y. 6. CD
naTOB8


nPABO 06U\EII1 C06CTBEHHOCTI;1
B POCCI;1I;1, ,EPMAHI;1I;1, ABCTPI;1I;1
1;1 WBEII1 l..J/IPI;1 1;1

crOp
Ko-KOMn8p8T
Bi'1crcKoe i'1CCne):10B8Hi'1e


MOCKBA
00,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
''''




Y,AK347
Ei6K67 A04
<1>51
CPl41laToeaY_6.
rlpaBo 061l18i:! co6c'meH-1ocn1 B POCCL-II1, repMBHL-II1, ABCTpl1l111 WI!8i:!l!8-
4>51pL-II1:IIIC'1lJP'I(O-KO./Y.Ei4>I1-
naTOBa.-M. 1i1)J.«lQplIIcnpYAeH'--''''fI,2012 -120c
ISBN 978-5-9516-0586-3
BMOHorpa4>l1l1ocHOBHble3Tanbllo1f1,
"'pa3B1<rnfl"HcrnryTaot)UJ:!iiCo6cTBeHHOC;TMBPoccM""repuaH"'M.ABc'rpl<",..WBeii-
LI<IP"'I1.HaocHoBeilHanM3BnpaBOBblXaKTOBnepe-
"HCJIeHHblXl!bllJJerOCYAilpGTB,perym<lpYJOlU,lolXOT1iOW8HM,(jbllla
<renOC;THafiKilprnH(lC1aHClBlletHl"pa3B",rnfinpaeaot)UJ:!ii
BClJJaHaXpmaHO-npaBOBoMCMGTeMbl..pa3pa60TaHpI\!IpeKOMeH,!l,ilU,l'lii,
HallpillllleHHblXHiIpocc¥1i:1cKOroperyJ1"'pyIO-
Ll!8ro06ll1Y'Oco6cTseHHOCTb
MOHOrpa4MflpaCC'll'lTaHat!ilW",po"",iiKpyr.Bl<lllO'"fiIflCTYAeHTOBlOpI<-
,II,I<ecK/olXBY30B,H8)"IHblXpa60THMKOI!..npen(),Qlll!lffi!Jl8ii.
.1'" ''''"'1
Y,AK347
66K 67.404
ISBN 978-5-9516-0586-3
@(1oIWlTOBaYEi.,2012
@OPOpMJIeHMe_"1.lI..2012

nPEAIiICnOBI1E
fpam,n;aHCKC>e 3aKOHO.n;aT€JlbCTBO J1 rpam,n;aHCKO-npaBOBaH ,lIOK-
TpWHa pa3Bt1TJlfl J1HCTIlT)'Ta 06l1\eii co6c'IEeHHo<:.- B PCJCCJrlicIOCIii
c!>e.ZJ;epaIVnt B YCJIOBHRX COBpeMeHHoro MJ.fpa HeMHC.ffi1Ma 6e3 3Ha-
HHH J1 Ol\eHlU1: J1CTopID1 era o6ecneID'!JI B ,lJ;peBHeM PHMe, 3apy-
6emHhIX CTpaHaX EBpOnei1:cKoro C0103a: fepMBHJ.1I1, IliBei1:QapID1,
ABc-rpim J1I1HbIX rocy):\apCTBax pemORa.
fpam,n;aHCKC>e npaBO POCCIDf, o6ecne t HrnaIOl1\ee npaBO oOll.\eii
COOCTBeHHOCTIiI J1MeeT I'JIyDOKM€ KOpID1 J16oraryro ]J;opeBOJIlOl\IfOH-
HYIO cl1creMaTJI3BQKIO JII K0)U14nmal\"no, CJlomt1BllD1ec.R no)]; BJH1-
flHl1eM fepM8HCKOrO rpam,QaHcKoro YJIO:IK€fHf.H, tIJpa3cKoro
rpa:>K,!\BHCKoro KOJJ;€EtCa, IIIBei1:r-tapCKoro rpam,n;aHCKoro KO):1eKCa
JilI1HbIX 3aKoHo):{aTeJIbHbIX aK70B, KOTopble HCCJI8,lIy8T aBTop B MO-
Horpacj:lwlecKOMTpy,l\€.
IIOKa3aTeJIbHo, 'lTO eCJIJII nyTb pa3BHTI1JII1HCTIlT)'Ta 06ll.\ei1: co6-
CTBeHHOCTH B POCCIDf cJIe)Jye'f IIpI1:maTb TepHJilCTbIM J1 Ha nparH-
:/KeID'!I1MHOrwx,AeCR1'l1JIeTmIHaxO.n;>fBIlBlMCH nO)];BJII1mmeMCOBE'T-
CKOii HC'I'OpI'fiI., TO,IJ; fry 1896 r., cfJrK 1804 r. JII.l1pynle
3aKOHo,n;aTeJIbHW€ aEThI €BpOneJ1cKHx crpaH HeJl3MeHHbI 80 Bpe-
M€1ill JII npOC'l'paHCTBe.
HeCMOTpn HB CpamuITeJThHO cTa6MJII:.HOe rpa)K,!1BHCKOe aa:rw-
HOp;aTeJII:.CTBO, peryJU1pYKJI..qee OCHOBHwe nOJIOmeID1H J1HCTI1TY-
Ta npaBa ofuuei1 C06cTBeHHOCrn eBponei1cKJ1X CTpaH, J1MeIOTCH
onpep;eJIeHHI:.'e paant1'-1t1H BOaHt1KHOBeHI.ffi., co,n;epmaHt1H coc06-
cmelllIJlKOB J1 npt1MeHem1H JnIeTJ1TYTB B 'Ip1OHHI:lX ycnOB:11-
HX CTpaHW.
HeJTh3R OTpt1WiTI:. J1 TO, 'ITO npaBO 06l1\ei1 C06CTBeHHOCTt1 Poc-
CID1 RaK IffiCTIrryr rpa:lK,JJ;aHcKoro npaBa B HaCTOHIl\ee BpeMH Bce
60J1ee nepem.tMaeT JIY'-llillfe  ,l\0peBO.JIlOlU10HHOro 3aKO-
Ho,n;aTenI:.CTBa (ynomelU1H 1913 r.), fpaWJI,BHCKOI'O
KO,lleKCa PCct>CP 1922 r. J1 fpa:lK,JJ;aHcKoro KO,lleKCa 1964 r. MHorne
HayqHWe Tpy,l\W yqem:.IX-l.U1BJ1JIJ'1CTOB COBeTCKOrO nepl1op;a, no-
CBHl1\eHHWe np06neMaM npaBa C06CTBeHHOCTI1 J1 npaBa 06l1\ei1 c06-
CTBeHHOCTt1, HarrpJ1Mep M.M. ArapKoBa, C.R. BpaTYCH, o.c. MotlJ-
cpe, JI.A. JIJHl.\a, ME. Homn.uroro, B0C'Ipe60B8.Hbl J1 B COBpeMefIHoe
BpeMH.

BbIDOp TeMbI J1CCne):lOBaHIDI, npe,lJ;CTaBJIeHHoro 3BTopOM, npe,!\o-
npe,!\eJIeH l\eHTpaJIbHbIM MeCTOM HHC'I'J1'I)'TB B rpa:>K,!\aHCKOM npa-
Be PoccmICJOCJH Cfle):lepaQJ1J1 J1 npe,IJ;llOJIaraeMblM 06HOBJIeHJ18M B
6.moKaiirnee BpeMR rOCY.r\apCTBeHHOH l{yMoii 4>e.r\epaJlbHoro Co-
6paHIDI nocJle BHeceHJ1H 7 eBpa.IDI 2012 r. COOTBeTCTBYIDlL\erO 3a-
KOHonpoeKTa npe311,QemOM PIp):I;. Me,IJ;Ele.r\8BbIM. J1HhIMIlf CJlOBaMJ1,
paCCMaTpJ1BaHnpeAJIQmeHHhlii 3aKOHOllp08KT, B TOM 'lJ1CJIe J1 onpe-
.r\etlf npaBOBoe IIOJIIDKeIDIe IffiCTl1T)'Ta  co6cTBeH-
Hocm B rpam.n,aHCKOM KO.IleKCe POCCIDicIOCIii Cfle):lepallYlYl, 3BTOp
MOHorpa4JJ1J1 nOJIaraeT HeOOxo):\KMhIM npOBE'CTI1 cpaBHJrreJ1bHbIi.i
aHaJIJ13 3aKOHO.DaTeJlbCTBa pH,!\a eBpOneHCKMX CTpaH, "':ITO BlIOJIHe
onpaB.L\BHHO B YCJlOBJ1.11X BCTYITJIeHt:lfi CTpaHbI B BTO, C03.I1aHtUI
C 1 JOO.IDl2012 r. e,lI;J1Horo TaMmKeHHOroIIpOCTpaHCTBa C PecnyfuIJ1-
KaMJ1 Ka3axcTaH J1 BeJIapych.
Pa3BJITHe JIHC'IH'IYT8 o6w;eii co6cTBeHHCIC'IH B POCCJ1J1 B YCJlO-
BIDIX o6HoBJIelDfj{ rpa:>K,!\aHcKoro 3BKOHo.n;aTeJlbCTBa .r\eJlaeT oco-
6eHHo BKTyaJIbHbIM J13y'ieHJ1e J1 HCIIOJIb3OB8.ID1e onpaB):IaBlillIX
ce6.11 KOHCTPYKL\t:lH qaCTHOro npaBa 3apy6e.mHhlX cTpaH. IIpoQecc
J13MeHeHMH rpa:>K,!\aHCKoro 3BKOHO.l\8TeJlbCTBa B JJ,aHHm ctlJepe
061L\eCTBeHHhIX oTHoweHIDf ,lJ;YlHaMW'IeH, a onhlT pa3JIM'{HbIX CTpaH
HeO.JJ;H03HaqeH J1 He Bcer.r\a MomeT 6b1Th J1CnOJlb30BaH B poccIDi-
CIrnX YCJlOBWlX, Ha qTO 06paaeT BIDtMamre aBTop MOHorpaqnm.
K COmaJleHYllQ, OT1\eJIhHble 3aJWH()J:IaT€'JlYI J1 cerop;tfH nhlTaIOTCfl J1C-
nOJlh30BaTb HeKOTOpble KOHCTpYKl\t:It:I npaBa o6w;eii co6cTBeHHo-
CTt:I pa3JIJ1'llibIX eBpoIleHcKt:lX CTpaH, He C'illT3HCb C Tpa.I:Oi!l\JrnMt:!
J1 o6bI'IBJIMH Ch'eqeCTBa, 6e3 yqeTa 3aKOHO):laTeJlbHbIX nOJlO:HteHt:li1:,
nporne.r\lllt:lX npOBepKY BpeMeHeM J1 anp,:,6IfpoBaHHblX npa.K'i1'IKOfl.
TeM Ba)KHee npe,!\CTIlBJlHeTCH Hec6xo.v;J1MOCTh YHCHJ1Th B paMK8.X
npeAITaraeMoro :t:I3ABHt:I.II ocof5eHH:crH ceCTByro npaBOBblX
CJ1CTeM eBpOIleHcKHx CTpaH, peryJIJ1PYIOlW1X npaBO co6cTeeHHocm,
JlOI1fKy HOpM, OCHOBHhle nOIDITIDl, BO BceM MHOroo6pa3J1J1 CeMeH-
HhlX, )KJfJUflltHbIX.  HaCJl8,l1(."lBeHJ1 HHbIXOTHO-
IlIE'mni, CH B npoQecce npBB1:IlpKM8Hemm, oxpaHbI
J13BIWIThl npaB, 3BKOHHhIX J1HTepeCOB cj:a.c3J1'>€CKHX J1lOpJf,!:J;Yl'lecKt:IX
"'"'
HaJIDoJIee HHTepeCHbIM J1 nOJle3HbIMnpe,D;CTaB.llH8'fCHJ13}"ieHJ1e
J1HCTJ1Tyra o6w;ei1 co6C'meHHocTIl npOMhillIJleHHO pa3BlITHX CTpaR:
fepMaHt:lt:I, liIBei1:QapID11i1 ABCTpMM. TeM 60Jlee qTO rpa)K,!\aHCKOe
npaBO crpaH KOHTt:lHeHTaJIbHOH EBpOIlbl, B qaCTHOCTJ1 fepMIDBDf iii

<PpaHqIDt, lUlK iii POCCI1I1, flBJIJleTCJI HaCJIe.v;HHI«)M 1 PI1M-
CKOro 'i8CTHoro npaBa.
HeJlb3J1nOJIHOCTblOOTBepraTblilrpam,QaHcKoe npaBoCIlIA, AH-
rnl1l1, OTHOCfi1W1eCJI II: CI1CTeMe o6w;ero npaBa, TaFt RaFt, HeCMOTpJl
Ha I1MelOmwecJl 3aKOHOJ(aTeJIbHble pa3JIWIl1J1 B o6ecne'lem1Yl rrpaBa
o6w;ei1 C06CTBelIHOC'TK, OITbIT npaBoBoro peryJIMpOBaHI1J1 .l\aHHoro
UHCTJrryIa MO:meT 6bITb orpaHM'leHHo nplilMeHeH 11 B pOCCl1liiCKMX
YCJIOBI1HX.
IIpoI1Cx B nOCJIe;:J;lrn:e rO.Ilbi €CCl:l Mem,Q)'Hapo,!\Hoi1
iii perl10HaJIbHOlii IiIHTerparttfJ1, yqacTI1e POCCUI1 B Mem..QyHBpobIX
COrJIarneHI1HX (BTO) Bbl3bIBaeTHe06xo.r\J:fMOCTb BHeCeHI>1J1 onpe.IJ;e-
neHHbIX 1i13MeHeHI1i1 B rpam,QaHcKOe 3aKOHOTeJlbCTBO. IIo:noMY
npe,lJ;CTaBJIHeTCR Ba:IKHblM aHaJIl13 TeH,.!J;eH1!111ii rapMOHI13a'--tl1M iii
ymtQ:amal\11JII rrpaBa 06mei1 m6cTBemIOCTI1iii IiICnOJIb30BaHI1H OIIbI-
Ta 3apy6emHblX cTpaH B pocam:CKI1X yCJIOBW!X npaaoool'O perYJUI-
pOBaHI1H IfHC'I1.I'IYTB-
MOHorpa4J11R Y. cI>MJIaTOBOM, HecMoTpH Ha .l\IfCKyccJfOHHOCTb
OT.l\eJlbHblX IIOJ1OJK8HmI, 3aCJIymJlBa8T BHI1M3HJ11H crrel..\JlaJrnC'TOB
B 06JIaCTI1 rpam,QaHcKOro npaBa. PaCIill1p€'HMe Mepo,lJ;Hl.1X
,lJ;eJIOBblX cBH3eiii .l\eJIaeT 3KTyaJIbHbIM BOIIpoC 3aLqlITb! IilHTepeCOB
pocCJB1crotx rpam.!\aH, c06CTBeHHocTI1, II8.XQIJ,fflU8Jlcfl B cTpaHe iii 3a
py6e)f(OM. II03TOMY poccuiiIcKKM ropl1CTaM, OTCTBJIBBIOI1tJ1M IiIHTe-
pecbl cpl13H'leCK1IX 11 IDplWI'leCKI1X JlMl\ B OOrraCTI1 rrpaBa o6w;ei1
coOcTBeHHOCTl1lUlK B POCCJ1I1, TaK 11 3a ee npe,QeJIaMl1, MomeT 00-
MO'-lb HaC'I'OSll'--tl1i Ha}"-lHMIii TPy
omae.iW.M
Cpa61tU7n€J!b1W20 npaso6eae1tWl.
POCCUiiC1WU a1OOI3eMuu npaooqjaWL
I1m:mop wpu(1u'leCKUX 1iaYK,
npocfJeccopA.fl.tPcmo6

BBE.L\EHI1E
J1HcTInyr o6w;6i COOCrnellllOCTH H Poccml BCer.r\a OTJIM'iaJICH OT
.rIpym:x I1HCTwry'I'OB rpa:m,!\aHcKOro npaBa 6o.rrnllrn:M KOJU1'lecTBOM
npooeJIOB, HeoI03lffi'IHO TOJIKYeMbIX TepMl1HOB, npaBOBbIX KO.JI.Jrn:-
3I1HHopM. HHoe<.t5croHTe.m,crl1MeeTpH,D;npJll'il1HB TOM<rnCJIeJII
J1CI'OpWlecKOro xapaKTepa.
J1HJJ;I.{BWflYaJIbHaH ro6cTBeJrnOC'l'h, llOIBfMaeMaH KaK c06cTBeH-
HOCTb OT,AeJIbHoro cy6"beKT8, 0'IH0CJ1TeJIbH0 MOJIO;J;a B "':IeJIOBe'ie-
CKOP'! I1CTOpJ:lI1 pa3BU'I1m. JLrm nepBoro 3Tana JilCTOpIt'l8CKOI'O pa3-
BI1TIffi 'leJIOB8'l8C'l'Ba 6bura xapaKTepHa 06Jl1aH KOJIJIeK'l'KBHiUI
COOCTBeHHOCTb (YCTaBH8J1 COOCTBeHHOCTb Ii COOCTBeHHOCTb KJIaHa).
3aTeM ceMeUHaR ccfic'meHHcx:.' JII TOJThKO nOTOM 
COOCTBeHHOCTb. J1Hp;mu,1f\yaJIbHaR co6c-rneIrnOCTb B03HIfKJla J13Ha-
':IaJIbHOHa)J;BJDKUMbIeBell.\l1, CHa':laJIa Ha.IDftlHblenpe,lJ,M8Tldncrrpe-
6neHJil.fl (o.r\e>K,!\B, HHcrpyM8HT, opyml1e,:yKpa11I8HHfi. 8'II>I
):\OMalilllero ofu1xo,!\a JII T.)];.) J1 ,n06bI'-1Y. 3eMeJIbHaH co6CTBeHHOCTb
Ha'ffiHaeT CTaHOBHTbCH mrrepeCHa TOJJbKO C IIDCeJIemm ":IeJIOBeKa
B KOHKpeTHoii MeC'IHOCTlf iii OCT8€TCR TalOKe AJ]JrreJIbHoe BpeM.fl
KOJIJIeK'l'J1BHOii JII CeMeillioii COOCTBeHHOCTbID. I1HTepec K I1CKJIJO'iI1-
TeJlbJIOMy yqacmy 3eMJU'I OTCyTCTBOBaJI y  nJIeMeH
OXO'lHlIKOB JII c06J1paTeJIei1:'. IIocTeneHHQ poJIh J1 c<}>epa npHMeHe-
HHH oow;eil C06CTBeIlllOCTJ1 )'MeHbllIaJIaCb, HO COBceM JIIC'le3HYTb
He Morna, IIOCI«JJIbI\YB qeJIOBe<:IeCKOM ofuueCTBe Bcer.r\a OCTaHYTCJI
OTHOllleHMJI, OMaA8JOlltl'le npJ13HaKaMJil o6meti cct5c'meHHoCTU.
TeMa 06meil co6c-rBemmCTI1 B POCCIDf Be'IHa B HaYKe J1 nocTO-
1IHHO BOCTpe6omma npaKTImoH mt13HJ1, B oc06eHHocTu CY,lJ;e6Hoii
IIpJ1 J13YIJ:eHYIu o606meHI1i1: CY,l1e6HOi1: npaKTMKI1 pa3JIWIHhIX KaTe-
ropJ1i1: ,l1eJI (c1>e.n;epawrn. cy6"beKTOB) EO MHomx ctlJepax npaoonpu-
MeHeHI1JI B POCCID1 CTaHOBI1TCJI O'leBJ.UJ;HO, "':ITO HmWr,lJ;a He 6y,l18T
J1,11eaJJbHoi1: KOHcrpyKlttm. cnOC06Hoti ,l1aTb 0.n;H03HaIJ:HbIe OTBeTbI
Ha B03HUKalOLqI1e npoQlleMbl ,l1efrrBHTeJIbHOCTll
JlCTOpJ1JI pa3BKrUJlMHCTiIITyra o6mei1: cx6:rneJrnocTH B PocCJm:
BO Bce BpeMeHa l\IfBJfJIiII3OBaHHOI'O 06I1teCTBa J.1JIJJIOCTpl1pyeT me-
.mmue npaBOBe,n;OB MaKCJ1MaJJbHO C6.rrJll3UTb era 3aKOHO,llaTeJJbHoe
'C...FIoIJrnannU_Osterr9I:tisct>I'nvaIrecI'rIsgSechsteak1uai!oEl1ehAlageSpriogerWen
New1t>rk,200B-S.176

o6ecne':lemle C «IIpO.IJ;BJIH)'THMI'I" 3apy6e:nan,rMJ1 CTpaHaMY! (Tep-
MBHY!fl, <fIpa:Ifl J1 Jij).), r.r\e OHO OCHOBaTeJlbHO 11 ClfCTeMHO rrpe.r\-
CTaBJleHO B KO.r\eKCaX C 200-neTHJ1M CTa:meM. Ha Cel'O,D,HJ!lliHJul
.r\eHb 3TO OC05eHHO aKryaJlbHO, TaK RaK poccJ1ikKOe rpam,QaHCKOe
rrpaBO rrepe:mY!BaeT rrep>1o,!\ rny60lrnx KopeHHbIX rrpe06pa30BaHY!i1,
':ITO CBfl3aHO C pB3pa50TKoi1 KoHl.errwrn pa3BIITJ'ffi rpaaHCKO-
ro 3aKOHo,!\aTeJThCTBa J1 npoeKTa HOBoro I'pa*,!laHcKoro KO.r\eKca.
II03TOM)' I1CCJle.r\OBalllifl cpaBmrreJThHO-npaI3OBOIiJ: HarrpaBJIeHHO-
CTH oc05eHHO BocTpe50BaHbl npOQeCCOM 3aKOHQTBOpqeCTBa. Co-
BepIlIeHCTBOBaHl1e 3TOro IIpOl\eCca - .lJ;eJlO HayxY!, B CBfl31i1 C ':IeM
C'IJlITaeM, ':ITO .r\aHHafl pa50Ta 6Y.IJ;eT cnoc06CTBOBaTb cOBepweH-
CTBOBaHM1Q 3aKOHOTeJIbHoro peryJIlfPOBBHHSI I1HCTIlTyra o6w;ei1:
C06CTBeHHOCTJ1 B Pel>.
B HacTOflw;ei1 pa60Te BcecTopoHHe JlI3y'leHo rrpaBoBoe perynY!-
poEaHlile OTHomeHHii 05w;ei1 co6c'meHHocTH B TepMaHlDI. ABcrpmI,
lIIBeJfi@pJlIY!J1 POCCMYI, a TaIOKe ocyrn;eCTBJleH aHaJllil3 npaBOIIpIf-
MeIDITeJThHoi1 npaKTHKJ111  J1CCne.r\oBaHlili1, BblflB-
neH IJOOI1'I'I.ffiH J1 Hera'I1'fElHNif onbiT rrpaBoBoro peryJII.lPOBBHIDl-
,lLaHHafl pa6oTa, B03M(»KHo, .r\aCT 60Jlee nomme npe,!\CTaBJIeID:!e
06 OCHOBHblX HarrpaBJlemmx, Tpe5yIOw;Hx COBepIlIeHCTBOBaIDUI
B perYJll1pOBaHJ1H, 6Y,l\eT cnoc06cTBoBaTb 60Jlee 060cHoBaHHoMY
pa3pelIleHJ1IOBCexnpo6neM,  Mem,ny COc06cTBeHHY!-
RaMH.

rfiaBa 1. nOHflH1E 11 COAEF?KAHI1E
051l1E C05CTBEHHOCTI1
B PI1MCKOM nPABE
J1HCTWI'yr 06meil.Jl(lJIeBm1 c06CTBeHHoCTH - 3'1'0 O.l1I1H 113 JlpesHeJ:i-
1111>1X IIpBBOBblX HHCTIfTY'TCE, t CO BpeMeR pHMCKOI'O npaBa,
n03T0M)', roBopH 06 :nanax CTaHOBJIeHI1H eBpOneiiCliOro npasa OOIl\ei1
COOCTSeHHOCTl1, HeJIb3J'1 He OC'ffiHc:mITbCfI Ha plfMCI«JM qaCTHOM IIp8Be,
Ha aCROBe peL\eIIQI1J1 Karoporo J16bIJlO CtlJopMJtpOBaHO 'laCrHoe npaso
IIO'IU1 BCex 8BponeiiCKl1X rDCy):\apcTB.
B O'--leHKe 3Ha'leHI1.f1 pl1MCKOro 'laCTHoro npaBa, 6e3}'CJIOBHO, CJIe-
,[U'eT COmaCI1TbCR C MHeHi1eM C.C. AneKceesa, I«YrO(HH: OTMe'JaJI,
"TO pl1MCKoe 'laCTHOe IIpBBO npoIf3B8JIO «MOI.1tHOe, IICOKa.JIyii, .r\:DKe
«B3pbIBHoe" I1HTeJIJIeKryaJlbHOe o6ocaIneHMe npaBa, Kor,na pB3:yM
«BopBaJICR» B 06naCTb cor..c:faJ!bOOi.i: perYJIHW1M J1 B CER3" C IIOTpe6-
HOCTmm 0B0ii *"3HI1 iii JOPUJUl'leO<Oi npa1cr'HKtf npOiUlI1J1 CBOIO
CHJlY B C03,naHIDIlOpWUi'leCIDIX MexaHI13MOB, I<OHCTpYKW1i1: 11 I<aTeI'O-
pHi-! BblCOKOro mrreJlJI8K'I'}'OO nopH,QKa. ... II03TOM)' aHa 'lJTb ID'J
HeBroTOBOMBl1,!\eBOlllJIOB KYJIhTYPy.IIpl1qeMBolllJIo
He IUiK CI1CTeMa fBHbIX lWHKpeTI1311poBalllibiX IDpIf.!I,Jl'recKltx
npe.n;rrIilCaHt1i:1: .n a RaK I1HTeJIJIeK'I)'8JlliHhIf' npaBOBbI8 '--IeHHOCTI1 - CO-
BeprneHHaJI CI1CTeMa 1OpI nOC'1'pOelU(ll, KOHC'I'pyKQIDl, Ka,-
TeroplfH, 1JOHHTJ00r0r0 11 JIeKCWIeCKoro annapaTa, cyMMJ1pOB3HHl:lX
B VIB.B.rtJ.1I'eCTaX (KOJleKce)IOcTl1HJ1aHa"'.
 lIpaso ObIJlO npaBOM OJleCTHlQei1 lItmJlJUf3BLtHI1, npo-
CTJ.1}XllJlll8t1cJ::r 0'1' Cpe.rui.3eMHOI'O Mopn /1,0 CesepHoro, 0'1' BI13aHTJIIYJ 1J.0
BpeTaID:!, BbI3bIBBBLU8if B ,D;ywe COBpE'MeHIDIKOB noxomee Ha HOCTaJIb-
nnO'lyacTBO e.ln'lHCTBa, yrpa'leHHoroxpl1CTJ1aHCKI1MMI1pOM»2.
J1MeHHO Ha era 113Y'1efOO1 B XIII BSKe Y'leHbIMV! eB}'XJl18ikKw< }'HI1-
BepcwreTOB 6bIJ1O OCHOBaHO 3apIDK,I\eHJ1e eBp<IIei1CKfJ'O II03IITI'ffiHOI
'1aCTHOra npaBa. P>1MclOOe npaBO HapJI,D;Y C KaHJHI.I'JI2C1{ CTaJIO OC-
HOBO» npenOABBaHJm np8Ba BO Bcex }'HI1BepCI1TE'TaX EBpJIIbl J1 JII1IlIb
3Ha'll1TeJIbHO n03,!J;Hee B }'HI1BepCI1TE'Tax Ha'laJll1 npenOABBaTh -
OHaJIhHOe npaBO. liIBe.!\CKOe npaBO nperrOABeTCR B YmCBJIe C 1620 r.,
'AneKCee.C.C,I1_H,,"npasa.M:Cralyr.2006,C.13Q.
.D.a.'lljp.>K'*ps.Cn_H03I1K-OcHO.....enpaIlOlrolaC..:Te"..CO.pet.oEIHHOC"'/nep.C4>!:taHII-M
Me><J1YIIiIP.OTIIOllJeH,,".1996,c.35

KaclJe)\pa clJpaHlt'J'3ClIDID npaBa 6hlJIa C03)\aHa B Cop60HHe B IIapH-
.me B 1679 r. Ho B 6anhwJrnC'l138 CTpaH HaLUlO1J3JIb1Joe npBBO Ha'Ia-
JIH npeno)\aBaTh B YHJ1B8PCHT8'I'8x JII1lllh B XVIII BeKe: B 1707 r. -
B BIITTeH6epre, nepBoM ymlBepCHTeTe, r)\e npenO)\BBaJIOCh He-
Me npaBO; B 1742 r. - B J.1cnaID1J1; B 1758 r. - B OKapop)\e" B
1800 r. - B KeM6pJ(JJ,m8 B AHr.m1J.1; B 1772 r. - B IIopTyTa.IDDf.
)].0 XIX BeKa 1i)\0 nepHO)\a  KO,!J;(.'l(lmKaI..Uri1 pHMcKoe
npaBO npeII),IJ;aBaJIO(.'b BO Bcex }'lll1BepCJITeTaX, Ii era "3}"{eHHe co-
CTaBJIHJIO OCHOB}' 06pa30Bamrn; np8JI),lJ;31!aIDfe .me HaLtJlOHaJIbHOro
npaBa "MeJIO BTopoCTeneHHoe 3Ha'IeHl1e. Hy.mHO .HCHO OT)\aBaTh ce6e
OT'leT BO BC8X 3TMX clJaKTax, B 6eccnopHo neII8HHOM 3HB-'IeID111
I13Y'Iemrn pJ1MCKOro npaBa EO Bcex }'HI1BepCJ.1TeTaX B Te'IeHYle MHornx
BeROS. 3TOT 4JeHoMeH Boopo:lfC,!J;eHYIJI I43J"1eHYIJI pJ1MCKOro npaBa BbI-
lll€JI no CBO€MY 3Haq€Hl1lO 3a paMKYI EOJIOHCKoro YHYlB€pcJ<lT8Ta,
c o)\Hoil CTOpoHhI, 113<1 npe)\eJIbI XII J1 XIII BeROB - C ,lWyroil'.
Oc06eHHo .QeTaJIhHOH npopa6oTaHHOCTblO OTJII1'ffiJIOCh pl1MCKOe
seIWIoe npaso. J1HCruTyr o6LIJ;eH JI(J.IleBOioJ: C05CTBeHHOCTJ1 - ::ITO O..r\l1H
I13,lWeBHefunMX npaBOBhIX HHCTII-ryros., J13B8CTHbIX P(.1MCKOMJ npasy.
IIo pJ.1MCKI1M 3aKOHaM O,[ltffi 11 Ta .me BeLqh MOrJIa np(.1HaAITe.mBTh
HeCKOJIbKI1M .IDlQaM BMeCTe. 3'1'0 OTHOllleID1e pHMCKIfe IOpJ1CThl Ha3hI-
BaJJ(.1 communion (06lQHocTb)2.
06lQ1iR  MOrJIa B03HHKHY'fh no :H<eJIaHJOO B CBR311
C HaJThI'IYI€M "HTepeCa B 06r.neM J1CnOJ1b30BaH(.111 J1M.}'r.neCTBOM JIJ.1DO
nporuB BOJII1 coc06cTBeHHI1KoB, HBI1pMM8P, nyreM CJIY'-latinmro co-
e,!U1HeHI1H BeLIJ;eii mI60 HacneJJ,OBaHIfJI. «B nepBoM c.ny'lae Me*JJY
coc06CTBeHHI1KaMl1 YCTaHaBJIJmaJIJ'1C K01ITpBK'lHhI8 OTHOWeHY!JI,
,lIeACTBOBaJIO npaBo TOBaplflI\8CTBB.. EO BTOpOM c.ny'lae c::yrnecTBOBa-
JII1 KBa.3MKOH'I'pCiHhle OTHOWeHY!JI, TO eC'fh 06LIJ;HOCTh )\eiicTBoBaJIa
nO)\05HO TOBapillI..\eCTsy»3. B 6anbnnrncme CJI)"18eB OTHOWeHY!JI 06-
LIJ;ei1 co6crnemJOCTIf He JI),[J;pa3yM8BB.1InCb KaK ,ll,ID1'I"8JIl:lIbI8, coc06-
CTBeHIDIKY B nepl1o)\ 3'roi1 He;:J;0JIr0Bp8MeHHOi1: CTB,!J;MJ1 ,[J;ocraBaJIOCb
n )'I1paB()MO'l8HHOO nepCOHhT, KOTopoe II03BOJUIJIO eMJ OKa-
3hIBaTh WlllHlllle Ha ynpaBJIeH(.1e 06r.netf BelltblO. KpoMe TOro, BCer,[J;a
cOXpaHHJIaCh BO:3MOmHOCTb B JII060e BpE'MH ,[J;05(.1BaThCR OTMeHh! 05-
LIJ;ei1 Co6cTBeHHOCTIi..
'CM.AasimP.K,Y""J.""".C,36
2 CM_ 1-\oeM1II<"1'i 6, P''''CKoenpaso,1.1a,o,.6.e.c,-epeonnM. I'i:t<l- .T&IC. 1996_C, 100
3 30MP 1'k:nIJyu,IK)'<e6H"KHCmp""'CI1GTe_pMCK,""OfJl3JK(JaHcKOro"",ea S.m. 2/ep.CH""'.
r.A,6ap<oocKOro.cn6., 1910 C,2Q8
. CM_ MypoMl\SBC. rpa>o:,!l,!ll<CKOenpaaoppeBHerOpMa.JIe'4"_M.. 16B3_C_466
10

06l1\1iR ,lIOJI8EJafI C06cTBeHHOCTb B KJlaCCWlecKOM pt1MCKOM npaBe
6bLna e;:urnCTBellllOO: 4JOpMOi1 OOlltei1 co6crnelllilX."nL IIpaBO 11.0 KJlac-
cWlecKOro nepJ.1o)J;a 3H8.JI0 COBMeCTHYJO C06cTBeIlliOCTb. B nepuo)J; MO-
no.n;oi1 pecny6.mool COBMeCTHaR ro6cTBemrocTI. BCe 60JIbwe IiI 60JIbwe
OTIeCHRJIaCb J1 B nepJ1o.n; KJIaCCJ.1'1eCKOrO npaBa nOJIHOCTbIO J1C'Ieana.
IIOTpe6HOCTHM xaID1Ta.J1J1CTWlecKOfO oOlltecTBa 60JIbwe coarBeTCTBO-
Bana OOlltaR .D:OJI€BaR  KoropaR BIIOCJIe)J,CTBI CTana
C'1wraTbCR KJIaCCt1'J€CROi!! $>PMOi.f oOll.Ietf co6crneHHOCTIf.
F'nMcIaDi npaBOnOpR,!\OK, B TOM 'illCJIe IIpromnOpR,!\OK OTHorne-
IDIi.f cofJc'J'BeJrnc:, l1MeeT cyry60 JIIW OTIeHOK,
RCITOpbIi.f nOCJIe11.0BaTenbHO IIpOCJI BO BCeM. O.v;J.fH J13 PJ.1M-
CKI1X KlpJ.1CTOB IJ;enbc yrBepiK)J;aJI, IJro «He MmKeT CYl1\eCTBOBaTb
C06cTBeHHOCTJ.1 J1JIJ.1 BJIa11.eHJ.1H 011.H0i1 J1 TOi.f me Bel1\blO, KOTopbIe
Ocyme<'TBJlHlOTC 11.BYMR JHIL1aMJ.1 B nonHOM o&beMe»'. 3Ta n03J11..!t1H
COOTBeTCTBOBana npe.D:CTaBJIeHJ.1lO 06 J1CKJIlOIJwrenbHOCTJ1 lIpaBa
COOCTBeHHOCTJ.1 J1 06ecne<nmana 06ll.1etf co6C'IEeHHOCTH «nnoxym nl1-
TaTI'JIbHYIO cpeA)'»2. Mem,!G'TeM 06lL1BR COOCTBE'HHOCTb He Mor.na ObITb
npoCTO 3BnpellteHa, TaK KaK,l\JIR onpe11.enellliblX arHIJllHDm no nOBO-
.D:Y BellteH.HBJIRJIaCb Heo6xo,l],JlMOJL
HeCMCITpH lIB TO IJTO 3BnpeTJ.1Tb J1JI11 BOOOll.le t1CKJllO'lI1Tb cJI)"1at1
06pa3JBBHI1H 06ll.1etf c.u6cTneHHocTH HeJlb3R, J1X Moarno CBeCTI1 R MI1-
IDIMJM)', a TaIDKe C0311.aTb npaBI1JIa, KOTOpbIe ObI peryJillpoBaJIJ.1 t1
3aKpenJ1JIJ]J1 CnocOOHOCTb R OHCTpOl1 JII1KBJf,!J,l!.1J1 0TH0III8Ht1t1 001l.l-
Hocm. 3Toro nym nOCJIe.D:OBaTeJIbHO I1pJf.D:8I»IDmaJIOCb KJlaCCJ1'1eCKOe
pl1MCK08 IIpromEroqeJIblOObIJIO 06pal1\aTbCRccoco6cTBemnmoM, lIB-
CKOJIbKO 3TO BCr3MCOKI«). KaK C e.I\l1HOJ1Jf'rnbIM COOCTB8HHI1K0M, eCJU1 OT-
HOW8HrnI 06ll.1etf co6crBeHmcm B .D:BHHOM KOHKpenJCM CJIyqae ObIIDI
Hel13OearnbI.
06r.qaH ,lJ;OJIeBaR COOCTBeHHOCTb nOHI1MBJIaCb RaK Co6cTB8H-
HOCTb, n011.Pa311.eJIeHlIBR Ha HeRl1e J111.eaJIbHble 11.0JIJ.1. RaR QTMe'laJI
YJIbmllm: «He11.eJII1Mble B€lIV111.eJIRTCR Ha ..aCTI1 CKopee paccy,n-
ROM, ':IeM B .v;ei1CTBI1TeJIbHOCTJ1».3
BJIBJ\eIDIe Bcet! Bel1\b1O paCCMBTfJlmaJIOCb KaK BJIaJ\eIDIe COBOKyn-
HOCTbIQBCeX,lJ;OJI8M. 3TOT IIpl1H1..111rr6bIJI pyKOBQI:\RlI\I1MHalJaJIOM opra-
lill3anl OOll.letf co6cTBetiHocrn
O6ILIHOCTb COOCTB8HHI1KOB BbICT)'II<lJIil RaK €JJ.MIDJDf'lHbIiii COO-
CTBeHHI1K. IIc:pR.AOK BJIa)J;eHilll, IIQ,JIb30RlHU.H 11 parnopmKeHI1.H Bel1\blO
'60ig.0. 13.6.5. 15.
Sch_B.0asMBgeJ1\rn.Bem.I973.S.17.
J48Sab.D_45.:35
11

B qeJIOM "110m! B 'laCTHOCTH 6blJI noC'rpoeH no 06pa311}' 8)J)fHOJllf'lH()J:l
co6cTBeHHocTJ.r, TO eCTb .J1JUI oCyu.lecTBJ1eIDIil npaBOMO'llIii c06CTBeH-
HOCTI1 no O1'HOla:HJDOK BeI1tl1 B qeJIOM He06xo)U1Mo Bblpa3UTb 06'-'lY1O
BOJIIO, a ,IVlR pacnOpRlKeHI1JI cBoeil110JIeil110CTaTO'lH0 BOJII1 011HOro CO-
co6crBemnma. IIpnpaBHJ'1BBIDIe OOll.\eH c06crBeInrocTIl K e,!JJfilom!q-
Hoil COOCTBeHHOCTI1 - 3TO I1pOHBJI8HH8 tnJ,lI;Wnt,l1yaJIKCTWIecKOI'O nOk
XOKnOCTpOeIDIIOO1'HOW8mml.
npm1IIbIpery.mIpOBaHIUI(Y1'1IOllICHIIi06U\HOCTHCBOJ];1IJIt1CbKI.'J1e-
JJYIOw:eMy.
Bo-nepBbIX, H8CKOJlbKO coco6c-rBeJnnmoB paCCMaTpt1BaJrnCb no OT-
HOllIeHJ1IO K B KBK 0)1;1I0 JunJ;O. Be B TaKOM CJIy'3:Be np11Ha.QJIe-
.maJIa He OTl1eJIbHblM m!QaM, a J1X o01UecTay, np11 31'OM KB:m..!1bIiI Mor
1I0Jlb30BaTbCR ero B paBHoil CTeneIDI.
BO-B1'OPblX, KB:m..!1bIill13 coc06cmeHHt1KoB Nor n0JIb30BaTbCR Bceil
BE'lW>IO'.
B-TpeTM1X, peweHJtH 0 paCllopmKeJrn11. COJJ;epiKaHmf 11 YIIPaBJIe-
Hlli1 oOll.\eti: Bell\b1O npuHI'1Ma.mtCb TOJlbKO eW'lHOrnaCHO. TaRm.!. oopa-
30M, eCJI11 O)J;11H 113 coc06cmeHlillKoB He I13'bRBI1JI CBoero cornaC11R Ha
npeAfIOJIaraeMytO nepeMeHY, Be ,l\OJI:>KHa OCTaBaTbCfl B npe:>KH8M
CBOeMnOJIOJoKeID111 2 .
qeTBep-roe npaBI1JIO 3aKJiIOIffieTCJi B TOM, 'ITOeCJH1 C BE'lW>IO, K01'O-
paR no ,)'MCTBeHHbIM ee 'laCTRM IIpI1Ha)J.JIe»\aJIa HeCl<O.J1bKHM JII1QaM,
6bLll11COe,l\l1HeHb!HeKOTOpb!e npaBa 11 OOH3aHHOCTI1, He .nrnyCKalOlQt18
pa3)\eneHJ.1fI, TOrl1a Bee coyqaCTHI1KI1 nOJlb3CEl3JItICl. TaKUM11 npaBallrn
COBOKyrIHO 11 O,l\l1H J13 HI1X He MOl' paCnOpHJoKaTbCR TaKI1M11 npaBallrn,
6e3 cornaCHH npo'IJfX, ,l\a:m:e Ha CBOIO 1J.omd.
TaKOti: nopMOK ocyll.\8C'I'BJI npaBOMO'llIii ObLII J1C'I'O'iHMKOM
cnopoB Mem.rur COcoOCTBeHHI1KaM11, TaK KaK np11HHTIle nI06oro, ,D,a:m:e
OqeHb BamHoro peweID1R Morno 6bITb OCJIO:iKHeHO 
n03HL\l'feJl 0)1;1I01'0"3 COCo6cTBeHHtIKOB. BblXO,l:lOM 113 3TI1X l«)
HblXcwryaI.lJrli6bIJl0'I"OJlbKOnpe
PnMCKI'1ii IDWfBI'1JIY3IDIcrH'lecrorli: no,l:lXO,I\ K OOll.\llOCTI1 COCOO-
CTBeHHJ.fKOB B3RT 3a OCHOay ,l\JIH llX"I'pDeHHf! co6cTBemroro perynl1-
pOBaID1HOTHOW8HJ.rl{ BCeMI1COBpeMeHHbThrn eBponeikKMMl1
K01J.K$UIMJ.L O,l:lBaKO  3aKOHOTE'JIbCTBO repMa-
rum, IIIBeJ1qaP"I1, ABCTpJU'l 11 4IpaHLJ;ID1 npaKIWl8CKJl cpa3y J1:CKJIJO-
'l11JI0 J1Jllf Cyu.leCTBeHHO OrpaHJ.1'3:I1JIO npt1M€HeHI1E' npl1HqI1lIa e,l\l1HO-
'0.._ Dig )(111_6.1 5,15T_
20... ra,pc""rappHJ:lOM.X PMCI<OO""CTHOOnpa80:Ka3yGbI,"C."'''H<:TIfIYTI>'/ep.c''cn. 011! pe,lI.
1l.11.Ko<j>aHoo,M.CnlTyr2005C,315
3CM_ Dig VIII_I 1.17
12

I'JIaCI1H, TaK KaK ,, Hf'06xo.l:\HM B nepBYJO Ollepe.lU> He YlleT
MHeHJ1Jl KaiK,!l;oro coco6c'l'Bemnma., a B03MmKHOCTb HaWrI1 KOMIlpo-
MMCC 11  stlxPeK'I'I1BHoe ynpaBneHl1e J1 n01IhaOBaHI18 06-
llIefI BeJ.1tbKJ»'. To eCTb f'l€CKHii no.nxo,1l; 6b1JI CMeHeH
KOJIJIeKTtmHUM.
IIpi1HQJD1bI peryJIl1pOBaHJ.1R 06J.WiOCTI1, cct>oPMYJIJlpoBBHHbIe
KJIaCClt'I€CKI1M pHMCKtIM npaBoM, 6bLJII1 nOJIHOCTbKJ BOCIIpJ1HHTbI JJ,O-
pe, roB8'fCI\JIM J1 cOBpeMelllibIM POCCJri.kKI1M 3aKOHO-
,naTenbCTBOM. OCHOBHbIM He,lJ;OCTaTKOM plfMCKOii: bl 06I11et1
co6cmeHmx.-rJl, I\aK }'me oTMellanocb, 6bLJI JoflJ.ZU'fBr.n;ya.rn:R.'TJt'I€CKHI1:
no,1J;XO,lJ;, KOTOpbrn 6bIJI 3anomeH B YH)J;BMeHT 06I11ei1 co6cmeHHO-
CTI1. CTpeMJIeHl1e pllMCKHX IOpl1CTOB MaKCHMaJIbID npHfi.ml3lITb 06-
l1IYID co6cmetrnoCTb R I11W1Bl1,!JyaJIbHOi1 BldpB3JLJIOCb B npMMeHeID111
IIpJIHQI1IIa e,lJ;MHOrnaCI1JI B pewewlJ.:! BOIIpOCOB BJIa,lJ;eID:1fl, nOJIb30Ba-
HI1JI, pacnOpJDKeIDIfl J1 ynpaBJIeIDI.fI BelltbKJ, '1TO, B CBOKJ Ollepe,lJ;b, He-
MMH)'eMo BneqeT nopom,QeHl1e KO CB.fI3BHHbIX C npJlHfl'IIl8M
peLUeIIHfL KpoMe TOro, 3TO IIpI1'il1HB H8CBoeBpeMeHHOCTIf 11 He:;ol}>--
eImlBlUC'l11 Mep no ynpaBJIelOOO BelltbIO, Be,1J;b .l\OCTaTOIIHO O)Uloro
co6cTBemJJ.ma, BUpB3I1BWE'I'O HeCOrJIaCl1e, <rro6b! peweIDIe, ROTOpoe,
B03MO:>KH0, Bnl1JleT Ha coxpaHHocTb BeIql1 m160 coxpaH€fDle ee nOTpe-
61ITeJIbC1O'1X CBOiicTB. He 6bLJIO IIpI1lUlfO. Bce 3'f() npe,IJ;!IOCbIJlKIf npo-
6neM IIpI1M€HeID:1.f1  06l11eHc06cTBeHHoCTIf, a TaIOKE' pa3JJY-
llIeHI1H arHorneIDIH JlM)'IlIecTBeHHOii 06urn0cTI:I.
'SchneK1erB.DasSd1wazenscheBem.1973_S,45
13

rnaBa 2. nPABO OE>UjE COE>CTBEHHOCfI1
B POCCI1I1
2.1. nPABO 06lJ1E AOJlEBO C06CTBEHHOCT
B AOPEBOJlIOl!OHHO POCC
IIepBbIe nOrIbITKM peIJrnMPOBaHHR 06eiii: co6cTBeHHocTt1 B POCCm1
BCTp8'I<UOl'CH yme B IIpOC1pBHH(If PycCKoil IIpaB,!J;e. Belltb Ha npaEe
061.l1ei1 C06cTBeHHocTJ1 Morna HaXQZJ;IITbCJ! Ral\: Y pO,!J;CTBeHID1KOB, Tal\:
" Y.ID1I..\, He CBR3aHHbIX po,!J;CTBOM. TaR MaTb, 8CJIJ1 MY'K ee, O'rel.\ ee
.l\eTe:if, }'MHpan, HeC.I\ena.rr APyroro pacrIOpamemm, 6b1JIa BIIpaB€ BJIa-
J\€Tb Hepa3,!\€JIbHO co CBO>fIlrnJ\eTbMJ1IcBoero }lMepwero
MymB, a x OTLla, yrrpaBJIHJI OOll.{HMJiMYw:eCTBOM.
Y nocTOpOHlll1X JJJ1lI B 061.l1 C06CTBeHHOCTiII ocooeHHo 'lBCTO Haxo-
.l\I1J1J.fCb yrolU>R, IIp(I\'IbIl1lJI 3aBe.I\8W1H, nepBOHa'laJ!bHOe )"If.Jem-
.l\eHJ1€J1COAepmalU1€IWTOpbIXnpeBbIWaJIOCpe,!\crnaO;:J;Horo':leJIOBeKa'.
Cn 8KTOM, peryJJJ1PYIOlQI1M OTHOIIIeID1.H 06l.l1ett a:6cTBeH-
HOCTI1, 6hI.rr0 Cc60pHoe y.nmKeHMe A.rreKceH M11X3ii.oom1'ID. 1649 r. B OT-
JHNI1€ OT npeAlliecTBymx :mKOHOB, KQTOpbIe o600Ha'iaJIJ1 JIJ1IlIb
pa3JIJ1'IHble BI>1)J;bI 11 np8.l\C'ffiBJI.H.ID1 npJIIMepbI oOll\eH co6CTBeHHOCTI1,
He onpeJleJIJUI B KaKUX-HI1Oy1n> npaBW1BX cyrn;ecTBa npas, 3aKJIKJ'Ia-
lOC.R B Het!, Co6opHoe yJJCnKeHJ18 cnp8JJ;8Jll1JlOOOLqHe nOJIOiKE'ffi1H,
perymrpyHJIJ.V1e B3BHMOOTHOlII8H11H Me:>K,.r\y COCo6cTB8HHI1KBMJ1.l!:aH-
RbIe npaBllJIa ClJl:W:fJlltCb K cJIeJl)'lOI.lI8My: 1) JlOXO,!\bI, nOJIy'laeMble
c cTBa, nplliffi,[lJle*R.m1BCeMcoyqacTHHKaM nocopa3MepHOCTI1
qacTeA, paSHO RaK B :3TOi1: me copa3MepHOCTI1 nBJ\aJIi1 Ha HID:: J1 OOJ'l-
3aHHOCTI1 no oOll\eMY J1Myrn;€CTBy; 2) ynpaBJIeHl1e 11 pacnopniKE'HM€
OOll.{HM t1MJl1I€'CTBOM JJ,QJDKHO 6blJl0 npot1CXO)J;l'ITb no 061.l1€MY corJIa-
CI1KJ scex }"IaCTHI1KOB. Ho 6b1J1B npe):G'cMOTpeHa B03M(J)KHOC'Tb nepe-
lIaTb ynpaBJietille oOIl\MM JtMyIQ8C'I'BOlIf Ot\HOMY 113 COCo6cTB8HHJ1KOB,
no 06eMY 1136paHlOO; 3) yqacTHJ1K B o6lIteM  He Mor OT-
'Iym;::\aTb ero 6e3 COrmCJ1R npo'Hlx; 4) yqac1'H11K BIIpaBe 6b1JI npOTb
J1Jll1 3aJIOjIDfJ'b J1JIJ1 J1 Boo6lIte YCT)'IUlTb CBOKJ 'IaCTb .npyr0M)'.
'e... HeOOJlMHKL1GTCp,,"fJOCCI1C<"'rp8>l<,<laHCt<>1'_OHO. T.2. K,.,ra"ropaR06MMY\IISCTN><.
0l6.TMnorpa""'"....nepa1"OPC"...HIII"',1651C_435

BeT. 14 I'JIaBbl XVII ,,0 BCfl"UffiaX» YJImKeHI1H 6blJl0 3BKp8J1JI8HO,
'1TO KamJIblH J13 6paTbeB, KOTOpblM ,QOCTaJIaCb nOCJIe OTLtB BOT'Il1Ha,
J1MeeT npaBo npoTb t1.ID1 3a.nO:>KI1Tb CBOIii: B Helii: yqacTOK; HO ,lJJ!yn:le
6paTbH J1MeKJT npaBo ynJIaTI1Tb eMY ,JIeHbraMl1 38 ero yqacToK J1 oopa-
TI1Tb yqaCToK K ceoe. C 3TOro MOMeHTa 3apo,IJ;HJIOCb np8J-
Hoe npaBO rIOK}'IllGL
PB3BlITl1e aTl1 n0J10eHl1R nony'll1J1l1 B YCTaBe Ky11e'l8Cl\Ol'O BO.n;O-
xo.n;CTBa 1781 r., r.n;e 6blJl0 onpeJIeHo. "'1TO yqacTHI1KB 06ll.\eM cy,JIHe
BJIaCTeH npoTb t1.ID1 YCT)'rII1Tb '1aCTb CBOKJ ,npyroM)', HO He J:IHa'1e RaK
C COrmCI1R npo'1J1X; eCJII1 OHI1 He 3aXOTHT npllli.l'lTb K ceoe B coyqaCTHI1-
KM TOro, KOMY HaCTOHI..W1H X03Hl1H HaMepeH YCT)'rII1Tb CBOKJ '1BCTb, TO
,nOJImHbl caMl1 ynJIaTI1Tb3a Hee X03HIrny no cnpaBe)J,.JlJlBOJI OQeHKe".
Bee 3TM npaBl1JIa 6blJIJ.:I,JIeTanJl3JlpOBBHbI B 1826 r. B CBO..n;e 38KOHOB
rpaHCKY!x. TOM Xco..n;epmaJlOT,neJlbHYKJrJIaBY, nOCBJlll.\eHH)'lO 00-
l1{eH co6cmemJOCTI:I.. CTaTbH 543 onpe.!l:eJIRJIa npaBo oOll.\eH c06cTBeH-
HOCTI1RaKnpaBo C06cTBeHHOC'III,  .v;BYMJ1JIJ1 MHorrn'w!
JImjaM Ha o;:nm J1 TO me J, OHO Ha3bIBBJIOCb TalOKe npaBOM
OOll.\ero BJIa..n;eHI1J'I
Ha OCHOBe aTom onpe,neJIeIDlH yqeHblMl1 clxJPMY.rrnpyIOTCR npl1-
3HalGl ofuQeii Co6cTBeHHocrn. E.B. BaCbEOBClGIH :yKB3b1BSeT, 'ITO 06-
l1{aR Co6cTBeHHOCTb xapaKTepl13yeTCH: 1) Ha.IDf'lliOC'TbIO HeCKOJIbKJ:IX
cy6oeKTOB 112) e,nJ1HCTBOM ofueKTa. IIpM ::ITOM yqeHbrn: OTMe'1aeT, '1TO
3BKOHO,l\BTeJlbCTBO He nocneJJ,OBaTeJIbHO npl1,nepmI1BSeTCH aTl1X npl1-
3HalWB 06ll.\ei1 co6cmellHOC'l'H, BBO)J;H B rJIaB}' 00 OOll.\e:i.J: co6cmeJrnoc-rn:
HeKOTopble IJOC'TBHOBJIeIDm UI'HOCJrreJIbHO OOll.\eCTB, aKLIl10HepHblX
l\OMIIaIIJul J1 06LWJHHbLX 3€MeJlb, cy6"beKTaMM npaBS co6cTBeJrnocTtl
B KCITOpbIX .fIBJlffiOTCR IOpJW:I'lecIDIe.IDu..la, Hanpl1Mep .v;B0pflHCKoe 06-
l1{eCTBO, OOll.\l1HB., a He COBOKynHOCTb JIIIII\. He nOCJle..n;OBaTeJleH 38KO-
Ho..n;aTeJlb 11 B co6.m<utelOOl npKJHaKa e..n;l1HC1'Ba ofueKTa, TaR RaK "CO-
CTam1T8JI1.:l X TOMa OOMeC1WlI1 no..n; py6pmron OOll.\ei1 co6cmeJrnoc-rn:
HeCKOJlbKO npaBI1JI onttI1T€JIbHO '1ep8ClIOJl)CHOro m, TO eCTb
npaBS cc6crBeHHOCTJf H8CKO.1IbKH'I: JII1L\ Ha OT,IleJlbHble '1aCrJ1 HepB3-
MemeBaHHoro J1MeHMH"',
CBO..n;OM 3amHOB OblJI orrpe,neJleH KPyr 06DeKTOB npaBa OOll.\eH COO-
CTBeHHOCTI1. Tax, yKa3blBaJlOCb, 'lTO npaBO oOll.\ero B.JIa)J;eHI1.f1 Mo:>KeT
arnOCHTbC.fl J1JIM K J1M)'lLIecTBY, KOTopoe no CBaICTBY CBoeMY t1.ID1 no
3aKOHY eCTb He..n;eJIIIIMoe, l1JIJ1:me K J1MYILI8CTB}',  pa3-
,neJlY. Me)K,11y TeM RaX oOlLlee 1:IM)'ILI8CTBO nepBoro po,na He MO>KeT
6bITb pa3neJleHO M81KJ:IY COyqsCTHI1KB.MM Ha OCOOble MaT8p18JibHble
IE8Y4e/5H'"'r;:ta>I\l\!IflCKOronpaBa,Bbln2Bel1J'oenpaao,cn5,1896,C.95-96

'IaCTI1. BGI'HOllI8ffimK06eMYHMYecTBY BTOpOropO)\B scer.na npl1-
HI1MaJ10Cb, 'ITO HI1KTO He 06J'13aH OCTaBaTbG.II coyqaCTHJ1KOM B TaKOM
t1MeHt111, eCJ1J:l He 06J'13aJIcJ'I K TOM}' .nOroSOpOM'.
3aKoHo.naTeJIbCTBO TOro speMefnt He TOJlbKO SOCnpillliUlO pl1MCKyro
KOill.\erruwo a nOHIDffiHl1t1 npasa o6ei1 ro6cmemDcTIll\aK npasa He-
CKOJ1bKt1X IDIQ Ha J1,l:\eaJIbHble .nOJill O)I.Horo J1 TOro J1M}'lneCTBa, HO J1 oc-
HOBHble npl1HQl1IIblocyIQE'C'l'BJl8HW1ofjll\eroHI'1Jl, pB3Bt1B J1XSHe-
o6xo./:J;MMuJ1:cTeneID1.
Perymtp0BBHH8 nopJ'l,ZU\a ocyr.u;eCTBJIeID1.ll npaBOMO'lJIii c06CTBeH-
BOCTI'! Ha':HmaeTCH C npaSOMO'illH pacnopH:lKeHIm. CTaTbH 546 npe31O-
MI1pY8T, 'ITO pacnopH:lfteHl1e 061QMM HepB3.neJI8HHbIM l1MeIDleM ,lJ;0JDK-
HO Ocy:w;ecTBJIHTbCH no o61l.\eMY cornacl1lo. Or,lJ;eJlbHO orOBapI1BaE'TCH
ynpaBJI8lU18 061QMM l1MYll\eCTBoM, KOTOpoe Morno ocyr.u;ecTBJIJITbCH
Jll160 SCeMJ1 co0611\a, Jll160 JloSepH./lOCb OJ\HOMJ 113 TOBapYlll\efi Bce pe-
lllelillH, Kaec.H nOJIb30SaHI'UI If ynpaBJIelHm, npI1Hl'1MaJlllCb
no s3aIDffi0M)' COrnaCI>HO, TO eCTh, eCJ1J:l XQTb OJ\illi yqacrHMK He co-
rnaCWI'CH Ha KaKyIO-JIH60 npe,lVl3I'aeM)'KJ ,npyrnM yqaCTHI1KOM Mepy
no ynpaSJl8HHIO l1MYll\eCTBOM, OHJ.1 He BlIpaBe npe.nnpilliHTb ee. OA-
HaRO coco6CTseHmm Hec 3a TaROe pew8HJ.1e 0I'B8TCTIIeHH0C "Co-
yqaCTHI'!KI1, npl'1HlJC.Hlql18 CBOJ.1M OTKB30M Ha 3aKJllOq8Hl1e CJ\eJIOK no
0611\eMY l1MYll\eCTBY spe.n ,npyrnM coyqaCTHI1KaM, 06H3aHbl OTB8'IBTb
nepe.n nOCJIeJJ,HJIMIl3a 1IOHeceHlill8 11MI1 y6bITKI1 no 06ll\11M npaBI1JIaM
3aKOHa 0 B03HaIpaJK)J;eHI1J.1 3a spe,n If y6blTKJ1. IIpI'I'll1H8HHbIe J\eHHJ1H-
MJ.1 Henpecryr1H:bIMU"'
CoyqacTHI1K Hepa3)J;eJleHmI'O 11M8HI1H 6bLJI snpase 3acTpaxoBaTb
sce J1MeHj,fe, O,!\HaKO CTpa.XOBOE' B03HaIpam,!l;eHl1e npllHa,[J;.1l8)KaJO He
tlCK.JllO'llrreJlbHO eMY, a sceM coyqacTHI1KaM copa3MepHO J1X ,J\OJIJIM.
OcTaJlbHbie coco6cTBemDnrn 6blID1 06H3aHbI B03M€CTHTb paCXO,!J;bI no
OIIJlBTe c-rpaxoBOi1 npeMI1J.1.
1\aJK,!1.bD1 yqacTHI1K 6bLJI BlIpaBe CB06o.nHo paCnOpIDKaTbCJ'I cBOei1
J\oJlei1 s 0611\eM l1MYll\ecTBe, 3aRJIa;:J;blBaTb ee, npOABBaTb. B TaKOM
cJI)"!ae ,npyrJ.1e cocc6:rneHIDfKJ.1 06JIa.naID1 npaBOM npel1M}'l-lI;eCTBeH-
HOi1 nOKYIIKl1, l.\eJlb OCYll\eCTBJleHJ.1H KOTOparo 6bIJIa TO'lliO c4JopMY-
JIItpOOaHB LLJ1. Mei1epoM, KOTOpbrn: OTMe'laJI, qTO «IIpaBO npeJ.1MY-
ll\E'CIE8HHoH nOKynKl1 yCTBHOBJleHO no coo6 'ITO Me:>tiJ\Y
COX03HeBaMJ.1 J\OJDKHO 6b1Tb cormCl1e, E',IUmO,IIJ'IilI8 B ocyIl.\E'CTBJI8lUlJ.1
npaBa o:fcmemn:crn, a Me;>fCJlyTeM nyreMo-rqyiK,ll;em1H,J\OJIJ.1, MWKeT
'CM.E,B.Y'<e6HMKIpIDl'Jl.aHCK<Jll}npaBa.C,98.
21lHOCl\S"K.Krp;l>l\l\£lHCKOronpaBa.l1m4-e_T_1 en_ 1t!96 C.524
16

6bITb, HaBIDKeTCR 6ecn0K0ftHblfi, CBOeHpaBHbIt1: TOBapMIl\ no npaBY
co6cTBemrocTtl» 1 .
3aKOHOABTeJIb npe;nOCTaBl1.JI nepBOHa'laJIbHbIM COBJIa.!\e.JIhQaM He-
OrbeMJIeMOe npaBO He ;nonycKaTb B CBOKJ cpe,14y nOCTOpOlnrnX.JIJ1:Q 6e3 I1X
Ha TO cornaCI1R, a Mexaffi'l3M  3TOro npaBa OCTaJlCR 3B paM-
KaMl1 npaBOBOro perYJII'ipOBaHU.H.. 3m 6b1JI ;nOCTaTO'lHO  npo-
6e.n 3BKOHO):lBTeJIbCTBa, TaK KaK «3HaTb 0 COB£PIIElOOI C)\eJllG:I npo.l\amt1
;nOJJM B 06Il.\eM HMeHID1 Y MJIa)J;IlIero HarBpuyca J1 06 yraepm.neHID1 :now
C)lemG1C'rapIllWMHOTapHycoM, eCJIHn}XJ):lBBeLlHnOK)'IIaTeJTh noiKe.lIalOT
co6.InoC'rn TafuIy, IIpO<rne yqacTID1IG1 B 3TOM J'IMemm, He 05.JIa;:JaR ;napoM
RCHOBu,rJ;emm, He JfMeJJJ:I ID'! KaKOii: B03MOmHOCTIf». A CJIe.I\OBaTeJIbHO, He
6bIJIO mmaKOii:  npe;nOTBpaTIfI'b HapyrneHlte npaB IDI60
CBOeBp8M8HHO npopearnpoBaTb lIB 3TO lIBpyweffi'le.
Y'laCTHI1KJ1.I\OJlmHb!6bIIDIH8Crn paCXO.I\b! nOCO.I\epmaID1IOOOIl\ero
HM.YI1\eCTBa copa3MepHO CBOJ1M .I\OJIRM. ;U;OXOlIbI pacnpe.neJlRIDICb no
TaKOMY me IIpI1HQJ1llY.
Bonpoc060HmlnpaBOl'IICMmBJIa.I\eHI1.f!06Il\11MI1M}'Il\e-
CTBOMTeJIbCTBOMHeperYJIl1}JOO<lJICR.Ho.noK1plHaJIbHoIIpJ1-
3HaBaJlOCb, 'ITO .naHHoe npaBOMo'me TaIDKe ;nOJImHO OC-
Cfl no B3aIDffioM)' cornacl1IQ. fuK OTMe'ffiJI K AIrn8H!l:OB, «BJIaJ\eIDIe
o6Il.\11M  nO.I\06HO TOMY, KaK I1lIOJIb3OBaHHe 11M, .I\OJlmHO
nO.I\JIemaTb pacnpe.I\eJI€HJ1lO Mem,uy coyqaCTIillKaWf COOTBE'I'CTBeH-
HO pasMepy JilX .I\OJIeii: yqaCTHH B H8M, T.€. .I\OJliKHO 6bITb .I\onycx.aeMO
wrn peaJIbHbIMJl 'laCTRW'J 06Il.\ero HMJI.I!;eCTBa, ec.ID1 eT-
Cfl B03MOiKHbIM BJla.r\eFU1e I1M no 'laCTRM, a ecnl1 I1M.YI1\eCTBO no CBoeii:
IIpJlpO,IIe TaKOBO, 'ITO COBMeCTHOe J1 O.I\HOBpeMeHHoe 06JIB.I\BHl1e 11M He-
rnOJIbKI1MM JrnI.{aMJl! npe;nc'raBJIflE'TCII H8l1CI3MIDKHbIM, TO nocpe.I\CTBOM
npeJlQC'ItlBJIeIDUI I1M nooqepe,nHoro BJIa.I\eHI1.f! COOTBeTCTBellHO pB3Me-
py J1X .I\OJleii: yqacTHH. B c.nyqae HecorJ!aCI1R HelWTopb!X yqBCTIIJIKOB
Ha TaKoe cnpaEI8.IVll1BO pacrrpe.I\eneHl1e... 11 CTpeMJIE'HJ1RI1X 3aXBaTJ1Tb
60JIb11I)'1O.I\0JII0 B HeM, TaRl1e ;neiicTmrn J1X .I\OJIiKHb! 6bITb IIpII3HaBB-
eMb! CY.I\OM yme 3a .I\eii:CTBI1.f!, Hap)'lIIalOIl\J1e npaBa .D;pyrnx COyqBCT-
IDIKOB, KOTOJ:He;nJlH:;rroro y nOCJIeWIl1X 11 ;nOJDKHbI CJI)'iKI1Tb OCHOBa-
lilleM K np8,l\"bHBJl8Hlfi 'I'p8fiosaIDul 06 yCTpaHeHI1J1 TaKIDf: ;neiicTBl1ti,
B BYI):lBX BOCCTaHOBJI8IDUI J1X npaB lIB 06Il\ee JfM.YIl.\8CTBO. He)'Ka.3aIDIe
B B"JI;aX pa3perneIDIR IIo.I\06I1b!X CIIOpoB B GaMOM3aKOHe npe;nCTaBJIR-
eTCR J\OBOJIbHO cYIlIeCTBeHllbIM npo6eJIOM B HeM...» 3.
'MeiiepAIII_P;oo<oel'p!l.>l\Q!lHClrl,[MlJJfIQI1p&A.A.III_E\oo.jot><a.1'QD,.8..cnp.",QJn_cn_190.2_C_264
, 6ap,o,cKl1A, ea-""""ecosna.<le1l_.HarpJ.llIDKy.ll.OJlM"o6u!e" ........JlBecTHM.npa03"'HOT3P.
ara.191C,NI5.C,175-177.
JAIIH"""""KC"CTeMaPYCCKOrOf])6><.l1<lHco<oronpaoa,T2_llpaBalleU\HbIS Cr1I$, 19OO.C.90

IIte npaBa 06ll.\efi Co6cTBeHHOCTJ.1 HaCT}'TIaJIO B c.nyqae
BbU\eJIa ,D;OJlV! J1 pa3,!\e.na OOll.\ero J. Pa3,!\eJI J1 BbU\eJI 6blJIJ.f
B03MmKHbi npJ.1 YCJIOBJ.1J1 JJ,e.IBIMOC'I1I J1M}'ll.\eCTBa. Pa3,!\eJI MOr 6blTb
,!\06poBOJIbHbIM J1 npI:lHY,D;m'eJlbHbIM. «IIepBbrn: COBepllIBJICF! nyTeM
pa3,!\eJlbHoro aKTa no npaBJ<L.IlaM HCYI'apJ.1aJ1bHoro IIO.1IIDK8HHH. BTopot1
npDJl3BO,lUfJICH no npocboe O,!\Horo J<L.IlJ.1 HeCKOJIbKI:IX yqaCTID1KOB B no-
pJI,QKe cY,l\e6HO-MemeBoro pa3011paTeJIbCTBa» '.
AHaJll13 ,!\op 3aKOHo,!\aTeJIbCTBa, perYJlJllpyIOll.\e-
ro J.1HCTJ.fTyr ci cofJcTBeJrnocTtl, n03BO.mreT rooopl'ITb 0 TOM, 'ITO
KpyIIHblMJ.1 BeXaMH B pa3BJ1TJfi4 rpam,IlaHCKOI'O npaBa B l.\eJIOM J.1 liH-
CThlTYTa 06lI{8ii C06cmeHHOC'TII B 'IaCTHOCTJ.1 .mmJlJ'!Cb Co6opHoe YJIO-
.meID1e 1649 r., CBO,!\ 3aKOHOB PoccmlCKcii J1MJlep11J.11826 r. HaI16oJIb-
rnei1 BeplillfHbI pa3BlITI1.fI JlBHHhrl1: J1HCTwryT ,lJ;OCTHI' B XIX B. O,!\HaKO,
3aKOHo,qaTeJIb He OblJI nOCJl8,l\OBBTeJIeH, OTHOCH K 06ll.\ei1 COOCTBeHHO-
CThI npaBOBble HBJleH11fl, elO He 1IBJl.ffiCII\lrecJI, HBnp11Mep, aKL\I:IOHep-
Hble 06ll.\E'CTBa J1JI}1 'Iepecno.nocHOe BJIa,!\eH11e. HeKOTopble BOnpOCb!
OCTaBamlCb 3a paMKaMH npaBoro perymtpOBaHWi, TaKwe KaK Mexa-
HW3M pe8.JIJ.l3Bl.\Kl: npaBa np8JIMyIl.\E'CIHHOi1 nOKyrnat, oCYllIecTBJIe-
Hwe I1p!BOMO'II1Si m COCo6cTBeHHl1KaMH. KpoMe TOro, 3aKOHQ-
,!\aTeJIb BOCIIpHHHll p11MCK)'lO IlH)UlBlf.llYaJIJtc'lWIecK)'IO KOHLjelIW1fO
OOll.\eHCOOCTBeHHOCTI:I, 'ITO HeMiIIHYeMo nopom,IlaJlo TPYAHOCThI C I1pw-
HflThleM pellleHIfR Ii 3clJcjJeKTUBHbIM ynpaBJIeHM.€M Bell.\bfO. KaK onpe-
,!\eJleHHbrn: MeXaHM3M crJlffiKl1B3HWJ: HeraTI:IBHblX nCCJl8J\CTIWnI np11H-
LtJ1na 8)1mmr.nac11H OblJI 3a HHCTJrryr OTBeTCTBeHHOC'lU
cocoOCTBeHH11Ka, no Billie KOTOpOro OblJlO npl1HH'TO HeBepRJe perne-
Hwe J1JIJ.f, TO'lHee CKa3aTb, He npl1HRTO BepHoe. BMeCTe C TeM HeJIb3H
He npJ13HaTb, 'ITO MHorne HOpMbI J1MeJU:! nporpea'I(8H)8 CO;l:\ep.?KaID1e
t1 MOrJll:l ObI 6blTb SatlMCTBOBaHbI COBpeMeHHbIM saKOHo,!\aTeJlbCTBOM.
K TaKt1M, Ha Harn B3rJlR)J" OTHOCHTCH HOpMbI, saKpelIJlflKJLU;I1e OTBeT-
CTBellliOCTb co6cTBeImHKa B Bl1):le B03Mell.\eIDIH yDbrrKOB 3a I1J:XfHHl'J18
HeBepHoro pernem1fl B ynpaBJI8HIDI 06IllJ1M tlMylll8C'I'BOM. a TaIOKe
HOpMbl 0 CTpaXOBaHt111 OOll.\et1 Bell.\l1.
2.2. nPABO 06lJ1E AOJlEBO C06CTBEHHOCT
B COBETCKO POCC
IIepBbIM COBeTCKJIM KOBaHHbIM aKTOM, peryJII1pYK>
GrnOlll8HlUl oOll.\ei1 J],OJI8B(it: COOC'!'BeHHOCThI, OblJI fpam,!:\aHcrom KO-
'E.B.Y\4e6tKrpa>KJ\aHC<OrOnpae;l_e_102
18

,neKC PoccwfCKOii CoB8TCROJl 4>e,nepaTltBHOA Cota.mICTIt'l8Cl«:ti Pe-
CnyDJIrnu1 1922 r.' (,IJ;aJIee - fR 1922 r.). ,lJ;aHHbrM JJ,oK)'Mem co,nepiKaJI
HeCKOJIbKOCTaTeH:, nOCBffiIteHHb!X 06ll.\e ro6cTBeHHOCTJf, HO, no cYrJ1,
Bce 0Im. 6b1Ju:I nOCBHlQ€Hl:l 061l.1eif.Jl(}.lI8BOii co6cmeHHOCTJ.:!.
fK 1922 r. BIIepBl>l8 3BKpeID1JI onpeJ:ll2Jlemte 06ll.\e co5cTBeHHc:x.-rn.
CornaCHO CT. 61 npaBo COOCTBeHHOCTM MO*8T npUHa,l1Jle)KaTb ,nBYM
J.:IJIJ.:I HecKOJIbIalM JillQaM coo6ll.1a, no ,noJUlM(06R co6cTBeJrnoc-n,)2.
06 nprnu.\lilloM o npaBoMo'lJrif BJIa.D;eHl1H,
I1OJIb3OBBHI1fI11 pacnopIDKf'Hi'fJl RBJUleTCR I1pJm 60JIb1lll1HCTBa ro-
nOCOB, KOTOpblif npI1MeHRJICR, eCJIM Y'JCI-CTHIIKJI He CMornM IIpJDITtI
K e.I\MHOrnaCHOMY MHeIDflO. ITpe,IJ;CTaBJIReTCR J1lITepecHbIM Tar 4JaKT,
"TO, ;nonycKaR peilleIDIe EOIIpOCOB, KaCaKJIWIXCR 06ll.\e c06CTBeHHO-
CTM, 6oJn,1ID1HCTBOM, onpe.A€JIHJIOCb::lTO 6o.nbun1HCTBO He no pa3Mepy
,QOJIeif, a no 'iJ1Cny rOJlOCOB. XarR HHOCTpBIIHbI8 HOpMaTHBHble npaBo-
Bble aKTbI, Hallpt:IMep fepMaHCKOe rpaHcKoe ynr:mremre ( 745),
IIIBeill.\apcKoe rpaiK.!\aHcKoe ynO*8HJ.:1e (CT. 647), onpe;neJlHJJJI6oJn,-
111I1HCTBono pa3Mepy ;nOJlJ'!.Ho;nJUlPOCC>H:lTOroBpE'MeHMIlpHMeHeIrne
"..I1CTO KaIIJITBJIJICTII'18CKOI'O IIpJ1HQlilla - Bepx 6epeT TOT, KTO 6oJn,-
llle36bIJlOHenpMeMJl8M0.
K <rn:cny 06maHHcxTeti coaJ6cTBeHHJOOJB OTHOCMOCb HeceIDIe
6peMeHI1 CO.I\epmam1fl11MYll.\eCTBa copa3M8pHO cBOeti .I\OJle 11 c06.mo-
,QeHl1e npaBa npellM)'Il.\ecTBeHHOti noK)'lllC'l npI4HaAJIema1l.\ero .u.pyrl4M
COC06CTBeHHI1KaM IIpI1OTqym.r:\eHI1I1 KeM-JIM1)o J13 HI1X CBoeti.I\OJill no-
CTopoHHeMY JII1QY, KpoMe CJI)"'aR npoarn .I\OJIM C ny6J111'llibIX TOp-
rOB. D,lJ;HaKO MeXaHI13M peaJI113al.\lni npE!l1M}'ll.l€C'TB8HHOI'O npaBa no-
KynK11, cpoM era C>Cyll.\eCTBJleHJ.1JI 11 IIOCJIeJlCI'Bl1Jl ero H8i1CIiOJiH€HM.H
ocralOTC.H 3a paMKaMM npaBOBOro perYJIJ1pOBaHI1H.
COrJIaCHO CT. 65 Ka:lR,!\brM  BlIpaBe "Ipe50BaTb Bbl.I\e-
JIa CBOe .I\OJill 113 o6ll.\ero J1MYILI8CTBa, IIOCIiOJIbKy 3'1'0 He IIpaTI1BO-
pe"lIT 3aKOHY J1JIM ,nOroBOpy. ECJII1 corJIal.U8HJ18 0 cnoco6e BbI,!\eJIa He
J1,OCTIffH,YTO, J4M}'ll.\eCTBO no perneHJ1JO Gym ;neJIJITC.H B HBType, eCJII1
3TO B03MO:1KH0 6e3 Hecopa3MepHoro YIl.Iep6a era HHOMJ HB-
3HB"€HMKJ; B npm1'ffiHOM c.rryqae BldJI8JUIeMbIi.i co6cTBeHHJ1K nOJIyqaeT
;neHeiKH)'IDKOMlIeHcaQI1lO
fpa:lR,!\aHCKID1 KO,IJ;eKC 1922 r. €1l.\e He nO,D;pa3,!:(eJIReT 05JlG'lO c05-
CTBeHHOCTb lIB ;nOJIesyKJ 11 COBMecTH)'1O, O.I\BaKO .I\OKTpl1HaJIbHO TaKoe
'CYPC<I>CP1922_N'71 CT904
'0.._ )(pecroMa'ntAnoMC1PJ)l4<OTe'+eC'IBeHHOrOrocyAal)ClBa"'npaaa,1917-19911'T/fIC\!Ipe,o,.O.I1,'j
cmK003,M.3epu,ano.I997C.I20.
J 3I1""l16oaMB.06uIa>Ic06c18SHHOC"'CO.e-rCKOM.--pa>K,o,aHCKO"'npaoe '8crbnep""""BecntK
rpa>l(J¥ltIC.....Onpalla_-M. OOO1."""'B,EMa..,2009,T_R""4.C203
"

pa3)\eneHJ1e yme ocyIIJ'CTBJ1fIeTCfI. It OO"beKTaM COBMeCTHOil COO-
Cre€HHOCTI1 OTHOCBT OOWe8 J1MYl1IE'CTBO CyrrpyroB 11  KOJI-
X03H<IO ;nBOpa'. qro KacaeTCB KnaCIKalUrn: ;nOJleBoil c06creeH-
HOCTI1, TO OHa ewe llOCTaTO'lHO xaOTWIHa. TaK KaK He l1MeeT emrnoro
KpI1TepYJR.
IIocKOJIbKY B rK 1922 r. ObIJU1 onpe.r:\8JleHbl nl1lllb 06lIU1e noJIome-
HI1B 11 npl1Hlfi1bI ocywecTBJIeHI1JI coc<ficTBeHfIl1lW.Wj CBOI1X npaBoMo-
'lID1, MHorne «3BKOHO)¥lTeJIbHble npooeJIbI pernaJU1Cb BeJ:I(JMCTB8HHb-
MI1 HOpMaTl1BHbIMI1 aKTaMl1, a TaIOKe cy;ne6Hcxf npaKTI1Koi1»2.
B 1961 r.6blJU1 IIpJfHRTbIOCHOBbIIpam,IlaHcKoro3aKOHO)¥lTeJIbCTBa
C0103a CCP 11 C0103HbIX pecrry6mfK (,I\aJIee - OCHOBbI). no Borrpocy
perym1pOBBlllUl OTHa.neHlfif oowe:i1 c OHI1 CO;nepmaJU1
eW'lHCTBeHH)'lO craTblQ. CTaTbH 26 3BKperuUIJIa cy&beKTHbrn: COCTaB
IIpaBa oowe>i co6cTII€HHQCTJ:!, a TaKme BIIepBble neraJIbHO npOBO,I\M-
na;neJIeID1e oowei1 c06cTBeHHOCTJiI Ha ,l\OJIeBYlQ I1COBMeCTII)'lO. 06ll.\BH
co6creeHHOCTb C orrpe,I\eJIeHJiIeM ,l];oJIei1- ;;ITO ;nOJIeBaH co6creeHHoCTb,
6e3 onpe,I\eJIeID1H,I\oJleil- 00BMeCTHafI Co6creeHHOCTb.
3Ha"IJrre.JIblJHii: mar BIIepe,I\ B Bonpoce perYJIl1p013aHJiIR oowei1 ,1];0-
JIeBOH co6creeHHOCTJiI ObLJI CJleJIaH C npl1HJITJiIeM rp.9.)K.AaHCKoro KO-
,I\eKCa Pocmik:lroii CcBeTcKoA 4>e,I\epaTJ1BHoi1 CowmmlC'I'Jf'l8CKOii
PecnyfurnKl1 1964 r. (;na.nee - rK 1964 r.t HHbrn. KD..qI14JpoBaH-
Hbill: aKT cO,I\epmaJI rnaBY 12, IIOCBffiIteHHYKJ oOIl.lei1 coocTBeHHOCTl1,
HOCRIl.JY1O O,I\HOl1MeHHOe Ha3BaID1e. rnaBa COCTORJIa 113 19 cTaTei1, lle-
TaJIbHO peryJIJ1pyx)JjJ)1X ,I\OCTaro'lHO 60JIblll0i1 Kpyr BOnpOCOB, BKJIJO-
'JaR OT;I\€JIbHbR:' Bl1,I\bI npaBa OOIl.lei1 co6creeHHOCTJiI.
BCJIeJJ, 3a OCHOBaMJiI CT. 116 rK 1964 r. OIIpE',[(eJIR€'T Kpyr cy6"beK-
TOB,OOIXI1MeTbJ1MYl1\ecTBOHanpaBeoowet:i
c06cTBeHHocTJ1. «JiMyll..\ecrm MomeT IIpHHaJ:I.JIemBTb Ha npaBe oowei1
006crneHHOCI'JII ;nB)'M MJIJ1 HeCKOJIbKI1M KOJIXOOaM J1JIJ1 J1HbIM KOOnepa-
THBHbIM 11 ,I\pyrnM oOl1\8CTB€HHbIM opram1RM., J1J160 rocYllapcrey
11 O,I\HOMY I1JII1 HeCKOJIbKI1M KOJIX03aM I1JIM I1HbIM KOOnepaTJwln>IM
11 ;npyrnM06ll.\eCTBeHHbIMop J1J160AB)'M 11JU1 HeCKOJIbKMM
rpam,QaHaM».
'0... 3MMSIleaaM.B,05I118"H"O(;J""C08fITCKOMrp8>i<,<laHCKOMopa.e.'iiiCJO"epaao.C,215
2M!OCJ106B_!».BonpoCblo!jweii_H0CT\<6Cyjl6(;HOiinpam<oe M__rociOP'3,IIa.T, 1963_C.2"
'05yJseHMMOctto8fP'l>l'A'iHCKOIl)Cooo3aCCP"'COto:lHbIJ(pecny6"MK(eMeGT"
OceaMM 3aKOllCCCPOT08.12.19BllfH!\O,OMOCTllecCCCP.19B1.W50.
'rpaJl<,!1a<CIII<iiop,eKCPC<bCP'yrB,BCPC<!>CPII.06,19fj.«(YrparnJ1CI1l1\lCI...".,.,2OOBI"QI1iIB"""""
_M<t>!:o,epanblllJl1)_OH3.OTIB.12.2006W2314GJIf",ecPOtCP.1964.W24.
2<J

IIPI1HL\ffi1 8,lU1HOrnacHoro OC npaBoMo'lJrii: co6cTBeH-
HOCTI1 Halllen3aKpen.neHI1e B CT. 117 rK 1964 r. BCJI.Y'lae pa:mornaCI1H
nopH,noK BJIaJJ:eHlilH, nOJIh30BaHU.fl 11 paCnOpffiKeHI1H onpe,I\eJUleTCH no
JIICKY mo6oro J13 yqaC'i'lIJ1K(E. B03poeHI1e I1fMHlUmB e,I\J1HornaCI1H,
6bLJ10 60JIhlIDlM «,[I,IJ(.'TIO!(freM» COBeTcKoro 3aKOHOTeJIhCTBa.
EpeMH pacxo;:J;oB pacnpe,!\e.J1HJloCh nponoPQHOHaJIbHO pa3Mepy
,ll0JII1 B nprrna,nnemalIt JlM)'llIecTBe.
Cocc:6cmemmmI JllMeIDI cneJJ:YIOIIJ;J'Je npaaa:
- npaBo Ha OT'IyeHJ1e cBoef1:,llOnl1,llpyroM)'.ID1
-npaBonOKynKJ1.IIpl1npo,!\Bme,llom1Bo6ll.\ei1
co6cmeHHoc-m: nocTO}XJHHeMY JIJ1ItY OCTaJIhHble yqacrHJ1K1i o6ll.\ei1
,llOJIeBof1: co6cTBeJrnc:Jconl J1MeKYl' npeI npaBo OOKYT1lat
npo,!\aBaeMoi1,llOJIJ1 no LleHe, 3a lWTOPYIO OHa npO,!\B8TCH, JII Ha npo'll1X
paBHbIX ycJDBIDIX, KpOMe CJI)"IaH npO,!\BmJI C nyfuIl1'IHb!X ToprOB.
B OT.ID1'111e OT ,llpyrl1X HOpMaTl1BHo-nJ:W!OBblX alITOB, 3BKp8lLIlHB-
1lI11X JII paHee ,llaHHOe npaBO 3a cocx:6:-meHHI1KOM, BIIepBbie 6bJn ,lle-
TanbHO per.JIaMeH'I'U(XJB MeXaffiI3M ero ocyIQeCTB.YI8li IIpo,!\aBeLt
,ll0JII1 B o6ll.\ei1 C06CTBeHHOCTI1 06H3aH JI3B8CTII'Ib B nucbM8HRJt1 .popMe
OCTaJIbHbIX yqaCTHI1KoB o6ll.\ei1,llOJIeBoiii co6cTBeHHocTI1 a HaMepeHl1l1
npO,!\BTb CBOIO,llOJIlO nocroPOHHeMY JIJ1ItY C yKa3aHJteM LleHbl t:I .npymx
YCJIOBMii, Ha lWTOpb!X npO,!\BeT ee. Ec.nJ.f 0CTaJIbHbl8 yqac'l'Hl1KJ1 o6ll.\ei1
,QOJIeBoiii co6cTBeHHOCTJ.f OTKamyTCH OT ocyw;ecTBJleHJ.ffl npet:lM)'l..ll;e-
cTBeHHoro npaaa nOKyrIKI1J11ID1 He Ocyw;ecTBHT3TOro npaaa B Te'leIDIe
MeCflLta B OTllOWeHt:lI1 ,llOMa, a B OTHOWeHt:ll1 npo':lero JIIMYll.\eCTBa -
B Te'leHl1e ,ll;ecHTIl,llHei1cO,D;WIJf3B€l.q8ffiIfl, npOBel.\BIIpaBenpo,!\aTb
CBOlO,llOJilO J1lO60M)' JIJ1ItY.
IIpl1 npo,!\Bme ,ll;OJlJ'! C HapyweHI1eM npeHMHOro npaaa
nOKyrrKl1 yqacrHI1K .npyroi1 o6mei1,llOJIeBof1: C06CTBeHHOCTIf B Te':leHJ1e
Tpex MeCJll.\eB l1MeeT npaBO Tpe60BaTb B CY,lle6HOM nopfl,QKe nepeBO,!\a
Ha Hero npaB 11 06H3aHHocTeif nOKynaTenJi.
Cneq1upmoc>ii o6JIawwa npo,!\Bma,llOJiJ1 B]KI1JIOM,II;OMe. B :aTOM cny-
<me «npaBo npeJ:lM)'ll.\eCTBeHHOiii nOKyrIKI1 MOrJIO 6b1Tb ocyIQ8CTBJleHo.
€cnl1 :no He IIpOTImope<umo CT. 106 fK PCOCP, cornaCHO KOTopOi1
B JIJf'lHoi1 co6cmeHHoc-m: IpaaH, a TalOKE' y COBMeCTHO I1pQ.)KKBalO-
I..WfX CynpyroB J:l11X HeCOBepl1l8HHOJIeTl11{X ,ll;eTei1 MomeT HaXO,llMTbCH
TOJThKO O)J;MH >KIfJIOII ,ll;OM (J:lIDI "Iacrb O,IJ;lloro ,ll;OMB) np8J\€JIbHHii pa:3-
Mep KOToporo He ,ll;O.IDKeH npeBbIIIIBTb 60 KB. M. >trn.IIoi1 nrroll.\BlJ.I1. 0,11;-
HaKO npl1 HBJllNJ'II1 Y cOC06CTBeHID:!Ka 6o.rrbWOi1 ceMbl1I1J111 npaBa Ha
,IJ;OnOJlHl1T€JIbHYlO JKJ1JIYIO nrrOlQB,!\b, OH Mom8T OCyw;ecTBl1Tb npaBo
np€11Myru;ecTBeHHoi1 nOKyrIKI1 C pa3peWeHJ1R J1CnOJIKOMa 
21

(ropo,!\CKoro) COBSTa HapO)J.HbIX ,nenyraToB Ha npM06peTeHMe ,n0Jll1
,nOMa»';
- npaBo Ha Bbl,IJ;eJI cBoeR ,n0Jll1 H3 oOl1\ero KM}'ln8C'l'BB, npM aTOM,
eCJIMCOrJIaWeIDIe 0 cnocooe BbJ,JJ;e.na He,lJ;OC'I'Kl1lyl, TO no HCKY .mooo-
ro )"IaCTHMKa JfM}'I..lI;eCTBO ,neJll1TCJI B HaType. IIOCR:fJJIbKY aTO B03Mom-
HO 6e3 HeCOpa3MepHoro Yl1\ep6a ero X03JIHCTBeHHOMY HB3HaQeHmO;
B IIpoTMBHoMcJI.Y'laerlicHc06cTBeHHJ.iKnOJIY'lBeT ,neHem-
HyroKOMIIeHcaQJ.1lO.
KpoMe TOro, OWl IIpE',DyCMJTpeH nepeqeHb ()('fD3BIUrn. npeKpa-
IQaBIlII1X npaBO 06Il\eif ,nOJIeBOA cOOcmelnrocTII. CTBTbJI 123 npe..Qyc-
M[lTPMBaJIa, 'ITO npaBO 06Il\eif WJI630Ii co6cTBeIrnocTIl rocy.napCTBa 11
rpam,!IBH, KoonepaTJ1BHbIX J1JI11 .npynrx oOIl\eCTBeHHbIX opraffif3aA
11 rpam,!IBH nO)J)le1Kl1T npeKpaIl\eIDfIO B Te'leHl1e O,!J;Horo roM, I1C'IHC-
JIJIeMOro CO,ntrn E03HI1KHOBeffim oOIl\eiiCOOCTBeHHOCTl1, nyreM:
1) pa3,QeJIa I1MJI1-IeCTBa B HaType, eCJI11 aTOT pa3,neJI Ba3MJ:lK8H;
2) BbIKyna rocy.napCTBOM, KOOn8paTWBHoi1 I1J]J1.npyroA oomecmeH-
HoAopraID13aeA,nOJlei1,IIpI'1H<l.WIe>RaIQItX
3) npO,!\8.iKM rpam,!IBHaM ,n0Jll1, npirnB.lI.lIf'1K&qE'H rocy.napCTBy, KO-
OnepaTI1BHoi1J1JII1.npyroi1ol;
4) npo,!\a>KI1 Bcero J C ITOCJIe.l\YKIll paCnpe,lJ;eJIeID18M
BbI)JY'-IeHHoi1 GyMMbI Me»i,!\)' yqaCTHI1KaMI1 06Il\eii a:6cmeHHoc-rn co-
0TBeTC'I'B8HH0 I1X .nOJIflM.
Bbl.ID1 perJIaM8HTI1poBaHbI oCOOeHHOCTl1 oC}'I..lI;eCTBJIeID1H npaBa 00-
l1\efl ,noJleBoR COOCTBeHHOCT11 Ha OT,neJIbHble Bl1J1bl HMyru;eCTBa. TaK,
B IJBC'I'HOC'nI, CT. 124 perY.ID1poBaJIa occ:funDcTH nOJlb3OBaHMR )KMblM
,nOMOM I1HTepec BbI3bIBaeT npe.nycMOTpeHHoe B ,llaHHOi1 CTaTbe npa-
BKnO arHOCHTeJlbH) corJIarneIDIJl Me»i,!\)' )"IBCTHI1KaMJ1 oOlQeti ,nOJIe-
BoA co6cTBeHoocn1 Ha mHJIOA,nOM 0 nOpil,!\Ke nom.aooamm 060c06neH-
HblMHf,nOMa(KBapTIIp8.MH.KOMHaTaMlil)BCOO'I'B8TC'I'BJI
c ,nOJIJlMJiI )"IBC'iIJJ1KOB. B TOM cJI.Y'lae eCJII1,naHHoe COrJIaIlleHI1€ ObIJlO
HOTapl1aJIbHO y,noCToBepeHo 11 3ap8I11CTpHpOBBHO B IICDJJIIDIT8JIbHOM
KOMJITSTe MeCTHoro COBSTa HapO)J.HbIX ,nenyTaTOB, OHO 06J13aTeJIbHO
11 ,lI,JIJI JIJIIrta. KarDpoe BIIOCJIe,QCTBMIl IIpI10fpeTaeT ,noma B oOmeA co6-
cmemrOCTl1 Ha 3TOT ,nOM.
B rK6oJn,llIilllCTBa COI03HbD: pecnyD.mnt CO,nepmaJlOCb }'Ka3aHl1e Ha
TO, 'ITO oOH3aTeJlbH)'lO CJ1JIY JfMeeT TOJIbKa TaKae COrJIaWeHl1e, B KOTO-
pOM nopMOK nOJIb30BaHl1Jl IiOMeLq8mfJlllolJf onpe,lJ;eJIeH B COQTB8TCTBJrn
C pa3MepaMl1,nOJIeA )"IacTID1KOO. TaKJ1M 06pB30M, pa3Mep ,nOJIeACTaJI
. M..:JrOOrpoMr.<yUjecT1l6HHOOKjOlKl1IfCo\ularlMCT>t'<ecK3"saKO"'ocn., ItA. l13.ec""",..
22

BJUlfITb Ha ocymecTB1I:'HJ1e npaBOMO'illi1:  CnpaBeMI1-
Ba$i OQeHKa SHa'1eIDIJ'l HOpMhl, 38.KpenJ!2HIIDJI BeT. 124 rK PCCPCP
1964 r. 6hLJJa ]:IaHa P.II. MaHaIlKOEOii, KOTOpali OTMe'-laJla, '1TO «Ha nep-
Bhrn: B3r.m>,1J; MomeT nOKa3BThCJ'I, 'ITO YKaSaHHaJ'l BhnIIe HOpMa "MeeT
l.\eJlhlO Jll:IIlIh OOeC!le<1eHl1e "HTepecOB npaBOnpeeMHl1KOB J1 n03TO-
MY coco6cTBeIunIKH Henocpe,ncTBeHHO He samrrepecoBBHbl B oco6oM
expopM.n€IDllt,l\OCTIfI"lIYTOi'O cornarnemlfl 0 nop$i,IJ.Ke I101Ib3OBaHJ1fI 06-
IlU1M ,[IOMOM. B .I\eiic'IE1'reJIl:HOCTI1 ,[Ieno OOC'f()I1T J.fHa'le. Oq:mpM.neHl1e
corJIallI8llJffI 0 nop$i,IJ.Ke nOJlh30BaHI1$i 060c06.neHHhlMl1 n0ME'1IJ;8HJ.IR-
MI1 B OOll.\eM :HUIJ10M ,[IOMe rapaHTl1py8T yC'l'OiitnfBOCTh Kj:f
CJK»KIfBIllI1'OCH oTHOrneHl1if, HeCMOTp$i Ha Hel130e:IKHhle I13MeHeHI1$i
B CyD"beKTHOM COCTaBe. 3aKpeILJJemie peaJlhHoif .I\OJll1 sa Ka*JlhlM 1:13
}"-IaCTHI1KOB CTI1M)'J1I1PYeT J1X Havr60nee 3aIDIT8pecoOOHO ".I\06poco-
BeCTHO Ocy:u..J;ecTBJIflTh CBOI1 OOJ'l3BHHOCTI1 no coxpaHeHmO " X03J'1if-
CTBeHHOM)' C0.I\8pmaIDDO OTBe)J;elllihlX eM)' I1OM8ll18mm»'. ,IJ,yMaeTC$i,
'1'f() )J;JIJ'I.I\OCTIDKeHIDI ,[(BHHhIX l.\eJleif 3BKpE'ILJJeHl1e HOPMh! CT. 124 rK
PCOCP 1964 r. B cOBp8MeHHoM 38.KOHO,!\BTeJlhCTBeOhLJ!06b1 O"leHb no-
ne3HbIM.
KpoMe ooll.\eif .I\oJ!eBoif co6cTBemIx.-n1, KaK yme 6hLJJO OTMe'-leHO
BhnIIe, perYJ1I1PoBaHl1IO no;vremaJla OOIl.\BH COBMeCTHaJ'l c06crneH-
HOCTh, K KOTOpoif B COOTBeTCTBJDI C rK 1964 r. OTHOCHJ!aCh Co6cTBeH-
HOCTh 'lJIeHOB KOJIX03HOro,IJ;BOpa" COOCTB€HHOCTh 3B11JIMalOIl.\J1XCH JfH-
JJ:11B11J1J18J1hHoU "IpyWBOii )J;e.meJIbHOCThIO B cenhCKOM X03HHcrne.
BIDCCCOBeTCKJ.fifnepl1o)J;BpeMflHa TeppI1TO-
pI1l1PCP,[lei1-rnoBamICkHOBblIpa.iK,lJ.BHCKoro1991r.2.
KOTQpble co,!\epmaJIl1 e)J;l1HCTBeHHyKI CTaTbiO, perYJHtpy}()IIJYJO oolIlJ'lO
cc6cTBeHHOCTh, BeCbMa clJparMemapHo.
IIO)J;BO)\H JITor JJ;BHHOM)' napaIpaclJy HaCTOHll\eii pa60ThI, XOTe.OOCb
6h! OTMeTlITh, 'lTO J:lMeHHO B COB€TCKIDI nepl10JJ; 6hlJll1 
clJ)'H,D;aMemaJlhHble le pa3pa6crrK11 I1HCTI1T)'Ta oOll\ei1
cooCTBeHHOCTl1, KOTOpble BO MHOfOM "11.0 CI1X nop He TepHIQT cBOei1 a.K-
ryaJIhHOCU1113Ha'll1MOCTI1. B 3TOT me nepl10)\ MOiKHO OTMeTIITb 11 onpe-
,QeJIeHHhII1 perpecc B npaBOBOM pEf'YJIi1POBBHJ1j.{, KO'lUpbli1 CBH3aH C
pe8HI1M>1pOBaHJteM np.l1HW1ITa e)J;l1HOrJIaCI1JI. Eo TE'M He MeHee MHOl'.l1e
HOpMhI BOOJ1He COBpeME'HHh111 npe11.CTaBJIJ'liOT 6e3)'CJ!OBHlill1l1HTepeC,
H8IIp1fME'p HOpMbI, 3aKpenJleHHh!e B CT. 124 rK PCOCP 1964 r. a He-
06xowmOC"IH saK.ln(l'-IeHl1.R HOTap.l13.JIhHO saBepeHHoro 11 nporne)J;!llero
''''_KOBapn_oI5uJeAOJIco/5cTIIeHfIOCTI'rpa>lWlHnoCO"eTCKOMY'1JEDI'A!IH
CKOMy:JaKOHQlIaTeJlbGToy.ToM""..l'iall'BOT'-:KOIU\IH'Tal977.C23
'OcHO"...--pa:.tWIHCKO r O:JaKOHO,IiaTe"bClW.O:ioo3aCCPMpecCl\'6JlMK(\'T8.BCCCCP3105.1991W
22111jlcI<3Id_0T03_03_1993J/lBwIoMocn<eH)1MBCCCCP26.061991 N!'26.Cr733
23

rOCYpcTBeHHYIO pEnf1O COrnallleHHR Me*.1\Y coco6cTBemm.-
Kar.rn 0 nOpH,[\Ke I1O.JIb3(IBaHJf 06oc06JIeHHbIMYI nOMell(8HHRMYI JlOMa,
KOTOpOe 6YJleT pacnpoCTpaHRTbCR B cJI.Y'lae OT'Iym,neHI1H ;n0.nt1 Ha
HOBore coco6cTBeHID1Ka.l(yMaeTCR, llBHHoe npaBt1JIO MOm€'!' 6blTb no-
ne3HbIMM cero)\HR.
2.3. nOHs:lTa.1E L-1 CO)J,EP)f(AHL-1E 06Ll1,EVI C06CTBEHHOCTa.1
no rpA>K,lJ,AHCKOMY 3AKOHO,lJ,ATEIlbCTBY
POCCf1CKOf1 <I>E,l1EPALI
IIepYlo)\ C Koa BO-x YI JlO Koa 90-x rr. npom.noro CTO.n€'!'11H Ha
3bIBa€TCH B JUfTepaType nepJ10)\OM "pecTaBpaql1J1 KaIDITa.JiH3Ma» .
B pa3BHTJfI'1 npaBa MOJoKHO BbJ)\eJUfTb .ABa STana, CBH3aHHbie C 113Me-
HeHltHMU, IIpOlfCXO)\JlBllmMU B o5ll(ecTBe. IIepBbrl1 STan - cepe,l\J1Ha
80-x - Haqa.no 90-x IT - xapaKT€p1il30BaJlCH nOCTeneHHblMMl1eMOKpa-
TJI'-l8CrofMH H3M8HeHHHMK, nOnbrrKar.rn .IBI6epa.Jm:3oBTb COLtlilaJll1CTi1-
qecK}'IO npaBOB}'JO CI1C'I"€MY, BTOpo - C Haqa.na 90-x n. - KOpeHHblMi1
t13M8H8HJIHMR B npaBoBo CIiICTeMe, HBJIBllIJofMUCR c..ne;ncTBUeM nepe-
XO ar  K KaID1TaJlt13MY. OT l1JIaH(E()Jl K pHHO'IHOH 3KO-
HOMlilKe.
B pa3mrmu rpam,naHCKoro IIpaBa TaKJoKe Bbl)\eJl.llIOT J\BB STana.
IIepBbI - C Cepe,!J;I1Hb! 80-x 110 Haqa.na 90-x n. - xapaKT8J:1f3OBBJICH
nocreneHHblM JIOnymeHlfeM pblHO'lHbIX OTHOllleIDI.
B 3TOT nept1o,!:( pa3BlfTlilH rpam,naHCKoro 3BKOHo):\aTeJ!bCTBa IIpi1-
Hl1MBeTCR 3aKOH «0 c06crneHHOCTIiI B CCCP", KOTOpbli1 YCTamlBJII.f-
BaeT, 'ITO B CCCP MOiKeT cJll.\eCTBOBaTb co6cTneJrnocTb COBeTCKIiIX
rpam,!\BH, KOJIJIeKTI1BHaH 11 rocy,l\apCTBeHHaH, co6cTBeJrnOCIb 111I0-
c-rpaHHbIX roCYMPCTB. MeiKJlYHaP0):\HbIX opro.llH3aqi1ii, JIHOC"IpaHIillX
ropl1,QI1"IeCKIiIX JIJ1l.1; t1 rpam,naH, ,I\OII}'CI\aJI0Cb 06"be,!J;I1HeHlile 11M)'ll.\e-
CTBa, HaXO,l\Hll(erOCH B c05CTBeHHOCTII rpam,naH, ropt1)\J11.{eCKIiIX JIIiIIJ;
J1 rocyMpcTBa, H06pa30BaHYIe HB3TOi10CHOBe cMeIIffiHHbIXopMC06-
crneHHOCTIiI
BTopoi13Tan B pa3m1TJDf rpam,naHCKoro npaBa, no Bcei1 BI1,Q!iIMO-
CTIiI, MO:>KHO CBJ'l3BTb C npl1HJITl1eM 24 ;nexa6pJ'l 1990 r. 11 BBe,neHH8M B
Jl8I1CTBJ18 C 1 .RHBapJ'I 1991 r. 3aKOHa «0 o:6c-memror:rn B PCOCP,,2.
Poccm1C1OO1 3aKOH H3.PJ'I..Qy C roCYMpM1!€HHoM, M)'HIlqlmaJIbHOi1.,
'liIc:ToP"'OTe'>eCT_"ororOC1AapcTBII",npaaa:H"rAKYfbM.F'C_,[E.HoB
.I!P,;IIOI1P<\!1,O.III. '1M=Kooa.3'el1'11\.,epepalj.".I\on.M :IICTh,2002.C 247
20co6croeHHOC1"PC<%ICP'3a""HPC<:K:Par24,121990NJ443'11P"Aar24.00,I9Q2.c_.ar
01 071994JllBe.<\o...:.;mCf-\llPC<%ICP"'BCPC<%ICP199O_NJ30_CT_416
24

co6cTBeHHOCTblO06ofu,e;nJIH8HJ1i1 (opram) BOCCTa-
HOBM 'IaCTH}'IO COOCTBellliOCTb. OJ:nJOBpeMeHHO 6wI npe.!I,YCMOTpeH 38-
npeT }J,JIJI rOCY,JIapCTBa yc-raHaRIDfBaTh B KaKOA 6bI TO HM 6bL11o q,opMe
crpaHWHRI1H J1Jrn npeJ.1MYI11eCTBa B  npaBa cOOCTBeH-
HOCTJII B 38BJ1CJ1MOCTII OT HaxIDK,!\eHJIIJ'll1M)'Lll;eCTBa B 'lBC1'Hoif JfJIJ1 .lIPY-
I'JIIX 4JopMaX co6cTBeHHocTJ.L BnfpBbI' nOCJIe  peBOJIK}-
l\JIIJII1917 r. B Co6cTBeHHOCTJII rpam,llaH MOrJIJII HaXO)UfI'bCJ'l3eMeJIbHble
yqac'IIDf. KBapTbI CTaIDI Om.eKTOM npaBa Co6cTBeHHOCTJII HeCKOJIbKO
paHee - no 38KOH)'COI03a BO'I'JIJIIIU1e OTnpeiKHera3a
He ma.mlCb 'IJIICJlO J1 CTOI1MOCTb lllI)ro J1M}'ll1;ecTBa.
BBO.rr;/'LJ1aCb npJll06peTaTeJJbHaJI ,JIaBHOCTh - .JI06pocreecnro J1 umpbl-
TOe BJIa,l:I8HJII8 He,nBJrnotMbIM I He MeHee 15 .!leT I1JU1,J1BJII-
mMMbIM He MeHee 5 .!leT - KaK OCHOBaIDle B03ID1KHOBEHH.II npaBa co6-
CTBeHHOCTIL 3aKOHnpel1:YCMaTpJllBaJI 38ilV'ITY J1HTE'}:>eCOB c06CTBeHHyma
B CJI.Y'Iae npJllHRTllil rocy,J\Bpc1'BOM 3aKOHO,JIaTeJIbHblX aKTOB, npeKpa-
Il{aIO npaBO co6CTBemrocnr. nyreM B03M8Il{eHJIIJ'l B nOJlliOM ofu.eMe
npwnmeHHblX yDblTKOB. IIpeKpaIIt€I1H8 npaBa Co6cTBeHHOCTJII B CB.R311
C p811IeHJlleM rocY,J\Bpc'I'B8IIl£ro opraHa, HanpaBJIeHHbIM Ha J13"bJIT11e
J1M}'ll1;8CTBa Y Co6CTBeHHI1Ka,  JrnIlIb B cJI)"laJlX, YCTaHOB-
.!IeHHblX 38KOHOM, C npe.AOCTaBJIeJnleM paEHOQ8IIlKIO J1M}'ll1;8CTBa JfJIJ1
B03MeIl{8IIJleM yDblTKOB. IIpl1 HeCOrJIaCID'J co6cTBemnma c peIlEIDIeM.
BJIeK)'IllMM npeKpauJ;eHJlle era npasa co6cTBeHHCCTIf, OHO He Mor.!l06bITb
0CYI1\eCTBJIeHO,JIO pa3perneHJII.II cnopa CY,JIOM. TaKI.fM 06pa30M, 3aKOH
o ccf:crneHHOC11f B PCOCP .HBJUleTCH TeM  pyDemoM,
C KOToporo HB'lBJICR npou;ecc nepexOM K  ::IKOHOMJIIKe. Oc-
HGBRble  HmeJJeHRH, BHeCeHHbIe ,J\BHHbIM 3alWHOM,
6bIJIJ1 arpameRbI B TeKCTe KoHC1'I.fTyu;ID'! POCCJI/H.
Ornocwre.m.Ho o5I1\ei1 C06CTBeHHOCTJ.1 n. 2 CT. 3 3aKoHa a c06cTBeH-
Hocm npe.!I,YCMaTpl1BaJIaCb BIJ3MOmHtX."ID npI.fHa,Q.JI€arnOCTJ.1 JfM)'I1\e-
CTBa O;UIOBpeMeHHO fII2O«)JIbl\J1M JIJ.1IJ;aM Ha npaBe o5I1\ei1 C05CTBeH-
HOCThI. }J;aHRbrn: B>f,I\ C05CTBeHHOCTYI HB3bIBBJIC-R TalOKe KOJIJI8KTI1BHOi1
c05cTBeHHocTbIO, 'ITO, KOHe"lHO me, no CYTM, HBJIfleTCH HeBepHbIM.
B 0CTaJIbH0M perYJIJ.1pOBaHJ.1e o5I1\ei1 afic'meIrHoc'rn ::ITI1M 38KOHOM He
OTJIJ1<IaJIOCb OT peryJIJ.1pOBaffi1fl, 3aKpeIIJIeHHoro B rK 1964 r
HeCMOTpH Ha TO 'ITO 3aKOHbl 0 C05CTBellliOCm J1 npe,IUIpIIIUfMa-
TeJIbCKoti ,JIemeJIbHOCTJ.1 flBJIflJIJ.1Cb pa.r:\!1K8.JIbHblMJ.1, T8M He MeHee He-
OOXOJl)IMO 6bL11o KCMIIJIeKCHoe, CJ.1CTeMHoe 06HOBJIeHJ.1e IpIDK.I1fiHCKOro
3aKOHO,J\BTeJIbCTBa,05ycJI:EJIeHHOE' nurpe6lJfJCTHMI1 nepexo K PbIH-
KY, KOTopoe BIIepBbIe 6b1JIO npe.r:\rrpJ.1HHTO B OCHOBax IpIDK.I1fiHCKOrO
3aKOHO,J\BTeJIbCTBa CoI03a CCPJ1 pecIIyfurnKar 31 MaR 1991 r. OcHOBbi
CTaJIJ.1 npI1MeHRTbCR lIB TeppJ.1TopJ.1l1 POCCJ.1J.1 C 3 aBrycTa 1992 r., 1IpJ.1-
25

'IeM TOJIbKO B TOi1: QaCTI1, KOTOpaR He IIpOTHBOpe'illJIa KOHCTI1TY'--11111
-'" 3aKOHOJlaTeJIbHbIM liKTaM POCCI1I1I1  yKa3aM, npl1-
HRTbIMIIOCJIe 121110HR 1990r.
CTaTbR 46 OcHOB 6wla 1I0CBRll..IeHa OTHOWeID1RM 06llteH c06CTBeH-
HOCTi1, Hal1MeHOBaID1e KOJlJleKTI1BHaR co6crBeHHoc:Tb fum.we He yno-
MI1HaJIOCb,HOpmaHlECTaTbI16b1J10I1JleH'lWlliblMCT 33aKOHaoc06-
CTB8HHOCTJ1
KcepeJll1He90-xIT.CJIO)KI1JIBCbCI1CT8Marpam,11aH-
CKOro3aKOHO,QaTeJlbCTBa: co6cTBemlOpOccKiicrore3aKOHblJ1npe;>J
CKl1eYKB3b1, 'laCTOII}XYI11Bope'lal1tl1e.upyr .JIpyry, OcHOBhl
3aKOHO,QaTeJlbCTBa CCCP 1991 r., re B}'KB3aHHbIX npe,n;e-
Jlax, fR PCqJC.p 1964 r., I1pO,!J;OJDKaBIllI1H ,!J;eHCTBOBaTb B 'lacrHX, He npo-
Tl1BOpe 3aKOHaM 11 }'KB3BM, CO,!I;HOi1 CTOpolIbl, J1OcHOBaM - C .upy-
rei-!, Ii TaIOK8 181IQl1,3B1OCHl1l aKTbL TaKOe c{)('T()5!HJlle
rpa.iK,!\BHCKOIU 3aKOHO,!J;aTeJIbCTBB OCJIIDKHI1JIO l13anyraJlO npaoonpl1Me-
HJ.ITeJlbHJ1O,I\8H'I'8JIbIIO CTaJIO TOpM030M lIB nym 1X npe-
cfpa3c::eaIDm:J1-rpe60BaJlOC03,!J;aHl1Re,D;l1HOIUKQ/J;m!mI.(l1pCE<lHHOl'OaKTa.
I1Mcra.rrH(lJt,n1:KO)J;eKcPc:x::cJ1J)J;
OcHOIlHl;lMlI HanpaBJIeIDIHMJ.{ fR pq, 6b1Jll1: Bo-nepBbIX, nOCJIe-
,l\OBaTeJIbHOe B03po:1R,!\eHl1e 'IaCTHOnpaBOBbIX HB'IaJI B rpcrnv:\aHcKo-
npaBoBoM perYJlI<IJ:>OBaHI1I1, BO-BTOPbIX, OTKa3 OT nOJII1TI1'ieCKI1X
11 <lI«JHfJMJJlelOlBpawrl1,1XnyTaHI1QYBnpaBOB}'lOpe-
rJffiMeHTaQillO, B-"Ip8TI>I1X. BCeMepHaH oxpaHa HM)'lQeCTBeHHbIX J1H-
TepecoB yqaCTHI1KOB rpcrnv:\aHcKoro 06opoTa, B-'l8TB8JYI'bIX.. pellleHl1e
ocrpoi1 11 MHoroJI8THei1 npo6JIeMbi OT8'lecrneHHQrO npaBOB8J18HJrn,
KacaKJlQei1CR paapaOOTKI1 oco60ro npe,l\npl1HMMBTeJIbCKoro (X03Hi1-
CTBeHHOrO, TOproBOroJ1ID1 KOMMepqecKOro) Ko.neKca'.
HOBbD1 BI1TOK pa3BJ'ITlU! npaBa 06I.l18H co6cTBeHHOCTI1 6wI 3aJIGmeH
erqe I\o1rnrryIJ;llEJl pq, 1993 r. 2 CorJIaCHO CT 35 KoHC'l'Kl}'lJW1 pq, Kam-
,lJ;bD1 BnpaBe l1MeTbJ1M.Yl1\ecTBO B co6c:rneHHOCTl1, BJIa,IJ;eTb, 1I000030BaTbCR
11 pacnOpmKaTbCH 11M l\BKe,ro:rnoJIJl'IHJ, TaR 11 COBM8CTHO C Jll:I-
qal\oll1.JI.aHHoenOJlomeHl1eKoHCTI1T)'QID'IB03MomHOCTh
U!O,!I;HOi1 Bel1tl1Bcofx.TBeHoocm:.nayx 116o.rree JII1Q.
froBa 16 fK pcp3 nOCBRll..IeHa o5l.l1ei1 006cTBeHHOC'DL B l.\eJIOM 3HB-
'ieHl1e «3I\OHC1MJo1'1€CKCJi.i KOHCTIITyrv.1I1 C1paHbl», fK pq, 1994 T., CJIOiK-
'CM. I'iCTopI1"OTe'IeCTB",,,,ororOOY/Jilpcrna,,,npaaa:y-II!IjH"",I:A. Kyn,ltHa,PC, M;-""""",",T.E,Ho
611111<3""'_ Q,IJ,(JSAO.11 KOoa 3.e_,nepepa6.",n M 1Op!<cr-..2002 '4_2_C_12B
2(C)"'STCIIdnonpaBO"__3B'OHB.."P<I>ononpaB"ax"!<oHCT"l)'lII'"P<I>oT30122008
Ni6-CJ)l(3.OT30.12.2008N07.11>K3Jtf C3 P4>,2009.Ni4,Cr445
3rpa>l(.<iilllCl<I1;:;QD,BKCPoccI1;:;""oi1LJ,I1MI""",,,neps8B);C3OT30,111994Ni51-11>3(pe,Ij.OT
06.04.2011ItfC3P<J> 1994_N'32_Cr_3301
26

HO nepeoneHuTb Eo KaCaTenbHO J1HCTwryra 06Il1eR cOOc'l'BeHHoc'm
IDIKaIDIX HOBeJ1J1 If cYIlIeCTBeHHbIX nooU'I'KBHHX Jf3M8HeIDnI OH He
npHHec. OR 6epemBo COxpaHJ1JI Bee H8)10CTaTKJ1 npaBoBOro peryJIJfpo-
BaIDIR., Ha6.rno.D.aBurn€Cfl B npomnOM, J1IIDpQlt1IJI HOBbie.
CTaTbR. 244 fK P<l:I 3aKpelIJl.lleT ,D;Ba Bl1,I:\a 06Il1eiii co6crneHHOCTJf:
,nOJleB}'IO co6c:TBeHHOCTb - c cnpe,ne.neHUeM ,n0Jll1 Ka)fi,!\oro 1f3 c06-
CTBeHHJfKOB B npaBe co6crBeHHocTH If ffiBMeCTH}'IO - 6e3 cnpe.ne.ne-
IDIR.TaKJ1x,nOJleiii.
fpa}K,!\aHcKI1!1: KOJ\eKC npe.!1YCMaTpJfBaeT, 'lTO o5Il1aR. c06cTBeH-
HOCTb OO3HIruaeT npJf 11OC'l'}'J1.II8D1 B co6crBemrocn. ,D;BYX I1JIJ1 He-
CKOJlbKI1X  J1M}'llIecTBa, KOTOpoe He MruKeT 6bITb pa3AeneHO 6e3
1f3M8H€lD1fI era Ha3Ha'leHJfH (He,l:lenl'lMble Bel1ti'l) nJf60 He no.nneOOlT
pa:3,ne.ny B cw.ny 3BKOHa. 05il.1BJ'1 co6cTBemJocTI, Ha ,neJrnMoe IfMYIlIe-
CTBO B03ID1KaeT TOJlbKO B CJI)"lamt, npe.D;YCMurpeHHbIX 3BKOHOM HID!
nm""'_
TaKmI 06pa30M, MOmBO BbI,!\eID!Tb TpJf pa:3IIOBH.V;HOC 06"beKTOB
npaBa co6cTBeltmcTn B npaBOOTHOllleHlffiX 06Il1eiii co6cTBeHHoCTJf:
1) BelltJf, pa:3,nen KO'fOpbIX B HaType HeB03MruKeH 6e3 1f3MeHeIDfH
If X Ha3Ha'leHJfH,
2) BelltJf, He no.nneiKaIl\l'le pa:3,neJlY B COOTBe'I'C'l'BI C 3BlWHOOJ;
3) ,l\eID!Mble BelltJf, B cnY'laJIX, npe.n;yCM01p8HHblX 3aKOHOM JjJlJj ,1\0-
rOBopoM.
IIpaBOOTHOllI8HHf coco6cTBemn:nros, B03IDlKaIOIlV'Ie no noBO.ny
o6I.l1ero J1M}'llIecTBa, 'leTKO onpe.neJleHbl B CT. 246-247 fK P<l:I. BJIa-
,QeHl1e, nOJlb30BaID:!e Jj pacnopmK8Hl1e  HaR.
B 06I.l1eiii ,D,OJIeBOU co6CTBeIrnocTJl, ocyIl\eCTBJIR.eTCH no cornaweHI1lO
Bcex ee }"laCTHID«JB. B cJIY"lae HE',IIOC'TImrem1R. cornacWi pemJ1M Bna-
,QeHWI J1 IJOnb3OBBIDIJI MruKeT 6b1Th ycTaHOBJIeH Cy,nOM.
,llOI'OBOpHaH clxJPMa peWeHJ.fH Bcex BOIIpOCOB npJII ocyIl\8CTBJIe-
IDn:! npaBoMo<rni1 BJlBAemUI, IIOJIl>3OBaIIJIJI J1 pacnOpIDK8lllf.H 06IW1M
 ofJecnetn:maeT paBHble ycnOBWI JJ:JI.H I1X peaID!3aql1l1
Kam,rJ;bIM Jf3 coco6cTBemurnos. fK P<l:I H80J\HoKpaTHO yrroMMHaeT 0 Ha-
JIJftIID:! TaKOro,l\OI'OBOpa, HaIIpMMep n. 3 CT. 245, n 1 CT. 246, 0.1 CT. 247,
CT. 248, CT. 252. O,nHaKO fR P<l:I He onpe.neMeT 4>oPMY ,l\BHHOI'O CO-
rnaweIDfe, BJIJUlIDfe urqy:m,!\eHJ.ffi ,l\0ID! lIB ,l\ei1CTBI1TeJlbHOCTb TaKaI'O
corJIaIIIeIDfR., GyIl\eCTBeHHble YCJIOBWI COfnarneHl1.H, He npe.nyCMaTpI1-
BaeT o6.H3aTeJIbHb1e JJ:.IIR era 38KJIIO'leHl1.H cJI,Y'1aM. ,llaHHbill,noraBOp 38-
cny<romaeT 6onee.Jl8'ffiJlbH(Ji pernal, J1 B HeKaTopbIXCnyqaHX
05R.38TeJIbHOCTIiJ era 38KJIIO'leHl1H, KOTOpaR. 6bIOTBe'l8Jla J1HTepecaM co-
Jj06J1eI"llfJla6bIpa3perneHl1ecnopoBBcy,ne.
v

IIpaBoMo..J18 B.na)\emm 11 no.nb30BamHi 06I1M I1MyecTBoM
MomeT 0CYll.leCTB.nHTbCH .lIBYMH cnoco6aMH' nYTeM COBMeCTHOrO
nOJIb3OBaHHH BceMH COC06CTBeHHHRaMH I1MyecTBoM KaK 8)J;ItHbIM
06'beKToM H nYTeM npe.llOCTaB.neHI1R COco6CTBeHHHKY B ero B.na.lle-
HHe 11 nOJIb3OBaHJ1e ..acrn 06ll.1ero HMYll.IeCTBa, copa3MepHoro ero
.lIo.ne.
PacnopIDK8Hl1e J B Q;e.nOM B03MO:mH0 TOJIbKOnO COrJIa-
llleIDOO Bcex }"iaCTHMKOB ,lIOJI8BOi.i cdicTBeIrnoc-rn Y'iaC"IHMK o6ll.1ei1
.lIOJIeBOJl co6cTBellliOC'l1( MOmeT caMOCTOHTeJIbHO JrnWb paC!lOpH,ZUfTb-
CH CBOE'H ,I\OJ!eH, a l1MeHHO npo,!\BTb, nO,!\BpI1Tb, 3aBell.\BTb, OT,!\BTb B 38-
JIor I1JII1 I1HbIM 06pasOM. OC06eHHOCTb OC}'li-leCTBJIeHl1H npaBOMO'illH
pacIIOp.IDK8HHH 3aKJIIO'iaeTCH B TOM, 'iTO npl1 B03Me3,!J;HOM OT'i)':IK,lI;e-
HI1I1 JlOJII1 H c06moc'n1 npaBo np8J1J\II)'I1\8C'I1J8HHOJ1 nOKyn-
KY!, KOTOpOel1HloIMc:or.oI5crseturKaMHaOT'i)':IK,lI;aeMJIO
.l\oma.
IIpaBo np8I'1MyIIt8Cmelllioiii nOKyIIKY! MO:mHO oxapaKTepY!30-
BaTlo KaFt npe,!lOCTaBJIeHH)'lO 3aKOHOM }"iaCTHI1KaM o61l.1eiii ,IJ;o.neBoiii
co6cTBeHHocTY! B03MOJKHOCTlo npY!06pscThl npaBo Ha npo,!\BBaeMJIO
O,!(Hl1M J13 COc06CTBeHHY!KOB .lIO.nlO npel1Myr.u;eCTBeHHO nepe,IJ; no-
CTOpDHHI'IMH Jrn'--\BMJ1 sa paBHloIX C HY!MY! YC.nOBJUIX. IIpaBo npeJ1:MY-
ll.IeCTBeHHoiii nOKymtYJ pacnpocrpaH.HeTCH Ha OT'i)'iK,!\eHI1e ,!IOJIY! no
.lIOroBOPy Kyn.nl1-npo,lJ,B1KJ1 (KpoMe c.nY'ffieB npO,!\B:>KJ1 C nyOJII1'lHbIX
ToproB) 11 MeHlo!.
IIpO,!\BBeQ ,IJ;0JilI 06J'13aH H3B8C'Tt1Tb B rulChMeHHOfi 4>opMe OCTa.nb-
HbIX }"iBCTIDIKOB JJ,01I8BOii co6cTBeJrnocTJl 0 HaMepemm npO,!\BTb CBOlO
.lIOJ!lO nOCTOfJOHH€MY .ID1QY C yKa3aHY!eM L\eHloI 11 .n:pyI'YIX yc.ocBWl, sa
KOTOpbIX npO,!\BeT ee. ECJrn 0CTa.J1bHbE Y'laCTHHKH,lIOJIE'BOfi: c06cTBeH-
HOCTI1 O'!'Ka)KyrCR ar nOK)'IIKM I1JIH He npH06p8'fY'!' npolI.aBaeM}'lO
.lIO.nlO B npase C06CTBeHHOCTH Ha Ht'JtBWfGIMOe 11M)'llt8CTBO B TeIJeIDIe
MecR, a B npase c06cTBellliocTI1 lIB rnalMOe JJMYl*'CTBO B TeIJe-
HHe .l\eCfITI1 ,IJ;lIeH CO,IJ;lIH l13BeWeHl1H. npoliaBeu BlIpase npollaTb CBOlO
.lI O J!lOJu06oMY.nI1l{Y.
IIpHnpo,!lame ,IJ;OJIJ1CHapyWeHl1eMnpel1M.Yll.IeCTBeHHoronpaBa no-
p;ynKYI JIlOooiii .l\pyroiii }"iaCTHI1K ,lJ;OJIeBOM c06CTBellliocTY! I1MeeT npaBo
B Te'1eHJ1e Tpex MecHQeB Tpe60BaTb B cy,!le6HOM nop.lllI.Ke nepeBO,!\B Ha
Hero npaB 11 o6H3aIDIOCTeiii nOKynaTeJIJI.
IIpeKpall.leHilIe OTHOllIeHilIiii 06ll.1e11 J1(IJIeBOii co6c:TBeHHOCThl B03-
MO:mHO B P83YJIbTaT8 pa3,!1e.na o61l.1ero l1M}'llIeCTBa MY! Blol,!\e.na ,IJ;OJrn
J13Hero.
06Il\B.JI c06cTBeHHocTlo Ha J1:Mym;ecTBo HBJIJIeTC./I JloJIeBDiii, 3B I1C-
RJIlO'ieHilIeM CJI}"iaeB, Kor,I\a 3aKOHOM npe,lJ;)'CMOTpeHO 06pa3oBaHilIe
28

COBMeCTHofi COOCTBeHHOCTt1 Ha 31'0 "M)'ll.\eCTBO. Pe>ID1M CCEMecTHOfi
c06cTBeHHocTH npe,[U'CMOTpeH 3aKOHOM B Ka'ieCTBe 3BKOHHOro pe-
:mIDIa I1M)'I.l1;eCTBa cynpyroB' I1ltMa 4>ePMepcKoro X03Hiii:-
cma 2 . KpOMe TOro, B Ca)lOBO,l:l'ieCKOM, Oropo,lJ,HJ1'1ecKOM I1JIH JJ,a'iHOM
HeKOMMep'JeCKOM TOBapHll.\eCTBe  OOll.\erO nOJIb30BaHHH,
npl100peTeHHOe "JII1 C03)1aHHOe TBKHM TOBaplillteCTBOM 3a C'JeT lIe-
neBblX B3HOCOB, JlBJIHeTCH COBMeCIIJOH C06CTBeHHOCTblO ero 'iJIeHOB 3 .
Bo Bcex OCTaJIbHblX CJI)"IaRX B03HImaeT 05ll\aR ,D;OJIeBaR co6CTBeH-
HOCTb.
OCHOBbIBBRCb Ha HopMax rK P<P, MOmHO Bbij];eJlJ1Tb CJIe.IJYlOll.\I1e
OC06eHHOC'J'H, OTJJJ.f'IalOll.\I'Ie COBMeCTHJlOco6cTaeHHOC'J'b err ,D;oJIeBok
1. CyD'beKTaMl1 COBMeC1'HOii co6cTaeHHocTI:f JlBJIRKJTCR TOJIbKO
rpam,l:lclHe, Ha'ID,lI,!Ill.\J'1eCH, KaK npaBJ1JIO, B onpe.v;eJIeHHbIX IDI'llibIX
J1Jll:I nWiHo-X03RI1cTBeHm.Ix OTHoweHI1HX, B TO BpeMH KaK yqaC1'HI1-
KaMl1 ,noreBOH co6cTBeJrnOCTIf Moryr 6bITb nKJ6bIe f'lecmle t1Jl11
lOpJf,!1;l1'l8CKlle JIJIIltB, a TaIOKe ny6mf'lHble o5paaooamm
2. Y'lBCTHI1KI1c05cTBeHHoc-rn:,e('JmlfiloeHenpe'!\yCMo-
TpeHo cornaWeID:IeM Me*.1\Y HIDrn, ocYll\eC'J'BJIHlOf BJIa)J;eID:Ie " nOJIb-
30BaHJ1e 06llW1M J1MYll.\8CTBOM coo5ll.\B. PacnopIDKE'HJ1e 
HBXOAHCR B OOBMecrnoH aficmeHHOCTI'1, oc C co-
rnaCI1HBCexeey<mcTIDlli03,Kcrroporonpe,IJ;IlOJIaraeT-
CR, nOCKOJIbKY JJJ.f'IHaR CBR3b cocofJcrBeHm.rn 06yCJIOBJIJ1BaeT HaJII1-
'i",e y HJ.1X 06ll.\efi BOJll1. IIo3TOMY B COOTI3eTCTBUH C n. 3 CT. 253 rK P<P
C,I\eJIKH C 06ll.\11M J1MYll.\8CTBOM MOm€T cOBepwaTb JIlO60i1 y<>acTID1K.
eCJII1I1H08 He YCTaHOBJIeHO cornaWeHl1eM Bcex }"'IaCTIrnKQB COBMeCT-
HOi1 co6cTaemJocTH.. O,!JJIaKO 3aKOHO.I\aTeJIbCTBO CO.I\epIKJlT piI,II I1C-
KJlI{)qeHHi1113 3TOro npamrna. TaK, comaCHO CT. 35 CeMeihDro Ko):\eKCa
P<P,,l\JIR COBepIlIeHI1H O.I\HI1M 113 CynpyrOB C.I\eJIKJ1 no pacrropmKeHI1lQ
He,JJ,I3I1)KHMOCl1 C.I\eJIKH,  HOTapl1BJIbHoro Y.I\OCTOBepe-
IDIH If (I1Jm) perHCTpa1.!Inl B ycraHOBJIeHHOM 3BKOHOM nopiI,IIKe, Heo5-
XO}J;l1MO nOJIY'il'ITb HOTapi1BJIbHO Y.I\oC'J'oBepeHlIOe cornacl1e ,D;pyroro
cynpyra. Yl\a3BHH08 Tpe600aJme 03HaqaeT, ':ITO B Tex CJI)"IaRx, KOT.I\a
B urnUII8HJ'1I1 06ll\ero 11M)'ll.\8C"I'BB CynpyrOB C£JBefJIillllUI'CH Hal11JoJIee
GyID.eCTBeHHbI8 C.I\eJIKJ1, cornacl1e cocofx.-meHHl1KOB He npe):\IIOJJara-
eTCR, a ,D;OJDKHO 5bITb nO.I\TBepm,n;8HO. .naHHaR Mepa 06yCJIOBJIeHa He-
'ee..ej:;H"KQII.eKC4>!\D.epall'1l<croPct>OT29.12.1995W223-4>3(e(l!\!\.OT29.12.201CJ.
Cf_3311C3P<t> 1996 ""'1 Cr_16
'O>:peC'llA1CJ<C'!JcroP<J>OT11-06.2003""'74-<113!pe,I\.OT26-12_2010)
Cr61JC3P<J>.2003.W24Cr2249
JO"/J,8'1H."HeKO''','ep'teCKM'HeHM''''.--p8>K,<IaH;croP<J>OT
15.04_199B""'66-<I>3!(I!\!\.OT01.(i12011) Cr4/1C3Pd> 199B.""'16.Cr1t!OI
29

06x0.zn:IMOCTbI{} }"IeTa l1H'!'epeCOB o6m:lx CyrrpyrOB t:I o6ecne'I8IIJ1f.[ CTa-
6J1JIbHOC'nIroo6opoTa.
3. 06ll1aJ'l COBMeCTHaH C06CTBeHHOCTb MO€T 6bITb 06paaoBaHa
TOJIbKO B npe.zIYCM0Tp8HHbIX 3aKOHOM CJ1)"1aJIX, '1TO 06ycJr0B.nem OCO-
6eHHOCTJ'lMYlOcy11l8CTBJ18HlU npaBOMO'IYIi1 coco6cmeHmn«m.
4. lIo corJIarnemuo CTOpoH COBMecTHaR co6cTBeJrnocTI, MroKeT 6b1Tb
TpaHB o5ll.\YlO,IJ;oJIeIJYlO co6c'l138HHOCTh.
Do,D;BOiJ..H mor, HeJIb3fl He OTM8TI1Tb, q'f0 I:IHCTI11}'T 06ll1ei1 ,IJ;OJIeBOM
co6crBeHHOCTl:! nporneJI MHOroBeKOB}'IO J.:ICTOpmO, 6blJJ BOCTpe6oBaH
t:I 3Ha'illM AJUI pa3J1J1'ffibIX BpeMeH J.:I <mox.
OcHoBHbIe nOCTYJIaTbI ,IJ;aHHoro InICTIrIym 6bLID1 ccJ:IoPM)'JII1poBa-
HbI ellle PJ:IMCKI1Mt:IIOCTaMI'1 J.:I 3aTeM BbIpaeHbI Ha nO'ffie Hawero
OTe'teCTBeHHoro npaBorropH,QKa. AHaJlJ13 HC'IOpPI:! pa.3Bl1TI1H ,IJ;aHHoro
UHCTI£ryrn. CEy€T 0 era KOJIWIeCIBeHHoii ,WtHaMt:lKe. Ka-
J\brn: HOIJHII HopMaTI1BHbIi1 CIID-npaBoBOi1 alIT .ID1Wb pacwl1-
pM c4>epy era ,IJ;a1C"mJUJ 1:1 J\eTaJ1l13>1pOBaJI npaBl1J1a era npt:IMeHeHt:lfl.
O,!JJIaKO CepbE'3HOM)' 1H8mno HopMb! IfH(.'TII"Iyr<l B POCCt:ll1 He nOk
BepraJ1l1Cb.
COBpeM8HHOe rpa1t<,IJ.3HCKOe npaBO nepemJ.1BaeT :=moxy pecJ:lopM,
'<ITO CBJI3aHOBnepB}'IO oqepec npIfiUIT1reM YKa3a lIpe3t:1,IJ;eHTa POC-
CI:IiicIioii 4JeJ\epaQJ.1t:I OT 18 t:IIOJIH 2008 r. N2 1108 «OcoBepW8HCTBOBa-
Hm1  KOJJ,eI\Ca F'occJdicKOjij tPe;nepBQIIJI», pa3pa6OTKOI1
KOHJJ;8IIqm1 pa2BJITHR rpa)K,AaHcKOro :3aKOHO,D;aTE'JIbCTBa 1:1 06cYiK/1.e-
"HeM npoeKTa H3M8HeHKii B '1acTb I fR pq,.

rfiaBa 3. nPABO OE;lJ.jE COE;CTBEHHOCTI1
B EBPOnECKI1X CTPAHAX
3.1. B03HKHOBEHE  PA3BmE nPABA
06UJ.EC1 C06CTBEHHOCTV1 B rEPMAHVlIII
3.1.1. MO)J,ellMpOBaHe npaBa o6L4el7l co6CTBeHHocH'I
B rpHcKoM 3aKoHo)J,aTeJlbCTBe
OcHOBbI npB.OOI3Oit: CMCTeMbI <PeJ\epaTIfBHoi1 Pecny6J1JOOf fepMB-
HJH'I 6bIJI1.1 3BJlO:>KeHbI nOCJIe 1HeHIDI B 1867 r. pH..QB roCYJlapcTB
nOJ\ rJIaBeRCTBOM IIpyCClrn B CeBepo-fepMaHcKUi1: COK/3, CTaBlllIUl
3aT8M, B 1871 r., fePMIDiCKClit: l1MIIeplteH.. ITpI1 3TOM Ha npOTlDfteHJrn
,lJ;OCTaTO'iHO ,WIJITeJIbHoro BpeMeHM, ,l\D I13,.$HI1H 
OOI1lerepMaHCKMX 3BKOHOB, B mmepl1Jil npo):\OJI:1KaJU1 ,l\8ACTBOBaTb
3aKOHo,naTeJIbHble aKTbI If npaBOBble OObNaM BOIlIe,qlllJ1X B Ree KHH-
:meCTS, ropoJ\OB 1:1 J1HbIX TeppI>1TOpHB.1lbHbIX 06pa3OB3HHii 3aKOHO-
,naTenbCTBO BOCC03)\aHHoro B XIX B. oOI1lerepMaHCKOrO rocy.napcTBa
pa3pa6aTbIBBJIOCb rJIaBHbIM 06pa30M H3. 6B3e 3BKOHOB IIpycCHM,
EasapJ1}f 11 CaKCOHID1 11 B MeHblllefr. CTefieIDI - .l1Pymx rocYJlapcTB.
EOJlblllOe BJIIDlIDIe OKa3aJlO IIpyccKoe 3eMeJIhHoe ynoiKeHl1e 1794 r.,
Karopoe OXBaTbIBBJIO MHOrMe OTpaCJII1 npasa, Easapanrii yrOJIOBHhrM
KOJ\eKC 1813 r. 11 60JIee paHHJ1e 6aBapCKJ1e cy,ne6Hb1ii 11 I'paHi,naHCKJUi
KOJ\eKcbl1753 111756 IT., CcrncoHCKl'IJI rpam,IlBHCKMi1: IWJ\eKC 1863 r.,
raHf£JB8PCJOOl rpam,IlaHCKMi1:npOU;eccyaJIhHbIA KOJ\eKC 1850 r. Ha Tep-
pJITOplrn HeKOTopblX BOll1e;nIIJ1X B fepMaHCK}'IO HMIlepmo rocy.napcTB,
B csoe BpeMF! ORK}'ID1pOBBHHbIX apr.rnetl HanOJIeOlIa, coxpaWlJnt cl<LIIY
BTm'nepMoJJ;rpKO.n;eKc4JpaHQID11B04r.HHHbIe
HBmJII2OIIOBCKI m,n81«H. «B.Ju.mm.1e :fl'MX 3aKOHOB lIB $JpM>
3BKOHO.n;aTeJ!bCTBa repMBHC1OC31 HMIlepl1M O'I8BJwro. HaKOHert npM no,!\-
roroBKe IIpOeKTOB )"llfIHBaJJDCbH o6IQee npaBO, npe.nCTa.BJIHBlllee c060M
CJIIDKHoe II8pEf1.JI8'TEt HOpM, BOCXO K pMMCKOM)' Hl\aHOHWIe-
CKOM)'npasyHnpaBOBb!M06brqaHMBID1XrepMaHl.\eB»'.
O,ll.H11M 113 nepBbIX npe.n;llleCTBeHHlfROB ;netlCTBYIOl1\ero rpaaH-
CKom YJIomeHl1H 6hlJ10 BaBapcKoe rpaaHcKOe YJIomeHJle 1756 r.,
1 >KanHc.<MA..PeP"""A.""BHe"'e<JI<OOnpaoo. M_ CIlAPK,2001 C.32
31

Ha3bIBaeMOe TalOKe KO,l:\eKCOM MaKCt1MlfJllfaHB BaBapCKOro. ,l4HHbn1
,l:\OKYMeHT CO,l:\epmaJi pa3,l:\eJl,  perYJillpoBaIDIlO OTHO-
llleHMfI o6utefI co6cTBeHHocTIf.
Coco6cTBeJnooa. no BbipamemllO H:3B8CTIJ()ro H€Mel.\Koro :yG€HOro
PaTa KpaiiiTMaiiepa, COCTOIDII1B urnOlllemmxcTpeTbI1M11MYJ RBK
'<OJ],JIII CyD"beKT»'. Eo BlI}"I'PeHHttx 0TH0llI8Ht1RX B coo6ecTBe npe06-
JlB.I\BeT npl1Hrr €,I:\I1HOrJIaCWI, KOTOpbri1 Jle:iKl1T B OCHOBe npl1HHTI1H
pellIeHI1i1 no pacnOpmK8HtUQ Bell.\blO B qeJlOM, a TIllOKe ynpaBJle-
Hl1lO tI nOJlb30BaHl1lO. B pH.l\e CJiy'laeB npl1MeHeHYJe 3'TOro 1Ip11Hl.\l1IIa
I1CKJ1lO'iaJlOCb. B IWMMemapl1l1 KpaiITMai1epa IipIfBO,IJ;I'JTCH l.\eJlbIi1
nepe<t8Hb, B TOM 'ffiCJIe, HEmpMMep, peMom, H8OOXO,lII(MI:li1AJI.H CO,l:\ep-
.?KaID'JR Bel.J..tl1. ero Mor OCYll\eCTBl1Tb mo6o:i1 tl3 C«XJ6c-rneHHtlKOB.lInH
:noro CJIY"8H YCTBHOBJleHO oorn;ee npaBJ.1JIO,  Ka:lK,!\brn, KTO YKJIO-
HHeTCH 0'1' HeceHWI 6peMeIHI pacxo,!\oo. Jll1rna€TCJI CBOei1 ,!\OJill. Jill:llle-
Hl1e ,l:\OJlI1 B03MOOJ eCJll1 COOTBeTCTB)'1Orn;m1 Co6cTBeHHI1K 1f3Bern;eH
o 3aTpaTax If C>CyI.qeCTBJleIrne 3TI1X M8pcnpmrUH ID'J KBKI1M 06pa30M
He Yll.\eMJIHeT MHTepeCbI.lIPyI'I1X coc06cTB8HHI1KOB.
ITepBOi1 cpe,!\11 npyCCK.I1X KO,l:\l1<!>I1KBqI1i1 .fIBJlHeTCH ITpyccKoe 3e-
MeJlbHOe YJlOmeHl1e 1794 r. ITepBbn1 npoeKT "Project des Corpus luris
Fridericiani» 0CIDBI.IBaJICfI ellie, KaK tI BaBapc:KHfI KO,l:\eKC, no cYil\e-
CTBY, Iffi OOll\eM npaBe. HetIDropbd1: npOCToi1 B pa50Te Iffi,!\ 3aKOHOM Ha-
6mo.1\BJlCR B nepl1o,l:\ CeMHJI€"1'H8ft BOi1HbI, nOCJIe 'Iero pa60Ta Iffi)\ 38-
KOHOMObIJia EOOO5Hrnnelffi.
Pe.1\BKTOpbl 3aKOIffi B3H.ID1 3a OCHOBY tl3Jl0meHHoe B KHWre PaTa
KpaHTMai1epa "1.fI. KpMTI1Ka 11 tlCTOpl1R» oOil\ee npaBo, KO-
Topoe ,!\eiicTBoBa.oono <!>OPMYJI€ «Ilp'1C'IOi1Ho, npaKTWlHo tI IIpl1M.eHI1-
MO». BepoJITHo, BIDIJlHlile p nfi Mb!CIDItI.fIBI1JlOCb
IipIf'llDlOJI J1Horo, 'IeM B OOil\eM npaBe, B3rJlH,l:\a Ha OTHOWeHI1R OOll\ei1
c06cTBeHHocTI1. "Pe.1\BKTOpbl 38KOHa npH.JIaI'iUTII Bce YCI1JlI1H, 'lroOb!
HaHnIl.\eJ!eco06pa3Hbrn nOpH,IJ;OK.l\JL<I 06ll.\ei1 cofx.-meHHOC'I'Jol, tI Haw-
JlI1 era, OTTaJlKlfBaHCb 0'1' IIpI'1pOLIH Bewei1. 'Iro HBJ.1JIOCb Bb!l1Tpb!llIHbIM
Bapl1amoM»2.
HeCMOTpH fiB eHHHe JeMble OTJII1'lJ.1R OT
pl1MCKoro rrpaBa, ITpyccKoe 3eMeJlbHOe YJlomE'ID'Je AJI.H oIIp8.ll8Jlemrn
OOll\eH cofcrBeHHocTIt 5ep8T 38 OCHOBY pl1MCK)'1O 06 c06cTBeH-
HOCTb no .l\OJIHM. XOT.H <!>OpM)'Jll1pOBKa  1 TJlaBbI 17 5o.JIee 6.ruf3Ka no
CO)J;8JDKBHtIIO II: cOBpeMeHHoM)' HeMeIVWM)' rrpaB)' OOEM8CTHQH coo-
'KreittmayrRlI<1markungenOberdenCodiceml\llaxJmlliane....bavaric......cillilam.II.Teil MCrlchen.
1621.5.293
20nni""rM.PfandrechtundbeiMileigentumuodBem:
Stampfli 19725_26
32

CTBeHHOCTI1. «B HeK01'OpblX CJIyq<iRX OOIl\BH co6c'rBeHHJcTb no IIpyc-
CKOM}'Y.mrnreHtUOHanOMmIaeTHe'l1'Ocpe.lnieeMem;Jy
COBM8C'I'HOfi: 11 ,l:\OJ1eBo!1: co6cTBeHHocTI.I J1 XOTH npYCCKoe Y.Jrm<f>IU1e
perYJmpyeT OOIl\.YlO 1\O.!I8B}'1O co6cTBeHHocTb. paa.mf'llible OpraHI1-
3B1V'ID1lliliI8 HOpMbI npe.IICT8BJlRJI 06paliteIDIe K TeopJ1lll COBMe<."I'HOii
CoOCTBeHHOCTI1»' .
K cyrnecmeHHl>JM OT.!II1'II1HM Mem;Jy 061It11M npaBOM 11 opraHIf3BQI'1-
ei1 0011lei1: ro6crneHmcTt1 no IIpYCCKOM)' Ipam,!J;aHCKOM}' Y.!IomeHl<IlO
OTHOCI1TCR B nepBYJO O'lepe;nb npl13HaHI1e npl1Hll.Hna 6o.rrbllll1HCTBa
B npYCCKOM npaBe. Pern.l1,!\eT 0 BO!lpocax,  CO,l:\epmaHJ.1H
0011lei1 Belltl1, WIfl pewew'IH ROTopbIX IIpfME'RH8TCJI npl11ll.\I1II 6oJlb-
111l1HCTBa. O.lniaKO npl1 BHeCeHllilI13MeHeID1!1: BeaM}' BeIqb, Hanpl1Mep
npl1113MeHeHI1I1 ee Ha:maqeIrnR, Tpe6yeTCH COrJIaCl1e Bcex c06cTBeH-
ID1KOB, BOrrpOC a BbIDope c!locooa BHeceHJUI J'!3MeHeHIDI MOmeT pe-
lllaTbCH6onbnnmC'l1KJM rOJlOCOB.
B OCHOE}' peIlIemrli:, KaCalOllIMXCH pacnOpHmeHI1H BeIqbIO, TaIOKe
nOJlomeH npI1HU;MT160JlbllIMHcTBa. COOCTBeHIDIIa1, He rrO,!JJ\epmaBWl1e
peWeHl1e OOJIbllnlHCTBa, BnpaBe TpeOOBaTb npeKpaweHI1H OOlllHOCTI1
( 19, 20 r.naBblI7) nl16oocnapl1BaTb 31'0 peWeHl1eB CYAeOHOM nopH,!!;-
Re. B nOCJle.lnieM CJIY'ffie CYAbR AOJDKeH IIpIIHHTb peIlIeHl1e 0 rOJlOCO-
BaIrnI1 J'! YCTaHOBHTb, HBJIHeTCH ID'J npl1H.11TOe peweHI1e .!IJ'lliII1M WlH
 Ec.n11 cy..QbJI nO;:J;TBep:iK,!\aeT 3TO, TOr.n;a YTBep:iK,!!;eHHble
MepOnpI1HT11H .J\OJDKHbI6bITb ocyru;eCTBJIeHbl; B CJI.Y'Iae eCJlI1 CY.J\bH He
YTBep:iK,!\aeT MepOllpI1HTIfH, Bce ;:J;0J1:iKH0 6bITb OCTaBJleHO oe3 113MeHe-
mdi EcJll1 MepollplfHTIUI JTBep:iK,!!;eHbI B cy,!!;e6HOM nopH.AKE', HO OHM
BJleKYT $fHaIICOIJH8 Jl3,J\epmKJ'1 11 nOTepl1,W1R MeHbWJ1HCTBa, CY;nbH
B CBoeM peWeHJ1III p8T 3TY! l13,lJ;epmKl1 Mem,n;y IDIL\BMI1, OT-
W:H K 601IblIll1HCTBY, npillUlBllieMY pellieIDIe. B 3TOM CMblCJI
KOMTIeHWQIUJHHOi1: 3aliV'ITbl MeHUlIInrrna.
YnpaBJIeHI1e BeIqbIO OCYll\eCTBJmeTCH IIpIf )"IaCThlI1 Bcex cocoo-
CTBeHHI1KOB. Me:>f\!\Y TeM 11PnyGKBIOTCH YKJIOHeHYIH OT 3TOro np"Hl\Y!-
na. B ':IaCTHOCTlf, yrrpaBJIeHY!e MO:iKeT ocyIl\8CTBJlHTb J130paHHbIM
8JVIoIIUUu:rpaTOpOM, p8IIIeHl1eO ero H36paHlO1I1p1UU1MB-
eTCH OOJIblill1HCTBOM rQJIOCOB. B cpa'lHblX CJI.Y'IBHx OT,l\E'JItHbrli cocoo-
CTBeHHI1K MOmeT Ha CBOi1: plfCK npl1Hl1MaTb Hed'iXQV;1fMb18 Mepbl.
EOJIblill1HCTBO YCTBHaBJJJ.lBB€TCH no OOlll€MJ pa3Mepy .J\0Jll1. TeM
He MeHee 3aKOHOM np8,!\yCMaTpI1BBeTCH B03M(I)KHOCTb caMOCTOm'€JIb-
Horo OnpeJleneHlfJI coc06cTBeHHMKaIlrn cJI.Y'Iaes, Kor.J\a 60JIblill1HCTBO
onpeneJIJIeTCR no KQJll1'IeCTE}' JlI1Il. «YJlom8Hl1e He I1pJ1BO)J;I1T npl1Me-
'SchneK1erB.OasscrischeS,21
33

pOB TaKOro no.n;C'IeTa 6o.nb1mnicTBa rOJlOCOB. MOmHO npe;nIlOJIO)KttTb,
'ITO corofx.-rneHIDIKI1 Mor.n11 caMOCTOKl'€JIb1JO onpe,!\eJIHTb nepe'IeHb
TaIDIX BonpOCOB»'. TaKJ1M 06pa30M, cocof.:crBeHHJmn MOrJIJ1 YCTaHaB-
.nJ.1BaTb J:lHbIe npaBJ.1JIa, 'IeM IIp8A,)'CMO'Tp€lllibIe B aaKOHe.
IIo.nb30BaIDIe BelltblO J:I pacnpe,!\e.neIDIe pBCXO.n;OB no ee co.n;epma-
HI110 pacnpeJI&IIMCb Mem,rry cocof.:czBemumaMH nponopIV10HaJlbHO
I1X ,IJ;OJIRM (45-51). B c.nyqae H61CIIOJIH8IOOI 00J!3BHIDC111 co.n;epma-
HI1JI BeJ1U1 no peweHIDO CYAB ccfcrBeIrmm .nl1UIaJICR cBoeR ,IJ;OJIJII. Cy-
,IJ;bR aIp8.[le.J1HJI LleHY, J.fJJ,OJIH npoBaJIaCb ocnI.1IbHl:oIMcocofcl'BemD1-
RaM(46).
JJ:OJIH B oOll-\eif o:fcrBeInn:crn npe,!\CTaBJIJLJIa coooif OOOporoCIIO-
c06Hbrn OO"beKT. DBa MOrJIa 6bITb O'l"l)'m.neHa, aaJIomeHa J.fJI1.1 J1HbIM
cnOCOOOM 06peMeHeHa 6e3 corJIaO:!R OCTBJIbHbIX Coco6cTBeHIDfKOB.
O,IJ,HaKO OTY:J'K,!\€Hille )'J;OJIJII JJ,OJImHO 6bIJIO  npl1 co-
1 npaaa npel1M)'ll.leCTBeHHOif nOKY=. npmUU\JIe.malllem
OCTaJIbHbIM c06CTB8HHillKaM
IIpeKpall-\€Hille yqaCTI1R B AOJIeBOif 06ll-\HocTill MOfJIO oCYl1\ecT-
BJIRTbCR nOCpe,IJ;CTBQM peaJIl13Bljillillnpaaa Ha BbJ,IIeJI ,IJ;O,JU1 B HaType.
fpam.naHClwe YJIOmeHille IIpycCID1 co,!\epjf{JilT H86o.rn.rnoe KOJIiII-
'leCTBO HOpM, J1JLJIlOcrpillpyIOIl\l1X npaBOBoe peryJIl1poaaHille oOll-\eif
c06cTBeHHocTiII, HO OHiII .Q8MOHC1ptpyKrr BbICOKO COBpeMeHHoe pery-
.IIt1pCEaIU1E' 3T11X 0TH0lll8HIm. IIpill'IiIIHa TaKOi1: BbI:OKOi1: IOpillM'lffJ\Otf
T€XHI1KiII - 3TO 'i)'BCTBO npaKTII'lH0C'I11 J1 Tll\BTeJIbHOe paCCM(YrpeHue
KaK pt1MCICOI'O, TaK J1 HeMel!Jwro OnbITa IIpaBOBOro perYJIHpOBaHI1fI 06-
ll-\eif Cof.:crBeHH0C'I11, '1m I103BOJUIJI() C03.n;aTb m,lJ,XD,I\Hll-\t8t: npaBoIIo-
pB,QOK .n.rm AJIiII'I'eJIbHbIX GrHOilieHillif o6ll-\ei1 c06cTBeHHocTill.
IIpaBOIIOpR,!\OK, 3aKp8J1JEHHbdi B IIpYCCKOM y.nmKeHIDl, C03,!\BJl xo-
POIlI)'lO OCHOBY AJIH fepMaHCKoro rpam,IlBHCKOro y.nomeIDIR (,!\aJIee -
ffY). fry BOCI1pI1H.HJI nOIJTJ:I Bee 6e3 HCItJOOIlE'HHR cpraHH3al!I'IDH
IIonooKelD1RIIpYCCKoroynomemm.6e3YCJIIEH(),CI1CTe-
MaTIf3Bljl1fl fry OTJIJ1IJaeTCR OT J:lHKOpnopl1pJBBHHoco aRTa, nocKOJIb-
KY fry pa3M8CTt1Jl HOpMbI 0606ll-\HOCTRX B pa3,l\e.ne, peryJIJ1pYIOll\eM
06R3aTE'JIbC'I'BeHOO npaBo.
B.rraro,!\apR npl13HBHMIO npmiIVma 6o.rrblllillHCTBa npoill30IlIeJI 6oJIb-
woif nporpecc B perYJBlpOBBIDfJ1 OTHOWemm 061l1ei1:co6cTBeHHocTII no
LpBBHeIDIIO C OOll-\MM npaBoM".
'JenerK.AusgewahlteProblemebeiEnIstehlK1J:J.OberIragunguIKlBeiaslUl1!:Jvon
WJrzburg,2006.S4.
20.._ SchnelderB.DassctTwelzerischeMo\elgenll.msreS_23
34

3.1.2. Aei1cTBYIOe npaBO o6j;1 C06CTBeHHOCTI.1
It! HeKoTopble Mop,enM co6CTBeHHoCT
C a30BaHl1eM CeBepo-fepMaHCKoro em03a HaqaJICR Me,l\Jl8H-
Hbrli. HO nOCJIe;O;OBBTeJIhHbIIlnpoQecc I13.I\BHI1JI ofuQerepMaHCKI1X 3BKO-
HOB, B xo;o;e KOTOporonepBOHB'lBJIbHO 6b1JIJ.1 npillilITbI pa3pa6crraHHble
paHee ToprOBoe YJIO)KeHJ.1e 11366 T. 11 YrOJIOBHOe YJIO)KeHl1e IB7I r.,
3aTeM fpa)K,.'¥lHcKoe npoQeCcyBJIbHOe 11 YroJIOBHo-npoQecCYaJIbHoe
YJIOiK8Hl1.fI, 3aKoHOCY;o; 11377 T.I1JIJ1llIbB 11396 r. - fpa)K-
.I\BHCKOe ym)KeHJ1e (Ha3BaHHhIe Ko.neKCb! UMeH)'lOTCfI ynO)K€HI1R-
MI1 cor.naCHO npl1HHTOfi B pycoroif: ;O;OpeBOJIIOQ110HHOfi nMTepaType
TepI\oll1H0JI0I1111)'.
fepMaHCKoe rpaHi,!I8 Ym>KeIUre" KaK KOJn1ctJJ1-
KaQ11R HeM8qRoro 06IQero qaCTHoro npaBB peryJIJ1py8T CaMble BB-'KHbIe
IDpJJ,lJ)l'IecKKe DTHOllIeHWI Me qaCTHbIMH.ID1QBMJ.1. ORo OOpasY8T C
3aKOHaMI1, C03,II;aHHbIMJf B ero HJ18 06IQee qaCTHOe npaBO, HO
He npe,l\JlaraeT nOJIHyKI KOJn1ctJI1KaQI1KJ rpa)K)J,aHCKOrO npaBa 3 .
fry BCTynJ1JIO B ci1JIY 1 fIHsapH 1900 T. 31'0 6bLJ1a nepBaH KO,!\J1-
ctJJ1Kaql1H qaCTHOro npaBa, KDTOpaH IiIMeJIa ci1JIY B arHOIlJe1OO1 Bcex
OUbE!.m1HeHHbIX I1MIIepI1ei106nacTei1l1.oBc'I)'llJI8HI1.IIB CJ1JIY ffY B oc-
ROBaHHofi B 113n T. fepMaHCl\Ofi: t1Mneplillil B ofulacrn qaCTHoro npaBo
lfMem1 IOpH,!\JJ<l8CKyKI ci1JIY O,!\HoBpeMeRHo HecROJIbKO npaBOBHX IiIC-
'I'QIlHI:IKOB, B TOM 'lJ1CJIe OOIQe€ npaBO, IIpyccKoe rpa:H<,iJ,BHCKOe ynmKe-
IDle 1794 r., 4>paHqy3CKIm: Ipa)K,l:(aHCKJ1i1 KO.n;eKC 11304 T., Ba.n;eHcKoe
npaBo 11310 T., Ko;o;eKC  BasapCKOro 1756 T., CaKCOH-
CRoe 3epQaJIO 1241 T.IiICmcoHCKOe repMaHCROe rpa1f<,IJ,8HCK( ynmKe-
IDIel1365r.
frY llep8)!MJ1o paanWIHbIe 11C'I'OpM'iff'Kl1e nepMO,!!,bI HeM1: 1'0-
cY,lIapCTBeHHOCTIiI, 'ITORe Morno Ha HeM He arpa3l1TbCH.
BTe'IeHlilenepBbIx 14neTerocy,IJ;e6HaRnpaKT!ilKa
IillOpl1cnpy,/:\eHQI1R pB3BJ1BaJII1 ,/:\OI'MaT!iIK}' ffY. Cy.IJ;bI,[IOIIOJIHHJII.f Ha-
IDIcaHHOe npaBo.
B neplilo,IJ; Bei1MapcKofi pecny5mu\JII ocoObrn YRJIOH 6bLJ1 ,/:\aH B CTO-
paHY YCJ1JIemrn 3alW'lTHbIX MexaHH3MOB rpa)K)J,aH B TP}',/:\OBOM npaBe
B TPY,/:\OBOM npaBe Y)K€ B 3TO BpeMR mJmHJIaCb TeH,!\eHQIU! K C03,!\a-
I g.iCaoo""".B.A.rpa>Kl:""'''''hQ,O,l!KCrep''''H.I'iCTopI1" c""--'''''''' "HCTMTyIbI,M.ICP<CT 1994.
'=OChlJeutschland\lOm1t!_AugI.lSt1896RGBlS,m51nkr3ftlrelen
JC..,SchlosserH_GrundziigederNeuerenFlechlsentwicklungenim
europaischenKomexl.10,Aufl Hetdelt>erg'Miiller,2005_S,1t!5
35

HI110 ocoooro 3aKOHO,lJ,aTeJIbCTBa, KOTOpOe npl1BenO cero)J;HH K MHOiKe-
cmy 3aKOHOB 0 Tpy.v;e J1 aanyrallllOif cy,!!;e6Hoif npaKTI1Ke'.
B nepl1o,!!; Ha1tJ10Han OCOObIM 1f3M8H€Ht1HM 6b1JIo nOk
Bepnryro HaCne,D,CTBeHHOe 11 C8MeJlHoe npaBO.
1IJHHbIiii nepl1o,!!; xapaKTepl13}'8'!"('JI yc1paHeHJ18M BJ1WIHI1H
roHaJl-a:IU1aJII1CTK'I8CROI'Ope>Kl1Ma.Pa3BJrme repMBHCROl'OrpaiK-
.v;aHCKOro YJlOiKeHI1H HYiKHO n:>.n;pa3JJ,8Jl, Ha'll1HaJI C <JTOii: ,[(aTbI, Ha
aanB)J;HorepMBHCKOe 11 BOCTO'ffiorepMBHCKOe pa3BI1TI18- B repMaHCKOi1
;l{eMOKpa1Wl8Cl\Ott PecnyfurnKe rry nocreneHHo o&wmmui:Jcr, yrpa-
TJ1BWI1M cl1JI}', nocKonbKY ,[(BHHbIi1aaKoH He cornaCOBbma.n:CH C CO-
qn8.]IKC'IWI8CK(llI I1,[(€OJIODleJL lIo O'lepe,!!;11 <JaM8HH.IDICb c8MefuIbrn
Ko,!!;eKC Ha npI1CnOCOOeHHbrn: K I13MeHeHHbIM ycnOBJ.1HM jf{J13H11 Cao,!!;
3aKOHOB a ceMbe (1966 r.), Tpy,!!;oBoe npaBO B Cao,!!; 3aKOHOB a Tpy,!!;e
(1961 r.), B 1978 r. Ha KOJJ;eKc 3aKOHOB 0 Tpy.v;e, OCTanbHble 'faCTI:!
B  CBO,!!; 3aKOHOB (1976 r.) 113aKOH a ,lJ;orOBOpe (1982 r.).
IIpaBo 6b1JIO nO)J;'3:l1HeHO coql18.JIJ1CTII'I€CKOH 3KOiOMJ1K€. ;l{oroBop cny-
:IKI1JI I1HCTp}'MeHTOM nnaHoBoro X03.HIfcTBa. C MOMeHTa ofh.e,n;I1H£'lillfl
repMBHHH, COC'IOHBIIa'OCH 3 OKTropfl1990 r., rry BHOBb npl1oopeno
CTaTYC 06rnerepMaHCKOrO npaBa.
B 90- x rr. npornnoro CTOJIeTUH rry nepeml1BBJ1O peBU31110 HeKOTO-
pbIX HOpM ceMei1Horo npaaa (B TOM 'll1cne OKOH'ffi.TenbHoe YCTpaHeHI1e
pa&JUI<t"'ft Mem,!\y cynpYiKeCKI1MU 11 BH€Opa'lHblMU .v;eTbMl1t, a TaK-
me 06paTHoe nepeMern€IDIe HOpM ceMeiiHoro npaaa B rrY.
IIoCJIe)J;HRH6oJIbrnaHnepepa6arKaBxo)J;eMQ!1epHl13B-
r.tm1 OfumaTeJIbCTBeHHOro npaaa, KOTOpaJI 6bLJ1a HaI1paBJIeHa, B TOM 'll1G-
Jle, 11 lIB J1MIIJIeM€HTaqJ1lO H€KOTOpbIX W1J>eKTI1B EC, CB.fl3BlllIbIX C 3aInl1-
TOif1.KpoMeTOro,6bLlIl1;ucrya.m13l1pOBBHblCTO'lKI1apeHJ1H
.III'1HrBI1C'IWJ8CN)ro BbIp8.meHl1H $JPMY.1D1pOBKI1 craTei111 ID: Ha3BaHl1R"'.
J1Hcnrryr oornei1: c06cTBeHHocm perYJll1py8'!"('JI B rry HOpMaMl1
KaK OOH3aTeJIbCTBeHHoro npaBa, TaK J1 BelllHoro npaaa. ComaCHO ro-
CIlO,[(CTB HeM .v;OKTPJfiIe Bce, 'ITO OTHOCHTCJI K OcyIl\eCT-
BneHI1IO npaBOMO"lwi1: cc6crB€lfHOC'fI1 B OTHOllIeHID'! 06rnei1: BeInl1, pe-
ryJll1pyeTcH BelllHbIM npaBOM  1008-1011 rry. CaMa me OOlllHOCTb
'CId.WeackerFderNeuzeitur1lerbesond""'rderdeutschen
Entwicklung.2.urr;er!\rld.Nad1d<der2.oeubeafb.AutI.vonl96713,-14Thd.GOttingen:
Vanr:lenhoeckARupreo;hl.I996,S.69
CId. Musielak H.J. Grundkum 8GB: eine  mr VEfmtttJng wn CJrulageJ1Wissen im
tio"gerIchenRechtmitFailenundFragenzurlern'undsowienil
Grundkum8GB_ 12_AuII_MLinchen:Beck.201I S_319
3C1d.UhiChEisertard..DeutSCheRec:trlsgeschc:3,AufI.IQ99,insb,S.404-411.
.CId. SchmoeckeIM.RuCl<.ertJ.2jmnermannR I<QmmeJ1larzumBG8 Band I.
AllgemeonerTeilI-240rtl:irlgenMClhrSoebeck.2003_S27
'"

I1MeeT OruI33.'1'eJIbCTBeHHYJO np"po.l1Y, n03TOMY nOJIOmeHlliI 0 .l1OJIe-
BOi1: o6lWIOCTI1 pa3M8Il.IeHbl B pa3.!1:e.ne «06R3aTe.JIbC'I'BeHHO npaBO»
r.rrase 17 «06lltHocTb»  741-758 (MeiK,!tYrJIaBaMl116 (!fOBa" 11
18 «FeHTa»), r.l1e .l10JIeBaR 05l1tHoC'l'b pery.rrwpyeTcR KaX BamHefuuaR
clxJPMa BbipameHlliI 06r.u;eiii Cof.:cTseHHOCTIL
HeMeLtKOe npaBo pa3JIl1'1aer e clxJPMbI 06r.u;eiii co6crBeHHocTH:
.l1OJIeB}'IO co6cTBeHHocTb 11 cOBMecm}'KJ.
Co6c-rnemnmoM BeLIJ;l1 MDmeT ObITb BCerAB 'I"OJIbK0 cy6'beKT npaBa.
3TO npRMo BblTeKaeT 113 onpe;1\eJIeHlliI cyfrbeKTa npasa, Tax Kax OH
HeceT npasa 11 06R3aHHocTI1, "ITO, B '1acmOCTI1, pacnpo<."l'palUll1
Ha npaBO co6crseHHOC'UL
EcJII1 c06CTBeHHlIRaMJI Bel1tl1 RBJIJ'IKJTCR60Jlbllle '1eM O.l111H cy6'beXT,
TOOHYI oopa3yror06I1..\HOCTb, a I1M€HHO, KaKnpamrno, .!I:OJIeB}'IO, B m1,ZJ;e
I1CRJIIO'IeHlliI- COBMeCTH}'lO. B  1008-1011 peryIDIpye-rcflTOJIbK01J,O-
JIesaR cofx.-rBeJrnocT CCEMeC'I'HBJ'I c06cTBeHHocTb B Ka)K,1:l0M OT.l1eJIb-
HOM cJIY'lae 06cym1J,BeTCR KaK npaBOBaJI KOHC'lpYKUlliI'.
COBMl2CTHaJI Cc6:TBeIDIOC'Tb cyr.u;l2CTB)'eT B OOr.u;eCTBaX rpam,!\BHCKOIU
npasa (705), 6pa'lHbIX J1MYIl\eCTBeHHbIX 06lltHoCTJIX ( 1415), HaCJIe,I\-
CTBeHHbIX OOIl..\HOC1'flX, B OTKpbITbIX TOplUBblX TOsapt ( 105
TOplUBOIU KOJ\eKca) J'! B KOMII'IalI,IJ;IITHblX TOsapl1ll\eCTBaX ( 161 Topro-
BOro KOJ\eKca). CosMeCTIlBfl co6cTBeHHOC'Tb MmKeT OblTb C03)\BHa TOJIbKO
B cm!)' npmmro npE',IJ;I1J1camm 3aKOHa, BHe yperyJrnIXJBaHHbIX 3aKOHO-
1J.BTe.J1bHOCJIy'l8.8B'Iepe3;QoroBopcoBMecTIlaJI06pa30sa-
Ha OblTb He MOmeT. Or Bcex clxJPM coco6cTBelniocT CYrJlJ'!'laeTCJI npaBO
,QOJJ£'BOii Cc6crBeHHOC1'I1 HB oor.u;ee I1M}'ll-I8CTBO c06CTBeHHl1KOB RBBprl1p.
JtJrn COOMeC'IEOii o:fcrn8HHOC'I11 xapaKTepHO, 'ITO BeLIJ;b H8X01J.ITI'Cfl
«B o61lt11X pyxax». .nOM OT1J,eJIbHoro c:oco6crBeJnu.n He HBJIfIeTCfl Ber.u;-
Ho-npaBOBOH, IIO:)TOM)' eii TaIOKe HeJIb3fl pacIiOpIDKaTbCJf. II0JIb3OBa-
HI1e 11 paCiiopIDfleHl1e OGylileCTBJIfleTCH TOJIbKO BeeM>:! COC06CTBeHHHKB-
MI1 coo6r.u;a I1JIJ1I1X npeJ\CTaBl1TeJmMl1. TOJIbKO B OTRpbITOM TOpIUBOM
TOBapl1ll\eCTBe H TOsapl1ll( M().}K8T paClIopmKaTbCR OOll\eii Be-
LqbIQ,BblCTyIIiliiIIp€J\CffiBl1Te.JIeMOOl1tHOCTl1 (125 TOproBOro KO;QeKca).
ltpyrafl Cl1T}'<lW1fl CKJIa;QblBa8TCfl npl1 yperyJIMPOl!<lHOOii 1J,OJIeBOH
COOC'l'BeHHOCTI1: 3,D;eCb Ka cocOOcrneHHi'lK I1MeeT onp8.l\eJIeHHy1O
1J.OJUO HB BeLIJ;b, KOTopaH He Bblpa)f(3.eTCfl B I1pOCTp8HCTEI8HHOii 'IBCTI1
BeLql1, peaJIbHOHe BlWfMB I1IIOTOM)'HB3blBaeTCRJ1;QeaJIbHOii ( 1008-
1011). 3Ta ;QOJ!fl flBJUIeTCfl c:06crseHHOCTbIO, Ka COCOOCTB8HHI1K
I 5ingH.Sad1erTed"t.hl5tJscheKurz-LehrbOcher.34.AuII.7Verlagc.H BeckMUnchen 20W
. 20 Sa... F .SlUmer R Sachenrecht IB..neubearOeileteAu!lage_ VerlagCH Beck Munchi!l12000.
37

MomeT €1O, RaK" tlH,lJ)(BJfAYaJlblIDJl co6crBeHHOCTbKJ, CBof.:o;zuro pacno-
pmKaTbCR., B TOM 'll1CJle OTTb, 06peM€HJITb" B 1J,pyrnx 4:!OPMaX,
KOTOpb!e B03MO)KHb! ,ltJUI €l\Innmf'lHOfi: cr:6c'IBeHHocnf'.
B mBMeCTllOtt c06cTBeHHocTH e;:urnaJ'l BeI.l\b COCTaBJl.!I8T <JaCTb
MaCCbI,HeCKOJIbIGlMJJJ1[[aM,06'b-
eJ],HHeHHbIM O!1pe.n;eJ!eJIHOi.i CBH3b1O. B ar,neJlbHb!X CJIY'laRX CBR3b
MO»re'l' YCTaHaBJ!J1BaTbCR 3aKOHO,!\aTeJlbHO. XapaK'l'epHb!M,IJ,JIJ'I 6o.m.-
IID1HCTBa 0TII0I.UeHJ1H 06rn;ei1 C<J3ME'CTIIOiii c06cTBeHHocTI1 RBJlReTCR
TO, qTO OT.n;eJlbHble COC06CTBeHIDIKJ1 HH B OTHOIllEfItUl Bell!t1 B [[eJlOM,
HH B urnanelOO'l cBoei1.n;OJlH caMJCTOH'I'€JIbHO parnopJJ,!J,JITbC.H He MO-
rp. C yqe1'OM 3TI1X 0006eHHOC'I'E'ii: ,l\JIR peryJIJ1P0BaHJ1R om:crneHirn
COBME'CTHOJI Co6cTBeHHOCThl nplfMeHRIOTCJ'I HOpMb! 06 o6wei1 ZlOJIeBOii
006cmeocm.
OcHOBHble nCIJIC»KeHHH, payJlJ1:pylOll1e 06ll.JYKJ .n;OJIeByro c06-
CTBeHHOCTb B rrY, CBO,!\HTCH K CJle)I.ylOll\eMY. IIpHo6peTeID1e It yrpaTa
npaBa 06ll-\ei1: J\OJIeBoi1 CcfcrBeHHocTIl peryJJJ1pyeTCJ'I o6rn;m.rn: nOJlO-
>KeHI1HMI1 0 C06cTBeHHOCTl1. HecMoTpJ'l Ha TO 'iTO  928 ITY npe,nycMa-
TpHBaeT B03MmKHOCTb OTKB3B OT npaBa c06CTBeHHocTH Ha 3eMeJlbHbrn
y<JacTOK, eCJU1 3TOT y<JacTOK HaXOAl1TCJ'I B ,lP.JJ€HOi.i c06cTBeHHocTH,
OTKB3 OT .n;0JIJ1 HeBrJ:3MmK8H. IIepe,!\a'lB .n;OJlH Ha 38Me.JIbHHiii yqacTOK,
KaK It 1t3M€HeID1e .n;0Jrn, HylOTCR B HOTapillUIbHO $aBepeHHOM co-
rnallleHm1" peIHC'lpBQHl1 B IICI38M8.J1I:HO Kffi1re.
Boam1KHOBeHJ1E' npaBa CBH$blBaeTCJI C npHo6p8TeID1eM .n;OJIH, RQ-
TOpai1 Ka>fi,!\brn c06cTBeHHi1K caMOCTOHTeJ]},IO " He3BBt1C1U1£) MC»KeT
paCnOpJ'liKBTbCJI ( 747 II fry). Pac!1opRJKeID1e Belltb10 B [[eJlOM B03-
MO:)KHO TOJIbKO no pern€HHKJ Bcex COCo6cTBeHHJ1KOB " Tpe6Y8T e;:urno-
rnacHoroYTBep>K,!\eHl>1Jl
IIJlo,!\b1 ".n;OXO,!\bI.n;eJl.llTCH Mem,JZV roco6cTBeHHJmaM nponop[[l1o-
HaJlbHOt1X.n;OJIRM.
IIpaBO nOJlb30BaHI1R BelJ..tbKJ He CBH3blBaeTCJ'I C pa3MepOM .n;OJIJ1,
co6cTBeHHtlli .n;ame He3Haq11T8J1bHoi1 no pa3Mepy ,I\OJll1 MmKeT nOJlb-
30BaTbCH BeILlbKJ B nOJIHOM oG'beMe, eCJIJ1 3T11M11 .n;mCTBl'1RMl1 He Ha-
pywaKYl'CR 'ipe3MepHO npaBa 1J,pyrl1X coro6crnemooroB ( 743 II fry).
YnpaBJIeID1e BelJ..tb1O oCYll-\eCTBJIJI8TCH Coo6IUB BceIDI cdicTBemn1-
KaMl1, O,!\HaKO .l\BHHaR HopMa CtlJopMYJBIpOBBHa,JJ,HCIIO:3J1'l, " co-
co6crneHHtOO1 CBOHM cornarneHlfeM MOryr JCTBHOBJITb "Hoe Or.n;eJlb-
Hbrn coco6CTB€HHJ1K He }'IX)JIHOMO'l8H 3aKOHOM JIJIR emm
.n;eflCTBJrii: no ynpaBJIeHHKJ 06rn;ei1 Bell!bKJ Ha CBOi1 C'rpax" pHCK. 31'0
, t'21 Baur F Slumer R. Sachenrecht. le.neu basrbeIIeIe.l\ullage. VerlagC.H. Beel<. Munchen 2000.
38

npaBJ.1JlO HMeeT Mem;Jy TeM Ba:!KHoe J:lCKJllO'IeHI1e, comaCHo KOTOpoMY
Kam,IJ;bIi1 coc06cTBeHHJ1K MOmeT ocyru;eCTBJ1RTb ,lJ;ei1CTBI1H, He06xo.z:J.H-
Mhle ,lJ;JUI coxpaHeJn1II BeLItt1, 6e3 cornaclliI Cof.:cTBeJnunroB APYfl1X ,lJ;0-
nefi.3TI1,lJ;ejiiCTBJUIRJJ,oTex nop, nOKaynpaBoMO'leH-
HbIi1 BI1,!J;I1T B aTOM He06xo,D;J1MOCTh AJlR COXpaHeHI1.II BellVlJ ( 747 frY).
eHI1e MeponpH.R'l'lffi. no rnJIb3OBaHHK) 11 ynpaB.neHillO
YTBepm.n:aeTCJ'! 6o.nhnnntC'I'ElOOl r0J10COB. B t1HTepecax 061WIOCTI1 no-
pJ'!,lJ;OK ynpaBJIeIDUlI1 nOJ1b30BaHI1R MruKeT Kam.n;hIM crx:06c-rneHHlflOC)Jlol
6bITb nepe,lJ;aH Ha pa3}'MHoe ycMarpeRlle cYJJ.hl1 (745 I,ll frY). 3TO
ynoMJ'lHyroe oopaLJJ;eHJ1eRcY,D;he .fIBMeTCR npemm.'TBHeM,l\J1J'! yt.IJ;eM-
nemrn J1HTepecoB MeHblillfHCTBa B cJJY'Iae IIpJIHH'lHH pewemm, He
}"lI1ThIBBIOIQOO J:lX J:lHTepeCbL
3aKOH npeJJ;yCMaTpl1BaeT B03MmKHOCTh ,lJ;OOOBOpHOro YCTaHOBJIe-
IDIR nopJ'!JJ;Ka IIOJIb3OBBHIffi J1 ynpaBJleHI1JL 3aKJllO'lelille TaKoro corna-
memUl JIMff'T oc06ble nOCJle,nCTBI1J'! ,nM 05IJ.U1OC'I'H. TaK, JlIMeeT Ct1ny
B IJTHOIll8JIIDI IIpaoonpeeMHJD«JB ( 746 frY), HO OHO,n61cTBmenbHo
TOJ1bKO npt1 YCJlOBI1JiI era pemcrpaQt1H B nroeMeJ1hHOA KHl1re B pa3,lJ;e-
Jle «06peMeHeHt1J'! ,lJ;0JThI» ( 1010 fry).
Kam.n;hri1 J13 cooof.:c'rBeHm1 MruKeT BbI,ZJ;BI1I'aTb T}JeOOBaIDIe a npe-
RIXllit8H1B1 ofiIQoocTI1, npl1'leM Ha ,lJ;aHHOe 'Ip86oBaHl18 CpOK l\BBHOC'l't1
He paCIIpOCTpaWlE'TC.II ( 749, 758 fry). fIOCpe,lJ;CTBOM 3BK.JIlO'I8HIff
,QorOBOpa ,nalUIoe npaBo MOmE'T ObITb IIpJIOCTaHOBJIeHO Ha BpeMfl t1J111
HaBCer,l\B HCKJIlOIl8Ho. O,lJ;HaKO Ha IIpexpaLJJ;eHt1e 061WIOCTI1 no Bam-
HblM OCHOBaHI1flM aTOT ,nOOOBop He pacnpOCTpaIDIeTCR. B OTHOmeHl1t1
3eMeJlbHhIX Y'laCTKOB TaRoe COfJIallleHJ1e nO,lJ;Jleml1T perl1CTpaQ'lfJ:l
B II038MeJ1bHOJI romre ( 1010 fry).
ITY cO,lJ;ep:oorr TaJOKe B  752-757 no.n;p06Hoe perYJrnPOBalille
JJ;pyfl1X cnoc06C)B npeKpaLJJ;eHJ:lH 001WIOCTI1. B 'laCTHOCTI1. npe,lJ;ycMa-
T}JI1BaeTCR pB3,lJ;eJl BellVlJ B HaTYpe, lWTOpbrn: B03MruKeH, eCJIl1 3TO He
IIpJ1l!QIJ;IIT II: OOeCQeIDIBaHillO Bell\11 ( 752 frY). B npOTHBHOM CJI)"ffie
BeLqh nepe,l\BeTCR Ha npoMiKY, J:I pa3,lJ;eny nO,l\J1eiKl1T TOJIbKO Bbipy-
'1eHHaR cyMMa, IIpJ:l'leM Bell\h npO,lJ;aeTCR COrJlaCHO npe,nI!J:ICaHI1HM
a npo,I\ame 3aJlOiKE'HHoro J1M)TlQ2CTBB, TO eCTb no npaBl1JIaM a npJ,f-
HY,lJ;IIT8JIbHOIi npO,I\ame C ayKLIl1oHa. B 3TOT nepl1o,!!; ,lJ;OJI:lKHbI ObITb
npe;:rbJlBJl8Hb17pE'6ooamm.l!bl'I'€KalO1.W J13 OOH3BTeJlbCTB no nOBO,n;y
0611leii: Bell{l1 ( 755 II frY). HHble HopMhI ,lJ;ei1:cTBYlOT TaKiKe npJ:l
JIHKBJ1HOTHOllleHl1i1 roBM€CTIlQH c06cTBeHHoCTI1, Hanpl1MepB Ha-
CJle,I\CTBeHHblX 061WIOCTHX iii OTKpblTh1X TOpraBbIX TOBapl1lII;eCTBax.
39

K OCooblM <jJOpMaM.JIO,1l€BOA co6creeHoocTIl OTHOCRTCR: npaBO c06-
C'IBeHH0C'II1 Ha oolltee MMyr.u;eCTBO 0J6cTBeHmrnvB KBapTIfp, npaBO
CooCTBeHHOCTJ.f Ha It£'Hlfule 6}'ManI, IT'.
 frY IIJXiBOIIOpR.[IOK C TO'lliJ.f 3peHI1J'1 ypery.nnpoBBHl'fIl
rnaBHoro cJl}"iaJ'l npaBoBoi1: 051..W1oCTIf - OTHOWeHl1H 051l1ei1: CooC'I'BeH-
HOCTI1 - MomeT paCCMaTpl1BaTbCR I\aK BeHe J:a3Bl1TIffi npaBa o51l1ei1
c06cmeHHocTJ.f. 3To y.QaJlocb 3a C'1eT B3pall.J;l.fBaHI1JI He KOpIDIX PJ.fM-
CKOro npaBa HIJ,!J;Ii1 KOIIQ8IIQIIH o51..W10C'I'J.f, OCHOBbmalO-
ll.IeikHTaloKeHa HeMeLUWi1TpaJJ;Jll!JfiI.QoroBapJ.1BaTbCHAJjyrc AJjyrOM.
HeMH KOHQelIQ11JI 06ll.1ei1 co6cTBeJrnoc-m Y.QeJlfleT oco6oe BHI1Ma-
HJ.1e 06M J.1lITepecaM BJIa)\eJIbQ8B Bell{l1, :KpOMe TOro, 3HB'lJ.1TeJIbHO
paC1ID1peHbI J1 YCJ.1JIeHbll103Jll.\ID1 ME'HbIIDlHC'I'Ba, Kcrropoe J1MeeT B03-
MOiKHOCTb OTCTaJ1BaTb CBOJ.1 npaBa, B cJIY'18e eCJlJ1 co<neT npJ.1H.HTOe
i50..nbnmHCTI30M peweHl1e HeQeJlecoo6pa3HblM. 3TOT nopH)J;OK o51l1ei1
006crBeHHOC'I'I'1 HBI1J1CH xopowei1 OCHOBOt! .wm npaBOBOro perYJIJ1po-
BaHI1JI o6lQHocTI1 c06cmeHHJ.1:KOB )KJ1JIoro AOMa, KOTOpoe 6bLJIO ocy-
Il.If'CTBJi€H)B3aKOHe 1951 r.
ITOCJie paspyunrreJJHlblX nOCJieACTBId1 B-ropoi1: r.rnpoBOM BQi1:HbI
nepe)J; H8M8QKI1M rocyJlapcrBoM BCTa.rra ;nna'la CKqJBIrnero BOCCTB-
HOBJleID1H »G1JIJ1I.lIHoro 4>oH)Jp.. ITOCKOJIbK)' JIJUI BbllI0JIH8HJ1.II aTOM 38-
M'ill -rpe5CH!3.JlCH f.om,urnl cfu,eM 1pOBBHIDI. 6b1J1o peweHO
MaICCIfMBJThHO npJ.fBJIe'lb Cpe.llCTBa HaCeJIffU1H, ,l\JlH 3TOro HeOOxoroIMO
6b1JIo C03,.$Tb HOBbie 4x>pMbI co5cTBeHHocnl, KOTOpbIe HallJ,lIl1 ypery-
JIJ1poBaHl1e B 3aKOHe OT 15 MapTa 1951 r. «OnpaBe co6-
CTBeHOOCTtI Ha KBapTl1py»2 (.naJlee - 3aIl:OH) J.f npuo6pe.ml TeXIDl<iecKoe
Ha3BaIDIe «KBapTI1pHBH rof.:cTBeHHocTb> (Wohnungseigentum). ITo-
Cpe.llCTBOM 3TOi1: KOHCTPYX11I1 CTaJlO B03MOHbIM npl106peTeHJ.fe B
cof.:cTBemDcn, onpe.II8JI8mroii: 'laCTI1 .lIOMa, O.l\HOBpeMeHHo Qepe3 Bell.l-
Hoe o5ecne'ieIDfe BblI1JlaT, no 'laCTHM CaMOCTOHTeJIbHO clJJ.fHaHCI1pOBaTb
»G1JIJ1I.lIHoe CTpOI1TeJIbCTBO. HoBeJlJlbl B OCHOBHbIe nOJloeID1H 38KOHa
6bLID'J BHeceHbI,lJJ!YI11M 38KOHOMur 26 MapTa 2007 r. 3 C HOBeJIJIaMJ.1 2007 r.
nepeCTpoE'HblJ1ynpa3,QHeHbrMHorneHOpMbl,l\acalOeC-HynpaBJIeID1H.
BOJlblllee pacnpoc'!'pBH€IDII2nOJl)"lJ1JlB npDQe.IJYpa IIpIlliH'IWI pE'IlHIIrli:
6oJn.unrnCTBOM I'OJIOCOB. ITo BOBOM)' yperYJrnpoBaHbJ npaaOBaH npJ.fpo-
M o6IQHOCTJ.1 cOOcraennDlOB KBapTl1p, 'ITOcnoa:6CTBOOaJ1O nOHBJleID1IO
60JIbwei1: HCHOCTJ.f B lIpaBOBbIX OTHoweHl1HX Mem,rry 
'0.._ Grziv>otzH_ l<e<A<ensctwijl.erA. RingG, BGBSacI1enrecht II Konmenlar Band3;1j854-1296
1\uf\age22008_S,1000
2 Eiu>cIesrepltJIDeutschlaooGeseIzUberdasWomungseigen!trnuood..DaueIwohnrechtvomI5.Miirz
1951 (BGBI IS. 175.209J.
3 BGBL13101/IJEG2007
'"

,nonei1:. KpOMe TOro, onpe,neneHa C1l'B8'I'CTB8HH coco6cTBeHHJ1KOB
11 npOl,\e,Dypa paccMOTpemmCnOpOB BCyP,e.
B 1951 r. rnHBUmCh  I1pJf3HaBaTb oc06}'10 cc:6-
CTBeHHOCTb Ha OT,neJIhHble KBBPTI1Pbl I1J1I1 )J,pyrne nOMellteHMH, ).\JIH
aTOro OH'" paCCMa7pJIBBJIJICb B Ka'IeCTBe peanbHbIX 'IaCTei1 3,naHI1R.
KBapTt1pbl ,nOJDKHb! OblJll1 3aKpblBaTbCR Ha KJlKJ'I, KpOMe TOro, npe,n-
YCMaTpl1BBnOCb 05R3aTeJlbHoe caMOC'l'OHTeJIb1Joe ynpaBJI8H1le ,nOMOM.
IIpe,!.\MeTbI, 06eClIe<iI1BalOlW1e oe30naCHOC'l'b 11 Ha.n;e:IKHOC'l'b 3,na-
IUIH, a TalOKe}'C'I'pOAcTBa J1 o6opy,noBaHl1e, cny>Kall.\l1e 06llteMY yno-
Tpe6.neHmo, He Morn", COC'l'aBJUlTb npe.n;MeTa ocoooro npaBa c06cTBeH-
HOCTI1 Ha rrnapTI1py, a CTaJlI1 npl.f3HaBaTbCR OOllteif Cof.:crBeHHOCTbIO
Bcex COCOOCTBeHHJIKOB KBapTI1p. K TaKHM npe,1l.MeTaM O'I'IIOCRTCH. Ha-
npl1Mep, HeCYll.\l1e creHbI, nOTOJlKl1, neCTIlI1ln>!, CJ1CTeMa 1.\8H'IpaJ1bHO-
ro UI'CIlJI8HJfH, OKRa, rJ!aBHbIM 06pB30M Bce o60py,noBaHl1e, KOTopoe
npe,lJ;HB3Ha'IeHO JJ,JIR 06lltero HCII0JIb30BaH"'R coc06cTBeHHlIKOB. K 00-
ll{ei1cxfJc-rnemrocTJ1 He OTHOCHTCH .zr;B8PI1, non, MemKOMHaTHb!e CTeHbI,
Rampble He RBJUlKJTCH HeCYIl.\l1MK
TaKI1M 00pB30M, BHYTpI13,naHI1H .n;pyrOKOJIO ,npyra cOCYll\ecrB}'IDT
0611..\BH ,noneBaJI c06C'1'BeHHocTb 11 npaBo 006cTBemJJcTI1 Ha rrnapTJ1PY.
IIpaBoBoe oq,opMJIeJUle o TOJIbKO no ,nB)'M HanpaBJIe-
IDIHM: nepBoe - 3'J"O 0611..\BH co6cTBeHHocTb no ,non.IIM, perYJllfpyeMaH
ffY, 11 oco6oe npaBo Ha KBap-rJ1PY, KOTOpoe Henocpe,IJ;CTBeHHO CBH3a-
HO C 0611.\ei1 cof.:creeHHOCTblO. 3Ta CBH3b RBnHeTCH npaBOBOJI HeOOXO-
JJ:I1MOCTblO 11 IIpoRBJIHeTCH B TOM, 'ITO npaBO c:06cTnemIoc-m: lIB rrnap-
THPY caMO no ce6e HCKJIIO'l8HO, OHO C'lJITaeTCH 3aROHHnii COCTaBHOi1
qaCTbKJ ,nOJll1 B npaBe 001l.\ei1 ,QOJIeBOii co6CTBemrocTt111B :3,naHl1e. Ta-
RUM 06p83oM, co6cTBeHHocTb Ha KBapnrpy COCTOJ.f1' 113 HepB3pelillfMO-
ro .l\YaJIl13Ma oco60ro npasa iii ,IJ;OneBoi1 c:06crEeHHOC'I'I'L IIOJIomeHl1e:
superjlcles solocedit 3.n;eCb npaBOM8pm '.
Bo3InrnHoBeID:!e c:06cTnemIoc-m: Ha KBap-rI1Py B03MOmHO nl160 no-
cpe,!.\CTBOM :3aKJIIOQeHI1H ,nOroBOpa coco6CTs€lllD1KBMJ1 0 crpowreJIh-
CTBe ( 3), JIJ160 nOCpe,IJ;CTBOM pMJ.\ena yme cYII.\8CTB}'1Oll\erO 3).\aHI1H
(B). CorJIallIeHl1e B03MOmHO KaK B OTHOllIemm yme cYII.\8CTB}'1Oll\ero
3,namm, TaKI1BQTHOllIeHI1I1TOJIhKO coopymaeMoro. IIpI13TOM,nOJlmHa
ObITb coomot\eHa cpopMa c.n;emm, KOTopaH npe.nno.nameTCH JJ,JIR /1.0-
rOBopOB 0 IIepe.na'le 06H3BTenbcTB. KCOtQ.\aJI J.\OJIR B IIpaBe 0611.\e>1 /1.0-
neBOM cotSC'rseHHQCTI1 IIO).\JIemwr 06H3BT8JItHOH pentc'Ip3I.\I1Il1B OT-
,nenbHOM mlC'fe B II03eMeJ1bHOfi: KAHre (7).
'i9Ba,-,"F.SliirnerR Sachemecht 1B..neubearOeileteAu!lage_VerlagCHBeck Munchi!l12000.

IIpaBa C<J6cTBeHm8«JB KBapTl1p COCTOwr B EI03M())KJI()C' pacnopR-
mBTbCJI, n0Jlb3OBaTbGj'/ If IfCKJIIO'JaTb .npyrnx, He OTHOC'Rl1t>1XCJI K OOll.\-
HOCTI1 c:06cTBeHHJ.uroB KBaprnp ( 13). Co6cTBeHHrrK BnpaBe CBOID
c06cTBellliocTb OT<JYm,IlBTb, 05peMelLllTb .m150 J],8JDITb Ha 'laCTI1. AnH
oCYll.\eCTBJIemm pacnOpHm8H11H B pH,Qe cJIY'1BeB o corJIa-
cl1e 06utH0cTt1 cofx:rBeHm1l(OO KBapTJ1p JtJThI TpeTbero JU1!.tB (ynpaBJIH-
IDll.\ero)(12)'.
Co6cTBeHHI1K KBapTI1pbT 06H3aH cO.r\epmaTb B nopH,!J;Ke OOllt)'lO
c06cTBellliocTb 11 HeCTI1 paCXO.I\bT npcrropWBJHaJTbHo CBOe" ,[(OJTe ( 14,
16). DB MOmeT IfCnOJIb30BaTb CBOID KBaprnpy J'! OOllt)'lOCo6cTBellliocTb
TOJIbKO B TaKoi1 clJopMe J'! T€M CDJCOOoM, KOTOpbTe He BJI8Kyr npwnrne-
Hl1e Bpe.I\a .npynrn Coco6CTBeHIDIKaM. Hamm OH TaRme ,[Io.rrmeHJ'!C-
IIOJIHflTb pernemiH o6ll.\ero c06pam1H Co6cTBeHID1KOB ( 23 ff ), cy,[lOB
(43 If) J'! paCIIOpIDKeHIDI ynpaBJIillOll.\ero (27 If).
Omornemm c06cTBeHHI1KOB KBapTJ1p Me)K,.!\Y co60i1 npe.I\CTaBJUllOT
c06oi1 QTHOilieHIDI 06ll.\ei1.lPJTeBOti c06CTBeHHOCTM.. Otrn He CKOHC1py-
IfpOBaHbI KaK TOBaplli1\eCTBO, B KOTOpoM J'!CII0Jlb3yeTCfI KOHCTpyKQI1H
COOME'CTIIcU ccOCrneHHOCTII, nOTOMY '1TO COBMeCTH<UI co6c-rneHHOCTb
OCJiOmHReT arq)':iK,1:\eHl1e J'! 06peMeHeHl1e, tqJOMe TOro, B .ID1'1HO-,[IOBe-
plITe]lbHHX 0'I'H0Ili8HI'fH COC06cTBeHHJ1KJ1 He COCTOflT. B 2005 r. 41e-
,[IepaJIbHbrn cylJ; repMaHI1J1 CBOI1M peIlI8m1eM npl13HaJI '1acrn'1HyID
npaBocnoco6HoCTb J1 npoeccyaJIbH}'KJ npaBOCnoco6HOCTb ofuQHoc'n1
c06cTBeHHI1KoB KBap-rn p 1. 370 pellleHl1e n0JIY'lJ.fJIo pe30HaHc. TaKI1M
06pa30M, 06ll.\HoCTb co6cTBeHHJfKOB KBaprnp CTaJIa paccMaTpl1BaTbCH
KaK IOpJW1'l€CK08 JU10, ee npaBOCl1OC06HOCTb Ha K npaBo-
cnoco6HocTrJ: a HO CIIOC06HocThro R 6aHKpOTCTB}' ,[IaHHaH
06ll.\HOCTb He ofulB)laeT ( 11 III). Tenepb B HeMeQKOi1: lOP'f,lJ.I'f'I8I«Jtt
,[IOKTpIme If npaK'IllKe pa3.I\eJUlIOT IDpl1,!J;l1'JeCK}'KJJII1'IHOCTb co6C'rneH-
HI1Ka KBapnrpb! J1 npaBocnoc06H)'IO 06ll.\HOCTb cOOc-rBemn1KOO KBap-
THp RaK co6cTBeHHI1KOB ,[lone". 3aKOH HenocpelJ;CTBeHHO 3aKpelT.llHeT
IIpaBa :oITOro 06ll.\eCTBa ( 10 VI, VII).
IIpaBoBoe nOJIomeHl1e, a TaKmE' ,[IemeJIbHQCTb 06ll.\HoCTI1 pery-
JIJ1pyeTcR RaR 06ll.\I1MI1 npe.u.nJ1CaHI1HMJ1 3aKOHa ( 10 II 1), TaR
If CIIel1aJIbHb!M11 ero IIOJIOmemffiMVI ( 10 III 1), nOCJIe.r\Hlfe OOJIa-
,[lam nplfopuTeTOM. KpoMe TOro, 3aKOHO)¥lTeJIb npeP,ycMaTpl1BaeT
6IJ3M(QKHQCTb 3aK.JI1CN8H1ffi ,IJ;oroBopeHHOC'f8i.i Mem,!\J coCo6cTBeHHI1-
KaMl1, KOTOpbTe CO.r\8pJKBT o6R3aTeJIbCTBeHHble npe.I\ill1CaHIDI, pe'lb
'o.._GI"2I"'"tzH.A_Ri""G_BGBSachenrechtIlKommenl8rBancl3:!iB54-1296
Aunage22008.S.100B
1UttiJ1!lH.SachenrechI.JUristischeI<UI"2.Lehrb(jcher.34.AuII7Ver1agC.HBeckMiiJK:hen201o.
42

J.1)J;eT 0 pe1ll€JU1HX, npltHHMaeMblX np}! pa3,'J;ene 3,lIaHI1H IIJU1 3eMenb-
HOro }"IaCTKa, a TalOKe 0 pacnpe,'J;eJl€mm paCXO,'J;OB Ha cO,'J;epmamle
OOl1leiil: Be'--l-tM ( 10-12, 15).
YnpaBJI8Hlte 06l11ei1: Bel1\b1O  coco5cTBeHmmallrn
KBaprnp coo6ll1B. ecJ1t1 HJI 3aKOHOM, HJI cornaweHlleM He npe.n;ycMO-
TpeHO rome. PeweHlliI np}!HJlMalOTCH Ha OO'-'-tllX c06paHlliIx, KOTopble
,'J;OJI:IKHbI c03bIBaTbCH He pe:me 'IeM pa3B rOA' PeWeHJIH npwnlMalCITC.f.!
60J1blID1HCTBOM r0J10COB. ITpll He,!:(ocTaTO"IHOCTVl KBopYMa pellleHVle 113-
Ha'laJlbHO 1U1'lTCQKHO SnYr BbIBO,!:( cy,neOHofr. npaKTIIKI16bIJI OTpa:meH
B 3aKOHe WIepe3 HOBeJIJlbl 2007 r. ( 23 IV). Kam,Ilbrn co5C'meHHHK MO-
meT OCnapllBaTb HeCnpaB8.lIJIJJBOe. Ha ero B3rJIJl,!:(, p81lleHHe. J13MeHe-
IDIey:meperneHllilB03MO:mH.OTOJlbKOHa OCHOBaID1.11
e,WJHOrnaCHoro peweHlliI co6cTBeJnooroB ( 10).
o TeKYll.\eM COC'I'OfIIOOI 3,II,aHlffi. era co,!:(epmamrn: B J1cnpaBHOCTI1
J1 ynpaBJIeHHI1 06'--l-tMMI1 cpe,nCTBaMl1 3a6crrnTCH ynpaBJUOOJ.J..tJfiL OH
0CJll.\eCTBJLlleT TaKme perneHllil o6l11ero C06paHJ.IH, npeJJ:0CTaBJIHeT
emera)J;Hbrn: OT"IeT 0 paCXQ[lOBBllIDl OO'-'-tllX cpe,nCTB iii 3KOHOMJ1qeCKI1i1
nnaH Ha 6yJJ:Yl1li'li1 ro,n. Y MomeT C03blBaTb BHeO"lepe,'J;-
Hoe 06l11ee c06paHJ.Ie (26).
IIocKoJIbKY Cof:crBeHHI1KY nplllHaJlJlemwr 'laCTh 3J\aHI1.fI, a OTClOJ\a
BbITeRBeT npaBO ,nOJleBoi1 co6cTBeHHocTn Ha 06l11ee l1MJll\ecwo iii oco-
60e npaBO cofJcTBeHHOCTH Ha KBapnlpy, TO Hapywem18 coc06CTBeH-
IDIKOM cyIl.\eCTBeHHWM 06pa30M 06H3aHHocTei1, BblTeRBIO'-'-tIIX H3 ,naH-
HOro craTYca, UJ3BOJUIeT OCTaJlbHbIM  Tpe60BaTb
arqeHl1Jl era npaBa c06CTBeHHocTil Ha KBap1'IIpY ( 18). ComacHo
 18 WEG penreHlle 06 3'roM MomeT 6WTb npJ1HHTO 6o.nbunlHCTBOM ro-
nOCOB Ha 06l11eM co6paHID'!. ECIDI 7pe60BaHJ1e co6paHJIH He BWnOJIHH-
eTCH Co6cTBeHlillKOM CaMOCTOm'eJibHO. TO OCI'aJIbHble C06CTBeHHI1KI1
BnpaBe 06paTHTbCH B cy,n C XO.I\BTai1cTBOM 0 npclf3OOJJ:C'I138 npolte-
.AJPb1 OT'I)'lK,IIeHJIH npaBa Co6cTBeHRocrn fIB KBap1'IIpY nocpeJ\CTBQM
npoBeJ\eHJIH ny6JI11'1HblX TOprOB, KOTOpwe OcyIl.\eCTBJIHIOTCH cornaCHO
IIO.1J())K8HJOO npolteccyaJlbHOro Ko,neKCa repMaHlrn ( 19 I).
Cnopw 0 npaBax iii 06H3aHHOCTHx c06CTBeHHl1R'OB KBapTl1p Mem,!IJ"
cc60ii.. KOTOpwe BbIT8KalOT IiI3 o6l11HOcn:l I1J111 ynpaBJIeHIDl 06'--l-tMM
I paRee paCCMa-rpmaJlllCb B oco60M npoIf3BO,IJ;crne 1J.0-
6pDBOJ1bHOH no,ncy,QHOCTI1. Celi<mc C IIpI1HHTl1eM WEG 2007 r. TaKYle
cnopbl paCCMB'I'pURllOTCH cornaCHO  23 I1CKJIIO"iJ'1'IJIbHO cy,naMl1
nepBoi1 HHCTaHl\I1Il RBK 061l.\MM11 rpamJlBHCIa1MII Cy,IJ,BMI1. Cnopw OT-
'PrUttingH.5actIern..ht..Ju1:sIIScheKurz.l.Ehb.chet34.1\ufl.7VerlagC_HBeckMrld1en2010.
43

HOCttreJIUJO npe;nMeTa, CO.nepHIDI tfJU:! OO'beMa CneLl!taJIbHOI'O npa-
Ba COOcTBeHHOCTII lIB KBaprnpy, BCer.lla paCCMaTptIBB.IDlCb B OObNHOM
rpa:>K.LlBHCKOM npOl-1eCce'.
TaKJ1N! 06pa3oM, KBapt'WpHaJ'l COOcTBellliOCTb npe,lJ;llOJIaraeT npaBO
co5cweHHocrl111B 'iBC'J'b,aHeIlBKBapTIfpYKaKTaKOB}'!O, naroM)'
KaKKBaprnp.:3. caMOCTOHTeJIbII6e3 3.rtBID1R. CYJl-tecTBOBaTb He MIDKeT. Or-
CIO BbrreKaIO'J' oco6eHHOC'Tt'I o:}JopMJIeHHfl:n'Oro IIpaBaB ID1,I:(e .n:oneBO
co6cTBeIrnocn:l lIB 3)-1BHI1e B l-1E'J10M iii 3B\!eJIbHblii }"ffiCTOK, a TaIORe oco-
60e npaBo lIB KBapTIfpY. IIpl1'-JeM npaBO ,lIOJIeBOii cofJcTBeHoocTI.JIBJlReT-
CRHe06xo;:J;rnlolblMYCJIOBlileMoco6oI'OIIpaBallBKBaprI1pY.
'leMIiI 06wCWIeTCRTO, 'lTO.mOOO4>axr HB1CI1OJIH€ffiI.H 06H3aHHocrn, KD-
TOpYJO HaKJIa,!-lbIBae'l' 'iJleHCTBO B OOlWlOCTI1 coco6cTBemotlOCEl, BbITeKa-
IOll(e J13 npe)J;ID1caIDfJI 3BKOHa JfJ]JII perneIDfJI OOll(eI'O c06paIDfJI, BJIe<l8T
I1CKJIIO<letrne 113 OOll(HOC'Tt'I, J-1JIH KOTOporo .lIOCTaTO'lHbIM C'-IIITaeTCR pe-
llleHl1e, npmurroe 6oJn,rmrnCTBOM ron:OCOB.
IIpOl-1eCcyBJIbHOe nOJIO:1KeHl1e .lIOJIeBO 06ll(HOcu:I xapaKTep:vt3y-
eTefl IIpO npaBOcyO'beK'I'HOCTb1O.lIeKowpHe I1CK:vt Moryr
npe,ll'bHBJUlTbCR OT.lIeJIbHbIMJI COCo5cTBeHHI1KaMl>1.l1Jlf13aIl{lITbI o6ll(11x
I1HTepeCOB, Hanpl1Mep, T})e60saHl1JI, CBH3aHHbIe C He)-1ocraTKoM paOOT,
Ocyll(eCTBJUleMbIX B OTHOllleID111 06ll(ei1: BeIl-\l1, no .lIOrOBOpy nOJ\PH,Qa
no  635 rrY, -rpeI5oBa:HHe 0 npeKpall(eHID1 nOCnraTeJIbCTBa np:vt npl1-
<ll1HeHJ1}f Bpemi no  1004 rI'Y.
Or l1MeHl1 IIpBBOCOOCo6HO 06ll(HOCTI1 B IIpOL\€CC)'3JIbHHX OTHOllle-
HIDIX RaK 3BKOIIHbIii npe)J:cTaBI1TeJIb BbIcrynaeT ynpaBJ1HlOI1:!lni.. 113-
.lIep:1KK11 npotteccyaJIbHOro I1p(3'f3BO.lICT HecyTCOOcTBeHHIOO1 He RaK
co.ni1A3.pHbIe tp.JDt001KJ1, 3 no ,no.nHM. 3m cy,lJ;eOHaJ'i npaKrnKa HaIIIJIa
Ha cerQltHHlllIDtiii ,lJ;eHb aaKOHO)-1BTeJIbHOe arpBjf{eHl1e.
3.2. B03HI;1KHOBEHI;1E 1;1 PA3BI;1TI;1E I;1HCTI;11YTA
06L11EH C06CTBEHHOCTI;1 B WBEHLlAPI;1I;1
3.2.1. CTaHOBJ1eHllle III paSBIIITl.1e
npaBa o6L1.1ei:i co6CTBeHHOCTJ.1 B WBei:i4apllllll
CTaHOBneHl1e lllBei1l-1apcKoro npaBCIlOPHJJ:Ka 06ll(ej;i co6cTBeHHo-
crn DCyI1-1ecTBJlHJlOCb Ha 633e.llBYX 3BTOpUT€THbIX npaOOBbIX cYiCT8M
pMMCKOro npaBa iii HeM8l-\KCf'O. KpoMe TOro, lllBei1l-1apCXIDII 3BKOH0Jl3.-
TeneM 6bIJI COOpaH I1M3YIJeH npaBOBOft OfIblT perYJll1poBaHIDI .l-1BHHbIX
'CM.WlhelmJSachoo""'ht.3.neu.bearbeileteAun"IJe.Ber1in2011.S.77.
2CM. G-ziY.<>tzH.A..AingG.BGBSachemectrt/{l<ommentar. Band3;B54'I296.
Aunage2200B_S_I00<!

O'l'HOllI'HHii B COCeJlCTBYlO11U1X co IllBeJmapuef1 crpaHaX: 4Ipa,
J1TanID1, ABc:rpnl
ITpeJlnOCblJIKj,j 33.t1MCTBOBaHHH I103ttTHBHOro OITbITa peryJlI1pOBa-
IDIJ'I BI1,!\HTCH B aHaJlOru<IHOCTU np06neM, 1ro'IOpble B03HImaKtT npM
onpeJleneHirn nOpJ'l,!\Ka OOll\ei1: co6cTBeHmcTt1. OJlHaKO 3TII npOOneMbI
B03HItlCa]ltl B pa3HOe BpeMH J1 B pa3HblX COWffiJlbHO-3f<OHOMIf'-l8ClOfX
ycnoBuHX, n03TOMY I1)'TI1 J1X pernelD1J'1 He Bcer,na o,z:tlmaKOBbl. a OTnl1-
qaIO'l'CJ'I'.
IllBefllapCKoe rpa>K,l\aHCKOe YJIOmeHue (.IJ;anee - IIIfYf - aTO
1«))J;i'f$1I\8.lU1H lIeHTpaJIhHbIX <IacTeil llIBeill..\BpCKOrO 'iaCTHOro IIpaBa,
K KOTopbIM arnOCIiTCJ'I npaBO cyO"beKTOB, ceMeIDlOe npaBO, HaCJIe.n;-
CTBemIOe npaBO J1 Bell\HOe npaBO. 06R3aTe.nbC'T88HHOf' npaB0 3 BbIJl:e-
neHO B OT.l\eJlbHbrn: 33.KOH J1 CYll.\eCTByeT RBK .IJ;OIIOJIHeHtre K IIIfY.
IIII'Y pa3pa5aTbIBBJlC'JIno.n;E Xy6epano nopyqelD1lO
clJe.n;epaJIhHOrO COBeTa. Pa60Ta Ha,n: npoeKTOM 3B1«JH'U1JJBCb B 1907 roAY,
B 1912 roAYynmK€lD1eBC'l)'Ill1JlOBCmlf'
llIry Ha3bIBaeT ABe 4>opMbI oOll\eti: COfx.'TBeHHOC'TU; ,lJ;OJIeB)'lO (
646) Ii cOBMecTH)'ID ( 652). CneJ\YH TpaJJ;tD..\tBf HeM€1..IIIDH npaBO-
Boil MbICJlI1, }"D'J'TbIBB8TCJ'I pe3Koe pa3JIH'D'I€ ABYX BI1){OB OOll\ei1:
c06CTBeHHocTI1. Eo Bpewr C03J\aHI1H YJIOmeHI1H yqeHble pe,lJ;KO BbI-
CKa3blBaJII1 MHeHIiJl a Heo6xQll,J1MOCTtf  OO'-'-tl1X nOJlO>KeHirn
IIOJIXO.WIll\I,Cpa3Y)\JIH o5011X BI1){OB oOll\etico5cTBeHHOCTH. focnok
CTBYIOIl.\I1M MHeHl1eM TorJ\a 6b!JIO y6e}K,!\eHl1e, 'iTO J13Y'IeHl1e npIipo-
JIbI oOll\ei1: co6cTBeJrnOCTIf CBJl3aHO C J.fCCJIE',lIOBaHl1eM J\OJll.f B B8ll.\11
J1J11.f B npaBe. COBMeCTHaH co6cTBeHHOCTb xapaKTepI130BaJIaCb 'lepe3
,lJ;OJlIO B npaBe, TaR RBK Bbl,!\eJll.fTb ee ObIJIO HeE03MO>KHO. COBMeCTHaH
c06cTBeHHocTb npe.n;CTaBJIHeT co5oi1: Hepa3AeJIeHHOe npaBOMO'll1e,
KOTOpoe 06paayeTcH B peayJlbTaTe B03HtIKHOBeHtUJ OTH£JlIl8Ht1H co-
BM€CTHoii: oOll\HOCTI1, aaKOHOM orpalD1'i1eH Kpyr J\aHHblX OTHorneHI1H.
,lJ;OJIeBaH co6cTBeHHocTb npe.n;CTaBJIHeT co50i1: I1CKJIlO'1tIT8J1bHO Bell\-
Hble OTHOllleHI1H.
J1:ma'iaJlbHO llIBetil..\BpcKI1iii 3aKOHO.n;BTeJlb oprellTHJJOBaJICH Ha
HeMeL\KI1i1 OIibiT npaBoBoro perYJDtpoBaHtUJ B CMb!CJle C1pOroro pa3-
,lJ;enelD1H OOll\eH CcfcrBeHHOCTII lIB J\OJleBYIO 11 COBM8CTH)'IO. O,D;HaKO
HeKOTOpble J'lCCJIe,IJ;OBaTeJII1 UI'CTIlJ1BaJIl1 ID3I1l.\WO, 'iTO He06xo,!I;l1MO
'C..,:Some;<lerBDasBer",S1anpL1973.S.16.
 SohweizerischesZivilgesettbuchvomlO_Oezember1907SR21OInkralt1ratenaml Januar1912
'IJUIdesgeseIzvom30,,,,,"rz1911belreffenddieErganZUrIQde$Sd1wazenschenZM\gesel2tll.lc
tFiinfterTellSR220lnl<rnltrelenaml.JanuarI912
'C..,TuorP.SchnyderB..SchmidJ.Rumo.JungoA,OasScl1weizerische13,AuIIJaui
Grundder12_Aufl_t2(02)noobearb,underg.Ziiich.Schuhhess.2009_S,563

C03,1:laTb 06lIti'1e HOpMbL YIJeHbie t:!CKa.nt:! pa3HHLtY Mem,rry COBMecTHOi1
11 ,AOJIeI3Oii: COOCTBeHHOCTb, 11 J1X BHJ1MaHl1e 6bIJ1o cocpeAOTCI'IeHO Ha
B03MmKHOCTHl1eneHI1R BelIt"-
B HCTOpl1t:! pa3BHTI1R WBeih.\apcKoro npaBOnOpR,I:\Ka oOlllei1: c05-
CTBeHHOCTl1 MmKHOBl>l.neJUtTb,lJ,Ba nept:!o;zJ:a. IIepBblJ11V1I1J1Cf1CMOMeH-
TaUlIllBei1L1BpCKororpa>K.1:lBHCKOI'OynomeHl1Rt:!,I:lOCepe,l\IDIbI
XX..
C 50-x IT. XX B. Ha'n:IHaeTCH npC)ll;eCC peBJf3HIl J1HCTI1Tyra oDllIei1:
c06cTBeHHocTH, KOTOpbJi1: 03HaMeHOBa.n HaIJa.no HOBOrO 3Tana pa3BH-
TI1RJ1HCTt:lTyra.
3.2.1.1. OCHoBHble nonmKeHLilR npaBa o6ll1eiii c06cTBeHHOCTJ.1
IJ,O peBJ.131.11i1 LilHCTI.1TYTOB rpCl)f(,ll,aHCKOrO npaBa
3aKOHO,l\a're.nbCTBO 06 oOlllei1: C06cTBeHHOCTH.IIO peB>13ID1 50-x n.
XX B. xapaKT8RpKO MIW
CKOi1: lroH1.\8lIl.\1'Iett 06ll1eii C06cTBeHHOCTH. KOTopaH KOpWlMJII YXO,!JJ1T
B pl1MCKOe npaBo, r,n:e .110M npe,n:CTaBJiHeT CODOM mMOCTOHTE'JIbHblM
OO"beKT coo6o.n;m.rli B pacnopJDKeHIDf. Onpe.n:eJiemJre orpaHtf'18ID18
CBODO,!1;bl pacnopHmeHl1H BH)J;I1TCH B YCTaHOBJleHHOM B 3BKOHe npaBe
np8HM}'ll-1€CTBeHHOM nOKynKl1 ( 682 rurY). «C.IqJyI'OM CTOpoHbI, 3TO
.fIBJlfleTCfl TaKme .IIOKa3BTeJlbCTBOM HeraTJfBHOrn OTHoweHHfl 3aKOHO-
.IIaT8J1H, TaR KaK npaBO npet1M)'ll\8CTB€lfH(Jlt mK)'TIKl'l, IIOMI1MO npo-
'Iero, npecne.nyeT l.\eJlb Jll.fKBLU1H 06ll\HOCTH"', AHanolw-IHoii: l.\eJIl1
C.II)':>rofT npaBO Kam,n:oro coco5crBeHHlIKa npe,n:"bflBJLlITb -rpeOcmaID:!e
o npeKpalll8ID111 ODll\HOCTI1, TaKaH BOOMOJRHOCTb AOJDKHa DbITb eMY
npe,n:ocTaBJieHa. B cJIY'lae npeA"bJUlJIeHl1R TaKOro TpeOOBaHI1.R 3KOHO-
MJ1<!eCKaSi CTQI1MOCTb ern .IIOJ!H B Bell\M .IIOJ!)fQIa DbITb eMY B03Bpall\e-
HB, n03TOMY H€3aBIIClIMO OT BO.ID11JPYTI1X  mm no,l\-
ne:>rofT pea.nlf3Bl.\tDI ( 650). ECJII1 npO,l\aTb 110JlJO 6bIJ1o 1I8B03MmKH0,
OH Mor TpeOOSaTb npeKpallleHl1.H BCeM OOll\HOCTI1 C npO;zJ:Bmei1 B€ll\I1
t:! pa3.lJ;eJIOM I1pJtfu.tm!. OT npO,l\a>K11 nporrOplJ,l10HaJlbHO 110JIRM. ITpaso
npe,n:"bHBJiHTb -rpe6ooaHJle 0 npeKpalll8Hl111 OOll\HOCTI1 Morno DbITb
orpatul'l€HO )J;OroBOpoM CpOKOM Ha AeCRTb neT. .JlJ1.r.J0, npU06peralOIl\ee
110JllO, HeaaBHCHMO err OCHOBaIUUI He 6bIJIO CBR3BHO 3TI1MH orpaHl1'1e-
HlliIMJII, nOCKOJIbKy mill He  p8n1CTpaLU111 B 0038MeJlbHoi1
KHJ11'e.
CBIf,I:\eTe.1IbCTIUd IW,[I,JfBJ1lI,YB.1IbHOit crpYKTYPbI oOlllei1: c06CTBeH-
HOCTI1 HBJiHeTCH TalOKe CneWffiJlbHoe npaBo errl1eJlbHoro B.YIaJ],E'JIbl.Ia
110Jll1 Ha ynmpe6neml8, II01Ib3(BBIDI8 IiI npe.llC'I'BBHI'ebCTBO OOil\HO-
CTI1 COCo6cTBeHHHKOB, TalOKe npaBOM7D1H no npoBe,n:eIDIlO 06bI'IHbIX
'Schi1eode<BD;lsschwel>aJs<:t1eM\elgelturlsrecS,rn
<B

MeponpWITJ1f1 no ynpaBJIeHJ110 {648 I,  647 II). OJ\HaKO :'ITa t1H,!U:IBJ1-
.nyaJIJ«:nl'IernaR KOHltemum oOlllei1: co6cTBeHllOCTH orpaHWillBaeTCH
,nei1cTBt1eM npHHLIJ.1I18., cor.naCHO KOTOPOMY peaml3BLt£1H npaBa MmKeT
6bITb orpaHw-JeHa TOJIbKO Cytl\€CTB:yJOlJ.V1M npaBOM ,npyroro.l1J-l1la. Ta-
KJ1M06pa:mM,npl1peaJn13BL\J1l1o,IJ;HI1MnpaBanOTpe-
6JIeHl1H iii nOJTh30BaIDIH BeJltbIO B03M£»KHOCTIf no peaJIl13aL\l1I1 aHaJIO-
rWllib1X npaBOMO'lI1i1.npyn:1X coco6cTBeliHJmcE He Moryr yxy,nrnaTbCR.
llpaKT1f'18CK113'I'O npl1Bo,!Ufl' K TOM.}', "ITO n0JTh30BaHI1e iii nmpe6nemre
BelltJ.f B03MOiKHO TOJThKO no B3aMMHCMY cor.nacl1lO coco6cTBeHHmroB.
06bI'1HbIe  noynpaBJIeHJ11O Moryr6b1Tb OeHbI o,!!;-
IDIM coco6cTBemnlROM, TOJIbKO eCJIJ1 6oJrblIDlHCTBOM roJIOCOB HI1'Iero
,npyroro He 6bIJIO onpe.neJIe1£l. Ho B .rno5oM cJI)"Iae coco6cTBeHID1K,
0CYllleCTBJ1RH caMOCTOHreJlbllbl ,nei1:CTBI1H B OTHOWeHI1J1 BCe" Bell\l1
B l.\e.noM, MOmeT ,neikrooBaTb TOJIbKO B oOll\I1X mrrepecax.
TaKI1M 06pa30M, B peaJlJ13aL\l111 ynpaBJIeIDIR BCel1lB npJ1cyrCTBY-
eT ROJlJI€KTIfBHbrn: acneRT, 'ITO He CRameWb 0 npaBOMO'llU:I pacnopH-
)KeHJ:IR. IIoaTOMY pacnopmI(8IUI8 cBoefI ,nOJ1efi MC»KeT OC-yILl8CTB1lRTb
co6cTBeHHJm caMlX.'TOR'I"8JIbI, a ynpaBJI8HIl8 - TOJIbKO BCeMl1 coo6ll1a.
B l.\eH"Ipe np06JIeMaTHKJ:! oOlllei1: C06CTBeHHOCTI1 BCer,na CTOJ.:IT BO-
npoc06opramf3aL\l1l1nOPRJIRaynpaBJ1€IDIH.BcBH3I1CTeM, 'lTOIiIHC'TI1-
T)'T oOlllei1: cOOcmEtrnocTn RBJ1HeTCH npaKTIf'I8CI\I1 BOcTpe60BaHHblM,
l.\e.neax:Xipa3HO 3aKOHO;:J;aTeJIbHOe peryJIJllpOBaHl1e :noro Bonpoca.
EcJU:I Obl3'1'O'1' BOnpOC He nOJl.Y'lI1JI 3BKOHO;:J;aTeJIbHOrO peryJIJllpOBaHl1H,
JmCTl'lT)'T oOlllei1: co6cTBeJroocrn He HailleJI Obllill:lpOKOro pacnpocTpa-
HeHM B IIIBeih,\apI11:1.
IIIBei1:QapcKoe  3BKOHo,naTeJIbCTBO, oc06eHHo npaBo
co6cTBemioc'm:, 06eCn€'illBaeT CI1JIbHoe COl.\lfBJlbH08 cOJ\E'p*BID1e,
'iTO HaXOJ\1:IT CBoe npOHBJleH1:Ie TaKiKE' B npaBOnopH;:J;Ke oOlllei{ c05-
CTBeHHOCTJ1, r,[(e oc06bIe JnITepecbl oTJ\eJIbHOrO cym,eKTa HenpeMeH-
HO ;:J;OJImHbl Haxo,W!Tb 06paTH)'lO CBH3b C 06ll\11M11 HHTepecaMl1. XOTH
B l.\eJIOM lIIBei1I,\apcKoe rpaiKMHCKOe 3aJOCEQJ:IaTeJIbGTBO o6JIa.naeT
CJ1JIbHblM  xapaKTepoM, HO 3aNJIlO,IIaTeJIbCTBO 06 oOlllei1:
cdicTBellJlOCTI1 J\O peBJ13Ini J:lM He o6.n8J:\aJm
JL;rn npaBClDJ o6ll1eH COOCTBeHHOCThl no lIIBei1I,\apCKOM)'
rpaiKMHCKOMY KO;:J;8Kcy xapaRTepHB, npem,IJ;e Bcero, BbTCORaH OL\eHKa
 6o.rn.unfHCTBa. IIpI .fIBJUI€'TCH ynpaBJI8IDle
06ll1ei{ Bell\b!O COBMeCTHQ. 370 TpeoyeT IIpIfHHTlUI peIll€HUH B paM-
KaX o6ll\HocTI1. JL;rn Bcex Meponplumm: no ynpaBJIemUQ lIIBei1I,\ap-
CKoe 3aKOHOJ\aTeJIbGTBO J\O peBl1$JIH npe'!\ycMaTpJ.1BaeT, TaK JK8 KaK
J:I npaBO Bcex COCenCTl3:yJOIl\I1X CO IllBei1I,\apJ.1eH rocYJ\apCTB, BOmo
60JThllll1:HcTBa, 'iTO, 6e3YCJIOBHO, HBJ1HeTCH Cl1JIbHbIM IIpIf3HaK()M: KOp-

nopaTItBHOfi OpraHlf3alU1J1. ITpY! aTOM 6om.ImIHCTBO nOHl1Ma€TCR KaK
OOnbunmC'J'BO JUII..\ ( 647). TOJIbKO B ffi'IIOIl1EfU1Y! BamHblX MepO!lpY!R-
TY!i1:lIoynpaBJIeHIOOHeOfJxo.ltm,roKB<UIJ.l$1poBaHHoe 6o.milln1HCTBO,
KOTopoe onp 110 6o.m.unrncTBY nOJIe" Y! 60JlbWl1HCTBY .nY!u
O)J;HOBpeMellllo.
)];0 peBI13Y!11 lllBei1apCKJ1i1 npaBoIIOpR)\OK 06nteJf c06cTBeHHo-
CTY! pa3JII1'la.n 06b1'lHbl€ MepOnpl1JlTY!R no ynpaBJIeHJ110 J1 BamHbJe.
B.nY!TepaType Btd,!\eJLfIE'TCfl TaKme7peTbflKaTerOpI1.f1MepOllpI1.f1TI1i1
no ynpaBJIeHI110 - oc06ble, KacalOll\Y!ec.fI MeponpJ1.f1TI1H, CB.fI3aHHbiX
C OT'ry"m,IJ;eHJ1eM, 06peM€HeHJ1eM If J13MeHeHYJeM l.\€JlJ1 Ha3Ha'le-
HI1.f1 Bell\I1. 06b1'lHbie MeponpI1.f1TI1.f1 no ynpaBJIem1IO, B OTJlI1'lI1€ OT
BamHbIX J1 OCo6eHHbIX, 6bIJII1 O'leHb JlerKY! B ocyIl\eCTBJIeHI'JJ1, TaK
KaK Kam,D;bli1 COco6CTBeHHI1K Mor 0CYll\eCTBJI.fITb IiIX C8MOCTO.HTeJlb-
HO, ecJII1 60JIbllli1HCTBOM rOJlOCOB He 6bLJIO peweRO 'ITO-mmo IiIHoe.
BamHble MeponpM.fITI1.f1 MorJlI1 0CYll\eCTBJI.fITbC.fI 110 pellleRI110 KBa-
JlJ$I1uI1poBaHHoro 60JlbIlll1HCTBO (JillQa iii ,lJ;OJill), a oc06b1e TOJlbKO
e,lJ;IiIHorJlaCHO.
ITo,!\IMeponpHJl'I'H.Hl\olJfnoynpaBJIeHJ1IOIIOHI1MBIOTMepbl,
KOTOpbIe He Tpe6yKYr cneHblX 3aTpaT 11 BbiTeKaIOT 113 06bl'lHOro
I1CIJOnb3fJB8HJ.1flBell\I1 J1JI}'!QTHOCHTCH K MepaMxopOweroynpaBJIeHI1.f1
KaK He06xO)J}1Mble liIl.\eJlecoo6pa3Hble, B TOM 'lI1CJle OilMTa 110 1iIII0Te-
Ke, 1I0)J,!lepmaHY!e 1I0P.fl.l\Ka Y! TJL
BamHble Mepcnpwrarn 110 ynpaBJJetnm - 31'0 T€, KOTDpbIe He OT-
HOCRTCR K 06b1'1HbIM J1 oc06blM
ITocne,!\OBaTeJIbHoe BBe,!\eHY!e 1Ip1111Q1ffiB 60JJbllUIHCTBa J1MenO CBO-
J1M IIOCJJetICTBI'1M TO, 'lTO Mep0llpH.RTKR 110 ynpaBJIeHJ1IO, ,!\ame Te, KQ-
Topble HBJIffiOTCR Heo6xoJ:n:fMbIMIoI ,!\JIR co,!\epmaHHR Bell\I1, B Ka}fi,!\OM
c.ll}"-Jae 'lepe3 6oJIbwJmCTBO JII1l\ J1J111 6o.nburJmc1'EO ,!\oJlei1 Mor.n11 6b1Tb
6.1uo1poBaHbL ECJlli O)U1H co6cTBeHHJm J1Men 60Jle€ 1I0000BY!HbI,!\0J1J1 OH
Mor 6.nOKJ1poBaTb .nr06ble perneHY!R. AnR MeHl:lInffiCTBa 3T0i1 ofuQH0CTt1
e,I\J'2HC'I'B8HHl:lM BHXOlIOM J13 31'Oi1 ClrryawfJl6bIJIo npeKpaweHl1e 06w-
HOCTJ1.
Pa3YMeeTCR, Ha npaKTI1Ke B03IDmaJIa H 06ma.noBa-
HI1JI TaKI1X peW€HID-L B cn)"lae eCJUf COrJIaUleHI1e He 6bLJ10 nOCTI1rHYro,
I1JIYJ peweHY!e 6oJn.Illi1HCTBa He YCTpaJ1BaeT Kal(()l"()-JBI6o coc06CTBeH-
HJ1Ka, nOp.fl.l\OK ynpaBJIeHI1JI Mor 6b1Tb nepenaH Ha cnpaBe,!\JII1BOe yc-
MOTpeHI1e CY,!\bl1 iii TBKI1M 06pa30M 06maJlOBaH. Cy,!\e6Hoe peIlleHl1e
IIpJ1HJ1MaJIOCb TOJIbKO B 06bl'lHOM cyne6HoM npouecce, KOTOpbIi1 MeK
3a 1: 60J1bllli1e cyne6Hb1e li13,!\epmKl1 11 XapaKTepI130BaJlCH AJIH-
TeJlbHOCTblO cyne6Horo pa3futpaTeJlbCTBa. KpoMe wro, OH npe,!\no-
.naraJl 06H3aTeJlbHoe y<UlcTI1e a,!\BOKaTa, noo1'OM}' nOIlYJUlpHOCTblO He
48

I1OJIb3OBBJ1CJ1. TaKl1M 06pa30M, IlOJI())KttT€JIbH()e 3Ha'leHl1e 3T0i1 npaK-
TI1KI1 B 3Ha'lll'l'8.1lbHOii: CTeneHI1 yrpa'll1BaJlOCb.
AHamr3t1PYH IllBeJmaPCKI1fi npaBonOpJ'l;zJ;OK OOlltei1 CaOCTBeH-
HOCTI1 ,[10 peBM31111, MomHO CKa3aTb, '1TO lllB8J1u.apcKaJ'l OOrnaH c06-
CTBeHHOCTb no cpaBHeHl1lO C pl1MCKI1M npaBOnOpJ'l.I\KOM oollte" c06-
CTBeHHOCTl1, KOTOpbli1 B CBaeM KJIacCWl€CKOM Bl1.l1e 6bLJI pa3pa60TaH
KpaiiHe I1H,lJ;tIBM,llJ'3JIbHO, KBlpyeTCJ'I KaK nporpeCCI1BHOe pe-
rYJIHPOBaHt1e, nOCKOJIbKY HaWeJI 3aKpenJIem1e npl'JHQHI1 6oJIbllUIH-
CTBa, KpoMe WrQ, 6blJIa 3aKpenJIeHa caMOCTOJ'lTeJIbHaJ'lI\DMI1€'T8HlU'fH
OT,[IeJIbHOrO cocdX:rneHHI1Ka, l\OTOpbIii Mor no cBoeMY ycMUlJJ8lU1IO
ocyI.l\eCTBJIJ'lTb OObl'lHble Meponpl1HTI1J'1 no ynpaBJleIDIlO. ITo cpaBHe-
Hl1lO C repMaHCKI1M npaBOIIOpH.1U«JM lllBeilI_lapCKoe 3aKOHO,[laTeJlb-
CTBO 06 oolltei1: C06cTBeHHOCTI1 ,[10 peBJI3HJ1 MomHO pacCMaTpl1BaTb
KaKOTCTaJlOe'.
IIpu'IIIHbl OC}ll{8CTBJJ8HJUI. peBJI3Jm
1. Oc06eHHocTIt npHIIIeIIeHJUI npllHluma60J1blilllHcTBa. IIpl1MeHe-
IDle nptrnQlffia OOJIbUIl1HCTBa caMO no ceoe nepe;zJ;OBoe npe,lJ;l1I1CaHl1e.
Ho ero O,!\Horo He,[lOCTaTO'lHO AJIJ'I HcpM<UIbHoro 1H
OTHOWeHJ1i.f06lltei1: TaKKaK3TOHecnOCOOCTByeTnpe-
,QOTBpallteHillO enopC)B iii Ka'lecTBeHllOMY CO,[lepmaHliIlO BeLql1. OH
co6cTBeHHrJK, eCJIII OH HaCTal1Ba8'l' Ha npoBe,I\8HHJ1 Meponpl1H'l'lllii: no
cO;zJ;epmaHIiIlOIil06HOBJIeIDIlOB. B cJIY'lae eCJIII era He nO)I.!\epmaJIII
OCTaJIbHble coc06CTBeHHI1KIf, He J1MeeT maHCOB peaJll130Ban. 1iIX, Kpo-
Me KaK 3a CBOii: C'leT. B cJIY'lae eCJII1 3TOT CocoocTBeHHIiIK rOTOB 3a CBOi1
C'leT OC)'IlI8CTBI1Th H MeporrpWlT!1.H, O,[lHaKO OCTaJIbHbJe
BCe paBHO BblCryIIaIOT npaTJ.m, 31'0 paCCMaTpl1BaeTCH Sit 3JloyrrOTpe-
6JIeIDIe npaBOM J'! COrJIaCHO  2 llII'y OH MomeT OOpaTJ1TbCH K CY;zJ;be.
CY,QbJI CB0I1M peweHlileM MOiK8T neraJlJ130BaTb OCHH8 ;:ITIiIX
MepOIIplilHTl1i1. O,l:lHaKO oOpa1.QeIDIe K cy,[lbe 3TO 1OJ:l1,IIH'I8CK11 CJIom-
HaR, ,[IOporocTOHU.laR iii ,WJIfl'E'JIbIIa npoQe.u;ypa, KpoMe Toro, aHa He
crrOCo6cTByeT yttpeIlJlemUQ crm:CI1Iemrn B 06LqHOCTIii.
TOJIbKO OObl'lHble MepoIIplilH1Wl no ynpaBJleHl1lO cocofx.-rBemDm
MomeT ocyIl(ecTBJUlTb caM, ecJIIiI6o.m.ImrncrBnM I'OJIOCOB 31'0 npaBO He
6bIJIO OTMeHeHO. JWiK8 eCJII1 paCXO,[lbl Re3Ha'lll'I'eJibHl:l a Meponp:vm-
TJ1H I£diX(),IJ;lfMbl, Bce paBRO 6o.m.unm:CTOO MorJlO npe;zJ;OTBpaTI:lTb 3TO
pellIeHlile, 'ITO B KQHe'lHOM IiITore MorJlO nOBJIe'lb rn6eJIb I1JIJ1 nDp'l)'
BeLql1.
2, CJ1O""MHOCTIii c npnHH1'JleM perneHJn1. ()qeHb pacnpocrpaHeHHbIM
HBJlHeTCHCJIy'laHo6wei1:.KOrLIa BHeH HaC'llITbIBaeTCH
'e"',Scme";IerBOassctYwe;zerischeBem.Sta/rPII1973.S_41
49

Bcero ABa cocofJcTBeJnuma. B aTOM c.lI}"-Jae rOBopwrh npe 6o.m.Imnr-
CTBO He  B03MroKHbIM, TaK RaK no,n; HMM nOHMMae-rcH
fJoJIbnntHC'I'BO IDII+ 31-0 ocooeHHO OhLJIO aKryaJIhHO]J,JIII oCYll-1eCTB.ne-
HI1.II OOhI'IHh!X MeponplUil'Jrii: no ynpaBnellJ'Il0 Be11U>lO, nOCKOJIhKY OHI1
MOryr ocyIl\E'C'I'BJU OT,neJIhHhIM coco6cTBefnn1KOM, eCJU1 6o.rrh-
lliMHCTBO He pellll1no I1HOro. B ornlCaHlYJd HaMI1 c.lI}"-Jae 6o.m.Im1HCTBO
pelill1Th I1HOro He MOJoKeT no npwrnHe era OTCyrcTBlfH.
BC.lI}"-JaeKBanoro60JThlID1HcTBa(nonl1QaMI1,noJUlM)
npmurrue peWeHI1H npl1 Hecornacrn1 JII060ro 113 COOCTBeHHI1KOB TaK-
*"-
EcJU1 co6crBeHHJ1K()B 60JIhwe '1eM ABa, HO 0.n;H0M)' npJIlla,AJlemJ:IT
nonomrna ,nOJH1 B B, <:ITO TOJoKe Be,n;eT K ero MOHOIJOJIJIC'I'ecKOMy
IIOJI())!{€flJO, 'lTO, npl1BO,!U1T K OTCyrcTBIOO npaBa Ha 11ID1lU"amBHhIe
 co cropOHhI APynrx COCo6cTBeHIrnKOB
JI3MeHJ1Th 31}' CI1T)'BQllllO MOJoKHO 6hLJIO TQJIhKO nocpe,!J;CTBOM 06-
paLQeHl1.II K cy,zr;be, 'ITO, KaK YJoKe UI'Me'IBnOCh Bhlllle, 6hLJIO He CaMhiM
y,n06HhIM cnoco6oM pa3pewemm mH$mf1ITHhIX CJf.
3. (}rcyrcnn1e Ha,n;JIemaJIJ;cro Kpwrepml OTHOCI[H'J1bHO pa:D]l3HU-
'IeHiUl McponpuHTuif no ynpaBJIeHllI{) Jtmyll1eCTBOI\I lInH pa3rpaHI1-
'leHHH MeponpJ1.1ITI1JI no yrrpaBJIeHIIIIQ B811U>1O 113 8BC"Ip11iicKoro npaBa
6hlna3aJ1MC'I1!CB3.HBKJIaCCl1m.,l\eifcTBJm:
no ynpasnemno ua o6bI'lHhle 11 saiKHhle. B lIIBeifqapeKOM npase 3Ta
,l\lIIrpcpepeHQJ1aQl1H I1CDOnb3yeTCH B 3peH,!\e ( 263 IlIry), s naXTax
( 284-2135 IIIry), a TaKJoKe npl1 UOJIh30Baffill1 ( 765 IIII'Y). B :3'I'11X
npaBOBbIX OTHOIIl€HI1.IIX CO,l\€pJKBHllle seLQl1 np8,l\ll0JIaUl€TCH. }J;OTIOJI-
HillTenbHO pernaKITCH BonpecbI no €HUKI MepollPHR'I11M no
co.n;epJoKaHI1lO selQl1l1 pacnpe,!J;eneHI1IO pacXO.n;OB. rIo.mmreHtre I1HTe-
pecOB s o6LQeif C06cTBeHHOCTIII HeCKOJIbKO OTJIWffi.eTCJI, TeM He MeHee
eCTh 06LQ11e npo6.rreMhI RaCaTeJIhHO CO;nepJoKaHl1H BeLQl1. rIpl1 COCOO-
CTBeIlliOCTII ;D;OJDKHO OhITh rapaHTlllpoBaHo cOJ\epiKaHllle BeLQl1, a He
KaK B apeH)J;e npe)J.llOJlBl'B.Th0l. BTophIM ;nOJDKeH OhITh onpe,!J;eneH BO-
npec 0 KOMI1eTeliltID1l1 pacnpe.n;enelD1l1 paCXOJ\OB.
Korna co.n;epJoKaHHe BeLQl1 rapaH'I'I1pOBaHO, TOr,l\a MOJil:HO I1CnOJIh30-
BaTh 3TY KJIaCCMq.&1KaQHKI Ha OOhI'IHhle 11 BaJoKHhIe. EcJU1 rapaHTIDI He
;D;aHa, Tor.na TepHeTCH CMhIcn o6LQeM co6cTBemucTI1 KaK,lI,IDI'I'eJJbH
OTHOllI8HIm 11 MOJoKHO ee npocTo HCIlOJIh30BaTb RaE: nepeXQlU1l;lit 3Tan.
06I1..\BH COOCTBeHHOCTh co.n;epmwr nareHLtl1aJ1 .r:tJ!I1TeJIhHhIX OTHowe-
HIIIM, n03TOMY TaKaH rapaHTI1H J\OJ!JoKHa  rapaH'I'I1H
co.n;epJoKaHI1H 06LQei1: BeLQl16y.n;eT TOJThKOTor.na, KOr,lla Kam,!thlM COCOo-
C'l'BeHHl1K6Y,!J;eT BhIHYJiI:,!\eH ReCTI'! pacXOJ\hI nOCOJ\epJoKaHJ1K). Pa3rpa-
HJ1'{8Hl1e MeponpwITI'!if no ynpasneHl1lO Ha o6bI'lHble 11 BaJoKHbre He 1J.O-
50

CTI1raeT lIeJU1 B pa3Ip3lU1'1E'HttM KOMlleTeHW111, nOOTOMY He06xo)J,l1MO
6bLnO C<pOPMY.ID1pOBaTb JWYI'OIf Kpl1Tepl1i1. B Ra'!eCTBe TaKOBoro IIC-
I1O.IIb3OBB.J1CJ1 np"HWffi JlO..1I())f(€}U1fI JlHTepeCOB 06Il\efr. C06cTBeHHOCTI1,
a J1MeHHO co.n;epmaHl1e BelltJ1MOJoKeT TaR.lIOJIrO, RaK
no KrxUWm Mepe O)J,l1H co6cTBeInrJm aTOm XOqeT. ECJII1 O)J,l1H 113 CO-
c06CTBeHHl1KoB XOqeT  Meponpl1RTI1fi no co.n;epmaHI1IO
Bel1tl1, TO era >KeJJam18 JJ,OJDKHO 6bITb rapaHTI1poBaHo. ,D;oJDKHa 6bITb
yc'ffiHOBJlEflB 3aKOHo.n;aTeJlbHafi BOOMOmlJOC'Ib npe,QllpJIHm4BTb .lIei1-
CTBJilfi npoTI1B 6o.m.rnHHCTBa. TaR, OH .lIOJDKeH oc TaKl1e
MeponpJ1HTlli1, B KOTOpbIX BeIl\b HYe'l'CJ'l, ,lVlJ'I TOre 'IT()6bI ee no-
Jle3HbIe CBOI:fcma He TepJLm1Cb.  .lII1t}xPepeHl..\l1al.\J1fi Ha
I1O.1l83HbI8 J.1 poCKOlillible MeponpJ1HTlli1 - 3T0 CJIe.UYK!nnnf Ma.n8HbRHtf
llIar B aTOM HanpaBJl8mm
Pa3Jll.RY!eMeponpJ1JlTffi1MCOKHo06HaPYJoKI1TbIlB.lIPY-
rnx 06.nacT.RX '1acTHoro npaaa. 1MEp. I«JMlleHCBl.\WI H
pacXO.llOB npl1 ocyu.teCTBJIeJOOf lC1'BJ1Jf B '1J"KOM MlIT€pece, npl1 He-
OCHOBaTeJlbHOM oOOrau.temnl, .lI06pocoaecrHOM J.1 He,D,06pocoBeCTHOM
BJIa,D;elOOl II TJI. Bo Bcex HB3BBHlll:lX c.nyqaHx OIIp8.l1eJIHeTCH, He-
06xo,lU1MHe IDI <:ITO 6b1JIJ.1 paCXO.llbl II RaK}'KJ cyMMY OH .lIOJIJoKeH B03-
MeCTJ.1Tb. IIaparpBIiJ 422 06R3aTenbcTBeHHoro npaBa perynl1pyeT
nopR.n;oK B03Mell.\eHI1H arnx paCXO,!:(OB, 3aTpaTbJ Ha He06xo.lll1MbIe
II nOJle3HbJe MepOnp"'HTI1H ,IJ;OJlJoKHbl 6blTb B03Mel..l.\eHbI, Bce APY-
me ynY'JllIeHJ.1R JJ,OJlJoKHbl 6bITb nepeABHbl B c.nyqae J.1X OT,IJ;eJlJ.1MO-
C'm. IIpl1po,!:(a cl.fTyal.\l1J.f TaKOBa, '!TO paCXO,!:(bl B03Mell.\BIO'I'CH nocJle
TOro, RaK ,!:(ekTBH.H 6bIJIJ.1 ocyu.tecTBJleHbl. B 06ll.\ei1 co5cTBeHHoCTM,
HanpOTI1B, CHa'IaJla orGBapMBaKYrCH BI1)U>I ,IJ;ei1cTBI.fi1 II pa:3Mep pac-
XO,!:(OB. B TIepBYlO o'!epe,!:(b <:ITO RaCaeTCH ,!:(eikTBmf no coxpaHeHMlO
CTQIIMOCTI'J II B03MOJoKHOCTY! IIC1lOJlb3OBaHY!R Beu.tY!, '!TO 11 HBJlReTCH
KpJ.1TeIJl'leM pa:3rpaHMQeHI1R KOMneTeHQI1I1. Bo BTOp}'KJ o'Iepe.zu, pe-
maeTCR Bonpoc 0 pacnpe,IJ;eJleHY!11 pacxo,!:(OB. &rOT np"'HQMn IIMeeT
MO,!:(Y!c}:IY!L\"'pOBaHHoe ,IJ;€i1cTBMe, TaR RaK pacnpe,QeJleHl1e paCXO,!:(OB
IIpHHLII.fI1I1BJlbHO OCHOBaHO no ,IJ;OJIRM. Cnoco5HOCTb II: MO.I\MclJI1Ka-
QMM <:ITOro Kpmep"'R npoRBJlJleTCR B TOM, '1TO MOJoKHO OTCTynMTb OT
pa3Mepa ,l\OJlei1 npM pacnpe.I\eJleHMM paCXO,!:(OB I1CXO,l\R 113 CTene-
HJ1 nOJle3HOCTJ1 MepOrrpI1HTI1fr. ,l\JlR KOHKpeTHoro COc05CTBeHHMKa,
KOTDpbli1 B 3TI1X Meponplfffi'HHX ,l\JlH nOJlb30BaHMR 06Il\efr. Bell.\blO
60JlbllIeeTCH..
4, B Ka'IeCTBe npe,D,IJOCblJlOK 113MeHeHMH 3aKOHo.n;aTeJlbCTBa 06
06ll.\ei1: C06CTBeHHOCTI1 M01KHO TalOKe BHJ\€JIIITb HC34xtJCKTIIBHOCTb
rOCY,l\apCTBeHHoii nOMOU\ll np" B03HIIKHOBelOlli cnopHbIx Cl1Tya-
1rL

IIpaBO 6a.m:ruuHcTBa coco6cTBeJuooroB 3anpernaTb I1JXE8;I18lU1e
,l\ame He06xQ[UtMblX MeponpJ1HTIfJI HBJlJ'IeTC'J'I, RaK yme OTMe'la.rrOCb
Bblllle, HeraTl1BHOfI cropoHofI 3aKpen.neffilJ'lI1pJ1HQJD1a 6o.millnfHCTBa.
Ha npBIm1Ke TalGfe JlCKJ1 I1pJlIDIMaIDrb, J1 CnpaBe,!l.JU1BbIMYCMarpeHJ1-
eMcy,!J;bM onpe,!J;eJlHJICJI nOpRAOKyrrpaBJIeHl1ll BeIltbID  m.IJIOHeO'leHb
O, TaKl(aKm.IJIOCBJt3BHOCIDlXOJlOI1I'18C1O'IM1fJ1MaTepl1aJIb-
HbIMJ1'Ipy,l\HOCTlIMJ'J, KO'fOpbIeCOnpo :nmnpoU;ecc. IIpoU;ecC6bDl
,l\OCTaTO'lHO,lT,IDITE'JIbHb,cy,!J;e6HaHnOMOlD;bHe6b!Jra
Ell.\e O,!J;HI1M He,!J;OCTaTKOM craporo 3aKOHO,!J;aTeJIbCTBa HBJlHJIOCb
Tpe60BaHMe e,!J;I1HOmaCMH,l\JlJ'I npulUmm pewemrn a IIpoBe,!J;eHl1M pe-
MOHTHbIX 11 C'qxUITeJIbIillX MejXUJJUHnOC
lIJlJ'IIIpoBe,!J;eID1H BamHbIX MepoIIJ:HHTIwynpaBJIeHl1H, a TalOKE',l\JIfl
6oJIbworo peMOHTa "IpeOYeTCH RBaJIJf<l»fL!JtpOOBHHOe 6oJIbllll1HCTBO
(no JIH'-ViM It ,!J;OJIHM). lIo peq>opMl1posaHHH 3aROHO,l\3.TeJIbCTSa
sonpoc 06 OTHeCeHl111 CTpOMTeJIbHbIX 11 peMOHTHbIX MepOnpI1HTMi1
K ROMIIeTeHL\1111 KSaJII1<l:>"U;lpOBaHHoro OOJIbWI1HCTSa 6bIJI cnop-
HbIM, 11 H8KOTOplde }"IeHbIe 0TCTaI1J3a.JIH n03Jfu;HlO a Heo6xo,n;J1MQCTJ1
e,lJ;l1HOrnaCmr AJI.H oCYll.\eCTBJIeHJ1H TaKl1X Meponpl'1llTl'nl.. q8M Aopome
6blJII1 MepoIIpJ1JITI1R, T€M 6o.m.we BO;3M(J)KH()CTb TOro, 'ITO KTO-TO Ha-
JIO:lKl1T sero lIB I1X oemle. IlIry OTBeTa lIB :nOT BOnpOC He
,l\asaJI, 'ITO «CI!IWffiJIhCTBOB3JI 0 HecKOJIbliO npeHe6pe»o1T€JIbHOM
OTHOllI8HJfH R ,lPJIeBOi COOCTBeHHOCTI1. 3aKOHO,!J;aTeJIeM OT,!J;aBaJIOCb
IIpeAIIO'ITeHl1e COBM€CTHOfI C(ocrBeHHOCTJ1» '.
IIocKOJIbKY 06ll.\BR cd5cTBeHHOCTb - J1JICTmyr, BOC1pe6OBaHHbn1 Ha
npaKTl1Ke, HeoOXO):tl1MO 6b1JI0 HaWm cnoco6 perneID1H aTOi1: npofuIeMhL
KpoMe TOro,  m.1JI0 S03po,!J;J.1'I'b IIO!l)'JIHPHOCTb 06ll.\etf c06-
C'J'EIeHHJC'I'R3aKO'fOpofIpen'jTal.\l1RamHJMJ:flI8CKCJfi:HeBbI-
ro,!J,Hoi1, 'ITO m.IJIOCBR3BHOB TOM 'II1CJ1e J1 C IIpOOeJIaMl13BROHO,!J;BTeJIbCTBa.
5. Orcyrcmue a4xPeKTlfBHbIX B03MOmuOCTeU npmII8HeHHH caHK-
L\uft: npoTlIB q.ofu.eRTos. OTRB3bIBalOlllI1X B npUHHTI1It pell1eHuft:. XOTH
S DCHose llIsei'll.!apcKotf 06ll.\et'1 cc:fJcTseJnIx:rJ 3aJIO:lKeHa pl.fMCKaH
ecKaJI KOHLIeIIJJ;I1JI. T8M He MeHee COCo6cTBeHHI1KJ1
06pa3YlOT 06UUJOCTb, '1ro Tpe6yeT B3BJ'2MHOI'O BHI1MBTeJIbHoro OTHO-
llIemrn. OrnoweIDI.11 OOUUJOCTI1 B 6oJIbIill1HCI'se cJIY'1aes "Ipe6ylO'r 06-
xAeifc'Im1l111J111 AE'J1cTmrli: B O,!J;HOM 06ll.\8M HaIIpaBJIeHl1Jf, AJlH TOro
"IT06bI He npH'llIHJ'JTb spe,!J;B sell.\l1l:1 He OTpaBJ.fTb O'TIIOllIeHWI Mem,n;y
coco6CTBeHHI:!KBMI1.
IIpl1Hrurn SJU1MaTeJIbHOI'O J1C1IOJ1b3OBBHWI npaBa,  OT-
paiKelUte B lIIsefu.{apcKoM npaBOIIOpH)J;Ke, 3aKJllO'laeTCR B TOM, 'ITO
'S<;hi1e<der.S_57
52

HapymeHl1eO)J.Hl1MI13COC cfuI3aHHocorH BHJ:IMaTeJIhHoro
0TH0lll8HJ1H APyr K APyry 11.ID1 K CJIOBaM .n:pyroro .n:OJDKHO BJIe'lh Ha-
CTYTIJleln1e ,[\AA HapY!ID1TeJIfl HeraTI1BHhIX nOCJIe,[lCTBlm.. JJ;eAcTBJ1R,
HapymaKJIIJ.I1e 3TOT m, Moryr BhIpa>KaTbCR B npenR'l'CTBOBa-
IDII1 D'I yrBepm.c:eHHhlX C06cTBeHlIJ1KaMI1 MeprnplfH'i1'rli,
npoBOKaLtJ.1l1 CnOpoB, K€H'I'pBQIflf TOJIbIW Ha CBOI1X 3roUCTIf'l8CKlIX
JIIHTepeCaX, 'ITO npl1BOiU1T K HeB03M())KH()C'l npo.n:OJI:IK€HWI O'THorne-
IDIiI o611\ei1 C06cTB€HHOCTI1. OrHorneHI1fl 061lU10C'J'11 Bcer,n:a COnpOBO-
)K,[IaKJTCfI pl1CKOM nOJI)"II1Tb acOWIBJIhHOro napTHepa, B CBR311 C '1eM
nonympHocTb 0611\eil co6cmemrocTJl erpa.n:aeT.
3aKOHo,!:(aTeJIhCTBO IliBeth.\apmf .n:opem13HOHHoro nePJfO,!:(B HJ.fKB-
Kom BHXOJJ.B ,nJIfI C06C'J'BeHHJ1KOB KpoMe npeKpaHI1.FI 061lU10CTI1 He
npe,DyCMaTpJIBBJIO. Co6c-meJrnJ.na. MOrnl1 TOnhKO npoTh CBOKJ .n:oma
nl160 Tpe60BaTh npeKpall.\emrn 061lU10C'J'1111 He npO,!:(OJI>KaTb ,/.\BJIhwe
OTHOlll8lDlR co6cTBellliOCTIL IIpaBo npeIlllirn nOKynKI1,
npe.DYCM01p8HHoe 3aKOHo,!:(aTenhCTBOM IliBeth.\ap"l1, C03,!:(BnO 6.naro-
npl1f1'THYJO no'lBY ,nJIR TOro, '1T06h1 acoI.\RB.1IhHl>rii C06C'J'BeHHI1K CTaJI
e,n;>mCTBeHHhIM co6cTBemn.rnoM. «l13MyqeHm.nl» coc06cTBeHHI1K, KQ-
TOpbll1 6hlJI 3al1H'I'epeCOBaH B I'1CIlO.JIbaOBBHffiI Bell.\l1, Bhlliym,r(eH OT-
C'IpBIDfI'bCJI OT C06cTBeHHOC'J'J1. 3To IIp8,!:(CTaBnfleTCfI HecnpaBeMI1-
BhIM, 60nee pa3)'MHh1M mJ,lJ,JITCH y.n:a.rreHl1e aaJl,\JlBJlbHOfO co6cTBemul-
1\.8. B npOTI1BHOM cnyqae Hapy1lIBeTCH npffilQI1ll Cne,D;OBamlH CaHKWfl'!
TOJIhK03BBJrnOBHblMl1'.
He,!:(OCTaTKl1 3BKOHO,!:(BTeJIhCTBa, .n:eilCTB}'lOll.\erO,D;O peBI13I1I1, CKOM-
IDlJIJtpOOBHHhIe Bhlrne, HOCI1JlI1 ceJ:b83HHii xapaKTep. Ho CCHOBHOi1
npeJlTIOCbL/IKOII ocyw;eCTBn8H11fl pEffi13W1 6WIB  C03-
,QaHWI 6B3h1 .zvm 3aKOHO,!:(BT8JJhCTBa, perYJTI1PYJOll\ero 06IltYKJ ,D;OJIe-
B}'1O a:6cTBeIrnoc-n. Ha 06ll\ee "MJll.\eCTBO C06cTB€HID1KOB KBapTl1p.
3.2.1.2. PeBJ.13J.1S13aKOHo,QaTenbCTBB
06 o6Ll.\eA ,AoneBoA C06CTBeHHOCTI.1
IIpol.\ecc peBI1311116hlJI OCHOBaH Ha aHaJll13e craporo llIBeill.\BpcKo-
TO npaBonopfl,!:(Ka 0611\eil C06cTBeHHOCTI1, OnhITa COC8)J,HJIX rocy,napCTB
JII Ha npl1ill.\Jllnax KJIaCCl1'IecKOro pl1MCKOro npaBa. Bnaro,napH l\.8'1e-
cTBeHHoMJ aHaJrn3Y onhITa npaBoBoro perYJillpOBamm: J1 Cy.n:e6H0i1
npaKnlKl1 J13MeHeIn1H ,D;€HC'rny101l.\efO WBeilQapcKoro 3BKOHo,!:(aTeJIh-
CTBa HOCJ1JJ11 rny6WHHhIM xapaKTep. rnaBHoil QeJIhKJ pE'llif3JIIJf m.1JI0
C03.n;aHJ:I€ He06xowlMOii 6a3bl AJUI perYJillpoBaID:!H oI'in,\eij co6CTBeHHo-
CTI1 Ha 0611\ee I'1MJll.\8CTBO C06cTBfflHI1KOB KBapTl1p. B nepBYKJ O'lepe,IJ;h
Bh!HBJ1HJIJII, no.n;xO,Ql1T J!I1 06ll\BH C06CTBeHHocru.wm 3TJ.1X OTIIOUIelUrn
'eM Schne"jerBS_48
53

t1 ecnl1 ;na, TO KaKHe I13MeHeHt1H HY:1KHO BHeCTH. 3TH t1CCJIeJJ,OBaHHH
t1 n03BO= BbIHBHTb OImCaHHble BbIIlle He;nOCTaTKH.
&e;nEfnfenpaBa.fHa06eeoBMHO-
rOKBapTHpHbIX ;nOMaX m.IJIO JlHHLtJ1HpoBaHO 1I01DITIfKaMJ1, a He IOpH-
CTaMH 11 conpoBOm,l\BJIOCh MHOI'O'iJfCJI8HHblf nBp.1IBMeHTCKIfMH CJIY-
rnaHJ.1J'IMH. 30 Mapra 1951 r. 6bIJIO BHeceHO npemK»K8lDle 0 BBe.n;eHHI1
o6efr. co6cTBeHHocTH Ha 06ee "MYeCTBO B MHoroKBapTl1pHOM
.n;OMe. ecKtm .n;enapraMeHT nBp.naMeHTa 6blJI npOTl1B 3TOro
pewemm, TaK KaK OHO BJIeKJIO 6o.m.lID1e Jl3M8HeHIDI B IIITY, KpOMe
Toro, Q:iaK'IU'ieClCn aHa..JlOIU'iHWt pe3YJIbTaT MO:1KHO 6bIJIO IJOJIY'llfTb,
uCDJJIb3}'J'I ;npyrne cnoc06bI, MJ1HYH I1HCTIITYT06eif 
TeM He MeHee B peayJIbTaTe HaY'llibIX ,W'JCKYCCI1if 6bLID YCTaHOBJIeHO,
'ITO Bce me JIY'illIe BCero noJI:XO)U1T I1HCTJ1TYT 06eif C06cTBeHHOCTlf.
C oceHI11955 r. 6h!JIa Ha'IaTa pa3pa6oTKa npoeKTa I13MeHeHJIIH
B CKOeynomeID1e, KOTopaH 3aKOH'rnJIaCb B Mae 1957 r. .D;aJIee
CJIe;nOBaJU1 MHOlU'llICJI8HHbIe 06cYm,!J;eHJ.1J'I npoeKTa B nap.rl8.MeHTe, 38-
K(JlNJIIIlID1eCR B 1959 r. 1I0 J11WaM 06cym,!J;eIDIR npoeKT 6blJI nepepa-
60TaH "BHOBb 06cymAaJICH JOC:M11CCJ'!8i.1: no BelqHbIM npBBBM, nOCJIe'lero
6bJJ!J'! BHeceHbI cyI..II;eCTBeHHbIe J:l3MeH8ID1.II. lIepBoro HHBapJ'I 1965 r. "3-
MeHeHI1R B IIITY BCT)'TIWH1 B CHJIY.
3_2_2_ Co6CTBeHHOCTb 1.1 npaBO 06Ll-\.E! co6CTBeHHOCTJ.1
no AE!CTBYlOl1IeMY 3aKOHO,D,aTeJlbCTBY
06Il.\BJ1 co6cmeHHocTb o6pa3yerCJI, ecJllf Y HecKO.JIbKJlX cym.ex-
TOBBo.rr;HaBelltb.06Il.\BJ1co6c'!'BeHHoCTbno
lllBeifI..\BpCKOMY 38KoHo.n;aTeJIbC'!'BY MO:1KeT 6bITh TOJIhKO ;D;BYX BJ.1JI;OB:
;D;OJIeBaJI co6cTBeJrnocTI, t1 COBMecTHa.H co6crBeHmcn.
OcHOBaID1eM BOOlllOOIOBeHl1fI CfJBl'IH.'THOi1 ro6cTBemIoc-rH BbICry-
naeT 38XOH J1Jll:I ;D;OroBOp, npl1 OOJ'I3aTeJIbHOM HaJIWlI.111 nwrnoif CM311
Me coc06CTBemHmaMI1. K BM COBMeCTHOIf co6cweIrnocTIf OT-
HOCHTCH cJIe,IJyIOilU'Ie 05IllHOCTl1: 05IllHOCTb TOBapoB, 05IllHOCTb HaCJIe,D;-
cwa, 06Il.\ecwa, KOMMYHaJlbHaJ'I 06IllHOCTh po.D;CTBeHIDrn:oB, a TBKme
OTKpbrroe ToproBOe 11 KOMMaH,IJ;IITHOe TOBapl1Il.\eCTBB. IIpaBO COBMecT-
HOM cOOcTIJemrOCI1l ocyIl.\E'CTBJIH 06Il.\ecTBOM B I:[eJIOM. IIpaBo Ka:iK-
;D;Or0I13HaBeIl.\hBI:[eJIOMnOJlJle)Kl1TpeI'J1C'I]J<l.I:[1I1.
.D;OJIeBaR c06cmeHHocTb MO:1K8T I303H1!KHyTh 6e3 nJ1Y:Hb!X OTHO-
rnemrl1. PernC'Ipl1pyeTCfI npaBO coco6C'rneHmma Ha 'laCTh BeilU'l, npt1
3TOM;D;OJIHyxB3brnaeTCH B aPJI eID1HI1lIBX. llOJIeBble co-
C06CTBeHHI1KI1 06pa3ylOT npaBosylO o6Il.\HocTb.
.D;OJIeBaR c06cmeHHoCTb - 3TO TaKOH BI1,!J; 05Il.\eH c05cTBeHHocTI1,
npl1 KOTOpoM rn ynpaBOMO'IeHHblii MmKeT pacnopHjfiRTbCR

TOJ1bKO cBoefi JlOJIet:i. BbJ.l\eJI.fIKYI' TIH1bI,llO.JleBOfi: co6cTBeHHOCTI1: ofu.1<I-
HblfI - npl1 KOTOpoM npaBO co6cTBeHHocTI1 coco6cTBeInooro pacnpo-
C'I'pBH.fI8TCfI Ha BC10 o6UC'ID Belltb, HO CCBOKYJIHOCTb npaB no cB060)J;-
HOMY I101Ib3JBaHIfi{ J1 pacnopJ1memno npOCrnpa€TCJ1 TOJIbKO Ha JlOJllO.
BTOpblM Tl1nOM JloJIeBofi co6crBeHH1X."n1 JlBJl.lleTC.II Co6cTBeHHOCTb Ha
<tacTb 3J1BHJ1J1, npl1 KOTOpoM coc:05CTBemmKY npUH8.l1Jlf')K!IT J1CKmO-
'llITeJIbHOe npaBO nOJIb30BaHJ1J1 J1 ynpaBJIeHI1.f1 BeIltbKJ.
KpOMe TOro, BbJ.l\eJl.ll1OT caMOCTruITeJIbH J1 HHyro
JlOJIeByroco6cTBeHHOCTb. B caMOCTOHTeJlbHoU ,noJ1eBofi co6cTBeHHocTJl
coco6cmeJnnmMomeT npl1HUJ1ID13J1bHO cBo60.n;HoOTaTb J1JIJ1 00-
peMemrrb CBOKJ JlOJllO. B HeCaMOCTO.HTeJIOJt .n;oJIeBofi co6cmeJrnocorn
oqmul'i€lUlfI,nJI.fIpacnopIDKeHlmJlOJIJ1MJ1
.l{0J1J1 B npaBe06ll.1efl C06cweHHOCTJI- <lTOCOBOKYJIHOCTb Bcex npaB
J1 06.f13aHHoc-reH OT.n;eJIbHOrO cocc6c'rtJemnma no OTHOWeHJ1KJ K 06ll.1efl
Bel1tl1. B <lTOM CMblCJIe JlOJUI npe,l:\CTaBJIJ1eT c060fl KOHKpeTHoe npaBO-
Boe 1nlImKeHJ18 OT,JIeJIbHoro coco6CTBemDma no amoweHI1IO K 06ll.1efl
Bel1tl1. KpOMe TOro, ,l:\0JIJ1 BblCT)'IIaeT OCIKJBBIUIeM onpe;zJ;eJIeHlliI pa3-
Mepa,ll,J1.f1 HeCeHJ1.ll6peMeml paCXO,l:\OB Ha CO,l:\epauiHJ1e 06ll.1efl Bel1tl1.
.l{0J1J1 ,JIeIDlMa, Hanpl1Mep, npl1 HaCJle,l:\OBaHI1J1 J1JIJ1 B pe3}'JlbTaTe
C,l:\eJIKJ1 ,l:\OnyCKa€TC.fI OTeHJ1e 'lBCTJ1 JlOJIJ1. .l{0J1J1 B npaBe c06-
CTBeHHOCTJ1 lIB 38M8JIbHbIii Y'ffiCTOK nOAJIeml1T rocy,JIapcTB8HHOU
peDfCTpawrn B n03eMeJlbHOfi KHJ1re. Ka}K.!l;brn cocOOcTBeHIDfK M()}KeT
pacnop.fl.!:\l1TbC.fI cBoefl .n;OJIeti nOJlliOCTbKJ J1JD1 B 'laCTI1.
06Il.\BJ1 He.zr;BJ1m11MaJI B81ltb - <lTO :mKOHO,l:\aTeJIbHoe OCHOBaHl1e AlliI
B03IIHKIIOB8HI1H npewM}'ll.IeCTBeHHoro npasa nOKYIIKI1 y .v;pYrJ1X CO-
co6cTBeHHJmos. .l{aHHoe npaBO npe.DYCMOTpeHO  682 IIITY, cOrJIac-
HO KOTOpoM)' OHO M()}KeT 6blTb J1CKmO'ieHO JIOroBOJXM Mem.n;y coc:05-
CTBeHHI1KaMl1.
IIpaBI1JIa pacllopHmeHlliI 06ll.1efl BelltbKJ CBO,!:\J1TCJ1 K cJIeJIYIOll.IeM)':
- pacnopmKeHJ1€ 06ll.1eif Ht BelltbKJ MO>KeT ocyu.\eCT-
BJlJITbCJ1 TOJlbKoe)J;IDIorJI8CHO;
- J13M8HeIDre I.\enesoro HB3Ha'ieHJ1J1 HM}'llI8CTBa B03MO:iKH0 TOJIbKO
Ha OCHOBe 8.J1I1HOrJIaCHO npl1lUITOro perneHJ1.ll coco6crneHHHKf)B. I[eJib
HCIiOJIb3OBBHI' 06ll.1efl Bel1tl1 AlliI K8.)K)J;0ro 113 COc06CTBeHHI1KOB - ;;ITO
CMblCJI Y'ffiCTIlJ1 B ofxw1OCTJ.{, nooTOMY J13MeHeHl1e l.\eJIl1I1C1TOJIb30Ba-
IDIJ1 B03MO:iKH0 TOJIbKO C )"ieTOM MHeHl1.H Ka»QJ;oro H3 coa:fcrneIrnl1-
KOB.
06'bE'M I1cnoJ1b3(J1!8J111J1 06ll.1efl BeI.ql1 OT,JIeJIbHbIM Coc06CTBeHHHKOM
Onp8J\eJIJI8TCH BeJlH'iillJofl ero ,JIQJlI1.
Oco60 perYJll1pyeTC.II nopMoK oC)'lL\eCTBJl8HJ1JI .JIE'iiCTBIU1 no
ynpaBJIeHJ110061l.1811 BelltblO. BbJ.l\eJIffiOT:

1. Ht'06xOp.ltMble .neil(:IBQfi no ynpaBJIeIDno. K ID1M arnocwrcJ'I Bce
..r\eii£:TBJ.1J'l, HeOOxCJl)1MbI8 J:lJI.H I13BJIe'feHJ.1JI IIpJ16N.Jm 113 BeIqH: 11 He.n;o-
IJYl1I€RI1fI YXYJJ.illeID1H ee COCTOHHHfI. KpoMe TOro, K 3TOA rpynrre OT-
HOCJ'lTCJ'I 06J'13aTeJlbHble C'IJXMf8.JIl>1I MepOnpJ1J'1TJ1f1 ( 647 IIITY),
peMoHT, BOCCTaHOBJleHUe rom peKOHC'f'JJYKQI'fII, KOTopble HBJUUOTCJ'I
06J'13aTeJlbHb!M11 J),JIJI HOpMaJIbHOro lOHIfpDBalU1fI BeIqH: 11 no-
JI)"-IeHJ1.II I1pItfu.J.m.L IIpl1MepoM .zwyrMX Hecfixo.nmn,Ix .neik:'rBJ.1fi no
ynpaBJleHl110 HBJIffiOTCH paC'feT no 11ll000Ke, noxyrnca KopMa .nJliJ. }KI1-
BOTHbLX, HB3Ha'IeHl1e npe,n;CTaBI1TeJlJ'l J1 T..D;.
2. Cpoq)Jble.neiJCTatH no ynpaBJleHJ1lO, TOeCTbTe, KaropbJe ,nOJDK-
Hbl 6blTb npe,n;!lpWHHTbl He3aMeTeJlbHO, eCJlJII yrpomaeT pl1CK Ha-
c"I}'lIJIeHl1Jl y6bITICOB J1JII1 yxy,nweHI1H J1Myi..II;ecTBa, HanpJ1Mep, cpO"l-
Hbrn peMoHT KaHa.1IJf3al:(JDL TaKJlle ,neflCTBJUl MOryT npe.nI1pJIHJ1MBTbCH
JllOOblM c0c06cTBelnurnoM
3.06bI'lHble,neikTBIIJlnoynpaBJIemno( 647 aIIITY).OHMHalIpaB-
JleHbI JlM60 Ha II0JIY'leHl1e npH6wDI OT 06ll.\eH BeIqH:, JlM60 Ha npe,!\ar-
Bpall.\eID1e Bpe.na (y6bITROB). 3roLleJleHanpaBJIeHHb!e ..r\eifCTBJIIH, npe,n;-
IIpl1ID1MaeMble cocoI5c'metnn1KBMM npM HOpMBJIbHOM T8'IeID1M ..r\eJl,
Ha"{{),WITCH B mrrepecax Kam,Iloro 113 IDIX 11 He -rpe6yror oco6eHHbIX
paCXQJ:\OB. OHM MOryr OGyl1\8C'IEJI1IT KaM cocc6cTBeHHl1KOM 11.0
Tex nop, I10Ka Wloe He 6Y..r\eT yCT:iHOBJIeHO COrJlalIletrneM CTopOH.
4. BamHble Aei'1('TBJ1fI no ynpaBJIeHl1IO ( 647B IIITY). 3ro nOJle3-
Hble J],8ftC'Imm no YIIpaBJleHMiO, He OTHOCHll.\I'18CH K 06bI'ffibIM, :i TalQK8
CTpOJ1T8JIhHbIM MeponplfHTIfHM. ,lLnR: HI1JI Ba>KHbLX Mepo-
IIpl1wrl1i1 no ynpaBJIeID1iO He06xo,ll;illYlo KBaJIl(1PJ1QupoBBHHOe 6oJIb-
IlIJ1HCTBO ro.rrOCOB coc:dX:TBeHm1KOB.
5. CTponTe.m.Hh18 MeP£I1Pl'ffiTIlR (HanpMMep, C'l'poWf€JIbCTB CJII-
CTeMb! LleH'IpaJIbHOro OTOlLJleHMH I1JIM )'C'ffiHCEKa HfffuCJl)1MTQ 060-
py,nOBaHJIIH).  Meponr:wmmTalOKenoJlJlemaT ,nJll4Jcpe-
peHIPIBlU'll1:
- HeOOXOp.l1l\lble C'I'pOU'I'eJIbR€ MepOnpl1J'lTl1J'1. ,lLnR: J1X oCYll.\ecT-
BJleHJIIJ'I Heo6x(),lUIMO npJUUITHe pelIleHJII.II  I'OJIOCOB co-
c06cTBeHHMKoB JlJ160 pelIleHl1e cy.na B npe.nnpI1tillMaTeJlbCKOH c4Jepe
MO,",eT 6blTb YCTaHOBJIeH ,npyroA KBOPYM;
- nolJl'3JII.Je - ::rro o&beKTJIIBHO nOJle3HbIe crpOl1TeJlbHble Mepo-
npmrnm, peIlHme 06 OCYllJf2CTBJIeHlOI xaropbLX npJIIHl1MaeTCJ'I TalOKe
6o.nbunIllC'l'BOMrOJlOCOB;
- pOCKOIIIHhle c1pOI1TeJlbHbIe MepolIpJII.IITJII.II, J),JIJI JIIX oCyi..II;ecTBJIe-
HJIIJ'I 'Ip€6y8'I'CJ'I e.n;mIOrJIacHoe pelIleHJlle.
.lJ;OJliJ.I1MeeT ,D;I'1CII03JITJ.mHYlOnpJllpo..Qy, a ,nOJIH npl1 co6cmeJrnocorn
Ha 'facTI. :HCI1JIoro noMeIl\E'lll1H J1M1IepaTJllBHa Pacxo1J.bl paclIpe,n;eJUI-
56

IOTCH nponOpl-C-IOHaJIbHO Be.1lWlHHe ,JIOJn1. EcJU1 O)U:lH 113 c.oco6cTBeHHI1-
KOB HeCeT paCXO)U>I, npeBblrnalOlqI1e ero ,JIOJllO, TOOH MroKeTTpe60BaTb
OT OCTaJlbHblX COC06cTBeHHHKOB B03MeLqeHJ1.flI13.ID1llIHe nOHeceHHblX
paCXO,l:lOB, CpOK I1CROBOH ,JIBBHOCTJI no ,JIaHHb!M KaTeropHRM cnopOB
ycTaHOBJlEfI B 10 .neT.
IIoPMOK ynpaBJ1eJUfR 3aKOHO.LlBTeJlbHO yperY.nup0B8H B OTHOllle-
IDII1 Heo6xoJ:\JlMblX 11 CpO'lHblX MePOIlpUITUH ( 647 II IIITY), .JIBHHaH
HopMa npaaa WMeeT ,D,JlCJI)3Jl'J'I1BHYIOnpl1po..Qy11 MomeT6blTbU3M8HeHa
eJJ,lnror.naCHbIM pemeHHeM. KOTOpoe IlO,lI.Jlf:?KIIT perl1CTpaQMl1 B n03e-
MeJlbOOU KHJ1re.
PelllemlJl coco6cTBemDmoo MruKHO nO,l:lpa3,1:1eJn1Tb B 3BBJICJIMOCTII
OT MexaIDI3MB I1pJ'IHH'lUH:
1. PewemlJl, npmIHMB8MbI8 e,l:ll1HOr.naCHO:
- a BBe,l:\8mDl B ,JIeiiCTBJle nOpH,!I;Ka IIOJIb3OBaIlIUI J1 ynpaBJIeHJ1fl 06-
ll{eHBe!lU>K>{ 647 I IIITY);
- pacnopmKeHl1e oDll.\eH Be!lU>K> J1 J13MeHeHl1e l.\eJn1 ee JICI1OJIb3()-
BaIDIfl (648 II IIITY). IIpl1 HaJllI'nD:! e.rtl1Hor.naCHO npmurTOro pewe-
IDIfl3Tar nOpfl,l:lOK MomeT 6blTb J13MeHeH nocpe,!l;CTBOM ycTaHOBJIemfII
KBopyMB;
- c6 eJUlJ1 pOCKOlilllblX CTpOIf'I'eJIbHbIX MepOnpHRTILIf
(647eIllIrY).
2. Pelllem1H, npl1Hl1Maf'MbIe 6o.nbwJ.mCTlllJd roJIOCOB:
- J13MeHeIDIe nOpH,!I;Ka peaJ1H3B11HJ'J <futnn.Jx .neiiCTBJonf no ynpaB-
.nemoo (647a IIITY),
- 0 BblllOJIHeHI<Ul HeoDxo,l:lHMblX CTpoJ1Te.nbHblX MepOnpJ1.HTHi1
(i647e);
- a I1p8;:J:bJIBJIeIDrn J1CKa 06 J1CKJIlO'feID1H, ec..rrn B COCTaB ODI..WIOCTI1
BX0.rtl1T60Jlbille 'ieM.JIBa cc6c'rBeHmma (649B);
- Ba*Hble MeponpHfl'IIlH no ynpaBJI8HJDO (npJnDlMaIO'fCfl KBaJII1-
);
- IIJJI83HbI8 C'ipmITe.ITbHble Meponpl1.HTI1fl (IIJMHHM8I01'CH KBBJII1-
i647);
- poCKQllIHbIe C'IpOJ1T{'JIHfbI8 Meporrpl1HTI1.H npl1 co6.mop,emm CJIe-
ro'IOlI.\I1X yc..nom1it
1) ,JIOJDKHO DbITb cor.nacrre60JlblIDlHCTBa COCODCTBeHHI1KOB;
2) J1M,!I;OJDKHB IIpInIaJlJIeJKBTb 60JlblllBSI 'laCTb BeLql1;
3) JlPyrne cocODCTBeHHl1KJil .ID:!llIalOTCfl IIOJib3(JB3IIJm Be!lU>1O HB
BpeM.H;
4) ,!I;OJDK.HbI 6blTb KOMlIeHCJ1pOBBHbI r:e CBH3BHHble C JIJ1I1le-
IDIeM n0Jlb30BaHlliI Be!lU>1O COC06cTBeHIDIKaM, He cor.naCHblM C MHeHI1-
eM i50.n:bun1HCTBa;

5) OnJIaTa peMOHTHbIX pa60T.
OcHOBaHl1RM11 J303Jil1KHlJBeHl1R 06ll.1eif AOJIeBOif co6cTBeHHOCTI1 MO-
ryr BblCTyrtaTb cJIeJlYlOll.II1e KJpJl,!tl.{'iecKJ1e $iKTb!:
1) C,IJ;eJIKa (.D;orOBOpI1J1J13aBeIl.lBHl1e);
2)CMellIeHlfeJ1JIl1eHlreB81It8A,B03HJflCHOBeHI.06Il.1el1.c06-
CTBeHHOCTII B ,lJ;aHHOM cJI.Y"Iae npe,lJ;ycMOTpeHO 3aKOHOM ( 727 I IIITY);
3) cytle6Hoe pellieIDfe MJIJ1 Be,I:\OMCTB€HHO pacnopJDKeHl1e.
IIpeKpBI1IeHlfi:' 061It8ii ,J\oJIeBofI co6cTBeHoocTt:I B03MO0 no I1CKY
a npeKpallteHl111 ( 650 I IIITY). 3,1J;eCb nO,l:lpa3}'MeBaeTCH He TOJIbKO
npeHJff' oTHollleHJ.1if 06ll.1eif ;nOJIeBofI c.o6cTBeHHocTn B qeJIOM,
HO 11 np€KpaIlleHl1e npO'!'l1B OT,J\eJlbHO B3RTOro cocc::6cTBeJnDrna, B TOM
cJIY"lae ecJlJ1 OH XO'ieT BbMfI1113 06Il1HOCTJ1, eM)' BbillJIa'il1BaeTCJI OT-
cryrnIoe, a ctrlIOllEffilH coc06cTBellliocTIf npO,lJ;OJImBKJT CYll.IeCTBOBaTb.
Cocx:fJcTneJnrnBnpaBe06paTJ1Tbcfl Bcy,J\CI1CKOMoero
}"iaCThlfl B 06ll.1eif co6cTBeHHOCTI1. OAHaKo ,J\aHHoe npaBO MOmE'T ObITb
orpaHWIeHO, ,J\aHHbJe OIpaHH'IeHIIH ,J\OJI*HbJ 6blTb 3aperifCl'pJfpoBBHb!
B n03eMeJIbHoif KHI1fe, B ::!TOM CJIY'ffie OHl1 Oy.llJT OOfl3aTeJIbHbl ,WIfl
JHlI\, np1106peTBlOIqI1X ,J\OJIKJ B OyJlYl-I\eM. IIpeKPaIll8H11e 06ll.1eif c06-
CrnellliOCThl He ,J\OJIO npJf'CO,JUITbCH Ha BpeMJI, KOr,J\a coco6cTBemDm
BblHpK,!\eH nOJIb30BaTbCH 3Toif Berw.lO (Hanp11Mep. KoM6afur B nep110A
y60pKJ.1 YP0iKaH).
IIpoQe..Qypa npeKpalQ8HKH OTJIJ1'1a8TCH B 3BBJICHMfJCTI'1 OT ee OC-
HOBBH11H. rom npEKpalQeHJ'!e CJCyIl.\€C'IEJ!.H8T no AorOBopy, TO CO-
c06cTBellli11KI1 Moryr npl1 c:06.moJ:\eHml  19-20 06H3aTeJlbCTB8HHOfO
npaBa 1Tb pa3,1J;eJI BelQH B ffilTYPe (np" pa3,1J;ene3eMeJlbHoro
Y'ffiCTKa), CBo60,ll.H)'IO npo,na*y C ny6.m'I'IHaX TOproB I1J1J1 CBo6onHyK>
npoAB*Y TpeTbeMY JlI1QY, npe06pa30Baffile 06ll.1eif co6cTBeHHocrn
11J1J1 nepe,M'IY .mIKBJi1 C)J;enKJ.1 -rpeTbeMY Jl114Y. B CJIY'ffie
npeeHl1H 0611\el1. cc::6cTBeHHJcm no cY1J3, KOTOpoe Ha'lliHaeTCfl
no I1CKY, CY,lJ;bH ,J\OJImE'H onpeJJ;eJIHTb nOpJI.I\OK np€KpaIlleHI1H. em MO-
>KeT BbmpaTb Me iPlJ3WlecKJ.1M pa3)\enOM, ny6mf'llillMH TOprallrn
cpe,!U1 coco6cTBeHHHKoB 11 o TOpraMI1, npl1 aTOM CY,lJ;bH
pyKOBO,1\CTByeTCH  404 II IIITY 11 MH8H11eM cOCOOcmeHHI1KOB. C MO-
MeHTa BcryllJleHl1.Fl B CI1JI}' pellleHJ.1fl cY,J\a C03)J,aeTCH HOBaH c06cmeH-
HOCTb
3a.KOHOM IIIBeiiiqapIDI perymlpyPI'CH TalOKe nOpH,1\OK JfCKJIIO"l8H11.F1
06Il1HOCThI.,lLnHfHJlCKJIIO'II2HIm co6Jno-
CThI CJIe,IIylOlQI1e YCJIOBI1JL Bo-nepBbIX, npl1'111Hb1I.1CKJ1lO'IeHI1fl,J\OJDKHb!
JleiKaTb B o6JiacTI1 urnollEHlfii coco6cTBemnnroB J1JII1 B 06JIacTI1 arno-
weHJri.f Me)K)J;y cyDDeKTallrn, KOTOpbIM 06IQafl Berw. npe,1\OCTaBJlfleTCfl
B IIJ.1Ib3OBaHJre. 3To ,J\OJDKHbl ObITb B8ClCfe npwrnHbl, KOTOpb!e AeJIalOT
58

I1pO.I\OJDK£'Hlfe 05lllHOC'm HeB03M:!HCHHM t:I onepJtpyfl KOropbIMJ1 CYJ],bH
MO:IKeT t:I3 05lllHOC'm t:lCKJIKI'IJ.11'h Bo-BTOpbIX, UCKJIIO'ieHIfe B03MO:IK-
HO TOJIbKO npt:l Ha.IIWn1J.:I BeCKJ1X 0CH0BaIUm. RaK I1OCJlE')J;Hee Cpe,nCTBO,
ec.m1 BCe npe,nynpem,!\eHl1H, -rpe6cEaIDffI t:I J1HhIe npaBOBbIe cnoc06bl He
npillleCJIJ1 pe3YJIbTaTa. B-Tpeu.Jo:. Ha):VIemaI.llJ1i1 IICTel..\ - aTO cy61,eRT,
KOroPOM)' HaHOCMTCRBpe.l\  Ha 00l1{YKJ Bel1tb. PerneHl1e
o nOJ\aqe IICRa ,nOJDKHO 6blTb npMH.l'lTO 6o.nbnnfilCTBOM r0J10COB coc06-
CTBeHHJ1KOB. HB)\JIemalll;l1M OTBeT'lliKOM MO:lKeT 6blTb coro6cmemnlK.
a TalOKe n0Jlb30BaTeJlb BeIW1 m160 B.JIa,IJ;eJleLt OrpaHU'leHHblX BelItHblX
npaB Jf.JThI npe,IJ;Bapl1TeJlbHblX JIWlHbIX npaB (HaI1ptMep, npaBBnp€t:lMy-
I.l{8CTB8fIlIJJI nOK}'IIKI1). TalOlM c6pa30M, B03HJ1KBeT IIM}'J.LteCTBeHHo-
npaBOBOH rpam.naIIa<lflf CrIOp. EcJU1 OTBeT'II1KOM BblCT)lTIaer coOCTBeH-
HHK, TO BblliOCI1TCJ'I CY,[le6Hoe perneHl1e 0 COBeprneID1Jll  BO
JlCIlOJIH8HJf8 OOR3aTeJlbCTBa no eID1lO ero J\0JIJ1; eCJIJ1 umeT'lJ'!-
ROM BblCT)lTIaeT BJIa,[IeJI8Lt ocpaIIWielIHOCO BeIWIoro Jf.JThI npe,IJ;BapI1TeJ1b-
HOro JIWllioro npBBB, BblliOCI1TCR l\OJIC'I'IIT)'TfBIDe perneHl1e 06 arMeHe
npaBa IIOJ1baOBaHIoff, TaR RaK orpaHJ1<leHHoe BelQHoe npaBO t:I JlWlHoe
npe,IJ;Bapt:l'reJIbHOe npaBOHe OeMOII He nepe,!\BBaeMO.
Oco6oroBID1MaID1R3BCJ1.Y'K1'1Ba8 3BKOHO,naTeJlbCTBO, pery.1illpYJOll.\ee
npaBo ,nOJ1eBofI C06cTBeHHOCTI1 liB 'laCTb ,[IOMa II 3eMeJIbHbrl1 yqBCTOK,
II CneLtl1BJlbHoe npaBo Ha KBBpTHpY, pacnoJlO:lKeHH}'lO B 3TOM ,noMe. Co-
QI1aJ1bHo-m.lU11WfeCKaR l.\eJlb BBE'JleID1R)\BHHoro illlCTIfI)'TB CBb
K TOM)', 'l'I'06bI CJ1enaTb 6o.nee J\OCTymIbIM IJFIMJ6peTeHJre II CTpOI1TeJ1b-
CTBO KBaPTJ.1P. B lIIBei1LtapIDI HeTCneWIaJlbHoro 3BKOHa, peryJll1pYJOl.l\e-
ro co5cTBeHHOCTb Ha KBBpntpbl, ,ll,BHHoe npaBO pery.IDfPYeTCR HopMaMJ1
lIIBei1LtapcKoro rpam.nBHCKOrO YJlC»KeHIDI II 05R3aTeJlbCTBelllioro IIpaBa.
IIpaBoJ\OJIeBofIco6CTBellliOCTIfHa 'laCTbmJIJIOro nOMeumRBKJII{)-
'laeT B Ce6H ,n0Jll0 Ha 3eM8JIbHb1i.i }"faCTOR (era npaBO perIfC'IpJ1py8TCfI
B ID38M8.1IbHOii KlOO'e) II onpe.AeJleHHYJO 'laCTb nOCTpOeHHoro 3,!\BIlliR, Ha
KOTOPYIO coco6cTBeInum l1MeeT oco6oe npaoo 06.n:B;¥lTeJU1,lJ;OJIJ1 B npaBe
o5ll.\eM,lJ.OJIeD)I1 ll1MeiOT cnelp18JibHoe npa:so B OTiiorne-
HIDf'laC'l'l1 3,!\B1lliR.lIaHHoe npaBO II03BOJIfI8T 11M IIO.1Ib3WBTbCJI ocy-
ll(ec'l'BJlJlTb ynpaBJIeHl1e 11 CTpOIITeJlhHble MepoI1pI1RTIUI (7128 IIITY).
Cn8l.\MBJlbHoe npa:so l1MeeT TE':me IICICJl€.,lJ;CT, 'lTO 11 npaBoco6cTBeH-
HOCT11 II np8.D;CTaBMeT co5otf Henocpe,lJ;CTBeHHOe BE'll(Hoe I'OCnO.D;CTBO
HB,!\ 'laCfbIO 3,!\BID1R 11 B03MOiKHOCTh DCyll(8C'IEJIeI  no ar-
cTpaHeID1lOOTBJ\PYI'I1X COcOOCTBeHHI1KOB 11 TpeTb11X.JiI1I..\.
Cnel.\lf<lJlbDJ8 npaBo pacnpocTpaHHeTCH Ha 'laCThI 3,[IBH11H rrocTO-
RHHO CBH3BHHble C HI1M 11 05opYIJ;OBaH11e, H8dixo 11 rrpe,lJ;HB3Ha-
'leHHOe JIM  3TQro 3,[IaIDfR (HBIlpJ1Mep, 6aJIKOH,
BXO.D;HBHJ\Bepb, mBJl10311, BepaH,I\a, OKHB 11 T.J\.).
59

J1MIIepaTI1BHO K OOJ.1tMM om.eKTaM OTHOCRTCR 'tacTJiI crpoeHHfi,
yc'lpOJICTBB JII OOOPY,[lOBaID1H, KarOpbIe HapH,!\Y C 3eM.nei1 JIIMelOT 00-
ee Ha3Ha'teHI1e, B TOM 'lIfCJI8 OOIq11e yc'I'pOiIcTBa JII OOOPYJlOBaHI1e. IIo
.JIOfOBOpeHHlX."nl JII,JIpyme OO"heKThI Moryr 6blTh OTHeceHbI K OOJ.W1M.
PacnopwK8H1f8 ,JIOJleif B ,JIBHHOM Bl1)J;e .JIOJleBOit: COOCrnellHOCTH ocy-
TaKme, KaKJIIBoObrmoii, r,JIe ,JIOJ1RBhlcrynaeTCaMocro-
jJTeJlbHhIMo6"beKTOM,JIJlR.
B OTIDI'lI1e OT oU: co6CTBeHHOCTY! 3,!\8Cb He C}'llIeCTB}'eT npe-
ro npaBa nOKyrrKI1 ( 712c I llIry). Coc06cTBeHHI1KI1
Moryr YCTaHOBMTb ero, 3aKJIIO't11B c,!\eJIKY, KOTopaR .l\OJDKHa COCYI'BeT-
CTBoBBTbcJleJlY1OyCJiOBl1ffl11:
1) ill'1CUoI8HHaH €}JoPMa,
2) e,!\l1Hor.naCHoe pernem1e Bcex COC06CTB8HH!1KOB;
3) pernc-rpaJ..V1H B n038MeJIbHcU KHJ1I'e C cOOTBeTCTB}'eti OTMeT-
KOIIHa CBlf,.!\8TeJIhCTB8, Y.l\OCTOBepHlO8M rrpaBO co6c.-rneHHOCTHKaiK-
.l\oro 113 c:oc::cfIC'rBetoo:
4) MaRCl1MaJIbHhli1 cpOK, Ha KOTopbrn MOiKeT 6hITb 3aKJIlO'Ima Ta-
KaR c.n;eJlKa, COC1'aBJIReT 25 JleT (216a 06H3aTeJibCTB8HHOI'OnpaBa).
CyeT TIHOfi.e BCGMOiKHOCTh yCTBHOBI1Th npaBO 
OCTaJihHhIXCo:::oI5cmeHHJ..B,KOTOpbIMOHYICMOI)"I'BOCIIOJIb3OBBThCRBCJI)'-
<ffielipD.lltljKl1.l\rurnIIpl1HaJ1WIID1:B8CKI1XOCHOBBHJ1i.1:(712cnllITY).
3.3. B03HI-1KHOBEHI-1E 1-1 PA3BI-1TI-1E I-1HCTI-11YTA
06L11E" C06CTBEHHOCTI-1 B ABCTPI-1I-1
3.3.1. CTaHOBJ1eH(.1e (.1 pa3B(.1T(.1e npaBa
o6l4E! co6CTBeHHOCT(.1 B ABCTpl.11t1
PB3BH'I'H8 8BCTpltticRoro 'laCfRoro npaBB He II)X111CXO,l\IfJIO B rpaHY!-
X cero,n;lUilllHei1 ABCTpl1"," CO,!\HOi1CTOpoHbl, Ha6.mo.n;aJIOCb BJillmrne
pJIIMCKoro JII HeMeqKOro npaBB, C JlPYI'oti CTOpOHhI, QCTaJrnCb rJlyOOKl1e
CJle,ZJ;h1 pE'l\.e OOrn;ero npaBB, '1TO xapaKTepHO J\JUI eBpOIIeiiClOClI'O
'laCTHoro npaBB B qeJlOM, J13 3TJilX 3J1eMeHTOB CKJlBAhlBaeTCH '1aCT-
HOIIpffi3OI38.H CKCTeMa. Ha py68JKe XV-XVI CTOJIe-n1H HB6J1IO,!\a€TCR
npoqecc npeBpaw;eHJIIH ,l\oMalllHeti npaBOBrn1: >ID13HI1 BMecre C npaBo-
BOM Texm1KOl1 OOrn;ero npaBB BO MHorY!e HOBbie COBpE!'l1eHHhle npaBO-
Bble cpe,!\CTsa, B KaropblX pacn03H3eTCH HeM8LjKaR qe3ypa pa3SJIITJIIJ'i
asc-rpJII!1icKOro 'taCTHoro rrpasa. K Hacryn.neHI1KJ cpe;znleSeKOSbJ'i CJIe-
11.YeT HOBNH BY!TOK pa3BJilTI1J'i 311C'IpD"icm'o npaBB, KOTDpbrn rrpl1BeJi K
HaY'lHblM OCHOBaM JII CJllcreMaTJII3altID1 <ffiCTHOro rrpasa.
OJ

TaKJ1M OOpB30M, aBC'Ip(ficKOe "laCTHOe IIpaBO pa3m1BaJlOCb nO,lJ;BJU1-
HHI1eM HeMeIVwro, pHMCKOrO HJn1 KaHOHWIecKOro npaBa, a TalOKe pR.JJ:a
 'I'8'l8HHff, TaKWX KaK cxo.nacnma, ryM3IIH3M. 4Ju.nOCO-
4J11Hml1J1J.15epaJIbHbIXB3rJL<J.!lOB'.
CpeAHeBeKOOafI OOH co6cTBeHmcTI, Ha He,IJ;BI1mJIIMOe 11M)'ll.\e-
CTBO CTa.Jla IIpoTOTlilIIOM MHOruX COBpeMeHHbIX npoHBJIemm Mom
npaBoBoro 4JeHoMeHa, K TaKHM OTHOCHTCH OOll.\MHHble :3eMeJIbHbIe
yqaCTKJ1 11 nacrlJI1ll.\a, cpeJnleBeKOBHe peaJIbHo-pa:3,1J;eneHHble ,lJ;OMa
(ceroJtHH, peanbHo-pa:3WJleHHa.H OOlJ.-1aH c.c6cTBeHHocTb). EonbliiaH
'laCTb ooll.\eif co6cTBeHHOCTH Ha He;:J;BJDKJ1MJe  6b1J1a npe-
OOpa:30BaHa B 'lBCTH)'1O I1JIJ1 ny6nWIH)'lO co5cTBeHHOC'Tb. B TOM "illCJIe,
HanpHMep, B paMKaX aeMeJIl:lJoii pe<lJoPMbl, npoBO.IUttom B ArerpmI
B IB4B r. K ny6m1'lHOJ1 ooll.\eif co6cTBeHmcm 6wIO OTHeceHO TO, 'ITO
HBnHeTCH OOIl.t"'M,[\JIfl Bcex, HalIpHMep ,lJ;oporn, BO)J;Hble ofh.eKn.I. Jlyra
,[\JIfl Bbmaca CKOTa. Bce aTO JICJ1OJIb;j()Ba.JlOCb 11 ynpaBJIHJXJCb KOnneK-
TmJHO.
OrrrpaBHOMTO'lKoif pa:mI1TYJ.Hooll.\eif co6cTBeHHOCTYJ 6b!J1B ,lJ;OMaW-
H.HH OOll.\HOCTb. CeMefrnaH OOll.\HOCTb 6b1J1a BbIpBmeHa B 4JoPMe OOll.\-
HOCTJI 6paTbeB, KpeCThJIHCKOIf OOll.\HOCTII, pbll.\apCKOM Ha
OOll.\HOCTJI, opa'llioi1 ofuqHOCTI13TO own1 pa:3IIOBJ1,lI;HOCTi'I ooll.\eif c05-
CTBeHHOCTH, JrnBeCTHOJf HaM ceWmc KaK COBII'IecTHaH COOCTBeHHOCTb,
TaK KaK pacnopmKeHHe OcyIl\eCTBJI.HJIOCb TOJIbKO «ooll.\eif P)'KOi1», TO
eCTb TonbKO coo6ll.\B no e,!IJ1HOrJlaCHOM)' peweHl<OO, nwlBJof.DYBJlbllO
npHHa,QJIe:mana TOJIbKO ,lJ;OnH. B cJJY'Iae CMepTJI co6cmeHHl'2Ka, eCJTII!
Y Hero He OCTaBanOCb HaCJIe)J;lil'lKOB, pa3MepoM era ,lJ;O./ll'l npHpacraJTIl!
,lJ;OJm,lJ;pyrJ1XB.
CooMeCTHaH cdicTBeJrnocTI, no.n;xO,!J;HT TOJIbKO,[\JIfl ManeHbJalX CO-
1030B, 1XJlM'lH0i1CIDf3blO, TaKKaKBCOBME'C'THOM,lJ;OMOBna-
,lJ;eHlffl Bce cofJcTBemn.JroI coo6ll.\B «ocyr.u;eCTBJlHlOT xroHifcTBOOaIDle
Ha rn5enb J1JIH e (nOOTOM)' J1MJll.\eCTBO, ,lJ;OXOAbl If pac-
XO}J;b1 Bee B 06lq111X pyKBX)>>2. TIOCTE'II8i1HO npaBoBoe peryJlKjX338ID18
oOll.\Hocrn nO,lJ,Bepranocb npeoOpB30BaHlOO, 'ITO 6b1no CIDf3aHO C He-
OOXO,lJ;JtMOCTblO C03,!\BIDtlI HOBbIX q,opM, xapaRTepH3)'lOlqIIIXCH 6oJlb-
llIeH cl3C6:Jwii It W1CJX)311TI1BH0C'I'b1O J1X 'lJIeHOB. B nepMO,lJ; n03,lJ;Hero
cpe)J;HeBeKOBbH Ha6mo,lJ;aeTC.H nepeXOJ(HbIi13Tan BbIDOpa q,opM, 6o.rree
JIJIH3TOi1L\emr.
Eo BHYTpetnrnX OTHOllleHMHX 0CYll.\eCTBJIH8TCH paarpaH1l'1etme
ynpaeneIUIH 11 1I0Jlb30BaHJ.1.H COBMeCTHbIM J Or,neJlbHblfi
'C...:AomannU.2007S164
. AoBmamU_S. 165
61

coc05CTBeHHHK nOCTeneHHO npl105peTaJl caMJCTOJITe.1Ib, TaR '1'1'0
B 0TlKI1It:'HJUIX C TpeTbl1MM JIl1I.\aMH O,!\I1H Mor BbIcTynaTb RaR lIpe,!J;cra-
Bl1TeJIb 05ll\HOCTM (Hanpl1Mep, B OTKpbITbIX TOBapmneCTBax). Ha'laJIa
IPOpMMpOBaTbCR 05ll\HOCTb c06cTBeHHJIIKOB, IIpM Iro'ropIJi'j: OTA8J]bHbIJt
co6crnemnm: Mor CBOlO ,!\OJIlO caMOCTOH'J"€JIlflO npoBaTb I1Jill 05pe-
MeHRTb, HO B OcyIQ8C'I'BJI8HI CBoem npaBa co5CTBeHHOCTJf OH 5bUl
orpaHWIeH aHaJI npaBaMH ,Ilpyrl1X JillL\ (.QOJIeBaR c06CTBeH-
HOCTb). TIORBMJIaCb HOBaR pMB TOBaPI1l.L\8ClOCii COOCrneHHOCTII, KQ-
TOpaH XOTH nPJ1,!\ep?KJmaJIaCb COBMeCTIIDI'O npmlIV'2II<l pacnopRme-
HJ1JI 05lL\ei1 BelL\blO, HO OT,!\eJIbHOM)' COC05CTBeHH>my npHHa,D,.II8)KaJI
CII8QI1aJIbHOe lIpaBo IJ;)JIb3QJ38HJ1 TIporpeccI1ImoM)' pa:3Bl1'I'I>1lO 05lL\-
HOCTVJ HaCJIe,!\H>mOBIIOMeWaJIa lI8lI03MIDKHOCIb M)"K'1J1H 11 :m:eHlL\VJH
Tom BpeMeIill COTpy,!\HJf'laTb Ha paBHbIX npVJ orrpe,!\eJIeHffif nopJI,W::a
ynpaBJIeHlliI 05lL\V!M l1MJll--\eCTBOM 11 B orpaHl1'1eHHoi1 CTeIIetrn IIpli.!
pacno_K
TalOK€ HecornaCOO8HHOCTb 5bUla B pery.m1JXlBBHlUl npeKpaw;etrnH
05ll\HOCTIf oo6cmeHHHI{{)B. HeKOTopbIe Bl1,!\bI CJ6rQHOcTII ycraHaBJIIi.!-
BaJIIi.!Cb «Ha Be'lHOe BpeMJI» (HaIIpIi.!Mep, pbILlBpCKOe Hepa3,l\8J!eHHOe
UMYIL\eCTBO), TOJIbKO 8):\YIHOrmCHoe peWeHYIe Bcex 'lJIeHOB 
MorJIO If3MeID1Tb ;;ITY cUTyaI.{YIlO.
YCI1JII1HMH IIpBBOBffiI HayKYI XVIII B. OOll\BJl co5CTaeHHocn, 6bUla
CIi.!CTeMaTI13YIpoBaHa. JJ:.rr.q: 3TOro BpeMeHIi.! xapaKTepHO, '11'0 HapJ'l,llY
C mU,I\yaJIbHbIM c06cmeBHYIKOM - IOpI1,I\WI€CKYIM JII1L\OM Morna
cyIQE'CTBOBaTb TOJIbKO 05lL\3.R cr:f:crBeHHocTb no i1,!\€aJIbHbIM ,!\OJIJ'IM,
r,ne c.oco6crBeHmm: Mor He TOJIbKO paCnOpRiKaTbCR cBoei1 ,[IOJI8JI, HO 11
IIpE'A'bJUlJIHTb m 0 npeKpalL\eHYII1 06Il\HOCTYI. 31'0 H8MI1HY-
£'MO BJIeMO OTMMpaHl1e COBMeCTHOii co6cTBeHHoCTJ;1. C KOHL\a XVII
CTOJ1eTJfH cyw;eCTBOBaJlJ..l HayqHbIe nOnbITKJf COXpaHI1Tb cOBMecTHyro
c06cTBeHHocTb, pe3YJIbTaTOM '1em CTaJIa KOHC'Ip}'KWm 05ll\ei1 c06-
CTBeHHOCTII, B KOTOpoi1 CO'leTaJIaCb HeM€LtKaR KOHL\enL\I1R COBMeCrnOIt
05ll\ei1 co6C'rneHHOCTli 11 pl1MCKaR KOHL\en 06Ll.1cii c05CTBeHHocTI1,
6a:3l1pYX)ll.\aRCR Ha IIpmILtJme HH,II;HBJ1.AYB.11bH0CTI0f IIp<I.BOMO'DIIi c06-
CmeHIDfKa. J1M.YlL\eCTBeHHaJI 05ll\HOCTb cynpyroB, o5ll\ee HB,!\eJI€IDIe
JIeHOM, He,!\eJIJIIMOe HBCJI8,[\CTOO, CeJIbCKaR 05ll\11Fffi nOHHMaJIJ1Cb RaK
cnel..llf<lJlbHCl8 OTHOWeHI1H o5ll\e}\i c05cTBeHHocTVJ, B KOropbIX OT,neJIb-
HOMY coco6c-rneHH>my npe,IJ;OCTaBJIJlJIOCb Cnel..lJf<lJIbH08 lIpaBo nOJIb30-
BaHlliI, HO TOJIbIW Bee BMeCT8 MorJll{ pacIIopmKaTbCHBlO.
HOBoe HanpaBJIeHI1e pa3BJITH.H 6bIJIO ,IlaHO yq€HI1eM Be3eJIep Ii.!
rVJpKe XIX B., KOTopbre paccMaTp11BaJUf 06Il\YlO C05CTB€HHOCTb qe-
pe3 Teop11lO 05lL\HOCT11 TOBap11lL\ei1, Bbl,I\eJIJIH B HeM ,!\Ba pa3JiU'lHbIX
T11IIa; COBMeCTHYlO c05CTBeHHOCTb 11 napTHepCK}'lO. KOpIIOpaTI1B-
62

HYIO o51ltYJO C05C'I'BeHHOCTb. 05I11aH Co6cTBeHHOCTb XapaKTepill30-
BanaCb, TaKHM 05pa30M, TeM, 'iTO npaBOMO'lJHH B co5CTBeHHOCTH ne-
pe.!\BIOTCH nOCpeJlCTBOMnpillo5peTeHiIIHJlOnH OTJlenbHblMH 'ineHaMH
05I11HOCTH, ITo IOpt1)\H'lJeCKOMY oclxJPMJIelilllO OpraHJ13aHOHHo-npa-
BOBOt! IPOpMb! 5b1Jm pa3JIWDUI Memy TOBap ill KopnOpaTJ1B-
HOf! o5ll1et1: co5CTBeHHOCTblO. CaMoe O'lJeBt1)\HOe BnI<IRHHe 3Ta TeopHH
OKa3ana Ha IIIBei1Qapcrom rpam,a:aHCIDIt! KOJ\eKC, B KOTOpOM 05lL1aH
JlOneBaR C05CTB€HHOCTb npOT11BonOCTaBJleHa KaK pO,lJ;OBOe no-
HHTJ1e'.
3.3.2. ,l],e"CTBYlOl1.lE!e npaBO o611.lE! c06cTBeHHocTI.1
05I11IDi rpam.zI,RIICIOmCBO,lJ;3aKoHoBABCTprnf(JlBJlee - ArY) - aTO
BCTyIDtBlliaH B cHJlY B 1812 r. 11 ,!J;eJ1C'I'1!}'KIl{RR,IJ;0 HaCTORllIem BpeMe-
HH caMaH Ba:!KHaH KOJ\illtlJJ1fffiWlR rpajK,!J;aHcKoro npaBa B ABcTpHiII
11 BMecTe C 'reM TaKme CTapel'iwifi.i J1€HcTmf'l"eJlbllbrii CBO,IJ; 3BKOHOB He-
Mero npaBOBoroKpyra.  pa60Tb1KKO.J:U«t:IIKa-
'-IHI1 aBC1pJ1lfcKoro rpam,z:\BHCIOOI'O npaBa Ha'lJrna.mlCb yme B cepe,!\HHe
XVIII B. npeJ1lll8CTI38HIDIKOM AfY HBMeTCR C03,Z1,aIIHl:ri l\apnoM AH-
TOHOM $JH MapTl1HM 3ana.nHo-fCBOJ\ 3aKOHOB.
<ppaHIJ; $JH l(atinnep, y<IeHI1K MapTl1HM, C'lliITaeTCH C03J\aTeneM
MY, ICaIOpbM 5bLJI cfrbHBJIeH HaK J1MI1epaTOpcKi1A: 3BKOH 1 IOOHfI 1811 r.
11 BCTym1JI B CiIIJIY C 1 RHBapR 1812 r. B HeMeIUa1X 3eMJ1RX, 0'I0llIt'JnlIKX
ABC'I'pID2cKcii MOHapXJ1H. PB3pyuIeHHe MOHapXHH He OKa3anO HeMe,!\-
neHHoro BJ1J1HHJ1R Ha cct>epy .neAcTBHH MY, em IOpJJ,,!\Jl'lecKaH CMa
npo,lJ;OJImanacb B rocY,!J;Bpcrnax-npeeMHHKax."
nepBwe em neT cBoero CYllIeCTBOBaID1R AfY He nO,!J;BepranCR HiII-
KaKillMI13M8H8HHRM, J\anee6bL1llf HeKOTOpWeHOBeJlJlbIB 1914, B 1915 ill
1916 IT., KOTOpwe 5bLJIH CBR3aHb!C HeOO:xo;:J;I'IMOCTb o5ecn8'lllTh eJ\iII-
Hoo5pa3He C HOpMaMJ'! frY'. B 70-e IT. xx B. npoillCXO,IUlJIJl CepbE'3HbJe
i113MeHeHiIIR B ceMei1HoM npaBe.
B ,QIJIIOJJHeHlI8 K HOpMBM ynomeHl1H JlciiC'l'B}'IOT MHOI'O'llfCJI8H
cneW1BJ1bHl;le3aKOHbi. TeM He MeHee MY - aTO no-npemHeMyocHoBa
aBCTpillllcKoi1 rpaHCKOi1 npaoosoi'i CYlCTeMbI ill HapRJIY C tlJpaHQy3-
'C... AossmanU_5-166
'AllgemeinestugendlesGese1>oochlfJrdiegesamlende\ll$d1enErblande;derOo1errelttosdle
M<nintJevomIJu,.,;IBl1JGSNI946JIBl1aml.Jan,..,rIB12
JC...Brauneder.OasABGBalsInG.Klingen.
berg I J M Rei,.." I H Stiegler (Hrsg_l, \IesIIoe luris RomanI. Fes1sd1rift IUr Gunter Wessner, Graz
1992.5.67--SO
'"73:rUcl<£:c:hwaigerF I50JahreABGBIIJuristenzeilulg.1963 W16.
63

CKMM I«J,l:\E:'KCOM UJU4 r. CTapethrnm 113 1\efICTBYJOIQIiIX 3BKOHOB, OTnl1-
'IalCUUtifcHpa3yMHOC'II>IOnpaBOBbIXJ1..!\eH'.
IIaparpa4> 308 MY 1\l1cfxPepeH'--1HJJyeT npaBo co6cTBeHHOCTH Ha
1IJ,!J;J'Im1JIYCUIbHOe 11 o51l1ee. HOpMbI CROro ynomeHIfJI pery-
n11pYJOT COBMeCTHOe BJIa.!\eHJ.fe B HeCKOJIbKJ1X pa3,!\enax. IIaparpaclJb!
825-849 npl1MeHJ::rIOTcH TonbKO K BelllHblM npaBoBblM 061l1HOCTHM.
K 06J13BTeJIbcTBeHHblM 06oCTHM I1pl1MeHJllOTCJI  888-896. IIapa-
rpaclJ361 ynomE'Hlmco,!\epmJIT6e3I13MeHeHM.HC 1812r.
IOpJ1..!\WlecI«Je onpe.n;eneHlI8, I«JTOpOe ctPJPMYJillpOBaHO TaKI1M o5pa-
30M, "iTO IJJ3lIOJlH8T I1fMMeHJITb ce5J1I«JBceMTI1I1aM06ll1eif c06CTBeH-
HOCTI1, B CBJ!3Y1 C "i€M MO;>KHO roBOpI1Tb 0 CYll\eC'I13OBaliWI HOpM, I1pYl-
MeHJleMbIX K J1HCTI1-ryry B '--1enOM.
CornaCHO  361, «ec.rrYl OARa B8l4b 6e3p8.3,!\eJIbHO I1pYlHa,!\JIe:>KIIT
HeCKOJIbKl1M JillQaM, OHa COCTOI1T B o6w;ei1 c05cTBeHHocTI1. B OTHOllIe-
HI1I1 Bew;J1 B '--1enOM COB.IIa,l\€J!hQ paCCMB"Ipl1Ba1OTCH KaK OARO JIJ1'--10,
HO Ka)fi,!\oM)' 113 HYIX llp1H3p.l!8)KlIT nOJlHoe npaBO C05CTB8HHOCTYI HB
OlIH}'IOxOTHI1HeBH,lJ;enellH}'lOqaCTb».
IIo'!\p06Hoe peryJillpOBaHYle o5oCTb COB KaK clJopMa
O(XJCTOM IfJlI1 l1,!\88JIbHffii c:oco6c.-rBeHHOCTI1 HaIlIJl8. B  825 11 nOCJIe-
JIYlDLqI1X. 06w;aH co6crBeHHOCTh IIOJIPB3A8JlH8TCH B CBOlO O'tepe,'J;b Ha
o5llQ'1O C06CTB8HHOCTb C J1..!\eaJIbHhlMJl ,!\OJIJlMI1, c pea.m.HbIM Bbl,l\ene-
HI18M ,nonefI 11 COBMeC'I'H)'JO cofx-rBeHHocT1,
IIpl1 peBJIbHO-pa3,neneHHoi1 COco6cTBeHHocTI1 BeW;b no,nne>KJ1T
pa3)1eny He TOJlbKO C opaBOBofI TO'lKI1 3peHIfJI, HO 11 cpaKTYI'leCKH.
IIocJle npHHJ::rTJ.1H 3aKOHa 1879 r. ,lI,aHlIl:lH BH)\ o51l1et1: c06cTBeHHo-
CTH He MOiKeT 60Jlbllle 05p830Bb1BaTbCH. TeM He MeHee B HeKOTO-
pb!X cpeJlepanbHbIX 3eMnRX peanbHo-pa3,neneHHBR C06CTBeHHOCTb
I1pO,!\OJDKaeT CYJ.'--1eCTBOBaTb B Ka'leCTBe co6CTBeHHOCTH Ha 3TaiKH H
OO)I.BanbI, HanpHMep B 3a.nbQ6ypre, EypreHnaH.ne 11 B THpOJlbCKOM
Haropbe.
3Ha'leHHe :nOM $JpMbl co6cTBellliOCTJI 5blJIO I1pmHaHo 3a,nonro
1\0 fpam,naHCROro y TaK KaK OHa 6blJIa 111l1pOKO pacnpo-
cTpaHeHa 11 COIUfaJlbHO 3Ha'll1Ma. Ee 1U1H B 1879 r. IlpOJ'J3O-
wna cRopee no ,norMaTJ1'leCKMM 11 Hey5e,lJ)IT8JIbHblM npJ1tlI1HaM.:r:rfu-
pOKaH cpoPMYn11pOBKa  361 II03BOJIH8T T8KmE' BKJlIO'laTb B ce5H H
,naHRbIMB>U\.
PeanbHo-pa3,!\eJIeHHaH Co6cTBeHHOCTb Morna I1pYIMeHHTbCH B 07-
HOllIeHI1HX o5Il1ei1 c05cTBeHHocTH C06CTBeHIDIKOB RBapTHp Ha "MY-
'c... Br.IuoederWCsteneK:hsAJlgeoTIeiroesBiigeJ1ichesGesetzbuCl1(A8GB)2,AufIage,Bd.I.8er10l:
D\nc1<er&l-IlfI'tIIo.2011 8146-155
64

llI€CTBO, npe;l:\Ha3Ha'leHHOe ME 051l1ero nOnb30BaHUfl, '1TO npeJIYc-
MOTpeHO  833 rpamHcKoro ynomemlfll1 npI1JIOm€HI1HWI K H€MY'.
CYllIecTBY€T cnop 0 npaBe IfCl10JIb30BaHIUI HapYmHbIX CTeH ;l:\OMa.
IIpI1MeH€Hl1e B ,naHHOM cJIY'lBe npocTOIt: COC05CTBeHHOCTI1 (I1JII1
l1,!J;eanbHoi1:) BJ1eqeT onp€,!\€JIeHHble CJiomHOCTH, KOTOPbl€ CBH3aHbI
C TeM, '1TO pe'lb l1,!IeT 0 H€KOM «TBOpeHl1l1lOpI1CTa», JfCKyccTBeHHo
C03JJ,aHHoH KOHCTpymnnr. KOTopaH He BOCnpl1l1M'-JI1Ba B peaJIbHOM
BHeWHeM Ml1pe. ,D;JIE perYJll1poBaHI1H ,!\aHHbIX OTHOWeHI1H P€)KJ1M
pea.nbHO-pa3,!\eJIeHHoi1: Coco6cTBeHHOCTI1 5b1JI 60JI€e nOHHTeH npo-
CTbIM JllO.IJ;EM.
IIpocTaH I1JII1 Jf.IJ;€aJIbHaH coco6cTBellliOCTb nO.IJ;JIemI1T peryJlI1-
pOBaHl1lO B  361, 825 11 B nOCJI8JI,YlOIW1X naparpacpax MY. )J;aH-
Hble OTHOWeIDIH Ha3b1BaIOTCH TaKme .I\OJleBoi1: Co6cTB€HHOCTblO 11J111
C05CTBeHHOCTblO no ,QOJIHM. 3,!\ecb pa3,!\€JI€Ha H€ B€, a npaBo.
O,nHaKo l1,!J;eaJlbHO€ cO)"-JaCTl1e B co6cTBeHHocTI1 erne H€ npe;l:\OCTaB-
JlJleT KOHKpeTHoe npaBo nOJIb30BaHI1H onpe,n€JI€HHoi1: npe,!\MeTHoH
'1aCTblO
Ka:m.n:bli1: c06CTBeHHI1K MOm€T caMOCTOHTeJlbHO pacnopHmaTb-
CH cBoeH .I\OJIeH comaCHO  829; OH BnpaBe 6e3 113B€rneHI1J1 .I\PY-
rl1x COc06CTBeHHI1KOB 11J1I1I1X cornacHfi npOTb, n€pe,naTb no Ha-
CJI€,nCTBY, 3aJI0)KJ1Tb 11J1I1I1HblM 05pa30M 05peMeHI1Tb, Hanpl1Mep
04JOpMllTb I1nOT€KY I1JII1 YCTaHOBJfTb cepBI1TYT. B OTHOW€1Uf11 OT-
,neJlbHOH ,nOJII1 MomeT TaKme ocyweCTBJlHTbCH npl1Hy,nI1TeJlbHoe
npOI13BO,!\CTBO.
06Il\BJI C05CTB€HHOCTb B03MOmHa KaK Ha .I\BWKI1M)'lO, TaR 11 H€JlBY!-
ml1MJlOBe
3aKOHOM npeJIYCMOTpeHb! B03MO.?KHOCTJf 3alWITbl co6cTBemIocTI1-,
KOTOPbl€ Moryr6bITb 05palI\€HbI KaK npoTY!B -rp€Tb!1XJIJ1l\, TaK 11 npo-
TYIB .I\Pyrnx coco5cTBeHHJ.fKOB. Coco5cTBeHHl1KH MOryr 3anpel.l\BTb ca-
MOBOJIbHbIe BMewaT€JlbCTBa 11 np€BblWeID'IJI BJIaCTI1 co CTOpOHbl.I\PY-
rY!x cocoIkTBeInn1KOB, HBnpl1Mep caMoBonbHoe orpaiKlleHY!e 'ffiCTei1:
051I\eH3€MJ111: JfJll1 Teppacbi".
CaMb!M pacnpOCT]JaHeHHblM cJJY'-1aeM 13G3lll000000IDUI npocToH CO-
co6crneHHOCTY! HBJIfIeTCJI Hacne,!\OBatrne, KpoMe TOro, OHa MOmE'T 05-
pa30BblBaTbCJ'I B cY!JIY cynEf:Horo pewetrnJ'l (HoillpIIM8p, paa,neJl 6pa..-
HOi1: 06LqHoCThI).
'&24/58(1951)
2C..,:Zll!hmsal;kHIJieAufheDUlljJller..nerDesonaererlIes
"'dderFleall8lu1g",FormderBegunckJngvonWenMat\z.
65

YnpaBJIeffile Haxo;nHl1\eflCR B npoC'l'ofi co6cTBeHmcTIl Bel1\bKJ ocy-
 COrJIaCHO  B33. ['pam,I\aHaroe YJIOmeHJ.fe pa3Ip8HIl'D'I-
Ba€T 06bl'IHoe J1 'lpe3Bbr'IBf1Hoe ynpaBJleHJ.fe
.n;JIJ'I HJ1R 06bl'1Horo ynpaBJleHJ1R JJ;ei1C'1'ByeT npmuum
6o.m.wJ.mcrBa. O6bI'lHoe yrIJXlBJI€HJ'E c.nymJIT coxpaHeIOOO LJ;eJleBoro
HB3Ha'leffilR Bel1tl1.
KpvJTepJrif pa3rpaHWI€HJ.fR OObI'1HOro J1 'lpe3BbI'JaMHOro yrrpaB-
JIeIDfR He'l€TKO C4>OPMYJIMpOBaH 3aFtOHOJJ;aTeneM, nOTOMY RBJlReTCH
rrOBO,!\OM JJ;JIH CYJJ;eOHblX CrrOpOB. AHaJlJ.f3 CYJJ;eOHOM npaKTI1KJ1 no-
Ka3bIBaeT, 'ITO K OObI"lHbIM M€poIIpJUITIUIM no ynpaBJIeIDIIO, FtpO-
Me Bcex Mep no COJJ;ep:-KaHI>1l0 OOl1\ero I1MYl1\eCTBa, OTHOCHT B TOM
'lMCne, Harrpl1Mep, paCTOpmeHJte JJ;orOBopa apeH,!\b! C apeH,!\aTopoM
OOl1\ero JfMyru;eCTBa, npMHHTMe pellIeHMH 0 H83Ha'leHMM ynpawuno-
l1\erOI1T.Jl,'.
rOBOpH a 'lpe3BbI'1afuIbIX Mepax no ynpaBJIemoo, HB3bIBalOT yn)"'-
llleHMe J M J13MeHeHMe era l.{eJI8Boro HB3Ha'leHI1H. IIpMHH-
TMe pellleHwi-i 0 npVlMeH€HID:! Mep 'lpe38N'IrtiiHoro ynpaBJJ8HJ1H Tpe6y-
eTewrnornacWi. HecornacMe OJJ;Horo J13 cocoocrneHHI1KOB MO:IK8T 6bITb
3aMeHeHO perneHMeM Cy,zu,M
«C,rra6b!M MecTOM npoCTofi cooo6cTBeHHocrn HBJIJ'IeTCH TO, 'lT0 1ta:IK-
JJ;brn: Y'ffi-CTHJ1K MmKeT -rpeOOB3.Tb npeKpallem€ ODl1\HOCTJII ( 830), 3a
1CKJIKJ'i€HJf8M CJlyqaeB, eCJlJ1 ::rro «npeKpal1\eHJ.fe HBJlHeTCR HecBoe-
BpeMeHHbIM t1JIJ.f Be.n;eT K yObrrxy OCTaJlbHWX». TaKI1M 05pB3oM, JJ;JIH
OC'l'aJlbHblX COCODCTBeHHJ1KOB C}'l1\8C'lBy€T BpeMeHHaH rapaHTIlR, KO-
TOpaH, O,lJ,HaKO, npe.nCTaBJIJ'IeT co6otiJlJ1illb OTCpO'IKY J1 He npe.nOTBpa-
ll..IBeT nOJIHOCTbKJ OTMeHYOOI..WIOCTI1. OTMeHbI 06nnr0c'n1
c06cTBeHHJ.fKoB napwr ltaK JJ;aMOKJIOB Me'! Ha)\ 1OpU,lU1'leCKHM J1HCTJ1-
TyroM.r:\O.1!€I3OH co6cTBeJrnocll1, TeM DOJlee IJ'f() MOIKHO J1CIJOJIb3OBBTb
3TY B03MC»KHOCTb B JIrnbIX lLJ;eKarJIl1BblX cwryaJ.U1RX J.f BCJIeJ],C1'BJI8
3Toroonpe.neneHfJoe.naBJleHJ1e».
CJle)I.yIO[LJ;J1M crroco6oM npeKpal1\8HJ1R 06I..WIoCTJII, KpoMe ee ome-
HbI, .HBJUleTCR JJ;eJIeIrne oDl1\et1: BelLJ;I1, yperYJrnpoBaHHoe  841. BbJ,IIe-
Jima!' JJ;Ba BVI.l\a JJ;eJ!€HJ1H' HaTypaJlbHOe J1 aroe.
Harypa.llbHoe JJ;eJleHJ18 OCY:W;ecTIIJUIeTCH no e,!\IDIorJIaCHO npilllJITOMY
peureID1IO no  841, B CJIy'ia€ He,!\OC"I'JDKeHWI eJJ;J1HorJIaCWi npmfeHHeTCH
rpIDK,!\BHCKOe JJ;eJIeID1e.
CorJIaCHO  843, €CJrn oOll\)'lO B8Lqb Bo06l1\€ H€Jlb3R paa.n;eJllITb JIM1)o
H8B03MOiKHO  683 3Ha'llITeJIbHoro YMeHbllleffi1H CTOMMO-
'CM. FeiIE,MIeIgen1uJ1EinesyslematischeOarsteUI.t1j:Jff....JiePrIDds,Wen,Un<le 1997.S.12
FeiIEMIelgen\um_Eines)'StemaUschelJers1e1lungfOrdiePrIDds_S_19
'"

cn1, TO.mo6oii: coco6cTBeJumK MOeT TpeOOBaTb cYJle6Hrn1 npoMmM 
pacnpe.ll;e.neHI1JI BblpY'leHHblX cpeJlCTB MeiK,ZlJ' Y'lacnnlRaMJ1. CJleJJ,o-
BaTeJIbHO, rpa)K)J:aHCKOe JleJleHHe, no cyrl1, 03Ha'ffi.eTnpOMmJ oOl1\efi
BelJ.tlll C ny6mI'-JHbIX TopraB C pacnpe.n;eJlf:'HJ18M no.nyqemroro Jloxo.n;a
nponoPJ.V.IDHBJIbHO ,n;OJI.IIM.
IIpeJIYCMO'IP8HB BCI3MmKHOCTb 3aKJllO'IeHl1H MeiK,ZlJ' coc06cTBeHHM-
I<aMt:! ,n;orooopa, npe.l\YCMa JICKJ1IO'II2HIre npaBa Tpe60BaTb
,n;eJleIDIH BelJ.tlll. 3Tar ,n;OroBOp 6y,n;eT HeJ18J1cTm1Te.m.HbrM: B CJIY'lBe B03-
1U1KHOB8HJ1JI BamHblX OCHOBaHl1K
TpeTbl1M BI1)J;OM OOl.l\ei1 COOCTBeHHOCTI1 HBMeTCR npaBO CO-
BMeCTHoif co6cTBeHHOCTH, lWTopoe pacIIpOCTpBHfleT CBoe ,n;eiicTBJle
Ha 1MyrnecTBO B KOMM,UJJJ;I1THOM J1 GI'KpHTOM ToprOBOM TOBapJ1llte-
CTBax, .I\aHHble OOLI4HOCTI1 ofiJIa.IIawr ,n;eecnocooHOCTblO. KpOMe Toro,
JHHaH 06L14HOCTb CynpyrOB, COBpeMeHHoe HB3BaHl1e KO-
TOpOi1 napmepcKafl OOlllHOCTb. TalOKe HBJlHeTCH COBMeCTHoi1: COO-
CTBeHHOCTblO.
Ci:EMecrnaH co6cTBeHHOCTb xapaKTepl13yeTCH TeM, 'lTO Y'lacTHJOO1
He MOryr CBo60JJ;HO pacnopHmclTbCH .I\OJIHMI1. TOJIhRO Bce BMeCTe OHI1
Moryr pacnOpamaTbCH BelO B l.\eJlOM 11 ,n;OJIHMI1. 3TI1 06L14HocTI1.f1B-
JlHKYI'CR 3KOHOMWH'Cl\If qyBC TaK I<aK 3aBI1CHT err JII1'1-
Hora Y'laCTI1H J1.I\OBepWl, l.\eJIb KO'rDpbIX - He CTaBI1Tb era no.n;yrp03Y,
,Qei1cTB)'H B OJJ;HOCTOpOHHeM nopJI,!J;Ke.
Oco6oH 4cPMoH 06lltei1: ,[IOJ18BOii COOCTBeHHOCTI1 HBJIHeTCH npaBO
,[IOJIeBoi1: co5cTBelrnocTJ1 Ha 'ffi.C'I'b )ID1J1oro ,n;OMa J13eMeJIbHbrn Y'lacWK.
KaKJ1 B repMBHID'!, J1B ABc-rpl1Jf.I\aHHbrn: J1HCTI1TyrHOlOJlb3OBaJICH
KaK cpe,!J;CTBO BOCCTaHOBJIeHlfH nocJle pa3p}'llD1'I'€JHHX lUCJIe.I\C'I'BI1i1
BTopoti MJIpCEOii BOi1:HbI. IIepBOHa':laJIbHO OTHoweHWI peryJll1poBa-
JlI1Cb 3aKOHoM 1948 r., 3BTeM 1975 r., cero,IJ;H.H .I\ei1cTBye-r pe.n;aKQI1fl
2002 r.' (.MJlee - 3aKoH). JJ;aHHbli1 3aKoH, KaK J1 3aKOHbi repMa-
HI1I1 11l.IIBepl1l1, peryJIJ1Pye-r npaBO Co6cTBeHHOCTII HB 'lBCTb 3,!\B-
HM H Ha Myn\eCTBo, rrpe.n;Ha3HB':IeHHOe AJlH 06lltero nOJlb30BaHJ1H,
a TalOKe Ha 38Me.JIbHbni Y'laCTOK. 0c06eHHOCTblO .I\aHHOra BI1,!\B .I\OJIe-
BOi1 ro6c.-rnellliOCTl'1.HBJ1HeTCH TO, ':ITO 06ll(HOCTb no 3BKOHY ye l1MeeT
Bell(HOe rrpaBO Ha OO"beKT COOCTBeHHOCTIl, a J1MeHHO rrOJlb30BaHJ1e,
J1 pacnopmt<f'lme (2 a03. 1). IIpJ1 npocrofr. cOCOOcTBeHHOCTJ1, HBnpo-
TIm, HI1K.BKOi1: c:oco6c-IEeHHJ1K Ha OCHOBaHJ1 TOJIbKO JlJ1IlIb 3aKOHHoi1:
KOHCTpyKIJ)1J1 He MO:>KeT JlCJ1OJIb3(:BaTb onpe.n;eJl€HHYlO KBaprJ1py,
TaR RaR TOJlbKO npaBO, a He Belltb nO;nne1t<JIT pa3)1eJleHJ1lO, n03TOMY
npam1JIa rrOJlb30BaHJ1.H J1 ynpaBJIelillHB8llIblOHym.uaIQTCH Bcornaco-
'BUndesgesetzRej)Oblikl!sterreichjjberdaswtn.rgselgenllr2002,StPBGBIINr1O/2002
fiI

BaHJIIJII COC06cTBeHHJ1K3MJ1. 3aKOHHaR KOHCTPYKQI1R OOl1let1: COOCTBeH-
HOCThl B MHoroKBapTI1pHbIX,[IOMaxymeBK.mO'ffieTno.fIb3OBaHJ18l1yrro-
'lpefu18HUe KoHKp8'I'HOfi:'laCTbKJ BeIQl1.
O,[lHaKO npaIDma nOJIb30BaHI1H oow;et1: Bell.\bKJ B ,[IaHHOM Bl1)J;e CO-
c06cTBeHHocTJII TaIOKe pB3pa6aTbIBaK1I'CR c06cTBeHHKKaMJoI I1l1rpaKJT
60Jlblll}'KJ npaKTII'leCKJIO pOJlb, HO He ,[IJIR J1C11o.J1b31EaHJ1F! KBapTI1p,
rapiUKei1, Mara311HOB 11 npoqero, a TOJlbKO JII1lllb }J,J/JI o6l1\11X 'laCTBl
HeJJ:BJUKJmoco I1MYInecTBa'.
3aKoHHaR KOHCTp)'Kl.\I1R KBapTJ1pHOJ1 co6cmeJrnrem: He rrpeJJ,o-
CTaBJIHeT OT,[IeJlbHoM)' coco6CTBeHffilIKY nOJIHarbI BJIaCTI1, OH He HBJIR-
eTCH ewmomf'IHbIM COOCTBeHID:!KQM CBoeM KBapThlpbI, TeM He MeRee
rrpaBOBafl $JpMa O'leHb pacnpccrpaHeHa. B HaCTOJn.Q;ee BpeMfl B AB-
C"Ip1111 npl1MepHO 450 000 KBapTl1p npl1HaiJ;JIe»\aT CBOI1M BJl8JJ:eJIbQ8M
Ha 3TOM npaBe. Ho CYll\ecTByKYI' J1 CBOM rn KaMHI1, KOTopbIe
IIpI1HOCIIT6Jrn:3KOE'oo:H\JrreJIbCTBOcJJ:PYrnMJ.{L
HecKOJIbKO J1HBH IOCIIIq8mpm 06l11eM Co6cTBeHHOCThl MHHOI'O B»,!\3.
3aKpenJIeHa B fepMaHm1, rJ(e cocc6cTBeHHI1KoO.rra..naeT CneQM3J1bHbIM
rrpaBOM Hli KBap-rnpy, KOTopoe, no cyrn, 03HaQaeT npaBOc06CTBeHHo-
CThI Ha Hee. Ha. oOl1\l1e 'i3.CTJ11\OMa ycTaHOBJIeHa 06l11BJI Co6cTBeHHOCTb
(WEGI951).
B lIIBei1:4apm1 peryJIl1poBaHl1e 3TOro I1HCTl1Tyra 6bLlIO ocym;ecT-
BJIeHO B 1963 r., JJ,aHHb1/ii: npaBonopHJ(oK HanOMI1HaeT ycoBeprneH-
CTIIOBaHHyKJ MOJ(eJlb rncKOro. CrreJ\OBaT8J1bHO, 06LqBH colkrB8H-
HOCTbB MHoroKBapTl1pHblXnoMax B ABcTp:m, fepMaHl1J111 lIIBei1:4apJ.fi1
C npaBOBOii: TO'IK11 :3peHi1H Jll1ll1b HeKO'IOpHI2 BOnpoCbl pernaeT no-
pa3HoMY, HO ROHJJ;eIl'ryaJIbHO Cl'I8Hb noxo:aca, TaR KaK Bce TpU CTpa-
Hbl B Ka'leCTBe 06pa3u,a J1CIlO.J1b3OBa.IDI :HTa.JIbfDICKJ1ii rpam,zIiUIc:KJofl1
Ko,!\eKC (1117-1139).
CornacHo a63. 2  2 3aKOHa 06'beKTOM npaBa co6cTBeHHOCTH HBJlR-
K1I'CR «KBapTl1pbl, npo'll1e He3BBHCHMbIe nOMelQ8HJ'lR J1 MeCTa CTOHH-
KI1>}. IIaparpa4> 2 a6a. 2 Onl1Cb1BaeT ynoMRHYTble nOHRTI1R BMeCTe
C KBapTI1pOM, TaK KaK npe.nrIJCHJIKOJI ,[\JIH C03,!\aHlilH 06l11eM cOOCTBeH-
HOCTI1 HBJIfleTCR cyIn8CTBOBBHI18 H€3BBJ1CJ1M(jjj- KBapTl1pbL YKa3BHHafl
BblUIe $JPMYJII1poBKa aaKOHa .HBJUleTCR ,l\OCTaTO'lliO Y3K0i1, BMeCTe
C TeM He TOJIbKO KBapTupbI, HO J1 04JI1Cb!, rapa:>Kl1, aBTOCTORHKI1
11 CBH3BHHble C HI1MJ1IIQl1,BBJIbHbI' J1 'Iep,!\a'ffibJe nOMell\eHrnJ, Ca;:J;bI,
OTKpb1TbI8 OOJIKOHbI, TepaCCbI J1 J\Pyrl1e Henocpe,!\CTBeHHO ,jJ;OCTyrr-
Hble J1 'I€TKO onpe.I\eJleHHbIe 'laCTI1 3,!:(aHJ1R, JfJII1, J1X RaK el1le HB3bI-
'0.._ TschiilscherJ 2()(Ci'+8r"1tb.d1fijrdiePra>:is_Wen:Verll>sterrei(:h 2003_S- reI
68

BalOT, «aKceccyapbI», no  2 n. 33aKOHa MOIyr 6bITb 05'beKToM KBap-
TJtpHOii co6cTBeHHocrH.
06'beKTar.rn npaBa Co6cTBeHHOCTItJ He JIBJlRlOTCJ'l 06l1t1'1e 'laCTI1 11M)'-
llteCTBa, cor.naCHO  2 n. 4 11  3 n. 3 3aKOHa OHI1 YHl1BepcaJlbHbl, TO
eCTb npe,!J;Ha:ma'IeHbl,l\J1J'1 06l1tero nOJlb30BaHI1.III1 He nOAJIemaT 3KC-
KJl103UBHOM)' HmOJlb30BalUOO co CTOpOHbI OTJleJlbHoro coco6rTBeIum.-
Ka. 8TII/ 'laCTII/ 3)J,BHI1.II MOryI' II/Cn0J1b30BaTbCJ'I B TOM 'illCJIe .JII1J..taMIl/. He
1rnJIHIOll..\I1MII/CH co6cTBeIniuKaMR
K06l1teMYOTHOCJ'lTCH:JIeCTHJfW;l.npa'Ie'ffible, CynntJI-
KI1, 'lepJJ.aKJ1. JleTCKll/e n.n01.J..l8.J1K11, CBaJIKa, ,IJ;OpmKKl1 K ,IJ;OM)', 3eJleHbIe
HaCam,r(eHI1.II 11 OTHO('J!l1taHCJ'I K ,IJ;oMY 6eClIJiaTHaH napKOBKa. Crp::m-
TeJlbHble pa50Tb1 no B03B8,I\8IDUO Bcex 3T1tJX 05'beK1'OB ocyIlf2CTBJIH-
IOI'CH 3a C'leT rnco6cTBemnlKOB.
IIaparpal}:! 3 003. 1 38RoHa 3aKpelIJlfleT B03MOmHble OCHOBaHIffi
B03HIIKHOBeHI1.II npaBa 051Qei1 co6cTB€HHOCTJll:
- ,IJ;OroBOp KBapTJtpHOii c05cTBeHHocTil/ (nI1CbMeHHOe cornallieIDIe
Bcex coc06cTBeHHlfKOB);
- cy,IJ;e5HoepeweHll/e nO.?KaJlO5e HaOCHOBaHI1II/  43 3aKOHa (maJlO-
6a cn no peKJlaMe npornBCOOCTBE'HHI1KOB 113-38. yrIylltE'HI1H
OpraHI13aTOpa KBaprnpHoi1 co6cTBeIrnoCTI1);
- cy,IJ;eoHoe peweHl<le B npOL\eCce OTMeHbl OOl1tHOC'ITl Co6cTBemul-
KOB CY,!J;e6Hoe pa3J1€Jl8Hl fe cynpymecKOI'O I1M)'1l1€CTBa.
IIaparpal}:! 5 3aKCma 33Rp8lIJlfleT npilllL\l1ll. cor.naCHO KOTOpoM)'
np106peTeHYle KBaprHpHOif c06cTBeHHocrn TpeoY8T carpy,IJ;HJ1tjeCTBa
cOOcmemooroB.
B 2007 r. 6blJ1o BHeCeHOJ13MeHeHll/e B  5 3aKOHa, cornacHoKOTOpo-
MY napKOBQ'lHOe MeCTO Ha C1'OHHKe B TeqeHl1e nepBblX TpeX JleT C MO-
MeHTa C03)J,BIDIH MOmeT npH05peTBTbCH TOJlbKO coco6c.-rnemnlKaMlf.
TIo J1CTe'IeIDI" 3TOfO BpeM8H" "IpeTbM JlI1L\B MOryI' np"oOpeTaTb MeCTa
.wm CTOHHKIL <PaRT npl106peT8H11H nOllJl81Kl1T perUCTpBIDrn B n03e-
MeJlbHoii:xHl1Te.
IIaparpal}:!6 nepe<rnCJUleT ,IJ;OK)'MeHTbI ,IJ;JUI3aHBJle-
HI1H 0 npnco8JJ;l1H8HID1 R 05l1teH Co6cTBeHHOCrn, cpeAM KOTOpblX:
- ,IJ;OKa3aTeJlbCTBa C03)J,BHJ1JI KBapTHpHoii: c05cTBelrnccrlt: no  3
a03. 1 (,IJ;OrOBOp OKBapTHpHoii: Co6cTBeHHOCT" 11 T-A);
- ,lJ;OKa3aTeJIbCTBa np0C'I1105'beKTaKBapIHpHoti:c06CTBeHHO-
CT" (Y,lJ;OCTOBepeID1e C'I'pOI'JT8JlliHOI'O Be,lIOMCTBa J1Jm 3KClIE'pTHoe 36-
KJII(I'IeH"e);
- onpe)J;eJleH"e nmpef:&rre.m.cmi1 CTOI1MOCTYlB COOTB8'I'C'I'BJ1H C  9.
69

IIaparpa4> 11 eT, 'lTO npaBO COOCTBeHHOCTIf Ha KBap-
Tl1py 11 MHHI1MBJIbHoe Y'lacTJlle B 05w;ei1: c:06cTIIeHHrcnl Hepa3pbIBHO
CBJl3aHbll1 MOryr OT'-lTbCR TOJIbKOB COBOKynHOCTI1, nepeMBaTb-
CJ'I no HaCJIe,lJ;CTBY, 06peMeIDITbCH J.1JII1 f'lIfBBTbCH.
K 06H3aHHOCTHM c:occ:.6crBeHHJ no  16 a153. 3 OTHOCJ'ITCJ'I OOJ'l-
3aHHOCTb 06cnyml1BaTb nOMew;eHl1e, COXpaHJ'lTb 06!lUfe BelItl1l1 npo-
HBJlJITb TepIBlMOCTb no UIlJ01lleIDllO ,D;pyI' K .n;pyry.
3aKoH 2002 r. YCTaHaBJlI>fBa€T pa3JB1'lJ18 MeiK,ZlJ' HCI1OJIb3OBaHI1-
eM OT,IJ;eJlbHbIX o15"beKTOB KBapTl1pHOii: C015CTBeHHOCTJII1 ynpaBJleHJ.f-
eM BceM II8)J.BJOKJfMUM  B OTHOllI8Hm1 ynpaBJleHI>fH J1
nOJ1b30BaHI1H BceM M coco6cTBeHHI1KI1 Moryr aaKJIIO'laTb
cornaWeHI1J'1. 3aKOH npe,I\OCTaBJ1flE'T Kam,!\oM)' COCoOCTBeHHI1KY npa-
BO Ha OCHOBaHl>f11 }'BB)KI1T8JIbHbIX npWII1H 06parnaTbcJ'I B CYA aa pery-
Jll1pOBaHl1eM :noro Bonpoca. IIpaBJ<LTIa n()JIb3(GUIJUI ycTBHOBJI8HHbIe
Cocc6cTBeHHI1KaMl1l1J111 CY,I\OM 6y.lIYT ,I\8iit.-rnuTeJIbHblI1 B OTHorne-
HI1I1 TpeTbJfX JlI1Lt., npJ106peTB1OllUfX KBaprnpy nocJle J1X ycTaHOWIe-
Hl1fl, ecnl1 ,I\aHHbIe npaBI1J1a 6bIJIl1 aapernC"Ipl1pOBaHbl B n03eMeJIb-
HOHKHl1re.
IIaparpa4> 18 a63 1 npe,I\OCTBBJIH8T 06oCTI1 ccro6cmeHmmoB
'lacrWIHYJD npaaocnocoooOC'rb B 06.rraCTI1 ynpBBJIeHI1JI H8J];IJIDKHMbIM
1 rIpl1 3TOM OHa MOmeT npl100p8TaTb npaBa 11 OOH3aHHQ-
CTJII, a TaRIKe Bb!CTynaTb I1CTqOM I1IJ'I1J€T'lKKCM B cY,I\e, no aHaJlOImf C
OTKpbITbIM TOproBbIM TOBafJIM H KO1THblM TOBapl1W;e-
CTBOMCOrJlaCHO  124 (Toproeoro KO,IJ;eKca).
ITpaBocnocooHoCTb 06oCTJII coCOOcrBE'HHI1KOB orpaHw-II1BaeTCfl
JlI1llIb Bonpocar.rn: ynpaa.neHl1H I1MJW;eCTBoM. BHe 3TOi1
cclJepbI ,lJ;eHTeJIbHOC'!'1il OHa He MOmeT npl100peTaTb HI1 npaB, HI1 OOJ'l-
33HHOC'I"6L CJ\a<fB B apeHJIY KBap'mp 11Jll1 I1pO'lHX He3aBlfCUMbIX no-
MellleHJ1i1, KOTopbIe COCTOHT B OCOOOM I1OJlb3(}BaHJfI1, He OTHOCUTCH
K BonpocaM ynpaBJleHI1H.
IIpI1 npeBblllleHl1I>f O'-lep'leHHOrO 3aKOHOM Kpyra 3a.nB'l npaaOBaH
C,IJ;eJIKal1Jll1npeJ\CTaBlf'I'8JlbC1(()8HeJ],eHC'I'BKI'eJIbHo.
ABC'I'pJff1CKJli.f npaaOIlOpJIJ\OK o15ll1ei1 co6cTBeHHOC'IlI I1pe,I\CTaBJIHeT
c050ti OOpa3e1l3aROH'l8HHOI'O Jf naKOHWIHoro perY.1II1pOBaHl1H. DH IiIMe-
eT HpKO BblpameHHble J 'lepTbI, HOnpl13TOMBeJll1KO
BJll1flHvre COce,IJ;lmx npaaOBblX CI1CTeM, cpe,I\11 KOTopblX IJaM60nee OT-
'leTnl1BO npOHBJIJ'leTCJ'I HeMeltKBH I..\eaypa.
70

rfiaBa 4. nOAJ(OAbl K nPABOBOMY
PErYnl1POBAHl11O OTHOWEHI1i1
05Ll1Ei1 AonEBoi1 C05CTBEHHOCTI1
B DeROSe npaBoBOro pery.m:1pOB8HI1JI OTHOIIPHUA 06ll\ei1 c06cTBeH-
HOCTI1 lJ()JI(»f{eHB HeKaH KOffitefl1U1H, OCHOBHaR t1,I:leJ'l, KoropoA nOCJIe-
J];OBaTeJIbHQ np>f..Q8p)KI'1BBeTCH 3aKOHOMTeJIb. CaMa no ce6e OOIl\3.R
COOCTBeHHOCTb - ::!TO 4>eH0MeH. }'me B Ha3BaHtH'I KOTOparo Ha
REHaH IWJI.J1M3I1H, TaR KaK, C o)J;HoA cropOHb1, nO,l:lpa:3YMeBaeTCH OOll1-
HOCTb, H)':ac.r\aRJIQ3.J'JCfI B perY.1II'1pOB3IilIH nopJI,D;Ka B3aillMO..r\ei1c'rBJ.u:l
l1}'me no cBoeR npl1po,!\e cOJ\ep>Kal1\aR HeKOTopble OrpalMl8HlfR, no-
CKoJlbKyem1€ Bo6lwIocrn - ::rrOHeoOXO)U1MOCTbn(),lJ;'lllHRTbC
Bblpa6araHHbIM 810 npam1JIBM. a c JlPyroi1: CTOpOHbl, npaBO co6cTBeH-
HOCTI1, KOTopoe nOHI1MaeTCH KaK nOJIHoe  HB):l BelltblO, a6-
COJIKfI' BelltHblX npaB.
AHaJ1M3 3aKOHOmiTeJ1bCTBa PoccJm. fepMaHIDf, ABcrpl1l111 lIIBefr.-
qapIDIl1OOl3O.llH8T npWiTIf KBb!B0.11Y0CyrnecTBOBBHIDI,l\BYX 
K pery.11IfJXI3<lHHIO OTmllElOOl oOll.\ei1 co6cTBeHHOCTJ.f, B OCHOBe 1\:OTO-
pbIXJIe>KaTpa3HbleKOHel1QID1: JIH,,!\HBJKOH1tenQl1H
J1 KOill\enl..\llil 06UUJocTI1.
J1H,!\I1Bt1)\yaJIHC'I'WI8CKaJ'l KOHQenQI1J'1 npl1paBHiIIBaE'T He TOJIbKO
caMY OOl1\HOCTb, HO J1 c06CTBeHHI1Ka J],OJII1 K nOJIOJoKemuo e,ZI;I1HO-
JII1'IHOrO co6CTBeHHiIIKa. IIopR,IJ;OK em1H. nOJIb30BaHI1H J1 pac-
nOpJ'ljKeHI1H BelItblO B qeJIOM J1 ,J\OJn1 B TffiCTHOCTJ.1 nOCTpoeH no 06-
pa3QY eJ\iIIHOJUI'IHOH COOCTBeHHOCTH, TO eCTb .lIJIE OCYl1\eCTBJIeHJ1R
npaBOMO<OOl co6CTBeHHOCTJ:! no OTH01lleHI:!lO I\: BelllI:! B l.\eJIOM He-
06XO,lJ;I:!MO Bblpa3J1Tb 06111Y1O e,IJ;l1HYlO BOJIKJ, a J1JIJI paCnOpJ,!)K€HJ1H
CBoeH .lIOJIeH .lIOCTaTO'lHO BOJII:! O,lJ;HOrO COc06CTBeHHI:!l\:a. J13 '1ero
CJle.ll)'eT, '1TO .lIOJIeBaJi c06CTBeHHOCTh paCCMaTpJ1BaeTCJI He I\:al\:
06ll1aH C06CTB€HHOCTh, a I\:al\: CI<ICT€Ma He3aBI<ICJ1MbIX npaB coc06-
CTB€HHI<II\:OB Ha .lIOJIJ1, 1\:0TOpbre B I<IX COBOK}'IlHOCTI<I 06pa3YlOT O,lJ;HO
npaBo.
.n;allliaH 1\OIJl.\8IllU1f.! nOHl1MaHIDI.lIOJI€BOH C06CTBeHHOCTII 6blJIa xa-
pal\:TepHa AJIH pm!CKOro npaBa, a 3aTeM aKK)'parno BOCnpmnlMaJlBCb
poccm.lcKm! 3BKOHO)J;BTeJIbCTBOM pB3HblX neplfOJ\£JB. HeKtYIUpb18 ee
01T0JiJCKJ1, HO He B a6comamoH pMe npORBJlHlOTCH B 3aKOHO,lJ;a-
TeJIbCTBe 4>paHl..II<I. <4>paHqy3CKIDi fpam,!\BHCKmf KO,lJ;eKC 1804 1'O,IJ;a,
IUlK J1 KlIaOCl'l'leCKOe pI1McKoe npaBO co CBOm!H 

TeH,I:\8HlU'1RM HaCTpoeHO, CKopee, Bpa)K,l\eOHO K ooeii:i: c06CTBeH-
HOCTI'!.  IIpaBOBaR Ha)'Ka YCMaTpl1BaeT CJ.1.I1bH)'IO nOMe-
xy ,l\J1R pa3B1TI'HR ooeii:i: cofJcTBeHHocom: B  xapaKTepe
c06cTBellliocTI1». '
fnaBHbIM IIpJl3Hal\OM CJW{8CI\(IU no)J;Xo perynl1-
pcEaH11f1 arH01llemm o6nteJl co6cTBeJrnocTu HBJIReTCR npl1HW1n e.n:l1-
HOrnaCJ1R, 3aJI»K8HHHH B OCHOay npl1HR'IWI peweIDIil, 
oCYliIeCTBJIemm Bcex npaBOMO'D1i1 co6cTBeHoocTIL ITocKo.nw\y coo-
CTBeHIDlK.n;OJIJ1 IIpl1paBHl1BaeTCH K KlI,lUmJr,uyaJIbIIOMy co6cTBeHHHKY.
TO COO'l1J8TCTI.\8lUIO peweIDfe :;rrnx BOnpOCOB, MJ1H.YH ero MHeIDIe. He-
B03M0KH0, TaK KBK 3TO H8.pywBeT ero I1CKJIlO'iJ1TeJIbHOe npaso COO-
CTBellliOCm, ero nOJlHoe rocno.n:CTBO HB.I\ BelltblO. Ra)K,l\brn- yqaC11l11K
oo.rra.n:aeT ius prohibendi (npasoM HaJIaraTb 3anpeT). 3anpeT HOCI1T
aocOJIlOTHbIi1 xapaKTep, pacilpocrpaHHeTCH Ha JllOObie peWeHI1H J1 cy-
.n;eOHoMy06maJIOBaHJ11O He nO,l\J1eml1T
CornaCHO npe,!\IIJ1caHI1JIM CT. 246-247 fKPIpBJIa.n:eHJ1e, nOJIb30aa-
HJ1e 11 pacnopRmeIDle S 0TH0Ill8HHJ1 06rn;ero HMYll\ecTBa 
eTCH no COmaweHJ1lO BCex COC06cTBeHHJ1KOB. B CJIy'lae He.n;OCTJ1iK8HJ1.H
CorJIaCI1R pe:iKl1:M BJIaJl8HillI J1 nom,aoBaHWI MomeT 6bITb YCTaHOBJI8H
cy.n;OM.
TIpJ1Hl.{J1II eJ\J1HOrnaCI1JI B oCYll\eCTBJIeHJ1J1 npaBOMO'llIi1 coc06-
CTBeHHOCTI1 Heo,!:(HOKpaTHO no.u;BepraJICR KpI1TJ1Ke. O.n:HaKo OH rny-
6oKO yiOOpeIDLIICH J1 nOJIY'Ufn npo'lHOe 060cHoBaHl1e B COBeTCKI1i1
nepuo,!\. M.B. 311Menesa, yxa3blBaJIa Ha TO, 'lT0 ::!TOT npt CO-
0TBeTCTBYeT ei1 TpBKTOBRe J1HCTJilTyra oorn;eii:i: C06cTBeHHOCTII
B COBeTCROM rpam,!l;aHCKOM npase RaR «HHCTI1Tyra, c.nymaero no-
'I'p€6wreJlbCKI1M lIeJIJlM. TIoCROJIbKY ;QOJL<l B 06efI C06cTBeHHOCTI'!
npe,!\Ha3Ha'leHa ,l\J1R y.n;OBneTBOpeHJ1H onpe.n;eneHHblX H}'m,!\ coc06-
CTBeHHI1KOB, peJ..IIeHJ1e Bonpoca no 60J1b1liJ'JHCTBYroJIocos rp0311T Jill-
IlillTb RaKOro-mroo KOHKpe'I'HOCOco.n;eJ»K8.IIIIHnpaBO MeHb11JJlliCTBa» 3.
)1.4:1. EpeMeeB IlO,Q'I8pKJ'1BaeT, 'ITO «IIptUllum e;UIHomaCHoro ynpaB-
JIeHWI ooeii:i: co6cTBeHHOCTblO caM no ce6e npe,!\IIOnaraeT HaH60Jlee
LteJleCOO6pa3Hoe J1CIIOJIb30SaHJ1e J1MYllIeCTsa 11 HaH60Jlee nOJIHOe
y.n;OBJIeTBopemle J1HTepeCOS Bcex Coco6CTBeHHtUWB, a He 6oJlbWJ1H-
CTBa113 HJ1X".,
'II.794;CoI11100ss
 Q.o_ r<anp. Macno8, B,Cl). Bonpoc", OI5uIeco6:T8eH"ocn< BCyIJ,SO"Onpa"",,'e_ M . 1963, c_ 25
33M"""""M.B 06LJ.jaRcOOc-r"""HOGTbBCO""'C.""fP'I>',O.3HC<OMflP'IOO "'cTh""l'lIaIIflBecrnMK
fP'I'I'JI,aHc.ororpaoo.M :OOOo1'i:>!l,lI.OMB.EMa..2009.T9, N04.C. 198.
.Eper.oee"ACl)_IlpaeoI1M.HOcoOcmettHocrnBcccprOCIOP"3I\!IT.rn5BC_7B
72

Tpe60BaIufe ,J\ocrIDKeHJ1R eJlI1HOr.nacJ1H He ,J\aer ffilKaKofI B03MOiK-
HOCTI1 JIJIH npJ.1HH'IWI perneIDIif B CJIy'lae OTcyrCTB"'-R COrJlaCJ.1H XOTH
6bl OJtHoro J13 COCo6cTBeHHJ.1KOB, 'lTO HeMlilH}'eMO 3BBO):\l1T B Tyru1K npH
pernemrn BonpoCOB, KOTOpble Tpe6}'JOT HeMe,l\JIeHH1I'O pearl1poBaH"'-R.
BOOMOiKHOCTb B CY,J\e6HOM nopH;J.Ke onpe.n;e.nRTb nopH.n;OK Bna,D;eHJ.1H
U nOJIb3OBBHlIfI 06eti BeI1tbKJ, 3TO, KOHe'IHO, cBoero po,!\a BbIXO,D; J13
I1OJt»K8HJt.R, HO CY,J\e6HaR ne.u;ypa HBJIReTCR,J\OCTaTO'lHO JlJlIITeJIb-
HoA, 3MOLPIOHaJIbHO J.1 MaTepl1aJlbHO aaTpaTHoif.
PerneHJ.1e 0 paCl1Opf!)KeHlfU 06I1tJ.1M UMyrQ8CTBOM MOiKeT 6bITb npl1-
HMO TD.nbKO coco6cTBeHmlKaMJ'I, J.1 HJ1KaKJ.1X BbIXO,J\OB B ABIDIOM c.ny-
'lae, 8CJllf COCo6cTBeHHJ1KJf He MOlYI' ,J\orOBOpJ.1TbCJI, aaKOH He ycraHaB-
.nHBaeT.
HeKOTOpbIM npoHBJi8HI'IeM mwecKoro nO,J\xo,!\a RB-
.nfleTCfl 3BRp8Il11811He oro npaBa JIOKYIlKH. KOTopoe
no CBoeif CYrl1 cnooo6cTByeT npeKparn:emuo 0TH0IIlelDW: o6u..Ieii c06-
CTBeHHOCTI1 U MruKeT C03,!\aTb no<my AJlR BblH)'iK,!:(eHHOif npo,!\a:Ha1
,!\OJIU coro6cTBeHmfROM, KOTopbili «YCTaJI» OT HeRO npaBO-
BOro coce,!\CTBa C ,J\pyrMIIU:I COBJIa,!\eJIb[tBMIiI.
IIHHOe npaBO nOKynKJ:I B eBpOIJeiiCKJ'lX npaBOIlO-
pH,!\KaX JIICIlOJ1b3}'eTCJI Kpai1He OCTOpOiKHO 1:1 «C'-JI:ITaeTCR trncnrry-
TOM ycTapeBIID:IM 1:1 He060CHOBaHHO ocpaID rpaiK,!:(aHcKJ:IA
o60pcrr»'.
J1IW1BI:I)J;)'aJllICTINeCKJrlI rrOJ\xOIJ; K pery.nJ.1poBBHIDQ ,lJ;OJIeBoi1
c06cTBeHHOCTJ.1 He MruKeT C'lI1TaTbCR Y,!\OBJIeTBopwre.nbHHM, 1l0J\Pbl-
BaH ee perryraQI1KJ HeIJO:3MOm.lK)CTb THBHOro yrrpaBJIem:lfl
OOlqID'l ID'IyrQeCTBOM, cBoJ\fllQeif K MIDfID'lYMY EO:3MOJKHOCTb 1\01'0-
BOpJ.1TbCR 0 nOpH.D;Ke BJIa,IleHJ.1R, rrOJIb3OBaH"'-R JII pacnOpIDKeHtffi Be-
lQblO, TaK KaK OqeHb BeJHfK p>fCK HeCorJIaCl<Ifl OJ\HOro 1:13 COCOOCTBeH-
HI1KOB. Bce 3'1'0 rropOiK,!:(aeT HeCBOeBpeMeHHOCTb IIpl1HHTl1fl Ba)KHbIX
JIJIH COOCTBeHHI1KOB peLUemdi, He::l1xPeKTI1BHOCTb yrrpaBJIeHI1H, 'iTO
B KOHe'lHOM HTOre Be1\eT K Ht1B8Hl:lJO caMoif l1,ZI;el1 06LQei1 1\0-
.n8B0i1 C06cTBeHHoc-rn: JII >KeJIaHI1KJ coco6c:-reeHHl1Ka npeKpaTI1Tb OT-
HOllleffilH co6cTBeIrnocrn..
JL;rn BTopOro TIlIIa peryJll1poBBffilH OTHOllleHIDI 06lQeif ,lJ;OJI8Boi1
COOCTBeHHOCTI1 xapaKTepHa KOHQenL{l1fl «06lQHOCTJ1». Ha 'faille BeCOB
B CJD3OCO'l8TaHI1I1 «OOIQBfl cc6:.-meIrn0CTh» lIepEBeIlll1BaeT TepMlilH
«OOIQaH». Bo r.naBY yr.na 3aKOHOj\3.TeJleM IJ()CT3EJI8HQ pery.nJllp0B3Hue
rrpoQecca m 06lQHoCTI1, KOTopaH  npaBo
'gH.s...heo"w6cItt.JuJ:st>sd>eKu"zOl..eht:iJt34.AuflageVerlagC,HBeckM(jnchen201C.
73

c06cTBeHHocTH B arHOIllf:'lOOl o6ero o&heKTa, a He npaBO c06CTBeH-
HOCTI'! OT,D;eJIbHoro coco6cTBeHHHKa Ha BeLltb H Ha,D;omo B Hei1.
B Ka'leCTBe xapaKTepHbIX ,D;JHi ,D;aHHOA KOHeI1QID1 npJ.13HaKOB
MOmHO HB3BaTb, BO-nepBbIX, npt1M€fl8HJ18 IIJ:MIIQJma 6omillnrnCTBa..
)1aHHblH npillll..\1111 C HeK01'OpblMJ.1 0006eHHOC'THMIf npe,!\YCMaTpHBaeT
3aKOHOJ\aTeJIbCTBO fepMaHHJ.1, IllBeapHJ.1 11 ABCTpIDI. Bo Bcex 31'11X
npaBOnopH,u;KaX npmUJ)"I1 eJ\illIornacml npMMeHfIeTCf! J\M npHHH'IWI
pewelll1i1 UIEOCJITeJlbHO pacnopmKeHMH BCelI BeLltblO B lJ;eJlOM J1 113-
MeH€fUtH lJ;eJleBoro HB3HaQemUI.l(eJIb 06ll.\eif BellJ;l1 ,D;M Kam,!\oro J13
COCOOCTBeHHI'IKOB - 31'0 CMbICJI }"'!aC1'11H B OOll.\HOCTYI, n03TOM)' 113Me-
H8Hl'le lJ;eJIl'l J1CIIOJ1b3OBaHMH BellJ;l1 Mom8T 6b1Tb OCHOBaHO TQJIbKO Ha
eAl'lHOrnaCHO npWHH1'OM peweIDDf ca:x:6:meHHJ.1KOB.
IIaparpaclJ 833 Bce06ll.\ero aBCTJJI'likKoro rpaiK,IIBHCKOro YJIOiKeIillfl
pa3JJJ1'laeT OObI'llfOe ynpaBJIeHl'le J1 '1p83BbI'WUroe, nOCJl8)\Hee nOMJ1:-
MO J13MeHeHl1H lJ;eJleBoro Ha3HaQeHMH BellJ;l1 BKJllO'ffieT B ceDH CYll.\e-
CTBeHHoe YJIY"Iw8Hl'le BellJ;l1, 3TH peWeHMH npt1Hl1MIDQTCH: e,!J.l1HorJlliC-
HO. BceocTaJIbHbJe peWeHMH -roJlOCOB.
BO-BTOPbIX, J\M KOffi\8IIqI1l'! «06I1J;OOCTII» xapaKTepHO yCI1J1eHHOe
,l\OI'OBOpHOe perYJII1poBaHl1e. TaB:, cor.naCHO  746, 1010 fry ,D;OrOBOp
Me MJiI B OTHOllIemm He,QBI'DKI1MOro JilM)'ll\eCTBa
MO:lKeT 6b1Tb 3apel1>1CTJll1PC'3a COCo6cTBeHHI1KaW1 B n03eMeJlbHoi1
KHJ.1I'e, B aTOM CJIy'laeOH 6Y1\eT 1\eAcrmrreJleH.l1J1H TpeTbHX JII<IT.I. IIpJ1-
06peTaX)Jl-\HX,D;0Jll0 B OY.lQ'Il\eM. .lI:aHHbli1,D;OrOBOpHBJlHeTCH rapaHTJilei1
6ecKoH  06ll.\HOCTJil1\a:>Ke npl'! CMeHe c06-
CTBeHHMKa 1\OJIl'l.
OTCyTCTBJiI€ peI"HC'l'pBI-\l npaBJiIJI BHyTpeHHerO peryJll1pOBaHJilH
B n03eMe.J1bmii KHHre BJle'leT HeJ\ei1c'rBJlT€JlbHOCTb 3TI1X npaBHJI
B OTtJOWeHI:IJ1 Tp8Tbl1X JII1I..\. HeMeL\KaH CY1\e6HaJI npaKTl1Ka UCXQD,J.fT
113 TOro, 'lT0, eCJll1 npo,':\aBeQ 1\0.1111 npl1HHJI Ha ce6H ofiR:3aTeJlbCTBO 1:13
BHyrpeHHHX npaBHJlI:I He 3apemc'ipJlpOBBJIl:IX B n03eMeJlbHoi1 KHI1re,
OH HeGeT 0TBeTCTBeHH0C'Ib 3a H8I1CIl0JIHeID18 npaBHJI ofnJ;HOC'D[, TaK
KaK, no,nmICbIBBH I:IX, OR 1\OJI:>KeH 6blJ1 nOID1MaTb, 'lTO OHl1l:1MeKJT 3Ha-
QeHl1e 1:1 WIH IIpI10DpeTaTeJlei1 J\OID! B 6y.lQ'Il\eM. 31'0 flBJlH8TCH OCHO-
BaHl1eMWIHnpI>1BJIe"leHMHeroK
AHamIWlHlde HopMbI CYIL\eCTBYIOT B ABcTpJ1iicKoM JII IllBetiQap-
CKOM rpa:>K,!\BHCKI1X YJlo:lKemrnx.
OAHOM J113 Ba:IKHei1WJIIX rapaHTJilM rapMOHH"IHoro CYIl\eCTBOBa-
HJIIH 06uJ;HOCTJ.f HBJlHeTCH npaBo TpeOOBaTb npeKpalL\eHJIIH 0611.\Ho-
CTJ.f B JII060M MOMeHT. HeB03MOmHOCTb cYIl\eCTBOBaHJilH ODll.\HOCTJII
B CI1JIY Hecnoco6HocTI1 IIpI1HHIb perneHHH, KOHKTHOCT}! JllJlJII
HanpH:lKeHHOCTJ1 M€)KJIY COCODCTBeHHJIIKaMJII, OTna,Q8HJile JIIHTepeCa

B cnonb30BaHU 06ero JIIMyllteCTBa BJle'leT B03MIDKHOCTb peaJIU-
3aql1M JIKJ5blM coco6cTBeHHMKOM npaBa Tpe50BaTh npeKpallleHHH
06I1tHocTI1 B lt8JIOM, a He TOJlbKO CBOeI'O y<ffiCTl1R B HeA. ITo  749 a53. 1
fry Ka:H<J\blfI yqacTHHK MomeT Tpe50BaTb B JIKJooe BpeMH oTMeHY
06I.J.nIoCTH, eCJIH Y'JaCTHHKJI CBOI1M COrJIaWeHJlleM He orpaHW.II1J1
aTO npaBO. Ecnl1 Y COC05CTBeHHI1Ka HeT JIIHTepeca B coxpaHeIDI
06I.J.nIoCTI1, OH MomeT B CYl1e5HOM nOpH,lJ.Ke Tpe50BaTh npeKpae-
mm 05HOCTJII, B aTOM CJIY'-Jae 06ll1aH Bellth nO,!\JIeml1T npol1ame,
a nOJIY'leHHble l1eHbrl111eJIHTCH Me)K)U' CoC05CTBeHHI1KaMM nponop-
1\110HaJIhH0110JIHM.
IIaparpat}> 650 llITY JII  B50 MY TaKiKe npe.D;yCMaTpl1BaKYr B03-
MC»KHOCTh OTMeHh! 06I.J.nIocTI1, eCJ1 OHa He orpaHIf'leHa l10nE0pOM.
011HaKO CYliIecTByeT MexaHl13M 3ahl 06l1\11x J1HTepecoB. ITpeKpa-
llIeHl1e06ei1co6c-rneHHOCTHHe110JDKHOHaBpeMH,lwr-
l1a coco6cTBeJIJum BhIH)'m,neH nOJIh30BaThCH 3TOH BellthKJ (HanpHMep,
KoM6afuI B nepHo,!\ yOOpKJ1 ypo:IKBH). 31'0 npaBl1JIo CJIY'KI1T BpeMeHHOH
OTCpotlKOii npeKpal1\eHI1H 06lltHOCTI1.
BwclID1M npoHBJI€HMeM 3al1\l1Thi 06l1\11x mrrepecoB HBJIHeTCH B03-
MC»KHOCTh TpeOOBaTb I1CKJIIO'ieHl1H H3 06IItmx:n1.lIaHHoe npaBo HMeeT
MecTO B lIIBefutapcKoM npasoncpH.lll\€, B KOTOpOM cYI1\ecTByeT npMH-
1\1111 BHHMaTeJIhHOrO HCIIOJIh3OBBHJUI npaBa'. 3.noyiIOTpe6neHl1e O.lUJ11M
113  CBOl1MnpaBOMHa 06uG'IDBellth
MomeT B pH,!\e CJIy'laeB C03,!\8.ThH8BhIHOCI1MWe YCJIOBJ.1H.J1JUIl1aJIhHei1:-
wero CYI1\eCTBOBaHl1H 06lltHOCTI1, 'ITO npI1BO.rr;J1T K BbIH}':IK.!I8HHOO npO-
,Qa»re 110M 11Jll1 npeKpal1\eHHKJ OOlltHOCTII CO CTOpOHW 006c-rneHHHKOB,
3aIDfTepE'C013aHHhIX B npaBe c06cmeHHoCTI1 Ha Bellth.
llnH cnpaBeAJ[I1BOI'O peryJIHpoBaHl1H 3TOi1 CJ.1ryawrn B nepo,!\ pe-
BJ.13ID'! lIIBei1qapcKOro 3aKOHo,!\aTeJIhcma 50-60 I'O,!\OB XX B. 6hlJ1a
BBe,!\eHa HopMa  649B llITY, n03BOmnOlljBJl J1CKJIlQ<taTh aCOql1aJIhHO-
ro nap-rHepa 113 061W10CTI1.
llnHOC}'ILIeCTBJIeHl1HI1CK..JiJO'{8HI1.Hco6JIlOCTJ1CJ1eJlY1O-
f1tI1e yCJlOBI1.H. «Bo-nepBhlX, npWlI1Hhl K:KJlK)q€HJU! ,ll;O.lDKHhl ne:IKBTh
B OOnaCTI1 OTHOIlleHl1ii COCOOCTBeHHI1KOB I1JII1 B OOnaCTI1 urnornemrn
Me)K)U'cy&beKTaMl1, KOTOphIMOOi1\BH BeIqh H B nOJIh-
30BaHl1e. 31'0 ,ll;O.lDKHhl 6WTh BeCKI1e npWll1Hhl, KOTOphle l1enaKJT npo-
,!\OJDK8m18 06I1\HOCTY! HeB03M01KHh1M J1 orrepI1pYH KOTOpbIMll CYAhH
MmKeT J1CKmO'lliTb 113 06Il\HOCTIL Bo-BTophIX, I1CKJiIO'I€Hl1e B03MOjf{-
HO TOJIhKO npY! HaJIH'lIDf BeCKI1X 0CH0BaHHi'i: KaK nOCJIe.lUJee cpe,!\CTBO,
I C"'.HeeOCQ<I6P>KaHI1,OI1HL.II1naBMS:teJlbHOrOOTHOLIJeHM"iJPVrKiJPVr'I"_
eroHecoOnIOPl'JH""HIIC.53I1!1(:T<)OUJel\paWb<

eCJUI Bce npe.uynpem.11eJU1H, 'IpffxEamm H HHhle npaEIOBI>E CIIOCO-
6101 He npmec.ml pe3}'JIbTaTa. B-TpeTb1r<, Ha,WII2)KalWm I1CTeLl - aTO
cy5"beKT, KOTOpOMYHaHOCI1TCflBpeiJ:HaOOIltYIOBelltb.
Pem8HJ112 0 nO'Ie I1CKa JJ;OJDKHO 6b1Tb npJ1HJ'lTO 6onbnnrn.C'I13OM r0J10-
COB cocOCicTBemrnKoB. Ha.lVlemaLW1M OTBeT'iJ'JR'OM MC»KeT 6b1Tb COCOO-
CTBeHIDlK, a TaKiKe 1I0JIb30BaTeJlb Bel1tl1, J1I15o BJIaJ\eJleLl orpaIDPIeH-
HblX BeLlUlbIX npaB J.fJlJ1 npe,!1;BapWreJIbHblX JIJ1'IHblX npaB (Hanpl1Mep,
npaaa npeHM}'lQ8CTB8I1HOO noK)'IIID'l). TaKI1M oopa30M, B03IrnKaeT
-npaBOOOM rpam,!\BHCKl1if cnop. ECJIJ1 CYrBeT'll'lKOM Bbl-
crynaeT cof:crnem!lfK, TO BblHOCHTCH CY,lJ;eOHOe peWeHl1e a COBep-
IlleID111 ,lJ;ei1:CTm1i1 BO I1cnOJlHeHl1e OOJI3aTeJlbCTBa no OT'IY>K;J;eHI1lO
ero ,lJ;OJlI1; eCJlI1 arBeT'iHKOM Bl>!CTynaeT BJla,lJ;eJleLl orpaHl1'leHHoro
Bell\Horo 11.1111 npe,!\BapmeJIbHoro JlI1'IHoro npaBa, BblHOCMTCH KOH-
c:-rmyrHBHoe pemeHl1e, 06 OTMeHe npaBa IIOJlb30BaHI1J'1, TaK KaK
orpaHI1QeHHOe BE'llUIOe npaBO H JII1'lHOe npe,II,BaplITeJlbHoe npaBO He
OT'lyiK,!\aeMO H He nepe,!\8BaeMO» '.
JJ;ornJIHJ1T8JlbHOii rapaHTl1eH c06J1lOtl8H11R OOIl\MX mrreperoB HB-
JIJ'leTCJ'I orpaIDf'leHl1e B pacnopJ'liKE'HID:! ,lJ;OJIei1. lihrrepeCHbIM He TOJIb-
KO C TO'IKI1 3p8Hl1R np:iIICEOii npl1pO)J;b1 ,l\OJlJ1, HO H C TO'IKI1 3p8Hl1R
llpaBOBO:W npl1pO)J;b1 npaBa o6ntefi: JJ,OJIesoii co6cTBeHHocTu B LleJlOM
npeAC'ffiBJi.He'fC BOnpOC 0 B03MmKHOCTIl OTKa3a OT ,l\OJlJ1 O)J;Hl1M 113
COCOOCTBeHHI1KOB. Hau6o.nhrny1o aK'I}'aJIhHOCTh 11 npalmf'lecK}'lO 3Ha-
'lI1MOCTb :flOT Bonpoc l1MeeT B fepMaHl1t1, TaK KaK JJ;OCTaTO'lliO JJ;JII1-
TeJlbHOe BpeMfl H ,lIORTptfHa, 11 npaKTHKa Ha OCHOBe 3BKOHO,I],8TeJIbHhIX
npeJ],TItiCaJOOl C'lMTaJlJ1:flOT BapMam paCIIOpJDKeHHJ'l ;I\OJIei1 B03MOiK-
HblM, OtIHaKO B03IOOQillI8 Ha npaK'IllKe CJrryal.IIDl 3BCTaBI1JII1 nepecMo-
TpeTb;naHHYIO
TIaparpaclJ 137 ITY IIpeJ\,YcMaTpl1BaeT B :Ka'IeCTBe oOll\ero IIpI1H-
l.\I1na npaBo Ha cB06oJ\,Y pacnopmKeHIUI, KOTopym H8B03Mt»KHO orpa-
HWIMTb c,I:\8JIKOJI, 'ITO nOtlpB3YMeBaeT H npaBo Ha OTKa3 OT JJ;0JI11 B TOM
'lI1CJIe. TIpe,!\ffifcamrn 3aKOBa He npOTIlBopeGaTHanpOTI1B, ,lJ;OnYCKalOT
B03MOmHOCTb OTKa3a OT npaB 11 o6HaamrocTei1I. KOTOpb!e BblTeKalOT
t13 JJ,OJIeooUOOll.\HOC'!'J1. Ho B!lOJIHe B03MOmHO, 'ITO BH)"!'p11 caMoif ,lJ;OJll1
eCTb orpaHl1"IeHMe lIB CYrKa3.
Bonpoc IIJ,IJ,HtIMaJlCfl HeOtIHoKpaTHo cY,lJ;eomri1: npaKTJU«rii B CBJ'l311
C ofuKanoBamteM ,lJ;8i.icrBHii no OTKa3Y OT ,lJ;OJII1 rernBllIJ.1MncH cocoo-
CTBeHHl1KaWf. TIOCKOJIbKY, ,lJ;0 TOro KBK $pr.n1pOBB.JJaCb COBp€MeH-
HaJJ cy,lJ;eOHaH IlpaKT1fKa. ,lJ;OKTpJ.fHa 11 npaBOIIpI1M8IDIe OpraHb!
. I-I sc;,8rund1aget>des Sachenrechlsund Eigentum. 3 erg. un LtJerarbeil. Aut! Bern: St!Impfti.
76

npl13HaBaJ1J:l B03MIDKHI:lM OTKa3 OT ,n0JU:l, MHOme CJIY'lal1 OTKa3a 6blJI11
3apeOK:IpnpoBaHhI B I1OOeM2J1hHoi1: KIDlre
B Ka'leCTBe npl1Mepa npl1Be,neM Cnyqa.f!, paCCMOTpeHHbifl 3e-
MenbHb1M Cy,nOM r. KOHCTaH!{ Coco6cTeeHHI1K 6acceflHa XOTen OT-
Ka3aTbCR OT ,nOJ1J:l B CoOCTBeHHOCTI1 B CBJI3I1 C OTcyrcTBl1eM I1HTepeCa
K ,naHHOMY OO'beKTY nocp8.llCTBOM pertI1 COOTBeTCTBYlOl1\erO
3aJIBJIeIDIR B nooeMeJIbHOi1: KIDIre no  928 fry. Cy,n 3eMJII1 npl13Han
HeB03MO)KIIl:D!! oTKa3, TaK KaK 06Il1HoCTb He MomeT npeKpall\aTbCH
B CI1JIY  11 3aKOHa 0 COOC'l'BeHHOCTI1 Ha KBapTl1py, a TalOKe nOTOMY,
'1TO TaKoe pacncpHmeHJ1e ,nOJlei1 B JJ;OJIeBoi1 co6cTBeIrnOCTJII1CKJnO-
'1eHO.
EcJrn 05paTI1TbCR K tlCTOptlH perynt1poBaHl1.Fl3TOro BOrIpoca, B  950
nepBoro npoeKTa fry 6bUIa B03MillKHOCTb OTKa3a OT JJ;OIDI B Co6cTBeH-
Hocm no 06 npe,QIH1CaHI1HM 0 co6cmeflHtX.'"IH; OOnblID1HCTBO 'lJIe-
HOB 'I"8J1bllOii KOMl1CCI1I1, 06cym,n;alOI1.1ei1npoeKT, C'II1TaJ103'ry
TO'IKY 3pemm npam1.JIbHOi1, HO 1Ip8.l\0CTaBHJIJf 3T01'BOIIpoC wm pewe-
IDIH HaYRe 11 npaRTIlKE'2.
C,IJ;epmaHHOCTb 3aKOHO,IlBTeJIJI B KOHe'IHOM I1'I'Ore BOCIIOJllDfJIaCb
ctiJopMl1pOBaBlill1MCR MHeHl1eM ,nOKTpmIb! 11 CY,l\e6HOtf npaKIJIKtf,
KOTOpoe OT'faJIIDmaJIOCb OT cnro. O.l\HOCTOf)(JHHRii 0TKa3 co-
BJl8J\eJIbrtB OT era ,n0JIJ1 C npl1pall\eHl1eM 3TOi1 ,l\0JU:I K ,l\OJIRM .n;pyrnx
COBJI8J\eJIbl.\eB HeB03MomeH, TaKKaK TaROf! OTKa3 ,IJ;eJIaeT ,IJ;OJIIO 6ecxo-
3Hi1:H0i1 (928, 958 frY). OrKa3 C IIOCJI8J\CTBII8M, '1TO ll\Ife
,QO CI1X nop HapRAY C npaBoM, OT KOTOporo OTKa3a.m1Cb, npaBa pac-
1ill1pHlUI"CR. cyu\eCTB)'eT B Tex OTHollIemmx, r,l\e eCTh MecTO orpaHY!-
'i€HHOM)' BeIllH0M)' npaBY 11 npasy cooCTBeHHOCTI1 ( 877 frY). B Cl1ny
IIpJI3Haffil aJIaL"I'J.1'IHOl npaBa cooCTBeHHOCTY! OTKa3 OT orpaHJ.1'leH-
Horo npaBa BOOCTaHaBJD1BaeT nOJIHary OCHOBHoro npaBa, HO Me:m;.!ly
MHCOt<eC"IEOM cOOCTBeHHI1KOB B03MillKHa TOJIbRO nept?AB'Ia ,IJ;0JrI1, a He
HaBJI3ldBaHIle 1J[JIIOJIHI1'T8JIbI wTIeii 0"I'Ka30M c nOCJIe,ll;CTBIteM npl1-
pall\eIDUl. TaKI1M 06pa30M, €AJflICTB€HHbIM IJOCJJe,l\CTBJ1M 0"I'Ka3a OT
npaBa HBJIHeTCH OOpa30BaIDIe 5ecxo3mfHoii BeLW1- ECJII1 HMeeTCH OT-
pe'leHl1e OT ,Q0JI11, KOTopaH paBHa, HalIJ:&1Mep, 1/8, HproW 6bIJ1o npe.n;-
CTaBJlHTh ceoe, '1TO Belqb MOmE'T C'I1UiOBI'1ThCH 6ecx03m"iHoM HB l/B.
TaR me KaK HeB03MOmHO IIp8.l\CTIUIIITb cYIl\eCTBOBaHt:le 6ecxmffi.iHoi;j
BeLql1 Ha 1/8, TaK me HeB03MOiKHO npe,l\CTaBl1Tb, 'ITO HB 7/8 aHa Ha-
XO.n;wrCHB
'C...:N.m-RRI989.1424,LGKoostaJllaaO.Wlhelm.SaItErmchIS.87
'C...Wlhelm.hlS_8B

K BbIBO.ny 0 HeB03MOHOCTI1 OTKa3a OT ,noJII1 MOHO npWim,
eCJII1 }"IeCTb nOCJIe,lJ;CTBI1H 06u.iei.f COOCTBeHHOC'IJf. ,lJ;OJIeBaJ'l c06-
CTBeHHOCTb XapaKTepl13yeTCJ'I TeM, 'lTO ee npe,lJ.MeT He,I\eJItfM. CO-
COOCTBeHHI1KI1 COOOll.\B OCyIlIecTBJUDOT npaBOMO'lI1fl, B 'laCTHOCTI1
I1CnOJIb30BaHl1e, nOTOM)' B t1TOre OHI1 Hecyr 06I.l411e paCXO.n;b!. ,lJ;0-
JIeBaJ'l 06lltHoCTb }"Ipe)J;aeT COBMeCTHble npaBa 11 OOJ'l3aHHOCTI1.
,lJ;OJII1 ,lJ;ei.fcTB}'ID1' O,!\I1lICUWBO t1 caMOCTOJ'lTeJIbHO, KpOMe B03MO-
HOCT" pacTIOpHeH"J'I TIP" ro.nOCOBaH"11 no noBO.ny OTIpe,lJ;eJIeH"J'I
nopH.n;Ka I1Cno.nb30BaHI1J'1 Bel1, pacnpe,lJ;eJ!eHI1H ,[IOXO,!\OB t1 pacxo-
,[lOB. Ka':leCTBO He,QeJIHMOCTJ1 npe.n;MeTa Be.n;eT K TOMY, ':ITO He MO-
:meT I1MeTbCH O€CX03JIiiiHocTIt: B8llV1 B ,[IoJ!e. Becx03ffiIHOCTb ,[IOJ!11
He MOmE'T OTpamaTbCH B OrpaHJf'ieHI1" I1CnOJ!b30BaHI1JI BeI.l4l1. To,
':ITO KaCaeTCH H€CeH"H 5peMeH" co.n;epmaH"H Be" 11 nOJ!yqeH"H
,l\OXO.n;OB, OHI1 Bee paBHO ,l\OJ!HbI ocyrn;eCTBJIHTbCH. Kpe,l\J.1TOpb!
He MorYT BbiCTaBJUlTb MeHbill"e C'leTa 113-3a arcyTCTBI1JI Y 0)I,H0i1
,l\OJUI COOCTB8HHMKB. To, ':ITO KaCa€TCH ,lJ;OXO.n;OB 113 06ei.f B8llV1, TO
'ffiC'DNHaH 6ecx03IDiH0cTb Be" B ':IacT" ,[IOJIJ'! Be,l\eT K TOMY, ':ITO
COOTBeTcTByIOJ1W,H 'lliCTb ,[IOXO.n;OB ,lJ;OJ!Ha pesepBMpoBaTbCH ,l\J!H
6YAYero X03SII1HB. BCJIe,lJ;cTB"e :'ITOm OCTaJlbHble npaBOMO'iHble
rpa»Q:laHe OblJ!l1 Obi 06peMeH8Hb! ynpaBJ!eH"eM BeIl{l1 B 'iBCT" 5ec-
x03HiiHoro .n;OXOAa 11.0 Tex nap, nOKa KTO-TO He penHITCH HB IIP"CBO-
8Hl1e 11.0.1111. B npMBe.n;eHHOM Bb!llle npJ.1Mepe I1J!aBaTeJ!bHblfi 6accefiH
H3XO,!\J.1TCH B ..r\OJ!€BOi1 co6cTB8HHOCTI1. ECJ!" O,!\"H IIpeKpaaeT I1C-
nOJlb30BaHM€ 113-3a OTKaaa OT 11.0JlM, KOHe'lllO, 6Y,[leT Ha6J1lO,!\8.TbCJ'I
cna11. t1HTeHCI1BHOCTI1lfCl10JIb30BaHI1H. 011.HaKO:'lTO 3aBI1CMT OT TOro,
KaK 'lliCTO OR nOJlbaOBanCH 6acceMHOM. ECJlM O..r\I1H paa B He,[l€JllO,
a nOTOM nepeCTaJi nOJlb30BaTbCH, TO B noJlb30BaTeJlbCKOM OTRO-
illeHl111 OTKa3 OT 11.0Jll1 Hl1'Iero He MeHReT, HO B nJlaHe HeCeHI1J'1 6pe-
MeHI1 paCXOJ\OB y OCTRBIill1XCH COCOOCTBeHHI1KOB I1X 6Y,[leT 60Jlbille
npl1 Heoll..\,Y'I'llMOM yaeJ!Jf'ieHI1I1 K03tlJqmL\l1eHTa nOJlb30BaHJL<I. ECJlI1
,[IOXO)J;bl npl106peTaKYf cTaTYc 5ecX03HihIocTJI, OHI1 He MOryT t1C-
nOJlb30BaTbCH OC'I'aIOIWIMJICH Coco6CTBeHHI1KaMI1. 31'0 3Ha'II1T, 'ITO
OCTaBill"eCJ'I COc06CTBeHH"K", eCJlI.1 OR" He XOTJ'lT npl1HI1MaTb npaBO
COOcTB8HHOCTM Ha ,l\OJllO OTKa3aBillerOCH, 11.0JlHbI OblJ!l1 Obi TeM He
MeHee ynpaBJlHTb 11.0J!ei1 ,lJ;oxo)J;a,lJ;J!J'I 0YAYll.\ero COOCTBeHH"Ka. By-
J\eT JII1 OCYll.\eCTBJl8HO B03MeLQ;eH"e paCXO,!\OB nptl nOCJ!eTJ.Y1Oll.\eM
npI106pE'TeH"M ,[IOJII1 TaR :me HeI43B€CTHO, KBR 11 caM .paRT npMo6-
peTeHI1J'1. TaKI1M 06pa30M, OpeMJ'I co.n;epmaHI1J'1 t1MYll.\eCTBa HeMI1-
HYeMO Obi 06peMeIDIJ!O OCTaBillI1XCJ'I }"IacTH"KOB 06W;HOcTI1. B03-
MeeHl1e pacxO,!\OB npl1 BQ3MO)KHOM 60J!ee II03)I,HeM npl1CBOeHI1I1
78

COY'JaCTI1fI C06CTBeHHOeTI1 HeJ13BeCTHO, KaK J1 CaMO npJ106peTeH1fe
npaBa c06cTBeHHocTI1.
TromM 06pa30M, OTRaS OT )J;0JIJ1 HeEIO.3MIDK8H, Ta.R KaK HeM>fH}'8MO
3aTparHBaeT 061W'1e J1HTepeCbl
IIo.zc<o'!\, J'136pa.Hm.m 3aROHO,IlBTeJIeM TOi1 J1JI11J1H0i1 CTpaHbI, npe,ZJ;o-
npe,!\eJUleT pa3Hoe perYJll1poBaHI1e OTH01lleHIm 06 J],OJIeBOfi c06-
CTBeHHOeTI1 C }'KJIOHOM.m16o B CropOHY J'lliJJ.JfBu.nyaJIbHOO cclJepb!, .m.roo
o6ei1. PocOOCROe 3BKOHO,,!\aTeJlbCTBO MC»KHO O,!\H03Ha'lHO oTHecrn K
nepBoM)', oCHoBaHHoM)' Ha HHJI.i'fBUJJYB.IDfCTJl'-lecKOM no,!\Xo,!\e npaBo-
BOro perymtpOBBHHR. fepMaHI1.R, ABCTpI1.R J1lIIBefutapl1.R, C TeMI1I1JI11
JlllblMJf OCOOeHHOCTHMI1, 1136paJII1 .AJlH ce6H J1HOi1 nyrb, oCHoBaHHbrn
Ha 6aJIaHee t1HTepecoB Kam,lloro J13 yqacTIDlKOB JJ,OJIeBOii: 06lltHOCTI1,
Ha yct1JIemlt1 KOpnOpaTJ1BHOCl1l B OTHOWeHt1RX u6et1  c06-
CTBeHHOCTt1
IIpoeKT fR p.p' B l..\eJlOM COXpaHI1JI J1H,I\I1BJf.IlYaJlJ1CTt1'leCKJilif
no,!\xo,!\, '1TO BbIpamaeTcfl B coXpaHeHI111 npJ1HLl>ma e,!\J1HOrJlaCt1H
(n. 1 CT. 277), ,Qonyw;eHI1I1 B03MOmHOCTI1 oT"Iym,!\eHJilfl '1aCTI1 ,J\OJII1
B O,!\HOCTopoHHeM nopfl,!\Ke (n. 2 CT. 276), cOXpaHeHI1JII npel1e-
CTBeHHoro npaBa nOKynKI1 (CT. 278). Ho TeM He MeHee yrnJIeHb!
n0311QI1I1 06lI{HOCTI1 ,J\OJIeBb!X co6cTBeHHI1KOB, '1TO npOflBJIfleTcfl
B 3aKpenJIeHI1M B03MOmHOCTJII pacnpOCTpaHeHMH ,J\eifCTBJ1fl co-
rJIaWeHI1fl COco6cTBeHHI1KOB Ha npaBonpeeMHMKOB (n. 5 CT. 277),
HOBOro MexaHI13Ma npeKpaWeHl1fl 06WHOCTM. nocpe,J\cTBoM rrpo-
,J\amJf BeIQI1 (n. :3 CT. 280).
I OHeCeHMM """"'''''H acntnepB\'ID, TopyIO, -.peTblOMeToePT\'IDrHCKOroKQIII!KCaPoc
CMKOOpalIMM,aT""""'owenbl<"e"""'pallVO<J1po
eKT4>eAepanl>MOrO:sa'OHa_,l]aTaepeoiiO><"n\'6JlMK3L1M"07.o22012J/hItp_II__
'!I_ru/2012j02/07,...-se-doI<tImI
79

rnaBa 5. KOHL\Ent-ll151 PA3BI1TI151
I1HCTI1TYTA 05LL-1Ei1 C05CTBEHHOCTI1
B rpA)I(,/J,AHCKOM
3AKOHOAATEnbCTBE
POCCI1i1CKOi1 <!JE.!:\EPAL\1111
npe3Jl,!(eIITOM Pefl ll.A. Me,!1;Be,!l;eBblM 18 J1lO.IDI 200B r OblJl J13,!J;aH
YKa3 NQ 1108 «0 cOBepllleHCTBOBaID111 I'pa>K,z:\aHaroro KO)\eKea Poc-
CJIWcI«JJ1 4te.1\epalUU1-. Ha ero OCHOBaHl111 6blJIa paapaOOTaHa If npl1-
mlTa KOHI..\el1l.l!1H pa3Bl1TJ'UI rpam,!\BHCKoro aaKOHO.I\aTeJIbCTBa Poc-
I«Jit: 4te.1lepaLtIDI ee - ROln.\eI1H). BCOO'f138"l"C'TI C 3TI1M>1
,l\OK)'MeHTaMY! COBeTOM npM npe3M,!J;eHTe Pefl no KO,!J;Jl(4w!1rn.lJ;I1l1 J'! co-
BepllleHCTBOBaID11O Ipcrnv:\aHcKoro 3BKOHOJ\BTeJIbCTBa OblJl nO)l;I'OTOB-
JleH npoeKT eHHji B rK Pefl (.IIanee - npoeKT rK PcfI), KOTOpbrn
3B"IpOHYJI pa3;J;eJIbI 1-3, 6, 7 rKp<to.
ITpoeKT rK P<I:o MHQI11e JlCC.TJ.8JPBaTeJll1 Ha3bIBaIQT He npOCTO 3BO-
JIIOQJ10HHbIM lTaIIOM pa3BIITIm rpam,!J;aHCKoro aaKOHO)\aTeJIbcTBa,
a CBOerQ pop;a peB0JIJ0qK8i1'. Oc06eHHo 0HHbIMJ1» KBmJTCH
OOJIO:IKeHI1R, KaCalOIqH:eCH BeIWIbIX npas. He 060lllJIJ1 BtillM3.HYleM 38-
KOHO,lJpTeJll1 J1HC=yr 06rn;ei1: co6c"I1J€HHOCTI1, KOTOpbrn Tffiepb npY!-
06peJl oOIqMe JI.IDI J];OJIeBoi1 M OOBMeCI1I:oH cc6cTBeHH0cTIl IIOJIOiKeIDIH,
3aKp€IJJIeHIille B  1 r.naBhI 19, 1f3MeH€HO perYJll1poBaHJ1e pacnpe-
,l\eJIeffi'JH IIJIO.n;OB npo..QyKL\ID1 J1 JlOXO,!\OB, YCTaHOBJIeHa B03MmKHOCTh
pacnopmKeHWi 'laCTblO )J:OJ1ei1: J1 o6pa30Baffile ,nOJleBoi1 cc6cTBeHH0cTtl
lIB He;I\enl1MYIO Bellth, HaXO)\Jll1\YIOCH B coocTBeHHOCTI1 o.n;Horo JHIQa
Ii T-A MHorne 113 3T11X MeHeHJ.1ti MOiKHO Ha3BaTb J\
HO He Bce HOpMbI Kayrc:H 3aBepllleHHbJMM. AHa.m13Y OCHOBHUX I1JIa-
lD'lpYeMbIX 8IIJU16Y,!J;eT nOCBHil.IeH.D;aHHbrM pa3,!J;eJl pa6oTbl.
CTaTbH 276 n. 2 {(PaCnOpH)KeUHe I1MYll\eCTBOM, uaXOAHll\HM-
CH B AOJJeBOif co6cTBeHHocm» npe.n;ycMaTpm3aeT npaBO )"IacTHWKa
.D;OJIeml co6c-rnemIOCTH <<TIO cBoeMyycMcrrpemnonpoTb, no.n;apwrb,
3aBeil.lBTb, CYr.n;aTb B 3aJ10r CBOIO .n;0JI1O ('IacTh .n;OJIH) JIH60 pacnopH-
.D;l1TbCH elO HHblM 06pa30M C co6Jno.r:\eHl'18M npH ee B03Me3,[I,HOM O"I"I)"K-
.n;eHHH npaBHJI, npe,!J;,)'cMarpeHHb!X CTaTbefI 278 HaCTOJlliIero KolleKea.
eCJIH HHoe He YCTaHOBJIeHO 3aKOHOM.
'CM.ee)J6l1LII<8RIO.O.l-leec"Me.HbIt!"')'HIffiIPH..e()praHl13aU,11M'HlpoeKTerpa;t;.
AaH,,"oroKO)lel<caPocc""CI<oMllrP6'Kl1llHCI<OOnpaElO.2011""'lc_ZJ
80

.n:0J1 B npaBe co6cTBeHHocTH He MO>KeT 6bITb pa3,Dp06.neHa coc06-
CTBeHHHKOM Ha IJacm, eenH3TO nOB.neIJeT HeB03MO>KHOCTb B.na)J;eTb
H no.nb30BaTbC IJaCTbKJ 06mero l1M)'meCTBa, copa3MepHoA IJaCTH
3TOM ,ll0Jrn, B c.ooTBeTC'I'BHJl C ero Ha3HaIJeHHeM»
B KoHLIemuul pa3BJTI11fI rpa.mJJPllCI«JrO 3aKOHO,D;aTeJIbCTBa 3B'Ipa-
nmaJICfl Bonpoc 0 cnoco6HOCTJoI ,ll0Jrn B npaBe  co6cTBeHHocTt1:
,llp06HTbCR Ha IJaCTH. EblJW OTMe'leHO, 'ITO «cofJcorBeJrnHKu He)I.BIDKJ1-
Moro TBB, nOJIb3YCb TeM, IJTO Kpyr oCHoBaHIDI, no KOTOpbIM
Belltb MC»KeT nOCTyru1Tb B o6IJ.tYIO co6cTBeHHOC'I'b JJ.Byx I1JIH6o.rree JII1'--1,
BeCbMa BeJIl1K (n. 4 CT. 244 rK), HepeAKO no.nb3 CBOJ1M npaBoM
He.l\06poooBeCTHO. ITa CBoeM)' YCMarpeIDIKJ OHH pa3Gl1BaIDI' e.I\illlOe
npaBo co6cTBelrnocTJ. Ha «KapmmoBHe» ,ll0JIJ1 TJ1na 1{100, 1{32 t:I
T.n.»'. .n;aHHble,neifCTBHf! 0CYll\ecTBJIKJl'CH B OCHOBHOM B OTHowemrn
He.I\Bt:I>KJ.1Moro JIMYllI8CTBB.. IJTO IIpJ1BQlI,JIT K HapyweHJIIKJ 3eMeJlbHoro
">KtfmOltHOI'O 3aKOHO)J;a'I'€JlbCTBa. .IJ:a.m,Hefunee pa3BHTI1€ 3Ta MbICJIb
nOJl.Y'l".1la B n. 2 CT. 276 npoeKTa fK P<P, COrJIaCHO KOTOpOM)' «y'IacT-
IDIK.I\o.neBati: co6c-meHHfJC"IH BnpaBe no CBoeM)' YCM0Tp8mno rrpo,!IBTb,
rrO,D;apHTb, 3BBeTb, OT,l\BTb B 3a.nor CBOID ,llomo ('IaCTb ,llOJIH) .m16o
pacnopH,!\I1TbCH eID "HbIM o6pa30M C c06.mo,!\elilleM rrpH ee B03Me3,!\-
HOMmm:rrpaBI1JIOrrpelIM)'IQE'CTBeHHoMnpaBerrOKJIIKI1, eCJII1
"Hoe He ycTBHOBJIeHO 3aKOHOM>}. A63B'--I BTopoA IL 2 CT. 276 YCTaHaB-
Rl1BaeT mpailll'ielme, B COCYIEeTCTIIJ'1 C KOTopbIM «,IJ;ORH B npaBe coG-
CTBeHHoCTH He MO>KeT 6b1Tb pa3,QpOO.rr8HB COCo6cTBeHHMKOM Ha IJaCTI1,
€CJlI1 3TO rrOBJlE"IeT HeB03MmKHOCTb BJlB.I\eTb" rrOJlb30BaTbCH "iaCTbIO
oGll\ero HMYll\ecma, copa3MepHoi1 'lBcTH3TOM .I\OJlH, B COO"I'II8T('"IBiI C
ero Ha3HaQetrneM'?,
AHaJIJ13 Hay<rnoif JII1T8paT)'pbI 1IOI\a3bIBa8'T, IJTO B OCHOBHOM B03-
MOiKHOCTb O'NJiK,!\eHI1JI IJacTH,IJ;OJrn OTPMQaeTCfI. ::ho apr)'MeHTMpy-
eTCHrro-pa3HOM)'. HeKOTOpbleasTOpbl yKa3b1BaKJT, 'ITO «,IJ;OJUI B npase
He paCCMaTpHBaeTCH KaK Beua. 1>1 COOTBeTCTBE'HHO K Hei1 HenpHM€HH-
MbI rrpamfJla 0 ,IJ;eJD1MIXTI'I Bell{8W'. O)J;HaKO XOTeJIOCb 6b1 OTMeTIITb,
..TO ,lJ;OJUll1,ll;eaJIbHa, H ec.ID1 npl13HaeTCR cnoco6HoeTb npaBa .I\eJlJilTb-
cH Ha .I\0JIJiI, TO MO>KHO rrp€JIIIClJl{»KtITb, IJTO 3TI1 ,lJ;OJll1 Moryr ,lJ;eJIWTbCH
ABJIbllIe, 'I'€M 6o.rree 'ITO saKOH 31'0 II03BOJm€T, Hanpl1Mep, npl1 HaCJIe-
)J;OBaHI1M.
'KOHII<!I1I1'1S1pa3."""'fJ>'D<,Oaf£KOro"""OHQlIOTeJlbGTBaO_MO"M,M.2004.C,13.
. OHSCeHMM _H";; m3.(;JM"epByIO, TopyJO. -.pe-roooMe-roepT)'lOrpa;o;o,aHc.orOKQ,o,eKcaPoc.
cM"",,<I>w1epallL'.8TSIOI<e"01;!1eJ1"""'e6l<TblPoccco<oIIIeJ\epaIlL'M'1lpoeo<r
<l>e,D.epa.nblllJll)""""""m07.o2,2012,URL,/lhtlp://WHN,rg.ru/2012j02/0 7 trJH>llElI<KJ1rrj
JrPi1waesc.n.r1P<:6leM,"i!HM"npaaa06L!19iil'lOJl98Oiico6<:JSeHlIO(;JMlia_"Moe
"''''YL$CTIIO/lIl<wOToMeHA""CMCTe_.'oq.,.'.nll.rooc,2005
81

)4>yme aBTOpbl }'Ka3b!BaKYl' Ha TO, 'ITO «11paBO, HaOOOpar, CTpe-
Mm'CR npeKpaTm'b COCmillilie 06w;ei1 COOCTB8HHDCTiII ill CTillMY.lli1pyeT
STOT npou;ecc. OrCID.!\B 6epyr CBoe HalJaJlO 060p0T0cnoco6HOC'I'b ;nOJlill
B 06ll.\Bf co6cTBeHHocn111 npaBo npel1oj;f nOKyrIKl1 ;nOJlill.
II03TOMY .JI()JI8BOR coco6cTBeHHJlK He I1MeeT npaBa ;np06uTb CBOID
;nOJlID 11 OT'IYTb ee no 'IaCTJlM. KpoMe TOro, npaBo ;nOJleBoiii: c05-
CTB8HHOCTl1 He MO}KeT pacnpocrpaHHTbCJI Ha caMY ;noma B npaBe 00-
eiii: co6cTBeHHocTI.t KaK Ha 06'beKT, He JlBJIffiOCfI OO'beK'l'OM npaBa
c06cTBellllocTI1» '. JryMaeTCH, 'ITO npl1 oT'lym.n;eHI1I1 '!aCTI1 ;nOJlill HOBaH
;nOJleBaH co6CTBeHHoCTb 06pa:3oBbmaTbcH He MIDKeT, HO caMS no ceoe
,l\OM, nOCKOJlbKY OHa J1,ZJ;eBJIbHa 11 Bbipa>Ka€TCH JIJ11lIb B IDf,I\e MBTeMB-
TwreCKOiI ;npoOI1, MO}K8'1' ,l\eIDITbCH 11 lIB MeHblill:le '!acTI1.
KH. CRJIOBCKi'1if: OTMe'ffieT, '1m «caMS no ceoe nepeMIJa B nopM-
Ke CT. 3132 He BCex UMelOIqI'lXCR -rpe6osnm:i1, a IJaCTI1I13 HID:: B03MmKHa
nOTOMY, 'ITO npI13TOMHe YXYJIIIIBeTCJl11QJ10:meHJ1e ,l\OJDKlIID\B, OOJI3BH-
HOCTl1 KOTOporo He l13MeHHeT TOT KT, '1m onp8J\eJleHHble OM33.T€JIb-
CTBa OH J1CID.1lHR8T B OTHOIlI8H11I1 J1HOro Kp8;nwrcpa. Ho B CBJl3J1 C TeM,
'ITO TaKO€' ,lJJXJ6.rreHJ1e yBE'JllI'n1BB€T KOJiJ1'leCTBO y«aCTHHKOB J1 TeM ca-
MbIM CHJ<DKaeT ero U;eHHOCTb. Oco6eHHo 3T0 JlCHO, eGJIJiI npllilJITb BO BHJ1-
MBHJ1e npaBO Ka>K,!\oro y«aCTIrnKa yqBCTBOBaTb BO BJla,!\eHl1I1I1 nOJlb3o-
BaHID100Iql1MIM3JI0>KeHHoeIlO3BOJlJl8TnpI1ifrnKBbIBOJIY
o HeBC:I3MmKHOCTH O'I"'I}"K.neHKH GaCTI1 ,l\0JU1 (;npo6.neIum ,l\0JU1) I1Ha'le
KaK nYTeM oT'ly}KJ\eIDIJl J\OJlill HeCI\O.IIbKI1M nl1IJ;aM 110 OJ\HOiii: cJ\eJIKe.
B If:3B8CTHOM CMbICJIe 3TOT BbIBQ!1 COBnJiAB€T C BblBOJ\OM 113 n. 4 CT. 244
olco6crBffimlKYco3J1aTb06JltY1OHaHe-
,l\eJrnMYIO BelIJ;b nyI'€M COrnallIeHMJI C I1HbIM: JllmDM.' .
Ha HallI B3rJl pacnopmKelUte 'IaCTbID J\OJll1 ,l\OnyCTillMO 11 C TO'I-
KI1 3P€HI1H BOmIDKHOCTH ABJlbH€iii:llIero ,l\eJleHI1H npaBa, 11 C 1I03HIUfi1
U;eJIeC()(fjpa3HOCTI1 c}'lII;eCTBOBaHMJI 06w;ei1 AOJI8BOii cooCTBeHHOCTl1,
KOTOpaJl npl1 paLtlfOHaJIbHOM pery.m1pOBBlOO1 MO}KeT 6blTb BnOJlEe
::!KOHOMl1'leCKIf onpaB,IJ,aHHOH. ,neHC'I'BJ'I'f8JlbHO, BO::!MmKlIOCTb OT'IJ'K-
,l\eHI1H GBcTI1 ,l\OJlill H800x()JJ;l1M) mpaIDf'll1BaTb, HO He Ha ypOBHe ocy-
ll.IeCTBJI€HI1H npaBOMO'll1H nOJlb30BaID1H, TaR KaK npaBOMO'll1e nOJlb30-
BaHM - 3TO, 6e3)'CJlOBHO, Ba>KHOe, HO He 8,IJ;I1HCTB8HHOe npaBOMo<rne
COOCTB8HHI1Ka.
CornaCHO rocnOJ\CTB}'lOIl.\eiii: 11 BOCnpmurrOi1 3aKOHOJ\aTeJleM ROH-
U;1H, ,l\0JlH npeJ\CTBBJlJleT coooi1 ,lJ;OJllO B €,IJ;I1HOM npaBe. II03TOMY
''''''MO"A.C''''''''''".QOJIIIcOOcrn"""""""a;t;.IOp",,,.2007NOI C.23
2CKno.CI;K.III.Hc,orooc:olX:T8eHHocrn"H...rlpaK'
....'ecia<eBOnpocbl_M Cra1yT.2004.c_211
82

nKJ60e pacnopH*eHHe ;nOJIef:! KaCaeTCH pacnopmK8Hl1H npaBa B nenOM
O;nHaKO HaJThI<n1e B npaBe ;noneBCii: COOCTBeHHOCTI1 J],OJIeif n03BOJlH8T
H€Koropble aRTbi pacnopmKf'ffilJ'I B OTHOllleHIDI ;nOJThl 
coco6cTBeHmmy caMOCTOHTeJIbHO, pacnopmK8Hlfe npaBOM B lteJIOM
ocyIlt8CTBJUI€TCfI BCeMJ1 coco6cmemnmaMJt co06Il.\B. C TO'11\:11 3pemfH
pacnOpIDKeHJ.UI 3aKCIKJ,J\8TeJIb Bbl,!\eJIJ'I€T B CT. 276 ;nBe Cct>ePbl: 06'-'lY1O
11 JilWfI3JofJ],yBJIbH}'K). OOlQaH c4Jepa KaCaeTCH paCITOpmK8Ht1H BeIQbKl
B lteJlOM If Tp€OYeT cornaCJf.ll BCex coco6cmemuruoB. Cqx,pa tfH,,!I;Wllf-
;ny8JIbHaJI OXBaTbIBB€T B03MO)KH()CTb coco6cTBeHHJ.IK paCnOpH*8Tb-
CJI coOcTBeHIDii: J],OJIeif 6e3 JfJIH BOlIpeKI1 BOJThl OCTaJThHblX coco5cTBeH-
IDIKOB, TaK KaK lIpl1 ocyIlt8C"IBJl8HJII1 npaBOMO'itftI pacnopamemm
3aTpar11B8KY1'CJ'I TOJIbKO I1HTepeCbI O,IJ.Horo coco6cTBeJrnJ.r
J1:3-3a TOro 'Iro ;n0JIJ'I B npaBe npe.IICTB.BJUIeT coooti He'lTO JU\eaJTh-
Hoe, no lIpWltfHe OTC}'TCTBMH peaJlbHoif ;nOJThl lIpt1 emal qaCTI1
;n0JI11 ;npyroMY JThIQ,Y pe'lli JU\eT He 0 ;neJleffill1 ;n0JThl, a B HelWTOpOM
CMblCJIe 06 ee }'MHomeHID'J, TaR RaK TpeTbeMY JThIQ,Y nepe,!\BeTCJ'I npaBO
Ha npeeT 6e3 OTKa3a OT co6crBeHHoiI npaBoBof:! n03tm.
C O,!J;HOi1 CTOpOHbI, CBOOo,!\B pacIIOpHm8Hl1H ,QOJIeH ;nOJDKHa pacnpo-
C'TpBIUITI>CR 11 Ha qaC'I'b ;n0JThl. Eo eCJThI CJIe.I\OBaTb 3TOti To<rn:e 3peHJ.UI,
npe,!UIOJIaraeTCH, 'ITO C iPoPMaJlblililM.JIPo6.n€Ht18MCBO-
en J1,Q8aJIbHOi.i,[lo.IDf Mor Ob! npe;nOCTaBJ!HTb nOJIomeffile COBJIa.I\eJlblteB
MHomecTB}' "IpeTbJfX JIJ11..1; 6e3 cornacJ.UI OCTaJlbHbIX coco6CTBemn1KOB.
B 3TOti CBEaM IIO.1IrnKJ'IT8JbHO MOJKHO OI..\8llHTh peWeHl1e 3aKOHO.I\aTeJIH
0TH0C11TeJ1bHO ycTaHOOJ!8HJ.fH rpaHl1l.1;.!Ip06JIemm ;nOJlJ'!. O,!J;HaKO cyIl.\e-
CTB}'lOT TaKt1e npaBOMO'illH, KOTOpb!e He 3aBMCJ'IT OT pa3Mepa ;nOJIt1,
KpoMeToro, IIOJIb3OBBIIH8HeBCeMJ1BeIl.\BMI13aBI1CJ1TOTpa3Mepa,[l0JIt1.
ll.rur TOro 'IT06bl Onpe.lle.IDlTb, OTHOCtffCJI Jill o1"i)'»t,r(eIDIe qaCTI1
,[IOJII1 K Jnwi1 t1JI}'!06lQeti c4Jepe, HeoOXO.I\I1MO npoaHaJlJ'!-
311poBaTb WD1ffiDfe O,!J;HOCTOpoHHeti npo,[la:mtf 'IacrH;nOJIJ1 lIB lOpl1,[1l1-
'IeCKt1e II03tn.p1t1 OCTaJIbHblX cOBJ!B.I\eJlblteB.
LlOJIeBBH ccfcrBeIrnocTI, co Beei1 O'1eBI1,!\HOCTbiO nO.u.pa:3yMeBaeT
B03MomHOCTb cyIQeCTBOBaHl1H pa3HbIX no Be.1!J1<rnHe J],OJIeii:, KOTopbIe
Moryr ObITb pa3Horo pa3Mepa Jf3HaQaJlbHO t1JIt1 MeHRTbCJ'I B npoQec-
ce CyrQeC'I130138HI o6lQeti co6cTBeHHocTu. Pa3Mep .I\0JI11 BJIIDleT He H8
Bce lI03MXfKHOC'fJf ocyw;eCTBJ!eHl1fl lIpaBOMO'lJrli cdicTBemIocTIt OH
Ba*eH .AJlH ocyw;eCTBJ!eHI1JI npaBOMO'lID! BJIB)\eID1.H If nOJIb3OBaHJrn,
TaKKaK C pa3MepOM .I\0JI113aKOHO,!\BTeJlb CBEabIBa€T .I\OJllOB BelQl1AJU1
ocyw;eCTBJ!eHl1fl nOJIb3Cl3aIDUL He BCer.I\a If He Bce BJ.f,!I;bI IfM)'Illecma
IffiXO)J.HTCH B pa3.I\eJIbHOM BJIa.I\8HID1 J'I n0Jlb30BaHl1J'1 cocc6r:rnetnrn:-
KOB. 3T0 3aBJICHT OT BOJIJ1 COCo6cm8HHI1KOB, BI>f.I\B J1:MYI--U;eCTBa J'I neJIJ1
ero Ha3H8.QeHI1R. EcJIt1 pe'lli 1f.I\€T a 3eMeJIbHOM }"ffi.CTKe J'lJIt1 a :H\.I1JIOM
83

nOMeIQemU:l, TO pa3Mep ,JIOm! 3)\eeh npmmnrulaJIhHo BameH ,ltJUI pea-
.JIH3aWll1 npaBOMO'IH.III1Onh3Ol3<lIDIJI. Ho B OOll.\e ..QOneBOii: c06CTBeH-
HOCTI1 MOmeT HB.XO,lUfThCfI, HBIIplIMep, 6acceflH, paCC'UilTaHHhIti: Ha
O;nIOBpeMemlOe I1WIh3OI3aIDle HeCKOJlhKJIIMH JUILtBM. IIomxJCI3affi1e
,JIaHHOfi BlO ID'JKaK He CBH3BHO C pa3MepOM ,JIOm!, C HID'! CBH3aHO
TOJlhKO HeceID1e opeMeIDI CO,JIep:maHI1H 06rn;ei1 Bell.\l'l, a Ie
OCYll\eCTBJlHSTCH Bcei1 BelO B lteJlOM.
CY,!J;eoHBJI rrpaKTMKa :maST IIpI1MEpH., KOr1\B pa3Mep ,JIOJll1 Ha )KI.1JIoe
HeID'!eeT::!Ha'leHl1.ll,D,JlHnpJ.13HaHl1.llnpaBaBceJleHl1.llBKBBp-
TMpy. TaR, J1CTI1QBanmachBcy,JIC J1CKOMK urBe-r<rnKaMOOOOH3aHID1
He 'IIDIJ1Th np€rurI'CTB11i1 B llOJlh30B8HID:! m1JIhIM  nepe-
.l\BTh KIIlO'UiI OT lWapn1phl, BCeJleHJ1l.1 B c6:>cHoBaIDle }'KB3hJBaJla, 'ITO
.HBJUIeTCH COOCTBeHHMKOM 1/6 ,JIOJIJ1 B O;nIOKOMHaTHOi1 KBap1'l1pe 06r.u;ei1
ILJ10LqaAhlO 35 K.B. M, KpoMe Ree cocoOcTBeHHl1Ka1.rn: HBJImCITCJi: 1/3,J1OJ1J1
npllliBAJ1eiKl1T TA, 1/3 JIOJll1- T.B., 1/6 ,JIOJIJ1- E. B mmape 2011 r.6e3
cor.naCI1.HI1CTI1:qhI ee 6paT, T.B., BCe.JiJ1JIBcrropHYlO KBBp-rnpyCB(>IOm€'HY,
Ec ,JIemp.H 2010 r. Mem,uy11CTI.\OMI1 E.CTaJillB03ID1KaTh KOH, B
mmape2011r. T.B. CM8HI1J13BMKJiIHElBXOp;HOiiJ:.J1B8P"l1nepeCT8JIrryCKaTh
I1CT11QY 11 ee ,x:pqepeii B crropHYlO KBBprnpy, OTKa3hIB3.eTCR. nepeMTh
KIIlO'II1 OT HOBbIX 3aMKOB, B CBJI311 C '<IeM I1CTI1QB JlllliI€'HB B03Ma1KHOCTI1
1lHTh yxo,!J;3B CBoei1TmKeJIOOOm,HOi1MaT8phlO.
PE'tII8HH8McY,JIa OT 12 anpeJ1H 2011 r. J1CIOCEb1e TpeooBaHI1.H Y,JIOB-
JIeTBDpeHhi.
OrB€T'II1KJ11 06paTl1JIl1eh B KaCCaLtl10HH)'1O I1HCTaHLtI1lO, CQl1TaH pe-
ll1eHl1e cY,JIa HroaIroHHhIM.
CynefHaR KOJ1JIerIDI, npoBepl1B ,JIOBOiJ.hI KaGC::8.I.t1ICHHHX >KaJ100, I1C-
CJle,JIOBaB Marepl1aJIhl ,JIeJla, BhlCJIyrnaB o&bHCHeffiIH Y'-IaCTID1KOB npo-
ltecca,npill.IIJIal\CJI.
B COOTBeTCTBl111 co cr. 304 fK p c:06cTBeJun.IK MIDKeT Tpe60BaTh
YCTpaHeIDIH BCRKItx HaPYll1eHI1i1: era npaBa, XOT.H OhI aTI1 HapYll1eHI1H
J1 He OhlJll1 coe.n;Jrn8Hh1 C JDnneHlleM BJIa;:\eHIDI.
CornaCHO CT. 30 JKK PtP co5cTBemnm )KJ1JIoro IH oey-
I.J..!€CTBJlH€T npaBa BJIa.n;eHIDI, n0JIh30BaHl1H 11 paCJI)pmK8H11J1 npl1-
Ha)I,JlemaIl{I1M €MY Ha npaBe Co6cTBeHROCTI1 ml1JlhIM nOMew;eHl1eM
B COOTBeTC'I'BHJI C ero Ha3Ha'<leHl1eM 11 npe.n;eJIaMl1 em I1Cn0JIh30BaHl1H,
KOTDph!e YCTaHOBJIeHhI.1KK pcp
BCOOTBe'I'CTBIrnco CT. 247 fKPCPBJIa.n;8Iillel1l1OJIh3OBBIIH8I1MJ-
r.u;eCTBOM, HaH B UJJI8BOtt COOC'I'BeHHOCTI1, ocyIU8CTBJlfIlO
no corJ1BllIeHillO BCex ee y«aCTHl1KOB, a npl1 fI8JIOC'fI'DK6IlI1 corJIaC1H-
B nopH,QKe, YCT8II3BJUIBaeMoMCYl1.0M. Y'ffiCTIillKJ1(IJI8BC&1 COOCTB8HHO-
cThlI1MeeT npaBO Ha npe.lIOCTBBJ18ffile B era BJIa.n;8Hl1e 11 nOJIh30BaHl1e
84

'!acTI1 OOll.\em tfMYllI€CTBB, copB3M8pHOA em Jlone, a npl1 HeB03MmK-
HOCTI1 3Tom B!1paBe Tpe60BaTb OT Jlpyrl1X }"IaCTIDIKOB, B.1IaJ18IilllVf
11 n0JIb3)'1Oll.\J'1XCR 11MYll.\8CTBOM, npHXO,nffi1\l1MCR Ha ero JlOJllO, COOT-
BeTCTB}'}Ol1\eft KC&meHmqJOC
CYJleOHaJI KOJIJIerl1J'1 C'lI1TaeT BbffiO.n; cY1J,a o6oCHOBaHHblM, no-
CKOJIbKY B xO)J:e paCCMOTp8HlfH Jle.rra OhLJIO YCTaHOBJIeHO, '!TO OTBeT-
'!t1K11 JleHcTmrre.m.HO CMeffi1JIJ1 3aMKl1, OTKa3bmBKJTCH npe.n;OCTaBI1Tb
JlCTt1Q8 KJilO'IM J.f '!I1HJlT eft npenJlTCTBI1.II B IIOJ1b3OBalD1J.f KBapTl1poft,
'!eM HapyrnaK1I' ee npaBa, npe.n;YCMO'IpeHHHe J\8fiCTBYlOll.\I1M 3aKOHO-
1J,aTeJlbCTBOM.
CCbLlIKa B RaCC<lWlcmKJi.i ma.n:00e 0TB8T'lJ'1I«JB 'ITO 1J,OJIH JlC'I11QbI
Mana 11 OHa He MOeT ObITb BCeJIeHa B cnopHYK! KBaprnpy, OTIUIOHH-
eTCJ'I, nOCKOJ1bKY COOCTBeHHI1K BnpaBe nOJIb30BaTbCH CBOHM 11M)'ll.\e-
CTBOM, C TpeOoBaID1HMI1 0 nepeBO.n;e npaB cc6crneJllDfRa Ha 1J,OJIKJ I1C-
Tl1QbI OTBeT'IMKJI He 05paIQa.mICb'.
TaKI1M 06paaoM, 1J,BmE' 06na)J;BTeJII1 MaJloft1J,OJ!I1 Moryr npeTeH.n;o-
BaTh Ha n0Jlb30BaHl1e Bell.\bKJ B qeJIOM
KmoqeBOe OTIDI'IMe OOll.\e£! cdx.-rBeHHocrn OT Jnw1l3H,llJ'BJlbll CO-
CTOJff B TOM, 'ITO Beutb npJIHa,ZJ;JI8)KHT Ha npaBe co6c-rnem«x.-r O)J;JIO-
BpeMeHHO H80\0JIbKI.IM JlMqaM. OroT cyll.\eCTB8HHbrn: npl13HBKnopom-
1J,BeTO)J;HO 113 rJlaBHbIX Ra'ieCTB OOll.\eM co5cTBeHHOCTI1- 0CYll.\eCTBJIeIDIe
Bcex npaBOMO'1J1ii c06cTBeHHocTI1 cooorqa. Hawe ,IJ;eWCTayKJw;ee 3BKO-
HO)J:aTeJIbCTBO J.f npoeKT HOBom 3aKOlIB npeAYCMaTplfBaeT B Ka'!eCTBe
IIpJIHQMIIa npl1HHTHH peweIDIH - npJUll..\11TI e,IJ;l1HornaCI1H, 'ITO Ha)J;e-
JIHeT npaBOM Ram,D;om 113 cocofIC'meJllDmDB He3aBI1CI1MO OT pa3Mepa
,IJ;0JII1 Onpe,IJ;eJIJlTb nopR,QOK BJIa)J:8lIHH, nOJIb3OOaHJIJI 11 pacnopmK€'-
IDIJI BeKJ, npl1'leM nOCJIe,I\Hee (nOpR,QOK pacnopJlmE'mm) He M<»KeT
YCTaHaBJIMBBTbCH cy1J,OM B c.nyqae He,I\OCI1UKeHHH cornaweHHH Me}K-
AY coc:06creeHm1K3MJL B KaKOM-TO CMbICJIe MO)K8T CYll.\eCTB8lIHO 00-
JIer<rnTb Cl1'Tyawoo corJIaweHJ1e 0 BJIa;J;eIIYUl J1 nOJIb30BaHID:! Bell.\bKJ,
KOTOpoe comaCHO n. 4 CT. 277 npoeKTa fK pcp ,IJ;OJDKHO ObITb 3BKJllO-
'!eHO B III1CbMeHHoH tPoPMe B OTHOWeHID:! He.v;BJ1iKJ1MOI'O J1MYll.\eCTBa.
01J,HaKO cornaWeHl1e TepHeT cl1Jl)' npl1 II8pe'ill1J.e 1J,0JII1 B npaBe coo-
CTBeHHOeTI1 Ha He,IJ;BI1:1KJ1M)'IO Be K 1J,pymM)' roco6c-meHtrnKy I1JI11
7peTbeMY JII1Qy, eCJII1 YCJIOBJffi aToro cornaweHHH He BHeceHbI B E.z:\11-
HbIW mCY1J,apeTBeHHbrn: peeCTp npaB lIB He1J,BIDKI1M08 l1MYll.\eeTBo. Ta-
KHM 06pa30M, OCTaeTCH OTKpbITblMBonpoc, COXPaHH8T JlI1 corJlaweHl1e
C1Ioe 1J,eibmle npl1 OT'I)"K,[IeHI1I1 'lBCTI1 ,IJ;OJIl1? COXpaHeHl1e 1J,BHHOro
'Olpe,o,e.neHMeC!H<r.-o)JOACKoroCyIJ,80T07.07.2011N!10336URL.flhttp.r/W'oWl.
.....- """""
85

corJIarneHllil HMeJIo Ohl CMblCJI npl1 yrpaTe OT'IYTeJIeM ;QOJll1 COO-
CTBeHHOM IIpaBOBOH n0311QIDI, TO eCTh ec.ID1 Ohl npl106p8TaTeJIh ;Q0JIJ1
1I00000CThKJ CTaHOBHJICR Ha MecTO OT'IYTeJlfl RBK rapaHTI1R TOro,
'ITO CMeHa O;QHOro coco6cTBeHHHKa HHKaK He 01pB3J1TCH Ha npaBOBOM
1I0JI())%(f'HJ{If ;npyrnx coc:06cTBeHHHKOB. B ;QaHHOM>Ke CJlY'lae pe'lb l1.neT
06 YBeJIWIeHIDI 'lI1CJIa COBJIa,D,€J]bqeB, KOTopoe ;QOJDKHO BJIe'lb nepe-
CMarp nopH,D,Ka B.JIaJ\eHJ.UI U l101Ib3OBaHU.fII1MJlI-\eeTBOM. KpoMe TOro,
COrJIaCHO n 5 aHaJDI3JIpyeMolii CTaTbl1 npoeKTa fKPtfl aTOHe 06J'13aH-
HOCTh coco6cTBeHHJ.rn, a npaBo BHOCWTh corJIarneIDIe 0 nopJ'l,!U(e BJIa-
;QeHI1J'1I1 n0J1h30BaHl1J'1 B E.rr;1Hhru rocY;Qapc1'El€liHWi peecTp. Y'IWThI-
BaJ'lypoBeHbnpaBoBoi1 aKTttBlDC'l'HIpam.,lJ;aH, MO>KHOTh
He'lacToenle<JTOMHopMOM.
He TOJIhKO npaBOMO'lI1J'1 nOJIb30BaHI1J'1 11 B.na;QeIDIJ'l Hy:m:;IJ;aKYl'CH
B cor.1la(.'(Glffill1, e,!\l1Hor.naCl1e I1MeeT oco6oe 3HB'IeHl1e npl1 ocyw:eeT-
B.neHffif npaBOMO'll1J'1 paclIOpmReHl1.H, TaK RBK "TOT npH,!\OK He MO>KeT
6bITh YCTaHOBJIeH CY;IJ;OM. B CBH311 C <J:eM nptt6aBneJnre JI106oro HOBOro
cocOOCTBeHHI1Ka nopoeT EICI3MOmHOCIb HBCTynJleIDffi «rrpaBoBoro
KOJiJIanca», BhIXO,!\113 KOTOporo 3aKOHOM HE' perJIaMeHTI1pyeTCH.
<paKT06JIa,!\BHI1H,!\OJIeMnpe.lIOCTaBJIH8 npaBO coc06CTBeHHI1K)'Tpe-
60BBTb B JIJ060e BpeMH pB3)J;e.na oOll.\ero I1M}'1l.\ecTBa I1JII1 BhJ,D;eJIa,!\O.ID1
113 Hero. IIYHKT 3 CT. 280 npoeKTB fK ptfl npe.n;yCMaTpl1BaeT, 'ITO npl1
He,!\OCTI1:m:eHI1I1 }"W.CTlDIKBMH ,!\o.neBoi1: coocTBeHHOCTI1 corJIaIlleHI1H
o CIIocooe 11 YCJIOBI1HX pa3J\eJIa 06Il.\€1'0 J1:MYII-IeeTBa I1JII1 BbJ.!\eJIa AOJIJ1
O):\Horo 113 HID!: yqaCTHt1K ,nOJIeBOi1 co6CTBeHHOCTI1 BlIpaBe B Cy,ne6HOM no-
pH,!\KE' Tpe60BBTbBhJ,D;eJIa B Harype CBQ€'M,!\OJiH 113 ooll.\ero J1MYU-\8CTBB.
Ec.ID1 Bhl,}:leJI ,n0.ID1 B HBType He ,nonyeRBeTCR aaKOHOM I1JII1 HeB03-
Mo:m:eH oe3 HeCOpB3MepHOro Yll\epoa 11M)'ll.\eCTBY, HaXO;:VUneMYCH
B 06ll.\ei1:cofJcrBeHHocn.r, noeroBhlI5opy
I1MeeT npaBO Ha BblIIJIBTY E'MY C'IOKMOCTH ero;QOJ1I1 ApyrnMH yqacT-
HI1KaMH ,QOJIeBOM c06cTBeHHocTI1 JII160 HB rrpe.IIOCTB.BJI eM)' npaBa
BeIWIoi1 BhI,1J:a<J:11 (n. 3 CT. 305 IIpoeKTa fKPtfl)
CaMa no ceoe HOpMa 0 :npeIqXlIQffitDl OOIl\HOCTl1 nOCpe)\CTBOM npo-
,nBjf{J1 oOll\ero l1MyIII;ecTBa n0311'1'I1BHa 11 J1MeeT MeeTO BO MHornx eB-
fU18UCKlfX 1\QltI.I$1Ka'-tl1.flx. O)\HaKO C TO'IKI1 3peHl1.f1 B03MO>KHOCTt1
B O,l\HOCTOpoHHeM nop.fl,l\Ke OT'J)'m)1eHl1H 'lBCTI1)\0JII1 OHa nopom,IlBeT no-
CJI8)\CTBI1F.! B Bl1,1J;e npO)\B:>KI1 BeInl1, B n0JTh30Ba.H1111 KOTOpo!1i Moryr OhITh
satfil'I"8pecoBaHhI .npyrne coco6cTBeHID1Kl1. IIpoeKT ill P<P He np€)1JC-
Ma1pJ.maeT orpaIDREWIe npasa Tpe60BaTb pa3)J;eJla BeIl.\l1I1J111 BhJ,D;eJla
)\0JII1 B HaType, 'lTO ;QeJIaer coco6c:rBffnnlKOB elite 6oJIee}'H3BHMbIMJ'I.
lWYrneeBpoI1eiiCIDJe1)1(J1lJCK<l1U1'orpaHWlE'Hl1e<JTO-
ro opaBa HB OCHOBaID111 ,!\ol"OBopa Mem:.n.y coc:06c-rBeHm1KMI1. TaK,
'"

a63. 1  749 fepMaHCIWrO CI\OI'O y.nmKeHI1H npe,l:lycMa"IpJ1Ba-
eT, '1TO Kam,!J;bIH Y'-IaCTHI1K MOmeT Tpe60BaTb B JIJ060e BpeMF! oTMeH)'
o6J1tHocTl1, eCJlll Y'lacTHI1KJ1 CBOI1M COrJlallleHl1eM He OlplHK'BfJIIf:'!TO
npaBO. .l*J1cTBJf8 3TOro COrmllleIn1J'1, 3apel1oJC'rpnpOBaHHOOO B n03e-
MeJlbHOH KHJIIre, PacnpocTFWUl8TCJ lIB npaoonpeeMIDlKOB. ComaCHO
 650 lIIBefiLtapcKoro rpa:>K,!\BHeKoro YJloeHI1.II If  850 ABcrpHikIID-
ro mro YJI()}J{8HJ1fI OTMeHa 06lltHocrl1 B03MO*Ha B J11060e
BpeMH, eCJll1 OHa He orpaHWIeHa .l\OfOI3OpoM. O.l\HaKO, KpOMe ycraHoB-
J1eHHoro COrJlallleHJ1eM, CYl1\eCTByeT 3aI«JHH1:lii MexaHH3M 3al1tl1Tb!
0611\11X mrrepecoB. IIpeKpal.lleHJ1e 06l.l1ei1: co6cTBemJocTIl He .l\OJDKHO
1IpJ1XQD,JITbCH Ha BpeMF!, Kor,[(a ooco6cTBeJnnm "MeeT oc06bD1 HHTepec
B nOJ1b3OEIBlOOI3TOH BeJ.1tblO (Hanpt1Mep, KoM5aHHOM B nepI10,l:ly6opKI1
ypomaJ'l). Bee 31'11 MepbJ HOCJIT BpeMellllblH xapaKTep, HO OHI1 3a1.l..U1-
ll{alOT I-UrrepeCb! .l\pymx coco6c'rBeJnnlKOB.
 aHaJll13 n03BOJU1eT npl1ifrl1 K BbIBO;:ry, '1TO OT'JY'K-
,QeIDIe '1aCTI1 .l\0JIJII He MomeT OTIlOCWl'bCJI K HlUUfBJuxya.JlbHm c4Jepe
cooo6CTBeHmma, TaR RaK HeMJrnY€MO 3aTparMBaeT turrepecl>l ;npyrnx
coco6cTBemnuroB. IImTOM)' ,I:lBHHbIi1 aRT pacnopHmeID1H .l\OJDKeH 6bITb
nOCTaBJIeH B 3aBJ1CJ'IMJCTb He ar BCGMO:iKlDCTJ1 J1CIIOJIb3OBBHIU '1aern
BeIql1nponlOHBJThH()ii.l\OJIJIInoHa3Ha'leID1lO, a err COrJIaCI1.IIOCTaJIb-
HbIX , KO'fOpble 6yIJYT npl1Hl1MaTb pellleHl1e, B TOM
'IJ1CJ1e" JfCXOAfj Jf3 B03MO:fKHOCTJI JfCn0Jlb30Bamrn oOll\ero JfM)'llIeCTBa.
IIOCKOJlbKY B .l\OJIlO HeB03MI»KHO 1Tb TOJIbKO Te npaBOMO-
'1W1, KOTOpb!e errHOCHTCH K JfiJ,!1J1BJ1,ZI.yaJIbIIrn cct>ePe, npu npO,l:lBme
'1aCTY!,lJ;OJIJII H8IIOlUITHO, O"Nym:,JJ;aeTCH TOJIbKO '1aerb npaBOMO'IJ1M cO-
co6cTBeHHrJKa JfJn1 yme Q;enoJl 06unr0cTt1. 18 O,l:lHOH JfJlY!
HecKO.JIbKJlX 'lBerei1 .l\0JU1 6e3 YTpaTbi ccfJcrBemJoH BJJa..I\eJrb'leCKOM
ll£J3I'1ItI'1H HeMYIHYeMO BJle<leT HapyrneHl1e IDITepecOB OeTaJ1bHblX CO-
BJla..n;eJlbq:eB, '1TO CBt1,[(8TeJIbCTByeT 0 BTOpmeIDII1 B 061.l..{Y1O Ct}JePYJfH-
TepeCOB, a nOTOM)' "Ipe6yeT cornaCJf.H Beex coco6craemImroB
CTaTbH277 «Rrra,n;ClDICl1no1lb3OBaIllICBeIqblO,CHB,lJ;O-
neBO" CoOCTOeHHren.. He J.13MeHJ.1JIa e.l\I1HOrnaCHbrn: nOp.H,QOK npHH.H-
TI1.fI perneHlUf, RaCBl()ll{11X('J1 BJIaJ\eID{.fl Jf I1().JIb3(EaJll 061l\eif Bell\blO.
IIo-npeJKHeMY «BJla,!\eHl1e 11 nOJIbSOB8HJ18 Bell{blO, H8xo,!\.Hru;ei1cH
B .l\OJleBOM ro6cTBeHHOCTH, eCJll1 HHoe He YCTBHOBJIeHO 3aKOHOM, ocy-
Il{8CTBJImOTC.H no COmallleHl1iO Bcex ee Y'iaC"IEHKOB, a npY! He,!\OCTY!-
:meHJrn corJlacWI- B nopH,l:lKe, yCTaHaEJlJ1B3.eMOM cy,lJ;OM».
B RoHQ;eIll\I1I1 npe,l\JlaraJlOCb ycrnHOOJ'ITb CJlyqal1 npl1HHTWI KBa-
Jll JfJlY! npOCTblM 6o.m.IllI1HCTBOM pelll8H11i1 coco6-
CTBelllll1KOB 0 npe.QOC1"3BJI8Hl1 B nClJlb:3Cl!8.HJ' "IpeThVIM.nI1Q:3.M 06ll\e-
ro J1M)'Il{8CTBa B 0C'mJibIIbIX cJl)"lBflX pacnopHmeHl1.H «BJIE'K}'IQE'I'O
87

t1JU1nOBJIe'lhnpeKpalll:eHt1enpaBac.o6c'I'Belrnocl,lwTOpoe
MO:1KeT J1MeTb MecTO RaK npt1 0T'1Y)f(,IJ;eHt111 COOTBeTCTByKlIl\ero IIIM)'-
Il\eCTBa Tp8TbJ1M JIHltaM (KYI1JUl-npOMma, MeHa, 3aJIOr III TJJ;.), TaK
t1 6e3 TaKOBOrO (peKOHCTpyKW1H. pa3pyrneHt1e) npl1M€HHTb nplilHUI1ll
eJJ,l1HOrJIaCI1R».
Ha Ham B3rJUUt He06xo.lI;tIMO nO;::I;BepraTb pB3I'J'XlIDrremno He CJIY-
'1aH nplflmTHH pernelUm, KaIXCfI npaBOMO'lI1F! pacnOpF!»<:eHI1F!,
a B nepByiOO'lepe,!J;b BJIa.n;eHl1R III nOJIb30BaID1F! BelltbKl. Ha €.n;l1llOrJIaCl1e
lIt:'06xo.r:\I' OC"J'aBl1Tb caMbJe BamHble pellEllJ1F!: 3TO pacnopIDK8Hl18
06Il\eti Bel1tbKl H  qeJIeBOro Ha3Ha'ieHill! liIMYIl\ecTBa. Bee
0CTaJIbHbI8 peW8Hl1.ll: ,l\0JDKHb1 IIpJ1HHMBThCH 6oJIbllll1HC'I'BOM roJIOCOB,
KOTOpoe 01Ipe,!J;E'JIHeTCR IIICXO,l\R 11I3 pa3M8pa ,l\0JIJ1, ecJIJlllilHoe He YCTB-
HOBJIeHO B corJIameHl1l1 Mem,IIJ COCo6cTBeHHl1KBMI1. KpoMe TOro, nplilH-
 €.zurnorJlaCI1R 1I)"KII0:npe.n;ya.ID1pE,l\J1R 1 O'I'Ka3a 0'1'
npel1M)'U.1;eCTBeHHoronpaBanoK}'ITK11. TaKl1Mo6pa3OM,
MOryr B CBOeM COrJlallElOO1 Jt3M8HRTb nopR,!JpK npMH.IITI1R peweID1R B
cTOpOlI)' paCWl1peHI1R Kpyra BonpOCOB, 7p€6yrou.:p1X eJJ,l1HorJIaCJ1JI,
a Ta.1OKE' onp8,QE'JIRTh nopR,!J;OKOIIpeJJ.eJiE'ffi1F! 60mnnrnCTBa I'OJIOCQB.
3aKpelIJlRR npl1MeHeHl1e nplilHUI1ll8 6oJIbWl1HcTBa, Heo6xo.n;r.lMO
npe.IIYcMarpeTb Mex8HJ13M 3aIl\l1Tb! liIlITepecoB M€HbIIDIHCTBa, KOTO-
poe ,lJ;0JDKH0 IIIMeTb npaBo ofpaIl\BTbCR B cY,lJ; B CJIyqae, eCJIJ1 co'neT,
'1TO pewelH1.H 60JIblllIDlCTBa HapymalOT era IIIHTepeCbl. KpoMe TOro,
3all..p1TOi1 0'1' IIJXII'13BOIffi 6a.rrbllll1HCTBa 6Y,!J;8T 6e:3yCJlOBHoe npaso npe-
KpaIl\eHI1F! OTHollleHJ1!:i 06rn;eti co6cTBeHHOCTIl
II: HeJ\OCTaTKBM 3TOi1 CTaTbI1 CJleJ\YeT (rIH8CTJ1 OTCyI'C'IEI18 KQMne-
TeHqID:! O,l\HOro 11I3 COC06cTBeHHI1KOB B O'I'HOllleHl111 o6ll\ero IIIM)'Il\eCTBa.
)J;OJImHa 6bITb 3BKperlJIeHa EI03MCOKHOC'I'b OCYlQeCTB.neIDIR 
O,l\HI1M J13 COC06eTB€HHI1KOB, HanpaBJI€HHbIX Ha COXpaHeHl1e IIIM)'Il\e-
CTBa. TaKl1e ,l\eAc1'BnH Tpe6ylOT HE'Mt',WIE'HHOI'O pean1pOB8HHH., 'lTO He-
pe,!J;KO IIICKJlIO'-iaeT B03MOmHOCTb n0Jl.Y'-ieHI1R pa3pemeID1R 60JIbWl1lf-
CTBa. PaCXO)J.hl no Ocymec'!'BJl8HlUO TaKI1X .v;eficTBJIft: ,l\OJDKHb! 6bITb
B03MeIl\eHbl 0CTa.1IbIlliIMJ1 cooo6cTBeInumaMJ nponopnuHaJlbllO I1X
,l\OJIRM. KpoMe TOro,  ,!J;onyeKaTb paCWI1peHl1e KOMneTeH-
ltlHI o;:nlOro coc.o6cTBeHHHKa no COrJIallleHl1IO CTOpOH, HBIIpiMep, oey-
1l..\€CTBJl€ID18M Meponpt1Rrniii, HanpaBJIeHHbIX Ha COXpaHeHI1e CTOI1MO-
ern 11 cnooo6HOCTt111en0J1b30BaIDIR BelItl1 no Ha3Ha'leHI1K!, B TOM 'lI1CJ1e
BOCCTaHOB.n€ID1e, 06HOB.n€Hl1e 11 peMOHTBeIl\l1. Coco6cmemnOOI Moryr
YCTaHOBl1Tb 61O,lPKeT 3TI1X Meponpwrruii, 3B paMKI1IWTOpOro coc05-
CTBeHIDlKHe,l\OJDKeHBbD:O,IUTI'b.
K 6e3}'CJIOBHbIM JJ,OCTCHHCTBal'>f TIpoeKTa O'I'HOCI1TCR YCl1JIeIDIe
pOJlI1 ,l\orOBopHOro perymtpm!8.liID'l OTHomeIDlti Mem,uy cocdicrBemnl-
88

KaMM. ComaCHO n. 4 11 5 CT. 277 IIpoeKTa fKPtf! «corJIaIIIeHlIe yqaGT-
IDIKOB ,lJ;oneBoif a:J6cTBeHaJcTt1 0 BJIa,J\8IDlJ1 11 rnJIb30BaHJUI Be}(}
,lJ;0J1:>KH0 6bITb 3aKJIK1'I8HO B IDICbMeHHOif 4>oPMe. Kaif\nbrM113 yqacT-
IDIKOB JJ,OJIeBOtI co6cTBeHHOCTIf BrIpaBe TpeooBaTb BHeceHIDI B E.rr;1HbrM
rOcy,lJ;apeecTpnpaBHaHe.zu>J.1ml1MoeJ}'C1DY1J1
COrJIarneHIDI 0 B..JIaJ],€HIDI 11 nOJIb30BaHI1I1 He,l\BJDKlUl«)ii BeIl\blO. np}!
nepexoJJ,e,JIOJlJ1BnpaBeHaH€,l],BJOKJfMYIOBeK.npy-
rOMY coco6c-rneHHImY 11JIJ1 TpeTbeMY JIJIIl{Y cornarnelD1e 0 BJla;:J;eHMJII 11
I1OJIb3OBBHIfiI M'OAB}(}npeKparnaeTCJ'l, eCJIl1 ycJIOBI1J'13Torocoma-
llleHIDI He BHeceHbl B E.rr;1HbrM rOcy,JIapCTBeHHbrn: peeCTp npaB Ha He-
,D;Bl1mI1MoeHM}'rnE'CTBO'".
B qeJIOM HOPM}', aaKp8I1JI€HHY1O B n 4, 5 CT. 277 npoeKTa, MO:>KHO
OQ;eHJIITb TOJlbKO I1OJI())KJ1'f€J Ho ,lIJ'MaeTcJ'I, He06xo.I:\HMo ,JIeTaJIb-
HO perYIDIpOBaTb GO,IJ;epmaHHe TaKOro ,D;OI'OBOpa, 3BKOHOTeJlbHO
ycraHOBJIB ero  yc.nDBHR, TeM CaMbIM onpe.n;eJIJ1B Kpyr
KOHKp€THbIX BOnpOCOB, no KOTOpbIM c06CTBelllil1KJ1 ,D;OJDKHbI ,D;OC'lWlb
corJIaIIIeHlfR, 'ITa cyrnecTB8HHO 6bl o6JIel"Il1JIo nrarmfliecKOe npJIIMe-
HeHl1e M'OA CTaTbl1. nepe'leHb cyw;ecTBeHHblX ycnomrlii .n;alllioro co-
rJIallieIDIJ'l MruKeTBbITJIeTb cJIe.n:yIOUJ;I1M 06pa30M:
1. nOpR.l10K 11 cnoc06 I1p'IHHI'J'IH pernem:rlii, KacalOl1tI1XCJ'I B.J1a)J;eHJIIH
I1I1OJ1h3OBaH1.1H JIM)'rn8CTBON. (Onpe,D;eneHJle Kpyra BOnpOCOB, Tpeoy-
1OUU1X e.n;l1HornacHoro peUJemm. KpoMe npe,!J;ycMOTpeHHbIX aaKOHo.n;a-
TeJIeM, I303MO.?K!I)CTh IIplIMeHeHJUI npl1HLtI1rIa 60JIbllIl1HCTBa K pacl1o-
pflmeHl1IO J1M}'llIeCTBOM B Bl1,!\e nepe'IJ1 JJMYrn8CTBB B lIOJIb3OBBHJIe).
2. nOpH,lJ;OKHeCeHIDI pacxo.n;oB no CQD;eJ»KBIDDO oornet! BernY!
3. MepoIIpJlHTWI, ocyIl\eCTBJIJ'leMble OT.n;eJlbHbIM cOC06cTBeHHI1KoM.
4. 3aKpeIIJIeIDIe HID! aHHYJII1pOBaIDIe npeI1Myw;eCTBeHHoro npaaa
nOKJIIKY!.
5. nOpR.l10K ocyIl\8CTBJIeIDIJ'l npaBOMO'llfJ'l mJIb3OBaHI1.H I1MJll1e-
CTBOM (n0Jlb30BaHY!e BeIqbIO npoIJOpW'IOHaJIbHO .n;one, nOO'lepe.n;Hoe
IIOJIb:3OBaIiJI BeeM BeIOJ OAHoBp€Melllioe lIIJJIb3013aHJ1e BceM Be-
1qb1O; IIOJIb3OBaIDle caWfMM coco6cTBeHHJmaWf Jll160 npe,lI;OCTaBJl8ID18
B IX)JIb30BaHY!e Bel1\l1 TPeTbl1M IDIQaM). B cJIY'ffi.e II£JJIb3(JBBHY! npo-
nopQY!OHBJIbHoro ,D;one .n;onmHbI 6b1Tb 0003Ha'leHbl pe8JlbHH8 .n;0Jrn
B Bell{Y!, nepe.n;aHHble B IIOJIb306BHJle Ka:m,!\OM)' 113 coco6crBeHHY!KOB.
B c.rryqae nOBpeMeHHOro ITfJJIb3OB8HKfI H8OOXO,D;J1MO OITb ne-
pY!o,!\blnCLJIb:3(IBaHWL
6. nOPMOK yrrpBBJIelOOl I1MJIQ8crOOM (caMOCTOme.JIbIIOe ynpaB-
.II8Ime .mrooHB3HB'I8HY!e yrrpaBro).
7. n npeKparneHAA OTHOrn8IDIM o6rnei1 AOJIeBOif coo-
CTBeHHOCTY!. (npoma B nocpe.n;CTBOM npOBe,!\eHIDI TOproB .mroo
89

ofu:ltnn.Ix Meponpwrn:tH no npo,l:la Bemt1, npo,l:lama Cpe,l:lH coco6-
CTBeHIDlKOB JIJIDO cpe.wr JII06bIX Jilll..\.
JJ;aHHbrn:nepe'leHbBonpOCOB - 3TOMHHHM:yM, KOTupbrn:Tpe6yeTco-
rnaCOBaHI1R ,D,JIR 1BHOfO perYJBIpOBaHI1R onJOllJ8IDm MemJJy
coco6CTBeHHI1KaMJ1)
CT3.TMI 218 ..npeU!'o1.Yrn:ecTBellllOe npaBO DOKYJ1RIt" OCTaBJL<IeT
nO'IT11 6e3 JI3M8Hemrlii cyI..IJ;eCTJJY1Ow;ee perY.m1pOBaHl1e npeJ.fM)'w;e-
cTBeHHoro npaBa nOKJIIKI1, KpOMe paarrnpemfJI c1Jepb! ,lI;eficTBI1R TO-
ro npaBa B OTHJweIDnl Bcex ,D;OrOBopoB, np8.I\YCMaTpHBaroI..W1X B03-
Me3)J;II08OT'1ym.!1eHHe ,lI;0Jll:I, eCJII1 JlI3cyI..IJ;eCTBa ,D;oroBopa He BbITeKaeT
11Horo
LIeikmJ1e npaBa HHOi1 nOKynKJII ,D;OJDKHO 5bl'l'b cy-
rqecTB8HHbIM 06pa30M orpaHJII'IeHO. [(eJIb 3TOro npaBa - npeIlHTCTBO-
BaTb Ea3MmKHOCTI1 BCTyn.rreHIDI TpeTbID:: IDIQ B 06Il\HOCTb coco6crBeH-
mfI\DB. 3T0 Ba}KHO He ,WIR Bcex 061qHOCTei1 ,lI;OJIeBblX coco6crBeHmll\JJB,
a TQJIbKQ TaM, r,ll;e CYW:8CTBye-r onpelJ;eJIeHHBH JIJII'IHaH CBJI3b .mroo IIIC-
n().JIb3(J3aIDIe 06w:ei1 Belql1 J1M:ee-r oc06oe 3Ha..eIDIe ,WIfl coco6CTBeH-
HI1KOB, KaK, HaIIpJlM8p, B HB-CJI€)J.CTBeHHblX 06Il\HOCTflX J'! np}! npolJPJK€'
,lI;OJII1 B )f{J.UJOM nOMeIl\eHl1}!. Bo scex OCTaJibHblX CJIy9am :'ITO He IIIMeeT
cMbICJIa. II03TOM)' np8I1M)'IQE'CTB8HHoe lIpaBo nOK)'ITK11 CJIe.I\YeT orpa-
HWillTb TQJIbKO :'ITJ'!MI1,l1;syMH CJIy'IaflM}j.
B Ka'leCTBe ,D;pyroA QeJIl1 np8JlIMYll.\ff'T npaBa nOKJIIKH Ha-
3blBaeTCfl npeKpaw;ame OTHOllleIDIfi ,lI;OJIeBofi co6cTBeHHocnr. Ho 3Ta
QeJIb ;I\0JDKHa yrpaTlilTb CBoe 3Ha'leHl1e, 'ITO ,D;OCTJ1)KJ1MO TOJJhKO IIpI1
ocyw;eCTBJIemm Ka'leCTBeHHoro perYmlpOBa.HlfJI OTHOIllemm: o6w;ei1
c06CTBeHHocTYI.
CTaTMI 280 c(Pa3J1,eJ1 11myIq8CTBa. uaOJI,fIlQe£OCH B ,D;OJIeBOii co\)-
CTBeHHOCTJI, III BblJl,eJl JlI3 Hero Jl,OJ1I1". CTaTbR 252 fK ptfl cO,!J;epoorr
npaB}!.ITa npeKpaw;eHHR <YI'HOI1I8HJIII1\01I8BOii C06CTBeHHOCTH. npe,l:lyc-
MaTpHBaR ,JIBa cnoco6a: pa3,!J;eJl JlIM}'w;eCTBa III BbUJ:eJ1 ,JIOJI}! 11I3 o6w;ero
HM)'IQ8C'I'Ba. Pa3,l1;en J1MYIl\ecTBa IT K npeKpal.QeHl1IO OTHowe-
HMA JJ,Oneeoii: co6cTeeJnrocTI.! B neJlOM, BbUJ:eJl - TOJIbKO ,WIR Bbl,l:teJL<lK)-
ll.Iero ,I\OJlIO coco6cmeHJJr.m:
Pa3,l1;en 06Il\ero J1MYLQecTBa OCyw:reTBJIHeTCSI no cornaweHl1lO
MemJJy COCo6CTseHm1KaMJ1. IIp}! He,I¥JCTttmeHl1R cornacl1R pa3,!\eJI He-
B03MO:lK81L
Bbl,l:teJI ,D;0Jll:I B HB-Type ocyru.eCTBJIHe"i'CH no Tpe60samno y«aCT-
HI1Ka, TalOKe B TOM CJIyqae, KOr,JIa COrnaWeHl1fl 0 pa3,!J;eJle ,D;OCTI1'lb He
Y,l\BJIOCb. Bbl,l:teJI B03MOH B CY,I\e5HOM nopJI,QKe. ECJII1 Bbl,l:teJI ,lI;OJII1
B Iffi.Type He ,!J;onyCKaeTCfl 3aKQHOM JfJlYI H€Ba3MI))K8H 6e3 HeCDpa3Mep-
HOro yw;ep6a l1M)'IlIecrny, M)'CH B 061l.1ei1 C06CTBelIHOCTYl,
90

BbI,I:leJ1HKUt]:DicR co6cTBeHHKK l1MeeT npaBO Ha BblI1J1aTY eM)' CTOIiIMO-
CTIiI ero JlOJ11i1 JlPyrl1Ml1 yqaCTID1KaMIiI wneooii c05cTBeHHOC'I'J'I.
JJ:efr.c'I'B 3aKOHOJlaTeJlbCTBO npe.nyCMaTplilBaeT He caMbrfi
YJla'iHbIfI cnoc05 npeKpaeHl1H amornemrii 05J.Qef1 C05CTBeHHOCTI1,
'i'fQMOmHOnpot1.TIJIIOC'IPHPOBaTb lIB npl1Mepe. J1CTeLl 05paTt1JICH B cY,!J;
C t1CKOM K P.RC. 0 pB3.!1ene )KI1noro .!10MB. B o6ouroBaHHe Tpe60Ba.H:J1!:i
t1CTeLl YKa3an, 'iTO RBJIJ'IeTCJ'I C05CTBeHHJ1KOM 1/2 JlOIDI :HGfJIoro JJ,OMa
Ha OCHOBaHID1 ,[(oroBopa ,[(apeHtlH. Coc05c'l'BeHHmtoM J'lBJUleTC'JI OT-
BeT'illK. B CBJ'l31i1 C TeM, 'iTO B03IUIKJUI cnopbl 0 nOp.fl.!\Ke l1OJIb3OBaHHfI
t1 Bna,!J;effifH ,[(OMOM, npoCI1n PB3,[(8JDt'I'b )Kt1J1OU JJ,OM, npl13HaTb npaBo
co6CTBemrocn1 lIB COOTBeTCTB}'lOLII,ylO 'iaCTh ,[(OMB, a TalOKe BbI,[(8.IDITh
eM)' c.ny>K86m,Ie IIOCTpOiiKH: neTHtiH JJ,OMl1K, K0J10,1J;eLt, 5aBlo, seMenb-
HbIfI Y"acTOK, IIJIOll\a,!!,b1O 1450 RE. M, npl13HaTb npaBo co6cTBeHHocTIt:
Ha }'KB3aHHbll1SeMeJlbHblii: }"ffiC'fQK, B3blCKaTb cy,[(e5Hble paCXO,!!,bL
OrBeT'illK JlCRUBbIe 'l]J86oBamUi He nptl3HBJI, CCbIJIaRCb Ha TO, 'ITO
,[(OM B ct1JIy Bl2TXOCTH pas,!\eny He nO,!\JIemtfT.
PerneHtleM IIIaTYPcKoro ropO,1J;CKOro cYTJ.a MocIroBcIroJ1: 05nacTIiI OT
31 MaJ'l2011 r.BY,QOBJIeTBOpeHHJ1 J1CKOBHXTpe60BaHtli1 OTKa3aHO. Bbl-
cy,!J;oCTaBt1JIperneHtle6e3t13MeHeHt1J1'.
HecoBeprneHCTBO ycTIlHOBJIeHHOCO nopH,!\Ka pas,!\ena 0611\ero IiIMJ-
LLleCTBa 3aKJllO'iaeTCH B TOM, 'iTO pa3,!J;eJll1Tb 05LII,ylO Bel.l..\b HeB03-
MruKHO 1iI,I],OIUBOpJ1TbC.H a COBMeC'TIIOM J1('ll{)JIb3()I3Hffif Hel103MO»\HO,
TJ.aHHaH  npe,!J;CTIlBJUleT CBOero POiJP npaBoBoi1 KOJIJIanc. Co-
co6cTBernIJ.m 06peQeH lIB cyILIE'C'I1J(JB OTHOrneHtli1 ,[(oneBOi1 c05-
CTBeHHOCTIiI, HeCMoTj)H Ha TO, 'iTO aKTI'N8CKJ.IHeBH,!\I1TB ID1X CMblCJIa
iii C"rpeMJITCfl J1300mITbcH OT ID1X. KaKOM BbIXO)J; E03MOJKeH IiI3 3TOf1 CI1-
TJBwrn:? C TO'iKti apeHllil '!\ei1CTB}'lOIl.\8I'O saKOHO)J;aTeJlbC'l'Ba TOnbKO
npo,!\Bma.mroo BbI,!\enJ\OJll'I. BbfJ\8.m1ThJ\OJllOBlIBType BJ\aHHoi1cI1TY-
aQ11Ji1 HeJ303M(l]KHO, npO,!\BTb ,!J;onlO B BeTXOM AOMe AOCTaTO'lHO CJlOiKHO,
TaK KaK B YCJIOBI1HX HeyperyJlJilpoBaHHOCTJiI OTHOrneHJili1 J\oneBoif c05-
CTBeHHOCTJiI J\OJUI nony.lIHpHOCTbIQ He n0Jlb3yeTcH iii Ll8HI1TCH HeBbl-
COKO. Ho B03MOiKeH BbI,!\en nocp8ACTBOM yn.rraTbl COOTBeTCTByKlIl.\8i1
KOMlI8HcaI.{I'D'L
TaK, A.AJ1. 05paTHJlCH B cYJ\ C IiICKOM nO TeM OCHOBaHJilHM,
'iTO C 2007 r OH HBJIH8TCH cOOcrsemnlKUd 5/8 ,[(OJIei1 O,!\HOKOMHaTIlOi1
KBaj)TJilpbL Co6c-rnemm:KoM OcrBnbHblX 3/8 J1(IJIeii HBJUleTCH C. Corna-
llI€HJiI.H 0 nopH)V{e IIQJIb&II!aHIm iii pa3)J;ene I1M)'ll\ecTBa, HaXO,l:\HI.I..\-
CH B 051l.\eif ,IJ;OneBOi1 cdicTBemIoL-rn, He ,IJ;OCTJITHYfO- I1creLl ,lI;Bam,D;bI
HanpaBJUIJI B al\Pec OTBeT'illKa nl1CbMB C np8.l\JICOfI:8H118M 0 pa3n;ene
1 Onpe,o,eneHeMOCI<OEIC""",OOJ1acT1f01"OCI\!IOT1"_072011noAenyN'33-16025
91

t1M)'lQ8CTBa, npe,!\JlaraR TpH BapHaHTa: OTBeT'II1K nOKyrraeT ,nOJIlO HCT-
LtB, HCTel.\ nOl0'naeT ,nOJUO OTBeT'1HKa, COBMeCTHaH npo,!\ama KBapTl1-
pbL lfu C O,lJ,Hl1M t13 HID.: arBeT'lI1K He corJIaCI1JICH. MCTel.\ npocl1JI B l.\eJUlX
Bhl,!\eneHI1R ero ,nOm! H3 OOll.\eiii: co6cTBemKJcTH OOH3BTh OTBeT'IHKa
BhIIIJIaTIlTh 887 750 py6., 'ITO COC'ffiBJI.fET 5/8 pblOO'fllOi.i crOI1MOCTI1
KBapTl1pbl H npeKpaTIlTb era npaBoc06cTBeHHocTI1 Ha KBapTl1py.
Pf2l1I8HH8M :£IeTpo3aooACKOro ropo,!\CKOro cy.na Pecny6ID1KIf Ka-
peJIM OT 7 tfiOJlH 2010 r. I1CROBble Tpe60BBHI1JI y,nOBJIeTBOpeHhl. CY'!\
B3hlCKaJI C C. B nOJlh3}' A.AJ1. 887 750 py6. B c<IeT KOMIJeHCal.\t111 3a
5/8 ,nOJleiii: KBapTl1pb!, npeKpaTJ1JI npaBoco6crBeHmcm A.A.J1. Ha 5/8
,nOJIell KBBpmpbl, npl13HaJI 3a C. npaBO COOCTB€HIIOCTII Ha KBBpmpy
C pemcrpaIU48u HlIOTeKI1 B ctfJIy 3aKOHa lIO I1O.1IHOii BblllJIaTbl KOMIIeH-
cal.\l1l1 A.AJ1.
OrB8T'rnK He cornaCI1JICH co CBOeH ofu13aHHOCTbIO BbllIJla'iMBaTb
cTOI1MOCTb ,n0Jl11, 06paTl1JIcR B Kaccal.\t10HH)'IO HHCTaHl.\t1lO, KOTOpafl
pew8Ht1e cY.IIB- Q'fM8Ht1JIa. BepxoBHblli cy11. cy6"beKTa CBOI1M nOCTa-
HOBJIeHJreM no)I.!\epma.rr peweHl1e cy,llB nepBoiii: t1HCrnHl.\I'1U, MOTI1BI1-
pOBaB CBOIO n03J.1W11Q TeM, 'ITO npaBo Ha BbI)I;eJI 11.0JiJf npeAoCTaBJIR-
eTCfl JIlOOoM)' coccfiC'rBeHHI1Ky H MC»KeT 6bl'I'b peam13OBaHO Ka:>f\.!\blM
113 cocOOcrnemi:I1Koo. 3aKOH He npenRTCTB)'8T J'! coo:6:-rnemmxy, 00-
Jl3Jl3.lOIl\eMYf.om.rneIinopa3Mepy 11.0JIeH, '18MAPyroi1c:oc:c6cTI1eHHI1K,
06paTtITbCH K CBOeM)' coco6cTBeHHI1Ky C Tpe60BaHHeM 0 Bbl,!\eJIe era
11.0JiJf, a npl1 H8J\OC'I1DK8HI1I1 cornaW8HWI 05panITbCR B cy,I\.
.n;ei1:CTBYJOll.\ee rpam,naHCKOe 3aKOHo,naTeJIbCTBO KOp
pyeT npaBO Bbl,!\ena ,nOJU1 COC06cTBeHHI1Ka C O J],pyroro
COCOOCTBeHHI1Ka no COBepW8HJ'!lO onpe,neJIeHHblX ,I(eJ1cTBmi, H ecJII1.
B CI1JIY  xapaKTepllC'IUK KM)Iln8CTBB, HaXO.nRJJJ:erocH
B 06ll\eiii: ,nOJIeBOii COOCTBeIlliOCTJl, Bhl,!\eJI lIOm! HeB03IoGK8H, a BhI,!I;e-
JIffiO'--!.tJ'Ii1:CR CoOCTBeHHI1K cornaceH Ha nOJIY'J€HUe KOMneHCaLtJ1t1 B3B-
MeH t1MYlllecTBa B HaType, Ha ,npyrMX COCo6cTBeHHHKOB B03JlaraeTCH
OOR3BHHOCTb BbllIJlaTbl l1I:>U\eJIRIOll.\8M)'CH COCo6cTBeHHI1Ky COOTBeT-
CTBYlOll\eiii: KOMIJeHCaLtI1J.1. lIpH a'rDM BblIIJIaTa KOMneHffiLltUl OCTaK>-
Il..IJ.1MCR coco6cTBemDmooJ l1I:>U\ He .HBJlReTCfl oOpeMeH8-
HHeM, a 03Ha'IBeT.u.nR OCTalOll.\eroCR coco6c-rnemnma yaeIDIt.JeIDIe era
lIom:! B npaBe co6cTBeJrnoc'm: Ha KOHKpernoe l1M)'I.lIeCTBO'.
C no.nyqeHHeM KOMneHCal.\ID'! COOCTBeHHMK yrpa'iMBaeT npaBo Ha
11.OJIlO B OOll.\eM l1M)'I.lIeCTBe, a c:ocof5c-rBemm:l, yru:raTI1BUII1e KDMIIeH-
cal.\l1lO, np:ro6peTInar H 3a ee C'-IeT yaeJIWll1BalOT CBOlO ccficTI!eHHyIo
11.0JIlOB npaBeaficmeHHOCTI1 Ha06ll\YlO BeIIlh. CJIelloBaTeJlbHO, yru:ra-
'Bep>o::&o::>;oc:pJfJKaperBtAor13.102010noJ¥!IIYN!44r-ro-2010_
92

Ta KOMIIeHGaQtDf 3a 1I0mo €CTb He 'lTO UHoe, KaK yn.naT8 nOK}'TIHOO
1IeHbi aa Hee U, KaK C.IIe,o;CTBl1e, nepeXO,1J; lIpaBa Ha ,o;oma. TaKIDII 05-
pa30M, fIDHY'K,!\eHMe K BbIT1JlaTe KOMI1eHGaLtJ1l13a 1I0mo - 3T0 noHJ'K-
,o;eHI1e K 3aKJlJO'I€HIOO 1I0roBOpa K)'rIJll1-npo,1J;ajKJIIllOJlI1, 'lTO 03Ha'la-
€T orpaHJ1'leID1e npl1Hl..\I1na CBoOO.I\b11l0roBOpa, Karopbliii cornaCHO CT.
422 fK PtP npe;mOJlara€T IIpBBO cropOH CaMiIIM pernaTh, BcrynaTb 11M
B JJ,oroBopHble crmoliEHufi J1J1I1 HeT. IIoH)'m,neHl1e K aaKJUO'lemno JJ,O-
rOBopa cornaCHO 3TOiii .me CTaTbe He ,D;OnyCKaeTCJ1, 3a J1CKJ11O'I8IDI8M
CJlY'Ia€B, Korlla o6fi3aHHocrb 3BK.JllO'll1Tb 1I0roBOp npe.nyCMOTp8Ha fK
PtP, 3aKOHOM J1J1I1 ,D;OOpoBOJIbHO I1pHHfITbIM 05J13aTeJIbcTBoM. IIOlryiK-
,QeHI1e K 3aKJllOqeHI1lO 1I0roBOpa KynJlI1-npo,lJ;ajKJII npl1 comacl1J.f 0)];110-
ro W3 coco6cTBemooroB Ha Bbl,l\eJl,o;OJ1J1 nocpe,l\CTBOM yn.naTbl ,o;eHeiK-
HOW KOMIIeHC3l\I1II npe.lJYCMO'lJJ8IIO aaKOHOM, HO He Hapywa€'l' .1111 3T0
1IeJlY! OIpaIDl'I8Hm1 CBoOO.I\bl ,D;oroBopa. Be,lJ;b aaKOHO,lJ;BTeJlb, OIpaHY!-
'll1BaJI 8BTOHOMIOO CTOpOH B 'laCTHOM npaBe,1I0JliKeH OT'l'aJlKl1BaTbCJ1
OTonp€.Q8JIeHHl:lX1I eJle iii.
CB060,lJ;B rpam,naHcKo-npaBOBHX JJ,oroBopoB B ee I«JHCTlflYlIJlOHHO-
npaBoBoM CMb!CJle, KaK HeO,!!,HOKpaTHo OTMe'laJlOCb B peWeHI1J1X KOH-
C'IKI)'lI,JIOHHOI'O CY.I\a Pocuriirnow 4Je,D;epaLlJ1J1, B 'lBCTHOCTI1 B ero 1Io-
CTaHOBJIeHIDIX oT6 J1lOIDI2000r. NQ9-II' HOT I anpe.rm2003 r.N4-II',
npe,JJ;!IOJlal'aeT I€ IIpIIIIL\lIlDB paBeHC'l'Ba H COmaCOBaHI1J1
BO.IDf CTOpOH. CJle.I\OBaTeJlbHO, perYJrnPYeMble rpam,!\BHCKI1M aaKOHO-
,D;BTenbCTBOM .I\oroBopHble o5J13aTeJIbcTBa .I\OJDKHbI6bITh OCHOBaHbl H8
paB8IICTBe CTOpOH, aBTOIIOMIDt J1X BOJIJ1 J1 J1MY1L\eCTBeHHOiii caMOCTO-
meJIbHOCTIl, HE',llOnyt:rJfMOCTIl IIpOI13BOJIbHOro BMewaTeJIbCTBa KOI"O-
.111160 B 'l8CTHble .I\ena. Cyih.eKTbl Ipa»QJ.8HCKOI'O npaBa CBo6o.I\Hbl B
ycTIlHOBJ!€H11J.f CBOJ.fX lIpaB J1 of5.H3amtoc-reH Ha DCROBe 1I0roBOpa J.f B
onpe,lJ;en8HJ.rn J1I06b1X He IIpOTI1BOpe'laIql1X 3aRIJH(J,I:\BTeJIbCTsy YC.IIO-
mrn,D;O!'OBopa(n 1112CT.l fKP4J).
B To.me BpeMJ1I\oHcTI CY.I\ PoccI.dicKoi14Je,D;epaqm:r
nO,lJ;'IepKlmaJI. qTO KOHCT1I1TYL\110HHO 3aIql1IL\BeMaJ1 CB060M ,D;O!'OBopa
He .I\OJDKHa npl1BOl1)ITb K OTpl1l\aID1K1 J1JIY! }'Man€HI1IO ,lJJ)yr= 06w;e-
npl13HaHHhIX lIpaB 11 cB06o,lJ; qenOBeKa J'! rpaiK,llBHI1Ha; aHa He .HBJlJleT-
CJ1 a6roJrn:rrHco1 J'! MOiK8'r 6bIThOrpaHl1qeHa, O,lJ;HaKO KaK caMS B03MOiK-
HOCTh orpaID1'1€H11iii, TaK J.f J1X xapaKTEp ,D;OJIiKHbI onpe.n;eJI.fITbCH Ha
'n0p,eJ1yonpooep""rnIII»II!HIOafuall1l-.peTbeIl)\'IIIffiI2<:ra1h1<TT4I<w!
panbHOrO_oHa.oHecoc.-om-en...0C1>t(6aHtq)OTCToe).BC."3C>K8l1060;;OT>:j)bITOroaKIIMOHep.
Horo.Tsepc_"P'\O.I'1I...a"4>a6pKa-:I"IocTaHOBllet<eKOHCT1fT)'U,l10HHOrOCy.o,af'<1)CT
06.06_2lKJON!'9-nllC3P<1>.2000_N!'24_Cr2658
2n01JW1y()npooopKeKOIICTIiT)III'IOHDCTn()J"))""I"..nYH"",2cTaTbM7oHoro""KOHa-OO
aYlI'fiopcKo;;.."e...-eJ1b11OCT>1.BC"3c>K3JlO6o;;.--pa;o;o,aHKIo1B_l'locraHoilJleHeKoH'
CTI<'I)'I1MOH......OCy.o,aP<boTOI04.2000N!4nllC3P<1>_2000.N!'15.Cr 1416
93

OCHOBe .E\oHcrnTyl.\Jfil PocCJIjtClOOJI4>eI',,
'ITO npaBa H CBo60,!1.b1 'IeJlOBeKa H rpam,n;aHl1Ha Moryr 6bITb orpaIDIGe-
Hbl Q:ie,!\epaJlbHblM 3aKOHOM TOJIbKO B TOfi Mepe, B KaKOfiaTO He06xo.nu-
MO B l\eJlJ'lX 3BIl.tI.fTbl OCHOB KOIrrJrIyl.I,JlOmIOro CTpOJ'l, HpBBCTB8HHO-
em, 3,!\OpoBbJI, npaB H3BKOHHbIX HHTepeCOB,[ijJynIX Jill!..\, 06ecne':lemm
o6opoHu CTpaHbI J.f 6e30nacHocrn rocy,!\apcTBa (CT. 55, 'l. 1 Jj :W.
 CB06o,!\B cyfueKTOB rpam,n;aHclwTO lIpaBa, co-
C'rn.B.IIHlOIl\ OCHOay CB06o.I\bl ,JJ;orOBopa, BCer.I\B 0TlIfJCI'IT8JIb, TaR
Rax HX cyr.u;eCTBOBaIDIe HeJlb3J'1 paCCMaTpHBaTb OTOpBaHHO (IT 06w;e-
crna, B KOTOpoM OHY! :mJ1Byr, H, CJle.I\OBaTeJlbHO, OllY! .I\OJlmHbl no)J;"lY!-
H.HTbCJ'l3aXOHaM 3TOrQ o6w;eCTBa. IIpl13TOM CB06o,!\B O.I\HI1X He .I\OJDKHa
HapywaTb CBo60.I\Y ,[ijJyntx.
I'pam,zwHOOC€ 3aXOHO.I\BTeJlbcrno lIpeAYCMaTpl1BaeT He TQJIbRO
orpaHl1GeHl1e npaB,lIJI.H 3aLql1Tblny6.m'I'fHbIX I1HTepeCOB, 3aLql1T€ no.I\-
JlemBT H lIpaBa OT.I\eJlbHbIX rpam,llBH 11 lOplf,AlN8CKlfX JD1q. CJJe,JJ;OBa-
TeJlbHO, l\eJlb!O yCTaHOOJJeHl1.H orpaHl1GeBI1M CB060.I\bl ,JJ;OrQBopa HBJIH-
eTCH 3BIWITa rocy,!\apCTBOM ny6.nWlHbIX 11 'IaCTHbIX 11HT8p8COB.
A.H. TaMara B nepBoM KUornJI8KOOM HCCJJ€JI(JBaIImI npuilIInm CBO-
60.I\b1 ,JJ;OI'OBOpa B COBpeM8HHOM rpa>ti,!laHcKOM lIpaBe DTMeTl1J1, 'ITO
"t1c.cne.uyeMbJill npl1Hl\i1n He HOCHT a6COJllOTHoro xapaKTepa. Ho .mo-
60e orpaHWleHl1e ero l\C>.IDKH0 6b1Tb B3Belll8HHO C T0'IKI13peHl1H 06w;e-
CTBeHHOO HeCJ6xo.niaroc'. A ycraHOBJJeHHblfl 3anpeT BCer;I\a CJle.I\YeT
TOJIKQBaTb OIpaHWllIT€JIhHO - B T(NHOM C<iOTBeTCTBIrn C 6yKBaJIbHblM
CMblCJlOM 3BKp8IIJ1fDCIQ8fi: ero HOpMbl. C ,[ijJyI'Ofi CTOpoHbI, paC1ill1pe-
HHe c<lJepbl ,!\eJICTBI1H ocpaHIf'IeHlm B03MO:IKHO nl1lllb nyreM BHeCeHl1H
B COOTBeTCTByKlLqI1e HOpMbl H3MeHeHl1R>,3. O.I\HaXO Y'leHbrn: OTMeTWI
.mmn.lfiITepecnpHIOIpBffif'ItHKflBnp}lH-
wmecB06o.I\bIWrooopa.
IIpl1HI..Ufil CBo6oAbl ,JJ;oroBopa, no MHeIDIIO B.H. YpyKOBa, ><,l\8If-
CTBYeT TOJlbKO B OTHOIll8HIDf, KaK npaBKJIo, 'laCTHblX Jrnl..\ Jj no nOBopY
oip3lf1-ReHmro lOC'IJIWIeCTBa om.eKTOB Ipam,zwHC101X lIpaB. OTvr .I\oro-
BOpbl B 6oUHIllfllC'TBe cBoeM HaIIpaBJIeHbl Ha YAoBJI8TBopeHl1e ,m.rq-
'KOfK:TKTYll'lR4<uwpaL.ll1MI""''''''''IiCeHaJlOJl,H.''.H'''()COoaH''''''1212.1993Jlcy-!eTO''
nonpaBOK.B"&eeH....3S1<O"aMP<POnonpa"K8XKKO"CTI<I)\jI<P<POT30_12_2008N'6."'K3,OT
30122OOBN'74>K3)/fPocCMiic....ru'm2009_N'7
'l1o.ll.eJ1jlo"",eePK"""""""YII'"ocrnOJlO)l(""MnyHtmllGT""",T79l1nyH""'ICTI1T...781rpa;t;.
.Aa>1CKoroKQAeKGapaL.ll1MBC""""CIl<a1lO6aMOOL1li!CTB<lCorpaHNelH)'O""'T'
CT""'HOCTI>IO-.AretnCTBOo<oprepang>QiinacHOCT''''Ipa)I(,!1a"MH!lB_BMa_eaIloCTS»OBII"'
11",,CyIJ.3P<POT23,012007N'1-nlfC3P<P.2007N'6.Cr.828.
3TaH3r.1A.H.npl1HLJ,I<nc:eo6Q.<looJlOr08OpaBIIC"""'IlpaIISPoccM:.II.I10 .......,IOp'llj,tI3yK,M.
Pr5.2003_c9
94

Hh1Xnmpe6Hocrei!: rpam,n;aH, KOTOpbIe HOCwr .mrqHbru
XapaKTep» '.
KoHLtermJ1R np1 CB06o.I\bl ,lJ;OI'OBopa HBJUleTCR TOHKOil «rpa-
HbKJ» Me>fiJ\Y a6COJl101'HOu CB06omil3lOCJHOMK'I8CKMX J1H'1'epeCOB }"Ia-
CTBYKJX B .I\OI'OBOpe JIJIILt Jj J1HTepeCOB 06LLtecTBa Jj rocY.lIBpCTBa,
o CTeneHb OrpaHJ1'-1eHJ1R JlOCOBOpHOii CBo60.I\bL
CTaTbJ'lI rKPtP,npe,l\YcMa'I'plnpJ106peTeHJ1eJ1oCYlL\ecT-
BJleHl1e rpam,n;aHaMJ1 Jj IOP"lI.J1'I8Cl\11MJ.f Jlln.laMJ1 CBOJ.fX rpam,n;aHCKJfX
npaB CBom BOJIei1: Jj B CBOeM I1HTepece, a TaIOKe CBOOO,l\Y B ycraHOBJIe-
IDIJ.f CBOJ1X npaB J1 06H3aHHc:x.-reH lIB OCHOBe J],orOBOpa IiI B onpe,neJleHJ111
nKJObIX He npoTl1BOpe'-lax 3BROHO.l\BTenbCTBY ycnomm .I\OrOBOpa,
B n. 2 onpe,neJuleT qeJIJII, paiU'l,nocTWKeHl1f.! KOTOpblX B03MC»KHO orpa-
IDI'JeIDIe rpam,!\aHcID1X npaB lIB OCIiC:EalDfif c}:Je,[lepaJlbHOI'O 3aKOHa.
K TaKJ1M l\eIDIM OTHOCflTCfl 3aTa OCHOB IWHCTJ1'I)'LIIfOHHOCO C1pOfl,
HpaBCTBeHHOC'l11, 3.I\OpoBbJ'l, npaB Iil3aI«JflHbIX IilHTepecoB ,[ijJyrJ.fX Jill1\,
ooecne'JeHJ1e o6opoHb! cTpaHbl IiI oe3onacHOCTJ.f roCY.llBPCTBa.
AHaJIJll3 Bcex c.II)''JaeB olpalUl'leHJtfl nplrnqJma CBo60.I\bl J],oroBOpa,
3aKpenJleHHblX B rK PtP, n03BOJU1J1 Ha ,[IOK'!'pIfH<UIbHoMypoBHe c<lJop-
MYnMpoBaTb cJIe,!l)'lOe TpJ1l\eJIJ1 OIpaHWIemrn cB06o.I\bl.I\oroBopa:
«Bo-nepBblX, 3allU1Ta CJla6eiirne:H CTOpoHbI, IWTOpaJ'l Ha'D1HaeTCfl
co CTaJ];JlJI3aKJIKJ'IeHJ.fJ'l ,[IOrOBOpa Iil3aBepWaeTCJ'I ero J1CnOJIHeHl1eM
J1 OTBeTCTBeHHOCTbKJ 3a HapyrneHl1e.
Bo-BTOpblX, 3TO 3al.l..\l1Ta J1HTepecoB Kpe,IJ;l1TOpoB, yrp03a KOTOpbIM
MomeT OKa3aTb paapyuDITeJIbHOE' BJlHflHJ.fe Ha rpam.!laHC1O'1ii o60poT.
B--rperbI1X. 3all\MTa MHTepeCOB rOCY.I\apCTBa, B KOHLteHTpI1pOBaH-
HOMBl1.!IeJ1HTepeCbIOOLLteCTBa.
llnfl 3JII1MID{JipoBaID1H A8JIcrBI1fl TaKoro po.I\a c}:JaKTOpoB B03H11KaeT
OCThOTCT)'IDITbOTnpI1HJ..tI1rraIOplWI'l8Cl\OroI1TeMcaMb!M
clxJJ:M<UIbHOOO paBEtiCTBa. IIpl1 IIBJII1'IID1 K TOM)' .I\OCTaTO'lHblX npe.I\IIO-
CbUiOK 3aKOHO.I\BTeJIb npe,IJ;OCTaBMeT onpe,IJ;eneHHble npeI1M)'lL\eCTBa
60JIee CJIaooi1 CTopoHe npJ.f 3aKJIlO'I8ID111 .I\orOBOpa, onpe.I\eJIeHl1J.f era
CO.I\epmaHHfl, B03MJ)KH()CTJIM3MeHeHHflI1.ID:l pacTOpmeHl1fl»2.
Hi1 onpe.n;eJIelllible 3aKQHO.I\BTeJIeM B II. 2 CT. I fK PtP, ID1,l1PK'1pKH£Ji1
l\eJIJ1 orpaID1'1Eti11R C:SOOO.I\hl ,lJ;OI'OBcpa He 060cHOBbIBBiOT IIOH)':iK.!leHl1e
K 3BKmOQeHIDD ,[IOl'OBopa KyI1JIi1-rrp.:>.n;amJ1 B J1CCJIe,l\YeMOM HaM>:! CJIy'-I3.e.
TaKl1M 06pa30M, IIOJiy'IBE'TC-f, eCJll1 HanpJ.fMep COCOOcTB8HHi1K He MOme'!'
IIpD.ABTh CBOlO.I\OJllO OHMOme'!' 06JI3aTh ee KyrntTh COC05creeHHl1KOB. Mo-
'Ypyl«)l1B_HBoJ1""-cyII\eCT"eHHblSycnoB,,"rpa>lWlHC<o--npaElOllOl'OAOrO!lOl)a"
H"","",,2010.fl.G27.C.25-30.
. D.orooopoooeI1j)aBO.KH"ranep_:06L11'16I]OJlo_",/M.I1.Epa","c"<I1,B.8 BH1peHCKI1 M .era.
TYT.2011 c_450
95

'lUBJ1fJCJf5I<a cyna 0 TOM, 'IT'O «BbIIIJIaTa  OCTaKJll(J1MCR CO-
Co6cTBeHHJ1KOM He RBJIR8'J"CJ'I 06peMmeIDreM, a 03Ha-
'JaeT ,l\JIH OcraKJerocfI COCo6cTBeHHl1Ka YBe.JIWIeHJ.1e era ,n0Jill B npaBe
co6cTBeHHOCTI1 Ha lWHKpeTHDe  He MomeT C'IJiITaTbCR yf>e-
.vxreJIbHoiii, TaR RaR peweIDfe 0 3BRJUO'IeIDfif ,nol'OBCpa KyIlJII1-IIpJ,!\am:vJ
,n0JDKHbI npIDrnMaTb o6e CTOpOHbI, a He TOJIbRO IIpJ,!\aBeLj. ITORynaTeJlh
CBM BnpaBe pewaTb eJlec006pa3HOCTb npm4JeTeIDm.wrn ce6H,n0Jll.1.
C>rpamol'Iem18 CBo5o,!J;bJ ,IJ;OraBOpa ycMa"TpJ.1BaeTCHTalOKe 11 B .npyrnx
acneKTax pea.mf3aLtJ111 BbJ,I:(eJla.nom1. CamacHo n. 4 CT. 252 «Hecopa::l-
MepHoCTb HMYeCTBa, MOrO B Harype yqacTHYlKY ,IJ;oJleBOiii
c06cTB8HHOCTI1 Ha OCHOBaffiIH HBCToReH CTaTbl1, era ,noJle B npaBe
co6crBeHHOCTH yc'IpBHH8TCR BbllIJIaTOiii COO'flI8'I'crBJlOW8HlI8HE'>KHOii
cyMMbII.fJiJ'llrnrn KOMII8HCaqMeM.
BblI11IBTayq:acTHI1KYJlOJleJ3Olfco6cTBeHHOCTI1OCTaJIbHblMl1col3c'rB8H-
HJ1KBMIII KOMI1eHCaq1'lll BMeCTO BbJ,I:(eJla ero ,n0Jll1 B mrype ,nOnyCKaeTCH
c era corJlacID!. B CJIy'lam: KOrna,nOJrn o:fcrnEHHUJi.B He3HS<rn:T€'JlbHa,
He MruKeT OblTb peaJIbHO BbJ,I:(eJleHa 11 OH He l1Meer cyIl\eCTBeHHora J1H-
TepeGa B Jt:cnJJIb3OBaHI'II1 o6era I1I\oIYI-lI8CTBa, cy,!\ MOiKeT J1 npl1 oTCyT-
CTBI1I1 cor.rracl1R :enora co6CTB8HHI1Ka OOH3aTb OCTBJlbHbIX yq:aCTHI1KOB
,noJl8BoMco6crneHlDCTHBbm.rraTIITbeM)'.
llepBbIi1a63ar.J..l\BHHOranyHKTa$pM)'.ID1pOBaHT3.lGfM06pa3OM, 'ITO
He 'Ip€6yeTCfl corJlacue 1m u:6cTBeHHKKa, no.rr:yqalOl1\era TaK)'lO KOMIJeH-
ca4i1lO, HI1 C06cTBeHHHKOB, Bb!lIJ1a'il1B8lQIqI1X €e. BTOpoMa63ar.J.npe-
Ma:rpHBaeTCOrJlaCUeTOJlbKO  BbIIIJIa'IY, HO He COco6cTBeH-
ID1KOB, BbIIIJIa'll1BBKJlQI1X  B TO BpeW! KaK IDCJIe.lJ;IDre
,nOCTa'I"O'fHO 'JaCTO BblCtynalOT n:pcmm TaKOra peweHl1H IIpJMeMbL TaK,
C.H. 06paTI1JICR B cY;II C J1CKOM K C.B., C.R. 0 Bl>J,IJ;eJle ,nOJU1 :H\]I/JlOro
,nOMa B Ha'lY])e, IIpOCI1JI npotl3B8CTtl pa3,!J;eJl,nOMa J1 Bbl,!J;eJrnTb B CBOID
C06cTBeHHOCTb 'laCTb:HGlJlOra ;IlOMS, KOMHaTbINQ 1, 2 B c'IpoeHJ.1J1JrnT. A;
TaM6yp NQ 3 B JU1T. A, J1 rrpeKpa'l11Tb 061l.{YlO ,nOJleBj'lO cofx:rnellliOCTb.
B o6oCHOBaHl1e 'Ipe6oBamm }'Ka3aJl, ':ITO eM)' IIpJ1HB.II.1I8) 1/4
,nOJL<l, C.B. -1/4,nOJlRJ1CH. - 1/2,n0m:r.nomMeco-
BJI3.ll£'JIbQBMR B03Hl1KalOT cnopbl 0 nOpH,!I;Ke nOJlb30BaHI1RI1 BJIaA8HHH
,nOMOM nopH,!\oK nOJlb30BaHI1.H ,IJ;OMOBJIa,!\eHl1eM Me coc06CTBeH-
HI1KaMJII ,nOMa CJlruKI1J1CR. He B03pama.n: I1pOTI1B y,nOBJleTBOpeHI1H
BCTpe'lHoro J1CKa. C 3BKJlKJ'IeIDI€M cy,ne6Hoi1 crponre.I1bHO-TeXHl1'i8-
cKOi13KCneJITl13b1 cor.rraceH B 'JaCTI1 onpe,!\eJl€HI1.H BapmUITa pa3,!\eJla
,nOMa, O,!\HaKO He comaceH C pa3MepoM KOMneHcawrn 3B npeBblllleffilIe
pa3Mepa lfJ\eaJIbooii: ,IJ;0JI11, C':II1TaR ee 3BBHllI€HHOH.
c.n He B03pa>KaJI nponm y,l\OBJI8TBOpeHl1R "Tpe60Bamrn C.H
npe,l{bRBI1JI BC1pe'lHbrn J1CK a BbI,!\eJle ,nOM ,nOMa B mrype, JKB3aB,
96

'!TO flB.nR€TCH Co6cTB€HHHKOM 1/2 ;nOJIH ;nOMa, 11 npocl1.n Bbl,l\eJII1Tb
II co6crBe1rn:OCTbecKJl3aHI1MB8MYK1'!aCTb;nOMal1 npeKpamTb
OOIl\Y1O ;no.neBYJO Co6cTB€HHOCTb.
OrBe'I"illK c.B. II cy;neoHoM 3BC8)\aHJ.rn He B03pa)Ka.IIa npoTMB Tpe-
fJoBaHui'j: 0 pa3,!\€JI€ AOMa no KTWIeCKJ1 CJ10arnBW€MYCH nOpR,lJ;KY
I1O.1lb3OBBHIfJI, COrJIaCHa C IIp8,l\C'l'aB.JI8H 3BKJIJO'IeHJ1eM CTpOJ1-
TeJ1hHO-ii 3KcnepTJ13bl, HO C'lJ1Ta€T 'ITO pB3Mep KOMTIeH-
cal.\J1I.f 3a npemnneHJl€ pa3Mepa u,II€aJlbHOi1: ,!\OJll.f 3BBblW€HHblM'.
HeCMOTpR Ha TO '!TO o6a OTBeT'll1Ka JKa3UB3.mf Ha 3aBbIWeffile
pa3M€pa KOMlleHCal.\l1H 3B npeBblW€lU1€ pB3Mepa Ju:teaJlbHOO AOJ1I1,
cy,!\ y,!\OBJIeTBopJ1.n I1CK Jj OOHaaJl BbinJIaTHTb KOMn€HCal.\HIO 3a ,D;OJIIO
II I1CnpaWl1BaeMOM pB3Mepe
n.M.c. OOpaTJ.fJICH II cy.n; c I1CKOM K MMH., RAC. 0 B3b1CKaHIDI
KOMIIeHCal.\HI1 3a ,D;OJllO II KBapnrp€, o6oCHOBaB "Ip€60BaIDIH TeM, '!TO
II COOTBeTCTBHII C ,D;OroOOpOM ,D;apeID1R m 23 I1lOJIR 2008 r. HBJUI€TCH
co6cTBeHHJ.JmM 1/4 ,D;OJlI1 II O.I\HOKOMHaTHoi1: KBapTI1pe. IWYrJllMI1 c06-
CTBelllHIKaMl1 A8HHoif KBBpTl1PbI .HBJlmDTCH OTlleT'IUllJ1. KOTOpble TaK-
me WMelOT no 1/4 ,D;0J1I1. OrneT'lJmn po,lIC'I'B8HHlmBMJI He flBJlRIOTCR.
HaMepeH pacnop.H.IIJlTbC.H cBOei1: ,D;OJIei1:, O)J;HaKO II GllHaI1 C TeM, '!TO
aHa CJII1IIIKOM MBJIa, :;rroi1 B£:I3MmKHOCTbIO IIOcnoJIb3OBaTbCH He Mom€'!'.
7 ceHTJIDpH 2009 r. '!epe3 HOTapl1yca mBeT'lJ1KaM 6b1J1o HaIIpaBJleHO
IIJ1CbMO C Wlt}JopMal.\l1ei1: a npo,!\BmE' 1/4 ,D;0J1I1, O,!J;HaKO O1'B€'!'a a mE'-
JIalU111 npro6pecTJl 3T}' ,D;OJIIO nOJI)"ieHO He 6b1JI0. npoCI1T B3b1CKaTb
C UI138T'iJIKOB COpHO CJMMYKOMlleHcawrn 3a 1/4,D;0J1I1 II pa3Mepe
260 000 !')'D.
0rIIeT<rnK MMH. II Cy.n;e5HOM 3aCe,I\BHm1 JICK()IIl,E Tpe6wamu:r
llB.IO.HeIIpI13HaJ1a,nOHCHI1JIa, 'lI'OHecOrJlBCHa cT])E'60BaID1HMJ10113bl-
cKaHm1 CJMMbI KOMI1eHCal.\1'lll II COpHOM nopflAKe, TaK RBK OHa,
OTBeT'IHK, .HBJlHeTCH neHCJroHepoc:M, I1HbIX AOXO.n;OB He lIMe€'!', CeMbH
M.AC.MHoro)J;eTHa.H, Hecor.nacHa cOCTOWMOCTblO
1/4)J;0JIJ1 II p3.3Mepe 238 000 py6 TaK RBKCTOWMOCTb 1/4,lJ;0JII.f noSHa-
JlOrJll'llibIMKBapn1paM, cOrJIaCHO3Ha'MTeJ1hHOIDDKe.
J.1cnmHe 'I]J86oEaIDm OblJII1 y,D;OBJIemopeHbI, pew€ID1e cy,!\a no,!\-
JleiKaJIO OO:HCaJIOBBHJ1lQ 11 1I:;rroi1 'iBcnrOC'raBJleHO 6e3 J'!3MeHeID1R BbI-
llIecroHll(J'lMJIJ.
O6H3aHHOCTb IIbITIJIaTI1Tb KOMIIeHCal.\Ifi B03JIaraeTCH H8 JII05oro
cocoDC'rB8HHI1Ka, 6YAb TO neHCI10Hep I1J11.f Hepa5crrmoI.l..p1i1: rpa1K,I\aHI1H.
'G1pe,o,eJleHMeMDCI<OEICKOIlJOO;,aGT>IOI1>CYJla0T26.Q5,2011JJOlI!!1IYNII33'12150.
'onpe.<iSI1&HMeBep>o:eo--ocyIJ,3YJIMYj)TcKoPecny6;lMKo23_03_2011OI'lSJlY
N!33-100Qj2011
97

3ro rome He MomeT B nOJIHOH Mepe COOTBeTCTBOBaTb t:urrepecaM Bbl-
,[IeJlR1Ow;eroCR C06cTBeHHt1Ka, TaK KaK BbllIJlaTa CTOt1MOCTIf ,IJ;OJlt1 MO-
>KeT paCTJ'lH)'TbCH Ha ,IJ;OJII'Me I'OJ\bL
IIII20TH0rnemli1: oow;e!::i,IJ;01l8BOii co6cTBeJrnocom: CorJIac-
HO HopMaM J18iiCTB}'IDw;ero rpam,IlaHCKOI'O 3aKOHO,!\BTeJlbCTBa xapaK-
rep:I3}'f:'TCfI 'ipe3MepHo 3aBblIlleHHblM rpacoM npI1HYJ\t1TeJIbHOCTM
t1 arcyrCTBt1eM OaJIaHCa t1lITepeCOB Bcex coco6crnemrJ.u< KOTOpbrn
BbIpIDK<l€'TCJI C OJIHoi1: Crop::lHbI, B $;lRTIftleCKOM 06H38JIt1t1 cocooCTBeH-
Ht1KOB BbIKynaTb J\OJlIO, a C JlPyroH CropoHbl, B pt1CKe J\0JIT0BpeM8H-
HblX BblllIIBT CI'CHMOCTJI ,[IOJll:l.
EM BbIHBJleHmI JI)"illIJ.1X 1303M0>KH0CTei1 npeKpaw;eHt1H OTHOllle-
Ht1H ,[pJIeBOI'i co6CTBeHHOCTt1 IJ;eJIecoOOpa:mo npoaHaJIJI3HpOBTb HOp-
Mbl HeKOTOpblX eBp::Inei1CK.t1X npaBonopH,IJ;KOB, a t1MeHHO HOpMbI rep-
MaHcKOro Ipa)K,!\aHCKoro YJIomeHIDI, lIIBe!::iqapcKoro rpIDK.JJ;lHCKOI'O
YJIOmeID1H t1 Bce06w;ero rp1mWJlororo YJIom8HmI ABCTpt1J1. ,l(aHHbre
I\OJI:I«!nfii.aQt1t1 t1MelOT 6o.rree 'ieM ,I:\ByxCOTJIeTHlQlQ tlCTOPHIQ perYJIt1-
pOBam1H urII)UEHJri.i cOOCTBE'HHOCTII t1 HBJlffiOTCH aBTopt1TeTHefunt1Mt1
B Espone.
EsponeikKt18 KOJIt1IiI npe,IJ;OCTaBJImOT CocOOCTBeHHt1KaM
6oJlbIID1!::i Bw60p sapt1BHTOB npeKpaw;eHt1H OTHOlll8B11M ,I:\OJIeBo!::i coo-
CTBE'HHOCTI1
ComaCHO  749 a03. 1 repM8HCKCro rpa>fi,!\8HCKITO YJIOmeHt1H'
(.D;aJlee - rry) .mo5oJ1 }"1acTHI1K B .moooe BpeMR MOmeT npeKpamTb
OTHOIIIeHtUl J],OJIeBolii: C£fuBeHHor:TIL B .moooe BpeMH 03Ha'laeT, 'iTa
He HYmHO J\Oml1J1aTbCR samHbIX npWU1H t1 OCHOBaHJ1H, a TalOKe He-
3BBMCt1NIO OT He6.naronpIUITHOCTt1 speMeIDI. RoNJICCJ1f! no C03,!\BHt1lO
rrY HaMepeHHo OTKa3aJIaCb OT nOHHTt1H «He6.naronpWITHoe ;n.m:I npe-
KpaIlleHMe speMJ'I», xarJ'l TaKoe YCJIOBt1e JIJIH OTcpO'ffit1 npeKpaw;eHI1J'1
cyw;eCTByeT B JlPynrx CTpaHax HeMeUKOro npaBoBoro Kpyra 2 . CpoK
tlCI«JBOi;j: J18BHOCTt1 Ha t1CK 06 OTMeHe J\OJleBOH oOIItHOC'l'tI He pacnpo-
CTpaIDIeTCH (758 rry). IIaparpa4J 752-753 rry peryJlJ1pYKY" nopH-
,[IOK OTMeHbl. IIpeKpaw;eIDfe OOIIJ;HOCTI1 npm nyTeM pa3J\eJIa
B HaType, ROrJ18 oow;ffi1 npe,QMeT t1Jll:1 HearoJJbKO npe,I:\MeTOB, eCJll:I OHI1
.HBJImDTCJ'I oOlIJ;I1Mt1, MOryr ObITb 6e3 }'MeHbllIeHJ1.H CTOJt:MOC'I11 pa3J\e-
JIeHbl Ha 'l8CTI1, COOTB8TCTByrolIJ;l1e ,I:\OJIJIM }"1aCTHI1JC;OB. B HeMeQKOM
npaBe BbI,II,E'JlHE'TCH qn He,I:\eJW!MOCTb, KOTOpaH npeJ\onpe,IJ;e-
JIeHa €}JIf3HY:eCKMMt1 CBOIICTI38.MJ.1 BelIJ;l1.  B CMny 3aROHa,
'Bir'gerllchesGesetzbuchDeutschland>'OmIB_AugUS11B96F1GaISI95rnkraltlre1en
aml..lanuarl900.
2:;'3hnOrrR.o;eGemejOSChaftnachBru::tMlleo1({i741-758BGBITMOhrSjebeCk.2004.
98

TO ecTb npe.lJYCMarpeHHaH 3aKOHOJ\aTeJIbHO, a TalOKe SKUHOMK'I8CKaH
HeJ\eJU1MOCTb, TO eCTb }'MeHbllI8HIl8 C'lOJ1W)CTIt: l1M)'meCTBa B pe3}'JIb-
TaTeJleneHUR. YMeHblll8HJ18C'I'OHMOCT1fnpeeTa ny-
TeM Bbl'll1TaHJ1H 113 CTOI1MOCTI1 Hepa3J\eneHHoro npe,IJ.MeTa CYMMb!
C'I'OJ'JWJC'I'€ JlOJ1etl, n0Jl.Y'leHHbIX B pe3YJIbTaTe pa3,!\eJIa. Ecnl1 lIpe,!\-
MeT B lIenOM crOI1T fum.llle 'leM COBOK)'I1HOCTb pa3J1e.II8HIill era 'la-
cTei1:, CJleJ\OBaTeJIbHO, pa3J\en np:fBQlU'IT K }'MeHbllleHJ1lO C1OJIMOCTtI
BellV1l1 JleJleHJ1e 6YJleT O nocpe,!\CTBOM ee npo,!\a»Ol'.
PacI1fJ8J18.lI8HJ1e paBHblX Jlone BellV1 Me*AY }"1aCTHJ1KaMl1 npoIf3EO-
JJ)1TCH no mpeol1IO.
Ecnl1 pa3,!\en B HaType OTnaeT, lIpe18 06lltHoCTI1 npo-
1f3BQlU{'I'CH nocpe,!\CTBOM npo,!\a»Ol 06mero npe,IJ.MeTa no npaBJ1JIaM
npo,!\a»Ol 3B.JI())I{8HIIC l1M)'meCTBa, JIJIH 3eMeJlbHbLX )"IaCTKOB - no-
cpe,!\CTBoM 1Ip11H)',IJ;J1TE'JIbIJOO npo,!\a»Ol C TOproB 11 paclIpe,!\eJleHl1H
Bb!py<nm. B CJlY"'ae 6e3pe3}'JlbTaTHOCTJ1 nepBoi1 nOnb!TKl1 1Ip0Tb
npe,QMeT lUlli\,lU>Ii1 }"1aCTHI1K MruKeT narpe60BaTb nOBTOpHoro 1Ip0Be-
,QeHUR TOproB 3a cooi1 C':IeT.
Ecnl1OT<JYm,!\eHl1e TpeTbeMY Jll11..\Y He .QOIJyrnaeTCJ'I, npe,QMeT JlOJI-
meH 6b1Tb 1Ip0H C TOprOB O;:J;HOM)' 113 )"IaCTlll1lWB 06lltHOCT!1.
IIpaBo TpeOOBaTb p3.:3.n;eJla B81lV1 MOiKE'T 6b1TborpaHl1'1E!1o B JlOroBO-
peMe*AYIHaOCHOBaHl1Y!ao3. 2  749 rrY,B CJlY"'ae
perJ1CTpaWU'l HHOro cOmallleHl1H B JI:!3eM8JIbHJif KHHre ORO OyJ1eT
I1MeTb J\eeCTBHe 11 B OTHOIlI8HJ':I11 nIXffiOnpeeMIDlKoB ( 1010 rry). 3a-
lIpe'l' Ha  06lltHOCTI1 He OYJ1e'1'.n;eiicrooBaTh IIpI1 HaJIJ1'II1I1
BaiKHbIX 0CIDBBHJrlii, KOTOpbIe .n;eJIaKIT JJ:BJIbHeihuee 
06lltHOCTI1 HeB03MOmHbIM. ):{aHHoe 1IpaBJ1J!0 IIpI1MeHHe'I"CH B repMaHl1I1
KO BceM npo,!\OJDKalOlltI1MCH OOH3aTeJIbCTBaM. OCHOBaHI1H, OTMeHH-
IOllV1e 3anpeT Ha npeRpameHl1e 06lltHocTl1, MorYT 6bITb OIlpeJl8JIEHbI
CaMl1M11 COCo5cTBeHlrHKaMM 11 }'Ka3aHb! B Ka'leCTBe TaKOBbIX B corJIa-
UJemrn.
CYJ1eOHaR lIpaKTIfKa CJIOJKI1JIaCb TBKI1M OOpa:30M, 'ITO O,--!eHKa
BamHOCTI1 0CHJBaIIJIi.f JJ:.IlH np€KpaI..IJ;eHl1H 06lltHoCTI1 OC}'l.ll;eCTBJIHeTCH
B KB1K,I{OM KOHKp8TIIOM cnyqae. BecKJ1e np14'll1RbI MOryr ObITb 3aJIO-
m8HbI B nCEeJ\E'HJU1 Y"'aC'rHMKB, eCJrn OR J\enaeT npeObIBaHJ1e B 06m-
HOCTI:! Henp14eMJIeMbIM. IIp14 STOM 3Ra'l8Hl1e I1MelOT TOJIbKO npaBOBbJe
aCIIeKTbI, TO eCTh Mernae-r Jill OR npl1HHTI1lO peIIIeHJ1J1. IIpeIIRTCTayeT
I1X 111J111 yKlIOHReTCR OT I1X I1CIIOJIHeHl1R.. Ecnl1 pe'lb l1,QeT
T('IJ1hRQ 0 JII1'IHbIX cCopax 11 OOI1,r\BX, TO ,[(BRHaR IIpI1'U1Ha He MruKeT
'C.., RebmaMK S!lckerF RlxeckerA Muncheoerl(onmentarzumGesetzbuch 5.AutI.
MfrdIerrBECK,201O,S_567
99

c'illTaThCR,nocKoJlhKYaTO.noneBa.<I06Jl.tHocTb,aHeco-
BMecrnaH  HaJB1'Dte J1W1HhIX O1'HOllI8HIrn 3.I\eCh He 06R3aTenhHO. IIo
MHeHl1KJ  cyTJ.a, Ba:>KHaR npWlHa MO€T Bh1paThCH
BO BCeCTOpOHHeM HapyllleHJII B3BJIMHoro ,[IOBepJIIH, HaIIpJIIMep, B pe-
3YJlhTaTe CCOpbI }"1aCTHI1KOB, HOTOJlhKO BTOM CJI)"18e, ecJIJ'J 3TOHeno-
cpe,lJ;CTBeHHO I\aCaeTCR o6nuIoc'm. Cy,lJ; B I\am,zJ;OM KOHKpeTHOM CJIyqae
BhlHCHHeT, MO8T J1J1 06OCTh npO,lJ;OJITh npJlleMJIeMhIM cnoc060M
ynpaBJI8HI18 11 nOJIh30BaHl1e 06ll.\eiii Bell.\hKJ. Ccopa M<»KeT 6hITh ,lJ;0-
CTaTO'llia I\aK BamHaR IIpJ1'DtHa, eCJUI cOC'06CTBeHHI1KI1 ynpaBJIHKYI'
06I.J..U1M npe,1J;ME'TOM caMJII, HO eCIDI ynpaBneID1e O8TCII Hei1-
TpBJIhHhIM yrrpaBJlHKJM, TO ccopa He HBJlHeTCR EroKHCDI IIpIf'n1IIOiii
JJ:.JIRnpeKpall.\8HI1Rm.
BaHOi1 IIpJ1'DtHOiii MOeT 6hITh He T{lJIbRQ IIOBeJ\8m18 }"1aCTH11Ka,
HO H 06-heKTKBHhle aKThI 11JI11 .nWiHhIe OTHOlll8HJIIH C06cTBeHH11Ka,
Tpe6YKJll.\erO OTMeHY. TaKOBhIM .HBJIHeTCH GYll.\eCTBeHHoe JIJlH 06ll.\-
HOCTI1 J13MeHeHH8 c6c:T0m-e.m.cm, HBIIpl1Mep, npH H€E03McPKHOC'rn
,[IaJlhHefuuero HCIIOJIh3OBaIDUI B8l.W1 no l.\eneBOMY HB3HB'leHHKJ. PB3-
BO,[l MO8T 6hITh npwiJ'1HoJ1: OTMeHhI ,[\OJI8BOii 06lqHOCTH cynpyrOB,
TaK>Ke KaK 11 npeKpall.\eHHe BHe6pa'lHhIX OTHOIll€HIrii I1mopHpoBa-
HHe IIpl1 IIJ:&1H.HTHI'1 pewemDI, eCIDI BhI,D.eJIHlOIl.H coa:fcmeIrnmt;
H3X£J.r0:1TCfI B M8HhllIIDfCTBe. IIOCKOJIhKY CTOpoHbI orpaHI'f'DfJIll CBOI1M
CorJIallIelUleM npaBO OTMeHbI, ,[Iae npJII HaJlJ'J'illJII Ba:>KHoi::i nplt'lHHhI
HY}KHO C'illTaTbCH C I1HTepecaMH ,[ijJyrJ.1X J'ffiCTHI1KOB. HeCBOeBpeMeH-
HOCThHJ1RMmKeTHapyrnaTbHHTepeCh1,[ijJy-
rHX B, nO:ITOMY OHJII BIIpaBe Tpe60BaTh B03Mellt8HHH
npl1'D'1H€HHbIX y6NTKoB.
IIIrY' npei1.YCMaTpJllBaeT B  650 npaBo l\am,zJ;oro COCo6cTBeHHJllKa
npeKpaI.l..\BTh OTHOllleHl1R,l\OJI8BOH C06cTBeHHoCTl1. ,lJ,amme npaBo MO-
.meT 6hITh orpaHl1'IeHO 3aKOHOM (Hanpl1Mep. npJII npaBe ,D;OJIeBOH c06-
CTBeHHOCTII Ha 'laCTb 3.I\BHJIIH), COrJIallI8HlleM CTOpoH .ID160 ,lJ;IDITenh-
HOCThKJ l.\eIDI JlCIIOJIb3OBBHI1H Bei..W'I. Cor.nallleHl1e MomeT I1CKJIIO'lBTh
npaBO OTMeHbl MaKCI1M)'M Ha 50 .neT. BOTHollleHIDf 3eMeJlhHoro }"1acT-
Ka ,D,aHHoe COrJIallleHl1e nO,!I,JIemJ:IT pernCTpal.\Jfi'l B n03eMeJlhHOH KHI1-
re, 'ITO 06ecne'illBaeT ero ,D;eJt:cTBI18 B OTHOlllE'lillH npaoonpe8MHJ1KOB.
OrMeHa He ,[IoJDKHa I1CIIpaIill1BaTbCR B He6JIaronpIDIrnoe BpeMH, TO
eCTb nepHO,!\, B KOTOpbrlf coco6crnemnm: I1MeeT oc06J1O 3al1HTepeco-
BaHHOCTb B I1O.JIb3OBaIDDI Bell.\hKJ (HanpHMep, CeJIhCK0X03.fliiiCTBeHHaff
y60pOIJ:H:iJI T8XHJUi.a B nepl1o,lJ;yDopKl1 ypojfi.ajJ)
'z;,l1lgese1ZbochIlOll'l10.Dezember1907SR2101nkratttretenam1Janl.lElrrn12
100

IIaparpacj:l651 IIp8.l:J;}'CM<ITpl1BaeT CJIeJJYKJIWfe Bapl1aHThI OTMeHb!
06lltHocrn: 1'H:"<:I{I61 pa3.n;enBel1tl1; npoma Bell.\l1 BOObr<rHOM no-
PHmt8.ID100 C 3YKW10Ha, nOCpe.n;CTBOM JleJIeHHR AOXOJla nponopl\llO-
HaJIbHO J],OJUIM; nepeM'la Bel1tl1 O)J.H0MY I1.JII1 HeCl({)JIl,I{HM COB.1Ia.n€JTh-
l.\aM. Ecmf CTOpOHhI He CMOr.ID1  a cnocooe pa3J1e.na, ero
Bb16upaer CYJ1hJ'l. B nepBYKJ o'-J.epe,lJ,b OOC)"K,[\aeTCJ'I B03MOHtHOCTb clJl1-
311'-J.eCKoro pa3J1e.na BeJW:I, ecmf 3T0 BJIe'leTC :yMeHbllle-
IDle ee CTOUMJC'l1l, TOrJla BenpO,!l;aeTCH. EcmfCTOpOHhIcornaCHbJ Ha
clJl13Jf'-J.8CIIDe ,neneHlfe B HepaBHblX 'laCTHX, TO B03MOjKHO Ha3Ha'leHl1e
,QeHejKHOM KOMlleHCaLtIDl.
AHaJlOI1f'llibJM nopOK npe.n;yCMaTpl1BaeT  830 MY'; Kam,zr;brn
cocofx:rBefIHUK MOeT Tpe60BaTb npeKpaIl\eIDIJ'l J],O.I18B(:iOi ofuQHocTtl
3a JK'K.JIIO'l8HHeM CJl)"-J.aeB, ecJIl1 ::rro «npeKpall.\eIDIe HBJ1He'I'CH He-
CBoeBpeMeHHb1M J.1J1J.1 Be,!J;8T K y6hITKY 0CTaJ1bHbIX». TaKrn'o1 06pa30M,
J1JIH OCTaJIbHb!Xcoco5cTBeJnooroB «BpeMellHaJ'lrapaHTI1H,
KaropaH npe,I\CTaBJ1HeT COOOM nrnIlb OTCpO'-J.KY J.1 He npe,!l;OTBpall\BeT
nOJ1HOCTbKJ OTMeH}' O6I.WJOCTI1».
CJIe.I\YIDilU'IM cnOCOOoM npe1fI 06lltHocrn, KpOMe ee OTMe-
fibl, HBJ!H8TCH ,l:\eJ!eIDIe OOll.\eH Bel1tl1, ypery.ID1poBaHHoe  841. BbI,lI;e-
nHlOT,[IEa BI1JIB ,l:\eJ!emrn: HaTypaJIbHOe 11 rp1mWJlCKOe.
Ha-rypaJIbHOe ,l:\eJ!eIDIe  no e,!J;I1HOrnaCHO npl1HJY-
TOMYpeWeHI1KJ no  841, B cJ1Y'-1.aeHe,!J;I1HOrnaC"1H npH-
MeHHeTCH rpl\]KMHcKoe ,l:\eJ!eID1e.
CornacHo  843 ec.ID1 OOuzyIO Be Boo6ll.\e HeJIb3H pa3,1],8JI11Tb.
.ID100 HeB03MOjKHO pa3,!J;eJ!HTb 6e3 3Ha'lHTeJIbHoro :yMeHbllleIDtll CTO-
I1MOCTH, TO .mo6oii: coco6cmeHHH:K MQ.}KeT Tpe60BaTb cY,QeoHoi1 npo-
J],amH Ii pacnpe,!J;eJleHl1H BblpY'lellHbIX cpe,!J;CTB Mem;:Iy yqaCTHIIRaWL
CJle,!J;oBaTeJIbHO, rpam,QaHCKoe ,IJ;eJ!eIDIe, no cyrn, 03Ha'laeT npomy
oOll.\eii: B8ll.\I1 C ny6.IDf'-IHhIX ToprOB, C pacrrpe,IJ;eJ!eID1eM nO.rry'1eHHoro
J],OXOM nponOpW'lOHaJIbHO,l:\OJUIM.
IIpe,!J;ycMoTpeH8. OO3MO>KH0CTh 3aKJIlO<l8HHH Me1KJ\Y cocdic'memn1-
KaMJ1 ,IJ;oroBopa, npe,qycMaT}JHBaIOIl\ero I1CKJII<)qeHHe npaBo -rpeooBaTb
,QeJ!eIDIH BeLqM. OTar ,l:\orOBOp 6Y,!l;8T He.I\81icTmlTE'JlbllblM, TaK me KaK
11 B HeMeIVWM IIpaBe, B c.rry'1ae i303H11KHOBE'HH.H BajKHbIXOCHoBaHI1i1.
IIpoeKTll3MeH€BI1M fKP<P BHOCHT 1:13MeHeHI1HB nopOK pa3,!J;ena
11 BbI,lI;eJ!a,!J;QJ!J1.
'1\IIge""'inesGeselzbuGhfUrdiege""mlendeutscl1enErblanderder
M<nintJevoml JU,.,;IBl1JGSW946jIBl1lnkraftt",lenaml JannerlB12.
'FeiIEBnesys!ematiscIleDarslellurogIOrdiePraxis_WlenLir.de.1001S,56
101

CTaTbR280IIpoeKTa60JIeenp0rpe<::cHBH08nocpaB-
HeHJ110 C .J\eilCTByroUJ;>1M3BKOHO,lJ;aTeJIbCTBOM peryJD1pOBBIDI8, KOTOpoe
3aKJlIO'laeTCR B TOM, 'l'I'0 CTOpoHbI BrIpaBe oopaTIfl'CR B CY,IJ; B CJlyqae
He,lJ:0C'fJDK8HH.I'I cor.naweHlliI KaK no Bbl,!\eJIY ,lJ;0JIJ1, TaR 1<1 no pa3,!J;eny
"MYll\eCTBa B l.\eJIOM. EcnJ1 BbI,!\eJI .J\0m1 B HaType He .J\onYCKaeTCR 3a-
KOHOM J1m1 lY2B03MmKeH 6e3 HeC0pa3M8pmro yll\ep6a J1MYll\eCTBY,
HaXO.J\m..u;eMYCH B 06ll\eil COOCTBeHHOCTI1, BlJ..Q8.JIH1(IWmrn cOOCTBeH-
HI1R no era BbIOOPY J1MeeT npaBO Ha BblIlJIaTY eM)' CTOiIIMOCTI! ero .J\0m1
.J\pyrnMiII yqacTHlfKBMJf .JIOJI£'Brnf cOOcTBeHHOC'l1f, JIJII60 Ha npe,!J;OCTaB-
.neHVle eM)'npaBa BelWIoil BbI,!\a'lill (n. 3 CT. 305). .naHHaHHOpMa n03BO-
.nH8'f oCYIl\eCTBJIm'b pas.n;eJI nocpe,!J;CTBOMnpo,!J;a:lfGf, HOC-
eM pR,!J;B ycnooJrn, lWTOpbIe C}'llI;eCTBeHHO YCJlcmrnmaI' IIpeKpBI1..teHille
OOLqHOCTI!. 3T0 nOJIOiKeIme, HecMO"IpR Ha BCIO CBOIO nporpE'CCHBHJC'
CTaBiIIT B HepBBHb1e yCJIOBVlH COCOOCTBeHHVLKOB, TaK KaK BblI50p CIIO-
cOOa npeKpaLq8HlliI Ocyr.qecrBJUlE'T BhI,JJ;DicH cocOOCTBeHHVLK.
IIpoeKT npHHl.\lUll18JIbHO He yCTj)aHReT He.n;OCTBTKiII .n;eilCTBYlOLqe-
ro nopR,IJ;Ka npeKpall!eIDU! OTHOW8Hm1.J\OJIeBoif  no-
npe)KHeM)' BbICOK 3JI8MeHT oOR3bIBaHmI H HiII30K 6aJIaHC J1HTepeCOB
COCOOCTBeHHI1ROB.
C yqeToM MHoroBeRoBoro IIIXMTI1BHOro OIIbITa perYJD1pOBB.HKfI OT-
HOWeHm1 OOll\eif COOCTB8HHOCTI1 H aHa.ID13a OCHOBHbIX HeAOCTBTKOB
OTe'leCTBeHHoro npaBOnOpJ'!)J,Ka. MO:>KHO npe.n.nOiKJfTb 
BapillaHT 1.R QTHOW8HIUf OOll\ei1 ;o;OJIeaoi1 COOCTBeHHOCTiII:
pB3JJ:e.n OOll\ero  J1 BbI,!\eJI ,l\0m1 J13 Hero OCYll\eCTBJIHeTCR
no cor.narneHl1IO Mem.z\Y coc06CTBeHHlIKBMJL ECJIiII COCOOCTBeHHiIIKVI
He CMor.nH ,l\OCTJ1Qb COrJlarneHKfI, OHI<I BnpaBe 06paTI<ITbCR B eYA.
Cy;o; C yqeTOM  pa3,1J;eJIa BeUJ;>1 B HaType oCYIl\ecTBJIfI-
eT pa3,!J;eJI J1JIJ1 Bbl,!\eJI J],0JI11. ECJlJ1 Bbl,!\eJI .J\0m1 B HaType HeB03MO-
>ReH, ;o;pyrl1M c:oco6c'meHHnKaM IIpeJJ.JIaraeTCR BbIKyrII1Tb ;o;OJlJO. ECJIiII
0CTaJIbHbl8 coco6cTBeHHiIIKVI He 3aMHTepeCOBaHbi B BbIKyne ;o;OJIJ1.nIIDO
CTOpoHaM He y,l\BJlOCb cor.naCOBaTb C'TOJ'2MOCTb ;o;Om1, eTCfI
pa3,1\en BeI.1tJL PB3,1J;eJI J1JIJ1 Bbij:teJl;O;OJIJ1 B HaType, f
B OTCTyruIeIDIe err p83Mepa .J\0JIJ1 C .J\eHe:m:HbIM ypaBIDmaHHeM, B03-
MO:m:E'HTOJIbKO ccor.naclliI coc06CTBeHHiIIKoB. Ec./ll'I cor.naW8lU'!e He ;0;0-
CTIfrnyTO,  IIpO,!J;B:m:a Bell\l1 C pa3.l\£'JJOM CYMMbI, Bbl-
pyqeHHoi1 err npo,!J;a:lfGf Bell\l1, nponopl.\1fOll<lJIl;l.J\OJ1RM
Crroc06 npo,!J;a:lfGf Mo:m:eT 6bITb YCTaHOBJI8H B cor.naweHID:! Mem.z\Y
coc06CTBeHHI1RaMJ1. ECJIiII OR He YCTaHOBJIeH, .J\OJl:m:eH 6bITb Oilpe.l:(eJIeH
cy;o;OM, KOTopbrn: IIpillHJ1MBeT penI8Hl1e, UI'1'<!JIKImaHcb err MHeHiIIH CO-
COOCTB8HHiIIKOB. CyqeToM II(»K8JmHJmCOC06CTBeHHJ1KOB npa]:la)tffi MO-
.meTOC}'l-l\eCTBJIJlTbCHMem.z\YMI1J1J116oTJJ8TbHII'Df.nl1-
102

lIaMlil nOCpe,1J;CTBOM I1pOB('J18JUIR TOproB JU100 I1pOBE'J18HJ.18 06bl'1HbIX
MepOnpJ1HTWi1:, CBH3BlllibD:: C npO,1J;amei1 .YJ.1\eCTBa.
TaKoi1 nOpR.!\OK npeKparrteHJ1H OTHOrneHm1 1 C06CTBeHHO-
CTM 06ecrPumaeT:
1) TO'lHbrli: a.nropMTM ,WlfI coco6cmemnmoB" WUI CY.l\a,
eropernelUf80pa3)1eJIe;
2) co6Jno.neml8 npHllQJU13 CB06o,1J;b1 JJ,oroBopa. O,!\HOro"3 0CH0B0I10-
JlaralOll\>1X npJ1HL!>mOB qaCTHOrO npaBa;
3) 6aJIaHC "HTepeCOB coc TaK RaK Bl:l,!\8JIffiO
,1J;0JI1O coco6cTBeHmIK 6Y.l\eT J.fMeTb pea1Ib1lliI8 BOOIIJI»KHOCTIf oCYll\eCT-
BJleHJ1HBbeJIa,a1KJ1,:meJIaiOllV'leCoxpaHI.fI'bBeIl\bBC05-
CTBeIDIOCTI1, - B03MIDKHOCTb YBeJU1'illTb CBOIO ,1J;0J1I0 J1JII1 OTKa3BTbCH
(YI' 3TOro npasa, 3HaR 0 B03Mo:mHblX l1OCJIe,I],CTBJUIX TaKora OTKa3B.
Omornemtfl o511\e:i1: c05cTBeIDIoCTI1 xap8KTepl13}'lOTC'JI O'ieHb
CJ10mHb!M J1WIHOCTHblM nepEf1Jl8'T€IDl8M. Oc06eHHo 3TO xapaKTepHO
,1J;JUI CJ1'1}'awrn, KOrAB Ha npaBe o511\e:i1: .l\OJIeBoi1 co6cTBellHOC'TIf npl1-
Ha.nJIemwr >KI1JIoe nOMell\eHl1e 11 nO)l o,!\Hoi1 KpbIDIei1 OKa3bIBalOTCH co-
BceM 'i)':mI1e JllO,IJ;III, B03MomHO .l\ame, KOrAB-TO J16bIBlill1e .l\pyr .l\pyry
po,1J;HbIMM (HanpJ1Mep, 6blBlill1e cynpyrl1). .uocTaTO'IHO pe,1J;KI1 cJIY'iaJ1
MMpHOro cocJllI8CTBOBBm1H, K coma.neIDIIO, 'iall\e coco6crBeJnnOOf Ha-
MepeHHo Bpe,lJ;m .l\pyr yrypB3Hb1MJ1 J13011\peHHbOOf cnoc05aMI1, KO-
TOpble JU1wawr II03MIJmHOCTJf HOpMBJIbHOTO COCe,lJ;CTBa TaKMe cJIY'ia",
CTaHOBiITCH IIpe.l\MeTOM CY.l\e6HOrO pB36aTeJIbCTBa '. MHorM nOBe-
,QeHHe coco6cTBelIHJfKa craHOBJ1'I"CH yrpomaroll\e Henpe,lJ;CKa3)'eMbiM
J1 roneTCHyrp03aMMnpl'1M8Hemmcl»f3WlE'CKOI'OHaCI1JII1.fI "'JII1
nC=QeCIUrMHaCWH1eM. TaK, HanpJ1Mep, C.M, ,lJ;ei1CTByK>l1\aHB CBOMX
J1HTepecax J1 B J1HTepecax H8CoBepui8I1HOJIeTIDIX ,lIETefi. 06paTJ'IJIaCb
B CY.l\ C J1CKQM K 0TI3eT'II1KaM, npoCJ1JIa BCeJU1Tb ee '" HecoBeprneHHo-
JleTIDIX .l\eTeH B TpeXKOMHBTHyIO KBapTMpy, oIIp€.AeJiKlb nopH,IJ;OK
IIOJIb3OBBIIH.H ,IJ;aHHbIM >KI1J1b1M nOMerrtem18M, nepe,r(aB eit J'! ee Heco-
BeprnemnJJ€THI1M ,lJ;8THM B IJOJIb:3OBaIDle ,lJ,Be KOMHaTbl, a B nOJIb30-
BaHMe OTBeT'U'lKOB 0t\HY KOMHBTY, a TaKme 06R3aTb OTBeT'-IMKOB He
'iilllMTb np€l1mCTBMR B nOJIb30BaHMI1 KBapni B o6oCHOBaHl1e 3a-
HBJIeHMR yKB3aJIB, 'ITO OHa J1 HeCOBeprnEHHCl.:Ji8Tffi1E' ,lJ;8T11 HBJlHlOTCH
c05CTBeHHI1KaMM 3/5,1J;OJlI1 cnopHOii KBapTl1pbl Ha OCHOBaHI1M )lOroBO-
pa nepeM'il1 KBapTl1pbl B co6c-rnemIOC'I'b rpaiK,ll;aH.
'C..,:OnpeneJoe."",CaHKTr<JpO.[lCK<JIl)CYA'lOT21.06.2011N1'9299I1URL:htlp:11
VMIW.coosullant.ruJsearch,Onpe,(\eJle...eCaHKTneTeJ>6l'prCl<oroCY;JiJ0T(J7(J72011
N!1003BIIURLhttp_/,............cora..IUrCru,/Se3I:d\Onj)e,<leJlSH..aMoci<OwcororOjX>ACKOCOCy;JiJCT
221L2011JnO.l1eJlyN"33-36167I1URLhttp:/,............rl\fsear<;h
103

OrB€T'll1RaM npMHa,lJ,JIe)KJfI' Ha npaBe COOCTBeHHOCrn 2/5 ;n0Jll1
KBapmpbJ. PaHee OHa COCTOHna B 3apen1CTpnpOBCIHHOM 6paRe c OT-
BeT'U1KOM C.K., KOTOpblli 6blJ1 pacTOprH)"1' IX'IlleHUeM I\annHJ.nICKOI'O
paiiOHHOro cy;na. B nepuo,!\ opaRa 11 nocne ero pacTOpmeHl1R OHa BMe-
ere c ;neTbMu npomJ1BaJ1B B CII:pH(it: KBaprnpe. Bo BpeMH npoarn-
BaHI1JI MeiK,Jfj' HeM 11 arBe"I"ll1KaMJ1 $a,KTI1'-ieCKJI! CJ10arnnCR nopH,!\oR
n0Jlb30Bamrn KBapT>1pOM, COrJlaCHO KOTOpOM)' OlJa C ;neTbM>1 3aID1Ma-
JIa ;nBe KQMHaTbJ, a OTBeTtIJ.1K11 O):\H)', 'iTO COOTBeTCTB}'eT pB3MepaM I1X
;nOJleJL IIpK'-iHHl:llf ee Bble3,Qa 113 ClJopHOIl KBaprnpbl BMecre C ;neTbMI1
noc.ny»aool IIpOTHIKIIpBBHbIe ;neMCTBUH C.K, KOTOpuR, IJaXO;:vICb B
COCTOJlHI1M aJIKOl'O.:JIbIn'O onbHHemm, yrpOiK£WI ei1 ylSIDi:Ci'BCM, B CBH-
311 C 'IeM 0blJ10 B03Oym,!\eHO yrc>JIOBHoe ;neno. B HaCTORIl.\8e BpeMH aHa
"ee ;n8TI1J1J111IeHbIl!03MCOKHOCTIl nOJlb30BaTbCR IIpJIlI3AJ1 J1M
UM'yllM, npo)KJ1BaTb B KBaprnpe,11!.JCKO.nbKy 11M co CTOpOHbl OT-
BeT'U1KOB 'lI1HJITCH IIp€IIflTC'IBIU RJIIOQei1 aT BTopOi1 BXO,IJ;HOA ;nseP" Y
Hee HeT 11 OB" cYrKa3blBalOTC/I ei1: I1X np8,l\OCTaBJI,HTb.
Cy,!\y;noBneTBopI1Jl 3aRBJleHHb!e Tpe60Bamm, cy;nb!
OCTaBI1JII1 pellIeHl1e oe3 113MeH€lmii'.
Pa3perneHa JIJ1 npooneMa? Tenepb I1CTI1:L\a BMeCTe C ;neTbMJ16y,neT
npo)KJ1Ba7b B KBapmpe 11 Ka>K.nblJI pa3 onaca7bCfl 3a CBOID:Ha13Hb 11
>KI13Hb CBO"X;neTei1:. OrBeT'll1K, HeCM01}lH IJa II03.II(I)HeHHe IJa Hero cy-
;nOM 06R3aHHOCTJI He 'lI1H11Tb nperurrcTBl1fI B nonb30BaHUI1 BeIltbID, no-
HUMaeT, 'ITOHapynIeID1e pernemm c)'1I:a He nOBJIeQeTHI1RaKI1XnOCJIe)J;-
CTBID1. BMecTe C TeM, coco6crBeHHinal .nOJDKHbl ocyr.u;eCTBJIJITb CBOI1
npaBa, He HapynIaR npaB JJ,pyrI1X COCo6cTBeHHlmoB. B
.naHHoM cnyqae Mb! J.1MeeM .neJlo c npaBOHapynIeHueM. «IIpaBOHaPy-
llIeHMe - aTO .llf;t1C7BJ1e, cOBeprneHl1eM KOTOporo JlI.fi.IO .neMoHCTp"PYeT,
ecnu 11 He IIp€HeOpeml1TeJlbHOe, '1'0, EO BCHROM cnyqae, 6e3pB3JIJ1tIHOe
UIlJOllI8HHe K 3Jl8MeH'ffiM HOpMaJIbHOCO ro npaBonOpJI,QKa
(rpam,!\aHcKoro Mt1pa), ycraHaBmreaeMoro, nO.IJ.,lJ;epm,JIBB8M01'O, oxpa-
HHeMoro 11 3aliU'lll.\BeMoro rocy.napCTBOM. TaKoe arHOIllI2Ime He )J;OJDK-
HO IIpHBOJII'ITb K ocnao.rremflO rpam,n;aHcKOro npaBOnopH)J;Ka.!(;m 'iero
11 C03.naHO nyfurwlHoe npUHYm,!\eID1e K npeI<p3ll{8mno .n6fC'IBJ1iii no-
cmaIDJW1X HB rpam.u.aHCKI'li npaBOIIopH.!PK. COBeplll8HmO ;nei1:CTBIDr,
H3IIpBBJJeHlllilX Ha BOCCTaHOBneID1e paHee cYll\eCTBOBaBlll8J'O n0J10-
:meID1H Bell.\eiirl1Jll1, HaROHeLl, K np8T8pI1eBaHJ1lO HeBbll'O,ZI;HblX nOCJIe)J;-
CTBIDf, HanpaBJIeHHbIX HB JIJ1'3ROCTb HJlI1I1M)Tll\eCTBO HBpynIl1TeJUl',2.
'o.._One""eQM<rI<OI"OCyMOT26_05_2011N!33.7833J20111IURL
http:!rujsea"'h
2rpa>l(,<lilIlCKOenpaoo,aICT)l311DHbI9np06"eMblTeop"""."/IlQ.O.06L11.pe,Ij,BA5eJlOoa,M.
l.1M-eo-1Q:laJ<r'.2009_c_671--.f172
104

Pelll€fnf8 cY,[Ia 06 OOR3aHI1JiI He 'lliHI1Tb nperuITCTBJrJi!: n0JTh30BaHm0
oow;eH BeIqbKJ - Mepa ny5.rrwIHOro nPJUlY'K,1l:8Inm, HanpaBJIeHHaJI Ha
np8Kpaw;eHl1e,neii:C'I'BId!: U BOCCTaHOEIJIeHUe paHee Cytl\ecTBOBaBlllero
I1O.1X»KeIUUI e:ii. B CJIyqae pewwma TaIrnX ,neiicTBJfii: Mepbl B03-
,neiiC'lE1R Ha npaBoHapyrnl1TeJUI OCTaKJrCR TeMJ.1.me, nOCKOJIbKY 3BKO-
Ho,naTeJIb Im'lero J1Horo He npe)J.yCMaTpUBaeT  BblXO-
,nOM;nJIR COCOOcTBeHlU1Ka B ,llaHHOM cJIY"lae HBJ1ReTCR npo,nama ,nOJll1,
'!W TOJIbKO Ha PYKY npaBOHapYllIU'reJIKJ, yql1TbIBaR .nei1c'rmre npaBa
np8JtMYl1leGTB8HHOH nOKyrnrn. )J;OJDKHa IDI OblTb npe.lIyCM)'J'pe Ka-
KaR-JIJ1Oo ew;e Mepa OTBeTC'l'BeHHOCf? )J;yMaeTCR, mBeT Ha STaT BO-
npoc,nOJDKeHOblTb
IIpI1Mep HOpMbl, npe)J.ycMa'IpJlBalOllt8fI GI'B8TCTB8HHOCT 3B «aco-
QuaJIbHoe» IIOBe,l\8ml8 coco6cTBeHHJ.iKa, npe)J.yCMaTpUBaeT l1IBep-
Cl{oe 3aKOHo.n;aTeJIbC1'BO, B KaTOpoM cyr.u;eCTBYeTnpllHl.\lffiBHUMaTeJIb-
HOro JIICJ10JIb30BaHl1R npaBa. HapyrneHl1e O)Ull1M 113 COCOOcTBeHHI1IWB
OO.ll3aHHOCTI1 BHI1MaTeJlbHOro OTHOWeID'J.II.npyr K.npyry JllJIJII K CJIOBaM
,npyroro MO:IKeT npoHBJ1RTbCfI B TOM, 'lT0 OH «BblCryna8T npcrruB Bbl-
nOJllieHI1.II Kam,lJ;oro Meponpml'l'JUI JllJIJII npOB(JlpyeT cnopbl, CKOH-
Q8H'TpHpOBBH TOJIbKO Ha CBOUX 3I'OMCl'J1'i8CKKX JllJITepecax, STI1MJ1
,neiiC'J'BI,ffiMJ,f OH ,nenaeT OTHOllleHUR dUneJl co6cTBeJrnocorn HeBUHOClf-
MbIMU. OrnoweHl1.11 06I.1U'10CTU Bcer,na COIIpOBruK,!\aIOTCR pJ'JCKOM noJIY-
'!lITb aCOl.\ltaJIbHOl'O napTIlepa. B CBR3If C '!eM nonyn.llpHOCTb oow;ei1
co6cTBeHHocnf C'IJXi,[lBeT»'. B ,llaHHOM CJIY'lae ewrnc-rneHHfJ1: B03MO:IK-
HOCTbKJ paCCTaTbCR C aCOl.\l1aJIbHblM COOCTBeHHUKOM HBJIReTCR npo-
,Qama,nOJll1 U npeKparu;eHUe OTHanemm: coficTB8HHJC'I'I1. TIpaso npe-
HHOj.i: I1OKJIOO:! C03.n;aJIO 6JIaronpI1.llTHYKJ no'ffiY ,lIJIR TOro,
'!WOb! a co6cmeHHlIK CTaJI 8,1J;1fHCTBeHHbIM Co6c1'BeH-
ImKOM. «113M)"1eHHbIi1 IDfK, ,lIJIR KOTOpOro 6bIJIB 3ailllTe-
peCOBaHHQCTh B JIICrI0JIb30BaHIDI seUI;J1, BbIH)')K.!I8Ii OTCTpaHl1TbCR OT
cOOcreeHHOC'l'J1.. 3T0 npe HecnpaBe)J;J!IfBHIV!, 6oJ!ee p83-
YMHbIM BI>1,ZJ;I1TCR Y.lJPJ!eHue aCOl.\l1aJIbHoro COOCTBeHH1ma. B nponm-
HOM cJIY"lae, sapyrnaeTCR npUHQilll CJI8):\OBaHI1.II ca TOJIbKO 3a
BmIOBHbIMU .n;eiicTm1HMJf»2.
!(;m CnpaBe,llJlMBoro peryJIJ1poBaHl1R 3Wi1 CH'T}'aI-{Ifi1 B nepI10,n pe-
BI13ID'lIIIBei1qapcKOro 33I«JtfO.A3.TeJIbCTBa 50-60 IT. XX B. OblJ1a BBe,ne-
HB HopMa  649B IIIBeiiqapCKOrO IpBJK,/WIICKOro yJICOK8HIf.H, n03BOJIR-
IOLQBR J'JCK.JIIQ'laTb 8COQJmJIbHOro napTHepa JII3 OOI.1U'lOCTIf.
, SchneiderS.S.I04
. SchnetderB.S_105
105

)J;JIJ'I OCYl1\eCTBJIeIDIR nCKJIlOll8HJUI He06xo,lJ)lMO co6.moc'ru cne)1y1O-
l1\I1e yc.ITOIYUl. «Bo-nepBbIX, 1lp11'D1HblllCK.JliO'ieIDIR JJ;OJDKHbI JIe:HmTb
B o6JIacTI1 OTHOlII€Hm1 COCo6cTBeHHJIIKOB I1JI11 B o6JIacTI1 oTHolIIeHJ.1fi
Mem.rur cy6DeKTaMl1, KOTOpblM 06H BelltbnpeJJPC'IaBJIHeTCH B nOJIb-
30BaHJlle. 3TO JJ;OJDKHbl 6bITb BeCKJlle I1pWiIfHbI, KOTOpble JJ;eJIaKJT npo-
JJ;OIDKeHIfe 06llUiOCTI1 H 11 OnepJllpYfI KOTOpblMl1 CY.Jn>H
MO:lKeT JIICKJilO'II1Tb 113 06llUiOCTJII. Bo-BTOpbIX, JfCKJIlO'18H1f8 B03MOm-
HO TOJIbKO IIpJII HaJIl1'111J11 BeCKMX OCHOBaHIDf KaK nOCJIe,IJ.Hee cpe.I\CTBO,
eCJIJII BCe npe,uynpem.n;eHI1H, Tpe600amUl 11 J1Hble I1pBBOBI>E cnoco-
6b! He npmiec.ml pe3}'JIbTaTa. B--rpeTbI1X, HaJ:\ JfCTeQ - :;ITO
cyO"beKT, KOTopoMYHaHOCI1TCHBpe,!J;Hao5l1..\YKJBelltb.
PellleHJlle 0 nO,!!,B':Ie J.1C1\a ,[(OJImHO 6b!Tb npJIIHJlTO 6oJIblIDlHcrnoM rOJlo-
COB cOC05CTBeHH\1KOB. HaJl.Jlemall\MM O'IBeT'lIfROM MomeT 6b!Tb coc06-
CTBeHHl1K, a TalOKe n0JIb30BaT8JIb BelL\M .111160 BJIa.n;eJIeQ orpaIDI'IeH-
HbIX BeLqIlbIX npaB J.1Jll.{ npe,D;BapHTeJllEblX JlM'ffibIX npaB (WlIIpl1Mep,
npaBa npei1MYl1\ecrneHHoi1 nOKynKI1). TaKMM otpB30M, B03H11KB.eT
I1MJI.W2CI'B8HHo-npanooml rpam,!\BHCKI1i1 cnop. ECJII1 OTBeT'rnKOM Bbl-
C-rynaeT C06CTB8HHI1K, TO BbIHOCIITCR cy,[(e5Hoe pew8Ime a COBepwe-
Hlli1 ,l\8IiCTBmI BO I1CTI0JlH8HI1e 06J'J3aTeJIbCTBa TIO OTqy}KJ:\8H111O em
,[(0.1111; eCJUI UTB8T'iJ.IK(IM BblCTynaeT BJlB)\eJleQ orpalJW{eHHoro Bt'll\HO-
TO I1Jill npeABapiITeJibHOI'O JlI1'IHOTO npaBa, BbIHClCJ1TCJi KOHCTJ1TYTIflI-
Hoe perneID1e 06 OTMeHe npaBa nOJIb30BaID1Ji, TaK KaK orpaHJ1'jeHHOe
Bt'll\HoenpaBO I1J111'iHoe IIpeJJ;BaplITeJIbHoenpaBo He OTeMO 11 He
nepeMBaeMO»'.
)J;aHHaJi HOpMa 6bIJIa 6bl nOJle3Ha 11 B HalIIeM 3aI<OHOMTeJlbCTBe.
Hr06.'ID,D;I'JMO 3BKpeID1Tb B03MJ)KHQCTb npeKpal1\eHI1J1 npaBa c05-
CrneHHOCTI1 co6cTBeHHJma, C03,!!,BlOl1\ero HeBHHOCJlMble ycJIOBMfI ,[(JIH
o6l1\ero IIOJIb3OO3HItH Jf BJlB)\eHI1fI o6l1\ei1 Bel1\blO, ymro
I1J111 noprHll.\ero 06l1\ee 11M)'I1I8CTOO. }'K.IiJIDIIOILI OT HeceIDUI 6pe-
MeHJII co.n;epmaHJllJI 06l1\ero JIM)'I*'CTBB, 'ITO IIpJlB()Jl;lIT K CJll'2CTB8H-
HOMY HapyrneID1KJ npaB I1HbIX CoC06cTBeHIIJIROR Hawlw.n;eKC I1MeeT
HopM)', npeJIYcMa"IpI1BalOlI..\YlO npeKpaIQeHl1e npaBa afJcTB8lIHOCTl1
Ha 6ec'ID3JIi.iHo co,[(epmJIIMoeml1JlOe 1IOMe1l.\8Hl1€, - 3TOCT. 293 fK PcI:>,
O)J;llaKO npaKTI1Ka ee npJIIMeHelUUI HeMHOrQ'<{J1CJ1eHHa. ITpe,QJIaraeMBfl
HaMI1 HOpM8. 6bIJIa 6bl 60nee BOC1p8I5oBBHa, TaK :KaK pearnpoBaTh Ha
Hapyrnemle CBOJ.fX npaB 6yAYT caMY!  31'a Mepa OT-
BeTcrneHHOCTI1 O'IeHb Cepb€3HBfl, nO:)TOMY OHa ,[(OJDKHa npe,!\IIOJIB-
raThCR KaK IIUCJI€,[(HHH npl1HJITBH Mepa nocJle pJi..QB npe.I\YTIP8,!\I1-
TeJIbHbIX n;ei1crnIDl B TOM <mcJle IIOCJIe npl1lU1TI1a cY,[(OM peweID1fl 06
'ReyH_Sachenrechlund6gentum6AunBern_Stamplll2006.S-2W
106

OM3aHMJ.1 He npenHTCTBOBBTh ocyIl\€'CTBJI8HUO IIO.1lb3OBaHMH. Perne-
HMe 0 IIplfMeHeHJDI TaKoi1 Mepbl OTBe'I'CTEI8HHOCTII,l\OJDKeH I1pJ.1HJ.1MaTb
CY,l\ Ha 0CH0BaHJ.1>1 perneHJ1R coco6cTBeHHJ.1KOB, npJ.1HJITOra 60JIbllThlH-
CTBOM. Ec.nJ.1 coco6cTBeHHJ.1KOB BCera ;nBoe, TO 06paTl1TbCH B cY,l\ MomeT
nI060i1 J.13 HJ.1X. .n.aHHaH HopMa n03BOIDrr peampooBTh Ha a
IIOBe.l18H118 COCo6cTBeHHl1Ka 11 3BCTaBI1T nl1lllHJ.1ft pa3 3a)JyMaThCH CO-
co6cTBeHHllKa 0 npaBl1JIbHOCTJ.1 CBOJ.1X .netic'rBw1.
J1HC'I'WTyr OOll.\e:i1: cc:6cmemJocTH BBJ.1..IIY HeO.lUl03Ha'iHOCTI1 cBOei1
npHpO)J;hI,l\OJDKeH 6bITb yperyJIl1pOBaHnOCllC"l'fME' 'c.JI8P)Kffi I1npoTI1BO-
BeCOB». 3T0 SHa'lliT, 'iTO J.1 coco6cTBeJrnrrKM BMeCTe, Jj coco6cTBeHHIm:
Kam,u;blii: no OT,l\eJlbHOCTI1 He ,IJ;O.IDKHbI THrOTl1TbCH 3Tmrn: umorneHl1-
HMJ1. Heo6xQlI,JfMO 60.nbJlI.YlO poJ1b OTBeCTI1 ,l\OI'OBOpHOM)' pery.ID1po-
BaIDIlO OTHOrneHJllii:, ,IJ;eTaJIbHO yperynl1pOBaB CO,l:(epmaHl1e ,l\OroBOpa.
KpoMe TOro, TJ)eoyeTCHI1CKJIIOGI1Tb npl1HLJ;J.m e,l:(I1HOrnaCI1H 11 saKpe-
nl1Tb I1pJ.1HHTl1e pemerom.  roJIOCOB, a TaIOKe B03Mom-
HOCTb PH.A ,l\eiicTBJ.n1:  coco6cmemDm:y caMOCTOHfE'Jlb-
HO. erore OTHCUIE'OO oOll.\e:i1: co6cTBeHHOC'r1l sac.nyml1BaeT
oco60ro BIIPMBHI1R, IIpl1'leM ,IJ;O.IDKHbI }"Il1TbmaTbCH I1HTepeCbl Bcex
COCOOCTBeHHl1KOB,aHeTOJIbKo.
AHaJ1J.13 IDJI())!{8HJti.1 IIpoeKTa fK PcI:> He nOOBOJJHeT C,I:(eJlaTb Bbl-
BO,D; a ero saKOWleHHOM xapaKTepe. :MHome era 1IOJIOm8IDIH, nporpec-
CI1BHble J.1 HeOOxo,JI,HMbI8.D:J1H perynI1pOBaHJ.1H QTHOwel!Jri;i OOll.\eiii coo-
CTBeHHOCTJI, Tpe6}'1OT llepeocMblCJI8H1IH.

3AKJlIO'iEHI1E
ITpoBe,!J;eHHbIi1 aHaJll13 CTaHOBJI8Iill1IJ1 pB3BJilTJ.1.fIHHC'I1nyra OOllleH
COOCTBeHHOCTJiI B POCCID1, repMaHJ.1l1, ABcq::m111 III:se£i:Q3.pID1 n03BO-
JUleT C,1J;eJIaTh C.1J8}JylOrwre BbIBO.n;b!:
1. OcHoBoii: cfIoPMMPOBaHlliI peryJlJ1poBaHJ1H OTHOIlI8Hm1 OOll.\ei1
coOCTBeHHOCTI1 JY)CJlf'Kl'1OO pl1MCKOe npaBo, Karopoe 6blJ1o B3JITO 3a
OCHOBY 3aKOHO.L\aTeJIHMI1 Bcex JICCJI8.lI.Y8Ml; B HaCTOJULjei1 pOOOTe
npasoIIopHp;KOB. PoccmiCK£.le npaBO BOCnpUHJIJIO pl1McKyKJ 11HJJ;I1BI'J,lIy-
a.JII.IC'I'Wi8CK}'IO KOHQeIIQmD WHOll1eHm1: 06ll.\ei1: co6cTBeHHocTi1 nO'lTI1
6e3 113MeHeIDIH. B fepMaHIDI, ABCTIUfH l111lBeiiu,apl1l1 OTOWIDI OT JilH-
JJ)1BI1JIYi KOHQeIIQID1 ,l\OJleBoi1 CCJ6cTBeHHOCTH B nOJ1bay
YCt1.J1eHHR If,l\eA 06IW10CTI1, B CBH311 C "eM B3HTI>Irt 3B OCHOBY 
npaBoIIOpH,!J;DK6bIn nO,lJ;Beprnyr C8pb83HOJl KOppe
2. PerYmIpOBBHIfe OTHOllHUrn 06ll.\ei1: ccf:IC'meHHOCTIl B aHaJU13J.1-
pyeMbIX HaW1 JrnocTpaHHblX rocY.J1apCTBaX MOiKHO C'll1TaTb CJIOiKMB-
lill1I'IICfI 11 yC1OffiIIID1MCR, TaK KaK OC.YJ--Il;€CTBJI.ReTCR f,
IMHOIffiE'J«JBYIOoo.noHOpMb!
06ooll.\e:i.J:.r:tOJleBOi1 Co6crBeHHOCTI1 ID,l1;EIepI<I.1U1Cb B 50-60-e IT. XX R, '1TO
6blJlO CBfl3aHO C DO,lJ;!'O'IOBl':Ui K perym1poBaHmO arHOIll8Hm1: ,l\0JI8B0i1
cooCTBeHHOCTI1 B MHOroKBapTHpHblX ,nOMax.
CoBpeMeHHOe peryJIl1pOBaHl1e OTHowemU1 OOll.\eH Co6c-mffrnOCTIl
B PoccJUf UMff'T JlMlllb ,l1.BB,!R\aTI1JIeTHIOIO I1cTOpmo 11 Ha cero,ll,HHlIIHRft
,neHb CHOBa n8p8)KJ1BBeT aTan pecpopMHJ>CEaHJut
3. ,llJm 3aKOHO,l:(aTeJIbCTBa fepMamrn, ABcTpl1J.f J.f III:se£i:Q3.pl1l1
xapaKTepHo BOCIIpJ1HTIfE:' «oollleH KOHL\eI1L\ID1" perYJ1l1pOBaHJ.1.FI OT-
HOlllemm AOJI8BOii oo6cTBeIrnoCTI1, Iwmpa..<! IlBnpaBJ1€Ha Ha JDoICIaf
KOMTIpoMJIICCa Mem.I\Y 06lltJ1MH J1lITepecaMI1 J.f JlIIT8pecaMH OT,IJ;eJlbHO-
ro COCo6CTBeHIDfKa. 3T0 npoRBJL<IeTCH B nepBYKJ O'lepe):\h B HCnOJIh-
aooamm: I1pl1HlUfila 6o.nwumcTBa B 11p00.\e,Dype npl1H.lITlliI peuI8Hlrli,
YCl1JIeHHoi1 pOJIH wrooopHOl'O peryJIlI]XE<lllID! OTHOWeHJlli1 Mem.I\Y
coco6cmeJnnfK8.MJII,,nocKOHBJlhHOI' perymtpOBBHHH omcrneIDlii npe-
Kpal..l.\eHI1H 06IW10CTH, B03MO.?KIIOCTJf lfCKJIIO'leHJ1H H3 06OCTI1 aco-
LlI1BJlbHh!Xca:.o6C'rneHllHKOB.
PocClriicKoe 3BKOIIO,':\aTeJlbCTBO 06 06ll-\e:i1 co6cTBeJrnocTu Bcex ne-
pHO,!\OB (,!\qJelOHIVro, COBeTCKOI'O, COBpeMellllOro) OCHOBaHO Ha
HH,QJ1BI1JI,Y<lJllfCTIf<!€CKOM pHMC1\fJ1 KfJHl.\81ll-\ID1 06ll-\ei1 c06cTBellHocTI1,
'1m BbIpamaeTCH, B nepB}'lO OGepe,!\h, B I1pl1MeHeHI1Y! I1pJlIll-\Ima €,!\11-
109

HOrnaCI1R. J13 3TOro BbITeKaeT cJIa60e 1\OI'OBOpHOE:' pery.mtpOB3HJf€ OT-
HOWeHJIif Mem.I\Y coco6cTBelJHJ'IKaMJoJ. Hea4JIj:!eRTI1BHOe yrIpBBJIeHUe
05lltJ1M nM)'l1I€CTBOM. !(;m poccIfiicKcro npaBOnOpRJn{a 06mei1: c05-
C'I138IlliOCTII TaIDKe xapaKTepHO I1J10XOe peryJBlpOBBHJle lIp8Rpawe-
HI1JI UIl!OIll8IDDI 05mei1: ,[(OJIeBoi1: co5cTBellHOC'IIL
4. AHaJII13 J1O.1D)K8}OOI IIpoeKTa J13MeHeHJlli1 fK PcI:> nOKa3b!BaeT,
'ITO B l.\eJIOM OH He pewwr npo5JIeM peryJDqXJBBHJIH 05mej;j: cOOCTBeH-
HOCTI1, nClCKOJlbK}' coxpaHReT CTapble He.I\OCTaTRI1 peryJIl1pOBaHI1R
11 nopom,n;aeT HOBbie. J1HCTl1'I'yr 05ll-\ej;j: ro6cmeJrnocTJf BBI1,!J;y HeO;:J;HO-
3Ha'lHOC"TIf CBoej;j: 1IpJ\P0.I\bl ,IJ;OJImeH 6b1Tb yperyJIl1]XlBaH no CI1CTE'-
Me «C.I\epmeK 11 npcm1BOE8COB». 3T0 3Ha'il1T, 'ITO 11 COC05cTBeIlliI1K11
BM8CTE', 11 coco6cTBemurn: Kaj;j: no OT,l\8JIbHOCTJ1 He .I\OJImHbl T.H-
rOTJITbCH 3TI1M11 OTIIOIIIeHI1.HMH. 1Ieo15xow1MO 60JlbrnyIQ pOJIb OTBeC"TIf
.I\OroBopHOMY perYJlupoB8.HIDO OTHOIll8lIm1, ,[(eTBJIbHO ypery.IDlpOBaB
CQJJ;eJDKaffi18 .I\OroBOpa. KpOMe TOro, Tpe5yeTCH I1CKJ1l()qJ1Tb 1Ip
e,IJ;l1HOrnaCI1JII1 3aKp8IIl1Th 1Ip11H.llTl18 pellleHm160JlbllIIDfCTBOM r0J10-
COB, a TBlOKe B03MOmHOCTb pH,!!; ,IJ;eiiermul ocyr.u;eCTBJUlTb coc06cTBeH-
HJ1KY CBMOC'IOm"eJJbHO. IIpeKpall-\eHl1e OTHOIll8lIm1 05ll-\ei1:co5CTBeIlli0-
C"TIf 3acJJY'KI1Bae-r oco50ro BHl1MaHl1J'J, IIpWleM .I\OJDKHbI YU1TbIBaTbCJ'J
I1HTepeCbI Bcexcoa:fcrneH:Hmro, a He TOJlbKO BblJ\eJlmDll-\eroca.

Cnl1COK
I1CnOnb30BAHHO nl1TEPATYPbl
1. KoHcTIIT}'lJJ1H Poccpjicmiii 4>e..QepaQffi:! OT 12.12.1993 (c yqeToM
nonpaIICI\. BHeCeHHhIX 3aKoHaMI1 pcp a nonpaBKaX K KoHCTIrrytllfi1
PcI:> OT 30.122008 N9 6-<pK3. ar 30.12.2008 N9 74K3) / / C3 Pet>.
2009. N9 4. Cr. 445.
2. HCKJDI KOJ\eKC PocaU1cKo1 CP8Jl81: <PeJ\epaJThHbIM
3aKOH OT 30.11.1994 N 51-4>3 (pe,[l. OT 27.12.2009) II C3 PCP. 1994.
N9 32. CT. 3301.
3.CeMeiiHhlihwJ\eKcPOCCI1KCKoo:4>eJlepaQIDf: 4>3PcI:>OT29.l2.l995
NQ 223-!t>3, B peA OT 23.12.2010 / / C3 Pet>. 1996..NQ 1. CT. 16.
4.0<I'OpQIUUf'EClGIXI1.na'lliblX1X
OObe.wnteHJ.IRX. I'JWK,[\BH. 4>3 P<tJ OT 15.04.1998 N9 66-4>3 (pe.n. OT
01.07.2011)/ /C3PcI:> .1998. .NQI6. CT. 180l
5. OKpE.'('TlJlliCIM(pMepcI«JM) xoomfcTBe: 4>3 PcI:>OT Il.U6.2U03
N9 74-4>3 (pe)l OT 28.12.2010) 1/ C3 P<tJ. 2003..NQ 24. CT. 2249.
6.mi1JUfllUibIi1KoJ\eKc POCCl1iiiCKoi1:4>e.D:e: CP3 oT29.12.2004
N9 18843 (pe)l OT 18.07.2011) / / PoccmlcKaH 1<138'Ta. 2005. 12 HHB.
7. 0 BHeCeHID1 J13MeHemU1 B ..aCTI1 nepaylO, BTOP)'lO, TpeThlO 11 'leT-
Bep'I}'lO fpam,QaHCKoro KOJ\eKca PoccwlcKoM 4>e..QepaQffi:!, a TaKiKe
B OT,IJ;eJIbHbIe 3aKOHo,!\aTeJIbHble aKTb! PocaDicIWM CPeJ\epaL\J.rn: ITpo-
eKTeAepaJIhHoro3BKOHa.TanepBOi1i1BI:
07.02.20l2/IURL: http://wwwrg.ruj20l2j02j07{gk-site-dokhtml
8. &MMOB A. Cnopmul J\OJIH C05CTBeHHI1KB / / 3iK-IOpMCT. 2007.
NQl.
9. AneKceeB C.C .JlJ.oo.1HIIpaBa. M: CTaT)'T, 2006. 461 c.
10. AneKceeB C.C. 06e;nooBOJHDtH 11 oOIqHe 3anpeTbI B coaeT-
cKoMnpaBe / IOpUitJIJ1T., 19139.2813 c.
11. AHHeHKoa K CucTeMa PYCCKOro rpaaHcKoro npaaa: IIpaaa
Bel..Wlbre. T. 2. 2-e J113,I:(., nepecMoTp. JII ,lJ;on. CII6.: Thn. M.M. CraclOJIe-
BI1'18, 1900. 703 c.
12. Eap,!J;cKl1if A. Comacl1e COBJIa,[(e..J1bQ8B Ha npo,!J;amy ,lJ;onl1 B 05-
ll{eM JIIMeIDII1 / / Bec'l'Hl1K npaaa JII HOTapI1aTa. 1910. N9 5. C. 175-1 n
111

13. BaCbKOBCKJIft RB. Y..e5HI1K rpa>KJJ.aHCKOro npaBa: BeI1tHoe
npaBo. BbIn. 2 / CIl6.: 1013.1\. IOpM,It KH. MaI'a3HHa HK MapTb!HOBa,
1896. 190c.
14. Bep6111..tKaH ro.0. HrnoMMep<lecKl18 KOpnOpaTI1BHble H ymlTap-
Hble opra1U13aWlI1 B npoeKTe  KO.I\eKCa PcI:> / / I'pam-
.l\aHcKoe npaBo. 2011. N91. C. 23-28-
15. fapcl1B fappl1.I\o M. X. PI1MCKOe 'iaCTHOe npaBO: :Ka3yCbI, HCRY!,
I1HCTI1TJTbI / OTB. pe.n;. JI.JI. KocpaHoB. M.: CTaTyr, 2005. 467 c.
16. fpaaHcKI1i1 KO.1\eKC PC4JCP: yra. BC PCP 11.06.1964
(Y-rpaTl1JIcI1JIYc l.mrnapH200B ro.l\a BCBH3I1CIIpl1H.1ITI18M.I\epa.JIb-
HOro 3aKOHa OT 18.12.2006 .NQ 231-4>3) / /  BC PC4JCP.
1964 .NQ24 CT.407.
17. fpam,!lBHCKOe npaoo: aKT)'BJlbHbIe npo6.neMbI TeopIDI H npaKTI1-
101 / no.l\ 0511\- pe)l BA EenoBa. M.: I13.11-BO «lOpat1:T", 2009. 993 c.
18. fpl1WaeB en IIp06J1eMblocYI.J.J;ecTBJleID1H npaBa 06I.J.J;e:i1: ,[(OJ1e-
Boi1: co6cTBeHHocTY! Ha He,QBJ1./KJ'1MC€ HM)'IlreCTBO / / ITOlD'OTQBJleH lIJIH
CI1CTeMbI KOHcYJlbTaHTIlmoc, 2005.
19.1IaBI1.1\ P., .H\ocppe-CID1H0311 K OmOBHbI8 npaBOBbIe CJlCTeMbI
cOBpeMeHHOCTI1 / IIep. C CPPBHQ. M: M8Hl:.I\YHap. OTHOIII8mUI, 1996.
400c.
20.JtoroBopHOenpaao.1\.Irn:ra nepBBH: 05I.J.J;118n/ MJ1. Epa-
I11HCKJo1ii, BE. B1T1pHHCKIDL M.. CTaTyr, 2011. 847 c.
21.:EpomeHliO A.A. JIWlHaR co6cTBeHHocTb B CIiOM IIpaBe.
M.: IOpI1.I\. JD1T., 1973. 208 c.
22.JKa.1ll1HCKl1ftA.3., Pepl1XT A.A.BBe.1\eHl1eBHeMeoenpaBo. M.:
CnapK, 2001. 767 c.
23. 311MeneBa ME. 06lWlH cdX.-rBemIocTb C COO8TCKOM rpam,QaH-
cKoMnpaBe. qacTh nepBBH/ / BeCTHl1Krpa1K..QaHCKOronpaaa.M: 000
«J13.I\BT..I\OM B. EMS", 2009. T. 9. N9 4. e. 198-234.
24. 30M P.I1HC'I11'I)'WfI1: BhIIl 1: J1cropl1H pl1MCKOro npaBa / nep. c 12
HeM. .113.1\. fA EapKOBCKOro, 1908; BbIn 2. CI1CTeMS pl1MCKOro IIpaaa /
IIep. C 13 HeM..I13.1\. f. A. EapKOBCKOro, 1910. Y..e6H!1K I1CTOpIDII1 CI1CTeMh!
pI1MCKoromTOnpaaa. BbIn 1-2 / 3oMP.CII6.. HltMap1'bIHOB,
190B.659c.
25. J1CTOpl1H OTe'lecTBeHHOCO rocy,ltapCTBa H npaBa: }"Ie6HJ.oc q. 2 /
K:yrhl1Ha fA, MynyxaeB P.e., HOBmtKBR T.R, POro}fOO1H AM., H ,[(p.;
IIO.l\. pe,lt. cTHKoBa 0.11. 3-e .113.1\., nepepa6. H ,[(Oil. M' IOpI1CT. 2003.
544c.
112

26. KaJIMhIKOB lOX. MMYIl\eCTBeHHble npaBa COBeTCKl'IX rpa*.naH.
CapaToB' J13,!\-BO cry, 1979. 159 c.
27 JImnnIKOBa H IIpaBoHHofI nOKyrucl1 / / Co1tJ1a-
JD«:'IWI8CI\aH3aKOHHOCTb.19S1. N2 8. C. 29-30.
28. :M:apKOBa M r. IIoHHTl1e JIIco.n;epmaHl1enpaBa06l1.\ei1 c06cTBeH-
Hocm / / O-J.epKl1 no  npaBY. C6. CT. JI.: J13,!\-BO JIry,
1957. C. 79-92.
29. MaHamroBa P.II. IIpaBOOTHoweHl1e o611.\el1 .l\OJIeBOH c06cTBeH-
HOCTI1 rpam,zI.aH no COBeTCKOIIf)' rpam,naHCKOM)' 3aKOHO,lJ;aTeJIbCTBY.
TOMCK.: J13,!\-BO Try, 1977. 363 c.
30. MaCJlOB B.<P. BonpocbI 06l1.\eii c06cTBeHHoCTJII B CY.l\e6H0I1 npaK-
nme. M: rOClOpJl3,1¥lT, 1963. 148 c.
31. Meifep JJ;.J1. PycCKoe rpam,llBHCKOe npaBo: 'tlTeID:!H, 113JIBHHbIe
no 3alll1CKBM CJIYllIBTeJleif / no.n; peA AM. BMqblH8., AX rQJlbMCTeH.
8-el13):\., I1cnp.I111on CII6.: ThmJJ;.B. YlI, 1902. 730c.
32. MypoMu;eB C.  npaBO JJ:peBHero Pi1Ma: JIeKu;J1l1 /
M.. Thm AM. MaMOHTUBa 11 Ro, 1883. 733 c.
33. HeBOJIl1H K. ITOJIHOe c06paHl1e CO'lJIIHeHItH: J1CTOpl1R poccl1lii-
CKI1X rpa)K,11aHCKI1X 3aKOHOB. q. 2. KHI1ra BTopaH 06 JIIMYIl\eCTBax: PB3-
}J.eJI nepBblli 06 t1MYl1.\ecTBax Bo0611.\e 11 pa3}J.eJl BTOpOi1: 0 npaBax Ha
Bell\l1. T. 4. CII6.: TJrn. a IIpau,a, 1857.460 c.
34.HOBItu;Klrli:J1B.f'IDlcKOenpaBO / arB. pe,l\.CyxaHOBE.AM. TEJiIC,
r)'MaHl1TapHOe 3HaID1e, 1996.246 c.
35. 06 yrBep)K)leH(1H OCHOB rpIDK1I8HcmIU 3aKOHODaTellbC'TBa Cmma
CCP H COlO3HblX pecny6ffi1K (BMecTe c ClCHOBaMH 3aIlDIJOlIifi"eIlbCTBa): 3aKOH
CCCP OT 08.12.196111 Be,lJ;oMoCTI1 BC CCCP 1961. N2 50. CT. 525.
36. OcHOBbl I]JIDKilllHCKOro 3aKOHo.aaTellbITBa COlO3a ecp H pecny6mm
(yra. BC CCCP 31.05.1991 N22211-1) (YTpaTIfJI CWIYC 1 HllBapH 2008
rO,lJ;a Ha TeppJIITopl1l1 Poccm1cKa1: J\epa'-\illl1 B CBH3J11 C npJIIHHTJII8M
J\epaJlbHoro 3aKOHa OT 1812.2006 N223143) /1 Be.I\oMoc'rIICHlI 11
BC CCCP. 26.06.1991. N2 26. CT. 733
37 0 Co6cTBeHHOCTJII B PC<t>CP: 3aKOH PC<t>CP OT 2412.1990
N2 443-1 (pe.n;. OT 24.06.1992, C 113M. OT 01.07.1994) (YTpaTItJ1 cl1JIY B
CBH311 C npJIIHJITl1eM q,eAepBJIbHoro 3BKOHa OT 30.11.1994 N2 52-cfI3) / /
Be,llCMOC'n1 CHlI PC<t>CP 11 BC PC<t>CP. 1990. N2 30. CT. 416.
38.lIaxcMJBa H.H. IIpaBo 06l1.\el1 C06CTBeHHOCTU. ABTOPe<P. }J.I1C...
KaH.!\. lOpJII,Q. HayK EKaTepHH6ypr, 1995. 19 c.
113

39.lIOOeJ:\oHocLteB K Kypc npaBa: Bar'lHHHhlenpa-
Ba. q. 1. CII6.: CIlliO.I\- TIm, 1896. 767 c.
40. CaBeJiheB BA.  KO,!J;eKC fepMaHm1. Hcroplm. CYI-
CTeMa, HHCnfiYl'bl. M: IOpYlCTb, 1994.96 c.
41. CaMoi1J10Ba M.B. 0 nOHHTIHf .I\OJlYl B npaBe 06ll.\ei1.I\oJl€Boi1
co6cTBeHHOCTIf / / Bonpochl pa3BI1TI1H 11 3all.\I1ThI npaB rpa)f{,!\aH 11
C01.1;VJ8J1I1CTM'I€ClmX OpraHl13a1.1;I.1i1. MemBY30BcKMi1 TeMaTM'I€CKMi1
C60PHI1K. Kamnnrn: J13,!\-BO KaJlI1H. YH-Ta, 1978. C. 43-49-
42. C>f)J;opeHKoAJ(, qecppaHoBa E.A. Oc068HHOCTI1 npaBoBoro pe-
:mY/Me. o6n.Ieii,l\OJlE'BOii c06cTBeHHocTY/ Ha 06ll.\ee I1Myrn;eCTBO B MHoro-
KBapn1pHoM .I\OMe / / lKYJJIJ1J.IJ;HOe npaBO. M.: J1HT€JI-CI1HTea, 2004,
N2 4. C. 8-22.
43. CKJIOBCIOOt KJ1. IIpl1MeH8Hl1e rpaHcKoro 3BKOHo.n;aTeJIh-
CTBa 0 Co6cTBeHHOCTl111 BJIa,leHIIH.. IIpaETJI'lE'CRHe BonpochL M.: CTa-
'Iyr,2004.365c.
44. Tarai1B3apoB III 06ll.\aH .I\OJIeBaJi co6cTBeHHOCTh B COBE"I"CKOM
rp8)K,I:IBHCIroM npaBe. ;l{ywaH6e, 1966. 219 c.
45. TaHara A. H IIpllliwm cB06o.I\hl.I\oroBopa B rpam,n;aHcKoM npa-
Be POCCI1VJ: .I\I1C..n KaH,!J;. ropYI,Q. HayK M: prE, 2003. 229 c.
46. YPYKOB B.H. BoJUi 11 BOJI€113'bJlBJIeHI1e - CYll.\eCTBeHHhle yc-
JlOB>UI rpaHtJl8HCKo-npaBOBoro AorOBopa / / HaJlorl1. 2010. N2 27.
C.25-30.
47. cfIoKOB An. IIpo6JIeMhI npaBa o6lL\ei1 Co6cTBeHHOCTI1: Teope-
TWJeCKI1e YI npaK'lWH'CKI1e aCneKThl: ,lU1C. ... ,lI-pa ropI1,ll.. Ha:yK. PJl3BHh,
2003. 336c
48. Xanqnrna P.G. IIpaBo .IDl'lHoi1 roficTBeHHocTIr COBeTCroIX rpam-
.I\aH.M: rocropI13,!\BT, 1961.95 c.
49. XpeCTOMaTl1H no I1CTOpl111 OTe'leCTBeHHoro rOCYAapcTBa
YI npaBa. 1917-1991 IT. / nOA pe.n;. 0.11. CT.HKOBa M: 3epLlaJlo.
1997. 592 c.
50. Allgemeines btirgerliches G€setzbuch fUr die gesamten
deutschen Erbliinder der Osterreichischen Monarchie vom 1. Juni
IB11 JGS N2 946/1Blllnkrafttretcn am 1. Janner IB12
51. Biirgerliches G€setzbuch Bundesrepublik Deutschland vom
lB. August IB96 RGBI. S. 195 Inkrafttreten am I. Januar 1900.
52. ScIw.elzensches ZIVllgesetzbuch vom 10. Dezember 1901 SR 210
Inkrafttreten ami. Januar 1912.
114

53. Bundesgesetzvom 30. Marz 1911 betreffend dieErgiinzung des
Schweizenschen Zivilgesetzbuches (FiinfterTeu. Obligationenrecht)
SR 220 Inkraftretenam 1. Januar 1912.
54. Bundesrepublik Deutschland G€setz iiber das Wohnungsei-
gentum und das Dauerwohnrecht vom 15. Marz 1951 (BGBI. I S. 175,
209).
55. Bundesgesetz Republik 6sterreich iiber das Wohnungseigen-
turn 2002. StF. BGBL I Nr. 70/2002.
56. Baur F., Stiirner R Sachenrecht. 18., neu bearbeitete Auflage.
Verlag C.H Beck Miinchen, 2009. 1085 s
57. Binder M. Sachenrecht. Theorieundsystematischaufbereitete
OGE-Fiille. Wien: VerI. Ostereich, 2003. 552 s
58. Brauneder W. Osterreichs Aligemeines Biirgerliches G€setz-
buch (ABGB) 2. Auflage, Bd. 1, Berhn: Duncker & Eumblo, 2011.
302s.
59. Grziwotz H., Keukenschrijver A., Ring G. BGB Sachenrechtll
Kommentar. Band 3:  854-1296. Auflage 2. 2008. 2030 s.
60. Feil E. Miteigentum: Eine systematische Darstellung ffir die
Praxis. - Wien: Linde, 1997.112 s.
61. FloBmann U. OsterreichlSche Privatrechto;gesclnchte. Sechste,
aktualislerte Auflage. Springer Wien; New York, 2008. 384 s.
62. Jener K. Ausgewiihlte Probleme bei Entstehung, Ubertragtmg
und Belastung von Miteigentumsanteilen Wiirzburg, 2006. 196 s.
63. Klein-Bruckschwmger F.150 Jahre osterreichlsches ABGB II
Jrnistenzeitung. 1963. N21B. S. 739-742.
64. KreiUmayr R. Arunerkungen iiber den Codicem Maximil-
laneun bavaricwn civilem II. Teil. Miinchen, 1821.1080 s.
65. Musielak H.J. Grundkurs BGB: eine Darstellung zur Vennit-
tlung von Grundlagenwissen im biirgerhchen Recht rm Fiillen und
Fragen zur Lem- und Verstiindruskontrolle sowie mit Ubungsklau-
suren Grundkurs BGB 12. Auf!. Milncben: Beck, 2011. 613 s.
66. Onniker M pfandrecht und Zwangsvdl<medung bel Mlteigentum
und Stockwerlrelgentum Bern: Stampfli. 1972. S. 26.
67. Palandto. Burgerhches G€setzbuch. KorrunentarmitNebeng-
esetzen, 70. Auflage, Miinchen: BECK, 2011 3085 s.
68. PrUtting H., WegenG., Wemrelch G. BGB. Korrunentar. 6. Auf!.
Koln. Luchterhand, 2011.3611 s.

69. Priittmg H. Sachenrecht Junstlsche Kurz-Lehrbiicher. 34.
Auf!.7 Verlag en Beck Miinchen. 2010. 411 s.
70. Rebmann K., Sacker F., Rixecker R. Miinchener Korrunentar
zum Biirgerlichen Gesetzbuch. 5. Auf!. Miinchen: BECK, 2010. 1841 s.
71. Rey H. DieGrundlagen des Sachenrechts und Eigentum 3erg.
und iiberarbeit. Auf!. Bern: Stiimpfli. 2007. 630 s
72. Schlosser H. Grundziige der Neueren Privatrechtsgeschichte:
RechLsentwicklungenimeuropalSchenKontext.lO. Aufl. Heidelberg:
Miiller, 2005. 316s.
73. Schmoeckel M, Ri1ckert J., Zirrunermann R. Historisch-kri-
tischer Kommentar zwn BGH Band I. Allgemeiner Teil  1-240.
Tubingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2003. 589 s.
74. Schneider H Das schweizerische Mitelgentumsrecht Bern:
Stampfli. 1973. 282 s.
75. Schnorr R. Die Gemeinschaft oach Bruchtellen ( 741-758
BGB).Tiibingen: Mohr Slebeck, 2004. 450 s.
76. Tuor E, Schnyder H, Schmid J., Rumo-Jungo A. Das Sch-
weizerische Zivilgesetzbuch.13. Auf!.j auf Grund der 12. AufL (2002)
neu bearb. und erg. ZUrich: Schulthess, 2009. 1315 s.
77. Tschfitscher J. WEG 2002-Handbuch flirdie Praris. Wien: VerI.
Osten-ich, 2003. 203 s.
78. VOIzmann A. Das Miteigentum als wesensverwandtes zwn
Alleineigentum und dessen Erlangung vom Nichtberechtigten. RP-
fleger. H2. 2005. S. 64-70.
79. Wilhelm J. Sachenrecht. 4., v611lg, neu, bearbeltete Auflage.
Berlin: DeGruyter. 1064 s.
80. Wieacker F. Privatrechtsgeschichte der Neuzelt unter beson-
derer Beriicksichtigung der deutschen Entwicklung. 2. unverand.
Nachdr. der 2., neubearb. Auf!. von 1967,13. - 14. Tsd. GOttingen:
Vandenhoeck &Ruprecht. 1996.659 s.
81. Ziehensack H. Die Aufhebung der Eigentumsgemeinschaft
unter besonderer Beriicksichtigung des Liegenschaftsrechts und der
RealteilunginFormder Begriindungvon Wohnungseigentum Wien:
Manz, 1998. 373 s.
116

OrJlABnEHI1E
npCJ10BE .
.3
BBE.Q.EHIotE
.7
rnaBa 1. nOHTE lot COp,EP>KAHHE
06L11.EH C06CTBEHHOCT
B PMCKOM nPABE
.......9
rnaBa2. nPABoo6L11.EiilC06CTBEHHOCT
B POCCM
..14
2.1. rlpaBO 06w.eC1.1J,OneBot1 Co6cTBeHHOCTIII
B,lI,OI)eBOII(I.HHOi.1POCCIIIIII..
2.2. rlpaBO 061.l..1,ei.1.1J,OneBOi.1 Co6cTBeHHOCTI1
BCooe1a<oiiiPOCCIIIIII..
2.3. nOHIITIII811 CQlJ,ep)I(8HIII8 06w.ei.1 ooI5cmet--t-ioc
nOrpB)!qJ,8HCKOMY3aKCJ-lO,lJ,aJebCrey
d>eJJ.epal\llll'i.
........14
..18
..24
rnaBa3. nPABoo6L11.EiilC06CTBEHHOCrn
BEBPonEiilcKxCTPAHAX .
..31
3.1. B03HI1KH0B8HIII8 1.1 pa3Bl'iTIII8 npaaa
06w.ei.1co6CTB8HHocTIIIBrepMaHIllI'i. ..31
3.1.1 MO,Q8J1J.1posaHI.18 npaBa 06LJ..Le Co6cTBeHHOCTIII
B rpB)I(,QBHCKOM 3af((H)J],CITe1. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31
3.1.2. .Qei.1CTB\t101J..lee npaBo 06LJ..LeC1 C06CTB8HHOCTIII
I.1MD.D.enIllC06cTB8HHocrn ....................35
3.2. B03HI.1KH0B8HIII81.1 pa3BI1TIII8 I.1HCTl1ryra
061.l..1,eC1 C06CTB8HHOCTIII B WB8L.LBPIllIll. . . .44
3.2.1 el'ipa3m"Tllle
npaBa 06LJ..Le co6c:TB8HHOCTIII B WBei.1I..1ap.1I.1. .44
3.2.1 1. OCHOBHble nQJlmK8HIIISI npaBa
061.l..1,ei.1 C06CTB8HHOCTIII
jJ,0 peBIII31111111.1HGrnryrOB rpaJK.Qi3tICKIJ npasa ......46
3.2.12. P8BIII3111S13BKOHOJ¥IT8J1bCTBB
06 061.l..1,et1 jJ,on8BOt1 co6craeHHOCTI1 .... . .... .. 53

3.2.2. Co6cTBeHHOCTb J.1 npaBO 06LJ..Le C05CTB8HHOCTI.1
no J],eCTBJt1OI.l..I,eMY 3aKOHo.a,arenbCTBY . " .. .54
3.3 Bo3I-H<HooeHI18I'iPa3BIilT1'i8I1HCTIifTYTB
06w.ei.1cOOc1BtH-1ocTI1BABCTpl1l11.. ........60
3.3.1. CJ-a..o!Je.il'ie 11 pa3BlilT1II8 npaBa
06LJ..Le Co6cTBeHHOCTIII B ABCTpllllll. . . . 60
3.3.2. JJ.ei.1CTByJOLl\8e npaBo of.tu.ei.1 a:6::1Ba--tJocTlII . . . 63
rl1aBa 4. nO)J,XOAbl KnPABOBOMY
PErYI1HPOBAHIOOTHOWEHHH
06L11.EH AOI1EBOH C06CTBEHHOCT. .. ..... .. ...71
rl1aBa 5. KOHLlEm,, PA3BT
HHCTTYTA06L11.EH C06CTBEHHOCT
B I'PA)K,[J.AHCKOM 3AKOHOAATEI1bCTBE
POCCHcKoH CiE,l].EPALl,. ..80
3AKJ1IO'iEHHE 109
cnMCOKMCn0l1b30BAHHOHI1Io1TEPATYPbl. . . .....111

4>lfnaroaaY.li.
IlPABO 06LLlEVI COECTBEI-I-!OCT B POCCI-1I-1.
rEPMAHltU,1.ABCTPltU,11.1 WBEVlLlAPI.1I.1
"'CTCKoe
11A..
115419 MOCK03 y (]p,<u;OHMKI1,II36 11
WHWJflSIZdaI.ru,"'mail:ru
Ten. (495)979.702B 926.7525
nQllllMca"".""""",OQC12012
<I>ojJMaT60><90JI6.rapHI'IT)'pa.Journ81C
ne<'H"<$Ce-r",, 6YM!raC$CeT..a.
TH,Oa>K500S"3.ne. n.75