I


c-
I. KYC-
CTBA




BBK 87.3
A 50
YpaJl,bCKaR tjJUJl,OCOtjJCKaR UlKOJl,a
Cocma6UmeJlb. a6mop 6cmynumeJlbHblX cmameiJ.
HaY'lHbtU peiJaKmop aHmOJlOZUU - iJoKmop cpUJlOCOCPCKUX HaYK.
npocpeccop BoziJaH J{3eMuiJoK
(riJaHbcKuu YHu6epcumem. z. riJaHbCK. nOJlbwa)
HaY'lHbtU peiJaKmop PYCCKOZO nepe60iJa -
KaHiJuiJam fjJUJlOCOCPCKUX HaYK. iJoqeHm B. B. OpJl06
(YpaJlbCKUU rocyiJapCm6eHHblU YHu6epcumem.
z. EKamepuH6ypz. POCCWI)
A 50 AMepllKnHcKaJl 4JIIJlOC<><l>IIJ1 IICKYCCTB8: OCHOBHble KOHLlen-
LlIIII BTOPOH nOJlOBIIHbI XX BeKa - aHTII3CCeHLlII8JI1l3M, nepLlenTY8-
JlII3M, IIHCTIITYLlIIOH8J1113M. AHTOJlOrIlJl. lIep. C aHrJl.1 lIoJJ; peJJ;.
B. ,!J;3eMIIJJ;oK8 II B. OpJlOBa. lIpll Yll8CTIIII 113JJ;aTeJlbCTBa Yp8JIbCKOrO
rOCYJJ;8pcTBeHHQro YHIIBepcIITeT8 (r. EKaTepIIH6ypr). EKaTepllH6ypr:
.,!J;eJloBaJl KHllra., BIIlllKeK: .OJJ;lIcceH.. - 1997 r. - 320 c.
AHTonorHH 3H8KOMHT C H8H60nee H3BecTHblMH TeOpeTH'JeCKHMH CT8TbHMH
BHAHblX 8MepHK8HCKHX $HnocO<lx>B HCKYCCTB8 BTOpoH nonOBHHbI XX BeK8,
BnepBble nepeBeAeHHblMH H8 PYCCKHH H3b1K.
BASHHOM H3ASHHH npeACTSBJIeHbl8HTH3CCeHHBJIH3M H nepenTYBJIH3M -
KOHenHH. B03HHKllIHe B KOHTeKCTe 8HBJIHTH'JecKOH 3CTeTHKH. S TSK:lKe
HHCTHTYLlHOHBJIbHSJI TeOpHH MHpS HCKYCCTBS.
KHHrs 6YAeT none3Rs BceM. KTO HHTepecYeTCH np06neMsMH 3Spy6e:IKHOH
$Hnoco4>HH. 3CTeTHKH. KynbTyponorHH H COBpeMeHHblM HCKYCCTBOM.
ISBN 5-88687-029-6 ..n.enoBaH Kuura.
ISBN 5-86745-022-8 .OAHcceii.
@ B. ,!J;3eMII.noK. COCT8BJleHlle, BCTynll-
TeJlbHble CTaTbll, 1997.
@ ABTOpCKIIH KOJlJleKTIIB. lIepeBOA Ha
PYCCKIIH H3blK, 1997.
@ .O.nllcceih. 0pllrIlH8JI-MSKeT, o4JoPM-
JleHlle, 1997.
.. '--
I
t
I
I
1
,
AMepUKaHCKaB c}JUJIOCOc}JUB UCKYCCTBa:
OCHOBHLle Koenu;UH BTOPOH nOJlOBUHLI
XX BeKa - aHmU3cceHlfuaJl,U3M,
neplfenmyaJl,U3M, uHcmumYlfuOHaJl,U3M
I
I

I
I
i
t
1
i
I
1
AHTOJlOrUB

noctJSl.llfaemcSl.
ctJemnou naMJImu
HzopSl. 6moMa
COBPEMEHHA5I <DV1nOCO<DV151
V1CKYCCTBA CWA:
rnABHblE np06nEMbi
V1 HAnPABnEHV151
AMepHKnHCKns cl>HJIOCOcl>H.H HCKYCCTBa BTOpoH nOJIOBHHhI
XX BeKa 3aCJIYJKHB8eT BHHMaHH.H no HeCKOJIbKHM npH'IHH8M.
Bo-nepBbIX, nOTOMY, 'ITO, paCCM8TpHB8.H B8JKHeHWHe
npo6JIeMbI cl>HJIOCocJ>CKOH TeopHH HCKYCCTB8, OH8 OJJ;HOBpe-
MeHHO nHaJIH3HpYeT CYlL\ecTBeHHbIe npo6JIeMbI H JJ;pyrnx
06JInCTeH cl>HJIOCOcl>HH - MeTOJJ;OJIOrnH, anHCTeMOJIOrHH H
cl>HJIOCocJ>HH .H3bIKa, OHTOJIOrHH H aKCHOJIOrHH.
BO-BTOpbIX, nOTOMY, 'ITO, CTOJIKHyaWHCb C npo6JIeMftMH,
KOTopbIe npHHec B HCKYCCTBO xYJJ;OJKeCTBeHHhIH He08BaHr8pJJ;,
nMepHKaHCKHe TeopeTHKH npeJJ;npHHBJIH O'leHb CMeJIhIe, XOT.H
H He BcerJJ;8 YJJ;8'1HbIe nonhITKH paapeIIIeHH.H aTHX npo6JIeM. B
aTOM - HecoMHeHHoe JJ;OCTOHHCTBO HX HCCJleJJ;OB8HHH, nOCKOJIb-
KY eMH'leCKaB cl>HJIococJ>HB HCKYCCTB8 O'leHb OCTOpoJKHO H
HeoXOTHO 38TparliBaeT np06JIeMaTHKY HOBeHwero HCKYCCTBa.
06lL\eH3BeCTHO, 'lT0 HaH60JIee HeopHHapHhIe H cnopHhIe
XYJJ;OJKeCTBeHHbIe peweHH.H HaxOJJ;.HT CBoe OTproKeHHe B COBpe-
MenHOH MY3hIKe H H300pa3HTeJIbHOM HCKyrerBe, H nOToMY, C
onpeeJIeHHoro BpeMeHH, EBpona nepeCT8eT HIJ>aTb BeYIL\YIO
POJIb B aTOM OTHoweHHH. CTOJlIfieH XYJJ;OJKeCTBeHHOro H
MY3hIK8JlbHOro HeonBWIr8pa CTaHOBHTC.H HhIO-MopK. Bee OOJIee
3Hn'lHTeJIbHoe nOJIOJKeHHe H8'1HHaeT 3aHHM8Tb HbIO-MoPK
TflKJKe H B 06JInCTH TenTpaJIhHoro nBaHrnpa. arOT cl>aKT HameJI
CBoe BhIpaJKeHHe B aMepHKaHCKOH cl>HJIococJ>HH HCKYCCTB8 H
nOBJIHBJl Hn aKTYWIbHOCTb pa.3paOOTbIBaeMoH eIO np06JIeMaTHKH.
5
., '--

B-TpeThHX, B 70-x H 80-x roax ftMepHKftHCKftB 3CTeTHKft
H c1mJIocoqm.s npH06peJIH 3Hft'lHTeJIhHyJO nOnYJIBpHOCTh Hft
MeYHapoHOH ftpeHe. AMepHKaHCKnB cl>HJIOCOcl>HB HCKYCCT-
Ba Ha'laJIa OMHHHpoBaTh B aHrJIOB3hI'IHhIX CTpaHftX H B
nOCJIeHee BpeMB OKa3hIBaeT Bee 60JIhWee BJIHBHHe Hft
ftKlI,AeMH'IeCKyJO 3CTeTHKY H cl>HJIOCOcl>HIO HCKYCCTBa pyrHX
CTpaH EBponhI (OC06eHHO CKaHHHaBHH) H A3HH.
B-'IeTBepThIX, ftMepHKaHCKaB cl>HJIOCOcl>HB HCKYCCTB8 elL\e
MaJIO H3BeCTHa B POCCHH H yrHx cTpaHax CHr.
B-nBThIX, nOHCKH ftMepHKaHCKHX cl>HJIOCOcl>OB y6eHTeJIh-
HO eMOHCTpHpyIOT 6ecnJIOHOCTh MHHHMaJIHCTCKOH n03HnBa-
TeJIhHOH nporp8MMhI 8H8JIHTH'IeCKO-JIHHrBHCTH'IeCKOH cl>HJIO-
COcl>HH. qacTH'IHO aTO y:me HamJIO BhIpWKeHHe B pa60TaX
nOCJIeHerO BpeMeHH, HaDHCaHHhIX ftMepHKaHCKHMH TeOpeTH-
KaMH. 06pHCOBaJI8Ch nOKft3ftTeJIhHft.H TeHeHI.J;H.H OTXO8 OT
pa,n;HK8JlhHOro CKeDTHI.J;H3Ma, nOOHnBaTeJIhHOro MHHHMaJIH3Ma H
aHTHacceHI.J;H8JIH3Ma nec.HTbIX H WeCTH,nec.HTbIX roOB.
AuTH3CCeHI.J;HaJIHCTbI (M. BeHI.J;, 11. 3HcI>cI>, B. ReHHHK,
M. ROaH, P8HHHH ,l{:m. ,l{HKH H p.) CTaBHJIH ce6e 3l1,Aa'leH
O'lHlL\eHHe .H3bIKa 3CTeTHKH OT nOH.HTHH, npeTeHyJOIL\HX Ha
BCKpbITHe CYIL\HOCTH HCKYCCTB8, npeKp8cHOro, 3CTeTH'IeCKOH
n03HI.J;HH H .T. n. I1pH KpHTH'IeCKOM aH8JIH3e OCHOBHbIX
3CTeTH'IeCKHX K8TerOpHH H npH OTKa3e OT OCHOBHbIX
Tpa,n;HI.J;HOHHbIX 3CTeTH'IeCKHX KOHI.J;enI.J;HH, OHH, KaK. np8BH-
JIO, Orp8HH'IHB8JIHCb HX pa3pyweHHeM, 'ITO, BO MHorHX
CJIYQ8.HX, BeJIO K pa,n;HK8JIhHOMY OTpHI.J;nHHIO 3CTeTHKH KaK
TeOpeTH'IeCKOH HCI.J;HnJIHHbI. OJJ;HaKO 'IHCTa.H ecTPYKI.J;H.H He
MOrJI8 H8 AJIHTeJIbHbIH CpoK CT8Tb CaMOI.J;eJIbIO. BhI8IOIL\HeC.H
H3 aMepHKaHCKHX cl>HJIOCOcl>OB y:me OC03H8JIH, 'ITO cl>HJIOCOcl>H.H
He MO:meT OTK83ftTbCB OT nonbITOK C03JJ;aHHB TeopHH.
HHHI.J;H8TOpaMH TaKHX nonbITOK B cl>HJIOCOcl>HH HCKYCCTB8
B KOHI.J;e 60-x H Ha'laJIe 70-x rOJJ;OB CT8JIH HeJIbCOH ryJJ;MeH H
,l{:mOPJJ;:m ,l{HKH. Heo6hI'I8HHO :mHBOH, a BpeMeHftMH BOCTOp-
:meHHhIH CTPOH aTHX JJ;BYX cl>HJIOcocl>CKHX TeopHH HCKYCCTB8
BBJI.HeTC.H HecoMHeHHhIM CBHeTeJIhCTBOM tTOCKH no TeopHH..
CHMBOJIH'IecK8.H TeOpH.H HCKYCCTB8 ryJJ;MeH8 H HHCTHTYI.J;HO-
HaJIbH8.H TeopHSI HCKYCCTB8 ,l{HKH B036YAHJIH nOJIHHHbIH H
O CHX nop HeOCJIa6eB8IOIL\HH HHTepec B CIlIA, BeJIHK06pHT8-
HHH H CKaHHHnBCKHX CTpaHax. OJJ;HaKO HeJIerKO 6bIJIO
, npeoJJ;OJIeTb JJ;OBOJIbHO JJ;OJIro rocnOJJ;CTBOB8WyJO B aMepHKaH-
CKOH 3CTeTHKe YCTaHOBKY Ha JIHHrBHCTH'IeCKHH aH8JIH3
B3hIK8 cl>HJIOCOcl>HH, B3hIK8 xyo:meCTBeHHOH KpHTHKH H
p83rOBopHOH pe'lH. HH'Iero YHBHTeJIhHoro HeT B TOM, 'ITO
aBTOpoM nepBOH H3 aTHX BYX TeopHH 6hIJI He Cnen;H8JIHCT no
acreTHKe, HO BhIAaIOIL\HHC.H ."IOrHK H cl>HJIOcocl> HeJIbCOH
rYJJ;MeH. TeopHH rYMeH8 H ,l{HKH 6hIJIH HCKYCCHOHHhIMH H
He YOBJIeTBOpHJIH Beex. Ho OHH BOXHOBJIBJIH H8 nOHCKH
HOBbIX peweHHH H KOHTpnpeJIo:meHHH. TaKHMH KOHTpnpe-
JIo:meHH.HMH BBJIBIOTC.H cl>HJIOcocl>cKHe KOHn;enn;HH HCKYCCTBa
,l{:m03ecl>a M8proJIHCa, HHKOJIaca Y OJITepcTOPCPcl>8, APTYpQ
,l{8HTO, CTHBeHa POCC8, MapWHH HTOH H yrHX. HeCMOTp.H
H8 TO, 'ITO Bce aTH TeopHH B03HHKJIH H3 8MepHK8HCKOH
cl>HJIOCOcl>HH nOCJIeJJ;HHX JIeT, OHH 3Ha'lHTeJIhHO OTJIH'IaIOTC.H
pyr OT pyr8, HO npH aTOM HX 06'heHH.HeT Onn03HI.J;H.H no
OTHoweHHIO K H8Typ8JIHCTH'IeCKHM H nCHXOJIOrH'IeCKHM
KOHI.J;enI.J;H.HM HCKYCCTB8. ABTOphI aTHX TeopHH npHHHM8IOT
aKCnJIHI.J;HTHO HJIH HMllJIHI.J;HTHO, 'ITO npoH3BeeHHe HCKYCCT-
Ba eCTb KYJIbTypHoe .HBJIeHHe H B CB.H3H C aTHM OHO He MO:meT
6bITb onpeeJIeHO npH nOMOIL\H TepMHHOB, X8PaKTePH3yJO-
IL\HX HenocpeCTBeHHO BocnpHHHM8eMhIe 'IePTbI npeMeT8,
npeTeHJJ;yJOlL\ero Ha 3BaHHe npoH3BeeHH.H HCKYCCTBa. AMepH-
K8HCK8.H cl>HJIOCOcl>H.H HCKYCCTBa 80-x rOJJ;OB CT8JI8 rop830
60JIee OTKpbITa BJIH.HHHIO T8KHX M8KCHM8JIHCTCKHX cl>HJIOCOcl>-
CKHX HftnpnBJIeHHH, KaK MapKCH3M H cJ>eHOMeHOJIOrH.H. B
CBB3H C aTHM CJIeYeT OTMeTHTh, 'lT0, H8npHMep, HeKOTopbIe
pacceHH.H H peweHH.H np06JIeM cl>HJIococJ>HH HCKYCCTB8,
npeAJIo:meHHbIe M8proJIHCOM, a elL\e paHhwe MeJIBHHOM PeH.zi;e-
poM, BO MHOrHX nyuKT8X MH3KH K MapKCHCTCKOH cl>HJIococJ>HH.
CJIeJJ;yeT OTMeTHTb TOT cl>aKT, 'ITO KpoMe ,l{:m. ,l{HKH,
KOTOpbIH CneI.J;H8JIH3HpyeTC.H Ha cl>HJIOCOcl>HH HCKYCCTB8 H
3CTeTHKe, Bce OCT8JIbHbIe 8BTOpbI cl>HJIOCocJ>CKHX KOHI.J;enI.J;HH
HCKYCCTB8 HMeIOT 3Ha'lHTeJIbHbIe JJ;OCTH:meHHB H B pyrHX
06JI8CT.HX cl>HJIOCOcl>HH. OHH .HBJI.HIOTC.H 8BTOpaMH HHTepeCHhIX
KHHr H3 06JI8CTH cl>HJIOCocJ>HH B3hIKa, cl>HJIOcocl>HH MbICJIH,
cl>HJIOCocJ>HH KYJIbTypbI, anHCTeMOJIOrHH, aTHKH, aKCHOJIOrHH
H JJ;8:me JIOrHKH.
AMepHKaHCKHe cl>HJIOCocJ>bI, KOTopbIe B nOCJIeJJ;HeM JJ;BlI,AI.J;n-
THJIeTHH CeJIaJIH HCKYCCTBO npeMeTOfoi CBOHX pa3MhIWJIe-
HHH, B CBOHX HCCJIeJJ;OB8HH.HX KOHI.J;eHTpHpyIOTC.H H8 MeT83C-
TeTH'IeCKOH, MeTOOJIOrn'leCKOH, anHCTeMOJIOrH'IeCKOH npo-
6
7
.. '-