­

一

AKA4EMmH HAVK CCCP
I I H C T H Ty T H C T O P H I ' I

C.

M.

K A 皿 TA H O B

CO IMAAbH Ono入mTZIIE CKAH
ZCTOPZH POCCmm
KOHIﾘaXV-

nepBoiinoJIoBmHEIXVIB.
｡

麓
H34ATE｡TIbCTBO
MocKBa

"HAyKA"
1967

『

、

B

一

pa60Te llccJIe,nVIoTcFI

coUllanblIo-

3KOHOMH【IecKﾙIe OTHonIeHlIH B巾eo“JIbIILIX BJIaneHIMx, n0.mo>KeHMe TPynH皿ⅢxcH MaCC,

BHyTPeHHFIH

nOJIIITIIKa

nPaBH-

Te J I I 〕 C T B a H o c I I O B H b I e Te H 且 e 皿 皿 M S KO H O ­

MMIIeCKOrO

H

nOJII,ITHIIecKorO

cTl)aHbl. ABTop mIIpoKo

Pa3BIITⅢ，I

IIcIIoJIb30BaJ1

nPaBHTeJIbCTBeHHLIe rPaMOThl, KaK Ony6JIIIKoBaIIble, TaK I,I IIeony6JIIMKoBaHHble.

OTBETCTBEHI-IblH

PEZIAKTOP

00/tTop "cTop"咄ecIc"X HQl/瓦,4．J4. 3"M〃〃

畔
一
識

４
６

／

I

〃αj4兄T〃〃OeeO OT""
M.m.Kα"〃α"o8α
" Cbj〃αC""e"6x邸

B

C Ty n A E H Z E

HacToHIIlaH pa60Ta nocBflUeHa B nepBylo oqePemb lI3yrle-

HHIOCy,me6TaKOrOCOUIIaJIbIIO-HOJmPITMLIeCKOrOIIHcTHTyTa｡eoXaJIbHoi anoxII, KaK HMMyHIITeT. npocJIe氷HBaFI IICTOPHIo

IIMMyHIITeTa B POCcHH KoHUa XV­ⅡePBOii nOJIOBHHbl
XVI B., Mbl cTpeMIIJI｣Hcb pa｣ccMaTpIIBaTb HMMyHIITeTHylo IIoU

JIHTHKy B 'cBH3II C IPyrlIMII cTOPoHaMII BIIyTPeHHeHnoJIII;
THKHⅡPaBIITeJIbcTBa H B CBFI31i |c |cOUIiaJIb'HO-nOJIPITIIIIeCKOII
U

〆

CTPyKTyPOH OOmecTBa，

HapHny

c

BonpocaMHnePePa'onpeneJIeHHH

3eMeJIbHblX

巾O皿OB BHyTPH KJIacCa ｡eOnaJIOB, IIMMyHIITeTHafl HOJIIITHKa

npaBIITeJIbCTBa nPHHaXJIe>KaJIa K TeM caMblM >KIIBOTPe-

memy皿HM ,npo6JIeMaM巾eOnaJIbHOii XeiiCTBIITeJIbHOCTII,KOTOPble 3aTParmBaJIH KOPeHIIble HHTePecbl He TOJIbKO BCerO

KJIacca巾eonaJIoB B UeJIoM, Ho H orpoMHoro '60JIbmHHcTBa
⑥

HenOCPeX'cTBeHHblx nPoH3BO瓜HTeJIeH B IePeBHe m rOPOne.
>KaJIOBaHHblG H yKa3Hble lIMMyHHTeTHble rPaMOTbl, FIBJIHIO皿HecH IJIH KoHUa XV­ⅡepBO曲ⅡoJIoBHHbl XVI B. e"IHcTBeHHblM cKoJIbKo-HII'6yXb KoMnaKTHblM HcToIIHHKoM IIo IIcTo-

pHH
｡eonaJ1bHoro
IIMMyHIITeTa,
oTpa3H皿B
ceqc
KoMnJIeKC
叩e3BblIIaiiHo 3anyTaHHbIX II BMecTe c TeM KpamHe Ba>KHbl¥
coUliaJIbHo-3KOHoMII'IecKHx H ⅡOJIIITHIIeCKIIX nPOTIIBOPe[IHH

(beo"JIbHoro o6UecTBa. CTpe]IJIeHHe npaBHTeJIbcTBa K orpaHIIIIeHIIIO ,eOnaJIbHOrO mIMyHHTeTa, C O皿Oji CTOPOHbI, H
ⅡOnblTKH 3aPyIIHTbCH HO皿eP>KKOih KPynHblX (beO"JIOB,
ⅡPHBOXIIBmme B PfUe CJIyLIaeB K Pa'C皿IIPellIIIO HMMyHIITeTa,

c nPyrOih; 06mlm KyPC Ha 3aKPeno皿eHHe KPeCTbHHCTBa H B

To >Ke BPeMH coKPameHlie |ceHboPHaJIbHOih BJIaCTH巾eOna JIOB - 3TH II MHOTIIe nPyl､me nPOHBJIeHIIfl nPoTHBoPeIIIIBoTo

XaPaKTePa Pa3BHT皿巾eOna皿3Ma B XV-XVI BB. oIIeHb
HPKO 3ane[laTJIeJIIICb B IIMMyHHTeTHblx rPaMOTaX.
3

ToJIKoBaHIIerlpoHcxo>KnleHHHHcymHocTII*eo"JIbHoro
3MMYHIITeTaHaPyCHBHayqHOit"TePaType̅nOCmxmOP
U

OCTaeTCH nPenMeTOM 八IIcKyccHH. BoJIbmHH!cTBo cOBeTCKIIX
liCC,JIePPBaTeJIem OnPe4eJIHeT IIMMyHHTeT, KaK <<BHe3KOHOMH｡

ﾀ

IIeCKoe nPIIHy)KneHHe)' (几B̲IIePenHIIH 1 H nP) , IoP皿HIIecKoeBblpa>KeHHepeHTbl（C、B・IOmKoB)2C・BB,eceJIoB -

cKHiillli。Ⅲ、CMIIpHoBpaccMaTpIIBaIoTIiMMyHHTeTKaKH3L-

月THe申,eOnaJIbHblX
BJIaneHIIII
H3
KOMneTeHUlIII
oPraHOB
KHHU

⑪

zKecKoH BJIacTH, Ho no-pa3HoMy TpaKTyloT 'npo6JIeMy npoHcxo)KJIeHIIH II sBoJIIoUlM IIMMyHHTeTa 3, HeKoTopble coBpeMeHHbley[IeHble|cOMHeBaloTcHBcaMOihBO3Mo>KHoCTHnP'IIU

MeHeHIIH HOHHTIIH <<HMMy,HIMTeT)' K PycCKIIM conHaJIbHO-nO-

JIHTH'IeCKIIMOTHO皿eHHflM.Hgna>KeTeH3HJIx,KoTopblecLIHTaIoT, IITo《HMMyHMTeT)' IIa PycH KOPelll･lblM o6Pa36M O,TJ1HIJaJIcFI OT 3ana4HOrO《HMMyllllTeTa>, nOJIb3ylOTCH HblHe 3THM
TePMH|HOM IJIH xaPaKTePIICTHKH IopH41IIIeCIKorO CTaTyca, 3a･

KpeWIeHHoro B )KaJIoBaHHblx rpaMoTax (B. myJIbUH1p.)

MHorlle
3ana4HoeBponeiicKiie
mcTopmkm
paCtMaTpIIBiKIT
U

HMMyHHTeT B cpe"epeKoBoii 3ana"oM EBpone npe)KIe

BCerOKaKyCTynKy ｡eo"JIaM｡yHK皿力rocy八aPCTBeHHOiii
BJI a'CTHHⅡpHo6peTeHIie 3eMeJIbHbIMH co6cTBeliHHI(aMII DoJIII
Mec'1,HoH
HoH BJIacTH,
BJIacTH，He3aBHcHMoH
He3aBHcHMoA oT
oTKopoJIH.
KopoJIH、Cno3H瓜HH3ToH
C no3H
4

妙

U

U

KOH UenUHHBonPOC o Bo3MO)KHo'cTH nPHMeHeIHIIH ;noHHTMFI

<IIMMyHIITeT> K noJIﾙITHIIeCKI1M OTHOmeHHﾁIM B |cPeXHeBeKo-

BOii
PycH
HePe叩<O
PeulaeTcJI
OTPl皿aTeJIbHo.
HaH'60｡JIee
pe3Ko oTpImaeT HaJI|IIIIMe HMMyHHTeTa B PocclIH B. 6. E,ﾉIbHme-

BH1I.ErOToIIKa3peHIIHcBH3aHacnpencTaBJIeHHeMo60TcvTロ

ゴ

CTBHH巾eo"JIbHOii cO6cTBeHHoCTII Ha 3eMJIIo B POcCIili B

cpenIHMeBeKa4.B.myJIbU6JIII30KKEJIbH皿eBIIIIyBTOMoTHOmeHHIi, IITo OH He CLIIITaeT PyCcKOrO 3eMJIeBJI"eJIbna ｡eO"JIbHbIM CeHbOPOM; nO erO MHeHmlo, mMMyHHCT - He nPOMe)KyToIIHaH BJIacTb Mexmy KHH3eM H HaCeJIeH|HeM, a K"-

!J1.<,Bf･ q ef e |M JI H'PYEg<He *eonaJIbHbleapxHBbl XIV-XV BeKoB,
{1｣ 2. M.-J1', 1951, cTp. 109.

2C.BLlOmKoB"HcrOpmHrocy"pcTBaHⅡpaBaCCCP,u.1.M.,1940,
cTp. 79.

3C、B.B ep el9E c K II ii､KBonpocyonpoHcxo)KneHHHBoTKIIIHHoro
PgWiMa ": 1926, cTP 13, 23, 26 1i ";" .M C M Ii P H o B CynE5"R
1550 r.­《HCTOPHIIeCKIIe 3anHcKH>', T. 24, cTp、296; o H )K e. C IIo3If-

U"
｡XP>Kya3HOiimCTOPIIorpa*Iin­《BonpocbllIcTopHII)D,1948,JYblO,
cTp. 113-124.

4 B..B. EJIb月ⅡLe B II u1. IIcTopHH npaBa no3eMeJIbHoii co6cTBeHHocTIIB

R9pclim,
[LLnapm>K,1948,tTp・17,65,111-113,251,268,303,305,
386．
4

一

に

>KeCKII# are|HT, Ue〃HKOM 3aBII'cIIMblii oT KHFI3FIHⅡO cBOeMy

noIJIo>KeHPIIo 6JIII3KH# K KopMJIeHIIIIIKy 5. CxonHbli, xoTfl II
He TO>KZIGCTBeHIIblii Te311C BblnBHraeT P. ByTPIOm.OI-IBI皿HT
OTJIII'1me PyCCKoro HMMyHIITeTa OT 3analHOrO B HaJIIIIIIM
KoHTpoJIFI HaJ IIMMyHHTeTHbIMH BJIaneHIIHMII 'co 'cTopOHbI

K">KecKoii BJIacTII II B oTcyTcTBIHII 3necb cKoJIbKo-HII6ynb

Pa
3BHTOrO巾eOntaJ1H3Ma
6.
X. mblol1, FIBJIRIo皿嘘CH cTOPoHHII|KOM KOHUe'皿戒C. B. BeCeJI OBICKOrOHn>K. BJIIoMa, He nPoBo皿TnPHHUlmmaJ1bHorO
Pa3JIH[IIIH Me>Kmy PyoCIKIIM II 3ananHblM IIMMyHIIITeTaMH, CIIII-

TaH, qTo Cy皿HOCTb lJMMyHHTeTa lCO'CTOHT B H3EHTHII巾eOXaJTbHblx BJIaneIHHi H3 KOMneTeI-IHIIII oPraHoB rOcynaP|CTBeHHOii BJIa'cTH, a ca'M IIMMyHHTeT HBJIHeT,CH 'HCToIIHI'IKOM !叩HBIIJIerHi 7.

Be3ycJIoBHo, Heo6xo皿MO yIIIITblBaTb CneUII'｡IIKy Pa3-

BIITHH I,IMMyHHTeTa |B |cTpaHax 3analHoii EBponbI II 'B Poc­
c'HII. OJHaKo, ecJIH paccMaTplIBaTb KopHPI H cymHocTb 9Toro
＝

HBJIeHIffI,

MO>KHO,

KaK

HaM

Ka>KeTcH,

y|cTa|HOBIITb

OO皿yIo

n P l I P O n y 3 a n a n H b l x I I P y c c K H x I I M M y H I I Te To B 、

C Hanleii ToIIKI1 3peHHH, HMMyHIITeT ecTb peaJIH3aUHFI
3KOHOMHIIeCKOii BJIaCTIi巾eOJaJIa MeTOnaMII BHe3KOIIOMHIIe-

CKOrO nPlI'IIy>KIeH'IIHⅢ旧oJIHTwIecKOe rOcnoIcTBo *eO"JIa
B nPeneJIax CBOero BJIaleHH月KaK 'HaII60JIee O6皿ee npOHB､IIeHIIe BIIe9Ko|HoMIILIe'cKoro nPIIHy>KneHIIH.

noJ1HDIit wIH IIacTH[IHbli oTKa3 ny6JIHIIHoi BJIalcTH oT
cBoHx rOcynaP'CTBellHblx nPaB 'B oTHomeHIIII巾eoXaJIbHO3a〃

BHcHMOrO HaCeJIe'HH兜(T.

e.

<<'HMMyHPI|TeT> B y3KOM 'CMblCJIe

cJIOBa) , paBHo KaK H KoHcTIITymPOBaHHe nplIBIIJYerlIPOBaHHOrO CTaTyca caMOrO I'IMMyHHCTa, eCTb Hell|36e>KHOe CJIenCTBMie j)eoXaJIbHOih 3KoHoMIIKH.

Maplcc HoKa3aJI, qTo <<Bo Bcex ｡opMax, npH KoTopbIx He-

nOCPenCTBeHHbliiPa60THHKOCTaeTCH,,BJIaneJIbUeM$&CpeXCTB
⑪

〆

nPoH3BOn'cTBa 'II y'cJIOBHHTPyna, HeOOxoIHMblx IJIFI nPOII3-

BOJcTBa cPeXcTB ero CO6cTBeHHoro |cymeCTBoBalIHfl)>, |npH6aBoqHbIii npoXyKT EJIFI HOMIIHaJIbHoro 3eMeJIbHorO co6cTBeHHIIKa

MO>KHo

Bbl>KaTb

H3

H e r o く To J I b Ko

BHe9KoHOMIIIIe­

一

5 W. S c h u l z. Die lmmunit5t im Nord6stlichen Russland des l4. und

15. Jahrhunderts.­《Forschungen zur
Bd. 8. Berlin, 1962, S. 265-269 .

Osteuropdischen

Geschichte>,

6 R. B o u t r u c h e. Seigneurie et feodalit6. Paris, 1959, p. 1 18, 120,
258,259.
7 Horace W. D e w e y.
Immunities
vol･XXIII, 1964, p､644, 651.
5

in Old

Russia.­《Slavic
、

Review",

I

CKIIM nPHHy>KXeHHeM> 8．3KOHOMHIIeCIKa兜 Ⅲ ⅡOJIHTHIIecKaR

BJIa
cTb巾eonaJIa
npaKTHqecKII
IIepa3neJIIIMbl.
OTcIona
Tpyn-

HOcTbOnPeneJIeIHII月HMMyHIHTeTacTOIIKII3PeHIIHCOBPeMeHHblX nOHHT" 06 3KOHOMINeCKIIx II HOJIHTiiLIGCKHx OfHome-

HIIHx. BHe皿He lIMMVHIITeT BblPa)KaeT TOJIbKO HoJIHTHIIecKoe
rOCnOnCTBO 3eMJIeBJIaXeJTbna lI ,CTeneHb ero He3aBIIIcIIMO'CTPI
⑥

oTI1y6JIHIIHoiiBJIacTI'I,HoHocy皿ecTByHMMyHIITeTHeJIb3FI
noIIHMaTb KaK HcKJIIoIIIITeJIb'Ho HoJIIITIIIIe'cKoe HBJIGHIIe: '6V|nqPOXAeH CaMOII cTPyKTyPO
ⅡyⅧ|ⅡOPO>K且eHCaMOHcTPyKTyPOh巾eOHaJIbHOh巾OPMbl
3eU

MeJIbHOii
'cO6CTBeHHoCTII,
OH
(､&ﾉIy>KIIT
CPen･cTBOM
PeaJIPI3aUIIII
nPoII3BoHCTBeHHblx OTHomeH" BHyTPH ｡eO"JIbHOrO BJIaneHIIH .

nocKoJIbKyIIMMyHHTeTnpencTaB&ITHJI'co60iicIHcTeMV|conHaJlbIIo-JIOJIHTII1IeCKHx oTIIOmeH", cymecTBoBaB皿Hx Me>K-

且y
*eOnaJIOM-3eMJIeB@II"eJI皿eM,
KPe|CTbHHcKHM
HaCeJIeHHeM erO BJIaneHIIH II rOCynaPCTBOM, OH HBJIHJIIcH cBOe℃6Da3A

HblM巾OKyCOM,
KOTOPoM
B
cKPe皿IIBaJIH'Cb
nPOTHIBOPeIIHBble
｡

Te皿eH皿HPa3BHTIIFI巾eOnaJIDHOH
3KOHOMHKHHrocynap④

CTBeHHOH neHTP aJIII3aUHI1.

npoUecco6pa30BaHIuIneHTpaJIH30BaHIIororocVXapcTBa
myeJIIBeocHOBHbleCTOPOHbI:Bo-nePBbIx,TepPmTojIiajIbHoe
＝

00'LenIHHeHIIe, BO-BTOPblx, cO3JaHIIe UeHTPaJIH30BaHHOro an-

IIaPaTa neHTPaJIbllOrO II MecTHOrO ynpaBJIellMH・3Ta BTOPaFI
cToPoHa" nPOUecca UeHTPaJIII3amlII HePa3pblBHO cBH3aHa C
HCTOPIIeH OrPaHPIqeHHH巾eonaJIbHoro IMMMVHHTeTa. Ho 3BoU

JIIoIIHH IIMMyHIITeTa npOIIcxoXHJIa He TOJIbKO HoI BJIIIHHIIeM
nOJI HTHKHⅡeHTPaJIDHOH BJIacTH-OHa B eme 60JIbmeii
⑥

U

MePeOnPeXeJIHJPCbxonPMCOUHaJIbHO-3KoHOMIIIIecKOrOPa3BHTIIH cTpaHbl. B UeJIoM )Ke 3BoJIIoUHFI IIMMyHIITeTa Bx6"T
B 'IHcJIo 3KoHoMIIIIecKIIx H nOJMTIIIIeCKIIX nPennO|CbIJIOK
cKJIanblBaHIIH a6､coJIIoTII3Ma
U

BPyccKoHHcToPHorpai)I1HXIX­Ⅱa1laJIaXXB.'H3yYIe-

HHeHMMIHIiTeTaBeJIocbrJIaBHblMo6Pa30MBIOpH瓜Ⅲ可elcKoM
nJIaHe: 06mHe KOIIUenUHII IIMMyHIITeTa He CO[IGTaJIH'Cb !C IMCCJIenoBaHHeM erO HCTOPHH, coRep>KaHHe oTUeJIbHblx HoPM
nPaBa BblHcHHJIocbnyTeM
BblHcHHJIocb nyTeM
cBe且eHI畑
cBeX6HIIH
BoeユHHOʻⅡo．Ka3aHHH
Boe"HO Ho･Ka3amm
U

rpaMoTpa3Hblx3nox.nepe>KHTKIIsToroHJIJIIocTpaTHB.HoIOP"HqecKOrqMeIOna gaMeTHbl H |B IIeKOTopblx 60JIee no3m-

HHx Tpynax (A 3Ka, B. B EJIbHmeBHLIa A 4p.) 9.

%IgiapKcmOaljreJIbc Cpq2T.25:[L 11,cTp353
99 Q･30R｡ mCmPmorPa4)III! cIL: II B q e p e nh II"m̅ykaa co[I" [L 2,
Wp̲97-1 U;o I{>K gnl)06J1eMaKpe6TbfnicKoro3aKPenolli6HIimi

POCCHII
OCBe山eHHII
B
6yPjKya3Hoii
HcTopHOrpa*IIH.­〈<KpHTHKa
6yi).
6

BOJIbmaH 3aCJIyra B H3yqeHH｝I >KaJIOBaHHblx rPaMoT
XIV-XVI BB. npHHaXJIe>KIIT C. B. BeceJIoBcKoMy, nonbl-

TaBmeMycH, xoTH !I He BnoJIHe ycnemHO, nPeOIoJIeT. 2WU

HII[IeHHdCTb IIJIJIIOCTPaTHBHOrO MeToXa lI yFIcHIITb Ba>KHell5
mHe Te|HneHIIIm Pa3BIITHH IIMMyHI1TeTa B |CBR31I C II'CTOPlIelI
U

TFITJIa l0.

U

CoBePmeHHo HoBbli lI BecbMa nJIoXoTBopHblII nonxoX
K aHaJIH3V
aHaJIIi3V HHC|HHTe3y
CIHHTe3yMaTePHaJIa
MaTe”aJIa＞KaJIOBaHHblX
>KaJIOBaHHblX "rPaMOT
rPaMOT
XIV-XV BB. HaxoⅡHMy几B. qepenHIIHa, KoTopblII BnepBble liCCJIe,IoBaJI HMMyHIITeTHyIo nOJIIITIIKy KHH>KeCKmx nPar
BIITeJIbcTB II yCTaHOBIIJI IIOJIIITIIIIeCKIIe nPli[IIIIHbl Bbma1IH
凹

U

PmarPaMOT11.

U
U

B 60BpeMeH|Hoi coBeTcKoi JIHTepaType >KaJIoBaHHblM

rPaMOTaMnPOHOJI>KaeT
rDaMoTaMⅡPO且OJI》KaeT
yXeJIFITbCR
yユeJIHTbc兜60JIb皿oe
60JIb
BHIIMaHHe:
OHII
』

ITPlIBJIeKalOTCFI
nJIH
II3yrleHIIfl
HCTOPlIⅢ巾eOnaJIbHOTO
3eMJIeBJIameHIIHHmMMyHiiTeTa,
KPe'CTEFIHcTBa,
rOPOnpB,
"HaH'COB, MeCTHOTOH ueHTPaJIbHoro ynPaBJIeH", ̲pHXTIlgH-

Heii nOJIHTHKII (几 B qePenHKH, A jLTOPCKmit, E E l<9U

mrM̅6aiaijoE,H "E Ho6oB, A A ̅3mMIIH II mP) 12

>Kya3HblX
KOHUe皿11ii
lICTOP"
POCClⅧⅡePIIOna
｡eOmaJI"Ma》M.,
1962,cTp.56-74,78­80,89mⅡP.;C.M.KamTaHoB.K[IcTo"9rpa'巾""KPenOCTHOrO
nPaBa
a20Cg叩.一《HCTOPIIH
mCTOPmKI12.
m
C.

cTafen.M.,1965,cTp、270-312;WSchulZ.Op.cit,S.57-861
HW・Dewey. Op・cit.,p、643-659 .

X
cKme
"px"Bb[
*eO"e
C.B'!
XIV-XV
Io
ʼʼJI
B，IIepenHHH・PyccKIie巾eo“JIblﾙIeapxʻHBbl
BeKoB,B
eceJIo,BcKHii・yKa3、coLI．
XIV-XVBeKoB，
【1. 2, cTp. 112-225̲

12 jl 'B :[l e p e n H II H O6pa30Ba¥me. RMpcKoro neHTWaJI"WWIR.I:]:
u

cyJapcTBabXIV-XVBeKax.M・,1960;o>K
He.AiKToBbliiMaTepHaJI
"̅ff5"Km m6ToPIIH pyccKoro KpecTbHHcTBa XV q､H3 MFTqp皿【

,ii56"""EHLIX CI!j! ""399nCT"H"̲OWgnWi)­<np o6JIe-

MbllICTOIIHHKOBeneHII月》,̅TJIVM,1955,cTp307-342;Ant､roP
cK|H iM．UIMSkmMAlleCIforqlll"cI>KeH"KPecTbHH､ Cepe"BggM:
｣

HoM PycH XIV-XV ̲ "．M,1960(cM.pengH31IIPA.A31IM"aB
U

《"T6" CCCP", 1962, Jvb 4) ; IJ､ E K o "1̲C""g̲WfiWp
Ha
PycHBnemoⅡo6pa30BaHIiH
PyccKoroneHTpaJm30ʻBaHHoro
rocy-

naPCTBa･KoHdIXIIIIIaqaJIoXVIB.M､一J1.,-1965;10.r.AneK-

6̅a̅6B. BojlocTE B nepeHcJIaBcKoM ye3Xe XV B.­《Bonpocbl aKoHo-

MIWII "EtmII oTH6meHMii B PycbKoM rocy"pcTBe XII-XVII Be-

60；oH〉Ke．①eoユaJYbHo3aBH“Mble
Hatlala
XVKOB>.
lIHHenepeHcJIaBcKoro
AIVI
M.一JT・"5
nepe,TcjiaBcKdro
ye3na
ye3且aXV­HaKIaJIa
XVIB.­《HccJIe且oBaHHH
KpecTbHHe
BoTB
i6.̅m""̅4)EOnaJIbHb"enOCTHHqecKOiP"C"¥nM:一J1.,1964;
61! ,"'WfPamM̅I CoUiiaJ,bHam lIFTOPILH gWPp9-ERcTR"9i P"
XV-XVI BBg. nep]IaBcKIiii yeaA̲M一几, 1966; A M・CaxapoB.
rdpo"CeBepo-BocToqHoii pycII XIV-XV BeKo2.M., 1959; H. E. H ou

66K'Oqe,)KII:nOHcTopm,iMe6TH｣qrOylLPaW"IIH｡PXCCKOm̲IPCy"pRW
A

mom ̅iBMiIBrXVl. Be""-̅m, 19574̲4:̲A2" WW!;.p"92
p

MEI I'IBaHa rPO3HOrO．M.,1960;o H>K e.OnpHIIHMHaliBallarpo37

I

3"IITC"BHOe
BHIIMaHIieynCmeTcm
BCOBeTCKO#HCTOU

PIIOrPad)IIII
MeTO皿KeI旧y[IeHI'IH
>KaJIOBaHHblx
rpaMOT
13.

n9W,､¥3na¥"<:rnaMoTBcJIIII(6RMM6pM"#n6KoBa>(1949),<<AKToB巾eO"JIbHOrO
3eMJIGBJIaneHHH
xoII

3”CTB”（ILI-III，1951-1961)，くAKToBco皿aJIbHo-3Ko"QTBa>
(FJ-III, 1951-1961), "AKT6g̅E5RRMH6Laf5¥WwgWWT9plim CeBePo-B9"qHoih Pycli> (TJ-m,
④

1952W= (9" J"'' Bce ̲ akTbi XiV aiMaHWi nr6

l506!M.UWWipo
ony6JIIIKOBa"EIMIIWMc626M
;bXW

rpa巾函"9M"YEQEHe
BJ<OMnaKT¥9M
H
BIme,
WTo
KPaiiHe
o6JIertIaeT
pa60Ty
HIIMH
c rpaMoTbiXVi
g.g皿e
PaCnblJIeHbl
⑥

noMHOroIIHCJIeHHblM
aPXIIBa狐ⅢⅡy6JIMIKamIHM.
HocJIeXB
Hee
BPeMFI
H34aH
xPOHOJIOrHIIeCK城ⅡePerleHb
BblJTBJIeHHblx

HMMyIMTeTHblx rPaMoT 3a l504­Ⅱa[laJTo l584 rr. 14

EWWWIETe"bWoKXII-XV"M56Hbi6Bonpocb{
⑥

licTOPIiII IIMyyIIITeTHOih noJIHTIIKII HamJIH OCBemeHIIe i M5=

HorPa巾ⅡⅡ几
B.
LIepenHI,IHa
15､To
CII｣cTeMaTHIIeCKOi
Da3Da⑥

〆

OOTKH HCTOP皿mMMyHHTeTa B KoHne XV-nePBo# nojIoBHHe XVI B. HeT.
U

HMelo皿皿CH
IIETOPMorPa巾HH
B
OnblIH3yIIeH"
IIMMyHIITeTHblx
aKToB XVI
B
(Tpynb[ B A MIIJIIoTIIHA,

A
aHoBa,̅irErmEMBeceJIoBcKoro，
M
HpHoBa,
MM.Cn
aKoBa,
Ell B"nOBoJIbHO
皿11．CMHpHoBa，B
PoMaHoBa，H
A
HocoBaHⅡp)
E
2a3HOcTOPOHeH, O"aKO HeXoCTaTOqHOcT5 6r6
ouIe．BHⅡHa．、Pe>K瓜e
Bcero〉KanoBaHHbIeII
yKa3HblerPaMOTbl

KoHnaXV-nePBOAnoJIoBHHblXVIB.HeIIccJIemogaHbIBo
Horo．M.,1964;C.O.mMⅢ且T.
npeJIn()CblJTKI,IルI
nePBblGrOntbl
<Ka3aHcKoi gPiiIIbl" ( 1545-1549) .

3aHcKoH
Bo師b”（1545-1549).­《Tpynbl
̅Mbo"bf6M6Hi
EMa̅
*r9"MgnpW̲II"
MrlIAII",
WI
Pbccm!
mITJIIITePaTyPe･­<gOBeTcI<al
!ICTOPmqeCKam
HayKa
bTXX̅KX"""

H〉Ke・BoⅢpocblHcTopHHPoccmT
o
HoBoHHcTopmIIecKoH
BeKa
XVI
B
u

⑪

KnCC茅.M., 1962.

HEHocoB．《HoBoG)D
13
HanpaBJIellHe
aKToBoM
B HcToIIIIHKoBeﾉ〔eHHH.一
《n29"""cToIIHlIKoBe4eHiI", m X M,1@"̅ 6.fi. X.E:6.MMIMF
【IecKOM
MWQJe̲
aKTPBOM
P HcTOIIHIIKOBGIGHIm.­《BonpocblaIDxHBoBelleHm",1962,M4;AA3HMmHOM5f6ⅡHKeaKToBoroH,cToqHⅢ"e¥"̲2̲P26gW nO HCrPPIIM MecTIIOrO ynPaB""̅p6c2"i6;叩

BoIIHoJIoBIIHbIXVIB.­《Bonpocb!apxIIB6BMeHm",196Z̅̅Nri;
g̲ji̲Ka m T a H o B K Bonpo6y ̅6̅ Kji58"""&1 66"BJIM

"r9JIoBKOB)Ka'IIQBaHHhIxrPaMOT­《HcTopHqecKIIfiapxllB>,1956,
U

W;""
'"̲̲p9ETaq
'Mi'y¥IifETIImf̅MM5f:､､ifMHn(》､noBHʻHbl
XVI
BeKa.­《ApXeorpa(I)IIIIecKIIii
eﾝKeroIIHIIK
3a
l962
ToJ)D.
M.,
1963;
9"9fMWi" "aniie !! !13yqC"5.M(illiRO"6 M";":¥;1
plm
PoccIIH
XVI
B．(B
̲ngPJIeBOeHHble
rOmJ1)一<E>KeI､"HIIK
arPaPII(!
IX" mpT"" BocToIIHoii
EBponb!
HoHHcTo”H
BocTouHoAEBpoⅡH・1962
r.>
MHH|cK,
1964.
U

b

い

'4 Xn, 1, 1I.

15几
W :J e" " Pyccwe *e̅jHb,｡ ｡Px,iBb! XIV-XV ,eKoB,
[1. 2, cTp. 97-225.
8

之

BCeHmxcoBoKyHHocT肌A'6e3TaKoro
KoMⅡJIeKcHoro
aHaJIII52̅neMO)KeT6blTbyBePeH'HO;CTIIBIOCTOBePHOCTIIBblEglm
U

iOmeHHblx
Pa3JMfIHbIMm
aBTOPaMm
""9WHH6oJIee

一

ii"' MeHee IIjiJIIocTPaTHBHOTo nPHBJIeLIeHIIfIHMMyHIITeT"IL

fPaMom K ToMy >Ke mccnemoBaTe"lWOg"",MW
XVI
06IJIqIHo
B.
toBepmeHHo
npeHe6pera"HⅡPO6JIeMO竹npoIIcxO>KneHHRⅡo6he"IIIx.3ToHeTdnbKoKpaiiHeo6eXHHJIo
TeMaTHKy
nPOII3BeneHHH,
nocBHmeHHblx
>KaJIoBaHHblM
rpaM6TalM,
MOTaM，Ho
HaKJIa及blBaJIoʼcxOJIaCTHlIIeCKHHʼOTⅡeUaToK,Ha
H
iloilHaKJIaXblBaJIocxOjlaCTMIleCK"OmeW9K"
U

四

allaJIII3HxcOXeP>KaHliH,TaKKaKIOPH瓜mIIeCKIIeHOPMblrPa-

MOT
PaccMaTPIIBaJIHCbII30JIHPOBaHHO
KOHKPeTHblX
OT
O6CTOHTeJIb℃TB,
b6yCJIOBHBmHX
BKJIIOIIeHIIG
B.
Ka>KnlyIq
"HHyIO

MW"6"6 Tex, a He mHbIx cTarei ̲(Wy3YJl:
“

yKa3aHHOe COCTOHHIIe HCTOPHOrPa巾皿 Honpe八eJI皿O

3anaqIIHaCToHmerOllcCJIenOBaHIIH:Bo-nepBbIx,M3ymWg

ndJiIITHqecKIix nPHqllH nOfIBJIeHIIH MMMyHIITeTHbIx rPaMOT
1492-1548 rr., Bo-BTopblx, aHaJIII3 Hx conep>KaHIIfI c ToIIKII

3PeHmHTOrO,KaKIieli3MeHe"HBHOcIIJIHO"̲5̲W9>"WE
dieOgaJIbHOrO mMMyHIITeTa PemeHye nocT"e"IM"H

ieJIOCbBPaMKaxIICCJIemOBaHIIHo6皿HXBOnPOCOBIICTOPHII
BHyTPeHHeII
IIO皿ITIIKHHCOⅡHaJIbHO-nOJIIHTHIIeCKIIX
OTHOU

U

meHHH・

rJIaBbl l-III pa60Tbl HannCallbl a,BTopoM B 19661967rr.IIny6JIHKyIoTc兄BnePBble.rJ1aBbllV-VIflBJIHIoTgH
⑫

HCnpaBJIeHIIblMIIH瓜OnOJIHeHHI)IIMIIBaPlIa'HTaMHTPeXcTaTelI,

ony6皿KOBa|HHblXpaHee16ⅡPyrlIeCTaTbIIJaBToPa,nOcBFI凹

皿eHHEIeHCToPHH巾eOnambHorOHMMyHHTeTaBnePBQⅢnOJIO-

EIMXVIB,B̅KimryHeBomJIII!7.BonpocaMco6cTBeHHo
16C､M･KamTaHoB、OrpaH”eI班e中eo“JIbHoroHMMyIIPITeTaⅡpaBH-

TEjIEBMmrpyCCKOrOUeHTPaJIm30Ba"OrqrggynaPQT""-OiITPeTI'
XVIBGKa.­《TpynhIMM4m"､T11．M.,1958,cTp.269-,296;o,H>Ke.

HMMvHIITeTIIblerpaMoTbl
l534-HaIIaJIa l538 rona KaK I"IcToLIHI,IK no
-

HcTOPl畑BHyTl〕eHHelInOmlTIIKII
Bne”O瓜PereHTcTBa
EneHbl
rJIⅡH⑥

cKoH､一《npo6JIeMbl
lMcToIIHIIKoBe八eHIm》,
V111.
T. M.,
1959,
cTP、372U

4"̅O H )k e "onaJIbHbIii mMMyHMTeT B rOnlbl .9HPCKOW､""eHI11
U

1
(538-1548rr.).一くHCTOPlWecKIie3anIICKm>>,T､66,cTp.239-268.

17C. M・K a lH Ta H o B. H3 HcToplIII JIocJIeXH1Ix ̲̲yneJI9B.一《TpymbI
，

MTIIAH>,T.10.M.,1957,cTp、275-302;oll)Ke.Knpo6JIeMenpQIiCxo>皿eHI胴巾eOJIa､mbHOTO
I(MMyHIITeTa.­くHcTOPlIIIeCKIMe
'HayXH》,
1959,
Nb4,cTp・rO6=121
O;H
)Ke..MOHacTblPCKmiiiIMMyHIITeTBHMIITpoBu

BonpocbI
coIIIIaIIbHo-3KoKioMIiqecKoE JIcTopmII ![ IIcToKIE
cKoM
yxeJIe.­《Bonpocbl
coⅡHaJIbHo-3KoHoMHqecKoHIIcTopI,IHIIlにTOKI-

imf6B&"" nepmoha (jeogaml3Ma B̲Ppc*'Ja622HIII( cTaTeff
76:EM5.X XW656cejIbckorQ M) 1961, cTP 25-29; o H )K e nBe

>KaJIoBaHHble
rpaMoTbl
l510
rona
npKQBClfIIM
MoHacTbllWM.­《3
anlIcKII

oT八WM5111fei̅rricynapcTEeHHoh
6m6JIIIoTeKI!
IIM
B
H
JIeHI1Ha)',
9

「

皿ⅡJIOMaTHIKH》¥aJIoBaHHbIx
rpaMoT
(HcTopIIII
!Ix
dispositio,

narratiO
HTユ)aBToPHaMePeBaeTcimOd""TMmmE
HOe HCCJIenOBaHHe

¥lWJg"̲
KaqecrBe
B
caMOpTofITeJIbHoronPenMeTa

H3yqeHKH IIMMyHIITeTHblx rpaMoT 1 492-1 548 rr. IIM6efcBoM

92"aH" B 3Tmx xpoHojQrHqecKIIx paM"̅ b6imAM
〆

r2aMOTbl TPex nePlIO,瓜oB: 1492-1505, 1505-1537 H1538-

548
1
rr・nepBblHⅡePHoユーsTo
BPeIMH
PemHTeJIbHoii
JIoMKII
"M WM."JaJIPJIOro IIMMymITCTABo BT6"̅i6FM
U

⑪

⑥

cy,Ⅱb6b] myMyHIITeTa 6blJTII B 3IfaqIITeJIEM IIEKM;M
U

U

＆

M9TQp"̲nocJIe"" Kpyn"x yneJIoB O6pa@oBaHHble B

l1594nnonyxoBHoiHBa"III̅yiamgiomj1mHxcblHoBeiHBJIHJIHcbo6'beKTaMI!BecEMa-aifTTIMHnOJIHTHKH
WWWW npaBwTembcTBaBcecJIo)KHbleBHyTplmoJMT""e co6blTIIH H B TQM %Ie BblmaIly !IMMMMiEb<
ジ
WMW"̲lIoHHTb 6e3 yqeTa aToiMcTpoii 60pb6b! c
⑪

｡

yneJIbHoKHHiKeCKHM cenaPaTII3MoM, B KoToPbii Ha6TVnmJIo
⑪

lI2EecTIIoe3aTlUlbeTOJIbKoBpe3yJIbTareJI11KB皿an血MH-

Te)Ka AH4peH CTapmUKoro B i537̅E1M=iMH­Ⅱe!WWWWm9JOcTa "li91jaCrbIPcKMx TaPxaHHbIx nPmBHJIerIIH，ⅡpepBaʻBmHHcH
BI549r.，Koma
KBJIacTHⅡ”mJIo
U

U

nPaBHTeJIbCTBO H36PaHHOii Panbl.

ABTopBbIpa)KaeT6JIaromaPiIocTbAA3HMIIHv3anoご

cToJIHHoe nPy)KecKoe BHIIMaHIIe.
U

ABTOP
BCerma
omymaJI
nO瓜瓦eP>KKy
cTOPOHbl
'co
TOBaPH-

meHⅡQ CeKTopy mfT9p" gPCP nepHo" ｡ednaJIII3Ma lIH-

cTHFXT"cTopIIH AII CCCP II BceX cBOiix ｣J;pjM
⑪

pH瓦HcToIIHHKoB6bIJIJIo6e3HoyKa3aHaBTopyC､HBaJIKoMLA. A. 3HMIIHblM,几 ZHBIi,Hoi,BA: . KyIIKHHblM,

B
UHa3apoBblM)BHqj"opeXX 几XopomKeBHIIII
mPyrHMH cnenHaJIHCTa MII
yKa3aTeJIbKKHIIrecocTaBJIellH.g.KpaAHeBoii.
⑪

BLIn.
24．M.,
1961,
cTl).
221-258;
o
H
>K
e．OTI)a>KcHIIG
B
>Ka.ⅣoBaHHblx
MnMKWW WWaX ""f9"̲C'icTeMbl Py6CKoro̲rOby"6"":
Bo力TBo#TpeTIIXVIB.­《PIcTppmqecKIIe
3amicI(Ii,x
70;̅"j̅25r-W;
叩

I司ﾉza8aI

BHyTPEHHHH HO八mTHKA

mのEO4AAbHblHⅢMMyHZTET
B 1 4 9 2 - 1 4 9 7 r r.

＊

3BO､IIOlMH巾eonaJIbHoro IIMMyHMTeTa B ycJIoBI'iflx cKJIa@r
U

1blB
aH}呪
ueHTP
aJIH30Bal-IHOI､O
rOCynaPCTBa
flBJ1HeTCH
OIHOII
mg̅Ba>KiJbIXnPo6JIeM
H3Ba>KʻHblxⅡpo6JIeM
coUIIaJIbHoH
coUIIaJIbHoii
HⅡomITHIIecKoH
IInomlTHqecKoiI
HcTo四m
IIcTQp"
POccmmCynb6b[IIMMyHIITeTaTecHbIMo6pa30McBfI3aliU̲̲c
HCTODHehPa3BIITWI
nPOII3BOユHTeJIbHblx
'cPIJI,
npOH3BOIcTBeHU

U

HblX"OT|HO皿eH皿IIToCynaPcTBeHHOHCTPyKTyPbl.
Bo6皿eM
KyPCe
BeJIMIKOKHH>KecKOHⅡOJIHTIIKII
OTHOmeHTIe
⑪

KqMImbWIIMMyHKTeTyHB*CbBQnP9Cgy̲PWWi

Ba
>KHoCTH．npHcoe且HHeHIIe
BeJIHKHX
yneJIbHblX
II
KHfDKeCTB
＝

⑪

K MocKoBcKoMy BeJIIIKoMy KHH>KecTBy np"cTaBJIHJIo cooQm
TOJIbKo oIHy cToPOHy UeHTPaJIIj3anIIII PYCCKOro rOWaPCr
U

○

U

Ba.BTopoii, He MeHee cJIo>KHoII 3anaJIeII,9To貝BmeHⅡepeX
ggjIIn<6ifHH>keckIIMnpaBIiTeJIbcTBoM,6biJIa60pb6a3aorpa哩

HII'IeHHe巾eo"JIbHorO IIMMyHIITeTa. OT Hee 3aBIIceJIo BHyTU

PeHHee
peHHee
VKpeⅡJIeHHeⅡpaBHTeJIbcTBeHHoH
ykPenJIeHme nPaBIiTeJIbcTBeH:Hqj
BJIacTH，KoHUeHTB""LIWIW
U

U

PaUIIH B ee PlllfaX rJIaBHeIImIIX HKTeii rOCynaPCTBeHHOrO
U

jnpaBJIeHIIH ̅ npm ｡eonaJIm3Me HeBo3ml"" ̲̲WWW

ueHTp
a皿3a皿H
bJIacTH,
TaK
KaK
B
cmJIy
｡eOnaJIbHOih
cTPyK-

Typbi 3eMeJILHoii co6cTBeHHocTH caMI] npQllaEQJEWW

oTiIomeHIIH ｡eonaJIbHorO cTpoH HocHT <<HenocpencTBeHHQ)'
n OJI IITH 'IeCKHHxaPaKTeP 1, T. e. nPeⅡnOJIaraloT cOCPeXOTOIIeU

iim6̅B pyKax ｡edXaJIa̅- B ToMKJImmHoMo6'beMe =IW⑨

naPCTBeHHblx
*yHK皿H皿H
OCymeCTBJIeHHH
BHe3KOHoMHIIe6K6ro npIIHy>KneH".Peqb, TaKIIM.o6pa30M, npJI>KHaH八Tm
O

CTeneHH

⑪

OTHOCIITeJIbHOH ueHTPaJIII3aUPIII

nOJIIMTHIIeCKOii BJIaCTH, O C T e n e H II OrPaHIIIIeHHR巾eOnaJIbHOTo IIMMyHHTeTa.

' K.MaPKcHm.3HreJIbc.Cou.,'r. 1,cTp.403
11

1.CocToHHIIecy4e6Horo
M TaMoJXeHHoro MMMyHMTeTa

BHepBojilIoJIoBMHe90-xro40B

nJIH
TorO,
LITO6bl
llPenCTaBIITb
Ce6e
co皿aﾉIbHylOPOJIb

!Wa""̲liMMyHIIT<Ta B HaqajrerXWrMMTM2
U

:"vWWWjWK9j̲BJIaCTH nO oTHOmenIIIO k̅ ̅feM7,

HeO6HeO6XO瓜HMO
6POCIITb
B3rJI兄及Ha
3BOJIIO瓜HHHMMyHHlITorII
TeT4 K KoHny nPenmecTByIoulerO cTOJIeTIIH.

D

E̲"mo4 K">KcH" iiBaHa mW6Mh nomiaTHofo liMWWeTAWWJIaJ"3y BecbMa 3IIailiTeJIbilbix OrPami-

[IeIIeHH#.
rPaMOTbl,巾I,IKcIIpylo皿IIe
ocBo60>Kn(eHHe
HMMyIIIIIEWX BJIaneHIm
TeTHblx
BJIa且eHHH
OT
OT
QEHOBHblx
OCHOBHblxnO3eMeJIbHblX
nO3eMeJIbilbIXHaJIOrOB
Ha"ME̅̅h
H

WWWx̲UW#; m¥H,､III BblnaBaJI rJIaBHbIM JM
3032MTW"ronoB XV B 3a 60-e romEMMMTTi;;＝

" III m3BecTHO OqeHb Ma｡mO 2 a 3aT49Fi505̅fr"HeW
xP"IIJWcbrUWiQWo
xPaHHJIocb
HHo且HoH
rPaMoTblⅡOユO6HorO
erorPaMoTblnOnO6HorO
cO瓜eP>KaHHH．
cOUeP>KfIH"

CQB BeceJIoBcK" yka3bIB", q75 ̅ Ma"EMMi
U

巾fWJIqWFM"plr9"2THbIMII
ocBo6Q>KneH"MII
npekm

THJIacboKoJIo1506r､2̲SToHcTowHQABTOp"I"ifiy

E"̲ l<QMnJIeKc rpaMoT, KaK BeJIIIKoKHH>kecKIIx, Tari
MBWIbHoKHH>KecKmx ̲OIHaKo B 90-x ronax XV B: ""JIE

M AWMQTbI, "cmpyIOm6 ̅nbMM5 ' iMM;M

BblnaBaJIHCbCBeTcKHM巾eOnaJIaMTOJIbKoBPJI3aHcKOMKHH-

lkeCTBe4IIByneJIax5nOPacnOPH>KeHmlO̅IMMiirjifM-

"H rpaM9Ta cBeTcKQMyPeonaJIy 6bIJIa BbInaHa B XV B. ̅B
⑥

MIe4H1W pa3､､p 1489/90 n5 Mo)KHo Cka3aTb, tIT5 5

l491̲rJIBaIJIIInpeKPaT""nPe,ⅡOCTaBJIeHHe
nOnaTHbIX
9fBo60)KneHIiii,
npHtIGM
cBeTcKHM,Ⅲ且yxOBIIblM
Ii
｡eO"JIaM.
Ⅱ"ECTaTbHoHeHano6HocTIITHHyTbbTHrJIbIMiIJImbMIi
｡

BOBcHKHenPOTOPbIIIPa3MeTbI-3TaMIIHIIMaJIbHaHⅡeKJIa-

WWWaTHpR､HMMyHHTeTa-BcrpeqaeTcHBrpaMomX
HHBaHalllBl492EBnocnemHmi̅6557:
｡

2HCTOI)IIH
Bblna[IHHMMyHIITeTHblx叩aMoT
c
XII
no
KoHeU
XV
B.
"WW 9."QM ", 80-x rom"""Te7'6" !EMM @y 'l:WWMM
A:P)WWe qjeOmaJTbHble aP)｡ XiV=jXVi"""M
1951l951,cTp.113-201).

BeCeJIOgCKI[曲．
3C
B.BQgr9LIHoii̲Pycli. M, 1947,
①e942JIbHoe
3eMJIeBJIanleHIIe
CeBepoB
crp 1"
4 ACSH, T、1!!, " 359=361, 369; xn, I, JYb 8.
5 A"HX, w・I!,̲JW21, 34; ACSH, T. 1I1," 64.
6 ACSH, T・I, Nb 541.

7TaM>Ke,JYb567,568;rnB,noro且．1905,J1J1.8006.-8106,,Nh71.
12

STo 3HaIIIIT, tlTo nPaBIITeJIbcTBO IIBaHa lll nPeKPaTIIJ1o
OCBo60)KnaTb lIMMyHIITeTHble BJIaneHMH He TOJIbKO OT naIIH,

HMa,BeJIHKoKHH>KecKoiicJIy)K6bl,TaMrHH MblTa7HOIIOT
60JIee MeJIKIIx nJIaTe>Keii­瓜BOPUoBO-KHfl>KeCKOrO II, Mo>KeT
6blTb, BoJIocTHoro I1PoIIcxo>KneHHH.

KoHeqHo, B KaKoi-To Mepe coxpaHHJlli ̲ Iop"IIIlecKyIo
U

cIIJIyrpaMoTbI, BblnaHHble no 90-x ronoB XV B" QJWKg"

4eiicTBIIe OrPaHHII}IBaJIocb pa3BePHyBmHMIIcH B KoHUe BeKa
nmcnoBblMlronlicaHIIHMH. BKJIIoIIeHIIe liMWIy"TeTHoro BJIaU

XeHIiH B onlicb d)aKTliqecKIIBJI"JIo 3a co60ii oTMeHy o9HopHblxnOlaTHblxOcBO60)K1eHIIi．nO,ITBeP>K,naHBOBToPoinoJIoBHHe 80-x ronoB oEHy m3 cBoHx npe)KHIIx ̲¥aJIoBaHHblx

fPaMoTTpollUeECeprlleByMoWWLRIo,IIBaHIILIIIIe瓜ⅡIIcaJ1
co6JIIonaTbee《八ooDIIc"aBl487r.conpaBHTeJIbIIBaHa
⑪

III, erO cbIH BeJIIIKllih KHH3b HBaH HBaHOBLiq yKa3bIB2Jl
一

cBOHM Ka山HI-ICKIIM IIaMeCTHIIKaMⅡ no皿JIIiHHHKaM, IITOObl

OHH《HePymHJIIIHHIIeMPPOnHCMI>cTaPble)KaJIOBaHHblerPa-

MoTbI
TpbilUe-CeprlieBy
MQIIacTbIpIo
9.
HoJIIITIIKv爵
90･x roIoB XV B. Mo>KHo cIIHTaTb nepBblM aTanoM cﾙIcTeMaTH[IecKoi 60pbl6bl 3a pe3Koe orpaHHIIeHIie llo-

"THoro IIMMyHHTeTa Ha PyCm.

Ha oTHoIIieHIIe lIBaHa lll K qJeonaJIbHoMy IIMMyHHTeTy,

HecoMHellHo, noBJIIIHJIH TaKIie co6blTIIH KQ"a 70-x -Z̲IIaLIaJIa 90-x ronpB, KaK nplicoe且HHeHI,Ie HoBropo,ma, TBepli,
IIam60IJIee 3HaxlHTeJIbHblx y,瓜eJIoB, OKOHIIaTeJIbHOe naneHme

O"blHcKOro
Hra・roc皿apb
<<BceH
PycII)',
MeHee
KIeM
IIPe)K八e
3alIHTePecOBaHHblII
B
HO皿eP>KKe
KPynHeimHx
｡eomaJIoB,
U

U

nPeKPaTmJI nPejmPcTaBJIeHme !IM IIonaTHhIx nPmBIIJIer"

Ef
fP3MoT3JMeJIbHbIx
KIIII3eii
BTopoih
nqJIoBmubI
xY"=
U

u

U

Haq5JIAFXVi̅E., "aK)Ke B rPaMOTax geJI"Oii KHHrm" Ma-

PHHHPocJIaBHbl，TaTaPcKoro
UaPeBHIIa
MyxaMMe且­3MI1Ha，
CblHOBem-COnP aBHTeJIe曲 HBaHallI­HBaHaHBaHOBHLIa
U

MoJIoHoro II ̅BacHJIHFI I'IBal-IoBH[Ia - He Ha6JIIonaeTcH cToJIb
>Ke nocJIeXoBaTeJIbHoih 60pb6bl 3a orpa"IIelIIIe llonaTHoro

iiMMVHIITeTa, KaK B rpaMOTax HBaHa lll. 3To roBopHT o
TOM，IITOOHII
ToM,̅IITO
OHH6bmKrOPa3且o60JIb皿e
6blJIII rOPa3np 60JIb
3alIHTePeCOBallblBHo4ntep>KKe MecTHblx (beo八aJIOB, 'IeM BeJIIIKIIII KHFI3b.
リ

OIHaKo, KaK noKa3blBaeT naJIbHelimafl HcTopIIH HMMyHIIO瓜HaKo，KaKHoKa3blBaeT瓜aJIbHeHmaHHcTo”HHMMyHHTeTa, 6blJIO6b[ HeOcHOBaTeJIbHo CBH3blBaTb OrPalWIIHTeJIb-

HVIOHOJII1THKVJIHmbcycnexaMIIneHTPaJIMI3a皿Ⅲ.uJ'Hnpoゴ

ロ

8 AC3H, T・I, Nb 349.

9 rnB, nOrO上1. 1905, @m. 64 06．,Nb47.
13

I

2WW̲IWTM" TaKoEQ pomg Tpe60Bamlicb m mpyrlie
npe且ⅡocbIJIKIIB KoHUe XV B 60p66a Be"MKoKH"kBMF6
I""lbCTBa 3a orPaHIIIIeHMe MMMyIIIITeTa nPoTeKaJIa E
yCJIOBIIHx
onPenleJIeHHOrO
3KOHOMHIIeCKoro
nO瓜'LeMa,
OTMeLIaeMOrOn'JIH3TOTOBPeMeHIIPHn(OMHccJIenoBaTeJIei''0.1/13-

WeW2WTgM"eMJIegleJIHH,POWnPOli3BO4cTBa3ePHOpMWW" PQyecJIa,BHyTPeHHeii lr BHemHeii TOPr6BJIH
U

U

PymeCTBeHHbIM
26Pa30M
aKTIIBI1311POBaJII!
xo3HACTieHIM
U

MWMc"HLLIQJ･KOHa3ToM｡OileMOMaPa3BePliWM
6PQPW､̲3aOTMeHylleKOToPblx tTaPmm3rmmLM
Wp:̲grPa"qeHmeIIMMylllifeTaHe6MJi5̅iigOJMMMM
ソ

HBJIeHHeM.OXIIoBpeMeHHomna60Pb6a3aCOKPameHIIe
UepKoBgo-MQHacTbipcKoro 3eMJIeBJIaneHIIH. BbIHalliliBajIIIcb
U

HleHo6皿eHceKyJIHpH3aUHII.
BcTpaHeHapacTaJIoceKvJIHゴ

W4"OHHO-<<ePeTII[lecKOe)'IBIDKeHIIe.60HPCKOe3eMJIebJIa

JIeHIie
B
nPHcOe瓜HHeHHblx
O6JIgcTHx
OKa3a"bCb
nOn
y"POM.
⑥

HQBroponcKoii
B
3eMJIe
oHo
6bIJIo̅
JTIEHⅡIIPOBaHO.

QEPaM"¥"̲"MMyHMTeT.
Cyme"M6̅MPblBaJIO

9WWRM9M"CKOrO !! qOJIHTllqecKOro BJI"H" KPynHblx CBeTcKHx H,n<yXOBHblX巾eonaJIoB. O"aKo aHTHCeilbu

U

92WbW̲1aHTIIMoHacThiPcKmiixaPaKTePaToi60Pb6bl̅iie

#9" ̲3WWQ"JIbnoro xaPaKTePa; nOckoJIbKy bMfiif
HHeHMMyHHTeTacaMonoce6ee皿eHeBeJIoKyTBeP>KXeHHIo

M92"Wfya3HOrOnPaBam3Be6THo,MT586MMTM
⑥

BHHeXVB・QrPaWeHme
nPa"=KPecTbfIHcKOrO
nePeXo"

rlOnBePraJIocb
Bce
60JIee
IIaCTOh巾HKca
UHHHI-IamJIo
o6meMFWWWie"e B Cy4e6HMKe l497 c ycIMeHme tb56naJIbHOH
SKCmlyaTauHHKPecTbgll
cOcTaBJIHeT
TaK>Ke
XaPaKWiXp HepTy 3Toro neplio" B pe3yJIbTaTe pe3Ko o66MWTW̲4MH"": C OnHOii cTbPdilbI, yBe"IIeHIie "ifl
U

U

ml̲9rpaHIIqeHIIH cTaPbIx cpencTE ee P6aJIM3aUIIII B BME

6oJIee
H@ﾉIMig¥ge
̲IIQJIHOrO
qonaTHOro
mMMyHHTeTa
POcT
m
○

a4MMHHcTPaTHBHOih
BJIacTH巾eOnaJIa
nO
oTHOmeHIIIO
KPeK
CTI,HHHHy;
nPyroii
c CToPoHbl,
3HaIIHTe,ﾉIbHaJI
IIeHTPaJIH3aUH凡
⑥

I､OCyJIaPcTBeHHbIx ｡HHaHcoB.

Hr9̲"3eTc"6yne6Horo!IMMyameTa,roo｢paMoTax

Ha MoHacTblpcKme BoT[lllllb! B KoHne 80-x Ii HaIIaJIe90-x rtjg
や

!oli3HoBeiimlixpa60TcM.:E,EKoqIIHCeJIbcKoexo3HiicTBoHa
t D

nePmO4P6Pa30BaHlifI
g PyCm
PybcmOf､O,rUeHWaJTII2QBaHHOrO
rOCynaP-

cTBa･KoHeU
"68u,i51965,cTp，241-248,
e&
ATI)5pHM
HaqaJIo
!i"
!!e
XIII
- "IIA
W
XVI
B#JLW̲
Io
431-434；10．「．Aʻ1IeKceeB・Arl〕apl･IaH1I
coll1Ia,唖ｺﾄ'aF(
CeIIcToI)HH

"9-BocTQ[IHoii
XV-XVr65・nepeacnaBcKMji
ye3X.
M=X,
1966,cTp.95Ⅲユp、 pycm
1,

14

npB npeo6JIanaeT HcKJIIoqeWe̲li3 BoT[ImHHoii lopHc"liIIKM
o"or6J,mmb4ymery6cTBa 1110pIIc皿KUHfl CBeTcKMx *eOnaJIoB B KoHUe 80-x rOnPB orPaHMIqIIBaeTcH, B cooTBeTcTBHⅢ
c 60JIee paHI･IIIMH TPa瓜HullHMI1, 3Ha【mTeJIbHo Pe3[le: nyllle-

ry6cTBo, pa360ii H TaTb6a c n""HblM IIacTo BblnaﾉlaIOT II3

c1)epb[
CgHbopmaJIbHoro
cy4a
CIIMnToMaTI11IHb!AiKa》KeT12
cfI HaJIIIIIIIe KOMnPoMIIccHoFI HoPMbl orPaHHqeHIIH (""THe

jlyll｣ery6cTBa H Pa360H C noJIIIIIHbIM) BJpaMoTe ､ 14" r.
IIbnaM.13 M B rpaMoTel497 r. cBeTcKI,1M *eoJIaJI,a'M 14 Pa3BHTHC皿eT, OIIeB皿HO, B CTOPOHy yHH巾HKamIII cynle6Horo

IIMMyHKTeTa"eTcKmxIIJyxo9HbIx3eMJIeBJIaneJIbne9.n"
MeHEHIIe 3TOii KoMnPOMHcCHoII, HO IJIH MOHacTblPem HBHO

o叩aHmqHTeJIbHoih HOPMbl B IByx rPaMoTax l500 r. KIIPIIJIJIOZIjeJIo3ePCKoMyMoHacTblPlO'5HBJIHeTCH
HaIIaJIbHblM
MOMeHTOM nocJIe八oBaTeJIbHO nPOBO瓜HBmeroCH 3aTeM B TelIe-

HIIePHnaJIeTcy)KeHHHCBeTcKOiiIOPHC且HKUHIIMOHaCTblPeit
ll uepKBII.

CoKp a皿eHHe MoHacTblpcKoii loPHcJHKUHII npl'I HeKoTopoM
pacmHPeHIIH Cyne6HblX nPaB cBeTcKHx ｡eQmaJIoB xaPaKTe-

Pm3)'eTHoBbIiiaTanPa3BHTIIH｡eOnaJIIi3Ma,Komac9eTcKOe

3eMJIeBJIaneHIIe yKPenJIHeTcH

H

Pac皿ⅢPHeTcH,

cyneOHo-nO-

J1皿eihcKHe｡yHKn皿cBeTcK3xm,nyxOpHbIx｡eOnaJIQpBn"

neL7IaX Hx BJIaneHKHⅡpHO6PeTaIOT 60JIee e"IHoO6Pa3HbIii
XaPaKTeP.nPOrPeCCmPyIo山Ⅱ曲ⅡPOUeCc3aKPenO皿eHHHKPecTbRHCTBa 3acTaBJIHeT nPaBIITeJIbCTBO Ha niaHHoM 3Tane Pa3-

IMTIIH rOCynaPCTBellHoji UeHTPaJIMI3aUHH-ⅡPII OTCyTCTBHH

xoPOmoHaJIa)KeHHO曲MeCTHOitHOJIIiUeiiCKOihCHCTeMbl-ⅡePe"BaTb B PyKII CBeTcKHx ｡eO"JIOB H OcTaBJIHTb B PyKax
nyxOBHblx

3eMJIeBJIaXeJIbUeB

nPaBo

cyna

B

OTHomeHHH

TaTb6bl, 3Toii HaH60JIee pacnpocTpaHeHHo曲巾OPMbl HaPy-

ILIeHI呪巾eo八aJIblloro nPaBonOP皿Ka・BMecTe c TeM ycHJIIIB皿eeCHneHTPaJIH30BaHHOerOCynaPCTBO6ePeTBCBOHPyKH
cyⅡno又ymery6cTBy H pa360Io, T. e. TeM HPecTynJIeHIIHM,
KOTOPble nPenCTaBJIHIOT KPaiiHIOIO OnaCHOCTb 4JIFI BCerO
●

KJIacca PeOnaJIoB B neJIoM.

'' ACSH, T. I, Nh 534, 561, 567, 568; T. II, Nb 278; rnB,n0ron. 1905,
.JIn. 80 06.-81 06., Nb 71.

12 ACSH, T: 111, Nh 109, 243 (cP AC31I, T・II, M 274, T- I11, JVb llO,
r且e ll3 10pHc皿皿HH IICKJIIOIIaeTCH JIHmb nymery6CTBO)
'3 TaM jKe, T. 111, JYb 28,2.
'4 TaM IKe, T. I, Nb 611.
15 TaM >Ke, T. l1, ,Nb 300, 301; J̅1. B. IJepenHIIH. yKa3. coII., L1. 2,
CTP. 200.
15

nPHrJIMJIMCH BHHMaTeJIbHee, K IIeMy cBO,mHJIaCb B
90-x ronax XV B.­HaIIaJIe XVI B. HMMyHHTeTHafI HoJIHTIIKa
BeJIIIKoKHH>KeCKOrO nPaBIITedJIbCTBa l6.

J1. B. IlepenHHH cIIHTaeT 80-e rombl XV B. IIePeJIoMHblM
sTanoM B
aTanoM
B HcTopHH
HcTopHH BHyTpeHHeii
BHyTpeHHeHⅡoJIIITHKHHBaHa
noJIIITHKII HBalla lllllll7．Col7. Co-

6blTHFII491r. KaK 6bl HontBeJIII IIepTyno4 UeJIoii cepHeil
迦

凹

neHTPaJII13aTOPCKIIX
HBJIHB
neHTPam13aTOPCKmX MePOnPHHTHil,
MePOnPHHTHH，HBJIHBmHxcfl
co,mep)Ka-

HIIeM STOro 'nePIIOna JIOMKH CTaPoii nOJ1HTHIIeCKOA CHCTeMbl.

B1491r・HBaHIIIJIHKBH且HPOBaJInOcJIenHHiiCePbe3Hbli
oIIar oIIno3HⅡHH­yrJIHUKoe KHH)KecTBo. B KoHUe̅ ceHTH6-

p2 1491 r. oH BeJIeJI apecToBaTb AHJpeH Bac"beBIIIla
<<BOJIbJlIOrO> yrJIMUKOrO H ero八eTeH H HOCJIaJI cBoIIx HaU

MecTIiHKOp̲ B rJIaBHIJIe rOPO,ma nPlIcOeXIIHeHHOro yXeJIa yr･皿哩HMoJKaiicK l8.
U

OT rpHo" c 1492 no oKTH6pb l505 r. ("Ta cMePTM

HBaHa lII)HaM M3BecTHbI 42 HMMylIIITeTHble rpaMoTbl, bbl"HHbleZ"HoM III m ero cbIHoM BacmJImeM:̅ 29 rpaMoT
II"Ha !9 (23>KajHoBaIIHbIx, !13 KoTopbIx 3 He coxpaHiIJImcb,
II 6 yKa311blx) ; 9 06皿Ix )KaJIoBaHHblx rpaMOT HBaHa lll
}IBacHJIIIH;4)KaJIoBaHHblerPaMoTblBa6H川順20,H3KOTOム

Pblx IBe He cOxPaHIIJIHCb 2' .

B WoJIe l492 r. IIBaH III BblJIaJI TpHンKaJIOBaHHble rpaMoTbl・I,poHne-CeprHeBy
poHne-CeprmeBy MoHacTblpIo
MoHacTblpIoHa
Iia ero
ero
BoTIIHHbl，HaBoTIIHHbl, ilaXO411 B]mIecH B nPeneJIax @JIIIKBII且HPoBaHHOro KHfI>KecTBa

AHnPeHBoJIbmol､o:ByrJIHUKoM22,Be>KelLKoM23IIMo>Kaii(､KOM 24 ye3,maX. UeJIb Bblna[IM 3TIIx rPaMOT cOcTO"a B
⑭

16yKa3a}IHoM
B
(hyH,maMeHTaJIbHoM
MCcJIeAoBaHIM几B.IIepellHHHa
aToT3TalnHMMyHIITeTHoiinoJIHTMKIIHemameJInocraToIIHono"o6Horo
OCBe皿eHHH，

l7 JI. B. qepeTIHHH. yKa3．c“.,11．1. M.­几, 1948, cTp. 182; I1. 2,
cTp. 183, 185, 237-238, 392-393.

'8 HCIMIA TJM Cn6" 1848, cTP l60; LVI@ CTP 39, 240; T. V111,
crp "; Tk20, ne22aH nojIQEIIHa, pTp 356-357;. T23; cTp. 195; T: 24,
crp. 208-"9; T. 27L, ̲ cTp.̲362; T. 28; cTp. 1 56, 32 1 -322; WcTId>KcI@m&
JIeTOinHcHblii cBOn>. M.­几, 19'50, cTp. 9|8-99 .

19 E aTO MC"O me BxO"T "e "brOTHLIe rPaMOTbI, Bbl"HHbIe OT HMeHII
ZBaHalllMecTHbIMIIBJIaCTHMHqePHbIMkPeCTbfniaM.
20 BaTo ̲LIHcJ10HeBxomTueTblp6"mbroTfIbIerpaMoTbI,BbUaHHbleoT
jpleHIIBacl%IMecTHblMIIBJIacTHMHqepHbIMK#ecrbHHdM

roBopH
2!
oHecoxpaHIIBmHxcHrpaMoTax,MbIHMeeMBEH且yTOJIbKOIO-

'KyMeHTbl, H3BecTHble no ynoMIIHaHHRM B 4pyrlIx IIcTo[IHIMKax. 06皿ee

>f EOmlilleCTBo HeCOjiPaHHBmmXcg rPaMOT, BKJIIOqaH H Te, O KOTOpblx
Ⅱ
IET ">Ke ynOMIIHaHHii, HaM, Pa3yMeeTCg, HeH3BeCTHO.

22 r,nB, norontl905,JJ1. 80 06.-81 06., JYb 71.

23 ACSH, T･I, Nb 568.
24 TaM測《e, Nb 567.

16

VKIJellJIeHIIH BeJIHKoKHH>KecKIIX no31皿HiM Ha npHcOenll,IHeHソ

且

llbIXTepPliToPmHx m, BePoHTHo, P OrPaHH[leHmm m"y"IWj
COneP>KaHIIe HMMyHHTeTIIOII IIaCTH BCeX TPex rPaMoT
OAliHaKOBO: nPaBO He THHyTb B nPOTOPbl H Pa3MeTbl; HeIIM-

CynHOcTb
HaIMecTHHIIbeMy
Cy八y,
KOnPHIIb
OnfHOrO
ny皿ery6cTBa>; 3anPemeHHe e310KaM CTaB'IITbgI, a He3BaHblM rOCTHM

npHxoﾕHTbHaⅡ叩blII6PaTIIIIHbl・nO-BImHMOMy,rPaMOTbl
3aMeHIIJIH
CO60iⅡpe只皿eCTBylO皿HerpaMoTblAHnpeHyrJII皿Koro. ETo rpaMoT c TIonaTHblMHnPHBIIJIerlIHMH Ha 3TII

CeJIalleCOxPaHIMocb.Bo3Mo)KHo,oHH6blJIII6JIII3KHKTeK-

CTyrl)aMOT,̅BblnaHHblX̅e皿e八onepexoJayrJIIIIIalIBe>KeXKa|BymeJI.Hayr皿皿KHeceJIaHMeJ1acbrpaMoTa
l455r.25,
a lla 6e>KeUKHe - 1462 1，. 26, KOTOpl]le OCBO60)KnaJI'II OT |H1Ma,

IIOABO4, MblTa, TaMI､M II IIp. ECJII1 3TII IIpliBWIerml He 6blJIH
oTMeHeHbl AH八PeeM, TO MO>KHO nPe,皿OJIaraTb, IITO rPaMOTbl

l492r.｡aKTHIIecKHoTMeHHJIⅢⅡonaTHoii|cTaTyccepenJIHbI
XV B.

3anoBenHblii pa3XeJI rpaMoT xapaKTepH3yeT cJIoKHB-

Ⅱ111eCFIBnePllOXkHH)KeHIinHBaHalllHOPMbl"nPaBa.yCIIJIeHI-lble CallK皿HnPOTHB He3BaHLIx rOCTeii (Pa3PemeHIIe

6paTb c HIIx 3a y6biTKM B R B o e 6e3 cyna H 6e3 1icnpaBbl)
BnePBble6blJIHCqJOPMy皿ll9BUIbl｡BBeJIHK9KHH>KeCW̲W:
MoTax 60-x ro,npB XV B. 27 3Toit cTaTbeii MoHacTblPcKHM
BJIaCTFIM naBaJIIIcbmHPOKme nOJIHOMOIIHH IJIfl nPecJIe八OBa-

llllF! IIaPymllTeJIeii ｡eOnaJIbHOrO nPaBOnOP"Ka, qTQ OTBe-

IIaJIO
MHTePeCaM
rOCnOnICTBylO皿erO
KJIaCCa
B
neJIoM・B
MecTe
c TeM B rpaMoTax 1492 r. He npHMeHHJIHcb aHaJIorlIIIHible
yC"eHHble caHKmiH nPOTIIB e310KOB, KOTOPble Mbl BCTPe-

､IaeM IIIIorna B rPaMOTax CePe皿Hbl XV B. 28 eTo oTpa>KaeT

poc1. 06fI3aHHocTeiI TJIrJIoro HaceJIeHHH Ho oTHomeHIIIo K
KI･IfnKeCKHM

nOCJIaHHHKaM、

TaKIIM O6Pa30M, nPHH3BecTHOii KoMnPOMHccHOCTH He-

cy八mMoIoIi33noBeniHciropa3nleJIoB,rpaMoTbl｡1492r.Pb"
cyry6() crPaHIIIIHTeJIbHblMII B IIacTH, KacalO皿eHcH nonaTHorO
M M M V H I n e Ta ，

Oco60e

3HaqeHHe

HMeJIa

cTaTbH,

ycTaHaBJIIIBaBmaH

nOncyJJIoCTb
HryMeHa
BeJIHKOMy
KHFI310
B
IICKOBblx
,meJIax29.
５TaM >Ke, Nb 254.
２
６TaM )Ke, M 304.
２
２
７TaM >Ke, Nb 312, 315, 322, 323ⅢⅡp、
８
２
９TaM Me, T. 11, JVb l70; A3MX, q. 1, M 247.
２
'r. e. B cJIyLIaJIx, Koma KTo-IJIII60 nPeⅡ'EJIBJIHJI HryMeHy IIcK, IIcKaJI Ha
IIerO CyAa H ynpaBbl.
2

C 、 M ・ K a 皿 Ta H o B

17

3TIIM HBaH III HO Cyme:CTBy OTMeHHJI IOPHC1mKu'IIIO MIITPOIIOJIIITa B OTHOmeHHII MryMeHa TPOI皿e-CepmeBa MoHacTbl･

" 30. Kypc Ha oTpblB MoHacTblpeii oT UepKoBHoAHePaPxHM
B o6JIacTH cyna m ycHJIeHIIe Hx叩aBOBOii 3aBH|CHMOCTH OT
BeJIIIKoro KHH3H nplIo6peTaJI nporpaMIMHblii xapaKTep, II|60

TpoHuIKHii MoHacTblpb 6blJI KpynHeiimIIM. npoBenleHHe aToro
KyPca O3HaIIaJIO PacKOJI e4IIHOi UePKOBHOii OPraHII3aUHH H
u

npoTHBo|nocTaBJIeHIie onHIIx ee [Ia,cTeH npyrHM.

BecbMa cnep>KaHIIoh 6blJIa mMMyHMTeTHaH noJIHTIIKa
l'lBaHa lll B 1493 r. OT 3Toro rona Mbl llMeeM ABe ero yKa3Hble rPaMOTbl, Pa3PemalOUHe 6e3MblTHblhⅡPOBO3くMOHacTblpcKoro)D xJIe6a B KIIpHJIJIo-BeJIo3epcKHii 31 H TpoHne-

CeFrHeB 32 MoHacTapH. OqeBHJHo, B o60Hx cJIy(IaHx peIIb
山皿I O xJIe6e, HBJIHBmeMCfl nPOlyKTOBoii PeHToii, KoToPaH
I10cTynaJIa B MoHacTblplI H3 Mx ceJIbcKHx BoTIIHH. B rpaMoTe,
KacaIomeiicH TpoIme-CeprIIeBa MoHacTblpH, 3To yKa3aHo
COBePmeHHo HcHO:《Hx xJIe6 H3 Hx ceJIa H3 MOHaCTblPcKOrO

H3 myxo6aJIa)> (Cy34aJIbcKoro ye3") . O KHpHJIJIoBcKoM
xJIe6e cKa3aHO HOIITII B TeX >Ke BblPa)KeHIIHx, HO He Ha3BaHbl
Ce(JIa, H3 KOToPblX OH PPCTaBIHJIcH: <<Hx xJIe6 MOHacTblPbCKOH皿eT II3 PocToBa B KmplIJIoB MoHacTblpb>> (Bo3Mo)KHo,

3TO 6blJI IIacTH【IHo H HoKvnHoih
xJIe6) 33.
­
■

nblTaHcb 'o6'bHcHHTb coJKep>KaHIIe paccMaTpHBaeMblx
rl)aMOT, HeJIb3H He O6PaTHTb BHHMaHIIH Ha TO o6CToHTeJIbCTBo, IITo eme B ceHTH6pe l491 r・HBaH III <<TOPr nePeBeJI oT
30 HacToHTeJIb BenajIcH rJIa'Boii Toii enapxIIH, r八e HaXOmHJICH MOHa'CTblPb.
no3ToMy He llMeeT 3HaIIeIIHH To, 'ITo 3eMJIH, Ha KoTopble MoHacTbl,pb
noJryIIIIJI B 1492 r. rpaMoTbl, 6blJIH pacnoJIo>KeHbl IIa'cTIIIIHo B PocToBcKoit enapxHH (o npHHa,mJIejKHocTII K Heil yrJIHIIa cM.: AC3H, T、111,
JMh 84; H. n o K p o B c K MI ii. PyccKHe enapxHH B XVI-XIX BB., T. 1.

Ka3aHb, 1897, cTp. 66, 105) , IIacTIIIIHo B HoB|ropo,mcKoii, Ky,ma Bxo"JI
Be]KenK" Bepx (H. n o K P o B ,c'KⅢ曲. yKa3. cou, cTp. 66, 99, 100) .
BpH八enoITBep>KJleHIIii 15151 r、K )KaJIOBaHHblM rpaMOTaM, BblnaHHLIM
TI)oHIIe-CeprHeBy MoHacTblpIo B 1492 r.Hno3八Hee，BoccTaHaBJIHBaJIOcbnPaBO CB兄THTeJIbCKOrO Cy且a Ha瓜HryMeHOM,

n､pm

aTOM

BO

BCex

叩aMOTax, B TOM IIHCdme l･I B OTHOCH皿HXCfI K Be)KenKOMy II POCTOBCKoMy ye3,naM, PeIIb皿eT o cy,Ue MIITpoIIoJ1IITa (AC31'i, T. I，Nb 568;
Xn, I, Nb 174, 181 1I ".). B coxpaHI1B皿eMcFI cmlcKe rpaMoTbl l 492 r.
Ha yrJIImKI,Ie ce0ma nontTBep>KneHIIH l551 r. IIeT, nocKoJIbKy caM cHH,coK
naTHpyeTcJI 30-MII ronaMII XVI B.
31 ACSII．T. 11. M 292.

32 TaM )Ke, T. 1, Nb 573.

、

33J1．B. IIepenHHH cIIHTaeT, xITo B aToii rpaMoTe <IiMeIoTcH yKa3aHHH
Ha MoHacTblpcKylo ToproBJIIo xJIe60M> (Ⅱ．B. qepenHIIH. yKa3.
ʻCO'1., q. 2, cTp. 224) .
HcToIlHHK He "eT ocHoBaH砿八皿cToJIbKaTeropH1IeCKorO BblBorma.
18

TpOIIM Ha rOpO,nOK B PanpHe)Kb> 34. yn0MHHaHIIe o6 3TOM
B JIeTOnHCHⅡOKa3blBaeT, IITO mar HBaHa lll llMeJI Ba)KIIOe
U

311aIIeHMe, OIHaKO JIeTOⅡHCeU He PaCKPblBaeT HaM PeaJIbHbllI

cMbICJI OTMeIIeHHoro HM ｡aKTa. H3 4Byx nO3皿ehmHx rpaMOT O JIHKBH且auHH Topra non KHpIIJIJIo-BeJIo3epcKHM

(1533 r.) 35 II BJIaroBemeHcKIIM KHp)KaUKIIM (1537 r.) 36
MOHaCTblPHMH MO>KeT CJIo)KHTbcH BIIeqaT4meHHe, IITO HOIMO⑤

｡
一

H a c T b l p H b l H To p r - H B J I e H H e , K P a H H e n a r y O H o o Tp a ) K a B m e e ｡

C兜HanOJIO]KeHHHMOHaCTblPCKOrO xO3HIICTBa M MOHaCTblP-

cKIIx KpecTbHH H3-3a <<HacIIJIbcTBa)> ToproBblx JIIonleit. OIHa一

KO BCe neJIO CocToHJIO B nPaBe COOPa TaMo)KeHIIblx nomJIIIH

c ToProBblx JIIonteii: ecJIH MoHacTblPb o6JIanaJI sTIIM npaBoM,
nOJMoHaCTblPHblii TOPr 6blJI n(JIH Hero KPaihHe BblrO"IOii
CT aTbe曲八OXO八oB. Mo>KHo XyMaTb, IITo TpoH1e-CeprmeB MoHacTblPb PaCnoJIaraJI IIPaBOM KoHTPoJIH 3a TOPrOB"e曲Ⅱ
C60Pa nOmJIHH IIa lToJMOHacTblPHOM TOPre, KaK, O[IeBIi皿10,
HMeJI OH eme B 1539 r. 3To npaBo B FBoeM ceJIe Me八He 37.
HHblMH cJIoBaMH, neiMcTBIie l/IBaHa lll B l491 r. 6blJIo, cKopee Bcero, He B HHTepecax MoHacTblpH. BⅢⅡHMo, OT nePellOca TOpra BblHrPblBaJI PeMeCJIeHHO-TOProBblii UeHTp PaXOHe>K, HaxOﾕHB皿城cH B lO BepcTax oT MoHacTblpH.
3To HOKa3blBaeT, C OnHOii CTOPOHbl, HOBblii nO且乃eM rO-

po4cKoii )KII3HH B KoHUe XV B., c "yroiI cTopoHbl, cTpeM,JIeHHe BeJIHKOKHH)KeCKOrO nPaBHTeJIbCTBa OCBO60nHTb BHyTPeHHIOIo TOPrOBJIIO OT MOHacTblPCKOrO KOHTPOJIH H JIHKBH-

JHPOBaTb TaMoJKeHHble nPaBa MOHaCTbIPeil.

B sToM >Ke pycJIe noJIHTHKH HaxoXHTcH Bb皿aIIa rPaMoT
0 6ecno皿JIHHHoM npoBo3e MoHacTblpcKoro xJIe6a KIIpHJIJIoBeJIo3epcKIIM H TpoIIUe-CepmeBbIM MoHacTblpHMm. Ho
3neCb Mbl HMeeM八eJIo C JPyrOit CTOPOHo曲orP aHIIIIHTeJIbHoii

noJIHTIIKII - 6opb60曲ⅡPOTIIB nPHBHJIerHPOBaHIIorO nOJIO)KeHIIH MoHacTblpeii Ha BHyTpeHHeM pbIHKe He KaK c60pmHKoB
TaMoJKeHHblx nomJIHH, a KaK yrlacTHHKoB TOProBJIH, Kyn-

UoB. rPaMoTe l493 r., KacaIo皿eiicH TpoHUe-CeprHeBa MoHaCTblPH 38, npe1meCTBoBaJIa rPaMoTa HBaHa lll, IIOcJIaHHaH B
q)eBpaJIe l490 r. B ToT )Ke IOpbeB HoJIbcKo曲l･l aMeCTHHKy
nalllIJly MHxaiiJIoBHLIy: 4<BHJI MH [IeJIoM TPoHUKoil ... HryMeH AdJoHacei..,, a cKaBblBaeT, [ITo八eH Bo3fITHx】KHTo

34 nPCJI, T. V111, cTp. 223; T・XII, cTP. 232; T. 27, cl､p．362; T. 28,

cTp・156.
35 pHB, T. 32, M 128.
36 AH, T. I, M 138.
37 AA3, T. I, M 188.

38 0 Heii CM・Ta!K)Ke; J1. B. q e p e n H II 'H. yKa3. coI1., u 2, cTp. 2|24.
1

9

2

＊

MaHacTblpcKoe B MOHacTbiPb li3 Hx ceJIa lI3 myxo6a", Il
TI,I neI,I ,Ha HIIx eMJIemb MblTHⅡomJIIJHb" 39. B rpaMoTe 3a-

IIpemaJIocb 6paTb nomJIIIHbl c MoHacTblpc,Koro xJIe6a, Ho
eJBa JIII Mbl Omli6eMCH, nPe瓜ⅡOJIO)KHB, IITO nleiiCTBIIfl HaMecTHFIKa 6blJilI . Bbl3BaHbl nPOBOpHBmeii,CH BeJIHKHIM KHH3eM
nOJIIITHKOji OTMeHbl TaMO)KeHHblx nPlIBWIernit MOHaCTblPeik.
OXHaKo npaBIITeJIbcTBo, cToH Ha cTpa)Ke KopeHHblx HIHTepe○

cOB rOcHOI'CTByloUerO KJIacCa, BblCTynaJIO C Ho3HnHHKJIaC-

CCBO曲《CIIPaBenJIIIBOCTI1>: OIIO He MOI､JIO,npiiTII,瓜o o6JIo>Ke1冊呪TaMO>KellIIbl MH ⅡO皿JIIIHaMH

BOTIIIIHIIblx

nePeBO30K

HeToProBoro xaPaKTePa．ⅢTeM He MeHee 60Pb6a 6blJIa
cT|OJIbo,CTPOit,aKPIITePmⅡ八J1HOTJIH[IeHIIHBOTIIMIHblXO6030B OT TOPrOBblX 3KCne皿皿油一CToJIb He'IeTKHMII, IITO, KaK
flBcTByeT H3 rpaMoTbl l493 r., HoBblii lopbeBcKIM HaMecTIIIIK
CeMeH KapmoBHII B3jlJI c BoTIIIIHHoro o603a MblT B pa3Mepe
l 1/2 py6"月Ⅱ9 4eHer.
y]Ke B rpaMoTe l490 r. co八eP>Ka!jlaCb cIIeUmaJIbHaH
CTaTbH, 3anPemaBmaH MOHaCTblPCKHM KPeCTbHHaMHHOCTO-

PoHHIIM JIIOMM 6eCnOmJIIIHHO nPOBO31ITb (Pa3yMeeTCH,皿H
nPopa>KH) cBoe班HTO HOIB皿OM MOHaCTblPcKOro,ⅢⅡp eXy-

CMaTPMBaJIHCbCOOTBeTCTBylO皿HecaHKUHH：《AxTonoenleT
C HIIMHHX KPeCTbflH, HJIH HHOih XTO CBOHM >KIITOM, a yIIHyT
nPoBOIHTII 3a MOHaCTIJIPbcKOih xJIe6, II TbI IIa Tex HomJI MHy
eMJII1, na TOrlbI H Cb lix C MaHaCTblPbCKblX CaHehnOmJIIIHy
BO3MH BcIO, II OHH II Bnepen He nPoJIblraIoTCFI>. STa CTaTbH
HoBTopeHa B rpaMoTe l493 r. 3anpemeHIie npoBo3HTb IIy-

x〈oii ToBap BcTpeIIaeTcH y]Ke B e4HHIIIIHblx rpaMoTax 6080-x ro八oB XV B. 40, caHKm､IIII >Ke 3a nPOBO3 HeMOHacTblPcKoro ToBapa nteKJIapIIpyloTcH B rpaMoTe l490 r．BnePBLIe.
TaKIIM o6pa30M, rpaMoTbl l493 r. noHBIIJIIIcb B pe3yJIbTaTe m3BeCTHOrO KOMnPOMIICCa Me>Kny BeJIIIKOKIIH>KeCKMM

nPaBIITeJIbcTBOM H KpynHehmHMII MOHaCTbIPHMH: B3aMeH

3anPemeHHHMOHaCTblPCKoi6ecnomJIIIHHOiiTOPrOBJIIIMOHacTbl"M raPaHTmPOBaJICH 6eCnOmJIHHHblknPOBO3 1IX BOTLIHHHblx xJIe6HbIx nPxOnPB・nPoBeneHHe aTOrO KyPCa TaMO)KeHHoii noJIIITIIKII IIaIIaJIocb c l489/90 r., oT KoToporo, KpoMe
ynOMHIIyTOii TPoHHKoii l､PaMOTbl, JPmJIa rPaMOTa, Pa3Pe-

maIomaH KIIpmJIJIo-BeJIo3epcKoMy MoHacTblplo 6ecnQmJII1HHblii nPOBO3 PyJKHOro XJIe6a 4! (T. e. xJIe6HOrO )KaJIOBaHIffl,
noJIVIIdeMoro̅ jIoHacTblDeM V鐘
BeJIHKoKHH>KecKHx HoceJIbcKIIx) .
ご

▲

３９ rnB, noro'n. 1905, n. 66 06., Nh 51.
４０
ACal'I, T. I, Nb 453; T 11, M 256, 460
４１

TaM >Ke, T. 11, M 279.

20

2．Bonpoc o no八mTImeCKOM CTaTyCe
HaCJkeNHIIKOB IIBaHa lII
KoHKpeTHbIe noJIHTHqecKIIe MoTIIBl21 BblnaLIII rpaMoT
1493 r. 06'乃兄CHIITb八oBoJIbHo TpyXHo. Bo BcHKoM cJIy[lae,
HII B CaMHX rPaMOTaX, HH B JIeTonHCHbIx TeKcTax Mbl He

HaimeMnPHMOrOOTBeTaHa3TOTBOnPoG・OcTaeycH
conocTaBIITb xPOHOJIOrmlO rPaMOT C Mx reOrPabnqeCKOimPmypoIIeHHOCTblO･

O6erpaMoTbIB311aIIHTeJIbHoiiMepeoTHQcHTcHKpaiioIIy
PocToBo-Cy3"JIbcKoii 3eMJIII: rpaMOTa o KHpIIJILoBe MoHaCTblPe6blJIanOCJIaHaBroPo,ⅡaoTPOCTOBanPBeJIOO3ePa,
rpaMoTa o TpomUe-CepmeBe MoHacTbIpe - B IOpbeB noJIbcKOik. MO)KHo CKa3aTb H HHaIIe: rPaMOTbl OTHOcIIJIHCb.K TeP-

pHTOpHHpocToBo-mpocJIaBcKo-6eJIo3epcIf9iiKcy3"JIbcKoii
6IIapiKIIii. ̅JIeTonHcHble TeKcThl KoHnla XV B. noKa3blBaloT
oco6yIo poJIb, KoTopaH npHHanJIe>KaJIa B sTo BpeMH apxII-

elllIcKony pocToBcKoMy. OH ｡IIrypHpyeT E Ka[IecTBe BTopor9
HO 3HalleHIIIo JIHna noCJIe MIITPonoJIIITa. ToJIbKo pocToBcK"

IIHOBrOPOXCKIIiliePaPXHHOC"HaPxIIenHCKOHcKIIitTHTyJI,

ocTaJIbHLIe 6bImi enHcKonaMH. EcJIH】Ke y'IeCTb, IITO B nePBoiⅡoJIoBHHe 90-x ronoB XV B. o>KecToIIeHHaH IIneIIHo-noJIH-

THIIecKafl 60pb6a Me>Kny MIITponoJIHToM 30cHMoii II HQBro-

po八cKmMa"IIenmcKonoMreHHa"eMoTIlacTI]ocJIa6JIMVIa
nOJIIITHIIeCKHii aBTOPHTeT

TOrOH瓜PyrOTO, 3HaIIeHIIeくHeHT-

PaJIbHorO)>POCTOBCKOrOaPxIIenHcKonaTIixoHa6ynleTTpyn4

110 nPeyBeJIHIIHTb.

U

nO3HUIIH UePKBH HO oTHOmeHmo K UeHTPaJII13aToPCKOII
nOJIIITMKe BeJIHKIIx KHH3eii BCerna OTJIHIIaJIaCb HenOcJIenPBa-

TGJIbHocTbIQ
UepKoBb
poneiicTBqpaJIa
o6pe皿HeHIIIO,｡
HO
lle
pP KoHna, C HocToHHHOii OrJIflJIKOii Ha CBOH《BCeP OccH HcKIIH》

npecTH)K,HacBoIoPoJIb<<BcepoccIIMcKoro>ap6HTpa.OKoHIIaTeJ1bHaFI JIIIKBH瓜anHH

yneJIbHblx

KHfDKecTB He OTBeIIaJIa

no3ToMy noJIHTIIIIecKIIM HHTepecaM UepKBII. TIInorpa*cKaH
JIeTOⅡHCbn皿7006 (1497/98) r. paccKa3blBaeT o ToM2 KaK
I'IBaH III no>KeJIaJI (a ｡aKTHIIeCKH, BePOHTHo, 6blJI BblHy>KneH) ny6JIIIIIHo noKaHTbcH nepeni MHTponoJIHToM, apxH-

elIHCKoNoM (pocToBcKHM) H enHcKonaMH 3a nory6JIeHHe
AHIIpeH ymHⅡKoro 42. B 1497 r. cMepTb AHnPeH 6blJIa JIIImb
42 HCPJI, T. 24, cTp. 2 1 3 ­ 2 1 4 . B T. H . 《CBO八e l497 r.> 3To co6blTIIe
onHcaHo nonl 7005 r (HCPJI, T. 28, CTp 160) .
21

a

np¥JIoroM "H.gplcTyWIeK" IIepKoBHHKoB (AHnpeii BoJIbu

moit yMep ¥1493 r) 43. Ho HcHb,wTo y>Kecpd3ynocJIe
noIIMaHIIHAHmpeHHacTpoeHHeBBblcmIIi<nepIfoBlibIxKpy-

EaX 6bIJIO Hq P nOJI"y BeJIHKOrO KHH3H. JIerK6 nOHfITb, "K

6eCnoKOIIJIa
HBaHa
no3HnH兄PoCTOBCKOrO
lll
aPxHenHcKOna,
B IIbIO enaPxHIo BxOXIIJI yrJIHII.

neJIO OCJIO>KHHJIocb B3alIMOOTHO皿eHHHMH HBaHa lll C
ero cblHoM BacHJIHeM.

HQCJIenPBaTeJIHMH
yCTaHOBJIeHa
TecHaH
CBH3b
nlIHacTH-

IIeCKoii60pb6bl90-xronoBXVB.-HarlaJIaXVIB・C6Opb＝

U

OOH BOKPyr UeJIOrO PHna BOnPOcOB BHyTPH- II BHemHenOJIH-

"IIecKoro ̲xapaKTepa. ConepHHKaMII C"bII naJIeoJIor lI

BaclIJIIm6bIJIHE､ﾉIeHa̲BoJomaHKa
(MoBacTapmerocblHa
I'IBaHa lll-HBaHa MoJIonpro) H ee cblH JMIITpHii - Bo3U

U

Mo)KHblH nPeTeHmeHT Ha nPe'CTOJI. no3HUHH H|BaHa lll B
3HaIIHTeJIbHOII MePe 3aBHCeJIa OT Pa|cCTa'HOBKH KJIacCOBblX H
U

HoJIIITHIIecKIIxcHJ1.3a]IHTepecoBaHHbl曲B,CeKyJIHPH3auHH
nePKOBHblx 3eMeJIb, I'IBaH III OKa3blBa!ﾉI H3Be'cTHyIO IIOI-

Xep>KKy6JIH3KHMKEJIeHeくePeTHKaM>,II3KoTOPbIxeXOP

KypIIUbIH noJIb30BaJIcH Ham60jIbmIIM BJI"HIieM Iia BeJImif6T6

KHH3H，BMeeTe cL TeMIIBaH IIInOHIIMa"6ecnePcneKTHB-

HOCTb60Pb6bI6e3cOneiiCTBHHKPynHeiimHXIiePaPxOBII
U

U

MOHaCTblPeii(OTcIO"­nOnbITKanPHBJIelleHIIHKHeCTH>KaU

TeⅡeⅡ》K UepKoBI･IoMy pyKoBoXcTBy, noca>KeHIIe 30c'HMbl

1a MHTponoJIH[I" npecToJI) . OTHomeHIie lIBaHa
HaMHTpoⅡoJIH[I”ⅡpecToJI)．OTHomeHHe
HBaHalll
lll KKcbIHV
cbIHV

BacmJIHIoHeMorJIo6bITbB3TMxycJIoBHfIxnpocTbIM.>KeJiaL
HIIe CneJIaTb H3 IOHOrO KHH3H nOMOmHHKa B HOJIIITHIIecKOH
u

P0Pb6e
noCTOHHHO
COrleTaJIOCb
OnaCHOCTblo
c
yCIIJIHTb
aTIIM
BacHjlIIH,Haj<oToporoBo3JIaraJIIIIIanexmblnbenlcTaBmTeJm
q

l

Hoc"J1FIHcKoii UepKBH, c6'nli3PIBmliecfI c Co"eii
HoJIHTHqecKaH Kapbepa BacmJIIIH B 90-X ro八ax XV B.
(nPerOOnaJIbI)
H3yqeHacOBepmeHHoHenocTaToqHo.BacpIJ1"6bIJIHoMIIHa@mbHOnPHO6皿eHKrOCyAaPCTBeHHOHIeH-

TeJIbHocTMoIIeHbpaHQHeKoTopbIerpaMOTbI30cTaBaBmmecH
49 CHX noP Wi3B"THbIMII, nPOJIIIBaloT cBeT Ha ero POJIb B

80-xronaxXVB.IIcToPHKH八aBHO31iaJIm,IITOB3TOBPeMH
BMocKoBcKoMBeJIHKoMKHmKecTBenBaJIHuaHOCIIJIHTHTVJI
:eJIHKoro I<"qH: H"H III ]1 erQ cbIH oT 6paKa c MapIIM
ｰ

U

BoIIIiggPHoiiHBaH̲HBaHoBMII<MoJIonp"
(.ponl.
15巾eBPa" 1458 r.- yMep 7 MapTa l490 r.). OIHaKd.HacaMoM "JIe

6blJIe皿eTpeTHHBeJIHKHiiKHH3b-BacHJI",nepBbliicbIH
U

U

い

43 JI. B.'IepenHHH.yKa3.coI1.,'1.2,cTp.294,298-299.
22

⑥

IIBaHa lll oT 6paKa c Co巾beiinaJIeoJIor (pom 25 MapTa
1479r.)．rpaMoTaBe皿KoroKHFI3flBacIIJIHHBacIIJIbeBHqa
TpoH"-CePrIIeBy MoHacTbIpIQJIa nBoP B E KocTpoMe, na-

TlipoBaHHaR16･eBpaml45fr"ppmep)KHTcJIegyIQ皿ylo

nOXTBePnHTeJIbHylOnoⅡnIICb:《HOCenrPaMOTeKHH3bBeJIH-

KH BacHJTeii HBaHoBII可 no)KaJIoBaJI IIryMeHa TpoHnKoro

CepmeBa MaHacTblpH MaKapIIH 3 6paTbeIo: cee rpaMoTLI
cBOIIM HaMeCTHHKoM KOcTPoM'bCKIIM

PymHTII He BeJIeJI

HII-

LIeM. A Ho瓜nHcaJI IHflK BaclIJIeik>> 44. noⅡⅡHCb OTHOCIITCFI K

1484-1488 rr., Korna lIryMeHoM TPoHue-CeprlIeBa MoHa-

cTblpH6blJIMaKapHii45.nonTBe皿HTeJIbHylOHo瓜nHcbBacH-

JIHRHaXoⅡHM eIIIE B OJHOM HCTOqHHKe - rPaMOTe HBaHa lll

TpoⅢⅡe-CePrmeBy MoHacTblplo oT 19MaH 1481 [., KacaIo皿ehcFI 3eMeJIb H Bonl B ropoxoBUe H HponoJIIIew <<KHH3b Be-

JIHKH BaC"ei HBaHoBIIII BceH PycII ceII rpaMoTbl PymblTH

He BeJIeJI HHKOMy HWIeM> 46. 3To nOnTBep)KneHIJe, Cy八HnO
TIITVJIV <<BCeH PVcH》, 60JIee nO3XHee.

nfaK,B80-ズronax3aBacIIJIHeM6bIJIHnpH3HaHIJIKaKIIeTocyBePelIHbIeBeJIIIKoKHIDKecKHenPaBaBoTHomeHHHKocTPOMbl. 9TOT BbIBOn 3aCTaBJIHeT Hac IIPHcTaJIbHee nPHcMOT-

PeTbcH K cocTaBy BJIanleHIIii HBa"ZBaHo"IIa.
cy皿Ⅱo npaBoii rpaMoTe l475/76 r., HBaH IIBaHoBHKI
06JIanaJI B cepeXHHe 70-x roHoB <<rocynapeBblMH》ⅡoJIHoMoIIIIHIMII B mMIITPOBcKOM ye3Xe, O皿aKO naJIeKo He nOJI!HblMII,

nOCKOJIbKyCy"eiiBblCmeiiIIHCTaHUIMOCTaBaJICfIIIBaH̲III4Z
Boo6me iogopH, HocJIe cMepTII IOpHH BacIIJIbeBIIIIa nMIITpoBcKoro (12 ceHTH6pH 1472 r.) HBaH III cpa3y >Ke 3aKpeⅡHJI CBOIO BJIaCTb Ha瓜ⅡpHcOenHHeHHblM yXeJIOM: OH BblJaJI

>KaJIOBaHHblerPaMoTblKaKHa3eMJIHcaMOronMHTPoBcKOro
ye3ma 48, TaK II Ha Te TePPlITOPIM, KOTOPble He BxOntHJIH B
44 rnB, noroX. 1905, ". 69-70, JYb 56.

45 0 BPeMeH'm erO IIryMeHCTBaCM.: ACSH,T"1, cTP、764-765.

46r,Ⅱ6, noron. 1905, JIJI. 73二74, Nb 59.
47 AC31i, T. II, JVh 229. B 3a1nHcKax KoHTal)HIIII IYojl l476 r̲ yKa3aIIo,
LlTOくCbIHa OT nePBOA )KeHbl)D HBaH III <He.c皿I皿KOM )KaJIyeT 3a XyPIIble ero HaKJIOHTIOCTII> (《nyTemecTBIIe AMBpocwI KoHTapIIHH妙.一
<<BH6JTHoTeKa HHocTPaHHBIx nHcaTeJIeii o PoccH", T. l. Cn6., 1836,
OTn. 11, CTP、1 13, 180) . O <<JypHblx HaKJI'oHHocTHx> IIBaHa HBaIJQBHqa

pyccKIie H6ToIIHHKII MOJIqaT (Cr). J. F e n n e l l. Ivan the Great of MosCow. London, 1961, p. 334) .

48 >KaIIoBaHHble rpaMoTb[ TpoIme-CePrmeBy MoHacTbipIq 1473 r.: oT
25 *eBpaJIH (rnB, noron.̅ 1905, JIm. 61 p6.- 63, Nb 43) H 1 1 MapTa
(AC32, TI, JYb 417) ; rpaMoTa HII'IMTe 3a60JIoTcKoMy, 6e3 naTbl( TaM
)Ke, M 419).
23

⑪

nMHTpoBcKIlii ye3X, Ho npHHanJIe>Kam lOpIIIo 49. O皿aKo
U

nPHCOenHHeHIIe yneJIOB K BeJIIIKOMy KHH>KeHIIIO BCfIKIIii Pa3
Bbl3blBaJIo POCT HenOBOJIbCTBa H Pa3,n<Pa)KeHHFI y OCTaBaBmIIXCH a>KIIBbIX yneJIbHblX KHH3eH II y nPe八CTa BHTeJI em
ソ

u

四

U

UePKOBHOit HePaPXHM (y八eJIbHble KHH3bH O6blIIIIO IOMOraJIHCbCBOeH且OJIH《HaCJIeⅡcTBa》)．ⅡO3ToMyJIaBHPOBaHHe
JIIIcb
cBoeii npJIH <(HacJIen(cTBa)') . no3ToMy JIaBHpoBaHHe H
BH瓜HMOCT. nePenarlH BblMOPO[IHblx yneJIoB B nPyrHe PyKH
6blJIII Heo6xoⅡHMblMII 3JIeMeHTaMH TaKTI1KII BeJIIIKHx KHfl3eil.
U

Bo3Mo>KHQ,HBaH̲IIInopyLIIIJIynpaBJIFITbnMIITpoBoMcBoe-

苫HBaHy. Bo BcHKoM cJIy'lae, 3a l474-1484 rr. Her
My cblHy
HcHblX XaHHblX O6

U

aKTHBHOii nOJIHTHKe HBaHa

lll

B OTHO-

meHHHIMHTPoBa.noJIo>KellmeMeHHeTcFIB1484/85r､7KOma7
cOnHOH
C
onHoii
CTOPOHbl，HBaHIII
cTopqlIbI, HBaH ̲III
BO306HoBnHeT
Bo306HoB"eTBbma[IyrPaMOT，
Bbmaqy rpaMoT)
KaCalOmHXCHmMHTPOBa50,CXPyrOiiCTOPOHbl,nOiIBJiHIOTcji
⑥

npH311aKHⅡOJIyIIeHHH HBaHOM HBaHOBIIqeM CyBePeHHblx
nPag Ha cy3"JIbcKIIe H raJIImKo-KocTPOMcKHe 3eMJIII.

Bce
naTIIpoBaHHble
|cBHneTeJIbcTBa̅o
cy3naJIbcKo-raJIHuKO-KOCTPoMCKOii n<eHTeJIbHOCTH HBaHa
KO-KOCTPoMCKOHⅡeHTeJIbHOCTH
HBaHa HBaHOBH[Ia
HBaHOBIIIIa He BblxO-

ⅡH'1，fiaJIPengJIbI̲BpeMeHII Me)Kly ceHTFI6peM 1483 r、HMap­

ToM 1485 n 5! K "M npHMbIK36T H3BecfKe, "TIIpyeMoe iio
ToM1485r､51KHHMʻⅡ”MblKaeTH3BecTIIe，“THpyeMoeⅡo
apxIIMaHnpHTy l482-1484 rn 52 3TV "THDoBKv ilWKHo cv八

I

コ

ご

3IITb, npmHHB 3a terminus ante quenl noh oc6HK 1483 f,
nocKOJIbKy, BO-nePBblx, naTHPOBaHHble TeK'CTbI He BOCxO4HT

K nePIIoLX PaHbUC STOrO MOMeHTa, BO-BTOPblx, IIMelOTCfl

rPaMOTbI HBaHa lll, KOTOPble no aPxHMaHnPliTy fO>Ke "TH49)KaJIoBaHHLIerpaMQT"TpoIme-CeprmeByMoHacTblpIoHa:1)3eMJIII
""ocTW, Bope, oT 21̲jeBpaJIH I473 p (ACSH, Tj, M 416) ;' 2) TepMeHeBcKIIii oMyT̲ B̲P. BOPe, "To IIM naji 6paT Moii kHfl3b lOpbiI
ロ BAg■

⑭

CIIJIbeBII[I>", oK. 1472-1474 rr．( rnB, no|rOⅡ、1905, 'JT，86, Nb 76) ;

3)c・KyqKH B IopbeBcKoM ye3JIe -BKJIaⅡno lOpHII BacImbGB"e,
1472/73 r. (AC3H, T. I, JVb 412).

50 yKa3HaH rPaMoTal484/85 n 6[Ie6paHIIli [IGJIoBeKaHaBGJIIIKoKHmKe-

WQWcMK･Yc,,AEoPaJPoWeFlgePrlleBaMoHacTbIpHBHMMTPOne
（rnB，noroⅡ．1905,J1．58，Nb35)；〉KaJIoBaHHa兄rpaMoTa
ToMv》Ke
""3cTblplo oT 6 anpe"'' 1486 E (AC31I, TJ, JVb 529) m nocJIdmyi6=
学

"e; B onlicHblx KHIIrax "panoHToBa MoHacTbIpH 1665 m l696" rr.
ynoMIIHaeTcH rPaMoTa BeJIIIKoro KHFI3H 1/IBaHa BacIMbeBHIIaくⅡMⅢ-

TPOBCKOrOye3myHaJIemKoBcKOiiHM:cMOHaCTblPCKmxBOT[IHHnd"OJI
"" " "JI9WoA,､IIIIca" "FTL7093-rQ (1) , ja qepHolo neqaTLI6jj

(rnB, Q 1v, JYb 398, JL 50 od; norouj911,'jL̅@6 66F;̅"MMMff
U

QTHpce¥" 3Tom rpaMoTb! KaK K I584/85 r., TaK H K 1484/85 r. coMHII-

TeJIbHa) .

5! AC", TJ1, M 396, 444, 479;
u TI11, JYb 237; "3Hx, [L 1, Jvb 248
/

2¥!licoK
53．

c HBHo !icKa>KeHHoii "Toii: <7000 BTopar" BMecTO 6992) ,

52 ACSH, T. 11, Nb 477.
24

９
９
１

PyloTcg!482-1484rr",[IoHeMomQWPWWWMIIM

1483-1484
r|rfBibx｡bibM)xMba"h
WH3-3a
Toro，IITo
BpeMH
(WWl
Cy3“JIeMII
IWI9W"
B3To
IIBaH
Ba
MII,叩MTtiWMTn
cJIemyeT
naWpoBaTp.
1482-neprOPOXOBuOMy>Key”aBJIflJTHBaH
ZBaHOBm（HHblMHCJIOBCHⅡojloBIIHoiil483rr.,arPaMOTylIBaHELHBaHOBIIIIa=
U

Mp5i･m65miohl483=14842r"npI""̲PWmeoCHoBa○

Hmz66TM"TbcH Ha l484 r., m60 Bge ToIIHo XaTmpoBa"r
U

TeKCTbI,ynOMIIHalO皿IIeI'IBaHalIBaHOBIIIIa,nOHBIIJIIIcb

B 1484-1IaIIaJIe l485 rr.) .
6bb6HfIKoM cToHT Tpm cyXHbIx cnmcKa, KoTopble.naT"yg

IOTC別n;WMTM,e̲CePrmeBa MOHaCTLIPa"""
iM-JM';" d""aiOiCfI KOCTPOMCKOif BOnOCTH HgpexTb'.
Cy瓜ⅡPom3BOmmCH
BO
BCe¥̲
TPeX
WIyrlafIX
<"
rWZ
i5"e f63MOTe BCJIiiKOr9 KHH3fI IIBaHa̲"WWIMW
U

p""; byXbfI nOJI>KeH 6bIJI nP¥JIaXbIBaTb O n,eJIe̲ f[OEWJ

U

Pi)>,
BejIIIIIOMYJ<HH3Io,
4̲cymHbIii
CUmC9K̲WM9pg¥"EWR
U

kiIM KHH3eM ̅HBaiIOM HBaHOBmqeM, KOTOPblli m BblHOC"

pemeHmeHaOcHoE3HIIIIsTIIxmcToq"K9B|WKH94W¥T2

fME{ntMEM IIBaHoBwI BblcTynaJI B 1488-14"TH

M､MM m"̅ i"HcTa'lum"9 WWWi ̲WW

5YigPeXEme6bmBKaKoit-TOMePenPHQ6Wl̲MIWU

JIeHIIib HePexToii, xoTMI He IIMeJI Ha Hee cyBepeHHblx,4IW;
u

napeBblx》ⅡPaB,
nPlIHaXJIe>KaBmHX
B
3TO
BPeMH
CaMOMy
IIBaHV
111．HMeHHooTcyTcTBmeMymBaHamBaHoBHIIaB
U

『 J

1488-Z1490 rr. <<rocynapeBblx》ⅡOJIHOMOIIIM HePexOTCKHII

3Tan erO KaPbePH OTJIIIqaeTCH OT IMIITPOBCKorO, ¥9"

cymbfl
cyⅡHJI《n6
0CnonaPfl
CBOeTO
CJIOBy
BeJIIIKOrO
KHFI3H
IiBaHa ZBaHOBIIIIa)> 55.

nPOMe>KyToK Me>K" "3maJIbCKo-raJWLK9"pTpWWMII ii"ET"MK (KoHeUl483 - HaqaJIo 1485 r) K HepexoTcKIIMII (1488-1490 rr.) 3anoJIHfleTcfI nPBoJIbIIo KoMEKIHblMBxPO|HOJIorII[IeC,KOMoTHOmeHHHKOMnJIeKCoMXaHHbIx,

nOKa3DIBalomHxcyBePeHHOeʼⅡoJIo>KeHHe
ZBaHa
HBaHOBHIIa

BTBepHHKamHib(beHTH6pbl485-MapT1488r.)56
53 TaM >Ke, JYh 478; T. 111, Nb 499.
54 TaM ]Ke, T. I, Nb 537-539.

55TaM)Ke,T.II,JVb229,cTp、149.

" TaM )Ke, T・iI M FiE, 5i9, 535; L LI｣ JYh 27jliJ 11.1!" 62:｡161, ｣#0;

rnB,noron.1905,J1．6006.,Nb47．Me>Knyl485H1488rr.HBaHMo-

i6iZit."5" "b'HTHO, TMTy" B"IIKorO KHFI3fI TBe"OrQ IjPBeCr"!
几Er.̅MMETLI -6 Haiinl!cbiO "KIIH3I, B""K IW1B"̅､ TBepclW
寺,

(A.Ope皿IiMI<oB.
PyccKHe
MoHeTb!
no
l547
r．M;1896,cTp.53;
A

6M >Kh. MaTepmaJIbI K PyCcKOii HyMIi3MaTIIKe nP utaPCKOrQ̲ngpm9".

M, 1901, cTp. 29, Nb 7) .b"aKo Ha 60JIbmliHcTBe ero MoHeT He yKa25

TaKoe
cTporo
BbInep>KaHHoe
pa'cnpemeJIeHHe
Bo
BpeMeHII
MaTePHaJIOB, OTHOCHmIIxC3 K Pa3JIIIIIHblM TePPHTOPWIM, 3acTaBJIHeTHo-HOBOMynOnOiiTHK
cTaBJIHeTⅡo-HOBOMyI10ⅡOHTH
K瓜aTHPOBKe
naTHPOBKe
HeⅡaTHPOBa'H'Hblx
HenaTHPOBa'H'Hblx

mcroqHIIKoB, B KoTopblx "ryplipyeT HBaH HBaHoBiIq. npeZEaPmTeJIbHO OTMeTHM, qTO HII B rPaMoTax TBePcKOTO nePliOna, HH B HepexoTcKIIx cynHblx 'cmicKax
l488-1490 rr.̅ HeT
HHKaKIIx 'cBeneHHH O nbHKax, yIIaCTBOBaBmHx B co,CTaBJIeHIIH
u

IoKyMeHTo'B.
HanpoTHB,
BonHo向Ⅱ3|rPaMOTcy3naJIbCKorO
nePHOJa ynoMm'HaeTCH1bHK BacH皿I曲且OJIMaTOB 57. y>Ke

H・A.roJIy6UoBnpaBMJIbHo,cHameiiTotlIkII3peHIIH,nOmE
TaJIcH cy3HTb naTIIpoBKy !nonnHcHoro IoKJIanHoro 'cVIHoro

cⅡⅢ'cKa
Ha
cⅡopHble3eMJIH'Cy3ⅡaJIb'cKoro
ye3瓜a，B
KoTopoM
U

gynibeII

U

nocJIeXHeH

IIHcTaHUlIII

HBJIHeTcH

BeJIHKHii
U

KIm3b

HBaHIIBaHOBHII,anoKyMeHT,no皿HcaHBa'c"HeMUoJIMaToBpLM5ayqIITbIB",JITonomBepmIITeJIbHylonomm65H"la MBaHoBIIqa l483/84 r. Ha >KdJIoBaHHof rpaM6Te Cn"-

EBql"iLeBy̲MoHacTblplocKpenIMXbHKBadnoJIMaToB59,

I'1.A・roJIy6UoBBblnBIIHyJIBKaIIecTBeHaqaJIbilOitBo3Mo>KA
HoII naTbl noKyMeHTa l483-1484 rl､., <KOrna K neJIy Mor
U

⑪

U

HMeTh､ oIIIomeHHe ynoMHHaeMblii 3necb XbHK Bac. UoJIMa-

TOB》60．nPaBⅡa，O且HOBPeMeHHO
aBToP
HcxoユHJI
H306皿Hx
一

⑪

cOOOPa >KeHHHo BeJIHKOM KHH>KeHHH HBaHa IIBaHOBHIIa nO

MWa l420 r" no3ToMy naTMpoBan noKyMeHT 1484=

1490 rr. O"aKo noKa3aHHoe BbIme cTpOro "oHoJIoriiIIe⑪

"9e Pa'cnPen(eJIeHIie mCToqHHKOB Pa3JIIIqHOii TePPHToPIIaJIbU

HoHⅡpllypoIIeHHocTH H oTcyTcTBHe ynoMHHaH" mbHKa BaU

PWIH .MIMaTOBaBrPaMOTaXHBAHaHBaHOBiitlaKOm
l485-1490rr・TPe6yIoTeUe60JIbmerocy>KeH""TliPOBKH
H 9rP3"IIe"H ee BPeMeHeM Me>Kny oceHbIo 1483 r・H Bec-

Hoii l485r. TaKaH JKe "TIipoBKa HiII60JIee o60cHoBaHa m
U

npaBoIi rpaMoTbl cyna K HayMoBa, 'HaqaToro <<no BeJIIIKOro
"IBaIoTcH ,Tep2HTopHaJILHble

aTpH6yU":

<BeJIIIKoro

KHH3H

HBaHa

llBa"*.(A;､9､p eJII K"o BPyc6Kme MoHeTU m i547fr6Tj̅51=
",̲ MW3="l:̲2 g JJyl)be 6qHTaeT, qTO II|" "aliliBiitrn5hy[IWI TIITyJI BeJJHKOI､9̅KIUI32 TBel)CKQrO HaP"y C THTyJIOM Be:ⅢHKOro

KH,13flMOCKOBCKOrO(H・9､IIypbeJMe9"rll[iecKajI66pb6aBpyccKOi
""IWFT"e̲ KoHUa XV =ilauaIIa XVI BeKa M=̅jif' MO;
cTp 3901 HcToqHHKoB, Ha3bIBaloUmx ero BeJIMKIIM KH"eM̅rtilodf6E｣

ｰ〆C K H M > ， M b l
、

ノ

He3HaeM、

"91i,̲jl,J1,r､Nb 44fP "c noJIMaToBe cM: JI B II e P en H II M
yKa3. coII., II. 2, cTp. 309-310.

５８ ACSH, T. 11, Nb 481.
５９
TaM >Ke, M 44|4.
６０

TaM )Ke, cTp. 521.

26

KHFI3FI rPaMOTe lIBaHa l'IBaHoBIIIIa》mPacCM aTPHBaBme|rO

TH)K6V63eMJIeBpaiioHeropoxoBUa61.

nfITb nPaBblx rPaMOT, HOMemeH'Hblx B nePBoM TOMe

ACaZ, Z A. roJIy6noB XaTIIpoBaJI 1485-1490 rr. Ha qgHo-

mmirCEOeronPeiCTaBJIeH"qj<BeJIHKOMKHHIKeHm"HBaHa lIBaHoBHIIa 'B 3To ,nflTIIJIeTHe62. Bo BTopoM ToMe H3naTeJIb
OTKa3aJI｣cH OT 3TOit HCXOEHOii nOcblJIKII H yKa3aJI B KaIIeCTBe

BPeMeHIIBeJIIIKOrOKHH>KeHlimm"HamBaHOBIIII4"nPJIge
nJIHTeJIbllblHHepHoユーcHatlaJIa70-xroXoBnol490r.，
U

3aMeTHB nPH 3TOM, IITO《Ⅱo 80-x roXoB THTyJI He cBH3bI
BaJIC凡Ⅱo-BH瓜mMoMy,cynpaBJ1eHHeMonpeXeJIeHHoHTePPIITOPHeih>>
63.
U

me
m3
nHTm
PacCMaTP|mBaeMbIXrPaMOT
oTHggHTcH
KHK

HeJIB6KoMy 64H Bepxmy6eHcKoMy 65cTaHaMnepeciI¥JIb-

3aJ,eccKofoye3na,o6eTIo皿Hca'HblXbflKoMBacH皿eMHoル

MaTOBbIM. BeJIHKHii KIIH3b IIBaH IiBaHOBHII BblCTynaeT B
ひ

U

3THXIOKyMeHTaXKaK'CynbH,HenOCPenJCTPeHHOBe瓜皿1IHneJIO,

oH H"BjiHeTcH <<rocy"peM> 'nonloneqHoii TeppIITop" Cy"

noⅡo皿HcH B. noJIMaTOBa, rpaMoTbl Mo>KHo |6blJIo 6bl oTHe-

cTH K IIepBoii noJIoBIIHe 80-x ronoB. CKopee Bcero gjlHⅡo⑪

HBHJIIf'Cb .B CaMoM HaIIaJIe IIx, eme nP nOJIyIIeHHH I'IBaHOM
U

HBaHOBIIIIeM |cy3XaJIbcKO-'raJIHnKO-KOCTPOMcKOPI TePPlITOPHH,

II60 B IoKyMeHTax o'ceHH 1483 r.­BecHbl l485 r. HeT naHHblx o n"BeXoMcTBeHHocTH eMy nepecJIaBcKoro ye3na.
｡

3a HaIIaJIo 80-x roIoB roBoPHT II |To, II|To B KIIHeJIbcKoli rpa-

MOTe IICTUbl-BOT[IIIHHIIKII ynOMIIHaIOT KaK HenaBHee 'Co6blTIie

cBoeoTcyTcTBHenonpmqiiHeHoBroponIcKoronoxo":<<AMbI,
rOCHO且mHe, 6blJIH c OTUOM |C TBOHM, c BeJIIIKHM 'KHH3eM, Ha

cJIv)K6eBHoBeroponeBBeJIHKoM》、BKapbepeHBa'Hal/IBaHOBHuaoTnpaBJIe"e XoJDKHocTH cynbH BnepecJIaBJIe-3aゴ

JIe'ccKoM 6blJIo,

Mo>KeT '6blTb, nepexoXHbIM sTanoM oT neH-

TeJIbHocTHB且MHTPOBeKBblⅡOJTHeHⅥIo60JIeeOTBeTcTBeHHoH
TeJIbHocTH
B nMIITPOBe K BblHOJTHeHHIo 60JIee OTBeTcTBeHHoii
MIIccIIH B o6JIacTII CV3naJIH H KocTpoMbl.

UBe npyrlIe rpaMoTbl, 6JIH3KHe Mexmy co'60imo ,opMyr
JIHPyHcoCTaBy XeHICTBylO皿IIxmm,KacaloTcFI3aJIeccKoih
U

U

U

BoJIocTM KocTPoMcKoro ye3ma H He HMeloT 4bflLlbeH IIo皿H-

cpI 66. B o60HX XoKyMeHTax HBaH IIBaHoBwI ｡H'rypHpyeT B
61 TaM >Ke, JVb 483 (3necb naTHpyeTcH 1485-1490 rr.) .
62 TaM )Ke, T. I, JVb 521|-525.
63 TaM >Ke, T. II, cTp. 521.
64 TaM )Ke, T. I, Nb 521.
65 TaM >Ke, Nb 522.
66 TaM )Ke, Nb 524, 525.
1

2

7

KaqeCTBe <<rOCynaPH>> II CynbⅢⅡOcJIenHei IIHcTaHuHII. Ha

ocHoBa'HHH TePplITOP]IaJIbHo曲ⅡPHHaXJIe)KHOCTII rPaMOT H
CyBePeHHOii
POJIIIHBaHa
HBaHaHBaHoBHIIa
lIBaHOBHIIa oT'HocHM3TH1oKVMeHOTHOcIIM 3T
cyBepeHHoKpoJIH

TblKoceHH1483-BecHel485r.,B'cooTBeTcTBHIIcTEppHToplJaJIbHo-xPOHOJIOrHIIecKHM PacnPen<eJIeHIieM AaTIIPoBaHHOrO MaTePHaJIa,

Oco6eliHbliHHTepecnpe4cTaBJIHeTnpaBaHrpaMoTaHa
U

U

nyQIo" KammHo B 3aJIeccKoit BoJIocTH KocTpoMcKoro ye3Xa 67. HaM Ka)KeTcH, qTo noKyMeHT 3ToT cobTaBJIHJIcjf 'Iie
enIIHOBPeMeHHO. nePBaH erO qacTb-ⅡPoToKoJI cy" Ky3bMbl
KﾉIIIMeHTbeBa,
nPOII3BO瓜HBmerO
Pa&C'CJIenPBaHIie
KnO
rOヅ

cynaPH cBOerO rPaMOTe

BeJIHKOro

KHFI3兄 H'BaHa

IIBaHO-

BHIIa》­MO>KeT6blTbOTHeceHa,O[IeBHJHO,
K
cy3,maJIbCKOEJIHIIKo-KOcTPoMcKOMy

nePHOJy

n<eHTeJIbHOcTII

HBaHa

HBaHoBHIIa.3arMBJ(oKyMeHTEnoHBJIHIoT,cFIHeKoToPble
<<frPaHHOCT". nOcJIe nOCJIeXHeii bPa3bl TIePBoi qaCTil U

《HO
ceMCyn<bfI
HJrbCH
nOJIO>KMTII
oChbnaPH
cBberO
Be皿KOrO
KH FI3H》­BMeCTO O)KHIaeMOrO cOO6meHIIH O XOKJIane HBa-

HyHBaHOBIiqyliOerOPemeHHHIIneT3aHBJIeHmeOmOrOII3
U

cBIIneTeJIeR coBceM npyroMy JIHUy - HIIK. Bac. BeKJIeMH-

meBy, 1nPen'CTaBIITeJIIO HBalla lll, nPH[IeM 3aHBJIeHHe, HBHo
KOMnPOMeTHPyIO皿ee

U

CyJIHblH

cIIIICoK,

nonaIHHbIit
U

Ha

Pac久

U

CMOTPeHHe:くAMpeiiKogKa3aJI,qTocyn6blJIHeTaKoB;KaK

nH'caIHoB'ceM|cHIIcKy>>.TaKoe3aHBJIeHmeMoJKHo6blJIocmeJIaTbTOJIbKoIIOHCTelleHHHKaKorO-TOnPOMe>KyTKaBPeMeHH
nOcJIe oKOHrlaHIIFI CynPmPOH3BoXCTBa. nJIH Hac Ba)KHO nO-

cTaHoBJIeHHeH・B.
BeKJIeMHmeBa,
KOToPblH
<<Be@JIeJI
cyntbe
Ky3MeKIIHMeHTligByo601ijwHcUeMcp6KyqmHIITmn6"
BeJIIIKHMKHH3eMIIBaHoMHBaHoBIIqeM,̅KaKY6y,meT
ycB6efd
章
U

9JIa y geJIHKoro KHH3fI co TBepm, noToMy (ITo ,KiIfl3b EeJIIIK"
四

HBaHBacnJIbeBHIIbBceHPyciIBeJIeJIc"b!3eMJ1HHbleoTJi5:
>KHTH IO CBOerO CbI|Ha, 40 BeJIHKOrO KHH3H>. meJIO He nPe,mnolaraJIoIcb pemHTb B caMoe 6JIm>Kaiimee BPeMH: He tJIV④

u

J

u

IIamHO
BeJIHKOKHH>KecKKii nbHK JIeoHTHii no
IIaHHO
BeJIHKOKHH>KecKHHⅡbHKJIeoHTHHⅡo旦ⅡH|CaJI
pe30JIIO-

UHIo BeKJIeMI1meBa <naMflTIi neJI" (IITo6bl lle 3a6blTb) .
JIH皿.,noCJIeaTorOqliTaeMTPeTblO̲linocJIeXHIoIOqacTbrP3
MOTbl, rne OHIICblBaeTCH nPKJIa瓜 HBaHy HBaHOBHLIy, PaC-

CMOTPeHIIe IIM H Peme'HIIe 3ToTO neJIa.

JyM"TcH,qToTH>KPaBo3HIIKJIaHe3amoJIromonepee3ma

HBaHaHBaHoBII[IaBTBepb,Bo306HoBJIelia>Ke6bl"ﾉIaBⅡe67 ACSII, T. 11, M 523

一
一

28

戸

pIIo且1eflTeJ1bH
OCTHHBaHa
l/IBaHoBIItla
TBepll,
B 11,
cKopee,
6JII1>Ke K KOHUy, HeM K HaqaJIy aTorO nePmOna, nOCKO"Ky

MBaHIII.OIIeBⅡ1ilO,y>KenPliHFIJIPemeHIIeoIIgPeBOJIeHBaHa HBaHoBIIIIa II3 TBepH・BblcKa3blBaHIIe BeKJIeMH'meB8
《KaK
6yneT
CBOerO
y
OUa..・co
TBepII》瓜OcTaTOKIHO
o'cTOPO)K-

ii67̅TI6'56piTliM BHIIMaHme, ̲'iro nogle MapTa l4Q@ r"eI
MM6EaKimBHoiinoJIllTIIKIIIIBaHaHBaHoBMqaBTBepcKoii
U

U

3eMJIe．BⅡ瓜HMO,HaMe[IaJICFIHenPIMe31cblHaarOCTIIKOTUy,

i(3KMo>KH6noiyMaTb,qIITafInocTaHQBJIeHIie̲BeKJIeMHmeBa,

3MMiian6JiiITwIe6KOrOcTaTyCaHBaHaliBaliQ"214U

KOH6U, 3aBePmeHme neJIa nPJI>KHO, " BC" BePOfITHoCTII,
oTHocIHTb!cH K 1488-1490 rr., KornaルIBaH MBa|HoBHII 3aHI1"

MaJIcHpa360poMKocTpoMcKIIx3eMeJIbllbIxT"K6BnocJI"

Heii [IaCTH M3yIIaeMorO八OKyMeHTa, |KaK II B cynHblx 'cnlI|cKax
U

1488-1490 rr., 'He HaxoLIIM !npll31･IaKoB <<rocynapeBblx》ⅡpaB

imHa n"HoEIIqa B oTIIomeiIIIII KocTpoMcKoro ye3na. HH､-

TePeCHO,IITOHOMo皿HIIKOM
(aMo)KeT6blTb,
COBeTII"PM)
II
U

"5"̅iIBaHOBHIIa B aTO BPeMH HBJIfIJICH 6JIII3KIlii K HBa-

Hylll"flK･enPpKyP皿bIH(OHno皿HCaJIPaCCMaTPlIBaeMylOnPaBylOrPaMOTyHany'cTOmbKa皿IHO68).
ご

y Ha|C eCTb e皿e nBa HenaTIIPOBaHHblx II3BecTIifI, cBH3aH-

IIblx c IIMeHeM HBaHa mBaHoBIIIIa. OIHo - 3To erq no八一

TBep>K,neHIieK)KaJIoBaHHoirpaMoTeIIBaHallloT18M"

1481 r・TpoHue-CeprHeBy MoHacTblplo HaraJII皿KIIe BO|TIIHHbl

(JBeCOJIfIHbleBaPH皿bIH皿OPBraJIIIIIe,IeP.r|He3皿KOB-

CKylOK".)69,XpyrOe-Pa3be3)KaHrPaMOTaCyAbHIIBaHa
BecTy>KeBa, naHHaH <<|no rocylapeBe rpaMoTe BWIHKoro "3-

3H IiBa'Ha nBaHoBIiua>' Ha cnopHble 3eMJIH KQcTpoMcKq7
U

f6Mmla,cTbIpHIIBaHanpe,ITeqmmKpecTbfIHKope>KcKoil
一

68 Cp. A A 3 H M m H OClioBHble n29"e",pePopM3""FJy"Wr
ʻcTHIIecKoro皿Ⅲ>KeHHH B PoccIIII B ̅XIV-XVI BB.­<HCTOPml, *OJIbU

KJIOP, llCKyCCTBO cjIaMHCKIIX HaPOnP". noW4pLSO2"". ,mW:1"'f V Me>K八y""Hblii c'be34. cJIaBMcTOB (Co*", ceHTH6pb l96al
唖

M., 1963, cTp・104; o H >K e. O noJIMTH[lecKHx nPe""bmKax 29M¥K-

IIOBeHHFIPyCcKOroa6COJIIoTII3Ma.­くA6coJIIoTII3PIIBPoccIIII(XVII­
U

XVIII BB.)". C6. cTaTeii K ceM皿ec別TIIJIeT1Iloco皿H 1)O)KneHHH H COU

POKamTImeTIIIQ"yqHOii
M､IIggal､orlluIecKoM且e兄TeJIbHOcTII
B.B.I<a"""M, 1964 cTI1 3& OKomo l482-1486rIA.Q̲KXR皿blH6bLJI
EBelirpHII,oTKy"oH ̲pepHyJIcHHen"八Hee 23 MapTal486 r.

．(几E.qbpeiiHMH" yK33.- c0q, q. 2, =CU. 311; no MHeHIW
H.C・JIypbd,<<KypmubIHMornpligx2Tb̲HB1485､r.He皿epaHee,BO

BToDoii liOJIoBHHe l484 r.沙一cM: H. C. JI y p l> e. yKa3. coII., cTp､401) .
69 rnB, nOrO八. 1905, n血.76 06.- 77 06., M 65.
U

4

29

BoJIOcTII KocTPoMcKoro ye3na 70 (TeKcT npnleJI B CoCTaBe
nPaliOii rpaMoTbl ()T 24 Mafl l 521 r. 71) .

Ⅱ04TB
epユHTeJI
bHa月3anHc.Ha
TpoliUKoII
rPaMOTe
anPe･
叩

coBaJIacb IIrIMeH)LMaKapHIo (1484-1488 rr.) II HMeJIa n6,m-

nHcb nbfIKa Bac. noJIMaToBano nbHKy II TePpIITopliaJIbHOit
U

ⅡPmyPOILeUHOcTH TPaMOTbl 3TO HOITBeP>"eHIIe MO)KHO XaTMpoBaTb l484 - HaIIaJIoM l485 rr.
U

B pa3be3>Kei HaM He ynaJIocb oTblcKaTb lMKaKIIx naTIIPyloIIl}I¥̲nPlI3"KOB, KPoMe CBeneHMii o CyBePeHHOM HOJIO-

>KeHIM
HBaHa
HBaHOBIIIIa
TePPHToPIiaJIEHOA
ll
npHHalJIe>KU

HOCTH且oKyMGHTa. 3aTo B npaBoii rpaMoTel521- I､., coxpaU

U

HHB山eH TeKCT̲Pa3'be3)Kem, ecTb nPHMoe yKa3aHIIe, IITo IIBaH

BaHOB}円く<C
II
KocTpoMbl
HocblJIaJmo30p皿ⅢKa>p
72.Mbl
3HaeM
BPeMFI I1Pe6blBalll呪 HBaHa HBaHoBIIIla B KocTDoMe - 3To
』

1483/84 r. 73 (Bo3Mo)KHo, Ii llaIlaJIo l485 r.) .

EcJIHoT｡aKToB,ycTaHoBJIeHHDIx34ec6nyTeMaHaJI'I13a
aKTOBOro MaTePliaJIa, 'nePeiiTH K II3y'leHIIIO JIeTonHCHblx TeKCTOB, |To B3aIIMOCBH3b 'CBemeHIM MO>KeT 'noIcJIy>KIITb oCHOBOii
XqIIFI PeKo'I1'cTpyKHI皿nOmｲTHIIGCKOM POJIII IIBaHa MOJIOIOrO.
u

U

U

Ha"JIeHIie
mBaHa
HBaHoBIiqa
|HEKoTopblMm
ynpaB"bil'[leg
CKIIMII
q)yHKUI1flMH
OTHOmeHHH且MMTPOBa
B
CePe皿He
B
70-x
ronpB
XV
B
6blJIo
o6ycJIoBJIeHo
HaETyⅡⅢB皿ⅡM
.CoBep-

meHH94eTIieM=ijacJIenHIIKa npecToJIa ( 17 JIeT) M cTpcMJIG-

H!ieMMBaHalll""ronoMo"IOHe#TI)aJIH30Baib!IPefeH311II
U

WIeJIbHblXKH23eiyIIaCTIieHBaHaHBaHOBMIIaBynPaB"eHHH
nepecJIaBJIb-3aJIeccKIIMKpaeMBHaqaJIe80-xrbmbBMOM6

OnpWleJIHTIJW onHTb-TaKII
OⅡPe旦eJIHTbIcH
onHTb-TaKH
HeHTPaJIH3aTopcKHMH
HeiiTPaJIH3aToPcKHMH
TeH瓜eʻHuHH­
TeHIeHUIIH-

MHHBaHalll,nblTaB皿eTOCHnPoTIIBoITOCTaBHTbcBoerOCblHa

yCHJIHB皿eiMcH
IIoc"e
cMepTI1
AHnpeH
MeHb皿oro
(1481
r.）

KoaJIIInIIII y皿皿KorqII BoJIOUKOro KHH3eii (e皿e 3a MeC皿

nocMepTMAH,mpeil. MeHbmorq HBaH III6bIJi BblHy)K"
yCTynHTbAHIpeloyrJIIiUKoMyMo>Ka#cK,aBopmcyBoJiOUg
U

KoMy P" ceJI) .

HoBoe
Bo3BblmeHIie
HBaHa
HBaHoBHIIa,
oTHocH皿eeCH,

cyJJI no rpaMoTaM, K KoHUy l483-HaIIaJIy l484 r., 6blJIo

cBH3aHO,
BO3MO>KHo,
ycJIo>KHeHHeM
C
J(IIHa6TIILIGcKOi
60Pb70JIJ1.
UrA8r.MocKBbl,巾.421
(40HcKoroMoHacTblpH),on.1,cB．l,JVb30,
06.- 9 ,06.

71
.I"",JJL7-15.CnHcoKKoHUaXVIIB"nonopueHHbliinoHII)KHeMy
KpaIo JIHcTOB.
○

72 TaM zKe, J1.8 06.; cp. J1. 12 06.

73A"IIX,w.1,M248,cTp213(o"BHoiiomli6oqHocTMAaTbl<<7000BTo○

ParO> CM BI,Ime) .

30

Ｉ

6b!nocJ1ePo>KneHIIHyWBaHaZBaHoBWacbIHanMIITp"
B oKTH6pe l483 r. 74 B BeneHHe mBaHa mBa¥oBIIIIa oT"Ba-

JIHcb (Iio cymecTBy Ha npaBax yneJIa) 'cTaPllliHble rHe3"
KHJDKetKoii bⅡHO3皿皿一Cy34aJIb|c|KHit ye3n |c ropoxoBIloM,
、

rmeOrPOMHbIMBJIIIHHmeMnoJIb30BaJIIIcbKH"bHLIIyiiCKze,
Iie,naBlilie cyBepeHbI 9TOit TePPmToPH1i, U̲PaiiOH raJIHqa KocTpoMbl -= HacJIencTBoHenoKopHoromeMHKII,HaKoToU

U

Poe M|orJIIi nPe瓜もfIBJIHTb nPeTeH3HH'yneJIbHble KHH3bH Mo6KoBcKoro npMa Bo rJIaBe c MfITe)KHblM AMpeeM BoJ1bmIIM

npHcoe"HeHIIe mBaHoM III TBepcKoro KHH>KecTBa, oT-

【I alCTHnorpaHHII|Horo c y'mIInKHM II BoJIoUKfIM yneJIaMII,
Hem36e)KHd XoJI>KHo 6blJIo npIIBecTH K naJIbHeimeMy o60U

CTPeHHIO
OTHO皿el･l'1噛'c
AHXpeeM
BoJIbmHM
H
npymMH
yneJIbHblMII KI-IH3bHMJI. B sTFIx y|cJIoBIIHx HacTynaeT KyJIbMIIIIaUH-

OHHblii MoMeHT nOJIMTIMIIGCKOih KaPbePbl lIBa!Ha l/IBaHOBI1IIa U

eMy'OTnaeTCH
(BCTaTyCe<<Be皿KoToKHH>KeHH")
TBepcKaH
3emJIH, npli'leM cpa3y no 3aBoeBalUill TBepII II, oRIeB"Hq,,
cOnPe"JIeHHblM｡oPMaJIbHbIMO6p.皿OM!Ⅲ瓜eKJIapaUIIelI
U

(He"pOM'qJaKToTMeneHBJIeTonlicII75)BaBoeBaHlleTBepH

MOrJIO Bbl3BaTb 6IOJIbmIIe 3aTPynHeHHH He TOJIbKO B"HyTPeH-

HerO, HO H BHemHenOJIIITHIIecKOro noP皿Ka(JIHTBa, O"a) .
nepenaIIa TBep'cKoii 3eMJIH BHyKy TBepcKoro BeJIHKoro KHH-

3fl̅BopHcaAJIeKca皿POBHIIaH<<ceCTPHqHIIy)'
(nJIeMJIHHHKy
noceGTpe)
cBeprHyTOroBeJMKoroKHH3HMmxalIJIaBopHcoBIITIa, CO3naBaH II3BeCTHylo BH41IMOcTb <<JIer}ITHMHocTH)",

nPeCJIeXOBaJIO naJIeKo Hny皿He BHyTPH- II BHemHenOJIIITIIIIecKIIe UeJIII・BeJIHKHii KHH3b HBaH HBaHoBHII HeMe4JIeHHo
U

TIpHcTynHJIKyKPenJIeHHIOcBoHxno3Hu砿BTBepcKoji3eM入

ご

JIe, Bb皿aB B ceHTH6pe l485 r. TplI )KaJIoBaHHble rpaMoTbl
Ha BoTIIH'Hbl B TBepcKoM, Ka皿HHcKoM II HoBoTopﾝKcKoM

ye3nax
ye3瓜ax
TpoHue-CeprHeBy
TpomUe-CePrlieBy
MoʻHacTblplo76，BJIHHTeJIbHeHmeMy
MoHacTblpIo76,BJIHHTeJIbHeiimeMy
nyXOBHOMy巾eOnaJIy, TeCHO CBH3aHHoMy 'c MocKOBcKIIM BeJIIIKOKHH>KeCKIIM nPaBHTeJIb|CTBoM.

He no3)Ke aB#rycTa l486 r., a cKopee B'cero paHbme aToro

BPeMeHHzBaH III HecKOJIbKO OrPaHHIIHJI ,nPeXeJIbl TePPlITO-

”Ⅱ，ⅡOJBJIa!CTHOii
l'IBa'Hy
HBaHOBIHqy・cy且I
nO
'COCTaBy
BblhaHilblx B ceHTH6pe l485 r. rpaMoT, HBaH MoJIonpHⅡoJIy-

IIHJI nepBoHaIIaJIbHo npaBo Be"Tb He ToJlQKo TBepcKIIM
HKa皿iiHcKIIM ye3naMH, Ho II coCe"HM HoBoTop>KcKIIM
74 nCPJI, T. 25, cTp. 330.
75 TaM )Ke, cTp. 331.

̲ 1

76 ACSH, 'T. .I, Nb 517-519; JI B. |q e p e n H H H. yKa3･coII.,II. 2,
cTp. 180.
31

ye3XoM 77. O"aKo y>Ke 27 aBrycTa l486 r. >KaJIoBaHHyIo
rpaMoTy Ha ceJIa HoBoTop>KcKoro ye3Ja Bbl4aJI caM
HBaH III 78.

He npHxo且HTcH coMHeBaTbcH B ToM, IITo, noJIyIIHB TBepCKyIo 3eMJIIO, IIBaH KBaHOBII[I HOTePHJ1 nPaBO Ha Cy3n<aJIbcKo-raJIHKKo-KocTpoMcKIIe 3eMJIII. 3a sTo roBopHT He ToJIbKo
oTcvTcTBMe KaKIIx-JIH'60 vHoMIIHaHHii o ero VIIpaBJIeHIM sTIIM

paiioHoM B KoHIle l485 - HarlaJIe l488 r., Ho ll HaJIIitme, c
oIHOii CTOPOIIbl, rPaMOT HBaHa lll BTOPOh ⅡOJIOBHHbl
80-x ronpB, Kacalo皿HxcFI Cy3naJIbcKoro }I KocTpoMcKoro
ye3ZIOB, C nPyrOit CTOPOHbl,­ⅡPIIBenleHHOrO Bblme nOXTBeP>KXeHI畑《BeJIHKoro KHH3H> BacHJII,uI IIBaHoBIIqa Ha

I､PaMOTe, HOCBFI皿eHHoii KocTPoMe. rpaMoTI,I HBalla lll no3BOJIHIOT yTOIIHIITb XPOHoIJIOmlO HOXTBePLHTeJIbHOhⅡonnl'I cII

BacImmFI HBaHoBIIIIa: GcJIII B KoHUe

l483 - HaIlaJIe l485 r.

KocTp'oMa |H raJIIIII e皿e nPHHanlJIe>KaJIH IIBaHy HBaHOBHIIy,
To, Mo>KeT 6blTb, y>Ke JIeToM l485 r. KocTpoMa nepemJIa B
BeXeHHe HBaHa lll (cOxPaHHJICH CⅡH'cOK c yKa3HOM rpaMOTbl

く93> r., HocJIaHHoii皿yxomaMcKHM BoJIocTeJIHM KocTPoMcKOrO ye3na: B intitulatiO Ha3BaH ｡eXoP HBaHoBHLI, nOCKOJIbKy rpaMoTa 6blJIa oTHeceHa nepemlcIIHKoM K XVI B､, OIHaKO
B. n. Ha3apoB II II. A. roJIy6UoB BoccTaHaBJIIIBaloT 3necb
IIMH IIBaHa BaCIIJIbeBIIIIa 79; y Hac HeT HoJIHoii yBepeHHocTH
U

B

nPaBHJIbHOCTI'I

STOII

KOH'beKTyPbl - B

OPHrHHaJIe

MOrJIo

VKa3blBaTbcH JImuO, HMeBmee OTIIecTBOくHBaHOBHII>: HBaH
I'IBaHoBHII HJIII Ba,cHJI嘘 mBaHOBHII; TaKoe nPennOJIO)KeHHe
ｰ

JIyIIme o6EHcHfleT omH6Ky |nepeⅡⅡc['HKa) .
B 1486/87 1,. HBaH III BblmaBaJI rPaMOTbI |Ha 3eMJIII B
Hep exoT℃Koii BoJIocTII H B BoHocTH CoTII KocTpoMcKoro ye3@ma 80; B MapTe l488 r. oH )Ke BblXaJI 'rpaMoTy Ha 3eMJI|H raJIHnKoro ye3na 81; B l488-1490 rr. Ho ero pacnopmKeHIIIo
3eMeJIbHblMII TH>K6aMII B KocTpoMcKoM ye3nle Be"JI BeJIIIKHii KHFI3b HBaH HBaHOBIIKI．OTcIoZIa 3aKJIIoIIaeM, qTo HoI-

TBep>KneHIie BeJIHKIIM KHH3eM BacIIJIHeM IIBaHoBII[IeM rpa­
MoTbI l454 r. Ha KocTpoMcKoh，mBOP MOrJIO COCTOHTbCH B

neplIo瓜HryMeHcTBa MaKapllFI ( 1484-1488 rr.) He paHbme
BTOPO曲noJIoBIIHbl l485 1､. II He nO3>Ke llePBohnoJIoBH･Hbl
1486 r. nbHK Ba｣CIIJIHh，Ⅱo皿Ⅲ|caBIHI1ii ,no,mTBep>KneHIIe BacIIJIHH HBaHoBHIIa,- 3To, Bo3Mo>KHo, BacI1JI砿 瓜OJI MaToB,
77
78
79
80
81

ACSH, T. I, M 517.
TaM )Ke, M 531.
TaM )Ke, T､111, cTp. 483, rp. 8.
TaM x(e, M 241, 502 (cTP 481, rp. 3)
TaM )Ke, M 243.
32

OTKOM
aIUIWIPOBaHHb耐nocJIe
npHcoeXIIHeHwI
TBepH
oT
HBaHa
HBaHOBII[laHⅡpIIc'raBJIeHHbIit K Ba'cIIJIHIo HBaHoBHIIy.
LITo Ka'caeTcfl ToPoxOBeUKOii BoJIoCTII, To 'cyユ〈<nO BeJIH-

KOrO
KHH3H
rPaMOTe
HBaHa
liBaHOBIIqa)',
npOIj329皿B皿嘘c3
3necb K. HayMoBbIM, MbI IaTmpoBaJIH oceHbIo 1483 - BecHoii

1485 r. 82 BJIII)Ka曲皿aFI no BpeMeHII K 3ToMy ･co6blTIIIo rpaMoTa HBaHa lll, 'nOcBFI皿eHHaH roPOxOBeUKoii BoJIoCTH,
6blJIa Bbl|naHa 22 XeKa6pH 1485 r. 83 3To |cBx且eTeJI b｣cTByeT

O noTePe I'IBaHOM I'IBaHoBIIIIeM nPaB Ha roPOxOBeU lle n03>Ke BToPoih noJIoIBHHbl l485 r.
O[IeBH且Ho, BacHm戒I'IBaHOBIIII 6blJT 'CneJIaH <<BeJIHKIIM

KHFI3eM>ウHI-IaneJIeHHeKOTOPbIMHTePPlITOPHHMII,6bIBmHMH
PaHee 3a l/IBaHOM I/IBaHCBIfIIeM, cPa3y nOc､ﾉIe nePeBOna nOcqJIeIHero B TBepb. 3Ta nonblTKa 3aHBJIellIIH BeJIIIKoKHH)Ke-

cKIIxHTeppIITopmaJIbHblxnpaBMaJIoJIeTHeroBa'cHJIHHo､6ycU

U

JIOBJIHBaJIacb, BePOHTHo, He 'cTOJIbKo 3anaIIeH HeHTPaJIH3a-

uHII yleJIbHbix KHfl3eii, CKoJIbKO naBJIeHIIeM Ha HBakla lll

cHJI,rpynmPOBaB皿1xcH̲poKpyrBeJIMKoih
KHHFIIHH
Co,bIi,

e皿e nPH >KII3HHHBaHa lIBaHOBHKIa MellTaB皿ell, KOHelIHO, O
DoJIII

HacJIenHIIKa

nPeCTOJIa

nIJIH

cBOero

'CTaP皿erO CblHa・

naBJIeHIie eTO 6bMo TeM 60J1ee 3HaqIITeJIbHbIM, IITo HBaH III,
Bo3Mo>KHO, nPH3HaJI nMHTP"-BHyKa <<BeJIHKIIM KHH3eM)>

CPa3ynOCJIeerOPO>K八e:H1iH84HTeMCaMblM
pemlmⅡIII-Ia-

CTII'IecK" BonPOc B noJIb3y nOTOM'CTBa HBaHa HBaHOBIIIIa.
no)KaJ1oBaHHe

Ba'cHJIIIIo

BeJIHKoKHFDKecKoro

THTyJIa

IOJI>KHO 6bIJIO H3Be'CTHblM O6Pa30M yPaBHOBeCHTb CIIJIbl CO-

nep HHIIIaB皿Hx cTOpO|1-1 85. HBaH III He naJI, 01HaKO, PaCHBe82 TaM )Ke, '1.. 11, Nh 483.
83 TaM )Ke, Nb 482.

84 B T. H. TBepcKoM c60pHHKe coo6皿aeTcH：く...Po八ⅢCH CbIH y BeJIHKOii
KIIFIMHbl y OJ1eIIIJI KHFI3b BenJI|IIK噸 ⅡMIITPeii liBallOBIIqb, IIa MOICKBe)"
(nCPJI, ̅T. XV, cTp. 499) . CaM HBaH IIBaHoBH'I IIMeJI TIITyJ1 BeJIIIKQrp
ukHH3H C l471 E (rBI-II1ロ, Nb 25-27; HCP几T. VI, cTP. 9; T. VIII,
cTp. 163, 168; J. F e n n e l l. Op. cit., p. 333) , no3ToMy H3BecTIie o
nO>KaJIOBal皿Hero cIJIHa TIITyJIoM

BeJI|IIKoI,O KHFI3fl y)Ke |nPm PO那八eHﾉHH

HeJ1Iｨ山eHo HoJIHocTblo BepoHTJ,IH. OnHa,Ko, HocKoJIbKy TBepcKoii c60pHHKcocTaBJI兄ncfl oKo,mo 1498 r., Koirna nMHTp" 6b皿旦eiiCTBHTeJIbH o
IBGHIIaII

Ha BeJMKOe KHmKeHHe,

eCTb Bce ocHoBaHHFI

nOnP3PeBaTb 3TOT

HcTOIIImK B Te皿eH叩o3HOknpHmcKe nMHFrP'lIIO BeJIH1KOKHH>Ke|cKOTO

TIITyJIa n" 1483 r. ('cp. A. H H a c.QH Q E"̲lleTQUcHbIe naMHTHHKIi
TIBepcKoro KHH>KecTBa.­くIM3BecT,HH AH CCCP>, VII cepHH, OTJleJIeHlle･ryMaHIITapHblx HayK J1., 1930, cTp. 741; J1. B. q e p e n H II H.
yKa3. coIL, [1､ 2, CTp. 300) .
85 4>K. (DeHHeJI cIIIITaeT, qTo conepHH:IGcTBo Me>K,my E,ﾉ1GHOii M CC*beii
HaLIaJIocb c 1483 r., 11IocJIe po)K八eHI1H nMIITpluI (J F e n l] e l l. Op.
cit, p. 324).
3

C. M. KalllTaHoB

33

u

CTH <BeJIIIKOKHFI>Ke,CKOH》ⅡeflTeJIbHocTH Ba,c'HJIHFI H, no-BH-

ユルIMoMy,y>KeB̲1486r.noKoHIIIIJIconblToMeroKocTPoMcKo!9KHH>KeHI13:BMecTecTGMoTo6paHHeBl486r.yMBaHa
IIBaHoBIIqa HoBoTop>KcKoro ye3", a nocJIe MapTi l488 n

巾aKTIj[IecKoe
nPeKpa皿eHIIe
erO
TBePCKOrO
nPaBJIeHIIH
B
neJIOM863acTaBJIHeToTKa3aTbcH
oT
II TPa"nHoHHOrO
nPeX-

cTaBJIeHIIH
O6H瓜･HJIJIHIIecKoM
xaPaKTePe
OTHOmeHHHM
e>KIy
MBaHOMIIIHHBaHoMMoIIToJLIM・IIHTePeCHO,IITOOTCTaBKa
U

MBaHa MoJIOIOro oT TBePcKoTo KHFDKeHHH CoBnamaeT nO
U

BPeMeHII c aKT}IBHOIi leflTCJIbHOCTblO nPl'I JBOPe MBaHa lll

po4cTBeHHIIKoB BeJIIIKo# KRF1rwww Co巾bH­ⅡMIiTpIIH II Ma-

HymJIaPaJIGBblx-naJIeOJIOrOB,HocJIaHilblxBCKOPeilITaJIHIo,
BepoHTIIo,CBa)KHblMnopy[IeHIIeM87.HoITpHHUIm<<pa31eJ1Hii
II BJIaCTByli>> He 6bIJI [Iy>K
mBJIacTByH》He6bIJI［1V>KユⅡo皿TIIKe
HBaHa lll. naBaH

I'1BaHymBaHoBH'IIyBI488r.npaBocy八aBTOPOi
A )IIICTaHUlm
B !lepexoTcKo-KocTI]oNIcKoi o6JIacTH, IIBaH III Jp611BaJIcFI
1eliTPaJIH3alLIilf HoTeHUliaJIbHblx IIJIII PeaJIbHbix nPeTeH31Iii
U

U

4

Co｡bII Ha HepexoTcKyIo BoJIocTb - ipa皿皿oHHblII yneJI
BeJIIIK" "HrllHb (HOcJIe cMepTH MaPHH HpOcJIaBHbl
ム
B 6ePeU

ユ

"He l485 rHepexTa KaK KocTpoMcK6e BJIahemme, 0[leBII"o,
nepemJIa Ha KopoTKoe BpeMFI B BeneHIIe BacHJIIIHルIBa|HO-

B皿a, T. e. ne-巾aKTo Co巾bll, a 3aTeM 'CaMOrO IIBaHa lll)

TaKIIMo6pa30M,H3nlecbHBaHMononoiiBbIcTynaJIBKaKoAU

TO MePe B Ka[IeCTBe aHTarOHIICTa

BeJIHKoi KHFITIIHII.

MHeHMeOTOM,IITOIIBaHMOJTO八oii<<npe6blBaJIHaTBepcKoM
△ KHHiKe-

86

⑤

IIIIII ,Uo cBoem cMepiTII B l490
11““cBoeHcMepITHBl490n沙（几B.
LI e p en H MI H. yka3. coI1., t1. 2,

cTp. 300) , He nonTBep>KnaeTcH IIcToIIHMIKaMII．E皿e B MapTe l488 r.
qocoJI noJIbcKoro KopolIH Ka3IIMIIpa ̲ll3JIaraJ! HBaHy nl >Ka'no6)'

CBOerOrOCymaP>IHa,neiiCTBHH皿onteii<<T(Pepb'cKoe3GM.ﾉIﾙI沙《cbIHaTBoe-

ro BeJIIIKqr9､j<HH3H MoJI9gloroll lj<C6. PHO'', T. 35, cTp
ムl6) , a y>Ke
B MapTe l489 r．ⅡOCOGJIHBaHalII3a皿H皿aʻﾉInepenl<a3Ⅲ］IIIpOMHHTppecu rocTeii <<MocKoacimliF 3eMIIII H T4)epbcKmebeMJIIImHdyropo4cKIIe3GMJIH>6e3KaKIIx-JIH|60ccIJIJIoKHa̅nO只旦aH'cTBOTiBePCKIIxrOcTeii
ゴ

oJIh
noCMbcKIIx
88
eBpallb
cJIe")
C
n.
"B
l490
!i 〔beBʻpaJIb
IIBaHy
23
l""9BIIqy
"KyMeHTax
cTp
.)Ke,
(TaM
l490n
nocoJIbcKHx且oKyMeHTax
B
'ynoMMHaloTcH,
y'ⅡoMmIaloTcH，Hal)皿v
11arljno
c nOKJIOHaMwI OT IIBaHa lll, nOKJIOHbl OT BeJIHKOfO KHfl3fl l/IBalia miall6BHLIa MOJILFKQMy JfOPQJIIO II KOPOJIeBIIKIaM II eMy OT HIIx (TaM >Ke,

cTpl8，19,34,40,41)，ueroHe6bIJIo paHbme (TaM >Ke, cTI1 6, 13,

!4!:､3TqnO3BWIHernPemOJIO)KMTb,ITbnOCJIe､MaPTaH八oIfloʻ1呪
!488 rJIBaH IilBaHoB|MII nepeexalI H3 TBepm B Mo6KBy (B̅pycckoli
l

WWXJIe IJoKJIOHa KOPOJTeBHIIaM eCTb cJIOBa: <KoTOPble TyT 6ynyT y
"PoJI"; OqeB"HO, H nOJIb:cKaMI cTOPOHa nOCblJIaJIa nOK"OHbl ̅I'IBaHV

ﾚIBaHQBII[ly,3Hamo ero nplicyTcTBIm ̅BMocKBe,npmoco6eBeJIm<6r6
，

KHR3Hj．
87

nCPJI, T. 27, cTp. 288.
34

B naJIbHe#IIIeii cyXb6e I'IBaHa HBaHoBIIqa P91cTBeHHIIKM
U

画

Co*bi chlrpa､nm,Bd3Mo)KHo,poKoBylopoJ1bJMe"Q̲m-

g636HHbiimMI! li3 BeHeUIIII JIeKaPb <<MRcTpo J1eo" BbI3BaJIU

CFI JIeIIIITb lI 3aJIeIIHJI Io |cMePTII TPHユuaTm瓜ByxJIeTHerO Be-

JIIIKoro KHH3FI, 3a60JIeBmero (Io HJIHnocJIe BO3BPa皿eH”
naJIeoJIoroB?) <<KaMLIIoroIo B Horax)> 88. CoBnaXeHIIe BR Bpe-

MGHII
npme3na
naJIGoJIoroB,
|6'oJIe31J1,1m《JI
exleHHFI》HBaHa
iim6"qaka)KeTcHnOPa3IITeJIbHbIM,xOTHOHOMo>KeT6bIT'
U

HCJIVIIaiMHblM.FIcHOOIHO:瓜mI1aIcTIIIIecKaH60Pb6aBoBTOPoii
J

Ⅱo｡ndBIIHe 80-x romoB pa3roPeJIacb c 60JIbmoi"IIIoi, n Hp
HCKJIIOqelIO,IITOI/I!BaHIﾉ1BaHOBwInaJIee>KepTBoi89.BTopoih

6paKRBaHallIccaMojpHa[IaJIaTamJIBce6ecMepTeJWW
oilacHocTb nJIFI IIBaHa MoJIoIoro, Ta:K KaK paHo Iimi no3"o

ⅡOJI>KHa6blJ1aBO311HKIIyTb60Pb6a3alIPaBOnPeCTOJIOIIaCJIe皿佃Me>KnyHIIMHcI)IHoMCo(I)bmnaJIeoJIOrl･IIIeMOrJIII
He
xOTeTb
H36aBIITbcfl
OT
I/IBaHa
MoJTo101,oⅡpH
)KII31111
1/IBaHa ll1, KOrna 'cEIH MaPHI'I BoPHcoBHbl He IIMeJI e皿e O'CHOBaHIIH 3aHHTb 'nPe|CTOJI.

KaKIIMII naHHblMm pacnoJIaraeM Mbl皿fI cy>KneHHFI O
Kapbepe BacHJIIIFI MBaHoBHIIa nocJIe cMepTII Be川IKoro KHHU

3HmBaHamBaHoBwIa
3H"mgaHa
mBaHoBwla
MOJIO瓜oro旦CO(bⅢ皿aJIbHoII
MOJIOIoro Io O(b
onaJIbl,
HaJIo>KeHHoH Ha BacHJIHHmBaHoMIII B KoHⅡe l497n？
U

OTMapTaⅡC
MapTa mo
a'BrycTa
a'BrycTa
l490E
l490
cBeⅡeHIIH，Ka'calo皿Hxc月
E cBeneHIm, Ka'calo

cTaTvca Ba'cHJIIIFI IIBalIoBH'Ia, HIcToIIH｣IIKII He |coxpaHHJIH・
ゴ

U

CaMoe pallHee l'I3 ToIIHo maTI叩CBaHHblx yKa3aHHHoTHocHTcH
U

K oKTH6pIo l490 r" Korna Bacli"" BbI"J WpjIJIeH)Wp
唾

rpaMOTy
rp・OcoKe
iIa
ynpaBJIeHIIe
noJIoBHHoii
ray6UoBa
99:
no -coo6meHHIo HIIKoHoBcKoIi JIeToⅡⅡ|cH II CTeneHHoi
U

KHMrH,BoKTH6pel490r.BeJIHKIIitl<IIH3bBa'cIIJIHiilIBaHoBIItl
nDHcvTcTBoBaJI Ha c'o60pe npoTHB HoBrOponl|cKHx epeTHKoB
ム

。

《bMebTO CaMOLeP>KaBHarO OTUa CBOerO> 91 a npyrIIX JIeTO-

nmcFIx II B xpoHOrpa｡e 3ToTo II3BGcTwI HeT. B XByx pe"KU皿x狐HTmH HocIId)a BoJIoHKoTo cJIHTbl Boe"Ho cBeneHHFI

Oco60pax l490 m l504 1r・BepoHTHo, IIMeHHo no3ToMy B
HIIx oTMeqae'I1cfI yIIacTIie BacIIJI" B pa60Te co60pa HapfI-

,XyCI'IBaHOIvIIII:《C'bceXFIme)KeoTneIMTOrna6JIarOIIecTII88 TaM zKe, cTp. 289.

89 iWi66XM̅ f6561" q norydneHllu HB41ia JIB"oBIFa, C"'! "HdMIIIHCo(I)beii(くCoIIMIieHwIKHH3HI<yp6cKoro:',T、1.Cn6.,1914,
cT6. 271 ) . Ho B ocHoBe aToro H3B"THH. JIe>KIIL PIIeB皿HO, CJIyX, CTaB-

lllI,Iii JIere皿on (cM' J' F e n n e l l. Op. ci,t., p. 334)'
90 ACSI'1, T. 111, M 181.

91 HCP几T. XII, cTp. 225; T. 21, BTopa兜no｡moBIIHa, cTp. 568.
35

3＊

〆

u

BblncaMonep>KeU
Bacm〃He...>92.
nO-BH且WIMOMy,
nOfIB"eHHe
BaclIJImfI Ha co60pe l490 r. B TeKcTax HIIKoH6bcK6fJIEf6=
砂

ⅡlICI!ll｡CTeneHIIoit,KHIIrliHanoTaK)KecqliTaTbPe3yJIbTaTbN{
U

⑪

no3"eHmero cMemeH" H3BecTHii o co60pax 1490 ii l504 rr.

"oIIHHKH,cqppcMeHHblpcgOopyl490T":I-aT̅6̅i"

cyTcTBIIIIHaHeMBa'cIIJIHH.B《noyIIeHHII>MIIITponoJIHTa30WMb! mrfqcero c960pa o epeTHKaX roBopIITcH,hpaBIa, [ITO

LIBana
Haco60pe
lll
nepBqmaqaJIbHo
B
cAMoMi6JEi68bIha
WIWpJIa4 0H BMecTo ce6H He MaJIoJIeTHe'ro cbIHa, a 60fIP
Ⅲ瓦bHKa:w<BcBoeMecTonplIcJIaJI60叩cBo｣Hx-KHFI3HI'IBa-

Ua lOpbeBIIIIa,､ IOpbH ̲3aXapbllqa, Bopmca BacIIJi6EE",
nHaKa,cBoeroAI皿peRMailfa)>93B
60JIbmliHcTBeTeKIcToB;
nocBHIneHHblx CO60py leKa6pH 1504 ､r., oTMeIIaeTcfl coBMe:

gTHoe jIIIacTMe "BaHa lll H BacMJIMH B pacKpblTIIII HoB!､o⑪

WWiePe"9411neyKa3blBagrCm,MTOBaCiIJIliiinP"MU

CTBOBa(ﾉIHaco60pe9MecTooTUa95,Ho(borTHapBbIgcBdLM
U

JIoHeceHIIH o"eH MeiilcTepy oT 5 ｡eBpaJIH 1 505̅ r. nH'caJI co

MoBpyccKoronJIeHHoro,[lIqllMeHHoBacnJIllihnpHKa3bIBaeT
U

"T4Tb">KeqbepeTIIKOB96(pepOHTHO,3Taxap5KTePlicTIIKa

9Mo"" K meHTeJIbHocTH BacllJIMH cpa3y riocJIe lco60pa,
"0 nepeg 3TIIM II3BecTIieM ynoMHHaeicH "o ""IIMM
Kyp皿.I") . CJIenoBaTeJIbHo, "Ba JIH Mo>KHo noJIb30BaTECFi
BepcHeiiHIIKoHoBcKoiiJIeTonHcHHCTeneHHoiTKH'IIrHo6vIIacTHIi̲BacIIJII1H B pa60Te co60pa l490 r.
U

U

“

UPyrIIe
""PoBaHHble
T6KcTbI,
KaCaIOmHeCHKaPbePbl

Bac""B1490-1497rr.,PacnPeneJIFIIOTCHBxPOHO-

JIorHIIecKOi
ⅡocJIe且OBaTeJIbHoCTHʻcJIe且yIomHM
o6pa30M：
l)1490/91r.­ⅡOnlTBeP>KIeHHeKrPaMOTelIBaHaHBaHOBIIIIal486r.06ecnomJIIIHHoMnpOe31eToProBblx3KCnemI92greW
""" 1903, KIL 3, [oTDJ II, cTp 34; H C JI yp b e. yKaa
｜Cow., cTp. 235-236.
93
E̲AKa3ali､oBa｡.¥.̲H
C
JIypbe.
AHT"eomla.ﾉIbHble
ePeTHWeCKHe
XBIDKeH"HaPy|cHXIV-HaulaJia̅XVIBeKa．M.­几,1955,cTp.385;
"A Ii. KJI II 6 a H o B. Pe.opMa"bIMi5且､BmKGHHH B POCCHH B
XIV­ⅡepB" nQ"PmmeXylB M, 1960, cTp. 199.
U

94 jJFMIA IM P",̲ 1848, cm 278E̲W" 49, 244; m XII,

CTp、258；T､20，nepBaHnoʻⅢoBIIHa，cTp、375；T、26,,cTp
28,

WIL337;
H.A
Ka3aKoBa
M9"eW"
"H" fWW"
xP6"PAMmi"C"ilUE
B
MML
⑪

95BBocKpeceHcKoHJe
I ToⅡHcHⅢBxpoHorpa巾eynoMmaeTcH川ImboⅡpH:yWBMM !H"a,E"!LB""" 6nymd"" (nCPJrrViirW ";
22,
[1．1,
T. pTp.515;C.0.mMIinT,npo八OJDWimC̲XPOHorPaq)a
Pe八aKUMH
I512roma.­《.MgropllilecK"apxmi",jr:yILM,"1951;cTf276;
u

gpJPEJL T26, CTR 337, IipIIMeqaHII)I e-em…一…）

96LEKUB,2-teAbt.,Bd.2,M722,S、563
(nepeBeJIacocTapoHeMeuKoro
XopomKeBHII,
JI
A
mo6e3HOyKa3aB皿aH
MHe
aTOTHCTOqHHK).
36

fi
"W
i WW鮮悩蹄酬:吋叩悶職F蝋糊;|
1<. CBHHblIHy o npoII3BonlcTBe pa'ccJIenoB"皿ⅡO CHOPHOMy
Me>KeBoMy ieJIy 98 B KocTpoMcKOM ye31e 99;̲3) 1492" Lcoo6mleHIie Padp"Hoit KImm o6 0TnpaBKe HBaHoM III BacIIJIHH B TBepb H o Ha3HaIIeH｣ⅡⅡ 叩HHeM BOeBOnaMII

n. B.皿eHHHⅡp. !00; 4) 1492/93 r.­ⅡOXTBep>KneHHe KyKa3Hoii rpaMoTe lIBaHa HBa'HoBIIIIa l487 r. o HeHapymeHIIH

<IOO血cII> cTapoii >KaJIoBaHHoii rpa'MoTbl TpoIiue-CeprlIeBy
MOHaCTblPIO Ha nBOPHⅡoJIflHyBKammHe(nbHK OJIema
Be306pa30B) ]0l; 5) 1496 r. MapTa-JIbroTHaH XIBoPlCKOro

>Ka6eHcKoi BoJIocTII KamlIHIcKoro ye3na KpecTbflHaM-HoBo-

Ca皿aM |02; 6) 1496 r. anpeJIH - yKa3HaH B fIpocJIaBJIb TIIyHy

o pa3Me>KeBaHIIII 3eMeJ1b 103; 7) 1496/97 r- yKa3HaH e"PyMIIxaiMoBycbnlyA,巾aHacbeBaopaccJIeXoBaHHHTH)K'6bl

Me>KnlyTpo皿e-Cepi､HeBbIM
MoHa'cTbIpW
HMIIKJII¥IIeNL3a-

xaPOgblM̅nOnOBOXy3eMeJIbJIePeBeHbnomlIHKOBoiiHBPlo-

xoBoiM B KIIHeJIbcKoM cTaHe nepecJIaBJIb-3aJIeccKoro ye3na 104; 8, 9) 1497 r. HIoJIFI 23 - - 4Be JIbroTHble nBopcKoro H
necFIuKoro )Ka6eHcKoii BoJIocTII KamHHCKoro ye3na KPecTbH-

Ha M-HOBOIIOP皿IIHKaM 105; 10) 1497/98 r.- JIbroTHafl BoJIocTeJIfl ropoxoBeUKoii BoJIocTII (Cy3naJIbCKoro IImI HH>Kero-

POICKOrO̅ye3na)
KPeCTbFIHaMKyxMblpeBbl'M106.
CneUHaJIblloro BHHMaHIIH 3a'CJIy)KIIBaeT BOnPOC o THTyJIe

BacHJIHH HBaHoBIIIIa B 90-x ronax XV B. B oKTH6pb'cKoiM

rPaMoTe l490 rHB･ TeKCTaX,巾HryPmPylomlIX Bblme noI
Nb 1-4, 6, 7, Ba'cIIJI" HMeHyeTcH npo'cTo ,KHH3eM・B TeKcTax JVb 5, 8­-10 0|H Ha3iBaH Be川IKHM KHH3eM BCeH Py|CH,
OIHaKo oco6eHHocTb TeKcToB Nb 5, 8-10 3aKJIIoqaeTcfI B
ToM, IITo Bce 3TO - BKJIIoqeHHble aKTbl,，momeⅡmHe B cocTaBe

ⅡonJIHHHblxIoKyMeHToB Toro BpeMeHII, Korna BacIIJI" HBaHoBHII 6blJI neii|cTBHTeJIbHo BeJIHKHM KHH3eM BceH PycH

(Nb 5, 8, 9-B 'cy皿oM cHIIcKe l504 r;, Nb lO - B npaBoit
97 AC31i, T. 11, JYb 271.
98 TaM )Ke, T. 111, Nb 244.

〆

99ye3八HaHnPII|HanJ1ex<HOCTbnDKyMeHTayCTaHOBJIeHalI．A.roJIy6moBblM、

100 <Pa3pH,ⅡHaH KHIIra l475-1598 rr.> M., 1966, cTp、23.
lo｣ rnB; noroL 1905, ". 64 06., JVh 47.
102 AC31'I, T. 111, Nb 163.
lo3 TaM )Ke, JVb 215.

104 rnB, noron. 1905, JT. 83­83 06., Nb 74.
Io5 ACali, T. 111, Nb 164, 165.
'06 TaM JKe, T. 11, Nh 489.
37

l529 r)ⅡJIH JVb 5, 8, 19 KoppeKTI叩ylo皿HM MaTePIIaJIOM
HBJIHIOT℃兄C"XpoHHble IIM rpaMoTbl JVb 6, 7. no3ToMy TIITyJI
B TeKcTax JVb 5, 8, 9 Mo>KHo yBepeHHo cIIIITaTb Pe3yJibTaTOM
penaKTopcKoi pa|60Tbl cocTaBPITeJIH cvIHoro IcHIIcKa l504 r.

MexaHHIIecK" xapaKTep BcTaBKH cJI6Ba <BeJIIIKoro>> B 3TIIx
rPaMoTax

OIIeBHⅡeH:

BMeCTO

nPHBbl[IHO曲旦JIH3Toro TIma

intitLllatio ]IHBePc" (<nO BeJTIIKOrO KHfl3fl cJIoBy…》107)
3Xecb Haxo"IM HeecTecTBeHHbli o60poT (<<no cJIoBy BeJIH-

KOrO KHH3FI…>>). Ha巾OHe HBHOii *aJIbCIIq)皿IiPOBaHHoIcTH
intilLI]atio B rpaMoTax Nb 5, 8, 9 0CTaHaBJIFIBaef BHIIMaHme
BHe山HHH JpcToBepHocTb (DopMyJIIIpoBKm B rpaMoTe Nb 9:
<nO BeJTHKOro KHH3fl cJIoBy...> nPlf OTCyTCTBHH且!JIH Nb lO
BIIoJIHe CIIHxPoI-IHoro cPaBHHTeJIbHorO MaTePHaJIa TPynHo
XaTb TBePJOe 3aKJIIOIIeHHe o CTeneHH To'IHOCTHnPaBOji rPa-

MoTbl l529 r. B nePena'le TIITyJIa Bac"P呪I'IBaHOBIIKIa

1497/98r･HeJIb3FIJII,IcBH3aTbropoxoBenKoecBHneTeJIb'cTBo
1497/98r.,ecJIIIcLIIITaTberonpcTOBepHblM,cynoMHHaBmlIMcH Bbl皿e 3al､anPIIHblM nOnTBeP>KneHI'IeM BeJIHKOro KHH3H

EacIIJIIIH HBaHoBIIIIa BcefI PycII K rpaMoTe l481 r. TpomlleCeprlIeBy'MoHacTblploHa,ropoxoBeUkIIelIHponoJIIIcKIieBJiaⅡeHHfl？

Bo BcHKoM cJIyIIae, c oKTH6" l490 r. np JIGTa l497 r.
BKJIIoIIHTeJIbHo BacHJIH曲 HBaHOBH'I HocIIJI TPITyJI TOJIbKO
K'HH3H・

noIIeMy TBepcKoe KHH>KeHIIe nocTaJIocb BacIIJIHIo He
Cpa3y nOC@ﾉIe cMepTHI'IBaHal/IBal-IoBHIIa？Heo'6xo瓜HMOⅡCM-

HHTb,IITOyHBaHaMOJIOnorO6blJIcblHJMIITPHii,KOTOPbIh,
no-B"HMoMy, HBJIHJIcH npeTeHXeHToM Ha TBepcKoe KHjDKe-

HKe.HBaHIII,BepoHTIIo,'KOJIe6aJIcHnPIIPemeHIMBOnPo'ca
o TBepcKoM HacJIeIcTBe. OLIeBH且Ho, TOJIbKO HOCJIe nOPa]KeHHH epeTIIKoB Ha co60pe l490 r. BacIm城nOJIyIIHJI nOJII'ITIIIIeCKOe nPeHMy皿eCTBO neP" UMHTPlJeM, BCJIen､CTBHe [IerO

HBaH III H 6blJI BblHy>KJeH npeXo6TaBIITb eMy TBepcKoe
KHH>KeHHe、

O THTyJIe nMIITpHFI Xo 90-x roIoB TpynHo cy"Tb H3-3a
oTcyTcTBHFI Hane>KHblx naHHblx. E皿e A. H. HacoHoB HocTa-

BIIJIB|OnPO'CO60THOmeH皿nMIITPHHKTBePCKOMyHaCJIenCTBy ero OTna: f<nPHMblx yKa3aHHhHa TO, COcTOHJIOCb JIII
Ⅱo)KaJIoBaHIIe-y HaC HeT…瓜MI1TP砿Ⅱo>KaJIOBaHHH O>KH-

naJI,Mo)KeT6blTbnoJIylllIJI>108.AHa@JIorHIIHoToMHeHIIHnpH107 CM., HanpILMep: ACSH, T・I, M 541 1i np
108 A. H・H aCoHoB. MKa3・COII., CTp､741.
38-

meP>KIIBae'I1CHⅢ几B・IIepenHIIH:<<yHa'cHeTHIIKaKIIxyKa"" Ha To, 'qTo TBepb nepemJIa K cblHy mBaHa MQJIonoro
U

U

JMI1TPHIo,HonPe旦乃FIBJIFITbHaHeenPa'BanOcJIenHHH,eCTe-

CTBeHiIO,
MOr)>
!09．BoJIee
onpeneJIeHHO
K
rImoTe3e
o
nplIo6p eTel皿HnMHTPlIeM nO HalCJIeXCTBy TIITyJIa BeJIHKOrO KHH3H

TBePCKOrOCKJIOHIIJICjIHCJIypbeulⅡ］K.eHHeJI,HanPoTIIB: 06p*I BHIIMaHIle Ha To, qTo B 6999 (1490(gl r) T"6IMOTiaMoTyHBaHaPIBalIOBIillanomTBeP4wI.PacmJIIli!11,
I13IIerOaBTOP3aKJIIOIIaeT:<...nocJIecMePTHmBaHaHBaU

HoBHIIa

BacIIJIIIi,

⑪

Ka>KeTcH,

IIoJIy[IIIJI

HoMIIHaJIbHbllI

KQHT-

po,IIbHanTBepbIo>"'12.A.A.31IMIIH,ccblJIaHcbHaoKTH6pbl

bKvIo rpaMoTV
ｰ 1490 r. m rpaMoTy 6999 r., nlimeT:くno'cJIe
L

ソ

cMbpTmIIBaHAIIBaHoBIIqaMoJIoXoro(MapL1490r)TBRpb
6bIJianepeJaHaHeeroMaJIoJIeTHeMycbIHynMIITplIIo,aBaCIIJIHIO I'IBaHOBpIIIy> 113.

ToKIKa3peHIIHH.C.JIyPbeJIH皿eHaKaKIIx-JIH60TBePlblx
U

OCHOBaHIIii, OnHaKO H B cxeMe IIccJIeXOBareJIeII, YcTaHOBIIBu

U

皿IIx, IJTo cbceHII 1490 r. TBepb noJIyIIIIJI Ba,cHm伽, IIMeeTICH
｡

U

oⅡmH Heo6'bfl|cHeHHblii MoMeHT: xpoHoJIoMIIecKI,IH pa3pblB

M6>KIv cMepTbIo HBaHa lIBaHoBMqa (MapT l490 r.) II nepabIゴ

MHⅡbOHBjieHIIHMⅢnpaBBacIIJIIIHHaTBepb(oKTH6Pb
1490 r.).
A. B OpemHIIKoB oTMeTIIJI cymecTBoBaHIIe mByx MoIIeT,

npenⅡOJIo)KIITeJIbHO TBeP'cKorO nPoII'cxo瓶ⅡeHIIH, c IIMeHeM

K"" nMIITPlifIBecbMa yCJIoBIIO oH oTHec11x K nMHTPIIIo-

BHVKV,oroBo.pHB
ʻ rImoTeTIIIIHocTb 3Toii aTpI46yuHHIIBo3M'o>K­
U

HobTEXpyrHX
HocTb且pyrHx
ToJIKoBaH戒ʼ'4．ABTop
ToJIKoBaH"｣'4.
ABTop
cBH3blBaJIⅡdHBJIeHI1e
cBH3blBaJI
ndiIBJIeHIie"
，

MOHe:T c KoPOHaUIMeii nMIITPHFI-BHyKa H BblCKa3aJI Jpra"y
o HoJIVIIeHIIH IIM TBep'cKoro KH"KeHIIfIImH且eHe>KHorO OTKy-

naBTBepILOnHaKOnpeXJIo>KeHHoeOpemHIIKoBbIM¥p"ojlOrmqecK6enpmypoqeHiieMoHeTnpmHHTbHeJIb3fI:Bl4981 502 rr.且MIITPIIi llocIIJI TIITyJI BeJIHKorO IglH3H｣ a ̲¥a MO○

HeTaxOH巾HryPmPyeTnPOCTOKaK<(KHH3bnMIIT{Pmii])'.
Io9 JI. B・I-lepenHIIH・yKa3. COII., II、2, cTp. 300.
110 H. C. JI y P b e. yKa3. cow., cTp. 390.
III ACSH, T. 11, JYb 271.
''2
J･Fennell. Op.cit., p. 335.

113 A A. 3IIMI,IH・OcHoBHble npo6JIeMbl…, cTp. 104; oH JKe. O no,、TH[Ie|cIKIIx npennocbmKax..., cTp. 33.

114AOpemIIIKoB.nBenpepHePy|ccKHg̲geH#"­《ApxeoJIorIIKIecKHe

"BEcfmlI K 3aMeTKml, 1 897; Nb 1 2,̅ cTp. 382-384i p H X e. MaT&21ia"

ifWE|6K6iflJMiigMdTiIKeXdUapckordnepliomaM,1901,cTp25­26,
u

池69．
39

EcJIIIcoMacHTbcHcAB・OpemHIIKoBbIMB ToM,IITo

liglieTb[ OTHOCHTcH K JMIITPHIo, BePHee, Ha Ham B3TJI",
44W9B",､Hx ¥o THTyJIy BpeMeHeM no l498 rno!cKoJIbKy
oceHbIo l490 E TBepb nepemJIa non BJIacTb BacIIJIHH IIM6L

ggc"II oH BnJIoTb np l497 n JImqp mo'cbIJIaJIcH B TBepb,

JIH60･HMeJIBJIa且eTeJIbHblenpaBaHa
KamH'H'cK皿ye3瓜,e皿HU

gZ"H" xPOHO"orllqeCKIIit OTPe30K, K KOTOPdMy Md"b

9JHecTII TBepcKIIe Mo"Tb! "HH3m UMHTpm", cIIIITaJI ero

且WITPmeM-/BHyWJBa¥III,-3TOnePmOnMe)K4yMaPToM H oKTH6peM 1490 r. 4'o皿enmme IIcT6qHIIKH He hO3B6-

IWF pa3ra"rll,gleUll*liKy qQJIo>KeHIIH TBepII B anpeJIe

1488 - Mapre l490 rr" koria IIBaH MBaHoB"ri6ZBMM6=

"y,oTcyTcTBoBaJIB3ToMropoUe.nepe皿JIaJIHB3TOBPeMH

I"p̅JO4IIoMIIHaJIbnyIOB"2cTL4MIiTPmfI̅(T6rna3MM:
rHIIecKIIePaMKH皿H"THPOBKHero̲MOHeTPacmmPHIoTcH),
ム

9cTa"a'Cb JIH oHa bOPMaJIbHo <3a)> HBaHoM MO"oibIM MJili

eJi"61KIMEM&W,
XcTBeHHo
By>Ke
6bIJIa
MeH，cKa3aTbTpyⅡHo，BoBcHKoMcJIy〔Iae,瓜yMaTb，'IT
TpymHoBo
PWWb
pcHKoM
cJIyqae,̲4yMaTb,
TBePb瓜ouTo TBepb
'cl488r.nonaJIaBc巾ePyBJIIIfIHIIHBacHJIIIH,HeTocIIo⑨

⑥

BaH", Tak KaK B 3TOM CJIy[Iae elBa JIHHMeJICH 6bl XPOHOU

JIorlIIIGCKHH Pa3PblB Me>Kly CMePTbIo IIBaHa HBaH6BIIqa

I1ⅡpPBblMm npoHBJIeHIIHMI{ npaB BacmJIIIFI Ha TBeph
H3yqeHme mcToIIHliKoB 90-x roppB XV B ho3BoJIHeT
311aIIHTeJTbHg PaCmlIPlITb Kpyr MaTePHaJIOB, oTHoCflmIIxcH

KKapbepeBacHJIHH
IIBaHoBHKIaB3TOBPeMH．B>KaJIoBaHHoIi rp4M9reIiBaHa
HoHrpaMoTe
liBaHaMoJIo且oro
MoJIomoroTpoHⅡe-CeprHeBv
Tpo
MoHa▲

ソ

cTblpIo l485 r・HaCeJIaKa皿IIHcKOro ye3naHMeeTcRno旦一
TBeP班且eHHe l492/93 r., no皿HcaHIIoe nbHKoM OJIe皿KoH
U

Be306Pa30BblMll5．Ⅱp'11
1i34aHHHnOIJIIIHHHKa
OKa3aJTOCb
¥FBo3MO)KHbIM nPoqecTD HaqaJIO 3TOrO nO4TBeP>KneHIIIL

Hg,J9Mor"mcnHcKH,"oTeKcTObLII
HemcilbaEhbIM̅M

E XVI B (nepenIIcIImK8" "4QB XVI B oTMer" <<fiepZ
Bble cTpoKII He 3HaT,") . B AC3Hn'pe皿oJIO>KHTeJIbHo naeTCH c,JIenyIo皿aH

peKoHcTpyKUl,IH TeKcTa:

<<KIIH3b BeJIHKIiii

I'IBaH BapIIJIbeBIIIIb Bcea pycIIIイnO Cei rPaMOTe nO)KaJIOBaJL .)> OT aToii KoIrbeKTyPb[ cJIenyeT p6皿HTeJIb'Ho oTKaじ

3aTbCH, yIIIigblBaR HaJIIIImie COXPaHHBmerOCH nOITBeP>Kne-

HHH KH33H Bac"" HBaHoBIIIIa､ 1492/93 r" 3a ho皿Ifcblo
LIIJ"a OJIemm Be306pa30Ba, K rpaMoTe HBalla lIBalioBHIIa
1487r.,Kacalo皿eHCHTPOImKoronBopalInoJIFIHblBKamHHe: <<KHH3b BacmJIeii HBaHoBIIq no c6ii rpaMoTe no"Ji""
U

U

''5 AC311, T. 1, Nb 5il9
40

TpOHuKoroHryMeHaCHMaHa36paTbelo:ceeyHHxrpaMoTbY
PymHTHHeBeJIeJIHIIKOMyHm[leM,aBeJIeJIOBgeMX9ⅡHTⅢⅡO

T6My, KaK y HIIx B cTapbix rpaMoIax micaHQ JIgTa 7000 nep-

BOr6.A noin,,CaJ]皿aK OJIema Be306pa30B)> 116.
EcTb Bce ocHoBaHIMFI cIIPITaTb, LITo H rpaMoTy l485 r. noX-

TBepXIIJI B 1492/93 r. KHfl3b BacIIJI嘘HBaHoBIIq, B cBoIo
6bIfHocTb B TBepH. Cy" no MecTy H3BecTHFI o nocblJIKe BacHJIIIFI B TBepb B 7001 r. cpe瓜Ⅲ叩yrmX 60JIee TOIIHO ,naTIIPOBaHHbIX 3anHCeii Pa3PfUHOii KHIIm, Mo>KHO IyMaTb, 'ITO ne･

pee3江IIeTblpHanUaTMJIeTHeroKHFI3HBTBepcKyIo3eMJIIoco-

6ToHJIcFI B anpeJIe l493 r. CJIeJoBaTeJIbHo, rpaMoTbl oH Mor

no'XTBe"HTb̅Me>KnyanpeJIeMHaBrycToM1493r.
HMeeTcH

nPBOJIbHO

MHoro

Ile八aTHPOBaHHbIX

TeKCTOB

90-x roXoB XV B., ynoMIIHalo皿IIx KHH3H BacwIHfl l'IBaHoBIIIIaHJIH HCXOIFIIIIIIX OT erO IIMeHM, ODHaKO TOJIbKO nflTb H3
U

}-II1X nOJIylll'IJIM B HOBeHmI1x II3naHIIHx nPH3HaHIIe noKyMeH-

ToB, me noX KHH3eM BacﾚIJIIIeM IﾉIB aHOBHﾘeM HOXPa3yMeBaeTcH 6VIV皿砿BacIIJImiM I I I 3To - 1 ) HoIITBep>KneHIIe 4<Ee･
JIIIKor6 1<HH3H)> BacIIJIIIH IIBaHoBHqaくBcefl PyCII)" K yKa3-

HoirpaMoTeHBaHaMQJIoXoro
l48ar・oco6JIIoneHHI,IcTapbixfpaMoTHa3eMJImTpoliUKoroKaJIH3!冊Ia
MOHaCTblPFIB
KamHiIcKoM ye3JIe (nbHIt "Xop CTpoMIIJIoB) 1I7; 2) KoR:
MJEi"rPaM6TaZBjllyCanblKyilanbKpoBcKyIoBoJ1ocTb!i8
U

』

(3V6noB6Koro ye3") !'9; 3, 4, 5) noKyMeHTbl, nocBH皿eHHbIe

6n6DHblM 3eMeJIbHblM neJIaM B HPocJIaBcKoM ye3ne: nPa』
U

BaH｣'20, nOKJIanHoii cynHblit cnHcoK 12', oTBoIHaH-pa3TjU

e3>KaFI '22.

Oco6eHHylo TpynHocTb npegCTaBJIfleT AaTIipoBKa non-

TBep>KXeHIIH̅KrpaMoTel488r､TIITyJIBeJIKKoroKHH33̲̲E"

PVcII He Mo>KeT cJIy>KHTb 3Xecb naTIIpyIommM MOMeHTOM,
n6cKoJIbKy aToT TeKcT, TaK >Ke KaK M TeKcTbI p
nOcKOJ1bKy3TOTTeKcT,TaK〉KeKaKHTeKcTbl
paccMoTPeHHblX
accMoTpeHHblX
Bblme JIbroTHblx rpaMoT 1496 II l497 rr., nomeJI B cocTaBe
cvHHoTo
cnHcKa l504 r.,ⅡHceU KOToPoro PenaKTIIPOBaJI
ご

IMmafiJcTapblxrpaMoTnpmMeHIITeJIEHoKHoBoiio6cT4HoBKe Ka3aJIotb 6bI, HalI60JIee BepoHTHoe BpeMH nomBeP>¥-

i5M-ZWi" 90-k ronoB (no " 1493 n bKmoqliTeJIbHo) ,
'16 rnB, noron. 1905, n. 64 06.
117 AC31I, T. I|11, M 161.
ll8 TaM >Ke, Nb 183.

119ye3nycTaHoBJIeHH.A･roJIv6noBblM.
120 AC3H, T. III! JYb 208.
121 TaM )Ke, Nb 209.
122 TaM >Ke, M 210.
41

KOma lL COCTOHJIIICb BCe XPyrHe H3BeCTHbIe nOⅡnHcaHIIH

rP3MoTIIBaHaMoJIonoroHa̅jiMHBacIMMHIIBaifOEMM̅6I
"9..MRWB ̲"rP rgpoPIIT IJIOM"aHme XbHKa OenPPa

CCTpoMHJIoBa
BMecTo
OJlemm
be306pa30ga,'̅､IMn6瓜nHcb
U

WWiM B ylOcTqEPPIITeJIbHQi q"TII BCex nonTBeP>KnleHIIii
U

BacIIJIHRHarlaJIa
90-x
ronoB
I23.H.
A.
ro.JIy6npB,
̅KoMMeH-

WYZ rpaMoTy l488 r., 3aMeTIIJI, qTo noiTBep>kmeHIie ee
HMe.JIOMeCTOくB
KaKIJe-TOro皿｡I,npeⅡⅡIecTByIo皿He
27
nie-

Ka6pH1498̲r"Koma6blJTKaf3fieH'.、 瓜bHKeXOP

CTI)oMHJIoB>D
124

<1498》­oneIIaTKa:
CTpoMIMoga̲Ka3HIIJIII
27
neKa6pH
I497
rj25｡
II3
J1eToHIIcHblx
iI3BecTI耐
①enop
CTpoMIIJIoB
Bbl-

CTynaeT KaK O,皿H H3 0IIeHb 6JIH3KIIx K BacIIJIIilo JIIm B nePHO瓜，HepOcPencTBeHHOnPe瓜mecTBOBaBIIHihOnaJIenocJIen-'

Hero !26. HMeHHo oT "iopa CTpoM"5" B55Hm蝋《cBenaJT.．. To, qTO OTelIb ero̲ KHH3b BeJIHKII xOmeTb )KaJIoBaTII

WWM WIH)KeHI1eM. :. BHyKa CBOero KHfI3H JMIITP" HBaHoBHIIa)".CTpoMIIJIoB巾HryPmPyeTB3TIIxI13BecTHFIxBKaIIecTBe CTopoHHHKa aKTIIBHoit 60pb6bl BacIIJIIIH 3a cBoII nPa人

Ea - 60Pb6b[ BnJIOTb np MIITe#Ka:くH IIaIIa nVMaTII
'K"310
章

gacmJIbIoBTopbIi
QQToHIIn
npenTe"AMaMij5nweHOK,
q"bgnyMeBToiimU"!<menopCTI;bMM5,ⅢⅡOFIpOK
○

U

PyHOB6PaT,mmHblene"60HPCkm6,3HHblXTaHI-IoKUeJIOU

BaHIIIo nPIIBo且Hma Ha ToM, IITo6 KHH310 BacIIJIblo oT oTIla
cBoero oTLeXaTH BeJIPIKoro KHH3FI, Ka3Ha norpa6HTII Ha Bo-

llOmel!HaBeneO3ePe,KHaTKHfl3eMIMHTPeeMHa4BHyコ

KOM H3Xpana yIIHHHTII), 127.

!2.
OBe306pa30BecM.:JI.B･IIePenHIIH.yKa3･coul.,w.2,cTp.309.
!24 4CalL T: 1I1, crp 176, npHM K Mi6I
125nCP几m̲IY},11,BbIL2,PJP530-531;mVI,@TI)､279;T.VIII,
cT｣L234;T̲XII,cTP246;269:T、39:nel)BaHno"oRlllla,crp.366;
T.28,̲CTp.330;T.30,.cTp.139;AA･maxMaToB.OTaKHa.3blBae&
MOii
POCTOBCKOii,7GTOmlCII．",1904,cTp、82-83;CI).nCPJI,T.22、

ILLXPoHorpa(ウpemaKu川!1512rona,CTp.513(6e"aTbi)"
126CBBecen6BCkmiiomm6oqHODM0"i6且ⅡⅢIcbCTpoMIIJIoBa
aKTe,
B
U

|IIOIO2"̲"JH̲PacCM9IPeILBblme, He K JIb̅ITBe"""̅EAMM:
a K TeKcTy l488 1､.：くOH(CTpoMIIJIoB- C K)6bm "HKoM y B.̅Kii!

PWia̲"amOBIIqa !I Hax6"JICH n"HeMWBMT15"' "O"

W23̲VeHa cTqPO¥e KH mMUrPlifl, cbIHa HBalfa HBaHoBiqa, a Ha

cTopoIIeB.KH|r.Co巾bli]4KH.BacIMHH-HenoHFITHo>(C.BBeceg
J10BcKHk.B､ﾉ1a"MIII) ryceB - CQcTaBIITe"b Cyne6HiIKa l 497 T6且a­《HEJRMgecKIig3amicK",T.5,cTp.46).
I27 UliTno nCPJI, TIV, " l, Bbm. 2,W､530.
42

ー

唾

HTaK, HaJIIIIIHe B IIOLTBeP"TeJIbliOH cTaTbe nO旦nHCHHe

OJIemmBe306pa30Ba,cBH3aHHqrocBacmJIllejiBnepBble:Q-

I6i̅55 ""H", amemopaPTpoMwIoBa, 6JIII3Koro K Ba･

CIIJIIIIOBOBTOPOHnoJIoBHHe90-xroIoB,no3BoJIHeTnaTmpoU

BaTb 3To no"Bep>KmeHHe l496-'1497 rr., KoMa, ,gY,Ⅱ､H nO
U

JiZf6THbIMrPaMofaMIBoPcKIIx,BacIIJImiiynpaBJIHJIKamIIHC K H M -V e 3 X 0 M .

M6>KIio BbIcKa3aTb eme XBa coo6pa>KeHIifI, KoTopble
⑪

MyT
HanPaBJIeHmm
B
Cy>KeHIIHnPe"WKeHHOⅢ且aTIIPOBKH

nePBOe:I-lecBH3aHO皿InoHBJIeHHenpmBacIIJIHⅢHBaHoBHIIe
①ehopa CTpoMwIoBa c nepexPmPM B BeneHMe MoJIWIp
KH"'irOPOj<OBeIlKOiiBoJIOCTM(oqeMMbI3HaeMm3ynPM21
U

M5;jIEMMMM6T6!roPoj(oBeUKorQ̲BoJIoqIe"1497/
U

U

ざ

98r.)？BeⅡbHMellHoHanpaBohrpaMoT
emBaHamBaHoBHIIa，
〃

oTHocHUeiicH K ropoxoBUy, cToIIT Ho瓜nIIcb nbfIKa enoPa
U

CTpoMmJIoBa !28Hg IIMeeM JIII Mbl 3Aecb neJIo c."WWlI5
HoHTPa皿'皿me齢EcJIHTaK，To且aTHpoBaHHblHMaTepﾚIaJI
U

U

(Bcefa>KeJIbroTHaFI1497/98r)"eTocHoBaHILeWIIIWL,

IITOnOnTBeP>KnelllIe6blJIOCjKeJIaHoIlepaHIJ皿eBTOPOiinOJIO-

BIIHbl l497r. OTcIona HecKoJIbKo 66JIb皿aFI BePOHTHOCTb BeJIIIKOKHH)KeCKOrO TIiTyJIa 3neCb, IIeIvl B JIbrOTHblx rPaMOTax

l̅496­nepBoiinoJIoBIIHbll497rr"li60mMeHHocnoc､me"Ⅲ…
U

MII MecmaMII KHfDKeH1wI BacIIJIIIH, Ka>KeTcH, cBfl3aHbl ero

nPeTeH3IIH,
KoTOpble
MorJIm
6blTb
OnlHoi
l'13
nPH可HH
OnaJIbl
1497 r.

BToDoe: B cBeTe cKa3ailHoro JIoBoJIbHo MHoro3HaIIMTeJIb典

U

HO 3BV[IaT HOcJIenHHe cJIoBa HccJIeXyeMOHⅡOITBePLIITeJIbHOi n6皿ⅢCII:く…且OKynb1 fl3 IIX, KHH36 BeJI2KII, PIOﾝKaJIylo

655ei5fPaMoTOlOnP6[IHolo>KaJIOBaJIHoIo)P.
3Ta巾OPMyJMPOBKa,,<bTOPyIoBUeJIOMHeJIb3H3anOmP3P"bUWWH-

fi66TII'(coMA6HmHKacaIoTcHToJIbKoTHTyJIq)cB皿eTeJIbCT,

ByeT,
C
OIHO向cTOPoHbl,
Heno.JTHOmPaBmHBacIJJII,IH,
o
C
npyrbiCTOPOHbl-OKaKIIX-TOerOnPeTPMQyfI)lⅢ皿HpoKIIxnJIa○

U

iI5Ma6"ymeeno-BMAIIMoMy,B 1496-1497 rr:̲MlW

HeHMeJInPaBanO4TBeP>KmaTI二、HMMyHIITeTHble
rpaMoTbl,II
U

caMOHOHTBeP班旦eHileliMKamfI3PIHcKoi
rpaMoTb!
6blJIo
He
BHoJIHeJIOHJIbHblM
BnoJIHe
JIOHJfbHblM且eHcTBIIeM
meicTBIIeM !no OTHomeHHfO
OTHomeHIHOK BeJIHKoMy
U

KHH3IO･

KopoIIe,Mblllpe瓜nOJIaraeM,IIToPaccMaTPlIBaeMoellOnTBep>KieHIieoTHoEIITcHKoceHII1497n

二一
­­
128 ACSﾚI, T. II, cTp. 521
43

IITO
IiaCaeTcH
KoPMﾉlelioi
rpaMoTb!
noKpoBcKylo
!la

29:19"..3Y"BcKoro̅ye34a,To,oLiEMHd,̅Hef.MMMM
U

:WW"WWkee "TmpOBKyBCn6NMIIFMW

PHaJIbHo-FWMO-xPOHOJIorliqecKOe
PaCiPe"JIe!冊Ie
naTIIPOBaHHblx

PaKTePm3yIO皿Hx
¥KcTOB,
TBepcKoH3eMJIH：B6999r.，T，e、Me》K凡y
̲ BacH皿JWWW%
npaBa
f｣rmc"""MM|YIW
.""ET
ceHTH6peM
l490r，
I1a¥4::rycTpll
!i49r"
1cocToHJIgcb
no"eP"6M叩aMoTbl
U

l486J.,I""rypliPoBaJIaくTBepcKafI3bM""BU6"Om,̅E
WW"'̲r"" MecTP. ""k6FMM MMM
u

HaⅡoM9̲I9J19EMHyr3y6UoBa;B1492/93IIBI+496=i"W"W
”

:IW､,nWW"aLcTaPble rPaMOTb! !i calIKMmiil)b"
Bbl八9HM9W｡H33eMJIm,H4xoRIIBuimecmTOJIhKOB6m5i
IIacTMTBepcKoi3eMJIH-BKamIIHcKoMve34e.
R P

U

He
cBH且pWRCTB"
3To
JIII
CymecTBeHHOM
o
cOKPaUe-

HMHBKoIIIlel49I
1､.Tepl)IITQpIIM,no4BeJoMcTBeHHojiBacH"2 2 1)aiiOHe 6h!BmerO TBePhKOfO ̅Ri"""" fMe
!9KWWWe"ITol)lil! MorJIOHaxo4MTbcH B nPHMoi &#
3H
nPe且nPHHHTblM,
c
nO-BIIﾕHMOMy,BOBTOPOiⅡOJIoBHHe
⑥

M̲r;"JIIICUOBbIMbnllCaniiCM̅TMkOr""ﾉIH,Ko|rna
U

IWJL BnePBble

"nOC"aLT1]c""3MrWaT;W

MWW ¥9", 4nmcaJI T"EKHH3b "omop OJIMIdiE,

CTap皿y
a
PppMc
KyTy3QB,
3y6UoB
fi
ma
OMHnMIITP
HH
U

nelWB,aKIMH neTp̲ JI96al! .3a60JioTUKof̅rXahif..M
MoBoii
ropo49KA""
KopoMbTm6E;̅d̅kh｣mHH
BacHJIeii
U

U

KopoMblmOB), 129

nPHBeneHHOe
J1eTomlcHoe
II3BeCTHe
He
HMeeT
ToIIHOii
99TMMW=I19Me"HOBcJ1em3a(bP330iiQnePeROmeTOP:
⑪

｡

r¥""129W "P"oHe>K B @eHTh6P.̅ 149rrHo"
npe瓜meCTPyeT. .:TaTbfL OnOlIMaHHMAHJPemyrJI!皿Koro
20
geHTH6pH
1491
OIIGBIIIHo,nHcUoBoe
E
omlcaHIIe
TBepCKOII3eMJII16bmOnPe
一

四

cKoH3eMJIII6bmo'ⅡPeユnPHHHToBcKopeIIJIIIcPa3V>Ke:nocJIe
JIHKBH且aummyr､珊皿KOrPKHH>KeCTBa.3TOHaBO"THa
MbIcJIb, qTo np apecTa AHnpefI HBaH III noqeMv-T6､He
"
ｰ
maJIcH HayaTb omicaHHe TBepcKoii 3eMJIH <Ⅱo­MocKoBcKH
U

4

g glWJg liMeJI JIH A"peii onp"c"eHHblX̅ i"EMM
U

U

B OTIIOmeHIm TBePCKOro HacJencTBa MIIxaﾙIJIa BOPHʻcOBmIIa9
上

cy皿Ⅱ940roBop2MHBaHallll486r'(aBr#cTaline-

%a6")
BopILoMBacwIbeBHIIeM
c
BMoiKIim̅rA､皿peeM

BacH@JIbeBHLIeM
yrJIMHKI,IM,
TIocﾉIe4HIIe
o6fl3aJIMIcb
He
<<BEcTvnarlic" .Bo T｡epb [i B KamblH II Bo BcH T(PeP6K"̅rB
ジ

I29nCPJ1,T、V111,c'I､,P223;T.XII,C|TP.232;Tʼ27,
cTP，362;T.28,
cTI).156;C．O.皿M1皿'1,.yKa3・coII.,cTP.264(UIIT.no'r.27):
44

KanlllH'bcKaH MecTa, Bo Bce BeJmKoe KHFI>KeHbe T｡epcKoe)D l30. 0,IHaKo He IIcK皿OIIellO, ulTO HaKaHyHe nPHcOe且ⅡHeHIIfl TBepH I'IBaH IⅡⅡPelJIO>KIIJI IIa PacCMOTPeHI1e KHfI3e曲MOcKoBcKOrO IoMa ceKPeTHblAnPoeKT Pa34eJIa TBepcKoro KHmKecTBa H, Bo3Mo>KHo, AI-Inpelo II BopH,cy, KoTopble yIlacTBoBaJIH B TBepcKoM B3HTIM 1485 r., 6bIJIII o6ema,HbI KaKHe-To IoHoJIHeHHH K IIx ynheJIaM 3a cIIeT TBepcKOii 3eMJIII. JoBO"bHO 'BePOFITHO yIIacTHe B sTIIx nJIaHax H

npecTapeJIoTo KHH3H MHxaIIJIa AIInpeeBHIIa BeJIo3epcKoro,
yMepmero nl)IIMepHo IIePe3 110JIrO4a

n'ocJIe nPHcOe且HHeHIl別

TBepcKoro KIIH>KecTBa (BecHoii l486 E 131) .
CaMa IIJefl pa3naIIII TBepcKHx yJIeJIoB

He 6blJIa

3KcTpaBaraHTIIoii, nocKocJIbKy, Bo-IIepBblx, B TBepcKoM BeLIIIKOM KHfl>KeCTBeH且O npPICOeⅡH1･IeHwI cyUeCTBOBa.JIII y八eJ1bl, H3 KoTopblx nel)BGHcTByloUee 3HaIIGHIie HMeJI KamHH-

CKIM, BO-BTOI)blX, B 4yxOBHOih l'IBaHa lll nO[ITH BCe 6blBmHe
U

TBepCKHe

y4eJIbl

OTUaBaJIIIcb

B

PyKH

y八eJIbHblX

KHFI3em,

MJIa且mHx cblHo'Beii BeJIHKoro KHH3H. TeKcT IVxoBHoii BocxOJHT, nO-BH典HMOMy, He K OIHoMy, a K HeCKOJIbKHM nPenmeCTBylO皿HM
BaPHaHTaM↓｡",
B OCHOBe
KOTOPblX MOrJII,I JIe1

句

n

>KaTb Pa3Hble 40KyMeHTbl, B TOM qHCJIe li CeKPeTHblii nPOeKT

l) a3ne唾ma TBepcKoro KHH>KecTBa. CoI､na CHO八yXOBHOi I'IBaHa lll, KHH310 4MIITpHIo, noJIyqaBmeMy B MocKoBcKoji

3eMJIe y r JI H KI, B TBepcKoih 3eMJIe oTXaBaJIHcb 3y6UoB II
OHoKII; KHFI310 AHXpelo, KoTopoMy llpeXHa3HaIIaJIacb B yneJI
B e p e H, B TBepcKoii 3eMJIe >KaJIoBaJIHcb CTaPllUa, XoJIM I1
HoBblji ro'po4oK l33.
He 6blJIa JIH 3Ta KoM6HHaUHH cKaJIbKlipoBaHa c ceKpeTHoro npoeKTa cepenMHbl 80-x ToIoB, npem'noJIaraBmerO, BO3Mo>KHo, nepemaIly yrJIIIUKoMy KHFI310 AⅢ瓜PeIO BOJIbmOMy
3y6UoBcKoro y八eJIa, a BepeiicKoMy KIIH3Io MHxaliJIy AHUpeeBHIIy-CTaI〕ImKor,〔)？l34He o6T｡HcHfTeTcflJ1Hl)ea〃bʻ1-11〕1曲
130 nMnr, JVb 81, 82.

131 HCPJI, T. V111, cTp. 217; T. XII, cTp. 218; A. A、3ⅢM H H. KpaTKIIe
JIeToHHcUbl XV-XVI BB.­《HcTopHIlecKIIii apxIIB>j, T. V. M.- JI,
1950, cTp. 35; no no4cIIeTaM H. A. ToJIy6HoBa, KHH3b MHxaHJI AH-

npeeBHII yMep 9 anpeJIR l486 r. (ACSH, T. 11, cTp, 449, 695) .
132 C. M. KamT a H O B. nlm.JIOMaTHKa KaK cneUHaJIbHaFI HCTOPlI(IeOKaH
皿CuHnJIIIH a.­《Bollpocl)1 McTdp":', 1965, Nb l, cTp. 43.
133 nmnr, cTp. 360-3611.

134 HHTepecHo, qTo o6eulaHHble B 1480 r. AHnpeIo B ymleJI KaJIyra H
AJIeKcHH (nCPJI, T. VI, cTp 20, 2'23; T. V111,
cTp.
204;
T. XII,
cTp. 198) 6bInHB 4yxoBHoii liBaHa lll 3aBe皿aHbl ynteJIbHblM KHH3b-

HM: KaJIyra - CeMeHy Be)KeUKoMy (HacJIe八HJIKy IIaICTK KHH>KecTBa
A"peH BoJIbmoro) , AJIeKclIH - A"pelo CTap皿KOMy (HacJIeUHHKy
45

oTKa3MHxaIIJIaAH八PeeBHIIaOTBeJIOO3ePal35,nplICOXpaHellHH 3a HIIM <BoTIIIl｣IHbIx)> nPaB Ha Bepelo, nepcneKTIIBoih

IIoJIy[IelIHH yAeJIa B TBel)cKoi3eMJIe II He naTIipyeTcH JIH,
cJIenpBaTeJIbHo, eTo myxoBHafl '36 1485, a He l486 roloM,
KaKnPenJIa|raeTcI皿TaTbJI．B・IIepeⅡHHH？137Ⅱo､cJIe瓜HH月
4aTHpoBallHaH rpaMoTa MHxallJIa AHIpeeBHrla Ha 3eMJIH
BeJIo3ePCKoro ye3nta 6bl｡Ta Bbl八aHa 26 MaH l485 r. 138. Mo̲

"WE 6bIM,cOCTaBJIeHMe eroAyxOBHoii'OTHoCIITCHKJIeTy

1482 r. !39, T: eK nepllQUy nOlroToBKII TBepcKoro B3fIT"
BoJIoUKIIi K,HfI3b Bopllc BacwIbeBPIII, tKopee B|cero,

npeTeHIoBaJI

Ha

noJIyIIeHHe

6JIIi3Kor|o

K

BoJIoKoIJIaMcKv

KJ'IIHa・OIIeBWIHo, He cJIyLIaiilIo HBaH III BHocJIenIcTBIiii
IJel)emcKoII !JacTII KH"KecTBa MIIxall,ma

A皿l)eeBIIY'a)

(且咽r,

cTI1 360) . 3ToT (1)aKT Io II3BecTHoii cTelleHI! oIIliaMIJIBabr n6IibiTkIi
I)eTI]oCIIeKTHBHOrO aHaJIII3a八yXOBHOii IIBaHa lll八Jm Bbl；ICHeHII別ⅢC-

()!c)｢山ecr3JIellllblx ymeJII>llblx lIpoe|K'I､oB KOMIIa XV B. nl)oeKT l480 r.
oTpa3II･JIcH B cnMIcKax ,moroBopa l473 r., penaKTIIpoBa|Bm'HxcH B 1481 r.
W)I!､n9#rOToBKe HoB9Io ,moroBopac AHnpeeM (nHnr, cTp. 242, 248;

几B. q e p e n̲IM H. yKaa coq., il. 1, cTp. .170).

135HoMIIHaJIMpMII"WLjHApeWiL!
dTK33aJIcffoT
BeJIoo3epaemeBploro9ope ｣483 E (nMⅡr, Nh 78), IIo TaM peIIbm順o IIePexOne Be-

peHC'KO-6eJIo3ePCKOii BOTIIIIHbl B PyKI1 BeQ)I凪ぐOrO KHH3H TOJIbKOⅡOCJYe

cMepTII 6eJIo3epcKoro KIlfl3H (cP A A 3 II M H H. O xpoHoJIor岫且yxoBHbIx

H

noroBopHblx

rpaMoT

BeJIIIKIIx

II

VneJIbI･Iblx

KHH3eii

XIV-

XV BB.­《Ⅱpo6JYeMbI IIcToIIHIIKoBenleHM",f VIM,1958, cTl)318,

n1ﾙ1M 254).
136瓜Ⅲ瓜r, Nb 80.

I37 TaM >Ke, cTP、301, 305; cp. J1. B. IIepenHHH. yKa3. co[1., '1. 1,
9TL .175(34eCh 3"ppoTHQcl" 3ToT4bKyMeHTK1485-1486rr.).

138ACSH,T.II,Nh397;cp.M269,272."TmpoBKam℃JIe,uIHeii
rPa-

MOTblHO ,,町yMeHyBeHe"KTyl486roJLoMHe npeAcTa|BJTfleTcJIy6e"""HoII, TaK KaK HeJIb3H oTHocIITb Ha[IaIIo HryMeHcTBa BeHelHKTa

K l486 r. JIHmb l･Ia TOM OCHOBaHIIII, qTO erO nPe旦皿IecTBeHHHK rVDIlii

*mrypmpYpTnpA6993rollow.("!>KeJVQ267);KOTopbliinplixo血jIcH

HaCeHTH6pbl484-aBI､y〈､T1485rr.THTyn《BcejlPyCIM)DBrPaMOTe

,6993r・HeroBopHTo6H3aTeJ12Ho
34̲1485
r.,nocKoJIbkyoHylioTpe6J1兄JIC兄e皿e B rpaMoTe CeHTH6" l484 r., oTHocHBmeii6H K foMV. ]Ke
(BoJIor"cKoMy) yeamy (TaM )ke, JNb 266) ;

'33Bo Bc3KoM cJIy[lae, B 3TO BI)eM兄Ⅱ"H IIIBIIOBb cTaJI OCVUeCTBnHTb
cBoﾙi IIaTPol･laT HaX Bepe曲cKIw ye3.nDM. B IIIoHe l485 rr oH BbmaJI

>KaJIoBaHHylorpaMoTyTpoI皿e-Cel)rlle,ByMoHacT1.II1ICHaC.I'iJIGMHy

《Bo KH"Ke MIIxa伽IoBe PilJII)c"Ij[la BoTIImHe>(ACEﾙI, T. 1, N. 516).

nl)e,nbLmymme rpaMoTb! IIBaHa lll, KacalommeciI BepeiicKIIx' M MaﾉIO)11)ocJIai)eUKIIx 3eMeJIb, IIe B()cxOﾕﾁIT K IIel)IIoJly nocJIe l482 r. (TaM

>Ke, M 462,46;, 497, 498) . 3To 3HaLIIrr, fITo Mel"y KoI皿oM l483 II

cel)"IIHoii l485 n coxpaH>IJ] cil:my 40roBop oT l2 heKa6pH l483 r.、
a HaqimaH c JIeTa l485 m ero mleiicTBIle nePeKI)blJIocb XeiibTBHeM Ka:
KOrO-TO mPyrOI̅O COrJIaⅡlerlIIH, oyPBI11Ho> nyxoBHoit MIIxaH.JIa AHJLI)ee-

BIII'a (cp.几B. 'I e p e n l.I II II. yKa3. coII.,̅ q. 2, cTp. 178-180)〃
.
46

BbIMeHIm cbIHoBbHM Bopmca BacII'mbeBMqa ̲BoJIouKoro

K皿冊IcKO-TBePCKHeBOJIOCTIIByiroPO八IIKoJInbl40.
IIoCa>KeHHellaTBePCKOeKH"KeHﾙIeHBaHamBaHOBHIIa,
U

3Toro nOIITH

<<JIermTIIMHOI､o>p HacJIe4HIIKa TBepCKHx KHfl3eli,

6blJ10,6e3ycJIoBHo,JIoBKHMMaHeBPoMIIBaHalll.Hoo6ecneIIHJIO J1II OHO eMy《3aKoI-IHble> oCHoBaHHH 4JIH OTKa3a oT

BCeXO6H3aTeJIbCTB，，naHHblXy瓜eJIbHblMKHH3bHM？MblTOIIU

Ho3HaeM,qToHBaHMBaHoBIiqynpaBJIHJIpaitoHaMHTB&pII，
KamHHa ll, oIIeB皿Ho, KJIIIHa. O 1GTaTyce 3y6UoBa M CTapIIUb｣ maM HIl'lero He ll3BecTHo. KaTeropli[lecK43 cTa"
6THbclITeJIbHo TBepcKoih 3eMJIH B nproBopax HBaHa ll!
U

○

l486 r. c yrJIMUKIIM H BoJIoUKMM KI-呪3bfIMII Ha nePBbIM
B31､J1皿He ocTaBJIFleT cOMHeH皿B ｡aKTe oTKJIoHeHM BeJII1U

KOK!|"<eCKI1M nPaBIITeJIbCTBOM KaKIIX 6b! TO Hm 6bIJlO

-Vﾉ1eJIbHblX nPHT}13alll1#I

IIa 3Ty TePPHT()'PIII() B LIeJIOM.
TeM IIe Mellee 4JIH l490/91 r. MojKIIo KoHcTaTl叩oBaTI，
U

nPllCTa川JHoeBIIIIMallIIellOCMTeJIemBJIa'cTMKPahoHaM3y6UbBa m CTapmUbL B oKTfI6pe l490 r. KHH3b BacIIJI畝 mBalioBMq Bblna)I KopMJIeHylo fpaMoTy Ha noJIoB"y n 3y6Uor
呼

Ba・KTo pacnoI)fDKaJ1cR
ユ
B 3To BpeMH BTopQI[ noJIpBIIHo¥
U

U

｡

3v6uOBa#
ToT ">Ke BacIIJIMi mJIIi, Mo>KeT 6blTb, A"pek
yMI皿K城？EcJIHⅡOCJIenHee

'nPe瓜ⅡOJIO)KeHHe

npnycTHMo,
U

JIerKo noHflTb oco6eHHyIo HanPFI>KeHHocTb oTHo皿eHI畑 B

3TOMPaiiOHe・HoecJIIIHMeJ1HcbJIH皿bnpeTeH3HIIAH4|pefl
4

Ha3y6UoB,BcepaBHonoJIo)KGHIieBacIIJIHH6blJIO3neCb
nPCTaTOIIHO CJIO>KHblM.

B 1490/91 r. HeKIIi KHFI3b lIBaH IOpbeBII[I pa'ccMaTPﾚIBaJI,
B KaqecTBe
KallecTBe Cy旦bH
CynbH BblcmeHmHCTaHmIH，MHPoBylo
BbIcmem mHCTa"mmL MljPOgyIo c且eJIKy
c4eJIKY
U

BoTIIHHHI'IKoB CTapl皿K,oro ye34a 141. C. B. BeceJIoBcK"

oTo>"ecTBJIHeT 3ToTo MBaHa lOpbeBIILIa c 60HpHHoM
HB. IOp. naTI)HKeeBblM 142. 3a TaKoe oTo>MeCTBJIeHHe r9-

BOl)IITiIO皿mCbBe皿KOKHmKeCKOrOnbfIKaMaiKaHCyne6-

Hah, a He BJIaneTeJIbHaH poJIb mBaHa lOpbeBIIqa OmHaKo,
eCJIII cJIenOBaTb Ha皿eMy nPe且nOJIo)KeHIIIo O nPoeKTe Hane-

JIeHIIH BepeiicKoro KHfl3FT CTapIIIJKMM ynfeJIoM, B KHH3e
U

HBaHe lOPbeBHIIe Mo>KHOBImeTb6p.aTa IMepmeroBepeiicKoro KHfi3H MIIxaIIJIa AHnpeeBII[Ia !43・CynJI Ho BceMy,

OH He 6bm cneJIaH yneJIbHblM CTapI皿KIIM KHFI3eM, HO MOr
140瓜間瓜r, NIJ 85; cp. Nb 89, cTI). 357.
141 AC31'I, T・I, Nb 549.

'42 TaM >Ke, cTp. 629, npmM K Nb 549.
143 B 'nlvxoBHoii MMxaIIJIa HBaH IOpbeBIIII BblcTynaeT KaK o皿IHH3ero
llaCieAHIIKoB (H11nr, cTp. 307, 309) .
47

、

ⅡWWTbOTBe"IIKOro ̲､KHII3HKaKI1e-TOynPaBJIeHqecKIIe

巾yHKUMM
OTHOⅡlelllIH
B
CTap皿bl.
Ha
.npe4JIojkeHHoH皿eHTH"KaU"《HBaHa
lOpbeBHLla)'
HeJIb3H
HacTalIBaTb,"IIou

CKOJIbKy
l9PMaJEJble
n(aHIIble
nO3BOJIHIoT
OTO)KnlecTBIIT6
5fO
c|Kopee c II.' 10．naTPII'KeeBbIM

3TaaKTHBHOcTb̅JI皿,BenaB皿HxB1490/91r.3y6no­
B'oM
H
CTapmUeii,
'no-BH瓜HMoMy,
onpeneJIHJIacb
HacTVnau

割

TeJIbHO曲Ⅱo〃HTmKoi"AH4pem
yrJIIInKoro
nocJIe
cM6pTH
Li"11aH"IIoBm[la MoJlo46roApecT AMI)en5meIMW
TyaUmlO.
OnHcaHHe
TBel)cKo曲3eMJIH
ycIfJIMJIO
BeJIHKoKHH｡

U

>KeCKHH
KOHT20JII'
Ham
BCeii
TePPHTOPlieHⅡPHcoe且Ⅲ'HeHHOrO
U

KHmKecTBa. Co3mam'Icb pea.ﾉ1bI-lble lIoJIIITH[lecKMe VcJIoBIIH

ﾉIJIHnpeBpa山eHIIHBacIIJUjHII3KHH3HTBepcKoro [f y八eJIb-

Horo KamlIHcKoro KHH3FI. TBel)b, HaKoIIeU, Eo皿JIa B BeJIHKO­
KHH>KecKIIH 40MeH,HnocblJIKa Tyna BacIiJIIIH c BoeBonaMH
U

Bl492/93nllenpllBeJIaKBojjO)K4eHIm̅ErO66皿eTBep-

"" KHfI>KecKmx noJIHoMqg" no3ToMy HaM Ka>KeTcH, qfo

WMJeHyp rpaMpTy Ha noKpoBcKyIo BoJIocTb 3y6uoBcKoU

凸

MW" Bacli"" BbimaJI, "OPee BterO, 4O cMePlII AM"

yrJIﾙIuK'OrOnp
Ii OHIICal冊IfITBepcKoii3eMJIII,mdnpliMei)Ho
U

ム

I9r" )K2, jfOrna OH BblUajI KOI)MJIeHylO rPaMOTy !ia n6JIOBHHy r. 3y6UoBa.
雪

4aWPoB""ocJIaBcKIixrPaMoTnPaBw1bIIoHaMe'leHa

Li. A roJIy6UoBbIM, KoTopblil bTHec m;< K 1495-=1497̅iE
U

四

Pyg, OTPaWeHHbi#､E nPa" rPaMOTe, H̅1cH nOmci6:
">KeHHIo HBaHa lll, Ho 6blJI ̅ 40JIo>KeH KHH3Io Bablinlim

HBaHoBHqy, . .WyPliPylOUeMy 31eCb B POJII! <<[Ie"M
WpMmerIoJ:144no[lbeMynpiIKa3yBO3HIIKnPoUecc,3a[b"
U

pHpOBaHHblM B cymHOM CnMCKe, Mbl ToLIHO He 3HaeM｢TaK
KaK IHa[IaJIO nPKyMeHTa He COXI)aHHJIOCb, OjIHaKO H B 3TOM
cJIyIIae JloKJIaX cJI'ymaJI BacIIJII1i KaK "eJIoBeK cTa-

pIImmib!45｡
CJIyma|Hlie
QCoIIxneJI
oTHocMTcH,
6e3yEJIoBiIo,
ｰ
K nepHo4y QrcyTcTB" HBaHa lll B MocKBe (B̅cBH3M C

oTbe340M B HoBropqll) , Korna ero B KaKoih-To M6pe, no-BII皿WMy, 32WIema" B"IlJIIIi "BaHoBIiq (c 20 . OKT'I|6pH
○

l495 rJIo 24 MapTa l496 r.) 146

OT904Hafl-pa3'be3)Kafl-60JIee
no34Hmii
JIoKyMeHT,
[JeM
u

t ■

Cy4Hblli CnHCOK Ha Te >Ke 3eMJIH・K Pa3'be3Ay THyH nplIcTymiJI
４
４
１
１
５
４
１
４
６

<<no

rocy"peBe

rpaMoTe

BeJIIIKoro

KHH3H

I'IBaHa

AC3II, T. 111, JVb 208, cTp 219.
IaM >Ke, Nb 209, cTp222.

nCPJIJ Lyl, crll. 40; T. V111, cTP. 230-231; T XII, cTP. 241-242
HnP; AC3H, T. 111, cTp. 499-500, hpIIM K JYb 215

イ
ム
０
０
向
一

BacHJIbeBMIIa BceH PycII H IIo I､ocy八a" cBoero KHfl3H Ba｡
cHJIbfI HBallOBHIIa |c,ﾉIoBy>P 147. CJIe八oBaTeJIb}IO, B aTO BPeMH
l/iBaH III V)Ke HaxoJMJIcH B MocKBe, T. e・OTBO八HylO-P a3be3>KylO rPaMOTy HylKHO JaTHPOBaTb BPeMeHeM HOCJIe
24 MapTa l496 r.

Bo Bcex sTIIx八OKyMeHTaX巾HryPHPyeT HPOCJIaBcK"

TliyH AqJ. 4ypoB. B npaBoii rpaMoTe li cy"oM ｡cnHcKe
nyPOB Ha3BaH TIiyHOM BeJIHKOrO KHH3H, B OTBOIHQH-Pa3b-

e3ﾝKen oH nPII3HaeT cBOIIM <<TOCynaPeM)P KH別3fl BacllJIIIH
MBaHoBHIIa. BcnoMHHM, [ITo B rpaMoTe anpeJIH l496 r. Ba-

;cMJIHiiO6pa皿aeTCHKHeMyKaKKくTHyHyHameMy>148.3'HaIIIIT7《r'ocy八apeBbl》nOJIHOMOIIMHBoTHomeHHHHPocJIaBJIH
Bac"" TIoJiyqmJI He paHbme Bo3BI)auleHMH HBaHa lll H3

HoBrol)o,ma. OLIeBWIHo, Ha八eJlellHe BacliJIIifl (Ha KaKoe-To
KopoTKoe BpeM,I) IIpaBaMII cJIy)Ke6Ho-yneJIbHoro HpocJIaB-

CKOrO KHFI3H八OJDKHO 6blJIO KOMneIICHPOBaTb eMy nOTePlO
HeO申皿HaJIbHOih POJIH COn'PaBIITeJIH BeJIIIKorO KHH3H Ha

UeHfPaJIblloM HocTy, Ky" oH nonaJI B KoHIle l495- HaIIaJIe l496 r. OTBo八Hafl-Pa3'be3)KaH rPaMOTa nOKa3blBaeT, IITo

Bac皿噸He npHo6peJI B HpocJIaBJIe caMocToHTeJIbHor9
3HaIIeHIIH, ,meikCTByfl B PaMKaX oTnOBcKHX PacnOPH>KeHHII

(Ha nePBOM MeCTe B皿HM qJOPMyJIy; <<nO…rPaMOTe Be皿一
、

KOrO KHH3H…》ﾉ．

Ha 3aBep皿aIo山eM aTane H3AaHHH AC3H H. A・rony6=
nPB nPIImeJI K BblBOny, 'IITo HeO6XO,瓜HMO yllllTblBaTb Cy皿ecTBoBaHHe KIHH3H BacIIJIIIH mBaHoBHIIa, cblHa HBaHa lll,

《ⅡPIIyCTaHOBJIeHHHJIIiqllocTHKHH3eiic!HMeHeMBacHJIIIH
IigaHOBHIIa (rOJIeHIIHa, naTPHKeeBa li nP.) , nleiiCTBOBaBmHx B 3TII ronbl (1495-1498) B KaIIecTBe 60Hp BBe八eHblx
H, Me>KXy n&POKIHM, nPHHHMa|B皿Ⅱx IOKJIanIJI nO cy4HblM ne-

JIaM o 3eMJIe), 149. K co)KaJIeHHIo, npli ny6JIHKaUHH nepBoro

ToMa A3IIXHⅡByx nepBblx ToMoB AC31'I poJIb KHFI3H
B aclIJII畑HBaHoBHIIa (6yny皿ero BaclIJIHH 111) B Ho皿THIIeCKoji邪H3HH 90-x rOnPB XV B・BOBce 'He 6blJIa nPHHHTa

B PaCLIeTHⅡO3TOMy B 60JIbmHHcTBe cJIyIIaeB <<KHFI3b BaJIeii l'IBaHoBI,III> yBePeHHO OTOXmecTBJIHJIcJI JIH60 c
B.Ⅲ、roJIeHHHblM, JIH60 c B．H. naTpIIKeeBblM. B ocHoBe

皿eHTHq)IIKaUlM BacIIJIIIH HBaHoBHIIa c B. H. naTpHKeeBblM JIe>KaJI Te3Hc JI. B. IIepenHHHa o ToM, IITo B l495１４７ AC3H, T. 111, Nb 210.
１４８ TaM x(e, JMb 215.
１４９

TaM >Ke, cTp、500.

4

C 、 M ， I 〈 a m Ta H o B

49

l 499 rr・ル1．10. H B. II. naTpHKeeBbl Bo3r､JIaBJ1fIJIM B
MOcKBe f<|Cy4e611ylO KoJIJIerHIO> 150.
Bo BTopoM ToMe AC31'i HeK唖《KHII3b BacMJIeA I/iBaHo-

BIILIb> ynoMHHaeTcH B Nh 285, 289, 290, KoTopble naTHPoBaHb% <(oK[oJIo] 1492 r.》B o"oM MecTe B Nb 290 "ryplIpyeT
<KHH3b BeJII1KM BacHJIe曲mBaHOBHIIb> 151, nPHIIeM n|OCJIeniU

Hee

IITeHIie

Bbl3BaJIO

y

H3naTeJIH

HeJIoyMel-IHblII

BOnPOC II

nono31)eHHe B HaJIIIIIPIH 3neCb onHCKII 152. B IIMGHHoM yKa3aTeJIe

<<BacIIJIei mBal-IOBH'Ib>

3THx八oKVMellToB

oTHeceH

oIHoBpeMellHo II K B. II. ToJIeHIIHy, II K BacHJIHIo I/IBaHoBIIIIy, cblHy mBal-Ia lll l53. HII B oJHoM I13 aHa@ﾉI H3HDVeMblx
TeKCTOB ｡aMHJ叩くroJIeHHH>> He BCTPe[IaeM, xOTH yKa3aHHe baMHJIMII - 06blIIHoe HBJIeHIIeノIJIH八oKyMeHTOB, r4e

瓜eiICTBHTeJIbHO PeIIbH1eT o B. li. ToJIeHHHe l54.
npocJIe>KIIBaH cJIyKIali ynoMIIHa'HHH BacIIJIMH MBaHoBHIIa B paccMaTpHBaeMbIx IIcToqHHKax, Mo)KHo y6e"ITbcH,
IITo oII npHHHMaJI yqacTHe B pa360pe 6eJIo3epcKIIx 3eMeJIIJHblx ,UeJI nBa>K4bl: BO-nePBblx, 3a HeCKOJIbKO JIeT JP TOrO

BPeMellII, Korna 6blJIII cOCTaBJIeHbl LOKyMeHTbl,-̲BH"IMo,

nPm npmeMe HacJIeUcTBa MIIxaIIJIa AHnpeeBHIla BeJIo3epCKoro 155, BO-BTOpblx B nePIIo4 0｡OPMJIeHm Ⅱ0m enmIIx
moKVMe,HToB 156.

Ha nepBoM II3 3TIIx sTanoB npII BacIIJIHHI'IBaHoBHIIe
H aXO皿JIcH AbFIK Bac皿砿 ⅡOJIMaTOB, KOTOPblii CO6IiPaJI

OTH OCH皿yIocH K Tfl>K6aM ZoKyMeHTaUIIIo 157. KaK IoKa:blBaJIocb Bblme, BacIIJI噸noJIMaToB 6blJI npHcTaBJIeH K Ba-

cIIJIHIOHBaHoBHqyBCKOPenocJIenPll|coe八Hl.Iel-IHHTBepH,
T. e. B KoHne l485 -HaIIaJIe l486 r., Korna BaclIJI砿noJIy-

1IIIJI BeJIHKoKHH>KecKIIik TRTyJI II KocTpoMy. npaKTHIIecKafI

peaJIII3aU" XyxoBHoM MIIxaIIJIa AHIpe"IIIIa, HaIIaTaH,
nO-BHXHMOMy,CI)a3ynOnPHCCe八HHeHHHTBepcKoroKHH>KecTBa, noTPe60BaJIa oT HBalHa lll 60JIbmoro yMeHIIH MaHeBpmpoBaTb. OT4aB omHoMy cBoeMy cblHy,《BeJIIIKoMy
KHH3Io>, TBepb, oH nocJIaJI npyroro #cBoero cblHa, To>Ke
150 JIBqePenHIIH.yKa3:"q.,I1．2, CTP、238, 308.
l51 ACSI'1, T、11, M 290, cTp. 225, ". 14.
152 TaM >Ke lI cTp. 591.

153 TaM >Ke, cTp. 591, 593.

154 '"3iX: I&1,Wi ", 39; AC3m, T- l,̲"624, 628, ,643,"9; TJ.
M 336-338,̅418, 419, 421; T III} " 25L 26, 46, 4" (rP: p 49Il.),"
155 AC91'i, T. 11, Nb 285, cTp、191; Nb 290, cTp. 212, 215, 216, 221,

222，225Ke,'
cTp204,
289,
290,̲cTp.̲244.226．
Nb
Nh
206;

l56TaMンKe,Nb289，cTp、204,206；Nb290，CTP、244．

157 TaM >Ke, M 285, 286, 290, cTp、2111, 215, 216m且p.
50

《BeJTHKoroKHH3",JIJYHo(i)oI)MJIeHIIHnl)MeMa6eJIo3epCKOrO
HacJIe八CTBa, Bbl3blBaBmel､o peBHIIBble IIyBcTBa y AHnpeFI

yrJI皿Koro. npll ccblJIKe Ha pe山eHlif! cel)"liHbl 80-x rOioB,
me旦皿He oT HMeHH BacIM", aBTopbl loKyMeHToB HaIIaJIa
90-x ronoB cTapaTeJIbHo 3aMeHHJIIi ero B6JIHKoK1ImKecKHii
TIITy,JI

KIIFI)KecKHM,

OJHaKo

B

OmHOM ,MeCTe

CTaPblM THTVJI
ユ

”

ジ

cJIyJIaIIHo BbInJIbIJI, nPeAOCTaBHB TeM caMblM JParOUeHHeii-

Ⅱ1HH MaTepmaJI八J1月皿eHT叫)HKaUⅡⅡJ1I'IIIHocTM KI-IFI3JI Bacli-

JIlmMBaHoBHIIa B oTJIMqlie oT HBaHa MBaHoBII[Ia, BacmJ1砿mBaHoBMIIHenOJIyIIHn《rOCynaPeBblX》nPaB
HaB|HOBb
n｣pHcoe41IHeHHylo TeppHTopHIo. CynH no ToMy, '[ITo HBaH III
OTMeHHJI MIIOrHe )13 erO peme|H" 158, OH 3八eCb He 6blJI na>Ke
Cymbeii BblCmeii IIHCTaHUlM.

BTol)IIIIHoe npe6blBallMe BacHJIIIH liBaHoBHLIa |Ha Be-

JIoo3ePe oTHogiTcH, nO Bceii BePOHTHoCTI1, K nePliOAy nOcJIe
JIIIKB"aUlM yrJIIJUKorO KHH>KecTBa, T. e・K KoHLIv 1491-

l492rr.CaMoynopflnoIIeHIIe3eMeJIbHblx八emBBeJIO3ePcKOM KPae HaxO""CH B HecOMHeHHoii CBfl3II c nPHcoe"HeHHeM COCe4Hero yl､J1 I'IuKOI､O VIeJTa.

PaHee Mbl nOKa3aJIII, IITO nPHCOe八HHe l冊Ie yr･JII皿Ko-Mo-

)KaicKoroK">KecTBam3MeHIiJTopoJIbBaclIJIIIRBTBep･
CKoii 3eMJIe. Tenepb Mo>KHo yToIIHIITb 3ToT Bonpoc. OT 7000

(ceHTH6pH l491 - aBrycTa l492 E) He coxpaHiiJIocb KaKIIx-

皿6PcB皿eTeJIbcTBonpaBaxBacIIJIHHBoTHomeHIMTBepCKoH 3eMJIH, 3aTO HMeIoTcH IaHHDIe, xa'paKTepH3ylo皿He erO

npHLIacTHocTb K pa360py 3eMeJIbHblx TmK6 B̅ KOtTpoMcKoM

ILPMe(ynoMJJHyTaHyKa3HaflrpaMoTaCBMHbHHy 159)II Ha
BeJIoo3epe(paccMaTpHBaeMbleHcTo[IHHKII) .HAnpamHBaeTcH

BblBo4,

IITo

HocJIe

npHcoe"IHeHHH

yrJIHqa

BacIIJIHii

6bIJI JIIImeH TBepcKoro KHfDKeHIIH !60 H noJIyIIIIJI B BeneHHe
戸８
⑰Ｑ
一︾
︒
︵︵
ＬＵ

TaM >Ke, JYb 290, cTp. 222, 225, 226.
TaM zKe, T. 111, Nb 244.

Bo3Mo>KI!9no3TQMy,IITo̲ MoHeTblTBepcKoronl)oIIcxo>KneH:"c HaA･

nHcbIo《KHfl3b
BacHJIe
HBaHoBHII”（A・OpeⅡIHHKoB・PyccKHe
MoHeTbLmo l547 r., cTp. 55, Nb 331-Z@32, cTp. 80, Nh 447; cp. ofl >K e.

"BenpeBHePYgEKIIeXeHbrII,̲cTpL.384)PTiIocIITcIIKndpiI6八vMe氷一
Jly oceHbio l490 r. !! ""oii l491 r̲ A B. OpemHmlfoB hampoa抑mx BpeMeHeM np l502 r., Kor", corJIacHo JIeTomIcII) Bac皿ﾙllo

OblJI nO#<aJIOBaH THTyJI BeJIHKOrO KHH3H Bcefl PyCﾚ1 (A. OpemHH-

K o B. nBe npeBHepypcKlie XeHbrII, cTI). 384) . H6 no6JIe l 497 r・Mo

HeTbl c Ha旦皿cblo "KHH3b Bac"e HBaHoBHill," HE Mor狐イⅡoHBHTIﾝcH1

TaK KaK B l498 r. BacHJIHii 6blJI B onaJIe lI MoHcTbl IIeリeKaHmJI，B
ll499 r. oH cTaJI BeJIHKIIM KIIH3eM, B 1500 r. 6e>KaJY B BH3L,My, B T'oM
JKe

ro4y

BHoBb

nOJIyllH､m

BeJIHKoKHH>KecKIIii

TIITVJI

H

60JIbme

ero

y)Ke He TepHJI TaKIIM o6pa30M, mHpoKMMII paMKaillI nlJIH "TIIpoBKH
5

1

4

＊

Te TeppHTop", KoTopble oll HMeJI B 1485/86 r.: KocTpoMy
(erO nPaBa 3八eCb, BI皿MMo, npll6JIH>KaJIIMcb K <<rocyﾉ1ape↑

BblM>, o ueM |rOBoPHT

U

(1)aKT

1BblnaIIH

MM

yKa3HoH

rl)aMo-

Tbl 161) H BeJIOO3epO (r,Ue nOJIHOMOIIIIH MOJIOnPTO KHH3fI

HOCHJIH, CKOPee BCero, LIIICTO Cy八eitcK" xapaKTep) . OIIeBⅢ瓜HO, !HO瓜且aBJIeHHeM CHJI, rPynlnlIPOBaB皿HxCH BOKPyr Be-

JIIIKoii KHHrHHH Co(PbH, a Bo3Mo)KHo, H "H HeiITpaJIM3a皿H
BoJIoUKoro KIIH3H BopHca BacHJIbeBI,IIla l62 1IBaH III BecHoii
1493 r. oTnpaBwI BacIIJIMFI B TBepb, Ho ｡aKTIIIIecKH JIHml, B
POJIII KHH3H KamHHcKoro. TaKIIM o6pa30M, 3aXep>KaTbcH Ha

BeJIoo3epe Bacmmiit Mor MaKcHMyM 'Io HaIIaJIa l493 r. !63
B nePBoM ToMe ACali nloKyMeHTb! Nb 582-595 (JBe
nPaBble rPaMOTbl, XBa CyJHblx CIIHCKa m l l nOK､ﾉIaJHblx CymHblX C皿CKOB )八aTHPoBaIIbl l495-1499 rr., nocKoJIbKy B
60JI bmH'HCTBe

l,I3

HHx

IIMelOTCH

IcIBe八eHIIJI

o 八OKJI a八e八eJI

KHH3Io BacIIJIHIo I/IBaHoBHqy, KoToporo H3八aTeJIII OTOIKnecTBJIflIoT c B. I'I. naTpHKeeBblM, IIMeBmIIM 60FIpcKoe 3BaHHe

ByKa3aHHbl向nPoMeIKyToKBpeMeHII164.
B JpKyMellTax JYb 583-594 B KaIIecTBe cylbll bliryPII･

PyeT O八Ho H To )Ke JIImo - AHnpeih nepeJIemHH, a o6'beK-

TaMH TH)K6bl HBJIHIoTcH cnopHble 3eMJIH 3aJIeccKoii H Bepe30BcKoA BoJIocTeii KocTpoMcKoro ye3,Ⅱ{a. CJIe40BaTeJIbHo,
BCe aTH且OKyMel-ITbl OTHOCHTCH K OnHOMy CPaBHHTeJIbHO y3-

KoMy xpoHoJIorHIIecKoMy oTpe3Ky. Bce neJIa 6bmHHaIIaTbI

nOw<rPaMOTe>HJIHくCJIOBy>>BeJIHKorOKHH3H(HBaHalll),
BO BCex CJIy[IaHx CynLH <<PeKcH nPJIO)KHTH rOCynaPH cBOero
④

BeJIMKOrO KHH3兜》, BblcJIymHBaJI )Ke nleJIO Ka班且blH Pa3 KHH3b

BacH"城HBal-IOBHII, KOTOPblhHBblHOCIIJI nPHrOBOP (IICKJIIoIleHHe - JVb 593, rme cBeneHHii o ppKJIa4e HeT) . B nPKyMeHTax JVb 585, 587, 588, 590, 591, 592, 594 Haxo瓜ⅡMⅡo4nIIcb
XbHKa OJIemKH Be306pa30Ba. B IIeTblpex IoKyMeHTax

(Nb 585, 587, 590, 59 1 ) cKa3a,Ho, IITo KHfl3b BacHJI戒mBaHoSTHx MoHeT Ha八o npH3HaTb oceHb l490 - oceHh l497 rr.,̲ 60JIee y3KHMH H HaH60JIee BepoHTHblMH - ocGHb l490 - Qce旧I｣ 1491 rr.
16! AHaJIorliqHylo yKa3Hyio rpaMoT)' BbUaJI HBaH III B 149al94 r､，Kor-

na BacIIJIIrit, kax<eTM, y)Ke HE BenaJI KOcTpoMoii (ACSH, T. 111.
IM 245).

162 0 HoJIiITHIIecKllx nJIaHax 3Toro KHFI3R BeCHoii l493 m cB"eTe､mbcT-

ByeTnpBoJIbHoHeo6blqHaH八ⅡH
npaKTHKH
BoJIoUKHxKHH3eiinonbITK3 yCTaHOBIITb TeCHbIiiKOHTaKT CEJIIIHTeJIbHeUl!IMnyj<onlitlMJbeO･
naJI6M - TpomUe-CeprlleBbIM MoHacTbIpeM (ACeli, T. I, M 572) .

163 nocJIe八Hme̅ no BpeMEHII maHHble o pa60Te Ha BeJIoo3el)e jTHcL(lai̲l<g"

TopblMnaBaJlyKh3aHIIHBaclIJ1,llii,dTHocflTcfIKBecHel493r.(ACSI4,

T. II, cTp. 246, npHM K Nb 290) .
164 ACSH, T. I, cTp. 494, npHM. K JVb 595.
52

BIIII <<BeJIeJI nlbHKy cBoeM'y OJIemKe Be306pa3QBY2̲cnleJIgTb

BbImICKHH3KOCTPOMCKHXⅡHcUoBblxKHIIrl464/65r.3To

▲
onpenteJIeHIIeAJI.̅Be306p330Ba
KaK"HKaKHFI3fI
BacIIJIHfI
HEaHoBHIIa cJIy)KHT HaII60JIee npoIJHblM ocHQ"HII･M IIJIH

oTo>KnecTBJTeHIIFI nocJIenHero c cblHoM HBaHa lll,1160 60H-

plIH
naTpHKeeB
He
mqr
HMeTb
<<cBoero渉及bflKa.
HCTOIIHIIKII

ilaqaJIa 90-x ronpB XV B. noITBep>KXaIoT, qTo AJI. Be306pa30B neiicTBIITeJIbHo coIcToHJI nbHKoM npH KHH3e BacHJIIM
U

HBaHoBH[Ie・HaKoHeU，paHoH，K
IIBaHoBIIIIe.
HaKoHell, paMoH, K KoTopoMy
KoTopoMy oTHocFITcFI
oTHocHTcfI cyユー
cyFIHble cnlIcKII,- KocTpoMcKoii ye3 - HaXOnHJIcH B KOMneHblec皿cKH,­KocTpoMcKoHye3,nI
TeHuHⅡBacwIIIFI I/IBaHoBMIIJa HMellHo B ToT nel)IIonl, KorIIa

y Hero 6blJI IbFIK AJI. Be306pa30B.
nOCKoJIbKy Bce HcCJIeXyeMble nOKyMeHTbI HaulIIHalOTcH
CO ccblJIKII Ha <rPaMOTy> IIJIII <<CJIOBO>
HBaHa
BacHJIbeBIIIIa,
nepBaH
cTanwI

BeJIHKorO
nPoneccoB

KHFI3FI
MorJIa

IIMeTb MecTo eme JIo nepexona KocTpoMbl B BeneHHe KHFI3FI

BacHJIIIH IiBaHoBIIIIa, T. e. np oceHH 1491 r．yxIaCTHe >Ke
KHR3FI B pemeHHII 3THx nieJI cJIemyeT, oIIeBHnHO, OTHeCTII KO
U

BPeMeHM BblnaIIII OT erO HMeHm yKa"OII rPaM9TbI, ､WaB-

llieiicII 3eMeJIb KocTpoMcKoro ye34a 165 (ceHTLH6pb l491 aBrycT 1492 rn) -̲
noKyMeHTbI Nb 582 H 595 - 3To npaBUe叩aMOTbl, nOCBHIJleHHble. cnopIiblM neJIaM: nepBafl - B nepecJIaBJIb=3aJIec-

cKoM ye3Xe, BTopafI - B BoJIocTII Bope-KQpaglleBe MocKoBCKoro̅ye3Xa.OCTaHoBIIMcHcHaqaJIaHaNb595,nocKoJIbKy
3meCbynOMHHaeTCHnbHKくOJIeme"(oH>KeくAJIeKca皿p>>)
Be306Pa30B BrpaMoTe
rpaMoTeroBopHTcH，〔ITo
roBopmTcH, qTo
KHH3b
BafIIJI"
Be306pa30B･B
KHH3b
BacHJIHH
U

四

u

PIBaHOBIIII, CJIymaBmHH旦eJIO, BeJIeJI IIOnnIICaTb Cynl･lblH CⅡH­
coKくB e JI H K 6 r o K H H 3 H "HKy AJIeKcaHnpy Be306pa30-

By)'. nPHBeneHHafI (bOPMyJIHPOBKa g皿e He naeT HaM npaBa
BimeTB B BacHJIHH HBaHoBHIIe B．Ⅲ. naTpHKeeBa. CKopee
BCerO, rPaMOTa OTHOCIITcH K HOCJIeTBePcKOMy nePHOPy nefITeJIbHocTH

KHH3H

BacIIJIHFI

IIBalloBIIIIa,

Koma

oH

ne-Iope

y>Ke 6blJI JIHmeH 4<cBoero>> IIbflKa, Ho JIe-巾aKTO TOT HPOmOJI>KaJI HCHoJIHHTb nPH HeM CBOH o6fl3aHHOCTH nO noPyIIeHIIIO
BeJIHKoTo KHFI3fI. CpenK naTHpoBaHHbIx TeKcToB 3ToT IoKy-

MeHT Ha BopbcKo-Kop3eHeBcKHe 3eMJIH MocKoBcKoro ye3na
(He ｡IIryPmPylOIIIHe a XPyrHX HCTOq"KaX, CBH3aHHbIx C
HMeHeM KHH3H BacIIJIIIfl) JIyIIme Bcero rloMemaeTcH B <npou

Me>KyToIIHbl" nepIIoI (KoHeII 1493-nePBaFI nOJ1OBIIHa

＝
E一一一
----I65 TaM )Ke, T. 111, Nb 244
、

53

!49Ml̲9I
K970Poro
He
momJIo
HIIKaKIIx
cBemeHIIii
O
KaPbepeBacIIJIHH HBaHoBIIqa.
U

K3ToMy>KeBpeMeHH,KaKHaMKa>KeTcfl,HV)KIIooTHe-

cTHH IoKyMeHTNb635­瓜OKJTa4HOHCynHblH CIIHCOKHa
no)KHIooKoJIonBopaTpoHⅡe-CeprHeBaMoHacTblpFIBPocToBe. Cyn 6blJI HaIIaT《Ⅱo rpaMoTe KIIH>Ke BacHJIbeBe HBaU

U

HoBHII", neJIO gOKJIanblBaJIocb KIIFI3Io, H cITHCOK HO瓜ⅡmCaJI

UbfIKQ"emKaBe306pa30B
B
m34aHmi!qoKyMERT̅6&̅M:
l<IIxo60gHoBaHmiinpHnlicaHBKroJIeHmHinnoBPeMem!
ero
nPe6blBaHHH
B
40JI>KHOCTHⅡBOPeUKOrO
naTIIPOBaH
1 500/01r.CHa皿eHTOxlKII3PeHIIH,HaJIHIIHenOnnHCII
AJL
Beap6pa30Ba
HaJoKyMeHTe,"cocTABJIeHHoMMMuHH
KHH3FIBacIIJIIIHHBaHoBIIqa,­ⅡoWTI16e30mH|60[IHbliinpHʻ
U

⑥

⑪

3HaK TOrO, IITO B HOcJIen<HeM HanO BMeTb CbIHa HBaHa lll.

KaKoe nqjIHTHrIecKoe 3HatleHHe MOr IIMeTb ̅aKT haie"

E" KHH3HBacmJI"HBaHoBIIqaonpeXeJIeHHblMmyiIPaBJIeHqeCKHMHⅡoJIHOMOwIIFIMH B OTHOmeHIIII POcTOBa H BOJIo-

cTII
Boplf-Kop3eHeBa
B
1493-1494
rl､.？npe瓜cTaBJIHeTcH，
qrp mWWo B 9ToT rppmon, Qgo6eHHo nocJIe !cMepTH 6 Ho-

H6pH1493r・KHFI3HAII,npeflyrJIHⅡKoro,ycIIJIIIJIIIcbVneJIb-

Hble npIITH3aHHH KHH3H BopIIca BacIIJIbeBIIqa BoJIOilKoro,
89MOraBmerOCHTHTVJIa<KHH3HMOCKOBCKOrO)',CKoTOPbIM

6bLIIo cBfl3aHo BJTa4eHHe HecKoJIbKIIMH yneJiaMII K"eii

MocKoBcKoronoMa!"BoJIocTbBoI]H-KoP3eHeBonpmHanU

ʻⅢeiKaJIa K3IIcJIy <<3aMocKoB'bcKIIx> BoJIOcTeii, oTiaHHblx

BacmJ1HeMTeMHbIMcF""y"IIIylOpHIo167,BtlbeM,yneJIE
oHH HaxoIHJIHcb no l472 r.168 PocToB o巾皿HaJIbHoTaK>Ke

Bxo凡HJI B pocTaB . BblMopoIIHoro Ha:cJIemcTBa lOp" nMHT-

PoBcKorO (xoTH巾aKTHIIecKMI B 60-x - Ha'IaJIe 80-x roIoB
PIM genama BeJIII"H KHRrHHH MapPIfI HpocJIaBHa) .

B HoroBollax HBaHa lll 1486r. c BbpHcoM BoJIoIIKIIM

II A"peeM yrJImUKHM MMeJIacb cneUmaJIEHaH cTaT"，3a-

npe皿aBmaHBopHcyHAHnpeIoくnoⅡEHcKHBaTH>TePPHTOpII¥, Ha KoJppbIe npe)Igle npocTIIpamcH cyBepeHHTeT IOp"
II AHmpefI MeHbmorQ Cpe"[ 3TIiX 3eMeJIE HA3BaHb! PodTo'E

I1 <<BoJIocTI" 169. CTaTbH HoKa3blBaeT HanpaBJIeHHocTb
V瓜eJIbllblX nPHTH3aH". nPH HaPymeHI畑nOJI IITHIIeCKOrO
166

u

C. M. KamTaHoB. O BHyTpeHHeMnO"ITm<e HBaHa rPO3HOro B
IIepI'Io瓜《Be,1I"o[Q KIiJI>KeHIIFI)' CIIMeoHa BeK6yJ1aToRIi'la-《Tpymb1
MrllAII>, T. 16.M., 1961, cTp. 432-4341.

６７
nHnr, cTp. 194.
６８
AC3PI, T・I, Nb 401.
６９

ⅡIInr, cTp. 316,320, 323, 326.
54

paBHoBeCHHBeJIHKIIMKHH3eM
(aTaKIIMlIaPymeHHeM6blJIO

nPHCOe"HeHHe
yrJI皿Koroy瓜eJIaB1491E，o3HaII BnIee

p33pblB JIoroBopa l486 r. c A皿PeeM) IO H3BecTHoih cTeheHil @<3aKOHHO> TePFIJIH cIIJIy H o6H3aTeJIbcTBa yneJIbHblx
KHFI3ei no oTHome'HIIIo K BeJIHKoMy KHH310 '70. XapaKTep

noJIHTHKII BopHca BoJIoUKoro B 1493-1494 rr. noBoJIbHo
HceH - cTaBKa Ha TpoHⅡe-CeprHeB MoHacTblpb, no poJII1

paBHbIii (oco6eHHo npH HeycTo加HBoM noJIoIKeHIIH 30cHMbl) MIITPOHOJIHqbeii Ka巾eXPe, II cTPeMJIeHHe pacnPOcTPaHIIfbCBOEBJIIIHHmeHaBbCTOIIHOe3aMOCKOBbe'71.

npenocTaBJIeHIie BacIIJIIIIo B 1493-1494 rr. KaKIix-To

noJIHOMoIIIIii 'B o6JIacTII PocToBa H BopH-Kop3eHeBa, nO-B}I-

ⅡHMoMy, nPeCJIen<OBaJIO UeJIb HeiTPaJIH3aUI'III c IIOMOmblO
onHOrO <HaCJIeXHI1Ka》ⅡPlITH3aH嘘ⅡP|yrOro <<HaCJIenHIMKa>.
HalI60JIee BepoHTHoe BpeMH BblnaIIm paccMaTpIIBaeMblX̲rpa-

MOT­ⅡepIIoX Me)Kny cMepTbIo AHIpeH yrJ]皿KoTo (6 Ho汀6pfl l493 rj II Bo"ca BoJIoIIKQTo̲ (29 MaH 1494 r) .

BepHeMcfl K HoKyMeHTy Nb 582. Cyn; 6blJI Ha'IaT Ho rpa-

MOTe l/IBaHa

lll, CynlbFI <<PeK!CFI HOJIO>KIITII ocnonlapH BeJIII-

KoTo KI-IFI3FI>, Ho cJIymaJI II pemaJI neJIo KHH3b BacllJIHi
I'IBaHOBH可.

CVmecTBeHHoe

oTJIIIIIHe

3Toro

IoKyMeHTa oT

Nb 583-594 cocToHT B HHoii reorpa巾HIIeCKO仇Ⅱp HypoIIellH O C Tm

(BepxJIy6eHcKIIii cTaH nepecJIaBJIL-3aJIeccKoro

ye3ma) H B oTCVTCTBHHnO皿IMCH且bHKa AJI. Be306pa30Ba.

kak iib1 noMHIIM, yKa3HaH rpaMoTa KHfI3H BacmJIIIf[ HBaHoBHqaoPaCcJIemOBaHHH3eMeJIbHoiiTfl)K6blBKHHeJIbcKoM

cTaHe nepecJIaBJIb-33JIeccKoro ye3" "TmpoBaHa 7005
( 1 496/97) roloM 172. Mo>KHo HoJIaraTb, [ITo nePecJIaBcKIIe
170 B mvMIIJIoBcKoM cⅡHcKe H}IKoHo:BcKoi J1GTonIIcI,I B WIHJIJIII'IecKoM

cBeTe･npencTaBJIeHbIoTHomeHIImMe>KLXIJBaHoMIILIIBopHcoMBoJIouKIIM B MoMeHT HoIIMaHwI AHmpefl yrJIYmKoro: <<BpaTa )Ke cBoero
KHH3fI BoD|I"IcfI BacmmeBIM[Ig Bo'YoTUcKaro 11 zIeTcii ero HeyxI]1u1peH”

IHarO HX ph皿HPaBa He BPe"I HII可HM >Ke" (nCPJI, T. X'11, cTp231232).rdpa3no5JTII>KeK̅nleicTBHTeJIbHocTI[JIaKoHHIIEogcoo6UeHMe

OJHOTo JIeTOnl,IcUa, nOKa3IJIBalo皿ee HanPH>KGHHoCTI､ o5cTal{oBKⅡしI

CTPeMJIeHmeBeJJIIKoroKHg3HlleliTPaJIII30BaTb̲BoPlica:"NT9rO̲>KeZIHI!
nobnan no 6i)aTa cBoero Ha BonoK no K"3H Bopmc" (fI C JI y p b e;

KpaTKIMii JIeToHHcenⅡorOmIHcKoTO cO6Pamm.­《Apxeorpa"IIecKI(ji
ekeroFIHIIK 3a l962 ro". M., 1963, cTP. 442) '
l7I BopMc Bblna.II TI)oI皿e-CeprHeBy MoHacTblplo TpH TIlgMoTI,I Ha, "2"-

liimbnkmli6Kylo iI nyCTomb IIejHbUoBcKyIO Ha p KIIfI3bMe (AG9H,
T. I, M 572, 575, 576) . neP. nonKliHcKaa ilaXQ11!JIaCb Me"y c. IJePK1I36B1,1M(1ia KJifl3bMe)!1 6 3"rHII1>1M(ACSH, T. I, cTI). 631、「I I)IIM.

K Nb 572) - ceBepo-BocTotIIIee MocKBbl.
172 rnB, noToZl. 1905, n. 83-83 06.
55

且eJIaBacHJIHiiIIBaHoBH印cTaJIPacCMaTPIIBaTbHePaHbme
3ToTo BpeMeHH, nocKoJIbKy eme B anpeJIe l496 r. oll 6bm
HPOcJIaBcKHM

<rOCynaPeM>.

OTHeceHIIe noKyMeHTa Nb 582 K I496/97 r. BnoJIHe co-

rJIaCyeTCH'coTCyTCTBIIeMHaHeMHO瓜ⅡIIcIIAJI・Be306Pa30-

BaOlIHaKo,CKOPeeBCerO,nPOUeCC,OTPa>KeHHbliiB̅nPaBoi rpaMoTe, HaIIaJIcFI np noJIyIIeHHH BacHJTHeM cyne6Iiblx

DOJIHOMOIIHii B OTHOmeHIm nepecJIaBJIfl-3aJIeccKoro. HHHⅡHaTHBHI>IM nOKyMeHToM nOCJIy>KHJIa 3neCb rPaMOTa l'IBaHa ll1, a, cy皿no yKa3Hoih rpaMoTe BacIIJI" 1496/97 r"
〆

OH CaM Obm HaneJIeH nPaBoM nlaBaTb yKa3bl O nPOH3BOIICT-

Be Cyna (<<a O qeM CH COnPyT, H BbI 6 IIX H Cy"J1II, a cym
cBoii cKa>KIITe MHe, KHH310 BacHJIblo HBaHoBIIIIIo)>) . Mbl
3HaeM

nPaBylO

rPaMOTy Ha

nePeCJIaBCKIIe

3eMJTII,

B

KOTO-

poi o6も月BJIeHo, IITo cyn HaIIaJIcH <<no rpaMoTe KHH>K BacIIJIbeBe HBaHOBRIIH》; KHFI3b BacIIJIHi cJIymaJI ,moKJIan, II
cyJII1,Ii

cmIcoK

TJonmlcaJI

nbHK

Ko6flK;

onHaKo,

nocKoJIE-

Ky BacHJIII# He BblHec oKoHIIaTeJTbHoro npHroBopa, a npHcy皿JI cToPoIIaM《ⅡOJIe)> (Cyne6Hbli nOe皿HOK), nPOneCc 3aTFIHyJICH, H O erO naJIbHeimeM XOne 6bmO nOJIo>KeHO y>Ke
BeJIHKOMy KHH310 nMHTPMIIO HBaHOBH[Iy, 3aKOHqIIBI[IeMy
PaccMoTpeHHe neJJa B MapTe l498 r.
B nepBoM ToMe A31IX, me HanetlaTaH 9ToT IoKy-

MeHT (Nb l l 7) , non KHH3eM Bac"IIeM HBaHoBIIqeM HoXpa3yMeBaeTcFI B. I/I. roJTeHI,IH I73. HIIKaKHx naHHblx XJIH TaKorO OTO派瓜eCTBJIeHHFI I･IeT. nePenl HaMH TeKCT, PHCylO皿城
n O C J I e n O B a Te J I b H b l e 3 Ta n b l n P O U e C C a :

e r O H a I J a J I O M XO 瓜 旦 O

onaJIbl KHH3fl BacHJIHH HBaHoBH[Ia, 3aBepmeHIIe llocJIe onaJIbl BacHJIHH H KopoHanHPI nMHTp"-BHyKa. To, qTo HMeIIHO nMIITPlIi ,mOBeJT nP KoIIna neJIO, HaIIaTOe nO IIII皿IｲaTHBeHnoI KoHTpoJIGM BacIIJIHR，yKa3blBaeT IIa ni)eeMCTBGHHOCTb KaK TePPIiTOPHaJIbHblx, TaK H dJyHKUHOHaJIbHbIx nPaB
3THX COnePl-IHLIaBmHx nPeTeH,melITOB Ha npecToJI 174 1I TeM
caMI,IM nQIITBeP>KnaeT Bo3Mo)KHOcTb OTOxmeCTBJIeHIIfl j)HrypHpylo皿ero 3necb BacIIJIIIFI HBaHoBIIIIa c cblHoM HBaHa ll1. TaKPIM o6pa30M, '1･1a[IaJIbHaHⅡaTa 3TorO XoKyMeHTa - 1 4 9 7 r.
173 Ad)311X, [1. 1, MMGHHoM yKa3aTeJTb, cTp. 339.
I74 06 3TOii npeeMCTBeHHOCTI,I CBImeTeJILCTByeT列1pyraH TIpaEafI rpaMoTa l498 r., rne, BnpotleM, BacImllii l'IBaIIoBIIII He ynoMII11acTcFI:
06'I,eKT cy" HaxommcH B KocTpoMcKoM ye3JIe, IBa脈Ⅱmno61,manIIIGM

B

Be,IGHIIII

Bacmmfl;

neJ1o

XoKJIanLIBaJIocI>

BeJI.

IfⅡ.

nM11"I､111110

I/IBalIoBIIIIy; ero nl)MroRoI) no皿ⅢCa,11皿HK A.IT. Ec3061]a30B (A(p311X,
q. 1, Nb 259).
56

B nepBoM
ToMe AC3H npHBJIeKaeT BHIIMaHIMe 40Kyʻ
MeHTNb427:KynIIafl6e3naTbl,HaKoToPoHmMeeTCH60JIee
U

IIO34HFIfl 3aⅡHcb o cyne6HoM npHroBope, BblHeceHHoM Ha

6&Mi" 3Toik Kyitleii' KynqaH KacaeTcH 3eMeJIb̲BePxU

n""bro cTaHa nepecJIagnb-3alrecgforo ye3": 34"b

6ieJIaHa oT MMeHI[KHH3RBacmJI"IIBaHoBIWa m mo瓜ⅡH65"̅JIbHKoM <<BeJIHKoro KHH3" "IopoM KypmUblHbIM.
B npHMeqaHHH B3"TeJ1H cKa3aHo, gro B 3anHCHくp a3yMe-

eTcFIKH.Bac.HB.roJIeHHⅡ，ⅡHceUnepeHcJIaBJIfl-3aJIeccKoro l504 r., KoTopblii cyZIIIJI ynoJIoBHHKoBblI c TpoHIIWIM
⑪

bTaPi6M BApJIaai{oMno.yKa3aHIilo cTap" BapJI""̲k

Pakoda, no jioMeHTa T"<66I MoHacTBI"c yrIWIQW"WW

oT IIoKvHKII IIVcTomHMeJIbHIIIIm皿e npomJIo 30 JIeT; oTcIona
ご

nPHMePHafl八ATa
KynIIei:
oK
1474-1475
rr.》

HCXOIHafl nOCblJ1Ka nPIIBeneHHOrO PaCCy>K,meHHFI nPOII3-

BoJIbHa: nouleMy KHH3b BacIIJI砿HBaHOBHII - HMeHHO
B．Ⅲ、roJIeHHIH？OTKyⅡaH3BecTHo，IIToⅡHceⅡB、H.
roJIeHHH cymiJI B l504 r．ynoJIOBHIIKOBblx c TI)OIiUKHM CTaPUeM

BapJIaaMoM
BapaKoBblM？ʼ'I3BecTHoJIHmbTo，【ITonHceU
⑪

E !mroJIeHIIH 9aHIIMaJ1cH MeJKeBaHIieM B IIIePeHCKOi BoJIocTII B 1504 r.175, IIo IIIIKaKIJx naHHblx o ero cyXe no TaX-

65̅MGMf ynoJIoBHIIKoBbIMH H cTapUeM BapJIaaMoM Ba-

paKoBbIMbnpKyMeHTax1504r:̲HeT.HaJIIIqHeBnpllrgB2p=
HOH 3aⅡHcII KIIH3fl BacIIJIIIH I'IBaHoBH[Ia noⅡⅡHCH旦bHKa
U

①e且opa
enopa KyplinbIHa,
Ky”ⅡbIHa，KoTopblH
KoTopbIii He
HeBcTpeLIaeTcH BHcToIIHHB HcToW-

Kax io3)Ke l500 r. !76, 3acTaBJIHeT e皿e PemHTeJIbHee OTKJIO-

IiHTbnPentJIo)KeHHyloBAC3I1八aTmPOBKy3aⅡHCHHeeaTp H6yuHio. CKopee Bcero, nePeJL HaMI! 3anllcb, f4eJIa""

H5̅im6boPyk"3flBac""HBanoBHIIa,cbInamBaUam:
u

nPII naTIIPoBKe 3TOII 3anHCII HanO IIMeTb B BH且y, wITO

KHH31J BacIIJMii l/IBaHoBII11巾mryPllPyeT 3JIecb B poJIHnpo-

cTocV"H(oIIIIe《BeJIeJICyntbe>>くOnpaBHTII)"H<<o6BHHII“

TH>,aCaM《onpaBIIJI)'II<<o6BHHIIJI>>).CoxpaHIMacbnpaBafl

rpaMoTacynakHH3HBacIIJIIIHHBaloBIIqa,3aJTq且nHcblo
旦団Ka
Ka
AJI・Be306pa30Ba，Ha3eMJIH
Am̅ Be306pa30Ba, Ha 3eMJIIIPoMaHoBcKoHBoJIocTH
PQMaHoBcKoir goJIocTW

ifM""I,-3anebcKoro yc3" B sToii rpaMoTe Ba""
IIB2HoBIiLI HcHOJIHHeT Ty >Ke (I)yHKmIIO HenOCPe"TBeHHOrO
⑫

CymbH,
[ITO
MI
B
TPOImKgHⅡPlITOBOPHoit
3aⅡHcH.
B
nepBoM

T6Me A3IIX <K"3b BacliJIeii l'IBaHoBJIq> paccMaTplIBa-

EMoro noKyMeHTa (JVb l 29) pacIHII(jpoBblBaeTcH KaK
175』ﾍC311, T. I11, M 46.

176 H・A.Ka3aKoBa '!n.C･JI y p b e. yKa3. co(I., cTp. 204,
わ

57

B M. naTp"eeB, a rpaMoTa naTIIpyeTcfl ToXaMH ero 60HpcTBa - 1495-1499. 0IHaKo sTa皿eHTII｡HKa皿H IInaTHPOBKa ,HIIIIeM He nOgTBeP>KXeHbL IIHTePeCHa bPa3a叩a-

MoTbl: <<A Ha cyne 6bLIIo y KHH3H BachIJIba iiBaHoBIi可兄

60兜p: "m3b lIBaH IQpbeBIIq, " IOpbH 3axapbliqb),. EcJIII
IIBaHIOpbeBIIII­ⅡeiicTBHTeJIbHoH.10.naTpHKeeB,oTeU
U

B ̲H. naTpmKeeBa, To ero npli'oyTcTBIieBo B6noMorATe,ﾉIbIIoIIpoJ1mnpHcoPcTBeHIIoMcbIHeKa]KeTcHCTpaHHbIM.KpoMeTOrO,<<KHH3bBaCIIJIeiliPaHOBIIII)MOCTaTOilHOfICHOnbOU

TIIBoHocTaBJIeH <60HpaM)M HaKoHeU, 3necb HMeeTcH TImiiLI-

I-IaJI 4JIH rpaMoT BacIIJIIIFI no且ⅡHcb AJI・Be306pa30Ba. Bce
3TH nPlI3HaKH uo3BOJIHIOT BI,皿eTb B BacHJTHII IIBaHoBH[ie
CblHa HBaHa ll1.

CoBnaXeHHe*yH"IIoHaJIbHblx
TeppliTopHaJIbHblx
II
npaB
BacIIJIHHBTpoHUKoihnplIroBopHoih3aⅡHCHHBnPaBOHrl)aし

U

四

MOTe rOBOPHT o XPOHOJIOrHIIecKOit

6JIII30CTH 3THx TeKcTOB.

BecbBonpocBnbHKax.Bbl皿eMblBblHCIIII,ⅡⅢ,qTOBCaMOM
KoIIne 80-x ronoB nLflK eXop Kyp皿blH 6blJI npHCTaBJIell
K BeJIHKoMy KHH3Io HBaHy lIBaHoBHIIy. He nepemeJI JIII oH
BcKOPe nocJIe cMePTHⅡocJIenlHero K KHFI3Io BacIIJIIIIo?UbHK
哩

A几Be306pa30B B MI3y[IaeMoji npaBoi rpaMoTe Ha3Eafl
且bflKoM <<BeJIHKoro KHH3H>D. He 3HaqHT JIH 3To, IITo oH 6blJI
HenocpencTBeHHblM npeeMHIIKoM enopa KypHUblHa, To>Ke
U

4bHKa <<BeJIIIKoTo KI-IFI3H>, npH KHFI3e BacIIJIHII, KoTopblti He
noJIyrllIJI e皿e BJIa八eTeJIbHblx，《rOCy瓜aPeBblx＞nPaB？HHblMH

cJ1()BaMH, He oTHocHTcH Jm o6a npKyMeHTa K nepliony Me>Kmy MapToM H ceHTH6peM l490 r.？177

Mbl noMliHM, [ITo HcnoJIIIeHHe poJIH cynbH nepBohHII-

CTaHUHHB nepecJIaBJIb-3aJ1eccKoM ye3" 6blJIo 6JIIHM H3

caMblxPallHIIxqJyHK皿IoIIa(JIbHo-TePPHToPmaJIIJHbIxnopy-

LIeHIIi KHfI3H IIBalla l/IBalIoBIIIIa MoJIoIoTo. B aHaJIoriliIIoM HcHoJII)30BaHHII BacHJIIJH npoHBHJIocb co3HaTeJIblloe
U

cJIenOBaHIIe onPenleJIeHHoIY TPa皿皿HH. Bo3Mo>KHo, cpa3y
nocJIe cMepTII HBaHa MoJIonoro HBaH III He xoTeJI iomfcKaTI,̲ BacIIJ1IIH K TBepcKoMy HacJ1encTBy (TeM 60JIee, qfo
c l488 r. ol-Io巾aKTHIIeCKII I-IaXO皿JIOcb B PyKax 'caMOrO Be-

JIIHEgroKHfl3FI),PTocJ1aBerocBePHblMII60FIPaMHIInbFIKoM
B nepecJIaBJIb-3aJ1eccK" ye3" Tpa""ciHHylo o6JIacTb
o6yIIeHIM IoHIJIx oTnpblcKoB MocKoBcKoH 皿IHaCTIIII neJIaM
④

I773Ta，maTIIPOBKa
He
nPOTIIBQPeIIHT̲JT3BeCTHblNI
"HwbIM
KaPbePe
o
(D. KypMIII)IM, KoToI)blii B 1492-1500 m̲gaIIIIMaJIcH no nl)ellMyme6T-

By皿moMaTⅡKIecKoh且eHTeJIbIIOcTbIo

coII., q. 2, cTp. 31 1, npHM. 6) .
58

(JI.

B.

I-Iepenl!IIII.

yK33

rOCy"PCTBeHHOrO ynPaBmel{IIFI, H JIIImb nOg BO3八eHcTBmeM
⑪

nePKogiII)IxmepapxoBIIBeJImKoiiKHHrmHIICo巾bPI,aTaK>Ke
yqilTbIBaf!Bo3boCnlylOnOJIMTHqecKylOaKTHBHocTbAIiAPe月
yrJIIInKoro, BeJIPIKIM KHfl3b 6blJI BblHy)KneH BBecTH Ba:cH-

JIHH B nPaBa nPeeMHHKa IIBaHa l'IBaHOBIIIIa KaK KHH3H
TBepcKoro. O BblHy>KneHIIocTH ̲3Toro " Ha3HaLIellH兄cBWIe-

TeJIBcTByeT 6bIcTpafI oTcTaBKa BacIIJIIifI oT TBepcKoro KI!II｡

>KeHIIFI (B KoHUe l491 r.)HnPeBPalUellHe erO B XaJIbHellmeM B KHH3H Ka皿HHcKoro (1492/93 r.l

Bo BTopoM ToMe ACSI'I ony6JIIIKoBaHa npaBafl rpaMoTa Ha 3eMJ1H Cy3naJIbcKoro ye3na; cyn HaqaJIcFI no rpaMoTe l'IBaHa lll; O nPOUeCCe《cynbPI peKJIHcHⅡoJIO>KmTHocnO-

naPH BeJIIIKoro KHH3H)D; Ha O60POTe cynHorO ̲CnHcKa - 3aU

nIICb,

CBImeTeJIbCTBylO皿afl,

IITO B

'nOCJIeJIHeII

HHCTaHnIIH

neJIo cJIymaJI KHFI3b BacIIJI" IIBaHoBHII: oH BblHec nPHroBOP, KOTOPbli 6blJI nO瓜ⅡmcaH BeJIHKOKHH>KeCKHM IbHKOM

HIIKH巾oDOM Ko6eJIeBblM (Nb 492) . H3XaTeJIb oToxmecTBJIHeT ､ K"3H BacHJIHFI HBaHoBwIa c B．Ⅲ. naTPIIKeeBblM

H且aTIIpyeTHoI<yMeHT
1497/98O60cHoBqHHe
r.
naTHpoBK1M
cJIemyIOmee:<BBImyaHaJIormqHocTIIPa36mpaTeJIbcTBa{!
U

PHna o61IIIIx cTaPO)KHJIbUeB H My)Keri Ha Pa3Le3"e c aKToM Nb

491

Mox<Ho naTHPoBaTb

nPaBylo

rpaMoTy reM

Xe

"bMeHeM,lTo [I 3anmcEQ pa3Leg" (7006-1497/98 rj ;
vilHTblBafI. 〃IITo KII. Bac MB., KoToPoMy neJIaJIcFI npKJIaX,
hepoHTHo,'naTpmKeeB,aronaMmero60fIpcTBa6bmII1495ゴ

1498 rr., npIIHHMaeM npe瓜nOJIO>KHTeJIbHylO XaTy: OK.
1497/98r.>>178.
maTIIPOBKa nO aHaJIOrHH c naTmPOBaHIIblM nPKyMellTOM
Nb 491 Ka>KeTcFI y6eⅡHTeJIbHOH, O皿-IaKo nPIIHFITb npeⅡnoJIo>KeHIIG o B. I/i・naTpHKeeBe HeJIb3H. B caMoM neJIe, Mbl
U

v>Ke 3HaeM, [ITo oceHbIo1497 r. KHFI3b BaclIJI嘘 HBaHOBHrI
■benan
Be且aJI
ropoxoBeⅡKoHBoJIocTblo'79Mo>KeT6blTb，HBecb
ropbxoBeuKoii BoJIocTblo '71 Mo>KeT 6bITb, H Becb
⑪

Cy3naJTbcKHHye34 BxO"" B 3TO BPeMH B erO KQjmeTelIr
U

U

uHIO・AHaJIII3 ilpaBoii rpaMoTb! noKa3bIBaeT, "o BacIIJIII#
U

WBaHoBIIq He HMe" BJI"eTeJIbHblx npaB Ha Cy3nambcKIIM

ye3X, a 6bIJI JIIImb cynlbeii BTopoii lIHcTaH"IL C､IIenoBafr
『p

『̲■

U

TeJIbHo, BblJalla JIbrOTHOHⅡO erOくcJIoBy> B roPoxoBenKoii
BOJIOcTH

He

OnPeneJIFIJIacb

cyBePeHHblM

IIOJIOJKeHIIeM

MoJIonProKHFI3HgpaiMoHeCy3naJIH-ropoxoBUa.To>Kecau

MOe, O[IeBHIH0, Mo>KHo cKa3aTI), cy八H nO aHaJIOrHKIIIHM
l78 AC3H, T. II, cTp. 535
179 TaM ]Ke, Nb 489.
59

IIWTHblM rPaMoTaM IBopcKHx >Ka6eHcKoii BoJIocTH I496U

1497 rr" o xapaIgepe BJTacTII BaC"1 B Kaim6koiM3U

jle B 3To BPeMfI. He cJIy[laiiHo caM oH He BbmaBaJI IIMMf"ヅ

TeTHbIx
rPaMoT巾eOnaJIaM
(nO皿IIcaI.IHe
BacIIJIHeM
rpaMoKa｡ﾉ1H31IHy
TbI
MOHaCTblPlo,
nPe皿OJIO>KIITeJIbHO
OTHeCeHHOe

""｣497 r" ""JIccb, KaK 6bIJIo noKa3aHo BbIm6,̅YW

BblmeHIIeM erO <3aKOHHblx》ⅡoJIHoMoIIHii) BepoHTHo, Ba-

W"̲"BaHOBII33anHMa"nOJIo)KeHme/CPeimeemb"'
9TaTycoMcJIy>Ke6HorOKHH3HHcynbHBToboi mHcTaHuHH
q

D

!II9̲gg"""IM TH'K6aM) 9 oTHoliieiIMIIKahiliMMrm
U

cJTaBcIgro ye3npB B nepBoII IIoJIoBHHe l496 r" KamIIHcko"

romnepecJIaBJIb-3aJIeccKoroye3noB - B1496-glZI"̅if.，
K KoTQpbIM oceHbIo 1497 r. 6bIJI npII6aBJIeH Cv3naJIbcKmif
⑱

ye3J;(coxpaHIIJIJIHBaclIJImii3ac660iiKamlli6fHHye34
切

U

IIocJIe HIoJIH l497 r., HeH3BecTHo) .

O noJIo>KeHIM nMIITp"-BHyka B I490-1497 rr. HcToIIHHKII nO IIcTOPHII= BHyTPeHHerO ynPaBJIeHHH He cOneP>KaT
④

HIIKaKIIX

△

CBemeHIm.

B WoTe l948 r. H. C. JIypbe nIIca'ﾉI: <...nMIITP"
ME"I!!mmPm3HanCBOmMHa6jlemHmKOMiIOCjiFM"
IJBaHa
HBaHoBmwa,
oTnaBafI,
TaKHMo6pa30M,̅iPennOIITeII"̲ BHyKy nepeJI BTopblM cblHoM Bac"HeM)> 180.B KHHre

1955
aBTop̲
n BbIcKaaFIBaeTcHocTopo)KHee,noJIaranrqf5fi6:

CJIe cMePTH HBaHa l'IBallOBHIIa《nMHTPHH MOr CrlHTaTbCH
aaKQHHLIMHa'cJIeXHIIKoMIIpeCTOJIa)> !81. ⅡpeⅡⅡOJIO>KeHHe
⑪

H C JIyPbe O Ha3HamleHHIi.nMHTP"-BHyKa. "cJmm6M

npecToJIa npHMeHHMo ToJIbKo K MapTy - ceHTH6pIo 1490 r.,
oIHaKo H TaKoe nqPymeHIIe BecbMa coMHHTeJIbHo, II60 jlBe

TBePCKHe MOHeTbl nMIITP", eCJIHHx nPIIyPOIIHTb TO>Ke K
2TOMy BPeMeWLIIOKa3bIBaIOT ero JIIImb B PO"H <<KHFI3".

g oKTH6" 1 490 r" Korna TBepcKoe HacJIMcfBo ̅MM
HBaHoBII[Ia noJIyqIm BacmJTIIii, nMIITpIIi enBa" M6ir̅MiZ
TaTbCH

HaCJIenHHKOM

nPecToJIa.

HeKoTopbleHa6JIIonteHIIFI,Kacalo皿HecHnOJIHTHIIeCKoH
I

T

r

poJIH cblHQBen ll BHyKa HBaHa lll B 90-x ro"x XV B,

cneJIaHb[n>Kd)eHHeJIoMnPIIaHaJIM3enOCOJI66KIIXKHIIF;
nocBHmeHHblx cHomeHIIHM c JIHTBoii. B npIIBeTcTBeHHoii
や

IIacTH

P"a

nOKyMeHToB

ynOMHHaIOTCH

HOKJIOHLI

II

qeJIO-

61ITbHoTIIJIeHoBnPaBH皿eroBeJIIIKoKHfDKecKoroIoMaJIII-

C・J1
PeP>KaBII"y9WI¥aWCl<!A
oro
y 180g.
《y〔JeHbTe3anHcKIIJ1rnI'111M
rePUella",
AⅡ．rePⅡeIIa》,T,781<31)“mHcTo.JJrnH
HA
｣IM
T"81<""̅iiffO-­
l)III! CCCP. J1., 1948, CTP. 81.
4

I81 H. A. Ka3aKoBaⅢ月. C. JIypbe･yKa3. coII., cTp. 164­1 65.
60

U

ToBcKoMVBenlIKoKIIfI>KecKoMyceMeAcTByIIHao60poT.3'IOT
U

ひ

UellIIIJIii MaTePHaJI nO3BOJIHeT八O K3BecTHOII cTenellH CynJTb o MeCTe TOrO IIJIH MHoro IIJIeHa BeJIIIKOKHH>KecKOH印a唖

⑥

ʻ

U

MHJIHII Ha CTyneHHX CeMeIIHOHHepapxHII. OAHaKo HoJIyIIeHHe
TaKOrO l)04a naHHbIx COnPmKeHO C I13BeCTHblMH TpynHocTHMIi・B HeKoTopbIx cJ1yqaHx nepeqeHb noKJIoHoB He nnHBo･

且HTcH,a yKa3blBaeTCFIJIEmb, IITOHOCJIenOKJIOHOB6blJIa
BpyqeHa rPaMoTa lI T、n. HenpcTaToIIHafl IIcToIIHHKoBe,mIIeCKa兄Ⅲ3yqellHOcTb
(bOl)Mbl nOcoJIbCKHx KHHr II B [IacTHo凸
U

cTII Pa3JIH[I" B TImax 3anHcIi Pa3Hblx BHユOB JIOKyMeHToB
He ntaeT BO3MO>KHOcTH I'IcHOJIb30BaTb HX MaTePIIaJI c yBe-

peHHOcTblo，IITo
PeHHOcTblo,
[ITo BCe
BCe瓜aHHble
naHHble ⅡeHCTBHTeJIbHO
neiICTBHTeJIbHO COnOCTaBHMbl
COnOCTaBHMbl
H IITo II3BJIeqeHHble cBemeHIIFI nPe八CTaBJIHIOT CO60ii CHCTeMy, nPlirOJHylo JJIH HCTOPHIIeCKoro nOCTPOeHIIH.
Ⅱ】K､ eHHeJI, CCblJIaHCb Ha nePeqeHb noKJIOHQB B TPeX
』

八OKyMeHTaX
(O皿oM1494r.182HⅡByxl495r.183),nHmeT:
《O6blIIHblii nop皿oK 6blJI TaKoii: IIBaH III, Co巾bH, EJIeHa
u

CTe｡aHoBHa, iIepBble Tpll̲cblHa (go巾bH-BacHJI", I0pHii
Ⅲ瓜iIIITpliii, bblli EJIeHIji nMHTp" npaKTHKa 6blJIa, oIHa⑪

U

KO，cJIe八ylo皿eH：cHaYIaJIa
ylomek: cHawlaJIa cTaPm"
cTaPmHH〔IJIeH
qJIeH MoCKoBcKoro
MoCKoBcKorononoCoJIbCTBa nePenaBaJI HOKJIOH QT BeJIHKOrO KHH3fI; 3aTeM

BTOPO力nOCTaPmlIHCTBylnOCOJI]nePe""JInPHBeTCTBHHOT
u

Tpex cblHoBeit Co巾bH; HaKOHeU, cTaPm皿 IIJIeH nOCOJIbCT-

B3 nepe"Ban npiIBeTcTBHe oT cbIHa EJIeHb] JIMIITp"."
Cod)bffIIEJleHaCTedJaHQBHa
ynoMMHanlicb
.jlIPo.BTopblM
nocTaP皿HHcTBy[nodnoM]nep"cblHoBbFIMIICo｡bHHJIM

cTapmliMqJIeHoM{nocoJIbcTBalcpa3ynocJIeBeJIIIKoroKIIIIZ
3H. ̅OTMeTIIM, [ITo EJIeHa CTe巾aHOBHa He ynOMHHaeTCH nP
l495 r. B cHIIcKe noKJIoHoB> 184.
U

BMecTe

c

TeM

BblBo,瓜 aBTOPa

MaJIo
U

yTemHTeJIbHblH:
⑥

くB xone八ⅢⅡJIOMaTHqecKIIX CHOmeHIiii C JIHTBOH瓜eJIaJIocb
Bce nlJIH Toro, qTo6bl cKPblTb oT JIHToBcKoro BQJoMcTBa IIHo-

cTpaiIHbIxXejl,KoMyomaeTcHnepBeHcTBo-BacmJIIIlo"U
瓜MHTpmlo.HeJIb3HBbIBecTIIHHKaKoro3aKJIIomleHIIH､MI3TQrP

56pHnka,BKoTopOMnepenaBaJIIIcbnpmBeTcTB"AJle"lt

o3EMif6TE'
HeMIIJIocTIi
90-xnHee
aerO》KeHe
6bIJIa
B
npy,
ceMeHcTBa，EcJIH
ECJIH
B
Cod)bH
HII ">Ke
OTIIJIeHOB
BeJIHKOKHH>KecKOrO
Co巾bH“》KeH6bmaBHeMHJIocTHB90­x
u

ronax,enBaJIHEBaHIIInleMOHcTPliPOBaJI6bIJaTO,OnyCKafI
eeiIMiI Bneneulax, nocblJIaeMbIx B BIIJIbHy, H60 B aTo Bpe-

MH OH HMeJI Bce OCHOBaHIIH nPeJICTaBJIHTb rJIa3aM 3anaPHO182 <C6. PHO>, T, 35, cTp. 138.

183TaM>Ke,cTP"164-165,204=205.
184 J・Fen nell・Op・cit.,P, 335, note 2.
61

．了､.-

．

-一

WWWW!II"Bem!K9[O
""33̲"HTOBCKOrO]
KaPTHIIIIy WI)MoHIIII H corJIacHH B KpeMJIe), 185

II" Ka>KergH, qTQ nl)m""EMbl"IIWIoMarweCKme

WeW"L Tpe6yIoT 60JIee cIIcTeMaTIIqeCkoro o66Jmm

H1IH.
nPe>Kme
BCel,O
3TI,IMH
I'ICTOIIHHKaMII
nOnTBeP>KnalOTcH
YM"eJIaHHbIe npm aHami3e aKToB Ha6JIIoieHmIg ̅6fil6bri:
Wbll9̲TIITy"HacJIe4HII"B HBalla lll B 90-X ro"X XVE

groCbIHoBbf!
BaclIJIliii,IOpHA,JMHTPlM
HBHyKJMPITP"
(|)HryI〕111)yIoT
B且ImJIoMaTH【IecKHx“KyMellTaxl491W" .WW̅ " K"IJII666n biM ､If6 X6 Mei tr F
守分

u

WW W:" 9:402" H ABmoTEH, ynoMHmyTfi>Io5MMeHTax I495-1497 rr" Ha3BaHb! B6JIilKK"̅MMh""

ReJnfKoKHH>KeCK"
lix
HmIieM̅X.｡i､PO311JI
TI1Tyn
HBaHy
lll.
｡

3aKpenjIeH!ipJKc"TyJIa
ieJIMKbiTj̅kiMMi<5#皿16oH3
noTOMKOBI'IBaHalllnoMy>KcKOiiⅡHHIIIIHMeJIo6blBecbMa
U

CePPe3Hoe noJIHTI1[IecKOe 3HaIIeHHe.

noCJIe
l9-Me(､flPIHorO
nePHona
ynOMIIHaHHFI
noKJIoHoB
OT

BeJIHKoroKⅡ”H
HBaHaHBaHoB恥a（cHIoJIfll488Ⅱo巾eB-

paJIb
l490
E)
B皿皿oM
aTIIIIecKOH及oKyMeIITanHII
o6Pa3yU

Wi
eTcH
TPGXMeCH【IHblHnePePblB，B
TR"MeCHqHbIjinePellPlB,BTeIleHme̅
TeIIeHHe
KoTOPorOnOKJIOHbl
KoTOPofOnOKjl6fib!
ImyT TO修矼bKo oT caMoro HBaHa lll l8Z B HIolie l490 E JIIIg
U

TOBCKIIII
HOCOJI《且,eTEM
BeJIIIKoro
KHH3H
oT
Kopo"eBHqeB

!9WMWW̲" 3Jp noKJIoH Ha 6oJIce HH3R3WME
I:RMWOML' "IIY HBaHoBIiqy, KoTQPblii nOJMajrrm｣
U

W9WI.E̲"bKO OT KOPoJIeBIIIIe#; HO I! 6T KOPOm
U

KKT9MIWHMgUmo mierm "cb IIe """MiifPMM
U

Mg̲̲YgoMfIHyT - "II oH Haxo"JIcH B TBe" iIJIIr3aHMMAji

cJIH山KOM
He3aMeTHOe
nOJIO)KeHIIe
nPH且Bope.B
HoFI6pe

1491r．jIIEoBCK"
'nOcoJI
<<CbIHy
BeJIIiKorO̅KHH3",KH"IO
U

""!QHBaHOBHrly, n""JI n6KIIOif̅MMMWWSr

RWWf"9"OH>Ke>189eTOnepBbliimCaMbliiTOP>KeCT･
U

"LIblii II3jcex noKJIoHoB, noJIyqeliHbIx Bac"RM E̅mi=

1497
rr.
nBeHa且naTHJIeTH皿KHH3b
BblcTynaeT
TVT
KaK
U

U

e皿""H" HaCJIenHHK HBaHa lll; !IMn erO nlimeTCfI,
BOTJIIIIIHeOTnOCJTenylo皿HxcJIyIIaeB,coT[IeCTBOM(">Ke

MQWW̲Ii"IIY "aHOBIIIIy jiocJIe41Imii H33bIBMCm6:
⑥

cTo BeJIHKHM KHH3eM HBaHoM) K HoH6plo l491 rBac"".
や

KaKMblnOJIaraeM,HOTeP"TBePcKoeKHmKeHHeII,0[leBH旦当
185 J・Fennell. Op. cit., p. 335.
W fC6PHO>, T 35, cTp・189, 194, 239.
W TaM >Ke, CTp. 42

!¥ TaM >Ke, crb. 47.
'89 TaM )Ke, cTi). 53.

62

Ho,IIaxoIIIIJIcHIIenocI)encTBeHIIonpHoco6emBaHalll.OH
IIMeJI B 3To BpeMH |60JIbmo曲nOJII1TII'IeCKmiI Be!C, IITO, nOB皿MMOMy, II oTPa31iJIOcb B (bOPMyJIe llOKJIOlla.
y>Ke B Mae

l492 r，noJIO>KeHHe 3aMeTHo MeHFIeTcH:

Ha-

",my c MMeHeM BacliJIIH B cnmPKe noKJIoHoB 99fIBJIFIIWH

HMeHalOpHHII八ByXnMIITPIIeB(CblHaHBHyKaHB2Halll).

JIIITOBCKHHnOCOJIく且eTeMBeJI]IKoroKHH3H,KHH310Bacll,mblo
II KHfl3Io IOpblo) oT KopoJI別HoT KOPOJIeBMLIeB IIPaBI{JI no｡

KJIoIi... A BIiyKa BeJIHKbro KHfI3fI, KHfl3H JMIITI)eR, II cblHa
BeJIHKOTo KHFI3H, KHH3H JMIITPefl, B Ty lIOPy y BeJIHKoro
KHH3H He 6blJIO, II OH HM OT KOPOJIH I'I oT KOpoJIeBIILIeB y

(TTOJIanOKJIOHnPaBHJI>P190.BPOCaeTCHBI､JIa3a,LITOB3TOM
JOKVMeHTe nMIITPmii-BHyK 3aHHMaeT TpeTbe nQ cTaplll!IHcT-

By imeCTo CPe皿hoToMKoB I'IBaHa lll, xoTH nMIITp"-cblil
J

6LLII Ha JIBd rona cTapme ero '91 Ta JKe mepapxmH co6JIIoU

naeTcH B ceHTH6pe l493 r., Koma JIIIToBcKHmⅡOCOJI《npa-

BHJI BeJIHKOMy KIIH310 HoKJIoH, a KIIH310 10PblO, cUHy BeJIMI-

KOrOKHH3H,IiKHH'310HMHTPlI10,B|HyKy,IIKHfl3!q4MHTPelo,

CblHy＞K
BeJIHKOrO
KHH3H，nPaBHJInOKJIOH〉K'e》ʼ92．

△
B ppKyMeHTax, I'Icxo且HBmHX OT PyCCKOH CTOPOIIbl,
B
U

l1492
4 9 2 r ，r.v c
vcTaHaBJIHBaJIcH
Ta H a B J I H B a J I c H HIIHoii
H o H ⅡnopFInpK
o”且oK ne
nepena[III
p e 瓜 a [ I H nHoKJIooKJIo-

HCB・B
B ilaKa3e
HaKa3e
MaR
MaR1492r，pyccKoMyⅡocJIymBaHy
1492 E pyccKoMy nocJIy mBaHy BeKJIeMmmeBy 6blJIO nPemIICaHO nePe"Tb ̲POKJIOHbl̲cHailaJIa

OT IeTeiI BeJIHKorO ､KHH3R-BacHJIIIfI, IOP皿HnMHTplIH,
3aTeM - OTneJIbHO OT JMHTPHFI-BHyKa 193 (nOCOJIbCTBO He
cocToHJIocD H3-3a cMepTH Ka31IMHpai B 3amIcII O npmeMe
JIIIToBcKHx HocJIoB 4 1-Iofl6pFI 1492 r. roBopHTcH:《A y BeJIIIKoro KHH3H '6blJIII neTH erd: K"3b BacIIJIei, H KHH3b lOpbli,
ひ

u

H KHH3b nMIITPeii, H BHyK Be皿KOro KHH3H; H OH(nOcOJI⑥

C. K)HM nPaBIIJI nOKJIOHンKe>p 194.
Bo3Mo)KHo, qTo B 1492­1493 rr. HMeJIIo MecTo PeaJIbHOe BO3Bbl山elilie nMHTpIIFI-BHyKa, KOTOPOe HBaH III eme
He ad)IILHIipoBaJI II He 3aKpenJIFIJI B UepeMoHIIaJIg, JIHToB⑪

U

cKHe >Ke nocJIbl, 3Hafl o nelicTBHTeJIbHOPI POJIH且MHTPIIFI-

BHyKa,ITePenaBaJIHeMynOKJIOHPaHb皿e,[IeMnMIITPlI10cblHy. B p皿e JIeTOnHcHblx cBonPB no4 7000 ( 1492) E co06皿aeTCH :くTofl >Ke BecHbl, anpHJIH B 5, B IIeTBel)ToK,
BblmOJI KHFI3b 'BeJIHKIIi II3 cBoerO XBOPa lI3 cTapOTo B KHH>K
ｑ

１﹄０
１Ｑ１
︾２
１Ｑ︾３

TaM >Ke, CTp. 57.

nMHTPlili-CblH I)O八McH 6 oKTH61)H l481 r. (nCPJI, T. V111, cTp. 213)
《C6. PII0>, T. 35, cTp. 108.

１伊障．
TaM >Ke, cTp. 61.
Ｑ
１﹄４

TaM )Ke, cTP、72.

，

63

IjBBHoBjlBoI]lOpbeBII[laB!IoBoi,I!cBeJIHKOIoKHjirmHeiO
Co巾belo I(C neTMH,H c HeBecTKOIoc Be川IKOIOKHflTHIIGIO

c EJIelloIo, Ii co KHH3eM JMlITPlieM C BIlyKOM), 19a yllOMIi-

HaHHenMllTPHH-BHyKaB3ToM
HaHHeユMHT”H-BHyKaB3T
oMH3BeCTHHOnepee3旦eBeJIHK
II3BeCTIIIIO̅nePee3neBeJIHKOOU

KHH)KGcKOH

U

CeMblI B八pyroH且Bop

caMo

no

ce6e Ka>KeTcfY

MaJIo noKa3aTeJIbHblM. OnHaKo, eCJIII conocTaBHTb erO c
naHHblMHノ]､Im@"OMaTHIIeCKIIX nPKyMeHTOB II ylleCTb, uTO

HMH<BHVK”BJIeTomlcHoI1cTaTbeHa3BaHO，a“eTIや〔bⅡMIMH
<<BHyKPl> B JIeTOmiCHOH CTaTbe Ha3BaHO, a <<neTI" (bHryPllPylOT 6e3 1IMeII, noJlyIIIITcfl KoMnJIeKc KocBeHIIblx IIa6Jilo八eHIIii, cJIy2Ka皿ﾙIx HaMeKoM IIa yBeJIH[IellIIe B l492 r. noJIHTII'IeCKOTO 3HaIleHHH nOCeJIe MaJIO 3aMeTHOrO H I-Ie OTMe-

qaeMOrO HCTOIIHIIKaMH HacJIe4HHKa KHR3FI I/IBaHa HBaHOBII【Ia MoJIonpro.

Bo3BblmeHIIemMHTI)IIFIB
14921､.JIBIIJIOCbl)e3y."I｣TaTOM
II3MeHeHHH nO"HTmⅢecKoi o6cTaHOBK}I nOCJIe aPecTa

AHnPeFIyr､mUKoroBceHTH6pel491r.OIIeBH八HO7KOma
｡

oTnaJIa HeO6XO且HMoCTb B HeHTPaJIII3aUlM yrJIHUKOro KHH-

33, HBaH III nPe>Kne BCerO JIHmHJI BacIIJIwI TBepcKoro
KHH>KeHIIH, a 3aTeM Ha[laJI nOcTeneHHO BblJBHraTb nMHT-

PHH-BHyKaB JaKIeCTBenOJIHTHKIecKOrOnPOTHBOBeca'CTaP-

meMy cblHy. BepoHTHQ& 3Ta noJIHTIIKa Bbl3blBaJIa conp6-

THBJIeHHe co cTopoHbl Co巾bH H nO3TOMy nPoBO皿JIacbnoKa
G皿e BecbMa OCTOPO>KHO. r,me HaxO皿皿cb o6a mMIITpHfl B
Mae l492 r (Hx <<B Ty nopy y BeJIIIKoro KHR3fl He 6biJIo>) ,
｡

HaM I･leH3BeCTHO, OIHaKO HeT HHKaKHX OCHOBalIHHC【IﾙITaTb>
U

LLTo B sTo Bp"H nMHTp"-BHyK Mor noJIymlMTb TBeph
B ceHTH6pe l493 r. npII IBopebTcyTcTBoB3" Bacﾙ、恥I．
⑪

O ero nocblJIKe B TBepE B l492/93 r. 6006maeTcH, KaK y>Ke
ynoMIIIIaJIOCb, B Pa3PfmaX.

B HHBape l494 - Mae l495 r. JIHToBcKIie nocoJIbcTBa
nePeniaBaJIH nOKJTOHbl B CJIe4ylOmeﾙI OIIePenHOcTH: nePBblM
HOCOJI - I'IBaHy lll, BToPOii nOcOJI-《瓜eTeM BeJII1KOrO
U

心

U

KHH3H, KHH310 BacHJIblo, KHH310 10pblo, KHH310 EMHTpelo,
II BHyKy BeJIHKOrO KHH3H, KHfl310 nMIITpeIO)" 196.
B MapTe l494 r. pyccKoe nocoJIbcTBo JIoJDKHo 6blJIo nePe,maBaTb nPIIBeTCTBwI B TaKOM nOP皿Ke: l ) nePBblii nOcoJI noKJIoH oT HBaHa lll; 2) BTopoii nocoJI - HoKJIoH oT
U

”

Co｡bH II IIeJIo6HTbH oT ee neTei - BacIIJI", IOpHH II
U

195nCPJI,T.1V.Cn6"1848,cTp.160-161;T、VI,cTp.39,240;T.V111,
cTp. 224; T. XII, cTp、233̲; T. 20, nepBa別ⅡoJIoBHHa, cTp. 357; T. 27,
0

cTp. 291; T. 28, cTp. 157, 322.

196fC6.PHQ',T35,cTp.112,157(nocoJ16bIJIo八IIH)、160,188(nocon
6bIJ' O"H).

64

nMIITp"; 3) nepBblii nocoJ1 - [IeJIo611Tbe oT IMIITpIIFIBHyKa l97. B jlHBape l495 r. Bo BTopoM nyHKTe 6blJI np6aBU

J I e H I o K J I O H O T < C H OX I I > B e J I I I KO r o K H H 3 F I - B e ､ ﾉ I H KO H K H H r H ­

HH EJIeHb[ (HocJIe noKJIoHa oT Co｡bH) 198. B aBrycTe
1495 r. B 3Toii mePeMoHIIII Ha'6JIIo4aeT'cH e皿e OXHO H3M'eHeHHe: noKJIoHbl oT BeJIHKHx KHHrIIHb (Co｡blI HEJIeHbl) ne-

pe"IoTcH nePBbIM nOCJIOM (cPa3y nOCJIe nOKJIoHa OT BeJIHKOrO KHH3fl) '99

TaKIIM o6pa30M, ecJIH JIHToBcKHe nocoJIbcTBa B l4941495 rr. npocTo cTaBHJIH瓜MHTPHH-BHyKa Ha nocJIenHee
MeCTo B PFIJy nOToMKOB IIBal-Ia lll, TO PyccKIIii UePeMOHH○

aJI

IOKa3blBaeT,

CKOPee,

naJIbllemmee

yKPenCJIeHHe

erO

nO-

3IIUHii npLI BeJIHKoKH"KeCKoM HBOPe. ByAyIHI nOCJIeAIIMM B
nePeLIHe, "MMTPmiTeM He MeHee BO3BblmaJI|CH IO BeJIIIKOKHH)KeCKoro yPOBHH, H60 erO nPHBeTcTBIIe nePenaBaJIOCb
“

nePBblM HocJIoM - TeM )Ke caMblM, KOTOPblH ⅡePenaB aJI
nokJIoH oT IIBaHa lll. y)Ke onHo sTo cTaBHJIo ero KaK 6bl
H a 旦 及 e T b M H B e J I H KO r O K H H 3 H ・

B

oTJIIIIIHe

oT

,meTeii,

Ha3BaHHblx

ToJIbKo

Ho

IIMeHH,

mMHTpHii-BHyK B PacCMaTPHBaeMblX HaKa3aX PyccKIIM HocJIaM

l494--l495 rr. HMeHoBaJIcH c oTIIecTBoM, IITo TaK>Ke

ⅡO,nHePKHBaeTKaIIeCTBeHHOHHohyPOBeHPeroHQJIO>KelIHH

Ho cpaBHeHIiIo co cTaTycoM BaCllJI", IOpIIfIH瓜MHTP IIH-

cblHa. HaKoHeni, o Bo3BblmeH皿旦MIITPwI B aTO BPeMfl cBH-

AeTeJIbcTByeT H BKJIIoIIeHIie EJIeHbl BoJIomaHKII B cnIIcoK
JIIm,

nePenaloUHx

nPHBeTcTBHfl

JIHToBCKoMy

BeJIHKoMy

KHH310. Co｡" noRBJIJIeTcFI B 3ToM cnHcKe BIJepBble B Map-

Te l494 r., BepoHTHo, KaK 6yly皿aH Te皿a AJIeKcaHmpa, B

cBfl3H c HatlaEmHMHcH B HHBaPe - MapTe l494 r. TIepero.
BopaMII o >KeHHTb6e BeJIHKoro ̲KHFI3FI JIHToBcKoTo Ha，n､oIIe-

pH HBaHa lll EJIeHe. EJIeHa BoJIIomaHKa BKJIIoIIaeTcH B
6mIcoK B HHBape l495 r., o[leBMHo, nJIH HeiiTpaJIH3aUHII
VCHJIHBalO皿ehc兄noJIIITH[IecKoii

poJIII Co｡bll ll "H yKpen-

JIeHIIH nO3皿噸ⅡMHTPHfl-BHyKa. B HHBape l495 r2 06e Be-

JIHKHe KHflrHI-IH cToflT B H3BeCTHoM CMblcJIe IIⅡ承e瓜MHTpHHBHyKa, II60 Hx HoKJIoHbl nepe,nalOTCfl BTOPblM IIOCJIOM.
POcTV
- HoJIIITIIIIecKoro aBToPlITeTa nMIITI)Iifl-BHyKa B
1494 - HaIIaJIe

l495

1､r.

cooTBeTcTByeT

HoIITHⅡoJIHoe Hc-

【Ie3HoBeHIIe B sTo BpeMfl c HoJIHTHqecKoii apellbl KHH3H BacHJIIIH HBaHoBHIIa, KoToPOe nPOcJIe>KIIBaeTcfl no aKTaM.
197 TaM JKe, cTp. 138.

l96 TaM >Ke, cTP、164­1 65.
199 TaM ]Ke, cTp. 204-205.
5 - C. M. KamTaHoB

65

IIO- BII八HMoMy, co cMel)TI)Io AHnpefI yrJIIIUKoTo B I493 r.

II Bol)Hca BoJIoIIKorqB Mae l494 r. oTnaJIa HJIH pe3Ko
yMeHbmIIJIafb noTI]e6IIocTb B IIcnoJIb30BaHI,III BaC""
nJIHnpoTHBoneihcTBHH yXeJIbHblM KHH3bHM. Bo3HHKJIa HoBaH 3ana[Ia - OrPaHHIIHTb TeppHTOPHaJIbHble nPIITfl3aH"

H BJIacTb caMoro BacHJIHH. Ocy皿ecTBJIeHHe 3TOA 3a,ma[III H
BblJIBIIHyJIO Ha nePenHI戒 皿aH UMIITPIIH-BHyKa.
C l495 rb0pb6a Me2"y mapTIIHM" BadiJI[硯Ⅲ且MHT/

PHflnpHO6PeTaeTocTPbl曲xapaKTep.Bblxo只只oIIepHHBaHa lll H Co巾bH, BeJIHKoii KHH>KHbl EJIeHbl HBaHoBHbl, 3aMy)K 3a "TPBcKQro BeJIHKoro KHFI3H AJIeKcaHnpa ycHJIHJI

HO3皿HIJ Co｡blI. CBa"6a cocToflJIacb B BImbHe . 1 5巾eBpa-

JIR 1495 r.200, Ho y)Ke c 3 ｡eBpaJIH 1495 E 3aMeTHo̅MeIIHeTcH IIepeMoIIIIaJI npllBeTcTBHiI AJIeKcaHDPy: noKJIoHbl TenePb, KaK nPaBHJIo, HayT ToJIbKO OT CaMOro BeJIHKOrO KHH3H

Ii nOCTaBJIeHHOi c HHM Ha OXHH yPOBeHb BeJMKoi KHHrHHII

Co｡blI 20L npaB", IIBaH III CTpeMIIJIcH He nPmycTIITb
giulecIBeHHoro noJIIITMLIgcKoro npeliMXUecTBa Co｡bn nepem
EJIeHoii: m3 nl)IIBeTcTBIiii aBrycTa l495 E Mb[ B"mM, 1JTo
EJIeHa To>Ke 6blJIa no4HHTa np ypoBHFI BeJIHKoro KHH3H

(nOKJIOH OT Hee nePe"Ba皿epBbli nocoJI) . OJHaKo ycHJIe-

HHe no3HU" Co巾bH OTPa3IIJIOCb Ha nOJIO>KeH皿ⅡMIITpIm.

Cp""M 3anllcII o nepenaIIe noMIIHKoB B HIIBape H aBTycTe l 4 9 5 r.

>IHBap1,

<< . . .nOMIIHKB
KO r O

KHH3H mOT

HBIITII

ABrycT

OT

BI･IVKa

BenllKI好I3IO

CGMel'v 202 nd 3anMcH・A oT BeJTwKIIX KI･IFITHHb lI OT neTei nOMMHKII

HBHTII MI1Xaii@JIy 203 110 3amlCII>> 20j

《．．. nOMIIHKH HBIITM OT BeJIHKOrO KIIH-

3fI H OT BeJIIIKRX I<IIJIrHHL BOPHCy 205
A noCJ1e BGJIHKIIX KIIHrHHb

BIIVKa Be．mHKOrO K1.1列3月》207

の ハ ハ
星 ． リ
り 八 ロ
↑ Ｕ ー

●

ITCPJI, T. 27, cTp. 366.

《C6 PI10", T. 35, cTIL 172, 173, i78 (MapT), 196 (Mai), 201-202

(''Io川.)
I̅IepBblii nOCO.m.
BTopoii noco.w.
"C5. PI'IO>, '1,. 35, cTI). 165.
nepBbIHⅡoCoJ、
︒
０
２ ６ BTopoii nocoJI.
２０
７
２
か０
手︽
２０
し
２０
４
○
０
二牌

llOMHHKOB

MaiiKy 206 jlBMTH ITOMRHKH OT 1eTeii
BeJIRKOrO KIIH3FI. A OnOCJIe JIeTI,IHLIX
noMIIIIKoB JIBHTMI IIoMHHKII BoPllcy oT

む
U

U

唖P

<C6. PHO>, T､35, cTp. 205; cl). cTp. 207.
66

Mo>KHo 3aMeTHTb, IITo ecJIFI B 'HHBape l495 r. oIIepeX･
iIoCTb nepenaqm nOMIIHKOB OTcTynaeT OT Oqepe"OCTmⅡe-

penaqH
noKJIoHoB,
[leM̲JaeTc兜npeHMy皿ecTBO
nMMTI)IIIO-

EHyKy､o B aBrycTe l495 E o｡e nepeMoHmm BnoJIHg "JIgg
cyibTBI m UMIITpIIik-BHyK B o60IIx cJIyqaHx omeMeT)cH ̲qT
EaflikOrOklifI3ffBeJ1HKiiMIIKHHrHHHMmmXeTbMH208
(Bne｡

U

peqHe qeJIo6IITIIii EneHe HBaHoBHe nMIITp""yM､"M

Ki56f̅n66jienHeeMeCTO,noc"e BeJImKmxKIIfDKoH･enocbm
IIA皿OTbli) 209

IWE"4or6,｡"BrycTe
!495｢Bo皿KIIeKHHrHHII6blJII1

nPen6TaBJIeHb[nePBbIBLnOCJIOM,qTOHaPymaJIO̲IIWW1i-

T6JIbiIocTb noJIo>K6HIIH nMIITPllfI nPII oco6e BeJIIIKoro KIjfl3>L
○

CTaB My)KeM AoLIePII IIBaHa lll PI Co(I)bII, JIHT9BcKIjII Bpr
JIIIKHHKIIfl3b AJIeKcaHXP, oLIeBH瓜Ho, ycMJIwl 60pb6y 3a
VMeHb皿6HlleaBToPMTeTa ̅nMIITPmfL B1492-l493 rr" KaK
Mbl noMHIIM, Ha6JfIoXaJIocbcKopee
MblnoMHIiM，Ha6JIIo瓜aJIocb
cKopee
o6paTHoe・HoTomaⅡo
o6pa"oe. H9 TorJLa no
cv皿ecTBV
- e皿eBeJIaC6BoiiHaC2BaHOMIIImHe6blJIO6PaqU

U

R6f5coI63a y>Ke c caMoro HaqaJIa l494 E, Koma AJIeKgaH4p

3amyMaJI
>KeHIITbcfl
Ha
EJIeHe
lIPaHoBIIe,
oTHo皿eHHe
JIHTBbl
K IMHTpIIIo lI3MeHIIJIocb, qTO 6bIJIo noKa3"9,､ ¥b皿eⅡ”

CP
aB
IIeHHHJIHTOBcKIIx
PyCCKHx
II
nPIIBeTCTBHh1494-1495
rr.
6656"5hPHMetlaTeJIbilbnPIIBefPTWie,nePpnaHHOemBaHylllJIHToEcKHMroHUoMBHIoJIel495r.：くBe.JIHKoMyKHH3IOH1eTeMnPaBIIJInoKJIOH;naOTlBeIIIIKIIGK"rlIH"TPJIeユ

HEIM"JIofuyqeJIo6MTEe,a6paTbenoKJIoH"21qBmyK
I/IBaHa lll 3neCb na)Ke He ynoMHHyT.

CooTHoIIJeHIie cIIJI Me>Kly BacwIHeM H nMIITpHeM B KoHue l495 r. BblpIIcoBblBaeTcH H3 "BecT" p"a JIeTonHcHblx

cBOIoB O noxMe liBaHa lll B HQBroPoA, OTK)Ina pyccKIIe
BOeBO4bl COBeP山ﾙIJIII B HaqaJIe l496 r. noxoI B HHnHI-IZIHIO :

<<OKTFI6"20,BBToPHH'K,noⅡユeKI-IFI3bBemIKbl曲mBaHBacliJIbeBIiqb c MocKBbi B BoTqzHy cBoIo B BeJIliKbliI HoBjppo,1I,
U

3̅6̅ iImM BHyK ero KHH3b nMIITPeii, na cbIH K"3b IOpbll;
a Ha MocKBe ocTaBIIJ1 y Be川1Kble KH}ITIIIIII Co(jbII cbllla
一

208

CI)・peIlbHBaHa
lllJIIITQBcKoMynocJIyB
Mae
l495r.:f3M9MWjK!!
oT Hac.r noKJIoMwIcH̲ A neTi BeJIHKoro KH,13", KHfi3L Bacw1eii !!
KHH3b lOl)blI MmKH”bⅡMHTpeH，HBHyKBeʻmIKoroI旧泥兄npHKa3a,IH･･.
KHH3blOl〕bH
KHH3b nMHTpeii, ]I BHyK BeJI1IKoro F,HFI3
3a nOMIIHKH IIeJIo6IITbe>; 3aTeM c･menyloT nOKJIOHIJI OT BeJIIIKMx KIIH⑪

fiiHE̅C"iJH !l EJIeHb! il "IeJIo6mTbe bT BeJIMKo# KHf"I," "mocbm
("C6. PI'IO>, T. 35, cTp. 194).
２０９ くC6. PIIO>, T. 35, cTP. 207.
２１０

TaM JKe, cTp. 199.

67

5＊

WW.MalBacHJibfIcMcHmelo6paTbcio'211､IIIITepccmo,

[:WJWW"IyKyma3aH",3TOM-IMTEPamigmⅡ凡

BBo3Mo>KHOcTb
nPiiHFITHH3TOII
BePCIIH且O
KoHUa
FIcHa,
H60
He
U

B,WQTP"x
JIeJ;OnIIcHx"lLBR<poHOrPadJeCHaIIaJIayka3aH

IOIQ"､anPToMHMmrpmji212T6MMEb,̅8y皿Ⅱo
"
TeKcTV
耳

IIocoJIbcKoiiKIIPIrmII6oJIb皿HHcTBaJIeTOHIIcHblxcBO40B,

Y ."c ecTLBCe ocHOBaHIIH nPe且noJIo)KHTb, IITo ecJIII B 1 492-

I W rrJMMTP"-BmyK cT6miBblmC̅XiMTMM3, ¥5 B
1495r.oHcToIIT,Bep6JITHo,y)KeHBL!皿elOpHH.Eroe瓜ⅡHU

cTBglHbIM ConePHHKOM HBJIHJICfI B aTo BPeMHBacHJImi

KapTMHarloJIy[IIIJIacbnpMMepHoTaKM:̅nm̅m.5mpa-

l班jW B noxog c JIIo6IIMbIM BHyKoM, a Co(I)bIo ocTaBHji B

M9Wg"c｣"IMbn! @bIHoM CMilaM6ri5[IKMMI15
U

轡

瓜lWPmll-BHyK
oKa3aJIcII
60JIee
BnpHBIMermpoBaHHoM,noJIoWWL(nMBeJIMKoMKHfI3e),weMBacIIJImi̅imMiIMi
R 2

KHHrIIHe)
Ho
. nocy皿ecTBy,pcTaBJImlCoq)bIo(I)aKTHIIGcKoM
に ｡

nPaBIITeJIbl-I皿eii B MocKBe, HBaH III Bo36blmaji ,I Bac""

49̲29JIcOWBHTeJ1HMaTePm
(HenaPOMBrPaMOTeHaflPOcJIaBcKHe 3eMJIﾙ! oH (I]IiryPliPyeT KaK [le)IOBeK <cTabm-

m"l̲" npm pacnpeneJiEIImif poJIc#E MMe i4Wf
人

U

II3BecTHoe 3HaqeHHe HMeJIII, Mo>KeT 6blTb, H BHeliHenoJIHTII-

LIecKIie
coo6pazI(eHIIfI.
OTnpaBJI"cb
B
ndxo瓜ⅡPOTHB
ceBePI-Iorococena­mBeUHH,BeJIHKIMKHFI3b
ocTaBJIHJI
MocKBv
4

U

" JIHU, nOJIb30BaBmHxcH cHMnarlleii 3ananHoro Cocema一二
B e J I H KO r O K I I H 3 H J I H T O B c KO r O .
〆

E｣"-1497rrBeJIHK"lyK"3IoAJIeKcaHUpynoKJIoHb!

WW̲UeRe4aBa¥" oT HBaHq Ul H Cobbm214, Pe]Ke-ToJIbKooTM¥Halll(BHaIIaJIel496r"KorhamBAH"6皿eHe
"PWJIc""MocKBym3HoBroponcKorohoxbna)2I5rimJf6=

HbIEJIeHeHBaHOBIIeB3TOBPeMH皿川I,KaKnPaBIIJIo,oTHIIx
" BMaC l496 rEIIeHa noJIyLIHJIa, nAPMy̅6 mifeiMi:
MH HOKIJIOHaMII, nOKJIOH OT CBOeii くCHOxI" - BeJIHKOji KHRU

⑪

rmHII EJIeHbI Bo"omaHKI1 2'6, Ho B HIoJle l497 rmfji6H6f̅H6-

211HCPJI,T、yj,gP"T.Y!11,cT2230;]:XII,cTp241;T、20,nep-

212《."a
BaHnOJIOBIIHa,
HHM
c KHH3blOpbH，cblH
CTP、363;
ero，“BHyK
T､24,
cTP2''
28,
cTp.
213;
ero
KHHsb且MHTpe”
T.
fif;nHI'{
nM"rpeii"
WA
W",̲"
MW,k"s､
",̅'"
（口CPJIPPJI,2.26Lc[p.̲290;bPT､28,cTp.160;T.30,cTp、138;T.22,
｡

［1.1,CTp.512;C.O.mM1皿myKaaC",gTp270=271).

no34Hem"ZHTepnperaTOP̅c65ZiT[戒一CTelleHHaH
213
K"ra-npHMO
V"N¥eT: ,､fHa MocKBe >Ke ocTaBH cbIHa cBO"̅KA"̅Ba""
(nCPJI, T､21, "opaH IQJoEWa, cTp. 571) .

:li fC6PHO", T. 35, bTP 220, 235,'"
W IaM )Ke, cTp213: cp: crp 218
216 TaM >Ke, cTb. 223:

68

cTyⅡHJIHTOJIbKOOTPO瓜ⅡTeJIeh2'7.AJIeKcaHXpBI497r.orpaHHLIHBaJICH IIOKJIOHOM OIHOMy I'IBaHy lll 218.
Bce 3To cBHneTeJIbcTByeT, no-BH且HMOMy, O TOM, IITO
Co｡be B 1496 - HaIIaJIe l497 rr. y"JIocb no61ITbcH onPeneJIeHHoro noJIIITII[IecKoro npeo6JIaUaI-IIIH. AKTbl noKa3blBaIoT
I I H O B O e B O 3 B b l 皿 e H H e B a c l I J I I I H B I 4 9 6 - 1 4 9 7 r r. ( n o J I v I I e H l i e
，

ゾ

〆

IIM yneJIbHbIx II cyneOHblx nPaB B OTI-IOmeHIIII "na TePPIITO-

pHil) . BepoflTHo, cKpblTaFI 60pb6a Me班旦yくnaPTPIFIMII>>
Co巾bH - BaclIJIIIH II EJIeHbl-nMIITpIIH HocIIJIa B l4961497 rr. Kpaiille Hanpfl)KeHHblit xapaKTep, Ho MBaH III cHoco6cTBoBaJI (bopMaJIbHoM HeiiTPaJ1II3alUlli 9Tofl 60pb6bl, B
EIaCTHOCTII OH IIePeCTaJI ynOMIIHaTI．B瓜I"Il.IJIoMaTIILIecKIIx 4()L Q

KyMeHTaX IIMeHa CBOIIX CblHOBeH II BHyKa.

nePeMeHa HacTynaeT B HoH6pe l497 r. CnenHaJIbHblii nocblJIbHblih HBaHa lll, oTnpaBJTeHHblii ToJIbKo K EJIeHe liBaIIOBHe, nOJIIKeH 6blJI HePe八aTb nPHIleTCTBIIH B CJIenyIO皿e曲
oqePe皿ocTI1: noKJIoIIbl oT HBaHa lll, Cod)blI, E:meHbl BoJJomaHKII; noKJIoHbl oT neTeik l'IBaHa lll, 6paTbeB EJIeHbl,BacIIJIIIH, IOpHHm且MIITPHH; noKJIOH OT BHyKa BeJIH'Koro
KHH3H - KHH3兄且MIITplIR IIBaHoBIIwa; [IeJIoI61ITbH oT Io[Iepe曲HBalHa ll l, cecTep EJIeHbl,- |BeJIHKIIx KHH>KoⅡ①eX|o cb}I

H ABppTbpI 219. B UeJIoM TyT 3aMeTeH Bo3BpaT K IlepeMoHHaJIy l495 r., I-Io cblHoBbR I1 BHyK HocTaBJIeHbl Ha 60JTee Bbl,coKyIo cTyneHb II|ePaPxHH, IIeM PaHbme (OT HIIx "yT He [IeJIO6HTbH, a noKJIoHbl) , BHyK )Ke ynoMIIHaeTcH, B oTJIIIqHe oT
aBryCTOBCKOrO PaCnHCaHmHl495 r., Xo BeJIPIKHx KH"KoH.
CJIeXoBaTeJIbHo,

aHaJIH3

"InJIoMaTI1|IIecKoii

npKVMeHTaUHII

nO3BoJIHeT rOBOPHTb O HaJIIIIIHHKOcBeHHblx nPlI3HaKOB BO3-

BbI皿ellHFI nMIITPlIFI-BHyKa BO BTOPOhnoJIoBIIHe l497 r.
no J1eToHIIcHM Bo3BblmeHIie nMIITPlM-BHyKa flcHo Ha6JIIozIaeTcFI y>Ke B aBrycTe l497 r. OHPIcblBafl BcTpeqy B 3Ti)

BI)eMFI B MocKBe pFI3al-IcKo曲BeJIIIKoi KHFImHII AHHbl, pfLI
cBoIoB yKa3bIBaeT: <<KHFI3b >Ke BeJIIIKblii cTpeTHJI ee LiecTH()
BeJI MH…CO BHyKOM H 3 meTMII II 3 60JIHPbl, TaKO>K,me H BeJIHKafl KHFIMHFI Co*IIH II c HeBecTKoIo c BeJIHKoIo KHHrHHelo

EJIeHoIo II c 60JIHpbIHHMII> 220. nocKoJIbKy BHyK ynoMFIHyT
U

paHbme neTGH II BeJIIIKIIX KHflrIIHb, MO>KHO myMaTb, rlTO OH B

aBrycTe l497 r. cToHJI 6JIIDKe BcEx K BeJIHKoMy KIIH310.
217 TaM IKe, cTP. 236.
21s TaM >Ke, CTp. 227, 232.
2'9 TaM >{<e, cTp. 239.

220 ncP几T､1V, q. 1, Bbln. 2, cTp. 535; T. VI, cTp. 42-43, 241; T. V111,
cTp. 234; T. XII, cTp. 245; T、20, nel)BaFI noJIoBIIIIa, cTl). 366; T. 28!
cTp. 329-330 .
69

3．no入ⅢT皿酊eCKIIe
nPlIKIIIHHB矼月aH皿丞a入oBaHHHx
II yKa3HBIx rPaMOT

nOcMOTPHMcTOIIKPI3PeHHHBblFICHeHHblx｡aKTOBHaO6cTaHoBKy, B KoTopoih 6blJIH BblnaHDI rpaMoTbI 1493 r. o npoBo3e xJIe6a KHp"JIo-BeJIo3epcKoTo II TpoIIUe-CeprlIeBa MoHacTblpeit. rpaMoTa KHpHJIJIo-BeJIo3epcKoMy MoHacTLIpIo
noHBIIJTacb B MapTe l493 r., Kornta 6JIII3HJIacb K KoHUy 60JIbmaH Pa60Ta no 3aKPem1eHHIO BeJIOO3ePa B cOcTaBe BeJIIIKoKHH)KecKoro noMeHa. B 3To BpeMH BacIIJI" 6blJI oTTyna, noBm瓜HMoMy, y>Ke oTo3BaH H roToBwIcFI K Hoe3ntKe B TBepb.

HaMepeHHe nocJIaTb BacIIJIIIH B TBepb - 3eMJIIo, cMe>KHylo c
ymeJIOM KHFI3H BoJIOHKorO, -- nP lI3BeCTHOii CTeneHII BcKPbl-

BaeT xapaKTep onaceHIIii l'IBaHa lll. npeTeH3HH BoplIca BoJoHKOrO MorJIII KacaTIJcH H PocToBa - I-IacJIemm兜旦MHTPOBcKOTOKHH3H.BOPHcnoJIb30BaJICHImeiiHo曲 ⅡOユユe p>KKO曲
HocH1)aBoJIoUKoro22!I1,Bo3Mo)KHo,KaKHocJIenHmiryn<eJ1bHblii KHH3b - pocToBcKoro apxIIemIcKona TIIxoHa. B

cBoIo

oIIepemb TPIxoH Haxo,nmJIc兄B KoHTaKTe c KIIpIMJIo-BeJIo3epCKHM MOHaCTb叩eM. B FIHBape l493 r. oH ocBo60LIIJI KHpHJIJIOBcKIIx cBHmeHHHKoB OT IHaTyPaJIbHblXHⅡeHe>KHblxⅡOcTa-

BOK 6eJIo3ePcKOMy necHTIIHHIIKyH瓜aH皿HKy 222.

3ana'Ia HBa'Ha lll cocToHJIa B ToM, IITo6bl nPHBJIeIIb
KHpHJIJIoB MoHacTblpb Ha cBoIo cTopoHy lI TeM yKpenHTb
l皿eiiH0-HoJIHTIILIecKHe IIO31Iu班I BeJIIIKO'KI-IH)KeCKOii BJIaCTII B
PocToBcKoi enapxHH. 3necb vMecTHo BblcKa3aTI] e皿eHcJIe-

nylo皿ee coo6pa]KGHHe: JIHmeHHe BacHJIIIH B KoHUe l491 r.
IIPaB KHH3fI TBePcKOrO nOcTaBHJIO noU COMHeHHe meihcTBH-

TeJIbHOCTb erO nOHTBeP皿TeJIbHO面Ⅱo皿HcH l490/91 r. Ha

rpaMoTe l486 r. 0 6ecnomJIHHHoM npoe3nle ToproBLIx 3KcHe皿Ⅱ砿KHPmJIJIO-BeJIo3epcKOro MoIiacTblPH. 9TO HaHOCHJIO
cepbe3Hbli ylUep6 MaTepHaJIbHblM IIHTepecaM MoHacTbl"
II HacTpaIIBaJIo ero He B IIoJIb3y BeJIHKoro KHFI3H. TaKIIM

O6Pa30M, KaK Pa3PemeHI1e6eCnOmJIIIHHOrO nPOBO3a XJIe6a
B rPaMoTe MapTa l493 r., TaK II oTnpaBKa BacHJIwI B TBepb
B anpeme l493 r. BxoIHJIII B IIIIcJIo neiicTBHih, KoTopble
〆

JLOJI>KHbl Obl川I yCnOKOHTb KIIPHJIJIOBCKIIX CTaPUeB.

HonpenpcTABJIGHIIGBacIiJTMIIoByneJIKamlIHaTpe60Ba-

JIo OT BeJIHKorO KHH3FI H H3BecTHoii nePecTPaxOBKH: cocenH" PocTOB CJIenoBaJIo KPenKo neP>KaTb B CBoIIx PyKax,
22' fl．C･JI y P b e. nOCJI3H}Ie Bem,Mo>Ke l'IOamy C cMePTI.Y KWfI3fI.一
くSIavia>, XXVII/2, 1958, cTI). 222-223.
222 AC311, T. 11, M 291.
70

oco6elIHo npII HeycTonIIIIBocTH ye3IHblx rl)aHIIU B To BI)GMH

(HeUapoM BHocJIencTBHH, npH IIepeXa'Ie KamIIHa B ynem
IOpHIo HBaHoBHIIy, KanIHHcKIIii ye3m 6blJI cnenHaJIIJHcLoTMe>KeBaH oT PocToBa 223I HaKoHeU, Bo皿blii nyTb H3 FIpocJIaBJIFJ B KIIpHJTJIoB MoHacTbIpb npoxo皿JI MHMo yrJI皿Koro
ye3na. TaKIIM o6pa30M, rJTaBI-IflFI JIeJIb BblUaIIH rPaMoTbl 3a○

KJIIOIIaJIacb B yKPenJIeHIM BeJIIIKoKH)DKecKIIx nO3HUlIII Ha He4aBHO nPHCOemIHeHHblX II CHOPHblX 3eMJIFIX.

rpaMoTa HBaHa lll TpoHue-CeprlieBy MoHacTblpIo HoHBHJI3cb B nteKa6pe l493 r., IIepe3 MecHU nocJIe cMepTII AIImpefl yr.mHIIKoro. K 3ToMy BI)eMeHI'I y>KG co Bcei'I onpeUeJIeIIHocTblo BblFIBwIacb TaKTIIKa BoPmca BoJIoUKoI､o­叩e )K Je

Bcero ero cTpeMJIGHHG HaiiTII oITopy B TI)oI皿KOM MOHaCTblPe.
BeJIIIKHii KHH3b cIIeJI ueJTecoo6pa311bIM IIpllHFITb KoHTpMepbl

BHanpaBJIeHIIMc6JIH)KeHH兄C3TI,IMKPynHeiimHMnyXOBHblM
(beonaJIoM Heo6xo皿Mo o6PaTIITb BHIIMaHHe Ha oHIIO IOIioJIHIITeJIblloe o6cToHTeJIbcTBo. B KoHne

l493 r. HBaH III,

no-BI{"IMoMy, oTo3BaJI cBoero cbIHa H3 TBepH II JIIImHJI ero
＝

IIPaB

KHH3fl

KamIIHCKorO,

IITo

Obmo

nPaKTIIIIecKIL PaBHO-

3HallHo oTMeHe noHTBe皿HTeJIbHBIx nOnnHcei BacHJIHFI
1492/93 r. K rpaMoTaM HBaHa mBaHoBIwa, KacaBmIIMcH KamHHcKIIx BJIameHIIii TpoHUe-CeprHeBa MoHacTblpFI, Bbmaqa
rPaMoTbl O HeB31JMaHHII nomnmH C TPOImKOrO BOTIIHHHorO

xJIe6a noJI>KHa 6blJIa B KaKok-TO MePe o|rPaHI'ILIIITb HenoU

BOJIbCTBO MOHaCTblPCKHX BJIaCTeII aKUHFIMH BeJIHKOrO KHH3H

B l492/93 r. IIBaH III yZIeJIFIJI BI{IIMaHIIe TaK)Ke MocKoB-

cKOMy qynPBy MOHaCTblPlo, XOTH KOHKPeTHble巾OPMbl ero
⑪

nOJI HTIIKmⅡO OTHOmeHHIo K 3TOH KOPmOPanIIII II3-3a OTCyr-

cTBMFI coxpaHIIBmllxcFI HcToqHHKoB I,I3y[IIIT6 TpynHo. B oHI1cH Ka3Hbl llynoBa MoHacTblpfl l755 r. ynoMIIHaeTcR《pO3be3>KafI CeMeHa... ToBapKoBa c. JIymKoB 3 nep. npynH皿eM
B. KII. HB BacHJIbeBHIIa, 7001 ToJly>p 224. MecToHoJIo)KeHI,le

CeJIa JIy>KKOB He yCTaHOBJIeHO 225HHTePeCHo, IITO maHIIaFI
(LIynPBy MOHaCTbIPIO?) Ha C. JIy>KKH OTHOCIiTCH TQJIbKO K
7015 (1506/07) r. 226 JIy>KKm, npmo6peTellHble B 7015 r" HaxQmIJMcb B cT"e Cypo>KIIKMocKoBcKoro ye3" 227. He BHoJI̲
223 n11mr, Nb 93.
224 AC31I, T、111, JVb 48a, cTp. 73, rp. 367.
225 TaM )Ke, cTp. 604.

226 TaM >Ke, Nb 48a, cTp. 73, rp. 515.
227 B 6. K o 6 p li H. .nBe >kaJIoBaHHble rpaMoTbI IIyXoBy MoHacTHpIo
(XVI B).­く3amlcKII oTneJTa pyKomIceii rocyllapc'IBeHl･Ioii 6H6JIII0TeKII IIM' B H JIelIIIHa", BbII1. 25. M., 1962, cTp. 295,
71

Ue HcHo, HA""X nP"ax BJIan<eJI IIynOB MOHaCTbIPb aTIIM

WOMmo1M/07EyCaBBo-CTQpoxieBcKoroMoHabTbIpHB
70-xroJaxXVB.6bmo
ceJIII皿eJIy皿KHB3BeHHrOPoncKoM
ye3ne228(HapmCTpe229?)nPHMBIXmaHHblXm"bT5ME
PJBJIeH" J[Iy>KKoB (JaBBo-CTopo)KeBcKoro MOHacTbI" c

JIy>¥KaMHJIynoBaMOHacTbIPHfIeT,HOcJIegyeTOfMMTE
KpamHIo!96JIII30cTbLcTaHa
Cypo)KIiK
3BeiimroponcKOMy
K
ye"y Cypo]KKK 6bIJ] pacndro]KeH no cpenHeMy
ｰ Tetle"b
P・HCTPblHeenPWPKgpHr2aHHIIHJICO3BeHHrOPOncKIIMII
U

3eMJIHMji c ceBep a 230.EcJIII JIy)KKII,ynoMHHyTbI6 8 bnHcII
Ka3HbI IIynoBa MoHaCTbI", Ha)fomIIJmcL B 1492/93 rB3Be-

"oponcKoM̲ye3nle(a3ToBnoJIHeBo3Mo>KHo,iI60rpaH皿bl

Me)K9y nopy6ey<HblMII cTaHaMH oTJIHqaJIIIcb" Kpaiilfeii HeU

妙

U

ycTOHIIHBocTbIO)
B
aKTe
, Pa3be31a
Mo)KHO
B皿eTb
nPOHBJIeHHeHoJImTHKH，HanPaBJIeHHoH
HHe
HoJIIITHKH, HanPaBJIeHHoi Ha
Ha3aKPeⅡJIeHHe
3aKPenJIeHHe BBCOcTaBe
COcTaBe BeJIIIKQ[o
KHH>KeH" TePPHToPHi,
BXOZIIB
JIHKoro KHH>KeHHH
Tep”TopHH，Bxo瓜HBmHx
B yn<eJI AHn-

peH ym皿Koro (3BeHIiropo瓜ⅡpHHa皿e>KaJI K IIx IIHcJIv) .

rllaM912'､6bmaBbImaHa
MejKIy.ceHTHqpeM
1492
IT̅̅M:
f
ゾ

ノ

cToM1493r.,T.e・瓜ocMePTHAHnpeHyrJIHnKoro231.

nonblTKa
BeJIHKorO
KIIH3H
3aPyIJHTbcH
nO瓜及ep>KKoi
qy-

JIOBaMOHac2blPH,TeCHOCBH3aHHorOcHoBrOPOn6KHMaPXiI-

eⅡHcKoIIOM
reHHamfeM,
HBJ1FIBmlIMC卯Ⅱ0
1484
r・IIynPBCKII
M
apXIIMaHIlpmTOM232,
OTLIaCTI!
OnPem-IaCb,
nO-BMIIMOMy;
228 AC31M, T. 111, Nb 59a.

229 TaM>Ke,cT2604.Hapy6e>Ke XV-XVIBB.HMeJIocbemeBeJIHKo-

WIH"cK"
JIy)KcKoeb
l)adloJIo)Keihoro-Po6MFI65
paiioHe
ceJIo
B
6bm
peKII
roperoBcKMii
roi]eToBKm
(ACOm7Tf̅mJVb
cTaH50) 6v"
Nb50)・ropeToBcKlmcTaH6bml〕acⅡoJIo>KeHIoro-PocTo咄ee Cvpo旦
一
u

〉 K H K a

230 B.H.n e 6 0 F E c K II ii.nyxoBHblelinioroBopHblerpaM,oTbIMoc-

I"cKMx KIJ23eji､ KaK ｣IcTol)IIKo-reorpa｡IIqecKMIji ̅HcTo[IHiiK, [11 Cn6"
1901, cTp.̲ 15, 19 11 96mafi !<apTa B. K6"e KHnrli; 10．roTbe. 3aMocKcIpIIWi Kpaii PB̲
▽XVII BeKe M., 1906, cTp 578; E L C T a m e EU

CKIIii̲MocKoBCKIfiiye3ユⅡoHHcUoBblMKHIIraMXVI
B.KHeB,
1907,
K a l ) Ta B K O H U e K H H r I I .

23!
gWria,JIyiKKI13B9WPPOnc¥IIM
cbJIOM,M1'!OTHOCI1Mrl)aMOTyKOCeHI! 1492 - Ha[laJIy l493 r" !16o nocJle ll mIBapH 1493 f 3BeiIIIfob67I
figq "Mi! nUUllW" "JUPM<a"Q"IJ TaTal)CkPMy niaPeBIIqy A6-

"IJI-JIeTImy (HCP几TJV. Cnq:L l848, crp. 162; ̅T. VI, cTi. 39,

240; T、24, cTp. 211 ; T. 28, cTp. 158, 323; B p"e JIETonHcefi ll B& xpo4
HOrPa*e cOO6皿aeTcH ToJIbKo o JTpIIe3nte A64bm-JIeT"a, Ho yMaJIMgaeTc3,､9 no>Kaj"aHIIILeMy 3BeMmropona: nCPJI, ̅T. V111; cTp.
225; T. XII, cTp. 235; T、20,JIePBa" noJIoBHHa, cTp. 358-359; T. 22,
cTp. 509; T. 27, cTp. 293, 363;《ncKoBcKHeJIeTomIcl,【》, BLIn. 11. no"
pe瓜．A. H. HaCQJIOBa. M., 1955, cTp、252-253; C. 0. m M H Z T.
u

△

yKaa co"., cTp. 266) .

232 !" 6bm B Wy"Be MOHaCrblPe al]xIIMaHmPlIToM MeﾝKnv
〃l484 ]1
1501 rr., B nllTepaType lle ycTaWoBJIdHo. n. M.CT.poGB, a 3a llHM II
72

ocJIa6JIeHIIeMno31m"MIITponoJIHTa30cHMbl.npoTHBonteii-

cTByH
y瓜eJIbHblMnPHTH3aHHHM，HBaH
yneJIbHbIMnPHTH3aHMHM,HpaHIIIBKaKOirTO
KaKOH-TO
BIII
MgRe
MePe
HcKaJIno皿eP]KKIrllPenCTaBIITeJIeii."IIHCIPylO皿eiiHoclI｡U

JIHHCKOIInePKBH・no)KaJIoBaHIieB1493r、3Bel-IHroponaTaTapcKoMy lfapeBIiqy A61bIJI-JIer"y ObIJIo BbI3BaHo, no-BIi"MoMy,. cTp6MJIeHileM HBaH4 111 HeiiTpaJIIi30BaTb npeT"311H BOpHca BoJIoUKoro IIJIII BacIIJI" Ha 3Ty IIacTb yrJIImU

劃

U

KO r O I I a c J I e n c T B a .

OT 1494-'1495 rr. H'e coxpaHHJIocb IIMMyHHTeTHblX rpa-

MIOTHBaHalll・3ToHoKa3bIBae'T,IITocMepTbBopHcaBoJIoUKoTo B Mae l494 r. cMHrIIIIJIa o'60cTpeHHocTb BHyTpHⅡo皿ITH-

556kdMciITvaumlilino3BoJImJIaBeJmKoMyKHH3IoHenpm6eraTb
K
TPa血皿oHHblM
CHoCO6aM
nO皿THIIecKoTO
MaHeBPIIPOU

Ba,HH月．

E1496 rmBaH III no>KaJIoBaJI HoBoro MIITponoJIIITa CH-

MoHa233,3aHHBmeroKa｡enpyBceHTH6pel4951LBMecTo
cBeUeHHbrocMIITponoJIIiqberonpecToJla30cIIMbLHocBoeMycontep>KaHHIorpaMoTal496FTecHonpmMbIKaeTKrpaM6TaMl493 rB Heih HBaH III 3anpe皿aeT cBOHM MblTIIHKaM

B31IMaTbMbITcMIITponoJ1H[Ibeipbl6bl̲(o"Tb-TaKHE皿ⅡpoU

"KToRoipeHTbl)hpoRo3MMoik
,
H3IIepenoBIja¥<MocKBe]

a TaK>Ke C JIIOUem, ConPoBo係,ⅡalO皿IIx 3Ty Pbl6y. B rpaMoTG
Ⅱo"epKHBaeTcH, qTo 6ecnomJIHHHocTb npoe3na rapaHTHU

PyeTCHJIHmbeCJlH《TOBaPycHHMHHe6yneTHIIKaKOBa,
onpmqbpbl6bl"HMeeTcHmcaHKUnfI:<<acToBapy6bI̲ecTg

HomJIIIHy HMaJIII)'. CJIenpBaTeJIbHo, B laHHoM cJIyrlae, KaK II
B l493 r., cTpeMJIeHHe BeJIHKoro KHH3H K coIo3y c BJIHflTeJIbHeimHM HePaPxoM He nPHBOnHT K皿eXpOMy lIMMyHIITeTHoMV HO)KaJIoBaHHIO,
ご

B onIIcII Ka3HbI IIynoBa MoHacTbIpfI 1755E.ylIoMMHaeTca

>KaJ1oBaHHaH rpaMoT3 HBaHa III 7004 (1495/96) r., "To6
KopMy
He且aBaTb》234.Mo〉KeT6blTb，rpaMoTa6blJIa
Hecy皿{U

｡

MOii, ConeP>KaBmeii cTaTblo o HeynJIaTe. HaMeCTHHIIberO KopMa, HJIH 3anoBenHoit, Pa3PemaBmeH He XaBaTb KopM
⑪

II.

A.

roJIy6noB

cLIIITaJIII

HeIEE"THIJM

IIMH

KIynoBcKoro

apxHMa"-

plITa, Halfa3aHHQro B 1487/88 r. 3a no皿e.JIKy npKyMeHTa
U

U

(n.u C T p o e B. CIIIpl<II ̲"2apx9B JLHaf""eJIeI!､MoHaCTblW WcHMcKoHⅡepKBH. Cn6., 1877, ̅cT6. 162; ACSH, T、111, cTp. 652). Cou

⑪

rJIacHoEpMoJIIIHcKoMycnmcKyEPMQJIHHcKoiimeTo'ⅡHcIIperO3BaJIH
⑪

MaKapHeim (nCPJI, Tr 23, cTp: 162) . OcTaaaJIcH̲ JIII MaKapmii Ha cBo風

eM ndcTy B､ 1492/93 ru ̲CKagaTJz̲TIlY"9 B 14ag n aRMMa皿皿TOM

6MiJf"6 ｡eorHo'6T (ACSZ, T: III,̅Nb 48a, grP 73, rp 73) .
233 A3IIX, q. I, Nb 292;几B q e P e ll H H H. yka3. coq., [J. 2, cTp, 224.
234 AC3II, T. 111, Nb 48a, cTI)､73, rl). 365.
73

'e310Ka
M・B2BCHKOM
CJIyqaC,
Cy"
nO
ee
3arOJIOBKy,
enBa
WW"
"eJMCI¥PrCTyriJIEH"
6T
OCHOBIiOfO̅ky"巾HHaHCOBOPI HOJIHTHKJI HBaHa lll.
U

IJW"""eMoTIIBb!Bhma"rPaMoTh!!496EMIITpo-

W"bg"X49MyyramblBaIOTCHnPirconocTaBJ1eHIiHTePP"④

IQW,J<KoTOjlbIMOHaoTHQp"acb,cOCqJePoiiBJIHHHIIHkilfI｡

22 BacIIJI" HBaHo"LIa rpaMoTA "jetbMM."". yifゾ

"Becb, na Ha̲ycTb-mexcHbl, na Ha 7cTb-MoJIorII・瓜a Ha

yrJIeIIb,"BKa皿",naHaycTb-ny6Hbl,naBnMHTPOB
MbITmHKoM BceM)'. noKyMeHT naTIIp6BaH 9 MIoJIH! Han6Mg
UIIM, [ITo HMgeTcFI cBII4eTeJIbcTBo Map'ra l496 rp noIIBeJIoM-

gWWWLBOlIWWMIICKOrO je3ma 235JIO4TE"〈且eH-

"i̲BacwmgM B !490/91 n rpaMjra l486 K̅MEMMi

"Tblo,me(bHKCHI]OBanacbTfIMo)KeHHaHKOMneTemiIHE:
¥JIFI rPaMoTb! B oTHomeHIIIi ､<ycTb-my6Hb" 236. yrJIIIIi li

IIMlirP9¥-3ToHenaBHlley4cJIIilbleil5HT";y6rbm&GH6i
li ycTb-Mo"grli - MeCTa B ̅ npeqe"ax 6bIimer6̅yrmk6iS

WW"LI3KliMo6pa30M,rpaMoTaKacajIacbreppmT6M
U

Kyna BxO皿JIII, BO-nePBblx, PeaJIbIIaFI c巾ePa BJIHHHIIH KHH3fl

E"W̲̲IMQBmqa (KammH, ycrbZi"ar56:ET5M

BblMopoIIHoeymeJIbHoeHacJIencTBo.OqeBH瓜Ho,npHxoIK

UepXoBHoMy
pyKoBoJcTBy
CIIMoHa
(6bIB皿ero
IIryMeHa
TpoHn;e-CepEHeBaMoHacTbl")

KHH3FI BacHJIIIfl HBaHoEIIila.

3HaIIIITeJIbHO

ycIIJIHJI

HO3H"III

EcJIHB1493-1494rr.BacHJIHHnOCymeCTBVJIIImHJICH
E" TepPHrop"", Mo>KeT ObITb, JIIImb rioJIy[IIIJf cyne6Hblc
U

U

npaBa B paihoHax PocToBa PI Bopli-Kop3eHeB4 To no(IfIIM=
3ynocJ1enocTaBJIeH”CHMoHaoHcHa可aJIa6bIJIocTaBJIeiB

MocKBe,no-BIInliMoMyBpoJ1IiconpaBIE11T̅56JMM."k#ff
u

rHHH, 3aTeM cneJIaJIcH 叩OCJIaBCKHM <rOCynlaPeM)D, BIIOBb

nplIo6peJInpaBaHaKa皿IIH̲IIT.n;,BsTHxycJIoBHHxBblna-

IIarpaMoTblMHTponoJIHTyCHMoHyonpe瓜eJ1HJIacbcTpeMJIe-

"eM̲HqaHaCBH3arb̅
!II
MaTePm3JIbHLlemITeP65bfM65U

兵

noJIHIIbeihKaqJempb[c3aliHTePEcoBaHHocTbIoB"VKPenJiEM!
ge"KoKIIH)KQpKoji BJIacTII B Toii o6"acTI1, KoTopiH ̅6blJIa oT｡

IIaCTII
C巾ppMRJIHHH",
oTqacTII
o6'beKToM
Bo3Mo>KHbIx
npm［B

TH3aHI,IH HO旦瓜ep>KIIBaGMoro nepKoBI,Io KHFI3H BacHJIHH HBaHOBHIIa、

IITOKacaeTcHrPaMoTblqy40ByMOHacTblPlo,ToeeBblnaU

KI4, BePQHTHO,P3HaqaJ1a HOBbIii mar nO JIIIHIIH KOHTaKTIIDO,

▲

235 ACSH, T. 111, M 163

236 TaM ]Ke, T. I1, JYh 271
74

BaHllmcnl]OrelIHa"eBcKOMKQPnoPaUmeii-Ha9TPTW̲W
f

p

6a3bl 《ⅡPHnBOPHOHnapTHH>>

⑥

CyJKeHmRnOJIm'1,liLIecKoH

Coq)bH-B acIIJIHH.

B HHBape l497 rmBaH III BbIna4nBe )KaJIoBaHI"JM

MOTbl:nH)Mi､613HMHa
HXCeJIOBPOCTOBCKOMye34e237!{
yfmKOMV
HOKPOBCKOMy
MOHaCTbIPlO
238.
nO
COmel)>KaHml9
,

nO>KaJiOBaif" O6e rPaMOTb[ He OTCTynaIOT OT [IPHHfITblX

HBaHOM
nPIIHUlinOB
III
IIMMylIMTeTHOII
nOJIHTIIKH・B
rpaMoU

Te
nlIJIbeMOBblM
(しHKCHPOBaJIcfl
TOJIbKO
Cyme6HblhHMMyH
IITeT. nPaBna, II3 IIx IoPmC且HKIIMIH He 6blJIa HCKJIIOIIeHa TaTb-

6a, Kak aTo [lacTo JIeJIaJIocb paHbme B rpaMoTax ppeTcKMX

IM5Maif̅BMM6fe noK"ncKoMy ｣""2,o̲IW[ ､!!!
ⅡO"8eP4MJI
ycfaHOBJIeHI10e
4H4PeeM
BOJIb皿HM
IIPaBO
MO･

llacTblPiI Ha ioJIyIIeHIle l3 py6JIeih li3 yFJIImKIIx TaMo)Kel-IHblx
U

AOx()10B.
JIerKO
nOHflTb,
noKIeMy
TflKOHⅡoPmlOK
Be皿eii
6bl,JI
npHeMJIeM皿HBeJIHKoroKHfl3fLKorAa-To
("TaBrPaMOTe

MMMidyBacmJImi TeMublii Pa3pcmlIJ] Mo"TI>LllUm
u

<ⅡVnPBOrOBeca)>
(B皿ⅡomJIHHbl3aB3Be皿I1BaHHeTOBapOB)

B yrJIIIIle 3Ta nPHBHJIerlIH AeJ1aJIa MOHaCTblpb xo3FIIIHoM
IIOJIO)KeHHFI, nPemCTaBHTeJIeM BJIaCTII Ha yrJIIInKOM PblHKe,

He roBopfl y>KG o ToM, qTo o6ecne[IIIBaJI4 eMy HeKql{TpWZ
U

WeMbIenPjtoUpL
BePOfITno,
B
ycJIOBmfIx
(PeOWWiBgW
MMfPeTMXVn"3ToTmar̅BeJIIIKoroK"3HIjMelloJILU

U

mOenOJIHTHIIecKOe3HaLIeHMe,nPeBPa皿aflHOKPOBCKmHMo-

HacTbIPb B nocJIeAoBaTeJIbHOro CToPOHHIIKa MOcK9"9I9
nPaBIITeJIbCTBaB yrJIHLIex "JIHBmeMCHOIIHMM̲E W9IO2
rAJIHUKIIx KHH3ei AHnpei BoJIbmoii, noJIyqIIBm城yrJIPIII B
U

VUeJI, ecTecTBeHHo, He 6bIJI 3amHTepecoBaH B coxpaHeH1III "
3aBIitHMoii poJIm
3aBHCHMOII
POJIIInOKPOBCKorO
noKpoBcKoro MoIEcTblpH
MOHaCTbl”II H
oTMeHHJ!
OTMeHIiJI3Ty
3TY
⑥

nPHB"erHId IIBaH III, KoToPoMy yrJIIIII nPHHallJIe>KaJI c

l491r. Ha npaBaxくOT"Hbl>', He liMeJI OCI-IOBaHIIiI BO3PO>KnaTb
TaMO)K6HHylO
neHTeJIbllOCTb
nOKPOBcKOrO
MOHaCTblPH.
MoHacTblpb, B cBoIo oIIepe", enBa JIII Mor HaneHTbcH Ha
TaKoi nobopoT B cBoeii cymb6e m,̲cKopee, onacaJIcH oTMeHL!
U

ⅡpII
HoBoM
Tocynape
Ha3Ha[leHHoii
eMy
AHJpeeM
KoMneHcaUIIM 3a nPe>KHIOIO nPllBIIJIeEIIIO.

E̅llebenmcHoiikmlireBglloro4cKoroKopluIJIIIeBa｡lWg
MeJIbcKoIbMoHacTblpfll676r．ynoMHHaeTcHnon7005
(1496/97) r. ､<rocy4aPeBa?MBalla lll?) >KaJIoBa"""⑭

MoTa, coneP>KaHHe KOToPOii II3JIo)KeHO B TPex cJIoBax: <<ToP-

267 TaM )Ke, T. I, Nb 611.
23H TaM JKe, T. 111, Nh 81.
75

FWIWMIU96e3noU"HHo)>2"̲y9mTbIBa206uUiiKypcTaU

Mo)KeHHoHHoJIHTHKH90-xronpBXVB.,H3BeCTHOIIHOCOXDaHHBHIIIMcH rPaMOTaM, Mb[ BnPaBe ycOMHHTbCfI B ToIIHO6Tm
U

』

ZepenaVl conep>KaH" rpaMoTbI nepenIIcHoih KHIIroh. OIHaU

I9""aKTBbInaqmrPaMoTbI(nPOb3)KemOTHfi3MMM【

9

ケ

RPII̲JIyqTbIHII yKa3aHLIIO-B"IIMOMy, nPaBIIJIbHO.nO iaHHbIM

MWWiHbKoro, KopH"mcB MUIE"MEiJfMSM̅;

L"r249M"4yTeMBiKmTHHKopH皿HFIcKa3aHo:<<BJIeTo

Zq09r90495"-Q K) npm"6 6"<EMM<6MM
MK""" "ec, 6e 66 T6r"Henpoxomn! M8M

XPaMHHyPa360池H哩eCKyHBCeJIHCHBHIO,HHaLIFITOTPe6JIRTH

MeCTO
TO>
241.EcmｲoCUOBaH"KoPHIIJIIleBa
MoHacTbiPfI
nPOH30mJIoMe)Kny̲SgXrH6peMl496maBrycToMl497r""Toibl-

瓜aIJyrpaMoTbl7005r，BepoHTHee
oTHecTH
Kl497r.，IIeM
K

KoHUyl496 r.

II9qeliyBHaqaJIel497rmMMyHMTeTHaHnoJIHTHKaHBa" Ul o6paWach B cTopoHy Po6ToBa, yr""̅IMMM-

Ho,BoJIor且blP

nPe>Kne
BCero
Heo6xo八IIMO
OTMeTI1.rb
yCTOIMLIIIBblii
nJ1fI
U

T J

U

WWWKeg<oH noJIMTHKm l496-1497 m IIHTepec K paii『
J

OHy
6blB皿ero
yWJImUKOrO
KHHxiecTBa:
cTPeMineHme&o"ef"
¥"̲"､caMbIH BJIIIHTe/IbHblii MecTHblii MoHacTbIP6 (nO⑪

KPOBCK")
Ha
II KPynHeHmIIXJ{yxOBHblx
(1)eonaJIOB
UelITPa,

gWaHHbl)Lc aTHM KpaeM JIII60 TpaH3mToM (MHTponoJII14mii
noM) , JIH60 3eMJIeBJIanleHHeM
(Tpo皿e-CeprlIeB MoHaL ､

gblpb242)yqMTbIBaH,qTOBcqJePy､BimmuiiHKIMIEa6皿皿

HBaHoBIIqaB1496-1497rr.bxb皿nHKallmHcK"nepe,I
U

U

cJIaBJIb-3aJJeg""ye3Xbl,oKpy>KaBmﾙIeyrJII皿KIIHye34C
q4,rmqToIWr=3ToBpeMHHapacTaHIiflKoHdJMMKTAM6>K:
mylIBaHoMIIIHBacHJIII6M,Mo)KiIonpeユnOJIO)KHTbHaJIIIIIHe
U

｡

np eTeH3HHⅡOcJIeAHero Ha BblMOPOIIHoe yrJIImKOe HacJIemU

CTBO-nPeTeH3WI, OIIeBHJHO, nOユユeP>Kal-IHblx B BblCIHHx
UePKoBHbIX KPyraX.

gpHTH3aH" Bac-I Kacamicb, no-BMHMoMy, He ToJII,-

KO yrJIHIIa, HO H cOcemHerO P()cTdBa, r" MdJI6Xoi̅ IMSb
HeKoTOPOeBPeMFIBenaJI3eMeJII,HblMH瓜eJIaMM.KToMy>Ke,
U

239 r,HB, Q. 1V, Nb 395, n. 85.
349 3BepmHcKIit, T. 11, cTp. 187, JYb 884.
⑭

241rEJI,Tpo皿K.CO6p.
(中.304),JVb676,J1.513;H.y.ByXoBHmU.

MOHacrbiPmHaPyC"̅OPph"cmIMIiKpe6TE;IIi̅EXIV­二XVIBeKax

（noく]KHTHHMCBHTLIX>).M・,1966,cTp.281-282.

242
IIIoJIe
B l497
r・nO
rPaMOTe
HBaHa
oCy皿eCTBJIf!,IICJI
lll
!3a3'be3n
TpO･
MllWmffM | ReJIIIKoKHH>KecKIIx 3eMellb B Be>KellKoM Belixe (AC9H,
．1，. 1, M 613).
〃
76

cMe>KIIblM c PocToBoM KamIIIIcK" ye31 Bxo皿JT B cQ)epy
B"HfIHIIfl

BacIIJIwI・BecbMa

rloKa3aTeJIbHo

To,

Ha

KoM

H3

pocToBcKIIx *eonaJIoB ocraHoBIIJI cEpii Bbl60p ligaH III npm
Eblna[Ie mMMyHIITeTHoii rPaMOTbL 3TO 6bIJ]H nHJIbeMoBbl-

Ca6ypoBbl, BETBb Tex caMblx Ca6ypoBblx, KoTopblM HBaHIII
U

HOBePflJI HacTOJIbKo, IITo 3a nOJIToPa MecHna no cBoeH CMepTH )KellHJI Ha nPencTaBHTeJIbHIIUe IiX Pona cBOerO y>Ke Ha-

3Ha[lelll-Ioro BeJIIIKHM KIIfl3eM cblHa BacHⅡHf1．

O Bo3Mo)KHblx nPeTeH3Hflx BacHJIHH Ha BblMopoIIHble

ymeJIbHble TePPlIToPHMI ToBoPIIT nePena[Ia I/IBal-IOM III B yne1I
MyXaMMen-3MHIIy (CBePrHyTOMy Ka3aHCKOMy xaHy, KOTOPblji nOJIyIIIIJI nPHIOT B POCC皿) CepnyxoBa !1 XoTyHP[ (B Mae
l497 r) 24a B八oroBopax I'IBaIIa lll l486 r. c BopIIcoM BoJIoUKHM II A皿PeeM yrJIIiUKIIM.<瓜MIITPoB, PocToB, MenLIHb,
CepnoxoB, XoTyHb)> (I)lirypHpyloT B KaIIecTBe paiioHoB, HBJIHBmHxcfl HacJIencTBoM IOpmfl II npeAcTaBJIflBmHX,BH且HMO,

o6beKT ymeJIbHblx npHTH3aHHi. BHHMaHHe K yrJIHIIy II PoCTOBy, BXO瓜HBmlIM B o"Iy enaPxHIo, xaPaKTePH3yeT cTPeM-

JIeHHe l'IBaHa lⅡⅡOMe皿aTb coIo3y Me)Kny BacHJIIIeM H apXI1enHCKOHOM POCTOBCKIIM.

C l497/98 r. liBaH III cTan 60Hb皿e cqHTaTbcH II C ｡aK-

TOM Cy皿eCTBOB aHmﾁI BoJIoUKoro H Py3cKoro yXeJIbHblx
242

nCP几T､VI, cTI). 41, 240; T. XII, cTp､244; T. 20, 1]epBaH noJIoBHHa,

cTp. 364; T. 28, cTp 328. B BocKpeceHCKoii, TIInorpa*cKoji "̲2QJIoroXcKo-nepMcKoiI JIeTomlcHx 3To co6blTIIe yKa3aHo uo4 7004 r.

(nCP几T1 V111, cTp. 232; T. 24, cTp' 213; 7. 26, cTp 290). B aTIIx

JieTonilcHx, TaK 'Ke KaK B ncKoBcKoii 3-ii II B xpoHorpa｡e ("ncKoBcKIIeJIeTomlcm》, Bbln. II, cTp. 253i nCPJI, T. 22, I1. 1, cTp. 512;
C.0．皿M1皿T. yKa3. coq., cTp. 271), caMo cBep)KeHHe MyxaMMenSMIIHa c Ka3alIcKoro lII)ecToJIa )I noca>KelMe A6nbIJI-JIeTHd)a oTHeceHo
K 7004 r. OⅡ皿60KIHOCTb aTOh且a'rbl BblHCHFIeTCH I13 Pa3PHIHOii KHIfrll》
me cKa3aHo：《7005-ro CellTH6Pfl..、corHaJI c Ka38HII MarMemeMHHH

Ual)H MaMyK, napb Hara曲cKoil...>，nOcJIG IIerO MyXaMMe,瓜-SMI畑Ⅱ”・
exaJI K IIBaHy lll, KOTOPblh《H3 cBShcKOro mOxo4y BOeBOX y6aBIIJI.
a nPlirOBOPimma B e c H y nocJIaTH ]!a Ka3aHb BoeBo" (<Pa3p皿HaH
KHIIT､a '1475-1598 rr.>, cTp. 27. Pa3P皿Ka MoH). BecHa 7005 r.- aTo
If ecTb anpcJII> - Maii l497 E, yKa3aHHbIe B Cod)"cKIIx, HHKoHoB-

cKoii il ,npyrHx JTeTon'IIcHx. 1497 r. Ha3blBalII! B cEcIIx pa60Tax
B. B BeJI"MIIHoB-3epHoB

("MccJIe,moBaHIie o

KacHMoBcKHx UapHx

II

Ual)eBINax>, 'I. 1．CH6., 1863, cTP. 190) H H. li・CMHpHOB ("UpcToII-

Ha汀nOJIMITHKa HBaHa lll>.­《HcTopIItIecKMe 3anIIcKH>, ･ T. 27, cTp.

20) , B To BI)eMH KaK K. B. Ba31{JIeBIIII, ocHoBblEaB皿嘘cRHaTeKcTe
BdCKpeceHcKoii ,JIeToHIIcII, HenpaBH.mhHo mIcaJI, IITo A6Jpl妬JI eT"
6blJI ilocJIaH B Ka3aHb IIa UaPcTBo (BMecTo cBeprH)'Toro MyxaMMenlSMMHa)くB anpeJIe l496 r." (K. B. B a 3 H JI e B II IL BHemHHfl noJIHTHKa pyccKoro UeHTpaJIM30BaHIIoro rocy"pcTBa. B'ropaRnoJIoBHHa
XV BeKa. M., 1952, CTp. 399) .
77

KHfI>KeCTB, me llaIIa'mnl)fIBRTb cI)lHoBbH BoI)McH BacHJIbe-

BH[la e八Ol) H MBaH (JP llX COBeP皿eHHoJIeTliH KHFDKecTBoM,
e皿e IIe pa3,meJIHB山HMcH, ynPaBJ1HJIa BJpBa BOPIICa KHHrl,IHFI

yJIbFIHa) 244B HIoJIe l497 r. MBaH III BblMGHIIJI̅V cBoIIx nJIeWIHHIIKOB nPHHa"e)KaBmme JIM BOTIIIIHbl B Pa3HblX ye3"x

MQ"9Bq<oi3eMJIII(3aMeHyoHIInoJTyqmJIIIB̅TBepcKOii3eMJIe)245.BeJIHKIIMKHFI3b,BepoHTHo,6TpeMHJIcHdrpaHHIIMTI'
EJIMHHe BoJIOUKHx KHH3eii B nPenteJIax BeJIHKOro KII"Kel･IHF1.
Bo3MozKHo TaK>Ke, IITo c HoMOUblo 3Toro no>KaJIoBaHHfl oH
xoTeJI HehTpaJIH30BaTb npeTeH3HII BacHJIHFI Ha 3eMJIH 6blBmero TBePcKorO KHmKeCTBa.
U

OTHocIITeJIIJHoBoJIorontcKoroHanpaBJIGHIIHIIMMyHI'ITeT-

HOIi nOJIHTHKH, He IIMeFI nPCTOBePllblX nlaHHblx, CKa3aTb IITO-

JIII60 TPyAHO・Hy>KHo yIIHTblBaTb llpHHanJIe>KIIocTb BoJIornbl
K BblMoPo[IHoMy y4eJIbHoMy HacJ1eAcTBy. CJIe4yeT IIMeTb B
BIUy TaK>Ke H onPenleJIeHHylO aKTIIBHOCTb B 3To BPeMH Meル

Koro yneJIbHoro KHH3H naHIIJIa AJIeKca皿POBIIIIa, BblnaBmero B aBrycTe l497 r．>KaJIoBaHHylo rpaMoTy BoJIoToIcKoMy
Cnaco-KaMeHHoMyMoHacTblpIo246.HeJIHmeHoBePOflTHH,IITO
erO BblcTynJIeHIie 6blJIo KaKIIM-TO O6Pa30M cBH3aHO c nOnblT-

KaMHBacIIJIIIHHaiMTHoHopyBcp"eBoJIoroJ<cKIIx｡eo"JIoB
Ho IIblI HHTepecbl Bblpa>KaJI naHHJI AJIeKca皿POBII (1­mBaHa lll HJIII BacHJIHH, PemaTb He 6ePeMcH.
CoUHaJIbHaHno40nJIeKaHMMyHHTeTHo向ⅡoJIHTHKH1497r.
pacKpbIBaeTcH, K co)KaJIeHIIIo, naJIeKo He noJIHocTblo. XapaK-

TeP HO)KaJIOBaHIIH HOKPoBcKOMy yrJIImKOMy MOHaCTblPIo
HaBOIHT Ha MblcJIb o KaKIIx-TO nePeMeHax B CHCTeMe TaMO-

>Kelllloro ynPaBJIeHIm yrqJIHIIeM B 1497 r. OIIeBHJHo, 3TmⅡepeMeHbl H 3acTaBJIHJIII MoHacTblpb np6HBaTbcfl rapaHTIIII B

oTHomeHIIII cTapblx Ioxo,npB. Bo3Mo>KHo, IIopFmoK c60pa TaMo)KeHHblx HOmJIHH B ymH'Ie nePeKPaHBaJICH B,n<yxe nPlIHⅡⅡⅡOB, oTPa)KeHIHIJIX B 6eJIO3ePCKOM TaMO>KeHIIOih rPaMO're
Mafl l497 r. 247

244

(I)aKTbl BI)ILaIIH II IIoXITBel))KJIGIIⅡI elO IIMMyHI1'｢C･1.11bIX I I)aMOT OTHO･
cHTcH K l494-1495 rr. (AC311, T I, JVb 575; A(b311X, II. 11, Nb l8,
21) .
２４５ 且ⅢⅡr, M 85.
２４６
AC3I'I, T. I11, Nh
２４７
TaM >KG,Nb 23.

272; Cp．M 271.

I､刀α8α 〃

“ﾙIHACTLI'IECKIIH KPII3LIC"
1 4 9 7 - 1 5 0 0 r r.

＊

1. 3aroBop l497 1､. M KopoHa皿虹烈MIITPmH-BHyKa
B3HTbIe B Ue9JIoM, rpaMoTbl l497 r. npo川IBaloT cBeT Ha

npeⅡnocblJIKII 3aroBopa l497 r., B KoTopoM npHHHJIII yIIacTHe

B. ryCeB,のrCTpoMHJIoB H npyrIIe cTopoIIHIIKII KHH3H BaCHJIIIH IIBaHOBHrla.

H. M. KapaM31IH, C. M・CoqJIoBbeB, B. O・KJIIoIIeBcKH曲，
I/i. m. CMIIpHoB H B HaIIaJIe 50-x ToIoB XX B. A. A. 3HMHH
cIIHTaJIH, 'ITo 3aroBop l497 r. RBJIHJIcH nporpeccIIBHblM JBH>KeHHeM XeTeii 60JIPcKIIxH且bHKoB, HanPaBJIeHHblM nPOTIIB

cl,IJI 6oflpcKoik peaKUMIII, rpymmPOBaBmHXCfl BOKPyr jlMHTplIH-BHyKa '. B JIeTonHcHx yIIacTHIIKIL3alOBopa nleiMcTBIITeJIbilo Ha3BaHbI neTbMH 60HpcKIIMII, a B ryceB npJIroe BpeMH

PaccMaTPlIBaJIcHB皿ITepaTypeBKaIIGcTBecocTaBHTeJIHCyne6HIIKa l497 r., me BonJIoTIIJIIIcb neHTpaJIII3aTopcKHe TeH-

neHUmH BeJIIIKoKHfl)KeCKohⅡOJI HTH KH．OJHaKo o6a apryMeHTa 6blJIH nOXBePrHyTbl CePbe3110ii KPIITHKe B TPynax

H．C. JIypbe, J1. B. qepenlIMHaHⅡPyrlIx IICcJIenOBaTeJIeh．
H. C. JIypbe nepBbl曲ⅡoKa3a@II, tlTo MHellHe o ryceBe KaK
cocTaBIITeJIe Cynte6HIIKa ocHoBaHo Ha HenpaBHJIbHoM HoHIi-

MaHIIII oIHoro HeFIcHoro MGcTa B TImOrpa巾CKOit J'GTOll',ICl,I 2.
IⅡ，し1．C M M I) H o B. KJIaccoBaFI 60Pl)6fI B MocKoBcK|oM I,OCyJIap|CTBe
B I,IeI),BohnoJIoBIme XVI B.­くIIpo6.71eMbI IIcTo1)m1，1o'Kal咽TaJIHc'rllL,ecK,ix o5皿ccTB>, 1935, JWb 9-10, cTp. 81; oⅡ》K e. PeUeH3IIH Ha

KHwʻI､yK．B. Ba3PI@neBWqa《BHemlMH IIoJIHT14Ka pycc,Koro UeHTpaJII130|BaHHorO rOlCynlaPCT旧鋤,一《BoInpocbl l{cTopl州》, 1952, Nb ll, cTp、142­
143; A. A. 3 II M II H. PeUeH3HH Ha KHIfry JI. B. 'IePerIH]旧a 4<PyccKI,Ie

(ieo"JIbHble apxIIBbl XIV-XV BeKoBJ>, q. 2.­《CoBeT℃KaH Kl畑r”，
1952, Nb 4, cTp. 66-67.

2H.C・JI y P f; e H3 mcTOPmm nOJIII1IIqecKOii 601)I'6b: nPm HBaHe lll=

くy(IeHble ̅33mlcKH [J1ry],, Nb 80 CePIIFI nc'ro1)MIIGcIMx HayK, Bbln. 10.
J1., 1941, cTp. 90-91.
79

ToIIKy3peHIIFIJIypbeno旦及ep>KaJI几B.I-lepenHIIH3.I,yceB,

cOrJIaCHO HcCJIenlOBaHHHM JIyPbe H I-IePenHIIHa, HHKaKOl.0
oTHomeHHH K cocTaB"eHIIIo Cyne6HHKa He HMeJI.

C. B. BeceJIoBcKIIii ( 1 939 r.) HoKa3aJI, IITo ryceBbl npoHCxo,IHJIH H3 3HaTHOrO POna 60叩瓜o6pblHcKIIx, oTeU

B. ryceBa EJIII3ap cJIy班HJI yneJIbHblM KHH3bHM, a HeKOToPble nPyme BImHble yIIaCTHHKII 3arOBoPa HBJIHJIHCb noTOMKaMH H3MeJIbIIaBmmx yneJIbHblx KHH3eii 4.

PaccMaTpHBaH 3aroBop l497 r. KaK oJKHo H3 cJIenlcTB"
H3MeHeHIIH B3alIMOoTHomeHHii Me)KJy BeJIHKOKIIfDKecKOii

BJIacTblo H 60HpcTBoM, C. 6. BeceJIoBcKIIii c[IHTaJI, IITo ry-

ceqcToBapIImaMI]<rloHeocTopo)KHQcTIIIIJIHH3no6y)K八e-

HHH

KaPbePbl

BMe皿aJIIICEL

B

ceMeiHoe

neJIo

BeJIHKoro

KHH3H> 5. TaKHM o6pa30M, aBTop Ho cymecTBy oTKa3aJIcJI oT
BblJICHeHHH CoUHaJIbHblx nPHIIHH H IOJIIITHIIecKIIx UeJIeh3a-

roBopa l497 r., xoTH H BImeJI B HeM npoflBJIeHHe HenPBoJIbCTBa <CJIy)KHJIOrO KJIacca)' (60HPCTBa) POCTOM caMOnleP》KaBHH．

H. C. JIypbe, nonp6Ho C. B・BeceJIoBcKoMy, 06paTHJI
BHIIMaHHe Ha pon<oBHTocTb ryceBa ( 1 941 r.) 6. no MHeHHIo

aBTOPa, B nePBOhⅡoJIoBIIe 80-x ronPB XV B. ryceBく6blJI
nPeXCTaBHTemeM ｡eO"JIbHOrO 6JIOKa, nblTaBmerOCH nPIIBJIeIIb TBepb Ha cBoIo cTopoHy>> 7;《…巾a KTHIIecKI'Ie naHHble
o BJIa瓜HMHPe ryCeBe COBePmeHHo onPOBePralOT B3rJIHI Ha
HerO KaK CToPoHHHKa caMonlepJKaBIIH> 8．B cTaTbe, Bblme八一
mek B l948 r., H. C・JIyPbe yKa3aJI Ha nOJIHTHIIeCKHe CBH31I

Co｡bH cくKHH>KHqeM-3MIIrpaHToM> Bac. MHx. BepeiicKHM
H Ha oTcyTcTBIIe XocToBepHblx H3BecTIIiM o cBH3H EJIeHbl

c

6oHpaMH 9. B pa6oTax l941 II 1948 rr. H. C・JIyPbe pa3BIIJI
aHTIITe3y

TPanllIUIIOHHo曲 KOHneⅡnHH 3aroBopa

l497 r.

B JIIITepaType, nHcaJI oH, Mo)KHo IIacTo BcTpeTHTb yKa3aHHe, IITo Co｡bH H BacHJIHii 6blJIH oKpy>KeHbI ,mBopHHaMH, a

３几B. II e p e n ll lI II. PyccKIIe *eo"JIbHble apxHBbl XIV-XV BeKoB,
４11. 2. M., 1951, cTp. 294.
戸C. B. BeceJIoBcKH曲. BJIa"IMHp ryceB - 'cocTaBHTeJIb Cynle6HIIKa
︒l497 rona.­KHcTQPIitlecKHe 3amlcK", T.
5,
cTp
31-47; cl).
６H. H. C M H p H o B. yKa3. pen., cTp. 143, IIpHM. 2.
７C. B. BeceJIoBcKIIit.yKa3. coIl.,cTp.47.
８月.C・JI y p b e. yKa3. co'l., cTp. 91.
︒raM )Ke, cTp. 92; cp. J1. B. II e p e n H ![ H. yKa3. coI1,,W．2, cTp. 301.
︶H. C. JI y p b e. yKa3. coII., CTp､91.
f1. C. JI y p b e. nepBble H八eOJIOrlI MOcKOBcKOro C8MoneP)Ka|BIIH.《yqeHble 3aml,ICKII JIrnII HM．A、Ⅲ. repUeHa>, T. 78 Ka*e,mpa HcTo"H CCCP. JI., 1948, cTp. 96-97.
80

EJIGHa ll nMIITpIIii - 60HpaMII:《①aKTbI HoKa3blBaloT o6pal･Hoe> '0.

K. B. Ba3IIJIeBHLI co皿acIIJIcH c H. C. JIypbe B ToM, IITo

<<3arOBOPmIIKMI...
nPlIHa皿e]KaJIII
K
｡eOnaJIbHO-OnnO3皿HOHHblM KPyraM> ''.
Ha 6a3e CpaBHⅡ'1，eJIbHOrO . II3yKIeHHH JIeTOmlcHblx, aKTo-

Bblx IIcToIIHHKOB H Cyne6HHKa l497 r・几B. IIepenHHH Bbl⑪

且BIIHVJI
- II 6JIecTH皿e o60cHoBaJI rIIHoTe3y o npoyrJIHUKoH

HanPABJIeHHocTH3aroBopa
l497Kap八MHaJIbHble
r.
BblBO八bl

aBT6pac｡opMyJIMpoBaHb[cJIelyPIIlliMo6pa30M:3aE@Bop
rvceBa-<nonblTKa Bo3Po皿Tb巾eOnaIIbHylo Pa3nPo6qJIeHH6cTb:' !2; <<ryCeB
ｰ
!1 erO TOBaP1皿II 6blJIII Bblpa3H｡TeJIHMII
U

onⅡO3HuHOHIIblx 60flPcKIIx IIaCTPOeHHH, KOTOPbIe 皿JIHH3

6blBmHxVneJIoBMocKoBcKoroKIIH>KecTBa、3THHaCTPOeHIIH
IIcHoJIb30baJIII B cBoHx UeJIHx Co｡bJI naJIeoJIor m ee cblH
Bacli!ﾉI油ⅢBa|HoBIIzl>P '3; <Ka3Hb BJIa瓜HMHPa ryCeBa H PPy-

rHx 3arOBOP皿HKoB B nleKa6pe l497 r. 6blJIa HenocpeXcTBeH-

HbIMnPOn6JDKeHHeMy"Pa,HallegeHHOrPmBaHOMIIInO
VrJIIIUlfOiicaMocToHTejibHocTHBl491r"14
U

B nocJIelHee BpeMH H A. A. 3IIMHH, roBopH o cHJIax,

CToHBmIIX 3a CⅡHIIoik <<KHH)KIIIIa BacHJIHH>, noXIIepKHyJI
り

くIIpoymH1KIIe
cHMnaTIIII>
BJIa八HMHparyCeBal5・KpoMe
u

ToTo,bl{ oTMeTIIJI, IITo Co巾blo noJJteP>KIIBaJI HOBrOPO八CKmH

aPXHenlICKOnreHIJa1砿16.CTopoHHPIKMTBepcKIIxBoJIbllo-

cTeii, no MHeHHIo A A. 3HMIIHa, HanpoTIIB> Bo3JIara｡illI cBoII
Han<e>KXblHa mMIITpHH-BHyKa '7. TaKHM o6pa30M, cTep>KeHb
1HHacTIIqecKoro Boilpoca A. A. 31IMIIH ycMaTpHBaeT B 601)b6e
⑪

U

CIIJI 4eUeHTPaJIM3aUMH 3a BOCCTaHOBJIeHHe nPe>KHel'I He3aBH-

10 H. C. JI y p b e.H3 11cTopHH HoJIIITIIIIecKo曲60pb6bl..., cTp、91.
l l K. B. 6 3 3 1I JI e B M [I. BHelllII" noJIIITIIKa Pyc|cKoro neHTPaJIM30BaH-

lioro rocyZIal)cTBa. BTol)am noJIoBIIIIa XV BeKa. M" 1952, crl). 364.
12 @Il. B I-I G I) ell H Ii l{. yKa3. coLI., IL 2, cTp. 318.
1，』TaM )Ke, cTp. 303.
l4 TaM >Ke, cTp、294.
15 A A. 3 11̅M II II. OcHoBIIblG III)o6J1GMb! pe*opMalAIIoHHo-ryMaHIIcTII【IecKoro 4B|II2Kel･11M B PoccIIH B XIV-XVI BB.­くl'ic1oPIIH, qJoJIbKJIop.

McKVccTBo cJIaB>IH|cKIIx HaponpB>,. 10K.Ⅲa4bI COBGTCKOH八GJIera皿】1．

Vルle>KnlyHaPO八Hblil c'be3m cJIaBHcToB (Co"fl, ceHTH6pb l963) . M,

1963, cTp. 106; oH >Ke・O HoJIHTH【lecKIIx npe瓜ⅡocbmKax Bo3HI1KHoBeⅢllH ▲
pI)VccKoro a6coJIIoTIM3Ma.­《A6coJIIoTIi3M B PcccIIII (XVIIXVIII BB.)》M., 1964, cTp. 36.

lJ A. A. 3 IIM Ii H. OcHoBHble npo6.JIeMbl..., cTp. 106­1071oH >Ke.Ono．Ⅲ、｡}iLIec剛Ixnl〕e且ⅡocI>lJIKax..., cTI). 37.

l' A A 3 M M IiH. OcHo:BIIIJIe llpo6JIeMbI…, cTp. 105 0H )Ke．Ono皿TmLIecKMx npeユnocbIJIKax.,., cTp. 34.
6

C.M.Ka皿TaHoB

81

叩

glIMocTH Pa3Jm[IHIJIx HeJIaBHo nPHcoeⅡPIHeHHblX o6JIaCTe#.

B3rJIFIn A. A. 3mIHHa Ha co6blTHFI I497 r. 6&IIH3oK K
n PeXCTaBJIeHHIo几B. qepenHIIHa o 3aroBope ryceBa KaK
pe皿皿Be d)eonaJIbHoli BoAHbl cepe"Hbl XVB OTJIIIIIlle lix
KoHUe皿mHcocToHT
H cocToHT BBToM，IITo
ToM, IITo A
A A、3HMHH
A. 31IMHH H且MHTp”Ii nMHTp"BHyKa CIIHTaeT He CTOJIbKO HOC,JIen<OBaTeJIbHblM CTOPOHHIIKOM

QaMOnePWBHH, cKOJIbKo nP"CTaBIITeJIeM onPeneJIeHHoii
｡

(TBePcKOii) JIHHHII MecTHord cenaPaTH3Ma.

BecbMa OcTopo>KeII B cBoIIx BbiBo"x LK. eHHeJI, KomPhJM B UeJIOM 6ml>Ke K ToLIKe 3Pe剛呪 兜. C. JIypbe H
几 B. qepenHIIHa, qem m m CMIiPHoBa. OHnMmeT:くHo

Ja>Ke eCJIH STH HCcJIelOBaHIIFI reHeaJIorlIH 3arOBOP皿HKoB

He nOKa3blBalOT OKoHLIaTeJIblIO, LITO ryCeB H ero IIaPTIIH fIBJIHJIPICb aKTIIBHblMH IIO60PIIHKaMII CenapaTII3Ma lr IIPoTIIBひ

HIIKaMH BeJIIIKOKHH>KeCKom noJIIITIIKIi UeHTPaJIE3a山皿7 01-IM,
即

唖

no KPaHHeH MePe, nOKa3blBaIoT, [ITO sTPI JIIOJJI IIMKoIIM O6-

Pa30M He 6bIJIII TI1'ⅡHIIHbn'IH nPenCTaBMTeJIFIMH TOrO, IITO

I/1.m.CMIIpHoBHa3blBaeT,,HeTIITyJIoBaHHbIMcPeJJ皿McnoeM
KHaCCa
q)eO"JIOB<<,
KOTOPblii
no皿eP>KIIBaJI
UeHTPaJ1)I30BaH《《

U

HOe rOCynaPCTBo, m e TImHIIHbIMII J<eTbMH 60HPoK}IMI1, Pe3-

Ko 'BPa班瓜e6HblMII ,,y,IeJ1bHoKHFI>KecKMM KI)VraM4l>p l8.

Oco6eHHo cJIa60H3yqeHblKoHKpeTHbier npIIIIIIHbl!IHeIIocpeAcTBeHHble nBH>KymMe npy>KIIHbl co6blT"

1497n no

MHeHHIoC.B.BeceJIoBcKoro,baMIIBaHIII《HeMorPa306paTbcHBcIJIoIKHoMKJIy6KeHHTplIr,Bo3HIIKmmXBOKPyr
BOnPOCa O nPecToJIoIIacJIe1剛i>> '9. H、C. JIypbe cLIIITaeT, IITo

B epeTIIIiax, 6JIII3KHx K EJIeHe, IIBaH III IiameJI 60JIee Bep一

"Ix HoOoPHIIKoB caMo4eP>KaBIIH, [IeM BくⅡaPTIHI)> Co｡blI

naJIeoJIor, noaToMy oH m Ha3Haq" nMIITpIIH:BHyKa cB6I1M
HaCJIenHHKOM
20．O4HaKo
aBTop
He
o6LHcHFIeT,
nciIIeMy《旦Ⅲu

HacTHIIecKHH KpH3Hc> pa3pa3HJIcH HMeHHo B 1497 r.

HHTepecHbIe
coo6pa>KeHIIH
oTHocIfTeJIbHo
pa3BHTHH

<<KpH3Hca>> B 1497 r. BbIcKa3aJI JI. B. qepenHHH. C̅ ero ToII" 3peH", B ceHTH6pe l497 r. (naTa, yKa3aHIIaH B TeKcTe

Cyne6HIIKa) 6blJIa paccMoTpeHa JIHmb nePBaH qacTb nonrQTaBJIIIBaeMoro KoXeKca, Becb )Ke Cynie6HHK B neJIoM 6blJI

o6Hapo且oBaH
B巾eBpaJIel498r.，o八HoBpeMeHHo
cKopoHa皿e曲且MmTpmH-BHyKa、Haqana
UeHTpaJIll3allIWI，I1poBo皿B皿HecHBCyne6HHKe,HBbl3BaJIH,corJIacHoLlepen}iHHy,Bbl７Ｋ
１Ｌ
０Ｆ
１却
○句
エソ

Ｊ
Ｃ
Ｒ

Ee,9 n ell lvan theQreat oI MoscowLondon, 1961, p 346-347
Q UeCejIOlicKHil yKaa Coq" CTP 4Z
C. JI y p b e. neDBble ll八eoJIor；1..., cTp. 97-98, 106.
82

cTVnJIeHIie《nPenCTaBIITeJIeii 60HPCTBa>>, Bo rJIaBe KOTOPblx

cT6HJI B. rycbB 21 TaKIIM o6Pa30M, 3Xecb 3aroBop pacUeHIIBaeTcR KaK ｡opMa 60pb6bl npoTIIB KoHKpeTHoro HoJIIITIIIIeCKOrO MePOnPmHTMI BeJIHKorO KHH3H: nPHcTyII K I旧凡aHHIO

Cyne6HmKaBceHTfI6pel49ZI・Bbl3blBaeT3arOBOP,3aroBoPmiikm rm6HyT B neKa6pe l497 r., a B (beBpaJIe l498 rnpoHCXO皿T IfopoHaUII" nMHTPIIH-BHyKa lI o6HaponpBaHIIe
Cyn<e6HIIKa．ⅡPm3TOM几B.IIepenHIIHnpoBoIHTBoIopa3"JI Me>KXy lIHTepecaMII Co*bli
1eJIMe>K瓜yHHTepecaMH
Co巾bll-BacHJIHH,CO皿oHcTopo- BacHJIMH, c o"oH cTopoHKOB - C nPyrOm, CIIIITaH, IITo >KeHa HlI CblH
CblH
Hbl，3arOBOP皿HKOB­C叩yrOⅡ，CIIHTaH，uTo〉KeHa
BeJIHKOrO KHH3H TOJIbKO IIcnOJIb30BaJIH B CBOHx UeJIHX 3arO-

BOp皿IIKoB,HHao60poT22.
Eme XaJIbme nO nyTII nPOTIIBOnOcTaBJIel-IHFI IIHTePecoB

II MOTHBOB neHcTBHR OⅡⅡO3HIIHOHHorO <<60HPCTBa>> II
u

CombH - BacHJIIIH nomeJI K. B. 6a3HJIeBHII, corJIacHo KoH-

Ⅱe血皿KoToporopacxo)K,meHHeMe)KnyCo｡be曲ⅢHBaHoM
III drpaHllqliBaJIoCb npo6JIeMoii oTHomeHIIH K JIKTBe, B T9
○

U

BPeMH KaK noBeXeHIie 3aroBoP皿HKOB HBJIHJIOCb peaKuHeH

Ha
JIOMKyく巾eonaJIbHO-y八eJIbHOrO
CTPOH>23
H
aHTIIJIHTOBCKyIo nOjiIITIiky BeJIHKOTOKHH3H 24(B HocJIe皿eMnyHKTe

aBTOP,OIIeBH且HO,nPI13HaBaJIBO3Mo)KHOcTLCOBIJaneHI呪ⅡOJIIITHIIecKHx B3m皿oB 3aroBopmHKoB II Co巾bⅢ)
U

BblBonl K B. Ba3HJIeBH[Ia cBo且HTcH K TOMy, [ITO rJIaBHOH
U

rlpHuHHoh3aroBopal497r.6blJIくIIe凡HHaCTI'ILIecKHHBonU

pOC>; He八OBOJIbCTBO, nPl1BeⅡmee K 3arOBOPy, 4<Bo3IIIIKJIo IIegaBHcHMo oT "HacTII'lecKoro neJIa, Ho 60pb6a, nonHHBmaHCH BOKPyr BOnPOca o nPeCTOJIOHacJIe瓜ⅡH, 3axBaTIIJIa I1

OⅡⅡo3mililoHHO1IacTPOeHIiyIoqaCTb60HpcTBa)>25.3TOT
BblBO瓜OCHOBaH
BblBOA
OCHOBall BB3HaIlllTeJIbHOH
3HaulllTeJIbHOII MePe
MePe HaⅡPe瓜CTaBJIeH皿i
Ha nPe4CTaBJIeHHIi
o He3bl6JleMocTH BJIac|TII I/i'BaHa lll: f<BpHA JIII 3TII JIHⅡa

( 3arOBOPmHKⅢ. - C. K.) MOrJIH CBH3blBaTb C nPHXOIOIMI K

iJIacTm botbbm!!ee cbIHaBacmJImfIHaZIe>KXb!HaocJIa6JIeHIIe UeHTPa皿3au皿HyKPenJIeHMe ｡eOXaJIbHo･ynleJIbHorO

21 JI. B. LIepenIIIIH. yKa3. coI1.,可．2, cTp. 308. Cp. Bo3pa>Kel･Iwl
A. A. 3mMIIIla (<<CoBeTcKaH KHIIIra)', 1952, J1. 4, c'『p､67)
22 JI. B. LI e p e n H ;I H. yKa3. coII., [1. 2, cTI)．294.
23 n0'm aTOii JIoMKOii aBTOP nOnPa3yMeBaeT <<ylIIIIITo>KeHHe MeJIKIIx y,meJIoB, orPamlIIeHIIe lIMMyHIITGToB I{ cHcTelIbl KoPMJIeHHII, nOIITPI〜、O舟
HOe lll)eKpallLGIMe l)a3JaIIH 3eMGJIb lla ROTLlmlHOM EPaBe, nl)GKpa皿el-II,Ie
⑪

BOQJIbH̅Oii -cJIy>K6bl 60HP II JleTei 6071PcKIIX, KO皿(pIIK8皿IonpaBa B
,,,Cynle6HMKe@! l497 r. c fIcllo
”,Cy瓜e6H,ⅢʻKe“l497r．cチIcllo
BIj[l〕a》Kel･IʻHoii
BLIPa>KeHHoii
TeHユGHUlleH
Te"gllUlleiI
BILeHTl〕aJIlⅡ3a­
B ILeHTI)a"2¥-

UHH cynaⅡnpo[Iee> (K、B B.a 3 11 II e B II II. yKaa co[I., cTI). 369).

24 K.B.Ba3H･JIeBIIII・yKa3. COII., cTp. 365-370.
26 TaM )Ke, cTP. 369-370.
83

6＊

nopfllKa. 3To cTaHoBHTcH TeM 60JIee HcHblM, IITo HH EJIeIIa

BoJIomaHKa,
He
llrPaBmaﾁI
CKO&mbKO-HM6y,mb
3Ha[IMTGJIbHOii
nOJIIITIIIIeCKOii POJIII, HH ee CblH "MIITPII曲, KOTOPOMy K MOMeHTy

,皿HaCTHIleCKOrO

3arOBOPa

HCIIOJIHIIJIOcb

TOJIbKO

14 JIeT, He MoI､JIII Bbl3blBaTb cepbe3Hoe onaceHHe B cMblcJIe
yCImeHIIH caMOneP>KaBHO曲 nOJIHTHKH, H60 BCH nOJIHOTa
BJIaCTH HaxO皿JIaCb B PyKax BeJIIIKorO KHH3H, 06JIaXaBmero

He3"HCIIMblM H BJIacTHblM xapaKTepoM), 26.

H.H・CMHpHoB B cBoeii peUeH3HHHa KHHry K. B. Ba3HJIeBIIIIa BbIcKa3aJI nPOTHBOnoJIO)KHylO ToIIKy 3PeHIIH, cIIM-

T4H, IITO BJIacTH IIBaHa lll rPO3HJIa cePbe3HafI bnaCHOCTb:
くB xoAe nHHacTHIIecKoro KpII3Hca l497 1 502 rr．VXeJIbHOご
KIIJDKecKHe KPym,

oIIeBII八HO,

PaCC[IIITblBaJIHHcnoJIb30BaTb

MaJIOJIeTCTBO BHyKa HBaHa lll, 41IMIITP",皿fl3aXBaTa

BJIacTH B cBoH."" (B (jopMe pereHTcTBa lI T. ,nl.) . HanpoTHB, 3aroBop l497 1､．ⅡpencTaBJIJIJI cO6010 1IoIIblTKV neTeii

60HpcKIIx H IbHKoB H3MeHIITb xo4 co6bITIM B cBoIo. noJIb3v
響
nyTeM HacIIJIbcTBeHHOrO yCTPaHeH" ,,BHyKa BeJIIIKOrO KHH-

3H" mHMIITpIIfl II nepenaqH BJIacTII Bac皿HIO> 27.

no-BH且HMoMy,BocHoBe3ToroMHeHIIHm.I'I.CMIIpHoBa
JIe>KHT BnOJIHe nPaBMJIbHoe nPenlcTaBJIeHHe O He,IOcTaTOII-

HOii nPOIIHOcTII e,nIIHO八ep>KaBHoM BJIacTII B KoHUe XV B.,
24HaKo nPOTHBOPelMH Me)K4y rPyⅡⅡHpOBKaMIイ且MIITpHH H

BacIIJIIIH aBTop paccMaTpHBaeT BHE cBH3H c Ho3ilUlieii
caMoro IIBaHa lll. no[IeMy 6blJIo pe皿eHO HCHOJIb30BaTb
MaJIoJIeTcTBoⅡMHTpmBl497r.，aHepaHbmeP3HaJIJIH

HBaH III O63THXnJIaHaX？nOIIeMyHBaH III BO3BblcHJI
nMHTp", ecJIH 3HajI, IITo IIMeHHo oT̅ Hero Hcxo,IIIT yrpo3a
ero BJIa,瓜blIIecTBy？Ha3TH BoⅡpocbI［IHTaTeJIb He HaxoⅡHT
O T B e Ta 、

CJIe,ⅡyeT o6paTHTb BHHMaHHe Ha MblcJIb K. B. Ba3HJIegliqa, nOJIyIIIIEmylO 3aTeM Pa3BIITHe B TPyne 4)K・のeHHeJIa・

Ho MHeHIIIo K B. Ba3"eBHqa, KopoHa"JI mMKTpliH-BHyKa
nPoBoIHJIaCb KaK cPenCTBo yKpenJIeHHH aHTI1JIIIToBcKorO
PyccIKO-MOJILa|BCKOro cOIO3a:《... BblcTVHJIeHHe HBaHa lll B

3a皿HTyCTe.aHacoBnaJIocMoMeHToM.pa3pblBacCo｡beiili
C nPOBO3皿ameHHeM UMHTPHH HBaHOBH'Ia HacJIe皿ⅢKOM
BeJIHKOKHH )KeCKo曲BJIaCTH)p 28.

26 K.B.Ba3HJIeBIIri･yKa3. coq､, cTP､364.

27 1/1.しI. C M M p H o B. PeueH3HH Ha Kimrv K B.
Ba311JIeBIIIIa <BHe皿H”I
HoJIMTIIKa PyCcKOrO UeHTPaJII130BaHH(JrO rOCynaPCTBa>p.­《Bonpocbl
IICTOPIIⅢ沙, 1952, ,Nb ll, cTp. 143.

23 K. B. B a 3 II Jie B ll u: ylta3. co'I., cTp. 36Q
84

n>K. eHHeJI K"TRIIeCKII 'OTHeccH K Te31ICy几B. qepenHIIHa o6 HcHOJIb30BaHHmCo巾be力HBacIIJIIMeM 3aroBopmII-

KoB B cBoIIx neJIHx et vice versa. OH nyMaeT, IITo 3To cJIIimKoM 60JIbmaH HaTJI>KKa 29. ApryMeHT K. B. Ba31IJIeBIIIIa,

IJp
H3B
aHHblH瓜oKa3aTb
pacxo)KneHHe
Me>K,my
Co｡be仇HHBaU

HbM III B 1497 n no Bonpocy o JIIITBe, - oTcyTcTBHe B
nlicbMax Co｡blI K npIIepH noJIHT"eCKlIx HacTaBJIeH皿一
U

U

①eHHeJI cIIHfaeT KpaitHe cJIa6blM 30. CaM aBTop nblTaeTcH

paccMoTpeTbco6bITIIH1497r.BEIIHaMHKe・nePBOHaIIaJIblIblii TOJIqOK OH BH瓜ⅢT, B COOTBeTCTBHH C JIeTOⅡHcHblMH H3U

BeCTHHMH,BPemeH皿mBaHalllHa3HaIIIITbnMIITpHHBe皿一
KIIM KHH3eM. OTcIona m 3aroBop - KaK peaKIIHH Ha 3To pemeHIIe 31.

HaMepeHMemBaHalllKopoHoBaTbnMIITpHH-BHyKaOelIF
U

HeJI BcJIe,nl 3a K. B. Ba3HJIeBIIIIeM cBH3blBaeT c HoJIIITHKoPI

ITO OTHOmeHHIO K MO皿aBcKoMy BoeBone CTe巾aHy (OTUy

EJIeHbl H neXy nMIITpHH co cTopoHbl MaTepll) . HBaH ̲III

xoTeJI HMeTb B CTe巾aHe Han<e>KHOrO cOIo3HIIKa nPOTIIB JIHTBbl. B aBrycTe l497 r. B MocKBy BePHyJIHjqll QTnp"JIeliHble

K CTe巾aH7 B IIIoHe l496 E IIocJIb1 IIBaHa lllルIB. I/IB. O山迄pHH H JIyKa BoJIoIJleHIIH, BMegre c HIIMHnPH6blJI MOJInaB軍

CK" nOcoJI HBaHⅡHTapb 32. KaK HoJIaraeT eHHeJI, BeJIH⑪

KHHKHH3b Mor noJIyKIHTb oT HIIx coo6111eHIIe o ToM, 11．ro
U

CTe巾aHBcJIyIIaeBcTynJIeHHHBMO皿aBHIonoJIbcKo-JIHToBcKII)I BohcK PemmJI o6bfIBIITb ce6H BaccaJIoM cyJITaHa m
U

conpoTIIBJIHTEcHHreJIJIoHaM.OTBeTHblMycJIoBIIeM
(KoTopoe
BbIIBHHy" CTe｡aH mJIH KoTopoe eMy PbLIIo npenlJIo)KeHo
IIBaHOM III? 33)ylBJIHJIOCb Ha3HaqeHHe nMHTPHH-BHyKa HaCJIenHHKOMnpeCTOJIa34.3TyKOHneⅡnHIOeHHeJIanO旦且ep>KaJI H. C. JIypbe35,
｡

C Hameii To'IKII 3peHIIH, B HoJIb3y MHeHHH①eHHeJIa cBHneJIbCTByeT P皿巾aKTOB: l) B JIeTOⅡHCHOH cTaTbe O BcTPeIIe
｡

U

pH3aHcKbiigeJIHKoiiKHHTIIHIMAHHblBaBrycTel497r.BHyK
2J J.Fennell・Op. cit., p. 348.
30 1bid., I). 356.
3i lbid., p. 343.

32 nCP,ﾉ1,T、VI, cTp. 41, 241; T. VIII, cTp. 232-233; T・XII, cTp. 244;

T. 20, nePBam no@m()BIllla, cTI). 364-365; T、24, cTI) 243; T. 26, cTp

290-291i T. 28, cTp. 328-329. KpaTKoe ynoMMHa1I11e o6 9ToM: <C6,
PMO", T. 41, cTP. 240.

33 ABTop npocTo roBopHTくa conditi,on> (J・Fennell. Op cit., p. 345>
34 J.Fennell.Op・cit., l). 345.

35 peUeII3''F' H. C・JIyl)1,C Ha K'II'ry mj･K. d)GHHCJIa <<I,an the Ol℃at oi
Moscow" ("McTol)MH CCCP", 1962, JVh 4, cTp. 206) .
85

ynOMHHyT CPa3y nOCJIe BeJIHKOrO

KHH3H,

PaHbme nieTeii

H

BeJIHKIIx KHHMHb; 2) coo6meHIIIo o BcTpeqe AHHbl HenoCPencTBeHHO nPe只皿eCTByeT PaCcKa3, 0ⅡHCblBalO皿嘘cTOJIK-

HoBeHIIe HreJIJIoHoB co CTe｡aHoM II BMemaTeJIbcTBo BeJIIIKOrO KHH3H B STOT KOH巾JIHKT 36; 3) ynoMHHyTafl B JIeTonHcHx HocbIJIKa K AJIeKcaHIpy neTpa JIo6aHa 3a60JIoTcKoro
H瓜bHKa HBaHa BoJIKa KypImblHa, KOTOPble nOJI>KHbl 6blJIH
oTroBopHTb JIMToBcKoro BeJIHKoro KHJI3H oT BoiiHbl co CTe-

巾aHoM, HMeJIa MecTo B aBrycTe l497 r. 37; 4) B BoJIoroncKo-

UePMCKOit JIeTOnHCMB!IgBeCTHIIoKoPoHaUmmJMHTP"
HBaHOBHIIarOBoPIITcH:くCTe｡aHoBaBIIyKaBoJIoIKcKoro>38.
rlmOTe3y Ba3IIJIeBIIIIa-①eHHeJIa HeO6XO皿fMo V'lecTb
管

nPH yCTallOBJIeHHHBCero KOMnJIeKca nPHIIIIH, 06ycJIOBHB-

mllx KopoHaUmlo IMI1Tp"-BHyKa Ho BHemHenoJIHTIIIIecKaH
nPHIIHHa He 6blJIa, Ha Ham B3rJI升八, enHHCTBeHHO曲. B cxeMe

のeHHeJIa ecTb OJIHO CJIa60e MecTO: ecJIII oHa xoPOmo O6'LHCHFIeT Bo3BblmellHe nMIITplIH B aBrycTe l497 r., To M3 Hee
Tpy皿o BblBecTH MOTIIBbl KoPOHa皿H且MHTPIIH-BHyKa B *eBpaJIe l498 E CorJIacHo Ha6JIIoneHIIHM aB'ropa, noCjIe oKTH6-

pH l497 r. HBaHy lllくIIeLIerO 6blJIO 6ecnoKOHTbcH> o cynb6eMo皿aBHH,nocKoJIbKy26oKTH6pFIl497r.CTe巾aHpa3一

OMJI BTOPrHyBmHecH B ero CTPaHy noJIbCKo-'ﾉIHTOBCKIIe BOii-

"fi̲j9. O6emaHlie 'CTebaHy, ecJIII OHo Il 6bIJIo naHo B aBrycTc

1497 r., MorJIo 6blTb Bblno"HeHo B c:JIy[Iae ocTpoii BIIyTpimoJIIITHIIecKoii Heo6xo皿MOC|TII B KOPOHa皿Ⅱ且MMTplIH-BHyKa.
BMecTe c TeM BHyTPHnoJIIITHII'ecKIIG MOTHBbl Ha3HalIeHIIFI
JMIITpwI BeJIHKIIM KHH3eM eHHeJI npeIcTaBJIgeT TaKIIM o6Pa30M, IITO TPy,nHo

npHypoLIIITb

IIx

IIMeHHo

K

l497

r.:

<<C

BHyTPHHoJIIITIIIIe,cKOii TOIIKH 3PeHIIH 3To MOMO 6blTb 3anly-

MaHo KaK八eMOHCTP a皿H erO (HBaHa llL - C K) HeOn06peH" 60fIPcKHx cHMmaTHii lI cBH3eiM Co｡bl" 4q
CoxpaHHBmH曲CHIOKyMeHTaqJIbHbliiMaTePliaqJIno3BOJIHeT
naTb CJIeXylOmee

o6EHcHeHIIe

co6blTIIHM

HIIHacTHIIecKoji

" nCP几T､1V,Ⅲ.l,Bb1,.2,cTp､534-535;T,VI,cTp､42,241;T,V111,
CTP、233-234; T: XII, crp. 245; T. 20, nepBam moJToBIIHa, cTP､ 365366; T、28, cTp. 329.

3/ <<C6．PHO>, T. 35, Nb 48, cTp. 236-238.
3d nCPJI, T. 26, cTp. 291.

3ﾐ'J. Fennel1. 01)・cit., p、344. 06 Ej1･oM c()'iblTIM IIonpo6Hee cM.:
L・KQ l an kO w s｣fi. Dzieje Wielkiego ksiCstwa LiteWskiego za
JagiellorlOw, t l . WWa, 1930, str. 4377 J. S Z u j s k i. History7 polski6j treSCiwie ol)owiedziall6j ksiflg dwanaSCie・W-wa, 1880, str. 150.
40 J. F e n n e l l. Op. cit., p. 345.
86

6opb6bll497r.<<napTHH>Co巾bH­,BacHJIHH,no3H皿HKO-

ToPoiMBecbllanomaTHyjllichBKoHUel423-1494rr"nocJ1e
cMepTII AHnpeH yrJIHUKoIIo H BopHca BoJIonKoIp, Ha[IaJIa
VcHJIHBaTbcH c cepe瓜HHbl 90-x ToIoB, Bo-nepBblx, 6JIaronaPFI

6paKyE"eHb!HBaHoBHblHAJIeKca皿Pa｡JIIITOBCKOrO)"BToPblx, 6JIarOXaPFI IIPHxOny K UePKoBHOII BJIacTPI yMePeHHoro opTonoKca CHMoHa, B-TPeTbmx m B oc"BHoM, noToMy,

IIToTelmeHUlIIIyneJIbHoimeueHTpaJIH3aulIII61，mHellleKPaHHecHJIbHb1HnpeTeH31mBacM"ﾙ呪Ham3BecTHyl9
TePPliTo-

PHaJIbHylO He3aBIIcHMOcTb BblPa>KaJIH oIHy lI3 00'beKTHBHblx
3aKoHOMePHOcTeii 3KoHoMHqecKQIPHnOJIIITIIIIeCKOrO Pa3BH-

TMFI B 9ToT nePHon. B l496-1497 rr. BacIIJIIIil o6JIaXaJI HeKoTOPblMII ye3naMI1Ha nPaBa]L yneJIa, Ha旦皿PyrHMII ocymeCTBJIHJICy八e6HbliMKoHTPOJIb・cy皿eCTBOBaHIIenOJIIITIIIIecKOrOCOnePHIIKaBJIHnemMIMTPlIH-BHyKa,nO瓜瓜eP>KHBaeMOTO
IIBaHoM III, 3acTaBJIHJIo BacIIJIIIH oco6eHHo aKTIIBHo Io6IIBaTbcH Bce HoBblx TeppHTopmaJIbllblx npaB II oco6bllf npeIIMV皿eCTB,BO3MO>KHO,THTyJIaBe,JIIIKOrOKHFI3月《BCeflPyCH>""
Bblnaqa I'IBal-IoM III IIMMyHHTeTHblx rpaMoT B l497 r.
nOKa3blBaeT, qTO y)Ke C CaMOrO HaLIaJIa rO" BeJIIIKOrg KHfl-

3H KpaiiHe 6ecnoI(o"a cylb6a yrJIIIIIa K PocToBa B Mae
l497 r・BbmaeTCH 6eJIO3ePCKafI TaMO>KeHHafl rPaMOTa.
B IIIoJIe l497 r. BemKIIii KHFI3bⅢ凡eT na>Ke Ha PacmlipeHIIe

BJIa,meHIIii BoJIoUKKx KHH3eiiB TBepcKo# 3eMJIe.B npoMe>KyTKeMe>KnyoceHblo1496r.II3BrycToM1497r.yneJIFIJIocb
BHIIMaHHe BoJIoroXcKoMy ye3ny.

TaKHM o6pa30M, yrjlIIII, PocToB, BeJIoo3epo, BoJIor",
TBepb - BoTnpmMepHbliKpyI:̲TeppllTopmit,BbI3bIBaBmmx

HaH6OJIbmHe on̅aceHIIH HBaHa lll eme nP nPme3na nocJIOB

oT CTe｡aHa B aBrycTe l497 r. MbI 3HaeM, IITo ¥roBopmHKH
l497 r. no,moBapHBaJIH BacIIJIﾙIH '3axBaTHTb BeJIOo3ePo H
BoJIorXV, BacIIJIll曲RBJIHJIcH HeJ,aBHHM cyBepeHoM TBepH,
OH IIMeJI Ka皿ⅢH, BePOfl'THO nPeTe皿OBaJI Ha yrJIIILI II MOr

PaCC(IHTblBaTb
Ha
nOユュep>KKy
cBoPIx
cTopoHHIIKoB
B
BoJI'oKoJIaMcIKoM ye31e 4'. <<3aroBop ryceBa nycTHJI KopHH He ToJIb-

Ko B yrJImKoM KHH>KeHIIH. HIITII 3aroBopa 3axBaTHJIII M

4pyrHeye34bl…:BoJIormy,BeJIoo3epo,BoJIoKJIaMcKIIM)D42.
4! BJIII3KIIe K BacIIJIHIo EponKIIHbl npHHanJIe]KaJIM K oKpy)KeHIIIo BQJI(lLI-

KIix KHH3e曲(JI B il e p e n H H IL S/Kaa coII., T. 21̲̲ cT,p. 295) .
C Hocli｡oM BOJIonKIIM BacmJImii 6bl" cBHaaH [lepe3 ･oHp qem皿HmHbIx
(FI. C. JI y p b e. nepBble "eoJIol,II.…, CTP､83, npHM. 4),

42 jl B. Il erPe II H II If yKa3. cot1., q2, cTp､294,
87

PeaJIbHafIonacHocTbcocTopoHblBacHJIIIHIIo6ycJIoBMJIa HoBoe Bo3BblmeHHe nMHTpIIfl-BHyKa B aBrycTe l497 r.,
nPH 3TOM BHemHenOJIHTHIIeCKHe CO6blTIIH MOrJIH 6blTb JIHmb

nOBoIoM HJIIf 6JIarOBHユHblM nPeXJIOrOM J;JIH nPOBeneHHfl B
>KII3Hb co3peBmero pelueHIIH. CorJIacHo TeKcTy CTenellHIoi
KHHrlI, HaIIaJIo <<rHeBa)D HBaHa lll Ha Co*bIo H BacMIJ1Hfl
'Hy)KHO OTHecTII K neP.BOhnoJIoBIIHe l497 r. Coo'6皿aH oⅡo-

lK"oBaH" BacIIJIIIIo THTyJIa BeJIHKoro KHH3H 21 MapTa
1499 r., CTeneHHaH KHIIra yKa3blBaeT, IITo HBaH III IIMeJ]

rHeB Ha >KeHy l'I CbIHa <<MaJIblM 60 nPen cHM, HKO 3a nBa
JIeTa> 43.

BOPb6a C cenaPaTIIcTcKIIMII Tel･皿eHuHHMH BaCHJIIIH Be-

JIacb HBaHOM III B PacrleTe Ha nO旦旦eP>KKy CPelHI1x cJIOeB

KJIaCCa*eO"JIOB
HnOCanlcKIIX
JIIOnie曲，COOTBeTCTBylOmIIX
ye3,IoB (rpaMoTa nIIJIbeMoBbIM, rpaMoTa noKpoEcKoMy
ylIJIIULKOMy
MOHaCTblPlO,
6eJIo3ePCKaFI
TaMO>KeHHafl
rPaM6Ta) . He cJIyIIaiiHo HMeHHo B ceHT26pe l497 E nPaBIIT6"bcTBonpHcTynHJIoKBblpa60TKeCyne6HIIKa,BKoTopoMHenpenyCMaTPIIBaJICH Cyn ymeJIbHblX KHH3eii 44.

Bce aTII MePbl B coIIeTaHHH c pemeHHeM o6'bHBIITb nMIITPIIH-BHyKa BeJIHKHM KHR3eM BLI3Baml B3PbIB He40BoJIbCTBa

rpynnIIpoBaBmIIxcH BoKpyr BacIIJIHH cTopoHHHKoB npe>KHeih
aBToHoMHH pa3JIIIIIHblx o6JIacTeii. CTeneHb arpeccHBHocTH
3 arOBOP皿IIKoB HaM HeH3BecTHa. HacKoJIbKo pemllTeJIbHo

co6HpaJIIIcb oHH npeTBopHTb cJIoBa B XeJIo, HeHCHo. O"aKo
JIer"̲noHHTb, [ITo pa306JIaIIeHIIe 3aroBopa 6blJIo XJIH HBa-

Ha lll y406HblM cHoco60M o巾皿HaJIbHo OnPaBnaTb lI y3aF
KOHIITbBO3Bb皿eHHenMIITPHFI-BHyKa,cO3naTbHoBylOnOJIH-

TIIIIecKylo cPIcTeMy. KopoHanHH I498 r・ToJIbKoBHemHe”ⅢIacb pe3yJIbTaToM pa3rpoMa 3aroBopa B neKal6pe l497 r.

①aKTIIIIeCKH>Ke,CymlnOCOUmaJIbHOiiHanPaBJIeHHOCTH
BHyTPHnOJIHTHqecKOro

KyPca

BTopoh ⅡoJIoBHHbl l497 r.,

H|BaHIIIcBFI3blBaJICB,O3Bblm|eHPIeMnMIITP}IH-B'HyKanP'OBeg
meHHe
onPenleJIeHHOii
cOUma､mbHo-no&JIHTHIIecKo曲ⅡpOrp
aM
Mbl.

HOcMOTPliMX<e, KaKOii xaPaKTeP HOCmJIa BilyTPeHH"

LIQJIHTIIKa B I498 r. OKa3bIBaeTcH, BeJIHKIIih KHfI3b nMIITp"
HBaHoBHEI He BblnaBaJI Ii He noITBep>KnaJI >KaJIoBaHiibIx

rpaMoT.OHBbmaBaJITo.mbKorpaMoTbl̅onpoI13Bo4cTBecyna
no 3eMeJIbHblM TH>K6aM H o pa3'be3ne cnopHblx 3eMeJIb, cV-

W UCPJI, T2 1 , 81'ol]afI no｡IIoBIIHa, cTI). 57 1 -572.

4'! C. B B e c e JI o B c K II ii. BJIa"IMIII) ryccB.･･, CTl). 42
68

皿JI
B
HOCJIe皿eii
IIHCTaH皿H3eMeJIbHble
XeJIa
45.
nMIITpMikBHVK,
nO-BH瓜mMoMy,
He
HMeJI
KaKHx-JIH60
TeppHToplIii
Ha
ご 46.IIB3TOMc9PTOHJI0erOKaUeCTBPHH9e̲9T=
npaBaXyneJIa

jiiiIllie df KHH3H BaclIJIM MBaHoBIIIla, KoTopbIih o6bILIHo
coIIeTam cyne6Hble byHK皿mB OTHOmeHHHo皿IIX ye3八oB c

yXeJIbHblMH
nPaBaMH
Ha
Te
)Ke皿Ⅲ叩yme
ye3nbI.
HHblMII
U

6JIoBaMm,Hoo6LeMynoJIHoMo叩岱瓜MIITPlin-BHyK,HeCMOTPH

Ha cBOii BeJIHKOKHH>KecKIIi THTyJI, 6blJI MeHee nOJIHOnPaBU

U

HblM,qeMBacHJIMIii.OHHBJIHJIcFIJIHmbCOnPaBIITeJIeM,｡aKTII'IeCKHnOMOmHIIKOM BeJIIIKoro KHFI3H, a He caMocToRTeJlbHblM VAeJIbHblM cyBePeHOM.

3TOTxaPaKTePBJIaCTHⅡMHTPHfI6blJIOTJIMI[IHOIIOIIHT
Ha 3anane. KeHHrc6eprcKIIM KoMa皿op JIIonBIIr巾oH 3aHcreiiM, nOCJIaHeU xoxMeiicTepa, nllca" !IMnepaTopy MaKcIIU

⑪

｡

U

MHJImaHy, 'ITO CO cBOHM BIIyKoMくCTaPblPi rOCynaPb O且HH
U

,neP>KIIT B CBOIIX PyKax ynPaBJIeHlie｡, 3eMJIem m He xoW
u

瓜onycTI1Tb co6cTBeHHblx IByx cblHo"PI K ynpaBJIeHIIIoH川I

Pa3neJ1y
3eMJIH・3To
nJIH
MarIICTPa
JIHBOHl皿Ⅲ瓜JIFI
Ho'ITellHor,o OpneHa
ユ Bo MHIorl'Ix oTHo皿eHIIFIx TfDKeJIO H !HeBblTO4Ho:
U

OpFIelfHeMo>KeTnpoTHBocToHTbcToJIb60JIbmoiicHJIe,coCjelOTOqeHHOii B O"mX PyKax, B O T JI II [l m e O T T o ｢ 9
nO!JIo)KeHIIFI,

Korna

3eMJIFI

noneJIeHa

Me>K八y

45 Aq)3IIX, qJ, Nb 1 17, 259, 308, 309 (CrP 362) ;̲ACSILI ,I, Nb 619;
TJI, ,M.116; J1. B. Ll e l) c n n !In. ylia3. coq…【L 2, cTp 238 (o llI)aBblx

rI)aMOTaX
Cy"
ZIM!ITPlifL
HBallO911qa)

4(' B oLHoih !13 cBoIIx pa60T A．A. 311MH1.I BbIcKa3aJI npem110.｢Io>KeHIle,

qTo 4kopoHauIIfI B 1498 n ZIMIITpliII IjpaHoBMqa 23Haqa"na noJIIjoe nllli-

"H,lig"ero nl)aB Ha TBepb:' (A A 3 !:! M II H OcHoBHI,le npo6JIeMbl""

cTp・105); o,nlla]<o B c'raTbe, B1'1山e皿Ieii nO31IIee, 3TO nPeJ､nOJIO)KellHe

cIIhTo(A.A.3IIMHH・OnoJ1MITIIIIGcKMxnpeJInocblJIKax…,cTp34)

neiicTBilreJ1bHo, UaHHblx o nel)enajie mMmpMIo TBepli｣ }IcT(IWIliax

11eT.nPaBRa,BくqIIHe>,BeHLIaHI畑ⅡMIITPH知nocmTcKynoroX.280ro56i)iITch, ilT6 0H 6bm nO)l､BaH̲<､KeCTB9W Eo"2皿IMepCKblM II

MCCKoBcKblM II HOBropomKHMHT*epcI<MM' (fl. C <rI y p b e. Iｲﾕeo←
JIo!rIwecKaH 60pb6a…., 6Tp. 385) OmaKo H C J1ypb(' He oTHocIII 3ToT
CnIIcOKKLIIIcJIyOTI)a>KawOIIlJⅨ nepBoHaqa｡nbHylop"2KU1.11o.KI)oMe
Toro, 3.mecb nPIIBenel( TwITyJI, a He nePe:leHb l)eaJIWo nepemell山しIx K

nMITl)ilio o6"iacTeiO6bl4Ho, ｢oBopmoBeHqaHIIM qMIITp"lJig9IWki! VI<a3blBaIOT TO&mbKO ,mBe TGpPIIToPmambHble aTI]HqynI堀，巾IIrypHpyIolllIieBBeJIH'KOKHmKeCKOMTMTyJIe: fBQJIO皿M eP'CKHⅢHMOCKOBCKHH》
J

u

11ʻⅢⅢ《MOCKOBCKmiIIHOBrOPOIICKHわ.
norol.
B>KG2803811McT|IIoBaHIMe
U

H3 BeJIIIKoKHfI)KecKOro TIITyJla n()皿JIo naJIbme. B 及師IJIoMaTHLIecKHx

4oKyMeHrax l498 E HBaH III BblcTynaeT, KaK M IIpe"21̲̲gllIIMI
Ee.miKOrO KH,13m <<BOIIO"MePCKOrO l! MOCKoBCKOrO [I HoBoroPOJIcKOrO [1
ncKoBcKorol1T巾c I) c K o r o !1 ̲̲IoToI)cKoTo H ､6oJIral)cKoro 1i lillJJIx"
､

("C6 PllO", 'L 35, cTI)250, 254. Pa3P皿Ka MOf').
89

r o c y n a p JI M H> 47. He cJIenyeT, KoHeIIIIo, a6coJIIoTH3IIPoBaTb 3TO BbICKa3blBaHI1e, nOcKOJIbKy OHO COXeP>KHTCH B He-

naTHPOBaHHOM HCTOIIHHKe,

I-IO TaK

HJIHHHaIIe,

KOPOHalIIIH

旦MIITPHH-BHyKa IIMeJIa, no-BH皿MOMy, HCHO BblPa)KeHHylO
aHTHyneJIbHyIO

HanPaBJIGHHOCTb

H

O3Ha[IaJIa

ToP>KecTBO

CaVOnleP)KaBHH
4a
lLMIITPmii-BHyK
6bIJI
nOJIIITmrlecKOii
｡Iiry-

POII HOBOrO THⅡa. Ero nocJIeloBaTeJIbHoe Bo3BblmeHHe Ha

BceM nPoTH>KeHHm90-x roloB (no KpaihHeii Mepe, c l492 r.)
H|e COnPOBo>KnaJIIO|cb nPenPCTaBJIeHIIeM GMy KaKHX-JIII60 3eMeJ1b B yneJI 49. BHoJIHe ecTecTBGHHo, IITo IIMeHHo oH oIKa-

3aJICH y TPOHa PHnPM c HBaHOM III nocJIe Pa3rPoMa nPoyneJIbHOrO 3arOBOPa.

OnHaKo HeJIb3FI nyTaTb nepBoHaulanbHblii 3aMblceJI, npHBenmlIit K KOPOHalII'III, C ee o6BeKTHBHblMIi nOCJIe4CTBIIFIMI1.

nOHBJIeHIfe BToPOrO 60JIee IIJIH MGHee HaneJIeHHOrO PeaJIbU

HoII

BJIacTblo

BeJIHKOrO

KHH3H

eXBa

JIII

MorJIo

B

Te'IellIIe

CKOJIbKO-HII6y八b nPonpJI>KHTeJIbHOro BPeMeHII cHOCo6CTBoIBaTb ,pocTy caMoLep>KaBIIFI. BblJIo 6bl MoXepHH3aUme曲Ⅱpen-

noJIaraTb nJIH KoHUa XV - HaIIana XVI B cyry60 *yHK皿o"JIbHbIii xaPaKTeP BJIaCTII nMHTP" KaK COnPaBHTeJI兄
HBaHa lll. B ycJIoBIIflx e皿e >KHBOih ymeJIbHOh瓜eiiCTB HTeJIbHIOcTII POJIb BT,oPorO BeJIIIKOro KHFI3H MOrJIa 6blTb ToJIbKO

｡yHK皿oHaJIbHo-TeppIITopIIaJIbHoih, T. e. caMo npllo6meHIIe
,LIMHTPHH K rOcynaPCTBeHHOMy yrlpaBJIeHHIo yﾝKe IIpe40npe47 Pa3pHIKa MoFI．《Supplementum ad Historica RLIssiae Monumenta>D.
Pei[opoli, 1848, M 121, S 312 ("TIIpyeTcH npeano.molKIITeJIbHo
l498 romoM); H. C・JIypbe・nepBble皿GoHorm..,, cTp. 97; LEKUB,

2-,te Abt, B(l. 1,，JMb 1023, S 772 ("TIIpyeTcH BI)eMeReM Me no3皿ee

aBrycra l500 r.). Ha nocIIGMIee li3zIaHMG KaK Ha iIcToIIHIIK cBe4eHI1ii o
JHIHa'cTHIJecKoii 60pb6e B PoccIIII KoI[Ua XV ･- IIa[IaJIa XVI B. MoG

BHHMaHHe川O6e3HO O5I)aTIMa A.几Xopol''KeBIi[1.
49月．C. JIy l) 1] e. nel)BI)IG IIJGoJIoF､I,I..., cTp. 97-98; o l, >K G･I/heoJIor}1 .
'lecKaFI 6ol)b6a..., cTl)、384-385; HA. Ka3aKoBa I1 H. C.JIVDL,e.

AHTIｲ巾eonaJIpHble epeTHIIecKHe nB}I>KeHIIfl Ha P)'cM XIV - Haula&ma
XVI BeKa. M.­几, 1955, cTp・194:Cp. JT. B. LlepenHIII-i. yK23・colI.'
'J. 2, cTp. 304-305 1I c&meX.: A. A. 3 i,I M II I-I. O.cHom化｢e npo6JIeMbl.̲,
Q､p. 105; o H )K e. O Do@JIIIT'II1ecKMIx npeﾉmocbmKax…, cTP. 34-35.
49 TaKoe oTHo山eHIIe l/IBaHa llI K nMIITPIIIO MOr､!IO 6MTb CnelCTBHeM
PI,meiiHoji 6JIII30cTM Me>Kny rpynnoii EJieHbI Bo,mo皿aHKH H BeJmKHM
KH兄3eM･BocnIITaHHblii llaHﾕeHx KepeTIIKOB>, HMI'ITI)", BO3MO>KHo,
6brJI MeHee npoHHKHyT ynteJIDHoii ncIIxOJIorl,Ieii, uleM BdcIIJIIIii, II no3To4
My 60JTbme rOmlJIcFI Ha pOJIb cO11paBIITe@JIFI BeLIIIKOI､o KIiH3FI. HaM Ka.

>KeTcH nPaBIIJIbHblM Te31IC H．C.̲JIypbe O KPynHoM BMane ePeTIIKOB
B MeQJOirHIO caMOJIeP>KaBⅢ兄（H C．!JI y p b e. nepBble皿eoJIor,11"、

c'Ip. 1O6; cp. I1poTIIBoHoJIo>KHyIo ToIIKy jPGIIⅡ列 Ⅲ. II. CMIIpHoBa 《BoIIPoclJI McToPHIi>, 1952, Nb l l , cTp. 143, ilpHM 3) .
卯

AeJIHJIO Pa3MeJKeBaHIIe nOJIHoMo'IHii ne,Ⅱa H BHyKa B TePPHToPHaJIbHOM oTHOmeHHII.

CoxpaHIIBmmecHrpaMoTb]
noKa3bIBaIoT,qTon<MMTpmIo

6blJIHnonBeXOMcTBeHHDI

CJIenylO皿He

ye31bI:

Mo)KeT

OblTb

(xoTH oTmoXb He HaBepHHKa) , BoJIoroXcKIMii 50; KpoMe̲Toro,

BeJIO3ePCK" (B巾eBpaJIe l498 r.Z m nos皿ee 52), nepe-

cJIaBJIb:3aJIecckIIX(B̅MapTel498r.53),KocTpoMcKoii(naTbl
HeT 54) , Be)KenlKIIi (B 7007 r") .
B3TO >Ke BPeMH IIBaH III nPOBO瓜HJI aKTIIBHylo 3eMeJIb-

HyIO HOJIIITIIKy B ye3"x C)gaJIbCKOM , (H3BeCTIIH MaH
1498 r. 56 II 7006 r. 57) , IOpbeB-noJIbcKoM ("Tbl HeT, npen-

noJIo>KIITeJIbHo B 1497/98 r. 58) , KoJIoMeHcKoM (naTbl HeT,

npe皿oJIo>KIITeJIbHoB1497/98E59),HInKeropoXcKoM(BoKTiI6pe l498 f 60) , MocKoBcKoM (B IeKa6pe l498 E 61 H B
7007 m).

OIIeB皿ⅡO, PaHbme npynIx TePplITOp砿瓜MIITPl戒ⅡoJIy-

IIIIJIB ynPaBJIeHHeBeJIO3ePcK城 Ⅲ(npe皿OJIO>KIITeJIbHO )
BoJIoroIcKHik ye3Xbl・Bo3Mo)KIIo, nepeXamJa Hx eMy cocToFIJIaCb He3anOJIrO nP o｡II皿aJIbHoii onaJIbl BacIIJII1H 62 H B
○

KaKOi-TO MePe, no-BI皿HMOMy, B CHJIy nPeTeH3HHHOCJI enHerO

Ha 3TH o6JIacTH 63. HenapoM IbflK enpp CTpoMwIoB B
50 AC31'i, TJ11, Nb 279 0LHaKo y Ha|c Her yBePeFIIo(TI{ ̲B ToM, IITo
ソ

ⅡO皿MCaBm'IIirPaMOTy@<KHfl31)IMIIT1)CilllBalIOBIJIIb》ユeiicTBIITembllo
且MIITI)mii-BHyK. Mo)KeT 6bl'rb, rPaM､OTa OTMOCMTCH I< ｡ aBrl!cTy-Cell-

Tfl61)lO l499 r. II (bIIryplipyeT B He曲且PyrOii nMIITI)IIii - TPeTHii CbIH
HBaHa lll oT 6paKa c Cod)be曲ⅡaʻⅡeo,Ⅲo正
1

5I AC311, T. II, Nb 416｡

52 A3MX, [1. 1, JYb 308; cAI. TaK>Ke JYb 309, cTp. 262.
5; TaM )Ke, Nb 117.
5{ TaM )Ke, 259.
55 ACam, T. 1, JYb 619.

56 TaM >Ke, T・II, Nb 494 (yn.: AC3II, T. 111, cTp. 479, rp. 53).
57 TaM )Ke, T. l1, Nb 491, 493.
58 TaM >Ke, T. I, Nb 615.
59 TaM )Ke, T. 11, Nb 414
60 TaM )Ke, T. 111, JYb 305.
6' Am3IIX, L1. 1, Nb 32.

62 rpaMOTa，KacaIoIllafIcH BoJIocTH qaBIIb[ B 3aKy6eHbe BoJIoroggKoro
』

V63", H6xo"JIa oT IIBaHa lll, Ho 6blJTa no皿HcaHa《KH”eM妙且MHTbmeM HBaHoBI'1[IeM．Ⅲ．A・roJIy6UoB
pHeM
HBaHoBHtleM. H. A roJIy6UoB oTHocIIT
oTHocI{Tee
eeKE
Kc BI〕eMeHH，HenoBpeMeHm, ̲Heno-

cpeacTBeHH|O
nPe且mecTBoBaBmEMy
nO>Ka@JIoBaHIIIQ
HMFTPlIH
BeJIKKoKMAfecKIIM THfyJIoM (AC3I'I, T.I11, Nb 279) . 31 0 npenno.IIo>KeHIIe
HeJIb3fl PaCCMaTPllBaTb !IHaqe, KaK IOra"L

630Eo3Mo>KHblx.npeleH3IMHx]1Hane>""̲Bac]m順HCo*blfHaBeJIoo3epo cM.: J. F e n n ell.̲ OP・cit., p. 345; cp. A. A、3 H M II H. OcHoB-J
Hble nl)o6J1eMIJ1..., cTp. 106; o H )K e. O noJIIITHLIecKIIx IIPe,lnocI>IJIKax...;
cTp. 36
91

"oIIx npe"0>KeHIIHx Bac}IJIIIIo cBH3bIBaJI HJIaH Ha6era Ha

BoJIormy
H
BeJIoo3epo
Kli3panoiiil
c
HaJ
KHfI3eM
JMmfPmeME
U

BHy'KOM .

KoppHaUIIHIJMWpHfIcocToHJIacb4｡eBpa"H1498r"Ho

e皿eB巾eBpaJIe l498 E (J(o IMH nocJIe 4 qiitJIa, MbI He dHa") nepeqIaBJIb-3aJIeccKMM ye3ZoM Bena" "<HH3b IODIiii
⑥

HBaHOBH可64,BTop"cblHHBaHallloT6paKacCo*beiilhale9Jor,KoTopgjiynepeCjaBJIb6bLimopyileH,B"mlio,cpa3y
nocJIeonaJIblBac皿Ⅲ兄BeJIo3epcKHih,nepecJIaBcKHMH̅Kdt
u

U

gTPOMcK'0IIye3nbIHBJIHJIHCb6bIBmeiicq)ePOjiBm呪'H1畑KHH3H
B a'cHJIHFI.

轡

瓜MIITPHHMOrnPenLHBMTbnPaBalIHaXPyrHeye3JLI,
BxoJJIBmHe paHee

B

[IIIcJIo

HoJBenoMcTBeHHblx

BaCHJIHIo

3eMeJIb. He 3TIjM JIII o6'bflcHHeTcH cTPeMJIe!HHe IIBaHa lII

yTBep"T. fBoii cyBepeHIITeT B HpoCJIaBJIe, me BacIIJI"

HMeJI
1496
B r．ⅡOJII-IOMOIII旧くrocy且a”>ｳ？B
MapTe
l498r．
CnaccKmiFIpocJIaBcKlijiMoHacTbiP6IioJIy[lliJIoTLnMIi5̅Iii
u

>KaJIOBa"ylO rPaMoTy, cTaBIIBmylO Bce HaceJIeHMe MOHaU

CT･IPCKoH BOTqIIHbI, a TaK>Ke aPxmMa"pIITa m 6PaTHIo no八
oneKy ,H KoHTpoJIb BeJIIIKoKHH>KecKoro npHcTaBa C・OXHH-

WBa
(noJIIIHmlicy,ne6HbIxUeJIcnocTojoHHIIM"皿aM'I).
mHbIe
nPmCTaBbI
He
mMeJIII
nPaBa
<<HaMeTLIBaTBM"MM
BC皿" "9aTb Ha nopyKIi apxIIMaHnpIITa, cTapUeB II Kpe-

grbHH"HMeHHOBIeJIfIx̅HeiiTPaJIif3auHⅢnPHTH3aHIIII
且MIITPIIH
BeJIHKIIH
KHH3b
nOCTaBHJI
HoIKOHTPOJIb
cBOerO
U

｡

U

nPlETaBaBcIoBOTIIIIHyHamqoJIeeBJIIIHTeJIbIIoro̅BHPoCJIaB-

JIe CnaccKoro MoHacTbIpfl. rpaMoTa l498 r. orpalilitlII"",
nO-BH且HMOMy,IOPHC且HKⅡHIOPocToBcKOroaPxmenlICKOna:nP

1498r.HeBcTpegaeTcHrpaMoT,3aKpenJfHIo皿ⅢxⅡoncynU

⑪

HOcTb HaCTOHTeJIeH H MoHaxoB HpocJIaBcKIIx MoHaCTblpeii

PFJIHKoW̲K"3IO(BePOHTHO,HxCy皿JIapxHenHcKon)
Mepa
.
"aH31116bIJIaCir"ymiPoBaHa̅OcTPoioiiBHyrPHnOJIHTII｡

IIeCKOH CHTyaUmHl498 r" Kor" npOTHBoHocT3B)IeHIie HHTePeCOB aPxHenHcKOna H MOHaCTblPH MorJIO ycIIJIIITb nO3HU I I H B e J I H KO r O K H H 3 H .

BTOM,qTOoTHOmeHIIHMe>KmyliBaHoMIIIIInMIITPmeM
Pa3"BaJIIIcb OTHIOnb He rJIa"O, CoMHeBaTbcH He nPIIx6"T-

gL TaK, nepexQI B cbepy BJI"H" nMHTpliH B"EMfo
Bepxa, KoTopblii npe""EJIHJI co60ii ilacTL EbiMjmi6f5
U

64 AC3I/1, T. 1, Nb 617.
051､nMンKe, T. 111, M216
92

yrJIH且Koro yXeJIa, eIBa JIH Bxo"IJI B nePBOHaulaJIbIII)Ie PacIIeTbl IIBaHa lll.

POCT nPeTeH3池瓜MHTPHH OTPa>KaeT SBOJIIo皿H ero
一

T H Ty J I a .

B

6oJIb皿HHCTBe

JIeToHIICHblx

cBonPB

rOBOPHTcFI,

IITO

ⅡMHTPHii 6blJI Ho>KaJIOBaH《BeJIHKIIM KHfl)KeHIIeM BoJIoAHMepcKIIM H MocKoBcKKM Bcea PycH》; B meTOHHcHoM PaCCKa3e O nePeMoIIHII BeHIIamiH OH HecKoJIbKO Pa3 Ha3blBaeT-

cHBeJIHKHMKHH3eMくBCefIPyCH》66.JIHmbBKPaTKHXcOo6meHHHx EpMoJIHHcKoi, TImorpa｡cKoit, BoJIoroXcKo-nepMCKOii JIeTOnliceii H xPOHOrPaba OTCyTcTBylOT CJIOBa <BceH

PyCII), 67.B <<LIHHe)> HocTaBJIeHHH nMHTI)HA TpIDK"I IIMeHyeTCHBeJIHKHMKHH3eM<<BceJIPycH方68.
B JIHTepaType mHpoKo I)acnpocTPaHIIJIocb MHeⅡme o

npHcBoeHIM UMIITpHIo B 1498 r. THTyJIa BeJIHKorqKHH3fl
<<BceH Pycli>". Cy旦月ⅡO JIeTOIIIIcHblM Ii3BecTHFIM Ii <<qlIHy>>
BeHIIaHHH, OH II B caMOM neJIe 6blJI Ha3BaH nPH KOPoHa皿珊I
BeJIIIKHM KHH3eM <<BceH PyCH》．OJHaKo HoKyMeHTaJIbHbl ih

MaTePHaJI HoKa3blBaeT, IITO nMIITPlm CPa3y nocJIe noCTaB､neHHH Ha BeJIHKOe KHH>KeHHe noJIb30BaJIcH ToJIbKO TIITyJIOM

BeJIHKOrO KHH3H, HO He BeJIHKOrO KHH3H <<BCeH PycH>.

B rpaMoTax nepBblx MecflUeB 1498 r. B TIITyle BeJIIIKPro
KHH3H nMIITPHH IIBaHOBwIa HeT CJIOB《BCefl PyCH>D. 3TO
ⅡOnOJIHeHIIe nOHBJIHeTCH B 6e>KeUKOii rPaMOTe, BblnaHHoii

H'e paHbme ceHTH6pH 1498 r. 69, II B HeXaTMpoBa･HHoM 6eJIo3ePCKOM cynJHOM cHIIcKe, KOTOPblii Ha[IIIlIaeTcH cJOBaMH
《ⅡOrocynaPeBerPaMOTeBeJIIIKOI10KHH3HmMHTPeaIIBaHOBHII" H KOHIIaeTcH ｡Pa30的《<H O ceM cyntba PeKcH AOJIo-

>KIITH rOCynaPH BeJIIIKOrO KHH3H (KaKoTO? - C K) BCea
PycH, a CTaPUy HrHaTblO rPaMOTy BeUeJI IIPJIO>KZTH nePenl
B6JIIIKHM KHFI3eM)' 70. EcJIH BecHoii l498 r. IIBaH III ynleJIHJI
60JIbmoe BHIIMaHHe TeppHTopHHM, 6blB皿mM HeKOrna B BenoMcTBe HBaHa H BacIIJIHFI HBaHoBmqeii (Cy3naJIbcKm曲，
66 nCPJI, T. 1V, u. 1 , Bblll. 2, cTp. 531 ; nCP几T､VI, cTp. 241-242;
T. V111, cTp、234-235; T. XII, cTp. 234-235; T. 20, nePBam noJIoBIIHa,
cTp. 366-368; T. 28, cTp. 330-331.
67nCPJI，T、22，cTl〕、513；T，23，CTP、1961T，24，CTI)．213;T.26,cTI).291;
C. 0.皿MH且T. npo八o凡>KeHIie xPoHorpa(!a l)"aKumI] 1 51 2 rona.くしIcTopmIlec,KMii apxIIB>, 'r. V11. M., 1951, pTp. 273.
68 JI3AK, 1864 r.，BbIⅡ．III­CH6.，1865．，”no？KmHH，cTp、10，12，15；
<qTeHI1H OI'IJP)', 1883, KH. 1, [oT4.] 1, rTp. 36, 38. 0 <<LIIIHe> cM no4-

po6Hee:H.C・JI yl)be．Ⅲ,瓜eOJ1OrwIecKaH60Pb6a".,cTI)、384-387.
6リAC31'I, T. I, Nb 619.
70 A3HX, u. I, JMb 308, cTp. 257, 261.
93

HPOCJIaBcK".XC"bl)To
, nPHcBOeHHenMIITpmeMBoBToPoii
noJIoBIIHe
!498ETHTyJ1a
BeJIHKoroKHH3"､<BceHPycH》H
erO XaJIbHeHmHe TePPHTOPHaJIbHble nPeTeH3HH3aCTaBJIHJIH

HBaHalllycIIJIHBaTEcBOlinO3HuIIIIBHeHTPe,BMOCKOB-

cKOM ye3ne.

EaBrycTel498EMBaHIIIBbImaJI)KaJIoBaHHylorpaMo-

TyllyAoBy̲MoHacTblploHac.MapbHHoBBbl皿eropo八cKoM

ye3¥̲(HanOngJPe)TeKcT3TOrOnOKyMeHTaHec6xPaHHル

cH.BonHcli̲1755 E rpaMoTa onpeneJImeTcH KaK <<c"llaf!》
(Hecy皿MaH?),<<Ha,KpecTbHHIIHampoT[Iee>71Cl473rBblmeropon HaxoHIIJIcFI B cocTaBe BoJIoUKoro KHFDKecTBa 72.

BpeMfLerOnepexonaUpyKHBeJIMKoroKIIH3HToIIHoHelI3BecTHo.B¥､B.Ko6pHHBIJIcKa3aJInpennoJIo>KeHIIe,IIToBo3Bpa皿ellHe Bblmeropona B IIIIc,nO BeJIIIKOKHFI>KGCKIIx BJIaneHMii
oTHocMTcfl, cKopee Bcero, K 90-M ToXaM XV B., Korna co-

CToHJICFI nPyrOih o6MeH 3GMJIHMH Me>K4y HBaHoM III II BoJ10UKHMII KHFI3bHMI1 73. 06MeH 3ToT HMeJI MecTo B IIIoJIe

l497 r. 74 HaJIHLIme rpaMoTbl l'IBaHa lll aBrycTa l498 r. Ha
BblmerOPo4cKme BしmaneHHH DoKa3blBaeT, LITo nPe且noJIo>KeHHe

B.B・Ko6pIIHaoBpeMeHHBKJ1Io[IGIIHHBblmefoponaBBeJIHKOKHH>KGCKII仇旦OMeH OKa3aomOCb nPaBI'mbllblM・BblnaLIa B

l498 E rpaMoTb! qynpBy MoHacTblPIo Ha ero BblmeropomCKHe 3eMLIIHHMeJIa nBOHKIIji nOJIHTII[IeCKH内cMblcJI: BO-nePBblX, 3TIIM aKTOM 3aKPemlHJICfl Pa3PblB BaCCaJIbHblX OTHO-

meHIf向Me)KmyHynpBblMMOHacTblpeM!IcbIHoBbfIMIIBopllca
Bac"beBHrla ｡enppOM Bo.mOUKIIM H MBaHoM Py3cIdIM),
KoTopbleb IIMeHHo c lj98 rmpIIcTynliJIM K aKTIIBHoii MMMy-

HIITeTHOi nOJIIITIIKe 75, BO-BTOPblX, yCTaHOBJIeHIIe COIO3a
Me>Kmy l/IBaHOM III I1 B川1HTGJI blleih皿HMBblulerOPOmCKHM
BOTqHHHIIKOM, KaKH̲M FIBJIfI&IICfl l-lynPB MOIIaCTblPb, nPeceKa-

JIo nPeTeH3HH Ha Bblmeropo瓜旦MIITPlM-BHyKa, HOI LIbHM
KoHTpoJIeM HaXo"JIocb BeJIoo3epo (BblmeropoI cIIIITaJIcR
HacJIencTBoM MHxaliJla AHnpeeBIILIa BeJIo3ePcKoro, xoTH
nPHHanJIe)KaJI eMy ToJIbKO B cePe皿He XV B. 76) .
7; AC3I/i, T. 111, Nb 48a, cTp. 73, rP. 73.

72ⅡⅢⅡr, ̲M 69; Cp: JIOHII, Ko"J1. 238, on. 2, KapToH 264, JVb l, J1. 3
(ym.: AC3M,TIII, cTI). 483).

72E:､ PK o 6 P̲II MHBe>KaJIOBaIIHI,lerPaMOTM[lyllOByMoIIaCTblPlO
(XVI B.)­《3ajlllcKII oTneJIa pyKomlceii rocynaPCTBeillloii 6H6"iio-

TEKLIiM2 B.l1. JIeHIIHal, Bbm. 25. M., 1962, cTp. 305:

74 nmmr, JYb 86

75 ACal'i, T. 111, Nb 64; T. II, Nb 417.

76B1450-1454r『(B.B=Ko6pIIH.yKaacowI.,cTp.304)のaKT6blB-

meil npl,IHanlJIe)KHocTII BbImerol)ona MIIxaHJIy AIIAla'eeBIiIIy oTIIIonb
94

K KoHnv 1498 - Ha[IaJIy l499 r. nMIITp" 6blJ1 ｡aKTHqeCKII OTCTPaHeH OT yLlaCTIIH B neJIa)i "yTPg"erO ynPa"e"L Be6b KoMnJIekc IIcToLIIHIIKoB 1499-1500 IT. noKa3blBaeTOTcyTcTBMeyHerOKaKIIx-｡mll60noJIHoMo[IMIIBoW&皿eU

HI,IH
Ve3nPB,
HaxO瓜ⅢB皿HxCfl
BerO
KOMneTeH瓜HHB1498r.
OLIeB皿Ho,Bl499-1500rr皿eJ1cyne6Hbl曲nPoUeccBBe-

JIo3eDcKoMVe31e,1-IaIJaTblHⅡorPaMoTel'IBaHalll77・BanU

A

"5｢i" f "､e34 3eMIm l KOcTPoMcKoM "42̲Wg

nOmBe八oMCTBeHHOM UMHTPlIIO B nePHOnl erO nPaBJIeHIIFI II
HMeHI-!onO3GMeJIbHI)IM八eJIaM)nPOII3BO皿mCH《Ⅱorocyna-

h"̅EEJIIlKoroKHfl3fl̲LIBaHaBacmJlbeBmqaBceaPYpIWMoTe m no cm!cKy)P (KocTpoMa ̲D QIo ̲BpeMH yUPaBJIflJIaCb
BeJIIIKoKHFI>KecKIIM IBopeUKIIM) 78. B BoJIorontcKQll ye3¥,

FK6f51)61ii,MO)KeT6bl.Tb,HM""lillg-TOnPaBanVllW皿，

"b"yKoBoJIcTBoB*! R I499/1500 E rpaM"hmBaHa lllm且OKJIanblBaJI o nPOUeCce BeJIliKoKHH2KecKoMy Ka3-

HaLIelO 79. flCHO 3ane[IaTJJeH CyBePeHHTeT BeJIHKOTO KHH3H B
e llHBBJIbroTHoHrPaMoTeToTeMcKoroTHy­
JIbroTHom rPaMoTe ToTeMCKorO THyBoJIoro瓜cKoMye3八e
Ha oT l oKTH6pfl l499 r. 80. To Xie ̲noIW3blBaeT )KaJIoBaH-

" rPaMoTa l/iBaHa lll Haq"a l500 n8}

OieBMHo,eUeBnepBoMnoJIoBIIHe̲1499m6bIJ!mno且一

BePrHyTbIOnHCaHHIoPa311blecTaHblMOcKoBcKorOye3"
nmCeuMBaHalllB．Ⅲ.
rOJIeHIIII3aHHMaJICHOnllCaHIIeM82
fi̅"Ro6IIJI
peuleHIIH
no3eMeJ1bHblMTfDK6aM83B
MocKoB-

cKoM ye3"B <<7007)> E yroqHIITb naTmPo¥y,̲,nq2BoJI2"
Rak̅HAMka>KeTcH,pa3'be3>KafIIBopeUKoron.̲BBe"KoIMJ

iERa""8̅f84mcro̲)KGMencIBIIafmcKa6pH1499̲̲F"
HO-BH"I MOMy,八BOpenKIIii BelaJI 3eMeJIbHblMH且eJIaMH B
MOcKOBCKoM ye3ne nO 11 nocJIe八eHTeJIbHoCTIi nl,ICUa.
OT

KoHUa

l499

r.

IIMeIoTc月 旦al-IHble

O

CyBePeHH-

TeTe liBaHa . III B oTHomeHPIII ye3npB HH>KeropoXcKoro
＝了

一

He 6bI｡II 3a5I)IT II IIOCTOflHHo ynOMIIHa@mCH B MeﾝKJlyKHH>KecKIIx IOrOGQ=

paxmpl48@rEKJIIoqIITeJIbHo,(""HaWWSP,八OrOBOPl'IBaHalll
f̅Bo511coM BoJ1oUKMM aBr)'cTa l486 r.­恥旦r, JW 81, cTp. 317).
a

77 AC3ﾚI, T. 11, JMb 334.
7jAm3'(X, L1. 1, Jvb 260.
7" AC314, T. lll, JYb 276.
83 TaM )Ke, Nb 280.
81 TaM jKe, T・I1, Nb 300.
82 A(D311X, q. I, Nb 39.

1

83 ACSI,I, T. II, Nb 418, 419.
84 A3IIX, t1．1, Nb 32.
85 ACSH. T. 1, Nh 624.

戸

95

一

(ceHTFI6pb) 86, IOI)IjeB-no､｢lbcKoro (,IGKa61)b) 87, MocKoBcKoro (八elKa61)b) 88.

B To )Ke BpeMH IIHKaK1Ix cBemeHHii o6 ynpaBJIeHqecKIIx
noJIHoMOIIHHx IMHTPlifI II o erO po.m}I BO BHyTPeHHIIx neJIaX
aKToBble IIcToLIHIIKM I499-1500 rr．Ⅱ60JIee no34HIIe He

CoXeP
zKaT・3TO
HeJIb3fl
06'I､RCIIHTb
nOCJIenyIO皿ⅡMⅡ3'b月THeM
II yHIIﾘTO)KeHMGM 40KyMeHTOB C ero IIMeHeM, nOCKOJIbKy OT

1498 r. oHH IomJ1M. HarlllIII1e HcHblx npll3HaKoB BenHKoKHFI>KeCKOrO PaCIIOPfDKeHIIH KaK TePPliTOPlljlMH, 6blB皿IIMII B Py-

KaX IMMTPluI, TaK II TGMII, KOTOPble OcTaBaJIHCb 3a MBaHOM,
noKa3blBaeT, [ITo B l499 r. HMIITpHii He coxpaHm&m ynpaBJIeHIIeCKIIX ｡yHKUlm B OTHO山eHHIf CBOeih C｡ePb[ B'ﾉmHH”
1498 r. II He npHo6peJI B3aMeH Upyroih c(I)ePbi BJIIIHHIIH.
na八eHIie BJIIH11IIfl 4MIITI)lifl C Cepe皿Hbl l498 r. KocBGHHO OTPa3IMOCb lI B nJInJIOMaTIILIeCKO曲且OKyMeHTaUlllI. J1ﾙI山b

B MapTe l498 r. BG川IKliih KIIH3b 4MIITPllii HBaIIOBMLI巾HryPHPyeT B cnHcKe noKJIoHoB (cPa3y nOCJTe MBaHa lll; 3a HMM

"yT Co｡bH II E｡meHa Bo:iIomaHKa; Bce oHII 6blJIII npemcTaBJIeHbl nePBblM IIocJIoM; Ha3BaHHblx nocJIe EJIGHbI AeTek Be-

JIIIKOrO KIIH3別ⅡP"CTaBJIHJI BTOPOji rIOcOJI) 89. y)Ke B MIOJ1e
l498 r. noKJ10Hbl nepenaBaJIIIcb To.JIbKo oT I/IBaHa lll H

CoqJblI 90. HII JMMTpllii-BIIyK, HII ero MaTI, EJIeHa He ynoMHHalOTCH Ha CTPaHHUaX IIoCOJIbCKOhKI冊lrH B COXpaHI1BmHxcFI 3amIcfIx UepeMoIII1aJIoB l499-1500 rr. (npaBna, He
nOHBJIHIOTCFI TaM B 3TO BPeMFIm且eTH BeJIIIKOrO KHH3fl) .
Hano oTMeTHTb, LITo IIocoJIbcKMe 3amicI{ 3a
l498-1500 rl､、
rJIyxo coo6皿alOT O HOKJIOHax OT JIMTOBCKOrO BeJIHKOrO KHH-

3FI AJIeKca皿Pa (ynOMIIHalOTCH <<nOKJIOHbl), ]1"H《nOKJIoIlb1

nQ O6blIIalo>; B 3amlcI1 0 nplleMe nocoJIbcTBa l3 HHBapR
1501 r・cKa3aHo: <<a nPaBMJI oT BeJIHKoro KHH3FI AJIeKcaHJpa
o4HOMy
BeJIIIKOMy
KHH310HOKJIOH)>9').
のaKTHIIeCKOe OTCTPaHellHe 4MI1TPHFI OT BJIaCTH He Bblpa3}IJIocb B l499 r. B (bopMaJIbHoih orlame ero IIJIII B JIIimeHIIII TMTyJIa. KOI､瓜a 2I MapTa l499 ｢. l'IBaH III o6'bHBHJI
BacHJIHH BeJIIIKMM KIIfI3eM HoBropo4aH nCKOBa, nCKOBH'III
HOCJI aJIⅢ《61ITH [IeJIoM KHH3eM BeJIIIKIIM HBaHy BacIIJIbeBI1-

唖o H BHyKy ero nMPITpHIo HBaHoBIIIIIo> o ToM, IITo6bl <<nleP鋪
飯
部
鯛
卯
虹

ACSII, T. 111, JYh 306; cp. JVb 301.
Aの3HX, u. 1, Nb 157.
AC3H, T・I, N. 624.
KC6. PI'IO", T. 35, CTI). 250, 253.
TaM >Ke, cTp、261.

〆

TaM )Ke, cTl). 308．Pa3pFUKa MOFI
96

4

,

>KaJIﾙIoT[IIIHycBoIoBcTapHHe>92.CorJIacHoEpMoJIIIHcKoH

JIeTonHcH, BeJIHKIIi KHfl3b UMIITP" nPlicyTCTBOBajl npHⅡO-

CTaBJIeHHIi HOBOro KPyT皿Koi､o ernHcKona Tp"oHa 93
(14 HIoJIH 1499 r.94).
CHomeHHfl c HcKoBoM oTHocIIJIIIcb K o6JIacTH cKopee

BHemHe曲,rIeMBHyTpeHHeiinoJIHTHKH.KPymHuKafl>Keenapu

xHH
BenaJIa
nPHcOe且HHeHHblMH
B
cepelHHe
90-x
roIoB
o6JIaCT兄MII,
KOTOPble,n｡STOrO
nPmHanJIE)KaJIH
JIIITBe
95・Coxp
aq

HeHHe 3a nMHTPHeM-BHyKOM BeJIIIKoKHH>KecKOrO THIyJIa m

56bHcHHeT" ofqacTK -BHemHenoJIHTHqecKHMH coo6pa)Ke-

HIIHMH,
BO3Mo>KHo
aHTIIJIHTOBCKIIM
nPe皿a3HaIIeHIieM
nMIITpHfI (cp. ero poJIb B Mae l500 r.)̲:

O6iaTIIM6HKno｡llo)KeHMIoBacmJIMOerq̲､cymb6eB

1498 r: HeT HoIITH HHKaKHx Hane)KHbIx cBeneH". CoxpaHIIJI⑪

cH cmicoK
CH
CⅡHcoKKoHUa
KoHUaXVII
XVIIB.
B．c瓜aHHoH3anHcH，cocTaBJIeHHoH
c ,maHHoii 3anlIcH, cocTaBUgHHoH
U

oTHMeHHBacHJIHHHXapylomeHⅡepKBIIHHKoJIbIBnpy>K-

kax,Bo-nepBbIx,Ko>KaH66(nepraMeHHoe)epaHreJIme(Ha
KOT6POM
6bIJIa
II CnleJIaHa
naPcTBeHHaH
3anHcb)
Bo-gTOPbIX,
,
＝

onPeneJIeHHoeKOJIHⅥeCTBO3eMJIH《oCBHIIleHHoMyCOOOPyHa
⑥

KoMeHlie)'96BamicbnaTmpyeTcH1MaHl498rBaR¥,mH

Ha3BaH B Heii KHH3eM BeJIIIKHM <<BCefl PyCHⅢ》(MI B intitUlaU

U

tio，H Bno皿HcH)．HoBeHmHHH3“TeJIb3ToroⅡoKyMeHTa
cII) . HoBeim" II3"TeJIb 3Toro XoKyMeHTa

I/I.A.roJIy6UoBnHmeT:<<HelIMeHocHoBaHHi3anonP3PHTb
U

XaTy 3anHCm, He MO>KeM He OTMeTIITb HaJIIIqmfI B HeH He'liPｰ
TopbIx oco6eHHocTei fI3bIKa m cTpyKTypb[ 3amicII, KW ob[
〆

U

noMHeimeii peqm, a TaK)Ke II Toro, qTo TIITyJIgBaHye Bacu｡

⑪

JIIIeM caMor6 ce6H ,,BeJIHKIIM KHH3eM BceH Pycm(( BcKope
noCJIe TOP>KecTBeHHOrO BeHqa"H, C sTHM )Ke THTyJIOM, erO

nJIeMHHHIIKa KH.瓜ⅢMIITPIIH HBaHOBHIIa…nOKa3blBaeT He
ToJIbKo, IITo BacHJIHHHe
ToJIbKo，IITo
BacIIJI" He oTKa3blBaJIcH
oTKa3blBaJIcH oT
oT3Toro
sToro THTyJIa，Ho
TIITyJIa, Ho

qTo eMy, Mo>KeT 6blTb, H He 6blJIo 3anpemeHOmMⅡOJII>30BaTbCH> 97.

HacKoJIbKo H3BecTHo, B 1490-1497 rr. BacImlIii o｡II-

UHaJIbHoHeHMeJIHHTIITyJIaBeJIHKoroIQHH3fI<<BceHPycH>,
92《nCKoBcKHe JIeTOIII･ICII>p Bbm・l nPHroToBIIJI K neIIaTw A. Hac()HoB.
M・­几, 1941, cTp. 83.
93 <<A Ha nocTaBJIeHbH ero centeJI c MEITponoJIIIMToM Ha MecTe KHFI3I, ̲ee-

JIHKHAⅡMIITPeii HBaHoBIILIb H E"八blK nHTb> (nCPJI, T. 23, cTp. 196).
94 nCPJI/T. V111, crp. 237; T. XII, cTp. 249; T. 20, rlepBaH noJIoBHHa,
CTP、369; T, 28, cTp. 332.

9らⅢ. nOKPOBCKHH．PyccKIIe enapxHH B XVI-XIX BB., T. ̲ 1. Ka3a,Hb, 1897, cTp. 192-193.

96 ACali, T. 111, Nh 52.
97 TaM )Ke, cTp. 79.
7

C.M.Ka皿TaHoB

97

I-IIIBoo6皿92eJIHKoKlifIJKecKoroTIITyJIa:0H6bl"nPOcT!
SKHH3eM)>9aTaKIIMo6pa30M,roBoI)IiTboToM,uToemiV
ごIie
6blJIo
3anpe皿ellQ
nOJIb30BaTbcH
TIITyJIOM
BeJIHKoro
KHH3H
BceHPycWBl498r"HenpmxomHTcHPeqbMo>KeTmmm66

Ono3nHeAmeiio6Pa60TKe3anllcII,JIII600He3aKoHHOMnPll･
¥29e"MBacILimeM TIITy"a BemlKoro KHH3" BceH P"､

(nocJIenHeenOnynleHIIe-MblneJIaeMe皿enJIHIByXTeK-

cToB - KoHUa l497 m: JIbroTHo# ropoxoBeuKoro BbjiocTeJIH
II nonTBep>K4eHIiH K rpaMoTe l488 E KaJIH3KHv軍MoHaU

、

CTbIPlO) .

BoJIeeBepgHTHblM,
qeMTI1TyJI,
Ka>KeTcH
caM巾aKTCO-

xPaHeIIIIH 3a BacIIJIIIeM oTHocHTeJIbHoji cBo60n<bI 9j I] K"･
｡

④

lfec"POJIHHaKaKOii-TOO3eHby3KOiiTcPPHTOPmmBdnHOii
H3
3aMocKoBcKIIx
BoJIocTeii
(B6JIocTbくmePHa-rOPoﾕqK>,
IZIp̲IIaxoIIIJIacb nepKoBb HIIKoJIU B npy>KKax, npiHanlJIe2

>KaJIa K y,meJIDHOMy HaCJI"cTBy lOPﾙIH BaC"beBH[Ia nMIITPOBcKOrO) .

BMapTel498r.KHH3bBacIIJm曲HBaHoBH[IVHoMHHaJIcH
B cnlicKe noKJIoHoB JIIIToEpKoMy BeJIIIKoMy KHH3io AJIeKcaHnpy H BeJIHKoII KI･IHrHHe EJIeHe HBaHoBHe, xoTH II 3aHIIMaJI
B STOM｡ UePeMOljIIaJIe lIOPa3,IO 60JIee HH3KOe MecTo, [IeM
BeJ1HKM KIIH3b nMHTp" HBaHoBI1II (IIocJIG BacIIJIﾙ呪Ha3BaU

U

VpI "a npyrIIx cbIIia mBana lll [I Co(bbH-KHH3b lOpHi

HBaHOBHLI
KHH3b
PI
JMIITPm曲HBalloBII[I)
100.
nepenHcKec
B

JIHTOBCKIIM IBoPoM HBaH III cOxPaHHJI BII"MO6Tb BJIIIJIU

IgJIWWIoJIo>KeHI11I BeJIIIKoii KHfIrlilIH Coq)bm. EUe B ,eB-

pa､ﾉIe
l498
r.,
B
nepHon
KopoHa皿Ⅲ瓜MIITPHH-BHyKa,
nOKJIO¥WII"""bKo oT HBaHa lll H Cod)bli1ol n6c.IIe MapTa

1498r・｣"TeLIeHIIeBceronepIIonal499-1500rr.BfiyK,

4eTM I1 11eBecT" BeJIIIl<oIo KHH3fI He .liryPmPoBaJIII B cn"

KeIIoKJIoHoBO6bIIIHoik｡opMoHnPHBeTcTBIIHcIIIoJIH1498r.
｡

BHQBb, KaK̲MI B l496-1497 rr., cTdJIHⅡOKJIOHbl OT HBaHa lll

I,ICo巾bII
102.
3TO
CB皿eTeJIbPTByeT
O6
113BecTHoji
HeiiTPaJIHU

U

U

3aUllM Bpa>KJle611blX《nal]TIM>' co BTopon noJIoBPIHbl l498 110
l500 r. BKJII()IIIITeJIbllo.

9,3CM.T,aK)Kc:J.FG11､11el1.01).̲Fi,t,I).335;AA3mMIII-I.OcHoBHI,IG
III)06.JIeM
IDI…,CTp・l04,n1)11M63;oi{)KeOnojillTII[lecKinai"ii6Y
cIDI｡JTKax..., cTp. 33.
9p｡eHHeJInPe皿汀o.maraeT,
xITo
BacIIJIlljiく61Jm
nocax(el星no1且oMamHHH
U

apgpr"̲(JLfen ne l l. Op. cit" p 336)'

ICO《""9>,1̲35,cTP250,253;cP.J･Fennell.Op.cit.,p.338.
、261，274，278，289，292，294；cp．』．Fennell．Op・
l02TaM
cit., p. 338.
W iC6PHO>, T. 35, CTp: 243, 244

98

OIIeB皿Ho, B cynlb6e Bac皿mH Co｡bH 6oJ1bmylo poJIb

CblrPaJIIIneP▲
KOBHbleIIePaPxII、3aranoIIHaHnocBoeMycMblcq D

JIy bUeHaiOKaHHMHBaHalllOnliCaHaBIHⅡorp a｡cKoii

JIeTO皿cIIBcJIen3aPacCKa30MoKoPoHaUllHnMIITPmil-BHyKa,HocJIebPa3blくayJIo>KHJIcy八cy皿TII60HpoMHoCy'me6Mepa ryceBa nncaTm>. BeJIMK" KIIH3b, coHHKy[…]BoJIo皿MeparyceBanHcaTm>､BeJIHKImKHH3b,COrJIacHoTeKCTy,nPOcIIJInPO皿eHIIH《OcBOeM6PaTeKHH3e
AHnpee BacmJIbeBIIqe, qTo cBoIIM rpexoM, HecTopo>KeIo, erO
VMoPHJI". MHTponoJIHT >Ke m apxmenlIcKon ]i enIIcKonH c
“

△

HCnblTaHHeM H C BeJIIIIKblM HaKa3aHKeMHⅡOHy且Hma n npJI｣ro

BPeMFI H e八Ba nP'ocTHma II H HOHaKa3ama erQ BIIpenlb H KaK
661 eMV cBoH lyma HcnpaBHTH npen 60roM> !03. B T. H. cBoXe
1497 f. 3ToT >ke TeKcT̅ noMe皿eH noX 7005 r., nplIIIeM eMy

npe且mecTByeTpaccKa30ToM,KaKI/IBaHIII,HocOBeTOBaB-

mlIcb c MHTponoJIHToM CHMoHoM, HocJIaJI 3a aPxHemicKonoM PocTOBcKHM, enHCKonaMII cy34aJIbcKIIM H TBePcKIIM;
u

HepapxHnPHexaJIHByKa3aHHbliiCPOlf-<<HanMHTPlIeB
サ

XeHb)>(260KTH6pH);<<KHH3b)KeBeJIHKIm,HeMHoroB2eMeHII

rio>K"E, nocJIag Ko oTny cBoeMy MIITponoJImTy CIIMaHy
60FIpHHa cBoero nMIITpIIH BoJIo皿IMePOBMIIa H皿HKacBoero
AHIpeH MaiiKa, a…)' (XaJIee cJIenyeT TeKcT, COXPaHIIBm皿一
U

cHHBTHnorpa｡cKoiiJIeTo皿cⅢ:《BeJIHeMy6blTIIyCe6JIHa
｡

nBOpe…＞HT瓜.) !04

EcJIII Mbl npliMeM naTy cBona l497 r., T. e. 26 0KTH61)H

1496 r., To co3EIB HepapxoB enBa JIH Mo)KHo 6ynleT cBH3aTb

c onaJIoii liBaHa lll Ha BacIIJIHH II Ka3Hblo ero cTopoHHH-

KoB. OAHaKo cBH3b MezKIy nepKoBHblM co60poM H onaJIoii
cvmecTBoBaJIa.
O6 3ToM |n"Mo cBH瓜eTeJIbCTByeT x,POHOー

rpa｡,皿eⅡoX 7006 r. roBopHTcfl, TITo HBaH III <<B'LcHoJIeル

cfl...ha cBoIo BeJIHKyIo KHHrMIHIo Co巾blO, na II Ha CblHa CBOero KHH3fl BacHJIIIH, nlaⅢ 班aJIo6y coTBoPH IIePe,I MIITPonoJIPIToM CMIMoHoM H npen apxIieⅡKCKOHbl H enHcKonblmⅡI) eno
U

BCeM CBHmeHHbIM CO60POM, na B TOH】Ke oⅡaJIe Ka3HHJI
KHH3b BeJIHKH Bo.JIo且HMepa EJIH3apoBIIIIa c ToBapIIʼ'皿》l05.

几B. qepenHPIH IIpaBHJIbHo npeユⅡOJIoIKHJI, 'ITO II3BeCTHFI
⑫

TIInorpa｡cKOih JIeTonlIcH K xpoHQrpa*a B3aHMHo Xon9JI-

HHIOTnPyr叩yra,PaccKa3bIBaflO604HOMHTOMンKeCO6bl-

103 nCPJI, T. 24, cTp、214.

|::WW舳溌RPyM:｡ow.crl272;nCP几T.22,u.1,cTp.513
99

7 :I:

fHII!9IICJIenPBaTeJ1bliO,八aTa<<7005),BT.H.cBojIel497r.
omH60[IHaHIcaMoM
"
4eJIenoJI)KHo
6LiTE-《7006>.OxHaKo
cBon
l497
r.,
eCJIH
3aMelllITb,B
HeM
f<7005)p
Ha
<<7006>>,
WM4Wll" !1HTePeCHOe yToq"HIie:OKa3blBaeTcm,̅qT6

:･WIWWMMa KOrOjOM "ir liiMMr;K"
HcbH
CblHa
6bI｡ﾉI
II BblHy]K八eH
HoKaHZbcH
.B
"ry6JIeHHII
AHnpeFI

ym皿WPl̲,MMFJIQMecToBHoH6pe
l497
(BcKope
f
ndtJIe

39n9W6W')e
m
, moKa3Hli
gafJE6j皿HKoB
(27̅neKa6"
l497 r) BHarIMT, onaJIa Ha Co""̅IIrRMM5LI"MW

¥WZ LIQ-BImmMoMy, Mexmy ceHTH6peM l497 r., Korna Fa⑥

cH"IIMOrPaCnoPHIIITbCHOBb皿aIIeJIbrOTHOnrpaMOTbllo7,
U

MWWPa̲M E 3" ""bBKa̅i6m""Men｣

IW9WWp,JITRll"I III co6IjPaJIp"o3"ciTmMM-

BHyKa e皿"̲"rXpTe- ceIITH6pe l497 rraKHM o6pa60M,
IPW"lB¥TcfI=60JIeeTeCHa"CBH3b
Me)K,myHaLI3JT6M̅66｣
WWI2H"r､Cyme6H'IKa
(ceHTfI6pb
l497 rj̅ H̅6IMMia
Co｡blo - BaCIIJIHH.
｡

¥p9"Or"ISPKa"
qPHyPOtleIIHOcTb
co6Pan",
COCTOHB-

WQgfI̲UgCJIe26oKTH6pH,mxapaKTepmp@Hmm)f6Mf529pWWWVIWTyll emICKOnaM y"JIOCL BbIPhaTb #II"U

"̲IIIO6emaHme̅IicnPaBHTbcmB'My皿eM,HaBoJHTHa

WW,LITQcMepTbAHnpeH-co6bITIi"eTLIp6xliETigH瓜aBHOCTIf-nOgWWl9 JIImb nPe"OroM J(JIH Pa3roBOPa b6
U

OnaJIbHoM
BacIIJIKII,
qbR
y[iacTb
BHymaﾉIa
MIITPOIIOJIHTy
ご

ggP.e3Hhle OnaW"2 m, BO3Mo>KHO, 6EIJIa na)Ke 6JIII3K3K

WpTZAHApeH !08pIIeBMIIo, UepKoBn" EMIIFMM
pIITbnJIHBacmJIIizonpcneJIeHHbfrapaHT"'ii̅iiPaE5"755106几B.IIepenHIIH.yKa3.co11．J｣&cTP302-303j̲"KHCepご

6MIja.H3"grop!IIipyccKoroJieTornic"fIm皿aXVB.(JIeToHIIbHbInl497
"" r.)­《nRP･JleWmCTOqHIIKoBemlel"TXIM,̅1",

"･MF" 3 c"" b eJ"'e na"Mi.W66I(6f;"6fI*｣
HIIHKoHUaXVB.­くHcTopmmCCCP>,1964,Nb5""[

Io7 ACSI/I, T・II, JVb 489.

!08WW".E"3bnn9"'IHH"
IIBaH,
m
o
pacKpb'TMeM
3a!､OBOpa
かモ
W|"#"4,I:̲ W""" ""i n i,,""MXMWf
し

yM}IIJIX apl､Y"!". BJ"""oW, [ITo qIMoH 11 mpyrme "Uel)KoBIime
|IIel)al)XI1
BI｣ICTylIIIJIII
C
3a山｝IToii
ryceBa，CTpoMwJIcEalInpoLIHx
vIIa・・
"m": ::ROB" ｡IW: 2 q̅e P e n H Ii1L yK"- ","'､' j､

"f99-Z299,̲aO2-303LaJo̲MHblmEri6i4e":Ⅲ兄C.
JIypbe

4:Ka3aKoBj]
(H
I･IeJI，IIcI10J1b3y兄Ha6JIIo且eHHH
C:̲JIy"5・yKa3.
H !I M"HIA̲g]1)pF
neb"II6MN-のeⅢ6oK1.,
LIepenlIHHa，roBopHT
b
c'rp.
201)"I,
roBPpHT
LIepqi"Ha,
MEWW3
ouepKoBHoM
."""HI!"
co660pe,
cnac山eW
m
BacIIJIIIIo
(J.Fenne'll̅6P:̅c7f,
p.337,Jote2,350-351)．H4MTo>Kenpe"TaB"eTc",urdiMM｣

¥YT"PmMoHOM allaJIOr" c A"peeM y"nMI･"igKa6; bMME
Ha
3aUHTy nepKoBbIo K"3flBac"II兜HBaHoBI,IIIa,IIeMPmPBblx3ar O B O D 皿 H KO B ．
100

>KI皿a (B mepHe-ropoAKe mJII! nPyroM MecTe) . rlOrocT
nPy>KKII HBJIHJICH, BePOFITHO, MIITPOHOJIﾙI1IbIIM BJIaleHHeM.
B rpaMoTe l504 r. MIITponoJIHTy CIIMoHy ynoMI'IHaeTc只瓜epeBHH f<B npy>KKy)D B MocKoBcKoM ye3ne l09. CynH no apxI1BHoii cyjlb6e rpaMoTbl l498 r., nepKoBb HIIKoJIbl B npy>KKax 6blJIa MIITDoHoJIHIIbeit.
農

HTaK, nOna'B B IIeMHJIOCTb, OTCTyⅡHBHa 3a八H1戒 ⅡJIaH,

BacIIJIHii Bce >Ke npoIoJDKaJI coxpallHTb llGKoTopoe noJIHTHIIecKoe 3Ha[IeHI1e. OqeBI皿Ho, oHo IoJDKHo 6blJI0 VBe@mlIIIHB aTbCH､no MePe yMeHbmeHIIH BJIIIHHIIH JMHTP".

KaKoBbI >Ke npH[IHHbl naneHHH peaJIbHoii BJIacTII nMIITp'硯？

: y>Ke nOcJIe OKoHLIaTeJIbHOro IIII3JIO>KeHI畑ⅡM HTP I1fl - BHyKa B 1502 r. HBaH III B HaKa3ax cBoIIM nocJIaM npenJIaraJI
naBaTb cJIenyIo皿He O6'MIcIIeHIIH OTcTaBKHnMIITpHH:<…KoTOPOi CbIH OTny CJIy>KHT II HOPOBHT, HHO OTeU TOrO 60JIe H
U

>KaJIyeT; a KOTOPOH CbIH PO皿ITeJIeM He cJIy>KIIT Ii He HOPo-

BHT, IIHo Toro 3a IITo >KaJIoBaTH" (1503 r.) ]10; <<BHyKa 6blJI
CBOero

rOcynaPb

Ha皿 no)KaJIoBaJI,

H

OH

yIIFIJI

rocyXaPlO

HameMy rPy61ITII: IIHo Benb BCHIKOii >KaJIyeT JJTH, KO|TOPOe
PoIIITeJIeM HOPOBIJT II cJIy>KIIT; a KoToPO前He HOPOBHT, Xa

emerpy6HT，HHo Toro3aIITo〉KaJIoBaTH”（l504r）！Ⅲ
B o6elIx HHCTpyKUHHx HMeIoTcH B BHIy KaKIIe-To pa3MoJIBKPI BeJIHKOrO KHH3fl c BHyKOM, HenOBHHOBeHIfe nOCJIenHerO.

CKoPee Bcero, 3TII npoTHBoPeIIIIH Bo311IIKJIII yJKe B
1498 r., Korma nMHTpIIik yIIacTBoBaJI Bo BHyTpeHHeM ynpaBJIeHHm. Ero nonblTKa npHcBoIITb ce6e TIITyJI BeJIIIKoro KHH-

3HくBceH PycI" nPoJIIIBaeT cBeT Ha xaPaKTeP KoH*JIIIKTa
Me>Kmy nen(oM II BHyKoM. Bo3Mo>KHo, nonycK K BJIacTH aHTIIyneJIbHo HacTPoeHHoro nMHTPlIFI B yCJIoBHHx ｡aKTHIIe｡

⑪

C KO H H e H 3 > K I I T O C T I I y n e J I b H O I I C I 1 C T G M b l C ｢ I O C O O C T B O B a J I B O 3 -

HIIKHOBeHIIIO nJIaHOB Kyna 60JIee OnaCHbIX JJIH HBaHa lll,
IIGM yneJIb'Hble nplITH3aHIIH BacHJIIIH. CTopoHIHII'KH且MHTPHFI
­

MorJIH3aMbl皿JIHTb

JIHOo

nPHMoe

oTCTPaHeHHe

oT

BJIacTH

CaMOrO IIBaHa lll, @JIII60 rPaH且mo3Hbl# Pa3neJI I､oCynaPcTBa
Ha XBa caMocToFITeJIbHblx BeJIIIKIIx KHH)KecTBa. TeppHTopllaJIbHaH npHyporleHHocTb rpaMoT nMIITpHH H HBaHa lll
1498 r. no3BoJIFIeT JyMaTb, TITo nMHTPHii xoTeJI BKJIIoIIHTb B
C(I)ePy cBOerO BJIIIHH" 3eMJIII, 6blB皿IIe B yneJIe IIJIH B Be40McTBe BacHJTIIH, a TaK>Ke HacJIenIcTBo HocJIGIHHx VnleJIbHblx
０９ A3HX, 1. I, Nb 70, cTp. 75
１０
<C6. PIJO>, T. 35, cTp. 430.
１１

TaM >Ke, T. 41, cTp、535.

101

KHFI3eii - BOJIOrOJIcKOrO,6eJIO3ePcKOrOHyrJI皿KOrO(HeT
Jmmb nPH3HaKoB nPI'ITH3aH醜 及MHTplIfl Ha TBepcKyIo

3eMJIIo) . TaKII" o6pa3'oM, Ha npaKTIIke <aHTIIyneJibHAH)>
neHTeJIbHOcTb nMIITP" CO[IeTa｡ﾉIaCb c y,meJIbHblM (nPH HaJIHⅧHcTaPlnerO BeJIHKOrO KHH3H) cTPeMJIeHIIeM nPlI6PaTb
K CBOHM PyKaM nPe)KHHe yneJIbl.
U

no nPoIIcxo>KneHHIO H xaPaKTePy cBOeii BJIacTH IMHT-

plM-BHyK

Mo)KeT

paccMaTplIBaTbcH

KaK

npe瓜mecTBeHHHK

CIIMeoI-Ia BeK6yJIaToBHIIa, noca>KeHHoro Ha npecToJI IIBaHoM IV B KoHne l575 r. Ho ecJIH且a>Ke B HocJIenHeiI IIeTBePTH XVI B. nofIBJIeHHe BToporo BeJIHKoro KHH3H c o6mepybCKHMHnpeTeH31IHMHTaIIJIoBce6eH3BecTHyloyrpo3yBJIacTH
rJI aBeHCTByIO皿erO MOHaPxa, TO He nPHxOnHTCH COMHeBaTb-

cH, IITo TaKaH yrpo3a 6blJIa H B KoHUe XV B.
2. Bo3BBImeHIIe KHJIBH BacH入1IH HBaHOBIma
II HoBroPogcKaH no入ⅢTIIKa B 1499 r.

MLIHeMo>KeMToIIHoXaTHpoBaTbycTpaHeHHenMIITpHH

OT neJI BHyTPeHHerO ynPaBJIGHI畑．OHo PIMeJIo MecTo, Bo BcHKoM cJIyIIae, nocJIe ceHTH6pH 1498 r. '12 naneHIIe BmIHHHH
JMHTPHH, nO-B皿HMOMy, nPe且皿eCTBOBaJIo OⅡaJIe HeCKoJIb-

KIIx Kpymlblx rocylapcTBeHHblx neHTGJIeik. 31 flHBa" 1499 r.

6bl血cxBa[IeHbl lIBaH IOpbeBH【I naTPHKeeB, erO CbIHOBbH
BacIIJIIIii HBaHoBII[I (Kocoii), HBaH MaHblHa II 3HTb HBaHa lOpbeBHIIa - CeMeH HBaHoBIIII PFmoJIoBcKH曲, H3 KOTOpblX HOCJIe皿I1ii 6bIJI Ka3HeH 5 .eBpaJIH 113mIO.IJ

B. H. naTpIIKeeBblx cnacJIo oT Ka3HH JIHmb 3aCTynHII[ieu

CTBO MHTPOHOJIHTa:

BeJIHKIIH KHFJ3b BeJIeJI

HXくⅡOCTPHIIH B

>KeJIe3ex> I,I cocJIaJI B 3aToLIGHHe - oTma B TpoHUe-CeprHeB
MoHacTblpb, cblHa B KHpMIJIJIo-BeJIo3epcKHii !'4 (IIBaH
MaHblHa 6blJI noca>KeH <3a npHcTaBbl> !15) .

BOJIbmHHCTBOJIeTOmlCHbIXCBO40BCOO6皿aeTopacnpaBe c PHnoJIoBcKHM H naTpIIKeeBI]IMII 6e3 yKa3aHI1fl KaKIIx''2 rl)aMoTy o pa3TJe34e 3eMeJIb B Be>KGILKoM BepxG oH BbInaJI B 7007 r.,
T. e. B nel)IIoX Me)KXy ceHTH6peM 1498 II aBrycToM 1499 r. (AC3H,
T. I, Nb 619).
113 nCPJI, T. 24, cTp. 214; T. 30, cTp. 139.

114 TaM >Ke, T. 26, cTp. 291; cp. T. 1V, [1. 1, Bbm. 2, cTp. 531; T. VI,
cTp. 43, 243; T. VIII, cTp. 236; T. XII, cTp. 248; T. 20, nepBa別ⅡoJIoB冊
Ha, cTp. 368; T. 23, cTp. 196; T. 28, cTp. 331.

115 TaM )Ke, T. 1V, II. 1, Bbln. 2, cTp. 531. BepoflTHo, nonaJT B ona,FIy II
A申. naTpIIKeeB (K，B. Ba3HJIeBH[I. yKa3．coII., cTp 370) .
102

q

JIII60 11pHIIHH 3Toi oIIaJIbl. B ycTIo>KcKoM JIeToIIHcIIoM cBome (T. 11. ApxaHreJIorop皿cKoM JIeTOIIIIcne) rJIyXO 3aMeIIeHo,
[ITO BeJIHKIIii KI-IH3b《noHMaJI B bl3MeHe>> IIBaHa IOpbeBIIIIa,
cbIHa ero Bac"" Kocoro II C. I/1．PfmoJIoBcKoro 116. KoH-

ueⅡnHflH3MeHblnonpo6Heepa3BHBaeTcHBCTeneHHoiiKHIIre.
roBopH, IITo c 21 MapTa l499 r. HBaH III <<HaIIaT JKaJIoBaTH
H JIIo61ITH>> BacHJIIIFI II Co巾bIo, CTeneHHafl KHIIra yKa3blU

BaeT: B TeqeHHe nPPIMePHo XByx JIeT nP 3TOrO BeJIIIKIM KHH3b
HMeJI rHeB Ha >KeHy lI cblHa <HeKOHx Pa瓜HJIIOIbcKblX KPa-

MOJI>>; 6ynyqlI B rHeBe Ha HHx, OH HO)KaJIOBaJI BeJIHKIIM KHH-

>KeIIHeM nM1ITPlIH-BHyKa, HO HOToM <<IIcnblTa nO叩o6Hy BcFI

nPe)Ke6blBmaHKPaMOJIbI,Hx>KePaユHnoBe@meKHH3FICI1-

MiIoHa PHnoJToBcKaro Ka3HI1TM cMepTHHM IIoce[IGHHeM. KIIfl3H )Ke I'IBaHa lOpbeBIIIIa lI cblHa ero KHFI3FI BacHJIbH KocoBo
nJIH MoqIIeHKFI MI1TPOnoJIIIIIa ll BJIanbIK MIIJI0CTb Han HIIMH

cOTBoPII: cMePTII He nPenaCT IIx… Ta >Ke Be@mHKHii KIIH3b
o BHyKe cBOeM, BeJImKoM KHfI3e mbMMTPiIH, HePa八eTH
I-IalIa...> 117

TaKIIM o6pa30M, 3necb naTpHKeeBbl lI P別nOJIOBCKHit

npencTaBJIeHbiBHHoBHIIKaMII6blBmeii̲onaJIIJI"BacIIⅡⅢflH

Cb｡bIo;Ka3HbPfInoJIoBcKoro!13aToqeHllenaTpmKeeB"
COOTBeTCTBeHHO CBH3aHbl C Pea61IJIIITamleii >KGHDI II CblHa
IIBaHa lll lI C OnaJIOi Ha nMIITPHH-BHyKa"

IH. .M. KapaM3HH, C M. CoJIoBbeB，B. O. KJIIo[IeBcK",
I'I. H. CMIIDHoB II B HaqaJ1e 50-x rOnpB A. A. 3HMHH, nplI-

HIIMaHBepcIIIoCTeneHHoiiKI-IMrlLc[11ITa&ⅢⅡ且MIITPlWI-BHyKa
II rpyⅡnHPOBKy naTPlIKeeBblX - PHnOJIOBCKoTO nPenCTaBIITeJIHMHPeaK|皿IOHHOrO60HPCTBa,nPOTHIBIIBmeroCFIyKPenU

JIGHI冊O caMOmeP>KaBHOMI BJIaCTII.

HI-ITepecIIbl II y6e"ITeJILIIbl npBo,nLI I'I. Ii. CMHpHoBa B
noJIb3y JocToBepHocTII cBI'IneTeJIbcTBa CTeneHHoii KHIIrPI o
cBJI3" naTPlIKeeBBIX II PFITIoJToBCKOro c nMHTplIeM-BHyKoM 118.

0皿IaKO Bbl3blBaeT COMHeHIIe yTBeP>KneHﾚle aBTOpa,

IITO PaCnPaBa C naTPPIKeeBblMm II PHnOJIOBCKI1M <<nPenlllecTBOBaJTa OnaJIe...ⅡHMHTpHH>> ''9. EcJIH IIMeTb B B皿yo巾ⅡuHaJ1bnylo onaJIy l 502r., TO 3TO TaK, HO B JIIITePaTyPe
He 6blJIo VcTaHoBJIeIIo, IITo K 1499 r. IYpoH3o1llJIo巾aKTH可ecKoe
''6《y,CTIO>KCKIIi JTeTo|IIwI,CHIJIii CBO且》．M・­JI., 1950, cTp. 100; K. B. B a.

3 HJIGB IIKI. yKa3. cotI., cTp. 371; J. Fennel l. Op. cit., p. 338.
ll7 nCP几T. 21, BTopaH no｡JIoBHHa, cTp. 57|1-572.
118 H．I4. C M H p II o B. KJIaccoBaFI 60pb6a…, CTP、79-80; <<Bonpocb1 11(､・
Topml>, 1952, JYb ll, cTI). 142
1'9くBonpocbl PIcToplI", 1952, Nb l l, cTp、142.
103

ycTPaHeHIie mMHTPHH oT yIIaCTHH B J(eJIax BHyTPeHHerO ynPaBJIeHIIH, II 3To yCTPaHeHIIe, nO Cy皿eCTBy 6JIH3KOe
K opaJIe, BepoFITHo, npe瓜mecTBOBaJIIO aPecTy 60HP.

Ⅲ．Ⅱ、CMmpHoB
BbIcKa3blBaeT
MHTePeclioe
nPe且ⅡoJIo>Ke-

HIIe: <<B xone "HacTHqecKoro KpPI3IIca l497-1502 rr.
yne,JIbHoKHFDKGCKIIe KPyrH, OIIGBⅢ且HO, PaccIIHTblBa,JIH Hc-

HOJIb30BaTb MaJIoJIeTCTBO BHyKa mBaHa lll, nlIMHTPHH, nJIH
3axBara gJIacTII B cBOH PyKH (B巾OPMe pereHTCTBa
H T. ,m.)> 120.BIIoJIHe Bo3Mo>KHo, IITo onpeneJIeHHIme noJIHTHIIeCKIIe KPyrII xOTeJIH IICHoJIb30BaTb UMHTPIIH-BHyKa B CBOIIX
neⅡ月x, Ho yneJIbHoKHH>KecKafl HanpaBJIeHHocTb Hx 60pb6bl
a B To P O M

He nOKa3aHa.

HeJIb3fI npH3HaTb apryMeHTmpoBaHHbIM ocHoBHoii Te3Iic

H. H. CMIIllHoBa: <<CyTb cTpeMjieHHi rpyⅡⅡIiPoBKH PHnoJIOB CKHXH naTQ"eeBgx:BoCCTaHOBJIeHIIenPe>KHeiiPOJIII
ymeJYbHblx KHH3e" l2'. XapaKTepHcTHKa C, H.̅ PHnoJIoEcKoro KalK 6JIH)KHero IIeJIoBeKa AHIpeH yrJIHuIKoro 122 He co3XaeT npaBIIJIbHoro npencTaBJIeHIIH o HeM: HMeHHo C. I'I. PH-

nOJIOBCKoMy
Be@ﾉIHKmi
KHFI3b
nOPyIIIIJI
<<nOHMaTH》AHnpeH
B
1491 r.123

Be3apryMeHTaUlIHocTaeTcHTaK>KeMHeHHem.II.CMHP-

HPPa o "IIqHHax Ho>KaJIoBaHHH BacIIJIHH B MapTe l499 r.：

くHBaHIIIHeMOr,"mHeXOTeJI,KOHeqHo,nPoimBOnOcTaBJIHTb ce6R neTHM 60HpcKHM II HbHKaM, "JIHEmHMcH co"u

aJIbHOH

U

onOPoII

H

aKTIIBHblMH

nPoBoXHIIKaMH

IoJIIITHKH

cTPQmeJILcTBq UeHTPaJIH30BaHIIOro rOCy"PcTBa> 124

B1952r.A.A､3HMHH,BImHBnaTPHKeeBblxIIP兜ⅡoJIoB-

CKHX nPOTHBHIIKOB《ueHTPaJIH3'oBaHHoh HoJIHTHKIM H!BaHa

III>, 06'bHcHHJI IIx na,meHHe <<He cJIyIIaiiIHblMH BHemHenoJIH-

TIIIIecKHMHO6cTOHTeJIbcTBaMH…2̲a60Pb60iiHBaHalllnPoTHB PeakUHOHHorO 60HpCTBa> 125.

3aqIIHaTeJIeM
n20TIIBgnOJIIO)KHOii
TeHneHUHH
B
HCTOPHO-

rpa"H BbIcTymwI FI C. JIypbe. OH BbIIBIIHyJI Te3Hc o H"ocToBepHocTH

noKa3aHIIH

CTeneHHo曲KHIIrH

KaK

IICTOIIHHKa

nO3皿ero (Ho CpaBHeHHIo C JIeTOnHcHbIMH cBo"MII, me
l29 gBQIpqcbI HcTopli", 1952, M ll, crp l43.
W Z I'I C M " H o BKilaccoBaH 60pI;6a"" cTp 81

122 TaM. >Ke(QpMKaHaliH.i ̲ q M.C o JI o bb e B.HcTcpIIHPoccmm,
KH3 1, crp l400 - cm!:P M g o U qg b e̲BMcTopIIH Potcmm c npeB｣

""XEpeyeH, KH. 111, JoMa 5-6. MJ96QA cT"3).

123 "yCTIO]KCKHii JIeTOHHCHblii CBO且》, cTp. 98-99; J・Fennell. Op. cit,
p. 350, note l.

124<Bonpocbl HcTopmm', 1952, Nb ll, cTp. l43.
125 "CoBeTcKaH KHmra>, 1952, Nb 4, CTp..67.
104

nPHIImHbIOIIaJIbInaTPmKeeBbIx-PfInOJIoBcI<QIWefWKW
BalOTCH)
HTe皿eH皿03HOro
(>KeJIaBmerOyrO皿TbBac皿HIo

III)126:w<B6oJIeepaHHIIxJIeToⅡHcFIx(Hanp,nCPJI,T.VI,

cTp､43,243）roBopmTcfIToJIbKoo60ⅡaJIeHa
PmoJIoBCKof6riInATpIIIteeBbI)fB1499r.-Me>Knym3BecTKeMo69IIalle
MCOMHBacIIJIHHIIm3BecTHeMon9MmJIoBaHIMB"Z
U

JIIIH.-7raK qTO HCcJIenPBaTeJIb, CKJIOHHblII K PaCcy)KnteHIIIO

noinpIIHUmmyposthoc-ergopropterhoc,Mo>KeTcBH3bI△

BaTbbnaJIynaTpIIKeeBHxCJIIo6bIMII33TIIxnpoTIIBoHoJIo)KU

Hblx co6blTIIii> 127. B sTo曲巾oPMaJIbHO-JIormulecKoH BHKJIgn-

KeVnV皿eHo,omaKo,qToMe"yli3BecTmeMo60naJIeBa-

CⅢ血ff II Ka3HbIO PHHOJIoBCKoro HMeeTCFI cTaTbH O

KOPOHa皿ⅢⅡMIITpHFI-BHyKal28-co6blTHII,BKopHeH3Me▲

HIIBmeM nOJIIITIIIIeCKyIO cIITyaUHIO.

ノ

CJIeXoBaTeJIbHo,coo6meHHe O60naJIe naTPHKeeBblX -

PHnOJIOB|cKoro Hy)KHo PaccMaTPlIBaTb He Me>KXy cTaTbJIMII
④

o6 onaJIeHⅡo)KaJIoBaHIIH BacHJIHH, a Me)Kny cTaTbeH o

KopoHaUHH
BHVKaHcTaTbeHoⅡo>KaJIoBaHHII
BacHJIHH，KaK
U

3T6HXeJIaeTH.C.JIyPheBMoHorpa申HH1955r.jHeMeHFIH,

o皿aKo, cBOero BblBona l29. KpoMe Toro, B ocHoBe 9Toro
CyXmeHIIH H．C. JIypbe JIe)KIIT TeopeTIiIIecKII HenplIeMJIeMaH
U

nOCblJIKa o 60JIbmei nocTOBePHocTH PaHIIHx IIcToIIHHKOB nO

EP3BHeHIIlOcn03nHMMm,xOTHHePenKO"BaeTHHao"
P6T-Bce3aBHcIITOTKOHKPeTHOrOcJIyqaH.yMoJIqaHIleBe"
TOIKePa3HOBHⅡHOcThTeHXeHUlIo3HocTIIIIHeXoCTOBePHOcTM,
U

a HMeHHO OHO H cBOiCTBeHHO B naHHOM BOnPOce JIeTOHIIc-

HblM cBoXaM, KoTopblM H. C. JIypbe omaeT npg皿oIITeHHe

no npliqIIHe IIx 60Jiee paHHero npomcxo>K4eH""Ma", apf6PMie
KOcHyncH
IICTOIiHIIKOBenqecKIIX
gOBOnOB
H．CMIIpZ
HoBa B HoJIb3V Te3IIca o,瓜OCToBePHOCTII l)aCcMaTPHBaeMor()
I I 3 B e c T I I F I CTeneHHoHKHHrH・
H3BecTHH
C Te n e H H o i i K H I I r H .

PacnpaBa c PRnOJIOBCKIIM II naTPPIKeeBblMH, nOJIaraeT

H.C.JIypbe,<<6bmaBbl3BaHa…(nOyTBeP>KneHmlOCaMOro

HBaHa lll B IIHCTPyK皿H nOCJIaM) TeM, [ITO naTPHKeeB
II PHnOJIOBOKHi, 6ynyIIHⅡocJIaMII B HoJIbme, ,,Bbl'COIKoyMIHIIIIaJIH -瓦eiiCTBoBaJIII BonPeKH yKa3aHHHM BeJIHKorO
6

ʻ

⑮

126 H. C. JI y p b e. PI3 HcTop" noJIIITHqecKoii 60pE6bI…, cTp. 91,
nDHM. 1.

127 Fr. C. JI y p b e. nepBb,e皿eoJIorm…, cTp. 97, npIIM. 2.
'28 nCPJI, T. V1, CTP､43.

129HAKa3aKOBa HH．C・JIypbe. yKa3･cou., cTp. 166-167.
105

KHFI3FI...》130.
IIHcTpyKUl畑ⅡOcJIaM
0"HaKo
B
<<BblCoKOyMIIe>>
B HnaTPIIKeeBa n C HPFIhOJiOBCKOrO BbBEER̅M5Ef
BaeTcFI
onaJIoII HaHHx
HHxB1499r､131
B 1499 r
BaeTcH cconaJIoHHa

KPOMe TOrO, HeHC'HO,
3a [ITo HocTpanlaJIH Ii. 10. naTpHKeeB II bro cblH IIBaH Ma｣

XblW,MfnPmqaCTHbleK"jlJIgMaTIIqecKOMy<<BblOOKOyMIIIO》

B H naTpliKeeBa li C m PHno"oRcKOr6, aFEEMMi
onaJI"bIx HBJIHJIcH cKopee Bcero cTapbli H . 10. naTDH曇
KeeB I32.
｡

CoI､JIacHoH.CJIypbe,naTplIKeeBblHeToJIbKoHeITMeJIII
HHKaKoji
HmeiHO-noJIHTIIIIeCKOii o6
HHKaKoHH瓜e伽O-noJIHTm[IeCKOho6皿HoCTII
cTOPOHHHKa･
CO

MHEJIeHbl-ⅡMIITPMIH､(HanpHMep,･Kyp皿blHblM)133,HO
cKOPeena>Ke6bIJIH6JIIi3KIiKrPynn!叩oBKeCo｡bH-BacIIJmH: aBTOP CIIIITaeT, qTO《nepBblM 4eJIoM BacHJIIIH PIBaHoBHIIa no BcTylIJeHIM ero IIa npecToJI 6blJIo ocBo60丞旦eHHe H

Bo3BbluleHIie BacmJI" (BacCIiaHa) naTpHKeeBa)> 1"noU

cJIemHIIH gpryMeHT enBa JIII y6e"TeJIeH. no MHeHHIo IIccJIe⑪

noBaTeJIeir, OCBO60>KneHIIeHⅡpl,I6JIIDKeHHe BacIIJIHeM III

BImaTPmKeCBanPOm30UjOliePambme6MEMRIMbi
IIeIHHH
,6bl'Bmero
conep'HHKa
Ba,cHJIHfl
lll-且MIITPHH-BHyKa
,

Te nocJIe l4 .eBpaJIFI 1509 rl35

E̲UgJIQM "IIIrn" FI C JIypbe naeT KaK 6bl "Ba pe-

"IHHBonpoca:l)̲ naTpHKee"= cTopoHHHKmpeakUm6H⑪

I-IoH rpynnHpOgKII BacI1JI"; 2) naTplikeeBbl HojIHT"ecKII
KenTpaJIbHbl. B o6QMx
IIeHTpaJIbHbl・B
o60Hx cJIyqaHX
cJIy【IaHxoTpiiUaeTcH
oT”ⅡaeTcR Hx
Kx cBH3b c

uMIITpHeM-BHyKoM.
HII
o皿o
II33THxpemeHHii
Hey6enlIU

reJIbHO・

BoTJIIIIIHeoTg.C.J1ypbe,几B.qepenHIIHnpHHHMaeT
o6bHCHeH" CIPneHHOik KIMrIIB TOi uac+m, rmMTMM:
BaeWI
cBfI3b
naTPliKeeBblx
rPynnHPOBKOhⅡMIITPIIH-BHyc

naTpHKeeBbl
Ka:
<<no旦瓜eP>KI1BaJIH
KaH瓜ⅢユaTyPy
Be,JIIIKoHa

KHH>KecKIIM
CTOJI
BHyKa
l/IBaHa
lll-ⅡMHTPHH
HBaHOBHIla,

npOTIIBoHocTaBJ1HFI
nOCJIe皿erO
BgCIIJ1HIO
HBaHOBIiqy
(6y,my=

皿EM)<¥¥acmJIIIIO IP naUeHIle nMIITP" Ii nePenafla､ IHHoM III cHaqaJIa HOBroponcKorb iI nck6BEK6f5""<M凡
!3｡3̲C"JI>'Rb9;H3!IcTOI)IIMJoU"IIlecKoh6Opb6b!…,cTp.91,
nplJM.l;H、AXa3aKQBa l!HCJIyPbe・yKa3. COq., cTP. 168.

W fC6.PHO>, T. 35, crp. 428.
W gp̲JfennellOjcit, p359

133H.A・Ka3aKoBa
HH.C､･JIypbe・yKa3.coKI.,cTp.168.

叩ⅡOmIT;IIIGCKOii
WʻnoBIIHa．M.,
'35E・roJTV6H
HcKHii、HcTopⅢRl〕yccKoH
60Pb6bl'3･
"op''｡
pymi̅M"fi
m,M､K
!m6
EI.9"
iiUepKBH，T・ʼ1，nepBaHnoM
rMX，”M､1．
1900, cTP. 654, .nPIINi.1 ; H、A. I< a 3 aKo B a. ̅BaccIIal.I
U

naTpmKeeBHeroco[mileH"M:-J1""1960,W53r56:
106

a3aTeM
BeJIHKoKHH)KecKorocToJIa
cBoeMycbIHyBacHJIHIo
Bbl3BaJIa B l499 r. onaJIy Ha naTpHKeeBblxHHX POHCTBeH-

MMEM5H̅CEMeHaHBiHoBli[lap"OJIOBcKOro'!3QJPIIBO-

皿巾aKTbl
cJIy>Ke6Hoi
6Horpa巾皿naTPHKeeBblx
PflnoJIOBII

CKOrO,几B̅qepenHKHBnoJIHeo60cHoBaHHoroBopHT,JIT9
3THⅡeHTeJIH,
nPIIHanJIe)KaBmIIeくK
CTaPOMy
MOCKOBCKOMy
60HPcTBy,
TecHo
CBFI3aHIIOMy
BeJIIIKOKHR】KeCKHM
c
IBOPOM>>,
nochenp"TeJIbHo
|60po皿Cb
<Ha
CToPOHe
BeJIHKOKHH>KeCIKOII
U

U

BJIacTHⅡPOTHB
OⅡnO3皿ⅡⅢ,皿emmeii
0meJIbHblX
lI3
｡eOnaJIb-

Hblx
UeHfpoB)>
137.
ABTop
BblcKa3hlBaen̲ITpe瓜ⅡOJIo>KeHIIe
o6
V""̅TiarpIIKeeBbIxEcocTaBJIeHHIICyme6HHKa
l497｡n.Ⅲ
C可HMMMMiMbfHia
3TOM̲3IanehPOrPeCCMBHOii
!3a
学

B"Ma "ITepecHa nonbrTKaJm B. qepemimHa yc"HoB"

6JIH30cTbnaTpliKeeBblxK･KypHublHy:《のenoPKyplIUblH
ⅡpHHIIMaJI
yqacTIie
o｡oPMJIeHI1I1̲Fe¥̲loP皿HIIecKKx
B
aKTOB,

KoToPbIecOBePmamIcbbbeXoMam.10.IIB.H・naTPHKeeBblx. TaK, oHnHCaJI MeHOBHylO II OTBOnHylO rPaMOTy Ha

6blBIⅡHeTBePcKmeBoJIocmbyiirOpg瓜HKoJInb,
npoMe]flellHble IIBaHOM III enPPyHmBaHy BOPHCOBHqaM BOJIQnKliM,

OTBoI
coBePmaJIcFI
nplIcyTcTBIImⅡaTPIIKeeBblx>,
B
139.3a-

MeTIIM,[ITO̅nPOMeHTBePCKKX
MeTHM，［ITOⅡPOMeH
TBePCKHX
BOJIocTeiI
BOJIocTeHcOcToHJIcH
cOcTpHJIcF
BHIQJIe
HIoJIe
B
U

⑪

l497 r．m, BePoHTHo, 6bIJI cBH3aH c nOWITKoII HemTpaJIji39r
○

BaTb TepPmTbpmaJIbHbIe npmTH3aHIIH BacliJIIIH B paIIoHC
TBepcKoii3eM､ⅡⅢ.3TanOJIHTIIqeCKaHaKUHHMOrJIaHCXOIHTb
ム

ユ

u

oT6TopoHHIIKoBJMIITpliH-BIIyKano3ToMyTpy皿ocomacP'Tb|cFI c H. C. JIypbeHn>K. ･eIIHeJIoM, KOToPble, Bo3Pa>Kafl

)rg.[Teijen"H7,'paccMaTpHBal9120TpynHwIecTBonaTpIKeeBbIXH①．KypHnblHaBIIIoJIel497r.KaKnpocToeBblHoJI-

HeHI1e
cJIy*e61iI;Ix
o6HaaHHocTeih
!4q

iMMhameHHH
mMHTPmfI-BHyKa,
naTPmKeeBblx
IEa-

noJIoBcKoro JI. B. IJepenHHII H皿eT B Ii3MeHeHHH BHemHeⅡo-

JIIITHKIecKoiho6cTaHoBKII.OHmimeT:《…OnaJIaHanMIITPHfI
II EJIeHy CTe｡aHoBHy 6blJIa Bbl3BaHa He>KeJIaHI1eM oTLla
EJIeHbI -Z CTejaHa pa3pblBaTb Mo皿aBCKO-JIHTOBCKHe OTHO-

meHI1H
H
BCTyflaTb
BBOimy
nPQTHB
JIHrQBCKOrO
rOCyXaPCTBa

Ha cTOPOHe IﾉIBaHa lll>> 141. Ha 3To I-lepenHIIIIy Bo3pa3IIJI
13t JI.B.LIepenHHH・yKa3. coII., '1. 2, cTp. 306.
137 TaM ]Ke, cTp. 307-308, 314-315.
138 TaM >Ke, cTp. 318.

139TaM>I<e,CTP､313-314;且ⅢⅡr,NI)85.

'40rrAI<ajaKoRa mH.C.JIyl)be・yKa3. COII., CTP・168; J. Fenne11. 0p・cit., p. 349, note 2.

l4l几EII6p ei# IIH. yKa3. coq., [L 2, cTF. 316.
107

①eHHeJI:
HHBape
B
l499
r．eme
He
6blJIo
HIIKaKIIx
nPll31IaKOB
¥WWaMH̲̲PT"alla BCTynmTb B "iriip6MjiMf
WWlIL BIM.le Y"uMW"･"5'CM#; c"X"
U

caHaPqji g aBrycTe l499 r.) 142

qepgjHIIH
B
JI
cBH3bIBdeT
Mexmy
co60ii
TaKme巾a
KTbl,

W"MIW.hP"eeBbIx II E"n｡Jf6MM iriMM;｣
JIe:WWW"̲u"opoma g nE""MIM MM;:

3）9)̲9m2aBKa
99COJIbCTfa
JTIIWEM皿Q)KeHHeM
E
f<He
Hy-

nHTb>E､ﾉ",W"9W"4T94'iwecTM4)"5M5̅pytFW :JIWW3 JIHTB6! PM BeJIbCKOfd, 6XM'MM
u

M MueMHIIIIJIa !"" AHTK"T6EMMiMMM
U

U

eW JWWli"2"BIM He BbI3bIBaeT COMHbH", ̅"65
HceHce¥､xaPaKTePXByxnePBbIx

ge4""aJIoEaHIIH､BacmJIII"
HoBropomoM
ncKoBoM
!!
:WWonFoWmapcT"-I&CMMMMM皿eIIBOHHblC
JIIITBO"'"
yIIa6THe
naTPIMeFMWHnOJIOBCKOrO
B
ne-

几 B・IMFPWMWU" "yKpe'I"iir mIMI f "FMi
P J

⑪

｡

2"29"M"QBUaMH B nepBoii noJIoBmHe 90EXm5BMT
WW̲̲9gHoBaHmen(JIH̲FbIBona,qTo3TI'BeJIEMMMM
U

｡

:IWWWIWa c JImTBoih: <OHm, KaK Mo>kmiyIM:

66blJIIinpoT"
nPHeMaTJJa
MocKoBGKyfo
cJIy>K6y
KHHgeii-3MM:
U

rp aHTOB­Ⅱ""QB meMHKII II PIBAHa Mo>KAMM=1M
U

>KeJIaJIH，uTo6bl
H3-3a3TIIx
K”3e曲Bo3HHKaJI
KoH巾JIHKT
c
JIHTJIHTBo#B1499r.>>145
U

epemmiHy,
B
"ohoIWWW"ejia=cBH3b
IWM̲"""
naTpliKeeBblx
cormacHo
JIHMeJIa
cBH3b
HaMGIIaB皿eHcH
c!iaiIEIiaiiMMMW"
6pyccKo-JIHToBcKOM
BOIIHOII>:
oHaく6blJIa
Bbl3BaHa
lIx
OnⅡO3IiUlfeII
MOCKOB｡

⑪

⑪

U

句 j

"My
nPapmTeJI¥TBy
nO
BonPOcy
Heo6xo且HMQCTH
O
BCTyn"

4gWI B Bo"y c JIHToBCKIIM rOcyjaPcTBOM<<naTPHKeeBbl
JIeHHHB'BoHHyʻcJIHToBCKHMrOcy皿aPcTBOM...>.

nPIIHan"e)KaJIII
K
napTHII
EJIellb!
CTfe巾aHOBI-Ibl,
BblcKa3blBaBU

U

meHc月nPoTHB BoIMHbl

c JIHTBo" 146

O6もRWWe̲""̲nMMTp"-BHyKa
naTpIIKeeBblx
!I

HCKJIIOIIIITeJIbHO
nePeMeHaMH
BO̅BHemlfeHnOJIHTI'IKG
nPentHe
U

WiWWUige9nblBalomliM !{ BnoJIHe y6e1HTeJIbHblM.

IPyAHO
npKa3aTb
baKT
no皿ep>KKIf
rpynⅡHpoBKoh
Co｡bH
-BacmJIIifI
nJIaHoB
EoihHb!
cnfTE5ﾙI,
CTOPOHHHKaMⅡ且MHTa
b

U

142J.Fennel1．9"iX,p,""qPmO",f35,crp28LnpaBUa,
XH:K:2WW
AJe
I Kca皿poMHCTe中aAMM"ewWJWaIMWMM:"
HoM（<C6p
. HO》T
,3
, 5c
, Tp､276)・

B.qebenHIIH・yKa3.
J."144 TaM >Ke.
COW.,
11．2,
cTp、315.
145TaM氷e,cTp.318-319.
'46 TaM )Ke, cTP. 315-31a
108

I)11;i-BHyKa-TGImeHHIIGiIMIIPIIOrOyPCryJIHPOBaHHfI147.CoMHIITeJIbHbI II HeKOTOPble (IaCTHble aPryMellTbl, nPe>Kne BCerO

IIPegnOJIOJKeHIIe O cOIIPOTIIBJIeHI畑 naTPlIKeeBblx nePexOmy
IIIPMH[IHqa H叩．y>Ke eHHeJI HoJ'IepKHyJI,ITo meMHIIHII
II Mo>KaiicK嘘nepemJIII Ha cTopoHy MocKBbl ToJIbKo IIepe3

l 5 MecImeB nocJIe apecTa 6oHp l48.
Bo B3rJIHnax K. B. Ba3HJIeBHIIa Ha onaJIy l499 r. Mbl Ha-

XO皿1M, c OJHOA CToPoHbl, BblcKa3aHHoe.几B. IIepenHHHblM
npen<cTaBJIeHme o naTplIKeeBblx KaK BepHblx cHoJBII>KHHKax
MOCKOBCKIIx BeJIIIKIIx KHH3ei, HO nPOTHBHIIKax BOiiHbl c JIHTBoii 149, c npyroi cTopoHEI,- BblJBI1HyToe B Pa60Tax

H. C. JIypbe MHellHe o TIelocToBepHocTII BepcHII CTeneHHoih
KHIIrM oTIIocHTeJIbHo 60pb6bl Me>K4y naTpHKeeBblMH II rpyn-

ⅡHpoBKoM Co*bH-BacRJIIIH 150. nepeHocH BcIo nPo6JIeMy
Bo BHemHenoJIIITHIIecKyIo nJIocKocTb, K. B・Ba3HJIeBHII ycMaTpHBaeT B pacnpaBe l499 r. nponpJI>KeHHe Ka3Heii l497 r.,
HMeB皿ee UeiJIblO cJIoMHTb

nO

KOHna《cymeCTBOBaBmylOB

o6JIacTH BHemHeii noJIHTIIKII oⅡnO3I皿HIo> 151. nocKoJIbKV
K. B. Ba3HJIeBIIII coeⅡmHHeT co6blTHH l497 H 1499 rr. B onHV

JIIIHIMIo, oH ｡aKTII[IeCKH cJIenyeT皿ee H. C. JIypbe o ToM,

IITO II 3arOBOP皿HKII 1497 r. II naTPHKeeBbl HrPaJIII Ha PyKy
くIIapTIM> Co巾bⅢ­B acHJIHH.
K. B. Ba3wIeBHII o6paTIIJI BHIIMaHI'Ie Ha cJIenylo皿eeH3BecTIie. BoJIoro,mcKo-nepMcKaH JIeTonHCb nOcJIe PaccKa3a o6
onaJIe naTpHKeeBblx H Ka3HH C. H. PFIHoJIoBcKoro coo6皿a­
eT:くToro )Ke JIeTa '52, anpeJIH, noIIMaJI KHH3b BeJIHK" HBaH

BacHJIbeBMIII KHH3H BacIIJIbH PoMoAaHoBcKoro ma OHnPeH
Kopo60Ba T｡epHTHHa>> 153. Ba3IIJIeBII[[ o6be"IHHeT onaJIy
naTpIIKeeBbIx, Ka3Hb PFIHOJIoBcKOro, aPecT POMonaHoBcKOrO
II Kopo60Ba B onHo neJIo, cIIPITafI cBH3ylomHM 3BeHoM o6elIx
PacnPaB nPHqacTHOcTb Bcex 3THx JIHⅡK cHOmeHHHM C JIHTBOii・Ho aBTop Ho cy皿ecTBy onpoBepraeT ce6H cBoHM Ha6JIIOXeHIIeM O TOM, IITO PHnOJIOBcK噸 H naTPHKeeBbl B
l･47 J・Fennell. Op. cit., p、360 .
148 1bidem.

l49
'50
l51
l52

KB・B a 3 II .II e B H q. yKa3. coII., cTp. 372-373.
TaM )Ke, cTp. 371, 375.
TaM >Ke, cTp. 370.
Bce aTM巾aKTbl B BoJIoroIcKo-nepMcKoii JIeToHIIcII II3JIojKeHbI HoJI
7006 ( 1498) |r., BcJIeX 3a KpaTKHM coo6皿eHHeM O KCPOHa"II JMIITP}IH-BHy'<a.

153 nCPJI, T. 26, cTp. 291; I<、B・B a 3 H JI e B II q. yK33. coII., cTp. 370­
371.
109

l496-1498 rr. <<HIIKaKoro yIIacTHH B neper()Bopax c JIIIToB-

UaMI1 60JIbme y)Ke He npIIHHMaJIII> 154.
no cnpaBeIJIHBoMy 3aMe[IaHHIoH．Ⅲ、CMIIpHoBa, pacnpaBa l499 E (rlepe3 5 JIeT HocJIe neperoBopoB) He MOrJIa
FIBHTbcH Kapoi 3a Hx <<BblcoKoyMIIHIIaHbe), 155. KaK yKa3blBaeT

eHHeJI,

MHeHIIe

O

nPIIMIIpeHIIecKIIx

TeHn<eHUmflx

H. I0. naTpHKeeBa B oTHo皿eHIHI JTHTBbl HeJIb3FI BblBecTHm3

TOrO巾aKTa, 'ITo 3a6epe3HHcKI1ii H Pan31IBIIJI Bbl6paJIII ero
JIJI別ⅡeperoBopoB B 1492 r.: npocTo oH HBJIflJIcH cTapmmM
60HpIIHoM II no3ToMy 6bm HalI60JIee cnoco6eHnOBJIHHTb Ha
cBoero rocynapH; KoJIJIera H. 10. naTpIIKeeBa HKoB 3axapbIIH, K KoTopoMy 3a6epe3IIHcKHi II PanBIIBIIJI To)Ke o6pamaJIHcb, He To"bKo nepe>KIIJI qPIcTKy l499 r., HoHⅡpoloJI>KaJI
BGcTH aHaJIorHIIHylo KOPPecnoH八eHnHIo B 1501 r.­HcHoBa

c 3a6epe3HHcKHM; ccblJIKa HBaHa lll Ha <<BblcoKoVMHe)P

C. m. PHnoJIoBcKoro H B. H. naTpHKeeBa, oIIeB皿'iO, He
IIMeeT IIII[IerO O6皿erO C IIX <II3MeHOi> HJIHⅡpHIII,IHoii HaKa3allHH B 1499 r・II OTHOCI1TCjl, CKOPee BCerO, K KaKOMy-JIH60
IIaCTHOMy cJIy[lalo: 1 ) oHa "eTcfl B KOHTeKcTe, rne nocJIaM
3anpemaeTCH nHTb CJIIimKOM MHOrO H 6eCIIecTIITb CBOero ro-

cynapH; 2) B Heii He ynoMHHyT naTpHKeeB-cTapmllit,可囲
BHHa B 1499 r. 6blJIa, no-BH八HMOMy, Ta >Ke, IITO H CblHa;
3) B cJIyIIae, ecJIH 6bl B H. naTpIIKEeB II C HPfmoJIoBcKIIii
coBepmHJIH 60JIbmyIo noJIHTIIIIecKylo omH6Ky B l494 r., oHII
enBa JIH 6blJIII 6bl Ha3HaIIeHbl BoeBOnaMII -­ⅡePBblM B HHJIFIII皿Io 3HMoji 1495/96 r., BTopoカーB Ka3allb B 1496 r.156
O KoHKPeTHohⅡpHIII1He apecTa PoMo"HoBcKoro II Kopo60Ba K. B Ba3HJfeBIIII BbIcka3bIBaeTcFIEecbMa rIInoTefli'IeCKH :くI/i3pecTHo, IITo B KoIIUe XV B. TBepcKIie KynublIIacTo

nocemaJIHBWIbHonoTOproBblMXeJIaM.Bo3Mo)Kilo,LITonpH

nocpenlcTBe AHppeH Kopo60Ba Bac"" PoMoXaHoBcK"
JIHqHo IIJIIj no nopyqeHIIIo BEJIHKo* "HrnHm Co｡bli no"ep-

>KHBaJI TaihHble cHoIneHIIH c EJIeHo曲HBaHOBHOii, IITO II MOI､JIO
IIOCJIy)KHTb HenOCPe4CTBGHHblM HOBO,nPM K apecTy KHH3H

Bacﾙ皿HHPoMonaHoBcKoroHA皿peHKopo60Bfi),157:BcTaeT
Bonpoc, no'IeMy B. PoMoIaHoBcK" 6blJI apecToBaH <<IIepe3
HeCKoJIbKO MeCHUe｣B noCJIe erO BO3BpameHWI B MOCKBV>>.
154

I<. B Ba3IIJleBIIq. yKa3･̲CoII,, cTp. 373. 3To npoTIIBopeIII1e B cxellp aBTopa OTMeTHJI y>KG H. H. CMwpHoB (<<Bonpo"I 1{cTOpw:', 1952,

Nb ll, cTp. 142)

５５
１
《BgnpocbI HCTopm", 1952, Nb ll, cTp
５６
１
J. F e n n e l l. Op. cit., p. 358-359.
５７
１

l42-143.

K. B. Ba31IJIeBIIu・yKa3. coII., cTp. 373-374.
110

TaKHM o6pa30M, K､B・6a3IWIeBHIIy He y4aJIOCb JIOKa3aTb,
IITo onaJIa naTpHKeeBblx H Ka3Hb PHnoJIoBcKoro, c oIHo#
cToPoHbl, II noHMKa PoMo,naHoBcKoro II Kopo60Ba,̲ c npyroit; 6bIJIH pacnpaBaMIi no onHoMy H ToMy >Ke XeJIy OcTaJIcH
p

HenPKa3aHHblM H erO rJIaBHblII Te3IIc - o cBfl31I HaKa3aHIifl

rpynⅡbl naTpHKeeBblx - PJInoJIoBcKoro HcKJIIoHIITeJIbHo c
BHemHenOJIIITIIIIecKIIMII nPo6JIeMaMH H o6 0TCyTCTBIM cBH3H
Me>K4y aTOii PacnPaBOiH瓜HHaCTHIIGCKIIM KPH3HCOM:
ﾕﾝK. eHHeJI HoIomeJI K H3y[IGHIIIo npo6JIeMbl c 60JIbmoii
IIcTOIIHIIKOBenlxlecKOil CTPOrOcTblO. no erO MHellHIO, B HcTOII一

HIJKaX

HeT

naHHblX,

CBH瓜eTeJILCTBylo皿Ⅲx,

IITo

aPecT

DOHP

6bm npHMo cBH3aH c瓜HHaCTH[IeCKI'1M KPm3HCOM; e皿e MeHbme OCHOBaH砿及yMaTb, IITO K 3ToMy MMeJIH OTHOmeHMIe BOnPoCbl BHe皿HehⅡoJIIITIIKH, a HMeHHo, IITo naTpHKeeBbl IIJIII

PHHOJIOBCK" BO3Pa>KaJIH nPOTHB HJIaHOB BOiiHbl C JIIITBOi
IMH nPoTHB HaMePeHIIH HBaHa lll nPIIHfITb BO3MO>KHblx nePe6e>KIIHKoB (meMHIIHIIa li np) 158
①ellHeJI oTBepraeT HoKa3aTeJIbcTBa H. Ii. CM叩HoBaH

几B. LIepenHIIHa B HoJIb3y MHeHI1fl o naTpHKeeBblx II PHHoﾉIoBCKoM KaK CTOPOHHHKax nMIITPwI-BIIyKa, nplIBO皿Tpll
apryMeHTa, KoTopble Mbl y>Ke BcTPeLIaJIII y fI. C. JIypbe MI

KO|TOPble HeJIb3H nPII3HaTb 6e3ynPeIIHblMH HII C TOIIKII 3,PeI - I H F I T G KC T O J I O r H I I e C KO r O a H a J I H 3 a J I e T O I I I I C H b l X C B O I O B , l ･ I H C
｡
｡

一

ToIIKI1 3PeHHH aHa,JIPI3a KoHKPeTHOH HcTOPIIqecKoH ODcTaHOB-

Km l497-1499 rm: l) IM3 HocJIenPBaTeJ1bHocTH co6blTllii
onacHo XeJIaTb KaKHe-JIH60 BblBoXbl; 2) CTeneHHaFI KHHra
U

HenPCTOBePHa

KaK,no3nHIM

⑥

H

TeHneHuHO3HblII

HCTO'IHIIK;

3) KoJ'J'erHno npo｡eccHH(naTpHKeeBb[ m emop KypmUblH) - He o6H3aTeJIbHo IIoJIHTII[IecKIJe napTHepbl 159.
nO3HTIIBHaH CTOPOHa KOHUeⅡ皿IⅢ ①eHHeJIa cOCTOHT B
p a3BIITHHMeJIbKOM 6pOmel皿Oii B Pa60Tax JIyPbe H IIeBblCKa3aIIHOih Ba3IIJIGBIILIeM (xOTH H BblTeKaIO皿eII II3 erO nOCTPOeHmH) l14eH o 6JII130cTII IIHTepecoB rpynnbl naTpIIKeeBblx P flnOJIOBCKOTOH《IIapTHII)> CoqJbH-BacIIJIIffI. CIIHTaH y6eJJITeJIbllblM MHeHHe几B. LIepenHIIHa oTHocHTeJIbllo MHoroJleTHero coTpynHHIIecTBa naTPHKeeBblx H PHnoJIoBcKoTo c
○

一

BeJIIIKo"H)KecKOII
BJIacTblo
B
ee
OOPbOe
c
yneJIbHblMII
KHH3bflMH, aBToP TeM He MeHee noJIaraeT, IITo II3 3TOro Ha-

6JIIoneHHH

BoBce

He o6H3aTeJIbHo HoJDKeH cJIenpBaTb Bbl-

〆

Bo", OymTO 'Ha3BaHHble BeJIbMo]KH HBJIHJIHCb cToPoHHPIKaMH
'FE J.Fennel1．0p. ci,t., p. 351
159 1bid., l). 349.
111

caMOnep>KaBIIoro nPaBJIellHH II nPoTIIBHHKaMH <(beo"JIBHOrO CenaPaTH3Ma>, 160.

n"6JIII>KeHIIe BaccmaHa naTpHKeeBa Ko "opy Bacm-

nHH III B XVI B・II 3acTynHHIIecTBo 3a naTpHKeeBblx MIITpoHoJIHTa CIIMoHa B 1499 r.- BoT ｡aKTbl, KoTopblMH aBTop
cTPeMHTCH IOKa3aTb Ha皿IIIHe cIIMnaTHit Co｡bH II BacHJIHH

K rpyⅡne naTpl'IKeeBblx - PHHoJIoBcKoro 161. O6a 3TH apryMeHTa MaJIo y6emiTeJIbHbl. CoMHIITeJIbHocTb nepBoro 6blJIa
ⅡoKa3aHa

Bbl皿e,

nPII

PaCCMOTPeHHH

TOIIKH

3PeHH免

H. C. JIypbe. Hano yIIHTblBaTb KoMnpoMIIccHocTb no3ImHH
MHTpoHoJIHTa CHMoHa・OH He ToJIblmo 3amHmaJI oⅡaJIbHblx B

l499 H, Bo3Mo>KHo, B l497 rr., Ho II caIHKUHoHIIpoBaJI KopoHa皿Io HMHTpHfl-BHyKa B l498 r. II ceKyJIHpH3aUIIIo llepKoBHblx '3eMeJIb B HoBropo,me B 1499-1500 rr. 3To H|e Ta巾HryPa, HoBeXeHHe KOToPoii MoMo 6bl 6blTb IIeTKIIM KpHTePHeM
,UJIH oIIo3HaHHH BHoJI|He on,PeXeJIeH|Hoii nOJIHTIIIIec|Koit JIHHHH 162.

naJIee eHHeJI BcJI" 3a Ba3IIJIeBHIIeM O6beXHHfleT B

o瓜Ⅱo XeJIo onaJIy naTpHKeeBblx - PHHoJIoBcKoro Ii apecT

PoMOnaHoBCKOro:<<JonyCKaH,[ITOPoMOXaHOBcKIIi6blJIaPeCToBaH no Toii >Ke nPHIIIIHe, IITOH旦Pyrme 60HPe, MbI MO>KeM
yKa3aTb Ha eme '60JIee TecHble cBH3H Me班只y ,,60Hpc|Koii
U

（

d

rpyⅡⅡOH.. B UeJIOM II naPTHeh…, Bo3rJIa'BJIHeMIoii BacIIJIHeM II
Co｡be", H6o B. B. PoMo"|HoBcK嘘,n(o CBOeh皿皿oMaTHIIe-

"oh cJIy>K6bI 6blJI cTapmHM 60HpHHoM ynleJIbHoro KHH3fI

MHxaIIJIaA皿PeeBIIIIaBepe曲cKoro,cKoTopblMCo｡bFIHMeJIa TecHblji nOJIIITHIIecKIIit

KOHTaKT.《ⅡOJIHTH[IeCKHe CKJIOH-

HOCTH 60Hp coBnanaJIII c noJIHTIIIIecKIIMH cKJIoHHoCTHMII
Co｡bII H BacHJIIifI> 163.

OTcyTcTBHe cBFI3H Me>Kly AByMH onaJIaMII eHHeJI cqHTaeT MaJIO BePOHTHblM, TaK KaK, BO-nePBblx, HO cBoe曲只ImJIo-

MaTHIIeCKOA CJIy)K6e POMOnaHOBCKIIii 6blJI 6JIH3KHM KOJIJIe-

roii naTpHKeeBbIx H PHIIoJIoBcKoro, Bo-BTopblx, PoMoJIaHoB-

CKHiiH｡PflnOIIOBCKImHaIQ1H皿ICbBPO4CTBe,
nPHHa"JIe>Ka
KO皿oii H Toii >Ke BeTBII PIoPHKOBPIIIeit. noBoIbl aBToPa Ka>KyTCH I･IaM JIIImeHHblMH IOKa3aTeJIbHOih CHJII]I. POMO八aHoB-

cKliiinpo八OJI>KaJIBblCTynaTbHa瓜ⅢⅡJIOMaTH[leCKoiaPeHeB
nepHon (1498 r), Koma naTpHKeeBbl ll P兄nO,JIOBCKHit 6bMH
l@Q J. F e n n e l l. Op. c･it., p. 350.
'61 1bidem.

162 A. H. K JI II 6 a H o B. Pe4)opMauIIoHHble ,nB11>Kell" B
XIV-nepBoM ̲noJIoBHHe XVI B. M., 1960, cTp. 219-220.
163 J.Fennell.OP.cit., p. 351.
112

POCclIH

B

y>Ke
maBHo
OTcTpgHeHbl
3TOro
oT B皿a
neIITeJ1bHoCTII
(nocJie

i495̅r) , T ePOMOna,,OBCKoIP m PHnOJIPEWm..WW
CIIHTaTb
JI皿aMI1,
06T,e皿HeHHblMII
Bo
BTopoii
noJIoBIIHe
90-x
U

rO八6:56MMMcJIyiKe6Hblx3aHHTHi̅PqgcWomx6bllP
oTXaJIeHHbIM
(TPoIOPO皿ble
6PaTbfI):
nleX
C.
PHnQJIo2cK:II.
roH．A.HaraBI皿d-PHIoJIOBOK"6blJI6PaToM八enaB.B.
POMOXaHOBCKOrO-①.A.CTapo,my6cKoro.

U

HeOcHoBaTeJIbHocTb o6be"HeH" "yx onaJI Ka)Ky皿eHcH
u

o6皿HocTbIOIIxHePa3ranaHHOihnPHqIIIiblnO3BoJIHeToTBCpIHVTE MHeHlle o cBfi3m naTpmKeeBbIx m P"oJIoBcKoro c《nap-

Tiie" Co｡bH­BacHJIIIHfHanpoTIIB,6皿30cTbKCo｡be
B.B.PoWIonaHoBcKoro,6blBm6rocnonBII)KHHKaMIIxaMJIa

A皿peeBHIa,Ⅱpe瓜cTaBmeTc且BepoHTHoh.①eHHeJI巾aKTH〔Ie-

CKHnpm3HaJI cJIa60cTb "oero Bbigona o cB"̲E"JW:
M ̅"P c <<napTIIe" Co*bm - BaclIJIIIHBb""WW{

rIInOTe3a7
nO
erO
)Ke
cJIoBaM)《He
nOKa3blBaeT,
IIT0
,,60flP-

CKaH rPynna: HMeJIa nPOynleJIbHble, nPQCglaW"":W;
＆4

neHIlIIH-LIePenHIIHnPHBellcBH瓜eTeJIbcTBanPaBIIJIbHOc'rm
⑪

jPO"rliBOnOJIOiKHOro ITe31ica])' - l#O aTa r"OI",JMWHM
MePe,
4<noKa3hlBaeT
{Ha"皿me]
KaKOrO-TO
KoHTaKTa
Me>Kmy Cojbeii, KoToPaH, KaK Nibl 3HaCMj̲｡""9cIlp EW"
⑪

6'gW"'fn"M̅m3 60"p, Bo"eqeHHbIx , co6EITHR
U

1499 r.> 164

fl6iaraH,ITOynaJIeHmeCnOJIIITIIuleCKOii
aPeHb[PfInO･

JIoBcKoro, naTpIIKeeBbIx, PoMonaHoBcKoIp ¥, qg3Mo"92

iPyfIix
6bfIp
MbrJIQ
paccMaTpHBaTbcm
Co巾bei
H
BacIIJIIIeM
KaK
HOTePH
neHHoH
Ho皿eP>KKII
B
BblcmHX
C.epaX
l65,
eHU

HeJIBm皿;̅b66emxonfiJia)f(HHBapHmanpeJIfI1499r.)ynap
⑪

U

no《ⅡapTHII)" Co｡bH-BacHJIHH, y皿P, KOTopblII BeJIIIKHH
KHH3b nDITaJIcH cMFIrllHTb《ⅡpomeHHeM)>Bac"" H no>Ka49-

BaHHeM
eMy
HoBropoXaH
nbKOBa
B
BeJIIIKOe
KHfl)KeHHe
l66.
516̅66MifeHHe
ioPa>KaeTcBOeiimcKycCTBeHHOcTbIoBOnePBbix,apecTPoMonaHoBcKoro6blJInpom3"g"9c12m
｡

XMMHil;I BacmJIIII6 BeJIMKoKHfIIKecKoro TIITyJIa 21 MapTa
1499 r. Bo-BTopblx, 3aIIeM Hanp 6blJo cMHr[IaTb y,nap llo̲"･

TepecaMCo"Ⅲ一BaclIJI四mⅡPlI6eraTbXJIfl3TOroKBO3-

BblmeHHIo BacmJIHfI？ ①eHHeJI c[IHTaeT，ulToⅡo>KaJIoBaHHe

21MapTao3Ha[IaJIo<<PJImmKOMMaJIOCTOLIKM3PeHI1HBJ1acTI1
H HIIIIerO B CMHCJIe 6yny皿erO> 167. 3Ta MblCJIb COBnanaeT C
164 1bidem・Pa3pH八Ka MoH・
165 1bid., p. 340.
16c lbid., p. 352.
167 1bid., P、340.
8

C. M. KamTalIoB

113

MHglWMHCJIypbe:<<nepBaHycTynKaBacliJ1HIoBMap-

Te l499 r・HIIKaK He o311a[IaJIa ero no6entbl>> 168. KaK 6bl HII
oneHIIBaTb MapToBcKoe nozKaJIoBaHHe l499 r., HeJIb3FI oTpH-

naTb, IITo oHo BHoBb (HocJIe l485 r.) "JIo Bac"HIo THTyJI
BeJIHKOrO KHH3FI, T. e. nOcTaBHJIO erO Ha o八IIII VI)OBeHb C

且MIITPIIeMHBePHyJIoII3nO"THqeCKOroHe6blTHHHamPIPo-

KylO IPJIHTIIIIecKyIO aPeHy nO MHeHHIO eHHeJIa, Ha3Haile-

HIieBacHJI叩くXOTH7nO-B皿HMOMy,IIJIIImaJIonMIITPHH

OJHOrO H3 erO ,,BeJIIIKHx KH"KeHIIii$& 169, 04HaKO HH B KOeii
U

MePeIIe yMeHbmaJIO erO BJIacTII KaK ,,BeJIIIKOrO KHH3H BCeH
L J

PycII",cOnPaBHTeJIHH |HacJIeXHIIKaiiPeCTO:ﾉIa>;<HHIITo He
noKa3bIBaeT,[ITOBJIaCTb UMHTPHHxOTbBKaKOih-ToMePe
yM eHbmHJI aCb》ⅡocJIe Ha3HarleHHH BacIIJIHH BeJIIIKIIM KIIH-

3eM HoBroponaⅢⅡCKOBa l70.

TyT
y)Ke
cKa3blBaeTcR
oTcyTcTBIIe
aBTopa巾aKTH可ecKHx
y
""blx, xaPaKTePII3ylO皿HX nOJIO)KeHHe nMHTP" B KO皿e

l498 - HaqaJIe l4"r- oTcTpanenme er6 bmeji̅ EMM=

HerO
ynPaBJIellIIH.
STo
H3MeHeHHe
POJIm瓜MIITPHH,
yCTaHOB-

JIeHHoe Bblme nplI aHaJIH3e rpaMoT 1498-1500 rT., HMeeT
2emalOmee 3Ha[IeHIfe XJIH BblBona o ToM, IJTo no)KaJIOBaHIIe

BacHJIIIHBMapTel499r.6blJIo,noUppToBJIeHoeCJIIIHelOP⑪

⑥

MaJIbHOII,TO巾aKTII'IecKOIIonaJIO曲瓜MIITPIIH.

CJIelmPBaTeJIhIIo,06bHcHeHIIecO6blTHfiHaKIaJIal499r.,
U

nPenJIO)KeHHOe eHHeJIOM H HO瓜及epzKaHHoe g. C. JIypbe l71

(IICXO皿.IenOcbIJIKIIKOToPOrO6bIJIHnPmHHTbI｡eHIieJIoM),

nPoTHBOPeqlIT HoKa3aHHHM BCerO KOMuJIeKca lICTO[IHHKOB m
IIe Mo)KeT cIIIITaTbcH y6e且HTeJIbHblM .

A A. 311MIIH B pa6bTax 1963-1964 rr. He KacaeTcH cne""bHo Bonpoca o n"IIIIHax co6bITmii l499 r. OH o6pamaeT
BHIIMaHmerJIaBHbIMO6Pa30MHacBH3mmMIITPIIHIIBacIIJIHH
2QIIPeneJIeHHblMHnoJIgrmqecKIIMIIKPyraMIiilCOnPeneJIeH-

WWe"HTopIIHMIInpm3HaBaH, KaK Mi paHblne, naT"Ke
:BbII(KPfmoJIoBcKorocTopoHHmkaMIIEjieHblm' nMm;",

A¥A̲3"IIHpa34eJIHeTT:0IIKy3peHMH几B.qepenHHHa
Z KB Pag¥JIeBIixla o crpeMJIeiimm bTIIx 6oHp kb6jiIMM5

CJIHTBOit.HxnO3mUHIO6HcBH3blBaeTCTEM666TMEJiMZ

|:: # AK""p o a !! jl C JI y p L e̲yKaa coq" cTpJ6Z
169169npyroM
B MecTe
aBToD
roBoPIIT,3rb，ⅡMI'ITPmi,
Mo>KeT
6blTb,
6bm
q J

巴 BemiKOrQKHH3FIHoBrol)oIcKoroco
OTHIJIHe
BLIHy>KmeHne,mlITb,THP'JT
cBom1旦皿eH-Bacl!JIIIellj4 Egn n e l l Op cit, p 340):

W Jrennell OPcit,p339-34Q
171《ﾙIcTopIIHCCCP",1962,JYb4,cTp.206.
114

BoM,[IToEmeHaCTe巾aHOBIIaHaxO皿JIaCbBPOnCTBeHHbIX

5MmflIIIIXcKHH3bffM1IJIHToBcKOrOnPMaZ
OmKOnPoJIIIToBcKafIHacTPoeHHOcTbnajIPHKeeBbl"
PHnoJIoBcKoroHy>KnaeTcfl
B且oKa3aTeJIbcTBax.C[IHTaHapecT
1499n(BcooTBeTcTB皿c BoJIoroncKo-nepMcKojiJIeTonHcblo-nM1498r)nponpJDKeHI1eMonaJIbl̲npoTIIBnaTU

HKeeBbⅨHPHnOJIOB6KOTO
P
KaK
cTOPoHHIIKOB
UMIITP"-BHyKa,aBTOPnP皿aeT3Ha'IeHHeJIH皿b｡aKTynOHMKIITBepHTHHaA.Kopo60Ba,nocKoJ1bKyBM皿TB3TOM｡aKTeHaMeKHa
i6""6'̅ TBePci<IIx cIIJI g noJIb3y nMIITpmHl7a Ho o"QBPeMeHHblii aPecT BBPoMonaHoBcKoro, "232WI9WU

⑥

PbeBcerocCo巾bei,3aCTaBJIHeTyCOMHHTbcZBnPHHanlJIe)K△

iIocTIIA.Kopo60BaK<napTllli)>EJIeHbl一旦MHTPHH.

HAgiiaqblimeBacmJImHBeJIHKHMKHH3eMHQBrqponam
ncf6E3̅6bmo nonroToBJIeHo, no MHeHmIo A A. 3IIMIIHa,
《Ⅱpe且meCTByIO皿IｲMH
KOHTaKTaMPI
KHFDKHIIa
cHOBroPo瓜Ⅱa-

M"
(IIMeeTCHBB皿yno3m皿HHoBroponcKoroapxHemiCKo-'
nareHHa皿月，nOnneP>KIIBaBmero
Co(bblo)174.aTo
coo6pa]KeHIIenPencTaBJIHeT3HaqlITeJIbHblimHTePeR,XOTHHHe

o6'bflcHHeT IO KoHUa nPHIIHHbl Bo3BblmeHIIfl BacIIJIH月．
qTo6bI JIvqme noHHTb cMblcJI co6blTIIit l499 n, npocJIe-

皿MXO瓜noJIIITH[IGCKoii 60Pb6bl B l499-1500 rn
npoBo3rJIameHme BacmJIHH BeJIIIK" KHH3eM K "e"
cTaBJfeHIieeMyBBeJIIIKoeKHH>KeHIIeHoBroponaHncKoBa
60JIbmIMHCTBo JIeTOⅡHcHblx cBonPB oTHOCIIT, KaK y)Ke roBO-

"JIocb, K 21 MapTa̲1499 rj75 3a Hen､ np gToro, 14 M4p:
fa l499 r" HBaH III BbmaJI rpaMoTy O 6ecnomJIHHHoM
U

npoBo3e BMocKByMIITponollllqbeiipbI6bI m3"yxceBep-

HLIX IOMoBHblX MOHacfblPei MIITPOnoJIIITa - BgCIfPeCeHbKord qepenoBeuKoro m HIIKoJIbcKoro c KoB>Kml76 B rpaMOTe巾HKcHPoBaJIIJcb Te )Ke nP"a nPOe3na, [ITO H B nP"-

mecTBVIomei rpaMoTe l496 r.177, ToJIbKo cQcTaB TepplITopHⅡ,dePe3KoTOPblePa3PemaJIcHnPoe34,6bmpacmlIpeH.
-

｡

ー

172 A.A、3HM PI H. OcHoBHble npo6JIGMbl…, cTp. 106; o H )K e. O noJIPITHIIeCK}IX nPe且nocbIJIKax.,., cTp. 35.

173A.A、3IIMHII・OcHoBHblenpo6JIeMI〕1...,cTP.106,npHM.69;oH>Ke.
O rio"T"ecKmx npemocbmKax", eTp 35, npmM "
174A. A 3IIMHH･OcIIoBHble nl)o6JIeMbl..., cTp' 106-107; o H >K e
O HoJT,!,ITH[IecKHx IIpeⅡnocI,IJIKax..., cTp. 37.

175 HCPJI, T. 1V, w．,1, Bbln. 2, cTp. 531j T、VI,cTp、43, 243;T. V111,

"1 236-237;T. XII, cTp. 249; m ", nep¥HnoJIoBIIHa, cTp. 368;

T､21，BTopaHnoJIoBHHa，cTp、571；T､28,cTp、332．
176 Am3IIX,:q. 1, Nh 293; JI B II e p e ll II Il H. yKa3・COII., '1. 2, CTP. 224.
177 A3IIX, 11. 1, Nb 292.
115

8:
！

rpaMoTaanpecoBaJiacb《BJIyKoBeCb,､旦aHaycTb-meKcHbi,
na Ha y|CTb-MoJIOrli, nla Ha yrJIeII,,n<aBKa皿IH, Xa Ha yCTb-

n)IDIHbI, " B HPOcJIaBJIb, 4a B PoCToB, la B nePecJIaBJIB, "

B HMIITpoB MblTmIIKoM BceM)'. no cpaBHeHHId c rpaMOToi
1496 r. 3，Ⅱecb XOHoJIHHTeJIbHo ynoM"yTbl HpO'CfJIaBJIb, PocToB̲ H nepecJIaBJIb (IIepe3 HHx, Mo>KeT 6blTb, Be3JIH pbl6y
MI3 HHKoJIbcKOIIo cKoB)KH MoHacTblpH, He "rypHpylO皿ero
B rPaMoTe l496 r). rPaMoTa l499 r. no cy皿eCTBy JteJIaJIa
MHTpOnOJIIIIa 3a"TePeCOBaHHbIM B yTBep>KneHHH cyBepeH-

HblX̲nPaB HBaHa lll B OTHomeHIIII BeJIo3ePcKoTo, ymI皿KOEo, KamHHcKoro, HpocJIaBcKoro, PocToBcKOro, nepecJIaBJIb-

3aJIeccIfOro m UMHTpoBcKoro ye310B. noqeMy lily)KnaJIcH
HBaHIIIBTaKOrOPO,nanO及及ePJKKeCOCTOPOHblMIITPOnOJ1HIIbeii Kal｡enpbl HaKaHyHe nocTaBJIeHHH BacHJIHH BeJIHKHM
ʻKHH3eM？

rPaMoTa nOKa3bIBaeT, qTO BeJIoO3ePo m nePeCJIaBJIb3aJIeccKHii (TeppIITopHII, KoTopbIMII B 1498 r., Kak MbI 3HaeM, Be"J1 JMIITpHii) B MapTe l499 r. IIoMHHHJIHcb pacno-

pmKeHHHM caMoro HBaHa lll. Ho oTcIoXa enBa JIII Mo>KHo

cnleJI3Th BblBOI o HaIIPaBJIGHHOcTH rpaMoThI nPoTHB nPHTH-

3aH城且MHTPIIHHaye31bl,HenaBHOBXO皿BmHeBCjepyero
BJIHHHHH. Bo-nepBLIx, oH He o6GnanaJI皿embHblMH (B TOM
，

IIH|CJIe TaMO)KeHHblMII)

nPaBaMH Ha aTII TePPIITO,PHH H KOIH-

TPOJI'HIPOBaJI Hx TOQnbKO B OTHOmeHHII C皿'e6Hblx TH>K|6; Bo-

BTopblx, ̲rpaMoTa Ho BpeMeHH 6JImKe He K onaJIe naTpIIKeeBbJx H P"OJIOBCKOrO (KOmae皿e 6blJIo BO3MOIKHO KaKOeTo BbIcTynJIeHHe nMIITpHH) , a K Ho)KaJIoBaHHIo Bac"" TIITyJIOM BeJIIIKOrO KHH3H.

Hy)KHooTMeTIITb,IITopaiioHbI,ynoMHHyTbleBrpaMoTe,
BXO瓜HJIII EPa3Hble nepHoAbl lo 1498 r. B yneJI BacHJIwI

(KamIIH, HpocJIaBJIb)皿HBC巾epy ero cyne6Hblx HoJIHoMoIIHih (nepecJIaBJIb-3aJIeccK", PIOcToB, BeJIoo3epo) , HBJ1HJIHQp onoplHblMILnyHKTaMU 3aroBopmHKoB B 1497 r. (yr-

"TI, BeJIoo3epo, PocToB) . He cJIytIaiiHo rpaMoTa l499 r.
6blJIa BbmaHa no rpaMoTe l496 f., HanpagjleHHoii B cBoe
BpeMH npoTHB TePPHToplIaJIbHblx npeTeH3" BacHJIIIH. nplI
3ToM rpaMoTe l499 r. npHnaBaJIH, Ka]KeTcH, e皿e 6oJIbmee

noJIHTHIIecKoe 3HaIIeHHe, KIeM rpaMoTe l496 r. (oTcIoJIa pacnPo,cTPaHeHHe c｡ePbl neiicTBHH npe)KHeii l、PaMOTbl nonoJI-

HHTeJIb'H9Ha
nepecJIaBJ1b-3aJIeccKIIii，PocToBcK砿H
Hpo-

CJIaBcK" ye3"I) .

BepoHTHo,He3anpJIromp21MapTal499r・o6cy]K4aJIcH
BOnPOC O TOM, KaKOBbl 6y八yT mpaBaH卿HK皿HB acHJIIIH.
116

Bo3Mo>KHo, cymeCTBOBaJI nPOeKT BOCCTaHOBJIeHIIFI erO B

POJIII
yneJ1EHOiO
nPaBIITeJIR
KammHa,HPOCJIaBJI2mnp･

Bbl,naqa MIITponoJIHIIbeMy nPMy l4 MapTa l499 r., 3a

HeneJIIo no o6'bHBJIeHHH BacIIJIHH BeJIHKHM KIJH3eM, rpaMo-

Tbl, ､yTBeP>KnaBmeii CyBePeHHble nPaBa HBaHa lll B OTHoIneH" BeJIoo3epa, KamHHa, yrnHqa H XpyrHx o6'beKToB
yneJIbHblX nPlITH3aHHii lI 6blBmHx c*ep BJIIIHHIIH BacHJT",
nOKa3blBaeT, IITo I'IBaH III He xoTeJI BO3BPamaTb CblHy eTO

yneJIbHble noJIHoMoIIHH B CeBepo-BocToIJHoii pycII H cTpeMIIJICH IO6HTbCFI HOn瓜ep]KKII MIITPOnOJIIITa B 3ToM BOnPOCe.
CBoeii neJIH BeJIHK" KHFI3b XIocTHr. 21 MapTa oH Ha3BaJI B
KaIIecTBe o6JIacTII, npeno'cTaBJIHeMoii BacHJIHIo B KHmKeHHe, I-Ie erO nPe7KHHe yneJIbI, a cOBePmeHIIO nPyryJO TePPH-

TopHIo - HoBropo,m H UcKoB. CToPoHHHKII MoJIoIoro KHH｡

3H

IIe

TOJIbKO

noHIIMaJIH

HOMIIHaJIbHblH

XaPaKTeP

3TOrO

nO)KaJIoBaHHH, Ho H 6bmH Pa30IIaPoBaHbl KPaxoM Hane]K"

Ha pecTaBpanIIIo BeJIo3epcKoro H KamHHcKo-TBepcKoro
KHH)KeH噸．TaKoBbl BepoflTHble

npHIIIMHEI

JBII)KeHHR HJIII

3aroBopa, B KoTopoM npIIHHJIH yIIacTHe B．B. PoMonaHoBcKHii H A.H・Kopo60B, apecToBaHHble B anpeJIe l499 r.
Mbl npHcoe及HHgeMCFI K nPe,nnoJIO>KeHIIIO eHHeJIa, qTO

aPeCT POMOnaHOBcKOrO -CO6LITHe, menmee BPa3Pe3 C
wHTepecaMII Co巾bII H BacHJIHH. EcJIH paccMaTpllBaTb
B.B・POMOn<aHOBCKOrO KaK BBIPa3IITeJIH HaCTPOeHII# BePeiicKo-6eJIo3epcKoii 3HaTH, a <<T*eplITHHa)> A. H. Kopo60Ba
KaK nPenCTaBHTeJIFI oⅡⅡO3PInIIOHHblx HBaHy lll TBePCKHx
KPyrOB, TO Hx nPe瓜nOJIaraeMaH <<BHHa> cTaHeT OqeBImHOi:
OHII OJTIIIIeTBOPHJIII CIIJIbl, 60POBmHeCH 3a PeaJTbHOe nPenocTaBJIeHIIe BacIIJIIMIo npaB Ha TBepcKoe lI BeJIo3epcKoe
KH月X《eHHH．

OnHoBpeMeHHocTb apecTa PoMoXaHoBcKoro II Kopo60Ba HeJIb3FI CqHTaTb CJIyTIaiiHOCTblO. IIX CBFI3blBaJIII KaK
o6mHOcTb noJIIITHIIeCKHx yCTPeMJIeHHii, TaK H CJIy>Ke6Hble
y3bl. B ceHTH6pe l498 r・oHH 6blJIII BoeBonaMII oJHoro Boi-

cKa : PoMonaHoBcKHi Bo3rJIaBJIHJI nepenpBoii noJIK, a Kopo60B-noJIK JIeBoi pyKII178. A. H. Kopo60B, KoHeqHo, -He
6bIJI KyⅡuoM, KaK npemloJIaraJI K．B. Ba3IIJIeBII'I. C KoHHa
80-x roXoB oH npHHIIMaJI yqacTHe B BeJIIIKoKHH>KecKHx

noxo"X:B 1488/89 r. - Ha BHTKy (B nepenoBoM noJIKy) 179,
B 1495/96 :r.- BのⅢH,JTFIH皿Io (B JIeBoii pyKe) 180, B I498 r.'Z8 <<Pa3P"HaH KHIIra l475-'1598 rr.:>. M., 1966, cTp. 28, "．27
179 TaM >Ke, cTp. 21, JT. 17.

180TaM>Ke,cTp.27,@J1.25
117

B Ka3aHb (B JIeBoii pyKe) 181. Ha HeKoTopoe BpeMH nocJIe apecTa l499 r. A I/1. Kopo60B IIcIIe3aeT I13 pa3pHIoB H
noFIBJIHeTcH BHoBb B oceHHeM pa3pHIe l505 r., nepBoM noc-

JYe CMepTH I/IBaHa lll '82. 3TO nOKa3blBaeT, IITO A. II. KOPO60B 6blJI cBH3aH c Ba|cHJIIIeM183, KoTopblii cpa3y )Ke no 3aHFITHH nPecToJIa no3a60THJIcR o ero Kapbepe. C BacHmIeM
6blJI cBH3aH I,I B. B. PoMoZIaHoBcKH曲. y>Ke B ceHTH6Pe
1501 r. oH 6blJI Ha3HaIIGH B cTopoJKeBoii noJIK184．C npHxonoM BacHJIHH K BJIacTII B. B. PoMonaHoBcK城 noJIyIIIIJI
noBblmeHIIe, cTaB BoeBonoii noJIKa npaBoii pyKII (ceHTfI6pb
1507 r.) 185.
HTaK, 3aroBop PoMonaHoB|cKoro H Kopo60Ba o6EHcHHeTCFI, no-BHn(HMoMy, oTKa30M IIBalla lll OCy皿eCTBHTb
TOT BaPHaHT HO)KaJIOBaHI'IH, KOTOPblii 6blJI Ha'I160JIee >KeJIaTeJIeH <<napTIIII> Co巾bH - BacPIJIIIH.
no IIHblM npH'IHIIaM o6'EHBJIeHHe BacIIJIH兜BeJIHKHM

KHH3eM HoBropona H UcKoBa BcTpeTIIJIo oTplmaTeJIbHylo
181 <Pa3pfmHaH KH}Ira...>, cTp. 28, J1. 27.
182 TaM )Ke, cTp. 37,几39.

183 HIITepecHo, qTo H BDIIBIIHyJIcH oH c 1488/89 r., T､e. IICcJIe ynaJIeHIIFI
IIBaHa HBaHoBHIIa II3 TBepH.

184 <Pa3P皿HaHKHHra…》, cTp 33, J1. 33 (B cTopo>KeFoM ucJ1Ky oH 6blJI
H B ceHTH6pe l502 r.- TaM )Ke, cTp. 35, JT､ 36; J. F e n n e ll Op.
cit, p 256, note 3). Bo3Mo)KHo, B. B. PoMo"HoBcKⅢ曲瓜06HJIcFI
nl)o皿eHF胴 e皿e paHbllle. PH瓜ⅡeTOmICHblx CBO,UOB yKaSblBaeT nOn

7008 ( 1499/|1500) r., 6ymo HBaH ill, noJIyIIIIB cEenleH" o npHHy]KneHMH ero npqepH EJIeHIJI K pHMcKoMy 3aKoHy>, (KaToJIHIJecTBy) ,

HocJIaJI K JIIIToBcKoMy BeJIIIKoMy KHH310 AJTeKcalmpy B. B. PoMoJIaHoBcKoro H XbHKa B. KyJIe皿1Ha (nCPJI, T､VI, cTP. 45, 243; T. V111,
cTp. 238; T. XII, cTp. 251; T. 20, nepBaH DoJIoBI冊la, cTp. 370; T. 21

J

BTOPa別noHoBIIHa, cTp. 572; T. 26, cTp. 292; T. 28, cTp. 333; cp. T. 1V,
II. 1, Bbln. 2 JI., 1925, cTI). 531 ) . CoTJIacHo IIocoJIIJcIくoii KHIIre,
B. B. PoMonaHoBcK" II B・KyJIe皿IIH e3ﾕI皿II
B
JIIITBy
B
MaPTe
11498 r., Ho B Hx巾yHKⅡHH He Bxo,miqm pa3roBopつくpHMcKoM3aKoHe〉
(<C6．PIIO", T 35, Nb 53) . nocKoJIIJKy TeMIJI IIocoJIbcTB 1498 1I
1499/1500 rr.- pa3HEIe, Mo)KHo 6blJIo 6bl npennoJJo)KHTb, ､ITo nepen

、

I･IaMH H3BecTIIH o XBVx pa3HI>Ix IIocoJIbcTBax. OHHaKo 3TcMV MemaIoT

XBa O6CTOFITeJIbCTBa: 1) OTcyTCTBIfe B JIeTOUIICHX COO6meHHH O nocoJILcTBe PoMQmaHoBcKoro II I<yJTemHHa l498 r., 2) coBm"eIIMe .mulHoro cocTaBa o60Hx HocoJIb'cTB. He HBI)THeTcH JIH H3BecTHe @JIeTonHceii
oIII|II60IIHblM, T. e. He llMelOT JIII oHII B BHnV nocoJIIJcTBo 1498 r.、

KOrna rOBOPHT O HOCOJIBcTBe non 7008 r. m npllImcI]IBaloT eMy BepoʼHcnoBe皿･IyIo TeMaTHKy？EcJIII B7008r．且eAcTBHTeJII〕Ho cocToHJIocb
nocoJIbcTBo

B

B.

PoMonaHoBcKoTo

H

B.

KVJIellIHEa,

To

3To

MorJIo

npOll30%TH JIII皿b nocJIe neKa6" ll99 r., a l,JMGHHo B rlepBcii noJIoBIIHe l500 I､., H60 elne B neKa5pe l499 r. B. KyJIelnwH HaxoⅡHJIcH
B MocKBe (ACSH, TJ, Nb 624; cp. ACSII, T. 111, Nb 276) .

185<<Pa3pfmHaHKHIIra…》,cTp.38,J1．4206.
118

peaKHIIIoBncKoBe.OxleB皿HP,Ha3HaqeHmeaTOPaCUeHmBaJIOCb nCKOBCKOi BePXymKOii KaK nOnblTKa nPHcOenHHe-

H血ncKoBa K HoBropony, T. e.巾aKTII[IecKH K MocKBe,
HocKoJIbKy HoBropon y>Ke BxoJHJI B cocTaB UeHTpaJIII30BaH-

Horo rocynapcTBa. Z3 HcKoBaB MocKBy 6blJIo 'HanpaBJIeHo
nocoJIbcTBo.

OHo

HacTaHBaJIo

Ha

coxpaHeHIIHくCTaPlIHbl>,

npe皿OJIaraBmeii l ) HOMIIHaJIbHoe nPH3HaHHe nCKOBIIqaMII
BePxOBHblM cIO3ePeHoM-くrocynaPeM》ⅡcKOBa TorO BeJIHKoTo KHH3H, KoToPblii HBJIHJIcH BemiKIIM KHfI3eM <<Ha MocKBe> 186; 2) ero HeBMemaTeJIbcTBo Bo BHyTpeHHIieH B 3Haqll-

TeJIbHoit Mepe Bo BHemHHe neJIa ncKoBa; 3) HaJIHIIHe
CO6CTBeHHOrO <KHFI3FI HCKOBcKOrO>.

naJIbHeimee pa3BIITIie co6blT戒nCKoBCKaH I JIeTOIIHCb
II306Pa]KaeT B cJIenylO皿eMBm瓜e: HBaH III <<OnaJIIIJIcH> 'Ha
HCKOBIIIIehHaPecTOBaJI IByx IIJTeHOB IIOcOJIbCTBa; B HoJIb3y
BacHJIHH cTaJI aKTIIBHo IeiicTBoBaTb HoBropon<cKHii apxH-

enHcKon reHHaⅡ城, KOTOPbl曲ⅡpHexaJI B HcKoB 30 Mafl,
nCKoBHrlII He naJIH eMy f<cO60POBaTH>, 3HaFI, IITO OH XOIIeT
<<MoJIHTII 60ra 3a KHfl3H BeJIHKoro BacHJIbfl>, H xmaJIII npHe3na cBoHx nocJIoB II3 MocKBbl C pe皿eHIIeM HBaHa lll;
reHHa皿蝋yexaJI II3 ncKoBa qepe3 4 HeneⅡHnocJIe cBoero
nPlK6blTIIH, T. e. B KOHUe HIOHH, nePen STIIM OH C Pa3PemeHHfI HOcanHIIKOB II 60HP <<360POBaJI nPlI KHFI3e nCKOBCKOM
AJIeKcaHXpe BoJIoIHMepoBII'III>;《ⅡO TOM》ncKOBHIIH HanPa-

BIIJIH B MocKBy BTopoe nocoJILcTBo <<61ITH IIeJIoM BeJIIIKoMy
KHR3Io HBaHy BacIIJIbeBIIIIIo HoBropoⅡuKOMy H HCKOBCKOMy,
qTo6bl rocynlapH HamH且OP>KaJIII OTIIIIHy cBOIO ,B CTaPHHe...>; HBaH III oTnycTHJI 3To HOcOJIbCTBo, naB HeOnPenleJIeHHblii oTBeT: <<A 3a MoHM 60HpHIHoM Bce 6yneT yKa3aHo>;
3aTeM B HCKOB nPHexaJI o6emaHHblit 60HpH:H (HBaH IJe60-

TOB) H O6EHBIIJI, [ITO HBaH III <<OTIIHHy CBOIO (nCKOB.C. K) neP]KHTb B cTaPHHe》nocJIe aToro, B 7008 r., B
MocKBy oTInpaBIIJIocb TpeTbe ncKoBcKoe nocoJIbcTBo c
186

CJIoB a "HoBroponlcKI噸 HnCKOBCKI'III> BXOXIIJTH B nOJIHblH TIITy,ⅢBe-

JIHKoro KIIH3H ̅ MocKoBcKoro (cM. TBHIIn, M 347) . nMIITpIIIo-BHyKy
JIeTonilICII II <<III'IH> nOCTaBJIeHIIH nPIImlcblBaloT THTyJI BeJIHKOro KHH3H BJIaユHMIIPCKOrO

II

MOcKOBCKorO,

B

HeKOTOPl'IX

CJIyqa3x

Ii HOBTo-

POncKOrO, a̅ B OJHOM cJIyrlae TaIPKe ̲TBePcKOrO (H.C. JI U) b e.

I"eoJIorIIIIscKafl 6opb6a…, cTp. 38｡1-386)．TaKwM o6pa30M, XMIIT･

PHii, B OTJIIIxIIIG OT HBaHa lII, enBa JIII CqIITaJ1cH CIo3ePelIOM nCKOBa,

j<oTH nocJTe nocTaBJIeHIIH BacIwIIIH BeJII1KIIM KHH3eM HoBropona lI

ncKoBa B30pbl HcKoBIIIIeii o6paTIIJIIIcb KaK pa3 K HeMy KaK coIIpaB･IITeJIIo IIBaHa lll. OH 6blJI ntJIH HHx xopoIH HMeHHo TeM, IITo Jie HMeJI
B CBOeii cnemlaJIbHOii KOMneTeHnM'HnCKOB，
119

IIeJIO61ITbeM <K BeJIHKIIM KHH3eM》 HBaHy lll lI BaclMJIIIIo
I'IBaHoBHIIy o6 0cBo60>KneHIIII IByx nOcamHHKoB - qJIeHoB
U

nePBOrO nOCOJIbCTBa, aPecTOBaHHblX B HatlaJIe 3TOH anOneH.

BeJIHKIIe KHH3bFI IIx npocTIIJIH, m ncKoBcKIIe nocanHIIKPI Bep-

IHyJIHcb B ncKoB 24 ceHTH6pH 1499 r・B HcKoBe ocTaJIcH
CBO力くKHH3b

ncKoBcKo#>.

II3BecTIIH

o

co6blTHJIx

31IMbl

1500 r., BecHbl H oceHH 1501 r. noKa3blBaloT xapaKTep oTHomeH" Me)KIy ncKoBoM H MocKBoil. BepxoBHbIMH cIo3ePeHaMHnCKoBa HBJIHJIHcb B 3TH OTPe3KII BPeMeHII HBaH III

H BacIIJIIm, c KoTopblMH HcKoBHIIH HMeJIH瓜eJIO Ho BOnPOcaM BOiiHbI c JIHTBOi lI JIPIBOHCKHM O皿eHOM 187.
HeKoTopble noBopoTHble MoMeHTbl 60pb6bl l499 r. ocTaIoTcH He BHoJIHe Hc:HblMH. Coo6皿eHHe JIeTOHIICH, yKa3blBaIO皿ee, IITO reHHaⅡ砿《360PoBaJI npH KHfI3e ncKoBcKOM

AJIeKcaHmPeBoJIo瓜HMePOBHIIII>,HanO,OKIeBH4H0,PaCneHH＝

BaTb

KaK

enIIcKona

CBImeTeJIbcTBo
oT

cBoero

OO

OTKa3e

HOBroPOJIcKOrO

nepBoHaqaJIbHoro

nJIaHa

aPxH-

npIIBecTH

nCKOB K《nplIcHre Ha BepHocTb> BacHJIIIIo，nOI BJIWIHHeM KaKHX ｡aKTOPOB yCTynlIJI reHHa瓜嘘HCKOB函aM？Ⅱo

HJIH HOCJIe BO3BPa皿eHIIFI B ncKOB yIIacTHHKa nePBOrO nOcOJILcTB a-ⅡOCa皿HKa

CTe巾aHa - 6blJIa

CneJIaHa 3Ta

yCTynKa？HMeJIJIHreHHa且嘘ceKPeTHylO HH巾OPManlIIO II3

MocKBbIP

npyroii Bonpoc: Koma npH6blJIo H Korna oT6blJIo H3
MocKBbl BTopoenocoJIbcTBo？Kor“Ⅱ”exaJI B ncKoB
HBaHIIe60ToB？nocKoJIbKy oT'Ee3n BTOPblX nOCJIOB CoCTORJIcFI HocJIe oT'Le3nla reHHamIFI, IIx npH6LITIIe B MocKBy
Hy>KHo oTHecTII, Ho-BHJHMoMy, K IIIoJIIo 1499 r. B HIIcbMe
-

H3 PIoreHa oT 28 IIIoJIH 1499 n JIIIBoHcKIIi MarHcTp (opmeHMeitcTep) coo611LaJI xoxMeiicTepy, ､ITo Bac"城Ⅱo℃a>KeH

BeJIIIKIIM KHH3eM HoBropo,niaH nCKOBa, HCKOBIIIIHⅡP OTIIB
3TOTO H CHaPH,ⅡJIJIH B MocKBy nocoJIbcTBo, nByx IIJIeHoB Ko-

ToPoro I'IBaH III aPecTOBaJI, noCJIe IIero HcKoBHIIH HanPa-

-

ユ

BHJIH K BeJIHKoMV KHH310 BToDoe nocoJIbcTBo c 60JIbmlIMH

naPaMII; onHH cqIITalOT, rITO OHO BePHeTCFI B HCKOB |Ha CB.

Bap巾oJIoMe兄(24 aBrycTa) , npyrlIe nyMaIoT, [ITo He PaHbme
皿月cB. A皿peFI (30 HoH6pH) 18a Me>Kny ncKoBoM H PIoreHoM paccToHHIIe 60JIbme, IIeM Me>Kny ncKoBoM H MocKBoh．

no9TOMy ecJIH TaM cTaJIO H3BeCTHOOBToPOMHOCOJILCTBe
187 <nCKOBCKIJe ,JIeTOnHCI"", Bbln. 1, Cm.83-86.

188 LEKUB, 2-te Abt., Bd．l, JYb 848, S. 647 (yKa3aJIa H Iiel)eBGJIa cO
CTapoHeMemKoro A. JI. XopomKGBIIII) .
、120

ncKoBIIweii oKoJIo 28 IIIoJIH, Mo]KHo HoJIaraTb, qTo caMo HoU

coJIbcTBonpII6blJIoBMocKByno28HIoJIH­nO-BH皿IMOMy,
BCePe皿HeMeC皿a.Tor@maemeHe6blJIoo巾皿HaJIbHoroPemeHiiH, Bo BcfIKoM cJIyqae, IIBaH IILHe o6'bHBIIJI ero noCJIaM・HBaH qe60ToB npHexaJI B ncKoB, BepoHTHo, He

響 m60TPeTbenocoJIhgTgo,oTnpaBHBuleeCH
paHbmeaBrycTa,
b MocKBy
ｰ BbKope nocJIe npHe3" qe60ToBa, BepHyJIocb
ToJIbKo 24 ceHTFI6".

nJIHyTOIIHeH"KaPTIIHbI,'HaPHcOBaHHQjiBHCKOBCKOiil
U

JI eTOnHcli, 60JIbmoe 3HaqeHIIe HMeloT coo6HIgHⅢ月旦ByX npyrlIX JIeTOⅡHcIHblx HcToIIHHKoB: BoJIoroncKo-nepMcKoi JIeToU

ⅡHcHHKpaT1KoroJIeTomlcUa,oIIy6JIHKoBaHHoToH.C.JIypbe.
I'I3BeCTIIH STII 6JIH3KII Me丞旦y co60ii, Ho pacxomlTcH B HeKOTOPblX CymecTBeHHbIX JIeTaJIFIx, nOaToMy nPHBeneM HX
na P aJIJIeJIbHo.

BoJIoroncKo-nepMcKafI JIc.roIIHcb

KpaTKI1i# JIGTomIcelX

《Toro ]Ke JIeTa (7007. - C. K.),

《Toro >Ke J1eTa (7007.-C. K､), MeCf'-

IIIoHH B 29, KwI3b BeJIHKIMii HBaH

na HIoJIH 29八eH・KHH3B BeJTHKIIii HBaH

BacHJIbeBIIII no)KaJIoBaJI cBoero cEIHa KHFI3fl BacRJIbfl BeJIIMKIIM KHH-

BacIIJIbeBwx

KHII3H BacIIJIbH HoBblM roponpM Ha

>KeHHeM , Ho BI,IM ropoXoM II nbcKo-

BeJIHKoe KHH)KeHHe H HaPeqe ero BeJIH-

BoM , H HaPeIIe ero BeJIHKHM KHH3eM ,
II 6JIarOCJIOBIJma eTO MHTPOnoJIHT
CHMaH H enHcKonm Ha BeJIHKoe

KIMM KHH3eM , H 6JIarocJ1OBIIma ero MIITDoIIoJIHT

KHH)KeHIIe
HoBoropo1ⅡKOe>189.

KHH3H IOpbJI Ha nMHTpoB, a KHH3H
nMHTPefl yrJIIiqeM"190 .

noXaJIoBaJI

cBoero cblHa

CHMoH , II nocTVn H Ha BeJIII-

、

Koe KHfl)KeHIIe Ha HayropoZcKoe , a

O6a HcToulHIIKa corJIacHbl B ToM,'IITo BacHJIHii peaJIbHo

noJ1yIIHGII
ToJIbKo<<KHH>KeHIIe
HoBoropo皿Koe)'.Pacxo>K¥HIie cOcTOHT B OnPemeJIeHHH TePPlIToPlIH, <<Ho>KaJIoBaHHOIIp

BacHJIHIo. BoIJIoro4cKo-nepMcKafI JIeTonHcb B cooTBeTcTBHH

C MaPToBcKHM II3BeCTlieM APymX JIGIOnmcHbIJfBoXoP roBo-

PHT o HO>KaJIoBaHⅢHHoBrop onaHncKoBa. KpaTK" JIeTo-

nHceU B COOTBeTCTBIIH c ｡aKTHIIeCKHM Pe3yJIbTaTOM《ⅡO>KaJIoBallHH> VHoMHHaeT H 3Xecb JII'Imb HoBropo,n<.

KPoMe Toro, JIeTo皿CII yKa"IBaIOT Pa3ILIe MecHIlb[ no-

》KaJIoBaHH別. Bo Bcex cⅡHcKax BoJIoroncKo-nepMcKoit JIeTo-

mlcH - HIoHb, B KpaTKoM JIeTonHcUe-HIOJIb・HMelO皿aHcH
189 nCPJ1, T. 26, cTp、291.
190 H. C. JI y l) b e. IKpaTKllii JIeTonMceU

noro,n.IIIICKOTo

CO6PaHWI.一

くApxeorp a巾函ecKHii e]Kel､oEHHK 3a l962 I,o瓜》. M., 1963, cTp. 443.
121

II peKoHcTpylIpyeMaH xpoHoJIorllFI

co6blTHii,

omIcaHHblx

B

nCKOBCKOii l JIeTOHIICH, XaeT OCHOBaHIIFI n<yMaTb, TITO B HIOHe pemeHIIfl o HocTaBJIeHIIH BacIIJIHH Ha HoBropoIcKoe KIHH>KeHHe He 6blJIo. ToJIbKo HocJIe Bo3Bpa皿eHHH BTOPOrO nO-

coJIbCTBa(aOHOHaXO皿JIocBBMocKBeoKoJIocepenHHbl
I'IoJ'H )ⅢnpHe3na B HcKoB HBaHa qe60ToBa ncKoBHIIH o6-

paTHJIHe. K BeJIHKHM KHH3bHM HBaHy Bac"beBHIIy lI Bac"HIo IIBaHoBHqy. 14 IIIoJIFI 1499 r. B KaIIecTBe BeJIIIKoro

KHFI3H "ryPHPoBaJI e皿e nMHTpHi-BHyK 191. >KaJIoBaHHble
rPaMoTbl Ha HoBrOPOIcKHe 3eMJIII, 'CocTaBJIeHHble OT IIMeHH

IIBaHa lll H BacHJIHH, HoHBIIJIIIcb JIIImb B aBrvcTe l499 r.192

BceaTono3BoJIHeTcrlHTaTbHIoJIb,aHeHiOHbMec皿eM,
Korma HBaH III o6'bFIBIIJI o Ho)KaJIoBaHHH BacHJIIIIo HoBro-

PoIcKoro
KHFDKe|HHH
193．nPH̲
nePenHcKe
IIcToIIHIIKoB
Hepen(Ko nyTaJIH HIo|Hb H HIoJIb. OnHaKo KPaTKHii JIeTonHceU B

IIacTH, Ka,caIo皿eiicH co6blTHii KoHna XV - Ha'IaJIa XVI B.,

He 6blJI cmlcaH c BoJIoroncKo-nepMcKoii JIeToHHcH. Cy"
Ⅱo瓜OnOJIHHTeJIbHblM II3BeCTWIM, KoTOPble B HeM COnePJKaT-

cm (B paccMaTpHBaeMoii cTaTbe - o no>KaJIoBaHHII VneJIoB

lOpHIoHⅡMIITpHIo) , oH HMeJI oco6blii HcToqHHK. npHMeIIaTeJIbHo, IITo nocJIenHee co6blTHe, ynoMHHyToe B JIeTonHc-

Ir,- ncKoBcKoe B3HTHe l510 n (omlI60IIHb nOn 7017 r.) .

CBFI3b Me>Kny aToit KoHnoBKoii II 60JIee ToIIHblM, IIeM B B6-

JIOronCKO-nePMcKo# JIeTOHIICII, H3JIO)KeHHeM O6cToHTeJIbcTB

no)KaJIoBaHHHBacPIJIHHB
1499r.,no-BHJIHMoMy,3acJIy>KHBaeT CnemIaJIbHOTO II3yqeHHH.

HMMyHHTeTHblerpaMoTblaBrycTal499r.HoBropon<cKHM
MoHacTlJpHM IIoMoraloT HoHHTb xapaKTep Ho)KaJIoBaHIIH BacHJ1IIH HoBI10pon;oM H nomITI1IIecKHe nemi 3Toro mara.

B cMblcJIe TIITyJIa BacHJIIIm, 6e3ycJIoBHo, BblHrpaJI. OH
BnePBble CTaJI 'Ha
９１
１
９２ nCP几T.
１

3aKoHHblx OC:HOBaHHHX BeJIIIKIIM KHH3eM

23, cTp､196; ̲cp. Tq V111, cTp; 237; T. XII, cTp. 249.

ZIAH, T. 1, Nh 48, cTp、67-68; r. r o im y K o B. KPaTKOe omicaHzle

193

K"oncKoro TpoEIIKoro MoHacTHpH. M., 1815, cTp. l7-18.
CcblJIaFIcb lla BoJIoroXcKo-nepMcKylo JIGTonHCb, A. A、311MHH BBIcKa3aJI

npennoJIo>KeHHe,

IITo

<<Bo3Mo)KHo,

ToJIbKo

29

II}oHH

BacIIJ1Hii

IJBaHOBIIII 6blJI OqJI皿IIaJIbHo nPOBO3rJIameH BeJIIIKIIM KHH3eM>
{A. A. 3 II M II H. OcHoBHble npo6JISMbl."., cTp. 107, IIpmM. 76; o H jK e.
OnoJI|1,IIHLIGcKHx npennocblJYKa'<..., cTp. 37, IIpllM、79). OHHaKo naHHblMII Bo@JIoroDIcKo-nepMcKo面、ⅡeToIIIIcH M Kp8TKoro JIeTomlcna
JIyl)be He nel)erlePKHBaeTcH I13BecTIIe XPylMX JIeTCIMCeii O nO>KaJIOBal･IPIII 21 Mal)Ta l499 r., H60 HcKoBcKafl l JIe'romlcb noKa3blBaeT,
KaKOe conPOTHBJIeHHe Bbl3BaJIO MaPTOBCKOe nO)KaJIOBaHHe. n01)KaJIOBaHI,Ie BacIIJIIIFI 29 HIoJIH 1499 r、6bIJIO BTOPmuIHLIM.
122

BceHPycmXoTHo6erpaMoTbImomnmBf9ETW̲"QW9-

poiinojloBIIHbIXVIB,Henp"g及HTcHCOMHeBaTbcHBnPaU

BIIJIbHOcTH
nePenaqHⅡ'obJie"IMH
intitulatio
rpaMoT
1499
r.
四

W5"o cHoIile"H
zMeHHo
cHomeHHH
c cHoBroponpM
HoBropo且oM6blJIII
6bIJIII
ToHⅡoIIBoH，Ha、
ToMpqBoH,13

k6;5" E63imk T,iTyJI BeJImKOro WfI3a ̲""̲fY" :皿e
U

riWE "Em6cTe 6 TeM ToJIbKo HoBroponcKoit ,9#JI¥Tbp

:r;MMenemmme RpeM3 M cJyaHi,WJUJMMW
iBMEMm5fbr BacmJIIiH II m lIBa"mg̲HW9PWM

1456II1471rr.cocTaBJIeHbIoTo6'beⅡHHeHHoroJIIIIlaBeJIIIk6FMH"H H ero cTapmero cbIHa, JpIIIIelMWIIrypIIpy"

6YMji6mEEJ,IIKOro kuH3H "CC" R)lc""̲̲9Tgrr.TWW
ynMe6JIHeTcHnpmmMenmHBaMIjpa"".2.HW八py-

" iIoBroponcKIii< JIQKyMeHTax !" Ho HH BMe)WW"
CKIMX
nPrOgOpaX
!97-200,
HH
B叩aMoTaX,
KOToI)ble
BblntaJI
CaM
iMIWidf5", K erd TIITyJIy HIIKoma !r nplI6aB""gb
U

CJIOBa
<<BceJI
PycH》r̅HeTIikiIBTIITyJIe
BacmJIlifI
HBaHo､
BHIIa
Cepe八HHbf
80-x
ronoBB
l490-1497
rr・BacIIJIHH,
KaK
Mbl
3HaeM,
0巾皿maJIbHO
6blJI
TOJIbKO
<KHFI3eM》nMHTplIIIU

U

U

BHVKBBblnaHHblXH nO瓜nHcaHHblxHMrPaMOTaxnePEOH

nojioBIIHb!
1498
Ha3blBaeTcH《IBeJ1IIKIIM
P
KHFI3eM>.
Be3

0npeneJIeHHHくBCeH
PyCH>
ynoMHHaIOTcH
HBaH
IIBaHoBHII,
ひ

B acHJI嘘Ⅲ瓜MHTP" II B IIOcOJIbCKIIx KHIIrax.

碑

BepoHTHO, HE ToJIbKo c BHyTplinoJImTIIqecKoII, Ho m̲p
BHemHenOJIIITHIIeCKo曲TOIIKII 3PeH" nPHcBOeHHe Zoro̲TIIユ

;MMMMi̅"KoM He ybTpamBajIo HBaHa JII, m6Q B
U

9b-x ronax JImToBcKIIii Be皿Kmi KHFI3b, HMeBm皿B cBOeM

BJI"eH" 3ananHyIo <<Pycb>', He xoTeJI np23HaBW MoEW-

Ef5fEMMM､idIH3HINOCynaPeM<<BceHPyqi),201,ajOHBJIe|HHee皿eOntHoroHJIIInByxBeJIIIKIIxKHH3eH《BceHPycII>>
U

瓜aJIO6bl
JImTBe1OnOJIHHTeJIbHble
ocHOBaHⅢ只旦JIH
HelTpH-

3"ilifinBaHalllBeJIMKIIMKHH3eM<<BceHPyCIi》・ynoTpe6JIeHIie cJIoBくBceH PycHil B JPKyMeHTax, HcxOmIB皿Hx oT
66nPaBIITeJIei, 03HaqaJIO B rJIa3aX HBaHa nOKymeHme, Ha
○

erOBblCmTMM5raTIIBblIIHeMe"eHHonPeceKaJIocb
(Mh!
ユ

194rBHmn,Jw16,19,21,86,88;Ac3H,T､111,M2.
194a f fl6IMI6"giiMeilIIoHOBroPoma, a He TBepll nOCjpL>KmlWifxW"

MoMeHToM
PacnpocTPaHelIHnTIITyJIa
BeJIIIKOrO
K"3只
<BCGH
PyCl,I>
IXM3Mf n｡WME"3m, f !, M 516; TII, Nh 254, 256, 266;

T､111, Nb 291).

!95 rBHFIn, Nb 22-23, 26-2Z.

196 T5M )Ke; Nb 25; ACSH, TJ11, Nh 1Z
197­鋤o CM.ⅡⅢⅡr, yKa3aTeJIb.

201 CM．《C6. PHO"; T. 35, Nb 64
123

nyMaeM,

IITO

IOMOraTeJIbCTBO

THTyJIa

BeJIHKOrO

KHH3H

U

＜BCefl PyCII> 6blJIO OnHOHH3ⅡplIIIHH onaJIbl BacHJIHH B

KoHme l497 rⅢⅡMHTp"-BHyKa B KoHUe l498 r.) .

B rpaMoTax aBrycTa l499 r. intitulatio 3aHM'cTBoBaHo

H3

HOBrOPOICKO-MOCKOBCKHXノIoroBopoB 1456 H
U

1471 rr.

①opMaJILHo BacﾙIJIPIII oKa3aJIcFI B PoJIII, cXo>Ken c noJIo>KeU

HHeM IIBaHa MoJIoXoro HaIIaJIa 70-x rOnoB, Korna ToT eme
He HMeJI HHKaKHx caMOcToHTeJIbHbIx巾yHKⅡ戒. BaCHJIIIii He
u

npHo6peJInpaBa
pacnopmKaTbcHHoEiopoIoM,Ho,BbIcTynaH B rPaMOTax BKyne c oTHOM, OH KaK 6bI nOmmICblBaJIcH
U
u

nOn TOII HOJIIITIIIIecKOi JIHHHeii,

KOTOPylO

nPOBO瓜HJI

llBaH III. CJJen;oBaTeJIbHo, caM HBaH Hy)K"JIcH gcoIoSe c
BacHJIHeM(Mo)KeT6blTb,mImbBeroHMeHH)J;JIHnpo'BemeU

HHH HOBrOPOnCKOII HOJIIITHKH.

B IIeMcocTo月JIa 3TanoJIHTHKa,eCJIH CynHTbnO aBryCTOBCKHM
rPaMoTaM？HHTePeCHblH
MaTePHaJI且aeTrPaMOTa
KoHeBcKoMyMoHacTbIplo202,KoTopblii6LIJIpaCnoJIoi<eHHa
〃

⑪

OcTPOBeOKoJIO3ana八HOrOHo6ePe>KbHJIanPZKcKOrOO3ePa.

AHaJIII3
｡opMyJIHpa
rpaMQTbI
nO3BoJIHeT
BbIneJIHTb
qeTbipe
9pHoBHble TeMbI, pa3pa60TaHHble aBTopoM noKyMemh:

1 ) Pe3KOe orPaHIIIIeHHe !OPIIc"KUIIII m 6IIHaHCOBIiX moJIU

HoMoIIHH HoBrQponcKoro apxHemlcKona; 2) '｡HKcaU" 3Ha-

qHTeJIb¥oroo6'beManpaBHaMecTHIIKoBHnPyrHxnpelcTa④

BHTeJIeH BeJIHKoK”>KecKoHBJIacTH；3）npoBeⅡeHHeo6皿eBeJIIIKoKHHIKecKoH BJIacTH; 3) npoBeneHIIe o6
TaMo)KeHHoII HoJIHTHKH; 4) yKpenJIepyccKHxn”HⅡ皿oBoBTaMo〕KeHHoHnoJIHTHKH；4）yKpemeHIIe amMHHHcTPaTIIBHOrO HMMyHHTeTa MOHacTblPH H O6eCneIIeHHe ero 3KoHoMIIIIecKHx HHTepecoB. noJIHTHIIecKII HaII60-

JIee pcTpblMH 6blJIII nepBble nBa BonpoCa.
CorJIacHo rpaMoTe, apxHellHcKoi lf ero HaMecTHHKII JIHmaJIIIcb nPaBa cyna HaJI HryMeHOM, 6paTbeIo, a TaK>Ke
JIIOnbMH H KpeCTbHHa|MII MOHacTblPcKoii BoTrlHHbl B n(eJIax,
nOHBenoMCTBeHIIbIx CBeTCKOMy cyny (3a aPXHenlICKoHoM
cOxPaHHJIocb npaBo cyna JIHmb nO nyxoBHLIM neJIaM ”

《OⅡP函b nyXOBHblx neJI)') ; aPxHemlcKony H erO nPencTaBHTeJUIM He Pa3PemaJIocb 6PaTb c MoHaCTblPCKHX BoTIIPIH
《OTKyna...ⅢⅡOmJIHH... HHKaKmx>,, a TaK)Ke CTaBHTb <KOPMHTH>D aPxHenHCKOIIcKHx KoHeH
MHTH＞aPxHeⅡHCKOncKHx
KoHeii B MOHaCTblPCKHx
MOHaCTblPCKHxBJIa瓜eHHBJIaneHH-

HX; XecHTIIJIbHIIKaM H《JIIonHM BJIanblIIHHM> 3anPe皿aJICH
BEe3n BMOHaCTblPcKHe aeMJIH, HOcTOii, B3HMaHHe KOPMOB,
ⅡQmBon H npoBo"HHKoB. B cTaTbe o cMecHoM cynle OroBaPHBaJIocbHeyIIaCTHeaPxHemiCKOnaBHcHOJIHeHIIHnPHrOBO202，ⅡAM,T.I,N@48,cTI)､67-68
124

I)aoTHocHTeJTbHoMoHacTblpcKoroqeJIoBeKa.HaKoHen,B
I1CKOBblx ,meJIax c HOcTOPoHIIMMII JII皿aMII, BblxO且fI皿mX3a

IIPeneJIbl KOMIIeTeHUIIM HaMeCTHIIKoB,IIryMell,6paTHfl,Mo-

HacTblPcKI1e JIIOmH II KPecTbFIHe 6blJIH HOnBeloMcTBeHHbl He

apxHeⅡⅡcKOny,aMOCKOBcKOMynpaBHTeJIbCTBy("IMbI
"eM Ha 'HIIx cBoIIx npIIcTaBoB c MocKBb[…>).
II3BecTHO, qTO y)Ke B nOCJIenHHii nePIIO4 HoBrOPOIcKoi

He3aBHCIIMOCTII IOPHcユⅡKmlH aPXHenlICKOna BblTeCHfIJIacb

IopHc皿KIImeii
CBeTCKHX
BJIaCTeii
203,
OnHaKo
OrPaHIIIIIITb
Cyr
JIC6Hble nPaBa apxHeⅡHcKOna B OTHO皿eHIIH MoHacTblPeH
6blJIO He JIerKO・CoxpaHIIJIHcb rpaMoTbl, oTHQcHMble no

apxHenHcKonaMK1434-1458204,1459-1470205H14711482 rr. 206, B KoTopblx Ka｡eApa 3anpemaeT npenlcTaBHTeJIHM HoBropom<cKHx cyne6Hblx opraHoB Bbl3blBaTb HryMeHa,

KIepHenoB II KpecTbFIH CnaccKoro BepC皿oBcKoro (6JIII3
HoBropo") MoHacTbIpH B cyユⅡoH℃KOBbl M八eJIaM, c'IHTaFI

3TOHCKJIIOI1m'1,eJIbHOitilPePOraTIIBOikaPxmenmcKOna:<<4Ka-

KOBO 6yneT KOMy nO Im)meJIO, H OH ("ICTem.- C. ̲ K) Hx

30BeT Hamelo nd30BHoIo, a cyJI HM npeXo MHoIo B HoBeropone>.

Mbl notITII HHIIero He 3HaeM o6 3BoJIIoUlIH apxHenHcKon-

cKoii IopHclHKU,HH HocJIe npHcoe且HHeHIIH HoBropona. B neKa6pe l477 r. HBaH III o6emaJI HoBroponcKHM 60flpaM H
BJIanblKe BblHoJIHIITb Hx npocb6y oTHocHTeJIbHo Toro, 1ITo6bl
くHnO3Ba MoCKOBCKarO 207 1I cyny 6blTII nO cTapHHe>, 208.
<<CTapHHa>D sTa, oIIeB皿HO, C*oPMyJIIIPOBaHa B nOrOBOPe
1471 r.,me cKa3aHo: <<A no30B Ho BoJIocTeM HoBoroponU

CKHM

HO3blBaTII

nO30BHIIKOM

BeJIHKHX

KHfl3eH瓜a

HOByrO-

U

U

POnCKIIM; a B roPO,me nO3blBaTH KHH3eH BeJIHKHx nOnBOH-

cKOii, a HOByrOPO且nKOii nOnBOiiCKO" 209．H3 rpaMoT 1499­
1 500

rr.

HOHBHJIIIcb

BHIHo,

tlTo

nPHCTaBbl

BMecTo

HoBropo,mcKIIx

HOBrOPOIcKIIx

Ho30BHIIKoB

HaMeCTHHKoB, 'HO

KaK

203 HPn, BbIn. 11, cTp. 229-231.
204 rBHHⅡ, Nh94.
2()5 TaM )Ke, Nb 97.
206 TaM >Ke, Nb 100.

207 naJIee lI3"TeJIII Cod)IIiicKoii ll lI Bocl<peceHcKoii JIeTonMceii BcTaB･

"IoT cJIoBa "e 6bm6 611 (nCPJI, T. VI, -cTp. 215; T' V111, crp. 194) ,

oLIeB"Ho, 3allMcTByH IIx II3 nPaBJIeHoro JIbBoBcKoro (CEaco-EB｡
"IMbeBcKoro) cnHcKa XVIII B. J1bBoBcKoii @JIGTonlIcII (nCPJI, T. 20,
nepBaH noJIoBHHa, cTp. 330) . STa BcTaBKa, oTcyTcTByloUaH Bo Bcex

J I e T O m I C H x ， H C K a > K a e T C M b l c J I Te KC Ta 、

208 HCPJI, T. VI, cTP、215; T、V111, cTp. 194; T. XII, cTp. 182; T. 20,
nePBa兄ⅡoJIoBIIHa, cTp. 330; T. 25, cTp､318.
209 rBHHn, JYb 27, cTp. 49.
125

3'ro IIoBJIwIJIo Ha cyne6Hble npaBa apXHenMcKona no l499 r.,
Mo)KHo To,JIbKo moranlblBaTbcH. CyUecTBeHHylo poJIb cblrl)an, HO-BH瓜HMoMy, C皿e611HK 1497 r., KoTopbl曲BBO八IiJI B
UeHTPaJIH30BaHHOM nOPHJIKe nOnCynHoCTb nO mCKOBblM八e-

JIaM JIH60 MOcKoBCKoMy nPaBIITeJIbCTBy, JIH60 MecTHoii
cBeTcKoii anMHHHcTpaUHII. B cT. 37 Cynie6HHKa roBopHJIocb, IITo GcJIH o6a TH)Ky皿HxCH (HO HCKOBblM ,meJIaM) HBJIHIOTCH )KHTeJIHMII O,mHOrO II TOro >Ke rOPOna HJIII BOJIOCTH,
To !HeneJIb皿ⅢKmPJIJKeH
CTaBHTb
HX
nePen
HaMecTHHKOM

IIJIII BoJIocTeJIeM. B CT. 30 HoBropon BeJIIiKIIii 6bIJI BKJIIoIIeH B nepeIIeHb ropoIoB, Kyna nocblJIaJIIIcb II3 MocKBbl He一

二

JIeJIb皿IIKH c cyneOHblM Bbl30BOM.

Ho MHeHIIIo B. H. ABToKpaToBa, T. H.《nPaBocynHe MHTPOnOJIIiqbe> Bo3HIIKJIO B

KPyraX HoBrOPonCKOrO八yXOBeH-

cTBa B nepHoX Me)KXy l497 r. H HaqaJIoM XVI B. II HMeJIo
neJIDIo <<3aMeHIITb ocHoBHble noJIo>KeHIIH CVnle6HIIKa l497

rona HOPMaMH ycTaPeBmerO HOBrOPOnlCKOrO npaBa>, 210.
B sToM naMHTHIIKe ecTb cTaTbH, rJIacHmaH:<IITO CH JleeTb
B |MoHaCTblPex JIH B MOHaCTblPCKLIx JIIOXex,八a He BCTyna-

eTbcH KHH3b JIH BJIaCTeJIIIH: TO Be4aeT HX enHCKon>> 211.CTaTbFI

ocHoBaHa Ha TeKcTe ycTaBa HpocJIaBa BocToIIHopyccKoih
penaKⅡHHnPOCTPaHHOii rPyⅡⅡbl 212, npHIIeM HHTePe'CHO, IITO
oHa He 6ePeT II3 cBOer'O HCTOIIHHIKa nOHFITIIeくⅡePKOBHble
JIIOXH)", cOCPenPTO[IHBaFI BCe BHIIMaHIJe
MoHacTblPcKHX JIIo,瓜Hx H TeM Ca|MbIM

Ha MOHaCTbl,PHX II
npIIXaIBaH nOHHTHIO

くMoHacTblPcKHe JIIoIH> TO coXeP>KaHHe, KOToPOe OHO HMeeT
B >KaJIOBaHHblx rPaMOTax MOHaCTbIPHM, rX'e TePMHHOM <JIIO-

瓜H)P o603HaIIaeTcfl KpecTbHHcKoe HaceJIeHIIe. TaKaH penlaKU

LIIH cTaTbH o enIIcKOIIcKoII IoPIICXIIKHIIH BnOJIHe COOTBeTCTByeT nPHTH3a'HHHM B Jyxe rPaMOT O nOnCylHOCTHHryMeHa ,

cTapUeB, JIIo,mekHKpecTbHH CnaccKoro BepeHJIoBcKor,o MoHaCTLIPH HOBrOPOnCKOMy aPxIIenH|CKOny.

B KaKoi Mepe 6blJIa orpaHIIIIeHa loplIcnlHKIIIIfl apxHepeeB B叩yrHxpa加Hax Py“K90­Mro旦aM XVB.？
CBeTcKIIe o6HTaTeJII[ MoHacTblpcKHx BoTIIHH (KpecTbHHe, nPHKa3IIHKII 213H叩.) B HcKOBblx meJIax HO皿e>KaJIHBe2'0 nPn, Bbln. 111, cTp. 438-439.
2'' TaM )Ke, cTP. 428, cT. 38; ACSII, T. 111, Nb 8, cT. 38.
2'2 nPn, Bbln. 1, cTp. 271, cT. 54, 9.

218 CouHa,JIbHOe nPOHcxO"KneHHe nPHKa3[皿KoB H IIx IOPIInlmecKoe nOJIO>KGHHe nO noQJIyKIeHI畑 八O,mKI･IOCTII I13yIIGHbl He,mocTaToKIHoI B XVI B.
cPeXH

nPHKa3IIIIKoB

IIMeJIHcb

ll

<<cTaPUbl)";

>KaJIOBaHI･Ible

rPaMoTbl

XV-XVI BB. npoBo,DHT, oJHaKo, 1IeTKyIo rl)aHb Me>Kny <<6paTI,eIo》
II TeMM, <KOMy nl)IIKazKyT", IIJIwI《nPIIKa3UIIKaMII".
126

XeHHIo BeJIIIKOKHH>KecKoro ("II yXeJIbHoKHHzKecKoro) cyna
(OIIeB皿HO, KPOMe meJI, OTHeceHHblx K KOMneTe皿皿UepK-

BH ycTaBaMH BJIanIIMIIpa H HpocJIaBa). Ha cBfl皿eHHHKoBI1
｡

｡

nPHIITbl MoHaCTblPcKIIx ceJIbcKKx UePKBeH, T. e. <<JIIonteli
U'ePKOBHblx)D B y3KOM cMblcJIe cJIOBa, PacnPocTPaHHJIOCb

及eiiCTBIie MOHacTblPCKOii IIJIH enHcKOHCKOii 10PHC且HKIIHH
(Hx cTaTyC OnPe4eJIflJIcH BO BJIanblIIHblx IKaJIOBaHHblx rPaMOTaX-HcTOTIHliKe, nOKa e皿e MaJIo H3yIIeHHoM) . B oco6eHHo cHopHoM noJIo>KeHHH HaxomIJIHcb HacToHTeJIH MoHa-

cTblpeiiliMoHaxII(<6paTHH)F),KoTopbIe,co皿OihCTOPOHPI,

qjoPMaJIbHO nPHIIHCJIHJIHCb K Pa3P皿y f<n<ePKOBHblx :mlonle"
(Ho ycTaBy BJIa皿MHPa) , HO, C JPyrOii CTOPOHbl,-KaK *eojmaJIbl-3eMJIeBJIaneJIbnbl - HBJIHJIIICb

BaCCaJIaMII

KHH3H-CIo­

3ePeHa．
且

Kopnop a皿Ⅲ7 Bo3!HIIKmHe B KalleCTBe KHH]KeCKIIX MOHa-

cTblpeih, HMeJIII oco6blii cTaTyc. Ha cyne y MHTpoHoJIHTa
repoHTHH, Korna pa36IIpaJIcH cnop Me)Kny KHH3eM MHxaliJIoM AHnpeeBIIIIeM BeJIo3epcKIIM H pocToBcKHM apxHeⅡⅢ-

cKoHoM BacbHHoM (oKoJIo l478/79 r.) 2'4, npemlcTaBIITeJIb
KHH3H CneJIaJI cJIenylO皿ee 3aHBJIeHIIe:く..､HCTaPHHbl nPeIK-

HIIe apxHenHcKonbl pocToBcKHe Bo rocy"pH Moero B KIIpHJIOB MOHaCTblPb He BCTynaJIHcH, nPHCTaBOB CBOHX He CJIaJIII,

a HryMeHa H 6PaTbH He cynHJIII, II neCHTHJIHHKOB CBOHx K
HMIM He B'bCblJIaJIH,ⅢⅡomJIII|H He IIMaJIH-ⅡpH KHpHJIe II
nocJIe KHpHJIa-npll TocynapH Moero KHH)Ke MIIxaiJIoBe
ome, npK KHH3e AHIpee nMIITplIeBHIIe, H pp cex MecT, a
cy八HJI…Toro KHpHJIoBa MoHacTblpH HryMeHa rocy"" Moero KHfDK MHxaiJIoB oTeU - KHH3b A皿pe曲旦M PITP HeBHKIb,
a 6paTblo cBoIo - cTapneB KHpHJIoBa MoHacTblpH - cyⅡHJI
IIryMeH; a |HocJIe oma cBoero Toro KIIplIJIoBa MoHacTblpFI

IfryMeHa Cy瓜HJI rocynapb Moii KHH3b MIIxaiiJIo AHXpeeBIItIb
H j P c I I x M e C T, o n P O I I b
HblX...

neJIex

4yxOBHblx

HryMeHa

XeJI, aB,myxOB割

BenaeT

aPxIienliCKOn,

3aHe>K... ToT KHpHJIoB MoHacTLIpb y r o c y n a p H M o e r o,
KaK yrOCynaPH

y

B e J I I I KO r O

KHH3H

erOMOHa-

cTblpH-Cnac
Ha
MocKBe,nia
npeIIHcTafI
CHMoHoBe,
JIa
HIIKo!JIa
Ha
yrpeme>215.

214

Ha

06 3TOii TH)K6e CM.: J1. B. LIepenHIIH. yKa3. ccq., L1. 2, cTp. 191­

194 (cp. cTp. 183-184) ; H. C. JI y p b e. HPleoJIormLIecKaH 60pb6a.,,:
cTp. 54-58.

215 AC31i, T. 11, M 315, cTP. 280.
127

neiicTBHTeJIbHo, B >Ka&IIoBaliIIblx rpaMoTax KIIp"JIo-Be"
@)Io3epcKoMy 216IICIIMoHoBy 217MoHa|cTblpHMBcTpeIIaeTcH
CTaTbflOnOnlCyIHOCTIIHacTOHTeJIHKHH310-CIO3epeHy218.ApxIIenIIcKoncKIIe rpaMoTbl noKa3blBaloT, IITo ecJIH enle B 50-x

ro,max XV B. IIryMeHbl H nonlJI ceJII>cKIIx Uel)KBeil KIII)IIJIJIoBa MOHaCTblPfl 6blJIII ne-IOPe nOKcynHbl BJIa八blKe, OIIeBImHO,

no BceM BonpocaM 2'9, To yJKe B 60-x ro,瓜aX cyn HaX HIIMH
OKa3aJICH B PyKax KHPHJIJIOBcKorO HryMeHa, a Ha nPJIIO BJIa-

八blIIHerOcynaOCTaJIOCbOnHO《,n<yxoBHoe,meJIo)P220.Be,poHTHo,
II CyJI Ham cTaPUaMH He 6blJI c MOMeHTa OcHOBaHHH MoHa-

CTblPH 6ecCnOPHOii nPHBHJIerKeii HryMeHa, XOTH nePemeJI K
HeMy PaHbme, IIeM Cy4 Ha瓜ⅡPHIITaMH ceJIbcKHx UePKBeit.
rpaMoTbl nepBoii noJIoBHHbl XV B., npoBo3rJIamaIomHe
nPaBO KHmKeCKOrO Cyna B OTHOmeHHH HaCTOHTeJIeii, KPaiiHe HeMHOrOIIHcJIeHHbl (II3BeCTHbl BCerO "Be) H KacalOTCfl

JIIImb KIIplIJIJIo-BeJIo3epcKoro MoHacTblpH 221.
Bo BToPoii no!JIoBIIHe XV B・Kpyr Kopnopan砿, HaCTOHTeJIH KOTOPblx CymIJIHCb KHH3eM, He OrPaHH[IHBaJICH TO$ﾉIb-

Ko<<KHfDKecKHMH)DMoHacTbIpHMH222.OIIeHb3HeprIIIIHopac216 BnepBble B rpaMoTe KHH3FI MI.IxaHJIa AHJPeeBI{qa l435-1447 rI､．
(ACSIi, T・II, JVb 79), 3aTeM B ero )Ke rpaMoTax 1473 r. (TaM )Ke,
M 223) , 1476-1482 rr. (TaM )Ke, M 239, 243 - 3necb petlbIueT y>Ke
H O HOnCy"oCTH cTaPUeB KHH3IO) , B rPaMOTe BeJIHKOii KHHrHHH

Co*bII 1448-1451 rr. (TaM )Ke, Nb 98) II B rpaMoTax HBaHa lll
1488 r. (TaM ]Ke, JYb 278), 1500 r. (TaM )Ke, M 300.301).

211. B rpaMdTe BeJIIIKoro Kim3fl BaclimIH BacI1､IIbeBHIIa l460 r., noIITBep)K"HHoA HBaHoM III (ACSH, T. II, JVb 360) .
218 B )KaJIoBaHHoii rpaMoTe nMIITpMH HoHcKoTo (lepFenty CaBBe Ha MoHacTblpeK
Cnaca-npeo6pa]KeHHH
(oK・1380-1382 rr.- BKJIIoIIBH
Hblii aKT B cocTaBe nloKyMeIITa XVI I B.) HacToFITeJIb cTaBHTcH nom

COBMeCTHyIO IOPHC皿KⅡHIo BeJIIIKoro KHH3H I! MIITpcnoJIMTa (ACSI'I,
T. I, JYb 340) . O cMecHoM cyne MIITponoJIIITa lI Be皿Koro KHH3ダ
q D

B

IICKOBbIX

neJIaX

CBeTCKHX

JIIm

nPOTHB

nPencTaBIITeJIeli

nyXOBeH

cTBa CM. B ,nPrOBOPHoii rPaMOTe BeJIHKorO KHH3FI B8cMJmfl nMHTPHe

BIIIIa II MIITpoHoJIHTa KImpIIaHa (HPn, Bbln. I11, cTp. 422, cT. 7) .
219 ACSH, T. II, Nb 161.
220 TaM >Ke, JYb l71-176, 183.

22I T. H・rpaMoTa BacIIJIIIH BacliJIbeBIILla Ha c.皿)･xo62JYCBo, HMelO皿醐
CTaTbIO O HOJICy,nHOCTH MIryMeHa, 6paTHII II CJIyr BemIKOMy KHFI310
(AC3H, T. I, JVb l76), HBIHeTC兄no"eJIKoii
Kcllua
XVI
B.
(cM
A. A. 3 H M H H. AKToBI,Ie no瓜旦eJIKII Tpol皿e-CeprmeBa MoHacTbl"
80-x ronoB XVI B.­《Bonpocbl
couHaJIbHo-3KoHoMI(IIGcKoAHCTOPmi

II HCTOKIHIIKOBeAeIIIIH nePlIO" qJeo".ⅢII3Ma B POc(､IIII>p. C6. cTaTeii
K 70-JIeTHIo A. A. HoBoceJIbcKoro. M., 1961, cTp. 250-251, oco6eHHo npIIM. 25) .

"2TaKHM6blJI，KpoMe v>Ke Ha3BaHlIblx，TpoHUK戒Ha Bepe3HʻmKe B Bo-

､JIocTIIBope;n̅aTpoHoMHc皿beiierOHiyMeHaHBJ1HJIcfiKHH3blOpHii
B acHJIbeB HリユMm;rpoBcKmit (ACSH, T. I, Nb 401; cp. TaM x<e, Nb 416).
128

1

nPOcTPaHHJIH
cBoIO
IOPHc瓜HKUHIO
yneJIbHble
KHH3bH・H
a'cToHTeJIH CJIeXyIO皿Ⅲx ･ MOHacTblPeii 6blJIII nOJBenOMCTBeHHbl

yneJIbHOKHH>KecKOMy
cy八y:TpoHUe-CepmeBa223,
MHTpOnOJIIIIIbero HoBHHcKoro224 (no rpaMoTaM IOpHH BacIIJIbeBH-

IIa mMIITI)oBcKoro 60-x -HaIIaJIa 70→x ronoB), CaBBo-CTopo)KGBcKoro 225, noKpoBcKoro yrJI皿KOrO 226 (no rpaMOTaM
A皿pefl BoJ1bmoro 70-x ro40B) , CnaCO-KaMeHHoro 227 (Ho
rpaMoTe AHIpeH MeHbmoro l479 r. 228) . TaTapcKHii cJIy>Ke6 11bl曲uapb MyxaMMen-3MHII, HoJIyIIHBmlM B yneJI KamHpy, ycTaHoBwI noncy4HocTb ce6e lIryMeHa TpoImKoro
BeJYoneCOU.KOTO MOHaCTblpH 229．CTaTbH o noncynHocTH HacToJITeJIFI

BeJIHKOMy

KHH310

HeOIHoKPaTHO

BKJIIOIIaJIacb

B rpaMoTbI HBaHa lll. Ee lHaxoJIHM B rpaMoTax MHTp'on|()J11MIIbIIM MoHa'cTblpHM - CHoBIIIcKoMy II JIIo6euxOMy
(1465 r.230), a TaK>Ke B rPaMoTax MoHacTbl"M Cnaco-

EBq)HMbeBy (1472 231, 1473 232, 1479 rr. 233), HHKoJIbcKoMy
MoKI)oMy (1482 r.234),Tpo皿e-CeprlieBy ( 1492 r.235) , Cnac̲
cKoMy HpocJIaBcKoMy (1498 r236) H ycTIo)KcKoMy ycneHCKOMy BOrOPO皿UKoMy co60py (1490 r237) Cy" no ToMy,
ご

rne

llaxOHIIJII,I|cb

'ITo

cBeTcKaJI BJIacTb aKTHBHO orPaHHIIHBaJIa lOpHc且HKⅡⅡIO

MIITPOllOJIHTa,

yKa3aHHble

POCTOBCKOrO

MOHacTblPll, MO)KHo
aPXHenHCKOna

H

CKa3aTb,

Cy34aJIbCKOrO

eⅡHcKona 238. rpaMoTbl l479 II l482 1T･BOJIOrO,ⅡcKHM
223 AC31I, T. 1, Nb 291, 305.
224 A3MX, 1. 1, Nh 86.
225 AC31M, T. 111, JYb 58.
226 TaM >Ke, JYb 77.
227 TaM >Ke, JWh 269.
228 1<IIH3b Cy瓜HJITaK）Ke H 6PaTHIO.
229 AC3m, T. I, Nb 618.
2co Ad)311X, L1．1, Nb 193.

231 AC3II, T. I I, Nb 466 (BeJIIIKHii KHH3b cy"､II TaK)KG II 6I)aTIMIo) .
232 TaM )Ke, Nb 473.
233 TaM >Ke, JYb 475.
234 TaM )Ke, T・I11, Nb 278.
235 TaIw >Ke, T. 1, Nh 567, 568; rnB, noro瓜．1905, "J1. 80 06.­81 06.,
M 71.

236 ACSH, T. 111, M 216 (Be皿KHiI KIIfI3b Cy"JI TaK>Ke m 6PaTIIIO) .
237 TaM >Ke, Nb 282 (BeJIHKIlii KHH3b cy"JI npoTo!10na, c"皿eHHllKoB

II nPlIIIT UepKoBHblii) . E皿e B TpaMoTe l467-148|l rr. 3ToMy co60py
IIoc1allOBJ]eHIie 6bl.JIo I1Hoe: !f<A KOMy Ha rmx 6yneT Llero IIcKaTm, HHO

IIx Cy>KIo H3 caM, KHfI3b Be,mKII, MH CaM aPxIIenmCKoII> (TaM IKe,
JVh 281).
238 rl)aMoTa KammPcKOMy BeJIOneCOILKOMy MOHacTbrPlO OrPaIMIIIIBaJIa,
OLIeBm八H0,

10PlICHHKuMIO M}ITPOIIOJIIIITa,

a

He KOJIoMGHCKOTO enHcKona.

I/1. noKI)oBcKHii cLIHTaeT, IITo Ka皿Hpa Bxo4HJIa B KoJIoMGHcI<yI()
enaPxIIIO c XIV B (H. n o K I) o B c K I! it yI<a3. ccIl., 'r. 1, cTp. 214)
9

C. M. KalllTaHoB

129

Cnaco-Ka
Mel冊IoMy
H
HIIKoJYLcKoMy
MoKpoMy
MoHacTbll)fIM
orPaHIiIIIIBaJII̲IOPII4IIKUHIO HoBrOPoICKoro al)xIIemlcKolla,

o4HaKo c l492 I､・BoJIoraanepemJIaBnepMcKyIoenapXIIIO239・BIIcToLIHIIKax,nPaBUa,PeqbH1eTOUePKBaXBcaMoMrBoJIomeMHanocaneM6>KeT6bITb,ye3hHbIeMoHacTblpH ocTaBaJIMcb eUe HeKoTopoe BpeMH B cocTaBe HoBU

r o p o I c Ko M e n a P x I m .

B IByx rpaMoTax HBaHa lll (1467 H 1475 rr.), oTHoC FI皿ⅢxcFI K oJHoMy lI ToM)L>Ke MIITpoIIoJIHIIbeMy BocKpeCellcKOMy MOHacTblPlo <Ha neHFIre)>, yCTaHaBJIIIBaeTcFI nbncynHocTb !IryMella B HcKoBbIx neJIax IwIITponoJIIITy240. Mo-

IIaCTblPb 6blJI PaCnOJIO>KeH B nBIIHCKO曲3eMJIe241, r4e neii̲
cTBoBaJIo cMemaHHoe MocKoBcKo-HoBropoIcIKoe npaBo. OLIeBHﾕHo, 3TIIM onPemeJIIIJIOCb nPenpCTaBJIeHHe MIITPonOJIIITy
IOPlIC,III KnHHHa且HryMeHQMB HcKoBIJIx XeJIax. B rpaMoTax
BoJIoUKIIx
'KoHUaXV­HaIIaJIa
XV - HarlaJIaXVI
XVI B.,
B BbllaHHblX
BoJIoUKIIxKHFI3|eik
KH”'eH'KoHUa

llocmqJo-'BoJIoKo"aMcKoMy MoHacTblplo,HeT cTATbmbimcy皿IoCTHHI､yMeHa KHH3IO, xoTHKHH3bHoToBal)HBaIOT cBOe
EPaBOCymITbB"mcKOBblxXeJIaxMOHacTblPcKOronPIIKa3qIIKa.
U

BoJIoKoJIaMcIKImi
ye31
Haxo瓜HJIcH
HoBropoXcKoji
B
enapxHH.
CJIenpBaTeJIbHo,
ecTb
ocHoBaHI畑,Ⅱ;yMaTb,
qTO
HOBrO,POn(CK"
U

apxHenlIcKoH B KoHUe XV B. ocTaBaJIcFI B Hc'KJIIoIIIITeJIbHoM
noJIo)KeHII)I, CoxpaIHFIH 3a cO60揃nPaBO Cyna Hal HacTOHTe-

JIHMII MoHacTblpeih HoBroponicKoii enapx"
no ntallkJbll! n. M CTPoeBa, K TIITyJIy KoJIoMelfcKIJx BJIa4bIK cJ1oBo

"omMI)cK"> cTaJIo nplI5aBJIHTbcH ToⅡDKo c l542 r (n. CTI)oea
ハ

しⅡmfKII,rMfPaP)iPB,IJ,､.l{aCIpfWP.1eii
MOMaghlPe#
POCCmiiCKoji
mePKBIL

qTq, ̲l", cTd 1q311 B 20x ｢Q:Iax XVi B cf""" ""y
q〃

ゴ

Ha nocTI)o#Ky HoBoii UepKBII B MowacrupcKoM ceme BobracdBe "
U

9 R q

,710neCOⅡKⅢII MoII"TLIPb nOJTy'IIIJI He OT KCJJoMeHCI<OrO CITIICI〈OIIa，a
gr̲MIITpono@IIHTa (ArP, T, I, cTp. 102)

(､TI〕、232；T、26，cTp、287-288；1．．27，cTp、291；cI〕．
XII,nCPJI,
T.
fOWII UapcKQEp al)xIIBa̲XYI "Kh M aIlXIIBa' nbcdib6k6f5hillI"
3a l614 ro"". no,m､ pent. C、Q I｣̲IM"Ta ̅M., 1960, cTp 32, J1, 300-

300 0｡ ､(AA3, TJ, " 289¥cTI1 346L HUlil{ l501; H IT 6k b̅6 B" li iL̲yKa3. COKI., T. 1, CTI).66 (npIIM. 2), 1{16

２４０ Aの31IX, 11. 1, M 315, 316.
２４１

B3aroJIoBKax,naHIIbIx3THMaKTaMBA3IIX，PeIIbl,IAeT
唖oBoJIo-

roJにKoM ye31e, 01I･IaKO B caMIIx maMoTax BoJIorcEcKHil ye" IIe
ylloMrlllaelcFI, a B I<oHIIiiHoii KFIIIre XVI n oml BbIXeJIGHbI B .oco5vIo
rJIaBy (17), noMe皿GHIIyIo rlocJIe BoJIoToXcKoro pa3nelITa. nocKoJ1bKV
rl)aMoTb! BbmalIM IIBaHoM III, nx HeJIb3H oTHe(fTI! K BoJIoronkcKoM,
ye3ay, K2Topblii no l481 r. IIpIIH"J1e>KHT AHmPelo MGII皿ⅡoMv. O nePexone nliHerlI R BeneHI1e MIITpono|mmTa B 1471 r. II o cMeiuaIIHbIx
v

“

B.n"eIIIMx

HQBroPOXcKoji

aPxIIemIcKomm

ll

MIITPCnOJmm

o6JIaCTH CM: H. nOKPOBCkHh. yKa3. corl., T. 1, cTp. 62.
130
可

E

sITOji

OTclo且a nOHHTHblM cTaHoBIITcH HBHO OrPaHHIIHTeJIbHbli
xapaKTep cTaTbH KoHeBcKoii rpaMoTbl l499 r., 3,anpeUaBmeH aPxHelllIcKoIIy cy皿Tb HryMeHa m 6PaTHIo (4(oI1PI1qb myXOBHblX neJI)>, TC KPOMe qHCTO KaHOHIIIIeCKHX BOIIpOCOB) 242 ●
B rpaMoTe l499 r. TpoHUKoMy KIIoHcKoMy MoHacTbl-

pIO 243 Mbl BH皿IM ToJIbKo cTaTbIo O cPOKe Bbl30Ba B CynI MOU

HaCTblPcKHx JIIOmeH H KPeCTbFIH HaMeCTHHIIbHMH HJIII BeJ1II-

KOKHFDKecKIIMII

nPIIcTaBaMH,

oJHaKo

B

HQnTBep>K4eHHII

1551 r. K 3Toii rpaMoTe BoccTaHaB皿IBaeTCH nl)aBo aPxHenHCKOrlCKOrO |Cyna Ha且HryMeHoM II 6PaTbelo. Heo6xoIHMOCTb TaKOrO BOCCTaHOBJIeH", qJOPMaJIbHO rOBO", He "KToBaJIacb coxPalIIIBmmMcH TeKcToM rPaMOTbl，nO3TOMy BO3HHKaloT ｣IBa nPenl1OJIO>KeIIwI: l ) JII160 nl)II IIQITBep>KJ<eHHH
Hcxo且HJ1H

II3

1)ea,III)HOrO CocToHHMIH

4eJI,

CJIo)KIIBmerocH

K

l551 r.; 2) JIM6o TeKcT rpaMoTbl l499 E 6blJI BKJIIo[IeH B
rpaMoTy l564 r. }Ie noJ1IIocTblo. B rpaMoTe l500 r. HoBropon(cKoMy BoJIoToBy MoHacTblpIo 244 HMeeTcFI ToIIHo TaKafI
>Ke cTaTbfl o cpoKe, KaK II B rpaMoTe l499 r. KJIoHcKoMy
MoHacTblPIO, Ho oHa HaxoHIITCfl B nJIOTHoM OKPy>KeHHHユpyrHX CTaTeli: eli, B IIaCTHOCTII,
nPe旦皿eCTByeT CTaTbH, yCTaq J

U

HaBJIIIBalOUlaH nOnCynHOCTb IIryMeHa B HCKOBblX neJIaX HOB-

rOpoXcKHM HaMecTHIIKaM; rpaMoTa l500 r., nono6Ho rpa-

MoTe l499 1､KoHeBcKoMy MoHacTblplo, HaTIIIHaeTcH c orpaHHIIellHH IopHc皿IKuHH;HOBrOPO4cKOrO aPxHemIcKOna B oTHO-

meH皿HryMeHa lI 6PaTIIII (くOⅡPmb nyXOBHblX Beme") .
MMeJI}Icb JIH B oKTH6pe l564 r. MoTIIBbl JIJIFI He'BKJIIoUPHIIH 3THX aHTIIBJIamb1[IHblX CTaTei B CmICOK C rPaMOTbl

KJIoncKoMy MoIIacTbIPIo l499r.？、ocJIe cMel〕TH B l563r・
MIITPOnOJIHTa MaKaPHH nPaBo cBflTIITeJIbcIKOrO cyna, BOccTaHoBJ1GHHoe B I551 r., cTaJIo nocTeneHHo cHoBa oTMe-

HFITbcFI. BepoHTIIo, BKJ1IoIIeHHe B rpaMoTy l564 r. TeKcTa
I.paMoTbl l499 r・Co CTaTbHMII, OrPaHIIIIMBaIOlUllMIi aPXII242
0《ユ)LXO3IIoMmeJIe"HcTOIIHI1KIII､OBo"T6e3
1)acKFblTIIfl3TOrO
mOHflT". B ｡oI)MyJI"HoM HaKa3e MIITI)oIToJIHTa HbHbl, oTIIocHmeMcH
K

3aIIanHOPyCcKIIM

TePPHToPMHM,く瓜eJIa

nyXOBHbyfl>、KaK II瓜eJYa

LlepKOpHble, nopyqGHb[ MHTponomIIIbeMy HaMecTHIIKy (AIOB, T. 11,

' Nb 167, cTd 524). BくnpaBOCy皿畑MIiTPOIIO川I:IbeMx TOROI)IITCH, IITO
non, IIryMeII II八bHKOH AIOryT 6IJITIJ cBIneTe&rlHMH 1.cJIbKO nO nyxOBHoMy ne,IIy KCBoeMy 6PaTy: HryMI･Iy, nOny, nbFIKOIIy>、(TIPn, Bbm lll,

cTP̅428,tT28)j̅IobnbemeJTeHm沁B.H.ABToKI)2ToBa,4<nyxoBHoe
且eʻmo­且eJIa,

CBH3aHHble

c

OTnPaBJ1eHFIeM

PeJ1mI､1103]-IOTO

KyLmbTa,

HPaBCTBeHHOcTblO XyxOBeHCTBa l'I T.ユ沙(TaM >Ke,cTp 452) .

2" [ ro iin yKoB yKaa coq" cTp l7-18.

244 AMBpoc!Ⅲ曲. HCTOPlIH PO'CClliiCKOiオHepapxHH, w. V1. M., 1815,
cTp. 474.-481 ; AII, T. I, Nb l l l
131

9:k

enHCKOnCKylO IOPHCXHKnH10, 6blJIo 6bl BOCnPlIHHTO K8K nO-

KymeHHe Ha Hee 245. rpa MOTa nOHBIIJIaCb HaKaHyHe OnPliqHMIHbl, Korla MBaH IV, no-BH4MMoMy, cTpeMIIJIcH He yxyntmaTb OTHOmeH" C HOBrOP皿cKoii Ka巾e,qpo曲. O Bbl60poIIHoM xaPaKTepe UIITHpoBaHHFI rpaMoTbl l499 r. B rpaMoTe
1 564 r. roBopIIT II neKJIapllpoBaHHaH neJIb BblJalIH HocJIenHeii: orPanHTb MoHaCTblPCKylo BOTIIHHy OT IIacTbIX Hae3nPB
IIaPCKIIX HeneJIb皿IIKOB, He nPH3HaBaBmlⅨⅡPe)KHero

CPoKa

Bbl30Ba KpecTbflH B cyn. TeKcT rpaMoTbl l499 r. B cocTaBe
rpaMoTbl l564 r・JIBJIHJICH BblmlCKOit TGMaTHIiecKoro xaPaKTePa (BbInmCb 6blJIa CJIeJIaHa lI3 <<KIIHr>, TaK KaK HO皿HH．
、

U

HIIK croPeJ1) ,

rPaMoTbl

nPlIIIeM

TeMa

BblnlIcKH OnPene｡JIFIJIaCb TeMOH

l564 r.

TaKIIM o6pa30M, Mo>KHo ZIyMaTb, IITo B HoJIHoM BMne
TeKcT rpaMoTbl l499 r. TpoImKoMy KJIoHcKoMy MoHacTblplo
6blJI 6JIH30K K TeKcTy rpaMoTbl l500 r・ycneHcKoMy BoJIoToBy MOHacTblPlO, T. e. COneP>KaJI cTaTbH, OrPaHHIIHBalO皿He
a p x H e n H c Ko n c Ky I o I o p H c 瓜 H K u H I O .

IJI3 rpaMoTbl KoHeBcKoMy MoHacTblplo co34aeTcH BneIIaTJIeHIie, IITO IOPIIcmHKnHH

aPxHemicKOna 'Han MoHacTIJIP-

cKHMMI JIIonbMH H KPecTbHHaMH np l499 r. 6blJIa e山e peaJIbHocTblo, B To BpeMFI KaK rPaMoTa BoJIoToBy MoHacTblPlo
( OIIeB皿HO, rlOBTOPH10皿aR B Hecy皿MOii IIaCTH巾OPMyJIFIp
rPaMoTbl KJIoHcKoMy MoHacTblpIo) roBopIIT nplIMeHIITeJIbHo
K JIIOnHM H KPeCTbHIIaM JIHmb O IOpHC典HKuHHcBeTCKHX BJIa-

cTeih. Bo3Mo>KHo, Ha oTnaJIeHHblx oKpaHHax HoBropoXcKoit
3eMJIII

OcTaTKII

cTaPHHbl

CoxPaHHJIHcb

nPOIIHee,

qeM

B

ueHTp e

PacCMOTPHM

'nPeneJIbl

HaMecTHIIqbIIx |HOJIHOMOIIHi.

B rpaMoTe KoHeBcKoMy MoHacTblpIo cKa3aHo:《…Ha MecT1-IHubl

HamHH瓜BoPeTUKHe H

KOHIO皿He H

BOJIOcTeJIHHXII

THyHII HryMeH|a c 6PaTbelO H HX JIIoXeiM H KPecTbHH He CynHT HII B qOM, OnPHII ny皿ery6cTBa lI po360H H TaTb6bl c HoJIII'IIHblM…> 3TOii CTaTbehⅡPII3HaeTcH Ho,nCyX|HoCTb MeCTHblM
BJIaCTHM-no neJTaM o nymery6cTBe, Pa360e H TaTb6e C
HOJIIIIIHblM - He TOJILKo MoHaCTblPcKHx KPecTbHH, HoHHry-

MeHa c 6paTbelo. no npymM BImaM npecTymleHH曲HryM eH
一

II

一

OPaTIm He OblJIIi noIcynHbl HaMecTHHKy II caMH CyXIIJIH

cBoIIx KPecTbHH. BcJIy[IaHx, Koma Bo3HIIKaJIII TFDK6bl c HocTOPoHHHMH JIIInaMH, He nomJIe>Ka皿IIe cMecHOMy cy4y, IIry-

245 TeM 60JIee, IITo B rpaMoTe 3ToMy >Ife MoIIacTDI1)Io 1560 ,r. CollepﾝKaJIacbcTaTbFI oⅡo八CynHOCTH IIryMeHa aPxMe'IIIICKOny
唾(Xn, II, Nb 796).
132

MGH, 6paTI1H, JIIo" H KPecTbflHe KoHeBcKoro MoHacTblpH
oKa3blBaJIIICb

BIIe

KOMneTeHnlIII

HaMeCTHHKOB,

nOnanafl

B

c(I)epynleiicTBmHBeJIIIKoKHfDKeclforocynaHanpoTHB,cQZ
rJia61iO KJIOnCKOii H BOJIOTOBCKOii rPaMOTaM, HCKHnPOTHB
MOHaCTblPCKHx KI)eCTbHH MOrJIH PaCCMaTPHBaTbCH KaK Be-

JIHKOKHH)KecKIIM, TaK H HaMecTHIIIIbHM cynpM.
BoJIoToBcKafl rpaMoTa noKa3blBaeT, IITo B HcKoBblx ne-

JIaXIIryMeHII6Pai"6blJIHno4cy4HblHaMecTHHKaM.BMe-

cTe c TeM, onPeneJIHFI o6'beM HaMecTHIIIIbei lopHc"KUHII
HaX IIIaceJIeHHeM MOHacTblPCKOii BOT1IHHbl, 3Ta rP2MoTa He

BKJIIoLIaeT B nyHKT O nOIcy瓜HIvIblX- IIryMeHa H 6PaTIIIO, B
nyHKT o cOCTaBe llPecTynJIeH", nOnBenPMCTBeHHblx HaMeCTIIIIKaM,- TaTb6y.
I'ITaK, cOoTHOIneHHe Me>K八y BJIacTIJIo HaMecTIIHKOB B

UeHTpe ll Ha oKI)allllax HoBroponcKoii 3eMJIH IIoJIy'IaeTcFI

cJIelyloLIlee.BIleHTI)eBoT1ⅧHHaflIOPIIC"KUHH(bHKCIfPyeTCfIB八yxe o6Uel)yccKoit 'HoPMbl, no3ToMy He npIFHaeTcFI

Cy,me6HaH
BJIaCTb
1IaMeCTHIIKOB
IIaユリryMeHOM
6PaTbelO
ll
B nPeneJIaX MOHacTblPcKIIx BJIaAeHHm, 3aTo HaMeCTHHKH

oKa3blBaloTcH nJIH IiryMeHa CynlbHMII B HCKOBblX neJIax, 3a-

MeHHH TaKHM O6Pa30M aPxHenlIcKona H noJIb3yFIcb IIHcTO

KWI)KecKOii nPePOraTIIBOii, nPlI 3TOM HOJIHocTblo OTPHUaIoTcH cyne6Hble noJIHoMoIIHFI HI13皿Hx 3BeHbeB HaMecTHIIqb-

ero ynPaBJIeH" (THyHoB) B OTHomeHHII HryMeHa H ero
叩mKa3IIHKoB; MOHacTblPcKme KPecTbHHe B IICKOBblx XeJIaX
MoryT CynHTbCH 'He ToJIbKO BeJIIIKoKHmKeCKHM, HO H HaMecTHHIIbHM cynoM Ha oKpaIIHe BoTLIHHHaH IopIIC瓜HKUHH cy>KHBaeTcH BnJIoTb no HcKJIIoIIeHIIH H3 Hee TaTb6bI c HoJIIIIKHblM, nPHqeM K IIHCJIy oTBeTCTBeHHblX 3a nPeCTynJIeHHH, CO-

BePmeHHble BHyTPII MOHaCTblPcKoih BoTIIIIHbl, 11pHBJIeKaeTcH H MOHacTblPcKoe 'HaIIaJIbcTBO, HoIcynHOe 'nO rJIaBHblM

B皿aM nPeCTynJIeHHii MeCTHblM OPraHaM (oIIeB皿HO, OT HaMecTHIIKOB Io TMyHoB) ; oIHoBPeMeHHO cBo"TcH K HyJIIo

P()JIb
HaMeCTHIIKa
KaK
Cy八bII
nO
IIcKoBbIM
meJIaM,脇 O
*yHK-

皿IHaP611TPa3aKI)enJIHeTCFI,COrJIaCHOO6皿ePyccKOHHoPMe,
3a BeJIHKOKHFDKeCKI,IM nPaBHTeJIbCTBOM.

npyrHMH cJT0BaMH, B UeHTpe HoBropoHcKoii 3eMJIH HaMeCTHIIKBblCTynaeTHOOTHOmeHHIOK!巾eonaJIbHOiBoTIIHHe
B PO."I OPraHa MecTHOrO ynPaBJIeHIIH, THⅡH(IHoro XJ1JI CeBepo-BocToIIHoii pycm, Ho, 6ymyIIH cynbeii-ap6HTpoM B
HoBTopone, oH ocymecTBJIHeT 'HenocpelcTBeHHo KHH>Ke-

CKylO, nPaBIITeJIbCTBeIIHylO ･yHKIAH10, oT"IIaHCb 3THM OT
HaMecTHHKoB JpyrHx ye310B PoccHII. Ha oKpaHHe >Ke
l33

t p
U

HaMec|TIII1[IMIi annapaT, He IIMeH ap6IITpa>KHoi poJIII, ycI'IJIHBaeTcH

nyTeM

aKTIIBHoro

HacTynJIeHIIH

Ha

BoTIIIIHHVIo
­

IOPIIcHIIKUHIQyPaBHeHIIeB4)OPMaJIbHO-IOP皿HIIeCKOM皿aHe BOT'IIII冊1I'IKOB II KPecTbHH HO JIIIHIM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 3a
rJIaBHble yroJIoBHble npecTymlGHIIH cBImeTeJIbcTBVeT o HenOcTaToIIHOM Pa3BHTHH IIacTHoco6CTBeHHH[IecKOrO xaPaKTe▲

U

Pa4)eo"J1bHojiBOTqIIHblBHeKOToPblxPaitOHaxceiePHOA
u

U

oKP allHbl .

STo
cBoeo6pa3He
CoUliaJIbHo-3KoHoMHIIecKoTo
pa3BHT"
OⅡPe瓜eJIHJ1o，C
H OnPeneJIHJIo,
O且HomcTOPOHbl，BO3MO>KHoCTbⅡPe且OcTaBc OIHoII cTOPOHbl, BO3MO>KHoCTb nPenOcTaBJIeHHH 3meCb MeCTHblM OPraHaM 60JIee皿叩OKHX nOJIHOMOU

U

qIIH, IIeM B U|eHTpe, c npyroA cTopoHbl, Heo6xo1HMocTb coU

xpaHeHHHapi6HT,pa)KIHoiipgJIHBeJIHKoroKHH3flKaKBepxoB-

IIoro <<BoT[IIIIIHIIKa), BceH PycII. npHMaH cBH31, c Mo6KBoi
6blJIa Ba>KHaHⅡo nl)li[IHHe 6JIH30cTH KoHeBcKoro MoHacTbl" K IUBemCKOi rPal.IHne．

CTI)eMJIGHHeycHJIIITbKoHTpoJIb
HaMecTHIILIIzel､oallllapaTwa Ha,m Pa3JIINHblMH CTOPOHaMII O6meCTBeHHO仇〉Kll3HIInDO卯"｣'OCb B KOHeBCKOII rPaMoTe eUe B TPeX nOCTaHOBJIeHm月X，
人

U

l)BcTaTbe,neKJIapmPoBaBmePIoTCyTCTBHeneHe>KHOカH
a且MHHHCTPaTHBHOii
OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH
>KHTeJIeii
MOHaCTblPU

u

cKoII BoTIIHHbl 3a cMepTb Koro-JIII60 ｣Ha Hx TeppHTopIM B
Pe3y.mbTaTe HeCIIaCTHOro cJIyIIaH I,IJIH CaMOy6"CTBa, PIMeJIacb oTOBoPKa,
orOBoPKa，cOrJIacIIO
cOrJIacIIO KOTOPOH
KOTOPOn HaMeCTHHIIbHM
HaMeCTHHIIbHM areHTaM

BO3MeUaJIIIcb ll3meP)KKH, CBH3aHHble c nPHe3JIOM Ha MecTO

nPOlicmecTB" (<<e3瓜noBepcTHbli)>j 2) C60p llHTHa 246,
Bxo"BUllih o6bl[IHo
Bxo瓜HBmHH
O6bl【IHO
B wHcJIo
BIIHCJIOMoHacTblpcKPIx
MOHacTblPCKHxⅡ”BHJIermH，
npHBHJIer
”

31ecb 6blJI nePenaH B ,PyKII HaMeCTAIIIIberd aⅡⅡap aTa :

《A nHTHa HaMecTHHKoM IiamHM H BoJIocTeJIeM Hx II nomJIHHHIIKOM maBaTH

C KynUa

no neHre

no MocKOBCKOii,
U

a

c

nponaBUa no JIeHrH )K>. Mbl 3HaeM ToJIbKo HBe rpaMoTbl,
KoTopble Mo)KHo pagcMaTpHBaTb KaK npen"eHT UlITIIpo-

"HHoro npaBIIJIa OmHa H3 HHx (1466 r.) oTHocIITcfi K

HPOCJIaBcKoMyye3my:くAKymlTJIomanbImHMeHHT,IIoHII
JIOma八b nHTHflT, a malOT mlTeHmHKy OT nflTHa C JIOmanlI HO

neHre, a 69JE̲TorQ OT "THa He nalOT HHqOro>, 247; mPyraR
rpaMoTa ( 1 479 r) KacaeTcH Bo"oKoJIaMcKoro ye3":. i<A
KTo Tex JIIOneii KynHT JIOmaJL HJIH nPonacT IIJIH MeHHT,

II OHH Te KOIIHnRTHHT y MOHX nHTeH皿IIKOB, a oT HFITHa He

naIoT HIIqero>, 248.KoHeBcKaHrpaMoTaII"T naJIbme"o246 nflTHo - nommIIIa c KyIIJIII-npoXa>KⅡ､ⅢO山aneii.
247 AC314, .r. III, Nb 203.
24R A(1)3IIX, L1. 11! Nb 4.
134

cJIaBcKoii H BoJIoUKoi, TPe6yH ynJIaTbI HaMecTHHIIbHM areHTaM BCe曲mTel-I I-Io力Ⅱo皿ⅡIIHbl cHoJIHa 3) npoe3m MoHa-

CTblPCKOi JIa"I'I C COJIblO m3 PyCCbl B MOHaCTI)IPb IIJIII I:13
MoHacTbl" B HoBropon II Pyccy <<c KaKIIM MoHacTblpcKIIM
3anacoM HH6V皿'I>>

06JIaraJIcFI oco60hnOmJIHHOih

B HOJIb3y

HaMecTHHKa JIano>KcKOrO noPora:くHOHII C TOe JIOnblI

malOT HaMeCTHI1Ky }Ia皿eMy JIaJIo)KcKoro nopora o6pa3
nPexlHCTblena cTaBeⅡ、瓜a nBe JIO>KKII, ma nOCOX, a nOPOM皿HKOM

THrJIeuOM, BBePXH且yIIH, XalOT c

@mOXbH nO mecHTH

aJITblll, a BHII3 IImyrllI, CnyOKHOrO XaIOT HO 'rpHBHe nO HoyroU

po旦uKOIか．

nPIIHy)KXeHHe K ynJIaTe aTO曲ⅡOmJIHHbl OnPeXeJIHJIO:cb
He ToJIbKO TPynlIblMII yCJIOBIIHMⅡnePenBIDKeHI嗣ⅡO naHHo-

My y[IacTKy nyTII, Ho H oco6blM HoJIQJ<eHHeIIL HaMecTHII"
JIanP>KCKOrO nOl)Ora, m60 BOJIOCTb《ⅡoI)or JIanp>KbcKoi>>
BXIO"IJIa B [IIICJIO 6blBmHx aPXIIenIICKOIIcKHx BJIaXeHHii,
KoHq)IIcKoBaHHI,Ix B l478 E249 CaMa nomJIIIHa HaMecTHIIKy
JIano)KcKOro HoPora nO CBOeMy nPOIIcXoXmeHHIO 6bma, BIInl'IMO, nomJIHHOii B HoJIb3y aPxIIeⅡⅢCKOⅡaHHOCHJIa B3Ha-

II HTeJIbHo曲MePe cIIMBOJIHIIecKHi xaPaKTep, BblPa)KaH BaCcaJIbHylo

nPenlaHHocTb nyxOBHoMy

cIO3ePeHy

lI

nPII3HaHme

ero BJIacTM (06pa3, nocox II T. Jl.).
06皿ePycCKHe nPlI|Hmmbl TaMO>KeHHOii nOJII1TIIKHⅡpoHBIIJIHcb B rpaMoTe KoIIeBcKoMy MoHacTblplo B 3anpemeHHI1
6ecllomJIHHHO IIOKynaTbHn,PoBO3HTb TOBaP《Ha nPOla>Ky>,.

rpaMoTa perJIaMeHTHpoBaJIa KoJIH[IecTBo coJIH (80 JIy60B B
rOn), KOToPOe Pa3PemaJIOCb nOKynaTb B PyCce H Be3TH B
MOHaCTblPb 6e3 ynJIaTbl MblTa, TaMrII, HBKH, nePeBO3a, MOCTOB皿ITH blH叩yrIIx nomJIHH, KPoMe nOmJIIIHbl HaMecTHIIKy

JIallO>KCKOrO 'nOPOra. MOHaCTblPb MOr KyⅡHTb TaK)Ke《BCH-

Koih 3anac Ha MoHacTblpcKylo HoTPe6y>. KoJIHIIecTBo ero He
o rlPeneJIflJIocb.

Pa3yMeeTcH, a巾巾eKTHBHOcTb nPOBeneHHFI BeJIIIKOKHH>KecKOTo KyPca B H3BeCTHoii MePe 3aBHCeJIa OT 3alIHTePeCoBaH-

IIocTIf MoHacTblpFI B co6JIIo4eHIIH IIOPM, ycTaIIOBJIeHHblx B

rPaMOTe. no3ToMy HBaH III cOIIeTaJI orPaHIIIIIITeJIbHbIe
nPwHnImbl cyme6Hoii H TaMo)KGHHO向ⅡOJIHTHKH c yKPemleHHeM

OCHOB

a八MIIHIICTPaTHBHOrO

I'IMMyHIITeTa

MoHaCTblpfl

B nPemeJIax ero BJIaneHHih. B rpaMoTe印IIKcHpOB aJIHCb :

l )omliH cPOK Bbl30Ba B BeJIIIKOKHfI>KecKmii Cy瓜nOHCKOBblM
ト

249 nCP,Ⅲʼ

ノ n e p B a H

T. VI, cTI). 216; T. V111, c'rl). 195; T. XII, cTp. 183; T. 20,
no皿oBHHa，cTp. 330; T､25, cTD. 319. 135

neJIaM-HaII60JIeeJ1brOTHOenPaBIMO250,6JIarOnaPH
KOTOpOMy H KPecTbHHe He OTPblBaJ1HCb oT CeJIbCKOxO3HiCTBeHU

HblXpa60T251,IIMOHaXH6blJIHII36aBJIeHblOTIIaCTblXHnOP OrOcTOH皿Ix noe3noK B MocKBy; 2) 3anpe皿eHHe JIOBUaM
H e3nPKaM CTaBIITbCH B MOHaCTblPCKOii BoTIIH|He, a He3BaU

HblM rocTHM H nonpomaTaHM BxonHTb H B'Le3>KaTb B Hee.

KpoMe Toro, B UeJIHx nolrbeMa MoHacTbIpcKoro̅
xd3Hiiユ
cTBaMOHacTblPloO6ecneKIHBaJIoCbnpaBOHa- MOHOHOJIbHoe
HcHOJIb30BaHIIG OcTPoBHOrO JIeCa (JIoBnaM 6blJIo 3anPe皿eU

U

HO Cerl. ero IIoI yrPO30ih 3anOBenlI)HnPeJoCTa BJIHJIOcb
U

npaBo6e306poIIHoiiJIQBJIIiPbl6b!BJIano)K6KoMo3epe<<Ha
MaIIaCTIJIPcKylo HoTPe6y>>.

KaKoBb'
6b'JTM
TIomｲTHIIecKHe
M()THBbT
BblJlaIIIJ
rPaMOT
KOHeBcKoMy II KnoncKoily MOllaCTbll],1M B aBrjcTe l""

CynfIHoco八el)>KaHIIIQ3TIIXfIKTOB,IIPaBHTeJIIJCTBOMMeJIOB
"4y pe3Ko orpalIIIIIIITb cyne6Hble noJIHoMo[IIIH u no"opBaTIJ BJIIIHH11e l･I()BI､opOIcKoro aPXHemlcKOna. 3To IIaMePe"e

noHFITHo B cBeTe

MepoIIpPIFITHi

HBaHa

II1

1499-

1500rr.,｡Korma6bIJIanPoB"el:IaIIacTHIIHaHceKyJIHPII3auHH
⑥

apxIIepeHcKHx II MoIIacTblpcKIIx 3eMeJIb B HoBropone. npo-

THBOIIQCTaBJIeHIIeOJIHOiiIIaCTHlyXOBHblX巾eOnaJIOBXPyrOII

"3p6"erLIeHIIH
aHTIIUepKoBHoii
̅601)b6bI
B6JIIDKa#IlieM
6y⑪

且y皿eM - TaKoBa

rJIaBHaH

BHyTPHnOJIHTHIIeCKaHueJIb Bblu

natlII paccMaTpIIBaeMblx rpaMoT. BeJIIIK" KHFI3b, KoHeIIHo,
3HaJI, KqMy oH BblnaeUpaMQTbl. KJIoncKIM MoHacTblpb e皿e
B nepBOHnOJIOBI冊leXVB、6bIJI npoBoIHHKoM MocKOBcKoro
U

U

B川IHII"BHoBroponcKoii3eMJIe.gf<BOpHcbcHoBroPoIcKHM
一

ooHpcTBoM H paTyH 3a BeJIMKoro KHH3H MocKoBuKoro, KJIonWIIH M9HWbl" noMor leJIy o6T,e"HeHmH HoBropoXa c
⑪

Moc"o"252
Bq<ope
noc"e̅HoBropo八cKHx
KOHq)IICKa皿H
U

ZO-80-x ronoB XV B HBaH III no>KaJIoBaJI HoBGIe geMJIIi

KJIoncKoMyMoHacTbIpIQ"BnepemlcHoihKHHremejioMk6M
mlTIIHbl7006(1497/98)EoTMeIIGIIo,[IToUepeBlIMBJIy6poU

UeHCKOM nOrOCTe, IIPIIHanJle>KaBullie l)aHee O八I-IOMy @JIHIly,

6bIJIm
p"meJIeHb!
MejK4y
BeJIHKIIM
KHji3eM,
IByMfI
!foMe[J皿一
KamW
H
KJIopcKIIM
MoHacTbIpeM
25a
TaKHM
O6ja30M,
cTaBka
U

Ha KJIoncK" MoHacTbIpb B 1499 r. HBJIHJIacb &ecTecfBeH"M
250HHor1a
ycTaIIaBJIHBaJIocbⅡBa
HJIHT”cPOKa、

22EIcyｪ【兄HoKJIoHcKojirpaMoTe、CI)OKOMFIBKII6風Ⅱo

KI)enlGIIIIe, 6 1H-

Bap月．

252 JT. A. m M II T P II G H nOBGCTII O )KII'1,111I MIIxalMa

I<JIoI1cI<oro，M.-

JI., 1958, cTI). 35.

253 HnK, T. 1V, CT5. 182;几 A. nMHTI)HeB yKaa
l36

co[1., cTp. 34--35.

四

BblBOJIOM II3 MHorOJIeTHerO COTPymHIMqeCTBa Me>Kmy 3TOH

KOPnOPalIIIeii
H
MOC.KOBCKHM
BeJIHKOKHH>KecKIIM
nPaBIITeJIbCTBOM･

KoHeBcK" MoHacTblpb no nl)Hcoe4HHeH" HoBropo"
BxOLPIJI, 0[IeBHIHo, B IIHcJTO MaJIO nPIIBHJIermPOBaHHblX KOP-

nopaU", no"mHeHIIblx HenocPencTBeHHo apxIIenHcKOⅡcKOii Ka.enpe 254 MoHacTblpb, no-BII皿MoMy, >KeJI 〃pa-

30pBaTbj3bI̅npe)KHeii3aBlicmMocTIIIIo6pecTHxo3HiicTBeHHylo II anMIIHIIcTPaTHBHyIO caMoCTOHTeJIbHoCTb, BCJIencTBIIe
IIerO oH 6blJI 3aHHTePeCOBaH B TecHoM CoIo3e c BeJIHKOKHFI>Ke'CKO# BJIacTblo・Bo3Mo)KHo TaK>Ke, IITo MocKoBcKoe npaBIITeJIbCTBo maBIIo ycTaHoBWTO KOHTaKTbl c 3THM MOHaCTbl-

1)eM, npllilHMaH BO BHIIMaHHe ero IIOrPaHIIIIHoe nOJLO>KeHHe
(B 1496 r" Bo BPeMRnOxOna PyccKI1x BOeBO八B HHJIHII-

"IIo,MaPmpyTBoiiCKnl)Oxo皿JInococeacTBycKoHeBcKm》1
MOII(1CTI,1PeM)"
BbUla[Ia rpaMoT IIMeJIa, KaK ITaM Ka>KeTcFI, He ToJIbKo

BIIyTPMIIOJIHTHIIecKOe, Ho H BHemHeIJQ"TII¥2"oe 3HarIeHHe.
B illicUoBbIx Ii nepenIIcHbIx KHIIrax 1498-1500 m yKa3aHb!
IBa KoMnJIeKca BOTIIHH TpoHUKoro KJIoHcKoro MoHacTUpH』

o皿H - pacnoJIo>KeHHMii HenaJIeKo QTHoBIpponla(B ̲EpH-

rOPbeBcIfoM
KpeqHeEcKoILnorocTe
Bo42Koii
nHTHIE2E¥B
Koc皿KoMnorbcTe256,BnoBepfl>KbeII3aBepflJKbe257me̲

JIOHCKO曲mTIIIIbl) , XPyrOh-no6JIII30cTH oT IcKoBcKoii rPa-

H皿bI, ceBepo-BOCTotmee ncKoBa (B KypeUKoM 258HⅡy-

6poBeHcKoM
norocTaxm
259
OHCKOh皿TIIHbl)
JI
.

TaKIIM o61)a30M, m c aToi ToqKII 3peHHfI KJIoncKmi̲MoHacTblpb6blJIBbl6paHHecJIyIlaiiHo.BbmaIIaoTIMMeHHHBa-

Ha

lll

H

BacIIJIIIH

rpaMoTbl 'Ha

Bce BOTIIIIHbl

MoHacTEIpH,

BJIan'eBmero 3eMJIHMH B HorPaHIIIIHblx co HcKQBoM paio-

Hax,neMoHCTPmPoBaJIancKOBCKO#BePxymKe,UmBOHIImm
mBeUI11,IpeaJIbIIocTb
no)KaJIoBaHH別HoBropoJlaBacHJIHIoII
I1OJII､OTaBJIHBaJIaO61UeCTBeHHOeMHeHlieKnePCneKTﾙIBe6()JIee TeCHOro no八LIIIHeHIm ncKoBa cblHy BeJIHKoro KHH3H Moc-

KoBcKoro. CJIenpBaTeJIbHo, oTKa3 1'IBaHa lll oT cBoero nep-

BoHaIIaJIbHOTo HJIaHa nPHcoeXHIIeHIIH HcKoBa He o3|HaqaJI
25" BnpoweM, onpemeJIGHHbix "HHblx o6,ycTorIIIBbIx ""̲K"B"oIP
MoilacTbl" 6 apxmemIcKoncKoii Kad)enPoii HeT (3EepmHcKmi, T・I,

雌255）
255 Hnl<, T. 111, CT6. 11.
250 TaM >Ke, T. V, cT6. 153.
257 TaM >Ke, T. 1V, cT6. 14-16; T. V, cT6. 292.
258 TaM >Ke, T. 1V, cT6. 14-16.
259 TaM ]Ke, cT6. 186.
137

nOJIHO# II yCTO#IIIIBOHno6enbl HocJIemero. BeJIHKIIii KHFI3b
U

ひ

IICKaJI HOBbIe cnocO6bl BO3neicTBIIH IIa HenOKOPHylO HCKOB〆

0 Ky I o r o c n o n y .

cy且只no nePenlIcHo# oKJTanHoii KHHre BoXcKoHⅡHTHHbl
U

u

U

7008 ( 1 499/1 500) r, KoHeBcK" MoHacTblpb lIMeJI 3eMJIH B
roponleHcKoM, KmpbFI>KcKoM, CaKyJIbcKoM, PoBmy>KcKoM,
Ky#BomcKoM, Kop60ceJIbcKoM H KeJITymcKoM norOcTax 260、
pacnoJ1o)KeHHblx BnpJIb 3anaJHoro no6epe>KbH JIanp>KcKoTo

o3ePa

lI

HenocPenCTBeHHo

rPaHHIIHBmHx

C

BJIaneHHHMIi

mBeuIIH.
U

一

MecToHaxo)KneHHe BoTIIHH o60Hx MoHacTblpei IIMeeT

OOJIbmOe 3HaIIeHlie nJIFI yTOIIHeHIIH BOnPOCa O BHemHenOJIHTIIuleCKIIX nPlILIPIHaX

BblnaIIII rPaMOT.

Eme B cepenHHe 90-x ronoB, qepe3 JIRa rona nocJIe 3aK川O(IGHIM PyCCKO-几aTcKoro coIo3a l493 1､., npaBPITeJIb

IUBellHH CTeH CType noJIyIIIIJI H3 HapBbI II3Be6THe, [ITo
naTcKI1ii KopoJIb XaHc o6e皿aJI I'IBalIy lll O6mlIPHylO IIacTb
4

U

mBe4cKoII TepplITopIM B HarPany 3a BoilHy co mBeuHeH, a
U

U

HMeHHo̲Bclo (bllHcKylo KaPeJIHIo: norocTb[ 3iipem (Ayrfipdi), HcKHc (Jiskis) H CaBoJTaKc (Savolaks) 261 3THMJI
260 <<BI)eMeHHHK OImP>, KH. X1. M., 1851, cTP l l、142, 193-195, 234235, 251-252; KH. XII. M., 1852, cTI). 32, 69-73, ll4-117, 141.
261 r．B. (D o I) c T e ll. BoI)b6a I13-3a rocnoJcTBa lIa BaJITIliicKoM MoPe B
XV H XVI cTOmeTHHx. Cn6., 1884, cTp. 159-160, npHM. 3; K. B. B a3 II JI e B H II. yKa3. CO(1.、cTp. 380-381. 3To o6emaHMe MorJIo 6blrb

naHo JIeToM I495 1､., noCne c'be3Zla B I<aJIbMal)e, IIe onPaBnaBmel､o
H aJIe氷旦bI XaHca Ha nPII3IIaHIIe ero mBencKIIM KoI)oJIeM. y>Ke 6 aBrycTa l495 r. HBaH III npHKa3aJI cBoHM BoeBoJaM ImTH f<Ha cBeiicKoro KoPoJIH HeMeTUKoro" (nCPJT, T. 26, CTp. 289; cp. T. 1V, [L l，
Bbln. 2, cTp、534; cp. TaK>Ke <Pa3pFLIHafI KIIMIra...>>, cTp. 24, J1．21;
B 60JIbmmHCTBe JIeTOmICHbIx CBOHoB nOﾉ1 7004 r., 6e3 MecFIUa -

ncP几T. 1V. Cn6., 1848, cTP・165; npyrlIe ToMa yKa3aHbl HM>Ke) ･
B ceHTH6Pe l495 r. l)ycCKMe BoiIcKa O6,JIo>KII.ﾉII,I Bbl6oI)I､, IIO He CMoI､．
JIH B3FITI] ero II npmIIJIII B HoBroI)oﾉ1 25 neKa6I)FI '1495 r. (<<Pa3pyI/〔}laFI KHIira".>,, cTP 26; r. B.
o P c T e H. yK83. CoIL, cTp. 157)

B IIepBoHⅡoJIoBIIHe l496 I､. 6bIJI0 cOBep皿ellO TPlI noxoma, IIaIIa.ﾉio
KOTOPblX OTHOCIITCFI K flHBaPIO (Ha l<aflHCKyIO 3eMJI1O) , amPeJ1Io (nOﾉl

Bbl60pr) , MIoHIo (Ha l<aflIIcKyIo 3eMJIIo) (nCP几T. 26, cTp. 290;
cp．T. VI, cTp. 39-40, 240; T V111, cTp. 230-231; T. XII, cm. 210.
242; T.. 20, nepB" no､noBHHa, cTp. 362-363; T、24, cTp. 241-242;
T. 28, cTp. 160, 326; r. B. o I) c T e H. yKa3. co[I.、cTp. 157-158;
K. B. B a 3 H .m e B II LI. yKa3. coII., cTp 387-392) . l-Ianl)aBJIe[1|I,IH pyccKIIx noxoAOB nonTBel)>KnalOT xapaKTeP o6emallIIfl, 4a}IHoro I1BaIIy lll KopoJIeM XaHcoM @｢IeToM 1495 r．E皿e B KoHne l494- Ha'laJIe

1495 r. peLIb m.rla o pyccKIIx IIPeTeH3mfIx I-la 3eMJII,I B III)yl,oM I)aiioIIe

llIBeJIcKoro
q)1111""M'')

KoPoJIGBcTBa - enMcKoncTBe A60ccKoM
(co6cTBeHll o
(10. H 皿e l) 6 a II e B. KOnellrareHcKHe aKTbl, OTHO138

3eMJIHMII II3naBHa BJIaAeJI HoBropo,m, Ho Ho OpexoBeUKo-

MymoroBopyl323r.oIIH6blJIli̲XcTynJIeHblmBeUHH262.
ECJIII BeplITb IIcToLIHIIKy HaIIaJIa XVI B,̲TeppHT"", KoTo-

pble KoPoJIb XaHc corJIamaJIcH QmaTbHBaHXm,̲ np9cTm-

baJIIIcb Ha 200 MMJlb B IJIHHy ll 20 B皿IIpHHy 263. Ham60JIee
io>KHbli H3 ynOMFIHyTblx PaiiOHoB - 3ipenfl - 3aHIIMaJI
nPoCTPaHcTBoMe>KIIy①｝IHCKHM3aJIPIBOMHa3anane,PeKa-

MiI C6cTpoii H Caeii Ha BocToKe li rPaHliqliJI c KeJIT)L山CKHM,

Kop60ceJIbcKIIM,̲KyhBoglcKIIM,P"Uy>KcKIIMI[CaKyJIhF
cKHM norocTaMH BoHcKo曲nHTHHbl. HCKHC, PaCnOJIO>KeHHblii

ceBepHee Bbl60pra, rpaHIIKIHJI c ropo4eHcKHM̲JIorocToM Ha
BocTbKe H KHp6fl>KcKIIM norocToM Ha ceBepe. naJIbme K ceBePo-3anamyJ1G>KaJ1a o61Ⅱ川)HaH o6JIacTb CaBoJIaKc, nPxo八HBm”且oくKafll!a MoPfI)" (BoTHm[lecKoro 3aJ1IIBa) 264
TaKIIM o61)a30M, 3iipenfl II HcKHc Henocpe4cTBe"o

nPHMblKaJIHKTeMIIorocTaM,rmeHaxO且IIJIHCbBOTIIHI化IKo-

H6BcKoro MoHacTblpH; HHa[le roBopH, rpaMoTa K'oIHeBcKoMy

MoHac'Tblplo'y'KpenJIHJIanpaBamBaHalllHBacHJIHRHa3eMJIII, pacHoJIoJKeHHble pflLoM co mBe4cKIIMH BJIaneHH兄MH・

BOT[IIIHbl KJIoncKoro MoHacTbIpH B KypeuKoMHny6poBeHCKOM nOrOCTaxmeJIOHCKOii nFITHHbl 6bmⅡcocPenPToqe-

liblB PaiiOHe, J1e>KaBmeMIIa6JIII3KIMX nOLCTynaXK JIHBOH1IH Iイ①HHcKoMy 3aJIHBy, Bo3JIe KOToPOrO HaXOⅡHJIacb pyc-

cKaH KPenoCTb - HBaIIrOPo,m, noCTPOeHHaJI HBaHOM III B

1492 r. ̅HanpoTHB JIHBoHcKoii KpenocTH HapBbl H nperpa>K-

n,aB山aH nyTbmｲBOHcKHM HeMUaM H mBenaM B PyCCKlie BJIa-

neHHfl Ha IO>KI-IOⅥⅡo6epe>Kbe HHcKoro 3aJIHBa 265. B aBry̲
cTe l496 r. I/IBaHToPo且ⅡomBePrCH HananteHIIIo mBeXOB M

6blJIpa3pymeHHMmⅡOIITHⅡoocHoBaHHfl266.TeMcaMblM
c月皿IIeCFI K pyccKoiM MCTOPMI, BbIⅡ、1. M., 1915, M 3). no3ToMy MHelIIIe、6vJITo XalIc o6e皿aJT IJBaIW III Kal)emIIo B 1493 r., nl)M 3aKJIIo-

［leH岨colo3ⅢoI､o ｣,oroBopa (r. B o Pc T e H. yKaa CoIL;̲cTp. 160，
nPllM.; K. B. 6 a 3 H J1 e b lI (I. yKa3. coq.! cTp. 380-381, 395, cp･CTp
387), HeJ11,3fl cLIHTaT1, 13noJIHe JIQKa3aHIjblM

262 rBHIIn, Nb 38 (<<CeBHJIaKmlo, HcKbl, O叩e6y") .

263 r. B. o I) c T G ll. yKa3. coII., cTp. 160, nplIM.; cp.I.EKUB, 2-te Abt.,
Bd. 2, Nb l51a, S. 99,

264C. ran3月ⅡK '' ii, KapeJ'b' 'I Kapem硯 B HoBroPomcKOe BPeMH.

neTPo3aBoJIcK、1941,npllmo>KeHIIe[JYb2]­くCxeMaTIIIIecKaHKapTa
K ]16Tol)IIII Kal)eJIIII{ XIV-XV BB,>>; cp・TaK>Ke K. A. HeBo,IIHH'
O nnTIIHax I1TIorocTax HoBrol)oncKIIx B XVI BeKe. Cn6" 118531,
KapTa B KoHUe KIII'rl1; rBHp1n, Nb 38 ((｣｢mcaH''e py6e)Keii) .

265 ndnpo6Hee cM.: K B B a 3 !! ､n e B II ､Lyl24̲p9[L, cm 383-384 .

266くncKoBcKHe @JIeToI1IIcH>､Bbln. 1, cTp. 82; nCP几T. 1V, L1.1, BbIn. 2,

cTI). 534; T. VI，cTp. 42; T. V111, cTP、233; T. XII, cTI)、244; T. 24,
139

Tepl)HToI)111,I KypeuKoroHⅡy6poBeHcKoro norocToB meJ1 OIICKOHnHTIIIIbl KaK 6bl nPH6JIII3IIJIHCb K C巾ePe BO3Mo>K･
U

Hblx JIIIBOIIcKo-mBenCKHx
HblxJIHBOHcKo-mBe且CKHx
BTOI〕》KeHHH・
BTOI)>KeHHIi̅

KaKoBa 6bIJIa Me>KmyHaponHaH o6cTaHoBKa K MoMeHTV
Bbl且a[IHPacCMaTPmBaeMblx rPaMOT？

B MapTe l497 r・皿BeUl'IFI 3aKJIIo[IIIJIEI c POCCHeii nePeu

MHPHe, nPH'IIeM rPaHIIUbl nPe瓜ⅡOJIaraJIOcb OnPeXeJIIITb Ha
HOBoM

c.be3八e

ynOJIHOMOIIeHHblx,

KOTOpbli,

no

CJIoBaM

r" B. opcTeHa, <<Ka>KeTcH, He cocToHJIC別》267. 26 HoH6DH

L497rJ<opOlLXaHc6bIJIKopoHoBaHmBeJIcKoiMKopoHoifB

CToKroJIbMe 268 }1 o6'beIIIIHI1&m B cBoIIx pyKax BJIa6Tb Ham

UaHIIei, HopBerHeHII IIIBeⅡHeii. HecMoT" I{a nepeMHpHe
U

U

I,I nepexo八山BenCKOH KOPOHbl K COIO3HﾙIKy HBaHa lll­且aTCKOMy KOI)OJII0, n()rPaHHIIIII,Ie KOH(bJIHKTbl Me)Kny l)yCCKIIMII
H mBe八aMII nl)OﾉIoJT)Ka"｢IHcI> H oco6ellllo o60cTI)IIJIIIcb B

1 499- 1 50()rr269XaHcHecneuIII"nepemaTbieJIIIKoMy

KHFI3Ioo6elllaIIIIble3eMJIli,BMJIHMo,HGToJII]KoHoToMy,IITt)
OHくOnaCaJICfl Bbl3BaTb l)a3八l]a>KeHIIe co cTOI)OIIIJI mBeJIcKoro p3Ta H yBeJIIIIIHTb IMcJIo cTopoHHHKoB CTeH CType, KoTOPblII nPonoJI>KaJI JeIICTBOBaTb npOTIIB KOpoJIH>>
TopblHnpo1oJI>KaJI1eHcTBoBaTbⅡpoTHB
KopoJIH〉270．CTaB
270
mBencKIIM KopoJIeM, Xal-Ic enBa JIII 6blJI 3aﾙIHTePeCoBaH B
u

HoTepe aTIIx TeppHTopHi BecHoii l498 E CToKro)IbM Hoce○

THJIO PyccKOe nOcoJIbCTBo, IWeBmee 3a"IIeii yPeryJIIIPOBa･
u

HHg no[paHIIIll1bIx cnopoB 27'. B cKII6cKoi XPomIKe̅ no4
1499 r. paccKa3aHo o npH6bITIIH B UaHHIo HocJIoB II3 PocCHHHo6 0TIIPaBKe nocJIe 3Toro naTcKIIx nocJIoB B Moc-

KBy272・nocKoJIbKye皿e.6HpHH
1499r.opneHMeicTepJ1IIU

BoHpKoro opmeHamIcaJI II3 BeH4eHa xoxMeiicTepy, tITO naTcKHii KopoJIb co6HpaeTcH cHapH"Tb nocoJIbcfgO K BeJIII-

IfOMy
KH2310
273,
MO)KHO
HOJIaraTb,
IITO
PyCCKOe
nOCOJIDCTBO
6bl!ﾉIO B nallIIﾙI Lo HIoHH 1499 r. naTcKoe >Ke IIoco.汀MTBoBo
cTp､244 (B Co巾IIjiCKOii l l, JII)BOBCK()曲ⅡT肌CBoﾉle l518 1､­u迄)JL

7005 r.; 11CP几T. VI,CTI).241; T. 20, IIepBaFI noJIoBI[lla, cTI). 365;
T28, cTp. 329) ; r. B o p c T e ll. yKaa boLl., cTp l58; K B.̅B a&
311JI e BIILI・yKa3. coLI., cTI). 392.

2W [. B. <P O P c T e H" yKa3. cbLI" cTI). 159
268 C. F･Allel]・De tre nordiske Rigers Histol･ie, B(1. 1. Kbh., 1864,
s. 154.

269 1､．B. opcTGII. yKa3・co[1., cT､p. 159.

270 K. B・Ea3 m m e B !! q. yKa3. colI" cTp. 395.
27' C. F. A･l l e n. OI). cit., Bd. 1, s. 198.

272 KMpnL!n)ePtq ljiStoriae Dania", 1, 1873, s22, 409; LEKUB，2-te
Abt., Bd、1, S. 623,Anm. 2.

273 LEKUB, 2-te Abl., Bd. l, Nb 823, S. 623.
140

ぞ

rJIaBe
eⅡMcKoIIoM
C
QIeHceiicKIIM
EHcoM
AUepceHoM274
⑪

Ⅱ”6blJIoB
MocKByToJIbKoB巾eBpaJIel500r､275

PvCcK5e noco"1JcTBol499nnpjDKHo ̅6blJIo Bblno"WiTb

4Ba̅idWn" ̅I'IBaHa lll: ! l 496mTbCa nl)Ii3HaH" "29gご

cHei o6も山aHIIbIx TeppllToplIii; 2) nocBaTaTb cblHa BeJIIIKoro KHH3fl - BacH川,IH - K nPIIePH且aTCKOrO KOPOJIH-npIIH-

Ie"̅Eim3aBeTenonepBoMyBonpocyKopoJIbo6paTWlCg

K mBe八CKoMy CoBeTy 3a Pa3'bFIcIIeHHHMHH瓜OKyMeHTaJIbHblMH ⅡOLTBep]KﾉIeHHFIMII TePPl'ITOPHaJIbHblx nPaB mBe4⑪

cKoii KopoHbl. Ha BTo"ii gonPoc oH oTBSTIIJI, no-BH瓜HMOU

My,TaKjkeyKJIoHLIIIBo276.CKopeeBcel､o,XaHc3afIBIIJI,!ITo

OmPaBMT
B
MOCKBy
CI1eUllaJIbHOe
nOCOハbCTBO,
KOTOPOe
nepe"cTBeJIliKoMyKHfi310erOOKoHIIaTeJLQHOeMWMp

mTcKilii Kop6Jlb Be"n cJIo>KIIylo Iirl)yB HIoHe l429 rpjl
哩

4pfRE"e,,Hohpm"JIBCToKfoJIbMpnocoJI9"9̲Q'八eHa,

nPemJIaraB皿erobMycoIo3npoTIIBPoccIIILKopoJIbBblpa-

3AJI roToBHocTb npmHfITb B KoneHrarelie HQE92̲noJIHoMoIl-

II65 nocoJIbcTBo JIiiBoHIIII B ToM>Ke l499 r. 277 XaHc xoTeJI,
LITo6bl OpneH npII3HaJI npaBa nal冊IH Ha HeKorna nPlIHantJIeIKaBmli6 eii 66JIacTM XapmeH K BI1pJIa" B 3cTJI"U

八mi"rEMeCTe6TeMOHHeXeJ1amyCTYjaTbPOCCIII|ofie-

lilaHHbie HBaHy lll 3eMJIH B K4PeⅢⅢⅢ. no3ToMy, 3Hafl 3a-

MMOEaHndbTbJIIIBOHIlumpbCcml!BCOlO3CmaU":

KOPOJIbcTPeMIIJIcHcToJIKHyTbMxIIHTePefb[HⅡyTeM.JIaBI4U

POBaHwI八O6HTbC月瓜JIH
Ce6H
Hal'IBblrO八Hei皿HX
yCJIOBIIIi.

B cBeTe nplIBeneHHblx 4aHHbIx Bblflc"gIcFI BHeU｣HenoJ1IITTiqecKoe 3IfaqeHme Bbinaqm B aBrycTe l499 rpT o6be八m'HeHHoro JIHUa HBaHa lll H BacwIIIfl rpaMoT HoBropo4cKII:w
U

MoIHacTblpFIMHa3ewII'I,coCe皿HecKapeJmeiill6､IM3KIIe
K HBaHrOPomy.

274B、ntlTIIIIcKoiiTpaHcKI)IITIIIIIH<<Joanl1GsA11(11.eeU
̲deplltatusepiscopus
Ottoniensis>, B li3JIozKeHIm llyc(pKIIX JIeTqqlI"H 《KamJIaH，ルIMel1pM

ii63"̅̅̅5 IIEM cM: C P Fa l u d a n "l U l l e rJens AnderseV

55IMak̅BiSkop
i Fyen Odense, 1827,44 (2HaKoWicTBoMc 31oi'!
u
KI-IHI-ofl FI o6H3aI1川o6e311()cTli nl)o(P p. a (D. CMII'1､a}

275 ir", T VI, cTp 44, 243; T VUl, c'rp"8;J XII, cTI)250; 1，.20、
nepBa団リ10JIOBIIl･la,
CTP、369;
T.28,cTp.332.
CBenfeIII,ifl
cHoInGHI,IFIx
o
P;&m c na,,,,eii B koHUe XV - Hauai'eXVI̲E. cMJJ Qmlcl! 49xli-

MW66oJI"5rO npllKa3al614 r" ｣JL 266-267 od (i(OIIIIp!1 Ual)-

Ekoi.6 apxmBa XVrBeKa ll aPlfU" nocojnhgKoFo nl)IjKa3a l614 rojla>'､
n()JI I)e且.C. O. mMmﾕTa.M., 1960, cTp. 1 16)

276 C，F.̅A l l e n. Ol). cit., Bd. 1, s、198. .

277 W・En z Die huswirtige Politik des livlanflischen Ordensmeisters
Waltel･ voll PIcilellberg bi|s 1510.Riga, 1928, S. 81

278 1bid<g,111; C. F. A l l e ll. OI). Cit., Bd. 1, s. 200.
141

⑪
U

BnlaTcKoih,HeMeUKojimpyccKoiiJIHTepaTypeHeoIHo⑪

｡

Kp@THo yn9WimHaJIog.̲li3Be"e cKII'6cKoi xpoHMKIi o npennpliHfIToM MBaHoM III B ̲I499 E cBaToBcTB6 BacIIJIHH If n6A

IIepII naTcKoro KopoJIH. O4HaKo sTo II3BecTIIe He 6blJIo IIoCTaBJ1eHO B CBfl3b C COO6山eHIieM PyccKIIx JIeTonHcei o no｡

>KaJIOBa l-II榧I BacliJIHIo 2I MapTa l499 E HoBropo4a m nckOBa B BeJTHKoe KHH]KeHMe. AJIJIeH, npaB", npe1ⅡoJIaraJIII BnPJIlie pe3pllIHo,- IITo nyTeM 6paKa BacHJIHH c EJIm3a-

BeToiMHBaHIIIcTPeMIIJIcfi 406IIfbcmnepexomaK PMmi
gloPHblx 3eMeJIb, KoToI)ble MorJIli 6blTb npIIo6peTeHb! B Ka⑪

UffTBe̲W"Hor9､3anaTcKoiinpIIHUeccoih279TaKIIMo6pa30M,
Ha3HaIIaH
BacIIJ1wI
Be.ﾉIHKHM
KHH3eM
HoBropo几am

nCKOBa
HaMePeBaHCb〉KeHHTb
H
B6JIHjKaH山eM6y八yerO
U

UleM Ha noIlepl! KopoJI3 XaHca, HBaH III paccLIIITbiBJJI

ⅡpHcoe且HlIHTb K BJIaneHI1flM cBoero cblHa cMe>KHble c HoB○

[qpQncKoH 3eM"eii o6JIacTli Siipem, HcKHc H CaBoJlaKc, II342""pHHa4IIe)KaBIglle HoBropony (Xo l323 r.) , a B l495 r

o6e皿"ge̲ liBaHy lII. ,KPpoJIeMXancQMOq""Ho, y>K6
”

p9.pI92" I10JQBIIHe l 498 -"KIa"e l499 r" nocjle 6egpe-

2YJbTaTHoro nocoJIjcTBa B CToKroJIbM, HBaH III noHiIJI,

MIo､f̲19MoUIo
o6LIIIHblx
4mnJ1oMaTHqecKIIx
neperoBopod
He ynacTcH 3anQJIyqIITb )KeJIaeMble 3eMJIm Koria “v !fbro
BO3HHKJIaH瓜elI6P3qHOrocoIo3a,CKa3aTbTPy4HdioBCHg

KoM cJIyq¥, nKo 2L MapTal499 r" "60, e6皿I pyccKoe noEWcI29 ""o B UaHHII no moHfl l499r" To 6"a"JI56b

Tyna OH0, nO-BH瓜HMoMy, CPa3y lIJIM BCKOPe nocJIe no>KaJIoBaHHfl BacHJIHH.

O6paTIWBHIIMaHlie,qTono>Ka"oBaHMeBaciIJIHIoHoB[QPomamnCKOBaBBe"HKoc KH"KeHile CoBnaji5̅6̅"M
:2W" "ynHb" aKUmHMli HBaHa lll - oTnpaBkoiI B
BBeHeUliloWePe3HOJIb皿yHBeHrpHIooTBeTcTBeriHoronoW"Pa nMMTPmH PajleBa-naJI60JIOra 280, MEMIMfa
U

Ba
clIJIIIHⅡO
MaTePm,ⅡⅡocblJIKoH
BoeBoI
Ha
IOrpy
H
BoryJIHqeii 281.
u

2I2 P FAllenOP･cit, Bd. 1, s. 198.

B
JIeT()nHcFIx
280 of.be3几nOCOJ1IJCTBa
MOCKBbi八aTI1pyeTCFI
H3
Mal)TOA1
1499 r．(nCP几J̲YJ"2 44̲2"TyjjL cT2236;" I̅Xir｣M
242T20,nepB"no"OBIIfla,cTp368;̅T､28,cTp.332).
281BBo,Ⅲ:rqJ"-IIgpMSMiialleTonmcl{
naTIipjIeTM12'MapTa
l499
E
U

(lIEM T:"" 291)B jnpyr" cM""u iIM;", r:;M6

H3BeCTIIemoMelJIeHo
HoC､mecTaTIJII
oT
14
1IIo,mFI
1499
i､.
TOBOPl,ITCH,
II
Ⅷ､9"eR9flp! EepIMllicb､2.̲MapTe ̲1500 n(nCPJ1,TW1，cTp.43,

243;
T、W11,
cTL237;
TXII,
cTP
249;
T，20,
IIel)BaHnO0JIOBMHa,
CTI).
369;
T.
28,
cTp.̅332;
".《yCTIO>KCKIIil
.neTOITIICHElii
CBO1》,
100;
CTp.
142

noCOJIbCTBO nPeCJIenOBaJIO, nO-BMIIMQMy, IIeJIb OnPen<e-

｡meHI-IO曲 ⅡoJIIITHIIEcKoii,meMoHcTpaUlIH.BeHeⅡHFIHaXO瓜ⅢJIacb Bo Bpa]Kne6Hblx oTHoIIIeHmRx c nPyrlIMH IITaJIbHI-ICKHO

MmrocynaPcTBaMII.BMapTel499rpHa3aKJIIoqIIfmaMmpc
ひ

TypUIIeii 282. HHTepecIIo,-ITo Hap"y c oTnpaBKoHnocoJIb-

cTfa B BeHeUHIo HBaH III HanpaBIIJ[ cBoero nocJIa K cyJI-

TaHy283・nOKa3blBafl
KoPOJIflM
noJIb皿HmBeHrpIIH,
KoToPbI5 6bIJIIipomHblMH6PaTbHMIL AJIeKc3H4paJIlIJpBcKoro,

△

bBoe HaMep5HIie
c6JIM31iTbcH c BeHeuliei, MBaH III neM"ユ
6TDHDOBaJI" "elO CO3"HIIR MOrymeCTBeHHOh KoaJIIIUmll384.
B63Jfo)KeHme nocoJIbcKoM MMccHII Ha npll6JIII)KeHHoro CoU

上

』

凹

d)blInaJ1eoJIor,weiicblHHa3HaIlaJIcflBeJIHKlLMKHfI3eMHoBU

,bPOJIa P, nCKOBa, 4OJI>KIIO 6blJTOﾉIoKa3aTb HreJIJIOHaM BHyA

TpbHHee
yKpenJIeHHe
npoTIIBHKKa,
oTcyTcTBHp̲
B
MoWe
n9U

ʻmmTII[leclfli)<cIIJI,MorylUMxConPOTIIBJIfITbcfIIIBaHylII,八eIfcTBVfl B noJIb3V
ー BeJIIiKoro KHH3H JIIIToBcKoro, T. e. 6ecnepジ

cnekTIIBHocTb ̅cTaBKII
cneKTHBHocTb
cTaBKm Ha
Ha BacHJIIIH
BacHJImHKaK
KaK6paTa
6paTa JIHToBcKoH

BeJIIIKo# KHHrHHH, I-IenPBOJIbHoTo HOBeneHHeM cBOerO oTUa.
U

IIonblTKa 3aBoeBaHHFI o6皿HPHOii TePPHTOPHII K BOCTOKy
oT HoBropo且cKoH3eMJIHo3HaIIaJIa
HoBropoHcKoi seMJIII o3HaIIaJIa TeH4eH
TeH且eHuHIo K pacmmpe｡

HHIO BJ1anleHIIm HoBroPOXCKOro BeJIPIKOrO KHfl3fl, n,eJIana erO

3allHTepecoBaHHbIMB̅BoeHIHbIxycnexaxHBaHallLocJIa6-

lJ1FIJIa B KaKoih-To Mepe BO3Mo>KHOcTb npeTeH3Hh BacIMHFI
Ha BIIyTPeHHIIe PaiioHbI POCCIm, a TaK)Ke nPlイユaBaJIa eMy
U

U

<<pa31)fl/lllafl KIIIIra".>, cTp 29)IIoJII)oOljee Q6 3Toii 3Kcne,111111|l! cM:
K. B.̅ B a 3 II @II G B II !l. yKa3. coII., cTI). 403-407.
282 I<.B.Ba31I･ﾉI e B H II. yKa3. CoII., cTP､426.

283 B J1eToIIIIcfIx cKa3aHo，[ITo mocoJ1 yexaJI B MapTe l499 r. (IICP几
'I. V1, cTp. 43m且p.). B()JIee ToIIHyIo uaTy - 16 MapTal499 1､­[{axo八HM BnocoJI1ｺcKIIx l<HIII､ax (<<C6. PHO>', T. 41, JYb 60、CTI). 280-

282; I<. B. B a 3 II JI e B !! il. yKaa coI1., cTP. 429-4301
284 KaKyIo noJIHTwqecKyIo MIIccHIo IiamJ1e>Ka-｢Io BblnoJIHI'ITb noc.maM B ca-

Moil ̅ I/ITamm, cKa3aTI) TI)ynHo. OHII IIMeJIII BepIITeJIbHyIo I､I)aMoTy OT
I/iBaHa lll K nane AJIeKcaHIIpy VI (P P i e l､l i n g. La RL1ssie et le

Saint Sidge, v. 1. Pal･is, 1896, p・197-198i rJIyxoe ynoMIIHaH'He o6
aToM nioKyMeHTe: n. 0. n l:I P JI JI H̲r, PoccImⅢⅡanCK}Iii npeCTOJI, KI{. l .
M.､ 1912, CTp、235) ､ l l MapTa l500 r. npIIcyTcTBoBaJIII Ha 3aceﾉlalIⅡI1
KoIICIIcTopH11,

me

nana

nPoII3IIOcHJI

nl)onoBeIIb

nPoTMB

TyP()K

(P.P i e r li n 9. 01). cit., v. I, p、208; n．0. n,M p JIH II r. y､Ka3. co[I,

6Tp.. 247; E. rm M v p JI o. PIIM II MocKBa. Ha[laJIO cHomellIA Moc-

KoBcKoro rocyllapcTBa c nancKIIM npecToJIoM.­《3amlcKII PycCKoro
H|CTOPHTIeCKOrO O6皿ecTBa B nPare", KH' 11I npara 'IemcKa只一HapBa, 1937, cTp. 93, cH. 2). O collep>KaHIIII I,Ix nepe]､OBOPoB c BelleUIIaHl-IaMmHaM HIIIIerOIlem3BeCTHO，HO, BePOFITHO, nOCJIbI I/IBaHa lll He

Pa3PylllaJII"I IIJIJIIO3IIi'1 0TIIOCMTeJIIJHO BO3MOIKIIOrO yIIaCTⅢfI Poccllll B

allTIifypenKoM coIo3e (n 0. n II 1) JT II H r. yKa3. corl., cTp. 247) .
143

60'mbuIIIii Bec B rJIa3aXHHOCTPaHHblX
OOnbⅡIIIABeC
rJIa3ax HHocTpaHHblx MOHaPXOBH叩e>K且e
MoHapxoB H npe>Kne
Bcero naTcKoro KopoJIH, KoTopblii, no)KepTBoBaB KapeJIHeii

H cTaB TecTeM BacHJIHH, AIor 6bl paccIIHTblBaTb Ha yKpenJIeHIIe几aTcKOrO BJIIIHHMIH Ha orPOMHoM nPOCTPaHCTBe Ce-

BepHoii PoccHII H noXqlIHeHHblx eii o6JIacTeih BnJIoTb Jo

yPaJIa m 3ana皿oii CH6HpH.

HeymiBHTeJIbHoHo3ToMy,IITonpoTHBoneiicTBHepeme"Io o Ha3HaIIeHIIII Bac"" BeJIHKHM KHH3eM HoBroponia lI
ncKOBa mBaH III BocnPlIHFIJI c 60JIblHHM Pa3nPa>KemieM H
IocTal)aJIcFI KaK MozKHo 6blcTpee rlI)eceqb. OTcIona - aPecT
POMOﾉIaHoBcKoro H Kopo60Ba,八ByX LIJIellOB nePBOrO nCKOBcKOrO IIOcOJ1bCTBa H nocJIe八ylo皿aH 60Pl>6a CO HCKOBOM.

Kpma, HaKoIIeU, HBaHy lll yAaJIocb no6HTbcfl npli3HaHⅡHBacMIJ1HFIBenHKIIMKHFI3eMH巾OPMaJIbHOrO3aKPenJIeHHFI 3a llHM HoBropo" (29 HIoJIH 1 499 r.) , BeJIHK" kHH3b,
OqeBII4HO, y)Ke 3HaJI o 60J1ee HJIII MeHee O6Hane>KHBalOmeM

oTBeTe KoPoJIFI XaHca oTHocHTeJIbHo 6paKa BacHJTHfl H

EJIH3aBeTblHco3HaBaJIe皿eHCHeeHeBO3Mo)KHoCTbnPl'Io6peTellIIH KapeJIIIII 4pyrHM nyTeM. 3HaJI oH, cKopee Bc6ro,
KO且HDJIOMaTII'IeCKIIx CHOmeHHHX MeH〈八y naHI'e曲HJIH-

BoIIcWM opLeHoM 285.BoT HoIIeMyBaBrycToBcKIIx rpaMoTaxl4991､.
HOBroPonCKHMI
MOHacTblI)flM
nOnTBeP>KnaJIHCb
BeJIHKoKHH>KecKPIe npaBa BacIIJIIIfl Ha 3eMJIII, cMe)KHble c

PaioHaMIi̲fIcKmCa m SiiPem, M Ha 6JIII3KHe K JImBoHIIII TePI]IJToI)IM meJIoHcKoii nHTHHbI.

npaB八a, HBaH III He noBe"JI BacHJIHIo II He oTJaJI
eMy B巾aKTI1IIecKoe o6JIama'HHe HoBropon|cKylo 3eMJIIo. BaC1M噸6blJI JIHmb ｡opMaJIbHblM conpaBHTeJIeM HBaHa lll
nO IIaCTH且eJI, KaCaBmHxcH HoBropo4cKoii 3eMJIH. 3Ta TaK-

THKa l/IBaHa, nPenycMoTPHTe,JIbHaH c BHyTPImOJIHTHIIecKO#
TOIIKH

3PeHIIH,

BePOHTHO,

CHII3HJIa

BHemHenOJIIITIIIIecKHih

3艸eKT no>KaJIoBaHHH BacHJIIIIo HoBT､oponta B BeJIIIKoe
KIIFDKeHIIe,

TaK

KaK

nPonteMoHCTPliPoBaJIa

nOIcTaBHoit

xaPaKTeP pOJIH BToPorO BeJIHKOro KHH3H.

nl)HBJIeKafl BacHm畑 B KaIIecTBe BeJIHKorO KHH3H BceH

PyCH K yIIaCTIIIO B HMMyHIITeTHOiⅡOJIHTHKe nO oTHOmeHHIo

K HoBrol)ony, I/IBaH III npec,IIenpBaJI UeJIb, Bo-nepBblx, cBH3aTb c ero IIMeHeM 60pb6y npoTHB npeporaTIIB HoBroPoXcKorO

aPxIienHCKona,

Bo-BTOPblX,

cO3naTb

BHnIIMOCTb

CorJIacHFI Me>KIy BeJIHKHM KHH3eM H erO cTaPmHM cblHoM，

285,"nOllcKoeJocoJbcTBqBepHynocbHapoJJIHyBKoHHeMIojIH
1499E
(W Lellz.Op cit., S. 81).

144

3．"MHTe丞沙KHH3H Bac皿入HH 1500 r.

Bo3Mo)KHo, nJIaH yperyJIIIpoBaHIIH KoH｡JIHKToB BHyTpm
BeJIIIKOKHH)KeCKOrO ceMeitcTBa 6blJI mmPe II' BKJIIOIIaJI B Ce-

6fI, ecJIII BeplITb coo6皿eHIIIo KpaTKoro JIeToHHcnia, npoeKT
pa3八a"IIII yAeJIoB 4ByM MJIammHM cblHOBbHM BeJIHKOro KHH-

3H - IOplIIo H nMIITpIIIo (cJI"ylo皿HM IIO CTaPmH'HCTBy
nocJIe BacHJIHH) 286. KpaTKIIji JIeToHIIceU coo6UaeT, IITo

IOpIIIo npe皿a3HaqaJIcH nMIITPoB, a UMHTPHIO - yrJIIIII.
Ho>KaJIOBaHHe cOcTOflJIOcb He PaHb皿e 29 HIoJIH 1499 r.
ocy皿ecTBOBaHHH npoeKTa nyxOBHOhHBaHa lll, BblPa60TaHHoro np l500/01 r., Mbl y)Ke roBopHJIH Ha ocHoBaHHII
U

CPaBHHTeJIbHOrO

a|HaJIH3a

TPex

HCTOxlHKKOB:

nyXOBHOH H

naHHO曲HBaHa lll l504 r・HnPHHHcHoii rPaMoTbl K XyxoBHoit BacHqJIHH TeMHoro 287・TenePb o6paTIIMcH K nPyrHM MaTepllaJIaM. B meKa6pe l499 r. IIBaH III npoMeHflJI cBeTcKHM

｡eo"JIaM (Ko30naBJIHM) HeKoTopble pMIITpoBcKIie 3eMJII1,
npHo6peTH B3aMeH 3eMJIII B MocKoBcKoM ye3,me 288.1 7 ｡eBpaJIH 1500 r. oH BblnaJ1 zKaJIoBaHHylo rpaMoTy KIIpIIJIJIo-BeJIo3epcKoMy MoHacTblplo Ha JBa ceJIa B HMIITpoBcKoM ye3nte 289. 3To cBIImeTeJIbCTByeT, C oJHOii CTOPOHbl, o ToM, IITo
B KoHUe l499 - IIaIIaJIe l500 r. IOpHit IIe HMeJI nMIITpoBU

cKorO yneJIa, OAHaKo, C ,mPyroH CToPOHbl, TaKoe 'BHIIMaHHe

HBaHa lll K nMHTPOBy, Bo3MO)KHo, HBJIFIeTcH HOKa3aTeJIeM

IKaKHx-To nPHTH3aHHIIi Ha Hero. MaJIoBepoHTHo, xoTH HcTOIIHHKaMII nPHMo H He OnPOBePraeTCH (HO H He nOnTBeP>K"eTcH) , JIonymeHHe, ､ITo IOpHii noJIyIIIIJI yXeJI B aBrycTe II
BJIaneJI IIM np HoH6pH 1499 r.
HHTePeCHa JIOKaJIH3aⅡⅡH3eMeJIbHO-IIMMyHHTeTHOji nOJIHTIIKH HBaHa lll B OTHOmeHHH nMIITPOBCKOro ye34a
B KoHUe l499 -HaIIaJIe l500 r・HBaH III oTnaJI CBeTCKHM

BOTIIHHHIIKaM 3eMJIH B BocTO[IHoih qacTH且M HTP OBCKOrO

ye3na (c. CympBo, no cocentcTBy c nepecJIaBJIb-3aJIeccKHM
ye3nPM) , a B3aMeH B3flJI 3eMJIH B ceBePo-3ananHoii uacTII

MocKoBcKoro ye3" (B BblKoBe cTaHe) . rpaMoTa KIIp"JIoBeJIo3epcKoMy MoHacTblplo KacaJIacb ceJI B 3ananHoM, KaMeHcKoM cTaHe mMHTpoBcKoro ye3na. BbIKoB cTaH MocKoBcKoro ye34a H KaMeHcK" cTaH IMIITpoBcKoro ye34a
286 H. C, JI y p lJ e. I<paTKIIA JIeToHIIcen n〔)ro瓜HHcKoI,o co6paHHH.<<Apxeorpa｡IIIIecKmii e>Kero皿HK 3a l962 1､o,心. M., 1963, cTI). 443.
287 C.M. Ka皿T a H O B. nmmloMaTIIKa KaK Cne皿aJILHaH IICToPlItIecKaFI
八HcUl,Imll,IHa.­《Bonpocbl lIcTopml)>, 1965, Nb l, cTp. 42-43.
288 ACSI'I, T. I, Nb 624.
289 TaM >Ke,T, II、Nb 301.
l O C ． M 、 K a m Ta H o B

145

6blJIH o6pa皿eHbl B cTopoHy ynleJIa enopa BopHcoBII[Ia BoJIOUKOrO,

aKTHBHO

yKPenJIHBmerO CBoII

IIoJIHTII'IecKHe

nO-

3ImHII B 3To BpeMH: B MapTe l500 r．①enpl) BblnaJI ]KaJIOBaHHyIO rPaMOTy lIOcII巾o-BoJIoKoJIaMcKoMy MoHacTblplo Ha

IBOP B r・BoJIoKoJIaMcKe 290. Mepbl npeppcTopo)KHocTHⅡpoTIIB BoJIoUKoro KHH3H, nPHHHTble B KoHne l499- Ha'IaJIe
1 500 r., 40 H3BecTHoA cTeneHH Ho4TBep>KXaIoT BepcIIIo o

nPOeKTe lIJIH巾aKTe KpaTKoBpeMeHHoii oT,maIIH IOpIIIo nMIITPOBcKOro ye3八a・

nepexoX y'皿池a lI yrJIHn;KOrO ye3" B PyKII UMHTP"
B l499 HJIIi l500 r・He nonKpenJIHeTcH JIa>Ke HaMeKaMII. Mo>KeT 6blTb, naMFITb o .MHTe>KHoM AH4pee yrJIIiUKoM ynep>KIIBaJIa HBaHa lll oT nepenaIIH yrJIHIIa B yneJI. BMecTe c
TeM BblnaIIa KIIpHJIJIo-BeJIo3epcKoMy MoHacTblpIo oX'HoBpe④

MeHHo c rPaMOToH Ha JMIITPOBCKHe ceJIa rPaMOTbI Ha BJIa-

1eHIIH B BoJIoroXcKoM ye3,me 291 HaBo瓜HT Ha Mbl.CJIb7 He

nPenHa3HarlaJIacb JIII IMIITpIIIo BoJIoma BMecTo ymHIIa 292.
BnpouleM, yKpenJIeHIIe BeJIHKoKHH)KecKIIx npaB B BoJIorne
U

MorJIo onPenleJIHTbCFI OnaceHHeM nPeTeH31IH |Ha Hee co cTo-

poHbl BacHJIHH.
nPOBeZeHIIe Cy,瓜a no cnopHoMy 3eMeJIbHoMy nleJIy B Mo瓶aiicKoM ye3ne, HeKorna nPHHaAJIe]KaBmeM AHnpelo BoJIbI H O M y , " B J I H e Tc H K o c B e H H b l M n O K a 3 a Te J I e M T O r O , I I T O e r o H a ､

CJIe4cTBo nPlIBJIeKaJIO K ce6e BHHMaHHe |BeJIIIKoKHH)KecKOro npaBHTeJIbcTBa (nPaBaH rpaMoTa 6bIJIa no皿mCaHa
27 HoH6" l500 r. 293, HaIIaJIcHンKe nPoILeCc, Bo3MO)KHO, 3a
，

H e C Ko J I b KO M e C H n ' e B I o 3 T O r o ﾉ ．

npoeKT pa3naIIII yneJIoB MJIa瓜mHM cbIHOBbflM BO BTOpoii noJIoBIIHe l499 r. npecJIeXoBaJI, BepoRTHo, neJIb HeitTp aJII13auHHnpHTH3aHIIi BacIIJIHH Ha yneJIbHble TeppHToplllI CeBepo-BocToIIHoii PycII.
０ A(p3IIX, w. 11, Nb 26.
２９
１
２９
ACali, T. 11, JYb 300.
２
２９

nOKa HwIeM OmPe"eJIeHIIblM IIeJIb3FI noKa3aTb, [ITo K 3TOMy BPeMeHII
oTHOCHTcH II KoPMJIeHaH rPaMOTa Ha BOJIorOnCKylo BoJIOCTb qaBUy B
3aKy6eHbe, BblAallHaH I'IBalloM IIIHnOIIIHCaHHaH KHFI3eM HMﾙITpHeM IMBaHoBHIIeM (ACSH, TJ1 1, MJ 279; cM. TaK>Ke B npIIMeIIaH皿1
li. A. roJIv6uoBa M B HacToH皿eii Pa60Te O BO3MO>KHOCTII OTO)K4eCTBJIeH" ynOMI'IHaeMOrO 34eCb KHH3fl HMIITPHFI IIBaHOBII[Ia C nMIIT-

●

、

PLIeM -BHyKoM）．
293

ACSH, T. 11, Nb 422. CBH3aHa JIMI aKTIIBII3amlH BeJIﾙIKOKHfDKecKO ii
noJIHTⅢKmB oTHo皿eHlllI MoﾝI<aiicKa c nepexonpM I･Ia cJIy>K6y K I'IBaHy lll BecHoii l500 r. KHH3fl CeMeHa HBaHoBMLIa MoﾝKaiIcKoro, cblHa
八aBIIIIInHero BJIalleTeJIFI Mo>KaiicKa HBama AHApeeBII'la, cKa3arl)
Tp y n H O .
146

no cBoeMy coXep>KaHHIo IIMMyHHTeTHaFI noJIHTIIKa B

｡eBpaJIel500r.6bl"acTporoorpaHmlllITeJIbHoii:!13MoH?-

CTbIPCKOji lOPlIC4IIKImHH3blMaJIHcb JIBe KaTerOPlIIi neJI (O

八ymery6cTBe PI pa360e c noJIIIIIHblM) . O皿oBPeMeHHo B
rPaMOTax ｡liKc叩oBaJIocb nPaBO BeJIHKOro KHH3H cynHTb
IirVMeHa no HcKoBbIM neJIaM. 3To HocTaHoBJIeHHe HocHJIo
aHTIIBJIanblIIHblii XaPaKTep, nonTBeP那且aH 3aBHcIIMocTb KHPIIJIJIoBCKOrO IIryMeHa OT BeJIHKoro KHFI3H II He3aBIICHMOCTb
oT POcTOBcKoro aPxIiemlCKona.

OT MapTa - aBrycTa l500 r. He coxpaHHJIocb HMMyHHTeTHblx rPaMOT MOcKoBCKOrO BeJIIIKoKIIH)KecKOrO nPaBHTeJIb-

CTB a、30 ceHTH6pH l500 r. 6bma BblnalHa y)Ke ymoMHHaB-

皿aflcH HaMH paHee B npyroik cBFI31i rpaMoTa BoJIoToBy
MOHaCTblplO 294・B intitulatio sToii rpaMoTbl cToHT IIMeHa
Be,JIHKMX KHfl3ehHBaHa BacIIJIbeBHqa H ero cblHa BacHJIIIH

HBaHoBHIIa <<Bcea PycHH>'. O neHTeJIbHocTH BacHJIH月ⅡocJIe

aBrvcTa l 499 r. M np ceHTH6pH 1 500 r. HH'KaKHx cBeleHHit
B H3BecTHblx HaM rpaMoTax He coxpaHIIJIocb. B KpaTKoM

JIeTonlicUe non 700g r. (celITH6Pb l499 -- aBrycT 1 500rr.)

coo6maeTcH: <<KHH3b BacHJIeii, cblH BeJIIIKoro KHH3H IIBaHa, xOTH BeJIHKoDO ImHH>KeHIIH, H x|OTeB erO HcTPaBIITH Ha

HoJIe Ha CBHHcKoM y CaMbcoBa 60py, II caM Io6eJKa Bb
BH3bMy cBoIIMH 295 II coBeTHIIKH. A KHH3b BeJIHKIIii HaIIa nyMaTH co KHHrHHelo Co巾HelO, H BO3BPaTm皿a ero, II 4ama
eMV BeJIIIKoe KH"KeHIie nonl co6010, a KHH3H nMI1TpeH no-

HMamalIcMaTepHeloKHHrHHeIoEJIeHolo>296.
H. C. JIypbe, BnepBble BBe及皿嘘B HayIIHbIii o60poT H3BecTIIe o 6ercTBe BacHJIIIH B BH3bMy, cnpaBenlJIHBo 3aMeTHJ1, IITO <XaJIeKO ･He BC|e B aTOM H3BeCTIIH nPelcTaBJIHeTcH

JIcHblM>, 297. HeHcHo HecKoJIbKo MoMeHToB: 1 ) MecToHaxo]K-

UelIHe CBHHcKoro noJIFI H CaMbcoBa 60pa; 2) cooTHo皿eHHe
rJIaroJI aくIICTPaBHTH)P c MeCToHMeHHeMくero>; 3) ToqHafl

"Ta no6era (Mec皿) ; 4) BpeMeHH6e cooTHomeHHe Me源ﾕy
HaMepeHHeM <<ero IIcTpaBHTIII)" MI 6ercTBoM BacHJIIIH B Bfl3bMy, a TaK>Ke cTeneHb (HaJIIIIIIIe KaKIIx-To neitcTBHii) H BPeMH (nIo IIJIH nocJIe no6era) ocy皿eCTBJIeHIifl 3aMblCJIa, Bblpa>KeHHOro

cJIoBaMHくXOTeB

erO

HCTPaBIITH》．

294 AIi, T・I,Nb 111.
295 He@IIb3FT corJIacI,ITbcFI c IIoBbIM cJIoBoPa3meJIelMeM, n1)eｴ1．rlo>KeHHblM

H. C. JIypbe: 4<c BoIIMII ". PaHee H. C･JIypbe ullTaJI <<cBOIIMIIII>D
(H､C. JI y p b e. nepBble ImeoJIorlI…, cTp. 99).
296 H. C・JI y p b e. I<PaTKIIii @JIeTOmHCeu..･, cTp、443.
297 H．C. JI y p b e. nepBLIe m,nteoJIorII..., cTp. 99.
1

4

7

1

0

＊

舍

no MHeHHIo H. C. JIyPbe､<CBHHb mJIM CBeHb - PeKa B
paiiOHeBpHHCKa> 298.MHOeOTO|>KXeCTBJIeHHeHaXO八HMy
①eHHeJIa, KoToPbl曲Ⅱpe旦ⅡoJIaraeT, IITo <<CaMbcoB 60p>,-

sTo CaMcoHoB JIyr no4 MocKBoit, Heo"oKpaTHo ynoMiIHaeMblii B nyXOB'HblX rl)aMOTaX BeJIMIKHX KHJI3eii 299.

CoBpeMeHHoecocToHHHeHcTopHIIecKoiireorpa(PHHHe
HO3BOJIHeT,瓜aTb yBePeHHOI､O OTBeTa Ha BOnPoC O MeCToHo-

JIoxfeHIIII CBHHcKoro noJIH II CaMbcoBa 60Pa.
CBIIHb (CBHHa, CBHHaH) , ynoMHHaIoUaHcH B JIeToⅡⅢcHbIx CTaTbHX CePe且HHbl XII B.300,- peIIKa, BnanaBmaH B

necHy no,U lIepHIIToBoM, 3ananHee p. CHoBH 301. KpoMe

Toro, B JIeToHIiCaX "rypHpyeT r. CBHHecK (B [IHcJIe ropo40B pH3aHcKHx 302 1I BoJIbIHcKHx 303) , c. CBIIHyxII B BoJIEIHCKOM
KHfDKeCTBe304,r・CBHHorpamBHo八O｡ﾉIHH305,CBHHTopor (皿BHHTopor) - MecTo npli BnanleHHII p. BKJIbHbl B

BeJIlo306,CBHHopTBHoBroponcKoii3eMJIe,yPmeJIoHII307.
reOrPa｡HIIeCKHxnOHHT",
HanOMHHaIOmIIXBbIPa)KeHHe
<<CaMbcoB60p>,BJIeToⅡHCHXHeT(ynOMHHalOTcHroPO』
CaM60p II CaIM60pcKaH enapxIIH B BOJIblHcKoit 3eMJIe 308) .

B aKTax CeBepo-BocToIIHohPycH XV-XVI BB. BCTpeIIaeTcH Ha3BaHHe <<CaMcoHoBo)" (Ho He <<CaMbcoBo)') 11 ,npoH3BoXHLIe oT Hero B Py3cKoM, HoBoTop]KcKoM, KamHHcKoM, BoJIoro八cKoM H BeJIo3epcKoM ye34ax 309. CaMcoHoB

298 H. C・JI y p b e. nepBbIe Imieo,JIorH..., cTp. 100.
299 J.Fennell.OP・cit･, p. 341, note 1.

300 nCPJI, T. I1, cTp. 70, 81, 1 18; T、VII, cTp. 58, 59, 66; T. IX, cTp.

208; T、20, nepBaH HoJIoBHHa, cTp. 1 19; T、23, cTp. 41; T. 25, cTp、56,
57, 63; T. 28, cTp. 33, 189.

301 TaM ]Ke, T. 25, cTp. 444; A、H. HacoHoB．《PyCCKaH 3eMJIH> II
o6paaQBa"e reppllTopHH npeBHepyccKoro rocy"pcTBa. M., 1951,
cTp、221, 225, 230.

302 nCPJI, T､VII, cTp. 241; T､23, cTp・1 64.
303 TaM )Ke, T. 23, cTp. 163.
304 TaM )Ke, T・I I, CTp、80; T. V11, cTp. 65; T. 25, cTp. 62.
305 TaM >Ke, T・XVII, CT6.452.

306 TaM )Ke, cT6. 235, 251, 261, 305, 314, 367, 374-375, 440, 493-494.
307くHoBropo八cKaH nePBafI JIeTOmICb CTaPmero M MJIa八meroⅢ3Bo且o”・
nonl pepi. II c npenmcJIoBIIeM A．H. HacoHoBa．M.̲J1., 1950, cTp，239;
HCPJI, T, 1VI. 1, Bbln. 1, cTp、179; cp. A. H. H a c o H o B. <<PyccKaH
3eMn”…, cTp. 118, nplIM. 6.

308 nCPJI, T. II, cTP、361i T. V, BbIn. 1, cTp. 16j T. VII, cTp. 240; T・IX,
CTP.̲XIII, XY; T. XVU, CT6. 112i r. XVIII, crp. 22; T.̅23, CTp. 163.

309Aの3HX,Ⅵ．II,cTp､265,317;AC3H,T、II,cTp､663（cp・cTp. 642) ;
T. 111, cTp. 618.

148

JIyr310THHy"KCCeMq"cKoMy"3M:IfQTnpoeBnocJIeXcT-

BHH,Ka>KefcH,cJMJIocbcMocKBoii312.BMo"oBcKoMye3ne dTMeqeHbI nep. CBHHKIIHo, THHyBmaH K c. IieBJIIo (B go-

jiocTHBope-KOP3eHeBe)313,HCBIIHKHHoo3epKoB6JIII3HTe-

mHJIOBcKHX nePeBeHb (B PaHOHe
、皿OBcKHXⅡePeBeHb（B
PaiTOHeMocKOBcKO-且MHTpOBCKOrO
MocKOBcKO-nMHTPqgCKOrO

py6e]Ka)314.
CBIIHyxoBcKIM
oBparynoMIIHaeTcFI
B
P兄3aHu

tkOM K">KeCTBe 315.
BnHcUoBbIx KI-IIIrax XVI B. 'HeonHoKpaTHo nonanaloTcH
<<CBHHKI" H <<CaMcoHoBbl)> (He <<CaMbcoBbl)>) B pa3Hblx

ye3naX
PyccKOrOroCynapCTBa316.

O6pa皿aFIcb K HCTormHKy BTopoi noJIoBHHbl XIX -

HaIIaJIa XX B.­《CmlcKaM HaceJIeHHblx MecT>, Mbl HaxoXHM

nyHKTbI
cHa3BaHIIeM<(CaMcQJIoBo)',<<CaMfo"xa)PHT．Ⅱ．

h. BoJIoTomoKoii,
．BoJIoTo瓜oKoH，
B̅ry6epHIIHx ApxaHFeJIbcKOi, BJIanIIMmpcKqi,
BgicK6it, KaJIy》KcKoH，
BmcKoH，
KaJIy)KcKoii, KocTpoMcKoH，HⅢ]KeropoﾕcKoH，
KocTpoMcKoi, HIIxferqponlcKo*,
ジ

人

｡

⑥

U

p

UcKoBcKoii, P"aHcKoii, CMoJIeHcKoit, TBepcKoM, TyJI.cKoh,

IIepHIIroBcKoi,HpocJIaBcKoii317,T.e.BoBcexTexry6epHHflX, TePPIITOPHH KOTOPblx neJIHKOM IIJIII H"THIIEQ "O"JIa B

co6Taifpyc6Koro ro6yXapcTBa KoHILa XV B.̲B IIep"roBcKoii ry6epHHH "rypHpylOT e皿e CaM6yp, CaM60p Be皿一
KIIii m baM60p MaJI" E CMoJIeHcKoii ry6epHIM -PaMUoBo, CaMUoBar. Ha3BaH" TIma CBIIHb, CBeHb, CBHHaH,
⑪

U

⑪

｡

CBIIHIKa, CBIIHKHHo, CBImyxII, CBIIHeHKH, CBIIHaH ny6poBa,
CBIIHaH roPa, CBIIHaH Hora II nP. IIMelOTcfLBo BceXyKa3aHU

⑤

HbIx ry6epiI"x, KpoMe Apx3HreJIbcKoi JI TyJIbcK9#, 4TaK>Ke B iy66pHKHx KypcKoii, MIIHcKo#, MocKoBcKoii, OpJIoBCKOji 318.

OTcvTcTBHe Ha3BaHIIH <CaMbcoB>" B npocMoTpeHHblx
ソ

HaMII IibTopHKo-reorpa｡HqecKIIx MaTepHaJIax XVI-XX BB.
３１
０ ⅡHnr, cTp. 554.
３１
１ TaM >Ke, cTp. 58mⅡp.
３１
２

B.

H.

ne6oJIbcKIIii．nyXOBHble

lI

nOroBOPHble

rPaMQJPImgg-

KoBcK" KHfI3eii KaK !1cTopliKo-reorpa"qecKIIii ̅ IIcToIMHIIK, [I]. Cn6.,
1901, cTp. 16.
３ACSIJ, T. I|, cTp､568.
３
１
４ⅡHnr, cTp. 394.
３
１
５ACSH, T. 111, cTp､618.
３
１
６
３
１
《nIIcUOBble KH:HrFI MOCKOBCKorO rocyntaPCTBa, 113"BaeMble IMMm.

pyccKIIM reOrpa*IIIIecKHM o6皿ecTBOM>, I1.1 . yKa3aTeJIb・Cn6., 1895;
曲]K, yKa3aTeJib K nepBbIM mecTH ToMaM (I-VI) . nr" l915.
317

《CnHCKII HaceJIeHHEIx MecT PoccIMcKoih HMneplIII>, I, VI$ VII, X, XV,
x v I I I , x x v , X x x I v , X x x V, x L , x L I I I , x L I V, x Lv I I I , L . C n 6 .
1861-1885.

318

《CIIHcKPI Hace,meHHbIx MecT...", XX, XXIV, XXIX. Cn6., 1862-1871 ;
くCHIIcoK HaceJIeHHblx MecT MHHcKoii ry6epHMII". M､HHcK, 11909.
149

nOKa3blBaeT, IITO 3TO HanlIGaHIie OKIeHb Pen<Koe H MO)KGT

6blTb nia]Ke nPIIHfITo 3a lIcKa>KeHHoe <<CaMbcoHoB>. B &JIIo60M cJIyIIae enBa JIH npaBIIJIbHo IIcKaTb <<CBIIHcKoe noJIe>i',

oTBJIeKmHCb OT《CaMbcoBa 60pa>', 'H Hao60poT. Koma
H.C・JIypbe npenJIaraeT oTo>KnecTBJIHTb CBHHcKoe noJIe c

KaKHM-To MeCTOM Ha BPHH皿I'IHe, OH He yqIITblBaeT OTcyTcTBHH TaM Ha3BaH" <<CaMbcoBo)D, <CaMcoHoBo> II T.Ⅱ．

Ⅱ》K.OeHHeJI,BH皿皿嘘B<<CaMbcoBe60py>CaMcoHoBJIyr
IToI MocKBoii, He npIIHIIMaeT Bo BHHMaHIIe, IITo "nPM - c

3TIJM JIyrOM He ynaeTCH Ha耐ⅢⅡplI3HaKoB <<CBHI-IcKoro
nOJIH》、

HeHMeH3necbBo3IMo>KHocTH
BblFIcHHTbcJIyIIaI'II､eO叩a-

巾HIIecKoii 6JIH30cTH O6もeKToB c Ha3BaHI1eM TIma <<CaMco-

IIOBO》Ho6'beKToB c IIa3BaHIIeM TIfna <<CBIII-Ia月》，《CBelIb>p,

<CBHHKa>IITJI,Mh!IIcxo皿MH3npnymeHIIH(Hy>KnalOlllerOcFI B maJIbHeH皿ei npoBepKe), [ITo B <<CaMbcoBo> - He

omlcKa , a npaB"bHoe HanHcaHIIe. Toraa Mo]KHo yKa3aTh

o皿Oe皿HcTBeHHoe (H3BecTHOe HaM) CorleTaHIie litKoMbIx

Ha3BaHII曲一B CaMHoBcKoii BoJIocTIi noporo6y>KcKoro ye3-

na CIMoJIeHcKoi ry6epHIIII, B paiioHe Me"y Bi3bMoi m no-

poro6y>KeM, K ceBepy oT EJIbHH. TyT Ha CpaBHHTeJIbHo He-

60JIbmoMpaccToFIHHH且PyroT，nPyraHaXOJHTCHnyHKTbl
くCaMUoBo>('f<CaMUoBa)')Ⅲ《CBMIHHaH)>
(CeHHa"npmp[l
CBIIHKe(CeHHoii) 319.<CaMHoB)>MJIII K<CaMbcoB)>6dPMor
npocTIIpaTbcH c ceBepa Ha lor np p11. CBHHKH・KoHeqHo,
nPenJIO>KeHHOe OTO>KXeCTBJIeHHe He nPeTeHnyeT Ha OKOHIIaTeJIbHOe PemeHIie BonPOCa lI HocIIT rmnOTeTHIIeCKIJii XaP aKTep .

O6paTIIMcH K cooTHomeHHIo rJTaroJIa《HCTP aBIITH》c MecToIIMeHHeM |<<ero>p. H. C. JIypbe He naeT nepeBona巾pa3bl lI
He oCTaHaBJIIIBaeTCH Ha 3HaqeHHHrJIarOJ1a <<HCTPaBHTII》．

n>K. eHHeJI nePeBO皿T {<HCTPaBHTII>> KaKくOnyCTOmHT”
H OTHOCIIT 3TO CJIOBO K <<BeJIIIKOMy KHH)KeHIIIO>>: <<tO lay it

waste>. noIIIIMaH a6cypnHocTb TaKoii HHTepnpeTau皿I, OH
nHmeT: <<Me>K,my cJIoBaMII ,,BeJIHKoro KHFI>KeHIIFI.… Ⅱ，!…caM
f G

no6e>Ka" ecTb HenoHHTHaH巾Pa3a: ,,x<eJIaH ero oITycTomI'ITb
(PHcTpaBHTH）Ha
6opyfG>320.
319

<<C60pHIIK

CBIIHcKoM

cTaTI'IcTI,IIIecKIIx

noJIe Bo3Me

cBeneH城 Ⅱo

CMoJIeHcKoii

CaMcoBa

rV6epHI'II"#

TL V. nol)oI､o6y>KcKHii ye3II. CMoJIeHcK, 1889, KapTa B KoHile kflllrm;
4<CMoJIeHcKafl ry6epHI,m. CnIIcoK IIace､meIII化Ix MecTno cBe且eHⅡHM
1859 rOma>. Cn6., 1868, Nb 4963, 4964.
320

J. Fennel l. Op. cit., p. 341, note l.
150

B
cJIoBapHx
pyccKoro
fI3blKa
<<IIcTpaBMTb》ⅡePeBOⅡmTcR

KaK IIcTPe6HTb, m3BecTH, nonOPTIITb, noPaHIITb, HaHecTH

ypOH
m
Tn.321
BaTOM3HgleHHm《HCTpaBI1TI"BeJIMKOe
U

i<iIH)KeHIie BacmJIIIii He Mon npe且ⅡOJIaraTb nPyrOe 3Ha'Ie-

HmerJIaroJIa<<IIcTpaBHTII),(aIIMe"q-nOJIVIIIITb,nP61ITbEfi)C｡nOBaPmHenAIOTOCwOWaH"322JI"""L̲P̲K9WgNiiM6"hbTmp6BaJIcH aBTop HacToflmei pa60TbI, "冊Io且ymHO
CIIHTalOT,
'JTOくero>
oTHocHTcH
He
K
BeJIIIKoMy
KHHMM,2KBeJIiIKoMyKHH310HBaHy.noHIIMaTbnOx《ero＞
⑥

BacIIJIIifI HeJIb3H, nocKOJIbKy oH B 3TQM nPeXJI9>KeHIM BbI･
U

EMAeT B KaqecTBe cy6beKTa, a He o6beKTa neiCTBIIHJpy
roii >Ke XeicTBoBaTeJIb He yKa3all; KPOMe TorO, CIgnyIOUlee
J

U

U

U

n〕
l eⅡJ10>KeHHe，r且ecy6b
' eKToMⅡeHcTBI畑HBJfl
I eTcHB
I'IaH，HaU

LⅡ冊iaeTcH c nPoTIIBIITeJIbIIOro COIO3a <a>, T e nelrTEHR
U

I/IBaHa
nPOTIIBOnOCTaBJIHIOTCH
nPe瓜UlecTBylO皿11M
XeHCTBIMFIM

BacwllIFI.

no MIIeIIIJIo rmBeJ1O3ePneBa (HHCTIMTyT PyCCKOrO
fI3bIKa AH CCCP), B paccMaTPPIBaeMoM TeKcTe pfrlb Mgg

>KeTImTIIKaKononblTKenPHMOronoKymeHHHBacHJIHH
imi er6 areHToB Ha )KII3Hb HBaHa lll, .TaK II o HaMePeIW

ime6TmeMynOpa>KeHme,H3BeCTIIHeB(bm31IIleCKQMLa"9-

6"O-noJIMTiIqeci<OMcMbICJIe(nPIIBToPOMBaPmaHTe XQIY-

cKaeTcH,ITocaMmBaHMOTHHeyIIacTBoBaTbBCPa>KeH皿)

fi5fiiOMrTEnePb
yTOwIHIiTB
BPeM"eIWa̲UaEWZ;

fl U ̅jlyjbe OTHo6IIT ̅ BbIQTymleHIIe WW"K ̲WMX
@Mmi 6.imBOi̅{HaqaBmeii6" Mae l500 r) : <Bce aTQ
⑤

四

⑥

⑫

npoHcxo且HJIoBPa3raPBoeHHblXノIeiiCTBIIiiKaKPa3BTOM

MEMi
M"incm
uegQWWMWW¥
Pa3MblmJIHfl O XaTeHnPmIIIIHax 6ercTBa BacIIJIIIH, eH4

回

U

HeJI
rOBOPlIT:
{《Ⅱa>Ke
,,7008''
ro及一CJIHmKoM
HeonPeZIeJIeH32' II. II. Cpe3HeBCKH竹．MaTePwaJIHnJIFICJIoBa"npeB¥PycCKorO

;i3Eitarf r brl5､ 1893, cTP i153; 2 4" h ,ToJIW::" "BWf

"MMeiiIM&f6f;' "",̅ ̅f' II Cn6-xM2 1" WRMi
《6ffM'o""6f,(j̅BenmKopyccKoro
cJIoBal)"
Cn6.,1852,cTP.76;
《且H";:;;E#"M:"6BMMfO BEmIKdPyCCKOrO Cjg"":EM
i"WE̅74; ̅PyKOmitHb,e KaPToTeKm ""JoWP¥ ll""M2"W
H3bIKa:
COCTaBJIeHHan
1)
no几PyKOBOJICTBQMP．r.BaPxyllaPoBa;

j｡｡"ail,dNMMJW646TEoM P H ABaHecoBo (IIHcTmTy｢
jyccKoro H3bIKa 4H CCCPI

322 HW""&66MB̅fl66cMoTpeHbI TaK)Ke cneUma""e ,246",

menpHBo皿Tc別MecTHbIecJIoBa
HMecTHble3Ha印eHI畑cJToB（Ⅱo6H6JIIIorpa巾""WmICKy,
cOneP)KauleMycH
B.KHmi
QnのⅥJIHH、
CJIoBapb
pyccKMx
IJapo皿IblX
TbBOPOB,
Bbln.
1.M.­J1.,
1965,cTp.
HI.IIIerO
IIaiiTI,I He yJIaJIOCb.

21-99)，o瓜HaKo
orJIaroJ1e《1ｲcTpaBHTH》HnIIero”､TⅢHeyxaJIocb，
323
H.C.JIypbe・nepBEIe皿eOJIOrW...,CTp.100.
151

¥M,naTa,
､IT96b!
e9̲¥2noJIb30BaTb,
m60
Me>KXy
ceHTH6peM
1 499 Ii CeHTH6peM 1 500 rr. npoII30mJIo TaK MibrO"""
⑪

co6blTHii-oT'Le3Ⅱ｣[B
POccIIIo1
3ananIHoPyCCKHx
KHH3eit,
⑥

U

U

cgKyJIHPH3aUIIfI " HOBIpPoncKOit UepKoBHoii cO6cTBeHHoCTII,

o6'bHBJIeHHeBoiHblJIIITBeHnon61TKIICTe巾aHaMo皿aBcKOrO coxPaHHTb MHP,- IITO HeBo3MO>KHO OUeHHTb HCTHH-

Hoe3HaqeHHePercTBaBacIIJIHH,He3HafITOqHo,KornaoHo
IIMeIIJDMegTo.BbIJIO̲JIIIOHOCBH3aHOCnePexOndMBeJibCKO⑥

ro,Mo>KaHcKoro HmeM”H[IaIHacTopoHy HBaHalll]？He
COWCIIJIIIcbJM3TIIKHH3bILnOcTynIITLHaPyccKyIOCJIy>K6y
ToJIbKo IIocJIe Toro, KaK BacⅢ皿揃 6blJI ,,BO3BPa皿eH" II3

BH3bMbl
HcHoBacTaJInoJIb30BaTbcHM”ocTblo|[oTⅡa]？He
EFmIIJI JIII Bac"" 6e>KaTb HaKaHyHe o6'LHBJIeHHRBoHHbl
⑪

加ITBeHanOnP6HeTOrO,̲KaK6PaTbfIHBaHalll,,OT'LexaJIHG:
""IIyHe｡BTOP>KeHIIHAxMaTa,BbI6PaBHaII60Jiee3aTPynU

I-IHTeJIbHblH且JIH BeJIHKoro KH”H MoMeHT？HaBce3THHMHo-

rHe nPyrlie BOnPOCbl HeJIb3fI, K CO>KaJIeHHIO, OTBeTIITb H3-3a
OTCyTCTBHFI TOIIHblX IIaHHblX)p 324

B npyroM MecTe cBoeii pa60Tbl eHHeJI 60JIee Bcero
U

cBH3blBaeT
6ercTBo
BacIIJIHR
c
ceKyJIFIpH3aⅡHeH
nePKOBHoひ

MM4cJbIpcKHx3eMeJIbBHoBroponle:<XoTHaTo|[M6ponpII-

Z"9
6bIJIO
PCymeCTBJIeHO
,,nO
6JIarOcJIOBeHIIIO
MIMTP6nOjiiiTa CIIMoHa!, oIHo MorJIo 6bITb HcToJIKoBaHo ecJIHMe ̅kaK

T"yMq)ePeT2qecKoinaPTyim,TO,nOKPaiiHeiiMePe,kaK
nOPa>KeHHe reHHa皿fl H HocH.a BoJIoHKoro, a kdcBeH-

Ho-Co,bH II BacllJIwl

Pe3yJIbTaTOMBCex3TIIXCO6blTHHRBIIJIocb...6ercTBoBaU

cHJIHR B I 500 r.> 325

Mbl
. 6blHecBH3LIBaJIHcToJIbonpeneJIeHHo6ercTBoBagiJIHH
C HoBrgPomcKoM CeKyJIHPH3a
CHJIHH
HoBrOPo瓜cKoHCeKyJIHPH3aⅡHeHⅡO
C
TPeM
nPHIIHHaM.
⑥

MepBbIx, Bac"" He 6LIJi y6c>K""M MMiiiM
⑪

U

fQlfPaHeHIIH UepKoBHo-MoHacTblpcKoii co6cTBeijHocTm 326,
xOTHBmaHHOMcJIyIIae,HaBePHOe,IIO旦旦eP>KHBaJIreHHanHH
K"CBOerP nOJIIITHIIecKorO cOIo3HHKa; BO-BTOPbIx, ZaTa HOBU

rOPO江CKoHceKyJ1HPH3auHHʻHe
yCTaHOBJIeHa
yBepeHHO：HH-

Bapb
l499
HJIHHHBapb
r.
l500r､327？B-TpeTbHx，H3HcToH324 J.Fenne11．Op. cit., p. 341.
325 1bid., p. 352.

326 B 1503 r. oll lToﾕﾕePl!<aJICeKy,JYHPH3aUllOHIIblemIaIIbIIIBaHalll

(10.
KBery!{oB.
4C"oBo
Mioe》­HOBOHaimeHHOe
nPOI,I3BeJIeHIIe

pyccKoiイny6"mUmgFIIKHXyj̲Lo6OPb6eMBaH3
111̅C̅55MEJiM6:

DP

nepKBH.­《Tpynbl
H'JeM
327B
HHKoHoBcKoH
JIeToⅢHcmII3BecTHe
OUp〃沙3''
M"QMWWii
3fo"M56";MIfP"
̲"QIJliclr
o63ToMⅢ”Be且eHo
ll32ebflie̅
､ ̅66BHyT”
cTaTbH 7007 r" Ho noc"e coo6meHIIH o Bo3"""̅Ebei6r"
152

HIIKoB Mo)KHo 3aKJIIoIIIITb, qTo HocJIe HHBapH 1500 r・B acHJ1Ⅲ尚eme B TeqeHme noBoJIbHO nPoXoJI>KIITeJIbHOro nePHona
BPeMeHII HaxoⅡHJIcH B MocKBe.
HocJIe H3BecTIIH oT 27 flHBapH 1500 r・nCKOBCKaH I JIeTOnHCb COO6皿aeT, qTO <TOH >Ke 31IMe》HBaH III npHCJIaJI B

ncKoB cBoero nocJIa c Tpe60BaHHeM HocTaBHTb Boopy>KeHHVIo cIIJIV IJIH HaMeIIaBmeiicH BoiiHbl c JIIMTBoえ《H ncKO-

BIIIIII!HeocJIymaJIIIcHBeJIHKHx
cHJIbeBIIIIa

H

BacHJIbH

KHFI3eii

HBaHa

HBaHoBHIIa...>328.

BaCJIe-

npBaTeJIbHo, e皿e B HHBaPe-巾eBpaJIe BacIIJI" coxpaHflJI
cBoH no3HUHm, Ho KpaiHeii Mepe ｡opMaJIbHo. Ho y>Ke K
o巾HnHaJIbHOMy OTKPblTIIIo BOeHHblx nleiiCTBIIii oH He HMeJI
oTHomeHIIH. B HoBroponcKoii ll JIeToⅡHcII noni 7008 r.
IIIITaeM :《nocblJIaJI

BHyK

erO

KHH3b

K'HFI3b

BeJIIIKII

BeJIHKH

HBaH

BacHJIbeBHII

IMHTPeii

II

HBaHO-

B H II b BoeBoXbl cBoII II KHH3II Ha BeJIHKoTo KHH3H AJIeKca:H-

npa JIIIToBcKOro…》329. nocblJIKa BoeBo瓜及aTHPyeTcFI B nPyTHx cBoXax 3 Mafl l500 r.330 B 9To BpeMH Ha cUeHeHⅡoHBJIHeTCH BHOBb nMIITPHii-BHyK.

I/ITaK, BacIIJIHii 6e>KaJI, oIIeB皿HO, HOCJIe巾eBPaJIH, HO
He no3JKe HaIIaJIa

MaH

1500 r.

1Orop'cKoii 3eMJIII B 7008 r.: "..､H nPHImOma Ha MOCKBy... JIeTa
7008, MapTa. Toro )Ke (?) JIeTa…HoIIMaJI KHH3b Be.JIIIKIIii... B HoBeropo几e B BeJIIIKoM UepKoBIIble 3eMJYPI 3a ce6fI…沙( nCP几T. XII!
cTp. 249)．B ApxHBcKoM 2-M cmHcKe ncKoBcKoii 3-# JIeTonHcHTo承e
H3BecmenoMe皿eHo B KoHIIe cTaTbH 7007 r., c yKa3aHIIeM MecHUa
､("reHBaPH>), HO nOCJIe COO6皿eHIIH o HapeIIeHHII BacHJIwI BeJ1IIKIIM

KHH3eM I[ oTnpaBKe BoeBont B IOropcKyIo 3eMJIIo (MaPT 1499 r.) II
nepen cTaTbeii 7008 r・o ITOCblJIKe BOGBOn B JIHTOBCKylO 3eMJ1IO (Maii
1 500 r. ) ; MoxCHo npmycTHTb, KITo 3nech IwMeeTcH B B皿y HI{hapb 7008
a He 7007 r. (cM. <IIcKoBcKHe JIeTomcIi》, BbIⅡ、11. noll pen. A､H. I-Ial

｡

coHoBa．M, 1955, cTp. 252) . B IIcTopIIIIecKoii JIIITepaType HeT o60cHOBaHHOrO oTBeTa l･Ia BOnPOc, KOma 6blJIa nPOII3BenleHa 3Ta CeKy.jlFIplf3a皿月.

H. C. JIypbe cHaqaJIa Ha3blBaJI I500

r.

(H.

A・Ka3aKoBa

II H. C. JI y p b e. yKa3. coII., cTp. 201) , 3aTeM 1499 r.(2. c. JIypbe.
IIneoJIomLIecKaH

6opb6a…,

cTp、244, 403),

H.

A・Ka3aKoBa

ll

A. H. KJII16aHoB yKa3blBaIoT 1500 r. (H. A. K a 3 a K o B a. Bopb6a
npoTIIB MoHacTbIPCKoro 3eM､meBJTaAeHIM IIa PycII B KoHUe XV -

Ha'IaJIe XVI B.­《E>Kero"IIIK My3efl HcToplIII pemfrlIII If aTeII3Ma)",
T. 11．M.­几, 1958, cTp. 157; A. II. K JI I1 6 a H o B, yKa3. coul., cTp.
224,225)，Ⅱ菰. eHHe" - 7008 r. (J. F e n n e l l. Op. cit., p，341)
II KoHeU l499 r､ibid., p 352) , A A. 3HMI1I.I - 1499 r. (A. A. 3 HM II H. OcHoBHble npo6JIeMbl…, CTp・103) .
328《ncKoBcKHeJIeTonHcH》, Bbln. 1, cTp. 84.
329 nCP几T. 30, cTp. 172.

330 TaM )Ke, T. VI, cTp. 45, 243; T. V111, cTp. 239; T. XII, cTp. 252; T. 20,
nePBa兄noJIoBMIHa, cTp. 371 ; T. 26, cTp. 293; T, 28, cTp. 333.
153

HaM Ka)KeTcH, ulTo BpeMFI 6ercTBa BacIIJIIIFI Mo>KHo e皿e

60JIbme yToIIHHTb. nocoJIbcTBo EHca A皿ePceHa (<Kamla-

Ha HBaHa)') npm6bIJIo B MocKBy B *eBpaJIe, a oT6hlno 2 3IIpeJIHl500r.,̅BMecTecpyccKIIMHocoJILcTBoMBnaHIIIo331.
CorJIacHo cKH6cKoii xpoHHKe, naTcKHe nocJIbl oT HMeHH Ko-

poJIFI XaHca cneJIaJIII I/IBaHy lll BecbMa o6Hanle>KIIBaIo皿ee
3aflBneHIIe oTHocIITeJIbHo IKeHHTb6bl BacIIJIIIFI

Ha nPHHUec-

ce EJIII3aBeTe m 6blJIII oTny皿eHbl C BeJIIIKOii IIeCTblO 332.
EcTecTBeHHo nPe,ⅡnoJIo>K1,1Tb, [ITo Bo BpeMH npe6blBaHHfl naTcKoTo HocoJIbcTBa B MocKBe, T. e. c巾eBPaJIFI nO

2 anPeJIH 1500 E, BacIIJII耐nPHcyTcTBOBaJI Ha UePeMOHIIHx
Hx nPHeMa lI B KaKoii-To MePe yqacTBoBaJI B nePerOBoPax c

HIIMII KaK 3aHHTepecoBaHHoe JIImo. CJIenoBaTeJIbHo, ero
6ercTBo MorJIo cocToFITbcFI, cKopee Bcero, Me>Kny 2 anpeJIfI
H IIaIIaJIoM MaH 1500 r.

BercTBo BacIIJIIIFI IIMGHHo B BFI3bMy o6'bFIcHFIeTcH, no-

BH且HMOMy, TeM, IITO 3TO 6blJI nOrPaHIIIIHblii rOPOn, HenaBHIM JIIIToBcK" yneJI 333, H, KpoMe Toro, Ha Bfl3bMy BacHJIPIi

HMeJI,

BO3MO)KHo,

KaKHe-To

BJIaneTeJIbHble

nPaBa.

B >KaJIoBaHHoi rpaMoTe lIBaHa lll l504 r.くOKOJIbHHIIeMy>
H

n.

CaTHHv

(o

cTeneHHnoIJ1IIHHoCTII

ee

TeKcTa

cM.

HII)Ke)06Pa皿aeTHace6FIBHIIMaHHeBblpa)KeHHe:<<BBH3Me, CBoeiO B e JI H K II x K H H 3 e i CJIHHKoBoIo cJIo60JoIo)p 334. 34ecb npocTynaeT HaMeK Ha coBMecTHoe ynpaBJIeHIIe BH3bMoih <<BeJIIIKIIx KHFI3eii)' (IIBaHa lll H BacIIJIIIH
HBaHOBHqa )．B HocoJIbcKHx KHHrax cHomeHHii c JIHTBoit e瓜mHCTBeHHoM

IICTOIIHIIKe

qacTo vnoMHHaeTcFI
咳

PyCCKOrO

nPOHcxO)KneHIIH,

BFI3bMa 90-x ronpB XV B., |HeT

rne

HIIKa-

KHx |HaMeKOB Ha cy皿eCTBOBaHIIe瓜BoiiHOro ynPaBJIeHHFI

3TIIM roponoM II ye3npM B 1494­HIoHe l499 rr. 335 CBene­
HI1i o BH3bMe 3a HIoJIb l499- HHBapb l501 rr. B HocoJIE-

CKHx KHIIraX BOO6皿e He IIMeeTcH 336. MoIKHo BblcKa3aTb no-

ra4Ky, qTo BacIiJIH曲6blJI npHo6皿eH K ynpaBJIeHIIIo Bfl3b331 nCPJI, T. VI, cTP. 44,243; T. VIII, cTp､238; T. XII, cTp. 250; T. 20､
nepBaHⅡoHoBI,IHa, cTp. 369; T. 28, cTp. 332-333.
332 <Monumenta HistoriaG Daniae>, 1, s、22, 409; LEKUB, 2-te Abt.、
Bd. l, S. 623, Anm. 2.

333 H. C、．Ⅱypbe、nePBb'e ll,meOJIOrll…, cTp. lOOI J. Fennell・Op.
cit., p. 341.
334 ACSII, T. II1, JVb 186.

335 <<C6．PHO>, T. 35, cTp･152, 153, '155, 194, 199, 229, 231, 257, 259,
260,263,264,276,278.

336 0HH HOHBn列IOTCFI C *eBPanHl501 1,. ("C6．PHO>, T. 35, cTp. 325
1' mp.) .
1 “

Moih B KoHUe lIIoJIH - aBrycTe l499 r. B cBH31I c HoJIyqeHIIU

U

eMnPaBHaHoBropo瓜HBUeJIHXHarJI只只HOH且eMOHcTPan,HIM
BeJIIIKoMV
．KHfl310 JIIIToBcKoMy noJIHoro HoJIIITHqecKoro e且Ⅲ-

HO,nymIIH BHyTPH MOCKOBCKOrO BeJIHKOKHmKecKOrO Ceu

MeHCTBa・

K

BH3bMe

oTHocHTcFI

eUe

nBa

H3BecTIIH

JIeTonIIcIIblx

HcTo[IIIIMKoB: 1 ) HBaH III nocJIaJI K AJIeKca皿Py c Pa3MeTHoii rpaMoTo#<<A1｡aHaca meeHLKa B H 3 M e T " a)'(>I〈ⅢTeJIHBR3bMbl)337;2)corJIacHocB皿eTeJIbcTByyCTIO]KcKorO
⑪

哩

JIeTOHIIcHOrO cBOna,くKHFI3b BeJIIIKⅢHJIHToBcK" AJIeKcaH"
nocJIaJIpaTbKBH3Me>>338.

nePBOeH3BeCTIIenaeTKaK6ynlTO
OCgOBaHI畑及yMaTb,

IITo HbaH III 3HaJI o 6ercTBe BacHJIIIH B BH3bMy: nocJIaB c
Pa3MeTHOII KJIHTOBCKOMyBeJIHKoMyKHH310<BH3MeTHHa》,oH，
U

bo3Mo]KHo,xoTeJInoKagaTb,qToBH3bMaBepHaeMy,̲ZBa-

Hy,HIIToJIHTBeHeKIeropaccIIIITEIBaTbHaoTnameHHeBH3bMbl oT MocKBbl.

BTopoe H3BecTIIe eme 60JIee mHTepecHo, Ho Hy)KnaeTcH B
⑥

U

TmaTeJIbHOHHcToqHIIKoBen[IecKoHⅡP OBePKe.
eii JIIITePaTyPeHeT
HeTy瓜oBJIeTBopHTeJIbHoro
ynoBJIeTBoPllTe,JIbHoro
Bcy皿ecTByIo皿eHJIHTepaType
aHaJIH3a BOeHHblx
aHaJIH3a
BOeHHblx瓜ehCTBHH
XeMCTBIm PyCCKOii
PyCCKOHHJIKTOBCKOHapMHHB
II JIIITOBCKOII apM
U

U

U

1 5 0 0 r. n o K a 3 a l l l 畑 》 Ke H c To I I H I I Ko B I o B O J I b H O n P O T I I B O P e I I H -

Bbl. O6mylo KaPTIIHy PacCTaHOBKII PyCcKHX cIIJI naJI reP6epmTeili. CorJiacHO ero pmlcaHIII9, nepBbIii oTpflg. 6bLII HanpaBJIeH Ha Ior npoTIIB C&BepcKQi 3eMIIII, BToppii Ha 3aIIa1-npoTIIB Topo皿a H BeJIbl (BeJIOrO), TPeTIii HaXO皿J1ひ

U

轡

cHHocpe皿HeII6blJIo6Pa皿eHnpoTIIBnopoTo6y>KaHCMoJIeHCKa 339.
一

BOJIbmIIHCTBo JIeTOnHCIIblX CBOIOB
u

IlaqHHaeT C CoOO皿e-

･
U

HHH O XeHcTBHHx Io>KHoH rpyⅡnbl BoII'cK nOn KOMaHIOBaHIieM
U

BoeBoXbl HKoBa 3axapbHIIa, KoTopblH瓜BIIHyJIcH H3 MocKBIDI
｡

3 MaH, B3flJI BpHHcK, 3aTeM Ho xoXy "JIbHeZUleJp pPo"W◎

>KeH"npmBeJfK nplicHre ceB|epcKIIx IQHH3ei lC. K Mox"-

cKoro II B H. meMHIIHqa) II 6 aBrycTa l500 r. 3aHHJI nyTHBJIb、3aTeM roBopHTcH o XeiicTBwIx BoiicK UeHTpaJIbHoro
u

HanpaBJIeHHH HoI KoMaHIoBaHHeM IOp" 3axapb"aLJoc-

JIaHiloro HBaHoM III J<ToFI >Ke BecHBI)P K noporo6y>Ky. nocJIe
nCP几T､1V, I1. 1, Bbln､2, cTp､532; T. VI, cTp. 45, 243; T. V1II,

句
qu T,
哩

cTp. 239; T. XII, cTp. 252; T. 20, nePBaFI HoJIoBHHa,cTp 370; T. 26,
cTp. 293; T. 28, cTp. 333.

３３
８
９
３３

《ycTIo>KcKIIii JIeTOITIIcHIJIii cBo", cTI)101.

C. reP6ep皿T̅e ii H. 3anIMcKII o MocKoBMTcKIIx neJIax. BBenelIife.
nePeBO且HnpMMeilaHI,IFI A．H. Ma,Ⅲ“Ha．Cn6., 1908, cTp. 13-14.
­

叩

155

三

3axBaTa lOpHeM noporo6y>Ka BeJII1KIIii KHH3b JIPIToBcK"
nOcJIaJI nPoTIIB Hero 60JIb皿oe BOiiCKO BO rJIaBe C BOeBOn(a-

MIIKHH3eMKoHcTaHTHHoMOgTpo>KoKIIM,naHoMrpIIropBeM

OcTIoKoBIIIIeM,MapmaJIKoMJIIiToBapoM.'HBaHIIiB
6BOIo
oIIepenb oTUaB" Ha noMomb lOpIIIo 60HpHHa maHIIJIa Ba-

C"beBIilla皿eHIO
<CO
TBePCKOIO
CHJI0I0》・PyccKHe
H皿TOB-

cKHe BoIIcKa comJIHcb l4 HIoJIH 1 500 r. <<Ha MHTKoBe noJIe

HapeIIKeHaBenipomlI)",rnepyccKHeoXep>KaJIIIno6enyII
B3H" B nJIeH Ha3BaHHblx JIHToBcKHx BoeBont 340.

THnorpa巾cKaHJIeTonHcbHBJIanmMHpcKII#JIeToHHceU
ⅡoⅡOnHHTeJIbHO yKa3blBalOT B IO>KHOii rPyⅡⅡe BOiiCK OCO6blii
OTpH旦non ifoMaHJ(oBaHHeM cJIy>Ke6Horo TaTapcKoro xa'Ha

MyxaMMen-3MIIHa
mnomIIHeImbIxeMyBoeB6瓜①enopalI
HBaHa naJIeUKIIx (rep6epmTeiiH omli66qHo cIIIITaJI Mvi<3M-

lie,n-3MHHa
HatIaJIbHHKOMBCei
lo>KHOii
rPynnbl
BOiiCK341).
B tlIIcJIe B3HTbIx Ha [ore roponoB3TH JIeT6nHcHHa3blBaIoT,
KpoMe BpHHcKa lI nyTIIBJIH, noqan, Panorom, JIIo6en. HaA
KOHeU, 3Xecb naeTCFI 60JIee nOJIHbl面ⅡePeIIeHb JIIITOBCKHx
BeJIbMO>K, nonaBmHx B mleH npH Benpome342.

BoJIoroncKo-nepMcKaH JIeTomicb ilpll6aBJIHeTII3BecTIIe

o KoJIH[IecTBe f<y61ieHblx JIHTBbl H JIHxoB)P H o B3HTHH r. Topo皿a (6e3 XaTbl) 343

Oco6HHKoMcToIIT60JIbmaHcTaTbFIEpMoJIHHcKoiiJIeTo-

nHcH, rnie IIHTaeM: <B JIeTo 7008・BblCTら60ii C JIHTBOIO Be-

JIHKgro KHH3H HBaHa Bac"beBHIIa BoeBonaM, KHfl3Io UaHII-

JIy Bac皿もeB IIIIy皿eHfITH, na lOpblo 3axapbHIIy,ⅡaKH”Io
IJeTpy Bac"""qIo O60JIeHcKOMy, na kHfI3io MmxaIIJIy

のeon;opoBmqIo
MIIKyJIHHgKoMy,
KHH310
Hocmby
noPoro6y>KcKoMy, KIIH310 eonppy BacHJIbeBHIIIo TeJTenHIo O60JIeH6KoMy II HHblM MHOMM BOeBOnaM, a C HHMH 6blJIH KHH31I II 60fl-

pe II neTII 60HpcKHe H3 MocKoBcKIia 3eMJIII H H3 T｡epcKIIa,
c BeJIHKoro KHH3H JIIIToBcKaro AJIeKcaHnpa BoeBonaMH,

g KHR3eM KoHcTHHTHHoM HBaoBHqeM c OcTpoUKﾙ1M,，np3

EpHropbeMEBcTHKyBIIqeM,"cIOpbeM3IIHoBbeBIIqeM,nac
JIIoToPOM II c HHeMH MHoTIIMH BOeEOXaMH, H BeJIHKOrd K"3H IBQp H3 BHJIHbl ll H3 noIoJIIIa H II3 BoJIblHcKHe 3eMJIH,
a H3 CMoJIeHcKa BoeBona HII CTaHHcJIaB, a c HIIM MIIor"
340 nCPJT, T、IV, q. 1, BbIn. 2, cTI). 533; T V1, cTp 45-46, 243; T. V111,
CTp、239-240; T. XII, cTp. 252; T. 20, nepBfif! no"oBIIHa, cTP 37I;
n 22, [1. lL cTI). 514; T. 26, cTp. 293; T､ '8, crp 333-334;. C. O
mMmⅡT・yKa3. coII., cTI). 273-274.

341 C.rep6el)IIITeiiH・yKa3. coII., CTI). 214.
242 ECPJI, T. 24, cTp. 214; T. 30, cTp. 139.
343 TaM >Ke, T. 26, cTp. 294.
156

BOeBOnbl II BCm CMOJIHflHe JIyIImmeJIIo且Ⅲ, Ha peUe Ha noJIMe>,,瓜aJIee roBOPllTcH O HO6ene PyCCKOFO BOiiCKa, nJIeHeHHH
<<60JImHX BOeBO瓜》ⅢT. X.

HOcJIe aTOro JIeTOHIIceU O6PamaeTCH K co6blTIuIM, npo-

IiC皿e且mHM <<Torna )KG HanePeX)", H IaeT IIaII60JIee no,UPo6Hbli, OTCyTCTBylO皿嘘B npyrlIX JIeTOHHcHblx cBOnax PaCcKa3

0 neiiCTBHHx IO)KHOi rPyⅡⅡbl BothcK HoX KoMaHnpBallIIeM MyXaMMen-3MIIHa H HKoBa 3axapbIIIIa. 3aTeMHⅡeT CTOJIb )Ke

yHIIKaJIbHOenOcBeXeHHHMH3BeCTmeOB3HTIIIInOPOrO6y)Ka:
<Toro >Ke JIeTa KHH3b BeJIHKHii nocblJIaJI cBoHx BoeBont lOpba

3axapblIIIa, KHH3FI neTpa BacIIJIbeBHIIa O60JIeHcKoro,̲KHH3H "Jppa BacIIJIbeBIIIIa TeJIenHH, KHH3H MBaHa nepeMblmJIbcKaro na HBaHa mappy c MHorllMII JIIonMH Ha rpaX

noPoro6y)Kb. OHII )Keme瓜me, rpa瓜旦oPOrO6y)Kb B3Hma H
.JIIoXeii BCex loPOrO6y氷ueB K IleJIOBaHblO 111)11BenPma 3a BeJ I H KO r O

KHH3H＞、

3aKaHIIMBaeTcH

Bce

aTo

onlicaHIie

BoeHHoii

anoneII

l500 r. paccKa30M o B3HTIIH Toponna 344.
B cepenIIHe cTaTbH 7008 r・EpMoJIIIHcKoi JIeToHIIcII HapymeHa xpoHoJIorHH co6bIT", B rleM npH3HaeTcJI H caM JrTo-

ⅢHceU,ynoTpe6JIHHBblpa)KeHHef<Torna)KeHanepe及》.B3HTHe noporo6y>Ka npoII30mJIo, no Bceih B皿IIMOCTH, PaHbme

6HTBblHap.noJIMe.CpaBHHMnpHBeXeHHbliBEpMoJIHHcKoii
JIeTOnHCH COCTaB PyCCKHx |BOeBOX, yllacTBOBaBmIIX Bo B3HTIIII

moporo6y)Ka lI B 6IITBe Ha noJIMe.
B o e Boxbl
B 6HTBe IIa P. noJIMe

npH B3HTIIH noporo6y>Ka
I

naHIIJIa BacHJIbeBIIII meHFI

IOpHii 3axap"q

IOpHii 3 a xapbIItI

neTp
BacHJIbeBHq
O60JIeHcKIIii

neTp BacIIJIbeBIIq O60JIeHcKHii
MHXaWI emPPOBWI MHKyJIHHCKHii
Hoc" noporo6y]KcKIIii
①epppBacHJIbeBH[ITeJIeneHbO60JIGH-

①eXop BacIIJIbeBIIq TeJIeneHb

U

C K H H

HBaHnePeMblmJIbCKHii
HBaH manpa
u

Mbl 3HaeM I13 60JIbmlIHcTBa npymx JIeTonIIceii, [ITo naH.

Bac. meHH npH6blJI Ha noMo皿b lOpHIo 3axapblIIIy nocJIe
B3RTIIH HOCJIe皿IIM noporo6y)Ka, Koma cTaJIo II3BecTHo, IITo
344 nCPJI, T. 23, cTp. 196-197
157

K noporo6y>Ky mleT JIHToBcKoe BoiicKo Bo rJIaBe c KHfl3GM

K. II. OcTpo)KcKIIM. TaKIIM o6pa30M, xpoHoJIorlITIecKoe cooTHomellMe B3FITwI noporo6y>Ka m 6HTBbl 'Ha p. ;noJIMe cTaIIoBHTcH BnoJIlle HcIIblM: noporo6y)K 6blJI B3HT Io yKa3aIIHOii 6HTBbl.

CoMHeHIIe Bbl3blBaeT To MecTo paccKa3a EpMoJIIIHcKoit
JIeToHIIcII, rXe omIcblBaeTcH IIcxonl 6IITBbl Ha p. noJIMe: |nJIeHeHHe JIHTOBcKHx <60JImIIx BoeBo且》H nPlIBO瓜HX B MOCKBy.

B KaIIecTBe 60JIbml'Ix BoeBon, yllacTBoBaBmHx B 3ToM cpa>KeHHH, B EpMoJIIIHcKoii JIeTomicH paHee lla3BaHbl K. H. OcT-

po>KcKIIii, r,pHropmii EBcTI,IKyBMII H mp. B pFme JIeTonHcHblx
CBOIoB, KaK y>Ke rOBOPlIJIocb, COO6皿aeTCH, IITO OHI1 6blJIII
B3HTbI B nJIeH nocJIe pa3rpoMa JIIIToBcKIIx BoiicK Ha p. Beユー
po皿e、BcTaeT BoⅡpoc：noJIMa HJIH Be且poma？
Eme 60JIbme 3anVTblBaeT neJIo

II3BecTHe

ycTIo>KcKoro

JI eTOnHcHoro cBona. nonl 7009 r. "ecb paccKa3aHo:《KHH3b

BeJIHKIIih JIIIToBcKIIit AJIeKcaHnp HocJIaJI paTb K BH3Me: Boe･
BoJy KocTellTHHa HBaHoBHIIH OcTpo)KcKoro, a c HIIM MHoro
U

KHH3eHJIHTOBCKHxⅡⅡaHOB cJIy>KHBblx, a C HIIMH CIIJIbl MHo-

rO)>; y3HaB O6 3TOM, HBaH III nOcJIaJI《ⅡPOTIIBy erO> BOeBO瓜y naHIIJIa BacIIJIbeBIILIa (皿eHIo) , 06a BoiicKa com皿Icb y
p. TpocHbl《HcTOHma MHOro XHH>, nOCJIe IIero nPoH30mJIO
一

KPoBOnPOJIHTIIOe

CPa)KeHIIe,

｡JIIITOBUbl

Oe>KaJIH,

KHH3b

K. m. OcTpo)KcK嘘Ⅱ叩yrIIe BOeBOnbl 6blJIH B3HTbI B nJIeH.
B ycTIozKcKoM cBoXe npllBoIHTcH yHIIKaJIbHbIe cBeXeHHH o
xoXe 6HTBbl II no3JHeimeM conep>KaHIIII B HJIeHy JIIIToBcKIIx
BOeBOX 345.

KoHeIIHo, naTa aToro H3BecTIIH - 7009 r.- HenpaBHJIbHaH, H60 y>Ke nocJIe l4 IIIoJIH 1500 r. (6HTBa nplI Benpome)
K. H. OcTpo>KcK" Haxo,nllIJIcH B pyccKoM nJIeHy. 3HaIIHT,

cpa)KeHHe Ha TpocHe HMeJIo MecTo B 7008 ( 1500) r・yCTIO)K cK" JIeTonHcHLIii cBoX Boo6me oTJIHIIaeTCH HecKOJIbKo cMe-

meHHoii xpoHoJIorIIeit B H3BecTIIHx KoHUa XV B.
OniHaKo cyTb neJIa cocToHT He B XaTe, a B HoHBJIeHIIH
eme OnHOii 61ITBbl, Pe3yJIbTaTOM KOTOPOii 6blJIO mleHeIIHe
K H. OcTpo)KcKoro,- 61ITBbl Ha TpocIIe. CKoJIbKo pa3 Mor
3TOT BoeBOna nonanaTb BnneH, OTnPaBJIHTbcH B 3aTOqeHHe

B rJIyxIIe PaiiOHbl CeBePHOii PoccHHHcHOBa yIIacTBOBaTb B
6HTBax？OnHTb-TaKH BcTaeTBonpoc：TpocHa HJIH BeⅡpoma？
O6paTHMcH K Pa3pfmHDIM KHIIraM. B KpaTKoit pe,naKUIM
Pa3"XHblx KHHr 3aIIHcH o pyCcKO-JIIITOB|CKOii BOihHe HaIIIIHa345 KyCTIO)KCKIIii JIeTO皿lCHblii CBO1》, CTp. 101.
158

IoTcH noX 7008 n c pa3p"a BQjicK c"epo･3ana""̲"
U

nPaBJIeHIIH
(BOeBQ八iJ1"
",mOP
m
mBaH
BQPlICOBmqm
EOJIoU-

HOBrOPOncKHHHaMecTHIIK
Kme,
AHXpeh①enoPOBIIII
qeJIJmHHHm叩.)
3aTeM皿eT
;
Pa3P皿EOiCK
]O)KHOrO
｡POHTa
U

U

"BBMik｡53axapbiiq,ilBakMMx"9WR"｡H且p.),
U

HocJIe
qero
pacnHCaIi
co6TaB
BOiiCK
UeHTPaJIbHOrO
bPOHTa
U

(55ggomlOpmii3axaPbm,HB"W4叩aBeJIbflMHHoB

m叩rCJIe",oma3 3aiy,cb rJIacmT:̲ "lp r̲FMpgM

JIaJIKHH3bBeJIHKHHBJIIIToBcKylo3eMJIIoKHH"CeMeHa
⑪

HBaHoBHIIa
CTapoIy6cKoI､o
na
k"3H
BacIIJIbFI
HBaHoBHIIa
meMHIIHHa,
na
HIIM
c BoeBoI
cBoIIx,
KHfl3兜naHHJIa
BacHJIb""irigMjrE M" 3aXapb""" mHLDi BoeBolk m̲ 9"
XO瓜HXli̅ff6cn6BJIIoIIKEJIbie,II60iizM6blJIHaBempomKe> 346.

U

yKa3aHHoM
B
MJIeepa3p"eBoiicK,JWTBgW皿HXB

BemPoiiMf6iiTBe;HeT,bXliaKo,IIMeWIW2̲3WPWh
IM"̅EK Ii3BcCTHQIBoeBaJI IIa lQ" "̲¥IWWW
iMfEJib:BPa3pzmHoiiKHmremMegTSM3WW9S""R:
⑪

U

IlaHKe:《amHbleBoeBOIble皿eHecomJIIIcFI)D347.PyccKHeJIeTonⅢMMMq5IOf yfIacT" HKoBa 3axapbIIqa B BenponlcKOM CPa>KeHIIH.

Bpa3p"HoiiKHIIrenpocTpaHHoipen"mmnoX7007r.
roBoplITcFI:
<<Toro
>¥e
rony
xo瓜HJIII
BOeBoXbl
JIHTOBcKylo
B
U

U

3eM皿; M K6MI XjieK6"" JImToBcKor9;THKoB 3"WL-

願;II30TBepiiK"3bnaHIIJIoPac皿beBHII皿eHH,aII3Ho-

曲①eⅡopoBH〔IIIeJIHⅡHʻ､H，H30ncKoBaKHH3b
Baropona
X:MMWmMp6"[I PocToB"oii, m ̲" ｣IWf "",,@
U

MMMMI̅JMEMM Iia PeKeHa nOJIMeHe B T̲ImH-

;WWWm¥M;Mi n5"61̅Jw･BcKmx n9W""

MMdimmiEke
349
BMecTq.c""oJIMeHe
TmmmHoBo》
l
IIIIT"M <noJIMe Ha noJIe B TH皿HoBe》･

く7007>
roXHacHenPJIIKeH
cMy皿aTb,
1160,BO-nePBblx,
XaJIbmeⅡOMeM
>Ke
ronOM
PaCCKa3PIBaeTcH
oTJePexQgg
H2

MM"W"m "3ei MQ"cgoI9̲UWWM
5f6̅iiP6II3omJIo i 7008 r" Bo-BTopblx, B EgEW､9 :W:-

HHHIja
noJIMe
EpMo皿IHCKaJI
JIeTonHcb
yKa3blBaeT
7008
r.
Mo̅.EOET"
3aTo
cocTaBBoeBoⅡ，ⅡepeIIHcJIeHHHx
BOedOn, nePeIIHcJIeHHbIX BPa3”ⅡHoHKHHre，
Pa3pHMOII KHKre,

ー

3464<Pa3pFIZIHaflKHIIra..LZJcTp.30,J1.2906.
347 TaM )Ke, cTp. 31, JI. 30.
348 rnB, 3pMIIT. 390, JI.20.

349
rlIM'皿yf"̅im,b3y,oCo
CJIyqaeM
Eb,P"r̲̲､q､marOnaPHOC'r1コ
E¥if' EyMibBf
UPenoCT3BUPuleMy̲ RM9"a""""MWW:
ひ
FMM"ETHy6XIIRMImpa3pmiHoiiKHmrilnpocTpaHHoiipemaK、

皿畑ノ
159

〃

Bbl3blBaeT60JIbmHecoMHeH".3八eCb巾IfryPHPylOTKoMaH⑪

XyIo皿H'e BOIICKaMH Bcex PPOHTOB - 'ceBePO-3an"|HOrO,
UeHTpaJYbHoro H Io)KHoro, xoTH (PaKT IIx o6'be皿HeH”He

ⅡORKQenJIHeTCH XPyrIIMH IIcTOKIHIIKaMII (JII皿b HoBroponL-

cKaflllJIeTOⅡHCbCOJeP>KHTaHaJIOrIIIIHOeH3BecTHe,oTHocH
cpa)KeHIieK̲paiioHX̲CMoJIeHcKa350).BoJIeenpcToBepHo,
U

3HaIIHT, coO6meHIIe EpMoJIHHcKoii JIeTonHcH, Ha3blBalomeii
yIIacTHHKaMII CPa]KeHIIH Ha llOJIMe BoeBO瓜皿eHTP aJIbHOrO
U

U

(nppoIo6y)KcKoro) lJanpaBJIeHHH. B To )Ke BpeMH h npocT･
U

U

PaljHOii Pe"""H Pa3PH"IOii KHIIM, HaP"y c H3BeCTHeM

o61irBe!HaHoJIMe,IIMeeTcHH3BecTHeo6iITBEHaBenipome.
B xpoHIIKe BblxoBUa yKa3blBaeTcJI, tITo BeJIHKHit ikHH3b
U

AJIeK:caH叩no|cJIaJIK.H・OcTpo>KcKoroHJIpyrlIxKCMoJIeHCKy nOCJIe nOJIyIIeHHH H3BeCTHH O B3HTHmBpHHcKa BoiicKaMH
･

2KoBa"3axapb"4̲mnepexQ4eHapyccKyl6cJIy>K6yKHH3eii
Mo)KaiicKoroHmeMHIIIIqa351.BCMoJIeHcKnPmmaBecTb,
”

｡

6ymoIQpmii3axapbIIqcToMTHaBenpomec6qeHbHe60JIb｣
BoiicKoM. To
、HM BoHcKoM・Toma
K.II.OcTpo)KcKHii,Ⅱ(BIIHyJICH B HanPaBJIeH皿Ⅱoporo6y>Ka,
Ho，OIIGB皿HO,
>KeJIaH
nPHcTynHTb
mHM

⑪

K HeMy c Iora, ocTaHoBHJIcH B E､ﾉIbHe. noiiMaHHblii JIHTo|BUaU

MH H3blKL̲JIO HMeHH rePMaH, cOo6mHJI, IITo M HemaBHero

BpeMeHIIIOpHii3axapbIIIIpacHoJIaraJIHe60JIbmHMBOiiCKOM,
<treteho Ze dnialb (<TPeTbHTo >Ke mH") K HeMy Ha noMomb
npHmJIH ,mpyrHe 6oJIbmHe

BoeBqmbl-瓜aH.

Bac.皿eHHm

IIB.
MIIx.
nepeMblmJIbCKHii・JIIIIQBCKme
BoeBonlbI
He
noBePll-

JIH JI3bl¥y li PemHJIH naTb 60ii, nPOit" niePeBHIO JIonaTIiHo
⑥

H He nOHⅡ月旦Be MHJIH np XepeBHII BempomH, oHH V3HaJIIJ, IITo

pyccKHe oWAalQT Hx Ha Benpome (naJIee cJIeXyET omlcaHIIe

gpa)Ke"H) 3¥ AHaJIormwniLIe cBeneHIifrcone"aTcHFM
U

IIIIKaxPTPbIiiKoBCKOrQHBeJIbcKOro,ToJIbkO"BHIIXBMe6TO

IPpmH3axapbIIIJanoomH6Ke｡HrypHpyeTBoBcexcJIyIIaHx
HKoB3axapbH11353.

｡

TaK9BH3BecTHpIiiHaMKpyrHcToIIHIIKoB,xapaKTepII3ylo⑫

U

m""eHcTBHH BoIIcK mpporo6y>KcKoTo HanpaBJIeH"

fLIIHBbIHcHeH"BonPoca6noJIMe,Tp6cHeii̅BEnpome

neo6xomiMonpencTaBHTbce6emxpaclioJIb>KenneHa""
350 nCP几T. 30, cTp. 172-173.

351
TaM
>Ke、T.
XVII,
cT6.
558;《.XpoHIIKa
̲BblxoBU".
npenHCJIOBIIe,
KOMMeHTaPH}IルInepeBonH.H・yJIa皿HKa.M.,1966,cTp.111.

W IWH!;̲T. l<Y(I, cTP; 559-560; "POn"FEiWfia"TP l 1 1-1 13

353353
<Kronika
polska,
litewska、Zm6dzka
wszystki61Rusi，Macieja
i
2tryi*9wskiegOlj i lI. W-wa, str. 309-=3167.."roiiiE' MX"
Bielskiego>, t、1I. Sanok, 1856, str. 907-908.
160

Bo MHorHx cIIpaBoqHHKax Benpo皿y Ha3bIBaIoT̲'"ToK9M

nHenPa,
Bna"IO皿HMBHerO6皿3
noporo6y)Ka
354.
HamO9-

JIee
nPOBePeHHble八aHHbIe
HaXO且mM
yH.H.yJIa皿HKa
355.

且eiicTBHTeJIbHO,
IOrO-3aina皿ee
AJIeKcIIHa
acnoJIo)KeH
p
a

"eP.eEHH
JIOnaTHHO
0qeBH八HO,
356,
TO)K,meCTBeHHafl
JIonaTH四

iiyWiOMfIHyTOMyBXPOnmKaXBbIXOP"gW"9BWMI
V

EaISCkoro. ･Me"y JTonaTIIHoM H AJIeKcIIHoM no npJMW

56MEIMM, aXopora MorJIa 3aHHMaTb H oKoJIo 19"

MMIMEfMfika3aHIilo xpoHIIK o ToM, qT9 ･T JWZ
MaX5 ne" B"pomII 2 MIimi nyTK JIecoMWWWW

iiiijirWrER paB"jiacb 5 JIHToBcKKM IIJIm 7,28 pyccKIIM
BePcTaM357).

ggfoH6MIIIIecKHxnpHMerlaHIIHxmaTJIacaxrelrpaJI"Qro ireIMam ̅ "eIoTdI npHMbl& nqKa3"" q､BenpolIIg

4<AJIeKcHHo
l)
Be八pomm
Tb)K)>3･8;
2)
4<CeJIb[
rpolLo"̲"
BeXpomHcce皿oM̅(AJIeKcIIHbIM)
3八ePeBHHMII)'.
ceJIe
B
(nofocTe)
Be4ppUIII
IIMeJIacb
,ntepe.""兇且epKoBb
reoprIIfI
fiMI6IM5"TibcrpoeHH",bcPoHTHO,BqecTb̲Be八pom6MH685m a" ndrocT 6bmjI WaHmqSn c ceBe" pW④

Heih,c3anana-BnanalO皿HMBCeJIHIo6e3blMHHHblMpyqbU

eM,
KOTOPblH
CJIenyeT
QTo班瓜ecTBHTb
peIIKoii
c BeAp9me此
U

HeCKoJIbKO
BocToIIHeeBenpO皿H
CeJIHH
Bna,ⅡaeTBPOcHy

MW;̅a̅qyTb",KHeWCTbZ""rR̲29W36Fn:八aeT
fioym
iIpoTekalomaH
'
B6"3m
morocTa
Bg,ⅡPo皿Ⅲ360.
BIIJIII-

MO,
POCHa­《TpocHa>
ycTIo>KcKor9
､neTonIIcHorq､̲229-

，Ⅱ､a361ゥnoJIHa-n6JiMa
EpMoJIIIHcKoiiJIeTonlicm
npocTm
｡

aKILIIH
Pa3pHplHOH KHIIr
PaHHolIPe八aKIlHH
Pa3”且HOHKHHrH．
｡

nCPJI砂，oT八．11．C、6.,1907,
"9:ulWWnWyKa3aTeJIb
ocbMlI
354""fib"̅EXIV;JTopaaJI･"",
CTP、⑪
27KnepBblM
；nCPJ1，T・
"̲W
XV
l ，BTopaHnoJo
I BmHa，cTp･8
ʼ 2；《SHUK
I 』oⅡe皿IuecK皿"MA hX 'EMzy3a " z A"9QII",｣0,｡W､ ZQM

BCS,H3nl.2-e,T、7;̅cfn5;̅'6M.">KQ̲g..HC"st,B"anad

Wiedrosza
l500
roku・一KWieki
Srednie>.
W-wa,
1962,
str、280.
356
46fe"aJIbHafI
KapTa
EBponeiic¥oii.
Pgpcm",
.n．44．Cn6.,
1912.
357 <SH皿KJIone八四66" ""pb ･ A. BpoKray3a m m. A. E｡PoH",
355 4XP6"KaEblxoBU", "｣37: nplIM2EE
⑭

｡

37, cTp. 324.

358urAnA,*.1355,JYh1483,".1*.;1356,CMoJIeHgl<afIry6.,Nh35)

eKcHHo
HaJIeBoM（ceBepHoM）6epery
0.Ho
91.
37af=iia
(loxfHOMli
cM.
CeJIHH，a
Be江po6#aBoM（lo謎HCM)；CM・cH､360．
1499&
"@
HM̅X:
35,
359T
"npaBbM
JIMP
5
aM>K
od:
;""5:Wi",
Ze，巾．1355,
̅j
N､1479,皿.7o6., 63；Nb1480,皿.50o6.5206.,､̅63;JYb1482,"．706．­8,̅963;JVbl485!J．7,
963;

Mi496,.JI.6/H,963;CpJYhl461,狐狐.i806.-1906.,563(110).

360TAMik6;*:1356,bMojigilcKaHrYO.,jWh33,34.

36【且J1兄丞HXJf̅6e"6JB6bTOx,H6iiEyCm
"m,CaHme,"92"2
WO
aiJiee
npHBblqntJM,
̅IIeM
<PocH2》・"Iika
TpocTbHa
(I"pmafI,
TPo
･
EEM,WEJi5EE̅'B̅paiiomePy3bl-3Beliliropo,ma
(蝋yKa3aTeJIb
K

1 1

C. M.

KamTalIoB

161

BepoHTHo,
roToBflcb
K
BcTpeIIe
c
JIHToBUaMH,
pyccKHe

BoeBoⅡbl
BoeBo"I
BbIcJIaJIH
BbIcJIaJIH［IacTb
IIaCTb BojicK
BoHcK3a
3a p・Be八POmy,
p. Be
B HanPaBJIeHⅢHK 3anaXy oT BenpomH, oCHOBHble )Ke CIIJIbl 6blJIH
▲

gKQHMFH'rplipoBaHbl,no-BMIIMoMy,BocToqHeepeKIIBenpo-

mm: QJcTyn""lie nepenpBoro ofP"a pyccK" " Bo&6qE" 6eper Bempomm "npIIBeJId K 6ibmHoii [lepen"Be
U

Ty,瓜A >Ke JIIIToBcKoro BoIIcKa, II 60it 6blJI npojPmKeH 362.

CpaBHIIM "JIee TeKcTbI xpoHHKm BbIxoB" ilycTIo>KcKo-

ro JIeTOHIIcHOro cBOAa.

ʼ

XpoHHKa BbIxoBUa

y c T l o J Kc K H i i c B o x

KMOCKBH[MH XyMaJIH, IITO JIHTOBUm
｡

HXyT Ha HHX H3 ,JIeCa C 60JIbmOii CHJIOHHUTo OHH TaK CMeJIOI1八yT,
Ha瓜eHcb Ha cBOIo cHQJIy, H oTToro He
⑪

pHCKOBaJIH c HIIMII 6HTbCH CMeJIO, H
e八Ba He no6eJKaJII1 Bce, Ho 3aTeM

《ILcpeTomacHo6olino"KmopeUe

yBHneJIH, IITO y>Ke BCe BblmJIH B
IIOJIe, [ITO JIHTOBUeB HeMHOrO. JI HTOB-

o TpocH e, H cToHma MHOrO 4HII,

CKOrO BOHCKa6bIJIO
BOjiCKa 6bIJIOHe
He60JIbme，唖eM
60JIbme, IIeM
TPH C nOJIOBHHOH TbICHKIH KOHHblX,

MQcTy 3a TpocHy. H cTynHmacJI
o6oII HoJIUbl Ha 6oIo, H 6HilIacH 'Io

U

KpoMe nemHX, a MoCKBHIIeii 6blJIo copoK TblcHq XoPomo BooPy)KeHHbIx KoH-

HblX, KPOMe ne皿ⅡX, H, BHIH My]KeCTBeHHoe II CMeJIOe HaCTynqJIeHHe TaKOrO
U

He60JIbmoro.JIHToBcKoroBoiicKa,y八HBJIHJIHCb 7 a nOTOMD KOr八ayB皿eJIH BCeX,
MOCKBHqH BCe e'MHOJIymHo H KPenKO
nOmJIH HaBCTPeIIy IIM. JIHTOBUH】Ke
6HJIHcb, Ho yBII'meB, IITo MocKBIIIIeii
U

MHoro, a IIx Ma,JIo,
He
cToHTb
nePeX
HMMII

Mor,JIII
60JIee
H
no6e]KaJIH.

MOCKBH唖IlKenorHa,J]IIcb3aHHMH,

ⅢⅡocJIeXH

JIHTBa

nePeJIe3,JIH

no

mTH [IacoB o60HnOJInbl; HMaIOmecH 3a pyKII, ceilaxycH. H no yloIJIIIJIM HKO PeKa, B TPyny KOHh

He

CKoqHT.HnOMO>Ke60rBe@ﾉIHKOMy
KHH3Io IIBaHy BacIIJILeBHIIy H BoEBo八e ero K"310 maHIMy BacHJIbq J

eBHIIy H BceH

CIIJIe

MocKoBCKo面．

AJIIITBa̲JIo6e)Ke,HMa,JIoHxyTeIIe 3a TpocTH y 3a peKy, 3aHe
班e BeJIHKarO KHH3H

CHJIanGm月河

3amJllj Xa MocT noceK" Ha TpocTIIe. H MIIorO B PeUe HCTone.

MHorHxno6H,JIII,a八PymX.]KHBEIMI13a6paJIH｡

Toma 6blJI B3JIT B HJIeH reTMaH KHJI3b

KqWIcTaHIMHHBaHoBHIJOcTpo>KcU

KH1.1》.．.363

A BoeBoJly ,60mnaro

JIHTOBCKarO7

KHH3H&KoHbcTJIHTHHa

OcTpo)KcKo-

l,OフnOHManH》..･3“

nell"V
ocbMII
ToMaM
nCPJI',
oT瓜．II:
CU6.,
1907,
cTpWA
"p::npW"a,
W "3'IX,Ih"
6fWa
""9;
"'
JVb347lf̲"Z,̲
cTp.
380;
ACSH,
̲I11,
T. JW
54,
cTP、82)．旦pyraH
TPocHa

noJIoBⅢIIa，cTp，260；Aの3mX，Ⅱ．11，1JYb78，cTp、76，
T、XIV，BTopafl
9TMege"IIgToWMK3MHBropo八cKoMCTaHel<o3eJIbCKOrOye3ma
LMqjIX, q:̲LM 400, CTp. 448) .

362nCP几IffYI,̲",559､";fXpoHIiK4ELIXoBUa)',cTp.12.

:W "g"Ka qbIxOBna>, cTP ll2-L-li3! ̅6PrTI"JrrXVff.c+3 560
364くyCTIO>KCKMir
,neToHIICIIblii
CBO八沙,
CTp.
101.
｡

162

MoIKHo ,myMaTb, [ITo, IIepenpaBIIBmHcb [Iepe3Benpomy,
JIHTOBUbl BeJIH 60ii He C OCI-IOBHblMII CIIJIaMII PyCCKPIX, a C OC○

TaTKaMII nePengPOrO oTP"a, He yCneBmIIMH oToMTli K ocIIOqr
HblM HOJIKaM・nOCJIenHHe cTO兄JIH, CKoPee BCerO, 3a PeKOH

TpocHoi. He cJIyIIaiiHo, roBoPH o 6HTBe npH TpocHe, ycTIO)KCK" CBOnt OnePIIPyeT HMeHeM TOJIbKO OXHOrO BOeBOnlbl -

naH'"bl BacIIJIbeBIIIIa: HMeHHo oH HBJIJIJIcJI B sTo BpeMH Ko-

MaH,ⅡyIo皿HM
BO3rJIaBJIHJIく60JIbmO肱nOJIK>>
II
365.

、

CpaBHeHIIe xpoHIIK c ycTIoIKcKIIM JIeToHIIcHblM cBonpM

nO3BOJIHeT CnleJIaTb BblBO4, IITO HOCJIe OTxO八a IIaCTH PyCCKHX

BoiicK oT BeJpomHHaCTynHJI KaKoii-TO 3HaIIIITeJIbHblknel)ePblB B BOeHHbIx 4eiicTBIIFIX (<<CTOHma MHOrO nHII)>, no cJIoBaM yCTIo)KCKOrO CBO"). HO-B皿HMoMy, Pa3rPOM JIHTOBcKoro BoiicKa cocToHJIcH Ha BocToIIHoM 6epery p. TpocHbl,

KynaくJIIITBa nepeJIe3JIH Ho MocTy>. OcTaTKH JIIIToBcKoro
BoiicKa no6e)KaJIII <<sa TpocTHy》一BePoHTHo, Ha loro-3ana",
Ho 6blJIH mp6HTbl Ha p. noJIMe, mle, Hano noJIaraTb, II yXaJ I O C b B 3 H T b B n J I e H J I H T O B C K I I X B O e B OX .

nPenJIO)KeHHOe
o6も月CHeHme
XO"
90eWlbIX
,meiPTBIIii

1500 i､. FIBJIHeTcH He 60JIee, qeM rImoTe30ih. Ha naHHoii cTa-

XIIII HCCJIenPBaHIIH 3Ta rHHOTe3a y"OBJIeTBOPHeT Hac, HO-

CKOJIbKy OHa nPHMIIPHeT nPoTIIBOPetlHH Pa3JIHIIHblx HCTOxIHHKOBⅡⅡOKa3LIBaeT, HO'IeMy, ynOMIIHaH IIJIHⅡOBecTByH

O

cpa)KeHHHxHaBe,mpome,TpocHeHnoJIMe,Ka)K4bliiHcToIIHIIK CIIHTaeT KOHeIIHhlM Pe3yJIbTaTOM nJIeHeHHe JIHTOBCKHX

BOeBOX: BCe aTH TPH CPa)KeHHH 6blJIH STanaMII O,n{HOii 60JIbmoit 6HTBbl. noHHTHLIM

cTaHoBIITcH

TaK)Ke BblHeceHHe Ha

nePe"" nJIaII Ii3BeCTIE OCPa]KelI皿ⅡpII HoJIMp B EpMqF

J1IIHCKoii JIeTOnHcm m nPOCTPaHHoit Pe"KHIIII Pa3P"HOih
KHHrll: noJIMeHcKafl onePaⅡHH 3aBePmaJIa Pa3rpOM JIHToBU

c KO r o

BOHCKa･

MHeHme, KITo Benpoma - peKa, Bna"IomaH B UHenp 3aⅡa皿ee nOPOrO6y>Ka, oCHOBaHo, HO-B皿IIMOMy, IIa nOMHCJIe.

CorJIacHo 60JIbmHHcTBy JIeToHIIcHblx cBoppB, K. H. OcTpo>KCKHii meJI H3 JIIITBbl K JoPOro6y>Ky, H CPa>KeHHe nPOII30mJIO HOユュoporo6y>KeM. OTcIona, KaK Mo>KHo AyMaTb, H Bo3-

HIIKJIOnPe且noJIo)KeHHeoMecToHaxoIKneHHIIBempomH3aⅡanHee noporo6y]Ka. B J<eiicTBIITeJIbHocTH IKe, no cB皿e-

TeJIbcTBy xpoHHK, KocBeHHo n"TEep>KnaIo皿eMyCH pa3pfma-

MH,OCTp(j>KcKmi nome4 Ha ̲noporo6y)KHenpHMqH3
CMoJIeHcKa, a H3 EJIbHH. EcJIH 6bl npH sToM pyccKIie BoIIcKa
365 <<Pa3pmlHaII KImra...>, cTp. 30i l<. B. B a 3 H JI e BHII. yKa3. cOII.,
cTp. 453-454.
163

11＊

cocpe"Toq}Imlcb rne-To 3ananHee ,moporo6y)Ka, Becb ropo八
OKa3aJICH 6bl nOしml-IOCTblo He3amH皿eHIIbIMc Iora, oTKymanBII-

raJIocb JIIIToBcKoe BoiicKo. CT. Xep6cT IIoMe皿aeT I). Be4pomy
Me>Kny 6e3blMHHHblM PyqbeM Ha BOCToKe lI p. y)KekHa3aⅡane, o血aKo B aTJIacax XVIII - HaIIaJIa XIX B. B 3ToM paiioHe

yKa3aHblJIHmb'cJIenyIo皿HeJIeBblenPmToKH瓜Henpa(CBOCTo-

Ka l-la 3ana八) : Cepe6peHKa, McKo>Ka, IIepHorpH3bH, XaTblLIKa, y>Ka・Cpe且ⅡⅡpIIToKoB HcKo)KII, XaTblIIKH M y)KH­B e4-

pomH To]Ke HeT. HeT 3ntecb ll npII3HaKoB TpocHbl, noJIMbl,
JIOnaTHHa 366.

BCBH3しIcBenpomcKoji6IITBoitBo6eHxpenaKUHHxPa3P"HblxKHHrrOBOPHTCHonoxOIa]LpycCKHXBOeEMKPOCJ1aBJIIo H EJIbHe:《HOHH XO皿JIH K PocJIoBJIIo (B npocTpaH-

HOir Pe皿K皿H - ,,PocTHcJIaBJIIo{@) II K EJIbHe, II 60M IIM 6blJI
HaBeXpomKe>>367.、
Ho且くPOcJIOBJIeM)PHaJIOHOHIIMaTb,cKOPeeBCerO,POCJIaBJIb, pacnoJIo)KeHIIblii K Iory oT EJIbHH, TeM 60JIee, IITo B
nPOCTPaHHOii PenaK皿HOH巾ⅢryPIIPyeT B CTaPlIHIIOM HanHCaHHH <POcTHCJIaBJIb>・3To oTo)KnlecTBJIeHHe HalI60JIee Be-

POHTHOe, HO He enHHCTBeHHOe, H60 e皿e O"IH <POCJIoBJIb)D

ynaeTcHHaimiBnoporo6y>KcKoMye3neHapeIIKePRcJIoBK9
npoTeKalomeii HecKo"bKo Ioro-BocToIIHee peIIKII CBHHHoii
(CeHHoi) 368,皿e, nO HameMy nPe皿oJIO)KeHIIIO, HaxomIJIOcb
CBIIHcKoe HoJIe. TaK IIJIII HHaIIe, Ho Mo)KHo nyMaTb, [ITo Ha
CBIIHcKoM noJIe cocToHJIocb KaKoe-To cToJIKHoBeHHe BoiicK,

Ⅱo只只eP>KIIB aBmHx BacIIJIHfl, c 'IacTbIo ･ BoiicK HBaHa lll.
BacIIJIHii Mor onHPaTbcH TOJIbKo Ha JIHTOBCKHe BOitCKa; erO
6ercTBo H3 MocKBbI <<c BoIIMH>, KaK y)Ke roBopHJIocb, MaJIo
BePOHTHo (H C rPaMMaT"ecKOit TOIIKII 3PeHIIH BblPa>KeHHe

<<c BOHMH> TPy,mo nOnyCTIIMO: cKOPee 6blJIO 6bl <<c BO") .
npaBXa, He HcKJIIoLIeHo, IITo B Bfl3bMe K HeMy npIIMKHyJIa
KaKaH-TO IIacTb MeCTHOrO raPHII30Ha H MeCTHblx巾eonaJI OB
C IIx BOOPy>KeHHblMH CJIyraMH.

B cJIoBax ycTIo)KcKoro JIeTonHCHoro cBOna o6 0TnPaBKe
JIHToBcKHM BeJIHKIIM KHH3eM paTH (K. H. OcTpo>KcKoro)
366 S. H e r b s t. Op. cit., str. 280; UrAnA, (P. 1356, CMoneHcKaH ry6.,
JVb 34, 35.

367 4<P a3p皿HafI KImra...", cTp. 30; rnB, SpMIIT. 390, JI．22 (nO MamHHOmlcII, npenocTaBJ1eIIHoii MHe B.H. ByraHOBbIM) .

3684<CMoJIeHcKaFT ry6epIIHJI. CmIcoK IIaceJIeHHbIx MecT Ho cBeXeH'HFIM
1859 r.＞Cn6., 1863, Nb 4700; cp. Nb 4699; <Cnel皿a｡JIbHaH
KapTa
EBponejicKoii PoccHII>, J1. 44. Cn6., 1912. nepeBHH PocJIoBJIb 6bIJIa

II B XVIII B. (UrAnA,巾．1356, CMonemCKag ry6., M 33-37a).
164

<<KBH3Me>MblBHⅡIIMoTPa)KeHIieonPeXeJIeHHorocTPaTe"IIM6ftmJIaHa ocTpo>K6K", Bo3Mo>KHo,̲､IIocJIaJI oTp""
U

coe1HifIMEBacnJfmeM
H
ero
JIIoXbMIL̲CToJIKHoqgHme
alQr

roo6もEMeiiImf66TP"acPycgKIIMBoiiCKOMHa̲PEWW
U

U

iI6Jfe oK6HqlIJIocb noPa>KeHIieM BacliJI", KoTopb!HnoHaJI B
MocKBy,BepoHTHo,y)KeBKaqecTBe,nJIWqrp:

IM<,̅MmmliMaCX BToPylo (He gyKBaJI"YI9)̲I"TOBM5fO
MeCfa｣<PaTKOro
J1eTOjWC"JMbC,,WROWW

6M"6'HMpMifBiCmJIIIH"epp
(HBaHaJIL=CK)̲IW2-

BHTMancfneHaCBIIHcKoMyCaMbcoBa60Pa)':jmeJIo3aJ<JIpMM6irmioTIblTKe BacIIJIIifi onep>KaTb no6eny Han BoncKaU

MHHBaHa lll.

〆

BnoJIb3yTaKoronoHIIMaH"cBmⅡeTeJIbCTByeTPHXCOOo電

Pax<eHMi:
eg'H
1) 6bI¥52cmJIMHnoKy皿aJICHIIenocPeAcTBeHiIoHa>KH31ibliBaHalll,enBaJIHnoCJIenHﾙIipemHJICFI6bl
6MMMEliBHoBblla3HaqIITbBeJIml<llMKHH3eM;2)caMo
VnoMiIHaHme B TeKcTe <<IIOJI" nOKa3blBaeT,̲ IITO Peqb皿eTO

66566Nr nOJIe - MeCTe cPa>KeH" (CP. "IITKoBO gJOJIe)' ､B
ソ

paiioHeBenpomlI,《nOJIE
B
TmInHOge>
PeKI!
y HoJIMbI);
妙

5｢"｡mii6cTb kaKoro-JIm6o cp4"<-l､Mc)KmyBAWW
⑪

m' IIMHOM III BO BHyTPeHHIIX PaiiOHax POCC¥II IIcIWOqaeTU

&;̅5j̅y̅Bac"" H"bmo Q96cTpeI1Horo BoiicKa;̲6) ""
M6MKMETcHnpmMepHbliiPahoH
pacnoJIo)KeHIIHCBIIHU

U

cKoro noJIH II CaMcOBa 60pa; 4) npenJIoJIo)KIITeJIbHoe QTHe-

ceHHeCBIIHcKoronoJIHKCaMHoBcKoitBoJIocTHⅡoporo6y>KCKOroye3nayKJIa"IBaeTcHBHe3aBIIcMMOoT'3Tor9nRe且noJIo)KeHHHBocCo3,maiIHyloKapTIIHyBoeHHblxAeicTBIIitCToJIKU

ご

”

HoBeHHe Ha CBIIHcKoM HoJIe MorJIo npoII30IMTII B nepHoI

CTOHHHRocHoBHblx BoicK Ha TpocHe, KorXa JIHToBIIbl oco6eHHOCTPeMHJIHCbHaiiTHnOMOmb2,BO3MO>KHO,qrnPaBHJIH
｡

u

OTDH且KBH3bMeHacoe"HelIIiecBacHJIIieM,Ho6bIJImpa3-

6H;Tbl BMecTe c HIYM Ha CBIIHcKoM 'HoJIe noXocHeBmHM PyCcKIIM BoiicKoM. MecTo, Kyna Mbl lTpeⅡnOJIo>KIITeJTbHo OTHoU

cIIM CBIIHcKoe noJIe, Haxo1HJIOcb cPaBHIITeJIbHo HenaJIeKO OT

MecTa cpa>KeHIIFI nplI BeXpome - ceBepo-BocTotlHee nlepeBHIi
AJIeKcIIHa .

TaKIIM o6pa30M, BpeMeHH6e cooTHomeHIIe co6blTHi B
TeKcTe KpaTKoro JIeToⅡHcUa nPeXcTaBJIHeTcH B cJIeXyIOmeM

BHⅡe:BabHJIMi,>KeJIaflBeJIHKoToKIIH)KerlIIH,xoTeJIIo6HTbひ

cH Hopa>KeHIMH I'IBaHa. OH ITo6e>KaJI co |cBoHMII coBeTHHKaMH B BH3bMy・Cpa>KeHme MeHmy no,『IﾉIel)>KIIBaBmHMIM erO

Bo#cKaMII II FoiicKaMH IIBaHa lll npoH30mJIo Ha CBHHcKoM
noJIe y CaMbcoBa 60pa.
U

U

165

ノ

L2 4npeJIH !500 n B MocKBy II3 JIHTBb[ npHexaJI K"3b
U

U

2U. PeJIbcK", nepememIIii lia pyccKylo cJIyiK6y. H3MeHa
C
H
BeJIBCKOrO
HaCTOJIbKO
BCTP･gb>KIIJIa
AJibKCjHXPa,
qTO
OH nPHcJIaJI no SToMy noBoXy K IIBaHy lll cnellIIaJIbiioe nocoJIbcTBO,KoTopoe Bo3rJIaBJIFIJI cMoJIeHcKIIii HaMecTHIIK CTaU

HIIQnaB neTpfImKoBHq KmmKa 369. 3To nocoJIbcTBo nDH6biJib
入

B Mo"y 23 anpeJIH 1500 r. AJIeKcaHnp npli3Ha"JI"maZ
HOMIIITHTyJIBeJIIIKOrOKHH3HくBCCHPyC",HonPenもHBU

JIHJT pHⅡⅡPereH31m, . Ha KOTOPble HBaH III OTBeTIIJI OTKa-

30M370-371．Banpe｡nel500n̅BMocKBynpHexaJIIInocJIb[
C．Ⅲ. MO>Ka#cKoTo lI B. H. meMHIIHqa.B6npoc o BoiiHe c
U

JYIITBOii 6blJI OKOHIIaTeJIbHO DemeH
エ 372.

Mo>KHO
nPe瓦ⅡOJIO)KHTb,
IITO
IIMeJI
MeCTO
KaKOii-TO
CrOBOP
U

Me)Kny BacIIJIHeM H IYocJIoM JIHToBcKoro BeJIHKoro KHFI3冗一

cMoJIeJIcKIIMHaMecTHIYKoM
CTaHHcJIaBoM
neT"mKoBHIIeM,

T.e.6eI℃TBO､̲POCTO"OCbBCaMOMKOHUeanPeJIH
HaqaJIe
MaH1500r.Bo3Bpa皿eH>Ke6blJIBacHJI","BepHoe,KaBU

ryCTy, HoCJIe Pa3rPOMa JIHTOBCKIIx BO#CK.

OcHoBHoiin"tIIIHoii6el℃TBaBacIIJIHH6bmo,no-BImH⑪

MOM)L,̲OTCTPaHeHHPMOJTOXOr2KHH3HOTyqacTHHBynPaBJIeU

HIM HoBI､oponcKoi 3eMJIe#. nocJIe aBrycTa l499 r. HET HII"KIIx n"311aKOB ero BJIaneTeJTbHoii POJIH B OTHomeHIIH
⑪

HoBropon<a・BMecTecTeMyqacTHeBa6HJI"BBblXaIIeaHTHBJIanBIIIHblx rPaMoT HoBroPoncKHM MoHaCTHPHM ITocTaBIIJIo ero B JIO)KHOe nOJIo>KeHHe II B I､JIa3ax reHHa"IH．CBa⑤

TOBCTBO K naTCKOHⅡplIHIIgcce B "eBpaJIe-MapTe l500 r.

MorJIoyKpenIITbHane)Kn(bIBacIInIIHHapeaJIbHo6noJIyqeHme
HoBropoma B BeJIIIKoe KHFDKeHIIe.

O皿4JfPaTaHane)KnaoKa3aJIacbBecbMamaTKoi.50eB-

pam 1500 r. B KopoJIeBcKoM 3aMKe B K"e cocToHJTacb"3aoIIHaHnoMoJIBKal4-JIgTHeinpHHneccBIEJIH3aBeTbl,KoToDvIo
p

1

割

Ip2¥TaBJIHJIj<opoJIbX3¥c,eeoTen22̲16-JIeTHIIMkyp巾IopcToM
BpaHn;eH6yprcKIIM
HoaxIIMoM
373.
i AJIJIeH
6可HTaeT,
TITO
369nCP几ir.1V,JI.̲.1,Bbm.&cTp532;T.VI,cTp､45,243;T.V111,
cTp. 239; T. XII、cTP "; T20, nepBa" nbJIoBIIHa, bTp 370:

T. 26, cTp. 293; T､28､ cTP、333.
370-371くC6. PHO>, T､35, Nh 64.

、

372 K.BBa3HJIeBHII.yKa3. coII., CTp､451.

37@ g̲E｣l｣en"E1isa" Prindles56 5f Danmark, Kurfyrstinde a｢
Brandepborg Kbh, 1 855, s 5 (3HaKoMcTBoM ̅65f6inMIW̅yr565:
⑥

aall̲JIo6e3HocTIJ nl)o巾.n, a .m gMI", LL TPPHePa II P. I<ioPbeJIm) ;

F. W a g n e r. Der Schatz der Kurffi!.stin E1isabeth von Brandeh-

blll･g.­《円ohenzollern-Jahrbuch", VI Berlin-LeipZig1902; g.7F7i;
166

CPOIIHOcTb nOMOJIBKII OnPeXeJ1FIJIacb cTPeMJIeHHeM 3aKPblTb

mbporynaJIbHeimmMpyccKmMnpeXJIo)KeHIIHM,m60)KeHIITb6a BacIIJIIIH Ha EJIII3aBeTe MorJIa Bbl3BaTb y mBenoB, naT-

CKOronyxoBeHcTBaHnanblHeloBoJIbcTBonoJIIITIIKoiiXa1･1ca 374. KaK npemoJIaraeT Ha3BaHHbli aBToP, nocoJIbcTBo

EHca AHnepceHa B MocKBe XoJI>KHo 6blJIo II3BIIHHTbcH 3a 3an<eP>KKy 6PaKa, CCEIJIaflCb Ha OIIeHE IOHbli Bo3PaCT nPHHneCcbl 375. TeM BpeMeHeM XaHc nblTaJIcR Ha Xene nocTaBIITb
や

KPeCT Ha 9TOM CBaTOBCTBe.

B cKII6cKoi xpoHHKe roBopIITcH, IITo naTcKIIM 'nocJIaM

rPO3HJIO nOnJIaTIITbCH CBO60nOi, eCJIII He >KII3HblO, B gnyqae,
eCJIII 6bl cJIyxH o6 06py[IGHIIII EJIH3aBeTbI nomJIHⅡo PoccmH

BnePlIon,komano66jlbcTBOHaxO皿JIocbemeTaM376.
He
3HaeM, noJIyrmJI JTII Bac"Hii cooTBeTcTByIomylo IIH｡opMamIIo Xo cBoero 6er|cTBa B BH3bMy, T. e. B anpeJIe l500 r. noJIyIIeHIIe ee, KOHeIIHO, MOI､JIo HoBJIIIHTb Ha pe皿eHHe KH”月．

C noTepeii Hane>KXbl Ha HoBropoXcKoe BeJMKoe KHH)KeHIIe
BacHJIHii oKa3EIBaJIcH 3aIIHTepecoBaHHbIM B c6JIII>KeHHHc
BeJIIIKHM KHR3eM JIIIToBcKHM, KoTopbIii 6bm coIo3HIIKoM CTeHa CType II ero《Ⅱa PTI畑》, cJIeXOBaTeJIbHO,- BParoM naTCKOTO KOpOJIH.

HO HOBeXeHIIe BaCIIJIHH O6yCJIOBJIIIBaJIOCb B nePBylO OIIe-

peXb Cnen<"IIKOii BHyTPeHHerO nOJIO>KeHIIH POCCHHB 1499ユ

1500 rr. KaK y>Ke oTMewaJIocb Bblme, oTneJIbHble HccJIenoBa-

TeJI"(H. C JIyPbe, n>K. ｡eHHeJIHⅡP.) CIIIITalOT, IITO B

l499r.npom30nlJIoJImmbHeKoTopoe yMeiIbmeHIIe BgacTH

nMHTPHH,CBOeO6Pa3HOePa3neJIeHIIGBJTaci;IYMe>KnymMIITpHeM II BacHJIIIeM, HeIITo Bpone ycTy,nKII BacHJTIIIo TIITyJIa

KHH3H HOBrOPOnCKOrO II nCKOBCKOrO II COxPaHeHHe 3a nMHTPHeM TIITyJIa KHFI3H BJIaⅡⅢMHPCKOTO H MOCKOBCKOTO 377. 9TO
nOCTPOeHIIe BbY3blBaeT y HaC BO3PaJKGHIIFI・Bo-nePBbTx, Mbl
9HaeM o ｡aKTHIIecKoM oTcTpaHeHHII nMHTp" K 1499 r. oT
VTIaCTHHB XeJTaX BHyTPelJHerO ynPaBJYelIIIH．B o-BTop blx,
-

<<Dansk biografisk Leksikon, grundlagt af C．F・Bricka>, VI･Kbh.,
1935, s、291; cP. G・L i e b u s c h. Elisabeth von Dinemark, Kurftirstin von Brandenburg, 1873.
３７４ C.F･Alle n. Elisab､..., s. 3­．4.
３７５
1bid., s、4.
３７６
《Monllmenta HisfOriae Daniae", 1, s. 22, 409; LEKUB, 2-te Abt, Bd.
1, S. 623, Anm. 2; C. F̲ A11 e n. E1isabet…,s.4;oH
>Ke.
Detre
11ordiske Rigers Historie, Bd, 1. Kbh., 1864, s、1 99.
CM. TaKylo >Ke TpaKToBKy B KH.: <OqepKII IIcTopIM CCCP>.
nepHoI
、

守

寺

｡ ｛ 『

*eonaJIII3Ma. KoHen XV B.- HaqaJTo XVII B M., 1955, cTp. 106.
167

cTPoro xPoHoJIorIIIIecK城nOnXOH K IICTOIIHIIKaM nOKa3blBa-

eT､ITo B 1499- 1 500 rr. He Ha6JIIonaeTcFI oJHoBPeMeHHoro
noHBJIeHIIH BacHJI" II nMIITpml B poJTH BeJIIIKIIx KHH3ei
CpaBHHM xpoHoJIorlIIo ynoMIIHaHIIi o BacIIJIHHH瓜MIITpmI
B HcToIIHIIKax l499-nepBo尚noJIoBIIHbl l 500 rr.
B

ac

HJTHi

n M H Tp H i

21 MapTa l499 r. 06ERBJIeH Bem­
KHM

KHFI3eM･

Me]KXy 21 MapTa H 29 moJIH 1499 r.

nocJTe 21 MapTa l499 r. ynoMIJHaeTcH

ero noJIo>KeHIYe HeonPeXeJIeHHo.

nCKoBHuaMH

u

KaKBeJIHKmH

KH別3b-corl-

paBIITeJIE HBaHa lll.

14 HIoI)IFI 1499 r, npMcyTcTByeT npII
nOCTaB'JJeHIIH

29 IIIoJIH 1499 r, noJIyqaeT B
JIRKoe KH"KeHHe HoBTopoｴ．

KPyTIInKoTo

emJcKona .

Be-

B aBrycTe l499 r・BEIⅡaeTBMecTe

C HBaHoM III rPaMoTbl HoBropoXCKIIM MoHaCTblPHM.
3 M M o i l 5 0 0 r. I I B a H I I I H B a c H ”

JIHHoTXaIOT PacnoPmKeHHe

nCKO-

⑪

BHIIaM o

n O c Ta B Ke

BoHcKa

XJIH

BOiiHbl C JIHTBOii.

B KoHue anpeJIFI-HauaJTe MaH
1500 r. 6e)KHT B BH3bMy.
3 MaH 1500 r・HBaH III H nMHTPHii
IIocbmaIoT BoeBoX Ha JIIITBy 878.

Ii3 cOHocTaBJIeHIIH naHHblx BImHo, [ITO JMHTpIIii-BHyK
oKa3blBaeTcFI

Ha

noJIHTH'IecKOi

apeHe TOrXa,

Korma

c Hee

PIcIIe3aeT BacIIJIHii, T. e. B neicTBIITeJIbHocTH He 6blJIo pa3ZeJIellHH BJIacTII Me)KXy lIBaHoM III, Bac"HeM II nMHTpH-

eM.IIBaHnbITaJICHCOCPenPTOqHTbBCIOBJIaCTbBCBOHXPyKax. He XaB peaJIbHoオnoJIIITIIqecKoi BJIacTH BacIIJIIIIo, oH

II nMHTPHH COXPaH" JIIImb KaK nO,nCTaBHylo ･IIryPy, OT378BM3"IIIIm｡LEKUBKnepﾙIonlynoaBrycTal500r.oTHeceHy)KemITIIPOBaHHblH HaMII HOKyMeHT, rne rOBoPlITcFI, [ITO IIBaI･I III, nPaBFI
EMecTe C BIlyKoM, CQcp"QTogHJI BcIo B@macTb B cBoIIx pyKax (LEKUB,

2-te Abt., Bd. 1, JYh lO23, S. 772). Bo3Mo)KHo} 3Ta.>(apaKTbpHcTIIKa
oTpa )KaeT noJIo)KeHHe, co3zIaBmeecH
168

B

Mae - HIoJIe

l 500

r.

IIacTHKaKnyraJIoXJIHBacIIJIH兜379IIBEIIBIIraJIerOHanOJIH-

TH可em6̅5ieHyEMoMcHTbIoTcTpaHeH""lWLoMYr
hBMMmMaJIbHoiipoJImconpaBIITeJIH.Be皿KIIiiKHH3b
u

nO11eP>KIIBaJI
BH瓜mMOCTb
CIIcTeMbl
COnPaBJIeHIIH,
HO
nO
Cy-

皿eCTBy
CTPeMmJICH
JI1KBImmPOBaTb・BJIarOnPHFITHblii
ee
HCx6X65rcTgaBacmJIIIHBB23bMy-Bo3BpameHmefroKRJW
凹

TH-M̅5 5ifa"6JIbHoii Mebe cBH33H c KpaiiHe cJIa60fi
nO3HIIIIehnMIITPlIFI.
379V唾○ql1Mn街1mOr-Korma
oTHomeHl,1列Me泳瓜V
HBacHBacH.
y>Ke311Moiil500r.,KornaoTHomellMfI
Me泳瓜yI'IBaHoM
l'IBaHoMIIIIIIH

MGM 6bmII KPaiiHe manPfl)KeHHblMII, a ZlaTcKIIe nOCJIb[ e""E̲M咽

6bmH,
I'IBaII,
OqeB皿i-I0,
1､I)031IJ1
唾 CbIIIylIOBblMBo3BbimellIIeMnMIITPlifI.
i5"Bpa" 1500 r. xoxMeiicTep n9JIytlWLoT̲9MWWTgI)4Mfc9;
HHe，r且eroBo”ʻmocb，IITo
BeJIHKmmKHH3b
Bpa>KⅡe6eH
cblHoM
c
H
u

U

5566Ma ､>KeJIaJf 6bI nteP>KaTb BHyKa B cBomx ropoXax K3K BeJIIIKQZQ
U

KHFI3FI,KIerO eMyHeXOLIeT Pa3PemHTberoco6cTBeHHblncblH;sTa

&5Pa "ep>KMB" Bein!KoE9 .KII", nllaIf,6"H n2n"IIc3""" #"》
MWg̅1[EKUB, 2-te Abt: Ed.J, Nb 923, ､ S 704; yKa3ama m

i6PeBema
cTapoileMeUKoro
to
A几XopouIKGB11II)
.

、

Y

I̅'〃a8q

III

COqIIAXbHO-nO八HTH'IECKAH BOPbBA
B 1 5 0 0 - 1 5 0 5 r r.

”

＊

1 . HMMyHIITeTHaH nO入HTHKa B 1500-1502 rr.

HoBoeno>KaJIoBaHHeBacHJIHFI
BeJIHKoKHH)KecKHMTHTyJIOM H nPaBoM nPHHIIMaTb yIIaCTIMe B HoBrOpOXCKO面ⅡOJIIITH-

KeOTPa)KeHOB|ceHTH6PbcKOカrpaMoTel500r.HoBropo,mcKoMy BoJIoToBy Mo|Ha'cTblPlo '.

>KaJIoBaHHaflrpaMoTaoT30ceHTH6pH1500r.BoJIoToBy
MOHacTblPIo IIOKa3bIBaeT, !ITo HBaH III He cO6HPaJICH nPeXocTaBJIFITIl̲BacHJIHIo enlIHoJIIIIIHblx npaB Ha HoBroponi (KaK
cKa3aHo B KPaTKoM JIeTonlIcUe, "ama eMy BeJIHKoG KHJDKeHIIe 'n O I c O 6 0 10)') II He XyMaJI OTKa3blBaTbCfl OT IICnOJIb-

3QBaHHH ero nJIH 60pb6bl c HoBroponcKHM apxHenHcKoHoM.
K,BoJIOTOBCKO# rPaMoTe 6blJIH nPHBemeHbl nBe neIIaTH: HBaHa lll II BacmJIIIH HBaH ｡HrypHpyeT B HanllHcH Ha neqaTH
co BceMII 'cBoHMH TepplITopHaJIbHblMII aTpII6ynlIFIMH, B IIH|cJIe
KOTOPblX yKa3aHbIくHoB.> H《ncK.>. BacIIJIHii >Ke Ha3BaH

ToJIbKO BeJIHKHM KHH3eM, na)Ke 6e3 <<BCeH Py'CH》­､CJI OB ,
HMelOmHxicH B TeKcTe rpaMoTbl. Mbl,n<yMaeM, IITo BacIIJIHit H

B1499r.HeHMeJIcneuHaJIbHOrOTHTyJIaKHH3flHOBrOPOXCKOro

H

ⅡCKOBcKOrO，

BoJIoTOBcKaHrpaMQTlaBecbMa6JII13Kanoconep>KaHHIoK

, KoHeBcKoii rpaMoTe l499 r. KaK II TaM, 34ecb oTMeHHIoTcH:

l)[opHc皿KUHH'HOBroPOn|CKOroaPxHenHcKOnaBOTHOmeHIIH

PIryMeHa H 6paTHH,くonpHIIb ,nyxoBHblx Bemeih)'; 2) oTKyn
II |nomJIIIHbl :B IIoJIb3y apxHenH,cKona H Bcero n<oMa cB. Co-

｡HH; 3) B'beam B MoHacTbIpcKylo BoTIIHHy n<e'cHTHJIbHIIKoB H
BJIa,mbl'IHblX JIIOLeh.no cPaBHeHHIO c 'KoHeBIcKOji BOJIOTOBcKaH

rpaMoTa nlaeT apxHenHcKoncKOii KaPeXpe HeKoTopble HecymecTBeHIIble npeIIMymeCTBa : l ) eCJIH B KOHeBCKOi rPaMOTe
IIoJIHocTblO OTMeHFT,IIOcb nPaBo aPxHemi'CKOna 'CTaBIITb B MOI AH,T・I,M lll
170

U

HaCTblPcKHX BJIaneHIIHx KOHeII Ha nPOKoPM, TO B BOJIOTOB-

cK|Oii rPaMoTe Pa3PemaeTcH CTaBIITb OXHy JIOmanL, IIO 3a
nJIaTV;
2，
．)ⅡoITBeP>K1aeTcFI
nPaBO<nOna CO巾eiicKaro Xa皿一

aKOHa>> 6blTb nPIIrJIameHHblMII B MOHa1CTblPbくHa npa31HHK
Ha ycneHIie nPeIII'I|CTble沙只JIH COBePmeHI畑nePKOBHOi 'CJIy)K6b1, 3a KoToPylo HM nPHIIHTaJIa'cb 'c HryMGHa rPHBHa HOBrO-

po1cKaHHela. CoxpaHeHIIe aTIIx 3JIeMeHToB npe>KHeii 3aBHcIIMoCTII MOHaCTblPH OT aPxIIePeiiCKOrO IOMa o6y'cJIOBJIHBaU

JIocb, BO3Mo>KHO, lle TOJIbKO ycTOIIIIIIBOcTblO MeCTHblX TPa且Ⅲ-

LIIIi, HO II TeM, [ITO HBaH III 60JIb皿e, [IeM B l499 r., CIIIITaJICH
C HO3I皿Heih BacHJIIIH IimeJI GMy Ha ycTynKII.
OrPaHHIIHBaFI IopHc瓜HKnHIO aPxIIenHCKOna, BOJIOTOB'cKafl
rPaMOTa yCHJIIIBaJIa BJIaCTb IIryMeHa, KOTOPOMy nPenoCTaBJ1HJIocb nPaBO Cyna Han MOHaXa'MH MOHacTI)IPH.

IIHTePeCHo Pe皿aJIcH B rpaMoTe BonPoc o cyne6Hblx noJIHOMOLIIIFIX HaMeCTHIｲKoB. MoHacTblpb HMeJI BJIaJIeHHH B IByx

Pa3JIIIqHblx anMIIIIIIcTPaTIIBHblX enHHHnax: B Pycce Ha nOCane (BaPH皿bl) H B nePeBCKOhⅡHTHHe (IepeBHH). B cBH3H C STHM |B rPaMOTe Pa3JIIIIIalOTCH <HaMscTHImbl HamlI pyCKHe》Ⅱ<@HaMeCTHHⅡbl HamHHOBrOPOnCKIIe H nPHrOPOXCKIIe

11 BOJIoCTeJIH》．nePBble noJIyIIaJIHnPaBo Cyna Han MOHacTblPCKHMH JIIoXbMH nO TPeM BH瓜aM npecTynJIeHIIih: nylnery6cTBy,
pa36010 II TaTb6e !c noJIHIIHblM, BToipble JIIImb no nByM 瓜ymery6,cTBy lI pa360Io c HoJIHIIHblM. BMecTe c TeM ToJIbKo
＝

HoBrOPOnCKHe HaMeCTHHKH oOJIanlaJIII |nPaBOM 'Cy旦HTbcaMOrO

HryMeHa B IIcKoBblx IeJIax. <<PycKIIe>> HaMecTHHKII no o6'beMy IOpH'C皿KHIM 6JIH3KH K HaMecTHIIKaM,巾Hryp Hpylo皿HM
B rpaMoTe l499 r. KoHeBcKoMy MoHa'cTblpIo. TaM He onpeXeJ1HeTCH IIx ye3XHafl nPHHanJIe)KHOCTb, HO, BePOHTHO, HMeJIHCb

B BHPy He CO6cTBeHHO HoBrOPonCKHe, a KoPeJIbcKHe HaMecTHIIKH.

B

npHcoenmHeHHoii
今

HoBroPonJcKoi

3eMJIe

ToJIb'Ko

《HoBrOPoXcKHe HaMecTHHKII> B y3KoM CMblcJIe 'cJIOBa 6blJIH
IIaneJIeHbl KHH>KecKIMM ap6HTpa]KHblM npaBoM，HaMeCTHHKH
>Ke oKpaHHHblx o6JIacTeii HoBroPOXcKoih 3eMJIH (KopeJIa Ha
ceBepe, PyCCa Ha Iore) HHIIeM HO CBOeMy noJIO>KeHHIo He OTJIHIIaJIIIcb OT HaMecTHHKOB

nPyrHx ye3nPB

PyccKorO rOCy-

napcTBa. ,npaBna, cTelleHb orpaHHIIeHIIH B Hx n|oJIb3y MoHaU

〆

cTI)IPcKoH IoPHcIHKnHH |Hant JIIom)MHHKPecTbHHaMII
OblJIa
Ma'KcIIMaJIbHOII, H3 IIerO MO)KHO 3aKJIIOIIHTb, [ITo nPaBIITeJIb⑥

cTBO nPImaBaJIo 60JIbmOe 3HaIIelIIIe yKPemleHHIo 'cBOerO
Me｢cTHOTo aⅡⅡapaTa Ha oKpalIHax HoBropoXIcKo# 3eMJIH.
He,cKoJIbKo IIHaIle o6'cToHJIo nleJIo c 'co6'cTBeHHo HoBro-

PoIcKHMH HaMecTHHKaMH・CoxpaHFIH Hx ap6IITpa>KHyIo
171

pOJIb, nPaBHTeJIbCTBo CTPeMHJIOCb JIHKBI'IXHPOBaTb ,uPyrlie
nPePOraTIIBbl KHFDKeCKOrO THna, BOcnPHHFITble HaMecTHHKaMH OT anOXH HOBrOPOn|CKOH He3aBHcIIMOCTH・B BoJIoToBcKoii

rpaMOTe OTMeHHJIo|cb HaMeCTHHIIbe nPaBO 'CTaBIITb KoHeiM Ha
npoKopM B MoHa'cTblpcKoi BoTKIHHe. EcJIII B BeJIHKoKHFDKecKIIx >KaJIoBa:HHblx rpaMoTax 90-x ToIoB Ha 3eMJIH B ye3nax

CeBepo-BocToIIHoii PycI'I, a TaK>Ke B KoHeBcKoii rPaMoTe .HeT
CTaTbPI, 3a'nPemaIOmeii HaMe'CTHIIKaM B3HMaTb 'CBOi KOPM c
I,IMMyHIITeTHblx BJIanleHHii, To B rpaMoTe BoJIoToBy MoHacTbIplo HoIo16}IaH 'cTaTbFI HMeeTcR: <<A IITo nomJIII'Hbl mJIo c

BoJIoToBcKoroMoIIacTblpFIHaMecTHHKoMHoBTopontcKHMHHx
THyHoM H IIx JIIOneM, II HM Tex nOmJIIIH HaMecTHIIKOM HamHM
HOBroPojlcKIIM II IIx TIIyHOM H Hx JIIOneM He naBaTH HH[Iero>.

KaK II B |KoHeBcKoii rpaMoTe, B II3yIIaeMoM IIcToIIHIIKe
yKpemlHeTIcH aXMHHHCTPaTHBHblit HMMyHIITeT MOHacTblPHf

BoTIIIIHHHKa (O及班I CPOK BbI30Ba B CyユnO H･cKOBbIM XeJIaM

cTaTbII nPOTIIB e310KoB II He3BaHblx rOCTeii, yCImeHIIble no
cpaBHeHIIIo c KOHeBCKoii rPaMOToii yrPo30h《onaJIbl>,《Ka3HII)> H neHe>KHblx mTPad)oB) .

K co>KaJIeHHIo, Mbl He lIMeeM naHHblx o xapaKTepe B3aIIMooTHomeHIIii Me>Kny BoJIoToBblM MoHaCTblpeM II apxH­
epeiicKHM npMoM B KoHnie XV B. MoHacTblpb 6bIJI ocHoBaH B
cepeⅡⅡ'He XIV B. II, 0tleBHJHo, Hax･onmJIcH B TecHoii 3aB|II-

CHMOCTH OT KabeXPbl 2. Cy皿Ⅱo qJaKTy BbI"IIII eMy >KaJIo⑪

U

BaHHOH rPaMOTbl, Pe3KO OrPaHII[IIIBalOmeH aPxHenHcIKOHcKylO

IoPHcXHKUHIO, MO)KHO 3aKJIIOUHTb, IITO MOHaCTblPb c6JIH3HJICH
c MOCKoBCKHM

nPaBHTeJIbcTBOM

H cTPeMHJICfl ｣nOPBaTb y3bl

Ba'CcaJIbHOrO nOnIIHHeHHH aPxHenH'cKOny.

nPH Bblnatle >KaJIOBaHHOi rPaMOTbl HBaH III, OIIeBImHO,
yIIIITblBaJI H MecToHoJIo>KeHHe BoTIIHH BoJIoToBa MoHacThI",
ⅡPHMblKaBmHX K O3eP|y HJIbMeHb rJIaBHblM o6Pa30M c IOra
ʼ ' 1 B o c To K a 、

STH paii,oHbl ;6blJIH o6pameHbl, ,c oIHoi lcTopoHbl, K ToponeUKoMy ye31y (Pycca, HaJIIoHKIIimorocT nepeBcKohm-

TIIHbl) , |c Xpyroii - K o3epy CeJIHrep H KJIII[IeHcKoii BoJIocTH
P>KeBcKoro ye3na (TyxoJIbcK", PyIIbeBcK嘘nOrOCTbI 3I
2 nCPJI, T. 1V, II. 1, Bhm. l , cTp. 285; <<HoBroponcKafl nepBaH JJeTomicb CTaPmero H MJIa,ﾛ皿erO II3BOHOB>．Ⅱon Pen. H c nPenHcJIOBHeM

A. H. HacoHoBa. M.- JI̲, 1950, cTp. 368; cp. nCPJI, T. 1V, q. 1 ,
Bbln. 2, cTp. 346; 3BepHHcKIIii, T. II, Nb l312.

3 K ceBepo-BocToKy oT o3epa lｲnbMeHb Haxo皿1JICFI ynOMFIIIyTblji B rPaMoTe l500 r・BO)KeHCKIIii nOrOCT.

172

Col､JIaCHO
nPoCTPaHHOii
Pe,maKIIIIH
Pa3pH八HblX
KHIIr,
TOPonEi̅ ̅6"B31iTP7ccKliMII" BoiicKaMM9 IIBrycTal 50Qr"
で

U

npaB,Ua,
ncKoBcKaH
JleToⅡHcb
I
,coo6皿aeT,
IITO
KwI3b
AmeK-

CaHXP,
HOcanHHKHHBoiiCKO
BePHyJIHcb
B
HcKOB
II3
TOPQIIUa
HanoKpoB60ropo且Ⅲ皿bl7009r.,T､e.10KTH6pHl500r.,
<<a 6blJIIi TaM l l iieneJIb)> 5. Ho B cIIeT l l HenleJIb, oIIeBH瓜HO,

BxoJMTHeonHoJIIimbBpeMFInpe6bIBaHH兜HxBToponUe,a
u

BeCb
nePliOnI
OT|CyTCTBH兜ⅡIcKoBIcKoro
BoilicKa
B
ncKoBe
r.
B
cBH3H c TOPonenKIIM IIoxOnpM.

MocKoBcKoe npaBIITeJIbcTBo, no-BH4HMoMy, onacaJIocb
nPeTeH3Hii n&CKOBa Ha 3aBOGBaHHble TOPOnenKHe TePPIITOPlIH
△

Im03TOMy yKPenJIHJIO cBOli nPaBa Ha CMe)KHbl" HIIMIi gOB-

roPOnlcKIIe3eM皿(rpaMoTa̅ 6bIJIaBbInaHa30ceHTH6",
BckopenocJIeyxo,manCKoBIJIIeiiH3Topo皿a).
U

IIToKacaefcflpaiioHa,6JIH3KoroKo3epy̲CeJIHre&ToTyT
U

Ona|CHOcTL IICxOﾕHJIa OT BoJIOmKOrO |KIIH3H eXOPa BOPHcO-

BH'Ia,KOTOPblHe皿eBMapTel500r.BbUaJIンKaJIOBaHHylO
⑪

rpaMoTy HocIIbo-BoJIoKoJI4McKoMy MoHa'cWlpIo Ha noJI9BHご

HV cJIo604KK TiiMo｡eeBcKoii - B 6yPymeM OcTamKoBcKoit H̅Hapbl6HbleJI|oBJIH
HHapbl6HbleJIʻoBJIH
B
CeJIHrepe,、pH[IeMrpaMoTaʻco3ﾕaBaJIa
BCeJIIIrepe,npHIIeMrpaMoTa|co3ntaBaJIa
JIbroTHble ycJIOBIIH IJIHnePexOna B 3TH MecTa KPeCTbHH <H3
U

3apy6e)KbH>6;dmlDKaiimHM<<3apy6e>KbeM)PHBJIFIJIacbKaK

Pa3XePeBcKaHⅡHTHHaHoBropo,IcKorOye3na7.BcHoMHHM eme, IITO enOPHHBaH BOPH'COBHIIII, TaK >Ke KaK II

ncKoBcK" KHH3b, yIiacTBoBaJIH Bo B3flTHII ToponⅡla ll B BoU

U

eHHblX XeiICTBHJIX B3TOM
eHHblX只eH'CTBHRX
B STOMPaHOHe・
PaIIOHe.

no]KaJIoBaHIIe rpaMoTbl BoJIoToBy MoHacTblpIo npeBpaU

maJIO 3Ty KOPnOPalMIO B 'nPOBOIHHKa BeJIHKOKHmKeCKOK nOJIHTHKH, MaTePHaJIbHO 3allHTePeCoBaHHOrO B COXPaHeHHH

npOqHOrO CyBePeHHTera MOCKOBCKOrO nPa"TeJI¥TBa .Ha
U

U

U

rPaHHUax C HeXaBHIIM TeaTPOM BOeHHblX neHCTBIIH H C¥eu

POit BJIIIHH" ncKOBa, a TaK)Ke C y,meJIOM BOJIOmiKOrq KHfI3fij
u

cTPeMHBmerOCH, oIIeB"Ho, K PaqllIiPeHHIO "oH¥ ̲M"eHIIH

HajceBepo-3anane,[IeMyBceHTH6pe̲-oKTH6pel500r.Mo⑪

⑫

rJIa6JIAronPHHTcTBOBaTbBOiiHacJIHTBOii.

4 rnB, SpMIIT. 390, J1. 21 (no皿'3ylOCb Ma皿佃oHIIcHoii Komleil, JIIo6e3Honl)enPcTaBJIeHHoiiMHeB.H.6yraHOBb'M).
5《nckoBCKHe JIeToHIIcM>, BbIn. I. npHroToBIIJI K neIIaTII A. HacoHoB
M,一J1., 1941, cTp. 84.

6 Am3HX, [1. 11, JWh 25; cp. ero >Ke rpaMoTy l498/" j，. CIIMoHoBy Mo-

HacTbIplb Ha 3eMIm mBombI B P>KeBckoM ye3Ue (ACSH, T. II, JW̲417) .

7 Ha KjpTe K. A. HeBoJIHHa caMo o3epo CeJIHrep HoKa3aHo B nepeBcKoh血THHe (K. A. H e B o JI H H. O nHTHIIax II nQrocTax HoBropo八一

cKIIx B XVI' Beke. Cn6., [1853], KapTa B KoIIUe KIIHrlI).
173

npHBJIerleHHe BacIIJIHH K ynpaBJIeilIIIo HoBropo,瓜oM HMeさ
JIO, TaKHM O6Pa30M, 60｡ﾉIbmOe BHyTPH- H |BHemHenO,JIIiTIIIIecKoe 3HaLIeHIie. OHo cHoco6cTBoBaJIo yKpenJIeHIIIo 3a IIBaHOM III 3a|nanHblX O6JIacTeii rOCy八aPCTBa, 6JIH3KIIx K JIIITBe, cMe)KHblx c BJIaneHIIHMII BoJIoUKoro KHH3H II n,cKoBa.

CaMo npo皿eHHe BacH加呪 HeJIb3H O6'HICHIITb TOJIbKO
BHemHenOJIHTHIIeCKHMII MOTIIBaMII (60H3HbIO erO COIO3a C
JIHTOBCKHM BeJIHKIIM KHH3eM IFIJIH >KeJIaHHeM HOKa3aTb nPa-

BOCJIaBHblM
HO只及aHHblMAJIeKcaHnpacoJIHnapHocTbopTonpKcaJIbHoro BacIMHH c HoJIHTMKoi HBaHa lll) 8. 4eJIo 3aKJIIoIIaJIOCb eme B HOTPe6HOCTHⅡOCTaBIITb nO,K KOHTPOJIb II PerJIaMeHTHpoBaTb ｣pa3BHTIie o6beKTHBHo npoJIaraBmIIx ce6e
nppory neHTpo6e]KHblx Te皿eHUlIih BHyTP.II POCCHH、瓜MHTPHii-BHyK, KaK, BII且HMo, noKa3aJIo ero npaBJIeHHe B 1498 r.,
JJIH 3TOii UeJIII 'He rO型mcFI. no)KaJIoBaHIIe Ba'cHJIHHHnpoTHBOHOcTaBJIeHHe erO BOJIOUKIIM KHH3bHM H ncKOBy OCTaBac J I O C b e m I H c T B e H H b l M B b l XO I 0 M .

BHCTOPHIIeCKoii JIHTePaTyPe nOcTaBJIeH BonPOC O naTe
IIpHo6peTeHHH BacHemIIeM THTyJIa BeJIHKoro KHH3H <<'BceH

PyCH>.IirHOPHPOBaHHeKJIOHcKoiiHKOHeBICKOiirPaMOTHOMemaJIo HccJIeXoBaTeJIHM y|cTaHoBHTb, IITo 3ToT TIITyJI BacIi-

JIHii HMeJI eme B aBrycTe l499 r. C Hameii ToIIKII 3peHHH,
npaBHJIbHee roBopHTb He o npIIo6peTeHHH Ba'cIIJIHeM THTyJIa
EeJIHKOrOKHH3HBCeHPyCHHOCJIeBO3BPameHKFIH3PaiiOHa

BH3bMIJI,aoBTopHIIHoM(nocJIel499r)nO>KaJIoBaH"eMy
3 To r o T H T VJ I a .

B cooTBeTcTBHII 'c Ha6JIIonteHHHMH H, A. roJIy6HoBa 9
H. C. JIypbe cIIIITaJI, [ITo BacHJI砿 Ⅲ'BaHOBHII HMeHoIBaJIcH

BeJIIIKHM KHH3eM <<BceH PyCH》c aBrycTa l501 r. lo n>K. eH̲
HeJI oTMeTIIJI ynoMHHaHIie BacHJIHH c THTyJIoM BeqJIHKoro
KHH3H BceH PycH B rpaMoTe MapTa l501 r・l 1 H BLIcKa3aJI
8 H. C. JI y p b e. Hnieo.JIorI円ecKafI ̲6opb6a B pyccKoii ny6JIH山IcTHKe
KoHUa XV - HaIJaJIa XVI BeKa. M.­几, 1960, cTp. 408-409.
9 ACSH, T. I, Nh 637, cTp. 550.

Io H.A. Ka3aKoBa II H. C・JI y p b e. AHT"eo"JIbIIble epeTHIIecKHe
IBIilKelllIH Ha pyCII XIV - Hamana XVI BeKa. M.-J1., 1955, cTp. 205;
月.C・JIypbe.IMeoJIorlI'IecKam 6opb6a…, CTp､408.

'l AC31I, T. II, M 305; J F e n n e l l. Ivan thE Great of Moscow・Lon-

don, 1961, p. 341-342; cp．A、A. 3 H M H H. OcHoBHble npo6JIeMbl
pe*opManHoHHo-ryMaIIHcTHIIecKoro

nBH)KeH"

B

PoccHII

E

XIV-

XVI BB.­くHCTOP", *OJIbKJIOP, PICKyCCTBO CJIaBFIHCKHX HaPOAOB:'.
JoKJI皿瓦coBeTcKo曲且eJIeramlH. V Me>KnlyHapoXHblii c.be3A cJIaBHcToB ICo*", ceHTH6pb l963 r.) . M., 1963, cTp. 107, npIIM，77; oH
]K e. O IIoJIHTH'IecKIIx npe且HO"IJIKaX BO3HIIKHOBeHIIJI PyCCKOro a6CO-

皿oTH3Ma.­噸AOCoJIIoTM3M B Poccmm (XVII-XVIII ")". M., 1964,
cTp. 37, nPHM、80.

174

I

llPenJIOJIO)KeHIIe, qTO, nO!CKOJIbKy JIHTOBCK城nOCOJI Ha3biBaJi
B aclmHfl BeJIIIKIIM KHJI3eM 'B ｡eBpaJIe l501 r｣2, a BepllTemb
HbIe rpaMoTbl HocoJIb:cTBy 6blJIII BblnaHbl B BIiJIbHe B JleKa6･
pe l500 r., BacIIJI" Mor B JleKa6pe l500 r・HOCHTb THTyJI
BeJIHKOrO KHH3H 13.

OXHaKo, |corJIa|cHo BoJIoToBcKoii rpaMoTe, BacIIJI" HMeJI
THTyJI BeJIIIKOTo KHH3H !BceH PycII e皿e ,B CeHTfI6pe l500 r.
THTyJI BacHJIHFI B BoJIoToBcKoii rpaMoTe 'ce|HTFI6pH 1 500 r.
II B rlpaMoTax MapTa II aBrycTa l501 'r. ,coBepmeHHo oJKHHaKOB: <<BeJIHKIIii 'KHH3b Bcefl Py'CH)D B TeK'CTe Ⅲ《KHH3b BeJIHKH> (6e3 cJIo'B <BceH PV&cⅢ》) Ha neIIaTHX.
、

ご

ʼ

II3 KpaTKoro JIeToⅡHCna H3BecTHO, IITO BO3IBPa皿eHIIe Ba̲
cIIJIIIH conpoBo>KXaJIocb <<onaJIoi)> UMIITp"-BHyKa. B (PeBpaJIe l501 r. JIIIToBcK嘘nocOJI nePeXaJI IIOKJIOH <BeJIIIKOMy
KHH310 BacHJIblo, H KHH310 10pblo, II KHH310 JMHTpelo, H KHH-

3Io CeMeHy, II BHyKy BeJIHKo'ro KHH3H, BeJIHIKoMy KHH3Io
UMHTpelo> 14. CJIeloBaTeJIbHo, ">Ke nocoJIhcKHii UepeMoHHaJI oTpa3HJI BO3Bbl皿eHIIe Ba'cIIJIHfl H noHH>KeHHe nMIITp"⑥

BHyKa,

KOTOPblH

xoTH |H COxPaHHJI TIITyJI

BeJIHKOrO KHH3H,

IIO BIIOBb OKa3aJICH Ha nOCJIenHeM MeCTe B nePeIIHe noKJIO-

HoB, KaK Io 1498 r. OnaJIa nMHTPHFI Hoc"a no-B皿HMOMy,
nOJIyO,"liaJIbHblit XaPaKTeP"
OIIeBH且HO, nOCJIe BO3'BPa皿eHwI BacIIJIHH, co BTopoii no-

JIoBHHbl l500 r., 4MHTpHi lnepecTaJI IonycKaTbcH K 'KaKoMy
6bI To HH 6blJIo,八a)Ke (bOPMaJIbHOMy yIIaCTIIIO B rOCyXaPCTBeHHblx neJIax. C Mafl l500 no anpeJIb l502 rr. (Koma

,nMHTPHimOIIaJI B o｡"IIaJIbHylo OnaJIy) oH He ynOMHHaerCfl
B JIeTO.IIHCHx・HHKaKKx cBenleHHiI o HeM 3a 3To BPeMH
△ HeT H
B

aKToBblx

HcToqHHKax.

B

IIocoJIbcKHx

3anHcHx

1501-

1502 rr. (KpoMe ynoMHHyTo曲巾eBpaJIbcKO-MaPToBcKOii 3anIIcH 1501 r.) He巾HryPHPylOT HOKJIOHbl八eTHM H BHyKy.
B *eBpaJIe - MapTe l501 r. Ha6JIIo"eTcH RaJIbHe曲mee
yKpe'mleHIie no31iUmii Bac'HJIIm. B sTo BpeMH IBo3po>KIaeT℃fl
npoeKT JKeHHTb6bl ero Ha npIIHne'c'ce EJIH3aBeTe, pp[IepII naTcKoTo KopoJIH. HaMeKIeHHaH Ha BecHy l501 r. cBa1Xb6a EJIH3aBeTbl H IIOaxHMa l, KyP｡IOPCTa BPa皿eH6yprcKorO, B yKa⑫

3a|HHblH 'c'pOK He COcToHJIaCb 'nO nPHIIHHe He'cOBeP皿eHHOJIe-

THH JKeHHxa (eMy HcHoJIH"ocb l8 JIeT ToJIbKo 21 ｡eBpaJIH
12 "C6．PIIO", T. 35, cTp. 310; cp．A. A. 3 M M II H. OcHoBHLIe npo6JIe･ Mb1.･･, cTp･107, npHM. 77; o H IK e. O noJIHTIIIIecKHx npemocDIJIKax…，
cTp. 37, npHM. 80.

13 J. F e n n e l l. Op. cit., p. 342.
14 <C6. PIIO>, T、35, cTp. 310｡
175

1502H
r.)ocJIo]KHeHIIMCOmBeuHe曲15.HBaHIIICHOBaBblcTVnHJI
c叩eTeH3Heii
Ha
KaPeJIb､cKHe
BoJIOCTH
aipe",
HcKHC
U

ジ

H CaBOJIaKC !6 II O八HOBPeMeHHO nOmBeP4HJI IIP"JIO]KeHHe O
>KeHIITb'6e BacIMJIIIH Ha E皿3aBeTe !7. naTcK" KOPOJIb 'CTPeMHJIcH OTKJIOHIITb nonl 6JIaroBIIXHblM nPenJIOrOM TePPHTOPH-

aJIbHble'8II,OIIeBII,nHO,MaTPHMOHHaJIbHblen@JIaHblBeJIHKOrO

KHH3H(BecHoiil502r.E皿3aBeTaBb皿JIa,Ha'KOHeU,3aMyIK
3a lioaXHMa ｣9).

HBaHIII HeorPaHIIIIHJI｣cHnpe八ocTaBJIeHIIeMBac'HJIHIo
U

mpamjiipaBliTeJIII'jorH9meHIilIHoBTopoXcKoii3eM"̲":
U

U

U

B̅MapTe l501 r. BacIIJImit, co)ppaHIIBm" BHoBb noJIygWW
B1500r・TIITVJI'Be,JIKKoroKHH3H<<BceHPycH>P,pacnopmKaル
cH 3eMeJIbHblMH旦eJIaMH B BeJIOO3ePe, KOTOPOe oII Ha3bl"J1

耐輌翫̅万堀iO" 20. B o皿cHoii KiiHre PoMaHoBcKoro Bo⑪

u

roHBJIeHcKoro MoHacTblpH 1743 r. ynoMHHaeTcH《rocy,naPeBa

rpaMoTaKHH3HBeJIHKoIlqBaclIJIb3̲MoaH9Wa3alWW"
Be|CJIOIOnellaTblO…》oT18MapTal501r.2[TaKHMo62a30V,
u

BMapTel501r.BacHJIHiiBJIa八eJIIIa'cTblo'6blBmeroBepeii6K5-EeJIo3ep'cKoro
KHmKecTBa
BeJIoo3epoM
He60JIbmmM
II
U

'5 C. F. A l l e n Elisabet, Prindsesse af Pannl3r!<, .Kllriyrstinde ､ "

Efafld6i66fg̅KGKI855, s. 5; <Dansk biografisk Leksik%', VI
Kbh., 1935, s. 291-292.

16 10.uH.皿ep6aIIeB. Konelll､areHCK}le aKTbl) OTHOCHml1eCH K PyC-

CKOiM
IICTOPHH,
Bbln、1.1326-1569rr.M.,1915,Nb4,cTp、5-8;

LEKUB, 2:te Abt., Bd. 2, S. 99, Nb l51a (yKa3ana H nepeBena co
cTapoHeMeUKoroA.几XopomKeBIIEI).
1710．H.皿e p 6 a q e B. maTcK" ̲apxMB. MaTep"JIbl､,､Io !lcT9R皿
噂

,DPeBHeit
Pocc",̲
xPaHg皿HecH
B
KOneHrareHe.
1326-1690
rr2­《qTe-

IIIIH OⅢ且P>, 1893, kH. 1, IoT,Ⅲ.] 1, cTP. 2-3, JVh 3 (yKaSa" 5. H･JIp-

PH)O
; H]Ke.KOneHrareHCKHeaKTbl…,Nb4,cTp.658.Bo6elIxpa60u

Tax皿eP6aIleBa COO6皿aeTcjl o AaTcKOM nepeBonle HaKa3HoIi PeIIII
PycCKMx .nocJIoB "TCKoMy KOPOJIIO; B aTOM neIleB･4e ly""" Ig"

PIITCH
O八OIIePII
BeJIKKOro
KHfl3JI
CbIMg
II
IfqP9",
j<OTH瓜OJDKHO
6blTb

Hao60poT,KaK
Unpe皿oJIaraJIy)KeIIIO．H・皿ep6aIIeB.BHocJIaHIIH

mBeptCkoro PeiixcPaTa UaH皿fy oT l aBrycT4 1501 r・yKa3blBaeTCH,

""m6"" i,JIa

dXe""e Ba"JIIm . (Eaqlli,llI

Magllu")

k6"656kb"6Mepm (LEKUB, 2.te Abt., Bd.2, s. !9, " !214.

Ha

u

u

1810．H・皿ep6aqeB.I<oneHrareHCKHeaKTbl...,Nb4.mae八cKHH
PeiixcPal, nmcam, nPaB",｣T2JfOP"b n9WI"W｡ BWImfphW, KIWFI9gW･
”

"6 6nopHble deM)IH (LEKUB2 ̅2-te Abt., Bd. 2, S、99, M 151a),
OiHaKO aia mHTePnPeTaUlifl CO6LIT" enBa JIm pIIOJIH2 JOPTOBPPH4:

19 5̅F:̅Ane n dp." cit, S 6; F. W a g ne r. DeX Schaiz ､ deI KIW

ftjrstin Elisabeth - von Brandenbur9.-<〈Hohenzollern-Jahrbuch", V1.

"M-rijEEE ig62r S. 71; <bansk biografisk Leksikon...", V1,
s. 291.

20 ACSH, T. 11, JW 305.
2' rnB, THToB 4638, @J1. 90.
176

KycKOM 6blBmero yrJIIInKOrO ymeJIa - POMaHOBcKHM ye30

0

JIOM色色．

̅

Jo 1501 r. BeJIoo3epo Haxo"JIo'cb B ynpaBJIeHHH BacIIJIHH, OIIBBH1Ho, IBa>KnLI - B 1485 1I l492 rr., 'Ho B o60Hx
cJIVIIaHx He KaK ,<<oIIHHa>>. B l498 r. BeJIoo3epoM BenaJ1

瓜MHTP "-BH'yK・qTO KaCaeTICH yrJI皿Koro yneJIa, To BacHJ1Hii lPaHee He BJIaneJI HHKaKIIMII erO rlacTHMII, a nMHTpHihBHyK HMeJI B 1498 r. |npaBa !Ha Be)KeUKHii Bepx, BxoJHBm砿
B cocTaB KWI>KecTBa AHnpeJI BoJIb皿oro. B l501 r. BnepBble
B acHJIH曲 noJIy[IHJI o,mHoIBPeMeHHO IIacTb 6eJIo3ePcKoro，H

yr皿mKOr|OHaCJIe"CTBaBHOJIHOeyneJIb'HOeO6JIanlaHHe.3TO
6blJIo HaIIaJIOM yXOBJIeTBOPelIHH naBHMmHIIX nPHTFI3aHIIih
BaclIJIIIH Ii ero <<naPTHII>'.

IIHTePecHa TePPHToPliaJIbHaFI Han'PaBJIeHHoIcTb BHyTPeHHei noJII1TIIKII I'IBaHa lll B H3y'laeMbIit oTPe30K BPeMeHH

B neKa,6|pe l500­月HBape l501 r. IM'Ba'H npoHBJIHJI BHHMaIIIIe K ropoxo皿y 23 H HpOCJIaBJIIO 24, OqeBHIHO, CTPeMHCb
HeiiTpaJIH30BaTb Bo3Mo)KHble npeTeH3HH BacIIJIml Ha aTH
ye3XbI, ymeJIbHo nomBeXoMcTBeHHble eMy B l496 Ii l497 rr.
B 7009 r. (Me邪ﾕy ceHTH6PeM l500 PI aBrycToM 1501 r.)
ZBaH III BblnaJI )KaJIoBaHHylo rpaMoTy TpoIIne-CeprIIeBy

MoHacTblPIo Ha ceJIa MaJIoHpocJIaBenKoI､O ye3,ma 25. nOHBJIeHIIe 3Toh rPaMOTbl cJIenyeT PaccMaTPHBaTb B cBeTe naHIIblx O

HoJIy'IeHIIH BacwIIIeM BeJIoo3epa, noIcKoJIbKy MaJIbli HpocJYaBeU 6blJI cocTaBHoii [IacTblo yneJIa MIIxalIJIa AHnipeeBIitla

BeJIO3ePCKOrO・m｣BaHIII,｣He>KeJIaHoTnaBaTbBaIcHJIMIIoBce
TePPIIToPmH BblMopoIIHOro 6eJIo3ePcKorO y八eJIa, yKpenJIRJI
CB O｢ⅢⅡPaBa Ha Te H3 HIIx, KoTOPble B y,cJIOBIIHx PyICcKO-JIII-

TOBCKOit BO伽･lbI IIMeJIH BajKHOe CTPaTerlIqeCKOe 3HaIIeHKe

(MaJIbli gpocJIaBen) . CKopee Bcero, Bbl"qa rPaMoTbl cocToHJIacb oKoJIo MapTa l501 r･, II60 np aToro BacIIJIHii, HoBH且HMoMy, He HMeJI 6eJIO3ePCKOro HacJIeXcTBa, a B nePlIOX

Me>K,n{y anPeJIeM H IIIoHeM oH oT6blJI B TBepb 26. BepoFITHo,
B 1500 r. BJIaneHPIH B ye34e MaJIoro HpocJIaBUa noJIy'IHJI

Iiepe皿e,Ⅱ皿嘘H|a cJIy>K6y K HBaHy lll KHH3b BacMJIIIih HBa-

22 0 nplIHanl､me>KHocTH PoMaHoBa AHnpelo BoJIb皿oMy cM.: mlnr, Nb 82.
23 AC31I, T. 111, JYb 114.
24 TaM >Ke, M 221.
25 TaMンKe, T. 1, JV@ 631.

26 <<Pa3pfuHaH KImra l475-1598 rr.>. M., 1966, cTp. 3 1 ; rnB, 3pMI･IT.
390, .m. 25-25 06. (noJIb3yIocb MalnⅢHOmlCHOFI KOⅡⅡe曲, nPe40CTaBJ1ellIIoih MHe B. H. ByraHoBblM).
12

C. M. KamTaHoB

177

HOBHII皿eMflIIHII 27. B KaKoji Mepe 6LIJIa BbI3BaHa BbInaqa
rPaMOTbl CTPeMJIeHIieM OrPaHHIIIITb erO nOJIIITHLIeCKOe B皿畑一
R J

HHe B STOM PaHOHe, CKa3aTb TpyIHO.

rpaMoTa BBoXmJIa HoByIo, npHMeHFIBmylocH c l500 r,
HOPMy OrPaHH[IeHIiH MOIIa'CTblPCKOrO Cynte6HOro IIMMyHIITeTa, H3blMaH H3 11ero pymery6cTBo II |pa360ii 'c noJIIIII|HblM.
①HKcaUHH no八CyXHOCTH MOHaCTblPcKOro npHKa3IIHKa H KPecTbHH IB HCKOBblx EleJIax BeJI'HKOKHH)KeCKOMy nPaBIITeJIb|cTBy

cOnPOBo)KnaJIacb ycTa|HOBJIeHHeM JByx |CPOKoB Bbl30Ba KPe-

cTbHH B |cynl. 3HaIIMT, TPoIIUKme MaJIOHPocJIaBeUKIIe ceqJTa
CTaBHIJIHICb nOA 60JIee 'cTpOrH曲KOH叩OJIb UeHTPaJIbHOji BJIaU

CTH) LIeM BJIa,八eHIIH HOBrOPonicKIIx MOHaCTblPelI, o KoTOpblx
mJIa PeIIb Bblme.

B Mae - HIoHe l501 r. liIBa|HoM III npoBo瓜HJI a'Cb lOBOJIb-

HoaKTH.BHaHHOJI'HTHKaBraJIIIUKoM281IMocKoBcKoM29ye3nax. BHHMaHHe K raJIHIIy Mo>KHo o6bfIcHIITb XBoHKo: c "HO的cTOPOHbl, OH HaXO八皿cH, O'IeB皿Ho, B C｡epe IIHTePeCOB
Ba,cIIJIHH, ynpaBJIHBmero B l485 II 1491/92 rr. coce"eii KocTPOMOih; c JPyrOii cTOPOHbl, nPaBa Ha raJIIIII M|Or nPe瓜もHBIITb nepemeﾕ皿mhB l500 r. 'nonl |cIo3epeHHTeT Iri｣BaHa lll
KHH3b BaIcHJIIIii l'IBaHoBIIII皿eMHII|IIII, |nPane4y KOTo｣POrO
HeKoma nPHHantJIe)KaJI 3ToT cTaPHHHblii yneJIbHblii UeHTP.
B MocIKoBcKoM ye3八e nOJIHTIIKa JIOKaJIH30BaJIa'cb !B PaiiO|He
nexoPcKorO cTaHa, oKPy>KeHHoTO c BOcTOKa BOJIOCTHMH,

npe班瓜e BXO皿BmHMH B ynteJI IOpHH Ba'cIIJIbeBH'Ia mMIITpoBcKoro H BHocJIe"cTBHH nepemeXIIIHMH K AHnpeIo CTaplInKoMy cOrJIacHO nyxOBHO曲HBaHa lll (DKeJIb, BoxHa li ".).
Bo3Mo>KHo, B l501 r. 3TH BoJIocTH cTaJIII o6'beKToM npeTeII3Hii BaCliJIHFI WII,I MJIa及山HX y4eJIbllblX KHFI3ei, B CBH31i C

IIeM H HaBo4HJIcH nOPH八oK B 3eMeJIbllblX八eJIax 6JIH3KOrO
K CnOPHblM TePPHTOPIIHM CTaHa.

K HHBaplo l501 r. oTHocmTcH BbmaLla npaBoji rpaMoTb｣

Ha 3eMJIH FIpocJIaBcKoro ToJIrcKoro MoHacTblpH 30. B poJIM
cy,Ⅱb'H Bbl'Cme曲 ⅢH|CTaHUliH B 3TOM 叩aMOTe BbICTynaeT
HBaH III. B 1500/01 r. HBaH, |BMIIMo, orlacaJIcFI 3a cynlb6y

HpocJIaBJIFI, KoTopblii B 1496 r. ,6bIJI o皿a:H B yneJI BacHJIHIo.

27

B 1505 r. npoBo且mJICH Pa3'be3,m erO 3eMeJIb

B MaJIOFIPoC,JIaBenKOM

ye3"e c 3eMJIFIMII TpoI皿e-CeprlleBa MoIIacTbl" (ACSH, T. I, JYb 659) .
２８ TaM ]Ke, T. 111, Nh250, 251.
２９
TaM >Ke, T. 11, JYU 424.
３０

TaM )Ke, T. 111, JVb 221.

178

HecMoT" - Ha oTnpaBKy BeJIIIKoro KHH3H BacIIJIHfl B
TBepb B l501 r., TBePoKOro KHa>KeHHH oH, o[IeBH且HO, He nO-

"yIIiiJL KalUi B l492/" r" c｡epa Ul)oHBJIe¥"yXeJIbHbIx
nOJIHoMoIIIIit BacIIJIHH IIBaIIoBHLIa B TBepcKo# 3eMJIe orpaHⅡ噸BaJ'a,cb Ka皿PIHcKIIM ye3npM. OJJHaKo caMH sTII HoJI!Ho-

MoIIIIH 6blJIH Bbl'Pa>Kellbl 60JIee OnPeXeJI,eHHo, IIeM B
1492/93 r., Korna BacHJIHi ToJIbKo 'noITBep>KmaJI HMMyHH-

TeTHble rpaMoTbl. B l501 r. oH BblmaJI )KaJIoBaHHylo rpaMo-

Ty Tpomme-CeprlieBy MoHacTbI'pIo Ha lBop c noJIJIHoii B Ka-

皿1He Ha nOcane 31' 3To 6blJIa BToPafl nO CLIeTy (HOCJIe rPaMOTbl PoMaHOBcKOMy MoHa'CTbIPIO) caMocToHTeJIbHO BblnaHHaH BalcHJIHeM )KaJIoBall'I-laH rpaMOTa・OHa KacaJIacb Tex >Ke

o6beKToB, qTo 'H rpaMoTa li|Ba|Ha HBaHoBIIIIa l487 r., noXnIICaHHaH HaHMFI BaCIIJI" B 1492/93 r.32

HopMbl HMMyHIITeTa, 3a(PMKcIiPoBaHHble B rpaMoTe
1501

r.,

HaxomflTcFI

B flBIHoM

npoTIIBo'pe[IIIII 'c npIIHIlHnaMH

H MMyllIITeTHO曲noJIIITHKII IIBaHa lll 90-x roIo'B XV-HaIIaJIa XVI B. XoTH Ho cPaBIIeHHIo 'c npe且mecTByIOmeit rpaMOTOiM Ha KamHHCKmiⅡBoP (1461-1466 rr. 33) no"THoii
IIMMyHHTeT npenoIcTaBJIHJIcH MoHacTblplo B rpaMoTe l501 r.
B orpaHH[IeHHoM o6beMe (BⅢHcJIeoTMeHeHHblxHaJIoroBH
nO皿JIHIH He ynOMHHalOTIcH FIM,く瓜eJIO>",

MblT, TaMra,

nHTeH-

Hoe lI JP.), o皿aKo OH Oc,TaBaJI'CH Bce e皿e3HaIIHTeJIbflblM

(ocBo60)KnleHHe oT "HH, noco皿HOii CJIy>K6bl H《ⅡomJIH") ,
a cyne6Hblii IIMMyHHTeT pe3Ko palcmmpHJIcH (B rpaMoTe 60-x
rOnOB H3 BOTIIHHHOii lO'PHc瓜HKnHII HICKJIIoIIaJIHCb Pa360ii,

且ymery6cTBo II TaTb'6a c |noJIIIIIHblM, B rpaMoTe l501 r.TOJI bKO Iy皿ery6cTBo, npHqeM K 3ToMy 'nplIcoemIHHJIocb ocBo60)KnleHHe oT HaMec'IYHIIIIbHx KopMoB H no60poB npaBeni、

IIHKOBH瓜OBOAqlIKOB) .

BacIIJIHit yKpenJIflJI cBoIo BJIacTb BBemellHeM B rpaMoTy
cTaTbH o HOJIC|ynHO!cTH eMy HryMGHa 'Ii erO npllKa3[IHKa. 3Ta
cTaTbH nOCHraJIa Ha nPePOraTHBbI He MIITpo'IIoJIHTa, a BeJIHU

KOrO KHH'3H, 'KOTOPbllI HBJIHJICH且JIH TpOHuKOrO HryMeHa lcy4b-

eii Bblc皿eii IIHcTaHUHH |cor@macHo rpaMoTaM 1492 1､、
Coxp aHHBm城cH MaTePHaJI HO3BoJIFIeT IyMaTb, IITO, |nOJIyIIIIB KamHHcK" yneJI, BacHJI" BpeMeHHo ,noTepHJI BeJIoo3epo H, Bo3Mo2KHo, PoMalloB. B npaBoi rpaMoTe ,Ha
6eJIO3ePcKIie 3eMJIH anPe@ﾉIH 1502 r. B poJIH cynlblI Bblcmek
３
１ TaM >Ke, T. I, Nb 637.
３
２
rnB, noro瓜．1905, J1. 64 06., Nb 47
３
３

ACSH, T. 1, JVb 298.

179

12＊

HHCTaHnHpI BblCTynaeT IIBa'H III 34; II3 npaBOii rPaMOTbl
aBrycTa l502 r. cJIenyeT, IITo cy4 6blJI HaqaT npH BacHJIHII,
Ho 3aKoHIIeH npli llBaHe lll 35. CoeJJIHeHHe Bcex aKToBblx II
JI eTOⅡHcHbIx naHHblx o BacIMHII 3a l501-1502 rr. B exIIHvIo
xPOHOJIOrHIIecKyIO Uenb XaeT CJIenylo皿ylo KaPTHHy: B MaPTe

1501 r. BacIIJImii HMeJI B yneJIbHoM BJIaneHIM BeJIoo3epo II
PoMaHoB; 24 MapTa B MoIcKBy BblexaJI n,cKoBIc:KIiji KHR3b
AJIeKcaHIp BJIaJIHMHpoB1III, a TeM BpeMeHeM B MapTe - anPeJIe lI, oIIeBHIHO, n03)Ke ncKOBII1IH HeoXHOKPaTHO O6Pallla-

JTHcb K HBaHy lll II BacIMHIo I/I'BaHoBwIy lc 'nPocb6aMII o
BoeHHoii noMomH B 60pb6e c JIHBoHcKHM o"eHoM 36; B KaKoe-To BpeMH Me>Kny anpeJIeM H HIoI-IeM BacPIJI" yexaJI B

TBepb ,c BoeBoXaMH H JIBopeUKHM B. I'I．roJIeHIIHbIM; B aBrycTe l501 r. oH BblnaJI rpaMoTy TpomUe-CeprmeBy MoHaICTblPIO !Ha KamlIHcK砿且BoP; B oKTH6'pe l501 r・くBeJIHKHe

KHH3H HBall Ba:cMJIbeBIIIIb II BacHJIehHBalHOB'H'Ib> nPII'cJIaJIH HICKOBH[laM HOBoe no4KPenJIeHme 4J1側nPOnPJI>KeHIIH BOii-

Hbl c JIHBoHUaMII 37; l l anpeJIH l502 r. ,co'cToHJIacb o｡H皿一
aJIbHaH (H OKoHIIaTeJIbHaFI) OnaJIa nMHTpHH-BHyKa, |KoTOpblii
6blJI JIHmeH BeJIHKoKHFI>KecKoro TIITy,IIa 38, 13 anpeJIH
HIBaH III H BacIIJIHih coBMecTHo BbInaJTH IBe )KaJIoBaliHble

rPaMOrrbl 'noMe皿H'KaM皿eJI OH'CKOhnflTHHbl HoBropoIcKoro
ye34a 39, 3TH rpaMOTbl KaCaJIH,Cb 3eMeJIb B nerO)KCKOM nOrocTe, p6paUeHIIoM K JIIIToBcKoMy TeaTpy BoeHHblx neii-

CTB" 40,IIHMeJIHHe TOJIbKOBHyTPHnOJilITHqeCKylO,HOII
BHe皿HenoJIHTHIIeicKylo HanpaBJIeHHoIcTb; 14 anpeJIfl HBaH III
《Ⅱo)KaJIoBaJI cblIHa cBoero BacmJIIIa, 6JIaTocJIo|BIM ,H no,caJIHJI

gaBeJIIwKoeKHH>KeH'MeBoJIoJMMepcKoeHMocKoBcKoeHBcea

PycHH caMoJpL>KneM,no6JIarObJIoBellHIoCHMoHaMHTponOJIIITa Bcea PyCHH》41; 12 MaH I502 r・nOBeJIe'HIIeM IIBa-

HalllHBalcIIJIHHHa[IaJIoIcbKpyinHoeo60poiHHoecTpoIITeJIb34 AC3H, T・I1, Nb 336.
35 TaM >Ke, Nb 337.

36《ncKoBcKme JIeToHIIcII>, Bbln. I, cTp. 84-85.
37 TaM )Ke, cTp. 86.

38 nCPJI, T. VI, cTp. 48, 243; T. V111, cTp. 242; T. XII, cTp. 255; T. 20
nepBa兜noJIoBIIHa, cTp. 373; T. 23, cTp・197; T. 26｡ cTp. 295; T. 28,
cTp. 336.

39 g. H C a M o K B a c o B. ApxIIBHblii MaTepliaJI, [T・II M., 1905, oTn.
II, cTp. 7, 8.

40 ner)KO­norocT Ha p. meJIoHII, He八aJIeKo OT ee lICToKOB, K IOro-BOCToKy oT 3Tgro. nOrocTa Haxo".mcFI XoJIM, K ceBepo-3anany - nopxoB
(cM. KaPTy K. A. HeBoJIIIHa).

41 CM. cH. 38, a TaK>Ke T. 30, cTp. 139.
180

1

cTBo B HoBroPone 42; 16 HIoHH 1502 r. BacwIIIii BbUaJI )Ka-

JIoBaHHyIo rpaMoTy noKpoBcKoMy ymlmKoM'y MoHacTblplo
Ha BoTIIIIHbI B Be)KeUKoM Bepxe 43; JIeToM l502 r. (Io aBrycTa) Ba'cHJT" BJIaleJI BeJIoo3epoM.
TaKoe pa!cnpenleJIeHIIe cBeneHIIii roBopHT He ,cToJIbKo o
coBMellIeHHII Ba'cIIJIHeM pa3JTHII|Hblx ｡yHKⅡ砿 H TeppIITOpHaJIDHblx nPaB, cKOJIbKO O 'Ia:cTBIX ｣nePeMeHax B erO .n'OJIO>KeHIIH, KoToPOe OcTaeTcH cTaOIIJIb｣HblM JIIImb B OIHOM OTHO一

meHIIII: c 1500 r. BacHJIHii HeII3MeHHo HoJIb3veTcfl THTvJIoM
ヅ

ジ

BeJIHKOrO IぐHFI3JI B|ceFI PycH. MapToB'cKHi 3IItcneplIMeHT
l501 r.-'nepenaLIa Ba'cwIIIIo HeKoToPblx qacTeit BepeiicKoBeJIO3ePCKOrO 'm yrJIHHKOrO KHH>KeCTB,- OIIeBImHO, y>Ke B
anpeJIe
ユ

VcTVnaeT
ゴ

ジ

M e c To

H ! c I To J I b 3 0 B a H I ' I I o

ero

B

DoJIH

人

IconOa入

BHTeJIH OTUa, HBJIHBmerOCH <<KHH3eM HOBrOPOICKI'IM II nCKOB-

CKIIM>> (BO3MO>KHO, B CBH､3II C HOBbIMHⅡpeTeH3HHMH HBaHa
Ha KapeJIbcKIIe BoJIocTIM H npeXJ1'o>Ke:HIIeM >KGHHTb BacHJI|HH

Ha EJIH3aBeTe), 3aTeM BaCH皿歯oTnpaBJIHeTcH B TBepb, Ha
Ka'Koii-To |cpoK nonyIIaeT KamlIHcKH曲yneJI, cHOBa Bo3BPa
皿aeTcH K IICHOJIHeHIIIo '(byHKU" cOnPaBHTeJIH KHH3FI 'HoBroPOXcKoro H |nCKOBcKoTo II ToJIbKO IIePe3 1Ba MeCHUa noCJIe

nOCTaBJIeHHHHa BeJIHKoe K|HH>Ke'HH|e <BJIalIIMepcKoe H Moc-

KoB'cKoe)> ( 14 anpeJIFI l 502 r.) oIIHTb nplIo6peTaeT [IacTb
yrJI皿Koro yneJIa (Be)KeUKH曲Bepx) , a BcIKope H BeJIoo3ePo
XapaKTep 'BI-IyTpHnoJIHTHIIecKo曲60Pb6bl HaKaHyHe ona'mbI IMHTpllFI-BHyKa IIe BnoJIHe HceH. Bo3Mo>KHo, oTbe31
BacHJIHH B TBepb H Ha3HaIIeHHe ero KHH3eM KamHHcKHM
BeCHOカーJIeToM l501 r.- Mepbl, BI)13BaHHble lYpIITH3aHIIFIMH

IIa TBepcKoe KHFI>KeHIIe UMIITPIIH-BHyKa, oTeU KoToporo
IIPaBHJI TBepbIo !B l485-1488 rr.
BoJIbme MO>KiHO cKa3aTb O nOJIHTHIIeCKoii 60Pb6e nOCJIe

OnaJ'b'nMIITpH兄.OIIeHbH;HTePecHoHaJI池meXByXMeCHIIHOrO
IIPOMe>KyTIKa Me>KXy 'cO6blTIIHMH cePeⅡⅢHbl a:npeJIH 1502 r.
m peaJIbl-IblM npoFIBJIeHHeM npalB Ba:cHJIHFI Ha Be>Kem〈1曲

Bepx B HIoHe. HecJIy[IaiiHbli xaPaKTep 3Toro pa3PblBa noXTBep>KIaeTcH conocTaBJIeHIIeM npaBblx rpaMoT 1502 r., H3
KoToPoro cJIeXyeT, LITo B an:peJIe l502 r. BacIMHii e皿e He

PaCnOPH>KaJICH BeJIOO3ePOM, HO nP aBryCTa y>Ke IIMeJI nPaBa Ha 'Hero. Oco6eHHo cHMnToMaTHIIHa 'BblnaIIa rpaMoT oT
o6be皿IHeHHoro JIPIUa HBaHa lll lI BacHJIHH Ha l-IoBropOnCKHe 3eMJIH 6yKBaJIbHO rlePe3 neHb nOcJIe OnaJIbl JMHTP".
42 nCPJ1, T. 1V, q. 1 , Bbln. 3, cTP. 61 1
43 AC3II, T. 111, Nb 82.

181

npIIBJIeIIeHHe BacHJIwI K paccMoTpeHHIo .BonpocoB, cBfl3aHHblx c HoBropoHoM, 3aciBMIeTe@mbcTBoBaHo II B JIeTo|nHIcHoM
TeKcTe non l 2 MaH l 502 r. Co3naeTcH BneIIaTJIeHHe, tlTo,

nocanlIB BacIMHFI Ha BeJIIIKoe KHFI>KeHHe B"ﾉIa凡IIMIIpCKOe lI
Mo'cKoB,cKoe, IIBaH III cTpeMH"cFI xoTFI 6bl lleKoToPoe BpeU

MH yneP)KaTb CblHa B OrPaHH'IGIIHOH POJIH CBOerO COnPa|BII-

TeJIH no HoBroPOXCKIIM XeJIaM 44
B cepe旦HHe alnpeJIH - cepe"IHe llIoHFI 1502 r・npo6JIeM a
pa31eJIeHIIH c｡ep BJIIIHH" npIIo6peJIa 60JII,nlylo ocTpoTy.
Bo3Mo]KHo, IIMeHHo K sToMy BpeMeHII oTHocHTcH BTopo曲
｡

nPO|eKT 'Pa34aIIII yneJIOB MJIa且mIIM Icbl'HOBbf1M, OTMe'IeHHblH B

JIeTomlcUe JIyPbe OnflTb-Ta'KH KaK 'coBepmHB山油CH ｡aKT:
<<Bb JIeTo 7010 0TnvIcTHJI KHFI3b BeJIHK砿瓜eTe'cBomx KHH3H

IOpbH na K.HfI3月瓜MHTPefl Ha yneJI Bb mMII叩OB II Ha yr̲
JIe'I> 45.

npoEKT, no Bcei BepofITHocTH, He 6bmⅡPOBeneH B >KII3Hb,
p

U

IIO BO3HIIK OH, BM瓜HMO, 4JIH IHellTPaJI'H3auHHTep P liTOP liaJIb-

Hblx npeTeH3Hii BacHJIIIH, rpaWIoTa KoTo'poro no｣KpoBIcKoMy
yrJIIIUKOMy MOHacTblPlO HOKa3blBaeT, qTo BeJIHKOMy KHH310
BacIIJIIIIo HBaHoBIIIIy nocTaJIcH B yXeJI Be>KeUKHii Bepx.

Ha|BepHoe, HBall lll npe八noJIaraJI nPenPCTaBHTb yrJIHIY
nMIITPHIO nBa *aKTa nO3BOJIFIIOT CIIHTaTb nPOeKT Pa3naIIm yneJIoB B 1502 r. HeocymecTBJIeHHblM: 21 IIIoHfl l502 r.

I'IBaH III BblnaJI >KaJIoBaHHylo rpaMoTy TpoIIUe-CepmeBy
U

MoHacTblPIo

Ha

nPoe3X

MOHacTblPcKHx

sKcne瓜HUHH Ⅱo

nMIITpoBcKoMy ye3ny46; 14 11IoJIH 1502 r" HBaH III oTnpaBIIJI B CMOJIeHCK砿ⅡOXOⅡ且MHTpHfI 47, npeTe皿eHTa Ha
44 B HaIIaJIe l503 r. o"eHMeiicTePy AoHocIIJm H3 noJIoUKa, IITo o瓜HH
IIJlel･IHIJIii,･6e)KaBmllil l43 MOCKBbl，cKa3aʻ可、6ymTo BacM｡mllii 3aKJIIoIIIM
cOIo3 C HeKOToPbIMI'I BJIHFITem)IbHeiimIIMII BeJIIJMo)KaMM H xOTeJI H3BeCTH

BeJIIIIKOTOKHFI3FI;y3HaBo63ToM,I]oCJYe皿砿aPeCTOBaJICbIWa,anP)t

TMX 6e3>KaJIoCTHO II Pa3I･IblMII CHOCo6aMII Ka3HIIⅡ；CTaPbli BeJIHKHii
KHFI3b HIIKOMy He Pa3PemaeT HH B'IJe3>KaTI> B cTpaHy, HII Bble3>KaTb II3

Hee; OH cTaJI nOn03PHTeJIeH I1 60HTCFI, IITO B cTPaHe nPOII30imeT 60JTbmaH pacnl)FI. OIHaKo npeZcTaBIITeJIH o"eHa Bblpa31IJIII ̲KpaiiHee He40Beplie K 3ToMy II3BGcT}IIo (LEKUB, 2-te AI)t., Bd. 2, Nb 441 , S 333;
yKa3aJIa lI nepeBeJIa co cTapoHeMenKoro A.几XopomKeBHq). UeicTBIITeJIbHo, H1Iqero noXo6Horo no pyccKIIM HcToIIHIIKaM IIe Ha6JIIomaeTcFI, a co6bITIIFI, omlcaHHble mlGHIIblM, HanoMIIHaloT 3aro'Bop l497 r.

45,H.C・J1 ypbe・KpaTKI'Iii JIeTonHceu norozIIIHcKoTo co6paH順.­《Apxeorpa"qecKIIji
e)KGI,o皿HK 3a l962 roﾕ沙M.、1963, cTp. 443.
46 rnB, norom. 1905, &T. 57-57 06., Nb 33.
47 nCPJI, T、VI, cTI). 48; T̲ VIII, cTp. 242-243; T. XII, cTp. 256; T. 20,
nepBaHno&noBIIIIa, c1･p. 373; 'r. 23, cTp. 197; T、24, cTp. 214; T、26,
cTp、295-296; T. 28, cTp. 336; <<Pa3pmlHafI KHIira...>, cTp. 34.
182

／

yrJ1HⅡKHhnpecTo｡IT.MapmpyT,noKoTOpoMypa3pe皿aJIcfl
U

6eCnOmJIH
HHblm
ⅡPOe3nl
MOHaCTblPCKOHくJIonKIM
noPy6c
ne" OxBaTbIBaJ]HeTOJIbKOmMiITPQBCK"ye3n(IIMHTpOB-HxpoMa - CecTpa-Ⅱy6Ha= BoJIra) , HQ M yrJI皿一
U

⑪

K戒(<<Bo)IToIoBHII3nbycTbH,mq̲moxoHcKoI､O)>),aTaK>Ke
BeJIo3epcKHii ("I B moKcTHy>) . Ha BceM npoTH>KeHIIII9To-

rO
nyTIi
rPaMoTy
nOJI>KHbl
6bmlI
Co6JIIOnaTb《HamH沙(IﾉIBaHa lll) HaMeCTHIIKII, BOJIocTeJIH, Hx THyHbl, nPHKa3IJHKH,
MblTIIIIKII II BCe nOmJIHHHHKI1.

1'IBaH III Hv>KnaJIcFI B 'coIo3e 'c T|poIme-CeprlieBblM MoHa-

cTblpeMIJIHyiep>KaHIIH3aco60h且MHTPOBa,yr皿Ila1ioT-

【IacfII BeJIoogePaB onmcHblx KHIIraX TpQ"Koro 6eJIo3ep･

cKoroycTb-meXoHcKoToMoHaicTblpH1678/79r.ynoMIIHaeT℃H
<rpaMOTa>KaJIOBaHHafInPOe3XiaHnQlyiCTOJInUO|BafI3a｣<PacH6IO BMCJ1OIO neqaTbIO Br IQHBaC mBaHOBIIIIa BCea POCIIII
7010 r,>D 48. CmlcoK c 9Toii rpaMoTbl BKJIIo'IeH KaK 6ymTo B
U

OIHIH H3 C'601PHIIKOB, XPaHFI皿HXICH B PyKOⅡHCHOM OTXeJIe

rnB,HOBHaCTOR皿eeB'PeMH'cBeneHIIihOHeMMblHelMMeeM.
rPaMOTa MOrJIa 6blTb 'BblnaHa,gWI nQ xPOHoJIorlM mPyrHx
H CTOLIHHKOB, He PaHbmeH灯HFI 1502 f (pI He nq3>Ke aBIycTa,
corJ1acHo -VKa3alHHoII B omIにⅢⅡaTe) .
唖

rpaMoTa ycTb-mexo|HIcKoMy MoHacTbIpIo 1 539 n 49 ccbYJIaeT1cH Ha
JIaeT16H
Ha npoe3>Kylo
npoe3>KylorpaMoTv
rpaMoTyBacHJIHfl，'BlKoTopoH
BacHJIHfl, B |KoToPoii caHKL

｡

ⅡHol.IHPOBaJIIcFI 6e'Cnom几HHHblH npOe3ⅡHryMe|Ha, CTapueB
wIHHxJIIo瓜eⅢ《Ⅱo'HameHoTIIHʻHe，no
o 'Hamei oTIII1|He, no Ho'yro;poユIlKoH3eMJ1e
Ho'yro;po,mlIKoii 3eMJIe
U

U

じ

If no T*epcKoHH'no BeJIo3ePcKo". EcJIII rpaMoTa l539 r.
じ

U

uHTHpyeT XeiIcTBIJTeJIBHo rpa MoTy l 502 r., a lHe 'KaK|ylO-TO
⑪

60JIee nO3XHIoIo, ITePeX !HaMII qPe3BblIIaHHo IIHTePeCIHOe CBII-

XeTeJIBCTBO, XaPaKTePII3ylO皿ee
聖
nonblTKy Ba,cI1JIHH B 1502 r.
O6'be"IHIITb
0
6 ' b e 皿 I H H T nOX
b n OCBOeii
1 C B O e H BBnaCTbIo
n a C T b I o TPli
T P H rrJIaBIHble
J I a B l H b l e TePPHTOPHII,
Te P ” T O ” H ，

K ynPaBJIeHIilo KoTopblMII oH Heo"IoKPaTIHO HMeJI OTHomeHHe
nⅡpeⅡmeCTBylO皿IIG OTpe3KH BpeMe'HII.

O6paTHMBHIIMaI-IPIee皿eHacJIelyIO皿eeo6'cToH|TeJIbIcTBo.
B 1498 r. BJTaneTeJ1b py3bl lwHH3b HBaH BoIpII'coBH印IBblnaJI

jKaJIoBaHH'ylorpaMoTyCIIMoHoByMoHacTbIpIo|HaceJI3̲KOPTIIHcKoe, I<ycakIIHcK6e M BoropommKoe 50; B HIoJIe l502 m
oH 3aHOBO - II

6e3

BcHKoii

⑨

BH瓜HMoH

nPllIIHHbl - BblnaeT

rPaMoTV
­ a'HaJIOrH[IHOTo coXeP)Ka'HHH Ha Te >Ke ceJIa 51. 3Ty
4

８ ACSII, T. 111, Nb 272a, cTp､287, rp. 1 (nocJIe rP l2)
４
９
４
rB几PyMFIHu' KH 53, nJ1. 10-13.
０
５
AC3H, T. II, Nb 415.
５
１
TaM ]Ke, Nb 426.
』

183

〆

HoBTOPHyIO BblnaIIy MO>KHO o6'EH,CHHTb, BePOflTHO, JIHmb 'cy皿eCTBeH'HblMII nePeMeHaMM B nOJIHTII'IecKOik O6cTaHoBKe,
I'IHTePecIHO, qTO ,CeJIa, FIBJIHBmHecfI o6LeKToM Ho)KaJIoBaHHH

rpaMoT 1498 H l502 rr., alJIII pa|onoJIoIKeHbl B BbImiKoBcKoM
cTaHe, no6JIIi30cTH oT Mo>KaiicKoro Ve3na 52．He CBH3aHa JIII
BBIna[Ia IIBaHoM BopHIcoBHlleM rpaMoTbl CHMoHoIBy Mo,HacTblpIo cⅡepexo且CM,COCʻeⅡIHero Mo>Ka曲c'Ka B pyKHBaIcHJIH”
Bonpoc 3ToT ocTaeTcfI oTKpblTblM.
HacTynaTeJIbHblii xapaKTep noJIIITIIKH BacHJIHH Bbl3blBaJI
y HBaHa lll cepbe3Hble onaceHHfl 3a cyXb6y KocTpoMbl,
np HIH a皿e)KaBmeii paHee (B 1485 H 1491/92 rr) BacHJImIo
Ha nPaBax yleJIa no'cJIaIHHblii Tyna l'IBaHoM III |mlcen
r. P. 3a|cToJI6cKIIカユe曲|cTBOBaJI, !BepOHTIHo, B nePllOI Me班旦y
anpeJIeM H aBrycToM l502 n (ero rpaMoTb【且amPOBaHbl
7010 r., 6e3 yKa3aHIuI Mec皿a 53).
O IIeB皿Ho, c noJIIITHIIecKoii 60pb60ii 1501/02 r. cBH3aHa
TeHIeHuHH HoBrOPOXCKOrO aPxHenI1'c:Kona reHHaJMH BOcCTaHoBIITb BJIacTb Kabelpbl B o6zeMe, 6JIH3KoM 'K ToMy, KoTopblM oHa o6JIanaJIa mo npHcoelHHeHHH HoBropona. reHHa瓜噸BblCTynWI |B POJ1Ii rO!CylaPH, nOITBe四m|B 'B 7010 T. >Ka̲
･moBaHHylo naHHyIo

II

3a1ITOBenllylo 叩aMOTy aPxHenHIcKOna

①eo巾HJIa l471-1482 rr. CoJIoBeUKoMy MoHacTblpIo Ha
Bo6poByIo ropy ([IeTblpe ceJIbUa 'c BonaMm H JIecaMH B

且BH|HcKoii 3eMJIe) 54. B |HoITBep>KUelHIIH Mbl B皿IIM OrPalHII【IIITeJI BHblhⅡyHKT, rAe 'CneⅡHaJIbHo oro'BaplI'BaIoTcH ocoI6ble
npepoIraTMBbl apxHem1IcKO|na:《…BcTynaT,IIcH ,He BeJIeJI HHKoM y, ̲ 0 n P o U e

TOrO,

Ko J I I , I

KO r O

nomJIe|T

alPXII-

enII|CKOn Ha CBOIO JIOBJIIO>'.3TOTXeMaP皿reHII an|HJI
Mor IIMeTb MecTo cKopee Bcero B ToT nepHoI, Korna Ba1cHIIIHih
npeTeHnpBaJI Ha e41IHoJIIfIIHoe yn!paBJIeHHe HoBropoIoM,
TBepblo H BeJIoo3epoM, T. e. B Mae - aBrycTe l502 r.
Co,aep>KaHIie llMMyHHTeTHohⅡoJIHTHKH l 502 r. pacIK|pbIBaercH npH a'HaJIH3e anpeJIb|cKIIx rpaMoT HBalHa lll H BaCHJIHH HOBTO'POnCKIIM HOM'e皿HKa M,叩aMoTbl Ba'cIIJIHfl oT
52 0 MecTOHaxO>KneI･IIM 06beKToB nO>KaJIOBallIIH 3TIIx rPaMOT - Ce.m
KopTIIHcKoro, KycaKIIHcKoTo H Boropo旦皿Koro (CTaporo) - cM.:
AC31I, T・II, |cTp. 649, 650, 665. BblmKo,BcKIIji cTaH rpaHHﾘIIJI c Mo. ->KaiicKMM ye3JoM HenocpencTBeHHo, B To BpeMH KaK oT BoJIoKoJIaMcKoro ye3na erO OTneJIfI"II cTaHbl JIbHfIHHKoB II PaxoB (E. n. M a M a-

T o B a. I<apTa 20-x rl,、XVII Be,Ka KaK IIcToIIHIMK no HcTopmi anlMIIHIIcTPaTIJBHOro neIIeHIm H *eOnaJIbHOrO SeMJIeBJIaZeHHH PyeCwOrO
ye3ma. M., 1957,皿mloMHaFI pa60Ta. MrlIAH).
5s AC31/1, T. I, Nb 639, 640; T、111, Nb 45; A31IX, q. 1, JYb 169, 254, 258.
51 rBHIIn, Nb 99.

184

16 HIoHFI nloKpoBcKoMy yrJIIIuKoMy MoHacTbIpIo,.e[9 >Ke叩a-

M6fiiVIcTb-mexoHcKoMy MoHa'cTbipIo II rpaMoTbl HBa'Ha lll
oT 21 HIoHH TIpoHue-CeprHeBy MoHa,cTblpIo.
AnpeJIbcKHe rPaMoTbl "aJIOBaJIH 3eMJIIO MHOTO[IHcJIeH-

HblM6paTbflMMoceeBblM.nePeBIHHnePenaBaJIH:cbIIMBnoM eCTbe《3 HoxoIoM 3 neHe>KHblM H |c xJIe6HblM H |c MeJIKHM
U

XoxOI0M,onPmq!HamlieBeJIHK"KHH3eitmO6e>KIH,lenalH¥》・
gE̅6faTbfI 6bIJIa OoHoBaHa Ha .OPMyJIe nPaMOTbI I'IBaHa lll
1482 r. noMemHKaM TIpycoBbIM 55. B rpaMoTaxl502 T., TaK
>Ke 'KaK II 'B TpaMoTe
l482 r.,巾HK|cIIPOIBaJIacb Pa31aIIa B no今
凹

MecTbe
KOH"cKoBalHHblx
BJIaneHIIi
lHoBrOPont'cKor9̲qOHplIHa
),InocanlHHIKaBomaHaEcHnoBa,KIoTopblme皿eBl476r.6blJI
U

6TMgheHBMdckBy,a3aTeMBK6J10MHyB3aToIle"e5q
yKi+IHcBomno31iilliliBHo'Br9po4cKoieeMJIeBHall60JIee
ocfpble
皇 MoMelHTbl HoJII1THIIecKoii 6'opb6bl, npaBHTeJIbcTBo
L

U

BMecTe
cTeMⅡpH且ep>KHBaJIocbo6皿ePyc'cKoHJIHHHH
ep>KMBaJIocb o6mePyccKoii JIIIHIMorpa'HHorpaHII-

[IGHIIHrlonaTHofoHMMyHIITeTanaIHb(o6e>K|Hylo)noMelcTHble
.JIaTIITb. Ii3 0TneJIbHOih r'PaMOTbl IHa
3eMJIH1OJI>KHbl'6blJIHⅡJIaTHTb，H30T瓜eJIbHoHr'PaMoTbllHa
no)KaJI|oBaHHoe l3 anpeJIH noMelcTbe AqJ MoceeBa MbI y3Har
U

eM, [ITO, nOMHMO naHH, TPe60BaJIOCb BblHOJIHel冊IeⅡocO山lHoH

cJIV>K6bi57.HoBroponcKafInoJIHTHKamBaHalllPe3Ko
cJIv>K6bl57・HoBropo瓜c'KaHⅡ,oJIHTHKaHBaʻHalll
pe3Ko
oTJI}IoTJIIiqajIacb oT Kamli'HicKOii no皿TIIKH BaIcIIJIHH, ocBo60皿旧皿ero
U

ZIBop TpoHUe-Ce!prII'e'Ba MoHa|cTblPH oTノIaIHII Ii nocO皿H,om
cJIy)K6bl .
OmeJIbHaH rPaMoTa oTIIeTJIHBo HoKa3blBaeT KJIacQQBblH
U

xaPaKTep
mMMyiHTeTHoiinOJIMTHKIIBenmKorQKHfI3HCon⑥

HoII|cT'oPoHbl,'noMeⅡmKaM,6blJIo3anpe皿eHO6PaTbくiHaKpeU

CTbHHeX》《1OXO1》C Tex 3eMeJIb, KoTOpble 'ny,cKaJIIIICb noX

6aPcKylo 3ana皿'Ky lI, oLIeBIMHo, o6pa6aTblBaJIII!cb Tpy40M
xoJIoⅡOB．Ho,'cⅡpWloHlcTo”Hbl，Ⅱ'oMe皿HKH|HOJIyIIaJIH
oB. Ho, 'c npyr,oii lcTopoHbl, n'oMe
BeJIIIKoKHFDKecKVIo ca|HKUHIo Ha yBeJIHIIeHIIe peHTbl B 'paMKax,

ⅡplIeMJIeMblx IJIH rocynaPCTBa, T. et nPH ycJIOBHII, ulTO. KPe一

cibRHe He 6ymyT pa3dpeilb[ m 3eMJm He 3aJIycTeeT:<<A JocneIoT nycT6, 3 0｡oHaCIO na erO cblHy eXoPy nJIaTHTH
BeJIIIKIIx 'KHH3eHna|H H 'HOCOmHaH CJIy>K6a CaMIIM, a OT BeU

JIHKHx KHH3eii B ToM 6blTII I'IM B OnaJIe>>.
⑥

rpaMoTa BacIIJIHH noKpoBcKoMyyrJIII"oMy MoHacTblplo
Pe3KO
O叩aHIIIII1BaeTMOHa'CTblPCKⅢⅡ'Cy"6Hblii
HMMyHIITeT.
U

四

5 5 n ̲ g . C a M o K ' B a c o B yKa3. CoII., [T I], 0m. II, CTP. 3.
56 nCPJI, T. 1V, w･ 1、Bbln 2, cTp. 449; T V1, cTp. 18, 33, 204; T. V111,

cTp. 182; T. XII, cTI). 107

5 7 n . H C a M o K B a c o B . yKa3. COq., [T. 1], oTn. II, cTp. 9.
185

ne9e"BaH B PyKH 'HaMeCTHIIKoB paCCMOTPeHHe neJI o nyme･

ry6cTBe,Pa360e H TaTb6e c noJIHilHblM. BMecTe c TeM, F IIeii
coLep>KaTcH cTaTbH,

ocBo60>Kn(alomHe

oT

HaMec'rHHqbero

KopMaHoT｣no'60PoBnPBoXLIIIKoBH!npa|Be瓜ⅧIKoB.nyHKTo
ⅡoX|cylHoC"HryMsHa BacliJIIIIo 6blJI HanpaBJIeH, KaK II B

rpaM9Tel501r｡TpomUerCeprmeByMoIIacTblplo,Han0npblB
pyne6Hblx npeporaTIIB HBaHa lll (IiryMeli noKpoBcItoro
yrJIHU|KOrO MO'HacTblPfI e皿e B 70-x roniax XV B. nonJIe>KaJI
BeneHHIo KHH>KecKoro, a He BJIalblIIHoro ,cVna 58) .

B UeJIoM >Ke 6e>KeUKaH rpaMoTa BacIIJI" 1502 r. oTJIHIlaeTcH oT erO KamHIH,cKoii rpaMoTbl l501 r. 60JIbmeih IcTe-

neHblo OI､PaHHqeHIIH cyne6HOro HMMyHIITeTa !! oTcyTcTBIIeM
ⅡonaTHblx nlpHBIMerlIih. CTpeMJIGHIfe y|cTaHoBHT6 1coIo3 c
KPynHblM nyXOBHbIM巾eOna､moM IIeHoii 3Ha[IIITeJIbHblx VcTVツ

ツ

HoK eMy lcMeHfIeTcH B noJIHTI1'Ke Ba'cHJIIifl co3|HaHHeM ro'cV-

naP'cTBe.HHoii
HeO6xO皿MOCTII八aJIbHeimerO
onPaHIILIeHIiH

*eonaJIbHOTOHMMyHIITeTa3TOnPH3HaKTOTO,[ITbnOJIO>KeHHe MOJIOnPrO KHH3H cTaJIo HOBoJIbHO VCTO池HBblM H OH VBe-

PeHIHO
IIyBCTBOBaJI
Ce6H
|B
PoJIH
e皿H6TBeHHOrO
nPeeMIhiKa
OTUa .

TeKcT'rpaMioTbI1539r.ycTb-皿exoHc'KoMyMOHaCTbl'Plo

coxpalHHJIIcH nJIoxo. BcTpeIIaIoTcFI .IIaKyHbl llI B Toit [IacTH eTo,
r瓜e lI3JIaraeTcFI rpaMoTa Ba|cHJHH. PeIIb B HeimJIa, no-BH皿MOMy, o &niPOBO3e MoHa'cTbIP'cKorOく3anaCa)' (Ha nfITH BO3ax H B cymHe JIeToM H !Ha "TH caHHx 3PIMOih) 6e3 ynJIaTbl
MblTa |11 mp'yMx In｣poe3>KHx nomJIIIH. O6'LeM |npeJocTaBJIeiHHorO MOHacTblIPIO HMMyHIITeTa BnOJIIHe 'cooTBeTCTByeT OrlPaHIIYIHTeJIBHDIM

InPHIHUImaM

TaMo>Ke.HHO向ⅡOJIHTIMKI1 1/IBaHa

lll

90-x nonoB XV B.

B叩aWIgJpHBalHa
lllTpoIIUe-CeprmeByM|oHacTblpIooT

21
HIoHFI
1502
|r・TIPeny,cMaTPHBaJIII'cb
MOHa'CTblPiCKIIe
nOe34KH, CQBeP皿aeMble, OIIeBImHO, C UeJIblO 'nPOna>Kli P>KH H COJIII
H IHoKynKII |Ha BblpyIIe'HHble neHbrli pbl6bl H IIKpbl. O4|HaKo
rop|roBble cIeJIKII He noLTe>KaJIH ocBo60>K4|elHHIo oT nomJIHH.

rPaMoTa 'pa3PemaJIa JIIImb 6e3MblTHbli H 6e'CnOmJIHHHblii
nPOe3n |MoHacTblPcKIIx To|PrOBblx JIIo4ehH'npoBO3 nlPOnyKToB, nPHIIeM TPaHcHOPT H KOJIHIIeCTBo nPOBO3IIMOTO nPo">K-

Ho" ToB3Pa 6bIJIH cTporo perJIaMeHTHpoBaHbl (JIonKa c nopy6HeM, 1 00 IIeTBepTeii p>KH, 30 nynoB 60JIm) .
58 ACSI4, T、111, Nb 77

186

2. KJkaccoBBIeⅥno八mT皿咀eCKIKe nPoTHBOPe酊皿兜

HaKaHyHe lI Bo BpeMJI co60pa l503 r.

nepMOX
Me>KImy
cePeⅡH'Hoi
1502
|H
,cepe瓜H!Hoh
l503
r.

cJIa60 ' npeXcTaBJI6HHcTowʻHHKaMH、Bo
cJIa60ⅡpeⅡcTaBJIeH
HcToIlHHKaMK Bo
BTo,poHlⅡoJIoBHIHe
BTopoii JnoJIoB"He
U

U

1503 r. jacenaJI nepKoBHbliM co60p, 06cy>KLaB皿IIH, B IIaCT-

や
HocTII, npo6JIeMy cekyJIFIpII3"" KaKoBa 6blJIa 'HMMyHIITeT-

HaHⅡoJIHTHKalHaKaHyHe
co'610pa？
3a 3To BpeMH Mbl ,He HaxoIHM HMMy|HIITeTIHbIx rPaMoT
Ha nePKOBHo-MoiHacTblPWle 3WeWlble BnamelHIIH
BEma'HHafI HBaHoM III B 1502/03 r. rpaMoTa HII>Keropo几-

cKHM
bo60paM-CnaccKoMy
m
M'IIxamIIo-ApxalH[､eJIbIcKoム
MV­巾11KIcII|PoBaJIa
lIx!n,PaBonOJIyLIaTbgeHe>KHylopyry<<113
Hi》Keropo四cKmxTaMo》KelHlHblxnpxoⅡo”59.TaKorop,o“no>KaJIoBaiHIie,npl!oTcyTcTBIMynyxIoBIIoihKopnopaUl!m八OcTaTO'I;HOrOKO川ILIeCTBa3eMeJIb,CTaBHJIOee'BTeiCIHyIO巾Ⅱ'HalHCO-

BVIo 3aBIIcMMocTb oT BeJI1IIKoK">KelcKoro npaBHTeJpIcTIBa
U

rbaMoTa4eMoIHcTpmPoBaJIaHall60JIeeKQMnpoMmlQcHbIII|myTb

p6meH"Bonpoca̅ogMaTepliaJIbHoMo6ecneqeHIIHnlyxoBeH

bTBa - nePeBM eroHa
CTBa-nePeBo瓜ero
Ha
roCy且aPCTBeHHOeⅡOBOJ1bcTBHe，IITO
roCynaPCTBeHHOe nPBOJIbcTBHe, 2TO

nO3BOJIHJIo
6blMOPaJIBHO
o|II,PaIBllaTbCeKyJIFIIpH3aumIo.
CorJIaIoHo <<CJIoBy lIHbMy>, IIBaH III, co6HpaHcb lnpenJIo)KIITb
cOdoPy lCBOii nJIalH ceKyJIHPli3aUmII, IIMeJI IlaMePeiHMe ""
U

U

PonOmiTa >Ke m BJIanbIK II Bcex̲MaHacTbIIleiI IIs 'QBCle"4M

neHbra MHH3npBoJIHTII II xJIe60M |II3006poIIHTII H3 cBoHx
>KHTHIIU>> 60.
⑪

OIIeHb cIIMnToMaTHIIHo, [ITo JomenmHe oT nepBoII HoJIo-

BIIHbl l503 r. cynHble cnHcKIi nocBHmeHbl He 3eMeJIbHblM
TH>K6aM,KaK60JIb皿HHCTBOCOXPaHIIBmIIxCHcynHblXCnHCKOB

HⅡPaBblX rPaMOTHaM m3BeCTIIQHPerq̲"a cy"PW,Cnliglg,
BblnaHHblx B nePBOHnoJIoBIIHe l503 r. B MapTe l503 r. nBoU

○

cy且HBmHH《no…cjloBy＞ⅢBapenKI1ii
Ha
lll3aKoH1IImPaccMOTPeHme1eJIa
BOpOBCTBe
o
ceHa61．
O6BHHilTeJIII - KpecTbFIHe TpoHILe-Ceprll"a MoHacTblpH
｡

サ

HoJIVeBbl-】KIIJIII
B nPHJIynKOM OKPyre yrJIIIUKOrO ye3"
．

lI3
ero
nePeBeHb,
（B℃aMOM cnPmJIyUKoM”HB O皿ozoih
m3ero凡ePeBeHb，

59 TBJT, (P 29 (co6p. H. il. BemeBa), Nb 1618, :Ⅱ.45.

6910. K. BeryHoB．<<CJIoBo IIHoe> - HoBoHameHHoe npoH3BeneHIIe

by6c,f6i hy6Jfi,UmgrmKM )M̲L o 6o"e ,llBaIW IM｡' "JIeW"R
HIIeM
mePKBH.­《TMB!OnPJI>,T.XX.M.-J1"1964,cTP#51．O
U

Bo3MO>KIIOCTIICymeCTBOBaHHHTaKOrOnPOeKTanHCaJIe皿eA.naBJIoB
(A n a B JI o B.̅ I'IcToplIKIecKIIii ouepK ceKYJI"H3alllili nepKoBIlbIx 3e､
MeJIb B PoccMIII. 1 . .0necca, 1871 , cTp､49) .
61rpB, noron. 1846,、叩. 7-110 06.
187

HeFIcHo) ;06BHHFIeMblカーKPecTbnHHHrplmbKaTeBeJIra ""
〕KIm
B nlePeWe,
BⅡepeBHe，THHyBmeH
TfIHyBmeii K BeJIIIKOKHH>KeCKOMy
BeJIHKoKH”KecKcMyceJIVnaBK
CeJIy naB草

JIoBcKoMy.
KpoMe
Be皿ecTBeHHblx
yJIIIK62,
cy皿eCTBeHHOe
8JIPIFIHIie Ha PemeHIIe CynbII OKa3aJIH 3aHBJIeHH別CBImeTeJTeH
U

oBopoBcKoMnPOmJIoMrPⅡ且bKH.BoTJIIIIIHeoT60JIbmHHcTBa

CnOPOB，'B
KoTOPblx
Ka>K旦aH
cTOPOHa
oTcTamBaJIaHHTePeCbl
cBOeHKOPnOPanlHHII3amIImaJIaqeCTbcBOerOMyH旦Hpa,
⑥

"ecb MOHacTbIPcKHe m BeJIIIKOKHH>KeCKme KPecTbHile o6beXHHHJIHCb nPOTIIB HaPymIITeJIH O6merO cHOKoIICTBHH:《na
TaK pKJIH naBJIoBcKIIe JK xpecTMIHH OJI巾op ma6aJ,a c ToBa.
U

”虹Ⅲ，“ⅢⅡplIJIynKHe xpecTbHHH, coTnKoii MIIKH巾opc
ToBapmmli: ,,ToT, rocno"He, rp"Ka TeBeJ1ra J11Ixoifq6jloU

BGK. TaTb H nOKJIeⅡⅡa, a TogMy He nepBaH TaTb6a. HcKaJIII,
9

MW"He,HaToM̲rpImKeTeBeJIrenepeXKHH3eMOHXpeeM

Bacli'iIbeBIImleM Te 6bi >K xpecTbfIHH nahJf6Bck6f51ceXrm:

KaBOPTHIIKOBcToBaPH虹Ⅲ,IIKHH3bOHjPeii,rocHoⅡHHe,
U

BacmJIbeBIIq,
cyⅡmPmJI
erO,
BeJIeJT,
1Ha
HeMMCUeBo
nOnPaBHB,

6HTb KHyTbeM. II 6mJIIr ero, focno"He, E̅ T6if̅̅;5M6
KHyTbeM…!<>p63.K.r.3a60JIoTcKIIihf<HIIIe曲①e皿anaKocTIo
虻，

U

noJIyeBbIxonpaBIIJ1,arpMKyTeBeJIryo6BAMI̅""且即I

ero B TaTHHBblnaJI ero IicUeM Ha Ka31･Ib no Cyne6IIHKy, a
HCTgeBOBeJIeJInOnPaBIITmⅡOCeJICKOMyII3erOCTa[T]KOB>64.

BXaHHoMcJIyq3eMUlIMeeM"eJI6HecKJIacc6gbi,aC

BHyrpHKJIaccoB" 60pb60ih KpecTbHH, npHIIeM IIocKojlbKV
ご

KPecTbHHCTBo
6bIJIo
KJIaccOM
beO"JIbHofO
O6皿eCTBa,
'T.
e.
KJJ
aCCOM巾eo"JIDHblM
Hameit
(B JTHTePaTyPe
HePenKOくりeO｡

U

"JbHbIII KJIacc)' BbicTynaeT KaK ClIHOHHM <(KJIaCCa *eOna-

J92>,̲qToTeoPeTIIqecKIIHeBepHO),nocToJIbKyroCy"PcTBO,
3a皿HmafIycTOH巾eo"JIbHOrOnPaBoIIOP皿Ka,HeMorJIOHe
3amlmaTb B
3amH皿aTb
BH3BeCTHOHMePe
HgBeCTHOii MePeHHHTePecblKPeCTbHH,>KIIBmHx
II IIHTePecbI KPeCTbHH, >KIIBmIIx

nO
nPaBIIJIaM
｡eOnaIIbHOro
O6皿e>KIITIIH.
Co,mep>KaHIIe
H
TepMHHoJIorlIHcynHorocnHcKa503
l r．ⅡO4T,BeP>KnaIOTy>KeBbl-

CKa3aHHylOOTneJIbll.IMIICOBeTCKIIMHHCTOpIIKaMH65MblCJIb,

IITO
HOHFITHe《JIIIXOi
IIeJIOBeK>>
IIくn･oKJIenUa>>
nPHMeHHJIocb
ljeTqmbKoKTeMKPecTbflHaM,KOTOPbleBeJIH《KJIaccoBylO
60Pb6y)>BIIpHMoMEMblcJIecJIdBa66

U

62CeHHa兜《TEyxa>
nPMBGJTaOTMecTa,
naXo",TcFI
me yKpaﾉIeHIIblHcTor，
go"9"IDp"bKe,ac｣IIqeHmeocTaTKoBceHa.B3HTLDic5Tor6̅M66fa;
”

E"IoN, HameIJHPIM y rpImbKII, noKa3aJ1o Hx meHTHIIHocTh
63 rnB, noro.n. 1846, J1.̅10.
64 TaM ]Kel J1. 10 06.

65Han”Mep，H、E､HocoBbIM,A
KonaIIGBbIM
I'I.
IIﾉIp･
66CpJIBHepgnHI1HpyccKIie巾GoJIaJIbHLIeaPxMBblXIV-XVBeKOB, q､2.M.­J1., 1951, CTp. 304, 327.
188

Cy八Hbli cnHcoK, naTIIpoBaHHblii 30 HIoHH l503 r., Ka⑪

CaJICH HOmKOra MoHaCTblPCKOIi XePeBHH JByMH KPeCTbflHa-

MH, Bblme及皿IIMH II3 MoHacTblpcKoii BoTIIHHb1 67. 3J<ecb Mo>K-

HoyCMOTPeTbnleiiCTBHTeJIbHOenPoH|BJIeHHeKJIaccOBOii60Pb6bI KPecTbH;H, KoToPble McTIIJIII cBOeMy 6blB皿eMy ｡eonaJIy Cnaco-EB(jHMbeBy MoHacTblpIo - 3a HaJIo)KeHHble Ha HIIx
3KoHoMIIIIecKIIe caHK"H (cTapeU AJIeKca皿P B3HJI C ojlHOrO

H3ymenmHX'KPeCTbflHくⅡO>KHJIOrO>3anBOpnOJIHOJITpIHbl68,
a nOKIIHyTyIo :HM 3eMJIIo 3aCeHJI PO>KbIo <<Ha MoHaCTblPb>) .
KpecTbHHHH, npeXcTaB皿砿Ha Cy4e, He CMOr 3amlaTIITb

mTpa｡ B pa3Mepe 9'/2 py6JIH II 6blJI oT4aH MoHacTblpIo "o
IIcKyna)D. BTopoii KpecTbHHIIH, 'coyIIacTHHK no"Kora, .Haxo八HJIcH B 6erax, nOsToMy

cyAbH - eroくBeJIeJI 3anOBenaTH

II

HO'IIMaTH,,Ⅱa nOCTaBHTII ero nePeX BeJIMKIIM KHfl3eM>.

BepoHTHo, aKTPIBII3aninfI 60pb6bl KpecTbHH H ceKyJIHpm3a且HoHHble nJIaHbl nPaBHTeJIbCTBa 6blJIII HBJIeHHHMH B3aIIMocBH3aHHblMII. OTcyTcTBIie cpe皿I II'CToIIIIHKOB CeHTH6"
1502 - aBrycTa l503 rr. cymllblx cnHcKoB, npaBblx H >KaJIoU

BaHHblx rPaMOT Ha 3eMJIⅢⅡyxOBHblx KOPnOPaUHHnOKa3bl-

B.aeT, IITo 3eMeJIbHaH npo6JIeMa 6blJIa B 3To BpeMFI IIcKyccT-

BeIIHo 3aMopo)KeHa. BoJIee Toro, B <<CJIoBe IIHoM>p pacclくaU

3blBaeTCH

o

3eMeJIbHoH

〆

THJKOe,

U

PemeHHoII

He

B

ｰ

nOJIb3y

MOHaCTblpH 69. neJIO nPOIICXO"JIO, B皿HMo, He3aXOJIrO nP

co6|oPa, cKopee Bcero BecHoii - JIeToM 1 503 r､70 <HeKoTopHⅢ... IIeJIOBeUbl>P Ho>KaJIoBaJIIIcb lIBaHy lll Ha TPOHIKOrO
cTapma KoHoHa, fIKo6bl HapymmBmero Me>Ky, oTneJIHBmyIo

BoJIocTb Tpo皿e-Cep皿eBa MoHacTbIpfl HJIeMHy (BepeｶcKoro
ye34a) oT BeJIHKoKHH>KecKoii 3eMJIII: <<KoHaH IIepHeU nepeoPaJI 3eMJIeHylo Me>Ky H TBOIO oPeT 3eMJIIo, BeJIHKaro KHH3H>>.

naJIee B

<<CJIoBe IHHoM),

co6blTIIH

H3JIaraloTcH TaK:

nocJIe

KOPoTKOro CJIelCTBHH I'IBaH III BeJIeJI HaKa3aTb IIePHeUa

ToproBoii Ka3Hblo, a c IiryMeHa CepanHoHa B3HTb 30 py6JIe曲；
KpOMe ToI､o, BeJIIIK" KHH3b lIcnoJIb30BaJI sToT cJIyqaih B KaKIecTBe noBoJa nJIH 3aTpe60BaIHHH B MocKBy TpoI皿KIIx rPaMOTHa BCe ceJIa, H TOJIbKo HeO)KⅢ瓜aHHaH 60JIe3Hb HBaHa lll,
67 AC31M, T. II, Nb 495; J1. B. LI e p e n H H H. yKa3. coq., 11. 2, cTp. 330.
68 B nal.IHoM cJIyrlae ,pa3MeP 《no】KHJIo'ro＞ ToIJHo cooTBeTc1､,BoBaJ1

TaKce, ycTaHoI]JIeHHoi Cylle6HHKoM 1497 r. O6BI研IReMblik ylne.m, nl)O>KIIB B MoHacTblPCKOii nePeBHe《瓜Ba ro,ny)>. B Cyne6HIIKe I､OBOPIIJIOCb,

IITO
KPeCTbHHIIH,
nPo>KHB皿I1曲エIBa
rOhna,《ⅡOJI4BOPa
mlaTMT>．ⅡoCʻKO皿〕KyくB ,mecex>, 3a nBop 6paJIacb noJITIIHa, c <<noJInBopa)P Tpe60BaJ1ocb
nOJIyqlITb nOJInOJITIIHb1.

69 10. 1<. B e r y H o B. yKa3. coII., cTp. 352.
7コCp・TaM >Ke, CTP. 360.
189

BoCnP'HHRTafI IIM KaK 60>Kbfl KaPa, npepBaJIa OcymecTBJIe､ HHe erO CeKyJIHPH3aUHOHHblx HaMePeH|Hii B OTHOmeHIIH

ITpoHUe-CeprHeBa MoHacTbl".
HecMoTpH Ha ocTpoTy KoH｡JIHKToB Me>KXy HBaHoM III
H npe八CTaBHTeJIHMH KPynHOrO MOHaCTblPCKOrO 3eMJIeBJIante-

HHR, nPHrOBOPbl lByx mome旦皿IIx cynHblx cHHcKoB 1503 r.
! CB"eTeJIbCTByIOT, rlTo nPaBHTeJIbcTBo, OxPaHHH yCTOII ｡eOU

XaJIbH|oH 3aKOHHocTH, nPeceKaJIO nOnblTKH KPecTbHH HaHec'TII

MaTePlIaJIbHbIii ymeP6 MoHacTblPCKoMy XO3HiicTBy H CBOHM
co6paTbHM Ho KJIaccy.

BHHMaHMe HBaHa lll B l502/03 r. K Cy3"JIbcKo-HwKeroPoncKoMy KPalo TpynHo o6'hFIcHHTb HcIIepmblBaIo皿HM O6-

pa30M. Bo3Mo)KHo, BeJIIIKHhKHH3b lI|cKaJI 3necb ce6e cTopoHHIIKoB, nPenB:m瓜H ocTpble cnopbl Ha co60pe. Benlb Cy3XaJIb皿HHa BXO八HJIa B [IIIcJIo TePPHTOP11ii, r4e lIBaH III, ec川I
BePIITb l･IaMeKaM 60JIee n03JIHIIX IICTOIIHIIKOB, nPe且noJIaraJI
3anPeTHTb

KHFDKaTaM

oTJally

3eMeJIb《no典ymeʼB MoHa-

cTblPH 6e3 40KJIana Be･JIIIKOMy KHfI310 71. HBaH III cIIIITaJI,
nO-BHIHMOMy, Ba)KHblM HOﾕﾕeP>KHBaTb XOPOmHe oTHOmeHH兜

Co Cnaco-EB｡HMbeBblM MoHacTblpeM, KoTopbIit 6bM TecIIo
CBH3aH C Cy3na)IbCKHMH III cTaPOny6CKHMII KHH3bfIMI'1.

BoJIee oIIeBHJHbl npHIIIIHbI BHHMaHMH K yrJIIIIIy II Bepee.
He roBopH y>Ke o ToM, IITo caM yrJIIiUKHii ye34 6bIJI o6もeK­
ToM 40MoraTeJIbcTB (BepoHTHo, KaK BacIIJI", TaK H IMIITPlIH-cblHa) , 3eMJIH c nPHJIynKoro Haxo皿JIHCb HenaJIeKO OT

KamliHcKoro ye3", c｡epbl BJIHHHIIFI BacHJIIIH. BepeiicKHii
ye3且RBJIHJIcH Hac,JIenCTBoM 6eJIO3epcKorO KHH3H MIIxaHJIa

1AHnpeeBHIIa, Ha KoTopoe npeTeHJpBaJI BacHJIHii 昏

I B 1 502/03 r. BeJIacbnHcUoBaH pa60Ta B BoJIoI､oXcKoM
ye3JIe 72. BepoHTHo, 3ToT paiioH ocTaBaJIcH nPe,n<MeToM
y八eJIbHbIx nPHTH3aHIIii.
23 HHBapH l503 r. HBa|H III IH BacHJI" Bbl八aJIH rPaMoTy
C. OraPeBy Ha 3eMJIH B Uero)KcKoM IIorocTe meJIoHcKoii
nfITIIIHbl, HeKOI､Ia nPHHanJIe>KaB皿me .'6|oHpliHy BomaHy EcIInoBy 73 (ero )Ke BJI"eHHH pa3naBaJIHcb B 1482 1I 1502 rr.) .

nOCO,Uep>KaHIIIoHMMyHIITeTHOA巾OPMyJIblrPaMOTaTo)KnlecTBeHHa anpeJIbcKHM rpaMoTaM 1502 r. CooTBeTcTBylomaH

oT4eJIbHafl rpaMoTa l503 r. Ha noMecTbe OrapeBa 74 HoBTo7' 0 BepoHTHocTII cymecTBoBaHIIfl TaKoro nocTaHoBJIeHwI cM.: A. n a BJIoB・yKa3. coII., cTp. 37, npHM. 3.
72 A3HX, m. 1．Nb 170.

73 U. H. C a M o K B a c o B. yKa3. cotl., [T. I], oT,Ⅱ･ 11, cTp. 6.
74 TaM )Ke, cTp. 6-7.
190

1

u
U

pHeTnoCTaHOBJIeHHRPaCCMOTPeHHOHBblmeoTXeJIbHOHrPa-

MoTbl l502 E Ha noMecTbe MoceeBblx・BblXaqa rpaMoTbI
OrapeBV cocToflJIacb 'B ycJIoBHHx 3aTyxaHIIMH pyccKo-JIIIToB-

cKoii BOiHbl (B MapTe l 503 r. B MocKBy npli6blJIo JIIIToBcKoe
nOcoJIbcTBo C nPe皿o)KeHIIeM HepeMHp") . OIIeB皿HO, B KOHIle HHBapfl l503 r. Tpe60BaJIocb yKpenIITb cyBepeHIITeT Beu

JiliKoK">KecKoro npaBHTeJIbcTiBa Ha 6JIII3Koii K py6e)Ky
u

TePPHTOPHH皿eJIOHCKOHIHTIIHbl.

iITali, nepHonl c ceHTfl6" l502 no aBrycT ̲1503 r- Bpe:
MH
60JIbmOiiCneP)KaHHOCTHBHMMyHHTeTHOMH3eMeJIbHOii
nOJIHTII'Ke. nO3muHH, 3aHfITafl BeJI|IIKoKHJI>KeCKIIM nPaBHTeJIb-

CTBOM, OTKPO|BeHHO neMOHcTPliPOBaJIa erO ceKyJIHpH3alllIoHHo-orPaHIIKMTeJIbHble HaMePeHI畑．

Bo BTopoHnOJIoBHHe l503 r. HaMeIIaloTcH cyme|cTBeHH bl e
U

｡

nepeMeHbI̅BnoJIwTHIIecKoiio6cTaHoBKe
Ue"9BHbl"9.92
OThePrbeKyJIHPm3aIMCHHylonpOrpaMMy IIBaHalll 75.
u

nPOBaJI nJIaHOB CeKyJIHPH3aUlM nePKOBHO-MOHaCTblPCKHx

3eMeJIb B PoccHII XVI B. PI, B IlacTHocTII, npoBaJI nJIaHa,

npenJIo)KeIIHoroB1503r.,IIcTopHqecKPI3aKoHoMepeH.yKa3blBaH, IITo UePKoBHble HMyIIleCTBa cOcTaBJIHJIII PeJIIIIrHO3-

HylOTBeP皿HIOKTPa皿皿OHHblx)>(beo,naJIbHbIx)OTHome-

H" 3eMeJIbHoii co6cTBeHHocTII, MapKc nIIcaJI:《CⅡaneHIIeM

3ToiTBeP,mblHIHHeMOrJIIIyCTOHTbH3TII|OTHO皿eHHH),76.Ho
U

U

Ⅱ"eHHe ｡eoXaJIbHoi co6cTBeHHocTII Bo3Mo>KHo ToJIbKo jlPH

HaﾉI池班I 60JIee HJIII MeHee rOTOBbIx *oPM HOBOrO - 6yP-

>Kya3Horo - yKJIana B HenPax巾eonaJIH3Ma 77. B pyccKoM
rocynapcTBe XVI B. e皿e He cO3PeJIH 3KOHOMIIIIecKIie nPen-

nOCblJIKH皿H -VHIHIITo)KeHIIH ｡eo"JIbHoii co6cTBeHIIocTII Ha
U

U

3eMJIIo HePKoBHO-MOHaCTbIPcKHX KOPnOPaUmI, xOTH CaMa
IIocTaHoBKa

3Toro Bonpoca cBIMeTeJIbcTByeT

o

3HaqHTeJIb-

｡

IIoM Pa3BHTHH ToBaPHO-,meHe>KHblx OTHOmeHIM H yKpenJIe⑥

H H H B e J I H Ko K H H > Ke C KO H B J I a c Tm ．
○

Kpa師eⅡʼHTepecHo,IITomcⅡOJIʻHTHIIecKoHToIIKH3peH皿
cy皿eCTBOBaHHeMOHaCTblPcKOrO3eMJIeBJIanleH|HHBnePBOII
U

TjeTIIXVIB6bIJIoBKaKoii-TocTeneHmHeo6xo且HMblMyCJIO75 nO叩o611ee CM.: A. n a B JI o B. yKa3. cotl., cTp. 39-52; A. A. 3 1.1-

M II H. O6 yIIacTmHHocII" BoJIoUKoro B co6ope l503．r､一《nocJIa･
HmH HocII巾h BonoUKoro".̅M.-J1., 1959, cTp. 370-374､

76 K.MapKcMの. S H reJI b c. Coq., T. 23, cTp. 734.

77 B AHrJTIm, HanpHMep, ceKyJmpm3anIIFI 6blJIa npoH3BemeHa, KaK II3BecTHo, B XVI B. (1534 r.), T. e. B nePHoA cTaHo"eHHH KanmTa順3Ma，
B o6cTaHoBKe
o6cTaHoBKe pa3BIITIIfl
pa3BHTHH6ypxya3HbIx
6yp)KyaaHbIx oTHOmeHKii
oTHomeHKH naJIQ̲jLepKQBHo-MonaJIo瓜epKoBHo­Mo-

HacTblpcKoe 3eMJIeBJI"eHHe̅H B PoccIIH (60-e ro"I XVIII B.) .
1ʻ91

B}IeM 60pb6bI 3a naJTbHeimylO UeHTpaJIH3auHIO rOCynaPCTBa.
npaBHTeJIbcT,Bo HcnblTbIBaJIo 3aIIHTepecoBaHHocTb B PacnPoCTPaHeHHmBOTqHH BOHHCTBylO皿HX HOC"JIHH B C巾epax
yneJIbHOKHH>KeCKOro 3eMJIeBJIanleHII凡TaK KaK 3THM, BO-neP-

BblX, yMeHIJmaJIOCb IIIICJIO CO6CTBeHHO yneJIbHOKHR>KeCKI,IX
3eMeJIb ll 3eMeJIb cBeTcKHx巾eOnaJIOB, HBJIHBmlIXCH BOeHHblMII BaccaJIaMH y,meJIbHbIx !KHH3eit, a BO-BTOPblx, yKPenJIFIJIocb
(IIePe3 MOHacTblPH) BJIHHHHe MoCKoBCKOrO nPaBIITeJIbcTBa
lla TeppHTopHH ymeJIoB. TaKHM o6pa30M, pac皿HPeHMe MoHacTblPcKoTo 3eMJIeBJIanieHHfl nPen(cTaBJIHJIO co60h巾OPMy pa3BHTHfl 3KOHOMHIIecKHx II nOJIIITHIIeCKIIx nPe瓜nOCblJIOKJIHKBH瓜 a n 加 I H O C J I e n H I I x y, m e J I b H b l x K H F D Ke C T B .

KacaHch Bonpoca o reorpa｡|H[IecKoM pa3Me>KeBaHIIII
IIOcI1｡JIfIH H HeCTH>KaTeJIeih,Ⅲ瓜eHHcOB nblTa.Icfl JIHmb B
H'CTOP'II H皿eii HaiiTH q)aKTbl, 06bflCHHIOmHe PacnPOCTPaHeHHe HocII｡JIHHCKIIx KoPnOPalIIIii B 3ana皿blx ye34ax. B coOTBeTCTBHII cO cBoeil o6111eii KoHUen皿e曲及eHHCOB CII|HTaJI

皿eihHylO cy皿HocTb lIOCIId)JIHHcTBa nPoHBJIeHPIeM PyC"II-

UlIPoBaHHoroPeHeccaHca.no3ToMyBo3HIIK|HoBeHHelIocH巾一
:JIHHcKIIx MoHacTblpeiM B paMKax IIMeHHo HoBropoXcKoi
enapxHH, B KOTOPylO BXO且皿Hoc"o-BoJIoKoJIaMcK" MoHaCTblPb, PaCCMaTPlIBaJIOCb IIM KaK Pe3yJ1bTaT JIaTHHH3aUHII

HoBropoIcKoii o6JIacTII1, TecHee Bcero conpliKaca:BmeiicH c
3ana皿oii KyJIbTypoih 78. B Hameit IIcTopHorpa*HII, K co)KaJIeHIIIo, HeXocTaToIIHo IIccJIeiyeTcH npo6JIeMa reorPa巾皿

IIOcI11JIHHCKHX H HeCTH>KaTeJIbc'KIIx KOPnOPaU"Ⅱ皿eii 79.
BOPb6a nPoTHB MOHaCTblPcKOrO 3eMJIeBJIaneHWI MOrJIa
HaIIaTbcFI TOJIbKO B yCJIOBHHx UeHTPaJIII30BaHIIorO rOCyXaP-

CTBa,rXe6blJIIHJIHKBII皿poBaHbIHall60"eexpynHbleyneJ1¥
II CaMOcTOHTeJIbHble KHH>KeCTBa, Ho3TOMy JIHmb BO BTOPOM

HoJIoBIIHe XV B. HecTH>KaTeJIbcKoe y(IeHIIe 'cTaJIo cMblKaTbcH
B KaKo曲-TO MePe C nPaBIITeJIbCrBeHHOii KOHUeⅡuHeit. OntHaKo

coxpaHeHIIe ynteJIoB Me>Kny MocKBoii m HoBropoﾉIOM neJIaJIO
"JIH nPaBIITeJIbCTBa oIIeHb 'Ba>KHblM yKPenJYeHIIe H na>Ke Pac-

mlipeHIIe BoTqHH HocH｡o-BoJIoKoJIaMcKoro MoHacTbIpH KaK
UeHTPa, HaxOIIIBmerOcH B ry皿e ynieJIbHoKHH>KecKIIx TePPH-

73 E. D e n i s s o f f. Aux origines de l'6glise rLIsse aLltoc印hale・一
《Revue des etudes slaves",t. 23, fasc. 1-4. paris, 1947, p. 86--88.

79 Cp. A. n. Ka八｡JIy6OBCKHiI. OqepKI'I no Jll)eBHepyccKoH J1HTepaType >KPITHii cBFITblx. BapmaBa, 1902, cTp. 328-329 (o cxeMaTIM3Me KoHnenUMIII Ka1ny60BcKoro cM.: H. C. JI y p b e. I'IAeQJIoI､HIJecKMI 6opb6a…, cTP 289-291 ) .
192

TopHii 80. 3a6erafI Ha 60 JIeT Bnepen<, Mo)KHo oTMeTHTb, IITo
JIIIKBM八aUliH CTapMUKoro yXeJIa Bo BpeMH onpHKIHHHbl cpa3y

>Ke cHli3HJIa poJIb Moc"o-BoJIoKoJIaMcKoro MoHacTblpH B
rJIa3aX nPaBMTeJIbCTIBa．A. A. 31IMHH B HccJIenpBaHHH, Ho＝

⑪

CBFI皿eHHoM 9ToMy MoHaCTblPlo, nPOcJIe>KHBaeT OO皿HH yna-

IOK BJI"HIIFI HOc"JIHH Bo BPeMH OmpHIIHHHbl 81.
HaJIHIIHe B XVI B. ynleJIoB Mexmy MocKBoii H HoBropoJpM HBJIFIJIOCb nOJIHTIIqecKHM ,aKTOPoM, Me皿aBmHM BblPa60TKe o6皿ePyCCKOii nPorPaMMbl ceKyJIHplI3aⅡⅢH. CHMHToMaTHIIHa nPOTHBOPeIIIIBOCTb CHTyauHH B caMoM HoBropoXe.

C oIHoii cTopoHbI, ZBaH III B l499 JIJIm l500 r. npom3BeJI
'laCTHIIHylo

CeKyJIHPH3anIIIO

3eMeJIb

aPxHenHCKOna

ll,

ヲ

oIIe-

BHユH0, 6,JIH3KIIx K HeMy MOHaCTblPeii, Ho, C nPyrOii CTOPOHbl,
B Te )Ke rOnlbl yKPenJIHJIHCb nO3HUHII HOBrOPOICKIIx MOHa-

cTbIPeii, cBH3aHHblx c BeJIHKOKHH)KecKIIM nPaBHTeJIbcTBOM.

ApxIIenmcKon mrpaJI B HoBropoJle poJIb aHaJIorH【畑ylo
皿eJIbHoKHFDKecKoi, no3ToMy npoTHB Hero II 6blJIO HallPaBJIeHo ocTplle 60pb6bl. npoMocKoBcKII HacTpoeHHble MoHaL 9

cTblpm,
HanPOTIIB,
co,meHCTBoBaJIII
HcKoPelieHHIo
HoBrOPomcKorO CenaPaTH3Ma lI B HarPaly noJIyllHJII1 3eMe,IIbHble llo.>KaJIOBaHI,IH

II HMMyHKTeTHble nPHBHJIerlM.

noJIIITHIIecKaH PoJIb MoHacTblpe曲 B Pa3JIIIIIHOii MePe

coxpaHHJIacb H B XpyrHx paiioHax cTpaHbl. BoT HoIIeMy HaM
Ka)KeTcH,

IITO

OTHOcHTeJIbHO皿HPOKHe

nJIaHbl

CeKyJIHPH3a-

UHII, KOTOPble BblHamHBaJI HBaH III, 6blJIII pe3yJIbTaTOM
3Ha'IHTeJIbHOhⅡePeOnleHKH CTeneHM UeHTPaJIII3anHH rOCynlaPCTBellHOii BJIaCTH,,n<ocTHrHyToit K HaIIaJIy XVI B.

npo6@IIeMaceKyJIHpH3aUHHHnpo6｡JIeMayXeJIoBHaxo,Ⅱ11iJIHCb B TecHOik B3aHMoCBH3H・HaIIaJIo TH)KeJIo曲60JIe3HII MBa-

Ha lll HHKoHoBcKaH ､JIeTonHcb oTHocHT K 28 HIoJIJI 1503 r､82

0JHaKo ToJIbKo 21 ceHTH6pH 1503 r. IIBaH III oTnpaBHJIcH
C CblHOBbHMH B HOe3nXy nO CeBePHblM ye3naM 83, KOTOpaH

npo皿HJIacb nP 9 HoH6pH l503 r・UeJIb nOe3XKH COCTOHJIa,
OIIeBH4Ho, B TOM, [ITO6bl Ha MeCTe，ⅡPrOBOPHTbcH HaCIIeT
80 SToMy He npoTMBopeqHT To o6cToHTeJIbcTBo, IITo nepBoHaIIaJIbHo
I'Ioc" BoJIonK" B皿eJI OHoPy B y,meJII'1･lblX KHFI3bFIx, a He B MOcKOBcKoM npaBHTeJIbcTBe (H. C. JI y p b e. I'MeoJIorHIIecKaH 60pb6a…, cTp.
260-261 ) .
81 A. A. 3 M M H H. OIIGpKH IIo HcTopHH qJeontaJIbHoro 3eMJIeBJIaneHIIH M
xo3HiicTBa
B
MocKoBcKoM rocynapcTBe XVI B．M., 1947 (rBJI, MamliHonlicb) , cTp. 618-623.
82 nCPJI, T. XII, cTp. 257.

83 TaM >Ke, T. VIIl, cTp. 243; T. XII, cTp. 257-258.
1 3 C 、 M . K a m Ta H O B

193

Pa3MePOB II rPaHI皿6yny皿IIx ynleJIoB 84. BepoHTHo, B aBryフ

cTe - ceHTH6pe BeJIHK" KHH3b >KnaJI cO60pHoro nPHroBoPa
Ⅱo

HoBOJy

nePKOBHO-MOHaCTblPcKOrO

3eMJIeBJIaneHHH Ⅱ
〆

OTKJIa八blBaJI B CBH3}I C 3THM pemeHHe BOnPOCa oo yAeJIax.

MbI 3HaeM, IITo 'co60pHble onpeneJIeHIIH, npIIHHTble 6 aBrycTa 85 H B CeHTH6pe86 1503 r., KacaJIHcb ,npyrllx BonpocoB
(o HeB3IIMalIIM M3,mbl 3a XHPoToHIIIO, O皿OBbIXnoⅡaxll
COBMeCTHbIX My>KCKHx m >KeHCKHX MOHaCTblPHX) , nPHIIeM
IBa nOcJIe皿Hxpe皿eHIIFI 6bIJIII IIOC"JIHHCKHMII nO CBOeil
HanPaBJIeHHocTII 87.
no MHeHIIIo IO. K. BeryHoBa, y氷e 60JIE3Hb HBaHa lll B
nocJIenHIIx IIIIcJIax HIoJ1H

l503 r．ⅡOJIO>KHJIa

KOHeU CeKVJIH-

PH3aUllOHHblM n@ﾉIaHaM |Be,IIHKOro KHH3H IH O6cy>KnleHIIIo 3TOro Bonpoca Ha co60pe 88. Ho, oIIeB皿IIo (KaK npe皿oJIaraeT

II caM IO. K. 6eryHoB1, cyn no noBomy mJIeMeHcKIIx 3eMeJIb
H KoH｡JIHKT HBaHa III c TpoIiUKIIM HryMelloM CepamloHoM,
u

U

nOJIyIIIIBmHH nPaMaTwIeCKyIo

Pa3'BH3Ky B BHne BHe3anHOH

一

O O J I e 3 H H B e J I I I Ko r o K H H 3 H , n P e Ⅱ m e c T B O B a J I H 3 a c e n a H H H M c O -

60pa. PaccKa3 06 3ToM KoH(PJIHKTe B <CJI0Be }IHoM> HB.JIHeTCH IICTopHIIeCKoii CnPaBKOii, nOHCHHIomei np HIIIIHbl
BPa>K4bI Me班Ⅱy HBaHoM III H CepanIIoHoM, co6blTHH >Ke,
｡

113JIO)KeHHble B nePBOH IIaCTH naMHTHHKa, cJIelyeT naTHPOﾂ

BaTb lia OCHOBaHHH叩yrlIx cBHneTeJIbcTB o co60pe. B T. H.
《nHcbMe o Hemo6Kax》HB )KIITIIHルIoc,H巾a, cOCTaBJIeHHOM
JIb|BoM HdIIOJI'OrOM, yKa3blBaIOTcH JBa 3Tana 3aceXaHHii
UePKOBHOTO 'cO60Pa !HJIH旦,Ba cO60pa-ⅡePBb血nOCBH皿eHu

u

HblH BOnPOcy O !BIOBblx nOnax, H BTOPOH - O MOHacTblPCKIIx

II nePKoBHblx 3eMJIHx 89.
40KyMeHTaJIbHble HCToIIHHKH HcHo rOBOPHT, IITo nePBblii
co60p 6bl@m B aBrycTe - ceHTH6pe. no nPe且noJIo>KeHHIo
A. A. 3HMHHa, HocII. BoJIoUK" yexaJI H3 MocKBbl cpa3y
nOCJIe 3TOrO CO60Pa B CBH3H cO CMePTbIO BOJIOUKOii KHHrH84 C. M. K a m T a H o B. H3 HcToplIII
MTI'IAH", T. 10. M., 1957, cTp. 280.
83 AA3, T. 1, JYb 382.
86 TaM )Ke, Nb 383/1.

nocJI"HIIx

yneJIoB.­《TpV･Ubl

87 A. A. 3 11 M H H. KHFDKecKHe nlyxoBHble rPaMoTbI HaIIa.JIa XVI B.《HcToI)HLIecKMe 3anIIcKH:", T. 27, cTp. 271; <<HocJIaHIIFIしIoc"a BoJIoUKoro>, cTp. 372.

88 10. K. B e r y H o B̲ yKa3̲ coIJ., cTp. 360.
89くnocJIaHIIH HocHq)a Bo､moUKoro>', cTp. 367; ">KIITPIe npenonp6Horo
I'IocM(ba BoJIoKoJIaMcKoro, cocTaBJIeHIIoe HeH3BecTIIblM》­《qTeHP1H

OlInp>, 1903, KH. 111, IoTJl.] II, cTp. 36-37.
194

ʼ

HK ynbHHbl 90, T. e B HaIIaJIe IIoH6pH (oHa yMepJIa, KaK

VcTalloBIIJI A A 31IMHH, 4 HoH61)R 9II A A 3HMHIIy yXajloCb TOqHo naTIIPoBaTb cMePTb Py3cKOro KHH3H IIBaHa Bo-

pmcoBmqa(28H6H6"!503r#"):Hoc"､BoJIo""EW

no ero no瓜nIMC'H Ha XyxOBHOii rPaMoTe HBaHa BOpHCOBH-

IIa93 ,HHo H3BecTHHM )KIIT", cocTaBJIeHHoro CaBBoIo Kpy-

TIIIIKHM94,HaxomIJIcFInDcMepTIIHBaHaBopHco'BHIIayce6H
B MoHacTbIpe. CorJIacHo )KIIITIIIo IIoc"a, cocTaBJIeHHoMy

JIbBOM ①HJIOJIOrOM, Ha cO60P O MOHaCTbIPCKIIx II HeP'KOBHblx 3eMJIFIx IIocIim BoJIoUK" 6blJI <<naKII)> Bbl3BaH (II3

yneJIa?).OTcIo"Mo>KHoKaK6ymo3百面IOIIIITb,IITO3TOT

co6op llpolIcxo1HJI BO BTOPO仇ⅡoJIoBMHe HoH6PH - Ha[IaJIe
neKa6pH l503 r.
OIHaKo oTHeceHIIe co60pa, 06cy)KXaBmero mlaH ceKy､

J1HpII3am恥I,KHOfl6PlO­且eKa6plol503r.HeBo3Mo)KHo,H60
HOBroponIcKHii apxHenHcKon reHHa瓜Ⅲii, KOToPblii, eCJIII Be-

pHTb4CJIoByHHOMy>95IIco60pHLIMoTBeTaM96,npHHHMaJI
VIIaCTHe B HoJIeMIIKe C HBaHOM III HO BOnPOCy O 3eMJIFIX ny-

i(oBeHcTBa, y>Ke l2 HoH6" 1503 r. BepHyJIcH H3 MocKBbl B
xoBeHcTBa，y】Kel2HoH6”l503r，BepHyJIcHH3MocKBbl
HoBropon H 60cJIbme B MocKBy He Bbl3blBaJIcH Io IIIoHH
l504 r. 97

B《nHCbMe O HeJIIO6KaX》­HCTOIIHIIKe 60JIee paHHeM,

IIeM >KHTHe HocIIja BoJIoUKoro, cocTaBJIeHHoe JIbBoM HJIOJIOroM, - HHIIel､O

He

rOBOPlITCH

o

BTOPIIKIHOM

Bbl30Be

90 A. A. 3 11 M II II. KHFDKecKIIe Ayxo.BHble rpaMoTbI..., cTP 271 ;《nocJIaHIIH HOCH巾a BoJIoUKoro>, cTp. 372.
91 A. A. 3 II M I1 11. KHIDKecKHe 'myxoBHble rpaMoTbl..., cTp. 269.
92 TaM )Ke.

93 nHnr, Nb 88.

94<>KIITIIenpeno八o6HoroHocH*aBoJIoKoJ1aMcKpro,cocTaBJIeliHpeCaBBOIo!enmckonoMKpyTIIIIKHM,.-- "(IITeHMHE MocKoDCIfoMO6皿ecTBe
JIIo6 IITeqJIenユyxoBH6fo npocBemeHII", {[1. 21 M., 1865, cTp、32-33.
95 10.K,BeryHoB.yKa3・coII., CTp､352.
96 B nepBoM co60pHoM oTBeTe roB'oPHTcHY:' S､CIIMoH MIITpoIIoJIHT B'cea

PyClIH II aPxlMemICKonbI II emlcKonbI…》（くnocJIaHIIFI Hoc"a BoJIon-

KOrO>, CTP,322) ; Bo BTopoM nocJIaHIII! CKa3aHo: f<...CMMoH MIITPoIIMMT
Bcea PVcMH H aPxlIemIcKoⅡHeⅡHcKoⅡb1...》(TaM )Ke, cTp. 325) .
B 1503.r. 6blJI Bbel､'O OntIIH aPXmenIICKOm Ha PyCM -- reHHa皿曲. noJ'ﾝKHOCTb POCTOBCKOro aPXHenHCKona oCTaBaJIaCb He3aMe皿eHHOA C flH-

BapH 1503 r. JIo HHBaPb l50Q r. (II M C T p o e2;̲Emi" "a!"

H ilacTOHTeJIeih MoHaCTblPeii PoCCmiiCKOAⅡepKBH. Cn6.,1877,cT6.332) .
Ho3ToMV MHo)KecTBelIHoe wcJIo (<<apxHenHcKombl>) B JIomenmeM⑪
TeKCTe nePBOrO CO60PHOrO OTBeTa HanP PacCMaTPIIBaTb KaK II03XHeIImee

IIcKa)KeHIfe (cp. ToKIHbIe .opMyJIIipOBKK B cO6QpHbIx̲ nppTalIpB""3x

oT 6 aBrycTa ̅1503 r. H ceHTfl6" l503 1,.- AA3, T. I, Nb 382, 383/1) .

97 HCP几T. 1V,II. 1,Bbln､3, cTp. 611.

195

13＊

II OCH巾a B MocKBy. Hao60poT, TeKcT《nHcbM”Ⅱo3BoJIHeT
nyMaTb, IITO CeKyJIHPH3aUHOHHaH nPOrPaMMa 6blJIa BbmBIIHyTa cPa3y nOCJIe nPlIHHTHH HOCTaHOBJIeHHH O BIOBbIx

nonax 98. KC'ﾉIoBO HHOe》Ⅲ《nHcbMo O HeJIIO6Kax> OnHCblBaloT, no-BH"IMOMy, He Pa3Hble, XPOHOJIOrHIIe'CKII 3HaIIIITe.JIb-

HO OT4aJIeHHble nPyr OT JIPyra 3Tanbl o6Cy班及eHI畑ⅡJIaHOB
CeKyJIHPH3aUIIII, a JIH皿b pa3Hble nepHneTH,II 60pb6bl B TexIe-

HHe cpaBHIITeJIbHo He60JIbmoro oTpe3Ka BpeMeHH (o6皿盟曲
MoMellI. B 3TMx paccKa3ax - BblcTynJIeHHe HIIJIa Cop-

CKO 1,0 99).

B HoBropoJIcKoii ll JIeToHIIcH npHBonHTcH To[IHaH naTa
ⅡpHHHTHH co60poM HocTaHoBJIeHH兜O BXOBblx nOnaX -l CeH-

TyI6PH
1503r.100(B"MoMIoKyMeHTecKa3aHo<<ceHTH6PH>>
6e3 yKa3aHIIH IMcJIa 1ol) . 3Ty "Ty MoJKHo B3HTb B KaIIecTBe

terminus ante quem non Co60ja o nepKoBHbIx 3eMJIHM
Z3 pH" JIeTomIcHbIx cBoHoB H3BecTHo, 1ITo 21 ceHTH6pH
LIBaH III ｣C n<eTbMHnoKIIHyJI MocKBy mBepHyJIcHToJIbi<o
9 HoH6pH. 21 ceHTH6pH - 3To, oEIeBII"o, temiinils post quem
nOn ll3yqaeMoro Co60Pa.

yKJIapibIBaeTCH JIH Bepc" >KHTHH HocII.a BoJIonKoro,

cOCTaBJIeUHorO JIbBoM ･IIJIOJIOrOM, B 3TII xPOHOJIorwIecKIIe

paMKH？ComacHo秘ⅢTHIO,HBaHIIIHaHeKoTopOeBPeMH
nloMe gQ60pa o BIoBblx Honax ygep>KaJI HocH" B MocK-

Be1o2・npe皿oJIo)KHM,[IToHocII｡yexaJIH3MocKBbloKoJIo
5 ceHTH6pH. EcJIH HoBoe 3ace"ilIie ,co60Da 6bmo co3BaHo

IIepe35nHeii̲llJIHwepe3Hen;eJIIoHocJIegToro,HocH*Mor
BepHYTbgHBMocKBy4020-x[IIiceJIceHTH6pH1503r・XoTH

FI､aKOH oOOPoT nleJIa nPelcTaBJIHeTcH HeCKoJIbKO CKoPOnaJIH"
TeJIbHblM, oH, 0JHa|Ko, He HeBo3Mo)KeH. BepcHH <<nHcbMa o

HeJIl96Kax)>, me HIIIIero He roBoplITcFI o6 6Tbe3nle IIocH｡a
m3MocKBbInocJIenePBoroco60Pa,KoHeIIHo,"yq皿ecorJIaCyeTCHCBbInBHraeMoMiXPoHOJIorHeitBTOPOrOCO60Pa.

98《HQIZa co|BepmHcH co60p o BIoBblx nonex H o IHFIKoHex, H Halla cTapeU HIIJI r"aIoJIaTII, 9To6b[ y MaHacTbipeii ceJI He 6bIJIq…》（《nocJIaHmHMoc"a Bo.moUKoro", cTP. 367) .
99 B >KHTHI,I HocH*a, cocTaBJIeilHoMJIbBoMの}MoJIoroM, H B JKIITIM CePPjlHOHa rQBOPIITCH O BblCTynJIGHHH HecT"KaTeJIeA, 6e3 yKa3aHIIFI HMeH:

@<HeKoHM 60 0TUeM." (<>KIITIle npeno406Horo mocI1ja BoJIoKoJIaMcKoro, cocTaBJIeHHoe Hell3BecTIIblM>, cTI). 37; r. H. M o II c e e B a. )KII-

THe.̲"alppoJlgKOIp̲ apxIIenIIcKona
LXXI. M.- J1., 1965, crp. 156) .
Ioo nCPJI, T. 30, cTp. 175-176, 200.
10' AA3, T. I, JVb 383/1.

CepanHoHa.­噸Tpynbl

OnPJI",

1o2噸>KIITIIenpeno406HoroHocIIjaBoJToKo.maMcKoro,cocTaBJIeHHoeHeM3BecTHblM>, cTp. 36.
196

TaK IIJIH HHatle, oTHeceHIIe co60pa K nepHoXy Me)Kny l lI

21 ceHTH6pH 1503 r. He npoTHBope[IIIT HoKa3aHHHM aKToBhIx

ｿ

JI eTOⅡHCHblX, >KHT"HblX H JPyrHX HCTOIIHHKOB 103. JaTIIPOBKa >Ke erO 60JIee n03XHIIM BPeMeHeM, oIIeBImHO, IICKJIIOWa-

eTcH, nocKoJIbKy c 21 ceHTH6pH Ho 9 HoH6pfl B MocKBe He
6blJIo IIBaHa lll, a B HoFI6pe­瓜eKa6pe - reHIIa皿1月．
3．Bo3pox月eHIIe y"e入EHOM CIICTeMLI
B >KHTHFIx IIocH申a H CepaⅡHoHa K BPeMeHII co60Pa

nPIIypO[IeHo《HeIITo 60>KeCTBeHo>>, CJIyqlIBmeecH cルIBaHoM III '04. 10. K. BeryHoB cIIHTaeT, IITo 3nlecb HMeeTcFI B

BImy 60JIe3Hb HBaHa lll KoHUa lIIoJIH l503 r. I05 0XHaKo
MecTo, rme o6 3ToM coo6maeTcH B )KHTIIHx (nocJIe paccKa3a

o co60pe, 06cy>KnaBmeM mlaHbl ceKyJIHpH3aUlM) , He no3BoJIHeT

COrJTacHTbcH

c TaKIIM

xPOHOJIorlIIIeCKIIM

nPHyPoLIeHII-

eM. yIIIITblBaH naJIblJeimylO aKTHBHylO neHTeJIbHOCTb HBaHa lll B 1504-1505 rr., 40nycTIIMo npe且ⅡOJIO)KIHTb, xlTO B
>KHTHflX PeIIbm瓜eT O cepbe3HoM yJIyIImeHHH 3noPOBbfI

Be-

JIHKoro KHH3FI B ceHTFI6pe l503 r., IITo XaJIo eMy Bo3Mo>K-

HocTboTnpaBIITbcflBHoe3nKy21ceHTH6pH106.
BHoJIHe ecTecTBeHHo, IITo IIocJIe HeynaIIII Ha co60pe
HBaH III HanpaBHJIcH npe>Kne Bcero K TpoIme, r,Ⅱe cJIeXoBaJIo oKoHqaTeJ1bHo yperyJImpoBaTb KoH('JIHKT c CepanIIoHoM. BepoFITHo, no6ena UepKBH pemlIJIa npo6JIeMy yneJIoB.
ToJIbKo HoJIyIIHB oTKa3 UepKoBHblx IIepapxoB npIIHHTb

nJIaH CeKyJIHPlI3auHHⅡⅡPIIMHPHBmHCb C STIIM, HBaH III
BnJIOTHylO nPlICTyⅡHJI K BbIPa60TKe nyXoBHOii, o IIGM CBHnleTeJIbCTByeT ero nOe31Ka C. ZIeTbMHⅡo roPOnaM K CeBePy OT

MocKBbl, pacHoJIo>KeHHblM Ho cocenlcTBy c 6yny皿ⅢMH IMHT-

poBo-KamlIHcKHM II yrJI皿KHM yneJIaMH (nepecJIaBJIb-3aJIeccKIIii, PocToB, HpocJIaBJIb) . >KHTIIH IIocI"a II CepanIIo＝

U

一

Ha nPHMO cBH3blBalOT Me>Kny cOOoH JBa COOblTHH:

nPOBaJI

103 no MHeHI110 H. C. JIypbe, Bonpoc o ceJIax o6cy>K",mcfl Ha ToM x(e
co60pe, qTo II Bonpoc o BJIoBLIx Honax (H. C. JI y p b e.Ⅲ八eoJIorHtlecKafI 60pb6a….cTp. 410).
104く>K'HTIfe npenono6Horo HocI"a BoJIoKoJIaMcKoTo, cocTaBJIeHHoe He. H3BecTI･IblM>, cTp. 39; r. H M o II c e e B a. yKa3. coI1., cTp、157. .
105 10. K. B e r y H o B. yKa3. coLI., cTp､359, npHM. 32.
106 B CTeneHHoii KHHre nocJIe H3BecTHH o 60JIe3HII I'iBaHa lll roBol)IITcJI:
《I'1 TaKO CaMOneP>KaBHblit He ylIbl, HII O6JIeHIICJI, nOJIe3HaH 'nymH
cBOeiinPoMblmJwIH, Cyry6O nOnBIfr nOJIaraH.HnOIIHe C MOCKBbl H C

cbIHoMcBoIIM…> (,niaJIee O nOe3XKe nO CeBePHbIM ye3JlaM-nCPJI,
T､2 1, BTopaFI HoJIoBIIHa, cTp. 577) .
197

CeKyJI H pH3 auHOHHOhnPOrPaMMblllCOcTaBJIeHHenyxOBHOii
IIBaHa lll lo7

paCCy>K4aH IIHCTO TeOPeTHIIecKH, Mo)KIIO BblCKa3aTb nOramKy, IITo B |CJIyIIae, eCJIII 6bl CO60P OIO6PIIJI mlaH CeKyJIH-

PlI3an'HII, HBaH III OTKa3aJICH 6bl OT PaCnPeneJIeHHH 3eMeJIb
B yneJIbl MJIa瓜mHM cI)IHoBbHM. npoBaJI ceKyJIHPH3aUIIOHIIOrO
nJIaHa nPenPnPen<eJIHJI Pa34aIIy yneJIoB. HBaH III 6blJI HocTaBJIeH nepen< Heo6xoIHMocTbIo pyKoBonlcTBoBaTbcH cTaPIIHHblM

nPaBIIJIOM

nPenOCTaBJIeHIIH

KHH>KeCTB

He TOJIbKO

HaCJIeXHIIKy nPecTOJIa, HO II XPyrlIM CblHOBbHM.

3TO
BblHy>KJleHHOe
CJIenOBaHIie
TPa瓜HuHHM
O6'bHCHHeTC兄
He3PeJIoCTblO ｡OPMIIPOBaBmerOcH PyCCKoro CaMo,meP>KaB"

B KoHne XV­nepBo向noJIoBIIHe XVI B., Koma B cIIJIy co／

nHaJIbHblx

nPHqHH

3eMJIeBJIaneHIIFI II

(HenPcTaTOIIHOe

Pa3BHTHe nBOPHHCKOTO

rOPOnpB, COxpaHeHIMe KpynHorO UePKOB-

HO-MOHaCTblPCKorO 3eMJIeBJ1aneHHH) <<e皿Honep>KaBIIe> eue
IIe

MorJIo

nPeBPaTI,ITbcH

B

HeorPaHHIIeHHylO

MoHaPxHIO.

B 3THx ycJIoBIIHx cocpenoToIIeHHe BJIacTII HaX BceMH paiioHaMH rocynaPcTBa

B PyKax OnHorO

CTaPuIero

cIJIHa - Ha-

CJIe八HHKa nPecTOJIa HeH36e>KHO Bbl3BaJIO 6bl巾eonaJIbHbli
MHTe>K erO MJIa瓜皿HX 6PaTbeB, OHIIPaBmlIxCH Ha 3HaqHTeqJIbU

Hble rPyⅡⅡbl 3eMeJIDHoH aPlICToKPaTHII B JIIIIIe OⅡⅡ03mⅡHOH-

Hblx cJIoeB 60"cTBa lI XyxoBeHcTBa (He cJIyIIaiHo IOPHii
cynH no <<CJIoBy lIHoMy>", 3aIIFIJI HBHo npomepKoBHylo Ho3II、
、

UHIO B BOnPOce O CeKyJIHPm3aIIHII) .

BepoRTHo, KaKoii-To BapHaHT XyxoBHoii 6bIJI HoXroToBJIeH y)Ke K HaIIa､my HoFI6pH l503 r., omHaKo 60JIe3Hb py3cKoro
KHfl3H I'IBaHa BopHcoBHqa B HoH6pe l503 r.H marH, HanPaBJIeHHble IIBaHOM III Ha nOJIyIIeHHe ero HacJIencTBa lo8,
3acTaBHqJIH II3MeHIITb 3Ty PenaKmiIO 3aBe皿aHIIH, :II60 #B Hee
He BOmmi PacnOPfl>KeHHH OTHOCHTeJIbHo Py3bl :ⅡⅡOJIOBHHbl
P>KeBbl, a KoMy-JIH60 H3 cbIHOBeii, BO3Mo)KHo, nPemocTaBJIHU

JTIICb TePPHTOPHH, 'B3aMeH

KOToPblx

BeJIHKHH

KHH3b

XOTeJI

TenePb naTb Py3CKIIii yneJI.
HaKaHyHe H nocJIe cocTa;BJIeHHH nyxoBHoii HBaHa lll
⑥

Me)KIy 'IJIeHaMII BeJIHKOKHfDKecKOrO ceMelIcTBa ,BeJIaCb O>Ke-

cToIIeHHaH 60pb6a 3a o6JIanaHHe pa3JIHIIHblMH TeppHTopwIMII. nyxOBHaH rPaMOTa HBaHa lll, CoxPaHHBmaHcFI B c皿一
cKe HaIIaJIa XVI 'B., He HMeeT naTbl Io9. He naTHpoBaHbl TaK107 ">KIITIfe npenonp6Horo HocII*a, cocTaBJIeHHoe HeM3BecTHbIM", cTp. 39;
r. H. M oH c ee B a. yKa3. coI1., cTp. 157.
108 A. A. 3 H M II H. I<HH>KecKHe ,myxoBHbIe rPaMoTbl..., CTp、268-273.
109 nl1nr, M 89.
198

>Ke naHHaH, OTBOXHaH H Pa3'be3)Kme̲ rPaMOTbl Ha 3eMJIII,

nOJIVqeHHbleyneJIbHblMKKHH3bHMMnaUayKa3a"TOJIbKO

B ioroBope . Me>Knly BacmJIIIeM H IOpmeM ( 1 6 HIoHH
1504 r.) !l0naHHaFI rPaMOTa nPenOCTaBJIHeT BceM yXeJIb-

HbIM KIiH3bHM (IOpIIIo,nMIITpIIIo, CeMeHy m A皿peIo),ⅡBO-

pbIBMocKBe'11.OTBOnHaH̲rpaMo14nocBFImeHanPHo6peTeHIIHMIOPHFInon MocKBoHHBMocKBe - c.Cy皿eBy lI
XBopaM1l2.B"TIIpa3'I>e3>KIIxrpaMoTax巾HKCHPOBaJIIICb
U

IMmbI,
no
KoTOpbIM
6bIJIm̲pa:Me>KeqaHbl
2JIanemmfI
IQ"
U

U

(KamHHCKI1ii,
nMIITPOBCK",
Py3CK皿H3BeHIIropoXcKHII

ye3,mbl)
C
TePPHTOPmfIMm,
OCTaBmmMIIPH
B
COCTaBe
BeJIHKQ[O
⑪

KHH)KeCTBa ll3・B oXHoii pa3be3)Keli rpaMOTe, coxpaHMB-

皿eiicH B cnHcKe nepBoi ioJIoBHHbl XVI B. 114, ycTaHaBJIIIU

BaJIcH py6e>K Me>KXy CTapHUKHM..yegJoM, npenHa3HaIIaB-

mmMcHXHnPelo,'HHOBoTop>KcKIIM!'5.Pa3'beg)KIIeHanPy"e

IIacTHyneJIaAH叩eH,aTaK)KePa3もe3)KHenMHTpIIIoIICeu

MeHy HelI3BecTHbl, O皿aKo巾aKT cylllecTBOBaHIIFI Pa3'be3>Keli
AHnpelo,caMoMyMJIa且meMyyneJIbHOMyKHFI310=IIo3BOJIHeT

npe皿OJIaraTbHaJIH'IHePa3'he3>KHxHa3eMJIHnMIITpWIH

CeMeHaHⅡ031H eHmee H3'bHTHe 9THx IoKyMeHTOB I'I3 BemlU

KOKHH)KeCKOrO aPxHBa.

llo nIInr, Nb 90.
'1[ TaM XETNb 91.
''2 TaM )Ke, Nb 92.
'13 TaM >Ke, Nb 93-97.

114BoⅡRHom3HaK­ⅡePqaTKaTaKoTPx<eTIma,KaKyIOBcTPglaeMB6yMare KonI畑HomKHI『iw 'rpoIme-CepmeBa MoHacTbIpfl 30=¥ r9JIoB
⑪

⑭

XVI B. (rBJI,巾.303, KH. 518; cM. C. M. KalllTaHoB.I<omIiiH ,JIG

KHPIr'' Tpol皿e-CEprHeBa MoHacTbl" XVI a­《3amIcKII oTnteJIa pyKo-

mi&iiro6yimapcmB6HHoii6H6JIHoTekIIHMBH.JIe"Ha",Bbm18M"
1956, cTp. 8, npHM. 30).

115<BblnlIcbTI3Bem,IKorOKHFI3fIrpaMoTblHBaHaBacⅡnbeBHqaBCeflPyc" nO>KaJIoBaJI cbIHa cBoerd KHfl3H AHXpeH ropoZIoM CTapI皿elo
U

IIpo3'be3nCTaplIneoTHpBoTopcKon3eMJIHnHCMarPIIrOPbfl･eﾕo-

poEacblHaHBaHoBa,maO6IIpHHmIIHCKOIOOrPallOIOHO3anOJIbIOMe⑪

>KeIO CTaP印o K BblMJIy, JIa C BblM.na Ha JIy>KeK II Ha B"30BQHⅡe111．

"Pbllo ilejKelo npfIM6 no fIMaM mo Mmapb[ Ha Mxy, lla lj O6."UZ
mHiiCKIIM BOI)OTHoM a OT BoPoTeU uePe3 JIyr no HMaM B 60JIoTO IIa

copoKKoJIoBXoBepxoBbfIIleKIIKopo>K11,HanpaBeJ1acIUbIIIanycToull,
JaO6epHIImHHanepeBHHBpbIKaIIeBcK'HeBoJIocTH-KCTaplIUeroI)o-

iy,HaJfeBonom"dIIoIILeli̅nollJIIinHpeHMonoKoBom,3pe3HeBQ-

HOBoToPcKafl
nePeBImKoH「y6bl,a3anoJIoToM（60JIoToM？一一
y
△ 3eMJIH
C､K)3acopoKKoJIoBnepeBHHBoraTqPeBo-HBOPOECKaflBOJIOCTbK
CTaPiiUerobony,aoT60jIoTapeKoIoKopQX<eIoBHI13110Kopo)KcKoro
四

Bo,molloH, na Hc ,KoPo漣HpeKH HaJTeBo nO 6eper JIyr9̲IIO fIMaM Ha Be"
J1HKoM KaMeHb Ha BoXHII" (rnB,noronl. 1564,几1 12)
u

199

nOKyMeHTbI,BblmeⅡmHe
H3
yneJTbHOKHR>KecKIIx
KaHUeJ1叩峨HHMelO皿IIe
naTy
(>KaJTOBaHHbIerPaMOTbl,
CymHble
cnHcKmH且p)no3BoJIHIoT
,
ycraHoBIITbnbHMepH6e"eMn

nePeXOUa OnPeneJIeHHblx ye3nPB B cOCTaB TorO HJIH IiHOrO
ynleJTa, oIHaKo, nocKOJIbKy nJIH pa3HblX ye310B OHH noKa3bIBaloT Pa3HOe BPeMH nePeXOna B yneJT, HX 3HaIIeHHe KaK
HCTOIIHHKOB, onPeXeJTRIOmHX naTy ,myxOBHOi, HeJIb3H a6CO-

JIpTIi9"9BaTbJIBqepemimHnaTiipyeTmyxoBHyIoanpeJIeMI504r.，H6oJIHmbB20-xIIHcJIaxanpeJIHnOFIBwIIicb
nepBbIe >K"oBaHHble rpaMOTbl KHH3H IOp" HBaHoBH[Ia Ha

3eMJIHB nMHTPoBcKoMHKammHcKoM ire3nax !16.K gToi
U

4aT"QBKe

nO

TeM

>Ke

MOTHBaM

cKJIOHHJIHCb

H

Mbl ll7.

A
A9"JIH
9IIIOCHT
COCTaBJIeHme
myXOBHO#
K
MaPTy=
an:
U

pe"Io l504 r.･118-

OnHaKoHaII60JTeepaHH噸及OKyMeHT,noKa3blBalO皿HH
⑪

ynteJIbHoKHH)KecKHe noJTHoMoII" 10pHH,- cynHbl# cnHcoK
U

¥2,､j<anJMHcKHe leMJIII, nomIIcaHHbli KHH3eM 26 HHBa"

1504r､119,-He6bIJInOcTaBJIeHBcBH3bcanPeJIbckmMII)KIa-

JIoBaHHblMHrpaMoTaMH,Hao60poT,oH6bl〃nPOTHBOITOCTaB-

JIeH IIM. B "meii cTaTbe xoTHm roBoPIIJIocb; qTo MI3 3Toro
XoKyMeHTalOp嘘ⅡPenCTaeTKaKyneJIbHblitKHFY3bl20,0nHaU

U

KO QJPI"a̲IIe 6blJI CnleJIaH BblBOm b Cy皿eCTBOBaI-IHII B fIHBa-

pel504r･KammHcKoroyme"alOp"Me>KmyTeMIOp"Mor
BJI"eTbKamHHoMBFIHBapel504r・HenOnPOeKTyXyXOBひ

"m, cograBJIeHHoMy̲B HaqaJIe HoH6" 1503 r. (J(o cMepTli

HBaHaBOPHCOBHqaPy3CKOrO)a
,y>kenOeeOKO"TeJIBil6g
My BqWaHTY>noIIgrmeMycfl nocJIe CMepTH HBaHa BopIIcoBHqa 28 HOH6pH 1503 r. ;

BMapTel504r・HBaHIIrBbma"cePHIo>KaJIoBaHHblX
EpaMoT MIITpOno"IIbeMy noMy rpaMoTbl KacaJIHcb ye3XoB
MocKoBcKoro ,
KOJIOMeHCKOrO,
nepecJIaBJIb-3 aJIeccKoro,

IOpbeB-nQJIbCKoro,BJIamIMIIpckoro,BoJIoroncKoroIIBeJIo｣

3epcKoro!2'.HeHaxoXIIMrpaMQTMapTal504r.HaMHTpo
IloJIHIIbH BJIa"H" B ye3nax KoCTPOMcKOM, POcToBCKOM

Cy3naJIbcKoM,
IIH>KeroPoXcKoM,
MyjoMcKoM,nMMTpoBcKoM
八

1l. JIBIIepenHmH・yKa3. CO[1., xI. 1. M.- JI., 1948, cTp. 221.
H:9.jILKamTaILoBH3IICTopmmnocJIemHmXymej1OBfb7"80-281
118118A．A3mMH.
IIOxpoHoJTOWmyxoBHbIX
mdibBopAbiX[fPgMoT̅56:
li
JIIIKIIx II yneJIbHblx KHFI3eii X IV-XV BB.­“nPo6JIeMbl lYcToqHIIKoBer̲ gemi", T. V1. M.,̅ 1958, cTp. 319-320.

119 AC3H, T. 111, JVb l72.

!20C. M. KamTaHoB･Ijg Hgpp" nOCnenHHx ynleJ10B, cTp. 28 1 .
121A･311x,u.1,Nb70,113;134,150,･224,311,313,
200

II 3BeHIITopozIcKoM, rne y MIITponoJ1IITQB HMeJIHcb BoT"HM

BXVB.OfcyTcTBHerpaMoTHa3eMJIIInMIITpoBcKoroH3BeHHroPOncKorO ye340B Ka]KGTCH HaM nPlI3HaKOM TOrO, qTO B

MapTe l504 r. nMIITpoB II 3BeHHropom y>KewmcJIHJIHcb3a
IOplIeM, xoTH HeH3BecTHo, ynPaBJIFIJIHcb JIII IIM peaJIbHo.
CocTaBJIeHHe nVxoBHoii 6blJIo HcxonHblM MoMeHToM, c Ko-

ToporoMoI､JIoHaiaTbcHpacnpeUeJIeHIIeyneJIoB.BTopbIM
HeO6xOnHMblM sTanoM RBJIHJICfI, nO-BHIHMOMy, Pa3'be3n 3e-

MeJIb. BepoHTHo, ToJIbKo nocJIe 3Toro KHH3bH BcTynaJIH B
⑪

ynPaBJIeHHey且eJIoMHJIIIK KOlI-TOfrOuaCTblQ

ConocTagiIM KamIIHcK" cynHblii cnHcoK FIHBapH 1504 n

Pa3"be3>KHMII
C
rPaMOTaMm.jIa
KammliPKIIe
3eM皿.
CynH
no

ⅡomenmHM pa3'be3)KIIM, KamIIIIC"ii ye3n pa3'b">KaJIcH

nBoHKIIMo6P230M:1)oTPocToBa12212)BMecTec4MIITPoBOM - OT PanOHe>KaHnepecJIaBJIH l23. B pa3'be3)Keit, ｡HK-

cHpylomeiirPaHHⅡyMe>KnyKamHHcKIIMHPocToBcKmMye3-

naMH,peqb"eT6KamHiIcKoiiBoJ1ocTH>Ka6HeBepxHeit.
I'IMeHHO B 3TOii BoJIOcTH H HaXO且HJIIIcb 3eMJIH, HBJIHBmHeCH

o6'beKToMTH>K6bI,oTpa>KeHHoiiBcynHoMcnliclfel504 ]､、
HHTePecHo,qToTH>K6aHaIIaJIacbHenorpaMoTelOp"・HMH
KHFI3FI, BblXaBmero rPaMOTy o nPoH3BOnlCTBe cyna, B IIOnl-

JIHHHIIKe cVnHoro
cnHcKa oTcyTcTByeT, TaK KaK, coTJIacHo
nPHMeqaHIIHM II3naTeJIH,B JIeBOM BePxHeM yrJIy JIHcTaくBbI-

pbaH3HaIIIITeJIbHbliKycoKTeKcTa
(Ha4cTpoLIKHBrJIy6bc
JII皿eBoii cToPOHbl, c cOoTBeTcTBylOIInIM noBPe>KneHIIeM II

o60poTa)＞124,KonHii>Ke3ToroⅡoKyMeH1aIIecoxpaHHJIocb，

KHH3b,
PacnoP皿HBm城CH
HatlaTb
Cyne6bliⅡpOUeCC,
6blJI
BeJIIIKHM KHH3GM BceH PycH. 3TO BImHO II3 0CTaTKa THTyJTa

B nePBOi巾pa3e CyJIHOTo cmIcKa (<<BIIIJa BcefI PycI") , a TaK>Ke H3 TOro *aKTa, uTO <<Cynbfl PeKCRnOcJIO>KHTII TOCyna PH

BeJIIIKOrO KHfj3FI HJIII CTaPemarO IYeJIOBeK" 125. 11. A・roxy6HOB BOCCTaHaBJIIIBaeT yTPa[IGHHbli TeKCT HaIIaJIa̲ rPaMOTbl

cJIenylo皿HMo6pa30M:T<BeJIHKoroKHFI3FIHBaHaBaCIMUg".

O"5Ko 3Ta nofanKa He npentcTaBJIflGTcH 6eccnopHoii. no-

cJIenHHii,KToBe,naJIKamHHoMITepenl504r.,6blqJIBeJIHKHi
KHH3b BacHJI戒HBaHoBII[I BceH PyCII (nOKyMeHTarlbHo 3To

3acB皿eTeJIbcTBoBaHo IJIR 1501 r., Ho《T｡epcKafl 3GMJ1"

ynoMHHaeTcH KaK 6y4ToIIBrPaMoTeBacHJIHH1502 r, ) .
He cJIyxIaiiHo Bo BpeMfI npouecca cymbH HHTepecoBaJICFI
'22 4Hnr, Nb 93.
123 TaM )Ke, Nb 94.
124 ACSH, T、111, cTp. 187.
125 TaM >Ke, cTp. 185.

や

.

201

･

･

E

,

-

閏

･

全

』
■

npe菰及e BcerO rpaMoTaMPI BacHJIIIH: <<To y Bac rpaMoTa Be･
JIHKoro KHH3fl MHxaIIJIa BoplIcoBII'IH. EcTb JIH y Bac rpaMoIa BeJIHKoro KHH3H BacIIJIbFI HBaHoBHqFI Bcea PycH?), 126.

OIIeBImHo,
B
ToT
MoMeHT,
Ko皿a
mJIO
PaCCJIenPBaHIie,
rPaMOTblBac"HHcIIHTaJIHcbBKamIIHcKoMye3nteHaH60JIee̅aBToP HTeTHblMHⅡeiicTByIo皿HMHaKTaMH，

EcJIII cyn HaqaJIcH B I503 n npH BeJIIIKoM KHH3e BacII-

JIIIIm8aHoBHqe,ToBbIHeceHmenpmroBopalOplleM26RHBapH1504r.ecTecTBeIIHeeBceroo6'bFIcHHeTcflnePexoIOMBerO
PyKZ̲KagIIIHcKOrO ye3na B cOOTBeTcTBHPI C nyxoBHOii MIBa-

Ha ll1. Tpy,IHo npe瓜noJIo)KIITb, IITo6bI IOp" BbIcTynHJI
3neCb B POJIII nPOcTO <<cTaPemaro qeJIOBeKa)", HcHOJIHHBmerO

巾yHKHIIH 60HpIIHa Ha cJIy)K6e y BeJIHKoro KHfl3H BacIIJIHg
IIJIH mla>Ke HBaHa・nO-B皿HMoMy, pa3be3n KamHHa oT PocToBa cocToHJIcJI B KoHUe neKa6pfl 1503­ⅡePBO面noJIoBHHe

HIIBapH ̲1504 n OTcIoIa npHMepHaH "Ta myxoBHoii一旦eKa6pb l503 r.

Pea"113aUnfInyxoBHo#oKa3aJIacbneJIoMHeMeHee,ec""
He60JIeeCJIo)KHbIM,qeMeecocTaBJIeHHe.Co4HoitcToPoHDI,

noJI)KeH6blJIO|CymeCTPJIHTbcfInePexOnP皿aTePPHTOP"B
PyKH yneJIbHblx KHH3eH­H3TO MorJIo nteJIaTbCH, KaK HOKa-

3blBaeT npHMep KamHHa, B y皿ep6 Hacy皿HblM HHTePeCaM

BacHJIHH.CnpyroiicTopoHbI,Tpe60BaJIOcb3aHoBooriPemeJIHTb oTHomeHHFI Me>KIy, I'1BaHoM III H BacHJIHeM, KoTopbl#,
cTaB HacJIenHIIKoM nPecToJIa, He nPHo6PeJI eme peaJIbHoii
U

BeJIHKOKH兜】KeCKoH BJIaCTH、

CocTaB IIcToIIHHKoB, Xome且mHx oT KoHUa l503 - Ha[IaJIa

1504 r., nioBoJIbHo cKyn<eH,OceHbIo 1503 r. (HocJIe l oKTH6･
pH) nHCeU ｡ ･･ J1ⅡnFITIIH《no…cJIoBy)> HBaHa lll PaccMa'rpHBaJI cnop o 3eMJIe B JIocKoMcKoii BoJIocTII BoJToroJ<cKoro
ye3pa 127. BepoHTHo, TorXa )Ke oH - onfITb-TaKH《no…cJIoBy)D IIBa'Ha lll - cynlIJI B BploxoBcKoii BoJIocTpI 128. B o6oHx

cJIyIIaHx cHoP 6blJI PemeH He B HoJIb3y BOJIOCTHblx KPeCTbHH:
B nePBOM cJIyKJae TH]K6y BblIIrPaJI cBeT|CK城巾eOmaJ1, BO BTOpoM - MoHacTblpcKHe KpecTbHHe. B HHBape l504 r. 3aKoH-

IIWlCH
qbIHrPaHHblii
rPO皿e-CeprHeBblM
MoHacTblPeM
3eVeJIbHblii npouefc B paiioHe C9JIII r"皿Koi, y p. KocTpoMLI

(cy,mbeii BbIcmei IIHcTaHUHH 6blJI HBaH III) 129: BoJIo6THble
KPecTbFIHe Ka皿HHcKoro ye34a npoHrpaJTH TFI)K6y KaJIH3IIHy
ゾ

126 AC31I, T. 111, cTp. 184
127 TaM >Ke, T. II, Nb 307.
128 TaM >Ke, Nb 306.
129 TaM >Ke, T・I, M651.

202

U
-

MOHacTblPIO(CM.Cy""Cnmg9if,.nq皿HCaHHblIIKHH3eM

iOpmeM
rlBaH6BwIeM
26
HHBapa
l50".)=

TMM̅06pa30M,nocJIec660pal503nBo306HoBIIJIacb
nPaKTIIKanPHCy>KIeHIIHMoHaCTbIPWqlQpWWWh:
U

iMMEMBJIiiBaJIcH mHTCPe6 ""a̅ III K Paii"" BP:
JIor且bl-CoJIHraJIHuKoHBKoHuel503­HHBapel504r.？
U

HIIKaKoTo cKoJIbKo-HII6y八b yBePeHHOro OTBeTa Ha 3TOT BO-

nPOCnaTbHeJIb3fLmyMaey,qTo3TyTePP"QpMWgU9:

ji"fBBacIIJI", Kofo" KRma-To BJIamleJI KocrpoMcKKM
U

○

ye3八OM,
Kyna
BXO瓜HJIa
Co|JIb
raJIIIIIKaH.

OT d)eBpaJIH 1504 E IIMeeTc"Ba npKyMeHTa, no3BqJWmIIx cy"TL o BeJIKKOKHFDKeCKOii WJIIITHKe: yKa3H"WMO=
Ta lMBaHa lll《B CepHoxoB H Ha nepeMblmJIb llbITrIIIKoM)> c
⑪

P"EmeHmeM
Tpomde-CeprmeBy
MoHacJpIpp̲qgcM9UWi¥o
m6Mb xJIe6 ila nByXg" Bqgax <m3 3apegL32.li9WW;
eg>KaH rpaMoTa nIIcna B. H. roJIeHIIHa IW CnopUbI":W

WymamoHacTbIPH
BeJIHKoro
II
KHH3H
B
3aMQ".pKo#"29JIOCTIM皿ePHe
(Pa3"be34
COQTOHJICR《Ⅱo…
C&mOBy)>
HBa-

Ha lll) 131. TaKIIM o6pa30M, 06'beKToM BHHMaHII"Ka3aJIIIcb

KaK
3apelIKaH,
TaK
H
3aMoclfoBcKa兜ⅡoJIoBHHbl
MocKoBcKo⑪

⑪

I､oye3ma.OnpIIqHHaxTaKoiiJIoKaJIII3anIIHBHyTpeHHeHⅡoJIIITIIKII Mo>KHo ToJIbKO nPranbIBaTbCH.

C 1497 no l502 r. CepnyxoB, XoTyHb H KamHPa HaXoJH-

JMcE"yKaxcJIy>Ke6HQto.Ka3aHc"rogapHMyxaMMg4=

3MHHa. gHMoi l 502 r. MyxaMMen-3MHH 6bIJI BoccTaHoBJIeH
Ha Ka3aHcKoM npecToJIe. C 3Torq BpeMeHII MQIJIH Bo3HIIK-

WTEMeJIbHbIeiIPIITH3aHIIHHa̲CepmyxoBmKoTyHb,crlliご

-

TAEmli66H HacJIentTBoM IOp" BacIIJIbeBm" nMIITpoBcKo-

f6132CepnyxoB!InepeMblmJI.̲̲LIMeJIHo6皿eeyneJIbHOe
npommoe; BiIJ10Tb nQ ggpeglIHbl XV B oHII BI9""̲E.XW
c6PnyxoBcKIIxKHFI3eii133・KsToMy)KeynteJIynplIHanJIe>KaJIa
II - @<MymKOBH rOPb! TPeTb)>, Ha nPOe3n qePf9,､j<OTW"

/I'IBaHIIIBblnlaJIrPaMoTy,oIIeBH且Ho,BHa'IaJIel504r・PeIIb

km̅jmE9iKeiirpaMOfeCIIMoHoByMoHacTbWo1""ji
FiXMOTeIMBI
nOc"Timm
CneUmaJIbHy'O
3aMeTKy
!35,
HanmCaHU

130 rnB, noronl. 1905, n.64 06., Nb 46.
131 ACSH, T. 111, Nb 46.
132 nHnr, cTp,326.

133TaM､>Ke,drp.70,129,132,135,138,169,173.
134 ACSI'I, T. II, Nb 432.

135 C、M. KamTaHoB. Hapy皿HJI JIII HBaH III CBOIO nyxOBHyIO rPa-

MoTy？（060皿Oi
OmlI6Ke̅
g
naTIIPOBKe
rpaMoTbI)
.­《Bonpocbl
apxII̅

BoB"eAII", 1965, JVb 2, cTp. 59-62.
203

HyIO, K gQ)Ka"eH2IO, 6e3 yqeTa noKa3aHHH pa3乃e3)Keli
U

rpaMoTbl
HBaHaⅡIIO”Io
HaⅡMHTpoBcK砿，Py3cKHH
H
U

"WQ"C" ye3mlbl̅" H3 pa3be"i̅EcWf:"<iT;
U

U

MMymKoBcIfafI
TpeTL
ocTanaJIac"
60MEE̅geJMMMFDRek
",|3
B
UMIITPOBCKIIji
yneJI
nePeXo皿JIa
<<BOJIOCTb
MymKOBa> 137
⑪

=WPIToPIIHI"ryPHPylOmafIBnPOe3]KeiirP3MoTe
④

I0pIIH
oT
29
3npe)IH
504
I f．ⅡQg
lIMeHeM
JByx
TpeTeit
Mymご
WWWW"oMy BblUaqa IIBaHoMnrMM6fEI̅MM-

e3瓜IIepe3MymKoBcKyIoTpeTb
Bne”o瓜nOCJIe
COCTaBJIeHIIH

"QFMWMOPIHeMOikeT6blTb､PaCmeHe"kakmjiii6:
WIe focf"" CJIe40BaTeJIbHo, Hama KpHTHKa maTHi6"

Hl4̲A.roJIy6uoBa,
oTHocH皿erQ
nPOe3]KylO
rPaMOTy
K
1 50h r. 139, licxo""a m3 HeBepmi n6Mfii:
q J

O"aKoMbInPonojDKaeMiyMaTb,W6MMoTaHBaHalll
U

BO3HHKJIaHenOCJIe,aXOaHaJIOrHzlHOHnOq)OPMyJIHPyrPa-

MoTbllOplm.O63ToMcB皿eTeJ1bcTByer
y)Ke
)l OTMeIIeHITblii
『

p

"MH nO42"aTejIbHbIA
HaMH
nO叩a>KaTeJIbHblHxaPaKTeP
xaPaKTePHMMyHHTeTHOHⅡoJIHTHKH
IIMMyHHTeTHOii noJIIITIIKH
U

P" 9 1504 n; 2)｡ cxo>Ke6TII rniMoTbI'HBa"̅fij 66EM:
U

"UC "BpaJIbcKoi rpaMoTQi I504 n o npoBo3e Tpd皿Koro

"eqanpoe3)Ka"rPdMoTaHBaHalllCHMoliOgy̅m6EMZ
pjo goUJIa go Hac B MoHacTblpcKoM cnIIcKe Haq3JIa XVI B｡

H．A.roJIy6uoByKa3aJI,qTobnHcoK3ToT《HeBIIoJIHeTOqU

HbI" LB BeJIIIKOKHH>KeCKOM THTyJIe HBaHa lll Henjfdh

《BceRPycH>，Bno且TBep>K瓜eHHH
BacHJIH兜oTcyTcTBVeTno瓜一
咳
nIIcb
nbHKa)．O皿aKo
H3naTeJTb
He
yCOMHIIJICfl
B
nPaBHJIb-

HOcTII VePenaIIH CHIICKOM mMeHH aPXIIMa皿PHTa (<BapJIaMbH>), xOTFI HO,ⅡaHHblM n M.CTpoeBa BapJIaaM cTAJ[
、

cHMOHoBcKHM HacToHTeJIeM ToJIbKo B 1 506 r､140 (JIeTOmlcII
〆

WW"T, qTo npenUfcTgeHHHK BapJIaaMa <<BacIIaH apxII=

MaH4PHT
cHMaHOBCKo曲》"IJI"3HgJIeH
POCTOBcKIIM
abxMemIcKoHoM18HHBapHl506r.141.･nO-B皿HMoMy,
)
BapJIaaM

HeHBIWfHHagroHTeJIeMCHMoHoBaMoHacTblpffiImgl504,

HII
B
1505
rr。ⅡOHBJIeHHe
̲erQ
IIMeHPI
B
HelICnPaBHOM
MOHacTbIpg<9M,､9nHcKe̲HaqaJIaXVIBcnpoe3)KeiirpaMoTbIHBaU

HalIIl504r.06bHcHfleTcHcKopee"BceroTeM,qT6̅Emi66k
coCTaBJIHJICH B nePHo瓜ⅡpaBJIeHHH BapJIaaMa (1506-136 nHnr, Nb 95.

l37 TaM >Ke,cTp. 387, 388.
138 ACSI'1, T、1 1, Nb 427.

139
K:T9"△
"､romy
oTHocIIJIrpaMoTymJIB､IepenHHH
(yKaaco[I"
【1. 2, CTP､225)
.
!49 n̲iLC T p Oe B yKaa co(L, cTd 149-150.

I41nCP几T,XIII,nepBa別noJIOBIIHa,CTP.2.
204

1 5 1 1 rr.) , H nepemlcIIHK, co3HaTeJILHo IIJIH no omH6Ke, BnHcaJI <<BapJIaMbH> BMecTo cToHBmero B non0JIIIHIIIIKeくB acbHHa＞・

qTOゞnpencTaBJIHJIaco60曲皿epHa？no且yxoBHoii瓜MHT・
PIIH nOHCKOrO OHa 6bIJIa omaHa BMeCTe C nMHTPoBOM
y八eJIbIIoMy KHH310 neTpy l42. B nyxoBHoii HBaHa lll mepHa
ynoMIIHaeTCHBIIHcJIeMOCKOBCKHxBOJIOcTeit,KOTOPble<<6bmH
K UMHTpoBy np"aHbl)> 143. no 1472 r. oHa, no Bceii BepoHTHOCTH7 BXO皿JIa B yleJI IOpHH BacIIJIbeBHIIa nMHTpoBcKoro,

HocKojlbKy BacHJIM TeMAblit 3aBe皿aJI IOpHIo nMIITpoB
く3 3aMocKoB'bcKHMM BoJIocTLMII..., KaK 6blJIo 3a KHH3eM 3a

neTPOM> 144．HanoMHHM, IITo B 1498 r. KHFI3b BacHJI嘘ⅢBaHoBHII, cLIH HBaHa lll, HMeJI KaKIIe-To He60JIblHHe BJIaAe-

TeJILHble nPaBa B PaiioHe皿ePHbl, rme oH nPenPcTaBIIJI 3eM⑤

JIH H nOPlaPHJI KO]KaHoe eBaHreJIHe MHTPOnOJIIIIIbeli UePKBIM

HHKoJIbI B npyjKKax.

HTaK, B ｡eBpaJIe l504 r. HBaH III cocpeppToﾘ皿BHHMa⑫

IIHe Ha TePPHTOPHHX, HBJIHBmHxCH [laCTblO JeHCTBHTe.ﾉIbHOrO

(mepHa) "m ycJIoBHoro (CepnyxoB) 4MHTPoBcKoro HacⅡenlcTBa. OJHaKo 3To 6blJIH He Te paiioHbl, KoTopble no ,nyxOBHOii HBaHa lll nePenlaBaJIHCb ynleJIbHOMy nMHTPOBCKOMy
KHH310 10PIIIO HBaHOBHqy, a Te, KoTOPble B COCTaBe BeJIHKOro KHH)KeHHH 3aBemaJIHcb BacIIJIHIo. qePTbl JMHTpoBcKoro
HaC,ﾉIenlCTBa IIacTHIIHO nePeKPblBaJIIIcb B

HIIx

IIePTaMH

Ha-

cJIen(cTBa cepnyxoBcKoro II, rJIaBHoe, "apcKoro), 145. KpoMe
TOrO, H3BecTHyIo POJIb HrPaJIH, oIIeBImHO, nOJIHTHIIecKHe CBH-

3Ⅱ皿epeHcKoii BoJIocTH c BeJIHKIIM KHH3eM BacIIJIHeM. no3TOMy enlBa JIH MO>KHO ,myMaTb, IITO rJIaBHaH UeJIb BbUaIIIf

rpaMoT ,eBpaJIH l504 r. cBo皿JIaCb K HeiiTPaJIH3a皿H yneJIbHblx npHTH3aHIIii lOpHH.
B皿HMo, nepenaqa lOpHIo KamHHa B HHBape l504 r. Bbl3BaJIa Pe3Koe HenpBoJIbcTBo BacHJIHH, noTpe60BaBmero ce6e
KOMneHCaUHIO B BH且e CepnyxoBa, nepeMbllnJI兄，皿epHbl H
6JIH3KKx K JMHTpoBcKoMy yneJIy BoJIocTeil. PaccMoTpeHHble
rpaMoTbl leBpaJIH l504 r、6blJIH HanPaBJIeHbl cKOPee nPoTIIB npeTeH3Hii BacHJIHH, IIeM IOpHH. npe瓜ⅡPHHHTafl HBaHoM III B HHBape - (PeBpaJIe l504 r. nonblTKa yKpenHTb no]KaJIoBaHHHMH HaPymeHHblA B l503 r. coIo3 c TpoHUe-CeprHeBblM MOHacTblPeM ｡aKTIIIIecKHno八HHMaJIa nPecTH班
４
１
２瓜Mnr, cTp. 34.
４
３TaM )Ke, cTp. 354.
１
４
４
１
５TaMンKe, cTp. 194.
４
１

UaPHMyXaMMeA-3MI111a
205

IOpHH, KoTopblm, B oTJI}11IHe oT BacIIJIIIH, He BblcKa3aJIcH B

l 503 r. 3a ceKyJIHpH3anIIIo.
BacHJTH# 6blJI KpoBHo 3alIHTepecoBaH B 3anep>KKe pacnpenleJIeHIIH yneJIoB II, oIIeBMHo, nPoHBJIHJI HaII60JIbmee

6ecnoKoiicTBo Ho HoBoJy paiioHoB, cM母KHblX C 4MIITPOBCKIIM ye3PPM, 60HCb PaCnPocTPaHeHIIH Ha llHX BJIHflHHH
IOpHH H, Bo3Mo)KHo, >KeJIaH nocTaBHTb Hx no,瓜CBOA KOHT-

POJIb (nO nOJIyIIeHIIH BCerO BeJIHKorO KHmKeHIIH nOcJIe CMePTH oTUa). O6 3ToM, KaK HaM Ka)KeTcH, cB皿eTeJIbCTByeT He,maTIIpoBaHHblii cy4Hblii cnHcoK Ha cnopHble 3eMJIH TpoIme7CTOmeH,
CeprIIeBa MoHacTbl" 146. noKyMeHT KacaJIcfl nycTomeii

p acnoJIo丑《eHHblx B MHmyTI,IHcKoi BoJ1ocTIInepecJIaBJIb-3
nepecJIaBJIb-3aaJIeCCKorO ye3J,a, Ha rPaH皿e C nMHTPoBcKHM ye3nt0M. 3T1 I
BJIaneHIIH THHyJIH K c. Be6HKoBy JMHTpoBcKoro ye34a ｣47
cynl ocy皿ecTBJIFIJI miceU B. H. roJ1eHHH. OH IoKJIaJLIBaJI o

nPOnecCe, OIIeBHJHo,ルIBaHy lll l48, HO pe皿eHHe 6blJIO nPenOcTaBJIeHo BeJIHKoMy K"310 Bac"HIo 149. nJIH "THpoBKII
3TOro

HcToIIHIIKa

PemaIo皿ee 3HalIeHHe

IIMeeT CoCTaB

JIIIU,

npHCyTCTBOB aBmHX《Ha CyAe> y B．Ⅲ. roJIeHHHa. B npKyMeHTe yKa3aHbI <<I'1rHaTeii enppoB cblH CJIo60JIKHH, Xa
MaKcHM BacliJIbeB cblll ropIIH,八a BJIaceii y皿aK OpTeMbeB
CblH》．

B JByx HenaTHPoBal丑IblX nPaBblx rPaMOTaX micna
b. I/I. roJIeHIIHa Ha 3eMJIH B ropeToBcKoM cTaHe MocKoBcKoro ye34a cy4H1>IMH My2KaMH HBJIHIoTCFI HrHaTHii CJIo60nlKIIH
11 MaKCIIM rOPlIH, HO B Ka[IeCTBe Cy4blI BblCmeii lIHCTaHIIHm
IJblcTynaeT To'JIbKo IiBaH III, o BeJIHKoM )Ke KHH3e BacHJIHII
l/iBaHoBHIIe ynoMIIHaHHii HeT '50. ropeToBcK" cTaH MocKoBcKOrO ye3八a rPaHIIKIIIJI C AMLITPOBcKMIMH II 3BeHHroPO八cKHMH

BoJIocTHMH15';cJIeXoBaTeJIbHo,HocBoeMynopy6e>KHoMynoJIoIKeHHIo oH HanoMHHaeT MIImyTHHcK" cTaH nepecJIaBJIb3aJIeccKoro ye3na. H MIImyTHHcKHit, H ropeToBcK" cTaHI>I
｡IIrypHpyloT B pa3be3JKHx rpaMoTax HBaHa lll lOpHIo B
４６ ACali, T、1, Nh 628､
１
４７
１
TaM ]Ke, cTp、596, KoMM. K Nh 61; cp. cTp. 634, KoMM. K M 628.
４８
１

<A KHH3b BacIIJIeil cyK cBoii cKa3bIBaJI Be@jlHKoMy KHH310, a y BeJIM-

Koro KHH3H 6blJIM 60Hpe HKoB 3axapbHIIb Jla Ka3HaIIe曲旦MIITpeii Bo-

J10"MepoBHIIb:" (AC3H, T. I, cTp､541).

４
９《Ii nO BeJIHKOl､o
５
０(TaM >Ke) .

１

１

TaM JKe, T. II, JYb 421; T. 111, JVb 50. O npHHa,皿eﾝKHOC'IM K ropeToB-

cKoMy
151

KHH3JI cJ1oBy BacIIJIbH HBaHOBIIqa Bcea pyCIIII…沙

cTaHy

3eMeJIb,

*H1,ypmpyIomHx B Nh 421, cM.: ACSH, T・II,

cTp. 645 (c. MBaHoBcKoe), 661 (no､mO)KMMOJIOTOBCKaH 3eMJIH) .
且皿旦r, cTp. 381, 388-389.
206

妙

qHCJIe CMe>KHblX C JMHTPoBCKIIMH BJIaneHIIHMII TePPlITOPIIH.

rOPeToBcKmii cTaH Ha3BaH
rOPeToBcKmH
!la3BaHBPa3おe3>KeH
¥ Pa3Ee3)KeiirPaMoTeⅡHcUa
rpaMoTe nIIcUa
U

U

B. l/i. roJIeHIIHa, nonnIIcaHHoII HecKo.JIbKHMH八OJDKHOCTHblM M

JIHUaMM,BToM[llic.meMaKcIIMoMropHIIblMHHrHaTHeMCJ1o60ntKIIHblM 152. OTcIoJla MoIKHo 3aKJIIoIIIITb, [ITo pa3'be3]KaH

HnpaBbIerpaMoTblB.m.roJIeHHHaHaropeToBcKIIe3eMJIH,nPKyMeHTbl 60JIee lIJIII MeHee CHHxPOHHble.
I/IHaIIe o6'cToHT neJIo c MmmyTIIHCKHM CynHblM CHHCKOM.

mMIITPOBcKme 3eMJIII OTUe>KeBbI"JI ､̲､OI MHmyTIIHCKHX He
U

B．ll.ToJIeHHH, a M. B. TyIIKoB '53. Pa60TaBmHII BMeCTe C
TvIIKoBblM
nbHK Bac. He"IMoHoB HoHBJIHeTcH y B. H. roJIeHIIHa y)Ke B *eBpaJIe l 504 r., ̲koma roJIeHlIH ｣le)K"aJJ B

mepeicKoiiB6JIo6TII154.B.M.roJIeHHHm,mbHKBac.He｡11MOHOB COBMeCTHO HPOBo八HJIH Me>KeBaHHe TaK)Ke B BOJIoCTII

BeJIIIMocKoBcKoroye3naB7012(1503/04)r.1552B3a6opcKoii BoJIocTMInep"maBJIb-3aJIeccKoro ye3ga(pa3'be3>Kaf[
6e3 naTbl) [56. Kp6Me Toro, B 7012 r. E. li. Iq9JIeHHH onIIRpIBaJIPa八6HeJK157.mepHa,Pa,KoHe)K,BeJIII,MH皿yTHHo,3a60pcKaH BoJIocTb - TeppHTopHH, ̲pacnoJIo>Ke#HbIe cpaBHIITeJIbHO HenaJIeKo JPyr OT,n､Pyra. rOPeToBCK" CTaH, HanPOTIIB, HaXOnmJIcH B 3HaIIHTeJIbHoM OTnaJIeHHHOT 3TIIX PaHOHoB, B 3ana"oii IIacTII MocKoB"oro ye3ﾉ1a.
⑥

｡

⑪

EcJIII pa60Ta roJIeHIIHa B mepHe oTHocIITcH K HaVaJIy

｡eBpaJIH 1504 r., To II B ocWJIbHblx BoJIocTIIx, pacnoJIolKgl-

IiblXfKCeBePO-BOcTOKyOTMoCKBbI,pHneiicTBoBaJI,nO-Bm皿MOMy,nPIIMePHOBTO]Ke"eMH､(4YMaeM,qTOHePaHbme

HHBa"･IIilenOg>KeMapTal504r.).MorJIaJIIIeroropeTQB-

cKaH nleHTeJIbHocTb HMeTb MeCTo HocJIe mePeHCKO-PanplIe>K-

cKo"SToMaJIoBepoHTHonocJIenylomJIMnpmqmHaM.BroPeTOBCKIIII
nePHo瓜ⅡpH
B.Ⅲ．rOJIeHHHe
Haxo且HJIH･cbToJIbKo
U

Te JIIiUa, KOTOpbIe BMecTe C HHM yIIaCTBOBaJIIL B Pa3'be3JIe

JM
HTPOBCKOrO皿eJIa
oT
BeJIIIKoro
KHFDKeHIIH.
B皿ePeHcKOU

MHmyTHHCKHHnePHoml y roJIeHHIIa noHBJI兄IoTcH H Te7 KTO
ocyilLecTBJIHJI
Pa3'Le3只只MIITPOBCKO-MOCKOBCKIIX
TePPliTQPHm
○

BMeCTe
C八pyrHMmnHcUaMH（B,He“MoHoB-c
M.B､TyLIKOBblM 158, y皿aK - c K. r. 3a60JIbTcKMM 159) . HocKoJIbKy
一
一
唾
唖
蝿
晒
駈
暉
配
㈱

池 Ｍ羅
︑ Ｍ睡
虹 ３肌
︑ Ｍ派
通 Ｍ涯
晦 Ｍ涯
皿 瓜凪
晒 Ｍ涯

諜
独
刺
雌
榔
独
岬
眺

９ａ
９４
Ⅱ雌
４鉋
Ｌ雑
６娼
４
９６

４６
ｃｍ
６喝

７３
７

ｒｐ

６

207

roJIeHIIIIpa60IgJ1BBocToIIHoM3aMocKoBbe,BMHMo,HocJIe

oTMe>KeBaHHHnenecJIaBJIHoTnMHTpoBcKHxBoJIocTeii,Mo)K-

Ho HoJIaraTb, IITo Heq)IIMoHoB oKa3aJIcFI cHaIIaJIa noMo皿HHKoM TyIIKoBa, a y)K HoToM - roJIeHHHa.
OcBenPMJIeHHocTb B 3eMeJIbHblx neJIax BocToIIHoro 3aMqgKoBbH,npHo6peTeHHaHHe｡HMoHoBblM3aBpeMFIPa60Tbl
c TyIIKoBbIM, oIIeB"Ho, m nocJIy>KHJIa ocHoBaIfmeM iJIH ero
IlP"oMaH"POBaHHH

K

oTnPaBJIeHHOMy

B

3ToT

PaiiOH

B．H. roJIeHIIHy. B. H. roJIeHIIH H M. rOpHH Me2KeBaJIHro-

PeTQBCKQ-JMHTPoBcKIIe 3eMJIH CKOPee BcerO TOrna )Ke, KOr八a

M B. TyIIKoB H B Heq)HMoHoE Me>KeBaJIH nepecJiaBcKo八MHTpoBcKHe 3eMJIH, a K. r. 3a60JIoTcKHit li ymaK vcTaHaB­
JIIIBaJIH JMIITpoBcKo-K,mIIHcKHe py6e班Ⅱ. KOHeIIHO, PaCCy)K-

gaFI ̲｡OPMaJIbHO-JIOrHqeCKH, Mbl BHPaBe XOnycTIITE,唖To H
B. He｡HMoHoB H y皿aK cHaIIaJIa pa60TaJIH c B. H・roJIeHIIHblM B BocTo[IHoM 3aMocKoBbe H ｡JIHmb 3aTeM nepeIIIJIII K
IIPe3BblIIahHblM nHCnaM, 3aHIIMaBmHMcJI Pa3Ee3npM uMIITpoB､cKoro yneJIa oT BeJIHKoro KHmKeHHH. npoTHB aToro, o,IHaKO, rOBOPIiT JIOrIIKa nHcUOBO-Me)KeBOh瓜eHTeJIbHOCTHTOro

BpeMeHH: He Mor B．Ⅲ．roJIeHIIH BMecTe c ymaKoM, M. ro-

PHHblMIIIi・CJIo6o,ⅡKHHblMCy八HTbBMH皿yTIIHCKOiiBOJIOCTIi
40 nPoBenleHHH 34ecb Me>KeBaHHH M. B. TyIIKoBblM, B. He｡HMoHoBblM H Il. CJIo60"HHbIM.

H・CJIo604KHHynoMHHaeTcHBpHnleHcToIIHIIKoB.Bpa3'Le3]KHX rPaMOTax Pa3HblX miCUOB HBaHa lll, OTMe)KeBblBaB-

皿Hx IMHTPOBcK" yAeJI OT BeJIHKorO KHmKeHHH, a TaK)Ke B
cynHOM cHHCKe, HO八nHcaHHoM 26 HHBapH l504 r. KHH3eM
IOpHeM I'IBaHoBHIIeM, lirHaTHih CJIo60AKHH Ha3BaH mibHKoM

KHH3H IOpHH; B ropeToBcKHx npaBblx rpaMoTax H B MH皿yTHHcKoM cyJHoM cHHcKe B.li. roJIeHIIHa lI. CJIo60"HH "IrypmpyeT 6e3 BcHKoro 3BaHHH, 'ITo HocJIy]KIIJIo JIJIH II. A. ro-

JIy6UOBa ocHoBaHHeM naTHPoBaTb on(Hy li3 roPeToBcKHx nPaBblx rpaMoT BpeMeHeM 40 1 504 r. ( 1498/99 r.) ｣60. B npaBblx

rpaMoTax H B cynHoM cHIIcKe CJIo60AKHH BblcTynaeT B oKpy>KeHIIH JIHU, HMeBmHX HenoCPe八CTBeHHOe OTHOmeHIIe X Pa3be3Jy "M HTPOB cKOrO yneJIa, nO3TOMy OTOABHraTb八aTy aTHX
八OKyMeHTOB八aJIeKO

oT l504 r. HeJIb3H.Ⅲ. CJIo6oAKHH npH⑨

cyTCTBoBaJI Ha cyne, O【IeBH八Ho, KaK yno!ﾉIHOMoIIeHHbIHKHH3H

IOpHH HBaHoBHIIa, nPe4cTaBJIHBm"
npe4cTaBJIHBm" erO
el℃IiHTePecbl.
IiHTePecbl・TaKoe
TaKoe
＝

IO OblTb BIIeDHoⅡ Me>KeBaHHH H･JIH BcKo­
HOJIOZKeHHe neJI MOI,JIO
OblTb B nePHO八Me]KeBaHHH HJIH BcKO-

Pe nO|cJIe HerO. IITO KaCaeTCH ynOMHHaHIIHH・CJIo604KIIHa
Iuo AC3I/1, T. 11, M 421
208

｜
ʼ

6e3 yKa3aHII)I ero 40J1>KHocTIｲ，'rO IIe cBH3aHO JIH 3TO cO Cne皿4)M'Ko力y瓜ocToBePmTeJIbHo曲[IacTHcy且e6Hblx瓜oKyMeHToB？
(ymaK To)Ke He Ha3BaH nbHKOM, xoTH B Pa3be3>Ke# rPaMoTG
OH onPe4eJIHeTcH KaK RBoPUOBblh且bHK 16!) .

MaKcIIM roplIH B HHBape l504 r、cJIy>KHJI nPH KHH3e
AJIeKcaHnwpe BJIanJIMIIpoBHIIe PocToBcKoM, KoTopbl曲6blJI ,
HaBepHoe, ero cIo3epeHoM 162; B 7012 (1503/04) r. roplm -̲
HocJIyx B PocToBcKoM ye3Jte '63, a 30 aBrycTa l504 r. oH
Pa3T,exaJI 3eMJHI B )K"HcKoM｣cTaHe MocKoBcKoTo ye34a 164.
nepexom ropIIHa K B M. roJIeHIIHy cocToFIJ1cH, no-BWIHMoMy, He l)aHbme FII-IBapfl l504 r.
HTaK, BCe naHHble o JIHnaX, ynOMfIHyTblx B Pa3'be3)KHx
rPaMOTaxH川)yrIIx HcToIIHHKax, BenyT Hac K HHBapIo 1504 1､．
KaK HaH60JIee BepofITIIoii maTe pa3'be3>Kei m ropeToBcKIIx
npaBblx rpaMoT B. I/I. roJIeHIIIIa H M. ropMIHa. MH山yTHH⑥

U
一

cKIIH >Ke Cym-IblH cnHCO|K OTHOCHTCH, MO>KeT OblTb, K CaMOMy

KO皿y HHBapH HJIII K (beBpaJIIo - MapTy l504 r.
HecMoTpH Ha pa3Be3瓜及MIITPoBCKHx BoJIoCTeii OT MocKoB'cKIIx II nepecJIaBcKHx B FIHBaPe l504 r., IOp" BcTynwI B
一

U

OOJIanaHHe nMHTPoBCKoH IIaCTblo

cBoerO

yneJIa

TOJIbKo

B

KOI-皿e anpeJIH 1504 r. 3HaIIIIT, Pa3'be3nt e皿e lle 6blJI rapaHU

U

TI'IeH

nelICTBIITeJIbHOrO

nePexoXa

ye34a

B

PyKH

cOoTBeT-

CT BylO皿erO ymeJIbHOrO KHfl3FI. 3ToT BblBO且ⅡOnKpenJIHeTcfl
TeM o6cToHTeJIbcTBoM, qTo nplI Ha皿凹HII Pa3'be3)Kei rPaMoTbl l'IBaHa lll AHnpeIo Ha CTapmUK" ye3瓜且0 1519 r・IIeT
HIIKaKIIx naIIIIblx o6 ynpaBJIeHIiH AHnpeH CTaplmeih.
KaK IIoKa3blBaeT MII皿yTHHCK" Cy皿blii CnHcoK, BeJIHKIIii
KHfl3b BacIIJIHi cTpeMHJIcH KoHTpoJIIipoBaTb neJIa, cBH3allHble c pa3'be3npM cHopHblx Hopy6e>KHblx 3eMeJIIJ. Ero aKTIIBHocTb B 3ToM nJIaHe BHoJIHe noHHTHa. Pa3･be3)KHe rPaMOTbl

IIBaHa lll lOpHIo 3aKaHIIHBaJIHcb cJIenylo皿eii CTaTbeii:
《I/i neTeM MoHM, BacHJIblo H IOpbIo, Tex ToponpB II cTaHoB II
四

一

BOJIoCTelI BenlaTH PyOex〈nO CeMy CnHCKy nO TOMy, KaK B ceM

cnHcKy nHcaHo)". C caMoro HaIIaJIa Me>KeBaHHH BacIIJIHii li
IOI)IIii oKa3aJIHcb B noJIo)KeHHHPeaJIbHblx noJIIITIIqecKHx conepHHKoB. 3a,mep>KKa B npenPcTaBJIeHHH yneJIoB MJIa瓜mHM
cblHoBbflM HBaHa lll onPeAeJIHJIaCb B nePBylo oIIepenb n03IInHeii BacIIJIHH.

６
１ 且Hnr, Nb 96.
１
６
１
２ACam, T. I, Nb 651.
６
３ TaM >Ke, Nh 648.
１
４
６
１
TaM月〈e,T・II, JVb 429
14

C ． M , ． K a 皿 I Ta H o B

209

3aMog<opp"eBoJIocTH,BKoTopblxBHarlaJIel504EJIeiWQBa4BHIPJIeHIIH,KoHUeHTPmPOBaJIIIcbBoKPyfPSI6He)Ka.
59"OCTb
̲Be"II
HenocPemCTEeAHO
nPHMblKaJMKWemy
cIora,mepHa6bIJIapacnoJio>KeHaKBocfoKyoTPa46IEM
U

ソ

oTneJIHJIacb
BoJIocTbIo
KHero
PaⅡoHe》K
oTBopeit-Kop3eHeBbIMPanPHe>K
rpaHIIIIHJI
c且MHTpoBcKHMH
JMIITPOBCKIIMMi
BOJIb6T""̅
CERill5f6:CaM
BoJIocTHMH
rPaHmqIIJ
Bblmero̲
pQAoMHHHo6a)KeM165.TaKIIMO6pa30M,co4HoicTopoHbl,
U

cO34aeTCH BneqaT,ⅡeHHe, [ITO Pa60Ta rOJIeHIIHa HMeJIa meJIblo
哩

W<PenJIeHIie BeJIIIKoKHfI)KecKo# BJIacTH B nOPy6e>KHbIx c

HMHTpoBcKHM
ye31IoM
3eMJIHx.
C叩yrOii
CTOPOHbl,
3TH
MePbl

Mo)KHo PacUeHHBaTb H KaK npe40xpaHHTeJIbHble npoTHB Ba-

CIIJIIIH, 2TPeMHBmerOCH, nO-BH"MOMy, yTBeP"TbcH B cOce几-

HeMCnMHTPOBcKIIMymeJIOMPa40i6>kem6JIII3KIIxKHeil#
3aMOCKOBCIgIx II nePeCJIaECKIIx BOJIoCTHx. PanoHe>K HeKOr"

BXO且HJI B CepnyxoBcKo-BopoBcKoe KHgzKecTBo. BHMMaHIie

IIBaHalllBH*Iel504rEKpa3HbIMqacTHMcepnyxoBcKo.9poBcKoro"HagJIencTBa
(CepilyxoBy,
nepeMb[皿J1Io,
TPeTH
MymKoBcKoii,PappHe>K)llKfi>K6Tc"iecJIyiaiiHblMCJIehyeT
･

yIIHTblBaTb TaK]Ke, IITo Bbl皿erOPOn, Pa4OHe)K II BeJIH-

6blBmaH c(Pepa BJIHHHIMA皿peHyrJI皿KOrO 166,'IblIMHacJIgWIK9MHKaKoII-To Mepe jIBJIHJIcfI BacmJIHii, noJIyqIIBmmii
B 1501-1502 rr・IIacTb ero VIeJIa.

PaCW9TPlIM
cQ2TaB
36MeJIb,
oXBaIIeHHblx
rPaMOTaMH
I/IBaHalllMapTa
l504r.MMTPohoJIIIqbeMynPMy.rpaMoT&l

Ha MIITP9nOJIIIIIPH BOT[IHHbl MOcKOBCKOro ye3" KaCaeTCH
U

WIaneHH" Co60JIeBe, EoxoBe, BbIKoBe, CefyHcKoM cTaHax,
JIyIIHHcKoiiBoJIocTIIHPoro>KcKoM<<ye3ne)>157.Bo"ocTbPo｣
U

ro>K HaxoJJIJIacb B PaiioHe HblHemHero HorHHcKa (6blBmero

BoropoUcKa)!68,ceBepHeeBoxHbIII,oIIeB皿Ho,IojKHeeCo-

60JIeBacTaHa,Me班且yI-lePHorOJIOBJIeMHaBocTOKe,BoxoBblM
cTaHoM II BoJIocTblo BeJIH Ha 3aname. Co60JIeB cTaH(Bo3-

ｰOTもe3班eMvcTaHy）
Mo>KHo, To>KnecTBeHHblA IIo3"eiimeMy
MC>KHo，To>K且ecTBeHHblHno3“eHmeMV
OTBe3JKeMy cTaHy)
い

y

n PenlCTaBJIH@ﾉI, CKOPee BCerO, OT4eJIIIBnlylOCH IlaCTb BOJIOcTII
mePHbl.
HaIore
IoreoH
oHrpaH皿H",
rDaHHLIII."nO-BH血MOMy,
nn-RwmTMnMv「、pnrn刃ぐ得M
mepHbl. Ha
c POrO>KeM,

Ha ceBepe - c Bopeit-Kop3eHeBblM,
ji-Kop3eHeBblM, Ha BocToKe - c meP
mepU

HOH, Ha 3anane - ,C

』BeJIH169.
BeJIH169，BOxoB
BOxoB
cTaH
cTaH6blJI
6blJI
oKPy)KeH̅c
oKpy>KeHc

165 B.

H. ne60JIbcKII ii. nyXOBIIb'eH瓜orOBOPHble rPaMOTbl MOCKOBL"¥ KHH3erI KaK IICToPllKO-reorPa中晒ecKIIii HcToIIHIIK, [Bbln. I]. Cn5.{

６
６

lg01, KapTa B KoHme KHIirlij Emll. ̅I1. Cn6" 1902, KaPia
OH IIMeJI 3Aecb p皿ceJI (JIMnr, cTp. 327) .

６
７ Aq)31,1X, u．1, Nb 70.
１
８
６
１
６
９
１

P r o T b e 3"IQpKoBHblil Kpaii B XVII BeKe M., 1906, crp 578
Pacn9JIo>KeHIIeCo60JleBacIaIjaycTaHaBJIIIBaeTcfIno.oTHo6IIMdiirpaMOTOii K HeMy《瓜epeBHe B npy)KKy>. OweBMHo, IIMeeTcFI B B"v rlo210

Iora lI Ioro-BocToKaBacI,IJIbⅡoBblMcTaHoM
IoraHIoro-BocToKa
BacI,IJIbnoBblM cTaHoMHII BoxHoH，cIoroBoxHoji, c IoTo3anaJIa - MaHaTbIIHblM

cTalloM,

c

ceBepa - BoJIocTblo

BeJIII, c BocToKa - o[IeBHJHo, Co60JIeBblM cTaHoM, c 3aⅡa瓜a - BblKoBblM. BblKOB CTaH nPHMblKaJI Ha ceBepe K

BBImeropoIcKoMy cTaHy nMIITpoBcKoro ye3" '70, " ceBe-

Po-BoCTOKe-KPanPHe>Ky,HalOreoIIrPallH【IHJIcMaHarbHHblM

H

BOxOBblM

cTaHaMH,

Ha

BOcTOKe - c

BoJIoCTblO

U

BeJTII, Ha 3anaXe - c JMHTpoBcKoii BoJIocTblo 3apanpMJIe ｣71.
U

TaKHM o6pa30M, B >KaJIoBaHHoII rpaMoTe PeLIb m｡JIa o
MOCKOBCKHX CTaHax, nPIIMblKaBmJIX C 3anama

H IOra K BO-

JIOCTFIM BeJm,meplle ll PanpHe)Ky, r八e Pa60Ta｡w nPHMel)IIo
B To >Ke BpeMFI nMceU B. I/I. roJ1eIII冊1．

CeTVIItKHii cTaH PI JIyIIIIHcKaH BoJIocTb 61,IJII1 1)acnoJIo-

>KeHbl B IIHOM PaIIOHe­K 3anaAy oT MocKBbl. JIyIIIIHcKa>I
BoJIocTbrpaHHqiIJIacMymKoBCKoitBoJIocTblonMHTpoBcKoro
ye3" m 6TaHoM Cypo>KHKoM MocKoBcKoro ye34a M "eU

U

bei72,3BeHIiropom6kllMye3npMHa!orem3ana4e!73(JIyIJriHcKOe Haxo旦HJIocb B 19 Bep'cTax K ceBepy oT 3BeHIIropona 174) , ropeToBbIM cTaHoM MocKoBcKoro ye3na Ha loro-Bo-

cToKe. CeTvHcKHmcTaH
Ha CeBePe rPal-IIIIIHJI, no-BHⅡHMOMy,
ご
｡

crOPeToB1ｺIMHKopoBIIHblMcTaHaMHMocKoBcKoroye3na,
IIa lOre - c CoceHcKHM H TapaKMaHoBcKIIM cTaHaMII, Ha

BOCToKe nPllMblKaJI K I､. MocKBe, Ha 3anane, Bo3Mo>KHo, co-

npHKacaJIcHIIacTH11HO
PHKacaJIcH [IacTIIIIHO
CJIyIIHHCKoHBOJIoCTblO，IIacTHIIHoC JIyWICKoII BOJIoCTblO, [lacTH[IHo c63BeHIIropoIcKzMye3IoMl7q
＝

CJIenoBaTeJIbHo, H 3ToT KoMnJIeKc 3eMeJIb Bxo且HJI B oo-

JIacTb,HaKoTopyIopacnpocTpaHflJIocb̲QCo6e!IHoeBIWMalIIIe

rlPaBIiTeJ1bcTBa"jiBaila lll B ilaIlaJIe l504 n(TpeTb MymKo-

Ba, rOl)eToBcKIIi cTaH).

rocT npy>KKI! Ha l)LL I̅Ipy¥<eHKe, jl"oMJpmToKe pBopl! ､!oq gW

"bdt tM;̅ACai4, Tf1.1 L cTp. 486-488; KoMMemTapum m. 4. IJo-

i7"3akNb28"52;pqnpy>KUlKy"PM/､HaKal]TGM9"BcW･Io6jl.

1 939 r.; coce且剛le cfjHb! 6M.: E. ̅n. C T a m e B c K II fi. MocKoBCKIIiiye3典nonIIcuoBbIMKIIIIraMXVIB.KIIGB,1907,KapTaBKoHUe
，

KHHr川．

170 nlInr, cTp. 392.
171 TaM }Ke, cTp. 390.
172 TaM )Ke, cTp. 387.
l73 TaM )Ke, cTp. 383.

L

174 B. H. ne6b"bcK m i yKa3. coLL, [Bbin. l], cTP21.

u

175CP･1'1．E.3a6eJIIIH．I<yl皿oBo
11
UpelJHIlih̅CeTyHcKIIii
cTaH.
M､，

l873. O MecToHaxo班旦eHIIH ymOMflIIyTblX B rPaMOTe MIITPOq9JIIHWK

ceʻⅢ「o]1eHIIUeBa n CGJ1fIT1IIIay cM.: <HcTopmfl MocKBbli", T. l M., 1952,
cTp. 73 11 KapTbl.
211

14＊

K" pacUeHIIBaTb3HaIIeHIIeTaKoii JIoKaJI!13aLIIIIIRIIvT咽

U

ゾ

eHHeHⅡoJIHTHKIIB
P
MocKoBcKoMye3且e？CBO皿MOCI>
JIII
3neCb

ユeJIoJIHmb
K60Pb6e
CⅡMⅡTPoBCKo厳OI1acHocTblO？MblBI,皿eJIH,[ITOOIHI199JIQCTIIIICTaHbl,nOnaBmHeBC巾ePynOJII,ITH"

¥MWa":1504r"rpanmwHjIm̲pye3naMIInMIMEMM
{P"911C'K,PbIKOBcTaATPCTEMyiIK"r"ﾘHHCKaflBo2"b),､"H3BeljIIropogcKHM(JIymincKajiEoIUcMW6>f5]

"9gIYHPK" :T3H) ; mPyr4e hB""" MMM,ME6

f"yBmIIMI" K IMIITpoBy (Poro>K, mepHa) ; oIHallcM"
"IIcb H Te2PIITOPlIII, ToJIbKo nPIJMblKaBmrIe K 3THM 3eMJIFIM

(29JIQcTbBeJIII,bTaHbl5oxoB,bo6oJIenJpETM"CMM

"Hr""cTaBnfIJI co60ih, oqeB"Ho, Ty (Iacfb lIp6BHe# BoJIo⑪

cTIIUIepHIJI,mellaxoJIII@mcHⅡOrOcTnPy>KKI,06'EeKTBJIajleTgil)HbIx nP3B BacIIJIIIH B nepmoJI el:6 0naJIb! l498 r:
U

BIyxOBHOjirPaMoTeHBaHdllIcKa3aHo!《且aIITO6blJII,I

lf̲JMHTPOBynP皿aHblBoJIocT2
MocKoBcKIIe
poro>K,
BopH,
IW3eneBo,mepHaropo49K,CyJIHmm"̅EROMi'CEM

3̲33̲ I¥｡JIocTH ntaIo K MocKBe co BceM no cTapIIHe cbIH#

"eMyBacmlbIo;maeMy)KnaIOBoJIocTIICypo派ﾙ1K,naJIy-

M"cKoe,naPanPHe>KcBoJIOCrbMHII3nyTwhiII365JIM̅60

BceMII ,IppnllIIIHaMH, " TpeTb My皿KOBy C MblTOM C JIOn-

cKHM>>176.BuHTHPOBaHHOH
cTaTbe
nePeIIHcJIeHbl
TePPIIToU

PIIH,COCTaBJIHBmHeHnPooIIePtleHHoroBbllueKPyra3eMeJIb,

oKa3aB皿HWIB̲leHTPe3eMeJIbHO-HMMyHﾙITeTHOirlOJTHTHKIf

Ha[IaJIa
l504
r・Bo3HHKaeT
npe瓜ⅡOJIO)Kel-IHe,
He
noCTaBHJI川l
BacIMMi !lepen MRalloM III.Ronpoc o lIEM"eiiMM"ﾉIⅢ『？

U

34m̲frrOHCTaTblUl､lleO6LfICHHerCfIJII!Bbina[IarPAMOTB

(heBIlaJIe-MapTel504rnonblTKoAIIBaHalllCOPBaTbnJIaHblBacHJIHRIi3aKpenlITbyKa3aHI­IblepaAoHbl3aco60能

2IMW""gHe
6HIIMaeT̅nPOdneME!
M6EMEK6riMmm
ご

"" oWI'OmeW, a nPe"TaBJIfIeT ee B 60JIee KoHKPefHoM

"eTe #BaH III 4QJI>KeH 6bIJI B KaKoih･To MepE IfO"riiAW
ryIIKII BacllJIHIQ OH no>KamoBa.II ero nPaBoAi 6ym"am
"IcTalInHII B oTgomeHIIIi cocenHeii c JMIITpoBOM MIImVTImｰ
WWJIQ"LrOPeTOBCKIIe ne"2 HBaH ITI PaCCMar"5)!
U

U

ソ

ロ

U

CaM,
I-IO,
nO-BH且HMoM)k
HaneJIIIJI
BacliJwIH
HeKOTopbIMHⅡo好

39WWMMBcWHeCypo>KIIKe(norpaHII[IHoM6My皿KCBC"BOJIOCTblO
cK
oHBOJIOCTbIO
nMIITPoBcKQro
nMHTPoBcKOroye3“Ⅲ，BePOHTHo，oTI
ye34a̅II,BePOHTHo,6r'la6fm
IacTH
CO
apeHIIrOPO,mCKHM
ye3"OM)
.

no47013r.BonHcHapxMBagynoBaMOHacTbIPHyKa3a-

Hbl nBe rpaMoTbl BeJIIIKoro KHH3FI BacIMHfl HBaHoBIIIIa.: o皿-1a
1 76 JI】且r, cTI). 354
212

<<Cy4Hafl> Ha 3eM川o C. JIynIKoB, ml)yraH 6e3 IIa3BalimR一一
《Ha CeHIIble noKocbl no p. I/IcTpe> '77. Mbl HoMHIIM, IITo oKo-

JIo 1506 r. c JIyIKKH Haxo"JIocb B Cypo>KHKe !78. PeKa HcT-

W npoTeIIaJIa B I)a"He MymKoBcKoii TpeTII, CypolKMKa,

JIyqmHcKo'KBoJIocTII,ropeToBcKorocTaHail3BeHHfdponcKo4
ro ye34a. CeHHble noKocbl JIe)KaJIm, oLIeBMHo, HenajleKo oT

JIy]KKOB. qyn<OBCKHe CB皿eTeJIbcTBaocynle6Hoii(Mo)KeT
6blTb, H MeJKeBoi)八eflTeJIbHocTII BacIMHH IIBal-IoBHIIa B cell-

TH6pe l504 - aBrycTe l505 r. He HBJIHIoTcH, KoHerlHo, npKa3aTeJIbcTBoM Toro, IITo oH y)Ke B HaIIaJIe l504 r・HMeJI Cyme6Hble npaBa B Cypo>KHKe H oKpecTHocTHx, Ho oHIi ppcTaToLIHo
paCKPblBalOT HanPa'BJIeHH|OcTb ero nPeTeH3Hit.

BrpaMoTeMHTpoRoJIHqbeMy八oMyHaKoJIOMeHCKHeBJIanelIHH o6'beKTOM Ho>KaJIoBaHIIH 6blJIo ceJIO BHCePOBo c 4epeBHHMH BBPameBe l79,PaCnOJ1O)KellHOiIMeX〈瓜ycpe4HIIM
TeIIeHIIeM p. HepcKoM H ee llpIIToKoM CyxaHKoji !80. C BocToKa K 3ToA TePPIITOPHII nPHMblKaJIa BOJIOcTb ryCJIHUa, BXO-

皿B皿" B XVB. E cocTaB JMKTpoBcKoro yneJIa. no nyxoB-

Hoii IIBaHa lll rycJIIiUa npe"la3Ha[IaJIacb AHnpeIo; npH
sToM IOpHIo 6blJIo 3anpeUeHo BcTynaTbcfl B Hee, KaK H- B
gpyrHe 3aBelnaHHbIe AIInpelo BoJIocTH, npe)Kne THHyBmme K
UMHTpoBy '81. CaMa BoJIocTb Bpa皿eBa HBJIHJIaCb HacJIe4cTBoM BeJIHKOti KIIH皿HH MapHH HpocJIaBHbl l82, Bo3Mo)KHo,

nepenlaBmeii ee onHoMy li3 cblHoBeil. TaKIIM o6pa30M, Bpa皿eBa HMeJIa BaJKHOe 3HaqeHHe JIII60 KaK ynteJIbHOe HaCJIencTBO, JIH60 KaK TePPHToPHfl, cOCe4HHH c ryCJIImeh．ynleJI bl

MJIa瓜mHX KHJI3eii 6blJIm瓜JIfl BacIIJIIIH 60JIee npcTynHbIM
KycKoM, IIeM yneJI IOPHH, nosToMy HBaH III cTpeMHJIcfI
OrPaHHIIHTb erO aⅡneTHTbl, yKPenJIHH CBOIO BJIacTb Ha nO,qC Ty n a X K y 八 e J I b H b l M B O J I O C T H M ・

B nepecJIaBcKoii rpaMoTe MIITPoHoJIHLIbeMy npMy "rypml)yIoT ceJIa B BeJIHKoii cJIo60", KoHIomcKoM M HI'IKmUKoM

cTaHax l83. BeJIIIKafl cJIo60Aa - Ioro-3ananHaH IIacTb nepecJIaBJlb-3aJIeccKoro ye3" - Haxo,瓜HJIacb B6JIH3H 3aMocKoB１
７７ ACSIJ, T. 111, JVb 48a, cTp. 73, rp. 353, 354.
１
７８

B.̲ P. K O 6 PjI H. nBe >KaJIOBaHHble rPaMOTb! IIynlOBy MOHacTblPlo
(XVI B.).­く3anMcKII omeJIa pyK,omiceii rocyAapcTBeHHoik 6M6JIIIoTeKHHM. B. H. J1eHIIH", Bbln. 25. M., 1962, cTl). 295.

９ A3HX, w．1,JVb ll3.
７
１
０
８
１
１ B. H.Ue6oJIbcKIIk.yKa3. coII., [BbIn. l], cTp. 5-6.
８
１
２ 瓜ⅢⅡr, cTp. 360.
８
１
TaM )Ke, cTP. 196.
８
１
３
Aの3IIX, [1. 1, JYb l34.
213

cKoii BoJIocTII KyIIeH ]84, KoTopafl, KaK H rycJIIiUa, B XV B.
6blJIa K UMIITPOBy @<nPlmaHa),, a HBaHOM III 3aBeuallaCaMoMV MJIa1meMV cblHV - AHnpelo
ム

(rpaHIIIIIIJTa

c MIJ皿VTIIご

HbIM) J<OHIOmCKHii CTaH, PacnOJIO>KeHHblji ceBePO-BoCTOtlHee
nepecJIaBcKoro o3epa, npocTIIpaJIcfl fIo pocToBcKoro py6e]Ka l85. HIIKI皿KIIil cTaH nPIIMblKaJI K o3epy c IOro-BocTOKa.
OH TFIIIyJIcfl no p. Tpy6e>Ky '86 B cTopoHy lOpbeB-noJIbcKoro
ye3na. IOpbeB-n'oJIbcKaH rpaMoTa Ha3blBaeT BJIanleHHH B
myTKHHe cTaHe l87. SToT cTaH 3aHHMaJI neHTpaJIbHylo IIacTb
ye3" B 6acceiiHe p. KoJIoKmH I88・myTKI'IH CTaH BXO瓜皿He管
Korma B c｡ePy BJIIIFIHIIH yneJIbHorO JMHTPoBCKOro KHH3H
IOpHH BacIIJIbeIBHIIa.
Bo BJIa且HMIIPcKoih rPaMOTe MIITPoIIOJIIITy nePeIIIIcJIeHbl
3eMeJIbHble BJIalleHH兄B CJIePylOUMX a4MHHI,ICTPaTHBHblX e4H-

H皿ax: B OIIoJ1LcKoM, BoTo｡mlo6cKoM,《MeJIexOTUKOM> (I/IJIbMexoUKoM) , KJIeKoBe cTaHax, B CeHry, B Pory, B BoJIocTHx
CJIaBUoBe, Bamaqe, ConoMoBe, >Kal､anoBe, THyHUoBe yme,
noropeJIIIIle, CaHHIIIIe l89・O noJIbcKH曲, BoroJIIo6cKIm, HJIbMexoUKH曲H KJIeKoB cTaHbl cocTaBJIHJIII UeHTpaJIbHylo IIacTb
BJIanHMHpcKoro ye3na, npH'IeM nepBble TpH 6blJIII pacnoJIo>KeHbl K ceBepy oT p. KJ1H3bMbl lI rpaHIILIHJIII c ye3naMII Cy3且aIIbcKHM (OnoJIbcKIIji, BoroJIIo6cKHii cTaHbl) II IOpbeB-

HoJIbcKIIM (MJIbMexoUKIIM cTaH) 19q BoJIocTb CaHHHue, BepOJITHO, BXO瓜HJIa ,B cOcTaB IIJIbMexOUKorO cTaHa lI 3axBaTblBaJIa 3eMJ1H Ho npaBoMy 6ePery p. KJIH3bMbl ]91. KJIeKoB
CTaH, JIe)KaBmmHK Iory oT r. BJIanIIMHpa B 6acceiiHe peK

By>KHH noJIH, npIIToKoB OKH '92, rpaHIIIIHJI Ha 3ana"e c
BJIanlIMIIPcKHMII BOJIOcTHMII皿aTypoM II BblmeJIecoM.皿aTyP HBJIHJIcFI HacJIe4cTBoM BeJIIIKoii KHHrmHH MapHH Hpo184 CM．c.B・Kal)HHcKoe 3ana皿ee［､. AJIGKcallXpoBa (coBpeMelIHam
KapTa no八MocKoBbFI) ; cp. B. H. n e 6 0 JI b c K II ih. yKa3. coII.,
Bbln. II, cTI). 21 11 KapTa B KoIIlle KHI"Irm; 10. r o T b e. yKa3. coII.,
F

­

弓

c Tp . 0 / / .

185 10. r O T b e. yKa3. COtl., cTp. 582. O MecTonoJIo>KellHII ynoMHIIyToro

B rpaMoTe c. MI､I.mHTIIHa KoHIomcKoro cTalla cM.:IO.r・AJIeKceeB.
ArpapHa別HcoUHaJIbHaH IIcTopHH CeBepo-BocTo[IHoiI PycII XVXVI B. nepeHcJIaBcKIIih ye3,nl. M.- J1., 1966, cTp. 143.
186 10. r o T b e. yKa3. cotl., cTp. 583.
187 A3HX, U｡ I, Nb 150.
188 10. r o T b e. yKa3. coMI., cTp. 600.
189 A311X, U. 1, Nb 224.
190 10. T o T b e. yKa3. coII., cTI). 556-558.
191 TaM >Ke, cTP、558.
192 TaM IKe, cTP、557.
214

cJIaBHbl l93, BblmeJIec - KIIH3H AHnpefl yrJIHⅡKOrO 194. Bal､JIalleBcKaH BoJIOcTb 6blJIa COcTaBHOカIIacTblo KJIeKoBa cTEI-

Ha l95 BoJIocTb CeHer Haxo且HJIaCb B 6aCceiHe P・CeHbrH I96,
npaBoro npHToKa KJIFI3bMbl l97・Ha 3anane K HeHnpHMblKa｡"
3aMocKoBcKaH o6JIacTb 3arapbe '98, Ha loro-3anane - rycJ1皿al99 (o6e B XV B. BenaJIIIcb nMHTpoBcKHM yneJIbHblM
KHFI3eM, a B lyXOBHOii I'IBaHa lll 6blJIH 3aBemaHbl AHJpeIo
CTapliUKoMy)．C ceBepa BoJIocTb CeHer rpaHIIqIIJIa, no-BPInHMoMy, c BoJIocTblo MapHHHHcKoii cJIo60noii nepecJIaBJIb3aJIeccKoTo ye3na, KoTopafl npencTaBJIHJIa co60ji HacJIencTBo BeJIHKoi KHHrIIHII MapHII HpocJIaBHbl. Por, pacnoJIo-

>KeHHbl# B CpeXHeM TeIIeHIIH p．ⅡeKmll, rpaHH[IIIJI c lOPbeBnoJIbcKHM ye3HoM Ha ceBepe 200 II, BepoflTHo, c MapHHIIHcKoii cJIo604oinePecJIaBcKoTo ye3na Ha 3anane. BoJIocTb
>KaraJ1oBa (IIJIII )KeraJIoBcKafl) TaK>Ke Haxo皿JIaCb B 6aCceihHe p. neKmII 20'. MecToHoJIo)KeHHe CJIaBUoBa 202, CoHoMoBa, THyHUoBa yrJIa H nOropeJIHnbl HaMH He ycTaHoBJIeHo.
yIIHTblBaH BblHBJIeHHblA CoCTaB TePPHTOPHii, oKa3aBmIIXcH o6'beKToM BHHMaIIHH HBaHa lll B >KaJIoBaHHblx rPaM()TaX MHTPOnOJIIIqbeMy nOMy Ha BJIa,meHIIFI B nePeCJIaBJIb3aJIeccKoM, IOpbeB-HoJIbcKoM II BJIamHMIIpcKoM ye3nlax,
U

MO)KHO KoHCTaTIMPoBaTb nPe>Kne Bcero, IITO BeJIHKPIH KHH3b

noITBeP>KIaJI He3bI6JIeMocTb cBoeii BJIacTII B UeHTpaJIbHblx
I I a c T fl x 3 T I I x y e 3 n P B , KO H n e H T P l I P o B a B m H x C H B O K P y r C a M I I x

roponoB nepecJIaBJIH-3aJIeccKoro, IOpbeBa-noJIbcKoro II
BJIa且HMHPa. nO-BHnmMOMy, Heo6xO旦HMO nPIIHHTb B PacIIer
poJIb BJIanHMHpa KaK 6blBme# cToJIIIUbl BeJIIIKoro KHH)KecTBa (B THTyJIe rOcynaPeii BceH PycII cJIOBo <<BJIa皿Mepu

cKHII> cTOHJIo Ha

nePBOM MecTe­ⅡePen CJTOBOM <<MOCKOB-

cKH"i 3To nePBonpecToJIbHoe nPOmJIoe BJIa皿MIIPa, OTPa>KeHHOe ll yBeKOBeqeHHoe B BeJIHKoKHH>KecKoM THTyJIe, MOrJIo

HBHTbcfI ocHoBaHHeM JJIH Tpe60BaHHH BacHJIIIH npenpcTaBIITb eMy BJIa皿MHPCKyIO 3eMJIIO B KaqecTBe BPeMeHHOii (40
卵
１
１
妬
１
ｌ
卵
岬
蛇

且Ⅱ且r, cTp. 197.
TaM ]Ke, cTp. 327.
1 0 . r o T b e . y K a 3 . c “ . , C T P, 5 5 7 .
TaM >Ke, cTp. 558.

CM. KapTy MocKoBcKoii o6JIacTﾙI I939 r.
E､且.CTameBcKIIFI･yKa3・COII., KaPT&I B KOI皿eKHRI､11．
TaM jKe; B. H. n e 6 0 JI b c K II ii. yKaa c()11., BLIn. 11, KapTa B KoHIle
K Ⅲ I I r H ʻ

２００ 10. roTbe・yKa3・coII., cTp. 558.
２０１
TaM >Ke, cTp. 557.
２０２

O CJIaBeUKoii BoJIocTlI cM.; 10. r o T b e. yKa3. co[I.! cTp. 558.
215

cMepTII HBaHa lll) odlacTH BeJIHKoro KIIH>KGHIIFI. OTMelleHLI9e Bblme yIIacTIIe BacIIJIIIH I) I)a3601)G TH>K6bl o 3eMJIe !;
U

MI")IrHHC"BOJIOcTI!2Jly>KIIThoKajaTeIIbCTBOMef6̅M

TeH3"=jianengcJIaBJIb-3aJIeccKHiye34
EcTecTBeHHo,4To
3eMJIﾙ!
IOPbeB-nOJIbCKOrO
ye3na,
JI6)KaB皿He
Me>Kny
nePecJIaBJIb-3aJIeccKHM H BJIa"MIIpcKHM ye3"MIi, MofJII! T5K>Ke "ccMaTpIIBaTbcH KaK o6beKT npHTH3aHHii BacIIJIHH.

Ho4 7012 r. BJTa"MHpcKHii JIeToⅡⅡCeU COO6nIaeT O Bbl｡

BoUe I'IBaHoM III B MocKBy H3 BJIa且HMIipaHnepeCJI aBJIFI-

aaJIeCcKOrO
<<HOBorOPO皿eB
rOCTei)'
(yKa3aH
P皿CGMeii)
203

y瓜aﾉIellHeII33THXrOPOnPBHoJIIITHIIecKIIOnaCHOrOSJIeMeHTa
HaxOnJITcfI, KaK HaM Ka>KeTcFI, B cBFI31I c BO3MO)KHI>IMHnpeTeH3"MH BacHJIHH Ha BJIa"MHPcKylo 3eMJIIQ BcHoMHiM,〃

IITo BaCHm曲6bl!ﾉIⅡPIIIIacTeH K ynPaBJIeHIIIo HoBropoJIoM:

B HoBropogpKHx rocTfIx oH Mor HcKaTb ce6e onopy Bo BJIa及HMHpe H nepeCJIaBJIe.

AHaJIH3
cocTaBa
3eMeJIb,
ynoMHHyTblx
Bo
BJIa"IMHpcKoii
RPaMOTe, noKa3bIBaeT, qTO, KPoMe UeHTPaJIbHblx Tel)PliTOPllii
U

BJIa"MHpcKoro ye34a, pe[IIJ "ecb "ET o cTaHa)i ､II BdJIo○

CT", PacnOJIO]KeHliPlX B erO 3ana4HOji qaCTH, nOrPaHII[IHOii
U

c MocKoBcKHM H nePecJIaBJIb-3aJIeccKHM ye3"" no coceJICTBy c I-IeKOTOPblMII H3 a4MHHIIcTPaTIIBHLIx enHHIIU, Ha3'BaHHblx Bo BJIa"IMIII)cKOIIHⅡePeC｡maBCKOH rPaMoTaX, Mbl
U

U

BIUlIM yneJIbHble BOIIIoCTM, HBJIHB皿HeCH HenaBHIIM HaCJIe4-

cTBoMIOpliflBacfmbeBHIIaUMHTPoBcKOro,MaPHIIHPOcJIaBHbl H AHUPeH BacHJIbeBHKIa ym皿Koro. B c｡epy 6blBmero
八MIITPopcKorO BJIHHH!:IFI Bxo"IJI m̲HenocPencTBeHHo ｡IiryPHpyloU" B IopbeBcKoji
pylo皿HH
BIopbeBcKoHrpaMoTemyTKHHcTaH．O且HaKoe瓜Ba
rpaMoTe myTKHH cTaH. OJHaKo enBa
四

JIH ocHoBHaFI 3a60Ta mBalla lll B I504 r. cocTofIJIa B oxPaHe
｡

"MIITPOBCKHx ,BOJIOCTem, 3aBe皿aHHblx AH4peIo HBaIIoBHII)'
ざ

CTap皿KoMy (KyHelI, BoxHa, rycJI皿a) , OT IIOcmraTeJIbcT"

IOpHH HBaHoBIIIIa mMHTpoBcKoro. Cy皿no o6EeKTaM BHHMaHIIH

U

BeJIHKoKHFDKecKoii nOJIHTHKH,

IIBaH III 60JIbme ona-

caJI" pacnpocTpaHeHHH BJIacTH BacHJIHH Ha aTH TeppHTopHH.

MapToBcKa兄rPaMOTaMHTPOnoJIHIIbeMynPMyHaerO6e-

,JIO3ePcKlieHnOmeXOHCKHe BOTIIHHLI 204 KaCaJIaCD KpaiiHerO
△
U

Ioro-BoCTOqHOro yrJIa BeJIO3ePcKorO ye3ﾉIa 205 II npHMblKaB-

加３
nCP几T.
加４
印５

30, cTp. 139-140.
Aの3IIX, q. 1, Jvb 311.

CeJIo H.JIbHI.IcKoe,1IepeBHPI no p. KoB)Ke (Bna"Bmeih B p. meKcHy)

Ⅲ且pyrme BJIa八em" jiIITPOnoJIHKIberO [IePenOBeUKoro MoHaCTblPi[

(A:# ̲K 9 n a H " HETOpILa ̲ 3eMineBJIan6HIIH BeJIo3ePcKoro KP"
B XV-XVI BB. M.- J1., 1951, KapTbI B nplIJIo>KeHIIII K Kl.(ﾙIre) .
216

⑥

meii K IIeMV c Iora Ap6y>KeBcKoii BoJIocTH nomexoIIcKoro

ye34a
206,
rjaMOTa
>Ker
,,h
BOJIorO八cKIfe
BJIaneHI1fl
Ka巾enpbl

6bIJIanobBilUeHanepeBHfIMBBQJIocTI!TomHe207,pacIIoJIo>KeHHoji B 3ana"IoiI IIacTH BoJ1orontcKoI､o ye3na M cMblKaBU

U

IIIeiicH
ap6yXeBcKo-6eJIo3epcKHMII
c
TeppIITopHflMII208.Ta唾

KIIM o6pa30M, B3HTble BMecTe, 3Tli rpaMoTbI neMoXpTpm""

En6JIHebnPeieJIeHHyIOJIOKaJiII3aUmionoJIIITIIKHHBaHalll:
U

BHHMaHIie BeJIHKorO KHH3H nPIIKOBaJM PaIIOHbl, HaxOnmBmlie-

cH Ha CTI,IKe "yX cPaBHIITeJIbHO no3nHo JI"BH瓜I'IPOBaHHblX

ymeJIoB-Bojiofomckoro
m
BeJIo3epcKorp
(BoJIocTb､4p6yE
u

k6Becb lIBJIHJIacb HacJIencTBoM BejIIIKoii KHHrmHII Maplil!
HPOCJIaBHbl209).
KaK Mbl nOMHHM, BeJIoo3epo B 1502 Ia HeKoTopoe BpeMFI

ⅡpmamJIe)KaJIoBacIIJIHIo.25anpeJIFII504I・CCaHKUI1I1
I/IBaHa lll 6blJI BblHeCeH nPHrOBoP no CHOPHOMy ne.IIy Me>Kfly

①ePanOIITOBbIMMOHaCTbIPCMIIBQjPCTHbIMHKPegrbflHaMIM

o3eMJIHxBPanOHeyCTb-meJIeKml,12'0,HarpaHIIUeBeJIO3ePU

cKoro ye3na c BoJIoroIcKHM. B cynHoM cⅡHcKe yKa3blBaeTCfl,

fITOKieCTBHHaMHa3HaqalloC.TPliCPOKafIBKIIBCyg:!la
l)
BeJIIIIfOe 3arOBeHbe MflCHOe (HO cymbH He nOcTaBIIJI Hx Ha

3ToT cpoK) ; 2) Ha neTpoB leHb (BcTaJIHⅡePen KHH3eM
B I'I ToJIeHIIHblM) ; 3) Ha BeJIHKoe 3aroBeHbe MHcHo2 <<ne-

l)e八BeJIHKIIMKHFI3eMBacIIJIbeM
HBaHoBIIqeM
BceH
PycII)>
(、
B'CTaJIHⅡepe八B.H・rOJIeHHHblM, KoTOPblII BeJIeJI Hx <<onPaU

BHTb>) .
BH且HMO, 3TM cBenleHIIH cOoTHoCHTCfl C COxPaHHBmHMHc)I

TeKcTaMIIcJIelylO皿HMo6pa30M:3aKaKoe-ToBpeMFInoneTPoBa ntHfI (29 IIIoHH) 1502 E HaIIaJIcH cy瓜ⅡO rPaMOTe |BeJIIIkoro KHfI3fl BacIIJIIIH 2'1; 3To MorJIo HMeTb MecTo HocJIe aII八

、

""!502r"m6QBanpbJIeBeJIoo3ePoMBenam｡IiBaHUI"i
｡

3aTeM cTOPoHbl 6bIJIII Bbl3BaHbl B cyJI BblCmeH HHCTaII皿川

(HanerP6B neHb?)｣ HoOKOIjllaTeJIb¥Oe Pp皿eHMenOneJIy
U

lipliHHJ1 d aBrycTe l502 rHe Bacll"", a lIBaH III, qTo K"

6VITocBH1eThJ1bcTByeT oHoTepeBacHJIHeMB3ToBpeMH
nbaB HaBeJIoo3epo.Me>Kny 'reMHa3HaqeHme cpoKaFIBKI!
206 B. H. ne6oJIbcKIIh．yKa3. COII., Bbln. II, KaPTa B KoHne KHmrl'I.
O ToM,IIToc.CnaccKoe Haxom1l,ﾉIocb B Ap6y>KeBcKoiM BoJIocTII, cM.:
⑪

Aの3IIX, q. I, Nb 307-310.
207 A31JX, K1．1, Nb 313.

208 B. H. ne6oJlbcKIIii. yKa3. coII.、BbIn. 11, KaPTa B KOHUe KHIIrH.
209 n11mr, cTp. 356.
210 ACSPI, T. II, Nb 338.
211 TaM )Ke, Nb 337.
212 TaM >Ke, Nb 336.
217

《nePenlBeJIIIKHMKHwI3eMRaCIIJIbeMHBalIoBHIieMBceHPycm》

HaMHcHoe34roBeHbe(1503r.)3acTaBJIHeT3a4yMaTbci,IIe
ひ

noJIyIIIILnm BacliJIIiii cHoBa BeJIoo3epo B KoHUe. 1 502 -Ha-

'IaJIel503r・EcJImaToTaK,ToBbInaqyrpaMoTb!1504r.MMTPOHOJIHIIbeMy,IOMyHa6eJIO3ePCKO-nOmeXOHCKHelIBOJIOrOmcKIE̲BJIanellHFI cJIemyeT paccMaTpllBaTb KaK nonblTKV HBaご

Ha
lll
yTBeP且HTb
34eCb
CB9H
CyBePeHHble
nPaBa
yCTPaHHTI,
ll

BacHm4HoTynPaBJIeHMHBeJIo3ePcKIIMKPaeM.
OTcyTcTBI1erpaMoTMapTa̅1504r・MHTPOnOJIHIIbeMy
mOMy,
OTHOCH皿HXCH
K
3eMJIHM
B
POCTOBCKOM,
Cy3"JIbCKOM,

HIDKeroponcKoMHMypoMcKoMye3nax,cJI#)KMIIo-Bm"｣

MoMy, yKa3aHIieM Ha To, IITo 3TH ye31bl He cTaJIH o6'LeKToM
CKO"bKO-HH6ynL HaCTOji[IHBblX，n{oMoraTeJIbcTB BacIIJIHH.
U

ルIII",
Ka>KeTCFI,
HaJLo
OUeHIITb
OTCyTCTBMe
rPaMOTbl
HBaHa lll Ha KocTpoMcKIIe BoT[IHHb! MIiTponoJIIIfa B 1506 r.,
U

BcKOl)e nocJIe 3aHflTIIFI IIpecToJIa, BacIwIHHBblnaJI MIITPOnOJIHIIbeMX noMy >KaJIoBaHIIylo rPaMoTy Ha KoCTPOMCKHe BJIa-

JleH"2E
aHaJIOrIILIHylO
nocdneP>KAH班O
MaPTOBCKIIMrPaMoTaM I/IBal{a lll l504 r・Bo3Mo>KHo, B MapTe l504 r. KcfcT⑫

99McK"npo6JIeMaHocIIJIaHacToJIbKoocTpEIiixapaKTep,qTo

HBaH
Pe皿I,IJI
III
OTKa3aTbCR
OT
nPFIMOA且eMOHCTP
aumI1cBoⅢxnpaBIIaKocTpoMyHcocpenpTOII"BIIIｲMaHPIeHanPyrHX
cHoPHblx TePPHTOPHHx, B OTIIomeHHH KoTopblx BacHJIIIii
HMeJI MeHbme nPaB.

IITaK, c6JIH班eHIie l/IBaHa lll c MIITpOnOJIIIIIbMM IOMOM
△

BecHo曲l504r.，BnepHo且HaIIaBmeHcH
peaʻﾉIH3aUpIIi
nyXOljU

U

HoHrPaMOTbl，HMeJIo，Ⅱo
Hom
rPaMOTbl, HMeJIo, no Bcen
BceH BePoHTHoCTH,
BePoHTHoCTH，maBHoH
rJIaBHoih UeJIblO
HalITH B MIITPonoJIIITe coIo3HHKa nPoTHB BeJIHKOKHH]KecKMX
U

⑥

IIPPITH3aHIIih BacHJIH凡nOmeJI JIMI HBaH III PanJ 3ToA UeJIli
U

Bpa3pe3 c pblpa60TaHIIblMM K 90-M ro,maM nPIIH"naMH IIMU

MyHIITeTHOHnOJIHTHKH？

4. eoga入BHLIji IIMMyHHTeT B 1504 - 1505 rr.
U

H#cKoJIbKo
Ho3BoJIHeT
cy"Tb
con<ep>KaHHe
rpaMoT,
BeR

j

JIHKHH KHFI3b nPOjPJIiKaJI CTPOrO nPHXeP>KIIBaTbCJI nPeIKHeii
JIHHI畑nPenoCTaBJIeHIIH oI､PaHIIIIeHHblx HMMyHIITeTHblx nPaH

rpaMoTbI,noJIyIIeHHbleCIIMoHoMBMapTel504r.,He3aK66n4
J1”IIBKaKolI-皿160巾O"IeOCBO60>KJeHHHOTymlaTblrbCy▲

J I F I J I I I B K a KO j i - J I H 6 o

zIap'cTBeHHblx IIaJIoroB. BHHx HMGJIIIcb TOJIbKo 3anOBeX.Hble

cTaTbll
(3anpe皿eHIIe
e310KaM
CTaBIITbc兄HnOCTOPOHHIIM
@JIPI213 A3HX, u. 1, Nb 262
218

naM nPlIxOⅡHTb B ceJ1a m llePeBHII MMTPOnoJ1IIH HaⅡⅡpbl lI

6paTqIiHbI),aTaK>KecyXe6HbliiPa3neJI,BKoTopoMll3̲MET"
〆

noJIHIIbeH IoPH|cﾕHKUml IIcKJIIo[IaJIH'cb ZIeJIa o lymeryOcTBe
U

II Da3!60e c noJIHIIHblM.
u

B BblnaIIe l'IBalloM III rpaMo'T MIITPonoJmqbeM|ynoMy B
1 504 r. IIeKoTopble aBTopbl ycMaTpHBaJIHnPe>K1e BCeTO OTU

cTVnJIel-IHeoTceKyJIHpl旧auHOHHOH叩orpaMMbl.A.naBJIoB
劃

U

''HcaJI: <<B cJIelylo皿eM (1504.- C. K) rony BeJIHK皿KHH3b
KaK 6bl B JIoKa3aTeJIbcTBo cBOero II'CKPeHHero PaCKaflHI畑B

HaMePeHIIHⅡocFIrHyTb
Ha
UePKoBHylo
co6cTBelIHocTb
naJI
MmTponoJIIITy CIIMoHy nBe >KaJIoBaHHbIx HecymIMbIx rpaM9Tbl, ̅o6HIIMaBHIHe noqTFI Bce noMoBble BoTIIHHbl MIITpoTIoU

JIIII"214. no MHeHIIIo B. MenJIIIHa, <<BemIKIm KHH3b叩enOcTaBIM BblcHIeMV IVxoBeHcTBy e皿e 66JIbmHe MaTePmaJ1bHble
。

，

ご

1 9

叩eIIMy皿eCTBa:
OH
OCBO60且Ⅵmm
CBOeii
OTCyne|6HO曲B､JIacTHH
HaJIoroo6JIo)KelIIIFI (?1) Bcex KpecTbHHⅡ叩yrlIx JIIm, Ha!ce-

J1HB皿HXMHTPOnO皿IilbiI3eMJ1IIBMocKoBcIKoMIIBJIanllMIIpcKoM ye3nax>, 215. 0HIIaKo y>I<e几 B. IIepenHHH oTMeTHJI

CMOdr6̅)KaJIOBaHHLIX
rPAMOTL̲BbmaHHLIx
MBaHOM
III

Bi504 E MIITponoJIHTy CIIMoHy216.
｡

noKa3aTb neiicTBHTeJIbHoe 3Ha[IeHHe 9THx rpaMoT IJIH
I1CTO DmHMIITPOnOJIIIIIberO IIMMyllHTeTa Mo>KeT TOJIDKo 'cPaB』

HeHIJe IIx C nPe瓜meIcTByIomHMH aKTaMH Ha Te >Ke BJIaneHIMH.

M H. rOPIIaKOB, 3aTPoHyBmliii BOnPOC O MeCTe
M.Ⅲ､rop[IaKoB,3aTpoHyBmI4HBoⅡpoco
MecTe>KaJIoBaHHblx
>KaJIOBaHHbIx

rpaMoT 1504 r. cpe皿旦pyrlIx nOKyMeHTOB,｡HKcIIPylo皿Hx
IIMMVHIITeT
Ka巾eXpbl,
nonomeJI
K
pemeHHIO
HOcTaBJ1eHHOrO
U

BOnPoCa c ｡oPMaJIbHblx n03皿ⅡⅢ: OH PaCcMaTPlIBaJI rPaMoTI>I 1504 r. KaK aKTbl, KoTopble <IoplJⅡHqecKII o6'benHHfl lOT
』

yqacTKII,IoceJIePa3Ee"HeHHblereorPa｡I1qecKHIIIOp皿WIeCKII> 217.

｡

Ha l3 H3 20 ceJI, ynoMFIHyTblx Bo BJIa"MHpclfpII rpaM95

Te l504 r., IIMeJIalcE >KaJIoBallHaH rpaMoTa lﾉIBaHa lll
U

1464 r. 218 B cJIy[lae oTcyTcTBIIH HoBoIi rp3MoTbl rpajiOTa
U

l464 r. coxpaHIIJIa 6bl cBoIo cIwIy Xo caMoH cMepTⅢⅢBaHa lll・OHa ocBo60)KnaJIa BJIa且HMIiPCKHe BJIaneHHFI MIITPo214 A. naBJIoB･yK a3・CO【1., cTp. 50̲

215 W．KM e d li n MoscoW ahd East Rome=Gen6ve, 1952,l). 85-86.
216 JI. B LI e p e n H M H. yKa3. coII., 11. 2, cTP. 200.
217 M.I/1.r f) 1) [! a K o BO3eMe｡nI,111,IxBJ1aILp1IIJIx . 62el)occMiiflilAxM11TPOⅡoJ1IIToB，「laTI)llal1xoB II cB. CII[IoﾉIa. Cn6., 1871, cTP. 253.
218A(P3IIX,L1.1,Nb210.BIIIIcJIeB｡咽几GII''ii
61>IJI1Ic､rIellyIo皿11eceJIa2naR四
mBcKoe, ByXaJIoBo, cTapblji JIBop, >E1TKoBo, HgBoe-n"-"e3aMI,
〆

nm"JIb,"BcecJ1aBcKoe;CnaccKbe,nopeuKoe,KycyHoBo,CHoBMcKoe, Me皿epKa, Ha]KI叩OBO．
219

WWi"""I)b!9TmMa,nomiBOII,TaMrm!!nPyrmx[､OcV副

4al)CTBGHHblXnOmaTeカIInOBI'IIIHOCTG曲．H3cVne6HoroIIMMv-

IIIITeTa
Ka巾eXp
bⅡ〃CKJIIOIIaJICFI
TOJIbKO
Pa360P
nle.JI
XymeO
ソ

WWnWe W"Cema, ynOMami&WMMOMM○

l" "4 r" IIMcJIa,cb rpajiQIa miaHa lln465̅nfbhi6-

2W̲IpATBep)KIIcHHam̲B1473r2!9nocomlep>Kalimm6ifa
"aJIorliIIHa oTMeqeHHoi Bblme rpaMoTe l464r. IIcKJIIo"

TeJIbHOmIIPoKHenPHBIMerlm6bljm3a巾HKCHPOBaHblB>KaR，

IWWmllaV9Te B"I" 11 (TeMHofo) HaboJIocTKy n6roPeJImUe, KoToQyIo Ha3bIBaeT rpaMoTa l504 rB qmcJI6 np6L

』剛xBoT[I"Ka｡enpblBoBJIa皿MIIPcKoMye3ne.rPaMoTa

EiW""U,nOnWBeP"eHH""336MYil,'5MⅡ〃HJIa3a
U

Ka巾e叩oHnoJIHbIiicyn(e6Hbli
noJaTHoji
II
HMMvHiITeT(oCEtF
ひ

〆

、

00>KXelIIIeOTJIaHm,HMa,TaMrII,MLITaHⅡp)22q加IKB皿11-

POBaB
d)aKTHIIGCKH
BCe
aTⅡⅡOXaTHbIG
JIbrOTbl
BJIaaIIM叩CKHx
WWM WP｡llo"mII !I¥9Ipan"" !opIIc""15IMM

npaBHTembcTBoIIBaHalllBl504r・HaHe|CJIO
cePbe3Hbl#
⑪

y"2 nO IIMMyHHTeTy MIITPOnOmIKIberO n;oMa.

no八06Hoe
>Ke
coKpameHHe
npIIBIIJIei､Im
,Ka巾eUPbl
Mo>KHo
U

Ha6JIIOnaTbHnP4
1f3yIIeHIM
MaTePHamoB,
OTHOClImHXCHK
Xp yl､""¥M TaK, H3 nfITH ceJI,̲̅yIIoMmilyTbIx B fp5M6TE

IWE Ha MliTPO'nO"imbH BOT(IIInBi' i"GMMrBMMM6

ye3Xa,TPH6blJIHⅡpe永旦eoTaPxalleHblOTHMa,TaMm,TIoIBoⅡⅢ且""｣10mJMH,acyn<e6HaHBJIacTbMHTPOnO"HTa
orpaHHIIHBaJIa'CbJIHmbnePenaIIeHBPyKHBeJIIIKOKHH>KecKHx
WW""B cyma no meJIaM ̲o Xymy6cTBe (cor"acHo BE:
o

E J

JIIIK2KHH>KecKoii rpaMoTe l463 r)̅ 221

J""TIYM3c9"comlOpbeR4nojIbcKoroye3na,Ha3BaHHblxBrPaMoTel504CyXe6Hblii̲
r.,
IIMMyHHTeT
KabenPbI
U

WWlllIWWJIRH, <ogpliqb nymery6cTBa>, eme B rp3M6Te

BEWW̲!I222

"9 ""@EmMMfrMMM

9"q0"e" B !474 ｢"BaIIoM III 6T""oi561r MM

WMWWJ¥" "OPUoBO-KHHjifecKmx nOBHHilOCfeii; Cy｣
ひ

42"C nPmBIIJICrIIm miTbOIIQJImTa m""MMWW6
9Wig, ̲Wp M B [paMofe Bac"mi̅mmW"cMM5

"WW;HWeu, ""eH" MIIMMMrfiMtf
BeUKoro MoHacTbI", ynoMIiHaeMoro g rpaMoTe l504 r"
219
Aq)311X，Wi
1:FMb
193
CeJIa
BoJIo"MepcKoe
CIIoBII4cKoe
!!
220 TaM )Ke, M 173.

;;""¥jg,M!"C:"aMW̅lo､H1IKIITcKoe,no6pmmoBQ
”2T222
TaM
>Ke,
JYb
145.
CeJIa
mm，ⅢHCKOe,
nOeJIOBo,
AⅢ叩eeBCKoe,
BOrOHB，ﾉ1GHCKOe, nbHHHUII'IO.
223 TaM >Ke, M 151.
220

6eJIo3ePiC'KHe
BOTIIHHbl
Ka巾enPbl,
nOJIb30BaJIIICb
nOJIHblM
'CyXe6HLIM IIMMyHIITGToM Ho rpaMoTe l449 r. KIIFI3FI MHxanJia

4皿peeBm[Ig224,aCeJIO"nOCOBCKOe
BeJIO3ePCKOrO
ye31a

oblJIo ocBOOO)KneHo oT naHII B rPaMOTe Toro >Ke KHH3fl, BblX a H B o i B l 4 7 3 - 1 4 8 6 r r. 2 2 5

TaKHM o6pa30M, >KaJIoBaHHble叩aMoTbr l504 r. MII|TponoJIHIIbeMy JIoMy Ha BJIanellHH, no KpaiHeit Mepe, B IIeTblpex
ye3"x (BJIa皿MHpcKoM, nepecJIaBcKoM, IOpbeBcKoM, BeJIO3ePcIKOM) 3aMeHmmr cTaPble rPaMOTbl, comeP>KaBIuIle
U

IIPe3BblllaHHo mHpoKI'Ie

HMMyHHTeTHble

npmBIIJIerIIII.

B apxHBe MHTponoJIHLIbero IoMa He coxI)aHIwIo'cb TapxaHHblx, JII)roTHblx IIJIII I-IeCy旦HMblx rPaMOT rlPe典ⅡIGCTByl()-

mero nepHoﾉIa }la ceJIa, llepe[IncJIGHHble B rpaMoTax l504 r.,

OTHOCH皿HxcH K Moc'KoBcKoMy, KoJ1oMeH'CKoMy H BoJIor"cKOMy ye31aM.

I/I3Be!cTHa ToJIIJKo 3anoBeXHaH rpaMoTa BacH川畑II OT

e3IoKoB Ha ceJIo BHcepoBo KoJIoMeHcKoro ye3" 226. Conep>KaHHe 3Toii rpaMOTbl巾aKTIIIIeCKHⅡoX|TvBeP)KnleHo B OIHoii
I'I3 CTaTe曲rpaMoTbl l504 r. Ha To >Ke 'ceJIo.

B cTapHIIHblx 'ceJIax MoIcKoBcKoro ye3na HMMyHHTeTHble
ⅡPHBHJIerIIII Ka巾enPbl 6blJIH, BO3MO>KIIO,皿叩e Tex, KoToPble
3aKpe|nJIeHbl B rpaMoTe l 504 r. TaK, B I､paMoTe l465 r. KHH3H

lOplIH Ba'cIIJIbeBIIrla MIITponoJIIIIlbli 3eMJIM B BoJIocTII Bope
MocKoBcKoTo ye31a (He ynoMHHyTbIe B rpaMoTe l504 r.)
ocBo60>K4aJIMcb OT Bcex ocHOBllblx IIaJIOroBHⅡomJIIII1, a
CyXe6HbliM HMMyHIITeT nPCJIOCTaB,ﾉI FI,ﾉIcFI <<onpH[Ib nymery6CTBa> 227.

O6'beM IIMMyHIITeTa BoJIorqlcKI1x 'ceJI Hell3BecTeH. B coceJHeji ,c BoJIorXoAⅡBHIICKo# 3eMJIe Ka*enPa nOJIb30BaJ1aCb
CyJKGHHblM Cyle6HblM I1MMyHIITeTOM:くonplIIIb nymery6cTBa
H po360FI H TaTb6bI c I1oJIHIIHbIM)' (IIo rpaMoTaM HBaHa llI
1467 228 11 1475 229 rr.) .

nO>KaqJIOBaIIHeMHTPOnOJIIITyHecy且HMO-3anoBe4HblxrpaMoT B Ma'pTe l504 r. I1MeJIo JBoiicTBeHHoe 3HaIIeHIJe XJIH IIAI-

MyHHTeTHOrO CTaTyCa Ka|巾enPbl. C oIHoii cTopoHbl, caM ｡aKT
nO>KaJIOBaIIIIFI yKPenJIflJI巾eoXaJIbllbliⅡPeICTII>K MIITPOnOJ1I1IIbero XoMa lI noXTBeP>KnaJI He3bl6JIeMOcTb ero BOTIIIIHHblx
ｌ
酔
塑
郵
獅
班
麹

ＴａＭ
ＴａＭ
Ｔ剛Ｍ
ＴａＭ
ＴａＭ
ＴａＭ

氷ｅ
水ｅ
氷ｅ
氷ｅ
氷ｅ
兆ｅ

池
碓
地
雌
恥
雌

９
﹄
ワ
﹄

﹃

７ｊ
８４且
ワ
１ １
︽
戸
ｊ １
．
ｎ
Ｐ
ｄ １
︑
ｎ
︿
Ｊ １
０
221

nPaB, a HeCynlIMble II 3anOBeXHble CTaTbII caHKUl,IOHIH'POBaJIII

cynle6HO-a八MI'IHH'cTPaTIIBHyIo He3alBIIcIIMOICTb MHTPOnOJII'IIIbHx BJIanteH". C Ipyroii cTopoIIbl, 0[IeBImHo, B oTHomeHIIH
60JIb山ⅡH'cTBa o6beKTOB IIO>KaJIOBaHIIH MO)KHo c:Ka3aTb, IITo
rPaMoTbl l504 r. 0巾皿IIaJIbllo Ho八pblBaJIII IOpH皿〔IecKme
ocHoBbl lIx npe>KHHx mlipoKHx npHBIIJIerlIii (maBHblM o6pa-

30M Ho"THblx H cyne6Hblx) . H ecJIII cHJTy 9Toro ynapa Ka巾eXPa He nOIIyBcTBO'BaJIa B IToJIHOii MePe, To JIHmb nOToMy,
IITo, BepoHTHo, c 80-90-x I､onPB XV B.皿eJI npoIlecc巾aKTIILleCKorO HaPy皿eHHH I1MMyHIITeTa, Oco6ellHO HaJIoroBOrO、

H1､paMoTbl l504 r., noIBoJJI IopH且H[IecKylO IIePTy nO4 3TII|MII
⑪

HapymeHIIHMM,

raPallTHPoBaJIII

KPynlIemmeM|y

nePKOBHoMy

IIePa'PXy HeO6XO"IMblii MHHHMyM IIMMyHII|TeTHblx nPaB.
B anpeJIe l504 r. Ha[IaJI BblnaBaTb IIMMyHMTe|THble rPaMoTbl KHH3b lOpHi l/IBalloBPI[I Ha 3eM@JIII B IMIITpoBc|KoM 230

HKa皿HHcKoM 231 ye3nax. B Mae l504 r. KHFI3b nMHTp"
IIBaHOBHII BblnaJI rPaMOTy Ha 3eMJIII B yrJI'ImKOM ye3J(e 232.
OT 1504 r・I-IeT HIIKaKIIx naHHblx o6 ylIpaBJIeHHII IOpIieM Py30ii m 3BeHIIroponpM. MJIa瓜皿IIe cblIIoBbH mBaHa lll CeMeH

II AHnpeii He noJIywIJIH cBoIIx yn<eJIoB - nepBblii 40 1509 r.,
BTOP On一旦o l519 r.233 B 7012 r. pa3'be3nbl 36MeJIb B Be>KeUKoM Bepxe (KoTopl,Iii no nyxoBIIoih ､MBaHa lll npen<０AC3P1, T. I, Nb 652; T. II, Nb 427; Aq)3HX, I1. 1, Nb 88.
３
２
３
１ACSH, T. 1, JYb 653.
２
３
２TaM )Ke, T. 111, Nb 83.
２
３
３
２

Ii. A. roJIy6UoB oTH()cIIT K 1503-1504 rm pa3'be3>Kylo rpaMoTy mM
Ho川IBaIIoBa, l)a3'be"Bmero 3eMJIII B AI)ryHoBcKoA BoJIocTII nepecmaBJIb-3aJIeccKoro jie3na <<no rocymapeBe叩aMoTe KHH3fI AII,mpefI
I'IBaHoBHqa), (ACSH, T. 111, Nb 469, cTp. 451-452) . K cox<aJIeIIIIIo,
H3JIaTeJIb lle yIIeJI JIeTonIICHoG II3BeCTIfe O *aKTIILIeCKoM nOJIy(IeHIM

yAeJ1a A皿peeM B l519 m (nCPJI, T. VI, cTp. 262-263) !I yx<e npllBo八IIBmIIecFI B JIIITepaType cBelleIIIM o ero ynpaBJIelIMI ApryHoBcKo&
BoJIocTbIo B l514 r., Korna AH八Peil 3aMemaJI B MocKBC BeJmKorO KIIH3FI BacII｡ﾉII'IH, OTcyTcTBOBaBmerO l.Io c､JIy'JalO CMoJIellCKorO nOxoma

(C､M, K a lu T a H o B. l<OmlitHble KHIIrII Tpo皿e-Cel)I､]1eBa MOHaCTIJII))I
XVI BeKa.­《3anHcKII oTJe&ﾉ1a PyKomlCeii rocyaaPCTBeHHoii 6II6JIIIoTeKII IIM. B. I'1. JIeHIIHa>", BbIn. 18. M., 1956, cTI)、1l; OH >Ke. I/I3
IICTOp l皿ⅡocJ1enHIIx ymeJIoB, cTp. 293; B. H. K o p e U K II ii・npaBaﾝI

rpaMoTa oT 30 HoFI6pJI l618
Ur. TpoIIUe-Cepl､IIGBy MoIlacTbII)Io.­《3amlcKII

OTAeJIa

PyKomlCeI1

rocynapcTBeHHoii

6116JIIIoTeKII

11M.

B. I/1. JIeHIIHa", Bb1n. 21. M, 1959, cTp. 196-197). IIMeeTcfl yKa3IIM IpaMoTa AHnpeFI I'IBalloBIILIa nM noJIIIBaHoBy oT 9 ceHTFI6pFI
l514 r. o I)a3Le3nte 3eMeJIb (rB几Tp. KII. 518, "n. 182-183 06.). no
3'1､oii-To rPaMOTe nM. noJIIIBaHOBblM II 6blJI nPoII3BeneH Pa3be31.
CJIeLoBaTeJIbHo, rPaMoTa, ony6JIMKoBaHHafl B AC3H (cmlcoK XVI B.
cM: rBJI, Tp. KH. 5 18, JIJ1. 182-183) , 4aTIIpyeTcfl BpeMeHeM nocJIe
9 ceIITH6pfl l514 r.
ʼ 2 2

Ha3HaKIaJIcFI CeMeHy) npoBoX"Hcb no rpaMoTaM BeJIHKoro

KHfl3FI Ba|cHJIIIFI IIBaHoBIIKIa 234, noJIyqlIBmero 3TOT ye31 B
1502 r. Pa3'be3)KI,Ie Ka'caJIHcb BJIameIIHi TpoHUe-Ceprl"IeBa
MoHa'CTblPH, PacnoJ1o)KeHHblX, |nO-BH"IMOMy, B6ml31I 'Ka皿HHcKoro Dv6eﾝKa 235.

STH IOKyMeHTbl MOrJIH noflBIITbcFI MeH〈瓜y ceHTH|6peM

1503 1I aBry,c|ToM l504 r., Ho Koma To'IHo­瓜oImHⅡocJIe

cOcTaBJIeHIIH nyxOBHOhHBaHa lll,-'cKa3aTb TPynHo. HcHO
oXHo: BacHJIIIit BeJI aKTIIBHyIo 60pb6y 3a o6JIanaHIie yneJIaMH cBoIIx 6paTbeB. B TIIHorpa｡cKoii JIeTonIIcI1 110cJIe l{3BeCTIIH O CMePTII HBalIa lll CKa3aHO:《Ⅲ ユa'CTb BeJIH'KOe

KIIH>KeHHe cblHoBII 'cBoGMy BacIIJIFIIo, Xa cblIIoBH cBoeMy
IOpblo HMIITpoB Ii mlble rpambl, a KHH31o nMHTpelo ymeIIb
na IIHble ropoXbI, a cblHa cBoero CeMHoHa Xa AImpeH macTb
Ha pyKH 6paTy IIx, BeJIHKoMy KHH3Io Ba'cHJIHIo, H HoBeJIH IIM
ZIaTH yn<eJIbl> 236.TaKIIM o6pa30M, B0Ⅱpo'c o6 yneJIax CeMeHa
II AHnpeH 6blJI ocTaBJIeH Ha ycMoTpeHHe BacHJIHH. OIHaKo,
CynH no nyxoBHOii H HO XOme且皿eMy 'CnHcKy Pa3'be3>Kei rPaMoTbl HBaHa lll AHnpelo Ha CTapImy, BeJIHK" KHH3b, oIIeU

BImHO,

HaMePeBaJIcH

HaneJIHTb

Bcex

CblHoBeli

yneJIaMI,I,

H

ToJIbKo ynoplloe conpoTHBJIeHIIe BacHJIIIFI npHBeJIo K ToMy
KoMnpoMHIcIcHoMy pemeHIIIo, IfoToI)oe npemcTa|BJIeHo B THnOrpa｡cKoii JIeToHIMcH KaK nPofIBJIeHIIe elHHomlIIHoi BoJIH
HBalla lll.

OⅡonblTKax BaCHm呪yKpe'ⅡⅡ|Tb cBOe BJIIIHHHe B MOCKOBCKOM ye34e KOCBellHO CBm瓜eTeJIbCTByeT BblnaIIa BOJIOⅡ-

KHM KHH3eM enppoM BoplIcoBIIIIeM B IIIoHe l504 r. >KaJIoBaHHoii rpaMoTbl TpoIIUe-CeprlleBy MoHalcTblplo Ha 3eMJIII B
BOxO!Be |CTaHe MOCKOBC|KOrO ye3Xa 237, KOTOpblii, KaK Mbl llOMHHM, eme B MapTe l504 r・BXO瓜HJI B III1CJIO cTaHOB, nOJIb30BaBmHx'cH oco6blM BHIIMaHHeM IIBaHa lll. eIIop BopII'coB1m, OIIeBHIHO, OnaCaflCb 'nPHTH3aHm曲 BaclMIIH, nepenaJI
MoHacTblpIo B co6cTBeIIHoIcTb MeJIbHImy li 3eMJIH, HaxOIIIB･
mHecH paHb皿e Ha o6poIIHoM npaBe. CTpeMJIeHIIe BoJIoUKoro
KHH3H np61ITbcH pa'cHoIJIo>KeHmH TpoIIUe-CeprmeBa MoHacTblpH HMeHHo B HIoHe l504 r. 6blJIo, Bo3Mo)KHo, cBH3aHo c
234 ACSI,i, T. I, Nb 644, 645.

235 3eMJIII Haxo4M.Jmcb E 6acceiiHe p. OcTpetIIIHbl, nplIToKa Mo.J1orlI
(AC3II, T. I, Nb 644) , n B ropoXcKoM cTaHe (TaM )Ke, Nb 645 n
cTp. 710 - BI)IcoKoBcKIIハnoIIIIHOK) , 1)acIIOJIOIKeHHoM HO BePxOBb9M
MOJIOrlI
I1 K IoI､O-BOcToKy oT I<ammlcKOI,o ye3na (10. roTbe yKa3.
coII" cTp. 552) .
236 nCPJI, T、24, cTp. 215.
237 ACSH, T. I, Nb 654.

口

223

im3｡mO>KGHI'IeM B sTo BPeMFI IIo nPIIKa3y liBaHa lll HoBrOPomcKOTo aPxIIenHcKona reHHamlIFI, B IIbeii enaPxIM HaxoL11JICH
BoJIo'KoJIaMcKHii ye34.
B I,IIoJIe - HaIIaJIe aBrycTa l 504 r. BHyTpeHHHfl no皿iTIIKa
6blJIa o6pameHa B cTopoHy 3ananHblx ye3npB: Mo)Kaii'cKoTo
H Bfl3eMcKoro. B IIIoJIe l504 r. 3aKoHIIHJIcFI npoUe'cc o cHopHblx 3eMJIHx BoJIocTHblx KpecTbfIH II CHMoHoBa MoHac|TblpH

B ycom'cKoii BoIJIocTI1 238, norpaIIIIIIHoiI c Py3cKIIM ye3noM 239.
BⅡo皿Ⅲ|cHOM C'ynHoM CHIICKe ecTb O6blIIHaH巾Pa3a: 4<I/I oceM
cynbfl PeKもCH LOJIO>KIITII TOcynaPH BeJIIIKOrO KHJI3兄》．OnHaKO HMH Bem1KOrO KIIFI3FI B，n<oKyMeHTe oT℃yTCTByeT. ｡aKTIIIIeCKII B pOJIII cy4IJII BbIcme曲HHcTaHIMH Bbl'CTynaJI HKoB
3axapbHLI KomKIIII, HBJIHBm砿CH B､O BPeMH oIHIIM II3 HaH60J1ee np}16JIH>KeHHbIx K HBaHy lll JI}皿(OH 6blJI B [IHCJIe
f

nOcJIyxOB

nPH

co'cTaBJIeHIHI

J

nyxOBHoM

rPaMOTbl

BeJ1IIKoTo

KHH3H 240I Cymblii cnHcoK no,nJIIIcaH nbHKoM AJI. 6e306Pa30BblM, HeKorna cJIy>KIIBmlIM BacHJIIIIo. Mbl y>Ke 'BblIcKa3blBa,JIII nPe瓜ⅡoJIo)KeHHe o nplIHanJIe>KHocTH BacHJIIIIo Mo)KaiicKoro ye3na B 1502 r・no Bceii !Be|poHTHocTH, B l 504 r.
HBaII III cTpeMIIJIcfI II3'bflTb Mo>KaiicK H3-noX BJIacTII BacHJIIIH, 1JIH KoToporo o6JIanaHIIe 3TIIM paihoHoM o31IaIIaJIo
Bo3Mo>KHOCTb KoHTPOJIIIPOBaTb cOceXHIIik py3'CK" ye3n,
npeXHa3HaIIeHHblii IOpHIo no ntyxoBIIoiHBaHa II1.

7 aBrycTa l 504 r. HBaH I I I BblnaJI >KaJIoBallHylo rpaMoTy
H. n. CaTIIHy Ha CJIIIIIKoBy cJIo604y B BFI3bMe24'. rpaMoTa
coxpallllJIa'cb B no3JHeM cnIIcKe - KoHna XVII B. 242 MoTHBHPoBKa

IIO>KaJIoBaHIIFI

B

HOIIIe且meM

TeKCTe｝IaIIoMH}IaeT

Tpa巾a peT巾aﾉIbluHBoK sTOrO BPeMeHII (<<3a BePHylO CJIy)K6y, 3a nocoJI:cTBo Bo OpXy)') . A. A. 3IIMHH oTMeIIaeT TaK>Ke
HenpcToBepHblii xapaKTep inscriptio rpaMoTbl, me H.Ⅱ.CaTHH onpeleJIeH B KaIIecTBe oKoJIbHIIKIero: f<CaTHHbl v)Ke B
238 AC3I/i T. 11, Nb 428.

239 CM. TaM >Ke, cTI). 637. nepeBMI ceJ1a BaTo､ﾉII|IIcKoro, q)IIryl)Ⅱ｢) ylomeI､()
B CymHOM cmlCKe, yIIoMliHaloTcFI B Pa3'be3>Keii rPaMoTe l/iBaHa lll

IOplIIo cPem nol､PaIIH[IHblx c Py3cKIIM ye3几oM 'rePP'HToPⅢ尚(4'Inr,
cTp. 398) .

240 HMJI､, CTp､364.
241 ACSI'1, T. 111, JNb 186.

242 1I. A. roJIy6UoB oTI･IocIIT 6yMary K Ha[IaJ1y XVIII B．(AC3Ii, T、1II,
cTp 200) , xoTH Bo"Hoji 3HaK (roJIoBa myTa c ceMbIo 6y6eHUaMII)
roBopIIT cKQllee 3a fQ-e ronibl XVII B. (H n. JI II x a q e n. Pa3"ﾉIHble,『(!,HKu XVI B. Cn6., 1888, cTp. 438-440; A A. 3 I1 M !! H. K II3y［IeHIIIo巾aJIbCII｡IIKaUIIII aKTOBbIx MaTePIIa､ToB B PyCCKoM rOCynaPC.rBe

XVI-XVII BB.­くTpyabI MrHAH沙、T. 17. M., 1963, cTp. 408; npIIM.

36, cp. Xn, 1, JYb 9).

224

XV B. 6bl皿3aXyla.IO衞瓜BOP HHCIKOh巾aMHJIIIeih, H HHKTO H3
HIIx !B HawaJIe XVI B・oKoJIbHHIIHM He 6blJI> 243. B ocTaJIbHoM
u

)Ke TeKICT, xoTfl II HCKa>KeHHblH｣ⅡePenIIIcIIIIKOM, He Ka>KeTCH

no11eJIbHblM IIJIII HHTepnoJIIIpoBaHHblM. Mbl y>Ke oTMeqaJIH,

IITo Bblpa]KeHHe <<B BH3Me c'Boelo BeJIIIKIIx KHH3eii
CJIIIHKoBoIo cJIo60nplo>D coJ<epJKHT HaMeK Ha coBMeIcTHoe

VnpaBJIeHHe BH3bMoh《BeJIHKHx KHH3e" (HBaHa lll H Ba-

611jlHH IIBaHoBIIIIa) . B aBrycTe l504 r. HBaH e皿HoJImHo
pacnopHIKaJIcH BH3bMoii H co'ce"HMH c Heit ye3"MH, 3aBe皿aHHblMH B nyxoBIIoii BacI皿HIo: oH 3anPemaJI CaTHI-Iy nePe3bIBaTb JIIoneit <<H 3 M o e r O BeJIHIKarq KHFDKeH" - II3
Mo>KaiicKa
II
II3
BopoBcKa
lI
H3
MenblHIIHH30
TBePII》・
3'Ta CTaTbH, KaK II BCH rPaMoTa, IIMeJIa B'nOJIHe o'npe八e-

JIel-IHylo HanpaBJIeHHocTb. noJIHTHIIecKHe cBH3II BacImHHc
TBepblo HBJIHIoTcH ycTaHoBJIeHHblM ｡aKToM. E皿e B l502 r.
BacHJIHii o6JIanaJI KaKIIMH-To 'npaBaMH HaくT巾ePCKylo 3eMJIIo>>. O Bo3Mo>KHoii nplIHalJIe>KHocTH eMy MoJKaii､c|Ka B

l502-1504 rr. roBoPHJIocb Bblme. BoPoBcKIiii ye3n 6blJI
IIa'cTblo CepnyxoBo-BopoB|cKo|ro KHfDKecTBa XV B. npeTeH311II Ba'cIIJIIIR Ha cepnyxoBIcKoe HaIcJIelcTBo BbIHBJIeHbl HaMH

npH aHaJIII3e rpaMoT HaIIaJIa l504 r. KpoMe Toro, Cep'nyxoB,
Mo>Kaii|c,K H MeXblHb,ⅡPenICTaBJIHJIH cO60ih IIa|CTb BblMoPoII-

Horo yJIeJIa lOp" Bac"beBIwa 244 (Mo>Kaii'cKoM np l491 r.
BJIa八eJIA皿Peii BoJIbmOii) .

BbImaBaH rpaMoTy Ca'THHy, I'1BaH III cKopee Bcero cTpeMHJIcfl yTBeP瓜HTb cBoIo enXHOnleP>KaBHyIo BJIacTb Han 3eMJIHMli, H3 KoToPbIx oJHII ynPaBJIHJIIIcb IIM PaHee coBMecTHo

c BacIIJIHeM (BepoflTHo, BH3bMa) , nPyrlIe JIH60 npHHa皿e>KaJIII np 3Toro Ba'clIJIIIIo, JIII60 HBJIHJIHcb o6'beKToM ero HaH60JIee JIBHblx IoM oraTeJIb'cTB .

OqeHb IIHTepecHa bopMyJIa o npH3bIBaHIM JIIonleii <<I13-3a

py6e2Ka
II3-3a
JIHToBcKoro>・OqeBH4Ho,
60JIbmOe
BHyTPII=
H
BHe皿HenoJIHTHIIecKoe 3HaIIeHIie aToii rpaMoTbl o6ycJIoBHJIo

BO3PO丞典eHHe
B
HeHmHpoKoro
o6'LeMa
cyXe6Horo
HMMyHHTeTa(<<anPOLIeO"OrO2454y皿ery6cTBa)')HJIbroTbloTAaHII:
.JIIO,瓜H･M, npH3BaHHblM H3 JIHTBbl B nyCTble "oPbl,- Ha

l roX, Ha nyCTO皿ⅡⅢJIec - Ha l l JIeT. rpaMoTa CaTIIHy no
CBOeMy cOXeP>KaHHIo CTOHT OXIIHOKO 'CPe且Ⅱ且PyrlIx HMMyHH243 A A. 3 II M H H. K H3yIIeHIIIo qjaJIbcⅢ申HKaUHH aKTOBhIX MaTePmaJIOB…，
cTp，408.
244皿IIJr, cTI). 194, 326.

245BpyKomiclinooml"16Ke<<cy八Horo》・
15

C. M. KamTalIoB

225

TeTHblx aKToB H3yIIaeMoro BPeMeHm, IITO, 04HaKo, eme He MO-

>KeT cJIy>KHTb OCHOBaHHeM IJIFI BblBOma O ee nOnJ:eJIbHOCTII.

B aBrycTe - ceHTH6pe l 504 r. 3eMeJIbHaH Ii ̲ IIMMyHIITeTHaH HOJIliTHKa HBaHa lll KaCaJIacb ye340B MOcKOBCKOrO,

BeJIo3ep'cKoro II HoBropoJIcKoro・K 30 aBrycTa l504 r. 6blJI
3aBepmeHHaIIaTblii《ⅡO…cJIoBy>HBaHalllpa3be343eMeJIb

B >KnaHcKoM cTaHe MocKoBcKoro ye34a 246. 3eM皿JIe班aJIH
Ho HII)KHeMy TeIIeHIIIo p. naxpbl lI [IacTIIIIHo MocKBbl B paiioHe ceJIa )KiaHcKoro 247. >K"HcKmii cTaH Ha BocToKe rpaHK11HJ1,HO-Bm1mMOMy,CyneJIbHblMHBoJIocTflMIir>KeJIblOHPaMeHeimeM, 3aBe皿aHHblMII B JyxoBHohmBaHa lll AHJpelo
CTapliUKoMy. B 3ToM pa3'Le3Je̲Mo>KIIo BHneTb omlTb-TaKH
nPoHBJIeHHe TeHnleHmiHmBaHa lll ycKJIIIBaTb CBoIO BJIa'CTb
Ha TePPHTOPlMX, PaCHOJIO>KeHHbIx BO3GJIe y八eJIbHblX BOJIO-

CTeii, n'penHa3Ha[IaBmmx'cH AHXpelo, H60 npeTeH31M Ha 3TH
BOJIO!CTI1 6blJIH, OIIeBH八Ho, cBoiicTBeHIIbl BacHJIIIIo H, Bo3MoﾝK-

HO,HOJIHTIIIIeCKKOKPen皿eMyK3ToMyBpeMeHHIOpIIIo(B,IyXOBHO曲IIMeHHo IOpmlo 3anpeUaJIocb B HHx BcTynaTbcFI):

B BeJIo3epcKoM ye3nle, 3aKpenJIeHHoM B 1504r. 3a IIBa
HoM III, neiicTBoB,aJI BeJIHKOKH"KecKI耐nMcen B. r. HayMoB.

B7012E(MeJKimyceHTH6peM15031iaBrycToMl504E.)oH

nOPacnOPwKellMIOHBaHaBeP皿IIJI
lll
cyJIo3eMJIFIxCIIMoHoja MoIjacTblpH B paiioHe nepeBeHb no6pena II Be3HocoBOih248BKpaiHeillOm-BocTQJIHQMaCTIIBeJIO3ePCKOroyeqF
na 249. B ceHTH,6pe l504 r. B. r. HayMoB, npoH3BQ瓜ⅢB皿HH

cyme6Hoepa361IpaTeJIb1cTBoくno…CJIoBy>I'IBaHalII,BblnaJI
nPaByIo rpaMoTy Ha 3eMJIm, 6blB皿He B cHOPe Me>Kny MHTPoII6JIIIrILIIM qePeiIOBeUKIIM MOHaCTblPeM H KPecTbHHaMII JIyKoBCKOro HOTocTa 250. 3TII 3eMJIII JIe)Ka皿1 Io>KHee ycTbfI

p. CymbI, Ha rpaHIIUe c nomexoHcKIIM ye3JIoM.

TaKHMo6pa30M,Bo601IxcJIyqaHxo6beKToMpHHMaH"

6blJI Bce ToT >Ke, ｡Iirypmpylo皿Ⅲ曲H 'B MaPTOBcKIoII rPaMoTe

l504 r. MIITpoInoJIIIqbeMy npMy paihoH 6eJIo3ep"o-lno皿exoHcKIIx 3eMeJIb, KoTOPblhHaxo"IJI,cFI Ha ,cThlIKe c BIoJIoro"cKIIM

ye3XoM.noJIHTIIIIecKHBa)KHoe3HaLIGHIie3ToropaioHa,pacIIOJIO>KeHHOrO Ha nOACTynaX K八ByM BblMoPoLIeHHblM ye34aM
４６ ACSH, T. 11, Nh 429.
２
４７
２

Cp. IO. roTIJe. yKa3. cowI., cTp. 579; ACS1'I, T. II, cTp. 644; cM. IIa
KapTe MocKoBcKoMI o6JIacTII 1939 r．c. >KAalloBcKoe B ceBepo-3ana,mHOii IIaCTII BPOHHI皿Koro PalIoHa.

８ AC91M, T. 111, Np 478.
２４
９ A. I/I. KonaHeB. yKa3･CoII., KaPTbl B HPIIJIO>KeHIIH K KHIIre.
２４
０
２５

Aの3IIX, [1. 1, Nb 306.

226

(BeJIo3epcKoMyHBoJIoromcKoMy),HonpemeJIHJIo,no-BMIf-

MoMy, oco6bIM HIHTepec K HeMy lIBaHa nl, onacaBme,rOcJI
UoBblx npeTeH31Iii BalcHJIIIH Ha BeJIoo3epo m, Bo3Mo>KHo,

BoJIomy.

B alBrycTe l504 r. oT o6Ee瓜H|HSHHO,rO JIIma l'IBaHa lll H

Bac皿皿6blJIa
BblnaHa
>KaJIOBaHHafl
rPaMoTa
cO巾嘘'CKOMy
nPOTo|Ho|ny lI BceM UePKoBHo'cJIyﾝKIITeJIHM CIo中城cKoro co-

60pa l･la 'c60p BeHe[IHblxH只pyrllx |nOmJIHH, a TalQKe Ha lno-

jy"HIie xJIe6Hoit pyrH y HoBToponCKoro ",openKoro 251.

A. naBJIoBnHCaJI, 'ITO<co｡"cKHii co60pHbl曲ⅡDHIIT B 1504 r.
ひ

▲

L

HoJIyIIIIJI八a班e皿e4Pylo >Kam)BaHHylO rpaMOTy Ha Pyry CO

BCeX
HOBrOponCKIIx
｣nfITH,H>
252.
3TO
yTBeP>Kne血eHeTOIlHOB
OnPeneJIeHHII Mac皿Ta6a no>Ka"oIBaHI1H (6e>KeUKaH nfITHIHa

B rpaMoTe He ｡II'ryPHpyeT) . KPoMe Toro, aBTop He pa'cKpblBaeT npH|[IMHbl IBblJaIIIi rPaMOTbl

II

MaTePllaJIbHoe nOJIo)Ke-

HIiec'o｡HiicKOronPHIITalBnPe瓜皿e'cTIBylom,"|nePIIOJI,H3-3a
IIerO Te3IIC o皿eXpOcTII rpaMOTbl ocTaeTcH HenoKa3aHHblM.

BblnaIIa rPaMoTbl Co巾HiicKoMyco60Py cTOIn. B nPHMoii
cBH3II c HPI3JIOzKeHIIGM

HOBroPoPIcKoro

aPxHenlicKona

reH-

HanHH, KoToPbl曲6blJI BblBe3eH Pi3 HoBropo" B MocKBy llocJIaHUaMII BeJIIIKOTO KHH3H

lレIIoHH l504 r. 253 rJIaBHoe o6-

BIIHeHHe, nPeﾕ'LRIBJIeIIHIOe reHHa4H10,-npo,瓜oJDKelHHe B3HMaHIIH M31bl cO ,CBH皿eH IIHIKO'B 3 a XIIP OTO IIMIO (|nO cTa BJIGHII e

B IoJIX|Ho'cTII) , HecMoTpH Ha co60pHoe pemeHIie oT 6 aBrycTa l503 r., npliH"℃e c corJIacHH II ,npH VIlacTHH caMoro
ず

reHHa"IfI. E皿e Bo BpeMH co60pHblx npeIIHii l503 r. IIBalI
III, no-BIIzIHMoMy, 6pocHJI B rJIa3a reHHa"Io V|npeK B
cpe6poJIIo6IM 254. 0"aKo JeJIo 3aKJIIo[IaJIocb He foJibKo B
cTpeMJ1eHIM K IIoJIyqeHJIIo MaTepHaJIbHblx JpxonpB

B3HMa-

HIie M34bl 3a xIIPoTOHHIO cHOco6cTBoBaJIo COxPalHeHIIIO Pa3BHToII cMcTeMU Bac|caJIblHo-IIePaPxIILlecKIIx oTHomeHHii BHy▲

U

U

TPlI IIePKoBHoii opraH|III3anHH 255・Bblme Mbl HoKa3aJIH, IJTo
５
２
１<I-ITeHMFI Om且P", 1866, KH. 111, oTﾉ1. V. CMecb, cTp. 5-7.
５
２
２A. naB.JIoB. yKa3・coIJ., cTl). 50.
５
３
２
５
４nCPJI, T. 1V, L1．1, Bbin. 3, cTI). 611.
２
５
５10．K. Bel､y H o B. yKa3. coII., cTp. 352.
２

no MHeHHIo H. C・JIyPbe, noBeleHIIe reHHamm B HoBropone B 150315041､I､･onpemeJI凡nocIJTeM,̲KITOoHBepHyJIcflcco60pano6entIITeJIeM
IHA"̲Ka3aKQBa !{ jICJIyPbC. yKa3・coYI., cTp. 209;

H.C・JIypbe．HleojlorIILIecKaf! 60pb6a..,, cTp. 419) . jl．C. JIypbe
oTBepraeT o6'HIcHeHIIFI oTcTaBK|li reHHa皿佃, npenJIo>Kel冊Ible H. H. Po-

30BbIM（3aPacIPOcTPaHeHI1e《nceB且OKOHcTaHT川loBohrpaMOTbl>）l｛

A. n. npoHmTeihHoM (IIo ZIoHocaM) (H. C・JI y p b e. ImeoJIorHLIeCKaH 6Opb6a..､cTP 418-419).
227

15＊

IIoIBropon|cKaH apxHenH,oKon|" 6blJIa K HaIiaJIy XVI B. HaH-

60JIee He3aBIIcIIMoit H3 enalpxIIi. OHa cyMeJIa y,nepJKaTb
｡eOAaJIbHblenPHBHJIerHI131nOxHy,,meJIOIB(nPaBOaPXHeHHCKOIHICKOrO Cyna Hal Ha'CTOFITeJIRMII MOHa|CTblPeih ,nO C,BeTCKIIM

4eJIaM II T. |n.) . C 3THM-To cylBepeHHbIM HoJIo>KeHIieM HoBrOPOXCKOIINO B､Ⅲa八blKH H 60POJI,CH B neP|BylO OIIePenlb
HBaH III.

B pJme JIeToHHcHblx cBoAoB yKa3aHo, 'ITo, BepHyBmmcb
BHo,B'1℃po且ⅡocJIeco60pa,reHHa,II1曲《HaIIHTMbl3XyHMaTII
y CBH皿elHHIIKO'B oT 'cTalBIIeHbH HaIInaIIe nepBa,ro, IIepe3 cEoe

O6eUaHHe), 256瓜o Hac 40皿eJI (B cnHcKe XVI B) 257 0皿H
U

U

LIp e3IBbIII aHIIO風HTePecHblM IoKyMeHT, npoHcxIo)K4eHIIe KoTO-

PorO He BInOJIIHe HCHo. Pe[Ib 1B HeMH典eT o Pa3IMePaX 'cTa|BJIeHblx 'HOmJIIIH B nlOJIb3y aPxIIenlICKoina H erO nePICOHa,JIa:

くnomJIIIHbl |CoH瓜eT c cTaBJeHIIKa aPxHenIIIcKoIHy r'pHB1Ha
HOyrOPO!瓜uKafI 6JIa!rOcJIo|BeHaH, "oPeU|KoMy aJITblH, nPH,mBepHoro 4 258 MocKoBKH 259, cBImeTeJIcTBa ceMb八eHer, 3a
U

ⅡHCIleH aJITblH, nPoTOHony 4|Ba
aJITblIHa, npOTo且HaKOHy XBa
aJITblHa,
aPXm且HaiKOIHy八|Ba
aJITblIHa7八ma.KOM
ne'BIIIIM
IBe

rPliBHbl HOylrOPO1uKaH, a nOIHaKOM 260 !n'0 [IeTblPe MOCIKOIBKIH,
He八eJIHOMy Ho,ny na nilIaKiqHy BOCM MOCKOIBoK, HoHaMaPeM
八Ba aJITblHa, ncaJIOMmH|KOM rleTbl'pe MocKOBKIi, 31BOIIUOM IleThlPe Mo'cKOBKII, nPOICKypHH,K'y JIBe MOcKOBKm, B UePKOBHylO
Ka3Hy ABa aJITblHa, |nO,U CTaBJIeHylO rPaMoTy nBe叩HBHbl
U

IIOylroP0nlUKaH, |KeJIeHIHIIKy aPxHenHoKOnJIIO aJITblIH, 0T IIIICMa

aJITbliH, nO,ⅡxepoToHelo XyxoBHIIKy aJITblH>. B UeJIoM c oIHo'Do cIBHmeHHHKa-<<'cTalBJIeHHKa)> Co｡HicKIIit 40M HoJIyqaJI

oKoJIo l,5 py6JIH |Ho Moc|KoBcKoMy cIleTy, 'ITo IIo TleM BPeMeHaM cocTalBJIHJIo BecbMa 3Ha|[IIITeJIbHylo cyMMy. BepoHTHo, TaKoii pa3Mep cTaBJIeHblx nomJIHII HMeJI B HoIBropone li
aHTHepeTIi|LIelCKoe 3HauleHHe, nPemlTIcTByH八o H31Be'CTHOii |CTeneHH IHOIHOJIHeHIIIO ,COICTaBa CJIy>Ka皿erO XyXOBGH CT|B a BblXOX一

Ua'MH H3 0eXIHblx CJIOeB Ha･ceJIeHHH.

Mo)KHo，nlyMaTb,IITOnPHBenteHHbl曲 只OKyMeHTBO3HIIK
noIcJIe n'l)H･coe且HIHeH.HHHo'BropoXa. CKopee Bcero, oH oTHo256 nCPJI, T. VI, cTp. 49, 244; T. V111, cTP. 244; T・XII, cTp. 258; T. 20,
nepBaH HoJIoBMIHa, cTp. 374-375; T. 28, cTp. 337.

257 rnB, noron. 1564, J1. 86. noIIepK XVI B:, J1HcT MeHbmero *opMaTa,
【IeM叩yrIIe JIIICTbl C60PHIIKa.
⑪

" QIIHTHO C 6yKBeHHOii n"Poii <<" HanliCaHa 6yKBeHHaH Um(bPaく”ʻ

259 naJIee !lallllballo n 3aqePKHyTo ,npyrIIMII [leplllimaMII: <<al]xMn.llaKoHy
aJITbIH》．

ヴ
△

260 TaK B pvKoIIIIcIl.
228

CIITcH K anoxe reHHa"H Ii, BO3MO>KIHO, na>Ke "ryPHPOIBaJI
B IIHcJIe o6BIIHIITeJIbHblx MaTepmaJIoIB npoTIIIB Hero, qeM II
o6LHcHHeTcH caM *aKT nepenHdKHaToroTeK'cTa
nPH HII3JIO)KeHIIH reHHaX,HH areHTbl BeJIHIKOro KHH3H,

Me|調Ⅱy n|pOIIHM, <<Ka3Hbl nOneLIaTaJIII> 261, T. e. HaJIO>KHJIH
CeKBe,cTP Ha naHb'rII H, BO3MoMHo, JPyrOe XBⅢ〕KHMOe HMy-

皿elcTBo Co｡IIihcKoro pPMa OTcIo" cJIemyeT, [ITo palccMaTpm|BaeMaH

)KaJIOBalHHaH

rPaMoTa

nOH|BIIJIaCb

B

y|cJIoBIIHx,

Korna Co｡IiiicKoMy loMy 6blJI HaHeceH cy皿eCTB eHHblHⅡoJIHTII|IIecKHi

H

MaTepmaJIbHbli- VDoH．y)Ke B IIIoJIe l504 r.
ユ

Ha6JIIoXaeTcH IIonblTKa nocTaBIITb n'cIKoIBcKylo qacTb Ho!B四

r o P o n ' c Ko H e n a p x H H n O I KO H T P O J I b M H T P O H o J I H Ta I I B e J I H KO -

KIHH'>KelcKoTo mp a'BIITeJIb'cTBa. 1 5 HIoJIH MIITpon'oJIIIT CHMoH
Han'PaBHI HocJIaHIIe nlcKoBcKoMy IQHH310 nMHTplilo BJIa皿一

MIIpoBH'IIy c npH3bl,BoM co,6JIIonaTb ,HocTa旧oBJIeHHe ,co60pa
O BJIOBblx nOnax H cMe,maHIHblX MoHa|CTbl|PHx. rPaM|OTa <<J1erJIa npe且ⅡOIcal4HHKII ,n$cKO｣BOKIIMH H CBH,瓜eHHHKII y JIaBHUbI》

l l a.BrycTa l 504 r. 262 ABry|cToIBcKaH >KaJIoIBaHHaH rpaMoTa
COm"CKIIM XePKOIBHOcJIy班HTeJIHIM ppJI>KHa 6blJIa pa3PemHTb Ha Ho|Bblx o,cIHoIBalHHHx |nPO6JIeMy IIx MaTePlIaJIbHOrO
o6eC|ne[IeHHH，BeJIHKoKHH>Ke,cKoe npaBIHTeJIBcTIBo II|cIHbITblBaJIo l,JIV6oKVlo
B
雪 曹 3aH旧TePeCOBa|HIHocTb
ユ

cOIO3e c TaKOii MO-

ry皿eCTBGHHOii ntyXoBHOii KOPHOPa皿eik, KaK Co｡HiicKH曲
"0M. n'03ToMy, oTMeHHB nlpalKTHIKy B|31I､MaHIIH M3Xbl 3a nocTaBJIeHHe cBHmeHHHKOB, oHO nPenOcTaIB"O CO｡IIiiCKOMy
nPHiIITy ,HeKOTOPhIe nPyrme HCToIIIHHIKH瓜,OXOIOIB, B TOM TI,H,CJIe

BIBeJI'o xJIe6Hylo pyry, cTaBIIBmylo comlIincKIIx nono'B B HenO'cPe4IcTBeHHylO

MaTePllaJIblIIylO

3aBIIICHMOcTb

OT

rocynaP-

cTBa. ronoBoe xJIe6Hoe loBoJIbcTBIIe npoTonony, npoToUbHKoHy, 18 nPImeJIbHblM cBH皿eHHHKaM, IIeTblPeM nLHKOHaM, 4ByM KpblJIomaHaM II 17 4bHKaM IIa3Ha[IaJIocB B pa3Mepe 345 Kopo6ei p>KH II 345 Kopo6eih oBca 263, KoTopble oHH
MorJIII nOJIyulHTb y HoBrOPOncKOrO nBOPenKOrO.

Pa3Pe皿eHHe CO'｡"CKHM UePlCQB|HOCJIyX〈HTeJIHMB'3HMaTb
IBeHeqHhIe nOmJIHIHIjI (8a BeHqalllIe 6PaIIymHX'CH) 6blJIo CJIenCTIBHeM oTMeHbl M31bl 3a noIcTalBJIeHHe cBHmeHHHKOB. PaHb-

me, n｣o B,Ceii BePoHT1HOCTII, BeHeIIHble no皿JIIIHbl co6II,paJIH B
U

CBOIO

HOJIb3y

CBH皿eHHHKII

MecTHblx

２６１ nCPJI, T. 1V, q. 1, BbIn. 3, cTp. 611.
２６２ AA3, T. I, Nb 388/11;“ncKoBcKIIe
JIeTonHcIf>',
２６３

UePKBelI,

KOTOPble

Bbm.
I、cTp. 88-89.
npoToHomy 25, npoTo4bflKoI-Iy II cBHmeHHHKaM no l5, JLJIKoHaM Ho
10, Kpbl,JIomaHaM H plbHKaM Ho 5 Kopo6eit.
229

nPIIo61)eTaJIHnPaBo Ha 3To, BcTyIIHB B JPJI)KHOcTb, T、e，3anJTaTHB M34y aPxHemICKOny lI erO anⅡapaTy・Tenepb >Ke
pa3PymaJIaCb CTaPaH CHcTeMa q)IIHaHCOBblX CBR3eii: c O皿oH
○

U

CTOPoHbl,OCJIa6JIH@ma,CbMaTePliaJIbHaFI3a'BHCHMOcTbMecT-

Horo lyxoBeHcTBa oT Co｡"'cKoro JIoMa, Ho, c npyroi cToU

PoHbl, H MecTILOe nyxOIBeHCTBO TepHJIO IlacTb cBOIIX nPe>KHHx40xoIoB.BnpoIIeM,cKopeeB'cero,Me｣cT1HbIecBH皿eHHHKH
OCTaBaJIIIcb H･nlOcPeXCTBeHHblMII c60PmHKaMH (OnlHaKo He

HoJIyqaTe"MI1) BeHeIIHblx nomJIIIH, }i6'o Tpymd nPe皿oJIo>KHTb,[ITo6blBce>KeJIaBmHeBcTynHTbB6pakXoJI)Kilbl6blJIH
exa|Tb nJIH sTOro H3 'c'BoHx ICeJIHユePe'BeHb ,B HoIBT'opon(.

BrpaMoTec'o八eP>KHTcHnlJIHI･IHblmnePeuleHbnOrOcTOIB,c
KOTOPblX
CO巾砿CKOMynPHIITyPa3PemaJIO'cb6PaTbBeHeq妙

Mple"n9jIIJIIIIHbl.ConocraBJIeHIie3Toroc|nm'cKa､cKapToii
○

K.A・HeBoJIKHa noKa3blBaeT, [ITo BcH 3Ta Macca norotToB
HaxoIwIacb B UeHTpaJIbHoji noJIoce HoBropoHcKo# 3eMJIH,
U

U

⑪

ecTBy B ceBePHOR IIaCT
T､e､noⅡPeHMy皿ecTByBceBePHOHIIaCTHⅡePeBCKOH
H皿eJIoHcKoHnHT班I
TIIII IIH BBIo>KHoIIIIacTHBoTcKo＃II
Io)KHoii IIacTII
BoTcKoi IIO6OHe>KcKoH
O60He>KcKoii
mHTHH･

BcTaeTBonpoc,HecoxpaHHJIocbJIIIcTapoenpaIBIIJIo
noJIyIIGHIIH |BeHeIIHblx nOmJIHH cBH皿GIIHIIKaMH MecTIHblx UePK-

BeカB QKpaIIHHblx o6JIacTHx HoBropoXciKoi 3eMJIH II B BeU

>KeUKOHnHTH'He？
U

B KaKoih Mepe KoMneHcIipoBaJIIi pyra H BeHeIIHble nomJIHHLI yTPaTy nPaBa M3"I 3a xIIPOTOIIHIO, CKa3aTb TPynHO.

BeHeIIIHbIe nomJIIIHbI <<c oTpoI<a)> H <<c nieB皿bl>(T. e CO
B|CTynaIOmIIxB6palfBneplBble)ycTaHaBJIIIBaJIIIcbBPa3Mepe

l/2
l HoB'roPOn'cKHx
('CJIeXOBaTeJibHO,TPexMOcKOBCIfIIx)
ie-

Her c qeJIOBeKa; nOmJIIIHbl <CO BjPBUa> H <<cO BnPBb",

2cTynaIomHxB6PaK,TPe60IBaJIHCbBIBO"OMPa3MePe(nO
U

3 HoBFopoIcKHx, HHaIIe - no 6 MocKoB,cKHx "Her cf qejlo-

BeKa) . CyMMa romoBoro noxona 3aBHceJIa oT [IHcJIa e)Keron-

HO 3aKJIIOLIeHHblx 6PaKOB Ha TeppHTOPHIJ, me cOdJIIACKoMy
nPHIITy Pa3PemaJIOcb B3HMaTb BelleIIHbIe no皿ⅢHHbl、

Mo>KIH､onpH6JIII3IITeJIbHo'Bblpa3HTbBneHbraxcToIIMo|cTb
Q D

xJIe6Hoii pyrII, npeXlia3'HaqeHHoii npoToHony H npyrHM nep-

KOBIIOCJIy>KIITeJIHM・nO1CKOJIbKyKOPO6b月PlKHCTOIIJIaBHa-

IIaJIeXYIB.10Ho|BropOJoK(mJIH20MockoBoK),aKopo6bH
oBca - 5 EoBrop:oXoK 264(IIJIml O MocKoBoK) , 345 KoPo6eii
p>KII H 345 Ko,po6en oBca nP,II>KHbl 6blJIPI CTOHTb BMeCTe
264 B. KJIIo'leBcKIIi'1．PyccKMii py6.Tb XVI-XVI I I BB･BerooTHo山eHIIII K IlblHemHeMy. M・, 1884, cTP. 26.
230

1
13,5
py6JIH
MocKoBcKMM
qm|cJIoM.
yqIITbIBafl,
HIo
nqFTaBJ1e-

"e" ohiIoFo cBfmeHIHIIKa npIIHo'cIIJIo oKoJIo 1,5 py,6J]兜ⅡoxOXa, Mbl BnPaBe 3a'KJIIOIIHTb, rITo CyMMy, PaBIHyIo cToIIM|o-

cTw xJIe6Hoii pyrII, co60py MOIJIo na" ̲IIocTaBJIeHIIe

nplMMep,Ho80cBH皿eHHIIIKoBBroX.EIcJIHK113,5py,6JIHnpH-

63BIITb XeHbrII, co6pa|HHble lB KaIIecTBe BeHeIIHblx :nomJIHH,
B UeJIOM, BePlOHTHo, noJIy|IIIITcH CyMMa, Pa|BIHaFI HOxOAy OT
noIcTaBJTeHIIH 100-150 II 60JIee cBHmelHHIIKoB B ro瓜・

rpaMOTa XalBaJIa, KaK XyMaeTcH, XoCTaToImylO M,aTepHaJIbHyloKoMneHCanlIIOy6BITKOB,oBflBaHHEIxCOTMeHoHM3nbl
U

3ax"oToHIIIo265,xoTFIBHoJIHey6eﾕHTeJIbHOHOKa3aTbaTo
CKaJIbIHOII TOIIKH 3PeHIIFI OTMeHa
HeBol3Mo)KHQ C 叩'CTO巾HcKaJIb旧oHTowKH3peHmoTMeHa

M3'XbllIBblXaiIIacO巾砿cKOMynpHIITyxJIe6IHoipyrHHe6blJIa
BblITOJIHalnPaIBIITeJIbCTBy.meJ1O3aKJIIOrlaJIOCb,nO-B皿HMIOMy,
⑪

U

B |noJIHTMtleCKoM 3IIaIIeH" 3TOh Pe.oPMbl, HBJIHBmeHCH,HoBblM ma'roM Ha nyTH nOnqHHeHIIFI nePlQBH rOCynaPgTBy.

O61cTaHoBKaB̅HoB'roponenocJIeHII3JIo)KeHIIHreHHaⅡxH

6blJIa lHeCnOKoiiH0it. n'03TOMy nPaIBIITeJIBCTBO 1CTPeMIIJIOCb

yKpsnlITb 3n<ecb nlOJIHTH唖eCKOe noJIO)Ke'H|He cBoIIX fIBI-Iblx

6T6Po'HHIIKoB.20ceHTFI6"1504r.oTodLeⅡmHeHIIOToJIHna
IIiBaHa lll H Ba|cIIJIIIH 6bma BblnaHa >KaJIoBaHHaH rpaMoTa

CBeTCKIIM巾eOnaJIaMenOPylIAHnPelOqePHbUOBblMngTfIM
U

nalOcOBa Ha nOMeCTbe lIx OTna B neHTPaJIBHoH印a'cTH HoIB-

ropoIcKo# 3eMJIII (B By">KcKoM
ropoⅡcKoH3eMJIH（B
By”>KcKoMnorocTe
norocr meJIoJIcWit
meJIoHcKoH
mU

TImbl266,n|pIIMblKalBmeMCIoraKo3ePyHⅡbMeHb).nalOCO-

,Bbl、OIIeBH且HO,aKTHBH!O,nO瓜瓦ep>KHBaJIHⅡ|OJIHTHKylIIBa,Halll

B HoBIro|po,me. Eme B 1477 r. neTeJIH nalOcoBBblHOJIHFIJI

BeiCHM a OT旧eTcTBeH'HOe lnoPyIIeHHe l'IBaiHa lll, cBFI3aHIHoe c
HoBroIpOXcKHIMB3HTHeM267.noTImyHMMyHIITeTHoronO)KaJTOBaHIIH I,PalMOTa He OTJ1HIIaJIacb OT nPenme'cTBylO皿HX
rPaMoT
上

HoBrOPonlCKHM

HOMemIIKaM:

OHa

noXTBeP>KXaJIa

nbaBo Ha 3GMJiIo <<3 noxoI|oM 3 neHe)KHbIM H 3 xJIe6IHbIM H
cMHJIKHM XOxO,nIOM, Onp'HII HamHe BeJIIIKHx KHH3eii O6e>K多

Hble naIHH>.

265

I<PoMe TorO, B rPaMoTe nO/ITBeP>Kna畑にI, HGKoToPble CTaPlIIIHble nPa-｣

BaCo巾HhCKOronPlIIITa:<<AqTOmJ1anommHaco(1)efICKOMynpOTOnonV
w nPoTOJIIIFIKOHy ll HoHoM C nPoPKyPHI皿eIO、ⅡIIM Ta nomJIIIHa c nPO-

cKvDHI皿eIo IIMfiTI1 no cTapIIHe A aHTIIMIIcb1 Be"Tb co(I)eiiCKoMy npo-

TOfIbnynnPOTO且ⅢflKOHyHCBH皿eHIIIIKoMRocTap1lHe.AcomT11

CO60POB CJ1y)KI,ITH rOPOXCKIIM CBH皿eHHIIKoM y Co巾eRBe川IKoro no
C Ta p H H e 》 ．

６ Ⅱ､兜.
２６
７
２６

C a M o K B a c o B. yKa3. coII., [T. 1], oTJL I1, cTp. 4-5.
ncP几T. VI, cTp. 209; T. V111, cTp. 187.
231

OT oKTH6pH 1504 r.­月HBapH 1505 r. He nomJIo naTliPOiBaIHHblX rPaMOT

nPaBIITeJIblCTBa,

nOCBFI皿eHHblx3eMeJIb-

HblM HJIII HMMyHIITeTHbIIM BOnPOCaM.

B coIcTalBe rpaMoTbl l 697 r. npH旧eneH TeKCT yKa3HOii
rPaMoTbl lIIBaHa lll oT 22巾eBpaJIH 1505 r. nepKIBH①enop a

CIBFIToTo ,Ha eXopoBe yJIHUe B HoBropoXe 268. rpaMoTa
⑪

MI3IBemaeT,

IITO IBeJIHKHHKHFI3b

no>KaJIOBaJI

HOBrOPOnOK1oro

くKoHIomero>D H. A. KoJIblIIeBa nlepeBHHMPI Bo BJIaX<HHcKoM
nOTOCTe nePeBCKOii mTHHbl, npHHanJIe>KaBmHMII paHee Ha-

3BaHHoii nePKBII, a B3aMeH 'najl eit BoJIocTb CbITIiHy B CblTIIHcKoM HoTocTe Toit >Ke mlTHHbl. CblTHHcKHi norocT Haxo-

ⅡHJIcH Ha BocToIIHoM no6epe>Kbe o3epa I'IJIbMeHb; BJIa>KIIHcKIIii (JIa)KIIHcKH#) norocT 6bIJI pacnoJIo>KeH Io>KHee Cbl-

THHcKorO, nPHMblKaH K Ioro-BOCTOtIHOii IIacTH o3ePa HJIbMeHb. no coo6mellHIo rpaMoTbl l505 r., paHee BoJIocTKoh
CblTHHoii BJIaneJT al)xIIemlcKon. I/I3 JIeTonHcHoro pac'cKa3a
o co6blTHFIx 1477 r. BblHcHHeTcH cTpaTerlIqecKoe 3HaIIeIIHe
3Toii BoJIocTH IIa noncTynax K HoBropoIy (TaM cToHJI Be-

JIHK" KHH3b lI Tyna nplie3>KaJI K HeMy BJIanblKa) 269. TeM
He MeHee, Mbl He HaXO皿M CblTIIHo B cⅡHCKe KoH｡HcKOBaH-

Hblx B 1478 r. BoJIocTei HoBropoXcKoro BJIan(blKH 270. BepoHTHo, BoJIocTb CblTHHa 6bma oTo6paHa y Ka巾enpbl oKoJIo
1 499-1 500 rr.

Pa'CcMaTpm,BaeMafl yKa3HaH 叩aMOTaⅡOHBHJIa'cbⅡOCJIe
neKa6pbcKoro co60pa l504 r. Ha HoBroponIcKHx f<epeTHKoB>
H, BepoHTHo, nocJIe 3IIMHIIx Ka3Hei l504/05 r. Korma, B
IIacTHOcTH)

CO)KmH3a

ePeTHIIeCT,BO

IOPbeBCKO.FO

aPXIIMaH-

瓜pHTa Ka'ccHaHa m ero 6paTa 271.

XapaKTepHo no)KaJIoBaHHeくKoHIomero> B KoHIIe XV
HJIII Haqa､JIe XVI B. BeJIIIKHi KHH3b, oIIeBHIHo, cTpeMwIcH
K ynpoIIGHIIIo BJIHflHIIH HaMecTHHLIbei BJIacTH B HoBropone.
Bo BTopo杓ⅡoJIoIBIme l504 - HaIIaJIe l505 r. noJIHTH'Ka
HIBaHa lll B HoBIropon<cKoih 3eMJIe JIoKaJIH13dBaJIa'cb B nel･ITPaJIbH|Oii ee IIacTH. STO 6blJIO Bbl3BaHo 3ana'IIeit 'HeihTPaJIH3auHHuePKOBHo# oⅡⅡ03HIIHH, o6e3rJIaBJIeHHoii II PacmaTaHユ

268 JI0mし1, KoJIJI. aKToBblx KHIir (KoJIJ1. 2) , Nb 73, JIJ18 06.- 4.

269 nCP几T. VI, cTp. 209, 211; T､V111, cTp. 187, 189; T. XII, cTl). 174,
1770

270 TaM >Ke, T. XII, cTp、1 83.

271 TaM )Ke, T. VI, cTp. 50, 244; T. V111, cTp、244; T. XII, cTp. 258; T. 20,
nepBaFI no.noBIIHa, cTI). 375; T. 28, cTI). 337; H A．I<a3aKOBa

!I

H. c. JIypbe・yKa3. coq., cTp. 210, 216-217; H. C・JIyl)be. I'血eQJIorHIIecKaH 60pb6a..., cTp、420-426.
232

HOii,
nO八IIH
He
HO I-IIIBmenCHnOJIHOCTblO
BeJIHKOKHH)KeCKOMy
U

U

nP aBIITeJIbCTBy.

Bo3Mo)KH6, qTO c 1505 r., nocJr PaonpaIBbl 2 <epem":

M"m5'imi cTaJI ynpaBJIHTb HoIBropo"" "｡WWm月

Ba!cHJIIIH・BoBcHKoMcJIyIIae,IIMHHocJIenHe"oTIcyTcTByeT
・

5MMoTe
Br
,paMoTeoT22巾eBpaJIHl
oT 22 ｡eBpaJuI
505E,
1505
xoTHo皿oII3T
n,l(9IiLWWM
oHrpaMorW95

Tbl ,IO皿eXmeih,K T6My>Ke,BcOICTaBerPaMOTb[KQW
XVII
B.,
HenocTaTo,咽IO皿H巾oPIMyJI|HPoBaHIIH
BbllIBIIHyToro
npemOJIo)KelHHH
BH瓜epe皿HTeJIbHOr'O
2
BbIBona.
U

ybT,paHeHIie BaicmJIIifT oT HoBnopoAcKmx neJI, ecJIK "9
L

瓜ei61BhTeJIbHO
IIMeJIo
MecTO,
MOrJI:O
6bITb
cJIeXIcTBIIeM
YPIt
U

MM no3IIIIIIii HBaIHa lll B HoB|ropone nocJIe oTcraW
e
rHIHa'皿硯,m'60ToJIBKo3Ha'qmTeJIbHa2pIeneHb'HoBTQIlQJIpW
MMNMI B KoHUe XV - HaqaJIe XVI B;､ BbIHyxmaJIa̲ rU

j1IIIKoTo
KHH3H
co6JIIoXaTb
oTHomelHHHHoB,rop|oIma
B
npHHBOih･HorocyBePeHHTeTa・
cyBePeIIHTeTa.
IlH'n1BOH･Hoʻro

KPbMEToro,b504
i rBpe3yJIgTaT"6WWHHBacII-

JIIIH̅ifacJIelHHK'OMnpecToJIallepO60pb6bI3anoJImTIIqgWe
U

nPeO6IIama"eBPa3JIMIIHbIXPa""WWI,"WWⅡHMo­
My,
pe3KO
o'60CTPHJ1HCb
nPOT"QUe"
̲Mgi〈,ny
H,HMH瓜py;MMIMMMWMikOf6 K"3il, a B oTHomeHm"̲W-

HalllCOCTaPmHM
cbIHoM
nO-nPe>KHeMy
rocHOLCTBOBajia nomo3pmTejibIHocTh ･"̲HapBh] B noUeggH"̲WW
MEMCTePyoT 8 ｡eBpaJIH 1 505 rmol, WWp ̲c¥WWM
U

o:A'HOrO
IIeJIIoBeKa,
nPlIme旦皿ero
II3
ycT6fl
HapIBbl,
I'IBaH
III
U

cMepTeJIbHo
60JIeH
ero
IIcbIIH
BacmJImⅢ瓜oJDKeH
6blTb
BeJII1KIIM
KHH3eiM,
BHyK
a BIce
e皿e
aPecTOIBaH,
pycC･KIIe
>Ke
60JIee
ERjibHHbl KEHyKy,̅wIeMK BalcmJIIIIo; MeX<'ny ,ngBMEWIII"9

RMii̅ira5Pb"ef 6oJIbmafI paon"; BoJ'K KY"ubMI,.̲"¥

CTaPOnO
B6JIHIKOrO
|KHH3H,
CO>K>KeHfO
WWMH叩yIIMMII
MKIIMII 3a epecb, KOTOPaH TenellP ̲MWOcIWWW;
BaclmHHnPlIKal6blIBaeTBceXePeTIIKOBxiBaTaTb,rneO|HHHH
U

nOHBHTCH, II >Keqb 272.

Bo3Mo>KHo,BacH狐HiiBbl3IBaJInpoTHBce6HmH'poKoeHeu

U

npB6JibcTIB'oBHoB|ropo,me,maTonolcJIy]Ioo"omm3npIIIII1,H ero OT1cTalBKII OT HOBrOpOmOKH,X nleJI.

BHi｡M̅EEjim̅6"
n6TePfIJI
KoiHTP9".̲¥MWPrgW

JmoMTio np,io6peJ, npaBa conpaBliTe" "WWW.,WE

coe,瓜miIEHIiM̅fyl6KaPH|3aHCK6roKHfnKeC"allPm,9""P
U

M
OJIO,n6f5̅
InHHBIf
K
ynP
aBJIeHIIIO
qalCTbIO
PfI3aHCKOH
3eMJIII,
272LEKUB,2-teAbt.,Bd.2,M722,S､563(yKa3aJIaHnePeBemllacocTaPoHeMeUKoro
A・JI･Xopo山KeBI4II)
.
233

u

nOCTaBmeIICRH!BaHy lll B HaIIaJIe XVI B.,一別BJTeHHe, nO
npHqHIHaM II cymecTIBy aHaJI'oTHIIHoe no@JIylIIeHHIo Ba'cIMIIeM
B cBoe BpeMH
BpeMH oⅡpelﾕeJ1eHHoH且oJIH
onpe'neJTeHHoii noJIH cyBepeHIITeTa
cyBepeHI1TeTaHaX
Ha1HoBHoBroPOn0M.

Pgn"bIxKHHraxKa3Hb!CoJIoTqIIHcKoroMoHacTbI"

1722 r. ynoMmHaencH <<'rpaMoTa 'BeJIHKor() K"3R̅mm5
BacIIJIheBHIla Bcea PocMIi II cbIIHa ero BeJIHKoro KHH"̅M

"" ¥Ban|9BMII"2ea pOclni Hecy"Mam, miana a"MM瓜plITy
noc"elo
7013…rO4y,
3a
,mBeMH
BHCJIblMII
KPa'CHbIMH
WWThMII̲>273rMM9Ta
qIJIa
BblXaHa
Me>KmyCdHT"6PEM

l504ma'B｣rycToM1505r.CoJ10TMIiiicKHHMoHaCTblDbHaxO"JIICH B TOii qaCTH PH3aHCKOii 3eMJIII, KOToPyIo ilBaH III
U

JIoJIy[IINI oT pH3aIIpKQro yneILHoro KHH3H ｡enopa BacmJIbe-

BH[Ia.B4yxoBIHo曲HIBaHalllroBoplITcH:<<A IIToMHnaJI
cecTpHwHII Mom
cecTpHIIHnI
MoIMKHH3b①eoⅡop
KHH3b eonop BacIIJIbeBIIq
BacHJIbeBHIIPH3aHcKoii
PH3aHcKoHcBoIo
cBOIo
U

grqIIHy H4 PFI3a,HII B ropome71 Ha no'c"e cBoih >Kepe6eih II
U

A

CTapyIoPH3aHbHnep6BIITecKcBoJIocfbMHHcnVTbMH…，
H H3 Ty erO BoTIIIIHy…"Io CblHy cBoeMy Ba,cIIJIblo)'̅274. na=
Ta c|MepTH KHH3H "nopa Ba'cIIJIbeBHia !lem3BecTHa, ho
noIc'KQJIbKy oH eme ynoMHIHaeTcH ,B 1 502 r., a nyxIOBIHylO HIBa-

HalllJ(aTHpyloTo6bl[IHol504r.,MCCJIeXOIBaTeJIHOTHOICHT
cMepTb ｡eXopa K 1503 r. 275

MblHoIIITHyBepe!Hbl,wToB<<HecymIMo"rpaMoTeCoU

JIoT'IIHII!cKoMy MoHaIcTLIplo ocHoIBHblIM comep>KaHHeM 6blJIo
orPaHHIIe'HIIe IOPHcIHK皿ⅢPHaaHcKOrO enHIoKO|na. nyMaeM
TalK, y'LIHTblBaH TeKcT rpaMoT HBaIHa lll H Bac}mHH'Ho'Bro-

p94gKIIIUipHa,cT.lpHM 1499-1500 IT. H |mpaMoT BacIIJIIIH III

1507-1508nr.HblBI1℃poAcKo｣W
IOpbeBy
PH3aH|cKoMy
M

CoJIowHHcKGMy
MqHacTblpfIM276.
O6
0rpaHI1,IIeIHHII
enli6口

lWfKOH IoPHIc"KUHII 'B PH3aHcKoM KHH>KeCTBe XO HatlaJIa

XVI
;B.
HalM
HIIxIel,o
HeH3BecTHo.
Ho
B'ceii
BepoHTHOIcTH,
PH3a'Hc|KMMBJIanbIKa,TaK>KeKaKm'HOBrOPontKMii,06JIMa"
273Xrpyllb[2"amcKoiiyLIelloil
apxIIBHoii
KoMMccmm
l887
3a ro瓜か7T、11.
q p

い

EH3allb, 1888, cTp. l 1..
"4 4mUr, cTp. 357-f358.
口

ZcToplifl
".H̲Jlp
K
PJI3aHcKoro
ciia
275
gcliblf,
n.
Tp，
KH"KecTBa"
223，，”M，220；A，
"LnplUL
B、aK3eilB6mmiery1858,
H
M
KⅡc
220;
Jl)
Tfl
flJI
l〕
M
A､B
ne
cK
3
!<
m
3A．Be川IKHeHy八eJIb""" R"epHoii P)lc'! B TaTap"Uifnepmofl, c l238 rio1665E,
T.I1.Cn6.,1891,CTP､646,nI)IIM.2095;A.r.̅Ky3bMIIH.PR3aHcKo6
JIeTonﾙIcaHHe，CBeneHI呪ʻrleTonHceho
P”aHHII
MypoMe且o
cepenHHbI
IVIBeKa. M., 1965, cTp. 275.

U

276
C･
M・JMmTaHo¥
CocTaq
!IMMyHIITeTHblx
rPaMoT
nePBoii
nOmoBHHbIXVIBeKa.­《Apxeorpa巾IIlIecKmhe>KerQIHIIK3al962ro八沙.M､、
1963, cTp. 99 M npHM. 7-8.

234

U

nPaBOMCynaHanHacTofITeJIHMI!Mo|LLacTLiPe4 " np̲ JWMI

Ⅱ6"ibM6TBeHIHbiMcBenc|KOMycynyEoPb6aHBaHalllc
CylBePeHHbIMH,
yneJIbHOKHfI)KeCKIIMII
nOJTHOmiOumHMH
llePひ

KbBHLIx IiepapxoIB HocIIJIa

UeHTpaJIH30BaIII'HblWI xapaKTep

H,

OqeB皿Ho, 6bijIa pacnpocTpaHeHa B 1504/05 r､ Ha npHcoe"HeHHylo IIaCTb PH3aHcKOrO KHfDrcTBa.

Bainbejle-Mael505r､Me)KmyHIBaHoMIIIMBaclllIHeM
Bo3HIIKJIiI,
BeP'OfITHo,KaKme-TOnl)OTmBOPeqlIII
H3-3a
BeJIO03epa・Ba,npeJIel505r.6blJIIIQK9HIIeHblnPoUeccbl..03eMJIe
⑪

1
yCTb-ynOJ1bCKOii
b)
BOJIOCTli277,
paOII,OJIO}KeHHOEBy¥e
u

U

H3Be|cTIHoihHalMKPariIHeIIIOI､oBocToIIHoiiIlaIcTHBeJIo3epU

U

U

6k6roye3",HaCTblKecBQJIorOncKII'Mye'3nIOM278L2)
QIJeBⅡⅡHO,'BfOM
>Ke
paiiOHe279
MJIIIlgrO-BOCTOqHee
BeJIOO9:U

pa280;
BoJIbcKgii
B
3)
BoJ1ocTHnOmeXOHCKOrO
ye31a281,
U

JIe>Kalbm6i B ycTbe meKcHbi, ceBepHee yrJIKIIa !I̲flpocJIaBJIH2820co6eliiIoII,HTepecHoBHIIMa'HIIejKBoJ1bqfoiiBoJIoIcIM,
FIBJTH!BmeihcFI
VneJIbHblM
|HaIcJIe,ⅡcTBoM
AHmpeH
BoJ1bmoTo
283.
"Ecex cJIVLfafix cyl"ei nepBoii liH'cTaHUmm fIBJIHJIcH 6eJIo･
B. r. HayMoB, cylbeii BblcmePI
II|HcTaH
3epcKHHnH'ceU
CeⅡB，r・HayMoB，cy瓜beHBbl
cmeHHHcT
aHuHH­
I'IIBa!HIII．OXIHalKIonoinblTK'ⅢⅢ,B̅aHalll3almpemITb3aCO60#
U

U

U

U

U

BeJ1OO3epOHHomexoHbeHeyBeHIIaJIIIcbycnexoM.BoTIIomeH" nomexoHbfI Ha aToT cIIeT HMeeTcH npHMoe noKa3a-

HIIe HcTotIHHKa. TH)K6y MIITponoJIIIIIpero HoBHHpKoTo MoU

HacTbIpHcqepHbIMIIkpecTb"aMIIAp6y)KGBIcKoiiBoJIo'"
nHcell B．r. HayMoB HaqaJI cy"Tb <<no BeJIHKoro . lW3H

Eji6EWIIBa'Ha BAcIIJIbeBmqa B6ea pyc", Ho 4 MaH 1505 r.
277 ACSII, T・II, Nb 310.

U

278 X.̅II"Ko n'a H e B yKa3. coil., npm". 1; B. H. n e 6 0・mbcKIIH、
yKa3. COIJ., Bbln. 11, KaPTa B KOHIIe KHm､Ⅲ、

279 AC31I, T. 11, JVb 309．0 1)acnoJIo>KeHIIII o6beKTa TII>K6b!
u
u cfBepgee

ifWf! 6"Mb6TEyer̲yiI)MIIHaHme "eBHI{ MIIX2"QBfl<Cl""
K1111cKoI､5Vefbm(cpAWKona!,eE̲yKaacoII"nP"2,KBamP4T
Mn;̅6mfhKo
3mb6b
HaxOUIMOCb
ce､mO
HBaHUoBO,
me
a HBaqeBO,
yKa3aHHoe B rPaMoTe.

280 A, H. KonaHeB・yKa 3･COLI., npH@IT、1, KBanPaT K 7; 3necIJ ecTb ceJII)
叩

m"Iieib ]! nlePeBHH
I/IBaL1eEO
II且ePeBHH
JIyKHHcKaH，HO
JIyKIIHcKah, HOHeT且ePeBHⅢ
HeT ,mePeBHI!
MHxaHJIOBCKOH・
MmxaiijIOBCKOh.
281 ACSI'1, T. I, Nh 658.

282B.Hne6oJIbcKHii. yKa3.coIL̲, Bbln･I, KaPTa B KOHUe KHHrlI.

283CoxpaiIAJIIIcI,
mBe
ero
rpaMoTb!
TpomUe-CeprmeBy"9¥2RTbIPIg<,M4
IMiiirE̅B6JIBbKoi BOJIQhTII""yeMble nd mryMeHy l4Z8=!"2Ip

(AC3H, TJ, Nb 464, 465) B 1 478 n nofTI)MMaC"̲ "2""M"22JmKaHKHfIrIIIIFIMapⅡ兜月pdcJIaBHa,KoTopoiinpHII"JIe>KaJIMAp6y>KeBU

cKaH II BoJIbcKaH BoJIocTII (nmⅡT, CTP、356) . OIleB皿HO, B CBFI3II C

nocTplI>KemleMoHamTIel)ellaJ1aAMJIpeIoBoJIbcKyIo BoJIocTb,aBo3Mo>KIIo, 'H Ap6y>KGBcKylo.
235

TeM>KgCynbeii6blJIBIJIHeCeH,nPH|ToBOP《nOBeJIIIKOrOKIHfl3H
cJIoB'y BacIIJIba mBaHoBMIa Bc6a PVcii)>
ｰ 284

Ap'6y|>KeB
cKaHBOJIo,CTb
HaxOIIIJIa||Cb
Meバュy
6eJIO3eP,CKO#
叩

ycT.-yrOJIbCKoit
BOJIOCTblO
Ha
ceBePeHⅡo皿exoHcKoii
BoJIb.
U

cKoiiBoJIocTbloHaloTe 285.KaK II̅ BoJILcKaFIBoJIocTb,oHa
⑥

geKoMa nPHHanJIe)KaJIa BeUHIKoii KHHrmIHe, Ho HeII3BelcTHo,

9blJIaJImnoTOMnePemaHaAHmpeIOBoMIbuioMynOJIy'lb"
BacmJIHeM B ""e a'npeJIH (|n'o"<e l 8-ro) 28r"1I E̅tMM
HaIIaJIe.Mafll505r・3ToHKJIIoIIeBOjino31mHH!HanOn,cTynax
K BeJIoO3ePy O3H"IO ecJIH He lO|pMaJIbilOe, To MfIF
U

U

g<Pe PaOnPO'GTPaH9Hme erOBJIIiHHHHHaBeCbBeJIO3eP,CKO
n,OmexOHcKIii KPait.
U

U

npeApcTaBJIeHHe
BacmJIHIo
cyBepeHHLIxnpa,B
Ha
BeJIo-

3ePlcKO-;nOmex(〕HCKyIO3eMJIIo6bmO，BO3MO>KHO，KoMneHCaU

UHeH 3a coirJIa'cHe oTnaTb KHH310 10IpliIo HIBaHoIBHIIV pV31cKVIo
ゾ

"|cTbeDoyneJ1a.nePBaHmOme凡m"IKamoBaHHaiiiPaM6Ta
IOpIIH,Ka,Calo皿aHcflPy3CKoroye3na,"THPyeT,cH
17IIIOHH
1 505 E 287 B ceHTH6pe ̅l 504 - abryCTe l505f BacmﾉIHii coxpaHHJI cBoII IIo3"HIi
U

U

lla 3ananHoA oKpaIIHe MocKoBcKorO

ye34a, nopy6e)KHoih co 3BeHIIroponcKHM ye3JoM 288. nepBoe
A

II3BeCTIIeOBJIanel-IHHIOpHH3BeHIII､OPOXOMOTIIOCHTCHy>Ke
K n99mony nocJIe cMepTII HBaHa lll - 22 neKa6pH 1505 f 289

MHeKa>KeTIcH,qTIoBcBfI311cIIepenaieiBhcIIJIIimno-

皿exoHbfl McIijlllJIocb BHIIMaHIle HBaIHa lll K 'coceXHeMV
ジ

HpocJIaBJIIo.21IIoHH1505r.'nOcJIO'Byl'IIBaHalllnlBoPenK'皿
nBnlecTyHoBBblHegnpmroBopno.cnopHoMymbhy531SMg
U

U

JIeBpamoHe"lJfBHHKIimKHIHoKoiiCnacEKordHpo|6JIalBoKoro MoHagrblpH 290, H"oIIIBmeiicHnpliMepHo B 3(i BepcTax K
▲

Io,ry oT HIpocJIaBJIH 291.

Bo3Mo)KHo,HapHJy,cBeJIoo3epoM,Ba,cHJIHHno-|npe|>KU

geMy npeTeHIoIBaJI HaHa
HeMyⅡpeTeH'且olBaJI
̲KOCTpoMy,
KocTpoMy，Ho3Ta
Ho 3Ta eroⅡpeTeH3HH
ero npeTeH3miI He

6bIJ1aynoMpJFopeljgB
lO73E̅(Me>KIyceHTH6peM
1504̅Ii
aBrycToM 1505 r) HBaH III BbI"JI rpailorypo n6Jlb30BaH"
IIepeBo30MKocTpoMcKoromnaTbegaMOHacTbIpH[Iepe3
２８４
A311X,
２８５
２８６

[1. 1, cTp. 262-264.

B、H. ne6o,JIbcKIIji. yKa3・cOLI., BbllI. II, KaPTa B KoIIUe KIIIII､II.
Eme l8 anpem l505 r. npIIroBop lio 3GMe､TbIIoii T"K6e B Bo"bcKoii

Bo･mOcTII
6bl｡TBblHeCeH《no…cJIoBy>HBaHal(ACali,T.I,JVb658).
８
２
７ACSIi,
T. 111, Nb 66.
８
８ IaM >Ke, JVb 48a, cTp. 73, rp. 353, 354.
２
８
２
９ TaM JKe, M 61.
９
０
２
９
２
１ TaM H<e, JYb 218. .
TaM>Ke,cTp.599(KIimKIIHcKaH),626(qelIxIypa)
236

PKo'cTpoMy292PqeBH瓜Ho,B1505r.norpa'MoTeIIBa'Ha
U

U

ill HaqAJIcfi cy,ne6HbIii npoUeoc B nJIecCKoj BoJIo|cTm, 3aKOHIIHBm1冊IcH B 1506 r., npI1 BacmJI皿III (IneqaTb K nPat ヤ

BoiirpaMoTe
6blJIanpHJIo)KeHa27beBpaJIR1506r.)293
ユ
U

BecHoii l505 r．Ⅲ|BaH III 'npoHIBJIFIJI oco6blii HIITepe,c K
noJIo>KeHIIIo AeJI 'B BHTcKoM Kpae. B Mae o|H no>KaJIoBaJI

AiH,npelo
IMBaHoBIIIIy
nJIeMfl,HHHKoBy
B
KopMJIeHIie
CJIo'60"CKOii rOpOnplK
294. npHqHHy 'Bblla[III 3TOIi rPaMOTbL HanP lilCム
U

U

U

KaTbBHOIBOMHoBOPoTeoTIIomeHmHcKa3aHblo.BJIeT|o|ⅡⅡcHx VKa3bﾙBaeTcH, [ITo BelcHoii l505 n Ka3aH,cKHiI xaH
ご

MyxjMMe4-3MII|HnpmcJIanBMogPy̲ KHH3HmaliHcIi｡a
(《maliCyna)>) <O HeKOIIX 4eJlelW95. neJIa aTII, BH皿MO,

HacToJIb|Ko o6ecnoKoIIJIHHBaHa lll, [ITo o;H oTnpa'BIIJI B Ka-

3aHb cBoero no1cJIa MIIXaIIJIa KJIfmmKa, HaKa3a!B eMy, <<IITo-

6bloHTeMpeIIeMBce'MHenoTaKaJI>xOXHalKoMyxaM'Me4r
○

3MHH BcTaJI Ha nyTb Pa3PblBa nPy>KecTBeHHblx oTHOmeHIM

(24 IIIoHFI oH apecToBaJI MHxaIIJIa KJIHnHKa m y[IHIII'IJI I)ac-

IiPaByHaUPyCCK,IMIUfy皿aMII)296"
OIIeB'"Ho,
nocoJIblcmBo
皿alIHcliqja 6blJIo B MocKBe He n03)Ke M", T. e. BblnaIIa

rpaMoTbl
nJIeMHIIHH､KoBy
npoIIcxo八HJIa
o6cTaHoBIKe,
B
Koma
HBaH III CTPe'MHJIcH yCHJIMITb cBoPI IIo3IiUIIII B IIOrP4H"llblx

cKa3aHcKIIMxaHcT|BOM3eMJIFIxnJIeMHHHHKoBbl6blJIIIM3｡

BeCTHblMII alM,IIIHHCTPaTopa'MII, MMeB皿mMII HeMaJIbll,I onblT

ylTPaBJIelIIIfr
ceBepo-EocTOIIHblMH
oKpalIHaMH
297.
n,ocKIoJ1bKV
ぎ xaH MoTIIBMIpoBaJI cBoIo H3MeHy

TeM, qTo

くⅡeJIOBa,JI
pOTy3a
BeJI,HIKoTO
KHFI3月旦MHTPeH
I/IIBaHoBH'la,
3a
BHVKa BeJIIIKOrO KHH|3凡 6paTcTB'o II JIIo'60IBb IIMeTII Io IHII
ジ

>KHBOTa llamerO, II He xO[IIO 6blTIi 3a BeJIIIKHM KHH3eM
BacHJIMeM I'IBaHoBHqeM>D 298, I1ePeMeHa KopMJIeH皿HKoB B

CJIo6olcKoM I,OPOJKe MOrJIa 6blTb o6yCJIOBJIeHa Hx TIOJIMTII[IeCKIIMII CBH3FIMII C OnPelleJIeHHblMmⅡPlllBoPHblMH､ rPynnIIpOBKaMH .

292 nO c T p o B c K II i.HcToPlll<o-cTarl!cTIILlCcKoeonmcaHlleKocTp9"
cKoro
nel)BoKJIaccHoro
Ka巾e1paJIbHoroⅢⅡaTHeBa
MoHacTblI〕凡KO-

cTpoMa，1870,CTI)．103．ⅡOCC瓜ep半aI11IiorpaMoTa5
l 04/05r、6bJ
l 1a，

B皿HMo,6JIII3KaKnpep､mecTBylouieiirl)aMoTrel443r.(ACS1'I,T.111,
Nb 229).
293 AC3I'I, T. 111, Nb 48.
294 TaMx〈e, Nb 293.

辞

295 nCPJI, T、1V, [L l, Bbln. 2, cTp. 535; T. VI, cTp. 50，244; T. V111,
cTp 244; TXI I, cTP 259; TgO, nepB"̲noJIOfMHa, cTp¥375
296 no叩o6HocTII cM: nCPJI, T. 23, cTp. 197; T. 30, cTp. 140.

297 1'IB. AI"1p．ⅡJIeMfIHHIIKoB IIeo八IIOKI)aTHO 6blJI BO,mocTeJIeM B
yCTIOﾝKcKdM ye3ne (AC3m､T. 111, JVb 286, 287}
298 H．C･JI y P b e. IIePBble lmeOJIorlI MOcKoBCKoro CaMO八eP>KaBMfl.一
237

K HocJIe皿eMy MecHny >KH3HH IIBaHa lll - OKTH6PlO

1505,r- oTIHocmcH pa3"be3>KaH rpaMoTa Ha 3eMJIM cEJIa
Pa>IcCKOrO(Pa>KKOB'cKOrO),nPlIIHanJIe)KalBmeroKHR310BaCH-

JImPHBaHoBHqymeMHqHqy,LHceJIanoqen,BoTqIIHbITpoHUe-CeplMeBa
MoHaCTbIPH・Pa3Ee3及ⅡPOH3IBOJHJICH《no…

rpaMo1e> H,BaHa lll 299. CeJIo HoIIen mJIH noIIaln Haxo,瓜ⅡJIQcb, BIMIHMo, 10>KHee nepeXoJIa, pacnoJIo)KeHIHoro !B 12-

l3KMKceBepo-BocToKyoTMaJIorOHpocJIaBUa300(norlancKlie 3eMJIH及OXO皿JIH "o TopycKoro py6e)Ka)>) . Pa3be3,m

6blJI BbI3IBaH cKopee B|cero HaMepeHIIeM̅npaBIITeJIblcTBa noMe,maTb PaOnPOcTPaHGHIilo 3eMJIGIBJIaAeHI,Ifl H HOJI･HTHIIe'cKO-

ro BJIHHIHwIBacwI:Hfll'IBaHoBPIIIameMH;IIIiula B MaJIoHpo!cJIaBen'KOM ye3ne.

'I'ITalK,H3yM&IIIiellMMyHHTeTHblxriPaMOTH4iPyl皿xⅡ'CTOuHMIKQEKoHUaXV-HaIlaJIaXVIB.'npIIBo且HTHacK,BblIBO4y,
IITO IIBaiH III CyMeJI B Te[IeHIie nocJIe八HIIx 15 JIeT cBoero
nPaBJIeHIIH OcymecTBIITb nPOrPaMMy OrPaHmﾘeHHH ｡eOnaJIbHo'ro IIMMMHIITeTa, HaMeqeHIHyIo

B

80-x ronax

XV B.

B acwIﾙiii B IIo4TBeP>KXeIIIIHx K cTapblM rPaMoTaM II B BblnaHHblx I,1M np l502 r・HOBblx rPaMoTax coxPaHflJI 60JIee
mH｣POKHe npHBHJIerIIIi IIMMyHI1!cTQB, IIeM HBaH III.、

nPoBe,m6HIIe HBaHoM ill cTPbrO orpaHIIqeHIIoii MMMyHHTeTHOji nOJIIITHKH 6blJIo Pe3yJIbTaToMCaMOro CyPoBOro
nO,瓜aBJIeHHFI nonblTOK Bo3Po>KnteHIIH ymeJIblloii CTiaPHHbJ

KeM 6bl OHH HHⅡpe1npHHIIMaJIIIcb. BMecTc c TeM, TeH八eH皿Ⅲ巾eoAaJIbHoii pa3pp!o'6JIeHHo'cTII eme npentcTaBJIHJIIi ,co60曲o'6'beKTHBHylo 3aKoHoMepHocTb・Co6paB Boe"IHo HoIITII BCe Py'OcK'lie 3eMJIIH Ii yTIBePmiB皿IIcb CaMOIep>KUeM Bcefl

P)ﾊcH, HBa'H III Hc1nblTbIBaJI HaTIilcK nelHTpo6e>KHblx cHJI II
cTPeMIIJIIcH nPenO'I1BPaTHTb HIx pa3BHTHe nyTeM BbIJIBH>KeHHH Ha ,noJIHTHIIIeoKylo apeHy coInpaBHTeJIeih. CIIcTeMa co-

niP?BIITeJIbcmBa nO 3aMbIcJIy cBQeMy H旧JIHJIacb aHTHynte､JIb-

HOH, O八HaKO Ha ,n'PaKTIIKe oHa 6blJIa KPaiiHe nPOTHBoPeIIIIBa. npebⅡ(Ha3HaLIeHHafI IJIH H3>KHBaHHH ocTaT|KoB V4eJIbHoii
fTaPHIHbl, 3Ta CH'CTeMa B To >Ke BPeMH IIx KOHCePBHPoBaJIa.

HaIIaB c cIIcTeMbl conpaBHTeJIbcTBa, HBaH III -KoHIIHJI
Pa3,maIIeii TePPHTOpH曲cblHOBbHM B y,meJIbl.
くyLJetIbie 3amlcKII JIrmi mM. A H. repHeHa>, T. 78. Kabe,mpa IIcToplII1 CCCP. J1., 1948, cTp. 105.
う
﹄

２９ AC3H, T. I, Nb 659.
３０
０

KaPTa MocKoBcKoii o6J1acTH 1939 r.; cp. AC3I'1, T, I, cTp. 613, KoMM.
K Nb 279.

ʼ

Fza8q

IV

IMMMyHZTETHAJI HO八HTIIKA BAC班八ⅢH III

＊

OTHo,meHHe npa'BHTeJIbc'1NBa Ba1cIIJIIIH III K IIMMyiHHTeTy,
KaK II BCH BHyTPeHHHHnOJIHTI1Ka 3TorO nePmOn<a, II3yIIeHO
U

U

qPe3BbIqailHOcJIa60・nPo6JIeMyHMMyHHTeTaB̲IIePBOITPe-

Til XVI B. 3aTPoIHyJI B caMbIx o6皿Hx qepTax n. n. CMIIPHolB．《…BaclIJ1IIii 11,­|ⅡHIcaJI oH,­…6blJI o[IeHb 皿enp Ha

BbmaIIy >KaJIo|BaHHblx TPaMoT, B !IHCJIe fOToPblx nO'BoJIbHo
MH6ro･|r'PaMOT II Ha rO'poncKme nBOPbI. BpeMH e[℃npeeM△

imkoB, ieJIHKIIx KHH3ei HBaHa lll m BacmJIIIH III,- 3To
u

BpeMH 60JIbmoii cnep>KaHIlOcW oTHocIITeJIglo,̲rn94faJIQ"

Hilii, oCo6e,HHO B rOP"ax)>L BoJIee TOIrQ, n．n．CMHpHIoB
U

oqHTaJI, IITo cT. 43 Cyne6HIIKa l550 E o'6 0'I1MeHe TapxaHoB
6blJIa Ho cv皿ecTiBy npocTblM 3aHMcTBQEaIIljeM H3̲ <y|cTaB-

HbIx K,HII,r7Ba,cHJIIiH
HbIx
KiHH'”Ba:cHJIHHIIIHJIHI'IBaHalll2．Ⅱ”̲BceHueHHoIII IIJIH I'IBaHa lll 2. npH. Bceih UeHHo-

cTH
nPIIBeneHHblXBblme3aMe[!aH城Ⅱ．n．CMHpHoBa
oHH
⑪

He MorVT cJIWKIiTb八OlCTaTOII･HOHxaPaKTepHcTHKOHHMMyHHO|CTaTOIIHOH xaPaKTepHcTHKOH HMMylHH-

TeTIHo曲ⅡoJIIiTHKII npaBHTeJIbcTBa BacHJIIIH III.
KoJIIIIIIe|cTBo IIMMyHHTembIx rpaMoT, BblmenmIIx H:3 KaHUeJIH|plIH BaIcIIJIIIH 111, cocTaBJIHeT, no HamHM |CBeneHHHM,

247 floMepoB 3;X|Be rpaMoTbl6blJIH BblnaHbl BeJIHIRoIKIHH>KeIⅡ.n.CMI,IpHoB.noca4cKI,IeJIIo八I,IIIIMx
KqmaCCoBafl
6OPb6anOCePe,mIHbl XVII d, T. 1. M, 1947, cTp. 88

2<cy旦兄nO
3aHBJIeHlIIoUapflmndconep)KaHIIIocaMoToCylUe6HHKa&oH

C6tRIBJIEH
6blJ! !I3 Pa3jillLIHblx ,,yCTaBIIbix" !i川! yKa3HbiX KIIIIr Om'1U

〉KaHmIⅨ「IoBPeMeHHnpaBIITeJIbcTBBacHQIIしmIIII'JIHIIBaHalll...

B 3TII y3aKoIIeHIIH npII Ko""KaumI, BO3Mo)KIIO, 6blJIH BHeCeHbI...

Pa3JIIIqHble
II3MeHeHH列,
eXBa
HO
JIH
cy皿ecTBeHHble.
TaKoBo
6blJIo
Be-

POFITHOenl)OHCXO)K八el畑e・"HCTaTeii...431I91-"
(n．ⅡCMI'IpHoB.

yKa3. coIl.; T. l, cTP l l2-113) ̅
3 B|oⅢmcaHIim H30cIiMHHcKoii l<JIHHcKoii nycTblHI! 1876 r. rJIyXQ ynoMmt

ｳ

HyTaHecy"MaHrpaMoTaoT
I7IIIoJIg
!506r．(JIeOHHⅡ.KJIIIHcKaH

I'I30CHMeHCKaH nycTblHb H ee aKTbl.-く'ITeHHH OHnP", 1876, KH. 2,
oTn̲ V CMecb, 6Tp. 74) . Ha3BaHHblii aKT o6Hapy>KMTb He ynanocb.
CocTaBIITeJIb omlCaHIIfl He yKa3aJI, KeM 6blJIa no>KaJIoBaHa rpa239

CKIIMH !mi'cUaMH;

TPlI­瓦BoIp eU'KIIMHHoXHa - Ka3HaqeeM;

B IITO're ycTaHaBJIHBaeTcFI Cy皿e1cTIBoBaHHe 253 rpaMoT.
247 rpaMoT BacMJIIifl lll neJIflTcH Ha >KaJIoBaHHble (226 HoMepo'B) H yKa3Hble (21 HoMepl rpaMoTbl "openKIIx HBJIHIOTCfl O6PO[IHbIMII 4. rPaMOTa Ka3HaIIeH - yKa3HaH 5, rPaMOTa OnHO'rO nHCIna - JIbroTHO-,HecyJMMaJI 6, rpaMOTa XByx
叩ymX ､n HICUO|B­瓜aHHaH, JIbrOTH｣O-06pOIIHaH 7.
Ⅲ3 )KaJIOBaHHblx叩aMoT Ba,cIIJIHRIII CBeTCIKIIM JIHⅡaM
X､Ba a|KTa ToJIb|Ko MnloMHHalOTIcH, HO He COXPallIIJIIIICb, IIx 'COAeP>K alHHeH，naT,HpOBIKa He BInoJIHe HIoHbl; IBa aKTa ZIomJ1II

B nepeIoKa3e 6e3 TOIIH'0曲旦aTIi,POIBKH 8; O且Ⅲ,H aKT IIHTePlHOJIIipOBaH9.
I'I3 )KaJIo,Bal･IHblx rpaMoT Bac皿HfI III 4yxOBHblM *eo4a･
JIaM ynoMIIHaloTcfI c yKa3aHIIeM ro" Bbl"LIII (IIHomaTaK>Ke MeC皿a H [IIIcJIa) 23 rpaMoTbl, 6e3 4aTbl - 28 rpaMoT
BoJIb皿mHcTBo rPaMOT OnPeneJIHIOT IIopMbl lfMMyHHTeTa
UepKoBHo-IMoIIacTblpoKIIix y[Ipe>KIGHHh. HII o"Ia yIKa,3Hafl
rpa,MOTa !He nOCBHmeHa nPO6JIeMaM, cBfl3a,HHblM C IIMMyHI'ITeTHbIMII In'pa'BaMH CBeTcKIIx巾eonlaJIoB. CoxpaHHIBmHxcH
>KaJIoBaHHblx rpaMoT Ba'cImmH III八yxOBHblM ｡eo,naIIaM
HalM II3|BecTHo l36, HecoxpaHPI|BmHxIcH - 51 , coxp aHII'B,mIIxCH >KaJI,OBaHHblX mPaM'OT erO )Ke cBeT℃IKHM JIImaM - 35, IIeMoTa, a BbIna'rb ee B 3To BpeMfl MoT KaK BacII川lii lll, TaK II BOJIOUKIIii KHFI3b d)eXoP BOPIIcOBIIII, B ymeJ1e KOToPOrO HaXoJHJIaCh tIaCTb

3eMeJIb H30CI'IMIIHCKohⅡcTbll冊l. 3a npl,IHanJIeIKI･IocTb rpaMoTbl K叩c90

｡my BeJII,IKOKHFDKeCKIIx

aKToB rOBOPIIT ynOMHHaH}Ie

He曲KPaCHOii ne[IaTM, 06bIﾘIIo IIe ynoTpe6JIHBuIeicFI

O

nPPIBelllel･IHOI,IK

B HaqaJIe

XVI B.

yJeJIbHblMII KHFI3bFIMII.
1

<<C60pHIIIK HoB,ropo,nlcKoro o6mecTBa JIIo6HTeOJIe曲瓜PeBHOcTII)', Bbln. 1.

HoBro1)o|X, 1908, cTp. 85; <<AKTbI HcTopHIIecKHe, 0HIIcaHHble m. M. KaTaeBblM M A. K Ka6alloBblﾊ" M, 1905, Nb l/20I AIOB, TII. Nb l75/1.
︑ A･3mX, w. I, JYb 295.
６ ArP, T. I, Nb 55.
７
Ka6aHoB, Nb 5.
８

Co6cTBeHHo roBopH, B nepecKa3e ll:x coXep>KaHHe巾､IryPmPyeT KaK

9

o皿H aKT, oHIIaKO oTMeqeHO, uTo TaKIIx rPaMoT 6blJIO mBe (Hecy"MLIG
rpaMoTbl maTcKIIM cJJyraM B Ka皿ⅢPCKOM ye3nG Ha nOCane - &ﾍrP,
T. I, cTp. 107).
>KaJIoBaHHafl rpaMoTa OcopbIIIIblM 1512/13 r. H、Ⅱ. JIIIXaulGB B皿eJI

B Heii TIIJIMqHyIo no"eJIKy (H. n. JI II x a q e B. rpaMoTbI po@ma OcopbHHblx.­《H3BecTIifI PyccKOro reHeaJI0rliqecKoro O6皿ecTBa)", Bbln. l.
Cn6., 1､900, oT且．111, cTp. 13). BepojlTHo, 6mDKe K IIcTIIHe C. B. BeceJIOBcKIIii, C[IIITalO皿" rPaMOTy l'IHTePHOⅡH1)OBaHHbIM aKToM
(C. B. BeceJIoBcKHh．I< BOnPOCy O叩oHcxo>K1eHI咽BOT[IⅡHIIoro
pe>KIIMa．M., 1926, cTp. 116, M 62; Cp. A. A、3 H M II H. K H3yIIeI-IIIIo
"Jlbcm(imKanlill aKToBblx MaTel)IIanoB B PyccKoM rocymapcTBe̅XVIXVII BB.­くTpyJlbl MrHAH>, T. 17．M, 1963, cTp. 404-405) .
240

ʼ
COXP aHIIBmHxC兜­4. O6e l､PaMOTbl, BI)皿aHIIble n･IICuaMII,11
JBe rPaMOTbl，ⅡBOPeUKOrO nOJIyLIHJIII CBeTCKHeⅡⅡⅡa．

HIDKe npolI3BeneHa reorpa巾Ⅱ'IeCKaH cHcTeMaTII3aUnfl
rpaMoT, nplIo6peTeHHbIx cBeTcKIIMH JIImaMIi.
06maH xapaKTepHcTHKa

BocToqHaHoKpaIIHa

Ｌｈにｎ Ｏ
ｒｐａＭ Ｏ Ｔ

ye3X bI

Pa曲oHoB

６

MyPOMCKHii

HH)KeroponCKHii
U

２

BblXan

q J

Be,ⅢHKHH

KI･IH3b

llHCIIbl
u D

n BOpeIIKHH
妙

BHTcKIIii

CeBepHaHoKpaIIHa

q J

1

BeʻnHKmi

KI･IH3b

cJTaBCKHM)

４

B巳mHKHK

KHH3b

KocTpoMcKoi

２

》

raJIIInK Hii

１

》

HoBropojnIcKRi

４

》

BoJIoroncKH#

１

刀

yCTIO)K CKI1ii

１

》

"BHHCKO#

１

HPOCJIaBCKHii(BoIHOiirPaMoTe ynoMHHaeTcH KocT⑪

POMCKoHye3八HaP"yCHPO-

｡

U

』
●

p

１

m l C e n

Kam即cKHii

ワ

Be.ⅡHKHH

u

I0]KHaH oKpaHHa

妙

BeJIO3ePCKH
i

=

a

KHH3b

nepecJIaBJIb-PH3aH cKMii

(c nepeBIITcKHM)

１

KoOJIoMeHcKIIii

２
２

U

T vJ'LcK"

勺
全

Memepa
3anaAHaH oKpaHHa

｡

BH3eMcKHii

HoBoTopJKcK
Hii

〜

⑪

K､JIIIHcKHii

四
B oIJIonKHii
U

MenlbIHcKIiii

１

BeJ叩KHH

１

》

》

１

》

２

”

Kop3eHeBcK Hii cTaH Moc-

V瓜eJIbHoro KHH3H

KOBCKOro ye3Xa

1

nepecJIaBJIb-3aJIeccK Hi
Cy31aJIEcK"

1

CKHX

16C．M、Kal皿TaHoB

ら

241

⑳

１

C*epa BJTHHH"
IOpHH nMHTpoBcKo･
ro II KHFI3eii myji-

︐
抄
抄
〃

2

BeJIHKHH

KHH3b

KHH3b

》
t 〃

XBOPeUKHH
BeJIHKHii KHH3b

npm'BeJleHHaH Ta'6JIIiUa no3BoJIReT ynBep>KAaTb, IITo ocHoBHaFI Mac'ca )KaJIoBaHHblx rpaMoT Ba'cHJIIIH III c|BeTcKHM
JIMUa'M oTHocIITcH K oKpaH'H,HblM paioHaM. Bo,cTo[IHble ye3Xbl, Ha KoTopble BblnaBaJIIIcb rpa,MoTbI (MypoMcK", HH>Keropon(cKHii, BHTcKIIii) , 6blJIH B nepBoii TpeTH XVI B ape④

E n

I-IOH IIacTblx BOoPy>KeHHblx

cTOJIKHOBeHHII c Ka3aHCKHMH Ta-

TapaMH. 10)KHble ye3八bI (nepecJIaBJIb-PfI3aHcK", TyJIbcKHii
Ⅱ且p) HeoXHoKpaTHo Ho4BepraJIHcb Ha6eraM KpblMneB.
rpaMoTbl KacaJIIIcb TaK>Ke BH3eMcKoro ye3na, nopy6e>KIIoro C JIHTBoi. nPaBIITeJIbcTBo KpaiHe Hy班及aJIocb B VKPenU

⑥

JIeHIIH cBOHx no3HnHII
B 3THx
PaHOHax,
IIepe3
cTpaHy
MOMIi
npOHIIKHyTb H 且eHCTBHTeJIbHO

KOTOpble B
nPOHIIKaJIII

叩

BHemHIIe BparlI. noceJIHH 3nlecb BoeHHblx BaccaJIoB I1 caHKuHoHIipyfl Hx IIMMyHIITeT, BacIIJI" III co3naBaJI onpeneJIeHHyIo cHCTeMy巾opnOcToB B HaH60JIee OnacHblx MeCTax.
B UeJIoM pFmle cJIyIIaeB K 3anaIIe ycIIJIeHIIH JIHHIM o60PoHbl cTpallbl oT BHemHerO Bpara npmlcoe且Ⅱ,HHJIa,Cb 3aXalla
一

〆

OoIpbobl c

MeCTHblM cenaPaTH3MOM

CPaiBHIITeJIbHO

HenaBHo

npHcoeXIIIHeHIHblx o6JIa'cTeit. Co[leTaHIIe 3THx 3a'IaII Heo6xo八H|MO ylIIHTblBaTb rlPH o6EFI'cHeHIim nPoHICxO>KneHIIH >KaJIOBaHHblx rpaMoT Ha ceBepHble TeppHToplIH (oco6eHHo HoBropoIcKIie H fIpoIcJIaiBcKIIe) . KpoMe Toro, Halo IIMeTb B
Bm瓜y, IITo, BblnaBaFI

rpaMOTbl

CIBeTCKIIM JIHuaM Ha HeIKOTO-

Pble rJ1yxHe MecTa B O6JIacTRX CeBePa H BOCTOKa, npalBHTe,JIBCTB'O 6blJIO 3aIIHTePeCOBaHO B Pa3pa60TKe HeO'cBoe,HIHblx
paiioHO|B. rpa'MOTbl, nPenOCTaBJIHBmHe nPa'BO OCBOeHIIH
<<"KHx)> JIecoB

B

BoJIorQIIoKoM,

ycTIo)KcKoM,

m@BHHcKoM,

BeJIo3epoKoM H Hm>Keropo,mcKoM ye34ax, HoJIyIIIIJIH na>Ke
IIe BOeHHble BaccaJIbl nPaBHTeJIbcTIBa.

>KaJIOBaHHble rPaMOTbl, KacaB皿HecR 3eMeJIb B O6JIa!CTHX
c HpKo Bblpa>KeH,HblM y,UeJIbHoKHH)Ke,cKHM II KH"KecKo-'60HPcKIIM CenaPaTH3MOM, nPecJIelOBaJIH 皿aBHblM O6Pa30M
U

UeJIb 3aKPen.JIeHIIH

yCneXOB neHTPaJIH3aTOPCKOII

n|OJIHTHIKK

nP a|BI1TeJIDCTBa・HIcInoMemaH 3,mecb BepHblx ce6e BaccaJIoiB,
BacIIJIHii lll ycHJIHIBaJI cBoIo BJIa'cTb Ha瓜ⅡPHcOemfHeHHblMII HJIH rPalHHqIIBmHMH･ c y4eJIaMH TePPHToPllJIMII. 3To 6blJIo
o瓜HHM H|3 cPeXIcTB 60Pb6bl npOTHB cenapaTHIcT1cKHx 3a'roBoPoB y4eJIbllIblx KHH3e曲H 6JIH3KIIx K HHM BJIHHTeJIbHblx 6'oHP.
B 6oJIbmH;HcIBe cBoeM )KaJIoBaHHble rpaMoTbI BacIIJIwI III CBeTCIKIIM JI皿aM HBJIHIoTcH naHHbl'MI1 (JIH60 "Io皿HMH 3eMJIIO, JIH60 nOnlTBep>KXalOmHMII cTaPble nPaBa BJIaJIeHHH) H K ToMy >Ke HeCy皿MblMH. MeHbme qHcTo Hecy皿一
Mblx rpaMoT. HoBrop|oJIcKHe aKTbl-皿HHble,巾HKcHpyIo242

mlie,

KpoMe

Toro,

onPenieJIeHHylo

IIopMy

nolaTHOrO

HMMyHHTeTa. JIbrOTHble rpaMOTbl noJI'yIII'IJIII KoJIOMeHCKIIe
｡eonaJIBI nocJIe pa30peHIIH KoJoMeHcKoro ye34a KpbIMcKIIMH TaTapaMH B HaIIaJIe 20-x ro"B XVI B. JIbroTHble rpaMoTbl nPenPIcTa,BJIHJIHCb H JIHuaM, |KoTOIpble nPIIO6PeJIH nPa具

Bo Ha pa3pa60TKy瓜ⅢK,Hx JIeCoB B ye3nla|x BoJIoronpKoM，

4BIIHcKoM,ycTIo)IQcKoM,BeJIo3ePcKoIM,HII>KeI,oponl'cKoM.
H33THxaKToBTPHcoXe'p>KaTe皿eIIHe,C皿|HMbliipa3,瓜eJ1,
a QmIIH - 06p'oIIHble o6H3aTeJIbcTBa.

PacnpocTpaHeHHe B nepBo# TpeTII XVI B. na'HHo-Hecy皿Mblx rPaMoT c 60JIee IIJIM MeHee yHII(PH皿PoBaHHblMII IIoPMaMH Cy八e6Horo IIMMyHIITeTa cBImeTeJIbcTBVeT o6 VcTaHoB-

JIeHIII'I OTHOcIJTeJTbHo e"IHOO6Pa3Hblx npHeMoB yTBeP>KneHIIH BeJIHKoKHH>KecKorO cIO3ePeHIITeTa Ha旦巾eOnaJIbHblM H
t q

BJIaneHHHMH B PaHOHax,InOJIIITHIIeCKOe nOJIO>KeHIIe KOTOPblX
BHymaJIO nPaBHTeJIbcTBy H3BeCTHble OnaceHHH.

1.OrpaH皿唖ⅢTexbHbIexaxOBaHHBIerPaMOTm
KoHIJa l505 - cepe月皿HBI 1511 rr.

MeponpPIHTHH BacHJIMIH III B o6JIacTII IIMMyHIITeTa HBMJIHcb npo八OJDKeHI1eM HaLIIIHaH池HBaHa lll, HanpaBJIeHI-IblX
Ha COKPameHIIe beo"JIbHblx npHBHJIermi. B l505- - 1 507 m

npaBHTe,mbcTIBO nPOII3BeJIo [IacTHIIHblii nePecMO'Ip crapblX
>KaJIOBaHHIJIx叩aMOT、

3TOT MOMeHT B IICTOPHH巾eonaJIUHorOMMMytIMTera 3acJIy>KIIBaeT ,oneUHaJIbHoIro If3yuleHHH. OXHaKo 1a>Ke 6e|rJIblIi

npocMoTp )KaJIoBaHHblx rpaMoT XV B. no330JIHeT ycTaHoBHTb HeKIOTOPble HTOrm lnPO|BeneHIIOii B BeJIHKOKHFDKeCIKOii

KaHUeJI印ⅢⅢⅡpOBepKII HMMylHHTeTHblx aKToB (npOBePOqHoii
p a60To# HenocpenIc'I1BeHIHo 3a'BemoBaJI M 6JIH3KHe K Ba'cHJIIIIo

III JbHKH Bo皿blpb nalocoB H ,maHHJIa KHnpHHH)B).
no'4TBep>KnaJIHcb rJIaBHblM o6pa30M I.e rpaMgjTbl, KoTopble He COneP>KaJIK nOnaTHblX OCBO60>KJIeHIIji 'Q 'IIJIII y>Ke
I/IBa'HOM III 6blJIII nO4TBepﾝKn(eHbl c orPaHHIIeHIIeM ''．B Ho4-

TBep>KIeIHHH 1507 r・K oJ,iloih rpaMoTe CHMoHoBy MoIHacTblpIo npaBHTeJIbcTBo Ba'cIIJIIifl lIl aHHyJIIIpoBaJIo cTaTHi, oc-

Bo6'o)KIa BmHe OT HMa7 MblTaf TaMrli HⅡpyrHx Hoﾕ｣｡ﾉIH!H 12.
Io AC3H, T. I, Nb l32, 307, 316, 327, 351-354, 356, 402 493-495, 497,
516, 530, 531, 534, 561,367, 568, 611, 631; ,r. 11，,M 278, 478 ; T、111,

Nb 196, 204. 241; A31,1X, u. 1, JVb 70, 113, 134, 313.
ll ACaH, T. I, Nb 349; r. 11, NL +52.
12 TaM ]Ke, T・II, M 364,
243

16

npaMa，cI)e皿noXTBep>KnelIIIbIx Bacll&ⅢⅡeKI rPaMOT MI,1
Haxo"M aKTbl, ｡HKCHPylOUIIe KpynHble nOnaTHble nPHBII-

JIerMH (cBo604y oT ynJIaTbl HMa, TaMrlI H T. IL) . HeKoTopble
H3 3TIIx HoATBeP>KXeH" IIMeJIM [IIIcTO ｡OPMaJIbHOe 3Haqe-

HIIe, HocKoJIbKy "HoBpeMeHHo 6blJIH HoITBep>KXeHbl 60JIee
nO34HHe, T. e. ,meihcTBylO皿He rPaMOTbI Ha Te >Ke BJIaXeHHH,

He COnep>KaB皿IIe no,maT:Hblx cTaTeii l3. OXHaKo Ho1TBep>KXeHIIeHeCKOJIbKHXrPaMOT,BO3MO>KHO,cHocO6CT|BOBaJIO｡aKTmKIeCKOMy yKpenJIe'HHIO HoXaTHOrO HMMy'HHTeTa OTJeJIbHblx

MCHaCTbIPcKIIX BJIa4eHIIih 14 (BO BCHKOM CJIyqae, HaM He y"JIOcb oTblcKaTb 60JIee llO3111Hx aKTOB IIa aTH BJIaneHMH, Ko-

Topble 6blJIII 6bl To>Ke nonTBep>K4eHbl BacIIJIHeM II IIepe"blBaJIⅡ瓜eiicTBHe nO4TBep>KJEHHblx PaHHIIx rpaMOT) ｣IoATBep皿,B He3HaIIKTeJIbHOe IIIIcJIO TaKHx皿enpblx岬MyHIITeTHblX叩aMoT, BacHJIHii lll, no-BHJJIMoMy, B KaKoih-To Mepe
oTcTynHJI, xOTH noKa eme MaJIo 3aMeTHO, OT HeyK､noHHoro

nPO|BeXeHHHO叩aHH[IIITeJIbllblxnPmlUlmOBHBa'Hall1.
nep exo八H HellOCPencTBeHHo K Pa360Py >KaJIOBaHHblx
rpaMoT Ba|cIIJIHH III, Heo6xoJJMo yKa3aTb, [ITo np cepemI-

Hbll511r.npaIBHTeJIbcTBo叩e3B¥qaiHoCTPorOnPllJSP>KM-

BaJIOICbnPHHUIIIHOBHMMyHIITeTHO力ⅡOJIIITHKII,BblPaOoTaHHblx B HoCJIetmHHe l5 JIeT KHFDKeH" HBaHa lll. OCo6eHHo
KacaJIocb 3To 'nonaTHoro IIMMyHIITeTa. B BeⅡHKoKHH砥ecKHe

rpaMoTbll505-cepeⅡHHbll511rr.,3apeX'laii皿HMHHcKJIIotlbHHHMII,HenoMeUaJIIIcbcTaTbH,｡HKcIiPOBaBmHeCBo6OAy

(PeOnaJIbHbIX
BJIaAeHKii
OT
nO,maTe曲ⅡnomJIHH.
Cpe皿rp
aMoT3ToroBPeMeHIIHeTHI'IO八HOMTapXaHHOiil5HJIIIO6eJIbHO曲rP aMOTbl.

npaBHTeJIbcTBo BacmJIMIH III npoXoJI""o orpaHMIIeHIle
JIbrof MIITPonoJIH[Ibero ppMa. B anpeJIe l506 r. 6blJIa gbl4a-

Ha Hecy"IMaH II 3anoBe4HaH rpaMoTa MHTponoJIIITy CIIMo13 TaM ]Ke, T. I, Nb 304 (cp. TaM )Ke, JYh 568) . MeHee yBepeHHo. XEI4HaBJIIIBaeTcFIcooTHomeHIfeMe)KnlycJIeXyIo皿HMIIrpaMoTaMH:ACS1'1,
f l, Nb 246, 247 (paHHme) !I 327̅ (no3"Hali̲JMb̲g09, 31qLEaHHmgl "
414,' 417 (nb3"m6); JVh 318 (paHH") m mB, noron. 1905, n 5757 06., JYb 33 (Ho3"") .

14 ACSM, T. I, JYi 332, 388, 412, 455, 491-491a, 492; T・II, Nb 366.
15 M.H・CMIIpHoB IIopl l506 r. ynoMIIHagT HeH3BecTHylo HaM<TaPXaHHIIKoJIIHyIO:p
HyIO》
rPaMoTy
rPaMoTy HIIKOGIIIJCKoMy llePeCJIaBcKOMy MOHacTblPIO
(M. H. C M II p H o B. yKa3aTeJIb pyKOnIIcHbIx II Ij3"HIipIx ̲49Ky"eHToB

nepecJIaBcKorb KpafI. nepecJIaBJIL-3aJIeccKI1ii, 19244.JVh 90) . O,IHaKo
TePMIIHoJIorlim M.̅ H. CMIipHoBa nloBepHTb He"b3fI. HeQI瓜HMyIOII3aHOBe"yIorpaMoTyCHMoHOByMoHacTblploHaceJ1皿o BJ1ynloBo (Xn,
I, JYb 50) oH BcJIeX 3a C. A.皿yMaKOBblM Ta,K>Ke Ha3blBaeT <<TaPxaHHOii> (M,Ⅲ. CMHpHoB. yKa3. coII., Nb 95).
244

Hy Ha CeJIaH且epeBHI1 KocTpoMcKoro ye3" 16. Conep>KaHIIe
ee coBnanaeT co cTaTbHMII rpaMoT, Bbl,maHHblx B l504 r.
BMecTe c TeM cTapble )KaJIoBaHHble rpaMoTbl Ha

MHTpono-

JIIItIbH BJIaneHIIH KocTpoMcKoro ye3ma 3aKJIIoqaJIH B ce6e
Be,cbMa mHpoKHe JIbroThl. TaK, JIHKyp>K,cKHe XepeBHII, ynoMHHyTble B rpaMoTe l506 r., 6blJIH ocBo'60>KneHbl BeJIHKoKH|H>KecKoii rpaMoToii l474 r. oT J(aHII, HMa, nonJBo,nlbl, MblTa,

T aMirHH四pyrlIx no皿ⅡⅢ,H 17. B cneUliaJIbHoii rpa'MoTe c nPoIIeToM l464-1473 1T・HBaH III Tpe60BaJI oT MecTIHblx BJIa:cTeii, LITo6bl oHH He HapymaJIIII erO >KaJIOBaHHyIO rPa|MOTy Ha

MHTpoinoJIIIIIbe ceJIo KyJIII|KoBcKoe KocTpoMcKoro ye3na
(oTMe[IeHIHoe H B rpaMoTe l506 r) . MKa'3HaH rpaMoTa 6blJIa
、

anpe,CoIBaHa He ToJIbKO HaMelcTHIIIKaM

II

HX TIIyHaM,

HO PI

U

JIBoPcKHM, Bena:BmHM

pacKJIanKOH rOCy八aPCTBGIIIHblx HaJIO-

rOB 18．3Ha'IHT, >KaJIoIBaHHaH 'rpaMoTa co,mep>KaJIa HapH,my
c cyAe6HbIMII HonaTHble nplIBHJIerlIH・
npaBIITeJILcTIBo BacHJIIIH, III HaIcToiiqHBo npoBoIHJIo

orpalHII:qeHHe H MoHacTbllp:cKoro IIMMIyHHTeTa. Ha,npIIMep, B
1 507 r. 6blJIa BblnaHa Hecyn|IfMo-BalnoBeXHaH rpaMoTa CHMoHoIBy MoHalcTbl|plo Ha ceJIa Kopo60Bo, JIHT｡BH.HoBcKoe II

OKyJIoB'cKoe MocKoBIcKoFo ye3Xa l9. noJIHblh ⅡOnaTHOii H
Cyne6Ho-aJMIIHIICTPaTHBHblii lIMMyHIITeT CeJI JIHTBIIHOBCKOro H OKyJIoBcKoI､o 6blJI 3aKpenJIeH eme B rpaMoTe BacImHH TeMHoro oT 28 MapTa l447 r. 20 MoHacTbIpb ocBo60狐ユaJIICH B Hei OT ,maHH, FIIMa, MblTa, TaiMrH H Boo6皿e OT
BcH,KHx nOmJIIIHH,ⅡeJI. HaMe|cTHH,KII H IIx are.HThl He nPJI)K-

HIJI 6blJIH CynHTb MoHacTblPcKIIx KPecTbHH《HII B IIeM>. B3aMeH Bcex JIb'I℃T M'OIIalCTblPb O6H3bl'BaJIIcH K ynJIaTe B BeJIHKoKHFI>KecKylo Ka3Hy Be'cbMa He3HaIIIITeJIbHoTo oi6poKa Ⅱo noJITHHe B ron21. BacIIJIH曲III He no瓜ⅡHcaJI rPaMOTy
l447 r. Ha |cIBoe HMH, H oIHa, TaKIIM o6pa30M, noTepHJIa 3IHaIIe,HIIe neiiICTBylOmero lop珊旦HIIecKoro aKTa. HoBafl rpaMoTa
1507 r・ycTaHalBJIIIBaJIa ro'Pa310 60JIee y3KHit KPyr MOHaCTblpcKIIx nplI|BHJIeTIIit. B Hei 6blJI coIBepmeHHo o60"eH Bonpoc o ,noniaTHblx JIbToTax. TeM caMblM HaceJIeH,IIe MoHa:cｏ６
ｌ
・
ｑＩ
ｌ８

A3HX, [1．1, JYb 262.

︒ヘ

TaM >Ke, M 255.
rHM, CIIM. KH. 58, Ho MocKBe M 41,皿虹. 188-190.
ACSH, T. 11, Nb 349.

勺リ
１
︽
⑨
Ｕ
坐
⑥ｑ
凸１

TaM ]Ke･Nb 251.

h

，

STa rPaMOTa cOXPaHIIJIa CBOIO CIIJIy ll IIPH HBaHe lll, KoTOPbTii nOXTBePm'1JI ee neJIIIKoM, 38 HCKJIIoIIeHIIeM
BCJIGJI
HIiqeM,
0nPOIIb
naI･II".
245

cTaTEII

O XaHII:

<<PymlITH

He

TblpcKHx BOTIIIIH nPlIHy>KnaJIOCb

K ynJIaTe

naHH,

fIMCKHX

neHerH瓜PyrIIx rOlcynapcTBeHHblx HaJIOr|OIB. nPe>Knle nOJI-

Hbli ,CyXe6Hblii HMMyHIITeT OrPaHINHIBaJIc月nyTeM I13bHTIIH
H3 BOTqHHHO# IOPHCXHK|ⅡH|H JeJI, KacaBmHX,C月瓜ymeiry6 cTB a
Ii Pa360H C HoJIHIIHblM, CyⅡⅡO KOTOPblM nePenaBaJICFI B
DViKH
坐

HaMecTHIIKoB，

ご

qHCJIo nPHMePoIB HoRO6HOrO cOKPameHIIH HMMyHHTeTI-lblx nPaIB巾eOnaJIOB MO>KIHO 6blJIO 6bl yBeJIHIIIITb 22.

TaKHM o6Pa3'oM, ycHJTeHHaH pa3naqa叩aMoT IB 1 5061 507rr. HIBJIHJIaCb JI,Hmb 'BII1HMocTbloⅡo>KaJIo'BaʻHHH HoBblx

nplIBIIJTerm瓜yxoBHblM KopnopamlHM. Ha caMoM八eJIe 3TO
MePOnPHH|THe nPe>Kne Bcero

nPeCJIenOBaJIo

UeJIb

CoKPa皿e-

HHH cTapbIx npeporaTHB ｡eonaJIoB BeJIIIKoKHfDKecKoe npa･
BHTeJIbCTBO

nPeKPaTHJIO

Bblnaqy TaPxa,HHbl,x

rPaMOT He

ToJIbKo cIBeTcKHM '3eMJIeBJIaneJIbUaM 23, Ho H - B o6meM
nOPfmKe - MoHa'cTblIPHM H n<ePlQBH. nlPOMe>KyTO|K c KoHna
1505 10 cepenHHbl l51 1 rr. 6blJI BpeMeHeM HalI60Jlee nocJIeZoBaTeJIbHoji 60pb|6bI npa'BHTeJIbcTIBa BacHJIHFI III 3a o|rpaI-IHqeHIIe nonaTHo'r|o HMIMyHIITeTa. B sToT neplIonl B >KaJIoBaHHble rPaMoTbl

coBepmeHHO

He BKJIIOqaJIHcb

cTaTbII, ｣KO-

TOPble OCBo60>KnaJIH 6bl HaCeJIeHHe lMMMyHIITeTHblx BoTIIIIH
oT KPyim-Iblx II

MeJIKHx

HaJIorOB,

TaMO>KeHHblx

HomJIHH

H

U

n O I B H H ; H O C Te H ･

HcKJIIOIIeHHe cOcTaBJIHeT TOJIbKO o6POIIHafl rPaMoTa,
HoJIyIIeHHaH B l507 r. Ka皿IPCKHM BeJIoneCoUKIIM MOHaC-

TblpeM・OHa npeXocTaBJIHJIa MoHa'cTblpcKHM JIIoXflM npa'Bo
He nJIaT,HTb naHb, 'ndBoPoTHoe H X,pyrIIe nOmJIIIHbI nPH yc-

JIOBIM BHeCeHHH 'B Ka3|Hy MenIBfIHOrO O6pOKa 24. 3Ta npHBIIJIerHFI o6'bFIc'HHeTcFI pHIoM 叩e3BblrlaihHblx o6cToHTeJIb､cT,p.

B a;cHJIﾙIIO III 6blJIo Heo6xO"IMO 3aPyII'HTbcFI ,nOⅡⅡep>KKoM
BeJIone,conKoro Mo'HacTblpFI, TaK KaK 'B 1506 r. pa3ropeJIacb
⑪

oTKphlTaFI

BoHHa

Me>Kmy

BeJIIIKoKH"KecKHM

npaBIITeJIbcT-

BoM II Ka3aH|cKHM UapeM MyxaMMen-3MIIHoM, cIo3epe|HoM
BeJIGnecoIIKoTo MoHacTblPfl. BeJIOneCOUK" MOHa|cTbl'Pb Mor
22 CIIMoHoBy MoHacTbIpIo 6blJIa BblmaHa B l507 r. rpaMoTa Ha 6eJIo3ep-

cKIIe BoTIIHHbl (UrAHA, rKS no BeJIo3epcKy, JYb 51/752), aHa,Ⅱor晒一
Hag rpaMoTe l507 r. Ha MocKoBcKHe ceJIa. no npe>KHeii rpaMoTe (KHH3H MIIxawIa AHnpeeBIIIIa

BeJo3epcKoro

l485 r.)

6eJIo3epcKHe

BJIaUe-

H", yKa3aHIIble B rpaMoTe l507 r., ocBo60)KmaJIIIcb oT MbITa, TaMrH,
〆

a

⑪

cyneOHblH

HMMyHHTeT

nPeXOcTaBJIFIJIcJI

MOHaCTbIPlO

<BO

BCeM"

(AC3H, T・II, Nb 397).

23 C. B. B e c e JI o B c K II ji. eona.TbHoe 3GM&neBJIaneHIIe B CeBepo-Bo･
cToqHoii PyCIi. M.- J1．, 1947, cTp. 138.

24 Arp, T. I, cTp. 97-98 (Xn, I, Nb 44).
246

nocJIy>KHTb onopHblM nyHKToM IJIH MyxaMMen-3MIIHa, IITo
BbI3bl,BaJIo cepbe,3,Hble oinaceHIM y BacIIJIHH III. MyxaMMeﾕー
3MIIH BJIaneJI KamH|poih c l497 r., Ho|cJIe H3rHaIH'IIH ero H3

Ka3aHII. B 1498 r・OH BblnaJI OqeHb皿eXPylO TaPxaH,Ho-HecynHMylo rpaMoTy KamlIpcKoMy BeJIonecoUKoMy MoHacThlplo. 3Ta rpaMoTa H onpeneJIHJIa oTHomeHHH Me>Kny MyxaMMeX-3MHHoM II MOHacTbl｣PeM, KoTOPblii 6blJI IIOCTaBJIeH, TaKIIM O6Pa30M, B BacCaJIbHylo 3a'BHIcIIMO!CTb OT 6blIBmero Ka-

3a|HIcKoro UapH 25. B l502 r. I/iBa'H III BepHyJI Ka3aHcKHii
npe,cToJI MyxaMMem-3MIIHy, Ho B 1505 r．ⅡocJ1elHIIih OTKPblTo BbI'cTynHJI ,n'poTIHB cBoero naTpoHa. BoiiHa npHHHJIa oco6eHHo onacHbliⅡJIFI PyCCKOrO rOcynaPcTBa o60POT B

l506 r. BoeBoJLI Ba,cHJIIIH III Bo rJIaiBe c yneJIbHIJIM yrJIIIUKIIM KHH3eM UMHTplleM HBaHoBHqeM >KIIJIKo曲ⅡOTepineJI H
noPa>KeHIie oT BO曲cKa MyxaMMen-3MHHa 26. BblnaLIa Bacll̲
JIHeM III >KaJIoIBaHiHoii rPaMOTbl BeJIoinecOUKOMy MoHalcTblpIo B ｡eBpaJIe l507 r. cocToHJIacb lB o[IeHE cJIo)KHoi o6cTaHOBKe,

KOrna

e皿e He

6blJI

oKoHIIaTeJIbHo

VperVJIHDoBaH

KoH*JIHIKT c MyxaMMen-aMHHoM ('neperoBopbl o nepeMIIpHIi
HaqaJIHIcb ToJIbKo B MapTe

l507 r.)27．3aKDenJIeHI1e 3a Be-

ʻ

』

JIHKoKHH)KecKIIM npaBHTeJIDcTBoM KamlIpbl 6blJIo BajKHoM

3anaLIei Ba,cHJIHFI IⅡ．OnHaKo c'p alB,HHTeJIb'Ho c r|p aMoToih
MyxaMMan-3MHHa rpaMoTa BaIcIIJIHH III y>Ke HBJIHJIacb
巾oPMOH cOKPaUeHm nPlIBHJIer" MOHacTbl", TaK KaK

rpaMoTa MyxaMMeX-3MIIHa 6blJIa Tapxa'HHoii, a rpaMoTa
BacHJIIIH III -o6poqHoii・KpoMe ToTo, B nocJIeJHeii oTcyT一

cTBoBaJIo

ocBooo>KXeHHe oT HMa

lI

pHna

l l p Vr H x

HaJIoroB,

KoTopoe IIMeJIocb B rpaMoTe l498 r.
noCJIe"oBaTeJIbHO nPOBO且HBmeecH c 90-x roIoB XV B.
COIKPalUeHHe nO,XaTHOrO HIMMyHKTeTa
BblPa311JIO'Cb
KO B OrPaHIIIIeHII,II CTaPblX Ii 'Bblnaule LIPe3BblqaHIHO
ひ

He TOJIbCKynblX

IIOBblX rPaMOT, IIO II B HarIaTOM eme B KoHUe XV B．ⅡⅢCnOBoM onIIcallHPI 3eMeJIb. noKyMeHTbl l506-1507 rE Heo"oKpaTHo

Vn o M H H a l o T < H o B o e Ⅱ H C b M O >

Pa3JIIIqHblX

IIHCUOB:

roJIeHIIHa 28, BameHIIHa 29H 且p・nO 3TOMy nHcbMy BOT一

IIHHbl1MHOrHXルI M MVHlICTOB

OblJI m

一

O O J I O > Ke I ­ J b l

HaJIOra MH-

。

I̅IPHLIeM IvIaBHblii ynap 6blJI IIanPaB鴎melI nPOTIIB MOHaCTi,1P25 ACSH, T･I, M 618.
26 nCPJ], T. XIII, nepBaH noJIoBMHa, cTp. 2-3.
27 TaM )Ke, cTp. 5.

28 B ycTaBHoji rpaMoTe l506 1､. nepec"aBcKIIM pb160JIoBaM ynoMIIHacTcH
<<HoBoe mIcbMo> Bac. IiB. ro､mGHIIHa (AA3, T I, JVb 143, cTP. 1 14) .
29 rBJ1, AKTbl Be,IIHeBa,M I/28 (Xn 1, Nb 46).
247

CKHx nPOMblCJIOIB, COnePHHIIaBmHx C TOPrOBO-PeMeCJIeHHbl-

MH npe瓜nPIIHTilIHMHⅡo'cancKIIx JIIo4eii. O pe3yJIbTaTax oRM-

caHHH B 1492 r. nepecJIaBJIb-3aJIeccKoro ye31a pacoKa3blBaeT onlHa JKaJJOBaHIHaH rpaMoTa l538 r. CHMoHoBy
MoHacTblpIo. C l492 r. nepecmaBcKHe coJIHHble BapHHnbl MoHacTblIpH He ToH"IIcb, cToHJIII <<nycTbl> (Xo 1538 r.)30. npH雫
BeneHHb曲ⅡPHMeP XOPOmo xapaKTePII3yeT TO TH>KeJIOe nOJIO>KeHHe, B KOTOPOM oKa3aJIIIcb MoHacTblPCKHe nPoMblCJIbl

6JIaronapH orpaHIILIHTeJIbHo# noJIHTIIKe npaBHTeJIbcTB I'1BaHa lU II BacmJIIIH III. B >KaJIoBaHHoi rpaMoTe l507 r. T|poIme-CepmeBy MoHacTblpIo Ha BoTIIHHbl B raJIHuKoM ye3ne
C BaPHIIuⅡpen,nH'Cbl'BaJIO;Cb naBaTb o|6POK く3 rOny Ha rOn
no KHIiraM no HoBoMy mI'cbMy ,no BacIIJIbe,By Ba'meHIIHa> 31.
B nepBb曲Ⅱep:Hon( IIMMy'HIHTeTHoii noJIIITIIKH BacIIJIIIH III
MOHaCTblPlI

JIHmb 'B eXHHHIIHbIX

cJIyIIaHx

HOJIyIIaJIH

nPO-

MbI'cJIbl B o6poIIHoe nep>KaHHee2. O 6e306poIIHoM >Ke 'noJIb30BaHPIH HoBblMH yro,nbHMH II PeIIII 6blTb He MorJIO.

CTeneHb coKpameHIIH nPaBIITeJIbcTBoM BacIIJIHFI I I I巾HHaHcOBblx nPHBHJIerHii MOHaCTblPei BblHCHHeTcJI H3 HeKOToPblx OrPaHH[IHTeJIbHbIx nOⅡⅡHCeii. B anpeJIe l507 r. nbHK

BoJInblpb nalocoB nonTBepmIJI rpaMoTy CIIMoHoBy MoHacTblp I o , 《 O n P H I I b H M y, I I M b l Ta , H Ta M r m , Ⅲ Ⅱ y n O B m H H b l , H n o M e p -

HOBO,HnHTHa> 33. CJIenp'BaTeJIbHo, oTMeHFIJIocb ocBo60xmeHHe He ToJIbKO OT rJIaBHorO nPHMOrO HaJIOra (HMa) , Ho H OT
TaMo>KeHHblx nomJIHH. npaBHTeJIbcTBo pemHTeJIbHo noXPblBa.JIO anMHHIIcTPaTIIBHbli lIMMyHIITeT XyxoBHblx KOPnOPaⅡ城B IIacTII c60pa TaMo>KeHHblx nJIaTe>Kei, cnoco6cTByH
U

3 T I I M n a J I b H e l I m e M y Pa3BIITIIIO TOBaPH0-neHe>KHblx OTHOme-

H". BnpoIIeM, Bonpoc o JmKBHnanHHTaMO>KeHHblx nPlIBRJIe⑪

rHH cJIeXyeT PacIIJIeHIITb Ha nBa BonpoCa: BO-nePBblx, nePe-

meJI JTH B PyKHnPaBHTeJTbCTBa C60P TaMrH H MblTa B nPeneJIax ｡eo"JIbHblx ceHbOP"; BO-BTOPblx, KeM CO61IPaJIOCb
nHTHo C KPecTbHH HMMyHHTeTHHx BOT[皿H？
nePBblii BOnPOC TPynHO BblFICHHTb, HCXOnH TOJIbKO II3 CO-

neP>KaHIIH >KaJIoBaHHblx rpaMoT BacHJIHH III KoHUa l505cepe皿Hbl l51 1 rr., H60 B HIIx I-IeT巾HHaHcoBblx cTaTei.
叩

30M. I/1･CMI,IpHoB･CoJIb nepeCJIaBcKaH.一《Tpyntbl BJIa瓜HMIipCKOH
U

u

yqeHoii al)xHBHoii KoMHccIIII>, KH. XVII. BJIamMMHp, 1917, npHJI. 12,
ご

cTp.

68.

31 rBJI, AKTb] BeJIFIGBa, Nb l/28

32 <<C60pHIIK HoBroponcKoro o6mecTBa mo6IITeJIeii叩eBHocTIｲ》, BHn. 1.
HoBropoⅡ↑1908, cTI). 85.

83 AC314, T. II, JW 364, cTI)、359.
248

3anpeIIIGHIIeMoHacTEIpHM-BoTIIIIHHIIKaMB3HM"nflTHo

(Ⅱc皿皿Iirg5̅kJIeiiMeHme､
nponaBaeMblx
jiomaneii)
TecHo

cBR3aHO
C
HOJIIITIIKOil
yKPenJIeHH兜aⅡnaPaTa
HaMeCTHIILIberO
U

MFMIIMieZaBH6 nbWCOen""xm""W9皿e-

MEBeJIIIKOKHmKeCKOrO nPaBIITeJIbcTBa-K nPaBy "H"UP-

8K5r;､M"6fMEilO d rPaMoTax Bac"" III 150Zr
U

｡

1524rrno9ToMynaHHbliiBonPocMo>KHopaccMoTpeTb,EW-

ii̅gaPaMKIIneiBOrO̲gTanaIIMMyHIITeTHOinOJIMTIIKIInPaBIITeJIb6TBa BacIIJIIIH III.

JTIIKBImaImHCeHbOPmaJIbHOrOJIpaBaB3IIMaHIIHnfITHaHe
Hoc"a B6606mero xaPaKTepa. OHa 6bma ocyIIIecTBJI"a
"mb TaM, me Tpe60BaJIocb ycIIJIHTb no3ImIIII BeJIIIKoWlf
&mx HaM6cT"KbB. MEI y)Ke ynoMm"JIII Q cJIyqaH¥､9TMe"

hMj"55̅gf5" noJIoBiHe XV Bnpm BacwIHH III叩eユー

iii6aFKeoc6bpenHTHacBJIaneJIbqecKHxKpecTbHIj̲B̲122-

igiXiMI"feTHOii
BOTqIIHEI､
BeJIIIKOKHfnKcCKmMWaiW⑪

IIIIIIblIMHIIJTIIBoJIOCTe皿HBIMII)
nHTeHmIIHaMII̲6bIJIo
BnepM̅MioiEHo B MapToBcKyIo rpaMoTy l 507 rBaJIaaMcWl'ご
MoHaCTblPlO.rPaMOTanPeⅡⅡmcEIBaJIa
MoHacTblpcKIIM
KPecTbHHaM i<opeJIbcKoit Bo"ocTm H o B r o p o nt c K o r o yg̲2"
nflTHaTbKOHeiiyKOPeJIECKIIxnfITeHmHKOB,KOTOPblMmJIOC
U

U

nPOnaBHaHnofynafeJIH
nO
UeHbre
MOcKoBCKoiiB
rP3Mgr:
U

6EIi633KJIIOqeH6cneUIIaJIbHOenOcTaHOBJIeHmeHaCJIYW

yKJI6HeHIIHKPeCTbfIHOTynJIaTUnjITUa:̲IZIeI皿HKHnoJIy1IaJIHnpaBoB9HMaTbc"pymmTQJI"2anoBe4"IWⅡ兜TeHbe
⑤

""""Xpy6mei (MTpa｡) 34̲32np""W2H"
上

ゴ

M6HacTfipIo606iiPaTbnHTyo,KoToPog̲WHixQJWU̲41-

PeJIbCKOii
OrPaHIIIIIITeJIbHo力Ⅱo瓜ⅡHciI
507
1
35,
oTHocIwTocb
r.
fmmbrP"M BoTqmHaM̲p̲Be>KeUKoMB:p̲>ffj̲Wg
fo;EM6M6"oi HB3"III JJpeXH""2" ffWy"
四

U

MWm"i6jiMi m509 rBflocJIeUcTB", B 1 52",̲gl-

MOlioB MOHacTIiPb noJIyqmJI HOByIO rPaMOTy Ha Tg>r̲W-

XeHHFIIIHanepeBHIoByrJIHnKOMye3Xe,nPlIcoe瓜HHeHHOMHOCJIeCMePTHnMHTplIFI(1521r.)KTepplITopIMBe皿一
KOrO

KIIH)KeHHR．

rpaMoTe
B
caHKuHOHmPOBaJIOCb
y)Ke
.03nlaBI｣JeeC副noJIo)KelJIMMFMoHa6Tblpci<lieKpecTIJHHe6blJTmo6H3aHILII
HaTb
KOHen
<y
MOIIxⅡRTeHmIIKOB>,
naBaH
C
JIOmaⅡHmITHa
nOnOJIyneHbre36・B
1511r.npaBIITeJIEcTBoBblXaJIoaHaJIo⑪

⑪

34 PIIB. T. 11, Nb 255.

33 ACSH, T. 11, Nb 364, cTp. 3592

36 rMX ri<gTI6Be>K6uKy, Nb 45/1 149 (Xn, I: Nb 208)
249

rHIIHyIOrPaMOTyBOrOFIBJIgHcKOMyMOHacTblPlo.rPaMOTaKaCaJIaCbceJIMoHaCTblPHBBe>KelIKOM

HMocI<OBCKoM

ye3nax (cPe皿MocKOBCKIIx BJIaneHHi Ha3BaHbl CeJIa B

p9JIocTIi ̲Bope-Kop3eHeBe H B r y c " II U e, 3aBe皿aHHoH
U

HBaHOMIIIcaMOMyMJIa瓜meMyCblHy
A皿peIO)
37.BIByX

rpaMoTaxIPl5rmoc"o-BpJToKoJI3McKoMyMoIiacTbIpid
­
ia
BoTqHHblBTBepcKoM
IIP>KeBcKoMy634axMoH4cTbIpU

CKHM KPeCTbflHaM nPe且nIIcblBaJIOCb mITIIaTb KoHeir y HaMeCTHHIIbHx HJIH BoJIOcTeJIHHblx nflTeH皿HKOB. nPaBma, B
naHHOM cJIyIIae CaM aKT KJIeHMeHIIH JIOmamleii He O6JIaraJIcH

qomJImHaMH38,qTO
nOKa3bIBaeTcKopeenOJIHTIIIIecKOe,
qeM

｡IIcKaJIbHoe
Ha3Ha[IeHme
cTaTbm
o
nfiTHe.
Tpe60BaHme
kJIeiiU

MeHIIfl
JTOmane#
HaMecTHIIKIbHX
y
nHTeH皿HKOB
cOmeP>KHTcH
u

BneKa6pbcKoih"rpaMoTe5
l17rrpoHIIG-CeprHeByM6HacTblU

PIO, OTHOCFI皿eHcH K BJIaneHHflM B nePecJIaBJ1b-3aJIeccKoM

ye3me:<<AnHTHaIIryMeHy36PaTbelOB̅TexCBOHXCeJIeXHB
nePeBHHx He neP>KaTIIA xTO y HHx B Tex ceJIex m B nlePeBHHx II B IBopex, IITo y CoJIH, KyHIIT JIomanb HJIHnpOntaCT,
"H MeIIIIT, H OHH Te JIOmanli nflTHHT y HaMeCTHI1KOB II y BOJIOCTeJIeHIIJIHylⅨⅡHTeHmHKOB､一AnOMOPO皿eHHblxCBOHx
JIOmaneII He nHTIIRT・A nflTHa wM nlaBaTI1 c kVⅡⅡa nelIra MOCU

U

KoBcKaH, a c np2,naBUa XeHbra >K MocKoBcKaH), 39. nepecJIaB-

CKme BOTIIIIHb[ TPOmUKorO MOHacTbIPH 6bIJIII PaCnOjio>KeHb!

nOcOcencTBycnMHTpoBcKHMyme"OM,nOaToMyyKPenJIeHIIe
3neCb BJIacTH HaMeCTHIIKOB HMeJIo 60JIbmOe 3HaLIeHHe.

TaKHMo6pa30M,60pb6aconlIoHⅢ3CymeCTBeHHblxaXU

u

MHHIIPTPaTHBHO-｡HCKaJIbHblx npIIBIWIer" "yxoBHbIx KoPnOU

pauHH­C nPaBOM MOHaCTblPCKOrO mITIIa - B TOM MacmTa-

6e, B KaKoM oHa npoBo"JIaCb, 6blJIa HanpaBJIeHa Ha yc"e
源 H II K o ,U H M. OnHcaIIIIe MocKoBcKoTo BoroFIBJ1GHcKoro MoHacTblI)fl.
』
M., 1877, cTp. 9-1 L H3'bflTIIIo nPaBa mTHa ll3 qHcJTa MoHacTbIPcI<H'x
u
四

nPIIBwTer"I

noC"nlaJIacb CneIIMaJIbllaFI

cTaTbfl

B rPaMOTe, "HHOii

oT

IIMpHH HBaHa lV noKpoBcKoMy yrJII皿KoMy MoHacTblpIo 25 flHBa"

1534 r. Ha Eema yrJIMnKoroIIEe>Kell.Koro ye"oB (《Hpoc-

JIaBcKIg ryOePHEIime BenoMocTII'', 1855, [IacTb !Ieo巾皿Ⅲa.mbHafl, Nb 48,

cTp.
435-436)．Hec9WIGHHo,
oHa
coneP>KaJIacb
H
nPeﾕmeCTByIO皿Hx
E
rpaMoTax Ba""" 11l｣ BbnaHHblx MoHacTblpIo BcKoie noc"e hpmCoenHHeHHH K MocKBe yrJIIInKoro KHH>KecTBa.B 3ToM Hac V6e>kmaeT
耳

npHMeprpaMoTBoroHBJIGHcIfoMyMoHacTbII)Io,meorpaHMtiHTe､mbHaH
cTaTb別oTHocHTeJIbHonHTHa̲6blJIa nePeHeceHa m3 rpaMoTbl BacImHHIII
B HOCJIenyIO皿ylo majiqT)JIBalia̲ IV B UeJIHx coxPaHeHII兄cJ10>KHBme-

roc月巾opMympa (Xn, 1, JVb 448, 570; II, Nb 808).

:: fMB"､HM｡oTJ"TIla !!"aIQZ H|!4erd> (A(P3IIX, qJ1, Nh 62-63j
3939 AA3、T. 1, M I64, cTp. 133-134.

250

U

BeJIIIKOKHR>KecKOiM BJIaCTII
B PaHOHax，rⅡe
PaHOHax, rne
HHe nO31皿mHBeJIHKOKHR>KecKOH
BJIaCTHB
HMeJIHcb HaJIIIIIo FIpKo BbIpa>KeHHDIe qepTU̲̲cenapaTII3Ma.
U

gToMeponpIIHTKenbaBIITeJibcTBaBacmJIIIfIIIIHocIIJIonpQZ

rpeccMFHblii xapaKTep Ero noJIHTHrlecKafI̲pWLpoWH¥
32KPenJIeHIM ycnexOB ̲UeHTPaJIII3aUIIII PyccKOro rOcYWr
u

U

cTBa. C 3KoHoMH[IecKoii ToIIKII 3peHIIH Ba>KHocTb oTMeHbl

MMCTEI"6rOnHTHaTaK>KeHenb"e>KIITcoMHeHIIIOEcJIm

VqecTb,qToMHormeli3nepeqIIcJIeliHbIxo6beKToB､no>KaJIoBar
WIIH-'cIIMoHoBcKmeceJIa(BecbEroHcKaHⅢⅡP),TPO皿KHe
ゴ

"ecJIaBcKIie
BJIanenmfl
(Co､mb
nepecJIaBcKafI)
6bmm3Ha-

qHTeJIbHblMIITOPrOBblMI1UeHTPaMH,CTaHeTnOI-IFITHblMCMblCJI

6V"H"3neCb,BOTIIIIHHOiiBJIaCTMMoHaCTblPeiQrPaHI1qe-

Hi,e巾eOnaJIbHblx
nPHBHJIer皿Co3naBaJIo
6OJIee
6JIaronPH⑤

月THbleVcJIoBHHⅡJIHpa3BIITHHToBapHo-且eHe>KHblxoTHome"h m' cOoTBeTcTBOBaJ1O, TaKIIM o6Pa30M, !IHTePeCaM
nOcaXCKIIx JIIoXei, nPIIIleM nOcancKIIx JIIOneiI Tex roPOnOq,
妙

妙

④

U

KoTopble npencTaBJIHJIH ̲eo60i lleHTpb] yAeJI"o-IfIMecW

oⅡⅡO3H皿Ⅲ(iIanpmMep,
yrJImq,
Be)KenK,
P>KeBaHⅡp.)．STO
noKa3blBaeTCTpeMJIeHmeBeJMKOKHH>KecKorOnPaBIITeJIbCTEa
⑥

3aPyLIIITbCH
nO及瓜eP>KKOi
roPoXCKOrg̲gaCeJIeHIIH,
flBJIHBmeu

roM HeMaJIoii cmJIbit y)Ke B KoHIIe XV B
U

JTHKBHⅡauHHnpaiaMoHacTbIPCKOrOnHTHa6bIJIaOCymecTBIIMa| B cIIJIy Toro, [ITo c60p TaMo>KeHHbIx nomm"̲¥g

onpeneJIHJI
3KoHoMIIIIecKylo
BJIaCTb巾eonaJIoB
He
IICJIy>KHJT
VcJIoBmeM noJIyIIeH" peHTbl c KpecTbHH.
ゴ

CoKPameHHe p皿a Ba>KHblx ｡IIHaHcoBbIX nPePOraTIIB

KpynHbi)< nyxoBHbix m cBeTcKIIx 3eMIIeBJI""UeWI2"19

K｢"ji"ib .eOnambHOro rHeTa w BbI3BaW =9WPWP
kJI"oBoih60Pb6bIBpyccKoM
rocymapcTBeO6ercTBeKPe･
CTbHH OT CBOIIx CeHbOPOB CBHmeTeJIECTByeT mHpoKoe npoHIIKHoBeHIIe B . >KaJIOBaHHble rPaMoTbl CTaTen, nPenOcTaB⑪

9

"Bmm)t B6TqmilHIIKaM nPaBo PacnPaBb[ c <<nOnPOmaTaH-

M" 40, "cJIo KoTopbIx B Ha[laJIe XVI B., oqeBImHo, 9mmi9

Bo3pocJIo．《Bo
Bcex
pa3BHTblx
cTpaHax
KoJIHIIecTBo6PoⅡHr
U

HIIkOma He 6bIJIO TaK BeJIHKO, KaK̲ B̲̲nePBOii nOJIOB"e

XVr deKa)',- yKa3bIBaJI ･ 3HreJIbc 4WcIIJIeHlleM KIa"-

EM 6bpb66I o6EfIcHHeTcfI m nfPecTpo" cyge"m ""
"feTa.B nePllOn KHH>KeHIIH BacWW 111. nPaWeJI"2a
nOCJIenHIIXJIeTKHH>KeHHRHBaHalllHBacIIJIHHIIIHcKJIIo40 xn, 1, Nb 49, 50, 53-5a

41 K. MaPKc H ･ SHre)Ibc･CoI1., T. 7, cTp. 354
251

[IaJIIIII3CeHbOPHaJTbHO#IOPHCMKnHIIO6blIIFoXBeKaTeroP"

neJI: nymery6cTBo II pa360i 42, ocTaBJIfIH B c巾epe BOTIIIIHHO-

ro cy" TaTb6y c nOJIHqHblM BnpoqeM, j)IIKcamIH IIMMy"、
TeTa H B TaKoM o6'beMe皿fY MHorHx ｡eOXaJIOB O311aqaJIa
cy)KeHIIe cTapblX npHBwIer", II60 pa360p Bcex TFI>K6,

《onpHIIb nymery6cTBa)>, FIBJIRJIcH BmloTb no ̅HatlaJIa XVI B.
nPaBOM 3HaIIIITeJIbHOrO IIIMCJIa nyxOBHblx KOPnOPaⅡ砿HHeKoTopblx cBGTcKHx 3eMJIeBJIaneJIblleB. nocJIeXHHe noJIVⅧIJI】ィ
B H3yqaeMOe BPeMH rOPa3XO MeHbme HeCynHMblx rPaMOT,
qeM MoHacTblPH II nePKBH.

B Ka>Kn;oM KoHKpeTHoM cJTyIIae BblXaIIa >KaJIoBaHHoi
rPaMOTbl ｡eOnaJIy皿KTOBaJIaCb OnPeneJIeHHEIMII nOJIIITIIIIe-

g<IIMHcoo6pa>KeHHFIMH.noX<aJIoBaHIIeMB1507nKyp6aTy
TpeT"Ky noKIIIHKoB c cyne6HblM IIMMyHHTeToM B KJI"cKom
ye3ne 43, IIenonaJIeKy oT BoJIoKoJIAMcKa, npaBIITeJIbcTBo
ycIIJIHBaJIO cBoII Ho3HumII Ha non(cTynax K BoJIoIIKoMy yneJIy

(BToM)Kel507r.HocII｡o-BoJToKoImaMcKHiMoHacT師も6bI|fI

B3HT HO瓦ⅡaTpoHaT BacIm" IIII B I510 r. KHH3" Ko3-

JIOBcHIIeJIOJIyWiJIH3eM皿BMypoMcKoMye3Ⅱe,nPIItleMIIx
Cyn;e6Hblii IIMMyHHTeT OrPaHIIIIHBaJICH JIIImL B IIACTHⅡeJI,

KacaBmHxcH Xymery6cTBa 44. STo HcKJIIoIIHTeJIBHblih cJTVIIaii
B nPaKTIIKe IIMMyHHTeTHblX nO>KaJIOBaHHi CBeTcKIIM巾eOna-

JIaM XVI B. mllPoKIIi o6beM IIMMyHIITeTa KHH3ei K63JIoBcKIIx o6'bHCHfleTcH, BHm1Mo, Hx oco6blM IIoJIo)KeHHeM B Mv学

PPMCKOM ye3ne, CJIy)KIIBmeM aBaHHOCTOM nPOTHB cOCenHe#

Ka3aHH, oTHomeHIIH c KoTopoi 6blJIII B 1510 r. BecbMa HaⅡPH>KeHHbIMII. Boo6me>KeロpHH皿nH3'bHTIIH II3 PyK巾eOXa JToB nPaBa Cyna no XByM KaTerOP"M nPecTynJIeHIIii (myme-

ry6cTBy ll pa360Io) npoBo皿JICH HaH60JIee nOcJTenOBaTeJIbHo
B

>KaJIQBaHHbIx

rPaMOTaX

HMeHHo

CBeTcKHM

3eﾊmeBJIa-

JIeJIbna M.

42

AA9LT I, JVb l41; Arp, TJ, crp lO7; JIOHH, Co6P JTMxaqeBa,
" 102/L .w1. 3-4; J M o H HC M M Mo>kaiicKlie aKTbr Cn6", 1892;
Nbl;《ⅡPm6aBJTeHHeKB,可amHMIIpcKIIMry6epHcKIIMBenoMocTFIMHa
1844 n& Nb 3, cTU l0-ll: UrAHA, rK9 ho MypoMy, M I/7733;
《AKIL! IQgIKQBa>, Nb 67; A(b3MX, [1. 1, M 262; TBJT,.py"HII.. KH 54;
" 20=27 06.;̲AM B p̲o c n ii. HcTopmH PoccmiicKoM mebapxmm, q. 11I
M., 1811, cTp. 315­332 m np" B. B. EIIb9IneBM coBepmeimo HenpaB,

yTBeP丞瓜aH, qTo E Xyl B. "3ERTIIe Tpex nPecTymIeiIIIii cTalIoBIiT'cH

o6UmMnpaBoMillB.B.EJIb"meBIiq:HcT6p1頂nPaBanO3eMeuTIbHO#
co6cTBeHHocTII B Roccmm, T. 1 . naplix<, 1948, cTp99)". 9To Mo)KIIo cKa3aTbʻmHmI，叩o 50-e roXIbl XVI B.
Arp, T. I, ､Nb 49.

１
３
４
１

<AKT･bl JOmKoBa>, Nh 79, 80.
252

L j

2・noHBJkeHLIe noJaTHblx ocBo60丞瓜eHHM

B狂aJIoBaHHImx rPaMoTax BacH入mH III
IIIoxH 1511­ moHJI 1522 rr.
U

BTopbIM
nepmompM
IIMMymmTeTHoiWIIIITHKH
Bac""
W
6blⅡnijoMe)KyioK BpeM" c l̅I 151 L no moHb̲lW̲E

Bce60)IeeHafipHIKeiiHbliixapaKTepnpmo6peTaJIIIoTHomeH"
U

BacliJIHH III c ynteJIbHblMII KHfl3bflMH MocKoBcKoro ppMa.

OcTpo cToHJI Bonpoc o MoHacTbIpcKoM 3eMIIeWI"GW:
BHyTpeHH" noJIIIT"a PyccKoro BeJIIIKoKH"CcK9pQ

npaBIIfejibcTBa l511-1522 m B JIHTepaType̲lWgWf
U

八OcTaTo[IHo. CnenIIaJIbHblx HccJIe,n<OBal･IHH7 nOcBH皿eHHblx

"JTOEaHHblMrpaMoTaM3TorOBpeMeHII,TaK)KeHeT.BAopeBoJIIO皿()HHoiiHcTOPHOrPa｡IIHneJIoorPaHHII"OcbHeU

bKOJIbKIIMH 3aMeIIaH"MH no HOBOny OT,meJIbHblx )Kall9"H-

M.̅fPimbT̅il3!mcJIaBeJIMKoKH"eCKliXaKTOB̲̲M=
U

l522 rr,45 B coBeTcKoii IIcTopHIIecKoii JIIITepaType rpaMoTbl
BacIIJIHH III HaIIIIHaR c ,l515 r. npmBJIeK K MPcJIenpBaHI1Io
U

j

H. E. HocoB. O皿aKO B MOHOrPa巾皿H、E. HocoBa, B coOTBeTCTBHH C ee 3anatlaMm, aHaJII13HPylOTCH naHHble )KaJIO-

BaHHblx H VKa3Hblx rpaMoT ToJIbKo Jo. 04HoMy Bonpocy

I,opoIoBblx x
TIpIIKa3[IHKoB)
.no3ToMX"Top
pa30(申yHK皿Hropo瓜oBbI
npHKa3[ImKoB)．no3T
oMyaBTopPa306paJIJIII皿b,6TneJIbHbIe̅aKTb!nepBoiiTpeTmXVIB"ocBeU

皿alo皿HeerOTeMy46.
KaK v)Ke oTMeIIaJIocb, B BeJIHKoKHfDKecKIIx rpaMoTax np

cepenJIIIbll511r.coBep皿eHHoOTCyTcTBOBaJIHcTaTbH,Pery-

JIIWommenonaTHoecr6JIojKeHIleHMMyHIIcToBKToMIx,

MHorlIerpaMoTblnPe瓜meCTBylO皿IIxnpaBIITe､mbCTB,noCBH-

皿"bieiaHHoMyB6npocy,yfpaTMJIZizBQlocIIJIy,He6yny[IH
no瓜nmcaHilbIMK ila m" ̅BacmJIHH IIL STo, no-BMIIMoMX,
｡

CnoCO6CTBOBaJIoHaPymeHIIIOMecTHblMIIBJIacTHMHOcHOBHoH

npHBEJIerHH巾eOnaJIoB-H
M
MyHII
CTOB-npHBMJIerIIH皿aTHTb
no,n､aTII
<<oco6Ho>>
oT
IIepHblx
JIIonleii・Bo3MoI>KHo,
IIMMyHIIcTbl
45m．ⅢJ<y3HeUoB,
HanpmMep,
npoKqMMeHTIIpoBam
rpaM9Ty̲
12"19jIOKoJIaMEKOMy
BOcKP6CeHckOMy
cO60Py,.
n2aBIIJIbHO
CBggaB
ge
M93ME･
HHec､JMKB皿'am,eii̅BoJ'o"oroy4e@JIa(<且peBHocTH.TpynlblMoCKq2-

cKoroapxeoJIoI､IIIIecKol､oo6皿ecTBa>,T・XXII,Bbl|n.11.M.,1909,

cTp､277) , M､H. CMIIpHoB oTMeTHJI, LITo rpaMoTa BacIIJIIIH III TpoHHeC6prlieBy
CeprHeBy
MoHacTblplo1517r．HaⅢepecJIaBcKHe
1517 r. Ha nepecJIaBcKKe coJIHHbIe
coJIHHbleBapHmmU
BapHHⅡbl̲C9coユ MoHacTbIpIo

Kpa皿aJIaCraPb,eMoHaCTblPCKmenPIIBMJrrmli,WnleP)KaBmmecHBJIPe¥Z

HiIXrPaMOTaX
u (M，Ⅲ.C̅M H p H o B.CoJIbnepecJI""":­くTpymbl
BJIa1HMmpcKoii jweHoii apxIIBfioii KoMliccMI", KH XVII. BIIa"MIIp,
U

1917) .

46 H E H o c o B OqepKm no mcToll,ll! MeQTllorqynp"jIeHmH EYccKoro
rOCy4dPCTBa rlePBOhⅡoJIoBII1Ibl XVI B. M.­几, 1957, cTp. 76 H mp､
253

He Pa3 06pa皿aJIIIcb c IIeJIO6IITHblMII K BeJIIIKOMV KHH3IO. nO
u

⑪

-

KpaIIHei̲liepe, c IIIoJIH l51 1 r. B >Ka"oBaHHblx rPaMoTax Ba-

CH川畑IIIHallmHaloTnOHBJIHTbCHCTaTbli,BKbTOPbIxcneuHa.ﾉIbHOorOBaPHBaeTcH
Heno4Be40McTBeHHOcTb
MoHaCTblPCKIIX KPeCTbFIH anMHIIIIcTPanHH 'IePHblx BoJIOcTeH: cOTcKHM
u

HneCJITcKHM3anPe皿aJIoCbnPHTHrHBaTbMoHaCTblPcKIIxKPe2TbHH BO BCHKIIe nPOTOPbl H Pa3MeTbl C THTJIblMH JIIO4bMH 47.

3To
3anpemeHme
IIMeJIO
BaxfHoe
3HaqeHme,
oco6eHH6
B
TeX
cJIyIIaHx, KOrna MOHaCTblPb nPHO6PeTaJI IBoPUOBble lIJIII IIePHble 3eMJIH, HaJIorH c KoTopblx mJIH B BeJIIIKoKHH>KecKVIo Ka3-

Hy<II3cTaPlI》・noKa3aTeJIeHcJIemylomHHnpHMep.Bl520r.
⑪

6blJIa
BbuaHa
HeCy旦HMaH叩aMoTa
TpoHme-CeprlieBy
MoHau

cTblpIo Ha nepeBHm B Kop3eHeBcKoii BoJIocTII, BBIMeHEHHble v

leJIIIKorOKHH3fl48.rpaMOTaHecOneP)KaJIaHⅢ巾OPMyJ,bI6
｡

mpqTopax H pa3MeTax, HII KaKoit-JIH60 cTaTbH, ocBo60>KnaB-

meHOT
meii
OTn9mJIIIIL
nOmJIHH．、O3T
nO3ToMy
oMyCK
CKOP3eHeBCKHx
OP3eHeBCKHx且epeBeHbnPO瓜0冊
nepeBeHbnPOXO
jKaJIIlco6mpaTbcHBKa3HyTyKoBbleneHbrli..nepecKj3LIBaH
IIeJIo6HTHyloTpoImKoroIIryMeHa
A"ﾉIeKCaHXPa,
COCTaBHTeJTb
[

p

>KaJIoBaHHoii rpaMoTbI l529 r. oTMeIIaeT:《…Hc Tex nePeBeHb
KOP3eHeBcKIIx IKMaJIII Ha MeHH TyKOBble nleHbrli. I'i HblHqe,
ne, c Tex Hx c MOHacTblPcKHX nePeBeHb C KOP3eHeBcKHX nO

ToMy >K eMJIIOT Ha MeHfI TyKOBble neHbrH》49. TaKHM o6Pa30M,巾oPMyJIa o nPOTOPaX, He OcBO60>KnlaH OT rJIaBHblX rOcylaPcTBeHHblx HaJIOrOB, naBaJIa Bo3MO>KHO'CTb H36aBHTbCH
oT BTOPocTeneHHblx nBOPUOBO-KHH>KeCKIIx II 3eMCKHX HOBHHU

HocTem, 4 TaK>Ke
HoCTeH，a
TaK1KeoT
oT O6皿eH
o6mem PaCKJIa瓜K}I
pacKJIanKM THrJ1a
TFIrJIa c wePHbIMH
qepHbIMH
妙

JIIonbMII.
OrpaHHqHBaR巾eOXaJIbHblH
HMMyHHTeT,
npaBHTeJIbCTB9̲6bIJ1O
BbIHy>KneHO
BMeCTe
C
TeM
yKP6nJIHT6
erb
OCHOBbl.
u

HHTePecbl naJIbHeimero ycHJIeHHi io3Hnmi BeJIHKOKHHU

U

>KecKOH BJIacTH Ha nPHcOe,Ⅱ{IIHeHHblx TePPHToPliflx H Ha nO4cTynax

K eme nPonOJI>KaBmHMCymecTBoBaTb

VneJIaM
ご

Bbl-

Hy)KnaJIHⅡPaBHTeJ1bCTBO HITH Ha ycTyHKH HeKOTOPblM
BJIHHTeJIbHblM myxoBHblM KopnopaUHHM. B xone 60pb6bI 3a
COXPaHeIille B PyKaX MOCKOBCKOrO rOCynlapH JIIIKBMHPOBaH-

ダ

Horo B 151 1 r. Be)KenKoro yneJIbHoro kHfl>KecTBa B "Ka6pe
3Toro rona noHBHJIacb rpaMoTa MocKoBcKoMv BoroHBJIeH-

47 CM,̲lJ#np!IMEp: UrA", [K3 1Ip Cy3naJIIo, JYb 9/1 1788; rBJI, Tp.

KH, 528, Nb 200, ""、"5-286; H. A. B a x p a M ee B. HcTopmqecKIie
3KIpI̲2pogJapoKorQ CnaccKoro MoHacTbmp"; T. 1．M., 1896, Nb lV;

HTMAarII9 Jo MajPM)LHPocmaBUy, M 6/7696, .no Kobfp6M6

Jyb.32/4999; AA3, T. I, Nb l64 m.np.

48 AAS, T. I, Nb 166.

49 AII, T, I, JWb 132, cTp. 193.
254

CKoMV MoHacTblpIo, oTHocHBmaJIcH K MoHacTbIpcKoMy Cely
プ

JIo3btBy,
KoTopde
6bIJIo
pacnomo>KeHo
B
Be>KeUKoM
Bepxe
50.
リ

Hap皿yc印opMyJIoHoⅡpoTopaxHpa3MeTaxrpaMoTacoⅡep、
⑪

>KaJIa cTaTbH, oTMeHHBmⅡe PHI KoHKpeTHblx nOBMHHocTeII:
O6H3aHHOCTb cTaBIITb BeJII'IKOKHH>KeCKHH瓜BOP, KocIITb CeHO,
KOPMHTb KOHeII BeJIHKOrO KHH3H.
U

｡

STa
｡oPMa
CPaBHIITeJIbHo皿IIPOKOrO
nO>KaJIOBaHMH
6bIJIa
o6ycJIoBJIeHa Heo6xo"IMocTblo ycIIJIHTb BJIIIHHIie KpynHoro
MocKoBcKOrO MOHacTblPH-BoTIIIIHHHKa B HenaBHO nPHCOenlI-

HeHHoM Be)KeUKoM ynteJIe. Bonpoc o 3aKpenJIeHIIM Be>KeUKa
B IIHcJIe BeJIHKoKHFDKecKIIx TeppIITopHii npHo6peJI 60JIbmylo
u

OcTpOTy BcJIencTBIie TOro, IITO HO COcenlcTBy Haxo且HJIOCb
yrJIIIUKoe KHH)KecTBO, npeTeH八OBaB皿ee Ha BKJIIOIIeHHe B HerO

Be>KenKOrOyXeJIa51.
10 JIeT cnyCTH, CPa3y noCJIe cMePTII yrJII皿KOTO KHH3H

nMIITpHHIIBaHoBHqa( 1 52 1E) ,Ha6JIIonaeTcHycHJIeHHaH
BblnaIIa

)KaJIoBaHHblx

rPaMOT Ha

MOIIacTblPCKIie BJIaZIeHIIH

B paiioHe yrJIHIIa lI 3y6UoBa, Bxo皿1BmHx B cOCTaB yrJIHIIU

Koro vneJI a、3TO 6blJIa Ta >Ke nonblTKa nPaBHTeJIbCTBa yKPemITb CBOIO BJIaCTb nOcPeXCTBOM yTBep)KXeHwI̲ BeJIHKoKHWKeU

CKOTo CIo3ePeHHTeTa Hanl BoTIIIIHaMH MOHaCTblpeH B nPeleJIax

JIHKBI皿HpObaHHoTo KHH>KecTBa. B "HHoM cJIyIL4e BacIIJIwI III MOrJIO 6eCnOKOHTb 6JIH3Koe cOcenCTBO C yrJIHIIKHM

ye310M TePPlITOP皿叩yroro - KamHHcKo-nMIITpQEcKoro
U

"eJia,KoT6PbIMjnpaBJImiaHepIIIIIHbliiKHH3blOpmiilIBaHo"II, II cocencTBo c 3y6noBoM CTapHnKOrO ye3na, me nPaBIITeJIbCTBO OKa3aJIOcb BblHy>KneHHblM BoccTaHOBHTb B nPa-

Bax yneJIbHoro KHH3fl A"peH HBaHoBH[Ia. OTHomeWIe
BeJIHIiOroKHII3HKIIMMyHIITeTyMOHacTblPcKmxBOTqlIHByrJIImKoM II 3y6noBcKoM ye3nax cooTBeTcTBoBaJIo HeKoTopblM
“

MepOnPHHTHHM nPaBIITeJIbCTBa no HaneJIeHHIO,ⅡlyXOBHblX KOP-

nopanHii
3eMJIHMII
npHCoe瓜HHeHHOM
B
KHH)KecTBe・O6blIIHo
U

U

IIPe3BblqahHOCneP>KallHOe HanO>KaJIOBaHHe BOTIIHHMOHaCTblpHM II IlepKBII, PyCcKOe qPa"TeJIbCTBo PaCmHPHJIo! 3e-

MeJIEHvIo
“ 6a3V B yrJIImKoM II 3y6uoBcKoM ye3nax HeKoTopblx

6JIII3KiIXKB6JIHKoMyKHH3IoMoHacTbipeii(Hoc"o-BoJIoKoJIaMcKoro, IIyXoBa, KaccHaHo-yIIeMcKoroH叩.).
50 HIIKoXHM・yKa3. COII., CTp、9-11.

51 He C､mV'IaAHo VrJII皿KIMii KHFI3b nMHTPH曲I'IBaHoBH'I BblJall B 1510 II

1511rf.rpaM6Tbl,nocBH皿eHHble"KCaUMIIIIMMyHHTeTa*eoJaJIbHOro
3eMJIeBJTaneHHH B I,OPonCKOM CTaHe̲yrjIMHKorO y"", PacnOJIO>KeHHgM

p皿oMc Be>KeUKHM : ye3"M(C.m y M a K o B.yrJIIiucKHeaKTb1.M ,
1899, Nb 111, 1V).
255

B 1522 r. BacHJIM III <<1aJI no 6paTe no cBoeM Do KHH3e
UMHTpee HBaHoBIIIIe>' ceJIo ･aycToBy

ropy

3y6UoBcKoro

ye3,na HocII｡o-BoJIoKoJIaMcKoMy MoHacTblpIo 52．KaccIiaHoyqeMcK" MoHacTblPb noJIy[IIiJI oT BacHJIIIH III B l522 r.《Ⅱo
KHH3e nMIITpee lIBaHoBIIIIe)" 14 nlepeBeHb, 8 noIIHHKoBHnyCTO皿b B rOPOnlcKOM CTaHe yrJIHnKorO ye3na 53．OHII 6bl!JIIi
〜

̅

ocBoOO>KXeHbl OT OOH3aHHOCTH KOCHTb ceHo, KOPMHTb KHH>Ke卿

CKOrO KOHH H八aBaTb JIIO4eH nJIFI yIIaCTHH B KHH>KeCKHx OXO-

Tax. no八O6Hylo IKe rpaMOTy nPaBHTeJIbcTBo Bbl八aJIo B 1522 r.

MocKoBcKoMy llynIoBy MoHacTblplo Ha BJIaXeHI1H B 3y6UoBcKoM ye3ne 54. B 60JIee no3JIHeii rpaMoTe CHMoHoBy MoHacTbIplo (1524 r.) Ha BJIaneHHH B yrJI皿KOM II Be>KeUKOM

ye3八axcoXep]Ka!ﾉ1II'CbaHaJIOrHqHblenOCTaHOBJIeHHH55.npli
cOCTaBJIeHHII

BCex

Ha3BaHHblx

rpaMOT
A

6blJI

HCHOJIb30BaH

｡opMyJIHp rpaMoTbl l51 1 r. BoroHBJIeHcKoMy MoHacTblplo.
B 1523 r・nOKPOBCK" yrJIIiUKHii MOHaCTblPb nOJIy[IHJI
JIbroTHylo rpaMoTy Ha ceJIo ApxaHreJIbcKoe, ocBo60>K,meHHoe
Ha TPH rOAa OT HaMeCTHHIIblix KOPMOB, nPOTOpOB H Pa3Me-

ToB 56, a BoTIIHHbl KpacHo-XoJIMcKoro MoHacTblpH B Be)KeUKOM ye3ne 6blJIH, BHpHMO, 6ecCPOIIHO OCBO60)KnieHbl OT ocHOB'
Hblx Ho6opoB 57. rpaMoTbl l521-1524 rr., oIIIoc兄山HecH K
yrJIImKIIM BJIaneHHHM MoHacTblpei yrJIImKoro noKpoBcKo-

ro 58, TpoHⅡe-CeprHeBa 59, KaccHaHo-yIIeMcKoro 60 H CIiMo-

52 A･3MX, u. 11, Nb 87, cTp. 83.
53 AAS, T. 1, JYh 171.
54 nPn, Bbln. 1V, CTp. 1 18.

56 Xn, I, Nb 208. B l521 - 1522 rr. )KaJ1oBaHHIJIe rpaMoTbl Ha 3GMJ1H
B paiioHe yrJIHIIa H Be>KeUKa noJIyIIIIJIH TaK)Ke MoHacTblplI KHplIJIJIoBeJIo3epcKMi (rnB, Co6p. aKToB H rpaMoT, NQ 1-89, 1-90; TaM )Ke,
Co6p. Cn6．Ⅱ/A,
A II/47,
"J1.322-325;
AI/17,
"J1. 455-456;

JIOHII, *. 11, Np 112, cT6. 168-173), Tpo皿e-CeprHeB (Xn, 1, Nh 174,
182), yrJI皿KHii nOKPOBCKHii (TPH rPaMoTbl - 3anOBe皿yIo, 06e.JIbHo-

HeCy皿MyIo H naHHylo - UrAHA, *. Ka皿eJIHpHII CeHaTa, KH. 192,
n. 251-251 06.), yrJ'皿K城A巾OHaCbeBCK"

(,nBe叩aMoTbl-Hecy皿一

MyIo II JaHHyIo - UrAJA, *. KaHneJIHpHH CeHaTa, KH. 192, JIJ1. 258259 06.).

56 <<HpocJIaBcKIie ry6epHcKIIe BenpMocT", 1855, IIacTb Heo巾皿HaJIbH”，
JYb 47, cTp. 426; cp・Url4A, *. 834, on. 3, M 1916, n. 38 06.
5？A，K，〉KH3HeBcKHii．且peBH噸apx” KpacHo-XoJIMcKoro HHKo,JTaeBcKoro AHToHbeBa MoHacTbIpH.­《npeBHocTH. Tpynibl MocKoBcKoro apxeoJIormqecKoro o6mecTBa>D, T. V111.M., 1880, cTp. 61.

b8 <<HpocJIaBcKHe ry6epHcKIIe BenloMocT", 1855, qacTb HeO申皿Ⅲ”bHaR，
Nb 47, cTp. 425-426.

59 UrAHA, rK3 no Bem<eUKy, JYb 42/1 146.
60 AA3, T. I, M 171.

256

HOBa
61,
COLep>KaT
CTaTbM,
nPe八OCTaBJIHBIIIIIe
3TIIM
KOPnOPa11MHMIIcKJIIO1IMTeJIbHOenPaBOnOJIb30BaTbcHnaHHbIMWcTaBoMII3anPe皿aBmHeHeneJIb皿HKaMB'be3>KaTb
B
MOHacTblPCKHe BOTIII'IHbl.

PVccKoe npaBMTeJIbcTBo 6bIJIo pco" 3amHTepeEpBW

TaK>KG
yKPenJIeHIII1
B
CBOI'Ix
nO3HuHiI
nepecJIaBJIb-3aJIecB
cKOMye3八e,
KOTOPblII
HaxO皿JIcH
p皿OM
HMHTPOBCKIIM
C
y且eJIoM
KHfl3H
IOp皿mBaHoBIIIIa.
>KaJIoBaHHafl
rpaMoTa
ソ

U

U

i 51 7 rrpollUe-CeprlleBy MoHacTblplo Ha ero nepecJIaBcKIIe
BoTLlllilbl d2 npll6JIII>KaeTcf! no xapaKTepy ' 3aKJIIoqelIHIM p

HeiinPlIBIiJIerlIHKymHuKIIMIi3y6uoBcI(IIMrpaMoTaMKac⑪

U

CIIaHO-yIIeMCKOMy, qyXOByH叩yrl'IM MOHaCTblPHM.

'1,aK11M
O61〕a30M，113'bHTHeIB1IⅡCJIa
MOHaCTblPCKHXⅡpH-

BIIJI(JrlliinpaBanflTHarI1)e八CTaBJIHJIOCO60iiTOJIbKOOXHy

CTOPOHMMMMyHIITeTllOiinOJ1MTMKmPyCCKOrOr･CyW""

nePecjiaBcKoM,
Be>KeUKoMmyrJI!皿KoMye3nax.
Hap"yc
U

OrPaHMeHIIeMIIMMyHIITeTaBqaCTH,CBH3aHHQ" "YW-

HlitIbIIMynPaBJIeHIIeM,nPaBIITeJIbcTBo"CTPeMIIJIocb34pYWLcfImHpOKOH
rlO瓜瓜ep>KKOM
MOHacTblPen
HenaBHo
B
nPHCoe瓜ⅢHGHHblX
yneJIax
TIyTGM
ocBo60>KneHMH"MoHacTblpcKHx
BoTIIHH
U

U

OTDBOPnOBO-KHH>KeCKmxnOBI1HHOCTeH.

HecMoTpH
Ha
HeKoTopble
ycTynKⅢ瓜yxOBHbIM
(PeO"JIaM,

IIMimiTETilafI !1 3eMenbilafl rioJImTIIKa BacIIJIIIH II!̲B I512=
ゴ

i.514Jffh""bb nPOnPJDKeHIieM Ha'laTbIX nPm IIBaJe llI
U

ME""TIliinOorpAIIHLleHIIIonPmBwIermikKPynHbix*eO"u

JIOB、

l512-1513 rr・HBIIJIHcb KyJIbMIIHalIHoHHblM MQMeHToM

col"̅BacmJIMfIIIIcHecTH)KaFreJIHMII63.JIeTpM15｣lr・MH-

TPOnOJIHTOM
CTaJI
BHユHbli
nocJIenPBaTeJIb
HHJIa
CopcKoro
BapJIaaM.OLIeBPIAHo,nPHno且旦ep>KKeBapJIaaManpaBHTeJIbcTiv
ｰ BacmJIIIH I I I y"JTocb KaKIIM-To o6pa3qji npIIocTaHo仏

EIITt
POCT
MOllaCTEjPCKOrO
3eMJleBJIaneHHH
3TO
UPQ瓜ⅡOJIO｡

>KeHme Hy>KnaeTCR B TulaTeJlbHOii nPOBjaPKe n9 [laCTHbIM af

,tiM.npe皿bJ1araeMblih3anpeTMor6blTbo｡opMJIeHBHe
U

且O山e瓜皿Hx np Hac <<6aTbKoBblx ycTaBHblX KHHEax)>, o KoTo-

FEiXf6RopmJMBaHIVHaCTorJIaBoMco60per"HハHmHaile,〃
B 1512-1514 rr. pe3Ko cHH3HJIocb則HCJIO >KaJIOBaHHblx
61UrAHA!rK3HoBe>KenKy,Nb45/1149;rHM,CMM.KH58,皿几317320 .06.

62 AA3, T. 1, Nb 164.

63 ̅g6EEM"HaMellaTeJIbHo To o6cToHTeJIbcTBo, qTo B !513 r. IJp¥lireJIhr

"rnli515̅Ch"mallbHylo rpaMoTy oq ̲QXpaHe JIIIJp" CopcKoii

『WblinT kTaTe" !! <ja360iiHHKoB> (PMB, TB2, JYh 861
l7

C.M・Ka山TaHoB

257

rpaMoT Ha MoHacTblpcKI1e BoTHIIHbl. CMMnToMaTHKllio pac-、
nPocTPalleHIIe B 3TO BpeMfl py>KHIJIx rpaMOT64 (pyroii nblTaJIILcb 32MellllTb geMeJIblible m HMMyliMTeTHble 八aIIil) .

CoIo3 BacMJII1H III c BaPJIaaMoM He ̅6b皿,0八IIaKo,八oji-

roBPeMeHHblM.1I0,ﾉIKTHIIeCKannPorPaMMaHeCTflJKaTeJIe曲HaxoJJIJIaCb B Pe3KOM nPoTHBoPeqHIi c no0JIIITI1Koii BeJIIIKOKIIH-

>KeCKOABJIaCTm・BacIIJIHiilllBcBoIIx>KaJIoBaHHblxrpaMoTax
llOCJIP八OBaTeJIbHOnPOBo皿J1HPIIHUlinnO4Cy,mHoCTIiHaCTOH-

TeJIeihMOHacTblPeiili.Hx6PaTIimBOBCeX八eJIaX,KPOMe八yXOBHblX, llenOCPe八cTBeHIIo BeJII1KoMy KHH310 1i'ﾉIM ero 6oHPMHy

BBe八eHOMy・3Ta Mepa IIMeJla oIleHIJ Ba)KHoe 3Haqeume. noiL
cy"IocTb MoHaCTMPCKorO ll"aJIbcTBa BeJ1IiKoMy KHH310 yK-

pellJIHJIa BJIacTb BacmJIMH III Ha及八yxOBHblMII qJeO"JIaMII.

O八HaKo
yKa3aHHoe
nO!ﾉIO2KeHI'le
Be皿eit,
no-BH八mMOMy,
11e
ycTPaHBJjlo MIITPoHOJIHTa, CTPeMHBmerocJI K UellTPaJIIi3a"II

UePKBH.
Pe3Koc
Ox@ma班旦eHlle
OTHOmeHIIII
Me>K八y
BapJIaaMoM
II BeJIliKEM KHH3eM ToJIKaJIO HOCJIe"erO K CoIO3y C liOc"JIHHaMH, nPOnOBe40BaB皿HMH TeoPHIo cHJIbHOii MOHaPxIIIIeCKOji

BJIacTli. K aToMy BpeMeHH Moclil BoJIonK", B HpoTIIBoIIo0

JIoJKHocTb HecTwKaTeJHM M, B LIacTHocTH, BaccMally naTpﾙIKeeBy,八OKa3blBaJI Heo6xo八HMOCTb TeOKpaTIIIIeCKOII BJIaCTli
MOCKOBCKOrO

rOCy八apH,

ila3blBaH

erO《maBoIo

BcerO> b｡．

nepeMeHa noJ1MTMLlecKoii opIIeHTaUmHBeJIHKOKH”KeCKOrO
IIp aBlil､eJIbCTBa

l-le 3aMe八JIIIJlti

CKa3aTbC月Hlla

OTHO皿elll皿

erO ̲K MoHaCTbIpcKoMy HMMyHHTeTy.

B qJeBpaJIe l515 r., BcKope nocJIe JIHKB皿a皿HBoJIoUKoroy八eJIa, HocI14Jo-BoJIoKoJIaMcK" MoHacTblPb, cJIylKIiBI皿in
皿T"eJIblo Hoc"JIHHcTBa, HoJIyqHJI oT Bacli皿H III ABe
TaPxaHIIO-HeCy八HMble H 6ePe]Ke0JIbHble rPaMOTbl Ha BJIa八euM兄

B 'IBepcKoM K PJKeBcKoM ye3,ntax 66. rpaMoTLI npe,瓜ocTaBJIHJIH MOHaCTblPIO皿HPo[Ian皿me nO,maTHble H Cy八e6Hble npMBHqJIerHH: OCBO60班八eHIIe OT八aHII, HMCKHx 4eHer, nOcOmHoji

cJIy)K61JI,MblTa,TaMrH,noCoLllHorOKOpMa,pa3JIMIIHblxCTPOI'lTeJIbHblX H，Ⅱ<BOPUoBo-KH"KecKHx nOBIIHHocTeih, cy4eO1iblih

HM MyllHTeT,くonpmIIb o"loro八ymery6CTBa>. E八llHCTBeHllaH
CTaTbH7 CBH3blBaB皿afl 3Tli rPaMOTbl C npe>KHMM KyPcoM MM-

MyHIITeTHOii nO@ﾉIIiTIIKH BacIIJII1H III,- cTaTb2 0 KJIeiMeHHM
64

U!̅、

61』

X11, 1, JYu 101, 104, 120; cp. Nb 127．CcblJIKII IIa py"KllyIo lloJIIITIIK)'
Bacll川IH III IIMGIoTcH B CTorJIaBe (<<CTorJIa". l'i"瓜．E. Ko>KallII'IKoBa.(JU6., 1863, cTP. 54, Bonl)oc 31, crp. 273-274).

A. A. 3 II M II H. O IIoJIMTI1'ligcKon nok'l､PIIIIe llocM(ja BoJIoUKoro-

<Tpy,qbl O4PJI>, T. IX. M.- J1., 1953, CTP. 175.
A(p3MX, M. 11, JVb 62, 63.

258

JIO皿a,meii
HaMeCTHHIlbllMHnflTel皿IIKaMm-巾aKTI1'leCKl'l
u

BecbMaCV皿ecTBeHHOOTJ1IIIlaJIacbOTHO八06HoiilKeCTaTbHB

瓜pyrmx
Xpyrlix
rpaMoTax，H600Ha
fpaMoTax, !i60 0HaocBo60》K瓜aJIa
ocBo60)KUaJla̲
MoHacTblpcKHx
̲MoWMfW
Kp
ecTbHHOT
caMoH
nO皿JIMHbl-くⅡJITHa>>,
c6op
KoTopoH
ocM5jiEmaKmMo6pa3oM,B̲p)llfaX̲MoH3crjgl"BnpoqeM,
u

⑪

y>Ke
B
x<aJIoBaHHoii
rPaMoTe
l51Z
1､.
Hoc"o-BoJIoKoJIaM"o-

iffMMEMioHaioTIIMHbIBTBepcKoM;KJ'"WWWIJIOUKOMye3八axco八epzKaJIocb八PyrOenOcTaHOBJIe"eoTHO､

cIITeJIbH6 nHTHa: <<AIIHTHo IiryMeH 3 6PaTbelo B Tex CBOIIx

CeJIbUaXHB4ePeBHHXAep>KaTCBOe>67.

noJIv[leHIie BoJIoKoJIaMcKKM MoIIacTblpeM >KaJIoBaHHblx

rPaMOT
IICK皿oIIHTeJIbHblMM
c
nPHBIIJIerIIHMH3HaMeHOBaJIO
6oJIb皿yIono6e八yHOCH｡JIHHCKOiiKO皿e皿ⅡⅢ,KPaeyrOJIbHhlM

KaMHeMKOTOPOII6blJIaMblCJIbOlleO6XO八mMOcTliH3aKOHOMepHocTm
CyUeCTBOBaHIIJI
MOHaCTblPCKOrO
3eMJIQB"八eHI呪H
IIMMyHIITeTa.C6JIII)KeHIieBeJIMKoKIIH>KecKoronpaBMTMW"
c HOcH｡JIHIlaMII He llPHBeJIO, O皿aKO, K PaCnPOCTPa"HlilO
mMMyHIITerHbIxJIbrOTHa"QJIbKO-Hm6y"3HaIMTeJIPH92̲W:
JIoXyxoBHbIxKopnopaUmii.nollle八POCTmⅡpe,pPCTaBJIeHHblx
U

npHBIIJIerliiiliocI"o-BoJIoKoJIaMcK皿MOHaCTbIPbOCTaBaJICH
HCKJIIoI'eH'ieM II3 06Uero npaBHJIa.

CoBep皿eHHoHen3MeHmJIacbnoJIHTMKaBacl皿IIHIIIB
OTHomeHHHHMMyHIITeTa TpoIme-CeprlieBa MoHacTbl", Ko-

TOPb皿ⅡponpJI)KaJ]
noJIyIlaTb
ToJIbKo
o6eJIbHo-Hecy""W$
U

rPaMoTbl,
cOXeP>KaB皿me
tTaTblO
nPOTOpaX
O
pa3MeTaX
m
68j
H̅
HeCy,nIHMble
69.

nPiiilUImbI,
noJIo2KeHHble
B
ocHoBy
nojmTMKM
90-Xrq八oB

XV - HaIIaJIa XVI B., npoKJIaAblBaJIH ce6e AoQQry E9 BTo-

POH
HTpeT砿nePmo4bl̅npaBJIeHHH
BacIIJIIiH
lll・Mo>KHo
U

M3aTb nleJIbIM" CJlyqaeB, KOrAa MOHacTblpm (nOMMMO
Tpo皿e-CeprlieBa) noJIyIlaJIII BecbMa cKynble >KaJIoBi"ご

ii&WaM63bL B ,"<aJIoEaH!" rp"oT" MoHacTbIpHM 223aHcK6MynoKpoBcKoMy(1524r.)70,HoBI)929八cKoMyAHMEggy,( 1524 r) 7', CiIa60-IJPWUKQW . ( l525 r)"744 BQji6imckoMyKoM6JIbtKoMyl1528/29r)73,ycneHcKoMBopo〃

HmHoii nycTblHll (1529 r.) 74 M HeKoTopblM JpyrIIM八yXOBU

67 TaM )Ke, JYb 79.

68 Xn, I Nb 102, 103, 136, 146, 147,181Ⅲ八p、

69 Xn l, JYb l39, 140, 157, 164, 174,｣9S, 207 1i ,Up.
70 rlIB, Co6P・aKToB
▲
H rpaMoT, Nh 1-94.
7I A M B D o c M ii. yKa3. coI1.,，1. 111, cTp. 136-,144.
△

72 rliM," Onli, Co6pEapcoBa, Nb l85j724̲ (Xn, I, ". 2221:
73 AMBPocH曲. yka3. 6OI'., T、1V. M., 1812, cTp. 717-719.
7& JIOlim, Co6P. roJIoBHHa, Nb 53.
259

17＊

HblM yIIpe>KnleHI,IHM OTCyTCTBOBaJIO oCBO60>KneHI1e OT nOna"

Te}I, a cyAe6Hblii HMMyHI1TeT (blIKcIipoBaJIcfI B ToM >Ke o6beMe, IITo M B pal-IHHx rpaMoTax BacwIwI III.
U

Ho'cl515r.pa3BIIBa･JIacbH瓜PyraHJIIIHMHHMMyHIITeT-

-HOII nOJIHTHKH - JIHIIIIH Ha yKPenJIeHHe li PaCmHPeHHe liMMy-

HHTeTa MoHacTblpeil. npHIIeM oHa npHo6peTaJIa HaH60JIee oTIIeTJIHByIo 'oPMy B Te MOMeHTbl, KO皿a nleJIo KacaJIocb 6opb-

6bl cy八eJIbHoKHH>KecKoii pa34po6JIel-IHocTbIo. B HI-IBape
1515 r., 3a MeC皿瓜O BblnaIIII TaPxaHHbIx rPaMoT IIOcH｡OBoJIoKoJIaMcKoMy
MoHacTblPlo,
nPaBIITeJIbcTBb
nPe八OCTa
BHL｢Io
JIbrOTHylO }I HecynMMyIO I､PaMoTy Tpol皿KOMy BeJIonecoUKO-

My NpHacTbIpIo Ha no[IIIIIKM B Ka!皿PcKOM ye3me. rl)aMoTa
OCBOOO>KnaJIa MOIIaCTbil)CKMX KPeCTbflH OT 4aIIM, IIOBOI)OTII()-

rO II BCex no皿川IH lla5@ﾉIeT 3a e>KerO八llblii O6pOK B I)a3Mel)e
nOJIynOJITIIHbl, H3 10PIICIHKUHI'I MOHaCTblPH M3blMamIcb lly-

皿ery6cTBoHpa360iicnoJIHLIHblM75.Kam叩CKHiiye34HaxOnlIJIcH Ha CeBePO-3ananHohrp aHP皿e PH3aHcKoro KHH>KeCTBa.

n'03ToMyMocKoBcKoMynpaBIITeJIbcTBy6blJIoBa)KHo3apyIIIITbCH HO皿eP>KKoii KamHPcKIIx iJeOLaJIOB.
︑

B HHBape l522 r. TpoHUKHii BeJIonecoUK" MoHacTblpb
nOJIywIJI HcKJIIoIIHTeJIbHo皿enPyIo TaPXaHHo-HeCynMMyIo I,pa-

MOTy・OHa ocBo60>K,naJIa Bce ero BoTIIMHbl oT naHII, jIMcKIIx
neHer, npHMeTa, HoCOmHOrO KOPMa, MenBHHOrO o6POKa, KO-

TOPblii OH PaHbme n,JIaTHJI, TaMrH, MbITaH1pyrlix nomJIHH 76.
BeJIonecoUK" MoHacTblpb 6blJI B sTo BpeMR ̅6JIH30K K BeJIHKOKHH>KeCKOMy nPaBIITeJIbCTBy. naHIIIIJI, CTaBm砿MHTPOno-

JIIIToM B .eBpaJIe l522 E, BblnaJI eMy cTaBJ1eHylo rpaMoTy
Ha lIpcTpoiiKy HoBoih llepKBMI B ceJIe BopracoBe 77. TapxaHHylOrPaMOTyMOHaCTblPbnPIIo6PeJInOuleJI0611TbloHeHryMeHa, a Haxo4HBmerocH B MoHacTblpe cTapUa eonPcIIH KoBePm, JIHu(a, HoJIb30BaBmerOCH, oKIeBII,niH0, 60JIbmI1M nPBePm-

eM BacIIJIHH III.

①eo40cHii KoBepH npHMo noTpe60BaJI Bb皿aⅧMoHacTblPlOrPaMOTbl,OCBO60>KnalO皿eiiOTBCeXHO皿JIHH(B[IeJIo61iTHOii 6blJIII nePe'IHCJIeHbl BCe nOnlaTM H HOBI1HHOCTH, OCBO60>KneHHH OT KOToPbIx MoHacTblPb nO6HBaJICH)．ⅡPHIIeM aTa
npocb6a HHIIeM He apryMeHTHpoBaJIacb. BecbMa noKa3aTeJIbHO TaK>Ke CO4eP>Ka皿eeCH

B rPaMOTe yKa3aHHe Ha

TO,

IITO

rPaMOTa BblnaHa liryMeHy《ﾕJIH cTapUa ｡eonpcMH KoBepli>.

O BJIIIHTeJIbHocTH BeJIonecoUKoro MoHacTblpH KpacHopeIIHBo
７５ rnB, Co6p. aKToB H rpaMoT, NU l-87
７﹄
ｂ ArP,
T. I, cTp. 102-103.
７７

TaM >Ke, cTp. 102.

260

roBoPflT HocanKHe JIIO" B cEQIIx noKa3aHIIFIx, 3anHCaH ¥bIx

B npaByIo rpaMoTy l542 r.:《HryMeH, rOCIIo且HHe, CepreHqeJ1bBek c"Hai, THraTIIcH c HIIM He MOqHa), 78.

B HaIIaJIe 20-x ronpB XVI B. 6eJTonecoUKHii MoHacTblPb

HMeJI OCo60e 3HalleHHe BcJIencTBHe 60Pb6bl 3a nPlICOenHHe-

HHe Pfl3aHH, Haxo皿BmeiicH Ho coceXcTBy c KamHpoii, a
TaK)Ke II3-3a yrPo3bl HOBOro Ha6era KPblMCKIIx TaTap, 3aKJIIOwHBmmxCoIO3cPfl3aHcK,IIMKHH3eMHBaIIOMHBaHoBHIIeM

(BoicKa KPbIMcKord xaHa B 1521 r"om"II no caMoii "ocK-

Abl)yKpenJ1HH
.
CBOIInO3皿I畑BPH3aHcKoMKPae,BacH-

J1HhIII BbInaJI B l523 r. Hecy且mMyIo rPaMoTy CeMelly l'IBa-

HoBMIIy Kopo6bHHy Ha BoTIIIIHbl B nepeBHTcKoM H nepeCJIaBnも-PH3aHCKOM
ye3naX
79.
CTpeMHcb3aKpemlTb3aco60iMBoJIoUKo-TBepC"C3eMJ1H,

npaBIMTeJIbcTBo BacIIJIIIH III oTlaJIo B oKTH6pe l518 r=TpoI皿KoMyCeJIIDKapoByMoHacTbIPlo《ⅡOKHH3eenOPeBOPHCOBn【Ie)'(BOJIOIIKHihy,menbllblihKHfl3b,yMep皿噸B1513r.)
pH只只epeBeHb B P)KeBcKoM ye34e lI ocBo'60"JIo Hx oT "HH,
jlMcKII)meHer, nonBonbl,

nocomHoii cJIy)K6blHⅡpyrllx no-

mJIIMH.Cyne6Hbl尚mMMyHIITeTCeJIII>KaPoBaMOHaCTbIPH6blJI
CaHKUHOHHPOBaHくonpHIIbonHoronymery6|cTBa>,80.BHofI6pe
l518 r.皿enPylo TaPxaHHO-HecymHMylo H OnHOcPQIIHylO rPa-

MoTv noJIvII"a KJTIIHcKafl H30cIIMHHa nycTblHb 81, IIbe 3eM-

JIGBjianeHile
KOHUeHTP叩oBaJIocb
paiioIiax
B
BoJIoKoJIaMcKa,
TBeplI H KJIIIHa.

TaKIIM o6pa30M, Bo BTopoi noJIoBIIHe lO-x ro40B XVI B.
pyccKoe nPaBIITeJIbcTBO CO3naBaJIo 30Hy Oco60 nPHBIIJIerlIPOBaHHoro MOHacTI｣1PCKOro 3eMJIeBJIaneHIIH K CeBePO-ganany

( IIoclI巾o-BoJIoKoJIaMIcKIIii, Ce皿>KaPOB MoHacTblpll, II30cIIMIIHa nycTblHb) H K Ioro-BocToKy (TPo皿KHii BeJIonecoUKIm
MoHacTblpb) oT MocKBbl, yKpen"H TeM caMblM cBoI1 no311UHII Ha noLcTynax K nocJIenHHM caMOcToHTeJIbHblM HOJIyrOCy-

,maPcTBaM, JIHKBHnaUlifl KoTopblx BcTaJIa Ha oIIepemb 4HFI. 3amaqa 60pb6bl c q)eoJIaJIbHoi pa31po6JIeHHocTblo TecHo IIepemTeTaJIacb c npo6JIeMoii MoHacTblpcKoro 3eMJIeBJIane79 TaM >Ke, cTp. 102.
79 <AKTbI IOmKoBa>, JYb 1 18．Cp. rpaMoTy MapTa l523 r. PFI3aHcKoMy

noKI)oBcKoMy MoHacTblpIo (Url/IA,巾. 834, on. 3, Nb 1917, ".m. 80-二

82 06.).
80 <<naMFITHaH KHM>KKa TBepcKoii ry6epHIM Ha l868 ro1》. TBepb, 1868,
cTp. 287-290. rpaMoTa oTJTMIIIaJIacb oT BoJIoKoJIaMcKHx rpaMoT TGM,
qTo

B

HGM

He

6bIJIo

ocB()60>KmeHIIH

oT

TaMo)KeHHblx

nom｡IIIIH:

TaMrl,1,

M b l Ta H n P 、

81 JIeOIIIi瓜．KmMHcKaH I/130CIIMeHCKaR nyCTblHIJ H ee aKTbl, CTP､87-9 1 .
261．

ⅡHFT, OCTPO O6Cy>KXaBmeiiCH Pa3JmqHHMII rPynmIPOBKaMIJ
KJ1aCCa (beOnaJIOB nOJIHTH[IeCKaFI nDKTPIIHa IIOCm巾JImB
⑥

U

OnPeneJIGHHOPI CBOelI IIacTII nPenCTaBJIFIJIaCb BeJIIIKOKHFDKe-

CKOMy nPaBIITeJ1bCTBy 3巾巾eKTHBHblM opy>KHeM B 60pb6e 3a
VKPenJ1GHHe w PacmwpeHwe UeHTpaJIIY30BaHHoro rocynapcTBa.

BCe 9TO, a TaK>Ke Ha3PeBaBmme npoTHBoPeIIIIH Me>Kny BeJTIIKHM KHFI3eM

H MHTPOnOJIHToM-HecTfDKaTeJIeM

cO3maBaJTO

HanPH>KeITHyYO noJTIITIIIIeCKylO o6cTaHOBKV, B KoTOPoW H BO3HwK coIo3 npaBHTeJIbcTBa BacIIJIIIFI III c MoHacTbl"MH
HocIJ(bJTflHCKoTo HanPaBJTeHPIH, HaxO皿BmlMHCHHacTIJKe
M o c K o B c K o To B e J I H K o To K H R J K e c T B a w V X e J T b H b l x r H e 3 n .

nOMIIMO rPaMOT, BbmaHHLIX IIOCH巾o-BoJToKoJIa McKoMy
MoHacTblPIo B 1515 r., nocJIenHI愉ⅡOJIyIIIWI OT nP aBIITeJIBCTBa

HeCKOJIbKO皿enPbIx IIMMyHIITeTHbTx aKToB B 1517-1518 rr. 82
CpaBIIel-IIfe BoJToHKo-TBepcI<wx >K3JToBaHIIbIx rpaMoT HocH-

巾o-BoJ1oKo.汀aMcKoMy MoIIacTblpIo c rpaMoToii l522 r. eMy
>Ke Ha CeJTO d)aycTOBy rOPy 3y61IOBCKOrO ye3Xa 83 ITOKa3blRaeT BblHy>KneHHbl# xaPaKTeP nPenPCTaBJIeHIIH MOHaCTblPlO

KPynHblx nPlIBIIJTerHi B ero cTaPlIHHoM BoT可HHe、3 necb
cellboPHaJIbHble nPaBa MoHacTblpH B IIpe3BblqaiHo mllpoKoM
o6LeMe 6H,m 3aKPemleflbl GIIIe B rPaMOTax yneJIbHI>Ix BOJIOIIKIIX KHFI3eh 84. nO9TOMV巾HKCallIIH Cy>KGHHOrO Kpyra JIbrOT

FIBHJIaCI>6HnPHMblMBbl30BOMB,皿fITeJTbHO#IIOCIId)JIHHCKO#
Kopnop anHII・

HHaIIe o6cToHJYo neJTo c >KaJIoBaHHoii rpaMoToii l522 r.
BoJIoKoJIaMcKoMy MoHacTblpIo Ha ceJTo OaycToBy ropy.
B 3y6HoBcKoM Veane MoHacTHpb Xo ToTo BpeMeHII BoTYIIIHa-

M11HeBJIaJIe几nOSTOMy,nPenOCTaBHBeMy3eMJIII,Cyne6HBI#
wMMyHIITeT, <<onPIIIIe nymery6cTBa m Pa360H c nOJTⅢ可HblM>,
a TaK>Ke OcBo60>KXeHIIG OT HBOpUOBo-KHFI>KeCKIIx nOBHHHOcTei, nPaBHTeJIbcTBO MOrJIo PacC'IIITblBaTIJ Ha 6JIaronaPHOCTb

MoHacTblpfI OTcyTcTBHe B rpaMoTe l522 r. pa3pemeHIwT He
nJIaTIITb rJTaBIIble HaJIOrll cBImeTeJ1bcTByeT o ITOcTOFII-IHOM
cTPeMJIeHIm nPaBHTeJIbCTBa KaK Mo>KHO cTpo>Ke CJIenoBaTb

o6mⅣM nPWnmmaM CBOei lIMMyHI1TeTHOh nOJIHTIIKII, KOrna
9To TO!JTbKO no3BoJIflJIo PeaJTbHoe COoTHoIllGIMe CIWI.
82 AO3PIX, [1･ 11，Nb 79, 80, 82．B rpaMoTe l 51 7 r. Ha BoT[IMIHbl TBepcKoro, I<JmIIcKoro H BoJ1ouKoro ye310B coJemKa,JIocb ocBo60>KmelIIIe oT
mamI、FIMcKIIX XeTIer nOcoml･10ii c.FTV>K6bl, MblTa, TaMrH II nPyrl'Ix nOm-

ʻ可服1 (･}､aM >Ke, Nb 79) . CyjlG611blii llMMvHI,ITGT MoHacTblI)FI orPalllIIIIf

Ba,JICFI TIyTGM 113LFTTI'函I{3 cellbOPlla&mbHOi Io1)IIcl11Kmm pa360Pa ''FDK6
〆

no BOnpoCaMnvuIeryOcTBa、

83 A3HX, [1. 11，Nb 87.
84 TaM )Ke, Nb 3, 4, 14, 17, 25, 26, 45, 50, 55.
262．

HTaK,BOBTOPOinePIIOⅡⅡO川ITHKHnPaBHTeJIECTBaBaCH加佃III B O6JTaCTH巾eOnaJTbHoTo HMMyHIITeTa, Hapmy c o6Iuei orPaHHIIWTeJIbllOi JIIIHIIe#, nPOCJIe>KIIBaeTCH BO3HIIKHOBeHIYe nBVx no60IIwHx JIIIHIIi, II3 KoToPBIx nepBafY cocToHJIa

R npeJIOcTaBJIeHIIH MOHaCTblPFIM MeJIKHx (bIIHaHCOBblx nPIIBRJIerlIii Ha BoTIIMIHbl B PaioHax yrJIII'Ia, 3y6noBa, Be>KenKa,
nepecJTaBJIH-38JTeccKoro. BTopoe oTKJToHeHHe oT o6111ero
KVDCa BHPaJKaJIOCB B Bbma'Ie mempbⅨ HMMylMTeTHblx aKTOB (c OcBO60)KnelIIIGM OT Bcex HaJIOrOB II nPenCTaBJTeHIIGM

npaBa cyna, <<onpH[Ib nymery6cTBa)') HeKoTopblM KpynHblM
HOCH巾J1FIHcKIIMKOPnOPa皿HM(BOCHOBHOMHOC"O-BOJIOKOJIaMCKOMy MOHaCTblPIO) Ha WX BJIaneHIIFI B JIIIKB皿ⅥPOBaHHoMBoJIoHKoMyneJIGIIBTBepcKo尚3eMJTe．
>KaJIOBaHHHe rPaMOTbl Ha BOJIOIIKO-TBePCKHe BQTtIIIHH

OTJTIIIIaJIIICb OT rPaMOT, OTHOCFImmxcFI K Be>KenKy, yrJIIIIIy,
nePeCJIaBJIIO-3aJIGC'CKOMy,60JIblne竹ⅡOJIHOTOiiHMMyHIITeTm)Ix nPIIBIIJIer" B 3IIa[IHTeJ1bHOi MePe nOTOMy, tITO celTapaTHcTcKHe TeHneHnHII B TBepcKo# 3ew1e m 6blBmeM BoJToU-

KoMyIIeJIe,nPHcOeⅡHHeHHoMJTwmbB1513r.､6bmH，BePOFTTJIo, HaMHOro cIIJIbllee, [IeM B Be>KenKe lI yrJTHqe, CPaBHIYTeJIbHO XaBHO

BXOⅡHBmIIX

B

COCTaB <OTIIIIHI)T>

MOCKOBCKIIX

⑪

rocyjla peH.

BblmaIIa HecyIIHMbIx (I1 naHH[､Ix) rPaMOT CBeTcKIIM巾eonaJIaM B 151 1-1522 TE o6ycJIoBJMBaJ1acb, KnK II B npenme-

CTByIOm耐nepHoⅡ､3aXaqaMII 60Db6bI c yweJIbHo-KHH>KecKoi
oYmo31mlYei B 151 1 r. npaBIITeJIbcTBo nPeIIocTaBIwIo HeCKoJTbl<IIM cJTy>KIIJ1blM JIIoXFIM IaHHHe lI HecynHMBIe rpaMOTI)1

Ha[IePHblenePeBHIIBHPOCJTaBCKOMye3Xe85,IIaCTbYOKOTOporo npaBImw yneJIHIEIe lo)foTcKHe KHFI3HI. B 1509-1510 rr.
IOXOTCKIIi l<HFT3b enOP HBaHOBwII nPOFIBJIFIJY, BIImIMO, 3HaIMTGJ1bHVIO nOJIIITIIIIeCKyIO aKTIIBHOCTb・HM B STO BPeMH,

NanpHMep, 6bma Bb皿aHa rpaMoTa CnaccKOMy MOHaCTHDIo 86. KH93b nOrOBOpIwTcFI c MoHacTblPeM OTHOCHTeJIbHO Pa-

60[II1x pyK:《…ApxMMa皿DIITy HOHe... II3 MOefi OTIIIIHbl JIIoユeii He npHIIMaTH, a MHe H3 ero)P. TaKIIM o6pa30M, 9ToT
Ba>KHeim"

BoHDoc

里

DemaJICH

3a

culeT

BeJIIIKOKHH>Ke'cKIIx

u1epHI)1X BOJ1OCTeii｡ yKpemlfWY CBOeⅡぴJTO>KGHIIG B FIPOCJIaBcKoM ye3ne, BacIIJTHii lll BbmaJI B 151 1 r. rPaMoTbl He ToJTbKo cBeTcKHM BaccaJTaM, Ho H FIpoc"aBcKoMy CnaccKoMy
85 <<AKT1>1 10HI,KoB", Nb 81-83
86A.BapcyKoB.
CBenelm汀 O5 10XOTCKOM BOJTOCTI,Y， Cn5" 1894,
c Tp . 4 - 5 ; H . n . . Ⅱ W x a I I e B C60PHHK aKToB. Cn6., 1895, cTp. 203205．
263

MOHaCTblPIO, roPOHcKHe nBOPbl KOTOPOrO, nO BeJIIIKoKHFI>Ke-

cKoi rPaMOTe, OcBo60>K4aJIIICb oT IIaTyPaJIbl-Iblx noBI'IHHoCTeii, 3a HCK皿oIIeHIJeM ocHoBHblx (nocomHoii cJIy>K6bl, miulaJIbHOro HaP"a H rOpOnoBOrO neJIa) 87.
B l514 E B HecoMHeHHoi cBfl31,I c I1pHcoe旦ⅢHeHHeM BoJ10UKOrO KHFDKeCTBa nPaBHTeJTbCTBO BblnaJIO naHHyIO II HeCy-

nHMyIo rpaMoTy EJIbulaHIIHoBblM Ha nepeBHH B PaxoBe cTaHe
BoJIoKoJIaMcKoTo ye3nta 88. EJIbqaHIIHoBbl HBJ1HJIIIcb-BaccaJIaMmymeJIbHoro KIIFI3H IOpHFI HBaHoBIiula, cIo3epelIHTeT KoTopoTo no rpaMoTe l507 r. pacnpocTpaH列〃cH IIa nepeBHII E,ﾉTI〕IIallHIIoBblx B Py3cKoM ye3,ne, cocejlHeM c BoJIonK1,1M 89npeBpa皿aFI EJIIJLIal-IIIHoBIJIx B cBoHx BaccaJIoB, BacH皿IA III
ocJIa6J1HJI nO3H山IPI IOpwI, Eo3Mo>KHoro npeTelUeHTa Ha BblU

MOpOLIHblH ynen.

B 1515 r.八aHHble H ̲l･IeCynJ1MI)Ie rPaMOTbl 6bl川I npenpCTaBJTeHbl llePeBHI-IblM Ha 4ePeBI冊I B raJIIInKOM ye3ne 90,

JM. MHpocJIaBH[IV 91 H B. neMbFIHoBV 咳
92 Ha 3eMJIM B MenlbIHcKoM Ve3nle. 3TMIMH aKTaMH npaBIITeJIbcTBo
xoTeJIo o6e30na＆

CIITb Ce6H OT BblCTynJIeHH向co cTopoHbl KHH3fl BacH,llHH I'1BaHoBHIIa lneMHIIMIa, KoTopblii noJIy[IHJI B yneJIbHoe ynpaBJIe11He MaJIbl曲HpocJIaBeU (oKoJIo MelblHH) 1I, OqeB皿HO,
U

nOMblmJIFIJI

O

BO3BPameHHI'I

CTaPHIIHOH くOTIIHHb” cBOHx

npenlKoB - raIIIIIIa (cp BblUaLIy BacIIJIHeM III B I516 E
>KaJIoBaHHblx rpaMoT TpoHUe-CeprIIeBy MoIIacTblpIo Ha BoT87H､.A. BaxI)aMeeB. HcTopHIIGcKPIe aKTbl HI)ocJ1aBcKoro CmaccKoro
MoI･IacTbIpfl, T. 1, @Nb lV, cTp. 5-6．MOHaCTbrPb MOr PaCUellllBaTb 3TO
KaK .mbrPTy, 1160 nPaBIITe@I1bCTBO nPeZOCTaBIIJIO eMy O6eqrIel刑Ible nBOPOBble MeCTa B3aMeH
3aBIIIGrocFI, o1IeBImHo,

CTaPOro, cropeBmero, MoHacTblPcKoro nBoPa, oKanoC,ITe mO>KaPa B I)y|Kax nOCamMcKIIx .nlOXeH．
q ｳ

OmHaKo, 06MeHMBaH MoHacTbIpIo cTapble mBopoBble MecTa Ha HoBble,
⑪

⑪

nPaBIITeJIbCTBO

JTIｲmaJIO

erO

IICKOI-IHOII

TePPHTOPllII,

noJIb30BaBmel'IcFI

HMMyHHTeTOM B CIIJIy O61ｺIIIHOrO nPa'Ba II OxPaHHBIIleHCH I)aCnO.nO>KcHHbIM pmpM MoHacTblpeM-KpenocTbIo. noMe皿aH MOHaCTblPCKIie nBOPbl
Bry皿e

nOCana,

BeJIHKOKII"KeCKOe

nPaBHTeJIbCTBO

PacCIII"ITIJIBaJ1O,

IITO

B XOjle 6OP1,6bl nOCantCKIIX JIIOnteHC 6eJTOMGCTIlaMII IIMMyHHTGTHble nPllBHJIerHHnocJTenHHx OKa>KyTcFI PemlITeJIbHblM o6Pa30M HoLoPBaHHbIMH

4邸

HB

p e 3 VJ I b Ta Te

3TOrO

I

De3KO

VcHJ1IITC兄
．
シ

3aBmCHMocTb

ʻ

MOHacTblPFI

OT

nPaBHTeJIIJcTBa, y KOToPOrO OH OyneT IICKaTb 3a皿HTbl CBOHX nPIIBI'1JIerIIH H KOTOpOe, npⅢnoユユeP>KKe noCana, cMO>KeT nPoBeCTH maJTbHeHU

u

mee orpaHH【IGHHe beOnaJIbHoTo IMMMyHIITeTa.
88 4<AKTbl lOmKoBa>, M 91.
83 TaM )Ke, CTI). 59-60, Nb 70.
90 TaM >Ke! cTp. 82-83, Nb 97.
9I AAS、T. I, Nb 160.

92 H. n. JIwxaIIeB・Pa31)HAIHbIe JlbFYKII XVI B. Cn6．, 1888, cTI). 155,
npl,IM. 1.
264、。

〆

IIMHbl
yeamax
B
ManOrO̲HI)ocJ1aBIIaルI
PacHoJIo)KeHI-LoTo
I)FI-

JIoMBoPoBcKa
1515
93,B r-Hecy皿1MOiirpaMoTblCO"HH:M;MMMMM "am'".'
rajmmMW#,, 9｡9
1518
>KaJIoBaHI1oWI
r.Hecy且ⅢMOi,
3anOBenHOii
rPaMOTbl
l､aJ1皿k6My
qyxJIoMcKoMy
MoHacT.I"951
｡

○

J

B l514­l515rr.，Bo3Mo>KHo，6blJI
g̅i614-Zl515
rm, Bo3Mo>Klio, 6bIJ] KaKom-To
KaKoH-To3aroBop
3aroBop
InViicKIIx B paiMoHe Cy34aJIH, rne HaxoLILIIHcb mXjlWM
妙

ゾ

BoTIIHHbl. mVicKlle, BepoHTHo, no且瓜eP>KPIBaJIH nPllTFI3aHIIFI

5M55BEJTi,kbrOkHf,dH!,a"MOPOiIH"̲̲BMWWW
($' "nMMROfbegna" K IOpmio B naJ1b,,eii,neml 96) n()

l<I):aiilleii MePe, IIMeHIIO B 3TIi rOnb! BeJIIIKOKHfl>Ke"le W1

BHTe@IIbcTBoVcIIJIeHHoPa3ﾉIaeTrPaMOTblCy3maJIbCKIIM(I)eo八aJ1aM
97.

l ■

no>KaJIoBaHHe B巾eBpaJIel519r・瓜aHHoH
eBpaJIe l519̲E maHHoII M
m HeW
Hecy皿M()iI

rl)aMoTbl
CyxoTMy
HaノiepeBHII
TylLcKoM
B
ye:me
98
cBfl31,､
写

HOCnOmrOTOBKOjiKnPHCOe瓜HHeHI,IIoPH3aHIJ.BblnaLIa
>Kaご

t

J

JIOBaHH(jirpaMoTb(BacIIJ1meMIII.ToTIIacp!,13BaJI49TBqTWe
MePOnPHHTHH
PH3alICKOTO
KIIH3HレIBaliaしIBaHOBMula
KOTO-

I)b'i血ncBoMM
BoeHHblM
BaccaJ1aM
BopblnaeBblM几BOpuOiwIoJIePeBHIoBoJIbHⅡleBcI<yIo99TormaEMapTel519r:Ba-

cIIJ,HifmMMaBIIJ14a,iHy,OIIHeCyn!IMy,OrPajil)TYWI:
iV｡XAMgb66ycbIHy
MacJIoBa
HanepeBIIIo
TBopHI1Km
ソ

93UrAnA,
｢K3｡oMaJIoMV̲2PocJIaBU,Nb6/7696j̲19̲̲E929BgW
M' dM' g "3#meMai,bii Mamoro 9pocnaBUg ,̲YI"JIeWW=
aiI1WWHI"niy,̅ IMI"TeTMailomPOcjIaBeUKIIxBQTWIill̲ Jll9WfCePI.IIGBa
MoHacTbll)FI
61>1!（3aKPenJIel･I
BeCI)Ma
B
lUl叩oKoM
o6'bGMe:
Mo-

FMMK"MMneWII""nIICL " yMaTC K1I""""MF

MFII11'iLIy
@ⅧⅡIbmanM,
loI)IIc"KIIIIH
a
Mq}I"Tblpfl
callKIll,IoH川〕oBaJIaCb
〈<oⅡpⅢlIb
o1Horo1yluery6cTB”･BacHJIIｲｶHBaHOBIN
FIBJIFJJIC兜noⅡHe
116hbaBHbIM
V4eJ1bllblM̅KHH3eM
Malloro
flpocmaBna･MOHEICTbIPCKIMe
l

nP,1|ka3qIMKI1
iOJDKHb1
6JJ'H
Cy皿TbCH
BeJI1{KOrO
y
KHH3H,
He
a KHFI3FI
y

R'acII､mmFI I/IBaHoBII[Ia. B BeJ1IIKoKH"KGcKoM cymte paccMaTpHBa@nHcIJ II
JIena MOIlacTblPcKIIx JIIOnei̲C nocTOPoHI冊IMH (mlIUaMH, He rIO4BelOM⑪

c,I､gEHli"̅IMEMMyCy"nocPaBHeHliloc>Ka"OBalIH9K̲WAMOTOji
iIMA̅ill̅i500I0 l' rJia' Te )Ke ManompocilaBcKlle cema (ACSし1,
ガRT. I,

Nb 631) rpaMoTa l516 r. 3HaIIIITeJILHo yBe川IIIl{BaJIa MOHaCTblPCKIM HMMVHHTeT､

94 rIW,Oml, Co6p yBapoBa, ""̲6@lg0, 1 0Tn., Nb 2.
9j AH, T･I, JVb l25; cp. AA3, T、111, Nb 95.
96 nCPJI, T. XIII, nePBa貝noJIoBIIHa, cTp. 77-78.

97CM.
>KaJIoBaHHblefpaMoTb!
l514-1515r[･MOHaCTblPFIM
nOKPOBCKOMy

"""6My (AIi, TJ, M l l9) ,̲ Pnagp-EB｡IIMbeBy (u[Anヘ，

のCnaco-EB巾ⅡM$beBa M-I)fl, KIL 1 , J1. 41 5) . Bo3JlBwKeHcKoMy ne[lepI

6K()My(Ka6aHoB,Nb 4),cBGTcKHM巾eO"JIaMPenbeBbIM(<<AKrbI

IOmKoBa)', Nb 96).
98 <<AKT･bl lOulKoBa>', Nb 109･
99 TaN1 )Ke, M llO.

■

265

b

I

IIoTocT B 3ayncKoM cTaHe TyJIbcKoro ye34a loo. B HIoHe Toro
>Ke rOma naHHyIo H IIMMyHgTeTHylO rPaMOTy nOJIyIIHJI oT Pfl-

3aHCKOrO nPaBIITe{ﾉlbcTBa rp HM Ko6HK !ol TaKmM o6Pa-

30M,o6ecTopoHbI,roToBHcbKcxBaTKe,pacceJI升m1BnOPy6e)KHblxMecTaxcBoIIxc"y>KIIJIblxJIIone曲.BI520r.npaBHTEJIbcTBoBacmJ"IIIBblfla｡iloHecymIMylorpaMoTyoiHoMy

Pl34yXOBHbIX巾eoUaJIoBPH3aHcKoroKpafITepeXoByMcr-

UaCTblPIo193rl)aMoTbl,Bbl"HHble4yx6BHbIMKobnoP血”M
PFI3aHII
IICKOBa,
II
III)ⅡⅡ"､me>KaTK[IMcJ1yHam60JIeecKynblx
>Ka&iloBaHIIblx rpaMoT nepBoi TpeTII XVI B.103 H H MaCJIelI"KoBa, nPaBga, paccMaTpIIBaeT BbUa[Iy rpaMoTbl l510 r

ncKoBcKoMyneTponaB"oEcKoMyMoHacfblpI6
KaKnonbITKy
OrP aHHⅦfTb BJ1acTI, HaMecTHI1Ka !04. OnHaKo c Heii BI)" "
M()>KHO COr.maCﾚITbcfl 3T() 6bm o6blIIHblii B IIpaKTHK6 BeJIHKOliH"KeCKIIx |II)aBIITembCTB CnOCO6 3al)y[IIITbCH !IO瓜瓜ep>KU

"H nyXOBHbIX q)eOnaJI0B nPHCOe皿HfleMOII TePl)IITopHM
U

l

IOI)
IIc且HKUnfl
)Ke
llaMeCTI冊IKa
B
rPaMOre
neTPOnaBJIOBCKO-

My MOHaCTblPIO 3aq)IIKCIIPOBaHaB 60JIee皿叩OKOM O6'beMe､
IIeM B nomaBJIHIO皿elI Macce >KaJIoBallHblx rpaMOT nePBom

TpeTHXVIB:eMynpeXocTaBJIHJIocbnpaBocyhaHaⅡHryMeHoM H 6paTIeiL KoToPoe o6blqHo coxPaHHJI ga co60it B6JIliK"KHFI3b!05.TaKIIenoJIHoMoIIIIHIIMbJIHToJIbKoHoBroPo4U

U

cKIIe HaMecTIIHKm (no rpaMoTaM l499-1500 rr)

npaBIITeJJbcTBoBacIIjII別111，ⅡeoTKa3bIBaficI,oTnl〕HHUHna 3aKPeIWleHI171 BeJII,IKOKHFDKecKOrO cIO3ePeIIHTeTa Ham
B}IoBb nl)HCOeZIIIHHeMbIMI1 3eMJIFIMII nVTeM Bblna[III )KaJ1O-

Bal-IHblX rPaMOT MGCTI{blﾊI JyXOBHbIM KOPlTOPamIHM, CIIPITaJIO,

04HaKO,HeO6XO皿,IMbIMOrPaHIIIIIITbCFInOOTHOmeHIIIOK"'00《H3 npO!IIJIoTo>', I1. 2. Ty､J1a, 1915, cTp. 7-8.
101 <<AKTbl lOIIIKoBa>, Nb l l l:

l" AIO, JYb 24, CTI)．59-60 .

'03Kngjie,̲XKa3am"IXrpaMoTTepexoBy
noKpoBcKoMy
!I
MoHacTblpHM
1520, 1523 !! 1524 rr" MMeetcn HeCj'4IIMo-3ahoBeUHafi rpaMoTa 'Bo-

rocmQUcKQMy

MoHacTI>Ip!o

l527 r.

(Url/IA,巾.

834,

o几3, Nb l917、

W1. 54-55 06.). O ncKoBcKIix rpaMoTax cM:: C. M" I< a iIJ T a H o H

mBe
>Ka"oBaHHbie
rpaMoTbl̲
151P
ncKoBcKmM
c
MoHacfbipfIM­《3au

III:ICKH

OT,r(e.na

l)yKOⅡⅡcef[

roCy"PCTBelIHoii

6116JIIIOTeKI{

I"1M.

B H JIeHIIHa", ELm. 24 M., i961、cTI). 221-258. noJIaTHblG
:npIIBHJIer"̲ ̲ConepjKaTcFI To､mbKo B rpaMoTe ncKoBcKI'IM nonaM H

"KoHaM I525 J: (IE 52JI x o B 1! T IiH o B] IIcTopm" KHfDKecTBa
[IcK"clIOro, [1. 1L KIieB｡ 1831$ cTp､87-89) .

!04HHMacJIemHI1KoBaTIhlicoe皿佃GHIIencKoBaKPyCcKOMy
lleWpaJIII30BaHIIoMX rocynapcTBy J1, 1955, cTp. 127-128.

!059̲KaUITamoBrIoJIe31Ioe'licejienOghHM6,­《Ha6el)eraxBeJIPIKoi>',
1956,f,"Z. fTI1137-138;o u>K enBe>Ka"6BMIIEI6̅fP5M5fEi…，
⑪

cTI). 239-244.

266

一
3a
l-ICKHMHⅡCKOBCKHM
MOHaCTblPFIM
Cal-IKuHei
o6blIIHblx
npIIEimmi BacmJImi lll He BnoJIHe 40BepHJI 3TIIM *eo"JIaM,
BO3MO)KHO, CBH3aHHblM C 6blBmHMII nPaBHTeJIbcTBaMII nPH-

COe且mHelIHbIX
TePPIITOPmik
106.
npliCOe且HHFIBmHeCfI
3TOT
B >Ke

rlePlioA
BoJIoUKci-TBepcKIIe
m
6e)KeUKo-yrJIIIUKIIe¥milli̲32JI"IIcb o6JIacTHMII, me MocKoBcKoe BJIIIHHIIe IcneJIo IIMc-

fMMRfjly60KiIekopHM, [IeM B ncKoBe M PfI34LIIIHe-

KOToPble
H3
1mIXe皿e
PaHbmeBXOⅡHJIII
COCTaB
B
MOCKOBt

J

CKOr6 KHH>KeCTBa, HO nOTOM ('TaJII1 yJIeJIaMP! KHfI3ei! MOCKOBCKOrO

mOMa.

3eMハeBJIaJIe､IIblIaMM 3meCb 6blJIII KOPnOPaU", HaxO"IB-

1皿i" B TebllOM cOIO3e C nl)aBIITeJIbCTBOM (Hanl)IIMeP,

MocM{I)o-BoJIoKoJIaMcKl1il,
BorofIBJIeHcKIlii,̲IIymoB
MQlia"I]li)jaBafIIIM|UmPoKlieJIbrOTbl,MO>KHOgblJ9̲IEFW"P"

CIIMITblBaTb
l-la
l̅10且旦bp>KKy
c
I1x
cTOPOHbL
n0311UlifI
Me9:rHbIx
MOHacTblPeiiPfI3aHI1H nCKOBaoTJIHIIaJIacbMeHbmeHHCIIocTI)Io. KpoMe Toro, 3TII MeJIKHe Kopnopa皿HBp皿JIH cyU

D

MeJII1 6bl OKa3aTb TaKylOンKe CePbe31-IylO HOMO皿b npaBII-

faiE6T"KaK
． BJ1mfITejlbHeiimme̅TPomUe-Cel]rlleB,IIymoB,
U

U

I'IocIKbo-BoJIoKoJIa McKMHMoHacTblpH. Bo BcHKoM cJIyIIae,
A

U

ImaBHTeJIbCTBO
CuHTaJIO
HeOnPaBnaHHOii
MePOi巾HKCa皿IO
lli<mMMvHIITeTaBcKombKo-HM6ylbpac皿HpellHoMo6'beMe.
ユ

3．rpaMoTBIaBrycTal522-oKTH6pH1533rr.
U

KoMnpoMIMccHblG
TGHneⅡ皿HB
IIMMyHIITeTHOHnoJIHTHKe

BacwIIIfl ' III 3aMeTHo ycHJIIIJIPIcb nocJIe npHxona K BJIacTPI

naHIn1川a,
6blB皿ero
MryMeHa
mocII｡o-BoJIoKoJIaMcK9J9,､Mo･

MMM'(27｡eBpaJIfl1522r)BPeMHcal;rycTal522̲J9
oKTfI6Pbl533rMo>KIIoycJIoBHocqHTaTbT2eTbIiMneJWoWM

MMfr6TA6itmoJIIITHKi!npaBHTeJlbcTBaBacIIJIH3
1113aHHTIib
MMTPOnOjmqbei
Ka｡enl)bI
naHmHJI0M
cnOCO6CTBOBaJIO
U

ヅ

U

MMMI6̅mMMy"reTa
Mm:rPonOJTwIbero""EW[3｡、
i5 1522 rBacwniih lll BbIfIaJI MMTponommTy ""IW.Ig
jYoBallHylorpaMoTy,ocBo60>K八aB皿yIOCeJIOTOJIeHH皿eBo
ｰ
MOCKOBCKOTO ye318 0T rOPOnPBOrO ne.JIa Ⅵ 瓜PyrlIx HaTypaJIbHblx noBPIHHocTei: <<ropo" Moero He ne""jUl.Wig-

iIII, HII II3BecTII K roPOny He BO3FIT, HII B POB HM nteJIa MOero,

nO UemPOcTm mMMyHIITeTHbIX̲nPmBWIermii, nPe"""""X
兜no
oMy
Hblxn”BHJIerliH，，Ⅱpe1ocTaBJIeHHblx
lo6C"1H:My
coc“HeMy
p”aHbIo
c
KamIIpcKoMy
BeJIoneconKoMy
MoHacTblpIo,BacmJIHii lll rOPa310 60JIbme PaCCIIIITPIB" Ha ero ng几瓜eP>K'Ky, IIeM Ha

E;"cfiie" ̅""cI"̅M6HacTblPei# (Tepexosa, noKI)oBcKo!ro, CoJIOTⅧHCKOI､o).
267

Be"KOrO KHH3fl, He HapmKalOT)> !07．rPaMoTa >Ke l'IBaHa III

1504r.HaceJIOTOJIeHH皿eBo3aKJIIo[IaJIaBCe6eJIHmb3anoBenHble l"{ cyne6Hble JIhroTbl lo8, KoTopble, KcTaTH, IIo4-

TBeP>K4aⅡHcbWaMoTojil522EB1526rkpecTbHHeMMTp6-

nOJIHIIbMxCeJITOJIeHHueBaHCeJIHTMHa6blJ1MocBo60)K"Hb!
OTqPg3aHHOCTIICTOHTbHafIMyCnOnBOJaMIi!09.
BTpeTHHⅡePHoLIIMMyHIITeTHoiinoJIHTIIKHBacwIHHIII
U

⑥

IIam60JIeeKpynHbIMI1,
llieKmlo'lliTeJIbHblMHnpHB"6MIMA
nOJIb30BaJICH, KaK Ii PaHb皿e, HocH｡o-BoJIoKoJIaMcKHi Mo-

HacTbII)brPaMoTa, BbUaHHaH eMy b l527 E |la ceJIa B6JIoUKoroH3y61IoBcKoroye3八OB,3aKI)enJ1HJIa3aMOHaCTblpeM 9cBo60>KneHIIe oT "HH, fIMcIfHx neHer, nocomHoIi

cJIyJK6･I,
MblTa,
TaMrm
H
4pyrHx
nom"III冊I.
Cyne6HbliM
HMMy･
U

〆

HMTeT｡HKC!叩oBaJIcFI<onPOIIenymery6cTBao皿oro)p'10

OLIeBli"9, B HaqaJIe
OlIeBH瓜Ho，B
Ha〔IaJIe20-x
20-xro且oB
r6UoB
B．ⅡpaBH'1.eJIbcTBo
XVIXVI BI"iTe"EcTBo

BacHJIMFI
BbInaしmO
III
TaPXaHHO-HeCy,mllMylO,
OlllIOcPOIIHyIo,
ザ

3a nOBeUHyIOルI npoe3)Kylo rpaMoTy Cnaco-npeo6pajKeHcKo-

MynyTMBJIbcKQMyMoliacTbiPIOHjPa3HbleBjl2ne"̅FTiWど

TMBIIbcKoM !I HoBropQm-CeBepcKoM ye3"x !!!: noflBJIeHie
じ

3TOIf rPaMOTbl MOJKI-IO CBfl3aTb C，叩IKBHnaUlieih B l522 r.
U

IJ9Bropo4-CeBepcKoro yneJIa KHH3H BEIM̅liEaA65M
meMH[IHIIa.

TaKHM
o6pa30M,
oplleHTaⅡHFI
npaBHTeJIbcTBa
BacI1JIII兄III
"JIQplI(bJ1H1I
MHTepecbl
II
60pb6brc
nepe>KIITKaMH
(1)eona"
U

HoMpa34po6JIeHHocTMnpHHy>K"J1IierbKpacmmp6HlibM6HacTblPCKIIxIj̲UePKOBHblxnPHB！IJIerH曲O皿laK64aHHble,

KaCaIO皿MegH
PIpcli(1]o-BorIoKOJ1aMcKoro
HeKoTopblX
l!
mpyEHX MOHaCTblPeR, a TaK>KG MIITPOnO川Iqbero JoMa, He MorVT
ｰ
⑥

A

6blTb
B39Tbl
3a
OCHOBy瓜ⅡFI
xaPaKTePMcTHKII
o6皿ero
Kypca
U

I1MMyHHTeTHoImoJIHTmKII BacIIJIMH IIL CKyI10cTb B oTH6me-

HM"Q>KaJIoBaHIifI
MoHacTIJIPHM
MMMyHIITeTHbIx
nplIBIIJIerHH
U

u

ocTapaJIacb oTJIMIJHTeJIbHo# [IepToi no:IIIITMKH BablIJIIIH III.

C4BIｲ｢,HaMeTIIBmHiicHB3Toio6JIacTHBHa[IaJIe20-xro-

40B XVIB" 3aK"Io[laJIcHB ToM, [ITo npagili､6JIEEM̅cTaib
nPenOCTaBJIHTI,OmeJIbHblMMOHaCTblPHMBPeMeHHbleJ1brOW A"MX, q 1, JYb 25, cTp. 47.
'08 TaM )Ke, Nb 70 .
'09 TaM )Ke, Nb 26.

!!91aM >Ke, q. 11, JYb lO3i cp・Nb lO2.

!!!W3ailli"aB"aqyrptlM6Tb!Ba"meMIIIcM&rpaMoTeHBaHalV
W ｢h"W. xe̲Mo"cTbIp" (ulMA̅̅'̅125, MM ､ iX&M;

rBJIIM̲RXMW!
"Z ̲J'Ji ､r1gT73rIIIYepHII"K#&"'eiMXib"
I13BGCTIM", 1861, npll6aBJI. K Nb 5).
268

Tb1. nePBafl 60{mbmafl CePHFI J1broTHbIx rPaMOT IIORBlIʻⅢacb B
l 522 r., nocJIe pa30pHTeJIbHoro TaTapcKoTo Ha6era l521 r.
EIUe B q)eBpane l522 m ceJIa CI1MoHoBa MoHacTblpfl )KJIaHcKoe, Kop()60Bo H mp. B MocKoBcKoM ye3八e 6blJIII Ha 5 JIeT
〆

CCBODO)KIGHbl OT naIII'1, FIMCKIIx neHer, nOBOI)OTI-IOrO, HaMeCT-

IIHLIbero, BOJIOcTeJ1HHa, THyHOBa KOPMoB II oT no60POB noBOLIIHKOB II nl)aBe叫IPIKoB. JIbroTa MOTMB}lpoBaJIacb Pa30PeHHeM MOHaCTblI)CKIJx BOTIIHILTaTaPaMI{ (HMeJICH B B皿V
響
Ha6er MyxaMMen-DIPeFI, cOBePmeHHblA B KoHIle IIIOJIH
1521 r) 112 B caMoM HaqaJIe l522 E JIbroTHble rpaMoTb1 noJIy[IwIII HeKoTopble cBeTcKlie (PeonaJIbl MocKoBcKoro H Ko.IIOMeHCKOrO ye340B, nOUBeprmllXCH Ha6ery ll3.
Bblme y>Ke lla3blBaJIacb JIbroTHafl rl)aMoTa l523 r. noKI)()BCKOMy yr･ﾉIIIIIKOMy MOIIaCTIJIPIO, OTMellflBmafl II(1 TI)II
IOJla ynJIaTy llaMeCTHIIIIbHX KOI)MOB, nPo'1．OPOB H I)a3MeTOB.

B ToM )Ke l523 r・BeJIHKoMy KHFI3Io 6HJI IIe.JIoM Cnaco-EB｡MMbeB MOHaCTblPb, nPOC月及aTb JIbrOTy, TaK KaK＜XOT刊T V
Cnaca B MoHacTblpe cTaBHTIi nepKoBb TemlyIo KaMeHHy>".
MoHa(､Tblpb noJIyKIIIJI Ha 3 rQma ocBo60)KIIeHHe oT nonaゴ

Teii l14.

3aMeTHoii Bexoii B IIcTopIM BHyTpel･IHehnoJIIfTHKM Bacl,I川畑III 6blJIII co6blTHH l525 r.- UepKoBHblカco6oP, ocy4MB山HiM BJ1皿e MaKcHMa rpeKa npoTIIBHMKoB IIocH｡JIHH IIecTFI>KaTejleii, Onana 60RPcKorOH八eoJIOra BepceHfI BeKJIGMM山eBa, pa3Bo4 BeJIPIKoro KHFI3FI c CoJIoMoHHeii Ca6ypoBoiﾉ1．3TH
Mepl)I 3HaMelloBaJIm pe3Koe o60cTPeHIIe npoTHBopeIIH力Me>K­
4y Bacw1meM III II yneJIbHoii oⅡnO31皿lleil. He yユHBHTem bl-IO,
[ITO IIMeHHO B 3TO BPeMH HeCKOJ1bKO yCIIJIHJICH COIo3 nPaBHTeJIbCTBa

C

BJ1HmeJIbHblMM 八yXOBHblAIH

KOPnOPaUliflMH.

B 1525-1527 rr. MHoI､I'le MOHaCTblPlI nO｡myLlllJIH >KaJIOBaIII-lble, nPeHMyLIleCTBGHHO JIbrOTHble rPaMOTbl.

B l525 r. naHEJIoBy nepecJIaBJIb-3aJIGccKoMy MoHacTblPlO 6blJIa BbinaHa HeCy瓜ⅢManⅡO6eJIbHafl rl)aMOTa, OCBO60>K"aBmaH Ha TPH rona MOHaCTblPCKOe CeJIblIO By40BCKOe

CTapoe oT ynJIaTbl HaJIoroB Ho o6Uei pacK@mamKe c '1,fImblMM JIIo4bMI1 115. B 1526 r. ToT )Ke MoHacTblI)b no61IJIcfI BbInlaLIH eMy JI̲broTHoii rpaMoTbl lla nepeBHIo By40BcKoe HoBoe.

MoHacTbTPcKIIMKI)ecTbHHaMpa3pe皿aJIOCbilenJIaTIITbnaHb,
''2 rHM, CIIM. KH. 58, Ho MocKBe JYh 72, JIJ1. 264 06．­265.
''3 KAKTIJI IOmKoBa>', Nb 1 14-1 16.

114 UrAHA, ｡. Cnaco-EB*11MbeBa M-", KH. 1, ,n. 416.

115B. r. no6poHpaBoB. HcTopHFI Tpo皿KQrq ̲JaHHJToBa hipHaCTblpH. CeprlieB nocam, 1908, npPIJI．, cTp. 16-17, JVb 1.
269

HMCKIIe neHbm,

MblT, TaMry,

nOMePHOe

H

II)yrlIe nOm.JII'I-

}lb1 116. nOKa3aTe､JIbIIa MoTIIBI1I)OBKa nPeJIoCTaBJIeHIIH &IIbrOTbl, 4aHHafI B rl)aMo're l526 r.: <<B ,mepeBI-IIo KpecTbFIHe >KIITb
HeH且yT, H MHe 6bl…瓜aTH JIbroTa>>. npaBHTeJIbcTBy BacHJIIIH III 6blJIo, HecOMHeIIHo, BblrOJHO Co3JaTb HeO6xO4HMble
yCJIOBIIH 4J1月ⅡePeXOna

B BeJIIIKOe KHH>KeCTBO KPeCTbflH H3

ccceZIHero nMIITpoBcKoro yneJIa lOpHH MBaHoBIIIIa. OIIeB胚旦HO7 C 3TO曲>Ke neJIblo BacI{JIHii lll BbInaJI JIbroTHylo rPaMoTV TpoHue-CepmeBy MoHacTblpIo Ha ceJIo BopoHaBoJIoKoBO, HaXOJMB皿eecH B6｡Ⅱm3H ynleJIa KHH3H IOpl,IH - B HepJIb-

cKoM cTalle nepecJIaBcKoro ye3na. rpaMoTa ocBo60>KnaJIa
MOHaCTblPCKIIX KPeCTbfIII Ha TPll rOna OT JIaHII, HMCKIIX neHer, nOCOIIIHOII CJIy>KObl, rOPOmOBOrO JIeJIa
l'I HaMeCTHHIIblIX
U

一

KOI)MOB ll7. CJIe40BaTeJIbHO, BOIIPOC OTII()CIITeJIbHO I)a6()IIMX
I)yK B 3rJIx rPaMOTaX I)emaJTC71 33 CIIeT IIaCeJIeI冊I兄旦M I'ITI)OBcKoro y几eJ1a, OTKylla
MOHaCTbll))1, KaK 3TO COBel)山ellHO He八ByCMblCJIGHI-IO nOnPa3yMeBaJIOCb B aKTaX, MOrJIII nPH3blBa'1,b
K P e C T b FJ H

B CBOH BOT[IIIHbl.

TapxaHHaH rpaMoTa MocI1(l)o-BoJIoKoJIaMcKoMy MoHacTblplo 1527 r. KacaJIacb rJIaBHblM o6pa30M cTaPHHHblx
MoHacTbll)cKPIx ceJI B BoJIoUKoM ye34e, a TaK)Ke ,mepeBeHb B

3y6UoBcKoM ye34e ll8. KpaiiHe lIHTepecHo To, !ITo BacHJmifl lII B 9TOji rl)aMOTe 6PaJT nOﾉI CBOii naTI)OIIaT nBG MOIIf1CTbl PCKIie八ePeBHm (E(bIIMbeBo II BL,Ⅸ<J1eUOBO), [IHCJIIIBmⅡecfl no rpaMoTe yneJIbHoro KHFI3H IOI)I,IFI MBaHoBHLIa l510 n

B cocTaBe ero <<oTIIIIHbl>> 119 (4epeBHII Haxo"JIIIcb Ha py6e>Ke BoJIoUKoro M Py3cKoro ye3npB) 12q TaKIIM o6pa30M,
60pb6anpaBHTeJIbcTBaBacHJII,IFIIIInpoTHB60HpcKoiionⅡo・・
3皿IIH COIIeTaJIaCb C HaCTynJIe1冊IeM I-Ia rpaH皿b' JM'ITpOBcKoro yneJIa '21.
1''] UrAnA, rK3 no nepecJIaBJIIo-3a"meccKoMy, JMb 68/8792. LIacTI1LIHo
H3XaHa B.r. no6poHpaBoBblM (yKa3. coI1., npHJI., cTp. 18). B 1526 r.
>KaJIOBaHIIyIO rPaMO'ry noJIyIIwI TaK>Ke roPHnK城 nepecJIaBJIb-3 aJIeccKHii MQliacTblpb (C. m e p e M e T e B．ⅡBa ynPa3皿eHHblx MoHacTblpH HaユngPeHcJIaBcKIIM o3epoM. M., 1901, cTp. 15).

|II LIr444, rK3 no nepecJIaEJIIo-3aJieccKoMy, "M 75/8799.

''R A3IIX, 11. 11, Nb 10a
I19 TaM >Ke, Nb 48.

!2oUrWMoIel529r"BbmaH"Hocm(I)o-Eo"oKoJ1aMcKoMyMoHacTI,1-

plo, lOpnii cHoBa lla3blB"T E(bmMI,eBon Bbi)KneuoBo "iicJi@̅"if6-

"2YPM"̲" 4eP"" Py3cKoro ye3mia (A"mX, " II, Nb l i"

、

!2 C"3I2Rp" C i)yKOBOmliTe"! bnflb3H"6iIM 60"6M36#>Km.
"agj lWIIq9j1ef qeTKo I1MeHHo B 3ToT nepliomB I528 ERHi"'XM

M ¥! MlllWIIE ggeJIam nOnb"y ̲KQTEgxaT"̅if iOPiWh6piii,

T. XIII, nepBaH noJIoBHHa, cTp. 77-=78)" B Kbi皿e 20-x ronpBBo3270

Ha cropeBmHe lI I]a30peHHble BJIaneHIIfl MoHacTblplI noJ1yLlaJ1I'I JIbroTHble rpaMoTbl H B HallaJIe 30-x ToJpB XVI B.
B I531 r. JIbro'1､IIyIo rPaMoTy lloJIyqHJI neulepcKHii Bo3HecellcKIM MoHacTbll)b. Ero BoTIIHHbl B HH>KeroponlcKoM H Cy3〜

1(aJIbcKoM ye3nax nPHoOPeTaJIII nPaBo He nJIaTHTb B TeqeHIie

TPex JIeT naHb lI flMCKIie neHbrII, a TaK>Ke He OT6blBaTb nO-

[OmHyIO CJIy>K6y. JIbrOTa MOTIIBHPOBaJIaCb TeM, IITO MOHacTbll)b cropeJI '22 AHaJIorHIIHyIo JIbroTHylo rpaMoTy noJIyIIIIJI
B 1533 r・TpoIiUe-CeprHeB MoHacTblpb Ha ceJIblIo rHe31IHKo･
Bo KocTI)oMcKoro ye3", pa30pellHoe TaTapaMIi l23.
TaKMM o6pa30M, JIbroTbl, I1pemocTaBJ1flBmIiecH MoHacTblIﾉfIM nPaBHTeJIbcTBoM BacHJIPIfI III B 20-x - IIaIIaJIe 30-x ro-

40B XVI B., He o3Ha[IaJIMI Kopel-IHoro nepeJIoMa B HMMyHIiU

TeTHOH

HOJIHTIIKe

pyccKOrO

IleHTPaJIII30BallllOrO

roCynaP-

cTBa. OHH HocI"IJIM BpeMeHHI)Iji xal)aKTep II o6ycJIoBJIIIBa川Icb
3anyCTeHmeM MOIIaCTbll)CKliX BoTIIIIH ((PaKTOI), C KOTOI)bIM
Tpy皿o 6blJIo He c[IHTaTbcH) "I1 3anaqeii 60pb6b[ c yneJIbU

⑪

H o K H H > Ke c KO I I O Ⅱ Ⅱ o 3 P 皿 H e H ・

BoJIee cePbe3HOe yBeJTHIIel-IHe HMMyHETeTI-Iblx nPIIBHJIerHii MoHacTbIpei B KoHILe 20-x - HaIIaJIe 30-x ronpB XVI B.
Mo>KIIo Ha6JIIonaTb B )KaJIoBallHblx rpaMoTax Ha MoHacTblI)-

cKIIG BoTLIPIHbl BoJ10roIcKoro H BeJIo3ePcKoro ye310B. B rl)aMoTax 1531/32 II l533 rr. 3a KIIpHJIJIo-BeJIo3epcKIIM II

･el]anoHToBbIM
MOHacTblPHMI!
3aKPenJIHJIOcb
nPaBo
Cy皿Tb
KpecTbfIH IIx BOJIOrOXCKIIx ceJIH且ePeBeHb <<BO BCeM>>,

KPO-

Me nymery6CTBa l24. HCKJIIOIIIITeJIbHO ml叩OKIIx nPePOraTHB
Io6HJ1cFIB15311，.KopHHIIJImeBKoMeJIbcKHitMoHacTblpb.OH
nOJIyIIHJI HOJIHOe npaBo CyXa l･IaJI KPeCTbHHaMH cBOIIx,瓜epe-

BeHb MI noIIHHKoB BoJIoroLcKoro ye3na (HaMecTHIIKH He
40JDKHbl 6blJIH Cy皿Tb HXくHII B [IeM") . KpoMe ToTo, BoTIIIIllHK MFITe)K 61)aTbeB Ba|cPI,JIIMH III, npPIIIeM IOpmii KaK 6yATo 3axBaTIIJI
PFI3aHbH，叩yrIMc ̲<<y'KpaIIHbll" ro1)ona, a AImpei - Be4Ioo3epo

( <AKT blルIToBcKO-P'yccKororocyllaPcTBa,m3XaHHblE M. noBHap-3aupJIlJ"IIM", Bbln. 1 (1390-1529 rr.). M., 1899, cTP､240) .

１２２ JIOHH, Co6p. ronoBHHa, Nb 54.
１２３
ATH, Bblm. II, JVb 7.
４
１２

UrAHA, rK3 Ho BoJo皿e, Nb 8/2579, 9/2580. B TaKoM o6beMe ｡IIKcmpoBa"gH cyne6HbliHMMyHIrIeT B e皿e 60JIee paHHeii (1528 r.)>Ka-

JIoBaHHoii rpaMoTe KIIpmIJIQ=BeJIo3epcKoMy MoilacTbIpld Ha qeTbIpe
4epeBHM B̲BoJIQcTII TouIHe BoJIoroncKoro ye3na (UrAnA, r,I<a rlo

BoJlome, JVb 4/2575) B (jeBpaJIe l529 E KHpmJIJIO-BeJID3ePcKmii MoHacTblPb nOJIyLII,IJI TapxaHHO-nPOe3>KylO rPaMOTy Ha 6ecnomJIHHHblM
U P O B O 3 , n l ) O " > l < y Ⅲ n o Ky n Ky To B a p o B ( r n B , C o 6 p . C H 6 ． 瓜 / A ,

JVb A II/47, "几68 06.- 72 06.) .
271

Hbl KOMeJIbcKOrO MoIIacTblI)fI 6ecCpOIIHO OcBO60)Kna川ICb OT

八aHII, HMCKMx Ael･ler, MblTam叩yrl'IX nOmJ1IiH l25.
npMIIMHy cToJIb UeAl)oTo o6eJIellHFI BoJIoroncKMx poTLillll
一

U

MOHaCTblPeII Ha40, nO-BH且mMOMy, MCKaTb B pe3KOM oOoCTPe-

IIIIH coUiiaJIbHo-HoJIMTH[lecKoil 60pb6bl B 3ToM paiioHe He
cJ1vIIaiHo rpaMoTa l531 r. co且eP>KI'IT CIIeuHaJI bHblHnyHKT,
OrOBaP HBalO山砿 BOnPOC O CPOKe Bbl30Ba MOHaCTblPCKMX
ｰ

KPeCTbfllI B BeJII1KOKHmKeCKMii Cy及 八aHIIblM nPHCTaBOM:
『 j

yCTaHaB､IIIIBaJICfl (ﾉ皿IH CPOK B rOmy <<OnPilIlb TeX JIIomeII, LITP
eCMH CBOMM 60HPoM nPHKa3aJI O6bICKIIBaTH JIMxMX JIIO4eM,
U

TaTeii m Po360hHIIKoB, M Ha KoTopbIx 6y4eT cJIoBo、mllxOe
B3MoJ]BFIT B TaT6e H B po360e, HIIo fI3 caM! KHfI3b BeJIMKH, no
TeX J1IOneii nOmJ1IO WII1 MOii 4BOI)elll<Oji, a Cy>KIO 1,1x H3…Hʻ川l
MOI1八BOI)eIIKOii>>・Oco6el.IIIoe BllﾚIMallIIe BeJIIIKOKII)I>KeCK()r()
U

ユ

⑰

npaBHTenbcTBa K paiioHy BeJIoo3epa - BoJIor八I)I B KOHlle
20-x -- Ha[la@me 30｣x rombB cBfI3aHO c nonblTKaMM AH4pem

CTapIiuKoro3axBaTIiTbBeJIoo3epo126.
Boo6111e >Ke, cy" no ｡opMyJIaM )KaJIoBaHHbIx rPaMoT,

Mo>KHoToBopIiTbO60co6eHHoMycMJIeHIMcHaLIaJIa20-xro40B XVI B. coUllaJIbl-Io-noJIHTHｴIecKo曲60pb6bI IIMel-IHo B ye3-

"x, pacnoJIo>KeHHblx K ceBepy oT MocKBLI,- B Be>KgUKoM,
U

yrJIHnKoM, HpocJIaBcKoM, BoJIoroAcKoM B FIHB3pcKoH rpaMoTe l524 r・CIIMoHoBy MoHacTblplo Ha ero 6e>KeUKHe lI
y皿HUKIIe ceJIa Ha311aIIaJIocb 4Ba cPOKa HBKH B cyn MQHa-

CTblPcKIIx
KPeCTbHH,
HO
4JIfl
nOHMKliくTaTei》Ⅲ《pO36OIII1II-

KoB>npaBIifeJIbcTBoBblroBapIIBaJIoce6eJpgBo4(6e3yRoIIHo)'
U

nOCblJIaTbHeleJIb皿HKOB<<33anliCbMI1>,127．BJIbroTHoihrPaMoTe l524 r. HayMKe Ko6eJIIo Bac｝mMM III Pa3PemHJI npliU

3blBaTb B IIepHbli JIec nBHHcKoro .ye3na JIIoneih "06pblx, a

He H6emHIIKOB M He TaTeih H He po360iIHIIKoB, a micMeHblx
U

THTJIblx, " II J1IIxHx J1Io,meii, TaTeii liJ1Ii po360iiHIIKoB IIJIH
FI6enHHKoB, KoTopble ll3 KoTopblx roponpU M H3 BoJIocTe曲Bbl6IITbl, H Tex IIM K ce6e He npHHIIMaTH>" 128.
B HaIIaJIe 30-x To,n､oB XVI B. oco6eHHoe o60cTpeHHe coUliaJIbHblxルI nOJIHTHIIeCKIIX nPOTIIBOPeWiII B CeBePl{blx PaIIOU

U

Hax cTPaHbl coLIeTaJIo(､b c oTKPblTblMII (POPMaMI1 1{ello皿I1He125

rn6, Co6p. aKToB II rl)aMoT, JW I-102. B rpaMoTe､nPaB4a, ;Ie 6bUIO

OCBO60那且eHHH OT TaKOii Ba)KHO曲nOBHHHOCTH, KaK nOco皿Hafl CJIyJKOa.

HMeIOTCH ynOMlIHaH”o八Byx mPyrmx rPaMOTaX KOpHMJ.eBy Mq"-

cTbiplo - f528/29 m l530/31 rn (mE, Q 1V, JW a95,皿.8406.-,85) .

１
２６ <AKfb!J̅IIIToBCKo-PyccKororocymapcTBa".",cTp.240
１
２７ Xn, I, Nb 208.
１
２８

AA3、T. l, Nb 285, CTI)、488-489.

272

HHH KpeCTbHII 4)eo"JIaM B 3ana"blX II IO]KHblx ye3八aX・
KpaiiHe HHTepecHo II3BecTIIe l531 r., oTHocH皿eecfl K TePPlI-

TopIm KJIHHa - BoJIoKoJIaMcKa - TBepH II KacaIo山eecH
BoTIIIIH

TeJIb

E30cHMHHcKoii

nfcTbIHH.
-

KJIHHcKoii

CocTaBH-

o630pa apxHBa nycTblHII JIeoH皿 yKa3hlBaJI B

l876 r. Ha rpaMoTy, Tenepb Hem3BecTHylo: <<B l531 rony npH HryMeHe KIIPIIJIJIe, KaK BMHo H3 rpaMoTbl Ha HMH
HKOBa ymaKoBa, 30cHMeHcKHe xPecTbHHe Bbl皿JIHm3noBHIIOBeHIIH IIryMeHa, II() 6blⅡHyCM叩eHbl cynoM)" 129. BepopITHo,
C HOBbIMll lJOI)MaMI[ 3KCnJlyaTa皿mKPecTbHH II aKTHBH3al皿ei Mx KJIaccoBoii 60pb6bl cBfl3aHo HoHBJIeHHe B l532 r.
く瓜OJIrOBOih KHHTII》ⅡI)yrOrO KPyllIIOrO BOTIIIIHIIIIKa 3THX
M eCT­ﾙIocII(b()-BoJIoKoJIaMcKoro MoHacTblpH 13q
HPKyIO KaPTHHy COUmaJIbHblX nPOTI1BOPeIIIIih B ,eOnaJIbIIoi BoTIIHHe BcKpblBaeT yKa3HaH rpaMoTa BacHJIHfI IIl
l 533 r. eXopy PoMonaHoBy o BblcblJIKe c 3eMJIII PH3aHcKoro BorOcJIOBCKOTo MOHacTblPH BaTyPHHa 3a HenJIaTe)K

06POKa II HenOnCyflHOCTb lIryMeHy '31. BaTypHHnEITamCH OCBO60AHTbcH

KaK

oT

nOnlaTHOrO

IiMMyHIITeTa

／

MoHacTblPH
、

（《ⅡOmJI PI H…IIryMelIy...

HHKOTOPblX He

nJIaTIIJI>) ,

TaK H

OT

CyZIe6HOrO (《Ⅱo瓜cy4 cH HM He XaeT)>) . MoHacTblpb He cyMeJI

caMocToFITeJIbHo

3acTaBIITb

BaTVDIIHa

no瓜可HHHTbcH

CBOeii BJIaCTII. 3TOT nPHMeP JHI皿HHhPa3 HoKa3blBaeT, IITo
roCynaPcTBO 3a皿1ImaJ1O ocHoBbI qJeOlaJIbHOrO HMMyHPITeTa
3eMJIeBJIaneJIbUeB, xoTH II orPaHIIIIHBaJIO erO B CBoIO HOJIb3y.

npocJIe)KIIBafl Pa3BIITIIe HMMyHHTeTHoji noJIIITIIKH Bacli.1IIFI III, Mo>KIIo HoJBeCTH HeKOToPble O6皿He HTorII，
B TeIIeHHe Bcero nel)IIona nPaBJIeHHFI BacIIJIIIH III IIMM y H I I c T b l , K a K n P a B I I J I O , n P H H y > K n a J I H C b K y n J I a Te r O C y n a P -

CTBeHHblx HaJIOrOB, a cy4e611blii l1MMyHIITeT *eO"JIoB orPa･
F

j

I - I I ' 1 I I I ' I B a J I c H n V Te M n o c J I e n p B a Te J I b H o r o I I 3 E H T H fl I I 3 B o Tq I I H H o l ' I

IOp lICnﾙIKUHII TFDK6 HO BOnPOCaM mymery6CTBa m Pa360H C
I.I OJIHIIHblM. HCKJIIO[IGHHH II3 3TOrO nPaBIIJIa O6'bFIcHFJIOTCH
f

｡

cy皿eCTBeHHbl Mm叩aKTOPaMH:

一

一

3anaIIeH OOPbObl C cOxPaHHB-

皿ⅢMHcH CaMOCTOHTeJIbHblMII KHH>KeCTBaMH, cOIO30M nPaBII-

TeJIbCTIja C MOCH(bJ1兜HaMII, Pa30PeHHeM H 3allycTel-IIieM
BOTIIHH MIMMyHIICTOB.

'29 JIeollMⅡ．I<JIIIHcKaJI H30cHMeHcKaH nycTblHb II ee aKTbl, cTp. 74.
Ha 3To ynoMIIHaHIMe llame BHIIMaHIIe o6paTHJI B．Ⅲ、Ko p enK" .
130くKHII'ra KJIIoLIeii ll IoJIIwoBafl KH11ra Hoc"o-BoJIoKoJIaMcKoI,o MoHacTLIpFI XVI B.》ⅡojI peJI. M. H. TIIxoMIIpoBa II A. A. 3IIMIma.
M.- J1., 1948.

131 AH, T. I, Nb l34; HPn, Bbln. 1V, cTP、1 22-123.
18

C, M. I<amTaHoB

273

、

Ho KaK 6bl HH 6blJIMI cepbe3Hbl MoTIIBbl oTcTynJIeHH兜BaCIIJIIIFl l l l oT CTI)orO orPaHIIKIHTeJIbHOrO KyPca IIMMyHMTeT1I0曲ⅡOJIIITIIKH MBaHa lII, ｡aKT oCTaeTcH qjaKTOM: nPaBHTeLIIbcTBo

OKa3aJIOcb

He

B

cOCToFIHHm ⅡOCJIenOBaTeJI bHO

IIPOBO八HTb aToT orpal-IH[IIITeJIbHblih Kypc. nepBblitmar K oTcTymlellHIo 6bIJI cJeJIall caMIIM MBaHoM III, Bo3po且ⅡBmHM
cMcTeMy yneJIoB. HoBble y,瓜eJIbHble KHFI3bH cPa3y jKe B3RJII{
l-Ia BOoPy>KeHIIe nPaKTHKy CTaPblx 60JIee HJIII MeHee UenPblx
MMMyHIITeTI-II,IX nO>KaJIOBaI-IHh．BTFIHyTblii B o>KecToIIGHIIyIo
60pb6y c HIIMH, nocTeneHHo cTaJI I)acmH"Tb IIMMyllliTeTIIblG
I11)HBWIerIIH KI)ynHbⅨ巾eoJaJIoB II BacIMJIMih. CTI)aHa 6blJIa
〆

3KOHOMIIIIeCKI'I

H

HO"ilMTIIIIeCKI,I

He

llO4rOTOBJIella

UeMy OrPaHIIIIGHHIO H yHIId)IIKaUIIII IIMMyHHTeTa

一

KO

BCeOO-

F〃a8a

V

C y 4 b B b l ｡ E O 4 A J I b H O r O I I M M y H I I T E TA
B HEPIIO4 PErEHTCTBA EJIEHbl r八ⅢH CKO K

＊

npaBHTeJIbcTBo EJIeHbl r川IIIcKOii nPllmJ1O K BJIacTH B
BecbMa cJIo>KHoii noJIMTH[IecKoii o6cTaIIoBKe. no八もeM coUliaJIbHOi 60pb6bl, KOToPblM OTMeqeH KOHeU KHH>KeHIIH BaCIIJIHH III, 11 060CTPeHIIe OTHomeHIIji c yXeJIbHblMII KHH3b-

flMIIIOPIIeMIIA皿peeMXeJIaJIHnOJIO>KeillleHoBorOnPaBHTeJIbCTBa mOBOJIbl-IO 皿aTKHM. Tpe60BaJIHcb 3HeprHⅢHble
Mepbl X｡ﾉIFI erO ynPOIIeHHFI.

HHKaKIIe McTo[IHIIKH, KpoMe >KaJIoBallHblx H yKa3Hblx
rpaMOT, He CnocO6Hbl O6PHcoBaTb BCe MHOroO6Pa3He nPIIe-

MOB BHyTPellHe曲nOJIHTH KHnpaBHTeJIbcTBa EJIeHbl rJIIIHcKOii oT yTBeP>KnteIIIIH ero y KoPMIIJIa rocynaPcTBeHHOii BJIa-

cTM Io cMepTII pereHTmlI. n. n. CMIIpHoB npIIBJIeK HecKoJIbKO )KaJIOBaHHbⅨ叩aMoT TPol皿e-Cel)rmeBy MoHacTblpIo
l534 r. c UeJIIJIo HoKa3aTb PocT 6eJIoMec'rHoro 3eMJIeBJIaJleHMFI B rOPO"X ' (Te3IIC CaM HO Ce6e nPBOJIbHO COMIIIITeJIbHbI曲ⅡpHMeHHTeJIbHo K 3ToMy BI)eMeHII). H. E. HocoB H3BJ1e-

KaJI H3 rpaMoT 1534-1538 rr. cBeneHIIH o ropoppBIJIx npHKa3IIHKax2. OLHaKo 3TliMIi pa60TaMII noLITII He BcKpblTa llMMyHIITeTHaFI nOJ1I*iTI,II<a PerellTmHnO JIeTOnllCHbIM (II TOJIbKO
IIaCTHIIHO aKTOBbIM) HcTOIIHIMKaM XaPaKTePH3ylOTcFI B JIHTepaType Hal,I60JIee flpKHe co6blTHH BpeMeHII pereHTcTBa EJIeHbl-ⅡoHMKa KHFI3H IOp皿 瓜MIITPOBCKOrO 3, @IIHKB皿aⅡ”
IⅡ. n. CMHpIIoB・nOcamcKIIe JIlonm m mx K"accoBag 60pb6a nlo cepenHHbl XVII B., T. 1. M., 1947, cTp. 104 II cnel.

2 H. E, H o c o B. OIIepKH no HcTopMI MecTHoro ynpaBJIeHHH PyccKoro
rQCynapcTBa nepBoii noJJoBHHLI XVI BeKa. M.- JI., 1957, cTp. 81-84,

.126Ⅲ且p、

3 C. B. B e c e JI o BcK II ii. nocJIelHI"Ie ynieJIbl Ha PycII.­《Ⅲ|CTOPIIIIecKPIe 3anlI'cKI,I>, KH̲ 22;くOIIepKH IIcTop'III CCCP),. nepHo旦巾eo“、3Mfl. KoHen XV-IIa[IaJIo XVII B．M・, 1955, cTp、269-296.
275

18＊

MHTe>Ka 4HXpeH CTaplmKoro 4, !IHTeHcIIBHoe rp"ocTpomTeJTbCTBO 5.

3anaIIa ITocJIGjpBaTeJIIJIIoro BblflcHcHI畑np ollcxo>K,ⅡeHIIH
>KaJIoBallHblx H yKa311blx rpaMoT EJIeHbl rJIHHcKoA B cBH3II
U

《 J

c BHyTPeHIIeHno@/IHTIIKOH ee nPaBHTeJIbCTBa OCTaeTCH B I1C-

ToPHOrP a巾皿且o CHx nOP He pemeHHoii 6.

1．TeppIITopIIaJkbHoe pacnPeJeJIeHIIe
MOcHoBHBIe 3aga項ⅢnePBImx >KaJLoBaHHLIX rPaMOT

IIp aBMTe入BCTBa EXeHLI r入HHCKO h

( 2HBaPb-中eBpajib l534 r.)
Ha BpeMfl pereHTcTBa EJIeHbl rJIIIIIcKoii ( 1 534 - HaqaJIo
1538 rr.) npHxo皿TcFI 74 co6cTBelIHo BeJIHKoKI-IH)KecKHe HMMyHRTeTHble rpaMoTbl, II3 HIIx 65 >KaJIoBallHblx, 9 yKa3Hblx.
I<POMe TOrO, JBe rPaMOTbl 6blJIH BblnaHbl OT IIMeHHHBaHa lV BeJIHKoKHH)KecKIIMH nHcUaMI1.

n oIITHnOJIoBIIHa BCex >KaqJIoBaHHblx rpaMOT nePIIo瓜と
npaBJIeHIIfl EJIGHbl rJIIIHcKoi (35 HoMepoB) oTHocIITcfl K
IIPe3Bbl[IaiHo y3KoMy oTPe3Ky BPeMeHIイーHHBaPlo II ｡eBPaJI Io l 534 m yKa3Hble HMMyHIITeTHble rpaMoTbl oT 3TIIx IByx
MeCH ueB 八o Hac

He nomm'1. 06'beKTbl

no>KaJIoBaHIIH,

IIa-

3BaIIHble B rPaMOTaX, IIaxO皿JTHCb B ye34aX nMIITPOBCKOM

(20 aKToB) 7, Py3cI<oM (ceMb) 8, Ka皿IIIIcKoM (11HTb) 9, 3BeHIIroponcKoM (4Ba) '0, BoJIoUKoM I! 3y6UoBcKoM (o皿H),
yrJI皿KOM, Be>KeIIKOM n HPOCJIaBcKOM (O皿H), nomexoH-

CKOM (O且mH) , BoJIoroncKoM (oIIIH) , MocKoBcKoM (IBa) ,
BJIa皿MIIPCKOM (O皿H) , IOpbeB-noJIbcKoM (o"IH) , Cy3"JIbCKOM M KOCTPOMCKOM (O皿'H) .

rJIaBIIafl Macca >KaJIoBaHHblx rpaMoT (21 113 35), BblnaHHblx B HHBaPe-巾eBpaJIe l534 r., KacaJIacb ye3XoB,
4 H. IJ. C MM p H oB. MHTe>K AHnpeH CTaPl皿Koro 1537 r.­《HcToplIIIecKIIe 3ainH'CIKII>', I<H. 50.

5H・E HocoB. yKa3・co'1., cTp. 74.

6 0 BHyrpeHHeii rIoJIHTMKe nepliona pereHTcTBa cM: H. H. C M H p H o B.
O'IepKHnOJIHTIIIIeCKOii l"IcTOP皿I PyccKoro rocynapcTBa 30-50-x ronoB
XVI BeKa M- JI., 1958, cTp. 19-74; A A. 3 II M H H. Ped)opMIｺI IiBaHa rpo3Horo. M., 1960, cTp. 222-248.

7 yLITeHbl l5 I､paMOT, l､1e ynoM刃ⅢyTbI TO､TbKO JMIITPOBCKIIe 3eM,JIII,
I1 5 aK'I､OB, B KOTOPblX几MIITPOBCKIIe Tel)I)IITOPIIII (1)IIryPllPyIOT BMeCTe
'C |KamlIHcKIIMH, 1)y3cKIIMII II 3BeHHrOPOAcKHMII B Pa31･Iblx KOM6III･IamlflX.

WlicKmoIIIITeJlbHOlly3CKmxrPaMOT-IleTblPe.
9 1ICKmOIIIITeJIbHO I(aml･IHCKIIX rPaMOT­且Be・

10
HCK.MIOIIHTeJIbHO
3BeHIfrOPO,UCKHx
rPaMOT­QⅡHa，
276

O6Pa30BblBaBml'IXJIHKBH且HpoBaHI-lbliiBcaMoMKoHnel533r.
yneJI KHfl3fl lOPHFI IIBaHoBHﾘa nMIITPOBCKOrO (nMMTPOB
KamllH, Py3a, 3BeHHropQX) . OcTaJIbHble TepplIToplIII, nepeIIIIcJIeHHble B HHBapcKo-(beBI)aJIbcKHx rpaMoTax 1534 r.,
⑪

COxPaHHJIII HeCKOJIbKO MeHee CBe)KIIe, IIO e皿e qPe3BblLIaHHO

3aMeTHIjle cJIenbl npe>KHeii aBToHoMHH. qTo6bl HcHo HoKa3aTb 3TO, Mbl 6yneM, rOBOPfl o nellTPaJIbHblx ye31aX, PaCCMaTPHBaTb He ye3nl B UeJIoM, a KOHKPeTHO Te BoJIOCTH, B KOToPblx HOMe皿aJIIIcb ynOMRHyTble rPaMOTaMI1 3eM皿1．

0LHa II3 4BVx MocKoBcKHx rpaMoT 6blJIa naHa Ha ceJIo

lieBJieBo <<B 3aiIocKoBcKIIx BoJIo6THx B Kop3eHeBe H B皿epeHKe>> U BoJIocTII Kop3eHeBo H mepHa 6blJIII cTapl'IHHblMII
yneJIbHOKHFI>KeCKHMII

TePPl'ITOPlIHMII,

BXO"IBmHMII

B

yneJI

npe及皿ccTBejjHIIKalOpIIHEBaHoBII[la-KHH3HIOpHHBqr
CIIJIbeBⅢ【Ia nMIITpoBcKoro. no nepBoMy BapHaHTy n<yxoBHoM

HBaHa lll oIIH n1)enma3HaIIaJIIIcb, oIIeBI"Ho, 10pHIo HBaHoBIIIIy, Ho B cBfl3II c nePenaqei eMy py3bJ IIocJIe CMePTH I'IBaHa BoDIIcoBH'Ia PV3cKoro B

I503 r.

6blJIII oTMe>KeBaHbl oT

L

瓜MIITpoBa l2. IOpbeB､noJIbcKaH rpaMoTa ̲ IIMeJIa B B皿y
3eMJIIi, pacnoJIo>KeHllble B myTKHIIe cTaHe '3, B KoToI)oM TaK>Ke HMem 3eMJIII IOpHi BacIIJIbeBIIII nMIITpoBcKIfi.
K rpaMoTaM 1534 r. IIa nMIITpoBcKo-3BeHIIropoIcKHe

3eMJIH npHMblKaeT rpaMoTa lla ceJIa Haxa611Ho MI I<apayJIoBo B ropeToBcKoM cTalle MocKoBcKoro ye34a '4, 6JIH3KoM K
3BeHIIropoHcKoMyHnMHTpoBcKoMy ye3naM. B nomexoHcKoii rpaMoTe o6beKToM Ro>KaJIoBaHIIfl 6blJIII BJIaneHIIH B

BoJIbcKoih o6JIacTm, KoTopaHⅡeKorna npIIHaXJIe>KaJIa AHnPelO BOJIbmOMy.

yr皿皿K砿m3y6UoBcKIIii ye34bl o6Pa30BblBaJIII ymHⅡKOe

KHH>KeCTBO,

nl)eKPaTHBmee

CBOe

CymeCTBOBaHHe

B

1521 r. CocenHHii c yrJIH[IeM Be>KellK" ye3nl 6blJI yneJIoM

巾aKTHIIecKII JIo l51 1 r" a bopMaJIbHo Lo 1518 r. KocTpoMa,
｡

II3T,flTaFI M3 yneJIbHoro ynPaBJIelIIIH TOJIbKo B TPeTbeH IIeT-

BepTII XV B., 6blJIa onopHblM nylIKToM MflTe>KHblx raJIHuKmx
KIIH3eii, noToMoK KoTopblx B. I'I. meMFIIIIIII npeTeHIoBaJI Ha

raJIImKO-KOCTPOMcKI1e TePPHTOPPIH e皿e npH BaclIJIHH III.
BoJIoroIcK"̅ye3I HaxoIHJIcfr no l481 r. B ynleJIe y AHnpeH
BacHJIbeBI1Ila MeHblnoro.

ll rB几Tp. ､KH. 527, Nb 242, "". 212 06.- 213 06
'2 nmnr, cTp. 354.

13 rnB, Co6p. aKToB II rpaMoT, Nb l-108.
'4 rBJI, Tp. KH. 527, Nb 246, JJ1. 217-218.
277

3eAWI,Ha3BaHHbleBrpaMoTax,KacalomllxcHFIpocJIaB-

cKoro,BJTam"pFKoromCY3na"bcKoroye3HoB,6bIJIIipac-

IIoIIO>KeilbIB6JII13I!BJIanleHIIiiymeJIbHbIXmcJIy)Ke6HblxkHH3ell, a TaK>Ke BJIwITGMIbHenmlIx KIIH>KaT. B HPocJIaBcKoM

ye3ne llMeJIcH yneJI KHFI3eii McTHcJIaBcKI,Ix. BJIaⅡHMHPcKaH

rl)aMoTa oWHocIIJIacb K cJIo60"e B BoJIocTK Menymax 15,
HaXOmlB皿eHCH Hena@ﾉIeKO OT JIyxoBUa, OTnaHHOrO HBa-

HoM III enPPy HBaHOBHIly BeJIbcKoMy KaK cJIy)Ke6HoMy
KHH310 <<B BOTIIHHy…c BoJIocTbMH> 16. CocenH" c BJTa"I-

MIIPoM Cy3XaJIb 6bIJI oKPy>Kell 3eMeJIbHblMII BJIa,meHHflMII
MOry皿ccTBeHIIblx KHH3eit myiicKIIx.

IITaK,
TePPllTOPllambHOe
PacITPenleJIeHIie
flHBaPCKo-q)eBPaJIbcKIIx BeJIHKoKHH>KecKIIx >KaJIoBaHIIblx rpaMoT 1534 r.
BCKPblBaeT BIIOJIHe

onPeneJIGHIIylo

TeHIIeHIIIIIO

B

nOJIHTHKe

npaBI'ITeJIbcTBa EJIeHbl rJIHHcKoii B sTo BpeMH. B >KaJIoBaHHblX rPaMOTaX nPaBIITeJTbCTBO 3aKPenHJIO CBOIO BJIaCTb Han

3eMJTHMII, BXOユHBmHMII B COCTaB HenaBI･IO 川IKBH皿IPoBaHHblx yneJIoB I{JIH pacnoJIo>KeHHbIMII B6JIH3H c巾ep BJIHHHH月

OCTaBmIIxCH yneJIbHblx, CJIy>Ke6Hblx KHFI3e曲HKPynHeiimHx
KHfl>KaThJPIIIIeM rJIaBHOe BHHMaHHe 6blJIo yneJIGHo TePPW-

TOPMM mMHTI)OBCKOrO KH"KeCTBa.

Ii3
JleTOnHCHbIX
HCTOIIHHKOB
H3BeCTHO,
IITO
CO6blTPIH
H;13PeBam cO ̲CTPeMIITeJIbHoii 6blCTpOToih y>Ke B HOcJIMHIIe

且HIi >KH3" Bac"" III. no3HmllI IByx 6paTbeB BeJIIiKoro
KHH3列一IOpHH nMHTpoBcKoTo II A血PeH CTap皿KOrO,OxlGBH旦HO, Cy皿ecTBeHHo pacxoHIIJIIIcb Me>KIy co60#. IOpmii

BO3JIaraJI 60JIb皿I1e Hane>KXbl Ha cMepTb BacIIJIIIH III. BynyIIH CTaPmIIM yneJIbHblM KHFI3eM, oH cTPOHJI mlaHbl 3aXBaTa

"JIIIKoKHH)KGcKoro npecToJIa BacIIJIIIji lll He loBePFIJI

IOpIIIo H cTapaJIcH KaK Mo>KHo IoJIbme cKpbIBaTb oT Ifero
CBOIO 60JIe3Hb l7.

B nepHo4 60JTe3IIII BaclIJI1IFI III oTHomeHIIH AHn-

peH c IOpHeM He TOJIbKo He yJIyLIIIIIwIIIcb, IIo, cKopee Bcero,
O6OCTPHJIHCbe皿e60JIeeAHnpeiiHe6blJI3amHTePecoBaHB

ToM, IITo6bl HocJIe cMepTII BacImHfl BeJIHKoKHH>KecKaH
BJIaCTb nePemJIa B PyKII MOry皿ecTBeHHoro IOPHH. ETo MeHbIIIe cTpamlIJT Ha npecToJIe pe6eHoK IMBaH IV. 3To cneJIaJIo

AH叩eH coIo3HIIKoM BacIIJIPIH III II EJIeHbl rJIHHcKoi Bo
BPeMH CMePTeJIbHoii 60JIe3HH Be,III1KOro KHH3H.
15 rnB, Co6P･aKToB I:I rpaMoT, M I-104.
I6nHnr, cTp､357.

17 nCPJI, T. XIII, BTopaH noJIoBIIHa, cTp. 410-41 1
278

noBemeHIIeAHXpeflBnocJIeJIIMIeIIIHI>KI13IIHBacwIm側III
xaPaKTePli3yeTerO>KeJIaHIIecnOcO69TBoBaTbyWenJIeIWIO
U

npnBHBaHalVHaBeJIHKoKHFDKecKⅡⅢ「IpecToJI.KornaBa-

cHJ1城ⅡIOTKa3aJ1CHOTMbICJIIIJIIIIIHO6JIarOCJIOBIITbl'IBaHFT

60FIcI, 1)accTpoHTb neTcKoG Boo.6pa)Kemle "IHa cBoIIM I13U

Mo)MeilHblM B"oM, !IMelIHo AHnpeii n 60fIpe noKa3aJIII
BacIIJmlo Heo6xo皿IMOCTb 3TOTO川IIIHOrO 6JIaT､ocJIoBeHHflH
U

nOTDe60BaJIIIIIOCJIaTb331/IBaHOMHBe川1KoiiKHHmHeitEJIel

Hoih'18. TV >Ke UeJIb npecJIemoBaJTa 60pb6a A"PefI B KoHTaKTe c ' HaH60JIee n.peXaHHblMI,I BacIIJIHIo III 60FIpaMII
-

(M. C. BopoHIIoBblM II BoJIonKo-TBepcKITM nBopenKHM
m lO mHroHoji-no"<orIIHblM)
nPoTIIB nonbIToK BeJIIIKoro
U

1<1-Ifl3HTIpIIIIHTb
nepen
cMepTbK)
MoHaulecKIIii
qIIH
19
Mo)Kgr
〆

6blTb，cMepTb Bac叩mFIⅡI B MoHalllecTBe rPo3HJIa ocJIaO-

J1GHIIGM
HeoCnOpHMOCTH
BeJIHKOKHR>KGcKIⅨⅡpaB
I'IBaHa
lV.
IOpH#IUe,JIoBaJIKpecTI'IBaHyno瓜皿aBJIGHIIGMIIno3TOMy
HeCtl!IT"CBOeKPeCTOUeJIOBaHIieneiiCTBHTeJIbHblM2q
U

CMepTb BacIMHfl lll Bbl3BaJIa noIITH MoMeHTaJIbHyIo
peaKmllo IOp", nbITaBInerocFI B ̲cBoIIx naJI･.K9mⅡy皿Ⅲx

imallax onePeTbcFI Ha BJIwITeJYbHeimHx KHH3ei myicKIIx,

KoTopl,IxoH･xoTeJIIIepeMamITbKce6GHacJIy>K6y.JIoHJIbHocTb l<HFI3eii mVicKHx no oTHomeH1110 K npaBHTeJIbcTBy
E,JIeHI)I rJIHHCKoi OCTaeTCH BOnPOCOM BecbMa COMHHTeJIbeHHe
HI,IKoHoBcKoii JIeTomlcI,I
JIGTomlcI,I
nonblTKax
I-IblM・Coo6皿eHHe
HI,IKoHoBcKoH
oo nonblTKax
U

U

A. mviicKoro Bo3BecTII IOpMIH Ha BeJ1IIKoKHmKecKI畑Ⅱpe-

cToJI 2｢ Ka>KeTcH HaM npaBIonono6HblM. Bo BcHKoM
cToJ121Ka>KeTcRHaMnpaB瓜oⅡoⅡo6HblM・Bo
cJIy〔Iae，
cJIy[Iae,

ycnexPereHT皿ⅢBneJT6JIHKBImaUIM3aroBopalOp"B3Ha-

imTeJIbIHOii cTeneHII 06"cHHeTcH ee COlO30M c AHnPeeM,
⑪

60FIBmIIMCH eⅡHHoBJIacTHH IOPwT.

11JIGI<Ei6pFI1533r.,KIepe37n(HeHⅡocJIeCMePTHBaCIJ⑪

mIFI III, IOp" y>Ke 6bIJT noca>KeH B TGMHImy, a nplIIIIIcJIeIIIIe ero yneJIa K cOcTaBy BeJIIIIfoTO KIIH)KecTpa CTaJIo IIPe3Bbl[Iaiiflo. Ba>KHoi noJIPITIIIIecKoi 3anaIIeii, C yneJIbHoKHFI>KeCKOii TOIIKI1 3PellHFI BKJIIOIIGIIIIe 3eMGJIb e皿e He yMePmerO
U

ylleJIbHoro K"3H B BeJIIIKoKHH>KeCKylo <<oTIIHIIy》HBJIflJIOcb
ocToIII･IblMCePbe3Hblx
CePbe3HblxCnOPoB，
CnOPoB.
aKToM MaJIoく3aKOHHblM》Ⅲ瓜ocToI冊IblM

3aToIIeHIIe lOPⅡHCVmecTBeHHo II3MeHIIJIO B3alIMOoTHO-

IIIGHIIHMe>KnynPhBIITejlbcTBoMEJIeHbITJIIIHcKoilIA皿peU

U

(JM CTapIIIIKIIM. C oZIHo# cToPoHH, npaBHTeJIbcTBo oKa3a18 TaM >Ke，CTp. 414.
19 TaM >Ke, cTP，417.

20 TaM )Ke, CTp. 420; T. VIII, CT1)、286.
21 TaM >Ke, T・XIII, ilepBaH noJIOBHHa, cTp 78-79.
279

JIo(､b noJIHTII[IeCKHM nOJ1>KHHKoM AIInPefl, KoToPblih 3a COIO3HIIIIeCKIIe neiiCTBIIfl

B

nOCJIenHIIG

JI1冊I

>KPI3IIII

BacIMIIFI

III

Io611JIcfl OT BGJIHKOrO KIIFI3H ilPaBa Ha PaCmlJPeHIIe CBOerO
yneJIa: 0'JeBIInHo, eMy o6enlaJIII BoJIoUKIIi ye3J:22. noBene-

HHe AHnpeH Bo BpeMFI JIIIKBHJIanHII 3aroBopa lOpmFT TaK>Ke
Tpe60BaJIo Bo3Harpa>KnelIIm. TaKIIM o6pa30M, y AHnpefl
HaKOnlWIcH Pfm 3eMeJTbHblx nPeTGI･I3m仇 K nPaBHTeJIbCTBy
ご

EJIeHbI TJIIIIIcKo曲. B HHBape l534 r. AHnpeii CTapImK", He
ye3>Kag ll3 MocKBbl B cBoi yneJI,《IIplmpamlIBaJI>> y EJIeHbl
rJIHIIcKohくK CBOeii BOT[mIIe rOPOnOB>> CBePX TOrO, IITO GMy
割

3aBemaJIocb B XyxoBIIoih rpaMoTe l'IBaHa lll. npaBIITeJIbcTBo nonblTaJIocb yMI1PoTBOPHTb AHXPeH 60raTblMHⅡonap／

KaMH（《ⅡoIITHJIH

erO,

KaK

npe>Ke

Toro

no

nPeCTaBJIeHIIH

Beml1KI'Ix KHH3eit 6PaTbe naBa川I, a eMy naJTII II cBbIme: naBaJIII eMy my6bl, II Ky6KII, II KoHMI IIHoxo皿b' B CeJIJ'eX)') ,
HO TBe"O OTKa3aJIO eMy B rOPOnaX 23.
C 叩yrOii CTOPOHI.I,《noIIMaHIIe>D 10pIIH cneJTaJIo AH"
u

nPefl

enlYHcTBGIIHblM

nelIcTBIITeJIbHblM

yneJIbHblM

KIIH3eM

一

MOCKOBCKOrO

nOMa,

naBaFI

nlI皿yel℃IIeCTOJIIOO IIIOHⅡpe-

BPalllaH erO B nOTGHUHaJIbHOrO nPOTHBHHKa nPaBHTeJIbCTBa.

OTKa3 EJIGHbl TJIHIIcKo# oT BblnoJIIIGHIIH 3eMeJIbHBIx TDe60L

BaHIIih AImpefl G皿e 6oJIee yxy旦皿IInHx B3aHMooTHomeHHH・
qPe3Bbl[IaiiHafl aKTIIBIIocTb PereHTmII B ne,IIe 3aKPemleHIIH
3a BeJIHKHM KHFI3eM yneJIbHoro KHfDKecTBa lOp" nMHTPOBCKOTO KPa伽Ie o6ecnoKoIma AHnpeH, KIbII BJIaneHIIH
(CTapllUa II BepeH) IIaxo皿mIIcb B6JIH3H 3anaXHoii IIacTH
JMMTpoBcKoro ymeJIa - Py3bI II 3BelII1ropona. qepe3 HecKoJIbKo XHeii nocJTG Toro, I<aK EJIeHa rJIHHcKaH B〉KaJIoBaH-

Hoi rpaMoTe TpoIIne-CeprPIeBy MoHacTblpIo Ha MoIIacTblPCKHe BOTIIPIHbl BO BCex IIeTblPeX ye3,naX JIIIKBHXIIPOBaHHOrO
yneJIa

nocTaBIIJIa

noH KOHTPoJII) npaBIITeJIDCTBa

nPllcOe且Ⅲ-

HeHHyIo TepplITopHIo (4 m1BapH) 24, AHnpeii BblnaJ1 ]KaJIoBaHHylo rpaMoTy HocH｡o-BoJIoKoJIaMcKoMy MoHacTblPIo
Ha nBop B CTap皿e (9 HHBapH) 25, nblTaHcb 3THM ynpoqHTb
CBOIO BJIaCTb B UellTPe nPlIHa4JIe>KaBmerO eMy KHH>KeCTBa.

CJIenoBaTeJIbl-Io, BblnaIIa >KaJToBaHIIblx rpaMoT, yTBep>KXaBmHx cyBepeHHble noJIHoMoqIIFI BeJIHKoTo KIIH3H B o6JIacTHx, KoToPble HBJIHJIHCb yneJIaMH IMHTPoBCKOro II BOJIoU22

A、A. 3 H M II H. KH"KecKIIe nyxoBHble rpaMoTI)I HaIIaJIa XVI B.《Ⅲc'ToplmecKIIe 3a,TIwcKH>, KH. 27, cTp. 284.

２３ nCPJT, T. XIII, BTopaH no.JToBHHa, cTp. 428.
２４
UrAHA, rK3 no nMHTpoBy, Nb 45/3757.
２５

A｡3HX, w. 111, M 129.

280

KoTo KHH3ei, 6blJIa o6ycJIoBJIGHa TeM, IITo YIPaBa Ha HHx

oCnaPHBaJIHcb
CTOPOI-IHIIKaMII
yZIeJIbHOKHH>KecKOM
OnnO3H-

Ⅱ皿. npHcoe皿HeHIIe nMIITPOBCKOro ynteJIa, OKIeB皿HO, BH-

3BaJIOFIPOcTbKHH3ehmy#ckHx,H3naBHacBH3aHIIblxcIOpHGM. AⅡ瓜peii CTaplmKI1i MoI、PaccIIIITblBaTb Ha BoJIbcKylo
Bo､IIocTb nomeXOHCKOrO ye3na, BXO瓜ⅢB皿ylo HeKorIIa B yneJI

AHⅡpeH yr川mKoro. KpOMe ToTo, oH npeTelmoBaJI Ha BoʻⅢOnKIIii ye3m m, BO3MO)KHO, IIa HeKOTOPble叩yme 3eMJIII,

cKopee Bcero I.Ia BoJIomy II BeJIoo3epo.
nO3HⅡI頂 皿yiCKIIX H, B qaCTHOCTH, nO旦瓜eP>KKa HMPI

IOpmg
nMIITpoBcKoro
Bbl3bIBaJIa
ona8eHIIH
EJIeHblMIIQTpg60BaJTa yKpenJTeHmRBemIKOKH"KeCKOH BJIaCTII B PalIoHe PO-

noBoro rHe3na myi(､KIIx - Cy3maJIe. HMeHHo HanpmKeHHblMII B33HMOOTHOmel･IwIMn npaBIITeJTbcTBa c myiicKHMH
O6TJFICHFIeTCH BblnaIIa >KaJIOBaHIIOM rPaMOTH IIa BJIanleHIIFI B
Cv3naJIe･
＝

CMepTb BacIIJIIIFI III II MaJIoJIelcTBo HBaHa lV BPI3BaJIH

aKTHBmdanlIIo He ToJIbKo IOp" nMIITpoBcKoro II AHnpeH
CTapmKoro. no Bcei BepoHTHocTH, oHII nopo"" o>KIIBJIe-

HIJe . B cpene, 6JIII3Koi lt yXeJIbHEIM KHfl3bHM. Bo3Mo)KHo,
na>Ke Pa3naBaJIHCb rOJIOCa B noJIb3y BO3BPameHIIH yneJIa
ⅡMIITpmo A皿PeeBIIIIy, C皿eBmeMy B TIOPbMe C CeMHJIeTHe-

To B63pacTa. nMIITplI# 6blJI cblHoM A皿pefl BoJIbmoro,
BJ1aIIeBmero yrJIH[IeM II Be>KeIIKoM. BoT noIIeMy TaKoe 60JIb-

IIIoe 3HaIIeHIIe HMeJIa BHmaIIa >KaJIOBaHHOii rPaMoTbl Ha 6e>KelIKO-yrJ1HIIKHe 3eMJIH.

HaKoHeU, He Bbl3bIBaGT coMI-IeHIIii onacHa列ⅡJIH BeJIHKo-

KHH>KeCKOrOnPaBHTeJIbCTBaaKTIIBM3auHfIBIIPOCJIaBCKOM
ve3ne vxeJIbHoTo KHH3fl enopa MIIxaiJIoBII[Ia McTIIcJIaB6Koro .Enle B
nocJIe皿城roX >KH3HH
BacIIJIIｲRIII enpp
MMIxaiJIoBIIq Ha[IaJT VKpenJIFITb cBoHⅡO31mlIH B 9POCJIaB-

｡JIe 26, B cBH3H c IIeM BacMMHi lll Bo BTopo向ⅡoJIoBHHe

1533r.cTpeMIIJIcFI3apyIIIJTbcflno皿ep>KKOh巾eonaJIOBTeX
TeppMITopmi, KoTopble naxoMJIIIcb Ile"JIeKo oT flpoCJIaBcKbio y63JIa, oco6eHHo KocTpoMcKIIx " OTcIo" ̲gT.aHoBIITcH

noHFITHo#nPm叩HanpenpcTaBJIGHIIHBHaIIaJIel534rfeJImKOKI-IH>KeCKIIX >KaJIOBaHHblX TPaMOT Ha 3eMJIII B PaHOHaX

fIpocJIaBJIFI II KocTpoMbl.

CopOcTaBJIeHIIe PeaJIDHOii PaccTaHOBKH CIIJI ymeJIbHO-

KIIH>KecKoTo cenapaTII3Ma B Ha[IaJIe l 534 r. c yneJ1bHblMH
26 UrAHA, TI<3 no HI)ocJIaBJIIo, JVb 8/14758.
27 Arp, T､I, Nb 39; <AKTbI IOmKoBa:", ､Nb l32
281

TPa皿mmRMII ye3JDB II BoJIOcTeii, oKa3aBmIIxCFI B neHTPe

BHIIMaHHH HHBaPcKO-のeBPaJIbcKIIx >KaJIoBaHIIblx rPaMOT
1534 r., noKa3blBaeT, IITo IIHTepec nPaBIITeJIbcTBa K̅ 3TIIM
TeppHTOpHHM 6blJI rJly60Ko o60cIIoBaHHblM. HepaBHoMepHOCTb Pa3BHTIIFI SKOHOMIIKHPOCCHH, 06ycJIoBIIBmaH cymeCTBoBaHHe yneJIbHbIx KIIH>KeCTB, B o6cTaHOBKe 3aBePmeHIIJI
UeHTP a川畑aToPcKOrO nPoUecca OKa3blBaJIa 60JIbmOe BJIHR-

HIIe Ha noIJIHTHKy. HaJIHqlle tlepT II TPan1m戒 yneJIbHOii
aBToHoMIIII y[IIITblBaJIocb nPe>Kne BCero caMIIM BeJIHKOKIIH-

>KecKHM npaBI,ITeJIbcTBoM BoJIoK II TBepb ynpaBJTHJIHcb cneuHaJIbHblM TBepcKIIM nBopnoM, PH3aHb H BoJIoMa - PH3aHcKIIM IBoplloM, yrJIHII II 3y6noB - yrJII皿KIIM. BcKope

nOCJIe《ⅡoIIMallIIFI> IOpHH Bo3HHK IMIITpoBcKHh皿open,
Be｡mKoKHFI>KecKoe npaBIITeJIbcTBo BI]mBI1raJIo Ha noJI>KHOCTIJ TePPHToPHaJIbHbIx IBOPeUK1IX Oco60 10BePeHIIblX JIIo-

JIei. BacIMIIii lll, 31IaH Bo3Mo)KHble npeTeH31III y八eJIbHbIx
KHFI3eii (B KoHne l 533 m KoHKpeTHo A皿peF') !'a BoJ'oK,
KPahIIe Bo3BblcIIJI BoJIoUKo-TBepcKoro mBopenKoro m. 10. mIIroHy-nomKorlIHa, HMeBmero BoTIIPIHbl B paiioHe TBeplI II
BoJ1oKoJIaMcKa. STHM oH, B uacTHocTII, cTpeMII､JI'cH HaihTH
onoPy B CPene BoJIoUKo-TBePCKHx巾eOlaJIOB, OT KOTOPblX
U

B 3HaIIHTeJIbHOH MePe 3aBHCeJI ycnex IIJIII HeycITeX yneJIbHO-

KHfl>KecKIIx nonbIToK 3axBaTIITb BJIacTb B BoJIoIIKoM Ve3nC.

Bo BpeMH 60JIe3HII BacIIJIHH IIImHrOHa 6blJI, Ka>KeTCFI,
caMblM npH6JIH>KeHHblM K BeJIIIKoMy KHH310 JIHuOM 28.
Ba>KHbIM IonoJIIIHTeJIbHblM HcToIIHHKoM, cBIiXeTeJIbcTBylOml'IM B nOJIb3y npHBemeHIIOrO O6'bfICHeHIIH IIOJMTHIIecKI1x nPHIIHII TePPIITOPHaJIbHOro PaCnPeneJIeHHfl HHBaPCKo-

巾eBPaJIbcKIIx

BeJIMIKOKHg>KeCKHx

)KaJIOBaHHblX

rPaMOT

1534 r., HBJ1HeTcH Kon"HaH KHIira TpoIme-CeprlIeBa MoHacTbl", cocTaBJIeHHaH B .eBpaJIe l534nnoHH皿IIaTHBe
HJIH noX PyKOBOHCTBOM nPaBI1TeJIbCTBa. PaCnOJ1O>Kel-IHe B
lleii MaTePHaJ1a O6HaPy>KIIBaeT OCO60e BHIIMaI冊Ie 叩aBmU

'reJ1bCTBa

K

TeM

KOMnJIGKCaM

TepPlITOPHH,

HO4BJIaCTHOcTb

KoTOPblx BeJIIIKOMy KHH310 3aKpenJIHJIacb 'B )KaJIoBaHHblx

rpaMoTax HaKIaJ1a l534 r. B nepBylo rpynny 3neCb Bblne"eHbl aKTbl Ha 6blBmlIit yneJI AHnpeH BoJIbmoro - yrJIHⅡKIm
II Be>KeUKI,Ii ye3nb1. 3aTeMHユeT HM IITPOBCKH前Pa3JIeJI, Kyna
BKJI1OIIeHbl He ToJ1bKO XMRTPOBO-Py3CKHe

XoKyMeHTbl, Ho

H

rl)aMOTbl, KaCalO皿ⅡecR BoJ1ocTH BopII-Kop3GHeBa 11皿yTI<HHa cTaHa lOpbeB-noJTbcKoro ye3na. AIIaJIorIIIIHblii Mo28

nCP几T. XIII, BToPafl no.TIoBIIHa, cTp. 409-417
282

MeHT Ha6JIIOAaJTCH B reOrl)a巾H[lecKoM PacnPelleJ1eHIM )Ka-

JIoBaHHblx rPaMoT ｡eBpaJIH I534 r. Ho HaH60J1ee fIpKo BBIHCHHIOTCH nO KonMHHoH KIIHre叩eTGH3HII AHnpefl CTapHUKOrO (xOTH M He BCe) : B OT4eJ1e CTaPl皿KMx IOKyMeHTOB, HaPfmy CO CTaPIIILKO-BePelICKHMH aKTaMH, nOMe皿eHbl MaTeU

U

U

7

U

PmaJIbI,OTHOCHmHecFI
K3aMocKoBcKoh
BoJIocTH
Kop3eHeBy
H roPeToBcKoMy
cTaHy (IIMeloTcH, B [laCTHOCTH, Pa3.be3>KHe
』
15181529 rr. Ha 3eMJIII ceJ1a Haxa6IIHa) 29.
U

B HamIcaHHoM o4HoBpeMeHHo c KHIIToli nepeIIHe HenonlTBeP>KneHHblx rPaMoT To>Ke yneJIGHo MHoI､o MeCTa aKTaM

HaTePPHTOPIM,HBJIHB皿I'1eCHO6'beKTOMBO3MO>KHblXIOMOraTeJIbcTB KHH3H AH叩efl, B ToM IIMcJIG Ha BoJIbcKylo BoJIOcTb nOmeXOIICKOTO Ve3na30. rPyIInlIPOBKa BCeX 3TIIx MaTePmaJIOB yDJIBHTeJ1bIIO IIanOMI冊IaeT KaPTIIHy, CO3nalOmylO-

cH̅ nPli
」 l13WeHIIII (beBpaJIbcKIIx )KaJ1oBaHHblx rpaMoT 1534 E
B HTore cpaBHHTeJIbHoro IIccImeXoBal冊IFI aKToBblx, JIeTOnlIcHblx HcToIIH}IKoB I'I TpOI,lUKoII KOⅡⅡⅢI-IOII KIIHTII BH八HO, IITO
KaK KonHHHaH KHMI､a, TaK H >KaqJIOBal･IHble rPaMOTbI Haqa,IIaj
U

U

U

U

J

U

1534 r. npecJIeXoBaJIIi UeJIb lleHTPaJIII3auHHyneJTbHOKHH>KeCKIIX nDHTH3aHIm H
CKHXⅡDHTR3aHHH
H CenaPaTH3Ma
CenaPaTI13Ma BJ1HHTeJIbHblX
BJIHHTeJIbHblX KHH>KaT・
KHH>KaT.

Co血ajlbHbliCOCTaBil)aMOTql1KOBBHHBaPe-巾eBpaJIe
1534 r. 6blJI o4Hopon,GH: >KaJIoBaHHble rpaMoTbl nPllo6PeJIH
KpynHeihmHe pyccKMe MoHacTblpll. no KoJIHIlecTBy noJIyIIGHロ

ユ

ー

Hblx HMMVHIITeTHblx aKToB Ha nepBoM MecTe cToFIT MoHa-

cTblPII Tpo皿e-CeprmeB (18) 31 II HocII巾o-BoJIoKoJIa McKIm
(ceMb)32;3aHI1MIIcJIenyloTBoJIoroncK砿①ePanoHToB(Kle、

Tblpe)33,
KIIpmJIJIo-BeJIo3epcKH仇("a)34,MocKoBcKIIiiCIIMoHoB(o皿il)35,CaBBo-CTopo>KeBcKmih(o皿H)36,y皿皿一
KH曲 nOKPOBCKIIii (O皿H) 37, BoJIoroIcKIIii rJIym皿K皿
U

｡

(o皿H) 38.
29C・M. 1< a m T a H o B. KonHiiHble KHIIrH TpoHUe-CeprlleBa MoHacTblpH
XVI BeKa.­<3amlcKII oTneJla l)yKonliceit rocynapcTBeHHOk 6jl6JIHoTeKII CCCP HM. B. If. JIeHIIHa>, Bbln. 18．M., 1956, cTp、16-18.
30 TaM >Ke, cTp. 13, npHM. 54.
31 Xn, I，恥302, 317-333.
32 A3MX, U. 11, Nh !130-136.

33 Arp, T. I, Nb 421 PI'1B, T、32, JYb l29-130; JIOHII, Ko""．1 15,
M 444, n. 11-11 06.

34 rnB, ' Q - IV - 1 136, ILI 732-733; TaM別〈e, Co6P Cn6. ZI/A,
Nb A I/17, "907 06.

35 mB, Co6p. aKToB M rpaMoT, Nb l=!"
36 JIOHI,I, Cb6p. aKToB no l613 r., Nb |1/93.

37くHPocJIAgcKIie
ry6epHcKHe
BemMocT",
1855,
qacTb
HeoqJIiUmambHafI,
Nb 48, cTp. 435-436.

38 UrAnA,TKS IIo Bo"orne, Nb lO/258 1 .
283

U

TpoⅢuKIIiiIIHocII(bo-BoJIoKoJIaMcKIIiiMoHacTblPIIHe
L 7

C@myulaHHO OKa3aJIIICb B 3TO BPeMFI rJIaBHblMII nOJIy[IaTeJIflMH

>Ka.10BaHHblx rpaMom JpoHUe-CeprlieB MoHacTblPb llrPa"
oIIeHb Ba>KHylO PoJIb B JMHTPOBcKOM ymeJIe, flBJI"Cb onmlM
II3 00raTelmlllx 3eMeJIbHblx cO6cTBel-IHIIKoB BO BCex LIeTblPex
ye34ax KIIH>KGCTBa li nPe班且e BCerO B JMIITPOBCKoM ye3ne,
〆

U

皿e IIOMe皿aJIcfl UeHTp yne.ma. HocIiq)o-BoJIoKoJIaMcKIM MoU

1

I-IaCTblPb HaXO八HJICH B ry皿e y4eJIbHOKI-IFI>KeCKIIX TePPllTO-

pliih.EroorpoMHoeBJIIIHHIIeBBoJIoKoJ1aMcKoMye34e;bTaBmeM nPe4MeToM [IecTo.'IIo61'IBblx Bo>KneJIGHIfii AIInpeH CTa-

pl皿KOrO, a TaK>Ke B ye3nax JMHTI)OBcKoM M Oco6eHHo

Py3cKoM,coc"HeMcBoJIoKoJIaMcKIIM,neJIaJIoLIIflnpaBHU

TeJIbCTBalleO6XOﾉIIIMblMTGcIIblHcOIO3C3TIIMMOHaCTblPeM.

JIeTomlCmmOKa3bIBaIoT,[ITOII3BcexMOHaCTbIPcKIIxieonaJIoB B I1eplIo4 60JIe3HII BacHJIHI III K BeJIHKOMy KHH310
OblJImlleiICTBIITePbHOnPll6JIH>KGHbITOJIbKOTPOMmKMeHBO〆

L D

nouKI,IecTapUbl39.BKoHUel533r・liryMeH
­ TpomUe-CeprHeBa MOHaCTblPH HOaCa巾nPeBOcxO皿JI CBOIIM BJIHHHHeM CaMOrO MMTPOnOJIHTa naHIIIIJIa.

KcTaTH, oTcyTcTBIie B 1 534 r．>KaJIOBaHHblX rPaMOT
MIITPOnOJIH｣jbeMy nPMy, KPynHOMy 3eMJIGBJIameJIbUy n;MHT-

poBcKoro, 3BGHIIropon<cKoro II Py3cKoro ye3nIoB, cEH3aHo c
U

HenocTaToIIHO
no3
HeⅡocTaTouHOonPeneJIeHHOIi
onPeⅡeJIeHHOHno3皿Heih
MIITPOnOJIIITa naIIIIHJI2,̲ Ile nomb30BaBmerocR B 1533 r. npBepHeM BacH-

JIHfI III, KOToPbli BHaIIaJIe cKPblBaJI OT Hero, KaK H oT MHorHx npyrHx, cBoIo 60JIe3Hb 40. OTcyTcTBIfe B l534 r・班aJIo妙

Bal-[IlblX rPaMOT BI'IIHeHmGMy 3eMJIeBJIa,neJIbuv KamHHcKoro

ye3"KaJIH3IIHyMoHacTbIPIoo6bfIc"eTcHJ7cTaHoBJIeHmeM
TecIIoro KollTaKTa

Me>Kﾕy3THM

MoHacTblpeM II IOpHeM

JMIITPoBcKHM B 1530-1533 rr., Korna Bac皿砿III nblTaJIcH
JIH皿HTb lOpHH no及旦eP>KKH MOHacTblPem, HaxOIIIBmIIxcH B
U

IlpeneJIaX BeJIIｨKOrO I<HFDKeCTBa 41.

BMecTecTGM,CaBBo-CTopoJKeBcKHiiMoHacTblpb,[Ibli
U

BOTIIHHbI, KaK II KaJIFI3HHCKI'Ie, HaXOII1JIHCb HCKJIIOIIIITeJIbHO

B yXeJIe lOpHFI IMIITpoBcKoro, He 6bl" B TaKoh 3aBIIcHMocTH
⑪

oT IOp", KaK KaJIH3IIHMoIlacTbIpb,I! He IIMeJI c IOpmeM
cToJIb dm3KHx oTHomeHHih. STo II noIIFITHo. B oTJIIIIIIie oT
｡

⑪

Ka皿HHa, 3BeHHropon,cK" FI Py3cK" ye34bl, rme 6blJIH pac３９
IJCPJI, T. XIII, propaH
４０
TaM >Ke, cTp. 410.
４１

noJIoBHHa, crp 409-419

Bo39!11!eHI1el<am31IHaMoHacTblpflBynleJIelOp"BHa!IaJIe30-xI,o/IoBXVI
B.II()K213alloIIaMIIBc.I､aTbe《lI31ICTOPII'IIIOCJIe八HllxyAeJIo”
("Tpy,ublMrHAH>,T10.M.,1957,cTp.299).
284

110JIo>KeHbl BJIaleHI'IH CaBBo-CTopo)KeBcKoro MoHacTblpH,
U

Benamlicb nO IlacTH yrOJIoBHblx nPecTynJIGHHM IleHTPaJIbl･IblM

npaBMTeJII,cTBoM 42. TaKIIM o6pa30M, BJIacTb yneJIbHoro KHfl3FI3八ecb 3aMeTHO OCJIa6JIJIJIacb BeJIHKoKHJI>KeCKHM KOHTPo-

JIeM. npaBIITeJIbcTBo EJIGHbl TJIMHcKoM, oLIeBHnHo, BnoJIHe
PaCCKIHTbIBaJIO Ha 6JIarO>KeJIaTeJIbHylO nO31皿IIIo CaBBo-CTo』

Po>KeBCKorO MOIIacTblPH, BblnaBaH eMy >KaJIoBaHHyIO rpaMO-

Ty､-Ipe3BblIIaiiHo IIHTepecIIa npaBHTeJIbcTBeHHafl HoJIIITIIKa

B OTHonleHHH6eJIO3ePCKO-BoJIOroXCKIIx MoHacTblPe曲- KIIplfJIJIo-BeJ1o3epcKoro II ｡epanoIIToBa. npenpcTaBJIeHHeM IIM
rpaMOT l･Ie Ha BoJIorO4cKIIe, a Ha nMHTPOBcKIIe 3eMJIII pereHTula n061IBaJIacb yKPe｢IJIeHHH cBOero nOJIo>KelIHFI KaK B

BoJIorne, TaK H B HMM'rpoBe, T. e. nPIIHHMaJIa Mepbl oZIIo-

BpeMeHHo npoTHB cTopoHIIPIKoB IOpIIH H AIInpefI.
Ba>KHocTb FIHBapcKo-(beBpaJIbcKIIx >KaJIoBaHIIblx rpaMoT
1534 r・He HCIIePmbIBaJIaCb JIHmb TeM, IITO C IⅨⅡOMOmblO

3aKPelIJTflJIIIcb ycnexH IleHTPaJIII3aToPcKO曲ⅡOJIIITHKII PyCcKorO nPaBHTeJIbcTBa H I-IaHOcIIJICJI ynaP nO ymeJIbHOKHfDKeCKOH OnnO31IuHH. O[IeBI皿IIo, 06皿ei, Ho HoKa e皿e MaJIo Hc-

cJIenoBalIHoi IIepToii llpoUecca UeHTpaJIH3aUHI1 6blJIo oco6eHHoG o60cTpeHIIe conMaJIbIIoii 60pb6bl B npHcoe且ⅢHfleMbIx
TeppllTopwIx. >KaJIoBaHHI)le rPaMoTI)I IIpeUcTaBJTFIIoT co60#
nOLITH e41ilICTBellHbliI HCTO[IIIHK, 1103BOJ1flloUI1W HaMeTIITb

3Ty npo6JIGMy, II60 B̲60JIbmlIIIcTBe JIeToIIHcHblx naMHTHI,IKoB
U

OCBe皿aIoTcH

TOJIbKo

CaMble

HPKHe

MoMeHTbl

KIIIaccoBOH

60Pb6bl, O KOToPblx IIeJIb3FI 6blJIo yMoJI'IaTb. yCIIJIeHHe COUlMaJIbHblx npoTIIBoPeumii B 1533-1534 rr. B HIIx Boo6me
He OTPa>KeHO・flBJIFIHCb 'Op皿IILleCKHMH nPOBOIHHKaMII
CJ1O>KHOii BeJIIIKOKIIH>KeCKOi nO｡mHTHKII, >KaJIOBaHHble rPaMOTbl OTBe[laIOT Ha liHTePeCylO皿IIG Hac BOIIPOcbl H3blKOM nPa-

BOBblx 1IoPM, TPe6yl()mJ1x LIacTo TmaTeJIbHoro CPaBHeHIIH c

HOPMaMM IIPenbmymllx rPaMOT, 6e3 LIerO 3aTPynHHeTCH BblU

U

HBJIeHHe lIX KOHKPeTHOII KJIaCCOBOII HanPaBJIeHHOcTII.

KJIaccoBaH cymHOCTb >KaJIOBaHI-IblX rPaMOT COCTOHJILI

nPe>Kme B6erO B TOM, [ITO OHII yKPemlFIJIH巾eonaJIbHyIO co6CTBel-IHOcTb Ha 3eMJII(). HIITeHcIIBHO paCmHpHBmeecH B XVXVI BB. MoHacThlpcKoe 3eMJIeBJIaneHHe He MorJIo o6ecneLIIITb ce6e OnmHaKOBOii CTeneHM MOIIOIIOJIIIII Ha BCe IIaCTH

3axBa'IeHHbIx HM TeppHToplm. O6JIanallHe nameHIIblMⅡ
VTonbFIMH II HaceJIGIIHblMII MecTaMH (ceJIaMII, nepeBHHMII,
42 C]L TaK IIa3blBae]1ylo MocKoBcKyIo
BDIIL 111, cTp 167-169).
285

3almc1]

o

nymery6cTBe

(nPn,

nOwlIIHKaMH II T. n.) IIMeJIO nPOIIHble 3KOHOMII[IeCKIMe lI IOPllヘ

HIIIIeCKI'IeO60CHOBaHH兄.MOHoHOJIbHOellPaBoCO6cTBeHHo6TI1
I･Ia JIeca M BOIoeMbl 6blJIO roPa340 60JIee CJIa6blM MecTOM
IIIIeCKoII H"cTPOAKe q)eO"JIbHOro 3eMJIeBJI"eHHH,
BIOP皿HIIeCKoHHa及cTPOHKeq〕eO“JIbHOro3eMJIeBJIa“H”，
U

TaK KaK OcHoBa 3THx nPaB ]IeHbme CBfl3blBaJIacb c 3KOHoMIIU

[IeCKoHcTPyKTyPO曲巾eO4aJIbHO曲申OPMbl3eMeJIbHoihCo6cTU

¥eHHocTm.>KaJIoBaHHblerpaMoTblXV-XVIBBHmPa3yHe

｡oPMyJIIiPOBaJIH
3anPe皿eHIIH
nOCToPOIIHIIM
JI皿aM
nPHxOⅡHTb B MOIIaCTblPCKHe JIeCa,nJIH c60Pa BaJIe>KHI1Ka, flrO瓦HJIH
一

rpIIOOB.

KMaPKCBCBH3HCBOnPOCOMOnOJIb30BaHHII｡eOnaJIbHbIMIi JIeCaMH yKa3blBaJI:《…HCTOIIHIIK

BCHKOrO

O6bIIIHOrO

一

nPaBa OenHblx 33KJIIQ[laeTCH B HeonPeXeJIeHHoM xaPaKTePe
U

HeKoTopbIx BMoB co6cTBellHoCrIL B cIIJIy TaKoii neonpene-

JIeHHOCTH 3TII BHIbl lle HBJIHIOTCFI 川I 6e3ycJIoBHo
ｰ
[IaCTHOih,
U

U

HH
6e3yCJIOBHO
O6皿eit
CO6CTBeHHOCTbI(),
nPeJICTaBJIHH
CO60it
TO CMemeHHe 'IaCTHorOⅡny6JIH[IHoro npaBa, KoTopoe Bbl-

cTynaeI nePenLHaMH Bo BCeX cpenHeBeKOBblx yCTaHOBJIeHHFIX>> 43;《… B o6b円aflX) HBJIHIO皿HxcFI O6blIIaHMH BCerO
＝

OeJIHoro

KJIaCCa, c BePlll]IM

HHcTIIHKToM

HoJMeIIeHa aTa

"eomoβ”ze""QJzcTOpoIIaco6cTBeHHOCTP防44.BpyccKoMrocynapcTBe ,mo BTopoHnoJIoBHHbl
cy且apcTBe且o
BTopoii noJIoBHHbl XV B・py6HTb瓜epeBbH
B. py61ITb n<epeBbH B
ʻﾉIecaX 3eMJIeBJI"eJIbUeB, IIQ-B"HMoMy, He 6bIJIo 3anpemeHo,

ⅡOXO6HoToMyKaKe皿eBXVIB.He3anpe皿aJIocbco61IpaTb

B HHx BaJIe>KHHK, HroAbl lIJIH rpII6b1. PocT ｡eoXaJIbHoro
3eMJIeBJIanellHH II KJIaccoBoih 60pb61,I B KoKIUe XV B. npIIBeJI
K ycTaHQBUeHIIIO sToro 3allPelUeHIIFI B "Xe )KaJIOBaHHblx

rPaMoT 45. Bbl八arla zKa,JIoBaHI-IblX rpaMOT Ha JIeca, KaK nPa"
品

BHJIo,3jlaMGHyeT60JIbmoeo60cTpeHHecoUHaJIbHblxnpoM⑪

BOPeIIHH B ye3Aax, nme llaxO皿皿IICb O6'beKTbl HO>KaJIOBaHH兄．

H3 flHBaPCKO-｡eBPaJIbCKIIx rPaMOT HecKOJIbKO aKTOB KacaeTCfl HMeHHO MOHacTblPcKI1x JIecOB, BbIPy6aBmIIxCR nOCTo-

POHHIIMII JIHⅡaMII-ⅡOCanCKI1MH JIIOIbMH H KPeCTLHHaMH
ノ

(nBgPUOBblMH,JlePHocomHblMH,60HpcKHMHHXp.).
rPaMOTbI 6blJIII BbmaHbl KPynH"mHM JIeCOBJIaneJIbUaM
｡

且MIITpoBcKoro yneJIa - MoHacTblpFIM Tpo皿e-CepmeBy
(HaPo皿m,3anymeHHblenOnameHHOI13eMJIeyPa3狐Ⅲ[IHbIX
ご

｡

MoHacTbIpcKHx ceJIH且epeBeHb B HMIITpoBcKoM, KamHH-

cKoM,Py3cKoMH3BGHHropomcKoMye3mX),CaBBo-CTopo43K.MapKc H①､SHreJIbc,CoII.,T、1, cTp. 128.
44 TaM )Ke, cTp. 129.

45 JI､ E, [l " e n H II & PYCcKIIe *eQnambmble aPxMBb[ XIV-XV BB"
u､2.M., 1951, cTp・180-181.

286

>KeBcKoMy (Ha JIec B 3BeHIIropoIcKoM ye34e) , CHMoHoBy
(Ha JIec H PO皿I B 4MIITpOBcKOM ye34e)nP a BHTeJIbCTBo
nOnblTaJIOCb Cy3HTb alMHHI'ICTPaTHBHble nOJIHOMOLII4H MOHa-

CTblPeii nO OTHOmeHIIIO K HaPy皿HTeJIHM, IITO6bl COXPaHHTb
3a co6oh巾yHKⅡHmCyna I'i PacnPaBbl, BeCbMa Ba>KHble 4JIH

ynPOllelUIH BeJIIIKOK">KeCK9ii BJIaCTIi B nPllCOe"IHeHHOV
yneJIe. O皿IOBPeMeHHO 3TO 6blJIo IIPoHBJIeHIIeM oTMeIIeHHOji

K.MapKcoM
HeonpeXeJIeHHocTH
pa3Me>KeBaHIIHny6JII1IIHqr

rO H IIaCTHOrO nPaBa B 4eJIax, CBfl3aHHblx C巾eOmaJIbHOI1
Co6cTBeHHOcTblO He nO Ko皿aO巾OPMMIB山erocflTlIna・

Cy>KeHHe cyXe6Ho-licnoJ1IIIITeJIblIoii (PyHKUIIII MoIIacTblPeii ylaJIOcb nPaBIITeJIbcTBy B Pa3HOM CTenelllI B cBH311 c
Pa3JIIIIIMIMII

B

Pa3MePax 3eMJIeBJIageHPIRHⅡoJIHTHIIecKOM

Bece nO>KaJIOBaHHblx KopllOPau戒. nPliKa3II]'IK CaBBo-CToPO>KeBCKOrOMOHaCTblPflAO｡m>KeH6blJInPen<CTaBJIHTbnOH­
MaHHblX IlaPymHTeJIeii Be､JIIIKOKI･ImKeCKOMy《且aHIIOMy nPHCTaBy>, KOTOPbl曲! B cBoIO O[IePenb, ycTPaHBaJI nePen BeJIIIKIMM KHH3eM OIIHylo cTaBKy HaPy皿HTeJIH c nPmKa3[IIIKoM, H
TOJIbKO B cJIyqae noKa3･aTeJIbcTBa nOCJIeXHIIM BIIHbl HaPylⅡⅢ-

TeJIFI BeJIHK" KHH3b 6PaJI c nPecTynHHKa mTPa* B pa3MePe

4Byx py6JIei (B皿HMO, B IIOJIb3y Ka3Hbl)．CHMoHoBcKafI BoTIIHHa TaK)Ke He m36aBJIflJIaCb OT BeJIMKOKHH>KeCKOrO《瓜aHu

HOrO nPHCTaBa>P, naBaBmerO HaPymHTeJIeM Ha nOPyKII, HO
CTaBI1BmerO Hx y>Ke He l.lePen BeJIHKI'IM KHH3GM, aくⅡepeX
CO6Oii>>, T. e. 4eJIO Pe皿aJIoCb llG B BeJIHKoKHfDKeCKOM Cyne,

II MoHacTblpcKoe o6BIIIIeHIIe TPe60BaJIO MGHbmmX nOKa3aTeJIbcTB. Hm【lero He I､OBOPlIJIocb 3,necb o皿Tp abax.
HaKoHen, B Tpo皿KOii rPaMOTe ｡HKCI1POBaJIOcb TOJIbKO
3a npe皿GIIHe CeIIb MoHacTblI)cKHe JIeca; cJIe八oBaTeJIbHo, PacnPaBa c
HaPy皿HTeJIHMII
OCTaBaJIaCb B PyKaX
MOHaCTblPFI.

MapKc HIiCaJI:《ⅡP}IcBOMIB ce6e皿Tpa巾Hble lleHbrH, ,JIeCoBJIaneJIeU... nplIcBoHJI ce6e, KpoMe cBoero 'IacTHoro npaBa,
へ

eme ll 8ocI/OQpcTBE凡凡Oe〃βαBO Ha HapymHTeJIH JIecllblx npa-

BHJI H 3aHHJI caM MecTo Tocy,XapcTBa>> 46. OTcyTcTBHe orpaHHLIHTeJIbHblx ｡opMyJI B rpaMoTe Tpo皿e-CeprlieBy MoHaCTI)IPlO O6bHCHfleTcH, nOMHMO erO KPynHOrO nOJIIITWIeCKOI､O
3HaLIGHIiH, eme H TeM O6CTOHTeJIbcTBOM, qTO rPaMOTa nOHBII-

JIacb B nepBble nHII HHBapH l534 r., Korna no3ImHH npaBHTeJIbcTBa Ha TePPHToPllH yneJIa 6blJIII KPa"e HenpoIIHblMIi
PI TaM

He

HMeJIOCb

BeJIHKOKIIHjKeCKOrO

46 K.MapKcH･3HreJIbc.CoII̲,T. 1,cTp. 152
287

aⅡⅡaPaTa

BJIaCTm.

K nePellHC"eHHblM 3anoBeXHblM rPaMoTaM Ha MoHaCTbIPCKIle @JIeCa ll pO皿m6JIII3Ka no cBoeih KJIaccoBoii ll llo.JIHTM-

LlecKoii llallPaBJIeHHocTH >Ka,IIoBaHHafl rpaMoTa BoJIoTo八CKOMy rJIy皿I'1UKoMy MOHacTbIPlo, 3anPeUalomaH IIocToPOHHHM
JIIOnHM HaPymaTb MOHOnOJIbHoe BJIa八eHIIe MOHaCTblPH TOHH-

MH《Ha
CyxoHe》、

C 3anoBenHblMII rpaMoTaMII, yKpenJIHB皿ⅡMHnpaBa
MoHaCTblpCKOii cO6CTBeHHoCTII B oTHO皿eHIIII JIeCOB II BoA,
cOIIeTaloTCH rPaMo'rbl, KOToPble PacmⅡPflJIII B Uel-ITPe JIIIKBH-

AIIPOBaHHOrO y4eJIa - rOPOne JMHTPOBe H JMHTPOBCKOM
ye3nle - 3eMJIeBJIaneHHe MOIIaCTblPei, Ba)KHbIx 4JIFI IIPaBHTeJIbCTBa.B KalleCTBe (1)OPrlOCTOB nPOTﾙIB AH八peH CTap皿一

Koro B BoJIoKoJIaMcKe li BoJIorne. liocli(Po-BoJIoKoJIaMcKHi
MOHaCTblPb lloJIy[IIIJ1 RBoPOBoe MecTO B r. 4MHTpOBe :17, a

B oJI oroJIcK砿 ①ePanOHTOB MOHaCTblPb - TPll nePeBIIII B
KaMeHcKoM cTalIe nMIITpoBcKoro ye3Za 48.
UeJIb aKTHBHoh 60pb6bI c pa3JIIIIIHblMH npoHBJIeHwIMI1
COnIIaJIbl-IOro JBwKeHMI Ha TePPllToPHIi 6blB皿ⅢX nMIITPOB-

cKorO H yrJIIIUKorO yneJIoB cTaBIIJIO nePeX Co60曲Ⅱp aBHTeJIbcTBoE!ﾉIeHblTJIHHCKOA,BblnaBaHMOHaCTblPHM]KaJIOBaHも

IIble rPaMOTbl, qJIIKCIiPOBaBmlIe CPOKII BI)I30Ba B Be皿iKoKHHU

>KGcKIIH

Cyl

MOHaCTblPCKHX

KPeCTbHH,

nPHKa3[IIIKOB,

)IOceJIbCKIIx, a HHorna I1 6PaTIIIo no IIx TJI>K6aM c nOcTOPOHHHMII JII皿aMM. npe>Kne Bcero 6pocaIoTcFI B rJIa3a 40BoJIIJHo

皿HPOKHe Mac皿Ta6bl llPenOcTaBJIeHIIH CPoulHblx rPaMoT. IIx
ⅡOJIyIIIIJIH MOIIacTbIPHⅡOKPOBCK" yr川皿K" (Ha 6e>KeUKHe, y皿皿Kme H HpocJ1aBcKHe 3eMJIII) , q)epanoHToB II KII-

plIJIJIo-BeJIo3epcKI1i (Ha EMIITpoBcKIIe 3eMJIm) , Tpo皿eCeprHeB (IIa lMIITpoBcKIIe, Ka皿IIHCKIIe m Py3CKIIe BIJIane､

H H H ) .
〃

yIIHTblBaFI Tpa且mnIIIo, cyUecTBoBaBmylo B yneJIe lOPIIFI
"M'HTPOBCKOrO,nPaBHTeJIbCTBOB60JIbmHHCTBeTPaMOTHa3HaIIIIJIo nlBa cpoKa |BbI30Ba OJHaKo cTpeMJIGHIIe pereHTcKoU

rO coBeTa nOIITH maJIb皿e B 3ToM BOnPoCe H OPraHII30BaTb

60JIee cIIcTeMaTIIIIecKIIiM KoHTpoJIb 3a coILIIaJIbHblMH cToJIKHo:Bel･畑列MII HaceJIeHHH MOHaCTblPcKIIx BoTIIHH c nPe八cTaBH-

TeLIH MH瓜I)yrlIx npocnoeK o6皿ecTBa HcHo O611aPy>KHJIOCb

B OIHOi l､paMoTe TpoIIIle-CeprHGBy MoHacTbIpIo, Kacalo皿ehcH ceJI pI 4ePeBeHb KamHHcKoro ye3Aa. MoHacTblPb B

cBoeii IIerIo61ITHOii >Ka,mOBaJIcH Ha cJIHmKOM IIaCTbIe cpOKII,
47 Am3MX, L1. 11 Nb 132.
48 ArP, T. 1, M 42, CTp. 44
288

yCTaHaBJIPIBaeMble nPMIcTaBaMH及JIfI erO KPeCTbHH II nOCeJIb-

cKoro. npaBHTeJIbcTBo cneJIaJIo cooTBeTcTByIo皿Ⅲ伽BblBOⅡH3
U

CO3八aBmerOCH B MOHacTblPCKoII

BoTIIHHe noJIo)KGHIIH II Ha-

3HaIIHJIO He XBa, a TPll CPOKa 49, Me]Kny TeM KaK TPeXCPOIIIIble rpaMoTbl B nepBoii TpeTIi XVI B. Boo6皿e He BblnaBaJIHCb 50.

Oco6eHHo HHTepecHa cTaTbH o cpoKax B rpaMoTe noKPOBCKOMy y皿HUKoMy MOHacTblPIO. nPaBIITeJIbCTBO BbIrO|BOPHJIO ce6e nPaBO HaPymaTb niBa 3a巾HKCHPOBaHHblX cPOKa:
一

ooHpem旦bHKH. MorJIIi nOcblJIaTb HeneJIb皿mKa《33aⅡHcblo＞
《OnPHIIb TeX JBy cPoKoB》­《Ii llIM K TeM 'cpOKaM cTaBHTIICH,

HIIO IIX Cy>KIO H3.,. HJ1II MOh且BoPeUKoii>>. 3To, 6e3yCJIOBHO,
〆

β

CBH3aHO c IICKJIIo[IHTeJ1bHblM OCOCTPeHHeM cOUlIaJIbHo-nOJIMU

THLIecKoH

一

一

'oopbObl

B

ceBepHblx

ye3八ax,

KOTOPoe

ynaeTCfl

IIp ocJIe且HTb c 20-x roLoB XVI B. 51 06e |cpoIIHble rpaMoTbl
Tpo皿e-CeprlieBy MoHacTblplo 52 nonl Tpa皿皿OH HOi巾OP MOji
｡

ʻⅡo)KaJIOBaHIIH JIbroTHblx cPoKOB CKPblBaJIH Ba>KHblll sJIeMeHT
u

U

JL

orPaHII'IeHIIH STOH JIbroTHoHⅡPaKTHKH:
MOHacTblPb He noJI y[IHJI《旦aHHOrO nPHCTaBa)，且JIH Bbl30Ba B BeJII,IKoKI-IH>KeCKHH

cy,I MoHacTblpcKIIx KpecTbHII. 4aHHble npHcTaBbl o6blIIHo Haし

XOII皿IIcb B 3aBHcHMocTII oT MOHacTblPePI H HepenKO HcHOJI-

I-IFIJIH Kx BoJIIo53. OcTaBJIHH npaBo Bbl30Ba 3a JIIo6blM BeJIHKOKHH>KGCKMM nPHCTaBoM IIJII,I HeneJIb皿HKoM, npaBHTeJIbcTBo Pac皿IIPHJIO Bo3MOlKHoCTb KOHTPOJIIIPOBaTb MOHacTblPb
ⅢOXHOBPeMeHHO nPHHHMaTb Pe皿HTeJIbHble MePbl JJIH ynleP-

]KaHHH3KcnJIyaTIIPyeMOrOHaCeJIeHHHBPaMK4x｡eOnaJIbHOro nPaBOnOpH瓜Ka・

KJIaccoBblii cMblcJI HMMyHHTeTHoii noJIHTHKH EJIeHbl
rJIIIHcKoii eme OTqeT､mmBee BCKPblBaeTCFI HO MePe II3yqeHI畑
HecynMMoii IIacTH >KaJIoBaHHblx rpaMoT. B cBoHx HHBapcKo巾eBpaJIbcKHx rpaMoTax 1534 r. npa|BIITeJIbcTBo nblTaJIocb,
Bo-nepBblx, 06ecneIIMTb nona'BJIGHHe KJIaccoBoi 60pb6bl B
｡eO"JIbHO曲及ePeBHe, 6e3 IIero caMOe nPIICoe皿HeHHeHOBblx
TePPHToPliit He MOrJIO 6blTb nPO[IHblM, BO-BTOPblx, OrPaHII[IHTb noJIHTII[IecKyIo BJIacTb MoHacTblpen. BTopylo 3ana'ly
U

B OTI-IO皿eHHm Pa3HblX八yxOBHblX
KOPnOPaUHH nPaBHTeJIbcTBy nPHxO瓜HJIOCb PemaTb no-Pa3HOMy, HCXOml H3 Pa3MePOB
49 AA3, T. I, M 178, cTp・1 50.

50 HaMII y>Ke oT,MeIIaJIocb, [ITo B Be皿IKO,KHH)KeCKIIX >KaJIOBaHHblx rPaMOTax nepBoii TpeTII XVI B. 6blJI 3,HatIII|TeJIbHo pacnpocTpaHell npIIHmm
oJHocpoqHocTII (nPn, BblII. 1V, cTp. 155) .
51 nPn, Bbln. 1V, cTp. 155-156.
52 AAS, T・I, JYb l78; rB几Tp. KH. 527, M 237.
53 Hpn, Bbln. 1V, cTpʼ1 55.
19

C. M. KamTaHoB

289

3eMJIeBJIaneHIIJI MoHacTblPeii H nOJIHTHIIecKOro BeCa Hx B

naHHblii MoMeHT. BMecTe c TeM, oT 3Toro pemeHHH 3aBHCeJIa

CTen H,
yqaCTMH
｡eonlaJIbHOrO
rOCyn(aPCTBa
B
BbInOJIHeHIIM
CBOeli qjyHKUHII aⅡnaPaTa HaCIIJIIIH HaJI TPy及只皿ⅢMHʻcfl MaC-

CaMIIHO6'beM:BOTKIHIIHOAIOCTH山畑，I､aK>KeCJIV>KHB皿e曲
CPe4CTBOM BHeaKOHoMIIqeCKOro nPHHyIKneHHH.

①HKcanJH CaMblx KPynHblx nPHBHJIer嘘只o6IIJIcH IIocH-

｡o-BoJIoKoJIaMcKHii
MoHacTblpb,
iloJIyIIHB皿嘘BOJIOHKO-3y6ll9PPKylO-H IMHTPoBO-Py3CKIIe rPaMOTb[ 'B KoHne HHBaPH

1534EIJocJIenpeA"BJIeHIIHA皿peeMCTap皿KHMcBoHx
lPeTeH3" Ha HacnemlcTBO BO"OUKIIx KHH3eii cOIO3 C IIOC"O-

BoJIoKoJIaMcKIIM
MoHacTblpeM,
KoTopblhHBJIHJICH
KpynHeiimHM｡eO"JIOMHaTePPliToPHI16blB皿eroBoJIoUKoroy八eJIa,
ⅡpIIo6peJI
nJ1兜ⅡPaBIITeCJIbcTBa
llCKJIIOIIHTeJIbHylO
Ba)KHOcTb.
K 20-M IMcJIaM FIHBapH l534 rJIocH｡o-BoJIoKbJIaMcK" MoHaCTblPb nPeB30皿eJI CBoeii PO､JIblO B CO6blTIIHX TeKymerO
MoMeHTa ">Ke TpoHUe-CeprlieB MoHacTblpb, [Ibe BJIIIHHHe

6blJIO He MeHee CHJIbHblM e皿e B HaqaJIe FIHBapH i534 r.
Ho3ToMynpaBIITeJIbcTBonpenlocTaBIIJIorpaMoT61BoJIoKoJIaMcKoMy MoHacTblplo paHbme, [leM Tpo皿e-CeprlieBy (ocII9"aJI MaCca TPOmUKHx rPaMOT nepBblX "yx MeCHUeB

l534 r. naTIipyeTcH 9 1e'BpaJiH) .

nBeBoJIQKo"aMcKHerpaMoTblHHBapH1534E
(BoJIoUKo3y6UoBcKaH54Ho八Hapy3CKaH55)
6blJIH'BblXaHblHaCTaPble
MoHaCTqPcKHe BJI"e"fl, 3anHcaHHLIe B )KaJIOBaHHbIX rPa-

MoTax BacII,ﾉIHH III 56 11 10plifl lIBaHOBIma 57. rPaMOTb1

l534 r. coxpaHHJIH cyne6Hblih HMMyHIITeT B npe>KHEM oObeMe (4<OnPHIIb,nymery6cTBa oJJlaro)') . TpII py3cKo-IMHTpoBCKlie rPaMOTbl Ha HOBble CeJIaH八epeBHH MocHqJo-BoJIoKo-

JIaMcKOrO MoHacTblPH "KcHPOBaJIH Ty >Ke caMylo HoPMy
orpaHHqeHIIH MoHacTblpcKoi IopHcJHKUIIII 58. Ho KaK HII
3aHHTePeCOBaH 6blJI PereHTCKHik COBeT B Hoユュep>KKe lIocH-

｡o-BoJ1oKoJIaMcKoro MoIIacTbl", oH 3aKpeHIIJT ero cy4e6U

HblII IIMMyHIITeT He BO BCeX MOHaCTblPCKHx BOTIIHHaX B

cToJIb Pac皿HpeHHoM BIme. npaBIITeJIbcTBo npH6erJIo K onlHoMy ToIIIfQMy yXmlllpeHHIo. B rpaMoTe KHH3H IOplIH HBaHoBmqa l527 r. HocII(bo-BoJIoKoJIaMcKoMy MoHacTbIpIo Hecy瓜HMOcTbceJIaBorOPO八cKorocy皿ecTBeHHOyPe3blBaJIaCb
54 A｡3MX， q. II, Nb 136.

55 TaM )Ke;

Nb 135.

56 TaM jKe, Nb lO3.
57 TaM )Kel Nb 1,12.
58 TaM )Ke, Nb 130, 131, 134
290

Ⅲ3'bHTHeM PI3 BoTIIHHHOi 10PHC且HKuHHPa360Pa TFI>K6 nO

TPeM KaTeroPlIHM nPecTynJIellH向(nymery6cTBy, pa36010,

TaTb6e c noJIIIIIHbIM) 59. EJIeHa rJIIIHcKafI; co3naBaH Bne-

IIaTJIeHMe 60JIbmorO nOjKaJIoBaHHH, PacmliPlIJIa yKa3aHHblIi
o6'beM HMMyHHTeTa np li3'bHTIIH Bcero nByx Bm且OB nPeCTyllJ'eHIm (4y皿ery6cTBa m pa360H), o皿aKO IIOIBeJIa nOm aTy
HOPMy He TOJIbKo'ceJIO BoroPOnCKoe, Ho H ceJIo HOKPoBcKOe,
noJIb3QFaBmeecH paHee Hecy"MocTbIo <<onpHIIHo 4ymery6-

cTBa> 60, a TaK)Ke p" HOBblx ceJI, KOToP61e llo riPHM6Py
nPynlx MOr.JIIf 6blTb nO4BenPMCTBeHHBI BeJIHKOKHH>KeCKIIM

HaMeCTHIIKaM JIIImb B nPOUeCCaX O Iymery6CTBe 61.

BHecy"IMblxpa3neJIaxrpaMoTTpo'IIne-CeprHeByMoHaCTuPlo Ha ceJIa lf mepeBHII JMIITpoBcKoro 62, Py3cKoro 63,
MocKoBcKoTo 64, IOpbeB-noJIbcKorO 65 1I nomeXOHcKoro o6
yegnoIB IIpaBHTeJIbcTBo EJIeHbl rJIHHcKo曲nOC､ﾉI enoB aTeJIbHo
np|oBeJIo orpaHHIIeHIIe MoHacTblpcKoro #HMMyHHTeTa, HcKJIIoヲ

qHB H3̲Hero npaBo cyna no nymery6HblM H pa360ihHblM XeJIaM.

PereHTcK"

cOBeT

BHOJIHe

HCIIOJIb3bBaJI 'CJIo>KHB-

mylocH npH BacHJIHHIII H IOpHHⅡMHTPOBcKOM TPa皿皿Io
3aKpenJIeHIIfl ･cyme6HohBJIacTH TpoHIle-CeprIieBa MoHacTEIpfI IIMeHHo B TaKoM o6'beMe 67. ToJIbKo o八Ha nIMHTpoBcKafl
rpaMoTa pacmHpHJIa (no cpaBHeHHIo c rpaMoToih IOpHH Ha
Te >Ke CeJIa) TPO皿KylO IOCT皿班o, "KcIIpyJI ee <<onpHqb Xymery6cTBa> 68, Ho JeJIaJIocb 3To 3a cqeT Cy皿ecTBeHHoro coKpameHIIH nOn<aTHOrO HMMyHHTeTa 69

HaKoHen, B IByx >KaJIoBaHHLIx rpaMoTax, KacaBmHxcFI
JMIITpoBcKIIx JepeBeHb BoJIoroIcKoro epanoHToBa MoHaQrblpH, [Ibe 3eMJIeBJIaneHKe He HMeJIo rJIy60KIIx KopHeih .B

且MIITPoBcKoMye3ne,nPaBHTeJIbcTBonPHMeHIIJIoKPaihHIoIo
CTeneHbOrPaHH[IeHHHBOTII|HHI･IOiilOPHCmIKUlM:1ymery6cT-

59 TaM )Ke, M 101.
60 TaM )Ke, Nb 14.
61 TaM )Ke, Nb 133.
62 Xn, I, Nb 317, 320.
63 TaM )Ke, M 319.
64 TaM JKe, Nb 328, 329.
65 TaM >Ke, Nb 332.
66 TaM )Ke, Nb 333.

67Pp.,HanpIWgp,̲rpaMpTp!IQpmHHaceJIoA"peeBcKoeHmepeBHIo
KH皿KHHo (Xn, I, JVb lll, 169) c rpa.MoTaMH 1534 r. Ha Te )Ke 'EoTKIH-

Hbl (TaM JKe, JWh 319, 320).
68 Xn, I, Nb 318.

69 J:paMoTa 6bIJIa BbmaHa Ha ce"a neTpoBcKoe !! "nopoBcKoe CeJIo

neTpoBcKoe ynoMMHaJIocb B rpaMoTe lOp" l513 c(Arp, TI, M 321
2

9

1

1

9

＊

Bo, pa360ji H TaTb6a c noJIHIIHbIM oKa3ailHcb BHe cq)ePbl
BemeHIIfl MOHacTblPCKoro cymaⅢ且O,Ⅲ）KI･11]1 6blJIII I)a361II)aTbCFI
BeJIIIKOKHjl>KeCKHMII HaMeCTIII,IKaMH 70

npaBHTeJIbcTBo EJIeHbl rJIHHcKoii, aKTHIBHo IIcHoJIb3yH
PeaJIbHOe noJIO)KeHHe MOHaCTblpcKOrO 3eMJIeBJIaneHI'Ifl H IIM-

MyHIITeTHble TPanⅡ皿IH Pa3JIIIIIHblx MOHaCTblpeit, HacTOiixIIIBO
CTPeMHJIOcb K yBeJIIIIIeHIIIO PoⅡHrOcynaPCTBeHHOrO annapa-

Ta B XeJIe yKPemleHI呪 巾eOnaJIbHorO nPaBOHOP皿Ka B
CTPaHe.

B (PI1HaHcoBoii noJIIITHKe pereHTcKoro coBeTa npoFIBIIJII'ICb |CxoIHble IIePTbl, T. e. y[IeT Tpa八mⅡHih HaJIorOo6JIO>KeHH兜
MOHacTblPcKHx 'BOTIIHH B OTAeJIbHblx ye3nax coKIeTaJIcH c o6-

meii TeHnel･IUHeii CoKPameHIIH nonaTHOro IIMMyHIITeTa. CaMble KPynHble nPHBIIJIerIm noJ1yIIIIJI OmlTb-TaKII HocH巾o-

BoJIoKoJIaMcK" MoHacTblpb. rpaMoTa l534 r・Ha ero BoJIOKKIIe H 3y6nOBCKHe 3eM皿I瓜o皿JIa B OTpblBKax 71. II3 HHx HcHO
TOJIbKo, IITo MoHaCTblPcKIIe BOT[IHHbl nO-npe>KHeMy oCBO00>KnaJIIICb OT rOPoIoBOro meJIa II HeKOTOPblx nPyrlIx HaTy〆

PaJIbHblxHOBHHHOcTeii72.rJIaBHblMHⅡOnaTHMHBH3yIIaeMOe
BPeMH 6blJIII HM (HMcKHe n<eHbl､H), HaMecTHII叩倣ⅡOCOmIIblih

KOPMHⅡpHMeT. K HIIM npHMblKaJIa II <<n<aHb)", noI KoTopoii
IIHOrna nO叩a3yMeBa,JIcFI, BnPOIIeM, BeCb KOMnJIeKc nPHMblx

HaJIOroB・OcHoBHblMII HaTypaJIbHblMHnoBHHHocTHMHHBJIHJIHCb rOPOXOBOe neJIO II nOCOmHaH CJIyJK6a 73.

Tpa皿uHH, CO34aBmaFICH B y4eJIe lOPHH JMHTl)OBCKOrO,
|cOCTOHJIa )B IIaCTo曲ⅡPaKTIIKe ocBO60>KneHIIfl ,BOTqIIH KPyllU

HeHmHx

3eMJIeBJIanleJIbUeB

OT

BCex

IIeTblPex

IIJIII

TOJIEKo

TPex ("HII, HMa II HOcOmHOrO KoPMa) nOnaTeit B CIIeT BHeCeHHFI B y4e&ﾉIbHOKHH>KecKylo Ka3Hy OnPen<eJIeHHOii, cTPOro

3alHKcHPoBaHHoi cyMMbl o6poKa OcBo60)KneHIIe oT roPonOBoro nleJIa II nOCOml･Ioh cJIy>K6bl B >KaJIoBaHHblx rPaMOTax

IOpHH HBaHoIBHIIa co八eP>KaJIOCb Pe4KO. 3TII TPa八HuHH HamJIII OTPa>KeHHe B O6皿e曲巾oPMe ｣B >Ka,JIOBaHHblx TaPxaHHo-

o6poIIHblx rpaMoTax EJIeHbl rJIIIHcKo曲Ⅲoc"o-BoJIoKoJIaMcKoMy H epanoHToBy MoHacTblpFIM. Ho BeJIHKoKHH>KecKoe
nPaBHTeJIbcTBo 6blJIo naJIeKO oT MexaHIIIIecKorO BOCnPoII3BeneHIIH

B

CBOHx

rPaMOTax

cTaPblx

IIMMyHIITeTHblx

HoPM.

70 ArP, T. I, Nb 42; PIIB, T. 32, M 130.
71 A3HX, [1. 11, Nb 136.

72 CR ̲ nPe4blilyUyIo BonoUKo-3y6noBcKylo rpaMoTy BacwIMH III
(Am3HX, [1.11, M 103).

73くOqepKH HcTopHII CCCP". nepHonl q)eo八aʻⅢ}I3Ma. KoHen XV - HaIJa@JIo
XVII B., cTp. 141-142; nPn, Bblm. IV, cTp. 146-148.
292

nPe>"e 'BcerO noJBePrJIHcb orPaHHｴIeHIIIO npHBIIJIerHIi XpeBHIIx MoHacTblpcKIIx BoTIIIIH. CeJIo HoKpoBcKoe, HoJIb30BaBmeeCH,

corJIaCHO

rPaMOTe

BoJIoUKOro

yXeJIbHorO

KHH3FI

1480 r., 6e306poIIHblM TapxaHoM 74, nonaJIo B rpaMoTy, Tpe60BaBmylo ynJIaTbl o6poKa B KaIIecTIBe KoMneHcamlH 3a ocBO60>KneHIIe OT nOnaTeii 75.
no )KaJIo|BaHHblM rpaMoTaM EJIeHbl TJIIIHcKo曲noﾕﾕaeTcH
IICCJIelOBaHIIIO皿巾巾ePeHUlIPOBaHHblhⅡOEXOユロP aBIITeJIbCT-

Ba K onPeneJIeHIIIo nOnaTHOro HMMyl-IHTeTa B PyJcKoM ye3ne,
CTapHHHOhHo6皿HPHoiio6JIacTIIBoJIon(Koro3eMJIe'BJIaneHIIH,
ⅢBⅡMHTPoBCKOM ye3nle, rle MoHaCTblPb IIMeJI MaJIO 3eMeJIb
H BCe OIIII BO皿JIH B COCTaB erO BOT[IIIHbl

CPaBHIITeJIbHO He-

naBHo. Py3cKHe BJIaneHHFI MoHacTblpfl HaXeJIHJIHcb '60JIee
menpblMHnpHBIIJIerl,IHMI1, IIeM IMHTpoBcKHe. Bo-nepBblx,
6blJIa noBTopeHa noIITII 6e3 H3MeHeHHhrpaMoTa IOpPIfI MBaHoBHIIa Ha PHI CTaPHHHblX Py3cKHx CeJIH且ePeBeHb, nPenO-

cTaBJIHBmafl IIM 3a o||6poK cBo601y oT naHm, HMaHⅡocomHo-

roKoPMaH,KPOMeTorO,OTnOcOmHOitCJIy>K6blHrOPOnPBOrO
neJIa 76. Bo-BTopblx, B Tpex rpaMoTax, KacaBmPIxcfl HoBblx

Py3CKIIxBJIaneHHh,ConeP>KaJIocbTa'KOe>KeOcIBO60>KXeHHe,
coenIIHHB皿eecfl c ocBo60xmeHIIGM oT npHMeTa 77. Hao60poT,

B rPaMoTe Ha nMIITPOBCKoe ceJIO ByJKaPoBo OTcyTcTBOBaJIO
⑥

HecKoJIbKO H3 3TIIx nPIIBHJIerllH: Pa3PemeHIie He HCnOJIHHTD

noco皿HylOCJIy>K6y,rOPOIOBOen<eJIOHHenJIaTIMTbnpllMeT78.
B Toii py3cKoii rpaMoTe, rne ynoMHHaJIocb nMHTpoBcKoe

ceJIo Boropo皿uKOe (BOrOPoIcKOe) , "H HerO CneUIIaJIbHo
Bbln|HCaJIH巾OPMyJIy, ycTaHa'BJIHBaIOmylO MeHbm砿o6'beM
謬

U

U

HMMyHIITeTa Ho CPaBHeHIIIO c ｡OPMyJIOII, 0nPenleJIHBmeHⅡO-

JIaTHO曲HMMyHIITeT py3CKHX BJIaJIeHIMi: BOroPOminKOe He
HoJ1yIIHJIoocBo60)KmeHHHo.rnpHMeTa79.
CBH3b oTMeHbl npHBIIJIerIM :B oTHo皿eHIIH nPlIMeTa C JIHK-

BImauHeii cBo60,mbl oT HocomHoih cJIy>K6bl H roponPBoro

neJIa He CJIyIIaiiHai neHe>KHbl曲《ⅡPIIMeT>> 3aMeHRJI cO60ii
HoBHHHocTb, 6JIII3KylO HO xaPaKTePy K rOponP:BoMy XeJIy
(HOBHHHOCTb <<nPIIMeT》­BePoHTHo cTPoIITeJIbCTBo《npHMeToB)p, T. e. oCanHblx coopy)KeHIIii nepem roPoncKHMII cTe、

HaMH)．

74 A3HX, [1. 11, Nb 14.
75 TaMンKe, Nb 133.
76 TaM x<e, Nb l35; ,cp､ TaM ]Ke, M ll2
77.TaM )Ke, JYb |131, 133, 134.
78 TaM >Ke, M 130.
79 TaM "Ke, M .133,
293

①ePanOHTO|BMoHacTblPb,HMeBmHjieme60JIeeCJIa6ble
3eMJIeBJIaneJIb1IeCKIieTPa皿皿HBnMIITPOBCKOMye3ne,IIeM
U

Iioc"o-BoJ10KoJ1aMcK"MoHacT61Pb,AecyMEJI"XmTM
U

oc9060>K"HIIH̲CBoIIx BoTqIIH oT rojonoBoro.XeJIa ii nocoIII=
HoII cJIy>K6bl.HaceJIeHIie ero BHoBLnpHo6peTeHHbIx JMIITU

PoBCKIIx nePeBeHb nPHMO nPIIHyxmaJIOcb K BblnoJIHellHIO I､OU

poJoBoro ne"a, a cTaybH o nocomHoji cJ1y)K6e B rpaMoTe oT-

gyTcTBoBaJIa;3acBo601yoTnaHm,"McKIixneHef,npHMeTa

Ii̲HaMecTHIIqberq̲ nqcomHoro KopMa Tpe60BaJIacb ynJIaTa
ヅ

O6POKa
'B
Ka3Hy
80・O6poK
3a
n(aHb,
HMHnpI1MeT
HoJI>KeH

6bIJLImaTHTbHKmpmJIJIo-BeJIo3epcKIIiiMoHa6Tblpb8i:
U

nPaBIITeJIbcTBo
HoBOJIbHO
TBe"O
BbIrOBOPIIJI6
ce6e
nPa･
Bo nPIIHy>KneHIIH MoHacTblpcKIIx KpecTbHH K BblHoJIHe'HTIIo

BoeHHblxIIBoeHHp-o60poLIHblxHoBIIHHocTeiiBnMHTpoBcKoM
U

X@3ne: nocomHoii cJIy)K6bl, roponoBoro neJIa H ipHMeTa.

I/1cIIoJ1b30BaHlieTPa"IIIIHⅡePeBOIa
l-Iao6poK
neHe>KHblx
ⅡoﾉIaTeiho6'bHcHHJIocb,coIHOitcTopoHbI,H606xo"MocTbIo
⑥

U

"fI nPaBI1TeIJbCTBa nPH nOMoUll 3TOii nplIBIIJIerlIII yKPenIITb
④

nOJIHTHIIeCKIIH COIO3 C MOHaCTblPHMH, nOJIyLIIIBmHMH3eMJIH

B I1PeneJIax yHwITo>KeHIIQ[Q KHFI>KeCTBa, c XPyrOii CTOPOHbl,
⑪

oTcyTcTBHeM B HHBapel534 r. Hama>KeHHorOannapafa ynQaBJIGH" nPHCOe"HeHHblMH TepPHToPHHMII, KOTOPblii MOr

6bl o6ecneIIHTb c60p nonaTei c M6HacfbIDcKIix
▲ BoT[imH
U

y)KeB.eBpaJIel534rB>KaJIoBaHHblirpaMoTaxTPo皿e-

CellrmeBy MoHacTbIpIo Ha nMIITpoBo-py36KIIe ceJIa" 6bIjIH
U

CneJIaHbl
nOnblTKH OTOmTII
OT 3TOii TPa
C瓜eJIaHblⅡOⅡblTKH
OTOHTHOT3TOH
TPa瓜HuHH II PemHTe,JIbHee
OrPaHIIqHTb MoHacTblPCK"
orpaHI画HTb
MoHacTblpcKHHIIo瓜aTHoHHMMyHHTeT・Oco6bli
IIOnaTHOih HMMyHMITeT
U

HHTepec

npencTaBJIHIoT

TpoHUKIIe

>KaJIoBaHHble

rpaMoTbl

534
1 T.
HaceJIa
neTpoBcKOeⅡ①enopoBcKoe
mMHTp6BcKoro

ye3na H ceJIo AHIIl2eBcKoe py3cKoIb ye34a. Tap"HHo-o6-

poIIHble npaBa ceJI neTpoBcKoro H AHnpeeBcKor6 6blJIH 3aKpenJI..Hbl B rpaWIoTe lOpHFI HBaHoBII[la l513 r., ycTaHaBJIHU

BaBmelI OnPeneJIeHHble CyMMbl nJIaTe>Ka c Ka>KIOrO H3 nByX
ceJI f<3a nallb, H 3a FIM, H 3a npHMeT>> 82. B o6elIx >KaJIoBaH-

HbIx rpaMoTax l534 rʼ一KaK Ha ceJIo AHXpeeBcKoe 83, TaK
８０ PIIB, T. 32, Nb 129.
８１
rnB, Co6P Cn6. n/A, Nb A I/17, ". 907 06.
８２

ArP, T. I, Jvb 32, cTp、33-34. B II3JIo>KeHIIII ITo3JHeimeii rpaMoTbl
( 1526 r) aToT o6poK npencTaB"eH B Ka[lecTBe XoMneHcaMm̅ 35

HeymlaTy60JIee山mpoKoroKpyrano4aTeii:"HaTeHxceJIaHntepeBHH
y lIIIx MoII >Ka,JIOBamIIble rPaMoTbl o6PoqHble: 3a naHI>, H 3a HM,- M 3a

""gIL li " JJRcomHoii KopM, M 3a Bce nomJIIIHbI)' (JIOHH, Co6p.
roJIoBHHa, Nb 52).
83

UrAnA, rKS Ho Py3e, Nh 28/10259.
294

H Ha ceJIa neTpoBcKoeH①enppOBCKOe 84,- 3TII npHBHJIerHII
oTcyTcTByloT. HMMyHHTeTHafl [IacTb aKTa l534 r. 6blJIa cⅡⅡ-

caHa c rPaMbTb[ IOP" HBaHoBIIqa l504 rrpome-Ceprlie:
By MoHacTblplo Ha ceJIa CHHKoBo, ByHHTIIHo H ⅡpyrHe B
KaMeHcKoM cTaHe nMIITpoBcKoro ye3na 85, o皿aKO C On(HOii
⑪

BecbMa

冬

U

cVmecTBeHHoHnonPaBKoH:

B HIIx He nOnaJIo oCBO-

60>KneHHe oT FIMa. TaKIYM o6Pa30M, KpecTbFIHe ceJI AHXPeeBcKOrO, neTPOBcKOTOH ①enPPOBCKorO nPHIIy>KnaJIHcb K
ynJIaTe rJIaBHblx HO3eMeJIBHblx HaJIOrOB (IaHII, HMcKHx nle、

Her, nPIIMeTa)

H BblIIOJIHeHIIIO OCHOBHIjlX HaTyPaJIbHblX HO-

BIIIIHocTeii (roponoBoro neJIa, nocomHoiM cJIy)K6bll rpaMoTa TpoHue-CePrlIeBy MoHacTblPlo Ha nepeBHH MIIxaJIKoBo
HKHmKIIHO nMHTPoBCKOrO ye3" TO)Ke He 3aKJIIOIIaJIa B
ce6e ocBo60>KneHIIH oT nePeKIIIcJIeHHblx nonaTeii II《瓜eJI> 86.
B 3THx rpaMoTax yKa3blBaJIIII'cb ToJIbKo TaMo)KeHHble npaBa MOHacTblPH B erO BOTIIII|HaX, ocBo60>Kn<eHHe MOHaCTblPCKIIx
KPeCTbHH

oT MeJIKHx

HBOpUOBO-KHH>KecKHx Ii 3eMcKIIx nO-

BHHHOCTe仇nPoqPIe rPaMoTbl, Bbl"HHble B 'eBpaJIe l534 r.
TpoIme-CepmeBy MoHacTblplo nlJIH巾HKca皿HIIM MyHIITeTa
erO CeJIbcKHx BoTIIHH B ye3nax JIIIKBImHPOBaHHOrO KHH>Ke-

cTBa lOpIIFI I/IBaHoBHIIa, Boo6me J1IImeHbl cTaTe曲巾HHaHcoB o r o x a P a K Te p a .

B ropa3Xo 60JIee orpaHII[IeHHoM o6'beMe, IIeM Ha TepPHTOpm且MHTPoBcKoro yneJIa, 3aKPemmO npaBHTe.IIbcTBO MOHacTblpcKIIe nPHBImer皿B yrJImuKoM, Be>KeUKoM II HPOcJIaBcKoM ye3nax､ B rpaMoTe noKpoBcKoMy yrJIImKoMy Mo｡

一

HaCTblPlO, KaCaBmeIIC兄ceJI II nePeBeHb B 3THX OOJIacTHx, nO-

naTHOi IIMMyHHTeT nOnBO及mJICH noI HoPMbl, BblPa60TaHHble
e皿e npaBIITeJIbcTBoM BacIIJIHH III ntJIH MoHacTblpcKIIx |BoTIIIIH B npHcoeⅡmHeHHblx Be>KeUKOM II yrJIImKoM yneJIax.
B rpaMoTe co4ep>KaJIIIcbm,Imb nyHKTbl, ocBo60>KnaBmHeOT
06me# PaCKJIanKII TFITJIa C BOJIOCTHblMII JIIOXbMHⅢOT MeJIKHx IBoPUOBO-KHH>KeCKHx noBIMHHOCTeii (《ceH He KocHT>>,
<KOHH MOerO He KoPMHT)>) 8Z r｡naBHble nOnaTHHnOBHHHOcTH 3necb He ynOMIIHaJIHCb.

84 rBJI、TD. KH. 527, M 240.
F

0

85 AC31I, T・I, Nb 652.
86 Xn, 1, JYb 320. B 3ToM y3KoM o6EeMe HMMyHIITeT mepeBHII KHmKHHDii

6blJI yTBep>KneH B I､paMoTe lOpllH IJBaHo'BHIIa l520 r. (TaM "KG,
M 169).

87くHpocjiaBGKHery6epHcKHeBenoMocT",1855,qacTbHeo巾皿HaJIbHaH)
JVb 48, cTp. 435-136.
295

HaKoHeU,
caMoe
pe3Koe
m
yH"皿HPOBaHHOe
orPaHHIIeHIIe nOnaTHorO IIMMyHIITeTa nPaBIITeJIbcTBO CyMeJIO nPOBecTII B rPaMOTax, OTHocIIBmllxcFI K CeJIbCKHM BOTIIIIHaM MOU

HaCTblPeH B nPenenax Tex TePPHTOPlIi, KOTOPble PaHbme H
nPO[IHee CJIHJIHCb C OCHOBHblM COCTaBoM 3eMeJIb BeJIHKorO

KHHjKecIpa,mleM BoIJoUK", Be>KeUK", yrJImUKo-3y6HoBcK" II nMHTpoBcK" yne"bL O6 3ToM 40cTaTo[IHo dilp"et

l

U

JIeVHO CBMGTgIPcTByloT )KaJIOBaHHble rPaMOTbl, |Bbl"HHble

9｡eBpanH1534ETpo皿e-CePrIIeByMoHacTblPloHaceJIa
M̲JepeB" B cTapII"blx yneJIbHblx BoJIocTHx MocKoBcKoro 88,

IOpbeB-noJIbcKoro89IInomexoHcKoro90ye310B、3nfecbMoIIaCTblPCKIMii ceJIbcKI1ii HMMylIIITeT cOKpa皿aJICH B TaKOII >Ke
CTeneHH, KaK；B XPyrHx cIIHxPOHHblx rPaMoTax (cy34aJIbcKOU

KocTPOMCKoII H 'BJIa皿NIIIPcKOi) PIMMyHHTeT rOpOmCKHx IBOPOB H CJIO6OJ<KH.

Boo6皿erOBOPH,nOCPaBHeHHJO
CeJIbCKIIM
C
I'IMMyHI'1.re=
U

TOM, MOHaCTblPCKHHHMMyHIITeT B ropoIcKI'Ix IBopax XVI B.
JIer〔IeⅡO瓜瓜aBaJIffl CTeCHeHIIFIM, TaK KaK B rOPOnaX 3TOMy

Cn,oCO6cTBoBaJI60JIeeBblcOK",He>KemイBnePeBHe,yPoBeHb
npoH3BoI'cTBeHHblx oTHoUleHIIM H KJIaccoBoii 60pb6bl IIepHocomHoro HaceJIeHwI. O皿IHaKOBOe C HOPMaMH KMMyHIIU

TeTa roPOJIcKIIx IBOI]oB OrpaHIILIeHHe nOnaTHOii II30JIIIPoBaHH(1CTI! MOHaCTblpcKIIx CeJI H 4epeBelIb B nepeLIIIcJIGHHblx
ye3"X 6blJIO CBfl3aHO C BeCbMa mHTeHcIIBHblM 3KoIIOMII|IeCKIIM H coIlllaJIbHblM pa3BIITHeM 3TIIx PaiioHOB. KPOMe TOro,
HOJIO>KeHIMe

･ anMHIHIcTPaTIIBHorO
○

annaPaTa

OTJIHIIaJIocb

U

3mecb60JIbmeitycToii[IHBocTblo.HecJIy@I"HoITo3ToMynpH
U

COCTaBJIGHIIH yKa3aHllI)IX aKTOB 6blJIH IICnOJIb30BaHbl 4Be

rPaMoTbl BacIIJIIIH III 1517 r., oTHocH皿I'Iecfl K nePecJIaBJIb-'
3aJIepgKIIM91IJKOCTPOMCKIIM92COJIHHblMBaPHH"MHⅡBOpaM TpoIme-CepmeBa MoHacTbl". Hx B3"H 3a ocHoBy,
OIIeBMHO, nOTOMy, IITO B HIIX, HaP"y
U

C IIIMPOKOBe皿aTeJ1b-

U

Hoi, Ho a6cTpaKTHoi ｡opMyJIoIi, oCBo60>KnaBmeih OT BCex
U

ⅡOmJIIIH, COneP>KaJIOCb BHOJIHe KOHKPeTHOe OrPaHHLIeHHe
ⅡOnaTHOrO IIMMyHIITeTa.

EJIeHa
rJIHHcKaHIIeeoKpy>KeHI,Ie,XeiicTByHBo6cTaHoBKe
U

HanpmKeHHoHBHyTpIIKJIaccoBoii
Hanp"KeHIIoIT
BHyTpIIKJIaccoBoh60pb6bl,cTPeMHJIHcbBrPa­
60pb6bl, cTpeMIIJIHcb B rpa
MoTax TpoImKoMy MoHacTblplo co3"Tb BH"IMocTb no>Ka８ rB几Tp. KH. 527, Nb 242, 246.
８
８
９ rnB, Co6p. aKToB II rpaMoT, Nb l･-108.
０TaM >Ke, M 1--1 07.
９
９
１
AA3, T. I, JVb |164.
９
２

UrAJA, rKe no KocTpoMe, Nb 32/4|999
296

､ⅡoBaHIIFI

3HaIIIITeJIbHblx JIbrOT, OIHaKO

Ha CaMOM neJIe Pe-

皿HTeJIbHblM o6pa30M coKpamaJIII o6'beM MoHacTblpcKoro
HMMyHIITeTa. B KocTpoMcKoii rpaMoTe l517 r. IIMeJIacb

cTaTbfI,3aKpenJ1HBmaH
ocBo60>KneHmeoTmaHIIMBcexppoqHx nomJIIIII, <<OnPIILIb FIMcKHx XeHer lI nocOmHble CJIy)KObl》．

B nepecJIaBcKoii rpaMoTe l517 r. roBopHJIocb:くonpII&KIb
〆

H M y Ⅲ Ⅱ o c o m H b l e C J I y > Ko b l > .

Bce aKTbl, BblnaHHble 9巾eBpaJIH EJIeHoii rJI|HHcKoii Ha
BoTIIIIHbl TpoImKoTo MoHacTblpfl B yKa3aHHblx Bblme ye34ax,

nocTpoellbl B UeJIoM no o6pa3Uy KocTpoMcKoi rpaMoIbl, Ho

orpdHIItlIITeJIbHblenyHKTbl
c｡oPMyJIHpoBaHblBHIIx｡6皿〉Ke

K TeKcTy rPaMOTbI nePecJIaBcKOii, nPmIIeM 'IPe3BblllaiIIIo cy:
U

uLeCTBeHHO nOHOJIHeHHe, CJeJIallHOe B nPaBIITeJIbCTBeHHOH

KaHIleJIHPllll K ｡oPMyJIe, KOTOPaH yKa3blBaJIa noBHIIHOCTII，
ⅡOnJIe>K aBmHe :BblHoJIHeHHIo: B qHcJIe nocJIeXHIIx Ha3BaHo

e皿e ropoIoBoe neJIo. Becb Pa3neJI, nocBH皿eHHblii nonaTHo-

MyIIMMyHHTeTy,BblrJIH4HTTaK:くHeHano6ellMMofl...naHb,
HII IIHble HHKoTOPble nomJIIIHbl,

onPHIIb FIMy H

ropoLOBoro

neJIaIInOCOmHbIGCJIy)K6bl>p93.
CJIeXoBaTeJIbHo, cpaBHIITeJIbHblit aHaJIII3 nonaTHoii KIacTH

gHB2pcKo-｡eBpaJIbcKIIx>KaJIoBaHHblxr"MoTE"bII皿HcKOii Ha CeJIbCKHe 'BOTqHHbl MOHacTblPeII B Pa3Hblx ye34aX

no3BoJIfleT 3aKJIIoIIIITb, IITo 60JIbmee WIH MeHbmee cOKPaIIIel-lMe O6'beMa

nOnaTHOrO IIMMyHHTeTa 3aBIICeJIO

rJIaBHblM

o6Pa30M OT TOrO, HacKOJIbKo TecHO cPoCJIaCb 3KOHOMI'1LIeCKII
HnO皿ITIIIIeCKII

C

BeJIHKIIM

KHH>KeCTBOM

Ta

TePPllTOPHH,

rne Haxo皿JIHcb o6もeKTbl HO>KaJIOBaHIIH. neiiCTBIITeJIbHO,
CaMble Cy皿eCTBeHHble nPIIBIIJIerlIH 3aKPenJIflJIHcb 3a MOHa-

CTblPCKHMII
BOTqHHaMII
B
COCTaBe
mIKBH皿POBaHHoro
nM
HTpoBbKoro KHH>KecTBa (Tapx"Ho-o6poqHble皿HHocl"oBoJIoKoJIaMcKoro, KHplIJLIo-BeJIo3epcKoro H epanoHToBa
MoHacTblpeii, ocBo60)KneHme oT HBopUoBo-KHH)KecKIIx, 3eM;
CKHX IIOBIIHHOCTe仇 Ⅱ ⅡPOe31Hblx

nOmJIHH

IJIH

BJIaneHHII

Tpo皿e-CeprlleBaMoHaCTbl")
MeHee
.
3HaqHTeJIbHblMII6bl-

JIHnOXaTHble lIMMyHIITeTHble nPaBa MOHaCTblPcKIIX BOTqIIH

ByrJI皿KoM,Be>KbUKoMHHPocJIaBcKOMye3nax(TOJlbKo
OCBO60>KneHIie

OT

IBOPHOBO-KHH)KeCKIIX

nOBI'IHHOCTeH H

3eMcMIx pa3MeToB) . OKIeHb cKyno o6eJIHJIHcb ceJIbcKMg BJIa-

neHIIflTp61me-CepfHeBaMoHacTblpHBMocKoBcKoM,IOpbeBnoJIbcK6M H nomexoHcKoM ye3,naX (oT 3eMcKIIx pa3MeToB
93 Cp. rpaMoTy l507 r. nepecJIaB'cKIIM coKoJIbHIIK3M,

<<dnpll[iblIM)r
ropOnpBaro
m
neJIammocomHblfIcmy)K6b!》
Nb ̅26, cTp. 47, cT. 3) .

297

r且e

CKa3aHO：

(ACSm, T､1II,

CIIeTKOh巾OPMyJIIIPOBKOinPHHy>KIeHIMKBblnOJIHeHHIO
U

HMaK roponoBoro ,mleJIa II nocomHoii cJIy>K6Ijl) .

BliCcJIe49¥HHlIoKomliiHbIxKH"IhxTIj6"e-CcprlieBa
U

MWEmpHXVIBMbInpmmIIIIKBbIBomy,qfo,K6Hfp6jimi
U

u

U

COCTaBJIeHHeTPO皿KoHKOnmiHOiiKHIIrHB巾eBpaJIel534r.,

WBHTeJIbcTBo
EJIeHbI
rJII1HcKoi
npMMeHlIJIb
ofIpeneJIeHHbi6
④

u

MeTOIDICOKPa皿eHIuIIOP皿晒ecKomOcHoBb[｡IIHaHcOBblx
U

qRUEI1JIerliWM9HaCrbIPCKIIXJBOPOB,nPOMbICJIOB̅IITOPrOBbIX
U

a"""" Kon"Ham KHlira ̅B KaK6#-To Mepe oTja>KaeT

yKP2nJIeHIie <<cOIO3a> BeJIIIKoKHfI>KeCKOii BJIacr" nOcMOB 94.

3TOT
BblBOI
B
o6me仇巾oPMe
nOJITBeP>KnaeTCH
II3yIIeHII-

RM HHBapcKo-｡eBpaJIbcKIIx )KaJIoBaHHbix rpaMoT 1534 r.

Pa3B;IITIie
TOBaPHO-neHe>KHblX
oTHOme|HHII
cTPaHe
B CnOCO6u

cTBoBaJIO nPaBHTeJIbCTBeHHOMy orpaHIIIIeHHIo TaMo>KeHHOrO
HMMyHIITeTa MOHaCTblPem
HMMyHHTeTa
MOHa'CTblPeH BBHX
IIX ceJIb'CKHx
ceJIbCKIIx BOTrIHHax.
BOTIIHHax，PereHTPereHTCKHH cOBeT BIToJIHe y[IeJI cIBHrH, nPOHC皿'e1mHe B 3TOii o6U

JJacTHBHa[IaJIeXVIB・B60JIbmIIHcTBe>KaJIoBaHHblxrpaMoT nepBom TpeTH
B
MoTⅡepBoH
TpeTHXVI
XVIB・Ha
CeJIaH1ePeBHHHecOneP>Ka4
JIocb
OcBO60>KIIeHIIH
OT
TaMrH­I､JIaBHoH
ToPrOBoH
nOmJIHHbl･
⑥

｡

npaBMTeJIbcTBo
EJIeHbl
rm,IHcKoH
I1cnoJIb30BaJIO
nPOBeU

neHHoe BBnPe又meCTBylO皿HHⅡePHo且cy>KeHHe
瓜eHHoe
nPe4meCTBylOmlm nePlIoJ< cy>KeHHe TaMO>KelIHOrO
TaMO>KeHHOrO
H M MyHHTeTa巾eOnaJIoB B Rx ceJIbcKIIx BOTIIHHax. I'IMeBmlie-

W ̲5 4Byx rPaMoTax IOpIIH (1510 m l529 rr) Iiocm.oBoJIoKoJIaMcKoMyMoHacTEipIoIiao1HHHTOTJKeKOMnJIeKC
Py"KHx BOT[IHH cTaTbH o nOP"Ke B3HMaHHH TaMrHHnHT­

Ha956bMHBKJIIoIIeHbIB1534nB>KaJIoBaHHiierPaMOMifa
2ce npyrIie Py3CKo-IMHTPoBcKIie CeJIaH且ePeBHII Hoc"O-

Bo"oKoJ1aMcK9ro
MoHacfbIpH
(3a
MoHa6TbipeM
3aKpenhn-

JIocbnpaBoc60pa3TIIxnomJIHHToJIbKococBoHxKp6cTbHH,
HO He C nOCTOPOHHHX­《rOpOnuKIIX>D IIJIH《CTaHOBblX》JIIO・

瓜eii).BcoxpaHIIB皿eMcHcHIIcKe(KoHUaXVIB.)rpaMoTbl
IOpHH1529r.B巾OPMyJIeくyrOPOnUKIIXJIIOneilIyCTaHOBblx H
H yy BOJIOcTHblx
BOJIOcTHblx KoHeH
KoHeli HryMeHy
mryMeHyCBOHMⅡHTI­IOM
CBOIIM "TI-IOM He
Hen兄T-

HaTH》ⅡpOnymeHa IIaCTHUa <<He> 96, BCJIemCTBHe IIerO CTaTbe
U

npH瓜aH o6paTHbIih cMbIcJI. Mo>KeT 6blTb, 3To oHHcKa HJ1II
TeHIeHnIIo3Hoe HcnpaBJIeH;He nepenHcqHKa KoHna XVI B.､ʼ
llq ecJIH nonycTHTb, tITo IOp砿ユeHCTBHTeJIbHO II3MeHIIIJI - B
U

l

l529r・TeKcTrpaMoTbll510r.BcTopoHyyBeJIH[IeHI畑ⅡpaB
MoHacTblPH, To Hano 6yneT nPll3HaTb c,ﾉIe40BaHIIe rPaMOT
唾

94 C. M. K a m T a H o B. KonllnHble KHHrll…, CTp、15-16.
95 A3HX, q. II, Nb 48, 1112.

96 TaM )Ke, M ll2, cTp. 106.
298

1534 r. orpaHHIIHTeJIbHo簡巾opMyJIe l510 r., a He pacmlipmTeJIbHO揃巾oPMyJIel529r.
BblnaBaH >KaJIoBaHHble rpaMoTbI TpoIiUe-CeprmeBy Mo-

HaCTblPlO Ha 3eMJIII EMIITPOBCKOrO yneJIa, nPaBIITeJIbCTBo
EJIeHbi rJIIIHcKoit IITIIoplIpoBaJIo HJIH nepeneJIblBaJIo ｡op-

MyJIHpTexrpaMoTIOpHFI,meHMelacbcTaTbHくWHTaMra>L.
BblJI nepeⅡⅡ'ca{H TeKcT TOJIbKo OXHo尚ⅡMIITPoBCKOPi rPaMoTbI
C STOh巾OPMyJIOii, HO H TO JIHmb nOTOMy, tlTO B rPaMOTe

O"oBPeMeHHO cOXeP)KaJIaCb CTaTbH, ｡aKTwIecKH aHHyJIIIPOBaBmafl neiiCTBIIe ｡opMyJIbl＜HH TaMra> B ee cTaPHHHoM
CMblCJIe: nOn BImOM OrPaHII[IGHHHnPaBa c60Pa MoHacTblpCKOrO nHTHa B rPaMOTe OnPeneJIHJIcfl nOP"OK TaMO>KeHHQZO

06JIo>KeHHFI npH nPOXa>Ke H MeHeBCHKHx TOBaPoB.no
cymeCTBy, KapTIIHa nOJIyrlaJIaCb TaKafl lfie, KaK B rPaMOTax

IIocII｡o-BoJIOKoJIaMcKoMyMoHacTblplo9Z

B XByx Xpyrllx py3cKo-nMIITpoBcKIIx rpaMoTax 1534 E
TpoIme-CeprlieBy MoHacTblplo Ha ceJIbcKIIe BQTIIHHbl 3aKpenJInJIocb ocEo60>KneHHe oT MHoroIIIIcJIeHHblx (IIacTHIIHo y>Ke

OTMePmHx)MeJIKIIxnomJIHH,rJIaBHblMo6pa30Mnpoe3n今

Hblx 98. TaMra cpe皿HHX He巾HrypHpoBaJIa. He 6blJIo cTaTbII
O TaMre II BO BCex nPOIIIIx RHBaPcKo-(I)eBPaJIbcKMIx )KaJIOBaHHblx rPaMOTaX, oTHOCH皿HxcH K CeJIbcKIIM BOT'IHI-IaM Mo-

HacTbIPeif. neiicTByfl coBepnleHHo B Iyxe noJIIITHK1 BacIIJIIIH
111,
nPaBIITelJIbCTBO
PereHTmmOTMeHHJIO
npaBO
HOKPoBcKoro yrjiIInKoro MoHacTblpH Ha c60p MoHacTblpcKoro
nHTHaHnepenaJIo ero yrJIHUKIIM BeJIIIKOKHH>KeCKHM nflTeHmHKaM 99. STO COOTBeTcTBOBaJIO IIHTePecaM HOCaXCKIIX JIIO-

且ei yrJIHIIa H 3anaIIe yKPenJIeHHH 3Xecb annaPaTa BeJIHKOU

KHH>KeCKOH

B J I a c Tx ･

He6e3blHTepecHo, [ITo BonpocaM TaMo>KeIIIIoTo IIMMyHHTeTa MOHaCTblPeii y4eJIeHO BHIMMaHIIe B rPaMOTaX Ha CeJIa

linePeBHI1BnPene､iax6bIBulliXmMIiTPOBCKOrOliyr"皿KOrO

ymeJioB,
Me>KJy
TeM
KaK
B
oCTaJIbHbIxTPaUOTax
nPO6JIeMa

iaMo>KeHHoro ̅HMMyHHTeTa He cTaBIMTcH. OTMeIIeHHyIo 3aKoHoMePHocTb nonTBeP>KnaeT cJIenyIomee: cneuHa4mbHblP
nPoe3>KHe rPaMOTbl, BblnaHHLIe MOHaCTblPHV" B HaIIaJIe

1534
m,
oTHOCHTcH
HMeHHo
K
mMHTpoBcKoMy,
KamHHCKOMy

HymI皿KOMy ye3naM, nPlIIIeM B HHx e皿e 3aMeTHee orPaHII' I H Te J I b H b l e Te H n e H u H H .

97 Xn, 1, M 320 (|cp. TaM )Ke, Nb l69).
98 TaM )Ke, Nb 318, 319.

,99<<flpocJIaBcKHery6epHcKIIeBenpMocT",
1855,KIacTb
Heo*|皿HaJIbHaH，
Nb 48, cTp. 435-436.

299

noIBepraJIHcb H3BecTHoit perJIaMeHTaUHH na>Ke BoTIIIIHHblg nepeBo3KII HeToproBoro xapaKTepa B rpaMoTe TpoII-

ue-CeprlieByMoHacTbIploMoHa6TblpckIIMKp6cTbHHaMba3pemaJIOCb6e3MblTIIQ116ecTaMO>KeHHoBe3TII
BMoHacTblPb
noBo3 B cocTaBe lOO Bo30B II3 ceJIa npHceK ToJIDKo oⅡHH
Pa3 ,B ronly, 3HMoii loo.

3HarIHTembHblii ynaP HaHecJIH fIHBal)cKo-｡eBPaJIbcKIie
rpaMoTb[1534jZnonpmBm"ermHMMoHacTblpcKnxToproBbIx
3Kcne皿皿嘘BKamHHCKoM,
nMHTPOBCKoM
IM
yrJI皿KOM
ye3"x. >KaJIQBaHHaH rpaMoTa lOplIFI Tpo皿e-CeprmeBy MoHa-

cTbIpIo.1507EnaBaJIgnpaBo̲｡ecno皿川IHH6roijPOe3na
口O BCeH TePPHToP皿 nMHTpoBo- Ka皿HHCKOrO yneJIa MOHa-

CTblPCKOMy KIIIqlIHe C JIIOXbMII H JIIO6blM TOBaPOM B 111060M
KoJII'IIIecTBe. npll 3ToM HaMGcTIIHKHHBOʻⅡOCTeJIPI He HMeJm
nPaBa cy瓜HTIJ KynIIHHy II erO JTIOnei H ,[laBaTb HX IIa nOPy-

KH: KynIIMHa B IICKOBblx neJIax 6bm n()JIcyJleH caMOMy yLIeJIbIi9My K"310 Imm erO 60HpIIHy BBegeHOMy !o'. rpaMOTa

1534E102BocnpoII3BomlIJ1alieaTyrpaMoTy,̅acKyn)fIorPa-

MoTy lIBaHa llI 1502 E, B KoTop6ii lie 6bLid ocB660"eli"

oTTaMrm!93nPaBZIa,nPOe3)KafTrpaMoTa"PanOHTOByMOHaCTblPlo104,OCHoBaHHaHHa巾opMyJIHperpaMoTbllOplIFI105,
conep>KaJIa ocBo60>KneIIIIe oT TaMTII H MIIorIIx npyrHx
nomJIIIH B >KaJIoBaHHoih rpaMoTe noKpoBcKoMy yrJHIIiKoMy
MoHaPTbIPlo npoBO皿JIOCb OrPaHIIrlellIIe nPOe34HblX nPHBIIJIer" MoI-IaCTbl" B yrJTHnKOM ye3ne・no rpaMoTe l523 r.

oT MpITa m IIBKI[ ogEo60>K""c2 3HMoii l2 MoHacTbIpcKHx

caHe#, a JIeToM - 15 Te,iIer lo6rpaMoTa l534 rl)a3PeImaJIa 6e3MblTHbli II 6e3LHBOqHblii npOe34 TOJ1bKo nHTH baHem
3IIMO力HJIII OXI-IOi JIanbH JIeTOM.

O6 0rPaHIIIIeHHII TaMo)KeHHoro IIMMVIIHTeTa Mo>KeT cBII"TeJIbcTBQBaTb oTcyTcTBIIe npoe3>KIIx rpaMoT CIIMoHoBy H

KHPIIJIJIO-BeJIo3ePCKoMyMoHacTblpHM,KoTopblepaHEme
nOJIb30BaJIIICb COOTBeTCTBylO皿HMH rpaMoTaMII IOpl'1R.

ⅡPHcTaJIDHoe BHHMaHIie PereHTcKoro coBeTa K TaMo>KeHHOMy HMMyHIITeTy MOHaCTblPeii Ha TePPlITOPHH且ByX B HOcJIenHIoIo oIIePenb ｡ﾉIHKBI皿HpoBaHHblx yneJIoB o6'EFIcHHeTcfl
０
０ LIrAnA, rl<3 no Be)KeUKy, Nb 69/1 173.
１
１ AA3, T. I, Nb 148.
０
１
２ UrAJA, rI<3 no nMIITpoBy, Nb 51/3763
０
１
３ rnB, noron. 1905, ､m. 57­57 06., Nb 33.
０
１
４
０
１
５JIOIIH, Konn.'lll5, JV@ 444, ". 11-ll o6.
０
１
６AAS, T. I, M 170/1.
０
１

f:2pQpJIaBcKIigry6epHcKme
BenIoMocTI",
1855,
lacTbHeo申Ⅱ皿aJIbHaHF
JMb47,cTp.426,

300

四

TeM, IITo B3THx
TeM，IITo
B STHxPaHOHax
PaiiOIIaxO>KHBJIeHHO}I
O>KIIBJIeHHOII
Tol〕rOBJ11i
Tol)rOBJIIi y瓜eJIbHble
yleJIbHble

TPaAHuHHcHOCO6CTBOBa皿4CoxPalleHIIIOKPellKllxTaMOJKeHHblX nePerOPOnPK II cBH3aHLiblX c HHMH HcKJIIOqMTeJIbHblX
MoHacTBIpcKHx npHBHJIer". Pa3pymeHIIQ. HJIH orpaHHtleHHe
U

IIMMVHIITeTHbIx ⅡPHBHJIerHH
HMMVHHTeTHbIx
nPIIBHJIer" MoHacTblPemHa
MoHacTblPeH Ha BHyTpeHHeM
BHyTpeHHeM
ジ

U

PycCKOMPblHKe6bmooLHHMII3Tpe60BaHI畑mHpoKIIxKpyU

roB Hocana. 3aIIHTepecoBaHHoe B coIo3e c comiaJIbHoII Bep-

xymKoHⅡOcanPB,ocO6eHHOTex,KOTOPbleHaXO且Hm1cbB
U

UeHTPaX HenaBHO yllliIITO>KeHHblX y4eJIbHblX KHH)KeCTB, nl)aB IJTeJIbCTBomJIO Ho JIIIHIM COKPaUeHIIH TaMo)KeHHOro HMU

MVHHTeTa MoHacTblpeih, oAHaKo B ycJIoBIIHx He 40 KoHna
U
U

nPeonpJIeHHoih3KoHoMm'leclfoipa3npo6JIeHHocTH
npeo瓜oJIeHHoK3KoHoMH1IecKom
pa3叩o6JIeHHocTⅡcTpaHbl
cTpaHb[
oilo He MorJIo nPBecTM 3Ty 60Pb6y nP PemliTQJIbHoro KoHUa.
II3 H3BeCTHblx HaM HHBaPcKO-｡eBPaJII,cKHx BeJIHKOKHH-

>KecKIIx )KaJIoBaHHblx rpaMoT 1534 r. nHTb noc"皿eHbl MO-

HaCTblPCKIIMrOPOnlCKI'IMJBOPaMHO八IIacJIo6oHKe.
rpaMOTbl
Ha
KOCTPOMCKHe
m
cy3maJIbCKHe八Bopbl
TpoIIUe-Cep〆

rIIeBa MOHacTblPH 107, a TaK)Ke Ha erQ̲ ceJIbcKylO CJIOOOnKy

BoBJIa"MIIpcKbihBoJIocTIIMe4ymax｣08conep>KaT,KaKy>Ke
U

P aCcMaTpIIBaBmmecH MoCKoBcKIIe, IopbeB-nOJIbcKIIe II nomexoHcKHe aKTbl, CTPOrO orPaHHIIeHHble HOPMbl nOnaTHOro

II cyne6Horo IIMMyHIITera. 3To cB"eTeJIbcTByeT o nonbITKa¥
｡

npaBIITeJIbcTBa lICnoJIb30BaTb B UeJIFIx orpaHHHHTeJIbHoIf
yH"HKa皿HIiMMyHHTeTa HaJIIIIIme BⅢ3yIIaeMoe BPeMH
U

HeKoToPorO e瓜HHCTBa B cTeneHH COUmaJIbHblx nPOTIIBoPe'IHH
B rop"cKIIX UeHTpax H ceJIbcKIIx MeCTIIocTHx K BocToKy oT

MocKBbl, Bo BJIa瓜ⅢMIIpo-Cy34aJIbcKoii 3eiIJIe, II B oTneJIb-

HbIx paioHax Ha ceBepg. Tpli rpaMQTb! PbI" BblXaHb! Ha
ropo瓜cKHe”opbI BnMHTpoBe（zoc”o-BoJIoKoJIaMcKoU

Mf!d9;KIipmiJId-BeJIo3epcKoMy!19,TpoliUeRPeprlleW''!MoHaCTblPHM)HO皿aHa4BoPBKa皿HHe(Tpo皿e-CeprHeBy

MoHacTbIplo) !'2. KHpHJIJIo-6eJIo3epcKafl rpaMoTa ycTaHaBJIHBaJIa KOHTPOJIb naHHOrO nPHCTaBa 3a rOPO4CKIIM 4BOPOM
II He oTJIHIIaJIacb nO conteP>KaHIiIo oT cPOIIHblx rPaMoT Ha

ceJIbcKIIe BoTqHHbl. OcTaJIEHble aKTbl *HKcHpoBaJIH ｡HHaHCOBble H cy4e6Hble nPlIBHJIerHH. lix orPaHIIIIHTeJIbHafl Ha-

npaBJIeHHoETbcpa3y
ⅡDaBJIeHHocTb
cpa3y＞Ke6pocaeTcH
>Ke6pocaeTcHBrJIa3a，O6e
rJIa3a.O6erPaMoTbl
▲

０
１
７AA3, T. I, JYb l79.
０
８rnB, Co6p・aKTOB H rPaMOT, Nb l-104
１
０
１
９A3HX, m. II, Nb 132.
０ rnB, Q- IV- 113 6, ". 732-733 .
１
１
１
１
１
ArP, T､1, M 43.
１
１
２

rnB, Co6p. aKToB II rpaMoT, Nb l­lO6
301

TpomUe-CepmeBy
MoHacTblpIo
coKpa皿aJII'I
I'IMMVHIITeT
roｰ

po八CKIIx JBOPOB Ho cI)aBHeHHIO Co cTaPblMII rpaMOTaMII IIa
JMIIIPOBCKIie II KammHCKIIe lBOPbl.

BoWIIqlleoTWMoTXVB;KacaBmlixcRTpoHuKHX4BO20B
BUMIITPoBe!'3,
HoBaHrPaMOTa
HeCO4gP>Ka"̅̅d65660xmeHMHoTHMamn"BoLB̅rpaMoTel501flop"HkiIH月

VWWPH B ､KaUlHcKoM "OPe 3aKPenJIRJIac6 <OnPliqb

典ymery6cTBa>
!14
HoBafI
rpaMoTa
Ha
lfamHHCKHH且BOP
OTU

HOCHJIa
K
KOMneTeHUHⅡHaMeCTHHIIbemQ̲cyna
He
TOJIbKO
4y-

mery6cTBo,
Ho
pa360曲C
II
HOJII,四HbIM.
>KaJIOBaHHafI
rl)aMbfa
llaJBopHocIIjo-BoJIoKoJIaMcKoroMoHacTbIpfIBJMilTpoBe,
｡

U

COBna八aH HO CO4eP)KaHMIO c TPOHUKoii rPaMoTOji Ha nBa
瓜MIITPPBcKJIx 4BOPa, Pe3KO oTJIMIIaJIacb OT cIIHxPOHHbIx rPa』

MoTHOc"o-BoJIoKoJIaMcKoMyMoHacrbIpIo!faceJiE6kmE

BQT[IHHbl, 3aKpenJIHBmHx o6poIIHoe ocBo60班旦eHHe OT nona-

Teih
H
Cyne6HylO
BJIaCTb《onpH[Ib
ny皿ery6cTBa)D.
B
IBopoBoii
rpaMQTe HeT ocBo60>KneHIIH oT ocHoBHEIx no"Teii H ioBHH｡

U

HocTeli,
HocT
eH，acy且e6Hbl
a cyme6H" mMMyHIITeT
I1HMMyHHTeT“K
｡IIKcmpyeTc
cmpyeTcH《onpHIIb八y-

mery6pTBampa360HcnoJIMIIHbIM1>.HHT6pecHo,LITbcaf6ii
U

r

,

HOPMOH OrPaHliqeHHH MOHaCTblPCKoA IOPHcIHKUlIPI COrJIaCo-

BaJIacb ToJIbKo oIHa rl)aMoTa IIoc"o-BoJIoKoJIaMcKoMV
ソ

MOHacTblPlO, KacaB皿aHcFI CeJIbCKIIx BoTIIHH,­HMel-IHO八MHTU

POBcKa H・B Heih >Ke orcyTcTBoBaJIo ocBo60xmeHIie oT n6comHOM CJIy>K6bI，rOPO八OBOrO且eJIaHnpHMeTa
HOH
CJIy)K6bI, rOPO40BOrO neJIa
ll5.

TaKIIMo6pa30M,HecMoTpHHaja3pbIBMe>K4yconel))KaHHeM.JIBoPOBblx H CeJIbcKHx IJMMyHHTeTHblx aKTOB, nOJIO)Ke●

○

IIHe "eO"JIpHoro HMMyllHTGTa IIe BO BCeiM MOHaCTblPCKO曲

BOTIIIIHeBOO6me,aBCeJIaX,PaCnOJIO>KeHHblxBye31ebooTBeTcTBylO皿erO rOPOICKOTo UeHTPa, B H3BecTIIOih CTeneHM
BJIHHJIO Ha xaPaKTeP OrPaHLIIIeHI1H 4BoPOBOrO IIMMyHHTeU

Ta - cBoeo6pa3Hoe npoFIBJIeHIie rocno46TBa nepeBHil Ha4
roPonoMnpH｡eonaJIH3Me3ToHa6JIIoJeHHeno"Bep>K,maeTcH coHocTaBJIeHIieM 4MHTI)oBcKHx rpaMoT 1534 r. Ha ceJIb-

9KHegoTqIIHb[ H Ha 4Bopb! Tpomue-CeprIieBa MoHacTblpH

(ocBo60>"eHHe
QT
TaMo>KeHHbli<
nomJIIIIi,
UBopUoBo-KHfI>ke-

cKHx HoBHHHocTeH HH3eMcKHx
cKHxⅡoBHHHocTeH
3eMcKIIx pa3MeToB)
pa3MeToB)．HocTaBHTb3HaK
. Ho cTaBHTb 3HaK

paBeHcTBa MeXZy "IHTpoBcKIIMH JBopoBblMII H ceJIbcKHMH

rpaMoTaMHl534r.TpoHuKOMyMOHaCTblPlOHeJIb3H-npe>Kne BcerO nOTOMy, IITO B IBOPO'BblX rPaMOTax IIMMyHHTeT Pacソ

' 1 3

４
５

ACali, T. I, JYb 337 (1463 1､.) ; m6, nOro4 1905, Jm. 60 od- 61 06"
JYb 42 (1462 r), ""､ 61 06.-63, JY@ 43 (1473 r.).ʻ
AC3H, T. I, JVb 637.
A3HX, m. 11, Nb 130.

302

ロpoCTPaHFIJIcH He Ha BCe HaCeJIeHMie nBOPa: nOnK HIIM HaXO瓜mJIIICb TOJIbKO MOHaCTblPCKHe nBOPI-IHKPI, T. e. CJIym, ynPaB-

､咽BUlHe 4BOPOM・noJIIIoe
coBnamelIHe HMMVHHTeTIIoii [IacTH
A

ﾉIM IITI)OBCKMX皿OPOBI)IX rPaMOTルIocII巾o-BoJIoKoJIa McKoMV
II TpoMUe-CeprlieBy MoIIacTblpHM cBI"eTeJIbcTByeT o HaJIH[IHII o6皿I'IX COⅡHaJIbHo-3KOHoMII[IecKHxⅢnoJIHTHIIecKHx MoM e H T O B , O n P e l e J I fl B m H x 3 H a Ⅶ I Te J I b H y I O C Ky n o c T b M o H a c T b l P -

cKHx rPaMOT, OTHOcHUIIxCH K JMMTI)oBcKHM IBOPaM. BOJIbmyIo POJ1b 3necb cblrPaJIo, OqeBI'皿IIo, 3KOHOMIIIIeCKOe yCHJIe-

HMe 4M1,ITPOBCKOrO nOCana lI O)KIMB4IIeHI'ie 60Pb6bl nOCamCKI'IX
mo且eii nPOTIIB 6eJIOMecTIleB.
yKPenJIeHIie lOBOJIbllomHPOKIIX nOnaTHbIX叩aB TpoMIIe̲

CeprmeBa MoHacTbipH B ero Ka皿1HcKoM IBope (ocBo60)K4eU

HMe BCeX <<JIIOLeII> BO nBOPe, T. e. He TOJIbKO ABOPHIIKOB, OT

mallHⅡⅡocomHoii cJIy>K6bl) oTpa>KaeT 3KoHoMHIIecKyloHⅡoJ I I I T H I I e C K V I O O T C Ta J I O C T b K a m H H c K o r o n o C a m a n O c p a B H e H H I O
ご

C瓜MIITPOBCKIIM. nOmaTHaH IIaCTb KamHHCKOii rPaMOTbl HO-

BTopflJIa yHoMHI-IyTyIo rpaMoTy l501 r., KoTopafl cxoJHa c
rpaMoToi l504 r. Ha ceJIa TpomUe-CeprlieBa MoHacTblpH B
KamlIHcKoM ye34e (ocBo60)MeHIie oT naHII II HMa) !l6
CJIenoBaTe,JIbHo, H 3八eCb CKa3aJIoCb Bo3meiiCTBHe CeJIbCKorO

-

u

I 1 M M V H I I Te Ta H a r o p o L c K o I I .

OT Bcex BeJIHKoKH"KecKIIx roponcKIIx rpaMoT cymeCTBel-IHe曲mHM O6Pa30M oTJIHIlaeTcH >KaJIoBaHHaH rPaMOTa

AII叩efl CTaP皿Koro, BblmaHHaH B FIHBape l534 r. mocII*oBoJToK()JIaMcKoMy MoHacTI]Iplo IIa nBop B CTapHUe. rPaMoTa
nPenOcTaBJIFIJIa HaCeJIeHMIO IBoPa nPaBO He nJIaTIITb rJIaBHble nOLIaTII H He }IC｢IOJIHHTb OCHOBHble l-IaTyPaJIbHble nOBHH-

IIocTII: <<He Ha406e... AaHb, HII FIMcKHe neHm, HH nocomHafl

cJIy>K6a, HH HaMecTHIIII KOPM.., IIH rOpOlla He neJIaIOT>> 117.
Ha ｡oHe yneJ1bHoKHH>KecKoii noJIHTIIKH 3JIeMeHTbl coIo3a
BeJIHKOKHH)KeCKOih BJIaCTH C HOCanaMH BblrJIHIHT OTqeTJIIIBO.

HCcJ1GIOBaHIIe HHBaPCKO-d)eBPaJIbCKIIX )KaJIOBaHIIblX
rpaMoT 1534 r., BcKpblBaHⅡPe)Kme BcerO HoJIIITIIIIeCKHe ueJIH
MX Bblna[III, nOKa3blBaeT OJHOBPeMel-IHO O6yCJIOBJIeHHOCTb
COneP>KaHIIH

rPaMOT

SKOHOMHqeCKIIM

Pa3BHTHeM

CTPaHbl.

CouHaJIbHO-3KOHOMIIIIeCKIie C4BIIrH B Pa3JIIIIIHblX PaiiOHax

pyccKoro rocymapcTBa no3BoJIHJII,I npaBHTeJIbcTBy EJIGHbl
rJIHHcKo曲B̅rpaMoTax HaIIaJIa l534 r. IIpoBecrTII HeKOToPoe
OrPaHHIIeHIIe MOHaCTblPCKOrO HMMyHHTeTa.
''6 ACSH, T. I, Nb 653.
117 Am3HX, q.̲II, Nb 129, cTp. 122
303

noaTBeP丞再eHIne
2.
KOHIJe中eBPa入図1534
B
r.
rPaMoT 4MLITPoBcKOro yaejia

nopHAQjf､JIo"HcaHHHHaliMHHBaHalVcTapbIxrpaMoT

B ｣IatlaJIe l534 n onpene""cfl l)a3MepaMm 3eMJI@BJIa"HIIH I1

｡6LeMoM IIMMyHmreTa MoHacTIjll)eiiB 20-x *1axhHB"
yTBeP班旦aJIHcb rpaMoTbI̲llali60JIee npHBIIJIerlil)oBaHHoro myご
XOBHOrO BOT'IHI-II･IﾙIKa - HocIIq)o-BoJIoKoJIaMcKoro MoHacTI;I-

I)H, B jJeBIl.JIe - rPaMOTbl TPex nPyrmx KpynHeiimIIx MOHaU

ユ

U

ダ

9Ibll)"-rFKIIp"JIO-BeJO3ePcKorO̅(1-rO),TPo皿e-Cepl､I1eBa
(9-ro) ,MocKoBcI<oro CIIMdHoBa(25-ro) !F MaPTci534 f
COCTOHJIOCb nOnTBeP>KneHﾙIe >KaJIoBaHHblX rPaMOT MOHacTblPelI 3HaqHTeJILHo MeHpmero MacmTa6a: TpoHUKoro BeJIo｡

IJgcoMKorO ( 1 -ro II 3-ro) , neIlepcKoro Bo3ntBM>KeHcKoro
(3-ro) , MocKoBcKoro qynoBa l! pfI3aHcKoro noKDoBcKoro
八

(9ZIo) , C"cCKorQ HpOcJIaBcKoro (28-ro) . Ellle no3mHee
(18 MaH 1534 r) 6bIJIa no皿HcaHa cTaPaH rPaMoTa ycIIeHcKoiiBopoHHHoinycTbIHmBsToMoIIeP"HocTHno1nHcaHHH
U

〃

･

HMMyHIITPmbIX aKTOB OTPa3HJICH XaPaKTeP (1)GOmaJIbHOrO O6-

皿ecTBa XVI B., B KiOTOPOM nOJIIITH[IeCKOe 3HaLIeHI'le l-ICDoCPelCTBeHHo 6a3HPOBaJIOcb Ha Pa3MePax 3eMeJIbHohco6CTBeHHOCTH、

BMecTe c TeM, 6pocaeTcH B rJIa3a BHeoLIepeJHoe no4TBeP>K4eHHe>KaJIOBaHHblxrPaMQT60JIeeMeJIKHMKOPnoPa"HM

Ha

BoTIIIIHbl

B

ye3max BoJIoroIcKoM,

yrJIIiUKoM H

PJKeBcKoM. l (PeBpaJIH l534 r. 6blJIH non"caHbl IIa HMFI
HBaHa lV >KaJIoBal-IHble rpaMoTbl BoJIoroncKHM MoHacTbl-

pHM-Cnaco-KaMeHHoMy1181IKoMeJIDcKoMy119,5jeBpa-

JIH nomBep>KnaJIIIcb .IPayoTbl BoJIoroncKoMy
­ Cnaco-npH-

JIyUKoMyMoHacTblplo!2orpaMoTaCeJImKapoByMoHacTblblo
I･Ia P>KeBcKHe BOTIIHHbl 6blJIa no皿HcaHa B 1)eBPaJIe

1534 r・'21, rPaMoTa ymHllKoMyKaccHaHo-y'ieMcKoMyMo-

HacTbIplo - 27 ｡eBpaJIFI 122.

BHeoIIepe4HoenoITBep>KJIGHIIe>KaJIoBaHIIblxrpaMoT,noCBHueHHblX dJHKCaUMII IIMMyHIITeTa MOHaCTblPCKIIx BOTIIIIH
B JIIIKBIUHPOBaHHblx y4e,JIbHOKHH)KeCKIIX THe34aX,
８
１１
９
１１

nOKa3bl-

JIOHH, Co6p. JIMxaweBa, Nb lO2/1, "". 3-6.

AMBpo'cⅢ曲. IICTOPHH POCCIIiiCKOh HepapxHH, w. 1V. M., 1812,
g2ZO4-=706, JYi l; mB, Co6p. aKToB i fpaMOT, JVb l-102:

JIOIIII, Co6p roJIoBIIIIa、Nb48; I､HM, Onm, Co6p. BapcoBa,
２
０
" 185/724 (Xn, 1, JYb 222) .
２《naMaIHaZ､"li>KKa TBep'oKoii ry6epHIIH Ha l868 ro". TBepb, 1868,
cTp. 287､290.
２
２
AA3, T･I, JVb 171.

１

304

BaeT, tITo nocJIenlHIle K cepenHHe 30-x ronpB XVI B．e皿e CO･
XpaHR皿I CJIenbl《Ⅱpe>KHeii aBTOHOMIIII>, CImbHO 6ecHOKOIIBmeii l)yccKoe npaBHTeJIbcTBo. B Ilel-ITpe BHIIMaHwI BHeoIIePe,IHblx HOITBeP氷典eHIIM OKa3aJIHCb rPaMOTbl rJIaBHblM O6pa30M Ha 3eMJIII, FIBJIHBmHecFI o6beKToM npHTH3aHIIih AI.I八一
peH CTapIIUKoro.
B nepBoe BPeMH HocJIe皿KBI,IAa皿Ⅲ且MIITPOBCKOro yneAJIa nPaBIiTeJIbcTBO KHHrIIHIJ-PereHTmHpe皿HJIO He nO4TBePjK-

4aTb )KaJIoBaHHble rpaMoTbl lOpHFI. O6 3ToM cBImeTeJIbcTByeT ToT *aKT, [ITo B MOMeHTbl HO瓜皿caHHfI cTaPblx BeJIHKoKHmKecKIIx rpaMoT MoHacTblpHM Hoc"o-BoJIoKoJIaMcKoMy

(KoHen< HHBa" 1534 r.) II Tpo皿e-CepmeBy (9 beBpaJIH
1534 r) aKTbI, BbUaHHble lOPIIeM, He no皿HcblBaJIIIcb. BoJIoKoJIaMcKHe rpaMoTbl lOpIIfl TaK II ocTaJIIIcb Heno1ⅡHcaHHDIMII, 3aTo PHI TpoHⅡKHx

aKToB

HoJIy[IHJI B

CaMoM

KOHIle

｡eBpaJIH 1 534 r. BeJIHKoKHH>KecKoe noIITBep>"eHHe. 3aTeM
y)Ke nOITBeP班及aJIHcb rpaMoTbl lOpHH HeKoTopblM ApyrHM
4yxOBHblM d)eo"JIaM H CBeTCKIIM JI皿aM. HocHq)o-BoJIoKo〆

JIaMCKOMy MOHaCTblPlo OblJIO La)Ke BblroPHO Heno瓜ⅡHCaHHe

]KaJIoBaHHblx rpaMoT IOpwI, TaK KaK←B nPelOCTaBJIeHHblx
eMy l･IOBblX rPaMOTaX nPaBHTeJIbcTBO HOBTOPHJIO TeKCT Hali-

60JIee皿enPbIx rPaMOT y4eJIbHOrO KHH3H, a MeHeemejpble
aKTbl OKa3aJIHcb JIHmeHHblMH IOPH,mllIIeCKOii CHJIbl. IIHaqe
o6cToHJIo neJIo c TpoIme-CepmeBblM MoHacTblpeM. HoBbIe
rpaMOTIJI, nO)KaJIOBaHHLIe eMy,̲ oTJIHIIaJIHcb 60JIbmoii cKynO-

CTblo, cTapble 2Ke rpaMoTbl lOp" c noBoJIbHo 3HaIIHTeJIhHblMH nPlIBIIJIerHHMH He 6blJIII yTBePJKJleHbl・TpoIIUKIIi MoHacTblpb, HecoMHeHHo, ynoTpe61IJI Becb. cBoii noJIHTIILIecKHii
一

一

BeC II BCe CBOe BJIHHHIIe, IITOObl HOOHTbCH nOXTBeP>KJleHHFI

pfma >KaJIoBaHHbIx rpaMoT IOpHH. 3To Ho4TBep]KXeHIIe, cocToHBmeecH 25-28巾eBpaJIFI 1 534 r., cBeJIocb K cJIenyIo皿eMy.

UbflK enop MH皿yPllH nO皿HcaJIHaBeJIHKoKH”KecKoe

IfMH rpaMoTy lOpHH 1504 r., B KoTopoii ceJIa MI,IxaitJIoBcKoeH necToBo KamIIHcKoro ye3na ocBo60>K八aJImcb oT
八alllI, FIMa, nOCO皿HO曲cJIy>K6bl, TaMTH II MIIorIIx nPyrHX n03eMeJIbI-IblX II TaMO>KeHIIblX nOmJIIII-I, a BOTⅢHHIIafI IOCTHUllFI

MoHacTblPfl OrPaHmIIHBaJIaCb TOJIbKO B neJIaX O nymery6cTBe l23.

BblJIII

noJIHOcTblO nOITBeP>KmeHIJI TaPxallHo-nPOe3-

>Kafl rPaMoTa lOpHfl HBaHoBIILIa l507 r. '24 H TapxallHo-o6'23 ACSII, T・I, Nb 653
124 AA3, T. 1, M l48̲
20

C. M. KamTaIIoB

305

poqHaH,

Hecy皿IMaH,八ByCPOqHafl

II

3anOBe,IHaH

rPaMoTa

1 532 r. Ha ceJIo UMHTpeeBcKoe 3BeHHroponcKoro ye3na ｣25.
EcJIH He cKIIITaTb npoe3)Kylo rpaMoTy l507 r., oTHocHB-

mylOcfl KaK K KamliHCKOMy, TaK II K ,mMIITPOBcKOMy ye31y,
6e3ycJIoBHoe H flBHo BblromHoe nJIH MoHacTblpFI BoccTaHQB-

JIeIIHe ero cTapblx npHBIIJIer" KocHyJIocb ero BoT[IHH B KamHHcKOM H 3BeHHroPOnlcKoM ye3AaX.
no瓜ⅡHCaHIIe HeKOTOPblx IMHTPoBcKHX rPaMOT y>Ke He
naBaJIO MOHaCTblPIO CTOJIb HeCOMHeHHblX BblrOnl, HOCHJIO

nPOTHBOPeIIIIBblii xaPaKTeP・n04TBep班且aJIacb TaPXaHHO-

o6poIIHaTI H Hecy"MaH rpaMoTa IOpIIH l513 r. Ha CgJIa neTpoBcKoe(XMHTpoBcKoroye34a)HA皿PeeBCKOe(Py3CKOrO

-ye3") ｣26, B pe3yJIbTaTe IIerO BOCcTaHaBJIHBaJIHCb nOnaTHble
JIbrOTbl B OTHOmeHIIII 3TIIX CeJI, HO BOTIIIIHHaH IOPHcntHKuHHD

3aKpenJIeHHaHBrpaMoTel534r.くoⅡpIIIIb八y皿ery6CTBa>,
nPIIo6peTaJIacTapb血cy)KeHHbliio6'beM(<<onpHIIbnymery6cTBa lI Pa360H c HO皿u''b'M)>) .

OnHoBpeMeHHo HoJIyIIIIJIII Ho"Bep>KneHIIe nBe rpaMoTbl

IOpHHHBaHoBHIIaHaTpo皿KoeceJIoHoBoenopeKIbeUMIITpoBcKoro
ye3na.
no皿HcaHHeHaBeJIHKoKHfpKecK9eHMHTap-

xaHHO-HeCymIMOii, 3anOBe,IHOii H JBycPOIIHOII rPaMOTbl
l516 r., oTHocH皿eiCH K 3TOMy CeJIy l27, 03HaIIaJIO BO3BPameIHIIe TpoH瓜KOMy MOHaCTbIPIO Ha HeOrPalllIrleHHblii cPOK HOJI-

IIoii cBo60nbl oT HoXaTeii XJIH HoBoro,nOPeIIbH, B TO BPeMH

KaKHorpaMoTelOpHFIHBaHoBHIIa,Bbl,maHHoi,HoKpaiilleik
Mepe, np l526 r., c yKa3aHHoro ceJIa <<3a naHb, H 3a HM, H 3a

nPIIMeT,H3anOCO"Oii̲KOPMIjBCeno皿叫Hbl)DByneJIbHylO

K23Hy meJI O6POK 128. qHCTO d)OPMaJIbHbIii XaPaKTeP nOnl-

TBep2皿eHIIH rpaMoTbI1516 E B qacTIi nontaTHblx npIIBIIJIerHii JIerKO BCKPblBaeTcFI nPH cPaBHeHHIi ee c JIbroTHOH rPa-

MoToii lOPIIH iia ceJIo HoBoe nopeIIbe l532̲r.2 TaK>Ke nonnIIcaHHoik̅ Ha IIMH IIBaHa lV 27 dJeBpaJIFI 1534 r. H conep-

>KaBmeii ocBo60JKnteHIIe oT o6poKa H nomJIIIH Ha lO JIeT.
OTcH且eB yPoIIHble rOnLI, rOBoPHJIOCb B rPaMOTe, MOHaCTblPcKHe KPeCTbHHeくⅡOTHHyT B... naHb, II B HM, H B nPHMeT, H B
nOCOmHOii BOJIOCTe.mHH KOPM, H B HOEBoIbl H BO Bce nOmJIH-

HLI HO KHHraM HHCUOB MoPIx, H O6POK IIM IJIaTHTH c TOrO

ceJIa II 3 XePeBeHb nO rpaMOTe> 129.
'25 urA,nA, rKS Ho 3BeHIIropo.my, Nb 9/4683
126 ArP, T. I, Nb 32.
127 rB几Tp. Nb l3/824.

'28 JIOHH,̅ Co6p. roJIoIBIIHa, Nb 52.
129 ATH, BIm. IL Nb 6.
306

B pe3yJIbTaTe yTBeP>KneHIIH o6elIx rpaMoT 6blJIII caHKuHOHHPOBaHbl, BO-nePBblx, cyne611blilIMMyl-IIITeT TpoHUKoro
MOHaCTblPH,くonpHIIb Xymery6CTBa lI Pa360FI c nOJIII[IHblM)",
BO-BTOPblx, nPHBHJIerIIH B OTHOmelllIIi BbI30Ba MOHaCTblP& ,

CKIIx KPecTbHH

B BeJIHKoKHH)KeCKHII

BenHble nPHBHJIerHIJ

H,

cy4,

HaKOHen,

B-TpeTbIIX,

3anO-

B-IIeTBePTblx, necHTIIJIeT-

Hee ocBo60)KneHHe oT rJIaBHblx npHMblx HaJIoroB (Ho皿Hca-

HHe rpaMoTbl l532 r. HBHJIocb cBoeo6pa3Ho曲ⅡOnPaBKoi K
ⅡomBep)KneHHIo rpaMoTbl l516 r.) . CJIemoBaTeJIbHo, B sToM

CJIyrlae MOHacTblPCKoe CeJIO B JMIITPOBCKOM ye3ne He nOJIyIIHJIo HocToHHHblx nonlaTHblx npHBHJIerIIit. rpaMoTa lOpHH
1504 r・Ha cTapHIIHble nMHTpoBcKHe ceJIa TpoHIle-CeprHeBa
MOHacTblpH '30, CxOIHaH C rPaMOTOii Ha KamHHcKHe CeJIa

MHxaiJIoBcKoe II necToBo, He 6bma yTBep>KnleHa.
ⅡH艸epeH皿POBaHHoe OTHomeHIIe K HOITBeP>KnleHIIIo
K a m H H C K H x H 瓜 M I I T P O B c K H x H M M y H H Te T H b l x r P a M O T o n P e n e JIHJIOcb B KOHeIIHOM
cIIeTe
Pa3JIHIIHblM
yPOBHeM Pa3BIITIIH

3KoHoMIIKH H coUIIaJIbHoih 60pb6bl B IMIITpoBcKoM H Ka皿HHcKoM ye3nlax. B 60JIee nepenpBoM c sToh TorlKH 3peHIIH
nMIITPOBCKOM ye"e nPaBIITeJIbCTBO OKa3blBaJIOCb B cOCTOHHIIII cHJIDHee yPe3aTb PIMMyHIITeTHble npHBHJIerHH TpomUe-

CeprHeBa MoHacTblpH. npH npoBepKe IKaJIoBaHHblx rpaMoT
KOPnOPaU", MeHee 3HaIIIITeJIbHblx, IIeM TpOHue-CeP rHeB

MoHacTbIpb, rpaMoTbl lOpHH, UeJIIIKoM II 6eccpoIIHo ocBo60>K,ⅡaBmHe OT nOnaTe曲KamHHcKIIe ceJIa H oco6eHHo roPo4cKHe BJIanleHIIH, To]Ke He noJIyrIHJIH nonTBep]KJleHIIFI. TaK,

Ⅱo皿HcaHHe B beBpaJIe l534 r. nByx JIbroTHblx rpaMoT
IOpHH KaJIH31IHy MoHacTblplo Ha ceJIa H XepeBHH B KamHHcKOM II nMHTPOBCKOM ye34aX, raPaHTHPOBaBmee COXPaHeHHeⅡOnlaTHblx JIbrOT MoHacTbIPfl nP HcTeIIeHIIH yKa3aHHblx B

rpaMOTaX<ypOIIHblxJIeT>131;COqeTaJIOCbCHenOnTBePJK,meHHeM 6e3naHHoii rpaMoTbl lOPHH HBaHoBHLIa l51 1 r. ToMy
ご

zKe MoHacTbIplo Ha ceJIo Kapa6y3HHoKamHHcKoro ye3Aa 132.
He 6blJIII nonTBep)KneHbl H TapxaHHble rpaMoTbl CpeTeHcKoMy >KeHCKOMy MoHaCTblPIO

Ha

ceJIo,

1ePeBHII,

nonOBCKIie

JBopbl H cJIo60HKy B KamHHe Ha nocaue 133.

HccJIenyH BOnPoc O ToM, nOrleMy He 6blJI yTBeP>Kn(eH Pfl4
rpaMoT IOpIIH nMIITpoBcKoro, MoJKHo ycTaHoBHTb JIBe rJTaBHble llPHqHHbl: Bo-nePBblx, 3aKPenJIeHIie B HeKOTOpblx aKTax
０ AC91f, T. I, Nb 652.
３
１
３
１Xn, I, Nb 275, 295.
１
３
１
２
３ <<pycCK" BecTHIIIK)", 1841, T. 3, KH. 9, CTp. 679
３
１
AA3, T. I, Nb 152, 158.
307

20

U

J1HIIHOH nonCy皿OCTII *eOUaJIa-rPaMOTIIIIKa ynleJIbHOMy KHH-

310134,BO-BTOPblx,cJIHmKOMPaCmHPeHHbIeHOPMbld)eO"JIb-

HoroI1MMyHHTeTaBomeJIbHblxrpaMoTaxIOpI皿．EcJIIIHeyTU

BeP>KIeHIIerPaMOTHOnePBOHnPIIIJIIHe̲HaxO瓜HJIOCbBCBH3II
rJIllBHbIM o6pa30M c BonpocaMII 60pb6bl npoTIIB y"JlbHoKHmKeCKHxTPa皿皿HHBaccaJIbHOH3aBIIcIIMOcTⅢ巾eOnaJIOB
U

U

oT noca>KeIIIIoro B TeMHI'IUy lOpI,IH, To Heno1nHcaHHe aKToB
U

no BTOPOHⅡpHIIHHe 6blJIo o6ycJIoBJIeHo C4BIjraMH, npoHcme且mHMII B aKoHoMIIKe ll KJIaccoBoii 60pb6e Ha TeppHTopIIH
JIIIKBH瓜HPoBaHHorO yneJIa.

BblXaBaH IKaJIoBaHHble rpaMoTbl, npaBHTeJIbcTBo yIIHTbl⑪

BaJIoH3MeHeHIIHBCO瓜HaJIbHOHIKII3HHCTpaHbI．OJHaKoMbl

HepacnoJIaraeMnpHMblMIIAaHHblMHocTeneHHrII6KocTH
3TOrO yIIeTa・IOpHnZIIecKIie npoTIIBopeIIIIH, HoJIyIIIIBmHecH

II3-3a IioXTBepIKieHIIH HecKoJIbkHx Tpo"KIIx rpaMoT IOp"
npII HaJIHq" HoBbIx rpaMoT 1534 r. Ha Te ]Ke BoTIIII¥bI,⑪

BOT, Ka>KeTCH, enUHCTBeHHOe, IITO HO3BoqJIHeT HaM nOnPIITII K

paccMoTpeHHIonocTaBJIeHHoroBonpoca.B.pIAynblxrQgMoTax
1534 r., KacaBmHxcH Ka皿IIHcKIIx EjlaXeH" TpoIIIle-CeprIIeBa MOHaCTblPH, nPaBIITeJIbcTBO, OIIeBH瓜HO) CJIHmKOM nepeoUellIIJIO CBoHⅡeHTPaJIH3aTOPCKHe BO3MO)KHocTII B ..CMblcJIe
U

OrPaHKqeHIIH MMMyHIITeTa nOsTOMy nOn BO3neIICTgIIeM

KPynHeHmerO
MOHacTblPH-HMMyHHCTa
oHo
BblHy班旦eHo
6blJIO
cnaTbeMyHeKoTopbIeHenaBHo3aBoeB""Ieno3H皿IH.nonlTBeP>KnleHHeB20-xIIIIcJIax巾eBpaJIH1534r.rpaMoTIOpIIH
U

Cy3IIJIO orPaHIIIIHTeJIbHOe 32aIIeHHe̲PmeJIbHbIx )KaJIOBaH

HLIx rpaM6T, BbIXaHHblx Tpome-CepmeBy MoHacTblpIo
9 (PeBpaJIH 1534 r.
3．》KaAOBaHHHe II yKa3HHe rPaMoTH

MapTa l534 - HawIaJla l538 .rr.

BnepHoHcMapTal534noHaIIaJIol538r・BIleHTPeBHHMaHIIH >kaJI6BaHHEIx H yKa3HbIx rPaMOT HaXo"JIcH nePe-

cJIaBJIb-3aJIeccKHih ye3X. H3 39 BeJIHKoKHH>KecKHx rpaMoT
K HeMV oTHocHTcH 1/3 06皿erO IIHCJIa( 1 1cO6cTBeHHO nePe-

cJIaBCkHxrPaMoTHABerpaMOTbl,ynoMHHalO皿HenePecJIaB134

3TOBOCHOBHOM)KaJIOBaHHbrerPaMOTblCBeTCKHMJI皿aM(urAHA,
rKe no nMIITpoBy, Nb 26/3738; nO KanlliHJI Nb 3/6698; *. KaJIH3IIHa
M-", KH. 4, Nb 94;AAS, T. I, JYb l49) . IE､ MoHa2Fblpc"x rpaMQT
TojTbko o"il aKT (>KaJIoBaHHaR rpaMoTa l524 r. CaBBo-CTopo"<eBCKoMy
MOHaCTBIPIO)
COneP>KaJT
ITyHKTL巾HKCHPOB
aBm嘘nOnCynHO:CTb
IInyMEHa lOpmld nMIITpObcKoMy (UrAnA, rKa no 3BeHImropoXy,
雌7/4681)．
308

CK"ye34HaP皿ycnPoIIHMII)．Cpe皿nePecJIaBcKHxrPaU

MoTnpeo6JIa且aIoTHe班aJIoBaHHble,ayKa3Hble（ceMb)，mITo

COCTaBJIHeT 66JIb皿yIO qacTb TOIIHO "TmPOBaHHbIx yKa3HbIX

fPaMoT 3al534 -ilaqamo 1538 rn CocT"̲"MoWW "2
li3yqaeMblitOTPe30KBPeMeHII,KaKIIBZWIlg­申eBPaJIe
U

r534r8fiJIh6qTmmcikJIIo"TeJIbHoMoHacTbIpcKmiT･"o

BOBHOiyKa3HOiirPaMOTeroBOPmJIOcbopapnpe"JIgW29⑪

⑪

ZAMMW"arew"M"" c""W"eOnalIQg !3LglU

皿gCTBeHHo;MHaKo,qToB1535-1537rrJpBoJIbIIQ̲pIｴIeT"Eb o6HaPy]KHJIHcb qepTb; coIo3a, cKJIa"""FW
Me)K,ﾛ;y
nPaBIITeJIhcTBoM
HeKOTOPblMHⅡPHBIIJIerHPOBaHHblII
⑪

MH
KOPnOPamIFIMH
nPOMblCJIoBblx
JIIOneH-606POBHHKOB
H
$k6EME̅5T6TB6npocTecHocBH3aHc｡aKToMoco6eUr
nO mliPoKOro PacnPOcTPaHeH" nePecnaBp"̲WM91.F
1 534=1 537 rr. ̅(rpaMoTbI npoMbICJIoBbIM KopnopaVHM II"
U

U

yye3ﾕbl
e
nePeCJIaBCKHHHII”MblKaBmHHK
eT BJI
IOTBBHMilbcitIIi)
a皿MHpcK”）Hno3T
no3ToMy
m oMyB瓜BoHHeTpe6yeTBbl皿皿〈eⅡ”
HeMy
fTo B II11CJIo Ba)KHeHmHX nPo6JIGM HcToP" BHyTPeIIHeII noU

U

U

EJIGHbl rJIPIHcKoii.
J1HTHKHBpeMeHHnpaBJIeHHHEJIeHbl
rJIHHcKoH・

"cK6JIbKo II3iecTHo, B nepecnaBJIb-3aJIeccKoM yegJIe
KOHUeHTPlIPOBaJIIICb
BoTLIIIHbl
PHna
KPynHblXH叩e3Bbl'IalIIIO
U

BJIHHTeJIbHblx
CBeTCKHx巾eOnailOB,
MIiOme
H3
KOTOPblx
6blJIII
cBFI3aHbl
POnCTBeHHbIMII
SKOHOMII1IeCKHMH
II
y3aMH
KHJI3bHC
MII myiicKIIMH.

EMfi"̅noJIHTHqecKaH poJIb nepecJIaBJIb-3aJIeccKoro
ve3且a
o6ycJIoBJIHBaJIacb
TaK>Ke
ero
HeⅡocpe瓜cTBeHHblM
co-

ceXcTBoM
TePPHTOPHe仇nMHTpOBcKorO
c
yneJIa.
ycIIJIHBag
COIO3CMOry皿ebTBeiIHblM
TPoIme-CeprHeBblM
MoHacTblpeM

HanoMIBe｡IIKCa皿IIMOHaCTEIPCKIIXIIMMyHIITeTHblXnPHBHjierHi B hepecJIaBJIb-3aJIeccKoM ye3ne, npaWeEgW
ii6kaJIo ce6e flpoqHylo onopy p cpeXe nepecJIaBcKIIX̲ 3eyr
EJIaneJIbUeB C nOjlIITHIIecKOii TO1lKII 3p2HIIH Ty ¥ 1gjlb
⑪

⑪

5;EMIMj,O̅nomTBePXWHme
rPaMQTLIBWW.11!､
nW
6iaBcKiiMCOKOJIbHKKaM136,̲nPenOCTaBJIe"er22M2TbIBJIa-

ユⅡMMM856"HIIKaM "IyaMOTbM｣"=1"IM92Z

"iOT"BnerlaTJIelime, wTO B 60PbPe c KPynHbIMII, ce"2arWg
U

CKH
ITaCTPOeHHEIMII
CBeTCKIIMII巾eoXaJIaMII
pereHTCKIIH
coB@T
U

PaCcIJHTbIBaJI
nO瓜ⅡeP)KKy
Ha
nePByIO
B OqePenb
MOHacTbIPeM,
U

3aTeMHⅡPIIBHJIerHPOBaHHblX
a
nPOMblcJIOBEIx
KOPnOPaⅡHH．
ー
135<<AKTblIIcTopmqecKHe,omlcaHWem.M.I<aTaeBEIMA.
II K.Ka6aHoʻBblM沙M., 1905, Nb l/24, CTp､31.
136 ACSH, T. 111, JYb 26,
137 AAS, T. I, Nb 183.

309

H3HCCJIen(yeMbIXIICTOIIHIIKOBHeHcHO,KaKaHPOJIbOTBOmIJIacb npH 3ToM ocHoBHoii Macce cJIV)KHJIoro nBo"HcTBa.

BoBcaKoMcJIyIIae,oTcyTcTBIIe>KaJIoEaHHbIxrpaMbTcBeTcKHM｡eonaJIaM3aMeTHOOTJIHKIaeTnePlIOnPer6HTCTBaKaK
oT BpeMeHH KHFI>KeHIIH BacJIJIIIH III, TaK II oT nocJIenIVIomero
-

nepIIonla, HaIIHIIaH c l538 r.

BblnaIIa
rpaMoT
npoMblcJ1oBblM
KoPnopaUlIflM
BblPa>KaJIa
npoBoDHBmylocH

npaBHTeJIbcTBoM

EJIeHbl

rJIHHcKoii

noJIH-

THKy
6JIaroUPmlTcTBOBaHHFI
TOPrOBO-IIPoMblcJIOBblM
KPyraM
HaceJIeIIHH.
3TO
HO4TBeP>K八aeTCH
IOIITII
noJIHblM
OTCyTCTBHeM HMMyHIITeTHblx rpaMoT MapTa l534 - HarlaJIa l538 rr.

Ha rOPOncKHe nBOPbl ｡eO"JIOB (CBeTCKIIx II XyXOBHblX) , 3a
IICKJIIOIIeHHeM IIecKoJIbKIIx BaPHHIIHblx MecT, MI Ha MOHacTblP-

cKHe ToPrOBble 3Kcnemml冊1. BMecTe c TeM, rpaMoTbl ToProBO-nPOMblCJIOBblM KOPnOPaUHHM He 6bmH OTPa)KeHIIeM
coIo3a npaBHTeJIbcTBa HenocpeXcTBeHHo c HocanlaMII. OHH

BblneJIHJIII nPlIBIIJIemPOBaHHble KOPnOPanHH II3 [IePHoTHrJIOrO MIIPa B BonPOcax cyXa H

THrJIa，HacKoJIbKo

3ameBaJIo

TaKOeBb皿叩eHHeKOHKPeTHOnOCaPl,cKa3aTbTPyXHo:3eM皿
KOPnOPaUHII HaXo且HJIHCb B BoJIOCTHx, H0, MO)KeT 6blTb, HMe-

JIII HeKOTOPOe anMHHHCTPaTIIBHOe OTHOmeHHe K noCany

(B rpaMoTe 606poBHHKaM IIJIbMexoTcKoro cTaHa IIJIeHaM

KOPnOPaUIIII Pa3Pe皿aJIOcb He TfIHyTb B. THrJIO <C roPoJCKH-

MHJIIonlbMII II C cTaHOBblM") . nPH oUeHKe 3THX HCTOqHIIKoB
KOPnOPaTHBHaHpTOPoHaneJIaHePPJDKHa3aTeMHHTbCy皿eCTBa COⅡHaJIbHOH HanPaBJIeHHOCTH rPaMOT, KOTOPaR CBO瓜Ⅲ-

JIaCb K yKPenJIeHHIO CBH3eii c 3a)KHTOIIHblMII CJIoHMH nPoMbICJIOBOTO

HaceJIeHIIH.

B rpaMoTax MapTa - HaIIaJIa MaH 1534 r. npaBHTeJII/
cTBo EJIeHbl rJIHIIcKoii 3aKpenl,IJIo pHⅡHMMyHIITeTHblx nPIIBHJIemi TpoHⅡe-CepmeBa MoHacTblpH B HepecJIaBJIb-3aJIeccKOBLye3ne l38 H HaxOnHBmIIxcFI PHnpM c HiIM Ha ceBePe
ye34aX POCTOBCKOM 139 H Be>KeUKOM 140.

BOJIee OnPeneJIeHHblii XaPaKTeP B STO BPeMFI HaxIaJI nPHo6peTaTb TaK>Ke KoHTaKT npaBHTeJIbcTBa c MocKoBcKHM CHMoHoBblM MoHacTblpeM. O6JIanafl 3eMJIHMI,I B 3aMocKoBcKoih

BoJIocTII PaMeHeille H B BblmeropoXe, npHHaJIJIeIKaBmIIMII
no nyxoBHoM HBaHa lll AHnpelo CTaplmKoMy, CHMoHoB Mo138 ATH, Bbm. II, Nb 8; H．①. ToKMaKoB HcToPIIKO-CTaTHCTHqecKOe
QIIlICaHIIe roPoXa I<IIp>KaIIa. M., 1884, cTp. 90-92; AA3, T, I, Nb 180.
139 UrAnA, rKS Ho PocToBy, Nb l2/10549.
140 UrAHA, rKa no Be>KenXy, JVb 70/1 147.
310

HaCTbIPbMOrOKa3aTbCfIpqeHb[IQJIe3HbIMR9fq3HIIWM̲B

66PE66cnPHTMI3aHIIfIMmAMpefIB
anpeJIe
l534rCHMQE
HOE MOHacTblPb noJIyqHJI >KaJIoBaHHylo rPaMOTy Ha ceJIO B

MypoMcKoM ye3ne '41, KoTopblik, Bo-nepBblx, rpaWM"̲f

BJIa,p<liMKpcKIIM ye340M, rne HMeJm BJIIIHHIie myifK",

BO-BTOPblX,
6blJI
H3BecTHOrO
POna巾opnocToM
npoTHB
Ka3a-

HII(BHaIIaJIe
l534 r・OTHOmeHIIHC Ka3aHblOOCTaBaJIHCb
，

5me¥IeBnoJIHeycToiiIIHBblMH:TOJIbKoBanpe"eBMopIW
U

nBMij,MM,6"e
nocJIb,,
npo6bIBmme
3me6b
mo
mlOml42

3HaIIeHHe )KaJIoBaHHblx rpaMoT IJIH yKpenJIeHwI npaBIM'reJIbCTBellHblx IIo3HHIIi B nOrPaHHIIHblx ye3,nax 3aKJIIorIaU

JIOCb B TOM, qTO C IIOMO皿bIO sTHx aKTOB nPaBIITeJIbcTBO nP6IIBaJIocb JIm60 ycIIJIeHIIH KoHTpQJIH Ham( MecTHbWm 3eMJIer

BJIameJIbllaMH,JIII60IIXn"MoIIHOﾕﾕep>KKⅡ．nOBenleHHe
U

⑥

mGM6i gliaTii, KaK cBeTcK6it, TaK H myxoBHoii, B o6cTaHoB⑪

｡

Ke BOeHHOii OnaCHOCTHB3HaIIHTeJIbHOHCTeⅡeHHOnPeⅡeJIHJIO
KeBOeHHOH
OnaCHOCTH B 3HaIIIITeJIbHOii CTeneHII OnPeneJIHJIO
U

⑪

Vcnex IIIIcTo BoeHHblx onepanHII.

KMalo1534r.oTHocIITcH,oIIeB皿Ho,HoBoeo60cTpeHIIe

ご

oTHomeHIIiicA皿peeMCTap皿KHM.>KaJIOBaHHblerPaMOTbl
⑥

B Mae 6blHII Bblnaiibl MOHacTbl"M 6BIBmHx yXeJIbHblx neHT-

M̅""Bm,XCfI
o6"eIIToM
noMoraTcUbCTE4皿peH
(Bo-

JIoKoJIaMcK，BoJIoma)．rpaMoTblⅡpHo6peJm
M6JiIMcK,
BoJIoma) .rpaMoTblnpmo6pejlH
BoJIoro且cKHH
BoJIoroApK"
rJIvm皿M m"cf61jb (Iia 6ecnomjlmHHBIii np9e3n B Mocr
"｣6e3ToBapoB)143kmbc"o-BoJIoKoJIaMcKHiMoH4"PP
⑥

｡

ゴ

(AaHHa"
faP"HHO-Hecy皿MaH
rPaMOTa
Ha
CeJIp
ryPOBO
&MEMM"TBePcKOMHKJIIIHCkOMye3na]L)｣44̲MW
1534 r. 06eJIbHo-Hecy且HMylo II 3anoBenHyIo rpaMoTy noJIy-

q"TBePcKoiMOTporiMoHacTbIpbl45.

ri"06TaBJIelime B "PaP6 II HIoJIe, "k532JlL̲IpWLW

BJTa"HHflMoHacTblpeti
(MaxpHmcKorol46HTpo皿e-CePrHeBal47)BnepecJIaBJIb-3aJIeccKoMye3Xe%Ka)KeTcH;JSWWR­
3aHOcnOnTBeP>KneHIIeMBHHBaPe-巾eBpaJIel535r.>Ka-

MMII;ijEMM6f
i[OBrOPOnicKHMMPHa6TbrP"MAIITQWEY
Mmm"148 H ycn6HcKoMy BoJIoToBy !49 B nIIcbMe

T
o6p、aKToBIIrpaMoT,Nb
iTCPjT;
rnB!42
141
I42nCPJT，T､XIII，nepBaHnoJIoBHHa，cT
1­111．
p、81．
l43AMBpbCWityKa3:COI1.,11･111.M.,1811,cTP.

710-712

144 A3HX, u. II, Nb 137.

'45 nr", '｡ 834, on 3, Nb 192L jL .5､5 26
146 mB, Cd6p. aKToB m rpaMoT, Nb｣-113

147 iirMX̅fKe no neljecJIaBJIIgg3anecgli9My: "
148AMBpo|cHh.yKa3.COtI.,tl.111,CTP、136-144.
149 TaM >Ke, I1．1V, cTp. 474-'481.
-311

96/88,20

L535nmryMeHaHoBroponcKoroXyrblHcKoroMoHacTbl"
・eo”c”HoBropoﾕcKoMyapxHe皿cKony MaKa”Iopa30DJIaIIaJICH <<MFITe>K> Me>Kny《cTaPHimHMH rPa瓜uKblMH) HanlecTHIIKOM H IBOPenKHM>. eOJIoc砿 npocwl MaKapHFI

XoJIO>KHTbO63'IOMMFITeIKeBeJIIIKoMyKHHgloCUeJIbloiPH-

HFITIIHMep,IITo6blくBTOM…uaPbcTByerOMHTe>KaHBOJIHblM

TmeTH B TeX PaCKoJIex He 6blJIO> 150.

y>KEB FIHBape l535 r. MaKap噸ⅡoceTHJI HBaHa lV II

gJIeHyrJII1HcKylom6blcTpOyexajlo6paTHoBHoBroponl5L
BHⅡHMo,
npaBHTeJTbcTBo
o6cy"IJIo
MaKapHeM
c
TpeBb>KHble
BecTII H HaneJIIIJIO erO HOJIHOMOIIIIflMH IJIfl nOn<aBJIeHIIHくMH­

Te>Ka>>.JIeTOⅡHCHbleH3BeCTHHOTHIOHH-HIoJIH1535r.Ⅱo瓦一

TBeP>K“foTBo3Mo>KHovbcy皿ecTBoBaHIIHBFIHBapel535r.

cePbe3Hblx Pa31IorJIacHII Me>KIy HOBrOpOnCKIIM1I HaMecTHHKaMH H HoBroponcKIIM nBopeUKIMM. Koma B I110He l535 r.

EJIeHa ̲rJIIIHcKaHnoBejIeJIa!IoBroponcKIIM!Ia MecTHHKaM
KHH310 B．II. rop"TQMJLII M. C BoIjoHIoBy II HoBroponcKoMy nBqpeHKoMy m H ByTYpJIllHy nocTaBIITb ropom B JIHToBcKoII ̲geMJI& Ha o3epe Ce6e>Ke, npHKa3y noXIIIIHHJIc"

TOJIbKO H．H: ̲ByTypJI", B To BpeMH̅ KaK ̅<KHH3b BopHc
HBaHoBHKI II MHxaiJIo CeMGHoBHIib no BeJIHKoro K"3H ilaKa3y BJIHToBcKylo 3eMJIIo He nomJIII, a cTaJIH Ha OHotI-

Kax),152.BepoHTHo,HBHHBapel535r.bTopoHynpaBIITeJIbETB4,nCP>KaJI IIoBrOPOn(CKIIimBOPenKHii ByTyPJIIIH, KHH3b ZKe

B. H. rop6aTblA H M. C. Bopo皿OB CKJI6H効Hcb K cenapaTII3My.

nOJIHTHIIGCKaH
CymHOCTb
<<MFITe>Ka>
HOBrOPoIcKIIXHaMecTHIIKoB BcKPoeTCH, OxleBH且HO, eCJIH y[IeCTb n031He甘mHe

naIIHbIe o nonblTKax A"pefI CTapmUKoro HcKaTb onopy nPoTHB npaBIITeJIbcTBa B HoBroponcKoii 3eMJIe・TecHblii KoHTaKT

M. C. BopoHnioBa c AHJpeeM CTapImKIIM B nocJIenHHe nHII
"3HHBacHIwI111,,nyMaeTcH,He6blJTcJIyrla伽IbIMbaKTOM
OTKa3
0T
yKpen,JIGHHH
norPaHHIIHo向ⅡOJIOCbl,
BIJIPa3IIBmlIihCH B HOBemeIIHHM C. BopoIInoBa II B. H. rop6aToro, BepoHTHo IIMeBmHx BJIHHHHe B nepecJIaBJIb-3aJIeccKoM ye3ne,
oTpa>KaJI Hx cBH3b c AHXpeeM CTaplInKIIM, KoTopbl# IIrpaJI
Ha PyCCKO-JIIIToBcKHx KoH,JIHKTaX IIPe3BblrlaiiHo nOKa3aTeJIbHo, IITo naTbl cocTaBJIeH" XByx nepecJIaBcKHx rPa-

MoT 1535 r. (,IHBapb H HIoJIb) coBnanaloT c xpoHoJIoriieii
'50 nAII, T. I, M 30.

151 nCP几 T. XIII, nePBaH noJIoBwHa, cTp. 90; BTopaH noJIoBIIHa,
cTp. 422; T. V111, cTp. 289.

152TaM>Ke,TXIII,nePBaHnoJIoBMHa,cTP
312

95.

onn031mHOHIIblXn<eiiCTBIIii}IOBroPoXCKIIXHaMecTHHKOB・BHnlaIIa nePeCJIaBCKHX rPaMOT IIMeJIa BITOJIHe OnQenleJIeHIIyIO

neJIb - yKpenHTb HO3皿HH npaBIITeJIbcTBa B c｡ePe BJIHfIHHHmyiicKHx-rop6aTblX152
nB"pyrlIe rpaMoTbl l 535 r. oTHocHTcH K HofI6pYoH瓜e-

Ka6plo. OHH KacaIoTcH raJIImKoro II KocTpoMcIfQFo ye3ppB
(>KfiJIoBallHaHrpaMoTaCHMoHoByMollacTblplo153HJIbroTAaHnⅢcnoB C. B. Co6aKIIHa H A. H. nHceMcKoro cTapUy

Tpome-CeprHeBa MoHacTblpH HcIIxee, npHKaSlllIKy C"a

①enPPOBCKOrO,HanycTylO
TPO皿KylO
BaPH皿yJIOmaK!54)
HoHBJIeIIIIe paccMaTPIIBaeMblx aKToB Ho3DHeH oceHblo
1 535 r. cTaHoBHTcH noHfITHblM B cBeTe JIeTonHcIIblx coo6皿e-

11HiioPyccKO-Ka3aHCKOMKOH｡JIHKTe・Heo6xo皿MOyYIecTbL
IITO ra皿皿KIIii H KocTpoMcKoit ye3"I B nepBoii noJIoBHHe
XVI B. MHoro pa3 npIIHIIMaJIH Ha ce6fl yntapbl Ka3aHcKIIx

T4Tap,qacTo6bIBaJIIIpa30peHb[HMIi.Co6blTIIjI>Ke.oceHH
1535
r、3aCTaBJIHJIH
nPaBIITeJIbCTBO
HCKaTb
oCO6eHHOHⅡo旦一
neP>KKII (jeOnaJIOB raJI皿KO-KoCTPOMcKorO PatiOHa.
nepeBopoT B Ka3aHH, IIpHBenmIIii K Top>KecTBy TaM aHTIipyCCKOhnapTHII, conpoBo>KnaJIcH Bble3npM II3 Ka3aHH
CB"aHHblx c PoCCIIeii TaTaPcKIIx KHH3eit. rOPOnlen<KHe (HJIH
KacHMoBcKHe) TaTapbl, HaxoIIIBmiecH Ha cJIy)K6e y pyccKorO nPaBHTeJIbcTBa, BOmJIH B CIIOmeHHH c

BblexaBmHMH Ka-

3aHcKHMH KHH3bFIMH II nepenaJIII EJIeHe rJIIIHcKoii, IITo
Ka3aIICKIIe KHH3bfl rOToBbl CJIy班HTb

PyccKoMy

nPaBHTeJIb-

cTBy B cJIyqae Bo3BpameHIIH m3 6eJIo3epcKoii ccbIJIKm̲PbIBmero Ka3aHcKoro naPH mHraJIGH. KaK nepeBopoT B Ka3aHH, TaK H Bble3X Ka3aHcKIIX KHR3eii, nPeⅡ'bHBIIBmmX BeJIIIKOKHH)KeCKOMy

npaBHTeJIbCTBy

OnPeXeJIeHHble

yCJIOBIIH,

co3XaJIII oqeHb HanpH>KeHHylo HoJIIITHIIecKylo o6cTaHoBKy.
BbIexaBmHe KHH3bH,

BepoHTHo, cocpenoToIIIIJIII

cBoH

cHJIbl

HeXaJIeKO oT PyccKHx rPaHIIII, H PaiioHbl, yKa3aHHble B >Ka-

JIoBaHHblx rpaMoTax KoHna l535 r., cTaJIH H叩aTbHcKJIIoIIHTeJIbHo Ba>KHylo cTpaTerlIIIecKyIo poJIb. O6e rpaMoTEI 6bmm
BblnaHLI BcKope nOCJIe nPe又'bJIBJIeHHH Tpe60BaIIHii Ka3aHCKHX KHH3eii rOP皿euKHMII TaTapaMH (25 0KTH6pH) 155
152a mViicKIIe 6LIJIII cIIJIbHbl He cToJIbKo 3eMJIeBJIaneHIIeM (10. r. A JI e KCedB. A叩apHaH II coHImJIbHaH IIcTopHH CeBepo-BocTo'IHoi PycII
XV-XVI BB. M.-JI., 1966, cTp. 1 10-133), cKoJIbKo, no-B皿IIMOMy,
I ･ I a J m I I Ⅱ e M n O m ｲ T I N e C K I I x C T O P O H I I I I KO B .

'53 nrAHA, rKS Ho ramlwy, Nb ,.19/3349.
154 r,nB, noron. 184'6, J1. 16.
155 nCPJI, T. XI'11, BTopaH noJIoBIIHa, cTp. 425.
313

BOJIbmyIOCJIO>KHocTbnJIHIICcJIePPBaHIIHnPenICTaBJIFIeT
U

np ollcxo班及eIIHe

cJIemyIomelJ

rpynnbl

IIMMyHIITeTHblX

rPa-

MoT, Bbln<aHHblx B IIIoJIe II oKTJI6pe l536 r. Ha 3eMJIII TpoH-

Ile-CeprIIeBa MoHacTblpH B HepecJIaBJIb-3aJIeccKoM 156 1I
KocTpoMcKoM 157 ye3nax. B Hx Bo3HIIKHoBeHHH, KaK H B IIcTOpmHnoHBJIeHHH IByx nPenblnymHx rPaMOT,

B

KOHeIIHOM

CqeTe OTPa31IJIOcb BeCbMa xaPaKTePHOe nJIH BHyTPeHHehno­

JIHTHKH XVI B. ycHJIeHIIe 60pb6bl npoTHB yneJIbHoKHH>Ke〆

CKOro II KHH>KecKO-OOFIPcKoro CenaPaTII3Ma B yCJIoBHHx, KOr⑪

且a

neJIaJIHCb

nOnblTKH

HeHTPaJIH30BaTb

BHemHIOIO

OnaC-

I­IOCTb．

y]Ke 3IIMoii l 536 r. HaqaJTHcb pyccKo-JIIIToBcKHe neperoBol)bl o MHPe. nePeMIIPIIe C JIIITBO#, OtleBImllO, MaJIO yCTpaHBaJ1o AIInpeFI CTapHIIKoro, He )KeJIaBmero yKpenJIeHIIH
IIO3Hn嘘PereHTcKOrOCOBeTa,KOTOPOeHBIIJIOCb6blHeII36e)KIIblM cJIeXcTBHeM nePeMHPHH・OTnleJIBHble KocBeHHble nlaHHble no3BoJIHIoT nPennoJIaraTb noJIHTHIIecKylo aKTIIBH3aUHIo

AHnpefl CTapImKoro B nePBo尚ⅡoJIoBIIHe l536 r. B cBH3H c
npo6JIeMoiinepeMHpII月ⅡPaBHTeJIbCTBOHbTTaJIOCbyCHJIHTb
cBoIo BJTacTb B cd)epe BJIwHHIIH A皿pefI CTap皿KoTo. no,ITB ep皿B B ｡eBpaJIe l536 r rpaMoTy BacmJIIIfI III nepecJIaBCKIIM cOKOJIbHIIKaM 158, nPaBHTeJIbCTBO 3al)yq"OCB nOnnep>KKoi sTo# npIIBwIerIIpoBaHHoih KopnopanHH B ye3ne,

皿e AHIIpeh CTapIInK" HMeJI HeMaJIo 10ToPoHHIIKoB bpe"'
KPynHblx CBeTcKHX巾eOnaJIOB.

no-BImIIMoMy, E,JIeHa rJIIIHcKaH cTpeMIIJIacb 3apyIIHTbCH
nOJIHOii
nO瓜旦eP>KKOi
BOJIoIIKO-TBePCKOrO
nBOPeUKOTO
H. 10. nomKorlIHa. B d)eBpaJIe l536 r. OHa nocJIaJTa ero K
I(oHIomeMy H. ｡ O60JTeIIcKoMy nJIH yqacTHHB nePerOBOPax
C JIHTOBCKHMHnocJIaMII 159. B巾eBpaJIe >Ke l536 r.《BJI anbl-

Zo" (enHcKonoM) B CMoJIeilcK- 6blJI Ha3HaIIeH cTapeX
Hoc"o-BoJIoKoJTaMcKoro MoHacTLI" CaBBa CJIenymKHII 160.
C caMoro HaIIaJIa l536 r. np rJIv60Ko#
oceHII npaBHTeJIb響
ユ

CTBo

3aHIIMaJIOcb

MIHTeHcHBHblM

rPanCCTPOHTeJTbCTBOM.

rJIaBHoeBHIIMaHmeyneJIHJIocb,KoHeIIHb,norPaHHqHbIMTepPIITOPHHM zI MeCTaM, qa皿e BCerO HOIBePraBmIIMCFI JIHTOB-

CKIIM H TaTaPCKIIM BToP>KeHIIHM・CTpoIITeJILcTBo HoBblx ro-

poZIoB-KpenocTei (By#-ropona B KocTpoMcKoM ye3ne, Be５
１
６AA3, T. I, JVb l82; rBJT, Tp. KH. 519,几Ⅲ. 32-34
７PHB, T. 32, M ｣135.
５
１
８AA3, T. I, M 147.
５
１
９
５
１
０nCPJI, T. XIII, nePBafr noJIoBIMHa, cTp. 108.
６
１

TaM >Ke, T. XIII, BTopa月noJIoBIIHa, cTp. 427.
­314

JTII)KaBToponenKoMye3ne,TeMHIIKoBa,nePeHeceHHoroHa
HoBoe MecTO, <<rPama Ha nPoHe>> H nP.) mJIo napaJIJIeJI"o c
1oneJIKoh H o6HbBJIeHHeM cTapbIx roponcKIIx IIeHTpoB (CTaU

pony6a, Top>KKa, HpocJIaBJIH, BaJIaxHbl, ycTIora, BoJIornlb')161
U

yKpenJIeHHe pyccKoro rocy,naPcTBa 6bmo o"oi ll3 nPIILIIIH T6ro, [ITo JTIITBa cHoBa 3anpocHJIa MIIpa. neperoBopbl
BeJIIIcb B Mae - HIoHe l536 r. '62 0IIeBHnHo, B 9To BpeMfI

nonblTKII AHXpeFI CTapHHKoro cOPBaTb nepeMIIpHe npHo6per
JIHBecbMa
JIH
BecbMaOⅡacHblHxaPaKTeP、nOe3瓜Ka
onacHbli xapaKTep. noe31Ka BeJIHKoKHFI>KecKoii
BeJIHKoKH”KecKOH
U

ceMbHBTpoIme-CeprHeBMoHacTblpbBHIoHel536r.163npeCJ1e八OBaJIa, KaK nyMaeTcFI, BnOJIHe OnPene｡ⅡeHHblenOJIHTHIIe-

cKme neJIII・CTI)eMJIeHIie BcTynmTb B coIo3 c TpoIIIle-CeprIIe-

BblMMOHacTbiPeUmlH60Pb6b!nPOTHBnPOIICKOBAHZIPeH
⑤

CTapHnKoro Bblpa3HJIocb BcKope nocJTe 3ToHⅡOe31KII B BHXaIIe MOHaCTblPIO HMMyHIITeTHblX rPaMOT Ha nePeCJIaBcKIIe
BOTIIHHb1．
U

JIIo60nblTHo HoBTopeHHe B BeJIHKoKHFIJKecKoHⅡOJIHTHKe
CTaPOrO COIIeTaHwI BblnaqH rPaMoT Ha

nePeCJIaBJIb-3aJIeC-

』

cKHe lI HoBropoIcKHe 3eMJIII (K IIIoHIo 1 536 n oTHocHTcFI

yCTaBHaHOHeX<cKaFIrPaMoTa)164BSTOMCoqeTaHIIIIOnHTbTaKH nPOFIBWIaCb TeHneImlIH CKOBaTb CenaPaTH3M cTOPoH-

HIIKoB AHnPeH CTapmKoro Ha nByx I､JIaBHLIx TeppIlTop"x,

rnleyHerOHMeJIHCbCTOpOHHHKH．ⅡpenocTaBJIelIIIeTpoHneCepmeBy MoHacTblplo KocTpoMcKoii rpaMoTbl B CKTH6pe
U

u

- 1 536 r. onpeneJIHJIocb maTKIIM HoJIo)KeHHeM BJIacTeH

BKocTpoMcKbMye3Xe:MoHaCTblpbnoJIyIIIIJIrpaMoTyl30KU

TH6", a e皿e 8 0KTR6pH B KocTpoMcKoM ye3瓜ⅡplImJIH Ka3aHcKHe TaTapbll65、K9ToHrpaMoTe
TaTapbl l65. K sToii rpaMoTe B
B KaKoH-To
KaKoi-Tq Mepe
MepenpHnpHMblKaeT >KaJIOBalIHafl rpaMoTa flHBapfl l537 r. PH3aHcKoMy
CoJIoTIIHH|cKoMy
MoHacTblplo166.
Ka3aHcKHe TaTapbl, IIEH HaMepeH" HanacTb Ha raJIHq lI
U

KocTpoMy 6blJIHH3BeCTHEI PyCcKOMy nPaBIITeJIbCTBy B HaIIa"
JYe l'537 r., npoFIBIIJIH 60JIbmylo aKTHBHocTb H B cepeⅡHHe
FIHBapH 1 537 r. coBepmeHHo Heo)KⅢⅡaHHooKa3aJIHcbHeBo3JIe
』

161

異

TaM )Ke, T. XIII, nepBaH uoJIoBIIHa, cTp、107-114; BToPafl HoJIoBIIHa,

cTp. 427428.
６
１
２ TaM >Ke, T. XIII，ⅡePBafI IIOJIOBIIHa, CTP. 1 12.
６
１
３ TaM >Ke, cTp. 113.
６
１
４ AA3, T. I, Nb '181.
５ nCP几T･XIII, BTopaFI HoJIoBIIHa, cTp､428 .
６
１
６
１
６
T・日．Bo3ⅡBII>KelIcKH仇．HcTopHIIecKoe
. HcToPHIIecKoe
o603peHⅢe
O603Pem'Ie PH3aHcKoI｛
PH3aHCKOii

IIepapxHI1. M., 1820, cTp. 308.
．315

KocTpoMbl, a noﾉI MypoMoM I67. npIIHaniJIe>KHocTb Ka3aHcKoro xalIa Caba-rHpefI

K

KpblMcKo曲皿HacTHHHHaJIHIIHeB

ユ

”

e r O B o H c K e 3 H a [ I H T e J I b H O r o I I I I C J I a K P b I M n e B H H o r a e B 3 a c Ta B -

JIHJIH pyccKoe npaBIITeJIbcTBo oHacaTbcH 3a cyXb6y PH3aHH,
KOTOPylO IIaCTO TPeBO)KHJIH KPblMUbl・KpoMe ToTo, B Ha-

tJaJIe l537 r. oTHomeHHH c KpblMoM 6blJIII To)Ke BecbMa Hanp"KeHHblMH. KpblMcK" xaH B IIIoJIe l537 r. npH3HaBaJIcFI,
KITo B To BpeMFI npy>K6bl Me]Kny HIIM II MocKBoii <<3a HeKoTOPblMH Pa3'LCTOHHHH... He cTaJIocH> 168. He cJIyIIaiiHo B HIIBape l537 r. npaBIITeJIbcTBo HacTaHBaJIo Ha nocbmKe AH-

npeeM CTap皿KIIM BoeBo,nbl B 6JIH3Kylo K PH3aHH KoJIoM-

Hy l69. rpaMoTa MBaHa lV CoJIoTIIIIHcKoMy MoHacTblplo
XoJI>KHa6blJIaycHJIIITbno及及eP>KKyBeqmHKoKHwKeCKOrOnPaBHTeJIbCTBaBJIIIHTeJIbHOiiMecTHOiiKOPHOPanHe尚．

BbmaIIa HMMy"TeTHbIx rpaMoT C 20-x qIIceJI oKTH6pH
1536r、又ooceHII1537r.HMeeTnpHMylocBH3bcco6bIT"MII, Pa3BepHyBmIIMIIcH IIa noIIBe 60pb6bI npaBHTeJIbcTBa 3a

JI IIKBHnauHIo MJITe)Ka AMpeH CTapHUKorO II ero HocJIemcTBHit.PaCcMOTPHMCHarlaJIarPaMOTbl,COcTaBJIeHHblenOMaH

1537r.,T.e､凡oHaqaJIaoTKpbIToroMHTe)Ka.rpaMoTblKacaJTHCb TePPHTOPIM, BO-nePBblX, JTIIKB皿HPoBaHHOrO mMHTPOB-

cKoro yneJIa, T. e. ye3JRoB nMHTpoBcKoro, KamHHcKoro, Py3cKoro, 3BeHIIropoJIcKoro, Bo-BTopblx, BopoBcKoro ye3ma, coce"ero c Bepeeit, me rocynapeM 6blJI AHnpeii CTapImKIIi,
B-TpeTbHx, nePecJIaBJIb-3aJIeccKoro ye3na II; HaKoHen, B-IIeTBeprplx, IOpbeB-HoJIbcKoro H Cy3naJILcKoro ye3,moB.

TeppHTopHaJIbHoepacnpeneJIeHIIeHMMyHilTeTHbIxrpaMOT HcCJIe"yeMorO nePHOJa, 6ecCnOPHO, BHOCHT MHOrO HOBOrO B IIoHHMaHHe noJIIITwIecKHx nPe瓜nOCblJIOK OTKPblTOrO

MHTeJKa AHmpeH CTaplIuKoro. Oco6eIIHo Ba>KHblM HgjlHeTcH
noBblmeHHblii IIHTepec npaBIITeJIbcTBa c oKTH6" 1536 r. K
3eMJIHM 6blBmero UMHTpoBcKoro KHmKecTBa. OH o6T>HcHHeT
HaM, noIIeMy 'IoJIbKo B KoHHe l536 - HaKIaJIe l537 r. MorJIa

Ea3ropeTbcHcToJIbocTpaH60pb6aMe>K,ⅡynPaBHTeJIbCTBOM

EJIeHbI rJIIIHcKo#IIcTapmUKjiMyneJIbHEIM ̅KHH3eM. HanP
mMeTb q B皿y, qTQ B aBrycTe l536 r. yMep B TeMH皿e ZMIITpoBcK" KHFI3b IOp" HBaHoBIIII. 3To, kaK Ho3BoJIHeT cV-

ⅡⅢTb PaCnPOCTPaHeHIIe rPaMOT nO ye3nlaM, BbI3BaJIO caMble
６７
１
PCPJI, T. XIII, nepBaH
６８
１
TaM )Ke, cTD. 119.
６９
１

M.

H

TIIxoMIIpoB.

noJIoBHHa, cTp. 1 16.
Ma,moH3BecTHble JIeToⅡHcHIJIe naMHTHHKI1

XVI B.­《I'IcToPlIIIecKIIe 3anHcKII>, KH. 10, cTp. 85.
316

|PemIITeJIbHblG
Tpe60Bal冊IFI
AHnpefl
oTmaTb
BblMopotlHblit
y
-A e J I e M y .
HamHHa6JIIOJeHHH IIa" rl)aMoTaMI'I IonoJIllfllOTcFI IIHTe-

pecHoii oco6ellllocTbIo TeKcToB BocKpeceHcKoit J1eToIIHcH I1

UapcTBeHHoii KIImrII, KoTopble paccKa3 0 MfITe>Ke A皿pefI
CTapliUKoro npIIBo"T BcJIen 3a H3BecTHeM, KacalQ皿HMcfl

cMePTIIIOp",̅nponycKaHnpoMe>KyToqHbleco6bITliH170.BocKPeceHCKaHJIeTO皿CbmUapcTBeHHafIIWlra,IlgcOMHeHH9,
cBFI3blBaloT MHTe>K AHXpeH co cMepTblo IOp". PereHTcKIIii

coBeT, xOPO皿O 3HaH HOJIIITHqecKHe TPa瓜HuIIH ynleJIbHblX

KHH3eii, Bcer,瓜a 6yHTOBaBmHx H3-3a BblMOPo'IHblx yneJIOB
ⅡoユゥJIarOM yneJIbHoKHFI)KeCKOrO, KOHCepBaTIIBHOrO JIerHTIIMII3Ma, nPHHHJI HeKOTOPble MePU "H nPenPTBPa皿eHHRar-

peccIIBHIJIxneiicTBIIii AH,npeH・nocJIe cMepTH IOpIIH 6blJIa
6bICTPoOTcTPOeHaIlyKPenJIeHaBOJIOma!71,CJIy)KHBmaH

o6もeKTOM,n(aEHHmHHx npeTeH3" AH,npeH.

OceHblo 1536 r. npaBHTeJIbcTBo B 60pb6e npoTHB nonDI-

ToK A皿PeH CTap皿KOrO nOJIyqIITb nMIITPOBcK" yneJI OnHpaJIocb Ha CPIMoHoB MoHacTblPb, KoTopoMy oHo II BbUaJIo
20 0KTH6PH EBe皿e八Pble >KaJIOBaHHble rPaMOTbl Ha 3eMJIMI

B nMHTpOBCKOM 172 H Py3CKOM 173 ye3nax. yKpemleHIIe llpaBHTeJIIJCTBeHHoro coIo3a c CIIMoHoBblM MoHacTblpeM 6blJIo
Ba>KHOii nOJIHTHIIeCKOit 3anaqeii, II60 MOHaCTblPb, HBJIHHcb,

Ka>KeTcH, KpynHeimHM 3eMJIeBJIanleJIbneM B 3aMocKoBcKoi
BoJIocTII PaMeHeime, HoJIb30BaJIcH 60JIbmHM BJIHHHHeM Ha

AImpeH, cTpeMHB皿erocH BepHyTb ce6e PaMeHeime B cooTBeTCTBHHc,ⅡyxoBHoii rpaMoTo# oTna 174. He cJIyIIaiiHo B IIe-

PHO4
MOcKOBcKO-cTaP皿KOrO
KOH｡JIHKTa
nPaBHTFJIbCTBO
HO-

cJIaJIo yroBaplIBaTb AH叩eH, HaPH,ny c BJIanLIKoPI KPyTHⅡKHM

moc"eeM H nyxoBHHKoM A皿peH CeMHoHoM, apxHMa皿pHTa CIIMoHoBa MoHacTbl" HJIo｡efl 175.
Ho MePe HaPaCTaHHH nPoTHBOPeu城Me>Kny nPaBHTeJIbcTBoM H AH,ⅡpeeM CTaplIIIKHM pereHTcK" coBeT, BonpeKII
cBoeii o6LIIIHoii npaKTIIKe, BblnaJI rpaMoTy, peryJIIIpoBaBmylo
１
０ nCPJI, T. V111, cTp．292; T. XIII, BTopaH HoJIoBHHa, cTp、428 .
７
１
７
１TaM IKe, T. XIII, nepBaFI noJIoBIIHa, cTp、115.
１
７
２ rHM, CHM. KH. 58, no nMHTpo,By JYb 7, Jm. 479=482.
１
３
７
１
４ rnB, Co6p. aKToB II rpaMoT, Nb 1-117.
７

BonpeKH nyxoBHoii HBaHa lll, Bac"" III y]Ke B 1507 T. yTBe""

B >KaJIoBaHHOii rPaMoTe CBoih CIo3el)elMTeT HanK CIIMoI･IOBCKIIMII CeJIaMII B PaMeHeiiUe; B ｡eBpaJIe l534 r. 3Ta rpaMoTa 6bma nomHCaHa
Ha BeJIHKoKHH>KGcKoe HMH (THM, CHM・KH. 58, no MocKBe Nb 41,
Jm. 188-190).
175

nCPJI, T. XIII, nepBaH noJIoBIma, cTp. 1 17.
317

BonP ocb【HMMyHIITeTa cBeTcKIIX d)eo"JIoB ( 1 1 MapTa
1537 r.) 176. rpaMoTa oTHocHJIacb K nel)ecJIaBJIb-3aJIeccKoMy ye3ny, rAe KoHneHTPHPoBaJIHCb BJIHflTeJIbHble cTOPOHHH-

KII y,瓜eJIbHoKHfl)KeCKOii ()ⅡⅡO3HⅡHH. rPaMOTa 6PaJIa nOni 3a-

mlITy nOMe皿HKa HBaHa皿aMCKorO, c BJIantelIHii KOToPorO
nonaTII B3HMaJIIIcb HKo6bl B II3JIIImHeM KoJIHIIecTBe, a 3aTo

ero cocemi 6paThH mlipHeBbl HIIrlero He nJIaTIIJIH. KpaiiHe
@JIIO60HblTHO,qTOIIePe311'JIeTHBaH皿aMCKOA巾HrypHpyeT
B KalIeCTBe nbHKa, T､e. oIIeHb BH,nHoro JIHIla, y cblHa AHppeH

CTaplmKoro - BJIaJHMHpa AHnpeeBHIIa l77・B 1538 r. HBaH
皿aMCKOit, HMeBm" y]Ke TOrna 3BaHHe BBeXeHHOFO PlbHKa,
nOJIb30BaJICH OCo6blM noKPoBHTeJIbcTBOMmyiicKIIx l78. OIIe-

BHJ(Ho, B 1537 r，HBaH皿aMcKOji 6bIJI CBH3aH CO CTaPImKHM
KHH3eMIIKHH3bHMHmyiicKIIMH.y,moB@meTBopHH3KoHoMHIIecKHe Tpe60BaHIIH maMcKoro, npaBHTeJIbcTBo nblTaJIocb 3aPyIIHTbcH erO HO瓜ⅡepzKKoii II ocJIa6HTb BJIHHHHe cTopoHHII-

KoB AIInpeH CTapHⅡKoro B nepecJIaBJIb-3aJIe|ccKoM ye31e.
AnpeJIbcKHe rpaMoTbl l537 r. Bblpa)KaIoT y)Ke 60､nee pemHTeJIbHylO HOJIIITIIKy nPaBHTeJIbCTBa B OTHomeHmHCTapmⅡ-

Koro y八eJIa. OnHpaHcb Ha o4Horo H3 KpynHeなmHx3eMeJIbHblx co6cTBeHHHKoB cTpaHbl - TpoHne-CeprHeB MoHacTblpb,
nPaBHTeJIDcTBo nePemlJIO B HacTynJIeHHe lI CTaJIo HO八rOTaB-

JIHBaTb 6JIaronpHHTHylo JJIH ce6H noIIBy no cocencTBy co
CTap皿Ko-BepeiMcKIIM y八eJIOM - B BOPOBCKOM ye3ne (CneⅡHaJIbHaH >Ka,JIoBaHHaH rpaMoTa TpoHne-CeprlleBy MoHa-

cTblpIo oT 14 anpeJIH 179 H ynoMIIHaHHe 60poBcKHx 3eMeJIb
B >KaJIoBaHHoii rpaMoTe ToMy >Ke MoHacTblpIo oT 17 anpe-

JIH) 180. 0皿OBPeMeHHo OHO ynPOIIIIBaJIO CBOII HO3皿HHHa
TePPIITOPIIH BCerO nMIITPOBCKOrO yneJIa, CMe>KHOrO C nMHT-

POBOM nePeCJIaBJIH II B CbePaX yneJIbHOKHHIKeCKOrO H KHH]KecKo-60HpcKoro cenapaTH3Ma B ye3nax IOpbeB-HoJIbcKoM
( 6bIB皿嘘 myTKIIH cTaH) II Cy3naJILcKoM (OHoJIbcK"
cTall) ]81. npaBHTeJIbcTBo oIIeHb o6myMaHHo oTHecJIocb K
npo6JIeMe 60pb6bl c AHnpeeM CTapHUKHM H JIHKBHntaUIIH
erO ymeJIa.

176

<AKTbl HcTopHIIecKIIe, onHcaHHble H. M. KaTaeBblM II A. K. Ka6aHoBblM,, JVb l/24.
１
７７ AAS, T. I, M 217.
１
７８
<AKTbl HcTopIITIecKHe, 0ⅡHcaHHble H: M. KaTaeBblM II A. K. Ka6aHoBblM),, JYb l/25.
１
７９ rBJI, Tp・KH. 527, M 251 .
８０
１
TaM )Ke､Nb 253.
８１
１

rpaMoTa oT 17 anpeJIH l537 r. (rBJI, Tp. KH. 527, Nb 253).
318

T

AHXpeihCTaPHILKHHnocJIecMepTPIIOpHFIcTaJIIIeToJIbKo FIBHblM nPeTeIInellTOM

Ha OTnteJIbHble TePPIITOPII11, HO

m

⑥

Bo3Mo)KHblM npeTeHmeHToM Ha BeJIHKoKHIllfecKHHIII) eCTOJI )

qTo H o6Hapy>k"ocb Bo BPeWI MFITe)Ka no3ToMy llacnpoCTpaHIIBmH66fl B HarlaJIe l537 r・CJIyxH o HoIIMKe AIUpefi
L

eihcTBIITeJIbHble
HaMePel･IHfI
nPacKOpee BcerO oTPa>KaJIH瓜eHcTBHTeJIbHble
HaMePel･IHHnPa-

BIITeJIbCTBa. I'IMMyHKTeTHble rPaMOTbI HoKa3blBalOT TO, qerO
HeT B JIeTOmlCHblX naMHTHHKax,- BHOJIHe lleJIeHanPaBJIeHHvIo cHcTeMV
彰 HoJIIITHIIecKIIx aKToB npaBIITeJIbcTBa, cBoXHB-

IliylocHKm30JIHnHH
皿ylocH
K "oJI"IIH A"peH
AH叩eHCTaplmKoIjo
CTa皿皿KorooTno瓜旦eP>KKII
oT Ho
⑥

BJIHHTeJIbHeiimlix myXOBHbIx H CBeTCKIIX巾eO,maJIOB Ha TeP○

pIITopIIH,
Henocpent6TBeHHo
rpaHIiIIHBmeii
co
CTapHmio-BebeickHMyneJIoM,IIBTexpaiioHa¥,HaKoTopbleAH,npelinpe⑪

u

U

｡

TeHJPBaJI II me y HerO MOrJIII HaIITIIcb CoIO3HII"g

H ocJIenylo皿Iie HMMyHHTeTHble rpaMoTbl l 537 r. 6blJIII
BblnaHbl no nPeHMy皿ecTBy TpoHue-CeprIieBy MoHacTblplQ

BnepHo瓜ⅡoXaBJIeHIIHMHTe)KaA"peflCTapH且KOronPaBIITeJIbCTBo IICKaJIO OHOPy B CaMOM KPymlQM BOTIHIHHHKe UeH­

TpaJIbHblx paiioHoB CeBepo-BocTollHoii PycIIH皿JIO eMy Ha

3FIaIIHTeJIbHble ycTynKH. OTKpbITbli MHTe)K
3HaIIHTeJIbHbleycTynKH・OTKpbITblH
MHTe>KcTa”ⅡKoroKHHcTapHHKoro..KHH3H HaIIancH
SH
HauancH2MaRl537r・B
2 MaR 1537 r. B 60JIbmHHcTBe
60JIbmHHcTBeJIeTomlceHHeT
JIeTomlceii HeT

ToIIHoii naTbloKoHIIaHHH
ToIIHoHⅡaTbl
oKoHIIaHIIH
M兜Te】Ka，ToJIbKo
MJITe>Ka. ToJIbKo
nocTHHKoBcKHH
HocTHIIKoBcK"
U

JIeTomiCen cOO6皿aeT, IITo AHnPeH Hoca瓜HJIII B TIOPbMy
l

lIIOHFI 182．OntHaKo HocJIe 3Toro pacnpaBbl nponpJI>KaJIIIcb.

BeJIHKoKHH>KecKoe ceMeitcTBo BblexaJIo B TpoI,IUe-CepmeB

MoHacTblpb JIIImb 21 HIoHH 183. no3ToMy TpH rpaMoTbl
1 4 MaH - 4 HIoHH 1 537 r. Mbl oTHocHM K nepIIonly JIIIKBH,nam l I I M H Te ] K a .

Ma#cKHe rpaMoTbl TpoHUe-CeprlleBy MoIIacTblplo IWa-

JIIIcbMoHacTblicKMxBoTqIIHBnePecJIaBJIb-3aJIeccKoM184M
PocToBcKoM 185 ye3"x. UeJIb IIx BblXaqH cocToHJIa B ToM,
IJTo6bl HeiiTpaJIII30BaTb cTopoHHIIKdB AHIEeFI B aTHx IIpe3BbIqaihHO aPHCTOKPaTIIIIecKIIX PaiiOHaX. rpaMoTa HaIIaJIa
U

U

U

IIIOHH PeryJIHPOBaJIa HMMyHHTeTHblH CTaTyc TPOⅢⅡKHX BOT-

IIIIH B6JIIIgH ToJIbKo IITo JIIIKBImlIpoBaHHoro CTapHuKo-Be-

PeiicKoroyneJIa-BBopoBcKeHMaJIoMHpocJIaBne186.
⑪

⑪

182

M、H. TIIxoMIIpoB. 3anⅢ'oKII o pereHTcTBe EJIeHbl r｡JIIIHcKoii H

60HpcKoMnpaBmeHmml533-1547rr.,orp:284.

８
３nCPJI, T・XIII, nepBaH noIoBIIHa, cTp. 1 19.
１
４AH, T. I, Nb 138.
８
１
５ATH, Bbln. 11, JYb 9.
８
１
６
８
１
TaM >Ke, M 110, cTp. 8-9J
319

Tpli rpaMoTbl cepemIHbl IIIoJIfl - IIa'laJIa aBrycTa l537 r.
xaPaKTepli3yIoT BKJIIoIIeIIIIe CTapI皿KorO yﾉIeJIa B cOCTaB BeJIHKoro KIIHzKecTBa. B rpaMoTax TI)oMUe-Cel)rHeBy MoHacTblplo npaBIITeJIbcTBo 3aKpenHJIo cBoIo BJIacTb Hanl CTaplm­

KIIM1871IBepe曲CKIIM188ye34aMM.I/IMMyllIITeTHblerPaMOTbl
,MIoT Bo3Mo)KHocTb KoHKpeTHo npeJIcTaBHTb ce6e BIIyTplmoJI IITIIIIeCKyIo OPHeHTa皿IO nPaBHTeJIbCTBaH巾OPMbl ee BblPa>Kel･IHfl B OJJIH H3 CaMblX OCTPblX MOMeHTOB B HCTOPHII Per e H Tc T B a E J I e H b l r J I H H c Ko i l .

Oco6eI･IHo IIHTepecHa rpaMoTa, noJIyIIellllafl TpoI皿KHM
MoHacTblpeM 18 IIIoJIFI 1537 r. 189 B Heit TeppHTopliaJIbl-Io oxBaqeHa oCIIOBHafl 30Ha TOJIbKo 'ITO JIHKBH且IIPOBaHIIOrO MfI-

Te>Ka: HoBoTop>KcKHii 190 II CTapImK" ye3nb1. rpaMoTa
Pa3PemaJIa MOHaCTblpcKHM HOceJIbcKHM, KJIIoKIHHKaM H KPe-

CTbHHaM 6e3もHBoIIHo H 6ecTaMo)KeHHo e3XIITb l,I3 HoBoTop>K-

cKoro ye34a B CTapHUy, <KaKHMHユeJIbl HII 6y八Ⅲ》. B rpaMoTe ecTb cnenlIaJIbHaH cTaTLH: <<A IIIo>KIIx HM JIIoJlei He npoBO〕KaTH c co60Io, a Koro npoBenyT IIIo)Kero, II Koro B ToM
yJIHIIaT, II oHII Ha ToM Bo3bMyT 3anoBepH ,mBa py6JIFI MocKoB-

cKHx>". B UIITIIpoBaHHoii cTaTbe lIMeIoTcH B BH且y He ToProBble JIIOnlH, IIaCTO cTpeMHBmHeCH nPHKpblTbCFI MOHaCTblP-

cKHM TaMo)KeHHblM IIMMyHIITeToM, a Boo6me <<IIIo>KIIe)' (He-

TpO皿KHe),KOTOPblMHMOrJIIIOKa3aTbCFI6blBmHeyKIacTHIMKH
MHTe>Ka IIJIH Hx areHTbl. rpaMOTa XaPaKTePlI3yeT 60JIbmyIo
HanpmKeHHocTb noJIo>KeHIifl JIeToM 1537 r. H KocBeHHo cBIIneTeJIbcTByeT O nPOBOJHBHIHxcH 3,mecb nPaBHTeJIbCTBOM PaCcJIenPBaHHHx H noHMKe MHTe>KHIIKOB,mnHOHOB II TOMy HO-

,np6Hblx JIHm, cBH3aHHbIx co cTapHUKoii onno31iUHeii.
UJIH TpoIme-CeprHeBa MoHacTblpfl rJIaBHeiimHMHToroM
coTpy瓜HHIIecTBacnpʻaBHTeJIbcTBoM6blJIo,ⅡoʼKaJI”,y瓜oB-

JIeTBOPeHIie TPe60BaHM MoHacTblPcKIIx BJIacTehno Kpec T b H H c Ko M V B o n P o c V.

Haxo皿cb B IIHcJIe HaII60JIee KpynHblx (beo"JIoB-3aKpenocTHTeJIeit, TpoIme-CeprHeB MoHacTblpb He Mor MIIplITbcfl
ccy皿ecTBOBaBmHM B erO BOT'IHHaX noJTo>KellHeM neJI, KOrna
nPIIe3]KaBmHe

BeJIHKoKH"KecKHe

HeneJIbmHKH Ha3HaIIaJII1

KPeCTbHHaM cPOK FIBKII B cy瓜nO I'ICKOBblM,瓜eJIaM BくnameH＝

一

一

一

187 Xn, I, M 359, 360.
188 TaM >Ke, Nb 361.

!" UrAHA, rKS no HoBoMy ToplKky, JVb 4/8332.
'90 Bo3Mo)KHo, IIMeHHo K 9ToMy BPeMe" oTH&rcH M >KaJIoBaHHaH
rpaMoTamBaHa IV 7045 r. HoBoTop>KcKoMy CeMHoHbeBcKoMy MoHaCTblPIQ (UrAnA, nnCJI, 7131 r.; JYb 4, m. 69; rAKO, qj. 1 03､
JYh 228, ､m. 1, coo6皿ⅢnB. A. Ky[IKIIH) .
320

Hoe BPeMH>・B cBoeii qeJIo6IITHoii MoHacTblpb npocHJI ycTaHOBHTb BCerO ,mBa CPOKa Bbl30Ba - OCeHblO, nOCIJIe OKOHqa-

11HH y60POIIHblx Pa60T, Ha HOKPoB CBHTOi 60rOPo瓜Hubl
(l bKTfl6") M 31iMo曲, B CTpeTeHbeB ,meHb (2 dJeBpaJIH) BblIIoJIIIflH MoHacTblpcKylo npocb6y, npaBHTeJIbcTBo Bbl八aJIo B
oKTH6Pe l537 r．>KaJIoBaHHylo rPaMoTy TpoHne-CeprHeBy
MOHaCTblPIo,BKOTOPoiinPaBHJIOJByCPOIIHblxBbl30BOB6blJIo
PaCnPOCTPaHeHO Ha BCe HaCeJIelime TPOliUKHx BOTIIHH BO

BCex ye3八ax (BJI"eHmH Tpo皿e-CeprmeBa MoHacTblpH pac-

KHHyJiHcb K sToMy BpeMeHIi no 26 ye3"M) 191. BJIIIHHIMe
TpoHnKoro MoHacTblpH ocTaBaJIocb oIIeHb 60JIbmliM e皿e B

HoH6pe l537 r. Co3HaBaH ero 3HaIIeHIfe B cTpaTerHIIecKII
Ba)KHOM MyPOMcKoM ye3Ae, nPaBHTeJIbcTBo 3anPeTHJIO CBo-

MMJIeTHM60HPcKHMH且pyrMIMBOeHHblMJIIO,n{HM6paTbpa3､JIwIHble KoPMbI H 3anacbl c TPoKUKOro ceJIa lleranaeBa B
MypoMcKoMye3Ae192.
nBe rPaMOTbl KO皿a l537 - HaIIaJIa l538 r. HBJIHIoTcH
HOCJIe八HIIMH HMMyHHTeTHblMH aKTaMH nePHOJa PereHTCTBa

EJIeHbl r､JIIIIIcKoii. OIIII KacaIoTcR ye3npB Ka皿IIHCKOrO (rPa-

MoTaTpo皿e-CeprlleByMoHacTblpIooT911ofl6"1537r)193

Hym皿KorO (rpaMoTa noKpoBcKoMy yrJI皿KOMy MOHaCTblplo oT 25 HHBapH l538 r.) 194. 3To HaBO皿T Ha MblcJIb, LITo
hocJIe 3aKJIIoIIeil", a noToM H cMepTH (B AeKa6pe l537 r)
AHJPeH CTaplmKoro cToPoHHIIKH ynleJIbHoKHH)KecKoro cenaPaTII3Ma He yHIiMaJIHCb II, BO3MO)KHO, HaCTaIIBaJIH Ha oTJa-

LIe 3aK皿oqeHHoMy CblHy A皿peH yrJI皿Koro UMHTpHIo AHnPeeBIiIIy HaCJIe八CTBa ero OTnia - ymHula II, KPoMe TOro,
npHMblKaBmero K HeMy Ka皿皿a l95.
１
９
１
２
９
１
３
９
１
４
９
１
︐
９
１

rBJI, Tp. KH､527, Nb 262.
ATH, Bbln. II, JYb ll･
rBJI, Tp. KH. 527, Nb 260.

UrAnA, *. Ka皿eJIHpHII CeHaTa, KH. 192, J1. 252 06.
Mexmly ceHTH6peM 1 537 H aBrycToM 1 538 r. (ToqHble naTbl HeII3BeCTHbI) 6blml Bbl,maHb" rPaMOTbI; l) IIy八OBy MOHaCTblPIO Ha ceJIa B
nPeneJIax @JIIIKBH,n､IipoBaHHoro CTaPl'IUKoro KHH>KecTBa - B BblmeToponlcKoM yeane H CeJIeHcIKoii BoJIocTII MocKoB,cKoiro ye3,ma
(B. B. Ko6plIH．ⅡBe >KaJIOBaHHble rPaMoTbl qy"OBy MOHaCTblPIO
(XVI B.) .­《3amicKI,I oTneJIa pyKomiceii rocy4apcTBellHoii 6II6JII,IoTeKHmM.B.H・JIeH皿a>, BbIn. 25. M., 1962, cTp,318) ; 2) I<HpIIJ'J'o-

BeJIo3epcKoMy MoHacTLIpIo Ha 3BeHIIropo'UcKIIe ceJIa O"IoJIeTKoBo }I
rpHroptIHKoBo (rnB, Q-IV-l l3a, cTl). 1516) ; 3) HoBropo,mcKoMy
aPXIIemICKOny MaKaPHIO Ha qy且HHnloBy yJIImy H 3ano@ﾉIbe lly｣aHHUOBO
(B. B・M aiiKo旧. nIIcnloBaH KHIira no HoBropony Be皿KOMy KOHUa
XVI B.Cn6., 1911, cTI)．105) ; 4) BoJIo]､oAcKoMy naBJIoBy O6HopcKoMy MoHacTbIplo (H・しI. C y B o p o B. OmIIcb naBJIo-O6HopcKoro
21

C ． M ， K a m Ta H o B

321

、

CJIenoBaTeJIbHo,BTeqeHIIeBceropaccMoTpeHHorooTpe3Ka

BPeMeHII

>KaJIOBaHIIblM

rPaMOTaM

OTBOJMJIaCb

OTBeT-

cTBeHIIaH poJIb B Mo6IIJII13aUllM cHJI BJIHHTeJIbHblx qJeo4aJIoB
Ha no只只eP)KKy nPaBHTeJIbcTBeHIIoA60pb6bl npoTHB y八eJIbHOKH月>KecKoro II KHmKecKo-60HpcKoro cenapaTII3Ma. BMeC1.e c TeM, yKPenJIHH OTHomeHIIH rOCHO4cTBaⅢⅡO4'IHHeHHfI

B *eOnaJIbllO曲旦ePeBHe, JKaJIoBaHHble rPaMOTbl 6blJIH oPy八HHMII rJIV60Ko
KJIaccoBo曲ⅡoJIHTHKH．
-

B o6JIacTH cyne6HoTo HMMyHHTeTa pyccKoe npaBHTeJIb･
cTBo B MapTe l534 - HaIIaJIe l538 r. cTporo npoIoJI>KaJIo
JIIIHHIo HoJIHTHKII BacIIJIHH III. H3 10pHcJIHKUHII IIMMyHHCToB HcKJIIoIIaJIIICb, KaK nPaBHJIO, 4Be

KaTerOPHHⅡpecTyn-

qIIeHHi: nymery6cTBo H pa360i c noJIHIIHb1M. Cpe八H Hecy瓜Ⅱ-

Mblx rPaMOT sTorO nePHo,n$a TpoIme-CeprHeBy MoHacTblplo
TOJIbKO B aKTe Ha ceJIa B nPHCOe且HHeHHoM BepeiicKoM ye34e
MoHacTblPcKaH

IOPHC八HKUHH

CaHKUHOHIIPOBaJIaCb,《onpH[lb

oJIHoro ,nymery6cTBa>>. rpaMoTbl l534-1538 rr. CHMoHoBy
MOHacTblPIo O6blIIHO TaK>Ke OrpaHIIIIHBaJIH I1MMyHHTeT H3'b,ITHeM H3 C｡epbl Be八eHIiH BOTIIHHHOrO cy皿只ByX rpynⅡ瓜eJI．
ⅡpHKIeM B rpaMoTe l536 r., oTHocFIUeiicfl K py3cKHM ceJIaM
MoHacTblpH, 'HKcaU" cyIKeHHoro o6LeMa cyne6Hblx noJIHoMOIIHih BblCTynaeT KaK O巾皿HaJIbHoe OrPaHHIIelIHe cTaPOll
I､paMoTbl l502 r., nepenaBaBmeit B pyKH HaMecTHIIKoB JIII皿b
Jejlao八y皿ery6cTBe l96. B rpaMoTe CHMoHoBy MoHacTblplo
1535 r. Ha KocTpoMcKIie li raJII皿KHe BaPHImbl H ce,JIa cynle6Hble nPaBa MoHacTblPH coKPamaJIIICb e皿e cHJIbHee: y HerO

6blJIo oTHHTo npaBo cynaHnO BOnPOCaM TaTb6bI C HOJIHLIIIblM. 3Ta Oco6eHllaH cKynoCTb c"e6Hblx nPHBIIJIerHhonpe八eJIHJIaCb MecTOHaxO>KPleHHeM O6EeKTOB Ho)KaJIoBaHHH coJIHraJIHⅡKIIx nPOMblCJIOB-nO
coCeJIcTBy C
nPoMblcJIaMII
U

nocancKI1x JIIo八eⅢ．

Ⅲ3'bHTHe H3 10CTI皿HH MOHaCTblPeil Pa360Pa TIDK6 nO
,mByM KaTerOPHHM nPecTynJIeHHii 6blJIo B nePHo且nP aB､meHI'IH
EJIeHbl rJIHIIcKO曲o6mHM nPaBHJIoM. HCKJIIOqeHHe cOCTaBJIHeT ToJIbKo MocIIqJo-BoJIoKoJIaMcK" MoHacTblph, KoTopbl曲
o6Lma4aJI BCe曲nOJI IIOTO曲cy八e6HOA BJIacTII, <<OnPHIIb ny皿e-

ご
〆

r V D c T B a > .

XaPaKTePHOii uePTOii ｡HHaHCOBOii nO皿THKH nePHo八a

pereHTCTBa 6blJIO nPIIHy丞且eHHe HaceJIeHHH BJIanleH" cBeTcKIIx

H 4yXoBHblx

MoHacTLIpH

beO"JIOB K

BoJIoro八cKoii

enapxlIH

ymlaTe rJIaBHblX rOcy"P1683

rona.­《H3BeCTwI

ApxGolJIorImecKoro o6皿ecTBa", T. V. Cn6., 1865, cTp、282) .
I96 ACam, T・I1, Nb 426.
322

11MH

cTBeHHblx IIonaTei lI BbmoJIHeHHIo

ocHoBHblx

HaTVpaJIbHblx

IIoBIIHHocTeii. I'I3 yKa3Hoit rpaMoTbl l537 r. o pacnpe,meJIeHHHnOnaTeii Me>KIy noMeCTbFIMII ,mByx cBeTCKHx巾eoXaU

JIOB

CJIenyeT,

qTO

C

HOMeCTHH nJIaTIIJIHCb

naHb,

HMCKHe

,UeHbrll H npHMeT. AnpeJIbcKHe rpaMoTbl l 534 r. TpoHueCeprHeBy MoHacTblpIo Ha BoTqmHbl B nepec,maBJIb-3aJIecCKOM, Be>KeUKOM H POCTOBCKOM ye34aX 197 6bMH COCTaBJIel-IbI
IIo ｡OPMyJIHPy *eBPaJIbcKHX rPaMoT TOMy )Ke MOHacTblPlO
Ha IOPbeBcIKHe, cy3naJIbCKHe,

KOCTPoMCKHe,

BJIaXHMIIPCKHe,

nomexoHcKIie H MocKoBcKHe 3eMJIII. 3HalIHT, no rpaMoTaM
EJIeHbI rJIHHcKoii KpecTbHHe TpoHUe-CeprHeBa MoHacTbIpH
B 9 ye3nax coBep皿eHHo o｡H皿aJIbHO nPlIHy>KntaJIHCb K Bbl'
U

noJIHeHHIO Tpex

OCHOBHblx

HoBIIHHOCTelI:

HMa,

roPOXOBorO

瓜eJIa lI HocomHoii cJIy]K6bl.
ropompBaH noBHHHocTb npH EJIeHe rJIIIHcKo曲npHo6peJI a
oCo60e 3HaqeHHe B CBfI3H C 60JIbmoii cePHeii Pa60T Ho
CTPOIITeJIbCTBy rOPOXCKHx yKPenJIelI嘘旦JIH 60pb6bl c TaTa-

paMHHJIHTBoii 198. K HoCTpoiiKe B MocKBe KHTaii-roPOna
B Mae l535 r. 6blJIH npHBJIeIIeHLI Bce JIIo八H f<6e3 Bbl6OPa>:

KHH)KecKHe, 60HpcKHe H MHTponoJIIIqbH l99. Pe3yJIbTaTbl
BKJIIoIIeHHH B )KaJIOBaHHble rPaMoTbl naParPaba, npHHy>KmaBmero K BblHoJIHeHHIO rOPOnPBOrO XeJIa, MO]KHO

nPOcJIe-

瓜ⅢTb no yKa3HblM rpaMoTaM. TpH yKa3Hble rpaMoTbl l535 200,
1536 201 H 1537 202 rr. conep)KaT cBeneI-IIIH o ToM, qTo KpecTbHHe TpoIIIle-CeprHeBa MoIIacTblpH HcHoJIHfIJIH roponpBoe
nleJIo B nepecJIaBJIb-3aJIeccKoM H PocToBcKoM ye3nax. rPaMoTa l537 r. cBHXeTeJIbcTByeT TaK>Ke o6 0T6blBaHIIH ropo-

IoBoii noBIIHHocTH MHTpoHoJIIIIIbIIMH KpecTbHHaMII KapamcKoi BOJIOCTH POcToBcKOro ye34a. nPHIIeM KPecTbHHe HMMyHIIcToB IeJIaJIH rOPOAOBoe neJIo《oCO6Ho>> oT HenpHBIIJIe-

rmpoBaHHblx THrJIenoB. OIHaKo B 叩e3BblIIaiiHbIX CJIyIIaHX
９７ Xn, I, Nb 337-339.
１
９８
１

r. 3. KyHne B H II. IIcTop" o Ka3alIcKoM napcTBe lIJIII Ka3aHcKHii

JIeTonHceU. Cn6., 1905, cTp. 309, 603; M. H T II x o M II |p o B. MaJIo､H3BecTHbleJIeTonHcHbIe naMHTHIIKH XVI B., cTp、90; oH )Ke. 3amIcKH

o pereHTcTBe EJIeHbI TJIHHcKoii II 60HpcKoM npa.BJIeHHH 1533-1547 rr.,
cTp. 284; A、A. 3 H MH H. CocTaB py'ccKHx roponloB XVI B.­＜H,CTOpHLIBoKHe 3anHcKH)', T. 52, cTp. 336-346;
o H )K e.
Pe*opMb[…，
cTp. 235-240; H E. H o c o B. yKa3. co[1., cTp、74; H. I/I. CMIIpH o B. OIfepKII.., cTp. 47-50.
HCPJI, T. XI'11, nepBaRⅡoJIoBIIHa, cTp. 82.
UrAnA, r,KS no nepec0JIaBJIIo-3aJIeccKoMy, Nb 96/8820.
AA3, T. I, M 182.
ATH, ,Bbln. II, Nb 9.

ユ
199

2 ”
201
202

323

21

OHH ,IOJDKHbl 6blJIH BblnOJIHHTb aTy nOBHHHOCTb HaPaBHe

C ulepHblMII KPeCTbHHaMII II HOCa,niCKHMH JIIOAbMII. rPaMOTa
1535 r., HanpHMep, yKa3blBa,JIa: <<A BnepeJ( HemTo B IIePe一

cJI aB,ﾉIe rOPO40BOe neJIO HOIIOPTm､Ⅱa, a BeJIHKoe, II Bbl O TOr-

八bl TeM KPeCTbflHOM BeJIeJIII rOPO,mpBOe nleJIO XeJIaTII C nePe-

cJIaBcKIIMH coxaMH BMecTe, nOBblTHO)p. yKa311afl rPaMOTa
oT 5 MaH 1534 r. co,Uep>KIIT cBeneHIIH o6 y[IacTHH KPecTbHH

TpoIme-CeprHeBa MoHacTblpH B oT6blBaHHH HMcKo曲ⅡoBHHHOCTH 203.

B BecbMa cylKeHHoM o6beMe 3a"IKCIIPoBaJIo nPaBIITeJIbcTBo EJIeHbl rJIIIHcKo曲nOnaTHOii HMMyHHTeT ceJI II BaPHIIU MocKoBcKoro CHMoHoBa MoHacTblpH B raJIImKoM H

KocTPoMcKoM ye3JIax. B Bbl八aHHOii MOHacTblPIo B HOH6Pe
1535 r. 2KaJIoBaHHoii rpaMoTe MoHacThlpcKHM KpecTbHHaM
npeⅡⅡHCblBaJIOCb nJIaTHTb HMCKHe neHbrli H nPHMeT, HcHOJI-

HTITb roponpBoe XeJIo H nocomHyIo cJIy)K6y. B sToji rpaMoTe,
KaK K B rpaMoTax TpoMUe-CeprHeBy MoHacTblplo, conlep>KaJIaCb八eKJIaPaTIIBHaH ｡OPMyJIa O Hey皿aTe HHKaKHx nOmJIHH HPlaIKe HMeJIIICb cTaTbH, 06eJIHBmlIe oT HeKOToPblx

八BOPmPBO-KHJDKecKIIxnOBHHHocTeii(<<KO"HgKOPMHT)',
くceH He KoCHT>,く,mBoPa MOerO.…He CTaBFIT)>)nP aBHTeJIb-

CTBO CIIHTaJIo HyzKHblM nPOBO八HTb orPaHHIIeHIIe nOnlaTHOrO
HMMyHHTeTa, co6JIIonaH BHJHMocTb npe,ⅡPCTaBJIeHHH皿Hpo-

KIIx npHBHJIer". B 60｡JIbmHHcTBe rpaMoT, Bbl,ⅡaHHblX
c l534 r. ,np HaIIaJIa l538 r., He o6HaPy)KlIBaloTcFI TaK2Ke
cTaTbH, ocBo60IK,naIo皿He OT TaMrm, MblTa m nPyrliX TaMOzKeHHblX

nOmJIHH.

B oTXeJIbHblx cJIyIIaHx, Kor八a npaBHTeJIbcTBo oco60 HyU

XmaJIOCb B nO且瓜eP]KKe KPynHblX nlyXoBHblx KoPnoPanHH B

6opb6e c A皿peeM CTap皿KIIM,HMMyHMTGm" ̲IWIIW

npHo6peTaJIa KoMnpoMIIccHblii xap2KTep, TaK KaK n9>faJIo-

B3HmeboJIee 3HaqIITeJIbHblx, IIeM O6blIIHo, npHBHJIer" 6bIJIo
CaMblM Ha八e)KHHM nyTeM o6ecneIIeHIIH noJIHTHqecKoro coIo-

3a C BJIIIHTeJIbHblMH MOHaCTblPHMH.

Cpe"KMMyHIITeTHbIXrPaMoTIyxoBHbIM*eo八aJIaM
MapTa l534 - HaqaJIa l538 rr. UenpocTblo noXaTHoro IIMMyr

iHHTeTa OTJIIIIIaeTcH Bcero HeCKOJIbKO aKTOB, npOIICxO]K4eHMie
l

KOTOpblX,
BbIHCHeHHOe
BbIme,
CBH3aHO
C
B4)KHeii皿HMII
3TanaMII CTaPImKO-MOCKOBCI"X npOTIIBOPeIIHII: "e TaPXaHHbIe rpaMOTbI - Hoc"o-BoUpKoJIaMcKoMY MoHacTblPIQ ̲"

ceJIo TypoBo c J<epeB"MH B TBepcKoM H KJIHHcKoM ye3"x
203 AAS, T. I, Nb l80, cTp・151-152.
324

(Maiil534r.),CHMoHoByMoHacTbIploHaⅡMHTpoBcKHeceJIa
、

(6"6pb l536 r) ; nBe TapxanHo-06""̲̲rpWW=

6MMM miafflpid Ha py3cKIIe boTIIIIHEI " (oKTH6pb

1536
HTpo皿e-C6prlIeBy
r.)
MoHacTblPKllJa
BePeiicKHe
3eME
jiiI̅ (aBfycT i 537 IJ rpaMoTa I̅I 1 537̲ rL ̲lia c222皿“e
己

BoTIimHbi TpoIme-CeprIIeBa MoHacTbIpH co3nlaeT, IIQiW"

TOJIbKO BHemHee BneqaTJIeHHemenPOrO HMMyHIITeTHOrO
aKTa: B Heii HeT OcBO60>KneHHH OT rJIaBHblX nPHMblX HaJIoU

roB,3aTOHMeloTCHCTaTbm,｡IIKCIiPyIOmmenPaBQYOggg-

鼻
TblPcKHxKpecTbHH
HeoT6bIBaTb
pa3｡IMq"e̲"pIJ9WWR>KeCKIIe nOBIJHHOcTH II He nJIaTIITb PHⅡnOmJIIIH IIa conep)Ka­
Hme anMIIHHcTPaTHBHOro anⅡaPaTa B ye3Xe.

BMMiiEM""II B TAPxaHHIiX rPaMOT3X IIO""

BoJf6"5McKoMyMCIIMoHoBy̅MoHacTblpfIM
o6pfIcHHIQW
U

TeM, [ITO rPaMOTEI 6blJIH naHbI Ha BOTqIIHbI BTP""" "-

MMfO
gEMJIeBJ1ameHMH
aTMx
MoHacWgiL
IWbgS""
U

5BaTb HenPBOJIbcTBa BJIIIHTeJIbHblX KOPnOPaU" B OTBeTCTBeHHbleMOMeHTblBbmaIIIIPaCCMaTPHBaeMLIXrPaMOT,nPa-

BHTeJIbcTBonPm6JIH3IIJIoCoXeP]KaHIIeaKTOB=wKHPPWM

IIMMVHHTeTa,
xaPaKTepHblM皿R
3eMJIeBJIaneHH月HoclI｡o-BoJ

⑪

JIoKdjIaMcKoro IT CIIMoHoBa MoHacTbIpeik B XaHHbIx ye3naX;
3KOHOMmqeCKIIe TPaXIm" 3neCb nPoHB"IICb B nOJIHOII
“

MePe, HaJTO)KIIB neqaTb HaTeKCT rPaMQT2 ̲"Z IWEW

XeiImenOCJIenHIIXHMeJIO,
KOHeqHO,
KOHKPeTHbIgnOJImmgg

CKIIe
nPIIIIIIHbl・BoJIoKoJTaMcKaH
rpaMoTa
ocBo60xmaJTa
oT
哩

naHH,HMCKHxneHel､,TaMM,rOPOnPBOrOXeJIa,nOCO21HOII

cJIV>K6blHnp.,cIIMoHoBcKaR­oTnaHII,RMa,TaMTII.BcIIご

M6HOBCKOifPaMOTenOnTBeP)KXeHOCTaPIIHHOenPaBOMQ":
④

CTblPH
B3IIMaib
KOHCKOe
mTHO
CO
CBOIIX
KPeCTbFIH
Xa)Ke
nPH
noKVHKe HMH
noKVⅡKe
HMHJIomaxeH
JIomaXei BroPo江eHJIH
B roPoXe lIJIHBOJIoCTH・
BOJIoCTIK.

B TapxaHHo-06poqHbIx rpaMoTax oTpagIIJIHcE HPYr¥2

TpaⅡHIM=PaCnp6cTpaHeHH"ByneJIax̅IOp"IIAH4pg3

nbakTZKanePeBOnanOnaTeii
(CIIMMyHHTeTHbIXBoTuHH)
Ha
06poK STm aKTbl 3aKpemlfIJIII, KoHewHo, Me""e̲UpIWE
』

M= "66tmeHIIebT naHII, HMa II npHMeTa 3a o6poK,
⑪

B cIIMOHoBcKOii rPaMOTe - eme nPaBO naBaTb HaMeCTHHKy
ero nocomHblii KOpM B BIme o6poKa.
⑪

BrpaMoTel537r.BJIa瓜ⅢMIIPCKHM606POBHIIKaMHnOnTBep)KieHHoii B 1536 rrpaMoTe BacmJI" III HgglaREW
65M""M o6POqHaH + CTaTbHHMeJIa,oqeBImHO,60JIee
｡

v3Kmii cMbIcJI:06poK pa3pemaJIocbtlJIaTIITb BMecTo HeIIQCPeXCTBeHHOHnOcTaBKH606POBblx
mKyPoK
H
COKOJIOB．
ゾ

⑮

gTO,BepoHTHo,
He
o3HaKIaJIo
ocBo60丞及eHIIFI
OT
HOXaTe#,
325

HalTPHMeP HMa, TaK KaK B rPaMOTe nePecJIaBCKHM COKOJIb-

HHKaMBcTaTbeonpoTopaxIIpa3MeTax
cKa3aHo:くonpHIIb
HMy II rOPOnPBarO neJ1a,HnocomHble cJIv>K6bl>' 204. B vKaJ

3aHHbIx menPbIX MOHaCTblPcKHX rPaMoTax; 3a HcKJIIOIIeliHeM
BOJIOKOJIaMCKOrO aKTa, nPaBO He MIcHOJIHHTb OCHOBHble Ha-

TypaJIpHble noBHHHocTIi - roPonoBoe XeJIo H nocomHVIO
CJIyX6y-TO>KeOTCyTCTBOBaJfo.
噂

H3yqeHHblerpaMOTbll534-1537rr.no3Bo,ﾉIHIOT3aKJIIOIIHTb，IITO，COXPaHRH
glir.2̲gTO,
COXPaHHHBKaKOji-TO
B
KaKOH-TO
MePe
BePHOCTb
BePHOCTb
OrPaHHIIHOrPaHIIIIIIIWWm""HnaM, n"BHTeJIbCjpo EJIeHbI rJIHHcKO# npo4Q""9 ̲HatlaToe npH BacIIJIHH III oTcTynJIeHme oT cTp6ro
U

OrPaHIJIIIITeJIbHOrO KyPCa IIMMyHIITeTHoHⅡOJIHTHKII. 3TOMV

cnoco6cTBoBaJIonpmCoe"HeHiienocJIenHmxy"oBT ̅ M
ⅡO瓜及eP)KIIBaJIHCb TPanHⅡHH 60JIee mIIPoKoro nOnaTHOrO
WMyHIITeTa"̲､MOHacTbIPei,
HMMyHHTeTa
MOHacTbIPeH，KIeM
qeMHa
Ha
ocHoBHO#
ocHoBHOHTePPPITOPHHrOTePPPITOPHmrOU

cynaPCTBa・BynyIIIIHeBcocToHHIIIIcpa3ynp6610JIET"fII

Tp anHⅡHH, neHTPaJIbHOe nPaBIITeJIbCTBO y3aKOHIIJIo HX B
BblXaHHblx MoHacTblPHM rpaMoTax.
204AC3H,T.111,JWb26,cTp.47,cT.3

l司鬼a8(z

VI

E O4A1b HbIⅢHMMyHHTET
B rOabl BOHPCKOrO nPABAEHmJI
＊

CoⅡHaJIbHo-9KOHoMIIqecKaH O6cTaHoBKa neplloma 60HPcKOrO nPaBJIelllIFI, PaBIIO KaK H BHyTPellHfIHnOJIHTHKa 3TOrO
ʻ

BpeMeHii,BJIIITepaTyPem3yuleHaHenocTaTo[IHQB3HaqIITEJIbHoii Mepe 3To o6'LFIcHfleTcH TeM､ITo IIJIfI xapaKTeplIcU

い

THKmnOJIHTHqeCKOII IICTOPlIⅡⅡaHHOrO OTPe3Ka BPeMeHII IICnoJIb30BaJIcFI nPeHMy皿ecTBeHHO JIeTonHcHblH MaTePHaJI.
⑪

nO JIeTOmlcFIM B oCHOBHOM HanmcaHbl IIHTePeCHble HCcJ1enP-

BaHHRH. II. CMIIpHoBa, PHcylomHe cJIO>KHble neplmeTHII

noJIIITIIqecKoi 60p66bI B WccKoM rocynapcTBe30-40-x roXoB XVI B. ' Ha foii >Ke IIcToIIHHKoBemecKoii 6a3e cTPoIITcH
U

H3JIo>KeHHe co6blTIIii BpeMeHII 60HPcKoro npaBJIeHIIFI B
U

cTaTbe H. C. JIypbe, noMellleHHoih B <<O[IepKax IIcTopIIH
U

CCCP> 2.

nonblTKH nPlIBJTeIIb aKToBylO IoKyMeHTalWo ZWI nOKa3a

oTneJIbHblx CTOPoII BHyTPeHHeHnoJIIITIIKII 30-40-x ToIoB
XVI B. B HameHHcTOPlIOrP a巾HH IIMeJIII MecTO. BOJIbmafl
38cJIVTaB3ToMneJIenpHHaXJIe>KHTn・nCMHpHoBy,KoToPbIiiECBOeihOneH¥en0J10>KeH"6eJIOMeCTHOrO3eMJIeBjl4"
⑤

U

HIIHBnePHOn60HPcKOroCaMoBJTaCT"̲HCXO瓜HJIH3aHaJIII3a

>KaJIoBaHiIbIXrpaMoT30-40-xroXoBTpoIme-CeprmeByMoU

HacTblpIo II pmy npyrHx nyxOBHLIx Jfopnopall" Ha lIx cJIoユ

60"rH ropMcKI1e nBopbl 3. H・E. HocoB npHBJIeK MHoro[IHcJIeHHble aKTbI nJIH II3yIKeHIIFI MecTHorO annaPaTa BJIacTII

l II. H. C M
四H p H o B. I<JIacIcoBaH 60pb6a B MocKoBcKoM rocyntapcTBe B
nePBoii noJIoBIJHe XVI B.­《npo6JIeMbI IIcTopIII1 IoKamITaJImpTIIqecKIIx

06illecT", 1935, Nb 9-10; o h >K e. Oqep"̲ noJIIITMq99Koii̲IIcT""

pyCcKororocyﾉIap|cTBa30-』50-xronoBXVIBeKa．M・­J1.,1958,
cT,p. 76-136.

2<OqepKIIHcTopHHCCCP2.nfpmo瓜巾eonaJIH3Ma.KoHeUXV-HarlaJIo
XVII.B. M., 1955, cTp. lll2-1116.

3n. n．C M w p H'o |B: nocan'cKIIe JIIonII H ZX KJIapcoBaH 60pb6a nio
cepeⅡmIIbI XVII B, T. 1. M.- J1., 1947, cTp. 104-109.
327

E nepBoii noJIoBHIIe .XVI B. 4 B pa3Hblx acneKTax HcnoJTB3ywoTCH oTneJIbHbre aKTbT 30-40-x ronoB B Pa60Te A. A. 3If-

MHIJa 5.Tpy"MII n. n CMHpHoBa, H E H6coBa H A A. 3HMIIHa no cymeCTBy lICIIePnblBaeTcH cITHcoK Pa60T, rne
>KaJYoBaHHble H yKa3Hble rPaMoTbl PaccMaTPHBaIoTCH KaK
⑪

IIcTO'IHHK ITO HcTOPHII BHyTPeHHeii nOJIHTHKII 60HPCKHX

曇
OnHaKo
H
Ha3BaHHble
aBTopbI
He
pemaIoT
Bce
npo6JTeMbl,

n P a B H Te J I b C T B .

cBFI3aHHBIe C II3yqeHHeM nPOIICXO泳瓦eHIIH H COXeP>KaHIIFI

>KaJIoBaHHblx rpaMoT 30-40-x ronioB XVI B. n. n. CMIIpHoB
KaK HCTOPHK PycCKIIX rOPOmOB, eCTeCTBeHHO, orPaHIIWHJIcH
L
U

aKTaMH Ha roPoIcKHe BJTaneHIIR MoHacTblPeii, T、e. MeHbmeit
"CWIq̲ BbmaHHbIX B 3TO BPeMH >KaJIOBaHHblx rPaMOT.

H E HocoB, He 3aHHMaHcb iIccJIeXoBaHIIeM >KaJIojaHHbIx
rPaMOT B UeJTOM,.PaCcMaTPHBaJT B IIHx Te cTaTbH, KOTOPble
xaP aKTePH3ylOT巾yHKmm rOPOnOBblx nPlIKa3IIHKOB.
U

HHTePeCHOHHⅡocIIxnOPHeHCCJIe,mOBaHHOiioCo6eHU

U

HOcTbTo nePHOna 60HPcKOi PeaKnHHHBHJIOCB BOnaPeHIIe ee

cPa3y BcJIeX 3a yHHIITO>KeHmeM nocJYe皿ero 6OJ,ee̅,mII Me-

Hee KpynHoro yneJIa Ha pycH -- CTaplmKoro｡ OqeBImHo,
JTHKBHⅡalIHFI
alMFI
yneJIoB
y旦eJ10B
B

KaKoii-TO
B
KaKoII-TO
CTeneHII
CTeⅡeHH
O 6 'b eO6'beKTmBHO
KT II B H O

CrJYa瓜HJIa ocT1〕OTy BOnPoCa O TOM，KTO”nPeⅡcTaBHTeJIeH
哩

u

*eo"JIbIIoii 3HaTH 6yneT Henocpen(cTBeHIIo bT6HTb V KoPMIIJIa rocynaPcTBeHHo# BJIaCTH. STHM B KOHetlHOM cfleTe .II
U

o6EHC"eTCHTaCPaBHIITeJIBHaHJIerKOCTb,cKOTOPO#Me"U

JIHcb 60"cKIIe nPaBJITeJIEcTBa B 1538-1548 rf. BMecTe
C TeM, nOCJIe JIIIKBHnaUmf yneJIoB 3anaqa noXaBJTeHHH KJIaC-

coBo#60pb6blmHpoKHxMaccTpyXoBoroHaceJTeHIIHnpHo6peJI4.eme60JIeeoTweTJIPIBblixaPaKTep,qeMnpe>KXe.
⑤

yHIIIITo>KeHIIe yneJToB II cB"aHHaiT c･3THM XaJIbHeHmaH
U

neHTPaJIH3anHH

rOCynaPCTBeHHOi

BJIaCTH

COneiCTBOBaJIH

yC"eHIIIO｡eOnaJIbHOrOTHeTa,pOCTy"HcKaJIBHOrO6PeMeHH H pacmHpe"Io MacmTa6a cynie6Ho-anMHHIIcTpaTHBHEIx
nPeCJIenOBaH" nPoTIIB HaPymlITeJIe# d)eonaJIbHoro nPaBonOpHIKa・He cJIyqaiHo HMeHHo 60Hp6KIIe npaBIITeJ16cTBa
HaqaJIH ocymecTBJTHTb c 1 539 r. ry6Hylo pe巾OPMy, 3aZy⑪

MaHHylO, BO3MO>KHO, HGCKOJIbKO paHee 6.
4 H E. H o c o B. OqepKII no HcToPHII MecTHoro VnPa,BJIeHIIH
rocy,Ⅱal)cTBa nel]Bofi no"oBIIHI,I XVI B M- JI; i957, 6Tp
178 H叩．

5A.A,3HMmH､pe4〕opMI〕I
HBaHarpo3Horo.M，1960.

6 H.E･H o 'c o B. yKa3. coq., cTp. 289=327.
328

炉

PvccKoI､o
126. 165,

BnpoqeM, H B sToT nepHoX He3aBepmeHHocTb nponecca
CO3naHHH neHTPaJIII30BaHHOrO rOCymaPcTBa OCTaBaJIaCb Xa¥

paKTepHo# IIepToii pa3BIITIIH PoccHII. BoT noIIeMy peaJIbHoi
oKa3aJIacb B 1538-1548 rr. Bo3Mo>KHocTb yBeJIIIIIeHHFI HM-

MyHHTeTa PH,na nyXOBHblx KoPnOPan戒,Bqbe竹ⅡOﾕﾕep>KKe
Hy)KniaJIHCb 6oHPcKHe rPynnmPOBKII, HeyBePeHHO IIyBCTBO-

BaBmIIe ce6H y pyJIFI rocynapcTBeIIHoii MamlIHH.
BpeMH 60flpCKoro npaBJIeH" npeXcTaBJIFIeT co60ii nePHOn CaMOhHHTeHCHBHOii BblnaIIH rPaMOT c I'IMMyHIITeTHbl-

MHnPlIBIIJIerIIHMIIBnePBOhⅡoJIoBHHeXVIB.3a3ToTcpaBHIITejlbHoHe60JIbmOiiXPOHOJIOrHIIeCKHiOTPe30K(11JIeT)

BeJIHKoKHfl>KeCKOe npaBHTeJTbCTBO COCTaBHJIO, no HamHM

poIcIIeTaM, 222 >KaJIoBaHHble H 56 yKa3Hblx rpaMoT.

1．BHyTpeHHHHno入晒TⅨKa

B anPeJke-oKTH6pe l538 r.
BpeMH c anpeJIFI no 22 oKTH6pH 1538 r. flBHJIocb nepHoXoM, Korna KHH3bfl myiicKHe, 3axBaTHBmHe BJIacTb B cTpa-

He, BblHy)KneHbl 6blJIH XeJIHTb ee B KaKo#-To Mepac K"3eM
H.O. BeJIbcKHM, 6JIH3KIIM K MHTpoHoJIIITy naH"ny. He-

nPOqHOCTb
noJIO)KeHIIH
60HPcKIIx
BPeMeHIIIHKOB
3afTaBJIHJIa
IIx HanPmKellHO HcKaTb cOIo3HIIKOB cPenH KPynHeHmlIX Xy-

xoBHblx ｡eonaJIoB OT sToro nepIIona HaM H3BecTHo 18 1IMMyHIITeTHblx rPaMoT: 14>KaJIOBaHHblX ( 1 2 1yXOBHblM ｡eO"JIaM H IBe CBeTcKHM) H 4 yKa3Hblx (oIHa lI3 >KaJIOBaHHblx

rPaMOT He COXPaHHJIaCb)．yJKe B nePBLIe MeC皿bI npaBJIeH" mvicKHx H BeJILcKoro Ha6JIIonaeTcH c6JIIDKeHHe npa-

BIITeJIbcTBa c TpoIme-CeprHeBblM MoHacTblpeM. IiryMeHa
Tpo皿e-CeprmeBa MoHacTblpH Hoacaba myiicKIIe HaMeIIaJIH KaH瓜Ⅲ瓜aToM B MIITPonoJIIITbI. CoIo3 c TpoHHKHM MoHacTblPeM BblPa3HJICFI KaK

B 3eMeJIbHblx, TaK HB HMMyHII-

TeTHhlX no)KaJIoBaHHHx MoHaCTblPlo.

ByKBaJIbHo IIepe3 neHb nocJIe cMepTH EJIeHIjl rJIIIHcKoii
(3 anpeJIH) , 5 anpeJIH 1538 r. npaBHTeJIbcTBo pacnopH"JIocb oTnaTb TpoIIne-CeprHeBy MoHacTblplo BoTIIHHy onHoro
H3 cBeTCKIIx q)eo"JIOB nMHTPoBcKOrO ye3", KOTOPyIO nPaBHTeJIbcTBo EJIeHbl

TJIIIHcKohnPenmlcaJIo

<<HaBenaTII> Ha

BeJIHKoro KHH3H 7. qepe3 MecHn, 6 MaH, ToIIHo TaKoe >Ke
VKa3aHIIe 6blJIo cneJIaHo oTHoCHTeJILHo KoH"cKoBaHHoro
ゴ

7 rBJI, Tp. KH. 521, J1. 129 06
329

y KI-IH3FI MHxalIJIa r,ⅡHHcKoro ceJIblla 3BFTrmHa MocKoB-

cKoro ye3na 8. B IIIoHe l538 r. CnaccKIIi HpocJIaBcKIIii MoHacTblpb noJIyrI" oTo6paHHble y Hero npH EJIeHe rJIIIHcKoii

nePeBHHHIJOIWHKH9nPa"TeJIbCTBOmTaJIOCb3aPyrIIITbCFI

WW¥" OfMoHoB9, Tpo皿e-CePrmeBa, KPIpHJIJIo-Be.

JIO3ePCKOrO MOHaCTblPen.

y>Ke c MaH I538 r・npaBHTeJIbcTBo myiicKHx cTaJIo BbIgaBaTb >KaJIoBaHHble H yKa3Hble HMMyHHTeTHble rpaMoTbl

B
rpaMoTax,
nQJIyqelIHLIx
Tpome-CepfmeBbIM
MoHAcTbIpeM
B MaS - ceHTH6pe l538 r., 3aKpemTeiibl TJIaBHblM o6pagoM
CyneOHbIe li 3anOBenHble nPIIBHJIermI.

H3
rPaMOT
HCHO,
qTO
B
yKa3aHHb[筒nPOMe>KyToK
BPeMeHIf
KpecTbFIHeTpoHIIe-CeprmeBaMo11acTblpiInplmy>KmajlHcbK
BblnOJIHeHHIO nByx OcHoBHblx HaTypaJIbHblx IIOBPIHHocTe曲一

rOPoXOBOrO neJIaHnoCOmHOii cJIy>K6bl, a TaK>Ke 60JIee MeJT-

KHXnOBIJHIIOCTe# lo.npaBHTeJIbCTBOnOmJIOHayCTynKy
MoIIacTblPloB oTHOmeHIIPI ymlaTbl HMcKHx neHer II npHMeTa:

MecTHblM c60PmPIKaM 3anPemaJIocb B3IIMaTb aTII iloXaTII,
MoHacTblPCKIIe BJIaCTH且OJI>KHLI 6bmlI nPHCblJIaTb <<C…CBoHx
MOHacTblPcKHx CeJI H 3 nePeBeHb HMCKIIe XeHbr肌 HnpIIMeT,
II BblTIIHe neHbrH... Ha MocKBV K Hamei Ka3He caMH》11.

TflKnQcTyJIHnmcOCTaPmHHbIMI!ceJIaMIIKyMraHOBbIMH
MeXHoi HoBoTop>KcKorO ye3na HelI3BecTHo, pacnPocTpaHHⅡCfl JIH yKa3aHHb耐Ⅱo"XOK C6OPa HMcKIIx meHer H nPHMeTa na BCIO MoHaCTblPCKylO BOTIIIIHy. nO KPaiHei MePe,
3TO nPaBIIJIO KaCaJIOCb II HOBonpH6blJIbHblx ceJI, Ha KOToPHe
HMeJTHCb TOJIbKO HeCyXIIMble m 3anOBenHbTe maMOTbl I2.

C ceJI, He ocBo60>KneHHblx o巾皿HaJIbHo oT HaMecTH顕bero
HOcOmHoro KOpMa, nocJIenHHii B3IHMaJTcFI HenocPeXcTBeHHo

caMIJMH HaMecTHHKaMH IJ IIx areHTaMII B ­vKa3Hoi rpaMoTe
ユ

MypoMcKQMy HaMecTHIIKy KHFI3Io m H. 0XoeBcKoMy 3anpe-

maJIOCb 6PaTb KOPM (､TPOImKOrO ceJIbUa qeranaeBa nOTOMy, [ITO erOくTaTaPOBH Ka3aHCKIIe BbDKrJIIT H BblBOeBaJIH)> 13.
8 rBJI, Tn. KH. 528, Nb 263, nJI. 368 06.- 369.

9H. A・B a x p a M̲e e B. PIcTopmecKIIe aKTbl Hpo|cJTaBcKoro CnaccKoro
MollaCTbl", T. 1. M., 1896, Nb X.

IoC･LU y l[ a K o B TBepcKme aKTbl, Bbm. 1 . TBepb, 1896, M IV,
cTp. 22-23.

II

TaM )Ke.

'2 CM. yKa3Hylo rpaMoTy o6 ymlaTe fYMcKIIx JeHer Kpe!cTEFYHaMIT XMHTl)oBCKI"Ix meJT I<ymmOBa II no皿oPTKoBa (TBJI, TP.. KII. 527, Nb 260) .
HeCyJIIJMaH rpaMoTa wa !IIIx 6bma BblAaHa l7 K1am 1538 1､. (rI"M,
OnH, yBap. KapT66/20, oT且.I,Nb 4).
13 11rAJA, rKa no MypoMy, Nb 4/7736.
330

C JIeTa l538 r. eme 60JIbmHM BHHMaHHeM, qeM TpoIm-

KIIi,HaIIaJIHoJIb30BaTbcHBnpaBHTeJIbcTBeHHbIxKpyraxCHMoHoB MoHacTEIpb. B HIoHe - aBrycTe l538 r. OH HoJIyIIIIJI

TpII)KaJIOBaHHbierPaMOTEI,II3KQTOPblXOXHa
(rPaMOTaHa

nePecJIaBCKHeCOJIflHbleBaPH皿bl)
nOKa3blBaeTCTPeMJIeHIIe
nPaBHTeJTbcTBa niaTb MoHacTblPlo Pm CymegrBeHHbIx npHBIIJIer城．C 1492 r. nepecJIaBcKIIe BapHHmbl CIIMOHQBa MoIIa-

CTbIPfIHeTOⅡHJIHcb,cTO月JIH<<nycTbl)'.rpaMoTal538r.IIMeU

JIa lieJIbIo coneiicTBoBaTb pa3BIITHIo coJIeBapeH" CIIMoHoBa
U

MOHacTblPfI: B Heik yCTaHaBJIHBaJIaCb onPeXeJTeHHafI CyMMa

O6POKa C BaPHHⅡ, HO CaMa ynJIaTa erO OTCPOIIHBaJIaCb nP
1542 r. 14

HapFIny c TPoHⅡKHMH CHMoHoBblMMoHacTblpHMIIB

HIoIIe - IIIoJIe l538 r. npaBIITeJIbcTBo nocHemHJIO BblnaTb
>KaJIoBaHHble rPaMOTbl H HeKOTOPblM nPyrIIM nyxOBHblM KOP-

nop aⅡHRM, Ha nO江,Ⅱep>KKy KoTopblx oHo MorJIo paccIKTW-

"E BblJia Bbl"Iia ilecWMafI rpaMoTa OJIII3KoMy K my#cKHM Cnaco-EB巾IIMbeB7 MoHacTblpIo " Ero cy3naJILEKIie
BoT可HHbl Haxo"JIIIcb io coceXcTBy c BJIaneHIIHMII myiicKIIx. 28 1IIoHH 1538 r. npaBHTeJIbcTBo nonTBepnHJIo He noX-

nHcaHHvIo
響 Ha BeJIIIKoKHH>KecKoe HMH B 1 534 r. HecyXHMyIo

H 3an6bemylo rpaMoTy l506 n Cy3XaJIbcKoMy HIIKoJIbcKoMymaPToMckoMy̅MoHacTBIpIo '6,Bo3Mo)KHo,WaaH．

HoMvt mvicKIIMII.
B KoHne HIoHH - HaIIaJIe moJTFI 1538 E
ー
ゴ

6blJIiI nMTBep>KneHbl "e rpaMoTLI ̲BacIM",III BeJmKo-

ycTIo)KcItOMy" cd6opy( 1 507 17 II1 5 1 6 rr. !8) ,'"c"oBgB-

mIIe ero |cVie6HbIe TI 3anoBeX'Hble npIIBIIJIer"｡ PaioH Be⑥

JIIIKoro y6TIora eme B nepBoii qeTBepTH XVI B HBJIFIJIcH
cBoeo6pa3HbIM noJIyyneJIoMBeJIHKoHKHHrHHHHynpaBJI列J1cBoeo6pa3HbIMⅡoJIyyⅡeJIoM
BeJIHKoii KHfITHHII H ynpaBJIHJIS
四

CH BeJIIIKOKHH>KeCKHM HaMeCTHHKOM H THyHOM BeJIIIKOII

kHfIrIIHII nO Bceii BePofITHOcTII, TaKOe noJIO>KeHme yCTIora
coxpaHMJIocb II npH EJIeHe rJIIIHcKoi. He ylIIBIITeJIbHo IQZ
妙

3ToMy, qTo myicKHe nocnemHJIH 3alfpenHTb cyBepeHIITeT
⑤

U

nPaBIITeJIbCTBa Han 3TOII TepPHToPHeII.

一二

Tpy" BJIaZIHMIIpcKom
14M．H・CMHpHoB、CoJIbnepecⅡaBcKaH.­くTpy瓜bl
BJIa瓜HMIIpcKoH

yqeHoiiapxIIBiIoiiKOMIIcIcII",KH.XVII.BJIa瓜ⅢMHp, 1917, npHn. 12,
⑰

⑪

bTP. 68; cp. Xn, I, Nb 381.
15 Xn, 1, JYb 370.
'6 Xn, I, Nb 35.

17mBdJIdronlcKIIery6epH"cKHeBenoMocTI",1851,qacTbHeo"UmaJIbHaH,
JYb 28, cTp. 325-326.

18H.P'yM･oBcKIIii.OnHicaHHeBeJIHKo-McTIo]KcKoroycneHnKoroco60pa. Bo.JIorna, 1862, cTp. 66-67.
331

Hecy"MyIo rpaMOTy Ha ceJIa Boprymy H TpoHnKoe

noJIyqIIJI B WoUe l 538 r. naHIIJIoB nepecJIaBJIb-3aheccKIIii

MoHacTpIpb19.noJIb3QBaJIcHB"MaHmeMII
KHpHJIJIo-BeJIo3epcKIm MoHacTblpb. 9 IIIoJ1FI 1538 r. eMy 6blJIa n(aHa HecynHMaH, 3anOBe4HaFI

H

oXHocPOIIHaH rpaMoTa Ha CeJIbno Ba-

"HcKoeB̲aP6y>KeBcKoih
FoJIocTHPoMaHoBcKoroyeMa"o.
16HIoJIH1538nnpaBHTeJIbcTBooTnpaBHJIoyKa3HjIdrpaMOTy xOJIOneHCKIIM TaMO>KHHKaM, 3anPemaBmylO HaPymaTb

>KaJIOBaXHyIO rPaMOTy yneJIbHOrO KHH3H nMHTp" HBaHO-

"Ia yrJIHHKoro KIIp"JIo-BeJIo3epcKoMy -MoHacTblplo.
B rpaMoTe coXep>KaJIoCb pa3pemeHIie nokynaTb 6ecn6mJIIIIlllO ToBapbl lla cyMMy no 20 py6JIeii B ron(21.

HaKoHeU, 3 aBrycTa l 538 f.- enHcKoH KoJIoMeHcK" H

KamHPcKHhBaccHaHTonopKoBIToJIyIIIIJITapxaHHo-Hecy1HMylo rpaMoTy Ha nBe KoJToMeHcKIIe cJIo60nKH 22.

nPHnOnblTKaxycTaHOBIITbTeCHOecOTPynHIIIIeCTBOcPHnOM 9eMJI GBJI aneJI皿eB nPaBHTeJIbcTBO B HaIIaJIbHblhneplIont
cBoei nieHTeJIbHocTH (np nepeBopoTa 21 0KTH6pH 1538 r)
nP"eP>KIIBaJIOcb QrPaHHIIHTeJIEHblx nPmHUHnoB HMMyHH­

TeTH O竹ⅡoJIIITHKI'1. B 3ToT npoMe>KyToK noIITH He Bbl"BaJIHcbTaPXaHHblerPaMOTbI(rPaMOTaKOJIOMeHCKoMyenHCKOny HBJIHeTcH HcKJIIoIIe"eM) . ToJIBKo BcJIen<cTBIIe Pa30peH"
MoHacTbIpcK" BoTIIHH Ka3aHcKHMII TaTapaMH JIeToM 1538 r.

MoHacTblpHKopH"IIeBKoMeJIbcK" 23 'mCHMoHoB 24 noJIy-

IIHJIH JIbroTHble rpaMoTbl, ocBo60>KnaBmHe IIx BJIaXeHIIH Ha
5 JIeT oT ocHoBHblx no3eMeJIbHbIx HaJIoToB II noBIIHHocTeii:
naHII, HMcKIIX neHer, rOPOnOBO:rO XeJTa, nOCOmHO'ii CJIy>K6bl,

HaMeCTHIIIIberO KOPMa・B rpaMoTax Mafl - ceHTH6pH 1 538 r.,
HMelOmlIx Hecy瓜HMbli Pa3neJT, IOPHCmHKUlIfl l,IMMyHIICTOB
OrPaHIIIIHBaJIaCb lI3'BHTHeM H3 Hee pa360pa nByx KaTeroPHii
yroJTQFHblx npecTymleH": nymery6cTBa H pa360FI c HoJIH可一
HbIM 25.

19B.rJL̲"06poHp̲aBoB.HcTop"Tpo皿KOrOnaHIIJIOBaMOHa|CTEI"
B rJIepeZcjlaBJ1e-3ameccKoM Ceprm6B nocam(,- 1908, npmJL Nb .2,
cTp. 18-19.

20 rnB, Co6p・Cn6.Ⅱ/A, M A II/47,測河. 340-343 06.
2j rnB, Q - IV - 1,､1 3 a, "J1. 1593-1596.

22B、AKy4IKMH)K3jIpBaHHa"TapxaHHo-Hecy"MaHrpaMoTaHBa･
"IVoT3aBrycTal538r.enIIEKdnyKoJIoMefIcKoMym｡KamllpcKoMy
BalccIIaHy
Ha
,nBe
cJIo60niKII
B
r・KoJIoMHe.­《ApxeorPaO,iqgcKIfii
e>K@L
ronHI,IK 3a l 959 ToX>､ M･, 1960, cTp. 342-343.

23 A M ERo QU̲il. HcTopllfI PoCcHiicKoit mepapxmT, w. 1V． M., 1812,
へ

cTp. 706-711.

24 M.H.CMHpIIoB.yKa3・co(I., nplm., Nb 12.
25 Xn,I, JYb 368, 370, 371, 377, 379,.382.
332

CKynocTb npHBHJIerllih, KoTopble conep>KaTcFI B rpaMoTax yKa3aHHoTo oTpe3Ka BpeMeHII, 6blJIa o6ycJIoBJIeHa TeM,
IITo HocJIe cMepTH EJIeHbl TJImHcKoi B npaBHTeJIbcTBe e皿e
U

cOXPallHJIII cIIJIy cToPOHHIIKMI

neHTPaJIH3aToPcKoH

noJIHTII-

KH. KoHKpeTHoe o｡oPMmeHHe HoBLIx rpaMoT H no八TBeP >KXe-

HIie CTaPblx Haxo瓜HJIOcb B PyKax BHJHorO COTPyJHHKa BacHJIIIH III H EJIeHbl rJIHHcKo曲瓜bHKa enppa MH皿yPIIHa
(IIM

6bmH 3aBePeHbl Bce rpaMOTH, nO瓜ⅡHCaHHble Ha BeJIII-

KoKHfl)KecKoe HMH B HIoHe - IIIoJIe l538 r.) . BJIMHIIeM

の. MHmypHHa, a Bo3Mo)KHo,Ⅲ Ⅲ．①. BeJIbcKoro o6'bHcHHeTCH IOcJIenoBaTeJIbHoe

nPOBeneHIIe

B >KII3Hb Tex HOPM

orPaHII[IeHIIH nPlIBIIJIemi KPynHblx ｡eO"JIOB, KOTQ"e JIe>KaJIH B ocHoBe HMMVHHTeTHohnoJIHTHKII
BacIIJIIIH III.
､ TeppHTopHaJIbHoe pacnpemeJIeHHe rpaMoT 3ToTo BpeMe-

HII cBIme'reJIbcTByeT O cTPeMJIeHHII K HeikTpaJIII3aⅡHH yJIeJIbHOii OⅡn03HnIIH. rPaMoTbl MaFI - IIIoHH l 538 r. KacaloTCH

ye3nloBHoBoTop)KCKoroHTBepcKoro26,4MIITpoBcKoro27,
Py3cKoro28,BoJIoroncKoromBeJIo3ep"oro29,HpocJIaBcKg-

rj30,Cy3"JIbcKoro31,KocTpoMcKorb3'HAlypoMGKoro3#
nepBbIe mecTb H3 rlHcJIa yKa3aHHblx ye3npB 6blJIIL6blBmeih

c｡epoi BJIHflHIIH A皿pefl CTap皿Koro H IOpHH nMHTpoBcKofo. B HPocJIaBcKoM ye3ne B Mae - IilOIIe l 538 r・aKTHBH-

3IipoBaJIcH ̅KHH3b "npP MHxaiiJIoBHII McTIIcJIaBcKIiii 34 Ha
｡eQnaJ1oB KocTpoMcKoro H MypoMcKoro yeaAQB, Bo3IvlQ)KIIo,

OnIIPaJIHCbKHH3bHBeJIbCKHe,COnePHHKH皿yiicKIix.KpoMe
Toro, 3plecbHrPaJI PoJIb巾aKTOP BHe皿Heii onacHoCTH(co
CTOPOHbl Ka3aHCKHx TaTaP) .
B HIo@)Ie - aBrycTe l538 r. B neHTpe BHHMaHHH oKa3bIEa-

IoTcH ye3"I nePecJIaBJIb-3aJIeccKHii 35, PoMaHoBcK", KQZ
JIOMeH6KHHH3aMOcKOBCKmeBOJIOCTH-BopH-Kop3eHeBo36
H KvHeH 37・POMaHOB HBJIHJICJI y,meJILHblM HacJIenlCTBOM

AH,njefIyrJ]皿Koro,BoJIocTbBopH-Kop3eHeBoHeKo皿anpH一

妬
鴻

Xn, I, JYb 366.
TaM ]Ke, Nh 368, 374.

鋤

TaM )Ke, Nb 371.
TaM JKe, Nh 373.

副

Ⅲ.A. BaxpaMeeB. yKa3・coII', Nb X.

鴻

Xn, I, JYb 370.
２TaM ]Ke, Nb 371.
３
３TaM JKe, JYb 367.
３
４TaM ]Ke, Nb 369, 372.
３
５TaM )Ke, Np 375-377, 379.
３６
TaM ]Ke, Nb 380.
３７
３

rB几TP. KH" 536, I 432-432 06" Nb 312 (coo6UmJIa几Ⅲ. HBIIHa)
333

""e)KaJIa lOpHIo BacIMbeBIILIy nMIITpoBcKoMy, a BoJIocTb
KyHelI no nyxoBIIoii HBaHa l l l EIIIcJIIIJI3cb 3a Aii叩eeM CTapIIUKHM.OIleBH八Ho,B1538r.y八eJIbHblellpeTeH3HⅢHCXOnliJIH II3 0Kpy>KeHHH MaJIoJIeTIIero BJIa1HMIIpa AHJPeeBWIa

CTapHUKoroII,6hlTbMo)KeT,HeKoTophIx，nPyrHX
nOTOMKOB
U

yneJIbHblX KHH3eH.

B aBrycTe - ceHTH6pe l 538 r. npaBIITeJIbcTBo BblnaBaJIo
rPaMOTU Ha KOCTP9MC"e, MypOMcKHe 38 H BJIa"MHpcKHe 39

3eMilliBFpoHTHo,myicKIIecTpeMH"cb
HaiiTHnonnep>KKy
B Tex PalfoHax, r八e HMeJIH BJIMHHIIe Be@JIbcKHe, II HaO60POT.

2.yc皿入eHIIeKOMnPOMIICCHLIX
TeHgeHIJ皿放
B MMMyHIITeTHOji nO入班T皿Ke

HoH6pH 1538 - nepBoir noJLoBIIHBI 1540 rr、

210KTH6pHl538r・山yliCKIIeOCymeCTBI皿HCBOknJIaH
yCTPaHeHIIJI

oT BJIacTII

cOnePHMIIaBmHXC

IIHMHⅡoJIHTHIIe-

cKIIx rpyⅡⅡHPoBoK: 6blJI y61,IT XbHK enop MHmyPHH, a KHH-

3HH。①.PeJIbcKoro6pocIIJIIIBTeMHImy.̅TenepIJilpaBHTeJIbCTBO皿yjicKHxroToBHJIOOTCTaBKyMHTPOnoJIilTanaHIIIIJIa,
no且凡eP>KHBaBmeroKHH3HBeJIbcKoro.OIIeBH且HO,y)KeBSTOT

nePIIOX6blJIO ̲TBePnO PemeHoBo3BeCTmHaMIITjOnOJIIIq"
cToJI HryMeHa Tpo皿e-CeprlleBa MoHacTblpfI Hoac"a, 6JIIi3Koro K I-IecTfDKaTeJIHM・n03皿IHH oceHb l538 r. HBHJIacb BPeMeHenLPe3Koro nePeJIOMa B HMMyHHTeTHOii nOJIHTHKe皿y曲一

cKIIx.BcBH3HcnpencToHB皿HMcBe"HHeMCMHTPOHOJIHllb-

eii
KabeJpb【且aHHIIJIa
nPaBHTeJIbcTBO
3HePrHIIHo
Xo6HBa-

JIoch coneiicTBIIH MOHacTblPeil.

OT H3yqaeMoro nepHo" HaM II3BecTHbl 55 HMMVHHTeTHblx
WPaMOT, H3 KOTOPblx HeTbiPe lIMeIOT HeonPenleJIeHHylO IaTy

(Me)Kny ceHTH6peM1538 H aBrycToM1539 r) . OciaJIbHbl6

[paMoTbl npeXcTaBJIeHbl 41 >KaJIoBaHHo# H lO yKa3HblMII.

H3>Ka@mgPa"blXrPaMOTTPH
OTHOCHTCH
KCBeT6KIIM
q)eOnaJIaM, 38(cpe皿KoTopblx 7 HecoxpaHHB皿HXCH)K IyXOB-

HblM, H3 yKa3HbIx OJ<Ha 6blJIa BbmaHa八BopenKHM. B KoHne

1538r.ycTaHoBHJIcHTecHbI曲KoHTaKTMe)K4ymyitcKIIMHH
TpomUe-CeprlIeBblMMoHacTblpeM,rneliryMeIibM6blJIKaH且Ⅲnay B MIITponoJIliTbI - Hoacab. B HaIIaJIe HoH6pH TpoImKHH MOHaCTbIPb HOJIyIIHJI >KaJIoBaHHylO naHHylO, TaPXaHHylO
II Hecy瓜ⅢMylo rpaMoTy Ha pbl5Hble JIoBJIH II no)KHH B HmKe38 Xn, I, Nb 381.
89 TaM jKe, Nb 382
334

l

rOPOACKOM ye3Xe, a TaK>Ke Ha nBOPOBble MecTa lI BaPHIiUbI

B BaJIaxHe H HIDKHeM HoBropo八e 40. 7 II 8 HoH6pfl 6blJIH
nOCJIaHbl CIIeUmaJIbllble yKa311ble rPaMOTbl B BaJIaXHy 4I M
HI1)KllHii HoBroPo八42 0 Epe八OCTaBJIeHIIH MOHaCTblPlO HO>KaJIOBaHllblx BJIaneHI伽ⅢⅡPHBHJIer噸．3To PaCnOPJDKeHIIe KaK
B cBOeii BOTIIMIHHO曲, TaK II B HMMyHHTeTHOA IIacTH皿JIO BPa3-

pe3 c IIHTepeCaMII HoCa,UCKHX JIIo4eii; 3a Hx cLleT Pac皿IIpHu

JIacb cyjKeHHaH

↑

〜

B IIpe只皿eCTByIO皿HHIleplIoI cqJepa

oeJIo-

MecTHoro 3eMJIeBJIa4eHHH 43, a ocBo60>K4eHHe MoHacTblpcKHx
JIIo,meih OT HaJIoroB 44 03HaIIaJIO ycHJIeHHe nOnaTHorO Ha>KII古
Ma Hanoca瓜．

B HoH6pe l538 r. TpoHUK" MoHacTblPb nP6HJIcH BbUaIIH

eMy rPaMOTbl Ha 6eCnOmJIIIHHylO JIOBJIIO Pbl6bl B nePeCJIaBcKoM H CoMMHe o3epax 45. Ko皿a-To BacHJIIIii l l l oTHHJI y
MoHacTblPH 3Ty nPHBHJIerIIIO,くⅡPOrHeBaBmHcb>> Ha liryMeHa

HKOBa 3a To, qTo <<HeKoTOPble 4eJIa 6PaHHble CTaJIII MOHa-

cTblpcKMM JIIoXeM c JIoBUbl nepecJIaBcKHMII>> 46. >KaJIoBaHHble rpaMoTbl, noJIyIIeHHble MoHacTblpeM B HoH6pe l536 r.,
BoccTaHaBJIHBaJIII B CHJIe cTaPHHHble
U

BJIanleJIbIIecKHe

H I,IM-

U

M y H I ' I Te T H b I e - n o K P a H H e H M e P e , n o 八 a T H b l e 一 Ⅱ P a B a M o H a -

CTblpH, Cy皿eCTBoBaBmHee皿e co BTopoii TpeTH XV B. 47
①aKT BecbMa noKa3aTeJIbHb1ii:皿yiiCKHe neMOHCTP aTIIBHO
40 rB几Tp. KH､518, JIJ. lO-l2 06.
4' Xn, I, M 385.
42 TaM JK,e, JVh 386.
43 0CIIOBHaFI IlaCTb BO八II yro4Mil, nePeIMcJIGIIHblx B rPaMoTe, npHHa八一
JIe)KaJIa MoHacTblplo c cepenlIIHbI XV B., o,nHaKo B nepHo八, HenOCPe,nkCTBeHHO nPe瓜meCTBOBaBmII曲 nO)KaJIOBaHI'110, MOHaCTblPCKMe BJIaCTH
U

H3-3aくKa3aHCKIie

PO3MIiPHnbl…JIIO瓜eʻH CBOHX Ha Te BO瓜bI HeⅢOChl-

JIaJIII>. qeJIo611THaFI MoHacTbIpfl II3JIaraeTcH B rpaMoTe TaK: <A KoJIm
IIHCUbl HamⅡⅡI,lcaJIII HoBrol)oJI HIDKIIei ll CoJIb BaJIaxoHcKylo, H Te
Hx Bo八bl HamlCaJIII B o61)oUte 3a rOPOnUKHMII JIIOmbMII C HHblMII c
Ha皿ⅢMII c O61)oIIHbIMII BOniaMI'I, HOTOMy uTo Ha HIIX MOHaCTblPcKIIx
ʻﾉIIoJleii He 6bIJIO, II HaM 6bl Hx TeMH BO八aMH H MeʻCTOM八BOPOBI>IM K
BapHIIUaMII y CoJIM y BaJIaxoIIcKIIe l'I B ropone Ha BaJIaxIIe MecToM
IIa pBop Ha oca,nHoii no)KaJIoBaTH>. OIIeBⅢ皿IC，nHcnhl B caMoM瓜eJIe
3amicaJII,I MoI･lacTbl･PcKJIe BJIaneIIHH 3a rOPoncKHMH JIIO4bMII. npaBHTeJIbCTBo

He TOJIbKo

BePHyJIo

MoHacTIJIPIo

cTaPHHHLIe

Bolbl

H

nBopbl,

HOlmnl)lUaJIo eMy HOBOG Oca"HOe MeCTO B BaJIaXHe, a TaK)Ke nP〆

noJIHH'reJIbHbLe PblOHbleʻJIOBJIH、

44 B yKa3Hoii rpaMoTe HH>Keropo八cKmM KJIIo[11･皿KaM, HanpIIMeP, roBOPllTcFI: <<H o6poKoB 6bl ecTe Ha皿IIxHcBoHx BcHKHx HomJIHH c Tex Bo瓜
Ⅲ3皿opoB c MoHacTbIpcK1Ix HbIHe li Bnepenl He HMaJIII> (Xn, I, Nb 386) ,
45 Xn, 1, Nb 383.
46 TaM ]Ke.

47 npHBwIerIIII }Ia HH>KeropoX,cKIIe BJIanteHIIH 6hlJIH且aHbl MoHacTLIPIO
B acmJIIIieM I I npPI HryMeH|e BacbHHe ( 1 455-1 466 rr.) , Ha nel)ecJIaB335

リ

nopblBaJIH

c orpaHHIIIITeJIbHoi

noJIHTIIKoii

BacIMIIH

III H

EJI"bl rJI"cKoit B o6JIacTII nonaTIIoro IIMMyHIITeTa.

Tp9皿e-CepmeB｡MoHacTIJIpb
6pIJI
Hee"H6TBeHHoh且y-

XOBHQH KOPnOPaUllen, noJIyIIHBmei B 3TO BPeMH 3eMJIHH

ocBo60>KXeHHeoT̲IIaJIoroB.BJ<eKa6pel538r.̅npaBIITeJIbcTBonpenpcTaBIIJIoToTGMcKoMyE｡peMoByMoHacTblplonpaBo
くOKOJIO TOro MOHacTblPH Ha BCe cTOPoHbl JIeC Ce[IHHKp eCTbHH Ha TOM Ha lHKOM JIecy CO且HTHHⅡaml-IIO naxaTH OT

TOrO MOHaCTblPH no mlTH BePcT)D, nPlIIIeM MOHacTblPcKaH

BOTIIHHaOCBO60班旦aJIacbHaHeonPe八eJIeHHbIiiCPoKOTrJIaBHblx HOmJIHH II HoBHHHOcTeii: JaHII, noJIBon, roPOHoBOrO
4eJIa, nocQlllHoA cJIy)K6bl, TaMrm 48. 22 meKa6pH l538 r.

CnaccK" HpocJIaBcK" 49 II HoKpoBcK" yrJIHiK" 50 MoHacIPlPli nQJIyqII" Ha3an OTo6PaHHble y HIIx PaHee 3eMJIH.
一

B 4eKa6pe l 538 r. B BeJIilKoKHH)KecKoii - KaHneJIHpllH

OEIJIII nO4TBeP班旦eHbl )KaJIOBaHHble rPaMOTbl Ha MOHacTbIP-

cKHe XBopbI Ha nocanax - CnaccKoMy HpocJIaBcKoMy Mo-

HafTblpIoo6eJIbHaHrpaMoTaBapIIJIIIHnl̅1511n,no̅KoToPOH MoHacTblPCKHM JIIOJJIM B JIPOcJIaBJIe Pa3PemaJIoCb He
THHyTb C rOPOXCKHMII JIIOnbMH I丑I B KaKHe nPOTOPbl H Pa3-

MeTbl,《oⅡ”可b noCOmlIble CJIy)K6bI H nlI皿aJIbHorO HaPfmy

rOPOnOBOrO,meJIa)>
H
51j
HocMI｡o-BoJIoKoJIaMcKoMy
MoHacTbit
plo TapxaHIIaH rpaMoTa yne@mbHoro KHH3fl AH且PeH HBaHOBII-

IIa l534 r., ocBo6o)KnaB皿aH OT nlaHH, HMcKIIx ZeHer, HOcomHOii CJIy>K6bl, rOPO,n<OBOrO neJIaH，mPyrHx noBHIIIIocTeiH
ⅢomJIHH MoHaCTblPCK城旦Bop B CTapHne 52.

HecKoJIbKozKaJIoBaHHblxrpaMoTb60JIbmHMH｡IIHaHcoBbIMHⅡpIIBHJIerHHMHnPHo6PeJIH MoHacTblPH B ｡eBPaJIe

l 539r.,Kor,na npoHcxo皿JIO CMemeHHeMHTPOHOJIHTa na-

""a II 3aVeHa ero moacaloM B aToT MoMeHT KmPIIJIJIo-

"O3ePcKmii
MoH4cTbIPb
XO6"cH
BO3BPameH"
eMyXBoPa

ByrJIHIIe,KoToPbliiくHblHe̲B3HJIHKrOPomyHaHacnPHKa3mmKH HamHropoppBble>. HaceJIeHIIIo MoHacTblpcKorb nBo-

pa Pa3pe皿aJIocb He THHyTb C IIepHbIMH JIIOnbMH HH B KaKIIe

pagMeTbl53.nocJIaHHaHB｡eBpajiel539r.yKa3HaHrpaMoTa
BCy3XaJIb3anpe皿aJIarOPOmPBblMnPIIKa3IIHKaM<<BcTynaTbcKoe . jI̲ ̲ CoMIIHQ o3ePa-ⅡPH HryMeHe 3 HHoBIIH ( 1432- 1445 rr. ;
cM. AC3H, T. l, JYh 92):
4: A MB no c m ji. yKa3. coI1" q. 1V, crp. 89-95"
49 1I. A. BaxpaMeeB. yKa3. coLI., NbXII.
50 urHA,巾. 834, on. 3, JYb 1916, ". 384.
51 H. A. BaxpaMeeB. yKa3 cOKI, Nb lV.
52 A3HX, q. 11, M 303.

53 C.A.myMaKoB・yr皿I[IcKMe aKTb1. M., 1899, Nb VI.
336

cH)> B mHnoBcKylo cJIo601Ky noKpoBcKoro IeBI1[lbero Mo-

HaCTblpH
54.
HapacTaHHe nonaTHblx npHBHJIermii KpynHblx nyxoBHblx

｡eonaJIoB npHo6peJIo B Ko皿e l 538- 1 540 rr. 3HaIIHTeJIbHblii
⑪

Pa3MaX,

cTaB

oIHOHH3

0TJIII[IIITe@mbHblx

IIePT

IIMMyHHTeT-

HO曲ⅡoJIHTHKIi myitcKHx. yBeJIIIrleHIIe ｡IIHaHcoBblx npaB MoHaCTblPeii HeJIb3H o6'bHcHHTb ToJIbKO OTJ<eJIbHblMH KOHKPeTHblMH nplirlHHaMH. OHo HMeJIo 60JIee mmpoKylo ocHoBy -

HenPOIIHOCTb nOJIO]KeHIIH皿yiiCKHX y KOPMIIJIa rOcynaPcT易

BeHHOi BJIaCTH

H CTPeMJIeHHe

lIx O6ecneIIHTb

cOIO3 c BO3-

MO)KHo 66JIbmHM [IHcJIOM nyxOBHLIX KOPnOPa皿嘘瓜JIH TOrO,

IITo6LI ynep>KaTb B cBoIIx pyKax 6pa3Xbl npaBJIeHHH.
nocJIe nepeBopoTa 21 0KTH6pH 1538 r. npaBHTeJIbcTBo
BblLaBaJIO 皿enPble

>KaJIoBaHHble

rPaMOTbl caMblM Pa3JIIIII-

HblM MoHacTblpHM. B ｡eBpaJIe l539 r. ycTb-皿exOHCKHii MOH a c T b l P b n O J I y I I I I J I r P a M O Ty, P a 3 P e m a B m y l o M O H a C T b l P C KO M y

4BOPHIIKy B BeJIOO3ePe Ha nOcanie He THHyTb c THrJIblMII

JIIoJLMII B pa3Hble npoTopbl H pa3MeTbl 55. B MapTe l539 r.
CoJIoBeUKoMy MoHacTbIpIo 6bIJIo niaHo 13 JIyKoB 3eMJIII
くc XpeHHLIM o6poKoM)' (coJIHHble BapH皿bl OCBo6O)KIaJIHCb
oT o6poKa) H co BceM, <<[ITo…ⅡoTHrJIo, onPHIIb o6e>KHbie

naHH> 56. B MapTe l539 r・KKplIJIJIo-BeJIo3epcK" MoHacTblpb
npHo6peJI npaBo 6ecnomJIHIIHoii JIoBJIH pbl6bl oJHHM HeBonOM B BeJIoM o3epe 57, a B IIIoJIe TorO ]Ke rOXa - MecTo nOn
coJIHHoji aM6ap B UMIITpoBeHⅡPaBO He nJIaTHTh c HerO
nOmJIHHbl 58. BOJIbmOhHHTePec nPencTaBJIHeT )KaJIOBaHHaH

rpaMoTa oT 16 HHBapH 1540 r. TpomHe-CeprIIeBy MoHacTblplo
Ha erO MOCKOBCKI揃且BOP, 3aBemaHHblh《B IOM…TpolIUe》
rocTeM HBaHoM MHxaiiJIoBHIIeM AHToHoBbIM. B rpaMoTe nepeCKa3blBaeTcH qeJIO6HTHafl MOHaCTblPCKHX BJIaCTeii:くA ToT
Hx

IBOP

HamiCaH B

THrJIe

3 rOCTHHblMH

IBOpbl, H THrJIb

Hamy 3 rOcTbMH Co BCeMII THHyJIH, II HaM 6bl Hx Io>KaJIo⑫

BaTH - C

TOrO

nBOPa

THrJIH

cBoeH

H

BCHKHX

HOmJIHH

〆

H M a T H H e B e J I e T H H 3 r o c T b M I I o b l H M H e T H H V T H H H B K o To -

pble pa3MeTbl>. npaBHTeJIbcTBo BblnoJIHHJIo npocb6y MoHacTblpH 59. TaKIIM o6pa30M, myitcKHe PacIIIHPHJIHnOnaTHOii
54 UrAnA, rKa no Cy3"HIo, M

2 1 /1 1800.

55 rB几PyM班皿. KH. 53, JIJI. 10-13.
56 X O C II * e il. reOrpa"qeCKOe, HCTOPHqeCKOe
m CTaTHcTIIqeCKOe
omlcaHHe CoJIoBeUKoro MoHacTblpH, 11. 111．M., 1836, cTp. 1-3, Nb 1.

57 rnB, Co6p. Cn6. n/A, Nb AII/47, 1. 169-169 06.
58 rnB, Q­IV - 1136, cTp. 718-720.
59 rBJI, Tp. KH. 520,矼矼. 19 06.­22.
22

C. M. KamTaHoB

337

ノ

HMMyHHTeT'IPoIIUKOrOMoHaCTblPHBy皿eP6HHTePecaMBePxymKH MOCKoBcKoI O HoCana - rOCTeii.
B l539-1540 rr. ocBo60)K,UaJIIIcb oT no皿JIHH HeToJIbKo
MOH aCTbIP CKIie八BOPbI Ii nPOMblC@ﾉIbl, HO TaKIKe ce.JIa lI ne-

peBHII. Hali6oJIee皿eJPylo TaPxaHHylO rPaMOTy nOJIy[IIIJI B
ceHTH6pe l539 E Hoc"o-BoJIoKoJIaMcK" MoHacTblpb Ha

ceJIo aycToBy roPy B 3y6UoBcKoM ye3八e 60. 3Ta rPaMOTa
6blJIa ,maHa B3aMeH rpaMoTbI BacHJIIIH III 1522 r. Ha To >Ke

ceJIo 61・rpaMoTa l 539 r. pe3Ko yBeJIIIqIIBaJIa HMMyHIITeTHble
U

ⅡPHBHJIerHII

MoHaCTblPH:

B

Heli

一

COXePjKaJIOcb

OCBOOOIK八e-

HHe oT ocIIoBHbIx npHMblx HaJIoroB, [lero HeT B aKTe l522 r.
PaCmIIPHJIaCb li MOHaCTblPcKaH IOPIIC,MKUIIH: 1IO rPaMOTe
BacHJIIIH III MoHacTbIpb MMeJI B OaycToBe rope npaBo cy八a,
《onp lIKle八ymery6cTBa li pa360H c HoJIHIIHLIM>>; B 1539 r｡
八eJIa O Pa360e C nOJIIIIIHblM CTaJIH nO,mBeXOMCTBeHHbl MOHaCTbIP IO.

Bbl,naIIy aToii x〈aJIoBaHHoii rpaMoTbl l539 r・HeJIb3H He
CBH3aTb c H3MeHeHIIHMH B HoJII1THIIeCKO曲opHeIITanIHH myiicKMx. noca)KeHHblit IIMII Ha MIITpoIIo皿I'Hii CTOJ' HOacaqJ
OKa3aJICH

naJIeKO

He

nOCJIe八OBaTeJIbHbIM

CTOPOHHHKOM

60HpcKoii rPyⅡnHPOBKH, CTOHB皿eii y BJIaCTII. H3BeCTHO, IITo
v)Ke B HIoJIe l540 r. oH八O6HJICFI OCBO60駆只eHIIH II．①．BeJIb“

cKoro H cHoco6cTBoBaJI, TaKIIM o6pa30M, na八eHIIIO npaBm･
TeJIbcTB a皿yiicKHx K KoHUy l540 r. BH八HMO, yjKe C OCeHM
1539 r. 60叩CKOe nPaBIITeJIbcTBO PemHJIO OHePeTbCfl Ha nOa
U

JIHTIIIIeCKIIX

nPOTIIBHIIKOB

↑

HecTH)KaTeJIeH - HOCHUJIHH,皿H-

TaleJIblo KoTopblx HBJIHJIcH BoJIoKoJIaMcK" MoHacTbIpb.
B HocJIe八cTBHH 6JIH30cTb myiicKHx K HoCH｡JIHHaM HamJIa
CBOe BblPaIKeHHe B COIO3e HX C HOBrOPO八CKHM aPxIienHCKO-

HoM MaKapHeM, KoTopblii cTaJI B 1542 r. MHTponoJIIiToM.
HOMHMO y>Ke yKa3aHIIblx rPaMOT, COnlePjKa皿Hx nO八aTHble npHBHJIerⅡⅢ,

MOJKHO OTMeTHTb

rPaMOTy,

BblnaHHylO

B

HHBape l540 r. neIIepcKoMy HIDKeropoJIcKoMy MoHacThIpIo,
B KoToPoii ero BoTIIIIHbl B HH>Keropo八cKoM II Cy3JaJIbcKoM
ye3Jax ocBo60)KXaIJIHcb Ha lO JIeT oT JaHH, HMcKHx nieHer,
nocomHoii cJIy]K6bl, HaMecTHIitlbero KopMaH瓜pyrlix nomJIHH 62. MoHacTI>IpIo BacIm皿KecaPHiicKoro B Cy34aJIe OblJIa
"Ha B 1539/40 r. TapxaHHo-o6po[IHaH rpaMoTa Ha ceJIo
Cy34aJILcKoro ye3Ja 63. 0 meXpocTH HMMyHHTeTHblx Ho>Ka０A3HX, q. 11, Nb 149.
６
６
１ 1､aM ]Ke, Nb 87.
６
２K a 6 a H o B , M 1 0 .
６
３
ul､HA, *. 834, 0Ⅱ.3,M 1 920, nn. 43-44.
338

｡

O･

JIoBaH['IH cBIIneTeJIbcTByeT II rpaMoTa, no.｢IyqeHHaH B aBl､ycT6

1539 r. TpoMUK}IM TJIenellcKPIM MoHacTblpeM. MoHacTblPb
yKa3blBaJI B cBoeii LIeJIo61ITHoit, LITo C ero 3aBo41I B p. CyxoHe o6poK HccTapm <<He lIMblBaJIH> npaBHTeJIbcTBo HoITBep瓜HJIO HepymHMocTb 3TOro nPlIHuHna m 3anPeTHJIO nPHxoJI B

MOHaCTblPcKyIo3aBOXbnoCTOpOHHIIxJIHn(64.
TaKHM o6Pa30M, B KoHUe l539 - Ha'IaJIe l540 r. ocBo60駆瓜eHHe MOHacTblPcKHx BOTqHII oT HaJIOrOB nPHo6PeJIO
3HaIIHTeJIbHbIit pa3Max. OHo coIIeTaJIocb c npenocTaBJIeHIIeM

MoHacTbIpflM HoBblx II oTHFITblx y HIIx paHbme 3eMeJIb. B oTneJIbHblx CJIyIIaHx, 06yCJIOBJIeHHblx O6blIIHO nePHneTIiflMH

oCTPOi BHyTPHKJIaCCOBOi 60Pb6bl, KO皿a nPaBHTeJIbCTBO
Hy>KnaJIOCb B coneiiCTBIIH TOTO HJIH IIHOrO MOHaCTblPH, BOCU

cTaHaBJIHBaJIHCb

HaPymeHHble

llMMyHIITeTHble

nPe旦皿eCTByIOmlIMH

llPHBIIJIerIIIi MOHacTblPeH,

nPaBIITeJTbCTBaMPI,HmI

pacmHpH皿ICb IIx CTaPbIe nOnaTHble nPIIBHJIerlIII.

BO,IIbmoe IIHCJIO TaPXaI･IHbIx II O6eJIbHblX rPaMOT, BbmaHH H X H Ⅱ O AT B e P > K n e H H b l x B 3 T O T n P o M e j Ky T O K B P e M e H I I , O T-

HOCIITcFI K MOHacTblPcKIIM IBoPaM B rOPOnax. MOHacTblPH,
noIIyBcTBoBaB ycTynIIHBocTb myiicKIIx B Bonpoce o nonlaTHblx nPHBHJIemFIx, nocnemHJIH BblnPOcHTb y nPaBHTeJIbCTBa
>KaJIoBaHHble rPaMoTbl, KoTOPble yKPenJIHJIHnO3H皿IⅢ瓜yXOB-

Hblx .eO"JIOB Ha maTKo曲nOIIBe, yCKOJIb3aBmeii II3-HOA IIX

Hor eme B nepHon KIIflJKeIIHfl BacHJIH兄111,- B rOPOnaX.
>KaJIoBaHHble rPaMoTbl KoHUa l538 - HatlaJIa l540 r.,
nOCBzI皿eHHble *IIKcaUl冊I ｡HHaHcOBblx nPHBIIJIer" MoHacTblPeii, nPenOCTaBJIHJIII Pa3JIHIIHblM MOHacTbl"M Pa3JIIIIIHble

Ho o6'LeMy KoMmleKcbl lIMMyHIITeTHblx npaB. Bo-nepBblx,

IIMeJIo MecTo noJIHoe ocBo60>KXeHIIG oT Ka3eHHblx c60poB.
OHo naBaJIocb HaH60JIee BJIIIHTeJIbHblM nyxoBHblM Kopmo-

=
PamlHMcUeJIIJIOHOJIyIIHTboTHIIxHOMo皿bBMOMeHTbIO60-

CTPeHIIH 60Pb6bl llOJIHTHIIeCKIIx rPyⅡⅡHPOBOK 60FIPcTBa 3a
BJIacTb. npH aToM o"IHaKoBo menpo o6enflJIIIcb KaK MoHa-

cTblpcKIie "opbl B roponax (rpaMoTbl l538 1i l540 1T.
TpoHue-CeprlieBy MoHacTblplo, noHTBep巫旦eHHe rPaMOTbl

1534 r. A皿peH CTap皿Koro BoJIoKoJIaMcKoMy MoHacThlplo) ,
TaK H MoHacTblpcKHe ceJIa (rpaMoTa l538 E E｡peMoBy Mo-

HacTblplo, rpgMoTa l539 r. IIocI"o'BoJIoKoJIaMcKoMy Mo-

HacTblpIoj Bo-BTopblx, Ha6JIIomaJIobb BpeMeHHoe HJIH HenoJIHOe OCBo60)KAeHIIe OT nOXaTeik. STy JIbrOTy nOJIyqaJIH
64 3TH cBeneHIKH II3BJIeLIeHbl H3 noPhJIo>KHoro cHIIcKa rpaMoTbl l539 r,．

(JIoHﾙI, Co6p・aKToB JP 1613 r., Nb l/131), me wacT薊【IHoHcnoJ1b30BaH

TGKcT

noⅡJIHHHmKa.

339

22＊

MeHee 3HaulHTeJIbHblG MoHacTblpH o61]IIIHo B o6cTaHoBKe HeKOT9POrO cnana noJIHTIIIleCKOii HanPmKeHHOCTH.

y皿eMJIeHme
llpaB
MoHacTblpeii
6blJIoo6paTHoIIponopUHOHaJIbHO

IIX皿eJIbHOMy BeCy

II - KO皿a

ZeJIo

Kac･a,mocb

MoHaCTblpcKIIx ABoPoB - IIPHMo nponO皿IIOHaJIbHO HOJIHTIILIeCKOH aKTHBHOCTHnoca,IoB. TaK, KpyllHblii CoJIoBeniKI1ji Mo-

¥2"" QCBo60>K"JIcfI oT pa3HbIx nom皿H,KPoMe oAHoi
oOe>KHoH JIaHH; Ba>KIIblII B cTPaTerIIIIeCKOM oTHo皿eHIIII HIi-

>Kerop on<cK砿 neIIepcKIIM MoHacTblPb 6blJI o6eJIeH oT Bcex

ITO皿JIIIHHa60JIb皿OiicPoK-10,JIeT・KHpHJIJIo-BeJ'o3epcK"

MOHaCTblPP HOJIyIIIIJI "H BcerO HaceJIeHIIJI MOHaCTblpCKoro

八BOPaByrJIIIIIenPaBOHeTHHyTbcTH皿blMH!JIIOXbMHBnPOTOPblmPa3MeTb!(HOBOO6皿eOTnO"TeliXBOPHe6blJIOCBo60)K,meH) . MeJIK" ycTb-mexoHcKIm MoHabTblDb cvMem

Xo6IITbcH3ToiinpIIBIIJIerlIHToJIbKoJIJIHo皿OrOiBOPfIIIKa
Bo>KmBJIeHHoM？KOHOMmIIeCKOMneHTpe-BeJIOO3ePe，皿e
IIMeJICH OKPenmHiI B KoHUe XV­Ha[IaJIe XVI B. Hocanl.

BnpoIIeM,cy皿ecTBGHHblerpanaUHIIBIIMMyHI,ITeTHblxnO>KaJIoBaHHHX He nOJI)KHbl 3aCJIoHHTb B HamHx l,･na3ax o6IIleii

JIHHIIHⅡOJIIITIIKI1myiiCKHx,cOcTOHBmeihByKPenJIeHHHnOnaTHOrO HMMyHIITeTa MOHaCTbiPek.

KpoMeJIbroTBoTHo山eHHIIymlaTblHaJIOrOB,MOHacTblPII
noJIyIIaJIHH久Pyrme lHHaHCOBble nPmBIIJIerHH. MMellHO B

3ToT'nepHo4HHKoJIaeBcKoMyKopeJIbcKoMyMoHacTblplo
ynaJIocb BblroB2pIITb ce6e npaBo Ha o6po[IHoe BJI"emie
IIacTbIo o3epa KyJMo, KoTopoe, KaK cKagaHo B LIeJIo6HTbe

MoHaCTblPCKHX BJIaCTeii, y HIIx<ⅡoOTHHMaJIII IBHHHIIe He-

HoKmaHe OJIeKcei Xa HBa皿Ko HKoBJIeBbl neTH MaJIoro)P.

nQpJIe"" nJIaTHJIH c o3epa B Ka3Hy o6poK B pa3Mepe
py6"兄 nPaBmTeJIbcTBooTna"OMOHiCTblPlO2/3 '03eja,
oCTaBHB B pyKax HeHoKIIlaH 1,/3. npH 3ToM o6皿aH cyMMa

o6po"̲c o3epa cHH3"acb Ha 2 rpHBHbl (MoHacTbIpb ̅nJIa-

TIi,JI 107 AeHer, a l･IeHoK皿aHe - 53 AeHbrH, T. e. c Ka)KAoii

TpeTH o3epa B3HMaJIocb 53 ,meHbrH) 65. noKa3aTeJIeH TaK)Ke
nPIIMeP c npe八ocTaB@JIeHHeM B Mae l540 r. MeJIbll皿b' naHH-

JIoBy nepecJIaBJIb-3aneccKoMy MoHacTblplo. no oT"" ee
B MOHacTbIpb MeJIbHHUa HaxO旦HJIacb B o6POIIHOM八eP>KaHIM

yHeKoero̲BoJIo4bKmTpo,lIMoBa,KoTopb[曲n@JIaTHJIO6pOK
B Ka3Hy.npaBHTeJIbcTBonepe"JIoMoHaCTblPloHe ToJILKo
MeJIblIHKy, HO H MeJIbHHKa, OTMeHHB ynJIaTy O6pOKa 66.
@i IC60pHMK rpaMoT I<omerliH 3KOHoMHIi>", T. 11.几、1929, M 86a.
66 B.皿且o 6 p o H p aB o B. yKa3 cou",npmJI" crP. 21-22, Nb 5:
くA MeJIbllilK y Hee BoJIonibKa Tpo"MoB . 3 XBopdM, c cHabTblo c
340

CJIeXoBaTeJIbHo, noJIHTHKa myicKI1x cIIoco6cTBoBaJIa
onyTblBaHHIO TOPrOBO-PeMeCJIeHHblX CJIOeB THrJIOrO HaCeJIe-

H1硯Ⅱe"MH IIaCTHO*eO"JIbHblx OTHomeH砿HmJIa BPa3Pe3

cHHTePeCaMHyKPenJIeHIIHTOcynaPcTBeHHblX巾HHaHcoB
B noJIb3y MoHacTblpeii cBepTI]IBaJIacb H BoJIocTHaFI ToproBJIfl. TaK, cHoco6cTByH c60py TaMo>KeHHblx no皿JIHH TpoH-

Ue-CeprlIeBblM MoHacTblpeM B ero ceJIe MenHe, npaBIITeJIIJcTBo myicKIIx B neKa6pe l539 r. nocTaBIIJIo non 3anpeT Bce
MecTHble Top>KKH HoBoTop>KcKoro ye3na, KpoMe nocana

r. Top>KKa H c. MeXHbl・yKa3HaH rPaMoTa l539 r. 0 3anpe皿eHIIII ToproBJIH B pa3HbIx MecTax HoBoTop>KcKoro ye3na
xapaKTeplI3yeT

cBoeKopblcTHylo

Ho,JIIITI1Ky

nPaBIITeJIbcTBa

myiicKIIx, cTecHHBmylo pa3BIITIIe ToBapHoro o6pa皿eHI旧B
cTpaHe. CaMo HoHBJIeHIie 3anpeTa, conep>Ka皿erOcFI B rPaMOTe, 6blJIo o6ycJIoBJIeHo TeM, IITo Ka3Ha He noJIyLIaJIa XoxonpB

oT ToproBJIII B BoJIocTHx HoBoTop>KcKoro ye3na, me oTcyTcTBoBaJI HHcTHTVT BoJIocTHbIx TaMo>KeIIIIIIKoB. nocJIeXHee
O6cToHTeJIbCTBO o6'MICHHeTCH B KoHe[IHoM CIIeTe HePaBHOMePI-IOCTblO Pa3BIITHH TOBaPHO-neHe)KHblX OTHO皿elIHII B PyCCKOM
U

rocynapcTBe XV-XVI BB・rpaMOTa npH3HaeT BO3HHKHoBeHIJe ToproB B BoJIocTFIx HoBoTop>KcKoro ye3na HoBblM HBUeHHeM :くA Hanepen, ne]1, Toro Bo BJIanblrlHe cJIo60nKe H y HIIKoJIIJI B BepHoBe, II B 3aro'pbe y nHTHImbl cBHToii, II B BEImKoBe, H B I/IJIblIHCKOM ceJIe ToPr He 6blBaJ1, H He TOPrOBaJI

HI'IXTOIIIIKaKHMTOBapOM),67.
BoT, no cyTH neJI2, npHIIIIHa Toro, IITo B BoJIocTHx HoBoTop>KcKoro ye3Xa He ycTaHoBIIJIacb K 40-M ronaM XVI B. CIIcTeMa Ka3eHHblx TaMo)KeHHIIKoB, KoTopaH Ha6JIIoXaeTcH B
cTaHax II BOJIOcTHX 60JIee pa3BIITblX B SKOHOMIIIIeCKoM OTHOmeHIIH ye3XoB 68. OnHaKo xapaKTepHo caMoycTpaHeHIIe npaBHTeJIbcTBa OT opraHII3anHII HoBblx TaMO>KeH, nePenaIIa《no

CTaPHHe)>*yHK皿憧BOJIOCTHorOc60PmlIKaTaMO>KeHHblxnomJIHH KPynHOMy MOHaCTblPlO-BOT[IHHHHKy.

noKpoBIITeJIbcTBeHHoe oTHomeHIIe myiicKIIx K MoHacTbl･
pHM o6HaPy>KHBaeTcH B UeJIoM P"e paCnOPH)KeHIIii,2blmeXmlIx B 3T6 BpeMH II3 BeJIIIKoKHH>KecKoi KaHIIeJIHpHII. TaKoBa,
M'eJIbHII[IHoIo co Bc'eIo, a o6poKy c Toe MeJIbHHUbl JBy py6JIeB 6e3
IIeTPI

B cBoIo Ka3HV HMaTIf…He BeJIeJI＞、

67 AAS, T. I, Nb l88, cTp. 165-166.
68 E11Ie B rpaMoTax KHR3H IOplIfl HBaHoBIIIIa Ha py3cKo-nMHTpoBcKHe

BOTqHHbl ̅ MOHaCTblPeii o6 mIcTIITyTe BOJIOCTHHX (CTaHOBbMX) TaMO]KeHHIIKoB roBoplITcH KaK o BIIoJTHIG o6blIIHoM HBJTeHHH. Cp. TaK]Ke

rpaMoTy l 540 r. Ha seMJIII B BeJ1o3epcKoM ye3nte (rBJI, pyM只HⅡ，
KH. 53, "". 14-17 06.).
341

HanpHMep,oTnpaBJIeHHaFIBPH3aHbBaBrycTel539r.rpaMoTa, npe瓜ⅡIICblBaIOmaH ropOnpBoMy nPHKa3IIHKy co6IIpa'rb

o6poKJIJIHCnaccKoroPFI3aHcKoroM6HacTblpH̅cpacnbJIo-

>KeHHblxHaMOHaCTblPCKOi3eMJIeXBOPOBmeTei60flPCKHXII
IIePHLIx JIIoneii, KOTOPble nocJJe cMepTII craPoro roPOXOBoro
rrP"a3IIII" nepecTaJIII mIaTIITb o6poK MoHacTblplo 69.

Ⅱ” 皿yiiCKHX yqaCTIIJIHCE cJIyIIalI nO)KaJIOBaHHH PyrH

XyxOBHblM ｡eOXaJIaM STO yC"IIBaJIO申HHaHCOBylO 3aBIICIIMPPrb HX oT npaBIITeJIbcTBa. II3BecTHbl py>KHHe rpaMoTl)I

1539-1540rr・HIIKoJTbcKoMynecHomcKoMy70,AJIeKcaHXpoByOmeBHeBy71,naH"oBylIPo)KnlecTBeHcKoMynel)ecJIaBJIb3aJIGCCKHMMOHaCTblPHM72.

MeHee6JIaronpHFITHoitnlJIHnyxoBHbIxKopnopan城6bmtl
TaMoJKellHaH noJMTIIKa npaBIITeJIbcTBa. B )KaJIoBaHHblx rpa-

MoTaJ< 1538-1539 rr. ToTeMcKoMy E巾peMoBy, KoMeJIbcKo-

My,rJIeneHcKoMyIIycTb-mexoHcKoMy̅MoHa6TbI"Mpa3pe皿aJIC兄nPOBO3 3anacOB TOJIbKO KHa MOHaCTblPCKyIO HOTPe-

6y>. CTapUbI, JIIoⅡHH KpecTb"e KoMeJIbcKoro MoHacTblpFI
noJIyIIIMH npaBo 6e3MblTHo npoBo3HTb K MocKBe <<KopM

CBOii>>
73.
3KCnenHnHRrJIeneHcKoTo
MOHacTblpH
ocBo60)KnaJIaCb OT MEITa, FIBKII, MOCTOBmIIHbl H nPyrIIx nOmJTIIH nPMI
yCJIoBHH nPoBO3a TOBaPoBくHe Ha nPOma)Ky> B OXHoM EOIIIa-

HIIKe IIJTII Ha lO Bo3ax 74. CTporo perJIaMeHTIIpoBaJIIIcb npogP3 H 3aliynKa ToBapoB ycTb-mexoHcKHM MoHacTblpeM 75.

ppaBna,
E巾PeMOBy
MOHaCTblPIO
Pa3PemaJIOCb
6e3MbITHO
H
OeCTaMO'>KeHHO KynHTbHnPOⅡaTbTOBap《Ha MOHaCTblPCKOh

ganaC>' 6e3 KaKIIX-JIm60 KoHKpeTHbIx OrPaHmqeHIIi 76.

Bo6JIacTHcyXe6HoroIIMMyHHTeTanpaBHTeJIbcTBomyiicKIIX nPOnOJI)KaJIO COKPamellIIe npHBIIJIGrIM MOHaCTblPeih II

MIITPonoJIHIIbero noMa. B rpaMoTax 1538-1540 rr・H3 IopHc瓜ⅢKnHH MoHacThlpeii HcKJIIotlaJIocb o6bllIHo npaBo cyla no
n;ByM B"aM yrOJTOBHblX nPeCTynJIGHmi (mymery6CTBO H Pa3一

69C・my M AIfp B. MaTepHaJIbl JJIFT HcToI)HII Pfl3aHcKoro KpaH, Bbln. l.
PH3aHb，1898, cTP. 11, Nb 2

70 K. ･. KaJIaimoBH印.HcToPHqecKoe II TOnorPa"wecKOe omIcaHHe
MpHacTblpH cBRToro IIyXoTBopna
M・, 1837, CTP、108-1 10.

HIIKoJIaFI,

IITo

Ha

nemHome.

21 mOIIH, Co6p･pyKonIIcHLTx KHIIr, Nb 41, :JT. 1-1 06.
72 AA9, T. I, M I91･

73<BoJIoToIIcKIIeenapxHaJTbHhleBeXoMocTm》,1870,nplI6aBJIeHIIeKNb3,
cTp. 103­1 04.

ZA JIOIIH Co6p. aKToB JIo 1613 r" Nb l/130.
75 rBJI, PVMHRn. KH. 53, JTm. 10-13.

76 A M B p o c H ii. yKa3. cozI., q. 1V, cTp. 89-95.
342

60iicno皿可HbIM)77.ToJTbKoBrpaMoTeHOcH巾O-BOJIOKOJIaM･
cKoMVMoHacTEIPIoHaceJTo｡aycToByropy"̲II，nO-BHⅡHMO･
MV,
ご 5 rpaMoTe tIynpBy MoHacTHpIg MapTal539 n Ha ceJIo
ソ

ユ

JIimHTIIiIO KOJIOMeHCkOrO ye3na 79 Cyne6Hbl# IIMMyHIITeT

yTBep>KnaJIcH<<onpIIqbXymery6cTBa>.yqacTIIJIIIcbcJIy"!

MMiim3PyKIiMMyIfm6TqBBPyKmHaMCcWKOBpa36929
k

nejlonymery6cTBeTaTb6e
H
CnoJM[IHI,IMⅡPaBHTeJIbCTBO
か

PemmJIOCb
nPOBeCTm
9TO
OrPaHmqeHme
B
9TIIgmeHIIIi̲MeJIW,

im"TbqlioBJMHTeJIbHbli(MoHacTHpgikToTeMcKorog巾一

66mOsa80,B:namIMIIpcKoroCnaccKoro81,̲BQjIoroXcIproKoMeJybcKor6 82, nepecjIaBcKoro naH"oBa 83. C Hpyroi cTopol

U

Hbl,npaBIITejlbcTbomyficKmx
coneiiCTBoBano..06ecnetIeHIIIQ
⑫

⑫

MOHacTEIPeii-BoTqlIHHIIKOB 3eMe,ⅢbHoit peHTom, nPenleJIBHo
COKDallIa月可HCJIOCPOKOBBbl30B9MOIIaCTblPCKHXI<PeCTbHHB
Be〃如くoKHFT)KecK"CynnoTfl>K6aMcnocTopoHHIIMHJI皿aMH、
⑪

T.aK､皿月KPecTbFIHToTeMcKoro
E巾PeMOB̅aMoHacTbl"84m
MockoBcKofo ycneHcKoro co60pa 85 ycTaHaBJIIIBaJTcH Bcel､oʼ
OnHH CPOK.

myficKIIMHⅡpOBOⅡⅢJIcFIBnOJIHoiMePenPHHmmlloXcyn-

IIoCTH ̅HaCTOFITeJIei Bo BCex neJIaX, KPOMe XyxOBHblx, He MIITPOnOJMTy H aPxHemICKonaM, 4BeJIIIKOMy if"310 Im1I BHCIuIIM
U

K

ilPaBIITeiibcTEeHHbIMqIIHaMSTOIIMeJIO60JIbmOe3HaqeIilie
nJ1H orPaHIfqelllM BJIacTHⅡePKBH II, BO3MO>KHO, "HJTOCB OII-

fioi mg npHqIIH pa3PbIBa
HOHH3Ⅱ”叩Hpa3”Ba
Cm”cKHMHHOaca4〕a，KOTOPblH，
c myjicKIIMII Hoaca4)a, KoTopbIji,
④

U

6VEVIIH

HecTFI>KaTeJIeM, np"ep>KIIBa､JIcFI

noJIHTHIIecKoII

H6i<fPIJHbl,
TPe60BaBmei
HeBMemaTeJIbCTBa
cBeTq<Ofi
BJIaCTI[
B
neJIa
nepKBII.
MeponPlIRTI硯nPaBIITeJTBcTBa
B
o6JIacTI1
BoT[IHHHOrO Cyna lI cyXa HaユユyXOBHEIMH巾eOXaJIaMII HeJIb3FI
HeⅡocTaBHTbBc”3bcry6Hoiipe巾opMoH,KoTop”HawaJIa
OPMOi, KOTOpafI Ha

nPOBO皿TbcH
9To
B BpeMFI.
Cyne6Hble
pe巾OPMBI
6bLIIH
Bbl3BaU

HBI o60cTpeHHeM KJIaccoBBIx npoTHBopeumi B pyccKoM rO･
Cynap cTBe .

HTaK, B nePBblhneplIoⅡnpaBJYeHIIH myiicKHx pacnpocTpaH"acb BEmaIIa >KaJ1oBal･IHblx naHHbIx rpaMoT MoHacTbl77 Xn、I,Nb 383, 384, 391, 400, 420.
78 A31,IX,1. 11, Nb 149.

79 TBJI, Co6p. OImP, AKTbT, KapToH 35,̲g. 6J1. 49, JVb 77.
80 AMBDOclIii.yKa3・coII.、LI. 1V, cTp. 89-95.

6! JTOHII, Co6D. roJYoBIIHa, Nb 58.
82 A MB P O C H ii. yKa3. COII･, [1･ 111･ M.､ 1811, cTp. 283-286.
83B.rn06POHPaBOB. yKa3・COtl., "HJY., CTP. 21-22, Nl1 5.
84 AMBpocII|ii・yKa3・coKI., I1. 1V, cTI). 89-95.
85 r. H. .m M e .II e B. H3 IIcTopIM MocKoBcKoro ycneHcKoro co60Pa. M・軍
1908-”wl,CTP､157-158' (VKa3aJIa JI. H.Ⅵ"IIa} .
34忽

EflM KaK Ha CeJIbCKHe, TaK II Ha rOPOnCKHe
BJIalleHIIF1.
ム
TaPxaHHblerpaMoTblB1538-l540rr・noJIyIIHJIH,noMHMoBo-

JIOKOJIgMcKOrO MgliaCTblPH, ̲HeKOTOPble CeBePHble KOPnOPa-

HIIII: ToTeMcKmii E｡peMoB, CoJIoBemKmii, rJIeneHcKIIii MoHicU

TblPH.nOHBJIe"eaTHXrPaMoTcJIenyeTPacCMaTPIIBaTbBcBeTenOⅡblToKmy曲cKHx3aPyIIHTbcH
no皿ep>KKOh巾eOmaJIOB
HoBropo" li npIIJIeraBmHXK HeMy ye310B: JIbroTHiIMii rpa人

MoTaMmmyiicKHenblTaJImcbnpHBJIEIIbKce6eBaToBpgMH
MoHacTblplI, HMeBmHe BoTqHHbl B nepecJIaBJIb-3aJIeccKOM Ii

Cy3XaJIbcKoMye3Xax,I､,nemyicKHe̅noJIb30BaJIHcboco6bIM
苧
BJIIIHHIfeM・H3TPex)KaJIOBaHHblXHeCyⅡHMblX
rPaMOT,BblnaHHblx B TerlGHHe PacCMOTPeHHOrO nePlIOna CBeTCKHM巾eOnaJIaM，瓜Be oTHocHTcH To)Ke x paiioHy nepecJIaBJIH-3aJIecU

CKOrO86HcOCe皿erocHIIMPaXoHe]Ka87(oIHarpaMoTa
KacaJIacb 3eMeJIb B HorpaHIIKIHoM TyJIbcKoM ye3n<e) 88.
写

3. LIMMyHIITeTHaH Ho入ⅢT政Ka
n p a B M I Te J l b C T B a K H H 3 H Ⅲ 、 の． B e 入 B c Ko r o

HatIaBmaFIE3(;JIeTal540r.rJIyxafl60pb6aMe)Knlynpa-

BIITeJIbcTBoM myiicKIIx H BblnymeHHblM H3 9aToKIeH" I<HHdeM

BeJIbcKI1y
nPIIBeJIa
K
CBOeO6Pa3HOi
HeiiTPa皿3anHH
B
IIMMy直HTeTHoH noJIHTHKe: nocJIe HIoHH H ,mo neKa6" 1 540 r. BbI"[IaLPaMoT npIIocTaHoBIIJTacb. C XeKa6" 1540 no 2 flHBa-

" ̲1542 r. y BJIaCTH CTOHJIo nPa"TeJIbcTBO KHJI3H
H.｡BeJIbCKOrO.nOHaCnOmJIOCPaBilHTeJIbHOMaJIOHMMyHHTeTHbIxrPaMOT3TOrOBPeMeHH：12>KaJIOBaHHbIX（O且HaH3

HIIx He coxpaHIIJIacb) H 5 yKa3Hblx, oIHa rpaMoTa, BbmaHHaH no nPaBHTeJIbcTBeHHoMy yKa3ynHCnaMH, H OXHa­瓜BO-

PenKIIM.
11
>KaJIOBaHHblxrPaMoT6blJIHBblnaHH且yXOBHblM
巾eOnaJIaM,
O皿a-BJIa皿MHPCKIIM
60PTHIIKaM.
nJIFInOJIIITHKIInPaBHTeJIBCTBaH.①、BeJIbcKoroxapaKTepHa ropa3no 66JIbmaH cnep>KaHHocTb B npeXoCTaBJIEH"
nonaTH.gnPHBIIJIer", qeM sTo Ha6JIIoXaJIocb B nePHoⅡⅡpa-

BJIeHHHmy#cKIIx.KpynHbleJIbrGTbly"JIocbnoJIy[iHTbnmllb

rPaMoTIIHKaM, B HenOCpeXcTBeHHOii nOⅡⅡeP>KKe KoToPDIx
"]KJaJIocb npaBPITeJIbcTBo KHH3H BeJIbcKoro B 60pb6e c

myicKIIMH、1 neKa6pH 1540 r、6BIJIa BbmaHa TaPxaHHo86 4<AKTbl IICTOPII[IeCKIIe, OnIICaHIIbleル1. M. KaTaeBbIM II A
BblM", M 1/25.

87 nPn, Bbm. 1V, cTP・121-122.
88 |<AKTbl IOmKoBa>;.M 136.
344

K. I<a6aHO-

c6poIIHaH rpaMoTa 60pTHHKaM BoJIocTH TaJImH BJIa""IIpcKOro Ve3Xa 89. BoJIocTb Haxo"JIacb B6JIII311 BJIaZeHHhrop6aTblx H皿yiicKHx. H3BecTHo, IITo B I541 r. 3a H. B・my曲-

cKOrO CTOHJIII HOBrOPo且uH <<BCeM rOPoIoM>, a TecHaH cBfl3b

myiicKIIx B STOT nePlIOX C HOBrOPOnCKIIM aPxHenHcKOIIOM

MaKaplIeM He nonJIe>KIIT coMHeHHIo. B cJIo)KHBmeiicH o6CTaHoBKe li. Q BeJIbcKOMy 6blJIo Ba>KHo yKPemITb cBOH
no3HUHH B HoBropoXcKoii 3eMJIe II npHJIeraBmlIx K Hen

ye3'max, a TaK)Ke :Bo BJIa,mMHpo-Cy3naJIbcKoii 3eMJIe.
y)Ke B HHBape l541 r. npaBIITeJIEcTBo HocJIaJIo rp8MoTy
6eJIo3epcKoMy HaMecTHIIKy H.①､BopoHUoBy c 3anpe皿eHHeM
HapymaTb HecyXIIMylo rpaMoTy BoJIoroncKoMy epanoHToBy MoHacTBIp}o, B KoTopoi cyne6HblhHMMyHIITeT CaHKUIIOHH-

pbBaJIcH<<onpHLIbnymery6cTBa)> 90.HoyKa3HaHrpaMoTa
He ToJIbKo HoITBep]KnaJIa nplIBIIJIerHIo,

3a(pHKcHpoBaHHylo

E rpaMoTe BacIIJIIiH III ePanoHToBy MoHacTblplo 91. OHa
e皿e 6OJIbme OrPaHHwHBaJIa nOJIHOMOIIHfI HaMeCTHKKa: y Hero

oTHIIMaJIOcbnP2BoyulacTBoBaTbBCMecHoMcyne92.HHCTHTyT
cMeCHOrO cyna B 6eJIO3ePCKHX BOTIIIIHax ePanOHTOBa MOHa-

〔､TblPH,BⅢ瓜HMo,Boo6meJIHKBI皿HpoBaJIcFI.Conep>KaB皿aHc兜
B rpaMoTe BacIIJIIIH III cTaTbH o Bbl30Be MoHacTblpcKIIx
KPecTbHH OnHH Pa3 B rony B BeJIHKOKHFI)KecKIIii cyX B CJIytlaHx, ecJIII Ha HIIx BO3bMyT

nPlIcTaBa,

pacnpoCTpaHFIJIaCb

'1enepb, no Bceii BepoHTHocTII, Ha TH>K6bl He ToJIbKo c JIHIIaMII, HenOnCylHblMII IIaMeCTHIIKy, HO H c JIIO"MH, IIaxO"B-

mmMIIcH nPe)KXe B ero BeXeHHII. CJIenoBaTeJIbHo, ry6HaH
Pe｡oPMa PemHTeJIbHo orPaHIIIIHJIa nPaBa HaMGCTHIIKOB KaK
B OTHOmeHHⅡⅡocanCKoTo II IIePHocomHorO HaceJIeHIIH, TaK II
B o T H o m e H H H K D e c T b H H I I M M V H I I Te T H b I x B o T ' I I I H .
冬

HanpmKellHblM noJIo>KeHIIGM B HoBroPone o6ycJIoBJIHBaJIHcb nonblTKII nPaBIITeJIbCTBa UeHoii JIIo6blX yCTynOK cKJIOHIITb Ha CBOIO CTOPoHy KPynHeimIIx HOBrOPOXCKJIX巾eOna JIoB. C sToii lleJIblo B HaIIaJIe beBpaJIH 1541 r. 6bIJ1a BblnaHa
>KaJIoBaHHaHrpaMoTaCoJ1oBenKoMyMoHacTblploHa6e3MblTHHhH6ecTaMci>KeHHblii npoBo3 6000 nynoB coJIII. MoHacTblpb
noJYyIIHJI npaBo cynlITb cBoIIx JIIoneii H KpecTbflHくBo BceM浄．
89 rABO,巾. 575, Nb l{ JIn. 19-20 06.; UrHA, * 834, om 3, Nb 1920,
JJI. 65-66.

90 AA3, T. 1, Nb 193, cTp..170.
9' Xn, I, Nb 276.
92 HaMecTHI'IKy npeⅡⅡHCI〕旧aJ10cb xo八mTbくO BCeM･ ITO TOMy, KaK B IIX

lKaJIOBaHHOii rPaMOTe nHCaHo B HeCym,IMO尚ァOnPHIIL cMeCHOrO Cyna".
345

CneUlIaJIbHo oroBaPHBaJIacb HenoncyXHocTb lIryMeHa H 6paTHII HOBrOPoIcKOMy aPXIienHCKOny (a HM 6blJ] 6JIII3KHii K

myicKIIM MaKap") <<HH B [IeM, onpII[Ib nyxoBHoro neJIa), 93.
B MapTe l541 r. npaBHTeJIbcTBo BblnaJIo >KaJIoBaHHylo
rpaMoTy EB｡HMbeBoii nycTbIHII Ha ee BoJIoroJcKHe II ycTIo>K④

P

cKHe BoTIIHHbI, T. e. omITb-TaKII Ha 3eMJIH, 6JIH3KIIe K HoB-

rOPOmy.yCTIO)KcKHeBJIanieHIMFInyCTblHIIOcBO60>KnaJIMCb3a
onPeneJIeHHblii O6POK, KOTOPbl# KOPnOPalIIIH PPJI)KHa 6blJIa

BbmJIaIIIIBaTb <B BOHOcTb)": 4<A n<aBaTHⅢM c Tex UepeBeHb M
nOIIIIHKOB B BOJIO｣cTb cTaPOcTaM II COTHKIIM II BCeM KPecTbR-

HoM MoJIbcKHe BoJIocTH o6poKoM 3 rony Ha ron 3a naHb lI 3a
BOJIOCTeJIIIH KOPM II 3an月THO H 3a BCe nOmJIIIHbI nO ZIeCHTll

aJITblH> 94. TaKIIM o6pa30M, npH Bcei meXpocTH no)KaJIoBawP

四

1-IbIx nycTblHH nPHBHJIerHH nPaB｝ITeJIbCTBO yIIMTblBaJIO FI Im-

TepecbI IIepHoTo THrJIoro Mmpa. OvleBHIHo, MoHaxaM HanJIe>KaJIo TaK>Ke

nJIaTHTb

B

BeJIHKoKHH)KecKVIo
ジ

Ka3HV

HMcKHe

ン

neHbrlI, ocBo60>KneHIIH oT KoTopblx B rpaMoTe HeT. B巾eBpaJIe - MapTe l 54 1 r. >KaJIoBaHHble rpaMoTbl 6blJIH BbmaHbl
eme XByM ceBel]HblM MoHacTblpHM: HpocJTaBcKoMy ToJIr-

cKoMy (py)KHaH) 95 II HpeHcKoMy HHKoJIbcKoMy (Hecy皿MaH
II c ocBo60>KXeHIIeM BapHIm oT o6poKa) "
Ⅲ3 npyrHx >KaJIoBaHHBIx rpaMoT, noJIyIIeHHblx B 1541 r.
myxOBHbIMH KOPnOPaUlIHMH, 31-IaIIIITeJIbHLIii HHTePeC nPemCTaBJIHeT JIbrOTHaH I,PaMoTa, BbmaHHaH B oKTH6pe l541 r.

BJIanlIMIIpcKoMy Po>KnecTBeHcKoMy MoHacTblplo. O6LeKToM
nO>KaJIOBaHIIH HBJIHJIOCb B Hei CeJIbUO, KoTOPOe <<3anycTeJIO..．

JIeT31Ba,mnaTb,XOPOMHeT,HnOJTHJIeCOM3apOCJIH>97．BHHMaHIIe Ha 9TO XaBHO 3anyCTeBmee ceJIO 6blJIO O6PameHO
oceHblo 1541 r. He cJIyIIaiHo. y>Ke c JIeTa l541 r. Bo BJIamiMHPcKOM ye3ne HaxoⅡHJTCH c Bo|iiCKaMH KHH3b HB・Bac. my#-

cKHii, nOcJIaHHblii cIOna nO瓜Ⅱpem'oToM o6opoHI､I pyccKIIx
rpaHHⅡoT TaTap. npaBHTeJTbcTBo H. ｡ BeJIbcKoro| nyTeM
nPenOCTaBJIeHHH rJIaBHeiimHx nOnaTHblX JIbrOT .OIHOMy H3
BImHblx BJIaⅡHMIfPcKHx MOHaCTblpeii cTPeMIwIOcb He XOnycTHTb c6JIII>KeHIIH KHR3H myicKoTo c MecTHblMH巾eOnaJ1 aMH
Ha noIIBe O6mero HenPBOJIbCTBa XeiicTBIIHMm叩aBHTeJ1bcTBa．

93 HOCH巾e i. yKa3. COIJ.,T､111, cTp. 3-7.
94 UrAnA, rK3 no Bonome, Nb ll/2582.

95 <<HPOCJYaBcKMe enaPxIIa､mbHIJie lle几oMocTII>, 1897, IIacTb lIGo(1)11IIIIaJIbHa", M 10 (urﾙIA,巾. 83.1、on. 3, Nb 1916, JJI. 317 06.-318､rp l44}̲
96 JTOHH, Konn. 47, 0n, 2, Nb 4.
97 UrAnA, rKa no Bna"MHpy, Nb l7/1794.
34侭

TeppHTopmaJlbHoe pacnpeneJIeHIIe rpaMoT HQKa3blBaeT,

[ITo B "BaPe - MapTe l541 r. Hali60JIbmyIo o3a60qegHocTb
nPaBIITeJIbcTBaBbl3blBa皿6blBmHeceBepHbIeyXeJILI(BoJIor", BeJIoo3epo) 98, HoBropon, nBIIHa, ycTIorWj PH3aHb 100,
B anPeJIe --MyPOMCK" 101 m ̲ MOCKOBC"ii 102 ye3", B
HIoHe= BaJIaxIia II HIDKHIIit HoBroponl 103, B oKTH6pe -

BJIaⅡHMIIpcKIIi ye3X 104, B HpH6pe­ⅡeKa6pe - mllpoK"

KpyfTepPmTopHii;Be)Ke""iBepjt,PQcToB105,Bono"a!06,

meCJI"JIb-3aJgCCKmi
107,
BaJIaXHa
'08,
Bo3MO)KHO,
Ce2qyxoi 109. Oco6eHIi6 MHoro rpaMoT npHxo"TcH Ha nleKa6pb,
KOrna nPaBHTeJIbcTBO H. m. BeJIbCKOrO, IIyBCTByH HenPOIIHOCTI)

CBOero

HoJIO>KeHHfI,

CTPeMHJIoCI,

3apyqIITbcfI

noll-

八ep>KKoii p皿a nyxoBHblx ｡eO"JIOB
O6mHe npIIHIIImbI IIMMyHI1TeTHoii noJIIITHKII B IIePlIOX

nPaBJIeHHHK"3H
BeJIbCKOrO
XaPaKTePm3yIoTCHBWaCTl!
n6XaTHOrOHMMyHIITeTa
no>KaJIOEaHIIeM
BPeMeHHOii!'0HmI
HeioJIHoit ! ' ! cB660"I oT rocynapcTBeHHbIX HaJIoroB; B o6-

JTacTII cyne6Horo HMMyHIITeTa - 06"HEIM orpallIIIIeHIieM
BOTIIIJHHOii lOCTHnIM B meJIax o nylnery6cTBe m pa360e c noJYIIIIHblM 1'2. nJIH PemeHHH TH>K6 c nOcTOPOHHHMH皿uaM W
VCTaHaBJ1HBaJICH OmlH CPOK Bbl30Ba B Be"KOKHFDKeCKIM

byn(113.CynHanlHacToFIT6JIFIWI,KaKHnpHmyiicKIIx,ocTaBAJICfIBPyKaXrCCynaPcTBal'4.

nP aBHTeJIbCTBo H、の、BeJIbCKOrO nOIITII He BbmaBaJIo
MoHaCTblpHM naHHblx, TapxaHHo-o6poIIHblx II TapxaHHBIx
rpaMoT. OT BeJIbcKIIx MoHacTblpH HoJIyIIaJIII, KaK npaBIIJIo,
JIbrOTHble, a He TaPxaHHble rPaMOTbl.

98 Xn、I, Nb 422, 423.
99 TaMンKe, Nb 425, 426.
100 TaM )Ke, Nb 424.
101 TaM >Ke, Nb 427.

lo2 rBJI, Tp. K11.637,Ⅱ几468 06.-470
103 rl4M, naTp., Nb 994.
'04 xn，1, Nb 428.

'05 rBJI, Tp. KH. 519, JIn. 39-40.
106 Xn, I, JVb 431, 432.
107 TaNI JKe, Nb 429.
108 TaM >Ke, Nb 430.
109 TaM ]Ke, Nb 433.
110 TaM ]Ke, Nb 427, 428.
1'1 TaM >Ke, Nb 426,
112 TaM >Ke, JW 426, 429.

ダ

ll3 TaMンKe, Nb 427.

''4 TaM )Ke,Nh 426, 429 H np.
347
1

4．POCT
MMMyHzITeTHLIx
nPlIB皿入er皿H
U

B nepIIoR BToporo npaBJkemm myjicKMx

3FIHBapH1542r.naJIonpaBHTeJIbcTBoKHH3HBeJIbcKoro.

EJa｡PTbB
grPaHeBHQPb3ai(BaTHJIa
rPynnIIPOBKa
KHR3eII
nlYiicKIIX ¥5 MaQTe ̲ !542 n 6bIJI cBe" c MmpOnom"
⑪

U

KaqJegllbl IIoacab. MHTpono皿IToM cTaJI 6@mli3K" K mviiU

cKHM MaKap".
U

ヅ

ユ

OT
BToporo
nepHoJa
npaBJIeHI呪myiiCKIIX,
HaIIaB皿erocH

f̲3 """ 1542 r., nocJie naneHHfI IipaBfT6JIbcTBa im"

II,QBeJIbCKOrO,H IJIHBmeroCHユ0 29 XeKa6pH 1543 r.,

ユomJIo 20 >KaJIoBaHHblx H 7 yKa3HblX mMMVHHTeTHbI)t
BeJIHKoKHfl>KecKIIx rPaMoT. K 9ToMy [IIIcJIy Hano hpH6aBIITb
具
TPII HeCOxPaHHBmmec" >KaJIOBaHHble rPaMOTbI, o"y rPaMOTy, BbmaHIIylO HHcnaMII, II XBe-瓜BOPenKHMH (o皿aH3HHX
To>Ke Je coxpaHmJIacb) . Bcero, cJIeXoBaTeJIbHo; HacqIITbIBa-

eTcH33rpaMoTbl、rpaMoTbl
KacaJIHcb
BJIaⅡeHHH旦yxoBHbIx
｡eolaJIOB, JIHmb o皿ayKa3HaHl､PaMoTaIIMeJIaBB皿y
U

3eMJIH cBeTCKIIX巾eOnaJIOB.

JJIHHMMyHHTeTHOHnoJIHTHKIImyitcKHx
l542r.xapaKU

A

TePHa e皿e HeKpToPaH HCKJIIoIIHTeJIbHocTb B HPenPcTaBJIeHHII npHBHJIerHHMoHacTblpflM. TaK, oco6blM HoKpoBHTeJIbCTBoM nPaBHJeJIbCTBa nOJIb30BaJIIIcb KOPnOPaU", PaCnoU

JXp)KeHHble B6JIII3m polIoBoro rHe34a myii6KIIx, "aioHe
Cy3naJIH,m,B"IIMo,m3"BHacBH3aHHbIe6mv曲cKHMH3Koご
HO MIJLIecKII MHHⅡoJIHTH[IegmMH y3aMH. B IIIoHe H HoH6pe

1542 E Bo BIIa"MHp II B Cy3XaJIL 6bIJIH nocJIaIiLI yKa3"6

rPaMOTbl, nPenmICblBaB皿IIe rOPOnoBblM nPHKa3IIIiKaM He

B31IMaTI) HMCKHe neHbrlI, nOco皿HblX JIIOne曲II He TPe60BaTb
HcnoJIHgIIIH 3eJIemHom noBIIHHocTH c KpecTbHH Cy3naJIbU

U

cKoronoKpoBcKoroXeBHIlberoMoHacTI3IpH !'ar"MoTb!
cCblJIaJIHCb Ha KaKylO-TO<Hamy>D IKaJIoBaHHylO TaPXaHHylO

rpaMoTy, Bo3Mo>KHo, BblnaHHyIo eme B 1539-1540 rr.

B l543 r. ocBo60>KneHIIe iloHacTblpeii oT npFIMbIx H Koc-

BeHHbIx
|
HaJIoroBnplio6peJIQPoJIeemHpoK"pa3MaxCpe⑥

IHHMMyHIITeTHblxaKToBl543r.,oTHocHmHXCFIKMOIIaCTblPcKHM ceJIaM II nlePeBHFIM, IIMelOTcfI, HOMHMO HeCy"Mblx,

TaPxaHIIble, 06eJIbHble II JIbrOTHble rPaMoTbl･Kypc Ha yBeJIHIIeHHe nomar"Ix nPHBHJIerHiiMOHaCTblPeH，Pa3BHBaBmHHJIH11eHHeⅡo瓜aTHblxHPHBHJIerHH
MOHaCTblpeii, Pa3BIIBaBm"”

u

cH c BecHbl l543 r., JocTHr anoreH JIeToM, k6ma 6blJIH BblXaHbl >KaJIoBaHHble rpaMoTbl
及aHbl〉KaJIoBaHHble
rpaMoTbl

KPynHeiimHM
KpyⅡHeHmHM 瓜VxoBHblM
myxoBHblM KOPKop』

|15 <AKTbl ̲HCTDp""KHe, omlcaHHbre H M. KaTaeBblM H A K. Ka6aHoBblM>, M I/26,1 /27̲

348

rioPaUnfIM - TPo皿e-CeprIIeBy H Hocm申o-B oJIoKoJI a McKoM)'

MoHacTblpJIM. B MapTe l543 r. 06eJIbHyIo rpaMoTy noJIyIIIM
MocKoBcKIIii BoroFIBJIeHcKIIii MoHacTbIpb l '6. B cBoeii HM"
U
ノ

MyHIITeTHOH IIacTII 3Ta rPaMOTa neJIHKOM KOmiPOBaJIa

(3a

HcKJIIoIIeHHeM IIeKoTopblx Xo6aBJIeHHii K cyne6HoMy pa34eJIy) rpaMoTy BoroHBJIeHcKoMy MoHacTblplo l51 1 r. 117: ocBo602K,meHIie oT IBopUoBo-KHmKecKIIx HoBIIHIIocTeii coLIeTaU

JIOCb B HeH c OTPmⅡaHmeM

nPaBa

MoHaCTbIPCKOrO

nHTHa.

B ToM )Ke MecHUe npaBHTeJIbcTBo BblmaJIoンK aJI oB a|HHylo
rpaMoTy c 60JIee cyUecTBeHHblMII npHBHJIerIIHMII TpoI皿KOMy MaXpII皿CKOMy MOllaC･rblPlo Ha ero cTal)IIHI-Ioe ceJIbUo
3eJIeHUblHo nepecJIaBcKoro ye3na ''8. no rpaMoTe l506 r.
3eJIeHUblHo HoJIb30BaJIocb ToJIbKo cyne6HblMH npIIBIIJIerHFI-

MH 119. rpaMoTa l543 r. npenPcTaBHJIa 3ToMy ceJIy ocBo60IKn e H H e O T n a H H , M b l Ta , Ta M r I I H n P y r H x n O m J I H H H n o B H H H O -

cTeik. OBIHaKo HMcKIIe pheHbrli, HocomHafl cJIy)K6a lI ropoIo〆

BOe neJIO He OblJIH B IIIICJIe nomJIHII, ynJIaTa HJIH IIcHoJIIIeHlie

KoTopblx oTMeHHJIHcb. no MapToBcKoii rpaMoTe l543 r. BoT[IIIHbl noKpoBcKoro Cy3naJIbcKoro MoHacTblpH ocBo60>K4aJIHCb OT HMcKIIX XeHer, nOco皿HO向CJIy>K6bl H nOn(aTeit '20.
B HIoHe l543 n HocII*o-BoJIoKoJIaMcKHii MoHacTbll)1,
HOJIyIIIIJI HC,KJIIO1IHTeJIbHOmeXPylo TaPxaHHylO rPaMOTy, Oc-

Bo60>KIaBmyIo ero 3eMJIII B BoJIoUKoM, Py3cKqM H TBepcKoM ye3Jax oT JaHH, FIMcKIIX XeHer, nOcO皿HOik CJIy>K6bl, rOU

P o P P B O r O n e J I a , Ta M r m , M b l Ta H Ⅱ P y r K x n o n a Te H H n O B H H -

HOCTeii l21．B neKa6pe l543 r. CIIMoHoB MoHacTbIPb lloZI
6JI aroBH瓜HblM nPenJIoroM HoCTPOiiKH IlePKBII BbInPocIIJI ce6e )KaJIoBaIIHylo rpaMoTy. OHa npenocTaBJIHJIa MoHacTblpIo
npaBO B TeIIeHHe 4Byx

JIeT

He nJIaTIITb

HHKaKHx rOCyXap-

cTBeHHblX HaJIOroB H nOmJIHH CO BCei BOTqHHbl '22. nO rPaMoTe l542/43 r・C aBBo-CTopo)KeBcKII曲MoHacTblPb noJIy[IIIJI
npaBo He cTaBIITb llaMecTHHIIIIji niBop B 3BeHHropoXe '23.
ll6 UrIIA, KHIIra Komih Bor"1BJIeHcKoro M-pFI, JIJ1.

16 06．­19

(yKa3a.m

C. H. BaJIK) .

117 HIIKoⅡHM. OmlcaHIIe MocKoBcKoro BoroFIBJIGHcKoro MoHacTbIpFI
M., 1877, cTp. 9-11.

ll8 rnB, Co6P・aKToB II rpaMoT, JYb l-124.
119 JIeOHH瓜． MaxpII皿CKII# MOHaCTblPb.­<qTeHHH OIinP>, 1878,
KH、3, cTp. 31-32, Nb 6.
'20 AH, T. 11, JVb 73.
121 Ao3HX, q. 11，M 171.

122 TMM, CIIM. KH: 58, no MocKBe JYb 62, JIJ1. 239 06.- 240 06.
123 UrAHA, d). 1 199, JYb 32, J1. 13 06.; 06 aHaJIorlIIIHoM Ho>KaJIoBaHIIM
TpoIme-CeprHeBy MoHacTblplo cM. Xn, I, Nb 458.
千

349

HoecJIHJIbroTblHaMoHacTblPcKHeceJIalInepeBHH3HaqjjTeJIbHO BaPbmPOBaJIIICb, OTJIIIIIaHCb npyr oT XPyra KaK

OO'IJeMOM, TaKⅡ且OJIroCPOLIHOcTblO, TO nPIIBHJIerHH, KaCaB-

mHeCH rOPOIcKIIx IBOP|OB Pa3Hblx MoHacTblpeii, HMeIoT

Me>KJIy co60ii 6oJIb皿He 'IepTbl |cxoIcTBa. B Hecy,瓜HMoii rPaMoTe l 542/43 r. KoMeJIbcKoMy MoHacTblpIo Ha mbIIHHKH e6Tb
CneUliaJIbHaJI CTaTbH, noCBH皿eHHaH HMMyHHTeTy MOHaCTblP-

cKoro ,IBopa B BoJIome:<ⅢC [IePHblMH JIIOn<bMH HM (T. e.
MoHaCTblpCKIIM JII0"M- C. K) B THrJIo He THHyTII HH-

IIeM>124．TaKIIMo6pa30M,HecymiMafl|rl]aMoTa3aKpenJI凡Ⅲa
HoJIHylO nOnaTHyIO H30JIIIPoBaHHocTb MOHacTblPCKOro nBO-

pa oT Hocana. B Mae l543 r. MypoMcKHM roponpBblM npHKa3IIHKaM 6blJIo BeJIGHo oTBecTII BJIan<HMHpcKoMy Po>KneCTBeHcKoMy MoHacTbIPlOくMecTO HOPo)KHee HeO6POIIHOG H
HeTHMOe Ha npHe3n>> 125.

B IByx )KaJIoBaHIIblx rpaMoTax, BbuaHHblX B aBrycTe H
oKTH6pe l543 r. TpoIIUe-CeprHeBy MoHacTblPIo Ha erO nBoPbl, CoPleP>KaJIOcb oCBo60訊旦eHHe oT Bcex OCHoBHblxno3eMeJIbHblx HaJIoroB: 4aHH, HMcKHx neHer, HocomHoih cJIy)K6bl,
nocOmHorO KOPMa H BCHKHx 3eMCKIIx nOBHHHoCTeii 126.

CJIe,npBaTe&nbHo, npaBIITeJIbcTBo myiicKIIx npeBpamaJIo
MoHacTblpcKIIe nBopbl B 6eJIDIe w<Heo6poIIHbIe H HeTHrJIble》
MecTa,

nPoTHBOIIOCTaB｡mFI

IIx IIePHOMy noCaXCKOMy

MHPy.

STOCOOTBeTCTBOBaJIOo6meii
JI|HHHHⅡoJIHTHKII
myicKHx,
HanPaBJIeHHOii Ha TeCHOe C6JIH>KeHHe c BJIHHTeJILHblMII MOHaCTbl"MH IIyTeM nPenPCTaBJIeHHFI IIM mllPoKHx HOXaTHblX

nPHBIIJIermii 127.

B oTHomeHIIII npaBHTeJIbcTBa K cyXe6HoMy IIMMyHHTeTy
He ynaeTcH o6Hapy>KHTb HIIrlerO npHHUIImlaJIbHo HoBoro. H3
IopHcniHKUlIH rpaMoTIIHKoBIIcKJIIoIIaJIHcb o6blIIHo JBe pa3HoBHIHOCTHnpecTymleHHii l28. ToJIbKo y KoMeJIbcKoro MoHaCTIJIPH, JIo nPHMePy rPaMoTbl, Ho)KaJIoBaHHoii eMy B

1539 r. ]29, oTHHMaJIocb npaBo cy" H B neJIax o TaTb6e c
nom1'IHblM130・BI543r.Mo)KHoHa6JIIo,ⅡiaTbCKoPeeHeKOTopoe yBeJIHIIeHHe cyne6Horo HMMyHHTeTa MoHacTblpeir. He
１
ｌ
Ｔ
４
０
Ⅱ
八
○
Ⅱ
△

４Xn, I, M 438.
２
５ Ul̅AIA, rKa no MypoMy, JYb 8/7740.
２
６
２
Xn, I, Nb 455, 457.
２
７

Ha"ny c HMMy|HIITeTHblMH npHBHJIel､HHMH, Bbl"BaJIacb pyra (JAH,
T・I, M 33; rnB, nor皿. 1911, nm. 1-2 06.).
１
２８ rnB, Co6p. aKToB I,I rpaMoT, JVb l-l23; AAS, T. I, Nb 200.
１
２９
A M B p o c II ji. yKa3. coKI., q. 111, cTp. 283-286.
Ｉ
３０
TaM )Ke, c'rp. 286-295.

350

roBopH y>Ke o6 HocII4)o-BoJIoKoJIaMcKoM MoHacTbipe, loplil-

ユHKIiIMKoToporo661JIa3aKpenJIeHa<<9npliqbnymery6;

ʼ

CTBa>, Cy皿ecTBeHHo PaCmHPHJIIIcb cyne6Hble nPaBa TaKOII

CPaBHHTeJIbHO
MeJIKO曲旦yxOBHOih
KoPnOPaⅡⅢH,
KaK
TpoImK"MaxPHmCK"MOHaCTblPb.rPaMOTa3TOMyMOHaCTblPI9
1506 r. Ha

ceJIo

3eqJIeHmblHo

H3blMaJIa

II3

MoHacTblpcKoII

IopIIcIHKUlIII neJIa o nymery6cTBe II pa360e c noJIHIIHYM.

rPaMoTa
l543rnepenaBajiaBpyKKHaMecTHIiKoBpa360P
Tfl>K6JIH皿bnOBOnPOCaMnymery6CTBa.

npaBIITeJIbcTBoM myiicKHx Ha3HaIIaJIcH o6blIIHo oJJIH
cPoK HBKIi B BeJIIIKOKHH>KecKIIii cyJI KpecTb", npHIIMJIe>KaBmHx HMMyHHcTaM ｣31, 3a HcKJIIoKIeHHeM IIocII｡o-BoJIoKOJIaMcKOrOMOHaCTblPH,KpeCrbHHeKOTOPOroIIoTPa叫皿I【
Bbl3blBaJIHCbBCy旦只Ba班,mbl.nOnlcynHOcTbHaCTOHTeJIenBeJIHKOMy KHH310 H erO nOBePe"blM JIH"M OcTaBaJIacb BO

BTOPOn
nePHOユnP
aBJIeH四町前CKIIx
OIHHM
H3
HenOKOJIe6HMblXnPHHⅡHnOBBHyTPeHHemⅡoJIHTHKII.ToJIbKoBrPaMoTe HocII｡o-BoJIoKoJIaMcKoMy MoHacTblpIo, KaK H&B rPa-

MOTax,
no>KaJIOBaHHblX
eMy
PaHee,
3TOT
nPlIH皿nHb6blJI
c｡opMyJIIIpoBaIL npaBHTeJIbcTBo myicKHx, pacmlIpHH noJaTHOM IIMMyHHTeT, OnlHOBPeMeHHO CTPeMIIJIOcb nOCTaBHTb
U

,n;yxOBHble KoPnoPaUHHⅡOJI CBOH KOHTPOJIb.

Bo BTopoii nePHo瓜nP aBJIeHHH皿yikcKIIx npo,npJDKaJIacb
HaqaTaH HMK eme B l538-1540 rr. BblnaIIa naHHblx H Tap-

xaHHblxrpaMoTHaceJIbcKIfeHropoJIcKHe3eMJIH.BuHcJIo
MoHacTblpeir,
np61IBmHxCH
OCBO60)KneHIm
CBOIIX
BJIaneHHii
OT ocHOBHblX HaJIOrOB HnOBHHHOCTehⅡPⅢⅡOcPenICTBe TaP-

xaHHblx II yKa3Hblx rPaMOT, BOmJIH rJIaBHIJwl O6Pa30M
KopnopauHH,HaxoJJIBmHecHBCy3naJIbcKoMHⅡepeCJIaBJIb3aJIecCKoM ye3Xax, r,memyiicKIIe, IIbH pO,ⅡPBDIe BOTIIIIHbl

KoHUeHTpmpOBaJImcbBpaiioHemyIIHCy34aJIH,3aBFI3aJIII
BecbMa TecHble aKOHOMH'IeCKIieⅢ ⅡOJIHTH'IeCKHe

cBH3H

C

MeCTHbIMH ｡eomaJIaMH.

EcJIHBnePBbl曲nepHo瓜ⅡpaBJIeHHR皿yiicKHxTaPxaHHble rpaMoTbl HoJIyIIaJIH rJIaBHblM o6pa30M ceBepHble lKop-

nOPaniIH,ano>KajioBaHHHCy3"JIbCKO-nePecJIaBCKHM｡eoJaJIaM prPaHH[IHBa皿Cb JIbrOTHblM|H叩aMOTaMH, TO T Hepb
nOJIO]KeHHe

HecKOJIbKO

H3MeHHJIoCb,

H

B

PFIX BHIHeHmHx

TaPxaHHHKoB BblIBIIHyJIHcb cy3naJIbcKo-nePecJIaBCKIIe MOHaCTblPm.

'3'

Xn, I, Nb 438.
351

Ｉ

5. 1/I3MeHeHWI B HMMyHIITeTHOii nO八HTHKe
B 1544-nepBoii noJIoBIIHe l546 rr.

nocJIe nepeBopoTa,npoBeneHHoro 29 nleKa6pHl 543r.，
K BJIacTH nPH皿J1o 60HPcKoe nPaBHTeJIbcTBO, BO3rハa'BJIHBmee-

cHBopoHUoBHMII・BopoHnPBblnpHHa4JIe>KaJIHKcTaPoMy
MoPKoBcKoMy 60FIpcTBy, oHH Bo3BblcHJIHcb npH BacIIJIHH III

m69mmerocnonBII>KHMKaMH
OLHIIMH3BaikHbIxMeponpH-

HTIIH sTQrO npaBIITeJIbcTBa HBHJIacb opraHH3aUHH BecHoh­

JIeToM1544r.nHCnOBOroOHIICaHIIH,KOTOPOeoxBaTIIJIOMHOrHe Xe34bl pyccKoro rocynapcTBa H 3aTHHyJIocb no l545 r. !32

II3COXPaHHBmHXCHOT3TOrOOⅡHCaHIIHcoTHHⅡMO>KHo
3aKJIIOIIHTb, IITO nieHTeJIbHOCTb nHCnOB |HMeJIa neJIbIO, Bo

BCHKOM CJIyrlae, He 3aKPenJIeHIIe nonaTHblx nPlIBHJIerm曲

IIMMyHHcToB. OnHcblBafl B 1544 r. Cy3XaJIb, BeJIHKoKHH>KecKHe nHcUbl nPHⅡHcgJIH K Hocany cJIo60,my Cnaco-EB｡IIMb-

eBa MOHaCTblPfl 133. BblJIa OIIHCaHa nJIH O6JIOIKeIIHH IIffJIOra-

MH glo601Ka TBepcKoro OTpoKIa MoHacTblpH 134.

HapjmycnonblTKo力nyTeMnHCUOBO向nepenIIcHnocTau

2IITb nOI cBoH

KOHTPOJIb

MOHaCTblPCKOe

3eMJIeBJIaneHHe,

BopoHUoBbl,nonp6Ho
npaBIITeJIbcTBaM
npenmecTBylo皿ero
nePlIOma,

nPaKTIIKOBaJIIi

Pa3"Lly

B

MoHaCTblPH

BOTIIIIH,

KoH｡IIcKoBa"bIx y HX IIoJIHTIIIIecKHx npoTIIBHHKbB. BcKope
Hoc,meKa3HIIAHnpeH皿yitcKorocIIeJIo6IITbeMKBeJIHKoMy
KHH31006paTHJIcHHacToHTeJIbCnaco-EB"MbeBaMoHacTblZ

pH, npOClIBmHkBepHyTb eMy c. neTpoBcKoe, npontaHHoe MoHacTblpeM KHH310 AHnpeIo 3a 900 py6JIe曲. npaBIITeJIbcTBo

MnPBJIeTBopliJIo npocb6y [leJ1o6IITq"a, onHaKo npm aToM
OblJI|Ii yIITeHbI 'II|HTePeCbl rOcynaPeBOii Ka3Hbl, B KOToPyIO

MoHacTbIpb o6H3bIBaJIcH BHecTH 600 py6JIeit, T. e､2/3 CyMMbl,
ymIaqeHHoii AHIpeeM myiMcKIIM 3a kynJIeHHoe ceJIo ]35. TaKHM o6pa30M, npaBHTeJIbcTBo He oTnaJIo, KaK 3To 4eJIaJIH
皿yiicKHe, a baKTIIIIeCKH nPO"JIO Ha JIbrOTHbIX yCJIOBHHX
132 C・nl y Ma KQ B. CoTHmUbI, rpaMoTb[ H 3anImcm, Bbln. 1. M., 1902,
,crl]. 51-74, 1"-137;n.M H JI Io K o B. CnopHbIe Bonpocbl巾HHaHco-

Boii IIQTQp" MocKoBcKoro rocynlapcTBa. Cn6., 1892, cTp. 162; <IITe-

"H OHnP>, 1896, KH. 2, oT且.《MaTePHaJIbl HCToI)HIIeCKIIe>, CTP、4­

̲ 6; AL P y 6 U o B. K MaTepma:maM IJIFI ne1)KoBHoii H 6bIToBoii . HcT,
pJIILTBepcKoro KpaJI B XV-XVI BB. CTapHma, 1905, cTp、17-21;
n.n・C M H p H o B. yKa3. coII., T. I, cTp、106; A3HX, u. 11, Nb 178,
179.

" n n. C M M p H o B. yKa3. coq､, TI, cTp. 106.

'34くIITeH"̲ OWIP>, 1896, KH. 2, oTX. <MaTepHaJIbl HcT|opHIIecKIIe:',
cTp. 4-6.

135 nPn, Bbln、1V, cTp. 107.
352

ceJIoMoHacTblplo.BHIoHel544r.KaJIJI3HHMoHagTblphno-

JIVIIIIJToTnpaBHTeJIbcTBaBKamHHCKOMye3neP・ropo"I皿e
nePeBIHHMH,
c
Haxo瓜ⅢB皿eecFI
<<3a
KHfl3eM
OJIeKcaH"oM
BoPliboBIIIleM rop6aTbIM>, !36, poncTBcHHIIKoM . LIIy""
ご

AH3JIorm[IHoenpm66peTeHlledplJIoc,meJIaHoBl544r、TpoHlle-CePrlieBblM
MoHacTbIpeM
137.
Pa34aIIa3eMeJIbBMOHaCTblpIIHe八OCTHmaⅡpHB'opoH-

ILOBblXmHPOKoro Pa3Maxa. nocJIe ,KPynHbIx HMMylIMTer¥blx

HO>KaJIOB
a,HⅡⅢ,
Ha6JIIOXaB皿HxcH
･nePllO瓜ⅡP
B
aBJIeHIiHmy曲一
U

cKHx, 6POcaeTCFI B rJIa3a 3Ha[皿TeJIbHaH CKynOCTb npenPU

CTaBJIBHHblX MOHaCTblPHM HOnaTllblX nPllBMJIerHH.

IIeplioJI c HHBal)ff1544 1o 2I HIoJIH l546 r., Koma Bo-

poHUoBbI [IMeJII] nPeO"anaHIIe B nPaBliTeJIbcTBeHHOM all-

TIapaTe, npeXcTaBJIeH 53-MFI Be"KoKHfl)KecKIIMII JKaJIoBallr

HbiMlirPaMoTaMH,II3KOToPbIxllHecO)iPaHIIJIMcb,XeqfITblo
VKa3HblMHIIoLHoirl)aMoToi,
BblXaHHoH且BopeUKMM.CoUllリ

u

AJIbHblii COCTaBrPaMOT[u1KOB
aJIbHblHCOCTaB
rPaMOT[lliKOBPaC山HPHJICH、ll
PaCII｣HPll.IICFL l l rPaMoTⅡOJIyrPaMoT nOJIyU

IIIIJIII cBeTCKIie beonaJIbl, B ocHoBIIoM IIoMe山mKII IIOrPaHllII-

Hblx ye3XOB, 3 iPaMoTbl KacaJIMcb nPHBIIJIerHii ll nop"Ka
ynPaBJIeHMIHaTePPlITOPHIIoTXeJIbHbIxrPynⅡⅡPOMblCJIOBO⑥

ro HaCeJIeHHFI ceBepa - KaHHHcKHx caMoeXQB, >KIITgleH

CJIo60IcKororopo4KaBBHTcKoii3eMJIeHcJIo60nIIIIKamBaHaHoBropo瓜uega.mToroMblHMeeM63rpaMoTbl.
JJIFI BpeMeHHⅡpaBJIeHI,IH BoPoHUoBblx xapaKTepHo HoIITH noJIHOE oTcVTcTBHe TapxaHHblx H o6eJIbHblx rpaMoT、

ToJIbKoKpynHeimeMyMoliacTblplo - Tpo皿e-Ceprl,IeBy, BⅡO只八eP]KKeKoTOPorOHy>KnaJIOcbBgJI!IKOKHH)KecKOenPaBHTeJIbcTBo, 6blJIa BblnaHa B MapTe l544 r. TapxaHHaH rpaMOTa Ha BOTIIIIHbl B pa3HblX ye31aX l38.MOHacTblPb nOJIyIIH"
3Ty rPaMOTy nO TOii nPH[IIIHe, [ITO B MOHaCTblPcKIIX BJIaneg
H"x <<OrPamy KaMeHHy cTaBHT)' - cTPOHTeJIbcTBo, IIMeBmee
60JIbmoe 3HaIIeHme皿yl o60poHbI rocy"PcTBa (ero HaIIaJIo
⑪

oTHocHTcH eUe K l540 r.) 139. 0皿aKo, cy皿ⅡonOLTBep>KnteU

HIIIo rPaMoTbl B1546 r., cOXeP>KaBmeecHBHeiiOcBO60>K-

八eHIIe oT HMCKIIx IeHerHⅡOCO皿HOii CJIy>K6bl, naⅡ叩yrHe
npHBIIJI el､HH nPennoJIaraJIOcb cOxPaHIITb JIHmb nP OKOHIIaU

HHH HOcTPOHKH OrPanlbl.

136《C6oPHHKMyxaHoBa>,H3nl.2.M.,1866,Nbl29̲

l37
<<noKpo,BcKIm
XoTbKoB八eBHLIH曲MoHaCTbl'l)b)'.
M.,
1854,
cTp.
12
(Xn,
1, Nh 474).
138 rBJI, Tp. KH、528, Nb 288.
139 AA3, T. l, M 190.
23

C. M. KamTaHoB

〜

L

353

TpynHo ,HaATH nplIMepbl llo)KaJIoBaHHH B l544-1545 rr.
nO八06HblX nPHBIIJIerHA八pyrIIM MoHacTblpflM. OcBo60)KnleHIle

OT HMCKliX八eHer BoTIIHH BblIIero4cKoro Cnaco-npeo6pa>KeHcKoro MoHacTblpfI Ha l). Coihre B l545/46 r.140 011peneJIH"
,IIOCb, BePOHTHo TeM, IITO rPaMOTa 6blJIa nlaHa Ha 皿1KIIii
JIec - coBePmellllo HeoCBOeHHylO 3eMJIIo. BpH4 JIH oLIel-Ib
u

menPOH MO]KHO Ha3BaTb JIbrOTHylo rPaMOTy, BblJaHHylO

B

Mae l545 r. CIIMo|HoBy MoHacTblpIo Ha pa30peHHble TaTapaMH cOJIJIIIble BaPH皿IIJI H ceJIa. CPoK ocBo6o)K八eHHH oT ocHOBHblx nPHMblX HaJIOToB, yKa3aHHblii B Heii, 6blJI KPaiiHe
KOPOTKIIM BCerO rO,瓜141. Heo6xoJJIMocTb ynJIaTbl c MoHacTblPCKHx BOTLIMH rJIaBHblx HO3eMeJIDHblx nOnaTeii qeTKO

KoHcTaTIipyeTcJI B rpaMoTe l 545 r. AHToHbeBy CMicKoMy
MoIIaCTblpIO Ha nePeBHM H CJIO60八KmB nBIIHCKOM ye34e:
《A naHb MoIo." II HMcKlle nleHrli li llocomHVIo
軍cJIV2K6v一H xJIe6ソ

qT

一

HoH OOPOK... AaloT HO KHIIraM H no MOIIM )KaJIoBaJIHblM rPaMOTaM> 142.

HcKJIIoIIHTeJIbHblii HHTePeC nPeXcTaBJIHeT >Ka､JIOBaHHaH
rpaMoTa, nocJIaHHaH B MapTe l545 r. IiryMeHy HocII｡o-BoJIoKoJIaMcKoro MoHacTblpH. B Heii coJ(ep>KIITcH npHMoe cBHneTeJIbcTBO o Pe3yJIbTaTax ⅡmcUoBoro

omicaHIIfl

l544

r.

IiryMell B cBOeM IIeJIO6HTbe yKa3bIBaJI, IITO <<C TeX,八e'H, 11X
ceJI II 3 4epeBeHb (HMeIoTCH B B皿y BoTIIHHDI BoJIoUKoro,
KJIHHcKoro II P>KeBcKoro ye3npB- C. K) no c o皿HOMV
II H C b M y HaPmKalOT nOCOmllblX JIIOJleii B rOPOnlbl B yKPaliHHble, II xJIe6a MoJIOTIITII II BeCTI1, II JIeCy BO311TH H H3BecTII Ha

MocKByBecTH,HaBcHKHeneJIbl皿o瓜e曲CCOXHaPH>KaTH>,143.
BoBcexnpe瓜皿ecTBylo皿IIX)KaJ1OBalIHbIXrPaMOTaXMOCI4q)O
BoJIoKoJIaMcKoMy MoHacTblPIo Ha BJIaneHIIH B BoJIouIKoM,
TBepcKoM, KJIHIIcKoM M P>KeBcKoM ye3nax 3aKJIIo[IeHbl KaK
pa3 06paT､Hble nocTaHoBJIeHHH, cTaBHBmHe BoJIoKoJIaMcK"
MOHaCTblPb B COBep皿eHHo oco60e noJIO>KeHIie nO cPaBHeHIIIO
C lpymMmHMMyHI'ICTaMH l44． CJIe40BaTeJIbHo, HcHoJIHeHHe
U

HaTyPaJIbHblx HoBIIHHocTelI B nOGJIb3y rOCynaPCTBa - HoBOCTb

140

Url,IA, (P. 834, on 2, Nb 1923, "". 65-67 06
UrAnA, rKa no ra几HLIy, Nh 26/3356. B 1544 r. ocBo6o]K'UeHlie ol、
nomaTeii Ha JIBa ro,ma l]oJIy[IH.FI MocKoBcKHii HoBocnaccKMii Molla,cTblpb BcJIelcTBIIe Toro, IITo ero ceJIa li cJIo60,nKa <onycTeJM oT I)aT･
IIblX JIIOmeii ll OT IOpOrⅡ沙(rljJI, Py.MRHU. KH. 52, JIJI. 52-53 06.l
２ "C6op,HIIK rpaMo･r Ko､Ⅲ"rlemM 3KOHOMIIII>, T. l. rlr・, 1922, J,(b 109.
１
４
１
３
４
A3HX, [1. 11, Nb 184.
４
４
CM.) HanpIIMep, rpaMoTbl l539 11 1543 rr. (A311X, 11. 11, JYb 149, 171).
141

354

B BoTIIIIIIax BoMoKoJIaMcKoI､o MOHacTblPFI,

KoToPafl

MoMa

HMeTb MecTo ToJIbKo Hoc@me onlIcaHIIH 1544 r. 145

rpaMoTa l545 r. He noKa3blBaeT, B311Ma@JIHcb JIPI c MGHa･
cTblPCKIIx 3eMeJIb JIMcKIIe neHbrli li nPyrUe nJI9Te)KII, noT9:

MyqTooHao6pameHanpoTIIB3JIoynoTpe6JIeHIIiiroponoBbIx
nPHKa3qliKOB146,|HeBenaBmPIx,CyJHnO'cT叩blM>KaJIOBaHHblM rpaMoTaM, c60poM XeHe>KHblx nJIaTex<eli̲c ceJIm且epe-

BeHb l'IocH巾o-BoJIoKoJIaMcKoro MoHacTblpfl. CaMa rpaMoTa
l545 r. He oTMe|HflJIa nopHXoK, cJIo>KHBm"cFI B pe3yJIbTaTe
nHCUOBOI､o omlcaHHfl l544 1､. OHa ToJIbKo ITpennIIcbIBaJIa

TOI)OjPBblM nPHKa3IIMKaM nPllHy>KnaTb MOHaCTblI)CKIIX｡ KI)e
cTbHH K IIcIIOJIHeHIIIo rOcynaPCTBeHHblx noBIMHHOcTePI, He

HrHOPHPyH MOHacTblPCKHe BJIacTII, a nleiCTByfI ulepe3 11Hx.
Ha

ocHoBaHIIII sToii

rpaMoTbl

Mo)KHo cneJIaTb BblBon, IITo

oⅡHCaHlie, nPe且ⅡpliHFIToe npaBHTeJIbcTBoM BopoHnpBblx,
nPHBe,JIOKJIHKBHユauHHCymeCTBelIHe曲皿HXMOHacTblPcKIIX

npHBwIemil.rpaMoTal544r・PH3aHcKoMyCoJIoTLIIIHcKoMy
MOHaCTbIPIOCBH瓜eTeJIbCTByeTOHeO6XO瓜HMOCTHynJIaTblnOXaTeih c <<>KHBymerO> 147
OLIGHb noKa3aTeJIbHbl HeKoTopble pacnopH>KeHHH npaBI1TeJIbcTBa oTHOcIITeJILI-Io oT6blBaHKH MoHacTblPcKHMH KpecTb-

flHaMH flMcKoi lloBHHHocTH. B HocblJIbHoi rpaMoTe ｡eBpaJIFI
l545 r. 6eJIo3epcKHM roponpBblM npllKa3LIIIKaM, HanplIMep,

3anpemaJIocb llapH>KaTb KpecTbflH KIIpmJIJIo-BeJIo3ePcKoro
MOHacTblPH Ha 6eJIO3ePCKHih HM, TaK KaK, corJIacHO UCJIO-

6ﾙITblo III:yMeHa, IIx o6fl3aHHocTb - cToHTb Ha npyroM, Bop6030BcKoM fIMy. BnpoIIeM, |He BHoJIHe 40BepHH IIGJIo6IITTIIIKy,
cocTaBIITeJIb rPaMoTbl TyT >Ke oroBopliJIcH: <<A 6ynleT K叩ⅢJIOBa MOHaCTblPfl xPeCTbFIHOM BeJ1GIIO nO rPaMOTeⅢⅡo yKa-

3y l'a O6eHx flMex C nO八BonaMII cToFITI'I, II KI'lpllJIoBa 6bl
MOHacTblPH ceJI xPecTbJIHe Ha O6eMx HMex c IIoLBoXaMH CToHJIII Ho IrpaMoTe n no yKa3y> '48. AHaJIorHIIHaFI rpaMoTa,
ToJIbKo 6e3 1IocJIemleik oroBoPKII, 6bma noCJIaHa B MaPTe

1545 r. HM皿皿〈aM FIpocJIaBcKoro BoKmepcKoro FIMa HacIIeT
･45 EcTb coTHaH I､paMoTa l544 r. IIa BoJIoUKHe ceJIaH瓜el)GBII:M MOHa'C'l､L〕IpH (A3,MX,u､II,JYb l79).
'66 3JIoynoT･pe6JIGHMe 3To, Bbl'pa>KaBmeecFI B npH|cbmKe B MoHacTblI)cKyIo

ロ
、

BOT[IHIHy

nPHCraBoIB

II

BcHKIMx

Jn
n p H B H J 1 e r H H l H M M y H H C Ta ・

<nPlICblJIbHHKOB>,

KOTOI)ble

maBa&TH

KpeCTMIH Ha n'O|PyKII, 6blJIo JIHm1コcJIe瓜cTBHeM llaPylⅡeʻⅡHH ocHoBl･Iblx
no且aTHblx

147 H. 4 0 6 p O JI Io 6 0 B. IICTOpHKO-cTaTIMcTIIIIGcKOe OnHCaHIIe UePKBeit
H MOLIaCTblPe曲PFI3aHcKoii enapxMM, T. 1. 3apaicK, 1884, crp. 237@
148 rnB, Q - IV-1 13a, cTip. 1657-1660.
3

5

5

2

3

＊

IIcnoJIIIGHII)I fiMcKoH IToBHIIIloc'1､H KI)GcTbFIHaMII CIIaccKoI､o

HPOCJIaBcKOrO MOHacTbl", KOTOPble <<c COx c HOnlBOnaMII
CTOJIT II flMCKO曲八BOP八eJalOTHaPOMaHOBCKOMHMy> 149.

IITaK, npaBIITeJIbcTBo ･ C. BopoHUoBa, Ho-BH皿IMOMy,
nblTaJIOCbllOJIO)KIITbKOHeUOCBO60)KnleHIIIOMOHaCTblPCKHx
BoTIII1H oT rqJIaBHblx nO3eMeJIbHblx HaJIorOB I,I nPe且Ⅱpl'IHHMa-

JIo MePbl JIJIfl JIHKBH瓜allIIII cTapblx noJaTHLIx npHBHJIerH曲

KpynHblx qjeo"JIoB. Oco60e BHHMaHme 6blJIo o6pameHo Ha
MOHacTblPcKHe CJIo60LbI: HeKoTOPbIe ll3 HIIxⅡHcubl l544 r.
nPImlicaJIH K noca八y (cJIo604Ka Cnaco-EB巾HMbeBa MoHa-

CTblPH) , nPyrme B KaTerOPllLIecKoii 4)OPMe nPHIIy>"aJIIICb K
ynJIaTe l､ocynaPcTBeHHblx IIaJIoroB (cJIo601bl AIIToIIbeBa
CHiCKOI､o MoHacTbl"I Bce 3To MorJIo cIIoco6cTBoBaTb BoccTa,HOBJIeHMIO COIO3a BeJIHKOKHH"KeCKo曲BJIacTII c rOpO八aMH・

HaH60JIee meXpble >KaJIoBaHHble rpaMoTbl l544 - Haula-

､ma l545 m llI)enocTaBJIHJIH ToJIbKo BPeMeHIIble (o6blIIHo
KPaTKOCPOIIHble) JIbrOTbⅡ瓜yXoBHbIM KOPnopallIIflM. nPII
BopoHUoBI)Ix JIbroTIIble rpaMoTbl 6blJIII B"ailbl cTal)HIII"M
MocKoBcKIIM MoI-IacTIJIpHM: CIIMoHoBy '50, HoBocnaccKoMy,

qyloBy l51 1I TpoHUe-CepmeBy, a TaK>Ke MocKoBcKoMy yC-

neHCKOMy CO60py l52．OpHeHTaUmflnpaBHTeJIbcTBa HayKa3aHHble MoHacTblpII He cJIyLIaiiHa. BopoHnoBbl, npMHamJIeIKa

K cTaPOMOCKOBCKoMy 60HPCTBy, 6blJIII, nO-BH且HMOMy, TecHblMII y3aMH cBH3aHbl c BH八Hei皿HMHMOcKOBcKHMHMoHa-

CTblpHMH, Bmme KOTOPblx nPaBIITeJIbcTBO CTpeMHJIOcb HaiiTII
cOIO3HMKOB B 60Pb6e 3a yKPenJIeHHe cBOeii BJIaCTII.

l544-1545 rr oTMeIIeHbl Bbl4a[Ieii pFIJa Hecy"IMblx
rPaMOT cBeTCKHM beO"JIaM - BoTqlIHHKKaMH HOMemHKaM・
rPaMoTbl, noJIyIIeHHbIe cBeTcKHMH 3eMJIeBJIaneJIbmaMH B
3TOT

nePIIO八,

cBIUeTeJIbCTByIOT

O

cTPeMJIeHIIH

npaBHTeJIb-

cTBa BopoHUoBblx onepeTbcH Ha nlBo"HcTBo. CpaBHIITeJIbHo
c l542-1543 rr., Kornta >KaJIoBaHHble rpaMoTbl npenPcTaBJIHJIHCb nO[ITII

HcKJIIoIIHTeJIbHo lyxOBHblM

KOPnOPanHHM,B

1544 r. yneJIbHblii Bec >KaJIoBaHHblx rpaMoT cBeTcKHM JIHnaM
BO6皿eii CyMMe BbUaHHblx IIMMyHIITeTHblx aKTOB Pe3KO
I49 H. A. Bax,paMeGB. yKa3・co!1., Nb XIII; cl). TaK)Ke <<TI)yAbl PFI3aHcKoii y'leHoii apxHBHoii KoAlliccHII>', T. VI, M 3. PH3aHb, 1892,
cTp. 38, rp. 6.

150 KpoMe JIbroTHoii rpaMoTbl, CHMoHoB MoHacTblPb noJIyIIHJI 3anoBenHylO rpaMOTy Ha PO山ⅢB I)a3Hblx ye3nlax B l544 n (rMM, CIIM.
K11. 58, no MocKBe Nb 37, JIJ1. 180-181).
151 rBJI, Co6p. OI'皿P. AKTbl, KapToH 35, n. 6, J1. 40, Nb 517, J1. 47 06',
Nb 63.

152 Xn, II, JVb 843.
356

ノ

noBblcHJ1cfl.Cyne6Hbli1lnnlyH1ITeTIIoMel皿KOBWBOTLIIIHHIIKoB VKpenJIHJIcH rJIaBHblM o6pa30M B Io)KHblx paiIoHax cTpa-

Hbl!53,ho,IBepraBmmxcFIHa6eraMKpbIMUeB,aTaK>KGBye3nax,e皿ecoxpaHflBmHx[lepTblnPe>KHeiiaBToHOMI111(HanPHMeP,BHPOCJIaBCKOM!54,me()TJleJ1bllblMPITgPI)MTOI)IIHM｣j

ni)aBM皿y"nbHbleKHfI3bHMcTIIcJlaBcKIie,PJKeBcKoM!55
nOJIIITHKa nOKPOBIITeJIbcTBa rOPonaM Bblpa31IJIaCb B
1 544-1 545 rr・He TOGJIbKO B OTm'lCaHIIII IIa BeJIIIKOrO KHH3H

M()HacTblpcKIIx cJIo60JpK, B o6JIo)KeHIIII ropoIcKIIx ̲BJIaneH戒HMMWIIcToB HaJIoraMII, Ho I! B ycnJIeHMI! c"060n<|cKI1x

KOPnOPafIIBHblxnPHBIMIer戒npaBIITeJIbcTBoBopo皿oBblx
cII6co6cTBoBaJIo B6311HKHoBeHIIIo HoBblx cJIo60Ⅱ． nOKa3a-

TEJIbHa B 3TOM OTHOmeHHII rPaMOTa, nOJIyLIeHHafl B MaPTe

1545 r. HBaHoM HoBropo瓜neBblM Ha pbl6Hble JIoBJIII, necKm,

<<coKoJIblIIIKpeIIaTI>II
ca46mlla>D
BpaioHep・neIIopbl:<<OT
nameHHblx JIIOneii II OT JBIIHcKIIX H oT ne|He>KcKIIx Te PeIIKK
II COKOJIbH Can6m皿a OTomJIII naJIeIIe: BePcT 3a mlTbcOT H

60JIb皿Ⅲ》156. HBaH HoBropoXUeB IoJI>KeH 6blJI <<KoHIITb> Ha
BeJIHKorOKHH3FIcJIo60Xy,BHoCflBKa3HyO6POKOMe>KerOnHO
no COKOJIy MI KPe[IeTy, <a He 6yleT KPeqaTa IIJIH CoKoJIa, IIHO

3a KpeIIaT皿H3a coKoJI o6poKy py6JIb> BbInaBaH rpaMo!y
IiBaHy HoBropo瓜ueBy, nPaBIITeJIbCTBO CTPeMIIJIQcb cOneHCTBOBaTb KaK BO31{IIKHOBe|HIIIO <<rOCy八aPeBOiM CJIO601bl>', TaK
II OCBOeHHIO CeBePHblx PaiOHOB CTPaHbl.
' B

1 544-1 545 1T.

IIocJIGIoBaTeJIbHo npoBoⅡHnocb orPa-

HⅢ【IGIIHe cyne6Horo IIMMyHIITeTa (beonaJIoB ITocp"cTBoM
I旧'b月THHH3CeHbOPIIaJIbHOilOPHC皿IKUHHpa36OPaneJIOJy-

Inery6CTBeIIPa360eCnOJIIIIIHblM157.
Bce 3To xapaKTepll3yeT HeKoTopble nporpegpIIBHble IIepTbl Bo BHVTpeHileii nOJIIITHKe npaBHTeJIbcTBa BopoIIUoBblx.

ycIIJIeHII6 - UeHTpaJIII30BaHHoro rocynapcTBa B 15441 545 rr. He 3aMe4JIIIJIo oTpa3HTbcH II Ha ero BI-lel̲uIIei no-

JIIITIIKe.

Ka3alTcK噸 Ⅱoxon

l545

r.

fIBIIJIcH

Bblpa)KeHHeM

５
３CM., HanplIMep, rpaMoTy HB. IieBJIGBy Ha BJIaJeH" B TyJIbcKoM ye3５
４ne (<<AKTbI IOmKOB", Nb l43; cp. TaM >Ke, Nh l44).

１

nAII, TJ, JVb 38, cTP 38 CM TaK)Ke rpaMoTy oT 25 MaH 15" r.
MHx.'Bac.,BepxnlepGBbKcMyHanoMGcTbeBPR3aHcKoMyeame(<AK'『IJI IOmKoBa>, Nb l45).

５ rBJI, Co6P. OTjlena
１５
６
１５
Xn, I, Nb 483.
１５
７

PyKonHcei, Nb 914/41 (coo6皿Hn B. H. nopH).

<<AKTIjl lOmKoBa>, Nb 143, 144; JTOI'III, Co6p aKToB，Ⅱo l613 r.,
Nb l/156; <C60PHMK MyxaHoBa", H3n. 2, Nb l29; JAI'I, T. 1, Nb 38.
CJIo60)KaHe HBaHa HoBroponUeBa 6bIJIII nollcynHLI IIaMecTHHKaM B

cJIyqaHx 'uymery6cTBa, pa360H H TaTb6bI c HoJIHqHLIM,
357

ll｣"OKO

3aIIyMaHHblX

noCJIe

cBeP>KeHHfl

npaBIITeJIbCTBa

lⅡyiicKHxnJIaHoByKPen,JTeHHHPOCcMIII.
qTO KaCaeTCH Pa3HOBIInHOCTeit rPaMOT, TO B nePHoX
npaBJIeHIIHBopoHUoBblxnpeo6JIanaIome甘巾OpMOhno》KaJIoBaHIIFI MOHacTblPHM nOnaTHblx nPHBIIJIer" cTaJIII JIbroTHble
rPaMoTbl.

B KoHUe l545 - HaIIa.JIe l546 r., Korna皿Ⅲa 6OPb6a Me>Knly BopoHUoBblMII II rJIIIHcKIIMII, HaMeTHJIHcb H3MeHeHIIH B
oTIIomeHHH ⅡPaBHTeJIbCTBa K nPHBHJIerHHM MoHaCTblPeil.

CTaJIa
oTMelIHTbcH,
HanpIIMep,
06H3aHHocTb
MoHacTblp6KHx
KPecTbHH CTOHTb Ha HMy c n皿Bo"MII 158. B ｡eBpame l546 r.

KHpHJIJIo-BeJI'03epcK" MoHacTblpb noJIyq皿 皿e八PylO TaPxaHHO-nPOe3>KylO rPaMOTy Ha nPOBO3, KyⅡmo H nPona>Ky

10 000 nynpB coJIII l59. noXTBep丞及eHHe CTaPblx H BblXalla
HOBblx

TaPXaHHblX

nPHBHJIer"

Ha6JIIonalOTcH

B

HIoHe-

｝IIoJIe l546 r. He3ano,IIro no Ka3HH ①．C. BopoHnoBa l60.
C HaIIaJIa MaH Io cepe瓜HII1)I aBrycTa l546 r. BeJIHK" KHH3b
waxo4IIJIcfl B KoJIoMHe, KyJIa oH oTnpaBIwIcH B cBH3II c HoJIyIIellHeM H3BecTHii o roToBHBmeMcH HOxOne KPblMcKOrO
xaHa Ha KoJIoMHy '61. nepIIoJI KoJIoMeHcKoro cHneHHH MBa-

Ha lV o3HaMeHoBaJ1cH pfl,UoM npaMaTHIIecKHx co6blTHii, I'I3
KoTOPblx Ba)KHe曲mHM 6bl･IIo oKoHIIaTeJIbllOe naneHIIe nPaBHTeJIbcTBa BopoHnoBblx. HHKoHoBcKafI JIeTomIcb paccKa3blBaeT, 'ITO八bflK BacHJI" rpPIropbeB cblll 3axapoBa rHHJIIIeB, 6blBm鋤B nPH6JIIDKellPIII y BeJTIIKOrO KHfl3H, OKJIeBeTaJI
nepen HIIM KHfI3fl RBaHa Ky6eHcKoro, enopa H BacIJJI"
BopoHHoBblx. 21 II10"H cocToHJIacb Hx Ka3Hb l62.

BblHcHeHIIe noJIIITHIIecKoro ｡爪,皿a瓜bHKa BacHJIIIFI rpHrQpbeBa IIMeeT 60JIbmoe 3HaLIeHIIe, II60 Bo BTopoitpOJIOBI畑e
1546 r. Bb皿aLIa >KaJIOBaHHblx rPaMOT |HaxoIHJIacb B erO BeneHIIII. BblcTynJIeHme B. rpHropbeBa JIeToM l546 r. KaK enHI･IHIIHbl曲巾aKT MaJIo HoKa3aTeJIbHo OXHaKo nyMaeTcFI, IITo
Xapbepa 3Toro nbHKa TecHo nepemleJIacb c 60pb60i npoTIIB

BopoHUoBblx. BnepBble BacIIJIHii rpHropbeB - oKa3bI"eTcFI
Ha noJIHTHIIGCKoii aPeHe Bo BPeMH nePBO的onaJIbl BopoHUoBblx, KoTOPa月瓜川macb c oKTH6pH no neKa6pb l545 r. 163

CaMaH paHHFIH rpaMoTa, nonmlcaHHafI B. rp|HropbeBblM,
' 5 8

Xn, I, Nb 495, 505, 506.

159

JIOI'IIi, Co6p. merpeHa, JWh 4.

160

Xn, 1, Nb 509, 511, 513.

161

PCPJI, T. XIII, nepBag nomoBMHa, cTp" I49

162
163

TaM ]Ke.

TaM )Ke, cTp. 147.
358

naTIIpyeTcHHoH6peM1545rJ"nocJIenofI6pH1545LPa=
emi｣r"ropbeBfHeynoMIMHaeTCHBaKTaXmOPeHTHqPR
1546r.165BMapTel546r.,KornayBJIacTHeme6bmH①enop
旦oD
＆BopoHnoB,
BopoHnoB,I/IBaH
HBaH Ky6eHcKHH
Ky6eHcK" II Hx
HHxcTopoHHHKH,Be皿KOcTopoHHIIKW, Be
U

KHFDKecKVIo yKa3Hylo rpaMoTy no瓦ⅡⅥcaJI npyl､OH XbflK -

MaKapII間①血opoB166.BMael546r.>KaJIoBa"ylorpaMoW

bIMN6M6536TbIpIo
nomTBepm"
UbmK
HKoB
rpjiropbeB
#W,
XM3M̅"aMoTjBCy3naimbnocJIan
UbHK
TpeTbflK16a
BacImmit rpHropbeB 6bm, KoHeIIHo, JIIImb opyⅡHeM B py-

Kax MorV皿ecTBeHHoii60HpcKoHrpyⅡmlpoBKm，Bo3maBJIflBecTBeHHOii 60HPcKoii rPynmlPOBKII, Bo3TJIaBJIFIB-

皿eHCH，ⅡO-BI皿HMoMy，rJIHHcKHMH．ⅡO3ToMyne”OⅡbl
eiiCH, ilO-BMIIMoMy, rJIHHcKIIMH. nO3ToMy nePlMOnLI erO
⑪

BO3BEImeHIIH IIJIII《ⅡPH6mｲ>KelllIH》K BeJIHKOMy KHH3IO CJIe-

瓜yeT
nyeT
paccMaTp・HBaTb
paccMaTpHBaTb
KaK
BpeMHⅡpeo6JIanaHI晩gToH
KaKBpeMHnpe26JIamgHWI3To"p"･
Bpa>Kne6HoiBopoHHoBblMrpyⅡⅡHpoBKIIEcJIIIBrplIropbeB̲Ha･
XO瓜mJICH<<BnPlI6JIH>KeHHH》y>KeBI'IIoHe­H'oJIel546r.,
'｢O,OqeBImHO,cePIIIOHMMyHmTeTHbIx rPaMOT KoHIIMIW]
u

1546 r. Mo)KHo cIIHTaTb BbmaHHoHmmaMII, CMeHFIBmPIMI1 3a-

TeM nPaBHTeJIbcTBo BoPoHnqpblx.
no no及面HcHM BacI1JIMIFI rpmropbeBa BblHcHHIoTcfI HeKoU

ToPble
OCO6eH!HOCTm
noJIIITIIqeCKOR
OPIIeHTam畑ⅡOⅡ瓜ep>KII-

BaBmHxero60Hp.BcerpaMoTbl,no且ⅡHcaHHbleB.rpl,Ii､opb-

5ERM,
KacaIoTcH.Tpomue̅CeprlleBa
MoHacTblpH
169yqIITblBail,
u

⑪

IITo TpoHⅡK" MOHacTbIPb Bxo"IJI B IIIICJIo KOPnOPaUlIIf,
A

noJIb30BaBmlIxCH oCO6blMmⅡPlIBImerlIFIMH

B

rOnbl

nPaBJIe-

HHHBopoHUoBblx, JIerKo HoHHTb, 'HacKoJIbKo cepbe3Hoe 3Ha'IeHHe npHnaBaJIII rJIHIIcKIIe 60pb6e 3a npHBJIeIIeHIIe MoHar
人

CTblPfl
CBOIO
CTOPOHy.OIIeBH瓜ⅡO,
CBFI3PI
B
C
3TOM
60Pb60ii
ʻ Ha
cToiiT I! cMeHa mryMeHoB B Tpolille-CeprlieBe MoIIacTblpe

EuLeBMapTel545r.TpoHⅡKmMIIryMelloM6blJYynl)3BJIFIBIⅡIImMoHabTbIpeMnpliBopoHUoBbIxHIIKaHnp!70.BHofI6pe
u

164 ｢B,几Tp. KH､527, Nb 292.
165 TEIM >Ke, JYb 288.

唾

l664TpyllbIBm℃Koiiy'I(,IIoiia'I)xHBHoiiKoMwIc.cHII)p.BHTKa)
1905,oTn.I11,
U

1

cT|D. 87-89.

167 mM, CIIM. KH. 58, no MocKBe Nb 38, JIJI、181-183 06.

168urAmA,巾.Cnac6-EB(bm,MbeBaMoHacTHpfI,K11.1,J1.520-52006.

169STOrJTaBHblMO6Pa30MO6皿IIerPaMoTbI,ocBo60班瓜alO皿HeBCIOMOI･Ia⑪

CTblPCKyIO
BOTIIHHy
OT
Pa3JIHIIBblx
nOnaTemHnOBIMHHOCTGii:
HOFI6pb，cKafll､paMoTa l545 r・O6 0CBO60XmeHIM TPOHUKIIx 3eMeJIb oT nOCTaB-

KH3anacoBⅡJIHKa3aHcKoroⅡOXO“（rBJI，TP、KH527，Nb292)，

叩aMoTal544r.,no且nHca'HHaflB.
r'pHrOpbeBI)IM25ceHTH6"
1546E

(TaM )Kc, Nb 288) . B. rp:IIro|pbeB Ho皿HCaJI OKTfl6,PbCKyIO rPaMOTy
1546 r. Ha nepecJIaBcKIIe, P8JIoHe]KcKIIeHn|MHTPOBCKMe Cena (Xn.
I, Nb 518).
170 AA3, T. I, M 203.
359

1545 T., B nepllo且ⅡepBoM onaJIbl BopoHUoBblx, IMH HecKoJIbKo pallpme WyM.HcTBo B TpoImKoM MoHacTblpe nepemJIo B
I)yKII HOHbl !71. m3 nPe6bIBaHIIfI BeJiliKOrO KHFI3fI B KOJIOMIIe

TpoHUKIIAMQHacTbrpbII3BJTeKHeMaJIyloBblrony,106HB皿Hcb
BblnaIIPIGMy24HIoHfll546r.ZaHHoiiHTapxaHiio-HecyXHMoii
rPaMoTbl Ha KOJIOMeHCKIIh1Bop 172. Boo6me >Ke JIHIIHoe yIIa-

cTHeHBaHalVBBblJa[Ie>KaJIoBaHHblxrpaMoTB3ToTn6pH2I OcTaBaJIoCb B 60JIbmIIIIcTBe CJIyIIaeB 'HOMIIHaJIbHEIM.
B HIoHe - aBrycTe l546 r., Korna lIBfIH IV Haxo皿IJIcH B Ko-

JIOMIHe, rPaMOTbI oT erO IIMeHII 6bml'I Bb皿aHbl B MocKBe l73.

ycnex rJIPIHcKHx B 3Ha'IIITeJIbHoii Mepe o6'bHcHHeTcH
TeM, [ITO OHI,I CblrPaJIH Ha HeynaIlaX BOCTOIIHOhⅡoJIIITIIKH Bo-

POHUOBblX・noIITHBCeIIMMyHIITeTHblerPaMOTbInePIIoXa

KoJIOMeHcKorO CH又eHIIH RBaHa lV HMeIoT, Ka>KeTcH, npHMoe
OTHOIleHme K CXBaTKaM Me)K4y PyCCKIIM rOCynaPCTBOM, C
oJHoM cI9poIibl, Ka3aHcKHMII H KpblMcKIIMH TaTapaMH, c

npyroi Hall60JIee flBIIo. 3Ta cBH36 yJTaBJTHBaeTcH h HIdHb-

CKOカパaJIoBaH'HoirpaMoTel546r.TpoHnle-CeprmeByMoHacTblpIo Ha nBop B I<oJIoMHe npaBIITe｡mbcTBo bllITaJIo, IITo,
BbImaBa兄皿enPylO IKaJIOBalIHylo rPaMoTy BJIHHTeJIbHoMy MOIIaCTbIPlO Ha MeCTO B rOPOne, HaxO皿IBmeMcFI Ho" yrPO30ii
XpblMcKoro Ha6era, oHo yKpemlHeT 3mecb cBoII no3HⅡHH、

K ToMy )Ke, BHyTpeHHee noJTo>KeHme B KoJ1oMHe 6biJIo B 3To
BpeM3̲ HecnoKo#HblM. Bo3HIIKm" TaM Bo BpeMfl npe6blBaHHH HBaHa 1V <<MFITeIK> HoBToporncKHx nm皿a川JIIHKOB ]74,
BHnHMO, HaBJIeK 'nonp3PeH11H I1 Ha KOJIoMeHcKHx 'cJIo60>KaH,

CKOTORblMI!nH皿aJIbIHIIKI11,BePOHTHo,06ma皿cb.
no3ToMy
BeJIHKHHKII-IFI3b､ BblCeJIIIB OTneJIbHblx CJIo60>KalI, naJI nBOP

BHpeneJIax cJIQ60nlbl TpoIme-CeprlIeBy MoHacTblplo, 3apy-

qa?cb,TAKIIMO6Pa30M,erOMOrymeCTBeHIIOhno皿eP>KKOiiB
PaiioHe KOJIoMHbl.

28 HIoHH - 6 HIoJIH 1546 1､. HMMyHIITeTHble rPaMOTbl

6bIJIH npeXocTaEjleHbl K""JIo-BeJIogepcKoMy MoHacTblplo
BoJIoroJIcKoi
II
rJIy60Koe3epcKohnycTblHPI
175
C巾epo曲且eカー
cTBIIH rpaMoT HBJIHJIHcb paihoHbl yrJIHIIa, BoJIornbl, BarH II
KapronoJIH.

１
７１ rBJI, Tp. KH. 527, Nb 292.
１
７２
nPn, BbIn. 1V, cTp. l l4-1 16.
１
７３

B、r: 4Q O P O H P a B o B. yKa3. COq., nPl!几, cTp. 23-24, Nb 7; AAa

１７４
１７５

L I,̲M 208; UrAnA, rKS no l<ocTPoME, Nb 43/5010"

ngPJL T. XIII, BToPaH noJIoBM'Ha, C叩. 448-449:
xn, I, Nb 512, 513、

尋

360

,
吊

歩

yKa31･IaflrPaMOTay皿IillKIIMTaMO>KeIIHIIKaMHOX-

TBePMM nOJ,)Wl,y,O KmP""PgJIWWIWWWF
"̅rFiaJIe l546 .c

>Kajio""9 WWWMo:3W

"M""6ecnomJ,MwHyfo nQMWE̲lWWIOIWnnR9:

MM " irIMM̅rmoiKe", n6noji,"TW'W"MW "

161̅icbJIKBrijaMoT63anpemaJIocbB3mMaTb""g.gW2-

POrO
MoHaerblPcKorO
cylllla,
KaK
3TO
XeJIaJIli
yrn!mKIIe
TaMO-

jKellHIIKII 176.

グ

rJIV6oKoe3epcKa兜nyCTblHbnOJIyrlHJIanPaBOHaBJIanler
v

HIIe HiiKeM He gaHfITblMH 3aiiMH皿aMIIH且HKIIM JIec'0MくHa

Bce
cTopOIIbl
oT
MOHaCIblPfl
nO
,IBeHa瓜uaTH
Bep,CT)p
177.

MMEi Tpmmc-CcirmcBy MoHacTb,plo 3̲W.9W
U

〃

e3ep6Koii njcTbIHII 6blJIM TapXaHHbIMH: B HIIX Q91WWW

o6e)IeHIIe OmaHH, flMcKIIx neIJer H BCHKIIx 3eMcKIIX nPPTQ-

b'6E̅m
pa3MeTOBB
rp3MoTe
Tpo皿KoMy
MoHacTblplO
l)IIKbllpoBaJIocb
eme
ocBo60那旦eHm6
0T
nocOmHoi
cJIy>K6bl,
Ho
M5̅MMOF̅ nPmHyX<ma"a :"CTbIPc"̲""",､W

EEInOJIH6HmlOrOPOnOBOroneJIa,mIMeBm.rOOWeHbBa)KHOe
5HaqeHIlenJIHo60poHbno>KHblxpy6e>Kek
U

f

6.PacIFBeT
｡eo"JibHoroJIMMyHJITeTanpmr入mHcKⅢx・
HoBLIe orpaHIIIIIMTeJIbHBIe TeHIeHIﾘⅢH

BoBTopoinoJIoBHHel546r・coCTaBnPaBHTeJIbcTBae皿e
U

⑥

ile 6blJI Bn6JIHe VcToihIIHBb1M. HacTofl皿PIMII xO3HeBaMII HOJIO-

>KeHIIR rJIJIHcKHE cTaJIH B FMBape l547 r26 1IIoIIFI O1111 naJIIM

Bpe3yJIbTaTeMocKoBC"IpBoccTaHmfL3a¥ReMa̲̲g̲.FWcTA l546 no 26 mIoHfI 1547 r HaM II3BecTwo 40 IIMMyHIITeT-

Hblx rpaMbT: IKaJIoBalIHblx 33 (八yXOBHI]IM KOPllOPamlFIM
23 rpAMoTbI, H3 KoTopbIX QXHa He coxpaHHJIacb,cBeTcK"

JI皿dM - 10) , yKa3HbIx 7 (cpe" HI1x oIHa yKa3IIafl rpa、

MOTa KOIIIOInerO H O4Ha yKa3Hafl rPaMOTa nbHKa）．

BaBrycTe-瓜eKa6pe̅ 1546r.MblemeHeHa6JIIonaeM

HanJIblBa . TapxaHHblx rpaMoT, xoTFI o6eJ1.Hble rpaMoTbY

(HeocBo60)K"Io皿HeoTTJIaBHblxHaJIOrOB)B3TOBPeMH

BblnalOTCH178.

nPaBIITeJIbcTBo HBaHa lV o6paTHJIO oco60e BHHMaHHe
△

HayltpenJIeHllenoJIIITIIqecKIIXygcTPpmUe-CGprlieBbilMZ
CIIMoI10BbIMMoHacTblPflMI1.C15ceHTH6pHnol2neKa6pm

4JIIIJIacb noe31Ka l'IBaHa lV B TpoIIue-CeprlIeB MoHacTblpb
176 rnB, Q-IV-113a, nJ1. 1581-1583.
177 AA3, T. I, Nb 208.
178 Xn, I, Nb 518, 519,

F

1

.

361

､
O

E

ﾔ

G

9

w ropona K cGBepo-3anany oT MocKBbl l79. BeJIIIKoro KI.IFI3R

conpoBo)KJaJI JIbflK BacIMIIii rpHropbeB II, Mo)KeT 6blTb,
HeKoTopble XpyrIIe npH6JIH)KeHHble JIHua. B 3ToT nepHon

HBaH IV IIMen, oIIeBHIHo, roPa340 60JIee llenocpe八cTBeHHOe OTIHO皿eIHIIe K BblnaIIe )KaJIoBa'IIIIblx rpaMoT, IIeM PaHbHIe: noLITII Bce oIIII cocTaBJIeHbl TaM, rme Haxo且HJICHOH caM．

yjKe 25 ceHTFI6pH 6blJIa noJTBep>KnleHa no MapTa l 548 r.
9"ag .J"oTHaH rpaMOTa Tpome-CeprmeBy MoHacTblplo
l544r・1803oKTH6pfI1546r.,6ynyIIHBMoHacfblpe,MBaH･IV
BbmaJI HryMeHy l'IoHe o6eJIbHo-HecynHMyIo rPaMoTy Ha cpaBMIITeJTbHo HenaBHo npHo6peTeHIIble MoHacTblpeM 3eMJIII B

gaMocKoBcKHxBoJIocTfIxmel)He, Kop3eHeBe,̅ Bope !8! H B

BblmeropoHcKoM cTaHe nMHTpoBcKofo ye3na 182. .Bce 3TII
MecTa 6JIH3Ko nonXQm"H K yneJIy BJIanlIMIIpa AHnpeeBHIIa
CTapImKoro, BJIaneBmero HeKoToPblMI! 3aIMOcKoBcKiIMII BoJIocTHMH

(PaMeHe"eM, BoxHo"

IIBaH IV 3a60THJIcfl o6 yKpenJIeHIIH BeJIHKoKHH)KecKoro
cIo3ePeHIITeTa ilaﾉ1 3eMJIHMH, paCnoJIO>KeHHblMH HenaJIeKO OT

yneJII)IIblx Tel)p}IT()plii. KaK noKa3aJIII IIocJIe八vIoluHe co6blTIJH, STa MePa 6bIJIa mOCTaTOKIHO nPe,mVcMoTpHTeJIbHoii: V>Ke

B HoH6pe l546rBJIa皿MIIp CTap皿kmii 6TaJ] yCIIJIeiIHO
PacnpocTpaHRTb cBoe BJIIIRHIIe B 3aMocKoBcKHx BoJIocTflx 183.

AKTIfBHoe
cypeMJIQlIH6
BJIa皿MIMpa
A皿PeeBIIIIa
3aPyIIIITbcH
no皿eP>KKoABePeiicKIIx巾eOnaJ1OB184CTHMyJImpOBaJIOI'IBa1-Ia lV ycwIHTb cBoI"I ITo3}皿HMI B cocenHeM c Bepeeii BoDoB-

cKoMye3JIe.BBeJIHKoKHHｼKecKoiiyKa3HOiirpaMbTe,nOchaHHoii 8 0KTfl61)H I 546 rJIa onIIH !I3 fIMoB BoI)oBcKoro ye3na,
3a rlI)e皿aJIocIJ Ilal)ymaTb >KaJIoBallllylo rpaMoTy MocKoBcKo-

My ApxaHreJIbcKoMy co60py !85. noJII1;rIIIIecIfoe 3HaIIeHHe

oKTH6pbcKoiirpaMoTbll546r.TpoIIUe-CeprHeByMoHacTbIplo
ycyry6JIHJIocb TeM o6cToflTeJIEcTBoM, qTo oiIa KacaJIAcb
!79 nCPJT, T. XIII, nepBaHⅡoJIoBHHa, cT!p. 129.
180 rBJI, Tp. EH. 527, Nb 288.

18! B .rpaMoTe l54f r. mepHa ma3gaHa cTaHoM nepecmaBcKoro ye3na,
a̲KO"eHeBo !i BopfI - CTaHaMII P"oHe)KcKoro y634a
!22 1JIA"｣ rK3 no nepecmaBnlo-3 aneccKoMy, Nb ̅1 40/8864

183 Xn, I, M 522.

184 Pme B IIIoHe l546 rpH no-I B Bepelo yKa3Hylo rPaMoTy o6 0cBo-

60)KneHHH K|PeCTbFIH TPOImKoii BoJ1OCTIJ HJ1eMHbI Ha rom OT O6H3alITIo|cTII cToHTb̲ ITa fJMy c IIpnBonaZIIII (AA3, T. I, JYb 207) B HofT6pbcKoil y,Ka3HOii rl)aMoTe l546 r. BmanMMHp AImpeeBI1IJ npeⅡnHcblBaʻ11

3aMemITEC60PnOnaTeiiccIIMoHOBcKOrOcema且HKoroBblmeropon"oK)

ye3"

133IIMaHIIGM

o6poKa

JVb 52, ".206-206 06) .
185 JTOHH, Co6P・JIIIxaIJeBa, M 61/1.
362

(rlIM,

CIIM.

KH

58,

ITo

MocKBG

rJIaBHblM
O6Pa30M
6blBmHx
BJIanleHIIii
THMo｡eH
3aMHTHH,

ⅡP
HBeP>KeHUam"cKmx,
noJIyqHBmoro
oT
HIIx
1538L̲"
B
ji65"ylO・
rbaMOTyHamePeBHm,nePe､IeHHbIeBrPaMOTe
1546 r.186

Haxo且Rcb B HoH6pe l546 r. B BeJ1HKoM HoBropon,e,
I'IBaH IV,bIIeBMIHo, mMeJI cJIyIIaih y6e,ⅡHTbCR B HaJIII'IHH

cpe皿II6br5POnCi<IIX'
｡eOnaIIOB̅
CToPOfIHIIKOB
KHfl3eli
myi-

EM̅H̅""ill6ro KHff3H BJIa"MHpa AHnpeeBH"CT2W:
RMh63ToMy ol! noonem" ynPBJIeTBopllTb ueJIo6"e
TpomUKIIx BIIaETei, BbInaB19 HoH6pH )IWI9"Wo̲WMQ-

Ty
TpoIme-CeprmeBy
MoH4grbIPIo
Ha
c・By>KaPOBO
nepPB
U

cjlaBjlb-3aJIec6KoM ye34e !87, HBJIHBmeMcH Q"Qm ll3 HalI-

60JIee3HaqIITeJIbHbIXc｡epBJMHHmfIKHfI3ei皿y曲cKmx

npHHuHⅡblIIMMyHHTeTHoihnoJIHTIIKIIHBaHalVBnePllon "ero oceHHeii noe3"m lP46 ccy皿ecTBeHHooTJIIillajImc60TOcHOBnOJIIITIIKII60HPcKIIxBPeMeH皿IIKO|B.KaK
U

人

⑫

oKTH6pbcKaH,TaKIIHoH6pbcKaflrpaMoTbIHenpenocTaW1ft
JIHTpollUe-CeprmeByMoHacTblpIo3eMeJIbHbIxBJIanleH!畑 凋
U

TapxjHHblx n"BHJIerIlii. OKTFI6pbcKaH叩aMOTa Comep>Kaひ

』

JIa. 06eJIeHMe JIIImb oT JBopUoBo-KHH>KecKI1x noBMIHIIocTeH
U

II3eMcKHxpa3MeToB,BHoH6PbcKoirpaMoTeocBo60>K,mellHf
c J

OT naHII, HMCKHx neHer, roPOnOBOrO neJIa H ̲IIocomHo}J

cJIv>K6bI
orpaHHIMBaJIocb
nByxJIeTIIIIM
cpoKoM・npontJIeHIIe
△
MoTbI, 3akJIIoqeHHoi B rpaMoTel544 r" np1548 1，．To〕Ke
ソ

口

6blJ1o cKopee orpaHIIIIeHIIeM {IMMyHHTeTHqlp̲ aKTa, IIeM
HoBblM Ho>I<aJIoBaflIieM, TaK KaK B rpaMoTe l 544 rJIe llMeJIOCb HHKaKHX KOIIKPeTIlblx yKa3aHIIii OTIIOCHTeJIbIIO CPOKa
⑪

寺

ee neHcTBI1H.

K TpoHnKIIM rpaMcITaM nPm6J1II>KaJ1aChno c"eMy xa-

paKTepjrpaMoTa,BbLmaHII"20IWI6pH1546ECllMoH9py

MoHa6TLIpiO
Ka3HaqeHMII
HB.
ZB.
TpeTbHKQBbIM̲
II̲Qe瓜・HB・

CyKHHblM,
oqeBH瓜Ho,
B
oTcyTcTBHe
HBaHa
lV
188.
Pa3pemaH
〆

HeynJIaTy naHII, MblTa H TaMrH C MOHa|cTblPcKHx CJIoOOXOK
B JIIo6HMe H Bye-rOPone, rPaMoTa BMecTe c TeM npe且nIイー
CblBaJIa

naBaTb

HMCKHe

neHbrlI,

IICIIoJIHHTb

nOCO山HylO
U

cJ1y>K6y lI ToponpBoe neJIo '89. C noJIHTIIIIecKoii ToIIKH
l86 TBJI, Tp. KH. 534, no MocKBe Nh 43, J1. 14.
187 Xn, 1, Nb 523.
188 MeCTO Bblnaul|H I､paMOTbl He yKa3aHO, HO K rPaMOTe nPHBemella

KPa-

cHoBocKoBaR neIIaTb; Me]Kny TeM
cHoBocKoBa月neIIaTb；Me】KⅡy
TeMHBaH
HBaHIV
IVBBnepHo瓜cBoeii
nepIIoJ cBoeii ocelIHeH
ocelIHeii
｡

noe3nKH

1546

r.

3anetlaT1ｺIBaJI

'HOM BOCKe・

189 Xn, 1, M 519.
363

rPaMOTbl

<nyTHoH矛neIIaTblo Ha［Iep-

3PeHIIFI STa rPaMOTa 6IIJIa B Ty >Ke UeJIb, IITO H aBryCTOBcKaH >KaJToBaHIHaH rpaMoTa CIIMoHoBy MoHacTblplo 190: oHa
ycWmBaJIa nO3HU" nPaBHTeJIbCTBa BB PaHoHe，HrPaBmeM
ycHJIHBaJIanO3HuHHnPaBHTeJIbCTBa
PaioHe, HrPaBmeM

ocoOylo poJIbB
ocooylopoJIb
B o6cTaHoBKe HanpH>KeHHblx
HaⅡ”>KeHHblxoTHomeHHhMe>KoTHomeHIIii Me>K-

ny MocKBoii H Ka3aHbIo. B HatlaJIe oKTFJ6pFI 3TII oTHomeIHHHIIPe3BBIIIaiiHOIIaKaJIIIJIIIcbBcJIeJICTBHenPHHRTIIFI PyccKIIM npaBIITeJIbcTBoM Ha cJIy)K6y B nocJIeZIHI,Ix IIIIcJIax ceII-

TR6pFI 76 Ka3aHcKHx KHR3eit,BbI6xaBHIHx H3 Ka3aHII 191.
U

⑪

BnpHMoiicBH3HcnoxomoMKHfT3FIAJ].Bop・rOP6aTOTO
B cTpaHy IIepeMIIcoB B neKa6pe l546 r.192 cToIIT BblmaIIa
U
U

23neKa6pHnaHIIoiilIHecymIMoiirpaMoTblTpomue-CeprHeBy MoHacTblPlo " nepeBHII B BoJIocTII CTpeJIIme HmKero-

poncKoroye3na194̲SToTaKT3aMeTHopacmliplIJITpoHuKOe
3GMJIeBJIaneHHe B HIDKeropOncKoM ye3ne 3a cI1eT o61)oIIIIblx
gePeBeHb HH>KerOPOncKIIx 60PTHIIKOB H noMecTHoi nePeBHH
U

JIHxopeBoi.npHIIeM
JIHxopeBo曲．npHIIeM
TpoHⅡKIIHMoHacTbTpbⅡ”o6peJInpaTpoHHK"MoHacTbrpbnprlo6peJInpaU

Bo He nJIaTHTb o6poK c 60pTHblx IIepeBeHb, TaK KaI< oHH 6blJI3 no>KaJIoBaHb! eMy <c o6poKoM, [ITo mJIo c Tex nepeBeHb
O6POKy MenOM 3a MOIo, BeJmKOro K"3H, naHb>>.

BIJcTopmlTapxaHoBBPmHoeMecTo 3aHIIMaeT oTI)e30K

BpeMeHw c HIIBa" 1 547 r., Korna cocToHJ1ocb BeHqaHIIe
IIBaHa lV Ha napcTBo, "o HIoI･IbcKoro Boc'cTalIMFI B MocKBe.

B 3ToT IIeplIoJI rJIaBHLIe npaBIITeJIbcTBeHHble nocTbl 60JIee
nPoIIHo, [IGM B KoHIle l546 r., 3axBaTIMII rJIPIHcKIIe. BblXaI旧>KaJIoBaHHblx II̲yKa3HbIx rPaMOT TaK>Ke cOcPenoTo叩イー

"" B HX PyKaX. IIMMyHIITeTHylO rPaMOTy OT 20 HIIBaPFI
人

1547E r" HanPmMel), BbIna" 6aM 60fII)Iil! ]{ KoHIomilii
M B rJIIIHcK"194 B BeJIIIKoKHfi>KecKIix !IMMyHIITeTHbIx
rpaMoTax nepBo# noJIQBHHbl l547 r. 3aTparHBaioTcH Tpll
⑪

KoMnJIeKca TeppllTop":̲Bo-nepBbIx, c(bepa BJIIIHHMI myiu

cKIMx B UeHTpaJ1bHblx pamoHax K BocToKy oT MocKBLI (Cv3，

ソ

2aJIbCKHi Jle3n, qaGTbBJIa皿MI1pcKoro，ⅡMHTpoBcKoro
mJIbcK皿ye3Ⅱ，IIacTb
BIIa"MIiPCKOrO, nMIITPOBCKdrO･ H

CTapomy672"oJIoBcKorOye3noB) ;Bo:BfobbIx;ceBepIIa"
oKpaHHa（HoBropoⅡcK城，ncKoBcKI噸，BoJIoroⅡcK城，HpocJ1aRcKli#,ycTIo)KcKIifiye3qbl)
HTBepcKoiiye3n;
画 B-TbeTblix,
』

④

190

Xn, I, M 514; C. M・K a UI T a H o B. meOnta.JIbHbIi IIMMVImTeT BroｪIbT

6o叩cKoronpaBJ1eIIHFI(1538-1548rr.).­《IIcToPlIIIGCKIIe
H3amlcK",
T. 66, cTI). 259-26 1 .

例
１
蛇
１
１
兜
１
叫

nCPJI, T. XIII, TIGpBa兜noJIoBHII8, cTI). 149.
TaM ]Ke.

rB几Tp. KH. 518,佃几13-14 06.
PHB, T. 32, Nb l65,
364

Io>KHaFIoKl)alllla
(Pfl3aHcKIIii,
Kamlil)cKlili,TyJ1bcKlliiye3、

Abl) .

Oco6eHHo 60JIbmoe BHl1MaHIIe 6blJIO yAeJIeHO Cy3八aJIb-

cKHM申eO皿JIaM，cPe皿KoToPhlxHaⅡePBOM
MeCTeOKa3anllcb lioHatTblpli Cnaco-EB｡IIMbeB195 M noKpoBcKIiH且eBxU

LIM曲196. HX BOTIIIIHbl OCBO60)KnaJIIiCb OT Pa3JIHLIHblX rOCy-

4al)cTBeHHblx nonaTeilm nOBHHHocTem, B TOM IIHCJIe H oT
rJIaBHblx. Cy3,maJIbcKHM ropoHoBblM npHKa3IIHKaM, 3anpe1UaJIocb 6PaTb兄MCKHe neHbrmmⅡOCOmlIblX JIIOneH TaK>Ke
虻

9

c ceJIa B"Bbl KHFI3H B M. UleMH[IIILIa - cTap皿bl EB巾HMb}I
IIIeMHL皿IIeBoiil97.

CaMoe

llpIIBHJIerlipoBaHHoe

noJ1o>KeHIie

cy3"JIbCKHe (PeO八aJIbl 3aHHmI B FIIIBaPe-HaIIaJIe MaPTa
1547 n, T. e g nepmQm ynpoqeHMH BJIacTI! [JIIIHcKHx nocJIe
JI I'IKBMnaUmHBPa]Kne6Hblx rPynnIipoBoK.OIIeBHJIHo,non-

4eP>KKa
KPynHIJIx
Cy31aJIbCKMX
BOT[IIIHHHKOB
qb皿a
Heo6xo八IIMa rJIIIHcKIIM 4JIH I-IeiiTPaJIH3am畑KHH3ei 皿yiicKIMx,
HBJIRRIIIIIxCH

IIx

rJIaBHblMI'i

noJIHTIIIIeCKHMII

nPoTIIBHIIKaMH

(He cJIvIIaiiHo B IIoroHIo 3a M. B. rJIHHcKIIM, nblTaBmHMcH
6e>KaTE B KO[皿e l547 r・B JIIITBy, 6bmnocJI al-I、KHH3b
n.I/I・myiiCKIIii) 198.
U

EcJIH B rpaMoTax cy3,maJIbcKIIM ,eonaJI4II IIMeJII1cb B

BHJy
3eM@JIH
Cy3nlaJIbcKoro,
BJIa八HMIIpcKoro,
KocTpoMcKoro
II CTapoAy6-P兄nOJIOBcKOro ye3HOB, To IMIITPOBO-KamllHCKHe
II TBePCKHe BJIa八eHHH nOJIyIIIIJIHnPHBHJIerHH B rPaMOTaX

Tpollie-CeprmeByl99,HllKQJIbcKoMy
｣TecHo皿cKoMy200,
TBepcltoMy
OTMmUKoMy20!
KmP"JIo-BeJIo3epcKoMy202
H
MoHa-

cTbl”M・KH”JIJIo-BeJIo3epcK皿
KHpHJIJIo-BeJIo3epcKHII
MoHacTbIpb，K
MoHacTbIpb, KToMy2Ke，
ToMy ]Ke,
406HJIcH HeKOTOPblx JIbrOT IJIH cBOIIx BoJIorOnlCKHx BJIa,UeHMIii 203. H3 ceBepHblx KoI)noPauHH IIMeHIIO OH OKa3aJICH
U

B ueHTpe BHIIMaHIIH npaBIITeJIbCTBa・KpoMe Hero, HMMyHH-

TeTHblerPaMOTblHaCeBel)llble3eMJIIInOJIyIIIIJ皿HIIKoJIbcKII#I
195 UrAHA, *. CIIaco-EB*IIMbeBa M-pH, KH l｡ J1JI 417-419 0d; Aﾙ1,
T. I, Nb 148.

196 <<AKTblHcToPHIleclMe, onH,callHble H. M．KaTaeBblM H A. K. Ka6aHoBblM", JYb l/28, 1/29.
197 AI'I, T. 1, Nb 145.

198 HCPJI, T. XIII, nepBaH noJIoBIIHa, Crp2 155.
199 UrAHA, rKa no UMHTpo!By, Nh 68/3780.
200 K.O,KaJ'aimoBH【1.yKa3. coII., cTp. llO-115.
201 "TBepcKIIe
ユ rv6epHcKIIe Be,moMocT", 1854, Nb 50, [IacTb lleo巾皿”Ⅱb-

HaFI, .cTp. 153-154, rp. 4; cI)' TaM ]Ke, cTp. 153, rp. 2 (A巾al-IacbeB-

cKoMy八eBHqbGMyMO'HaC'rbI!PlO).
202 rnE Q̲IV-1 136, JIJ1. 727-732.
203 PIIB, T. 32, Nb l65.

365

t

､

Kol),11M"lCj<iliIMoHacTbll)b204,nyCTblIIIIBaccllalIoBaCTpofliHa205,AJIeKcall41]4CBIIpcKoro206,ycTIo>KcKIlemePkBﾙI
〃

Po>MecTBeHcKaH II HHKoJIbCKaH 207.

CMapTal547r・IvIaBHOeBHHMaHIIenPaBHTeJIbcTBa6blJIo IIepeHeceHo c cy34aJIbcKMx *eo"JIoB Ha lo)KIIblx. Onac-

HaH BHemHenoJIIITIIIIecKaFI o6cTaHoBKa Tpe60Ba.JIa ycIIJIeq

?

I･IHH III)aBHTeJ1bcTBeHHblx IIO3皿" B Cpene *eOnaJIoB

IO)KHO曲oKpaHHbL KpynHeAmIIe nonaTHble, TaMO)KeHHble H

cy4eqlbIe npHBHJIermli 3necb nQIIyqIM KammpcKllii TpomU-

K"
BeJIoIIecoUKHii
MoHacTblpb208.P皿IIecy血MbIx
rpaMOT
6blJI BblnaH Io>KHblM HoMe皿HKaM 209.

npe八ocTaBJIeHIIe 皿enPblXTaPXallHDIXrPaMOT4yXOBソ

HDIM｡eOnaJIaMHeCMOMOCnaCTIinPaBPITeJIb@TBOrJIHIICKHX
oT B3PblBa KJIaCcOBOi 60Pb6bl, HpIIe BcerO nPoFIBHBmerocH
Bo BpeMFI IIIoHbcKoro' BoccTaHHH 1547 r. B MocKBe. OnHa

>KaJIoBaHHaH rpaMoTa, BblnaHHaH 28 1110HH l547 r., y>Ke
HOC"e nanleHHH nPaBIMTeJIbCTBa rJIIIHCKMX, IIMeeT, Ka>KeTCJI,
u

HeKOTOPoe OTHOmeHIie K MePOnPlIHTHHM ｡eOnaJIbHoji BepxymKm,

HanPaBJIeHHblM

Ha

nOnaBJIeHHe

MOCKoBCKOrO BOC-

cTaHIIFI. rPaMOTa nOKa3blBaeT, IITo MOCKOBCKOe BOCCTaHHe

IIMeJIo mHPoKIiji OTI<JIIIK B 6JIH3JIe>Ka山Hx paiioHax KaK Mo-

CKOBCKOrO,TaKH旦MHTpoBcKoroI13BeHIIroponcKoroye3"､oB.HenapoMB3ToMaKTe,Bb皿aHHOMByCJIOBHHxHeCOヅ

BceM 3aTIIxmero BoccTaHIIfl B MocKBe, TpoHUe-CepmeBy
MOHacTblI)IoPa31)e山a&JIOCbnPeCJIe40BaTbKl)ecTbJIHHroPOn-

cKI'Ix JIIOneii,ceKymllxMOHacTblPCKMePO皿HBHa3BaHHblx
ye34aX,HnPHBO"ITbnOiiMaHHblXBBe川iKOKHfl>KGCKH耐cy4

TpomuKII#
MoHacTblpI,
noJIyqaJI,TaKMM
o6pa30M,
Bo3MML
IIOCTb,3a皿11皿aRCO6CTBeHHble
I1HTePeCbl,
3KTHBHO60POTbcH ,c IIapy皿MTeJIFI MH巾eO"JIbHOro nPaBoHoP皿Ka・

PaccMaTPmBaeMbliraKT6bIJ!BbI4aily>Keil6gbIMnPaBII-

TeJIbcTBOM:̲ rPaMOTy《nPHKa3aJI》且BOI)eUK嘘 瓜aHHJIO POMaHoBHq lOpbeB210.
２０４
２０５ JIOI41'I,Co6P・Kol)知"KeMcKoroM-",Nb6.
AH, T. I, JVb l47.
２０６

J10HI/1,
AKToBbleKHMI､H,onHcaHHbleB.4rpeKoBbIM,JVb27,
皿狐. 36 06,-- 42 06,

勿
一
卯

７M．9g'[P"､clt""geMembHWL｡bIT̲EelIbCKorO
HaCe%ifIpyCcKOro
８CeBepaBXVI-XVIIIBeKax.CI̅I6．41913,CTp.315-316,npIW.2.

Ur4","3̲noKal'ImPe,Nb7/5769,
9/57|71;̅rBJT,.̅'1，P.KH.535,

"J1. 628-629 06.
９ 《AKTIJI IOmKoBa>D, JYb l54-158.
２０
０
２１

TBJT, Tp. KII. 527, Nb 295.

366

OIIGBIInlIo,PoMaHoBbl-IOI)beBbl,6J111>Kaiilullel)04cTBel{IIMKli llaPfI no >KeHe, 3aHMMaJIn PyKoBo"Illee noJIo>K"IEB
ⅡpaBHTeJIbCTBeBTe'IeHHelle”O瓜aCMOʻCKOBCKOrOBOCCTaH1畑且o MapTa l548 r. H ellle no3JHee coxpaHHJIH cBoHⅢo-

cTbL B >KaJ1oBaHHblx rpaMoTax 3Toro BI)eMeHII RpTpellaloT-

CH
HO皿Mcm
ynoMHHyTdro
maHHJILI
PoMaHoBH[Ia21!
H
BacHJIIIfl MPIxaiiJIbBIILIa2!2 10pbeBblx. BnoJIHe八OHycTIIMa TaK]Ke

To[IKa 3pellllFI A. A、3HMIIHa o npII6JIH)KeHHII K BJIacTH
mv曲cKM;< B 1548 r. Bo3Mo>KHo, nocJIe nonbITKII 6ercTBa
ざ

M." B. rJIIIIIcKoro B JIMTBy myiIcKHe, 4eHcTBIITeJIbHo, JleJIwIII BJIacTb c PoMaHoBblMH-IOpbeBblMM.
I/IMMvHHTeTHblx rpaMoT, BblAalIHblx BeJIHKQK">KecKI1M

npaBMTejibcTBoMcmlOJ1H1547r八o(beBpaJ1Hl548r.BKJIIo-

qiiTeJIbHo, HaM II3BecTHo 29:>KaJIoBaHHblx23(nyxoBHbIM
KopnopaUIIflM l8, II3 KoTop｡Ix̲o八Ha He coxPaHIIJIacb, cBeT-

CKIIM JI皿aM 5) , yKa3Hblx 6 B TeIIeHHe BTopoi noJIoBIIHb1
1547 r・BblnaIIa lIMMyHHTeTHblx rPaMoT 6blJIa cBfl3aHa c 3antaIIeWi nOn,aBJIeHHH KJIaccoBOii 60Pb6bl B UeHTPaJIbIIblx ye3U

nax PacnPocTPaHeHIie m3yqaeMPlX lICToIIllljKOB no y@34aM,
U

HenOcPeUcTBeHHoOKPy>KaB皿IIMMocKBylIMocKoBcK"ye3n,
1

naeT HHTepeCHble ll HoBble nPKa3aTeJlbCTBa TorO (PaKTa, [ITo
MOCKOBCKOe BoCCTaHI1e - J1IⅢub Hali60JIee "KaFI BCnbImKa

pa3BePHyBmeroCFI rOPa3Ao uIIIPe HaPomHoro nBM>KGHIIH.
Oco6eHHo I)enKHM B IIcToPIHI >KaJIoBaHHblx rpaMoT HBJIe･
HPIeM 6blJIa BblnaKIa 3HaIIHTeJ1bHOrO IIHCJIa rPaMOT Ha MOCKcBcKme 3eMJIH. B MocKoBcKoM ye3ne Pa3Hble nplIBHJIe｢MH

i6MIJImTpome-CepbrmeB2!3,-CaBBb-CTop"eppKMii2'4,
ゾ

CMMoHoB215
MoHacTblpil,
nonb!
4BopLIoBblx
ceJI216・HHTepeCHo, IITo B rpaMoTax CHMoHoBy II CaBBo-CTopo>KeBcKoMy Mo･

IIaCTblPHM, KaCalO皿HXCfl MOCKOBCKJIX BOTqHH, OCHOBI･IOe
U

BHIIMa､HMe; KaK II B TpollUKoih rPaMoTe, 06pauLeHo Ha 60pb6y
ｰ c HaPymllTeJIFIMⅢnpaB巾eOnaJ1bHOii CO6CTBellHOCTI'I U

〆

c nopyO皿HKaMI1．

KioMe MocKoBcKoro ye3ma, B 3To BpeMR Ha6JIIoEeTcH

nPHCTaJIbHbl曲HHTePeC
nPaBIITeJ1bCTBa
COCenHIIM
K
̲IIePe-

c.iaBJIb-3aJIeccKoMy; nMIiTpoBcKoMy, KamliHcKoMyi yrJIImKoMy, Py3cKoMy; 3BeHIITopoIcKoMy ye34aM. rpaMoTbl
2'1 X|n, I, Nb 549, 556, 559, 584.
212 TaM JKe, JYb 563.

213 rBJI, TIp. KH. 527, Nb 295.
2'4 UrAnA, rKa no 3BeHMropony, Nb l7/4691.
215 AA3, T, I, Nh 216.
216 AII, T. I, Nb 149.
367

BblAaBaJIMcI, B ocHoBHoM MoIlacTblpFIM (Tpo皿e-Cepl､IIeBy 217, nel)ecJIaBcKoMy naHwIoBy 218, IMIITpoBcKoMy nec､HO皿CKOMy 219, yrJI皿KoMy A(PaHacbeBcKoMy220, CaBBo-CTo-

po>KeBcKoMy22') . Te >Ke TePpHToplM d)IIrypllpyloT B >KaJIoBal-IHblX rPaMOTax J,pyrmM巾eOAaJIaM - MIITPOnOJIHIIbeMy
jIoMy (nl)oe3>KaFI Ha nl)oBo3 pbl6b1 oT Hm〉KHero HoBropoAa
八o MocKBbl) 222, KHH3Io M. M. Ky6eHcKoMy (TapxaHHo-Hecy"MaH Ha CeJIO B nMHTpoBcKOM ye3nle) 223, nOMe皿HKaM PaXMaHIIHoBbIM (Hecy皿MaFI Ha noMecTbe B IMHTpoBCKOM ye3八e)
224.
1/IMMyHIITeTIIble rPaMOTbl lIO3BOJIFIIOT BbmeJIIITb PI nPyI､oil
⑪

一

一

P

G

一

一

paIIOII OOJIbmOrO OOOCTI)eHIIFI KJIaCCOBOII OOPbObl B 3TO BPe-

MH - HoBropo且mHoBropoIcKylo 3eMJIIo. HcKJIIoIIHTeJIbHaH
巾OPMyJIa O 6e3'ypoIIHOii noIIMKe JIIIxHx JIIoneii,皿IIpoKo npo:班K皿ajl B )KaJIOBaHHble rPaMoTbl

HoBroPOncKIIM

MOIIaCTbl-

"M l547-1548 rr., flBJIHeTcH xapaKTepllblM cBImeTeJIbcTBoM aKTIIBH3aUlM aHTIIq)eo"JIbHoro nBH>KeHIIH B HoBro-

Po,IcKOii 3eMJIe. IIMMyHIITeTI-lble rpaMoTbl Bo BToPoii lToJIoBHHe l547 r. noJIyKIIIJIII MoHacTbIpH CoJIoBeUKIIii (Ha ,nBop B

HoBropone225, ToproBble 3KcneXIIuHH II 3eMJIII B HoBroponcKoM I! nBIIHcKoM ye3"x226) II Tpo皿e-CeprlIeB (Ha ceJIo
B HoBoTop2KCKOM ye3ne227) .
TaKI1M o6pa30M, nPH noMo皿H HMMyHHTeTIIblX rPaMOT
npaBIITeJIbcTBo PoMaHoBblx-IOpbeBblx nblTaJIocb 3apyqPITbCFI no"eP>KKOii 60JIbmOrO KPyra (jeO"JIOB B nleHTPaJIbHblx

ye3nax M B HoBroponcKo2 3eMJIe 4JIH nomaBJIeHHfI qpe3BbI-

IIaiiHO 6yPHo Pa3BePHyBhleiicH B 3To BPeMFI COUlIAJIbHoii
一

一

oopbobI.

B HHBape - (beBpaJIe l548 r・rPaMOTbl BblXaBaJIIICb
nOIITI1

McKJIIo'IIITeJ1bHO

IIa

3eMJIH

B

Io>KHblx

H

BoCToIIHblx

2'7 rnB, Co6p. aKToB PI rpaMoT, Nb 1-130.

218 B. r且o6PoHPaBoB. yKa3.CoII., npIIn., cTp. 24-25, Nb 8.
219 K.①、K aJI a imo B IIII. yKa3, coII., cTp. 116.
220 UrAnA, d). I<alIUe.JIFTplIII CeHaTa, KH. 192, ･J1. 259.

221Ⅱ｢AJIA, rKa no 3'BGHI汀oI)oXy, Nb l7/4691.
222 Aq)3HX, L1. 1, JVb 244.
223 AA3, T. I, Nb 215.
224 <<AKTbl lOmKoBa>, Nb 159.
225 JIOMH, Co"oB、136, nn. 143-144, N@ 26.

226 40,cH巾e ii. yKa3. co[I., K1. 111, cTp. 7-17.
227 UrAIA, rKa no To,p>KKy, JVh 4/12046; cM. raK>Ke rpaMoTbl oKTH6pH
1547 r. TopolleUKoMy TI)oliUKoMy (UrmA, (j．834,
oll. 3, JYb
J1.20-20 06.)ⅡユeKa6pll I547 r.I<openbcKoMy HIIKoJIaeBcKoMy
11, JYb 640) MoHacTbl|l)fIM.
368

1919,
(Xn,

ye3"x (PfI3allcKoM, TyJIbcKoM, KaulUPcKoM, KoJIoMeH･
EKoM, MypoMcKoM, BaJIaxoHcKoM)228. yKpenJIeHIIe [o>KHblx
I"I BOCTOLIHblX OKPallH 6blJIO HeO6xO414MO B yCJIoBIIFIx nOnrOTO B KHHnPOBenel-IHH Ka3aH|CKIIX HOxOIOB.

3aMeTHblji, xoTFI e皿e H He PamHKaJIbHblii, nOBopoT
B nPaBHTeJIbCTBeHHOinOJIHTI'IKe B OTHO山elII'III MMMyHIITeTa

npoM30meJI BecHoM l548 r. I/1.m・CMHpHoB y,ma'IHo BblneJIHJI MapT l548 r. KaK Bexy B IIcToPIM cocTaBa pyccKoro
npaBMTeJIbcTBa. npoaHaJIII31叩OBaB CnHCOK J1MU, KOTOPblM
IIPenHa3HaIIaJIMCb

nOmaPKII

HOBrOPOnCKOrO

aPxI,IenMCKOIIa,

OH nPli皿eJI K BblBOny, IITO y>Ke B 3To BPeMH B nPaBMTeJIb-

cTBo Bxo,nHJIII ｡ r. II A. ･ AnameBbl, a 60HPCKIfii COCTaB
nPaBIITeJIbCTBa
H3MeHHJICH
B
CTOPOHy
IIOrO BeCa
HeTHTyJIOBaHHOrO OOHPCTBa
〆

ノ

yBeJIH[leHHH
yaeJIb(B nePByIO OLIePeZb

UapcKo曲po皿M) 229.
3a MapT­瓜eKa6pb l548 r. HaM H3BecTHa 21 BeJIIIKoKHFI>KecKaH HMMyHHTeTHaH rPaMoTa: )KaJIoBaHHblx 17 (nyxoB･
HblM KopnopamiflM I4, H3 KoToPblx IBe He coxpaHIIJIHCI,,
cBeTcKHM JIImaM 3, H3 KoTopblx cIHa IIe coxpaHIIJIacb) ,
yKa3Hblx 4. rpaMoTbl oxBaTblBaloT UeHTpa,mbHble II CeBep-

ソ

H1>Ie ye34bl PyccKoFO rOcynaPCTBa.

BbmaHHafl l9 MaPTa l548 r. 06UaH zKaJIoBaHHaH
rpaMoTa KIipIIJIJIo-BeJIo3el)cKoMy MoHacTI)IpIo Ha Bce BoTIIHI-Ibl He COnePJKaJIa nOnaTHblX OCBO60>KmellIIi 230. npeKI)a̲
UaBmaH cBoe UeiicTBHe l7 MapTa l548 r. 06山afI TapxaHHafl
rpaMoTa TpoHUe-CeprlieBy MoHacTblpIo He 6blJIa nonTBep>K,meHa 231. Bo3Mo)KHo, B nopFI4Ke KoMneHcaUlm Tpol,lUK"
MoHacTblPb. IIoJIyIIIIJI 6 anPeJIH I548 r. o[IeHb Uenpylo TapxaHHylo rPaMOTy Ha nlBoPoBoe MecTo I1 JIePeBHIO B nBIIH-

cKoMye3ne232..npIIBceil山emPOcTH3TorOno>KaJIoBaHHFI
U

OHO,

KOHeIJHO,

HM

B

KOeII

〆

MePe

He

郡

OblJIO

3KBIIBa､meHTHOM

２
２８ Xn, I, Nh 570-574.
２
２９

1'1. I'1. C M M p ll o B. O[IepKH IIo'wIH'1,HIIeCKOii HCTOPMM PyCCKOTO rOCy-

JapCTBa. M.- ,几, 1958, cTI). 169-179. noKa3aTe･｢11)Ho, IITo B HoH6I)e
1548 r. (a BeponTIIo, II HecKo｡IIbKo paHbme) yrJ11IIIK11M JBopeUK|IM
6bl&mの. r. AnameB (A. A. 3 II M II H O cocTaBe lIBoI)UoBblx yLII)G>KJIeHIIH PyccKoro TocynapcTBa KoHIla XV II XVI B.­《HCTOl) M LIeCKI{e

3anHcKH>, T. 63, cTp. 197). 40"KHocTb yrJI皿KOrO ABOPeUKOrO IIMeJIa
oco60e 3HaLIeIIMe B cHJ1y Toro, ､ITo yrJIHL{ (BMecTe c HeKoTopblMH
npyrHMII Tei)pHTo|PHflMH) ｡oPMaJIbHo nPHHanJ1e)KaJI 6paTy
HBaHa lV - IOpIIIo.
２３０ JIOI/1H, Co61). merpeHa, Nb 6.
２３１
rB几Tp. KH. 527, Nb 288.
２３２

《C60pHIIK

』4

rpaMoT

C 、 M ， K a m Ta H o B

KoJIJerHH

3KoHoMMM>',
369

T･I1. J1., 1929, Nb ll8a.

⑭

nJIaTOH 3a yTPaTy JIbrOTHOrO CTaTyCa OCHoBHblM KOMnJIeKcOM

TpOl皿KIIxBoTqlIH.HaH60JIee HpKo HoBopoT BIIMMyHIITeTじ

坐 nOJITBeP>KnteH"
ljql[ noJIMTI"g gKa3aJICH Ha xaPaKTePe

!fl anpeJIH l543= r. TapxaHHo-o6poIIHEIx rpaMoT1547 r.
HIIKoJ1bcKoMynecHom6KoMym.TBepcKoMyOTMHuKoMv
ジ

MOHaC.rblPHM,OCBO60流ユaBmIIxMoHaCTblPcKIIeBJTaneHIIFIOT
ご O6pOKa233･
HMcKⅢx且eHerH瓜PyrHxnO1aTeH
PyrHx nonaTeII BBcqeT
C[IeTyn｡JIaTbl
VnJIaTbl
o6poKa 233.
B anpeJIbcKIIx nonTBepmIITeJIbHbIx nomlicfIx 1548 f oTMeePeBon nOnaTem Ha O6PoKx巾OPMyJIIIPOBaJIcfl
O6PoK
Hmc別ⅡePeBo且no瓜aTeHHa
IIPIIHUIIn B3HMaHIIFI HMcKIIx AeHel、且al-I皿HKaMH <C COX…Ⅱ0

1)03Bony, no"IIeMy KoToporo rony IIMeTUa Ha coxy>. OIHaKo
U

3ToT

cJIyIIaH

orPaHIIIIeHHH

nonaTHoTo

HMMVHIITeTa

6bl<JI

l548r、HBJ1eHHeMHcKJIIoIIHTenbHblM，HHKaKHx叩yrHx
JUIH
ノUIH
1548
n
HBJ1eHHeM
McKJIIoqIITe"bHbIM,
HHIIaKHxnPyrmx
cJIemoB nePecMoTPa cTal)blx TapxaHHblx rpaMoT B l548 1､、
Mbl He l-IaXO1HM 234.

3aToHocJIeanpeJIH1548r.HeHa6JIIonaeTcHmH1)oKoii
u

BblnaIHI HOBblx TaPxaHHblx rPaMOT. JIHmb oTHOcH山Hecfl

KHIoJIol5481､．》KaJIoBaHHblerPaMoTblBoJIoroncKoMy

rJIym皿KoMy235IIKoCTpoMcKoMyKopHRJImeBy236MoHacTbipHM conlep>KaJIH ocBo60)KnteHIIe oT HMa. Bo3Mo>KHo, KaKHeTO HO4aTIble nPIIBHJIerlJII COneP>KaJIII HeCoxPaHIIBmHecH

I､I)aMoTbl
MocKoBcKoMy
HoBo且eB咽beMV（HoH6”l548r.)237

1{Cnaco-EB(I)IIMbeBy(1548/49r)238MoHacTblbIIMnpdBII233 K.の、K a JI 4im o B II I1. yKa3. cotl., cTp. llO-116, Nb lll-IV;
"TBepcKIie"6eUI!cKMePenoMocT",
1854,.JYh50,[IaCTLHeo巾皿HaJIb．
HafJ, 'cTp. 153-154, rp､ 4.

2342ceHTH61)el548rmBgllVnonTBepmmJIHecy"MylorpaMoTyl510n

BepxHep2Tp9BcWMy neTponaEJoBCKoMy MbliacfblPld nciton6KOfd
ye3Ja (C. M. K a m T a m o q nBe >KaJ16BamHble rpdMoTb[ 1510ro"
HCKOBCKHMMOHaCTblPFIM.­《3aIIIcKI!OTneJIaPyKOnmCeirOCynaPCT-

ge!IHoii6I16JImoTeKMHM̲BMJIeHmma>,Bbm24M"
1961,cT6266j

3T0 no|4TBep>KneHMe, 06ycJIoBJTeHHoe g 3HaLIMTeJIbudii Mede dHemH&g

noJI!ITMIIecKIIMIIo6cToFITembcTBaMH(TaM>Ke,cTp.244-245),HecToIIT
B

cBH3H

c

nombITKaMH

orPaHH[leHwI

nonaTHoI,o

HMMVHIITeTa. ynoMM-

I-'aeNIOe B. myJI皿EM . no4TBePKneHIIe nByX TPo皿K" rPaMoT 1485 r.
B <1548'' m (W. S ch u l z. Die lmmunilat !hl Nord6s{lichen RIlSSg

land des l4. und 15．Jahrh llllderts.­《Forschullgell zLIr Osteuropaischen Geschichte>, Bd 8 Berlin, 1962, S 253｢ B UeiicTBIITeIIbHogTM !IMeJIo MecTP B l549 n (ACSH, T. I, Nb 517-518).

" AMB̲pp E". yKaa coq" [L 1II M" 181 1,bTp 714-723:
2" UrAnA, rKa no KocTpoMe, JYb 47/5014.

237 n A:̲P ag II K o B.Oqel)KIinomcToI)MMon"qHMHb1.M.­几, 1950,
cTp. 455-461.

238<<OnHcHaHKHIIraCnaco-EB巾IIMbeBaM-PH)p.­《E)KeronHMKBJIamKM叩cKoroI､).6I)HcKoro cTaTIIcTIIIIecKoro KoMIITeTa>. BJIa"MIIp, 1878,
c･r:). -18.

370

TeJIbcTBoI548r.co6JIIo八aJIO6OJIbmylOOCTOPO）KI-IocTbBBonl)OCaX IIMMyHI'ITeTHOAⅡOJI IITIIKII．ⅢCⅡOIBOJIb nOnrOTaBJII,I-

BaH 60pb6y c nonaTHblMHⅡPlIBHJIerHHMII KPynl-IblX 3eMJIeBJIanteJIbUeB,

oHo

TeM

I-Ie

MeHee

nPIICJIy皿HBaJIocb K Iix

)KaJIo6aM Ha He3aKoHIIble neicTBHH MecTIIbIx BJIacTe曲, nblTaʻB皿HxcH
xcJIco6HpaTb
co6HPaTbno瓜aTH
no"TH ccMoHacTblpcKHx
MoHacTblpcKHx
BoTIIHH・TaK，
BoTqjlH. TaK,

BHIoI¥l548r.npaBIITeJIbcTBonocJIaJIOyKa3HylorpaMoTy
ゾ

Mo>KalIcKHM roPonoBblM nPHKa3IIIIKaM, oT KoToPblx IIoTPe-

60BaJIo̲WellapymeHHFIJIbroTHoiirpaMoTblCIIMoFIoByMoFIacTblpIo239.BaBrycTel548naHaJTorHIIHaFIyKa3HaH.rpaMoTa 6blJIa OTnPaBJIeHa 60POBcKoMy roPOnPBoMy npHKa3IIIIKy
He3aKoHHO 93HBmeMy fWQ"e nWPrH c TPo皿KIIx KPecTbfIH
ソ

フ

3a JIbroTHblii nJIH HHx 1 547 ro4 240.

CJIenoBaTeJIbHo, xoTH B HoJIHTPIKe l548 r. Mo>KHo BImeTb
ilgIf9TOPble 3JIeMeHTbl OrPaHHqeHHH PaCnPOcTPaHeHHO# B

1547 r. npaKTIIKH oTapxaHHBaHHH, TGM HE M6Hee ee e皿e
HeJIb3H cIIIITaTb HaIIaJIoM cHcTeMaTHIIeCKOi 60Pb6bl c
IICKJIIO'IHTeJIbHblMHnOnaTHbIMII nPHBIMerIIHMⅡ巾eOXaJIOB-

画
EcJIHIIoIIblTaTbcH4aTbo6皿ylOxaPaKTePIIcTHKyrPaMoTaM"1547-1548
rr.,
To
npImeTc別nPli3I-IaTb
HX
KOMHJIeKCOM

I I M M V H H c To B .

HaIIOOJI ee皿enPblX HMMyHHTeTHblx aKToB nePBohⅡOJIoBHHbl

XVIB・rpaMoT¥̲nepBW(Mec皿eBI547r、pa3pe山aJ1m

HeynJIary nonaTeih c ceJI Cy34aJILcKoro noKPoBcKorO MoHa-

cTbIpH241,cnBopoB,cJIo60JoKHceJICnaco-EB巾HMbeBaMoHaCTblpFI242．TaKIIe>Ke皿enPbIeTaPxaHHbIerpaMOTblnOJTV-

IIHJIHTpo皿e-Ceprm"33,
KHpIIJIJio-BeJIo3ephKmii244,
Tp6-

皿"̲5e"eCgJKmi24､MoHaCT叩M,
nyCTblHbAJIeKCaHni)a
CBHpcKorO 246. B oIHoi yKa3Hoii rpjMoTe l547 r. 66ijIo
BeJIeHoo6eJIHTboTIIonaTeh且BopCoJIoBeUKoroMoHacTbl"
B HoBrOpone 247.

Hap"y CnpllBHJIerwIMII Ha BoT[IIIHbl, nyxoBHble Kop-

IIopaUHII np6HBaJIHcb BbInaIIH HM UenpbIX TapxaHHI;Ix
rpaMOT Ha nPoBo3, KynJIIO II nPona)Ky ToBaPoB・B I546 r.
­­．­­

­■

239rHM，CHM．KH、58，no
Mo】KahcKyJVL5，,JTJI、523o6.-〔ﾌ24
240 ATH. BBIn. I1, M 14.

241 Xn,i, Nb 526､ '527.
242 TaM )Ke, JVb 534, 537.
243 TaM )Ke, Nb 538.
244 TaM ]Ke, JVb 536; cp. Nb 576, 582, 592.
245 TaM )Ke, Nb 545.
246 TaM )Ke, Nb 542.
247 TaM ]Ke, JVb 557.
371

24＊

TaKylo rpaMoTy noJIyIIIM KIipHJIJIo-BeJIo3epcKMii MoHacTblpb. npaBMTeJIbcTBo nl)enPcTaBIIJIo eMy npaBo 6ecnonl
J I I I H H o n P O n a B a T b H Ⅱ O Ky n a T b e > Ke r O I H O B P a 3 H b l x r O P O n a x

20 000 nynpB coJIH 248. TapxaHHo-npoe3>KHe rpaMoTbl B
1547 r. 6bmHBbUallbl TpoIIUKoMy BeJIoneconKoMy 249, Co､I()BeUKOMy250H叩yrHM
MOHaCTblPHM.
MeJ1KHe,He八OcTaToIJHOBJTIIHTeJIbHblemyxOBHbleKOPno･
paumH II B 3ToT nePHOnl He BO BCeX cJIyIIafIx ocBO60>KnaJIHcb

oT no4aTeit. TaK, KpecTbflHe BaccHaHcKoii nycTblHH Kapr()noJIbcKoro ye34a 6blJIHⅡPllHV)KneHbl BbInoJIHHTb rJIaBHble
｢OCynaPCTBeHHble nOBHHHOcTK 25'・C BoTIIIIH HIIKo､rlbcKoro

neCHO皿cKOrO MOHaCTblPFI Pa3PemaJIOCb He mlaTIITb naHb,
HMcKHe

UeHbrH II nPyrme

nOnaTIi

nPII

yCJIOBHII

BIIeceHIIfl

06poKa B rocy4apeBy Ka3Hy 252. noJIHTIIKa皿enporo o6eJIeH1,呪MOHaCTblPCKIIX BOT'IIIH OT rJIaBHbIX HaJIOrOB

nPOBOJJ'I-

JIacb lI B 1548 r. TapxaHHble rpaMoTbl 6blJIH noJIy[IeHbl B
1 548 r. TpoIIUe-CeprmeBblM 253, Tpol,皿KIIM BeJIOneCOUKHM 254,
rJIVmllUKHM 255 MoHacTblpHMI'I.
4

Hapflny c pacmIIPeHMeM nOnaTHOrO HMMyHMTeTa, nPaBMTeJIbcTBo pe3Ko yBeJIwIwIo o6.beM BoTIIIIHHoii lopIIc皿IKumIi
MoHacTblpeii. B rpaMoTe l547 r. KopH)KeMcKoMy MoHacTbll)IO HaMecTHHKaM He Pa31)emaJIOCb Cy瓜HTb HaceJIeHHe MOHa-

cTbipcKHx ABopoB H cJIo6040K <<HH B qeM)D 256. CorJIacHo
rpaMoTe l547 r. Cnaco-EBd)HMbeBy MoHacTblpIo, MoHacTbIpb
U

CymmLI cBOIIX

JIIOmeH II KPeCTbHH<BO BCeM>, <OnPIIIIb lyme-

rv6cTBa>
257.
冒
一

npIIMepbl
舎

noIo6Horo

U

vBeJIHIIeHwI
画

o6'beMa

u

cyneOHoH BJIacTH MoHacTblPeH He enHHHIIHbl.

l'IMMyHHTeTHaH n:oJIHTIIKa npaBIITeJIbcTB l547-1548 rr.，
o[IeBHmH0, 6blJIa cBH3aHa c Pe3KHM yCIIJIeHIIeM cOUmaJIbHo｡

IIOJIIITMIIecKOH

〆

〆

ooPbObl

U

B

I)ycCKOM

rOCynaPCTBe

BTOPOII

noJIoBIIHbl 40-x ro八oB XVI B. BoHpcKIIe npaBHTeJIbcTBa
Bbl6paJI]'I HaII60JIee JIerK砿 ⅡyTb yKPenJIeHHH cBOeiI BJIaCTII-nyTb TecHoro c6@IIIDKeHIIH c MoHacTblpHMH, nPe40248 Xn, 1,Nb511.

249 TaM >Ke, Nb 541.
250 TaM >Ke, Nh 560.
251 TaM >Ke, Nb 532.
252 TaMンKe, M 543, 551.
253 TaM ]Ke, JYb 554, 555, 566, 571.
254 TaM >Ke, Nb 573.

255 TaM )Ke, JVb 583.
256 JIOMM, Co6p. KopFI>KGMcKoro M-pFI, Nb 6.

257 11TAnA,巾. Cnaco-EB(DHMbeBa M-pH, KH. 1, J1JI. 417-419 06
372

CTaBJIHHMOHacTblPfIMmllPOKIienOnaTHbIeH，cyne6Hble
npHBMJ1erHH,
nPaBIITeJIbCTBa
OZIHOBPeMeHHO..naBaJJH
HM
⑥

nPaBo nOCblJIaTb KPeCTbHH B BeJIIIKoKHH>KeCKmli Cym TQJI"o
o"H pa3 B romy. OrPaHIIIIeHIIH KacaJIHcb JIHmb ynOMHHyTOrO Bblme cyna Ha且《JIIIXHMII JIIO八bMH矛．

BrpaM6felIBaHalV,no>KaJIoBaHHoii28fIHBapfI1547r.

HHKoJ1bcKoMy Kop"KeMcKoMy MoHacTblpIo, roBopHJIocb, IITo
naHHblⅢnPmcTaB Bbl3blBaeT MOHacTblPcKIIx KPecTbHH B Cyn
K UapIo oユHH Pa3 B rOn, <<onPlIIIb Tex nleJI, [ITO eCMII nPHKa3aJI 60HpoM cBoKM o6blcKIIBaTII JIIIxKx JIIontem, TaTeII Ii po3U

U

○

60伽mK6B;aKaKoBo6yneTcJIoBoJImxoeB3roBopHTBTaT6｡e

"̅̅P636" II H3, UaPb !I Benli"̲"H3b, no Tex JIlOgeii

nom川onpHcTaBa33anlicbIo> 258.>KaJIoBaHHaHrpaMoT3
〆

1548 r. HoBoneBHIIbeMy MoHacTblplo, conep>KaBmaR nonoo-

Hylo )Ke CTaTbIO, ycTaHaBJImBaJIa nO""HocTb くHIixHx
JIIOnem> CaMOMy UaPIoレ皿Ⅱ瓜BoPeUKOMy BOJIbmOro nBOP⑪

Ua 2" AHaJIorHiHaH ̅｡opMyJIa Haxo皿Tcfl B rpaMoTe l548 r.
U

〃

KopHIIJ1}IeBoji nycTbIHII 260 !I He¥oTopbIM npyrIIM KopnopaU

UH列M. Ha ocHoBaHPIH 3THx cTaTem Mo1KHo cynHTb o BblcoKoM

ⅡOユbeMe BOJIHblHaPOnHOroBo3MymeHIIFI60HPCKHMII BPeMel-I山HKaMIM B KoHUe 40-x roLoB XVI B.
. '

BcJ1encTBHe

BecbMa l'IHTellcHBHoro pocTa MoHacTblpcKHx

｢IpIIBHJ1erlIHB
IpIIBIIJIerllii B 1546-1548
l546-l548rr・qpe3BblqaHHo
rr. qpe3BblqamHoocJIo>KHHJIcfl
､9cJIo)KH"cFI
U

巾bpMyJI">KaJIoBaHHbIxTapxaHHbIxrpaMoT.KMHoroqHc-

JieITHbiM CTaTbHM, ｡IIKCIIPOBaB皿HM ocBo60)KnleHIIe oT pa3-

J1H'IHblX HOBHHHOCTeHHOT BJIa|CTH Cyne6HblX areHTOB nPaU

BIITeJIbcTBa, npH6aBHJIIicb c l547 r. cTaTbm, peryJIHpoBaqr
U

皿He OTHOmeHIIfl MOHaCTblPCKIIX BOTIMH C MIITPOnOJIHIIbelI
⑪

Ka｡enpoii. npaBHTeJIbcTBo cIPeMHJIocb K orpaHHIIeHIIIo
MIITPOnOJIl'IqbePI IOPlIc且HKuHH. B BeJIHKoKHmKecKIIe >KaJIoU

BaHHble rPaMOTbI MOHaCTblPHM CTaJIM ̲ nOna"Tb Pa34eJIbl,

KoTopble(PaKTHIIecKII3aMeHRJIIIco60jiMHTpoHoJIwIbmHMMvHIITeTHble aKTbl, ocBo60)K"BmHe 4yxoBHblx JIIm, >KIIBず

miIx B MOHaCTblPcKHx BOTIIIIHax, oT Ka｡enPaJIbHblX nOmJIHH
II cyna. 3TO, oqe!BHnHO, cIBH且eTeJIbcTByeT o cePbe3Hblx cTOJIK〆

HOBe}IIIHX7 1IMeBmHX MeCTO B OTHOmeHHHx Me>Kmy OoHPcKII-

MH
BPeMeH皿IIKaMmHMHTPonoJIIIToM
MaKapHeM.
npHﾘHHbl paCmlIPeHIIFI (PeO"JIbHOrO IIMMyHIITeTa B HoJIHOM MePe He BblFICHellbl. 3JIeMeHTbl Pa30PeHIIFI OmeJIbHblX
258 JIOI41ｲ, Co6p. KopfDKeM,cKoro M-IpH, Nb 6.
259 3Ta rpaIMoTa momJIa B nepecKa3e rpaMoTbl l573 r. (n. A. C a m HK o B. yKa3. coII., 40KyMGHTLI, Nb l9) .
260 Xn, I, Nb 584.
373

ʼ

Tel)PHTOP", nOHBHBmmecH y)Ke B 20-x ro,nlax XVI B. 261 H

cTaBmme 60JIee 3aMeTHblMII Bo BTopoii noJIoBHHe 30-40-x
rOlOB262,OIIeBH1Ho)HBJIHJIIICbHeMaJIOBa>KHOhnpe且nOCblJIKoII BbUaIIII JIbroTHblx II TapxaHHblx rpaMoT. Mo>KeT 6blTb,
II I)OcT 3aKPenO皿eHIIFI KPeCTbHHCTBa CTaBwI nPaBIITeJIbCTBO

nepeX Heo6xoXIIMocTblo ycHJIHBaTb sKoHoMHIIecKyIo PI noJIIITI1IIecKyIo BJIaCTb leOXaJIOB B nPeneJIax IIx BJIaneHHi.

Pa3BHTHecoUHaJIblloronBII>KeHIIHH60pb6acyneJIaMIITaKH<e BXO皿JIH B KOMHJIeKC ｡aKTOPOB, OnPenleJIHBmMIxIIMMy1-IIITeTIIylo noJIIITHKy, HaKoHen, HenpoIIHocTb noJIo>KeHIifl 60HI)cKHX BPeMeH皿HKoB o6JIerIIaJIa 60pb6y BJIIIFITeJIbHblx巾eoZIaJIoB 3a noJIyIIeHHe HOBblx nPHBHJIemii.

OnHaKo B nepIIoI 60FIpcKoro npaBJIeHIIfl TeH4eHUIIH K
OTCTynJIeHHIO oT OrPaHHIIHTeJIbHblx nPlIHHImOB IIMMyHIITeT-

HoM IIoJIIITHKII noJIyIIHJIa JIHmb Ham60JIee no"Hoe pacKpbl-

TIIe. CaMa >Ke aTa Te"eHnHH He HBJIHeTcFI IIGM-To̅HoB61M.

OHa Ha6JIIonaJIacb y)Ke B noJIIITHKe BacH@JIHFI III H EIIeHb!
rJIHHcKOi. yPOBel-Ib cOUHaJIbHo-9KOHOMIIIIeCKOrO II COUHaJIbHo-noJIHTHIIeCKOrO Pa3BHTHH cTPaHbl l-Ie nO3BOJIHJI noCJIenO-

BaTeJIbHO OCy皿eCTBIITb 3aBeTbl lIBaHa lll.
261 C. A.. m y M a K o B. O630p rpaMoT I<oJIJIerllM 3Ko1I()M1M, BhlⅡ、1I1､

M., 1912, cTp. 92, Nb 308; A3MX, q．1，比90, cTp. 88­89 n np.
262 rB几Tp､KII. 528, Nb 288; PyMHHU. KH､52, JI几52-53 06.; Xn, 1,
Nb 488mnp.

ʼ

3AKXIOIIEH

HE

HoJIBO4H HTorII IICCJIeXO|BaHHIO COUmaJIbHO-HOJIHTHIIecKoi

HCTOP l冊I PoccIM KoHUa XV­nepBohⅡoJIoBHHbl XVI B., Mbl
⑫

OCTallaBJIHBaeMCH nePe,瓜3aranKOII nOnHTHOrO HBH>KeHIIH oT

yH"皿HpoBaHIIblx HopM HMMyHIITeTa 90-x roRoB XV B. K
60raTOi nPaKTHKe mIIPoKIIx HMMyIIIITeTHblx HO>KaJIoBaH"
40-x ronoB XVI B. KoHeIIHo, c皿eP>KaHIIGM sTOrO nPoneCCa
He 6blJIO BO3PO>KneHIIe lIMMyHHTeTa B o6'beMe, cBoAcTBeHBoM anoxe ｡eonaJIbHoii Pa3nPo6JIeHHocTII. C oIHoit cTopoHbl, mJIO BceO6皿ee orpaHI,IIIeHHe cTaPHHHbIx Cy,me6Hblx H
Ho"THblx npaB *eo"JIoB. C npyroii cTopoHbl, Bce qaUe
II IIaUe neJIaJIIICb HcKJIIOKIeHIIH II3 3TOrO TIPaBHJIa.

BPoCaeTCH B rJIa3a ll HeO瓜mHaKOBOCTb Cynte6 UePKOBHOMoHacTblpcKoro II cBeTcKoro IIMMyHHTeToB yH"IIKaU"
II
〃

orPaHII1leHIIe

、

(XOTH

H

HenOJIHble)

IIMMyHHTeTa

CBeTCKIIX

qJeomaJIoB coqeTaJIHcb c pacmlIpeHHeM IIMMyHIITeTa KpynHbIX XyXOBHblX 3eMJIeBJIaneJIblleB・nPIItllIHbl 3TOrO HBJIGHIIH
KPOIOTcH B Cne皿｡HKe 3KOHOMHIIeCKOii H HOJIHTHIIeCKOi POJIH
HePKBII B POCCIMI, BOCTOP>KeCTBOBaBme曲nocJIe Pa3rPoMa
Pe｡OPMa皿oHHo-ryMaHIIcTIIIIecKoro XBHIKel-IIIH KoHna XV B.
U

⑪

｡

I I y K P e m l H B m e l l c B o e x o 3 ” I c T B o I I a n O [ I B e Te C H o H C B H 3 H c
pblHKOM.

>KaJIOBaHHble m yKa311ble rPaMOTbl HOKa6blBalOT nOJIHTHKy npaBHTeJIbcTBa B neiiCTBHII7 T. e. nPHMeHeHHe O6mHX
nPlIHUHHOB K KOHKPeTHblM TePPIITOPlIHM, JIIIUaM H rPynⅡaM
HacemeHHH･

. H3yLIeHIIe IIMMyHIITeTHblX rPaMOT nePBOh ⅡOJIOBHHbl
XVI B. nonBo瓜HT HaC K nOHHMaHIIIO TOrO, HOIIeMy nPaBPITeJIbcTBo H36PaHHO曲Panbl oKa3aJIocb nepel Heo6xoJMMoCTbIO HaIIaTb CTO､mb PemHTeJIbHylO 60Pb6y 3a JIHKBⅢ且auHIO
MoHacTblpcKIIx npl'IBHJIerlIi H na>Ke BHecJIo B Cy4e6HI,IK

1550 r. cTaTblo o6 0TMeHe TapxaHoB. B ron<bl 60HpcKoii
375

PeaKU畑中eonaJIbHblih (rmaBHblM o6pa30M MoHacTblpcKIIi)
U

HMMyHIITeT PacmHPIIJ1cFI HO TaKOH CTeneHH, [ITo UeHTPaJIIi-

3aTOPCKOe nPaBIITeJIbCTBO He MOrJIO naJIee TePneTb nOXI06HOe nOJIO>KeHIIe Beme曲. OIHaKo [IeM KoHIIIIJIHcb nonblTKH

BHOBb OrPaHIIIIIITb H yHII,H皿POBaTb HMMyHIITeT B CeI)eﾕmHe

XVI B., HoKa3aJIa nocJIenoBaBmaH onpHIIHHHa. TaKoii 3Hr3arOO6Pa3Hbli nyTb Pa3BIITIIFI IIMMyl冊ITeTa OnPeneJIFI&mCH B
KoI･IeIIHOM CqeTe

nPOTIIBOPeIIIIBblM

XaPaKTePoM

3'BO"loUIM

*eOnaJIIi3Ma B POCCHm①OPMHPoBaHIIe cOCJIOBHorO cTPOfl
npOHCXO且mJIO 3Aecb Ha 6a3e Bo3HIIKaBmerO KPenOc'THHIIeCTBa, HO nPH COxPaHeHIIH nOJIHTHIIeCKHX IIHCTHTyTOB ｡eOnaJIbHOrO cTPOH. nOnblTKa BTIIcHyTb HoBble KPenOcTIIIIIIecKIie OTHOmeHIIFI

B

PaMKII

CTaPblx

HOJIHTHIIecKHx

PIHcTHTy-

U
〆

TOB cHOCoOcTBOBaJIa, C OnHOH CTOPoIIbl, Pa3JIO)KeHHIO caMHX

3TIIx HHCTIITyTOB (B TOM IIHCJIe lI HMMyHHTeTa) , nP皿aB”
IIM IIaCTHonPaBOBOM xaPaKTeP, C nPyrOi cToPOHbl, 04)OPMJIFIJIa 3JIeMeHTbl xlaCTHOii co6CTBeHIIOcTII B BHne nOJIIITHIIGcKHX
U

n pHBIIJIerlIII-

B XVI B. 3ToT npoUecc o6pa30BaHIM cocJIoBHoro cTpofl
HaxOHIIJIcH Ha PaHHeii cTa皿畑, KOrna nPe>KHHi llMMyHIITeT
Pa3JIHIIHblx 3eMJIeBJIaneJIbUeB H KOPnOPa皿Ii ellle He Mol、
nPeBPaTHTbcH B o6皿ecoc､HoBHoe npaBo. B pa3BHTHII IIMMyu

HI1'reTHoH ⅡoJIIITHKH

〆

nOOe>KnaJIII

nO3TOMy

TO

TeHnteHUIM,

nPemBOCxH皿aB皿He a6coJIFoTH3M (yHH(DIIKa"H II cTporoe
O叩aHIIIIeHIIe IIMMyHHTeTa ) , To nPyraH JIIIHIIH, KOTOPafl

6blJ1a o6ycJIoBJ1eHa coxpaHeHIieM 3KoHoMIIIIecKoii pa31Po6JIeHHOCTH
cTPaHbl
lI
He3aBePmellHOCTblo
UecKOH UeHTPaJIII3aUHH.
⑪

nPOUeCCa

nOJIIMTH-

CnMC0KCoKPAmEH

Mレ！

ApxMBI,IIKapxmBI･11jleco6paHm別
I,ABO - rocynlal)cTBel-IHblii apxIKB BJ1a4MMIII)cKom o6JIacTII
rAKO - rocynaPcTBeHHblii a'I)xHB Ka几HHIIHcKoii o6LnacTM

rBJT- Omei- byKonllceii TocynapcTBeHHoih 611dmmoTeKM CCCP
HM. B. Ii. JIeHIIHa B MocKBe

rHM - OTnleJI pyKoIIIIceii rocynapcTBeHHoro IIcTopl･ltlecKoro My3eH
B MocKBe

rKS - rpaMoTbl KoJIJIerIIII 3KoIIoMIIII B UrAHA
rnB - OMeJI pyKoHIIceii rocy"pcTBelJHoii ny6JIIIIIIIoii 6116JIMoTeKII
IIM. M. E. CaJITblKoBa-皿e"IIHa B JIeHIIHrPa,me

JIOHH­ApxIIB JIeHIIHrpaXcKoio oTneJIeHIIfY HHcTIITyTa lIcTol)MM AH
CCCP

OJInn - Co6Pa'llIe O6皿eCTBa

@mo6IITeJIeHノIPeBHeii nIICbMeHIIoCTII

B rI̅1B

onm­OTﾉleJI nIICbMellllblX IICTO[1HIIKOB rlIM

naTp.- nfITI)llaPlllee co61)all!ie B rliM

n且CJI-njliKd3Hble meila cTaPbIX JleT B UlZMA
noron;.- Co6paH'Ie (《nPeBJTexPa|HIIJIH皿e>') H. n noro皿Ha BrnB
PyMHIIn.- Co6paHHe H．n. PyMHHueBa B rBJI
CiIM- (D. CMMoHoBa MoHacTbIpH B̲rl'IM
Cn6. n/A - Co6I)aHIIe pyKomlceii CaHKT-neTep6yprcKoi! JIyxoBHoii aKJAEMIIH B rnB

Tp.­申. Tpo皿e-CeprmeBa MoHacTbIpfl B rBJI ((P 3031
UrAJA - UeHTpaJIbllblii

rocy"pcTBelIHblii

apxIIB

jlPeBIIHx

aKToB

B MocKBe

UrA r. MocKBbl - UeHTpa｡JIbHbIi rocy"pcTBeHHblii apxIIB E MocKehl
UrMA - UeHTpaJIbIIblii rbcynlapcTBeHHblii IIcTopIIIIecKIIil al)xIIB CCCP
B JIeHIIHrPanle.
Ⅲ3再aH皿H

AA3­《AKTbl, co61)aHHble B 6116JIIIoTGKax H apxIIBax PoccIIiipKoii lIM-

neplIIIApxeorpa(しHIIecK'oIo3Kcne且皿IieIoI'IMIIepaToI)cKojiAKanleMIIH
HaVK>, TI Cn6., 1836; T. 111．Cn6., 1836.

ATP一二<<AKTLI, oTHocH皿HecFI JIo rpa7KLaHCKOII paC]1paBI.I JIPeBHeii PoccHH》. Co6Pa,rlHH皿aJI A. enpToB-LIexoBcKHi, '1，. 1. KHeB, 1860.
A3P­《AIKTbI, OTHOCJI皿HecJI K IIcTopmll 3a|naIIHoM PoccI川, CO6paHIIble

II H3JIal[IIbIG Apxeorpa(しⅡ【IecKoIo KoMIIccIieIo>", T. II. Cn6.，1 848
25 C. M. I<alu'raIIoB

377

AI1­《AKTbl IIcTopII[IGcKIIe, co61)alIIII)ie l[ ]13"HIIble Apxeorl)al)1I[IecKoIo
KOMIICCI1el()>, T. 1，11. Cn6., 1841.

《AKTbl lO山KoBa》­《AKTI>I XIII-XVII BeKoB, 111)eJIc'1､aBJIeHllble B Pa3p皿Hbl曲nPIIKa3 11PeJlcTaBM1.enflMﾚI CJIy>KI皿blX (baMIl:mhnoCJIe OTMeHbI MecTHH[IecTB”・H3ユallbI
MeHbI
MecTHII[IecTBa>. H34allbI AJIeKcaH叩oMIO山KoBblM．M.,
AJIeKcaH"oM IOmKoBblM
1898.
AC31'i­《AKTbl coUlia@JIbHo-aKoIIoMII[lecKoil IIcToI)Im CeBepo-BocToqHoji
pycII KoHUa XIV - Ha[la@JIa XVI B.>,T. 1.M.­几, 1952; T. 11. M.­
J1., 1958; T. 111. M.­几, 1964.

AIH一《AKTbI, oTHoc兄山I1ec兄K I'ICTOI)HHTFIMOTO HaceJIeHHH B MOCKOBcKOM roCy,UaPCTBe>, II3,nlaHHble M. 4IJHKOHOBblM, Bbln. II. lOPbeB,
1 897.

A･3 MX­《AKTbi (I)eoJla@IIbHoro 3eMJIGBJI"eHIM I1 xo3"cTBa XIV-XVI
BeKoB>, {1. 1. M., 1951; q. 11. M, 1,956; q. 111. M., 1961.
AIO­《AK'rbl lop皿叫lecKMe, 11｡ml! Co61)allMe (1)oI)M cTal)IIHHoI､() JIeJIoll l)oH3Bo4cTBa>. CH6., 1838.
AIOB­《AKTbI, oTHoc兄皿Hec凡凡O IOpli且HIIec|KorO 6bl'1､a mpeBHeii pOCCml>',
T. I. Cn6., 1857; T. II. Cn6., 1864;.T. 111. Cn6．, 1884.
TBHHn­《rPaMoTbl
BeJIHKoro
HoBrOponaⅡ ncKoBa)D. M.-J1., 1949.

且AH­<且o!noJIHeHIifl K AKTaM IIcTopIILIecKPIM, co6PaHHble II II3JaHHble
Apxeorpaq)II'IecKolo KoMHccHeIo)', T. I. Cn6., 1846.
且H且r­<且yXOBHbleH且OroBoPHble rPaMoTbl Be.）IHKIIx II yUenbHblx KI･IH3ek XIV-XVI BB.>. M・­J1., 1950.
>KMIO­《>KypHaJI MMHIIcTepcTBa IocTIIIII1I1),.

3EepHHcK砿一B.B、3 B e p li H c K M ii. MaTepllaJIbl lJIFI IIcTopHKo-ToIIorPa*|IIIIecKOI10 11ccJIenPBaHIIR O nPaBOCJIaBIIblx MOHacTbIPFIx B PoCclMcKohHMnel)HII, T. 1. Cn6., 1890; T. 11.-Cn6., 1892; T. 111. CH6．，
1 897,

Ka6aHoB-《MaTepllaJIbl n() IにToI)HII HHｼKer()PoncKOrO KPaH II3 cToJ1IIIIHblx apxHBoB". l̅Ion pe4. A. K Ka6aHoBa (《且eMcTBIIFI HII>Ke'ropoHcKoii ry6epHcKoil yIIeHoii ai)xHBHoiI KoMIIccIM>', BI]1IT. 3, 11. 1 .
CI60pHHK, T. XIV. HIDKHIIii HoBropo4, 1913).
JT3AK­《JIeTOHIICb 3allHITlin AI)XeOrl)a(bllqe'CKOil KOMM(.CIII"

HnK­《HoB旧opoHcKIIe mlcUoBble KIIII", IBJaHHbIG Apxeorpa(I)IIIIGcKoIO
KoMIICCIIelO>,
1905.

T.

I11.cn6．, 1868; T、1V. Cn6., 1886; T. V. Cn6.,

nK­《,nllcHoBbIe

KHHrll
MocKoBcKOro rOCynaPCTBa>.
noJI
pen.
H.B･KaJ'auloBa , I1．1．ⅡⅢcUoBble KHIIM XVI BeKa, oTJt. I. Cn6.,
1872; oTnt. 2．CH6., 1877.

nPn­《naMFITImKII pyccKoro npaBa>, Bbln. 1. M., 195,2; Bbln. I1.
M., 1953; BbIIn. 111．M., 1955; BbIn. 1V. M., 1956.

ncPJI­《noJIHoe co6paHIIe pycpKIIx JIGTonl,Iceii, II"aHHoe Apxeorpa-

q)IIIIGCKOIO KOMMCCIIGIO>, TⅡ Cn6., 1843; T. 1V. Cn6., 1848;
T. 1V, L1. 1, Bbm.̲ 1. nr., 1915: T. 1V, II. 1, Bbln. 2. JI., 192& T、1V,
M. ̲l̲, BbIn. 3. J1., 1929; T. V, Bbm. 1. J1., 1925; T. VI. Cn6., 1853:
T. V11. Cn6.,1856; T、VII1.cn6．, 1859; T. IX. Cn6., 1862; T. XII.
Cn6., 1901; T・XIII, nepBaH no"oBIIHa. Cn6., 1904; BTopajI no,IIoBHHa. Cn6．, 1906; T. XIV，BToPafl noJIoBHHa. T. XV. Cn6., 1863;
L̲XVIL Cn6.､ l907; T. XVIII. Cn6., 1913; T. 20, nepBaa no"oBMHa.
Cn6., 1910; T. 21, BToPan noJoBIIHa. Cn6., 1913; T.̅22, L1. 1. Cn6.,
1911; T. 23. Cn6., 1910; T. 24. nr" 1921; T. 25. M.-J1, 1949; T、26.
M.- JI, 1959; T. 27. M., 1962; T､2R. M., 1963: T. 30. M., 1965.

PI/IB­《PyccKaflllcToI)lI'IeCKafl6116@ITHoTGKa,I13JaBaeMaFIApxeorpaq)liIIecKolo KoMI,IccHeIo>D, T. II. C｢16., 1875; T. 32. nr., 1915.

378

《C6. PH0>­《C6()1)IIIIKPyccKoroIIcToPllIIGcK()r()()imecTRa>,TJ35.
Cn6., 1892; T. 41. Cn6., 1884.
くTDVJL' MTMAH》­くTI)yAbl MocKoBcKoTo rocyAal)cTBelIIIoro IIcToPllKo-al)入I1BIIOrOIIHCTⅡTyTa》．

"Tpy4blOIPJI》­"fTpy4b!OT¥Wr"""fc".､nWWWpp【しIHcTIITyTaPyCCKOH皿TePaTyPb[(nymKI1HcK"npM)
AKaneMMHHayK

CCCP》．

xn, I-c. M. KamT a H qB XpoH9JIorliqe9<mii nepeIIeHb｣IVMW""Hblx rpaMoT XVI B.­《Apxeorp a巾函ecKIIii e)KeroJHIIK 3a l957 ronl>.
M., 1958.

xn, II-c.M・K a m T a lI o B. XpoHoJIorlIqecKH曲nel)eIIfl{b WIMMyHH-

Te.I.Hblx rPaMoT XVI B.,叩．2­《Apxeorpa(blIulecKI1ii e>Kel､o皿ⅡK3a
1 960 ro瓜》. M., 1962.

無印TeHIIFI OI'MIP》­“LITellIIH B O6111ecTBe HcToI)IIII H XpeBIIocTeii poc･
CPIiiCKIIX

TII)I"I

MOCKOBCKOM

VIMBel)CHTeTe>'.

LEKUB­《LN-, Est- !111(I KufltmdiSches Urkundenl)LIch，zWeite Abtheilullg", B(1. 1 ' Riga - Moskau, 1900; B(l. 2. Riga - Moskall,
1905．

、

25＊

MMEHHOK

A6nblJI-JIeT",
72，73，77

Uapb

y K A 3 AT E 1 b

Ka3aHcKIIji

A皿peAⅡMIITPIIeBII[1, KH. MO>KaHU

U

CKIIii, CblH nMHTP" IIBaHOBHIIa
noHcKoro l27

ABaHecoB P. Z. 151

ABn|oTI]FI IIBaHoBHa, B. K11., 40[Ib
11Balla lll 62, 67, 69

AHnperI I'1BaIIoBPIII, KII. cTap|I皿K}畑，
u

nopoBIIII, KII., nllceU 44
AJIeKcaH八p, IIryMeH Tpollue-Cep-

cbIII IIBaHa lll lO, 45, 178, 199,
209, 2 1 3-2 1 6, 222, 223, 226, 250,
255, 27 1 , 272, 275, 276, 278­
285, 288, 290, 303, 305, 310-312,
3 14-319, 321, 324, 325, 333, 334,
336，339
AHHa BacIIJIbeBHa, B. KH. pH3aHcKaH, >KeHa KH. BacIIJIwI HBalloBIIIIa, cecTpa HBaHa lll 69, 85,

rIIeBa MoHacTbII)fI 254
cTapeU Cnaco･EBAJ1eKca HnP ,

AHToHoB HBaH MHxaimoBIIq, rocTb

ABToKpaToB B. 1-1. 126, 131
A n a mAJIeKceieB
eB
〔 pAJIeKcei･I
e J I o p o(peJIopoBII[I,
BII&I，
oKoJIbllI,IIII'ii 369

A且ameB ｡e40P rPHrOPbeBMq, 60FI-

PMH, n{BOPenKI'Iih yrJIHnKIIil 369
AJIa6b皿b (OJIa6blmb) enPp e-

｡IIMbeBa MoIIacTI)Ipfl l89
AJIeKcaH八p BJIamIM'IIpoBIIII cﾉ側、
PocToBcKIIi'l AJIeKcaⅡ川1 B.na八11MIII)OBMII

AJIGKC a H八P l<a3I'IMIIPOBII11, KOI)OJIb
IT|OJlbCKi,1ii

II B. KII.川IToBcKMIi'I 61，

65-69, 86, 87, 96, 98, 108, 1 18,
143, 153, 155, 156, 158-160, 166,

86
MocKoBcKIIii 337

ApTeMbeB
(OpTeMbeB)
B｡naceii
ylnaK, Jlb"K 206-209
A(I)allacIIil,
IIryMeH
TpoI皿e-Cel)I､IIeBa MoHacTbIpfl 19, 25

A巾al-IacIJeB (peJIoI) MI,IxaiiJIoB cIJIH,
JIO30PUllK II CyAI>兄37
AxMaT, Uapb 30JIoToii ol)nlbl

l52

168, 173, 174

AJIeKcaHXp VI, nana pllMcKIIii l43
AJIeKceeB

IO．r. 7, 14, 214, 313

A皿eHI<．①. (Allen C. F.) 140142, 166, 167, 176

AMBpocIm, IIepKoBHblk ⅡHcaTenb
131, 252, 259, 304, 31 1, 332, 336,
342，350，370

A"epceH EHc, enncKon OgeHceliZ
cKIM (･IoIIcKIIK) 141, |154, 167
AHXpeii (A皿PeiKO), cTaPocTa 3a．ⅢeccKH2 28

AHnpeii BacIIJIbeBIIII Bo.JIbmoi'!, KII.
VrJ''mKI,ii, ClDIH Izia(､ⅢⅡIIH II l6,

i7, 21, 22, 30, 31,44-48, 51, 54,
55，59，64，66，71，72，75，77，87，
99, 100, 1104, 129, 146, 177, 188,
210, 215, 216, 225, 235, 236, 277,
281, 282, 321, 333
AHnpeii BacIIJIbeBIILI MeHIJIuoA, KII.
Bonor,o八cK", cblH BacIIJIIIFI II
30, 54, 129, 130, 277
380

Ba311JIeBIIII

K,

B、77, 79, 81, 83-

86, 102, 103, 109-112, 1l4, 117,
138-140, 143, 163, 166
BapaKoB cM. BapJIaaM (BapaKoB)

A

BapcoB E. B. 259, 304
ユ

BapcyKoB A. n. 263
BapxyniapoB C. r. 151
BaTyPlm, C'beM皿HK MOHaCTblDCKOii

△

3eMJIII 273
Bamel･IIIH BacIIJmii, nIIceU 247, 248
U

BeryHoB 10. K. 152, 187, 189, 194,
195, 197, 227
Be306pa30B AJYeKcaHmp (OJTema) ,
abHK 37, 40­43, 52-58, 224
BeKJIeMHmeB

HIIKHTa

BacIIQJIbeBHIM,

pa3'be34L11IK II cynbFI 28, 29
BeKJIeMMmeB-BepceHb lIBaH HIIKIITHII cblH, cblH 60HpcKIIih 63, 269
BeJIo3epUeB r. H. 151
BeJIbcKIIe, KHFI3bfl 333, 334, 347,
348

Be@nbCKIIii llBaH のenOPOBIILI, KH・ʼ

6oHpHH329,333,334,338,344-347

]/J'bcKIIii M

(Bielski M') , xpo-

III,IcT 160, 161
BeJIbcK"
CeMeH

HBaHoBIIII,

KH.,

97-109,
111-124,
137,
139,
141-147,
151-155，164-171,
174­186, 190, 199, 201-206,
209, 210, 212, 213, 216-218,
222-227, 231 , 233-240, 242-

275,277-282,284,290-292'

6oHpIIH lO8, 152, 166
BeJIbCKmA ①enP,l) IIBaHOBH[1, KII.,
6oHpHH 278
BenHeB II. n. 187, 247, 248

BePCeHD-BeKJIeMⅡmeBcM.BeK峰TeMHHIeB-BePCGIIb
BecTVxKeB HBall, cVnm29
BoJIxoBIITIIIIoB E．A. 266

AmeKCaHnPOBIIIl,

295, 296, 299, 309, 310, 312, 314,
317, 322, 325, 326, 331, 333, 335,

336，338，339，345，352，374
B acIIJII戒 HBaHoBⅢ【【（meMn叩K'),
KII, Cblll KH. I'IBal{a mMIITPmeBII-

[Ia, BHyK nMIITpHH IOpbeBIIWa

B血Ioiin》K. (Blulll J.)5
BOPllc

47-7 1, 73-8 1 , 83-85, 87-93,

B.

KH.

TBel)CKOii, CI>III KH･AIIeKcallnp a
』

IIBai-IoBIILIa 31

Bopllc BacII|m,eBIl[I c.M. KyTy30B
Bopllc Bacll川〕eB11LI
BoI)IIC BacHJIbeBIIII，KH、BoJ1011KHH，
61)I1I B acIIJIII FI I I 30, 44-47,
u

52, 54, 55, 66, 70, 71, 73, 77, 78,
87，94，95

BopTIIHKoB CeMeII (CeIIbKa) , KpecTbm畑H 188
BDoKrav3①．A. 161

劃

nleMRI<II 108, 109, 111, 152, 155,
159, 160, 166. 177, 178, 238, 264,
265,268,277,365

BacH川m MIIXailJIOBIIII,

KII.,

CbIH

K,I. MIIxaIIJIa AImpeeBII[Ia BepeiﾉIcKoro 80
BaccIIal! (BacbflI1)、a l)xIMMa皿pHT
C1,1M()HoBa MoIiacTbII)fl, 3aTeM
apxIIemlcKon l)ocToBcKIIii
l27,
204, 205

』

⑪

BaccllaH (BacbFIII)、ⅢryMelI TpoIIUe-CepmeBa MoIIacTbIpFI 335
BaccIIaH naTpllKeeB c.ﾙ4. naTPHKe-

EVJIoBH I皿 Ⅲ.y.76

eB-Kocoih BaClm油I'1BaHOBIIII
BaccIIaH (TonopKoB) , emlcKon KoJIOMeHCKIM II KamIIPCKI'IiﾉI 332

ByTplom P．（Boutruche
ByTpIom
p. (Boutruche R)
R）5
5

BaxpaMeeB H．A、254, 264, 330,

4

BVraHoB B. I'I. 159, 164, 173, 177
BvTvDJmH HBal･I HIJKHTIm, BoeBoma,

"6peUKIIii 1loBropoXcKHii 312
"

BI>IXOBeU，mI1､OBCKI伽ⅡOMe皿ⅢK，

U

333,336,356
BeJIHK11ii cM. mecTylloB-BemIKmii
BeJIbflMIIHoB

I'IBall

B acllJIbeBH'I

manpa, BoeBona l57, 159

BJIa,meJIen xpoHIIKII 160-162

BeJIbHMIIHoB-3epHoB B．B. 77
BanK C. H 10, 349

BeHe且HKT.

BapJIaaM, apxIIMalI,mpllT CIIMoIIoBa

3el)cKoro MoHacTbipH 46
BepxnepeBcKIM MHxalm BaclIJ1beBH[I, ITOMe皿IIK 357
BeceGIIoBcKIIii C、B、4, 5, 7, 8, 12,
42，47，80，82，88，240，246，275
BJIam1MIIp AHjlpeeBwI, KH・CTapmUKIHPI, CblH KH・AHnpeFI HBaHoBH[Ia
318, 334, 362, 363
BJIamIMIIp l CBFITocJIaBIIII, B. KH.

MOIIaCTLII)FI,

3aTeM

MI,ITPOnOJIIMT

MocKoBcKIIil 204, 205, 257, 258

BapJIaaM (BapaKoB), cTapeII̲Tpo･
Ime-CeprlIeBa MoHacTblpfI 57
BacwIHi, nLFIK cM. noJIMaToB Ba即

KIIpml.JIo-BeJIo-

q力

哩

CHJIHH

BacIIJIIIii

HrvMeH

ll

BacHJIbeBIIq

TeMI-Ibli,

B. KH. MocKoBcK" 23, 54, 75,
1 23, 128, 145, 205, 220, 221, 239,
245，335

BacI,IJIIii rpl,IropbeB c〃l. 3axaPoBTHImHeB

U

BfIcIIJIHii

rpHTopbeB

KmeBcKI,Iii l27

Bo31BIDKeHcKHii T. H. 315

△
v

BoJIK KvDIInblH cM. KvpImblH BoJIK
IIBaH HBaHOBIIKI

BopoHUoB BacMIJIMIii MIIxaiiJIoBH[I,
叩

CblH

B aclIJIImnMIMTPlleBH可、B・KH・MOCKoBcKHii l28
BacwIHii lll HBaHoBI1[I, B. KH. Moc-

KoBcKIM 13, 16, 22, 23, 32-44
381

6oFTpIIII 358
Bol)oIInoB HBaH のenOPOBMIq, HaMecTHIIK

6eJIo3el)cKIIii 345

B()poIIIIoB

MMxalI&II

CGMelloBIIII,

OOFIPliII,
HaMeCTmⅡK IIOBrOI)04CKIIハ279, 312
BoI)oHUoB
enop
MIIxaii.noBI1II,

6oHPIIH 358, 359
BopoIlUoB e八op CeMeHoBIIq, 60FI-

rpeKoB B. n. 366
rplllI>Ka TeBGJIra，KI)ecTbFIIIIIII

cKoro MoHacTblpfI 46
ryceB BJIanJIMIIp EJIH3apoBHII, cbIH
6oHpcKHK 42, 79-83, 87, 88, 99,
100

pllII 356, 358

! BopoHUoBbl,
60FIpe MocKoBcKIIe
352,353,355-360
BnpbInaeBIJ1. 3eMJIeR.maJle.JIbulbl 265

ryceB E､m3ap, BoeBona 80
namb B H 151

naHIIII.m,
ra"FIILKIIii C. C. 139
3aTeM

al)xIIenIICKoII

IIoBropoXcKIIil 21, 72, 81, 1 15，
119, 120, 152, 166, 184, 195, 197,
224, 227-229, 23 1, 233

rel)6e1)1ITTeiiH
CIIrII3MyH4, nocoJI
u
aBcTPI[I'ICKOr()

IIMnePaTOPa

MocKBV l55, 156
rePMaH, 11TGHIルlii l60
rePOHTIIii, MIITI)onOJIIIT
cKIIii l27
rJIIIHcKaH
EJIelIa

cM.

B

IIoc"o-BoJToKo-

MOIIaCTblPFI,

3aTeM

MIITponoJTIIT MocKoBcKIIii 260!
267．284，329，334，336
nalIII,m MIIXaiiJWOBHII, IIaMeCTHIIK
1，. 101)I)eBa no"1)cKoro l9
naIIII､na AmeKca''八p,oBli'I cM. nellK() naHIma AJTeKcaH典pOBII[I
na''I'､ma
BacllJII>eBII[I
cM.meH1
nalIII､wa BaclI&TbeBIIII

MoCKOBEneHa

Ba-

ne6oJ1bcKII曲 B. 1-1. 72, 149､ 210,
211, 213-215, 217, 235, 236
meMMIIIoB (neMI>fIIIoB!円) BacPIJIIili
HKoBJIeB CbllI, 3eMJIeBJIaJIeJIeU
264

CⅢJ1beBHa

rJTHHCKMe, KHH3bF1, 60叩e 358-361,
364-366
r川IHcKHii
M1IxaII@JT

BacHJIbeBHKI,

KH., 6oHpIIH 330, 364, 365, 367
rllllmleB c.M. 3axapoB-rHMJIIIGB
r o M V Ko B r. 1 2 2 , 1 3 1

roJIeHIMII BacII川Iii l'IBaHOBIIII, KII.!
6oHplMII, mlceU 49, 50, 54，56,
57, 95, !180, 203, 206-21 1, 217,
247

neHIIcoB II. (Denissoff E.) 192
nlloHIICII#, Uel)KOBHblii mlCaTeJIb
252

且MMTplleB JI. A. l36

"MIITplIK A皿PeeBI'IIJ, KH., Cbll･I KH.
AHJIpeH BacIMbeBIIIIa yrJII皿Koro
281, 321

nMIITpliii BIIanIIM1叩OBIIII CM. POCToBcKI曲 旦MIITPmii BJIanJ1MIIpoBIʻI【I

roJIoBIIII Hr r. 259, 271, 294, 304,
306．

roJIy6IIIIcKIIi E．E. 106
rony61LoB I'1. A. 26, 27，32, 37, 41,
42．45, 48, 49, 73, 91，97, 123,
146, 174, 201, 204, 208, 21 1, 222,
224

rop6aTbIe，KIIH3bfl 313
rop6aTblii AJYeKcaHnl) BoplIcoBII[1,
KII. 353, 364
rop6aTblii-Cv3naJIbcKI"Iii

Bopllc

HBaHOBHI1, KII., 60flPIIH, HaMeCTHHK HoBroponcKIIii 312
ropllII
MaKcHM
lbHK 206-209

HrVMeH

JIaMCKOrO

reHHaJmit, apxIIMall叩IIT qy40Ba
MoIIaCTblPfl,

l88

ryPllii, IiryMeH K111)II.mO-BeJIO3eP-

BacIIJIbeB

cblH,

"MIITplm BJIanlIMIIpoBHII cM. XoBI)ⅡIImMIITpIIiI BJIa皿IMHPOBHLI
nMI'TpH曲HBaHOBHII,
KH.,
BHyK
HBawa lll 29, 31, 33, 38-40, 42,
56, 60-69, 79, 81-109, 1 11, 112,
114-116, 119, 122-124, 146,
147, 153, 167-169, 174, 175, 177,
180, 181, 237

"M]ITPIIii l'IBaHOBIIm mOHCKOA, B.
KII. MocKoBcKIIii 1 28, 205
. >KIIJIKa,
瓜MIITP"
HBaIIOBHII
KH.
yr皿皿KIm, CblH HBaHa
llI
45, 61-65, 67-69, 91, 98, 121,
122, 145, 146, 175, 182, 190, 199,
222，223，247，249，255，256，332
nMIITI)IIii lOPbeBIIKI meMfIKa, KII.

9q

ropcKIm A. n. 7
rop[IaKoB M. H. 8, 219

3BeIIIIrOPOXCKIIII

roTbe IO. B. 72, 210, 214, 215, 223,
226
382

II

u

ra.JIIInKIII'I,

cblH KH・IOp lIFI
JMMTpIIeBIItl a
3BeHIIroponlcKoro 31

■

no6i)oHI)aBoBBE269,270,332､

EcIInoB Bomall, 60FIpllH HoBTopoJIcKIfil ll noca皿IIIK 185, 190
Ed)Do,I Ii. A. 161

no6PblHcKIIe, 6oFIpe 80

)KI13HeBcKlliM A. 1<, 256

JIo6PoJIIo60BH.355
340, 343､ 360, 368

瓜oBHap-3anoJIbcKHAM．B、271
noJIMAToB Bacm"!lii. nbllK 23, 26,
⑭

3a6e川佃I I/i. E. 211

3a6epe31IHcKI'ii
(3a6ePe3cKIIii) HH
△
IOPbeBIIII. BoeBoJIa TpOIIKmh、Ha-

27, 30, 32, 50

no poro6y>KcKI畑Hoc''* A皿pe叩

eB岨，KH.，BoeBona 156, 157

MeCTHIMK I̅IoJIoIIKHii

cKoTo MoHacTblpH 234

nocm巾eii,emIcKOTIKpyTIIIIKIMi'1317
nocI'巾e仇,
UepKoBHIJII
337,346,368

mlCaTeJII､

JIeBJIaneJIeu 23

cKI1il 49

3aMFITIIFI TIIMo巾eii, 3eMJIeB,IIaJIeneu

nblol[ X. (Dewey H W) 5, 7
mbflKolIoB M. A. 378
cJt.

363

巾oll 3allcreiiM JIIoﾉIBI1r，KeH1IrcOcTIoKoBIIII

6eprcKwiM KoMaⅢ且op 89
ユ

3acTbJI6cKIIII rl)IIrol)IIii PI)MalIo-

EB巾HMiIFI IneMFIqllIIeBa, KHFIrmlfl,
CTa.pllUa，BHoBa KH B. II. men

戸

1『

3a60noTcKHii-JTo6aH neTP rl)IIrOpl,eBIM11,Ⅱ【Icen44,86

nyPOB A巾aHaCmi, TllyH FIl)OCJIaB'

EBcTIIKVBIIII

110

3a60J1()TcKIIii
KoIIcTaHTIIH
rI)I'ITOI)I)eBIIII, nlICeU, nBOPeUKⅢⅡ
187，188，207, 208
3a60J1oTcKHii HIIKHTa JII]BoB, 3eM-

noc"e#I, aPxPIMaIIJIPIIT CoJIoTIIml "

BIIII, nlIceI1 184
3axapoB MIIKJIFIII1, 3eMJ1eBJIaIIe,mell

戸

M汀〔JI1LIa DOO

37

EJIeHa BaCWIbeBHa, B・KH、MocKoB-

cKafl, mo'IE KH. BacIIJTHFI JTbBo-

3axal)oB-rllll川IeB

BacIImIii

rpII-

>Kella

roPbeBcbIII,11I,mK358､359，362

BaclIJwH I11 9, 275, 276, 278-

3axapoB-rHwJI1IeR FIKoB rpllropb-

B1Iqa

rJIIIHcKOrO,

BTo1)aR

281，285，288，289，291­293
296-299,303,305,309,310.
312-314, 316, 319-324,326｢

eBcI)'Ⅱ，J1IｺﾂIK 359

3BePlIIIcKIIitB.B.76，137，172，378
3IIMIIH A A. 7, 8, 10, 29, 39, 45, 46,

79，81-83、89-91, 98, 103, 104,

329­331，333，336，374
EIIeHa BoJIomaHKa cM. EJIeHa CTe,
巾aIIOB1Ia
E､neHa

114, 115, 122, 128, 153，174､ 175,
191, 193-195, 198，200，224, 225､
240, 258, 273, 276, 280,323, 328,

lIBaHoBHa，B･KII.， ⅡoLII，

I'IBaHa lll, >KeHa AJIeKcaH几I) 3;
Ka31'MHpoBIIIIa, B・KII・J1wToBCK()ro 65-69. 87, 98, 108, 110, 118

311110B11ハ．'IryMGII
TPolIUe-CePrIIeBa

EJ1eHa CTe巾aHoBHa (BoJ10HIaIIKa),

30cIIMa, apxIIMailﾉ11)IIT CIIMoHoBEl

且oTIb

CTe巾aHa lV,

rocnonapFI

MOJIJIaBCKOfO, >KGHa I'IBalla HBaIIoBⅡ咽MoJIomoro 22、33､ 61，

64­69，80­82，84，85，90，96，
npHI皿eCCa,

MOHaCTI,IPH,

3aTeM

MIITPQJIOJIIIr

MocKoBcltlIii 2 1 ､ 22, 36, 55, 73

MBaH AWIpeeB咽、KII. MOX<aiiCKI"lii,
KH.

AHnpefl

nMIITplleMqa

I46

ZIOKI1フユaT-

cKoro Kopo" Xa'Ica l41、1 42,
144, 154, 167, 175, 176, 181
EJTb[I almHOBLI,
26ʻ4

MoHacTbipFI 336

cblH

106-108, 114, 115, 147
EJIII3aBeTa,

367，369

3eMJIeBJIa1eJIbⅡbl

HBaH BOPncoBIIq, KH Py3cKIit,
cbIH KH. .BoPIIca BacIIJIbeBIIIIa 78,
94，107，159，173，183，184，195，
198, 200，277
HBaII III BaCI,IJII)eBWII，B、KII・MOC-

E,JIb別meBII[I B. B. 4, 6, 8, 252

EponKIIH (PonIIelloK) A巾aHacⅡ1ʻ
cblH 6oHpcKIIii 42
EI)omKIIHbl, nBo"I-IcKI{i poﾉ1，m(j…
ToMKII cMoJ1eHCKIIx KHmKaT 87

KoBcKI"Ii 10, 12, 13, 16-19, 21­

25，28­38，40，44­71，73­79，
81-96, 98-111, 115-125, 128-

130, 135-147, 151-156, 158, 159,
162、164­166,

383

168-172,

1 74,

■

■

■

■

■

■

■

■

176-187,
189-191，1 93-206,
208-228,
23 1-239,
243-245,
247-25 1 , 257, 265, 268, 274 ,
277, 278, 280, 300, 3 10, 31 7, 334,

Ka1Jv6oBcKIIii A. n. 192
Ka3aKoBa H. A. 36，57, 60､ 90，
100, 105-107, 114, 153，174, 227.

374

1(a3IIMmp lV HreJI@JIoBIILI, KopoJIb

HBaH IV BacHJIbeBI,III rpo3Hblii,
B・KII., 3aTeM Uapb MocKoBcKIIii 7,
54，102, 132, 250, 257，268, 276,
278, 279, 281 304, 306，312, 316,
320，332，358，360-364,369,
370,373

232
noJIbcKIIii lI B. KH. JIIIToBcKIIii 34,
63

KaJIaimoBII'I I<. ｡. 342, 365, 368,
370
I<ama[IoB H. B、378

1<apaM31111 H. M. 79, 103

HBaH I'IBalIOBIILI, KH. Pfl3aHCKIIil,
cblH HBalIa BacIIJIbeBII[Ia, B. KH.
"3aHcKoTo 261, 265
I'IBaH Iﾉ1BaHOB1III MOJIOZIOii, B・KH.、
cblll l/1BaHa lII 13, 22-43, 47,
48, 5 1, 58-60, 62-64, 71, 93,
118, 123, 124, 179, 181

IIBall MIIxaiiJIoBIIII,

KI(.

nePe-

KapaMblmeB AHnpeii, nlIceu 44
KaPaMLImeB BacPIJIIM, nIIceU 44

I<aCCHaH, aPxIIMallﾉIpIIT HoBroponcKoro IOpbeBa MoIIacTIDIpFI 232
KaTaeB I4. M. 240, 309, 318, 344,
348，365

B. B. 29
プ1<a(jcHray3
，
N1ml)IIall, MIITDOTIOJIHT

MOCKOBCKMii

128

Mblm.nbcKIlit 157, 160

IIBaw IOpbeBHII, KHH3b 47

1<IInPIIFIHOB naHIMa，nbflK 243

1/IBaH IOI)beB1III c｣1f. IIti'1,1)IIKeeB

KI'I)'IJ'J1,

ルIBall lOI)beBIILI

HBaIIOB rPHrOPl戒①e40POB cblH,
ITIIcelI 199

IirIIaTI1ii, CTaPeU, MIMTPOnOJIII[11'Iii
noceJII]cKHii 93

HeBJTeB IIBaH, 3eMIIeBJIaneJIeu 357
HJIOBa i#CKI曲Ⅱ. H. 234

IIOaHII, <<BeJIbMO)K", 8jlPeCaT nOcJIaHIM I'IocII(I)a BoJIoHKoro 70

Hoaca巾, IIryMeH Tpo皿e-Cel)rHeBa
3aTeM

KIIPmlJT, IIryMeH I<JmHcKOii l/130cmMIIHoii nycTblHII 273

HBIIHa JI. H. 10, 333, 343

MOHacTblPFI,

I,'ryMeI' KHI)wIJIo-BeJ'o-

3el)cKoro MoHacTHpfI 127

MIITPOnOJIIIT

MocKoBcKIIii 284, 329, 334, 336，
338，343，348

HOaXHM I, Ky"IOPCT BPa"eH-

6yprcKHi 166, 175, 176
HoHa, aPxIIMaHJIPHT flPOcnaBCKorO

CnaccKoro MoHacTblpfl 263
HoHa, IIryMeH TpoHUe-CeprlIGBa
MoHacTblpfl 360. 362
1/IOHa, MHTPOnOJIIIT MOCKOBCKmii
131

PIocⅢ巾BoJIoUK1Iii (HBaII CaHIIH),
ocHoBaTeJIb l,I III､yMeH BoJIoKoJIaMCKOrO MOHaCTbIPfl, ny6JIH-

ⅡⅡcT 35, 70,. 87, 152，191, 193-､
1 98, 258

KIImKa CTaHIIcJIaB (HH) neTpHHIKOBHII (neTPOBIIII) , BOGBOna H
HaMeCTIIIIK

cMOJIeHCKIIit,

nOCOJI

JIm､oBcKMii B MocKBy l56, 166

KJIeMelITbeB I<y3bMa, cy"H 28

I<JIm6aHoB A. II. 36, 1 12, 153

KJIIoLIeBcKIm B､0. 79, 103, 230
]<JIFInllK-EponKI"IH

MIIxal,IJI

CTena-

I{oBIIII，nocoJI 237

Ko6e@meB HIIK"op, ZlbfIK 59
Ko 6e.JII.cJIt. CaBml HayMKo Ko6eJTI,
Ko6pIIH B．B. 71, 94, 213, 321
1<o6fTK, JIbFIK 56

Ko6fIK

rpmropHh

nMI,ITPmeBI'ItI,

3eMJIeBJIaneJIeu 266

Ko>Kall[IHKoB n. E. 258
Ko3JIoBcKIIe, K"3bH 252
I<o30naB､ml, 3eMJJeBJIaneJIbUbl '145

Ko.rlbl[leB-JIo6aH I'IBaH AH叩eeBHII，
IIaMeCTHIIK II

KOHIOmHh HOBrO-

poJICKIIii 232

KoHoH, cTapen Tpo皿e-CeprHeBa
MoHacTbl" 189

I'IcIIx11H, cTapen TpoI皿e-CeprmeBa
MoIIaCTblPfl 313
Ka6aHoB A. K. 240, 309, 318、338,
344,348,365,378

6

384

KoHTaPmm A (Contarini A.) 23
I<onaHeB A II. 188, 216, 226, 235
1<oI)eUKIIi B. II. 222, 273
KopHH"Ⅲi|I
KoMeJIbcKIIit, ocIIoBaTeJIb l<opHH|JIbeBoii n#cTblHII 76

｡

I<oPo60B AI皿peii l/IBaHoBHII, B()e- 1 82，192, 193, 197, 227, 232, 237,
Eo" 109-111, 115,

117, 118,

327

144

JIIoToI) c,11.
4

Kopo6bllH CeMeH IIBalloBIIII, 3eMjeBJIMeJIeU 261

KoIIIIH r.E7, 14
KomKIIII

IOp" 3axapbl111 (3a-

Xpe6ToBMq

JIIIToBaP

MailKo AHmpeik me｡nol)oB,八b列K，

.,n9coJI"､47,
66, 99
MaiiKoB B. B. 321
U

fa"BII11," 60HpmH, &HaMecfHI"

Maifa2IIit,̲gWe"""2ro"-

HoBroponcKIIii 36, 58, 155--157、 CKIIM, 3aTeM MHTPOnOJIIIT MOCKoBcKIm ･131, 312, 338, 345, 346,

159, 160

U

348，373

KomKMI-3axapbIIH HKoB 3axapIｺII〔I

MaKap", aPxIIMalMPIIT LlyJlOBa

(3axapbeBHII), 60RpllH, BoGBQ4a

W r ; : : F W ' " M M " MMaKapllii,
M " " bIIryMeH
W
“ i TI)oⅡue-CeprIIel<y6eHCK戒 HBaH IIBalIOBIIII, KII.,
Ba MolIacTbIpH 23, 30, 32
JIBoPenKHi 358, 359
MaKcIIMrPeK; ny6"l皿ⅡcT 269
KV6eHcKIIi# MHxaHJI HBaHoBIIq, MaKcIIMImllaH I, IIMnepaTop aBK11., 6oFIPIIH 368
cTpIIiicKMii 89
1(V3 1 IelIoBm.Ⅲ. 253
MaJIelIH A.Ⅲ、155
Ky3bMIIH A r234

MaJIoB AlleKceii (O"el<"ii) HKoB:IIeB CI,111, JLBIIH>III11H 340

l<VJIemlIH BacII|川Iil, J【団K 118

KVHmeBMII r. 3. 323

MaJIoB IIBaH (I'1BamKo) HKoBJIeB

KyP6cKImAH八Pei[MMXaiiJIoBIILI,､CbIH, "mWW "
"̅35-

-̅4̅-

MaMaToBa E n l84

MaMyK, IlapbmM6aHCKHh77

Kyp [皿blll BoJIK I'IBall HBalloBHII，

i"36,86, 233

M"bnla ..HBaH
GﾙL・ naTp lIKeeB
HBaH HBaH'oBH[I MaHblHa

I<yPIIUbIH enOP HBaHOBIIM,Jb71K

" ", 57, 58; 106, 107"1 1 1

MaplifI BopllcogHa, B KIMJj9"92-

Ic|kaf', nl,OI,L BOP､'I|ca A|JIeK|cIaHL-

I<yTy30B BopIIc BaCWILeBUq, P0m-

iIMm""ioESr:5",̅'66̅-

!"laijIM｡ WW9IR nePBa"

I<XMAI"M'K;"hIf､3r, "

MM WWMMW

MaMapllfl HPocJIflBHa (Mal)4)a), 3

KyqKIIH B. A. 10, 320, 332
KIopbemb p. (Curiel R.) 167

KH. M:O'CKOBICKafl, nPIIb 601)OBCKO1CePnVX'OBICKOrOKl-Ifl3HHPO1CnaBa

B@iaiHMmpolBMa,)KallaBa"皿》】

JIeB mlIJIOJIOr, 60JIraPcKI[ii UePKoB-

11 13, 347 54, 2,1'3-2117, 235

I I b l i t m l C a Te J I b l 9 4 - 1 9 6

M,apKc K、6, 1'1, 19'1, 251, 286, 287

JIeoII, JIeKapb ].[3m
BeHemllI
35
『
JIeoHIIn, IlepKoBHblik mlcaTeJI1> 239,

MalcIcJIeHIIHKo'Ba H. H、2i66

MaCJIOB HB'a,H A皿bl,(bePOB cIJIII,
3eMJIeBJIa'XeJIeJl 265

261, 273, 349
J̅IeoHTIIil, nbHK 28
JIIInHTMH eXOP meIIOPoBHII，Ⅱ11-

Me皿IIH B. (Medlin W. K.) 219

劃

MIIKWI I,IHcW城MHxaHJI

ceu 202

eniopo-

BHk1, KII., BoeBona l5'6, !1157
,mIIToBap "!. XPe6ToBIIII JImToBaP MMMK6B h. H､3512
HI'

JIIIxa[IeB
264,304,362

MIIJIIoTIIH B. A. 8

224, 240,
H．Ⅱ
252,
、 2263,
2 4 ， 2MMm､̅",hnu
4 0 ， 2 5 2 ， rIMwTnwM
2且IMHTP”HIMIITPHit
63，．
lI'BaHOB
'CblH, 3eMJI|eIBJIalneJleu 264
MIIxalM
cM.
PycaJI|Ka
MIIxaIIJI
flIKoBJI|eBIIKI

IJIo6aH cJI4. 3a60JIoTcKIm-JIo6all

JIvKa BoJTomeHI[H, nocoJI 85

J1ypbe H．C. 26, 29, 36, 39, 55, 57､ MHxa:wl AHIXpeeBII'I, KIH. BeP:eil60，70，79­82，85，87，89，90、93，

R,

ʻcKmⅢʻⅢ6eJIiO3ePCKHH，cbI11KH
|'I 6eJI,O3ePCKHii, cbIII KH

100, 104-107､ 109, 111, 112, 114,

AHZIPeRⅡMIIT,pHelB I,画a 45, 46,

1 19, 121, 122, 127, 145, 147, 148,
150, 151, 153, 154, 165, 167, 174,

50, 94, 1 1|2, 1|13, 127, l'28, 177,
|1'90, 2'21, 246

385

■
モ,

MIIxaIIJI BoPMCOBIIII, B. KH. TBeP|CKOji, CI,IH KH. BOI)|IIICa AmeK'caHIJJ)oBH.ua 31, 44, 202
MHxaIIJI

OrapeB CGMell AJIGKca'H|mpoB cbIII,
noMeUHK 190

011･IHUoB CnHlplmmoH, npH!cTaB 92

KJIOIIiCKHii,
OCHO,BaTe7卜
HoBropoacKu｣･o
KJlon|cKoro
MoHa'cTIJIDJI l,36

0JDeBoKHii eXol) I'IBaH'oBHq, KH.,

MMm'yPHH GJI01) MHXaiiJ1OBM(1,

0，m'巾opma6a|JIa,Kpe|cTbHIHMH188

A

JlbHK 305, 333, 334

01)emHI1･KoB A. B. 25, 26, 39, 40、

Moll'ceeBa r．H、lM一198

MO'CeeB

A*aHa'C",

Hal1GcTIIIIK MypoMcKIH|ii 330
Ona6IJImb c". AJIa|6blmb

51

nOMe皿HK I85

OcoPblIHbl, 3eMJIe|BJIaneJIIbnbl 240

MoceeB enop, HoMelul"IK l85

0IcTDoBcKIafl M, A. 366

MoceeBbl, nOM,e皿H,KH 185, 191
McTHc.JIaBcKI,Ie, KHFI3bFI 278, 357

OcTpoBIGKKHii n. 237
OcTpoI>KicKIIii KoHcTaHTHH IIBaHoBIIII, KH,, reTMaH川,IToBcKIIii l56,

McTH|CJIa.BICKHii OeUOP MMxaiMOIB'H[1, KH. 281, 333

158, 160, 162-165

MyxaMMeJI-rllPeii, UaPb KI)I)IMCKIIii
269

Myx a MMaﾕ-3MMH, nlaPb Ka3aHCKIIii

OcTIoKoBHII (OcTIIKoBHII, EBcTHIKyB II L' ) r l)Iw'､op" CTlaHHcJIaBoBII11,
'B1oe}BOIIa, IIaMeICTHIIIIK MePell|c'KMii
II oH)lIKmTaicK" 115'6, 158

13, 77, '129, lli56, 157, 203, 205,
237,246,247
MyxafloB n A. 353, 357

OIIlel)HH I'IIBaH I'IBaHoBHII, no|coJI

H ajra･BIIIILa -PRIHo"oBIc|KI1 ii

naB.moIB A C. 187, 1190, 191, 2119,

l'I Ba,ll

IAlUpeeBIIII, KH. lll8
Ha3apoB B. n. 10, 32
HalcoHo,B A. H. 33, 38, 72, 97, 148,
l'53, 172, 173, 3128

HayMo,B BalcIIJIIf,ii rpH,rol)bBM11, nII,ceU 226, 235

HalyMoB I<JIsMeHITIIji, cyn" 26, 33
HeBoIHIH K. A. 139, 173, 180, 230
He"|MoHo|B BaIcHJ1Mii, 1bJIK 207,
，208

HIIIKaHmp, HryMeH Tpo|Hne-CeprPIeBa MOHa'cTblpH 359
HHKII,q),oP, c:oTcKMii l'88
HMKomIM,
U e P KO B H I J I I I Ⅱ Ⅲ ' C a T ʻ e J I I ,
i250, 255, 349
HIIJI CopcKIIii, rJIaBa HecTmKaTen'ei, ny6JIIHumlcT II|96, 257
HoBrol)o且ueB
HBaH, cJIo60A[111K
353，357
HoIB'oceJIBolM,ii A. A. 9, 1 28
H,oIcoB H. E、7, 8, 188, 253, 275,
276,32,3,327

Pq

85

227

naJIGoJ1oir Co｡bH cM. Co巾bH ｡)MIIHmIIHa naJIeoJIOr

n aJIe'UK砿 HBa'H eaOPIOBMII, KII.,
BOe|BOna l"

Ⅱaﾉ1 euK城 のenOP HBaHOBH[1, KII.,
BoBB'oXa l56

naTI)IIKeeB A*aHacMii lIBaHoBHIM,
KH. ･102

naTpHKeeB IIIBa'H IIIBaHoBHII MaHblHa, KII. 102, 106

na|TI)IIIKeeB HIBa|II IOPbelBII･III, KH.,
6oHip,HH 3'6, 47, 48, 50, 58, 102,
1103, 106, ,l'07, 1 10
naTPHKeeB-KoIcoii
BacIMMi
l'IBaHOBH|11, KH., 60HPIIH, B MOHameIcTBe BalCCHaH, |ny6JMILHIcT 49, 50,

52, 53, 58, 59, 102, 103, 105l107, 1 10, 1'112, 258

n､arPHKeeBbl, K,HH3DH, 60flpe lO2-|109, l111,'1-1!16

口aIOcoB AHmlpeii '-IepHbUoB cblll,
nioMemHK 231

060JIeHIcK:IW

I'1BaH

elopoBII'1,

K11., KolllomlIii 314

0 60｡Ⅲ巳H;cK砿neTp Balc|HJTbeBIILI,
|K11., BoeB[o1,a 156, 157
O60.JIeHICKIM-PemHH

I/iBall

JIO|BIIII, ImH., 60"|IMH, BOeBq1a l59
KH., BoeBQna

naIocoB neTe.m, nocoJI 231

niaIocoB eJIop qepHIJUoB cHI1,
no'Me皿HIK 231

MHx'a'ii-

O60JIeII'cKHii-TeGneineHI> eXop BaCImbeBII[I,

naIocoB BoJmblpb, nibHK 243, 248

l56,

157
386

nalo,cdBbl, noMe皿IIKIM 23'l

neHIKonaH'maA.ﾉIelfca皿!poBH1I，
KII.,

6oFI"H

78

nepeJIemHH AH"eii, c!yabH 52

POCTOBCKmhⅡMPITpHii
BJ1aJ､HIM}1po;BM･q, KH・, 60HpHH, HaMGC'TIIHK

neTp mMMTPlll"", KH. 4MHTI)"

Ckmi" Cb,,inMm"MHmOHIOKOrO

|mcKoBIcKIIii 229

” 5

Ply61UoBM．B.3|52

nemlfoIB c.,1t. Cal6ypoB-,nemKoB

nHXEEMo"CW",̅3eMJIeBJIa-2yMoBIoKmii,II#34
1"mW5777:@8- ; ̲ ̲̲ 2yMfIHueB Ii．n.377

n""|hYid' iPierling P) |43 PWW" ̲NWM HKoa-,
n･KceMIcK,Hlii
AH,且peiiHBaIHoʼBⅢ'1，，1ʻI60”ʻ､H,ʻnoIcIoWI6i6
"""" h̅̅ -̅2iOP,ikPBJM U2

nffabE̅mBam,
MoJIIgaB[KIIii
2獄noJIoBIoKIIie,
n̅!
KIHR3bHlO4,105
u

W:P｡ "｡c,"､-.- -̅ ̅ -

P｡IoBcKIIii
w､C"H !,MBaHoBII[I,
KH.,nocon66,1102-11116

n｡JIeMfIHHHIKoB AHInpeii MBaH.oBHLI,
Bo｡JIocTeJIb 237

nfMMMMMX'"｡pmHcKIIipo4
Ca6ypoBa,,PQJl"9H"":､
｡foJloM6,:,H,f, IOPbeBHa Ca6y|PO｣4
237
naf614MH H n 377 Ca6ypoB-IIe山KoB
HMIITpllii CeMemdA,iL1, 60fipmH, !Iwcell 44
1/1IBall
(m,HroH a)
n0a>KOTIIH
rL CaBBa,
enIIcKoInKplyTImKHA195
U

IOpI,eBII11,

6oHp", JBopeUKMII

W"i' 2797Mr a&"̲ "̲

Ca"L,cTI>,
HgPHFM4､"MWk"WWi
I)bK3
C,,,alca-|nl)Go61)a,>KelIHH

noKP'oBCKIlii MM" 18, 97, 129, 130

112
'8
'

n0｡milBaHOB HMIITP'I1il, 1)a31,e3XKI11K

M｡｢'u｡ ¥ ' !､""' r̅-

CaBBa (CJIpIW|KmH) , enmol<on

T I ' ' 1o J （
<IOCH
T》)I，
n o J I y eKoBH cʼTacl IM
Ie
'cKHlh311'4
MMbH":"̅
̅- " - " CaW Ha'yMKo
Ko6eJIb, mBIIHHHIII{
ʼ
，272
己

nOJiyeB enPP PembKa), KPC-

6TMIIIH 188 " "
PaUmKOaⅡ．A. 370, 373
ndr;":､ "cTbfIHe } 87 C a'llNbIK CTapbli! M旧aH, BOJIOCTe皿》
ii"6I<, 'PyHOB 6PaT, cb,H 60HI)- ,̲L4!
:W42rynu" ､''｡' """ &̅"[ CaXQ"BacoB m fl 180, 185, 190,
1TI)OHmTeiH A．Ⅱ227

231

CaTHH HMIMTa ne'"IMbeBW, 3eM｡meB@ma,meJIem 'l" 224, 225
CaTHHbl, nBIOpHHe 224

Pa43MB}IJI HIIKoJIaii HHKo4maeBII[1,
t D

BIOeBO4a BIIJIGHCK", KaHnJIeP J1II-

¥55"i mb-̅- "

̅

Caq)a-rmpeii, ｡¥a" KasaHcKmk316
ひ

CaxapIoIB A．M、7

PaJIeB-naJIeO.jlOr nMIITPHi HBa-

HCI”11,ʻnocoⅦ33，35，142CBHHbmH
KapaHⅡam
r”iropbeB
:cblH, CymbH 37, 51

Pa.TIeIB-naJIeOJIOr MaHyWI HBaHO-

B'Ⅲ岬'｢;;""ji, 35""｣"- -̅̅̅-

CelleW " PHnoTK" CeMcI!

PaXMAI"oBbI, mMeulMKm 368

̲ MBaH"mq

Kajly>KcKIIii, cbiH mBa" III 45,
U

PenbeBbl, 3eMJIeB,JIa.1eJIblLIJI 265

""W. #i""､.- -̅-

̲ 175; ｣99, 222, 223, 249

b5MI65 EA 8

PoMaHoBbl-IOpbeBI)1,

U

CeMeH HBaHOBMII, KH. 6e)KeUKHHⅢ

PenHFI cM. O60JIeHIcKIfii-pe:nHH

ひ

ゅ

CeMeH HBaHoWq, KH WWgWh
|cblH

6oH|pe 367,

WU"-｡""' ̅r- -̅"

KH.

HBaHa

AHJIp･eeBIIIIa

lq6, 109, 166146, 152, 155, 160,

PoMOJIallOB ｡enOP lIBaHOB CI)IH,

”HlcTaB皿HnPaB“mIHʻK273CeMeHKa”OB皿I，HaMecTHIIK
PMM;B"'EMf" - Ba̲､ rJOpbeBanq"cK"̲2Q
⑪

'CIJJIbeIBMq, KII., BOeIBOna, nO'COqJI

ii#m3; i̅i5W 117;m8,' 144

CeMIIoH., 1yxoBH'IIIK AH叩eH CTa-

JmUKoiro 31I7

PO|IIIIeHO|K cjf. EpGHKIHH

p5&MRM̅AJI6Kca"p BJ1amlIIMm.

CerpamIoH,
MryMew
TpoI皿e-Cep'rHeBa MoHacTkJW,̲221pM |:RxIiW

poBHLI，KH.，60”ⅢH，HaMecTHH！K
cKoⅡ
HoBrol〕o且cKI1il
l89，194，
"6Eblmi'1 19, i20,159, 180, 209

387

196, 197

Cep61IHa l<. H. IOO

CeprIIii, HryMeH Tpol皿Koro BeJII)neconKoITo Mo,IIacTbl" 261

102

CPIM'oH,HIryMeHTpol皿e-CepII､IIelJa
3aTe.M

79, 91, 100
CTp blii Ko BIcKmH
じ

CHMeoH BeK6'yJIaToBHII, xaH KacII･
MOBCK", <<B. KH. BCeR Py'CH》51,
MOHaICTbl",

CTU)PMIwIoB ｡elol)､ ̲ ZIbFIK 4 1-43,

MHT,P'OnO,JIHT

MoIclcoBIcKHA 41, 73, 74, 87, 99-

M.

ご

(Si,･vikow-

ski M.),
ski
M.),xpoHIIcTl60,l61
xpoHIIcT 160, 161

CType CTeH; npaBIITeJIb mBeUllII
138, 140, 167
CyBQpoB H. H, 321

Cy,KPiH e40p HBaHoIBmII，Ka3Ha­
qe# 363

101, ll12, 1121, '152, 1180, 195, 218,

219, 229, 244

CIIeny:mKHIH cM. CaBBa (CJIenymKHH)

CIIO,60"III[ ̲mm3Tmii (DenOPOB
,cIJIH, "bHK 206-208

CMI叩HpB PI. IJ. 4, 77, 79, 80, 82!
84,90, 103-106, 1 10, 1 1 1, 276,
32,3, 3'27, 369

CMII|PHOB M．I/1. 244, 248, 253, 331,
332

06'oJIeH'cKIIi-TeJIe-

IneHb

THX,pMHp'oB M. H. 273, 31'6, 319,
323

THxoH, apxHellIIcKo,n pocToIBcK,flji
2'1, 22，70

ToBapKoBCeMGH,pa3be3"HK71
ʼ'l･OKMaKOB H．q)3'10

To,noplfoBc,1J.Ba,ccIIla,II(TolYop-

q

、

KO1B）

(JMIipHQB ̲ IT. n. 8, 239, 275, 327,
328，352

CwIIIT R̲a (n (Smith R E F)
141, 166

'cell 313

TpeTbHIK, zlbFIK 359

TpCr"K Kyp6aT, 3eMJIeBJIaneJIeU
TIpeTbHKoBIIB|al･IIIBaH|oBH[I,Ka|3Hatleii 368

CoJIoIBbeB C. M、79, 103, 104

CoJIoMoHHHIOpbeBHaCa6ypoBa,B.
Mo:cKoBcK",

TopHep m. (Thorner D) 166
25'2

Co6alKIIH CTenal･I BalcWIbeBIItI, mY-

IcH.

TeJIeneHb cJM.

nPtlb

IODIIH

I<oH｣cTaH'TIIiHoBIILIIa Ca6ypdBa,
n e P B a H ) Ke H a B a c H J I I i fl l l l - 2 6 9

Co｡bH oMHHH[IHa naJIGoJIor, B.

Tpml(boH, emIIcKoH KpVT皿KH# 97

TpoqJHMoBBJIa"MIiri(BoJIonlbKa),
|MeJIEHIIIK 3'40

TpycoBIJI, noMe皿HKH li85

TiyIIKo|BMHx,aHIJIBa'cIIJIbeBIIII,6oHl)IIH, miCen; 207, 208

IKII. MOCKOBICKaH, JIO[Ib OMbI na-

neo狐ora，且ecnoTa
MOpeH,BTOpaH
>Kel･Ia IIBaHa ll'1 212, 23, 3335,
412, 52, 59, 61, 64­69, 75, 8088, 91', 92, 96, 98-100, 103, 105,
106, 108­lll'3, 1115, 1 17, 1'18,
143, II47, 15,2
CPe3HeBcKHii H. H. 15'l
CTaHHcJIaB c.1I. KImIKa CTaHIIc.waB
n|eTP HmKOB II'q

CTaHHIcJIaB neT"mK'OBII(I
c".
KIJmKaCTaHIJcmaBneTpHmKoBHKI

CTMapony6|cKIIiiCeMGHPIBaHoBwI,
K|H., BoeBoma li5'9

yBaPoIB A. C. 265

yLma皿HKI-I･H. 160, 161

yJIMHa MII'XaiJIIOBHa, KH.，ⅡOLlb
⑫

,K1,1．

MII.x aIIJI a

△

JMHTpHeIBIIIIa

XoJIMcKoro, >KeHa BopIica BacI'IJIbeBII[la, KH. Bo,JIoUKoro 78, l95

ynOJIOBHI1KOBbl, 3eMJIeBJIameJibUll
仔

甸

O'／

ymaK

ymaK

ApT,eMbeB
c"、BjI

a'ceii

ymaKoB HKoB, BOJIocTeJIb (?)
、ʻ 273

のeIIOPBoPHCOBIN,KH.B'OJIOUKIIii,
u

C
T
a|p|o,m,y6cKI城
①,enop
AHnpeeBMII,
!KiH. lll3

lCUH KH. Bo,piH'ca BacHJIbeBHKIa

Z4 94L 107, 146, 159, 173, 223,

CIwa皿eBIcKHi E. n. 72, 211, 215
CTe巾aH, nOCanHIIK n'CKOBCIKmii l20

CTe(jaH IV, ro|oⅡ皿aPb MOJIInaBCKHi 84-87, 107, 108, 1 52
CTPPeB n M. 72, 73, 1｣30, 195,
204

240, 261

①enop
四BaicwIbeBII11, KII．pH33JIgKH11, cblll B KH. PH3aHCKOrO
BacII:T1IFI HBaHoIBIIqa .234

(beXOI) HBaHOBIIIJ, KH. IOXOTCKIIii,
cblH KIL IIIBaHa naIIwIoBI7IIa 263

388

①enpp IIBaHoBII[I, uapeBIIII, cbIH malHIICIill ̲ (Ulamoyn) , Kn. Ka3aHIIBaHa lV 32

cKIlii 237

①enppo:B MaKapHii, "JIK 359 ̲̲̲ 1UaMcIKoii H"H, HoMglu､IIK 318
U

のenObbFI, B K1i, "tlb HBaHa lll 山ax-A"I! (muraJIeii) , Uapb Ka62, 67, 69.
3aHcKIli 313
①ʻ“om,E-LlexoB|cKIM A. A. 377
maxMaToB A. A 42

①eHHeJ1Ⅱ》K. (Fennell J. L. I.) 23, meeHoIK A巾aHac'I,Iit, nOcoJI l!55
33, 35, 39, -60, 61, 8'2, 84-86,皿eM,fluI1[I Cﾙ1. Ba'cwI|Hii l'IBalloBIIII
咽

(meIM HI''i|II )
91; 98, 100, 103, 104, 106-U4,
117, 118, 148, 151-154, 167, mepeMeTeB C. n. 270

174, 175

m'ecT,yHoIB-Be皿刊K城 neTIp

のeOINHOCT, aPXMIMaHInPlMT qynOBa

Ba-

CWIbeB.II,q, KIH., 60叩ⅢH)瓜BOPeni-

回

;Mo H a!cTbm H 713

KHii 95 , 236

①eoAoIc" , I1Ty M e lI Ho BIro p oXIGKoro皿H'raJIellcﾙt. nlax-A､mII

X VT blH'cIK,oT o M o II|a,cT bIp H 3，12 Ulll,r､oHa.,n1oJUKoimllll c.M. nomKo,rl"111

のe血Ocllii KOBePH, CTaPen TI)OII1U-ルIBaH (nlIIroHa) IOpI'eBIIII
KOrO BeJIOIIBCOnKOirO{ MOllaiCTbll)fl m}IpHeBIDI, nOMe皿IIIKH 311 8
.260

m'MeJIeB r. H. 343

①eO*", a'PxHeⅡHcKoim HoBro'poX- mM皿TC、0. 8, 3'6, 44, 68, 72,
CKAA I84 ､
"
77, 93, 99, 130, 141, 156
①HJHH m. n. 15'l 皿,MIypJIo E. ･ 143

①HIC中eit, apxMMa"pHT CIIMoHoBamyi6Kme, K"3Llfi 31L 342@5, ",
IM"1cTLIPh 317 "
2719, 281, 3", &U, "'3, ､"8,
のi" B H 1 0, 1 76, 357, 379
329̅33 I, ", ", ", WのopcTGH r. B、138-140
348, 350, 351, 353, 358, 363­

365"
"oJIh̲|la"140,
m"6km&
AH4'peii
"mxalijIoBIIII,367
kH., 6oH'l)HH 270, 279, 3'52

XaIFc，，qaT℃K”iIpopoJIb：'38­1140，myii1cKHii
AH1,pei
MHxa”CBH【'ʼ
l42, 144, 154, 166, 167, 176

XeP6cT C. (Herbst ̲S.) 161, 164

皿沌IcKIIii

XoBplIH nMII叩,IIlii BIJIaJJIMIIpoBIILI,
66HpmH, Kaama'Lleii 99L20p

lIBaH

BalcIIJIbeBMII,

KII.,

60jIp.H.H346

XoPO山KeBIIKIA.几Wb",120,
ʻ mNW":a"MII̅8"I%
6o,flPllH270

'1169, 17'6, |l'82, 233

皿沌|cMI|ii neTI) I'IB!aH'0IBII11, KH . ,

Xpe6ToBllu JIIIToIBap (JIIoTop) HH，
60"H H 365
M'ap'mall9K, HaMelcnH" "Bo- my"皿B (Schulz W) 4, 5, 7, a70
rp"cKmii m c"oHMMIcKmii l56
myMiaKoBC.A、244,255,330,336,
U

342,352,374

1le60ToB I/IBall, 60Hp,HH l'19-122

IJeJI皿HIIH

A皿;M"M｡p"",

m""AaW'｡iWWu',R#H"
66oHpHH
37, 156､160, 162, 1'63

60FIpIIH,
HaMecTHI"IK
HoBropoX-皿ep'63[IeBIO.H.138,176
cKIIii l 59
LIeJIJMHIIHbl, 60Hpe 87

3K A (Eck A.) 6

LlePeBHHbl,3eMJIGBJI"ej1bIlbI264

q…遡Ⅱ几WW",f"l･,
:繍醐WW M9,:3;5,, 286,
i6, 18, 1'9, 22, 26, 29, 31, 33L34,
287

39; 42, 46, 49, 50, 58, 78, 79-

831 85, 87, 89, 90, 99, 100, 106= IOpmi BacHIbeBIIII, KH. yrJIHnK",
CblH BaclIJIIIH III 369
109, 1 111, 1 13]111{5, 127, 188,
189, 200, 204, 21'9, 286
10pH,M BacHIbeBM MJIa瓜mHH，KH・
qepHIjUoB
c" naIocoB AH"eii
△
,IM&HTP､oBcKII:#, cblH BacIIJIHH II
｡

u

tleplibuoB cbrH

23, 24, 54, 98, 128, 129, la ":

205, 214, 216, /221, 225, 277, 334

皿a八pa lIBaH c" ̲BeilbHMIIHoB IO" ｡ 2""" c" I<omKIIH
IOplIii 3axapblI,xI

1ｲBaH BaCHm,eBH[I mainpa
389

且

IOpHii 3HHoBI]eBHII, RoGBo,ma ,mIIToBcKIIii 156

101)IIii lIBaHoBMY, KII，ユMIi叩OB,cKI1ii, clﾌIH I/IIBaHa lll 61-65,
67-69, 71, 77, 92, 98, 121, 122,
145, 1･46, 1'75, 1182, 198-206,
208, 209, 213, 216, 222-224,
226, 236, 241, 246, 255, 261, 264,
265, 270, 271 , 275, 277 -282, 284,
285，288，290-295,298-300,
305-308, 317, 319, 325, 333, 341
IOpbeB BacIIJIIIM MIIxiaiiJToBFIL1，
60HI)IIH, JBopeUKHii 367

10pbeB naHIIJIo PoMaHoBHII, 60fII)IIH, 1B'opeUKIfii 366, 367
10mlKoB A. H、252, 263-26,6, 269,
281, 344, 357, 366, 368, 378
1 0 m Ko B C ． B . 4

HKoB (IiaKoB) , .HryMeH Tpo皿e-

凸 335

MoHa'cTblDFI

HKOB ripH,I,OpbeB CM､3axapoB-r'HH.IIIIeB HKoB rPHrOPbeB c61H
HKOB

SaXaPbHII

C"・KoIuKHH-3 a-

xapbMH HKoB 3ax,apbHII

HH CTaH|HcJIalB c.M. KHIHKa CTaHPIcJIaB

CBHTocJIaBIIIIa l26, 127

Allen C, F･"z.
Bielski

M.

AJIJIeH

cM.

K.

O.

BeJIbcKIIii

M.

Blum J. cM. B@JTIoM且》K，
BoL1truche R cM. ByT,PIom P.
B1･iCka C. F. 167

Contarini A. c.4l. K'oHTapHHII A.
CLlriel R．cJw. KIopbeJIb P.
Denissoff E cM. neHIIcoB H.
Dewey H. W cM. nbYolI X.
Eck A．c.11. 3K A.

Fennell J. L. I. cJ,l. eHHe佃且流．
Herbst S. cM. Xep6cT C.
Ko l a n k o w s k i L . 8 6

Lenz W・141|, 144
Liebusch G・167

JJreqJIJIO|Hbl, @JIHTOBICKO-IIOJIbcKaH ,MIIHacTIIH 85, 86, 143
CeprlieBa

H1)ocmaB I BJ1aZIIIMIII)oBII1I (MymI)IJIii), cI>III B. KH. B､manlHMHpa l

ne|TPflmKoBHII

Medlin W. K、cM. ManJIIIH B.
Paludan-Mnller C. P・l41

Pierling P. cﾙt. nHp,mHIHr n. O.
von plettenberg W. 14'l

Schulz W. c" myJIbU B.
S m i t h R ・ E F. C " . C M I I T P. 3 . m

Stryikowski M. cJM. CTpblMKoBcKIIii M.

Szujski J 86

Ihorner D. "f TopHel) n.
Wagner F. 166, 176

CO4EP>KAHIIE

BcTymleHMe

白■●

.

３
■

｡

■

●

■

■

F

/.ﾉlaBαBHyTpeHHHsI
f
noJ1MTHKaM*eo"JIbHbliiMMMyHIITeT
B

1492-1497

rr.

l. CocToFIHIle cy4e6Horo II TaMo)KeHHoro HMMyHIIg
TeTa B nel)BOhⅡoJIoBIIHe 90-x roXoB

2. BoHpoc o I10JIIITIIIIecKoM cTaTyce HacJIenlHHKoB

□

I/IBaHa lll .

3. noJIHTMLIecKIIe npIIIIIIHbI Bbl4aLIH )KaJIoBaHHhlx
II yKa3Hblx rl)aMOT .

■合

ﾉｰﾉtaBaノノ. "nMHacTM'HecKIlii KpH3Mc)' 1497-1500 1,r，
1 . 3aroBop l497 rJI KopoHauIIFI nMIITplIFI-BIIyKa
2. Bo3BblmeHl,Ie KHFI3H

Bac1,IJT11H

2

陀
妬

１

170

I/IMMyHIITeTIIafI noJIIITIIKa B 1500-1502 rr.
I<JIacCOBble II nO川ITPILIecKIIe nPOTHBOPeIIIIFI HaKa-

①

Bo3po>K且､eH}Ie yne@JIbHOII CHcTeMb1 .

回
(peo,Ⅱa,几bHbl#I

218

IIMMyl･IIITeT B l504-1505 rr.

F4aBa ノV・HMMyHIHTeTHaMI nOnmTIIKa BacIIJIIM III

187
i97

R J

.

79

１

ザ

４

70

CoUllaJIbHo-noJIHTM'lecKag60pb6aB1500-1505rr.170

HvHe M Bo BpeMFI co60pa l503 r.
３

21

I'IBalIoBIILIa

3. 4<MflTe>K>p KIIFI3FI BacIIJ1wl l500 r.

1

12

79

II HoBroI)o,UcKafI rloJIIITI"IKa B l499 r.

r ,7Q Bα///.

11

○

1. OrpaHII[IIITeJIbHble >KaJIoBaHHble rpaMoTbI KoHUa
申
1505 - cepemHHLI l511 rr.
2．noHBJIeHIIe nonaTHblx ocBo60]KneHMit B )Ka･mOBaH-

239

243

IIblx rPaMoTax BacIIJIIwI III IIIo,m l511 - IIIoIIFi
253

1 5 2 2 r r.

3. rpaMoTbl aBrycTa l522 - oKTH6pH 1533. rr..
391

267

す〃qB
Cynb6b'巾eOna'J1bHOrO
i/. q
IIMMyHMTeTa
B
nepHOJI
PereH'i､CTBa EJIeHbI ｢LmMHCKOji
｡

275

●

1. Tel)l)IIT()1)IIa川jHOe l)aclll)e｣leJIGHIIC II OCHOBHble

̅

寺

ﾖ

■

3ana[IH nePBIJIx )KaJTOBaHHI)Ix rPaMOT nl)aBﾙITeJIb-

gBaEIleHb!r"I!HcKoii(fmlBapb-q)eBpaJIbl534n)

276

go4TBep>K4elllle
2
BKoHue(I)eBpaJIm
l534rrpaMof
HMHTPOBCKOI､o yneJIa .

304

3．>Ka.JI0BaHHLIe
yKa3Hble
II
rpaMoTbI
MapTa
l534-

■

●
r〃a8aV/.
｡eOmaJIbHblii
MMMyHIITe'r
rOmIJI
B 60叩CKOrO
nPaBHaqaJTa l538 rr.

308

U

JIeHHZ1

．

327

!E!|yll]emllafIno"l!TIIKaBaml)eJle-oKT,16pel538 !､、
yCIIJIellue
2.
KOMnl)oMMCCHblX
TeHnellUHih
B-HMMVHM四

329

オ〃

Te･rHoHnoJII,ITHKG HoH6pH 1538­ⅡePBOii llO"･IOBIIHbl

l540

■

rr.

334

3.I'IMMyIIIITeTHaFIHoJIIITHKanpaBm､eJ1bcTBaKH”H

e
U
e
POro nPaBJTeHI呪 皿yiicKHx
2q U
5.1'i3MeIIeHIIHBIIMMyIIIITeTHoiinoJIHTIIKeB1544 nel)BoIi noJIoBI,IIIe l546 rr.
●
●
H. ｡ Be@ﾉIbcKoro ・

344

4．POcT
IIMMyIIIITeTIIblX
nPPIBMJIerliiI
B
nePIIOJl
BTO-

348

352

EacUBeT
a
*eoJIaJlbHoro
lIMMyHIITeTa
npu
rJI!川cKⅡx､

凸心■

HoBbIe
orpallII[IJITeJIIjIIbIe
TeII八eII山11i・

3aK"I()IIeHIIe

①◆

.

CHIIcoK coKpa皿ell1Iil .
IIMeHH()ii yKa3aTeJIb .

●

B

■

｡

■

｡

■

●

■

●

３６１
３７５

■

３７７
●

■

c

３８０

一一一一己
­ - ＝＝＝

一
⑲

Cep2e" Mz"QzZ"oGz" Kq2"""o8

COL皿A入bHO-nO入I'TTI'IIIECKAHルICTOPI/IJI
POCCI'ILI
KOHUA XV - nEPBOH nOAOBL'IHbl XVI B.

』ﾉT“β牝02"oノc"“αT〃
〃"cT"7"To"
"CrOp""ʻ4凡aaeﾉM""〃α"ﾉc
CCCP
PeUaKTop
H3,nlaTe,JIbcTBa
｡/7eB"〃α.
4.
C.
Xy,nko)KHIIK
/̅'.
Ko6/)"H
A
TexIIH[IecKMii pe'aaKToP //. ".ﾉn/3"e 'ｨOBα

唖

一

画

､.』J，

！･

C,maHo
Ha60p
B l4/III
1967
no八nlicaHo
r.
ne'IaTII
I< 3/VI
I967
(I)oI)MaT
r.
84 108i/]2.

ByMara
､Nb
yc,JI.
2.IIGL1.
J1.
20,6.
y(1.-}【3瓜．、ﾉ1.
21,8
Tlipa]K
1700.
T-080'19,
THIw.
3aK.
()652
ueHa l p. 49 K.

""b""HayK"mocKBa,!<-62,no"coce!lcKIIimep"D
21
q
morPa（1）IIHII3瓜aTe皿bcTBa“HayK”、MocKBa，r-99,my6HHcKHM
2­H
nep.，lO

O H I E I I AT K H

……。…,|……"|瓜………
38

1CB

19

9

38

11 CB

9

10

215

5cB

O6JIaCTb

BOJIOCTb

236

12 cH

1073 r.

7013 r｡

C ， M ･ K a m Ta H o B