1!rIX rocYJlapCmeHHYIO IJ IJHYIO Oxpamle-
MYJO 3aKOHO TaHY, CO.nenCTBHe npennpl1JlTI'I-
SlM, Y'lpe)l(J1eHI'ISlM 11 OprflHI'I3f1UI'ISl (He3f1BHCI'I-
MO OT $OpM C06CTBeHHOCTI'I) l! JflWrITe KOM-
Mep4eCKOM TaMHbl (a6J. 9 CT. 1
He I1pCJJ.}CMOTpCHO
OxpaHa roCy.naPCTBeHHblX ceKPeTOB 11 .npyrl1x
Ba;KHbIX WIII rocy.napCTBfI I'IHTepeCOB (no.nn 7
n 1 CT 2)
1_e Hlfefie] OIlIlCtl OCTHcyfu.etrnmOP,Q
06eCne>leHl'le 6eJ0ll3CHOCTI'I opnmOB IJ JlIJU,
OCyweCTBJlSllOlllHX OP,Q (CT. 3)
06CCne'leHlJe OpraH()B, ()cyweCTBJlSllOIllHX OPD
(a6J.llcT I)
06CCne>leHl1e 6e30naCHOCTI1 opraHOD, ocywecT-
BJI.IIlOlUHX OP,Q ('I. 7 CT. 3)
 peJKH ..,)CTaIIDIIJJeHHOI)..mOB-
1I0-l1cnOJ1I>I1I>IM:JaKOIIOJ],8TeI1IoCT80M
nO)JJIepJKflHl'le peJKjMa, YCTaHOBJleHH()rO yro-
JlOBHO-I1CnOJ1HI'ITCJ1bHbIM JflKOHO.fillTeJ1bCTBOM, B
Mecrax Jll'IllleHI'ISI cBo6011bl (aro. to CT I)
43
llpo()(u;J(Cl!Hue maM. 4
3aKOH PecnyGnl'lKH
Ka38XCT.tH
«06 OnepaTHBHO-
po3bICKHO
!leSln:J1bHOCTI'I»
3aKOH KblprbIJCKO
Pecny6nl1l1l1
«06 onepaTl1BHO-
p03bICKHOt!
neSlTeJ1bH()CTW'
3aKoHJ1aTBl1i1clloii
PecnyGnl'lKIi
«06onepaTI1BHO"
,lleSln:J1bHOCTW'
3allOH Pecny6nl1l1l1
fieJ1apycb
«06 OnepaTHBHO-
P03b1CKHO".neSlTeJ1b-
3aKOH PecnyGnl1KH
Ka3axcTaH
«06 onepaTBHO-
po3blCKHOrl
.neSlTeJ1bHOCTW'
3aKoH Kblprbl3CKoii
Pecny6JJI'IKH
«06onepaTl1BHO-
p03bICKHO
neHTeJ1bHOCTI1"
3aKOH PecnyGnl1KH
Ka3aXCTaH
«06 OnepaTHBHO-
P03blCKHOii
neSlTeJ1bH()CTI1»

OKOH'lOHUf! maM. 4
1 2
He npellYCM()TpeHO 3aKOH KbJprb13CKO
Pecny5J11'1111'1
«060nepaTI'IBHO-
p03blCKH0I1
lIeSlTe.l1bHOCTI'I
BOThlCrnCHl'le)1llcp6a
06ecne..-eHl'le B03MerneHI1 ymep6a, HaHeCeH- 3aKoH JhnBI'IClloj:j
Hom B pt':3YJ1bTIITt': npecTY[].I1eHI1 (nOlln. 4 n. I Pecny6nl1KI1
cT2) ..06 OnCpaTI'IBHO
lleHTei1bHOCTI1
06eCne'leHtle 1I03MellieHI'I yJllep6a. npl'l'lI'lHeH- 3aKoH Pecny6nl'lKI'I
Hoe npeCTYl1JJeHl'leM (a63 I CT 2) MOJl!lORa ..06 om-
paTI'IBH()-P03bICKHOj:j
lIeSlTeJ1bHOCTI'I»
He npCllYCMOTpeHO 3aKOH KblprblJCKOA
Pecny6nl1KI1
..060nepaTI15HO-
pOJblCKHOA
lleTbHOCTI'I»
3:IAA'IHOPlt,J3Kpcn,leHl1b1eBCJlCJJ,yIOUUlXI'Ta"I1.mI:J.aIlOHOB.
CnITbSl 2 Q)ellepaJIbHOrO 3aXOHa ..06 OnepaTI'IBH()-P03bICKHO lleSl-
TeJ1bIiOCTI'I"
CrnrWi I JaKOH" YKpaI'lHbl,,06 onepaTl'IBHO-po.lblCKHOl1 De 1reJIbHOCTI1».
CTaTbJI 3 3allOHa PCCny6J1I'1KI1 EiCJ1apYCb «06 OnepaTI'IBHO-p03bICKHOA
ne>lTeJ1bHOCTI'I".
CTaTbJI I 3aJ<oHa PecrIy5.11I'1K Ka3aXCTaH ..06 onepaTBHo-p03bICKHOj:j
lleSlTCJ1bHOCTl1».
CTaTMI 3 laKoHa Kblprbl3cKoA Pecny5.11I'1KI'I ..06 onepaTMBHo-
p03bICIIH0i1 neHTCJ1bHOCTH»
CTaTMI 2 pa.>J1e.l1 I 3aKOHa JlaroMllcKoll Pecny6nl1KH ..06 onepa-
TI'IBHOHlIeSlTeJ1bHOCTI'I»
CTaTbSl I 3aKoHa JlI1TOBCKOH: Pecny6n('jKM ..06 onepaTHBHoll neA-
Te.l1bH()CTI'I»
CTaTbJI 2 3aKOHa Pecny6nl1KI1 M0J1110Ba «06 onepaTI1BHo-po3bICKHOH:
AeSlTe.l1bHOCTM".

Ta6;:[11l.ta5
Onpe.ll:e1lelfHt' :JaKOHO.llaTeJ1eM II CTpaHaX CHr H 6UTHH
06mamJ0cIeii OpraHOB. OC)lUCC11IijHIOWHX OP))
HtlUIH!H()(J{lHUe
M 'JtIKOHoiJtIme1bHblx
ny, 06RJaHHOCmU OpaH08, ocyeCmf1,)HIOUjUX CllCm08,peUltH!H-
OPJ/ IIIIIp.VIOUl,UX OPJ/.
-T-Lo6naHI10CTH 3
npHHHMaTb np3BOBbie Mepbl
- :I1=:::7 r:::J1:OHX nOJ1HOMO- CJ)ellepMbHbl"
'III" Bce He06"().llI1Mble Mepbl no JaWI1Te JaKOH ..06 onepa-
XOHCTK1}'UHOHHbJX npae 11 CB060.ll 'leJlO- TIIHO-p03bICKHOJ1
,, " rpaJK.1l1iH('jHa. co6cTBeHHocTI1. , J\eSlTeJ1bHOCTI1»
TaKJKe 00 06eCne<leHmo 6e30nacHocTI1
o6wecna 11 roCYJ\apcTBa(n. I 'I. I CT 14)
npl1HI1MaTb . "" co CBoeM 3aXOH Pecny6J1I1XI1
xOMnereHUl1eA .co He()6xOlll1Mble Mepbl 6eJ1apycb
J\JUI JaWHTb! oxpaHSIeMblX 3aKOHOM npae 11 ..06 ()nepaTI1BHo-
Cllo6o.ll 1111'lHOCT. co6cTBeHHocTH, 60r p03blCKHOl1
onacHocTH 061llCCTB3 1'1 rocynapcTBa (n I .uCSlTC!1bHOCT.....
, leT. 13).
npl1HI'lMaTb . "" co cBoeA 3allOH Pecny6J11'11111
xOMnereHUl1eA He06XODJtMble Mepbl "'. Ka3J.1CCTJ.H
aaWIIITbl oXpmUleMbJX 3aKOHOM npall, ceo- ..06 onepaTI1I1HO-
60l! 11 I1I1TepecOB i»H311'leCIII1X 11 IOP»mJ- p03blCIII1ofl
'leCXI1X 1111U, C06CneHi-JOCTI'I, 6e30nacHo- .ueSlTe!1bHOCTI'I"
CTH 061lleCTBa, rocy.uapcTBa 11 }'KpenJleHI'ISI
ero 3KOHOMI'I'leCKOrO nOTeHUl1a.118 (n. «3»
, leT. 10)
npI1H('jMIITb B npe1lellax CBQHX nQJ1HOMQ- 3allOH Kblprbl3-
'l1'li1 Bce Heo6X01ll'lMbre Mepbl no JaWI'ITe CKOH PeCI1y6nl'llll1
XOHCTHl)'IlI'IOHHblX npaB 11 Cll060Ll '1eJlo- ..06 OnepaTI'IIIHO-
,, " rpaJKJIaHI1Ha, c06cTlleHHocTI'I, , p03blCKHOA
TalOKe no 06eCne'leHI'l1O 6e30nacHocTI1 .ueSlTenbHOCTI'I"
o6mecTBal1 rocy.uapCTBa(n. 1 CT. 17)
OxpaHSlTb npaBa 11 3aKOHHb!e I1Hn:peCbl 3aKOH lh1TollcKol1
)I<I'ITe!1ei1 111'1TOBCKOH Pecny6nl'llll1 1'1 apy- Pecny6;JI'IKI'I
fl'lX 111'1U, nOrID.IIIllI'lX B ci»epy OnepaTI1BHOH ..06 OnepaTI1BHOH
.ueSITeJlbHOCTH (n. 2 'I. 2 CT. 6) neSlTeJlbH()CTI1"
45

npoikJ!l;JKeHUe mOM. 5
 npl1HI1MaTb 2 3
B C()CII'BeTCTBI1I1 co CBoeH 3alloH Pecny5J111111{
KOMneTeHUl1eA Bce He06xOlll1Mlole Meplol MUJUlOBa
I M" "lli"'" O'P'H"""" "KOHO" np'" H ...06 onepaTI1BHO-
Ce06011 J111'1HOCTI1, BCex BIU!OB co6cTBeH- pOThICIlHOH
H()CTI1, o6eCne'leHI1J1 6e:mnacHocTI1 ()6we- neSlTeJ1loHOCTW'
------;;--_ CTaa 11 roc'.napcroa (n ...a.- 'I. 1 CT. 12)
2 06uaHHOCTb KCnOJ1W1Tb nOJlY'leHIIH opra-
_IIOBIOCTHQIIII CJ)enepaJ1bHbIH
HcnonHSlTb II npeLlCJ1BX CBOI1K noJ1HOMQ'lI1H
I nOP,"'HH" " nHC""'HHO' OP"' OP"HO" "JaKOH ...06 onepa-
n03HaHI1J1, CJ1ellooaTeJlJl, YKaJaHI1S1 npoKY- TBHO-p03loICIlHOA
pop" 11 peWeHI1H cyna 0 npOBelIeHl111 OPM neSlTeJ1loHOCTI1"
no yroJlOBHbIM nellBM, npl1HJITblM I1MI1 K
npOM3flOnnPNjn 2'1.1 CT 14)
BblnonHHTlo nHCloMeHHbie nopy'1eHHH CJ1e- 3BKOH YllpaHHbl
nOBaTe}!JI, YKa3aHI1.11 npoKypopa, n()CTa- ...06 onepaTI1BHO-
HOBJIeHI1J1 cyna I{ 3anpocbl nOnHOM()'IHloIK pOJblCKHOA ne.ll-
rocynapcTBeHHblx opraHOB, Y'1pe)l(,!!eHHH H reJ1bHOCTH
opraHI13aUHH 0 npOReJleHHH onepaTHBHO-
03bICKHb1KMcp(n I, ICT7)
It1cnOJ1HHTb nopy'1eHI1S1 CJ1enOB3Tt'1JJI, YKa 3aKoH Pecny5J1I1KI{
3aHI1.11 npoKYpopa 11 OnpelleJ1eHI'IJI cYAa 0 EeJ1apycb
npOBelleH1'I1'I OPM no yr0J10BHbIM neJli1M, ...06 onepaTHBHQ-
npHHSlTb!M H"H . npOH3BOllCTBY, npell- pOThICIlHOH
CTaMJlTb MaTepHaJ1bI onepaTHBHofi AeJl- neSlTeJ1loH()CTH"
TeJ1bH()CTI1 CJIellOBaTe}!JlM npH paCCJlellO-
BaHl'l1'l I1MI1 KOHKpeTHbJX yroJloBHloIX nen
6e3 pa31J1BWeHHJI I1CT04HHKOB onepaTHB-
HOH I1H<\JOPMBUI1I1 (n 2 'I. I CT. 13) -
It1cnOJlHSlTb nl1CbMeHHble nop)f'1eHI1.11 CJ1e 3allOH Pecny5J1I1KI1
1l0BaTe}!JI 11 YKa3aHI'I.II npo,,1'POP3, a TaJU:e KaJaXCTaH
onpCi\eJleHI1H cyna 0 npoBei\eHHH OPM no ...06 onepaTHBHo-
yr0J10BHbIM lIeJ1aM, HBXOj]JIll{MCH B npOM3- p03blcllHOHlIeH-
JlOllCTI\e 3TMX opraHOH (n ...6.. 'I Icr 10) TCJlbHOCTH»
It1cnOJ1HJlTb B npcnc.1JBX CBOHX nOJ1HOMO- 3allOH KlolprblJ-
,HO nopy'leHI1J1 " nl1CbMeHHotl $opMe CKOft Pecny6nl1KH
opraHOB n03HaH('jSl, CJlellOBITeI1Jil, yKBJa- ...06 onepaTHIIHo-
HHH npoKypopa 0 npmleneHlJl1 OPM 00 p03blCKHOH
yrOJloBHbI"J lIeJ1aM, npl1HJlTblM HMI1 K npo- lICSlTeJ1bHOCTH»
I1JBOllcTBv(n. 2cT. 17)
46

2
JicnOJIl-JJlTb nl'lCbMeHHble nopy<leHI1.11 CJle
IlOBaTeJlJl. }'Ka3aHIUI npOKypopa 1'1 onpene-
neHHSI CYlla 0 npODelIeHl'I1'I OPM no yro-
nOBHblM neJlHM. npHl-JJlTbIM I'IMI1 K npO"3-
1I0!lCTII (n. E1." I CT 12)
3 OiiSB8I1IIDCTh .-.eiiCTBOB3Tb B I'OO"IIIE-ICUIIII
Ie MC}I(.1I,.VH8J!0llULlMH .noroBOpaMH II ccJIepe
npaeooxaHbl
BbInOJ1HJ1Tb Ha OCHOBC 1'1 B nopSlllKC. npc
n.yCMOTpCHHbIX Me)l(J!)'HapOLlHblMI'I noro-
BOpaNI1 POCCHHCKOH 4IclIcpaUHI'I, 3anpo-
ChI COOTDeTCT1I}'IOWI'IX Me)l(JlYHapOllHblX
npaoooxpaHHTCJ1bHblX opraHOB H cncll'1-
aJ]hHbiX CJ1Y}K6 I1HOCTpaHHblX roCYIlapCTB
(n. 3... I CT. 14\
BbInOJ1HJ1Tb 3anpucW-- CUOIlJt:lCTByJOWI'IX
Me)l(JlyHapoLlHblX npaBooxpaHI1TCJlbHblX
opraHH3aUl1W 11 npaBoOXpaHHTe!1bHbiX op-
faHOB npyrl'lx rocynapcTB Ha ()CHOBaHI'II'I
!loro Bit COHJaWCHl1fi (n. 2.. I CT. 7)
BbIrIDJ1HJlTb HB OCHOSC JlorOllOpa 11 COrIIa-
lUCH('jfi 0 npaBoBofi nO:\tOI.l.lI1 aanpocbl
COOTBeTCTByIOIUI1X Me)l(,Q)lHapOllHbJX np,,-
BOO.'<paHI'ITCnbHblx opraHI13Bmdt 11 npaoo-
OXpaHl'ITeJlbHblX OpraH()B I'IHOCTpaHHblx
r :na B n 3 'l. I CT. 13
BbInOJ1HJ1Tb HB OCHOBC norOBopOB (corna-
IUCH('jfi) 0 npaBOBofi rIOMOlll1t JBnpOCbl
COOTBeTCTB)'IOIlII1X MC)I(.!I)'HapOJlHblX npa-
OOOWtHl1nJ1bHbIX oprBHI13Bmdi 11 npaeo-
OXpaHI1TeJlbHblX opraHOB HHOCTpaHHblX
napcre (n. ..r» '1:. I CT. 10)
Bb1n()J]HJlTb Ha OCHOBe 1'1 B n()pSlllKe. npe
llYCMorpeHHblX MeJKJIYHapOllHblMH lIoro-
BopaMI'I KbrprblJCKOM Pecny6nHKI'I. Janpo-
Cbl COOTlJeTCTBylOll.lI1X :\te)KjJ,YHapOllHbIX
npaHooxp3H(JTnbHbIX OpHlHH3D.UHfi, npa-
BooxpaHI'ITeJIbHbrX opnU-JOB 1'1 CneU1'I3JIb-
HbJX CJlY)K6 HHOCTP-IHHbIX rOC}'lwpcTB (n. 4
CT. 17)
47
npoik)/Jl(;f!Hue moo,. 5
3
3allOH Pecny6J11'11111
MUJUlOBa
,,06 OnepaTI'IBHO-
P03blcIIHoH.ueR-
TJIbHOCTH»
CJ)ellepaJIbHbrH
31lKOH «06 onepa-
TIfBHO-pOJbICKHOM
.ueSlTeJlbHOCTW'
3aKOH YKpaHHbJ
..06 onepaTHBHo-
pOJbrCKHO
.ueSlTeJIbH()CTH"
3aKOH Pecny6nHKI1
EeJlapycb
..06 ()nepaTHBHo-
p03bICKHOH
.ueSlTeJIbH()CTI'I"
3aKOH Pecny6J1I'1KI1
Ka:J;;!.'u:TIIH
..06 onepaTHBHO-
p03blCKHOH
.ue!lTeJlbHOCTH"
3aKOH KbrprblJ
CKOft Pecny6nHKH
..06 OnepaTI'IBHO-
p03bICIIHO .ueR-
TeJ1bHOCTIN

Oll:l3blBaTb no nopY'leHI'lJO II COOTBeTCT
111'11'1 C .uorOIlOp:lMI'I (COrJ1:1UleHI'I1IMI'I) npa-
IIOBYIO nOMOUlb COOTBeTCTl1}flOUlI'IM npaBO-
OXpaHI1TeJlbHblM opraHaM npyrx rocy-
na p CTB (n. «cO> 'I 1 CT 12)
4 IODHJaHl1OCTh oDMeHHBaThCH Ill1l)opM8l\lleii
_ C cyfu.etcr.wH OPlJ
I1I1$opMl'lpoflan llPyrl'lc opraHhl. ()CYUle-
I CTBJ1I1IOUlrIe OPlJ Ha Teppl'lToplt1t Poccl1ii-
CKOM q,enepaLlItI1. 0 CTalJwltx 1t3IJeCTHbiMit
4Ja,,"T':\x npoTl1BOnpaBHok ne1lTeJ1bH()CTI1,
QTHOCSlWI1XCJI K KOMneTeHLllt1t 3TltX opra-
HOB, IJ OKa3blBaTb :lTI1M OpUHaM treo6xo-
_I 1'1:%::;:;b(:;r:el ;a,. ocyme-
I CTBJ1IJOUll'le OPlJ Ha Teppl'lTOpl'l1'l Pecny6-
JlI'IKI'I Ee_apycb, 0 CT:lBWI1X 1'13BeCTHblMI'I
4JaKTIlX npOl1'lBOnpaflHok .ueJlTCJ1bHOCTH,
QTHOCSlIl{('IXCJI K KOMneTeHLllt1t 3TltX opra-
H()e, 1'1 OKaJbllJBTb I'IM Heo6XOllltMYJO no-
_, MOUlb (n. 4 'I I CT. 13)
I1H$opMltpoBan .npyrlte opraHbl. OCYIl.le-
CTBJ111IOUlHe OPlJ Ha TeppHTOpl'l1'l Kb!P-
rbl3CKOW Pecny6nl'lKI'I, 0 CT:llIlliI1X 1'13BeCT-
liblMI'I $aKTaX npOTI'IBonpaBHOH neSlTeJlb-
HOCTIt. OTHOCSlU\ItXCSI K KOMneTeHUIJIt
3TI'IX opraHoe, 1'1 OKa3blBaTb I'IM He06Xfi-
1ll'lMYIO nOMOlUb (n 5 CT. 17)
I1H$opMltpOBBTb .npyrlte opraHbl. ocyme-
CTBJ111JOlUHe OPlJ. 0 CTaBWI1X 1'13BeCTHblMI'I
4JaKTax npoTI'IBOnpaBHow neJlTeJlbHOCTH,
QTHOCSlWItXCJI K KOMneTeHLllt1t 3TltX opra-
HOB, IJ OKa3blllaTb :lTI1M OpraHaM treo6xo-
----;:-- 1l1'l"IYIO nOMOlUb (n. «do> 'I. 1 CT 12)
S OfuLJaHHOCThco6JuoJJ.an.lI{HIDpdI.IiEIBOPlJ
C06J1JOllBTb npalll'l.a KOHCn11pau1'l1'l npH
OCYlUeCTBJleHl'I1'I OPlJ (n S.. 1 CT 14)
'8
llpo()(u;J(Cl!Hue maM. 5
3aKOH Pecny5J11'11111
MUJUlOBa
..06 onepaTItBHO-
P03bICKHOi{
neSlTeJ1bH()CTH»
(J)ClICPMbHbIW
3aKOH ..06 onepa-
TIJHO-p03bICKHOi{
neSlTeJ1bH()CTH"
3aKOH Pecny5J11'11111
EeJ1apycb
..06 ()nepaTI'IBHO-
p03blCKHOk
JJ,eSlTeJ1bHOCTI1"
3allOH Kblprbl3-
cKoii Pecny6nl'lKIi
..06 OnepaTI'IBHO-
p03blCKHOk
lIeSlTeJ1bHOCTI1»
3aKOH Pecny5J1IJKH
MUJUlOBa
..06 OnepaTI'IBHO-
P03bICIIHOHlI eJl -
TeJ1bHOCTIt"
(J)ellepMbHblii
3aKOH ..06 onepa-
TBHO-p03b1CIIHOfi
neSlTeJ1bHOCTI1"

1 2
Co6.nKUlaTb 1"pe601JaHIHI KOHCnl1p<U.lIm npH
OCYlllCCTB!1CHI1I1 GPn (n 5.. I CT 13)
- ----np;1HI1MaTb He06xODItMble Mepbl no oticc
ne<iCfil'110 IWHCnl'lpaum'l rIpH npOBtllCHl'I11
OPM 11 HCllonyw,eHl:IIO paccet..pe'lIIIIaHItlI
I'ICTO'JHI'IKOB i1H4>oPMaulfl:l (n <\II"" I CT 10)
C06J1lOlUITb npac",)]a KOHCnl1paUl'I11 "PM
ocyweCTBJleHl111 GPIt (n. 6 CT 17)
06ecnC<JCHI1C CCKpeTHOCTI1 onCpaTI'IBHoi1
.neJlTCJlbHOCTH. KOHIJJH!leHUI'laJ1bHOCH:! 11
6c30nacHocTI'I mm, npI'lIJJlC'lCHHb!X II Me-
pOnpl1S1T1UIM onep-mtBHoiJ nCSlTCJlbHOCTH
(n 5.. I CT 27)
rapaHTl1pOBBHI1C KOH4!WlcHUI13J'1bHOCTI'I 11
1IHOHi1MHOCTH COTpYAHH'IeCTBB (n. 4 OJ 2
CT. 6)
C06mO.MTb npaBI1J18 KQHCrmpal.!I111 npl1
()cymeCTBJICHI1I1 GPn (n. «e.. "I. I CT. 12)
6 061133J/HOCTh 06eaie<00JaTL oo6cmetmym
- e;;':;:::Jb 06eCnC'1eHI{lO e nop.llllKC.
YCTllHOBJICHHOM JaIlOHOll8TC!1bCTBOM Poe-
CI1HCKOH (]>cllep"UI'lI1. 6e30naCHOCTH 11
C()XpaHHOCTI'I I'IMYWCCTBll CDOHX cOTpyn-
HI1KOB. 1111Ll OIlH3bIBalOl1\I1X co!!eficTBl1e
OpraHaM. ()cymeCTBJ1S1JOUU'lM Opn. Y'lacT-
HI1KOB yronoBHoro CYLlOnpOIt3BOL\CTBa. a
TalGKe 'UleHOB cCMd1. 11 6J1I1JKMX YKa3aH-
H:  c leCTynHblX nOCSIraTeJlbCTB
49
npoikn)ll:eHue maan. 5
J
JaKOH Pecny6nl1KH
Ee_apycb
.060nepaTI1BHO-
p03bJCKI-!OH ne.ll-
TeJlbHOCTI1»
JallOI-! Pecny6nl1l1l1
KH3axcraH
..06 ()nepaTI1BHO-
P03blclIHOHne.ll-
TeJ1bHOCTI1"
JallOH Kblprbl3-
CKOi1 Pecny6nl1KI'I
..06 OnepaTI1BHO-
P03blcIIHoi1ne.ll-
TeJlbHOCTI1"
3aKOHJ]aTBI1i1cK0i1
Pecny5J1I1KI1
..06 oncpaTI1BHOH
ne!lTeJlbHOCTI1"
3aKoHJ1I1T0I1CKoi1
Pecny5J1111111 ..06
onepanlBHoi1 neSl-
TeJlbHOCTI1"
3aKOH Pecny5J1111111
MUJUlol1a
.06 onepaTI1BHO-
p03blCKHOH
neSlTeJlbHOCTI1"
q,enepaJIbHblH
JaKOH ..06 onepa-
TeHO-p03bJCKHoi1
neSlTCJ1bHOCTI1"

06ecne<1I1BaTb npl1BJ1e'JeHl1eM .!\pyrl1x
nOJJ.Pa3J\eJ1eHl1ii 6C30naCHOCTb COTpy.!\HI1-
KOB 1'1 11I1U, ()Ka3bIBaJOll11'1"- nOMOWb 1'1 CO-
nelicTByJOwl1x OnepaTBHO-p03bICKH()n .!\e.ll-
TeJlbHOCTH, 11 I'IX 6.11113KI1X, a noc.IIe BOJ6y-
)I(JIeHI1J1 yro.llOBHoro .lIe.ll8 - Tall)KC Y48CT-
HI1KOB npouecca, .upyrl1x 11111.4 npl1HI1-
MaJOWI1X y<lacTl1e B lle.lle, 11 'l.IIeHOB 113
ceMeii (n.5 'l. I CT. 7)
06ecne<1I1BaTb 6e30nacHoCTb COTpyllHH-
KOB, y43CTHHIlOB yrO.llOBHoro cYllonpOI13-
DO!lCTBa, 'l.lleHOB I1X ceMeH 1'1.1111 6.11113KI1X
pOllCTBeHHI1KOB, a TalCKe I1X HMywecTBa
()T npecrynHbJX H.II11 I1Hb!X npOTI1BOnpae-
HblX nOCJlr3TeJ1bCTB(n 6'l 1 CT. I])
OxpaHa npaB 11 3allOHHbIX I1HTepeCoB ceK-
peTHblx Y'lacTHl'llloB onepanlBHoi'l lleJl-
TeJ1bHOCTI1, 1JJ11311'JeCKI'IX 11 IOpK1ll1'leCKI'IX
JIHLl, OK,,3bllJalOlLll1X cOlleiicTBl1e onep,,-
TBHO" lIelITeJ1bHOCTI1 (n. 2 'J. 2 CT. 61
COileficmoBTIb 06ecne<JeHI1JO B nopllllKe,
ycr3HOBJIeHHOM 33KOH0Jl8TeJ1bCTBOM Kb!P-
nlJCKOH Pecny6.11I1I1I1, 6e30nacHocTI'I 11
coxpaHHOCTI1 I1MywecTBa CBOI1X COTPYA-
HI1KOB, III1Ll, OK,,3bIBalOlLlI1X co.neiicTBMe
OpratillJ.I, ocywecrW1S1JOlLlI1M Opn:, Y<JI1CT-
HI1KOD yro.lloBHoro CYllonp0l13BOilCTBa, a
TalCKe 'l.lleHOB I1X ceMeH 11 6.11113KI'IX YKa-
33HHbiX III'ILl ()T npecTynHblx noc.IIra-
TeJ1bCTB(n 7CT. 17)
COileficTROHaTb 06ecne<JcHI1JO 6e30nocHO-
CTI'I 11 coxpaHHOCTI'I I1MYlLlccTBa COlJlYlIHH-
KOB, '1JIeHOB I1X ceMeJ:l, 6l1113KI'IX, a TalCKe
Y<J3CTHI1KOB yroJIOBHOrO cYlionpol13lJollCT-
Da, 'JJ1eHOB I1X ceMefi, 6J1113XI1X OT npe-
Cl)'!1HbJX 11 I1HblX npOTI'IBOnpaBHblx nocSl-
raTeJ1bCTlI(n «f»'1. 1 CT 12)
7 I =b :1:::H:=e?::HbI rocy-
50
llpo()(u;JKeHue maM. 5
3aKOH YKpal1Hbl
.,06 onepaTI1BHO-
p03blCKHOi'l
lIeSlTeJ1bH()CTI'I»
33110H Pecny6JII111H
EeJ1apycb
«06onepaTI1BHO-
p03bJCKHoi'lAe.ll-
TeJlbH()CTI1»
3aKoHl111T0l1CKoti
Pccny6JIHKI1 «06
OnepaTI'IBHotille.ll-
Te.llbHOCTI1»
3allOH Kblprbl3-
CKOH PeCIJy6.11111111
«060IJepaTI1BHO-
p03blCKHOii
lleSlTeJ1bHOCTI1»
3aKOH Pecny6.11111111
M()}IJ10B3
«06 onepaTI1BHU-
p03blCKHOii
lleSlTe.llbHOCTJ1O>

llpo()(u;JKeHue maM. 5
1 2 3
CBoeBpeMeHHo I1H$OpMl1pOBaTb BblClUl'le 3aKoH YKPal'lHbJ
Opl1lHbl rocynapcTDcHHOW BJlaCTIf YKpalf- «06 onepaTI'IBHO-
Hbl 06 1'13BeCTHbiX 11M <!>aKTax 1'1 l!BHHbIX, p03bICIlHOHl!eH-
cBlflleTelIbC11IyIOlUl'lx 06 yrpOJe 6eJonac- Te.llbHOCTI'I"
H()CTtI 06lUeCTBB 1'1 rOCYl!apcrBa (n. 3 'I.. I
CT. 7)
CeoeBpeMeHHo HH$opMHpOB"Tb Y'Ipe)l(J!e- 3aKoH Pecny6lIl'IKI1
HI'IH rocyn,apcTDeHHoH BJ1acTI1 11 ynpaBJ1e- KBJaXCTaH
HI'IH PeCIJy6lIl'1lIl1 KOJaXCTaH 06 l13BeCTHbIX «06 OnepaTl'lflHO-
"" <!>aKTaX 1'1 l!aHHbIX. I:BlUlerelIbCTB}'IO- p03bICIlHOHl!eH-
lUl'IX 06 yrp03e 6eJOIJaCHOCT11 ()6meCTBa H TeJlbH()CTI'I"
rocy.ua CTBa (n «B 'I.. I CT. 10)
He npe.nycMoTpeHo 3aKoH KbrprblJ-
CKOW Pecny6lIl'IKI'I
..06 OnepaTI'IBHO-
P03bICIIHOH!leJI-
TeJlbHOCTI'I.
CBoeBpeMeHHo HH<!>OpMl'lpOBBHl'le Y'lpe)I(- 3aKoH J]:noI1wclloJi
l!eHI'IH rocYl!apCTBeHHOH BJ1acTlII 1'1 ynpae- PeCIJy6lIl1l1l'1
'IeHI'IH 0 p"CKpblTbJX BHelUHI'IX 1'1 BHyrpeH- ..06onepaTI'IBHOI'I
HI'IX n()CSlraTelIbCTD  6e30IJaCHOcTb. neSlTeJlbH()CTI1"
060POHY. 3110HOMI'I'1eCIII'IH cYBepeHl'lTeJ
rocynapcTBa 1'1 061.l.lecTBeHHblH nopSillOll B
HeM. B ycraHOBJ1eHHOM 3BKOHOM nopSlllKe
npOBeneHl'le MeponpHJlTIfH no npellOT-
JIJIBweHl'l1O 1'1 HeiiTpanl'lJaul'l1'l ':+TI'IX nOCH-
rJ.renbCTB(n. 3'1.. I CT. 27)
8 06S1JaHIIOCTb BJaHI'()'1eHCTBOBaTbccyfu.eK-
_I ;;:r:JlTb B3aI1MOlleWCTBl'le Me)l(J1)' 3aKoH YKPal'lHbJ
c060ii 1'1 llpynlMI'I IJpaf!OOXpBHI1TelIbHblMI'I «060nepaTl'lflHO-
opraH3MI'I B UeJ1HX 6blcTporo 11 nQJ1Horo P03bICIIHOH!leH-
paCllpblTlJ1'I npecrynJleHI'IH 1'1 I1Jo6J1l.J<leHI'I1 TeJlbHOCTI'I»
BI'IHOBHblX (n. 4 'I.. I C1. 7)
06eCne'leH(']e COTPYllHI'I'leCTBa " IIOOp- 3aKOHJlaTBIJHcIIOi1
.nIJHDUI'lI1 pa60TbJ C .npyrl'lMI'I cy61,eKTDMH Pecny6lIHKI'I
()nepaTI1f1HoJi neJlTeJlbH()CTI1 (n , . I ..06onepaTI1BHof1
" 27) neSlTeJlbHOCTW>
51

1 2
He npenycMmpeHO
06S1JaHI1OCTbOeC'THpa3BellblBaTeJlbHYIO
a60T
ClloeBpeMeHHoe nO.ll)"JeHl1e npaWlHBoi1 1'1
nonHoii HH$OpM8UI1I1, Hco6xOllHMOH wm
BblnOJ1HCHI1R JaJl3'J 1'1 .uOCTI'I)KCHI'IR )'lIa-
:iaHHbIX B CT. I 3aKOH8 ueJleti npl'l l'IC-
JlOJlbJOBJ.HIU'l He06XOJlHMblX MeponplulT1dl
onepaTl1BHoi1 .l{eSlT)]bHOCTrj, BIWOB 11
CpCJlCTB, MerOllOB 1'1 TaKTHlI1'I ee npOfleJle-
HI'IR, no B03MO;>KH()CTI'I MeHbwe BMeUU'l-
BaTbCSI II c4>epy npall 'le.l10BeK" (n. 7 OJ I
CT. 27)
C6op, H8KamUiBaHI1e, aH3J1IB 11 peaJ1l138-
JJI1R HH4>OpMBUHI1, CBII38HHOti c rOCY./lap-
CTBCHHOH 6nonacHoCTblO. a T8ICKe co
c4>epoti 1'1 l'IHlJJpacrpyKTYPoti npecryJlHO-
UK (n. I 'I. 1 CT. 6)
He npeJ:\yCMO"flJeHO
Hi I 06HJ.U1110Cb oecn o I"Oc)'-
_1VIpcmet1110HT3.HI1b1
06ecnC'Jctme coxpaHCtU1C rocyuapcTBcH-
HblX cCKperoB 1'1 npyrl'lx Ba;>KHblX DJUI rocy-
mtpCTBJ. I'IHTepeCoB (n. 4 'J. I CT. 27)
He npCJlYCMorpeHO
52
npoi)O/IJ/CeHue maM. 5
3
3aKOH KblprblJ
CKOf! Pecny6J1I1K!1
.06 onepanlBHO-
P03bICIIHOHllCH-
TCJlbHOCTI'I"
3aKOHJTamHiiCi(()i""
Pccny6J1I1KH
..06 OnepaTI'IBHOH
neSlTCJ1bH()CTI'I&
3aKOH lh1ToBcKoj{
Pecny6}1111111 ..06
OnepaTI'IDHOHnCn-
TC.IIbH()CTI1"
3aKOH Kblprbl3-
CKOH Pecny6J1I1H,]
..06onepaTI1BHO-
P03bICKl-Jof1ne.ll-
Te.llbHOCTI1»
3aKOI-JR3TBI1HClloi1
Pecny5;mKI1
..06 OnepaTI1BHof1
ne!lTeJlbHOCTiW
3aKOH Kblpr!>IJ-
CKOH Pecny6J1I1KI1
..06 onepaTI1BHO-
pOJbICKHOi1
ne!JTeJlbHOCTW>

OKOII'laHUe marin. 5
II lJOHLlI1I10CTbnpcnI'lTCTBOB3TbROBJIC'ICHHKI
BRn nll)KI.II,CRTeJlbI10C'T"
3awl1Ta 1II1U OT npol3oK<luuii flKnlBI10rO
OKaJbiBacMoro npOTI'IB BOJ1I'1 l-JaJKI1Ma. C
UCJlblO 0CYIUCCTBJlCI-JI1J1 npccrynl-JOW ncSI-
TeJ1bHOCTH n. 3'1 2 CT. 6
He npCJlYCMOTPCHO
3aIlOHJh1ToIJCKoi1
Pccny6J1l'1KI'I.,{)6
oncpaTHDHoHlICH-
TCJlbHOCrI1»
3aKOH KblprblJ-
CKoii Pccny6J1I1KI'I
..06 onepaTI'IBHO-
P03bICIlHOHlICR-
TCJlbH()CTI'I"
06I1MHHOCT11 CJfIfatlOB. OC)I1IeC'T1IJIAJOIUHX OPD., npenycMaTpHBaIOT
CJJeJJ}lOlltHccr3rbll3aKOHOB.
CraTbl'l 14 <I>CllCpa.rlbHorO 3aKOHfI ..06 oncpflTBHO-pOJbJCKHOii lICA-
TCJlbH()CTI'I"
CTaTbli 7 3allotm YKpal1Hbl ,,06 OnCpanIBHo-p03bICKHOH nCSlTeJlb-
HOCT"">.
CraThIJ 13 3aKOHa PeQIy6J1I1I1I1 lieJJapycb.,{)6 oneparIJBHo-p03bICKHO
ACHTeJlbHOCTI'I".
CHUbl'l 10 3aKoHa Pecny6J1l'1KI'I KaJaXCTaH ,,06 onepaTHBHo-
p03blCKHOii l!CRTCJlbHOCTIJ"
CTaTbl'l 17 3aKOH3 KblprbJJCKoi1 Pccny6J1I'1KI1 ,,06 OnCpaTIJBHO-
p03blCKHOH nCRH:JlbHOCTIJ".
CTaTbl'l 27 3aKoHa JlaTBl'liicKoi1 Pccny6J1I1KI'I ..06 onepaTBHoi1 ncSI-
TCJlbHOCTIJ»
CTaTbl'l 6 3aKOHa JlI1TOBCKOri Pccny6J1I'1KI1 ..06 onCpaTHBl-Jori ncSI-
TCJlbH()CTI'I"
CraThH 12 3aKoHa Pccny6J1I1K MCIJU{oBa ,,06 oncpar1JBHo-P03b1CKHOii
ACSlTCJlbH()CTI'I».

Ta61I11l.ta6
1aKoHOJJa1't'JlbHOe onpeaeJleHUe MepOnpUSlTUii
B OnepaTHBHO-pa1l>K'Kl1I>1X JaKOH3X CTpaHaX CHr U 63J1THU
Hau.'IIfflO6UHUe
IV<> OnpeiJe,1eHue onepamU6Ha-pa'jbiCKHbiX HlKOJ«XJameflbHbiX
Oy, W!pot1fJ1U1mUU af<n106, pe.;>UTNeH-
mUj)V1Vf4U'COPjJ,
--J- 2 3
I OllepaTBHo-p.BbICIII1...eMeponpHIITHII.OC-
_ _ 1I0BaHHbie Ha KPIIIIHH3JlHCTIl'lCCKIIX MeTOlln <J;oe.nepanbHbltl3a-
1.1. Unpoc rpa)l(llilH (n.1 '-I.. 1 CT. 6)
KOII..060nepa-
TI1BHO-p03bICKHO
neIlTeJlbHOCTH»
Onpoc IHU C I1X CorJ1aCI1.II. I1CnO.llb30BaHI1e 3aKOH YKpal1Hbl
I1X n06pOBO.IlbHOH nOMOLUH (n I, I CT. 8) ..06onepaTHBHo-
p03b1CKHO neJl-
Te.%HOCTH»
Onpoc rpa)l(!JaH (n. 1 CT. 5) 3aKoH Pecny6J1HKH
EieJlapycb
..060nepaTHBHO-
P03b!CKHo!:llleSl-
TCJ1bHOCTH»
Onpoc rpaJKJIaH. ll()J])KH()CTHbiX J1I1U. no 3aKOH Pecny6J1HKI'I
J1}'4eHHe OT HHX HHl110pMaUHH (a63. 1 n_ 2 Ka3aXCTaH
CT. II) ..06onepaTHBHo-
P03b!C"HOHlle.A-
TeJlbHOCTII»
Onpoc rp!DKll2H (n. 1 cr.1) 3aI<OH KblpTb!3-
CKOrl Pecny6J1HKH
..06 onepaTHBHO-
p03bICKHO nel1-
TCJ1bHOCTH»
OnepaTHBHbitl onpoc (onepaTHBHbltl 00- 3aKoHlTaTBI'If!-
pOC - 3J1eMeHT TaKof! CTMHH opn. lIaK CKOW Pecny6}U'lKH
onepaTHBHoe paCC.IletiOBaHHe) (n. 1-2, IJ:. 1 ..06 OnepaTHBHO
CT 9) neHTeJlbHOCTH»
P,,3BellbiBaTCJ1bHbltl onpoc (n. 7 nOCTaJ-Joe- 3aRoH JhnoBcKof!
J1CHHH BepxoBHoro COBeTa lTl1TOBCKOW Pecny6J1HIIH
Pecny6J1HKI1 0 BHeneHHH B .neilcTBHe 3a- ..06 oneparHBHo
KOHa 06 OnepaTI'IBHOW neHTeJlbHOcTH) neHTenbHOCTH»
54

1 2 3
Onpoc rpaJKIUIH (n .a. CT. 6) 3aKOH Pccny6J1I1KI'I
MOJl.!lOBa
..06onepaTI'IBHo-
p03blcKHo!:!neSl-
- Te.bHOCTW'
1.2, HaBeJleHl1eCnpaeoK(n.21J. 1 CT. 6) (f)e,lepaJIbHbJi1
3aKOH ..06onepa-
TI:IBHO-p03bICKHOR
.IIeJIT;:[bHOCTI1"
It1CT]Je60BaHl1e. c60p 1l0KYMeHToB 11 naH 3aKoH ¥Kpal1Hbl
HblX, xapaKTepl'lJ}'IOWI'IX .ueIJTeJ1bHOCTb .. 06 onepanlBHo-
npe1lnpl1S1Tl:lti. Y4pe)l(Jlf:HI1H. opraH('j3aLll1H, po3blCKHOH !reSl-
, TalOKe o6paJ )/(113HI1 ()r.ne.llbHbIX JlI1U, renbHOCTW>
nOllU3peBaeMblx B nOllrOTOBKe I1JJI1 cOBep-
weHHI1 npecT)'[]J1eHHR, I1CTO'1HHII " p-
MenblI1XJ\OX01l0B (n 4'1. leT 8
HaBeJIeHl1e cnpaooK (n. 2 CT. 5). 3aKOH Pecny6J1I1KI'I
lt1C1]Je60B<lHl'le. cGop 1'I113)"1eHl'le 1l0IlYMeH- 6enapycb
TOB 11 CBI:t\eHI1i1, IIOTQpb!C xapmCrepl13YIOT ,,060nepanJBHO-
.nelJreJ1hHOCTb npeD,npHTj:j, Y4peJK1leHI1I1, po3bICKHOii nes-
()praHI1Jaufj, 3TIlICKe o6pa3 >KI1JHI'I N- TeJlbHOCH:!»
llCJIbHblX 111m. nOllo3pcB<ICMbiX B nonroTOBllc
111111 coaepweHHI1 npeCl)'!lJ1eHiJSI, I'ICTO'JHI1K
11 Dd3NeDbll'lX nOXOllOB n. 7 CT_ 14
HaocllCHl'lc CnpaBOK. npoBqJKa no }"JeTaM 3aKOH PeCl1y6J1I1KIf
Y4pe)l(J\eHHii, npcllnpl1lHHi1 " opraHI13a- Ka33XCT3H
liMn (HB3aeI1CI1MO OT nOlllJl1HeHHOCTI1 11 ,,060nepaTrIBHQ-
$OpM c06CTBeHHOCTH) (003. 8 n. 2 CT. II). poJbICKHOI'I neSl-
npoBqll<a no onepanlBHblM. KpI'lMI'IHa.rJI1- TeJ1bHOCTI'I»
CTH'IeCKI'IM Y4eTaM 1'1 CI'ICTeMBM yr0J10BHOii
cerl'lCTOOUl'l11 (a63 17 n. 2 CT. II)
HaI>eJleHl1e cnpaOOK (n. 2 CT 7) 3aKOH Kblprbl3-
cKoii Pecny6J1I'1KIf
,,060nepaTl'IBHO-
P03blcKHo1'IJleSl-
TeJ1bHOCHI»
HaeeneH(']e cnpaooK (n. "B CT. 6) 3aKOH Pecny6J1I1KI'I
MOJlllOBa
,,06onepanJBHO-
p03b1CKHOii
.ne.llTeJ1bHOCT..
flpoiJolJK:eHUe moo". 6
55

npO()(u;J(CI!Hue maM. 6
1 Z 3
1.3, O6cneJ:ioeaHHe nOMeWeHl1H. ;YJaHI1H, @e.aepaJIbHbIH3a-
Coop}')KeHl1. }"IaCTKOB MCCTHOCTH 11 1paHc- KOH ..06 onepa-
noprHblXCpeJlCTB (n. 8 '.I. I CT. 6) TIJBHO-p03bICKHOil
.aCSlTeJlbHOCTIf»
06CJ1e.LlOBBf.me .lKI1J1blX 11 .upyrlJx nOMewe- 3aKOH YKpBI1Hbl
HI1M C COH1Bcml I1X BJ13.1!elIhllfB 1{1I1{ 061{- ..060nepaTliBHO-
TaTelIef1 rum BbHlCHeHI1J! ()6CTOSlTeJ1bCTB P03blcKHOH.ueSl-
COBepweHHoro 111I11 rOTOBSIllIerOCJ! npecry- TenbHOCTIf»
nJleHHJ!(n 6'1. I C1.6) 3aKOHPe
06CJ1CllOBaHl1e nOMeWCHI1H. 3lJaHI1H. co-
Opy.IKCHI1H. Y'1BCTIIOB MecrHOCTI1 I{ TpaHC- E)eJmpycb
nopTHhlX cpe.aCTB (n 8 CT S) ..06onepaTIJBHO-
po3blCKHOH .aes-
TelIbHOCTW'
llocMoTp :lIm:JIhIX nOMeWeHI1I1. pa60'111J( I{ 3aKOH Pecny6lIl1KI1
I1HblX MeCT (a63. IS '.I 2 CT. II) KaJaxcTBH
..060nepBTI'IBHO-
POThICKHoi1.ueSl-
TelIbHOCTH"
06CJ1e.LloBBHHe nOMellleHI1H. 3.IlBHI1i1, <0- 3aKoH Kblprbl3-
Op}')KeHI1H. Y'lacTIlOB MeCTHOCTIf I{ TpaHc- CKOH Pecny6J1I{KI1
nOj)rHblxcpe.acTB(n. 8 CT. 7) ..060nepaTIJBHO-
poThICKHOA .ues-
TeflbHOCTH»
OnepaTHBHhli:t ()CM()Jp (n. 3 'I. I CT. 6) 3aKOHflaTBI1f1cKof1
Pecny6lIl1l1l'1
..06 OnepaTI1BHOii
.aeSiTelIbHOCTI1"
Ti1I1HOe ocywecnmeHl1e oCMorpa nOMe- 3i1KOHJ1HTOBCIIOH
llIeHmr (onepaTl1BHblH OCMOTp) (n. ..a.. '.I I Pecny6lIl1KIJ ..06
CT. 6) onepaTI1BHOH.u C IJ-
Te.%HOCTH»
06CJ1ellOBBHHe nOMellleHI1H. 3lJaHI1H. co- 3aKOH Pccny6lIl1KI1
opy.IKCHI1I1. Y'1acTIlOB MecrHoCTI1 I{ TpaHC- MOJ1.aOBa
nopTHhlX cpe.aCTB (n "I" CT. 6) ..06 onepaTHBHO-
poThICKHOH .ue5!-
TeJlbHOCTH»
56

llpo()(u;JKeHuema6n.6
1 2 3
lA, C60p 06paJUOB WLII CpaBHI'ITenbHoro cDe.aepa.rlbHb!fl3aKOH
I'ICCJ1ellOBal-m (n. 3'1. I CT. 6) .06 onepaTBHo-
po3b1CKHOfl
.u:eSlTeJ1bHOCTH»
Coop ()6pa3uoB WLI! CpaeHI1TeJ1bHuro IiC 3aKOH Pecny6J1I1KH
CJlellOBaHH (n 3 CT S) 6eJ1apycb
,,060nepmIBHo-
p03b!CIIHOfl
JIeHTeJ1bHOCT»
Or6op np06 H 06pB3LlOB W1I1 I1CCJ1ellOBa- 3aKoH Pecny6J1I'1KI'I
HI1$1 (a6J. 9n. 2 CT. II) Ka3aXCTaH
(,060nepaTHBHo-
P03bICKHOHlleSl-
TI:J1bHOCTH"
C60p ()6pa3UOB WUI CpaBHI1TeJ1bHOrO I'IC- 3aKOH Kb!pfblJ-
CJII:llOBaHIUI (n.] CT. 7) cKofi Pecny6J1I1KI'I
,,060nepBn'!BHO-
p03bICKHOfl
JIeSlTeJ1bHOCTIf»
OnepaTl'leHOe n()J]}I'l.eHl'le 06pB3LlOB 3aKOHJlaTBl'lficKOfl
(n 4'1.. I CT 6, n. I CT. 12) Pecny6J1I'1KI'I
,,06 OnepaTI'IBHOii
JIeSlTeJ1bHOCTI'I"
H3'bIlTlfe MBn:pI18J10B, JIOK}lMeHTOB, Cblpbll, 3aKOHJ1IfToBclloii
06pa3L10B npOilYKLll'I1'I 1'1 JIpyrl'lx o&beIlTOB Pecny6J1I'1KIII ,,06
W]H I'ICCfle1l0BaHI1 6e3 c006meHI'II1 06 If X onepaTI'IBHofiJIel1-
H3MITHJ.1 (n. "B lI. I CT. 6) TeflbHOCTH"
Coop MBTeplf8JIOB, 06paJLlOB W1I1 CpaBHI1- 3aKOH Pecny6J1I'1KI'I
TeflbHoro I'ICCiH.1\OlJaHIfSi (n. "C» CT. 6) MO!1JIOBa
,,06 OnepaTI'IBHO-
p03bICKHOfl
JIeSiTeflbHOCTIf»
1.5. npoaepO<IHBSI JaK)lnKa(n. 4'1.. I CT. 6) @eJIepaJIbHbln
JaKOH ,,060nepa-
THBHO-p03bICKHOn
JIeSiTeflbHOCTIf»
57

llpo()(u;JKeHuema6n.6
1 2 3
KOHTpOJ1bHaSi 3aKynKB TOBapOB C L(CJ1blO 3aKoH ¥Kpal1Hbl
Bb1JlBJ1eHHSI npOTI1BOnpaBHOH lleSlTCJ1bHO- ,,060nepaTI1BHO-
cTl:l(n 2'.1 I CT. 8) P03blcKHoj{neSl-
TeJ1bHOCTI1»
KOH'TpOJ1bHble 3aKynKI1 (n_ 4 CT. 5) 3aKoH Pecny6J1I1KIJ
6e.rmpycb
,,060nepanJBHO-
P03bICKHoj{neSl-
TeJ1bHOCTI1»
KOHTpoJ1bHble 3aK)'TIKI1 (003. 10 n. 2 CT. II) 3aKOH Pecny6J1I1KI1
Ka38XCTaH
,,060nepaTI1BHO-
P03bICKHOHneSl-
TeJ1bHOCTI1»
npOeepO'lHble 3aKynKI1 (n. 4 CT. 7) 3aKOH Kblprbl3-
CKOM Pecny6.11I1UI
,,060nepaTIIIBHO-
po3bICKHOH lle-
TeJ1bHOCTI1»
KOHTpoI1bHaSI 3aK)lnJ<a TOBapoB (n. "r» CT. 6) 3aKOH Pecny6J1I1KI1
MOJu{OBa..06
onepaTIIIBHO-
po3blCKHOii lle-
TeJ1bHOCTI1»
1.6, It1cCJ1ellOBaHl1e npeLlMeTOB 1111()KYMeH <I:oenepaJIbHblH
TOB(n. 5'J. I cr. 6) 3aKOH ,,06onepa-
TIJBHO-P03bICKHOH
neSlTeJ1bHOCTIJ»
JhY'leHl1e nOIlYMeHToB 11 DaHHblX. xapall- 3aKOH ¥Kpal1Hbl
Tepl13YlOWl1X ne}ITeJ1bH()CTb npeLlnplJSlTHH, ..06onep"TIJBHO-
Y4peJK1leHI1M, OpraHl13al[l1H. a TalOKe 06pa3 po3blCKHOH ne-
JKI13HI1 OTneJ1bHblX 1I11L(. n()JI03peBaeMblx B TeJ1bHOcnl"
nOllfOTODKe 111111 COBepWeHU'I npec-rYIUle-
HI1S1. l'ICTO'IHI1K " pa3Mepbl I1X nOXOLlOB
(n.41J. I CT. 8)
HCCJ1ellOlJaHl1e npellMeTOB l111oKYMeHToe 3aKoH Pecny6.r1l.1KIJ
(n.5CT5) 6e.rmpycb
,,06 OnepaTIJBHO-
P03blcKHoj{neSl-
TeflbHOCTIJ»
58

npoiJotlJK:eHUe maM. 6
1 2 3
npeliBapHTeJIbH()e IfCCJIelIOBaHlfe o6Hapy- 3aKOH Pecny6J1I1KIf
JKeHHbIX. He.-mICHO 3;UPI1KCl1pOBaHHblx " Kil3aXCTaH
1f3'bSlTbIX CJ1ellOB npon:!BOnpaBHblX neSlHI1H ,,06onepanJBHO-
(a6J. 13 'l. 2 CT. II) po3blCKHOH .lJ(:S1-
TeJlbHOCTW'
HCCJIeliOBaHl1e npellMCTOB 11110KYMeHTOB 3aKOH Kblpt"bl3-
(n SCT. 7) CKOt! Pecny6J1IfKI1
,,06 onepaTI1BHO-
P03blcKHol'llieSl-
TeJlbHOCTM"
OnepaTI1BHOe I1CCJleDQBaHMe (n. 2 CT '2, 3aKoH l1aTBI1HCKOH
n.4'l ICT6) Pecny6J1MKI1
.,()6 onepanllJHofl
- lleSlTbHOCTM"
HCCJleliOBaHMe MBTepl1aJ10B, .nOKYMetITOB, 3mWH JlIfTOficllOH
Cblph!!. 06pa3uoe npollyKUHM " llpyrl1x Pecny6J1MKH
06"beIlT08(n. "8»'1.1 CT.6) ,,06 onep:nMBHow
lle}lTeJlbHOCT..
It1cCJlellOBaHl1e npeJ1MCTOB M .noK)'MeHToB 3aKOH Pecny6J1MKM
(n. ..g"cT_6) MOJIlIOBa
..06 onepan:!BHO-
P03bICKHot!lleSl-
TeJlbHOCTH»
1.7. OrO*1leCTMeHMe JlM'.JHOCTH (n. 7 'l. 1 <I:oeliepaJIbHblt!
cT6) JaKOH ,,06onepa-
THBHO-pOJbICKHOtt
lleSlnJlbHOCTH»
OrO*1leCTBJ1eH(leJIH'lH()CTIII (n 7CT.S) 3aKOH Pecny6J1HIIM
EeJIapycb
,,060nepanJBHO-
P03blcKHol'I.neSl-
TeJlbHOCTH"
nOI1CK (I OTOJK.llfCTBJ1eHl1e JlI1'1HOCTI1 no 3aKoH Pecny6J1I1KI1
npMMenlM (alh. 12'1 2 Cl II) KaJaxcnlH
..06onepaTI'IBHo-
P03bICKHOHlieSl-
TeJlbHOCTH»
59

2
OrO;tQ1CCTBJ1CHl1e J111"1H()CTI'I (n 7 CT. 7)
OnepaTI'IBH()e ()6CJ1eJlOBaHl1e JIIma (n. S
<I_lcT.6)
YCTaHoaneHl'le nWHOCTIf (n. ..h» CT. 6)
1_8. Ha6J110llt:HHC ([J 6 '{. I CT. 6)
B113YaJ1bHoe Ha6J11oJleHI11': B ()61l1I':CTBeHHbIX
NeCTax c npl'lMCHCHI'ICM IPOTO-. I1I1HO- 11
BH1leOC'beMKI'I, OnTI'I'ICCKI1X 11 paIU:IOnp!160-
pOB, npyrl'lx TeXHI'I'ICCKI'IX cpeIlCTB (n. II
I CT. 8)
Ha6J1IOJlCHl1e (n. 6 CT. 5)
Ha6J11oaCHlJI':, B TOM 'HJcn!': C I1cnQJ1b30Bil-
ImeM TCXHIf'1CCKI'IJ( CpCllCTfI (aylUlO- 1'1 BI'I-
neOJanl1CI1. KI1H()<)JOTOCbeMKI'I 11 npynJX
TeXHI1'1CCKIiX CPeJlCTB) MaTepl1aJlOB 11 Be-
lllccm. He HaHOCIIllHX BpeJ1a }l(113HH. 3110-
pOBblO 11 ol<pY>K3}owdi cpclle (a63 6 n. 3
CTII)
OnepaTI'IBH()e Ha6moneHI'IC (n. 14 CT. 7)
60
npoi)O/IJ/CeHue maM. 6
3
3aKoH Kblprbl3-
(KOt! Pecny6.1U'1KI'I
,,060nepaTI'IBHO-
P03bICKHOHliCSI-
TC.%HOCTW>
3aKoH llaTBI1HcKoft
Pecny6nl'lKH
..06onepaTliBHofi
lICSlTC:ibHOCTIf"'
3aKoH Pccny6nHKI'I
MOJUloBa
,,06onep"TlJBHO-
P03bICKHOHJ\Cf1-
TCJ1bHOCTW>
Q)epanbHbljj
.aKOH ,,06onepa-
TI'IBHO-p03bICKHott
.o:eSlTC.:JbHOCTH»
3aKoH YKpaHHbl
,,06o!1CpanmHo-
po3bICKHO!:! ncSl-
TCJ1bHOCTW>
3aKOH Pecny6nHKH
6enapycb
,,06onepanmHo-
P03bICKHO nes-
TeJlbHOcnl"
3aKOH Pecny6nliKH
Ka33xcT3H
,,06onepanmHo-
po3blCKHOI'I neSl-
TeJlbHOCTW"
3aKOH Kblprbl3
CKOtl PecnyOJlIiKH
,,06onep"TwBHO-
po3bICKHO neS]-
TeJlbHOCTI{"

llpooo,J;JKeHuema6il.6
1 2 3
Onepan1BHoe Hafi.rnoJ!eHt!e (CJ1e)l(Ka) (n. 2 3alloHl1aTBI{McKoif
'I. I CT. 6, CT. 10) Pecny6nl1KI1
«06 OnepaTI1f1HOA
lleSlTbHOCTI{"
1ll{<jHaSI 11 niiHaSI CJ1eJKKa (n. 7 nocnlHOfl- 3aKoHllI1TOBCKO
neHIfSI BepX013Horo C013eTa 1ll{TOBClloii Pecny6nl{lIl1
Pecny6nl{lIl{ 0 BBCL\eHI1I{ 13 lleiicTBHe 3a- 06 onepaTI{BHoii
KOHa 06 onepaTI1BHoii lJ;eHTeJ1bHOCTIJ) lJ;eSlTeJ1bHOCTI{"
Bl{3y3J1bHoe Ha6J11oJJ,CHl{e (n "C" CT. 6). 3aKOH Pecny6nHKIJ
Ha6JJlOL\eHl{e 11 nOIlYMeHTlfpOBaHl{e C HC- MO.l11l0Ba
n()J1b3QB3Hl1eM COBpeMeHHblX ",eTOlKlB " ,,06onep"TIiBHO-
TeXHI1<jeCHJXCpeacTB(n «dCT. 6) po3blCKHOA neSl-
TeJ1bHOCTIi"
1.9. KOHTpOJmpyeMaIJ flOCTaBKa (n. 13 'I. I Q)epa}lbHblii
cT6) 3aKOH ,,060nepa-
TIJBHO-P03bICKHOfi
AeSiTellbHOCT"
B uellllX BblSlBJ1eHnll npenynpeJl(Jlt'Hltli 11 3akoH Pecny6nHkl1
npece<jeHnll npeCTyl1J1eHl1ii, a TIllOKe nplJ'Ia- KaJaxcTaH
CTHblX II HHM JII1U ()cywecTIJJlffil> ()nepal1'lB- ,,06onepanJBHO-
HblH 1I01ITp0J1b nOCTaBOK TOBapOB, BewecTB po3blCkHOI'I neSl-
)1 I{HblX J.laH:pa}lbl'IbIX UCHHocreif, SlflJlSlJO- TeJ1bHOCTIi»
WI1XCSI npel!llleTIUIIl{ npeCTynHoMlleSlTI:J1bHO-
CT I{ npeal'Ia3Ha<jeHHbiX II npoBQ3Y. BblI\03Y
)1J11{ BIIWy Ha -reppltTopl1lO Pecny6J1I1KI1 Ka-
3dXCTilH (n.«M»'I. I CT. 8)
KOHTpoJ1l1pyeMbie nOCTaDkli (npoDep04Hble 3aKoH KI,lprbl3-
nOCTaBKJI) (n. 6 CT. 6) CKOtt Pecny6J1I'1KI1
«06onep"TIiBHo-
po3blCkHOI'I nes-
- TeJ1bHOCTIi»
1.10. OnepaTMBHblH 3KCnepl1MeHT (n " (J.Iellepa}lbHbI
'I. I CT. 6) 3aKOH «06 onepa-
TIJBHO-p03bICIlHOfi
lleSlTeJ1bHOCTIf»
61

npoi)O/IJ/CeHue maM. 6
1 2 3
OnepaTI'IBHblA 3KCnepl'lMeHT (n 7 <. I 3aKoH llaTBI'II1cKoA
CT. 6. CT. 15) Pecny6nl'lKI'I
...o60nepaTl'IBHofi
lleSlTbHOCT"
nOcewaTb llPyrl'le l'I )Kl'IJlb1e nOMerneHI1J1 C 3aKOH Yllpal'lHbl
CorJ1aCl1.I1 I'IX BJ1aneIlbueB I'IIIl'I oOI1TaTeIleii «06olJepan:!BHo-
llml BbUICHeHI1.11 ot5cToRTenbCTe coeeprneH- po3blCKHOfi lle.ll-
HO.-O l'IJ1l'1 .-OTOBSIll!e.-ocSi npecl)'lJJ1eHI'IJI, a TeJ1bHocn:!"
TaK)!(C C06l'1paTb CDCneHl111 0 npOTI'IBO-
npaBHO" lIeSiTeIlbHOCTI'I nOllo3peBaeMblx
'II'IU, B ()THOrneHI'II'I KOTOpblX npODOlll'ITCSI
mXIBeDK8 (n. «6 'I. I CT. B)
EecnpenSlTCTBeHHo BX01ll'lTb B 1I1060e I1pe- 3aKoH Pecny6nl{KI1
MJI C)'TOK HB TepptlTOpl'l1O 1'1 B nOMellleHl'Ili KaJaxcT8H
npelInpl'lJlTI'IH, Y'1pe)KlJeH11H 11 0P.-8HI'I3a- «06olJepan:!BHo-
ul'IA (He3"BI1CI'IMO OT 4JOPM C()OCTBeHHo- po3blcKHoHneSl-
CTI1). B HB TeppllTOpIllO BOI1HCKI1X 'IBCTeJ:i 'JeflbHOCTI1"
IJ 11PYrl'lX pe)l(l1"'HblX Ofu.eKTOB - no co-
HlacoDaHl'l1O C 11X P}'K0OOlUfl"{'QJlMI'I, TOIIt.--
KO , ueIlJ!X npOBeneHl'Ili OPM, npeny-
CMOTpeHHbIX CT. " HaCTO.lll.l.lffO -3BKOHB
(n. «Ii<> 'I. I CT. B)
OnqJaTI{BHblfi 3KCnepl{MeHT (n. 15 CT. 7) 38110H KbIP'-b!J-
CKOI1 PecnyoIl11KI'I
..060IJepaTI1BHO-
po3blCKHOfi ne!l-
TeJ1bHOCTl1»
Ta}iHO npOHl{lIaTb B IIBapTl1py, nOMel1!e- 3alloHJ1dTBl{flcKOfi
1'11'111, Tp8HcnoPTHb1e Cpc::LlCTBB 1'1 lIpyrl'le Pecny6nl'llll'l
ny6nl'l'.IHO HenocTynHble ()ObeKTbl B ueJlSlx «06 oneparl'lDHO
o6ecne'leHI'IJI npOBeneHI1J1 Meponpl'lSiTIiA .neHTe;,]bHOCT»
onepaTI'IBHOfi .neIlTeflbHOCTI1 (CT. 14)
BXOJUJTb B nOMernCHIfJI npe1lnp(:!IITI'IA. Y'!- 3aKOHll(:!ToBCI(o
pe)!(l]eHl{fi, opmHH38(l(:!it, npol13IJ01ll'lTb Pecny6nl{lI(:!
KOHTpOJlbHble npoBepKl1, reXHo;']orl1'leCKl1e «06 oneparl1DHol1
3Kcnepl1MeHTbI. 113blMBTb MBTepHBJlbl, .no- .neSlTeJlbHOCT»
KYMeHTbl, cblphe I{ o6pa:n.[b1 npOJ:!YKL[I{I{ IJ
ApY.-l1e 06'beKTb! 1lJISi IICC11t:OOBBHI{S1 60 co-
o6weHIfJI ()6 I1X I'I:J'WITI'II'I (n «D» <J. I CT. 6)
62

-+-t- UnepaTHBHO-paJLICKHe MepOnpH:ATIIH, oc.
- aHer:JI=::::!1;::;I::::XTe_
l1erpa<t>HblX  (JHb]X C006!l.lfHHH (n. 9 'I. I
CT,6)
KOHT)JOJl!' nyreM oT5opa J]() ()TneJ1bHbIM
nplUH3K3M Tenerpa<jJHo-nO'lTOBbIX OT-
npaBJ1eHI1H (n. 10'1 I CT. 8)
KOHT)JOJlb nO'1TOBO TeJlerpa4JHblx OTnpaB--
nemdi(n. 9 CT. 5)
KOHT)JOJlb nO'JTOBbiX OTnpaBJ1eHI1H (a63. 2
Jl. 3 CT. II)
KOHT)JOJlb nO'JTOBblX OTnpaBJIeHl'lii TeJle-
rpa4>HblX 11 HHblX co06weHldi (n. 9 CT. 7)
OnepaTl1BHbri1 KOHTpOJ1b 33 KoppecnOH-
neHUHeft (n. 9 'I. I CT 6, n. I 'I I CT. 17)
C[JeUHaJlbHbIH KOHlJIOJIb nO'JTOBbIX nOCb[-
n()K (n. 1 nOCTaHOBJIeHH.II BepXOBH()fO Co-
BeTa J]I1TOBCKOtl Pecny6nm<li 0 BBe1leHl11'1
B neHCTBlJe 3aKOHB 06 onepaTliBHof! neH-
TeJ1bHOCTH)
KOHT)JOJlb nO'JTOBbTX OTnpaBJIeHidt (n. ..j,.
cT6)
63
npoi)O/IJ/CeHue maM. 6
cI>enepaJIbHblfI
BaKOH ,,06onepa-
TI'IBHO-p03bICKHOk
neSlTeJIbHOCTH»
3aKoH YKpalU-Jbl
,,06onep"THBHO-
p03b1CKHOHlieSl-
TeJlbHOCTW>
3aKoH Pecny6nHKH
EieJlapycb
,,06onepaTrJHHO-
p03b1CKHoi1J\eSl-
re.bHOCTW'
3aKoH Pccny6nl'lKH
Ka3BXCT3H
,,06onepaTI'IBHo-
P03blcKHoiiJ\eSl-
TeJlbHOCTW>
3aKoH Kblprbl)-
CKOtl Pecny6J1l'1KI1
"06onep,,niBHo-
P03blcKHoHJ\eSl-
TeJlbHOCnl&
3aI<Of:l
J]aTBI1HCKoft
Pecny6nl1KI1
,,06onepaTl'IBHoli
lleSlTe;J1>HOCTl'I"
3aKoHJ]I1TOBCIIOH
Pecny6nl1KI1
«D6 onepaTI1BHOl'l
lleSlTe;JbHOCTW>
3aKOH Pecny6.11l'1Kl'I
MO.lllIOBa
«D6onep1TIiBHO-
P03blcKHoliJ\eSl-
TeJlbHOCTW>

1 2 3
Onepan1BHblH nOI1CK nO HHeWHI1M np(']- 3aKoH Pecny6nHKI1
3HaKaM I-Ja nO'ITOBO-TeJ1erpa$Hblx KD.Ha1aX KaJ.axcHUJ
Cl\,II3111 (363. J n. JCT II) ,,060nepanJBHO-
po3blCKHOI'I neSl-
TCflbHOCHj"
CHSlnJe i1H4IOPMaUl'II1 C TeXHl1'1eCKI1X Ka 3aKoH Kblprbl3-
HaJ10RCHSl311 (n. II CT 7) CIIO Pecny6.rU'lKI1
,,06onepaTI'IBHo-
po3bICKHOA lleSl-
TeflbHOCTW>
UeH3}'pa KOppeC[]()HlleH[UlH ocy;KlleHHblx 3aKoH Pecny6nHKi1
(a63. In. JCT. II) Ka3aXCTD.H
,,06onepan:lBHO-
p03bICKHOH lleSl-
TeJlbHOCTH»
He npeuycMOlpeHO 3aKoH Kblpn>l3-
CKOti Pecny6.1U'1KI1
,,06oncpanIBHo-
P03blcKHoHlleSl-
TeJ1bHOCTW>
npOCM3Tpl1BaHiJe KoppecnOH.1leHLlI1I1 ocy- 3akOH Pecny6nHKI1
)I(l!eHHblX (n. "K CT. 6) MOJl1loBa«06
onepaTlJBHO-
po3bICKHO neSl-
TCJ1bHQCnl»
2.2, npocnyllJJlBaHife TeJIe<]JoHHblx nepe cI>enepaJIbHblR
TOBopoB(n 10'1. I cr. 6) IaIlQH
,,06onepanIBHo-
po3bICKHOA lleSl-
'JeflbHOCTI1"
npocnywHHD.HHe Te.e<]JOHHbIX neperOBO- 3alloH Pecny6nHKI'I
pOB I1I1HblX neperOBopOB (n. 12 CT. 5) EieJlapycb
..06onepan:lBHO-
P03blcKHoHJ\eSl-
Te.bHOCTW'
npOCJIywl1BaHlte TCJle$OHHbIX neperoeopoB 3aKoH Pecny6nltKI1
H I1HblX neperoBopOB (003 4 n. 3 CT II) KaJaxcTaI-J
,,060nepanJBHO-
po3blCKHOI'I neSl-
TeJ1bHOCTW>
flpO(J01)KfflUe maan. 6
64

npocnYWI1BaHl1e TeneOHHbIX neperoBo
pOB 11 HHblX neperOBopOB (n. 10 CT. 7)
OnepaTI1BH()e npOCJ1}'ll1I1Bal-me paJrOBOpOB
(n.lI<I ICT.6.n.3cT 17)
npocnYllll1BaHl1e TeJleOHHbIX neperoBo-
pOB 11 I1HblX neperOBOpOB (n ..i» CT 6)
2_3, CJlyxQBOfillOHTpOi1b In. 13 cr S\
2_4. CHJlTHe HHOp"'aLlHI1 C TeXHH<leCHJX
KaHaJlOBCBSl311 (n. II <I I CT. 6)
CHSlTl1e I'IH4>OpMilUI1I1 C KaHaJI()B Ce.ll311
(n 9<1. I CT 8)
CHSlTl1e I'IHi»OpMaUI1I1 C TeXHl1<1eCIIHX KII-
HMOBCBil3H (n 14 CT. S)
CHSITHe I'IHi»OpMaUI'II1 C TeXHl1<1eClIl1X Ka-
HMOB CBSl311, KOMnbKnepHblX CHCTeM IJ
I'IHblX TeXHl1'leCKMX cpeIlCTB (a63 S n 3
CT. II)
65
llpooo,J;JKeHuema6il.6
3aKOH KI,lprbl3-
cKofi Pecny6.rU1KM
..06onepaTI1BHO-
P03blcKHOflJleSl-
TeJlbHOCTI1»
3aKoH JIaTBI1HCKoft
Pecny6nl1l1l'1
..06 oneparl1BHoft
lIeSlTeJlbHOCTIf»
3aKOH Pecny6nl1KI1
MOJ1lIOBa
..06 OnepaTlIBHO-
po3blCKHOft JleSl-
TeJ1bHOCTlI»
3aKOH Pecny6nHKH
6eJ1apycb
..06onep"TI1BHO-
po3blCKHOft Jle.ll-
TeflbHOCTI1"
CJ>eJ\epaJIbHblii
3aKOH ..06onepa-
TI'IBHO-p03bICKHOfi
lIe"TeJlbHOCT»
3aKoH YKpaHHbl
..06onepaTI'IBHO-
po3blCKHOft JleSl-
TeJlbHOCTW>
3aKoH Pecny6nHKI1
6eJillpycb
..060nepaTHBHO_
po3blCKHOH JleSl-
TeJlbHOCTH»
3aKoH Pecny6nHKM
KaJaxcTaH
..060nepaTHBHO-
po3blCKHOI'I JleSl-
TeJlbHOCTH"

llpooo,J;JKeHuemafiJl.6
1 2 3
CHSlTHe HHI]>OpMBUHH C TeXHH'IeCKI1X Ka 3aKoH KI,lprbl3-
Ha.rJOBCBSlJI1 (n, II CT. 7) CIIO P<:cny6.rUJKI'I
,,06onepaTI'IBHo-
po3bICKHOH neSl-
T<:11bHOCTH"
OnepaTI'IBH()e n()J1yqeHl'Ie I1HI]>OpMaUHI'I C 3aKoH llaTBI'IcKO
I'ICn011b30BaHIiCM T<:XHWleCKI1K Cp<:j{CTB Pecny6nl1KI1
(n. 10'1 1 CT. 6, n. 2 CT. 17) ,,06 Oneparl'lBHO
j{eSlT.:JbHOCTW>
CnUI'Ia.rJbHbljj KOHlJIO.l1b 3J1eKTpOCBl!3l'1 3aKOHlll'lToBcllofi
(n. 7 n()CTaHOBJIeHI'IJI BepXOBHOTO COBeTa Pecny6nl'lKH
J]l'ITOBCKO Pecny6nl'llll'l o BBClICHl'Il1 " ,,06 OnCpaTI'IBHOH
neikTBl1e 3aKoH3 06 oneparl1BHOH "',- AejIT.:JbHOCT"
Te.l1bH()CTI'I)
CHSlTHe I'IHI]>OpMaUl'I1'I C TeXHI'I'ICCKI1X Ka- 3aKoH Pecny6nI1KI'I
Ha.rJOBCBSlJI1 (n. "T»cT7) Mo.rrAoBa
,,06oncpmIBHO-
po3blCKHOii lleSl-
T11bHocnl»
3 OncpaTHBHo-paJblCKHblC MeponpHATHJ\
1UI""II3TC.IIbI1UCMeTO!\bI
3.1. OnepaTI'IBH()e BHCllPeHl'le (n. ". I cI>encpaJIbHblii
CT. 6) JaXOH ,,060nepa-
THBHO-p03bICKHott
lleSlTJ!bHOCT[f»
OCYlJ..[eCTBJUlTb npOHI1KHOBeHI1C " npc- 3aKOH YxpaMHbl
crynH}'1O rpyn[JY Her.rIDCHoro pa6oTHI'IKa ,,06 OnCpaTHBHO-
onepaTI1BHOrO nonpa31lenCHI1S1 )11160 <0- P03blcKHollneSl-
Tp)'lIHI'I'IalOlJ..[erO C HI'IM mma C coxpaHe- TeJ!bHOCTH»
liMCM B TIlfilie llOCTOBCpliblX 113Hlib!X, Ka-
CalOlJ..[l'IKCSI I'IK J11'1'1HOCT. Yxa3aHHble J1l'1ua
lie Hecyr OT13nCTHCHHOCTM, eCJ!M OHM lIcfI-
CTBOBaJll'I B COCTO.!lHI'II'I He06.\.QDJIMOtl 060-
pOHbl 11111'1 xpaHHefi Hco6xoJll1MOCnl (n. 8
. ICT.8
BHcnpeHl'lc COlJlYllHI1K013 B OpraHI'IJOBaH- 3aKoH P<:cny6nMKI'I
HbIe npecTynHhle rpynnbl l'I xpl'lMMHOreH- 6e.rrapycb
Hble 06'beKTbl (n. 10 CT. S) ,,06onepaTHBHo-
P03blcKHOHlleSl-
TeJlbHOCTH»
66

1 2 3
BHe'!!peHl1e C01PYllHI'IKOB . npecrynHYIO 3aKoH Pecny6nHKH
cpellY (alh. 3 n 2 C1 II) KaJ.axcHUJ
,,060nepanJHHO-
po3blCKHOI'I neSl-
re.bHOCnj"
OnepaTI'IBH()e BHellPel-me (n. 13 CT. 7) 3aKoH Kblprbl3-
CIIO Pecny6.rU'lKI1
,,060nep"TI'IBHO-
po3bICKHOH lle-
TeJIbHOCTlI»
OnepaTi1BH() llcreKTHBHaSilIeSlTeJIbHOCTb 3aKoH llaTBIJHcKoM
C C3HK!!IUI npollypopa npOHlJKHOBeHlJe Pecny6nl1KI1
(npHM()e "'" nereHLIl1pOBaHHoe) . np'- ..06 OnepaTi1BHOM
CT)'flH}'1O CPCllY. ycraHoa.rreHHe C(lSI)H H3- lleSlT'IbHOCT"
XQllSlIUi1Mi1CH Hi! OnepaTI'IBH()M Yljere JII{-
UHI\U'I Ii co CBSlJaHHblMI1 C HI1MI'! JII1UH"'UJ
II. 3eT. 16. n. 8'1.. I CT. 6\
AreHTYPHbli1 !>tCTon (n. 7 nOCraHOBJ1CHHJI 3aKoHlll1ToBclloi1
BepxoBHoro COBeTa 11I1TOIICKOi1 Pecny6- Pecny6nl1KI1
JII'IIII1 0 BBeneH1J11 B nei1cTBl'le 3aKOHa 06 ,,06 OnepaTi1BHOM
onenauIIUJoi1.neI'lTeflbHOCTH .neSlTe}]bHOCT..
3,2, Her.nacH()e BblJlBJIeHl1e " $I1KCaUI'IJl 3aKoH YllpalU-Jbl
CJ1e1l0B TSlXKO.-o npeCTynJ1eH('jH. lIOlIy'>teH- ,,06 OnepaTl'IHHQ-
TOB 11 n.pyri1x npellMeTOB. KOTOpble MOfyr po3bICKH0i1 neSl-
CJ1¥XItTb JlQlla:IaTeJlbCTBaMI1 nQarQTOBKI'I TeJIbHQCTlI»
I'IJli1 C()BepWeHI1.11 TaKOrO npecTYnneHI1
(n.7.. I CT 81
06Hapy;KeHl'Ie, Her.naCI-JaSI $l'IKCaUI1.11 " 3aKoH Pecny6nl{KM
l'IJb.IITMe CJ1e.uOB nponJBOnpaBHblX ne.llHI1H, KaJ.axcnlH
I1X "pUre1JhHOe I1CCJle.uOBaHl1e (a63. 13 «06onepaTI'IBHO-
n. 2 CT. II) po3bICKHOH .ueSl-
TeJ1bHOCTl1»
He npenYCMOTpeHO 3aKoH KhlprblJ-
CKOI1 Pecny6nl1KM
«06onepaTI1BHO-
po3blCKH0l1 neSl-
TenbHOCTI1»
3,3, Ilpl1MeHeHl{e Mo.uenlJ nQBe.aeHI1.11, 3aKOH Pecny6nl{KI{
I1Ml'ITPYlOllien npeCTjlnHYIO neSlTe.llhH()CTb KaJ.aXCTBH
(al:l3. 4n 2CT II) «06onepanJBHO-
po3blCKHOH nef1-
TeJlbHOCHJ»
flpO(J01)KfflUe maan. 6
67

llpooo,J;JKeHuemafiJl.6
I 2 3
He npeJlYCMOTpeHO 3aKoH Kblprbl3-
CKOM P!:cny6nKI{
«06onepan'lBHO-
po3bICKHOH lle-
T!:J1bHOCn'I"
npHMeHeHe MOJlen nOBeJlCHI111. I'IMnl- 3alWHJlI1TOfiCilOM
PYlOmeM npccrynHYIO .u:eSlTCJ1hHOCTb Pecny6nl{KIJ «06
onepaTI1BHOfi llCII-
- Te.%HOCTIJ»
],4, OCYW«:Tl'lIeHl'le nl1'.lHOrO AocMOTpa 3aKoH Pecny6nl'lKI1
3a1lep)!(aHHblX Jll1u. oCMorpa 11 1'13'b,ATH KnaxcTaH
l'IaXOlillumxc npH HI'IX Bewd! 11 JlOKy\teH- «06onepaTIJBHO-
TOB. MorYWrIX OTHOClITbCSI K npecrynHoii po3blCKHOfi lleSl-
AereJ1bHOCTH, a TalGKe llOCM()rpa )l(HJ1h1X TeJlbHOCTIJ»
nOMCWCHI1 pa60'll1x 11 HHblX MeCT .u:oc-
MOlpa TpaHcnOpTHblX cpe.u:CTB (a63. 15 n. 2
cr. II)
He np!:.u:ycMOTpeHO 3aKOH Kblprb!3-
CKOtl Pecny6nl'lKH
«06onCpaTIJIIHO-
P03bICKHO(l.u:CSl-
TeJlbHOCTIJ»
3,5, OnepaTI1BHali npOlJepKa (n. 7 nOCTa- 3axoHJlI{ToBcllol1
H0BJ1eHI111 BepxoBHoro COBera JlI1TOBCIIOfi Pecny6nl1KIJ «06
Pecny6nl1l1l'1 0 BBCllCHl'Il'I II .u:CiiCTBI1C 3a- onepaTI1f1HOif .u:ell-
KOHa 06 onepanlBHofi .u:eHTCJ1bHOCTI'I) TCJ1bHOCH!"
3.6.OnqxmffiHO-.u:CTeK11'lBH35Ib - 3aKoH JlaTBI1CKOif
Kall OTXpb!TaSi. Tax I{ tie3 omarnCHI{S1 npl{- Pccny6nl{KH
Hart!1e)KHOCT K cy6'beKTy onepaTHBHotl llC$I- «06oneparl1BHol1
TeJlbHOCTH no c60PY I1H$opMaIlHH B KjJI1- .u:eSlTr:.,TbHOCT"
MI1H8J1bHOif cpelle. B TOM 'II1CJ1e YCTaHOBJIC-
HH" CBflJH C JlI1W'1MI'I. BblJblBalOll.[I1MI1 one-
pilTI1BHhltlI1HTCpec('I 1,2cr.6)
3,7. Onep1ID1BH()e paccnenoBaHl1e (n. I 'I. I 3aKoH JIaTBI111cKofi
CT. 6. CT. 20) Pecny6nl1KH
..06 ()nepaTl{flH()ij
.u:e$lTeJlbH()CT»
68

1 2
3,8. OnepaTIJHOe HbJI'ICHeH('je nOJl}''I.e-
}me I1H$opMHmm OT mm. eCJJI1 eCTb oc-
JiOBaHHI! nonaraTb, 'lTO JJ,aHHHSI I'IH4JOp"'B-
UHH I1MeeTCSI B pacnop.IDKeHIUI J1I1U. H()
OHM xcnalOT npCllOCTasltTb ee Henocpel1-
CTBeHH() ('I. 4 CT. 9\
4 I ;P:::P;:;
-' "M'"'""' ,",y,",..oM ,apo.,,",
nJlJI CI-mHtli l'IHl)JopMaUl'I1'I C KaI-rnJI0B CBII-
:;D:I::H:'JK;X'I.:;T:) nOJl}''1eHlUl ('jH-
npl1MeHeHlJe cneUlffiJlbHbIX -reXHI1'1.I':CHJX
cpellCTB (alh. 7 n 2 CT. II)
OPM. CB.II.3aHHble C KOHTpOJleM nO'JTOBblX
OTflpalV1eHI1H. TCJ1erpa$HbIX ('j "HLIX CO-
061lleHI1H, npOCi1YWI1BaHl1eM TeJle4>oHHbIX
neperOBopOB c nOllKJ1IO'1eHl1eM II craUl1O-
HapHoti annapaT)'pe npCiUJpl1HTI1f1, Y4PC}!(-
neHl1ii 11 OpraHI1J.aUl'lti He3aBI1CI1MO aT
4>OpM co6CTBeHHOCTI'I, cJm3H'l.eCIlItX It IOpl1-
IlH'1eCKI1X m1U. npell()CTaM.IIIOIUI1X YCJ1YrH
1'1 CpCllCTBH CflSlJl1, npOBOlllITCSI C "CIlO!1b-
30BaHl'leM ooeplTl1BHO-TeXHI1'1.eCKI1X Cpe,llCTB
opraHOB HBUI'IOHaJlbHOH tiC3onacHoCHJ 11
DEll B nopSlllKC. onpeaeJ1HeMOM npBBI'I-
reJlbCTBOM KblprblJCKOH Pecny6nl1KI1 (I,[. 4
cT7)
npl1MeHeHl'Ie MapKl'lpOBKI1 CneW1aJJbHbIMI'I
XItMWJeCllltMI{ I{ lIpyrl1MI{ BeweCT(IaMI{
(n. "0* CT. 6)
4,2, npl{MeHeHl1e cny;Ke6HO-p03bICKHblX
co6aK(a63. II n 2 CT. II)
69
flpO(J01)KfflUe maan. 6
3aKOH lbtTBI{HCKOH
Pecny6nl{KI{
..060nepaTI{BHot!
lIeSlTeJIbHOCT»
3aKOH YKpal{Hbl
..06onepanJBHO-
P03blcKHoHJ\eSl-
TeJlbHOcnl»
3aKoH Pecny6nl{KI{
KnaxcT<1H
..060nepaTHHHO_
po3bICKH0i1 J\eSl-
TC.bHOCnJ»
3aKoH KbIprbl3
cKoii Pecny6JIHKI'I
..06 OnepaTI'IHHO-
po3bICKH0i1 J\eSl-
TeJIbHOCHJ»
3aKOH Pecny6nl'lKI1
MOJIlI06a
..06 onepaTHHHo-
P03bICKHoiiJ\eSl-
TeJIbHOCHJ"
3aKoH Pecny6nma'l
KaJaXCTaH
..06onepanJBHO-
P03blcKHoiiJ\eSl-
TeJ1bHOCTIt»

OKOII'laHUe marin. 6
1 2 3
He npenycMoTpeHO 3aKoH Kblprbl3-
CKO PecnyijJU'lKl'I
,,060nepaTIIIBHO-
po3blCKHOI'I neSl-
TI:.blIOCTI1>'
OnepaTl'IBH()e n03HBHl'Ie coop l'IH4J()P 3aKoH JlBTBl'ICKOI'I
MBUl'll'l 0 KOHKpeTHb.!X nl'luax In 3" 3 PCCny6J1l'1l1l'1
CT. 9) ...06 oneparl1BHol'I
.neSlTeJlbHOCTIf"
- - -  -
OPl\l npeJQ'cMBTpIlB81OTCH CJleJQ'IOJllIIMII CT.3.TbIlMH 33I<OHOB,
CTarbSi 6 4IellepaJ1bH()rO JBKOHa POCCI'ICIIO 4Iellepaul'll'l ,,06 one-
paTIIIHHo-pOJbICKHOfineSlTeJ1bHocTl'I"
CTaTbSl 8 3aKOHa YKpal1Hbl "06 onepan:!BHO-p03bICKH()fj .neIlTeJlb-
HOCT1'I".
CraTWI 5 3aKOHB Pecny6J1I{K1'I 6eJ1BPYCb ,,06 onepaTI:!BHO-p03blcKHol'I
neSlTeJlbHOCTl'I".
CTIlTb!I 11 JaIlOHa Pe<:n)'fumK Ka:nxcr.::IH ..o6onepamBHo-po3bICIlHOii
Ae.lITeJlbHOCT"
CTaTbSl 7 3aKoHli Kblprb!3CKoli Pecny6JU'lKl'I ,,06 onepaTI'IBHO-
P03blcKHofj.ne.lITenbHOCT1'I".
CTarbSi 6 3alloHB JlaTB1'Ii1CIIOi1 Pecny6J1l'1l1l'1 ..06 onepaTHBHoHneSl-
Te.llbHOCTI1
CTarbSi 6 38KOH8 JlI1TOBCKO Pecny6J1I1Kl'I ,,06 onepanJBHOH neSl-
TeJlbHOCTI1...
CraTWI 6 3aKOHB PecnYOJlI'IKH MWUloBa ..00 ()nepaTl'IBHo-po3b1CKH()fj
neSlTeJ1bHOCTH...

Ta6J1l'1ua 7
Co1lllVlbHall1'1 l1J!aBOBBIIJaIlUITBJ\O:DKI!IXT1Ibt'1[JlUItOprBHOB,
ocyIIIeCIWUIIOWJR onepBTHBHO-pB:JUa\I\)1O lleSITeJlbHOCTI>.
I1J!Cll.VCMOTpeHHBH JBKOHOLlBTeJlbHWMH aKTaMH. pernaMft'l11lllYlOllH OPD
B cTpaHax CHI' H 6annuI
]V,
.",
floIOJlCf'HUR. Kl1Cl1J()ueCR Cl1!jUtL1bHOU U npu-
BOIIOU 3Ul/iumbl {kn"l/CliOCmHblX .Utj Opl1HQ6.
ocY'4eCm6.'111/QUX OPJ1.
-J-
I
()q:JeI:teJ:I H enpaooool'O nO!lOJlleHUSI.;J,o'iDKJIOCT-
UbIK_-'HUOJ]r3}lllll.OPD
COTPYllHHKH vpraHvB, ocywecTBJlHfOWHK
OPD. npH I'Icn()J]HeHHH CJ1}')KeGHblx vGHJaH-
HvcTeH HMRWTCR npeliCTaBI1Te.HMI1 BJlaCTH
('] HIl'tQJUlTCSI nOil JLlu.unofi rOCYllBpcTBa Ha
HHK pacnpocTpaHHfOTcSI rapaHTH npaHOBoit
11 COUHa.rJbHOH JaWI'ITbl paGoTHI1KOB MI1HH-
cTepcTe 11 BellOMCTB, B wraTbl K010pbIX OHH
BXQi\HT. C Y4eroM I:neUHI1KH pa60TbI 1:0-
Tpy!lHI'IKH vpraHOB, 0CYWCCTI1J1HIQWHX OPD,
raf.bl 1"::.;bI ll()nOJlHHTe:JbHbIMH
Ha IlOJl)l(HOCTHblX JlI1U opr"Hoe. oc:ywecTB-
J1HfOIllHK OPD, pacnpocTpaHHfQTCSI rapaHTHH
COUHa.rJbHOH H npaBOBOH JalllHTbl COTPYIlHH-
: :.e:;p;:::; {.T\01OPbIX YKa3aH-
Do.'I)I(HOCTHble J1I'1U" Cy6beKTOB OnepaTI'IBH()H
!leSlTCJIbHOCTH HIlXOiUlTCSI nOl! JBIllHTOfi rocy-
napcTBa H HMelOT YCTaH()BJ1eHHble JaKOH()!>I
npaBoBble 1'1 COUHa.rJbHble rapaHTH(,] Ywep6.
npl1'1l1HeHHblfi HMywecTBY .nomKHocTHOro
J1l1ua C}WKTa onepaTHBHOH !leSlTC.'IbHOCTIf
111m 6J1I1JKHX era pOllCTBCHHHKOB II CBSlJH co
cJlY)l(e6HoH lleSlTeJIbHOCTbJO naHH()rO .nOJl)l(-
HOCTHoro Jll1ua, nO.nneJKHT HQ3MemeHHfO H
nOJlHOM o6beMe HJ CpClICTB rocy.napcTBeHHO-
roGfO.1JKera ('I. 2 CT. 28\
PacnpocTpaHeHHe Ha cOTpyaHHKoB onepaTHB.
I UbiX 1101lJlaJIleJ1eHHit JlbrOT. YCTaHOB.l1eHHblJ  I
VIR COTPYlll1HKOB BI:/IiOMCIII3, rIle IJIyHKwIoIIK-
IO\eTfIIIt'DaT1IlIlIbliiannaDaT
71
HOU'>IeH06t/HUe
3UKoHodumeAbHblx
l1Km08,pe?,1U-
MeHmupylOUJ,ux
OP.o
3
3aKOH Pecny6-
J1I1KI'I KaJLlXCTLIH
06 ()nepaTHB-
HO-POJbICIlHOH
!leSlTeJlbHOCTH
3aKOH Kblprb13-
CI'OU Pecnyw1I1KH
06 ()nepaTHB-
H()-pOJblCKH()H
lleHTeJ\bHOCTH»
3aKOH
]IaTBHi'iCKoii
Pecny6JmKH
06 ()nepaTHB-
HOM JleJ1TeJlbHO-
CTH»

llp0OOn;JKI!Hue mUM. 7
I 2 3
Ha llomKHOCTHblX ]]HU ()praH()B. ()cyweCTB- IJ>enepa.rrbHbIH
J1HfOWHX opn, pacnpocTpaHHKITCSI rapaHTHIi 3allOH ..06 one-
COllHaJ1bHOii H npaBOBoti JaWHTbl cOTpy.r:aiH- paTHHHo-
KOB rex opraHoB, B UlTaTbl KOTOpblX YK3JaH- P03b1CKH()f1Ae.ll-
HbleJlHlla BXOlUlT ('I ,,, 16) TeJlbH()CTW>
Ha pa6OTHHKOH, ocyweCTIJJ1HfOWHX GPn, pac- 3aKOH YllpaHHbl
I1pOC'1]);-lHJlKITCSI rapaHTHH npaliOOOfl H COlll'I- ..060nepaTHB-
aJlbHOf1 3aWTbI. npe.nYCMoTjJeHHble JaKOHaMI1 HO-pOJblCIIH()f1
YllpaHHbl 06 3T1fX opraHaX (,; I CT. 12) DCSlTCJlbHOCTH»
Ha DomKHOCTHblX l1Hll opr"HOB, OCYW!:CTB- 3aKOH P!:cnv6-
n.llfOlUHX Opn, pacnpoCTpaHJiIOTCSI rapaHTHI1 JlHKIi fieJl3pYcb
npaBoBoH 11 COUHaJlbH()W JaIUlfTbl COTPYllHH- ..06 ()nepaTHB-
KOB Tex opraHOB, " WTaTbI KOTOPb!X 0"" HO-POJbICIlHOti
!JXOllHT('I. I CT. 16) lIe!lTeJlbHOCTH
Ha 1I0Jl)KHOCTHbIX ]]HU ()pn1H()B, ()cyweCTB- 3aKoH Pecnv6-
J1HfOllIHX opn, pacnpocTpaHSIIOTCSI rapaHTHIi l1HIlIfMOJ1Ba
np"IJOBOH H COUHW1.bHOH 3alllHTbI COTPYllHH- ..060nepaTHB-
KOB Tex ()praH()B, " wnnbI KOTOPb!X 0"" H()-pOJbICIIH()f1
BXOllSlT('I Ie, 14) DeSlTeJlbH()CTH
3 JanpeT Ha I!MeUI8"re/1IoC BlleHTeJ]bHOCTh co-
- ::K::=:;'B:=::;a:b[!: IJ>elIepaJIbHblH
lIeticTB(']H 1I0Jl}((HOCTHb!X 111fL! opraHOB, ocy- JaKOH ..06 one-
WecTBJ1JilOlliHX OPR Ja I1CKJllO'IeH(']eM ]]HU, paTHBHo-poJb!CK-
nplll>!() ynoJlH()MO'leHHblx Ha TO IJ>ellepaJIb- H()HDeJiTeJ1bH()-
HblM 3BKOHOM ('I 2e, 16) CTW>
HHKTO He BnpaBe BMeWI1BaTbC.II. B 3aKOHHble 3aKOH Pecnv6-
llef1cTBI1.11 AO}]}((HOCTHblX '"u " opraHoB, l1H1l1f fieJl3pYcb
OCYWCCTBJlJifOllIHX DPlL " HCKJllO'1CHHeM ..06 ()nCpaTHB-
J1HL!, npAMO ynoJlH()M()4eHHbIX Ita TO J3KO- H0-POJbICIIH()ti
"OM 'IlcT.IS) lIeSlTeJlbHOCTH
HI1KTO IIpOMe JlI1U, npHMO ynoJlHOMO'leHHblX 3aKOH Pecnv6-
Ha TO 3aKOHOM. He BnpaBe BMeWIfB-fIbCSI J1HKI1 KaaaXc"TBH
3aKOHHble Del1CTBl1i1 CUT'lIHI1KOB H upr"HoB. ..06onepaTI1B-
ocyweCTBJ1JilOWIiX OPIt (n 3 'I. I CT. 22) HO-pOJblCKH()f1
DeSlTeJlbH()CTH"
HHKTO He BnpaBe BMeWI1BflTbC.II. B 3.3.KOHHble 3aKOH Kblprbl3-
lIef1cTBI1.11 llO}J}((HOCTHblX n"u " opraHOB, CKOti PecnyoomKI1
ocywecTBJlSlfOlUHX Opn, " I1CKJllO'leH(']el>! ..06 ()nepaTHB-
nl1L!, npllMo ynOJlHOM04eHHbiX HB TO 3aKO- HO-pOJbICIIHOti
HOM ('I lCT. 19) lleSlreJlbHOCTI1
72

I 2 3
HlJKTO He lUtee-r "paBa BMeWI1BaTbCf1 B one- 3aKOH
paTIfDHYro neSrreJlbHOCTb cyG'beKTOB onepa- J1aTBI1HcKOH
THBHOH DCHH:)1bHOCTH 11 DO!1}1(HOCTHbIX J1IJU. PecnyijJIHKIi
I1cK.lnO'leI-1I1e npellCTaBJISlJOT ()co60 yno.llHo- .06 ()nepaTHB-
MO'1eHHble 33KOHO'" JlI1U3, ocyweCTBI1JUowe HOHlleJlH:J1b-
:no B yt."'To1.HOBJ1eHH()M 3aKOH()M nupruu::e HOCTH9
In 4C1 281
HI'IKTO He BnpaBe eMeWHBilTbC.II B 3aKOHHble 3aKOH Pecnv6-
lICliCTIJI1J1 nOJl)KHOCTHblX nHU H opraHoB, J1HIIH MO!1nDa
ocYllIeCTlJiHllOllll1X OPI1, " HCKJHO'leHlJeM .060nepaTl1B-
mm np.llM() ynoJlH()M()'leHHblX Ha TO JaKOHOM H()-P03bICIIH()fj
2 CT. 14 .ueSlTeJ1bHQCTW>
4 CneUH4rnKa 1I011'lHlfeHHOC'TH CUIJIYllHIIIWB op.
- raHOB oe Il{eC'I1IJ]HIOII1HXOPIl
DO)])KHOCTH()e n\Uo, ynOJ1HOM04elmoe  IJ>e.nepaJIbHbIH
oCYllleCTl1J1eHHe OPl1. " XOlle npOBe.aeHIHI 3allOH ..06 one-
OPM [J()ll'IHH.IIerCSI TOJ1bKO HenocpellCTBeH- panlBHO-
HOMY H npSlMOMY Ha'laJ1bHHKY npH nOJlY'1e- pOJbICIIHOH.ueH-
HHH npHK"aa 111111 YKa:JaHI1S1. np01I1BOpe'la- TeJ1bHOCTH"
lliHX J.aKOHY. YKaJaHl-j()e llO!])KHOCTHoe J1HU()
06113aHo PYKOBOJl,CTBOBaTbCSI 3aKOHOM (t,[. 3
CT. 16)
LlOJUKHOCTHoe JlI1LlO, ynOJIHO»tO'leHHOe H' 3aKOH Pecnv6-
ocyweCTBJ1eHl1e OP,lJ" " XOlle npOBelleHI'I.I1 JlI1I1I1 Eiem'pYcb
OPM nQlJ,'1l1HJ1eTCSI TOJIbKQ Henocpe1lCTBeH- <060nepaTI1B-
HO»ty 11 npHMOMY Ha'laJIbHI1K) IlpI'! nOJly<1e- HO-p03b1CKH()fj
HHH npl'lKB3a HnH }'K3J3H111J. npOTlfflOpe'la- neJHe!1bHOCTW>
WIfX 3aKOHY, YKaJaHHoe .QOJDI(HOCTHOe nl1LlO
06H3aHO pvKOBOllC"filOBmbCJI 3allOHOM, a eCJII1
y Hero I1MelOTCH OCHOB3HI1J1 nQ!181<1Tb, '1TO B
peJyJ1bTBTe I1CnOJ1HeHI1J1 npma133 I1JII{ Ylla3a-
HI1J1 MOJKer 11J111 MorJlO 6blTb COBepweHQ npe-
Cl)'nJleHl1e. Coo6WI1Tb ()6 3TOM B BblweCTOSl-
llil1Honl<lHI1J1I1 nIJOI\VOODV('1 3 CT. 151 3aKoH Kblpn;;;-
,lJ,oJlJKHOCTH()e nl1U(), ynonHOMO'1eHHoe 
ocyweCTllJ1eHl1e opn, " XOlle npOael]eHWI CK{ui Pecnyruml<H
OPM n01l'll1HSleTCJI TOJ1bKO HenocpeilCTBeH- 06 onepaTI1B-
H()MY 11 npSlMOMY H3'1a.rJbHI'IKY. IlpH nOJ1y<1e- HO-p03b1CIIH()H
HHH npl1l<fI3a 11J111 YKfI3aHI1J1. npOTI1BQpe48- lIeSlre!1bHOCTl1
lliHX JaKOHY, YKaJaHH()e nOn>KHOCTHOe J1HLl()
06S13aHO pyKOBOllCTaOB3TbCJI J3KOHOM
IJ. 3eT. 19
flpoiJoVKeHue maan. 7
73

B xO.l\e MepOnplUITlill OnepaTliHHOH .IleSITelIb-
HOCTM AOJ1>KHOCTHble mm8 OO'beKTOB Onep8-
TMBHOH !leSiTelIbHOCTM nOLl"lIiHeHbI TOlIbKO
3aKOHY Ii CBOeM)' HenOCpellCTBeHH()MY H8-
'UlfIbHIiIlY EClIl'I 3al1aHl'Ie 1iJ11i pacnopH)I{CHlie
npOTliBope.t1'IT 3aKOHY, .nO}])KHOCTHOe 11IiUO
00Sl3aHO PYKOBOllCTBOBaTbCH TpeOOBaHI1HMIi
38KOH8. EClm B pe3Y11bT8Te BblnOJ1HeHIiSi 3a-
MHIiSi rum pacn()pH>KeHIiSi MO)l{eT 6blTb CO-
BepweHO npecry!1.;IeHlie, 1I01I)I{HOCTHoe JIIiUO
06S13aHO He3aMelIJ1I1TenbHO COOOlIll1Tb 00
3TOM BblweCTOSlweM)' Ha'laJlbHIiIlY IiJlI1 npo-
Kvnonv (OJ_ 3eT. 28
J],OJI)I{HOCTHoe JIIJUQ, ynOJ1HOM04eHHoe tlli
ocymecTBJleHlie OPLl, B XO.llf npOBelleHIiJi
OPM nOll"lIiHSleTCSI TOJIbKO PYKOBOlllJTeJIJO
3TI'IX MepOnpliSlTfI ('I. 3 CT. 14)
npeJl,ocr3BlIeHHe lInmR11UC111b1M JIHII3.M opra.
HOB, OqWecTBJIHlOlIIHX OP.lJ., llIICKpfIIJIOHI1b1J
nOlIBOMO'1Hii
npl'l JaIUMTe >KIDHI1 11 31l0poBbSi rpa)l(1!aH, I1X
KOHCT1)'LWlOHHbIX npaB Ii 3aKOHHbiX IiHTepe-
COB, 8 TaICKe JlJ1S1 06eCne'JeHIiSi 6e30rIaCH()CTI'I
06lI1eCT!la 1'1 rOCYllapCT!la or npecrynHb!X no-
CSlr8TeJ1hCTB llOnYCKaeTCSI BblHY)l(,l],f:HHoe npli-
'1I1HeHI1e Bpe1l8 npaBOU'ijJilHIJTeJ1bHblM IJHTe-
peC8M .IlOJ1>KHOCTHb!M 1I1'IL!O},t OpraHa, oC}'me-
CTBlISIlOlIlero OP.lJ., 111160 11IiUOM, OKa3bJDaJO-
WHM eMY CO!!dICTlllie. cOBepwaeMOC:: npl'l
npaBOMepHOM BblnOJlHeHl111 )'KaJaHHblM JlI1-
L!OM cooero CJI}')Kc6HOrO ('JJI('J 06mecTBeHHoro
.nonra I;/.4eT. 161
He Hecer HHOCT('J pa601HI'IK onepa-
TIiHHoro nOJJ.Pa:)1!eJIeHIiH. KOTOpblH npl'l"lIiHIJ/1
Bpell npaBat, CB06QnaM '1eJl()BeIl8. IJHTepeca"
rOCY.IlapLTBa eo BpeMH ocymecTBJ1eHIiJI OP.lJ..
HaxOlUlCb B COCTOHHIJI1 HOO6XOJIIIMOH 06opo-
Hbl, KpaiiHeii Heo6xo.uliMOCTIII 1J/11'1 npo<fJec-
CliOHWIbHOro pliCKa, 8 TaICKe B CBSl31J C 38-
Jjep)l{8HlieM JII1L!8, B Jjet1CTBHm( KOToporo CCTb
nn.BHaKIi nnecT\ll1neHIiSi '1.4 CT. Iii
74
flpoiJoVKeHue maan. 7
3aKoHJ1anmH-
CKm1 Pecnyfi.'IIiKH
060nepaTIi13-
Hof1AeSlTeJ1b-
HOCTH
3aKOH Pecny6-
111i1l1i MOJlllOBa
06 ()nepaTIJ13-
HO-p03bII:IIHOH
DeSlTeJIbH()CTM
q,eDeparrbHb
3allOH «06 one-
paTI'IBHO-
P03bICIIHOH.DeII-
TeJIbHOCTIi
38KOH YKpalJHbI
060nepaTIiB-
HO-p03bICIIHOH
lIeSlTeJlbHOCTIi

I 1
npH 3ailll'lTe )KH3HH 11 31lOpOBbll rpa;KJJaH. HX
KOHCTHTYUHOHHblX npaB H 33KOHHblX HHTe-
p<:COB, a TBK)I(C llJ1J1 05eCneLJeHHII 6c30nac-
HOCTI'I o6!UeCTB<1 H rocynapcm3 aT npccryn-
HblX nOCllraTbCTB .DOnyCKacTCJI BbIHY;KJJ,eH-
I-Ioe npl1'1l1HCHHe BpeliB npaROoxpaHIICMbIII1
HHn:peCBM .I\O;:[)KHOCTHbIM 1111LlOM opraH8,
OCYllIeCTlIJ1l1lOlJ..lefO OPIt 111160 JII1UOM, OKa-
3bIBaIOIlU'I},t eMY COJlfi1I:TBHe, COBepurne"loe
"PH npaeOMepHOM BblnO.llHeHl111 }'K3.31HHblM
111100111 CBoem CJlY>Ke6H()rO l1iU'l ()6weCTBeH-
I -IoroDo.ra('1.4CT. 191
I e::::He"I:=:::IX nbroT WTaT-
BpeMJI HblnQJ1HeHI1J1l1OmKHOCTHb!MI111l1lta"IH
opraHOB, OCYllleCTBJUllOllll1X OPll, cneUH-
aJlbHb!X 33J1aHHf1 H OpraHI130I1BHHb!X npe-
crynHblX .-pynnax, a TBK)I(e BpeMSI I1X CJ1Y)K6bl
B .l\O!1JKHOCTIIX IUTBTHhlX HefJIBCHblX C01PYll-
HHKOB YK"aaHHbIX opraHOB n01lJ1e)!(I1T 3a'teTY
B BblCJ1yry JIeT Mil I-Ja3Ha'JeHI-m neHCHH B
JIbrOTH()M I1C'IHCJ1eHI1I1 B n()pMKe. ()npelle-
JIHeM()M npaBI'ITe!1bCTBOM POCCl'IHCIIOH tDe-
- :I1blO::H: JlOJ1)KHOCTHb!MH J1IUlB\tH
OPTaHOB, OCYIllCCTBJUllOllll1X QPll, cnCUH-
RJ1bHb!X 3aJ:\BHHf1 H OpraHI130I1BHHb!X npe-
crynHblx .-pynnax, II T.(KA(e BpeMSI HX CJ1Y)K6bl
B .l\OmKHOCTI1X IUTaTHblX Herl1acHblX COTPY.l\-
HHIIOB YK"3aHHblX opraHOB nOnne)!(I1T :.m..eTY
B ebJCJ1Yry neT nnSi HaJHa..eHI1JI neHCHH B
nbrOTH()M HCIJHCJ1eHI1I1 8 nop.llllKe. ()npelle-
:H .a;eJ1TBOM KblprblJCKOif Pec-
7nIIHD,Ono.1HHTe;lb.
HbiX n..rOT COTpYD,IIHKaM onepaTHBHblX 110.1\.
- ::':CYD,apCTBeHH()H MaCTIII Cy6beKTOB
F'OCCHJ:!CKOJ:! <toeJIepaUl111 11 ()praHbl MeCTH()rO
caMoyl1paWleHIUI enpaBe YCTaHaOJ1I1Ban D,()-
nOnHHTeJl..Hble 81tllbl COUl1an..HoJ:! JalUl1Tbl
::)!(.aT.1X6 IpraH()B, ()CyweCTB-
75
flpoiJoVKeHue maan. 7
3
JaKoH KblprblJ-
CKOH Pecnyti'lHKI1
06 ()nepaTHB-
Ho-p03b1CIIHOH
.l\eSlTeJlbH()CTW>
<toellepa.rJbHblH
JBIIOH 06 one-
paTIIIHH()-
P03bII:IIHOHl\fJl-
TeJlbHOCTH"
3aKOH Kblprbl3-
1:K0i1 PecnyrumKI'I
060nepaTHB-
HO-POJbICIlHOH
.l\eSlTeJ1bHOCTH
<toe.nepaJ1bHblll
3aIlOH..06one-
paTI1BHO-
pOJbJCKH()f1l\f.ll-
TeJlbH()CTW>

He npe.aycMoTj)eHo
Pa60THKaM, OCyrueCTBI1HlOllUl\. OPD" npelloc-
TaBl1S1KlTCSll!onOJlHrrreJ1bHble JIbrOTbl B eonpo-
cax COUl'larJbHO-Gb!TOeoro 11 <fJl'lHaHCOBoro
ooe<:ne4eHI1J1 B IJOpAA"f, \lCTdHOOUeHHOM Ka-
6I1HeTO1 MI1HOC1POB YIII1Hbl ('I 3 CT 12)
8 TlpaBo cOTpyaHHKoB onepaTHBHblX IJ().'IIJame.
_eH"iillaOOeCne'leHHeJlH'IlIoii{je:lOnacllocrn
npl1 H8JlI1'11111 llaHHblX 06 yrpo3C )K113HI1,
31lOpOBbJO 11J111 I1MywecTBY pafioTHI1Ka 11 ero
UJllJ3KI1X p01lCTBeHHI1KOB B CBSl311 C ocywecT-
BJ1eHl1eM 11M OP)], B HTepecax 6e30naCHO-
CT Ykpal1Hb! I1nl1 no packpblTl110 TfI)KKOrO
npecry[]!leHI1J1 lJJII1 pBcKpblnno opraHl130-
BaHHOH npecrynH()W rpynnb! ()nepaTI1BHOe
nOJqJB31leJIeHI1e 00Sl3aHO npl1HJ1Tb CnCUI18J1b-
Hble "tepbl no ()6eCne'leHI1IO ero 6C30naCHO-
CT - 113MeHeHI11O 1l8HHbIX 0 JILle, Ma-ra
JKI1Tt:J1bCTBa, pa60Tb!, Y4e6bl 11 IIp)TI1X B no-
p}[1lKe, ()npe1leJ1J1eMOM Kafil1HeTOM MI1HI1CT-
POI1Y"l<II1Hbl ('I. 3 CT. 12)
OPM, o6ecne411BalOume cooCTBeHHYIO 6e30-
naCH()CTb OBB, npOBOlUlTCH 11 nup}[1lKe, npe-
llYcMOTpeHH()M 3aKOHOllaTe!lbHbIMI1 8KTal\.tI1
Kblprbl3clloii Pecny6JII1I1I1 ('I 6 CT 9)
9 He1lOn}'crnMocTb J.aHHTIIH nOJlHTII'K'C':KOii .neR_
re;lbHOCTblO .IlJlH COTpy.nHHKOB onepaTIIBHI>IX
_I JI:;e6HOii llCHTt:nbHOCTI'I COTPY.n-
HI1I1I1 OprBH()B, OCYWCCTBJIJlIOWI1X OP)]" PY-
KOElOl«:TBYIOTCSI Tpe60BaHlliIMI1 3aKOHa 11 He
CBSl3aHbi C peWeHI1HMI1 nOJ1I1TIII'IeCIII1X nap-
Tf1 11 MaCC()BbIX 06wecTBeHHblx llBI1>KeHI1f1,
[]peCJIe.llYIOWI1Xn0J1I1T'1eClIl1eUe)]11 (n.2 '1.1
cT22)
76
llp000n;JKI!Huema6il.7
3aKOH Kblprbl3-
CKOH Pecny6nlJKI'I
.00 ()nepaTHB-
HO-p03bICIIHOH
llCSlTeJIbH()CTH"
3aKoH YKpaHHb!
.06 onepaTHB-
H()-P03b!CIIH()f1
lIeSlTeJ1bHOCTI1
3aKOH YKpal1HbI
.06 ()TTepaTHB-
HO-P03bICIlHOH
llCSlTeJIbH()CTH"
3aKOH Kblprbl3-
CKmt PecnyoJWIKI'I
.000nepaTI1B-
HO-p03bICIIHOH
llCSlTeJIbHOCTH"
3aKOH Pecnv6-
JlI1KH Ka3axc"TBH
.00 ()nepaTHB-
HO-po:JbICIIHOH
llCSlTeJIbH()CTH&

_ 2
OprattaM (no/1)!(HOCTHbIM mmaM), OCyweCTB-
mllOIUHM OPD., J:JnpeIUaeTCW npOBOlll1Tb
OPM B HHTepeC:JX K:JIIOH-J11f60 nOJ1HTH'Ie-
CKOH napmH, 06IUeCTBeHHblX o6belll1HeHHit
11 peJ1IfnlOJHb1X opraHl3aUIfH. JaperHCTpH-
poHaHHblX B YCTaHOB!1eHHOM H"OHOM no-
pSl1lKe. C UeJ1blO OKaJaHI1J1 BJ1HJlHHJI Ha xa-
paJITepl1XlleSlTeJlbHOCTH ('I. 6CT 9)
to BOJJlO>KeHlleliaPYK08O.l(ItTeJlJlopraHa.OQIUe-
CTBJlIIKllltero OP./J, 06,uaHIIOCTb 06eCnC'lIIBaTb
6cJOnacllocTbITOLl'lHHeHHbIXCMYCOTpylltlHKoB
PyKoBollHrenl1 upr:JHoB. OCYlUeCTBJlJllOlUHX
OPD. 05S1JaHbl ()5eCne'1HBaTb JlI1'1HylO 6e30-
naCHOCTb, coxpaHHOCTb I1MYlUeCTBa CBOMX
COTPYllHHKOB, '1J1eHOB I1X ceMel1 11 finH3KHX
p01lCTBeHH(']KOB (n. 4 'I I CT. 22)
He npellYcMOTpeH()
----..- flpaBo COTpy.nHHtlOB opralloB, OCYUJ,CCTBJlI!KI.
lI,"xOP./J.llaOIIan"HYI0110IlrOTOB.
KY. nOBblweHHe KBa:lHl2)HtlaHII. I\ICJ\IIUIIIICIIOI
....",.......,
B uenJlx HaLlJle)Kamero BblnOJlHeHHJI CJlY-
>Ke5HblX ()6S1JaHHocrej.j cOTpynHHlloB opra-
HOB. OCYUJ,eCTBJHlIOUJ,HX OP./J, COJJ];UOTCSI
YCJlODI1.11. HeOOxollH"tble llJIJI nOJlY'JeHHJI cne-
(l(']8.."IbHOH npo41eccIfOH8J1bHOH nOJJ.rOTOI1I1H,
nOl1bllUeHI1.11 KD8J1lf4JI1KaUMH If llJIl! Melllt-
UItHCKOrO 06CJ1}')KHB3.HI1J1 (n. 5 'I. I CT. 22)
He npellYCMOTpeHO
77
OKOH'lOHUf! mOM. 7
3aKOH Kblprbl3-
CKOH Pecny6J1HKH
.06 ()nepaTHB-
HO-pOJbICIlHOH
lleIlTeJlbHOCTH
3aKOH Pecnv6-
11I1KH KaJaXT3.H
.060nepaTHB-
HO-pOJblCKH()fj
neSlTeJlbH()CTM"
3aKoH Kblprbl3-
CKOH PccnyijJIHKH
.06 ()nepaTHB-
HO-pOJbICIlHOH
llCSlTeJlbH()CTW'
3aKOH Pecnv6-
11I1KH KaJaXT3.H
.06 ()nepaTHB-
HO-pOJbII:IIHOH
llCSlTeJlbH()CTM"
3aKOH Kblprbl3-
CKOii Pecny6J1(JKH
<060nepaTHB-
HO-pOJblCIIH()fj
neaTeJ1bHOCTM

COI!Hft.ilbHYIO II np8BOIIyIO :J.UIUrIy COTjJY.IJ,HIIKOB oprallOB, ocymeCTII-
JlJlIOIllHXOP.lJ.. npeIQ'CMftTpIiBftIOTCJIe;IJ'lOlllHeCTaTbIiJftKOHOB.
CTaTbJI 16 <Dt:llepanbHQfO JaKOlia ..06 onepaTIIIBIl0-p03bICKHOH .ueSl-
TenbHOCTI'I».
CraTbIl123ax:OHaYI<JX1Hbl..06onepa111RHO-poJbICIIHOH
CTaThIi IS 3"1KOHd Pecny6J1I1KH 5e.'lapycb ..06 OnepaTHBHO-pOJbII:KHOH
.ueSlTeJlbH()CTI1».
CTaTbSl 11 3aKoHa PecnyfuJI1II11 KaMlXCTilH ..06 onepaTHBHo-
p03bll:KH()fj Ae.llTeJ1bHOCTI'I»
CraTbSl 19 3aKOHa KblprblJCKOM Pecny6J1I1KI1 ..06 OnepaTI'IBHO-
pOJbJCKH()fj.ne.llTenbHOCTI'I».
CraTbSl 28 3aKOHa J1aTBI'lf1CKOf! PecnyQJll1l111 ..06 onepaTl1BH()H neSl-
Te.llbHOCTiJ».
CTilTbJI 14 3aKoHa Pecny6QI1KI'I MUJUlOBa ..06 ()nepaTI'IBHO-p03bICKHOH
.ueSlTeJlbHQCTI1".

Ta6JIHua8
C01lt'ltcTBHe QlaJK!UIH OnepaTHBHo-pa3I>ICI(I{()fi 1lt'1ITt'nbHOCm,
CIII01)JelIHoe :JIIKOHO;IaTeJlbHblMIt aKTaMlt, pernaMellTllpylOWIIMH OP)],
B cTpaH3x CHI" H 6a:nHH
M
"In
30lA06Ue
----t- _ 2
I YCT3110B:lCHHe KOIIIpIUlftIUHaQbHblX OTHowe
_"HHltanoOpoBOJlbHbIXlta':la.J1ax
OTJ\fJlbHb!C 11ltua MOryT C ItX corl1BC(']1I
npHBJ1CI<8TbClI K nO.1l'-OTOBKC It npOBe.1lC-
Hmo OPM (':I 1 CT. 17)
OmCJlbHb!C nltua MOryT C ItX COrnaCl111
npHBJ1el<ilTbClI K nOllrOTOBKe 11 npOBelle-
Hmo OPM (':I. 2 CT. 13)
OTJ\fJlbHblC 1111ua MOryr C Ii)( COmBCl111
npHBJ1C1I3TbClI K nO.1l'-OTOBKC It npOBe.1le-
Hmo OPM (':I 1 CT. 20)
OnepaTBHaSI !leSlTCJlbHOCTb OCHOBbIB3CTCH
Ha 1l06pOBOJlbH()H .-nacHoi1 Itnlt T3HHOH
nOMOWIt $lt3H':ICCllltX l1ltU (':I 1 CT 5)
OTllenbHble nltua M()ryr C }IX COmaCl111
npHBJ1CKaTbClI K nOllrOTOBKC 11 npOBellC-
Hl'IlOOPM (':I I CT. 15)
HItHan""OCTIoCOTPY,D,llH..eCTBa
I OTJ\fJlbHble nl1ua MOryr C Ii)( COmaCl111
npHBJ1CKaTbClI K nOllrOTOBKe 11 npOBellC-
Hl'IlO OPM C coxpaHeHl1e:\t no ItX JKenaH1110
KOH$HJ:!eHLll1a.J1bHOCTI1 cOllelicTBl111 opra-
HaM, OCYILlCCTWUII01LlI1M OPIt (':I. I CT. 17)
79
HaU'IIet/080HUe
3I1KmIOiJume.J/bHbiX
l1Km06, pe111.ffl-
muJlJ'lOU¥Jx OPjJ
3
IJ>ellCpaJ1bHbIH
3allOH «06 onepa-
TI1BHO-p03blcKH0i1
llCHTCJ1bHOCTH»
3aKoH PccnyQJlI1-
Kit Ka331[CT')H
«06 onepaTI1BHo-
P03b1CKHoJ:!lleSl-
TeJ1bHOCTI1»
3aKoH Kblprbl:'l-
CKOll Pecny6.I1KI1
«06 onepaTI1BHO-
pOJb!CKHoi111ell-
renbHOCTI1»
3allOH J](']TOBCIIOll
PCCny6J1(,]KI1 «06
onep3T(jflHOH J\fH-
TeJlbHOCTI1»
3aKoH PecnyQJlI1
KI1 MO.ll1l0Ba «06
OnCpaTI1BHO-
pOJb!CKHoi111ell-
renbHOCTI1"
IJ>ellepaJ1bHbIH
:'IaKOH .06 ()nepa-
TlteH()-pOJbICKHoi1
lleIlTeJlbHOCTI1"

I 2
OmeJlbHb!e 111m3 MOryr C I1X COrn8CI1.11
npH1!J1CI<3TbCli K l1011fOTOflilC If npOBel!e-
Hmo OPM C coxpaHeHlfeM no I1X }KeJUlHI1K1
KOH$HlleHUIfaJ1bHOCTI'I cOllecTBI1I1 opra-
HaM. OCVlllCCTMJllOllllfM GPn ('i 2 CT. 13)
OT1Ie)l1,HbiC J111W1 MOryr C I1X COIJJaCI1I1
npHBJ1CII!lTbCH K nQlJ,r01OBKe 11 npOl1elle-
Hmo OPM c co\.paHeHtleM no I1X >KeJlaHIfiO
KOH!}1l'1nCHUIfaJ1bHOCTH cOlle£1cTBIfIi opra-
Hat. OC\'llleCTBI1J1IOIllI1M opn (<j 1 CT. J])
OTneJlbHb!e J1lfua MOf:yT C I1X COrJ1BCI1.11
npHBJ1el<aTbC.II K nO!lroToBKe If nporene-
Hmo OPM HB 1I0Hi}mi\eHUI18J1bHOii OCHOBe
('I I CT. IS)
CeKpeTHblJ.UI }"18CTHI1KaMIf onepaTI1BHofi
JleHTeJ1bHOCTI1 II!JlJlIOTCSI ceKPeTHhlC paoOT-
Hl'IlIlf cy6'beKTOB onepaTBHOn neSlTeJlbHO-
CTIf 11 TatiHo COTPYllHI1'IBlOlUMC $I'IJM'-Je-
CKI1eJUJua(<i 2 CT. 4)
3 OfiSIJ8HHOCTb l1H1t, cOlleHCTBylOlltllx OPlI
\naHHTIoTaiiHV
3m nltl!3 06maHhI CQXpaHJlTb II rniiHC CIK:LIC-
HI1.11. CTaBWIfC 11M I13BeCTHblMl'I e xane nQ11ro-
TOBKI'Illi1lf npoBelleHl'ISi OPM ('1. I CT. 17)
Jh1ua, np!1I1JleKaeMbIC K BbinOJIHCHI11O :'Ia-
na'l OP)],. ()OSlJ8Hbl xpal-JlITb TaflHY. CT8B-
wYJO 11M l'IJBeCTHOii PaJrnaWCHIfC :ITOM
TatiHbl BJ1C4CT 3a co6oti OTBnCTl1eHHOCTb
no lleCTBYlOweMY 3aKOH01!aTeJlbCTBY.
KPOMe CJlY'!aeB pa3rJlaWeHlfSi IfH4JopMaUIfI1
o He3aKOHHblJ( lldicTBI'IJlX, IIOTopble H3PY-
W3IQTnOBH!l'le;10BeKa('I. Jcr II)
3TH 111m3 015.113aHbl C()XpaHJlTb B TaHe
CBelleHIfJl. CTaBWlfe IfM 1'13BeCTHbiMif B J(Olle
noarOTOBll1f Wlif npOBeLleHIfJl OPM. Pa3-
maweHlfe :nOH rai1Hbl BJ1e4eI 33 col5OH
OTBeTCTBeHH()CTb. YCTaHOBJ1eHHYJO 3aIlOHO-
naTeJlbCTBOM PeCllyOJll1l11f KaJaxcTaH ('i 2
CT. 13
80
llpo()(u;J(Cl!Hue maM. 8
3
3aKoH PecnyOJlI1
Kif Ka3aXCTBH
..015 onep3TI1BHO-
P03b1CKHotllleSl-
TeJ1bHOCTH&
3aKOH Kblprbl3-
CKoii PecnyOJlI1KIf
..015 ()nepaTI'IBH()-
P03bICIlHOHlieSl-
3aKOH PecnyOJlI1-
1111 M0!11l0Ba
..015 onepaTI1BHO-
P03blcKHoi1lIe.ll-
TeJ1bHOCTI'lj}
3aKOH J]IfTOBCIIOii
Pecny6!1IfKI1 ..015
onepaTlfBHOk neSl-
TCJlbHOCTI'I"
<tJl:.!IepaJ1bHbIH
3aKOH ..015 onepa-
TIfBHO-p03bICKHOtl
lleJlTCJlbHOCTI'I"
3aKOH Yllp3lfHbI
..Ol5onepaTl'leHO-
p03bICIlHOHlieSl-
TeJ1bHOCTI1"
3aKOH PecnyfuJl'IKIf
KaJ3J(CTaH
..015 onepaTI1BHO-
P03bICKHOHJ],eSl-
TeJlbHOCTI1j}

llpo()(u;J(Cl!Hue maM. 8
-' 2 3
3T. n.", 06HJ.aHbl C()XpaHJlTb . TaMHe 3aKOH Kblprbl3-
CBellelUIJ1. CTaOWl1e 11M 1130eCTHbiMif e XOlle CKoii Pecny6J1I1KH
nOllrOTOBll1f IfJlIf npOBelleHIfJl OPM ..06 onepaTI1BHO-
('I. I CT. 20) P03b!CKHoi1llell-
TeJ1bHOCTI1"
06HJ.aHHOCTblO 3Ti1X JlI1U JlBJlJleTCSI coxpa- 3aKoHJTaTBIfM-
HeHl1e B T"i1tre C01py1lHIf'leCTBa 11 Hep3.3- CKofi PecnyOJII1KI1
rnaweHlfe nOJIY'IeHHOH B xOlle Hero HH- ,,06 onepaTBHofi
4>OpMHUI1I1 ('I. 2CT 30) .ne.llTeJIbHOCTi1"
JTI1LlO, trnpYWI1Bwee IIOHt1Jl1lleHLWlH.'IbHOCTb 3aKOH JTI1TOBCKOi1
HJIH aHOHI1MHOCTb ceKpeTHbJX Y'IHCTHI1KOB Pecny6J1IfKIf ,,06
onepaTi1BHoi1 lleJlTI:J1bHOCTIII H I1H4>OpMH- OnepaTl1(1Hok l!CH-
WfH. HeceT OToeTCTBeHHOCTb e COOTeeTCT- renbHOCTi1"
BI1I1 C 3aKOHHMi1 JTIITOBCKOM Pecny6JJ1f1l11
('1_2 CT. II)
3T. nl1ua 06.113aHbl COXpafUlTb . raAHe 3aKOH PecnyOJII1-
CBelleHIf.ll. CTaBWlfe IfM 1f30eCTHbiMif B XOlle KI1 MOJllloaa ,,06
OP.lJ.('l. leT IS) onepaTl18HO-
P03b1CKHoi1.neH-
4- T(:J]bHOCTI1"
06H3aHHoCTb 13m3H'IecKHX JlqQ.u:ofipoooBeCT-
HocOTpy1lHH'IaTb
3T Jll1ua He BnpaBe npellOCTaBJISITb 3aue- <tJl:.!lepMbHblH
1l0MO nmKHYIO l'IH4>opMaUi1JO YKaJaHHbJM 3aKOH ,,06 onepa-
opraHHM ('I. I CT. 17) TI1BHO-pOJbICKHOI:!
.ne.llTenbHOCTi1.
31"11 nl'lua oGSl3aHbI HenpellOCTIlBI1JJTb 3aBe- 3aKoH Pecny6nl1-
1l0MO JlO;KHYJO l'IH4>OpMaUI'lJO YKBJaHHblM Kif Ka3aXCTaH
oprm.reM ], npeAOCTaBlleHl'Ie 3aBellOMO ,,06 OnepaTI'IBH()-
JlO;KHOM I1H4>OpMHUi111 OHI1 Hecyr OTaeTCT- P03b1CKHOH1leSl-
BeHHOCTb, YCTaHOBlleHHYJO 3BKOHO.llareJIb- renbHOCTI'I.
crBOM Pecny6JJlfKIf Ka3a1[eyaH ('I 2 CT. 13)
He onpaoe npellOCraB.'IJlTb 3aBellOMO JlO;K 3aKoH KblprbJ3
HY l'IHt1JopMaUMIO YIlaJ.aHHbIM opraHBM cllol1 PecnyOJII'IlIl'I
('I. I CT. 20) ,,06 OnepaTI'IBH()-
P03blcKHoi11leSl-
renbH()CTI'I»
81

I 1
06J13aHHocTbJO 3TI1X J1IfU JlBJlJlercSi npe!l()C-
TaBJICHl'le cy6'beKTOM OnepaTlfBHOW 1ICJI-
T'jbHOCTIf TOJlbllO npafllllfBOii IfH4JOp}.j3-
wm('I2cT.30)
3T nl1ua He BnpaBe npeIl()CT"BJUITb opra-
HfI).t. OCyweCTBJlJlJOllilfM OF'D,. JaBe.nOMO
JI())KH}'IO I'IH4JOp},t3L!L11O ('I. I CT. 15)
-Snpa80 .j;It:JH"fn.NlX JIHll Ita UplIIJleH"1:
fl"DlOIIlellllA COTOV;tIIH'lt'CTBa KOIITOOXTOIII
OpraHbl. OCYJJJ,eCTBJUllOlJ.!l1e opn. Moryr
3aKJ1IO'ffiTb KOHTpaKTbI C cOBepweHHOJ1er-
HItM" lIeecnoco6HblM('j Jmuam He3aBI1CIf-
MO OT rpaJK.l\aHCTBa, HaUI10HaJ1bHOCTIf. no-
113. I'IMywecTBeHHoro. .nOJUKHoCrHoro 11
COUl'la.!1bHOro nOJlOJKCHI1J1. ()6p"JOBaHI1J1.
npHHa11JIe)KHOCn! K 06meCTBeHHbJM ()Obe-
DlfHeHlfJlM. OTHOlUeHI1J1 II peJ1lfr11 If 00-
1JI1TI1'leCKHxeHIfW{'l.2CT.17)
no }l(CJlHHIfIQ Jli1U If X COTpy!lHW.ecmo C
onepaTI1BHblMIf nO!!p33!leJ1eHI1J1MIf MO)KCT
61>1Tb o$opMJ1eHO nl1CbMeHHblM C0T113ll1e-
.'meM C rapaHTl1p013aH('jcM KOH4mlleHUI1-
aJ1bHOCTI1 COTpyllHI1'1eCTBa
CorniiWeHl1e 0 cCUldiCTB11 onepaTI1HbIM
n0.iLPa:tlIeJ1eHI1IM Opn MO)KeT 6blTb :.m-
KI1lO'1eHO c .neecnoc06Hb!M nIfUOM. nOpSlllOK
3aK.f1JO'IeHIfJl cornaWeHIfJl ()npeJ1eJ1J1eTCSI Ka-
6lfHeTOM MIfHHCTTIOB YKnaHHLI <J I CT. II)
OpraHbl, Ocy!llCCTBJlJIIOWl'lC OP)]" MOryr
J.a1011O'l3Tb l<OtfTpaKTbl C cOllepweHHOJ\eT-
H!l.UI JleeCnOCo6Hb1!1.UI J]('JWlM('J He3aRIllC('J-
MO OT rpaJKJIaHCTt13, H31!('JOHaJIbHOCT('J, no-
113, COLlL1BJ1bHorO, JlOJDKHOCTHOfO 11 I1MY-
meCTBeHHoro n0J10JKeH('J}I, o6p330BaHI1I.
nprIH<I,.1111e)KHOCTrI II 061l.1eCTBeHHb1M 06be-
JlI1HeHI1IM, nOJll1TI1<jeCKI1X 11 pelII1fl103HbIX
y6e)!(J[eHI1H.
(]JopMa KOHrpaKTa, YCJIOBMSI 11 CpOIlH ero
neHCTBMSI onpelleJlSlJOTCSI BellOMCTBeHHblMI1
HOOMaTMBHblMH aKTaMH '1.3 CT 13
82
flpoiJo1.JlW/uemal5.n.8
3
3allOH
J1aTBHWCKOW
Pecny6Jll1KH
..06onepanJBHOH
JleIlTeJ1bHOCTW'
3aKOH Pecny6J1J1KI1
MO.:wOB3
..06 OnepaTI11!HO-
pOJblCKHOi1 neH-
renbHOCTM"
(]Jl:.lIepanbHblfi
3allOH «06 onepa-
TI1BHO-P03bICKHOiJ
neSlTeJlbHOCTI1»
331<OH YllpaHbI
«06 onepaTI1BHO-
pOJb!CIIHO JleSl-
TeJlbHOCTI1»
3aKOH PCcny6J1l1KM
Ka331{C'f3H
..06 onepaTI1BHO-
P03blcKHoiJJleSl-
TeJlbHOCTI1"

1
OpraHb!. ()cy!llCCTBJlJlIOWlfe OP)],. MOryr
J.aKJ1IO'IaTb KOHTpaKTbl C CODCPWCHHOJleT-
HIfMI1 lIccCnOC06Hb1MI1 Jll1uaMIf He:JllBI1CIf-
MO OT rpa;;w,aHCTlJa, HaUl'lOHaJlbHOCTIf. n()-
Jla, I1MYWCCTBCHHoro. .DOJ1>KHOCTHOro 1:1
COUl'l3J1bHoro nOnO;f{eHUI. o6pa]ORaHul.
npHH3J1)1C)KHOCTH II 061l1CCTBCHHb1M o6be-
;:==;;:;. =:: :. e:;r;; If no-
YnOJlH()Mo<lcHHble Ao.ru;HOCTHble I1Ima cyfu.-
eKTOB onepa11tBH()!:\ ne.llTeJ1bHOCTIi I1MCIOT
npaBO Ha OCHOBe 1I06pOBOJIbHOCT If B3aIfM-
HOro 1l0BCjJI'IJI npI'lBJICII1lTb II onepaUIBH()M
nellTeJ1bHOCT B IGI'JeCIDl' CeKpCTHblX no-
MOWHIfIl0511eecnoc06HblX JIIfU 'I. I CT. 30
(hJlfJlbHb!C .I1lll.la Moryr npI1MCK1lTbCSI K
nonroTOlJlle If npOBelleHlf1O OPM, e TOM
'IMCJ1e no KOHTpaKTY ('I. I CT. 17)
OrllcnbHble nHua MUf:yT nplfBJIeKarbCSI K
noarOTOBKe If npOBenCHmo OPM (B TOM
'!l1cne no KOHTpaIlTY) ('I. 2 CT. 13)
4IopMa KOHTpaKTa, YCJlOBHJI 11 CpOll11 ero
nei1cTBwr onpellCJlSlIOTCSI flCllOMCTBCHHbI),UI
HopManJBHblMI1 IIIIT3MI1 '1.3 CT IJ
OTneJlbHb!f' Jllfua MOryr C If X cornac(U1
npHBJ1CKaTbC.II K nOllrOTOBKC If npOBellC-
Hmo OPM c coxpatreHl1c)'! no If X )KCJ11lHIfIO
KOH$l'IJ1eHtllfaJIbHOCTI1 COllel1CTBIUI opra-
),i0i=%M2pn. B TOM T.JIfcJle
O..I<pt'I1{OeCaIpyLlHWJecroo MO)l(CT6bITbOl1Jla-
'WI]!aeMbIM Cr:Kpe1lible 1lOMOUDi111<1'I c I1XCO-
M01)'T npljJIeKrrrbCJI I< on:pmmHoii
JleJrn:I1bHocrn H3OCHOBeJlOroaopa ('I. 3 CT. 30)
Cr:Kp!:THbIM nOMOIl.!HI1KaM. COlpyJ\H('1<I81O-
llLl'IM C Cy6beKTO),t onepaTI1BHOH .r:LeSlTeJlb-
HOCTI1, HB OCHOBe J\o.-oBopa 06r:cne'llJBa-
IOTC}! COLlI1aJ1bHble .-apaHTlJlJ, npeilycMoT-
peHHble 3aKOHOM 11 JlpyrlJ),t11 HOpMaTIJB-
HblMH 8IITaMI1 DJ1f1 J\on)KHOCTHbIX J1I1Ll }"I-
:e:c :'1T;2\ onepaTBHoH J\eSl-
83
flpoiJo1.JlW/uemal5.n.8
3
3al<OH Kblprbl3-
CI<O£1 PecnyOJIl1l111
..06 OnepaTI'IBH()-
P03b1CIIHoHJ\eSl-
TeJ1bHOCTH"
3allOH
JIaTBI1HCI<OH
PecnyfuJl11<11
..06onepanJDHOH
.r:Lr:IITeJIbHOCnj"
<tJl:.!repanbHblH
J3110H ..06 onepa-
'JI1BHO-p03bICKHOll
.r:Le.ll.TeJlbHOCTIJ"
3al<OH Pecny6J111
I<1'IaH
..06 OnepaTI'IDHO-
p03bICKHOHJ\CSI-
TCJ1bHOCTIJ"
3aKOH Kblp.-bl3-
CIlOll Pecny6m1KI1
..06 oneparmlHo-
pOJbICKHOHneil-
renbHOCTIJ"
3aKOH
JIaTBl1iicl<Ofi
Pr:Cny6JUlKI1
..06 onepunlBHoii
D,eSlTeJlbHQcTI'I"

npoiJotl;JKeHUe maM. 8
I 2 J
AIITIfBHaSl, 34J(jJeKTBHaH nOMOWb 4JI'IJIf 3allOH Jh'lTOBCKOH
'leCKI1XJlIfUOnJla'lIfBaeTCH ('I. I CT. 5). Pecny6J1IfKIf ..06
COTpyAHI1'1alOll{e no JJOrOBOpy 1Ilfua 06ec- onepaTI1BHofl J\eSl-
ne'll1BalQTCJI COUlf8J1bHblMI1 rapaHTI1J1MI1 TCJ1bHOCTIII»
'I.2cT5)
OpraHbl. ocyrneCTBJlJlIOWl'le OP,lJ,. MOryT 3aKOH Pecny6JII1-
3aKJ1IO'laTb KOHTpaKTbI C cOBepllJeHHOJIeT- KI'I MO.ll1l0Ba ..06
HIfMIf Aeecnoc06Hb1MIf JlIfUaMIf HC3aBHCI1- OnepaTI1BHO-
MO OT If X rpa;KlW.HCTBa. HaUIfOHaJIbHOCTli, P03b1CKHOHlieSl-
nOJIa. coummbHoro. J\()J])KHOCTHoro H TeJ1bHOCTIi»
IfMywecTBeHHoro n()J]())KeHIfJl, n()JII1Tl1'le-
CKI1X 11 peJllJrl103HbiX y6e)K,I],CHI1H. npI1HarJ,-
Jle)l(HOCTI1 K o6ui:ecTBeHHbiM opraHI1J<1UI1J1M
" 2" 15).
OmeJIbHb!e rpWK,IWHe Moryr nplfBJIeKaTbC.II
K nOllrOTOBKe If npOBeJ\eHIfIO OPM, B TOM
'IIfCJIe 11 no 1I0HI1HKTV ('I. I CT 15)
. IJt-paJupJeIIHeKJIYraIJrn3H'leCKHx .1111!,npH
B,leKaeMblXK CfI1JJY1l HIt 'lfC11j)'
OpraHaM, ocymccTBJlJlIOIlJI1"t OP,lJ" Janpe- 41CllCp8J1bHbIW
maeTCH IfCnOJIb30BaTb KOH$WleHUI18J1bHOe JaKOH ..06 onepa-
cOAecTBHe no KOH"TpaKTY AenyraToe, cY- TlfeHo-p03b1CKHOn
liei-!. npOKypOPOB, 8lIHOKaTOD. CDSlllJeHHO- J\e.llTCJ1bHOCTH»
CJIY;KIITC;JCi1 If n()J]HOMO'lHblX npeACTaBIf-
TeJIeH, ()<2mmfaJIbHO 3aperHcl'pltpoBaHHblx
enlfrHOJHblX 06belllfHeHlfH (<.I. 3 CT. 17)
3anpewaeTcH npI1BJ1eK"Tb K BblnO.l1HeHlf1O 3aKoH YKpmHb!
onepaTHBHO-P03bICIIHbIX Ja,/\a'l MellHl.[I1H- ..06 onepaTI1BHO-
,, pa6OTHI'IKOB, CBHW e HHOCJ1Y)I(I1TeJ1ew, P03b1CIIHOHlieSl-
a1lBOK:lTOB, eC.I11f Jll'IUO no ()THOllJeHIfIO. II TeJ1bHOCTH»
KOTOpOMy OHIf llO.l1>KHbl ocymecTBJlSlTb
OPM. JlBlISleTCJI I1X nalmeHTOM I1J1I1 KJlI1-
CHTOM ('I 4cT. II)
33npeTc.II I1Cn0.l1b30D3Tb 1I0H4JI111eHUI1- 3aKoH Pecny6JII1KH
aJIbH()e cOlleWCTBl1e Ha KOHTpaIlTHoi1 OCHO- l>eJIaPYCb
Be HapOllHbJX llenyraToB, CYAeH, npOKYpO- ..060nepaTI1BH()
POD. 8llBOKaTOB, CBSlI.l.[CHH()CJ1Y}l(I1TeJ1eH P03b!CKHoi1l1eSl-
nO.l1HOMO'1HbIX npeJlcTamrrenefl. ()<2JI1UI1- TeJ1bHOCTIII»
aJIbHO 3apemCTpl'lpOBaHHblX peJIl'Il1fOJHblX
06'bellHHeHIfH ('l. SeT. 9)
84

llpo()(u;J(Cl!Hue maM. 8
I 2 J
Opr:JHaM, ocywecTBJlSllOllU:!),1 OP)]" 3:Jnpe 3aKoH Kblprbl3
waeTCSI I1Cn0J1b30HaTb KOH.pmieHUI13J1bHoe CIlOti Pecny6J1111111
COllel1CTBHe no KOH1]J:JKT)' llenyr:JTOB. 1.)'- ..06 OnepaTI'IDH()-
lIeH. npoKypopoD, UlIlOKdTOB. CBSlweHHO- p03blcKHOHlIeJl-
rnYA<HTeJleH If nOJlHOMO'lHblX npellCT:JDIf- TeJ1bHOCTI'I»
TeJleH, ()<2mmffiJ1bHO 3:Jperc1]JltpoBaHHblX
QeJJI1rl103HbiX 06"bellI1HeHI1i1('I 3 CT 20)
3anpeweHo "PH nOMOilllf MepOnpmrTI1H 3allOH
onepaTI!HOH lIeJlTeJlbHOcnl ueJleHanpal!- l1aTHI1HcKOH
11eHHO nOJ1Y43Tb I1H.pOpM3ID'1lO OT npI1CJI)K- Pecny6JUlKI1
HblX, a1lBOKaTOB, HOTapl1YCOB, npalJeH. ne.na- ..06 onep"TIiBHOH
rorOB, nCI1XOJ1orOI1 H l1)'XOBHb!X 111111 BO DeRTeJlbHOCHI»
BpeMSI ()Ka3aHIfSl HM npoqJecclfoHWIbHOH
nOM0ll.ll1, 33 I1CKIllO'IeHl1eM CJlY43eB, Kor1l3
YK:J3:JHHble 11IfU:J C:JMIf SlBJ1S1IOTCJI 051,eKTIlMI1
onerJaTIiBHoH 0060ThI n.5CT.24)
OpraH3M, ocyweCTBJlJlIOWI1M opn, 3anpe- 3aKoH Pecny6J1I1-
W:JeTCR I1CnOJ1b30BaTb B cBoeM lleSlHJlbH()- KI1 MOJlllOB:J
CTIf KOHltJl1JleHUIiMbHoe cOlleHCTBl1e  ..06 onepaTIfBHo-
KOHTp:JIITHOii OCHOBe nenyraTOB, cyneM. p03b1CKHOM
nnoKvnOIY'B ne.llTeJlbHOCTI1»
7 06R3aHHOCTbJlO>nKIIOCnIbI1[11HIl
- BaTbonraHaM.OC\IltfC"I1IIUIIOIIDftI OP)],
D()}I)KHOCTHble nl1Wl rocynapcrBeHHblX If 3aKoH PecnyfuJl1
ItHblX npe,lJ;.npHTH, )"Jpe)l(1leHI1H, OpraHl133- Kit l)eJillpyCb
W'lH, BOI1HCKI1X 'iacreii B p:JMKaX caoeii KOM- ..06onep:JTI'IBH()-
nereHU111'1 06S133HbI OK:J3blB.1Th co.aetlc1mte p03bICKHOH ne.ll-
oprnl-mM. OC\'wecnvmlOWI1M OPD (cr 16) TCJlbHOCH'I»
)],OJ1)KHOCTHble nH H ""'"'" pa6OTHlfKI'I 3aKoH Pecny6JII1-
I"OcynapCT11eHHblx opraHoB, BflI(MCIB, oprd- KI1Ka38H
HI133I1I'1H Ii )"Jpe>KlleHIfH (HeJaBIfCl'lMO 0' ..06 onep:JTI'IBHO-
$>pM C06cTBeHHOCTI'I). BOiicKOBblX 1JaC'Te1i. p03bICKHOH neil-
Coe){HeHI1H 11 o6wecrHeHHb1x o51,eJJJ'IHeHI1H TeJlbHOCTIII»
Pecny6JJIfKIf K.:ua\C'I3H 06S13:JHbl ()Ka3bIB:JTb
co){euCIl!I-Ie opraH3M, ocyweCTHJ1J1IOWI1M
OP)],. B peweHl11f 3all:J'i. [J)Jl'JIyCNOTpeHHblX
CT. 2 HaCTO}lwero 3aKoH3 'i. I CT. IJ
He npeIlYC),IOTpeHO 3aKOH Kblprbl3-
CKOti Pecny6J1IfIlIf
..06 onepaTIfBHo-
P03b1CIIHOMneSl-
- TeJlbHocrn»
85

I 2 J
8 YCT3HOB'Jfh '" gao.i"'1TOI... Jl;Jp:.."rev" CBeJI,e
JlHii, KacafOUI.IIXCSI KOHII,1CIII,"anbHoro CQ-
oreiiCT8HRHIIHI,/XacI1CKTQIIOPl{ 4Icliepa.rJ
CBelleHS1 06 IfCnOJ1b3ycMb1X WIlt IfC!JOJ1bJO-
IJ.aHHblX npH npOlJellCHIU'l HCr.nacHbIX aPM JallOH ..06 oncpa-
CI.JJIID:. CpeJ1CTBax, Meronal[. IfCTO'lHIfK.aX.. TIfBHO-p03bICKHOn
rJJJaHax 1'1 peJynbTaTa'l: OPD" (I mUkl'<. BHC- .ne.llTeJlbHOCTIf»
npeHHbIX . OpraHIf30BaHHble npecrynHble
rpynnbl. (I WTBTIiblX HemacHblX cOlpy1lHHKaX
opraHoB, ocyw:eCTRI1J1lOumx OP)]" (I JUJuax,
OIla3bIBaIOIlII1XI1),tCOJleHCTI1He JIB KOHIj:JI1-
JJ,eHL!3JlbHOi1 OCHORe, a TaIlJKC 06 opraHH3a-
L11f If (I TaKTHJ<C npOBe!(eHIfJI OPM, COCTBB-
MIlOT rocYlIDp:;TBCHHYIO TaHHy If n()1lI1C)IW.T
pacceKPe'JI1IJaHI1IO TOJIbKO  OCHOIJaHIfIf
nocr.tHOBJICHIfSl PYKOI!QllJfJeMl opraHa, ()cy-
weCTWlIIOLl.lero GPIt ('l I CT. 12 3aKoHP
CBelleHl1fl (I 1IImBX, corpynHlf<JaIOIlUIX 11JU'I
(;0Tpy1lHI1'la8WI1X , OpraHaMI1, ocyJJ.J,eCTB- K('j l)eJlapycb
JUllOllUIX or)], JIB KOH$lWeHl!aJ1bHOii OC- ..060nepaTl1BHO-
HOBe, COCT3BJHlIOT rOl:yJ:\dpCTlJeHHYIO TaMHY P03bICKHOi1JJ,CSI-
Ii MOryr 6blTb npC.QBHbl r113CHOCTH TOJ1bKO C TeJ1bHOCTIJ»
IiX rrnCb\teHHoro COrn3lueHI1R 'I JCT.17
CBe.[JeHml 0 rpmKllBH3X, COTPYIDiWJaIOWI1X 3m<OH Pecny6;m-
WIlt cOTpynHwlaBlliI1X C opraHBMIf. OCYWCCT- Kit KaJaXCTaH
BJUlfOlllltX OP)], Ha 1I0HIPltileHUI'laJ1bHOH OC- «060nepaTI'IBH()-
HOse, COCTIUJ.1SlJOT rocynapcTBeHHyJO TatHy It pOJblCKHOi1 neSl-
ci::a:;tT; :;m;iO C ItX TeJ1bHOCTI'I»
CBelleHI1S1 ()6 Itcn()J]bJye).tb!X WIlt l1cnOJlb- 3aKOH Kblprbl3
30BaHHbIX nplt npOBe1leHItIt HernaCHblX CKOn Pecny6JJItKIt
OPM CW1i:1X, cpe.lJ,cmu, MerOllax, IfCTO'1HIf- ..06 onepaTIfI1HO-
KID:. n;rnHax If pl1bTaTID: OP)],. 0 11lfuaX, P03bIcKHoi1.u:eSl-
BHeJqJeHHblX B opraHlf30BaHHb1e npeCT)ln- TI:J1bHOCTIII»
Hble rpynnbl. 0 WTIlTHblX Her.nOCHbIX co-
"fPynHIfKax opraHoB, ocvwecTBIIJlfOLUI'IX OP)]"
11 J1I1UaX OKaJblBaJOLUl1X 11M COlleWCTBIfe HB
KOHIPltileHUI'laJ1bHOH ()CHOBe. a TaJOKe 06
opraHIt3aUItIt It 0 TaKTKe npOBeJIeHI1.11
OPM. COCTaBJIJlJOT rocynapCTBeHHYIO TanHY.
n011Jle),mT pacceKpe'nmaHItIO To.'IbKO Hi! oc-
HOlJaHlf1f nOCTaHOBJIeHlUl pyKOUOlllfTeJlJl
opr.Ulli, ocyweCTBJlJlfOutero OP)],. B COOT-
:na:Hm;.bBOM Kblpfbl3-
llpo()(u;J(Cl!Hue mUM. 8
86

-
2
ctJallT C!:Kpr:TIiOrQ COTpy.!\HI1'1TBa KaK ro-
CY!l3pCTl.eHHa!l TatiH3 06ccneLJI1I1TCSI oco-
6b1/1,\ nopSlllKOM yqeTa. xpaHeHlU1 If BbUIa'l11
HH4Jop"taul1l'1, KOTOpblM onpeneJlJleTCJI
cy6"eIlToM onepaTlfBHOM lleSlTe}]bHOCT C
Y'1eTOM nOJ\O;KeHI1H 'I. 2 CT. 3 HaCTOSlluero
3aKOH3. BbJ1l3113 11I-JIJIOpM3UMI'I 06 lilleH-
TI1'JHOCT ceKpeTHoro nOMOIUHI1Ka 111111 0
€!JaKTe CorpyD,HI1'JecTBa MO)l(C1 npol13Bo-
llHTbCSI 1011bKO B YCTaHOBJ1CHHO),t HaCTOSl-
11!I1M 3aKoHoM nopar:u<e ('I. 2 CT. 31)
CeKpeTHblH rIOMOlUHI1K MO)l(!:T 6bITb npl1-
BJ1e4eH K yroJ10I1HOM)' npoueccy 6e3 PacKpbl-
nUl 4>aKT3 ceKpMHOfO CQ1JJYLlHH'JecrBa.
ctJaKT cCKJXTHoro COlpYllHI'I'IeCTB3 nl1ua 11111'1
npellOCTaWleHHble 11M C(lel!!:HI1J/ B XOl!e yro-
J!()DHOrO npouecca MOryr 61>1110 ()WaWCHbl B
TOM CJI)"Jae, eCJIIf 310 OlnIMO ID1J1110C-
nnKeHI1.II UeJleM CIIt'l1C1BWI, WTSI rapaHTI'IIf
oorneCTBeHHoif 6e30nacHOCT. If JUlllJb B TOM
CJ1}"!ae, eCJU'I 3TO He CTaBm nOll yrp03Y
)l(113Hb, JllOpOBbe. cB060llY ceKpeTHOfO no-
MOlliHl'IKa 111111 npyroro l1J'Iua JlI{60 8031\.10)1(-
HOCTb IDUIbHcifwero IfCnO.llbJOBJ.l-mJl ceKpeT-
HOro nOMOIllHI1Ka ('I. 3 CT. 31)
n()J]Y'leHHaSI C nOMOIUblO cpencTB onepa
TIfBHOH neSlTenbHOCTI'I I1H4>opMaUHJI MO)l(eT
6bJTb p"CKpbJTa II X()lle cyne6HoH npouellY-
pbl c npeilllapHTCJ1bHOrO p,UpeWeHI1}1 re-
HepMbHom []pm."}'JJ0p3.. 3alTpewaeTCJI I1C-
[]0!1b30BaHl1e I1H$opM3LlI1I1. []0!1Y4eHHoii C
[]OMOWblO cpeJlCTB Om:p3TI1BHOfl JleJlTeJ1b-
HOCTJ.I. He B LleJ1JIX. B03Hl1l1alOJ( 113
caHIILlHOHI1DOBaHHOM CJ1e;KKH ('I. I CT 9)
CBeJleHI1S1 0 1111L13X. CCJflJYJlHI14HIO!Lll1X 111111
CmpYJlHI1'1al1Wl1x Ha U!eHLIaJ1bHOti
OCHOI\e C opraH31I1. ocyweCTBJISlIOW:"I\1
OPA HBJlHIOTCJI rocYJlapCmeHHoM TaHHOH 1'1
MOryr 6bITb []PC::Jl3Hbl maCHOCT TOJ1bKO C
[]\1CbMeHHoro COIJ1aC1U1 3TX lUlU ('I 3 CT. 16)
87
llpo()(u;J(Cl!Hue maM. 8
J
3alloH
Jl3TBlfMCKOM
PecrJy6J1I1KIf
«06 O[]epaTHBHoil
neHTe11bHOCTH»
3aKOH JlHTOBCKOi1
Pecny6J1I1KH
«06 O[]epaTHBHOi1
neHTe11bHOCTI1»
3aKOH Pec[]y6J1I1-
KI1 M0!1110aa
«06onepaTHBHo-
p03b1CKHOH neSl-
TeJ1bHOCTH»

nOJlmKeHItH. Kaca10IItileCH COJl,eiiCTIIIIH ..PIDK,lJ,aH OPlt, I1pe1J..M3lpH-
B31OTC1JeIJJIOIUIIeCT3TbHJ3KOH08,
CT3TbH 12, 17 <Dt:llepanbHoro 33110H3 06 onepaTHBHO-p03blcIIHoi1
AeHTeJ1bHOCTI'I"
CraTbli I) 3aKOHa YKpaHbl 05 on:paTIlIIHO-po3bICMiOIi nellTeJ1bHocm».
CT3lbH 16, 17 33KOffi3. Pecny6;:[11KH 6e)/3pycb 06 onepaTHBHo-
P03blcIIHOifneHTeJ1bHOCTH"
CT3TbH 13, 13 3aKOffi3. Pecny6}1HKH Ka3axCTilH 06 onepaTl1BHQ-
P03b!CK-HOif neSlTe}lbHOCT"
CTaTbH IS, 20 3aKoH3 Kblpfbl3CKOfi Pecny6JII'IIIH 05 onepaTHBHO-
pOJbJCKH()fin,eHTenbHocTH".
CT3TbH 30, 31, 32 3aKOffi3. JIaTBl'lficKOfi Pecny6JIl'IlIH ..06 onepaTB-
HOi1 neJne.llbHOCTH».
CT3TbH 4, 5, II 3aKoH J]HTOBCKOfi PecnyfuJHKI'I ..06 onepaTHBHofi
,UeJlTeJ1bHOCTIJ»
CT3TbH 15, 16 3aKoffi3. PemyfuJHKH MOJl1l0Ba ..06 onepaTI'IBHO-
P03bICII-HOflneSlTeJ1bHOCTH».

Ta6;uu.la9
COUJtaJIbIIo-npa80Ball3aWHTa'1'aQaH,opraHalll,
OCYLQeCTB"lIlKlJllllM OPL{, COfjl8CHO J3KOH3M, peryJlllJlylOJllIIIII OP)],
HCTP3H3XCHrHJ)aJlTHH
10&
.y,
ZJeMellmblC04I1GJlb/l()-nptl6tJ6Oil30I14umbi
z
np3B04>HJIN(('KH1{_'IHI.l,XOne-
JI.t11IB....M [JQ;JJIdJ,iJ,('IJeI1HHM, nO.'IY'l3Tb rocy-
1hm3, CO!leWCTB)llOllil'le Opr3H3M, ocymecTB-
JlJlIOLQI'I},t OP.IJ, HdXOJJ,JITCH rJOJ\ 3allilnO
rocynapcTBa(<J.lcr 18)
- hu.lo, npIllBJ1ell3eMoe K Bb![]OJ1HeH('J1O 33J13<J
OP.IJ, HiUlOJ\HTCH nOLI JaWI1TO rocynapCTBa
(<J.lcT 13)
1hm3, cOJ\ewcTBYJOllil'le opraH3M, ocyw:eCTB-
JlJlIOWI'IM OPil, H3XOllSiTCH noll 33WHTOH
rocynapcTBa (<J. 1 CT. 17)
1hm3, cOllecTBYlOllil'le opraHBM, ocyw:eCTB-
JlJiIOWI'IM OPil, H3XOIDITCH nOll 33llilIToH
rocynapCTBa(<J. I CT. 23)
I11ma, c01lecTlWlOurne opraHaM, OC}l.I.lecTB-
JlJiJOWI1M OPil, H3"0JJ,JITCH nOll 33llilIToif
rocy.napCTBa(<J. I CT. 21)
CeKpeTHble nOMOlliHI1KI'I HaXQIUITCJI nOll 33-
wlrroR rocymlpCTBa, a CBelleHl'IJI 06 If X lflleH-
T'IHOCTI1 H ceKpCTHOM COlJlYllHH'ieCTBe C
cyfu,eKTON: OnepaTI'IBHOH neSlTe.%HOCT JiBJIH-
IOTCSI rocYJ\apCTlR:HHoti T3HHOi1 ('I. I CT. 31)
89
HOUtU!IKJ6OHUe
3C11'.:OHOdomeAbf/biX
OKm06. pel.WtU!ll-
mupYIOl«ux OPJ/.
3
4te!leparrbHblA
:laKOH ...o6o!lepa-
TBHO-P03b]CKHOH
,llCSlTeJ1bHOCTW>
3aKOH YKpaHHbl
..06 OnepaTlfBHO-
p03blcIIHotiJ\eH-
TeJ1bH()CTIfD
3aKoH PeClly6JlIf-
IIH 6eJl3pycb
«06 OnepaTlfBHO-
P03blcIIHOHJ\eH-
TeJ1bH()CTIf_
3aKoH Pecny6JlIf-
IIIfKa3BXCTBH
«060nepaTlfBHO-
pOJbICIIHOHJ\eH-
TeJ1bHOCTIf»
3aKoH KblprblJ
CKOW Pecny6J11f1l1f
..060nepaTIfBHO-
pOJbICIIHotiIleH-
TeJ1bH()CTIfD
3aKoHJ1aTBj:j-
CKOH Pecny6J1IfKI'I
..06 onepaTIfBHo
IleSlTeJ1bHOCTI'I"

1 2
COTPY1lHI1"1BlOllll1e no .lIOrOllopy mUla o6ec-
ne"U'leaJOTCH COLlL1aJlbHblMI1 rapaHTlUIMI1 (ll. 2
CT.j)
1hma. COlleHCTB}/lOllll'le oprm-JaM. ocymeCTB-
]1IUOlllI1M OPll, H3X0JJJ1TCH nOli 33WIiTOH
rocy.oapcTBa("I. I CT 16)
-----z- fapauTupoBaHHe $1I)II'IIeCIIHM JUI1I3M BblnOJl-
III.'HltcofiH)8'f('1]bCTBIIOKOtrI'paKTaMCHHM
focYIlapcTBo rapaHTpyeT J1l1llaM, 113'b1IBJ1B-
U1I1M COrl1iiCl1e COlIeWCTBOmnb n() lIol-JTpalay
opraH3M, ocyweCTBJ1IUOIlUIM OPll. Bb!nOJl-
HeHl'Ie CliOi'll( 06I13BTeJ1bCTB, npellycMolJleH-
HblX KOHTpaKToM, II TOM "II1CJ1e rapaHHlpyeT
npaBOI!YIO 3auuny. CBI133HHYIO c npaBOMep-
HblM BblnOi1HeHl1eM YK":'!aHHbIMI1 .I1l1llaMI1
()OmeCTBeHHoro nOJ1fa 1'1)]11 B03JIO)KeHHbIX Ha
tmXOOH3BHHocTetl ('/. 2 CT. 18)
focynapCTBo rapaHTPY 1111U8M. 113'1.1111118-
U/I1M corJ1OCl1e COlldiCTROfl3Tb no IIOHTpaKry
opraHBM, ocyweCTBJlIUOllll1M OPll. IIb!nOJI-
HeHl1e CBOI1X 061133n:J1bCTB, npellYCMOlpeH-
HblXKOHTnl.lKTOM 'I. JCT 17)
fp:l)KJ1ilHaJ,t. 113HIBI1BU1I1M corJ1aclie cOlleilcT-
BOBBTb no 1I0HrpaKT)' opraJ-J3M. ocyIl.(eC1B-
J1HIOIUI1M OPll, rocynapcTBo rapaHTl1pyeT
()tiecne'leHlfe If X npaB 11 Bbln()J1HeHl1e 065133-
1l:J1bCTB B couroeTC11\Hl'I C HOCTOIIUU\M 3aKO-
:;:::;XT:OT:H;;;11
rOCY.IlapCTBO rapaHTupyeT 1111Ll<!M, 1131>IIBI111-
ml1M corl1acl1e cOlldICTBOBi1Tb n() Kompalay
uprm-JaM. ()cymecTBJlSllOmliM Opn. BblnOJ[-
HeHl'Ie CBOI1X OO.lI3aTeJ1bCTB, npellYCMOl'peH-
HblX KOI-ITpaIlTOM, B TOM "mCJ1e rapal-ITl1pyeT
npaBOB)'1O Jamlil)'. CBSlJaHHYIO C npaBOMep-
HblM BblnOJ1HeHl1eM YIIBJaHHblMI1 1111uaMI1
oomeCTBeHHoro JlO11ra 111111 B03l10)KeHHbIX HB
HI1X06HJ<1HHocrefi ("I 2 CT. 21)
90
flpotJoVKeHue maan. 9
J
3aKoHl111ToI!CKofi
Pecny6lIl1KI1 06
OnepaTI1BHOfi
AeSirenbHOCTM"
3aKoH PeCnv6lIl1-
KI1 MonlloH; ..06
onepaTI1BHO-
p03blcIlHoflJ\eH-
Te11bHOCTI1
4JellepaJIbHbrfl
JallOH «06 one-
paTIJBHO-
p03blcIlHoflJ\eH-
Te11bHOCTI1
3allOH Pecny611I1-
KI1 6e11Bpycb
06 onepaTI1BHO-
p03blcIIHOHJ\eH-
Te11bHOCTI1
3aKoH PeCnv6lIl1-
KI1 KaJaxc"n1H
..06 ()nepaTI1BH()-
pOJbICIIH()HneH-
TeJ1bHOCTW>
3allOH KblprblJ-
cKofi PeCnv6lII1KM
«06 ()nepdrI1BH()-
P03bICKH()flneH-
TeJ1bH()CTW>

--.
-
fOCY.IlapCTBO .-apaHUlpyer 11I1l.laM, JJ,iUJIllI1M
COrl1aCl'Ie collei1CTBoBBTb Ha KOHTpaKTHoi1
OCHOBe C opraHBMH, ocyweCTaJlHfQWI1MI1
:no::I1=O;BOM()'l°T::B,
r3aIUllThIIJlH:JH'JeeKHMJlHualll.
CO!&'IicTBYH1Ir"NIIIITIIIJ()I1""""JI8fH""
npH B03HHKHOBeHi'U'I peaJIbHOH yrpo3b1 npO
nl50npaBHoro nOCSIraTt:J1bCTBa HB }l(113Hb,
31lOpOBbe KJlH I1MYllleCTBO OTJJ,eJlbHbIX J1I1Ll B
CBSlJI1 C I1X COlIeMCTBl'leM OpraHaM. OCYWCCT-
BI1IUOIllHM OPll, a paSHO '1nCHOB I1X ceMefi 11
6JJ1'I3KI1X 3nJ upraHb! 00Sl3BHbi npl1HSlTb He-
06XOJJYIMbie MepbI no npeLlOTspaweHl11Q npo-
nlBonp"BHbIX nelt<.'TBld1:. YCTBHOBJIeHI1JO 811-
HOBHblX 11 IJplUlJ1e<1eHI1JO I1X II (Jf1Ie"J'CTI!eHHO-
CH!. npellYC'IOTPeHHOfl 3BKOH()lWTeJlbCTBOM-
POCCJ\t!cKoi141cllemUI1I1 C.. 3 CT. 18)
npl1 BOJHl1l1HOBeHl111 peaJIbHOH yrp03bl npo-
TlfBOnpaBHOro nOCSIraTeJlbCTBa }Ja }K3Hb, 3110-
pOBbe I1J]I1I1MYllleCTBOOTIleJ1.bHbIXJ1I1Ll BCIDI-
311 C I1X co.neHcnmeM opraHaM, ocyureCTB-
J1HIOUlM QPll, a paBHO '1J1eHOB I1X cCMei1 11
6JJHJKIU( 3TI1 opraHbI 06S1JaHbl npi1HS1Tb He06-
XOllMb!e Mepbl no npellOTBpaweHmo npOT-
eonpaBHblx .lIei1CTBI1i1. )'CTdHOBI1eHHIO BHOB-
Hb!X Ii npi1BJ1e'1eHI1IO HX K ume1C1BeHHOCTIf
"I 2 cr. 17
npi1 B03HI'IIIHOBeHI'II'I pea.rrbHoH yrpoJbl npo-
TI'IBonpaBHorQ nQCSlraTtJ1bCT&I Ha >KI'IJHb,
JJ1upoBbe 111m I'IMymecTBO ()menbHblX nl'lU B
CBHJI1 C I'IX co!!dicTBl'leM opraH3M. OCY!l[eCT-
BJLlIIOIUI'IM Opn, 3 paBHO '1neH()B I1X ceMdl 1'1
6JJI'IJKI'IX 3TI1 opraHbl 06H3aHbI npl'lHJlTb He-
06XOJ],lf},tble Mepbl no npellOTBpameHI1JO
npOTI'IBonpaBHblX neI'lCTBI'IW. YCTaHODJ1eHI1JO
BrIHOBHblX 1'1 npl'lDJ1e'1eHI1JO I'IX II OTBeTcr_
BeHH()CTI'I. a TBK>Ke n() npOBe.neHI'lIO B CJlY-
'IDe He06xOIII'IMOCTI'I CneUI'la.J1bHbIX Mepo-
npl'lJITI'I no I1X JBmrITe B nOpH.lIxe. onpe!!c-
:e::x:H:J.;I'ICTPO(l Pecny6:iI'I-
91
flpotJoVKeHue maan. 9
J
3allOH Pecnv6lIl'I-
KI'I MOJUlODa «06
onepaTI1(1HO-
p03bJCKH() .De.ll-
TeJ1bHOCTI'I»
<J>e.nepa.rrbHbl
JaIlOH«060ne-
paTI1BHO-
P03bICIIH()Wne.ll-
TeJ1bHocrl'l»
3aKOH Pecnv6lIl'I-
KI'I6elIapycb
«060nepaTI'IBHO-
P03b]CIIH()ne.ll-
TelIbHQCTW>
3aKOH PecnytiJ1I1K11
""=<="
«06 ()nepaTI'IBH()-
pOJbICIIHOWne.ll-
TelIbHOCTI'I

-
2
npl'l B03HI'IKHOBeHI'I1'I peaJIbHotl: yrpo3bJ npo
HlRonpaSHoro nOCSIfaTeJ1bCTA.a HB )l(113Hb,
JJ1upOBbe HIm I1MywecTBO ()rnenbHblX mm B
CeflJI1 C I1X cOlleMcTBHeM opraH3M. ocymecT-
BJlJllOllIl'IM opn, a paBHO "!leHOn 1'1" ce"teft 11
6.r1113KI1X 3TI'I OpfaHbl 06S133H1.1 npHH.ll.Tb He-
06XOlWlMbie Mepb! no npeliOTspaweHHIQ npo-
nJBOnpaBHbIX .net!CTBldi. YCTJHOBJIeHI1JO BI'I-
HOBHblX 11 npl1BJ1C'ieHI1IO I1X II QTBt':TCTBeHHO-
en!, npenYC"IOTpeHHOH IaKOHQlJ,aTeJlbCTBOM
Kblrn-b!3CK0i1 Pecn 06I1I'1KI'I 1'1. 3 CT. 21
EC1U'l B CBA311 C cCKpeTHblM COTpy1lHI1'1ecr-
80M B03HI'IKaeT peaJIbHaSi yrp03a )l(1'I3HI1,
3llopOBblO, I1MymecTBeHHblM H.f111 .npyrHM
JaKOHHblM I'IHrepecaM CeKpeTH()rO n()!>t()W-
HI'IKa 11 "IJleHOB em ceMb. He06xOllI1MO
npHHJlTb MCPb! 6e30nacHocT ./!IIJI YCTpaHe-
HI1.11 :noH yrp03bl, BKJlIO'IaSi cMeHY MeCTa
::e:::CT (O:YCB, ynoCToBepSlIO-
npH B03Hl1KHOBeHI11'1 yrp03bI )l(1'I3HI1, 3110
POBblO. I1MYlllecTI1)' ceKpeTHblx }"13CTHI'IKOB
1'IJ11'1 'iJIeH()B I'IX ce",eft Cy6beKTb! ()nepaTlfB-
Holi ,/J,fmeJ1bHOCTH npl1HI1MiUOT lice He06xo-
1ll'lMb1e MCpl.l llJ1S1 JaLID:lTbl )1(1131"11'1. JL!OpoflbSl,
.fiOCTOIIH<:TB I 11 I1MymeCTBa. COBepWeHHble
npOTliB 3THX 1111Ll npr:crynJ1eHI1S1. CBl!3aHHbie
C I1X TaHHblM ooTpynHII'lecTBOM C onpelle-
l1eHHblMI1 .-ocynapcTBeHHblMI1 I1HCllfi)'UlUI-
MI1, IIBa.rJI1$I'ILll1pyIOTCJI fiB OCfiOflBHl111 COOT-
BeTCTBYIOIllI1X CTBTe Yro.llOBHOro KOlleKCB
('I. I CT. II)
npl1 B03HI111HOBeHI111 peaJ1bHOH yrpo3b1 npo
TIIIBOnp"BH()rO nOC$lr.neQbCTB" Ha )K113Hb,
J1l0pOBbC 11.1111 I1MywecTBO OTnr:JlbHbIX 1111Ll B
CBS/3M C I1X COnel1CTBlteM up.-aHBM. ()cymecT-
BI1HlOllIl1M QPD, a pBBHO 'UleHOB I1X ceMeH 11
6.rJ113KI1X 3TM opraHbl OOnaHb! npmmTb He-
06xOJ],lfMble Mepbl no npeilOTBpaweHlUO
npOTI1BonpaBHblX .oei1CTBI1H. YCTaHOBl1eHl11O
BHH()BHbIX 11 npl1B11e'leHl1lO I1X II ()TBeTCT-
BeHHOCTI1 ('I. JeT. 16)
92
llpooo,J;JKeHuemafiJl.9
3
3aKoH KbIP.-bIJ
CKOH PeCnv6lIl1l1l1
..06 ()nepaTI1BH()-
P03b1CKH0i1.ne.ll-
Te.llbH()CTW.
3aKOHJ1aTI1I1H-
CKOf! PeCnv6lII1KH
..06onepaTI1I1Hoi1
AeSlTe!1bHOCTW'
3aKoHJ1I1TOBCKof!
Pr:cny6J1(J1I11
..06onepaTMBH()fj
.neSlTeJ1bHOCTI1»
3allOH Pecny6J1I1-
KI1 M01I1l0Ba ..06
onepaTHBHo-
P03bICKH()f!.ne.ll-
TeJlbHQCTI1»

1 -
---t-I=:.:="
_ ;M3"=:::::=a:::"
COBepml1BWee npOTl1BOnpaOHOe .nem.me. He
n()BJ1CKWee 1IDKK1'I1( nOCJlCllCTBl'lti. 11 npl1BJ1C-
"IeHHO!: K C01pY1lHW1CCJBY C opraHOM, ocy-
llIeCTB.:ISIIOLl!lI),t OPD. aKTBHO cnoco6CTBO-
B<1Bwee pacKpbITI1JO npecryn;'JeHI1.11. B03Mec-
nlBllIee H8HeCCHHblH ywep6 11J11j I1HbI"t cno-
COtiOM 3arl1alUJBllIee nplf'-JI1HCHHblH BpCll.
QCI1060)l(J{aeTCSI OT yrQJ10BHoli OTBnCTBCHHO-
cnl e COOTBeTCTBl111 C IaKoHon.neQbCTOO\I
POCCI1HCKOi1 4Ie.ueooUHI1 C'I 4 CT. 18)
npH HlI3H8<1CHlU1 H8K838HI111 11 OTHQIl1CHHI1
111111 113 'JHCJIa npecrynHOH rpynnbl, COBCp-
WI1BWI1X np01BonpaBH()e ACSlHl'IC 11 npl1BJ1C-
"CliHb!X II COTpYDHI'I'JeCTB}' C opraHOM, ()cy-
mCCTBJISlIOL1W1),t OPD. aKTBHO CnQC06CTBO-
BaBWI1X paCKPbIT1O npecryruJeHml, BOJMCC-
nlBWI1X HaHeCCHHblH ywep6 I1Jm I1HblM ()o-
paJOM 3arJIaL\I1HWI1X nplII'U1HCHHbIH "pea, CYli
Y<JI1TblBaeT .!\BHHblC o6cToJ£renhCTBa Kall 06-
CTOSITC.IIbCTB8, CMSlf'l8101lIHC OTBeTC'1'Bl'HHOCTb
B C()()1'IJCJ'CTBl'I C yrOJ1()BHbIM 3BKOHOliaTeJ1b-
CTBOM Kbl rbl3CKoii PCCnv6n111111 ('J. 4 CT. 21
5 T] V'ielJKCB03H8
Tl1ua, COTpyllHIf'l8101lIltC C opraH8MI1, ocy-
IlICCTB,;ISIIOUUJMH QPD, .'m60 01l1>38BI11I11: 11M
nOMOll.lb Ii paCKPbIT11 npecryn11eHI1J1 111111 B
}'CTaHOBJIefU'lI'l 11I1U, I1X COBepWI1BUlI1X, MOryT
n()J1)"-1aTb B03Harpa)l(l!eHI1J1 11 npyrHe BblllJ1a-
n()J1}'4eHHb!e }'Ka3aHHblMI1 1II1UBMI1 CYM-
Mbl S03H.up-OKJJ:eHI1 11 npyrl1e eblnJIfffbI HB-
11uraMI1 He ()fuJaralOTCSI 11 B neK!1apaUltSIX ()
.D01I:0!lilXHevt<"3bIBBJOTCJI ('I Scr 181
1I11ua. corpynHI1"1BIOUll1e C opraHBMl1, OC)'-
UleCTBJlJlIOIUI1MI1 OPll, I1MelOT npaso HB no-
lI}"1elU'le R03Harpa)l(l!CHI1H ('I SCT 23)
93
llpooo,J;JKI!HuemafiJl.9
CJ>enepaJ1bHblii
3aIlOH«06one-
paTI'IBHO-
P03bICIIH()HAeH-
Tt:11bHQCTW>
3allOH Kblprbl3-
CKO PeCnv6lII1KH
«06 ()nepaTI1BH()-
P03bICIIHOH.D e H-
TeJ1bHOCTI1»
CJ>ellepaJ1bHbIA
3aIlOH«060ne-
paTI1BHO-
P03bJCIIH()H.neJl-
Tt:J1bH()CTW>
3aKOH Pecnv6lIl1-
KI1 KaJaxcraH
«060nCpBTI1BHO-
p03blclIHoiineH-
TeJ1bHOCTI1»

flpoiJotlJK:eHUema6ll.9
1 2 3
1l1ma. corpynHl'I"JaJOl.l.ll1e C OpraHaMI1, ocy- 3allOH Kblprbl3-
l.l.leCTBJ1HfQWI1MI1 OPD, J1I160 OKa3aBWl1e 11M CKOM Pecny6lIl1KI1
nOMOllib B p"CKpbJTI1I'1 npeCTYn:IeHI11 1'I1I1'1 B .,Q6 ()nepaTI1BHO-
YCTaHOBJ1eHl1l'1JII'Il!, I1X COBepllil1Bllil1X, MO- P03blcIIHoi1neH-
'Y' n()J]y<laTb B03HarpmKlleHI1H " n.pyme TelIbH()CTI1"
BbmaTbI('I.SCT.21)
CC:KperHoe COTpynHI1'1C:CTBO MOJKeT 6blTb 3aKOH11aTl1l1li-
OnlIa'll1l1aeMblM CellpeTHble nOMOI.l.lHI1KH C CKOM Pecny6lII1KH
11)( Cor.nacl'l.ll MoryT npl1B1IeKarhCH K onepa- ..06 onepaTI1BHoH
TIIIBHOH lleSlTe.bHOCT 1'1 HB OCHOBe llorOIJO- neSlTeJ1hHOCTH»
pa('l. 3 CT. 30) 3aKoH pecny\i1l-;:;:-
111100. cOTpynHl'I'JalOl.l.lHe C ()pral'IDMI1, ocy
meCTI1J1HIOWI1MI1 OPD. l'IMelOT npaBO OKa3b1- KI1 MonllOBa ..06
BaTb 11M COllet1CTBI1e Kall 6eJB03Me311H(). TaI< ()nepaTHBHO-
113aIJ03HarpmIUleHl1e('I. 4 CT. US) P03b1CIIHOH.neH-
RJ1hHOCTW.
. nOKOHTpaKTY
nepH()ll corpynHI1'1eCTBa """""" no '0" (]>e1repalIbHblt!
TPU-1)' C opraHaMI1. ocyu1CCTBI1HlOllil1MI'I OPD. JaKOH .,Q6onepa-
B Ka'leCTBe OCHOBHOro palla JaHHTI'I BKJUO'Ja- TI'IBH()-P03bICKHOR
eTCH B TPynoBOH CTaJK rpIDI\1ldH. YKA31HHble AelTeJ1bHOCTIJ
JlI'lOO I1MelOT npaao Ha neHCI10HHoe 06ecne-
"IeHl1e B COUJIIfiCTBIIH C JaKOHO.naTeJ1hCTBOM
PoccHlicKOH(]:IeJ:\epaL.!11 ('I 7 CT. 18)
COTpYl!HI1"1eCTIIO Jll1ua C onepaTI1BHblM n01(- 3aKOH YKpal1HbI
pa31leJ1eHl1eM 3a'll'lClIHeTCli B o6mjji Tpyno- .,Q6()nepaTI1BH()-
DOli CTaJK B CJlY'l8e 3aKJI104eHI1}1 C HI'IM Tpy- P03b1CIIHOHlleSl-
noooro COfJl3weHI'Ili ("I. 2 CT 13) TeJ1hHOCTI1»
nepl1011 corpynHI1'1eCTIIa rpa}l(j]aH B Ka"leCT- 3aKoH Pecny6lIl1-
Be OCH()BHOfO pOJIa 3aHJITI'IH n() KOHTpaKTY C KI1 6elIap}':b
opraHBMI1, OCYWecTBJ1HIOWI1MI1 OPD, 11 Ka- ..060nepaTI1I1HO-
"IeCTBe ()CHOBHOro po.aa JaHSlTI1H BKJUO'JaeT- P03bICIIH()i1neH-
" B I'IX Tpynol1oli CTaJK. YKaJ8HHble Jll1ua TeJ1bHOCTI1
I1MelOT npaBO Ha neHCI10HHOe 06ec[JC'lCHl'le
B C()OTBeTCTBl'Il1 C nei1cTBywlUl1M JaKOHona-
TCJ1bCTBOM ("I SeT. 17)
94

2
nepl'I()ll COT]J}lDHl'I'leCTBa rpa;K1laH no KOH
TpaKl)' Ha ruJaTHOH OCH()Ie C opraHBMI'I,
OCYIlICCTBJlSlIOI.l.lI'IMI'I OPfl. BKJIIO'laeT B TPY-
llOBO CTa rpIDKllBH. OHI'I l'IeJOT npaBO HB
neHCI'I()HHOe oGecne'JeHl'le B CJ1)"Jae rl'l0eJ111
1'1" CeMbl'l 11 ('DI\..!\I1BeHLlbl - Ha nCHCl110 no
CJlY'IalO nOTepl1 KOpMI1J1bua B COOTBeTCT1II1I1 C
newCTBYlOllil'lM 3aKOHQmrreJlbCTIJOM 1'1 B no-
pSlllKC, onpC1lCJlSlCMOM Ka611HeTOM MHHI1CT-
pOD Pecny6nl1KI1 K"JD'u:TdH (l!. 6 CT. 23)
nepHOLl COTpyllHl'I'JeCTBa rpB)KL!aH no KOH-
TpaK1)' C opraHBMI'I, OC}'llIecTBJ1l1lOllII1MI'I
opn. B Ka'JecrBe OCHOflHoro pOllB 3(lHSlTIII}1
BKJ1IO'ffieTCSI B rpyllOl1oii CTa)K rpa>KJ\BH.
Yt-a31HHble 1111ua I1MCIOT npaBO HB neHCI1-
OHHoe 06ecnB'leH(']e B COOTBeTCTIlIUI C 33KO-
HOllaTcnbCTBOM KbIpThUCKOii Pecny6J1I1KH
('I.. 6 CT. 21)
nep!1011 COTpYlIHI'I"IeCTBa rpa)KilllH n() KOH-
Tpalay c ()praI-JaMl'I. ocywecTBJlJlIOIUI1MI1
OPfl, BKJ1104HeTCSI B !'IX TPY1l0BOH CTa}l( B
113'leCTBC OCHOBHOll .!\CSlTeJ1bHOCTH. YKa33H-
Hble 1111Ll3 I1MCIOT npaBO Ha neHCI'IOHHoe
o6eCne'leHl1e B COOTBCTCTBIUI C 311KOHOJLil-
TCJIbCTBOM () neHCI10HHO),t 06eCne4CHI111 BO-
eHHOC.V}l(all.lI1" ('I. 6 CT 16)
7 flpoBencu"c cnCUHUbHbJX \It'POIIIIJUITIfIi
B ueJlJlx ()ficcnc'lcHim 6c30nacHocTI1 RI1U,
COTPY.!\HI1'ffiIOIl{X C opraHBMI1 ocyw:eCTB-
RI1IOW:I1MI1 OPLL 11 'iJ1eHOB I1X CMeii JJOnyc-
118eTCSI npOBe.!\eHl1ecneJ..lI18J'IbHbIX Meponpl1S1-
TI1H no I1X 3<111.1I1Te B nOpJI.!\Ke. onpe.!\e.JUle-
MOM 3aKOH01laTeJlbCTBOM POCCI'IHCIIOH $e-
AepaU1111 '1. 8CT 18)
B cJI)"-1ae B03HI1KHOfleHI1J1 yrpo3b! )K1'I3HH,
3..IJ.OpOflblO I1Jm I1MyweCTIlY RHUB, npl1W1e-
l<8eMoro II (lblnOJlHeHI1IO 33ll8"1 OPil, ero
38lm'1Ta o5ecne'lHB8erCI1 B nopHi\Ke, npei\Y-
CMOTpeHHOM 'I. JeT. 11 HBCTOSIwero 38KOHB
('I.JcT.IJ)
95
flpoiJolJK:etlue mOOI. 9
3
3aKoH Pecny6J111
1111 Ka38xcTaH
...o60nepaT11BHO-
P03bJCKH()Hlle.ll-
TeJIbH()CTI1"
3allOH KbrprblJ-
CKOH PeCnv6JII1I1H
06 onepa-TI1RHO-
P03bICIIH0i111H-
TeJIbHOCTI1»
3aKOH Pecny6J1I1-
Kl'I MOJlllODa 06
onepaTI1BHO-
p03blcllHOHlleH-
TeJIbHOCTI1
CJ>e.!\epaJIbHbrH
JallOH
06 onep8TI1BHO-
p03bJCIIHOH neR-
TeJlbHOCTI1
3aKOH YKpal1Hbl
06 onepaTI1RHO-
P03blc1IHOHlleH-
TeJlbHQCTW>

llpooo,J;JKeHuemafiJl.9
1 2 3
B LlelUlX 06eClle'leHI111 6e30nacHOCTH 1111U, 3alloH Pecnv6lIl1-
COTpyHHl.JlmJOLllX no KOHrpaKl)' C opraHBMl1, KH 6elIapycb
OCYLllCCTBJ1I1IOLllI'IMI1 OPD. 1'1 'llICHOD 11X ce- ..06 ()nepaTI1BH()-
Mdi J\onYCllaerCH npoBcileHlte CneLll13JIbHbiX P03blcIIHOHJ\eH-
Meponpl1J.lTM no I1X 3aLlll1Te B nopJ.lJ\Ke. on- TeJlbHOCTI1»
peIleJ1I1CM()M ()praHBtI1. YKaJaHHb!MI1 B .... I
CT. 2 HacTOSlLllcro 3aKOHa (... 6 CT 17)
B uelIl1X 06ecne'I.BHIUI 6e.!OnacHocTI1 nl1Ll, 3allOH Kblprbl3-
COTPYAHl.JlialOLllHX C opraHBM11, OCYLlleCTB- CKOi1 Pecny6nl1KI'I
11111OLllHtI1 OPD, Ii ...lIeHOB I1X ceMcti J\onyc- «060nepaTI1f1HO-
113ercSi npOBe!leHl1e Cne!.WIaJIbHblX MCpO- p03bICIlHOHl\CH-
npl1.llTl1i1 no I1X 3aLllI'ITC e nopHllKC. onpeIlC- TeJlbHOCTI1
1111CMOM 3aKOH()llaTeJ1bHblMI1 11 I1HblMI1 H()P-
MaTBHblJ.tI1 npaBOBblMIt 811T8MI1 Kblprb!3-
CKOi1 PeCnv6lIl1l1l1 (.... 7 CT. 21)
B UCJ1J1X 06ecnc...eHI1H 6e30nacH()CTH 1111U. 3aKoH Pecny6J111KH
COTpYllHlf'mIOLllX no KOHTpaKl)' C opraH8"'I1, MOJ1110fl8
OCYLl{CCTBJlHIOLl{HMI1 OPD, 11 'IJ1CHOB I1X cc- «060nepaTI1BHO-
Mei1 HonYCKaeTC.II npoBeIlcHlic CnCUl1aJ1bHblX P03bJCKHOi1D,C.II-
MCpOnpl1J1TH no I'IX 3BUII1TC B nopSlllKe, ()n- TeJ1bHOCTW'
pelleJ1l1eMQM np8BTCJ1bCTBOM (I{. 7 CT. 16)
8 B, aerH5e.1H
B CJ1y'me r6eJ1I1 JII1LlB, COTPYllHI1...moLllcro CJ>ellepaJ1bHblii
no KOHTP"KTY C OpraHaMI1. oCYLl{eCTBJlJlIO- 3alloH«060ne-
Ll{HMI1 OPD, B CID!3M C ero }"IacTl1eM B npo- paTI'IBHO-
BelleHl11'1 OPM CCMbC nocrpammwero 11 1111- P03bICIIH()HHe.ll-
LlaM, HBXOJ{"Ll{I1MCH Ha cro 11}1(J\ItBeHItI1, 113 reJ1bHOCTI1
cpellCTB COOTBeTCT6YlOlllero 610IDKCTa B"-
nl1B'II1BaerC.II Clll1HOBpeMcHHoe n()c06l'1e B
paJMcpe nCCSlTl'IlICTHCro nCHCJKHOrO COllep-
}!(aHI1S1 nor6wcro 11 B ycrilHOBlICHHO),t 3a-
KOH()M n()pSlHKe Ha3HB'IaeTCJI nCHCI1.11 n()
CJ1}"131O nOTCDl'I KODMI'IJlbLla (I{ 9 CT 18)
EC)/11 11 CBil311 C BblnOJ1HeHItCM TBKI1M 1111LlOM 3aKOH YxpBI1HbI
3M3" DPLl HaCl)'[JI1JIB ,m 11HBaJ1I'11lH()CTb ..06 ()nCpaTI1BH()-
"'" cMeprb, "" Hero pacnpocTpaHlllOTCSI P03bICIIH()Hl\C.II-
l1brOTbl. npCilYCMOTpeHHblC n().Q06HblX reJ1bHOCTI1
CJ1Y'la.llX llJIJI pa60THI1KOB onepaTl1eHblX nOll-
p3.3J{eJ1CHI1j;! (... 2 CT. 13)
96

1 2 3
B CJI)"me r6eJ[Ii nlma, COTpyllHl'I'IalOwero 3aKoH Pecny6JU:lKH
no 1I01-ITpaKI)' C OpraHaMI1. ocyweCTlJJlJlIO- 6}lapycb
uuum orn. B CBIIJI'I C ero )"-1acTHeM B npo- ..06 ()nepaTI1BH()-
BelIeH111'1 OPM CeMbe nOCTparrnBwero 1'1 ero P03bICIlHOHneJl-
!J)KJJI1f1CHUaM 1'13 cpellCTB YlOwero RJlbH()CTW.
610lVKcTa B!>ln)1a'lI1(1CJI elll1HOHpeMeHHoe
nocoG"!: B pa3Mepe J{eCHTI1J1Hero cOllep-
)!(3HI'IJI nor6wero 11 B YCT3HQB]'1CHHO),t 33-
H: eSl::o;::::e; 7 S1 nO
B cJI)"lae rl'l6eJU'I rpa)K!!aHHl-m. COrpYllHl1 3aKoH Pecny6J1HJG'1
"Ialowero no 1I00-ITpaKTY c upraHaMI1. ocy- KaJaxcTaH
WeCTBJlJllOllIl1MI1 OPD, B CDSl3H C ero )"Ja- ,,06 ()nepan1BHO-
CTHeM B npOflClleHl111 OPM ceMbe norl16we- P03bICIIH()HlI e l\-
ro 11 ero IUIUJJ!IJeHuaM 113 CpellCTII COOTBer- RJlbHOCTH»
CTlI}flOllIero 6101IJKeTa Bbln)1a"I1BaeTCH-
HOBpeMeHHoe noco611e B pa3Mepe neCSITIj-
J1eTHero J\eHC)KHoro COaepJKaHHSI norlf6we-
roo COTPYllHI1'lliBlllero HH nlIHTH()i1 OCHOBe, B
p3.3Mepe JleCSlHI .-oJ\OBbIX CYM),t ),tI1HI1MaJlb-
:e:1:i1 n:ca;:e 112;aHlllero 3allOH Kb
B CJ1Y'lae r6eJlI1 nl1L1i1, COTpyllHH'lalOwerO
no 1I01-ITpaKI)' C OprmIDMI1, ocyweCTlJJlJlIO- CKOft PeCnv6lIl1l1l'1
WI1MI1 OPD. II CBfI3l'1 C ero )"-1acTl'ICM B npo- ..06 ()nCpa-TI1BHO-
BelleHml OPM CCMbC nOCTpa.!laaWCro 11 JlI1- pOJbICIIHOHll C J\-
uaM, HBXO.QIIIl.!I1MCH H8 era 11}1(.!1IiBCHI1I1, 113 Tt:J1bHQCTW>
Cpe!ICTB COOTBeTCTBYIOlJ..lerO 6Td
nJ1a'lIiBaeTCH eJ:\IiHOB)JeMeHHoe noco61'1e "
pnMepe lIecHnrnCTHero JJ,eHeJKH()ro cO.Qep-
)!(BHI1H Ii B YCTBHOBJ1eHHOM 3allOHOM nOpSlll-
n:::118 I no cnY4alO nOTepl1
B CJ1Y'Jac r1'l6eJlli nI1UB, COTpyllHIi'JaIOWCJ"O 3aKoH Pecny6J1IiKl1
n() 1I0HrpaKI)' C ()praHro.Il1, OCYlUCCTBJlJllO- M()JllI()Ba
WI1Ml'I opa, II CBIIJI1 C ero Y"HlCTl'ICM B npo- ..06 ()nepaTI1BHO-
BellCHl111 OPM ceMbC nocTpa.aaBwera 11 ero pOJbICIIHOHll C J\-
Ii>KJJ.l1BCHUHM 1i3 Cpe!ICTB COOTBCTCTBYlOmero Tt:J1bHQCTW>
61Q.1\JKeTa I1blfU1B'IIiBaCTCSI CliliHOBpCMCHHoe
noco6lie B pa3MepC .necHflIDeTHerO JJ,eHeJKHO-
ro COlIepJ!<AHIi1 nom6mero 11 11 ycrBHOBJIeH-
HOM 3aKOHOM nOpJlllKC HaJHa'JaeTCSI neHCI1.11
no CJIV'ffi1O nOTeOIi KDP!IIl{)']bua <J. 8 CT_ 16)
flpotJoVKeHue maan. 9
97

llpooo,J;JKeHuemafiJl.9
+ 2 3
9 np' nOJl.Y'lCHlt1t Tp:leM, p:lHCHItH, yoC'IHH,
- KOHl)'3HH
npll nOJl}"ICHl'Ili JlIIUOM, cOTpynHli'lalOIUIiM CJ>llCpaJ1bHblt:l
00 IIOHlpaKTY C opraHal>tIi, OCYllleCTBJlSlIO- 3alloH«06one-
IlIMMIi OPD, TpaBMb!, paHeHMI1, KOHTY3M, paTHBHO-
}lBe'lbSl, HBCl)'rmBIlII1X BCBSl311 cerO)"JacTlI- P03bICIIH()HAe.ll-
'M , np08e.neHI1I1 OPM " I1CKJ[IO'IaIOIUI1X TeJlbH()CTW'
"'" Hero e03MO)l(HOCTb .na.rIbHClllero <0-
TP}lnHIt'leCT8a < OpraHBMM, OC}lllIeCTBJUUO-
IlIMMIt OPD, YKa3aHHOMY Jlltuy 113 CPCllCT8
COOTBeTCTB)llOlliero 61OIDKeTiJ. BblnJIa'll'lBael'al
C.nI'lH08peMel-JHOe noc0611e 8 pa3Mepe nl1TI'I-
.I1CTHerO neHe)KHOrO COJlepA(.[HIt11t , }lCTa-
HOBJ1eHHOM 3aKOHOM nQpSlllKt HB3HB'IBeTCSI
neHCIU! no ItHHaJ1IU1HOCTIII ('I IOcT IE)
npll n()J]}f'IeHl'Il1 JlI1UOM, COTpYDHH'IaIOIlII1M 3allOH Pecny6lIl1-
00 1I011TpaKTY C ()praHaMI1, OC}'IUeCTBJI.IIIO- KI'I EeJIapYCb
IlII1MI1 OPD, TeJIeCHblX nOBpe)l(.1lCHl'I ",- ...06 ()nepaTI18HO-
CTynltlJwcro B CIJSI3M C ero Y'IOCTItCM B npo- p03bJCIIHO lIS1-
BeJleHl111 OPM 11 11CIU1104BIOIlII'IX JU1H Hero TeJlbHOCTIt»
B03MO)KHOCTb .D3J1bHdiwcro CorpyllHI1'1ecr-
!la, eMy 8blnJIa'l.118aeTCSI 113 CpeJlCTB COO1BeT-
CTBYIOIUcro 610DAreTd eJlI1HOBpeMcHHoe no-
c06l1e paJMepe nJlTItJIBTHCrO .r:\eHe)KHOrO
COJlep)KBHItJl " 11 YCTaHORJIeHHOM IBIIOHOM
nop.llJllle Ha3Ha'!aeTC.II neHCI1J1 no l'IHBaJ1It11-
HOCTII('!. 8 CT. 17)
np" nOJlY'leHI1I1 rpa)l(.llaHI1HOM, COTPynHI1 3aKoH
'1BIOI.l.lMM < OpraHaMI1, OCYllleCTBJI.IIlOllIltMI1 Pecny6JII1KI-I
OPD, YBe'lbSi 111t60 I1HOrO nOBpe)l(.1leHlt11 KaJaXCTdH
JJIOPOBbSl, nonY'IeHHoro B CBH3111 C ero Y4B- «06 onepaTI-IBHO-
CTMCM B npOeelleHl'Il1 OPM, c"'y BblnJIa'l.lI- P03bICIIH()HDe.ll-
eaeTC.II e.nI'lH()8peMeHHoe n()c06l1e 8 pa3Mepe TeJlbH()CTI1»
nITHJIeTHerO neHe)KHOrO COJlep)l(BHItH """
cOTpynHI-I'laIOI.l.lMX "' nJIBTHoli OCHOBt, ,
paJMepe nHTII ronOBblX cyMM MItHI-IMaJ1bHOH
JapaGOTH()H nJIaTbl JU1H cOTpynHI1'1BIOIllI1X Ha
6eJBOJMeJDHoi1 OCH08e ('I. 8 CT. 23
.8

1 2 3
npH n()J]}f'leHl'IH J1I1UOM. corpYDHH'lalOllIHM 3aKoH KblprblJ
no IIOI-ITpaKI)' C opraHa"tI1. OCYllIeCTMHIO- CKOft PCCnv6lIHlIl'I
WI1"tI1 OPll, TpaBMb!, paHeHI'IH, IIOHTYJIfH, 06()nepaTI1BH()-
}lBe'lbSi. Hacl)'!U'lBIlII1X BCBSl3H cerO)"JacTl:I- P03bICIIH()H./leH-
OM B npOBeneHHI1 OPM " HCK,1fO'UIIOWHX RJlbH()CTl'I»
"''' Hero IJ03"'O)l(HOCTb nanbHeHwero 00-
Tpy.aHH"IeCTB!I opraHHMl'I, OCYllIeCTBJUUO-
IlII1MI1 OPll, YKa3aHHOMY 1111UY 113 cpellCTB
COOTBeTcTl1ylOme.-o 610JVKeTa BbmJIa"lI1BaerCSI
enHHOBpeMeHHoe noc0611e B pa3Mepe MTI'I-
JleTHerO neHe)KHoro C()llepJl(aHI'ISI 11 B YCTa-
::H;il1:::O:K cHT3;:,;rneTCSI
ECJU'I cellp<:Tl-lblH nOMOLUHHIl npl'l BblnOJlHe- 3allOH
""" aallaHI1S1 cy6'beI<Ta onepaT(lHoii ..leJ1- JIanm:liCKoii
TCJ1bHOCTH n0J1Y4(1]1 HHBaJll1!!HOCTb 111111 no- Pecny5J1111111
rlf6 nH60 HaHeceH ywep6 ero 31lOpO!lbIO I1}IH «060nepaTIIII1Hoii
HMYllIeCTBeHHbIH Ylllep6, eMY 111I11 'UleHBM lIt:llTeJ1bHOCTI1»
eroce),tb l1b1nJla"lHBaIOTCJI noc0611J1, neH-
'"" """ KOMneHCaUHI1 COOTBeTCTBHI1 0
3aKOHOM. npenYCMHTpHomOUlHM T8KI1e BbJ-
nn8Th! ./lOJl)l(HOCTHblM JlHuaM Y'Ipe)l(1!eHl'ltI
COOTBeTCTBVlOl1lerO cy6beKTa onepanlBHoJ:i
- AeSlTeJ1bHOCTI'I " 2 CT. 32)
npl'l n()J1}f'1CHI'II1 J111L10M, corpy.uHI1'U1IOWI1M 3allOH Pecny5J1I1-
"0 IIOHTpaKry c oprnHaMlf, ocyweCJBI1RIO- 1<11 MOJ1110Ila..06
WI1MI1 OPIt, paHeHI1S1 I<OHry3IJli, YBe4bSl onepaTI1BHO-
11J1I1I1HOH T]J3BMbl BCBSI3IJ cero Y4HCTIJeM B p03blcIIHoH.ueR-
npOBe.lLeHIUI OPM 11 I1CKJ1IO'UlIOWI1X j]JUI -reJ1bHOCTI1
Hero B03MO}l(HOCTb JJ,aJ1bHeHWero COTpy.DHI1-
"IeCTB3 eMY BblnJ13'II1BaeTCSI e.lLrIHOBpeMeH-
"00 noco.611e " p":'!Mepe nSlTI1J1erHerO ne-
He}l(HOrO COllep}l(aHI1S1 " e YCTaHOBJ1eHHOM
JaKOHOM nOpHllKe HaJHa'iaeTCR neHCI1R no
I1HBaJ1I11lHOCTI'I('1. 9 CT. 16)
-'" BOJMeweHtte " rll6eJ1tt
B03MeweHI1e ywep6a npl1"1I1HeHHoro. rl16e- 3allOH Pecny5J1I1-
J1blO, YBe4beM J1116o. I1HblM nOBpe)KJ\eHl1eM 1111 Ka:Uu:T3H
3t\opo.BbSl, CHSl3aHHbI},t C Y4BCTl1e},t B npoue- ..06 oneparl1BHO-
.ueHIWl OPM, np0I1311011I1TCR 113 cpellCTB op- pOJbICIlHOHl\eR-
raHOB, ocymeCTBJlSllOwlJX OPIt nOpRllKe, TeJ1bHOCTI1»
:SII1/;I1CTPOB Pec-
flpotJoVKeHue maan. 9
99

OKOII'laHUe marin. 9
1 2 J
B cJlY<Jite m6ei1li mu.m, COT-py.!\HlJ<JitlOwero 3aKOH
00 1I01-ITpaKI)' C opnma!>tIi. ocyweCTBJlJIIO- Kblprb13cKoH
WlJMlJ OPll, H CBII3H C ero Y4HCTHeM B npo- Pecny6nliKlJ
BelleH111i OPM CeMbe nocrpa.aaBwero I{ nl1- 06 onep3TI{BHO-
UtlM, HaXOlllllUliMCJI Ha ero I{)I(.JllJHCHlJl1. 113 P03bICIIHOH!leJl-
cpellCTB COOTBeTCThYlOwero 61OJl)KeT3 Bb]- TeJlbHOCTI{"
nJla'tliBaeTCJI ell11HOBpeMeHHoe n()C06He "
pa3Mepe .!\ecJITIrneTHero .!IfHOKHOro cO.llep-
>K3Hl'IJI nom6wero I{ B YCTaHOBJIeHHOM Ja-
IIOHOM nopSl.!\lIe Ha3Ha<JaerCJI neHClJSI no
CJ1Y'l81O nOTepl'l KOpMliJIbua ('I. 9 CT. 21)
1I0J]OHHH.KaCatOUtileCHCOlUlaJlbHO-llJlaBOBOii3aUtllTbirplOl\J\aH.CO-
HeHCTBytOU\HX OpraHallt. OC)1Jl«TB.f1HtOU\HM OPD.. npUYCM3TpHBatOT cJle-
.lQ'tOUtileCTaTbH3aIlOHOB.
CnITbSl 18 4Iellepa.nbHuro JaKOHa ..06 onepaTI{BHO-p03b1CKHoti HeSl-
TCJ1bHOCTIi».
CTaTMI 13 3aKOHa YI<p"lllib] ..06 onepaTl{eHO-p03bICKHOt:! JleUeJIb-
HOCTH'>
CraThll 17 3aKoHa Pecny6nJJKI'I l)enapycb ..06 onepamBHo-po3blcKHoll
HeSiTenbHOCTW>
CTaTbSl 23 3aKOHit Pecny6nliKH Ka:klttTaH ..06 onepaTHHHo-
p03bJCKH0f1 Ae.llTeJlbHOCHt..
CTaTbSl 21 3aKOHa Kblprbl3cKOH PCCnyOJ1I1KH ..06 onepanlBHO-
p03bJCKH0f1 .!If.llTeJlbHOCHt...
CTaTbH 30, 31. 32 3allOHa JTaTBHHclIOH PCCnyOM'IKH «060nepaTI'IB-
Hofl.!\eJlTeJ1bHoCTH».
CTaTbl{ 5, 11 3alloHa JTI'ITOBCKOH PecnyfumKI'I ..06 OnepaTI'IBI-IOH
.!IfHTt':JlbHOCTI'I»
CTaTbSl 16 laKuHa Pecny6J1I1KI'I MWUloBa ..06 onepaTI'IBHO-
p03b1CIIHOH !leIlTCJlbHOCHI»

Ta6J11iW! 10
0cti0BaJIHJIllJ111 npOBClIeHlt1l OPM. I1pe.ayclllUl)Jlflflll>x
:JaKOHOllaTenbHI>IMH aKTaMlt, pemaMftl11lp)1OIllIII!H OP)]
BCTpaHaxCHI"H6a:nHH
HUWfeH()f'QHUe
f{, OCHOBGnUH np08etJeHuH OPM 3aKOHOtXInre.JbHblX
"In QJem08.pelflGMeH-
mupVl(Jll(UX OPJI
I 2 3
I OCH08aHI1I1 D,.1R onepaTHB.. u-pa3(,I( "';»U co-
- -DBO=::j;pe::;:=: c;;::::ro q,ellepanbHb!
lleJIa(<J.lcT.7) JaKOH ..06 ()ne-
paTlJBHQ-
P03!>ICIIHOH.u e lj-
TeJlbH()CTW'
Harrw-me B036y;K;J,eHHoro yr0J10BHOrO lleJla 3allOH PccnytiJ1li-
(n. I CT. 8) KI1 6eJ1apycb
..06 onepawBHo-
P03!>lcIlHoHlleH-
TeJlbHOCTW'
Harrw-Wle B036y;K;J,eHHoro yr0J10BHOrO lleJla 3allOH PecnytiJ1li-
(n.<ta» 'i I" 10) Kli KaJa-.cT:jH
..06 ()nepaTIi8Ho-
p03!>lcKHoi111el'l-
TeJlbHOCTIi
Harrl1'il1e B036YJK.lleHHQro yr0J10BHoro lleJIa 3allOH Kblpr!>l3-
(n. I CT. 8) CKOH Pecny6J1IiIlI1
..06 onepaTIiBHo-
pOJbICKHoi1.ne$l-
TeJlbHOCTIi»
HeB!>I5!CHeHHble 06cn:>HrenhCTBa no B036YJK- 3aKoH Pecny6J1lJlG1
.neHHOMY yr0J10BHOMY lleJIY (n. «a» 'i I CT. 7) MOJl!IOBB
«06onepaTliBHO-
P03bICKHOf1n,e$l-
-I :'"'. nO",""H' 'O'=. 011. Y""HH' TeJlhHOCTIi»
(]>ellepanhHbI
npoKypopa 11J111 onpelleJIeHIfSI cy.ua no yro- 3aKOH ..06onepa-
nOBHblM lIeJIaM, HaXOllHWI1MCH B 11)( npol13- TIJBHO-po3b!CIIHOH
Bo.ncTBe('i.3CT7) .ueSlTeJlbH()CTI1»
101

flpoiJrJnJK:el/ue ma6J/. 10
1 1 J
nOPY'leHI1.11 CJ1ellOBaTeJ1S1, YllaJaJ-J1U1 npOKY 3aKoH Pecny6J1If
papa 11J111 onplle!1eHI1Ij CYllH no yrOJlORHblM KH 6JlapYCb
nenaM, HaXOllSlIUHMCSI .  npOIf3BOllCTBe ..o6onepaTHBHo-
(n. 3CT 8) pOJblCIIHOH nII-
TeJlbHocnl»
nl-lCbMHHbI nOpy'lHHII CJ1nOllaTeJUI M 3allOH Pcny{iJ1H-
YKaJaHl'lSl npoKypopa, a TalOKe onpene!1eHH1 KI1 Ka.JIXCT6H
cyna no yroJloBHblM nC!1aM. HaXOlUllUHMCSI B «06 onepaTHDHo-
npol13BollCTBe :'YrX opraHoB (a63. «n" '1:. I pOJbJCIIHOH ne.ll-
CT.W) TeJlbHOCTW'
nOPY<JeHl'I.II opraHiI llOJHaHHSI, CJlellOBaTJlSI. 3aKoH Kblprbl3-
YKaJaHI'ISI npoKypopa HJ111 onpene!1eHHSI CYllH CKOH Pecny6,!1HKI1
no yrolloBHblM !le!1aM, HaX01lSl111I1MCSI B 11}( ..06oneparHBHo-
npoH3BollcTBe(n. 3CT 8) pOJbICIIHOH!le.ll-
ttJ1bHOCTI1
Meponpl'lSlTIlli onepanfBHoR neHTeJJbH()CTH 3aKoH
MOryr 6blTb npOl1elleHbl B COOTBeTCTBl111 C J1arBikKofi
Ol1lenbHblM nHCbMeHHblM 3MaHI1eM, npell- Pecny{iJ1HIIH
CTaBJ1eHHbIM npo"ypmypofl, Y4p)KJIeHHSlMI1 «060nepaTI1BHOH
n()CY!le6Huro paCCnellOl1aHl'I.II (npeliBapl'l- neSlTeJJbH()CTH"
TJ1bHoro C,JIenCTIII1S1) 11 cYLle6HbIMH }"1pe)lt-
neHl1.11MH no yronoBHblM nenaM. HaXOLlSl-
111l'lMCII 11 !leJJOnpOHJBOllCTBC 3TftX Y'lP>Klle-
I-mii(n. I 'J.2CT. 16)
Z OCBOBaHKSI M' nOJQ"leHKII paJBellbIBaTeJIb-
tlOiiHtll!topMawlK
He npenynlOTpCHO 4IelleparrbHblH
JaKOH «06 onepa-
THBHO-paJb!CKH()A
neSiTenbHOCT»
HeotixOlll'lMOCTb n()J]}"1cHl'ISI jX1JBenbIBaTeJ1b- 3aKOH YKPaHHbl
HOi1 HH<!:>0pMaUHI1 B HHTepecax 6e30nacHO- «060neparHBHo-
CTH o6lUeCTBa 11 rocynapcTBa (n 3 CT. 6) p03blCKHOk
e!lTeJ1bHOCTIII»
HeotixollHMOCTb nOJl}"1eHI1!1 pa3BeLlblBa- 3allOH Pecny{iJ1H-
TeJ1bHOfi I1Hl]>opMaUHH B I1HTepecax ()6IUe- KH Ka3axcraH
CTBa, rOCYJlapCTBa H YllpenneHHJI era 3KO- «06oneparHBHo-
HOMH'leCKOrO 11 060pOHHOro n()TeHllHaJIa p03blcllHOHneJl-
(a6J. "'ll"'J. I CT. IO) Te!1bH()CTl'I"
102

npoiJrmJlcel/uema6J/.1O
1 2 3
I H, "",,'MO,"'"O 3aKOH KblprblJ-
CKOf1 Pecny6JJIfKI'I
«06 OnepaTlfBHO-
P03bICIIHOH!leJl-
TeJ1bHOCTIf»
3 OCtiOBaHtiS DJlS onepaTHBHO-pa3HClWOro npo-
tlJ80)\CTBa
3.1. CUBWlJe IfJBeCTHblMIf opraHiiM, ocy- (]:IeJ\epaJ1bHblii:
rueCTBJlSllOl1!l1M OPn. CBelleHIfSl 0 nplJJHa- 3<lKOH «06onepa-
Kax n()llroTaBJlI1BaeMoro, cOBepwaeMoro lJJlIf TIiBHO-p03bICKHOM
COBepweHHoro npOTIfBonpaBHoro Jlt:S1HIfSl, a Jlt:S1TeJlbHQCTIf»
'JalOKe 0 JlIfL!1'IX, 'co nOJ\roTaBllIfBalOl1!I'IX,
COBepWBlOl1!l1X "'" COBeplUlfBWIfX, ,"
HeT nOCTaTOLJHblX lliIHHbIX lLf1S1 peWCHIfSl 80-
npoca 0 B036YJKJIeHlfl1 yrQJ10BHoro "'''
n. Ill. I CT. 7
HaJIl1l1lJe lIOCTaTOLJHOMlJHl)xlpMaUl'l1f 0; 3aJ<OH YKPalfHbl
- rOTOBSlILlIfXCJI 1fJ11f COBepILleHHblX HeycTa- 06 onepaTIfBHO-
HOBJIeHHblMI1 nl1LlBMI'I npecTynneHmlx (a63. I P03b1CKHOi1.ne.ll-
n. leT 6). TeJlbH()CTIf>'
- J1I1LlBX, roTOBJll1!l'IX lJJIIf COBepWIfBWI'IX
- [JDecrvnrreHlfe(a63. I n. I CT. 6)
CraBWlJe IfJBeCTHblM ()praHBM, ocyurecm- 3aKoH Pecny6JJ1f
JlSllOl1!HM opn, CBCneHIfJl 0 nOnrOTaBJIIfBae- Kif 6CJ1BpyCb
M()M, COBepWi1eMOM KJlIf COBeplllCHHOM npo- 06 onepitTIfBHO-
TlfBOnpaBHO1 ne.llHl1lJ, no K01OPOMY 06$13<1- pOJblCKHof1ne.ll-
TeJlbHO D.1CC1Ie1l0BaHI1 (a63. 4 CT. 81 TeJlbH()CTI1»
nOCT)'nI'lBWBSI " 0511. ocyweCTBJlSlIOWlfe 3allOH PecnytiJ1l'1-
OPll. IfHl]>opMiiLlI'IJI 0 nQlJ,rOTaBJ1IfBaeMOM, Kif KaJaXCTaH
COBepWBeMOM lJJIlJ cOBepweHHoM npaBoHB- ..o60nepaTIfBHo-
pyweHlf11 (a63. 4 1I Icr 10) P03bICIIHOH!leJl-
TI:JlbHQCTIf»
CTaBwI1e IUBeCTHblMI1 opraHBM, ocywecTB- 3aKoH KblprblJ
JlJlIOWIfM opn, CBeneHIfR; CKOH Pecny6JJlflllJ
- 0 nplUHitl\BX noLIroTaBJIIfBaeMOro, cOBep- «06 onepaTIfBHo-
waeMoro 1fJ11f coeepllleHHoro npoTBOnpaB- P03bICIIHOH!leSl-
HOro AeSlHIfSl, B TalU<e 0 nlfLlBX, ero nOllro- TeJ1bHOCTIf
TaBJIIfBalOWI1X, coeepwalOWl'lx " cOBep-
WIfBWIfX, eCJ11f HeT !lOCTaTQ'lHblX J\aHHbIX./UISi
pemeHI1J1 Bonpoca 0 eo16yJl(J]eHlJl1 yrOJ10BHO-
roAeJlB (n. Ill. I CT. 7
103

2
flepBI1'IH8S1 IfH4JopMaumr 0 nOllronmJlIfBae-
MOM 11]]1{ COl\epweHHOM npecTyn.f1eHIUJ,
TlpeC1Ym-Jo AeJITeJ1bHOCTI'I mm He3allOHHblX
no:roJlax flpeAYCMorpeHHoe 38KOHOM one-
paTlfBHOe pacCJ1ellOn3Hlfe npeCl)'m-Jb!X neSl-
Hid! npOI'lJBOJ1flTCSI: B cJlY'lae HeYCTaI-JOBJIe-
tU1JI CORepWItRWIiX I1X ]1ItU, npH H3J1WWIIt
nepBl1'lHOH npoBep04HOH Ifl-«]>opM8U1f1f 0
npecTYIIHOHneSlTeJ1bHOCTI1 mu!;;' (. ])
CTIlRWl1e 1f311eCTHbiMIt opraH8M, OCYWecTE\-
JlSllOlliHM opn, CBelleHIUI 0 npl'lJHal<IDt nOMO-
TIlBI1lJBaeMoro, coaepwaeMOTO 11111{ COBepweH-
HOro npornoonpaoH()ro neSlHI'II1. no I'XJ'IOIXINY
c6JrJ.IrenbHO npoll3l!OlI.CTBO npe1lBapl11el1bHOrO
CJ1ellCTDl'lSl{a63 In <<:10"'1 I CT 7
3.1. CTaBwl1e I'IJBeCTHblMIf opnuJaM, ocy
meCTBJ1mOIllIfM opn, CBCJ{eHIfSl 0 C06b1TI1S1X
rum neHCTBIfJIX. COJ!JalOlUI'IX yrpo3)' rocy-
napCTBeHHOJ:l, BoeHHoH, 3KOHOMI1'ieCKOHI1/111
;jJ;I'I; O;c;cnl Pili (no11n 2
Han(j"ll1e .nocT3'JO<IHOi1 I{H4>opMau11 0 pa3-
f!f:llbIMbHO-n01lpbl{lfiOii nCSlTCJ1bHOCTI1 cneu-
CJI)0K6 IfHOL-rpaHHbIX rocYlk\PCm, oprm.ul3a-
ufI If OT.QeJ1bHbIX lUJU npOTHB YKpaltHbl
863.5 n. I CT. 6
llocrymmwflSI B opraHbI, ocyrneCTB.IIAlOllil'le
OPll, I'IHI]>OpM8UlfJl 0 pa3f1CllbIBaTeJ1bHO-
nOllPblBHblX 8KUlUIX cneUCJIy6 l'IHOCl'p:lH-
::o(:  :tapOJIliblX opr81i1'l-
CraBwl1e 1'I3BeCTlibl).t1'l opr"HaM, ocyureCTB-
ltSIlOWI1M opn, CBl:JleHI1R 0 C06b1TSlX 111111
Jlei1cTBI1RX, C()JJIalOllU])( yrpOJY rOCYAapCT-
BCHHOii, BoeHHOii. 3KOHOMI1"1eCKoiJ
3K0110rH"IeCIlOH 6eJOnacHoCTH (nolln. 2 n. 2
CT. 8
3_3_ CTaBWl'Ie 113BeCTHblMI1 opraHHM, ocy-
weCTBJlSlIOWI1M Opn. CBelleHl'ISi 0 J1l'1WIX,
cKpblBalOWHxcH OT opr"HOB JlOJHaHl'IJi.
CJlCJlCTBl'IR 11 cyna 1'IJ11'1 YKJIOHRIOWI1XCR OT
\'rOlOBHoro HaKaJ:lHI1S1 In 3 'I. I CT. 7)
104
flpoiJrmJlcel/ue ma6J/. 10
3
3aKoHlhrroBctwfj
Pecnyti11l'1l1l'1 06
OnepaTl'IBHOH
neRTe11bHOCTH»
3allOH
Pecny6:II'IKl'I
M011J1QBa
06 onepaTl'IBHO-
p03bJCIIHOii neR-
TCJlbH()CTl'I"
(]:IellepaJJbHblfj
3aKOH 060[]epa-
THBHO-pOJbICKHOH
neSlTeJ1bHOCTM"
3aKOH YKPaJ.1Hbl
06 onepaT1'I51i0-
pOJblCKHOrl
ne!lTeJ1bHOCTI1"
3aKoHf'ecJ1)'5nmcH
KHJaXCTaH
06 onepaTl'IBHO-
pOJblCIlHOii
neSlTeJ1bH()CTH"
3aKoH KblprblJ
CKoii Pecny6J1l'1l1l'1
06 onep:lTl'IBHO-
P03bJCIIHOii neR-
TeJlbH()CTH"
f1>t:.aepaJ1bHblii
3aKOH «060nepa-
THeHO-pOJbICKHoi1
neRTeJlbHOCTl'I"

npexku.1ICel/ue ma(j/l 10
I 2 3
Harrw.me nOCT3TO'lHOA HI-Jl)JopMaUl'll'l 0 n- 3al<OI-I YKP81'1Hb1
uax, CKpblBalOll.!l1XCSI or opraHOB pacclIeno- 06 onepaTl'IIJHO-
08HI1.11, YKJ10HSllOlUI1XCSI OT ()rob108HIUI yro- P03blcIIHoi1ne.ll-
J10BHoro I-IBIIB3BHliJI (a63. 3 'I. I CT. 6) Te.llbHOCTIf"
CTaBwI1e 1f3BeCTHblMif Opral-l8M, ocyweCTB- 3aKOI-I Pecny6J1If
J1J1lOlUIfM OPD. CBel\eH(JJI 0 J1I1QHX, CKpbl- IIIf 6ellap}'Cb
081OUlI'IXCSI ()T opraHOB n03H8HI1J1. CJ1ellCTBIfSl ..060nepaTIfBHO-
11 cyl\a 1'1111'1 YKJ10I-lSlIOWI'IXCSI OT yr0J10BHOrO P03bICIIH(li1neJl-
Hil.K..1..J3HIUI (a63. 5 CT. 8) Te.llbH()CTI'I»
nOcryn1'lBUJ8S1 . OED. ocyweCTBJ1S1lOlUl'le 3all01-l Pecny6JlIf-
OPD. I'IHl)xlpMOlWlSi 01I1'IUBX, CllpbIBaIOWI'IX- KI1 KnaXCT"H
C.II OT opr8HOB n03H8HI1S1. C.I1enCTBIfSl 11 cyn8 06 onepOTlfflHO-
I'IJ1H YKJ10HJlIOWHXCJI OT yronoflHoro HBKa38- pOJbJCKHoi1ne.ll-
HI'ISI (003. 5 'I. I CT 10) TI:J1bHOCTW>
CT8BWl'le H3BeCTHbl"m oprOHaM, ocyweCTB- 3allOH Kblprbl3-
lIJllOlUHM OPD, CBelleHI1.11 0 nl1uax, CKpbl- CKOrt Pecny6JJIfKI'I
B810WHXCSI OT oprOHOB l\03H8HI1S1. CJ1enCTBIfSi ..o60nepaTHBHO-
1'1 C)'M HJlH yKJ10HI'lIOWHXCSI OT yrOJloBHoro P03blcIIHof1ne.ll-
HBKaJaHI'ISI (nolln. 3 n. 2cT. 8) TI:.I1bHOCTH
CToBwl'le H3BeCTHblMH oprBHaM, ocyweCTB- 38110H Pecny6JJH-
JlSllOlUlfM OPD. CBel\eHI1.11 0 nl1uax, CKpbl- KI'I MOJUlOB8 ..06
BalOll.!l1XCSI OT oprBHOB n03HHHI'ISI, CJ1TBI{JI onepOTI'IBHO-
11 CYM I'IJ1If YKJ10I-lSilOll.!l1xCS! OT yro.l1oBHoro P03bICKHOf1n,e.ll-
H8Ka3BHHSI (a63. 2 n. "b»"I.ICT_7) TeJ1bHOCTH»
3.4. CTaBWl1e H3BeCTHblMH opraHaM, ocy- cJ>enepa.nbHblH
rueCTBJlSlIOWI'IM OPD, CBeneHI1.11 0 nl1uax 6e3 JaKOH ..06 ()nepa-
BeCTI'I npOnBBWHJ( (J 06HBpy)l(eHHH Heono- TIJBHO-P03bICKHOi1
3H8HHbiX TpynoB (n 4.. I CT. 7) neSll"e.llbHOCTI'I"
Hanl1"1e nocT8To'JHOW Hl)JopMaUMI'I 0 6e3 3aKOI-I YKP81'1Hb1
BccTHnpOmtBwHJ(JlHl.lax(a63.3<j. I CT. 6) ..06 onep8TlfBHO-
P03blcIIHoi1ne.ll-
Te.llbH()CTIf"
CTaBwI1e 1f3BeCTHblMif Opral-l8M. ocyweCTB- 3aKoH Pecny6JJ1f
lISllOlUl'IM OPD. CBellCHI1S1 0 6e3BeCTHOM OT- KH 6ellap}'cb
CyTCTBl'I11 rpaJK1l8H I1 06H8py)l(CHI1I1 Heono- ..060nepaTIfBHO-
3HBHHblJ( TpynOR (003. {, CT. 8} P03bICKHOi1
nCSlTCJ1bH()CTH"
105

flpoiJrJnJK:el/ue ma6J/. 10
I 2 3
nOCT)'mi(lwaSl . OElI, OCYWCCTBJllllOWI'IC 3aKoH PecnytiJ1I'I-
OPLt. I'IHIJIOPM3UI'ISI 0 6e3BeCTHOM orcyJCT- KI1K.UIXCT"H
(\1'11'1 rpa)l(JlaH 1'1 OOOapyJKCHI'I1'I Heon03ttaH- 06 onepaTI'IBHO-
HblX TpynOB (003. 6 <I. I CT 10) p03b1CIlHOHne.ll-
TeJ1bHOCTI'I
CraBWw IBBeCTHbI"UI opraHHM, OCYWCCTB- 3allOH KblprblJ-
J1S1lOlUI{M opn, CBelIeHl'I.II 06e3BeCTHOM ()T- CKOH Pecny6JJI{KI'I
CyTCTBl'IlJ rpa)l(JlaH lJ 06ttapyJKeHlJlJ Heono- .,{)6 onepaTliBHO-
JHHHHblX TpynoB (n()lln 4 n leT. 8) p03blcllHOHne.ll-
TeJlbHOCTI{»
CT!1BWl'le 1{3BeCTHblMI{ opraHaM, ocyweCTB- 3aKOH Pecn)fiJ1l'IKI1
JIJlIOWI{M OPll. CBellCHI{SI 0 6e3 BeCTH npo- M())]1I0Ba
naBWI'IX I{ 06ttapYJKeHI111 HeonU3HHHHblX .,{)6 onepaU1BHO-
1pYno(l (a6J. I n «b»cJ7) P03bICIIHo i1 n ell -
- TeJlbH()CTI{>'
3.5. 3anpocbI .npyrl1X opraHoB, ocyureCTB- cJ>etreparlbHblH
JIJlIOll!I'IX OPll. no OCHOBaHI'IIIM, YKaJaHHblM 3aKOH.,{)6onepa-
BHacTOSlll!eH CT<1Tbe(<I 4cJ. 7) TI'IBHO-p03bICKHOH
J],f:nTeJ1bHOCTIi»
3anpOCb1 llpymx opraHOB. OC)'U.IeCTBI1nlO- 3allOH KblprblJ-
lUl'IX Opn, no ()CHOBaHI'ISIM. YII<13aHHbIM B CKOH Pecny6JJI{KI'I
HfiCTOnl1..lfH CTflTbe(n. 4cT. 8) 06 onepaTlilJHO-
p03blcllHOHne.ll-
TeJlbHOCTI{
Meponpl'lllTJI onepaTBHoj{ neSlTeJ1bHOCTI1 3aKOHJ1aTBl{li-
MO,," 6.m npoBelleHbI (I COOTBeTCTEI1{ C CKOH Pecny6JJI{KI'I
nl{CbMeHHblMI{ .J.1.IIBJleHI1HMI{ DPYIlIX c)fibeKTOEl ..06 OnepaTI{(lHOH
onepHI1IBHOHl!eSlTe]1bHocm(n 1<1 1 CT. 16) .DeSlTe)1bHOCTI1»
3.6. 3anpoCbl MeJK11YHapOIlHblX npaeooxpa $enepanbHblH
HI1TeJ1bHbIX OpraHl13aLlI'li1 . npaBOOXpaHlJ- 3aKOH .,{)6onepa-
TeJlbHbIX opraHOB I'IH()CTp<1HHbIX rocyll<1pCTEI TI'IBHO-p03bICKHOH
B COOTIJeTcml'll'l C MeAULytllipOilHblMI'I Iloro- .nenTeJ1bHOCTI'I
BOOOMI{ POCCI{HCKOH tDeneroLll{1{ {<I. 6 CT 7}
3anpocbl MeJK11YtllipOllHblX npaBooxpaHI1 3aKoH Pecny6JJl{-
TCJlhHblX OpTaHOB lJHOCTpaHHblX rocynapCTB KI1 6c.apycb
BCO<:fI1jf"fC"JBI1I{ C AorOBOpaMI{ (cornall!e- «06 onepaTIilj}jo-
HI1!1MI1) 0 npaBOBoH nOMOlUl1 (n. 4 CT. 8) p03bJCIIHOHnen-
TeJlhHOCTI'I»
106

3anpOCbl Me)l(1!yHapOllHblX npaBOO>.pJHHTeJlb-
HblX OpraHH3aUHH H npaEOO>,paHHTCJlbHb!X
opraHOB HHocrpaHHblX rOCYl!apCTB B COOTBeT-
CTBHH C l!OroIlOpdMH (COr.naWeHHJIMH) 0 npa-
BOBOtI: nOMOlli (363. «r» <j. I CT. 10)
 Me)l(J],)'H8pO)\HbIX npwoo'lJi'!HHTeJlb-
HblX opraHHJJ.LlI1f1 H npaBUO.'qJaHHTeJlbHb!X
OpraHOB I1HOCTpaHHblX rocyn.apCTB B COOTBeT-
crBHH C l!OfOoopar.IH (cOrJIaUleHHSlMH) () npa-
BOooii nOMOIllH, pam$('jupoBBHHbIMH Kblp-
rblJCIIOH Pecny6.r1HKOH (n. 6 cr. 8)
MepO[]PHJlTJI onepaTBHOH l(eSlTeJlbHOCTH
MOryr 6blTh npOl1etleHbl II COOTBerCTBHH C
3aJlBJ1eHIfSIMH HJlH norOBopeHHOCTblO MeJK-
lIYHapOllHb!X H J.apyf3eJKHbIX npaBooxpaHH-
TJlbHblX Y4pC)!(l]CHHH H Y<ipe)l(lJeHHH rocy-
napCTBeHHoti 6e30nacHoCTH 11 06OPOHbI
(n 3 <i 2CT 16)
3.7. llocTBHOBJ1eHHe 0 npHMf:HeHI1I1 Mep
6e30nacHocTH B OTH()WeHHH 3alUHlUaeMbiX
nHU, ()cyweCTBJ1JIeMb1X ynoJlHOM()'leHHbIMH
HH TO rOCYl!apCTBeHHbl"tH opraHHMI1 B no-
pH1llle. npellYCMOTpeHHOM 3aKOHOll3.TCJIbCT-
BOM POCCHtiClWti <lJellepaUI'IH ('I. 5 CT. 7)
IlOCTBHOI1JlCHH 0 npHMeHeHIWl Mep 63-
onaCHOCTH B OTHOlUeHHH 3alUHIUaeMbIX nHLl,
<X."}'Il1e\."TBJIJleMbIX ynOJ1HOMO'leHHbIMH Ha TO
rocyn.apCTBCHHbIMH OpraH3..\1H II nopfUlKe,
npellYCMOTpeHHOM 3BIIOHOllaTenbCTBOM (n 5
CT. 8)
4 OCIlOBaHI1I1 llJISi onepaTIIBHoH l1poBepKH onpe-
U!JleHHOHK3TffOIIIDII]JIDII.!J.III1(Cl1xcorJla-
- : OpraHbr, OcyuJCCllIJIJlfOWl1e OPll, B npe-
llCJJ8X CIIOHX []QJ1HOMO<iHH BnpHBe TalOK
c06lipaTb naHHble, Heo6xollHMbre llJIJI npH-
HSlTHH pClUCHHH 0 AonycKe II cBellcHHHM.
COCTaBJ1J1IOWHM rocynapCTBeHHYIO raHHY
(a63. )1 CT. 7)
107
flpoiJrmJlcel/ue ma6J/. 10
3
3aKoH Pecny6J1H
IIH Ka3BxcTaH
«06 onepaTHBHO-
P03bJCKHOHncH-
TeJlbH()CTHn
3BIIOH Kblprbl3-
CKOf1 Pecny6JJHKI'I
«06 onep:rrHBHo-
P03bICIIHOHl!eJI-
TCJ1bHOCTH
3aKOH
J1aTBHCKof1
Pecny6JJHIIH
«06onepaTHBHoH
l(eSlTeJlbHOCTH»
<IJe.l!epMbHblii
3<1KOH ..06 onepa-
TI'IBHO-p03bICKHO
llCJlTCJ1bHOCTH»
3allOH Kblprbl3-
CKOH Pecny6J1HKH
..06 onepaTHBHo-
P03bICIIHOHl!eR-
TCJ1bHOCTH»
<IJe.l!epMbHblti
33.KOH..o6onepa-
Tl'leHO-p03bICKHOn
neSITeJlbHOCTH"

3anpOCbl nOJlHOM04HbiX rOCYJJ£IPCTBHHbIX
oprm-roB, Y'lpe;KJIeHIfi1 If OpraHl13aUIf 0
npOBepKe nl1U B CB>l311 C I1X nonYCKOM
rocy.uapcrBeHHOW, BOCHHOW If CJJy;;<c1)HOW
T,uiHe in. 2CT.6
OpraHbl, OCYUJeCTRJUllOlUfle OPLl, B npf:l\,C1IiIX
CBOIfX nOJlHOMO'lIfi1 BnpaBe TIllCKe cof3Hpm.
naHHble, x"pa"-repll3}wUJe 111f<jHOCTb rpa;;<-
lIaH. Heo6xorufMble lL'ISi nplfHJlHJSI peWeHI1S1 0
lI()nYCKe K CBeD,eHI1S1M, COCTaB!1S1IOUJHM rocy-
1lHHI-IVICITai1,"",a6311CT.8
OpnlHbI. ()cyweCTBJISIIOWl1e OF'Ll. B npelle
118X ceoeii KOMneTeHLllf1f no co6CTBeHHOii
I1HlflllfaTIfBt 111f60 IUJlfUlfaTlfBe I'IHblX rocy-
napCTeeHHbIX opraHOB BnpaBe TaKJKe c061'1-
paTb JlaI-IHble, xapallTtplf3}llOWl'le 111f<jHOCTb,
He()6xolllfMble DJ1S1 nplfHSlTI'ISI peweHIfSi 0
lIOnyCKC K CBl:lIeHIfJlM, cocraBJlJlIOIUIfM ro-
cyn.apCTBeHHYIO Tat1HY. nepe'IeHb KOTOpblX
onpcaeJlJlerCH Ka6lfHeTOM MIfHI1CTpOB Pec-
nv6n1f1l1f Ka3aXCTaH (a63. 4 n 2 CT !O)
OpraHbl. ocyweCTB!1S1lOlUlfe OPLl, B npeneJlax
C130IJX n011HOM0411f1 BnpaBe Tall)l(e CQoopaTb
JIaHHble. He()(ixOlll1"tb!e DJ1S1 nplJH.IITI'ISi pewe-
HI1J1 0 1I0nYCK K cee.aeHIfJlM, COCTIlHIISlIOIUflM
rocy.uapCTBeHH)'IO TawHY, I1J1If K pa6oTaM,
ceSl3aHHbiM C )KCnJlYil'13L1l'1eil 061>eKT013,
npellCTaBJIJlIOIUIfX nOflblIUeHHYIO onaCHOCTb
DJ1S1 )l(If..lHI1I'1 31lopOBb>l nlOneil, a TIllCKe DJ1}1
QKnv"A(dH)IUei1 c""... fa63. 2 n. I CT 8
OpraH. ocywecTDJlJlIOIUIfH OF'Ll. B npeneJlax
cBoeii KOMneTeHLlfllf Bnp"Be co6l'1pan. Heo6-
XOlllfMble IIm-JHble. xapaKTepl'l3YlOwife 1111'1-
HOCTb non03peBaeMblx, 0 lIonycKe II CBe.ne-
HIfJl"t. COCTaBJIJlIOIU"t rOCYll8pCTBeHHYIO
Taf1Hv In «3<> 'I. 3 CT. 7)
4.2. OpraHbl, ocyweCTBJlIllOlIllft: OPLl, e npe-
lleJIax CBOI1X nOJlHOMO'lIfH BnpaBe TalOKe
c06lfpaTb lIaHHble, Heo1)xolllfMble DJ1J1 nplf-
HIITHII peweHIfJl 0 1I0nYCile K pa60HIM, CflSI-
3aHHbIM C :}KCnJ1yaTaUlfew 061>eKToD. npen-
CTaB!1I1IOUlIfX nOBblweHHYIO onaCHOCTb DJ1J1
::11!::.11{. c_TlOKe DJ1S1 OK-
108
flpcXJo'l.1/Cf!lIuema(j/l.1O
3
3aKOH YKPalfHbl
«06onepaTlfBHO-
p03bICKH0i1
lIeIlTCJ1bHOCTW>
3allOH PecnytiJlIf-
Kif 6eJlapycb
«06 onepaTlfBHO-
p03blclIHOHlIeJl-
Te.llbHOCTIf
3aKOH Pecny6Jm-
Kif Kn'l1tCTIlH
..06 onepaTlfflHo-
pOJbJCKHoii.ne.ll-
TeJlbHOCTW>
3aKOH Kblprbl3
CKOH Pecny6J1IfU1
«06 OnepaTlfBHO-
P03bJCIIHOfll!fH-
TeJlbH()CTIf»
3allOH PecnytiJlIf-
Kif MOJJ1l.QBa ..06
onepaTBHo-
P03bJCKHof1.ne.ll-
TeJlbHOCTIf»
cJ>enepa.llbHblf1
33KOH«06 onepa-
Tl'leHO-pOJbICKHOn
.DCIITeJlbHOGTIf"

2
o llonYCK!: K pa6QTaM, CtHl3aHHb!M C ::IIIC-
ruJyanlueij 06'b0::1ITOII npeJlCT3BJ111IOLUI'IX
nOBblwclmylO 3K0J10rWleCKYJO OnaCH()CTb
(a63 )1 CT. 8)
OpraHbI. ()CYllieCTBJllllOLUl1e OF'JI.. II npelle
nax cBoeti KOMneTeHUHIf no c06CTBeHHo!1
I1HJ.1UIillTlfee J11J60 HHI'ILlI'IBTlfee IfHblX rocy-
napCTBeHHbIX opraHOB BnpaBe TaKJKe co611-
paTio .lmHHble, xapaKTeptl3YlOllU1e 111'1'1HOCTb,
He()\'ixOllHMble J]J1S1 npHHSlTlUI peweHlU1 0
lIOnycKe 11)11{ II pa6QTaM, CBII311HHbiM C 311C-
ruJyaTlIUl'letj 06'beKTOB, npellCTlIBJ1J1IOWI'IX
nOBblwclmylO aBapl'lIHYJO If 3KOJlorl:l'JeCKYIO
onaCHOCTb a63 4 n 2 CT. 10)
OpraHb], ocyweCTBJ111lOlUlfe OPJI., B npeneJlll't
COO"" nOJlH()MO'mti BnpaBe TIU0Ke co6I1paTb
naHHble, HeU6\QWUlble DJ1S1 npHl-JSlTH$I perne-
HlHI 0 110nVCKe K CBeJ1eHmlM, COCTaBJIJI.IOUlJ.1M
rocy.r:mpCTB-eHHYIO -raj:jHY, 111m II pa6cmJ., CBH-
3aHHbIM C :JKGnllYdT.nmei'i ofueKToB, npej{-
C1'31i11S1}()ll!IJX nOBblweHHYIO onacHOCTb JlJlSI
}IU13HH 1'1 :yropoBbJI J11O.Qei1, II TaKJKe !l.1U1 OK-
rJlmlOWefic';"rTH 1003. 2n leT 8
OpnlJJ. OCYWCCTMJlIOWI'IH OPll. B npenenax
CDoeW KOMneTeHUl'I1'I DnpaBe C0611paTb He06-
XOlllfMble naHHbre, xapaKTepl:l3YIOlUife J11f<1-
HOCTb n()llUJpeBaeMblx 0 .nonycKe K pa6oTaM.
(SI..';:'MJ c:'KJ10rlf\.JeCKYIO onac-
4.3. OpraHbl. ocyweCTBJUllOlUlfe OPLl, B npe
.!\eJ1iiX CBOIfX no.HOM04Ifti BrrpaBe TalOKe co-
611paTb JUlHHble He06xOillfMble l1J1S1 nplfHJ1TI1S1
pelUeHIfSi 0 .!\Onyclle II }"Jacr1O B OPll W11f 0
.!\OnYClle K MaTepl1aJ1aM, nO!1}"JeHHbrM B pe-
'JIbTIlTeeeOCVlIiec-moc HIfSi a63.!JCT 7
OpraHbI, ocyweCTIIJ1S1IOWlfe OPll, II npelle-
nax CIIOIfX n()J1HOMo'mi1 BnpaBe TalOKe co-
611paTb JUlHHbre, xapailTeplf3}llOllil1e nWi-
H()CTb rlXUKJlaH, He06xOlll1).tble WI.II nplfHSI-
TlfSl peWeHI1JI 0 nonycKe K Y'IacTHIO B OPll
ru1l1 nocryne K MitTepl1aJJaM, n0!1Y4eHHblM Ii
pe3YlIhTaTe ee ocymeCTBJIeHIfSl. llaHHoe no-
1I0)KeHlfe pacnpOCT]JaHJleTCSI till cy.!\eti. clIe-
.!\OBaTCJ1eii If nOOKvOODOB 363. 12 CT. 8
109
flpoiJoJJJK:el/ue ma6J/. 10
3
3alloH Pccny{iJ1H-
Kif 6ellapych
«06 OnCpaTIfDHO-
P03blcIIHoi1ne.ll-
Te!1bH()CTIf»
3aKoH PecnYW1H-
Kif K.:uaxCTaH
..o6onepaPIIJHo-
P03bJCIIHotineJl-
re!1bHOCTIf
3allOH Kbrprbl3
CKOf1 Pecny6JJIfKI1
..o6onepaTIfBHo-
pOJbJCKHoi1neJl-
Te!1bHOCTIf
3aKOH Pccr.)f3"'iii'iKH
M()!11l0Ba
«06onepaTlfBHO-
P03bJCKHof1neH-
Te!1bH()CTIf"
$enepaJIbHblfj
38KoH..o6onepa-
TI1BHO-P03bJCKHOti
JJ,eJlTeJ1bHOCTIf»
3allOH Pccny6nlf-
IIIf 6eJlapyCh
«06 onepaTIfBHo-
P03blcIIHoi1ne.ll-
Te!1bHOCTIf

2
OpraHbI. ()cyureCTBJISIlOWl1e OPD. II npelle
nax CBOCH KOMnCTCHUl'I1'I no co6cmcHHoH
('jHI'ILll'lanIB 111160 ItHI'ILlItaTI'IBe I'IHblX rocy-
JJ,3.pcTBeHHblx opraHoB Bnpal1e TflKJKe co611-
paTio llal-JHbJe, xapailTeplf3YJOume J1I1'1HOCTb,
Heo5xo!llfMbie DJ1S1 npl'lHRTI'IJI pelllem1ii 0
JlonYCKe II Y'1OCTI'lIO II OPD 111m 0 JlOCTyne K
MaTCpl1aJ1aM, n0J1Y4eHHblM II pe3Yl1bTare ee
OCvweCTBJleHI'IJI a63. 5 n. 2 CT 10)
OpraHbl, ocyweCTBJ1SUOWlte OPD, 13 npelle!18X
CBOIJX n0J1HOM0411i1 BnpaBe Tall)l(e co611paTb
naHHbJe. Heo6xo.ml),tb!e DJ11 np!1H!lTIUI peme-
HI'IJI () ll()nYCKe K Y'JaCTI'IIO B opn 11111'1 0 11()-
:;ell =:=::H:'! tJY]lb-
OpraH. ocyweCTBJHIIO!UIff1 OPD. II npelleJIaX
CBoeM KOMnneHUl'l11 DnpaBe C061'1pm'b He06-
:XOlll'IMble nafiHb[t. xapailTeplll3YlOWl'le 1""1-
HOCTb nOl103pemleMblX 0 JlOnYCKe K Y4:«:nJlO
II opn 111111 0 1l0nYCKe K MaTepl'laJ1aM, nOJlY-
'IeHl-Jb!M II XOlle ee ocyweCTBJ1eHI1J1 (naHHoe
;:;B p.npTJ1;;C;) Ha CYlldl 11
4.4. OpraHbl. ocyweCTBJ1J1IOWl'le OPn.. II
npene!1ax CDOI1X nOJ1HOMOLJI'IH BIlpalJe ulla<e
c06l1paTb lIaHHble, Heo6xOllltMbie DJ1S1 npl1-
HRTl1n peIlleHI1J1 06 YCTat-1OlJJIeHlf11 l'IJlI'I nOll-
nep)K8HI'II'I C JlI1U()M OTH()WeHl'lti COl]JYLIHI1-
ea a64 ;BKe 1'1 npOBeLIeH1'I1'I
OpraHbl, ()cyweCTBI1S!lOUme OPll, II npenen:.uc
coo"", nOJlHOMO'll'Iti BnpaBe "faK)Ke c05HpaTb
lIaHHblt. xapal<"fepH3YKJWlfe JlI'I'iHOCTb rpaJK-
J\aH, tre06XoJ\ItMble J]JISI npI1HSlTS1 peweHl'lii B
CIJJI3I'1 COI<2IHHlJeM IV1I'1 cUJ\ejjCTBeJ<.1 B no.l1-
rOTOBKe 11 nnOBeileHl'I1'I OF'M (003. 13 CT. 8
OpraHbI, OCYl1!eCTB.-unOl1!l'It OPll. B npeLI
nax CBOI'IX n011HOI04I1ii BnpaBC TaK)KC co-
611paTb naHHble. He06x()J1I'1Mble J]JIJI npl'lHJI-
TI'IJI peWeHI'IJI 05 YCTaHoBJIeHl'I1'I 11111'1 nOJ1-
J\epJK8HI'II'I C JlI1UOM OTHOWeHl'lii COTp)'J\HI'I-
npl'l no!\rOTOBKe It npOBe!\eHl'I1'I
OPM OOJ. 2 n. 3 CT. 8
110
flpoiJrHJJlcel/ue ma6J/. 10
3
3aKoH Pecnyfum
KI'I KaJaXCTaH
06 onepaTItBHO-
P03bICIIHOiillCH-
TeJlbH()CTI'I"
3allOH KblprblJ-
cKoii Pecny6111t1l1'l
.,()6 oneparl1BHO-
pOJbICIIH()Hlle.ll-
TeJ1bHOCTW>
3aKOH Pecny6J1I1KH
M()J1ll()Ba
060nepaTl'lflHO-
P03bICIIH0i1l1CH-
TeJlbH()CTI'I»
(tIeJ1epanbHbJi1
3aKOH 06onepa-
TBH(I-po3l>lCKH()i1
ne.llTeJlbHOCTI'I"
3aKOH Pecnywm-
KI'I f)eJlapycb
060nepaTl'lflHO-
p03bICIIH0i1 neH-
TeJlbHOCTI'I
3allOH Kblprbl3-
CKOi1 Pecny611ItKI1
.,()6 ()nepaTI'IBHO-
P03bICIIH()Hlle.ll-
TeJ1bHOCTI'I»

-
2
OpraH. OCYWCCTB/1J1IOW"M OPD. (I npCllax
cfloefi IIOJ.mCTeHUIU'I BnpaBC co6ltpan Hc06-
XO!ll'lMble lial-JHble. xapal<TCpl'l3YlOWI'IC )]"''1-
HOCTb nOll03peBaetb!X. ()O 0ll:l33HI'II1 1'1)]1'1
coneflcTBl'I1'I B OpraHI13aUlfif 1'1 npOBCneHl'Il'I
OPM(n. «C»<j.3CT. 7\.
4.5. OpfaHbl. ocy!UeCTBJ1IIOWl'le OPn. B
npCllenax CBOtiX nOJlHOM041111 BnpaBC TIllOKe
c06l1paTb .naHHhIC, Hco6xOllltMbie W1J1 npl1-
HJlTItJI peWCHItJI 0 BbIJ{a..e pa3pCWCHItH Ha
:::b KTIB.;. 11 QXpaHHyIO lICH-
OpraHbI, ocymcCTBJImOllllte OPD. B npCll,f:-
J1ax CBOItX nOJ1HOM0411i1 Bnpaec Tall)KC co-
6HpaTb HaHHble. xapailTeplf3}lJOume JlI1'.-
H()CTb rpa)l(1!aI-J, Hc06xo.rUJMbIC lJ)!.II nplfHSI-
niSI perneH"" 0 Bbtaa'le pa3perneHitti Ha
::b TIBi It ()XpaHH}l1O neJi-
OpraHbI. ocyweCTBJ1S1lO!Ulfe OP[L B npellC.I12X
ceoe" KOMneTeHUlf11 no COOCTBeHHojj I'IHI1-
[.!H3T11Be Jlw60 ItHI1Lman1Be ItHblX rOC}'.ll<1pcT-
(lCHHbIX opraHOB BnpaBC T(11)KC co6HpaTb
naHHb1C. xapallTCpl'l3YlOWI'IC nWIHOCTb, Hc06-
XO!ll'lMblC lJ)1JI npl'lHJiTIfJi pernCHI'I£'I 0 BbllW'lC
":eSleb:3KT21'1. 1'1
OpraHbI. ocymeCTBJISUOWl1e OPD. B npelle
nax CBOIfX nOJIH()M()'lIfti BnpaBe TaJOKe co-
6iipaTb naHHble. HeoO}[()J!HMble DJlSI nplfHSlTI'I.II
perneHI1.11 0 BbUia'l.e pB3perneHiffl Ha 'I.aCTHYIO
.nereKTIJBHYIO oxpaHH}'1O .neJlTeJ1bHOCTb
a63. 2 n Scr 81
OpraH. OCYllIeCTI1JISIlOllll1H OPll. B npeJreJI8X
CBoeH KOMneTeHLll111 BnpaBe c06l1paTb He-
06XOi\I1Mble D,aHHble 0 I1b1ll8<1e paapeweHI1i1
:JI::n !le:TB;  oxpaHHYIO !leSl-
4.6. OpraHbl. oCYlUeCTBJ1S1I0111lfe OPll. B
npelleJI8X CBOI1X nOJ1HOMo'lIfi'i BnpaBe TBlCKe
c06lfpaTb D,aHHble, Heo6xoi\IfMble DJlSI nplf-
HSlT.II peweHIfSl () nplJeMe HB c.y".ri'iy B op-
raHbl. OCYllleCTBJlSlJOlliHe Opll. llaHHoe no-
:e:e :er:3.  cC:'D.:.
111
flpoiJrHJJlcel/ue ma6J/. 10
3
3aKOHPecTl}WnfKJl
MOJ1ll()BB
..06 ()nCpaTIfBH()-
p03blcIIHoH.ne.ll-
TeJIbH()CTIf>'
4IellepaJIbHbl!1
3"KOH «06 onepa-
TI!HO-p03b1CKHOi'i
JJ,eJlTeJIbHOCTI1»
3allOH Pecny6JII1-
1111 f)eJIapycb
..06 ()nepaTIfBHO-
P03bICIIH()i'i.ne.ll-
TeJIbH()CTIf>'
3aKOH Pecny6JIIfKl1
Ka:nxCTaH
«06onepaTl1BHO-
P03blcIIHOH.neH-
TeJIbHOCTH»
3allOH Kblprbl3
CKOi'i Pecny6JIIfKH
..06 ()nepaTIfBH()-
P03b1CKH()i'i.ne.ll-
reJIbHOCTI1
3.-IMJti Pecny6JII1KIJ
MOJIllOI18
06 onepaTltBHO-
poablcIIHoH.n e H-
TCJIbHOCTIf
3aKoH PecnywlIf-
KIJ f)eJIapycb
..06 ()neparIfBH()-
P03b1CKHoi'i.ne.ll-
TeJIbHOCTIf»

OpraHbI. OCYWCTWllJlOwe OPD. EI TlpJle-
nax cBoei1 KOMTleTeHUl'I1'I no c06CTBeHHoi1
HI'IUI'I3TI'IBe J11'160 I'IHI'IUl'IBTl'IBe I'IHblX rocy-
napCTBeHHbIX opraHOB Bnp"Be Tal0Ke c061'1-
paTio JlaHHb1e, xapaKTepl'l3}llOWIJe J11'1'lHOCTb,
He06xoJlI'IMbie JIJ1IJ npl'lHSlT1'I1J peWeHlJH 0
nplJeMe H!I pa60ry 1'1 CJ1YJl::6y B OBlI:, Ha-
UOHMbHOH 6e30naCHOCTI'I, BoeHHOM paJ-
BellK1'I, HaJ1()rOBOW CJ1YJl::6bl. CnYJl::6y oxpaHbl
Ilpe-..II1J1fHTa Pcny6nlJlIl'I Ka3aXCT!lH (a63. 2
n. 2CT 10)
He npellYcMOTpeHo
4.2. OpraHbl. 0CYIUCCTBJ1IjIOWI'IC OPD., B
npe1le1lax CHO('JX n01lHOM041'1H BnpaHe TalOKe
c06l'1paTb naHHble, Heo6xoi\I'IMble JIJ1Ij npl'l-
HIjTItJI peWeHItJI no 06eCne'leHI'lIO 6e30n!lc-
HOCTH OpraH()B, OCYIUeCTBJ1IjIOUlI'IX OPll
(863.15 CT. 7)
OpraHbI. oCYUleCTBJ1IJIOWl1e OPD. B npeJle-
nax ceoeii KOMneTeHLll'I1'I no C06CTIJCHHOii
I1HI'ILll'laTI'IBe J11'160 I'IHI'ILll'larl'lBe I'IHblX rocy-
napcTBeHHbIx opraHoB BnpaBe TaKJKe Co6lJ-
paTio naHHb!e. xapaKTepIJ3YlOlUl'le J111'IHOCTb
rpaJKJlaH. He06XOJWIMble JIJ1J1 npI'lHJlT1j pe-
WeHI'lf! n() ()6eCne'leHI'lIO 6eJOnaCHOCTIJ ()P-
raHOB, OCYIl.[eCTBJ1IjIOWI1X OPD (a63. 3 n. 2
CT. 10)
OpraHbI, ocywecTWlljlOWl'le OPD. B np{:Jle-
nax CElOI'IX nOJ1HOMO'll'lti Elnp,me TalOKe C()-
6111paTb naHHble. He06Jo.QllI'IMble llJ11j npl'lHIJ-
TI'IIJ peWeHl'I1J n() o6ecne'leHI'lIO 6eJOnacHo-
CTI'I opraHOB (Jlon}l(HOCTHbIX Im:u). OCYIl.[eCT-
B.IJOWUX OPD (a6J. 15 CT. 7)
OKOH'ful/ue ma6J/. 10
3
3aKOH1
Ka:HXCTaH
06 onepaTltBHO-
pOJbJCKH()f!.ne.ll-
renbHOCTW>
3aKOH KblprblJ-
CKOW Pecny6J1I'1KIJ
«060nepaTltBHO-
pOJbICIIH()f!ne.ll-
Tei1bHOCTI'I»
4IellepanbHblti
JaKOH ..06 onepa-
TI'IElH()-pOJbICKH()M
.ueHTi1bHOCTI1»
3aKOH Pecny6nI'lKH
Ka38XCTdH
..06 ()neparI'lElH()-
pOJbICIIHoi1.l\eH-
TenbH()CTI'I"
3allOH Kblprbl3-
CKOf! Pecny6J1I'1KIJ
06 onepaTI'I13HO-
pOJbICIIH()f!ne.ll-
TeJlbHQCTI'I»
112

OcHOB31111H WlH IIJI0BeJJ,eIlIlH OPM npeJJ,YCMOTpellbi CJleJJ,yIOJllIIMH
cr3TMIMH33KOHOB,
CT3TbH 7, 10 Q)epa;rbHoro 33KOHB ,,06 onep3TlII8HO-p03blCIlHOfi
Ae.llTeJ1bHOCTI'I».
CT3TbH 6, 9 3alloH3 YKpaHHbl ,,06 onepaTH8HO-p03bICKHoti .ueSj-
TeJ1bHOCTH».
CraThI'l 8, 10 3aKoHa Pecny6J1HKH f)eJJaPycb «06 ()nepanIBHo-p03bICK-
Hoti.ue.llTeJ1bHOCTI1».
CT3Tblf II, 16 3aKoHB Pecny6JIlfKIf Ka3a1[CT3H «06 onepaTHBHo-
p03bICIIHOH.Qe.llTeJIbHOCTI1»
CTBTbH 8 3aKOHa Kblprbl3CKOn Pecny6JII1KIf «06 OnepaTI'IBHO-
P03bICIIH()fjne.llTeJ1bHOCTH»
CTarbH 16, 23 3aKoHB JlarBl1ticKol1 Pecny6JII1KI1 ..06 onepaTlfBHoH
Ae.llTeJ1bHOCTI'I»
CT3TbSl 3 33KOH3 JlHTOBCKOH: Pecny6JIHKH ,,06 onepaTHBHoii .ueSl-
TeJIbH()CTH»
CraTbI1 7, 9 3aKOHB Pecny6JII1I1H MQJtilOBa «06 onepaTIIIBHO-po3b1CIIHOii
Ae.llTeJ1bHOCTI'I».

Ta6J111W1 11
OCHOBaHHHDJ1l1npeRpIW,IfIIHHOPM,nx
:JaKOHo.mrreJlbHblMH BKTaMH, pefitaftlftll1lJlYlOlH Opn
BCTpaHaxCHl'u6a.nu"
HOILl,leH06QHUe
M UcH/MOHWI imH npeKpaeHUH UPM JDlo.OIftJdumeJlbHblX
"In OKm06, Jlf'llOveH-
mumlfOIJ./UX OPP.
I 2 3
I DeJ1() OnepaTI'IBHOrO Y'JeTa npellparuaercSi B lJ>ellepaJIbHblH
CJ1Y'laSix peWeHI1H KOHJqJerHblx 3aJIa'l OPn, 3aKOH «06 ()nepa-
npellYCMOTpeHHblX CT. 2 HBCTOSlll!ero lJ>elle- TI1BHO-po3bICKHOH
pa11bHoro JallOHa (a6J. 4 CT. 10) .uCSlTCJ1bHOCTW'
Oncpan1lJHaSi npOBeplla npellpawacTcH . 3aKOH PecnyD!111111'1
CJ1Y'JaSiX peWeHI'ISI KOHllpeTHblX 3Ma'l Opn, f)eJJapyCb
npellYCMUTpeHHblX CT. 3 HaCTO.lll.J.lCrO 3aKoHa «06onepanJBHO-
(CT. 10) p03blCKHOH .neH-
Te.bHOCT"'"
OPM npeKpawalQTCSI npi1 BbillOJ1HeHI1It Ja- 3aKOHPtxny6J]I1I1H
.ua'l, 1IJ1H pCUlCHI'IH KOTopblX I'IX npODC!leHl1e Ka3axcTaH
6101110 npe!lyc),10TpeHo (a63. 2 CT (6) «06 onepanlBHo-
p03blCKHOii neSl-
Te.bHOCTI1"
OPM npeKpal1!afQTCH npl1 BblnOJ1HeHl111 Ja- 3aKOH KblprblJ-
na'l, 1IJ1H PCWCHI'IH KOTopbrx I'IX npOBC!lCI'II1C CKOH Pccny6J1I1KI'I
6101110 npe!lycMorpeHo (a63. 1 'I. I CT. II) «06onepanIBHo-
p03blCKHOH .neSl-
TCJ1bHOCTW>
Dcna no onepaTBHOMY )"Ie'!)' (!](:J1a no one- 3aIlOHJ]aTBIIIH-
paTI1BHblM npoBepKaM 1'1 OnepaTI'IBHblM pa3- CKOH Pecny6JJI1KI'I
pa6oTKa)'l) npellpawalOTcSI, eC!11'1 BbmOJ1He- «06 ()neparI'lBH()H
Hb! npyre 3aJIa'll'l OnepaTI'IBHOH .neSlTe.llbHO- .neHTenbHOCTI'I»
en'! (n. 3 'I. 4 CT. 23)
Onepan111Hbie JJ,C:ileTBItSI npet<pawalOTCH npl'l 3BKOHJ]I1TOEICKOH
paCllpblTl'I1'I npecrynJ1CHI'IH (a63. S CT. 3) Pecny6JJ1'I1I11
«06 ()neparI'l8H()H
.neHTeJIbHOCJl.I»
OnepaTl111HBH npoBepKB npeKpBJJJ,3CTCSI . 3aKoH Pe<:nyD!1I1KI'I
CJ1¥'JaSix peWCHItSI KOHKpeTHblx JaJla'J Opn, MO!11l0Ba
npClIYCMUTpeHHblX CT. 2 HaCTOHwero 3aKoHa «06 onepan'!BHO-
('I. 4 CT. 9) p03b1CKHOH
1leIITe;]hHOCnl
114

J 2 3
2 llen() OnepaTI'IBHOrO Y'-1tHI npellparuacrc B Q)ClIepa,1bHbIH
CJ1Y'13S1X YCTHHOB..1eHItJI o6crOSlTeJ1bCTB, CBIt- 3aKOH ,,06 onepa-
.neTeJlbCToyJOUU\X 06 06'beKTIiBHOi1 HeB03- TMBHO-poJbJCKHOi1
MO;t{HOCTl1 peweHI'IJI KOHl<peTHblX "' lleSlTeJlbH()CTH»
opn (afu. 4 CT 10)
OnepaTI'IBI-JaH npoBepK" npeKPaluaeTCA flpl'l 3aKoH Pe<:ny6J1I'1K
ycr3H()BJ1eHI'lIf 06CTOHTeJ1bCTB. CBl11leTeJIbCT- f)eJJapycb
BYIOWI1X 06 06'beKTHflHOi1 HeIJOJMO;KHOCTIi «060nepanlflHo-
peweH('jJj KOHKpeTHblx 3M2'! opn (CT. 10) p03blCKHOfi JleSl-
TeJlbHOCTIf»
OPM npeKJXIW,aK!TC>J np" ycr3HOBJ1eHI'II'I 3aKOH Pccny6J11'1111'1
06CTOSlTeJ1bCTB, cBI1./IfTeJlbCrnYlOUUlx 06 om.- Ka3aXCT3H
eKTHBHoJ:! HeB03MmKHOCT peweHRII n()CTaO- «06 onepanlBHo-
l1eHHb1X3a.rJa'l (a63 Jcr 16) p03bICKHOlleSl-
TenbHOCTIt»
OPM npeKpau.ra1OTCSI np" yCTaHOBJ1eHIU1 3aKOH Kblprbl3-
()OCTOHTeJ1bCTB, CBl11leTeJlbcTBYIOWI'IX 06 OOb- CKOt! PecnyfuJl1KI'I
eKfBHoi1 HeB03MO)KHOCT peweHI1J1 n()CTIlB- «06onepanIBHo-
J1el:UJbIX33./Ja<j (a63. 1'1. 2 CT. II) P03bICKHOH:J\eSl-
TeJlbHOCTtI..
OnepantBHaSi npoDepK3 npetq)8waeTC.II np" 3aKOH Pecny6J1I1KJ'1
ycr3HOIL"1eHIWI o6crOSlH:lIbCTB, CBIt1IeTeJ1bCT- MOJ1110Ba«06
BylOUlx 06 06beKTI'IBHOH HeB03MO)!(HOCT onep1TIfBHO-
peWeHI1.II KOHKj)eTHblX 3aJ1all. OPll (II.. 4 CT. 9) p03blCKHOtl: neSl-
TCJ1bHOCTIf"
3 OPM npe"IXtI1.!dIOIOI no IJblJlW1eHlflO 06cTOH- 3aKOH Pe<:ny6!1IfK
Te!1bCTB, I1CK.ruO'JalOlliX nplfBJIe'leHlfe npOBe- Ka3a'<CT3H
pJleMOrO 111100 K OTBeTCTBeHHOCTIf no OCH()Ba- «06ollepaTIfBHo-
HIfJlM, npt:lJ:}CMorpeHHbIM 3aKOHOiUlTeJ1bCT80M P03blCKHOii .!\eSl-
- PeCII);6I1KI1 K ua'«.TJH (a63. 4 CT. 16) TeJlbHOCTI1»
OPM npeKp:UillHOTCJI no BblJlBJIeHlf10 06 3aKoH KbIprbl3-
CTOSl"f(:J1bCTB, I'ICK.ruO'l.3IOWIfX npHB!1e'leHl'le CKO" PecnyfuJl1KH
npOBepSle"'lOro 1IltLl3 K OTl1eTCTBeHHOCTH no «060nep3wIBHO-
OCHOBaHI'IJlM, npenycMoTpeHHblM 3aKOH01l8- p03blCKHOii neSl-
TeJ1bCTBOM Kblprbl3clloH Pecny6J11f1l1'l (a63 I TeJ1bHOCTIf"
3 CT. II)
4 OPM npHOCT"HaBJIlfBlIOTC$! If npeKp"W3IOTCfI 3aKoH Pecny6.ru.1J(If
B CpOKH, npellYCMorpeHHble HOpM3THBHbiMif Ka3aXCT3H
ilKTI1MIt opraHOB, OCyweCTBJlSlIOWItX OPll, «06onepaTHflHO-
cornacoB3HHbIM('j C reHepilJlbHblM npollypO- P03bICKHOi! .!\eSl-
00\1 Pecn m('jKH Ka3aXCTaH 1a63. 5 CT. 16i. TeJlbHOCTIf"
flpotJol3lCf!l/uema6A.ll
115

I 2 3
OPM ocyweCTBJ1f1IOTCSI, npl'IUCTaHfinmma- 3aKOH KbIprbl3-
JOTCH H npeKpm.illUOTCSI II. CPOKIf. onpene- CKO Pecny6J1I1KI'I
l1S1e).tb!e npaBI'ITeJlbCTBOM Kb!PrbIJCKOH Pec- «06onepanIBHo-
nyfu!HKH (a63. 2CT II) POThICKHOHnefl-
TenbHOCTw>
"'-''''''''' nenCTBHSI """""""" "PH 3aKOH J1I1TOBCKO
I1CTC'ICHHI'I I1pCII)OIUIpeHlJoro yrorrOBHblM 33- Pecny6J1I'1I1H ,,06
KOHOJ\bCTBOM CpclKa E:IBHOC1JI (a63. 5 cr 3) onepaTltBHofi
neiITe;:[hHOCUI»
5 ECJlI1 II. Te'lel-U'le rneCTI'I MeC.IIueB He YCTa- 3allOH YKpalfl-Jbl
HOBJIeHbI JlaHHble, YKa3b1B3JOll!lte nplt- ,,06onepa-JltB-
3H8KH npecryI1IJeHHSI B lIeikTBHJIX mlua, B HO-pOJbICIlHOfi
OTH()WeHI'II'I KOTopbIX ocywecTB.lUlJ1IfCb ()ne- neHTenbHOCTIf»
OOTI'IBHo-roJbICKHbre MeDbl (a63. 3 CT. 9)
OPM ocyweCTBJ1J1IOTCSI, npIllOCTatrnBJIHlJa- 3aKOH Kblprbl3-
JOTCfI 11 npeKpawalOTCSI II. cpOKI1. onpeile- CKOH Pecny6JU'IKI1
J1J1e).tb!e npaBI'ITeJIbCTBOM Kb!prbIJCKof1 Pec- «06 onepanJBHO-
ny6J11'1111'1 (a63. 2 CT. II) P03blcJ<Hot!ne5l-
Te_bHOCT",'
ECJlI1 CBe.neHI'IJI. "' ()CHOBaHHI'I KOTopblX 3aKOH
111'1U() nOCTaBJleHO Hfi ()nepaTI'IBHbIH }"JeT, He J1aTBI'IHCKOH
n()llTBepllI'lJlI'ICb, l(!IHHOe JlI'IUO nOAl\e)Kl'IT PecnyfuJl'IlIl1
cHSlnnocY4eT3 (n.4<!. JeT. 23) 06 onepaJltBHofi
ne}ITe;JbHOCTIf»
OnepaTMBHbie nei1cTBIfJl npet<pawalOTCJI npM 3aKoHJ1I1ToDcIl0i1
HenOllTl1ep>Kl!CHIfIf nep13I11<1Hofi IfH41opMHuHI1 Pecny6J1MH'I
(a63. 5 CT. 3) .,()6 onepaTMBHO
neSlTCJ1bHOCTIf»
. .ucJla no ()ncproltDH()MY}"JCTy (LlCJJB no one- 3aIlOHJ1aTl>11H-
parnBHblM npoaep""- If OnCpaTHBHblM p83pa- CKOi1 Pccny6J1IfKIf
=al) npCIqJall1aIOTCSI. eCJJI1 npOBCp.lleMbli1 06()nepaTIfI1H()i1
HenOnTBeOlUUlCSI n. I 'I. 4 CT. 23 neSlTCJlbHOCTIf»
He npeLlYCMOTpCHO 3allOH Kblprbl3-
CKOH Pccny6J1IfKJ1
06 onep"THI1HO-
p03bICKHO neSl-
TeJlbHOCTI'I»
7 .fiena n() ()ne)J3TIIl1HOMY Y'lery (LlcJ1a no()ne 3aKoH
paTI1BHblM npOBepKaM It OnepaTl1l1HblM Pa:.!- J1aTBl1ticlloti
pa60n:aM) npeKPawalOTC.II. eCJlIf npecryn- Pecny6J1IfKH
:JlV:;d:=B.I'I 'lT c;nJ1eHl1e ..06 ()nepaTlfflHoi1
JlCHTeJlbHOCTIf»
flpodo."QJI.T!NUema6/1 II
116

OKOH'IaHlIema(jJl.11
J 2 3
He npe.1lycMoTpeHo 3aKoH Kblprbl3-
CKOH PecnyfumKI'I
«060I1epaTI'IBHO-
p03blCKHOti neSl-
Te.bHOCTIt»
8 llena no ()neparItBH()M)' )'4ery n()CJ1e I1X 3a 3aKOH
BepWeHlt1l XpaH1ITCR B )'CTaHOBJ1eHHOM 3a- J]aTBItHCIIOH
KOHON nopMKe It e Te'telme onpe.1le.lleHHO- Pecny6J1ItKI1
fO ItMCpOKa('t SeT, 23) «06 ()neparltnHoti
ne}ITe;:[hHocnl»
He npellycMoTpeH() 3aKOH KblprblJ-
CKOM Pecny6J1ItKH
«06 OnepanlBHO-
p03bICKHOH
neHTeJlbHOCTIt»
OCHOBa""" .I1JHI rIjleKpallt('HIIH OPM llJIe1lYcMOTpeHbl IOIIIJIMIl
CTaTbSlMH3aKOHOB,
CnrrbA 10 (fJe.aepaJ1bHOfO 3aKmm «06 oneparItBHO-p03bICKHOH neH-
HJlbH()CTIt».
CraTb!I 9 3aKOHB YKpaIllHbl «06 oneparnl1Ho-p03blCKHoii: nCSITI:/1bHOCTH".
CnITWI 10 3airoHa PecnyG..QI'IKI'I EieJIapYCb «06 ()neparI'lI1HO-p03blcKHol:!
neSlTCJlbHOCTIt».
CTaTWI 16 3aKOHa Pecnvfi.r1I'1K K,naxCTIlH «06 oneparnBHo-p03bICKH()1:!
.DeJlTCJ1bHOCTI'I»
CTarbSi II 3aKot-Ja Kblprbl3cKoH Pecny6J1ItKIt «06 onepaT(jBHo-
P03bICIIH()HAeRTeJ1bHOcTW>
CTarbSi 23 3aKowd J]aTBl1iJcIlOM Pecny6J11t1l1t «06 onepaTItBHOM neSl-
TeJlbH()CTW'.
CTaTbSl 3 3axoHa J]ItTOI1CKOii Pccny6J1I1KI'I «06 onepaT(jBHOH ne1l-
Te.llbH()CTIt"
CTarbSi 9 3aKOHa Pecny6J11t1l11 MOJU!()Ba «06 onepaTI'IBHO-
pOJbICKHOHl!C.ll.TenbHOCTI'I".

Ta6.rmua 12
0npe.Ire.netnre 3IIIOOJII:I.,1,1Jef>I B ClpBHax CHf H Ea.rrrHH
BajlHBHTOB HCnOJ1b30BaHHH pe:J.}'.lbTaTOeOPD
HOu."UII06t/HUe
'" BapUQHmhl UcnQ/lh3Q60HIlH pe-sy.lbmOmQ8 OPfl 30fWHOiJtlme.Ib#/b/X
.y, OlCm08,pei!./lO-
."IeHmupyIOUI,uX
OPJJ,
1 2 3
I JfcnOJlb30RaHHe pe:JY"bTaT08 OPD B )TOJIOB-
- Ho-npoueccyanbHoH cepe
1.1. KaK n()BOll DJ1S1 B036}')K1leHHSI yrOJl()BHO- cDellepaJIbHbltI
rOlleJla 3aKOH «06 onepa-
THBHO-po3blCKHOti
lle.!lTeJ1bHOCTH»
KaK np.IUIorH DJ1.!1 B036y)l(l\eHHSI yrOJlOBHoro 3allOH YKpaHHbl
n. «06onepaTHBHo-
P03blcKHotillell-
TeJlbHOCTHo>
K.K nOBOll DJ1S1 B036Y)l(l\eH(!.!I yronoBHoro 3aKOH Kblprbl3-
lIeJlS CKOH Pecny6JJI1KI'I
«06 OnepaTI'IBHO-
po3blCKHOM lIeSl-
TeJlbHOCT»
1.2. Kall ()CHOBaHHSI DJ1S1 B036)')Kl1eHI1S1 yro- cDellepaJIbHb!H
l()BH()roneJla 3aKOH «06 onepa-
l1'IBHO-po3bICKHOH
lle.!lreJlbHOCTI'I»
KaK OCHOBaHHI'I DJ1S1 B036yJK.llf:HH1 yroJloB- 3allOH YKpaHHbl
HOrolleJJa «06()nepaTBHo-
P03blcKHotilleSl-
TeJlbHOCT»
1.3.1J.;IS1 nOllrOTOeKri n OCYllleCTBJ1eHriSi (fJe.aepa.'JbHbltI
CJ1<:t\CTBHHbIX llCMCTBHM !.aKOH POCC('JM-
CKOH (fJepaUH('J
«06 onepaTBHO-
po3blCKHOM lIeSl-
TeJlbHOCTH"
118

flpwc!.J.1l('(!lIue ma(j/l. 12
I 2 3
11" npOeellel1lfS1 l1eOTJlmKl1b1X CJlellCTBel1- 3aK0l1 YKpaHl1bl
HbJX llefCTBl'lfj ,,060nepaTBIf0-
po3bICKH0f1 neSl-
TeJIbHOCT»
DiLlI n()llrOTOBKH 1'1 ()cyrneCTBJlel1l1S1 CJlellCT 3aKoH Pecny6
BeHHblXlldicTBI'IH JlI'IKI'I6eJIapycb
,,06 Onep"TI'IBHO-
P03bICKH()H neSl-
TCJIbIfOCTI'I"
L\.JIJI nOllTOTOBKH 11 ocywecroJIeHItJI CJle.rlCT- 3allOH Pecny6-
BeHHblx.u:ef1cTBl1ti nlJKI1 KaaaXCTaH
,,06 OnepaTI'IBHO-
P03bICKH0f1 neSl-
TeJIhHOCTH»
L\.JIJI nQlJ,r01OIJKH 11 OGyrneCTMeHHSI cnellCT- 3allOH Kblprb!3-
BeHHbJKlleHCTBI'IH CKOH Pecny6nI1KH
,,06 OnepaTrIBHO-
P03bICKH()f1neSl-
TeJIbHOCTrI"
npl'l n()nroToBKe 1'1 npOBelleHI'IH npellycMoT 3aKoHJ1aTBrIf1
peHHblX aaKOHOM CJIellCTBeHHbIX neticTlIHf1 CKOf1 Pccny6nI1KI'I
no yronoBHblM llenaM ,,060nepaTI'IBH()fj
.u:eSlTeJ1bHOCTH"
L\.JIJi n01lrOTOBKI'I 1'1 OCYWCCTBJlCHI'IJI CJlC.llCT- 3alloH Pecny6-
BeHHblX .u:ef1CTBlJf1, a TaKJKe B l11NeCTBe .u:o- l1HKI1 MO.l1.u:oBa
K,UlTeJlbCTB no yronoBHbIM AenaM ,,06 onep"THBHO-
P03bICKH()H neSl-
TCJIbHOCTH"
1.4. B Ka'leCTBC 1l0Ka3Hfel1bCTB no yro.l10B- lDt:.rJ.epanbHblf1
HblM .neJIaM nOCJ1e lJX npOBepKI1 B COOTBer- 33.KOH,,060nepa-
CTBI'II'I C yro.l1oBHo-npoueccyaJIbHbJM aaIlOH()- TI1BH()-po3bICKHOfj
llHTCJIbCTBOM lleHTeJ1bHOCTI'I»
B Ka-IecrBe 1l0KaaaTeJ1bCTB no yro.l1oBHblM 3alloH Pecny6-
nenSM B COOTBCTCTBI1I1 C yronOBHo-npouec- JlHKrI 6CJIapyCb
cya.l1bHblM JaKOHOJIaTeJIbCTBOM «06 ()nepaTrIBHO-
po3blcKH0f1 lleJi-
TenbHOCT'"
119

npoiJrJnJK:el/uema6J/.12
I Z 3
B K1NeCTBe .nOK3.3aTeJlbCTB no yrOi10HHhIM 3alloH Pecny6-
nemlM n()C.IIe I'IX npoBepKI'I B COOTBeTCTBI'II'I C nl'lKI'I KaJaxcTBH
yro.lloHHo-npoueccyanhHhlM J8KOHOLl8TeJ1h- ,,06 onepilTIfBHo-
CTHOM po3blCKHOW neSl-
Te':-'hHOCT"
B .n0IlB3b1BaHI'II'I no yrO.llOBHblM .neJTBM B co- 3aKoH KblprbI3-
n 0 nO.llO)KeHI1.11MI'I }'fOJl()HHO- CKOH Pecny5JII1KH
npoueccyanbHoro 33KOHQl1.8TCJIbCTBa Kb1p- ,,06 onep"niBHo-
rb!3CKoJ:i Pecny5JIl'IKI'I P03hICKH()W neSl-
TeJTbHOCTI'I"
B K8'leCTBe .nOKa3aTCJIbCTB no yrOi10HHbIM 3aKOHflaTBI'IH-
neJlBM TOJIbKO nOCJ1e npOBepKI'I B COOTBeTCT- cmH Pecny5JIl'IKI'I
.nn YrOJIOBHO-npou ecc YaJ1hHhIM KO.aeK- «060nepaTI'IBHOH
cOMflaTBl'I1'I .neSlTeJlbHOCTH»
B IIB'leCTBe nOKaJaTeJlbCTB no yro.lloHHhlM 3alloH Pecny6-
"",'M JUlIII1 MOJI.nOBB
,,06 onep"TBHO-
P03blCKHOW ne.ll-
TeJIhHOCT..
1.5. npeJlOCTaBJIeHl1e pe3yJlbTaTOI! OPLt op- cIJe.aepaJIbHbIH
raHY .n03HaHI'ISI, CJ1en()BaTeJlIO 111111 B cyn, B 3aKoH«060nepa-
np0l13BO.IlCTBe KOToporo HHXOJ1I1TCSI yroJIOH- TI1HHO-po3b1CKHOH
HOeneJ1() .ne.llTeJ1hHOCTI'I»
npellOCTaBJIeHl'le pe3ynbTaToB OF'Lt opraHY 3aKoH KblprbIJ-
.n03HBHI'ISI, CJ1eJlOBBTeJ11O I'lJII'I H cy.n, H npo- CKOH Pecny5JII1KH
1'13BOllCTBe KOTopOfO HO"""",,, yro.lloBHoe ,,06 ()nepan:!BHo-
neJlo po3blCKHOH .neSl-
TeJlbHOCT»
npl'l nOJlY4eHI111 onepaTI!HOH I1H!tJOP},18UHI1 3aKoH flanmn-
no yrOJl()BH()MY neJIY C() BceR nOJlY'1eHHOH B CKOH Pecny5JII1KH
npouecce onepaTBHoi1 .ne.llTeJlbHOCTI'I I1H- ,,060nepaTI'IBHOH
!tJopMaU11eR no 3TOMY neJlY n()J1)KH() 6bITb l{eSiTenhHOCT"
03Hil.1l0},tJleH() l111UO, PYKoBOJ1S1ll{ee XOJ1[)M
yrO.ll()BH()fO npouecca
1.6.lI.nSl n()J1Y'!eHI1.11 !tJaKTM'leCKI1X .nBHHhIX. 3aKOH YKpal1HbT
1I0Topble Moryr 6blTb .o:OKB3aTe}lbCTBaM11 . ,,06 onep"TBHO-
\lfO.II()BH()MneJle P03bICKH()W neSl-
TeJIbHOCT"
120

flpodOfiJ/CeHue ma6f1. 12
1 2 3
2 I1cnOJlb30BaH8e p e1 } 'J1bTaTOBOP .n,
l_I.lI.nJl npouelleHltlJ OPM 3aKOH Pecny6-
J1I1KH 6enapycb
«06 onepaTHBHO-
P03blCKHOH J\eSl-
TeJIbHOCTHo>
lI.nJl npOBelleHI1J1 OPM 3aKoH Pecny6-
nl1KI1 Ka].(lXCTaH
«06 onepaTBHO-
P03bICKH()W neSl-
TeJIbHOCTO>
lI.nJl npOBelleHI1J1 OPM 3aKoH KbIprbl3-
CKOH Pecny6JII1-
'"
«060nepaTiHIHO-
po3blCKHOH neSl-
Te:ibHOCTO>
'"', npOeeJ1eHIUI OPM 00 npenynpe)l(1le- 3aKoH Pecny6-
HI1IO. npccc'JeHI1IO 11 pacllpblTHIO npecl)'Tl- 1111KI1 MOl1lIoBa
J1eHI1H «06 onepaTBHO-
P03bICKH()H nelJ-
Te:ibHOCTlJ»
2.2. lI.n1J npellYnpe;KJIeHI1J1. npeCe'ieHI1IJ " (})enepanbHb!H
paCKpb!TI1IJ npeCTYnl1eHI1W, BblJ111JIeHI1IJ " JaKOH«060nepa-
YCTaHOBJ1eHI1J1 1111U, I1X nonrOTaMI1BaIOIUI1X. TI1BHO-poJbICKHOH
COl\eOW31OIUI1X11 coneOWl1(1WI1X lICHTCJI
11" npcnOTBpaweHlUl, npece'JeHI1JI 11 pac- 3allOH YKpal1Hbl
CJJen()BaHI1J1 npeCTYnl1eHl1w. paJBCnbllJaTeJ1b- «06onepaTIfBHo-
HO-nQJ1pbIBHblX nOCHrareJlbCTB np01I1B YK- poJblCKHOH neJl-
pal1Hbl. pOJbICKa npecTyJlHI1KOB 11 6eJ 8eCTIf TeJIbHOCTIfO>
noonaeWI1X]I1RI
'"', npenynpe)l(1leHI1IJ. npece'JeHlfSI " P" 3alloH Pecny6-
IIpbrrl1J1 npeCTYnJleHI1H 11I1K(\ 6eJlapycb
«06 ()nepaTIfBHo-
poJblCKHOH .ue5]-
TeJIbHOCTo>
'"', np e llynpe;KJIeHI1J1. npece'JeHI1J1 " pac- 3allOH Pecny6-
Kj)bITJUI npeCTYnneHI1H JlllKI1 Ka].(lXCTaH
«06onepaTIfBHo-
P03blCKHOH J\eSl-
TeJlbHOCTIfO>
121

1 2
,ami npCL!ynpe)!(,.!l,eHI1S1, npece'JeHI1S1 11 pac-
IIpblTl'ISI npeCTYnJlel-mw
2.3. lI.nSl BJ.aI1MH()rO I1H!}JopMl1pOBaHI1.11 nOLI
pa3JleJleHI'IH, ynOJ1HOIO'JeHHblX ocyweCTB-
JlSlTb onepaTHBHYJO ne.llTeJlbHOCTb, 11 npYnlx
nmmOOXOaHIfTCJ1bI-/I>1X 0 ral-lOB
3 HCnOJlb30B3Ulle PeJyJlbTaTOB OP,Q B lIJIo41H-
_TaKTH'IecKHXIK'JlAX
3.1. l\,.JUI I1H$OpMl'lpOBaHI1.11 rocynapCTBeH-
HblX opraHoB B COOl1IeTCTBl1l'1 C I'IX 110"'"1'-
TeHLll1ef1
,ami 03HaKOMJleHH.II pYKoElOlllITe/1ef1 I1HCTI1-
T)'TOB rocynapCTBeHH()H BJIaCT 11 ynpaBJIe-
HHJI, ynQJ1HOM04eHHblX I1MI1 mm JaKOHOM
n()J])KH()CTHbIX J1I1U. a TaK)Ke B YCTaHOBJ1eH-
HOM JaKOHOM nopSlllKc -rex nOn>KHOCTHbIX
J1HLl cy6beKToB onepaTBHoi1 JleSlTI'JlhHOCTH.
KOTOpblM 3Ta I1Hl)JopMaUl'lSl HeOOXOlIl1Ma WlSI
BblnOJ1HeHHJI c;I¥JKe6HblX 33J1aHHH. I'CJ1H ee
cOllep}KaHi1e CBSlJaHO C i1Cn()!1b30BaHl'IeM
nopY4eHHbix 3THMH nOJIlKHQCTHblMH 11IU.taMH
ol5.113"HHocrei1
4 n aBOBOI' 3Ha'leHHe 1'3 JlbTaTOB opn
nOJly'leHHRII. c nOIOWblO cpenCTB ()nepa
TI16H0l1 J\eSlTeJ1bHOCTH HH.pOPM2UIUl /l,\O)l(l'r
6bITb pacllpb1Ta B KOlle cyne61-j()H npouellYpbl
c npeilBapHTeJlbHO.-o pa3peweHlu1 reHe-
pa.nbH()rO npoKypopa 3anpewaeTCJI i1CnOJlb-
JOBaHl1e 1U-J4JOPMaWU'l, nOJ1Y'leHH() c n()-
MOWblO Cp!:!lCTB onepaTluJHO lleSlTJIbHO-
CTI1. He B ue.llBX. B03HI1KalOWI1X 113 caHK-
Lll10HI1pOBaHHOH 1:1Ie)({KIJ
B c.IIY'Jae HaMepeH11S1 rocYAapcTBeHH()W I1H-
CTI1TYLlI1I1 i'ICnOlIb30BaTb nOlIY4eHHYIO c no-
M()lllblO ()nep:rrI1BHb!X Cpe!lCTB I1H4JopMaLlI1l0
()Hf! npelumpl1Te.llbHO .nomKHa 11H$OpMl1pO-
BaTb 06 3TOM i'IHCTHTYUI'IIO. II OTH()weHI1I1
JroTOnnO >KeJlaeT 3TO ocvwecTBHTb
122
npoiJo.l:JICelillema(jA 12
3aKOH Kblprbl3-
CKOW Pecny5lIl1KH
«06 onepaTHBHO-
po3bICKH() lleSl-
T!:;JbHOCTIN
3alloH YKpal1Hbl
«06onepaTHBHO-
po3bICKHO .neB-
T!:lIbHOCTH»
3aKOH YKpaHHbl
«06 onepaTHBHO-
p03blCKHOH J],eSl-
TelIbHOCT»
3aKoH
JlaTBHflcKOil
Pecny5lIl1l1l1
«06 ()nepaTHBH()fi
.nel\TeJIbHOCTH»
3aKoHJlI1TOB
CKOH Pcny6J]11-
KI1 «06 ()nepa-
T11BHoMJ\eI'lTei1b-
H()CTI1»

OKOH'IaHlIema(jJ/ 12
I 2 3
B cJ1yqae pacKPblTI1R I1H4>opMaUl1l1 0 J1I1Ue,
nOJ1yqeHHow C nOMOlUblO Cneuml.fTbH()W TeX-
tH:lI<I1, H33S3HHOC nl1LlO snpallc 06J1\aJ10113Tb
11 ()Tpl'ltlaTb n()1<a33HI1H I1CXOilll 113 Toro, 'lTO
I) I1H!)JOpM3UI1H 6bln3 nOJ1Y4CH3 HC33KOHHO;
2) npl1MCHeHl1e cpcrICTB OnCp3TI111HOW neJl-
TCJlbHOCTI1 6b1JIO HeC3HKLll10HI1pOll3HO
B 3TOM CJ1Y4ae cyn Bnp3Be orJ13CI1Tb ""-
.uepJKIII1 ", MOTI1Hl1pOBaHHoro npencraBJIe-
HUI H3 nOJ1Y'1eHl1e CaHKIU'II1, J\OKa3blB3lQme-
ro JaKOHHOCTb C3HKlll1l1.
(1H4JCfJMauWl, nOJI)"1eHHaH C IlO\IOIlIbIO cpen(.TI!
onep.1T11BHoM .neRTeJ1bHOCTI1 npOHI1I(1UOmero
xap3KTepa 6e3 caHKW111 reHepallbHoro npOlcy-
popa I.JJ1I1 3aMelllUOlUero ero J1l1ua. nOJ1J1\Ha
6blTb HeJaMe1J)!I1Te.l1bH() YHI1'lTO)l(eHa (CT. 9).
Jll1ua, HaPYWI1BWl1e 3aKoH 06 oneparIIBH()fi
neSlTeJIbHOCT, HecyrUIBe1'C11leHHOCTb B COOT-
- Be1C1BH11 C JaKOHOM JlI1TOBCKOW PeClwfirmKI1
PCJyJ1bT3TbI OP,Q II OTHOWeHl111 J1I1Ll, nepc- 33110H KbrprblJ-
'l11CJ1eHHbIX B n 1-]115'l.2CT 8 H3CTOH- CKOH Pecny5JII'IKI1
mero 33KOtlli, Y411TblinUOTCH npl'l peWeHl111 ..06onep3nUIHO-
:fC:H:X el\ YK333HHblM BI1JI3M p03blCKHOH .ueSl-
TeJ1bHOCTI1
MaTepl1aJ1br onepaTI1BH()n npoBepKI1 He RB- 3aIlOH Pecny5
J1RIOTCSI ()CH()B3Hl1eM W1R ()rpaHWreH!'I.II J1I{KI'I MO.l1nolla
npaB, CB06011 11 3allOHHblX !'IHTepeC()B 4>11311- ..06 onepaTBHO-
'leCKI1X 11 IOpl.JJll1'leCKI1X n!'lU P03bICKH()W neSl-
TeJIbHOCTo>
BapHaHTbl I{CIIOJII..JOe3HHR pe3YJ1bTaTOe OPll IIpt'.OJo'CMArpHB3IOT CT3-
TbHCJle.'I,,)'IOUlIIX33KOHOB,
CTaTbfl 2 (]JenepaJIbHOrO 3aKOH3 ..06 OnepaTI'IBHO-p03brCKHOH: neA-
TeJIbHOCTI'I.
CraTbIi1 33KOI1aYllp3111Hbi ..06onep<rrnfll1o-po3t.ICKHOIl
CTaTbH ] 3alloH3 Pecny5JII1KI'I EiCJ13PYCb ..06 Onep3TI1IJHO-p03brc1lHOn
.DeSlTeJ1bHOCTI'I
CTaTbH 2 3alloHa PeClly6.11I1KI'I KaaaxCTaH ..06 onepaTBHo-p03bICKHOfi
AeSlTe.l1bH()CTSlI1.
CTaTbSl 14 3aKoHa Kblprbl3CKofi PeClly6.11I1K ..06 OnepaTI'IIIHO-
p03brcKHOnneSITe.l1bHOCTl'l0>
CTaTbH 2 3aKOHa Jla'f(I11McKoi1 Pecny5JII1KI'I ..06 OnepaTI'IIIH()H: neA-
TeJIbHOCTIN.
CraTb1i1 3aKcH.JJlIflOBCKCi.i Pecny6J1l1Kl1..06oneJ:ETI1BHOH..l!e=bHlX:m
Cr.\Tb!! 2 3aKoH3 Pecny6f1I1KI1 MOfW,OlH ..06 Onep"TI1BHO-p03bICKHOH
AeSlTeJ1bHOCTI'I

Ta(i.l1ua 13
OpraHbI. OQIItfCTB.IJJIKlUUle OneparHBHO-pa'ThlCKHylO ,/¥:JITenbtlOCTh
B cTpaHax CHI" u 6aJ1THH
Hau.'4el/Q6(jllue
IV'> HauMeHoflollue Op<'OHOfl, meJIIHJUlUX aKoHOIJame,7bHb/X
_In OP/l OKm08, pei?lO-
.",eHmupyIOUI,uX
OP/l
I Z 3
I o raHl,IB .neJl
OpraHbI BHYTpeHHl1x]:\C:J1 (n. I CT. 13) (]>enepilllbHblH
3aXOH «06onepa-
1l1BHO-po3bICKHOA
HCIITCJ1bHOC1W>
OpraHbl BH}'11JeHHI1XHell yro.oBHOH 11 me- 3alloH YKpal1Hbl
UaJIbHOR Ml1l111Ul1eR. nanp.ulIelleHltIlMI1 00 .,{)60nepaTl1e-
-'" , ()pr<1HI130B<1HHoi:i npecrynH()CTblO, HO-p03bICKH()W
onepanIBHo-pe;KH"tHbIMI1 [J()JIIJmlK'QeHI1S1"tH HeSiTellbHOCTI1»
MeCTJlI1WeHwrceo6o.J:bI a63.1 OJ. I CT 5
OpraHbl BHYTpeHHI1X Hell (a63. I .. I CT. 2) 3aKoH Pecny6
QI1I1I1 Eienap)lCb
,,06onepa-mB-
HO-pOJbICKHOH
HeJiTenbH()Cll1»
OpraHbI BHyrpeHHI1X .Den (n. "a&'J. 1 CT. 6) 3allOH Pecny6-
1Il1Kl1 K!l3aXCT3H
«060nepaTe-
HO-p03bICKH()R
- ()jJfaHbl BHyrpeHHI1X neJl (003. I n. I CT. 16) HCJlTeJlbHOCTI1»
3aXOH Kblprbl3-
c,,-oii Pecny6JII1KH
,,06 ()nepaTI1B-
HO-p03bICIlHOH
ne.flTeJ1bHOCT"
focynapCTBeHHb!e Y'lpe;KJIeHl1fl. ()6ecne'{I1 3aKoH
BalOLIlI'IC 06WCCTDeHHblW nopflHOK J]an>l1wcllow
Pecny6nl1l1l1
,,060nepaTBHO"
neJlTeJ1bHOCTH»
rOC}fLlapCTBeHHble I1HCT(1)IUI1I1. ocyweCTB- 3aKOH
nSilOume rOCYJJ,apCTBeHHQe ynpaBJIeHHe B 06- J]I1TOBCKOH
nacTIII BHYTpeHHI1X neJl Pecny6nl1KH
«06 ()nepaTHBHOn
.uerrreJlbHOCTH»
124

I 2 3
OpraHbl MI1HI1CTepCTBa BHyrpeHHI1X nen JallOH Pecny6-
QI1KJ'1 MOJllIOaa
«06onepaTl1B-
HO-P03bICKHOH
IleSlTeJ[bH()CTO>
 .aHblI"OCJJA BeHHoiioeJonacHOcT (]>enepilllbHblH
OpTaHbI CJ>C;!C:P,L"IbHOil clIY>K6b1 6c30rmcHO-
cT([J.2cT.13) 3aKoH«06onepa-
TI1BHO-probICKHOH
IlellTI:!1bHOCTI'I"
OpraHbl HailItoHJ.JIbHOIJ 6e30nacHOCT p" 3aKOH YKpal1Hbl
Be.LlKa, KIJIi1"PIH]II!:JJ.K3. BOetuiIDI IIOHrppa3Beil- ..060nep!fJ11B-
Ka. nonpaJlIeJleHIUI 3alliTbI HauoHa,1bHOH HO-p03bICKH()H
rocynapCTBeHHOCTl'l. 6opb6bI C IwppynUl1eR 11 neHTe.llbH()CTO>
OpraHI130fI3HHOH npeCTYnHOHllcSlH:;JbHOCTblO,
OnepaTliBHO-TeXHIJ'JeClIl1e. ()neparBHoro li()-
KYNeHlllOOBaHI1J1 363. 2 'I. I CT 5)
OpraHbI rocYllHpCTBeHHol1 6e30rr3cHoCTH 33)(OH Pecny6-
(a63. 2<1. I CT. 2) J1I1Kl'I6e;ompycb
.060nepaTl1B-
HO-p03bICKH()H
.l{eSlTeJ1bHOCT..
OpraHbl HauoHa.rrbHOj:j 6e30nacHoCTIf en. ..6. 33110H Pecny6-
'I. leT 6) m1l<l1K,:naxcT3H
..060nepaTl1B-
HO-p03bICKH()H
JleHTeJ1bHOCT"
OpraHbI HaLIHOHaJ1bHOH 6e3QnaCHocnl (003 I JaKOH KblpTbl3-
n. 2 CT. 16) CJ<OH Pecny6JII1KI'I
..06onepaTl1B-
HO-p03bICIlHOH
.neHTe.llbHOCT..
rOCYllapcTBeHHb!e Y4peXCLIeHltSl, o6ecne.m- 3aKOH
BalOWI1e6e30naCHOCTb JlaTBI1HCKOH
Pecny6JII1KI'I
..060nep3TBHofr
neSlTeJ1bHOCTH»
rOCYJlapCTl1eHHb!e (lHCTInyIUl(I. OCYllleCTB- 3aKoHl1(1TOB-
nSlloWl'le rocyuapcTBeHHoe ynpaBJ1eH(le B CKOW Pecny5JII1-
06JIacTH HaUH()HaI1bHOH 6eJOnacHocTH 1<11«06 ()nepa-
TBHOfiJJ,eSlTeJ1b-
H()CTH"
npoOo.UJa!Nuema6/1 13
125

flpQ(}o/l.I/Cf!HuemaQ/I.13
I Z 3
OpraHbI MI1HHCTepcrna HaUHOHaJlbHOH 63- 3allOH Pecny6-
onaCHOCTI1 1111KI'I MOJl1l0Ba
«06onepaTl1e-
HO-p03bICKHOH
lIeSlTJlbHOCTHO>
 HaJlOrOeaS nOJlltllHS (cnY&W)
He npeJlycMoTpeHO C3>elIepa.rrbliblH
3aKOH ,,06 onepa-
1l'IBHO-po:!HCKHOA
lIeSTe.l1bHOCTW>
OpraHbl H8JlorORbIX paCCJ1ellORaHI1H r113BHOH 3allOH Pecl]y6-
rocynapcTDeHH()H HaJ1()rOBOH I1HCnellUl'I1'l 1111KI'I EieJIapycb
MI1HI1CTepcTBa f!JI1HaHCOB taG3. 4 'I. I CT. 2) ,,060nepa-fI'IB-
HO-p03bICKH()H
.neSTeJIbHOCTo>
OpraHbI HaJlOrOBOH CJ1)?K6bl MI'IHI1CTepCTEIa 3allOH Pecny6-
$I'IHaHcoB(n. "r»'l I CT 6) nl'lKI1 KaJ.axcTaH
,,06 ()nepa-fI'IB-
HO-p03bICKH()H
neJlTeJIbHOCTo>
OpraHbI $I'IH3HCOBOif nOJ1I1Ul'l11 (aG3. I [I. 4 3all0liKblpl"blJ-
CT. 16) CKOM PeCflyfuJl1KH
,,06 ()nepaTI1B-
HO-p03bICKH()H
neJlTeJIbHOCTo>
rocynapCTBeHHb!e I1HCTI'IT)'UI1I1, ocyweCTB- 3aIlOH11I1TOB-
l1J1lOlUl1e rocynapcTBeHHoe ynpaBJIeHl1e . CKOH Pecny6JII'I-
06;:[aCTI'I f!JI1HaHC()B 1<11 ..06 ()nepa-
THBHOfiJJ,eSlTeJ1b-
,rOC):aaPCTeeHHaAoxpaHa HOCTHO>
-I ""PM"""" OP""W rOCy"pITHHO' 0'- C3>elIepanbHblfi
p8Hbl" rnaBHoe ynpaBJleHl'le oxpaHbI Poc- J<llIoH,,06one-
CI'IHCKOH $eLlepaUI1I1 11 CJ1)?K6bl 6e30n3CHO- paTI'IBHO-
CT npe311.neHTa POCCI1HCKOH $e.nepm.l1111 po3bJCKHOifJJ,es-
(n. 4 CT. 13) renbHOCT
126

flpQ(}o/l.I/Cf!HuemaQ/I.13
I 2 3
YnpaBJ1eHl1e OXPaI-Jbl BblCllIl1X .!I()J])KH()CTHblX 3aKOH YKpal1Hbl
nou n()llPaJneneHHeM onepaTHBHoro ()6ec- «06onCpaTHB-
ne'leHHSI oxpaHbl (a63. 4 'I. I CT. j) HO-p03bICKH()R
neHTeJlbHOCTHo>
W}'}K6a oxpaHbl np<:3I'IJleHTa Pecny6!1111111 3allOH Pecny6-
Krl3i1xcri1H (no «n"'1 1 CT. 6) nHKI1 KaJ<lXCTaH
«06onepaTHB-
HO-pOJbICKH()R
lle}IT!1bHOCTI1O>
OpraHbl CJly;K6bl rocynapcTBeHHofi oxpaHbI 3alloH KblprblJ
(a6J. I n. 4 CT. 16) CKOJ:l Pecny6JII1KM
«06 ()nepaTI1B-
HO-p03bICKHOH
.!IeSlT!1bHOCTO>
focynapCTBeHHble I1HCTM1)IUMI1. ocylUecTB 3aKoHJII1TOB
nHlOlUl1e oxpaHY eblCllillX OpraH()B rocynap- cKoR Pecny6JIH-
cTBeHHoll BJ1aCTI1 11 ynpaBJleH('j}[ J1HTOBCKOll 1111 «060nepa-
Pecny6J1I1KI1 TflHotll!eSlTe!1b-
._- HOCTI{>.
 norpaHII"'H3HCJlpKI'i.a -
BK.f1104eH() , COCTIlB ()praHa cDe.!lepaJlbHol:! (]>enepaJIbHblW
CJIY)l(6bl 6e30nacHocTil JaKOH «06 onepa-
TBHO-P'1:Jb1CKHOj:j
neJlTeJ1bHOCTI!O>
n()rpaHl1'mble BofiCKa nunpaJlleqeHI1.11 no 3aKOH YKpaHHbl
onepaTl1BHO-p03bICKHOH pa60Te (a63. 3 'I. I «06 ()nepaTI1B-
CT. 5) HO-pOJbICKH()R
.!IeSlTe!1bHOCTO>
OnepaTl:!BHble nOllPaJDeJleHI1H n()rpaHI1'lHblX 3alloH Pecny6-
BoRcK npl1 COBere MHH('jCTpOB Pecny6JII1KI1 J1I1KI1 EieJIapYCb
6enapycb (a63. 3 OJ. I CT. 2) «06()nepaTe-
HO-p03bICIlHOM
.!IeSlTeJlbl10CTI10>
BKJlI04eH() B C()CTaB OpraHa HaUl10HaJlbHOfi 3alloH KblprblJ
6e30mtCHOCTH CXOM Pecny6JJI1XH
«06onepaTl1e-
110-p03b1CIlHOM
lleSlTeJlbl10CTI10>
127

flpc;xJo.J.1/Cf!l/uemaIJ/I.13
-,-1- 2 3
6 T3MmKf'H118J1cJlpima
TaMO)KHHble opr[lHbl POCCI1HCKOJ:i €Dellepa- <1>eJ\epaJIbHblH
LlHI1 (n.6cT. 13) 33KOH ,,06 onepa-
1l'IBHO-JXI3I>ICKHOA
1leSlTeJ1hHocrn..
TaMO)Ke!-lHble opraHhl (a63. I n. 5 CT. 16) 3aKOH Kblprbl3-
C""OH PecnyfuJl1Kl1
,,06 ()nepaTl1B-
HO-pObICKHOH
1leSlTeJlhHOCTIf"
rocy.napCTBeHHblt' I1HCTI11)'LlI1I1, OCYllleCTB- 3aKOH11I1T08-
JlSlIOWHe rOCYllapCTBe!-lHoe ynpaBJIeHlte B 06- CKOH Pecny6J111-
nacTlt TaMO)KeHHblX AeJ1 Kit ..06 ()nepa-
TBHOH.!It'S1TeJ1b-
- !-IOCTIt"
UpraHbIBHernllellpa3Be)J,KII POCCI1CKO <1>eJ\epaJ\bHbl
CJlyJK6bJ BHelUHeH pa.menKIf
€Dellepawm(n 7 CT. 13) 3aKOH ..06 onepa-
1l'IBHO-po3bICKHOJi
- 1leSlTeJ1hHocm<>
OpraHbl BOeHH() pa3BellKI1 MI1HI1CTepcrna 3aKoH Pecny6
06opoHbI (n. "B»'I:. I CT 6) 1II1KI1 Ka33XCT3H
,,060nep3TI1B-
HO-p03bICKH()H
lleJlTJ1bHOCT"
OpraHbl BOeHH()H pa3BeliKIt MItHI1CTepcTBa 3alloH Kblprbl3
06opoHbI (003. I n. 3 CT. 16) ct..oii PecnyfuJl1KI1
.060nepanlB-
HO-p03bICKH()W
1leSlTJ1bHOCT<>
focynapcTBeHHble Y4pe)Kl]eHI1H_ ()6ecnB'l1t 3aKoH
BalOWHe 06opOHY 11aTBHHCKOn
Pecny6J1111111
,,06onepaTIfBHoH
lIe.IITeJ1bHOCTH»
128

OKOH'IOHUe maIJ/I. 13
1 2 3
rocYJ\apCTlleHHb!e l'IHcun)'IUII1. OCYlIleCTB- 3aKOH11I1T08-
lU1IOIUl1e rocynapcTBeHHoe ynpaB11eHl1e . CKO" Pecny5lIl'I-
o6lIacTIII oxpaHbI Kp8S1 1111 .,06onepa-
TBHOM .ne1TelIb-
HOCTW.
OpraHbl MI1HI1CTepcTBa ()6opOHbl 3aKoH Pecny5
QI1I1I'1 MOJlllosa
..o6oneparl1B-
HO-pOJbICKH()W
 - ::"aJ1e::S1Ha;Jla;A l'ICnQJlHeHI'IJI lIeSiTelIbHOCTIfo>
H8IGIJa- <De.r:IepaJIbHblii
HI1" (n. 8CT 13) JaKOH
,,06oncpaTI1B-
HO-p03bICIlHOH
lIeSlTeJl1>liOCTIf"
OpraHbl yrolI()BH()-I1CnOJlHI1TelIbHOn Cl'ICTe- 3aKoH Kblprbl3-
!>Ibl (863 I n.1 CT. 16) CKOM Pecny5lIl1KM
«06onepaTl'lB-
HO-pOJbICKH()jj
=r -  ::: :'=P  :": :POTOM HapKO- .neSiTelIbHOCTIf»
<DelIepanbHblii
'J11'1eCKMX CpeIlCTB 11 nCI1XOTpOnHLIX BeurecTB 3aKoH,,06onepa-
(IJ.9cT.13) 1l'IBHO-poJblCKHOH
.neSlTeJlLHocrn..
OpraHbI . cepe KOHlJIOJIJI HapKOTIiKOB 3alloH KbIpTLI3-
(a63. I n. 9 CT (6) CKOi1 PecnyfuJl1KH
,,06 ()nepa'JI1B-
HO-pOJbICIlHOH
- ne}ITeJlbHOCTI1"
 :J HO Y:;'HoMO'leHHble I1HCDrryIlIlI'I 3aKOH11I1T08-
CKOH PecnyfuJl1-
KI1«06 ()nepa-
TIfBH()wJ\eSlTeJlL-
HOCTI'I
He npellYCMOlJleHO 381<0H KblprLl3-
CIIOM Pecny5lIl1KM
.,060nepaT11S-
HO-pOJbICKH()jj
lIe}lTelIbHOCTH..
129

nepe>JeHb OJII".vroe. O OPll. I1pfJJ.yCM31pHB3IOT C.IIe-
DJlIOUlHeCT3TbH :JaKOtIOB.
CT3TbSl I] <DepanbHoro 33110HH ,,06 onep3TI1BHO-pOJblCKHOH lleSl-
Te.llbH()CTI1".
CTaTbSl 5 3allOHH YKpal1Hbl ,,06 OnepaTI1BHo-pOJbICI<HOH .ueSlTCJ1b-
HOCTW>.
CraTbSl 2 3aJ<oHa Pecnyo.lll1I<11 5e.napycb ,()fj Onep3TI1I!HO-pOJblCJ<Hoi1
lleSlTeJ1bHOCTI1".
CraTbSl (; 3aJ<oHa Pecny5.11I1I< KaJaXCTaH ,,00 Onep3TBHo-pOJbICKHOA
.ueSlTeJ1bHOCTI1"
CTaTbH 16 3aKOHa Kblprbl3cKoJ:1 Pecny6.11I1KI1 ...06 onepaniBHo-
p03bICIIH0J:1 Ae.llTeJ1bHOCTI1"
CTarbH 25 3aI<oHa J1aTeI'lHCI<OH Pecny6.11111<11 ,,06 onepaTI1BHOH .ueA-
Te.llbH()CTI1".
nYHI<T 2 nOCT3HOBJ1eHHI1 BC J1I1TBhl 0 BBe.rteHI1I1 B lleHCTBl'le 3alloH3
"06 ()nepaTHBHoi1 Ae.llTeJ1bH()CTI'I"
CTaThIi 11 3aKOH3 PecnyfuJl1I<11 MOJUlOBa «06 onep3nIBHo-p03bICKHO
AeSlTe.llbH()CTH".

Taf5.rmua 14
npalla opraltOB. ocyweCTB.llIlIOWHX onepaTIIBHo-pa:JblCKHYIO lleIlTeJ1101l0CTIo.
npe.lQCMUI]It'HBble :JaIlOHIJ,lJ,aTI'.I1IoI1IoIMH 3KTaMH, perJl.3.MeIfJ1IIIYIOUIJ OPD
Bcrpaua."CHl'uJ)a.UHH
HaUNeH06C1Hue
M llpmw OpaH()8. OCJml/JllI/fJUl!lX J(lJ.."(JJI(J('tamen/;>-
"'" onepamU6Ho-p03blCKHYIO oellme,l/;>Hocm/;> H/;>IX OKm06. pe-
naMeH7J"(
J 2 3
 npoBO:;::: o: : r=:boO:: nepe- epaJIbHblW
'UICJ1eHHble BeT. 6 H!1CTOSllllt:ro <D\:llepaJ1bHO- 3aIlOH..o60nc-
TO 3aKOHEl, npOl13BQJ:\HTb npl1 I1X npOBc.aCHI1I1 paTI'JBHO-
I1:rbSlTl'le npeIlMeTOB, MaTepl1a.rJOB 11 c()06we- P03bICKH()t!
Imk, , TalCKe npepblBBTb npellOCTBBJIelme lleIlTeJ\bHocrn»
YCJ1yr CBII3H II CJIY4He B03HHKH013eHHII Heno-
cpellCTBeHHOH yrp03bl 3J\OPOBblQ
nl1ua, a TaJOKe yrp03bl rocynapCTlJeI-UJOH BO-
eHHOH 3KOHOMW.J.eCKOW "'" 3KO;IOrl1'.J.eCKOH
6C30naCHOCTI1 POCCI1HCKOH <DcllcpaUI1I1 (n. I
CT. 15
OnepaTHHHblM nOJlpa3J\CJ1CHl1eM AMI BbInOJ1- 3aKOH YKpaHHbl
HeHl111 3BJl3'1 OF'D nplt Ha.rJ11'1I111 OCHOBaHI1H, ",060nepaTB-
npeJlYCMOTpeHHblX CT. 6 3aKOHa, npellOCTaB- HO-p03bICKHOk
nllCTCSI n aBO lleSiTenbHOCT»
npl1 pellleHHH 3BJl3"1 OPll ynOJlHOMOlJeHHblC 3aKoH Pecny6-
Ha ee oCYlUeCTBJIeHHe opraHbl I1NelOT npaBo J1I1KH 5e.napycb
OCYWCCTBJIIITb rJ1!1CHO 11 Her.naCHO OPM, ne- ",060nepaTlfD-
pe'lHCJ1eHHble H CT 5 3aKOtlli (CT. 14) HO-P03bICKHOM
llCSlTCJlbHOCT
npH peweHHH 3BJl3"1 OPlI. ynOi1HOMOlJeHHble 3allOH Pecny6-
Ha ee OCYlUeCTBJICHHe opraHbl I1NCIOT npa130 nI'lIlHKa3aXCTBH
npOBOJaJTb rnacHo 11 HerJ1BCHO OPM, nepc- «06onepaTB-
'1I1CJ1eHHble B CT. II 3aKOHa, B npeJ1Ci1ax CHO- HO-pO.>bICKHOM
eM KOMneTeHUHH n.«a»"I.lcT.8 lleIlTe;JbHOL"'T1I"
np pewCHHH 3alIa'l OPlI. Y!lQ;IHOMO'IrfiHble fiB 331<OH
ee OC}'WeCIBlleHHe opraHbI HMCIQT npaBO npo- KblpTbI3CKOM
BOllHTb r_qaCHO 11 HernacHO OPM. B npeJ1e.lJax Pecny6J1HKI'I
CBOHX nOi1HOMO'll1M ycraHOBJIeHHblX HaCTOSlWM ",060nepaTB-
3aKoH0\I, npOlt3BO.aHTb np HX npoaellCHl1l1 HO-p03bICIlHOk
J13bIlTe npelIMCT013. r.t8TCpIl3JlOB H Coo6weHHi:i. llCSlnJlbI'lOCTH"
8 TdJu!<e npCpblBaTb npe,i:lOCTdBl1eHHe yCJlyr CBJl3H
B CJ1}"1ae B03HHKHOBCHI111 HenOCpe.ncmeHHOti
)'l1)03bl )Klt3HH 11 1I10p0BblO nHWl, a TaJOKC YllX>-
3b1 rocy.napcmeHHOH, BQCHHOH. 3KOHOtl1'1CCKOri
lU1H 3Ko:IOni'IfeI«JM 6e:}(macHIXT Kblprbl3CKoil
PCCnv6nI1I1H n.1 CT. 18
131

J 2 3
Cy6beKTbl onepaTHHHoH .r:LeSlre.bHOCT H HX 3aKoH
I\O![)KHOCTHble J1HlIa npl1 I1CnOJlHeHI'IH CBOI'IX J]aTlJHHCKOH
CJ1YJKeOHhIX 06H3aHHocrdi HMelQT npaBO Pecny6nHIIH
npOBOlll'ITb OTllpblTbJe 11 ceKPeTHble Mepo- ..06 onepaTMB--
Jlpl1HTlUI onepanlHHOH lleSlTtJ1bHOCTH, npellY- HOHllCHTCJ1b-
CMomeHHble CT. 6 HOCTH"
Cy6"bCKTbl onepaTlfBHOH .uelljJbHOCTH "MeIOT 33KOHJhrroB-
npaeo npl1MeHHTb MeTOHb] OPll (n. 7 nOCTa- CKOM PecnyoJlI1-
HOMeHIffi BC JhlTBbI 0 DDC!lCHHH B AeHCTB"e 1111 ..06 oncpa-
3aKoHl1 ..06 onepaTIJHoJ:j neHTeJ1bHOCT") TrIBHoJ:iAeJI-
TeJ]bHOCT"
npH peweHIU1 :'lalla'! OPll opraHbl, ynOJlHO- 3aKoH Pecny6-
MO'leHHb!e ee ocyrneCTBJUlTb, HMelOT npaBo 1111KI1 MOJl1l0B!l
JlpOROID'lTb OPM, nepe'lHCJIeHHb!e (I CT. 6 «060nepaTB-
HO-pOJbICKHOH
lleSlTeJlbHOCTIf"
1,l.Onpoc rpaJKllaH (n. I '.I. I C1. 6) u-Jblj;j
3(l)(oH«060ne-
paTI1J1'j()-POJbICK-
HokneSlTeJJb-
HOCTIN
Onpoc nlm c HX comacHSI, I'ICnOJ1b30BaHHe 3aKOH YKpal1Hbl
I1X Ao6pOBOlIbHOfi nm,IOI.l.lH (n. 1 'I. I CT 8) ..06onepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOk
.l{eSlTellbHOCT
OrrpocrpaJK1l.3H (n. I CT. S) 3aKoH Pecny6-
1111KI1 l)eJlapycb
,060nepaTB-
HO-pOJbICKHOk
.ne.llreJlbHOCT"
Onpoc rpmKll3H, 1l0J1>KHOCTHbIX ]II1U, nOJIY4- 3allOH PecIly6-
Ime () HI1X HHcbopMaUl111 (a63. I n 2 CT. II) JlHKI1 K!l3aXCT"H
",060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOH
IleHTe]lbH()CT"
Onpoc rpa)l(l\!lH (a63. 1 n. 1 CT. 7) 3aKOH
KbIprbl3CKol1
Pecny6n l1l1H
",060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOk
.l{eSlTeJ1bHOCT"
npoiJo.l:JICelillema(j,114
132

 --=- 2
OncpaTIIIHHbllfonpoc (n. I 1 <I. I CT. 9).
(OnepaTBHbIll onpoc - :JJleMCHT TIlKOti I:Ta-
.lUWI OPl1, K:JII oncpaTBHOC p3ccnc.aOB3HIfC.)
Pa3BCllbIB:JTeJlbHblll onpoc (n. 1 n()CTaI-JOBJIC
ImJl BC JhlTBbl 0 BBe.aCHIfIf B nCHCTBl1e 3a-
KOHa 06 oncpaTRHOH nCSlTCJlbHOCTW»
Onpoc fJJ'iJK,IWi (n. a.. CT 6).
npoBeneHl1e 6ecen C lIono3peeMblMI1 C npM-
MeHeHlfeM ne-reKTOpoB CIfMYJlJlUMIf (n. n» CT. 6)
1.2. HaBe.acHl1eCnpaBoll (n 2'1: I CT 6)
Hcrpe6oB8HJ.le, c60p .nOKYMCHTOB 11 D,aHHbIX,
X8pal<TepI13YIOWMX .nenTeJlbHOCTb npennpl1-
}lTIfH, Y4pe}KjJ,CHIfH, opraHlf3aulfH. a TalOKC
o6pa3 >KIDHI1 OrneJlbHblX I1U, no.a03pCBae-
MbiX B n().afOTOBKe I.JJ1I1 COBepweHlf11 npecT}'-
nnCHIfJl, I1CT04Hlfil 11 pa3Mepbl IfX A()XOllOB
(n 4<1 I CT. 8
HaIJCllCHW cnpaROK (n 2 CT 5), Ifcqx£oHa-
Hlfe, c60p If 1f3}''1eHlfe nOKYMCHTOB If CB-
HIfH, KOTopble xap3KTeplf3YlOT .l\CSlTeJlbHOCTb
npC1!nplfJlTlJll, Y4pC>K1!CHIfH, oprnHlf3aUlfH, a
T3KJKC 06pa3 }l(lJ3HIf ()TneJlbHbiX JlIfL!, nOJlO3-
pCHaeMblx H no.aroToBlle IfJlIf cOBCpllleHlJlJ
npccrynneHIfJl, IfCT04HlfK If pa3Mepbl If X .!to-
X01!OB n_JcT. 14
HaBelleHlfe cnpaBolI, npoBepKa no )"ICTIlM
Y'1pe>K1!CHIfH, npellnpl1J1TIfH If opnU-J1f3:JL!IfH
(HC3:JBIfCIfMO OT nOll<ll1HCHHOCTIf If !bOPM
C06CTIJCHHOCTIf) (a53 8 n 2 cr II)
npOBcpKa no onCpaTIJBHblM, KpIfMIfHaJ1I1CTH-
<lCCIlIfM Y4eT3M If CIfCTCMBM yrOJlOBHOll penl-
cmmWlIf a63.17n.lcr.11
133
llpoiJwJJtcelluema6J/.14
3
3BKOH
flaTBIfHclIOH
Pccny6n lflllf
06onepaTB-
HOH1!CHTeJlb-
HOCT",>
3aKoHJhrroB-
CKOH Pecny6J111-
1111 ..06 oncpa-
TIJBHOHHeH-
TcnbHOCTH"
3allOH Pccny6-
JlIfKIf MOJU{OH3
06onepaTB-
HO-pOJbICKHOH
HCnTeJlbHOCTH»
(]>eneparrblJblH
3aKOH06onc-
paTl'lflHO-po3blCK-
HOHnCSlTeJlb-
HOCTI'I»
3311()H YKp3lfHbi
06onepaTB-
HO-pOJbICKHOtr
.neJlTeJlbHOCT
3allOH Pccny6-
J1IfKIJ I)cnapycb
06 onepaTHB-
HO-p03bICIlHOH
nCSlTClIbHOCT»
3allOH Pecny6
JlI1I1If KaJaxcT:JH
060ncpaTHB-
HO-p03bICIlHOH
nCSlTeJlbHOCT»

2
HaBelIetU'lecnpaBOK(n. 2 cr. 7)
HaIJe.aeHHe cnpaBOK (n. @»CT.6)
- ---.--:3:- O6cne.rioB<IHl'Ie IJOMeWeI-U'IH, 1illlHI1H. co-
()py.>KeHmt, }"JaCTKOB MeCTHocrn 11 rpaHcnOj)T-
HbIXCpe,llCTB(n.8'1..lcr.6)
06cJJ:eJ1()BaHl'le >KHJlbIX 1'1 npyfl'lx n()MellleHHn c
cornaCI1S1 I1X BJ\Me.l1bL1eB 111U'1 06Hrnrenetl: lUlli
BbIJlCHeHI1S1 06crCIIJrCJIbCT6 COBepWeHHOro 1U111
fOTOBflwerocSi npec1)WleHHSI(n.6'1. I CT 8)
06cJJ:e!lOBaHHe nOMeweHHi:i, maHl1n, coop)')Ke-
I-U'lH, }l'IaCTKOB MeC1HOCTII 11 lpaHcnopTHblX
cpellCTB(n.!j CT. j)
nma&.14
3
3aKOH
Kblprbl3C);()l1
Pecny6nHKI1
«06onepfITBH()-
poJblCKHOH llell-
TeJlbHOCll'I»
3aKoHPemy6-
JlI11<HMOJ1l10aa
",06 onepalllDlJO-
POJblCKHOH llell-
@eLIeparrbHblW
3al<oH",060ne-
paTi1BHO-po.JbICK-
HOMJ\eSlrenb-
3al<OH ¥KjJal'lHbl
",060nepaTBH()-
poJblCKHOn nell-
3aKOH Pecny6-
JIHKH 5eJlapYCb
",060nepaTBH()-
poJblCnJOflnell-
,nOCMOlp )KJ1J[blX [JoMemeHI1R. paGo'JHX 11 IfHblX 3aKoH Pecny6-
MeCT (a63. 15 'I.. 2 CT II) JlHKH KaJaXCTaH
",060nepaTBH()-
poJbICD.ell-
06cJJ:e!IOBaHHe nOMeJlIeHl'IA, aDaHl1n, coop)?Ke-
I-U'ln, }"IaCTKOO teC1HOCTII 11 lpaHcnopTHblX
cpellCTB(n.!j CT. 7)
134
331<0H
KbIprbl3CKoH
Pecny6nI1KI'I
",06onep"TBHO-
pD3bICKHoHJ\eH-
TCJIbHOC1W>

1 2
OneparnBHb!A OCMOlp (n. 3.. I CT 6)
TaAH()e ocyweCTBJ1eHl'IC OCMorpa nOMeWCHI'ISI
(onepaTl1BHblA OC"IOTp) (n «a» 'I. I CT. 6)
- 06CJ1CllOB8JiHC nOMClliCI-IHH, 3llaHl'IH, C()OPY-
JKeHl'Ifi. }"13CTKOH "teCTHOCT 11 rpaHcnopr-
IibIXCpClJ:CTB(n. "1" CT. 6)
HerJ!aCHoe BblSlBJleHl'Ie 11 c]:JHKCauI'lSi C.IICllOB
TSI>KKOrO npecryn_eHI1S1, llOKYMCIHOB 11 llPY-
nIX npell).teToB, KOTopble M()fYT cnY;KI1Tb no-
KaJaTeJ1bCTBaMI1 nonrOTOBKI'I 11]]11 cOBepwe-
HM}! TaKoro nDeCTlrureHI'ISI n 7.. leT 81
nOcewaTb 1lPyrne 11 JKW!bre nOMCweHI1J/ C
ConmCI1H l'IX BJ1a.r:\CJlbUCB 1'I1I11 06WraTCJ1ei1 J]J1S1
BbIJICHeHIHI 06crOSlTt:J1bCTB COIICpWCHHoro
J1}111 rOTOBSIwerOCH npeCT)'[JJ1eHIHI. II r3KJKC
c0611paTb CBC1lCHIUI 0 npon1l10npaBHOH JJ,eSl-
TeJ1bHOcnl n01l03pCI1aCMb!X 1111U, II OTHowe-
HI1I1 KOTOpblX npOBOJU1TCSI npOBcpKa (n. 6
lIICT.8
06Hapy;KeHlfe. HermICHUI c]:JI1KCaUHSI H 11b-
JlTI'IC CJICllOB npOTI'IBOnpaBHblX neHHHk. I1X
npeliBapl'lTCJ1bHOe I'ICCnCllOBaHl'ISi (a63 13
n 2CT II)
l>ecnpemlTCTBeHHO BUWIITb B mo60e Bpe).tJl
CyrOK Ha nppl1Topl11O 11 e nOMeweHI11 npen-
npl1S1Tl1ll, Y'1pCJK.llCHI1H l'I opraH('j3aLll1M (HeJa-
BI1CI'IMO ()T <VOPM co{icTBeHHo(.'TI1). a Ha Tep-
pl1TOpHIO BOHHCKHX lJaCTcA 111lpynlx pe)l(I1M-
HblX 06'bCKTOB - no COrJlacoBaJ-IH1O C I1X py-
KOBOnIfR'JlJlMH, TOJ1bKO C ueJIblO npOBelleHHJI
OPM, npe!lYCMOTpeHHblX B CT. 11 HaCTOJlwe-
fO 33KOHa n, "1'1"'" 1 CT 8\
135
npoiJo.l:JICelillema(j,114
3
33KOH
JIaTlJlfficllOH
Pccny6;II'1J<H
..060nepaTHB-
Hoii.ueSlTeJlb-
HOCTH
3aKoH11I1TOB
CKOn Pecny6JII1-
KI1..o6onepa-
THBHOn.neSl-
Te_bHOCT"
3allOH Pecny6-
nl'llll1 MO!l!lOHa
..06onepaTHB-
HO-p03bICKHOH
.neSiTenbHOCTW>
3aKOH YKpal1Hbl
..06onepaTB-
HO-pOJbICKHOn
.neSlTeJIbHOCT"
3allOH YllpaHHbl
..060nepaTH-
HO-p03bICIlHOk
.neSlTe.n:bHOCT"
3aKOH Pecny6
JlI'IIIH KaJ.axCTaH
..06onepaTHB-
HO-p03bICIlHOk
.neSiTenbHOCT"
3allOH Pecny6-
JlI1I1I1Ka3ilXCTaH
..06onepaTB-
HO-pOJbICKHOH
.neflTeJIbHOCT

llpoiJrm;Jlcel/uema6J/.14
1 2 3
Hr: np.nycMOTpeHO 38KOH
Kblpll>l3CKOH
Pecny6nHKI'I
",060nepaTB-
HO-pOJbICKHOH
.neSiTenbHOCTW'
T8HHO npOH('JKaTb H KHaJympy, nOMellleHHJI. 38KOH
TpaHcnoPTHble cpeIlcTBa H .npyrl'le ny6nIf'IHO- J]aTlJHHCKo!1
HeIloCTynHble 06'beKTbl c UeJ1blO o6eCne'leHHSI Pecny6nHKI'I
npOBeJleHI1S1 MepOnpl1J1HIH OnepaTI'IBHoi1 J\fJl- ",06onepaTB-
TeJ1bHOCTH (CT 14) HOHJleSlTeJ1b-
HOCHN
BXOJlI'ITb B nOMellleHHJI npeIlnpl1J1THH. Y'1pe- 3aKOH J]HTOB-
)IQ1eHI1H " OpraHIf3aUHJ:I, npOBOllHTb KOH- CKOH Pecny6J111-
TpOJ1bHble npoBepKH, reXHOJlOr11'1eCKl1e 311C- KI1..060nepa-
nepHMeHTbl, 113blM8Tb M3Tepl1aJ1bl, JlQIIYMeH- TI1BHOHIleSl-
Tbl. cblpbe H o6pa3Ubl npoIlYKUl111 H llPyrl'le TeJ1bHOCTH»
06'beKTbl DJlJI HCCJ1ell()BaHHSI fie3 coofillleHHSI
06 HX H3'bSlTHH (n. ..B»'1. 1 CT. 6)
1.4. C60p o6paJUOB DJ1S1 cpaeHHTeJ1bHoro HC- (])eJlepa.rlbHbIJ:i
cm:.IJ,OBaHI1J1(n. 3'1. I CT. 6). 3flKOH ..Q60[]-
pmllBHO-po3blCII-
HoklleSlTeJ1b-
HOCTI1<>
C60p ()6pa3U()B DJlJI CpaBHI1TeJlbHurO I1ccne- 3aKoH Pecny6-
IlOBaHHJI (n 3 CT. 5) JII1KIJ l)eJ1apYCb
..060nepaTI1B-
HO-p03bICKHOH
IleJITe;IbHOCT
Or6op np06 11 ()6pa3U()B DJlSI I1CCJleJIQBaHHSI 3aKOH Pecny6-
(a63. 9 n. 2 CT. 11) JIHlIl1KaJaxCTaH
..060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOk
IleJlTeJlbHOCT»
C60p 06pa3lJ,Oe DJ1J1. CpaBHHTeJ1bHurO Hccne- 3aKoH
IlOBaHHJI (n. 3 CT. 7) Kblprbl3CKOH
PeCny6nHIIH
..06onepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOH
IleSlTJlbHOCT»
136

J 2 3
OnepaTHHHoe nonY<JeH(1e 06pa3UOB (n. 4 'I. I 3aKoH
(;T6,[I ,,, (2) J]aTlJHHCKOfi
Pecny6n HIIH
",060nepaTB-
HOH.ueSlTeJ1b-
HOCTM»
1t13'bIiTHe MBTepl1aJ10B, llOKYMCHTOB, CblpbSl, 33KOHJhrroB-
06pa31lOB npOllYKUl111 H npyrHx oObeKToe DJ1S1 CKOM Pecny6J111-
I1CCJ1CllOrnU1H1I 6eJ C006WCHHJI 06 If X 1131>11- 1111 ..06 oncpa-
TI{ (n. «e'>'I.lcT.6) THBHOiiAeJI-
TeJ]bHOCT"
C60p M3TepHMOB, o6pa3LlOB ill" CpaBHH- 3aKoH Pecny6-
TeJ1bHOro HCCnell()BaHHJI (n. "C»CT 6) 1111K" MOJl1l0Ba
..060nepaTB-
HO-pOJbICKHOtl:
lleSlTeJlbHOCTIf"
1.5. npoBepo'maSi JaK)'TlKa (n. 4 'I. 1 CT. 6) u-Jblj;j
JaKOH",06ol1e-
paTI1IJHO-pD3blCK-
Hoi1neffil:J1b-
HOCT"
KOI-JTpOJIbH3H JaKynKa TOBapOB c ueJIblO 3aKOH YKpal1Hbl
HblllBJleHI1S1 npoTHBonpBBHoH lIeSlTeJlbHOCHI ..06onepaTB-
(n.2.. I CT. 8) HO-p03bICKHOk
lleSlTellbHOCT"
KOHrpOJlbHble JaK)'llKH (n. 4 CT. S) 3aKOH Pecny6-
11I1KI1 l)eJlapYCb
,060nepaTB-
HO-pOJbICKHOk
.ne.llre)]bHOCT"
KOtOJlO!TbHbre 33Kynlll1 (aG3. 10 n 2 CT. II) 3aKOH PecIly6-
IHKI1 Ka3aXCTaI-J
..06onepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOH
IleHTe)]bHOCT"
npOBepO'lHble 33KynKH (n. 4 CT. 7) 3aKOH
KbIprbl3CKoH
Pecny6n HIIH
..06onepaTB-
HO-pOJbICKI-JOW
.l{eSlTeJ1bHOCT"
npoiJo.l:JICelillema(j,114
137

llpodofiJ/CeHue ma6f1. 14
I 2 3
Km-rrpO.l1bHaSi 3aKynKa TOBapOB (n «r.. CT. 6) 3aKOH Pecny6-
JU'IKH MOJU{OBa
",060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOH
lleSiTC.I1bHOCTIt»
1.15. I1cCJ1enoBaHlte npenMeTOB 111lOilYMeHTOB @enepa.rrbHbIH
(0 " ICT6J 3aKOH",06one-
paTBHO-po3bICK-
H()HneHTeJlb-
HOCT
HJ)"leHHe JIOKyueHTOB 11 naHHbIX, XapaKTepI1- 3aKOH Y KPal1Hhl
3YJOllIHX lleSl1t:J1bHQCTb npCj{npHJlTH. Y4pC)K- «060nepaTB-
lleHI1H, opraHlf3aUHH, a TalOKe ()6pa3 >K1'I3HH HO-p03bICIlHOit
OU!ellbHblX J1HU, nOJ\03jJel1aeJ<.lbIX B nOJ\.-01OBKe lleJlTC.I1hHOCTH
1'11111 COeepWeHl'I11 npecrynJ1eHmI. I'ICTO'1HHII H
p1.3'>1 bI HXJ\O'W.1OO {n. 4 'I. 1 CT.S)
HCC.I1eJ!oBaHl1e npenMeToB 1'I1ioKYMeHTol1 3aKoH Pecny6-
(n. 5 CT. 5) l1HKHI)CJ1apYCh
",060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOit
lleSlTcnhHOCT"
npCj{BapHTClIbHoe HCC)]eJ:\OBaHl1e 06HilpY)KeH- 3allOH Pecny6-
HblX, Herl13CHO 3mfJHKCMJlOBaHHbIX 1'1 H3DIITbIX JlHKH Ka3aXCTBH
CJIeJ!()B npOTHBOnpaBHhlX neSlHHti (a63. 13 'I. 2 ",06onepaTB-
CT. 11) HO-pOJbICKHOH
lleSlTcnbHOCT"
It1cCJ1e.llOBaHHe npeJ\MeTOB I1ll0KYMeHTOB 3aKOH
(n.5cT.7) Kblprbl3CKoH
Pecny6n l1KH
",060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOit
lleJlTe;J.hHOL"'T1I
OnepanlBHoe I1CC.I1eJ!oeBHl1e (n. 2 CT. 12, n. 4 3aKoH
'1.1 CT. 6) naTBl1ikKOH
Pecny6nHKI'I
",060nepaTB-
HofilleSlTe.l1b-
HOCTI1..
138

llpodQ/l.1ICf!Hue ma(j/l. 14
1 2 3
HCCJ1eJ:\oBaHl{e MHTeplJaJlOB, llOKYMeHTOB, 3aKoHJ1I{TOB-
CblPbli. 06pa3LlOB npOllYIILllJl{ I{ JlPyrx 06'b- CKOH Pecny6n('J-
eKTOB (n «(I» 'I. 1 CT 6) KI{ ..o6onepa-
TI{BHOHlleSl-
Te_bHOCT"
It1cCJ1eJ:\OBaHl{e npellMCTOB I{ llOKYMeHTOB 3allOH Pecny6-
(0 <;g»cT.6J J1I1KI{ MOJ1110Ba
«06onepaTIfB-
HO-p03bICKHO
.neJlTe;IbHOCT»
1.7. Oro)l(J!eCTBJleHl{e JUI'J.HOCTH (0 ,,_ I blH
cT.6J 3aKoH«06()nepa-
TIIBHO--pOJbICK-
HQHlleHTeJ1b-
HOCTI1<>
OrO)l(J!eCTBJleHl1e JlI1'1.HOCTH (n. 7 CT. 5) 3aKoH Pecny6-
11I1KH 6e_Hpycb
«06onepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOH
lleSiTenbHOCT»
nOI{CK I{ OTOJIUIt:CTBJleHl{e nl{'IHoeTH 00 3allOH Pecny6-
npl{MCTaM (863. 12 'I. 2 CT 11) ]I1{I(I{Ka3<lXCTaH
«06onepaTIfB-
HO-p03bICIIHO
.nCSlTC;IbHOCTIf»
OrO)l(J!eCTBJleHl{e ]IW1HOCTH (n 7 CT 7) 331<01-1
Kblprbl3CKoH
Pecny6nl{KH
«06onepaTB-
HO-pOJbICKHOH
.neSlTeJ1bHOCT
OnepaTMBlJOe 06CJ1ellOeaHl1e nl1na (n. 5 'I.. I 3aKoH
cr. 6) J1aTBI{HCKOJ:!
Pecny6n l1K I'I
«06onepaTB-
HOHlleSlTeJ1b-
HOCTI{
YCTIlHOBJ1CHl{e 1111'IHQCTI{ (n. «h» CT. 6) 3allOH Pccny6-
1111111{ MOJ1110Ila
«060nepaTI{B-
HO-p03bICIIHO
.neSlTCJ1bHOCTIf»
139

flpotJoDirelluema6A.14
J 2 3
1.8. Ha6JIfOlleHMe (n 6... I CT. 6) Q:!cllepal1bHbrM
3aKoH..06()nepa-
1liBHO-p03bICK-
HOHlleSlTeJ1b-
HOCT",>
BI13YaJIbHoe Ha6J1I011eHMe , ()\)mecTBeHHblx 3aKoH YKpal1Hbl
MeCTax C npm,teHeHMeM $010-. KMHO- M BI1- ..06()nepaTB-
_ :nM::::: (O HO-p03bICKHOH
llCIITCilbHOCTM
Ha6.lOllCHMC (n 6 CT 5) 3alloH P<:cny5-
J1I1KM EeJlapycb
..o6onepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOH
- lOlleHl1e. B TOM 'J1'ICJ1e C I1CnOJlbJOBaHM lleSlTC;(bHOCTIf
3aKOH Pecny5
eM TeXHl1'jCClIl1X cpellCTB (aYllI10- 11 BH1le03a- J1MKI1 KaJaXCTaH
nIJCI1. KI1HO$01OCbeMKI1 IJ npyrl1x TeXH('j- ..o60nepaTB-
'JeCKI1X cpellcTB), Marepl1aJlOB 1'1 BemeCTB, He HO-p03bICIlHOH
HaHOCJllUMX BpClla >KM3HM, 31lOpOllbIO M OKpy- lleSlTC!lbHOCTIf
)KalOlUet1c"..';.. (a63. 6 n. 3 CT. II)
OnepaTHBHoe 1-i36J1I011eHlJe (n_ 14 CT. 7) 3aKoH
Kblprbl3CKOH
P<:cny5J1MIII'I
..06 OnepaTB-
HO-pO.>bICKHOH
ACJITCJlbHOCT
OnepaTIIIBHoe HB6.lOlleHl'le (cJle)f{l<8) 3aKOH
(n.2'J I CT. 6,CT.10) naTBMHCKOA
Pecny5J1MKH
..o60nepaTB-
HOHlleSlTeJ1b-
HOCTM
nM'JHaH M TaMHflJI CJ1eJKKa (n 7 nOCTaH()B"le- 3aKOHnMTOB-
HI'IJI BepxoBHoro COBeTa nl1TOBCKOH Pecny6- CKOH Pecny5J1I1-
J1IJKI1 0 ImellCHl111 B lleHCTBl1e 3itKOHit 06 KI1 ..06 onepa-
onepaTI1E1HOH JleIJTeJlbHOCTH) THBHoi111eSl-
TeJ1bHOCT»
BI13YaJIbHoe Ha6nJOlleHI1e (n. "c»cT.6) 3aKoH Pecny5
Ha6J1I011eHMe . llOKYMeHTl1poaaHl1e , H<- J]('jKJ1 MOJUlOBa
nQJlh30llaHlJeM COBpeMeHHblX MeTOllOB 11 TeX- ..o6onepaTB-
HJ1'1.eCKHXCpellcTB(n. ..d»CT.6) HO-p03bICKHOH
lleSiTClIbHOCTW'
140

llpcxJcu.1l('(!l/ue maIJ/I. 14
---L.L_ 2 3
1.9. KOI-rrpOJlHpyeM n0CT3BKa (n. 13 'I.. I CT. 6) (])eaepal1bHbtA
3aKOH«06 onepa-
THHO-p:)3b1CII-
HOW ncmrnb-
HOCTH»
C uenbJO BbHlBJIeHHJI npenynpe)K1leHHR H 3al<OH Pecny6
npeCe'IeHI1S1 npecrynneHHH. a Tal0Ke npl1'1a- J[HI<H K,naXCTaH
CTHblX K HI1M nHU ()cywecTBJlSlTb ()nepaTI1B- «06()nepaTB-
Hblll 1I0HTPOJ1b nOCTHBOK TOBHPOB. BllIeCTB H HO-pOJbICKH()A
HHb!X MaTpH3J1bHbIX ueHHOCTell. RBJISIIOWHX- JJ:S1TJ1bHOCT
CSI npeliMeTaMH npecTynHoH Ae.llTenbHOCTH H
npellHaJHa'leHHblX K npOBOJY. Bb1B03)' "'"
BB03)' HH TeppHTopHIO Pecny6nHKH K=-
CTHH (I] «M'I.. ICT8)
KOHTpOJ1HpyeMble 1]0CTaBKIJ (npOBepO'l.Hble 3HKOH
JlOCTaIlKIJ) (n. 6 CT. 6) Kblprbl3CKOH
Pecny6nHKIJ
«06()nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKH()A
JJ:eJlrenbHOCTH
1.10, KOHTpOJ1b nO'ITOBblX UTnpaBJIeHI1A. TeJle 4oellepanbHblj:j
rpaQ>HbIX H HHblX COO61l.lCHHH (n. 9 'I. I CT. 6) 33KOH ..06 one-
paTHBHO-
po3blCKHOW lIe.ll-
TenbHOCT»
KOHrponb nyreM ar60pa n() OmeJ1bHb1M nplJ- 3al<OH YKpal1Hbl
:nrnKaM Tenerpa$H()-n04TOBblX oTnpaBneHHj:j ..060nepHTIfB-
(n. 10'1. I CT. 8) HO-p03bICKH()W
.neSiTenbHOCTIf»
KOHrponb n()L]TOBO Tenerpa4JHblx ()mpaBJIe 3aKoH Pecny5
HHH (n. 9 CT. 5) nHKIJ 6enapycb
.Q6 ()nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOti:
.neSlTJ1bHOCT
KOHrpOJIb nO<JTOBblX OmpaBJIeHl1ll (a63 2 3aKoH Pecny6-
n. 3 CT. II) J[HKH KHJaXCTHH
..060nepHTB-
HO-p03bICKH()W
.neSiTenbHOCTIf»
141

llpcxJcu.1ICel/ue maIJ/I. 14
Km-rrpO.l1b n()'1TOBbJX OrnpaBJIeHI1t!, Tene-
rpaIJJHblx H HHbJX co06meHHH (n. 9 CT 7)
3aKOH
Kblprbl3CKoA
Pecny6J1HIIH
«06()nepaTB-
HO-pOJbICKH()W
lleSlTe.l1bHOCT
3aKoH
J]aTBHf1cKo!1
Pccny6J1HKH
«060nepaTB-
H()t!neSlTe.l1b-
HOCTH»
3aKOHJ]I1TOB-
CKOH Pecny6.11H-
KH ",06 onepa-
THBHOillleJl-
Te_%HOCT»
OnepaTHBHblH KOHTpOJ1b Ja KoppecnoKlleH-
l.[JieH (n. 9 'I. 1 CT. 6, n. 1 '1.1 CT. 17)
CneUHaJlbHblt! KOHTpOJIb nO'lTOBbIX nOCblJ1()K
(n. 7 nOCTaHOBJIeHItSi BepxOBHOro COBera J]I1-
TOBCKOti Pecny6JIHKI1 () IIDeneH1111 II lleticTBHe
3aKoHa 06 onepaTHBHoH lleSlTeJIbHOCTH)
Km-rrpO.l1b nO'lTOebIX ornpaBJIeHI1f1 (n. ",j» 3aKoH Pecny6
CT. 6) nl1KI'I MOJl1l0Ba
",060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOH
lleSlTeJIbHOCTH»
1.11. npOCJIyumllaHl1e TeJIe4JoHHblx nepero- c])enepa.rlbHwf1
1I0poII(n. 10'1 1 CT. 6) JaKoH«060ne-
paTl'lflHO-JX)3bICK-
HOHJ\eSlTeJ1b-
HOCTI1<'
npOCJ1ywl1BaHl1e TCJle4JoHHblx nepO-OBopOB 11 3allOH Pecny6-
HHblX neperooopoD (n. 12 CT. 5) 11I1KH 6eJ1apycb
",060nepaTB-
HO-pOJbICKH()f1
lleHTeJIbHOCTH»
npOCJ1ywl1B3Hl1e TeJle4JoHHb!X nepo-oBopOB 11 3aKoH
HHblX neperooopoD (a63. 4 n 3 CT. II) Pec:ny6J1HKH
Kro<11(CT.JH
.Q6()nepaTB-
HO-pOJbICKH()W
lleSlTcnbHOCTW'
142

flpotJoDirelluema6A.14
I 2 3
npOCJJywHBaHHc Te;IC<f10HHb!X nepcrOBopOB 1'1 3aKoH
HHblX neoeroBOpoB (n. 10 CT. 7) KblprbucKoi1
Pecny6J1HIIH
",060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOi1
lleSlTe;IbHOCTH
OnepaTI'IBHOe npoc.I1ywHBaHHe pa3roBopoB 3aKoH
(n. II OJ I CT. 6, n. JeT 17) J]aTlIHi1clloi1
Pecny6J1HKI'I
",060nepaTB-
H()WneSlTeJlb-
HOCTH
npOCJJYWHBaHHe TeJIe<!JOHHblX nepO-OBopOB IJ 3allOH Pecny6-
HHblX neperOBOpOB (n "'PCT 6) nl1KI'I M01IllOBa
«06onepaTB-
HO-p03!>ICIlHOil
lleJlTeJl!>HO<."'TII»
1.12_ CHSlTl'le HH4JOPM3W'IIJ , TeXHH'l.eCKJJX -,
KaHaJIOBCBJl3H (n. 11 OJ I CT. 6) 3aKOH",06()nepa-
TIIIU-jO--poJUCK-
HOWneSlTeJ1b-
HOCTH&
CHJlTe IJH4JopMaUI'IH C KaHaJlOB CBJl3H (n. 9 3aKOH YKpaHHbl
OJ.ICT8) ",06onepaTII-
HO-pOJbICKH()t(
lleSlTeJIbHOCT
CHSITHe I1H4JopMaUHI1 C TeXHHOJeCKI1X KaHa- 3aKoH Pecny6
110BCBSl3H (n. 14 CT. 5) 11I1KI'I 6e.apycb
",06onepaTHB-
HO-p03bICKH()t(
lleSiTenbHOCTW'
CHJlTHe I'IHIpOpJ.taUHI1 C TeXHH'JeCKI'IX KaHa- 3allOH Pecny6-
110B CBH311. KOMnblOTepH!>IX CI1CTeM 1'1 HHblX 11HKI1 KaJaxcT"H
TeXHH'JeCKHX CpeilCTB (003. 5 n. 3 CT. II) ",060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKH()t(
lleSlTeJIbHOCTW>
CHJlTHe I1H4JOpM3UHI1 C TeXHHOJeCKI1X KaHa- 3aKoH
11()BCBSl3H In. II CT. 7) KbIprbl3CKot(
Pecny6J1HIIH
",06()nepaTB-
HO-pOJbICKH()t(
lleSlTeJIbHOCTH
143

OnepaTHBHoe n()JJyqeHl'le HH$OpMaUHH C HC-
nOJlbJOBaH('JeM reXHWleCK('JX CpeJ\CTB (n. 10
OJ. 1 CT. 6, n 2CT 17)
CneUl1aJ1bHb!iI KOI-11l'()JIb 3JIeKlpoCBH311 (n. 7
nOCT"HOBJIeHHJI BepxOIJHoro COBera 1II1TOB-
CKOf1 Pecny6JUlKH 0 BBeJ\eHIUI B .Ilef1CTBHe
3aKOHa 06 onepaTHBHo J\eHTCJlbH()CTI1)
CI-1S1Te I1I-1$OpMaUI1I1 C TeXHHOJeCKI1X KBHa-
1I0BCBI!31'1 (n. «T»CT. 7)
- 1.13. OnepaTl1BHblii 3KCnepl'lMeHr (n. 14 OJ. I
cT6)
OnepaTIJBHblH 3KCnepl'lMeHT (n. IS CT. 7)
OnepaTIJBHbTii 3KcnepHMeHT (n. 7 OJ. 1 CT. 6,
CT. IS)
-.
11.14. "'-"- 6H""'""' (n 12" 1 cr. 6)
144
llpoiJrJnJK:el/uema6J/.14
3aK0l-1
lIaTBHHcKOH
Pecny6J1I'1I1('J
«060nepaTB-
H()WneSlTei1b-
3aKOHJlI1TOB-
CKOH Pecny6JUI-
KI1..06()ncpa-
TI1BHoti.lleH-
3aK0l-1 Pecny6
J](,]KI'I MOJ1.QOBa
«06onepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOH
lleSlTCJlbHOCTH
(])e.Qepal1bHblH
3BKoH«06()ncpa-
"'-.,,"'''',,-
HOHlleSlTCJ1b-
HOCTH»
3alWI-1
KbIprbl3CKol1
Pecny6J1I'1I1('J
«060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKH()W
lleHTCJ1bHOCT»
3aKOH
«06onepaTB-
HoiilleSlTeJ1bHO-
CTH
lIaTBHHcKoi1
Pecny6J1I'1KIJ
(])e.QepaI1bHbrJ:t
3aKOH«06 onepa-
TIIBHO-po3bICK-
H()t!neSlTCJ1b-
HOCTW>

2
OcymcCTIIJIRTb npOHI1KHOIJCHI1C npecryfl-
HYIO rpynny HenmCH()ro pa6oTHHI<a onepa-
TBHoro nO!!pa3l1CJlCHI1J1 nl160 COTpyuHI1-
lJaJOllicro C HI1M Jmua C COXjJ<IHeHI1CM B Ta-
lie .nOCT06epHbIX IDlHHbIX. KacalOWI1XCSI 11}(
JlI'IIJH()CTI1. YKa3aHHbie smUll He Hecyr OTBeT-
CTBeHHOCHJ, eCJ1H ()HI1 neHCTBOBaJll1 B CO-
CTOHHIUI Heo6xoJll1Moti 060POHbl Kim Kpaf1-
Heft He06XOD"M()CTI:! (n 8'1 I CT. 8)
BHellpeHl1e COTpyJlHI1KOI! B opraHl130lJaHHbie
npeCTynHble rpynnbl 11 KPHMl'II-j()rCHHble 06'b-
eKTbl (n. !OCT. 5)
BHenpel-me COTpy.nHHKOB B npecrynHYIO cpe
1lY (a63. 3 n. 2 CT 11)
OflepaTJJBHm: BHelipCHl1e (n. 13 CT. 7)
OflepaTI'IBHO HeTeKTI'IBHaH ne.lITeJIbH()CTb C
C6HKLUU1 npOK}-pop1 npOHI1KH()lJeHI1C (npHMoe
IUIH J1CITHllHpOB6HHOC) B npccrylmylO CPCllY,
ycr.iHOBJIeHl1e CBJlJH C HaX01!SlUlHMI1CSI Ha ()nc-
paTlJ(lHOM )"1e'J1: J1I'1U3MI1 1'1 co CBSl3aIUiblMH C
HHMH JU1UaMH '1.3 CT 16, n. 8 '1:. leT 6)-
ArCHTYPHblf1 MeTOl! (n. 7 nOCTaHOli.1CHI1R
BepxOBHoro COBera JII1TOBCKOii Pecny6J1111111
() BBelleH1111 B nef1CTBl1c 3aKoHB 06 ()nepa-
TBHoii.!\eSlTeJ1bHOCTI1)
CJ1)"<OBOH KOHJponb (n. 13 CT. 5)
145
flpoiJo.l:JICelillema(jA 14
3aKOH YKpal'lHbl
,,06()nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOH
neSlTeJlbHOCTH»
3aKOH Pecny6-
J1I1KI'I EeJlapycb
",060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKH()
J{eSlTe;(bHOCT»
3aKoH Pecny6-
JII1KI1 KaJ<]J(cT<lH
,,060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKH()W
J{eSlTeJlbHOCTH<'
38KOH
KbIprbl3CKo
Pecny6J1l1l1lJ
,,06oncpaTIfB-
HO-pO.>bICKHOH
J{eSiTenbHOCT"
3aKoH
J]aTIJI1cKoi1
Pecny6J1HKlJ
",060nepaTB-
HOHlleSlTeJlb-
HOCTW>
3aKOHJ]I1TOB-
CKOH Pecny6JUI-
KI1..06()nepa-
TI'IBHoiiJ{eSl-
Te!lbHOCT»
3aKOH
Pecny6J1HlIlJ
EeJlapycb
",060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKH()W
J{eSlTeJ[bHOCT»

npl1MeHeHl1e MO):lelIl1 nOBe):leHI1J1. I1MI1HI-
PYIOIJ.!efi npecTynHYIO .!\eSlTeJIbHOCTb (a63. 4
n. 1 CT. II)
He npenYCMOTpeH()
npl1MeHeHl1e MOJJ,C:lIl1 nOBeJ\eHI1S1. I1MI1Trj-
pylOl.l.ltl1 npeCTynH}'1O ne,lTeJIbHOCTb
npl1MeHeHl1e .!\pyrl'lx, 'JeM YCTpoHcTBa DJ1J1
CHJlTI'IJI I1H!f1opMaUI1I1 C KaHaJIOB CDSl311. Tex-
HI1'1CCKI'IX cpcnCTB nOJIY'JeHI1S1 I1Hi)JopMalll1l1
n.9'J I CT. 8
npl1MeHeHl1t cneUl13.JILHLIX TeXHI{'JeCKJ.1X
t:penCTB(a6J. 7 n. 1 CT. II)
OPM. CD3aHHbTe C KOHTpoJleM nO'fTOBLIX
OTnpaDJleHi1i1, TeJlerpai)JHblx 11 I1HL1X co06-
IJ.!CHI1H, npocnYWI1BaHI1CM TeJIC!f10HHbIX ne-
perOElOpOB C nOlll01104eHl'leM K CTaUI10HapHoi1
8nnapaType npeLUJpl'lJlTl'lii, }'4pe)KlleHI1H 1'1
opraH('j3aUl1H He3aBIJCl1MO OT i)JOPM C06CT-
BeHHOCrl'l, i)J1J31'1'1eCKI'IX 1'1 IOpl1iUl'ieCKI'IX JlI1I.L,
npetLOCT"B1IIIOIJ.!I1X yc.yr 1'1 t:pencTBa CBSI.II'I.
npOBO.IDlTCJI C I1CnOJIL30BaHI1eM OnepaTI'IBHO-
'JeXHI1'JeCKI1X CpetLCTB Op.-aHOB HBLlI10HaJIbHOJ:i
6e30naCHOCTI1 11 OELl B nOp.!lilKe, onpene-
JlJleM()M npaBl1renbCTBoM KbIpTbI3CKOH Pec-
nvfuTl1KI'I ( 4 CT. 7
npl1MCHeHl1e CJlYA<WHO-P03bICKHbIX co6aK
(a63. II n lCT 11)
146
flpodo.UJ«!Nuema5/1 14
3
3alloH Pecny6-
JlI1KI1 KaJaxcTaH
,,060nepaTa-
HO-p03bICKHOH
ne}lTe1lbHOCT"
3aKoH
KbIprLI3CKoH
Pecny6J1I1KI1
,,060nepaTI'IB-
HO-p03bICIlHOH
.!\eSlTenbHOCT"
3aKOH11I1T08-
C)WH Pecny6JI('j-
KI1 ..06 onepa-
TI1BHoJ:ine.ll-
'Je.bHOCTI'I"
3aKoH YKpal1Hbl
..06onepaTB-
HO-p03LICKHOH
.!\eSlTe1lLHOCTI1"
3alloH Pecny6-
Il1KI1 Ka.mxcT"H
,,060nepaTB-
HO-pOJbICKHOfl
neJlTe1lbHOCTH..
3aKoH
KbTprbl3CKoH
Pccny6J1I1KI1
..06 ()nepaTI'IB-
HO-p03bICKH()H
neSlTeJlbHOCTI'I"
3aKOH Pecny6-
JlI1KI1 KaJaxcTaH
,,06()nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKH()H
neSiTeilbHOCTI'I..

J 2 3
He npe.nycMoTpeHO 3aKoH
Kblprbl3CKoH
Pcny6J1111111
",06()nepaTB-
H:0-p03bICIlHOIi
.neflTenbHOCT»
OcyurecTBJleHIfC JIH'IHOrO JlOCMOTpa J3Jlep- 3aKoH
)KaHHbl)( Jmu, oCMoTpa 1'1 HJhIITHfi. HaX01U'1- Pecny6J1I1KM
IllHXCR npH HHX Bernek Ii noKYMCHTOB, MO- Kro3XCTflH
.-yllt"X OTHOCI1Ti>CJI K npeCTynHOH .r:LCSlTeJlbHO- ",060nepaTB-
CT. a TalGKe llocMoTpa )l(HJ1bIX n()).1eureHHfI HO-p03bICKH()H
pa60'!."x 11 HHblX MeeT .o:OCMOTpa TpaHcnopT- lleSiTenbHOCT»
HbIXCDell.CTB aG3. IS n. leT. II
npOBepKa no yrO;JOHHbIM, IIprUtl1H3J1HCTH'le- 3aKOH
CKI1M Y'IeTflM 11 CI1CTeMaM yro.l1oBHoti perHcT- Pecny6J1HKI'I
paLlHH (363.17 n. 2cT. 11) Ka3axcT3H
",060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKH()W
J{eSlTCJ1bHOCTH<'
UCHJypa ooppecIl()!-tiIHUHH OC)?K1leHHblX (aoo. I 3aKoH Pecnyti-
n_ JCT. II) JII1KH KaJaXCTflH
.Q6 ()nepaTB-
HO-P03bICIlHOH
.neHTeJ[bHOCT"
He npeJ:\yCMOIpeHO 3aKOH
KbIprbl3CKotl:
PeCIJy6J1HKI1
",060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKH()W
.neSiTClIbHOCTH<'
npH)'1eHcHHe MflpKl1pOBKI1 CneUHaJ1bHblMH 3aKoH Pecny5
(jUtH'IeCKHMH 11 .llPYrMlJ BelllttT1l 111.111 (n. «0» JWIKH MOJu{OBa
cr. 6) ",06()nepaTB-
HO-p03bICIlHOH
.neJlTenbHOCT..
npOCMBTpHB3HHe KQPpeCnOHJlCHLlI1I1 OCY)K- 3aKOH
nCHHblx(n «Ko>CT.6) Pecny6J1I1KI'I
MO!lllOBa
",060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKH()W
J{eSlTellbH(lCT
flpoiJo.lJK:ellllema(jA 14
147

llpoiJoJJJlcel/uema6J/.14
  2 3
OnepaTIIIBH8!1: npoBepK8 (n. 7 nOCTaH()B1IeHI1J1 3aKOHJII1TOB-
BepxoBHoTO COBeTd JII1TOBCKOM Pecny6J1I1KI1 CKOH Pecny6J111-
o BBeJ\eHI1I1 B J\eHCTBl1e 38KOH8 06 onepa- KI1 06 onepa-
TBHoHJ\eSlTeJ1bHOCTI1) HIBHoiiJ\eSl-
TeJ1bHOCT"
OnepaTI'IBH() lIeTeKTHBHaJl lIesrreJJbH()CTb 38KOH
KaK OTKPb!TaSI. TaK 11 6eJ ()rJ18WeHHJI npl1- ",06()nepaTB-
HanJ1e;KHOCTH K cy5"eKTY ()nepaTl18H()H lIeJl- HOHneSITeJ1bH()-
TeJ1bHOCTH no c60py HH!]:>OpM8UHH D KpI'lMI1- CTW>
H8J1bHOH cpe!le. B TOM '1HCJ1e YCTaH()B1IeHHSI JI8TBHHCKOH
ClliIJH c J1HWIMH. DblJblBalOlliHMI1 ()nepaTHB- Pecny5J1HKI'I
Hbrii!1HTC ec 'I 1 2cJ.6)
OnepaTHBHoe paCCJ1ellOBaH!1e (n. 1 'I. 1 CT. 6, 3aKOH
eT.20) ",060nepaTB-
HOM neflTCJ1bHO-
CTHO>
::
OnepaTI'IDHoe DblSlCHeHl1e nOJ1Y'1eHI1C HH- 38KOH
4JOpJ.taUHI1 OT nl1u. eCJ1I1 CCTb OCHOB8HI1J1 no- J]8TBI1HCKOH
JI8raTb, '1TO lIBHHa!1: I1H!]:>OpM8U11J1 l1J.teeTCSI B Pecny5J1HKI1
pacnop!1:)I(eHl1l1lIl1u, HO OHI1 >KeJ18IOT npelIOC- ",060nepaTB-
TaBl1Tb ee HenOCpel1CTBeHHO ('I 4 CT. 9) HOHJ\eSlTeJ1b-
OnepaTHBH()e n03H8HHe c60p I1H4JOPM8 38KOH
UHH () KOHKpeTHbiX J1I1uax (n. 3 'I. 3 CT. 9) J]8TBHf1CKOJ:!
Pecny5J1HKI'I
",06()nepaTB-
H()HlIeSlTeJ1b-
HOCTH»
nOi1)f'18Tb p83Bel1bIB8TClIbHYIO I1H$OpM8U11IO, 3allOH Yllp811Hbr
B TOM '1IJClIe n}'TCM npOHI1KHOBeHI1J1 onepa- ",060nepaTl1B-
TBHO-p03bICIIH()ro pa60THI1Ka " nOMewe- HO-P03bICKHOH
HI1J1. Tp<lHCnOpTHble cpe.!\cTB8, Ha JeMellbHble J\eSlTCJ1bHOCT»
'l/q8crKI1 n. 7'1.1 CT. in
CHI1M8Jb HI-$OpM8UHIJ , K8H8J10B CBSl3H, 3aK()H YKpal1Hbl
npl'lMeHSlTb lIpyrl'le TeXHH'leCKHe qJellCTB8 n()- ",06 ()nepaTHB-
JI)"JeHf.Ull'IH4JopMaUI'IH (n " leT8) HO-pOJbICKH()H
.!\CSlTCJ1bHOCTH»
OcyweCTB1ISlTb BH3Y8J1bHOe Ha6111O!1eHl1e 3all()H YKpal1Hbl
06meCTBeHHb1X Mec1'8X C npHMeHeHl1eM 410- ",060nepaTB-
TO-, KHHO-, BHlleoc"eMKI1, OnT'1eCKI1X 11 pa- HO-P03bICKHOH
JUJon 1160 OB n. 11'1. I CT 8 lleSlTCJ1bHOCT»
148

-+-+-lIOJlHOMO'lIlH nPHMeHb I1Hble. 'leM OPJ\.1,
_1:::..=eoc=:::HHble JJ)lH
1.1. YCTaHaEIJII1IJ.ITb H;} 6e3003,,-e3AHo 1'1)]11
B03e31lH()fj OCHOBe OTH()llieHl'ISi COTpYllHl'IlJe-
CTaa C J1HuaMH. H3bSlBI'IBllil1MI1 c()rnacl1e ()K;)-
:iblDaTb cOllef1cTBHe I-Ja IWHIJ!H!leHUHWlbH()i1
OCHOBe oprm-rnM. ()cyweCTBJ1HlOum).1 opn
n2CTIS
It1cnOJlb30BaTb D;o6poBOnbHYH) nOMOWb 'IHCT-
HbIXJ1l1u(n 1'1. I CT. 8).
YCTaH3BJ1I1BaTb KOH€!>}]):!CHUHaJ1bHoe COTPYlI-
HI1'1.eCTBO C Jll1l.UlMlJ till Ha'laJ18X 1l06poOOJlb-
HOCTl-1 n. 13 'I. I CT. 8
YcraHaBJU1B<1Tb Ha 6e':mo':Ne':mHoii rum 003-
Me31lHOH OCHOBeOTHOrneHI1HcarpYllHl1'leCTBac
nmrnMH, HJ'lJIBIfBlliHMI1 cornOCHe ()f.;.)JblBaTb
CO!leHC1BHe Ha KO!$lt1IeHUW1bHOi1 OCHOBe
ODl<lHaM. OCVUIeCTBJlHIOWH).t OPil n 2 CT 14
YcraHBOlIlJBaTb till 6e3B03Me3AHofi 111160
nJlaTHoti OCHOBe OTHOmeHI1H COTpy1lHI1'1.eCT-
03 C 1111uaMI1, IB'bSlBlJBlUHMH Corl1BCl1e OK3-
3b!B3Tb co.!!ellCTBl1e H3 KOHqm1leHL!I1aJ1bHof1
OCHOBe OpraHaM. 0CYL1LenBJ1IIOIl.!I1M opn
n. «6»11. I CT. 14\
YCTaHaBJII1B<1Tb I-Ja 6e3B03Me311H()fj 111160
nJJaTHOH OCHOBe OTHOllleHI1H COTpYllHH'leCT-
Ba C J1HuaMI1, H3'bHBI'IBWHMH COlJ1aCl'Ie 01«1-
3b!BaTb C01lei1cTBHe Ha KOH4>mICHUl1aJJbHOii
OCHOBe opratlliM. ocyweCT6J1S1IOWHM OPil
a63. <j 1 CT. 14) .
npHl!JleKaTb K npoBeneHHIO Meponpm1T
onepaTHBHo ne.llTe.llbHOCTH KaK ()TKPbITO. TaK
11 KOH$I'IllCHLlHaJIbHO OTJJ,e.llbHbJX nOJDKHOCT-
HblX nl1U, CneUl'laJIHCTOB. 3Kcnep-roB B c4Jepe
HaYKI1. TeXHI'IKI'I 11 npyrl'lx 06.r1acTSlX, a TaJOKe
ome;IbHb1X J1I'1U C I'IX corJ1acl'lSi n. 3 CT 28\
YCTaHaBJIl'lflBn CDII3H C Ofi'beKTaMI'I onepa-
TflHOW lleSlTeJIbHOCTI'I (n. «6 <j 2 CT. 6)
149
flpcXJo.l:JICelillema(jA 14
cI>eD,epaJIbHbl
33KOH «06 one-
paTI'IBH()-
P03b]CIIH()
neSlTe.llbHOCTH
3aKOH YKpal1Hbl
«060nepaTB-
HO-P03bICIIHQH
J{eSiTellbHOCT
3aK()H Pecnyti-
11I1KI'I Ee;'Japycb
",06()nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKH()W
neSlTCllbHOCTH
3alloH Pecny6-
JIHKH KaJaxcTBH
",060nepaTB-
HO-pO:JbICKHOH
neSlTeJ1bHOCT
3aKOH
Kblprbl3CKow
Pecny6J1HKl'I
..06onepaTHB-
HO-p03bICIlHOH
J{eSiTellbHOCTW'
381<0H
J]aTIJHHcKoJ:i
Pecny6J1HKI'I
",060nepaTB-
H()t!lleSlTe.llb-
:: -
J]aTlIHHCIIOH
Pecny6J1HlIl'I
",060nepaTB-
HOMJ\eHTe.llb-
HOCT11e

YCTaH8WII1BaTb OTHOWeHIUI C 1111WiMI1, 1l3.8-
WI1MI'I COr118Cl'le COTPYllHI1'18Tb }Ja IIOH4II1-
lleHUJ-I8J1bHO OCHO(le opraHBM, ocyweCT13-
nsllOllll1M OPLl (n. «at> 'I. I CT. 13)
2.1, B XOlle npOl3elleHI1S1 OPM I1CnOJlb3013HTb
I1H4IopMaUHoHHble CtlCTCMbl ('I 3 CT 6), :>aBO-
llHTb.nenaoneparl1eHoroY'Iera('1. I CT. (0)
C0311aBaTb 11 npl1MeHSlTb 8BTOM8TI13I1poBaH-
HbleCI1CTeMbl (n. 17'1. I CT. 8)
C0311aBaTb 11 I1CnOJlb30BHTb I1H4IOPM8UI1()H
Hble CtlCTeMbI, 06eCne'l(JB81Oll!l1e BblnOJlHe-
Hl1e 3M3'1 OPLl (n. 3 CT. 14)
COOllaB8Tb If I1CnOJlb30B8Tb onep8TI1BHb1e
Y4eTbI, I1H<!:>OPM8u(JoHHble CI1CTeMbI, o6ecne-
'lI1BalOilll1e BblnOJlHeHl1e 3M3'1 OPLl (n «B"
'I I CT. 8)
B XOlle npOBelieHI-IJ! OPM I1CnOJlb30B8Tb I1H-
ltJopM8Ul10HHble CI1CTeMbl, 8 TalOKe 38BOllI1Tb
lleJl8 onepaTBHoro Y4era ('l. I CT. 13)
C0311all8Tb (J I-ICnOJlbJOllaTb I1H<!:>opMaUI1OH-
Hble CI1CTeMbI 11 TeXHI1'leCKHe cpeJlcnn WSi
npOl3elIeHtlSI 3TI1X MepOnpl1.11THH 11 I)JI1KCl1pO-
BaHI-IJI I1HltJopMaU(J) (n. 2 'I. I CT. 28)
EeCTI1 onepaTHBHblA }"leT npol1cwecTBHA.
l)JaKTOB, npeJJ.MeTOB, JlpyrHX I1CTQ'lHI-IKOB (JH-
ItJOPM8UI1I1. 1)J113H'IeCKHX 11 IOptllll'l'leCKI1X JlI1U
(n«1l"'l2cT.6)
150
npoiJo.l:JICelillema(jA 14
3
3alloH Pecny6-
JlI1KI1 MOJlllOBa
«060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKH()A
lleSlTe,-IbHOCTW'
tDeJ\epa.1bHbIH
33KoH«06one-
paTHeHo-po3bICK-
tlOHlIeSlTCJIb-
3aKOH YKpal1Hbl
«06onepaTB-
HO-p03bICKH()
lleSlTeJIbHOCTW>
3aKoH Pecny6
1111KIJ l)eJlBPycb
«06()nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKH()
lle.llTeJ]bHOCT
3allOH Pecny6-
JlI1KI1 KaaaxCTaH
«06onepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOH
lleSlTeJ[bHOCT"
3aKOH
KbIprbl3ClwA
Pecny6J1111111
.Q6 ()nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKH()
lle.llreJ[bHOCT"
3aKOH
«06onepaTB-
HOHlleSlTeJlbH()-
naTBI1AcKOA
Pecm.6nI1KIJ
3aKOHnI1TOB-
CKOH Pecny6J1I1-
KI1 «06 ()nepa-
THDHoHneSl-
JeJlbHOCT"

C03.uJBJTb H HCnOJlb30BaTb OnepaT1'IDHbTe
Y4bl, HH4JOp}.tBLlHOHHbT CHCT"tbT, 06cn-
I,IHBalOlllHe BblnOJlHeHl1e 3aJ12'1 OP!l (n. ..C»
I,IICT,I3)
2.3. J1cnOJlb30BJTb B xone npOBlleHHJI OPM
no .norOlJOpy HJJH yCTHOMY cor.nBUleHHIO CJly-
)Ke5HbTe n()MeILleHI1.11, HMywecTBo npennpH-
JlTHfi, )"Jp>KLleHHtj, Opr3HHJ3UH£'!, fIOlfliCI<11X
I,IflcTdt a TBl0Ke JKH.lTbTe H HeJKH.lTbTe nOMe-
ILleHI1S1, TpaHcnOjJTHble CpellCTBa 11 I1HOe
HM weCTBO I,IBCTHbTX11HLI n. 3 1,1.1 CT. 15
It1cno11b30B3Tb C cor11acH.II .3.LlMHfiHClp3LlHH
cJlYJKe6HbTe nOMemefiHJI, TpaHcr10pTHble cpeJl-
CTBJ H llpyroe I1MywecTBO npennpl1S1TH£'!, Y'I-
JKLleHHi1, opraHI1J3UH, a TaIlJK C COmHCHJI
11HLl - )KI1JJHUle, .npyrHe nO"teUlefiHJI, rp8HC-
nOjJTHble cpellcTB8 H npl'lHW1J1eJKaILlee HM
H..:vTII.,CTBO n. 151,1. 1 CT. 8
It1cnOJlb30BaTb B XO.U npOBeneHHJI OPM 110
.norolJop) H.H YCTHOMY comaweHHIO CJJy-
)Ke5HbTe n()MeILleHI1.11. HMywecTBo npennpH-
JlTHfi, )"Jpe)KJJeHH£'!, Opr3HHJ3L1Hfi, BOHHCKHX
I,IBcTei1, B T810Ke JKH.lTbTe H HeJKH.lTbTe nOMe-
=T::t:H;:LI e:aI4; I1HOe
It1cnOJlb30[lBTb B XOll npO[lCnCHHJI OPM no
.uorolJQpy H.H YCTHOMY comaweHHIO CJlY-
)Ke5HbTe nOMeILleHHJI, TpJHCn()pTHble 11 I1Hb1e
reXHHl,leCime CpellCT(I3, HMywecTBO npelinpH-
JlTHH_ Y4pe>KLleHi1i1, opr8fiH38L\i1i1, BOHHCI<HX
'!HCTe£'!, a TJKJKe JKl.JJJbTe H HeJKHJlbTe nOMe-
meHi1S1, Tp8HcnopTHbie cpeJ\CTB8 i1 HHO
HMywecTBo rpaJK.!laH C B03MeILleHHeM YILlep5a
BJ1aL1eJ1bLlHM B CJ1)f'1ae ero HBHeCeHI1J1, B TBII-
)Ke pacxOlloe 3a C'IeT opraHoe, oCYILleCTB-
11J1IOWHxOP!lln ..P>I,I I CT 81-
J1cn0J1b30IJaTb B xOlle npOlJelleHi1J1 OPM no
.uOTOIIOp)' HJ1H YCTHOMY comaWCHHIO CJlY-
)K5HbTe nOMemeHi1.11. m,tywecTBo npeilnpH-
JlTi1, Y'Ipe)KJJeHHH, opr8HH38UHH, BOHHCKl'IX
l,Iacrei1, a THI<JKe )!(l-U1bTe }I Hf:)!(l-U1bTe nOMe-
ILleHI1Jl, Tp"HcnOjJTHble cpellCTBa H HHoe
HtfVllleCTBOI,IHCTHbIXJlI1U 003 1 n 4CT 18)
151
npodo.UU!Nue ma6/1 14
3
3aKoH Pecny5
JlHIIH MOJlilOBB
..06onepaTB-
HO-pOJbICKH()£'!
.ueSlTeJlbHOCT»
-..""
38KOH..060ne-
paTBHO-po3bICK-
HOlleSlTeJ1b-
HOCTI1
3aKOH YKpal1Hbl
..06 onep3THB-
HO-pOJbICKH()£'!
lleSlTJlbHOCT»
3allOH Pecny5
11HI<11 1)J1BPYCb
.Q6 ()nepaTB-
HO-pOJbICIIHO
lle.llreJ1bHOCTH
3aKOH
Pecny6J1HIli1
K.ua'<CTilH
..060nepaTII-
HO-p03bICI<HOH
lleSlTeJlbHOCT»
3f1KOH
KbIprbl3CKofi
Pecny6J1HIli1
..06onep8TB-
HO-pOJbICIIHO
lleJlTeJ1bHOCTH

J 2 3
no tlJalfMHOI'I 1I0rOHopCHHOCTI'I IfCnO!1b10BaTb 3aKOH
W111 npOBCliCHlf1l MeponpH1ITlfH oncpanlflHoH J1an>HHCKOA
.ncrreJ1bH()CnJ nOMCUlCHI1S1, I'IM}'WCCTIJO, npc!!- Pccny6J1HU'I
MeTbI lJP)'fH1[ opraJ-JH3aUHH If npCnnpl'lJlTI'IH. a «06()nepaTB-
TIlIOKC }l{HJlble 11 npyre nOMeIUeHHJI. lpaHC- H()HneSlTeJ1b-
n()jJTHblC cpe.Il.CTBi\ H llpyryJO C05CTBCHHOCTb HOCTH»
nHU n.4"1. I cr. 28
I1cnOJlb30B'iTL 11 XQJJ,e npOBeneHl'l.l1 aPM no 31.KOH Pecny5-
.nomBopy !1JI('] yCTHOM}' COr.n3.rneHHIO CJ1}'}I(c6- J1(JKI1 MOJu{OBa
Hble OOMemeHI1S1. I1Myme<:TBO npellnplUlTI1H, «06onepaTB-
Y4pe)l(i\eHHH, opraHnal!l1fi. BOHHCKIfX 'U1CTdl, HO-P03bICIIHOi1
a T311)1(e lKW1ble 11 He)l(l{,ble notellleHI1.SI, lleSiTenbHOCT»
!p;'e n C':;I /3e H'IYWecrro
2A. I1cnOJlb30B3Tb B ueJl.llx KOHCnl1paUI'IH (J.IeliepaJ1bHblA
IloKYMeHTbI J.alUH4JpoBblBalOIUl1e JlI1'lH()CTb 3aKoH..06()ne-
llOJDKHOCTHblX mm, Bell()MCTBeHHYIO npl1HM- paTHBH()-
ne)l(H()CTb npellnpHJlTtI:. Y'lpe)l(1!emdl, opra- p03blCKHOA
HI1..!aL!ldi, nOllPB3.lle:1el-1l1H. nOMemeHI1H H lIeJlTe.llbHOCTH
rpaHcnopTHblx cpe.l\CTB op.-aHoH, oCYlllecTB-
nJUOIlI11X OPLl. a TBlOKe nIJ<jHOCTb rpa)l(Jl8H,
OK!I3blBBlOllIlfX 11M coaeficTBHe H3 IIOHI]1(J){CH-
L111a.bHofi OCHOB!: n.4'1. I CT. 15
It1cnOJlb30B3Tb 1l0K)'MCfiTbl, J.3WmPPOBb1BalO- 3al<Ofi Yl<pal1Hbl
WI1C JlWiHOCTb 11J111 BCllOMCTIJCHHYIO npl1HM- «Q60ncpaTIfB-
JlC;KHOCTb pa60THI11<OB, nOMelliCHI1H 11 TpaHc- HO-p03bICI<}j()k
nupTHblx CpCllCTB OnCpaTI1BHblX nOllPa31lcJlc- lleSlTeJlbHOCT
HH" n. 16'1. I CT. 8
It1cnOJlb30B3Tb B UCJI.IIX 1<0HCnl1paUl111 ll()I<Y 3al<OH Pecny5-
MeHTbI, 3aWI1<1JpoBblBalOWl1e JlI1'1HOCTb ll()J])K- JlI1I<I'I EeJlapycb
H()CTHbIX JlI1U. BenOMCTBeHH}'lO npI1Harme;K- «Q60nepaTB-
HOCTb np!:llnpl1JlTI1H, }''1p!:)I(l!eHI1H. OpraHl13a- HO-p03bICI<HOH
UI1H, n01lP3:t1\C.CHI1i1. nOMCIlICHi1i1 11 TpaHC- llCSlT!:JlbHOCT
nopTHbiX cpC!lCTB opraHOB. OC}'IlICCTIIJ1S1IOIl.WIX
OPLl, a Tall;KC Jli1'1HOCTb rpa;KJJ,aH. COTJl}fllHi1-
xo::::rn or:11 HB KOH$l1l1CHUI1-
It1cnOJlb30B3Tb l!OK)'MCHTbI. 3aWI14JpoBb1DalO- 3aKoH
IUI1C l!()mKH()CTHbiX JlI1U. BellOMCTBeHH}'1O I-'ccny5J1111111
npI1HB1IJ1C;KH()CTb nonpa31lc.cHl1k. OpraHl13a- Ka3a1(CTaH
UI1i1, nOMeIllCHI1 11 TpaHcnoprHbIX cpellCTB «Q60nepaTB-
opraHOB. oc}'meCTIIJ1IIOIl.WIX OPI!. , ralOKe HO-pO.>bICI<HOH
Jll1'1HOCTb rpa)l(Jl3H, COTp)'llHI1'1aIOIlII1X C 3TI1- lleSlTeJ1bHOCT"
MI1 oprBHaMI1 Ha 1<0HI]1I111!:HUl1HJ1bHOH OCHOBe
n..,u» 'I. I CT. 8
npoiJrHJJlcel/uema6J/.14
152

HCnOJlb30BaTb B ueJlJlX KOHCn(1paUIUI J\CIIIY-
MeHTbI, 3aWI1$pOBblBalOml1e J1H'IHOCTb .fi()J])K-
H()CTHbIX J1HU. BellOMCTBeHHYJO npHHar!J1e)K-
HQCTb npellnpl1.SlTH, Y'1pe)l(lleHH. opraHl13a-
LlHi1, nOlljXI3lleJleHHi1. nOMeILleHHll H TpaHC-
n()pTHblX cpellCTB ()praHOB. ()cymeCTBJ1J1lOUlI1X
OPLl. a Tall)Ke JlWlHOCTb rpa)f(lIDH. OKaJbI-
BalO1LlHX HM cOilei1cTBHe HH KOH$HJleHUllaJlb-
H()j;j: ()CHOae (a63. I n. 5 CT. 18)
1t13rOTOfIJIJlTb 11 HCnOJ1bJOIlaTb J\CIKYMeHTbl H
I!PYre cpeilCTBa MaCKHpOBKH JL'IH COKpbITSl
.nei1CTBJtTeQbHoi1 npHHar!J1e)KH()CTH OTneJIbHblX
CTpyKl)'pHbIX n()npa:meJleHHi1, Cy6beKTOB ()ne-
pBTHDHOH ileSlTeJlbHOCTH, HX CJI)')Ke6HbIX no-
MeILleHHi1 H rpaHcnopTHblX cpenCTB. B TIlJOKe
l'I1leHTH$HKaUHH HX C 3TI'IMI1 upraHaMH HB
KOHmrulCHUH;I"lbHOii OCHO[lC (n 5 'I I CT 28)
HCnOJlbJOB"Tb perl1CTpaUHOHHble 1'1 OTl1H'JI1-
TeJlbHble 3HaKH npellnpHSlTI'li1, Y'Jpe)l(lleHHi1 H
0PWHI13BUHH ([I «!J>i> 'I. I CT. 6)
It1cnOJlbJOBBTb B UCJlJlX KOHCnl1paUHH .fiOIlY-
MeHTbI, 3awH$pollblll"101lII1e J1H'IHOCTb .fiOJ])K-
HOCTHblX JlHU. BC.nOMCTBCHHYIO npHHar!J1e)K-
H()CTb nOllpB3lIeJIeHHH. upraHl13auHH. n()Me-
J1[eH(1(i M TpaHcnOpTHbiX cpellCTB oprBHOB,
OCYl1!eCTfIJIHlOllIHX OP!l, a TIllOKe JlHU, co-
TpynHH'IBJOl1!I'IX C 3TI1MH opraHBMH Ha KOH-
$ruleHLll'la,lbH()H OCH()Be (n «e.. 'I. I CT 13)
CO.>[lauaTb B ycr.JHOllJleHHOM 3aKOHOllrrrenbCT-
BOM nupSl!lKe npe!lI1pI1S1TI'I.II. Y'lpe)l(lleHI1S1, ()P-
rBHH3aL11'111 11 nOllpa31lCQCHIfSi. Hc061(()1!HMble
LUISI peweHHSl 3BJ!a'J. npeilYCMOlpeHHb!X Q)eJ\e-
paIIbHblM 3aKOHOM 06 OPLI (n. 5 'J. 1 CT. 15)
C03llaBaTb 11 uenSiX KOHcnHpaUH(J npeilnpH-
JlTI1.SI. opraHH31U..!l1H (n. 16 'I. 1 CT. 8)
153
flpoiJrm,:lICf'l/ue ma6J/. 14
38KOH
KbIprbl3CKoj;j:
Pecny6J1HKI'I
«060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKH0i1
lleSlTeJlbHOCT»
3aKOH
«060nepaTB-
Hoi1neHTeJlbH()-
CTI'I»
J1aTl>HHCKO
Pecny6J1HKI'I
3aKoHJ1HTOB-
CKOi1 Pecny6J111-
KH «06 onepa-
THBHO.I{eSl-
TeJlbHOCTH»
3alloH Pecny6-
JI(1I1H MOJlilOBa
..060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICIIH()H
neSiTenbHOCT"
pMbHbI
3BKoH..060ne-
pml'IBHO-poJblCK-
HOH:.I{eJlTeJlb-
HOCTI.]»
3alloH YKpa(1Hbl
..060nepaTB-
HO-pOJbICKH()i1
lle.llTeJlbHOCT»

C03JlilBaTb B uelIJlX 1I0HCnl1paUI1I111eretUll1pO-
BaHl-Jble npennpl1J1TI1J1. Y4pe;t(LleHI1H 11 ()pr3-
J-J1133LW1I1 (n 5cr 14)
C031l3B3Tb KOHCnl1paTI'IBHble npellnpl'lJlTI'IJI.
opr3HI133UI1I1(n. 61! 'I 1 CT 8)
C03JJ.3B3Tb KOHCnl1p3TI1BHble npellnpl1HTI1.SI 11
opraHmaUl111 (n. 12 CT. 7)
OCHOBb!B3Tb .DJIJI npl1l1pblTI1J1 npeJlnpl1J1TI'IJI,
OpraH(l3aUl1I1 11 Y'1pe}l(,J],fHI1J1. I1CnOlIb30BaTb
perI'lCTpaUI1()HJ-Jble 1I0KYMeJ-JTbl. B TIllCKe JHa-
)(11 (IX pa3J1H<IlUI (on03HaHI1J1) C ueJlblO 06ec-
ne'leHI1J1 ()nepanlBHoti AeJITelIbHOCTI'I 11 COJ-
D;aHI1J1 6.rraronpl1.SlTHblX .DJIJI Hee YCJ10E\l'Iii
(n. 6".1 CT. 28)
Y'Ipe;t(LlaTb npellnpl1S1TI1.SI. Y4pe}l(l\eHI1J1 11 op-
raHI1JaUl'll1, ()oeCne'II1B3101Ul1e ()nepaTI'IBHYIO
lIeSiTelIbHOCTb 11 COJI\3I()ll!l1e.DJIJl Hee 6.rmr()-
npl'lJlTHble YCJlOBI1.SI. nOJlb30BaTbC.II perl'lCTpa-
Ul10HHblMI1 11 OT11I1'1I1TelIbHbIM(I 3HBKBMI1-
npellnpm1TI'I. Y'-1pe;t(LleHI1 11 opraI-JI1.!aUI'li1
(n «a"'i.2cT6)
2.6. HMeTb rnacHblx 11 HernaCHblX ll!TarHblX
pa60THl1l1oB(n 12'1 2CT 8)
2.7. nOJ1y'12Tb OT IOpl1Jll1'ieCKI1X 11 4Jml'l'ie-
CIII1X11l1u6ecnlIaTH() I1J1I1 Ja BOJHarp3;t(LleHl1e
I1H4JOPMBl!1'I1O 0 rOTOBSlll!I1XCJI 111I11 COBepll!eH-
HblX npec1)'Il1leHI1S1X tI yrp03e 6e30I1aCHOCTI1
o6wecn3 11 rocy.uapCTE\a (n 7'1 1 CT. 6)
154
flpodOfiJ/CeHue ma6f1. 14
3allOH Pecny6-
11I1KI'I Eellapycb
«060nepaTa-
HO-p03bICKH()i1
lleSlTeJlbHOCTIf"
3aKoH Pecny6
1111)(11 Ka3aXCTaH
«06onep:rrB-
HO-p03bICKtlOH
lle.llTeJlbHOCTIII"
3aKOH
KbIprbl3CKoi1
Pecny6lIl1l1l1
,,06onepaTHB-
HO-p03bICIIH()H
lleSlTellbHOCT"
3aI<OH
J]aTlJl1iicKoii
Pecny6lIHKI'I
«060nepaTB-
H()HlleSlTeJlb-
3aKOHJ]I1TOB-
CKOH Pecny6J111-
)(11 ,,06onepa-
TI'IBH()lleSl-
Te.bH()CT"
.:Sa
«06onepaTIfB-
HO-pOJbICKHOii
lleSiTCilbHOCTIf"
3alloH YKpal1Hbl
«06 ()nep:rrl1B-
HO-p03bICKHOH
neSlTeJlbHOCT"

npoiJon;Jlcel/uema6J/.14
J 2 3
n()J]}f'IaTb 0' 1OpH!l..ecKHx H I)JI1JH'lecKHx 3aKoH Pecny5
nlm tieCnJlaTHO I'IJ1H 3a BOJHBrpaJIUleHHe HH- JlHKI:I EeJ1Bpycb
1)J0pMHLl1O 0 TOTOBHIl!IIIXCSI WUJ COBeprneH- «060nepaTa-
HblX npecrynJleHHSlx H yrpo.>e 6e30nBcHocTH HO-pO.>bICKHOH
()\'ill!eCTBH 11 rocy.napcrna (n. 8 CT. 14) lleSlTeJIbHOCT»
n()J])"1HTb 6e31103Me3JIHO H HcnOJlb30BHTb 3allOH Pecny5_
I'IMelO11lY1O JHa'leHHe ill" peWeHI1H JanH'I JlI'IKI1 KH3aXCT"H
OPI! HHI]:IoPMaUI'lIO npyrx MHHI1C-repCTI1, ..O\'i()nepaTB-
BC.llOMCTI1, npelinpHIITI'IH. }"IPf:)IUleHI'IH 11 op- HO-pOJbICKHOH
TaHHJUIIIH He3aBHCHMO Or I)JOpM co6CTBeH- .o:eSlTClIbHOCT»
H()CTH (CT 8)
He npe.o:YCMOTpeflO 3aKoH
Kblprbl3CKoH
Pecny5J1HKI'I
«060nepHTB-
HO-p03bICIlHOH
lleJITenbH(...."TII
2.8. npl1MCHIITb CpCnCTBa I)JHJI:I'ICCKOfO B03- 3alloH YKpaHHbl
.o:eHcTBlUl, CneLll1HJ1bHble cpC1lCTBB H Of He- «060nepaTB_
CTpeJIbHOe opY)KHe no OCHOIJaHHSlM H e no- HO-pO.>bICKHOH
pIIIKe, YCTHH()II.'JeHHbIMI1 JHKOHBMH" 0 MI1J1I1- lleSlTeJIbHOCT»
UHH, CITy",&: HHLlHOHaJlbHOH 6eJonacHOCTIII,
nOrpHflH'IHblX BoiiCKaX, YnpaBJleHlJH oxpaHbl
BbIClU1.JX 1l0J[)KHOCTHblX JlI1Ll YKpal1Hbl (n. 18
'I. leT 8)
2.9. Hcn()J]b30B.1Tb nOMOll!b llOJDKHOCTHblX Jll'ILl 3allOH Pecny5-
1'1 CneUHaJll1CTOB, ()\'iJIMHIOIl!HX HeU6\Ol1HMbIMI1 JlHKI1 KH3aXCT"H
HaY'IHO-TC>;HWICCKHMI1 HJ1H I1Hb!MI1 CnCLlaJlb- «06onepaTHB-
HblMH n03HHHI1S1MH (n. «e» 'I. 1 CT. 8) HO-p03bICKHOH
lleHTe;IbHOCT»
!lon)!(HOCTHble nH OpraHOl1, ocyweCTI1- 3aKoH
JlJIlOWI.JX GPIt. pewalOT " 33Jla'llJ OyreM KblpTbI3CKOH
JlH'IH()fO Y'lacTHH e opraHH3aLll111 11 npoBene- Pecny5J1HKI1
HHI1 OPM. HcnoJlb3YJl n()M()Wb 1l0J[)KHOCTHb1X «06()nepaTB-
JlI1Ll 1'1 cneLlHB.rmCTOB, 06JIBJlHIOWlfX HaY4HbI- HO-p03bICIlHOH
MH. TeXHH'IeCKI1/1,UJ H lIPYfHMH CneLllJaJlbHbI- .o:eSlTellbHOCT
MH n03HHHHJlMI1. B THl0Ke cOlleHCTBl'Ie 0'-
lleJIbHblX rpa)K!!3H C HX COrJlacHJI HB rJlacHoH
11 HeTJlacHoiiocHoBe ('I. 6 CT. 16)
155

1 2 3
2.10. npBJ1eKaTb n() comaCOBam'110 C I\PY- 3m<OH
fl1MI1 opraHa"tH. H"lelOlUHMI'I npano ocywc- Pccny6J1HU'I
CTBJ1eHHII OP!l H8 TppHTOpHH Pcny6JJIfKH KaJa1(CTaH
KaJaXCT8H. Cl.JJJbl H CpellCma 3TH" OpraHOB ..060nepaTIfB-
..,'" npOBCnCHH" OTlItJlbHblX MepOnpH"TI:IJI HO-pOJbICIlHOH
n.«J»'l. ICT 8 lleSlTcnbHOCTW>
He npenYCMOTpeHO 3aKOH
KbIprbl3CKoJl
Pecny6J1I1KI'I
..06()nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKH()Jj
neSlTeJ1bHOCT»
2.11. npOBclleHI1e onepaUHH no 3aXIJ3ry BOO- 3allOH YKpa(JHbl
pyJKeHHb!X nTIHHIlOB. npeCC'leHl1e TSI}I(- ..06onepaTIfB-
npeCT)'nlleHI1i1, pa3BellbIBaTeJ1bHo-nOJl- HO-p03bICKHOk
pblBHOi1 JleSlTeJ1bHOCTI1 cneUCJ1¥)!(6 }lHOCTjJaH- lleSiTenbHOCT»
;: '1'p. fraHI13aL!Hli 11 QTJ\fJlbHbIX
npoBelleHHe onepaUl.JJj no JaXBa1Y BOopy 3aKoH Pecny6
)KeHHbIX npecTynHI'IKoB (003. 16 n. 5 CT. II) nHKH KaJ.axcHII-J
..06()nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKH()H
UZ_ HCIITCilbHOCTW>
n peCJ1C1l0B3 HHe-Imua-:-COeepw8101lIcro 3allOH Pccny6-
COBepUUJBlllerO npeCT)'nJ1eH(je, . ,m JII1KHKaJ.aXCTal::l
33J\epJK3H}le (863. 16 n 5 CT. II) ..060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOi1
.!\eJneJ]bHOCT
He npenYCMOTpeH() 3aKoH
KbIprbl3CKoi1
Pecny6J1HKI'I
«Q6onepaTlfD-
H:O-p03bICIlHOit
LleSlTnbHOCT
OcymeCTBJUITb npeeeHTI1BHOe 33JlepJKaHl1e 3aKOHl1I1TOB-
nl1ua (CT. E npI1M.) eKOH Pecny6J111-
KI1 ..06 onepa-
TI'IBH:OHLleJiI-
-I :'.13. Y"cr""" . opo",p.o ."..".o- Te.bHOCT»
3aKoH YKpal1Hhl
X03S1HcTBeHol1 LleITJ\hH()C':rH npe!lnpl1Ji1TI1H. «Q6onepaTB-
Y'1pe)KjJeH:I1I1, OpraHl13aUl1li I1 DT.lleJlbHblX H:O-p03bICKHOH
no" LleSlTeJ\hHOCT»
npoiJo.l:JICelillema(jA 14
156

OKOH'IaHlIema(jJ/ 14
J 2 3
npHHH},tarb Y4f1Cn'Ie B npoBepKe $HHaHcoBo- 3aKoH Pecny6-
X()3S1CTlJeHH() neSlTeJlbHOCTIf npellnpl1S1Tlfk. JlI1KI'I EeJlapycb
Y4pe>lUleHI1M. opraHI1JaUHM 11 OT.ueJlbHbIX JlI1U «Q60nepaTB-
(n. 6 cr. 14) HO-p03bICKH()
neSlTeJlbHOCTW'
He npellYCMOTpeH() 3aKoH
KblpfbrJCKo
Pecny6J1I1KI'I
«Q6onepaTIfB-
HO-pO.>bICKHOH
neSlTeJIbHOCT»
npalla opraHOB. ocywecTBJIJIIOI OP.D:. npen;ycMaTpIIBIIIOT cJlelQ'lO-
lltHeCTaTbH:JaKOH08,
CTaTbl1 6. 15 (])ellepallbH()ro 3aKOHa ..06 onepaTIfIJHO-p03bJCKHO
.uCHTeJ1bHOCTI'I»
CraTbSI g 3al<t.1Ha YJ<paI'lHbl ..06 onepm'!BIJO-po3blCKHOtI: .DeHTeJIbHOCTI'I».
CTaTbl1 5. 14 "3aKoHa Pecny5J1HKH EeJIapycb ..06 ()nepaTHIJHO-
P03b!CIIHOM .u:eSlTeJlbHOCTW'.
CTarbl1 8, II 3aKOHa Pecny5J1HIII1 Ka3axcraH .Q6 onepaTHBH()-
p03blcIIHoi1J\eHTeJlbHocTH»
CTaTbH 18 3aKOHa KbrprblJCKoi1 Pecny6J1I1KI1 ..06 onepaTHBHo-
pOJbICII}j()k.uCSlTCJlbHOCTW>
CTarbH 6-17 PaYl. I 3aKOHfI J]:lTImiicKoii Pecny6J1I1KH ..06 onepa-
TI'IBHOHneSlTeJlbHOCTW'
CTaTbSl 6 3f1KOHfI JhnOBcKoii Pecny6J1('JK('J ..06 onepaTHBHoii lleSl-
TeJIbH()CTI1".
CTarbH 6. 13 3aKOHa Pecny6J1HKIJ MOJ1llOBa ..06 onepaTIJBHO-
p03bICKH()i1Ae.II.TeJlbHOCTIJ».

Ta6.rmua 15
3aIlOHQIJ,aTf'J11>1101' onp&:.ItI'J1et111e npHI1I!HnOBOP,IJ
H onepaTHBHo-paJblCKHblX :JaKOHax CTjlaH CHr 11 EaJlTHI1
Hou.uelfQ6(j-;jue -
M npUl/l{unblOPp' 3tlK0H0iJameJlbl/biX
ny, OKm06.peVlG-
.'>IeHmupyIOI1J,Ux
OPO
J 2 3
I n HHUHn:JaKOHIfOCm
OPll ()CHOBblBaeTCSI Ha KOHCllfTYLm()HHblX epanbHbiJI
npHUl1naX 3aKOHH()CTI1 (CT. 3 rn I) 3aKoH..06()nepa-
THBHO-p03bICUiOii
lIelITtJlbHocrn»
OP,IJ OCHOBblBaeTC.II Ha npl1HUHnaX 3aKOHH()- 3aKoH YKpaHHbl
CT(CT. 3rn. I) ..06 ()nepaTl1B-
HO-pOJbICKHOH
JleSlTeJ1bHOCTH»
opn CTpOI1TCH Ha OCHOl3e nplIIHUtma 33KOI1- 3aKOH Pecny6-
H()CTH (CT 3) nHII EeJJaPycb
..06onepaTB-
HO-pOJbICKHOH
lIe.llTeJlbHOCTH
OPll ocyweCTBJ1HeTC.II B COOTIjtrCTImH , 3al<OH Pecny6-
npHUl1naMH :JaKOHH()CTH (CT 3) mKH Ka3aXCTaH
..06onepaTB-
HO-PO:JbICIlHOH
Jle5lTeJlbHOCTW>
opn OCHOBblBaeTCH Ha npHHUHnax 3aKOHH()- 3aKOH
CT(CT.4) KbIprbl3CKoH
Pecny6J1I1KH
..060nepaTl1B-
HO-p03bICKH()H
JleSlTeJIbH()CTH»
OnepanlBHa.ll JleSlTeJIbHOCTb n()llIIe)l(HT opra- 3aKOH
HI13aU(J 11 ocymeCTHJ1eHI1IO Ha OCHOBe 3a- J1aTBI1CIIO
KOHHOCTI1 (n. I CT. 4) Pecny6J1I1I1(J
Meponpl1HTHJI ()nepaTHBH()H lIe.llTeJ1bHOCTH ..06 ()nepaTHB-
CJIellYeT HalJHHfln 11 ()cyweCTBJ1J1Tb TonbKO e H()HJleSiTenb-
TOM cnY'13e. eCJII1 BbIl10J1HeHl1e YKa:JflHHbIX B HOCTI1
CTaTbe 2 HaCTOJImCro 3allOHa 11 JlOCTI1>KeHI1C
o[Jpe!leJIeHHbIX B CTane I ueJleH HHblM cn()-
:I1T:M:O CT11 cywecTBeHHo ,,-
158

npoOolJlC(!lIue maM. 15
I 2 3
opn OCHOBblBaeTCH HB npl1HLll1ne 3aKOHHO- 3aKOH Pecny6-
em (cr. 4) nl1KIJ MOJU\oBa
06 onepaTI1B-
HO-pOJbICKHOH
JleSlTJ1bHOCTI1"
2 " HllImcoiin UCBOOo.J,'I.eJlOBeKa
<Jpn OCHOBbJBaeTCSI Ha 1I0HCTI1TVUI1()HHbIX Q)e.uepa,lbHbln
npmml1nax YBa;t<eHI1H 1'1 c06J1fOlleHI1H npaB 11 JaIlOH 06one-
cD06011'JeJ1()BeKa 11 rpaJKlJaHI'IHa(cT. 3) paTl'lDHo-po3bICII-
HOWJleSlTeJ1b-
HOCTI1
opn OCHOBbIBac:TCSI Ha nplJHLll1naX c06J1f0- 3allOH YKpHI1HbI
JleHlJH npaB 11 c8060.ll 'leJ10aeIlH (CT. 4)  06 onepaTI1D-
HO-pOJbICKHOH
JleSlTJ1bHOCTI1"
opn CrpOI1TC.II Ha OCH()De cOOJllo.neHI1.11 3axOH Pecny6
npl'lHLll1na c06J1fo.neHI1H npaB 11 cBo6011 'le- J111111'1 EeJIHpycb
J10BeKa I1cBo6011J1I'1'IH()CTI1 (CT. 4) 06()nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKH()W
.ueSlTeJ1bH()CTI1»
opn ocyureCTBJ1HeTCSI II COOTBnCTBl'lI'l C nJllfH- 3aKoH Pecny6-
LlnaMI1 c06mO!!eHI1H npal1 11 cB060il, YBaJKe- lU1KI1 Ka3aXCTHH
HI1H !!OCTOlJHCTBH J111'1HOCTIJ, paeeHCTBa rpa- 06onepaTB-
}l(!\aH nepel! 3HKOHOM (CT. 3) HO-pOJbICIlHOW
JleSlTJ1bHOCTI1
Opn OCHODblDfieTC.II HH npl1HLll1nHX COfuIlO- 3aKoH
JleHI1.11 npaD 11 CB060l! nl1'lHOCTI1 (cr. 4) KbIprblJCKOn
Pecny6J1I1KI1
06onepaTI1B-
HO-pOJbICKH()n
JleSlTeJlbHOCTI1
OnepanJBHa.ll JleSlTeJlbHOCTb n()D)le)KI1T opra- 3aKoH
HlfJaLl1111 11 ocyweCTflJlefil1l0 C c06J1IO!JeHIfI1 JlaTBl1ijclloij
Bce06WHx npaD '1eJ10ReKa (n. I CT 4). Pecny6J11f1l1'l
OnepaTHIIHble 3a.11aHlfH Heo6XOllIJMO BblnOJ]- 06onepaTlfB-
HHTb no B03MOJKHOCTH 11 Mefibwe DMeWIfBa- HOWJlCSlTeJ]b-
HCb R c$epy npaR 'leJloaellB (n JeT. 4) fiOCTI1»
"pH npoeel!eHI1I1 "tepOnpI1.HTIJi1 onepaTI1B-
HOi1 .r:LeJlTeJ1bHOCTH Janpewae-rcSI: HitHOCI1Tb
nl1UaM tfJl1311'.eCKI1H 11J111 MfiTeptUEIhHbli1
ylJ..I,fp6. nOJlDepraTb yrp03e >KI13Hb 11 3J\OpO-
ebe, Yl"pOA(dTh npl1MeHeHl1eM cpen,CTe $1311-
e:H:e:;;M n:h nl1Ll .
159

npoiJon;Jlcel/uema6J/.15
1 2 3
opn OCHOBblBaeTCSI H8 nplJHLll1naX co6J1Jo- 3aKoH Pecny6-
.ueHI1J1 npaa 11 cB06011 J111'lHOCTI1 (CL 3) J1l1l1lJMoJ1l10aa
..06onepaTl1B-
HO-p03bICKHOn
neHTe.llbHOCTI1»
3 "pHHlUln B3aHMoneiiCTBHJI C opraHaMIl )'npaB-
- opn OCHOBblaaeTCJI H8 npl1HUHnaX B3aI1MO- 3allOH YKpal1Hbl
nei1cTBIiH C opnuJaMI'I ynpaBJIeHI1J1 (CT 4) ..06onepaTl1B-
HO-pOJbICKHOn
neHTC.IIbHO(''TI1''
opn QCHOBb](laeTCSI H8 npl1HUlJnaX B3a111>10- 3aKOH Pecny6-
.ueliCT5111l C llpyrl'lMI1 OpraH8MI1 ynpaBJ1eHI1Il J1I1KI'I MOJ1l10Ba
(CT. 4) ..06onepaTl1B-
HO-pOJbICKHOn
neHTC.IIbHOCTw>
He npellycMorpeHO 38KOH
Kblprbl3CKOH
Pecny6J1I1KlJ
..06onepaTI1B-
HO-p03bICKHOH
.ueSlTeJ1bHOCTI1"
4 flpllllUHn IWHCIDI
OPl1 OCHOBblBaeTCSI H8 IIOHCT11l)'UHOHHbIX .Ilep:!JIbHblfr
nplJHLll1rIaX KOHCnlJpaLll111 (CT. 3) JaKoH..06one-
p.:tTIIBHO-poJbICK-
HOHlleSlTCJ1b-
- OPll OCYUleCTRJ1J1CTCSI a COOTBCTCTBI1I1 C npl1H- HOCTI1"
3aKOH Pecny6-
Lll1nro.tI1KOHcnltpaLll1lJ (CT. 3) IHKI1 Ka"3a1(CTaH
..06onepaTB-
HO-P03bICIlHOH
neSlTeJ1bHOCTI1"
opn OCH()BbIBaeTCJI HB npl1HUl1naX KOHCnl1- 3aKoH
paUHI1(cr.3) Kblprbl3CKOn
Pecny6J1I1KH
..06onepaTI1B-
HO-p03bICIlHOH
.ueSlTeJlbHOCTI1"
160

2
.. DHHuHn BJaHMO.IIt'IIC"mHR C HacenCHIlCM
opn OCHOBbIBaerC!'I Ha npHHW1nax B3BHMO-
.uejkTB(JHC HaCeJ1eHl1eM (CT 4)
He npellYCMOl'peHO
OnepaniBHa.ll .ne!lTeJlbHOCTb n())]]]eJKHT opra-
HH3aU(J 11 ocymeCTBJ1eHHIQ B COTPYJlHH'IC-
CTBe C HaCeJleHHeM npl1 onope Ha ero no-
MOlllb{n I CT. 4)
flpQ()o/l.1ICf!Huema(j/l.15
3aKOH YKpal1Hbl
060nepaTl1B-
HO-p03bICKHOn
)leSlTeJ1bHOCTW>
3aKoH
KbIpfbl3CKOR
Pecny5J1111111
..06onepaTI1B-
HO-p03bICKHOH
neSlTeJIbHOCTH»
3aKOl!
JlaTBlllikllOH
Pecny5J1I1KI'I
..06om:prIllBHOH
lleSlTe.f\bHOCTH»
7 np"HlUln IIOllKOIJ'IIIOlbHOCTH BblCWHM opraH8M
rocvJlaeHBoiillJ1aCTHl1nlD4l1.11eHHH
- opn CTpOI1TCSI liB OCHOBe npHHUHnOB nOli 3aKOH Pecny6-
KOHTPOJ1bHOCTH 11 n()J\OT4eTHOCTIJ BblCWHM JlHIIH 6eJU1pyCb
OpraHaM rOCVllapCTBCHHofi DJlaCTIf II ynpaB. I ..06 onepaTlm-
JleHI1S! (CT. 4) HO-pO.ibICKHOH
-..--  _ _ JleSlTeJlbHOCTW>
8 npHHUl1l1 Mt:KIIBTHunl1 OPM IIJIH"HHt: H]-
- =H::TI'lIj OnepaTlIBHOH lleJlTeJIbHocTH.
8M I1X npOBelleHI1.11. 06"eM 11 I1HTeHCI'IB-
HOCTb JlOJUKHb! coo-meTCTBOB!lTb Blt1ly nocSI-
raTeJ1bCTBa 11 CTeneHI1 OnaCH()CTH (n. 3 CT. 4)
.. I(HnlleHLleO;JOrH3awIHH6ecna
Cy61.eKTIlM OnepaTI'IBHOH neSITeJ1bHOCrn 11 I1X
J\omKHOCTHbIM "IHLl<I»t 3!'Inpeu.reHO npSlMO I1JUI
OnOCpe,llOBaHOJ1eHcTooB:m, B III-ITejJeCW( nOJII1-
TJNeCI<I1)( n"pTj:j. Opr"HI.f3aUI'IJ:l 11 nBI'I)KeHI1J:1
IfJlHJIIIll. BeWIll!aTbCli flnellrr:JlbHOCTb IIHCTIf-
T)'L1HI1 rocynapCTBeHHOfi 1iI1ik.111 11 ynpalil1eHl1Ji,
)'4pe>K..!\eHHfi npoh"YJITIYPbl H CY!!iI, a TaICKe 06-
wecTBeHHblX, nOJlIITlI"leCKIiX 11 peJlIfl"If())Hb!X
opraHH3al!i1 C UeJ1blO OKfi3HHSI RIIItSiHIt" I1J1It
BO:UIeHCTBIUIH:I HI1X,3!'II1CKlIIO'leHHeMC!1)"liIeB,
Koma :1TO He06xQ[J,MO n:m npenOTl!jnweHItSl 11
"""Krn.rJ"I1S1 nN'MVJl;ICHI1Hln 6cr.4
161
3aKOH
JlaTBI'li1CKOIi
Pecny5J1ItIlH
..06 ()nepaTl'lBHofi
nemt:JlhHOCTII"
3aKOH
JlaTBl1i1cllofi
Pecny5J1ItKI1
..06 onepantBHOJ:l
llel(lt:JlbHOCTII"

O/WH'laHlIema(j/l 15
1 2 3
OPLl OCHOBbIB'leTCJI Ii<! npl1HLllmaX J\el1J\eo- 3iiKOH Pecny6-
Jl0fl13aLlIUl 11 6ecnapTj{Hoc-rn (a63. 7 CT. 3) JII1KI1 MOJU\olJa
..06onepaTI1B-
HO-p03bICKHOi1
10- J\eSlTeJIbHOCTW>
" 111(H" BeHCT8B " :JBKOHOM
MepOnpl1J1TI1J1 onepaTI1BHOH J\eSlTeJIbHOCTI1- 3aKOH
npoBoWlTCSI HeJBBrJCrJMO 0, rpIDK.1!aHI:TBa, JlaTBIIIHclIOH
nOlla. HaLlI10HaJIbHOCTrJ. BQ3PacTIl. MeCTa npo- Pecny6JII1I1I1
}lmBiiHI1J1, 06pB30BBHI1J1, COLlI18J!bHOrO, CJIY- ..o6011t:pTIlIBHOH
}l(e6Horo " I1MyLl.lfcTlJeHHoro nOJ10}l(eHI1}[ " .u:eSlTC:J1hHOCTJ1O>
.u:on>KHOCTHhIX JlI1U, I1X nOJII1TlNeCKI1X 11 peJlI1-
rOJHhIX BJrJlSl1l0B, npl1HartJIe>KaIlIl.JX K napm-
JIM 11J1I1I1HbJM ()6rneCTBeHHhIM opraHI13aLlI1J1M.
YnOMHHyrble 4IaKTOpbl He 1l0JI)KHbJ B!1I1J1Tb Ha
onepanJBHYIO lleSlTeJlbH()CTb, eCJII'I :no oco6o
HC ()fOIlO"":HO JallOHOM (n 5 CT 4)
II n "3KO:lOIWlecKoii6eJOIII!.CHOCTH
np" npOeelleHl'I11 MepOllpl1}ITI1H OnepaTI1B- 3f1KOH
HOO neSiTenbHOCTI1 lanpeuraeTC.II HaHOCI'ITb JlaTBI1HcKOH
cyrnecTBeHHblH epeLl OKpyJIWlOlllej{ cpeLle Pecny6J1I1KI1
(n 2 CT. 4) ..06onep1T1tBH011
lle.llTeJIbHOCll'I»
12 n nl'lroetJ H HOC11I
OPLl OCHOBblBaeTCJI Ha I1pI1HLll1nC CBOCBpC- 3aKOH Pccny6-
MeHHOCTrI 11 HficrynaTeJ1bHOCTI1 (a6J. 7 CT. 3) JII1KI1 MOJU\oBa
..060nepaTI1B-
HO-pOJbICKHOH
---.J - [fr.....lJ,II,,-CU....,...'HH.II J\eSlTi1bHOCTW>
maCHblX " Heo,ilCHbIX
>1CTOllOBHCDelI£m
OPLl OCI'IOBblBacTC.II Ha npl1HUHne CO'leTaHI1.11 llCpaJIbHblH
maCHblX " Her.'1aCHbIX MCTOLlOB " CpClICTB 3aIlOH..06one-
(CT. 3) parnBHO-poJblCII-
HOHlIC.IITeJ1b-
HOCTI1C<
OPLl OCHOBblBaeTC.II I-IB npl1HUl1ne CO'leraHI1.11 3aKoH
rnaCl-lblX " HerJlBCHbIX MCTOllOB H cpellcTB KbIpfblJCKOH
(CT. 3) Pecny6J1I1KI'I
..06onepaTHB-
HO-pOJbICKHOi1
J\eSlTeJIbHOCTH»
162

3BKOH(W,BTei1bHOe OnpeJrelJ('HHe 1lJlllHDl00II opn npel\YclIIItrpIIBMOT
I01UIIt'CTaTbH3aKOHOB.
CT3TbSl J 4IllepanbHoro :>aKOH3 ,,06 onepaTI1BHO-p03bICIlHOH llS1-
Tei1bH()CTI1".
CraTbli 4 3aKQH3 YIIp1IIIIHbl ,,06 onepaTIllJHo-JXI3t.ICKHOiI !!S1TCi1bHOCTI1"
CTaTbli 4 3aKoHii Pec:ny5J1MKrI 5eJJapycb ,,06 OnepaTrIBHO-p03bIC:KHOH
!!eSlTei1bHOCTI1"
CTaThIi J 3all01-l3. Pecny6J1111111 Ka:JaXcriIH ,,06 onepaTBHo-p03bIC:KHOH
AeSlTei1bH()CTM".
CT3TbSl J JaKoHB Kblprbl3cIIOH Pecny6JU'IKM ,,06 onepaTHBHo-
pOJblCKHOI1 .ne.IITCnbHOCTrI".
CT3TbSl 4 3all01-l3. J1arBl'Il1cllol1 Pecny5J1I1KI'I ,,06 OnepaTI'IBHOn lleSl-
TC.IIbHOCTI1".
CraTbH 3 3aKoHa Pccny5m'lKI'I MWUloBa ,,06 ()nepaTI'IBHo-po3b1CKHol1
.ueSlTeJ1bHOCTI1".

Ta6J1Hua 16
KoHTjlO.1b H HIIJUop J.3. O.-qJJrnmt1O-I1J13b1CKHOii .!WIITeJlbHOCThlO.
llJIellJlcMOTpeHIJ....e JaKOHOJLrR!_LlMH 8KTaIltU. pern8MeHTHp)'IOUUlMH opn
B crpaHax CHI" u 6aJlTHH
'"
"In
1aKOIKJdamelbHoe 30If'HUe KOHmpOilH
U HaIDvpa 30 onepumU6Hu--pa:lWCKHOii
i)eRme,1bHocmb/Q
I"ocy...ii KOHTpOJIb J.3. Opn co CTO-
Hbl A3
KOHTpOJ1b 311 Opn ()CyweCTBJlIICT npe:UUlCHT
POCCH£icKO£i 41cllcpaum'l
n ",n aIlleH-.-CKHl1tl1I1tI Pfl,l .1>
41Cllepa.nbHoe Co6paHI1e PocCl1ikKOH: 41eJlt:-
pawm
KOHTpOJ1h Ja Opn 11 pac1[()lJOlJaHl1eM Bbl1lC
JlIICMhrX Ha TIf UCJ11'1 IPI1HaHCOlJblX cpellcTD
ocyw:eCTRJ1JIeT KOMI1CCHII BepxoDHoro COBCTII
Pecny{)J1I1KIf 6eJ1apycb no 1J0npOCaM HaUHO-
HaJ1bHOH: 6C30naCH()CTIf. 06OPOHbl 11 6opb6bl
en nHOCTblO
KOHTpOJIb 311 Opn ocymCCTBJUICT CIIJH:M
KOHTpO.b 311 Qpn OCYIUCCTBJlIlIOT COOmeT
CTIJ)'IOWI1C nOCTOIIHHblC IIOMI1CCI1I1 napJIa-
n pa BllTe1JbC11l6lHblil KOHT poJ1b
flpaHHTC:IbCTHO POCCHH:CKOil €DeJ:\epaUHH B
npellCJlaX nOJll-JoMo'll1ii, OnpelleJ1l1eMblX KOH-
cnrryUI1CH PocrnHCIIOH 4lellcpaUIfI1. (Iclle-
paJ1bHb!MI1 IIOHCTlfi)'UlfOHHblMI1 npalJ<1MI'I 11
.ae a.nbHbIMI13aKOHaMll
164
HUUMeHOl/rlHUe
30KoHoOomeJ/bHbIX
UKm06.pei!.ilO-
MeHmupym/u,ux
OPJl
3
41ellepa.bHbrii
I.IIKOH ..06 one-
panIRHo-p03b!CK-
HoiiJ\csITeJlb-
HOCT»
41ellepa.nbHblH:
3IIKOH .(X':ione-
panIBHo-p03bICK-
Hoiij\eSlTeJlb-
HOCT»
3aKoH Pecny{)
JlI1K1'1 ECJ1apycb
..060nepaTI1B-
HO-p03bICKHOii
nCIITeJ1bHOCTIf»
3aKOH
J]aTIJI1H:CKOii
Pecny{)J1I1KH
",060nepanl(lHoii
.1IeSlTCJlbHOC111.
3aKoH Pecny{)
JlllK" M0J1110Da
..060nepaTI1B-
HO-p03bICKHOfi
.nCIITeJ1bHOCTIf»
41ellepaJIbHblfi
3aKOH ,(X':ionc-
paTIfBHO-P03b!CK-
HOHllCSrreJlb-
HOCT"

COOTl!eTI;TBYlOllllft OpTaHbI COBtTa M(JHIfCT-
po'
BblnOJIHCHlfe 3MaHI1A cy6'beKT8MIf OnCp8
TI1BH()H J\eSlTCJIbHOCTIf KOHTpOJIIfPyCTCJI B
nOpAilKC, YCT3HOBJICHHO),t 33KOHOM (J Ka611-
HeTOM MIfHl1cTpOB
4 npOKYPopcKlliiH3,;J,30)J
HaLlJOp 38 I1CnOJIHCI-1I1CM 38KOHOB POCCI1A
CIIOH €DeJ:\epaUIfIf. opraH3MIf, OCYWCCTB-
JUIIOWI1MIf OPll, 0CYllleCTBJ1J11OT reHCpaJIb-
HblA npOKYPop PoccHAcKOn €DeJ\epam1l1 11
}1I0JIHOM0'1CI-IHbIC HM m>OKYJYIn.1>bI
HaJ\30p 3<\ C06J1IOJ\eHIfCM a8KUHOB nplf npo-
BeJ\eHIfIf OPM ocyweCTBJI.IIeTCSI reHepaJIb-
HblH npOKypOPOM YKpal1Hbl 11 n()ll'lIfI-lCH-
HblMIf eMY npOllypopaMIf KpblMCKOli ACCP,
06.rrnCTCfI. (()pOJ\OB KI1CBa If CCBacron0J1}1
KOHTpOJlb 3a C06J1fOJlCHHCM 3aKOHHocm B
OPll OCYllleCTBJ1.11eTCJl rCHepaJ1bHbiM npOIlY-
pOpOM Pccny5J1HKI1 6CJIapYCb, npoKypopaMI1
06.rrnCTdt. ropona MHHCK8, a TaiCKe cneUI1-
aJIbHO n()JII-IOIO'lCHHb]m nOOKvoooam
HaJ\30p 38 I1CnOilHCl-Il1eM 3"KOHOB B OPll
0CYlUCCTBJI.IIIOT fCHepaJIbHblH npOKypop Pec-
ny6n(JKIf Ka3axCTIlIfIf If nO.[('UlHelfHble eMY
npoKypopbl
H3Jl30p 3<\ IfCn()JIHeHlfeM 33KOHOB Kblp£bl3-
CKOJ:i Pecny6nHKIf OpraH1I..MIf, ocywecTB-
JIJlIOWI'IMIf OPll, ()CYlUecTBJISIIOT fCHepaJIb-
HblH npOKYpoP Kblprbl3CKOH Pecny6J1HIlIf H
ynO.:JHOMO'1eHHble IfM npOIlYPOPbl He HI1)KC
cTaTyca npOKypopOB 06J111..CTdi II ropolla
6HlUKeK
165
npoiJrmJlcel/uema6J/.16
3allOH Pecny5-
JII1KI'I6eJlapycb
06 oncpanlB-
HO-p03bICKHOfi
.nC}lTCJIbHOCT"
3aKoH
1TaTlJl1HcKOH
Pecny5J1IfKI1
06onepaTIfBHoti
JleJlTCJIbHOCTH&
€Dellepa.%Hblfl
3<\KOH 060[]e-
paTI1BHO-p03bICK-
HOHlle.llTeJIb-
HOCT&
3aKoH YllpallHbl
«06oncpaTHB-
HO-p03bICKHOk
neSlTCJ1bHOCT(f>i'
38110H Pecl1y5-
11IfKI1 6CJ1apycb
06 oncpaTl1B-
H()-P03bICKHOt!
nCI\TC.:JbHOCTH'"
3aKoH Pecny5-
11HKI1 Ka33xcT3H
060[]epaTHB-
HO-p03bICKHOfi
.ne.llTenbHOCTH&
3aKoH
Kblp£b13CKOfi
Pecny5J1I1KH
06 oncpaTHD-
HO-P03bICKHOfi
neSlTCJIbHOCTI1»

H8J\30p 3a COOTBTCTBItCM onr:paTItBHOH JleA-
T)lbHOCT JaKOHaM ocywecmnmur r CHC-
pa.rrbHblH npoKYPOp It oco60 yn())lHOMO'I8H-
HblC ItM npOKypOpbl
3aKOHHOCTb Onep<rnIBHOH JleSTeJlbHOC111 KOH-
TpOJIltpyeTCSI rCHCpaJ1bHbIH npoKypopoM JIIt-
TOBCKOH PecnyUJlltK1t I1JlIt JaMelillUOlill1M era
JlI1UOM
H8J\30p Ja ItCnOJ1HeHlteM 3aKOHOB Op.-aHfI-
MH, ocywecTEIJ!l!fOwltMIt OPn.. 11 JaIlOHHO-
CTbfO npl1HI1"taeMblX HMI1 peWeHI1 ()cywe-
CTBJlJlfOT npOKYPOP Pecny6J1ItKI1 MUJUlOBa,
ero ,taMeCTItTJIIt It npOK}'popbl ropo.aOB It
paHOHOB.
HalI30p Ja JleI!TeJ1bHOCTbfO Jlltti. OKaJb1BafO-
WHX 1t;'I1t OllaJblBaBWI1X KOH<!JltlleHUl.faJJbH()e
cOlldtcTBHe op.-aHaM. npOBOllSlWI1M OPM,
OCYlllCCTBJlJleT npoKypOp Pecny6JHJKIt MOJI-
llOBa 1tJ11t npOIlYPop, CnCUIt8}1bHO ynonHo-
M()'It'HHbIH npl1l1:JJOM npOKypopa Pecny6-
JlI1KH MOJlllOBB
KOH O;lbJaOpn
PYKOBOllI1TeJ111 opraHOIl. OCYWecTBJlSlfOWI1X
opn. Hecyr nCpCOHaJIbHYIO OTBCTCTBCHHOCTb
3a C06J1JOllCHIiCM JBIIOHHOCTIII nplt OpraHI1-
J.aUHI1 Ii npOBelleHlt1t OPM
KOHTpOJ1b Ja opn ocyweCTBJll!eTCH:
MBlI YKpaltHbl, CJ1YJK60H HaUHOH3J1bHOH
6C30naCHOCTH YllpaltHbl; YnpaElJ!eHItCM OX-
p:JHbl BblCWI1X llOJlJKHOCTHblX JlI1U YKPaIiHbI;
rocYJlapCTBeHHblM KOMlITeTOM no oxpaHe
r-oev.nancTBCHHQH Tn8.HItUbI YKn8ItHbl
PYIlOBOJlItTeJ11t opraHOB. OCyu..teCTBJ1J1fOIJ.!HX
opn. OnpellCJ1J1IOT nopSlJlOK BellOMCTBCHHOro
KOHTpO!1J1 J:J Het! It Hecyr nepCOHaJIbHYIO
OTBeTCTBeHH()CTb Ja C06!1I011eHlteM JaKOHHO-
ern nplt OpraHItJaUMIt 11 npoBet\eHItIt OPM
166
npoiJrmJlcel/uema6J/.16
3aKOH
JIaTBItHCKOH
Pecny6J1I1KI1
..060ncpaTHBHOn
Jle!'lT!1bHOCTI1»
3aKOH
JIItTOBCKOH
Pecny6J1I1KI1 ..06
Onej)<lTHBHot!
lleSlTlIbHOCTH"
3aKoH Pecny6-
JlItK'" MOlIllOBB
060nej)<lTHB-
HO-pOJbrCKHO
l!eSlTlIbHOCTM"
<toellepa.rrbHbrn
33KOH ..06onc-
paTltflHo-pOJbICK-
HOt!llCSlTelIb-
HOCT"
3aKoH YKpal1Hbl
06 oncpanlB-
HO-pOJbICIlHOH
l!eHTeJlbHOCTH»
3aKOH Pecny6-
JlI1KH EeJlapycb
..060nej)<lTHB-
HO-pOJbICKHOt!
lleSlTlIbHOCTH"

DKOI/'IDHUe maM. 16
I 2 3
BblweCToSlWl1e Bell()MCTBeHHble opraHbl ()5ec 3aKoH
ne4HBalOT KOHfpOJ1b 3a OPD, nQ.1\'lHHeHHblX Pcny5J1HKI1
HM oprSHOB. PYKoBOllI1TeJ111 opraHOB, ocy- K,:naxCTsH
l1\eCTBJIJUOUlHX OPD. 06eCne'lHB8IOT KOH- 06 onepaTI1B-
tpOJ1b Ja C05J1lOlleHl1eM JaKOHHOCTI1 "PH HO-p03bICKHOtl
o-nmHH3aUi1H 11 nnoOCllCH1111 OPM .IleJlTCiibHOCTI'I""
PyKoBOllIITenH opraHOB. 0CYUlecTBJ1J1IOWI'IX 3SKOH
OPD, fiecyr nepCOH8J1bHYIO OTBeTCTBefifiOCTb Kb1prbl3Clwii
Ja C06nlO1leHHe JIDWHHOCTH npH opraHHJ8- Pcny5J1HKI1
UI'II1 11 npOBelleHl111 OPM «06onepsnIB-
H()-P03bICKHOI1
aeJlTeJlbHOCTI'I»
nOpSli{OK KOH-rpOJlJl B Y'lpeJKaeHHJlX onepa- 3aKOH
Ti1BHOtl lleSITe.%HOCTI1 ycraHaBJII1BSIOT PYKO- JTaTBI1HCKofJ
BO!!HTeJlH 3THX Y'1peJKj{eHHi1, HeCYUlHe nep- Pcny5J1HIIH
COH8J1bHYIO OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a opraHJ.l3a- «06onepsn:!BHOn
UI'lIO pa60Tbl n01l'lI1HeHHbIX 11M CTPYKTypHblX neSlTeJlbH()CTH»
nOJlpa31leneHHH B coomercmllH C HaCTO\!-
WI'I"t 3aKOHOM l11lnVrl'lMH JSKOHaMH

Ta(iJmua 17
o6ecne'leHHeOnep3THBHO-pa3HCKIIoiilll'jlTeJ\bHOCTH
B crp3Hax CHf H 6aJ1THH
HOUMFHOflaHUe
M llolOJfCel/uR, KllCOKJUqlf'CR rpuHaHc(}Boo 3{]JwHodamF1b-
.y, 06ecne'leHUROPjJ HblXoKmoe,
pez:lOM€HmupylO-
UjuxOPjJ
I 2 3
I (J)HBaHcI\fJOB3HHe OPU H'JI"OCY.IJ.3II'C1VI'II1!(If"(I
6Kt'J)KeT3
focy.napCTBeHHblM opraH1I.M, nOllp,,3.1leJleHI1SI cI>eJrepaJIbHbI
KOTOpblX ynOJ1HOM04eHbi OCYll.leCTBJUITb opn. 3aKOH «06 one-
Bbl1lenllOTCH 113 4JellepaJIbHOrO 61OJ1)I(era 4m- panlBHo-
HaHCOBble cpellCTBa ('I.. 1 CT. 19) P03bICKHOl'lllcSI-
TeJlbHOCTW>
41I1HaHCl1pOBaHlfc OPU ocyrnocnmJJCTal 33 3aKOH
C'1 aCCHrH:ORaJiHti H3 pecny6J1HKaHClwro Pecny6J1HIIH
6101lJKeT3. HanpalmHeMblx trn co.aepJKaHHe op- K3J.aXCT3H
raHon, OCYUlec1BllHlOWI'IX opn, KaK B HaUJ'lO- ..060nepaTHH-
Ha!1bHOfi. Tall H (I HHOCTpaHHofi BaJlJOTe B HO-p03bICIlHOfi
nopSl.IJ.Ke, onpe.aeJ1S1eMOM 33KOH01l3TCJ1bCTBOM neSlTCJ1bHOCT"
=e:xc::CT6H:.e; OHH-
focy.napCTBeHHblM OpraHaM. oneparnBHble 3aKoH
nOllpa311eJ1eHHH IIOTOpblX ynOJ1HOM()'IBHbl Kblprbl3CKoti
oCYll.leCTBJ11ITb opn, BbIlleJlHlOTCH 113 61OJ1)I(e- Pecny6J1HKI'I
Ta 4JI1HaHCOBble cpelIcma, IIOTOpble pacxo- ..06oncpanm-
:::MO:: :aIfIHM; P}'IIO- HO-p03blcIIHOf1
neSlTC;'IbHOCTIf»
41HH3HCHpoBaHHc onepaTBHofi neHTeJlbHO- 3aKOH
CTI1 OCYllleCTBI1HeTCI1 113 cpenCTB rOCYAapCT- J]aTBHficKOfi
BeHHom 61OJ\JKeTa (p. 6 CT. JJ) Pecny6J1HKI1
..06onepulIIJHofi
.neJITe.!1bHOCTH»
Onep<mtBHaH.neffi'C"lbHOCTb$IfHaHcI1PYeTCSlI13 3aKoHJ]1fT0B-
cpenCTBfocy.napcTBeHHoro6JOJ1)I(eTa(cr 13) CKO" Pecny6J1I1-
1111 06 onepa-
TIIIBHOHlIeH-
TCJlbHOCTH"
MHHHcTepcTBaM. ynOJlHOM04CHHbiM ocywe- 3allOH Pecny6-
CTBJlHTb Opn, BbUleJ1HIOTCfl Ha 3TI1 ueJl" $11- J1HKI1 MOJULOB3
HaHCOHblC CpellCTB3 "' pecny6J1HII3Hclloro «06onepaTHB-
61OJ1)I(eT3 ('1.1 CT. 17) HO-p03bICKHOfi
.neI1TeJlbHOCT»
168

----£-1-. -
Z "Hble IICTO'lBIlKIl dmHaHCllpOB.3.HIIH OP,!t
3aWJ-iQlI8TeI1bHble 11 I1Cno."IHHTeJ1bHble ()praHbI
rocynajXTDCHHOH BJJaCTH Cyfu.cKTOB PoccHi:!-
CIIOH 4IellepaU1I BnpaBe caMOCl'OHTt'JTbHO Ja
(;4eT co6CTBeHHbIX 61Q11)KeTOB 11 BHe6101I.JI(eTHbJX
UeJ1eBbIX<!>oIi./lOB yaeJ1H'1I1BaThpa3MepCpe,i:lCTB,
BbUleJISleMb!X opraHaM, ocyun-rBI1HI011U1M QPIt
HB -repplITOpHH (':()()'JBe'TCTl'l. Cyfu.cKTOB
Poccj:jcKOIt.IH(...2CT.19)
41I1I-JaHcl1poBBfme QPLl OCYJJ.J,eCTBJ1HeTCH 3a
C'18T aCC1THOImHHj{ 113 MeCTHoro 61O.!LJKeTa.
HanpaWllleMblX liB COllep>Kalure opraHOB,
oCYlUeCTBJ1HIOWHX OPLl, KBK D HaUHOHaJlb-
HOI1, TaK 11 B III-j()CTpaHHOn oa.rnore B rlOpSlIl-
Ke, onpe.aenHeMOM 3aKOHo.aarelIhCTBOM Pec-
ny6J1iJKI1 Ka3aXCTIlH 11 Ka611HeTOM MI1HHCT-
pOB Pecny6J1HKI1 Ka3aXCTaH ([J S CT 20)
4Im-JaHCl1pODaHHc opn ocywecTDJlJreTCH
TalOKe 3a ClleT OT'II1CJ\eHllfI aT CYMM B03Me-
weHHoro rocynapCTBY YUlep6a, nocTyn<'IIO-
U.!('IX OT peam13aUH I1MYllleCTBa, 06pallleH-
HOro B nOXO!l rOCYllapCTBa Ha OCHODBHIIH
npl1rOBOpa cyna, B nopSlllKe. onpeneJlHeMOM
3aKOHOmrrenbCTeOM Pecny5nl1KI1 KaJa'\CTdH
11 Ka611HeTOM MI1HHCTpOB Pecny6J1I1KIJ Ka-
3aXCTaH (n SeT 20)
Hc l1pCJIye).tOTptHO
OnepaTBHaSI neSITeJ1bHOCTb 4'>I1HaHCHPyercSi
J.a cyer 6naroTBopl1TeJ1bHblX 4>oHn08 B COOT-
BTCTB(UJ co CMeTaMI1 rocy1l3pcTBeHHbix I1H-
CTl1ryUI1H (CT 13)
 nopllJlOK paCKOllOBaHK!I cpenCTB, BbIlIeJleHHbI),.
KaOPlI
169
flpoiJrmJlcel/ue ma6J/. 17
fDellepilJlhHblH
JaKOH
..06onepaTIfB-
HO-pO.lbICKHOH
.l{eSlTJ1bHOCT"
3axOH
Pcny6J1I1KJJ
KaJ.(lXCT3H
..06onep3Ti1B-
HO-pOJbICKHOH
.l{eJ.lTJ1bHOCT"
3allOH Pecny6-
Jll'IKI1 K.uaxCTaH
..06onepanm-
HO-p03bICKHOfi
.l{CSlTCJlbHOCTIf'"
3aKOH
Kblprbl3CKoti
Pecny6J1I1KI1
«06onepaTlm-
HO-pOJbICIlHOfi
lleSlTJlbHOCTIf'"
3aKoH
naTBI1i1cKoi1
Pcny6J1I1KJJ
...o60nepaTBHOn
lleflTCJlbHOCT'"

flpotJo lJK'£lIue maM. 17
I 1 3
$m-JaHcoBble cpeLICTBa, BbllleJIJleMble Ha $ellepaJIbHblH
opn, paCXOLIYKHCSI B nopSiLIKe, YCTaHOBl1eH-
HOM pyKOBOllIfTt'JUIMI'I 3TMX opraHOB ..06onepaTB-
('1.1 CT. 19) HO-P03bICIlHOH
neSlTe;'JbHOCT"
OpratillMl'I, ynOJlHOMO'leHHblMI1 Ha OC}lllleCT- 3allOH Pecny6-
BJleHl'le opn, BbUleJleHHble Ha 3T11 ueJlI1 4>11- .J1I1KH 6elI!1pycb
tmHCORbie cpeliCToa P!JC1(OIlytOTCJI B nopJlllKe, ..06 onepanlB-
onpeile.nJleMOM MB1I, Pecny6.rUlKH 6eJlitpycb, HO-p03bICKHOfi
KotHTero\l rocynapCTBeHHOH 6e30naCH()CTM IleSlTeJlbHOCT"
Pecny6.rUlKI1 6e.i1pycb 11 f.J1i1BHbIM ynpaB..e-
Hl'leM norpaHwlHblX BOHCK npl1 COBeTe MI1-
HI'ICTDOB PeCnv6J111111'1 6eJlaDVCb OJ 1 CT. 18) ja
focyn,apCTBeHHblM opraHaM, OnepaTI'IBHble
nOilpa:welIeHI1J1 KOTOPblX ynO.HOMO'leHbl Kblprbl:JCKoR
OCYllleCTB.J1J1Tb OP)]" BbllleJlJlJOTCSI 113 6JOillKe- Pecny6J1I1KiJ
Ta 4>I1HaHCOBble CpellCTBa, KUTOpue pacxo- ..06 onepanlB-
1lYIOTCii B nopHllKe, yCTaH!1B11iJBaeMOM pyKO- HO-p03bICKHOfi
oo.;urreJ1J1MI1 3TI1X 0 nmoB ('I leT 22) neSlTeJlbHOCT"
nOpMOK I1Cno.%30BaHl1e 4>I1HaHCOBbIX Cpe,i:lCTB 3aKOH
YCTaHaB.J1I1BaeT PYKOBOlll1TeJlb Y'lpe)l(J!eHI1J1 naTBMHcKOR
onepaTBHoii LIeSlTeJ1bHOCTI1 (CT. 33) Pecny6J1I1KH
..06 onep:.mmHoH
AellTC/lbHOCTH»
nOpSillOK paCXOll()B no onepaTHBH()A 0" 3aKoH
Te)lbHOCT YCTaHaB.J1I1BaerCJI cy6"beIlTaMI'I JlI1TORCIIOii
Onep<IT!1BHOif neSlTeJlbHOCTI1 (CT. 33) Pecny6J1I1K!1 ..06
OnepaT!1BHOH
----;s-(oJ1"'3apacxOJl(l8llHlfel\lCpeaCllj,Btol1!e. LIeSiTelIhHOCT"
- ::.: acx01l0BaHl1eM 4>Hl-JaHCODblX $ellepaJIbHblH
CpellCTB, Bb!1leJleHHblX LIJlJI OP)]" ocymecTB- :'IaKOH
J1J1eTCJI PYKOBOLII1TeJlJlMI1 rOC}lnapCTBeHHblX ..06onepaT!1B-
opraHOB, B coe-raB 1I0TOpblX BXOJJ.JlT onepa- HO-P03bICIlHOH
TI1BHble nOllpa:'llleJleHI'IJI opraHOB, OCYllleCTB- neSlTeJlbHOCT"
.J1J1lQml1X OP)]" a Tal()!(e CneWtaJlbHO ynOJl-
HOMOljeHHblMI1 Ha TO npenCTaOlirenJlMI'I MI'I-
HI'ICTepCToa 4>liHBHCOB POCCI1HCKOH $ellepa-
U11 'I. lCT. 19) -
170

I 2
KOI-HpOJlb J.a paCX01l0BaHI1eM 4>HHaHC()BbIX
CpellCTB, Bbl!leJleHHbIX Ha OPD" ocyweCTBJlS!-
eTCSl PYKOBQDIfTeJIJIMI1 3TMX opraHOB ("I. 2
CT. 18)
KOHTjJOJIb 3a pacXOllOBaHl1eM 4>HI-JaHCOBbIX
cpellCTB, Bb\1leJleHHhlX tW. OPD" 0CYllleCTBJU]-
eTCH pyKOB01lIiTeJlSlM('j TOcyJJ,3pCTBeHHbIX op-
r8HOB, B COCTaB KOTOpbJX BXQIJ,S1T Onepan18-
Hble nOJJ.Pa:t1\eJ1eHItSi opraHOB, ocymeCTB-
JlJllOlIUIXOP,lJ, ('I. 2CT 22)
nOp!lj{OK BH}lTPeHHero KOHTpOJUI YCTBHiiBJIH-
(IT PYIIOllQlUlTeJlb Y4pC)!(,jjeHmr onepanlB-
Hoi111eHTJlbHOCm (CT 33)
KOtllpOJ1b 3D paCXOllOBBHHCM 4>HH(lHCOBbIX
CpellCTB, BbllleJletfHblX HB OPn., ocyweCTBJ1Ji-
eTCSI pYKODQIUITeJUIMH yno;lHoMO"leHHblX MH-
HI1CTepCTB. a TIlJU;;C CneUl'laJlbHbIX npellCTaBI'I-
. Te11CH MI1HI1CTepcTlJa QJI1HaHcoB(..- 2 CT. 17)
 MaTeJllla.1bHO-(l6ecneqeHHeOPJ],
MaTepIHL'IbHO-TCXHH'reCKOe o5ecne'ICHHe OP))
ocyrnCCTBJUlCTCSI HJ CpCLlCTB pecnyOJlHIWH-
CKoro 11 MecTHoro 6JOll;KeTOB B coomeTCTIJHH
C nOJlo;+:eHl1eM 0 rocynapCTBeHHOM oi'iOPOH-
HOM J.aKaJe. yrBep;KJJaeMOM Ka6HHeToM
MHHHCTpoB Pecny6J1I1KH KaJB\.CTaH. 3a Cl,leT
IU'MITb!X H KOHI}I('JcKoBaHHblx no pellleHl'IJO
cyna aBTOTjJBHcnopm. pall1'103.11eKTpoHHblX
Cpe1lCTB, aYllHO-. B(\)\C01Mi:HI1KH. 3.eKTpOH-
HO-BbI'nlCJ1I1Te.bHblX YCTPOHCTB, oprreXHI1KH
I1JJPYfomI1MymccTBa(p.5CT_21)
He npeJlyc},tOTpCHO
171
OIi:VH'fUl/ue mu6J/. 17
3
3aKoH Pecny6
J1I1KI1 6enapycb
«060nepaTHB-
HO-pO.lbICKHOti
.l{eSlTe}]hHOCT"
3aKOH
Kblprbl3CKofi
Pecny61I11KH
,,060nepanm-
HO-P03bICIlHOfi
.l{eSlTe.,"IhIlOCTI1»
3aKOH
lTaTBI1Hcllofi
Pecny6J111111'1
..06 onepaTBHO"
.l{CSlTCnbHOCTH»
3alloH Pecny6-
J1I1KH MOlIlloBa
,,060nepanIB-
HO-p03bICKHOti
.l{eSlTe}]bHOCT..
3aKOH
PecnyfuJl1KI1
Ka3aXCTaH
«060nepanm-
HO-p03bICKHOfl
.l{eSlTe}]bHOCT..
3aKOH
Kblprbl3CKofi
Pecny6J1I1KH
,,060nepaTHB-
HO-P03bICIlHOfi
.l{eSlTe;'IbHOCTI1»

nOJlmKeHIIH, KolC.tI01JUI('CJ[ IJ»m,aucoIIoro ooecne'lellHH OP,lJ" lIJIeJ\Y-
CfII8'I1IHB8IOTCJlell,YlOJ.1JJK'CTaTbH3aKOHOB_
CTaTbSl 19 <DepanbHoro 3allQHa ,,06 onepaTI1BHo-pOJblCKHOH lleSl-
Te.llbH()CTI1".
CTaTbSl 18 3allQHa Pcny6J1I1KIJ ECJ1apycb ,,06 onepaTl'lBHO-
p03blCKHOti l!CHTJlbHOCTI1».
CTaTbl1 20, 21 3aKoHa PcnyOJlI1KI1 Ka3aXCTaH ,,06 onepaTHBHO-
P03bICKHOtil!CJlTeJlbHOCTI1».
CTaTbSl 22 3aKoHa KblprblJCKOfi PecnyGJII1KI1 ,,06 onepan:!BHO-
p03b1CIIHOH !leJiTenbHOCTI1"
CTaTbH 33 3aKoHH JlaTBHtiu::ofi PecnyOJlI1KI1 ,,06 onepaTI1BHOfi neA-
Te.llbH()CTI1"
CTBTbH 13 3aKoHa 11I1TOeCKO" PecnyGJII1K('] ..06 onepan:!BHOH neA-
Te.llbH()CT(']".
CTaTbSl 17 3aKOHa Pcny6J1I1KI1 MOJlAOBa ,,06 onepaTI1BHO-pO-
JblCKHoj:jlleSlTeJ]bHoCT".

3aKIlIO....eHlt1e
npoeen,eHHblR HalotH Cp"BHHTenbHblR aHaJ1H3 onepaTHBHO-pa3b!CIIHOrO 3aKOHO-
.o.rrrenLCTBa6hU1 Hal1eJ1eH .mY"CHeHI1"OCHOBHoRcyrHpJ3J1H"H;; Me:.lU!jld!<:JIepaJ1L-
HbIM 3aKOHO'I .06 onpaT!<IIHO_poobICI<:Hol! JI"T'JlbHOCTJ< .. aH8.f10rHHbIM" 3a1W_
HaMH B CTPaHX CHr H 6aJ1THH. D.pymR JanacR HCc.CIIOB"HH>1 >1BJ1>1nocbycT"HOB-
l1eHH H,,,,60Jle" nonHoro 11 OTB"'lalOl11ero cOBpeMeHHbI'" Tp.60""HHM ]8110H8 .06
onq>a11IIIHO_pOJbICKHOI! lIne:lbHOCTII K HaweMY HHIO. CpeD.H H3Y"HHbIX
HopMaTHBHblx.nOIlYMCHToBHcyna.nocbOnpCD.C:lHTb'JaJ«>HOlI.m:.%Hbll!allT,lIoToPblI!
6b! COOTIIL"ICTEOII.IJ1 Tpe60BJHHnM cop'MeHHOCH!. B OCHOB" C"X JU;IJHO J1e>KHT
Q>e.nepa.nbHbll! 3a"OH 1995 r OQ Ol1epaT!<lIHO-poJbICIlHOh .IltT'JlbHOCT,,"
PC3YJlbTaTbl 8H8.f1ma n03BOnIOT rOBopHTb 0 Hc06XOIIH\fOCTII JIAIIbHCRwcro co-
BepweHCTBO"HI1 3JIIOHO.ll8R!lLHOH 6mb!. Be.!!eHI1  np"KTHKY cOBpoMeHHblx,
H8)"IHOo6ocHoBaHHblxOpraHmaI]l10HHblx$OpM H "'TO.l\OBOnepaTHHO-pa]ICIIHol\
JlOT'JlbHOCTII.06.cne>lIlBaIOWl1X34$cKTHBHYI060pl>6ycllp"CTynHoCTblOnpHCTpO-
>K";;WeMco6J!IO.1\OHI111JI1«JHHOCTJ<.
C'IHT""M lIencoo6p83HIM )"leCTb c.,e.1l.j'IOWHe HaWH npJlJ1o","HH
I llono.1HHTbcT ) IJ)] 060Pll H COOTIICTCTBYlOwlie 3aKOHbI npllHI1HnOM Ha-
CTYnTenHOCTl< (onepaTHBHocTH).ne;;cTBHR Cy6UKTOB OPllll6oph6e C npeCTynHo-
CTLIOHo6ecne'leHHH6eJon8CHOCH!!lH'IHOCTH,06weCTBJI1rocYl1"pCTBa.o60eHO8-
HHC IIOToporo H3,o",eI!O "IHorolq>aTHO  Cl1elllla.rJbHOlll1HTeP"TYP'
2. He060cHoBHHo npHMeHeH HCepl1b1B"1011IHR nepeel!b Ol1ep"THBHO-
pJ3b1CKHblX MeponplInHfi. IIOTOpl;; MO.t.eT 6b!Tb H3MeHeH TonbKO 3"KOHOM. 'lT0
TOp'l03HTpa3BHTHeTllOp'lIoronI¥mVl8KOpraHI1"'"HHI1TaKTHII"HXn""MeHHHII
B 3THX ycnoBX HeT HHK"KIIX $oPM8.f1bHblX H $3I1TH'IeCIIHX OCHOBaIiHI! 1U1 orpaHH-
'IeHH OPM He KJ1IOeHbI  nep.""HL OI'M TIlKHe "IpJIIHL1HOHHO npH"'eHneMbie
08):\ "'ponpHSlTH, 11311 npecne.llOBaHHe Cl<jJhlWHXC C MCTa npm,cwCTBHn nOJ(03-
p.""e"lbIX no ropHM c.1ellaM. OpraHH3aIlIl 3"Ca1 no I1X 3aIlCp)KHHIO> npOBeD.CHHe
Ol1ep.1THBHblX Ko.,6HH3QHi1 "T"IITH'IeCK"X onep.,""i1 no "J'bHTHIO "I"repHaJ1bHblX
CJ1o:l10B np.CTYnHO .IltTe:JLHOCTH. <:.1I.HHOBpMeHHO'lY 3",""P,*,JHHIO yacTHHKoB nl"'-
crynHblx$op'lHPOBaIiHI!.1I00PY>KCHHbIX npeCTYnHHII0.OCB060:K!ICHHI03a!10:+;H"IIOB
II T.n. YCT""o...,eHHe KOJ1H'IeCTBeHHOrO OrpaHI1'.eHHn OPM He 6YeT CTIIMynl1pOaTb
cBoepeMeHHoro BOCTp.60""HI1 HOBb1X H8)"IHblX l\OCTI.....,HHH ., Riot 60!le. TIiKI1
HTp!UIYI1]l10HHblX MeTQ.IIOl\, KaK IICno.1L]0""HH nO!lHrpa4>a. ..e_'OBeKO-MaWl1HHIX
CHCTe.,. ry"l"HHO;;a"KTHnOCIIOnl1" I1.npyrotx.
:I rl1aBY II d!] 06 OPll pJCWHpHTb 11 I13110)KHTb "cn pe.wiKIlUH. aOpra-
HH3aI]HOHHbI" q,OP'lbi. Me"KU!U. cpeCTII3 11 "'epOnpHTIt onepaTHBHo-po]ICIIHOII
JleTCJ1HOCTl1. COOTBen7BeHHO IIa:K!lO'lY H3 3THX COCT"BJIIOWHX JlOJ1)KHII 6ITb no-
CIDIllleH" OT/lenbHaJI CT"T"" J.lI10H3. <l>op.'ynHpoKY 1I0TopblX MO,*,HO Ja""ICTOoaTb "
cn1]IUIJ1bI-fffii J1HT.paTYJI" (06 OpraHmal]"OHHIX  pa6OTh! C"ToB OPll.
OnCp"TlIBHoco6cJ1yJKHBaHHe.llOK)'III'HT11j)OBaHHC.BJaHMOJlcltI.'IBIC:.oneparnBHo-pa3h!CK-
HO. o6eeneeHHeyrOJ1OBHorocynonpOHJI!Q:II:rua 11 lIP.).
4. P"CWHpH npaa OnepJTHHblK nOllPJ3l1!leHHIi  aCTH npHMeHeHI1 HaH60-
l1e" CJ10)KHIK areHTYpHo-onepaTHBHbTX "IP. 3aKOHQ)jaTe;"lL OCTaHOBHJlC !-Ia nOJlnyrli
poweHH 'ITO;; np06ne'bI H He 06ecneI1n H"'"'''''Hbl''lH np"I\OBb1"111 rnp"HT"'"
173

WTaTHbiX OnCpaTHBHblX p,,6OTHHIlOB. H B 'IacTHOCTJI BHCIlPetb'X B I\PHMHHMbHYIO
CI"'IIYJ],./JR HX P3]1,,60ThH. npI1<J1l'IeCM'M peWeHI1eM yt:'1J1HeHHOI TaKOra npo6e""
Morna 6bl C.'YJKltTb CnellHaJlbHa Hop"a npaBO i!IlEpTfIlHorO pa60THHila Ha npo-
q,CCCOHaJlbHbJA PHCK' CTPY""TYI'd I'! COllCpJKaHHC npCllJlal1lCMOA HOptbl !.tornI'! 6b1
BblrnJUJ,eTbCnellYlOl1IM{)6p.uOM
He npH]HalOTC npecrynHblMH a,eIkml,OI Cyfu.eI<TOB ()nep3THHo-po]bICKI-!IJII.IIe-
TeitbHOCTI1. q,OPMaJtbHO HapYWHBWHC npaBaIt 3aIlOHHbJC HHTt:PCCblq,]H'ICCIIX.IOPH-
.II'IeCKHX Jutll, HO COBCpllJeHHble B 3KcrpcMMbHbiX CH1)'BII">lX B COCTOBHHH He06xo-
.IIHMoli06opoHbI.llpaIiHet1 Ilell6uvutMOCTH HitH IIycnoBHlIXnpoot>eCCHoHaJlLHoropHC-
KaPl<CKnonpal\!laHHbI..._ec,,'HCOllepWeHHQeJle,,"Hco6J,eI<THB1-10IlbITeKBJlO
ltJI<jJHMHH'\JtLHO;; HHllI(JI""'"HH Oq,II:TdX 11 C<J6bITHBX, IIOTOpbl"'H p3cnOJJa"'eT{) nep.l-
THHbliip36<rrHI1l1npBBOO'pBHltTe..'LHLIXopraHOB,ablnOJ1HeHI1eOiBIIOHHo;;q,YHlIlIHlt
>Ie "'omo 6b1TbJlQCTHrJ-fyro He cB3aJ-f>lbl"'H c npoo!>eCClloHa.'bHbl... pHCKO'I M<"fOlla"",
H cpellCT"'U"".
npHHRTlteTaKOii HopMblRHn>CL6b1 coepeMeHHO;; peallllHeii 3BlloHOJ\aTenOI
>18 peMbHQe npoTI<nOJ\eljcTnllc IIPIIMH>l8!lbHOil cpeJ\bI npanoo'paHHTeJ1b>lblM opra-
H"M BcospeMeHHbJXYCitOBH>!X 3TI\Cpen" npH6eraCT Kpa;<JJH'I>lblM YXHJJJ.PCHHI1M-
OTCOKpLITHBHYI<H..TOJKeHHOI.IIOKYMeHTOBHH306nl1'1alOIlIHXHXMrrrCpHaJlLHblX
npC,llM010B JJ,O q,ot'I<"CCIIOI1 pBcnpabI C nOTeHI]lt3l1LHblMH CHJlCTenOIMH. a TaIlJKC
;;:;:M n:xH:=;:.HR nOJ\KynoB H HIIC).!JIotn II CaMHM onepaTI<BHbI!.t pa6<rrHHKaM H
S Hco60rnollBHHoorpaHH"eHHb! noowpHTeJ1bHb!C MepblJ],./J HerlaCHoroanna-
paTa. nl'OnllHBwcro npo<\JeCCHOHMbHYIO 8I<THlIHOCTb B 60pl>6e C npecTynHoCTbIO
06bJ'IH03TOn0J10JKeHHeorp"HH'IH""eTcn BblJ"l'1eii .!IeHe><HbIX npeMHii.lleHHblxno-
l!;IJJKOII. nOblweHHeM nOCToHHOro a,eHCOUiOTO CQI\epJK"Hlt np"KTHKB nOJ\TBCp-
>K.IlaeT.'ITOeCTbllceOCHonaHHn BK.'IO'IHTb ,,3"IIOH 1l0nOJ1HHTei1bHble MepbJ noowpe-
H"n. npe1lCT"JB.eHHn 0 J10epo..HO," OCS060>QeHHM HitH CMBr..eHHI1 H"II"""HHB. 0
nOMltnOBBHHH, nepco H" Yi1}"1weHHble YCJ10HR COIqJJ!<OIHI1>1  YJ.1H. eC"H arcHT
OCy>K.I!CH C'H CCOBopWeHoteM npe<:T}'IlI1CHHOI YCJ10BHSlX paJ06i1a'leHltA npecryn-
HOro co06wecT"" HitH OprHH30B"HHo>i npecTynHol1 rpynnbl. npOO!BltJl HacTol1'1H-
BQCTbHpHCKblnOi1HeHHI1J3.11,BHHiinpaBOoxpaHltTCi1bHblXOpraHoB,"4><peKTHB-
HOCTbHcrlaCHOrOCOTI')'JII-!H'IeCT,,""'CCTIlX"HWeHlt"CBofi<mo,J 3aoc06b1e'Bcnym
HcrnaCHblXCOTPYJlHHIIOBCJlCllOB(IJ106b1npcllCTaB.,nTbllrocynapCTBCHHbIMHarparJaM
B HOBb1X YCOBMRX npH nOllCe.nHeBHo>i nenUbHOcTH ype6)ercJ! nepecTpo>i1lB
pa6OTbIKa><lloron0.1l.PB]JJ,Ci1CHIIAHCOTpYllHI1l1a3'ronpeJKaCBCOrOCIIHOiBHOCYIICI111-
'IcHotCM lJ'I.6oBaTcbHOCT II npop..CCHOHB.""MY C01)JYllHHKOB_ OcywCCTlI"nSlTeCHOC
15JaHMQlleiicTHHe C ,npyrMMH J'IQI:q).mIeleHHHMH OB.D. -rOC'o.ll,pcTIICHHblMH 11 06weCT-
BCHHblMH cTI')'Kl)'paMI1. onepaTHHble annapaTbi npaBOoxpaHltTCi1LHblXOprBHO npH
HIUU1e>KaWeM np""OIlOM n0)10"OHHH H opraHHJ:!I]ltHCMOTyrOCyulffTBI<TbHI!J!C><HYIO
JaIllHTYIG';+;,aoro..eJ10HelG,OTnpecrynHblxnoCHraTUbCTB

Cnlt1COK .nIt1TepaTYpbl
HopMarHBHbleaKTbI
I KuHcnnyu POCCHilcllOil 4Jc.nLp.1UHK. pHHSlTa BCeHapOllHI>IM rOJJOCOB<,HHCM
11 e",,6p 199]
II. 3"KOH YI<jJUHI-!bI..o6 onep"THIIHO-pOJLICKHo>i .3.UTe:JbHOCTH N>213S-XII OT
12. :II::K,,,::r,H"l5"'eTn994H; 1:SXwr:O';e-
175

Or.naBI1eHlt1e
BBe)J,eHlo1e
Ta6nHa1 CYI..I.\HOCTbOnepaTI'IBHO-p83bICI(HOlJ.eATenbHOCTI'I,
3a$I1I1Cl'lpOBilHHaSi B 3allOHO)\arenbHbiX aKTaX CTpilH CHr 11 5i1nTIII,
nOCBAL.LjE1HHbIXperJIaMeHTaLl1II3Toii4JYHKLI1'I
)'I'OJ'1OBHOiiIOCT
Ta6nlo1L1i12 YCJlOBI'ISI npOBep,eHI11'10nepiITI'IBHO-
:;y;.&eaof;H aKTaMl1,
Ta6nLIiI3npilBOBaSiOCHOBiI
0C)I1!I0CTBI1AE B CTpaHaX CHr 1'1 SanTHI'I
Ta6nlo1a4 3aOeonpelJ,e.neHl1e3aAa4
onepaTBHO-p<I3bI(;I(Hoii.AeSlTeJlbHOCTI1
B onepaTIIIBHo-pa3blCKHblX 3allOHax CTpaH CHr 11 5al1TI'II1
Ta6nLIiI5 Onpe.i:\eJ1BK'lBeCTpaHaXCHrI15anTl'l
06S13i1HHOCTeii ()praHOB, 0CYIl\BCTBnSlIOLl\X OPA
Ta6Io1e=;;:H:'tP1'I6TI111
Ta6nlo1L1i17 C0L1anbHilSll1npilBOBa"3i1Ll\TilAOJlnLI
opraHOB,OCYl4eCTBnAIOI411xonepaTIo1BHo-pa3bICKHYIO
;:l'IcWHci;ao1-a;::T11 allTaMIII
Ta6nHa8 COJJ,eiicTBHerpa>K,!\8HOnepaTBHo-pa3blcKHO
,/J,eATBnbHOCT npet1YCMOTpeHHoe 38KOH()J\ilTe.nbHbIMIII
allTaM, perJlaMeHTl1pylOl4MIII OPA B crpaHax CHr 1'1 EianT1'I
Ta6nHLla9 C0L1anbHO-npaBOBaA3al411TarpaH,
oprSHaM. 0CYl4eCTBnAIOLl\M OPA, corn8CK038KOHaM,
perynl'lpylOl4M OPA B CTpaHax CHr 11 Eiaml1lo1
Ta6J130:'I1:T:r:"pbIX
BCTpaHaxCHrIllEiaJlT1II
Ta6J130J\=I'I:T:y
BCTpaHaxCHrIllEiaJlT1II
Ta6nl1L18 12 OnpeJJ,eneHHe 3aKOHOlJ,ilTeJleM B CTpSHax CHr
I1EiilnTBilpl1aHToBHcnonb30BilHI'ISlpe3ynbTaroBOPA
Ta6JlI'ILlil13 OpraHbl, CIC)II4BCTBIlROl4He Oneparl'lBHo-pa3bICI\H)IIO
IJ,eATenbHocTbeCTpaHaXCHrl15aJm.111
Ta6JlI1L1i114 npaBa oprilHOB. ()CYLl\eCTBnSlIOLl\X ()nepaTBHO-pa3bIcKHYIO
AeATenbHocTb,nble3aKOHO.AaTeJlbHbIMIo1
aIlT8M. perJlaMeHTPYIOI..I.\e OPA B CTP8H8X CHr 11 5811T11
Ta6I1e1T:=,:;crH5nao:T:A
Ta6nl1L18 16 KOHTpQ,l1b 11 H8J:\30p3a onepaTI'IBHo-pa3bICJ(HCIM
,/J,eATenbHOCTblO, npe.i:\ycM01peHHble 3i1KOHOJIiITenbHbIMI'I
aIlTaM. pernaMeHTPYIOI..I.\MIII OPA e CTpaHax CHr 11 5al1TI'II1
Ta6JlI1L1i117 4JI'IHaHcoBoB06ecne4BHl1eonep8TBHQ-pa3bI(J(HCI
AeATenbHOCTI1 B CTpaHax CHr 11 5anT11
3aKll104eHl'le
Cnl1coKnlo1Teparypbl
31
37
54
79
89
101
114
124
131
158
164
168
173
175

11.11. TY30B, A./J,. WeMWeeB
3aKOHOl\aTenbHbie aKTbl,
pernaMeHT"PYIO..e
OnepaT"BHO-pa3bICKHYIO l\eSlTenbHOCTb
B POCC..iiCKOii <l>el\epa....,
CTpaHaX CHr .. 6anT....
nO)J,pe,qallL1l1ei1
3aCnYJKeHHOrO IOpl1CTa POCCIIII1,
I\OKTopa IOpl1J\l>t'4eCKIIIX Hayll, npol1:>eccopa M_A_ KnHMOBB
"oYoAH"'eCKHMljeHTpoM
,,y...e(jHI1K"Bf{a...eCTBeY4e(jHoronoCO(jI1S1
JIIIRCTyAeHTOBBblCWl1xy...e(jHbIX, O(jY'fBlOll,IHXCR
no03050' "lOpHcnpYAefH..jI1R",
nO"BY4HOti'200'2"K
C}'H8R:onepHSR"
"OHa1BIJbCnfMI1HCm1YTOM
f1J'1HaYKI1BKa<;eCTBeY4eOHoronoco0I1S1
JlllSiCTyAeHTOBBbJCWl1xy...e(jHbIX.O(jY'falOll,IHXCR
no03050' "1OpMcnpy,Qefiljml",
nO"aY4Hoti'2.00.'2"K
C}'THaR;HaRfJ,BHTEJnbHOC1b"

W
IOHIITI1
iJii"i"'i'V
3aKOH 11 npaBO. MOCKBa.2012

YJIK34J.1J2(47+S7)(075.8)
1i6K(j7.41O.111-J2(2)7J
T"
PCUCJlJCJlTbi.
JacJty><eHHblii.nenCl1LHaYKHP4>.
.nOIlTOPIOpWll1"CCIIHXHaYII,npoljleaopTK.C_tolJ
.nOIlToplOpI-l1J,H'IeCIlItXltaYK,npO$eccopAM.-4fi:1a_
r"8Hbli'!pe!ll\KTOplt-U1nebCTllaH.J1.IlI.
I<aH.III........JOpJUlH'IeCllltKHayK,.!IOIITOp3KOHO..WICCIIHXHayll.np<>qJeccq>,
n"ype"TnpeMHHnpUIIHTel1bCTB"P4>Boli."cnlHaYKHHnXHHIIH
Ty30B,J]eBJ]bBOBH'i.
T81 3aKOHo.mrreJ1bHb!e HKTbI. pernHMeHTI1pYlO1l1l1e onepaTHBHO-
pa3blCKHYlO neHTeJ1bHOCTb B POCCfiCKOfi <])ellepaUHI1, ClpaHax
CHr  EaJlTHI1 Y'le6. noco611e lUISI CryJreHTOB BY30B. o6y'lalO-
lllHXCSI no Cnelll1aJ1bHOCTI1 dOpl1cnpyneHUHH» / n.n. TY30B.
A.D.. WefiweeB; non pen. H.A K.rrMoBa. - M.: IOHHTH-
DAHA: 3aKoH H npaBO, 2012. - 175 c.
I. lIIeiiweeB, A3aM3T lIJKYllla6eKOBH'i.
ISBN 978-5-238-02361-8
AreHTCTBO CIP prE
npuB'flCH cpaBHHTC11bHblR alia1HJ Jal:Otfo.lDinCQbHbiX aIlTOB. pcrJlatCHTH-
PYIOl11HXOnCp<1TJ1HO-pa3blcIIHylOJJ,eHTenbHOCTbPOCcHiiCKo,,4Je!J,ep<1I1J1H.
Pecny6.uille KaJaH. KblprblJCKOR »cuIYW1Hlle 11 npyrHx  CHrH
&urn'H.
lLu CryJJ,eHTOH (KYpc8HTOII" cJtywaTe;lcl1). BcnHpaHTOIl (3JI'bIOHKTOII)_
npeno.!laaTCJeii blCWl1X IOpIUU"'IIHX OOI"""'BI<I1'QLHblX 11 H"y'I>lO-
l1C1.lCOOllaTC1IbCIIHxy4pe:lK.lleHIiR_IITlllOKenpaKTH'IeI:I(Ii'(paoo-rHHlloBnpaBO-
OXP"HHTCl1LHblXopmHOB
IiEK(j1AIO.111-J2(1)H13
ISBN 918-5-238-02368-1
tJ:J t13l1ATEJ1bCTBO IOHHTt1-lIAHA. 2012
npHHIl!I.'C)I(H1 HCK..11O'I<tTe.'bHDe npaBO HII ItCnO)lb30II">lH H pacnpocTpaHCHHe
WmaHHSI (4)JM 'il4-4>JoT21 "1011H 2005 r) BOCnI"'HJBe.!!eHI1CBCCHKHHrJ1HJlI1
11I060ii ee "aCTH JlI06b1MH cpeCTD"MH """ B 0.111<011-)11160 4>opMe.  10M ,,"c.le B
"HTepHCT-cent.JanpewacTcR6eJnHCbr.JCHHorOp"JpeweH"BHJilIITe11bCTea
@Ooj>opMl1eHI1c.IOHt1TI-:!-llAHA..l0Il

BBeAeHlt1e
COBpeMeHH3S1 OU:'1eCTBeHHBSI Teopl1S1 onepaTHBHO-pa3bICIIHOH .neSl-
TeJlbH()CTI1 (Of)],) CTaJla $OpMItpOBflTbCSI C I-Ja'laJI3 1960-x fO.nOB, n()CJle
npl1HSlTI1S1 yronoHHo-npoueccYaJlbHblX KOlleKCOB COlO3Hb1X pecny6J1I1K,
flIe BnepBble H3 J3KOHo.n3TeJlbHOM ypOime nOSlBI1J1CSI Tep'-tI1H «o!1epa-
TI'IBHO-pfl3blclIHbre Mepbl", ()cYUlecTBJleHl1e KOTOpblX fibUlO B03JIO)KeHO
HtlOpraHblllOJH3HI1S1 I .
B 1992 f. 6b!n npl1HSlT 3alloH P<D «06 OnepflTI1BHO-p03bICKHOfi
.neSlTeJlbHOCTrI B POCC('JHCIIOH €DeJ\epaLl('J('J. B 3aTeM. B 1995 r.. 4JeJ\e-
panbHblH 3"KOH ..06 onepflTMBHO-p03bICKHOH .nCSlTeJlbHOCTW>. C npl1-
HI/THe'-t 4JeJ\epaJIbHOrO JBKOHa .naHHblH BI1J\ .neSlTeJ1bHOCTM npBBooxpa-
H('JTeJlbHbIX opraHoB nOJl:y'1l1n o(jJl1L1l1aJlbHbIH craTyc focy.napCTBeHHO-
npBBoBoH $OpMbI 60pb6br C npccrynHocTblO )],BHO onpelieneHI1C OPll
C pacKpbITlJeM ee COi\ep>KBHI11/, onpelleJleHl1eM OCHOBHblX 3ai\B'1 11
npl1HLll'lnoB. C$OPMYJ1l1pOB3Hbl ()CHOBHble nOJlO)KeH('JSI. YCTflHaBJlI'I-
BalOll!l1e npaBQMepHOCTb, YCJIOBI1S1 11 nopJlllOK npOBeHI1S1 onepanm-
Ho-pa3blcKHblX Mep()npl'lllTHH. I1Cn()Jlb30B3Hl1e I'IX pe3y.lbTaTOB B p3C-
IIpblTHI'I npccrynJ1CHHfi 3allpenJ1CHbl npfiBa 11 061/3f1HHOCTM J1l1ll. CBSI-
JaHHblX C Ofll. a TalOKe perJl3MeHTHpoBaHbi Bonpocbl I1X COlll1aJ1bHOi1
H npaBOBO" Jflll!I'ITbl.
Heo6xo.!!l1MO Y4el:Tb, '1TO npOBel!eHl1e DTlleJlbHb!X OnepaTIJBHO-
pa3blcKHbiX MeponpHSlTl'lfi 3f1TpflfHBa1OT KOH(J1fl)'llHoHHble npaBa rpa)K-
113H. npm.leHeHHe TBKI1X BIfiIOR Meponpl1J1TI1H SlIIJ1J1eTCSI OCODOH cneul1-
$I1KOH B npoLlecce .nellTenbHOCTM onepaTHBHblX nonpameneHHfi. C :noH
LleJ1blO 3aKOH onpelleJ111eT npBBoRbre OCHOBaliHII npOBelleliHII TaKHX Me-
pOnpmlTl1H I1CKJlI04HTeJ1bHO B LleJlSlX 38ll!I1Tbl >K113HI1. :WOpOBbSi. C06CT-
BeHHOCTH. fiOpbDbl C npecrynHocTblO H TonbKO B UTHOll!eHHH J1HLI
(rpynnbl 111111). ODOCHOB3HHO n01lO3peBaeMbix B cOBepWeH1111 TSI>KKIJX 11
()CODO TSI>KKI'IX npecrynJleHI1H.
npOBeJ\eHHblH HBMI1 CpaBHI1TeJlbHblH aHaJ1('JJ 113J10)l(eH B BI1J],e paJ-
J111'1HbIX Ta6J1('JI1, orpaA\d.lOll!I1X OCHOBHble nOJlOJKeHI1" JaKOHOllfITeJlbCT-
DB, pemBMeHHtpylOUlcro onepaTMBHo-pB3brcKHYIO lleJlTeJ1bHOCTb Poc-
CI1I1. cTpaH CHr 11 EaJlTI111. UeIlb npoBe.aeHHoro I1CCJlellOaaHI1S1 - 01-
I rOpJlUHfJ61< 1<., OnuHCJ<uU B.C. CUIIfL_ r.1<. TeopHH onep"THIIHO-pOJblCKHo>i .neH-
J1HOCTIf M HH@PA-M.2012 Bo BC"" 6hlllWHX pecny6.'"I1I\X CCCP. H"'He CTP"-
H"x CHr 11 6a.UHI1, 6hlnot npItH>!T'" COOTBeT\."THYlOwlte 3<01I0HI>I, perJ]"MeItTHpyIOII\He
onepaTHHO-P"3h!CIIHYIO .neHT"J1LHOCTh. 3TH 31\KOHbI rnp:LIGIJJ" H"I]I'IOHaJIH"'e OCO-
6cHHOCT K3)!(!]oR pccny6nHKH, flO C)'Th H Ha3HacHHC oncpaTHBHO-P<13b1CIIHOR CII-
TeIILHOCTH He "3MeHI-LI1C

p3.3rITb CXOJ\CTBa I{ pa3JIli'uUI B n0J10)l(eHI1f1X 3all0110B pa3HblX CTpaH.
BblSlBI1Tb n0311TI'IBHbie 11 HeraTI1BHbie CTOpOHbl, 1<0TOpble HBI160JIee n()J]-
HO OTpB)I(a}QT COBpeMeHHble Tpe60BaHI1f1 B 60pb6e C npeCl)'nHOCTblO.
H3MeHel-1I1e 06meCTBeHHbIX OTHOWeHl'I, HeCOBepWeHCTBO yroJlOB-
Horo I{ yrO,ORHo-npoueccyanbHoro JallOHOll3TeJlbCTBa RO MHoro", npe-
nflTCTBYIOT pellleHl1lO nOCTaBJIeHHblX 3<U\a'l. He06xoJ\I1MO pa3HOCTopOH-
He nepeOueHI{Tb n()JI'IUI1I'1. lleHCTB}'lOllll1e KOHCTInyUl111 11 JaIlOH())1a
TeJIbHble al<Tbl. perm,MeHTl{pylOllll{e OPll npflBOOXpflHHTeJ1bHbIX opra-
H()B POCCl'Il'I, CTpaH CHr 1'1 6annm, JlBJISlJOTCSI nprlBOBOH OCH()BOH lIJIJI
Hal160nee Onnl"'aJIbHOrO npHMeHefil1S1 OnepaTI'IBHo-paJbICKHbIX Mep
Tpe60BaHI1J1 I< Ka'leCTBY ne.II.TeJlbHOCTI'I OnepaTI'IBfiblX nOllPfl3.1lenefil1H
3flBI'ICSIT OT ypoBH.I! pflJBI1TI'ISI TeOpl'l1'l 1'1 npfll<T1<1'I OnepflTI'IBfiO-
PUbJCKHOH neJITeJIbHOCTI1 I{ HaJIl1'1l{}1 :JiPeIlTl1BHOrO npaBOBOfO nOJlS! C
enl'lH()H MeT01l0JI()rl'l'JeCIlOH. Opr8HI1J8UI'I()HH()-T8I<TH'leCI<OH OCH()BOH
I]JyHIIUOHl{pOBaH(JJI.
npeIlnpl1HIITble Illflr B pa3IX16on:e OCHOBHblX nOJ[O)l(eHI1 Teopl1l1
OPll B 06CTaHOBKe OTKpblTOCTI{ C nepe1((U!O\I HB JBKOHOJ\BTenbHoe pery-
Jll'IpOB8HI1e n03BOJlI'IJlI'I npllBJIe'tb I< u6cy)t;nefil'lJO 1'1 onpelleJlefil'lJO ee Mec-
Ta B CI'ICTeMe Ha}"1H()rO 3HaHI'IJI npl1 310M ue'Jec006pa3HO I'ICnOJIbJOB8Tb
npaKTI1'teCK" onblT 1'1 npeeMCTBeHHOCTb npeJKHI1X I'ICCJleJ\OBaH(JH. H3)"1-
HblX pfl3pa60TOK TeOp1'l1'l OPll C Y"eTOM H()BbIX I13MeHeHl'I B o6wecme
B npouecce nViKTIf'teCKOH .r:!eSlTeJ1bHOCTrI B03HI{I<aeT PAJI BonpOCOB. CBSI-
3<1HHbIX C perY.'1l'1pOBflHl1eJ.t 3flKOH0ll3TeJ1bCTB8. perneHl'Ie KOTOpbIX HeB03-
11.10)1(110 6e3 I1CnOJlb30RBH(J.I! HB}"1HblX 3HaHI1H He06}(Q[!1tMOCTb JBIIOHOIDI-
TeJlbHOfO peryJll{pOBaHl{fI OPll 06ecne'tI1BaeT YCJlOBl{fI rom C03JWH(JR
Clll1HOH MOjltJI(J .uOKYMeHT8, KOTOpblH 6Y.r:!eT per.na"leI1Tf1pORBTb npouccc
opraHI{3aUl{I{ 11 T.ucntKrI np0BeJ\eHl{fI onepaTI1BHQ-pa3bJCKHbIX MepO-
npl'lJlTI'IH Ha TBPpl'lTOp1'l11 BJ8I'1MQlleHCTI!}'lOlUI'IX CTp8H (POCCl'Il'I. CTp8H
CHr 1'1 EanTf1I'1) B 6opb6e C npecrynHOCTbJO, a TBKJKC C pB3JI1'I'IHbIMI'I op-
raHI.f30BaHHblMI'I ee 1JI0pMBMI'I - KoppynUl1e. TeppOpl'l3MOM. 3KCTpe-
MI13M()M, He3BIIOHHblM o6opo1O\I HapKOTI'IKOB l'I.up
C Y4eTOM COBpeMeHHblX ImrerpaUI{OHHbIX npoueccoB If rJly6oKI1X
l'13MeHeHl'I B )l{1'I3H1'I 061lleCTBB B03pacTBeT JHa'JI1TeJIbHaSi nOTpe6H()CTb
B J\aJlbHeHrneM npe06pa30BBH(J11 310ll c$epbI J\eSlTeJIbHOCTI{.

Ta6:uuta I
CyumOCTb onepa'IIEIIO-pablCKHOii llellTeJlbHOCTH. 3a$HKCHpoIIBIIILUI B
3aKOHOilaTel1bHblX aKTaX CTpaH CHr 11 l)aJlTIII1. nQCBSlU{eHHbIX pemaMeH-
TIlI1HH:nOHIJI)IIKI1MIYroJ]oeHOHIOCTI1HIt

T361I11l.ta2
YClIOBHJI I1pOIIt'.1IeJIHOnepaTHBHO-pa3bICKHLlX MeponpHATHii.
TeJlbHbIMHaIlTaMH,pefJ]aMeHTHpYIOl.QHMHOPA
B crpaHax CHI" u 6a:nHH
M lJ01C);JlCfflUfi :w1COllCliJa111l!fl/;>H1;NX i!oKYMeH- HOUtIfl{QfI(]HUe :JOKO-
nln m08, npeiJ}'CtlOmpu8alOlI4ue }'c;/oouI/ npo8e- HoiJame,lbHblX OKm08.
i!eHUH onepomUflHo-p03WCKHbiX peao"'eHmufl}
W!OfNIourJmuii op..n OPjJ
---J- 2 3
I HanpallJleHUoCTb OPM Ha onpe.nelJflIULllt
K vf06beKToB
r pa)KJ],aHCTBo. HRUI:!()HanbH()CTb, nWL 4lenepanbHblWJaIlOH
MeCTO >KIfH:lIbCTBB, IfMYlllCCTBeHHoe, «060nepBTIfBHO-
.nO}DKHOCTHoe 11 COUManbHoe nOJIo;+::eHl1e. pOJbICKH()HAeSl-
npHHa1lJlC;>KH()CTb K otiWCCTBCHHblM 06'!>- TeJIbHOCTH"
eJ\I1HeHHJlM, OTHomeHHe K pellHfHH H
nOllI'lTI'I'JeCKHM ytie)!(lJeHI'ISlM ()!HeJIbHbIX
nHLlHe SlBJlSlIOTCSlnpenJlTCTBHeMJlJ1J1
npoBe.neHI'ISI B OTHOWeHI'IH HX aPM Ha
-repprnopHH PoccHi1cIlOH <Depm.!I1If.
eCJ!H HH()e He npe.nYCMOTpeHO <De.nepaJIb-
HblM JaKOHOM (a63. 1 CT 8)
rpaJKll8HCTBO, HaLlI'IOHaJlbHOCTb. nOJ!, 311110H PecnytillHIIH
MeCTO >Kl'neJ!bCTBa. COl!aJlbHOe, IfMVWC- l)eJIapycb
cTBeHHoe 11 ll()J]>KHOCTH()e nOllO)KeHHe. ..060[lej)<lTHBHO-
npIJHaaJIe>KHOCTb K 06111ecTBeHHblM ome- P03blCilHOH llCJI-
.nHeHI1S1M. ()THOWeHHe K pellHrHH H [10- TellbHOCTHt>
lUJTIf'JeCKllle ytie)!(lJeHHJI OT.IIe.bHbIX Rnu
He HBJLlIIOTC.II npenJlTCTBHeM DJUI npOBe.ne-
HHSI B OTH()WeHHH HX aPM Ha TepptlTO-
pl111 Pecny6l1l1KIJ l)CJ1apYCb, eClIlf I1HOe He
OroBO eH()3aKOH()M a63.lcT9
rpa)KJ],aHCTIJO. Hal.llfOHaJIbHOCTb, MeCTO 3aKoH PecnytilllfKI1
>KHTeJIbCTBa. COUHaJIbHoe. nOJI>KH()CTHoe J(roa1[CTil.H
11 11MywecTBeHHoe nOllQ;>KeHIfC, npIfHa,a- «06 onepaTBHO-
ne)KHOCTb K o6wecTBeHHblM ()6bellHHe- pOJblCKHOH AeJl-
HIfJlM, OTHOWCHIfSi K pelllfflflf H nOJlIfTIf- TeilbHOCTH"
lJeCKlfe ytie)!(lJeHlffl rpa)!(lJaH He JIBJHIIOTCJI
npenJlTCTBHeM JlJ1J1 npOBClleHHJI B OTHO-
lUeHl11f HIfX OPM Ha Tepp11Top111f Pec-
nytillHIIH KaJaXCTaH. eCJ1H HHoe He ()fO-
BopetiO JaKOHOM (n. I CT. 12)

rp--GlU\dHCTBO, HaLlIJOHMbHOC1D. ncm, MeCTO
)l(lJreJlbCTBa.llO.COLllJaJ[bHoel'l
I'IMYWecTBeHHoe n0J10JKeHl'le, npl'lHaLIJ1eJK-
HOCTb K 06weCTBeHHbIM OO1,elll'lHeHl'IHM,
OTHoweHI'IJI II pe.r1l'1r1'I 1'1 nO!11f1}1'1eC}a1e
y6eJK11eHItlI He JlB.IIIOT(;1I npemlT\."TBIteM DJHI
npoBelleHl'ISi B OTHOWCHl'Il'I Hi'll( OPM Ha
TI:pplIT(;pIII'I KblptDl3CKOii: Pemyfu1l'lK,
ec.ll'l I'IHoe He ()rOBO H() 3JKOHOM (CT. 9)
Meponpl'lIT}I onepaTIIHOI1 ,/J,CSlTe!1bHO-
CT npOBODJITCSI HeJ.aBI'ICIJM() OT rpaJKD.aH-
CTB3. nona, HaUOHaJlbHOCTH, MeCTa npo-
)l(HBaHI1S1, 1'JO.Jp3CTII. oopa30BaHI'IJI. COUH-
i1I1bHoro, CllYAte6Horo 1'1 I'IMYWCCTBeHHoro
'""''''-I\.H'''' v<'J""I1UH"JA tUIJI>JJlU", "i'''-
H3JL!1eJKHOCTI1 II napTI1J1M KJ11'1 II I'IHblM
o5wecTBeHHbiM OpraHI1J.aUIJHM. Yn()MJlHY-
Tb!e 4JaKTOpbl He romKHbI BI1I'1J1Tb Ha one-
paTHBHYIO lleSlTeJlbHOCTb, ec.1'1 :no oco60
He orolJO HO J<1110HOM (OJ S CT 4
\!ieKBanrocTbonepaTuBHo-paJblCKHblX
ITUH. n HHa HI( n eHttH
npOre1!eHl1e OPM. KUropb/e orpaHI'I'I111k11OT
KOHCTII1)'lJJIOHHbIe npana Ipa)KllaH HB Tat11-1)'
nepemlCKII. RJletJxlHHblx neperullOpOH, no'l-
l£iIibI.'(, RJ1erpmjmblx 1'1 IfHbIX coo6weHIfH,
nepe.IIO\BaeNblM no CeTHM 311eKl'pl'1'1eCKOn 1'1
nO'lTOBOH CBSlJ. a TalOKe npmlO HB HenpH-
KOCHOBeHHOCTb )l(tL"Il'Iwa, OOIl)'CK8!:TCJ1 Ha
OCHOBaHI'lIf cY.QcliHOro peweHI'ISI ill11'1 HaJll'I-
"11J1I1H4JopMaUI'I(aoJ.2CT.!j).
1.0 npl'l3HaKaX nO.QronIBI1I'1BaeMoro, co-
Bepwae\loro KJ111 coaepWeliHOro npoTH130-
npaBHoro lleHHI'IJI, no lI01opOMY npolllllQlJ,-
CTB0CJ1eJlCTBI'I.II06S13aTeJlbHo(ao3. 3 CT. 8).
2. 0 J1l'1ual( nOlirOTaBJ1I'1BaIOWI1I(. OOBep-
lUalOWHX IfJlI'I 1:0eeplUI'IBWI'IX npOTI'IBO-
npaBH()e .Qe.llHl'le. n() IIOTOPOMY npOI'lJ-
BOliCTIIO npeliBapl'lTeJlbHorOCJ1ellCTBIIIJI
06S13aTeJlbHO a6J. 4 CT. 8 .
llpo()(u;JKeHue maM. 2
3aKOH Kblprb!3CKOH
Pecny5J1I'1KIf
q060nepanlBHO-
P03b!CKHOn
lleSiTeiTbHOCTW>
3aKOH
J1arBl'lticKon
Pecny5J11'1111f
q060nepaTIJBHu-
P03b!CKHOii
(]>e.QepaJIbHbII133.KOH
..06 OnepaTI'IBHO-
P03b!CKH0i1
neSiTeiTbH()CTI'I"

llpo()(u;JKeHue maM. 2
1 2 3
],0 006b/T1111x 11111{ neik;11\WIX, CO.1llalOlllllX
yrp03y rocY.llapCTueHHoi1. BOeHHOH. :JXOHO-
MI1'1ecMJlII1J1I1 1JGn1'lOC"oii 6e30nacHo-
CTItPOCcl1ticKotiepaLll1I1(a63.5crE).
npOBC!!CHI1C oncpaTI1HHOro 311Cnepl1MCHTa
.Il0nYCII3eTCR TonbKO (I UeJIHX (I!>IHHJ1eHI1H.
npellynpe;t(}1eHI1H. npeCe'JeHHH I{ pOCllpbl-
THH T.IDKKoro npecryl1J1eHI1H. a TaJOKe B
ueJlHX BbIHHJ1eHI1H 11 ycraHOBJIeHI1H JlI1U,
I'IX nOllrOTaHJ1I1BaIOIUI1X, COBepUJaIOWI'IX,
I'IJWI COBepWI1BWl'lx{a63. 9 CT. 8).
npl1 npOBeJreHl111 OPM nO OCHOB3HI1I'1M.
npe!!ycMOTpeHHbIMI1 n. 1-411 6 'I. 1 CT. 7
HBCTORlI.It:ro CDt:1lepaJ1bHoro JaKOHa, 311-
npewTCSI ocywecTBJlCHl1e .IlciiCTRI1i1. YKa-
J3HHb1X II n 8-11'1 I CT 6 H3CTOSlWCrO
CDt:1lepaJIbHOr03aKOHB(a63.IOCT.E).
OPM. 06ecne<JI1BalOWl'le 6e30nacHocTb
opraHOB. ()CYlUeCTBJlHIOWI'IX OPD.. npOBO-
MTCH e COOTBeTCTel'l1'l C HflCTOHWI1M (]Je-
.IlepMhHbIM 3allOHOM I{ I{CKJlIO'II{Te1lbHO B
npe!!e1l3X n01lHo},tO<jI{}1 YKBa3HHblx opra-
HOB, YCTaHOBJIeHHblX COOTBeTCTBYIOWI1MI1
3KTaMI1 Poccl1ticKoii 4ICJlCpaLWII1.
nOOCIiO!l[lHI1RM.H!>IMn 5'1 2
CT 7 I-WCTOHWCro 4ICllCpar1bHOro JaKOH3,
p<l3pelUaercSi ocyweCTBJISlTb .IlekcTIn'lSi. yxa-
3BHHbleBn.E-II<j.1 CT.6,6e3cyne6Horo
peweHl'l.ll npl'l HaJll1'1.HI1 cornacJ.UI rjXOK1WH B
nl1CbMeHHoi1l)JopMe (dfu. II CT. E).
CBeJleHI1H 06 I1cnOJlb3yeMblx 111111 I1CnOl1b-
JOB3HHbiX nprI npoet:1lCHI1I1 Hcr.naCHhIX
OPM C(J)1BX, cpeJICTII3'[. I1CT04HI111BX, Me-
TOJlBX, mBHax 11 peaYJlbT3T3X OPD., 0 JlI1-
uax, BHclIpeHHblx B Opr3HI130B<lHHbIC npc-
Cl)'IlHbJe rpynnbJ. 0 WTBTHb!X HernOCHblX
cOlpynHI1Kax opraHoB, OCYllieCTBJlHIOWX
OPD.,I1()JlI1UaX,()KaJbIBalOlUXI1MCollefj-
CT1l11e till KOHH.l\eHLll1aJ]bHOi1 OCHOBe, fI
TdKJKe 06 opraHI{JaLll11{ 11 0 T3KTHKe npo-
HellCHI{S1 OPM COCTdBJ1HIOT rOCY1l3pCTBeH-
HYIO TaiiHY 11 n0.lU1e>K3T pacCCllpC411B<1HI1JQ
TOJ1bKO H3 OCH0H3HI1I1 nQCTaHOWICHI1R PYK<>-
CSlT Ha, OCYWeCTRl1S1lOwero OPD.

npH npHMeHeH1{1{ OnepaTl'lBHO po3blCKHblX
",rep, pa60nmK Onepan1llHblX 1lQlq)-naene-
HI{W OOSlJaHbl Y'II1Tb!BaTb HX COOOBel'C11!He
creneHI{ OOll!t:CTBeHHOH OnaCHUCT npe-
C1)'nHb1X nOCHraTeJlbCTB H yrpo:>e HHTepecat
06Il1CCTlJiIl{rocy.aapcn>a(a6a. 7 cr. 9).
OnepaTHBH()-po3b!CIIHble Mepbl. CBH3aHHble
C BpeMeHHblM OrpaHH'ieHHeM npaB'ieJlOBe-
Ka, njJOBOllffi'CJl B ue;ISlX npellOTBpalUeHI1S1
')}aAUU1'( npeo=ryru:reHHi1, I1X npece'1eHI1S1 H
pacllpb!nISl. po3b!Clla nl1ll. YKJ10HSlIOWHXCSI
OT O1f:ibIBaHI{H HaK,,3aHI1S1 l1.I1H 6eJ BeCTH
nponaSWHx, npece4eHife pa3I!ellb1HaTeJ1b-
Ho-no.apbJIJHoii: neWreJIbHOC'TH nponm YK-
paHHb! B CJ1}"1ae onepanfIJHOW HC06'<OJIH-
M()CTH He0Tl10JKH()ro ocYllIeCTBJ1eHI1H 311ft
Mep ooep'I'IIIBHO-po3b!CIIHbJe no.apa31lCJle-
HIiH ()5H3aHbl B Te'leHl1e 24 '1aCOB CoOO-
ll.[I1Th npOKypopy 0 nplfMeHeHlf1f I{ OCHO-
BaHI{HX DJHI I1X npoBeJIeHI1S1 (003. 14 CT. 9).
&l3}'IIJ1bHQe Ha5JJlOJ!eHlfe MOJKeT BeC111Cb B
UeJlSlXHI1HllilHHb!X()J1l1uel1ero
CII!I35IX, eOlIf IfMelOTCA $JKn,J, n01lTBep-
.'ITOI1tl1lUIOB1llU1W1I1COBeprne-
HO"f}I)KKoe npecryl1J1eHlfe.aTIUoKeJIJISI nOlly-
::onPHJHaKI1
npoBelletille OPM, 3aIpareaIOWx TilHHY
nepenl1CKH. TeJ1e4JoHHblx I{ I1HblX neperooo-
poB, TeJ1e.-pa.pHhlx coOOwetilli1,
nepemBae\lbl).t n() TeXHl{1leCKHM KaHaJIaM
CI!5I3. HenpHIIQCHoaeHHOCTb }K1fJ1Hll.[3. 1l0-
Jl}'CI<ae'JCjJ nHll.[b JIJIH c50pa HH4Jop1awm ()
JIlfU3X, nOilrcrmRl1IfBaIOWX IfJlIf IlOK}rn-uo-
IUHXCSI Ha 1'SDI(I{Ije npecryrlJ1eHI1S1. COBep-
rn310IlUn JlH60 COBepWI1BWIfX TII)KKe npe-
C1)'l1J1eHI1S1 H lThlbKOC caHIIUHH 1lpOJ<."}']XJ1:0
no MOTIIIBpoBaHHOMY nQCT3HOILleHI{IO py-
KOBOlI.IITeJISI (JaMeCTIfJeT)CM) cocrt"I!e1\.-rnylO-
ll.[ero opnUla, ocymecTBI1J1lOllICro OPLJ,.
B CJ1Y'Jae BOJHHIlHOBeHHJI JlBHOW yrp03bl
}K1f3HIf. 3ilOpOlJblO, co6<:TBeHHocrn OT-
,IlCJ1bHb!XJlHll, aTillOKe no 3aHRI1CHI11O1'IJ11{
c cornaCH1 rpa)l(J!aH 1l0nycKdeTCSI np08e-
,IleHl{e YKaJaHHblX OPM Ha ()CHOBaHHI{
nOCraHOBJ1eHI1JI, yTaepJK.IleHHoro pyKOBO-
,WIRJlCM (aaMeCTtrre'le).t) COOTBeTCTI\YIO-
lUero opraHa. OCYlUeCTBJI.!IlOmero OPLJ" C
061!3aTeJlbHbiM YlleilOMJleHl{eM []JJOKYPOPIl
BTe'leHl{e 241.J. 003.2 cr. 9
llpo()(u;JKeHue maM. 2
3
3allOH YKpalfHbl
«06()nep:1TI1BHO-
P03blc1lHOHlIeJl-
TeJlbHOCTI1»
3aKOH Pecny5J1I1KI'I
I)e!]apycb
«060nepaTHBHO-
P03bICKH()HAeSl-
TeJlbHOCTIf

2
OPM, J:JTparl1BalOWHe ()XpaHSleMYIO a
KOH()M TaHHY nepenl'lCKl'I, TeJIe4JoHHblx
neperooopOB. TeJ1erpai))Hb!X coo6lUeHIdi
1'1 nO'JTOflblX OTnpaflJ1eHI'IH, a TaKJI<e He-
Jlpl1KOCHOBeHHOCTb )KI1JIHwa, ocyweCTlI-
JIIUOTCH HCK.'IIO'IHTe.'IbHOW1l1
- BbllUlJ1eHI1S1 npellynpe)l(,!{eHI1S1 11 pac-
KpbITI1H TIUKKI1X 11 oc060 TA)KKI1X npecry-
J]JleHI1H. a TdlVKe npeCTynneHl1ii, nOJlro-
T3e.m1BaeMb!X 11 COBepWiteMblX npecryn-
HblMI1 rpynnaMI1 (... 4 CT. 12).
- n()JIY'leHI'ISI paJBeI1bIB.IJeQbH()fj I1H!j:JOp-
MaUI'IH Ii UeJ1S1X ()6eCne'leHI1S1 6eJOnacHo-
CT PecnyfuJl'IlIH Ka3a'OC'T.JH. BbISlBJIel-U'I.!l.
npellynpe;t(}1eHI1J1 1'1 npece'JeHI'ISI jXDBellN-
mrreJ1bHO-nOllpbIBHbIX nOCSIraTeJ1bCTB cne-
UI'la.rJbHbIX CJ1Y I'IHOCTpm-JHbIX rocy-
,W!pCTB 11 HHocrpaHHblx opraHlnm.!I1H ('I 5
CT. 12). OpraHI1J3UHSI 11 TaKTI1K3 npOBI:}:Ie-
HeH13CHbIX QPM MOryr COCT3H11S1Tb
Cij)'JKffiHYIO, BoeHHYIO HJ111 rocYlIapCTBeH-
HylO TaWHY B COOTI!eTCTffitlJ C nepe'JHeM
cBe.neHI1f1. n01l!1e)!(J.IUHX 3aCelq)e'II'IBaHIUO,
ymep)I(,QaeMbIM K,,6I1HeTOM MI1HHCrpOB
PecnytiJII'IKH KaJOlACTaH Ha ()CHOBaHlU'1
3aKOfJa ..0 J.aWI'lTe rocynapCTBeHHblx ceK-
peroH PecnytiJII'IKI'I KaJ.a1[CTaH
'I.9CT 12
npoBeJJ,eHl1e DPM, J.arparlJBiIOIJ.U'IX oxpa-
J-meMble 3aKOHOM TaftH}' nepenltCKIt, m:-
$OHHhIX It ItHb!X neperoOOpQB, TeJ1erpa$-
IiblX It lJHblX co06meHltii. nepe,llaeaeMblX
no CeT}lM 3JleKrplJ'l.ecKoi1 It rtO<ITOOOii cell-
:m. a TIllOKe npaBO H3 HenpI1KOCHOBeH-
HOCTh >K1tf1lt1U3. .D()nYCKaerC.II J1ltlUb DJISI
coopa ItH$OpMau1t () J1I1Uax, nQl1roTaBJII'I-
BiI.lOIUII'I( I{ n()IIYlUaIOIUI1XCSI Ha 1JDKKIte
npeCl)'TlJleHH.II. COBepWalOlUl'IX J1HOO co-
BepWI1BWI1X TIDKKl1e npecryn1lf'HHSI. TO!1b-
KO C caHIlUHH npQJ<ypQpa no M01I1BHpo-
BaHHOMY nOCTaHOIJ!1CHHIO OllHoro H3 PYKO-
BQWneTJeH COQ'OIe"lCJ1I)'wero opraHa, ocy-
IUeCTIiI1H1Owero OP!],.
10
llpo()(u;JKeHue maM. 2
3
3aKoH PecnytiJlI1KI'I
""""em"
..06onepanIDHo-
P03bICKHOHneSl-
TenbHOCTIt
3aKOH Kblprb!3cKOtl
PecnytiJlltllH
..060nepflTliBHO-
P03blcKHoHneSl-
TeJlbHOCTIt"

2
npH 3TOM ()OCJICL!()BaHl1e >KWlbiX J]()Me-
WeHI1W A()nycKBeTCJI II I'ICKI1fO'1I'1TeJlbHb!X
CJlY4BSlX 11 TOJIbKO C C3HKLlHI1 COOTBCTCT-
lI}'IOll.lcro npoKypopa ('1.1 CT. 9).
B CJ1Y'lWlX, K010pbIe He Tepn.II.T oTJIara-
TeJ1bCTBa 11 Mor)'T npl'lBecn:! K COBepwe-
HI1IO TqJpOpHCT'1eCl';Oro 3Kl11 ru1l1 !U1f1ep-
c"m, HB OCHOBaHHI1 MOTI1BHpOBaHHoro
nOCTiIHOBJ1eHI1H OIlHoro 11.1 PYKOBO!U1TeJlei1
COOJBeTCTBVlOwero opraHfI. OCYlUeCTB-
nJllomcro OPll 1l0nYCl<aCTCJI npOBCllCHl'le
OPM, nepe'll'lCJ1eHHbIX B '{aCTH BTOpOH
Hal:Tomllei1 CTaTbl1. C He3aMeJlJ1I1TeJ1hHbIM
YBenOMlleHl1eM coorEeTCJlI}"£dUero npOKY-
pops 1'1 n()CJ1CLIyJOlliHM nOJ1}"1CHI'ICM CaHI<-
m1HBTe'lCHl1c24..aCOB('J JCT 9)
B CJ1}"IHC B03HHilHOBeHHJI yrp03bI }l(113HI1,
:W:OpOBblO, c06cTBeHHocTH O'rJ\e;IbHbIX l1HLl
no !'IX 3aSlBJleHmO HJ[I'I C !'IX nI1CbMeHH()rO
COrJlacl1S1 paJpewacrcSi npOCJ1YIllI1BaHl1e
neperoeopOB, BeJlYLl.lHXCSI C I1X rC}1c410HoB
111111 Jlpyrl1x nepefOBopHblX YCTPOi1CTB. H3
OCHOBaHl11'1 nOCTflHOB.'ICHI1J1. }lTBCp;KJICH-
H()rO PYIIOBOlll1TCJlCM opraHB. 0CYlUCCTB-
nJnowcro OPD.. C 06S1J3n:JlbHbl'" yflCllOM-
JICHHCM COOTl!eTCTII}'lOwero npo"ypopB (I
Te<lCHHC 24 'I.. ('I. 4 CT. 9).
npl1 npoBCllCHHI1 aPM no oCHOBaHI1J1M.
npcIlycMOTPCHHbl"tH n 1-3 1'1 S 'i 2 CT 8
HacTOSiwero 3m<OH3, J.anpewaeTCJI ocywe-
CTRI1eHl1e J!eHCTBI1H, YK3.3aHHbIX B n. 8-14
'I.. I CT. 7 HaCTO.II.wero 3aKoHa (II.. 5 CT. 9).
OPM. o5eCne'II1BalOWHe cufJcrneHHYIO
6e30naCHOCTb OBll. opraHOB 5eJonaCH()-
CT, ynOJ1HOMOII.eHHoro rOCYJ!apCTBeHHO-
m Opr[lHB B c$epe KOHTpOJ1J1 HBPKOTI1-
KOB, upraH()B ymJ1()BHO-I1CnOJ1HI1Te.%HOH
CI1CTeMbl, npooonsrrcJl B nOp.llIIKe, npeIIY-
CMOTpeHHOM 3aKOH0Ll3TeJ1bHblMI1 HKTaMH
Kblprbl3cKOH Pecny5J1I1KrI.
no OCHOBaHI1J1M. npeIIYCMOTpeHHblM n. 4
'I.. 2 CT. 8 pa3peUJaeTC.II ()cywecTBJlJlTb
,[(eticTBHJI. YKB3BHHbie B n 8-14 'I. I
CT. 7 HOCTOH1J.!ero 3allOHa, 6.j CBHIIUI1H
:"n:0;JI611 ;aHI1Ha B
11
flpOI}(M:MCeliUe ma(jA. 2
3

J 2
MeponpS1T1U[ onepaTMBH()!:I AeSlTeJIbHOCll1,
BI1!lI'lX npoBelleHI1S1. ()fj'beM 1'1 IiHTeHCI'IB-
HOCTb nOmKHbJ COOTBeI'CTIJOB,b BI11I,Y no-
CHraTeJlbCTBa 11 creneHI1 onaCHOCT. one-
parl1BHble 3MaHI'IJI HeOO.:«llllIMO BbJnOJl-
tulTb, no B03MOJKHOCT ),teHbwe BMeWl'Il1a-
JlcbBcilJepynpaB'lCnOBeKa('I. 3 cr. 4)
3anpewaeTcSI I1CnOJIb30BaHI1e onepaTl'IB
}j()fj neSlTe.llbHOCTI'I BHe CJIY>KeI5Hblx I1HTe-
pecoll (CT. 4)
npOBellel-U'le OPM. .IrrrparHBalOll.ll1X OX-
paHJleMble 3"KOHOM Taf1HY nepenl1CIII1.
TeJ1e,pOHHblx 11 I1HbIX neperOBopOB. TeJle-
rpa.pHblx coo6meHHH, a TaIOKC npaBO H3
lienpHKocHOBeHHocTb )l(1'IJ111ll!3, JIOnycKa-
eTCSI JU'llUb lIJUi c60pa I'IH4JoPMaul'll'l 0
JII'ILIiIX, [j()llr01aBJ1I'1B3IOUUlX I'IJ1H nOl<:Y-
rualOWl1xcSI I-Ja Tfl>KKHe npecrynJleHI1.11.
C()eepWaIOWI1X l1}m COBepWI'IBWI'IX TSI)I(-
Kl1e npecTynneHI1.11 ('t. I CT. 8).
OPM, 06ecne4I1BaIOUle 6e30naCHOCTb
.neSlTeJ1hHOCH'I OBIt. HaLlI1Otw.J1bHoti 6e3-
()nacH()CT 11 060POHbl, npollO,lJ,JITCJ1 B no-
p!L!\IIC, npC!!YCMOTpeHHOM H8CTOHIl!I1M
3aIlOHO'" 'l. 4 CT 8
3 I1IHllcaUHH no.arQT08KH II pe3ynbTaT08 ocy-
IJ.IeC1BJJeHIJI OnepaTHBHO-pa3b1CKHIoIX Mepo-
npIlHTKitBonepaTHBIIO-cIXHHHbIX
- ':ll:H:: ca:;:U'lBalOllmX
J(()I-JC11fi)'UHOHHble npaBarpa;t(1laHI-JaTIlnHy
nepenl1CKI'I. TeJ\$HHbIX neperoBOpOB,
1lO'lTGEIbIX, Te.llerpa,pHblX 1'1 I'IHblX coo6ille-
Hl1H, rrept'J\alBileMbJX no CtlSlM 3lIeKrp<je-
CKOi1 1'1 npoBoj{Hofi CBSl3, a TaJOKe npaBa Ha
HenpKOCHOBeHHOCTb )!(1V11'1ll!3, J\onYCKaeT-
S1 Ha OCHOBaHI'II'I cy1K'6Horo peweHI1S1 np
Hal'I'.ml'l I'IH4JoPMamm 0 np3HaKax, 3(1-
4JI'IKCl'lpoBaHHbIX B MOTBpoBaHHOM no-
CTaH()BJ\eHI1I'1 PY£OBQIIJITCJISJ ()praHa, ocywe-
CTlWlIOLl\ero OPD, 11 06OCHOBbIBalOillerO
 nepen CYJ\OM 0 npe.D,0C1i\BJIC-
Hl1l'1 p<l3peWeHl'ISI Ha npoBeJleHl1e A3.HHb!X
OPM
12
flpOOolJKf!tlue moth. 2
3
3aKoHJ]aTBl'lftcKoft
PecnytiJ1I'1KI1
..06onepaTI'IBH()ft
JleHTe.l1bHOCTI1.
3aKoHJII1TOBCKoft
PecnytiJ1I'1KI1
..06 onepaTI'IBHOH
JleHTe.l1bHOCTI'I"
3aKoH
PecnytiJ11'1111'1
MOJU\oBa
..06 onepaTI'IBHO-
POThICKHOHJ\CSI-
TenbHOCTW>
<DellepanbHblft
JaKOH
«06onepanIBHo-
p03b!CKHOi1
JleHTeJ1bHOCTI'I

npH ()CYlUeCTB.I1eHI1H OPD, BOJMOJl(Hbi
OTne.l1bHble Orpal-JWICI-II1H npaB H CB06011
'ICJ10BeIlH. fOpHllH'IeCIIHX J1HL[ OHH 1-10-
I:SlT HCKJ1IO'II1TeJ1bHbIH H BpeMeHl-lblii xa-
paKTep H MOryT npHMeI-lSlTbC.!I 1II1Wb C
C3HIIL1I'1H npollypopa 11 B OTHOlliCHHH
1111Ll3, B JJ,eHCTBHJlX 1I0TOporo I1MefOTCJI
npl13HaKH npecTynneHl1.!1, 11 B CJI}"ffiSlX,
npellYCM()TpeHHblX 3aKOHO)1aTeJ1bCTBOM
YllpHI1Hbl B L1lISiX 3all.!l1Tbi npaB H CBO-
60)\ npyrl1x JIm!, 6eJOnaCHOCTI1 06weCT-
Ba. TaKl1e onepaTHBH()-P03b!CKHble Mepb!
npoDolllITCSI C CaHIIUI'IH npoKypopa B
ueJ1HX npel(OTBpaWHI1H TSI>KKI1X npecTY-
nJleHldl, HX npeCe'leHI'ISI 1'1 pacKpblTI'ISI,
p03blcKa JIHU, YKlIOHHfOWHXCH ()T OTObl-
lIaHI1H HalGBal-ll1H I1nl1 01:3 IICCTI1 npo-
naBWHX, npeCe4eHI1S1 pa3BeJlblBarJ1bHO-
n()llpblBHoti lle.II.Te.l1bHOCTI1 npOTI1B YK-
pal1HbI (a03 5, 14cT 9)
np()BelleHl1e OPM, JaTparl1BalOIllHX
TaHHY nepenl'lCKl1, TClIel)J()HHblX H I1HblX
neperOBopOB, H:J1erpaI)JHblx co06wc-
1-11111. nepellaBaeMblX no 'JeXHI1'1eCKI1M
KaHaJla CB.!I3I1, HenpI1KOCH()BeHHOCTb
>K(I.'IHlliH. ll()nYCKaeTCH Jll1llib W1H coopa
I1HI)JOpMflLll111 0 J1HLl3X, nOllrOTaBJ1I1-
BalOlUHX Hnl'l nOKYWfllOlUHXCJI Ha TSI>K-
Kl1e npecTynJleHHSI, C()BepWaIOWHX JlI1-
60 COBepWHflWHX TH>KKHe npecTynJle-
HHSI 1'1 TOJ1bIlO C CaHKLll111 npOKypopa no
MOTHBl1pOBaHH()MY n()CTaH()BJleHHIO py-
KOBOllI1TJlH (JaMccTHTCJlH) COOTBQCT-
HYlOwero opraHH. ocyweCTBJlHfOwero
OPil(aoJ. 2CT_ 9)
13
llpo()(u;JKeHue maM. 2
3allOH YKpal1Hbl
,,060nepaTI1BHO-
pOJbICKHof1neSl-
TCJlbHOCTW>
3aKOH PecnytiJlI1KI1
EeJ1apycb
,,06 onepaTHBHo-
P03b!CKHOH
neSlTeJ1bHOCTW>

llpooo,J;JKI?HUI? mUM. 2
OPM. 3f1TparnBalOll!('Ie oxpaHl1eMble 33.KO-
1i0M Tai1HY nepenHCKII, TeQ>oHHblx nepe-
roaoPOB, TeJ1erpa4JHblX co06JJJ,eHI1H 11 no'1-
TOHblX QTnpaHJ1eHI1H. II TaKJKe HenpI1KOC-
IiOBeHHOCTb JKIV1I1ll1a, ocymeCTBJ1J1IOTCSI
I1CK.fTIO'1I1TeJlbHO llJJlI BblSlBJleHIffi. npeay-
npeJKlleHIffi 11 pactqJNTHJI THJKKX 11 oc06o
TSDI(}(JtI( npecryrmeHI1i1, nOllroTaBJII1BaeMblX
11 COBepIUaeMblX npecrynHblMI1 rpynna"lM.
TOJIbKO C CaHKUHI1 npmcypopa. CaHKWuo
Ha npoBeLleHl1e TaK"" MeponpJUm:!H n()
nOCTaHOBJIeHl11O OpraH()B, ocyrueCTHJ1HIO-
IlIHX OPD., llaeT reliep,L"IbHbIH npoKypop
Pe<:ny6JJI1K K'UaXCTaH 11 ero 3<1MeCTi1RI1I1.
BoeHHblfI npoKypop pecny6J1I1KH. npOKY-
POPbI o6JJIICTdi 11 npl1paBHeHHb!e II HI1M
npOllypopbl ('J 4 CT. 11)
It1CKJ1IO'1I1TeJ1bHOllJJl1 nOJ1}"1eliI1J1 pa3Bellbl-
BaTeJ1bHOH I1HQ>opMBUI1I1 B LleJ1S1X 06ecne-
'JeHI1J1 6e3QnacHOCTH Pecny6JJI1KH K:nax-
CTaH. BbISlBJIeHI1J1, npe!lynJ'C>l'1lCHIffi 11 npe-
Ce'1eHI1S1 pa3BellblBBTeJlbHO-nollpblBHblX no-
CHraTeJlbCTB cneumUlbHblX CJlyJK6 I1H()-
clpaHHblx rocynapcTB 11 l1lJ()crpaHHblx op-
raHI13aUliH OPM. nepe'II1c.'IeHHble B n. 4
H3CTOHll]eHCTaTbII. MuryrOCYJJJ,eCTBJ1J1TbCSI
B nopHllKe, COrJ1BCOBaHHOM C npollypopoM
Pecny6J111K11 K'U1'<\."T.lH ('J. SeT 11).
npl1 nOJ1Y'1eHI1I1 CHHKLlI1I1 HH npoBelle-
liue OPM, nepe"Il1CJIeHHbiX e n. 4 HH-
CTOJlll]eH CTaTbH. npoKYpopy npeJlCTae-
J1l1erC1 MHTepI1HJ1bl OCHOBaHI1J1 llJJJ.I I1X
npOBeJ\eHI1I1. B <!>opMe 11 nO COllepJKI!-
HI1IO I1CK.fT104111OWl1e B03MOJKHOCTb pac-
IUI1<!>POBKIi CBelleHI1H 0 J111'JHOCHI rpl!-
)IUl3H. COTPYJ\HI1'JllIOWI1X IiJII1 COTPYll-
HI1'J3BIUI1X I-!a K()H$H1leHUI13JIbHOH ()C-
HOBe C ()pr3H3MI1. ocyweCTDJIJlfOIlIl1X
OP,ll ('I. 8 CT. 11
3aKOH Pecny6J1I1KH
Ka3aXCTaH
..06 onepBTHBHO-
P03bICIIH0 i1 .ue I1 -
TCJIbHOCTW'
14

2
npoBeJ1eHl'le uPIVI'. 3aTp:JIl'IBalOIlII'IX oxpa
HlieMble 3aKOH()M TIlHY nepenl'lcKI'I. TeJ1e-
4>oHHblX M I1lJblX neperoBOpoB, Te!1erpa<1J-
HbJX 1'1 I'IHblX co06u.eHI'IH. nepenalkleN:bIX no
CeTIlM 3I1eKT]JI'I'leClloiJ 11 IlO'nOBOM CBJl311. a
TdlOKe npaeo H3 HenpKOCHOBeHHOCTb }l(11-
1I111ll3, JJOnyclG1erCSI IUIWb J]JISI c60pa lJH-
tlJoPMaL\lUI 0 lUIL[aX. nOllrQT3B11I'1BaIOIlII1X 11
1l0KYWaJOWlRCP tfa TS!)I{!<l1e npecryJ1JJeHI1I1.
COBeplilllfOlWIX J1W)o COBePWIfBlliI1X UDKKl'le
npeC1)W1eHMJI. TOJlbKO C CaHKUI11'I npoKYpo-
IX! no MOTBl1poBaHH()MY nOCT:JHOBJ1eHI1IO
O1lHOroI13py1«)BOill11'efjC
lUefO oprnHa, oc)'lIleCTB/lJIIOmerO OPD"
npl1 3TOM ()6C!lenOBaHl1e )l(I1.11bIX Il()Me-
llleHI1H nonYCKaeTCII e I'ICKJllO'II'ITe.llbHb!X
=;o I1n:: =; 9COOTBeTCT-
nqJe411CJ1eHHblC BeT. 6 H3CTOSimcro 3a-
KOHa MepOnpl'lllTl'I1I OTlepaTI'IBHOH JleJl-
TeJ1bHOCTI'I MO;KHO 0CYlUeCTBJlJlTb, II ()O-
llieM 11 oc06oM Bl'IliaX ('I. I CT 7).
MepOnpl1HTl'I1i onepanlBHoti neHTe.llbHO-
CTI'I npOB01UITC.II e 06weM liMe, eC.l1I1
npl1eMbl. tlJoPMa 11 06beM I1X npOneJleHl11'1
CYllIeCTBeHHO He 3aTpan1lJaKH KOHcrTY-
LlI1QHHblX npaB .nI'lLl K npOBt:.QeHI1IO 3"mX
MepOnpl1I1THi1 npl1BJIeKaeTCSI LlomKHOCT-
lioe J1I1UO C CaHIIUl111 CBoero HenOCpellCT-
BeHHoro PYKOOOIDlTCQJI ('J 2 C 7)
MepOnpl1HTl'I1i onepanlBHoti neSlTe.llbHO-
CTH, B XOlle KOTOpblX 3aT)JarMBa1OTC.II KOH-
CTHTYUOHHbJe npaBa J1I1U. npOBOlUlTCSI e
OC060M BHllC('I.. JCT. 7).
OneparnBHbII1 KOHTjXlJlb 33. Koppe<:noH.lleH-
lU1eif, nOfl)'JeHlJe onepaTIJBHoi1 I1HijJopMa-
lU1l1cl1cnonb30BaHI1CMTeXHlf'1eCI<lncpeilCTB,
om:p;nIlIJHQe TI1i1Hoe npoc.r1YWI1HilHl1e HC-
ny6i1I1'1.HbIX paJfOoopon (BKJ1IO'IlliIlt:JJC<]JOH-
Hble, 'ICpe3 CKIpOHHbIC lJ lJHOro Brurn
CpellCTBaCBSl3) M()neparnBHoe npOHlJKHO-
BCHl1e ocyJllecTBllJllO'l'CR TMbKO ocOOblM
06pa30M 11 C caHKU11 cy.nelt.
15
flpoiJo1)KfflUemafin.2
3
3aKoH Kblprb!3CKoi1
Pecny6J1MKI'I
..060nepaTHBHO-
P03b!CKH0i1
i\eSlTeJ1bHOCTI1
3aKOH
JlaTBI1i1cIIOii
Pccny6J1l1l1lJ
..06 onepaTI1BHoif
i\eSlTeJ1bHOCTI1

PaJpeweHe H8 npOIl<:lleHm: 3TX Mepo-
npl1S1TlJii onepaTI1BHofi l!eSlTeJ1bHOCTIJ
MOJKeT 6blTb BbIJ{SHO HS CpOK l!O 3 MecSI-
Llf:B 11 B cJ1)''1ae 06ocHOImHHoll He06xo-
JUJMOCT MOJKer 6blTb npOJ1.l1eHO, HO
TOJ1bKO H8 TO BpeMH. noK1'l no OTHOllle-
luno K J111Ll)' npoBOllKTbCJl OnepaTI1BHruI
......J......60TKa <J. 4 CT. 7.
TawHblfl OCMOTp )lmJ1()ro nm.temeHI1S1.
npMeHeHe Mo.ae;II1 npoee.aeHI1H. I1MI1TI1-
PYlOilletl npecI)'[1HYIO J\eSlTeJ1bHOCTb, a
TIlKJKe onepaTIJIIHblX CPeJ1CTB npoHI1KalO-
mero xapaKTepa caHKlll1oHI1pYIOTC.!I reHe-
pa.nbHblM npoKypopoM JlmoBCKoH Pecny6-
1I1I11 (J]]11 3aMewalO!l.[(JM eTO J1I1UOM. Cy6-.,..
eKTOM onepaTIfBH()H J\eHTeJ1bHOCTIJ II M()T-
BI1pOBaHHOM nOCTaH()BJ1eHI1I1 OTHOCI1TeJ1b-
HO nOJ1Y'1eHI1S1 CaHKll11 YKa3blB8MCSI:
I) l]1aMI1J1I1S1 cJ1Y>Ksmero, nOi\8BWe[o 38-
JlBJ1eHl1e.
2) ()nl1caHl1e06'beKTal1J1l1l]1aMI1J1I1S1J1l1Ua,
3" KOTOpblM 6yneT )'CTJ.H0BJ1eH8 CJ1eJt(K1'I;
3) l]1aKTbI 060CHOBblB8lOlI1l1e TjJe60BaHe
o nplJMeHeHl111 MeTOn()B 11 cpeJ\CTB npo-
HI1KalOlIlero x8paKTepa;
4) onl1caHl1e cpellCTS8 CBSlJI1, II KOTapOMY
6yner n()nK.IO'reHa CneUI'IMbHaSi reXHl1l1a;
5) nOllTBepJt(ileHl1e HeBOJ»tOJKHOCTI1 no-
JlY'teHI1S1 TaKow I1H$OpMaUIJI1 C nOMOIUblO
06bl'l.H0I1 TeXHI1KI1 pSCCJ1ellOBSHI1.!1;
6) npenYCM8Tpl'lBaeM8J1 npOllOJ1>KI1TeJ1b-
HOCTb npl1MeHeHI1J1 :\teTanOI! 11 cpeilCTe
npOllOJ1>KTeJ1bHorOXapaIlTepa;
7) AOCTl'lraeMblti peJYJ1bTaT
no COBepweHl111 TaHHoro OCMorpa JKI1J10-
ro n()MellieHIfSI 0pllep 11 cnpaBKa () pe-
3yJ1bTaTSX oCMoTpa II Te4eHI1e 14 OJ H8-
npaBJIHIOTCH naBweM)' C8HKUIJIO nOJ1JKHO-
CTHoMynl1Ll)'
Opllep 0 npl1MeHeH11 onep8TI1BHO-Tex-
HI1<JeCKI'IX cpellCTB IIbl1l8CTCJI Ha CpOK He
60J1ee 90 CyrOK C npOJ1.l1eHl1eM K8JK.1\b!e
15 CV'mK AetiCTBI1H ()n"nen:l.
16
flpodOJIJ1CeHUe ma5A. 2
3
3SKoHJll1TOeCKOH
Pec[Jy6J1111111 «06
OnepaTI1I1HOI1J\eSl-
TenbHOCTW>

1 2 3
B CJ1Y'lae OTK333 npOllJll1Tb ()pIlep "'"
I1CTe'1.CHI1S1 cpOKa 0<, .o:eficTBI1S1 opllep
BOJapamaerc}[ 1l0JUf(HOCTHOMY J1111lY. Bb!-
naBweMY caHKUHIO.
F'a3p:furnHHaSI C)Ubet..TOM Onepal'KB!-Ol n-
TeI1bHOC111MQ.1ICJ1b,I1Mlmlp}'}O-
l1..lIDI npeC'TYI1HYJO neJrTeJlbHOCTb, C'lHKU\IOHH-
:;:m ro::7::e KQ-
npOBenemfe OPM. 3aTparHBafOllIl1X()X- 3aKoH Pcny6J1I1KH
paHReMble JaKOHOM Tau-JY nepenHCIII1. M()!111()Da ,,06 onc-
TeJ1C<)JOHHbIX 11 HHblX neperOBopOB. TeJ1e- panll!HO-p03blcKHoJ:i
rpalJmblx cOOOlUeHl1tt. a TalOKe npaBO Ha lIeSlTeJlbH()CTW'
Henpl1KOCHOBeHHOCTb >KI1.1IHrua, n()nYCKa-
eTC$! n11lUb '"" c60pa I'IH4>OpMflUI1I1 ,
J1I1LlaX, no.o:roTaBJ1I1SalOll.!l1X "'" [joKY-
lUalOl.1!l1XCSI "" TSI}KKl1e npcCTynJleHIHI.
coeepWBlOll.!l1X 111m CQeepWI1HWI1X TSI)I(-
KI1C npccrynJ1CHMH, a Tall)l(C C CaHKLl11
npollypopa no MOTBl1pOBaHHOMY nocra-
H()8J]CHHIO OliHoro 113 pyKOBOllI1T!:J1cfi co-
OTBCTCTB)'IO!llCrO opraHa. ocywecTBJlJllo-
mero OPn. nepe'1eHb KaTeropHi1 TaKI1X
PYKOBOlli1TeJ1CJ:i YCTaHaBJU'lBaeTCSI HupMa-
TBHbIMl1aKTaMI1('I.. I CT B).
OPM, 06ecne<ll1lJ<uollme 6e3onaCHOCTb .neSl-
Te.!1bHOCTI'IOElt, I-JaUHOHaJ1bH0I1 6e3onac-
HOCT 11 06oJXIHhl, npCIBO!ll1TC>I e nop!lJlKe,
npe,o,ycr<ImpeHHblM HacroAIl{M 3aKOHOM
'1.4 CT. 8
3,2, B CJ1Y'JaSlX, KOTopble He TepnJlT OTJ1a- 4IellepallbHb!W3aIlOH
nneJlbCTDa If MOryr nptmeCTIf K COBepwe- «06 onepaTMBHO-
HI1IO TH)!(KOrO npecrynJIeHI1S1, a TaJOKe npl'l P03b!CKHO
I-m.l'I'tl1l1 D,aHHbIX 0 C06bITl'l.lIX 11 nef1cTBI1- neSlTJ1bHOCTW'
EX. C()3.QaIOIl!MX yrp03Y roCYJlapcTBeHHoi!.
BoeHHOH. 3KOHOMM'teCKoi! lUm 3KO.:Jorlll-
'teCKOH 6onacHOCTIJ Pocc(JilcKOH 4Il:lIe-
paUlf11 Ha ()CHOBaI-J(J(J MOTHBI1pOBaHHOrO
nOCTIlH()BJleHI1HOllH()ro 113PYIlOBOlll'lTeJ1ei1
opraHa. ()CYlUeCTBJlSllOwero OPlJ" Aonyc-
KaeTCH npOBelleHl1e OPM. npenYCMorpeH-
HblX It. 2 HacTOJ.ul!e CTdTbH C 06!'!.>rrreJlb-
HblM YBeJ\oMJleH(JeM cYlla (CYllbl'l) B Te4e-
I-lMe14't.
npoikM;w:eHue ma6,1 2
17

Z
B Te..eHl1e 48 'I C MO\feHT3 I-Ja'Jarra npOBe-
.neHI1$1 OPM opraH, ero ocymeCTB/1}1I0-
11111i1, 06S13aH nOJ1)"1I1Tb CYJle6HO pelUe-
l-U1e 0 npOBeJ:LeHml TBKOro OPM 111160
npeKpBTI1Tb ero npOI\t:lleHl1e (a63. 6 CT. 8).
B CJ1Y'Jae B03HlfKHOBeHHH yrp03bl JKM3HI1.
:mopOBbJO, co6cTBeHHoCT OTlleJIbHblX J1I1U,
a TalOKe n() 11" 3aHBJleHI11O 1'11111 C IiX co-
rnaCI11 e nl1ChMeHHoii 4JopMe pa3pemaeT-
C.II npOCJ1YWI1BiiHl1e neperoBopoB. Be.llY-
Il\I1XCSI C I1X TeJIe.pOHOB, Hif OCHOB"HI1I1
JlOCTBHOll!1eHIfJI. yrnt:pJIUIt:HHOro pyKORo-
,Wnt:neM oprafia, OCYllieCTRJ1JIIOwerO Opn.,
c (){iH38TCJlbHbIM YDClI:O\I.IICHMCM COOTBCT-
cTB}'IOIUero cy.na (CYllbli) B Te'leHl1e 48..
('( 3. 4 CT. 8 (]>3. 06 opn (003 7 CT. 8).
npoBepO'II-ID.II 3BKynKB I1nl1 KOHTpOJ1I1-
pye"'l<lJI nOCTBBKa npellMeTOB. eemeCTB 11
npOllYIIL!HI1, CBo6o,QHBSI pearmJaUI1J1 KO-
TOPblX JBnpe1J..leHB 111160 060POT KOTOPb!X
OrpaHI1'JeH, a TIlIOKC onepaTI18Hblk KC-
nepl1MelH tin" ()nepaTl1BHOe BHellpeHl1e
I\OJDKH()CTHbIX J1I1U opraHoB. oC}lwecTB-
J1S1lOlliI1X Opn., a paSHO nl1U, ()Ka3bIBalO-
IUI1X 11M C01!ei1cTBl1e. npoB01UITCH Ha OC-
HOIJ"HI1I1 nOCraHOBJIeHl1l'1, yTBep)I(AeHHO-
JOeBojr:. 80.a. OCYllIeCTB-
B CJ1)"lae ()nepaTI1BH()W He06xOlll1MOCTli
/ieOPIOJKHoro OCYlllecTRI1eHI1S1 Mep, orpa-
Hl1'Jl1BalOUmX KOHCTI1TYUI1()HHble npaBa l'I
l!06011bl rpa)K.IWH, oncpaTlfflHO-p03b1CK-
Hble nO.!!p3:u\elIeHI1S1 06S13aHbl B Tf'leHl'Ie
24 'IaCOB C006ml1Tb npOKYpoPY 0 npl'lMe-
HeHl1l'1 3THX Mep 11 OCHOBaHl'IH .IlIlSi I1X
npoBelleHI'ISI (a63. 14 CT. 9)
B CJ1Y4ae B03HI1KHOBeHI'IH HIIHoii yrp03b1
>KIf3HI1. 31l0pOBblO, cOOcTBeHHOCTI'I ()T-
.!!eJ1bHbIX 111'1L1. a TaKJKe no 3ID1B..eHmO 111111
c cornacl'lSi rpaJKJlllH .nonycKaeTcSI npoBe-
IleHl'Ie OPM. orpaHWll1BafOilll1X KOHCTI'I-
TyLll10HHbie npaBa 11 cBo60llbi f))"UK,[IaH Ha
OCH()BaHI1I1 n()CTaHOBJIeHl'ISi. Y!1Iep;fjleH-
HOro pyKOOOllI1TeJ1e}.t (33M. pyKoOOllI1TeJ1IJ)
opraH:!. ocy!UeCTBI1J.llOmerO Opn., C 06!!3a-
TClIbHblM YOC!l()MlICHOCM npollypopa B Te-
'1eHI1el4'1 J63. leT. Il}
18
flpoikJu/ceHue ma6,1. 2
3
33110H YKpal1Hbl
,,06onepaTIfBHo-
P03b!CKHOii
lleHTel1bHOCTI1
3aKOH Pecny6l1l1KI'I
l)el1apycb
..06 onepaTIfBHO-
P03b!CKHOiJ
lleSlTeJ]bHOCTI1

2
B CJ1}"1!1r: B03HlfKHOReHI'ISI yrp03b1 )l(113HI1,
:mopOlJblO. co6CTBeHHOCTI1 OT.l\fJ1bHbIX
nMU C nMCbMeHHOrO cornaCMSI pa3pewa-
eTCSI npOCJlYWI1BaHl1e neperOBopOB. Be-
llYWI1XCSI C 11)( Te$OfiOB }]}II.] llpymx
neperOBopHblX ycrpoikTB H3 OCHOBBHIUJ
nOCT3HOElJleHl1fl. }fTeep)K)]eHHoro PYKOBO-
llTeJleM upraHB, ocyweCTBJ1S1IOIUerO OPn.,
c 06S13BTI:;JbHbIM YHellOI)1eHl1eM npOIlYpo-
paBTe4eH"e 24 '1('1. 6 CT. 12).
B C.IIY'U'lHX, He TepnSIllil'lx omarareJlbCTe 1'1
MOryll1l1X npi'lBeCTM II COBeprneH111O rep-
popl'lCTl1'JeClloro BKTa, lll'lBepC(J11 1f.DPY-
HIX TffiKKI1X npecrynJ1eHI1H H3 OCHOBaH(']l)
MOTl1lmpOlJaHHoro nOCTBHOBi1eHml 01lHO-
fO M3 PYKOBOllHTt'Qef1 uprm-la, oCYlUeCTB-
J]Jl}owero orn.. llonycKaeTcli npOBelleHlfe
OPM, nepe'llfCJleHHblX B n. 4 H3CTOSlWdi
naTb. C YBelloUleHl1eM npOK})JOpl. 11
[]()CJ1ellYIOWI1M nOJly'!elmeM CaI-JKUI1I1 B
Te'1eHl1e 24... (.. 7CT 12
B CJ1Y'J8J1X, IIOTQPble He TCpmlT 0T11ar8-
TenbCT03 11 MOryT npl1BeCTM K COElepllle-
HMIO Teppopl1CTlf'leCKOrO aJ<T3 If JIM 111'1-
DCpCI1I1. HB OCHOBaHm MOTHDl1pODaHHO-
fO nOCTaHORJ1eHIUl OllHoro 1f3 PYII()BOlll1-
TeJ1ef1 COOTBeTCTII)'IOwero opraH3, ocywe-
CTBJ1S1lOwerO opn. ll()nYCKaeTCSI npoEle-
lleHl1e OPM, nepe<lI1CJJeHHbIX B 'I 2 H3-
CTOllmeii CTBTblJ, C He3aMC;uuneJ1bHbIM
YBeJ1()M.CHI1CM COOTJJeTCTEylOlUcro npo-
Kypopa 11 n()CJ1CllYlOlUMM nOJl)"JClmCM
t:3HIIUMM B n'iCHMC 24 'i (OJ. 3 CT 9)
B CJ1Y4ae B03HMKHoeeHur yrp03bl >KM3HM,
3.Il0poBbJO, COOcTBCHHOCTM OTnCJlbHblX nlm
no I1X 3aSlBJ1CHI1IO MJlM C I1X nMCbMcHHOro
t:ornaCMSI pa3pClU3ercSi npocJlYWI1BaHife
neperOBOpOB, BCJ\Yl1!lnCSr C MX TeJ1eOHOB
1'IJ111 npyrl1x neperoBopHblX ycrpoJiCTB, Ha
OCH()BaHI1I1 n()CTaHOBJICHI'ISI. yYBCp)l(}]CH-
H()rO PYIlOBOIUIreJJCM opraHa, OCYWCCTB-
JISllOwero Opn., C 06S13.aTCJlbHbIM YBCJ\OM-
JICHI1CM COOTBCTCTByIOlUero npOKYpoP" e
TCllCHHe24 'l. 'i.4CT.9
19
npoi'Jo1;HCfflue ma6,1. 2
3
3alloH Pccny6J1MIIH
Ka3d.'<CffiH
..06 ()nepaTBHo-
P03b!CKHOH
lICSlTCJlbHOCTW>
3aKOH Kblprbl3cKofi
Pecny6J1MKM
..06 onepaTHBHo-
P03b!CKHOH
neSlTeJlbHOCTM

B CJ1Y'13HX, Tpe6YlOWl1X He33MellJ1I1Tenb-
HbIX JleHCTBI1f1, B LlelUIX npellOTBpaWe-
1-111.11 n()C.IIraTeJ1bCTB Ha Ba)KHbJe DJ1H ro-
CylWpcTBa I1HTepeCbl. TeppOpa 1'IJ111 aKTOB
,[(lfBepCU'l, y6HWCTB HJ111 HHblX nl>l<KHX
npecrynJ1eHI1H, 8 Tall)Ke B TOM I:J1Y48e.
Korn,a cyweCTBYeT peaJIbH8H yrpo3a >l<I1J-
HH. J1l0pOBblO I'IJIH C06CTBCHHOCTIJ nHLla
11J111 ero 6J11131111X pO!!CTBeHHI1KOH, YKa-
3aHHbJe B '1. 4 HacTO!lllleii CTaTbJ.1 Mepo-
npl1.llTJ.1H ()nepaTBH()k neHTeJlbH()CHI
MOTyr OCYllleCTBJ1HTb 6e3 C3HIIUl111 cy-
llbl1. 06 3TOM H Te'1eHl1e 24 '1 He06xo-
nl'lMO C006Wl1Tb npoKypopy. B Te'l.eHl1e
72 '1 - nOJI)"JI1Tb caHIILlHIO cynbH B npo-
TBHOM CJI}"13f' npOBeneHl1e Meponpl1H-
niti OnepaTHBH()A neHTeJlbHOCTH CJ1ellyeT
npeKp.TfHTb ('1.5 CT. 7)
B CJ1Y4ID1X. KOTOpbJe He TepmlT QTJl8ra-
TeJlbCTB H MOryT npHBeCTIJ K COBepWeHl11O
TS!)KlIoro npeCTyn;'JeHI1S1. Ha OCHOBaHI1I1
MOTI1BI1pOB3HHQro nOCT3H0BJ1eHI1J1 O.IJ.Horo
1-13 pyilOBollTeJIeH COOTBeTCTBylOwero op-
raHa. ()CYllieCTBJ1HlOwero Of'D. JlOnYCKa-
eTCSI npOBelleHHe Of'M C YBellOMJIeHl1eM
npo"-ypopa BTe"leHl1e 24'1 ('I 2c 8).
npl1 B03HI1KHOBeHI1I1 yrp03bl >l<1I3HI1.
J1l0pOBblO. co6cTBeHH()CTH ()TJleJIbHbIX
JlI'IU IJO I1X 33HflJleHHIO HJlI1 C I1X nHCb-
MeHHoro COrJliiCIHI pa3pewaeTCH IJPOCJ1Y-
WI1B"Hl1e neperoBopoB, BellYWI'IXCSI C I1X
TCJ1C!»OHOB I1J1H JlPymx nepeToBopHbIX
YCTPOHCTB, H8 OCHOBaHlUI nOCTIlHOBl1e-
HI1J1. yrBep)K[LeHHoro pyKooomrre.neM op-
TaHa. ocy1UeCTBI1HlOlUeTO OPlJ" C npelloa-
pl'lTC:JIbHblM YBellOMJ1eHl1eM npoKypopa
(OJ. 3 CT. 8)
20
llpooo,J;JKeHuema6il.2
33KOH
J18TBl1i1cK0i1
Pecny6J1HKIJ
..06 ()nepaTHBH()W
lIeSlTeJIbHOCTH
3aKOH Pecny6J1I1KI1
MOJ\llolJa ,,06 one-
p3TI1BH()-P03bICKHOJi
lIt:S1TeJ1bHOCTW>

llpooo,J;JKeHuema6il.2
I 2 3
3.3. B CaJ-JKUI'IM cynbl1 HeT He06xonl1M() 3aKOHJII1TOBCKOf!
CTI'I npl1 npOBeJleHl111 ocoooro emta Me- PecnyOJ1I'1HJ «06
ponpMSlTl'lif onepaTI'IBHOH lleJlH:J1bHOCTIII OnepaTI'IBHoi1 neH-
npoTi'm 3a.nep;j(aHHblx, OOBI1HSleMb[x, co- TeJlbHOCTI1»
CTOHIJ.!I'IX nOll CYliOM 1'1 OCYJK,L\eHHbIX JU'1U
6 n()MeIUeHI1HX cy6"beKTOB ()nepaTI'IBHoti
neSlTeJ1bHOCT MJlI'I neHI'ITeHUI'IOpHblX Y'l-
peJK,L\eHMif. . TaK;j(e , CJlyqaJlX. lIor.ua
cy6"beKT ()nepaTI1IIHOn llCSlTeJ1bHOCTI'I ,
COQTBeTCTBIJM C nl'lCbMeHHblM 3<lHBJ1eHMeM
KOHllpeTH()rO 11MLIiI npoCJ1ywMBaeT pa3ro-
Bopb[ lToro nmrn ('I. 2 CT. 176.1 YrOJlOB-
Ho-npouecCY3l1bHoro IIOllCKca 11I'1TBbl)
3A. OpraHbl. OCYlJ.!ecmnmOlJ.!l'Ie OPlJ, JUIJI 4IellepanbHbIA3aKoH
pelUeHI1S1 JaJIa'I. B03J1();j(eHHblX "' ""' ,,06onepaTI'IBHo-
$eJlepa.'IbHblM 3aKOHOM. MOryr C03JIaBaTb P03b!CKHOH
1'1 I1CnOJIb30BaTb MH$opM8UI10HHble CI1C- neSlTeJlbH()CTM»
TeMbl(oOJ. I CT. 10)
OnepaTHBHble n()lJflaJ1leQeHI1H ill" Bb[- 3aKoH YKpal1Hbl
nOJIHeHI1J1 3arra'l OPlJ,. npl'l HaJll'I<J1111 YC- ,,06onepaTI'IBHo-
11081'1", npellYCJ.IQTpeHHbiX CT 63aKOHa pOJbICIlHOifllel1-
05 OPD. BnpaBe COJ.QaBaTb 11 npMMeHJlTb TeJIbHOCTM»
BBTOMBTl131'1pOBaHHble I'IH$OpMOUI'IOHHble
CMCTeMbI (n. 17cT 8)
Bxolle npOBelleHMJI OPM I1Cn()JIbJyIOTCSI 3aKoH PecnyfuJl1KI'I
I'IHl)JopmL[l10HHble CI'ICTeMbl, K010pble l)eJlOpycb
opr:JHbl, OcyilleCTBJ1l1lOlJ.!l'Ie OPD. Bnpafle ,,060nepanJBHo-
COJJIaBaTb B I1HTepec.:l1C: ()oeCne'leHMJI pe- pOJbICKH()f!AeJl-
lUeH1'I1131\J14'1 OPlJ,('I. JCT. 14) TeJlbHOCTI'I»
np" flbmO;JHeHI'lIf '",,"" QPIl opraHbI. 3alloH PecnyOJ11'11111
yn()JIH()MO'leHHble ee ocyweCTBJ1J1Tb, I1Me- Ka3a1[CT.1H
w, npaBO C03JIBBaTb " I'ICnO;Jb30BaTb ,,06onepaTI'IBHO-
onepaTMBHb[e Y'JeTb[ 1'1 MH4JopM:JUI10HHble P03b[CKHoi'lnCI1-
CI'ICTeMbI, ()oeCne'lI1BalOIJ.!Ife peWeHl'Ie TeJlbHOCTW>
3JJ1H'IOPlJ,(n "B»'I I CT. 8)
21

OpraHbI, OCyJJ.J,eCTBJUllOlJ.!l1e OPll, WIl1
peWeHI1.11 3M3'!. BQ3JlOJKeHHb!X Ha HI1X
HacroSlWI1M 3aKOHOM. Moryr C0311aBaTb H
HCn0.l1b30BaTb HHIJIOpMaUHOHHble CHCTe-
MbI('J I CT, 13)
Y'ipe)lQ1eHH.II OnepanJBHoi1 AeJlTeJ1bHOCTI'I
npaBQMO'iHb! ocyweCT!!JUITb c60p. CI1CTe-
MaT113aul'llO. aHaJlH3. xpaHeHHe H }"leT
O.pI1UHa'lbHOii. J1era.'IbHoii 11 CeKpCTHOH
I'IHIJIOpJaUHH 0 J1I'1Uf1X. IJI"KTaX. C06b1TI'ISIX
1'1 AenaX (naCCHBHaSi 1JI0pMa Y'1eTa), He06-
XOllHMOii 11 I1MelOlJ.!eii 3Ha'JeH(je J1)1S1 Bbl-
n()J]HeHHSI 3M3'1 OnepaTI'IBHoti AeSlTeJ1b-
HOCTI1 11 yrOJloBHOro npOLlCCCa. CTaBI1Tb
Ha OnepaTI1BHblH Y'1eT (aKTI1BHaSi lJIopMa
Y'JeTa) rpaJK,JJ,aH J]aTBMi1cKOi1 Pecny6J1MIIH
paJpeWeHO TOJlbKO H TOM CJ1}f'ffie, ec.rm
no OTH()UJCHMIO II HMM npOBOlll1TCSI ()ne-
paTI1BHaSlpa3pa601Ka ('I. I CT. 23).
Cyfu.eKTbI onep;rnuJHoi1 .neSlTeJlbHOCTI1
o6S13aHbl c06l1paTb, HaKanJlMBaTb, aHaJll1-
311poBaTb M pC:aJlH30Bb1BaTb MHlJlop"Ja-
UI1IO. cBSl3aHHYlO C rocynapCTBeHHOt!
6e30naCHOCTbIO. co clJlepoi1 H MH<f1pa-
cTpyKTypoii npecTynHOCTI1.
Cy6'beKTbl OnepaTI'IBHoti .neSlTeJ1bH()CTI'I
BnpaBC: BeCTM OnepaTI'IBHbli1 Y'1eT npoMc-
lUeCTBl1ii. 4>aKToB, npeAMeTOB. npyri1x
I'ICT0'1HI1110D I1HI!:J0pMaUI'II1, 4>11311'JCCIII1X
11 IOpl11ll1'JecKl'lx .I1MU (a63. 6 'I. 2 CT. 6)
OpraHbl ynOJlHOMO'1eHHble OCYIlleCTB-
.I1S1Tb OPll. BnpaDe C0311aDaTb 11 I1CnOJlb-
30BaTb I1HI!:J0PM:U.[I10HHble CI1CTeMbl.
()6ecne<II1BalOlJ.!l'Ie peWeHl1e opn (a63. ..c»
'J.ICTIJ)
22
llpooo,J;JKeHuema6il.2
3mWH Kblprb!3CKOH
Pecny6J1MKI'I
..06 OnepaTI'IBHO-
P03bICIlHOifLleSl-
TeJlbHOCTM»
3aKOH
J]aTBllliiclIOii
Pecny6J1MKI1
..06 onepaTI1RHoif
lIeHTe.l1bHOCTI1»
3HKOH J]MTOBCKOH
Pecny6J1MIII1 «06
onepaTHBHoHlICH-
TMbHOCTI1»
3aKOH Pcny6J1I1KH
M().I1l1()Ba,,06one-
paTI1HHO-p03b1CKHOH
lIeSlTe.l1bHOCTM»

3_5. OpraHbl, QCYIl.lecTBJ1J1lOllWIe OPll.
llIISi pClUeHIiJl 33J1a'J B03J1Q)I(CHHblX H8
HIiX (])t:!!epanbHbI},t 381<0HOM, MOryr 38ao-
HI'ITb HeJla onepaTI1BH()ro Y'leT8 (a63 I
CT. 10)
!lena onepaTIiBH()rO }".reT8 38BOllJlTC.II npH
HaJll1'1l1l1 OCH()BaHI1f1, npe.ll.}'CMOl'peHHbIX
n. 1-6'1. I CT. 7 H8CTOSlIUero (])ellepanb-
HOro 3allOtffl, B uenJlx C061'1paHMJI 11 CMC-
TeMaTlUaUMM caelleHMw, npORepllM 1'1
OlleHIlM pe3YJ1bTaTOB OP!l, H TBK)Ke npl1-
HIHIIIJI HB I1X OCHOBe COOTBeTCTBYlOlUl1X
pelUeHl1ll ClpraH8MI1, QCYllleCTRJ1J1IOIJ.!I1MM
OP!l(a63. 2 CT. 10).
(])aKT 3aBe1leHI1.1111eJla onepaTBHoro Y'I.e-
T3 He JlM.IIeTCSI OCHOB8HI1eM .DJIJI Orp"HI1-
'IeHI1J1 KOHCTI1TYUl10HHbIX np8B 11 CB06011,
a Tal()Ke JaKOHHblX I1HTepeCOB 'teJlOBeKa 1'1
rpa*1l8HI1Ha(a63. 3 CT. 10).
!leno OnepaTI'IBHOrO Y'IeTa npeKpalU8eTCSI
D cJI)"JaSiX pelUeHMJI KOHKPCTHblX JallB'J
OP!l, n(XllYCMOl'peHHbIX CT. 2 tfflCTOSllJ.!e-
ro (])ellepanbHoro 3aKOHH, H THICKe YCTH-
HOIL"1eHI1J1 06CTOIITCJ1bCTR, CBl1lleTeJlbCT-
BYIOIUI1X 06 06beKTI1BHOfi HeB03MO)KHO-
CTpelUeHI1J13TJJX33J1a'J (a63. 4 CT. 10)
OpraHbl, ocyweCTMJlIOIJ.!(fe OP!l, /lJIJI
pelUeHI1J1 33J1a'J, B03J10)KeHHblX HHCJOJl-
IUI1M 3allOHOM, Moryr 3BaOlll1Tb l(ena
onepaTI1BHoro Y4em ('I I CT. 13).
!lena onepaTMBH()rO }"IeJa 3aBOllSlTCJI npH
H8]1I1'J1111 OCHORBHI1W, npel!YCMOl'peHHbIX
n. 1-6'l leT 8 HHcTOSIlUer03allOH8, B
uenJlx C0611pBHliJl 11 CliCTeMBTI13BUl11i
coelleHIii1, npOBepKI'I M OueHKI1 pe3ynb-
TaTOB OP!l, a Tal()Ke npMHJlTI'IJI Ha I1X
()CH()Be COOTEeTCTByiOIUI1X pelUel-1I1f1 op-
raHaMM, oCYIlIecTBJlJliOlUl'IMI'I opn ('t 2
CT. 13)
23
llpooo,J;JKeHuema6il.2
(])el!epanbHblll
3aKOH
«06 onepaTBHo-
P03b!CKH0i1
neSlTeJlbH()CTMt>
3aKOH Kblprb!3CKofi
Pecny6J1I1I1M
«06 OnepaTBHO-
P03bICKHOWllCJI-
TCJlbHOCJW>

npoiJotlJK:eHUe maM. 2
 - 2 3
B K<UIUI,O\l I:11Y4ae HiU1I1'1I1J1 OCHOBaHI1M 3allOH YKpal1Hbl
MJI npOBelleHI1}1 OPlI, 3"BOllHTCH onepa- «060nepanIBHO-
TBHO-pOJbICIIH()e Ae11() nOCTBHOBJ1eHl1e p03bICKHOtil!f:JI-
o JBBelleHl111 Talloro lle11a nOllJ1e.>KI1T yr- TenbHOCTW>
Bep)l(J{eH111O H!1'IiU1bHMKOM OB11, H8U110-
HaJ1bHOti 6e30nOCH()CTH, n()rpaHI1'1HblX
BOt!CK, oxpaHbI Bb!CWI1X ll()J1.>KH()CTHbiX
JIl1u(a63. 1 CT. 9).
Ha 6e3 Becnl nponBBwee JII1UO, nO.1\03-
peaBeMoe B nOllroToBKe I1J1M COBepWeHl111
npecrynJleHI1J1. CKpbIBalOlueeCSI ()T ()pra-
H()B paccnell()BBHI1J1 111111 YKJlOHSIlOweecSi
 orobIBBHI1J1 yr011OBHOro Halla3aHI1H.
BelleTC.!I TOJ1bKO OllH() ()nepaTI1BHO-
pOJblCIlHOe lleJ1(). EC!111 B TC'leHl1e weCTH
f,leCHueE\ He YCTaHOBJ1eHbl lI3HHble. yf(a-
3blBalOIl.!l1e H8 npM3Halll1 npeCT)'lU1eHI1J1 B
Ilet!CTBI1J1X JlI1U3. B ()THOWeHI1I1 KOToporo
ocywecTBJlHJJI1Cb OPM, TaKOe lleJl() nOll-
JIe)KI1T YHI1'1TOJKeHmO (a63. ] CT. 9).
npl1 npOBeplle JlI1U B CBHJI1 C I1X .Donyc-
KOM K rocy.napcTBeHHoH. BoeHHOH 11 cny-
.>Ke6H()j:j TaHHaM onepanIBH()-pOJblCKH()e
IleJ1()He 3BBOlII1TCSI (863. 4CT 9)
OnepaTI'IBHaJi npOBepKa npoBOJJHTCJl , 3aKoH Pecny6.r1I1KI1
paJpeWeHI1J1 " non KOHTpOJIe"l PYIIOBO- EieJIapycb
IlI'lTeJ1J1 (JaM PYIlOBOllI1Te11J1) opraHB. ee «06 onepaTBHO-
ocyweCTBJHllOllIero. Pe3YJlbT8TbI npol1e- P03blcIlHOHAeJl-
neHHblX OPM ()Tpa)K3IOTCSI B OnepaTlIB- TenbHOCTI1
HOooCJIYJKe6HbiX DOKYMeHTax 1'1 CIlCTeMaTIt-
31tpy1OTCH(a63 (cr. 10)
OnepaTI1BH0-cJ1}'}Ke6Hble .1\OXYMeHTbl DOJI-
.>KHbI 6blTb npellCTaBlleHbI npOKypopy npM
()cywecTBlIeHI1I1 HMJopa I'IJII'I llJI.!I n()J1Y-
'1eHl1J1 CaHKUl111 "' npOBeneHl1e OPM
(a63. 2 CT. 10)
24

2
npouece ()neparHBH()A neSlTCJlbH()CTI'I
3TO BCC MCpOnpl'lHTlUI. npooolUl"lble
1l0n)KHOCTHbIMH 1U1U3MH cy6'beIlTOa one-
paTHBHoi1 lleITeJ1bHOCnl B yCTaHOBJ1CH-
HOM nup$lllKc. nOllo6Hble nei1cTBIUI 1'1
PC3YJlbTaTbi IJJI1KCl'lpylOTCH B CJ1Y)Ke6Hb!X
1I0KYMcHTax, Ha Koropblc pacnpocrpaHR-
eTCSI PC)!(HM crpororo}f'1eT8('I. 1 CT. 18)_
npollecc onepaTBHoi1 neSi-reJ1bHOCT MO-
)KeT Ha"IaTbCH ll() OOJ6yJK1ll'HI'IS! yrOJl()BHOro
Hena. ()H MOJKeT npoxOllTb BO BpeMSI CJ1C!l-
:IJ !r:=HC:'I 1nllf:)aTb-
..OnepaTBHbIM poJbICKOM C'II1TaeTC.II co-
BOK)'nHOCTb lICi1CTBI'I. He lpc6yJOwI'IX
CaHIIUI'IH reJiCpaJ1bHOrO npoll)'pOpB I1JJtI
:mMCl1[alOwero era lUn!a. B UeJ]RX peaJ1I13a-
U11 nepBHIJ:Hoi1 I1HlJlopMaUl'll1 0 npecryn-
nCH"'''' 1'1 npeCT)'nHOH neSlTe;'JbHOCTH (n 9
'I. 2 nOCraHOBJiCHmr Bcpxomroro CODeTa
J]I1TOBCIIOH PecnyfuJHKH ..0 BBt:J\CHloWl B
.neikTBI1C 3aKOHa JIHTOBCKOH: Pecny6f1HKH
ooonepaTI'IBH()H:llCSlTCJ1bHOCTI'I»)
..OnepaTI'IBHoe pacc.IIl'll()B:HI'IC" RBJ1S1CTCSI
opraH113allOHHO TaKT'1eClIoj:j lJIopMOi1
.uCATeJ1bHOCTIJ. OUl'lTI.lBalOllleti onepmlB-
Hbte nCHCTBJIJI npoHI1KaJOlUcro xapa"Tepa
(n. 11 'I 2 nOCraHOBJ1CHHSI Bepxt.1BH()rO
CODeTa JlI'lTOBCIWi1 Pecny6f1HIII'I ..0 OOCllC-
HHC B J{CiiCTBIIIC 3mmHa JIHTOBCKOfl Pec-
mful1KI1 06 oneo.rrHHHOH .neSlTeJlhHOCTI1»
npUHaJ1l1'IHI1 OCHOBaHI1H, HHblX
7 3aKOHa 06 OPll, OpraHhl, ocywecre-
JISilOlllHe OPll, BnpaBe npollQ!lJfTh onepaTIfB-
HYJO nporepKY. (fJaKT ee IlpOB{:/:t"HIffi nQ/U1e-
)IHIT06snaTeJ1bHoHpeIlIC1]XIU.I1lt(<J. I cr. 9).
OnepaTI1BHa npoBepKa npollOllHTC C
C3HIIUHH H nOli IIOHTpOJ1eM pyKOROlWlTe-
JI OCYllleCTBJ1lOl1!ero ee op.-aHa Pe3}'J1b-
Tanl OPM Orpa>KaIOTC B onepaTBHo-
CJ1y)t;;e6Hblx nOKYMeHTax 11 Cl'ICTeMaTH311-
PYIOTC ('I 2 cr 9)
OneparnBHO-CJIYXelJHh!e 1l0K}'MeHTbi !lOi1)t;;-
Hhl 6bJTb npencr..B.IleHb! npoKypoPY np
IIC'Ipe6oo.aHHl'I CaHKUHI1 Ha npOBelleHl1e
OPM 'I3cr.9
25
flpoi'Xn;JKeHue maM. 2
3aIlOHJ]aTBHHCKOii
Pecny6J1HKI1
..06onepaTHBH()H
neSlTei1hH()CTW'
3"KOHlII1TOBCKOk
Pecny6J1HIII1 ..06
OnepaTI1BHOHneH-
TeJ1bHOCTH
.:SaKOH Pecny6J1I1KI'I
MOJl!108a ..06 one-
paTHBHO-P03b1CKHOH
.neSlTei1hHOCTH

2
3.6. CBelleHmr ()6 I1CIlUJIb3}'t'MblX 111111 l'IC
nOJlbJ()BJ.HHbJX npl1 npOBelleHl11{ Hernac-
HblX OPM CI'I;'JaX, cpellCTB<lX. I1CTO'IHI1KaX,
MeTO!JaX, I1JJaHax 1'1 pe3YJ1bTaTaX OP.ll, 0
]]mwx. BHe.a.peHHbIX B upraHI'IJOBaHHble
npeCl)'nHble rpynnbl, 0 LUTIlTHblX HerJ1aC-
HblX COTpylIHI11\.)1I: ()praHOB, OCYilleCTB-
J1J1IOLUIJX OPD., 1'1 0 J1I'lUax, OKa3bIBaIOUlI'IX
)'1M COlieticTBH!: fi3 IWH$H..IJ.eHUI18J1bHOi1
OCHOBe, a TIlIOKe 06 opram'lJamm 1'1 () TaK-
TlIe npOHelleHmr OPM COCTaWUlIOT rocy-
lIapCTBeHH}'KI Tai1HY 11 nOl1.l1e)l(aT pacceK-
pe'lI'lBaHl'1l0 TOJlbKO Ha aCHOBe nocraHoB-
JIeHmr pyKOBOIU!TI:1]JI opraH:!, OCVll\eCTB-
milome.-oOPLl a63. I CT. 11
OpraHI1JaUl1fr 1'1 TaKTHKa npOBeneHI'IJI
OPM cocraBJUIlOT rocynapcTBeHHYJO TaA-
Hy(a63. 7 CT. 5)
OpraHHJaUI1J1 1'1 TIlIITKa npOlleHI1J1
HenlaCHblX OPM MOryr COcr3BJIJlTb CJ1y-
JKe6HYlO, eoeHHYIO n:II1 rOCYJJ.aPCTBeHH}'1O
TaMHY B COOTBeTCTBI1I1 C nepe<JHeM cae-
lleHHi1, nOlU1e>KalJ.!l1X JJCeKpe'lI1B3HI1IO.
YTBepJKJJ,aeMbIX Ka6HHerOM MI1HI1CTpOB
Pecny6JJI1KI'I Ka3aXCT1'IH Ha OCHoee 3aKO-
Hit 0 38I1lI1Te .-ocYlIapCTBeHHblx ceKperOB
PeCnV6J1I1KI1 Ka3dCTaH (n. 9 CT. 12
CBelleHI'IJI 06 I1cnOJlb3yeMblx 111111 I'ICnO!1b
JOBaHHblX npH np()BelleHIfI'l Her.nacHbiX
OPM CIDJax, . I'ICTO'IHI1KaX, Me-
T01U\X, ruJaHax 11 pe3YJ1bTaTax OPlI:, () 111'1-
uax. BHelIPeHHblx II opraHI130BaHHble npe-
Cl)'nHble rpynnbl. 0 lliTaTHb!X HemacHblx
C01pYIDiI'lKaX opraHolI, ocyweCTBJ1J1IOWX
OPlI:, 11 0 11l'1uaX. OKa3bIBat01ll1f1( 11M COllCH-
CTRl'le tfa 1I0H<1>lleHUI'I.3.!1bHOii OCHORe. a
TaKJKe 06 opraHI13aUI'lI1 1'1 0 TaKTIJKe npo-
BelleHI1S1 OPM COCTaI!J1J1IQT rocynapCTReIj-
HYIO TaHHY 11 no.r:Ull paccellpe41'1BaHl'lIO
TOlIbKO H3 OCHoae nOCTdHOl!J1eHI1S1 pYKOBO-
.nTeJlIl. opraHa, OCYl.lIeCTBJHllOl.lIerO OPlI:, II
=TfT;:C 1:0 Kblp-
26
flpOOOAJK:f?HUe maoil. 2
3
aJ1bHbltl3aKoH
06 onej)<lTHBHo-
P03b!CKHOI:!
.neSlTeJlbH()CTI'I&
3aKOH PecnyfuJl1KH
EieJlapycb
..06 onej)<lTHBHo-
P03bICKH()HAeJl-
TeJlbHOCTI'I»
3aKOH PecnyfuJl1KH
Ka3axcT3H
,,06 onepaTBHO-
P03blcKHoHlleSl-
Te.n:bHOCTI'I
3aKOH Kblprb!3CKoti
PecnyfuJl'IKI'I
06 OnepaTI'IBHO-
P03bICKH()HAeSl-
TeJlbHOCTI'I&

OKOH'lOHUf! maM. 2
2
OpraH'I3aUI1J1, MeTOlll1Ka 11 TaIlTI1Ka Me-
pOnpl1S1TI1H onepaTHBHoti AeJlTeJlbHOCTI'I
JlBJlJlJOTCSI cnyAe6Hon TaHH()n ('I.. 3 CT. 8)
3
33KOH
J1aTBI'IHCKOn
Pecny6JJ11111i
06 onepanlBHOH
.ueSlTeJ1bHOCTI1
4IepanbHb!H3aIlOH
06 ()nepaTBHO-
pOJbICKHOnAeJl-
TeJlbHOCTW>
3,7. npellaHl1e fJlaCHOCTIII C13elleHl1if 0
nl1l[aX, 13HellpeHHblX 13 OpraHI130lJ.aHHbie
npeCTynHb]e rpynnbl. 0 WT3THbiX Hernac-
lib]X COTpyllHI1Kax oprat-1OB, ocywecTB-
nmOWl1x opn. 11 0 nl1U3X, OK33blRaIQWl1X
11M COlleHCTBlie Ha KOHIPI{lICHUHaJ1bHOH
OCHOBe. nonycKaeTCJI nl1Wb C I1X c()rna-
CI1J1 e nl1CbMeHHOH IPopMe 11 B CJlY<JRIIX,
npellYCMOTpeHHblX IPeliepanbHblMI1 33KO-
HaMH (1363 2CT 12)
CYlIe6Hoe peWeHl1e Ha npaBO npOBelIe-
HI1J1 OPM 1'1 MaTepHaJ1b!. nocn}')K1'IBW1'Ie
OCHOBaHl'IeM J]JIJI npl'lHJlTI'ISI: TaKoro pe-
weHl'ISi. XpaHJlTCJI TOJ1bKO B opraHaX.
ocywecTBJlSl:IOWIiX opn (a63 3 CT. 12)
OneparnlJHO-<JJ)')KC6HbleDOK}'\lel-ITbi. mpa-
)KalOWl1e peayl1bTaTbI opn, MOryr 6blTb
npellCT3B11eHbI opraHY ll03HaHI1J1, CJ1ellO-
BaTeJlJO. CYlIbe. DPyrl'lM opraHaM. ocywe-
CTB11J1JOWHM opn, B nopmure 11 C11}"IaSiX.
YCTaH()BJ1eHHbJM HaCTOSl:WHM 4Iellepanb-
HblM 3aKOH01>l (a63. 4 CT. 11)
nOnO)KeHI'IH. KacalOwliecH YCJ10BHIi npoBe)J,t'HI1H OnepaTHBHO-paJbICK-
IIblxMeponpHSlTliit. npellYclllaTJIIIBaIOTCJ1ellYIOWlieCTaTbliJaKOHOB,
CT3ThIi 8, 10. 12 4IeJ.IepalbHoro 3<1KOHa ..06 OneparI1BHo-poJbICKHOH
.neSlTeJ1bHOCTI1".
CTaTbl'l 9, 10. 14 3aKoHa Pecny6JJI'IKH EieJ1apycb 06 OnepaTI1BHO-
P03bICIIH()HneSl:TeJlbHOCTH"
CTBTbI1 8. 12 3aKOHa Pecny5J11'1111i Ka:iaxcroH .Q6 onepaTHBH()-
P03blCilHOH l!CSl:TeJ1bHOCTI1".
CTaTbl1 7, 8, 9, 10, 13 33110Ha Kblprbl3clloit PecnyUJll1l111 ..06 one-
paTI'IBHO-p03bICKH()H neSlTeJ1bH()CTI'I".
CTBTbI1 2. 4. 7. 8. 18 3aKoHa J1aTBIiHcKOH Pecny5J1I1KI'I ..06onepa-
TI1BHOHlIeSlTeJlbHOcTW>.
27

npouecc OnepanlBHO lIe}lTeJlbHOCTI1 MMeeT cnellYlOll.lMe CTanI'lM:
I) onep3TBHoe paccne;WBaHMe (CT. 9, 20);
2) OnepaTI1f1Hali npoflqJl<3 (CT. 21),
3) onepaTBH311 pa3pa6OTKa (CT 22)
CntTbSl 9. OnepaTl'lBH()e paCCJ1ellOBaHMe «()nepaTMBHbl ()npoc, one-
paTI'IBHOe l103HaHl'le, ()nepaTI1BHOe BblllcHeHMe).
OnepaTMBHoe paCCJ1!:.1I0BaHMe npellCTlIBJ1J1eT c06o OTKpblT)'1O MJlM
3aMacllMpoB3HHYlO lIeSlbHOCTb lI0Jl>KHOCTHbrx J1I1U cy6beKToB onepa-
TI'IBHOH lIeSlTeJlbHOCTl'I, B xOlle KOTOpOH npl'l nOMOlUl'I ()nepaTMBH()ro
()npOC1I, OnepaTI'IBH()fO 1I03H3HI111 1'1 onepaTHBHoro BblllCHeHl'Ili c06l'1pa-
eTCII I'IH4IopMaUI111 0 <f.>a"T3X, J1l'1uax 11... onepaTI1BHOH lIeHTeJlbHOCTl1, B
XO.!le IIOTOpOH npM nO"IOUlM onepllTMflHoro onpoclI. onepllTMflHOro 1103-
HaHl'Ili M onepaTMBHoro BblliCHCHMII C061'1pi}CTC11 I'IH<f1opMaUI111 0 $u.aax,
Jll'luax I'IlleJIaX.
OnepaTBHbI ()npoc npOl'l311Ol1HTbC11 nyreM onpoca J1I'1U 06 MHTC-
pecylOll.lMX cy6t.eKT"x onepaTHBHoi1 neUeJ1bHOCTM <f.>aKT"X.
QnepaTMBHoe n03HaHMe OCYllleCTBJ1J1eTCSI nyreM c60pa MH$OpMaUMM
() KOHKpeTHbrX Jll'luax. OnepaTHBHoe Bbl11CHeHl1e OC}'lllCCTBJllleTCII nyreM
n()J]}f'reHl'Ili I1H4IopMaUMI'I ()T J1I1U, eCJ1M eCTb OCH()BaHI1S1 nOJlaraTb. 'lTO
AaHHaJl I1H4IopMawm I1MeeTCII e pacnopSl)l(eHl'I11 COOTEeTCTIIytOUlMX JlI'IU.
HO OHM He )I(CJliilOT npellocraBMTb ee HenocpetlCTBeHHO.
CT3TbSl 20. Onep3THBHOC pacCJ1eJ!OB3HMe.
OnepaTfI1ioe pacCJ1CJlOBllHl'le IIBJlIICTCSI lIellTeJlbHOCTblO 1I0Jl>KHOCT-
HblX 'JI'IU Cy6beKTOB ()nepantBH() lIeSiTenbHOCTI1 B ueJlSlx nOJlY4eHI1S1
()60CH()B"HI111 Mil fJalJaJllI onepaTliBHoi1 npOBepKI'I I1nl1 OnepaTI'IBH()
pnpa60TKM
B npoueccc onepanlBHoro pacCJ1eJ!OB3HMJI MOryr npOB01lMTbCSI Me-
pOnpMJlTHli oncpaTMBHOH lIeSlTCJ1bHOCTI'I. ynoMIIHyrbre II CT 9, II, 131'1
'l I CT 16 HaCTOSiUlero 3allOH1I B XOile onepanJBHOfO pacCJleil()BaHI111
.Dru])KHbl C06J1IO.DaTbCII 'lpe60BaHIJII, ynoM.IIHyrble B It. 2 CT. 7 HacTO!'IllIe-
r03aKOHR.
CTaTbSl 21. OnepanlBHRSI npOHepKa
Cy6beIlT OnepaTI'IBHOH lIeSlTeJlbHOCTH II COOTBeTC1BI'II'I C() CBOI1MI1
JalJa'IaMI'I 11 cBoeH KOMneTeHWJeH npl1 npOBelleHl111 yn()MIIHyrblx B CT 6
HacTOSlll.!erO 3aKOHa MepOnpmlTM MO)l(eT npOlJ01ll'lTb onepaTMBHYIO
npOBcpIlYCQ(JmI:T(:myIOIJ.!Mx$aKTOB.
OnepaTMflHaSl npOflepJ<a Ha'lMHaeTCSI C ClIHIlUMOHMpOBlIHHOro PYIIO-
B01lrrreQeM Y<Jpe)!(JIeHMJI onepaTMBHoti lIeSlTeJ1bHOCTM nOCTaHOBJ1eHMJI M
()cyllleCTBJ111eTC.II n()ll ero KOHTpOJleM. n() Ka)!(JI()H OnepaTI'IBH()H npo-
BepKC lIOJl>KHO 6b11b BOJt'iVA<LleH() lIeJlO 06 onepaTMBH()H npOBtplle CpOIl
.!leJlonpOMJBOilCTB3 no 3TM .!leJlID.1 COCTlIBJ1J1eT 2 MecSlua. OH MO)l(eT
28

6bITb npO!lJ1CH C C3HKLlIH1 PYKOBOlll1TeJUI Y'1peJK.ltCHI1S1 Onep3TI1BHOH
AC.!!TeJ1bHOCTI'I
nOplilIOK ()nepan1BH()H npOBepKI'I YCT3HaBJU'lBaeT PYKOBOlll'lTeJlb )"J-
PC)!(1!eHI1J1 onepaTBHoli .DeSlTeJlbHOCTI1
OCHOB3HI1eM JJ,J1J1 HB'IaJ1a OnepBTI1BHOli npOBCpKI'I MO)KeT 6bJTb 11
peWeHl1e KOMnCTeHTHOrO .nOI1>KH()CTH()ro JlI1U2 () Ha'laJlC paCC.I1ellOBa-
HI1J1 B YCTaH()BJ1CHH()M YrOJl()BHO-npOueCcyaJ1bHbIM IIOllCIIC()M J]aTBI'II'I
nOpSlllKC.
CTaTb.!! 22. OnCpaTI'IBHa.!! pa3pa60TKa.
ECJ11'1 B paCn()pSl>KeHl'le cy5bellTa ()nCpaTI1BHOIi lleSlTeJ1bHOCTI'I
I'IMCCTCSI I1H4JOPM3UI'II'I () KOHllpCTHblX J1l1uax (II TOM '{I1CJ1e nOJlY'1CH-
HIISI 11 B pe3YllbTBTC onCpBTI1BHOfi npOBCpKI1), 1I8101lI8J1 1IOCH1TO'lHOC
()CHOBaHI1C lIJlSI n()1I()3peHI1S1 3H!X JlI1U B n()llrOTOBKe 11./11'1 COBepWC-
HI1I'1 npccTynJlcHI1S1 1'IJ11'1 nOCJlr8TCJlbCTBa Ha Ba)KHble JJ,J1J1 rocynapCTDa
I1HTCpeCbl, 111160 OHI1 pB3bICKI1BaIQTCJI 38 COBepWeHHoe npecTynne-
Hl1e, no OTHOIllCHI1IO K 3TI1M JlI1l!8M D,O./IJKH8 6blTb HB'1BT8 OnepaTl1B-
HaS! pa3pa6OTKa
OnepaTI1I1H8S1 pa3pa6on;a Ha'1I1HBeTCJI C npl1HJlTI1J1 pellleHI1S1, caHK-
Lll1oHl1pyeMoro pyKOlI01IrrreneM Y4pC)[(J\eHI1S1 oneparl1BHofi lICSlTCJ1bHO-
CTI'I 06 3TOM CTaBI1TCH B 113BeCTHOCTb npoKYpoP npH ()nepaTI1BHOfi
pa3pa6OTKe 1I0.l1JKH() 6b1Tb B03GY)KJ}CHO ACJI() 06 oncpaTBHoH pa3pa6oT-
lie, II 1I11l!8, no OTHoweH1'l1O K KOTOpblM npOBOlll1TCH onepaTI'IEII'I8J1 paJ-
pa6OTKa, n()JJ,J1C>KaT nOCTaHOBKe HB ()nepBTI'IBHbIH Y'1CT. B npoucccc
()neparI'lBH()H pa3JJ36oTKH M()ryr 6bITb I1Cn0.l1b30BaHbi ./I1Q5b!C I'IJ YKa-
JaHHblX II CT 6 HBCroHwcro 3aKoHII MCpOnpl'lS!TI1H OnCpaTI1BHOH llCSI-
TeJ1bHOCTI1 11 J11Q60fi 113 ynOMSlHyrblX B CT. 7 BI'Ill npOBtlIeHI1S1 3TI1X Me-
pOnpl1J1THH.
CpOIl onepaTMDHoH pa3pa50TIII1 n() 3THM ACJlaM C()CTaDJlS! weCTb
MeCJlUCB, OH MO)!(!:T 6b1Tb npO!lJ1eH eme HB weCTb MeCSILleB C CaHKUl111
pyKOB01ll1Te./IfI )"JPC)!(J[CHI1S1 OnCpaTrIBHoi1 .ncsne./IbHOCTI1 nOBTopHoe
npO!lJ1CHI1C cpoKa B03M())!(H() TOJlbKO C CaHKUl111 reHCpaJ1bHOrO npoKY-
popa I'IJlI'I CnCUI'laJ1bHO yn()J]HOMO'leHH()rO 11M npollypopa, HO He 60J1ce
'1CM Ha cpOK 1IaBHOCTI1 Toro npecrynJ1eHI1S1, B CBSl3rI C KOTOpbIM npOBo-
AMTC.!! onepaTHBHaH pa3pa60TKa.
CTaTbl1 8, 9 3all()Ha YKpal'lHbl «06 ()nepaTI'IBHO-p03b1CKHOH .ne.!!-
TCJlbHOCTI'I"
HcrnacH()C npOHI1KHUIJCHI1C B JKI1J1bIC nOMcmeHI1S1, BI1.JyaJIbHUe HB-
6nlOlICHI1C 0 HI1X, CHS!Te l'IH4JOPMBUI'II'I C KaHaJ1()B CBSlJI'I, npl'lMCHCHI'IC
lIPYrx TCXHI1'1eCIII1X CpC1ICTB nOJ1)"JcHI'IS! I'IH4JOPMBUI'II1 11 KOHTpOJlb
nO'lTOBO-TCJ1CrpaijJHblX OTnpaBJICHI1i1 np0I13B01ISlTCH Kall I1CKlIIQ<JI1TeJlb-
Hble MCpbl C CBHKUI1I'1 rCHCpaJ1bHoro npOl<ypopa YKpal1HbI e cJ:y"lBe,
CCJ11'1 I1HblM cn()C060M HCBOJMO)KHO nOJl)"JI'ITb 4JaKTI1'iCCKI'IC llBHHblC
29

.lIJ1J1 o6eCne..eHI1J1 3allll1TbI 06111eCTHa 11 rocy.napCTHa OT npecrynHhlx no-
CSiTaTeJlhCTB.
J.1CKJlIO'II1TeJlbHO B Ut:!IJlX nOJl)"leHI1S1 p33IJellbIBaTe;1bHO I1H4>opMa-
UI1I1 .lIJ1J1 06eCne<leHI1J1 IJHeWHei1 6e3QnaCHQCTH Yllpal1Hbl, npellynpe)l(-
.neHI1J1 11 npeCe..eHI1J1 pa3BeJ:\bIBaTeJ1bHo-nO.npbIBHb!X nOCSIraTeJlhCTB
cneUCJ1Y)l(6 I1HOCTpaHHhlX rOCYAapCTB 11 ()praHI13aUI{j:j YKa3aHHbJe Mepbl
MOTyr ocymeCTB.'JJlTbCJI B n()pMKe, COrJ1aCOIJ3HH()M C reHepaJ1bHbJM
npOKypopmt YKpaI1Hbi ('I. II, III CT. 6)
CTaTbl1 4, 6, g 3aKOHa JlHTOBCKOIt Pecny6JJI1KI'I ..06 onepaTI1BH()j:j
AeJlTeJ1bHOCTW'
CTaTbl'l 8, 9, 13 3aKoHB Pecny6JJ1'I1I11 MOJUlOIJ3 ..06 onepaTHIJHO-
p03bICIIH0i1.neRTt':J1bHOCTI'I».

T361IHl.la3
flpaBOBIUI OCHOBa OnepaTHBHO-pnblcKHoil: .nesrrt'1JbIIOCT1I.
BClpIIHa,CHrHEiIlJlTIiH
Huutu'H08CIHue
M flpOOOOOR OCHOOU OP/l 1aKOHOikm'e.JbJlbIX
.", OKmOO. pei!..lO'JeH-
mu VHJU(U.x OP/l
+'KOHCTH"IJI1"OIfIfWC  3
--=-- flpaHORYIO OCHORY onepaTIIIBHO-P03b1CII- (J)cllepW1bHbl3aKOH
HOH nCSlTC!1bHOCTH COCTaBJ1HIOT KOHCTH- ..06onCpIITHBHO-
"J'YUHJI POCCHHCKOH (J)CllepaUHI1 po3LICKHO
(a63 I CT 4) neSlTeJ1bHOCTH..
flpaBoBYIO OCH()BY onepaTl'IDHO-p03bICK- 3aKoH YKPaHHbl
HOH .ueJlTCJ1bHOCHJ COCTaB!1J1IOT KOHCTH- ..06onepaTHBHO-
"J'YUI'IH YKpal1Hbl (CT 3) P03bICKH()H.ueH-
Te!1bH()CTI'I&
flpaBoBYIO OCH()BY OnepaTI'IBHO-p03bICK- 3alloH Pecny6JJl'IlIl'I
HOHneSlTe!1bH()CTH COCTaBJ1HIOT . KOHCTI'I- Eie!1apycb
T)'UI1S1 (OCH()BH()H JaKoH) Pecny6JJl'IKI'I «06()nepllTBH()-
EieJIaPycb(a63. I CT. 6) P03bICKH()H.ueH-
Te!1bHOCTI'I&
flpaBoBYIO OCH()BY OnepaTI'IBHO p03blCK 3aKoH Pecny6JJI1KI'I
H()il:neSlTe!1bH()CTH COCTaBJ1HIOT.. KOHCTI'I- KaTIXCTaH
T)'UI1H Pecny6JJI1KI'I Ka3ilXCTJ.H «060nepllTBHO-
(n. I CT. 4) P03blcKHOHlleJl-
Te!1bHOCTH"
flpaBoBoH OCHOBOH onepaTI'IBHO-p03bICK- 3aKOH KblprblJ-
HOHlleJiTelIbHOCTI1 JlBJ1J1eTC}(.. KOHCTHTY- CKOH Pecny6lIHKI1
UJI Kblprbl.JcKoi1 PeCnV61Il1KH ..06onepIlTHIJHO-
(CT. 5) p03bICKHOHJreJl-
TelIbHOCTH»
flpauoeylO OCHOHY onepaTHIJHoi1 neJITelIb- 3aKOH
HOCTI1 COCTBBJ1J11OT .. CBTHepcMe. KOHCTH- J18TBI1HCIIOH
TYUHOHHbIH 3aKoH l1aTBHHcKoH Pecny6- Pecny6nHIII1
JlHIII1 "flpaBa H 06S1JBHHOCT 'IeJ10BeKa H ,,06 oncpaTHBHoH
rpa>KllIDil'ltffi»(n ICT3) .ueSlTeJ11,HOCTI'I»
Cy6DeKTbI onepllTHBHOH lleSITen1,HOCT 3aKoHl11'1ToBCKoH
pyKOBOllCTByIOTCH BpCMCHHblM OCHOB- Pccny6nl'lllH ,,06
H1,IM 3BKOHOM (KOHCTHTYUHeH) 11I1ToB- ()nepaTI'IBH()H
CKOH PeCnv61II'IKI'I (CT 2) .ueHTeJ1bHOCTW>
31

npOOO,J;JKI?HUI? mUM. 3
1 Z 3
flpaBoBoH OCHOIJOH OnepaTI'IBHO-pOJbICK- 3alloH Pecny6JJ111111
HOti .!\eSlTI':lIbHOCTI1 JlBJUlIOTCSI.. KOHCTI1- MOiUIOBa
"I)'1.!11S1(n 1 CT 4). ..060nepaTI1BHO-
P03blCKHOH
 .DeSlTeJ1bHOCTI1»
OJ.'e.aepa.1bHblll JaKOB 06 OP.Q,
flpauoeylO OCHOBY OnepaTI1BHO-p03bICK- 4>CJ1epMbHb!f1
HOti nellTenbHOCTI1 COCTaMJlIOT... 4>e.ae- 33KOH ..06 onepa-
pMbHblH 33KOH ..06 OP.Q (a63. 1 CT. 4) TBHO-p03bICIlHOti
lleSlTeJ1bHOCTI1»
flpauoBYIO OCHOBy OnepaTI1BHO-p03bICK- 3aKoH Ykpal1HbI
HOti neSiTClIbHOCTI1 COCT3BJ1S1IOT... 3aKoH ..06oneparI1BHO-
Ykpai1HbI «06 OP.Q.. (CT. 3) P03bICKHOtil!fJl-
TClIbHOCTI1»
flpaBoeylO OCHOBY onepaTI1BHo-p03bICK- 3aKoH Pecny6JJI1KI'I
HOti lleSiTClIbHOCTI1 COCTRBJ1S1IOT... 3aKoH Eenapycb
Pecny6lIl1KI1 Ee.rmpycb ..06 OP.Q.. ..060nepaTBHO-
(a63. I CT. 6) P03bICKHOtil!fSl-
TClIbHQCTI1»
flpaBoBylO oclioey onepaTMBHO-p03bICK- 3allOH Pecny6JJ111111
HOti lleSlTC;IbHOCTI1 COCTRBJ1S1IOT... 3aKOH K.i3a1{CTaH
Pecny6JJI1KI1 KaJaXCT3H ..06 OP.Q" ..060nepaTBHO-
(n 1 CT. 4) P03blcllHo ti llelj-
TClIbHQCTI1»
flpaBoBoH OCHOBOH OnepaTI1BHO-p03bICK- 3allOH Kblprbl3-
HOti lleSiTClIbHOCTI1 SlBJ1S1eTCSI. 3allOH CKOH Pccny6lIl1KIII
Kblprbl3cKOti Pecny6J1IiKI1 ..06 OP.Q.. ..06onepaTI1BHO-
(CT. 5) P03blclIHoi'lllelj-
TCJlbHOCTI1»
flpaBOByiO OCHOey orrepaTI1HHOH nCHTClIb- 3aKoH JlaTHIllf1CKon
HOCTM COCTaBJ1J1IOT. 3alloH _06 onepa- Pecny6lIl1l1l1
TMBHOi1 llCSlTClIbHOCTIII» lIaTBI1HcKOfi Pcc- ,,06 onepaTI1(1Hoi1
ny6J1111111 (n. I CT. 3) lleSlTeJ1bHOCTM»
Cy6beKTbI onepaTI1IJHoi1 .!\CSlTcnbHOCTI1 33KoHlII1ToBCKoi1
pyKOElO.!lCTBYIOTCSI .. 3alloHoM Jli1TOBCKOH Pecny6J1J'1KI1
Pccny6lIl1KI1 ..06 OnepaTI'IBHoti llCSlTClIb- ..06 OTlepaTI1(1Hoi1
HOCTIII" (CT. 2) lleSlTeJ1bHOCTI1»
32

npOOO,J;JKI?HUI? maM. 3
1 2 3
npaDoBoH OCHOBOH onepaTl'IDHO-p03bICK- 3alloH Pccny6JJ1'I1I1'I
HOti .!IeSlTlIbHOCTI'I JlRJUleTCJI... 3allOH MOJUIOBa
Pecny6JJI1KI1 M0.l1.!10Ba ..06 OnepaTI'IBHO- ..o6onepaTI1BHO-
p03blCKHOH AeSlTeJ1bH()CTI'I" (n I CT. 4) p03LICKHOH
.!IeJlTeJ1bHOCTI'I..
3 "', IIbHbleJ.aKOHbllln BOBbieaKTbI
npaHOHYIO OCIIOBY onepaTIIIHHO-p03b1CK- (]>J1epanbHb!H
HOti JJ,e!ITCJ1bHOCTIII COCTaBJIJUur.. Llpy'", 33KOH 06onepa-
4>eJ1epanbHble JaKOHbl 11 npl1HJlTble e co- THeHo-po3bICKHOH
OTBeTCTBI1I1 C H1'I),111 I1HbJe HupMaTI'IBHble neSlTe.l1bHOCTI'I"
npaBOBble aKTbJ 4>elJepanbHblx opraHOB
rocwwnrTBeHHoH RJlaCTI1 "6, I CT. 4)
npaBoBYIO OCH()BY OnepaTI'IBHO p03blCK 3aKoH YKjJal1HbJ
H()H.!IeJlTeJIbHOCT COCTaBJIJlIOT ..06 ()nepaTI1BH()-
Yr0!10BHbIH KOJ1eKC Yllpal'lHbJ; P03bICIIHOH.!IeJl-
YffilloBHo-npoueccyanbHblti IIQ.I:IeIlC }<KpaJ1Hbl; TelIbHOCTI1»
3aKoH YKpal1Hbl () npoKyPaType;
3aKOH YKPal1Hbl () "JI1JII1UI'II'I;
3alloH YKpal'lHbI 0 CJ1Y>K6 HaUI'IOHa.rJbH()H
6e30nacHocT;
3aKOH YKPal1Hbl 0 nurpaHl'IlJHblX BoflcKax;
3aKOH YKp,mHbl 06 YnpaB.I1eH1'I1'I ()XpaHbl
BblCLU1'IX .!IOJI>KHOCTHbIX nl'lu;
npyrrIe 3aKOH()J],d"f(:ijbHble lIKTbl 11 -
HapollHo-npaBOBble COrn31lleHI1H 11 .!Ioro-
Bopbl. Y'IaCTHI1KOM KOTOpblX RBJlJleTCJI
YKDal'lHa «,
npaBoeylO OCHOIIY onepaTlJHHO-p03bICK- 3aKoH Pecny6lIl1KI'I
"0" .!IeHTe;'JbHOCT co..-raBJIJlIOT... I{Hble EeJ1apycb
JaKOHo.n;.ueijbHb1e allTbI Pecny6JJ1'I1I1{ Ee- 06()nepaTBHO-
napycb (363.1 CT 6) P03bICIIHOH!lelj-
TlIbHOCTI1»
npaBoBYIO OCH()BY OnepaTI'IBHO p03blCK 3aKoH Pecny6JJI1KI'I
HOH lIeJlTCJ1bHOCTI'I COCT3BJ1J1IOT. .DPymc Ka3axcTaH
33KOHbl I{ I'IHbIe HOpM3TlllflHbie BKTbl Pec- 060nepaTBHO-
ny6J1I'1KI1 KaHxuaH (n. 1 CT. 4) P03bICKHOH.l\tJl-
Te.l1bH()CTI'I"
npaDoDofr OCHODOH onepaTI'IDHO-p03bICK- 3alloH Kblprbl3-
HOti .!IeSiTelIbHOCTI1 JlBJlHIOTCH... .npyrl1e CKOH Pcny6lII1KIII
HopMaTBHb!e npaBOBble aKTbl Kblprb!J- 06 onepanJBHO-
CKOft Pecny6f1I'1KI'I (CT. S) P03bICKH()H!leJl-
TeJlbHOCTI'I"
33

1 2 3
npaBoBYIO ()CHOII)' ()nepaTlfBH()R lIeSlTeJlb 3alloH naTBHncKol:!
HOCTHCOCraBJ1J1IOT Pecny5J11'11111
YroJ10BHO-npoueccval!bHbltiKOlleKcJlaTBmf; ..06onepaTI'IBH()tj
npynJC 3a1lOHb[ 11 \le>K1lYl-mpOllHblC lloro- AeSlTeJlbHOCTW>
BOPb!, perJ1aMCHTl'lpYIOWHe Ja)la'm. npaBa
11 06RJaHHOCTI1 cy&beKTOB no 06ecne4e-
HH rOC}f.!WpCTBCHHOii 6e30nacHOCTH.
6B:::I::o e.H;\TeTa
Cy6beKTbl ()nepaTlfBH()R .neSITenbH()CT 3aKoH JII1TOBCKOR
PYKOBOllCTBylOTCR.. npYflfMIf 3aKOHaMIf. Pecny5}]11K11 ..06
peWeHlfRMIf 1'1 []()CTaH()!J.'JCHIfRMIf flpaBI'I- QnCpaTI'IBHOHneSl-
TCJ1bCTBa JhlTOBCKOti Pecn 6nI1KIf leT. 2) TCJJbHOCTW.
flpaaOBOH OCHOBO" onepaTIIIHHO-P03bICK- 3allOH Pccny{iJlIfKI:I
H()ti lICHTeJlbHQCTI'I HBJ1J1IOTCSI.. npl1HI1- MOJ1!lOBa«060ne-
MaeMble H C()(ITIJeTCTBWI C KOHCTI1TYLll1eti panmHO-
113<u.oHm1 Pecn}6'1IIK1f MOII.1\OBa «06 OPll- P03bICIlHOtillCJI-
.[\nvrllf' HOno.IaT1fi1lible <lKTbI (n. I cr. 4) TCJ1bHOCTl1»
4 I :lItble opraH3MH. ocyutCCTB-
- - OpraHb!. OCYWCCTMlllOilIHC OPIt H311aIOT IDeacpaJIbHblA
(I npellCJl3X caoltx nonHOMo'mt'! BCOOT- 33KOH «06 onepa-
BnCTBm'! C J3KOHOJJJln:J1bCTBOM poccl1n- TBHO-p03bICIIHO"
ClWij 4JepaLlm'l HOpM3TI1E1Hble aKTbl, lleSITeJ1bHOCTW>
pemaMeHTl1pyH)U\l1e opmHI133umo 11 T3K-
Bt:,'\eHmI OPM a63. 2CT 4
OpraHb!. oCYllieCTBJlSlloU\l1e OPl{. B npe 3aKoH PecnytiJlI1KI'I
lleJlaX CBodt KOMneTeHUl111 B COOTBeTCT- EeJlapycb
BI'II1 c 3aKoHoM ..06 OPl{» 11 I1HbJMI1 3a- ..06()nepaTBH()-
KOHOlWTeJlbHbJMI1 allTaMI1 Pecny6J1I1KI1 P03bICKH()f!lle.ll-
EeJlapycb MOryr 113lWBaTb no comacoBa- TeJlbHOCTI1f1
HmO C feHepaJlbHblM npOKypOPOM HopMa-
TI1BHble aKTbl, perJJaMCHTIIIPYH)WHC opra-
HnaLlmo 11 TaIlTI1I1} npOBCHI1J1 OPM
(a63. 1 CT. 6)
OpraHbl HRrIOroBblX paCCJ1eJ:\oBaHI1H fJlaB-
HOi1 rocYll"pCTBeHHoi1 HaJJoroBoi1
CneKLll111 MI1HI1UepCTBa $I1HaHCOB Pec-
ny6J1I1KI1 EeJ1apych opraHI13yer 11 ocyU\e-
CTBJlJler OPLt e COOTl!erCml111 c HopMa-
Tl1eHhlMI1 aKTaMI1 MBLl PecnytiJlI1KI'I Ee-
;M 6HT:l1la3.1111 ,
flpoiJoVKeHue maan. 3
34

llpooo,J;JK:f!Huf!ma6il.3
1 Z 3
OpraHbl, ocywecTBJlRlOillMe OPIt l13!IalOT 3alloH Pecny5J1MKI:I
B npe!IeJlax CBoeti KOMneTeHUlU'l H3 ()CH()- Ka3aXCTaH
BaHMI1 3aKoH3 «06 OPD. HopM3TI:IBHbie «06 OnepaTBHO-
3KTb1, pern3MeHTMpylOIl.!l1e opraHM3aUMIO p03bICKHOi1.neI'l-
M TaKTI:lt;y npoBclleHMSI OPM (n 2 CT 4) TeJlbHOCTI1»
He npenYCMorpeHO 3aKoH Kblprbl3-
Ct;Oi1 Pecny6J1I1KI:I
..06 onep3TMBHO-
P03bICt;HOi1.neSl-
TeJlbHOCTIf»
rOCYAapCTBeHHble MHCTTYUHI1, t;OTDpbIM 3al<OH J13TBI:lt!CKO!:j
3at;OHOM npe.llOCTaHJ1eHO npaBo HII OCy- Pecny5J1I1KI1
l1\eCTHJ1CHl1e onepaTI1BHOH }J,eHreJ1bHOCTH, .<060nepuHBHoi1
B npe!IeJ13X cBoei'l KOMnereHUMM 11 B co- .neSlTeJ1bHOCTH»
OTBeTCTBl111 C HaCTOSll1\l1M 3aKoHoM 113l!a-
lOT HopM3TMeHble aKTbl... OHI1 BI:Tyn3l0T B
CKJlY TOJlbKO nocne yrBep)l(J\eHI1S1 I1X re-
HepanbHblM npOKypoPOM (n. 2 CT. 3)
Cy6beKTbl ()nepaTMBH()t! JleSiTenbH()CT 3aKoH JhITOBCKOt!
pYKoeOJlCTBYIOTC.II... cOOTeeTcTBYlOllil1MM Pecny5nl1KI1
HOpMElTI1BHb!"UI allTaMI1 11 I1HCTpyKUI1S1MI1 ..06onepaTI1BHoi1
rocYJlapCTlleHHoi1 I1HCTI1TYUI1I1 (CT. 2) .neSlTeJ1bHOCTI1»
OpraHbl, ocymecTBJU1lOll.!l1e OnepaTI1BHO- 3aKoH Pecny6J1111111
p03blCKHYIO JleSiTenhHOCTb, l1:t1\alOT B npe- MOJU\oBa
JleJlBX CBoeH KOMnI:reHUI1I1 BCOOTTCT- ..060nepaTI1BHO-
DI1M C 3aKOHon:JJeQbCTDOM 11 n() cornaco- p03brcKHok
BaHMIO c BepxoBHblM CYA()M M Pecny6J1M- AeSlTeJlbHOCTMfI
KIIHCKOfl npOKypaT)'POfI" BeJl()MCTBeHHbre
HOpMaTIJHble 311Tbl, pefJ13MeHTl1pylOJl[l1e
opmHI13aUI1IO, MeTOllhl 11 TaIlTIIY npOBC-
JleHI1S1 OPM (n. 2 CT 4)
lIpaBoBbIeocHoBbIOP.ll:.33I1peIl.llCHHbleBCJJeJJ..VIOUlIfCTaThS!X3aKOHOB,
CT3TbSl 4 IDenepanbH()rO JaKOHa ..06 OPD,»
CTaTWI J :hIroHa YtqX\I:IHbl «06 OIlepTIHBHo-poobICKHOri JleSirenbH{)...
CYdTbJI 6 3aKOHa Pecny6J1I1KM 5eJJapyCh ..06 OnepaTI1I!HO-p03blcKHo1l
.DeKfeQbHOCTI:I"
35

CraThJI 3 3alloHa Pecny6JII1K K.uaxcT"oIH .,{)6 onepaTBHo-p03bICKHOH
ne$lTeJlbHOCTI1".
CTarMl 5 JaKuHl1 KbIP.-bl3CK0f1 PecnyfiJII1KI1 ..06 onepaTMI!HO-
P03b1CK-H()tI.neSlTeJ1bH()CTI1t>
CTarbSi 2 3aKoHa JIaTBI1t1cKoti Pecny6J1I1KM..06 onepan:!BHoti neSl-
TeJ1bH()CTI1»
CTarbSi 2 3aKoHa JlI1TOBCKOfi Pecny6J1I1KH ..06 o[Jcpan:!BHoH neSl-
TeJ1bIiOCTI1»
CTaTbSl 4 3aKOH8 Pecny6J1I1KI1 MOJ1.lroea ...06 onepaTI1BHO-
P03blCilHOH neHTeJlbHOCTI'I".

Ta6;1I'IUa4
3aKOII<maTei1bIlOe Onpei1,eJleHRe 'l OnepaTIlBIlO-pa1blCKHOiii
.neRTeJlbHOCTH B OnepaTllllJlO-flBJWCKHblX JaKOHaX CTpaH CHr II 6aJ1THH
HUU!l/eHOOaHUe 3aKO-
3ada'lu OPJl Hodame,lbHbiX aKmOB,
peZ.1QM(!HnHlPJ7OIllUX
OP/l
2
BblHB.fTeHlleIlIl'fC1)1l1JellHH, YCTaHOBi1eHlleJ1111.l. HX
1l0MOTaBJIIIB31OUlHX, COBepUl31OUIIIX ... cooep-
BbJlBi1eHl'Ie npecT)'n;'JeHidt. BbI.I[BJleHl1e If YCTa c})elleparIbHbln JaKOH
HOBJIeHlfe J1IfU, If)( nOlirOTaR,"lHBafQWIfX. cOflep- .,{)6onepaTlfBHO-
wafQll.[I1X 11J111 COBepWI1BWI1X (a63 2 CT. 2 HI. I) p03b1CKHOti .neSlTJlb-
HOCTH
nOHCK If I)/I1KCaUmr l)/aKTH'IeCKIfX 113HHbIX 0 3aKoH YKPalfHbl
npOTIfBonpaBHoH lICSlTC;'JbHOCTH OTllCJlbHblX J1IfU ...06 oncpaTIfBHO-
11 rpynn B UeJlHX npeCe'leHI1H npaBoHapyweHI1i1 p03bICKHOti .neSlTJlb-
B IfHTepecax Vro.OBHoro CYlionpOIfJBOllCTBa HOCTI'I
" I)
BblHl\!1eHMe npeCT)'nJleHI1i1 (CT. 3) 3alloH Pcny6J1I1I1H
6eJ1apycb
..06()nepaTBH()-
pOJblCKHo!1.neSlTeJlb-
HOCTH
Bbl.l[BJleHl1e npeCTyru:reHl1n (003. 4 CT. I pam. I) 3aKoH Pecny6J1IfKH
Ka3aXCTi!.H
..060nepaTHBHO-
p03bICKHOti .neSlTJlb-
HOCTIf
BblHBJleHMe npeCT)'nJleHlfti 1'1. SeT. 3) 3aKoH Kblprbl3cKoi1
Pecny6J1I1HI
.,{)60neparI1IJHO-
p03bICKHOi1
neSlTeJ1bH()CTIf..
BblHBI1eHMe CQBepWI1BWI1X npecT)'lU1eHl1e JlI1U 11 3aKoH JhnBHticlloH
I1CT04HI1KOBlIOKa3aTJlhCTB (nolln. 2 n. I CT. 2) Pecny6J1111111
..06 ()nepaTI'IBH()ti
neHTeJ1hHOCTW'
C60p IfHl)/opMaUlf1f II c4Jepe If l'IH4>pacrPYKType 3aKoH JhlTOIICKOti
rocynapCTlJeHHhlX npecrynJleHI1H If yro;'JoBHblX Pecny5J1IfKl'l ...06
npecrynJleHl1ti (CT I) onepaTIIIBHO .neH-
TJ1bHOCTI1
37

1
BblI1B11eH}le npeCTynHblx nOCSlraTbCTB (a63. I
CT. 2)
Cu op uH$upr.taUit Il. L......-<... _HUb'" .. ..IIM(
.neJicTBJlA no ooecne'leHHIO 6e30nacHOCTH rocy-
IDI crea H 06WCCTBa
.l{oGblDHHHe I1H$opMaUIfIf 0 COGblTIffiX "'JIlt .Ildi-
CTB"HX, C03llHIOWHX Y'-P03Y rocYllapcracHHOM,
OOCHHOfi, 3110HOMH'1eCKoti HJ111 3K0J10r'leCKO"
6onacHocnl POCCIfHCKOij 4JepaUIHJ (a63. 4
cT2)
nm:!cK If IJ>I1I<CaUI1S1 $aKTH'leCI(ID: lJ,aHHbIX ()
palBe1lUB.IJeJIbH()-nOllpbIBHoi1 ne.llTeJlbHOCTH cne-
UI'laJ1bHbIX CI1yJK6 I1H()CTpal-UJbIX rocy.napCTB 1'1
upraHlf3aufi B UCJI.IIX npece'JeHI1S1 npaBOHapy-
llIeHI1i1 If B I1HTepecax yrOJ!()BHOrO CYA()npmJ3-
B01!CTBa, a TalOKe nOJl}"1CHIfJl I1Ht]:>opMBUI'lI1 B
"HTepeCax 6GOnacHocTH
CO!!efiCTBHe B 06eCne<leHU' 6CaQnocHOCTI1 06-
mccrBa, rOCY.IlapCTBa 11 YKpenJleHl1e ero 3KOHO-
MWleCKoro nOTeHLlI1aJ18 }I OOopOHocnocOOHOCTI1
(a63.3cr.1)
Bbl18I1eHl1e, npe.llynpe)l(J],fHl1e npeCe'leHl1e
pa3Be1lblBaTeJlbH()-nOllpbIBHOH ne.llTeJlbHOCTl'l cne-
UI'laJ1bHbIX CI1yJK6 IfH()CTpBHHbIX rocy.napCTB H
pOIlHbIxopraHlf3aUldt (a63. 6 CT. I).
06eCne'leHife 6e30naCH()CTI'I npeJl1lleHTB Pec-
nytiJlI1KIf Ka3axcrBH If npyrl'lx ()XpaHAeMbJX JlIfU
(a63.7cTI)
C:'H paHbl rocYlWpCTBCHHOH rpaHI'I-
06eCne"leHl'le 6e30naCHOCTI'I Kblprbl3c"oii Pec-
ny6J1I'1KI'I 1'1 COlleHCTBl1e B peaJIl'I.J"ul'Il'I I'IHTepe-
COBroCYlIapCTBa Ha !>1I'IpOBOH apeHe ('I. I CT. 3).
Bbl.1lMeHl'le. npeILynpeJK1leHl'le 11 npece'1eHl'le pm-
BellbIBaTeJ1bHO-n011PbIBHO lIeHTe.llbHOCTH cne-
Ul'laJlbHblX cny;.:6 I'II-JocrpaHHbIx rocynapcTB 1'1
MeJK11YHapoIlHblX upraHlf3aul'I" ('I. 2 CT. 3).
06eCne'leHl'le 6eJOnacHoCHJ 05'beKTOB rOCYllap-
CTBeHl-j()H ()XpaHbr{"l. 3 CT. 3).
06CCnC'leHl'le oxpaHbl rocYlWpCTBeHHOA rpaHI'I-
Ubi 'I 4 CT. 3)
38
flpoiJo1.JlW/uemafin.4
2
3allOH Pecny6J11'1111'1
MOJU\oBa.,{)6one-
paTI'IBHO-P03b1CKHoi!
,1ICSlTeJ1bHOCTI'I»
ellepanbHb[£13aKOH
..06 OnepaTI'IBHO-
p03brcKHok
ne.llT(:J]bHOCTW>
3"IKOH YKpal'lHbJ
.,{)6 Oneparl1BHO-
p03brcKHo
neSlTeJ1bH()CTW'
3allOH Pecny6J11'1111'1
Ka3axcTaH
..060nepaTBHO-
p03blCKH0l1
neHT(:J]bHOCTI'I
3aKOH Kblprbl3cKol1
Pecny6J11'1111'1
,,06 Oneparl'lBHO-
p03brcKHoH
neSlTeJ1bHOCTI'I"

llpooo,J;JK:f!Huf!mafiJl.4
1 2
n0J1Y4Hl1e, HHlIonJ1eHl1e. HH:!J1I1J 11 I1CnOJ1b30- 3aKoH JhnBI'IClloj:j
B!lHl1e B YCTaHOBJIeHHOM JaKOHOM nopSlllKe 00- Pecny6J1111111
]]I1TM'IecKO. COUMaJ]bHO. BoeHHOn. 3KOH()MIf- ..06 onepaTIfBHOn
'IeCKoi:i. Hay'lH(). TeXHlf'leCKOH, KpI1MIfH:!J1b- lIeSlTeJ1bHOCTIf"
Hofi If .r:r.pyro IfH$opMaulflf. CBSlJaHfiO co
cQ>epoti npecT)'!1HOCT 11 ee I1H<J>paCTJJYKrypOH
Ifn()CSlraTe.%CTBa
nOJ1}'4eHl1e I1H4>OP"'BUI1I1 0 KOHllpeTHblX Im:uax. 3aKOH 1111ToBCKoH
ecnlf pernaercSi Bonpoc 06 If X COOTBeTC'TBillf pa- Pecny6J1I1KI1 ..06
60Te Hi! B<DKHblX rocynapcTBeHfiblX nOCTax If B O!1epaTI'IBHO neSl-
IfHCTHl)'UMX 11160 0 J11ll1ax, IfMelOll1HX nocl)'!1 K TenbHOCTIf"
rocynapcTBeHHblM "'" I1HblM oxpaHeMblM Ja-
KOHO ceKjJeT" (nonn. Ii n. I CT. 2)
n - ueHH"
npenynpeJKneHl1e npecrynJ1eHI1i (a63. 2 CT. 2) (]>enepanbHblH3BKOH
,06 ()nepaTBHO-
p03blCKHOH
lleSlTt:J1bHOCTI1»
npellyrrpe)l(l!eHlfe npecrYJlJ1eHl1n (CT. 3) 3aKoH Pecny6J1IfKI'I
ECJ1apycb
..060nepaTHHO-
p03bICKH0i1 ne.llTeJ1b-
H()CTM»
npellynpe)l(.1leHl1e npecrynJ1eHI1H (363. 4 CT_ I) 3aKoH Pecny6J1I1KH
KB3aXCTJ.H
..06 onepaTBHo-
p03b1CKHOH lleSlT]]b-
HOCTH»
npellyrrpe)l(l!eH1fe npecryrrJ1eHl1n ('i. 5 CT 3) 3aKoH Kblprbl3CKOn
Pecny6J1111111
..06 onepaTl1lJHO-
P03b]CKHO neSITeJ1b-
HOCTH"
npO<J>I1J1aKTKa npecrynJ1eHI1H " "' npellOT- 33KOH J1.rnlJlticlloiJ
BpaIUeHl1e([J()nn. 2 [J I CT. 2) Pecny6J1IfK
..06onepaTHBHOIf
lIeSiTenbHOCTI1
39

llpooo,J;JK:f!Huf!mafiJl.4
1 2
npeJIynpe)K.[leHHe npeCTynneHl1fi (003. 1 CT. 2) 3allOH Pecny6J1HIII1
MOJlJ\OBa ..06 one-
paTHBHO-P03bICKHOll
.ueITeJ1bHQCTIf»
IIpece'leHHeI1jJeCT)'1UIeHHH
npeCe'leHl1e [JpeCl)'nJleHI1W (a63 2 CT 2) ellepa.rrbHblfi3aKoH
..06 onepaTBHo-
P03bICKH()J:illeSITeJlb-
HOCTH"
npeCe>leHHe [JpaBOHapywelf1ffi (CT I) 3alwH Yl<pa1fHbT
.,()6onepaTHBHo-
P03blcKHoJ:i.nenTeJlb-
HOCTH»
npeCf'leHl1el'l npecl)'nJleHl1fifcT. 3) 3aKoH Pecny6J1I1KH
EieJ1apycb
..06 onepanTBHo-
P03b1CKHoM.neSlTeJlb-
H()CTH"
npece'leHHe npecTynJleHHfi (a63 4 CT. I) 3allOH Pecny6J1HIII1
Ka3a"cTaH
«06onepaTHHo-
p03blcKHoJ:i.u:eSlTeJ1b-
HOCTH"
npeCf'leHHe npeCl)'nJlel-Jl1W ('I SeT. 3) 3aKoH Kblprbl3cKoW
PeC[Jy6J1I1K
.,{)6onepaTI1HHO-
P03b1CKHOW .neSlTeJlb-
H()CTH"
npece'leHl1e npeCl)'nJ1eHHH (a63. I CT. 2) 3allOH Pecny6J1HIII1
MOJU\oBa "{)6 one-
paTH13HO-p03b1CKHOM
.ueSlTeJ1bHQCTH»
PaexJlt>l1lK! J1IeCT)nneHIIH
PacKpblTHe npeCl1'nJleHlffl (a63.2cT 2) eJIepa.rrbHblfi 3aKOH
..06 onepaTHBHo-
po3blCKHOfi
JIeSlTeJ1bH()CTH»
40

llpooo,J;JK:f!Huf!mafiJl.4
1 2
PacKpblTl1e npeCT)'nJ1eHl1ti (CT. 3) 3aKoH Pecny6J1111111
fieJJaPycb
«06()nepaTBHo-
pOJblCKHOHlleSlTCJ1b-
HOCTI1
PacKpblTl'le npeCT)'nJ1eHlfti (a63. 4 CT I) 3:1110H Pecny6J1IfKM
Ka3'iXCTaH
«06()nepaTBHO-
pOJblCKHotiJ{eSlTCJ1b-
H()CTM"
PacKpb1Tl'le npecT)'r!J1eHl'lfr('l. 5 CT. 3) '3aKOH KblprblJCKofr
Pecny6J1IfKI'I
«06 onepaTlfflHO-
P03bICKHoi111enrenb-
HOCTM"
PaCK)JbITl1e npecrynneHl1fr(nQl1n. 2 n. I CT. 2) 3aKOH J1dTlJlli1CKOi1
Pecny5nlflllf
«060nepaTI1IJHofr
lleSiTenbH()CTIf"
PacKpblTl'le npeCT)'nneHl'lfr (a63. I CT. 2) 3aKoH Pecny6nlfKI'I
MOJU\OBa.,{)6one-
paTlfeH()-p03bICKHOn
.DenT!:J1bHOCTW>
Oc:IJ..IeCJBJU:'Hlle :JI.ICKanHU
OcyweCTBJ1ellI1C po3b!CKa _qIfU. CKPblB31OWl1XCJI cllepanbHblliJaKOH
(IT opraHOB l103HaHlfn. cnellCTBMn Ii CYlla, YKJ]()- .,{)6 OnepaTI1BHO-
HJlIOWi1XCSI OT yr0J10flHOrO HHI<33aHI1I1. II TaK;KC pOJblCKHoi111cSlTcnb-
DO.fuI.CKa 6e3 BeCTI'I nIXmaBWl1x(a63. 3 CT. 2 HOCTIf»
POJbJCK CKpbWUU'IXCSI npCCT)'nHIfIlOB_ 6e3 BCCTI'I 3:1110H Pccny6nlflll1
nponaBumx rpaJlUlaH (CT. 3) fi!:J1apycb
«06 OnepaTI'IBHO-
pOJblCKHotiJ{eSlTcnb-
H()CTM"
OcyurecTBJ1eHl1e Mep no pOJblCKY J1I1Ll, Cllpbl- 3aKoH Pecny6J1I1KI1
BalOWI1XC.II ()T ()praH()B .DU3HaHIfR, CJlellCTBlfn If """"'=H
""",. YKJIOHJlIOWI1XCSI OT yrO;IOIlHOrO HHllaJa- «06onepaTlfflHO-
HI1.11, 6e3 BeCTI-! nponaBwlfx rpaA;.IJ;i;H If IfHblX p03blcKHoi111eJITe.b-
J1IfU II CJI}"IaSix. npellYcMOTpeHHblx 3aKOHO1 HOCTM
a63.5CT.1
41

1
OcywecTBJleHlfe po3bIcKa J1IfU. CKpbIBalOWI1XCH
()T opraHoB CJ1ellCTBI'I 11 cyna. YK.'JOHRlOllUIXCH
OT yr0J10BHoro npeCJ1eJlOBD.HI1H. a TaK)I(e P03bl-
CKa 6eJ BeCTI'I nponaBwl1X('I.. 6 CT. 3)
nOIfCK J1I'IU, KOTopble B YCTHHOW1eHHOM nopR!l-
lie J[BJlHIOTCH nO.ll()JpeBaeMbIMI1. 06BI1HJleMblMH
111111 OCYJKJ1eHHbIMI1 33 COBepllleHl1e npecTynfle-
Hlfj;! (n()lln 3 n. I CT. 2)
nmlcK J1IfU nponaBWIfX 6e3 BeCTIf (no)ln S n. I
cr. 2
3auUITa H J3KOHHblX HlITe "
3mUl1T3 npaB 11 3a1<OHH!>IX HllTepecon rpa)l:;ll:m
3aU.ll1Ta npaB Ii 33KOHHbiX I1HTepeCoB rpaJKJ13H
(CT. 3)
3arUlITa )l<1f3HI1. 31l0pOBbSi. np:m. CB0601l, 3a-
IIOHHblX I1HTepeCoB rpaJK1JaH If coGcmeHHOCTI1
(HeJ3BIJCHMO OT 41opM) or npOTlIBonpaeHblX
nocnrarenbcTB(a63. 2eT. I)
He npCJlycr.'IOTpet'lO
3mmHa J1IfU OT npeCT)'JlHblX nocnraTenbCTB
([l01UJ. I [I. I CT. 2)
 rocyn:'pCTBeIIHLIX ceXpeTOB
OxpaHa roc}'napCTBeHHbJX CeKpeTOB (CT. 3)
42
npoi'JoVKellue mOM. 4
2
3aKoH KbJprbl3CKoj;!
Pecny5J11f1l1f
06 onepaTlIBHO-
P03bICKHoi1.nenreJlb-
H()CTM"
3aKOHJlaTl!l1i1cIl01l
Pecny6J1111111
..06 onepaTl1lJHOH
neSlTe!1bHOCTIf>'
ellepanbHb!ij3aKOH
Poccm1cKOH 4Je-
paUHI1 ..06 onepa-
TI1BHO-PO]bICKH()
neSlTeJ1bHOCTIN
3alloH Pecny6J1HIIH
EieJlapycb
..06 onepaTHBHo-
pOJblCKHOH llS1TJlb-
HOCTH"
3aKoH Pecny6J1HKI'I
KaJaXCTaH
..060nepaTHHO-
po3blCKHOW
lleSlTeJlbHOCTI1»
1allOH Kblprbl3cKOW
Pecny6J1HIIH
..06 ()nepaTHBHo-
P03bICKH()t!
.ueSlTJlbHOCTI'I"
3aKoH J1aTBHwcKOn
Pecny6J1HKI1
..060nepaTHHH()H
lleSlTeJ1bHOCT1'l
3aKOH Pecny6J1HKI'I
EieJlapycb
..060nepaTHHO-
po3blCKHOii
neSlTeJ1bHOCTHt>

06o::cne'leHI-If COXpaHHOCTH Cl!elleHI1, COCTa(l-
J1IUOl1!rIX rOCYJlapCTl!eHHYIO H HHYIO Oxpamle-
MYJO 3aKOHO TaHY. CO.nenCTBrIe npennprIJiTrI-
JIM. Y'lpe)l(J1eHrIJiM 11 OpraHrI3aUI1J1 (He:JaBHCIf-
MO OT t]:>OpM C06CTBeHHOCTI1) l! 3aWrITe KOM-
Mep4eCKOfiraHHbi (a63. 9 CT. I
He njJCJ1}CMOTpCHO
OxpaHa roCy.naPCTBeHHblX ceKPeTOB 11 .npyflf)(
Ba;t{HbIX WlJI focynapcTBa IfHTepeCOB (no.nn 7
n ICT2)
1_c Hlfefie] OllaL'tI OCTHcyfu.etrnmOP,Q
06eCne>leHl1e 6onacHocTI1 opnmOB H J1HU,
OCyweCTBJlJllOWI1X OP,Q (CT. J)
06o::cne'leHHe ()praH()B, ()CywecTBJlJllOUU1X OP.n
(a63.llcTI)
06o::cne'leHl1e 6e30naCHOCTI1 opraHOD, OCYllIeCT-
M.IIlOlUl1X OP,Q ('I. 7 CT. J)
 peJKH ..,)CTaIIDIIJJeHHOI)..mOB-
1I0-I1CIIDJ1I>III>IM33KOIIOJ],8TeI1IoCT80M
nO)JJIepJKaHlfe peJKjllla. YCTaHOBJleHHOro yro-
J10BHO-I1Cn0J1HIfTo::J1bHbIM 3aKOHOD,aTeJ1bCTBOM, B
Mecrax J1lfllleHIfJl cBo6011bl (a63. 10 CT 1)
43
llpooo,J;JK:f!Huf!mafin.4
2
3aKoH PecnytiJ1IfKI'I
K33aXCr.tH
.,{)6 OnepaTBHO-
po3bICKHO
ne5ln:J1bHOCTIf»
3aKOH Kblprbl3cKo
Pecny5J1I1HI
«06 OnepaTI1BHO-
p03blCKHOti
neSlTei1bHOCTW.
3axoHJ1aTBI1Hclloii
PecnytiJ1IfKI1
«060nepaTI1BH()fj
,lleSln:J1bHOCTW.
3allOH PecnytiJ1I1I1H
fieJ1apycb
.,()60nepaTBHO-
P03b1CKHoHnO::S1Tei1b-
3aKOH PecnytiJ1IfKI'I
Ka3axcTaH
..060nepaTHHO-
po3blCKHOrl
.neSlTei1bHOCTW.
3aKoH Kblprbl3CKoii
Pecny6JJIfKI'I
..060nepaTIfBH()-
p03bICKHO
.neHTeJ1bHOCTI1"
3aKOH PecnytiJ1IfKI'I
""""=H
..06 OnepaTI'IBHO-
P03blCKHOrl
neSlTei1bH()CTI1"

OKOH'lOHUf! maM. 4
1 2
He npellYCM()TpeHO 3aKOH KbJprb13CKO
Pecny5J11'1111'1
..06 OnepaTI'IBHO-
p03blCKH0I1
lleSlTe.l1bHOCTI'I
BOThierneHlte)1llep6a
06ecne'leHl'le B03MerneHI1 ymep6a, HaHeCeH- 3aKoH IhnBI'IHclloM
Hom B pt':3YJ1bTIITt': npecTyn.l1eHI1 (nOlln. 4 n. I Pecny6J1I1I1H
cT2) ..06 OnCpaTl'IBHOH
lIeHTei1bHOCTH
06eCne'leHl'le 1I03MellieHI'I yJllep6a. npl1'l.HHeH- 3aKoH Pecny6J1I1Kl'I
HOt': npeCTYl1J1eHl'leM (a63 I CT 2) MOJl!lORa ..06 one-
paTI1BHo-p03bICKHOM
lleSlTeJ1bHOCTW'
He npellycMOTpeHO 3aKoH Kblprbl3cKo
Pecny6J1I1KI1
..060nepaTHRHO-
p03blCKHOH
lIeTbHOCTI1»
3:IAA... HOP lt,33Kpen,leHHbleBCJleJJ,yIOUUlXI'Ta"I1.mI:J.aIlOHOB.
CnITbSl 2 (]:JelleparIbHOrO 3aKOHa ..06 OnepaTl'lBH()-p03bICKHOH JIeSl-
Tt':J1bHOCTI1»
CrnTWI I JaKOH" YKpaI1Hbl,,06 onepaTl'IBHo-po.lblCKHOlt  1reJIbHOCTI1».
CTaTbJI 3 3allOH3 Pccny6J1I1KM EiCJ13PYCb ..06 onepaTI1BHO-p03bICKHOM
lIe>lTe.l1bHOCTI1».
CTaTbJI I 3aKoHa PeCf1y6.11I1K KaJaxCTIlH ..06 onepaTBHo-p03bICKHOM
lIeSlTt':J1bHOCTI1».
CTaTMI 3 lflKOHfI Kblprbl3cKoA Pecny6.11I'1KI1 ..06 OnepaTl'IBHO-
p03blCilHOH lIeHTt':J1bHOCTI'I»
CTaTMI 2 pa.>JIe.l1 I 3aKOHa JlaroHHcKoH Pecny6J1I1KH ..06 onepa-
THBHOHJIeSlTeJ1bHOCTW'
CTaTbSl I 3f1KOHfI JlHTOBCKOi{ Pecny6J1I1KH ..06 onepaTI'IBHoii lIeA-
Te.l1bH()CTI1»
CTaTbJI 2 3aKOHa Pt':cny6J1I1KH M0J1110Ba «06 oneparnBHo-po3blCKHOii
AeSlTe.l1bHOCTl'I».

Ta6;u1Lla5
Onpe.ll:('Jlelfll :JaKOHO.llaTeJ1eM II CTpaHaX CHr H 6UTHH
ii OpraHOB, OC)llreC11IijHIOWHX OP))
HtlUIH!H()(J{lHUe
M 'JtIKOHoiJtIme1bHblx
ny, 06RJaHHOCmU OpaH08, ocyeCmf1,)HIOUX CllCm08,peUltH!H-
OPJ/ IIIIIp.VIOUl,UX OPJ/.
-T-Lo6naHI10CTH 3
npHHHM3Tb np3BOBbie Mepbl
- :I1=:::7n;::J1:OHX nOJ1HOMO- CJ)ellepMbHbl"
'11'1" Bce He06"().llI1Mble Mepbl no JaWI1Te JaKOH ..06 onepa-
KOHCTKT}'IlHOHHbJX npae 11 CB060.ll 'leJlO- TIIHO-p03bICKHOJ1
,, " rpaJKJl3H('JHa. co6cTBeHHocT('J. , J\eSlTeJ1bHOCTIW
TaKJKe no 06eCne'leHmo 6e30nacHocTI1
06wecna 11 roCYJ\apcTBa(n. 1'1. I CT 14)
npl1HI'IM3Tb . "" co CBoeM 331<0H Pecny6J1I'1KI1
KOMnereHUl1ei1 .co He()6xOlll1Mble Mepbl 6eJ1apycb
J\JUI JaWHTb! oxpaHSIeMblX 33KOHOM npae 11 ..060nepaTI1BHo-
Cllo6o.ll 1111'1HOCT. co6cTBeHHocTH. 60r p03blCKHOM
onaCHOCTH 061llCCTB3 1'1 focynapCTBa (n I J\CSlTC!1bHOCT....'
, leT. 13).
npl1HI'IM3Tb . "" co cBoei1 3allOH Pecny6J11'11111
KOMnereHUl1ei1 He06XOJ\HMble Mepbl "'. Ka3J.1[C'f,).H
aaWIIITbl OXpmmeMbJX 3aKOHOM npall. ceo- ..06onepaTI1I1HO-
6011 11 I1HTepeCOB i»H3It'1eCIII1X 11 IOPI1lll1- p03blcllHofi
'1eCKI1X 1111U, c06cneHHocTI'I. 6e30nacHo- J\eSlTe!1bHOCT....'
CTH 06IlleCTBa. rOCYJ\apCTBa 11 yJ<penJleI-1I1S1
ero 3KOHOMI1'1eCKOrO nOTeHUl1aJlil (n. «3»
, leT. 10)
npl1HI1MIITb B npellellllX CBQHX nQJ1HOMQ- 33110H Kblprbl3-
'1I1H Bce Heo6XOllI'IMble Mepbl no 3aWHTe CKOH Pccny6J1111111
KOHCI1IT}IJlI10HHblX npaB 11 CB060Ll 'IeJlo- ..06 onepaTI1I1HO-
,, " rpaJKJ13HI1Ha. c06cTBeHHocTI1. , p03bICKHOi1
TalOKe no 06eCne'leHmO 6e30naCHOCTI1 J\eSlTenbHOCTI'I"
061lleCTB311 rocy.uapCTBa(n. 1 CT. 17)
OXpaHJlTb npaBa " 3aKOHHb!e I1Hn:peCbl 3aKOHl111TollcKOM
JKI'ITe!1di 1111TOBCKOH Pealy6J1111111 1'1 Llpy- Pecny6;iI1KI'I
fl'lX 1111U. nOnallllll1X B ci»epy OnepaTI1BHOH ..06 OnepaTI1BHOH
J\eSITeJlbHOCTH (n. 2 'I. 2 CT. 6) J\eSlTeJlbH()CTI1"
45

npoikJ!l;JKeHUe maM. 5
npl'IHI'lMaTb 2 3
B coomercTIJl'Il'I co CBoeH 3alloH Pecny5J11'11111
KOMneTeHUl'le Bce He06xOllI'IMble Mepbl MUJUlOBB
I M" "lli"'" O'P'H.oMW' ".oHOM np'" " ...06 onepaTliBHO-
Ce06011 J1t!'1HOCTI'I. BCex BIU!OB co6cTBeH- pOThICIlHOM
H()CTI'I, o6ecne'JeHI'IJI 6e:mnaCHOCTI'I ()6we- neSlTeJ1bH()CTW'
------;;-- _ CTsa 1'1 rocynapcrBa (n ...a.. 'J. 1 CT. 12)
2 OOH3aHHOCTh KCnOi1I1J1Tb nOJlY'leHIIH opra-
_"OBIOCTHItIIl CJ)ellqJaJ1bHbIM
HcnonHSlTb II npeLleJ1BX CBOI{J( nOJ1HOMQ'lI{H
I nOP>",'HH" " nH"M'HHO' OpM' OP"HO" "JaKOH ...06 onepa-
n03HBHI'IJI. CJ1ellOBaTeJ1.11. YKa3aHI1S1 npOKY- TBHO-p03bICIlHOn
pop" 1'1 peWeHI1H cyna 0 npOBelIeHl111 OPM neSlTeJ1bHOCTI'I"
no yroJlOBHbIM 11I:1IBM, npl'lHJITblM I'IMI1 K
npOM3flOnrcnw (n I 'I. 1 CT 14)
BblnonHHTb nl{CbMeHHble nopy'1eHHSI CJ1e- 3BKOH Yllpal{Hbl
nOBaTeJIJI. YKB3aHI1.11 npoKypopa. n()CTB- ...06 onepaTI'IBHO-
HOBJIeHI'IJI cyna I{ 3anpOCbl nOnHOM()'IHbIX pOJbJCKHO 111:.11-
rocynapCTBeHHbJX opraHOB. Y'1pe)l(LleHI1H 11 TeJ1bHOCTIi»
opraHI13aUI{M 0 npORe.JleHI{I{ onepaTI1BHO-
03bJCKHblxMep(n I, ICT7)
It1cnOJ1l-JJlTb nopy'1eHI1S1 CJ1enOB:.ITe1JJI. YKB 3aKoH Pecny5J1I'1KI1
:iaHI1.11 npoKYpopa 1'1 OnpelleJIeHI'IJI CYAB 0 EeJ1BpYCb
npOBelleHl111 OPM no yr0J10BHbIM neJli1M, ...06 onepaTI{BHO-
npI1HSlTb!M HMH . npOI13BOllCTBY. npell- pOThICIlHOM
CTaBJIJlTb MBTepl'laJ1bJ onepan:!BHofi AeJl- neSlTeJ1bH()CTM"
TeJ1bH()CTI1 CJIellOBaTeJIJlM npH paCCJIellO-
BBHI1I'1 I1MI'I KOHKpeTHblx yroJloBHbIX nen
6e3 pa3rJ1BWeHI1J1 I1CT04HI{KOB onepaTl{B-
HOH I'IH<\JOPMBUI'II'I (n I 'I. I CT. IJ)
It1cnOJlHSlTb nl'lCbMeHHble nop)f'JeHI1H CJ1e 3alloH Pecny5J1I'1KI1
1l0BBTeJIJI 11 YKa38HI'I.II npo,,1'JIOP3. B TaJU:e Ka3axcTaH
OnpeileJleHI1H cyna 0 npoBeLleHl11{ OPM no ...06 onepBTI1BHO-
yr0J10BHbIM lleJ1aM. HBXOj]JIll{MCH B npOM3- p03blcllHoHneH-
JlOllCTI\e3TI:!XopraHOH(n ...6»'1 Icr 10) TeJlbHOCTH»
It1cnOJIHJlTb B npCllC.1JBX CBOMX nOJ1HOMO- 3alloH Kblprbl3-
,HO nopy'leHI'IJI " nl1CbMeHHo $opMe CKOft Pecny6J1I'1KH
opraHOB n03HaH(:!JI, CJletlOBITeIlJiI. yKBJa- ...06 onepBTI1I1HO-
HI1H npoKypopa 0 npmle1leH(:!(:! OPM no p03blCKHOM
yrOJloBHbI"l neJ1BM, npl'lHJlTblM I{MI'I K npo- nCSlTeJ1bHOCTM"
1'13BOllcTBv(n. IcT. 17)
46

2
JicnOJIl-JJlTb nl1CbMCHHblC nopy<lCHI1.11 cJle
IlOBaTeJlJl, }'Ka3aHIUI npOKypopa 1'1 onpene-
neHHSI CYlla 0 npODelIeHl'I1'I OPM no yro-
nOBHblM AeJlaM. npHl-JJlTbIM I'IMI1 K npOH3-
1I0!lCTII (n. E1." I CT 12)
3 OiiSU8111IDCTh .-.eiiCTBOB3Tb II I'OO"IIIE-ICUIIII
Ie Me}l(.1l,.VH8J!0llULlMH .noroBOpaMH II ccJIepe
npaeoox3Hbi
BbInOJ1HJ1Tb Ha OCHOBC 1'1 B nopSlllKC. npc
n.yCMOTpCHHbIX Me)l(J!)'HapOLlHblMI'I noro-
BOpaMI1 POCCHHCKOH 4IclIcpaUHI'I, 3anpo-
ChI COOTDI:TCT!I}'IOWI'IX MC)I(JlYHapOllHblX
npaoooxpaHHTCJ1bHblX opraHOB Ii cnclWl-
aJ]hHblX CJ1Y}K6 HHOCTpaHHblX roCYIlapCTB
(n. 3... I CT. 14\
BbInOJ1HJ1Tb 3anpucW-- CUOllJt:lcmyJOWI'IX
Me)l(JlyHapoLlHblX npaBooxpaHI1TCJlbHblX
opraHH3aUldi 11 npaBoOXpaHHTe!1bHbiX op-
faHOB npyrl'lx rocynapcTB Ha ()CHOBaHI'II'I
!loro B Ii COHJaWCHHH (n. 2.. I CT. 7)
BbmOJ1HJlTb HB OCHOSC JlorOllOpa 11 COrIIa-
lUCH('jH 0 npaDoHoH nO:\tOI.l.lI1 3anpocbl
COOTBeTCTByIOllIHX Me)l(,Q)lHapollHblx np,,-
BOO.'<paHHTcnbHblx opraHI13Bwdt Ii npaoo-
OXpaHl'ITeJlbHblX upraH()B HHocTpaHHblx
:na B n 3 'l. I CT. 13
BbInOJ1HJ1Tb Ha OCHOBC norOBopOB (corna-
IUCH('jfi) 0 npaBOBofi nOMOIllH 3BnpOCbI
COOTBeTCTB)'IOIlII1X MC)I(.!I)'HapOJlHblX npa-
OOOWtHKnJ1bHblX OprBHtI3Bwdi Ii npaeo-
OXpaH!1TeJlbHbIX opraHOB I1HOCTpaHHblX
napcre (n. ..r» '1:. I CT. 10)
BbJn()J]HJlTb Ha OCHOBe 11 B n()pSlllKe. npe
llYCMorpeHHblX MeJKJIYHapOllHblMI1 lIoro-
BopaMI1 KbrprblJCKOM Pecny6m'lKI1. Janpo-
Cbl COOTlJeTCTByIOll.lJ.1X :\te)KjJ,YHapOllHbIX
npaHooxpaH(JTenbHblX opraH(J3D.Ul1fi, npa-
BooxpaHI1TeJIbHbrX opraHoB 11 CneU113JIb-
HbJX CJlY)K6 I1Hocrp-IHHbIX rOC}'JwpcTB (n. 4
CT. 17)
47
flpoik)/Jl(;f!Hue moo,. 5
3
3alloH Pecny6J1111111
MUJUlOB3
,,06 OnepaTI1BHO-
P03bICIIHOH.DeR-
TeJIbHOCTIi»
CJ)ellepaJIbHbr
3D.KOH ..06 onepa-
TIfBI10-pOJbICKHOM
.DeSlTeJ1bHOCTW>
3aKOH YKpal1HbJ
..06 onepaTI1BHO-
pOJbICKHOH
.DeSlTeJIbH()CTI1"
3aKOH Pecny6J1I1KJ.1
Eeflapycb
..06onepaTI1BHO-
p03bICKHOfi
.DeSlTeJIbH()Crn..
3aKOH Pecny6J1I1KI1
Ka:r'«:rnH
..06 onepaTI1BHO-
p03blCKHOfi
.De!lTeJlbHOCTI1
3aKOH KbrprblJ
CKOft Pecny6J1I1KI1
..06 OnepaTI1BHO-
P03bICIIHOH.DeR-
TeJIbHOCTI1

2
Oll:l3blBaTb no nopY'leHtIiO II C()()'[]!CJ'CT
81'111 C .DOrOBOpaMI'I (COrJlflWeHI'I1IMl'I) npa-
BOBYIO nOMOl1\b COOTBeTCTBYIOll.lHM npaBO-
OXpaHI1TeJlbHblM opraHaM llpyrx rocy-
na p CTB (n. «cO> 'I I CT 12)
4 IOOHJaHl1OCTh OOMeHHBaTbCH I1l1l)opM8l\lleii
_ C cyfu.etcr.wH OPlJ
I1I1$opMl'lpoflan llPyrl'lc opraHbl, ()cywe-
I CTBJ1S1IQUWIe OPlt Ha TeppltTopmi PocclJii-
CKOM q,eJ1epaUHI1. 0 CraBill"X 113BeCTHblMI1
4Ja,,"'J':\x npoTl1BOnpaBHoH neSrreJ1bH()CTI1,
QTHOCSlLlJI1XCJI K KOMneTCHLlHI{ 3TIiX opra-
HOB, H OKa3blBaTb :flI1M OpUHaM Heo6xo-
_I 1'1:%::;:;b(:;r:el ;a,. ocyllte-
I CTBJ1llOlliHe GPIt Hi! Teppl'lTOpl111 Pecny6-
JlI1KI1 Ee_apYCb, 0 CT:JBWI1X I'IJBeCTHblMI'I
4JaKTIlX npOTI'IBOnpaBHOH 1leJlTCJ1bHOCTH,
QTHOCSlIl{('IXCJI K KOMneTeHLlHH 3TIiX opra-
Hoe, I{ m:aJbllJaTb 11M Heo6XOlll1MYJO no-
-' ::.I1a;:;He opraHbl. Ocyute-
CTBJ1SilOlli!1e OPlJ Hi! Teppl'lTOpl111 Kb!P-
fbl3CKOH Pecny6J1I1KI'I, 0 CT:JBlliI1X I'IJBeCT-
HblMI'I $aKTaX npOTI'IBonpaBHoii neSlTeJlb-
HOCTH. OTHOCSlU\I1XCSI K KOMneTeHUIUI
3TI'IX opraHoe, 11 OKa3blBaTh 11M He06Xfi-
llHMYIO nOMOlUb (n 5 CT. 17)
HH$OpMl1pOBaTb .npyrl1e opraHbl. ocyllJ,t'-
CTBJ1SilOlUHe GPIt. 0 CT:JBWI1X I'IJBeCTHblMI'I
4JaKTax npon1BOnpaBHoH neJlTeJ1bHOCTH,
OTHOCSlW"XCJI K KOMneTHI.!"" 3TIiX opra-
HOB, " OKa3bIBaTb :fl"M oprattaM Heo6xo-
---s ==OCBOPl{
C06monaTb npaB".a KOHCnl1pamUI npH
ocywecTBJleHl111 OPIt (n S.. I CT 14)
'8
llpo()(u;JKeHue maM. 5
3
3aKOH Pecny5J11'11111
MUJUlOBa
..06 onepaT"BHO-
p03blCKHOH
neSlTeJ1bH()CTH"
(J)CllCPMbHbIH
3aKOH ..06 onepa-
TIJHO-p03b1CKHOH
neSlTeJ1bH()CTW'
3aKOli Pecny5J1I'1KI1
EeJ1apycb
..06 onepaTI1BHO-
p03bICKHO
JJ,eSlTeJ1bHOCTH»
3allOH Kblprbl3-
CKOH Pecny6J1I1KH
..06 OnepaTI1BHO-
p03blcKHOti
neSlTeJ1bHOCTH»
3aKOH Pecny5J1I'1I1H
MUJUlOBa
..06 OnepaTI1BHO-
P03bICIIH0 i1 n eJl -
TeJ1bHOCT"»
(J)ellepaJIbHblH
3aKOH ..06 onepa-
T(lHO-p03b1CIIHOfi
neSlTeJ1bHOCTH»

1 2
Co6.nKUlaTb 1"pe601JaHIHI KOHCnl1p<U.lIm npl1
OCYlllCCTB!1CHI1I1 GPIt (n 5.. 1 CT 13)
- Jli)I1Hl'IMaTb He06xODItMble Mepbl no o6ec
ne<iefil'110 IWHCnl'lpaum npJ1 npOBtllCHl'I1'I
OPM 11 HCllonyw,eHl'lIO paccet..pe'llIIiaHItlI
I'ICTO'1HI'IKOB l'IH4>oPMaulfl:l (n <\II"" 1 CT 10)
C06J1lOlUITb npac",)]a KOHCnl1paUl'I1'I "PM
ocyweCTBJleHI1H QPIt (n. 6 CT 17)
06ecnC<JCHl1e ceKpe"rHocnl onCpaTI'IBHoi1
neJlTCJlbHOCTH. KOHIJJH!leHUI'laJ1bHOCH:! 1'1
6e30nacHocTI'I JUJU, npI'lDJlC'lCHHb!X II Me-
pOnpl1S1TI1IM Onep-ITItBHOH nCSlTCJlbHOCTJ.1
(n 5.. I CT 27)
rapaHTtqJoB3H!1e KOH4!WleHUI13J'1bHOCTI'I 11
8HOHl1MHOCTH cOTpynHi1'1eCTBB (n. 4 OJ 2
CT. 6)
C06mO.MTb npaBI1J18 KQHC[mpaI.!1{1{ npl1
()cymeCTBJIeHI1I1 GPIt (n. «e» "I. I CT. 12)
6 061133J/HOCTh o6ec:ne<Dman. oo6cmetmym
- e;;.:;:::rb 06eCne'1eHI{lO e nop.llllKe.
YCTllHOBJICHHOM J3110H0ll8TC!1bCTBOM Poe-
CI1HCKOi1 (]>ellep"UI1I1. 6e30naCHOCTi1 11
C()XpaHHOCTi1 I'IMYWCCTBll CBOI'IX cOTpyn-
H"KOB. 111Ul OIlH3bIBalOl1\I1X co!!eficTBHe
()praHaM. ()CYilleCTBJ1IOUU'lM Of D.. Y'lacT-
HHKOB yronoBHoro CYLlOnpOH3BOL\CTBa. a
T:llGKe 'UleHOB cCMdl 11 6J1i1JKMX YKa3aH-
H:  c leCTynHblX nOCSIraTeJlbCTB
49
flpOOo1JKeHUe maan. 5
J
3aKOH Pecny6J1I1KH
Ee_apycb
.06 onepaTI1BHO-
p03bJCKHO ne.ll-
TeJ1bHOCTIi»
3alloH Pecny6J1111111
KH3aXCTaH
..06 onepaTI1BHO-
P03blclIHOHne.ll-
TeJ1bHO(.,I1»
3alloH Kblprbl3-
CKOti Pecny6J1I1KI'I
..06 OnepaTI1BHO-
P03blcIIHoi111eH-
TeJ1bHOCTI1»
3aKOHJ]aTBl1ticK0i1
Pecny5J1l'1KI1
..06 oncpaTl'IBHoi1
ne!lTeJlbHOCnw
3aKOHJ]I1T0I1CKoi1
Pecny5J1l'1l1l1 ..06
onepilTIIBHoHJ\eSl-
TeJ1bHOCTW'
3aKOH Pecny5J1111111
MUJUlol1a
.06 onepaTI1BHO-
p03bICKHO
lleSlTeJlbHOCTW'
q,enepaJ\bHbl
JaKOH ..06 onepa-
TeHO-p03bJCKHOH
lleSlTCJ1bHOCTW>

06ecne<1IiBaTb npl{BJle'leHl{eM .!\p)TI1X
nOJJ.Pa3J\eJ1eHI{(J 6C30naCHOCTb COTpy.!\HH-
KOB 1'1 nl1Ll, ()Ka3bl&1.I0ll\H1( nOMOWb 1'1 CO-
nericrByJOwl{x onepaTBHO-p03bICKH()n .!\e.ll-
TeJlbHOCTM, 1'1 I{X 6.11113KI1X, a noc.IIe BOJ6y-
)l(JleHI{.II yro.llOBHoro JJ,e.ll8 - Tall)KC Y48CT-
HI{KOB npouecca, .upyrl1x J!1{L4 np1{H1'I-
MaJOWI{X y<lacrne B lle.lle, I{ 'l.IIeHOB 1'13
ceMeii (n. 5 '.I. I CT. 7
06ecne<1IiBaTb 6e30nacHoCTb COTpyllHI'I-
KOB, y43CTHI1110B yrOllOBHoro cYllonpoli3-
DO!lCTBa, '.!lIeHOB I1X ceMeH 1{1I1{ 6111'13KI'IX
pOllCTBeHHI'IKOB, a TalCKe i1X 1'IMywecTBa
()T npecrynHblx 11.11i1 I1Hb!X npoTi1BOnpae-
HblX nOCJlr3TeJlbCTB(n 6'.1 I CT. I])
Oxp3Ha npaB I{ 33KOHHbIX HHTcpeCOB ceK-
peTHblX Y'laCTHI'lIlOB onepanlBHoi'l lleJl-
TeJ1bH()CTI1, 1JJ11311'1eCKI'IX 1'1 JOpl.f1lWleCKI'IX
JII1Ll, OK,,3bllJaJOLl.lI1X cOlleHCTBI1e onep,,-
TBHO" .!\ellTe.llbHOCnl (n. 2 'I. 2 CT. 61
COileficmoBTIb 06ecne<JeHI{JO B noplUIKe,
YCT3HOBJIefiHOM 33KOH0Jl8TeJlbCTBOM Kb!P-
fblJCKOH Pecny6J1i1I1I1, 6e30rIaCHOCTI'I i1
coxpaHHOCTi1 i1MYLl.leCTBa CBOi1X COTPYA-
HI{KOH, JII{Ll, OK,,3bIBaJOLl.lI1X co.neficTBl1e
OpraHID.I, ocyweCTW1S1JOLl.lI{M OP,u. Y<J3CT-
Hi1KOB yr0J10BHoro CYllOnp0i13BOilCTBa, a
TalCKe '1J1eHOB i1X ceMeH 1'1 6.111'13KI1X YKa-
33HHbiX JIi1Ll ()T npecTynHblx noc.IIra-
TeJ1bCTB(n 7CT. 17)
COileficTHOH3Tb 06ecne<JeHi1JO 6e30nocHO-
CTI'I 1'1 coxpaHHocTH i1MYLl.lCCTBa COrpyllH1'I-
KOB, '.!J1eHOB I1X ceMeii, 6.11i13KI1X, a TalCKe
Y<J8CTHI1KOB yroJIOBHOrO CYllonp0i13IJOllCT-
DB, '1J1eHOB I{X ceMefi, 6J11{3XIiX or npe-
Cl)'nHblX 1'1 I{HblX npOTI'IBOnpaBHblX nocSl-
raTeJIbCTlI(n«f»'1.lcT 12)
7 I =:1:::H:=e?::HbI rocy-
50
llpo()(u;JKeHue maM. 5
3aKOH YKpal{HbI
«06 onep3TI{BHO-
p03blCKHOi'l
lleSlTeJlbH()CTI1»
33110H Pecny6J1I{IIH
EeJ1apycb
«06 OnepaTi1BHO-
p03bJCKHOHAe.ll-
TeJlbH()CTi1»
3aKoHl11{T0l1CKoti
Pccny6J11'1Ki1 «06
OnepaTI'II1Hotille.ll-
Te.llbHOCTi1»
3allOH Kblprbl3-
CKOH PCCI]y6J1i11111
«06 OnepaTi1BHO-
p03blCKHOii
lleSlTeJ1bHOCTI1»
3aKOH Pecny6J11{1I1{
M()J1J10B3
«06 onepaTi1BHU-
p03bICKH0i1
lleSlTeJ1bHOCTH»

llpo()(u;JKeHue maM. 5
I 2 3
CBoeBpeMeHHo I1H$OpMl1pOBaTb BblClUl1e 3aKoH YKPal1Hbl
opraHbl rocynapcTDcHHOH BJlaCTIf YKpalf- «06 onepaTIfBHO-
Hbl 06 1{3BeCTHblX I{M <!>aKTax 11 l\BHHbIX, p03bICIlHOHl\eH-
CBl11leTelIbC11IyIOlUl1x 06 yrpOJe 6eJonac- Te.llbHOCTI1
H()CTtI 06lUeCTBB 1'1 rOCYl\apcrBa (n. 3 'I.. I
CT. 7)
CeoeBpeMeHHo I'IH$opMl'lpOB"Tb Y'Ipe)l(J!e- 3BKOH Pecny6lIl1KI1
HI1H rocYlWpcTDeHHoH BJ1OCTI1 11 ynpaBJ1e- KBJaXCTaH
HI1H PCCIJy6lII1U'I KaJaXCTaH 06 l13BeCTHbIX «06 onepaTI1f1HO-
"" <!>aKTaX 11 l\aHHbIX. I:BlUlerelIhCTB)'IO- p03bICIlHOHl\eH-
lUl1X 06 yrp03e 6eJOIJaCHOCT11 ()6meCTBD 1'1 Te.llbH()CTI1»
rocy.na CTBa (n «B 'I. I CT. 10)
He npe.nycMOTpeHO 3aKoH KbrprblJ-
CKOH Pecny6lIl1KIf
..06 OnepaTI1BHO-
P03bICIIHOH!leJI-
Te.llbHOCTI1»
CBoeBpeMC:HHo HH$OpM1'IpOBBHl{e Y'lpe)I(- 3aKOHJ]aTBIJHClloJi
!leHI1H rocYl\apCTBeHHOH BJ1aCTIII I{ ynpae- PeCIJy6lIlllIl{
'IeHI1H 0 p"CKpblTblX BHelUHI1X 11 BHyrpeH- ..06onepaTI1BHOI1
HI1X n()CSlraTelIbCTB  6e30IJaCHOcTb. !leSlTeJ1bH()CTI1»
060POHY. 3110HOMIi'1eCIII1H CYBepeHI1TeJ
rocynapCJBa 11 o61.l.leCTBeHHhiH nopSillOll B
HeM. B ycraHOBJ1eHHOM 3BKOHOM IJOpSlllKe
npOeeLIeHl'le Meponp1'lJlTlfH no npellOT-
opBweHl{1O 11 HeiiTpanl1JaUl{1{ ..nix nocJI-
r.uBnbCTB(n. 3'1. I CT. 27)
8 06S1JaHIIOCTb B3aR1'U'1eHCTBOBaTbccyfu.eK-
_I ;;:r;JlTb BJaI1MOlleHcTBl1e Me)l(J1y 3aKoH YKPal1HbI
c060ii I{ !lpynlMI{ IJpaf!OOXpBHllTelIbHbIMI{ «06 OnepaTI1BHO-
opraHHMI{ B UeJ1HX 6blcTporo II nQJ1Horo P03bICIIHOH!leH-
paCllpblTlJ1'I npecrynJleHl111 11 I1J06J1l{<leHI11 TeJlbHOCTI1»
BI1HOBHblX (n. 4 'I. I C1. 7)
06eCne'leHlle COTPYJ\HIWecTBa " IIOOp- 3aKOH JlaTBIJHCKOi1
411HaUI1l{ pa601bI C llpyrl'lMI1 cy61,eKTaM1'I PeCIJy61I1'IKI1
onepaTI1BHoJi J\eJlTeJlbH()CTI1 (n , . I ..06 onepaTI1BHoii
" 27) neSlTeJ1bHOCTH»
51

1 2
He npeny<:MmpeHO
06S1JaHI1OCTbOeC'THpa3BellblBaTeJlbHYIO
a60T
ClloeBpeMeHHoe nO.ll)"JeHl1e npaWlHBoi1 11
[Jon HOt:; HH$OpM31.!1{I{, HeOOXO!lHMOH W1S1
BblnOJ1HCHI1R JaJl3'J 1'1 .uOCTI'I)KCHI'ISI )'118-
:iaHHblX B CT. I 3aKOHa ueJleti npl'l l'IC-
nOJlbJtlBJ.HIU'l He06Xbl!JtMblX MeponplulT1dl
onepanlBHoH .l{eSlT)]bHOCTrj, BIWOB 11
CpCJlCTB, I\'Il:r0110B 1'1 TaKTHlI11 ee npofleJle-
HI'IJI, no B03MO;>KH()CTI1 MeHbwe BMeUll'l-
BaTbCSI II c4>epy npaD 'le.l10BeK" (n. 7 OJ I
CT. 27)
C6op, H8KamUiBaHlie. 3H3J1IB 11 peaJ1lt38-
JJI1S1 HH$OpM3UHI{, CBII33HHOti c rOCY./lap-
CTBCHHOH 6e30rIDCHOCTblO. a THlCKe co
c4>epoti 11 l'IHlJJpacrpyKTYPoi:t npeC1)'nHO-
UK (n. I 'I. 1 CT. 6)
He npenycMO"qJeHQ
Hi I 06HJ.U1I1OCb oecn o I"Oc)'-
_lVIpcmet1I1OHT3.HI1b1
06ecnc<lcH:I1C coxpaHCHI1C rocyuapcTBcH-
Hbrx cCKperoB 1'1 npyrl'lx Ba;>KHbIX DJUI rocy-
mtpCTBJ. tu-rrepecoB (n. 4 'J. I CT. 27)
He npCJlYCMorpeHO
52
npoi)O/IJ/CeHue maM. 5
3
3alloH KblprblJ
CKOi1 Pecny6J1I1KH
.06 onepaTliBHQ-
P03bICIIHOHllCH-
TCJlbHOCTW'
3"KoHJTarBHii
Pecny61U1KH
..06 OnepaTI'IBHOH
neSlTCJJbH()CTI'I»
3aKOH lh1TOBcKOH
Pecny5JWIIIH 06
OnCpaTI'IDHOHnCn-
Te.llbH()CTI1»
3aKOH Kblprbl3-
CKOH Pecny6l1lill(J
..06 onepaTIiBHO-
P03blcIIHoi1ne.ll-
Te.llbHOCTIi"
3aKOHRaTI\I1HClloi1
Pecny6nl{l<M
..06 onepaTIiBHoi1
ne!lTeJlbHOCTiW
3aKOH Kblpr!>IJ-
CKOH Pecny6l1liKIi
..06 onepaTIiBHo-
p03bICKH0i1
ne!JTeJlbHOCTW'

OKOII'laHUe marin. 5
II lJOHLlI1I1OCTbnpCnI'lTCTBOB3TbROBJIC'ICHHKI
BRn nIt)KI.II,CRTeJlbHOC'T"
3"w11Ta 1II1U OT npoCOK<luuii 3KHIBHoro
OKaJbiBacMoro npOT"B BOJ1I1 Ha)KliMa. C
UCJlblO 0CYIUCCTBJlCHI1J1 npecrynHoH ncSI-
TeJ1bHOCTH n. 3'1 2 CT. 6
He npeJlYCMOTpeHO
3alloHJ11IT0IJCKoi1
Pccny6JU'lKI1 .,{)6
OnepaTI'IBHOHlICH-
TCJ1bHOCTI1»
3aKOH KbrprblJ-
CKOi1 Pccny6J1I1KI1
..06 onepaTI1BHO-
P03blcIIHoi1ncR-
TCJ1bH()CTI1"
06HMHHOeDI CJfIfaHOB, OC)IlIeC'T1IJIAJOUlHX OPD., npeD:jcMaTpHBaIOT
CJJelI)IOlltHCCT3Tbll3aKOHOB,
CTaTbl1 14 CJ)ellcpa.rlbHoro 3aKOHa ..06 oncpaTBHO-pOJbJCKHoi1lIcA-
TCJ1bH()CTW.
CTaTbl1 7 3alloH8 YKpalJHbJ ,,06 onCpaT(\BHO-P03blcKH0i1 nCSlTeJ1b-
HOCTW..
CTaTh(\ 13 3aKOHa Pecny5J1(\II(\ lieJJapYCb ..06 oncpamBHo-p03bICKHO
ACHTe.llbHOCTI1».
CTaTbl1 10 3aKoHa PCCny6J1liKI'I KaJaXCTaH ..06 onepaTHBHo-
P03blcKHoi1.neRTeflbHOCT(\"
CTaTbl1 17 3aK0H8 KblprbJJCKoi1 Pccny5J11'11111 ..06 OnCpaTI'IBHO-
p03bICKH0i1 nCRH:J1bHOCTW..
CTaTbl1 27 3aKOHa JlaTBI1i1cKoi1 PCCny6J1I1KI1 ..06 onepaTBHoi1 ncSI-
TCJ1bHOCTI1»
CTaTbl1 6 3"KoHa JlI'ITOBCKOri Pccny5J1111111 ..06 oncpaTHBHori lICSI-
TCJ1bH()CTW.
CraThH 12 3aKoHa Pccny5J1lJK MClJ1J{oBa ..06 oncpamBHo-p03blCKHOii
ACSITC.IIbH()CTI1».

Ta61I11l.ta6
"HOeOnpeileJ]eH"eMepOnp"S1T"ii
B Onep3THBHO-pa1l>K'Kt1l.lX JaKOH3X CTpaHaX CHr " 63J1TH"
HOu.'IIfflO6UHUe
IV<> OnpeiJe,1eHue onepamU6Ha-pa'jbiCKHbiX HlKOJ«XJameflbHbiX
Oy, W!pot1fJ1U1mUU Of<n106, penONeH-
mUj)V1Vf4U'COPjJ,
--J- 2 3
I OllepaTBHo-p.BblCl\l1I>IeMepOnpHIITHII.OC-
_ _ 1I0BaHHbie lIa KPIIIIHHaJlHCTIl'leCKHX MeTOlln <J;oe.nepanbHbltl3a-
1.1. Unpoc rpa)l(lliUJ (n.1 'I. 1 CT. 6)
KOII «06 onepa-
TI1BHO-p03bICKHO
neIlTeJlbHOCTH»
Onpoc 1l1U C I1X CorJ1acl1l1. I1CnO.llb30B2HI1e 3aKoH YKpal1Hbl
I1X n06pOBO!1bHOH nOMOLUH (n I, I CT. 8) «06onepaTHBHo-
p03b1CKHO llell-
Te.%HOCTH»
Onpoc rpa)l(!JaH (n.1 CT. 5) 3aKoH Pecny6lI1iKH
EieJl2Pycb
«060nepaTHBHO-
P03blcKHo!:llleSl-
TCJ1bHOCTH»
Onpoc rpaJKJIaH. A()J])KH()CTHbiX J1HU. no 3aKoH Pecny6lIl1KI'I
J1}'4eHHe OT HHX I1Hl11opMaQHH (a63. 1 n_ 2 Ka3BXCTaH
CT. II) «06onepaTHBHo-
P03blc"HOHne.A-
TeJlbHOCTH"
Onpoc rp!1)l(!J3H (n.1 cr. 1) 3aKOH Kblprbl3-
CKOrl Pecny6lIHKI1
«06 onepaTHBHO-
p03bICKHO llell-
TCJ1bHOCTH»
OnepaTI1BHbltl onpoc (onepaTI1BHbltl 00- 3aKoHlTaTBI'It!-
pOC - 3J1eMeHT TaKot! CTMI1H opn. KaK CKOH Pecny6}U'lKH
onepaTHBHoe paCC.IletlOBaHHe) (n. 1-2, IJ:. I «06 OnepaTHBHO
CT 9) neHTeJlbHOCTH»
P,,3BellbiBaTCJ1bHbltl onpoc (n. 7 nOCT"Hoe- 3aKoH JhnoBcKot!
J1CHI.JSI BepxoBHoro COBeTa lTl'ITOBCKOH PecnyfuU'lKH
Pecny6.1lHKI1 0 BBeJleHl111 B .neilcTBHe 3a- «06 Oneparl1BHO
KOHa 06 OnepaTI'IBH()H neHTeJlbHOCTI1) neHTenbHOCTH»
54

1 2 3
Onpoc rpaJKIUIH (n .a. CT. 6) 3aKOH Pccny6J1I1KI'I
MOJ1.!\oBa
..06onepaTI'IBHo-
p03bICKHO!:! neSl-
- Te.bHOCTW'
1.2, HaBeJleHl1e cnpaeOK (n. 2'1. I CT. 6) (f)e.J:epaJ]bHbJ
3aKOH ..06onepa-
TI:IBHO-p03bICKHOR
.IIeJIT;:[bHOCTI{"
It1CT]Je60BaHl1e. c60p 1l0KYMeHToB 11 DaH 3aKoH ¥Kpal1Hbl
HblX, xapaKTepl'lJ}'IOWI'IX .ueIJTeJ1bHOCTb .. 06 onepanlBHO-
npe1lnptmTl:lti. Y4pe)l(JlfHI1H. opraH('j3aL[I{H. po3blCKHOH J\eSl-
, TalOKe o6paJ )/(113HI1 ()r.ne.llbHbIX J11'IU, renbHOCTI1»
nOllU3peBaeMblX B nOllrOTOBKe I.JJlI1 COBep-
rueHl'I11 npeCT)'[]J1eHI'IR. I'ICTO'1HHK 1'1 p-
McnblI1XJ\OX01l0B (n 4'1.1 CT 8
HaBeJIeHl1e cnpaooK (n. 2 CT. 5). 3aKoH PecnyfuJliKI'I
lt1C1]Je60B<lHl'le. cGop 1'1 113)"1eHl'le 1l0IlYMeH- 6eJlapycb
TOB 11 CBI:t\eHHH, IIOTQpb!C xapmCrepl'l3YIOT ,,060nepanJBHO-
nelJreJ1hHOCTb npeD,npHTj:j, Y4peJK1lfHI'IH, po3blCKHOii nes-
()praHl1Jauj{, aTIllCKe o6pa3 >KI1JHI'I N- Te.llbHOCH:!»
llCJIbHblX 111'1U. nOl103pcB<ICMbiK B nonroTOBllc
}1111{ COaepWeHlU1 npeCl)'!lJ1eHiJSI, I'ICTO'IHI'IK
11 Dd3NeDblI'lX nOXOllOB n. 7 CT_ 14
HaocllcHl'lc cnpaBoK. npoBqJKa no }"JeTaM 3aKoH Pecny6J1I1KIf
Y4pe)l(J\eHI1ii, npClInpl'llHHH . opraHI13a- Ka33xcT3H
UMn (He3aeI1CI1MO OT nOll'lI1HeHHOCTI1 11 ,,06onep3TrIBHQ-
.pOpM c06CTBeHHOCTI'I) (003. 8 n. 2 CT. II). po3blCKHOI'I neSl-
npoBqll<a no onepanlBHblM. KpI'lMI'IHa.rm- TeJ1bHOCTI'I"
CTIJ'IeCKI'IM Y4eTaM 1'1 I:I'ICTeMBM yr0J10BHOii
perl1CToaUl111 (a63 17 n. 2 CT. II)
HaBeDeHl1e cnpaOOK (n. 2 CT 7) 3aKoH Kblprbl3-
cKoii Pecny6J1I'1KIf
,,060nepaTl'IBHO-
P03blCKHOI'I neSl-
TeJ1bHOCHI"
HaeelleHl'le cnpaooK (n. "B CT. 6) 3aKOH Pel:ny6J11IKI'I
MOJl1l0Ba
,,06onepanJBHO-
p03b1CKHOii
ne.llTeJ1bHOCT..
flpOOo IJK:eHue mOOf. 6
55

npooo,J;JKeHuemafiJl.6
I Z 3
1.3, O6cneJ:\oeaHl{e nOMeWeHJ1H. ;YJaHI1H, @e.aepaJIbHbIH3a-
cooPY)Kel-m. }"IaCTKOB MecTHOCTH I{ 1paHc- KOH ..06 onepa-
noprHblXCpeJlCTB (n.8 '.I. I CT. 6) TIJBHO-p03bICKHOM
nCSlTeJlbHOCTIf»
06CJ1e.LlOBal-.me )KtlJ1bIX 11 .upyrlJx nOMewe- 3aKoH YKpaHHbl
HI{H C C0rJ18CHJI I1X BJ13.1!elIbllfB HJ1t1 06H- ..06onepaTIJBHO-
TaTeJ1eH rum BbHlCHeHlliI ()6CTOSlTeJ1bCTB P03blcKHOH.ueSl-
C(lBepWeHHoro 11J11{ rOTOBSIwerOCJI npecry- TenbHOCTIJ»
nJ1eHHH (n 6 '.I. I C1. 6) 3aKoH Pe
06CJ1Cll()BaHl1e nOMeWCHI1H. :maHI1H. co-
OPY}l(CHI1H, Y<JI!CTI\OB MeCTHOCTI{ 11 TpaHC- E)eJ1apycb
nupTHblX cpcnCTB (n 8CT5) ..06onepaTIJBHO-
P03bICKHOj{ .ues-
TeJ1bHOCTW'
llocMoTp }l(l{lIblX nOMeWCHI1I1. pa6o<JI{X I{ 3aKOH Pecny6J1I{KI1
tlHblX MeCT (a63. IS '.I 2 CT. II) KaJaxcTaH
..06onCpBTI'IBHQ-
P03blcKHoi1.ueSl-
TeJ1bHOCTW>
06CJ1e.LloBBHI{C nOMCmCHI1H. 3.IlBHI{H, <0- 3aKOH Kblprbl3-
Op}')KCHI1H. Y'lacTIlOB MeCTHOCTIf 11 TpaHC- CKOH Pccny6J1I1KI1
nOj)THbIXCPC.lLCTB (n. 8 CT. 7) ..06onepaTIJBHO-
po3bICKHOA .ueH-
TeflbHOCTIJ»
OnepaTHBHblH ()CM()Jp (n. 3 'l. I CT. 6) 3aKoH flaTBI1HCKOH
Pccny6J1I1KI'I
..06 ()nepaTI1BHOii
JJ,CSlTelIbHOCTI{"
Ti1HHOC ocyweCTImeHl1e OC),tOTpa nOMC- 3i11WH JhnOBCIIOH
lUeHI1H «()nepaTI1BHbIH OCMOTp) (n. ..a» 'i I Pccny6J1I1KIJ ..06
CT. 6) onepaTI{BHOH.uCIJ-
TC.bHOCTIJ»
06CJ1ell()BaHHC nOMCmCHI1H. :maHI1H. co- 3aKoH Pccny6J1I1KI1
OPY}l(CHI1H. Y<JacTI<OB MeCTHOCTI1 11 TpaHC- MOJ1DOBa
nupTHblX cpcnCTB (n "I" CT. 6) ..06 OnepaTIJBHO-
poJbICKHOH .ue5!-
TeJlbHOCTIJ»
56

npooo,J;JKeHuemafiJl.6
1 2 3
1.4, C60p 06paJUOB WLII cpaBHI1TenbHOCO cDe.aepa.rlbHb!fl3aKOH
I1CCJ1ellOBaHI-rn (n.3'1.1 CT. 6) .06 ()nepaTBHo-
po3b1CKH()n
.u:eSlTeJ1bHOCTH»
Coop ()6pa3U()B WLII CpaBHI1TeJ1bHuro I{C 3aKOH Pecny6J1I{KH
CJlellOBaHI1 (n 3CTS) 6eJlapycb
,,060nepmIBHo-
p03b1CKHOfl
JIeHTeJlbHOCT»
Or6op np06 11 06pB3LlOB }]J1 I1CCJlellOBa- 3aKOH Pecny6J1I{KH
HI1$1 (a63. 9n.2c1.ll) Ka3aXCTaH
(,060nepaTHBHo-
po3bICKHOH neSl-
TI:JlbHOCnl"
C60p ()6pa3U()B }]J1J1 CpaBHI1TeJ1bHOrO I1C- 3aKoH KblprblJ-
CJII:llOBaHI1 (n.] CT. 7) cKofi Pecny6J1I1KH
,,06onepBn'!BHo-
p03bICKHOn
JIeSlTeJlbHOCTIf»
OnepaTl1eHOe n()J]}I'l.eHl1e 06pB3LlOB 3aKoH JlaTBl1ficKOn
(n 4'1..1 CT 6, n_ I CT. 12) Pecny6JJHKI'I
,,06 OnepaTI1BHOii
JIeSlTeJlbHOCTI{"
H3'bIlTlfe MBrepl18J10B, JIOK}lMeHTOB, Cblpbll, 3aKOHJ1IfToBclloii
06pa3L10B npOilYKLllf1f H JIpyrHX o61,eIlTOB Pecny6J1IfKIII ,,06
wm IfCCJlellOBaHI1J1 6e3 Co06Il{eHH 06 I1X onepaTIfBHofille-
113MITI11-1 (n."B '1..1 C1.6) TeJlbHOCTH»
Coop MBTepl18J10B, 06paJLlOB }]J1 CpaBHI1- 3aKOH Pecny6J1IfKH
TeJlbHoro HCCiH)J,()lJaHIfSi (n. "C» CT. 6) MOJl1l0Ba
,,06 onepanlBHo-
p03bICKHOn
JIeSlTeJlbHOCTIf»
1.5. npoaepo<IHaSI JaK)lnKa (n. 4 'I. 1 CT. 6) @ellep8JIbHbln
3aKOH ,,06onepa-
THBHO-p03bICKHOO
JIeSlTeJlbHOCTIf»
57

npooo,J;JKeHuemafiJl.6
I 2 3
KOHTpOJ1bHaSi 3aKynKB TOBapOB C L(CJ1blO 3aKoH YKpaHHbl
Bb1JlBJ1eHHSI npOTl1BonpaBHOH lleSlTCJ1bHO- ,,060nepanJBHO-
cTl:l(n 2, I CT. 8) P03bICKHOj{ .neSl-
TeJJbHocn:!»
KOH'TpOJJbHble 3aKynKH (n. 4 CT. 5) 3aKoH Pecny6J1I1KIJ
6e.rmpycb
,,060nepan:!BHO-
P03bICKHOj{ .neSl-
TeJJbHocn:!»
KOHTpo.llbHble 3aK)'TIKIi (003. 10 n. 2 CT. II) 3aKOH Pecny6J1HKI1
Ka38XCTaH
,,06onepaTIiBHO-
po3bICKHOH .neSl-
TeJJbHOCTIi»
npOeepO'lHble 3aKynKI1 (n. 4 C1. 7) 3aKoH Kblprbl3-
CKOM Pecny6.1UJKIi
,,060nepaTIIIBHO-
po3bICKHOH lle-
TeJJbHOCTI1»
KOHTpoI1bHaSI 3aK)lnKil TOBapoB (n. "r» CT. 6) 3aKoH PecnyfuJHKI1
Mo.rr.noBa..06
onepaTIIIBHO-
po3blCKHOii lle-
TeJJbHOCTH»
1.6, It1cCJlell()BaHl1e npeLlMeTOB 1111()KYMeH <I:oe.nepaJIbHblH
TOB (n. 5 'I. I cr. 6) 3aKOH ,,06onepa-
TIJBHO-P03bICKHOH
neSlTeJlbHOCTH»
JhY'leHl1e .n()IIYMeHToB 11 D,aHHblX. xapaK- 3aKoH YKpal1Hbl
Tepl13YlOWI.JX ne}ITeJlbH()CTb npeLlnpl:!SlTHH. ..06onep"TI:!BHO-
Y4peJK1leHlJM, OpraHlJ3m.!l1H. a TalOKe 06pa3 po3blCKHOH .ne-
JKH3HI1 OTlleJlhHblX JlI1L(. n()J!03peBaeMblx B TeJlbHOCTIi"
no.nrOTODKe I.JJlI1 cOOCpWeHlJlJ npecTYIJJ1C-
HI1JI. lJCTO'IHI1K " pa3Mepbl I1X nOXOLl()B
(n.4'1.1 CT. 8)
HCCJlellOtiaHl1e npellMeTOB l111oKYMeHToe 3aKoH Pecny6J11'IKIJ
(n.5cr5) 6eJlapycb
,,06 onepaTHBHO-
P03bICKHOj{ lleSl-
TeflbHOCTI1»
58

npoiJotlJK:eHUe maM. 6
1 2 3
npeliBapHTeJIbH()e IfCCJIelIOBaHlfe 06Hapy- 3aKoH Pecny6JIIfKIf
JKeHHbIX. HenJ8CHO 3;UPMKCl1pOBaHHblx " Kil3aXCTaH
1f3'bSlTbIX CJ1ell()B npon:!BOnpaBHblX neSlHI1 ..06onepaTI1BHO-
(a6J. 13 'l. 2 CT. II) po3blCKHOH lleSl-
TeJlbHOCTW'
HCCJIel1013aHHe npCllMeTOB 11110KYMeHT013 3aKoH Kblprbl3-
(" Scr.7) CKOt! Pecny6J1IfKI1
..06 onepaTI1BHO-
P03blcKHol'llieSl-
TeJlbHOCTM"
OnepaTI1BHOe I1CCnenOBaHHe (n. 2 CT '2, 3aKoH l1aTBI1HCKOH
n_4'l ICT6) PecnyfuJMKI1
..06 onepanllJHofl
- llCSlTbHOCTH"
HccnenoBaHHe M8Tepl1aJ10B, nOKYMeHToB, 3aKOHJllfToficilOH
Cblph!!. 06pa3uoe npollyKUHI1 " llpyrl1x Pecny6JII1KH
06"bCIIT013(n."B» 'l. I CT. 6) ..06 ()nep:nI'lBHOW
lle}lTenbHOCT..
It1ccnellOOaHl1e npeJ1MeTOB 1'I110K)'MeHTOB 3aKoH Pecny6JII1KI'I
(n...g..cr.6) MOJIllOBa
..06 OnepaTI1BHO-
P03bICKHot!lleSl-
TeJlbHOCTH..
1.7. OrO*1leCTMeHl'le Jll1'mocnl (n. 7 'l. I <I:oeliepaJIbHblt!
cr61 3aKOH ..06onepa-
TI'IBHO-p03bICKHOO
lleSlTeJlbHOCTI1»
OrO*1leCTBJ1eHHC JIH'lH()CTIII (n 7CT.S) 3aKOH Pecny6JIHKI'I
Eenapycb
..060nepanJBHO-
P03blcKHol'llieSl-
TeJlbHocnl"
nOMCK IJ OTOJK.llfCTBJ1eHl1e 1I11'1HOCTI1 "0 3aKOH Pecny6JIHKI1
npl1MeTaM (a63. 12'1 2 Cl II) KaJaxcTaH
..06onepaTI'IBHo-
po3bICKHO lleSl-
TeJlbHOCTI'I..
59

2
OrO*1lCCTBJ1eHl1e J111"1H()CTI'I (n 7 CT. 7)
OnepaTI'IBH()e ()6CJ1eJ!()BaHl1e JII'lUa (n. S
<I_lcT.6)
YCTaHoaneHl'le nWHOCTIf (n. ..h» CT. 6)
1_8. Ha6J11011CHHC ([J 6 '{. I CT. 6)
B113YaJ1bHoe till6J110JleHI'II': B ()61l1I':CTBeHHbIX
MeCTax c npl1MCHCHI'ICM IPOTO-. KI1H()- 1'1
BH1leOC'beMKI'I, OnTI'I'ICCKI1X 1'1 paIU:IOnpl'l60-
pOB, npyrl'lx TeXHI1'1CCKI'IX cpeIlCTB (n. II
I CT. 8)
Hi16J1IOJlCHl1e (n.6cT.5)
Ha6J1lOaCHl'lt, B TOM 'men!': C I1cnQJ1b30Bil-
ImeM TCXHIf'1CCKI'IJ( CpCllCTfI (aylUlO- 1'1 111'1-
neOJanl1cl1. KI1H()<)JOTOCbeMKI'I 1'1 npynJX
TeXHI1'1CCKI:IX CPeJlCTB) MaTepl1aJlOB 11 Be-
lllccm. He ttaHOCIIllHX BpeJ1B }l(1'I3HJ.1. 3110-
pOBblO H OI<pY>KaIQWCW cpClle (a63 6 n. 3
CT II)
OnepaTI'IBH()e Ha6moneHHc (n. 14 CT. 7)
60
npoi)O/IJ/CeHue maM. 6
3
3aKoH Kblprbl3-
CKOrl Pecny6J1l'1KI1
..060nepaTI'IBHO-
po3blCKHOH llCSI-
Te.bHOCTH"
3aKoH llaTBl1wcKoA
Pecny6J1I1KH
..060nepaTliBHofi
lICSlTC:ibHOCTIf"'
3aKoH Pccny6J1I1KI'I
MOJUlOBa
..06onep"TlJBHO-
po3blCKHOH JlCf1-
TeJlbHOCTH»
@e.aepanbHbli1
.aKOH ..06onepa-
TI'IBHO-p03bICKHOO
.o:eSlTC.:JbHOCTH»
3aKoH YKpaHHbl
..06o!1CpanJBHO-
po3blCKHO!:l ncSl-
TCJ1bHocn:!»
3aKOH Pecny6JUIKH
6enapycb
..06oncpan:!BHo-
P03bICKHO ncs-
TeJlbHOcnl"
3aKOH Pecny6J11IKI1
Ka33xcTafi
..06onepanIBfio-
po3blCKHOI'I neSl-
TeJlbHOCTW"
3aKOH Kblprbl3
CKOrl Pecny6J1l'1KI1
..06onep"TwBHO-
po3bICKHO neS]-
TeJlbHOCTI1"

npooo,J;JKeHuema6il.6
1 2 3
OnepaTI1BHoe Hafi.r1lOJ!eHl1e (CJ1e)l(Ka) (n. 2 3aKOH l1aTBI{McKoif
'I. I CT. 6, CT. 10) Pecny6J1I1KI1
...06 OnepaTI1f!HOA
lleSlTbHOCTI{"
1l1{'IHaSI 1'1 niiHaSI CJ1eJKKa (n. 7 nOCTIIHOf!- 3aKoHllI1TOBCKO
JIeHtm BepX013HOru C013eTa 1ll{TOBCKOii Pecny6J11{1<IJ
Pecny6J11{1<IJ 0 BBCLleHI1H 13 lldkTBl1e 3a- 06 onepaTI{BHOH
KOHa 06 onepaTI1BHOH AeHTeJ1bHocTIJ) .IIeSlTeJ1bHOCTI{"
BH3y3J1bHoe Ha6J1IOJ],CHl{e (n "c"cT.6). 3aKoH Pecny6J1I{KI1
Ha6JJIO.IIeHHe 1'1 n()IIYMeHTlfpOBaHHe C I1C- MOJ11l0Ba
n()J1b3QBaHl1eM coBpeMeHHblx ",erOlKlB " ,,06 onep"TIiBHO-
TeXHI1'1eCI<IJXCpe.llCTB(n ..dCT.6) po3blCKHOA neSl-
TeJ1bHOCTIi"
1.9. KOHTpOJ1l1pyeMaIJ flOCTaBKa (n. 13 'I. I Q)ep3J1bHblii
cr6) 3aKOH ,,060nepa-
TIJBHO-P03bICKHOH
AeSiTellbHOCT"
B uellllX BblSlBlleHH.II npenyI1peJKIIeHl1.11 11 3aKoH Pecny6J1I{KI'I
flpece'leHH.II flpeCTyl1J1eHlill, a TInOKe npl1'1a- KaJaxCTaH
CTHblX II HI1M J1I1U ()cyJ.UeCl1JJIffi'b ()nepal1'lB- ,,06 OnepaTrIBHO-
HblH 1I0HTpOJ1b nOCTaBOK TOBapOB, BewecTB po3blCKHOI'I neSl-
1'1 HHblX J.laH:p3J1bl'IbIX ueHHocreif, SlflJlSlJO- TeJ1bHOCTIi"
WI1XCSI npellNeTIUIIl{ npeCT)'nHOii lleSlTI:J1bHO-
CT I{ npe.l{l'Ia3HB'IeHHblX K npoBQ3Y. Bblf!(ny
1'IJ11{ BIIWy Ha reppltTopl1lO Pecny6J1I1KI1 Ka-
3dXCTilH (n.«M" 'I. I cr. 8)
KOHTpoJ1l1pyeMble flOCTaDKII (npoDep04Hble 3aKoH Kblprbl:J-
flOCTaBKH) (n. 6 CT. 6) CKoA Pecny6J1HKI'I
..06onep"TIiBHO-
po3blCKHOI'I nes-
- TeJ1bHOCTIi"
1.10. OnepaTMBHblH 3KCnepl1MeHT (fl " (J.Iellep3J1bHbl
'I_I CT. 6) 3aKOH ..06 onepa-
TIJBHO-p03bICKHOH
lleSiTellbHOCTIf»
61

npoi)O/IJ/CeHue maM. 6
1 2 3
OnepaTI'IBHbltl: 3KCnepl'lMeHT Ie 7 <. I 3aKoH llaTBl1wcKotl:
cT.6.cT.15) PecnyfuJl1KI'I
...o60nepaTl'IBHofi
lleSlTbHOCT"
nOCCwaTbllPyrl'le 11 )Kl'IJlb1e n()MeWeHI1J1 C 3aKOH YKpal1Hbl
corJlaCI1.11 I'IX BJ1aneJIbueB I'IJIl'I 0611T8TeJIeW «06onepaniBHo-
ll!I.II BbI.IICHeHI1.11 06crol'renbCTe coeeprneH- po3blCKHOfi lleJl-
HO.-O I'IJIl'I TOTOBSIll!e.-ocSi npeC1)'nJIeHI'IJI, a TeJIbHOCTI'I"
TaK)!(C C06l'1paTb CDCneHI111 0 npOTI'IBO-
npaBH()W lIeSlTeJIbHOCTI1 nOllo3peBaeMbix
'II'IU, B ()THOUJeHI1I1 KOTOpblX npOBOlll'ITCSI
mXlBeOKB (n. «6 'I. I CT. B)
EecnpenSlTCTBeHHo BX01ll'lTb B Jll060e I1pe- 3aKoH Pecny6JI1iKI1
MJI C)'TOK HB TepptlTOpl'l1O 1'1 B nOMellleHl'Ili KaJaxcTaH
npelInpl'lJlTI'IH. Y'1pe)KlJeHl'IH 11 ()p.-aHI'I3<1- «06onepaniBHo-
Ul'ltl: (He3"BI1Cl'IMO OT 4JOPM C()6CTBeHHo- po3blCKHOtl: neSl-
CTI1). B HB TepplltoplllO BOI1HCKI1K 'I3CTdi TeflbHOCTLJ"»
1'1 1IPYrl'lK pe)l(l1"'HblK 06beKTOB - no co-
TJlacoBaHl11O C l'IK pYKOBOlUfl"eQJlMI'I. TOJIt,-
KO , ueJIJlK npOBeneHl'IJi OPM. npeny-
CMOTpeHHbIX cr. " HacTO.lllJ..teTO -3aKoHB
'e. «W>'I. I CT. B)
OnqJaTI'IBHblH 3KcncpMMcHT (n. 15 CT. 7) 3aKOH KbIPI1>!J-
CKOW Pecny6J1l'1KI'I
«06onepaTI1BHO-
po3blCKHOfi ne!l-
TeJlbHOCTI1"
TaHHO npOHl'llIaTb B l<BapTlipy. nOMeI1!C- 3aKOH J1dTBMHCKOfi
1'11'111. TpaHcno(YfHble cpc::acTBa 1'1 apyrl'le Pecny6JII'IKI'I
nyfuJl1"lHO HenocTynHble ()6beKTbl B ueJlJlx «06 ()neparI1BHO
06ecne'leHI'IJI npOBeneHI1J1 MeponpliSlTI1t1: .neHTe;'JbHOCT"
onepaTI'IBHOfi !lfJlTeflbHOCTI1 (CT. 14)
BXOJUJTb B nOMeweHMJI npe1lnp('jJlTI'IH. Y'!- 3aKOHll('jToBCKo
pe)KlJeHMfi. opmHM3a(l('Jfi, npoH]IJ01lI'lTb Pecny6]]MI<I:!
KOHTpOJlbHble npoBepKI'I. TeXHO;'J()rl1'leCKl'le ...06 ()neparI1BH()W
3KCnepI1MeHTbI. 113blMBTb MBTepl.J8J1b1, .no- .ne.llTeJlbHOCT"
KYMeHTbl. cblphe 1'1 06p8311b1 npOJ:!YKL[MM 1'1
J:!pY.-He 06'beKTb! 1lJ1S1 IICC11t:00B3HMSI 60 co-
o6weHIiSI ()6 I1X I'I:J'WITI'II'I (n «B» <J. I C1.6)
62

-+-t- UnepaTHBHO-paJLICKHe MepOnpH:ATIIH, OC.
_ HOeaHHbJe Ha IM-me.'!LleareJlbHblX MerolUlX
2.1. KOHrpOJlb nt."HOBbiX ompaHJleHl1 Te-
l1erpa<t>Hblx I1l1HblX C006Il.lfHHH (n. 9 '1. I
CT. 6)
KOHT)JOJlb n}'Tel>! oT5opa no ()TneJ1bHbIM
npl1.maKaM Tenerpa<jJHO-nO'lTOBbIX OT-
npaBJ1eHHH (n. 10'1 I CT. 8)
KOHlJIOJlb nO'JTOBO TeJlerpa4JHblx OTnpae--
neHI1i1 {n. 9 CT. 5)
KOHT)JOJlb nO'JTOBbiX OTnpaBJ1eHI1H (a63. 2
n_ 3 CT. II)
KOHlJIOJlb nO'JTOBblX OTnpaBJIeHl'lii TeJle-
rpa4>Hblx 11 I1HblX co06wel-mi1 (n. 9 CT. 7)
OnepaTl'lBHblii KOHTpOJ1b 311 KoppecnOH-
neHUl'ldt (n. 9 'I. I CT 6. n. I 'I I CT. 17)
C[JeUHaJlbHbIH KOHlJIOJIb nO'JTOBbIX nOCb[-
n()K (n. 1 nOCTaHOBJIem'l.ll BepXOBH()fO Co-
BeTa J]I1TOBCKOtl PecnyfuJl1K1i 0 BBe1leHI1H
II neHCTBlJe 3aKOH3 06 onepaTliBHOM neH-
TeJ1bHOCTH)
KOHT)JOJlb nO'JTOBbTX OTnpaBJIeHl'lft (n. ..j,.
CT6)
63
npoi)O/IJ/CeHue maM. 6
<I:oe.nepaJIbHblfI
aaKOH ,,06onepa-
TI'IBHO-p03bICKHOk
neSlTeJIbHOCTH»
3aKoH YKpaHHbl
..06onep"THBHO-
p03b1CKHOHlieSl-
TeJlbHOCTW>
3aKoH Pecny6J1I1KI'I
6eJlapycb
..06onepaTrJBHO-
po3b1CKHO .!\eSl-
re.bHOCTW'
3aKoH Pccny6J1I1KI'I
Ka3aXCT3H
..06onepaTI'IBHO-
po3blCKHOii J\eSl-
TCJlbHOcnl»
3aKoH Kblprbl)-
CKOrl Pecny6J1l'1KI1
"06onep,,nIBHo-
po3bICKH0i1 J\eSl-
TeJlbHOCnl&
3a1<Of:!
J]aTBHCKOn
Pecny6J1I1KH
,,06 onepaTlIBHoli
J\eSlTe;J1>HOCTI{»
3aKoHJ]I1TOBClloii
Pecny6JJI1KH
«D6 ()nepaTI1BH()1{
J\eSlTe;JbHOCTIi<'
3aKOH Pecny6,rrI1KH
MOJmooa
«D6onep1TIIBHO-
po3blCKHOli J\eSl-
TeJlbHOCTW'

1 2 3
Onepan1BHblH nOI1CK no HHeWHI1M np(']- 3aKoH Pecny6l1I{KI1
3HaKaM I-Ja nO'ITOBO-TeJ1erpa$Hblx KaHaWX KaJ.axcHUJ
Cl\,II3111 (a63. J n. JCT 11) ,,060nepanJBHO-
po3blCKHOI'I neSl-
TeJlbHOCTW'
CHSlTlJe I'IH4IopMaUI'lI1 C TeXHI'I'IeCKI1X Ka 3aKoH Kblprbl3-
HaJ10RCHSl311 (n. 11 CT 7) CKOti Pecny6JU'lKI1
,,060nepaTI'IBHO-
po3bICKHOA lles-
TeflhHOCTH»
UeH3}'pa KOppec(J()HlleHLUlI'I ocy;KlleHHblx 3aKoH Pecny6J1I1KI'I
(a63. I n. JCT. 11) Ka3aXCTBH
,,06onepan:lBHO-
po3bICKHOH lleSl-
TeJlbHOCTH»
He npeuycMOlpeHO 3aKoH Kblpn>l3-
CKOti Pecny6J1l'1KIf
,,060IlCpanJBHO-
po3blcKHoHlles-
TeJ1bHOCnJ»
npOCMaTpl1BaHiJe KoppecnOH.1leHLUm ocy- 3akOH Pecny6J1HKI1
)I(l!eHHblx(n. "K"'CT. 6) MOJl1loBa«06
onepaTlJBHO-
po3blCKHOti neSl-
TtJ1hHOCn'I»
2.2, npocnylllllBaHlfe TeJIe<]JoHHblx nepe <I:oenepaJIbHbl1!
TOBopoB(n 10'1.1 CT. 6) IaIlOH
,,06onepaniBHo-
po3bICKHOA lles-
'JeJlbHOCTI1»
npocnywHHD.HHe Te.e<]JOHHbIX neperOBO- 3alloH Pecny6l1I{KI'I
pOB I1I1HblX neperOBopOB (n. 12 CT. 5) EieJlapycb
..06onepan:lBHO-
P03blcKHoHJ\eSl-
Te.%HOCTH»
npOCJIywl1BaHlte TCJle$OHHbIX neperoeopoB 3aKoH Pecny6J1ItKI1
11 I1HblX neperoBopOB (003 4 n. 3 CT II) KaJaxcTaI-J
,,060nepanJBHO-
po3blCKHOI'I neSl-
TeJ1bHOCnJ»
flpoiknJKeHue maan. 6
64

llpooo,J;JK:eHuema6il.6
1 2 3
npocnywl1BaHl1e TeneOHHbIX neperoBo 3aKoH Kblprbl3-
pOB 11 HHblX neperOBopOB (n. 10 CT. 7) cKofi Pecny6nHKH
..06onepanJBHO-
P03blcKHOiiJleSl-
TeJlbHOCHI»
OnepaTHBH()e npOCJ1}'ll1HBaHHe paJrOBOpOB 3aKoH JIaTBI1WCKOn
(n. 11 <I ICT.6.n.3cT 17) PecnyfinHlI1'I
.,{)6 oneparl1lJHOn
JleSiTenbHOCTIf»
npocnywl1BaHl1e TeneOHHbIX neperoBo- 3aKoH Pecny6nl1KH
pOB 11 I1HblX neperOBopOB (n ..i.. CT 6) MOnJlOBa
..06 onepaTlJBHO-
po3blCKHOn JleSl-
TenbHOCTlJ»
2_3, CnyxOBofi IIOHTpQJ1b In. 13 CT S\ 3aKOH Pecny6nHKI1
Eenapycb
..06onep"TIfBHO-
po3blCKHOA Jle-
'JeJlbHOCTI1»
2_4. CHJlTl1e HHopMaLlI1I1 C TeXHI1<1eCIII{j( CJ>eJlepanbHblfi
KaHMOBCBSl311 (n. 11 <I I CT. 6) 3aKOH ..06onepa-
TI'IBHO-p03bICKHOfi
Jle"TenbHOCT"
CHJlTl'le I'IHopMaUHI1 , KaHMOB Ce.ll3H 3aKoH YKpaHHbl
(n 9<1. I CT 8) ..06onepaTI'IBHO-
po3blCKHOA JleSl-
TenbHOCTW>
CHJlTl1e I1Hi»OpMaUI'lI1 C TeXHl1<1eCKI1X Ka- 3aKoH Pecnyfinl1KI1
HanOBCHil3H (n 14cT. S) Eenapycb
..060nepaTHHHO_
po3blCKHOii JleSl-
TenbHOCTlJ»
CHJlTlie I1Hi»OpMaUI'II1 C TeXHl1<1eCKI1X Ka- 3aKoH Pecnyfinl1KH
HanOB CBSl311, KOMnblOTepHblX CHCTeM ; KaJaxcTaH
I'IHblX TeXHl1'leCKHX cpeIlcTB (a63 5 n ..060nepaTI1HHO-
CT. II) po3blCKHOn JleSl-
TenbHOCTW>
65

llpooo,J;JK:eHuemafiJl.6
1 2 3
CHSlTHe HHl]>opMaUHH C TeXHH'IeCKI1X Ka 3aKoH Kblpfbl3-
Ha.rJOBCBSlJI1 (n. II CT. 7) CKOti PtCny6JUJKI1
,,060nepaTI'IBHO-
po3bICKHOH lIeSl-
Tt11hHOCTH"
OnepaTI1BH()e n()J1yqeHl'Ie I1HI]>OpMaUHI1 C 3aKoHlIaTBI1ticKoti
IJCn011b30BaHIiCM TtxHl'I'leCKI1K cptacTB Pecny611I1KI1
(n. 10'1 I CT. 6, n. 2 CT. 17) ..06 OnepaTl1BHoti
.o:eSlTt.:JhHOCTW>
CntUIJa.rJhHblii KOHlJIOJ1h 3J1eKTpOCBI!31'1 3aKOHJll'IToBcllofi
(n. 7 n()CTaHOBJIeHI1J1 BePX()BH()TO COBeTa Ptcny6n11KH
JlI1TOBCKOti PtCIly6n11111'1 o BBClICHl111 " ..Q60ncpaTI1BHoti
.o:eikTBl1c 3aKoHa 06 onepaTl1BHOH "',- .o:ejITt.:JhHOCT"
TeJ1bH()CTI1)
CHSITHC I1HI]>OpMaUl'I11 C TeXHl1'1ecKI1X Ka- 3aKoH Pecny6nl1K11
Ha.rJOBCBSlJI1 (n. ..ncT7) MO!l.o:oBa
..060ncpmIBHO-
po3blCKHOii lIeSl-
Tt11hHocnl»
3 OncpaTHBHo-paJblCKHblC MeponpHATHJ\
1UI""II3TI'.I1bI1I>IeMCTO!\bI
3.1. OnepaTI1BH()e BHellPeHl1e (n. ". I <I:oenepaJIhHhlii
CT. 6) JaKOH ..060ncpa-
THBHO-p03bICKHOti
.o:eSlTtJ!bHOCTIf"
OCYlJ..[eCTBJUlTb npOHI1KHOBeHl1e " npc- 3aKOH YKpal{Hbl
crynHYIO rpynny Hcr.naCHoro pa6oTHI1Ka ..06 oncpaTHBHO-
onepaTI1BHOrO no.npa31lCJlCHI1S1 )11160 <0- P03bICKHOll11cSI-
TpyllHl1'1alOlJ..[erO C HI1M mma C coxpaHe- TCJ!bHOCTH"
Hl{eM B TIlHHC .II0CTOBepHbiK JJ,aHHb!X, Ka-
CalOlJ..[l1KCSI I{K J111'JHOCT. YKa3aHHh1e Jll'Iua
HC HCCyr OTBnCTHeHHOCTl{, CCJ!1{ OHI{ lIeH-
CTBOBaJll1 B COCTO.!lHI1I1 He06.\.()llIIMOtl 060-
pOHbl 111111 xpaHHcH Heo6xOmIMOCni (n. 8
. I CT. 8
BHC11PeHl1e COlJlYllHI1KOB B OpraHI1JOBaH- 3aKoH Ptcny6nl1K11
HbIC npecTynHbJC rpynnbl 11 xpI1MI{HOrCH- 6eJJapycb
HbJe 06'beKTbl (n. 10 CT. S) ,,060nepaTHBHo-
P03blcKHOHlIeSl-
TeJlbHOCTH»
66

1 2 3
BHe'!!peHl1e C01PYllHIiKOB . npecrynHYIO 3aKoH Pecny6l1I{KH
cpellY (alh. 3 n 2 C1 II) KaJ.axcHUJ
,,060nepanJBHO-
po3blCKHOI'I neSl-
TeJlbHOCTW'
OnepaTI'IBH()eBHellPel-U'le (n. 13 CT. 7) 3aKoH Kblprbl3-
CKO" Pecny6JU'lKI1
,,060nep"TI'IBHO-
po3bICKHOH lle-
TeJ1hHOCTlJ»
OnepaTI'IBH() lleTeKTHBHaSilIeSlTeJIbHOCTb 3alloH llaTBHwcKoti
C C3HK!!1J11 npollypopa npOHlJKHOBeHlJe Pecny6J1I1KI1
(npHM()e "'" nereHLIl1pOBaHHoe) . npe- ..06 OnepaTI1BHoti
CT)'flH}'1O CPCllY. ycr3Hoa.rreHHe C(lSl3H H3- lleSlT'IbHOCT"
XQllSllUl1MI'ICH Ha OnepaTI'IBHOM Yljere JII1-
UBI\U'I 11 co CBSlJ3HHblMI'I C HI'IMI'I JIi1UB"'UJ
II. 3eT. 16. n. 8'1..1 CT. 6\
AreHTYPHbli1 !>tCTon (n. 7 nOCraHOBJ1CHI'IJI 3aKoHlll1ToBclloi1
BepxoBHoro COBeYa lh1Tol!cKoi1 Pecny6- Pecny6J1I1KI1
JII'IKI1 0 BBeneH1'I11 B nei1cTDl1e 3aKOHa 06 ..Q6onepaTI'IBHoti
onenaTl1lUJoi1.neI'lTeflbHOCTH .neSlTe}]hHOCT..
3,2, Her.nacH()e BblJlBJIeHl1e " $I1KCaUI'IJl 3aKoH YKpal1Hbl
CJ1e1l0B TSlXKO.-o npeCTynJ1eH('jH. 1I0Ily'>teH- ,,06 OnepaTl'IBHQ-
TOB 11 n.pyrl1x npellMeTOB. KOTOpble MOfyr po3hICKHOi1 neSl-
CJ1¥XItTb JlQlla:IaTeJlbCTB3M('j nQarQTOBKI'I TeJlhHQCTlI»
1'IJ11'1 cooepweHI1.11 TaKOrO npecrynneHI'IJI
(n.7.. I CT 81
06Hap)';KeHl'Ie, Her.naCI-JaSI $l'IKCaUI1.11 " 3aKoH Pecny6J1I1KM
l'IJb.IITMe CJ1e.uOB npoTMBonpaDHblX ne.lll-mk, KaJ.axcTaH
l'IX "pUre1JhHOe l'ICCJle.uOBaHl1e (a63. 13 «06onepaTI'IBHO-
n. 2 CT. II) po3bICKHOH .ueSl-
TeJ1hHOCTl1"
He npenYCMOTpeHO 3aKoH KhlprblJ-
CKOM Pecny6J1I1KM
«06onepaTI1BHO-
P03blcKHoMneSl-
TenhHOCTI1»
3,3, Ilpl1MeHeHl1e MOllenl1 nOBelleHl1.11, 3aKoH Pecny6J1I1KI1
I1Ml'ITPYlOllien npecTjlnHYIO neSlTe.llhH()CTb KaJ.axcTaH
(al:l3. 4n 2CT II) «06onepanmHo-
P03bICKHoHJ\ef1-
TeJlbHOCnJ»
flpoiknJKeHue maan. 6
67

llpooo,J;JK:eHuemafiJl.6
I 2 3
He npeJlYCMOTpeHO 3aKoH Kblprbl3-
CKOM Pecny6J1I1KI{
«06onepan'lBHO-
po3bICKHOfi lle-
TeJ1hHocn'!..
npl1MeHeHl1e MO)lenl1 nOBeJleHI'IJI, I1MI1TI'I- 3a1WHJlI1TOfiCIlOM
PYIOll!f:M npecrynHYIO .u:eSlTeJ1hHOCTb Pecny6J1I{KIJ «06
onepaTI1BH()t!ne1l-
- TeJ1bHOCTIJ»
],4, OCYW«:Tl'l(eHl1e nl1'.lHOrO AocMOTpa 3aKoH Pecny6J1I1KI'I
3a1lep)!(aHHblX J1I'1U, OCMOTpa 1'1 113'b>1THJI KaJaxcTaH
HaXOlillumxc npH HI'IX Bewd'! 11 JlOKy\teH- «06onepaTIJBHO-
TOB, MorYWIJX OTHQClITbCSI K npecrynHoii po3blCKHOI'I neSl-
AeJlTeJ1bHOCTH, a TalGKe n()CM()Tpa )l(l1J\bIX TeJ1bHOCTIJ»
nOMCWCHl1ti pa60'll1x 1'1 I1HblX MeCT noc-
MOlpa TpaHcnOpTHblX CpeJlCTB (1163. 15 n. 2
cr. 11)
He npe.u:ycMOTpeHO 3aKOH Kblprb!3-
cKoil Pecny6nl1KIt
..06onepaTIJBHO-
P03blcKHoillieSl-
TeJ1bHOCTIJ»
],5, OnepaTI'IBHaJi npoBepKa (n. 7 nOCT3- 3axoHJlI{ToBcllol1
HOBJ1eHI'IJI BepxoBHoro COBeTa JlI1TOIICIIOI'I Pecny6J1I1KI'I «06
Pecny6nl'llll1 0 BBelleHl111 B neiiCTBl'le 3a- onepaTl'lflHOk neJl-
KOH8 06 onepaTI1BHOM lleHTeJ1hHOCTI'I) TeJ1hHocn'!..
3.6.OnqxmffiHO-neTeK11'lBHa5Ib - 3aKoHllaTBI1ticKoti
Kall OTXpb!TaSl, Tax I{ tie3 omarneHI{S1 npl{- Pecny6J1I{KH
Hart!1e)KHOCT K cy6beKTy onepaTHIIHot! JleJl- «06 oneparl1l1Hol1
TeJ1bHOCTH no c60PY I1H$opMaUI1I1 II KjJI'I- .u:eSlTe.,TbHOCT"
MI'lHaJlbHOk cpelle, B TOM 'I11CJ1e YCTaHOBJIC-
}'II1S! CBJlJH C J1I1W'1MI'I, BbIJblBalOll.[HMI1 one-
paTl'IlIHhlii I'IHTepec('I 1,2cr.6)
],7. Oneparl1BH()e paccneJ1QBaHl1e (n. I I.J. I 3aKoH JIaTBl1l1cKot!
CT. 6. CT. 20) Pecny6nl'lKI1
..06 onepaTl{flHot!
neJlTeJIbH()CT"
68

1 2
3,8, OnepaTIJHOe BbJI'ICHeH('je nOJl}''I.e-
I-Ufe I'IH41opMBUI1I1 OT ]]1m. eCJJI1 eCTb oc-
JiOBaHtIJI nonaraTb, 'lTO JJ,aHHBSI IiH41opMB-
UI'I I1MeeTCSI B pacnop.IDKeHI1I1 Jmu. HO
OHM xcnalOT npCllOCTasltTb ee HenOCpel1-
CTBeHHO ('J. 4 CT. 9\
4 I ;P:::P;
-' "M'"'"'" ,",y,,,,..oM ,apo.,,",
nJlJI cnJ.1[ l'IHl)JopMaUl'I1'I C KaHaJ10B CBII-
:;D:I::I'I:'JK;X'I.:;T:) nOJl}''1eHlUl I1H-
npl'lMeHeHl1e cneUlffiJlbHbIX -reXHI1'1.I':CIII1X
Cpe!lCTB(a63. 7 n 2 CT. II)
OPM. CB.II.3aHHble C KOHTpOJleM nO'JTOBblX
OTflpalV1eHl1ii. TCJ1erpa$Hblx ('j HHblX co-
061lleHI1ii, npOCi1ywl1BaHl1eM TCJletl10HHbIX
neperOBopOB c nOllKJ1IO'1eHl'leM II craUl'lO-
HapHoti annapaT)'pe npCiUJpl1J1TI1f1, Y4PC}!(-
neHidi 11 OpraHl'IJ.aUl'ltI He3aBI'ICI'IMO aT
410pM co6CTBeHHOCTI'I, cJm31'1'1.eCIlItX It IOplJ-
IlH'1eu:ux ]]1m. npell()CTaM.II101U11X YCJ1YrH
11 CpCllCTB8 CIISl31'1, npOBOlllITCSI C "CIlO!1b-
30BaHl'leM OI1eplTl'IBHO-TeXHI1'1.eCKI1X Cpe,llCTB
opraHOB HBUI'IOHaJlbHOW tiC3onacHoCHJ 11
OEll B nopSlllKC. onpeaeJUleMOM npBBI'I-
reJlbCTBOM KblprblJCKOH Pecny6nl1KI'I fl,[. 4
cT7)
npl1MeHeHl1e MapKl'lpOBKI1 cneU!'laJlbHbIMI1
XItMl1'JeCIlItMIt It npyrl1MIJ BeweCT(IaMI1
(n. "0* CT. 6)
4,2, npl'lMeHHl1e cny;Ke6HO-p03bICKHblX
co6aK (a63. 11 n 2 CT. 11)
69
flpoiknJKeHue maan. 6
3aKOH l1itTBl1ikKO
PecnyfiJlI'IKI'I
06 onepaTI1BHot:i
.neSlTeJlbHOCT»
3aKOH YKpal1Hbl
06 onepanJBHO-
P03blcKHoHJ\eSl-
TeJlbHOCHI»
3aKOH Pecny6J1I1KI1
Ka3aXCTaH
,,060nepaTI1BHO_
po3bICKHO!:! J\eSl-
TC.bHOCnJ»
3aKOH KbIpfbl3
cKoii Pecny6J1I1KI'I
,,06 OnepaTI'IBHO-
po3bICKHO!:! J\eSl-
TeJlbHOCTL1»
3aKOH Pecny6nl1KI1
MOJl.D06a
06 onepaTI1BHo-
P03bICKHoiiJ\eSl-
TeJlbHOCTLW
3aKoH PecnyfiJlI1KI'I
KaJaxcTaH
06 onepaTI1BHo-
P03blcKHOHJ\eSl-
TeJlbHOCTI1»

OKOII'laHUe marin. 6
1 2 3
He npenycMoTpeHO 3aKoH Kblprbl3-
CKO Pecny6JU'lKI'I
,,060nepanJ8HO-
po3blCKHOI'I neSl-
TeJlbIlOCTI1"
OnepaTI'IBH()e n03H8Hl'le coop I'IH4JOp 3aKoH 118TBl1wCKol'I
M8U1'll'l 0 1I0HKpaHb.!X nl'luax 10 3" 3 PecnyfiJll'Ill1'l
CT. 9) ...06 oneparl1BHol'I
.neSiTenbHOCTIf"
- - -  -
OPl\l npeJQ'cMBTpIJB31OTCH CJleJQ'IOJllIIMH CT.3.TbHMH 331<0HOB,
CTarbSi 6 4IellepaJ1bHOrO 3aKOHa POCC1'ICII0 4Iellepaul'll'l ,,06 one-
p3TIIIBHO-p03blcKHofilleSlTeJlbHOCTIi»
CT3TbSl 8 3aKOHa YKpal1Hbl "06 onepan:!BHO-p03bICKHO ne.II.TeJlb-
HOCTW>.
CraTWI 5 33KOH8 Pecny6nl1KH 6eJJ8PYCb ,,06 onepaTI1BHO-p03blcKHol'I
lleSlTeJlbHOCTI'I".
CTIlTb!I 11 3aIlOHa Pe<:n)'fuU'lK Ka:JaXCT13H ..o6onepamBHo-po3bICIIHOii
Ae.lITeJlbHOCT"
CTaTbSl 7 3aKOHa Kblprb!3CKoli Pecny6J1liKIi ,,06 onepaTI'IBHO-
p03bICKHO ,IIe.lITenbHOCTIi".
CTarbSi 6 3alloH8 llaTBI'li1clloi1 Pecny6nl'llll'l ..06 OnepaTI'IBHOW lleSl-
Te.llbHOCTIi
CTarbSi 6 38KOH8 11I1TOBCKO Pecny6nl1K1'I ,,06 onepaTHBHoH lleSl-
TeJ1bHOCTIi».
CraTWI 6 3aKoH8 PecnYOJ11'1KM MWUloBa ,,00 ()nepaTI'IBHo-po3b1CKHO
.ueSlTeJlbHOCTM".

Ta6J11'IUa 7
Co1lllVlbHaIlHl1JIaBOBBIIJaIlUITBJ\O:DKI!IXT1IbI'1[ JlU It O pr3HOB,
ocyIIIeCIBJUIIOWJR onepBTHBHO-pB:A«I\H)1O lleSITeJlbHOCTI>.
I1JICll.VCMOTpeHHBH JBKOHOLlBTeJlbHWMH aXHIMH. pernBMft'I11IIIYIOIIH OPD
B cTpBHax CHI' H 6AnnuI
]V,
.",
flolOJlCf'HUR, Kl1Cl1J()ueCR Cl1!jUtL1bHOU U npu-
BOIIOU 3Ulliumbl {kn"l/CliOCmHblX .utj Opl1HQ6.
OCJ1l4ft7l16.'111/QUX OPJ1.
-4-
I
lJq:JeI:teJ:I H enpaooool'O nO!lOJlleHHSI.;J,o'iDKJIOCT-
HbIK__IHUOJ]r3}lllll.OPD
COTPYllHI1KI'I vpraHvB, ocywecTBJlJlfOWI'IK
OPD. npl'l I1cn()J]HeHI'II'I CJ1}')KeGHblx vGJlJaH-
HvcTeii JlMRWTCR npelicTaBme.HMI1 BJlaCTH
H Ha'tOJJ,JlTCSI nOil Jilllunofi rOCYllilpcTBa Ha
HI1K pacnpocTpaHHfOTcSI rapaHTH npaHOBoit
11 COUl'la.JJbHOH JaWI'ITbl pa60THI1KOB MI1HI'I-
cTepcTe 11 Be1l0MCTB, B wraTbl K010pbIX OHI1
HXQi\HT. C Y4eroM I:neltH4>I1KI1 pa60TbI 1:0-
Tpy!lHHKI'I opraHOB. 0CYWCCTBJ]JHOWI1X OPD,
raf.bl 1"::.;bI llOnOJlHI'ITe:JbHbIMI1
Ha !lOJl)l(HOCTHblX JlI1U opr"Hoe, OC)'IllOCTB-
J1J1fOllll1}( OPD. pacnpOCTpaHHfQTCSI rapaHTI1H
COUI1a.JJbHOH 1'1 npaBOBOH Jallll'lTbl COTPYWiI'l-
: :e:;p;:::; {.T\01OPbIX yxa3aH-
Do.'I)I(HOCTHble J1I1U" Cy6beKTOB onepaTI1BHoR
J\eSlTCJ1bHOCTI1 HilXOiUlTCSI nOl!JilIllI1TOii rocy-
lIapCTBa 1'1 I'IMeIOT YCTaHOBJ1eHHble JaKOHOM
npaBoBble 11 COUl'la.JJbHble rapaHTI1H Ywep6,
npWJI1HeHHblfi I1MYlllecTBY .nomKHocTHOro
J1l1ua C}6"beKTa onepilTI1BHOH J\eSlTC;IbHOCTI1
I1J1H 6J1I1JKI1K ero pOllCTBCHHI1KOB B CBSlJI1 co
cJlY)Ke6HOii neSlTeJ1bHOCTbJO lIaHHOrO nOJl)l(-
HOCTHoro 11I1Lla. nO.!LlleJKI1T H03MellleHI1fO H
nOJlHOM o6beMe 113 CpClICTB rOCYllapcTBeHHO-
r06fO.1)1(era (OJ. 2 CT. 28\
PacnpocTpaHeHHe Ha cOTpyaHHKoB onepaTHB.
I HblX 1101lJlaJlleneHHit JlbrOT. YCTaHOBJIeHHblJ  I
'J.JIHCOTPYlll1HKOBBI:nOMerua,rlle-
IO\eTfIIIt'DaTllllllbliiannaDaT
71
Hou'M!H06tIllue
3UKoHodumeAbHblx
l1Km08,pe?,1U-
MeHmupylOUJ,ux
OP.o
3
3aKOH Pecny6-
nl1KI1 KaJilXCTaH
06 onepaTI1B-
HO-pOJbICIIHOH
!leSlTeJ1bHOCTI1
3aKOH Kblprb13-
CI'OU PecnyrumKH
06 onepaTI'IB-
HO-pOJbICKHOR
lle!lTeJ\bHOCTI1»
3aKOH
]IaTBHiicKOli
Pecny6JU'lKI'I
06 onepaTI'IB-
l-iOH.IleHTeJ1bHO-
CTI'I»

llpooo,J;JK:eHue mUM. 7
I 2 3
Ha llomKHOCTHblX J1I'1U Opral-JoB, ()cyweCTB- IJ>e.nepa.rrbHbIH
J1HfOWIf)( OP,u. pacnpocTpaHHlOTcSI rapaHTIUI 3allOH ..06 one-
COUI1aJ1bHoii 11 npaBOBojj JaWltTbl cOTpyJ!Hl1- paTHBHo-
KOB rex opraHoB. B WTaTbI KOTOpblX YK3JaH- P03bJCKHOiineSl-
HbleJll'ltla IJXOlUlT ('I I" 16) TCJlbH()CTW>
Ha pa6QTHtlKOIJ. ocyweCTIJJ1HfOWHX OPLI.. pac- 3aKOH Yllpal{Hbl
I1pCJC'1])aHJlIOTCSI rapaHTHI{ nparoooii 11 COUI'I- ..060nepaTI1B-
aJlbHOii 3aWTbJ. npe.nYCMoTjJeHHble JaKOHaMI1 HO-pOJblCIIH()ii
YIlOO1'IHbl 06 3THX opraHaX (,; I CT. 12) nC)ffCJ1bHOCTH»
Ha .!\omKHOCTHbIX 11I1U opr"HOB, ocyweCTB- 3aKOH Pecnv6-
nJlfOlUl'lX OP,u. pacnpocTpaHJlIOTCSI rapaHTl111 11I'1KI1 fiCJlBpYCb
npaBoBow 11 COUl'laJlbHOW JaIUlfTbl COTp)'llHI'I- ..06onepaTI'IB-
KOB TO: opmHOB, " WTaTbI KOTOPb!X O"M HO-pOJbICIIHOH
!JXOllHT('I. I CT. 16) .!\e!lTeJlbHOCTI1
Ha llOJl)KHOCTHbIX J1I'1U Opn1HOB, ()cyweCTB- 3aKoH Pecnv6-
J1HfOllIlf)( OP,u. pacnpOCTpaHSIIOTCSI rapaHTl{1i 111{1I1{ MOJ1.!\Ba
np"lJoBoii I{ COUI1W1.bHOH 3alllltTbi COTPYllHI1- ..06 onepaTI1B-
KOB Tex OpraHOIJ, " wnnbI KOTOPb!X OOM HO-pOJbICIIH()ii
BXO.!\S1T('I Ie, 14) nelTeJlbH()CTH
3 Janper Ha BMeuarreJ1I>CTIIO BliellTeJJbHOCTh co-
- ::K::=:;'B:=::=:;;:ble IJ>ellepaJIbHblW
.!\dicTBI1H llOJUKHOCTHb!X 111{L! opraHOB, ocy- JaKOH ..06 one-
WecTBJ1S1IOL!lI1X OP,u. Ja I1CKJlJO'IeHl'IeM 11I1U, paTI1BHo-poJb!CK-
npllMo ynoJlHoMo'leHHblx Ha TO <DenepaJIb- HotineSITeJ1bH()-
HblM 3aKOHOM ('I 'e, 16) CTW'
Hl'IKTO He BnpaBe BMeWI1BaTbCJI B 3aKOHHble 3aKOH Pecnv6-
neiiCTBI1J1 AomKHOCTHblX nMU M opraHOB, 11I'1KI1 fieJlBpYCb
OCYWCCTBJlJlfOllIl'IX OP,U, " I'ICKJlJO'1CHl1eM ..060nCpaTI'IB-
J1I1U, npAMO ynoJlH()M()4eHHbIX HB TO 33KO- HO-pOJbICIIH()jj
HOM 'I 2 CT. IS) neSlTeJlbHOCTI'I
HI1KTO IIpOMe nl1U, npHMO ynoJlHOMO'leHHblX 3aKOH Pecnv6-
Ha TO 3aKOHOM. He BnpaBe BMeWI{BfibCSI J1I1KI1 KaaaXc"TBH
3aKOHHble neHCTBl1i1 OJJ'nHI1KOB 11 opr"HoB. ..06 onepaTI1B-
ocYllleCTBJ1S1JOwl1X OPIt (n 3 'I. I CT. 22) HO-pOJblCKHOii
neSlTCJlbH()CTH"
HI1KTO He BnpaBe BMeWI1BflTbCJI B 3aKOHHble 3aKOH Kblprbl3-
neiicTBI1J1 llomKHOCTHblX nMU M opraHOIJ, CKOti PecnyfuJl1KIi
ocyweCTBJlSllOlUl'IX OPIt, " I1CKJlJO'leHl1eM ..06 onepaTI'IB-
nl111. npllMo ynOJlHOM04eHHbiX HB TO 31IKO- HO-pOJbICIIHOH
HOM ('I lCT. 191- lleSlreJlbHOCTI1
72

I 2 3
HlJKTO He lUtee-r npaBa BMeWI'IBaTbCf1 B OI1e- 3aKOH
paTIfDHylO neSrreJlbHOCTb Cy6beKTOB onepa- J1aTBI1HcKOH
THBHQH IleHH:)1bHOCTH I{ .o:O!1XHOCTHbIX JlI{U. Pecny6}1I1KH
I1cK.lno'lel-lHe npellCTaBJISlJOT ()co60 yno.llHo- 06 onepaTI1B-
MO'1eHHble 33KOHO'" )1HWl. ocyweCTBI1JUowe HOHlleJlH:J1b-
:no B Yt:Td.HOBJ1eHH()M 3aKOHOM nopruu::e HOCTI19
In 4C1 281
HI'IKTO He BnpaBe eMeWI'lBaTbC.II B 3aKOHHble 3aKOH Pecnv6-
lICliCTIJI1J1 nOJl)KHOCTHblX nlm " opraHoB, ]]1'11111 MO!1nDa
ocYllIeCTlJiHllOllll1X OPD., " HCKJHO'l.eHl1eM 06 onepaTliB-
RIm np.llMO ynoJlHOM()'leHHblX H<I TO J:lKOHOM HO-p03bICIIH()H
2 CT. 14 .ueSlTeJ1bHQCTW>
4 CncUH4IHKa 1I011'lHHeHHOC'TH CUIJIYllHIIIWB op.
- raHOB oe Il{eC'I1IJ]HIOII1HX OPfl
DO)])KHOCTH()e n\Uo, ynOJ1HOM04elmoe  <I:oe.nepa.rrbHbIH
oCYllleCTl1J1eHl1e OPl1, " XOlle npOBeIleHIHI JallOH «06 one-
OPM [J()ll'II1H.IIerCSI TOJ1bKO HenocpellCTBeH- panlBHO-
HOMY 11 npSlMOMY Ha'laJ1bHI'IKY npl1 nOJlY'1e- pOJbICIII-JOH.ueH-
""" npl1K"3a 111111 YKa:JaHI1S1. np01I1BOpe'l<l- TeJ1bHOCTI1"
WI'IX J.aKOHY. YK<lJaHl-me 1I0!])KHOCTHoe J1I1UO
06113aHo pyKOUOJlCTBOBaTbCSI 3aKOHOM (t,[. 3
CT. 16)
LlOJUKHOCTHoe miLlO. ynOJIHO»tO<K:HHOe "' 33KOH Pecnv6-
ocyweCTBJ1eHl'le OPLl. " XOlle npOBelleHI'I.I1 JlI'IIII1 Eiem'pYcb
OPM nQlJ,'II'IHJleTCSI TOJIbKO Henocpe1lCTBeH- <060nepaTl1B-
HO»ty 11 npHMOMY Ha'mJlbHHK) Ilpl'l nOJly<1e- HO-p03b1CKHO
""" npl'lKB3a "'" }'K3J3HI'IJI. npOTlfflOpe'la- !leJHe!1bHOCTW>
WIfX 3aKOHY, YKaJaHHoe !lOJDKHOCTHoe nl1Uo
06H3aHo pvKOBOllcr1lOBa"IbCJI 3alloHoM, a eCJII1
Y Hero I'IMelOTCH OCHOB!lHI1J1 n0!181<1Tb, 'ITO B
peJyJIbTBTe I1CnOJ1HeHI'IJI npma133 1'IJ111 YIIB3a-
HIUI MOJKfT 11J111 MorJlO 6blTb COBepweHO npe-
Cl)'n]]eHl'le. Coo6WI'ITb ()6 3TOM B BblllIeCTOSl-
WI'I onl<lH 11J111 nlJOK1IOODV ('I 3 CT. 151 3aKoH Kblpn:n::-
LlO]]JKHOCTH()e nl1OO, ynonHOMO'1eHH0e 
ocyweCTllJ1eHl'le OPLl. " XOlle npoaelleHl'I1I CKOIi PecnyfuJl'IKI'I
OPM n01l'll1HSleTCJI TOJ1bKO HenOCp1lCTBeH- 06 onepaTI1B-
HOMY 1'1 npSlMOMY Ha'laJ1bHI'IKY. Ilpl'l nOJ1y<1e- HO-p03bICIIHOk
HI1I{ npl{KfI3a 11]]1{ YKfI3aHI1J1, npOTI1BQpe48- .!\eSlreJ1bHOCTI1
WI'IX 3aKOHY, YKaJaHH()e !lOn>KHOCTHOe JlI'IUO
06S13aHO pyKOBOllCTaOB!lTbCJI J!lKOHOM
'I. 3 CT. 19
flpoiknJKeHue maan. 7
73

B xO.l\e MepOnplUlTrIll OnepaTrIHHOfl .IleSITelIh-
HOCTI1 AOJ1>KHOCTHble mma OO'beKTOB onepa-
TI1BHOfl lleSlTCJ1bHOCTI1 nOLl"lI1HeHbI TOJIbKO
3aKOHY 11 CBOeM)' HenOCpellCTBeHH()MY }Ja-
'laJIbHI1I1Y EC!1I1 3al1aHI1e 111111 pacnopH)I{eHlfe
npOTrIBope"ll'lT 3aKOHY, 1l0JDKHOCTHOe J1IfUO
00Sl3aHO PYKOBOllCTBOB8TbCH TpeOOBaHI1HMIf
38KOH8. EC1Il'I B Pe3YJ1bTUe BblnOJ1HeHI1S1 38-
lWHl'IH llill1 pacnopH>KeHI1S1 MO;KeT 6blTb CO-
Bepll1eHO npecry!1.;IeHlfe. lI01l>KHOCTHoe 1IlfUO
06S13aHO He3aMe1lJ111TenbHO C006rnl1Tb 00
3TOM BblWeCToSlweMy Ha'IDJlbHIfIlY l'I1I11 npo-
Kvnonv 1'1_ 3 CT. 28
1l01l)l{HocTHoe 1I(Juo, ynOJ1HOM04eHHoe H8
oCYllleCn!JleHlfe OPLl, B XO.llf npOBeJleHIfH
OPM nOJl'll'lHSleTCH T01lbKO PYKOBOllI-ITeJlJO
3TI'IX MeponplfSlTfI ('I. 3 CT. 14)
npCJl,ocraBJIeHHe .IlnmRHucn1I>IM JlHIt3.M opra.
HOB. OC)mecTB!lHIOLlIHX OPD..llHCKpfIIJIOHI1L1J
n01lBOMO"lHii
npl'l JaIUI1TB >K1-I3HI1 11 3ll0poBbSi rp8)1(1!aH. I1X
KOHCTT)'LWlOHHbIX npaB If 38KOHHblX IfHTepe-
COB, a TaICKe JlJ1S1 06eCne'JeHl'IH OeJonacH()CTI'I
06rneCT68 1'1 rOCYll8pCT6a or npecrynHb!X no-
CSiraTeJ1hCTB .nonYCKaeTCSI BblHY)!(,I],fHHOe nplf-
'1I-1HeHl1e BpelI,a npaBOO'ijJaHl-lTeJ1bHbJM I1HTe-
peC8M .IlOJ1>KHOCTHb!M 1I11LlO},t OpraHa, oC}'me-
CTBJ1SJlOlUero OPll, 111160 Jll'ILlOM, OKa3bJBaJO-
WHM eMY CO!!dICTlJlfe. cOBepwaeMOC:: npH
npaBOMepHOM BblnOJ1HeHI-II-I YKaJaHHblM 111-1-
LlOM ceoero CJI}')Kc6HOrO rI1I1-1 06mecTBl:HHoro
nonra 1;/. 4 CT. 161
He Hecer O1IJe1'C11JeHHOCTH pa601Hl1K onepa-
TIfHHoro nOJJ.Pa:)JleJIeHIfH. KOTOpblll npl1"lIfH(1/1
Bpell npaBat. CB060naM '1eJlOBeKa. I1HTBpeca\l
rOCYlIapLTBa eo BpeMH OCYIlICCTB!1eHIfJI OPD..
H8XOlUlCb B COCTOHHI1I1 He06xoom,tofl ooopo-
Hbl. Kp8iiHeii Heo6xOllIfMOCTIII (1/111 npo<Jx:c-
Cl'IOHWIbHOro pHCKa, a TaICKe B CBSl31-1 C 38-
nep)I{aHlfeM 1I11ua. B net1cTBHSlJ( KOToporo eCTb
nn.BHaKIf nnecT\ll1J1eHIfSi '1.4 CT. Iii
74
flpoiJoVKeHue maan. 7
3aKoHJ1anmfl-
CKOI1 Pecnyfi.'Il'IKI1
06 onepaTIf13-
HoiiAeSITeJ1h-
HOCTH
3aKOH Pecny6-
Jllfilif MOJl.llolJa
06 onepaTI-IB-
HO-p03b1CIIHOfl
neSlTeJIbH()CTI1
(]>eJleparrbHb
3allOH «06 one-
paTI'IBHO-
p03b1CIIHOH neH-
TeJIbHOCTIf
3aKOH YKpaJ1HbI
06 onepaTIfB-
HO-p03bICIIHOH
.IleSlTeJlbHOCTIf

1 1
Dp", 3aIUI'ITe )K113HI'I 11 31lOpOBbll rpa;KJIDH. I1X
KOHCTI1TYUI10HHblX npaB 11 33KOHHblX I'IHTe-
P<:COB. a TBK)I(C llJ1J1 05eCneLJeHI'Ili 6c30nac-
HOCTI'I o6!UeCTB<1 1'1 rocynapcm3 aT npecryn-
HblX nOC"raTbCTB .DOnYCKacTCJI BbIHY;KJJ,eH-
tioe npl1<iI1HeHl1e apena npaROoxpaHIICMbIM
I'IHn:peCBM JlO;:[)KHOCTHbIM 111'1LlOM opraHB,
OCYllleCTlIJ1J1lOlJ..lefO GPIt, 111160 1II'ILlOM, OKa-
3bIBaIOIlU'I},t eMY COJlfi1I:TBl1e. cOBepurne),toe
npl1 npaeOMepHOM BblnO.llHeHl'I11 }'K3.31HHblM
11l'1ooM eeoem CJlY>Ke6H()rO l1im ()6weCTBeH-
I -Iorono.ra('1.4CT. 191
I e::He"I:=:::IX lIbroT WTaT-
Bpe",,, HblnQJ1HeHI'IJI lIOmKHOCTHb!Ml'Il1l1lta"tI1
OpTaHOB. OcyllleCTBJ1J1I0111I'lX OPll. cneul'l-
aJlbHb!X 33J1aHI1f1 H OpraHI130I1BHHb!X npe-
crynHblx .-pynnax, a TBK)I(e BpeMSI I'IX CJ1Y)K6b1
B .l\O!1JKHOCTIIX IUTBTHhlX HerJl8CHblX C01PYJl-
HHKOB YK"aaHHbIX opraHOB n01lJ1e)!(I1T 3a'teTY
B BblCJ1yry 11eT nn" HB3HBLJeHI1JI neHC1J1'I B
lIbrOTHOM I'IC'II'ICJ1CHI1I1 B nopMKe. onpellC-
1IHeMOM npaBI'ITe!1bCTBOM Poccl'Ii1clloi1 tDe-
- :I1:bI::H: JlOJ1)KHOCTHb!MI'I JlI1UB\tI1
OPTaHOB, OCYIllCCTBJ1J1I0111I1X QPll. cneul'l-
RJ1bHb!X 3aJ:\BHI1f1 H OpraHI130I1BHHb!X npe-
crynHblx .-pynnax, II rdKACe BpeMSI I1X CJ1Y)K6b1
B J\omKHOCTI1X IUTaTHblX HelJlacHblX COTPYJ\-
HI1110B YKa3aHHbIX opraHOB nOnne)!(I1T :.m'leTY
B eblCJ1Yry neT nnSi HaJH3'leHI11 neHC1111 B
nbrOTHOM I1C'lI1CJ1eHI1I1 B nop.llllKe. onpelle-
:11 .a;eJ1TBOM KblprbIJCKO Pec-
7npe.oocrallJlelllUlD,Ono.1HHTe;lb.
HbiX n..rOT COTpY,WIHKaM onepaTHBHblX 110.11.
...-
- OpraHbJ rOCYD,apCTBeHHO MaCTIII Cy6beKTOB
F'OCCI1J:!CKOJ:! (]>e.aepaUI1I1 11 opraHbl MeCTHoro
c3MoynpaBJIeHIUI enpaBe YCTaHBOJ1I1BaTb JID-
nOnHI1TeJIbHble BlIllbl COUl1anbHoJ:! JalUl1Tbl
::)!(TX6 IpraHoB, ()cywecTB-
75
flpoiJoVKeHue maan. 7
3
'3aKoH KblprblJ-
CKOH Pecnyti'lI1KI1
06 onepaTI1B-
HO-p03bICIIHOH
neSlTeJlbH()CTW>
(]>ellepa.rrbHblj:j
3allOH 06 one-
paTIIIBH()-
P03bICIIHOj:jl\fSl-
TeJlbHOCHN
3aKOH Kblprbl3-
CKOi1 F'ecny6JII1KI'I
06 onepaTI1B-
HO-P03bJCIIH0i1
J\eSlTeJ1bHOCTI1
(]>ellepaJ1bHbl
3allOH 06 one-
paTI1BHO-
pOJblCKHOJ:!l\f.ll-
TeJIbH()CTI1»

He npe.aycMoTj)eHo
Pa60THKaM, OCyrueCTBI1HlOllUft OPD" npelloc-
TaBl1S1KITCSI l!ononHrrreJ1bHble nbrOTbl B eonpo-
cax COUl'larJbHO-Gb!TOeoro 11 <fJl'lHaHCOBoro
ooe<:ne4eHI1J1 B nop5IJu,e, ycrdHOOIleHHoM Ka-
6(JHeTO1 MI1HOC1POB YIlp;lHHbl ('I 3 CT 12)
8 TlpaBo cOTpyaHHKoB onepaTIIBHblX IJ().'IIJame.
_eH"iil1aooeCne'leHHeJlH'Il1oii{je:lOnacI10Crn
npH H8JlI1'1I1H llaHHblX 06 yrpo3C )KH3HH,
31lOpOBbIO 11J111 I1MyweCTBY pafioTHI1Ka 11 ero
UnlJ3KlJX p01lCTBeHHHKOB B CBSl311 C ocywecT-
BJ1eHl1eM 11M OPD, B HTepecax 6e30naCHO-
CT YKPal1HbJ I1nl1 no paCKPblTl110 TH)KKOrO
npecry[]!leHHJI lJ!lH pacKpblHno opraH(J30-
BaHHOH npecrynHo fpynnb! OnepaTI1BHOe
nOj{JJB31leJleHHe 00Sl3aHO npHHJlTb CneLlH8Jlb-
Hble "tepbl no ()6eCne'leHI1IO ero 6C30naCHO-
CT - 113MeHeHI11O 1l8HHbIX 0 flLle, Mecrn
)K11Tt:J1bCTBa, pa60Tb!, Y4e6b! lJ Jlpyrl1x B no-
p}[l]Ke, OnpelleJUIeMOM Kafil1HeTOM MI1HI1CT-
poBY"mliHbl ('I. 3 CT. 11)
OPM, 06ecne4HBalOume cooCTBeHHYIO 6e30-
naCH()CTb OBB, npOBOlUlTCH B nop}[l]Ke, npe-
nycMOTpeHHOM 3aKOHOllaTe!lbHbIMH 8KTal\.tI1
Kblpfbl3ClI0i1 Pecny6J1HIIH ('I 6 CT 9)
9 HeJ:IOn}'crnMocTb J.aHHTIIH nOJlIITll'K'C':KOii .neR-
re;lbHOCTblO .IlJlH COTPYJlHHKOB onepaTIIBHI>IX
_I JI:;e6H0i1 llCHrenbHOCTI1 COTPYll-
HI1I1I1 OpfaHOB, OCYWCCTBJUlIOWI1X OPD" py-
KOElO1«:TBYIOTCSI Tpe60BaHI1HMI1 3aKOHa 11 He
CBSl3aHhi C peWeHI'IHMH nOJ1I'1TIII'IeCIIHX nap-
TH 11 MaCCOBblX 06weCTBeHHhIX llBI1>KeHHH,
[]peCJ1e.llYIOWI'IXnOJ1HT'1eCIlHeLleJl(J (n.l 'I. I
CT22)
76
llpooo,J;JKeHuema6il.7
3aKOH Kblprbl3-
CKOH Pecny6nI'lKI'I
.0GonepaTI1B-
HO-p03b1CIIH0i1
Llt'S1TeJ1bHOCTH"
3aKOH YKpal1HbJ
.060nepaTHB-
HO-P03b!CIIHOH
JleSlTeJ1hHOCTH
3aKOH YKpaHHbJ
.06 ()TTepaTI1B-
HO-P03b1CIIH0i1
Llt'S1TeJ1hH()CTH"
3aKOH Kblprbl3-
CKOH PecnyfumKI'I
.060nepaTHB-
HO-p03b1CIIH0i1
Llt'S1Te!lbHOCTI1»
3aKOH Pecny6-
fll1KH Ka3aXCTaH
.060nepaTI1B-
HO-pOOblcIIHOi1
Llt'SiTenbH()CTH&

_ 2
OpraHaM (no/1)I(HOCTHbIM mmaM), OCyweCTB-
mUOlUl1M OPD" JanpeIUaeTCW npOBOlll1Tb
OPM B IiHTepecax Imlloi1-111f60 nOJ1IiTIi'le-
CKOH napTl1Ii. 061lleCTBeHHbJX o6belll1HeHliit
11 peJ1IfnlOJHbJX opraH(\JaUIiM. JaperliCTpli-
poH3.HHbIX B YCTaHOB!1eHHOM n"OHOM 110-
pSl1lKe. C UeJ1blO OKa3aH(\SI B11IiSlHI1S1 Ha xa-
paJITep(\XlleSlTeJlbHOCTIi ('I. 6CT 9)
10 BOJJlO>KeHlleliaPYK08O.l(ItTeJlHopr3.Ha.oqnre-
CTBJlIIKllltero OP.!J, 06,uaHIIOCTb 06eCne'lllBaTb
6eJOnacllocTblTOLl'lHHeJlHblxeMycoTpylltlHKoB
PyKoBOlllirenl1 opraHOB. OCYlUeCTBJUllOlUl1X
OPD. 05S1JaHbl ()5eCne'lI1BaTb J111"lHYIO 6e30-
naCHOCTb, coxpaHHOCTb I1MYlUeCTBa CBOI1X
COTPYllHIiKOB. 'IJleHOB I1X ceMel1 11 6nIiJKIiX
pOJ:\CTBeHH(\KOB (n. 4'1 I CT. 22)
He npellYcMOTpeHo
----..-- flpaBo COTpy.nU8t10B opra8oB, oCYUl,eCTBJlluo.
UI"X OPD. 113. an"HYIO 1I0IlrOTOB.
KY. nOBblweu8e KBa;lHt2IHtlaH8. MeJ\JIUIII1C1101
....",.......,
B uenSlx HaLlJle)Kamero Bbln()JlHeHI1S1 cJlY-
>Ke5HbJX ()6S1JaHHocrew cOTpynHlilloB opra-
HOB. OCYUI,eCTBJHlIOUI,IiX OPD,. COJJ];UOTCSI
YCJlODI1.11. He06XOllH"tble llJ1S1 nOJlY'JeHIiSl cne-
Uli8..TbHOM npo41ecCIiOH8J1bHoi1 nOJJ.TOTOBIlIi,
nOBbllUeHI1.11 KD8J1(\!tJI1KaUI1I1 11 DJI.II Melllt-
UI1HCKoro 06CJ1}')KHB3.HI1S1 (n. 5'1. I CT. 22)
He npellYCMOTpeHO
77
OKOH'lOHUf! mOM. 7
3aKOH KblprblJ-
CKOH Pecny6JU'lKIi
.06onepaTI1B-
HO-pOJbJCIIHOi1
lleIlTeJlbHOCTIi
3aKOH Pecny6-
JlI1KIi Ka3aXCT3.H
06 onepaTIiB-
HO-pOJbJCKHOi1
neSlTeJlbH()CTIt"
3aKoH KblprblJ-
CKOH Pccny6JUJKIi
06 onepaTIiB-
HO-pOJbJCIIHOH
llCSlTeJlbH()CTIt"
3aKOH Pecny6-
JlI1KIi Ka3aXCT3.H
06onepaTIiB-
HO-pOJbJCIIHOi1
llCSlTeJlbH()CTIt"
3aKOH KblprblJ-
CKOP Pecny6JU'lKrI
,<06 oneparliB-
HO-pOJbICIIHOi1
neaTeJ1bHOCTIt

COI!Hft.ilbHYIO II TIp8BOIIyIO :I.llllInY COTjJY.IJ,HIIKOB oprallOB, ocymeCTB-
JlJlIOIllHX OPD. npeIQ'CMftTpliBftlOT CJIe;IJ'lOlllHe CTaTbK JftKOHOB.
CTaTbJI 16 <Dt:llepanbHoro JaKOlia ..06 onepaTIIIBIl0-p03blcKHoi1 .ueSl-
TenbHOCTI1».
CraTbIl123ax:OHaYI<JX1Hbl..06onepa111RHO-poJbICIIHOH
CTaThIi IS 3"1KOHd Pecny6J111KH 5e.'lapycb ..06 OnepaTHBHO-pOJbII:KHOH
.ueSlTeJlbH()CTI'I».
CTaTbSl 12 3aKoHa Pecny6J1111\1'I KaMlXCTi!H ..06 onepaTHHHo-
p03bICKH0i1 Ae.lITeJ1bHOCTI1»
CraTbSl 19 3aKOHa KbrprblJCKOM Pecny6J1I1KI'I ..06 OnepaTI1BHO-
pOJbJCKHoi1.ne.lITenbHOCTI1».
CraTbSl 28 3aKOHa J1aTBI1HCKOi1 Pecny5J11'11111 ..06 onepaTl'IBHOH .ueSl-
Te.llbHOCTlJ».
CraTbJI 14 3aKoHa Pecny61JI'IKI1 MUJUlOBa ..060nepaTI1BHO-p03blcKHoi1
.ueSlTeJlbHOCTI1".

Ta6JI1'IUa8
C01lt'ltcTBHe QlaJK!UIH OnepaT1lBHo-pa3bICI(I{()fi 1lt'1ITt'nbHOCm,
CIII01)JeIIHOe :JaKOHO;J,aTeJlLHLIMIt aKTaMlt, pernaMellTllpylOWIIMH opn
B cTpaH3x CHI" H 6a:nHH
M
"In
30lA06Ue
_2
I YCT3110B:lCHHe KOIIIpIUlftIUHaQLHLIX OTHowe
_"HHltanoOpoBOJlLHLIXlta':laJJax
OTJ\fJlbHb!e 11111..18 MOryT C 11)( cor118CI111
npHBJ1CI<8TLCH K nOJIrOTOBKC 11 npOBeJle-
Hmo OPM (':I I CT. 17)
OmCJlbHb!C 11111..18 MOryT C 11)( cor.naCI1H
npHBJ1eI<ilTLCH K nOllrOTOBKe 11 npOBelle-
Hmo OPM (':1.2 CT. 13)
OTJ\fJlbHLle 1111ua MOryr C 11)( COrnaCl111
npHBJ1CllaTLCH K nOJIrOTOBKC 11 npOBeJle-
Hmo OPM (':I I CT. 20)
O[]epaTBHaSi neSlTCJ1bHOCTb OCHOBLIBTCH
Ha n06pOBO!TbHOH rnacHoi1 111111 Tai1HoH
nOMOWIt $113H':IeCIII1X nl1L1 (':I 1 CT 5)
OTnenLHLle 11l1ua M()ryr C }IX COmaCl111
npHBJ1eKaTLCIi K nOllrOTOBKe 11 npOBene-
HI1100PM (':I I CT. 15)
 HItHan""oCTlocOTPYDHH"eCTBa
I OTJ\fnbHLle 11111..18 MOryr C 11)( COrnaCl111
npHBJ1eKaTLCII K nOllrOTOBKe 11 npOBene-
HI110 OPM C coxpaHeHl1e),t no 11)( JKeJlaHl110
KOH$HJ:!eHLll1anbHOCTIt coneliCTBI1H opra-
HaM, OCYlLleCTWUII01LlI1M Opn (':I. I CT. 17)
79
HaUJlet/080HUe
3I1KmIOiJume.J/bHbiX
11"mo6,pe111I1ffl-
muJlJ'lOU¥Jx OPjJ
3
(]>encpanbHblH
3allOH «06 onepa-
TItBHO-p03LlcKH0i1
nCIITCJ1LHOCTH»
3aKoH Pccny6nl1-
KI1 Ka331[CT')H
«06 OnepaTItBHO-
p03L1CKHOH neSl-
TeJ1LHOCTI1»
3aKoH KblprLl:'l-
CKOH Pecny6m1KI1
«06 OnepaTl1BHO-
pOJL!CKHoi1nell-
renLHOCTI1»
3allOH J]I1TOBCIIOi1
Pccny6!TI1KIt «06
OnepaTI1f1HO" nCII-
TenbHOCTI1»
3aKoH Pecny6nl1
Kit MO.ll1loBa «06
OnepaTI1BHO-
pOJbICKHOi1 nell-
renbHOCTIt..
(]>enepanbHblH
:'IaKOH .06 onepa-
Tl1eHO-pOJbICKHoi1
neIlTeJlbHOCTH"

I 2
OrneJlbHb!e mma MOryr C HX cor.nacl1.11
npH1!J1CI<3TbCli K nOlifOTOfillC 1'1 npOBelle-
Hmo OPM C coxpaHeHlJeM no HX }KeJ18HI1K1
KOH$w.eHUHaJ1bHOCTI1 cOllecTBml opra-
HaM. OCVllleCTMJllOlllHM GPn ('i 2 CT. 13)
OT1Ie)l1,Hbie J111W1 MOryr C I1X COIJJaCI1I1
npl1BJ1ellBTbCH K nQlJ,r01OBKe 11 npOl1elle-
HI1IO QPM c co\.paHeHtleM no !'IX >KeJlaHl1l0
KOH!}1I'111CHUI'laJ1bHOCTH cOlle£1cTBI'IJI opra-
Hat. DC llIeCTBI1HlOllll1M opn (.. 1 CT. 13)
OTneJlbHb!e mma Mor:yT C IJJ( cornacml
npHBJ1el<aTbC.II K nO!lroToBKe Ii npoDelle-
Hmo OPM HII 1I0Hi}mi\eHUI18J1bHOii OCHoee
(<i I CT. IS)
CeKpeTHblJ.UI }"18CTHI1KaMIJ onepaTI1BHOj.j
J\eHTeJlbHOCTI1 II!JlJlIOTCSI ceKPeTHblt' paoOT-
HI1I1I1 CYObeKTOB onepaTBHOn lleSlTeJlbHO-
CTIf 11 TatiHo COTPYllHI'I'iBlOlUMC $I'IJM'-Je-
CKI1eJUJua(<i 2 CT. 4)
3 OfiSIJ8HHOCTb nH1t, cOlleHCTBylOlltllx OPlI
\naHHTIoTaiiHV
3m nltl!3 06maHhi CQXpaHJITb II rniiHC CIK:LIC-
HI1.11. CTaBWHC 11M I13BeCTHblMIJ II xo.ne nQ11ro-
TOBKI'IIli1I'1 npoBelleHl'ISi QPM ('1. I CT. 17)
Jh1ua, np!1I1JleKaeMbIC K BblnoJIHCHlJ1O :'Ia-
.rIa"! OPD. ()OSlJ8Hbl xpal-J!1Tb T8"HY, CT8B-
wYJO 11M !1JBeCTHOii PaJrnaWCHHC :ITOM
TaHHbJ BJ1C4CT 3a co6oii OTBnCTl1eHHOCTb
no ncj.jCTBYlOweMY 3aKOHQ.!1aTeJlbCTBY.
KPOMe CJI)"JaeB pa3r.naweHIfSi IfH4JopMaulflf
o H3aKOHHblJ( lldicTBI'IJlX, IIOTopble HBPY-
WBIQTn08B8'1e;10BeKa("l. Jcr II)
3TH mma 015.113aHbl C()XpaHJlTb B TaHe
CBelleHIfJl.CTaBWlfe IfM 1f3BeCTHbiMif BJ(Olle
nOlirOTOBll1f Wlif npOBelleHIfH OPM. Pa3-
r.naweHlfe :nOM TaHHbI BJ1e4eI 3a C0150M
OTBeTCTBeHH()CTb. YCTaHOBJ1eHHyJO 3aIlOHO-
naTeJlbCTBOM Pecny5J1IfIlIf Ka3axcTBH ('I 2
CT. 13
80
llpooo,J;JKeHuema6il.8
3
3aKoH Pecny5J111
Kif Ka3BxcTaii
..06 onepaTI1HHO-
P03b1CKHoi111eSl-
TeJ1bHOCTH&
3aKoH Kblprbl3-
CKOi1 Pecny6J1IfIlIf
..06 ()nepaTI'IBH()-
P03blcllHoHneSl-
3aKOH Pecny5J1I1-
1111 M0!1110Ba
..06 onepaTI'IHHO-
p03blcKHOHne.ll-
TeJ1bHOCTI'I»
3allOH J]IfTOBCIIOi1
Pecny6.IfKI1 ,,06
oneparlfBHoH neSl-
TCJIbHOCTI'I"
<tJl:.!IepaJlbHblH
3aKOH ..06 onepa-
TIfBHO-p03bICKHOtl
lleIlTCJlbHOCHj"
3aKOH YllpBIfHbI
..06onepaTl'leHo-
p03blcllHoHneSl-
TCJ1bHOCTI1"
3aKOH PecnyfuJl'IKIf
KaJ8J(CTaH
..06 onepanlBHO-
P03bICIIHOH.!leSl-
TeJlbHOCTI1»


3T1t Jll1ua OGHJ.aHbl C()XpaHJlTb B TaHHe
CBellelUUI. CTaeWl1e 11M 1130eCTHbiMIt e XOlle
nOllfOTOBlI11 ItJlIt npOBe!leHlU1 OPM
(<,I. I CT. 20)
06HJ.aHHOCTblO 3TIJX nl1Ll JlBJlJlercSi coxpa-
HeHlte 11 T"i1He C01py1lHI1'1eCTBa 11 Hep3.3-
r.naweHlfe nOJlY'IeHHOH B KOlle Hero I'IH-
4>OpMHUItI1 ('I. leT 30)
Jh1l.lO, HapYWI1Bwee IIOHt1JltJleHlWIaJIbHOCTb
HJIH aHOHI1MHOCTb ceKpeTHblX Y'lacTHI1KOB
onepaTI1BHoi1 lleJlTI:J1bHOCTIII 11 ItH4JOPMa-
Ulm. HeceT OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb B COOTBeTCT-
BltH C 3alWHaMI1 J1I'1TOBCKOH Pecny6m'llll1
('I_lCT.II)
3T1t Jll1na 06.113<1Hb[ COXpafUlTh B nAHe
CBe.neHItJl. CTaBWl1e 11M 1'130eCTHbiMIt B XOlle
OPD('l. leT 15)
4 - 06J13aHHOCTb 13m3H'IecKHX Jlqu.u:ofipoooBecT-
HO COTpyJU1H'IaTb
3T JU1Lla He BnpaBe npellOCTaBJISITb 3aue-
nOMO J[o)KHYJO I1H4JopMaul'lJO YKaJaHHblM
OpraH:lM ('I. I CT. 17)
3T1t JlHua oGSl3aHbJ Henpe1l0CTaenJJTb 3aee-
llOMO JlO;KHYJO I1H4JOpMaUI'lJO YKa.33HHbIM
opnlHaM 3a npeAOCTaBlleHlte 3aBeAOMO
J[O)KHOH I1H4JopMaum'l OHI1 Hecyr OToeTcr-
BeHHOCTb, YCTaHOBJIeHHYIO aHKOHO.llaTeJlb-
CTBOM Pecny6J1ltKI'I Ka3a1[CT')H ('I 2 CT. 13)
He enpaee npe1l0CTaB.JlTb 3aBellOMO JlO;K
HYJO HH4JoPMaUMIO YIlaJ.aHHbIM opraHBM
('I. I CT. 20)
81
llpooo,J;JKeHuema6il.8
3aKOH Kblprbl3-
CKOll Pecny6m1KH
..06 onepaTI1HHO-
P03b!CKHoi1nell-
TeJ1bHOCTW>
3aKoHJTaTBI1H-
CKOi1 Pecny6J1111111
,,06 onepaTBHoi1
ne.llTeJlbHOCTI1»
3aKOH JTtlTOBCKOi1
Pecny6J1I1KI1 ,,06
OnepaTI1BHok.u e S]-
renbHOCTI1&
3aKOH Pecny6J1I1-
KI1 MOJllIOBa,,06
onepaTl18HO-
P03b1CKHoi1ne.ll-
T(:J1bHOCTI1»
(]>ellepMbHblll
3aKOH ,,06 onepa-
TI1BHO-p03bICKHOI:!
.ue.llTenbHOCTI1&
3aKoH Pecny6nl1-
KI1 Ka3axcTIIH
,,06 OnepaTI1BHO-
P03b1CKHOHlleSl-
renbHOCTM&
3m<OH Kblprbl3
CIlOll Pecny6J1111111
,,06 OnepaTI1BHO-
P03blcKHoi1.u:eSl-
renbH()CTI1»

I 1
06J13aHHocTbJO 3TI1X J1I1U JlBJlJleTCSI npe!l()C-
TaBJICHl'le cy6'beKTOM OnepaTl'IBHOH 1ICJI-
T'jLHOCTI'I TOJILIlO npafllltlBoii I1H4JOp}.j3-
wm('I2cT.30)
3T nl1ua He BnpaBe npeIl()CT"BJUITb opra-
HiI).!. OCyweCTBJ]UOlliHM OF'D,. JaBe.nOMO
./1()JKHYIO I1H4JOp),t3L!L11O ('I. I CT. 15)
-Snpa80 .j»i:JH"fn.NlX JIHll Ita OliUPIIIJIeHII'"
fI"I1III"A COTDV;tIIH'lt'CTBa KOIITDaKTOIII
OpraHbl. OCYJJ.J,eCTBJUllOlJ.!l'Ie opn. Moryr
3aKJ1IO'ffiTb KOHTpaKTbI C cOBepweHHOJ1er-
HI'IJ.UI lIeecnoco6HblM(J JUJl!am He3aBI1CI'I-
1.10 OT rpaJK.l\aHCTB3, H3UI10HaJ1bHOCTI'I. no-
.na. I'IMywecTBeHHoro. .nOJUKHOCrHoro 11
COUl'la.!1bHOro nOJlOJKCHI1J1. ()6p"JOBaHI1J1.
npHHa11JIe)KHOCn! K 06meCTBeHHbJM ()Obe-
DlmeHI'IJIM. OTHOllleHI1J1 II peJ1l1r11 11 n()-
1JI1TI1'leCKHXeHI1"{'l.2CT.17)
no }l(CJlaHl1lQ J1I1U If X COTp}'llHW,ecmo C
onepaTI1BHblMI1 nO!!p33!lCJleHI1J1MI1 MO)KCr
61>1Tb o$opMJ1eHO nl1CbMeHHblM cor113rne-
l"meM C rapaHTl1p013aH(JeM KOH4mlleHUI1-
aJ1bHOCTI1 COTPYllHl1'1CCTBa
CorniiWeHI1C 0 CCUldicTB11 onepaTI1HbIM
n0.iLPa:tlIeJ1eHI1IM Opn MO)Ker 6blTb :.m-
KI1lO'1eHO C .neecnoc06Hb!M RlU.lOM. nOpSlllOK
3aK.f1JO'IeHI1J1 cornaWeHI1J1 ()npeJ1eJ1J1eTCSI Ka-
611HeTOM Ml'IHHCTTIOB YKnaHHbI <J I CT. In
OpraHb!, Ocy!llCCTBJ1J1IOWI'IC OPD, MOryr
J.a1<J11O'illTb l<OtfTpaKTbl C COllepweHHOJleT-
Hu,m JleeCnOCo6HbJM(J !I(JWlM(J He3aRIllC(J-
MO OT rpaJKJIaHCTt1a, Hal!(JOHaJIbHOCT(J, no-
118, COLlL18J1bHorO, JlOJDKHOCTHoro I1M)'-
meCTBeHHoro n0J10JKeH(J}I, o6pa30BaHI1I.
npI'lHaJLT1e)KHOCTrI II 061l1eCTBeHHbJM 06be-
JlI1HeHI1IM, nOJlI1TI1<ieCKI1X 11 pelIl1fl103HblX
)'6eJKJleHI1.
(]J0pMa KOHrpaKTa, )'CJlOBI1J1 11 CPOIl" ero
ndlcTBI1S1 OnpelleJlJlJOTCSI BeJlOMCTBeHHblMI1
HOOMaTI1BHblMI1 aKTaMI1 '1.3 CT 13
82
flpoiJoVKeHue maan. 8
3
3alloH
J1aTBI1HCKOH
Pecny6J1I1KI1
..06onepanJBHOH
JleIlTeJ1bHOCnj"
3aKOH Pecnv6.IJKI1
Mo.:woBa
..06 onepaTl1t1HO-
pOJbJCKHoi1.neSl-
renbHOCTH"
(]JellepanbHblij
3allOH «06 onepa-
TI1BHO-P03bICKH0i1
.neSlTeJlbHOCTI'I»
3aKOH Yllpal1HbI
«06 onepaTI1BHO-
pOJb!CIIHO JleSl-
TeJlbHOCTI1»
3aKOH PCcny6J1I'1KI1
Ka331{C'f3H
«06 onepaTI1BHO-
P03blcKHoi1J1eSl-
TeJlbHOCTI1"

1
OpraHbl. ()cy!llCCTBJUlIOWl'le opn. MOryr
J.aKJ1IO'IaTb KOHTpaKTbl C CODCPWCHHOJleT-
HI'I"1I1 lIccCnOC06Hb1MI1 JlI1L1i1MI'I He:JllBI1CI'I-
MO OT rpa;;w,aHCTlJa, HaUI'IOHaJlbHOCTI'I. n()-
na, I1MYWCCTBCHHoro. .DOJ1>KHOCTHOro 1:1
COUl'l3J1bHoro nOnO:KCH(JJ!. o6pa30RaH(JJ(,
npHH8J1)1C)KHOCTH II 061l1CCTBCHHblM o6be-
;:==;;: ==: :. e:;r;; 1'1 no-
YnOJlH()Mo<lcHHble Ao.ru;HOCTHble nl1ua cyfu.-
eKTOB onepaTHBH()!:\ ne.llTeJ1bHOCTH I1MCIOT
npaBO Ha OCHOBe 1I06pOBOJIbHOCT 1'1 B3aI'lM-
HOro 1l0OCpl'lJl npI'lBJICII1lTb II OnepaTI'IBH()M
nellT(:J]bHOCT B I<3'JeC11!e CeKpCTHblX no-
MOWHI11101311eecnoc06HblX JIIfU 'I. I CT. 30
(hJ\fJlbHbIC .I1lll.la Moryr npI1MCK1lTbCSI K
nonroTOlJlle 11 npOBelleHl'l1O OPM, e TOM
'mc]]e no KOHTpaKTY ('I. I CT. 17)
OrncnbHble nl1lia MUf:yT npl'lBJIeKarbCSI K
nonrOTOBKe 1'1 npOBenCHmo OPM (B TOM
'!l1cnc no IIOHTpaIlTY) ('I. 2 CT. 13)
4IopMa KOHTpaKTa, YCJlOBHJI 11 CpOll11 ero
neikTBwr onpellCJlSlIOTCSI f\C110MCTBCHHbI),UI
HopManJBHblMI1 311T3/1.111 '1.3 cr IJ
OTneJlbHb!f' .I1l'1ua MOryr C 1'1]( cormcw,
npHBJ1CK1lTbC.II K nOllrOTOBKC 11 npOBenc-
Hmo OPM C coxpaHcHl1c),t no I'IX }KCJU'lHI'lIO
KOH$l'IJ1eHUl'laJIbHOCTI1 COllel1CTBIUI opra-
).t0i=%M2pn. B TOM 'II1CJle
C'-I<pt'I1{OeCaIpyLlHWJecroo MO)l(CT6bITbOl1Jla-
'ill]!aeMbIM Cr:Kpe11ible 1lOMOULH111<1'I C I1XCO-
M01)'T npljJIeKrrrbCJI I< on:pmmHoii
JleJrn:I1bHocrn HaOCHOBeJlOroaopa ('I. 3 CT. 30)
Cr:llpeTHbJM nOMOIl.!HI1K8M. COlpyJ\H(,]'I81O-
llLl'IM C Cy6beKTO),t onepaTI1BHO JleSlTeJlb-
HOCTI'I, Ha OCHOBe J\o.-oBopa 06eCne'llJBa-
IOTC}! COLlI1aJ1bHble .-apaHTlJlJ, npeilycMOT-
peHl1ble 3aKOHOM 11 JlpyrlJ),t11 HOpM8TIJB-
HblMH 81<TaMI1 DJ1J1 .nomKHOCTHbIX J1I1Ll }"I-
:e:c yTT;2) onepaTBHo .neSl-
83
flpoiJoVKeHue maan. 8
3
3axOH Kblprbl3-
CI<ofi PecnyOJll1l111
.06 OnepaTI'IBHO-
P03b1CIIHoHJ\eSl-
TeJ1bHOCTH"
3allOH
JIaTBI1CI<O
Pecny6J1I11<11
.06 onepanJDHOH
Jlr:IITeJlbHOCnj"
<tJl:.!IepaJlbHblii
3allOH ..06 onepa-
'JI1BHO-p03bICKHOii
.ne.ll.TeJ1bHOCTI1"
3axOH Pecny6J111
1<11 Ka"J:.11[CT8H
.06 OnepaTI'IDHO-
p03bICI<HOHJ\CSI-
TCJ1bHOCTIJ"
3aKOH Kblp.-bl3-
Clloii Pecny6J1111111
..06 OnepaTl1BHO-
P03blcKHoJ:i.neil-
renbHOCTIJ"
3aKOH
JIaTBl1iicKOii
Pr:Cnv6.I1KI1
..06 onpunlBHoii
AeSlTeJ1bHOCTI1"

npoiJotl;JKeHUe maM. 8
I 2 J
AIITI1BHaSl, 34J(jJeKTBHaH []()M()Wb 4JHJI1 3alloH Jh'lTOBCKOfi
'I.eCKI1XJlHUOnJ1a'l.I1BaeTCH ('t. I CT. 5). Pecny6J1I1KI1..06
COTpyJ\HI1'JalOll{e no JJOrOBopy 1II1Ua 06ec- onepaTI1BHol1 J\eSl-
ne<II1BaIQTCJI COUl18J1bHblMI1 rapaHTI1J1MI1 TCJ1bHOCTIII»
('t.2CTS)
OpraHbl. ocyrneCTBJlJlIOWl'le OPJI.. MOryT 3aKOH Pecny6JII1-
3aKJ1IO'laTb KOHTpaKTbI C COBepllJeHHOJIeT- KI'I MOJl1l0Ba ..06
HI1MI1 J\eecnoc06HblMI1 JII1UaMI1 HC33BHCI1- onepaTI1BHO-
M() OT I1X rpa;KLIDHCTBa. Haul1()HaJIbHOCTIi. pOJblCKHoHJ\eSl-
nOJIa. COUl1aI1bH()ro. J\()J])KHOCTH()rO H TeJ1bHOCTIi»
I1MywecTBeHHoro []()J]())KeHHJI, n()JII1Tl1'le-
CKI1X 11 peJmrl10JHbiX yOe)K,}],CHI1H. npI1HarJ,-
JIe)l(HOCTI1 K 06mecTBeHHbiM opraHI1J<1UI1J1M
('t2CT IS).
OmeJlbHb!e rpWK,IWHe Moryr npl1BJ1eKaTbC.II
K nOllrOTOBKe 11 npOBelleHl11O OPM, B TOM
'l.MCJle 11 no 1I0HI1HKTV ('I.. I CT 15)
. lJt-paJupJeuHe KJlYra 1Jrn3H'IeCKHX .JUI!, npH
B,leKaeMblXK CfI1JJ)'1l HIt 'lfC11j)'
OpraHaM, OCYWCCTBJlJlIOWI1"t OPJI., Janpe- 41CllCp8J1bHbIH
waeTCH I1CnOJlb30BaTb KOH$WleHUI'I8J1bHOe JaKOH ..06 onepa-
C01leCTBHe no KOH"TpaKTY 1lenyr3Toe, cY- Tl1eHO-p03bICKHOn
lie", npOKypOPOB, 8lIHOKaTOH. CHSlweHHO- lIeJlTCJ1bHOCTH»
CJIY;KI1TC;JCH 11 []OJlHOMO'lHbIX npe1lCTaBI1-
TeJleH, ()<2JI1l1H8J1bHO Japemcl'pl1pOBaHHblx
enl1rHOJHblX 06belll1HeHI1H ('I.. 3 CT. 17)
3anpewaeTcH npHBJIeK"Tb K BblnOJIHeHl11O 3aKOH YKpaI1Hb!
onepaTHBHo-pOJblCIIHbIX 3a,/\a'l MellHUI1H- ..06 onepaTI1BHO-
,, pa60THHKOfl, CBHW e HHOCJIY)l(I1Tt:J1eH. pOJblCKHOHlleSl-
8lIBOKaTOB, eCJII1 JlI1U() no ()TH()llJeHI1IO. II TeJ1bHOCTI'I»
KOTOPOMY OHI1 llOJI>KHbl ocywecTBJlJlTb
OPM. HBJlJleTCH I1X nal.[l1eHTOM I1J1I1 KJlI1-
CHTOM ('I. 4cT. II)
3anpeTcJI I1CnOJlbJO(laTb IIOH4JI111eHUI1- 3aKOH PecnyOJlI1KH
aJIbH()e cOllei1cTBl1e H3 KOHTpaIlTH()H OCH()- l>eJlapYCb
Be HapOllHbJX llenyraToB, cYAefi, npoKYpo- ..060nepaTI'IBH()
POH. 8llBOKaTOB, CBSIlUeHH()CJlY>KlJTeJ1el1 pOJb!CKHoi111eSl-
nOJlHOMO'1HbIX npeJlCTamneJ1el1. ()<2JI1l.[l1- TI:J1bHOCTIII»
aJIbH() JaperI1CTpl'lpOBaHHb.!X peJlHrl1()JHb.!X
06'bellHHeHI1I1 ('I. SeT. 9)
84

llpooo,J;JKeHuema6il.8
I 2 J
OpraHaM, ocywecTBJlSlIOIlU:!),1 OP):!:. 3anpe 3aKoH KbJprbl3
waeTCSI I1Cn0J1b30H3Tb KOH.pmleHUI13J1bHoe CIlOti PecnyOJ1111111
COllel1CTBHe no KOH1]J3KT)' llenyraTOB. 1.)'- ..060nepaTI'IBH()-
lle. npOKypopOB, UlDOKdJOB. CBSlweHHO- p03blcKHOHlleJl-
cnyAOlTeJ1eH 11 nOJlHOMO'1HbIX npellCT3BI1- TeJ1bHOCTW>
TeJleH, ().pI1UI13J1bHO 3aperC1]Jl1pOBaHHblX
QeJJl1rI103HbIX06"be1lI1HeHI1i1('I Jcr 20)
3anpeweHo "PH nOMOilll1 MepOnpmrTI1H 3alloH
onepaTI!HO lleJlTeJlbHOcnl ueneHanpae- l1aTBI1i:cKo
J1eHHO nOJ1Y4aTb l1.upopMaIDJIO or npI1CJI)K- Pecny6J1I1KI1
HblX, a1lBOKaTOB, HOTapl1YCOB, npalJeH. ne.na- ..06 onep"TIiBHOH
rorOB, nCI1XOJ10rOB " l1)'XOBHb!X J1I1U BO DeRTeJlbHOCTI1»
BpeMSI ()Ka3aHI1S1 "M npoqJeCCI1()l-1WIbHotl:
nOM0ll.ll1, 3a I1CKJlIO'1eHl1eM CJlY43eB, Kor1l3
YKil3aHHbie J1I1UiI CilMH JlBJlJlIOTCJI 051,eKTaMJ1
onerJaTIiBH()f1 0060Tbl n.5CT.14)
OpraHBM, ocyweCTBJlJlIOWI1M OPLl, 3anpe- 3aKoH Pecny6}1I1-
waercR I1CnOJ1b30BaTb B CBOe" lleSlH}lbH()- KI1 MOJllIOBa
CTI1 KOH!tJl1JleHUIiMbHoe cOllef1cTBl1e  ..06 onepaTI1BHO-
KOHTpilllTHOii OCHOBe DenyraTOB, cYDe". p03bICKHO"
nnol(VnOI1OB .ne.llTeJlbHOCTI1»
7 06R3BHHOCTb llO'DKIIOCnIWI: J1HIl
- BBTbODTBHBM.OC\IltfC"I1IIUIIOIIDftI OPLl
Ll()}I)KHOCTHble J1I1Wl rocynapcrBeHHbIX 11 3aKOH Pecny6}111
J1HbIX npennpHT, Y4pe)l(J\eHJ1H, OpraHJ13a- KJ1l)eJJapycb
W'lH, BOI1HCKI1X 'iacreii B paMKaX caoeii KOM- ..06onepaTI'IBHO-
nereHU111'1 06S13aHbI OKaJblB.1Th cOllftrcmHe P03bIcKHotl.ne.ll-
O[JillHaM. OC\'wecnvmlOWI1M OPLl (CT 16) TCJlbHOCTI'I»
LlOJ1)KHOCTHble n" " ""'"'" pa6OTHI1KI'I 3aKOH Pemy6}1I1-
I"OcynapCT11eHHblx opraHoB, eeoow:rn, oprd- KI1Ka38H
HJ13aUI'IH H Y4pe)l(J\eHI1H (HeJaBI1CJ'1MO 0' ..060nepaTI'IBHO-
$>pM C06cTBeHHOCTI'I). OOi1CKOBblXlJaC'Te1i. P03bIcKHotl.neil-
CoellHeHI1H 11 06wecrBeHHbix o51,eJJJ\HeHI1H TeJlbHOCTIII»
Pemy6J1I1KI1 Ka3a\Cr..1H 06S13aHbl ()Ka3bIBaTb
c01leucnme oprBH3M, ocyweCTBJ1J1IOWl1M
OPLl. B peweHl111 3ailil'i, npenycuurpeHHblX
CT. 2 HaCTO}lwero 3aKoH3 'i. I CT. IJ
He npeilYC),IOTpeHO 33KOH Kblprbl3-
CKOti Pecny6}1HIII1
..06 OnepaTI1BHO-
P03bICIIHOH1leSl-
- reJ1bHOCTW'
85

I 2 J
8 YCT3HOB'Jfh '" gao.i"'1TOI... Jl;Jp:.."rev" CBeJI,e
JlHii, KacafOUI.IIXCSI KOH1I,1eHI,"anbHoro co-
'1eiiCT8HRHIIHI,/XacI1CKTQIIOPl{ 4Icliepa.rJ
CBelleHS1 06 I'ICnOJ1b3ycMb1X W111 HC!JOJ1bJO-
IJ.aHHblX npH npOlJellCHlU'I HCrIraCHblX aPM 33110H «06oncpa-
CI.JJIID:. CpeJ1CTBax, terolI81[. HCTO'lHHIQX.. TI'IBH()-P03bICKHOn
rJJJaHax 1'1 peJynbTaTa'l. OPD" () mUkl'<. BHC- .ne.llTeJlbHOCTH"
npeHHbIX . OpraHI130BaHHble npecrynHble
rpynnbl. (I WTarnblX HenJacHblx cOlpy1lHHKaX
opraHoB, ocyw:eCTRI1J1lOumx OPl{, (I mu.!ax,
OIla3bIBaIOIlII1XI1"tCOJleilcTBI1e JIB KOHIj:JI1-
}],eHL!3JlbHOi1 OCHOa!:, a TaIlJKC 06 opraHH3a-
L1H H (I TaKTHJ<C npOBell!:HHJI OPM, COCTBB-
MIlOT rocynap:;TBcHHYIO TaHHy Ii n()1lI1C)IW.T
pacceKPe'JI1IJaHI'lIO TOJIbKO "' OCHOIJaHI'IH
nocr.tHOBJICHHJI PYKOoo.nmerJJi opraHa, ()cy-
weCTWlIIOLl.lero GPIt ('1 I CT. 12 3aKoHP
CBelleHI1J1 () nlmBX, corpynHl1lJaIo!Ul1x 11JU'I
(;OTpyllHlJ'laBWI1X C OpraHaMI1, ocYlUeCTB- Kl1l)eJlapycb
JUllOllUIX OPl{ JIB KOH$lWeHI.taJ1bHOii OC- ..060nepaTI1BHO-
HOBe, COCT3BJHlIOT .-<K:yJ:\dpCT1!HHYIO Tm1HY P03bICKHOi1JJ,CSI-
Ii "toryr 6blTb npC.QBHbl 1Jl3CHOCTH TOJ1bKO C TeJ1bHOCTIJ»
IiX m'lCb\teHHoro COfJ13weHI1J1 'I JCT.17
CBe.[JeHml 0 rpmKllBH3X, COTPYllliWlaJOWI1X 3mWH Pecny6;m-
WlH cOTpynHwlaBlliHX C OpraHBMI'I. OCYWCCT- KI'I KaJaXCHIH
BJlJIIOIllI'IX OPil Ha 1I0HIPl1lIeHUI'laJ1bHOH oc- ..06 OnepaTI'IBHO-
HOBe, COCHUJ.1SlJOT rocynapcTBeHHyJO TaHHY H pOJblCKHOHneSl-
ci::a:;tT; :;iO C I'IX TeJ1bHOCTI'I»
CBelleHI1S1 ()6 Hcn()J]bJye).tb!X WlH I1cnOJlb- 3aKoH KbJprbl3
30BaHHbIX npl'l npOBe1leHI'II'I HernaCHblX CKOH Pecny6J1I'1KI'I
OPM CW1i:1X, cpenCIBu, MerOllax, I'ICTO'1HI'I- ..06 OnepaTI'IBHO-
Kax, n;rnHax 1'1 pJlbTaTax OPIL 0 Jll'luax, P03bIcKHoi1.u:eSl-
BHeJqJeHHblX B opraHI'I30BaHHbic npeCT)ln- TI:,JlbHOCTIII»
HblC rpynnbl, 0 WT3THbIX HcrnOCHbIX co-
"fPynHI1Kax opraHoB, ocvwecTBIIJlIOLUI'IX OPLl,
1'1 JlHWIX ()KaJbIBaIOWI'IX HM COlleHCTBl'le Hi:!
KOHIPl1lIeHUI'laJ1bHOH ()CH()Be. a Ta10Ke 06
opraHI'I3aUI'II'I 1'1 () TaKTKe npOBeJIeHH.II
OPM. COCTaBJIJlJOT rocynapCTBeHHYIO Taf1HY.
n011Jle),mT pacceKpe41'1BaHl'lIO To.'IbKO Ha oc-
HOlJaHl'I1'I nOCTaHOBJIeHlUl pyKOU01U1TeJlJl
opraHi:!, OCYllleCTBJlJllOlllITO OPIL B COOT-
:na:Hm;.bBOM Kblprbl3-
llpooo,J;JKI?HUI? maM. 8
86

-
2
ctJallT C!:KIJl:TIiOro COTPYJ\HI1'IrCTBa KaK ro-
CYll3.pCTl.eHHa!l TatiHB 06ccneLJI1I1TCSI oco-
UblM nopSlllKOM yqeTa. xpaHeHIUI Ii BbUIa'l11
I1H.pop",aUI1H, KOTOpblH ()npe!leJ11IeTC
cy6"eIlToM ()nepaTI'IBH()H lleSlTe}]bHOCT C
Y'1eTOM nOno;KeHI1H 'I.. 2 CT. 3 HOCTOSlluero
3aKOH3. BbJ1l3113 HI-JlJlopMallMI1 06 lilleH-
TI1'1HOCT ceKpeTH()rO nOMOIUHI1Ka 111111 0
€!JaKTe corpyD,HI1<jecTBa MO)l(C1 npol13Bo-
J\I1TbCSI TOJ1bKO B YCTaHOBJ1CHHO"t HOCTOSl-
11!I1M 3aKoHoM nopar:u<e ('I. 2 CT. 31)
CCKpeTHblH nOMOlUHI1K MO)l(!:T 6bITb npH-
BIIe4eH K yroJ10BHOM)' npoueccy fie3 PacKpbl-
nUl .paKT3 ceKpMHOfO CQ1JJYLlHHLJecrBa.
ctJaKT ceKJXTHoro COlpy.uHI'I'IeCTB3 JIHUa W1H
npellOCTBWleHHble 11M C(lel!CHI1J/ B XOl!e yro-
J[()DHOrO npouecca MOryr 61,1110 ()WaWCHbl B
TOM CJI)"Jae, eCJIH 310 HCOO'<OllJ'IMO ID1J1 lIOC-
nnKeHI1.II UeJleH C/It'J1C1H1JI, WTSI rapaHTI'IH
oorneCTBeHHOn 6e30naCHOCT. Ii J1Hllib II TOM
CJ1}"!ae, eCJU'I 3TO He CT3Bm nOll yrp03Y
)l(113Hb, JllOpOBbe. cB060llY ceKpenJoro no-
MOWHHKa 111111 npyroro JIJ1ua JlI{60 8031\.10)1(-
HOCTb IDUIbHef1wero HCnO.llbJOB.1I-U'IJ1 ceKpeT-
HOro nOMOIllHHKa ('I. 3 CT. 31)
n()J]Y'ICHHaSI C nOMOIUblO cpencTB onepa
THBHOf! neSlTenbHOCTI'I I1H.pOpM3UHSI MO)l(eT
6bJTb p"CKpbJT3 II X()lle c:yne6HOn npouellY-
pbJ c npei\lIapl1TJlbHOrO p,UpeWeHI1}1 re-
HepaJIbHOm npo,,"}'POpil. 3anpewaeTCJI I1C-
nOJlb30BaHI1e I1H$opMHUI1I1. nOJlY4eHHoli C
nOMOWblO cpeJICTB onepaTI1BHOH lICJlTCJ1b-
HOCTJ.I. He B uejUlx. B03Hl1l1alO" 113
caHIIUHOHI1DOBaHH()H CJ1e;KKH (OJ. I CT 9)
CBCJlCHI1S1 0 J111L\aX, CCJflJYJlHI14HIOIl!l1X 111111
CmpYJlHI1OjaBWI1X H8 U!eHUaJ1bHoi1
OCHOIIC C opraHalI1. ocyweCTBJISlIOw:,.nl
OPA HBJlHIOTCJI rocYllapcmeHHoH TaHHOH H
MOryr 6bITb npellat'lbl maCHOCT TOJ1bKO C
nl'lCbMeHHoro COIJ1.X'1IJ1 3TX mm (OJ 3 CT. 16)
87
llpooo,J;JKeHuema6il.8
J
3alloH
JIaTBI1HCKOH
Pecny6J1I1KI1
..06 ()nepaTHBHoil
neHTe11bHOCTH»
3aKOH JIHTOBCKOi1
Pecny6J1I1KI1
«06 onepawIBHOi1
neHTeflbHOCTI1"
3aKOH Pecny6}1I1-
KI1 MOJlllO(la
«06onepaTl'IBHO-
p03b1CKHOH neSl-
TeJ1bHOCTH»

nOJlmKeHItH. Kaca10IItileCH COJl,eiiCTIIIIH ..PIDK,lJ,aH OPJI:, I1pe1J..MalpH-
BalOTC1JeIJJIOIUIIeCTaTbHJaKOH08,
CTaTbl1 12, 17 <Dt:llepanbHoro 3allOHa 06 onepaTI1BHO-p03bICIIHOH
AeHTeJ1bHOCTI1"
CraTbli I) 3aKOHa YKpaH!>1 05 onepaTIlIIHO-po3bICMiOIi nellTeJ1bHocm».
CTaTbI1 16, 17 3aKOffi3. Pecny6;:[I1KI1 6e)/3pycb ,,06 onepaTHBHo-
P03bICIIH()HneHTeJ1bHOCTI1"
CTaTbl1 13, 13 3aKOffi3. Pecny6JII1KI1 Ka3axCTilH 06 onep!ITI1BHQ-
P03bICK-H()H neSlTeJIbHOCT"
CT!ITbl1 IS, 20 3al<Oli3 Kblprbl3Clwfi Pecny6JIItIlI1 05 onepanJBHO-
pOJbJcI<H()fin,eHTenbHOCTI1".
CTaThI1 30, 31, 32 3aKOHa JIaTBl'lficl<ofi PeCny6JIHIII1 ,,06 ()nepaTB-
Hoi1neJ'ITeJIbHOCTI1».
CTaThI1 4, 5, II 3al<OH J]I1TOBCl<ofi Pecny6J1111<1'I ,,06 onepaTI1BH()fi
,UeJlTeJ1bHOCTIJ»
CTaThI1 IS, 16 3aKoffi3. Pecny6J1I1KIJ MOJl1l0Ba ..06 onepaTI'IBH()-
P03bICII-HOHlleSlTeJ1bHOCTI1».

Ta6;uu.la9
COUJIaJIbIIo-npa80Ball3aWHTa'1'aQaH,'I{opraHalll,
OCYLQeCTB"lIlKlJllllIII OPI{, CO.-J18CHO JaKOHalll, peryJ1l1J1ylOJllIIIII OPD.
HCTpaHaxCHrHJ)aJlTHH
10&
.y,
ZJeMe#lmbiCO/{IIGJlb/ln-nptl6tJ6Oil30I14umbi
z
npaBO $lJII'K'('KH1{ _'1Hu, C'tJJ\f'iiCTIIyx one-
JI.t11DI- [JQ;JJIdJ,[J,('OJeI1HHIII, nO.'1Y'IaTb .-ocy-
Ihma, CO!leHCTB)lIOWl'le opraHaM, ocymecTB-
J1J1IOLQI'I},t OPD., HdXO!lJITC1I nOJl 3aWlno"
rOCYIlapCTBa('1.lcr 18)
- hll!O, nplllBJlellaeMoe K Bb![]OJlHeHI1IO 33J13.'1
OPD., HiUlOJ\I1TCH nOLI JaWI1TO" rocynapCTBa
('1.lcT 13)
1111l..ta, cOJ\eHcTBYJOWl'le opraHaM, OCYllieCTB-
J1J1IOWI'IM OPlJ., HaXOJ\S1TCH nOJ\ 33WI1TOH
rocYll8pcTBa('1.ICT.17)
Jil'll..ta, cOJ\ef1cTBYIOWl'le OpraH1I.M, OCYllieCTB-
J1JiIOWI'IM OPJI., HaXOILllTCH nO)l 33WI'ITOM
rocYIlapcTBa('1. I CT. 23)
JIl'lua, cOlIef1cTlWlOl.\U1e opraHaM, OC}1.Ile<:TB-
J1JilOml1M OPil, H3WMrrCH nOll 33LUI'ITOH
rOCYll8pCTBa('1. I CT. 21)
CeKpeTHble nOMOlliHI1KI'I HaXQIDITCJI nOll 33-
minoR rOCYJ\apCTBa, a CBelleHl'IJI 06 I'IX lflleH-
T'1HOCTI1 1'1 CKpeTHOM COlpYlIHI'I'ICCTBe C
cyfu,eKlUM OnepaTI'IBHoi1l1eSlTe.%HOCT JiBJJH-
IOTCSI ,-ocYJlapCTlR:HHOH TaHHOi1 ('I. I CT. 31)
89
HoutU!IKJ6OHUe
3C1KOHOdome,/bf/b/x
OKm06. pel.WtU!ll-
mupYIOl«ux OPJ/.
3
4te!leparrbHblA
:laKOH ...o6o!1cpa-
TBH()-P03b]CKH()H
,lleSlTeJ1bHOCTW>
3aKoH YKpal'lHbl
..06 ()nepaTl1BH()-
p03bICIIHOHIICH-
TeJlbH()CTI'ID
3aKOH Pecny6J1I'1-
1I1'I6CJlapYCb
«06 ()nepaTl1BHO-
P03bICIIHOH.u eH -
TeJlbH()CTI'I_
3aKOH Pecny6J1I'1-
111'1 Ka33XCT3H
«06 ()nepaTl1BH()-
pOJbICIIHOH.u eH -
TeJlbHOCTI'I»
3aKoH KblprblJ
CKO" Pecny6J1l'1u'I
..06 ()nepaTl1BH()-
p03blcIIHOH.ueH-
TeJlbH()CTI'ID
3aKoHJIaTBj:j-
CKOH Pecny6J1I'1KI'I
..06onepaTI'IBH()f1
,lleSlTeJlbHOCTI1"

1 2
COTPY1lHI1'1HlOllll1e no Jlorollopy mUla o6ec-
ne'll1eaJOTCH COLlL1aJlbHbIMJ.1 rapaHTlUIMI1 ('I. 2
CT.j)
1hm3. CO!leHCTBYlOllll'le opraH3M. ocymeCTB-
J1J1I0111I1M OPil, HaXOJJJ1TCH nOli 33WIiTOH
rocy.oapcTBa('I. I cr 16)
-----z- fapauTupoBaHHe $1I)II'IIeCIIHM JUIIIHM BblnOJl-
III.'HlteofiH)8'f('1]bCTBIIOKOtrI'paKTaMCHHM
focYIlapcTBo rapaHTpyeT J1l1lrnM, 1i3'b1IBJ1B-
U1I1M coroocl1e COlIeHCTBOmnb n() lIol-JTpalay
opraH3M, ocyweCTBJ1J1IOIlUI'" OPD.. Bb![]OJ[-
HeHI1C CBOI'l)( 06I13BTeJ1bCTB, npellycMolJleH-
HblX KOHTpaKToM, II TOM 'II1CJ1e rapaHTl1pyeT
npaBOI!YIO 3auuny. CBI13aHHYIO c npaBOMCp-
HblM BblnOi1treHl1eM YK":'!aHHbIMI1 .flIlI.taMI1
()OmeCTBeHHoro DOJ1fa I'IJ1H 1I03JIO)KCHHbIX HB
HI1XOOH3BHHocTetl ('I 2 CT. 18)
foC)'napCTBO rapaHTPY J11iU8M, 1'13'bIlBI'IB-
wm,t COIJ1OCI1C cOlIdiCTROfl3Tb no IIOHTpaKry
opraHBM, ocyweCTBJlJllOllll1M OPD., IIb![]OJ[-
HCHI1C CBOI1X 061133n:J1bCTB, npeIlYCMOlpCH-
HblX KOHTn."iKTOM '1..3 cr 17)
nXDK,1!dHaJ,t. 113HIBI1BU1I1M cornaclic coneilcT-
BOBBTb no 1I0HrpaKT)' opraH3M. ocyu.recm-
J1S1IOIUHM OPJI:, rocynapcTBo rapaHTl1pyeT
()tiecne'leHIfC I1X npaB 11 BblnOJ1HeHl'le 065133-
1l:J1bCTB B CocrroeTC11\1UI C HOCTOIIUU\M 3aKO-
:t;:'l::;XT;OP'lT:H;;1I1
rOCy.llapCTBO rapaHTupyeT J1I1I.!<1M, 1131>IIBI18-
ml1M cornacl1e cOllef1cTBoBaTb n() KOHTpaKTy
upraHaM. ()cymecTBJlSlIOUUiM OPD.. BblnOJ[-
Hem'le CBOHX OO.lI3aTeJ1bCTB, npellYCMOl'peH-
HbiX KOHTpallTOM, B TOM "mCJ1e rapaHTl1pyeT
npaBOB)'1O Jauuny. CBSlJaHHYIO C npaBOMep-
HbiM BblnOJ1HeHl1eM YllaJaHHblMI1 J1l1uaMI1
06meCTBeHHoro .Il()J1ra HJ111 B03l10)KeHHbIX HB
HI1X 06HJ<1HHocrefi (OJ 2 CT. 21)
90
flpotJo1JKeHUemafin.9
J
3aKoHl111ToI!CKofi
Pecny6J1I1KI1 06
OnepaTI1BHof1
AeSirenbHOCTM"
3aKOH Pecny6J1I1-
KI1 MonllOHa«06
onepaTI1BHO-
p03bICIIHofll\eH-
TeJ1bHOCrI1
4JerrepaJIbHbrf1
JallOH «06 one-
paTIJBHO-
p03bICIIHofll\eH-
TeJ1bHOCrI1
3allOH Pecny6J1I1-
KI1 6eJ1Bpycb
06 onep3TI1BHO-
p03bICIIHOHl\eH-
TeJ1bHOCrI1
3aKoH Pecny6J1I1-
1111 KaJaxcT3H
«06 ()nepaTl1BH()-
pOJbICIIH()HneH-
TeJ1bHOCTW>
3allOH Kblprbl3-
CKOf1 Pecny6J1I1KM
«06 ()nepaTl1BH()-
P03bICKH()f1neH-
TeJ1bH()CTW>

--.
-
rOCY.IlapCTBO .-apaHTl1pyeT Jll1uaM, J],aIJIllI1M
cornacl1e COlleHCTBOBBTb Ha KOHTpaKTHOH
OCHOBe C opraHaMI1, ocyweCTaJlJlfQWI1MI1
:n{):':I1=O;BOM()'l°T::B,
r3aIUllThIIJlH:JH'JeeKHMJlHualll.
cowicrBYH1I'''N IIIITII 1J()11""""JI8fH""
npl1 B03HI1KHOBeHW'l peaJIbHOH yrpo3b1 npo
TlI50npaBHoro nOCSIraTt:J1bCTBa }l(113Hb,
31lOpOBbe KJlI1 I1MYllleCTBO OTJJ,eJlbHbIX JIM!.! B
CBSlJI1 C !1X COlIeMCTBl'leM OpraHaM. OCYWCCT-
BI1J1IOIlII1M OPLJ" a paSHO '1nCHOB I1X ceMefi 11
6JJH3KI1X 3nJ upraHb! 00Sl3BHb[ npl'lHSlTb He-
06xOlUJJ.tble MepbI no npLlOTBpaweHI1IO npo-
nlBonp"BHbIX nelt<.'TBld1:. YCTBHOBJIeHI1JO 811-
HOBHblX 11 IJpIUlJ1e'leHI1JO !1X K (Jf1Ie'JCTI!eHHO-
CH!. npellYC'IOTPeHHoi1 3BKOH()lWTeJlbCTBOM-
POCCJJHCKoi141cllemUI1I1 (OJ 3 CT. 18)
npl1 BOJHI1KHOBeHlJl1 peaJIbHOH yrp03bl npo-
TlfBOnpaBHoro nOCSIraTeJlbCTBa }Ja }K3Hb, 3110-
pOBbe I1J]I1 I1MYllleCTBO OTIleJ1.bHbIX JIM!.! B CBJI-
311 C HX co.nericnnteM opraHaM, ocyureCTB-
J1J1IOUlM OPLJ" a paBHO 'InCHOB I1X CCMeH 11
6JJHJKIIX 3TI'I OpraHb! 06S1JaHbl npi1HSlTb He06-
XOllMb!e Mepbl no npellOTBpaweHlf1O npOT-
eonpaBHbJX .lIeHCTooi1. )'CTdHOBI1eHl1lO BHOB-
Hb!X 11 npl'lBJ1e'1eHI1IO HX K OTBe1C1BeHHOCTIf
'I 2 cr. 17
npl'l B03HHilHOBeHHH pea.rrbHoH yrpoJbl npo-
nmonpaBHQrQ nQCSlraTtJ1bCT&I ffil >KI1JHb,
3J1upoBbe 111m I1MymecTBO ()menbHblX J1HU B
CBHJI1 C I1X co!!dicTBl1eM opraH3M. OCY!l[eCT-
BJLlIIOIUi1M OPD., 3 paBHO '1neHOB I1X ceMef1 i1
611i1JKHX 3TI1 opraHbI 06H3aHbI npi1HJlTb He-
06XOJ{If},tble Mepbl no npe!!OTBpaIUeHlJlO
npOTi1BOnpaBHb!X AeHCTBi1H. YCTaHOBJ1eHI1IO
Bi1HOBHbIX 11 npl1BJ1e'1eHI1IO i1X K OTBeTcr_
BeHH()CTi1. a T8K>Ke n() npOBe.neHi11O B CJlY-
'1Ht" He06xOlll1MOCTI1 CneUI1a.J1bHbIX Mepo-
npI1J1Ti1f1 no I1X JBIUI1Te B nOpH.lIxe. onpe!!c-
:::X:H:J.;I1CTPOB Pecny6J1I1-
91
flpotJo1JKeHUemafin.9
J
3aKOH Pecny6nl1-
KI1 MOJUlODll «06
onepaTlfBHO-
P03bJCKH()f1n,e.ll-
TeJ1bHOCTI1»
<J>ellepa.rrbHblf1
3aIlOH«060ne-
paTI'1BHO-
P03bICIIH()Hne.ll-
Tei1bHOCrl-I»
3aKOH Pecny6nl1-
KI1 6cnapycb
..060nepaTI1BHO-
P03bICIIH()f1ne.ll-
TeJ1bHQCrW>
3aKOH PecnytiJ1I1KH
""=<="
«06 ()nep,m1BH()-
pOJblCIIHOH nc.ll-
Tei1bHOCTi1

-
2
npl1 B03HI1KHOBeHHH peaJIbHotl: yrpo3bJ npo
HlRonpaSHoro nOCSIfaTeJ1bCTA.a HB )l(113Hb,
JJ1upOBbe HIm I1MywecTBO ()rnenbHblX J1HU B
cefl311 C I1X cOlleMcTBHeM opraH3M. ocymecT-
BJlJllOllil1M OPD., a paSHO "!lCHOB 11" ce"tefi 1'1
6.r1113KI1X 3TI1 opraHbl 06S133Hbl npHH.ll.Tb He-
06XOIDJ"tble Mepb! no npeliOTspaweHHIO npo-
nJBOnpaBHbIx net!cTBI1fi. YCT:JHOBJIeHHIO BH-
HOBHblX 11 npHBJ1e'IeHmO I1X II QTBt':TCTBeHHO-
::":::II 'la:,o;;bCTBOM
EC1UJ B CBA311 C cexpeTHblM COTpyllHH'iecr-
80M B03HHKaeT peaJIbH3S1 yrp03a )l(1'I3HI1,
JJ1opOBblO, I1MymecTBeHHblM H.f111 .npyrHM
JaKOHHblM HHrepecaM CeKpeTH()rO n()!>t()W-
HHKa 11 "IJleHOB em ceMb. He06xollHMO
npHHJlTb Mepb! 6eJOmICHOcT J1JIJI ycrpaHe-
HI1.11 :noH yrp03bl, BKJlIO'IaSi cMeHY MeCTa
::e;:::CT (O:YCB, yllOCTOBepSlIO-
npH B03HHKHOBeHI1i1 yrpOJbI >K1'I3HI1, 3110
POBblO. HMymecTey ceKpeTHblx }"13CTHHKOB
I'IJ1H 'iJIeH()B I'IX ce",di Cy6beKTb! ()nepaTlfB-
HOll JremeJ1bHOCTH npHHlJMmOT lice Ht'OOXo-
11l'lMble Mepbl llJ1S1 JaLID:lTbl )1(1131"11'1. JL!OpoflbSl,
AOCTOIIH..."TB I 11 I1MyJl1eCTBa. COBepWeHHbJe
npOTl1B 3TI1X JURI npecrynJleHItSi. CBI!3BHHble
C If X TaHHblM corpYllHII'lecTBOM C onpelle-
J1eHHbIMH roCY.l!apCTBeHHbIMI1 I1HCT1nyw;UI-
MI1. IIBa.rJI1$I1Ul1pyIOTCJI fia OCfiOflaHl111 CooT-
BeTCTBYIOIllI1X CTaTe Yro.llOBHOro KOlleKca
('I..lcT.11
npl1 B03HHilHOBeHHI1 pea.rJbHOH yrpo3b1 npo
TIIIBOnp"BH()rO nOC$lr.rreQbCTB" Ha )K113Hb,
J1l0pOBbC 11.1111 I1MywecTBO OT.l!t.llbHbIX nHU B
CBS/3M C HX COllel1CTBHeM upraHaM. ()cymecT-
BI1J1lOllII1M OPLl, a paBHo 'UleHOB I1X ceJ.tdi 11
6.rJ113KI1X 3TM opraHbI OOnaHb! npMHJlTb He-
06xOJUfMble Mepbl no npeiloTBpaweHmo
npOTI1BOnpaBHblx .uei1CTBI1H. YCTaHOBl1eHl11O
BMH()BHbIX 11 npl1B11e'leHl1lO I1X II ()TBeTCT-
BeHHOCTI1 ('I.. JeT. 16)
92
llpooo,J;JKeHuemafiJl.9
3
3aKoH KblprblJ
CKOH Pecny6}1I1I1M
..06 ()nepanlBH()-
p03b1CKHOH.ne.ll-
Te.llbH()CTW'
3aKOHJ1aTBI1li-
cKofi Pecny6.11I1KH
..06onepaTI1BHoH
neSlTe!1bHOCTW'
3aKOHJ1I1TOBCKOfi
PtCny6}1(JKI1
..06onepaTMBH()fI
.neSlTeJ1bHOCTI1»
3allOH Pecny6}1I1-
KI1 MOJl1l0Ba ..06
onepaTMBHo-
P03bICKH()fi.ne.ll-
Te}1bHQCrI1»

1 -
---t-I=:':=
_ ;M3"=:::::=a:::"
COBepWI1BWee npOTl1BOnpaOHOe nem-me. He
n()BJ1CKWee '[}f)KKI'I!I: nOCJlellCTBI'I. Ii npl1BJ1C-
'Ie!iHOC K COlpy.QHW1CCJB}' C opraHOM, ocy-
llIeCTB.:ISIIOLl!lI"t OPD.. 3KTBHO cnoco6CTBO-
B<1Bwee pacKpbITl'l1O npecrynJIeHI1.11. B03Mec-
TI1Blliee H8HeCCHHblH ywep6 11J11j I1HbI"t cno-
COtiOM 3arIlWUJBlliec nplf'1I1HCHHblH BpCll,
QCI1060)l(J{aeTCSI OT yrQJ10BHofi OTBnCTBCHHO-
CHI e COOTBeTCTBl111 C IaKOHOllJ]'eQbC11IO\I
POCCI1HCKoi141eJJ,eOOUHI1 ('I 4 CT. 18)
npH HlI3H8'1CHlUi H8K838HI1J1 B OTHOIl1CHHI1
Rim 113 'JI1CJIa npecrynHOH rpynnbl, COBCp-
WI1BWHX np01BOnpaBH()e nCSlHl'IC Ii npl'lBJ1C-
'JCfiHb!X II COTpYDHI'I'JeCTB}' C opraHOM, ()cy-
mCCTBJISlIOL1W1"t OPD.. aKTBHO cnoco6CTBO-
BaBWHX paCKPbIT1O npecryruJCHml, BOJMCC-
nlBWI1X HaHeCCHHblH ywep6 l1}m HHblM ()o-
paJOM 3arJIaL\I1BWI1X nplll'l.IfHCHHbIH "pea, cyn
Y<JI1TblBaeT JlBHHblC 06cmJJTenhCTBa KaK 06-
CTOSITC.IIbCTB8, CMSlf'UUOIllHC OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb
B COOmCTCTBl:U'1 C yrOJ1()BHbIM 3BKOHOliaTeJ1b-
CTBOM Kbl rbl3CKoii PCCnv6n111111 (OJ, 4 CT. 21
5 T]OJIV'reI1IICB03H8
ll1ua, COTpyllHlf48101lIltC C opraH8MI1, ocy-
WCCTB,;ISIIOUUJMH OPLl, .'11160 OIla38BWI1C 11M
nOMOll.lb Ii paCKPbIT11 npecrynJlCHI1J1 HJ111 B
YCT8HOBJICHi1H J1HU, I1X COBepWI1BUlI1X, MOryT
n()J])"-1aTb B03Harpa)l(l!eHI1J1 11 npyrl1e BbUU1a-
n()J]}'4eHHb!e }'Ka3aHHbIMI1 ImuaMI1 CYM-
Mbl B03HJrp-OKJJ:eHI1 11 npyrl1e eblnJIfffbI Ha-
J1uraMI1 He ()fu!araIOTCSI 11 B lleK!1apa.u"SIX ()
1l01l:0llilXHevt<"3bIBaJOTCII (OJ Scr 181
1I11lIa. corpynHH'JalOUll1e C opraHaMl1, ocy-
weCTBJLlllOUlI1MI1 OPJI:, I1MelOT npaBO Ha no-
J1}"1elme R03Harpa)l(l!CHI1J1 (OJ SCT 23)
93
llpooo,J;JKeHuemafin.9
CJ>nepaJ1bHbl
3aKOH,,060ne-
paTI'IBHO-
P03bICIIH()Hllell-
Tt:J1bHOcrW>
3allOH Kblprbl3-
CKO Pecny6J1I1KI'I
,,06 ()nepaTl1BH()-
p03b1CIIHOH 1l1I-
TeJ1bHocrl1»
CJ>ellepaJ1bHbIA
3aIlOH,,060ne-
paTI1BHO-
p03bJCIIH()fj D,e.ll-
Tt:J1bH()CTW>
3aKOH Pecny6J1I1-
KI1 Ka3aXCraH
«060nCpaTI1BHO-
p03blclIHOHneJl-
TeJ1bHOCTI1»

flpoiJotlJK:eHUema6ll.9
1 2 3
1l1ma. corpynH11'1aJOl.l.ll1e C OpraHaMI1, ocy- 3allQH KblprblJ-
l.l.leCTBJ1HfQWIf"11f opn, ]]lIDO OKa3aBWlfe If "1 CKOM PecnyfuJl1KI1
nO"1Ol.l.lb B p"CKpbJTI111 npeCTYn:IeHI11 1'IJl11 e «06 ()nepaTI1BHO-
YCTaHOBJ1eHIfI1 1!11l!, I1X cOBepllilfBlliHX. "10- P03blcIIHoi1neH-
'Y' n()J]y<laTb B03HarpmKlleHI1H . npyrl1e TeJIbH()CTI1"
BbmaTbI('I..5CT.21)
CeKperHoe cOTpynHI1'1.eCTBo MOJKeT 6blTb 3aKOH11I1Tl1lfli-
onJlII'lmlaeMbl"1 CellpeTHble nOMOI.l.lHIfKH C CKOM PecnyfuJl1KH
11)( COfllaClf.ll MoryT npl1BJ1eKarbCH K onepa- ..06onepaTI1BHoH
TIIIBHOH neSlTe.bHOCT 1'1 H3 OCHOBe norOIJO- neSlTeJ1bH()CTH»
pa('l. 3 CT. 30) 3aKoH pecnyfuJ
111100. cOTpynH11'JaIOI.l.lHe C ()praH:'IMI1, ocy
l.l.leCTI1J1HIOWIf"111 opn. l1"1elOT npaBO OKa3b1- KI1 MonllOBa ..06
BaTb 11M COlleHCTBl1e KaK 6eJBOJMe311H(). TaK ()nepaTHBHO-
11 3a IJ03ffi3.rpmlUleHl1e ('I.. 4 CT. US) p03b1CIIHOH neR-
RJ1bHOCTW'
. nOKOHTpaKTY
nepH()ll corpynHI1'JeCTBa """"". no IIOH <l>ellCpaJIbHblj:j
TPU-1)' C opraHa"1lf. OCyll1eCTBl1HIOWI1MI1 OPD. 33.KOH«06 onepa-
B Ka'JeCTBe OCHOBHOro palla 33.HHTI'I BKJIJO'Ja- TI'IBH()-P03bICKHOR
eTC.II B TPynoBOH CTfl)K rpIDI\1IdH. YKa31HHble AelTeJ1bHOCTIf»
JlI1U3 I1MelOT npaBO Ha neHCIfOHHQe 06ecne-
'leHl1e B COUJ'IIeJ'CTBIfH C 33.KOHO.naTeJ1bCTBOM
POCCHi1cKOH(]:IClIepaL.!11 ('I. 7 CT. 18)
COTpYl!HI1'JeCTIIO JlI1Lla C onepaTI1BHbl"1 n01(- 3aKOH YKpal1Hbl
pa31leJ1eHl1eM Ja'J1'ICJlHeTCli B 061.l.lHH Tpyno- «06 ()neparI1BH()-
DOli CT3JK B CJly'lae 3aKJI104eHI1}1 C HI1M Tpy- P03b1CIIHOHneSl-
1l0OOro COrJI1illieH111J ('J. 2 CT 13) TeJ1bHOCTIf»
neplfOll corpYllHIf'1eCTIIa rpa}l(j]aH B K3'JeCT- 3aKoH Pecny5J1I1-
Be OCH()BHOrO pOJIa 3aHJITI'IH n() KOHTpaKTY C KI1 6eJl:Jp}O:b
opraH3MI1. ocyweCTBJ1HIOI.l.lI1MIf OPD. 11 Ka- ..060nepaTIfI1HO-
..eCTBe ()CHOBHOro pOlla 3aHSlTlfH Bl(JllO'JaCT- P03bICI<H()nne.ll-
" B I1X TPYllOl1oli CT3JK. YK333HHble JlI1Lla TeJ1bHoc-rl1
IfMelOT npaBO Ha neHCI10HHOe 06eCne'ieHl1e
B C()OTBeTCTBlfI1 C lIenCTBYlOWI1M 33.KOHOlla-
TeJ1bCTBO"1 ('J 5 CT. 17)
94

2
nepl'I()ll COT]J}lJiHWleCTBa rpa;K1laH no KOH
TpaKl)' Ha ruJaTHOH OCH()Ie C opraHBMM,
OCYIlICCTBJlSlIOI.l.lI'IMI'I OPfl. BKJlIO'laeT B TPY-
.DOBOn CTa rpIDKllBH. 01-11'1 l'IeJOT npaBO HB
neHCI'I()HHOe oGecne'JeHl'le B CJ1)"Jae rI'lOeJ1M
1'1" CeMbl'l 11 ('DI\..!\IfBeHLlbl - till nCHCl110 no
CJlY'IalO nOTepl1 KOpMI1J1bua B COOTBeTCTIII1I1 C
nekCTBYlOllil'lM 3aKOHQmrreJlbCTIJOM I{ B no-
pSlllKC, onpe1le!1S1tOM Ka6lfHeTOM MIfHI1CT-
pOB Pecny5J1I1KI'I K"Ja"':TJH (l!. 6 CT. 23)
nepl'lOLl COTpylIHI1'-jeCTBa rpB)KL!aH no KOH-
TpaK1)' C opraHBMl'I, OC}'llIecTDJJllfOllIl'IMI'I
opn. B KB'JCCTBe OCHOflHoro pOll3 3(lHSlTIII}1
BKJ1IO'laeTCSI B rpynol1oii CTa)K rpa>KJ\BH.
Yt-a31HHble 11lfUa I1MCIOT npaBO till neHCM-
OHHoe 06ecneqeH(']e B COOTreTCTIllUI C 3aKO-
HOllaTcnbCTBOM KbIprbl3CKof1 PecnyfuJl1KH
('I.. 6 CT. 21)
nepl'lOll COTpYlIHI1<jeCTBa rpa)KilllH n() KOH-
Tpatay C ()praI-JaMI'I. ocywecTBJlJlfOlUl'IMI'I
opn. BKJ1104aeTCSI B !'IX TPY1l0BOH CT3}1( B
113'leCTBC OCHOBHOll JlCSlTeJ1bHOCTIf. YKa33H-
Hble 11lfLl3 IfMCIOT npaBO Ha neHCI'IQHHoe
06eCne'leHl1e B COOTBCTCTBIUI C 311KOHOJLil-
TCJIbCTBOM 0 neHCI10HHO),t 06eCne4CHI'IM BO-
eHHOC.V}l(all.lI1" ('I.. 6 CT 16)
7 flpoBencu"c cnCUHUbHbJX \It'POIl1IJUIDfJi
B ueJlJlx ()fiCCnC'lCHIffi 6c30nacHocTI'I nl1Ll,
COTPY1lHIf'lliIOIlHIX op.-aHam ocyw:eCTB-
11JUOW:I1MI1 OPD. 11 'iJ1eHOB I1X ceMeii .!\onyc-
IIBeTCSI npOBe.!\eHl1eCneLll18.'IbHbIX Meponpl1S1-
TI1H no I1X 3aW:I1Te B nopJI.!\Ke. onpe.!\e.JUle-
MOM 3aKOH01laTeJlbCTBOM POCCI1HCIIOi1 $e-
AepaU1111 ... 8CT 18)
B cJI)"-1ae B03HI1KHOfleHI1J1 y.-paTh! )K1'I3HI1,
3..IJ.0pOflblO 111111 I1Myw:eCTIlY 1111U3, npm:lJ1e-
l<8eMO'-O II (lblnOJlHeHI1IO 33ll8'J OPil, e.-o
381lW1Ta 05ecne'JI1B8erCJI B nopHilKe, npeilY-
CMOTpeHHOM 'J. 3 CT. 11 H8CTOSlll{e.-o 38KOHB
('J.3cT.13)
95
flpoiJolJK:etlue mOOI. 9
3
3aKoH Pecny6.r1l1
KIf KaJaxcT8H
...06 onepaTl1BHO-
P03bJCKH()f111e.ll-
TeJlbH()CTW'
3allOH KblprblJ-
CKOH Pecny6.rJ111111
06 onepaTI1RHO-
P03blcIIHoi111eJl-
TeJlbHOCTI1»
3aKOH Pecny6J1I1-
Kl'I MOJUIODB 06
onepaTI1BHO-
p03blcIIHoi111eJl-
ttJlbHOCTI1
$eilepaJIbHblf1
JallOH
06 onepBTI1BHO-
p03bJCIIHOH neJl-
TeJlbHOCTI1
3aKOH YKpal1Hbl
06 onepaTI1RHQ-
P03blcIIHoi111eH-
TeJlbHOCTI1»

B LlClUlX 06eClle'leHI1S1 6e30rmCHOCTH 1111U,
COTp)'HHl1'mJOLllX no KOHrp3Kl)' C opraH3MI1,
OCYLllCCTBJ1S1IOLllHMI1 OPll, 11 'lJlCHOD I'IX CC-
MeH .!\onyclI3ercSI npoBCi\eHl1e CneLllf3JIbHblX
Meponpl1J.lTM no I1X 3all\I1TC B nopJ.l!lK. on-
pCHeJ1S1eM()M ()pr3H3tI1. YK3J3HHb!MI1 B .... 1
CT. 2 HacTOSIlliero 3aKOHa (... 6 CT 17)
B llCJlSlX 06ccne...eHIUI 6c.!OnacHocTI1 nl1Ll,
COTpYAHI1...alOllIHX C opraH3MI'I, OCYLlleCTB-
l1S1IOLllHtI1 OPll. 11 'lJlCHOB I1X CCMC lIonyc-
lIaeTCSI npOBellCHl1e CnermaJIbHblX Mepo-
npl1.11TI1f1 no I1X 3aLllHTe e nopHliKe. onpeHe-
l1S1eMOM 33KOHUliaTeJ1bHbIMI1 11 I1HblMI1 H()P-
MaTBHbIM(J npaBOBbIM(J 311TaMI1 Kblprb!3-
CKOi1 PeCnvfu11I11 ('J. 7 CT. 21)
B LlCJ1J1X o1:Jccnc'JcHI1S1 6c30nacH()CHJ 1II1Ll,
COTpYlIHlf'mIOWX no KOHTpaKl)' C opraH3"'I1,
ocyweCTBJlJllOll\HMI1 OPll, 11 'lJ1eHOB I1X ce-
Mef1 HonYCKaeTC.II npoBcIleHl1e CnCLll1311bHbiX
MCpOnpl1S1TI1 no I1X 3aWI1Te B nopSlllKe, ()n-
pei\eJ1S1CMOM npaBH:J1bCTBOM ('l. 7 CT. 16)
8 B C aerH6e.1H
B CJ1y'me r6e1l11 JII1Lla. COTp)'lIHI1'J3IOwero
no KOHTP"KTY C OpraHaMI1. OCYll\eCTBJlJlIO-
LllMMI1 OPll, B CID!3M C ero }"IaCTl1eM B npo-
BelleHl111 OPM CeMbe nocl]Jam!Bwero 11 111'1-
LlaM, HHXO.!\"WI1MCJI Ha cro 11}1()\I1BeHI1(J, 113
cpellCTB COOTReTCTEYlOlllero 610IDKeTB BbI-
nJl3'tI1B3erC.II elll1HOBpCMeHHOC n()c06l1e B
paJMcpe lICCSlTI'IJ1eTHerO nCHeJKH()rO COIlep-
}!(BHI1S1 nor6wero 11 B yCT,1tJOBlIeHHO),t 3a-
KOH()M n()pSlHKe HaJH3'1aeTCJI neHCI1.11 n()
CJ1}"1DIO nOTeoo KODMI'IJ1bLla ('l 9 CT 18)
EC)/11 11 CBil311 C BblnOJ1HeHl1eM TBKI1M 1111LlOM
3M3'! OPll HaCl)'[JI1JI3 ero I'IHBaJII'I1lH()CTb
11J111 CMCprb, H3 Hcro pacnpOCTpaHJlJOTCSI
l1brOTbl. npei\YCMOTPCHHbIC rID.Q06Hb1X
CJ1Y'la.llX MJI pa60THI1KOB onepaTl1eHblX nOll-
p3311eJ1eHI1f1 (... 2 CT. 13)
96
llpo()(u;JKeHue maM. 9
3allOH PecnyfuJl1-
K1'I6cJl3pyCb
..06 ()nepaTI1BH()-
P03bICIIHOHlICH-
TeJIbHOCTI1»
3allOH Kblprbl3-
CKOf1 PecnyfuJl1KI'I
..06 ()nepaTI1f1HO-
p03bICIlHOHl\eH-
TeJIbHOCTI1
33KOH Pecny6J1I1KH
M011l1()l1a
«06 onepaTI1BHO-
P03b1CKH0f1D,C.II-
T<:J1bHOCTI1»
f1>clIepanbHblH
JalloH«060ne-
paTI'IBHO-
P03bICKH()Hl\C.II-
-reJ1bHocrl1
3aKOH YKpBI1Hbl
..06 ()nCpaTI1BH()-
P03bICKH()Hl\e.ll-
ttJ1bHOcrl1

1 2 3
B CJly'me r6eJ[I1 J1Mua, COTpylIHl'I'JalOwero 3aKoH Pecny6JU:lKH
no IIOI-ITpaKI)' C OpraHaMM, ocyweCTlJJlJlIO- EeJ1apycb
uuum opn, B CBII3M C ero )"JacTHeM B npo- ..06 ()nepaTMBH()-
BelIeH111'1 OPM CeMbe nOCTparrnBwero 1'1 ero P03bICKl-1()HneJl-
tDK.IJ.l1f1CHUaM 113 cpellCTB YlOwero RJlbHOCTW>
610lVKcTa B!>ln)1a'l.If(lCJI elilfHOHpeMeHHoe
noco611e B pa3Mepe J{eCHTI1J1Hero cOlIep-
)!(3HMSI nor6wero 11 B YCT3HOB..'IeHHO),t 33-
: eSl::01=:::e; 7 S1 no
B cJI)"lae rl'l6eJU'I rpa)K!!aHHl-m. corpynHl1 3aKoH Pecny6J1HJG'1
<jalowero no 1I00-ITpaKTY C upraHaMl1, ocy- Ka3aXCTaH
WeCTBJlJlfOWMMM OPD, B CDSlJH C ero )"Ja- ,,06 ()nepan1BHO-
CTHeM B npoflClleHMI1 OPM ceMbe n()n16we- P03bICIIH()Hn e ll-
ro 11 ero IUIUJJ!lJeHuaM In CpellCTII COOTBer- RJlbHOCTIf»
CTlI}flOllIero 6101IJKeTa BblnJ13'1.IfBaeTCJI =-
HOBpeMeHHoe noco611e B pa3Mepe neCSITIj-
neTHero J\eHe)KHoro COaepJKaHMSI norlf6we-
roo COTPYllHIf'lliBlllero H1I nlIHTH()H OCHOBe, B
p3.3Mepe JleCSlHI .-oJ\OBbIX CYM),t ),tIfHI1MaJlb-
:e:1:n n:ca;:e :r7!12;aHwero 3aKOH Kb
B CJ1Y'lae r6eJlI1 nMLIiI, COTPYlIHl1'lalOwerO
no IIOI-ITpaKI)' C OpralIDMM. ocyweCTlJJlJlIO- CKOH PecnyfuJl1l1l1
WI1MI1 opn, II CBfI3H C ero )"-1acTHCM B npo- ..06 ()nCpaTI1BHO-
BelleH(J11 OPM CCMbC nOCTpa.!la5wero (J nl1- pOJbICIIHOHll C JI-
UBM, HHXO.lUIWl1MCH HB ero IUIU\lfBCH(J(J, 113 TeJ1bHQCTW>
cpellCTB COOTBeTCTBYlOwero 61Q1:L;KeTd
nJ1a'l.IfBaeTCH eJ\I1HOllpeMeHHoe noco61'1e "
pnMepe lIecHnrnCTHero J\eHeJKH()ro cOllep-
)!(BHI1J1 If B YCTBHOBJ1eHHOM 3allOHQM nopSlll-
n:':::H8 I no cnY4alO nOTepl1
B CJ1Y'Jac rH6ejJif nI1UB, COTpylIHIf'JalOl1!CrO 3BKOH Pecny6jJlfKIJ
n() IIOHrpaKI)I C ()praHaMl1. OCYWCCTBJ1J1IO- M()jJlI()Ba
WI1MI1 opa. II CBflJH C ero Y"HlCTHCM B npo- ..06 ()nepaTIfBH()-
BellCHI1I'I OPM ceMbC nOCTpa.aBBwero 11 ero pOJbICIIHOHll C JI-
I1>1<.1111BCHUHM If3 cpellCTB COOTBeTCTBYlOmero TeJ1bHQCTW>
61Ql1JKeTa I1bI[lJ]a'JI1BaCTCSI ClilfHOBpCMeHHoe
noco611c B pa3MCpe lIOCHT1tneTHerO J\eHeJKHO-
ro COlIepJ!<,3HI11 nom6mcro 11 B ycrBHOBJrCH-
HOM 3BKOHOM nOpJlllKC Ha:JHa'JaCTCSI nCHCWI
no CJlV'ffi1O noTCPI1 KOPl\lKJIbUB 'J. 8 CT_ 16)
flpotJo1)Kffluemafin.9
97

llpo()(u;JKeHue maM. 9
+ 2 3
9 np' nOJl.Y'lCHlt1t TpaeM, paHCHItH, yoC'IHH,
- KOHl)'3HH
npli nOJl}"ICHl'Il1 JlI1UOM, cOTpynHI1'1aIOIUI1M <J>enepaJ1bHblt:!
no IIOHrpaKTY C opraHal\.tl'I, OCYllleCTBJlSlIO- 3alloH«06one-
l!Il'IMl'I opn, TpaBMb!. paHeHI1S1, KOHTY311, paTIiBHO-
YBe'lbSl, HaCl)'rmBWI1X BCBSl31i cerO)"JacTli- P03bICKH()Hne.ll-
'M , npOBeneHl111 OPM " I1CKJIIO'IaIOIUI'IX TeJlbH()CTW'
'"" Hero e03MO)l(HOCTb naJlbHCHwero <0-
TP}'nHI'I'l.eCTlla < OpraHBMl1, OCYllIeCTBJUlIO-
l!Il'IMl'I opn, YKa3aHHOMy JlI'IUY 113 CP!:1lCTB
COOTBeTCTlJ)llOwero 61OIDKeTiJ. BblnJIa'll'lBaeTCSI
CnI'lH06peMeHHoe noco611e B pa3Mepe rlSITI'I-
IICTHerO neHe)KHOrO COJlepAW.HI'I11'I , yCTa-
HOBJ1eHHOM 3aKOHOM nQpSlJlKt Ha3tm.'I.8eTCSI
neHC(JSI no (JHHaJ1IV1HOCTIII ('I. IOcT IE)
npli n()J]Y'!eHl'I(J JlI1UOM. cOTpynH(J'JaIOIlI(JM 3allOH Pecnyfum-
no 1I0HTpaKTY C ()praHaMI1. OCYlUeCTBJI.IIIO- KI'I EeJlapYCb
WIiMI1 Opn, TeJleCHblX nOBpe)l(1!eHl'If1 ",- ...06 ()nepaTI1BHO-
CTym1BWCro B CBSI3H C ero Y'1OCTHCM B npo- P03bJCIIHOHntSl-
BeJleH(J11 OPM (J I1CIU1104BIQU{IiX JU1S1 Hero ttJlbHOCTH»
B03MOJl<HOCTb .lL3JIbHetiwero COlpyJlHl1'Jecr-
!la, eMy BblnJla'lI1BaeTCSlI13CpeJlCTB COO1BeT-
CTBYlOlUero 610fuKCTd enl1HOBpeMeHHoe no-
co611e pa3Mepe mlTHJlenrerO neHe)KHoro
COJlep)KaH(JSI " 11 YCTaHORJIeHHOM Iail0HOM
nop.llJllle Ha3Ha'iaeTC.II neHCMSI fl() l'IHI1aJ1It11-
H()CTIi('l. 8 CT. 17)
np" nOJlY'leHI1I1 rpa)l(JlaHI1HOM. COTPYllHM 3aKoH
lJalOI.l.lHM < OpraHaMI1. OCYl!IeCTBJI.IIlOllIHMI1 Pecny6J1I1KI'I
opn. YBe'1bSl l1H60 (JHoro nOBpe)l(1!eHHSI Ka3aXCTdH
JJIOPOl1bSl. nonY'1eHHoro B CBH3111 C ero Y4a- «06 onepaTMBHO-
CTHCM B npOBClleHl'IM OPM, C)ofY I1blnJIa'll'l- P03bICIIH()Hlle.ll-
eaeTC.II enI'lH()6peMeHHoe n()c06l1e B pa3MCpe TeJlbH()CTI1»
fIJlTHJIeTHerO nCHe)KHOrO COJlep)l(BHHSI ,"n,
cOTpynHM'laIOU{HX "" nJlBTHOll OCHOBt, "
paJMepe nSlTIt rOnOl1blX cyMM MHHMMBJ1bHOti
JapaGOTH()H nJlaTbl JU1S1 cOTpynHI1'1alOWl1x Ha
6eJ60JMe31lHoi1 OCHOBe ('I. 8 CT. 23
.8

-
2
nplJ n()J]}f'leHl'IM J1I1UOM. cOTpynHI1'laIOWI1M
n() IIOI-ITpaKI)' C opraHa"tI1, ocywecTMHIO-
IlII1M" OPD., TpaBMb!, paHeHMH, IIOHTY311£1,
}'Be'lbSl, H3Cl)'!U'lBIlII1X BCBSl3M cero)"JaCTI:I-
eM B npOBeneHMM OPM Ii MCK,1fO'13IOWHX
.DJ11j Hero IJ03"'O)l(HOCTb nanbHei1wero co-
Tpy.aHH'JeCTB3 opraHaMl'I. OCYllIeCTBJUUO-
1lI(J}.t!1 OPD" YKa3aHHOMY 1111UY 113 cpellCTB
COOT11eTcTl1ylOme.-o 610JVKeTa BblnlIa'JI1BaerCSI
enHHoepeMeHHoe noco611e B pa3Mepe nflTI'I-
JleTHefO neHe)KHoro C()llepJl(aHI1IJ 11 B YCTa-
::H\1:::O:K cHT3;:,;rneTCSI
ECJU'I cellp<:Tl-lblH nOMOLUHMIl npl'l BblnOJlHe-
liMl'I JallaHml cy6'beI<Ta onepaT(lHOii ..leJl-
TCJ1bHOCTI1 n0J1Y4(1]1 I1HBaJll1!!HOCTb 1111" no-
rlf6 nl160 tmHeCCH ywep6 CTO 31lOpO!lbIO I1}1I1
I1MyllleCTBeHHblii Ylllep6. eMY l'IJlI1 'UleHBM
ero ce),tb I1b1nJl3'lI1BaIOTCJI noC0611J1, neH-
elflf 111m KOMneHcaUlf1f COOTBeTCTBIUI C
3aKOHOM. npenycMaTpl1omoUlMM TaKl1e BbJ-
nnaTbl ./lOJl)l(HOCTHbJM JlI'IU3M Y'1pe)l(1!eHl'ltI
COOTBeTCTBVIOUlero cy6beKTa onepanlBHoJ:i
AeSlTeJ1bHOCTI'I " 2 CT. 32)
npl1 n()J]Y'!CHHI1 11I1UOM, cOTpynHI1'laIOWIiM
no IIOHTpaKry c oprnHaMlf, ocyweCJBI1RIO-
l!I(JMIf OPLt. paHeHI1S1 KOHT)'31Jt1, YBe4bSl
11.1111 (lHOt1 T]J3BMbl BCBSI3IJ cero Y4acTIJeM B
npOBe.lLeHI1I1 OPM 11 I1CKJ1IO'la1Oll.l11X j]JUI
Hero B03MO}l(HOCTb JJ,aJ1bHetiwero C01JJ}f.!\HI1-
'JeCTB3 eMY Bbln.ll3'1.I1BaeTCSI eJU'IHOBpeMeH-
Ho.e no.co.611e B p"3Mepe nSlTl1.11erHero. ne-
He}l(H()rO COllep}l(3HIU1 11 e YCTaHo.B.IIeHHo.M
33KOHo.M nopHllKe HaJHa'l.aeTC.II neHCI1.11 no.
I1HBaJ1I11lHo.CTI1('I.. 9 CT. 16)
BOJMeU1eHl1e n rll6e.lll1
B03Meu.teHl1e Yll.lep6a npl1'1.I1HeHHo.ro rl16e-
.111010, YBe4beM .111160. I1HblM rIDBpe)KJ\eHl1eM
3.!\opo.BbSi. CBSl3aHHbI},t C Y43cTl'Ie},t B npoue-
JleHl111 OPM. np0I13Bo..!\I1TC.II 113 cpellCTB o.P-
raHo.B, o.cymeCTBJlJlIOll.lIJX Opn nOpHJ\Ke,
:SI=I1/;I1CTPOB Pec-
--'"
99
flpotJo1)Kffluemafin.9
3
3aKoH Kblprbl3
CKOH Pccny6J1111111
,,06 ()nepaTI1BH()-
pOJbICKH()HneH-
R.IIbHOCT1'I»
3all()H
JIaT(lI'It1cKoii
Pecny6J1l1l1l1
,,060nepaTIIIBHoii
lIt:IITeJ1bHOCTI1»
3allo.H Pecny6J1I1-
1<1'1 MOJlllOlla,,06
onepaTI1BHO-
pOJbICIlHoti.lLeR-
-reJlbHOcrl1
3311o.H Pecny6J1I1-
1111 Ka:Uu:T3H
,,06 onep3T1fBHo.-
pOJbICIlHoti.lLeR-
TeJlbHOCTI1»

OKOII'laHUe marin. 9
1 2 J
B cJlY<Jite m6ei1lf fllflta, COTPYJ\HI1'JalOlllero 3aKOH
no 1I00-ITpaKI)' C oprmIDMIf. ocyweCTlJJlJlIO- Kblprb13cKoH
W(JlIf(J opn, H CBIIJIf C ero Y43CTlfeJI.! B npo- Pecny6J1I1K(J
BelleHI1(J OPM cellfbe nocrpa.aaBwero (J nl1- 06 ()nepaT(JBH()-
WllIf, IffiXOlllIWlfllfCH H3 ero IUI(J\IfHeHIfI1, 113 P03bICIIHOH!leH-
cpellCTB COOTeercrr.YlOlllero 61OJl)KeTa Bb]- TeJlbHOCTIf"
nJl3'IifBaeTCJI el!(JHOBpellfeHHoe n()C06He "
pa3Mepe J\ecHT1rneTHero !leHOKHOro cO.llep-
>K:lHI1J1 n()m6wero If B YCT:lH()BJIeHHOM 3<1-
1I0HOllf nopSlJ\lIe Ha3H3OJ3erCH neHCIfSi no
CJ1Y'l31O nOTep11 KopMI'IJlbU3 (OJ. 9 CT. 21)
1I0JlOHHH.KaCatOUlileCHCOlUlaJlbHO-UJl9BOBOii3aUlllTbirplOl\J\aH.CO-
HeHCTBytOU\HX OpraH911t. OC)1Jl«1BJIHtOU\HM OPD.. I1PUYCM9TpHB9tOT cJle-
.l!J"lOUlileCTaTbH3aIlOHOB.
CnITbSl 18 4IellepaJJbHuro :iaKOH9 ..06 ()nepaTIfBH()-P03b1CKHoJ:i AeSl-
TeJlbHOCTIf».
CTaTbH 13 JaKOHa YKP"IfHb] ..06 onepaTlfeHo-po3bICKHOt:! JleUenb-
HOCTW>
CraThll 17 JaKoHa Pecny6nl'lKI'I l)en3pyCb ..06 onepamBHo-po3blcKHoll
HeSlTeJlbHOCTW>
CTaTbSl 23 JaKOHit Pecny6J1I1KIf Ka:klttTaH ..06 onepaTIfHHo-
P03b1CKH()f1AeJlTeJlbHOcTIf»
CT3TbSl 21 33KOH3 Kblprbl3cKOH Pecny6J1I1KIf ..06 onepanlBHO-
p03b1CKH()f1.neJlTeJlbHOCTlI».
CTaTblf 30. 31. 32 3allOHa }19TBlfHCIIOH Pecny6J1I1KIf ..06 onepaTlfB-
HoflJ\eJlTeJlbHOCT1f».
CTaTblf 5, II 3alloH9 JTI'ITOBCKOH PecnyfuJlfKIf ..06 onepaTIfBI-JOH
.neHTt':JlbHOCTI1»
CTaTbSl 16 laKuHa PecnyfuJl1KIf MWUl()Ba ..06 onepaTIfBHo-
p03b1CIIHOH !leHTeJlbHOCTlI»

Ta6J111l.ta 10
0cti0BaJIHJIllJ111 npOBClIeHlt1l OPM. I1pe.ayclllUl)Jlflflll>x
:JaKOHOllaTenbHI>IMH aKTaMlt, pefita_11tp)1OIllIII!H OP)]
BCTpaHaxCHI"H6a:nHH
HUUJfeHOf'QHUe
f{, OCHOBGnUH np08etJeHuH OPM 3aKOfIOtXInre.JbHblX
"In QJem08.pelflGMeH-
mupVl(Jll(UX OPJI
1 2 3
I OCH08aHI1I1 D,.1R onepaTHB.. u-pa3(,I( "';»., co-
- -DBO=::j;pe::;:=: c;;::::ro q,ellepanbHb!
lleJIa(<I.lcr.7) JaKOH ..06 ()ne-
paTlJBHQ-
P03!>ICIIHOH.u e lj-
TeJlbH()CTW'
Ha.rrI1<1l'1e B036y;K;J,eHHoro yr0J10BHOrO lleJla 3alloH Pccny5J1M-
(n. I CT. 8) KI1 6eJlapycb
..06 onepaTl1BHO-
P03!>lcIlHoHlIeH-
TeJlbHOCTW'
Ha.rrI1<1m: B036y;K;J,eHHoro yr0J10BHOrO lleJla 3allOH Pecny5J1M-
(n.<ta» <I I" 10) KI1 KaJav:rnH
..06 ()nepaTMBH()-
p03!>lcKHoi1l1el'l-
TeJlbHOCTI1
Ha.rrw_me B036YJK.lleHHQro yr0J10BHoro lleJIa 3allOH Kblpr!>l3-
(n. I CT. 8) CKOH Pecny1irJMIII1
..06 ()nepaTMBH()-
pOJ!>lcKHoi1l1eH-
TeJlbHOCTI1..
HeB!>IHcHeHHble CJ6cIoHrenhCTBa no B036YJK- 3aKoH Pecny6J1I1K11
lleHHOMY yr0J10BHOMY lleJIY (n. <ta» 'I. I CT. 7) MOJl!lOl1a
..06 ()nepaTMI1H()-
p03!>ICKH()fjn,eSl-
-I :'"'. nO",""H' 'O'TI. 011. Y""HH' TeJlhHOCTM..
(]>ellepanbHbI
npoKypopa 11J111 onpelleJleHI1S1 cy.ua no yro- 3aKOH ..06onepa-
JlOBHblM lIeJlaM, HaXOllHWI1MCH B I1X npOH3- TIJBHO-po3b!CIIHOH
BOllcTBe('l.3CT7) lleSlTeJlbH()CTI1"
101

flpoiJrJnJK:el/ue ma6J/. 10
1 1 J
nOPY'leHI1.11 CJ1ellOBflTeJ1S1, Ylla3BHlUi npOKY 3aKoH Pecnyw1I1
papa 11J111 onpelle!1eHI'ISI cyIDI no yrOJlORHblM KI1 EeJlBpycb
nenaM, HaXOllSllUl1MCSI . "' npOI1JBOllCTBe «06 ()nepaTI1BHO-
(n. 3CT 8) P03bICIIH()Hnell-
TeJlbHOCTIb>
nl-lCbMeHHble nOpy'leHI111 CJ1enOIl3TeJUI H 3alloH Pecny6J1I1-
YKaJaHI'ISI npoKypopa. fI TalOKe onpene!1eHIUI KI1 K.u IXCT3H
CYJIa no yrOJl()BHbIM nC!13M. HaXOlUllUl1MCSI B «06 ()nepaTl1DHO-
npol13BollCTBe :'YrX opraHoB (a63. «B'> '1:. I p03bJCIIH0i1 ne.ll-
CT.W) TeJlbHOCTW>
nOPY'IeHI'I.II opraHfI .D03HflHI1S1. CJlellOBaTeJlS!. 3aKoH Kblprbl3-
YKa3aHI'ISI npoKypopa I1JJI1 onpene!1eHIffi cyna CKOH Pecny6J1I1KI'I
no yroJloBHblM !lenaM. HaX01lSlIllI1MCSI B I1X ,"060nepaT1fBHO-
npOI13BOllcTBe(n. 3CT 8) P03bICKH()H!le.ll-
TenbHOCTI1
Meponpl'lSlTIIJl ()nepanlBHoR neHTeJlbH()CTH 3aKoH
MOryr 6blTb npOBelleHbl B COOTBeTCTBl111 C J18TBiiCKOii
OmeJlbHblM nl1CbMeHHblM JMaHl1eM. npell- Pecny6J1I1K11
CraBJIeHHbIM npo"ypmypoti. Y4pe)KJleHI1S1MI1 «060nepaTI1BHoti
n()C)'!leoHuro paccnellOBaHl-I.II (npeliBapl-l- AeSlTeJlbH()CTH"
reJ1bHoro CJlellCTIII1S1) 11 cyne6HbIMI1 )"1pe)lt-
neHl1.11MI1 no yronoBHblM neJlaM. HaXOllSl-
IUI'IMCII B !leJlOnpOI1JBOllCTBe 3TlfX Y'lpe>Klle-
I-mi1(n.1 '1:. 2 CT. 16)
Z OCBOBaHKSI M' nOJl)"leHKII paJBeJlblBaTeJIb-
I-IOiiHI-ll!iopMawll1
Hc npenynlorpcHO <J>elleparrbHblH
33KOH «06 onepa-
THBHO-pa3b!CKH()A
J],f:S1TenbHOCT»
HeotixOlll'lMOCTb n()J])"1eHl-ISI paJBellbIBaTeJ1b- 3aKoH YKPal1Hbl
HOi1 I1H<!:>0PMBLlI1I1 B I1HTepecBx 6e30mlcHO- ...o60nepaT1fBHO-
CTH o6lUeCTBa 11 rocynapcTBa (n 3 CT. 6) pOJbICKH()W
e!lTenbHOCTIII»
HeotixOlll1MOCTb non)"1eHI1!1 paJBellblBa- 3alloH Pecny6J1I1-
TeJ1bHOii I1HI]>OpMaUl111 B I1HTepecax ()OlUe- KI1 Ka3BXCTBH
CTBB. rOcyIDIpCTBB 11 )'lIpellJleHI1J1 era 3KO- «06 ()neparI1BH()-
H()MI1'1.eCKOrO 11 060POHH()ro n()TeHLll1aJla p03blcllHOHneJl-
(a63. «ll'"'J. 1 CT. 10) TeJlbH()CTI'I"
102

1 2
I H, "",,'MO,"'"O
3 OCHOBaHHS WUI onepaTHBHO-pa3HCl\tlOro npo-
tlJ80)\CTBa
3.1. CTaBWe l1:meCTHbIMH apr-aHaM, ocy-
ruecTBJIlOml1M OF'D.. CBelleH1U1 () npl'lJHa-
Kax n()llfOTaBJlI1BaeMoro. cOBeplllacMoro HJIM
COBepweHHoro npOTlfBonpaBHoro JleSlHItSi. a
'JalOKe 0 l1HL!1'IX, ero n01lroTl1Bl1HBalOl1!l1X,
COBepUJalOllIl1X I'IJ1M COBepIllI1BWI1X. eCJIM
HeT AOCraTOLJHblX lliUJHbIX lLfUl pernCHMJI BO-
npaCB 0 BQ36YJK.lleHI111 yrQJ10BHoro .ueJlB
n. Ill. I CT. 7
HaJIw-me lIOCTaTO'1HOH l'II-Jl)xlpMaUI'IM 0;
- rOTOBSlIlIHXCH 111111 coaepllleHHblX HeycTa-
HOBJIeHHblMI1 JlHuaMH npecTyruJeHlUlx (a63. I
n. I CT 6).
- JTI1uax, rOTOBIIllIl'IX HJIM COBepWIfBWHX
_ npferVnneHHe (a53. I n. I CT. 6)
CraBWl'Ie IBBeCTHblM ()praHBM, ucymecTB-
nSlIOUUlM OPD., CBC1leHI1J1 0 nOllrOraBJIlfBae-
M()M. COBepwaeMOM Ki1lf COBeprneHHOM npo-
nlBonpaBHO1 ne.llHl1l'1. no K01OPOMY 06ma-
TeJlbH() lJ.)CCJIe1l0BaHI1 (003. 4 CT. 81
nOCT)'nl'l1'1WBSI II 0511. ocyweCTBJlJlIOWMe
OPD.. Ht«]>opMaUIfSi 0 nQlJ,fOTaBJ1I1BaeMOM,
COBeprnaeMOM mU'l COBepllleHH()M npaBOHB-
pyweHIUI (a63. 4 OJ I CT 10)
CTaBWl1e IUBeCTHblMH opraHBM. OCYllieCTB-
JlJlIOWMM opn, CBelleHIUI:
- 0 nplf3H31<aX rIO!!roTa6J1IfS3eJ.IOro. COBep-
waeMoro Ifllif coeepweHHoro npOTBO[]paB-
Hore AeSlHIf. a TalU<e () JlIfU3X. ero nOllro-
Ta6J1l18alOWI1X, coeepwalOull1x I1J1If COBep-
W(JBW(JX, eClIlf HrT L(OCT3TQ'l.HblX J\3HHbIX JlJlSI
pellleHl111 Bonpoca 0 8O:]('jyJl(J]eH(J11 yro.l1oBHO-
rOAe.l1a (n. I 'I.. I CT. 7
103
npoiJrmJlcel/uema6J/.1O
3
3aKOH Kblprbl3-
CKOf1 PecnyfuJlfKI'I
«06 ()nepaTIfBH()-
p03bICIIHOHL(eH-
Te.l1bHOcnl»
(]:IeJlepaJ1bHblii:
3aKOH ...o6onepa-
TI'IBH()-P03bICKHOM
.ueSlTeJlbHQCTIf»
3aKOH YKPalfHbl
06 onep3TIfBHO-
P03b1CKH0i1!lC.II-
TeJlbHOCTIf>'
3aKOH PecnyfuJlf
Kif EeJlapyCb
06 onep3TIfBHO-
pOJblCKHof1.ue.ll-
TeJlbH()CTIf"
3allOH Pecny6J1If-
IIIf Ka33xcT3H
...06 ()nepaTIfBHo-
P03bICKH()H.ue.ll-
Tt:JlbHQCTIf»
3aKoH KblprblJ
CKOH PecnyfuJlflll1
«06 ()nep3TIfBH()-
P03bICIIHOHL\eSl-
Te.l1bHOCT"

2
flepBI1'1H8S1 I1H4JOPM8UI1.II () nOllronlBJ1I1Bae-
MOM Ii]]" COl\epweHHOM npecryn.f1eHmJ,
TlpeC1Ym-J() AeJITeJ1bHOCTI'I HIm He3allOHHblX
D,O:rOJ\aX flpeAYCMorpeHHoe J8KOHOM one-
paTlfBHOe pacCJ1ell()B3Hlfe npe(1)'(JHb!X neS/-
Hid! npOI'l3BOl1J1TCSI: B cJlY'lae HeYCT8H()BJle-
l"U1I1 cORepWIfRWHX I1X ]1IfU, npl1 H3J1WnUI
nepBI1'IHoi1 npoBep04H()tj HH4JOPM8UI1I1 ()
npfCTYIIHOHlIeSlTeJ1bHOCTH mu!;;' (. ])
CTIlRWHe 11311eCTHbiMif opraH:!M, OCYWecTE\-
nSilOlliHM opn, CBelleH () npl'lJHal<IDt TlOMO-
TIlBI1lJBaeMoro, coaepwaeMOTO I1J1H COBepweH-
HOro npornoonpaoH()ro neSlHHH. no I':01OpONy
c6JmrenbHO TlpOll3l!OlI.CTBO npe1lBapl11el1bHOrO
CJ1ellCTDl'lSl{a63 In <<:10"'1 I CT 7
3.1. Cr8BWi1e I'IJBeCTHbIMH upnUJaM, ocy
meCTBJ1IUOIllHM OPlt, CBCJ{eHHSI 0 C06b1THSlX
rum neHcTBHSlX. C()3!JaIO!UI'IX yrpo3}' rocy-
napCTBeHHOJ:l, BoeHHoi1, 3KOHOMI1IieCKOHI1J111
;jJ;I'I; OC;cnl Pili (no11n 2
Hanwme .ItOCTII'JO<IHOti HH4JopMau11 0 pa3-
f!f:llbIMbHO-n01lpblafiOii nCSlTCJ1bHOCTI1 cneu-
CJI)0K6 I1HOL"TpaHHbIX rocynapcm, opr"HJ.\Ja-
ufi Ii OT.QeJ1bHbIX JUJU npOTlfl1 YKpaHHbl
863.5 n. I CT. 6
llocrynl1ewaSl B opraHbI, ocyrneCTB.IIAlOllil'le
OPIt, I'IH4JOpM8UHSI 0 pa3f1CllbIBaTeJ1bHO-
nOllPblBHblX 8KUllilX cneUCJIy6 i1HOCl'paH-
::o(:  :tapOJIliblX opnlli-
CTaBWl1e IUBeCTHbl}.t ()pr"HaM, ocyureCTB-
J1J1IOWHM OPIt, CBI:JJ,eHHJI 0 C06b1TJlX }]J1}]
Jlei1cTBI1J1x, C()JJIalOllU1J( yrpOJY rOCYAapCT-
BCHHOii, BoeHHOfi. 3KOHOMH<leCKoiJ
3K0J10rH'jeCKOH 6eJOn3CHOCTH (noJin. 2 n. 2
CT. 8
3_3_ CTaBWHe }]3BeCTHbIMH opraHHM, ocy-
weCTBJlJllOWI1M OPIt. CBeJleHJ.UI () J1I1WIX,
CKpblBalOWHXCH or opr"HOB JlOJHaHJI.
CJlCJlCTBI1J1 H cyna 1'IJ11'1 YKJI()HJlIOWHXCJI OT
\'rOlOBHoro HBKaJBHlUl In 3 'I. I CT. 7)
104
llpoiJrm;Jlcel/uema6J/.1O
3
3aKoHJlHToBcKofj
PecnyOJUJKH 06
OnepaTI'IBHOH
neRTeJ1bHOCTH»
3aKOH
Pecny6:II'IKI1
MOJ1J1OI1B
..06 ()nepaTI1BH()-
p03bJCIIHOii neR-
TCJlbHOCTH»
<J:IellepaJJbHblfj
3aKOH 06o[]epa-
THBH()-pOJbICKHO!1
neSlTeJ1bHOCTM»
3BKOH YKPBI'IHbJ
06 onepaTlf51i0-
pOJblCKHOrl
JIC!lTeJ1bHOCTI1»
3aKoHf'ecn)'6n1fKH
KaJaXCTaH
..06 ()nepaTI1BH()-
pOJblCKHQfi
neSlTeJ1bH()CTM"
3aKoH KblprblJ
cKoii Pecny6J1HKH
..06 ()nepaTI1BHO-
P03bJCIIHOii neR-
TeJlbH()CTM"
f1>t:.aepaJ1bHbJfi
JaKOH «060nepa-
THeHO-pOJbICKHoi1
neRTCJlbHOCTW>

llpexku.1ICel/ue ma(j/l 10
I 2 3
Harrw.me nOCT3TO'lHOA I1HI)JOpMaUl'll'l 0 nH- 3aKoH Yt<paJ'lHbl
uax, CKpblBalOll.!l1XCSI or opraHOB paccJleno- 06 onepanllJHO-
B8HI1.11, YKJ1()HSllOlUI1XCSI OT ()roblBaHlliI yro- P03bICKH()Hne.ll-
J10BHoro HBIIB3BHIf.ll (a63. 3 'I. 1 CT. 6) Te.llbHOCTI1"
CTaBWl1e 113BeCTHblMI1 ()praH8M, ()cyweCTB- 3aKoH Pecnyfum
J1.11lOlUIfM OPIt. CBel\eH(JH 0 J1I1QHX, CKpbl- Kif 6eJlap}'Cb
B81OWI'IXCSI ()T opraHOB n03H8HI1.11. CJ1ellCTBlliI ..06 ()nepaTI1BH()-
11 cyl\B IfJlIf YKJ10fi.llIOWIfXCSI OT yr0J10BHOrO P03blcKHoi1neH-
H<I.J{a.J3HIf1 (a63. 5 CT. 8) Te.llbH()CTW'
nOcryntlBUJ8S1 . OEIt. OcyWeCTBJ1.11lOlUlfe 3alloH Pecnyfum-
OPIt. (JHI)JOPMBUl1.11 0 1IIfUBX, CKpbIBaIOWIfX- Kif Kn8XCT"H
C.II OT opr8HoB n()3H8HI1.11. C.I1enCTBlliI 11 cyn8 06 OnepBTI1f1HO-
IfJ1If Yl010H.IIIOWlfXCH OT yronoflHoro HBXa38- pOJbJCKHOHne.ll-
HtlSI (003. 5 'I. I CT 10) TeJ1bHOCTW'
CT8BW(Je 1f3BeCTHbI"tIf oprBHaM, ocyweCTB- 3allOH Kblprbl3-
nJllOlUl1M OPIt, CBeneHI1.11 0 nl1uax, CKpbl- CKOH PecnyfumKI'I
B81OWI'IXCSI OT uprBHOB 1I03HBHI1S1. CJ1enCTBIfSi «060nepaTIfBHO-
If C)'m'I Iffllf yKJ10HI'lIOWrIXCSI or yrOJloBHoro P03bICIIH()f1ne.ll-
HBKBJafilfSi (no.m. 3 n. 2 CT. 8) TeJ1bHOCTIf
CTBBw(Je 1f3BeCTHblMif oprBHaM, ocyweCTB- 3aKoH Pecny5.rJlf-
JlSllOlUlfM OPIt. CBel\eHI1.11 () nl1uax, CKpbl- Kif MOJUlOB8 ..06
BalOll.!l1XCSI OT oprBHOB n03HHHIfH, CJ1TBIf.ll onepBTIfBHO-
11 cYm'l 1fJ111 YKJ10HSlIOIl.!l1XCS! OT yro.l1oBHoro P03bICKH()f1n,e.ll-
H8Xa.3BHIfSi (a63. 2 n. "b»'1.ICT.7) TeJ1bHOCTIf»
3.4. CT8uw11e 113BeCTHbiMif opraHaM, ocy- Cl>etlepa.nbHblH
IUeCTBJlSlIOWrIM OPIt, CBeneHI1.11 () nl1uax 6e3 JaKOH ..06 ()nepa-
BeCTI1 nponBBUJIfX (J 06HBpy)l(efilfif Heono- TI1BHO-P03bICKHOi1
3H8HHbiX Tpyn()B (n 4 'I I CT. 7) neSlTe.llbHOCTIf"
H8JIw.me nocT8To'J!-j()H HHI)JOpMBUl'l1f 0 (k3 3aKoH Yt<p8IfHbl
BCCTl1npOmtI1WIfXlIl1l.lax(a63.3".lcT.6) «06 onepantBHO-
P03bICIIH()Hne.ll-
Te.llbH()CTI1"
CTaBWl1e 113BeCTHblMI1 ()praH8M, ()cyweCTB- 3aKoH Pecny5.rJ11
lISllOlUlfM OPIt. CBeneHI1H 0 (k3BeCTHOM OT- KI1 6eJlap}'cb
CyTCTBrIl1 rpaJK1l8H 11 06H8py)l(eH1111 Heono- ..06 ()nepaTI1BH()-
3H8HHbiX TpynOR (003. (, CT. 8) P03bICKHOi1
neSlTeJ1bH()CTH"
105

llpoiJon;JKel/uema6J/.1O
I 2 3
nOCT)'nl1(1W3S1 , OEll, OCYWtCTBJ111IOWl1t 3aKoH Pecny6}111-
OPLt. I1HlJlopMaUI1S1 0 6e3BeCTHOM 0TCy1CT- KI1K.UIXCT"H
'"" rpa)l(JlaH 11 06tmPYJKtH(J11 Heon03HaH- 06 onepaTI1BHO-
HblX Tpyn()B (003. 6 'I. I CT 10) P03bICIIH()HJ\e.ll-
TeJ1bHOCTI1
CraBWw IBBeCTHbI"UI opraHBM, OCYWCTB- 3aKOH KblprblJ-
J1S1lOlUI'IM OPll, CBelIeH(J.II () 6e3BeCTHOM ()T- CKOH Pecny5.rJI1KI'I
CyTCTBl111 rpa)l()],3.H 11 06HapyJKeHl1l1 Heono- «060nepar11BHO-
JHaHHblX Tpyn()B (n()lIn 4 n 2 CT. 8) P03bICIIH()HJ\eSl-
TeJ1bHOCTI1»
CTaBW(Je 113BeCTHblMI1 opraHaM, ocyweCTB- 3aKOH Pecny6J11'1K11
nSlIOWI'IM OPll. CBelICHI'ISI 0 6e3 BeCTH npo- M()J]lI()Ba
naBWI1X 11 o6HapYJKeHI111 HeonU3H3HHblX «06 oneparl1BHo-
1pYnoEl (a6J. I n b» CJ 7) p03b1CKHOH J\II-
- TeJ1bH()CTI'I"
3.5. 3anpocbI IlPyrl1X opraHoB, ocylUeCTB- Cl>etleparlbHblH
J1J1IOWI1X OPll. no OCHOBaH(JJlM, YKaJaHHblM 3aKOH ..06 onepa-
BHacToSiweH CTaTbe('l 4 CT. 7) TI'IBH()-P03bICKHOH
}],fnTeJ1bHOCTI1»
3anpOCb1 Jlpymx opraHOB. OC)'U.IeCTBJ1nlO- 3aKOH KblprblJ-
lUl'IX OPD., no ()CHOBaHI1S!M. Ylla3aHHb1M B CKOH Pecny5.rJI1KI'I
HaCToHweHCTarbf(n.4cT.8) 06 onepanllJHo-
P03bICIIH()HJ\e.ll-
TeJ1bHOCTI1»
Meponpl1l1TJI onepaTBHoj{ JleSlTeJ1bHOCTI1 3aKOHJ1BTBI1H-
MO,," 6.m npoBelleHbI (I COOTBeTCTEI1'I C CKOH Pecny5.rJI1KI'I
nl'lCbMeHHblMI1 3<1.IIBJleHI1HMI'I npyrIl'I: Cy6beKfOEl ..06onepanlBHoH
onepa11lBHOH }],fSlTt:}1bHocm (n 2 'I 2 CT. 16) ,DeSlTeJ1bHOCTI1»
3.6. 3anpocbl MeJK11YH3pOIlHblX npaeooxpa $enepanbHblH
HI1TeJ1bHblX OpraHI13aUl1H " npaBOOXpaHI1- 3aKOH ..06 onepa-
TeJlbHbIX OpraH()B I1H()CTpaHHblx rocynapcTB TI'IBH()-P03bICKHOH
B COOTIJeR:ml1l1 C MeAULyffi3.pOilHbIMI1 Iloro- .nenTeJ1bHOCTI1
BOOOMI'I POCCI'IHCKOH tDelIepaUl'I11 {'l. 6 CT 7
3anpocbl MeJK11YHapolIHblX npaBooxpaHI1 3aKoH Pecny5.rJl1-
TeJ1bHblX OpTaHOB I1HOCTpaHHblx rocynapCTB KI1 6e.apycb
BCOO"IBeTCTBI1I'1 C JlOrOBOpaMI'I (c()mawe- ..06 ()nepaTI1BHO-
HI1S1MI1) 0 npaBOBoH nOM()lUl1 (n. 4 CT. 8) P03bJCIIHOHneH-
TeJ1bHOCTI'I»
106

3anpOCbl Me)l(1!yHapOllHblX npaBOO>.pJHHTeJlb-
HblX OpraHH3aUHH H npaEOO>,paHHTCJlbHb!X
opraHOB HHocrpaHHblX rOCYl!apCTB B COOTBeT-
CTBHH C l!OroIlOpdMH (COr.naWeHHJIMH) 0 npa-
BOBOtI: nOMOlli (363. «r» 'I. I CT. 10)
3'lIJiX]CbI Me)l(J],)'H8pQJ\HbIX njYlBOO'(Ji3.HHTeJlb-
HblX opraHI1JJ.LlI1f1 H npaBOO.'«JaHHTeJlbHb!X
OpraHOB I1HOCTpaHHblX rocyn.apCTB B COOTBeT-
CTBHI1 C l!OroBOp3r.tH (cOrJIall/et'lHSlMI1) 0 npa-
BOooii nOMOIllH, pam$('jupoB3HHblMH Kblp-
rblJCIIOH Pecny6.rIHKOH (n. 6 CT. 8)
MepO[]PHJlTH onepaTBHOH ,DeSlTeJlbHOCTH
MOryr 6bm, npOl1etleHbI 11 COOTBerCTBHH C
3aJll1J1eHI1S1MI1 HJlH llorOBopeHHOCTblO MeJK-
lIYHapOllHb!X H J.apyf3eJKHbIX npaBooxpaHH-
TCJ1bHblX Y4pe)!(l]eHHH M Y<ipe)l(lJeHHH rocy-
napCTBeHHoJ:! 6e30naCHOCTI1 11 06op()Hbl
(n 3.. 2CT 16)
3.7. llocT3H0l1J1eHHe 0 npHMeHeHMM Mep
6e30nacHocTH B OTH()WeHHH 3alUI1IUaeMb1X
nl1U, ()cyweCTBJ1JIeMb1X ynOJlH()M()'leHHbIMH
HH TO rOCYl!apCTBeHHbI"tH opraHHMM B no-
pH1llle. npellyCMOTpeHHOM 3aKOHOll3.TeJIbCT-
BOM POCCHJ:!CKOJ:! <lJellepaUI'IH ('I. 5 CT. 7)
IlOCT!lHOl1JleHHe 0 npHMeHeHI1H Mep 6e3-
onaCHOCTH B OTHOlUeHl111 3allUilUaeMbIX nl1U,
<X."}'lUe\."TBJIJleMblX ynOJ1HOMO'leHHbIMH Ha TO
rocyn.apCTBCHHbIMI1 OpraH3..\1H B nOpfUlKe,
npellYCMOTpeHHOM 3aKOHOllaTenbCTBOM (n 5
CT. 8)
4 OCIlOBaHI1I1 llJISi onepaTIIBHoH l1poBepKH onpe-
U!JleHHOHK3Tft"OIIIDII]JIDII.!J.aI1(CI1XCOrJlB-
- ;! OpraHbl, OcyuICCllIJIJlfOWHe OPIt. B npe-
j],CJJ8X CIIOHX nOJ1HOMO<iHti BnpaBe TalOKe
C06l1paTb llaHHble, Heo6xOlll1Mble llJISI npH-
HSlTJ.1JI pelUcHHSI () l!()nycKe II CBel!CHHSlM.
COCTal1J1J1IOUUlM rOCYllapCTBeHHYIO TIlHHY
(a63. II CT. 7)
107
llpoiJrm;Jlcel/uema6J/.1O
3
3aKoH Pecny6.rIH
1111 KnaxcTaH
«06 onepaTHBHO-
P03bJCKHOiilleH-
TeJlbH()CTHD
33KOH Kblpl"bl3-
CKOf1 Pecny6.rJI1KI'I
«06 ()nep:rrI1BH()-
P03bICIIHOHl!eJI-
TeJ1bHOCTH
3aKOH
J1arBiicKof1
Pecny6.rJHIII1
«06onepaTHBH()H
,DeSlTeJlbHOCTHD
(]Jen,epMbHblii
3<1KOH ..06 onepa-
TI'IBH()-P03bICKH()H
neHTeJ1bHOCTHD
3allOH Kblprbl3-
CKOti Pecny6.rJHKH
..06 ()nepaTI1BHO-
P03bICIIH()Hl!eH-
TeJ1bHOCTHD
(]Jen,epMbHblfi
33.KOH «06 onepa-
Tl'leHO-p03bICKHOn
l!eSlTeJlbHOCTH"

3anpOCbl nOJlHOM04HblX rOCYJJ£IPeTBHHblX
OpraH()B, Y'lpe;KJIeHI1i1 11 OpraHI13aUldt 0
npOBepKe nl1U B CB>l311 C I1X nonyeKoM
rocy.uapcrBeHH()H, BOCHHOH H CJJy;;<c1)HOH
T,uiHe in. 2CT.6
OpraHbl, OCYUJeCTRJll1lOlUfle OPlt, B npf:l\,C1IiIX
CBOflX nOJlHOMO'lHH BnpaBe TIllCKe cuf3Iq:Iml.
naHHble, x"pa"-repll3}wUJe 1111</HOCTb rpa;;<-
lIaH, Heo6xorulMble lL'ISi npl1HJlTflSI peWeHI1S1 ()
lI()nYCKe K CBeneHI1S1M, COCTaB!1J1IOUJflM rocy-
1lHHI-IVICITai1,"",a6311CT.8
OpraHbI, ()cyweCTBJIJlIOWl1e OPlt, B npelle
118X CBQeH KOMneTeHL!1111 no co6CTBeHHOH
I1HI1UI18TI1Bt 111160 I1lJI1Ul1aTl1Be HHblX rocy-
llHpCTeeHHbIX opraHOB BnpaBe TaKJ!(e c061'1-
paTio JlaI-IHb1C, xapallTtpl13}1JOWI'IC 1111</HOCTb,
Hc()6xolll1Mble DJUI npHl--1J1TI'IJI peWeHHJI ()
JlonYCKe K CBI:J],eHI1HM, COCTBBJlHIOll.[I1M ro-
cyn.apCTBeHHYJO TaHHY, nepe'IeHb KOTopblX
onpj{eJUreTCH Ka6l1treTOM MI1H!1CTpOB Pee-
nv6nHIII1 KaJaXCTaH (a63. 4 n 2 CT !O)
OpraHbl. OCYUJeCTBJlJllOlUl1e OPlt, B npelleJl8X
CBOIJX n011HOM04IJii BnpaB TIlK)I(e cooopaTb
llHHHble. Heo6xumt"tb!e DJlJI npliHIITI1J1 pewe-
HIJH 0 1I0nYCK K cee.aeHI1I'1M, COCTIlHIISIlOll.[flM
rocy.uapCTBeHHyJO TaHHY, HJlI1 K pa6oTaM,
ceSl3aHHbiM C )KcnJly.rraUlieil 061>eKTOB,
npellCTaBJIJlIOWIiX nOflblWCHHYJO onaCHOCTb
DJlJI )l(IUHI1 H 31lopOBbJi nlOlleil, a TalCKe DJI}1
QKnv"A(dH)ll.[eH C""hI fa63. 2 n. I CT 8
OpraH. ocyweCTDJlJlIOll.[I1H OPlt. B npelleJl8X
cBoef1 KOMneTeHL!fll1 Bnp"Be Co6Hpan. Ht'o6-
XOlll1Mble lIalUJble. XapaKTepl'l3YJOWI1e 1111</-
HOCTb nOll03peBaeMbIX, () lI()nYCKe II CBellC-
HI1I1"t, COCTaBJUllOW"t rOCYMpcTBeHHYJO
Taf1Hv In «8<> 'I. 3 CT. 7)
4.2. OpraHbl, ocyweCTBJllllOlIIl1e OPLl, e npe-
lleJI8X CBOI1X nOJlH()MO'lI1H BnpaBC TBlOKe
c06l1paTb lIaHHble, Heo6xOlll1Mbie DJlJI npH-
HIJTfllI peweHl11J 0 1I0nYCile K pa60TBM, CflSI-
3aHHbIM C :}KCnJ1yaTaUl1eH 061>eKToD. npen-
CTBB!1I1IOWI1X nOBblweHHYIO onaCHOCTb DJlII
:;ell!::"{. c_TlOKe DJlSI ()K-
108
llpcXJo'l.1/Cf!l/uemafJ/I.lO
3
3aKOH YKPal1HbI
..06 ()nepaTI1BH()-
p03bICKH0i1
lIeIlTCJ1bHOCTW>
3BKOH Pecny6JII1-
KI1 6eJIapycb
«060nepaT11BHO-
P03bICIIH()HlIell-
TeJlbHOCTI1
3aKOH Pecny6.rm-
1111 KaJ'lu:TIlH
..06 ()nepaTI1f1HO-
pOJbJCKHof1.ne.ll-
TeJlbHOCTW>
3aKOH Kblprbl3
CKOH Pecny6.rJI1KIJ
..06 ()nepaTI1BH()-
P03bJCIIHOHl\CH-
TeJlbH()CTW>
3allOH Pecny6JII1-
KI1 MOJJ1lOBa..06
()nepaTBHo-
P03bJCKH()f1l1e.ll-
TeJIbHOCTI1»
cJ>enepanbHblf1
38KOH «06 onepa-
Tl'leHO-pOJbICKHOn
lIeIlTeJlbHOCTI1"

2
o llonYCK!: K pa6QTaM, CtHl3aHHb!M C ::IIIC-
n.rryaTHUHeij 06'b0::1ITOII npeJlCT3BJ111IOLUI'IX
nOBblWCHHYIO 3K0J10rl'l'leCKYJO ()naCH()CTb
(a63 )1 CT. 8)
OpraHbI. ()CYllieCTBJllllOLUl1e OPlt. II npelle
nax cBoel1 KOMneTeHUHI'I no c06CTBeHHo!1
I1HHUIffiTl1ee J11160 HHI1LlHantee I'IHblX rocy-
napCTBeHHbIX opraHOB BnpaBe TaKJKe co611-
paTio J:(aHHble, xapaKTepl13YlOIlUJe 1111'1HOCTb,
He()\'ixOllHMble j]JUI npHHJlTlUI peweHIUI 0
lIOnYCKe 11)111 K pa6QTaM, CBII311HHblM C 3KC-
ruJyaTlIUl1etj 06'beI<TOB, npellCTlIWUlIOWI'IX
nOBblWCHHYIO 8f1apl'lftHyJO 11 3KOJlorl:l'JeCKYIO
onaCHOCTb a63 4 n 2 CT. 10)
OpraHbl. ocyweCTBJ111lOlUl'le GPIt, II npeneJJll't
CBOI.JX nOJlH()MO'ml1 BnpaBe TIU0Ke cu6I1paTh
naHHble, HeU6\QWUlble DJ1" npHH"TI1J1 perne-
H!HI 0 110nVCKe K CBeJ1eHmlM, COCTaBJIJI.IOUlHM
rocy.r:mpCTB-eHHYIO -raI1HY, 111UJ II pa6cmJ., CBH-
3aHHbIM C :JKcnllYdT.nmeti ofueKToB, npej{-
C1'31i11S1}()ll!IJX nOBblweHHYIO onacHOCTb JlJlSI
}IU13HH 11 :yropoBbJI J11O.Qei1, a TaKJKe DJ111 OK-
rJlmlOwei1 C':"'rTH 1003. 2 n I CT 8
OpraH. OCYWCCTMJlIOWI'IH GPIt. B npellenax
CDoeW KOMneTeHUl'l11 DnpaBe C0611paTb He06-
XOll1'1Mb]e naHHb!e, xapaKTepl:l3YIOlUI1e JlI1'1-
HOCTb []()llUJpeBaeMbIX () .fi()nYCKe K pa60T3M.
(SI';:'; c:'KJ10rl1'1eCKYIO ()nac-
4.3. OpraHbl. ocyweCTBJUllOlUl'le OPLl, II npe
J\eJ1iiX CBOI'IX nO.HOM04I'1ti Brrpal1e TalOKe co-
61'1paTb JUlHHble He06xOill'lMble l1J1S1 npl'lHJ1TI1S1
pelUeHI'ISI 0 J\Onyclle K }"Jacr1O B OPll WlI'I 0
J\OI1YClle K M3Tepl'laJ1aM, nO!1}"JeHHbrM 11 pe-
'JIbTIlTeeeocvuiecrRocHI'ISI a63. I3cr 7
OpraHbI, ocyweCTIIJ1S1IOWl'le OPlt. II npelle-
nax CIIOI'IX n()J1HOMO'iI'lH Bnp(lBe T(llOKe co-
61'1paTb JUlHHbre, xapailTepl'l3}l101Ul'le nl1'i-
H()CTb flXUIUl3H, He06xOlll1).tble WI.II npl1HSI-
TI1SI peWeHI1JI 0 nonycKe K Y'IacTI'lIO B OPlt
ru1l1 nocTyne K MitTpi1aJ1aM, n0!1Y4eHHblM Ii
pe3YlIhTaTe ee ocyweCTBJIeHI1S1. ltaHHoe no-
1I0)KeHl1e pacnpOCT]JaHJleTCSI till cy}],(:ti. cJle-
J\OBaTeJleii 11 nOOKvOODOB 363. 12 CT. 8
109
llpoiJoJlJK:el/uema6J/.1O
3
3aKol1 Pecny6}1I1-
KI'I6eJlapych
«06 ()nCpaTI1DHO-
P03bICIIH()Hne.ll-
Te}lbH()CTl'ln
3aKoH Pecny5.rm-
KI1 K.:uaxcTaH
..06 onepanmHo-
p03bJCIIHOii .nJI-
TeJ1bHOCTI1
3aKOH KbrprblJ
CKOf1 Pecny6J1I1KI'I
..06 ()nepaTI1BHO-
pOJbJCKHotineJl-
TeJ1bHOCTI1
3aKOH Pccr.)f3"'iii'iKH
M()!1ll()Ba
06()nepaTI1BH()-
P03bJCKH0f1.ne.ll-
TeJ1bH()CTI1"
$e.nepaJ1bHblf1
38KoH..o6onepa-
TIJBHO-P03bJCKH()ti
JJ,eJlTeJ1bHOCTI1"
3allOH Pcny6J1I'1-
1I1'I6eJlapycb
06()nepaTI1BHO-
P03bICIIH()Hne.ll-
TeJ1bHOCTI1

2
OpraHbI. ()cyureCTBJISllOWl1e opn. B npelle
nax CBOCH KOMnCTCHUl'I1'I no co6cTBeHHoH
I'IHI1Lll1aTI1BC 111'160 IfHI1Lll13TI1BC I'IHblX rocy-
J\3.pcTBeHHblx opraHoB I1npal1e T3KJKe c0611-
paTio nmmbJe, xapallTepmYJOume J111'1HOCTb,
Heo5xo!ll1Mbre DJ1S1 npl'lHRTI'IJI pellleHI'IH 0
JlonYCKe K Y'18CTI1IO II opn 111UJ 0 JlOCTyne K
MaTepHaJ1aM, n0J1Y4eHHblM 11 pe3Yl1bTare ee
OCvweCTBJ1eHI'IJI 863. 5 n. 2 CT njl
OpraHbI, ocyweCTBJ1IUOWl1e QrIt, 13 npelle!18X
CBOIJX n0J1HOM04I'1ii BnpaBe Tall)l(e CQoopaTb
naHHbJe, I-re06xo.nm,tb!e DJ11 npHH.!ITI1JI pellle-
HI'IJI () ll()nYCKe K Y'JaCTI'IIO B opn I1J1I'1 0 11()-
:;eK =:;:::H:'! tJY]lb-
OpraH, ocyweCTBJHllOlUl1f1 Opn, B npelleJIaX
CBoeM KOMnneHUl'I1'I DnpaBe C061'1pm'b He06-
:XOlll'IMble llaHHbre, xapailTeplll3YlOWl'le 1""1-
HOCTb nOl103pemleMblx 0 J!onycKe K Y4acTIJ1O
B GPn H.f1l1 0 1l0nYCKe K MaTepl'laJ1aM, nOJlY-
'IeHHb!M B XOlie ee ()cyweCTBJ1eHJ.UI (naHHoe
;:;B p.npTSI;;C;) H8 CYlldl 1'1
4.4. OpraHbl. ocyweCTBJ1J1IOWl'le OPn.. B
npene!1flX CDOI1X []()J]HOMOL1I'IH BIlpalJe uua<e
c06l1paTb lIaHHble, He()l)xOlllfMble JJJUI npl'l-
HJlTI1J1 peIlleHI1J1 06 YCTflHOlJJleHl111 l'IJlI'I no.fi-
nep)KaHI1I1 C nI1U()M OTH()WeHI1t1 COl]JYllHI1-
ea a64 ;lI;;rroBKe 11 npOBeLIeH1'I1'I
OpraJ-Jbl, ()cyweCTB!1S1IOWWe OPlt, II npenen:.uc
CBOI.JX OOJlHOMO'lHtI BnpaBe "faK)Ke c05wpaTb
naHHblt, xapal<"fepW3YlOwwe J11'1'iHOCTb rpa)K-
J\aH, ..re06XO.nI'lMblt J]J1S1 npI1HSlTS1 peweHl'lti 11
CIJJI3I'1 C OI<2lHHlJeM IV1I'1 cUJ\etiCTI1eM B 0011-
rOTOBKe 11 nnOBeileHl'I1'I OF'M (003. 13 CT. 8
OpraHbI. ocyweCTB.-unOWl'lt OPlt, B npell
11ax CBOI'IX n011HOt04I'1ti BnpaBC TaK)KC co-
611paTb naHHble, He06x().fiI'lMble IV1J1 npl1HSI-
TI'ISI peWeHI'IJI 05 YCTaHoBJIeHl11'1 1'1111'1 no.fi-
J\ep)l(BHI'II'I C 11I1UOM OTHoweHlfti COTpyJ\HIf-
npl'l no.nrOTOBKe 1'1 npOBe.neHIfIf
OPM OOJ. 2 n. 3 CT. 8
110
llpoiJoJlJK:el/uema6J/.1O
3
3aKoH Pecnyfum
1111 KnaxcTaH
06 ()nepaTIfBHO-
P03bICIlHOtil\CH-
TeJlbH()CTW,
JaKOH KblprblJ-
CKOti Pecny6.rJIfKIf
..06 onepantBHO-
pOJbICIIH()H.fie.ll-
TeJ1bHOCTIf>'
3aKOH Pecny6J1I1KH
M()Jlll()Ba
06 OnepaTl'lflHO-
P03bICIlHOtil\CH-
TeJlbH()CTI1»
(tIenepanbHbli1
3aKOH «050nepa-
TBHO-P03b/CKHOti
ne.llTeJlbHOCTW>
3aKOH Pecny6.rJl1-
Kl'I6e;Japycb
06 OnepaTI1f1HO-
p03bJCIIHOti neH-
TeJlbHOCTIf
JaKOH Kblprbl3-
CKOti Pecny6.rJIfKI1
..06 ()nepaTI1BHO-
P03bICIIH()HneSl-
TeJ1bHOCTIf»

-
2
OpraH. OCYWCCTB/1J1IOWHH OPIt. (I npCllax
cfloefi IIOJ.mCTeHUIU'I BnpaBC co6!1pan He06-
XO!ll'lMble nalU-1bre. xapaI<TCpI'l3YIOWI'IC )]"''1-
HOCTb nOll03peBaetb!X. ()O 0ll:l33HI'II1 !1J11'1
coneflcTBl'I11 B OpraHI13aUl111 H npOBcneHHH
aPM (n. «C»'I.3CT. 7\.
4.5. OpraHbl. ocy!UeCTBJ1IIOWl'le OPIt. e
npellenax CBOI1X nOJlHOM0411H BnpaBC TIllOKe
c06HpaTb .naHHble, Hco6xOllHMbie WIJI npH-
HJlTHJI peWCHHJI 0 BbIJ{a..e pa3pCWCHHH Ha
:::b KTIB.;."!, Ii QXpaHH}'1O lICH-
OpraHbI. ocymcCTBJIIUOIlIHe OPIt. B npCll,f:-
Jlax CBOHX nOJ1HOM04MH Bnpaec TaK)KC co-
6!1paTb HaHHble, xapailTeplf3}lJOume Jll1'i-
H()CTb rpa)l(1!3H, Hc06xo.rUJMb1C WI.II npl1HSI-
Tl'lSI pemeHHt1 0 Bbtaa'le pa3pemeH!1ti Ha
::b TIBi Ii ()XpaHH}l1O neJi-
OpraHbI. ocyweCTBJ1S1lOlUl1e GPIt, B npellCJl2X
ceoei1 KOMneTeHUl111 no c06CTBeHHOH I'Il-jI1-
[.!H3T11BCnI160 HHHL!mff}]BC HHblX rOC}'.ll<1pcT-
(lCHHbIX opraHOB BnpaBC T3K)KC cooopaTb
naHHblC, xapa1lTCp1'l3YIOWI'IC nWIHOCTb, Hc06-
XO!ll'lMblC lJ)1JI npI'lHJiTlf11 pemCHI'I£'I 0 Bbl1la<le
I1:eSleb:3KT21'1. H
OpraHbI. ocyweCTBJIJlIOWl1e opn. B npelle
nax CBOIfX nOJIH()M()'mM BnpaBe TaJOKe co-
611paTb naHHbJe, HeoOXOJIJ;IMLle DJlSI npl'lHSlTI'I.II
perneHI1.11 0 BbUia'le pa3perneHidi Ha 'laCTHYIO
lleTeKTIJBHYIO oxpaHH)'IO lleJlTeJ1bHOCTb
a63. 2 n SCT 81
OpraH, ocyrneCTlIJ1S1I0111I'lM Opn, B npellfn8X
CBoeM KOMneTeHLll'I1'I BnpaBe c06l1paTb He-
06XOlll1MbJe lI3HHble 0 I1bllla'le p!13peweHI1M
:n:n lle:TB; ; oxpaHHYIO Jielj-
4.6. OprBHbl. oCYlLleCTBJ11IIOllll'le opn. B
npelleJ1BX CBOI1X n()J]HOMO'II'IH BnpaBe TBlCKe
c06l'1pBTb lJ,aHHLle, He()6xolll1Mble DJ1S1 npl'l-
HSlT.II peWeHI.JSI () npl1eMe HB c.y.ri'iy B op-
raHLI, OCYllleCTBJlSlJOllll1e opn. naHHOe no-
:eJ1':H er:3.  cC:'ll:.
111
llpoiJoJlJK:el/uema6J/.1O
3
3aKOHPecTl}fi.rnfKJl
M()J]ll()BB
..06 ()nCpaTI'IBH()-
p03blclIHOHne.ll-
TeJ1bH()CTI'I"
$e.aepanbHblH
a"KOH «06 onepa-
TI!HO-p03b1CKH0t1
JleJlTeJ1bHOCTI1»
3aKOH Pecny6.rJl1-
KI1 6enapycb
..06 ()nepaTI1BHO-
P03bICIIH()t1 llC.II-
TeJ1bH()CTI1"
3aKOH Pecny6J1I'1K11
Ka:nxCT1tH
«06 onepaTl1BHO-
P03blcKHoi1neH-
TenbHOCTH"
3allOH K1.lprblJ
CKOt1 Pecny6.rJI1KH
..06 ()nepaTI1BH()-
P03b1CKH()t1ne.ll-
-reJ1bHOCTI1
3'1M:11-i Pecny6J1I1KH
MonJJOI18
06 onepaTI1BHO-
P03bICKHoHn e H-
TCJ1bHOCTI'I
3aKOH Pecny6.rJl'I-
KH 6enapycb
..06 ()nepaTI1BH()-
P03b1CKHot1ne.ll-
TeJ1bHOCTI1"

OKOH'ful/ue ma6J/. 10
I 2 3
OpraHbI, OCYWCT6JlIJ}Qwe OPlt, EI TlpJle- 3aKOH1
nax cBoeil KOMTleTBHUl'l11 no c06cTBeHHoil Ka:HxcT1m
I'IHI'IUl'laTI1B ]11160 I1HI1UI1aTI1B I1HblX rocy- 06 onepaTI1BHO-
napcTBeHHbIx opraHoB Bnp"Be Tal0Ke c061'1- pOJbJCKH()f111e.ll-
paTio llaHHble, xapaKTepl'l3}llOume ]11'1'lHOCTb, TeJlbHOCTW'
He06xoJll1Mbie M" npl1HSlT1111 peweHl'liI 0
npeMe Ha pa60ry 1'1 CJ1YJl::6y B OBlI:, Ha-
UOHaJlbHOil 6e30naCHOCTI1, BoeHHOH paJ-
BeJlKl'I, HaJ1()rOBOW CJ1YJl::6bl, CJlYJl::6y oxpaHbl
Ilpe:nmeH£a Pcny6JII'IIII1 Ka3aXCTaH (a63. 2
n.2cT 10)
He npellYcMOTpeHo 3al(OH KblprblJ-
CKOW Pecny6.rJI1KI:I
«060nepaTI1BHO-
pOJbICIIH()f1 ne.ll-
TeJlbHOCTI1»
4.2. OpraHbl, 0CYIUCCTBJl1IIOWI'IC OP1\, . $e.aepanbHblH
npeJleJlax CHOI'IX nOJIHOM0411i1 Impal!e TalOKe JaKOH ..06 onepa-
c06l'1paTb lJ,aHHble, He()6xolll1Mble ru]lj np- TI1BH()-P03bICKH()M
H1ITI111 peWeHI111 no 06eCne'leHI1IO 6e30nac- neHTJ1bHOCTI1»
HOCTH OpraH()B, 0CYIUeCTM1IIOWI'IX OP1\
(863.15 CT. 7)
OpraHbI. ocywecTBJllJlOwl1e OPlt. B npeJle- 3aKoH Pecny6!U'IKH
no, ceoeti KOMneTeHLll111 no co6cTBeHHOti Ka3BXCTdH
I1HI'IUI.JaTI'IBe 111'160 I1HI'IUl.JaTl1Be I'IHblX rocy- ..06 ()nepaTI1BH()-
Jl3.pCTl!eHHbIX opraHoB I!npHl!e THKJKe co61'1- pOJbJCIIHotiJleH-
paTio Jl3.HHbJe. xapaKTepl:lJYlOwl'le 1I11'IHOCTb TeJlbH()CTW'
rpaJKJlaH, He06XOJ:an.lb1e lUIH npI1HHT1I pe-
WeHI1f1 n() ()6eCne'leHI1IO 6eJOnaCHOCTH ()P-
raHOB, OCYIl.lt:CTBJl1IIOWJ.IX OPlt (a63. 3 n. 2
CT. 10)
OpraHbI. OCYWCT6JlI1}QllIl'le OPlt. B np{:Jle- 3aKOH KblprblJ-
nax CBom n()J]HOMO'II'IH BnpaBe TalOKe C()- CKOf1 Pecny6.rJI1KI:I
6111paTb naHHble. He06Jo.(1Z1I1Mble lUIH npl'lHIJ- 06 onepaTI'IElHO-
TI'IIJ pellleHl'I1J n() 06ecne'leHI1IO 6e30nacHo- pOJbICIIH()f1Jle.ll-
CTI1 opraHOB (llO!UKHOCTHblX lU'1u), OCYIl.lt:CT- TeJlbHOCTI1»
B.IJOWUX OPD (863. 15 CT. 7)
112

OcHOB31111H WlH IIJI0BeJJ,eIlIlH OPM npelJ,YCMOTpellbi CJleJJ,yIOJllIIMH
cr3TMIMH33KOHOB,
CT3TbH 7, 10 Q)epa;rbHoro 33KOH3 ..06 onep3TIIIBHO-p03bICKHOfi
ne.llTeJ1bHOCTI'I».
CTaTbH 6, 9 33110H3 YKpaHHbl ..06 onepaTHBHO-p03bICKHOfi neSj-
TeJ1bHOCTH».
CraThI'l 8, 10 3aKoHa Pecny6!1HKI'I 6eJJ3Pycb ..06 ()nepanIBHo-p03bICK-
Hofine.llTeJ1bHOCTI1».
CTaTbl1 II, 16 3aKoHa PecnyfuJl1KI'I Ka3a1C:Cf3H ..06 OnepaTI'IBHO-
p03b1CIIHOH DeIlTeJlbHOCTW>
CTaTbH 8 3aKOHa Kblprbl3CKOn Pecny5.rJI1KI1 ..06 OnepaTI'IBHO-
p03blCIIH()fj ne.llTeJ1bHocn:!»
CTa'TbI'l 16, 23 JaKoHB J1arBl1iiCKOI1 Pecny5.rJI1KI'I «06 onepanlBHoH
Ae.llTeJ1bHOCTI'I»
CT3TbSl 3 JBKOHB J1HTOBCKOH: Pecny6J1HKH ..06 onepan:!BHoii neSl-
Te.llbH()CTI'I»
CraTbl17, 9 JaKOHa Pecny6JJI1I1H MOJtilOBa ..060nepaTIIIBHO-po3bICKHOii
ne.llTeJ1bHOCTI'I».

Ta6J1HWI I)
OCHOBaHHHDJ1l1npeRpIW,IfIIHHOPM,nx
:JaKOHO.mrreJlbHblMH 8KTaMH, pefit8ft1ft1l11J1Y101H OPJI
BCTpaHaxCHl'u6a.nHH
HOILl,leH06QHUe
M UcH/MOHWI imH npeKpaeHUH UPM JDlo.OI!tJdumeJlbHblX
"In OKm06. Jlf'llOveH-
mumlfOIJ./UX OPP.
I 2 3
I .l{eJ1() OnepaTI'IBHOrO Y'JeTa npellpawaercSi B lJ>ellepaJIbHblH
CJ1Y'laSix peweHHH KOHJqJerHblX 3aJIa'l OPJI. 3aKoH«06()nepa-
npellYCMOTpeHHblX CT. 2 HElCTOSll1!ero lJ>elle- TI1BHO-po3bICKHOH
pa11bHoro JallOHa (a6J. 4 CT. 10) .ueSlTeJ1bHOCTW'
Oncpan1lJHaSi npOBeplla npellpawar:TCH . 3aKOH PecrIyD!1HIII'I
CJ1Y'JaSix peWeHI'ISI KOHKpeTHblX 3M3'1 OPJI. Eie!1apyCb
npellYCMUTpeHHblX CT. 3 HaCTO.llwero 3aKoHEI «06onepanJBHO-
(CT. 10) p03blCKHOH llell-
Te.bHOCT"'"
OPM npeKpawalQTCSI npi1 B!>IIlOJ1HeHI1H Ja- 3aKOHPtxny6J]i1I1H
.ua'l. 1IJ1H pCUlCHI'IH KOTopblX I'IX npODC1IeHI1e Ka3axcTaH
6101110 npe1lyc),10TpeHo (a63. 2 CT 16' «06 onepanlBHo-
P03blcKHOiille.ll-
Te.bHOCTI{"
OPM npeKpal1!mOTCI1 npH B!>lnOJ1HeHHH Ja- 3aKOH Kblprbl3-
.ua'l, 1IJ111 pcweHI'IH KOTOpblX I'IX npOBC1ICHI1e CKOH PccnyG!1I1KI'I
6101110 npe1lycMorpeHo (a63. ) 'I. I CT. II) «06onepanIBHo-
p03blCKHOH lleSl-
TCJ1bHOCTW>
JIcna no onepaTBHOMY )"leT)' (.aeJ18 no one- 33110HJ]aTBIIIH-
paTi1BHbIM npoBepKaM 1'1 OnepaTI'IBHblM pa3- CKOH PecnyG!1I1KI'I
pa60TK3)'1) npellpawalOTcSI. eC!11'1 BbmOJ1He- «06 ()nepaTI'IDH()H
HbI n.pyre 3aJIa'll'l OnepaTI'IBHOH lleSlTe.llbHO- lleHTenbHOCTI'I»
cn'! (n. 3 'I. 4 CT. 23)
Onl':pan1BHbil': neilcTBHH npet<pawalOTCH npl'l 3aKOHJ]I'ITOElCKOH
paCllpblTl'I1'I npecrynJ1CHI'IH (a63. S CT. 3) PecnyGJ11'11111
«06 ()nepaTI'IDH()H
llellTeJIbHOCJl.I»
OnepaTI1I!H811 npoBepKa npeKpaJJ.J,BeTCSI . 3aKoH Pe<:nyD!1I1KI'I
CJ1¥'JaSix peweHHH KOHKpeTHblx JaJla'l OPJI, MO!11l0Ba
npCllYCMUTpeHHblX CT. 2 HElCTOJlwerO 3aKoHa «06 onepan'!BHO-
('I. 4 CT. 9) p03b1CKHOH
lle}ITe;ThHocnl
114

J 2 3
2 nen() onepanmHoro Y'-1tHI npellparuaCTC B Q)ClIepa,1bHbIH
CJ1Y'13S1X YCTHHOB..1eHI1J1 o6crOSlTeJ1bCTB, CBIt- 3aKOH «06 onepa-
.neTeJlbCToyJOUU\X 06 06'beKTIiBHOi1 HeBOJ- TMBHO-poJbJCKHOi1
MO;t{HOCTH pemeH"'JI KOHl<peTHblX "' lleSlTeJlbH()CTH»
OPll (afu. 4 CT 10)
OnepaTI'IBHall npoBepK" npeKPaluaeTCA flpH 3aKoH Pe<:ny6.11I'1K
ycr3H()BJ1eHI'II1 06CTOHTeJ1bCTB. CBl11leTeJIbCT- EieJlapycb
BYIOWI1X 06 06'beKTHflHOi1 HeIJOJMO;KHOCTH «06 oncpanlflHO-
peWeHI'IJI KOHKpeTHblX 3M2'! OPll (CT. 10) p03blCKHOfi JleSl-
TeJlbHOCTW>
OPM npeKJXIW,aK!TC>J np" ycr3HOBJ1eHI'II'I 3aKOH Pccny6.111'1111'1
06CTOSlTeJ1bCTB, cBI1./IfTeJlbl:rnYJOUUlx 06 om.- Ka3aXCT3H
eKTHBHoJ:! HeB03MmKHOCT peweHRII n()CTae- «06 onepanlBHo-
l1eHHb1X3a.rrn'l (a63 JCT 16) p03LICKHO neSl-
TenbHOCTIt»
OPM npeKpau.ra1OTCSI np" yCTaHOBJ1eHIU1 3aKOH Kblprbl3-
()OCTOHTeJ1bCTB, CBl11leTeJlbcTBYIOWI'IX 06 OOb- CKOH PecnyGJlI1KI'I
eKfBHoi1 HeB03MO)KHOCT peweHI1J1 n()CTIlB- ..06onepanIBHo-
/1el:UJbIX33Jl8.<j (a63. 1'1. 2 CT. II) P03bICKHOH:J\eSl-
TeJlbHOCTtI..
OnepaTIlDHaSI npoDepK3 npetq)8waeTC.II np" 3:1<OH Pecny6.11I1KJ'1
ycr3HOIL"1eHIWI o6crOSlH:lIbCTB, CBIt1IeTeJ1bCT- M0J1110Ba «06
BylOUlx 06 06beKTlUlHOH HeB03MO)!(HOCT onep1TIfBHo-
peWeHI1.II KOHKj)eTHblX 3aI1a'l Opn. ('I. 4 CT. 9) P03bICI<Hot!neSl-
TCJlbHOCTI1"
3 OPM npe"pat1.!dIOIaI no IJblJlW1eHl'1lO 06cTOH- 3aKOH Pe<:ny6.11l'1K
Te.l1bCTB, I1CI<!UO'JaIOUlHX npl1BJIe'leHl1e npOBe- Ka3a'(C1'3H
pJleMOrO 111100 K OTBeTCTBeHIJOCTI1 no OCH()Ba- ..06 onepanlBHO-
HI1J1M, nJX:IJYCMOTPeHHbIM 3aKOHOiUlTeJlbCT80M P03bICKHOt! .!\eSl-
- PecII);6111<11 K ua'«.TdH (a63. 4 CT. 16) TeJlbHOCTI1»
OPM npeKpawalOTCJI no BblJlBJIeHl110 06 3al<OH Kblprbl3-
CTOSl"f(:J1bCTB, I1CK!1IO'laIOWI1X npl1B!Te'leHl1e CKO" PecnyG!Tl1KI1
npOBepSieMoro 1111L!3 K OrBeTCTBeHHOCTI1 no ..06 onep3nlBHO-
OCHOBaHI1J1M. npenYCMOTpeHHblM 3a1<OH0118- p03bICKHOfj: neSl-
Te11bCTBOM Kblprbl3clloi1 PecnyGJll1l111 (003 I TeJlbHOCTI1"
" 3 CT. II)
4 OPM npI1OCT"HaBJII1BlJOl'C$! 11 npeKp"walOTCfI 3aKoH Pecny6.11lOO1
B CpOKI1. npellYCMO'fjJeHHble HOpM3TI1BHblMI1 Ka3aXCTaH
ilKTI1MI1 opral10B, OCyweCTBJlSlIOWI1X OPn., ..06 onepaTHfll10-
comiICOB3HHbIMI1 C reHepilJlbHblM npollypO- P03bICKHOi! .!\eSl-
00\1 PeCnv6nI1KI1 Ka3aXCTaH 1003. 5 CT. 16i. TeJlbHOCTI1»
flpotJol3lCf!l/uema6A.ll
115

I 2 3
OPM ocyweCTBJ1f1IOTCSI, npl'l()CTaI-ffiBmma- 3aKOH KbIprbl3-
JOTCH 1'1 npeKpawmOTCSI II. CpOKI1. onpene- CKO PecnyGJlI1KI1
l1S1e).tble npaBI'ITeJlbCTBOM KblPrblJCKOfi Pec- «06onepanIBHo-
nyGJlHKH (a63. 2 CT II) P03blcKHofinefl-
TenbHOCTw>
"'-''''''''' nenCTBHSI - "PH 3aKOH J1I1TOBCKO
I1CTC'ICHHI'Itfljoroyro,rrOBHbrM33- PecnyGJll'IlIH ,,06
KIJHOJ\rrenbCTBOMCpclKa.l1ilBHOC1JI (a63. 5cr 3) onepaTltBHol1
.neiITC;:[bHOCTH»
5 ECJlI1 II. Te'lCI-U'le rneCTI'I MeC.IIUCB He YCTa- 3allOH YKpal1Hbl
HOBJIeHbI JlaHHble, YKa3b1B3JOll!l1e H3 npH- ,,060nepaTl1B-
3Hf1KH npecrynIJeHHSI B .neikTBHSlX 11ltUa, B HO-pOJbICIIHOI1
OTH()WeHI'II'I KOTOpbIX ocywecTB.lUlJ1I1Cb ()ne- neHTenbHOCTI1»
OOTI'IBHo-roJbICKHbre MeDbl (a63. 3 CT. 9)
OPM ocywecTBJUllOTCSI, npIllOCTaH1lBJIHlJa- 3aKOH Kblprbl3-
JOTCfI 11 npeKpawalOTCSI II. CPOKH. onpeile- CKOM PecnyGJlI'IKI1
nSle).tble npaBI'ITeJIbCTBOM KWprbIJCKof1 Pec- ,,06 onepanJBHO-
nyGJll'IlI1'I (a63. 2 CT. II) pOJblcJ<Hot!ne5l-
Te_bHOCT",'
ECJlI1 CBe.neHI'ISI.  ()CHOBaHHI'I KOTopblX 3aKoH
111'1U() nOCTaBJleHO Hil ()nepaTI'IBHbIH }"JeT, He J1aTBI'IHCKoi1
n()llTBepllI'lJlI'ICb, l(!IHHOe J1I'1UO nOAl\e)Kl'IT PecnyGJll'IlI11
Ctrnn11OcY4eTB (n. 4 'I. JeT. 23) 06 onepaTl1BHofi
ne}ITe;JbHOCTH»
OnepaTl'IBHble net1cTBHJI npet<pallliUOTC.II npH 3aKoHJ1I1ToDCII0t!
}1enOllTl1ep>Kl!eHI1I1 nepl1l11'1Hofi HH41opMauHI1 Pecny6nl1l1H
(a63. 5 CT. J) «06 onepaTl1BHO
neSiTenbHOCTH»
. .ucna no ()ncpaTIlDH()MY }"JC1)' (LlCJ111 no one- 3alloHJ1aTl>11i1-
parnBHblM npoaep""- 11 Onepffrl1BHbI"t p33pa- CKOH Pecny6nl1KI1
=at) npelqJallliHoTCSI. eCJ111 npOBep.lleMblt! «06 ()nepaTHI1H()t!
He nOnTiJeOlUtJlCSI n. I '1.4 CT. 23 neSiTenbHOCTH»
He npeLlYCMOTpeHO 3allOH Kblprbl3-
CKOH Pecny6nl1KH
..060nep"THI1HO-
p03LICKHO neSl-
TeJlbHOCTW>
7 ,Uena n() ()nep:rrlIBHOMY Y'rery (nena no ()ne 3aKoH
paTI1BHblM npOBepK3M 11 OnepaTI1BHblM Pa3- J1aTBl1ikilOH
pa6oTKal>t) npeKPalJ.taIOTC.II. ec.r1l1 npecryn- Pecny6nHKH
JlV:;d:=D.I1 '1T c;nneHl1e «06 ()nepaTHflHOH
neHTeJ1bHOCTH»
flpodo."UJl.Y!Nuema6/1 II
116

OKOH'IaHlIema(jJl.ll
J 2 3
He npe.1lycMoTpeHo 3aKoH Kblprbl3-
CKOH PecnyG!Tl1KI1
«06 OI1CpaTI1BHO-
p03blCKHOti neSl-
Te.bHOCTIt"
8 llena no ()nepaTItBH()MY Y4ery n()CJ1e I1X 3a 3aKoH
BepWCHItJl XpaHJlTCR B YCTaHOBJICHHOM 3a- J]aTBItHCIIOH
KOHON nopMKe It e Teitel-me onpe.1le.lleHHO- PecnyGJ1I-1KI-I
fO I-IMcpOKa(It SeT. 23) «06 ()nepaTl-lnHoti
ne}ITe;:JbHocnl»
He npellycMoTpeH() 3aKoH KblprblJ-
CIWH PecnyGJ1I1KI1
«06 onepanlBHo-
p03bICKHOH
neHTeJlbHOCTI-I»
OCHOBaHHH 11JHI llpeKpallt('HHH QPM llpe1IYcMOTpeHbl IOIIIJIMH
CTaTbSlMH3aKOHOB,
CTaTbA 10 (fJe.aepaJ1bHOfO 3aKOHB «06 onepaTltBHO-p03blcKHoti neH-
H!TbH()CTI1».
CraTb!I 9 3aKQHB YKpaIllHbl «06 oneparnl1Ho-p03blD<Hoii: nCSITI:/1bHOCTI'I".
CnITWI 10 3aIroHa PecnyfuJl'IKI'I EieJIapYCb «05 ()nepaTI'II1HO-p03blcKHol:!
neSlTCJlbl\OCTlt".
CTaTWI 16 3aKoHa Pecnvfi.r1I'1K KaJaXCTIlH «06 oneparnBHo-p03bICKH()1:!
.oCJlTCJ1bHOCTI'I»
CTaTbSl II 3aKOIffi Kblprbl3cKoH PecnyGJ1('jKIt "{)6 OnepaTI'IBHO-
P03bICIIH()w.oeRTeJ1bHOCTI'I»
CTaTbSl 23 3aKOHa J]aTBI'IHI:IIOH Pecny6J11t1l11 «06 onepaTItBHOH neSl-
Te.llbH()CTI1».
CT3TbSl 3 3axOHa J]I1TOI1CKOii PecnyG!Tl1KI1 «06 OnCpaTI'IBHOH .DCJI-
Te.llbH()CTI1»
CTaTbSl 9 3alloH3 PecnyG!Tl1l1l1 MOJU!()Ba «06 onepaTI1BHO-
pOJblCKHOH .DC.ll.TenbHOCTI'I».

Ta6J1Ima 12
0npe.Ire.netnre 3IIIOOJII:I.,1,1Jef>I B ClpBHax CHf H Ea.rrrHH
BajlHBHTOBHCnOJ1b30BaHHHpe:J.}'.lbTaTOeOP.lI.
Hau."UII06t/HUe
'" BapUQHmhl UcnQ/lh3Q6QHIlH pe-sy.lbmom08 OPfl 30fWHOiJtlme.Ib#/b/X
.y, OlCm08,pei!./lO-
."IeHmupyIOUI,UX
OPJJ,
1 2 3
I JfcnOJlb30RBHHe pe:JY"bTBT08 OP.lI. B )TOJIOB-
- Ho-npoueccyanbHoH cepe
1.1. KaK n()BOll DJ1S1 B036}')K1leHH.II yrOJl()BHO- cDellepaJIbHbltI
rOlleJlB 3aKOH «06 onepa-
THBH()-po3bICKHOti
lle.llreJ1bHOCTH»
KaK []p.IUIorH DJ1R B036y)l(l\eHHSI yrOJlOBHoro 3allOH YKpaHHbl
n. ..Q6onepaTHBHo-
P03blcKHotillell-
TeJlbHOCTH..
K.K nOBOll DJ1S1 B036YJKJIeH(!R yronoBHoro 3aKOH Kblprbl3-
lleJlS CKO" PecnyGJ1HKI'I
«06 OnepaTrIBHO-
po3blCKHOH JJ,eSl-
TeJlbHOCT»
1.2. Kall ()CHOBaHHSI DJ1S1 B036)')Kl1eHI1S1 yro- cDellepaJIbHb!"
l()BH()roneJlB 3aKOH «06 onepa-
l1'IBHO-po3bICKHOH
lleRreJlbHOCTH»
KBK OCHOBBHHI'I DJ1S1 B036yJK.llf:HH1 yroJloB- 3allOH YKpaHHbl
HOrolleJJa «06()nepaTBHo-
P03blcKHotilleSl-
TeJIbHOCT»
1.3.L\.JISI nOllrOToeKH n ocyrneCTBJ1eHHS! (fJe.aepa.'JbHbltI
CJI<:t\CTBeHHbIXJ],eHCTBHH !.aKOH POCCHH-
CKOH (fJepaUHH
«06 onepaTBHo-
po3blCKHOH lleSl-
TeJlbHOCTrIO>
118

llpwc!.J.1l('(!lIuema(j/l.12
I 2 3
11" npOeellel1l1S1 fJeOTl1mKfJblX CJlellCTBefJ- 3aKOfJ YKpaHfJbl
HblX llefCTBl'lfj ,,06 onepaTBHO-
po3blCKHOH JlfSl-
TeJIbHOCT»
DiLlI n()llrOTOBKI'II'I ()cyrnecTBJlefJl1S1 CJlellCT 3aKoH Pecny6
BeHHblXlldicTBI'IH 111'1KI1 EieJIapycb
,,06 Onep"TI1BHO-
POThICKH()H neSl-
TeJIbHOCTI1"
L\.JIJI nOllTOTOBKI'I 1'1 ocywecroJIeHI'IJI CJle.rlCT- 3allOH Pecny6-
BeHHblx.u:eHCTBI1H nlJKI1 KaaaXCTaH
,,06 OnepaTI1BHO-
P03blCKHOH JlfSl-
TeJIbHOCTH»
L\.JIH nQlJ,r01OIJKI1 11 OGyrneCTBJleHI1S1 CJIellCT- 3aKOH Kblprb!3-
BeHHbIXlle"CTBI'IH CKO" Pecny6JII1KH
,,06 OnepaTrIBHO-
po3b1CKH()fj neSl-
TeJIbHOCTrI"
npl'l n()nroToBKe 1'1 npOBelleHl'I1'I npellYCMOT 3aKoHJ1aTBl1fj
peHHblX aaKOHOM CJIellCTBeHHblX J],eHCTl!l1H CKOH Pecny6J11JKI'I
no yronoBHblM llenaM ,,060nepaTI'IBH()fj
.u:eSlTeJ1bHOCTI1"
L\.JIJI n01lrOTOBKI'I 1'1 ocywecTBJleHI'IJI CJle.llCT- 3alloH Pecny6-
BeHHblX .u:eHCnJIJH, a TaKJKe B l13'leCTBe .u:o- 1111KI1 MO.l1.u:oBa
K,uuenbCTB no yronoBHbIM nemlM ,,06 onep"THBHO-
P03bICKH()H neSl-
TeJIbHOCTI'I"
1.4. B Ka'leCTBe nOKa3HR:J[bCTB no yro.l10B- lDt:.rJ.epanbHbIH
HblM JlfJIaM nOCJ1e lJX npOBepKI1 B COOTBeT- 33.KOH,,060nepa-
CTBI'II'I C yro.l10BH()-npoueccyaJIbHbIM aaIlOH()- TI1BH()-po3bICKHOfj
DHTeJIbCTBOM lleHTeJ1bHOCTI1»
B K3'leCTBe llOKaaaTeJ1bCTB no yro.l1oBHblM 3alloH Pecny6-
JJ,eJ1HM B COOTBeTCTBl111 C yrOJ10BHO-npOLlec- 1111KrI 6eJ1apycb
cya.l1bHblM JaKOHOJIaTeJIbCTBOM ,,06 ()nepaTI1BHO-
po3blCKI10H neJl-
TeJ1bHOCT'"
119

llpoiJOII,:!/Cf'IIUe ma611. 12
I Z 3
B K1NeCTBe .nOK3.3aTeJlbCTB no yrOi10BHbIM 3alloH PeCny6_
.nemlM n()C.IIe I'IX npoBepKI'I B COOJBe'JCTBI'II'I C nl'lKI'I KaJaxcTBH
yro.lloBHo-npoueceyanbHblM J8KOHO.n8TeJ1b- ..060nep;rofBHo-
CTBOM po3blCKHOH .neSl-
Te':-'bHOCT"
B j],QIIB3b1BaHI1I1 no yrQlIOBHblM .neJTBM B co- 3aKoH Kblprb!3-
.. 0 nOlIO)KeHI1.11MI'I yrOJl()BHO- CKOf! PecnytiJ1I1KH
npoueceyanbHQro 33KOHQJJ.aTCJIbCTBa Kblp- ..06 Onep"TI1BHO-
rb!3CKoJ:i Pecny6J1I'1KI'I P03LICKH()H .neSl-
TeJTbHOCTI1"
B K8'leCTBe .nOKa3aTCJIbCTB no yrOJlOBHblM 3aKOHJ]aTBI1H-
.nem1M TOJIbKO nOCJ1e npOBepKI'I B COOTBeTCT- emf! PecnytiJ1I'1KI'I
BI1I1 C YrOlIOBHo-npou eec Y8J1bHbIM KO.aeK- ..o6onepaTI'IBHof!
cOMJ]aTBI'II'I .neSlTeJ1bHOCHI"
B IIB'leCTBe .nOKaJaTeJ1bCTB no yro.lloBHblM 3BKOH Pecny6-
"",'M J1I1I1I1MoJllIOBB
..06 onep"THBHO-
P03blCKHOH .ne.ll-
TeJlbHOCT..
1.5. npeJlOCTaBJIeHl1e pe3yJlbTaTOI! OPLt op- cIJe.aepaJIbHbIH
rBHY .n03HaHI'ISI, CJ1e.n()BBTeJ11O I1JII1 B cy.n, B JaKOH ..06 onepa-
npol13BOlIcT6e KOToporo H1IXOlll1TCSI yrolIOB- TI1BHO-po3b1CKHOi1
HOeneJ1() ne.llTeJ1bHOCTI'I"
npellOCTaBJIeHl'le pe3ynbTaToB OPLt opraHY 3BKOH KblprbIJ-
.n03HBHI'ISI, CJ1e.nOBBTeJ11O 1'1111'1 D cy.n, D npo- CliO" Pecny6JJ1'1KH
1'13BOJlCTDe KOTOpOro HBWllI1TCJI yro.l1.oBHoe «06 ()nepanJBHO-
.neJlo po3bICKH0i1 .neSl-
TeJIbHOCT"
npl'l nOJIY4eHI111 onepaTI!Hoti I1H41op}'18uHI1 3BKoHJ]anmti-
no yrOl1()BH()MY nelIY C() Bcef! nOl1Y'1eHHO" B CliO" PecnytiJ1I1KH
npouecce onepaTBHoi1 .neHTeJlbHOCTI'I I1H- ..06onepaTI'IBHof!
41opMaUl1ef! no 3TOMY .neJlY .n()J1)KH() 6bITb lIeSiTenbHOCT"
03HilII0},tJ1eH() 1111UO, pyKoBOJ1S1ll1ee XOJ1[)M
yrO.ll()BH()fO npoueCCB
1.6. L\.JISI n()J1Y'!eHI1.11 41aKTlf'leclIl1x nBHHbIX. 3BKOH YKpal1Hbl
1I0Topble Moryr 6blTb .o:OK83aTeJlbCTB8MI1 " ..06 onep"THBHO-
\lro.llOBHOM neJ1e P03bICKH()H .neSl-
TeJlbHOCT"
120

llpodoflJICeHue ma6f1. 12
1 2 3
2 I1cnOJlb30BaH8e p e1 } 'J1bTaTOBOP .n,
l_l. L\.JII1 npouelleHltlJ OPM 3aKOH Pecny6_
]]I1KII 6enapycb
,,06 onepaTHBHO-
po3bICKH0i1 J\eSl-
TeJIbHOCTW>
L\.JISI npOBelleHl111 OPM 3aKOH Pecny6-
nl1KI1 Ka].(lXCTaH
,,06 onepaTBHO-
P03bICKH()H neSl-
TelIbHOCT"
L\.JISI npOBelleHI1J1 OPM 3aKoH KbIpn.l3-
CKOi1 Pecny6lIl1-
'"
,,06 onepaTHBHO-
po3blCKHOH neSl-
Te:ibHOCT"
'"', npOeeJ1eHIUI OPM 00 npenynpe)l(1le- 3aKOH Pecny6-
HI1IO. npCCC'JeHI1IO 11 pacllpblTmo npecl)'Tl- 1111KH MOl1lIoBa
]]eHI1i1 ,,06 onepaTBHO-
P03bICKH()H nelJ-
Te:ibHOCTI1"
2.2. L\.JIIJ npelIYnpe;KJIeHI1J1. npeCe'ieHI'IIJ " cDenepanbHblH
paCKpb!TI'IIJ npeCTYnl1eHI1H, Bb1l1BJIeHI1IJ " JaKOH «06 onepa-
}lCTaHOBJ1eHI1S1 1I11U, I1X nonrOTaMI1BalOlUl1X. THBHO-poJbICKHOH
COl\eOWHfQWI1X1'1 coneOWI1BWI1X lICHTCJI
11" npCJ10TBpaWeHIUI, npeCe'leHI'IJI 11 pac- 3allOH YKpal'lHbl
CJlen()BaHI'IJI npeCTYnl1eHI1H, paJBCJ1bllJaTeJ1b- ,,06 onepaTIfBHO-
HO-nQJ1pbIBHblX nOCHraUJlbCTB np01I'IB YK- poJblCKHOH .neSl-
pal1Hbl. pOJbICKa npecTyJlHI'IKOB 1'1 6eJ BeCTH TeJIbHOCTIf"
noonaBWI'IX1!111!
'"', npelIynpe)l(1leHI1J1. npece'JeHI1S1 " P" 3alloH Pecny6-
IIpblTl1Jl npeCTYnJleHI'li1 11I'1K(,] 6elIapycb
,,06 ()nepaTHBHo-
poJbICKHOi1 .oe5]-
TeJIbHOCTo>
'"', np e llynpe;KJIeHl1l1, npeCe'leHHI1 " pac- 3allOH Pecny6_
IIpblTlUl npeCTYnneHHH JlI1KH KaJaXCTaH
,,06 onepaTHBHO-
p03blCKHOH J\eSl-
TeJlbHOCTIf"
121

1 2
L\.1IH npCL!ynpe)!(,.!l,eHI'ISI, npece'leHI1S1 11 pac-
IIpblTI'ISI npecTYnJlel-U'lH
2.3. L\.1ISI BJ.aI'lMH()rO I'IH!}JopMl'lpOBaHI1.11 nOLI
pa3JleJleHI'IH, ynOJ1HOIO'JeHHblX ocyweCTB-
JlHTb onepaTHBHYJO neHTeJlbHOCTb, 11 npYnlx
nmmOOXOaHIfTCJ1bI-lI>IX 0 ral-lOB
3 HCnOJlb30B3Ulle PeJyJlbTaTOB QPLt B lIJIo41H-
_TaKTH'IecKHXIK'JlAX
3.1. l\..Jrn I'IH$OpMl'lpOBaHI1.11 rocynapCTBeH-
HblX apraHoB B COOl1IeTCTBI'II1 C I'IX 110"'"1'-
TCHLll1ei'i
Lt.IH1 03HaKOMJleHH.I[ pYKoBOlllITt'.l1eH I1HCTI1-
T)'TOB rocynapCTBeHH()j:j BJIaCT 1'1 ynpaBJIe-
HIUI, ynQJ1HOM04CHHblX 11MI'! mm JaKOHOM
n()J])KH()CTHbIX 111m. a TaK)Ke B YCTaHOBJ1eH-
HOM JaKOHOM nopSlllKC -rex nOn>KHOCTHbIX
J1HLl cy6beKToB onepaTBHoj:j JleSlTI'JlhHOCTH.
KOTOpblM 3Ta I1HI)JOpMalll1H HeOOXOlIl'IMa WlH
BblnOJ1HeHHH c;I¥JKe6HblX 33J1aHHi1. I'CJ1H ee
COllep}KaHl'le CBSlJaHO C HCn()!1b30BaHHCM
nopY4eHHbiX 3THMH nOJIlKHQCTHbIMH 11Itl.taMH
ol5.113"HHocrei1
4 n aBOBOI' 3Ha'leHHC 1'3 JlbTaTOB QP)]
nOJlY'!eHl-m.ll c nOIOWblO CpellCTB ()nepa
THBHOH J\eSlTCJ1bHOCTH HH.pOPM3UIUl /l,\O)l(l'r
6bITb pacllpb1Ta B KOlle cyne6H()H npouellYpbl
c npeilBapHTI'JlbHO.-o pa3peweHlUI reHe-
pa.nbH()rO npoKypopa 3anpewaeTCJI CnOJlb-
JOBaHl1e I1H41opM2U1'IH, nOJ1}1'leHH()tI c n()-
MOWbH) Cp!:!lCTB onepaTltlJHoti lleSlTJIbHO-
CTI1. He B ue.llBX. B03HI1KalOWI1X 3 caHK-
LlI10Hl1poBaHHoi1 !:lIe)({KIJ
B c.IIY'Jae HaMepeHI1S1 rocYAapcTBeHH()" I1H-
CTI1TYLlI1I1 i'ICnOJlb30Barb nOJlY4eHHYH) C no-
M()lllbH) ()nep:rrI1BHb!X Cpe!lCTB I1H41opMaLlI1IO
()Hf! npellB"pl1Te.llbHO .nomKHa I1H$OpMl1pO-
BaTb 06 JTOM HCTHTYUI1IO. II OTHoweHIUJ
KOTonnil >KeJlf!eT 3TO OCVIIICCTBHTb
122
flpoiJo.l:JICelillema(jA 12
3aKOH Kblprbl3-
CliO" Pecny1)JlI1KH
,,06 onepanJBHO-
P03bICKH()tlllcSI-
T!:;JbHOCTIN
3alloH YKpal1Hbl
,,06 onepaTHBHO-
P03bICKHOtl.nCB-
T!:JlbHOCTH"
3aKOH YKpal1Hbl
..06 onepaTHBHO-
p03bICKH0i1JJ,eSl-
TeJlbHOCT"
3aKOH
JlaTBHtlcKoti
Pecny1)JlI1HJ
..06 ()nepaTHBH()fi
.nel\TeJIbHOCTH"
3aKoHJlI1TOB
CKOi1 P!:cny1)JlIt-
KI1 ,,06 ()nepa-
TItBHoMJJ,CI'ITei1b-
H()CTW>

OKOH'IaHlIema(jJ/ 12
I 2 3
B CJ1yqac pacKPblTI'IR I'IH41opMaul'Il'I 0 J1l'1ue.
nOJ1yqeHHow C [JOMOlUblO CneUI'la.rJbH()W TeX-
tH:lI<I'I. H33saHHOC nl1LlO snpallc 06J1\aJ10113Tb
1'1 ()Tpl'ltlaTb n()1<a33HI'IH I'ICXOilll 1'13 Toro. 'lTO
I) I'IH!)JOpM3UI1H 6blna nOJ1Y4CHa HC33KOHHO;
2) npl'lMCHeHl1e cpcrICTD OnCp3TI'IIIHOW nCJI-
rCJlbHOCTI'I 6b1JIO HeCaHKLlI'IOHl'lpOll3HO
B 3TOM CJ1Y4ae cyn BnpaBe orJ1aCI'ITb ""-
nepJKlI1'I ", MOTI1Bl'lpOBaHHoro npeLlCTal\!1e-
HIU! HH nOJ1Y'1eHl'le CaHIIlU'II1, nOKa3blBHlOme-
ro JaKOHHOcrb CHHKlll1l'1.
(1HCtxJpr.I3UHJI,nOJIy<JeHHaHcllO\IOI1IbIOCpeLl(.TI!
onep.1TI'IBHOM neRTeJ1bHOCTI1 npOHI'lKalOmerO
xapHKTepa 6eJ caHKW111 reHqJallbHoro npOlcy-
popa I.JJ1I'1 JaMel1l8lOlUerO ero J1l'1ua. HOJ1J1\Ha
6blTb HeJaMe1J)!I1Te.l1bH() YHl1'lTO)l(eHH (CT. 9).
J1l'1ua. I-IDPYWI'IBWl'le 3aKoH 06 onepanmH()fi
neSlTeJIbHOCT, HeCyrUIBeTCJlleHHOCTb B COOT-
- BeR:1BH1'I C JaI<OHOM J1I1TOBCI<OW PecrwwmKI'I
PCJyJ1bTaTbI OPIt II OTHoweHl'I1'I J1I1Ll, nepc- 3alloH KbrprblJ-
"'1'ICJ1eHHblX B n 1-3 1'1 5....2CT 8 HaCTOH- eKOH PecnytiJ1lJKI1
mero 3aKOHa, Y41'1Tbl1!81OTCH nplJ peWeHl'I1'I ,,06 onep3nUIHO-
:fC:H:X el\ YKaJaHHblM BmI3M p03blCKHOH neSl-
rCJ1bHOCnN
MaTepl'laJlbr onepaTI'IBH()n npoBepKI'I He RB- 3aKOH Pecnyti-
J1RIOTCSI ()CH()BaHl'leM W1R ()rpaHWreHl'l.l1 J1I1KI'I MO.l1nOBa
npaB. cB060n 1'1 3allOHHblX I'IHTepeC()e 411'131'1- ,,06 onepaTHBHo-
'IeCKI1X 1'1 fOPI'IJII'I'IeCKI'IX nl'lU p03brCKH()W neSl-
TeJIbHOCT»
BapHaHTbl IICIIOJII..JOeaHHH PC3YJlbTaTOe OPll IIpt'.OJo'CMArpHBaIOT CTa-
TbHCJle.'I,,)'IOUlIIX33KOIIOB,
CTITTbfl 2 (]JeJlepaJIbHOrO JaKOHH ,,06 OnepaTI'IBHO-p03brCKHOH: neA-
TeJIbHOCTI'I".
CraTbll13aKOI1aYllpHIIIHbi "060nepaTl'IIJI1O-po3bICKHOIl,,
CTaTbH 3 3allOHa PecnytiJ1I'1KI'I EiCJ1apYCb ,,06 Onep3TI'IBHO-p03brc1lHOn
.oeSlTeJ1bHOCTI'I"
CTaTbH 2 3alloHa Pecrry6J1I'1KI'I KaaaxCTaH ,,06 onepaTBHo-p03bICKHOfi
AeSlTeJlbH()CTSlI'I".
CTaTbSl 14 3aKoHa Kblprbl3CKofi Pecrry6J1I'1K ,,06 OnepaTI'IBHO-
p03brcKHOnneSlTeJlbHOCTI'I»
CTaTbH 2 3aKoHa J1areI'lMCKOn PecnyGJ1I'1KI'I ..06 OnepaTI'IBHOH: neA-
TeJIbHOCTH".
CraTblll3aKcH.tJ111lO11CKCJti Pecny6J1I1Kl1..oGoneJ:ET1'lBHOH.ne=bHlX:fiI
Cr.\Tb!! 2 3aKoHH Pecny6f1HKH MOf)JJ.OIJt ,,06 OneparHI!HO-p03bICKHOH.
ACSlTCJ1bHOCTI'I"

Ta(i.Hua 13
OpraHbI. OQIItfCTBJUlKlllUIe OneparHBHO-pa'1blClrnylO,/¥:JrreJIbJlOCTh
B cTpaHax CHI" u 6aJ1THH
Hau.'4el/Q6(jllue
IV'> HauMeHoflollue op<,aHofl, meJIIHJUlUX aKoHOIJame,7bHb/X
_In OP/l OKm08, pei?lO-
.",eHmupyIOUI,uX
OP/l
1 Z 3
I o raHl,IB .neJl
OpraHbI BHYTpeHHl1x]:\C:J1 (n. I CT. 13) (]>enepilllbHblH
3aKOH «06onepa-
1l1BHO-po3bICKHOfi
HCIITCJ1bHOC1W>
OpraHbl BH}'11JeHHHXHell yro.oBHOH H me- 3alloH YKpaHHbl
UaJIbHOj{ MHlII1UHej{. nOHp.uI1elleHl1.11MI1 00 «060nepaTl1e-
-'" , ()praHI13OBaJ-moi:i npecrynH()CTblO, HO-p03bICKH()H
onepanIBHo-pe;KH"tHbIMH [J()JIIJIUlleQeHHSI"IH HeSlTeJlbHOCTH»
MeCTJlHWeHwrceo6o.J:bI a63. I OJ. I CT 5
OpraHbl BHYTpeHHHx HeJl (a63. I .. I CT. 2) 3aKoH Pecny6
QHIIH Eienap)lCb
06 onepa-mB-
HO-p03bICKHOH
HeJlTeJlbH()Cll1»
OpraHbI BHyrpeHHl1x.oen (n. ..a&'!:,lcT.6) 33110H Pecny6-
lIHKH K!I3IIXCT3H
«06 onepare-
HO-p03bICKH()j{
- ()jJfaHbI BHyrpeHHl1x neJl (003. I n. I CT. 16) nCJlTeJlbHOCTIf»
3aKOH Kblprbl3-
C"-OU Pecny6JIHKH
06 OnepaTHB-
HO-p03!>ICIlHOH
ne.flTeJ1bHOCT"
focy.uapCTBeHHb!e Y'lpe;KJIeHI1.11. ()6ecne'{I1 3aKoH
BalOLUI1C 06WCCTDeHHblk nopflHOK J]an>Hkcllok
Pecny6JIHIIH
«060nepaTBHOH
ne.llTeJ1bHOCTH"
r OC}fLlapCTBeHHble HHCT(1)IUHI1. ocyweCTB- 3aKOH
nSllOwe rocy.uapCTBeHHQe ynpaBJIeHHe B 06- J]HTOBCKOH
nacTIII BHYTpeHHI.JX neJl Pecny6JIHKH
«060nepaTHBHOn
.uerrreJlbHOCTH»
124

1 2 3
OpraHbI MHHI1CTepCTBa BHyrpeHHI1X nen JallOH Pecny6-
QI1KI'I MOJllIOaa
«06onepaTl1e-
HO-P03bICKHOH
IleSlTeJ[bH()CTO>
 .1HbII"OCJJA BeHHoiioeJonacHOcT (]>enepilllbHblH
OpTaHbI CJ>C;!C:P,L"IbHOii clIY>K6b1 6c30rmcHO-
cT([J.2cT.13) 3aKoH«D6onepa-
THBHO-probICKHOH
IlellTI:!1bHOCTI'I"
OpraHbl HailltOHJ.JIbHOII 6e30nacHOCT p" 3aKoH YKpal1Hbl
Be.LlKa, KOtfIJJIH3I1!:JJ.K3. BOetuiIDI IIOHrppa3Beil- ..060nepaTl1B-
Ka. nonpaJlIeneHIUI 3alliTbI HauoHa,1bHoi1 HO-p03bICKH()W
rocynapCTBeHHOCTl'l. 6opb6bI C Iwppynmrej{ 11 neHTe.llbH()CTO>
OpraHI130fI3HHOH npeCTYnHOHllcSlH:;JbHOCTblO,
onepaniBHO-TeXHI1'JeClIl1e. oneparBHoro li()-
KYNeHniOOBaHI1J1 363. 2 'I. I CT 5)
OpraHbI rocYll3pCTBeHHoti 6e30rracHoCTH 33)(OH Pec[Jy5-
(a63. 2 <I. 1 cr. 2) ]]I1Kl'I6e;owPycb
.060nepaTl1B-
HO-p03bICKH()j{
.l{eSlTeJ1bHOCT..
OpraHbl HauoHa.rrbHOj:j 6e30nacHoCTIf (n. ..6. 33110H Pecny6-
'l.lcT 6) nl1KI1 K,:naxcT3H
..060nepaTl1B-
HO-p03bICKH()H
JleHTeJ1bHOCT"
OpraHbI HaLIHOHaJ1bHOH 6e3QnacHocnl (003 I JaKOH KblpTbl3-
n.2cT.16) CKOH Pecny6JIHKI'I
..06 onepaTl1B-
HO-p03bICIlHOH
.neHTe.llbHOCT..
....ocyllapcTBeHHb!e Y4pexateHltSl, o6ecne.m- 3aKOH
BalOWHC 6e30naCHOCTb JlaTBHHCKOH
Pecny6.rJI1KI'I
..060nep3TIfBHofr
neSlTeJ1bHOCTIf»
rOCYJlapCTBeHHb!e HCTUIYIUIH. oCYllIecTB- 3aKoHl1HTOB-
J1S1IOWHe rocynapcTBeHHoe ynpaBJ1eHe B CKO" Pecny6.rll1-
06nacTIf HaUHOHal1bHOH 6eJOnacHocTIf KI1 «06 onepa-
TBHOfiJleSlTeJ1b-
H()CTI1»
flpoiJoDJr£,mema611 13
125

llpQ()o/l./lCeHuemaQ/I.13
1 Z 3
OpraHbI MHHHCTepC1&I HaUHOHaJlbHOH 63- 3allOH Pecny6-
onacHocTH 11I1KI'I MOMoBa
«06onepaTl1e-
HO-p03bICKHOH
lIeSlTJlbHOCTH"
 HaJlOrOeaS nOJlltlilts (cnY&W)
He npeJlycMoTpeHO C3>elIepa.rrbliblH
3aKOIi 06onepa-
1l'IBHO-po:!bICKHOit
.neSTeJlbHOCTW>
OpraHbl HaJlorORblX paCCJ1ellORaHHH r113BHOH 3allOH Pecl]y6-
rocYll3pCTDeHH()H HaJ1()rOBOH I1HCnellUl'I1'I 11I1KI1 EieJIapycb
MI1HHCTepcToa 4JI1HaHCOB taG3. 4 'I. I CT. 2) 06 OneparHB-
HO-p03bICKH()H
.neSTeJIbHOCTo>
OpraHbI HaJ10rOBOH CJ1)?K6bl MI'IHl1cTepCTEIa 3allOH Pecny6-
$I'IHaHcoB(n. ..n... I CT 6) nHKH KaJ.axcTaH
..06onepaTI1B-
HO-p03bICKH()H
neJlTeJIbHOCTo>
OpraHbI $I'IH3HCOBOif nOJmUHI1 (a63. 1 n. 4 3all01i KblpfblJ-
CT. 16) CKOM Pecny6JJHKH
060nepaTI1B-
HO-p03bICKH()H
neJlTeJIbHOCTo>
rocYll3pCTBeHHb!e I1HCTI'IT)'UHH, ocyweCTB- 3aIlOHJ1HTOB-
11J1lOlUHe rocyll3pCTBeHHoe ynpaBJIeHl1e . CKOH Pecny6.rJH-
o6;:mCTH $HH3HCOB KI1 «06 onepa-
THBHOH)leSlTeJ1b-
,rOC):aaPCTeeHHaAoxpaHa HOCTW>
-I""PM"""" OP""W rOCy"pITHHO' 0'- C3>elIepanbHbIH
IXIHbl. rnaBHoe ynpaBJlCHI'IC oxpaHbI Poc- J(lIlOH 06one-
CHt1CKO $eLlepaUHH H CJ1)?K6bl 6e30nacHo- paTHBHO-
CT npe311LleHTa POCCHHCKOH $e.nepm..ll1l1 po3bJCKHOHD,eS-
(n_4cT.13) re.nbHOCT
126

llpQ()o/l./lCeHuemaQ/I.13
1 2 3
YnpaBJIeHl1e OXPal-Jbl BblCllIl1X lIW])KH()CTHblX 3aKoH YKpal1Hbl
nou n()llPaJlleneHl1eM onepaTHBHoro ()6ec- 060nCpaTHB-
ne'l.eHHSloxpaHbl (a63. 4'1..1 CT.j) HO-p03bICKH()
neHTe.llbHOCTHo>
W}'}K6a oxpaHbl np<:3I'IJleHTa Pecny6J1HIII1 3allOH Pecny6-
Ka3aXCTil.H{n_ "n".. 1 CT. 6) nHKH KaJaxcTaH
060nepaTHB-
HO-pOJbICKH()
lle}ITeJ1bHOCTHo>
OpraHbl C.IIy;K6bl rocynapcTBeHHo oxpaHbI 3alloH KblprblJ
(a63.1 n.4CT. 16) CKOJ:l Pecny6JIHKM
..06 ()nepaTI1B-
HO-p03bICKHOH
.!Ie}lTeJ1bHOCT
focynapCTBeHHble I1HCTM1)IUMH. ocylUecTB 3aKoHJlHToB
nHlOlUl1e oxpaHY eblCIUHX opraHoB rocynap- CKOH Pecny6.11H-
CTI}eHHOll BlIaCTH H ynpaBJ1eH('j}[ JlI{TOBCKOll III{ ..06 onepa-
Pecny6J1I1KH TflHotilleSlTej]b-
._- HOCTW.
 norpaHII"H3HCJlpKI'i.a -
BKJlI04eH() B COCruB opraHa cDenepaJIbHol:! (]>ellepaJIbHblll
CJlY)l(6bl 6e3oru!CHocTIl JaKOH ..06 onepa-
TBHO-P'1:Jb1CKHOH
neJlTCJ1bHQCTIIO>
n()rpaHl1'iHble BoftCKa nunpa3llelJeHI1.11 no 3aKoH YKpal1Hbl
OnepaTl1BHO-p03bICKHOH pa60Te (a63. 3 'I.. 1 06()nepaTI1B-
CT. 5) HO-pOJbICKH()
.!IeSlTeJ1bHOCTO>
OnepaTl:!BHble nOllPa31leJleHH}I n()rpaHH'IHblX 3alloH Pecny6-
BOCK npl1 COBere MI1HI'ICTpOB Pecny6.rJHKII J1I1KII Eienapycb
6enapycb (a63. 3 'I.. 1 CT. 2) 06()nepaTe-
HO-p03bICIlHOM
.!IeSlTeJlbHOCTH
BKJlI04eH() B C()CTaB OpraHa HaUl10HaJlbHoft 3alloH KblprblJ
6e30ITdCHOCTH CXOM Pecny6JII{KH
..06onepaTl1e-
HO-p03bICIlHOM
lleSlTeJlbHOCTHO>
127

llpc;xJo.U/Cf!l/uemalk 13
-,-1- 2 3
6 T3MmKf'HH8H cJlplma
TaMO)KHHble opr[lHbl POCCI1HCKOJ:i €Dellepa- (]>e.nePaJlbHblH
LlHI1 (n.6cT. 13) JaKOH 06 onepa-
1l'IBHO-JXI3I>ICKHOit
lleSlTeJ1hHocrn..
TaMO)KeHHble opraHhl (a63. I n. 5 CT_ 16) 3aKOH Kblprbl3-
CKOH Pecnyfull1KI1
06UnepaTI1B-
HO-pObICKHOH
lleSlTeJlhHOCTH"
rocynapCTBeHHble I1HCTI11)'LlI1I1, OCYllleCTB- 3aKOH11I1T08-
JlSlIOWHe rOCYllapCTBeHHoe ynpaBJIeHl1e B 06- CKOH Pecny6J111-
nacrI1TaMO)KeHHblXAeJ1 KI1 «06 onepa-
TBHOfiJleSlTeJ1b-
- HOCTI1"
UpraHbIBHernllellpa3Be)J,KII POCCI1CKO (]>e.nepaJ\bHhl
CJI}'JK6w BHelUHeH pa.me.DKH
€Dellepawm(n 7 CT. 13) JaKOH ..06 onepa-
1l'IBHO-po3bICKHOI1
- .u:eSlTeJ1hHocm..
OpraHhl BoeHHoH pa3BellKI1 MI1HI1CTepcrna 3aKoH Pecny6
06opoHbl (n. «B»'I:. 1 CT 6) lUJKI1 K!I33XCTaH
06 onepaTI1B-
HO-p03bICKHUH
lleJlTJ1bHOCT"
OpraHhl BoeHHuH pa3BellKI1 MI1HI1CTepcTBa 3alloH Kblprbl3
06opoHbl (003. 1 n. 3 CT. 16) c"oii Pecny6JII1KI1
.060nepaTI1B-
HO-p03bICKHUW
.u:eSlTJ1bHOCT"
focynapcTBeHHhle Y4pe)Kl]eHI1H_ ufjecne'lI1 3aKoH
BalOWHe 06opOHY J]aTBHHCKOn
Pecny6JII1I1H
06onepaTHBHoi1
lIe.IITeJ1LHOCTI1»
128

OKOH'IOHUe maIJ/I. 13
1 2 3
rocYJlapcTlleHHb!e HcnnyIUll1. OCYllleCTB- 3aKOH11I1T08-
JUllOlUl1e rocynapcTBeHHoe ynpaBJIeHl1e . CKOW Pecny6.rm-
06nacTIII oxpaHbI KpaSi 1111 .,06onepa-
TBHoM.neJ1Tenb-
HOCTW.
OpraHbl MI1HI1CTepcTBa U6opOHbi 3aKoH Pecny6
QI1I1I'1 MonnoDa
..o6oneparl1B-
HO-pOJbICKHUk
 - ::"aJ1e::SlHa;Jla;A I1CnQJlHeHlU1 neSiTenbHOCTIfo>
H81G13!I- <De.r:IepaJIbHblii
HI1W (n.8cT 13) JaKOH
060nCpaTI1B-
HO-p03bICIlHOH
neSlTen1>liOCTIf"
OpraHbl yroJlUBHO-l1cnOJlHI1TeJlbHOn CI1CTe- 3aKoH KblprblJ-
!>Ibl (863 1 n.1 CT. 16) CKOM PecnyfulHKIf
«06onepaTI1B-
HO-pOJbICKHUA
=r -  ::: :'=P  :": :POTOM HHpKO- IleSiTenbHOCTIf»
<Denepa.rJbHblH"
'JH'IeCKI'IX CpeIlCTB 11 nCHXOTponHblX BelUeCTB JaKoH«06onepa-
(n.9cT.13) 1l'IBHO-poJUCKHOH
IleSlTeJlbHOCTIJ..
Opral'lbl . cepe KOHlJIOJIJI HapKOTI'IKOB 3allOH KblpTblJ-
(a63. 1 n.9cr (6) CKoii Pecnyfull1KH
06uneparHB-
HO-p03bICIlHOH
- ne}ITeJlbHOCTW>
 :J :HO Y:;'HoMo'leHHble I1Hcnrr)'LIIIH 38KOH11I1T08-
CKOH PecnyfulH-
KI1 ..06 onepa-
TIfBHUkneSlTeJlb-
HOCTI1
He npc:llYCMOlJleHO 3aKOH KblprblJ-
CIIOM PecnyfulHKI'I
.,Q60nepaTI1D-
HO-p03bICKHUA
neJlTeJlbHOCTH..
129

nepe>reHb OpI".lIIOB. O OPll. IIpfJJ.yCM8lpHB8IOT C.IIe-
DJlIOUlHeCT8TbH :JaIlOtIOII.
CT8TbSl I] <DepanbHoro a8110H8 ,,06 onep8THBHO-pOJblCKHOH lleSl-
Te.llbHUCTI1".
CTaTbSl S 3alloH!l YKpaHHbl ,,06 onepaTHBHo-pOJbICI<HOHlleSlTCJ1b-
HOCTH".
CraTbSl 2 3aJ<OH3 Pecny6.11I1I<H Einapycb .()fj Onep3THBHO-pOJbICKHoi1
lleSlTeJ1bHOCTH".
CTaTbSl (; 3aJ<oHa PecrIy5.11I1I< KaJaXCTaH ..00 Unep3TBHo-pOJbICKHOA
lleSlTeJ1bHOCTH"
CT3TbH 16 33KOHa Kblprbl3cKoJ:1 Pecny6.rJI1KI1 ..06 onepaniBHo-
p03blcIIHui1Ae.llTeJ1bHOCTH"
CTarbH 2S 3aKOHa J1areI'lHCI<OH Pecny6.rJHKI1 ..06 oneparHBHoH neA-
Te.llbHUCTH".
nYHKT 2 nOCT3HOBJ1eHml BC J1I1TBbl 0 BBe.rteHHH B lleikTBl'le 3alloH8
,,06 onepaTHBHui1 Ae.llTeJ1bHUCTH»
CTaThIi II 3aKOH3 PecnyfuJHKH MOJUlOBa ,,06 onep3nIBHo-p03bICKHO
AeSlTe.llbHUCTH».

Taf5JIHlrn 14
npBlla opraltOB. ocyweCTB.llIlIOWHX onepaTIIBHo-pa:JblCKHYIO neIlTeJlIoIIOCTIo.
npe.lQCMUI]It'HBble3aIlOHO,l\3"II'.I1IoII"'MHaKTaMH.perJl.3.OPD
Bcrpaua."CHl'uJ)a.UHH
HOUNeH06C1Hue
M llpmw OpaH()8. OC}'UjeCml/JllI/fJUl!lX J(lJ.."(JII(J('tamen/;>-
"'" onepamU6Ho-p03blCKHYIO oellme,l/;>Hocm/;> H/;>IX OKm06. pe-
naMeH7J"(
J 2 3
 npoBO:;::: O: : r=:boO:: nepe- epaJIbHblH
..I1CJ1eHHbJe BeT. 6 HacTOSllllt:ro <D\:llCpaJIbHO- 3aIlOH,,060nc-
TO 3BKOHEI. np0l13BQ.IJ,I1Tb npl1 I1X npOBC.aCHI1I1 paTI'JBHO-
I1:rbSlTl'le npeIlMeTOB, MaTepl1aJ10B 11 cu06we- p03blCKHUti
1-1I1k. , TalCKe npepblBBTb npenOCTBBJIel-1I1e neIlTeJ\bHocrn..
YCJ1yr CBII311 II CJIY4Be B03HI1KH013eHI1I1 l1eno-
cpellCTBeHHOH yrp03bJ )l(113HI1 11 OPOBblO
nl1ua, a TaJOKC yrp03bl rocynapCTlJeHHOH BO-
eHHOH 3KOHOMI1'lBCKOH 11J111 3KO;IOrl1..eCKOH
6C30naCHOCTI1 POCCI1i1CKOi1 <DC.aCpBUI1I1 (n. I
CT.15
OnepaTHHHblM no.apaCJIeHl1eM AMI BblnOJI- 3aKOH YKpal1Hbl
HeHl111 3ana" OPD npH HaJll1'lI1l1 OCHUBaHI1H. ,,06UnepaTIfB-
npenYCMOTpeHHblX CT. 6 3aKoHa. npenocTae- HO-p03bICKHUk
nllCTCSI n aBO neSiTenbHOCTW'
npl1 pellleHl111 3ana.. Opn ynOJlHOMOlJeHHblC 3aKaH Pccny6-
Ha ee oCYlUeCTBJIeHl1e opraHbl I1MelOT npaBo JlI1KH EieJlapycb
OCYWCCTBJIJlTb rJlacHo 11 HernaCHU OPM, ne- 06 onepaTIfD-
pe..l1CJ1eHHble H cr 5 3aKOHa (CT. 14) HO-P03bICKHOH
.aeSlTCJlbHOCT"
npl1 peWeHl111 3ana.. OPlI. ynoJlHOMOlJeHHbie 3alloH Pecny6
HB ee OCYlUeCTBJICHl1e opraHbl I1MCIOT npaBO nl1l1l1 Ka3aXCTaH
npOBOJaJTb rnacHa 11 HerJlBCHO OPM, nepc- 06 onepaTB-
"I1CJIeHHble B CT. 11 3aKoHa, B npeAcnBX CHO- Ho-pa.>blcKHOM
eM KOMneTeHUl111 n...a.....1 CT.8 neIlTe;IbHO'.:III»
np pewCHl111 JalIa'l OPD YJlQ;1HQMO'!rfiHble fia 3aJ<OH
ee ocyI.J!eCIBIIeHl1e opraHbJ I1MelQT npaoo npo- KbJpTbI3CKOH
BOAHTb r_qaCHa 11 HernacHO OPM. B npeAe.rJax Pecny6.rII1KH
CBOI1X noJlHOMO'II1H YCT;U1l..""IBJ1eHHbIX HaCTOSlWM ..060nepaTB-
3aKoHU\I, npOH3BOllHTb np I1X npoaenCHl111 HO-p03bICIIHUk
IfJbl!Te npelIMCT013. r.taTqJIlBJIOB 11 coo6weHI1t:i. neSlTeJlbfiOCTIf"
8 TdJu!<e npepblBaTb npe.aOCTdBJIeHl1e yCJlyr CBJl3H
. CJ1}"1ae B03HI1KHOBeHI.JII HeI1OCpe.ncmeHHOti
)'I1)03bl )l(H3HI1 1'1 1I10p0BblO nl1UB, a TIlJOKe yf1)O-
3b1 rocynapcmeI-1HOi1. BOCHHOi1. 3KOHOtl'I'ICCKOri
11.II11 3KO:IOni'lfCKOM 6e:}(macHIXT Kblprbl3CKoii
PeCnvt1n111111 n. I CT. 18
131

J 2 3
CyfibeKTbl onepaTHHHoH .r:LeSlre.bHOCT 11 HX 3aKoH
IlO![)KHOCTHble J1HlIa npl1 I1CnOJIHeHl'I11 CBOI'IX J]aTlJHHCKOH
CJ1YJKe6HbIX 06H3aHHocrdi: I1II.telQT npaBO PecnyfulHIIH
npOBOlll'ITb OTllpblTbJe " ceKPeTHble Mepo- ..06 onepaTMB--
npHHTlUI onepanlHHOH lleSlTtJ1bHOCTI'I. npellY- HOHllCHTCJ1b-
CMomeHHble CT. 6 HOCTH"
CyG"bCKTbl onepaTlfBHOH .DelljJbHOCTH HMelOT 3aI<OH11I1T08-
npaeo npl1MeHHTb MeTOllb] apn (n. 7 nOCTa- CKoiiPecny6.rm-
HOMel-!HH BC 11I1T61,1 0 DBC!lCHHH B neflcTBlfe 1111 «06 uncpa-
3aKoHl1 ..06 onepaTIJHoJ:j neHTeJ1bHOCT) TrIBHoJ:iAeJI-
TeJ]bHOCT"
npH peweHIU1 3M3'! OPD opraHbl. ynOJlHO- 3aKOH Pecny6-
MO'leHHb!e ee ocyrneCTBJUlTb, HMelOT npaBO 11I1KI1 MOJl1l0B!l
JlpOROID'lTb OPM. nepe'lHCJIeHHb!e (I CT. 6 060nepaTB-
HO-pOJbICKHUti:
lleSlTeJlbHOCTIf»
1,l.Onpoc rpaJKllaH (n. I '.I. I CT_ 6) -
3(lJ(0H06one-
p:ID1B'1O-POJbICK-
HukneSlTeJJb-
HOCTH<>
Onpoc nlm C HX COrJ!aCHSI, HCnOJlb30BaHHe 3aKoH YKpal1Hbl
I1X Ao6pOBOlIbHOfi nm,IOI.l.lH (n. I 'I. I CT 8) ..06onepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHUk
.u:eSlTellbHQCTW>
OrrpocrpaJK1l.3H (n.1 cr.S) 3aKoH Pecny6
l1HKIJ l)eJlapycb
,06Unep,ITIfB-
HO-pOJbICKHU"
.ne.llrenbHOCT"
Onpoc rpmKll3H, llOn>KHOCTHbIX ]IHU, nOJIY4e- 3allOH PecIly6-
I-me 0 HI1X HHcbopMaUl111 (a63. I n 2 CT. II) JlHKI1 K!l3aXCT"H
«060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOti:
IleHTe]lbHUCT"
Onpoc rpa)l(l\!lH (a63. I n. I CT. 7) 33KOH
KbIprbl3CKoj{
Pecny6.rJHIIH
«06unepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHUk
.l{eSlTeJ1bHOCT"
flpoiJo.J:JKelillema(j,114
132

 --=- 2
OnepaTIIIHHbllfonpoc (n. I 1 'I. I cr. 9).
(OnepaTBHbIll onpOC - :JJleMeHT TIlKOll I:Ta-
IUU) OPl1, KJII onepaTBHoe pBccnc.aOBBHlfe.)
Pa3BellblBJTeJIbHblll unpoc (n. 1 nUCTaHUBJle
HHJI BC 11HTBbl U DBe.aeHHH B neHCTBl1e 3a-
KOHa 06 OnCpJTRHoi1 nCSlTCJIbHQCTH>')
Onpoc rp'iJIUIilH (n. a.. CT 6).
npoBcncHlfc 6ecen C lIon03pe&lCMblMI1 C npM-
MeHCHHCM ne-reKTOpoB CHMYJlJlUHH (n. n» CT. 6)
1.2. HaBc.aeHl1c cnpaBOIl (n 2 'l I CT 6)
Hcrpc6oe8HHe. c60p nOKYMeHTOB 11 HaHHblX,
X8pal<TepI13YIOWMX nCJlTCJlbHOCTb npcnnpl1-
JlTHH. Y4pCJKJ1eHHH. opraHlf3auHH. a TalOKC
o6pa3 )l(H3HI'I OrneJIbHblX I'IU, nOllOJpCBae-
MblX B nUllfOTOBKC I.JJm CODepweHHI1 npccT}'-
nJleHHJI. I1CT04HHII 1'1 pa3Mepbl HX nUXOllUB
(n 4'1 I CT. 8
HalJellCHW cnpaROK (n 2 CT 5). Hcrpe6oBa-
HHC. c60p H H3}''1CHIfC nOKYMCHTOB H CB-
HHH. KOTopble xapBKTcpH3YlOT .IIeSlTCJ1bHOCTb
npC1!npHJlTHll, Y4pC>K1!CHHH, oprnHlfaaUHH, a
TBKJKe 06pa3 }l(lJ3HH UT.IICJlbHblX JlHL!., nOJ\03-
pCHaeMblx H nO.aroToBlle HJlH cOBCpWeHlf1J
npcCTynneHIJJI. IJCT04HIJK IJ pa3Mepbl IJX .!to-
XOllOB n_ 7 CT. 14
HaBelIeHHe cnpaBOIl. npOBepKa no )"leTIlM
Y'1pe>K1!eHHH, npelInpl1JlTHH H opraHH3aUHH
(HC3aBHCHMO OT nOll'll'lHCHHOCTH H !bOPM
Co6CTlJeHHOCTIf) (a63 8 n 2 CT 11)
npOBepKa no onepaTHBHblM, KpIfMIfHaJ1I1CTIf-
'ICCIlIfM Y4eTBM H CIfCTCMBM yrOJlOBHOll perH-
cm81U'1IJ a63.17n.lcr.11
133
llpoiJwJJK:elluema6/l.14
3
3HKOH
flaTBIfHclIOH
Pecny6J11f1l1f
06 onepaTB-
HOHllCHTeJlb-
HOCT""
3aKOH11HT08-
CKOH Pecny6.rll1-
1111..06uncpa-
THBHoHHeH-
TCJlbHOCTIf"
3allOH Pecny6-
JlHKIf MOJU{OHB
06 onepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOH
HeJlTCJ1bHOCTIf»
(]>encparrbHblH
JaKoH060ne-
paTl'lflHO-poJblCK-
IiOHlleSlTeJlb-
IiOCTH»
3BIIUH YKpBIfHbl
06 onepaTB-
IiO-pO.>bICKHOtr
neJlTCJ1bHOCT
3allOH Pecny6-
JlIfKH l)eJlapycb
06 oncpaTIfB-
HO_p03bICIIHQH
.IICSlTClIbHOCT»
3allOH Pecny6-
JlIJIIH KaJaxcTaH
06 OnCpaTlfB-
HO-p03bICIlHOit
llCSlTeJlbHOCT»

2
HaBelIetU'lecnpaBOK(n. 2 cr. 7)
HaIJe.aeHHe cnpaBOK (n. @»CT.6)
----.--:3:-06cJJe.rioB<IHl1eIJOMeI.l1ffiJilH,J1I,aHI1H,co-
Upy.>KeHI'IH, }"JaCTKOB MeCTHocrn 11 rpaHcnoPT-
HbIXCpe,llCTB(n.8'1..lcr.6)
06cJJ:e.aUBaHl'le >KHJlbIX 11 npyfl'lx nUMellleHHH C
cornaCI1S1 I1X BJ\Me.l1bL1eB 111U'1 06HrnTenetl: lUlli
BblJlCHeHHSI 06crCIIJrCJIbCT6 COBepWeHHOro 1U111
fOTOBflwerocSi npec1)WIeHHSI (n. 6 'I. I CT 8)
06cJJ:e!lOBaHHe nOMeweHHH. maHI1A, coop)')Ke-
I-U'lH, }l'IaCTKOB MeC1HOCTII 11 lpaHcnopTHblX
cpellCTB(n.!j CT. j)
nma&. /4
3
JaKOH
KblpTb13C];()11
Pecny6nHKI1
«06onepfITBHu-
poJblCKHOHnell-
TeJlbHOCll'I»
3aKoH Pcrny6-
JlI11<HMOJ1l10aa
«06 OnepallIDHO-
POJI,fCKHOH nell-
@eLIeparrbHbl"
3aKoH«06one-
paTi1BHO-po.JbICK-
HOMJ\eSlrenb-
3aKOH ¥KjJal'lHbl
«06onepaTBHu-
poJlfCKHOfJnell-
3aKOH Pecny6-
JIHKH 5eJlapycb
«06onepaTBHu-
poJb(C}(H()f1nell-
,nOCMOlp )KJ1J[blX [JoMemeHI1R, paGo'JHX 11 IfHblX 3aKoH Pecny6-
MeCT (ao3. 15 'I.. 2 CT II) JlHKH KaJaXCTaH
«06onepaTBHu-
poJbIC!<HOJtnell-
06cJJ:e!IOBaHHe nOMeJlIeH1'IA. aDaHl1it coop)?Ke-
I-U'lH, }"IaCTKOO teC1HOCTII 11 lpaHcnopTHblX
cpellCTB(n.!j CT. 7)
134
3aIlOH
KbIprbl3CKoH
Pecn}15nJ.nm
«06onep"TBHo-
pD3bICKHOHJleH-
TCJIbHOC1W>

1 2
OneparnBHb!A OCMOlp (n. 3.. I CT 6)
TaAH()e OCYlUeCTBJ1eHe OCMorpa nOMeWCHI'lS1
(onepaTl1BHbIA OC"IOTp) (n aa.. 'I. I CT. 6)
- 06CJ1CllOB8HI'IC nOMcllicHHH. 3llaHHH, CUopy-
JKeHwfl. }"13CTKOB "teCTHOCT 11 rpaHcnopr-
IibIXCpClJ:CTB(n. "1" CT. 6)
HerJlaCHOe BbIJlBJlem'lC 11 c]:JI1KCaUl'lS1 C.IICllOB
TSI>KKOrO npecryn_el-nm. llOKYMCIHOB 11 llPY-
rl1x npell).teToB, KOTopble MOfYT cnY;KlITb 40-
KaJaTeJ1bCTBaMI1 nonrOTOBKI'I 1'IJ111 COBepwe-
I-mJlTaKOrO nDeCTlrureHl'lSl n 7.. leT 81
nOcewaTb llPyrHe 1'1 JKWlbie nOMCweHI1J/ C
Corl1HCI1J1 HX BJ1a.r:!CJlbUCB 1'I1I1'I 06wraTcJlei1 J]J1S1
BbIJICHeHIHI 06crOSlTt:J1bCTB COBepWCHHoro
J1}111 rOTOBSIwerOCH npeCT)'nJ1eHIHI. II T3KJKC
cooopaTb CBC1lCHIUI 0 npon1l10npaBHoj:j JleSl-
TeJ1bHOcnl n01l03pCl1aCMb!X 111'1Ll. B OTHowe-
HI'II1 KOTOpblX npOBOJU1TCSI npOBcpKa (n. 6
lIICT.8
06Hapy;KeHlfe, HernaCHaJl c]:JI1KCaUHJi Ii 11b-
JlTI'IC CJICllOB npOTI'IBOnpaBHblX neHHHfI, I1X
npeliBapHTCJ1bHOe I'ICCnCllOBaHHJI (a63 13
n 2CT II)
l>ecnpemlTCTBeHHO BU>J\IlTb B JlI060e Bpe).tJl
C)'TOK Ha nppmopl1lO 11 B nOMeweHi1J1 npen-
npl1J1Tl1ll, Y'1pCJK.llfHI1H 11 opraHH3aLll1M (HeJa-
BI1CI1MO or <popM co6cTBeHHo(.'TI1). a H3 Tep-
pl1TOpl11O BOHHCKI.])( ljaCTen 11 npynlx pe)l(I1M-
HblX 06'beKTOB - no COrJlacoBaHl11O C I1X py-
KOOOlllfTt'nJlMH, TOJIbKO C ueJIblO npOBelleHHSI
OPM. npenYCMOTpeHHblX B CT. II HaCTOHwe-
fO 3<1KOHI1 n, "1'I"1j leT 8\
135
npoiJo.l:JICelillema(j,114
3
3<1110H
JIaTlJIfHCIIOH
Pccny6;IHJ<1J
..06onepaTIJB-
HoiineSlTeJlb-
HOCTIJ
3<1KoHJhrroB
CKOH Pecny6JII1-
KI1 ..06 onepa-
TIJBHOnneSl-
Te_bHOCT"
3alloH Pecny6-
nHIIH MOJlllOHa
..06onepI1TIfB-
HO-p03bICJ<HOit
neSlTcnbHOCTW>
3aKoH YKpaHHhl
..06onepaTIfB-
HO-pOJbICKHOH
neSlTeJ[hHOCT"
3<1110H YllpaHHbl
..060nepaTH-
HO-p03blc1lHOit
neSlTe.n:hHOCT"
3<1KOH Pecny6
JlI'IKI1 Ka3<1XCTI1H
..060nepI1TIfB-
HO-p03blc1lHOit
neSlTe.n:bHOCT"
3allOH Pecny6-
JlHKH Ka3<1XCTI1H
..06onepaTB-
HO-pOJbICJ<HOH
ne$lTeJIbHOCT

npoiJon;Jlcel/uema6J/. /4
1 2 3
H np.nycMOTpeHO 38KOH
Kblprbl3CKoit
Pecny6J1I1KI'I
«06onepaTB-
HO-pOJbICKHOH
.neSlTbHOCT",'
T8i1HO npOHI1K8Tb B KB8Jympy, nOMellleHml, 38KOH
TpaHcnoPTHble cpeIlcTBa 1'1 .np)'fl'le ny5J1I'1'IHO- J1aTlJl'litcKoi1
HeIloCTynHble 06'beKTbl c UeJ1blO o6eCne'leHf.ISI Pecny6J1I1KI'I
npOBeJleHml MCpOnpl'lJlHIH OnepaTI'IBHoi1 J!fJl- «06onepaTB-
TeJ1bHOCTI1 (CT 14) HoitJleSlTeJ1b-
HOCHN
BXOlll'ITb B nOMellleHf.ISI npeJlnpmlTl'Iit. )"Ipe- 3aKOHJhITOB-
)I(l!eHI1H . OpraHKJaUI'IJ:I, npOB01UITb KOH- CKOit PecI1)'6J111-
TponbHble npoBepKI1. reXHOlIOrl1'1CCKI'IC 311C- KI'I..060nepa-
nepl1MCHTbl, 1'13blM8Tb M3Tepl1aJ1b1, JlQIIYMeH- H'!BHoi1.neSl-
Tbl, cblpbe 11 o6pa3Ubi npoIlYKUl111 1'1 llPyrl'le TeJ1bHOCTI'I"
06'beKTbl DJlJI I1ccnelluBaHf.ISI 6e3 co06weHI1J1
06 I'IX1'13'bSlTI'II1 (n. ..B"'1. I CT. 6)
1.4. C60p o6paJUOB DJlJ[ cpaeHlneJ1bHoro I1C- (])eJlepailbHblH
cm:.1IOBaHI1J1(n.3'1.ICT.6). 3flKOH«060[]-
pmllBHO-po3blCII-
HoitlleSiTenb-
HOCTW>
C60p u6pa3uuB DJlJI CpaBHI1TeJlbHurO I1ccne- 3aKOH Pecny5-
IlOBaHI'IJI (n 3 CT. 5) JlI1KIIII)elIapYCb
..060nepaTI'IB-
HO-p03bICKHOH
lleJITe;IbHOCT
Or6op np06 11 u6pa3UOB DJlSI I1CCJleJIQBaHI'ISI 3aKOH PecnyG-
(a63. 9 n. 2 CT. II) JII1KI1KaJaXCTaH
«060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOit
lleJ[Tei1bHOCT»
C60p oGpa3lJ,Qe DJlJI. CpaBH(']TeJ1bHurO HCCi1e- 3aKOH
IlOBaH(']JI (n. 3 CT. 7) Kblprbl3CKOH
Pecny6J111111'1
..06onepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOH
llCSlTi1bHOCT»
136

J 2 3
OnepaTHBHoe nonY<JeH(1e 06pa3UOB (n. 4 <]. I 3aKOH
(;16, n ,,, (2) J]aTIJHHcKofi
Pecny5J1I1I1H
«06onepaTHB-
HoitlleSlTeJ1b-
HOCTI1..
1t13'bIiTHe MBTepl1aJ10B, lloKYMeHToB, CblpbSl, 3aKOH11HT08-
06pa31lOB npOllYKUl111 H npyrHx o6beKToe DJlSI CKO Pecny6J111-
I'ICCJ1ellOBaHH1I 6eJ C006WCHlliI 06 If X 1131011- KI1 «06 oncpa-
TI{ (n. ..e"'1.lcT.6) THBHOiilleJI-
TeJ]bHOCT..
C60p M3TepHMOB, o6pa3uoB ill" CpaBHH- 3aKoH Pecny6-
TeJ1bHOro HccneliUBaHlliI (n. ..c»cr 6) nl1KH MOJl1loea
..060nepaTB-
HO-pOJbICKHOH
lleSlTeJlbHOCTIf»
1.5. npoBepo'maSi JaK)'TlKa (n. 4 'l. I CT. 6) -
JaKoH..06ol1e-
paTI1IJHO-pD3blCK-
Hoi'lneffil:J1b-
HOCT"
KOmpOJIbH3H JaKynKa ToeapOB c ueJIblO 3aKOH YKpal1Hbl
BblllBJleHI1J1 npoTHBonp3BHoH lIeSlTeJlbHOCHI ..06onepaTB-
(n.2'1 I CT. 8) HO-p03bICKHOk
lleSlTellbHOCT"
KOHrpOJlbHble JaK)'llKH (n. 4 CT. S) 3aKOH Pecny6-
1111KIIII)eJlapYCb
.Q6 OnepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOk
.ne.llre)]bHOCT..
KOtOJlO!TbHbre J3Kynlll1 (a63. 10 [] 2 CT. II) 3aKOH PecIly6-
IHKI1 Ka3aXCTaI-J
..06onepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOii
IleHTe)]bHOCT"
npOBepO'lHble 33KynKH (n. 4 CT. 7) 3aKOH
KbIprbl3CKoH
Pecny6J1I1I1H
..06onepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOk
.l{eSlTJ1bHOCTG
npoiJo.l:JICelillema(j,114
137

flpodOfiJ/CeHue ma6f1. /4
J 2 3
Km-rrpO.l1bHaSi 3aKynKa TOBapOB (n "f» CT. 6) 3aKOH Pecny6-
JUJKI1 MOJU{OBa
«060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOH
lleSiTC.I1bHOCTIt»
1.15. I1cCJ1eJloBaHlte npeJlMeTOB 11110IlYMeHTOB epa.rrbHb]"
(n 5'J ICT6J 3aKOH«06one-
paTBHO-po3bICK-
HUHlleHTeJlb-
HOCT
I1J)"leHlte JIOK)'UeHTOB 11 naHHbIX, XapaKrepl1- 3aKOH Y Kpal1Hhl
aYJOllIl1X lleSl1t:J1bHOCTb npCanpl1J1T". Y4pC)K- «060nepaTB-
lleHI1H. opraHl.f3aUItH, iI TalOKe U5pa3 >K113HIt HO-pOJbICIlHOit
OU!ClIbHblX J111L!, nQlJ,03jJeBaeJ<.lbIX B nOJlT01OBKe lleJlTC.I1hHOCTH
1'11111 COeepWeHl'I11 npecrynJ1eHItJl, I'ICTO'1HItIl It
p13'>1 bI I'Ixno"Q.1OIJ{n.4'J. 1 CT.S)
I1CC.I1eJ1oBilHl1e npellMeTOB 1'1 nOKYMeHTOB 3aKOH Pecny6-
(n. 5 CT. 5) 1111KI11)eJlapYCb
«060nepaTB-
HO-pOJbICKHOit
neSiTenhHOCT»
npeaBapI1TellbHoe I1CC)]eJ:\OBaHl1e 05HilPYJKeH- 3allOH Pecny6-
HblX, Herl13CHO 3mfJltKCltPOBaHHbiX 1'1 HJDIITblX 1111)(11 Ka3aXCT3H
CJIeJ1UB npOTHBOnpaBHhlX neSlHltti (a53. 13 "I. 2 «06onepaTB-
CT. II) HO-pOJbICKHOH
lleSlTbHOCT»
It1cCJ1eJlOBaHl1e npeJlMeTOB 1'1 nOKYMeHTOB 3aKOH
(n.5CT.7) Khlprbl3CKoA
Pecny6J1I1KI1
«060nepaTB-
HO-pOJbICKHOit
lle.llTe;J.bHOC11l
OnepanlBHoe I1CC.I1eJ10eBHl1e (n. 2 CT. 12. n. 4 3BKOH
'J. 1 CT. 6) naTBl1ikKOH
Pecny6J1ItKI'I
«060nepaTB-
HoitlleSlTeJlb-
HOCTI1..
138

flpodQ/l.1ICf!HUe ma(j/l. /4
1 2 3
HCCJ1eJ:\oBaHlie MHTepliaJIOB, llOKYMeHTOB, 3aKoHJ1IiTOB-
Cblpbll, 06pa3LlOB npOllYIIWUJ Ii JlPyrx 06'b- CKOit Pecny6J11{-
CKTOB (n «(I» 'I. 1 CT 6) Kli ,,06onepa-
TIi(lHOHlIe>\-
Te_bHOCT"
It1cCJ1eJ:\OBaHlie npeliMeTOB IJ 1I0KYMeJiTOB 3allOH Pecny6_
(0 <;g»cT.6J JlI1KIi MOJ1110Ba
«06onepaTIfB-
HO-p03bICKHOH
lleJlTe;IbHOCT»
1.7. Oro)l(J!eCTBJleHl1e JlIi'l.HOCTH (0 ,,_ I -
cT.6J 3aKOH«06 unepa-
_K-
HOHlleHTeJ1b-
HOCTI1»
OrO)l(J!eCTBJleHl1e JlI1'J.HOCTI'I (n. 7 CT. 5) JaKOH Pecny6-
nl1KI'I 6e_Hpycb
«06onepaT(I-
HO-p03bICKHOit
lleSiTenbHOCT"
nOIiCK Ii QTQJlUU:CTBJlCHIiC nli'IHOCTI'I 00 3allOH Pecny6-
npliMeTaM (863. 12 'I. 2 CT II) JIIiKIi Ka3<lXCTHH
«06onepaTIfB-
HO-p03bICIlHOH
llCSlTC;IbHOCTIf»
OrO)l(J!eCTBJleHIiC JIIi'IHOCTI'I (n 7 CT 7) 3aJ<OH
Kblprbl3CKoit
Pecny6J1I1KI'I
«06onepaTB-
HO-pOJbICKHUH
lleSlTeJ1bHOCT
OnepaTMBHoe 06CJ1ellOeaHl1e nl1Lla (n. 5 'I.. I 3HKOH
cr. 6) }]aTBI1HCKOJ:!
Pecny6J1I1KI'I
«06onepaTB-
HOHJ\CSlTeJ1b-
HOCTIi
YCTIlHOBJ1eHMe JI(J'IHOCTIi (n. «h» CT. 6) 3allOH Pecny6-
JlI1I1Ii MOJ1110Ba
«060nepaTI1B-
HO-p03bICIlHOH
lleSlTcnbHOCTIf»
139

npotJol:JlC(!lIuema6A. /4
J 2 3
1.8. Ha6JIfOlleHMe (n 6... I CT. 6) Q:!cllepal1bHbrM
3aKOH«06 ()nepa-
1liBHO-p03bICK-
HoitlleSlTeJ1b-
HOCTM..
BI13YaJIbHoe Ha6J1I011eHMe , ()6meCTBeHHblx 3<1KOH YKpal1Hbl
MeCTax C npm,teHeHMeM $010-. KMHO- 11 BI1- « 06 onepaTB-
_ :nM::::: (O, HO-p03bICKHOit
nCIITC;IbHOCTW>
Ha6.lOllCHI1C (n 6 CT 5) 3<1110H Pecny6-
nl1KM EeJlapycb
«06onepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOit
- ----.=iafilOlleHl1e, B TOM 'I11CJ1e C I1CnOJlbJOBaHI1 neSlTC;lbHOCTW>
3<1110H Pecnyti
eM TeXHl1'reCKI1X cpellCTB (aynl1o- 11 BHlle038- JlMKI1 K8JaXCT8H
nl1cl1. KI1HO$01OCbeMKI1 lJ npyrl1x TeXHI'I- ..o60nepaTB-
'IeCKI'IX cpellCTB), MaTqll'lanOB 11 BeweCTB, He HO-p03bICIlHOit
HaHOCJllUMX apClia >KM3HM, 3110pOllblO lJ OKpy- HeSlTcnbHOCTW>
)K8IOlUetic"..';" (a63. 6 n. 3 CT. II)
OnepaTHBHoe 1-i36J1I011eHlJe (n_ 14 CT. 7) 3aKoH
Kblprbl3CKoit
Pecny6nMIII'I
«06onepaTB-
HO-pO.>bICKHOH
$JlTellbHOCT"
OnepaTIIIBHoe Ha6.lOlleHl'le (cJle)f{l<8) 3aKOH
(n.2'1 I CT. 6,CT.10) J]aTBMitcKoA
Pecny6nl1KI'I
..o60nepaTB-
HoitlleSlTeJ1b-
HOCTM"
J]1'I'IHiUr M TaMHaJi CJ1eJKKa (n 7 nOCT8H08"le- 3<1KOHJ]MTOB-
HIDI BepxoBHoro COBeTa J]IITOBCKOH Pecny6- CKOH Pecny6nl1-
JlI1KI1 0 BBellCHl111 B lleHCTBl1e 3itKOHit 06 KI1«060nepa-
onepaTI1E1HOH JleIJTCJlbHOCTH) TI'IBHOiine>\-
TeJ1bHOCT
BI13YaJIbHoe Ha6nJOlleHI1e (n. «c"cT.6) 3<1KOH Pecnyti-
Ha6J1JOlleHl1e . HOKYMeHTI1poaaHl1e , HO- nl1KI1 MO.lUlOBa
nOJlh30BaHl1eM COBpeMeHHblX MeTOllOB 11 TeX- «06onepaTB-
HI1'1eCKHXCpellcTB(n. ..d..CT.6) HO-p03bICKHOH
neSlTellbHOCT"
140

flpcxJcu.1/cel/ue ma(j/l. /4
---L.L_ 2 3
1.9. KOI-rrpOJUfPYeM n0CT3BKa (n. 13 'I.. I CT. 6) (])eaepal1bHbtA
3aKOH«060nepa-
THHO-p:)3b1CII-
HOW ncmrnb-
HOCTI1..
C ueJIbJO BbHlBJIeHHJI npeIlynpe)K1leHHR H 3aIlOH Pecny6
npeCe'leHI1S1 npeCl)'nJIeHHfI. a Tal0Ke npl1'ii1- JIHKI1 K,naXCTaH
CTHblX K HI1M nHU ucywecTBJlSlTb onepaTI1B- «060nepaTB-
Hblll 1I0HTPOJIb nOCTaBOK TOBapOB. BnteCTB H HO-pOJbICKHOti
HHb!X MaTpH3J1bHblJ( ueHHoc-retl, SlBJISlJOWHX- neSlTJIbHOCT"
CSI npeIlMeTaMH npecTynHoti Ae.llTenbHOCTH H
npeIlHaJHa'leHHblX K npOBOJY. BblB03Y "'"
BB03)' HB TeppHTopHJO Pecny5nHKrI K=-
CTaH (I] «M"'1. ICT8)
KOHTpOJIl1pyeMble I]OCTHBKrI (npOBepO'lHble 3BKOH
1l0CTHIIKIII) (n. 6 CT. 6) Kblprbl3CKof1
Pecny6JII1KH
«060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOti
neJITeJlbHOCTH..
1.10, KOHTpOJlb nO'ITOBblX UTnpaBJIeHI1t1. TeJle 4oellepanbHblj:j
lpaQlHbIX I1I1HblX COO6Il.lfHI1t1 (n. 9 'I. I CT. 6) :JaKOH ..06 one-
pan1BHO-
po3blCKHOW lIeS]-
TenbHOCT"
KOHrpOJlb l]yreM ar60pa no OTneJ1bHbIM npH- 3aIlOH YKpal1Hbl
:nrnKaM TenerpaQ>Hu-n04ToBblX OTnpaBJIeHHj:j ..060nepaTIfB-
(n. 10'1. I CT. 8) HO-p03bICKHOW
lIeSlTeJlbHOCT"
KOHrpOJIb nU'lTOBO TeJIerpa4JHblx umpaBJIe 3aKOH Pecnyti
I-mtl(n. 9 CT. 5) JlHKIf 6enapycb
.Q6 OnepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOti
neSlTJIbHOCT"
KOHrpOJIb nO'ITOBblX ompaeneHI1t1 (a63 2 3aKoH Pecny6-
n.3cT.II) JlHKH KaJaxcTHH
«060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOW
neHTeJlbHOCT"
141

flpcxJo.J.1ICelluema(j/l. /4
Km-rrpO.l1b nU'ITOBbJX oTnpaBJIeHl1t1. Tene- 3aKoH
rpaIJJHblx H HHbJX co06meHHH (n. 9 CT 7) Kblprbl3CKoA
Pcny5J1HIIH
«060nepaTB-
HO-pOJbICIlHOk
llSlT.I1bHOCT
OnepaTHBHblH KOHTpOJ1b Ja KoppecnOKlleH- 3aKoH
LlHeti (n. 9 'I. 1 CT. 6. n. 1 '1.1 CT. 17) }]aTBI1AcKOJ:!
Pccny6.11HIIH
«060nepaTB-
HotineSlTe.l1b-
Cnem:!aJ[bHblA KOHTpOJIb nO'lTOBbIX nOCblJ1UK
(n. 7 nOCTaHOBJIeHItSi BepxOBHOro COBera }]It-
TOBCKOJ:! Pecny6.11HKI1 0 BBeneH1111 B netlcTBl1e
JaKoHa 06 onepaTHBHoH neSlTe.l1bHOCTH)
JaKoHJhrroB-
CKOH Pecny6.11H-
Kit 06 onepa-
THBHOilneJl-
TenbHOCTH
Km-rrpO.l1b nO'lTOebIX OTnpaBJIeHI1J:1 (n. «h. JaKOH PecnyG-
CT. 6) nl1KH MO.l1ll0Ba
«060nepaTB-
HO-pOJbICKHOH
neSlTe.l1bHOCT
1.11. npoc.I1yumBaHl1e Te.l1e4JoHHblx nepero- c])enepa.rlbHwJ:l
BOpaB (n. 10 '( 1 CT. 6) JaKOH «06 one-
paTl'lflHO-JX)3bICK-
HOH:neSlTeJ1b-
HOCTI1
npQC.l1ywltBBHlte Te.l1e4JoHHblx nepo-QBOPQB It 3allOH PecnyG-
I'IHblX neperoBOpoB (n. 12 CT. 5) nl1KH 6enapycb
«060nepaTB-
HO-pOJbICKHOti
neJlTenbHOCT
npoc.l1ywltBBHlte Tene4JoHHb!X nepo-oBopOB It 3aKoH
HHblX neperoBOpoB (a03. 4 n 3 CT. II) Pecnyonl1KH
KaJa1(CT.JH
,06 onepaTB-
HO-pOJbICIlHOk
lleSiTenbHOCTW>
142

npotJol:JlC(!lIuema6A. /4
I 2 3
npOCJlywHBaHHc Te;IC<f10HHb!X nepcrOBopOB 1'1 3aKoH
I'IHblX neoeroBOpoB (n. 10 CT. 7) Kblprbl.lCIWH
Pcny5J1HIII'I
«06onepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOH
.neSlTe;IbHOCT»
OnepaTI'IBHOe npoc.I1ywHBaHHe pa3roBopoB 3aKoH
(n. II OJ I CT. 6, n. JeT 17) J]aTlIHHclloi1
Pecny6J1I1KI'I
«060nepaTB-
Hok.neSlTeJlb-
HocnN
npOCJlYWI1BaHJ.le TJle<pOHHblX nepO-OBopOB 11 3allOH Pecny5-
HHblX neperOBOpOB (n «I»CT 6) nl1KI'I MOJllIOBa
«06onepaTB-
HO-p03!>ICIlHOk
.neJlTeJlbHOCTH
1.12_ CHSlTl'le I1HIlJOPMlIlU1I1 , TeXHI1'1eCKJJX -""
KaHaJIOBCBII3H (n. 11 OJ I CT. 6) 3aKOH«06 unepa-
THBHO-pOJblCK-
Hok.DeSlTCJ1b-
HOCTI1»
CHJlTe I1HIlJOPM3UI'II1 C K3HaJlOB CBII311 (n. 9 3aKOH YKpal1Hbl
OJ. leT 8) «060nepaTII-
HO-pOJbICKHUH
.DSlTeJlbHOCT
CHSlTl'le I1HllJopMaU1111 C TeXHHOJeCKI1X KaHa- 3aKOH Pecnyti
nOBCBJl311(n. 14 CT. 5) nl1KI'I 6e.apycb
«06onepaTI'IB-
HO-p03bICKHOH
.DSlTenbHOCT»
CHSlTl'le I1HIpOpJ.taUHI1 C TCXHH'IeCKI1X KaHa- 3allOH Pecny6-
nOB CBH311. KOMnblOTepHblX CI1CTeM H I1HblX nHKI1 KaJaXCT"H
TCXHH'IeCKHxcpcilCTB (a63. 5 n. JCT. II) «060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOH
.DeSlTeJlbHOCT"
CHSlTl'le I1HllJopMaU1111 C TCXHHOJeCKI1X KaHa- 3aKoH
nUBCBSl3H In. II CT. 7) KbIprbl3CKoH
Pecny5J1I1I1H
«06onepaTB-
HO-pOJ!>ICKHOH
.DeSlTJlbHOCTIf»
143

OnepaTMBHoe n()JJyqeHl'le I'IH$OpMaul'll'l C I'IC-
nOllbJOBaH('Je),t reXHWleCKI'IX CpeJlCTB (n. 10
OJ. 1 CT. 6, n 2CT 17)
CneUMaJlbHb!iI KOH1l'UJIb 3JIeKlpoCBH3M (n. 7
nOCT"HOBJIeHI'IJI BepXOIJHoro COBera 1II1TOB-
cKoii Pecny6l1l'1KI'I 0 BBeJleHl'I1'I B .IleiiCTBl'le
3aKoHa 06 onepaTHBHo .IleUeJlbHUCTI1)
CHSlTe I1H$OpM:lUI1I1 C TeXHI10JeCKHX KaHa-
1I0BCBI!31'1 (n. «T»CT. 7)
- 1.13. OnepaTl1BHblii 3Kcnepl'lMeHT (n. 14 'I. I
cT6)
OnepaTI1HHblM 3KCnepl'lMeHT (n. I SeT. 7)
OnepaTMBHbTii 3KCnepl'lMeHT (n. 7 OJ. 1 C1. 6,
CT. IS)
-.
11.14. """,,",- 6H""'""' (n 12, 1 cr. 6)
144
npoiJrJnJK:el/uema6/l.14
3aKOH
lIaTBI'IHCKOH
Pecny6l1l'1l1('J
,,060nepaTB-
HUW.IleSlTei1b-
3aKoH1II1TOB-
CKOM Pecny6l1l'1-
KI1 ,,06 uncpa-
TMBHOil.lleH-
3aKOH Pecny6-
JII'IKI'I MOJl.QOHB
,,060nepBTB-
HO-p03bICKHOM
llCSlreJlbHOCTH
(])e.QCpaI1bHblH
3BKOH,,06 uncpa-
"'''''.,,''',.,,-
HOMJlCSlTeJlb-
HUCTn<>
3alWH
KbIprbl3CKol1
Pecny6l1l'1l1('J
,,060nepaTH-
HO-p03bICKHUW
lleHreJlbHOCT
3axOH
,,060nepBTB-
HoiiJleJITeJlbHO-
CTH
lIaTBI'IHCKOH
Pecny6l1l'1KI1
(])e.Qepa.r1bHblft
3aKOH«06 onepa-
TIlBHO-po3bICK-
HuilJleSlTeJlb-
HOCTI'I

2
OcymcCTIIJIRTb npOHI1KHOIJCHl1e npecryfl-
HYIO rpynny HenmCl-1uro pa60THI'lI<a onepa-
TBHoro nO!!pa3l1CJlCHI1J1 nl160 COTpyllHI1-
<,ImOllicro C HI1M nl1lia C COXjJ<IHeHI1CM B Ta-
lie nOCT06epHhiX IDlHHbIX. KacalOWI1XCSI 11}(
nI'lIJHOCTI1. YKa3aHHbie nl1ua He Hecyr OTBeT-
CTBeHHOCHJ. eCJ11'1 UHI1 neHCTBOBaJll1 B CO-
CTOHHIUI Heo6xOlll1Moti 06opoHhl Kim Kpafl-
Heft He06XODHM()CTI:! (n 8'1 I CT. 8)
BHellpeHl1e COTpyllHI1KOI! B opraHl130lJaHHbie
npeCTynHble rpynnbl 11 KPI'IMl'II-j()rCHHble 06'b-
CKTbl (n. 10 CT. 5)
BHenpel-me COTpynHI1KOB B npecrynHYIO cpe
1lY (a63. 3 n. 2 CT 11)
OnepaTJJBHm: BHelipCHl1e (n. 13 CT. 7)
OnepaTI'IBHO lIeTeKTI'IBHaH ne.lITeJIbHUCTb C
C:!HKLlIUI npOK}-pop1 npOHI1KH()lJeHI1C (npm.toe
1'lJ1I1 J1CITHlll'lpOB:!HHOC) B npccrylmylO CPCllY.
ycr.mOBJIeHI1C CBJlJI1 C HaX01!SlWl1MI1CSI Ha unc-
paTlJ(lHOM )"1e'J1: JlI'IU3MI1 1'1 co CBSl3aIUiblMi1 C
HI1M'" J!l'IUaMI1 '1.3 CT 16, n. 8 '1:. leT 6)-
ArCHTYPHbIH MeTOl! (n. 7 nOCTaHOli.1CHI1R
BepxOBHoro COBera JII1TOBCKOii Pecny6J1I1KI1
U BBClleHl111 B llellCTBI1C 3aKoHB 06 uncpa-
TBHOiiJ:leSlTeJ1bHOCTI1)
Cn)"<OBoj;j KOH'Tponb (n. 13 CT. 5)
145
npoiJo.l:JICelillema(jA 14
3aKOH YKpal'lHhl
,,06UnepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOH
.neSlTeJ[bHOCT»
3aKOH Pecny6-
J1I1KI'I EeJlapycb
,,060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHUH
J{eSlTe;(bHOCT»
3aKoH Pecny6-
1111)(11 K33<!J(CT3H
,,060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHUk
J{eSlTeJlbHOCTH<'
3aKOH
KbIprbl3CKoH
Pecny6J1l1l1lJ
,,06oncpaTIfB-
HO-pO.>bICKHOH:
.neSiTenbHOCT»
3aKoH
J]aTIJI1HcKoi1
Pecny6J1I1Kl'1
,,060nepaTB-
HOHl!eSlTeJlb-
HOCTW>
3aKOHJ]I1T08-
C)(OH Pecny6J1I1-
KI1 ,,06 unepa-
TI'IBHoiiJ{eSl-
Te!lbHOCT"
3aKoH
Pecny6J1l'1l1lJ
EeJlapycb
,,060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHUk
.neflTeJ[bHOCT»

npl1MeHeHl1e MO):lelIl1 nOBelleHI1J1. I1Ml1n'I-
PYIOIJ.!efi npecTynHYIO JleSlTeJIbHOCTb (11.63. 4
n.lcT.II)
He npeJlYCMOTpeHU
npl1MeHeHl1e MOJJ,C:lIl1 nOBeJ],eHI1S1. I1MI1Trj-
pylOl.l.lf:l1 npeCTynHYIO Jle,lTeJIbHOCTb
npl1MeHeHl1e Jlpyrl'lx. 'JeM YCTPOWCTB8 DJlJI
CHJlTI'IJI I1H!f1opMaUI1I1 C K8HaJ10B CDSlJI1. Tex-
HI1'1CCKI1X cpcnCTB nOJIY'JeHI1S1 I1H!)JopMaUI1I1
n.9'J I CT. 8
npl1MeHeHI1C: CneUI13J1LHLIX TeXHI1'1eCKI1X
t:penCTB(a6J. 7 n. 1 CT. II)
OPM. CDJ8HHbTe C KOHTpoJleM nO'fTOBLIX
OTnp8DJleHHii, TeJlerpai)JHblx 11 I1HLIX co06-
IJ.!CHI1W. npocnYWI1B8HI1CM TeJIC!f10HHLIX ne-
perOElOpOB C nOlll01104eHl'leM K CTaUl10HapHoii
8nn8paType npeLUJpl'lJlTHii, Y4pe)KlleHI1ii 1'1
opraHH3aUI1fi HeJaBHCI1MO OT !)JOpM C06CT-
BeHHOCTl'I, !)JH31'1'1eCKI1X 1'1 IOpHilH'ieCKI'IX JlI1U,
npellOCT"BMIIOIJ.!I1X yc.yr 1'1 t:pe.ilCTBa CBSI.II'I,
npOBO.IDlTCJJ C I1CnOJIL30BaHI1eM onepaniBHO-
'JeXHI1'1eCKI1X cpeilCTB Op.-aHOB H3UHOHaJlbHOJ:i
6e30naCHOCTI1 11 OELl B nOp.!lllKC:, onpene-
JlSleMUM np8BHrenbCTBOM KbIpTbI3CKO Pec-
nv6..QI1KI'I ( 4 CT. 7
npl1MCHeHl1e CJlYA<WHO-P03bICKHbIX co6aK
(11.63. II n lCT 11)
146
npodo.UJo.Y!Nuema5/1 14
3
3alloH Pecny6-
JlI'IIII1 KaJ.BXCTaH
,,060nepaTa-
HO-p03bICKHOif
.ne}lTC:1IbHOCT"
3aKoH
KbIprbl3CKo
Pecny6J1I1Kl'1
,,060nepaTIfB-
HO-pOJbICIlHOk
.neSlTc:nbHOCT"
3aKoHlhnoB-
C)WH Pecny6J1I1-
KI1..060nepa-
THBHoJ:i.ne.ll-
'Je.bHOCTIf"
3aKoH YKpal1Hbl
,,060nepaTB-
HO-pOJLICKHOk
lleSlTC:1ILHOCTIf"
3alloH Pecny6-
Il1KI1 Ka.mxcT"H
,,060nepaTB-
HO-pOJbICKHOfl
lleJJrc:1IbHOCTH
3aKoH
KbTprbl3CKow
Pccny6J1I1Kl'1
,,06unepaTIfB-
HO-p03bICKHUk
lleSlTeJlLHOCT
3aKOH Pecny6-
JlI1KI1 KaJ.BXCTaH
,,06UnepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHU
lleSiTeilLHOCT

J 2 3
He npe.nycMoTpeHO 3aKoH
Kblprbl3CKow
Pcny6J1111111
,,06UnepaTB-
HO-p03bICIlHOICI
.neflTenbHOCT
OcyureCTBJIeHIfC JII'I'IHOrO JlOCMOTpa J3Jlep- 3aKoH
)KaHHblX nl1ti, oCMoTpa 1'1 I'IJhll.Tl'lfi. HaX01U'1- Pecny6J1I1KM
IllI'lXCR npH HI'IX Bernek 1'1 nOKYMcHTOB, MO- KaJaxCT3H
ryllt"x OTHOCI1Ti>CJI K npeCTynHOH JlCSlTeJlbHO- ,,060nepaTB-
CT. II TalGKe llocMoTpa )l(11J1bIX nU).1eureHidl HO-p03bICKHUk
pa60'lltx 11 I1HblX MeeT .o:OCMOTpa TpaHcnopT- lleSiTenbHOCT
HbIXCDell.CTB (a63. IS n. lCT.)1
npOBepKa no yrO;JOHHbIM, KpHMI1H3J1I1CTI1'le- 3aKOH
CKI1M Y'IeTaM 11 CI1CTeMaM yro.l1oBHoH perl'lCT- Pecny6J1I1KI'I
paLlHI'I (363.17 n. 2cT. 11) KaJaxcT3H
,,060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHUk
.neSlTcnbHOCTW'
UCHJypa ooppecIl()!-tiIHUHI'I OC)?K1leHHblX (aoo. I 3aKoH Pecnyti-
"-JcT.II) JII1KH KaJaXCT3H
JJ6 UnepaTB-
HO-P03bICIlHOH
neHTeJ[bHOCT»
He npe.n)t:MOJPeHO 3aKOH
KbIprbl3CKotl:
PeCIJy6J1I'1KH
,,060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHUk
.neSiTClIbHOCTW'
npl'l)'1eHCHl'le MapKJIpOBKI'I CneUHaJ1bHblMI'I 3aKoH Pecny6-
(jUtH'IeCKI1MI1 11 .llPYrMlJ Belllecm 111.111 (n. «0» J]('jKI1 MOJu{OBa
cr. 6) ,,06UnepaTB-
HO-p03bICIlHOH
neJlTenbHOCT
npOCMBTpl1B3HI1e KoppeCnOHJlCHLll111 OCY)K- 38KOH
.neHHblx(n «KO>CT.6) Pecny6J1I1KI'I
MO!lllOBa
«06onepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHUk
1leSlTe!lbH(lCTO>
npoiJo.l:JICelillema(jA 14
147

npoiJoJJJlcel/uema6/l.14
  2 3
OnepaTIIIHH8!1: npoHepK8 (n. 7 nOCTaHUBJIeHI1J1 3aKoHJII1TOB-
BepxoBHoTO COBeT.! JII1TOBCKOM Pecny6J1I1KI1 CKOH Pecny6J1I1-
o BBeJleHl1lJ B JleHCTBlJe 38KOHB 06 onepa- KI1 06 onepa-
TBHOHJleSlTeJ1bHOCTI1) H'IBHojj.u:eSl-
'JeJ1bHOCT&
OnepaTI'IHHU neTeKTHBHaJl nesrreJJbHUCTb 38KOH
KaK OTKpb!'J8S1. TaK 11 6e3 UrJl8WeHI'IJI npl'l- ,,06unep8TB-
HaIJ)1e;KHOCTH K cy6"eKTY Unep8Tl'l8HUW neJl- HOHneJlTeJ1bHU-
TeJ1bHOCTI1 no c60py I'IH!]:>OpM8UI'II'I D KPI'IMI1- CTH&
HWlbHOH cpene. B TOM '11'1CJ1e YCTaHUBJIeHI'ISI JI8TBI'IWCKOH
ClliI3H C JlI'IWIMI'I. Db13blB81Ollil'lMI1 unepiITl'ID- Pecny6J1I'1KI'I
HblH I1HTC ec 'I 1 2 CT. 6)
OnepaTHHHoe p8CCJlellOBaHl'le (n. 1 'I. 1 CT. 6, 3aKoH
n.20) ,,060nep8TB-
HOMllefiTC.I1.bHO-
CTH»
:=:
Onep8TI'IDHoe DblSlCHeHl1e nonY'1eHI1C I'IH- 3aKOH
$OpM8UHI1 OT nl1L1. eCJlI1 ecTb OCHOB8HI1J1 no- JI8TBI1WCKOH
JI8raTb, 'ITO .u:BHH8H I1H!]:>OpMBUI1J1 m,teeTCSI B Pecny6J1I'1Kl'1
pacnopH)I(eHl1l1lIl1ll. HO OHlJ >KeJ18IOT npenoc- ,,060nepaTB-
TaBI1Tb ee HenOCpel1CTBeHHO ('I 4 CT. 9) HOH.u:eSlTeJ1b-
OnepaTHDHue n03H8I-1I'Ie c60p I1H$opM8 38KOH
UI1I'1 U KOHKpeTHblX nl1U8X (n. 3 'I. 3 CT. 9) JI8TBl'lflcKOJ:!
Pecny6J1I1KI'I
,,06unep8TB-
HUWneSlTeJ1b-
HOCTI'I»
n011)"13Tb p83BeJJ,bIB8TClIbHYIO I1H$OpM8UI1IO, 3811011 Yllpal1Hbl
D TOM '1l1cne nYTc'-I npOHI1KHOBeHI1J1 onepa- ,,060nepaTl1B-
TBHO-p03bICIIHuro pa60THlJKa " nOMellle- HO-P03bICKHOH
HI1J1. Tp1lHCnOpTHbie Cpel1CTB8, Ha 3eMeJlbHbie .u:eSlTCJ1bHOCT»
'lN8CTKI1 n. 7'1.1 CT. in
CHI1M8Tb I'IH$OpM8UHI'I , K8HWlOB CBSl3H, 3aKUH YKpal1Hbl
npl'lMeHJlTb npyrl'le TeXHI'I'leCKl1e qJellCTBa nu- ,,06unepaTHB-
JI)"JeHI1J1 I'IH$OpM8UI'II'l (n 9 'J ICT8) HO-p03bICKHUW
.u:CSlTCJlbHOCTI1»
OCYllIeCTBJIJlTb BHaYWlbHoe Ha6J1IOJ\eHlJe 3allUH YKpal1Hhl
o6mecTHeHHhix MeCTaX C npHMeHeHl1eM $0- ,,06onepaTB-
TO-, KHHO-, BHlleoc"eMKI1, OnT'IeCKI1X 11 pa- HO-P03bICKHOH
JUJon 1160 OB n. 11'1. I CT 8 .u:eSlTCJlbHOCT»
148

-+-+-lIOJlHOMO'lIlH nPHMeHb I1Hble. 'leM OPJ\.1,
_1:::..=eoc=:::HHble JJ)lH
1.1. YCTaHaEIJII1IJ.ITb H;} 6e3003,,-e3AHo I'IJlI'I
B03e31lHufj OCHOBe OTHUllleHI1S1 COTpYllHl1l1e-
CTaa C nl'luaMI'I. 1'13bSlBI'IBLlLI1)'111 curnacl1e UI(3-
:iblDaTb cOlleflcTBHe I-Ja IWHIJ!H!leHUI'IWlbHui1
OCHOBe opraHaM. ucyweCTBJlHlOum).1 opn
n 2cr IS
It1cnOJlb30BaTb D;o6poBOnbHYH) nOMOWb 'IHCT-
HblXnl1u(n 1'1. I CT. 8).
YCTaHBBJ1I1BaTb KOH€!>}]):!CHUI1aJ1bHOC COTPYlI-
Hl1'1eCTBO C Jll1l.UlMlJ tili tili'laJI8X 1l06poOOJlb-
HOCUI 0.13'1.1 CT. 8
YcraHaBJU1BaTb Ha 6e':mo':Ne'mHoft K!111 003-
Me31lHOH OCHOBeOTHOrneHI1HcarpYllHl1'leCTBac
Jll1tlaMI'I, I'IJ'lJ1BIfBUlI'IMI1 cornocl'le ot::.)Jbl.BaTb
CO!leHC1BHe Ha KO!$lt1IeHUW1bHoi1 OCHOBe
ODl<lHaM, OCVUIeCTBJlHIOWI'I).t OPil n 2 CT 14
YcraHBOlIl1BaTb Hli 6e3B03Me;mHofi 111160
nJl3THoti OCHOEe OTHOmeHI1H COTpY1lHI1'1eCT-
03 C 1111uaMI1, IB'bSlBlJBlUI1MI1 Corl1BCl1e OK3-
3b!B3Tb C01lellCTBl1e Ha KOHqm1leHLlI1aJ1bHOii
OCHOBe opraHaM. oCYL1LeCTBJ1IIOIl.!I1).t OPil
n. «6"11. I CT. 14\
YCTamlBJJI1BaTb I-Ja 6e3B03Me311Huf1 nll60
nJJaTHOH OCHOBe OTHOllleHI'lJ1 COTpYllHI'I'leCT-
Ba C ]1I'IuaMI1, 1'13'bHBI'IBWI1MI1 COlJ1aCl'Ie 01«1-
3b!BaTb C01leiiCTBl'le Ha KOH4>mICHUl1aJJbHOii
OCHOBe opraH3M, ocyweCT6J1S1IOWHM OPil
863. <j I CT. 14) .
npHl!JleKaTb K npOBeneHHIO Meponpm1T
onepaTHBHO D,e.llTe.llbHOCTI1 KaK UTKPbITO. TaK
11 KOH$I'IlJ,eHLlHaJIbHO OTJJ,e.llbHblX nOJDKHOCT-
I-1blX nl1U, CneUl'laJIHCTOB. 3KcnepTOB B c4Jepe
l-1aYKI1. TeXHI'IKI'I 11 npyrl'lx 06.r1acTSlX, a TIlJOKe
ome;IbHblX JlI1U C I'IX corJlacl'lSi n. 3 CT 28\
YCHIHaBJIl1f1an CDII3H C Ofi'beKTaMI'I onepa-
TflHOW lIeSlTeJIbHOCTI'I (n. «6 <j 2 CT. 6)
149
npoiJo.l:JICelillema(jA 14
cI>eLlepaJIbHbl
JaKoH..06one-
paTI'IBHU-
P03b]CIIHU
lIeSlTe.llbHOCT
3aKoH YKpal1Hbl
..060nepaTB-
HO-P03bICIlHOW
!leSiTellbHOCT
3aKUI-1 Pecny6
11I1KI'I Ee;'Japycb
,,06UnepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHUk
!leSlTC.llbHOCTI'I
3alloH Pccny6-
11111111 KaJaXCTBH
,,060nepaTB-
HO-pO:JbICKHOW
!leSlTe.llbHOCT
3aKOH
Kblprbl3CKow
Pccny6J1I'IKH
,,060nepaTI'IB-
HO-p03bICIlHOW
!leSiTellbHOCTW'
3HKOH
J]aTlJl1ticKoJ:i
Pecny6J1I1KI'I
,,060nepaTB-
HUlIeSlTe.llb-
: -
J]aTl!l1WCIIOH
Pecny6J1111111
,,06onepaTB-
HOJleHTe.llb-
HOCIl1e

YCTaHHW1I1BaTb OTHOWeHI11 C 1111WiMI1, 1l3.8-
WI'IMI'I COrmlCl'le COTPYllHl'I'JaTb Ha KOHl]m-
lleHQI'I8J1bHoti OCH013e opraHBM, ocyweCT13-
nsllOllll1M OP,U (n. «W> <,I. I CT. 13)
2.1, B x01le npOBe1leHI'IJI OPM I1CnOJlb30B8Tb
I'IH$OpMaulfoHHble CI'ICTCMbl ('J 3 CT 6), :>aBO-
llHTb.nenaoneparl1eHoroY'Jera(<,I. I CT. 10)
C03118B8Tb 11 npl'lMeHJlTb BBTOMBTI'IJl'lpoB8H-
HbleCI1CTeMbl (n. 17'1. I CT. 8)
C0311<1B<1Tb 11 I'ICnOJlb30B8Tb I'IH$OpM8UI'IUH
Hble CI1CTeMbI, 06eCne'lI'lBalOllJl1e 13blnOJlHe-
1-1I1eJBlJa<,l OP,U(n. 3 CT. 14)
COO1laBaTb 1'1 I1CnOJIb30BaTb onepaTI1BHble
Y4eTbI, I1H4>OPMHUI'IOHHble CI1CTeMbl, o6ecne-
'JI'IB<1lOllIl'Ie BblnOJlHeHl'le JBlJa'l OP,U (n «13"
'I I CT. 8)
B XOlle npOBcllcHIUI OPM I1CnOllb30BaTb 111'1-
$OpM8UI10HHble CI1CTCMbl, 8 T810Ke 38BOllI'lTb
lleJlaOllepaTBHorOY4eTIl('1. I CT. 13)
COJlIallaTb 1'1 I1CnOJlbJOllaTb I1H$OpMBUI'IOH-
Hble CI1CTeMbl 11 TeXHI1'1eCKl'le cpe.ncnn WJI
npOBelIeHI'IJI 3TI'IX MepOnpl1.11TI'IH 1'1 I)JI'IKCl1pO-
BaHI-IJII'IH$opMau('j) (n. 2'1. I CT. 28)
BecTI'I Onep8TI'IBHblfl }"JeT npo('jcwecTB('jfj.
$aKTOB, IlpeJJ.MeTOB, Jlpyrl1x ('jCTQ'lHI1KOB ('jH-
$OpM8UI1I1. 1)J1131'1'1eCKI1X 1'1 IOpltlll1<,1eCKI1X JlI'IU
(n «11" 'J 2 CT. 6)
150
npoiJo.l:JICelillema(jA 14
3
3alloH Pecny6-
JlI1KI'I MOJlllOBa
,,060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHUfI
lleSlTe,-IbHOCTW'
tDeJ\epa.1bHbIH
33KoH,,06one-
paTlfeHo-po3bICK-
HOHlIeSlTI:JIb-
3aKOH YKpal1Hbl
«06onepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHUH
lleSlTeJlbHOCTW>
3aKoH Pecny6-
111'1K(11)ellBPycb
,,06UnepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHUH
lle.llTeJIbHOCT
3allOH Pecny6-
JII1KI1 Ka3BXCTaH
,,060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOH
lleSlTeJlbHOCT
3aKOH
KbIprbl3CKofl
Peclly6l1l'1l1l1
.Q6 UnepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHUH
lle.llreJlbHOCT"
3aKOH
,,06 onepaTB-
HOHlleSlTeJlbHU-
naTBl'lflcKOfl
Pecn 6nI'lKI1
3<1KOHnI1T013-
CKOH Pecny6l1l'1-
KI1«06unepa-
HJDHOHneSl-
JellbHOCT"

J 2 3
C03.uaBaTb 1'1 HCnOJlb30BaTb Onepan'IDHbTe 3aKuH Pecnyti-
Y4bl, I1H$op}.taLlI10HHbI CI'ICT),tbl, o6eclle- JUlIII1 MOJl.QOB3
<,II1BalO1l1l1e BblnOJlHeHl1e JaJIa'l OPil (n. <lC» ,,060nepaTB-
., ICT,I3) HO-pOJbICKHUk
.ueSlTellbHOCT»
2.3. J1cnOJlbJOBaTb B xone npOBcneHI'IJI OPM -
flU .norOlJOpy 11)]1'1 yCTHOMY cur.naUleHI1IO CJIy- 33.KOH,,060ne-
)Ke5Hble nUMeIUeHI1.11. I'IMywecTBo npellnpl'l- paTBHO-po3bICK-
JlTl'lfi. )"Jpe>KlletH:lti, Oprmi1'lJ3UI'IW, fIOl'IHCKI1X HOWl!eSlTeJ]b-
lIacTdL a TJl0Ke JKH.llble 1'1 HeJKH.llbJe nUMe- HOCTI1
IUeHI1S1. TpaHcnOPTHbre cpellCTBa 11 mJOe
11M meCTBO<laClHblXl1IU.\ n. 3 'I. I CT. 15
It1cnOJlbJOBBTb c COrJl3Cl'Ili .3.!lMl1fil'lclpaul'll'l 3aKoH YKpal1Hbl
clIYJKe6Hbie nOMemeHI1J1. TpaHcnOpTHble cpeJl- ..06 onepaTl1B-
cTI!a 1'1 npyroe I1MYlUecTBO npennpl1S1THw. Y'I- HO-pOJbICKHUk
)I(.[leHI1", opraHIQBUI1i1, a T(11)1(e C comacl1J1 lleSlTellbHOCT»
JII1Ll - JKJ1JUIU{e. IIPyrl1e nO),temeHI1J1, rpaHc-
nOjJTHbre cpencTB3 1'1 npl'lHallJ1e)Kawee ""
m,,'"v-rllecTBO n. 15"1. I cr. 8
It1cnOJlbJOBaTb B XOlle npOBelleHI'IJI OPM 110 3aKoH Pecny6-
.norolJop) 11.11 YCTHOMY COmaWeHl11O cJly- JlI1KIJ I)CJlapycb
)Ke6Hble nUMeIUCHI1.11. l'IMYWCCTBO npennpH- JJ6 UnepaTB-
JlTHW. )"Jpe)KJJeHl'I£'I, OpraHI'IJaUH£1, BOI'IHCKI'IX HO-pOJbICKI'IO£'l
lmcTe. a T310Ke )KH.llbJe 1'1 HCJKH.llbJe nUMe- ne.llTCJ[bHOCTH
=T::t:H:U e:aI4: I1HOe
It1cnOJlb30[laTb B XOlle npO[lCnCHl'IJi OPM no 3aKoH
J{oroBOpy 11.11 YCTHOMY comaWCHl11O CJlY- Pecny6J1111111
)KefjHblc nOMeIUeHI'IJI, Tp3HcnupTHbTC 11 I1HbJe K.uaXCTaH
TeXHl1l1CCKl1e CpellCTBa, I1MYWCCTBO npelinpH- ,,060nepaTII-
JlTI1H_ Y4pe)KJJCHl1ii, opr3HI133L!11fi, BOI1HCKI1X HO-p03bICKHOH
"!acTe. a T3KJKe )K11J1bIC 11 HeJKI1J1bIC nOMC- J{eSlTeJ[bHOCT
weHI1S1. TpaHcnopTHhle cpC!lCTB8 11 I1Hoe
I1MywecTBo rpaJK.!l8H C B03MeIUeHI'ICM YIUep6a
lIJIaLleJlblUlM II CJ1)"Jae ero HBHeCCHI1J1, a Tall-
)Ke pacxOlloe 3a ClIeT opral-Joe, ocyIUecTB-
JlJlIOWI'IX OPilin "r II I CT 81 -
HCnOJIh30IJaTb II xone npOlJellCHI1J1 OPM no 3aKOH
,IloroBOp)' "'" YCTHOMY COrJJaWCHl'l1O CJlY- KbIprbl3CKOW
)Ke6Hhle nOMCweHI1R, I1MyweCTBO npeilnpH- Pccny6J1111111
JlTfi. Y'Ipe)KJJeHl'Ifi, opr3HI133UHfi, BOI'IHCKHX ,,06oncpaTlI-
lIacrefi. a T8KJKC )!(H.llhIC 11 HC>I<H.llhIC nOMe- HO-pOJbICIlHO
IUCHI1JI. Tp"HcnOjJTHblC cpellCTBa 11 I1HOe neRTeJ[hHOCT
l'ItfVllleCTBO'J8CTHbJxJlI1U 003 In 4CT 18)
npodo.UJ<Y!Nuema5/1 14
151

I 2 3
no tlJalfMHOI'I 1I0rOHopCHHOCTI'I IfCnO!1b10BaTb 3axOH
W1J1 npOBClleHl'IJi Meponpl'lJlTIfH onCpanlElHOH J1aTBI'IHClIoA
.ncrreJ1bHUCnJ nOMCUlCHI1S1, I'IM)'WCCTIJO, npc!l- Pccny6J1I'1Kl'1
MeTbI JlP)'fHII: opraHI'IJaUl'lii 1'1 npcnnpl'lJlTI'IH. a ,,06UnepaTB-
TIlIOKC }l{HJ]bTe 11 npyre nOMeIUeHI'IJI. lpaHC- HUHlleSlTeJ1b-
nUjJTHblC cpe.IlCTBi\ 1'1 llpyryJO C05CTBCHHOCTb HVCTW>
'HU n.4"1. I CT. 28
I1cnoJIb'30l1'ITb 11 XQJJ,e npoBeneHml aPM nu 31.KOH Pecnyti-
.nomBopy !1JI('] yCTHOMY COrnarneHl11O CJ1}'}I(c6- n('jKI1 MOJu{OBa
Hbre nOMCmeHI1S1. I'IMyme<:TBO npellnplUlTIfH, ,,06onepaTB-
Y4pe)l(i\eHI1H, opraHnal!l1f1. BOI1HCKIfX 'IacTcii, HO-P03bICIlHOH
a TBlI)I(e IKWlb1e 11 He)l(l{,ble nOtellleHI1J1, lleSiTenbHOCT
!p;'e n C':;\ T.l'lr3e I'I'1YWecTI'O
2A. I1CrTOJlb30B3Tb B ueJl.llx KOHCnl1paul'l1'l (J.IeliepaJIbHblA
IloKYMeHTbl J.alUl'IlJIpoBblBalOIUl1e JlI1'lHUCTb 3aKOH ,,06 une-
llOJDKHOCTHbIX JU'IU, BellUMCTBeHHYIO npI1HM- paTI'IBHU-
ne)l(H()CTb npellnpI'lJlTtI:. Y'lpe)l(1!eHldi, opra- p03blCKHUA
HIf..!aL!ldi, nOllPB3.lleneHI1H. nOMemeHI1H H lIeJlTe.llbHOCTH
rpaHcnopTHblX cpe.l\CTB opraHoH. oCYlllecTB-
nJllOllll1X opn. a TBlOKe l1i1<1HOCTb rpa)l(Jl8H,
OK!I3blBBlOllIHX 11M coaefkTBl1e HlI IIOHI]1(J){CH-
L111a.bHOfi OCHOBe n.4'1. I CT. 15
It1cnOJlb30B3Tb 1l0K)'MCfiTbl, J.3WI1I]1POBb1B31O- 33110"1 Yllp311Hbi
WI1C Jll1'1HOCTb I.]JlI.] BCllOMCTIJCHHYIO npI1HM- ,,060ncpaTIfB-
nC;KHOCTb p360THI1KOB, nOMcwcHIfH I.] Tp3HC- HO-p03bICKHUk
nupTHblx cpcncTB oncparlfBHblx nOllP33.11CJIC- lleSlTeJIbHOCT
HH' n. 16'1. I CT. 8
It1cnOJIb30BaTb B UCJI.IIX KOHCnl1p3Ulfl1 llUKY 3aKoH Pecny5-
MCHTbI, 33WI141pOBbIB31OWl1e JlI1'1HOCTb ll()J])K- JlI1KI'I EeJlapycb
HUCTHblX nI'IU. BellOMCTBeHH}'lO npI1Harme;K- ,,060nepaTB-
HOCTb npennpl1J1TI1H, Y'1pe)l(,!!eHI1H. upraHl13a- HO-p03bICKHOH
UI1H, n01lP3:w,e.eHI1H. nOMeweHlJH 11 TpaHC- .l{eSlTeJlbHOCT
JlOPTHbiX cpC!lCTB opr3HOB. OCYWCCTBJlJlIOIl.!lJX
OPil, a T311;Ke JllJ'IHOCTb rp3;KJJ,aH. COTJI}'llHlJ-
Hxo:::eMrn or:11 "13 KOH$l1l1CHUI1-
It1cnOJlb30B3Tb nOK)'MeHTbI, 3aWI14JpoBbJDalO- 3aKOH
IUI1C numKHUCTHbiX nl1U. BellOMCTBeHHYIO I-'CCJly6J1I1Kl'1
npI1HallJlC;KHUCTb JlO11Pa311C.CHI1H. OpraHl13a- Ka3a1(CraH
UI1H, JlUMeIllCHI1H I.] rpaHcnoprHbIX cpenCTB ,,060nepaTB-
opraHOB. OCYIJ.!CCTBJIIIOIl.!lJX OPil. , TalOKe HO-pO.>bICKHOH
1II1'1HOCTb rpa)l(Jl8H, COTJI}'llHl1'1BIOWI1X C 3TI1- .l{eSlTeJ1bHOCT"
MI1 opraHBMI1 HB KOH€!>I1.I:(eHL[I18J1bHOH OCHOBe
n..,u»'1.lcT.8
npoiJrHJJlcel/uema6/l.14
152

HCnOJlb30BaTb B ueJlJlX KOHCn(']pau(']('] JlOIIY-
MeHTbI, 3aWI14JpoBblBalOWl1e JlI1'1HOCTb ll()J])K-
HUCTHblX J1I'ILl. BellOMCTBeHHYJO npI'lHarlJIe)K-
HOCTb npellnpl'lJlTI'IH, Y'1pe)l(lleHI'IH. opraHl'I3a-
UI'IH, nOlljX1:1lleJleHI'IH. nOMemeHHH 1'1 TpaHC-
nUpTHblX CpellCTB UpraHOB. ucywecTBJlJllOUlI1X
OPil, a Tall)Ke 11WlHOCTb rpa)f(lIDH. OKa3b1-
BalO1LlI'IX 1'111.1 COileHCTBl'le HH KOt$I'IJIeHUl1aJ1b-
HUH UCHoae (a63. I n. 5 CT. 18)
It1JrOTOfIJIJlTb 11 I'ICnOJlbJOIlaTb JIOKYMeHTbl 1'1
I!PYre cpeilCTBa M3CKrIpOBKI1 lL'IH COKpbITJI
neflerellTBQbHUfI nprIHarlJIe)KHUCTrI OTlIeJlbHblX
crpyKl)'pHbIX nonpa:weJleHl'lfI, CyQbeKTOB une-
pBTI'IBHOfi ileSlTeJlbHOCTH. HX CJI)')Ke6HbIX no-
MemeHI'IH ('j rpaHcnopTHblX cpellCTB. a TIlJOKe
l'I1leHTH4JI'IKaul'Il'I I'IX C 3TI'IMI1 upraHaM('j Ha
KOHmruJcHUI'la,lbHOii OCHO[lC (n S 'I 1 CT 28)
HCnOJlbJOB"Tb perHCTpalli'IUHHble H OTnWlli-
TeJlbHble JHaKI'I npellnpl'lJlTI'IH, Y"Ipe)l(lleHI'IH 1'1
OpraHI1JBUI1H ([I «11» 'I. I CT. 6)
It1cnOJlb30BBTb B UCJlJlX KOHCn11pau1'I1'I 1l01lY-
MeHTbI, 3aWI14Jpollblll"1011\(\e J11'1'1HOCTb 1l0Jl)K-
HOCTHblX JlI'IU. eellOMCTBeHHYIO npI'lHarlJIe)K-
HUCTb nOllpa31leJIeHl'lw. OpraHI1JaUl'lw. nUMe-
JLleHI1H }I TpaHcnOpTHblX cpellCTB oprBHOB,
OCYJLleCTfIJIHlOllIl'IX OPil, a TBlOKe 111'111, co-
TpYlIHwmJOJLlI'IX C 3THMI'I OpraHaMI'I HB KOH-
<!JruJeHlli'la,lbHUW OCHUBe (n «e.. 'I. I CT 13)
Co.w,auaTb B ycTdHOllJleHHOM 3aKOHOlurrenbCT-
BOM nopSlllKe npellnpl1S1TI'I.II. Y'lpe)l(lleHI1S1, up-
rBHI'IJaL11'111 11 nonpa:11lCQCHI'ISI, Hc061(()1!HMble
lIJISi peWeHI'IJI JBJ!a'l. npeilYCMOlpeHHb!X Q)elle-
paIIbHblM 3aKOHOM 06 OPil (n. 5 'J. 1 CT. 15)
C031laBaTb B uenJlx KOHCnl'lpaWH1 npeilnpH-
JlTI1J1. opraHI'I31U..!ll1'l (n. 16 'I. 1 CT. 8)
153
npoiJrJnJK:el/uema6/l.14
38KOH
KbIprbl3CKofl
Pecny6J1I1KI'I
«060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOH
neSlTeJlbHOCT»
3aKOH
«060nep3TB-
HOHlIeHTeJlbHU-
CTI'I»
J1anu'lficlloH
Pecny6J1I'1KI'I
3aKOH11I'1T08-
CKofl Pecny6J111-
KI'I ..06 onepa-
TrIBHOiineSl-
TeJlbHOCTH»
3aKoH Pecny6-
11(']111'1 MOJlilOBa
«060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHUW
lIeSiTenbHOCT"
pMbHblH
3BKoH«06one-
paTI'IBHO-poJblCK-
HOHneJlTeJlb-
HOCTI1»
3alloH YKpa('jHbl
«060nepaTB-
HO-pOJbICKHUH
lIe.llTeJlbHOCT»

C03JlilBaTh B uelIJlX 1I0HCmtpaL!l1I111eretUlItpO-
BaHHble npennpl1J1TItJl. Y4pe;t(LleHI1H It Opr3-
HI133L!1111 (n SCT 14)
C031l3B3Tb KOHCnltpaTI'IBHble npellnpl'lJlTI'IJI.
opr3HI133UI1I1(n. 6ll 'J 1 CT 8)
C03JJ.3B3Tb KOHcnltp3TI1BHble npellnpl1HTIt.SI 11
opraHmaUlt1t (n. 12 CT. 7)
OCHOBh!B3Tb .DJIJI npltllphlTItJl npellI1pItJlTI'IJI.
OpraH(l3aUI1I1 11 Y'1pe}l(Jl,fHI1J1. (lCnOlIb30BaTb
perl'lCTpaUItOHHble 1I0KYMeHTbl. a TIllCKe JH3-
KI1 (IX pa3J1J1<IlUI (on03HaHI1J1) C ueJlblO 06ec-
ne'leHItJl onepanlBHoii AeJITelIhHOCTI1 It COJ-
AaHI1J1 6.rraronpl1J1THblX .DJIJI Hee YCJ10EllJii
(n. 6...1 CT. 28)
Y"pe;t(Ll3Tb npellnpl1S1TIt.SI. Y4pe}l(l\eHI1J1 11 op-
raHlt3aUl'llt, ()oeCne'IItB3101Ul1e onepaTI1BHYIO
lIeSiTelIbHOCTb 11 C03IW.1Oll!1te .DJIJI Hee 6.rmro-
npl'lJlTHble YCJlOBItJl. nOJlb30BaTbCJI perl1CTpa-
L[I10HHblMI1 11 OTl1lt'1l1TelIbHblM(I 3H3KaMI1-
npellnpmlTl1. Y'lpe;t(LleHIt It opraHIt.!aUI1i1
(n "3" ,<, 2CT 6)
2.6. HMeTb rl1acHblx It Her113CHbiX ll!TarHblX
pa60THltlloB(n 12,< 2CT 8)
2.7. n011y'13Tb OT IOpl1Jll1'JeCKI1X 11 4JmlJ'Je-
CIlItX 11ltU 6ecnlIaTHo It11It Ja B03Harpa;t(LleHlte
I1H4JopMal!1'I1O 0 rOTOBSlll!I1XCJI 111I11 COBepll!eH-
HblX npecl)'Il1leHI1S1X 11 yrp03e 6e30nacHocTIt
o6wecna 11 rocyuapCTEl3 (n 7'J 1 CT. 6)
154
llpodoflJICeHue ma6f1. 14
3allOH Pecny6-
11ltKI1 Eellapycb
,,060nepaTa-
HO-p03bICKHO
lIeSlTeJlbHOCTIt"
3aKoH Pecny6
11111111 Ka3aXCT3H
,,060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICIIHO
neHTeJlbHOCTIII"
3aKOH
KbIprbl3CKo
Pecny6lIltlll1
,,060nepaTHB-
HO-p03bICKHO
.l{eSlTeJlbHOCT"
3aI<OH
JhITlJl1iicI<oii
Pecny6lIltKI1
,,060nepaTB-
HOlIeSlTeJlb-
3aI<OHJhrroB-
cKoii Pecny6lIl1-
1111 ..060nepa-
TI1BHOilneSl-
TbH()CT",>
.:Sa
,,060nepaTltB-
HO-p03bICKHOil
AeSiTCilbHOCTIt"
3alloH YKpa(lHhl
,,06oneparltB-
HO-p03bICKHOfi
neSlTeJlbHOCT"

llpoiJonJK:elluema6/l.14
J 2 3
n()J]Y'W,Tb 0' 1O)JH!l..eCKI1X " 1J!11311'leCKI1X 3aKoH Pecny6
nlm tiecruJaTHO I'Inl1 Ja B03HarpaJlUleHI1e I1H- RI1KH Eenapycb
IJ!OPMHLlHIO 0 TOTOBHLlIIIIXCSI WU'I COBeprneH- ,,060nepaTa-
liblX npeCTynJleHI1S1x 11 yrpo.>e 6e30nacHocTI1 liO-pO.>bICKHOH
u\'iLllecTBB 11 rocynapcrna (n. 8 CT. 14) lleSlTeJIbHOCT»
n()J])"1BTb 6ea1103Me:ulHO " IicnOJlh30BBTb 3allOH Pecny6-
I'IMelO11lY1O 3Ha'leHl1e """ peWeHI1H 3a.na'l RI'IKI1 KBJaXCT"H
OPl! I'IHl]:IopMaUl'l1O npyrx MI1HI1C-repCTB, ,,060nepaTB-
Be.llOMCTl1, npellnpl1HTI1H. }"IPf:)IUlCHI'IH 11 op- HO-p03bICKHOH
TaHli3UlliH HCJaBIiCIiMO OT 1J!00M c06CTBeH- .l{eSlTellbHOCT»
HUCTI1 (CT 8)
He npel1YCMOTpeHO 3BKOH
Kblprbl3CKoH
Pecny6nl1KI'I
,,060nepBTB-
HO-p03bICIlHOH
lleJITenbHO<.11t»
2.8. npliMCHHTb CpenCTBa 1J!113H'ieCKOTO BOJ- 3aKoH YKpal1Hbl
.l{eHCTBI1H, CneLlllliJIbHble cpellCTBH " orHe- ,,060nepaTB-
crpeJIbHOe 0pY)Kl1e no OCHOIJaHIiSiM 11 e no- HO-pO.>bICKHOH
pIIIKe, YCTBHOB.'JeHHbIMI1 3BKOHBMI1" 0 MI1J1I1- lleSlTeJIbHOCT»
UIUI, CITy",&: HHLlIiOHl1J1bHOH 6e30nacHOCTIII.
nOrpBHIi'JHblX BOHCKaX, YnpaBJleHlJli oxpaHbl
BbIClUl1X nOJ[)KHOCTHblX JlI1U YKpal1Hbl (n. IB
'I. leT 8)
2.9. Hcn()J]b30B.1Tb nOMOlllb nOJDKHOCTHblX J11'1U 3allOH Pecny6-
1'1 CneUHaJll1CTOB, u\'inaaBIOIllHx HeOO\OlIl1MblMI1 RI1KI1 KaJaXCT"H
H3)"IHo-TC'aIWleCKHMI1 I1nlJ IiHb!MIi CnCLlaJlb- ,,060nepaTHB-
HblMIi n03HHHI1S1MIi(n.«e»'J. 1 er.8) HO-p03bICKHOH
lleHTe;IbHOCT»
!lon>KHOCTHble n" OpraHOl1, ocyweCT(I- 3aKoH
J1J1l0WI1X OPIt. pewalOT " Ja.na'JlJ OyreM KblpTbI3CKOH
RI1'JHOro Y'lacTI1H e OpraH1'I3aLll111 11 npOBe.ne- Pecny6nliKI1
HI1I1 OPM, IicnOJlb3YH nOMOWb nOJl)!(HOCTHbIX ,,060nepaTB-
RI'IU 1'1 CneLlHaJlI1CTOB. 06JIalIalOWliX HaY4HbI- HO-p03bICIlHOH
M(I. TeXHIi'JeCKI1MI1 Ii .npyrl1MIi cneLW1aJ1bHbI- .l{eSlTellbHOCT
M" n03HBHI1HMI1. a TBl0Ke cOlleHcTBHe 0'-
neJIbHblX rpa)K!!BH C I1X COrJlacl1H Ha rJlacHoH
11 HerJ1acHoiiocHOBe ('J. 6 CT. 16)
155

1 2 3
2.10. npl'lBJIeK:!Tb no comaCOBaHmo C I\PY- 3aKoH
fl1MI1 opraH3).tI1. l'I"lelOlUl1MI'I npano ocywc- Pccny6J1I1K1'1
CTBJlet'll1J1 OPll H3 Tppl1TOpl1l1 Pecny6J1IfKI1 KaJa1(CT,:u-J
KaJaXCTaH. CI1J1bl 11 cpencma 3TI1" opraHOB ,,06onepaTIfB-
..,'" npOBC.llCHI1J1 OTlItJlbHblX MepOnpl1J1TI:IJI HO-p03bICKHO
n.«J»'l.ICT8 lleSiTenbHOCT"
He npenYCMOTpeHO 3aKoH
KbIprbl3CKoti
Pecny6J1I1KI'I
,,060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOti
neSlTeJ1bHOCT"
2.11. npOBClleHHe onepaultl1 no 3aXIJ3ry BOO- 3allOH YllpaHHbl
pyJKeHHb!X npe<T}TIHI1110B. npeCC'lCHl1e TSI}I(- ,,06onepaTIfB-
npeCT)'nlleHl1ti, pa3BellbIBaTeJlbHQ-nOJl- HO-p03bICKHO
pblBHOH JleSlTeJ1bHOCTH cneUCJ1¥)!(6 I1HOCTjJaH- lleSiTenbHOCT"
;: '1'p;::. fraHI13aL!l1li It OTJ!fJlbHbIX
npOBelleHl1e onepaW.JJj no 3aXBa1Y BOopy 3aKoH Pecny6
)KeHHbIX npecTynHl'IKoB (003. 16 n. 5 CT. II) nlu<I1KaJ.axcHIH
,,06onepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOk
2]2_ HCSlTCilbHOCTI1"
n peCJ1eLlOBD. HHe -lmua-:-COeepw3101lIcro 3aKOH Pccny6-
cOBepUU'IBlllerO npecT)'nJleH(1e, . om JIl1l1ltKaJ.aXCTal::l
33J1epJK3HI1e (863.16 n SCT.II) ,,060nepaTB-
HO-p03bICKHOfi
.!\eJneJ]bHOCT
He npenYCMOTpeHO 3aKoH
Kblprb[3CKO
Pecny6J1I1KI'I
,,060nepaTI'ID-
HO-pOJbICIlHOit
neSiTenbHOCTO
OcymeCTBJUITb npeeeHTI1BHOe 33JlepJKaHl1e 3aKOHl1I1TOB-
nl1ua (CT. E npI1M.) eKOH Pecny6J1I1-
KI1..06onepa-
TI'IBHOHneJiI-
-I :'.13. Y"croo.", . opo",p.o ."..".o- Te.bHOCTO
3aKOH YKpa('JHhl
X03S1CTBeHojj nelTeJ\hH()C:1'I npe!lnpI1Ji1TI1. ,,060nep:JTB-
Y'1pe)KjJeHI1I1, opraH113aUI1H 11 OUleJlbHblX HO-p03bICKHOH
no" neSlTeJ\hHOCTO
npoiJo.l:JICelillema(j,114
156

OKOH'IaHlIema611 14
J 2 3
npl1HI1},tarb Y4aCn'Ie B npoBepKe $I1HaHCOBo- 3alloH Pecny6-
X()3S1CTBeHHO lIeSlTeJlbHOCTIf npelInpI1S1TIf. J1I{KI'I EeJlapycb
y4pe)!(,J:leHl{fI. opraHI1JaUl{fI 11 OT.ueJlbHbIX JlI1U ,,060nepaTB-
(n. 6 cr. 14) HO-p03bICKHOfi
lIeSlTeJlbHOCTW>
He npellYCMOTpeHO 3aKoH
KblprbrJCKo
Pecny6J1!1KI'I
,,06onepaTIfB-
HO-pO.>bICKHOfi
lIeSlTeJIbHOCT»
npalla opraHOB. ocywecTBJIJIIOI OP.D:. npen;ycMaTJlllBlllOT cJlelQ'lO-
lltHeCTaTbH:JaKOH08,
CTaTb!1 6. 15 (])ellepallbHoro 3aKOHa ,,06 OnepaTI'IBHO-p03bJCKHOfi
.ueHTeJ1bHOCTI'I»
CraTbSI g 3aI<mJa YJ<paI'lHbl .,()6 onepm'!BIJO-po3blCKHOtI: .neSl'reJIbHOCTI'I».
CTaTb!1 5. 14 "3aKoHa Pecny5J1!1K!1 EeJlapycb ..06 OnepaT!1BHO-
pOab!CIIHofi .u:eSlTeJlbHOCTW'.
CTarb!1 8, II 3aKoHa Pecny5J1!11111 Ka3axcraH ,06 onepaTHBHu-
p03bICIlHofl.lleHTeJlbHocTH»
CTaTbH 18 3aKOHa KbrprblJCKOfi Pecny6JII1K!1 ...06 onepaTHBHo-
pOJbICK}JO.uCSlTCJlbHOCTW'
CTarbl1 6-17 P2Yl. I 3aKOH2 J]arnuficKoJ:i Pecny6J1I1KI1 ..06onepa-
THBHoHlIeSlTeJlbHOcTW>
CT3TbSl 6 32KOH2 JlI{TOBCKOii Pecny6JI('jKI1 ,,06 onepaTHBHoii !leSl-
TeJIbHUCT!1".
CTarbl{ 6. 13 3aKOHa Pecny6J1I{KIJ MOJ1llOBa ..06 onepaTIJBHO-
p03blCKHOfi Ae.II.TeJlbHOCTIJ».

Ta6J1I1ua 15
3aIlOHQIJ,3Tf'J1I>I1OI' onp&:.ItI'.net1IIe npHI1I!HnOBOPll
H onepaTHBHo-p3JblCKHblX :J3KOHax CTjlaH CHr 11 EaJlTHI1
Hou.uelfQ6(j-;jue -
M npUl/l{unblOPp' 3tlK0H0iJameJl"l/biX
ny, OKm06.peVlG-
.'>IeHmupyIOI1J,Ux
OPO
J 2 3
I n HHUHn:JaKOHIfOCm
OPll UCHOIIblBaeTCSI Ha KOHCTIfT)'llHOHHblX epanbHbiJI
npl'lHUlUJaX 3aKOHHUCTl'I (CT. 3 rn I) 3aKOH <,()6 unepa-
THBHO-p03bICUiOii
lIelITtJlbHocrn»
OPll OCHOBbIBaeTC.II Ha npl'lHUlmaX 3aKOHHO- 3aKoH YKpal1Hbl
CT(CT. 3rn. I) 06onepaTl1B-
HO-pOJblcKHoH
JleSlTJ1bHOCTI1
OPll CTpOHTCH Ha OCHOI3!: nplllHUltna aaKOH- 3allOH Pecny6-
HUCTH (CT 3) nl1l1l'1 EeJ1apycb
...o6onepaTB-
HO-pOJblcKHoH
lIeSIT!:.rrbHOCTI1
OPll ocywecTBJlHeTCH B1111 , 3alwH Pecny6-
npl'lHUl1naMI1 :JaKOHHUCTH (CT 3) 1I1KI1 Ka3aXCTaH
...o6onepaTB-
HO-PO:JbICIlHOH
Jle5lT!:.rrbHOCTW>
OPll OCHOBblBaeTCJI Ha npl1HUl1naX 3aKOHHO- 3aKoH
CT(CT.4) KbIprbl3CKoH
Pecny6.11I1KH
060nepaTItB-
HO-p03bICKHO
JleSlTe.llbHUCTW>
OnepanlBHa.ll JleSlTe.llbHOCTb nUllIIe)l(l1T opra- 3aKOH
HIt3aU1t It ocymeCTHJ1eHItIO Ha OCHOBe aa- J1aTBI1MCIlOM
KOHHOCTI1 (n. I CT. 4) Pecny6J1ItIlI1
Meponpl'lHTHJI unepaTl1BHoti lleHTeJ1bHOCTH 06 onepaTl1B-
C.IIellYeT Ha'JI1HBTb 11 ucyweCTBJlJlTb TOJIbKO e HOMJleSiTenb-
TOM c.IIy<Jae. eCJIIt BbIl10JlHeHlte YKa:JBHHbIX B HOCTIt
CTaTbe 2 HaCTOJImCro 3allOHa It 1l0CTH>KeHI1C
onpe!le.lleHHblX B CTane I ueJleH I1HblM cno-
:ItT:MnOCT11 cywecTBeHHu ,,-
158

npoOolJlC(!lIue maM. 15
I 2 3
opn OCHOBblBaeTCJI HH npltHLllme 3aKOHHO- 3aKOH Pecny6-
CTIt (cr. 4) nltKI1 MOnJ\oBa
060nepaTItB-
HO-pOJbICKHOH
JleSlTnbHOCTIt..
2 " HllImcoU.n UCBOOo.J,'I.eJlOBeKa
0Pll OCHOBbJBaeTCSI Ha KOHCTI1TVUl10HHblX Q)enepa,lbHblfl
npmml1nax YBa;t<eHI1S1 1'1 c06molleHI1J1 npaB 11 JaIlOH 060ne-
CD060lJ'l.enOBeKa 11 rpaJKlJaHItHa(cT, 3) paTl'lDHo-po3bICK-
HOW JJeSlreJ1b-
HOCTI1
opn OCHOBbIBac:TCSI Ha nplJHLlltnaX c06mo- 3allOH YKpHItHbl
JleHlJH npaB 11 CBo6oJl'l.enOaella (CT. 4)  06 onepaTI1B-
HO-pOJbICKHOH
JleSlTJlbHOCTI1"
OPll CrpOI1TC.II Ha OCHOBe cOOJlIo.neHI1.11 3aKOH Pecny6
npltHLll1na c06mo.neHI1J1 npaD 11 CB0601l 'fe- nl1l1lt Eenapycb
JlODeKa 11 cB0601lnlt'IHUCTI1 (CT. 4) 060nepaTD-
HO-p03bICKHOW
.neSlTeJlbHUCTI1»
opn ocyureCTBJIJleTCSI II COOTBnCTBl'lI1 C nJll'lIi- 3aKoH Pecny6-
LlnHMI1 c06mOlleHI1H npaB It cB060il. YBaJKe- nltKIt Ka3aXCTHH
HI1H llOCTOlJHCTBH nW-jHOCTI1, paBeHCTBa rpH- 06onepHTB-
}l(.)\HH nepell 3aKOHOM (CT. 3) HO-pOJbICIlHOH
JleSlTJlbHOCTI1»
opn OCHOBblBaeTC.II HH npl1HLll1nHX cofulJo- 3aKoH
lIeHI1.11 npHe 11 CB0601l nl1'JiiOCTIJ (cr. 4) KbIprbl3CKofi
Pecny6nl1KI1
060nepHTI1B-
HO-pOJbICKHOfi
neSlTeJlbHOCTI1»
OnepanJBHH.II JleSlTeJlbHOCTb nUD,JIe)Kl'IT opra- 3aKOH
HI'I3!1Lll111 1'1 ocyweCTflJlefil1l0 C c06J\10lJeHIfif JlaTBl1iiCKoii
Bce06WHx np!lB 'JeJlOReKa (n. 1 CT 4). Pecny6nl1l<lt
Onep!lTHlltible 3!1.!J:afil1J1 fieo6XOlll1MO BblnOJ]- 06onepaTl1l1-
HHTb no B03MOJKHOCTH It Mefibwe BMeWIfBa- HOHJ\CSlTeJ1b-
JlCb R c$epy npaR 'JeJloaella (n JeT. 4) HOCTI{»
"p" npoBelleHlf1f "teponpltJlTl1li onepaTI1B-
HOH .r:\eJlTeJlbHOCTI1 Janpewae-rcSI: HitHOCItTb
nlfLlHM $KII1'JecKIfH !1J1!1 MHTepltB;]bHblii
ylJ.J,Cp6. nOllBepraTb yrpOJe >KIt3Hb It 3J\OpO-
ebe, YI"p(M(dTh npltMeHel-1I1eM cpen,cTe IJm:m-
e:H=e:;M n:b nl1Ll .
159

llpoiJonJK:elluema6/l.15
1 2 3
OPll QCHQBblBaeTCSI H8 nplJHLlltn8X c06J11Q- 3aKoH PecnyG-
.ueHI1J1 npaa It cB06011 J]WIHOCTH (CL 3) J]ltlllJMOJ1l10aa
06onepaTltB-
HO-p03bICKHO
neHTe.llbHOCTIt»
3 "pHHlUm B3aHMOJI.eiiCTBHJI c opraHaMIl )'npaB-
- OPll OCHOBblB8eTCJI Hi! npltHUHnaX B38I1MO- 3aKOH YKpaltHbl
lleHCTBI1H C opraHaMI'I ynpaBJIeHIt (CT 4) 06 onepaTltB-
HO-pOJbICKHO
JleHTe.llbHOCTIt
OPll OCHQBbIB8eTCSI H8 npltHrmnaX B38ItMO- 3aKOH PecnyG-
.ueliCT81111 C npyrHMI1 OpraHi!MIt ynpaBJIeHl11I nltKI'I MonnoBa
(CT. 4) 06onepaTltB-
HO-pOJbICKHO
lleHTe.llbHOCTIt
He npellycMorpeHO 38KOH
Kblprbl3CKOH
PecnyG.IIltlllJ
06onepaTItB-
HO-p03bICKHOH
.ueSlTeJ1bHOCTIt
4 flpllllUHn IWHCIDI
opn OCHOBbiBaeTCSI Ha KOHCT11l)'llHOHHbIX .IlepanbHblfr
npm1LlItrJax KOHCnlJpaLllt1t (CT. 3) JaKOH ..Ql'ione-
p.:tllIBHO-poJbICK-
HOMJleSlTeJ1b-
- OPll ocyureCTRJ1J1eTCSI a COOTBeTCTBlt1t C npltH- HOCT",>
3aKOH PecnyG-
Llltna).tIt KOHCnltpaLlHl'l (CT. 3) tltKIt KaJ.a1(CTaH
Ol'ionepaTB-
HO-P03bICIIHQH
neSlTeJ1bHOCTIt
OPll OCHUBblBaeTCJI HB npltHUHnaX KOHCnlt- 3aKOH
paUHIt (cr.3) Kblprbl3CKo
PecnyG.IIltKH
060nepaTItB-
HO-p03bICIlHOH
lleSlTeJlbHUCTIt"
160

llpQ()o/l.1ICf!Huema(j/l.15
2 3
, .. DHHUHn BJaHMO.IIt'IICmHR C HaCeJleHHeM
opn OCHOBbIBaeTC!'I Ha npHHW1naX 113aI1MO- 3aKOH YKpaHHbl
.nejicTI!(,!RC HaCeJleHl1e11.l (CT 4) 060nepaTltB-
HO-p03bICKHO
)leSlTJlbHOCTH"
He npellYCMOl'peHO 3aKoH
KbIprbl3CKoR
Pcny6J1HIIH
...o60nepaTHB-
HO-p03bICKHOH
- - - .neSlTeJIbHUCTH»
OnepaniBHaR neHTeJlbHOCTb nU.1lJIeJKHT opra- 3aKOH
HH3au('j ('j ocymecTBJleHHIO B COTPYJlHlt'le- JlaTBIIIHclIOH
CTBe C HOCeJleHHeM npH onope Ha ero no- Pecny6J1HKI'I
MOlllb{n I CT. 4) ,,06 ont:pmIBHOti
.neSlTe.f\bHOCTI'I»
7 npHHWIn IIOllKOIJ'IIIOlbHOCTH BblcrnHM opraH8M
- rocvJlaeHBoiiBJ1aCTHl1nID4BJ1eHHR
opn CTpOI1TCSI Ha OCHOBe npHHUl'lnOB nOli 3aKoH Pcny6
KOHTPOJlbHOCTH 11 nUJ\OT4eTHOCTIJ BblCWHM J1HIII1 6JlapyCb
opraHBM rocvnapcTBcHHofi OJiaCTlf H ynpao. I 06 onepaTo-
J1eHI1S! (CT. 4) HO-pO.ibICKHOH
-.- -=-- _ _ JleSlTeJIbHOCTW>
npHHUI1I. Mt:KIIBTHunl1 OPM IIJIH"HHt: H]-
- oPOeetleHIIH
\fcponpHSlTI'IIJ onepanlBHoH !leJlTJIbHOCTH> 3aKOH
""' "' npOBeneHI1J1. 06"beM " HHTeHCI'IB- JlaTBI'li1CKOIi
HOCTb JlOJl.!KHb! coo-merCTBOBaTb BtUly nocSI- Pecny6J1HIII1
faTeJ1bCTBa H CTeneHH onaCHUCTH (n. 3 C1. 4) .,()6unepaTl'lBHo!1
lIfJ[l1:/IbHOCTI'I"
, " I(HnneHLleO;JOrH3aWIHII 6ecna
c,tn<=M onepaTHBHoH nemeJ1bHOCrn " "' 3aKOH
JlOI1JKHOCTHblM "lHl.[a»l 33npemeHO npSlMO I1J1H JlaTBlJticlloti
OnOCpe,llOBaHOlll'HcTooroTh B IIHrepeCaX nOl1I1- Pecny6J1HIII1
nNeCKI1)( n"pTj:j. opr"HH33UI'IH H nBI'I)KeHI1 .,()6 onepantBHo!1
HJI!lJIHll, B»IeWHBaTbCSI fI.nellTt:JlbHOCTb HHCTlf- nel(lt:JlbHOCTI'I"
T)'L1HH rocynapCTBeHHo!1 BJlik.l1l H ynpaBJIeHI'lJi,
)'4peJK..!\eHHfi npoh"YJITIYPbl H CY!!il, a TaICKe 06-
WecTBeHHblX, nOJlHTH'leCXHX " peJlHflfU3Hb!X
opraHI13al!ti C UeJ1blO OKnaH!lSI R1IHSlHIUI I1J1H
BO:UreHCTBIUIHa HI1X,33I1CKlIIO'leHl'leMCJ1)"laeB,
Koma :1TO He06xQ[J,MO n:m npenompUl!eHH!! H
"""1Irn.rJ"\ffi nN'MVJl;ICHHHtn 6CT,4
161

OKOH'IaHlIema(j/l 15
1 2 3
OPll OCHOBbIB'leTCSI Ha nplJHLllmaX J\el1J\eo- 3aKoH Pecny6-
J10fl13aLlI1('J 11 6ecnapTi1H0CTJ1 (a63. 7 CT. 3) JII1KI1 MOJU\olJa
...o6onepaTlm-
HO-p03bICKHOI1
10- J\eSlTeJIbHUCTI1»
" 111(Hn BeHCT8B " JBKOHOM
MepOnpl1J1TI1J1 onepaTlJBHOH J\eSlTe11bHOCTI1- 38KOH
npoBoWlTCSI HeJBBI1C('JMO 0, rpIDK.1!aHCTBa, JlaTBIIIHclIOH
nOlla. HaLlI10HaJlbHOCTI1. B03PacTIl. MeCTa npo- Pecny611l1l1lJ
}lmBaHI1J1, 06pB30BBHI1J1, COLlH3J!bHOrO, CJ1Y- ..o600t:pTIlIBHOH
}l(e6Horo " I1MyutecTI!eHHOrO nOJ10)l(eH('J}[ " J\eSlTeJ1hHOCTH»
nOn>KHOCTHblX }II{U, I1X nOJII1TI1'JeCKHX 11 peJlI{-
rOJHhIX BJrJlSl1l0B, npHHart.I1e>Ka1l1l1X II napm-
JIM 111111 lJHblM u6rneCTBeHHbiM opraHI13aLlHJlM.
YnOMHHyrble 4IaKTOpbl He nOJ1)KHbl B!1I1J1Tb Ha
onepaTlJBHYIO J\eSlTe11bHUCTb, eCJIlJ :no oco6o
He urOBO"":HO JallOHOM (n 5 CT 4)
II U HItIIn3KO:lOIW!eCKoii6eJOnacHOCTH
Up" npOeelleHlJl1 MepOllpl111THiI onepaTHB- 3f1KOH
HO' neSiTenhHOCTI1 lanpeuraeTcH HaHOClJTb JlaTBI1HcKoi1
cyrnecTBeHHblH epen OKpy)l("lOurei1 cpene Pecny6JII1KI'I
(n 2 CT. 4) .,()6 onep1THBHCll1
ne.llTeJIhHOCTI'I»
12 U naroet! II HOC11I
OPl1 OCHOBblBBeTCJI Hfi npl1HLll1m CBOBpe- 3aKOH Pecny6_
MeHHOCTI1 11 HficrynaTeJ1bHOCTH (a6J. 7 CT. 3) JII1KI1 MOJU\OBB
060nepBTI1B-
HO-pOJbICKHOH
---.J - i'iiumll,llll-cu....,....HHJI J\eSlTCJ1bHOCTI1»
maCHblX " Heo,ilCHbIX
"ICTOllOBHCDelI£m
OPl1 OCHOflblBacTCJI Ha npl1HUl1ne CO'leTaHI1J1 llCpanbHbli1
maCHblX H HenlaCHblX MeT01l0B H CpllCTB 3aIlOH06one-
(CT. 3) paTIIBHo-poJblCII-
HOH l!CSlTeJ1b-
HOCTIN
OPll OCHOBbIBaeTCJlI-Ja npl1HUHne CO'leraHI1J1 3aKoH
m8CHblX H HerJlaCHbIX MCTOliOB H cpeLlcTB KbIprbl3CKol1
(CT. 3) Pecny611I1KH
«06onepaTI1B-
HO-pOJbICKHOi1
neSlTeJIbHUCTI1»
162

3HKOH(W,HTei1bHOe OnpeJ],eJJ('HHe IlJlllHDlUOII opn npel\YclIIItrpIIBMOT
I01UIIt'CTaTbH3aKOHOB.
CTaTbSl J 4IllepanbHoro :>aKOHa ,,06 onepaTI1BHO-p03bICIlHOH llSI-
Tei1bHUCTI1».
CraTbli 4 3aKQHa YIIp1IIIIHbl ,,06 onepaTIllJHQ-JXl3t"CKHOiI !!SlTCi1bHOCTI1
CTaTbSI 43aKoHa Pec:ny6J1ItKrI 5eJJapycb ,,06 OnepaTrIIIHO-p03bIC:KHOH
!!eSlTei1bHOCTI1»
CTaThIi J 3alloHa Pecny6JIItIlIt Ka:JIDoc:raH ..{)6 onepaTBHo-p03bIC:KHOH
AeSlTeJIbHUCTI1».
CTaTbSl J JaKOHH Kblprbl3cll011 Pecny6JII1KI1 ,,06 onepaTHBHo-
pOJblCKHol1D,C.liTenbHOCTrI».
CTaTbSl 4 3alloHa J1aTBl'lilcllOil Pecny6J1I1KI'I ,,06 OnepaTI'IBHOil neSl-
TeJIbHOCTI1».
CTaTb.li 3 3aKOHa Pecny6JII1KI'I MUJUlOBa ,,06 unepaTI'IBHo-po3b1CKHol1
neSlTeJ1bHOCTI'I».

Ta6J1Hua 16
KoHTjlO.1b H HIIJUop J.3. onqJJrrnIIt1D-I1J.3b1cKHoii .!WIITeJlbHOCThlO.
llJIe,IIJICMOTpeHlJhle JaKOHOJL)T('_LlMH 8KTaMU. l1erJl8MeHTHp)'IOUUlMH OP)],
B crpaHax CHI" U 6aJlTHH
'"
"In
1aKOIKJdamelbHoe 30If'HUe KOHmpOilH
U HaIDvpa 30 onepumueHu--pa:lWCKHOii
i)eRme,1bHocmb/Q
l"ocYlIhIii KOHTpOJIb J.3. OP)], CO CTO-
Hbl All
KOI-ITpOJIb 311 OPD. UCyweCTBJlIICT npc:nUlCHT
POCCH£icKO£i 41Cllcpaum:l
n ",n aIlleH-I-CKHl1tl1llt1 Pf1,1 II>
41Cllepa.nbHoe Co6paHI1e Pocc('JikKOii 41eJJ,C:-
pawm
KOHTpOJlb Ja OP,lI; H pilC1IDllUlJaHl1eM Bbl1lC
JlIICMhrX Ha TIf UCJ111 IPHHaHCOlJblX cpellCTD
ocyw:eCTRJlJleT KOMI1CCI1I1 BepXODHoro COBCTII
Pecny6.11I1KIf 6eJ1apYCb no 1J0npOCaM HaUI10-
HaJ1bHOii 6eJonaCHUCTIf. 06apOHbl 11 6apb6br
en HOCTblO
KOHTpO.llb 311 OPD. 0CYIlLCCTBJlSlCT CIIJiiM
KOHTpO.b 311 OP,lI; OCYIlLCCTB.IIIlIOT COOTBeT
CTIJ)'IOWHC nOCTOIIHHblC IIOMI1CCHH napJIa-
n pa Blfle1JbC11I6IlI...I1K(111T poJ1I>
flpaHHTe:IbCTHO POCC('JiiCKOll €DeJ:\epaul1l1 B
npellC.IIaX nO.llHOMO'lHii, UnpelleJ1l1eMblX KOH-
cnrryuHcii POCatiiClloii 4IcllCpaUIfI1. (Iclle-
paJ1bHb!MI1 IIOHCTlIT)'UlfOHHblMI1 npalJ<1MI'I H
.lie aJ1bHbIMI13aKOHaMI1
164
HUUMeHOl/rlHUe
30KoHoOomeJ/bHbIX
UKm06.pei!.ilO-
MeHmupym/u,ux
OPJl
3
41ellepa.bHbrii
I.IIII:OH "OGone-
panIRHo-p03b!CK-
HOllJlC}ITeJlb-
HOCT»
41ellepa.nbHblii
3IIKOH ,06 one-
panIBHu-p03bICK-
HoiiJlcSlTeJlb-
HOCT..
3aKoH Pecny6
1111KH ECl1apycb
..06 OnepaTl'IB-
HO-p03bICKHOii
nCIITeJ1bHOCTIf»
3aKOH
J]aTlJl1iicKOii
Pecny6.11HKI'I
,,06 onepaTl'I(lHoii
.1IeSlTeJlbHOC111.
3aKoH Pecny6
l1HKH MOJlllODa
..060nepaTI1B-
HO-p03bICKHOfi
nCIITeJ1LHOCTI'I»
41ellepaJIbHblfi
3IIKOH ,06 onc-
paTI1BHU-P03b!CK-
HOllnCIITCJlb-
HOCT"

llpoiJrm;Jlcel/uema6J/.16
1 2 3
CQCITIIeTCTBYlOlllHt OpTaHbI COBtTa M(JHHCT- 3allOH Pecny6-
po' JlI1KI1 EeJlapycb
06 oncpanlB-
HO-p03bICKHOfi
ne}lTCJIbHOCT"
BblnOJIHcH(Je 3MaHI1A cy6'beKT8'-m uncp8 3aKoH
TI1BHUH JleSlTCJIbHOCTI1 KOHTpOJI(JPyCTCJI B ITaTlJl1HcKOH
nopAilKC, YCT3HOBJIeHHO),t 33KOHOM lJ Ka6JJ- Pecny6J1I1KI1
HeTOM MI1HI1CTpOB 06 oncpaTJJBHoti
JleJlTCJIbHOCTIJ&
4 npOKYPopCKIIHH3,;J,30)J
HaLl30p 38 I1CnOJlHel-1I1CM 38KOHOB POCCI1A <toClIepa.%Hblf!
CIIOH <toe.JlcpaUI1I1. opraH3MlJ, OCYWCCTB- 33KOH 060[]C-
JI}IIOWI1MlJ OPD., oCYllleCTBJlIUOT reHepaJIb- paTJJBHO-p03bICK-
HblA npOKYPop PoccHAcKOf! <toellcpaUI1H H HotineJlTCJIb-
}1I0JlHOM0'1CI-IHbIC HM nPDKYJYIn.1>bI HOCTH;>
HB1l30p 33 C06J1IOJleH(JeM a8KUHOB npH npo- 3aKOH YllpaHHbl
BelleHHH OPM ocyweCTBJl.lleTCSI reHepanb- «060nCP<lTHB-
HblH npOKypOPOM YKpal1Hbl 11 nUJI'1Hl-leH- HO-p03bICKHOk
HblMlJ eMY npOllypopaMH KpblMCKOfi ACCP, neSlTCJlbHOCTH"
06.rrnCTefi. roponOB Kl1eBa H CeBacronOJUI
KOHTpOJlb 3a C06J1fOJlCHHCM 38KOHHocm B 38110H Pecl]y6-
OPD. OCYllleCTBJI}leTCJI rCHepaJIbHblM npOIlY- JI(JKI1 ECJlapyCb
pOpOM Pccny6JIHKI1 EeJIapYCb, npoKypopaMH 06 onepaTl1B-
06.rrnCTCti. ropoilll MHHCK8, a TaiCKe cneUI1- HU-p03bICKHUti
aJlbHO n()J11-1010'1CHHb]JH nOOKvoooam nCIITC:ibHOCTH"
HB1l30p 38 I1CnOilHel-ll1CM 3"KOHUB B OPD. 3aKOH Pecny6-
0CYlUCCTBJ1}1IOT feHepanbHblH npOKypop Pec- JlHKH Ka3aXCT8H
ny6n(JKH K33axCTaH(J H nOLl'1HHeHHble eMY «06 onepaTHB-
npoKypopbl HO-p03bICKHOfi
ne.llTeI1bHOCTH&
H3Jl30P 33 HCn()J1HeHHeM 3aKOHOB Kblp£bl3- 38KOH
CKOJ:i Pecny6nl1KH opraH8MlJ, ocywecTB- Kblprbl3CKOfi
JI}lIOWI1MI1 OPD., UCYlUCCTBJISIIOT fCHepanb- Pecny6JII1KI1
HblH npoKYpoP Kblprbl3cKoH Pecny6J1HIII1 H 06 oncpaTHB-
ynO:iHOMO'1eHHble HM npOIlYPOPbl He HI1)KC HO-P03bICKHOfi
CTaTYC8 npOKypopOB 06J18CTdi H roP01l8 neSlTCJIbHOCTH»
EJJIUKeK
165

H8J\30p aa COOTBTCTI!ItCM onepaTI1BHOH J!eA-
T)lbHOCT JaKOH3M ocywecmnmur r CHC-
paJIbHblH npoKYPop 11 oco60 yn())lHoMo'ICH-
Hble 11M npOKypOPbl
3aKOHHOCTb OIJep'l11IBHOH neSTeJlbHOC111 KOH-
TpOJII1PYeTCSI rCHepaJIbHblH npoKypopoM JII1-
TOBCKOH Pecny6JlI1KI1 I1J1I1 JaMelillUOlUl1M ero
JlI1UOM
H8J\30p Ja (JcnOJIHeH(JeM 3aKOHOB op.-aHa-
MH, ocywecTEIJ\lIfOWI1MI1 OPD., 11 JaIlOHHO-
CTbfO npl1HI1"taeMblX I'IMI1 peWeHI1 ucywe-
CTBJlJlfOT npOKYPOP Pecny6nl1l1l1 MUJU\uBa,
ero ,taMeCTI1TJUJ (J npoKypopbl ropo.aOB 11
paHOHOB.
HallJOp Ja nellTeJ1bHOCTbfO JlI1U. OKaJb1BafO-
IUliX 11;'111 OllaJblBaBWI1X KOH<!JI111eHUl.Ja.f1bHUe
cOlleHCTBl1e up.-amIM. npOBOllSllUl1M OPM,
OCYllleCTBJlJleT npoKypOp Pecny6JUJKI1 MOJ1-
JIOBa 11J111 npOIlYPop, CneUI18J1bHO ynonHo-
MU'leHHbIH np1111aJOM npoKypopa Pecny6-
JlI1KIi M0J1110BB
KOHO;lbJaOP)],
PYKoBOllI1TeJ1H opraHOIl. ocyweCTBJlSlfOlUl1X
OP)],. Hecyr nepCOH3J1bHYIO QTBCTCTBCHHOCTb
3a Co6J1JOlleHHCM JBIIOHHOCTIII npl1 OpraHI1-
J.aUI1H H npOBelleHl11'1 OPM
KOHTpOJlb Ja OPD. oCYlUecTBJlJleTcs:
ME)], YKpa(JHbl, CnYJK60H H3UliOH8J1bHOH
6C3QnacHQCTIi YllpaHHbl; YnpaElJ\eHl1eM ox-
p:JHbl BblCllll1X nOJ1JKHOCTHbIX JlHU YKPaHHbl;
rocynapcTBeHHblM KOMI1TeTOM no oxpaHe
rocv,llBOCTBCHHQH rn8.H('JUbI YKnIIl1Hbl
PYlloBoJlI1TeJ1H opraHoB. OCY!l.lCCTBJlJlfOIJ.!HX
OP)],. OnpellCJ1J1JOT nupSl1lUK BellOMCTBCHHOro
KOHTp0!111 J:J Het! H HecyT nepCOH3J1bHYIO
OTBeTCTBeHHUCTb Ja C06!11011eHHeM J:JKOHHO-
CTH npH OpraHHJBUHI1 11 npUBetJeH('J(J OPM
166
llpoiJrm;Jlcel/uema6J/.16
3aKOH
JIaTBI1HCKOH
Pecny6!1I1KH
..06onepaTliBHOn
lleST!1bHOCTI1"
3aKOH
JIHTOBCKOH
Pecny6nHIIH ..06
Onej)<lTliBHot!
J!eSlTnbHOCTIi"
3BKOH Pecny6-
11I1KH MonL!oBB
06 onej)<lTliB-
HO-pOJbICKHU
l]eSlTnbHOCTH"
<toellepanbHblft
33KOH «06onc-
paTliflHu-pOJbICK-
HoftneSlTe!1b-
HOCT"
3aKoH YKpal1HbI
06 oncpaTliB-
HO-pOJbICIlHOH
ne.llTeJlbHOCTIi"
3aKOH Pecny6-
1111KH EeJiapycb
..060nej)<lTliB-
HO-pOJbICKHUti
lIeSlTnbHOCTIi"

DKOI/'IDHUe maM. 16
I 2 3
BblweCToSlWl1e BellUMCTBeHHble upraHb] u5ec 3aKoH
ne411BalOT KOHTponb aa OP)]" nQ.1\'lI1HeHHblX Pcny5nI1KI1
HM upr8HuB. PYKoBOlll1Tenl1 opraHuB, ocy- K,:naxCT8H
l1\eCTBJIJUOUlI1X OPD.. 06eCne'lI'lB8IOT KOH- 06 onepanlB-
tpOJ1b Ja c05nlOlleHI1eM JaKOHHOCTH "PH HO-pOJbICKHUtI
o-nmHHJaUHH 11 nnoOCllCHI111 OPM .IleJlTC;JbHOCTI'I""
PyKoBolll1TenH OpraHOB. 0CYUleCTBJ1J1IOWI'IX 3aJ(OH
OP)]" fiecyr nepCOfi8J1bHYIO OTBeTCTsefifiOCTb Kb1prbl3CKOH
Ja C06nlO1leHI1e JIDWHfiOCTI1 npl1 opraHI1J8- Pcny5nI1KI1
UI'II1 11 npOBelleHHH OPM «06 Onep8TI'IB-
HU-p03bICKHOI1
aeJlTeJlbHOCTI'I»
nOpSli{OK KOH-rpOJUI B Y'lpeJKaeHI'IJlX Onepa- 3aKOH
THBHotlneSITe.%HOCTH YCTaH8BJ111B8IOT PYKO- JTaTBHcKofj
BO.lwrreJlI1 3TI1X Y'1peJKj{eHl1ti, HeCYUll1e nep- Pcny5nl1l1l1
COH8J1bHYIO OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb Ja OpraHliJa- «06onepaTl'IBHOn
UI'lIO patioTbl n01l'UIHeHHblX 11M CTPYKTYpHblX aeSlTeJlbHUCTI1»
nOJlpaJ.!LeneHl1ti B COGTEeTCTBIII1 C HBCTO\!-
WI1"t 3aKOHUM 11 nnvrl'lMH J8KOH8MH

T a(i.rmua 17
o6ecne'leHHeOnep3THBHO-pa3blCKIIOiilll'jlTeJ\bHOCTH
B crp3Hax CHf II 6aJ1THH
HOUMFHOflaHUe
M llolOJfCel/uR, KllCOKJUqlf'CR rpuHaHc(}Boo 3{]JwHodamF1b-
.y, 06ecne'leHUR OPjJ HblXlIKmoe,
pez:l{lM€HmupylO-
UjuxOPlI.
I 2 3
I (J)IIB3HCltpOB3HHe opn H'JroC'y
6Kt'J)KeT2
focy.napCTBeHHblM opr3H8M, nOllp,,3.1leJleHHSI cI>eJ]epaJIbHbI
IIOTopblX ynOJlHoMo4eHbi OCYll.leCTBJUITb OPD.. 3aKOH «06 one-
Bbl1lenllOTCH 113 4JellepaJIbHOrO 61OJ1)I(era 4m- paTI1BHO-
HBHCOBble cpellCTBa ('I.. 1 CT. 19) P03blcKHol'llleSl-
TeJlbHOCTW>
41I1HaHCl1pOBaHIfC om ocyrIIC<TWJSlCTCSI 33 3BKOH
C'1 aCCHrKoR3HHti H3 pecny6J1HKaHClwro Pecny6J1HIIH
61011JKe'fa. H3npalmHeMbiX HII co.aepJKaHHe op- Ka3aXCTBH
raHOO, OC}'UlCC1BllHIOll.lI'IX OPD., Kall B HaUI'IO- ,,060nep3THB-
HaJ1bHOfi. Tall H (I HHOCTpaHHofi BaJlJQTe B HO-p03bICIlHOfi
nopSl.IJ.Ke, onpe.aeJlSleMOM 33KOHOll3TCJlbCTBOM neSlTCJlbHOCT"
::;e:XC::I.T6H:.e; OHH-
foey.napeTBeHHblM opraHaM. oneparnBHble 3BKOH
nOllpa311eJleHHSI IIOTOpblX ynOJlHUMU'leHbl Kblprbl3CKoti
ocyll.leCTBJ11ITb OPD., BweJUlIOTC}[ H3 6lOlUKe- Pecny6.11HKI'I
Ta 4JI1HBHCOBble cpelIcma, IIOTOpble pacxo- ,,060nCpBTI'IB-
:::MO:: ::3lfrM; P}'IIO- HO-p03bICIIHUU
neSlTC;'IbHQCTIf»
41(JH3Hc(JpoB3H(Je onep3TBHOfi neHTeflbHO- 3aKOH
CTI1 OCYllleCTBI1S1eTC}[ 113 cpenCTB rOCYAapCT- J]aTBHficKOfi
BeHHom 610JlJKeTa (p. 6 CT. JJ) Pecny6f1HKI1
«06011ep'IDIIJHofi
.neJITe.!1bHOCTH»
OnepJflmHaH.neffi'e"lbHOCTb$HHBHCI1PYeTCSlI13 3aKoHJ]1IT0B-
cpenCTBfocY1l3pcTBeHHoro6lOlUKeTII(cr 13) eKok Pecny6J1I1-
1111..06unepa-
TIIIBHOHlIeH-
TCJlbHOCTH"
MHH(JcTepcTBaM. ynoJlHoM04eHHbiM 0CYll.!e- 3allOH Pecny6-
CTBJUITb OPD., BbUleJUllOTCfl H8 3TM ue.llM $11- J](JKI1 MOJULOB3
HaHCOlJble CpellCTBa ., pecny6J111113HCllom «06onepaTMB-
61OlUKeT3 ('1.1 CT. 17) HO-p03bICKHOfi
.neflTeJlbHOCT»
168

----£-1-. -
Z "Hble IICTO'lBIlKIl dmHaHCltpOB.3.HIIH OP,!t
Ja"OliQllllTel1bHble 11 I1Cno."IHHTeJ1bHble upraHbI
rocynajXTDCHHOH BJJaCTH Cyfu.cKTOB PoccHi:!-
CIIOH 4Iellepaul'I BnpaBe caMOCTCIHTt'JlbHO Ja
(;4eT co6CTBeHHblX OlQ1l)KeTOB 11 BHe6101I.JI(eTHbJX
UeJ1eBblx4>oIi./lOByaeJ1H'1I1BaThpa3MepCpe,i:lCTB,
BbUleJISleMb!X opraHaM, ocyun-mJ1HI011U1M OPll
HB 1eppIIlUpHH coarneTCTByIOOll'l. Cyfu.cKTOB
POCCj:jCKOH (]>enf00Ill1H('.1. 2 CT. 19
41mmHcl1poBaHHe OPD. OCYilleCTBJlHeTCH 3a
C'18T itCCl1rHOImHHH lJ3 MeCTHoro 61O.!LJKeTa.
HanpaWllleMblX HB COllep>Kalure opraHOB,
oCYlUeCTBJ11IIOWHX OPD., KBK D HaUHUHaJlb-
HOI1, TaK 11 B l'II-j()cTpaHHuf1: oa.rnore B rlOpSlIl-
Ke, onpe.aenHeMOM 3aKOHo.aarelIbCTBOM Pec-
ny6niJKI1 Ka3aXCTIlH 11 Ka611HeTOM MI1HHCT-
pOB Pecny6J1HIII1 Ka3aXCTaH ([J SeT 20)
4Im-JaHCl1pODaHHc opn ocywecTDJlJreTCH
TalOKe 3a ClleT OT'II1CIleHl'Ii1 aT CYMM B03Me-
weHHoro rocynapCTBY YUlep6a, nocTyn<'IIO-
U.!('IX OT peam13aU(J I1MYllleCTBa, 06pallleH-
HOro B nOXO!l rOCYllapCTBa Ha OCHODBHI1H
npl1rOBOpa cyna, B nUpSlllKe, onpeneJlHeMOM
3aKOHOmrrenbCTeOM Pecny6nHKI1 KaJaXCTilH
11 Ka611HeTOM MI1HHCTpOB Pecny6J1I1KIJ Ka-
3aXCTaH (n SeT 20)
Hc I1pCllY010TptHO
OnepaTBHaSi neSITeJ1bHOCTb 4'>I1HBHCHPyercSi
J.a c'IeT6naroTBOpI1TeJ1bHbIX 4>oHnuB B COOT-
BTCTB(UJ co CMeTaMI1 rocyllapcTBeHHblx I1H-
CTl1ryUI1i1 (CT 13)
 nopllJlOx paCXOllOBaHK!I cpenCTB, BbIlIeJleHHbI),.
KB OPlI
169
llpoiJrm;Jlcel/uema6J/.17
fDellepilJlhHbli1
JaKOH
«06unepaTlfB-
HO-pO.lbICKHOi1
.l{eSlTJ1bHOCT"
3aKOH
Pcny6J1I1KJJ
KaJ.axcTaH
«06onepaTHB-
HO-pOJbICKHUi1
.l{eJ.lTJ1bHOCT"
3allOH Pecrly6-
nI'IKI1 K.uaxCTaH
«06orlepanm-
HO-p03bICKH0i1
.l{CSlTCJlbHOCTH'"
3aKOH
Kblprbl3CKoti
Pecny6J1I1KI1
«06onepaTl1B-
HO-pOJbICIIHOi1
lleSlTJlbHOCTH"
3aKoH
naTBl1ticKoi1
Pcny6J1I1KI1
...o60nepaTBHOn
lleflTCJlbHOCT'"

flpotJo lJK'£lIue maM. 17
I 1 3
(J)m-JaHcOBb!e cpeLICTBa, BbllleJIJleMble HB (J)ellepa.%HbIH
OPD.. paCXOLIYKHCSI B nOpSl.IJ.Ke. YCTaHOBJICH-
HOM pyKOBOlUtreJUIMH 3TMX opraHOB «06unepBTB-
('1.1 CT. 19) HO-P03bICIlHOH
LIeSlTe;'JbHOCT»
OpraHBMH, ynOJlHOMO'leHHblMH HB OC}llllCCT- 3alloH Pecny6-
BJleHHe OPD., BbUleJleHHble Ha 3TH ueJlI1 4>H- J1HKH 6eJl3pyCb
HBHCORblC cpeLICTBa p!lC1{OIlytO"lCJI B nopJlLIKC. «06unepanlB-
OnpeileJUICMOM MBD, Pecny6J1HKH 6eJlitpYCb, HO-p03bICKHOfi
KOtHTeTO"l rocynapCTBeHHOH 6e30naCHuCTM IleSlTeJlbHOCT»
Pecny6J1HKH 6eJlilpYCb H rJ1itBHblM ynpaB..e-
HHeM nOrpaHl1'lHblX BOHCK npl1 COBeTe MI1-
HHCTDOB PeCnv6J1HIIH 6eJlBDVCb OJ 1 CT. 18) jB
focynapcTBeHHblM upraHBM. OnepaTI'IBHble
nOilpa3!!enCHHSI KOTOPb!X ynO.HOMO'leHbl Kblprbl:JCKoR
OCYllleCTBJ1S1Tb OP)],. BbllleJlJlJOTCSI 113 6JOillKe- Pecny6J1HKJJ
Ta 4>HHaHCOBble CpellCTBa. KOTOpue pacxo- ,,06 onepanlB-
J\YIOTCil B nopHlIKe. yCTaH3BJ1JJBaeMOM pyKO- HO-p03bICKHOfi
DOillITel1J1MH 3T"" u faHOD ('I IcT22) IleSlTeJlbHOCT»
nOpSlIlOK HCno.%30BBHHe 4>HHaHcoBbIX Cpe,i:lCTB 3allOH
YCTaHaBJII1BaeT PYKOBOlll1TeJlb Y'!Pe)l(J!eHHJI naTBMHcKOR
onepaTBHoii JleSlTeJlbHOCTH (CT. 33) Pecny6J1HKH
"06unep:.mmHoH
AellTCllbHOCTW'
nOpSillOK pacxolluB "0 onepaTHDHuA De' 3aKOH
Te)lbHOCT YCTaHaBJIHBaeTCJI cy6"beIlTaMH JhnORcllOH
Onep<ITBHO" neSlTeJlbHOCTH (CT. 33) Pecny6J1I1KI'I "06
UnepaTI'IBHOH
----;s-(oJ1"'3apacx(lJl(leaKIJelllCpeaCllj.Btol1!e. JleJ.JTe)lhHOCT"
- ':::.: acx01l0BaHl1eM 4>1'II-JBHCODblX c]>ellepaJIbHblH
CpellCTB, Bb!1leneHHblX J],JIJI OPJL ocymecTB- :'IaKOH
l1J1eTCJI PYKoBOLII1TeJlJlMI1 rOC}lnapcTBeHHblx «06unepaTl'lB-
opraHOB, B CQe-raB 1I0TOpblX BXOJJ.JlT oncpa- HO-P03bICIlHOH
THDHble nOllpa:'llleJleHlUl opraHoB. oCYlllecTB- neSlTeJlbHOCT»
J1J1lQmHX OPD., a TBKJKe cncwm.rrhHO ynOJl-
HOMO'1eHHbIMI1 HB TO npellCTBOlirenJlMH MI1-
HHCTepCTBB 4>I'IHBHCOB POCCHHCKOH c]>ellepa-
UH '1. 2 CT. 19) -
170

I 2
KOIHpOJlb J.a paCX01l0BaHI1eM 4>HHaHcuBbIX
CpellCTB, Bbl!leJleHHblX Ha OPD., ocyweCTBJlS!-
eTCSl PYKOBODJtreJ\J\MI1 3TMX opraHOB ("I. 2
CT. 18)
KOHlpOJlb 3a pacXOllOBaHl1eM 4>HI-JaHCOBbIX
cpellCTB, Bb\1leJleHHblX Ha OPD., ocyweCTBJ1f1-
eTCJI PYKoBoJ\IiTeJUIM(J TOcyJJ,3pcTBeHHblx op-
r8HOB, II COCTaB KOTOpbJX BXQIJ,SlT onepaTl1B-
Hble nOllPa:t1\eJ1eHItSi opraHOB, ocymeCTB-
JUllOlIUIXOPD. ('I. 2eT 22)
nOp!lj{OK BHyrpeHHero KOHTpOJUI YCT(lHiiBJIH-
(IT PYIIOIlQlUtTe}lb Y4pe)!(lleHmr onepaTtlll-
HOHlleHTeJlbHOCm (CT 33)
KOHlpOJlb 3a paCXOliOBaHI'ICM 4>HH(lHCOBbIX
CpellCTB, BbllleJleHHblX HB OPD.. ocyweCTBJ1J1-
eTCSI PYKOI3OlUllJUIMl'I yno;lHoMO"leHHbIX MH-
HI1CTepCTB.aTIlJU;;ecneUl'laJlbHbIXnpellCraBI'I-
.Tel1ei1MI1HI1CTePCTlJaQJI'IHaHCOB{'l2CT.17)
 MaTeJllla.1bHO-(l6ecneqeHHeOPJ],
MaTepIHL'IbHO-TCXHH'reCKOe o5ecne'ICHHe OP))
ocyrnCCTBJ11ICTCSI HJ cpeLlCTB pecnytiJlI'IIWH-
CKoro 11 MecTHoro6JOll;KeTOBBCOOTIJeTCTBHI1
C nOJlo;+:eHl1eM U rocynapCTBeHHOM oi'iOPOH-
HOM J.aKaJe. yrBep;KJJaeMUM Ka6HHeToM
MHHl'ICrpoB Pecny6J1I1KH KaJa'l.CTaH. 3a Cl,leT
11.J'MITb!X 11 KOHI}I(lCKOBaHHblx no pellleHl'IJO
cyna allTOTjJaHcnopm. pall1'103.11eKTpoHHblX
Cpe1lCTB, aYllHO-. B(\)\eOTM<:HI1KH. 3.eKTpOH-
HO-BbI'nlCJ1I1Te.bHblX YCTPOHCTB, oprreXHI1KH
l1J\JJyromI1MymecTBa(p.5CT_21)
He npeJlyc},tOTpeHo
171
O;;OIi'ful/ue mu6J/. 17
3
3aKoH Pecny6
!1I1KI1 6eJlapycb
«060nepanm-
HO-pO.lbICKHOti
.l{eSlnlIbHOCT"
3allOH
Kblprbl3CKOH
Pecny6lIl1KH
«060nepanm-
HO-P03bICIlHOH
lIeSITe."IbIlOCTI1'"
3aKOH
lTaTBI1HClloti
Pecny6lIl1l1l'1
...o60nepaTBHO"
lICSlTCi1bHOCTH'"
3alloH Pecny6-
!1I1KH MOlIlloBa
«06unepanlB-
HO-p03bICKHUI1
lIeSiTelIbHOCT»
3aKOH
Pecny6lIl1KI1
Ka3aXCTaH
«060nepanm-
HO-p03bICKH0I1
lleSiTelIbHOCT»
3aKoH
Kblprbl3CKofi
Pecny6lIl1KH
«060nepaTI1B-
HO-P03bICIlHOH
lIeSlTe;'IbHOCTI1'"

nOJlmKeHIIH, KolC.at01JUI('CJ[ IJIllu.lIICOIIOKI ooecne'leHHH OP)]" lIJIeJ\Y-
CfII8'I1IHB8IOTCJlell,YlOJ.1JJK'CTaTbH3aKOHOB_
CT3TbSl 19 <DepanbHoro aallQHB ,,06 onepBTI1BHO-pOJblCKHOH lleSl-
Te.llbH()CTI1».
CT3TbSl 18 3allQHB Pcny6J1I1KIJ EeJlBpycb ,,06 onepaTl'IDHO-
p03blCilHOti l\CHTJlbHOCT('j».
Cmrbl1 20. 21 3aKoHB PeCny6nl1KI1 Ka3aXcntH ,,06 onepaTHBHo-
P03bICKHOtil\CJlTeJlbHOCTI1».
CmrbSi 22 3aKOHa KblprblJCKOfi Pecny6.11I1KI1 «06 onepaTHBHo-
p03bICIIHOH!leJiTenbHocTH»
CTBTbH 33 3aKoHB JlaTBldlu::oti Pecny6nl1KI1 ,,06 onepBTI1BHOH !leA-
Te.llbH()CTI1»
CTBThH 13 JaKoHB 11I1TOeCKO" Pecny6.11I1K('] ..06 onepaniBHoH lleA-
Te.llbH()CT(']».
CTBTbSl 17 3BKQHa Pcny6J1I1KI1 MOJl!\OBB ,,06 onepBTI1BHO-pO-
Jb!CKHOH!\eSlTeJ]bHoCT".

3aKIlIO....eHlt1e
npoeen,eHHblR HalotH Cp"BHHTenbHblR aHaJ1H3 onepaTHBHO-pa3b!CIIHOrO 3aKOHO-
.o.rrrenLCTBa6hU1 Hal1eJ1eH .mY"CHeHI1"OCHOBHoRcyrHpJ3J1H"Hii Me:.lU!jld!<:JIepaJIL-
HbIM 3aKOHO'I .06 onpaT!<IIH"_poJbICI<:Hol1 JI"T'JlbHOCTJ< .. aH8.f10rHHbIM" 3a1W_
HaMH B CTPaHX CHr H 6aJ1THH. D.pymn JanacR HCc.CIIOB"HH>1 >1BJ1>1nocbycT"HOB-
l1eHH H,,,,60Jle" nonHoro 11 OTB"'lalOl11ero cOBpeMeHHbI'" Tp.60""HHM ]8110H8 .06
onq-.......IIHO_pOJbICKHOI1 lIne:lbHOCTII K HaweMY HHIO. CpeD.H H3Y"HHbIX
HopMaTHBHblx.nOIlYMCHToBHcyna.nocbOnpCD.C:lHTb'JaJ«>HOlI.m:.%Hbll1allT,lIoToPbl11
6b! COOTIIL"ICTEOII.IJ1 Tpe60BJHHnM cop'MeHHOCH!. B OCHOB" C"X JU;IJH(; JIe>KHT
Q>e.nepa.nbHbll1 3a"OH 1995 r OQ Ol1epaT!<lIHO-poJbICIlHOh .IltT'JlbHOCT,,"
PC3YJlbTaTbl 8H8.f1ma n03BOnIOT rOBopHTb 0 Hc06XOIIH\fOCTII JIAIIbHCRwcro co-
BepweHCTBO"HI1 3JIIOHO.ll8R!lLHOH 6mb!. Be.!!eHI1  np"KTHKY cOBpoMeHHblx,
H8)"IHOo6ocHoBaHHblxOpraHmaI]l10HHblx$OpM H "'TO.l\OBOnepaTHHO-pa]ICIIHol\
JlOT'JlbHOCTII,06.cne>lIlBaIOWl1X34$cKTHBHYI060pl>6ycllp"CTynHoCTblOnpHCTpO-
>K"iiWeMco6J!IO.1\OHI111JI1«JHHOCTJ<.
C'IHT""M lIencoo6p83HIM )"leCTb c.,e.1l.j'IOWHe HaWH npJlJ1o","HH
I llono.1HHTbcT ) IJ)] 060Pll H COOTIICTCTBYlOwlie 3aKOHbI npllHI1HnOM Ha-
CTYnTenHOCTl< (onepaTHBHocTH).neiicTBHR Cy6UKTOB OPllll6oph6e C npeCTynHo-
CTLIOHo6ecne'leHHH6eJon8CHOCH!!lH'IHOCTH,06weCTBJI1rocYl1"pCTBa.o60cHO8-
HHC IIOToporo H3,o",eI!O "IHorolq>aTHO  Cl1elllla.rJbHOlll1HTeP"TYP'
2. He060cHoBHHo npHMeHeH HCepl1b1B"1011IHR nepeeHb Ol1ep"THBHO-
pnblCKHblX MeponplInHH, IIOTOplii MO.t.eT 6b!Tb H3MeHeH TonbKO 3"KOHOM, 'lT0
TOp'l03HTpa3BHTHeTllOp'lIoronKOpraHI1"'"HHI1TaKTHII"HXn""MeHHHII
B 3THX ycnoBX HeT HHK"KIIX $oPM8.f1bHblX H $3I1TH'IeCIIHX OCHOBaIiHI1 1U1 orpaHH-
'IeHH OPM He KJ1IOeHbI  nepO""HL OI'M TIlKHe "IpJIIHL1HOHHO npH"'eHneMbie
08):\ "'ponpHSlTH, 11311 npecne.llOBaHHe Cl<jJhlWHXC C MCTa npm,cwCTBHn nOJ(03-
p.""e"lbIX no ropHM c.1ellaM, OpraHH3aIlIl 3"Ca1 no I1X 3aIlCp)KHHIO> npOBeD.CHHe
Ol1ep.1THBHblX Ko.,6HH3QHiI "T"IITH'IeCK"X onep.,""iI no "J'bHTHIO "I"repHaJ1bHblX
CJ1o:l10B npOCTYnHO .IltTe:JLHOCTH, <:.1I.HHOBpMeHHo'lY 3",""P,*,JHHIO yacTHHKoB nl"'-
crynHblx$op'lHPOBaIiHI1,1I00PY>KCHHbIX npeCTYnHHII0,OCB06o:K!ICHHI03a!10:+;H"IIOB
II T.n. YCT""o...,eHHe KOJ1H'IeCTBeHHOrO OrpaHI1'.eHHn OPM He 6YeT CTIIMynl1pOaTb
cBoepeMeHHoro BOCTpo60""HI1 HOBbIX H8)"IHblX l\OCTI.....,HHH ., Riot 60!leo TIiKI1
HTp!UIYI1]l10HHblX MeTQ.IIOlI, KaK IICno.1L]0""HH nO!lHrpa4>a. ..e_'OBeKO-MaWl1HHIX
cHCTeol,ry"l"HHO;;a"KTHnOCIIOnl1,,".npyrotx.
:I rl1aBY II d!] 06 OPll pJCWHpHTb 11 I13110)KHTb "cn pe.wiKIlUH. aOpra-
HH3aI]HOHHbI" q,OP'lbl, Me"KU!U. cpeCTII3 11 "'epOnpHTIt onepaTHBHo-po]ICIIHOII
JleTCJ1bHOCTl1. COOTBen7BeHHO IIa:K!lO'lY H3 3THX COCT"BJIIOWHX JlOJ1)KHII 6blTb no-
CIDIllleH" OT/lenbHaJI CT"Tb>I J.lI10H3. <l>op.'ynHpoKY 1I0TopblX MO,*,HO Ja""ICTOoaTb 
cn1]IUIJ1bI-fffii J1HTopaTYJI" (06 OpraHmal]HOHHbIX  pa6OTh! C"ToB OPll.
OnCp"TlIBHoco6cJ1yJKHBaHHe,llOK)'III'HT11j)OBaHHC.BJaHMOJlcltl.'IBIC:,OneparnBHo-pa3h!CK-
HOO o6ecneeHHeyrOJ1OBHorocynonpOHJI!C¥\CIIJa 11 lIP.).
4. P"CWHpH np33 OnepJTHHblK nOllPJ3l1!leHHIi  ..aCTH npHMeHeHI1 HaH60-
l1e" CJ10)KHIK areHTYpHo-onepaTHBHbTX "IP. 3aKOHQ)jaTe;"lL OCTaHOBHJlC !-Ia nOJlnyrli
poweHH 'lToii np06ne'bI H He 06ecneI1n H31U""'HbI"IH np""OBbI"Il1 rnp"HTH'"
173

WTaTHbiX OnCpUTHBHblX p,,6OTHHIlOB. H B 'IacTHOCTJI BHCIlPetb'X B IIPHMHHaJlbHYIO
CI"'I\YJ],./JH HX P3]1,,60ThH. npU<J1t'IeCM'M peWeHI1eM }'t:TI"HeHHO! TaKOra npo6eJI"
MOrJI3 6LI C.'y"'ItTb CnellHaJlhHa !-!Op"a npaBO onEJY'TI'HorO pa60THHila Ha npo-
q,eCeHOHaJlhHbJA PHCK' CTPY""J}'I\d Ii C01lep"'aHHe npC1lJlaI1lCMOA HOptbl MOrJIIi 61>1
BblrJIJUJ,eTbCneI\YIOIlIHMc6p.1JOM
He npHJHalOTC npecrynHblMH aelkmtnl Cyfu.eIITOB CnepaTHHo-po]bOCKHIJII.IIe-
TeJIhHOCTI1.q,OPMaJJbHOHapywHBwHcnpaBUlt3aIlOHHbJCHHTt:PCCblq,..JH'ICCIl"X.IOPH-
.IIH'ICCKHXJHtIl, HOCOBCpllJeHHble B 3KcrpcMaJJbHblX CHTYBII"SlX BCOCTOBHHH Hc06xo-
.IIHMoli06opoHbI.llpaAHet1 I-lelJ6uvutMOCTH HJ1H ycnoBHIIX"poot>eCCHOHaJlLHoropHc-
KaPl<CKnonpal\!laHHbIM_CC.'HcolICpweHHQeJlellH"ec6J,eKTHB1-10IlbITeK""O
ItJI<jJH"'H"'\J1LHOii HHllI(Jp'''IIHI1 oq,'KT<IX 11 CC6bITHBX, IIOTOpbl"'H p3cnOJ13"'eTc nep.l-
THHbl;;p36<rrHI1l1npJBOO'pJHItTe..'LHLlxopraHoB,3blnOJ1HeHI1e,,"lIoHHoiiq,YHIIIIHIt
>Ie MornO 6b1Tb JlQCTHr"yra He CB3a">lbI"''' C npoo!>eCClloHa.'bHhIM P"CKO" M<"fOlla"",
H cpellCT"'U"".
npl1HHTIte TaKO;; HopMbJ HI1nQCL6b1 coepeMeHHoii pealllll<eii 3BIIOHOJ\aTe.nO!
>I" peaJIbHQe npoTI<HOJ\eljcTHlle IIPIIM"H8!lhHOIl cpeJ\bI npaHoo'paHHTeJIb>1b1M opra-
HaM BCospeMeHHbJXYCJ10B....X JTI\cpen" npH6eraCT Kpa;<JJH'Il-ibiM YX"JJJ.PCI-iHI1M-
OT COKpLITHB H YHH"TO",eHHO! .IIOKYMCHTOB It H306nl1'1alOllJHX HX MBTCpHaJILHblX
npe=010B JJ,O q,ml<"ecllol! pJcnpabI C nOTeHI]ltBnLHblMH CHJlCTenO!MH. 3 Tall",e
;;:;:M n:xH:=;:.HO! nOllKynoB H HIIC).!)II1H II CaMHM onepaTI<BHblM pa6<rrHHKaM H
S Heo60rnollBHHo orpaHH..eHHb! noowpl1TeJIbHbJe Mephl J],./J Her13CHoro anna-
paTa. nl'OHIIHBwero npo<\JeCCHOHaJlbHYIO 8I<THaHOCTb B 60pl>6e c npecTynHoCTblO
06b1'1HO"TOnOJlOJKeIlHeorp"HII'III""eTcH BblJ"l'1eii .!IeHe><HbIX npeMHii.lleHHbJXnO-
JI;IJJKOI!. nOLlweHHeM nOCToHHOro lIC""OUiOTO COJIepJK"HIt np"KTHKB nOJ\TBCp-
)!(llaeT. 'ITO eCTb lice OCHOHaHHH BK.'IO'IHTb.,3"IIOH1l0110J1HHTei1bHhleMepbl noowpe-
H"H.npe1!CT"JB.,eIlHHOJlOCPO'lHOMOCso60>QeHIIMHJ1I1CMBf'leHHI1Hall"""IIHB.O
nOMItnOBBHHIt, nepco H" YJ1}"1WCHHble YCJ10HH CGIqJJKiIHI1B" YJ.1H. CCi1H arcHT
OCy>KJIeH C]H CCOBopweH"eM npeC'l)'nneHHO! YCJ10HSlX paJ06i1a'leH"" npecryn-
HOro co06wecT"" HJ1H OprHH30B"HIIo>i npecTynHo;; rpYl1nb!. npOHBItJ1 "aCTO;;'III-
BQCTbItpHCKbln0i1HCHHI1J<U1,BHH;;npaBOoxpaHItTCi1hHbJXOpraHoB,34><peIITHB-
HOCTbHer'aCHOrOCOTI')'JlHH'IeCT,,""'eCTIlXJI"WeHIt"CB06<u\bl 3aoc06b1eJJcnym
HCrJIaCHblXCOTPYJlHHIIOBCJlCllOB(IJ106b1npcllCTaB.'HTbllrocynapCTBCHHbIMHarpan8M
B HOBbJX YCOB"HX npH nOllCe.nHeBHo>i .nene.1bHOcTH ype6)ercJ! nepecTpo>i1la
pa6OTLIKaJK.l\oron0JJ.PJJJJ,Ci10HIIAHCOTPYlIHI1l1a3'ronpeJKaeBCOroCIIH,,"HOCYBeIII1-
'ICH"C'" TJ'I.6oBaTehHOCTH II npop..CCHOHB."'JMY COTPYllHHKOB_ OCYlUCCTII.'HSITeCHOC
15JaHMOJ]e;kTHHe" llPyrHMH I1QI:q).1JlIeleHHHMH OB.D. 1'OC'o.ll'PcTIICHHbJMH 11 06weCT-
BeHHblMH CTI')'Kl)'pUMI1. onepaT"Hble arm3paTbi np"BOoxpaHItTei1LHbIXOprBHO "pl1
HIUU1e>K3W...."paIl01l0M n01l0"OHHH H opraHHJ:!I]ltHCMoryrOCyuieCTBI<TbHI!J!e>KHYIO
JUlUHTYIG';+;,aoro..eJIOHelG,OTnpecrynHblxnOCHraTe..1bCTB

Cnlt1COK .nIt1TepaTYpbl
II. 331WH YI<jJUHHbI ..06 onep"THIIHO-pOJLICKHo>i .3.UTUbHOCnt No 213S-XII OT
12. :I\::K,,,::r,H"15"'eTn994H;  I:SXwr:O';e-
175

Or.naB.neHlt1e
BBe)J,eHlo1e
Ta6nlo1a1 CYI..I.\HOCTbOnepaTIo1BHO-p83b1C1(HOlJ.eATenbHOCTIo1,
3a$Io1I1Clo1pOBaHHaSi B 3allOHO)\arenbHbiX allTax CTpilH CHr 101 5i1nm.
nOCBAL.LjE1HHbIXpernaMeHTaLj1013To4JYHKLI1'I
)'I'OJ'1OBHOii IOCT
Ta6nlo1Ljil2 YCJlOBI'ISI npOBep,eHI'IOnepiITIo1BHO-
:;y;.&eiIof;H allTaMl1,
Ta6nLjil3npilBOBaSiOCHOBiI
0C)I1!I0CTBI1AE B CTpaHaX CHr 1'1 5anTHI'I
Ta6nlo1a4 3aOeonpelJ,e.neHl1e3aAa4
onepaTBHO-p<I3bI(;I(HoiilJ.eSlTe.nbHOCTI1
B Onepan'lBHO-pa3bICIIHbIX 3allOHaX CTpaH CHr 11 5anTHI1
Ta6nLjil5 Onpe.i:\eJ1BK'lBBCTpaHaXCHrl15annm
06S13i1HHOCTeii OpraHOB, 0CYIl\BCTBnSlIOLl\X OPA
Ta6Io1e=;;:H:'tP1'I6T11
Ta6nlo1Ljil7 COL1ilnbHilSlI1 npilBOBaI'l3i1Ll\TilAOnnLj
opraHOB, OCYl4eCTBnAIOI4X onepaTIo1BHo-pa3blCKHYIO
;:l'IcWHci;ao1-a;::T11 allTaM
Ta6nHa 8 COJJ,eiicTBHe rpa>K,!\8H onepaTBHo-pa3blcKHO
,/J,eATenbHOCHI npet1ycMoTpeHHOe3i1KOHoAilTe.nbHbIMIII
aIlTaM. perJlaMeHTl1pylOl4MIII OPA B CTpaHax CHr 1'1 5anT1'I
Ta6nHLja9 C0L1anbHO-npaBOBaA3al4TarpaH,
opraHaM. 0CYl4eCTBnAIOLl\M OPA, cornilCK03i1KOHilM.
peryI1l'lpylOl4M OPA B CTpaHax CHr 11 5aml1101
Ta6J13O:II1:T:r:"pbIX
B CTpaHax CHr III Eiam1II
Ta6J13OA=I'I:T:Y
BCTpaHaxCHrlllEiam1II
Ta6nl1L1i1 12 OnpeJJ,eneHllle 3aKOHOlJ,ilTeJleM B CTpaHax CHr
11 EiilnT BilpaHTOB IIIcnonb30BilHI'ISI pe3ynbTaToB OPA
Ta6nl'lLjil13 OpraHbl, CIC)II4BCTBIlROl4He OnepiITlo1BHO-pa3bICI\H)IIO
IJ,eATenbHocTbBCTpaHaXCHrl15aJm.111
Ta6nl1Lji114 npaBa oprilHOB. ()CYLl\eCTBnSlIOLl\X ()nepaTBHO-pa3bICKHYIO
AeATenbHOCTb,nHble3aKOHO.AaTenbHbIMIo1
aIlTaM. perJlaMeHTPYIOI..I.\e OPA B CTpaHax CHr 11 5anT11
Ta6I1e1T:=I:; CrH5nao:T:A
Ta6nl1L1a 16 KOHTpQ,l1b 11 HaJ:\30p3a onepaTBHo-pa3bICJ(HCIM
,/J,eATenbHOCTblO, npe.i:\ycMOTpeHHble 3i1KOHOJIiITenbHbIMI'I
aIlTaM. pernaMeHTpYIOI..I.\MIII OPA B CTpaHax CHr 11 5anT11
Ta6n11Lji117 4JI'IHaHCOBOe o6ecne4BHI1e onepaTBHQ-pa3bI(J(HCI
ABATBnbHOCTI1 B CTpaHax CHr 11 5anT11
3aKll104eHl'le
Cnl1coKnlo1Teparypbl
31
37
54
79
89
101
114
124
131
158
164
168
173
175