/
Теги: акции правоотношения
Год: 2011
Похожие
Текст
AKU
OHEPHbIE OEiLllECTBA
AKU
OHEPbl
KopnopaT"BHble
loIo6R3aTenbCTBeHHble
npa
OOT HOWeH"'R
AKljI1C1<EPH"E06L1jECTBO
I1AKLU1C1<EI'bI
-T-
BBeAeHHe
HuC'TT/.OJt11JD.Jl-.MI) npeacrTl.Q6lJ..ll.€'co6oi11CQ.MT!.IIe1OC1--U)e
UCCi1€t3oecuiuen .MeJKiJy bl.MUof51.qe-
CT116Q.M:U Ii. U. Heo6xOOwitocmt, U3Y'leH'UJI. YKa3a1-i1tblX
npaoocrrn:l1011. OOyCA.06.lle1-ia UX 311il OJ1Jl.atclfUOHeP-
wrii ifXJ'P.M.bl npei1npu1ttLilW.me.tl.bC1{(}'[i HOC1rUI.. E€ wupo-
me p1Cnpocmpa1l£1-j.u€ 1«1 npaJCmuKe.Ml):JfC1W OOoJl(.'1-iUmb pWOM
npeuMy"ilJ€CIDB. KU"I11Op'/>l.IIU 06Jw.aaem opzauU3f.1'lj.UOH1iO-npa8o-
ElMifJop.r.taa'KlfUOi-tep1WZOo6uj.ecmea.
IIpeJlfiJe Bcezo, J/ Om..M..€mUmb, 1,:mo 'l1laXQ.J/. ifJop-
.M.Cl eOOe1twt npean Koii CleRmeA.N«X'mU n036()J1.R-
em npU6.liex:amb 31ia1tUmeJlbHbl€ gJuuaW:06bl.€ pecypcbi6 YC1nQ6-
'HbtU 1wnumM aK"IlUO'Hep1WW o6t1J€crneu. KpoJ\1€ molD,
u"ltlfU01t€pNOe 06uJecrneo o6Aaaaem tI.06blLUel-i1-tOii cnoco61wc-
mb10 anxy.M.y.nup:1l3ll'lTlt> cpeOcmea U U'HOe UMytIJf!C1TI-
eo e ycma8J-fbtu mnuma.rt Y:JfCe nOCM e20 g)(:rPMUPOOU1iu..<l nyme.M
ocy oonO.l1.1-tUme.n.b1iblX 6bmYCK06 u"ltlfuu.
IIpu 311WM aM orn.8em,J/.bIX u1C/.fUOH€jXJe O1leHb np-uevww.-
me.tl.bwrU Jl8AJleJ71C.H OO3.II!OJ/O-iOCmb rjxm:m.u"i€C1ru pllC11.OpJI.J/fb-
cJt npu8J1£"lemtblJl'W cpeOc1J1OO.MU U ocy b 1OOUmpoAb
('U'HCJZda nMH.MU 1COHmpMb) 3U de.JtTl1£.llbHOCm'b"KJ 0611Jecrn8U,
I3J1.aCIM onpeCleJ1£1-j.1{blJlt na1re11W.M. aKlJUii. Ca.M. JICe a1crl'UO'1-t€p ne-
cem CKfJlJ:HU'lRH1i!J1O amBf?f1IL'"I1'IBeH.1-«JC'I1lb no do.n2a.M 06t.qec'iJ18U fI
npOOeJlaX C1TIO'I.I.MOC7nU €20 u'K1{uiL
KpOMe molD, nOMUMO yow.cmUJ1. e ynpaMenuu oo
neped1ro onpedeJUl101q:U.M 06pa.mm, 1C ifxl'IcrnoprLM, C'JlOCfJt5cmBy-
10UfUM Y'laCmU1O e UKljUOI-iepJ-fblX 06tqecmooX, Dm-UocumcJl.
B03JIWJ/O/.OC7Ib 'J1..OJLy<l€J-I.'WI 8ueu.OeH800 no QX1fUJlJl-t. A1C1luU, K
'mOMY 3/fe,"KaK npa8UJW, ron.aiJmomijocma:mO'l'iiou.nuKBUClI-iOC-
mb1O, '"lm.o 06YCJ1.06JtU8aem.lle2KOC'm'b ijJ1Jl a"lCllUO'ii€p06 eolXooa
U3 06 cm6a. B c//'y.tae 3/fe Y6/?J1.U'"le'ii'Wl ux KYPC060U. C"1lWU.4WC-
-,-
mu. COBepuu?Hue roe.JlD1C no am"-lyJKiJeHu1O aKlfUu .M.OJ/Cem .JIB-
./iJ1.mbC.Jt ilDnOJ1.'liUmeA.bHblJlt ltCmQIOj.U1\::OM iloxoaa.
OO1ia1\::o TlWpbt, 06yCJlOB.i1.U8aJ1. tuUp01COe pac-
npocmpm-teHU€ aKtfll-O'H€PHblX o61.qeCm8 iffiK rftop.Mb 6e&1i11-Jt
npeeJnpuUUM.ameA.bC'1Wii c1e.<l111.eAb1-WC'l11U. npu8J1.€1WJD712 U ueeJ06-
}X)COO€C71l'HblX .nu1J. cmpeMJl-"U{UXC.R K pa3,llU1O-tOW poda 3J!JJYtW-
mpe6Ae1-tUJl.M C 1f€Jtb1O U3B.i1£'1l€'HWl npu6butu U3 Y1J.peJKiJeuWl
wafU01tep1t"blX o61.qeCm8. KU1\:: U36€C7J1J-IO, UMeH1-W 6 rftop.Me a1\::-
'lfU01l€pJlblX o61if€CmB .pyHK1JUO'H.UpoBa.ftU 1TWK 1W.3"btBUe.M"bL€
tftu1W.'HCOB"b1€ nupa.MuO-b , noBJH?1CUtU€ 06.Ma1i JlU-LOJJcecmea U1CZfUO-
'liep06. IIo.'YfI'ifJJIfY npae060e peZYJ1.up06auue eo3tXrnwl u ileJtmeA."b-
'HOcrnu a1C'!fllO'H€p1(bIX o61.qeCm8 KgJKibemc.R 6 e1e'TI'WA"b1Wii. pe2JJ.a-
.Meuma'lfuu, 1.wnpaMeu'l-toii 'Jia ueeJonyU(£uue noeJo6ubIX
cmnyutpni..
B nctC.I1£duue ZOOb n 'lem1roJl m£1-ttIeu'lfu..'t 'K
c06eptue1tC'11180001tU1O 3a ameA.bCm8a 06 U1CZfUO 06-
tqeCm8UX, U amo n036()J!.J1£m 1mileJtmbC.R, "-l'TTW npa6060ii .MeXU-
'liU3.M OCYUJ€Crn8.lte1i11-Jt npaa u1C1fuouepoo no.rtY1J.um C6De c1C1Jlb-
'lieiituee pU36umue.
B coCIePJICUuue am1-/.01.ll.e1/.uii 6XOdJtm 6aJ/CH£ii-
tuue npU6U UK1JuouePJ6: npaeo 1m Y1Wcmue 6 06"U{eJ1-t co6pa1iUU,
1W. nMyttel-tUe (;wrnoe1.iiJa, .nUK6U(;atpW1t'1-toii K60mb , npaeo 'Jia
U1-tff1opm.aIJU1O, 1ffi KO"H.mpOJtb 3a c1eJt71l€J!.bHOCmb1O aK1JUOHep1W-
eo 061qecm6a U ilpyzue.
Ta1ru.llt o6pa.JOM.. 6 pa.M1\::UX UCC.MdYeM"b1X amHOUJRltuii npo-
ucxooJtm 63a ue a1crjlKmep1fbtX 061¥cm8 u UX Y1W-
cmuUK06, peMU3a1ju..'t 6u:JlC1-teiimux npue a'Kt{lllJ'I/.€}XJB. 6"btme-
iffi1D11lUX U3 UX 'Y'-lfl£mu.JI 6 aK1fUO'H£pHbIX 06tqecmsax_
Huy1t.M.Jt 'li06U3'1ia npe(1cmaeJtel.m.mo ltCCA.e&Jea'liW1 npM6-
.JLJ1Rmc.Jt60 66edeHUU 'H06"btX1my-'l'JiblXnOH..Jtmuii. pU36U8U1O"U{UX
npeClcma6.I1£uue 0 c1U'lia.MU1re npaooom1tO'l..U€uii.MeJKiJy U1C1fUO-
'liepHblJltU 06tqeCmeaJltu U UK1JUO'Hepa.MU, 0 CYUf'HOC7nU 1OOpno-
pamU81ibl.."r npaeoomHouteHUii. 6 'KJW.Ccuif>u1W:ifUU npaeoomHo-
ULeHUU. 603HU'Ka1D11lUX .MeJ/Cdy U1CljUOl-l€pIlblJltU 06r.qecm8ClJ11.U U
U1C1fU01t€Pa.MU. 6 6"btJ/.8J1.eUUU npucy"U{ux Y1W.aaH'l-tblJlt npaeoom-
HOUl.eliUJt.M oc06eHHocmeii. 6 6bliJeuJ!ceJlUU 1W6"bLX CYJKUeH.UU no
(JUCXYCCU01i1i.bLM. 60npOCa.M, U ma"IQICe npeai1.OJlCeHUU no C06ep-
UU?'HC71t606llH.:U1Oaei1.cm8!f101l¥'W bCm8U.
r naBa 1. 06UjaA XapaKTepHCTHKa
npaBOOTHOWeHH , B03HHKalOI..4MX
Me)f(,qY aKIIHoHepHblMH 06111eCTBaMH
H aKIIHoHepaMH
f 1. B03HI1KHOBeHI1e npaBooTHoweHIIH Me>KJIY 3KLlHDHepHblMil
o6aqecTBaMI111 I1X acTHHKaMI1. AKLjHH KaK KDMnneKC
KopnOparl1BHblX 11 06R3aTenbCTBeHHblx "pas aKLlHoHepa
cPe,l\epanbllHJl 3aROH OT 22 8IIpeJifl 1996 r. NQ ;39-4:13 «0 pbIHKe
LI€HHbIX 6)'Mar» ( J1ee 3a1\:OH «0 pb1HKe lteHHbIX 6YMar ) B CT. 2 onpe-
1J,eJUleT 8KLtJ1lO KaK ;}MHCCI10llllyro l.teHH)'IO 6YMaIj', 3aKperounor.uyro
npaBa ee BJIa;J;enbQa (aK oHepa)Ha no.nyq€HJ1:e QaCTI1 npn6bL.TIHaKW1-
oHepHoro 06IL1ecTsB B BJ1J\e ,D,I-fBl1,!J;el1,ZJ;OB, HS yqaC'l'J.-Ie B ynpaBJ1emm a1\:-
QMOHepHbIM 06ll\eCTBoM If Ha 'lBCTb HM.}'ll-IeCTBB, OCTBlOLqeroCfl nOCJle
ero IDIKBJ1,I:IaWU1. TalU1:M 06pa30M, 3aIOOH)JJ;aTeJIb nOHl1MaeT fiOA aKW1-
en lteHH)'1O 6YMary J1 KOMI1J1eKC npas.
B 3TOM :!K€ 3aKOHe 3BKOHOJ\aTeJIeM ,l:\enaeTCfl 8Kl\eHT J1MeHHO HS CQ-
BOKynHOCTl1 npas, 3BKpenJifieMbIX BK'-<I1HMJ1 B 'i8.C"IHOCTH, Y! lteHHbIMI1
6yMaraMH Boo6r.qe. TaK, B CT_ Ui CO;:J;ep:lfGfTCR CJIeJ<YlOLWlH 4JOPM)'ID:!-
poSM: «JTI06bleI1MYIl\eCTBeHHbleY!HeJ npaBa.3aKpeII-
neHHbIe B AOK)'Met!TapHoi-1 JfJ111 6e3 OKYMeHTapHoi-14JopMe. He3aBI1CI1-
-5-
MO OT J1X Hffi'lMeHJBaHlUI. HBJUIKJrCR M>1ca:lmHbIMJI! L\eHHbIMM 6yMara-
MJI, €CJU1 yclJOOlUlI1X S03ID1KHOBeIDI.R J1 05pa eHl1.R COCYfBE"I'C'1' CO-
BOKymIOCTI1 IIJM3H3lIDB M>1cCJroHHOif. L\eHlIQi1 6YMB-rn. YKa3aHHOM B
CTaTbe 2 Ha tPe 3alOClHa». CTaTb.R IB TOro me 3a-
KOHa HOCJ1T Ha3saIDIe: ..4>cJpMa Y)J;ocTOsepeHl-UI npas. COCTaSJ1H1OlilliX
::nYD1CCJ«)HHYJO L\eHllYID 5yMary».
Onpe.I\eJ1eHl-le aKLUfJ1, B1>IBO,lI,IfMOe"3 CMbiCJ1a n.l CT. 2 4>e.I\epaJ1bHO-
ro 3aKOHa or 26 ,lJ;eKa6p.R 1995 r. NQ 208-1:;I:>3 «06 aELjlDIeplllilX 06 e-
CTSax» tI:IaJIee - 3aKoH «06 aKLUfoHepHbIX o6J.qecTB3.x») TalOKe "MeeT
fiCTBeHllbJti: xapaKTep. C o,J:UDfi cropan.I, no.I\ i nOID1MaeTC.R
,lJ;OJUl. H roBOKYJIHOCTb an.IX .I\OJIei1 COCTaBJU1e'T BeJII1'Urny YCTaBHoro
Kam1'TaJIa 8KLjJ10HepHoro o6lL\eCTBa C ,/:\pyrofi CTOpOHbJ. Ha3Ha'leHJ1e
aKLUfJ1 - Y,lJ;OCTOSepJ'ITb npaB3. yqaCTID1lOC1S 06J.qecTBa (aELjlJ"JHepOB) no
OTHOilieIDIKJ K o6J.qeCTBY (npWleM npaBa 06H3aTeJIbCTSeHHble).
TaI01M 00pa3OM, nOMJ1MO roro, 'ITO aKqJ1H RB.J1J'IeTCR, npe)J\,!le acero,
KOMIIJIeKCOM npas, 3aTeM - L\eHHOM 6yMarofi, OHa TaJOKe C()()'fB€"J'C'J'yeT H
JlPJIe yqacTI1.R aKLjJ10Hepa B ycrasHOM KaIDfTaJIe aKLjJ10HepHorOO €CTBa.
.!LB. JIoMaKI1H TOiI<e xaJ:GKTeP13)eT aKl<JOO B Tj)€X 3H3.'1eHJ1.R:X. IIp€)fC-
scem, K3.K:q€HH)'lO 5yMary. 3aTeM K3.K,/J;0JII{) B aKqI1OHepHOM KaillfTaJIe.
C1I'Me'ffiR, 'ITO HMeHHO TaKJ1e CMkK:JJOBbIe 3Ha'ieHIDI J1Me€T 8Hr.JIJG"ic:KJrl:i:
TepMI1H«share». ,lJ;J1fIc600H3.'1eHIDI .CaHTJDn1cKoco
H3bIKa CJIOBO «share» MO'IKHO nepeseCTI1 H KaKJ\OJIR, J1 KaK aK4WL B CIlIA
TepMJ1HOM «stock» oI503Ha'l3.€TCH KaK Becb aKiUWHepHWt: KaIDIT3.JI B L\e-
JIOM, TIIKJ1 em 'l3.CTh, J1MeH)'€Ma:fIa.K4I1€i1. TepMI1H «1lK4IDI» J1MeeTeLqe O.I\-
HO 3Ha'leHl1e. YJaCTO BeCb KOMIIJIeKC npas, KO"IUpbIM o6.rra.z\aJ:I aK4>fOHep,
l1MeHOBaJ1CR O.I\ffi1M 'I'E'pMillIOM «npaso Ha Y'ffiCTI1e B 06J.qeCTse» JfJIJ1 «aF;-
L\I10HepHoe npaso». npWleM Mem.r:\Y 3THMM II()H.HTIfJIMI. H aK4I1efi CTaSI1JI-
C.R 3HaF; paseHCTBa. TaKJ.1M 06pa30M, CJ10S0 «aKqJ1H» ynarpe6JI.ReTCR 11M
TaIOKe S 'Ipex 3Ha'leHJ1.R:X - K3.K L\eHHa.R 5yMara, K3.K 1JPJUI B ycrasHOM Ka-
lII1'TaJIe H KaK KOMIIJIeKC npas..
IIpI1 aTOM, OTMe'laeT YKa3allHlDi asTOp, s aKLjJ10HepHbIX 06lL\ecT-
sax, r.I\e arcyrcTsyeT ar.rn:cC:mI 06ocoEi.neHHllx ]1OEyMeHTOB, 06 aKLjJ1.RX
MO:>KHO roBOpl1Tb IDIIlIb KaK 0 '1aCTI1 yCTaBHCI'O KaIIl1TaJIa 10IUI,/J;II'leCIID-
ro IDIQa H, C .I\OCTaTO'-IHoA CTeneHbKJ ycJ1OBHOCTH, KaK 0 KOMr1J1eKCe
npas aKJ-tl10Hepa, HO He KaK 0 6e3,lT,OKYMeHTapHofi L\eHHoi16YMB-re. 1
EJ.qe paHee J10CV!4JOM Epay,/:\e 2 J1 II. IIl1ceMcKI1M 6blJII1 BbICKa3aHbI
CXO,!J;HbIeB3rJ1.R)U>I. YKa3aHHble yqeHble onpe.I\eJ1.RJ1J1 aKlV'OO '1epe3 CJIe-
,uyKJIIJ;.YIO "Tpl1aAY. «Bo-nepSbIX. nOJ\ 8KLjJ1ej;j pa3yMeeTC:fI I13B€CTH8H
,lJ;O!IFI yqaCTI1R J1l1L\a B npe,D;Ilp UITIm; BO-BTOPbIX, 113B€C'TH8J'I p'O!IFI 06-
ll.jECTBEHHOIU KaIIWTaJIa; B-TpeTbI1X, ,/J;oK)'MeHT. CBU.l\ereJIbC1'ByIOlL\I1fi
06 yqaCTIDI J1I1Qa B JOCIMnaHJIJP. 9
-6-
llH. I'yccma:EcIorn nOHl1MaJI B.KQHIO KaK crIpeJ\€JIeHHYJO J\0JIl0 Ka-
IDITaJJa JlB.IOJltY1O npaBO J1I>1l\Y, BH€crn€MY :n'Y 'laCTb 06ll\€-
crneHllOro KaIDITaJIa., npaBO aKQI10Hepa, TO eCTb npaBO Ha Jf3BeCTHDe
yqaCTI1€ B ynpaBJI€HI1I-f J\€J1aMJ1 aKQJlOHepHOl'O OOI1l.eCTBa 11 npaBO Ha
nOJ1Y'1eHl1eJlJIBJIJI€HJ1<l"
liD MH€HI1IO H.T. TapacoBa. «aKIV1Jl eCTb J\OKYMeHT Ha yqaCTl1e B aK-
l\J10HepHOM npeJlIIplU!'I'l1JI C OIIpeJ\e.neHHot1:]:\OJ1eii: aKl\l1OH€PflOl'O KanJ1-
TaJIa. J\alOll\I1H onpeJ\eJ1eHlIb1e npaBa 11 BCI3J1aI'IDOllVI onpeJ\eJ1eHlIbI€
06H3aHHOCTJr, COCTaBJIHlOll\J1e co.n;e e TaK Ha3bIBaeMoro aKl\J10-
HepHoro npaBa:l>.S
T.R KarnaHl1Ha C'I11TaeT, '1TO aKL\11J1 - aTO l\eHHafl O)'M8ra, YJ\OCTQ-
sepH1OIlJ,3.H npaBO €e BJIa)J;€JIbQa Ha ,lJ;OJOO B co6c-rsemibIx cpe)J;CTBaX
aKQHOH€PHOro 06ll\eCTBa, Ha nOJ1)"1€Hl1e )J;oxo)J;a OT ero J\€HTeJIbIIOC'I'H
11, KaK npaBJ1JIO. Ha yqacTI1e B ynpaBJ1eHJU13'rI1M 06rQ€C"l'Ba\IL CaMO CJ10-
SO aKQI1fI (OT JIaT. actio) 03Ha'lae-r pacnopIDf«'Hl1e. . np€-
TeH3MH. 6
OB. BeJ1DyCOB Bbl,l\eJ1HeT ,D;Be xapaKTepl1CTI1KJ1. npl1 e aKl{ID:l.
Bo-nepBbIX.aKQJ1flMomeTObITb TOro. 'lTOJ1J1L1;Of!BJlJ'1-
eTCfl 'lJIeHOM aK4JIDH€pHOI'O oOlllecTBa. YKa3aHHoe 'lJIeHCTBO nOHl1MaeT-
Cff KaK ca>oKYJ1HOC'Tb nplU! J1 o6H3amiocTeii: 8Kl\J10Hepa no OTHorneHi1lO
KaKl\J10HepHOM)' oOlllecTBY. a B 3aKpbITbIXaK4J10H€pHbIX OOllleCTBaX-
TaJOKe npas 11 ii: aK4J10Hepa no OTiiOrneHl1IO K}JJ)yrMM aK-
Bo-BTopbIX, aKQHH MOiK€T 0603Ha'laTbJ\0JIl0 yq8CTI1fI aKL\l1-
OHepa B aKQJntepII('M 06I11.ecTBe. TaR, nO)J;pa:3)\eJ1eHl1eM ycrmmo:ro Ka-
IDITaJ1a aKqIDH€PHOro 06ll1eCTBa Ha B.K4J1M nOHl1MaeTCR npeiK)J;e Bcero
TO, 'lT0 aKQW1 B AaHl10M cJ1Y'ffie BbipamaeT AOJ11O yqaCTM aKIV'IOH€pa B
.'
KaK TO'1HO lDJ];MeTJ1J1 M.J1. RYJ1anlH, C OCTb aKl\J111 HeJ1b3fl pac-
KpbITb, cpamnmas1 11 Bbl,l\eJU1J1 06ll\11€ '1epTbI aKq.rn. OCTaBanCb Ha
ypoBHe rop aHaJill3a, TaKKaK npaBO He MOiK€T ObITb nORllTO
113 caMoro ceOf!. C OCTb aKql111 MOiK€T Ob.ITb paCKpbITa J1J1Wb npl1
aHaJm3€ 3ItOHOMII'1ecKIfX OTHOl1l€Hl'Dl, '1TO J1 npo,!\eJ1aJJ K MapKC.
C :3mHOMJl'1ecKOH TO'ffiI1 3peHl1H K MapKC oxapam-ePJI3OBaJI 8KQI1IO
KaK TJ1TYJ1 coocrneHlIOCTJ1 Ha npl16aButmyro CTOI1MOCTb. B IIpJ1 3'rOM
K MapKC nOJIaraJI, '1TO CTOIfMOCTb aKQID'J: «eCTb BCerJIB. KaIDITaJIR3llpO-
BaHHbIHAOXOA., TO€CTbAOXOA, I1C'fV!CJ1eHHbIHHa KaIIl1Ta.n
BrocrrBE"IC1'BJBI c CytIJ;eCTBYIOI1I.et1: C'I'aBK()jii n. OHI1 (aBTOp
l1MeeT B BI1JJY 8KQHI1) CTaHOBHTCH HOMl1HaJ1bHb!Ml1 npe.l:IC'"rnBUT€J1HMI1
HeC)'U.\eCTSYIOI1I.ero KaIDrraJIa.l160 AeiicTBKre.nbHbill KamrraJ1 Cy:Il\€CT-
eyeT HapH.DY C HI1M J1, KOHe'IHO. He nepexo,!\11T B Apyrl1e PYID'l OT TOro,
'1TO 3T11lJY1)JlHKaTbI nepeXO):\HT 113 pyK B p)'Kl1. OHI1J\eJlalOTCH ct>oPMOH
Kanl1TaJla, npJ1HOCRllIeronpOQ€HTbl He TOJIbKO nmOMY, '1TonyreM npo-
-7-
,lJ;a>KYI 3a HMX MmKHO nOJIY'ffiTb OOpaTHO ,lJ;eHbrn KaK 3a KaIDITaJIbHbIe
CTOIIMOCTI1... BeJIJf'U1Ha J1X CTOJIMOCTIf MOmeT nOBblllIaTbCJ! Jf na..n;an.
COBeprneHllO HroaBI'JCJIMO OT ABlf)K'eHWI CTOJfMOC"fH ,lJ;eJlCTBJITe,JIbH()1
Ka.mrraJIa, rnT)'.nOM Ha KO'T'()pblii OIn1 EBJlJ!IOTCH».V
npe,lJ;craBJU1lOTco60tirnTy.nco6cTBelll1ocTI1Ha,AeHCTI3JI'I'eJIb-
Hbrn:KalIJiITarr4JMpMbI,C H.anOJIY"leID1eI1plt6aBo<rnoiiCTO-
J-IMOcrn, KOTOp)'KI STOT KaIlJ1TaJI npmIOCJfT, 0'Ip:UKelIJK' Ol'HOwemm.
CBH3aHHb!X C npoI'23BOJ1C'1'IOd Jf pacnpe.r\eJIE'IDleM Ha KOHKpeTHOM npe,lJ;-
""""""'""
KaK c'-urraeT 10.11. qeTBepm<oBa. aKLIJ1f! BbICT)'naeT B Ka.'IeCTBe OCO-
60ti 4>opMbi MOfu 1 cpe,lJ;CTB. «C ee nOMOIqbIO BHaI-16oJn,rneJI Me-
pe ,lJ;OCTI"IraeTCJ! Ol',IJ;eneHJ1e nrrynoB Ha ,lJ;OXO.n; 01' peaJibHoro npou;ecca
npo B TO.me BpeMR aKLIJff! Ol'pamaeT .n;BJlmE'HJfe peaJlbHoro
K'lIUrraJ1a, KaID1Ta.naJfnpOII;eCCnpJ1CBOeHJff!pe3YJlbTaTOB
J1X o6opOTa TeM WIH JfHbIM cy6'beKTOM. Cyrb aKII;J1J1 He B TOM, 'ITO c06-
CTBeHHI1K BHec onpe)\eJ1eHHblti nati B npe.!UIplfH11'1e, a B TOM, '-ITO :3TOT
nati nOJIY"laeT EI03MOJKHOC'Tb o6palII;emm Ha 4JOH;J;OBOM pblHKe, 3 3Kl\J1-
OHep M B.1la)J;eJIbII;a .n;eHe:>KHoti CYMMbl npenpaLII;a€TCH B cymeKTa KOH-
TpoJUI Ha)\ npe,ll;!lp>1HTI1eM JI! B n OIU co6cTBeHHl1Ka .n;OXOA8.
KOTOpbIti 4>oPMJ1PyeTcH Ha OCHose 3TOro nRIP) 11.
Jf3Il(1J1(1)KeHH.1cT.147 Ko)\eKCa 4Ie)\e-
pau;>m (}:J;anee - rK P4I) cne,nyeT, '-ITO II;elll1aE 6yMara, a 3Ha'.Hrr JI! aK-
QJ1H, Y,IJ;OCTOsepHeT OOH3aTeJ!bCTBeHHble npasa, rIOCKOJIbKY a63. 1 IL 2
YKa3aHHo:w: craTbl1 YCTaHaBJll1Bae-r, '-ITO OTK83 OT HCIlOJIHeHIfJI 06H3a-
TeJIbCTBa, Y,l\OCTosepeHHoro II;eHHo:w: 6YMIDDlf, co CCb!JIKOti Ha O-rcyrCT-
IDle OCHOBaH1'U1 06H3aTeJibCTBa J11160 ero He,l\efic'rBl'rreJlhHOCTb He ,l\orry-
CKaeTCH. A63.11L 1 CT. 2 3aKOHa «06 aKql10HepHb!X 06Il\ec"1'B3X" npHMo
YCTaHaBJlJ1BaeT, '-ITO aK1U1F! y;n;ocTOBepf!eT J1MeHHO 06H3aTeJlbCTBeHHbIe
npasa yqaCTHI1KOB 06ll\ecrBa no Ol'HOrneHWIQ K 06ll\ecTBY.
CTaTbH 307 rKP4I ,l\3eT onpe)\eneID1e 06H3aTenbCTBa, B ('()(JT1JeTCT--
BHM C KOTOpbIM B CJ1J1Y 06H3aTeJlbCTBa O,!!,HO J1JfQO (,l\OJDKHJfK) OOf!3aHO
COBeplll11Tb B nonb3)' APYToro J1l1Lta (Kpep,wropa) onpeAeJ1eHHOe AeticT-
B>1e, KaK-TO: nepe.n;aTb HM)'III;t:'CTBO, BI:mUJIID1Tb paoary, ynnaTJ1Tb
AeHbrn J1 TOMY nO;:J;ooHoe, J11160 B03;:J;epmaTbCf! 01' onpe,l\€J1eHHJro ,[teti-
CTBWI, a Kpero-rrop J-IMeeT npaBo -rpeOOBaTb 01' AOJDKID1Ka JfCrIQJlHeID1Jl
ero OOH3aHHOCTJ1.
J1 Bce.me MHorne Y'-IeBbIe C'U1TaKYI', 'ITO no KpaAHeti Mepe 'IaCTb OT-
HOliIE'HMlf, B03HHKalOIl\>1X Jf3 4Ja,KTa npl105pe-retn1H npaBa Co6cTB€HHOC-
TJ1 Ha aKII;I1IO, He c-rpoJ1TCH no MO,D;eJIJ1 06H3aTeJlhcTBeHHb!X. TaK, €lL\e
MM.ArapKOBBcBoeM Tpy)\e «Y'IeID1eoQeHHb!X6y-
MarnX' yKa3blB3J!, 'ITO «npaBa 'lJIeHCTBa. COCT3BJ1IDOT cYJ.L\€CTBeHHYlO
'IaCTb CO,D;epmaHJ1H aKl<J1l1» 12. Bo.m,WJ1HCTBO >Ke yqeHb!X (HaIlpJ1M€p,
-,-
B.IT. M03OJIJ1H, E.A RparneIDIHHJIRDB, H.M. M:i1plJIIIffiIRDBa, A.ll Bepllll1-
IDIH, )];.B. JIoMaKI1H, E.A CYXaHOB, HE. GrerurnoB) nplf,!\EJ»KI1BaIffI('.51
TOi1TO'DCM3J)eHIDI,'i'ToH8«YI'OpbleOTHOllieHIDI, J13IIJ:m06-
pe1'eHIDI npaBa u:6cTBemrocm Ha aKLUfJ1, 11, npaBa,
Y,l\OCToBepJ1eMbIe 1, flBJUllOTCJ1 He 05H3aTeJJl>C'l'BeHHl>IMH a
J1MemlO JWplJOpaTI1BHbIMM. H.M. MMpollIHl1ROBa B CIDI3M C::rrnM OTMe<ffi-
eT, 'ITO «a Y,ll,OCTOBep92T npaoo 'iJ1eHCTBa B 1«ipncpa1U-'lJl, a He Te
06s'I3aTe.11bC'IBeHHbll1J1l.-l BeLqHhle npaBa, K()'fOpbIe MOry:r B03l11-1KlI.YTh Y
aKQJ1oHepanpMHaJIWrnJ1 4>aKTOB.IIo-
3'I'OM)' HeT Hl1l\aK1-1X OTHOCl1Th aRLII1J1 K 'n-IcJ1)' 06J13a'reJ1hCT-
BE'HHo-npaBoBbIX IfJIJ1 BE'LqHO-npaBCEbIX qeHHbIX 6YM<lT>}.13
)];0 npJ1HffTI1J1 r ro Ko)J;eKca P4I B )J;eiicTBoBaBllEM IIo.no-
:HremIJ.-I «06 aKIV10HepHbIX 06w;eCTBax» 3aKOlJ"J,l\aTeJ1hHO 6hIJ10 3aKpen-
neHO, 'ITO aKq>leM HBJUIeTCfI qeHHaH 6)'Mara, BbIII)'CKaeMaJI BKQJIIOHep-
HbIM 06IL\ecTBoM J1 y,IJ,OC'IOBepHK:W,aJ'l npaBO co6cTBeHHocTIt: Ha ,/J;OJUO B
YCTaBHOM KaIDITaJIe o6w;eCTBa 14 TaRMM 05pa:3oM, 6hIJ10 YKa3aHO, 'lTO
aKQIDi 3aKpenJIHe'T J1MeHHO BelL{Hble npaBa. O,/J;HaKO no CBoei1 cyrn: Ta-
Koe orIpe,l\€J1ffIlle He COOTBeTCTBOBaJIO npan, YAOCTOBE'pJl-
eMhIX a L IIpJ1 :n'OM, KaK COBepWeHHO BepHO OTMe'laeT A.ll Bep-
llIJ1HJ1H, B CpaBHeuml C JJPKyMeHTapHbIMJ1 l.leHHbIMJ1 6yMaraMJ1 ew;e
,D;aJIbwe OT Bew;Ho-npaBOBoro perYJrnpDBaHl-IJI HaXOJJ:IITCH pernaMeHTa-
LUfH npaB J13 6eaJ:\oJCYMEH'ffiPHbIX qeHHbIX 6)'Mar. IIpJ13TOM OTCyrCTBY-
lOT HaJIWlHble L\eHHble 6)'Marn KaK OObeKTh! BeI.qHbIX npaB.15
Crrell;YeT OTMeTI1Th, '!:TO, npJ13HaBaH 'lJIeHcram: xapaKTep npaB, 3a-
KpeIIJlfIeMbIX BKqI1eH, OH ,l\aJIee IIpOTJ1BOpeqI'IT ce6e, BHaJIM3J1pyH
CKJIa.r:\hmalOI1UfeCfI OTHowemm no 06H3aTeJ1bC'I'Bell1lOi MOAeJ1J1 CJIe,Dy-
tomI1M05PB30M. IIOCJIe BbI,M"lli l\('HHOii 5YManiB C()()"IBeTC'I'BJ1 C 3aKO-
HO,!J;aTeJJhCTBOM B03HJ1KaeT npaBOOTHOllleIDIe, B KOTOpOM ,l\OJ1mHJ1KY, TO
eCTb J1J1Q)', BhI,! aBweMY qeHHyro 6)'Mary, I1pOTI'1BOCTOJ1 Kpe,l\I-'lTOp, TO
eCTbJ1JlII;D, ynpaBOMOqeHHoe liD qeHHoi16YMBre.ll3MeHeIDle npaB B OT-
HOWeHI-IJIX yqacTHJ1KOB Ipam,llaHcKOro 05opoTa AonYCKaeTCJI 3aKOHOM,
no 05w;eM)' npamwy, TOJIbKO IIO COm3rneIDUO CTOpOlL OWIOCTOpmrnee
J13MeHeHJ1e)TCJ!UBJm:06H3aTeJIbCTBaHe ,3aJ1CKJIKJ'leHV!eM
CJ1Y'laeB, npell;YCMO'IpeHHhIX 3aKOHOM (CT. 310 rK P<f». HanpJ1Mep, B
CJ1J1)' CIIeqr.-rq.um1 KopnopaTJ1BHhIX 6)'Mar 3aKOHO,!J;aTeJIbCTBO npe,DyC-
MaTpVlBaeT npM onpe,l\eJIeHHbIX yc.noBJ1HX B03IIK.OI<HJC'T ,l\eHcTBIDi,
BJ1eK J13MeHeHJ1e Y,I:\OCTOBepeHHbIX J1MJ1lIpaB. TaK, HanpJ1Mep, B
pe3ynhTaTe cOBepweHJ1.ll AefiCTBHii no KOHBepraJ.J}rn, KOHCOJ1J1,l\al.lMJ1
MJUI .LJ;po6JIeHJ'oo aKwrn J13MeHHlOTCR. COO'!Be'rCTBeHHO. YZlocToBepJ'!€-
Mble J1I\rn npaBa. 16
B COOTBeTCTBWI co CT. 142 rK P r<eHHaH 6)'Mara Y,l\OCToBepHeT
J1Myw;ecTBeHHbIe npaBa, ocyw;eCTBJIeHl-Ie run'! nepe,l\a'la KOTOpbIX B03-
-,-
MO:IKHbITOJIbKO np:!1 IIpe.II'bHBJ1€HJUr K)'II1eHW. eHlIOif 6)'Marn. He MO-
ryr 6bITb OO"beKTOM eHHbIX 6)'Mar JiI1'llibIe He npaBa
(Ha HMH, 'leCTb Jf . ,lJ;eJIOByro perryra Jf TaK ,lJ;aJ1ee) Jf
npaBa, HepaapbIBHo CBR3aHHbIe C m:rnJOC'TbJO. O;:uIaKO cpe,D,l-f npaB aK-
QI10Hepa MO:IKHO HaHn-l npaBa Hel-!MYll-\eCTBeHlIOro xapamepa. HanpI>-l-
Mep, npaBO Ha nOJI.Y'leID:Ie IrmPo 0 ,lJ;eJITeJIbHOCT>f oow;eCTBa.
ECJm CA',DtiBaTb npaBI1JIaM c}xpMaJ1b11Oii nrnKlI, 1-13 CMbIcna 'I. 1
CT. 142 rK PCPCJIelIYE'T'. 'lTO He HHbI(' npaBa He yJ1OC'T'OBepfl-
IOTCH .o.wmKO. KaKno E'T'J-IJI,lLB..Jlc:Mucmf.
npaBa TeCHO CB$l3aHbI C HE:1-fMYll TBel1HbIMU Jf B eJIOM 06pa3)'1OT C IDI-
MJ1: e)l;I>-l1lbItf KOMIIJIeKC. KOMIlJIeKC ;yroT OH l1MeuyeT npaooM 'UleHCTBa,
KOTopoeB eJIOMHocRTI xapaKT€p. Co6CTBeHlD-lKaKLII-II'I
KaK l\€fllJ"Jil5)'Mam -:01'1'0 He 06JIa,l: a.'reJ1b pa3p03I1elllibI IIpaB, nOCKOJIb-
KY OTl\eJIbHble npaBa He MOryr 6bITb nepe.n;am.I 11M I\pyrl1M JIJ-lQaM 17
B CBR3:!1 C BbIW€Jo13.JIJ)fteHHbIM S031U1KaeT sonpoc: a 'lTO me nopo::tC-
,lIPeT KOMIIJ1eKC npas aKql10Hepa? BUJJ}-IMO. .paKT :oIMJ-ICCID:! aK4YIOHep-
HbIM 06meCTBoM aK4YlI>-lI-! J-IX pa:3M€Il\eH:!1e CaMO no ce6e
emeHeBJ1€'ieT 1R Yl1Xnp:!106peTaT€JIeHnpas.
K TaKoM)' JKe BbIBOlIY npl-lIlleJi J-I M.M. ArapKoB, OTMe'IaBIIll-li1. 'ITO
«COCTaBJIeIDIe J-I Bbl,!\3'Ia aKIU-lI-! He HBJIHeTCH Heo6xo,rolMblM }'CJIOBJleM
AJIH B03HMKHOBeHI-IH npaB aK4YlOHepa».18
Ha HallI B3rJIHA, l1MeHHo.paKT npIID6peT€HIDI CTaTyca yqa.CTHJ1Ka B
aKi{l10H€pHoM 06mecTBe nopO::tC,/J;aeT yKa3aHHbn1 KOMIIJ1eKC npaB aKQ:!1-
OHepa. A npI>-l06peT€Hl-le cTaTyca y<mCTHI-fKa aKQI>-IOHepHOro 06IQeCTBa
nO.llTBep)K,l\aeTCH BHeceJD:leM COOTBeTCTB}'lOIl\ei1 3aJD1CJ1 B peecTp aK-
QI10HepOB 06Il\eCTBa. cOl\epmaIQei4l\aHHbIe ° ero y<mCTIDIKa.X (aKIU-lO-
HepaX). BHeceHI>-Ie JKe B peecTp aKQI>-IOHepoB B03MO:IKHO TOJIbKO B c.rryqae
npnOOpeT€HI-IH aKQJ-IH 06IQecTsa. TaKl-fM 06paaoM. ,D,mI B031JJIRHOSeID:IR
npaBa 'IneHCTBa (yqa.CTIffl) He06xoJll-iM COCTaB IOpJ-W:!'IeCKMX tPaRTOB'
nplr06peTeH1'1E' aKl1l-ur (l-IMeeTCH B B».!IY a:JBeprnelIlte c.lIeJIIaf no rrepe-
xo,!\}' npaBa c06CTBeHHOCTI>-I Ha aKQJ11f. HeSa:IKHO B l\aKOti .popMe - co-
rnallIeHI-IH ° nO,!\IDICKe, 1J;OroBOpa Kyrum-npOMmi-lI-fJ1I>-1l\PyroM):!1 BHe-
ceHi-le ,lIPHHbIX 06 aKIU-lOH€pe B peeCTp aKQ:!10HepOB 06w;ecTsa. Ee3
npnOOpeT€HI-IH aK1V11f HeBCI3M())KIj() BKJlIO'1eHI>-Ie B peec'I'p aKlU'IOHepOB,
5e3 BKJlIO'Iemm B peeCTp HeB03MomHa pea.1II13aQHH KaKI-IX 6bI TO HI-!
6bIJIO npas aKQJWHep6M:l1-
3roT BbJBO,!\ C!1paBe,I Jnm " ,D,mI C-.I1)"1aR yqpe::tC,/J;em-u:r 05w,eCTBa. B co-
CfI'BeTCTBWI C n. 1 CT. 10 3aKOHa «06 8KUV:IOHepHbIX r yqp€)J;I1-
TeJIRM:!106w;ec-rsaRBJ1.ll:lOTCRrpa::te.lI.aHeJf (1-fJ111)IOpIf.l<I JI:I1Q8,np:!1-
IUIBIillfe pellIeID:Ie 0 ero yqp€m,!\eHID:!. Ha OCHOBaHID1 a63. 2 n 2 CT. 25
yAA.3aHHOro 3aKOHa np:!1 yqp€m,!\eHJrn o6w;ec-rsa see era aK1V11f 1\000000I
6bITb pa3Mew;eHbI cpe,lJ;J1 era Y'Ipe,lI,l-lT€JIei1. OraTbH 2 3aKOHa «0 pblliKe
-10-
qeHHbIX 6yMar M onpe.n;e.mIeT e RaK OT'!)')K,!\effi1e -
HbIX qeHHbIX 6JMar ::IMMTeHTOM nepBblM BJ1a,JJ;eJ1b'-\<lM nyreM 3aKJ1lO'1eH11R
IpIDK,!\B.HCI<:Q-npaBOBbIX C,!\eJIOK Or<tym,Qeffi1e qeHHbIX 6yMar, B TOM'tffiC-
ne aK1V1ti, npe,!I,IlOJlaraeT IIepeXo.D, npaBa I Ha IDIX K HOBbIM
B.I18J\eJThL\8.M E1..I-J1I1L\O,KOTOpoMYqeHHble6j'MB1'I-'Inpl1lffi,!\JIeIKaT
Ha npaBe co6cTBeHlIlx:n1 J1.ID1 HHOM BeI1VIoM npaBe (CT. 2 TOro me 3aKoHa).
PeeC'rp BJ1a,!\eJ1bqeB qeHHb1X 6YMar (.n;aJIee - peecTp) - 3TO qacrb
ClfCTeMhI Be,lJ;eHl1J1 peecTpa, npe cooot1 cn COK 3apemCT-
p 1pUBaHHbIX BJIap;eJIbI.\eB C YJffi3affi1eM 1«l1IJI'I€CTB3., HUMi'1HS.JIbHUi CTO-
J1MOCTJ1 J1 KaTerop J1 npmJa;:v1emall.U1X l-IM J1MeHHbIX qeHHbIX 6JMar.
COCTaBJ1eHlllillI no COCTOSlllMlO Ha .mo6yro YCTaHOBJ1ellllyro ,lJ;aTY J1 noo-
BOJ1ffiOLW'IWIV\ Tb3TI1X J1RaTe-
ropM1Onpl "J1MqeHHblX6)'Mar.
TIo,!\ CJ1C'I'eIOOii: Be.n;eH11R peecrpa BJIa,!IeJIbQeB qeHHbIX 6)'Mar nOHI1-
Ma€TCflCCEOKyIIHOC'I1o,lJ;aHHbIX, HHbIXHa6yMamHoMHOCI1-
TeJIe J1/J1Jrn: C I1crnJIb30BalDI€M ::IJIeK'"IpC)lIIW 6a3b! ,l\aHHbIX, 06ecne'IJ1-
BaIOIl1:3-R J1,!\E'HTJ1 lU1IO 3aperl1C'IpupoB3HHb1X B CI1CTeMe Be.n;eHIDI
peecrpa BJIa,lJ;e.-JIl,QeB qeHHbIX 6yMar HOMJma..TJ:bIll:jX ,lJ;epmaTeJIew J1 BJIa-
.n;eJ1bQeB qeHHbIX 6JMar 11 yqeT J1X npaB B OTHOIlleHJ:U:1 qeHHbIX 6yMar,
3apenlCTpJ1})<l3aHHblX Ha J1X J1M.II, ID3BOJIRIOIqaH: nOJ1y'IaTb J1 HanpaB-
,lliITb J1H!}xJPMalU1IO YJffi3aHHbIM Jllfi¥3-M 11 COCTaBJUITb peecTp BJIB,IJ;eJlb-
ueB qeHHbIX 6JMar (CT B 3aKOHa ,,0 pbIHKe qeHHbIX 6yMar»l
AKIU10HepHoe oomecrBo 06H3aHO 06ecne'llITb Be,!\eID1e J1 xpaHeIDIe
peecrpa aKqI10HepoB OOW;eCTBa B COOTBeTCTBIDI C npaBOBb1MJ1: aKTaMJ1
PoccJrliCKdi r4>e.n;epal.\l1l1 C MOMeHTa rocy,l\apCTBeHIIOM pEflIc-rpaqm1 05-
mE'CTBa (n 2 CT. 44 3aKOHa «06 aKl-\>1OHepHblX oOIl\ecrBax»). TaKl1M oopa-
30M, C MOMeHTa roCY,l\apcTBeillIOM pemc-rpal.\l1l1 OOW;eCTBa ,lJ;OJDKHa 6bITb
ooecne'1eHaB03MomHOCTbJ1,l:\eHTl-f I B.KIV1ti.J1Wo'!eH-
HOCMCT€Ma Be.n;eHIDI peecrpa BJIaJ\eJThQeB B.KIV1ti n03BOMeT 1 rQJJ1-
L\!1JXIBaTb BJIBJ\eJ1bQeB J1 HBJlfIeTCH I1D,!\TBE'p:m,I\eIrneM OOJIaJ¥IIDIH J1MJ1
COBOK)'I1WCTblOJIM)'ll1:€CTB€HH J1 npaB.
TIOCJIe COBepIllemm c.n;eJIKJf no nepexo.n;y npaBa c06crBellllOCTl-I Ha
aKl[ID'! npl106peTaTeJIb nOJ1y'IaeT TOJibfW O;:J;HO npaBO - npaBO Ha BHece-
IDle ero B peeCT}) aKLtI,-IQHepOB. OmoweHJ1e, CQJ:Iepm.amreM KOTOporo
fiBJIRe'fCH npaBO aKIU10Hepa Ha BHeCeHl1I2 3arrnCI1 0 HeM B peeCTp, fiBJIfl-
eTCfl 06H3aTeJ1bCTBeHHbIM no CBoeM npwpo.n;e.
IIpaBO Ha BHeCeID1e B peecrpaKWIOHepcm BeCbMa BaiKHO]J)l1I npwJ5pe-
TeHIDI JIJ1l¥)M CTa'Ij'Ca aKW-lOHepa. Era 3Ha'1eHl1e TPYIJ:HO nepeoQeHl1Tb.
.no MOMftfIa BHeCeHI1.FI 3affi1CI1 B peeC'rp aKqMOHepOS 0 npw>fpeTe-
IDII1 aKqI1J1, J111L\O, clxlKTWleCKtf oc)'1l.tecTBI1B TaKoe npwJ5p€TeHJ1e, J1J1-
IlleHO EI03lIfOJKHOCTH peam13OBa'Tb CBOI1 npaBa, BbIT€KaIOlW1I2 J13 'lJIeH-
CTsa B OOmeCTBe. Tor,lJ;a RaK,lJ;JiJ'l cTaTyca aKIU10Hepa 3HaqeHl1e J1MelOT
J1MeHHO npasa. KOTOpbIl\rn OH HH]J;e.lliIeTCH B CKJIY "lJIeHCTBa B ofuQec'rBe.
31'0 OTMe'IaJ1 el1\e J1.T. TapaCOB, KCYI'Opbllf miCaJ1, 'ITO«
:;IJIeMeHT B nOHHTI-!1f 06 8Kq110Hepe COCTaBJIHeT He 8Kq1fI1. 8 aKqlfOHep-
Hoe npaso, If no.n;TBep eM 3TO TeM npOCTblM If flCHbIM clJaKTOM, '1'1'0
J1IflIa. He np0l13H;mmle I1QJ1IJOii OrtnaTbl aKqI:BI, nOJ1Y'1aIOT He 8KQ111f, 8
TOJIbKOBpeMeHHble CBMeTeJIb("T1Ja. C'lMTaHCb. TeM He MeHee, 8KQIfOHe-
paMIf J:I nOJ1b3YJ'lCb 8KQ110HepHblM npaSOM, Mem.n;yTeM KaKnIfLta. oIlJ1a-
TI-lBllIlfe cnOJlHa CBOM aK , HO He JIMeIOliV!I€ J1X B YCT8HOBJ1elll10M KO-
.JIHqecTBt:'. meHb 'IaCTO He nOJ1b3yKJTCJi 8KQlfOHepHbiM npaBOM B
nOJ1HOM ero ofueMe; XOTJi, KaK :yKa3aHo YiRe Bbillle. HBJIeHife 3'1'0 CJ1e-
11YeT OTHeCTIf K pa:3pfl1JY 8HOpM8J1hHbIX, HO OHO J1 Bb!3BaHO J1MeHHO He-
npaBIfJlbHbIM onpe.lJ.eJJeHJI€'M nOHHTI-!Ji 06 8KL\I'IOH€pe. OTrnK,!l.ecrBJlIilO-
ILtJ1M aKQ110Hepa C BJ1a,lIe..lJbI.!eM aKw-m He38BJ1CJIMO OT nOJ1b30BaIDfJ'l
aKql10HepHbiM npaBoM».19 YKa38HHbllf BbIBO,i:\ nO,i:\TsepJK,l:\aeTcJi J1 MHO-
I'O'nIC.JJ€HHUMH CY,/J;e6HblMlf np€LIeAeHTaMI1.
TaR, MIDrnCTepCTBO OTHOllIeHI1M MOCKOBCKOit: 06-
.n8CTIf 06paTI1JlOCb B A cy,/J; MOCKOBCKOii o6JIaCTI-! C J1CKO-
BblM 38fIBJ1emreM K DAD «Xne6» 0 nplf3H8IDfIf He.n;eiicTBJITeJIbHbIMJ1
perneHIDl BHeO'lepe,!{Horo co6paHIDI aKql10HepOB DAD «Xne6» r. Mo-
:1K8MCK OT 03.12.2000 r. J1 06H38HI1H 0"IEe'I"n1AA BHecTI-! COOTB€TCTB)'IO-
Il{IfeJ13MeHeHJ1H.KaC CTaTycaJ1CTLta.BpeeCTp
B xo.n;e cy,!\e6Horo pa36wpaTeJIbCTBa 6b1JIO ycraHOBJIeHO. 'ITO MlfHJ1C-
TepCTBO HM)'lII;ecTBeHHbIX OTHOllIeHl1M 06JIaCTM B pe3YJIb-
TaTe np CTaJlO BJI1lJIeJIbqeM 25% aK4IDi DAD «Xrre6».
paHee HaXQD;J:1Blill1XCH Y KOMIfTeT8 no yrrpaBJIeHHIO CTBOM Moc-
KOBCKOO o6JIacTH. B roomeTCTBIDI C Tpe60BaHWlMJ-l3aKOHa «06 aKl-t\.1O-
HepHbIX o J1CTeQ Hanpamrn OTBe"NIfKY ID1CbMO OT 09.11.00 r.
.NQ HC-599B, B KOTOpoM npe,!\J1OOKJ:1J1 BHeCTif COCITBeTCTBYIOILJ;He J
HIDlB peecTpaKQlfClHePOO- OraeT'llfKOM - ,lJ;epiK<lTeJ1eM peeCTpa B HaPy-
IlIeIDfe 3aKOH8 J13MeHemm: B peeCTp He BHeCeHbI, MOTIffiIf-
poBalll10e onpe,!\eneHife 06 OTKa3e so BHeceHifJ1 3anifCif ifCTIU' He
HanpaBJ1eHQ. He,lJ;aH J1MTaKmeJ1 OTBeT Ha 3anpoc 0 BhI,!\a'l€ BhIIDlClUf J13
peeCTpa HepOB 061L\€CTBa.
Cy.n;OM TaKme YCTaHOBJ1eHO, 'ITO CJ1e,i:\CTBifeM HenpaBOMepHoro6ea-
1J;ei1CTBIfH OTBeT'illKa fiBlfJIOCb HapY'-lleHl1e npaB J1CTqa, Bbrpa311B1lIee-
CH B He,/J;ony:w:eHIfIf ero npe.lJ.CTaBH'It:'JIf! K yqaCTJ1K) B pa6are BblCIlIero
opraH8 ynpaBJ1eHJ1H 06IL1eCTBa, KaKOBbIM flBJ1f1eTCH 061L\ee C06paIDf€
aKql1OHepos. IIpl1H11M1':lH EO BHI1MaHlfe. 'ITO J1CTeQ HBJIHeTCH BJI8)J;eJIb-
QeM 25<'0 8KQJ1i1 06lL\ecTBa. el'0 YQaCTl1e B 06lL\eM co6paIDfif MOrJIO 113-
MeHlfTb pe3YJIbTaTbI IUJDCOBaHMH no npl1HJITblM Ha HeM BonpocaM. B
CBH31f C 3TI-!M 'Ipe60B8HJ1H J1CTLta 6bLJD1 nOJIHOCTbKJ Y,l\OBJIeTBopeHbl
JJ;eJIO ,l\OllIJIO,i:\O tfle,l\epaJIbHoro ap6mpa)KH()ro cy,i:\a MOCROBCKOro 01{-
-12-
pyra, OJ\HaKO BbIHeceHHbIe no J\erry paHee CYJ\e6Hble aKTbI 6bLID1 OC-
TaBJ1eHbI 6e3113MeHeill'UI:, a KaccaI1UOHHaR »taJ106a OAQ «Xne6» - 6e3
YJ\OBJIeTBOpeIDUL 20
TalrnM 00pa30M. I1MeHHO 4JaKTOM BHeceHWI B peecTp aKlVloaepOB
KQHCTaTI1pyeTCfl CTaryc JtI l1MeHHO C MQMeHTa BHeCeHl-UI B
peecTp OHep q:m:06peTaeT Bce npaBa, ycTIlHOBJEIIHHt 38.KOHOM-
TeJIbCTBOM. EcJ:r11 pHoe 061lteCTBO He 38.pemcrp 1pCE<\HO B yC'ra-
HOBJ1eHHOM 3aKOHOM nopfl,lJ;KE', TO AJ1R B03H11KHOBeHJU1 aKQ110HepHom
npaBOCYIHUWtliJ -rpe6yeTCH elL\e 6oJ1ee CJiroKHbD1 co-
CTaB, 1MHii AJ1R npl106peTeHl-Ul mCTaT}'Ca He
TOJIbKO aKQ110HepaMJII, HO 11 06lltecTBOM - npox npOL\ep;ypbI ro-
cy.v;apc:'l'l!{HH1ii: pemCTp8LPDL B.lO. BrurbC}:l s Ka'l£'Crne aneMeHTOB STOm
CJ1IDK11om COCTaBa BbJ,IJ;eJIRJI CJie,JIjfKIlV1E' KpJ1,II,K'Ie(W1e q:.aKTbI: nO,!\a'la
JIJ1IUlMl1, Jtte.naIOIl!I1MJI! CTaTb 3 UlSJleHWI 0 nO)J;!IJl!CKe Ha
aKQJ1J1;npI1HHI11eSTOm33JtBJ1efll1H aKQ110-
HepHOro 06LqeCTBa a:x:mHBlill1MCH. 21
AKqI10Hep l1MeeT npaao Em BHeCeHYIe aarrncJII 0 HeM B peecTp aKW1O-
HepOB 11 O,!!,HOSpeMeHHO Hece-r no npe.tIOC'I3BJIf CB€,Qe-
HJ1f1 0 ce6e ,l\ep:/futTemo peecrpa.,lJ.Jm HJm :3Toro npaBa aK-
L1I10HepOM o6lL\ecTBo ,l\OJDKHO npe.l\llPHHHTb lIKTHBHbR? ,l\ei1:cTBJII.If -
06ecne'lJlITb BeJ\eIDfe 11 xpaHeHHe peecTpa aKL1I10Hepos 06LqeCTBa B coor-
BeTCTBID:! C npaBOBbIMJII lliITaMl1 PoccmICKcit: 4Je,Qepau;I1JlI C MOMeHTa ro-
cy,l\apc:1'B€tiHOii I o6lL\ecrna. EcJIl1 B o6lL\ecTBe 6oJ1ee 50 aK-
QIKlliepoB, TO B npaaoarnolIJ2lIl1.H Me:m,!ly 06lltecTBOM 11 em aKqI10HepoM
aBTOMa"IW-IeCIG1 BKJIIO'ffieTCH elL\e O)J;l1H yqaCTHJIIK - cneQ!1aIDf:3I1POBaH-
HaR 1.11, KOTOpaR 6Y,l\e-r 38.ID1MaTbCH Be,lJ;eIDfeM peecrpa. EcJ:rJ.1
:me 'lJ.1CJiO aKQ!fOHepoB 06LqeCTBa ,n,eifcTmrre,m,o 3lffi'lJITeJ1bHOe, TO K
yqaCTHJfKaM MOiKeT npJ.16aBJ.1TbCH eLqe J1 TpaHc4:>ep-areHT, OCYJl.\ecTBJIR-
IOIIJ;I-1f1: CBOIO ,l\emeJ1bHOCTb Ha OCHOBaHmf ,l\OroBOpa C peruC1paTOpOM.
B peeCTpe pentC"IpHPyroTC:fI BJIa,l\e.JIbQbIl1 HOMJIHa.JIbHl,Ie ,l\epmaTe-
JII1 LleHHblX 6)'Mar (n. 1 CT. B 3aKOHa «0 pblHKe LleHHbIX 6JMa1"").
l1MeHHo Ha OCHOBaHl111 ,l\aHHbIX peecTpa aKqMOHepoa 06l1\eCTBa co-
CTaBJI:fIIOTCH Cnl1CKJII JII1Q, Heo6xu,/J,J1MbIe AJI:fI oCYILIeCTBJIf'HI1H npaB,
3a.RpenJIeHHHX aKL\I1.HMJ.-I, B 'laCTHOCm, CnJ.1CKJ.1 JIJ.1Q, I1MelOlltI1X npe-
I1MYl1\eCTBeHHOe npaBO Ha npI106peTeHI1e ,l!,OIIOJ1HIITeJIbHbIX aKL\I1i111
SMI1CCJIOHHbJX QeHHbIX 6)'Mar. KOHsepmpyeMbIX s aKL,I1I1; npaso Ha
nOJ1YQeHl1e ,l\I1BJU\ S; npaBo Ha YQaCTl1e B 061lteM co6paHI111 aKL\I1-
oHepos. TaKl1M 06pa30M, CTaHOBWrCH JICHbIM 3Ha'lefll1e Tpe60saHIDI
se.v;eHI1R peecTpa aKqI10Hepos JlJIR S03MOmHOCTI1 ocywecTSJ1eHI1R aK-
QIfOHepaMl1 CBOI1X npas.
JJ;epmaTeJ1b peeCTpa aKqI10HepOB H€CeT 0'I1!eTCTB€HH0C 3a em se-
,D;eHl1e 11 XpaHeHl1e nepe,Q 38.penICTpnpoBaHHbIMI1 S HeM JIl1L\aMI1. IIpl1
-13-
:31'OM 06Il-\eCTBO, nopY'"ll'ffiwee Be,lJ;eHJ1e 11 XpaHeHMe peeCTpa aKQI1OHe-
poB 06!l,\ecTBa pernCTpaTOpy, He eTCJ1 OT 0TBe'I'C'T13eHH
38. era Be,lJ;€IDI€ J1 XpaH€HJ1€. 06Il-\€CTBO 06R3aHO :EI'OH'TpOJIJ'1Tb CO-
6mo,!\eHJ1e pernCTpaTopOM npaBI1J1 Be,!\€HJ1fI peeCTpa aKlUIDHepoB 06-
llIeCTBa, 'lT0 ,D;OJIiKHO 6brrb 3aKpenJ1eHO B 1l0rOBOpe Meml\Y 06l1leC'I13OM
J1 pi'fIICTpaTOpOM.
PaCCMO'l'pMIl'l npaBOBYlOnpl1pO.r:\YOTHowemm, CKJ1a,!\bmalOll\I1XCH no
nOBO npaBa aKltJIDH€pa Ha BHeCelD1e B peec'I'p. JJ:epmaTeJIb peeCTpa
06J133.H BHeCTYl3arrnCb 06 aKql10Hepe B peecTp B nopJ1,lJ;Ke,
peHHOM 38.KOHO.r:\aTeJ1bC'mOM. O,llHaKO :31'0 MOmeT 6b1Tb HO
TQJ1bKO B CJ1.Y'ffie aKTIlBHbIX Jl{'iiCTBHi'i CO CTOpOHbI aKql10Hepa no npe-
,u;OCTaBJ1eHlOO 0 ce6e J1H4>opMaW'lYI. OrKa3 OT BHeCeHJ1.II 38.rrncYi B pe-
€CTP aRQJlOHepOB 0611\€CTBa MomeT 6bI'I'b ofuKamBaH aKLIYIOHepoM B
cy ITo perneHJ1KJ CYM. ,u;epmaTeJIb peeCTpa 8KQJ110HepoB 06Il-\eCTBa
06J133.H BHeCTYI B yKa3aHHbD1: peecTp CoorseTCTBYKJW;YKJ 38.nWCb. RaK
B>1)J;HO, B 3TOM CJ1.Y'ffie OTHOllIeHJ1H nO)J;na,IWIO'f nO)J; onpeJ1{'JIeIDle orul3a-
TeJIbCTB8, Cct>oPMYJIHPOBaHHOe CT. 307 rK P4>. CneL{Jllcpl1K8 3.n;eCb co-
CTOWI' B TOM, 'ITO O'I'HOIlEHJlfI MOryr CJCJI())KtL!fJ' MHomecmeHHbIM
cy6'beKTIfblM COCTaBOM. B3aMMO)J;ei-kTBYle yqaCTIfillCOB
Il{J1XCJ1 OTHOllIeHI1H C'IpOWI'CJ1 no CJIO>KHGii: cxeMe, OCHOBaHHoi1: Ha CYlC-
TeMe J1X MHOfO'lliCJ1eHHbIX B3aMMHbIX npaB J1 06H:33HHfJC'Teii.
TaK, B COOTBe'fCTIJIDI C n. 6.1. ITOJImKeHJ1.R «0 B€J\eIDIYl peeCTpa BJIa-
.n;eJIbL\eB HMeHHb1X L\eHHbIX 6)'M3.r» (yrE. ITocraHOBJ:IeHYIeM 4Je,n;epaJib-
HOti KOMYlCCID1 no PblliKY L\eHHbIX6yMarOT 2 OKToopJ11997 r. NQ 27) 3a-
p€'I11CTp11pOBa1iHb1t B peecTpe JIYlQa OOJ13aHb1:
- npe,D;OCTaBJ1J1'I'b perYlC'I'paTOpy nOJ1Hb1e J1 ,lIOCTOBepHbIe ,lIaHHbI€,
He06XQW1Ml>1e AJUI O"I'Kpbrrl1H Jrnq€Bora c<t€Ta;
- npe,D;OCTaBJ1J1'I'b perl1CTpaTOPY J-IHct>oPMaI.U-UO 06 J13MeHeHYIYI ,lIaH-
HbIX, npep;ycMO'IJJ€Hli noJV1. 3.4.1 n 3.4 3'I'Ora me lIoJ1omemm:
- npe,!\OCT8BJIHTb pen:ICTpaTOpy J-IH4>opMaqwro DO oopeMeHeHYIYI
LI€HHb1X 6)'M3.r OO.ll3aTeJ1bCTBaMl-1;
- npe.r:\OCTaBJlfI'I'b pemCTpaTopY,lIOK)'MeHTbI, npep;ycMOTpEflHble yKa-
38.HHbIM IT0J10meHHeM, AJlJ1 1C1YIJJ:HeHJ1R onepaLlJIii no J1l1L\esoMY C"I€Ty;
- rapaH'1'MpOB8Tb, "TO B CJ1y<1ae nepe,D;a"M L\eHHbIX 6)'M3.r He 6y.l\Y'l'
Hap)'llIeHbI orpaHII'IeHW1, ycraHOBJJeHHble 3aKOHOJlaTeJIbCTBOM POC-
CJrlicmi'I 4:leAepaL\l'leti YlJIYI yCTaBOM 3MHTeH"Ia. HJIYI BCTyIIJIEIlDIM B 3a-
KOHH)'1O cW1)' peweHJ1eM cy,lla;
- OruraTY yCJ1yr peri1crpaTOpa B COOTBeTC'TBJlJIIcero
npeticKypaHTOM.
B CJ1.Y'ffi€ Henpe.llOCT8BJ1eHIDI aaperYlCTpYlpoBaHHb1MYI J1Y1QaMYI I-rn-
ct>oPMaQWJ1 06 J13MeHeHI1JII ,IJ;aHHbIX, npe,llJ'cMOTpeHHbIX nOJIII. 3 41 IT. 3 4
ITOJl())Kt'HJ'IH, YlJIYI npe.D;OCTaBJIeHJm J1MYI HenOJ1Hoii J1JIH He.I\OCToBeptroii
J1H4>oPMaL\ID1 06 113MeHeHJU:! )'Ka3aHHbIX ,lJ;aHHbIX perllCTpaTop He He-
ceT O'I'I3eTCTBt'lllIOC'nf 3a I1pJ1'lIrneHHble B CBR3'" C :;yr"'M y6bITKl1. Ha OC-
HOBaHl1H 3aROHa «06 BKLI"OHepHbIX 06!l,\ecTBax» He HeceT y6bITKl1 11
OOIlt€CTBO (n. 5 CT. 44).
PerI1cTpaTOp B COOTBe'I'C1'BID C pa3J1. 5 BblllI€)'Ka3aHHoro IIonome-
HI1H TaKme HeceT nepeA :ilMWTelITOM 11 3aperMCTpllpOBaHHbIM JIHIWM
MRX'O'aIC.T:I€IIHbIe OOR3a1lHOCTI-f.
B'illCTIIDC'l'l'1. pemCtpaTOp oOR3aH:
- oCYlL\€CTBJl./ITb OTKpbITH€ JlYlQeBbIX Cq€TOB 11 I1CI1OJIHJITb on€pa-
1\1-1'" nOJl"'QeBbIM Cq€TaM B nopR,ZU(€ 11 CPOKYI, lllIble)'Ka-
3aHHblMlIo.nc:JmelD1€M,
- npe.n;oCT3.BJl./ITb J1H4xJpMaL\lOO 113 peecTpa B nopH,!\Ke. YCTaHOB-
JI€lllIOM II()J1I'J)K€ffi(€M;
- B TeqeHYle BpeMeHI1. YCTaHOBJJeHHOrO npaBnnat.U1 Be,l:\€HI'IfI peeCT-
pa, HO He MeHee -qeM 4 -qaca Kajf(,JJ;brn pa60'1ID1 AeHb He.LJ;enYi (BKJilC)qa.fl
06ocofirreHHble IIOAPa:3,l:\enelDlR perm:rpaTopa) o6ecne<ltmaTb 3MHTeH-
TY. saperitCTpl'1POBaHHbIM JlYlQ3.M, ynOJIHOMOqellllblM npe.n;cTaBHT€lliIM
B03M())KH()CTh €tDIfI pacnOpR:>KeHID111 nO.11y'IeHJ1R J1H4>op-
MB.l\ID'! 113 peeCTpa;
- IIO pacnopRiKeHJOO 3MJITeHT3. 11JI"'.1IYIL\, l1MelOlL\YIX Ha 3T0 npaBO B
OOO"IBE'TCTBIDI C saKoHo.n;aTeJIbCTBOM PoccH:i1cKoif 4'e.n;epaQM"', npeAO-
C'1'aBJIJITb 11M CIll1COK.mm. IlMeKIlII1X npaBo Ha yqaCTI1e B o6weM c06pa-
HI1Y1 aKQMOHepOB;
-11H4>oPMHpOBaTb 3apel1lCTpl1JJOBBHHbIX .JillQ no I1X saIIpOcaM 0
npaBax, 3aKpen.rreHHbIX 1\eHHbIMY! 6YMaraMJ1, 11 0 cnoco6ax 11 nOpH,!J;Ke
ocyII-\eCTBJ!€IllU1 3= npas 11 T-lJ.
BBI1,!Iy Ba:IKHOCTY! paCCMa"IpYIBaeMbIX OTIIDllleHlnt: AJlH Q:lymI'1U'XlliIl-
poBaIDIH OOllteCTBa '" ocyIU€C'IBJI€1n1R npaB aK1VXiHepOB 3a HapyweID1R
B 3TOti c4;Jepe npep;ycMOTpeHa ,rw.mE' aAMJ:nD1CTp3.TImHa.!i OTBeTCTSeH-
HOCTb. RO.n;eKCOM PocCl£iiCKOii 4lep;epaQIDl 06 B,AMI1HYI-
CTpaTYlBHbIX npaBOHapyweID1RX OT 30 .n;eKaOpH 2001 r. NQ 195- (.n;a-
Jlee - RoAII PCP). TaR, CT 15.22 RoAII PCP YCTaIJaBJ1"'BaeT
OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb sa HapyweHl1e npaBI1JI Be.n;eHl1H peecTpa BJIa)J;eJ1bQeB
1\€HJlbIX 6)'Mar. CT. 15.23 - 3a }'RJJJHelDle OT nepe.n;a..", pemcrpaTOpy B€-
AeID1R peeCTpa IIJ13A€J1bl\€B L\eHHbIX o)'Mar.
TaKI1M 00pa30M, AJlH ocyw;eCTBJ1eHIDI npaB 8.KL\YIOHepy COBepweHHO
He HymHO npe,!J;"bRBlliITb 1\€HH)'1O 6)'Mary, ,lIOCTaTO'-IHO J1"'Wb era JUJ;eH-
TI1Q:1Y11ffiL\l1Y1 no peecrpy aKlU>-IOH€POB. CXO;:J;Hb!e BbIBO.n;b! 6b!.ID1 c.n;eJIaHbI
MM. ArapKOBblM. «B 'I'eX CJIy'IaRX, KOf.r:\a HI1e npaBa no
HMel1U'Jti 6}'MareHe Be,lleTIDI KIIOJlHOMY. HI1 K 'laC'IWlHOMY IIoraW€m-no
npaBa. OHO MOJKeT l1MeTb MecTO 6e3 IIpe,l:t"bHBJI€IDm Kajf(,JJ;brn pa3 caMoti
6yMam. TaK, npl1 OC)'lL\€CTBJI€HID1 aKL\YIOHepoM, BJIa.LJ;eIOlW'IM l1MeHHoti
-15-
aKql1eH, npaBa y<1aCTI:!JI B 06Il\eM co6paHml aKql10HepC)B HeT H8.)\oOHO-
CTI1 B npep;"bflSnemrn aKQl1l1. 3am1Cb B aKQl10HepHOM KID1re .f1SJUleTCfl
AOCTaTOtlHoi1 ne ii .n B TeX CJIy'ffiJIX, RorAB- :<11'0 Tpe6yeTCfl
ycraBOM. npe,1J;"bflBneHl1e 8KL\l1J1 npl«)6pera.TeJleM AOn*HO 6b1Tb C):\ena-
HO 3a Onpe,1J;eneHHbrn cpOK l1.0 06Il\ero co6paHl1JI».22
II. ITI1CeMcKl1i1 TaKme OTMe<ffiJI, 'ITO «,l\JIJI nOHJITl1JI 06 axqIWHeJIlOU
KOMllaHJ.1l1 Bosce He C)'1U€CTB€HHO, 'Ir06bI KOMI1aI1JL'I BbII1}'CF.<\J1a AOKY-
MeHTbl; npaBO YtlaCTl1JI MomeT l1.0Ka3bmaTbCfl 3a1llfCKOlOJ1MeIDI 8KL\l10-
Hepa B KHwrax KOMll3.IDII1, r,/J;e 11 OTMe'IalOTCR Bce nepeXO,/J;bl npasa».23
IIon)"-JeHHHii BWBOA TeM 60nee no;rrSepm,IlaeT, 'I1'O OTHOwelU1R,
eMeaQIy J1aKQl10HepaMJ-f,nOpo lOTcRyme
OlllfcaHHbIM BblWe CJI0*HblM IOpl1,lJ;W-leCKJ1M COCTaBOM.
HeB03MO.mHO COrJ1aCl1TbCR C MHeHJ1eM o.B. Eenoycosa, Koropblii
C'lJlITaeT, 'lT0 'IJIeHCTBO B 8Kl1110HepHOM OOIQecrBe B03Hl1KtleT y yqpe-
W1TeJUI J13 ycraBa npYl ycJIOBIlH nO,/J;l1J1CKI1 Ha 8K1.\I1I1 J1 'IaCTWlHorosHe-
ceHl1R BKJIa)W B ycTIlBHHJl KaIDITaJI 06IQeCTBa B nopJI,!J;Ke, ycraHOBJIeH-
HOM YCTaBoM 06meCTBa. ]1,0 pen1CTpaL{IDI aK J10Hep, HBJlRRCb qneHOM
aKL\l10HepHoro 06mecTBa, snpase yCTyTII1Tb 'iJleHCTBO (a CJle,D;OBaTeJlb-
HO, J1 CBOM qneHCKJ1e npaBa) ,l\pyroMY.ID-Il\)', nOCKOJlbKY 'iJleHCTBO B aK-
QMOHepHOM 06meCTBe B03Hill\3.eT BCJIe,l\CTBn€ era npl1V6p€T€H1lR, a HE'
BCJleACTBMe pen1CTp8l.II1K. ITo MHeIDIIO aBTopa, pacnopIDKeHJ1:e 'iJleH-
CKJ1Ml1 npaBaMJ-f He 3aBI1CIIT OT perI1C'1'paqm:r, 8 BOT peaJill31lql1JI 'iJleH-
CKID:: npaB CTaBI1TCR B 3aBJ1CJ1MOCTb OT BHeCeHlIR B peeCTp aKQMOHepoB
He06XO,l\11Mb1X 3alllfceti 0 npl106peTemm aKql10HepoM 'iJleHC'I'Ba B ,l\aH-
HOM 8KL\l10HepHOM 06meCTBe.24
B CBfl311 co C):\eJIaHHbIM BblBO,D;OM 0 CJIOmHOM q>aKTWleCKOM COCTaBe,
nOp lOIl\eM KOMlLJleKC npaB aKl.\110Hepa, 13fJ3HJ1Iffi.€T CJIeJIYIOII!IDI
BOnpoc: nOCKOJlbKY peecTp Be,D;eTCR TOJ:lbKO AJ1R BJIa,D;eJlb eB J1MeHHblX
aKql1M, TOBJIaAe 18K 11ff Ha npe,I\"b$IBl1TeJU1 Heo6n8.)\alOTKOMI1JleK-
COM npaB aKLpKlliepa?
OrseT Ha IJ'JC'TaBJ1€1JI BOnpoc CO,D;epmwrCR B caMOM onpe,1J;eJ:le-
m-m aK IDj Ha npe,I\"bJIBl1Tenfl. 3MHcclfOHHbl€ qeHHbIe 6yMarl1 Ha
npe.IJ:bHBIlT€JlR - qeHHble 6yMam, nepexo.n; npaB Ha KOTopble J1 ocYIl\e-
CTBJ1€HJ1€ 3aKpellJIeHHblX J1MJ1 npas He Tpe6ylOT 1KalU1l1 Bna-
l1.eJlbQa (CT. 2 3alwHa ({a pblllKe qeHHb1X 6yMar»).
05menpuHRTbJlIII flBJ:lHeTCfI pa3,/J;eJIetme aKQHii Ha J1M€HHwe J1
np ITo MHeHl110 J1.T. Tapacosa, TO rnotiCTBO MMeHHoA
aKWUl, 'lT0 OHa MOJKeT 6b1Tb 0T'1yJK,QaeMa TOJibKO nocpe.n;CTBOM yKa3a-
HWI B perJ1CTpe KOMnallJoDI Ha npol13se,/J;€HHoe OT'Iym,IleWle C 3aHeCeHJ1-
eMJ1MeHHHoBoro BJIa)\eJlb a B pen1CTp "J\OTOro CTBeHHJ, "ITO, coo-
CTBeHHO rOBOpR, Ha HeM TOJIbKO J1 OCHOBaHO Bce pa3JIwrne MeaQIy
J1MeHHblMJ1 J1 npe.tl,'bHBJrreJrbCKJlMH aRQIlHMJl, TaR 'iTO I1MeHHbIe aKQJ1l1,
-16-
eCJIJ1 TOJIbKO OHM OT"Y aeMbI 6e3 IH nOCpeACTBOM I1pOCTOfi
finam«mojij: Ha,JJ')1IfCII, TepJllOT CBoe 3Haqem-le KaK J-IMeHHbIX aKQWA, XOTE
6bI Ha ID-IX 6bIJIa C)\e.mma Ha.n;rnlCb J-IMeIDI B.II1l)J;eJIbQa I-IX, H OIm no 06pa-
lJ.IaeMOCTH cBOeA Moryr6bITb TOfAa, npUpaBHeHbI K npe,!J;'bRBHTeJ1bCKJ'IM
a.KLtJUIM, KaK 3T0 J-I BUJVIO 1-13 npaKTI-IKJ-I aKQWOHepHoro Aena».25
AKQID:r Ha npe,qhflBWTeJIJlHe COOTBeTCTBYJOT aKQWOHep-
Horo 06lJ.!€'C'I'Ba B TOM BJoU\e KaK OHa nOHI-IMaeTCR COBpeMeHHbIM 3aIWHO-
Aa,TeneM, IIOCI«JJ1bEY He n03B0JIJ1lO1' M,!\e 1JX'EClTb cBOero BJIa-
,IJ;eJIbL\a J-IHaqe, KaK no npe,!J;'b.HBJIeHID1 AOKyMeHTapHoi1: qeHHoi1: 6)'M3.rn.
B 3aEpbITlDC 8K1U1OHepHbIX I-IX SMJ1CCW! Bo06Ilte HeB03-
McmaIa, TaK KaK npcmrnope'IJ-IT npillll.\11IIY 06ecne'-!eHW! mpaHI-I'-!€HHO-
ro J-I1f36paHHoro COCT8sa aKW'IOHepOB 3aKpbrroro AKQJ-IJ1 Ha
npe,!J;'b.HBJ1TeJIJI so Bcex CJIY'ffiRX OCJIOmHRlOI' AeHTeJ1bHOCTb 06ll1ecTBa,
KOTOpoe BblH)'iK.l\eHO BbmyCAATb J-IX CepTYIq:mKaTbI, 3aOOrnTbCJI 0 3a-
lLWl're J-IX OT KpOMe TOro, .AJIJ'I TalU1X aKi.\IDI npe,!J;ycMOTpeH
C1l nopH,1\OK BOCcr8HOBJIeHIDI npaB IIO ID1M B CJIY'ffie I-IX yr-
paTbI
3aKOH «06 aKLti'lOHepHbIX 06lL\ecTsax» CIl nO,IJ;'-!epIU-lBaeT,
'1TO Bee aKqIH-I 8KQJ-IOHepHOfO 061L\eCTBa EBJIIDOTCR l1MeHHbIMM (n. 2
CT. 25) XOTE3aKOH ,,0 pbIHKe qeHHbIX GyMar» J-I cO,LIep)f\JiIT B CT. 16 no-
JImKeIrne 0 TOM, '1TO SIWICClI(EIJl,J{' qeHHbIe 6YMarn, K KOTOpbIM OTHO-
CRTCH J-I 8KQJ-IYI, Moryr 6bITb HMetfHbIMM J-IJI}'[ Ha rrp€JJ:bHBIITeJIH, HO B
CT. 2 npHMo )'Ra3aHO, 'ITO aKQJ-IH HSJIJ1eTCH J-IMeHHoiil LjeHHoiil 6)'Maroiil.
Jt1MeHHofi qeHHoi1: 6YMaroiil HBJIHeTCH T8IOKe J-I 0IIL\HOH ::tMHTeHTa.
llpe,n:bHBIITeJIbCKl'l€ aKqI-rn cyr.u;ecTBYJOT sa py6e)K()M. HO He B POCCIDI,
J-I m.mycKaIOTCH B AOK)'MeHI'apHoi1: q:.opMe,
OrcyrCTBHe ,l\OK)'MeHTa qeHHoiil 6)'Man-l xapaKTepHO,lJ;JlH 6e3,L10KY-
MeHI'apHOA q:.OPMbI 6)'Mar. Be3,z:pK}'M€HTapHaJl clxJPMa ::tIWICCHOHHbIX
qeHHbIX 6)'Mar - 3TO TaKaJl q:.opMa SMItCClf()IlHbIX qeHHbIX 6)'Mar, npH
KOTOpofi BJ1a)J;eJIeLj YCTaHaBJIl-IBaeTCH Ha OCHosam'!M 3aIrnCH B CHCTeMe
BeAeHW! peeCTpa B.II1l)J;eJIbJ.t qeHHbIX6YMarJ-lJIJ1, B CJIY'ffie lt€mHHpO-
BaHHR LjeHHbIX 6)'Mar, HaOCHosamm 3aTIJ1CJ1 no C'-!eTY ,l\eno (CT. 2 3aKO-
Ha ({OpbIHKe LjeHHbIX 6)'Mar»).
CaMa l1,!\eJlOB03MCOKHOCTJII €ffi-I.fInpas, YJ1OC'I'OO€PH€Mb
qeHHoiil 6}'MID'Oii, 6e3 npeA"bSIBJI€ffi'1H nOCJIe,l\Hei1:, 'lTO II03B0J11-1J10 roBO-
pl1Tb 0 6e3)JPKYMeHTapHbIX LleHHbIX 6)'M3.rax, 6bIJIa 3amVICIECEaHa J-I3
amnIDicKoro J-I aMepl-lKaHcKOro 3aKO TeJ1bCTB, KOTOpbIMJ-I 3aKpen-
.neH oco6bIli ctiop:mn,ni ,IJ;OK)'MeHT - negotiable instrument.
IIpasAa" OT 11CIIO.JIb3OBaIDUI TaKora 3aYIMCTBOBaHIVI npe,!J;ocT€pera.n
elL\e MM. ArapKOB, mlCaBUIJ.1A, 'ITO nOHHTHe o60poTHoro ,l\OK)'MeHTa
"no He MOiK€T 6bITb ItCIIO.Jib3(E;).HO IIpI-I ,IJ;OrMaTII'I€CI«)II pa3pa601'Ke KOH-
TilJHeHTa.1llflOro esponeiilCKora npasa. a TaIOKe 11 COB€'rCKUrO npasa».26
ITo MHeHillO .n;.B. IHa, 6e3J\OK)'MeHrnpHble L{eHHbIe 6yMan1
CJ1e,rr;yeT AamE' paCCMaTpill>aTb B Ka'leCTBe HOBOro npaBoBoro UHCTIny-
TII, nOCIWJ1bRY He cy:Il\eCTByeT OCHOBamrn: J1CIIOJIb30BaTb AM 0603Ha-
'Iem1F! mBOti: clxJPMbl 4>J1KCaLl"J1 npaBaK1U10HepOB ,lIaBHOCJI().)KJ(Blll€ro-
CJ1 npaBOBCI'O t1HCT£fTYTa l\ellllbIX 6ytlffir_ fuR yme OTMe'iaJ10Cb, OH
C'lJITaeT, 'ITO B aKl\11Ol«'PHbIX TBaX, r,n;e OTcyTCTBYeT :ilM£fCCI1J1
060c06.neHHbDl: AOKYMeHTOB, 06 aKLti'I.IIX HeJ1b3F! roBOpl1Tb KaK 0 6e3.DP-
KYMeHTapHbDl: L{eHHbDl: 6ytlffirax. 27
RA CyxaHOB C'Im'ae-r, 'ITO Ha 6e3)JPKYMeHTapHble 8KW1I1 He Moryr
nepeHOCJ1TbCJ1 CBOiicTBa Bell.leti:, TaKJ1e aKLIJ1J1 He Moryr f!BJIHTbCF! 060-
eKTaM£f BeIIVIoro npasa, a f!BJ1moTCJ1 JIillllb oc05blM cnoc050M 4>J1KCa-
L{I1I1 npaB aK1U10H€pos. K TaKOW «6e36yMfutuo1» 4>oPMe 4>J1KCaL{l1J1
npaB Moryr, no era MH€HI1JO, npJ1MeHHTbCF! HeKOTOpble npaBJ1J1a 0 l\eH-
HbIX 6ytlffirax, ec.ID1 31'0 He npDTl1Bopeqi1T cYII-\ecTBY JJ;eJ18; npl1paBHI1-
BaTh «3aID1Cb Ha C'IeTe» K qeHHow 6y-M3.re WIJ1 TeM 6cJJIee OTO:)K,D;eCTB-
.JIRTb me: npaBOBOii p€'JKI1M H€B03MmKHO. 2B ,lJ;yMaeTCH, 'ITO C aBTopoM
CJ1e,rr;yeTCOrJI8CJ1TbCHBTOM, 'ITOL{eHHble 5)'MarJ1B pHoi1
4>oPMeJJ; J1MeIOT3H3.qjrreJibHbIeOTJIJ1'1VUIOT6YMar AOKY-
MeHTapHbIX J1 He Bce II1JJX»K€IDffi rp aHCKOro Ko.n;eKca P4>, npl1Me-
HHeMble K I1OCJIeJJ;HIlM, 11'10*"0 paCIIpoc-rp8Hm'b J1 H8 6e3.n;OKYMeHTap-
Hble 6)'Marn.
Cne)IyeT UfMeTJ1Tb, 'ITO XOTH npaBOBoi1 pe:lKJ1M )'Ka38HHoff clxJPMbl
qeHHbIX 6ytlffir J1 J1MeeT CBOI1 CIJeqi(cpl'lecKJ1€ 0c06ellllOCTI1, 'reM He Me-
Hee, cyIllI2C1BCE8IDl€ Taroi1 clxJPMbl BIIOJIHe eCTeCTBeHlIO J1 06YCJIoBJIeHo
'reM 4>a=M, 'ITO caMO no ce6e IIImo6peTeHJ1e aKqIrn ell.le He n03BOJIHeT
OCYII-IE'CTBJ1J1Tb Bce npasa yqacrH11Ka 06l1\ecTBa J1 npe,!\"bJ1BJ1eIille aKqI-fi1
He"Ipe6yeTcH AJIH lIJ1H ero IIpaB. llMeHHO}ffi fJ(H1)BaID[1l3a-
I1J1CJ1 B CJ1CTeMe se,n;elD1J1 peeCTpa BJIa.n;eJ1bLJ;eB qeHHbDl: 6ytlffir J1J1J1, B
CJ1yqa€ J1€IIOIDIp(E3HUJ1 qeHHblX 6yMar,}ffi fJ(H1)BaID[1l3aID1CJ1 no C'Ie-r;'y"
AeliO ycraHaBJIMBaeTCH ee BJIa.n;eJ1en; J1 o&beM em IIpaB. Ei..qe Ii1T. Tapa-
COB C'IJ1TaJI, 'ITO BnOJIHe ycneWHo «caMa BbI,!J;a'Ia J1MeHHbDl: aIaUrli: Morm
5bI6bITb 3aMeHeHa pen w.29KpoMeToro, J1CIJOJIb3CI3aIDI€Taroi1
clxJPMb14moc'awm: npaB8K1U10HepoB yJJ;06HO XOTH 5bI IICrroM)', 'ITO 06lL\e-
cmyHeTpeoye-rCH AoporoCTOH1lfjl1Onpon;e YBbUlYCKa
CepTJ1<tnmaTOB aKn;I-rl1:. 3'rnM J1 o&1.HcHHeTCH TOT T, 'ITO nO,llaBJlHlO-
lL\ee f'ioJIHm1HCTBO pOCOrlicro1X aKL[IlUHf'pHbIX 06lL\eCTB 3M11TwpyIOT 8K-
J.tI-U1l1MeHHO B 6e3J:\oKyMeHTapHoA 4>oPMe,
3aKOHOM «05 8K1U10HepHbIX O6lLleCTB8X» npep;ycMO'IJJ€H JJ;Be KaTe-
ropID1 rlt:- J1np1llJmenIp.::eaHJlbr. BocHoaearnece-
HJ1H aIaUrli: K onpe,n;eJIelllloi1 KaTeropMJ1 J1.JIJ1 Ti1IIY ne:lKI1T 06III;I1i1 Om.eM
npaB, 3aKpeII.IDI€MbIX 3TI1J\rn 8K1U1HM>1. !uauDiepHO€ 061L\€C'fBO 06H3a-
'reJIbHOAOJDiUjO 3MJ1TJ1pOBaTb aKL[I1I1 J1 He OO.ll3aHO3MJ1-
-18-
TI1pOBaTb . HOMJ1HaJIbHaHCTOMMOCTb BC€X 06b1KHo-
BE'HHhIXClRqlnio5.u.tecTBa Ao..nmHa 6blTbOAJ KpaMeTOrO, Bcoor-
BeTCTBID1 C IL 1 CT. 31 3aKOHa «05 aKqJ:o:ntepHbIX OOll\ecTBaX» Kam;!\aJI
o6UKHoBeHHa.R aKW1H 06ll\eCTBa npe.z1PC'1'<IBJ aKqJ:DJePY - ee BJla-
AeJTh'-\Y - o6"beMnpaB.1133TOroCJJe;:ryeT, 'fTO nopoccillicKO-
MY 38.KOHQ!\8.TE'JIbCTBY 06ll\eCTBO He MC»KeT m.mycx,aTb OObJF:HOBeHHble
aKqJ:fJ1 pa3JlWIHbIX TJ1fiOB, B TO BpeW! KaK 3aKOH npeiJYCMa'IpJ1BaeT 003-
MroKHOCTb pa3Mell\eHWIHecKOJIbKMX TJ1I10B aKWrl1
(n. 2 CT. 25 3aKOHa «05 8 OHepHbIX OOll.,=CTBa:'!: ). 3a py6ejf(()M B03-
MroKHO OOI.J.\eCTBaMJ1 aKLtJ1jj:, 3aKpeI1JHOO-
J.ltIDC pa3J1l1'lHhlM 06"beM npaB aK.L\I10HepclB. J1CXOAfl J13 3'I'Oro, )'Ka3cullible
CIRqI1J1MOOt\HO Ha re: traKl1e,KO-
TOpble He AalOT npasa ronoca, HO npl1 3'I'OM Bce HHb1e npasa
aKqIo:ntep<E COxpaHmOTCH); (Aroolll;I1e IIpaBO l'OJIOca, HO B
M€HbIlEH: CTeneHJ1 B pacqeTe Ha O aKW-OO, 'feM BbIII)'llIeHHble 'reM :IKe
06ll\ecTBOM aKQl1J1 AJ>YrOro TIma), C oIp8.HW'leHHbIM npaBOM I'OJIOca (Bbl-
nyCKaeMb!e C OIp8.HW'leHJ1eM 'iI1CJIa Aep:?KaTened:, MOryrn;I1X I'OJIOCOBaTb).
- 06bIKH011eHHb1:X OOll\eCTBa Moryr
Y"IaCTBOBaTb B 06w;eM cof1JaHIDI a OHepoB c npaBOM roJIoca no BceM
BOnpocaM era KOMIIeTeHqIDl, a TatoKe HMelOT IIpaBO Ha nonyqeHJ1e ,1I;rnm-
AeH,!\OB, a B CJJ.)"ffie .JIMKBU.!IaQID:! OOll\eCTBa - npcmo Ha nOJlY"leID1e 'faCTI1
ero l1M)'I1J;eCTBa (n. 2 CT. 313aKoHa «06 aKl{IKlliepHbIX 06w;ecTBax ).
TaKI1M oOpa30M, 3aIOCEQl:I8TeJThHO 3aKpE'11JI€HbI TpJ1 npaBa 8KlU10He-
paR: npaBO Ha y<m.CTl1e B 06w;eM c06pam.fi1 C npaBOM 1'OJI0ca nOBceM BO-
IIpocaM era RDMIIe"I'€tfWnt; IIpaBO Ha II1J.JI)'geHHe ,l{I1Bl1,!\eH)J;OB; npaBO Ha
no.rryqeID1e 'faCTI'! eCTBa o6mec"ma B CJJyqaeero
IIymcT 3TOH:IKe CT. 31 HanpaBJleH Ha coxpaHeHJ1e CTaTyca aK4I1OHe-
pOB - BJ1a.I\ 06bIKHOBeHHbIX aKWrl1 J1 pa3Mepa YCTaBHoro KanJ1-
TaJJa 06ll-\ecTBa: KOHBepTa HbIX aKlU1H B npHBWlen-ipo-
BaHHble aKqID1, o6=aqI111 J1 J1Hb!e qeHHhle 6yMarl1 He AorryCKaeTCH
B rooTBeTC'I'BWI CO CT. 32 3alwHa «05 B.KLUfOHepHbIX OOw;eCTBax»
B.KqI10Hepbl - BJlap;eJIbqbI I1pHBI-fJI€rnpcmaHHbIX aKWrl1 06ll-\ecTBa He
J1MeKrr npaBa l'OJIoca H3. 06ll\eM c06paID111 aKWIoHepaB 3a J1cKJIlOqeID1-
eM CJJyqaeB, Iwr,lla Ha c06paID111 pewalOTCR Bonpocbl 0 peOpraHl-f3aql1H
J1 J1I1KBI1AaqI111 06ll-\ecTBa. BHeCeHl1l1 B YCTaB J13MeHeHJ1H J1 JIOII(IJ1HeIDrii,
orpaHWIJ1BaIOll\Wx npaBa 3T11X 8.Kl<J10Hep0B. KpoMe TOro,
npl1BWIerupoaaHHbIX 8KqI1ff I1MelOT npaBo Ha no.rryqeID1e ,lJ;I1Bl-'l,!\eH,!\a H,
KaK npaBI1JIO, JlI1KBI>-I,!\3QJ10HHOH C'"IU1MOCTi'1.
B yCTaBe AOJl*HbI 6blTb onpeAeJ1eHbI pa3Mep ,l{I1BI1AeH,D;a
H (J1JII1) CTOI1MOCTb, Bb!ILTla'fl-fBaeMaH npH J1KKBJ1,ZI,aLlJ1JI 06ll-\ecTBa (JlI1K-
B!1MWIOHHaH CTOI1MOCTb) no IIpJ1BlfJlem:poB8HHbIM 8KWUIM Ka:!K)\oro
TI1l1a Pa3Mep.Al1BJ1.Lle a 11 JIUKBJIlIaQJ10HHaH CTOHMOCTb onpeAeJiHIOT-
-19-
CHBTBep)J;oti)J;eHeJiCHotiCYMMel1JD1B K CTO-
11M0CT np am.p:1ii Pa3Mep )J;l1B 1JJ;eHM 11 JU1KBIJ,JIa-
QWmlHaHCTOIlMOCTbno aKl\IDIMTaIOKE'=TalOT-
CH onpe)J;eneHHblM , eCmI ycTaBOM 0611teCTBa ycTcIHOBJK'H nOpR,!\OK I1X
onpe,!\eJIeH11.11. npl1B1UIerl1posallllbIX a rii. no KOTOpbIM:
He OIIpe,!\eJIeH pa3Mep , l1MelOT npaBO Ha IIfJJIy<leHUe JlMBI1-
;n;eH,!\OB HapaBHe C BJIa.I\eJ1b1 MU oObIKHOBeHHbIX a lii (n. 2 CT. 32 3a-
KOHa «05 am.p:f(EepHbIX o611tecTBaX» ).
IIpnswIernpoB3.HHbIllrn 8KqV111 Ha3bIB8.IOTCH noTOM)'. 'ITO YCTaBoM
0611teCTBa,l\J1H J1X BJ1a.lI€.I1bLI€B YCTaHaBJmBalOTCf! CI1p€ bIe np -
m1J1erl1l1no CpaBlIemDOC 18K flMI1. TaR, n03TI1M aK-
LlHHM Moryr YCTaHaSJrnBaTbCH nOBbIWellllbIti pa3Mep JlMBl1)J;e a, B03-
MomHOCTb npl100peTeHIDI rre.11bHO pa3M€W,aeMHX aRLtI1ti J1
,u;pyr e ycnOBIDI. KpOMe roro, BCOO'I'Be'I'CTBMI CO CT. 23 3aKOHa «05 aK-
LlHOHepHbIX 0611teCTBax» onpe,lJ;eJIeHHaH yCT8BOM JII1KBI1.A3J.I OHHaR
CTOI1MOCTb no IIpI1BI1JIeOIpOBaHHblM aKqJ1HM BbIIIJIa'<ll1saeTCH nepe,lJ;
pacnpeJJ;eJIeH11eM JIIM)lll\ecrea JIJIIKBIl.D:IfPYeMoro 8K oHepHOro oOIQe-
CTBa Mem;Jy BJla;J;eJlb$MI1 OOuKHoeeHHb!X aKW1i1.
HOMl1HaJIbHaJI crOI1MOCTb pa3Mell\eHHbIX IIJWIBI aK-
QI1i1 He JJ;D.lDKHa npesbII1IaTb 2560 or YCTaBHoro KBIII1TaJIa oOll\eCTBa. 3m
HopMa, KaK cosepllIellllO sepHO YK1I-3hIBa1OT B.Il M03OJII1HJf A.ll lO,!\eH-
KOB, HaIIpaBJIeHa Ha e no.rryqeH11H .wml1,!\e OB co6CTBeHHl1-
KaMl1 o6bIKHOB€HHb!X aKQJ1:ti JII npemrrCTsyeT B03HJIKHOB€HdKJ TaROti CI1-
TyaqwH, np H'OTOp<D MeHhllll1HCTBO B.IIaJIeJIhu;eB 06bIKHOBeHHbIX aKW1i1
ynpaBJIHJIO 6bI ycraBHbIti RaIIl1TaJI KOTOporo 6bLJJ c<lx:JpMl1-
poBaH Jf3 HOMHHa.11bI1Ofl CTOillJlOCTI1 npmlllJIerupDBaHHbIX aKlU-'Iff. BJIa-
,!J;eJIbIJ;bI KaropbIX no oOil\eMY npaB>fJIY He 06.rra;:IP1OT npaBOM ronoca Ha
06il\eM C06PaHJ111 aKlU1OH€JXtB. 30
JLB. JIOMaKJ.m BbI,lJ;BI1HYJ1 n0311IJ;M1O, '1TO IIpJilBl'JJJ€-
n:IpDBaHHblX aKu;J1ti He COOTBeTCTByeT 8KqV10HepHOti $JpMe npeJIIIPI1-
H11MaTeJIbCKOA ,JJ;eHTeJIbHOCTI1. Ecn 6bI Bce aK1U61, BbUlYCRaeMbie 3MI1-
TeHTOM. 6bLJJt1 nplmll.llen:1pOsaHHbIMt1, TO 3Mt1TeHT nepeCTan 6bI
Tb RaK aKQJIOHt:'pHO€' 06Il\eCTBO B Tp8.D.JIWIUHH1M no-
H11MaHJ1t1 3TOra TepMi1Ha. Bna;J;eneU; 06uJw0BeHlJl,l"( aKW1i1 .fIBJI.I1eTCfl
'lJ1eHOM aK oHepHoro oOIl\€CTBa. a BJ1a;J;eJIeq np:wm1J1€I1fpDBaHHblX
aKLtI1W - ero KpeAl1TOpOM. 31
,lIyMaeTCH see.me, '1TO (YI'J1WU1e Mem;Iy Kpe,!\J.1TOpoM J1
I1pJIIBIIJI€I'JHHh!X aKW1i1 MOiKHO npoB€CTI1 no KpvtT€pl1K1 B03BpaT-
Hocnl npe,!J;ocTaBJIHeMbIX B 3aeM cpe,!\CTB. Bmu:I€JIbQ8M IIpI1Bl1JIerI1pO-
BaHHbIX aKu;J1ti, B OTnl1'rne OT Kpe.llIITOpOB, 06il\eCTBO He B03Bpaw.aeT
J1X BKJIa;J;bI B OllJIaTY aKqI1ti. OHJl! COCTaBJIIDOT yc"I8BHbIti Rant1TaJl 06-
ll\eCTBa, a He 3aelllHl>llt. RaK OTM€'iaeT JII caM aBTOp H3JI())Kftrnoti ro'lKI1
-20-
3peHIDl. BJIaJ\eJIbQbI IIpl1Bl'LlIerI1pOBaHHb1X aKWrli TaJOKe aKQJIIOHepbI
06!l,\ecTBa, HO l1MelOIqWe yceqeHHbIMIWMTIJ1eKC npaB no cpaBHeH1110 C
qaMJ:1 8KqHti.
IIpl1BJUIerJ1pOBaHHble aKLI111--1 B POCCI1I--1 noJ1Y'D'I.ID1 3aKOHO,!\aTeJIbHOe
3aKpeIlJ1eHl--le ropa3,!\0 n03mE', 'leM 06b1KHOSeHHble. .lI.o peIlO.J1lOLllII--I. no
CBI'J)Ie"I'eJIby IlA Py,wIesa. pyCCKOe 3aKOHO,!\aTeJIbCTBO «B 06IqID(
IDJ1())1{('HHHX He 3HaJ10 npl--lSHJ1ernpOSaHHbIX aKWrli. XOT.fI B OT,lJ;eJ1bHbIX
aKqHOH€pHbIX ycrasax 3TOT BI1J1 al\.L\Mti np€J:\YCMaTJMB<UIC5V-. 32
no C!lOC06Y 00pa30B3.HI1.FI al\.L\MM MOryr 6b1Tb eneHb1 H8 IIpH-
Mble - Te, 3a KOTopbIe BHeceH "nl1 J1M)'1U€CTB€HHl>IA. BKJ18J1
,lJ;epmaTeJLflMM, "06paTHble - OIIJ1aTa KOTOpbIX 6blJ1a npoIf3B€11€Ha B pe-
3ynbTaTe pacnpt:' 'IaCTYI MM)'1LIeCTB8, 1lpJffu.um, 8.MopTnaaWIYI
JfJ11--1 ,lIpyrl1X clxJH,!\OS Mem;:Iy J1X C03,!\aTeJLflMI--I" H8J1enemUl I1OC.T.I€,D.HI-IX
CTaTYcoM aKqYIOHepoB. IIo CH IIpaKTI1K€ OOpaTHble 3.KqY!YI
3aKpeIIJ1H1OT 3a HX ,IJ;ep::teaTe.T1.llMYI YC€'leHHbIti 06'beM IIpaB B 'l8CTYI no-
.nyqeHHH J1MYII-\eCTB8 06l1\€CTBa nocne ero.IDIKBI nL33
IIoTaKOMYK[MTepmoKaKCnoc06onnaTbI8KW'!M nO,IJ;-
pa3iJ;eJ1RIO'!'CR ua al\.L\MYI KanYIT8na M 8KL<I1YI npOMbIIllJ1€HHble. O!lJ1aTa
lIj)OMilllliIeHHbIX aKJ.tl1H npoYI3BOJ\YITCH .JIWIHbII\oD1 yexyfaMY! 06Il\ecTBy.
a He J\eHeJoKHbIMJlJ: cpe}J;CTBaMYI. If.T. TapaCOB OTM€'laJi. 'ITO «MHOfYie
IIpl1Jl8lOT npoMbllllJIeHHbIM aEqHHM ern;e TO OTJIJI'-I1ITeJlhHOe CBOJ'icTBo,
'I1'O 6yJ\TO 6b1 OHl1 He l1MeIOT 3Ha'leHl1HJIOKYMeHTa H8 J\OJIIO aEqHOHep-
HOro Ka!lYITaJ1a. 8 TOJibKO J\OKYMeHTa H8 IIpaBO y<IaCTYIH B npYI6b1J1RX
ROMIIaIrnM, BCJ1e,IJ;CTSMe'lero Hepe}J;KO npoMbIlllJI€HHb 8KqHM aaMeHH-
KITCfI TaR Ha:3blBae IMYI aKWfHMYI nOJIb30BaHIDl, IfJill n0Jib30B8TeJ1b-
CKMr.rnaKLtJ1jlMM..';'
,lI.eijcTB I'pa:m,!\aHCKYIM KoJ\eKC P4I He J1ony=eT TaROH 803-
MrnKHOCTYI O!lJ1aTb1 aKWrli ofuQecTBa nyreM OKa3aIrnH OOIl\eCTBY YCJ1Yf_
B COOTBe'I'CTBHII COCT. 99 rKP<P H CT. 25 3aKOHa «06al\.L\MOHepHbIX 06-
ll\eCTBaX» ycTIlBHbliii KaIli1TaJ1 06Il\ecTBa onpe}J;eJIHeT
pa3M€p HM)'lIJ;eCTBa 06l1\€CTBa, rapaH'I'Hp)'lClU€ro J1HTep€CbI ero Rpe,!U1-
TOpoB. B COCT8B 3TOro HM)'lIJ;eCTBa YCJ1yrM BXO)];>ITb He MOryr.
IIo EI03lI«»KHUCTI OT3bIBa BbmyCTI1BWI1M J1X al\.L\MOHepHbIM 06IL\€CT-
80M I1pI-fBMJ1€n:1pOB8.l1Ebl€ a ,l:teJLflTCR Ha 803Bpa'I'HbIe" HeB03Bpa'I'-
Hble. ARqHOHepHble 06l1\eCTBa, BIID)'CTIffiIllI€ B03spaTHble 8KJ.t11M, 'l8CTO
pro€pBHpYlOT 3a cr.6ofI npaSO «OT03BaTb" J1X CIyreM BbIKyIla. HeB03-
BpaTHble I1pJ1BJ aRllI1Jl He nOJlJle::teaT noraweJrnIO, !lOKa
C)'IlIeCTB)'€T ENIJ)'CTIDillE€ J1X 8KI<I10HepHoe 06IL\€CTBO. 35
PerpeKn1BHb1e npnBJ aKQI-1J1 J1a:IOT npasO,l:tep::teaTe-
.JlHM noracWI'b I1X B O!lpe,IJ;ene MOMelIT no npe,DyCMOTpeHHOH qeHe.
.lI.ep::teaTeJib pe1peKTi'1BHblX 8.KQJ1:ti MOJoKeT B yC"ISHOBJieHHbIM cpDK no-
-21-
"Ipe60BaTb ar 06!l,\ecTBa HX BbIKyna. 3TI1 aRQID1 CTaHOBHTCR npHMbIMJ1
npnBlmel'llpOBaHHbIMI1 aEL\l1HMI1, eCJIl1 cpoK 113'bJ1T11H I1CTeKaeT. 9B
panbHbIM 3aROHOM OT 28 AeRa6pR 2002 r. NQ 18543 {{a BHe-
CeHI1J1 113MeHemd H ,lJ;OIlOJlHeHHn B 4Je 3aKOH «0 pb1HKe
l\eHHbIX 6.)'Mar» 11 0 BHecemrn: ,lJ;OIlOJIHeIDIfl B paJ1bHbIW. 3aKOH
«0 HeKOMMepqeCRHX opraHI13aQl1HX» BBe)\eH HOBbm B 3MRCCUOHHOit:
l\eHHOfi 6.)'Mal'H- OITl(I10H 3MI1TeHTa Om.U-lOH3MHTeHTa - :aMJf(UKtHHafI
l\eHHafl 6.)'Mal'a, 3aKpeI1JlfllOIlI<tfl npaBO ee BJ1a)\eJlbQa Ha noKYIIKY B
npe):lyCMO'I'peHHbl B Hei1 CpOK J1!I1J1J1 npJ1 HaCTyIIJIetuDi yKa3aHHbIX B
Hen o6cTofrre.nbcTB (I1})e,D;eJ1eHHOI'O I<OJ1Jrrecrsa aKWrl1: 3MJ1TeHTa TaKO-
roOIT'--tI10Ha ITO l\eHe, OITpe.I\eJleHHOfi B OIll\J10He 3Ml1TeIJ'l'a. 0rr'--tI10H 3MI1-
TeHTa HBJLFIeTCH HMeHHOM l\eHHOM 6yMarow. TaKJ1M o6pa;3oM. OITl\I10H
CTaJl 3aKOHO,lJ;aTeJlbHO :3aKpeI1J1eHHOM aJlbTepHaTJ1BOti: aKl\I1ff C op.I\epa-
MH. OJ\HaKO eCJ:U1 aKl\ID1 C op,lJ;epaMJil Mol'JIJil6bITb TOJIbKO IIpI1BI1JIHI1pO
BaHHb!Ml1 11 ,AaBaJDI CBoeM)' Jlep:ac,neJllO npaBO KynM'b onpe.D.eJIeHHOe
'lJiICJIO aJI:I(Iu"i, T00IIW10HMmKeT6bITbpa3Mell\eHcpe,lJ;JiI
Aep::teaTeJIeHHe TOJIbKO IIpl1Bl1JIernpOBaHHbIX, HOI1 aK-
l\I1M. J1HOrJla op,lJ;epa 6biBalOT OT,l1eJlJilMbl OT ITpHBJilJlerl1pOBaHHbIX aK-
l\I1MI1 Mol'yr 6bITb npOJ\aHbl 'laCTHMI1 = l\eJll1KOM npH coxpaHeHJilJil
HHbIXaKWIW.CTO'lKI13peHJilHI1HBeCTopOB, npHBJilJlem-
poBaHHble aKl\Wl1 c op,lJ;epaMJ1 IIpe,QCTaBJlHKYl' co6oi11Jl3e l\eHHble 6.)'Ma-
rn, Ka:1f\l\YlO 113 KOTopbIX MmKHO xpaHJilTb I1JH1 npo.n;aTb OTlteJlbHo. 37
B nepJilo,lJ; H3IIa oco6oe MeCTO 3aHHMaJrn rapaHTI1poBaHHble 8Kl\W11.
rapaHTI1poBaHHble aK1\I111 ooecne'll1BaJII1Cbrocy.n;apCTBOM.
TaKl1X aKWrl1: B CJI)"Iae O"l'cYl'CTBI1H npl16b!JlJil,Wffil1,lJ;eHJIB Te'-leHJile onpe-
A€J1€H1IOl'O PMa neT BbIT1J]a'lJilBaJlCflI13 l'ocy.n;apCTBeHHbIX Cpe,l1CTB. ro-
CyltapCTBOM MOl' 6bITb TaKme rapaHTI1p(E8H ar YM£HbIlEHI1H ycraBHbIi1
KaIlI1Ta.TI oOll\eCTSa
M.H. J'I3pa:;Inwr BbIJIeJlflJ1 TaKofi TI1Il KaK CB.R3aHHble aKl\l1Ji1. «Csfl-
3aHHbIMl1 (BJilHKYJII1pOBaHHbIMJ1) aKl\l1HMJ1 Ha3bmalOTCH Talme, KOTO-
pb1e = Bosce He Mol'yr6blTbnepeAC\B8€Mli HX BJU\,J\€.J1bl\a "IpeTbl1M
J1Wl\aM = Mol'yr 6blTb nepe.n;aBaeMbl, HO nl1lllb C pa3pernemf.R npaB-
neHI1H J1JIJ1 OOll\el'O c06paHJ1H 06Il\ecTBa. B 3TOM HeB03MCOKHOCTII nepe-
'l11 8Kl\11ti: "IpeTbJ1M nl1QaM J1 3aKJIlO'-IaeTC.R I1X «CB.fI3aHHOCTb»: TaKtIe
aKl\l1I1 OObl'llibl B npaKTI1Ke aK'--tI10HepHbIX 06ll\ecTB, KOl' Y'lPeJ\HTe-
JlHMJilI1X HBJ1HfOTCH QJ:J;HOpO.IJ;Hb npe I1HTI1H».30
C 1 HliBap.fl 2002 l'. B 3aKOH «06aKl\l1oHepHbIX 06Il\ecTBax» BBelteHO
nOHHTHe,l:lp06Hm1 aKWfil, KOTopoe B HaCTOHll\ee BpeMH Bb13NB8€T MHO-
ro cnopoB. .l{pooHb1e 8.KLlI1J1 (ecmt npJil06peTeHJile aKl\>1OH€pOM l\enoro
'lJiICJIa aKWdi HeBIJ31IoI:»tQ) MOryr 06Pa30Bb1BaTbCH B 06ll\eCTBe B cne-
,uyKJIIJ;J1xcJI)"-I3.me
-22-
1. ITp>1 OC eCTBJIeHl1I1 IIpEJ ronpaBa Ha np>106pere-
IDle aKLI>1i1, n eMbIX aK'-1WOH€POM 3aKpbrroro aK'-1WOHepHoro 06-
lI{eCTBa.
2.ITpJ.1 OC eCTBJ1eHJ.1J.1 n JHoro npaBa Ha IIpJW6peTe-
IDIe1\OlI01llU1TeJlhHblXaKl.-tIDI.
3.ITp>1 aKQIDi
ITepe'l€Hb CJ1)"-JaeB, npJ.1 KOTOpblX 06pa3:yK1I'CfI ;:J;p06Hb1e aKLtJ.1J.1, .fIB-
J1J1eTC.l1HC'l€p
O,IJ;HaKO A3,JleKO He Bee )"'IeHble cornaCHbI C Ba3MO)KH()CTbK) cy:w:eCT-
BOBaHWI nO;:J;06HblX aKLtJ.1ti:. Ellie TaKl1e Bu,IlHb1e npaBOBe;:J;b1 KaK MH
J13pa3JllfT JI II Th1CeMCKHi1 SOBce OTpJ.1 caM)' IIIJ3MCOfaIOCTb ;:J;p06-
neHJ1:.fI aK'-1WM. TaK, M.H Jilapas,mITnoJlaraJl, '1TO «aKlU1H He MorYT 6b1Tb
APD6J.1MbL 3Ta l1€,l\emfMQCTb BbiTeKa€'T JI3 caMoro nOHRTWI aKI.\I-1ti:, KaK
HaHMeHbrnei1 e)J;l1H11L{b1, Ha KOTOpble pa3,1J;eJIeH OCHOEHOH: KalIlITaJl aK-
1.{M0HepHoro 06ll1€CTBa.113 3TOro me CJleJ\YeT, 'ITO B Ip HCKOM 060-
paTe MO:1KeT 06p TbCH TOJIbKO u;eJIaR aKU;WI, EO He 'iaCTb ee».39
II ITnC€MCKHi1 no 3TOM)' BOlIpoCy ID'IcaJl: «E.KQIDI KaK mmimum yqa.c-
TWI B npe,r:ulpHHTJDI He 1"IO,f:\JI€)KJ1T pa3,lJJX)6.nrnmo».4<I
llH. I'yccaY.c:JBCKKit: BblCKa3blBaJl MHeHI1e, 'ITO «npaBO 1'OJI0ca He,Ae-
JlMMO, 8 nOTOM)' He Mor)'T OblTb,n;eJlHMbII1Te 8KQJ.1I1, KOTOpble,n;81OT 3TO
npaBo».41 TaKMM 06pa30M, aBTOp OTpl>lI,\aJl BfJ3M())KH()C'T ,lIJXI6.neHIDI
TOJIbKO ,lWlOlIJ;I1X npaBO roJloca aKLII1ff.
Jl,.A MaKapoB y6e}f\,l\rn B TOM, 'ITO 11pII3HaBaTb 8K'-1WOHepOM .ID1QO,
KOTOpoe If MeeT B COO('TB('llH()C1'H MeHee 0;:J;H0i1 u;eJloi1 aKQMM, HesepHO.
Bo3M01'KHOCTh cyIIJ,€C'TBIJB8 ,n;pOOHbIX aKQMi1 IIpOTHBOpe'i1IT OCHOBO-
nOJ1aralOlIJ;I1M npMffi\rnIaM aK'-1WOHepHoro npasa. 42
TeM He MeHee, TaK11XaKI.\I-1i1BbI3BaHO K :HOI3HJ.1He-
06x0.Ju1MOCTblO. Be,llb He BCerAa, aKiV'lOHepHOe 06lLf2CTBO MomeT pa3;:J;e-
.m;:Th Memp,y aKI.\I-10HepaMl>f lfMeHHO u;eJJoe 'illCJ10 aKQl1tf, nooTOM)', 11.Y-
MaeTCH, "1TO BBe;:J;eHl1e B 3aKOH «06 a OHepHbiX oow;eCTBax»
APD6HbIX aKQMti: - 3TO "1HCTO 'l'€XIDf'1e<ro-dt npl1€M, n03BOJLIIJOIIJ;I1ti: Ha
npaKTI1Ke aKQMOH€pHbIM 06ll1e<:TBaM lf36eraTb He06xo;:J;HMocTIf ,n;p06-
neHJ1:.fI11JII1 BbIKYlIa 8KQMi1 B Tex CJly'I3.fIX, KOf,Aa Heso3MO)fCH() oOpaao-
BaHl>fe QeJ1b1X aKQMti:
&K pa.::rhflCH€HO B J.fiRlxJpMaQIroHHOM IDICbMe cpKqB OT 26 HOHf)PH
2001 f. NQ J1R-09j7948 «06 oOpa3C58.HID1 ..aCTIf aKQMti: (Ap06HbIX 8X-
)>> ;:J;p06HaHaKQJ1j'l oopaIQae'I'('JI KaKQeJlaR aKQJ-1fI. KpoMe TOrn, 8KLtJ.1-
OHep - BJl3,D;eJIeQ ,n;pof:Ea1: 8Ku;1111lfMeeT npasa B o!YbeMe, COOTBeTCTsy-
IOllIeM ..acTIf I.\€.1D1i 8KQi111 olIpeAeneHHoi1 Kareropl1l1 ("I1ffia). KOTOpyro
COCTaBJUIeT ,n;pOOHa.R aKIJ;I1R.
TaKI1M 06pasoM, 8KI.{MH MOJKeT aaKpelIJlJITb pa31lWIHbD1 no o&beMY
KOMIIJIeKC npaB 8KQI10HepOB, O;IHaKO BO Beex cJIy'IaRX,D,JIH I1X peaJII>1-
-23-
3aqIDf B npou;ecce B3aJIMOJJ;etICIBIIH 8KW'10Hep>'!Oro 06ll-\ecTBa II ero
yqacTH>1KOB M oc06b1ti IOpl1,!\>1'1eCKi1R COCTaB - COBeprneH>1e
cJ\eJIKJ1 no nepexo,lly npaaa coocTBeHHOCT>1 Ha 8 II pe
B peeCTpe 8KlV-'10HepOB, 8 IIHorAa J-f rOCYAapCTBeHHa.1I pemCTpaLtl-'lJ'l
BHOBb C03J\aHHoro 8KLtI-'IOHepHoro 06ll-\ecTBa, KcrropaJ'l B 3TOM cJ!Y'f8e
npeWlIec-rnyeT m>YM nepBbIM IOpuJI.I1"IecKWII clJaKTaM. IIOM>1MO Toro,
'ITO aKLIIIF! npe,!:lCT8BJ!J'leT co6oii KOMnJ!eKC npaB, OHa TaKme HBJIHeTCH
II qeHHoti 6yMaroi-i:, II Ao.neti y<mCThlJ'l B YCTaBHoM KaIIlrra.ne aKLIMo-
HepHoro 06I.qeCTBa.
lIpaBOQ'I'H()lllel, nopom,rJ;aeMble YKa3aHHblM CJ!OmHblM IOpl-1,!!,11'-Je-
CKI-1M COCTaBOM, 8 TaIOKe, COOTBeTCTBeHHO, II npaBa, YJ\OCToseplleMbl€
aKW1eti, no cBoei-i: npllpo,l\e HBJIRIOTCf! KopnopaThlBHbIMll .mrt50 OOJi3a-
Te.nbCTBeHHblMtf, KaK OY,I\eT nOKa3aHO ,D;aJ1ee.
t 2. IOpMJ:\M..,ecKa51 npMpo,qa npaBooTHoweHMM
Me>K,q)' aKLlMOHepMblMM 06lL1ecTBaMIt It aKLlMOHepaMIt
A03aQ 2... 2 CT. 48 rK Pc1> npHMO yc-raHaBJIJ'1BieT, 'ITO K IOpl1,!{W-lec-
KIIM M, B OTHOllleHim KOTopbIX JilX y<IacnUfi«1l1MelOT OOJi3aT€.nb-
CTBeHHble npaBa, OTHOCIITCH xroIDicTBeHHble TOSap>1l1\eCTBa. II 06l1\ecT-
Ba, IIpOIf3BO)J;CTBeHHble II narpe6JITeJ1bCK1le KOOliepaTlIBbL
Q)J;HaKo, KaK OTMe'IaJI ell-\e n IfuceMcKi1R, MHeHIDI y<IeHblX no 3TO-
MY BOlipoCY pa3,l\eJI.HI(YI'CJI: 0J\HJ1: T B aKl\ID1 npaBO co6cTBemrocn:1,
,n;pyrlle - OOJi3aT€JIbCTBO, TpeTb>1 - CMeIlIeHI1e TOro II ,lIpyroro (caM OH
61"3 KO.11€6aIum np>13HaBaJI npaBIfJ1bHblM nepBOe MHeH>1e).43
IIp>'! 3TOM c:JnIeCeHHe npaB, 113 KOTOpbIX CJlaraeTCH y<Iacme B aKW1-
oHepHoM llpe.lII1pJ1F!T1I11, K pa3pH.rtY BelltHbIX y<IeHbIti 06oCHOBbIBaJI CJle-
.nyroru;m.'!oopa30M. «IIp>13HaID1e KOMllaHID-lIO JIIIL\OMHeIlC-
KJIlO'IaeT npaaa a>6crnetrn0C111 aKQIfOHep<E, JIDO KOMllaID1H He eCTb
cy6"beKT'Iym.rtbltia Ho.nIlIllb(OOOK}'I1HOCTbI1X, pacCMaTpll-
BaeMafl KaK OAHO Jun-tQ. IIpaB)Jp., B Te'leID1e BCero BpeMeID1 CYW;eCTBOB8-
HI:I.fI KOMnaHlll1 npaBO COOCTBeHHOCThi aKQIIOHepoB BbIpa::teaeTCH JlIIIllb B
npaBe Ha. AOXOAbI C ee J-fM)'llleCTBa; npaBo pacnOp&IKeHIDI OTXO,l\J1T OT
ID1X II TIepexoAlIT Ha KQMIJaH11lO; HO no ee BKJIaAbI ipso
jure B03Bpal1\8IOTCH 8KQ110H€paM. lIpaBo COOcTB€HHOCThI troMIJaHJDI
eCTb <PJ.1KW1F!, BBeJ\eHHaH,l\J1F! ropJ-W1'l€Cl«1X Qe.neA (legum subtilitate),
DHa MOJKeT ,lI0 HeKOTopoM CTeneID1 yCTpaHIITb, HO He B COCTOHHID-I COsep-
W€HHO )'HWITO:>KV!Tb ,lIejic:TBwrem.H:Jcn {non enim Ideo rei veritas dele-
ta vel confusa est)>>.44
, eCJiJ1 OTHDweHIDI Me)f(,1lJ' aK[{I10HepDM JiI 06l1\ecT-
80M HOCHT i xapaKTep, TO JilMeHHD MOMeHTDM BHeCeHI1H BKJiaM
-24-
B yc-raBIIbIit KaID1TaJI 11 OIIpe)\eJUIeTCH IJ03HJfKH1JBeffile 3Tll!: OTHOIlIe-
IDIi:t BrrOJIHe eCTeCTBeHHO nepe.Q aBTOpOM B03H11K Bonpoc: eCJ111 BKJIa.Q
B YCTaBlll,ll;j Karn-rraJI 6bIJI C,!\eJlaH nocpe.QCTBOM BHeceIDIH BeLql1, a 3Ta
BeILtb 1l0rn6.na, Ha KOM JIeml1T pHCK - Ha OOILIeCTBe J-fJIJ1 aRlUlOHep€?
ABrop C'll4TaeT, qTO eCJ1I1Belltb 6blJIa nepe):\aHa B co6cTBemIocn, 06IL1e-
crny, TO If pl1CK ,lJ;Q.JDKeH JIe:lKaTb Ha OOILIeCTBe, ecJIJ1:me TOJIhKO B nOJIb-
30BaHHe - TO pHCK Ha 8KQJ10Hepe. B nOCJIe,!!,HeM CJ1)"l3.e, KOma pHCK Jle-
mIT Ha 8K OHepe, OH .m1IlIaeTCfl CBoero IIpaBa yqaCTI1R If BbIDbIBaeT
J13 ofuQecTsa.; oOlL\eCTBO He oOH3aHO IIpO,!\OJ1maTb BbII1JI8.'iI1BaTb eMY
".."',,,"''''
KarJta BKJIa)\ aKqI10Hepa COCTOJ1T J13JII-1'IHblX ycnyr 11 npe
HI1eJ1XCTaHOBI'ITCH ,nYCTb,/J;a:>KeI16e3er0Bl1HbI,3TaHe-
B03M<»KHOC'Tl> JIJ1wa€T ero CBOiicTBa OHepa
Kama BeILtb 6blJIa nepe,!\aHa aK OHepoMOOlL\eCTBY Bn I€,
TO npl1 <lac"I'WIHUi1 ee n16eJIl1I1JIJ1 nop"!e pl1CK TalOKe JI€)ftJ1T Ha 8KQJ10-
H€pe. CJIelG'IDIIJ;J1i:i eMY ,l(J1Bl1;:\eH,lJ; ,l\OJDKeH )'MeHblIIJITbCH ct:II1'B€TCT-
BeHHO )'M€HbIll€HI'110 LleHHOCTJ1 Bell{J1, Ha OCHOBaHJ1J1 HOBO" 1"1" nepe-
OL\eHKI1. 45
IIpJ1 3TOM CJIeJIYeT OTM€TIITb, 'ITO, IIp>f3HaBaH OTHOWeHI1R Me:IKJIY
8KlU10HepoMl106lL\eCTBOMBel1{HbIMl1, n TInC€MCKJ1" A3,JIeeH€lIOCJIe,n;o-
BaTeJIbHO 8HaJllf3l1pyeT I1X no MOJ\eJIl1 06H38TeJIbCTB€HHblX OTHowe-
HI1", BG3HI1KaRIIU'JX 113 ,lJ;OroBOpa.
.0000000001e Me»i,lJ;y aKQIroH€PKM KOMII8Imml1 8KlU10HepoM €CTb
arnonremle .lIBYCTOlxHlHee; n03TOMY K HeM.)' npHMeID1MbI Bee IIpaBUJIa 0
,D;ByC'1OJXEHHX ,l\OroBOpax. B JJ;ByCTOpOHHJ1X ,IJ;OIUBqJ8X KOH-
T})areHT Brrpase OTKa3aTb ,n;pyroMY B l1CIJOJ1HeIDDl CBOll!: o6sI2ammCTeii,
eCJII1 nOCJIe,qmrl1 He I'K.'IIO.IIHIVI CO CBoe" CTOpoHbl CBOll!: c06CTBellHbIX
06R3aHHOCTeii <...> HeHcnOJllleW1e ,lJ;oroBOpa MbICJII1MO KaK CO CTOpoHbI
a.KL\I10Hepos, TaK If co CTOpoHbl KOMTIam-rn. TIOOTOMY KOMIIalillfl Brrpase
(YI'Ka3aTb 8K OHepy, He IfCITOJIlUIlOll\eMY CBOll!: ofuI:3aInDcTei1, B ocy-
lnpaB, I1pJ eMYnOYCTaBy,I<aKro: BnpaBeHa
,IJ;J1BH,!\eH.I1, B npaBe yqacTWI B 061l\eM co6pam-rn. Hac60pcrr, aI\.QI10Hep
BIIpaBe CYrKa3aTb B yruIaTe B3HOCa, €CJII1 KOMIIaHl1.fl Hapywa€T ,/J;oraBOp.
B 'IaC'I'HOC'I'n, KOMITaHl1.fl c<mTae'I'CJ!: He J-fU1OJ1llJ'JBIl1l CSOll!: 06H3aHHOC-
TeA, eCJIl1 He 11('1IIJJIHflE'T 1IpE'.lI;IIpIU1,IfJllf I1cnOJIHHeT ero TOJIbKO (YI'-
qacTI'!, I1JII1 He IIpIElO,WIT era nCilOJIH{'HJ1e II: Ha3HaqeHHOMY cpoKy, J1J1J1
OTKa3bmaeT 8KLlHoHepy B Bb1,!\a'Ie ,IJ;J1Bl1,!J;eH,!\a, I1JIH B ,l\onytIJ;eH11J1 B 06-
llIee co6paHl1e, 11JIJ1 I13M€Irn€T Te n0J10:>K€Hl1JI YCTaaa, B BJ1.IIY KOll!: OH
1J,a!I CBoe cornacl1e. - Ho HeJlb3H C'-Jl1TaTb Hf'ItCIIOJIHeID1eM co CTOpoHbI
KOMIIam-rn, 'ITO np€,!\IIpl1HTI:!e He np:1HOCJIT rntrn.l\aeMbIX BbII'O,!\».46
H.T TapacoB TalOK€ C'-JJ1TaJl, '-JTO npaBa 8KQI10Hepa no CBOe" npJ1-
po,!\e HB.T1HIOTCH BelL\Hb!Ml1, 11 n08TOMY «aKLli1Otfep 06R3aH 0T8€'18Tb
-25-
CBoeM J\OJIeH aa KOMIIaffi11O» JI HaKL(IIOH€p JlMeeT npaBO Ha IDJIY'f€HI1€
06paTHO CBoet1 J\O;UI KarnfTana cor.rraCHO 3alOOHY JI YCTaBy».47
Op;HaKO C npe)J;CTaBJIeHHOM TO'lKOt13peHllil HeJIb3.fl cor.rraCI1TbCH. He-
CB&3bC J1M)'1L1eCTBOM, BHeCeHHbIM BKa'IeCTBeB3HOCa B
KaID1TaJ1, OHepoM yrpa'II>1Ba€TCfl. fuK 3a1q)eIlJ1€HO B
A 3B.KOHO TeJIbCTBe, npl1 npe J\eHTeJIbHOCTl'l
aKLIl10H€pRiI'0 061.J.!€CTBCi nl1l-l0 non)"-JaeT He CBoA nepBoaa'Ia.l1bHHii
B3HOC, a 'IaCTb JlMyrI-leCTBa, nponopQl10HaJIbHO pa3Mepy ero y<ffiCTI-1fl B
4>opMMpOBaHID'I YCTaBHOrD KallJilTaJIa. Bp JJ;aHHOMBbIClID'I-
MJ1 CYAe6HblMJ1 :yKa3aHO, 'ITO ycnomm YCTaBa X03micT-
BeHHOro ofuQecTBa. npe CMaTpJ1BalOll.\I1e npaBO yqpero-;:TeJ1J1 (yqaCT-
HJ1K3.) J13'WITb BHeceHHoe JIM B Ka'IeCTBe BKJIa,Qa J1M)'1LIeCTBo B H3:rype
npJ1 BbDW,!J;e m COCTaBa Horo 06IL1eCTBa, ,!J;OJVKHbI npJ13Ha-
BaTbCR H , sa JlCKJIIO'-IeHJlleM cJIY'-I3.es, KOrJJ;a T8KaR
B03MOiKHOCTb n 3aKOHOM.48
CJIe,n;y€T TalOKe OI'MeTIITb, 'ITO 3aKOHo,!J;aTeJIbCTBOM He npe.lJ:YCll'lOI'-
peHO TaKoro OCHOSaHJII.H ,lVIH IIpeKpam€HJ1H npas aKQl10Hepa B OTHOIlle-
HJIIJ1 o6IL1ecTBa KaK rn6enb I , BHeceHHoro aKQJlOHepDM B Ka-
'1€CTBe BKJIBJ\a B YCTaBHbrn: KaIlIrraJL B CJI.Y'lae I'J11j€JIJ1 B€IW1 CBH3b
aKI{l10Hepa c He npeKpama.€TCR.
HeKOTOpbleY'leHble C'lJ1Tal{1I', 'ITOMem,zry 8KQ110HepOMJI 06r.qecTBOM
CKJI1l)(bIB8IOTCH UI'HUlIeHI:IH, 06R3aTeJIbCTBeHHble no csoei1 npl1pOJ\e.
TaK,o. JIOMH,!\3e C'lJ1Ta€T, 'ITO JJ;OJIR )"-I3.CTHJllKa (aKQl1R) BbipaiKaeT
o6R3aTeJIbCTBeHHOe npaBO, KOTopoe yqaCTHJ1K JlMeeT B DTIIOIIIeHl£lI 06-
Il\eCTsa. 49 TO'HU1 3peHJ1H 06 06H38TenbCTseHHoM IIp>fpo)J;e npas
8KI{110HepoS npHJ1€P'KHB8.eTClI JI E.E. ,lJ,onJ1HCKafl. 50
n.R. I'yccaK0BCEI'.11it: nonaran, 'ITO 06R3a-re.JIbC'l13eHHbl€ OTHOllieIDfH
CBH3bIBaIOT He TOJlbKO OT,!J;enbHoro aKI-lfK1H€p8 J1 aKLtJ10HepHOe
EO, HO Jl8KQJ10HepOB Me»QJy co60ft Co.n;epmaHJ1e nocneAHero npaBOOT-
HOIlleH>fH CSOro-;:TCH K cJle,n:yroll\eMY: 8KI{110HepbI cornaCJ1JIJ1Cb Mem,zry
co60tJ: npe,!J;ocTaBJ1Tb onp€,D,eJ1€HHble C)'MMbl,lVIH YCTpoikTBa J1 3KCnny-
8TaLtJ1J1 npep;nptf.flTHJ J1 He oTCTynaTb IIp>f 3KcnnyaTaQID:! 8KQJ10HepHO-
ro npe.n;npIDITJ1H OT T€'X 11C!craH0ElJI€mm 3aKOHa JI YCTasa, KOTopbIMJ1
peryJIJ1PYeTCfI .n;eJ!'T€.J1bJ1OCTb 06IL1ecTBa. J1cxoWI J13 3TOro, aBTOp yr-
BepmJt8eT, '1TO EO BCex CJlyqaHX npJ1HHTJ1H HroaKOHHOro pellieHIDI 06-
ll{I1J\'! c06paHJ1eM aKl.\I10Hepos, np1'il'1Hl'1BllIK Bpe.D; ,[ij)yTJ1M <JneHaM
Jt8HHOn KOpnopal.\J1J1, Ha I'OJXJCOBaBlID1X 3a npJ1HRTJ1e TalOO!'O pellieIDfH
aKI{l10Hepos MomeT 6bITb B03JIOmeHa 06H3aHHOCTb B03M€CTJ1Tb Bpe.D;.
1IpJ1 3TOM He l1MeeT 3Ha<JeHJIIR, waJl J1I1 3apaHee aKQl10Hep 0 B03MO:>K-
HOCTJ1 nJM'Il'1HeHIUI Bpe.lla,l\€ikTBoBa.n J1I1 OH no HeOC'TOpOJKHOCT JlJIJ1
)lMb!lILJIeHHo. 51
-26-
HeKOTopble yqeHble BbICKa3bIBalOT B3I'.IDJJ];bI 0 cMewaHHoM XSPSR-
Tepe npSBOOTHOIllemrn:, C 1XC51Mem,zr;yaKqHCHepaMi'I If 06-
lI{eCTBaMJ1 If, KaK npe,!\CTSBJUIeTCII, 3SHJ1MSlOT Hal16o.nee 06oCHOBaH-
H)'KII103Jn.tIoo.
CrreJIYeT cornaCJ.1TbCII C B.II. MooOJ1J.1HbIM, KOTOpblff ;yKa3bIBaeT, '1TO
«xa}')aKI'efUCTIDI'a npaB BKqI10HepC)B no CYrHOilleHillO K 06LqeCTBy KaK
06Ji3a'1'e11bC'I'BeH He JmJIfIeTCF! 'T'O'llJ'Jtt ,UaHHoe OOT.IomeH1fe HaXO..!lJ.1T-
CJi B np:YI'i'1BOpe"lH1 C nOHJ1TlfeM Ofu13aTeJIbCTBa (CT. 307 I'K), B KOTOpoM
CTOpoHbI BblcrynaKYr B Ka'leCTBe H€38BIfCI1Ml:iX ,[ij)yT or APyra yq3.CTHJ1-
KOB npaBoOTHoIlleID1fi. BH}'TPeHHlfe orHoIlleHJ1F! Mem,rIy aKIVWIIEpaMR C
O)\1l0H CTOpoHbI JI 06LqecTBOM C JWYI'OH CTQPOHbI, Hepa3pbffiHIDf 'laCTblO
KOTOPbIX JiB.ILIIKTrC.III1 OTHOIUeHJ1F!, CB.H3aHHbIe C J1MY1LIecTBOM nOCJIe,!J;He-
1'0, CTpOHTCJi no COBepIlleHHO wroj,j: M"J,lI{'J1J1. 3T0 - OT'HOIUeIDiF! yqaCTKF!
(-qJJeHcma) B eJIaX l\aHHoro 06mecma, B TOM 'lI1CJIe 11 B peIlleHJ1liI BOOpo-
COB no ynpaSJIeHillO 11 pacnopJVKeHillO ero J1MYLII;eCTBOM. COOTBeTCTBeH-
HO, l\aHHble OTHOIllEIDUI KacaTeJIbHO npaB JI o6.H:3.aJrnocTe aKqI10HeJX]B
peryJIJ1PYIOTCH HOpMBMJ1 BK4I1OHepHoro npaBB. AKw10HepbI 06Il\eCTBa
HaxO;::vrrCJ'! Ha noJIIDI<eHIDl ero X03J'!eB, a He nocTOJX>HHHX JIi'Il\. 06J'!38-
TeJIbC'I'BeHHbIe OTHOllleHJ1F! Me)fQJy BKqI10HepaMH JI 06LqecTBOM MOJYT
B03HJ1KaTb IDlliIb no 'Ip€6oBaHJ1F!M 06 yrIJIare ,IJ;!1BI1)J;eH-
AOB, nOJIY"Iemrn J1MYI--II;eCTBa B c.rryqae .m1KIn 06Il\eCTBa If I\pyrnM
061l.\ffPB1ti,!\aHCKMM Tpe60BaHIDIM..., TO eCTb TOmS, KOr,l\B aKiU'IOHepbI
113MeHRKYr CBOH npaBOBoH cra"l)'c, nepexOM Ha IIOJIOIiIEHJfe 06bJ<IHbIX
BHellIHHX Kpep;wropC)B Jf.ID1 ,/J;O.JDKIDrn:OB 110 O'I1IDIlI£HJ:nQ K 06meCTBY». 52
no MHeHI1IO MM ArapKoBa, «OTHOIlleHJ1F! Me)fQJy aKQ>IOHepaMJf 11
aK4I10HepHbIM 06Il\eCTBOM He MOJYT 6bITb OTHeCeHbI K 'll1CTO 06113a-
Te1IbCTB€HHbIM npSBOO"I'lIlliIEHI1IIl\oL MQWoHepy rrp:rnaJJ.,1IemaT npe:>K,!\e
BCero KOpnopaTJ-IBHble npana ..».:13
E.A. CyxaHOB TalOKE' OTMe'ffieT KOpnOpSTIIBHbD1, a He 06Ji3aTeJIbCT-
neHllbIi1 xapaKTep OTAeJIbHbIX npaB yqBC'IIDfKOB. diJiarOJ\BpH KOpnops-
TJ1BHbIM npaaaM yqaCTID-IKI--I KOpnopa1V'D-'l ( TOaapl1lll;e-
CTBa, 06Il\eCTBa, KoonepaT 1:Ba 11 TaR MJIee) Moryr yqacTBOBaTb B
pa3JIwrHbIX qx:pMBX B yrrpaBJJ2HJDI KOpnDpa4I1eHl1 eeJ1MYLII;eCTBOM. Pe-
aJIJ13YJi CBOJ.1 KOpnopaTIlBHb1e npaaa, yqBC'IIDfKJ.1 KqJI1OpaLlHJ1 E\JIJ1F!KYr
Ha Qx>pMII}X!Balll-fe Bomf ASHBOro KOpnopaTJ1BHoro 06pB3oaaHJ1F!, flBJ1JIK)-
lL\erocH C8.MOCTOHTeJIbH Cym,eKTOM rpa HCKOro npasa - IOPI-W1-
'1eCKMM JII1lIOM. TaKaR arryatVUI HeTl1IDI'lHB AJlF! rpaiK,IlaHCRD-npaBOBO-
ro peryJIJ1poBaHIDI, TaR RBR no 06Il\eMY npSBKJI)' B rpS:wyJ;aHCKoM
060pare Cyfu.eKTbI C'aMOCTOHI'€JIb If He3BBJICMMbI ,[ij)yT ar ,[ij)yTa 11 no-
:3TOM)' He MOJYT He o yqaCTBOBSTb B qx:,pMMpOBaHIDiJ BO.ID1
KOHTpareHTS» 54
-27-
T.B. KawaHl1Ha C'-IlITaer, 'ITO OTtfOWeHJ1R, HB aK-
Ql-fOHepHOM 06mecme. Hocm CMeWalll1bIi1 xapaKTep. TaK, «yaKI..tJlOH€-
pa eCTb Kopnopanl1JHoe npaBO - yqacrnOBaTb B ynpaBJIeHWI aKQWO-
HepHblM 06ll.1ecTBOM. 011 OOJ1a,!J;aeT TaK:>Ke OOR3aTenbcTBeHHblMJ1
npaBaMI1; npaBOM TpeO{IBaTb BbIllJ1aTbl OO"bRBJ1eHHbIX ARBJIA€HJ1OI!;
npaSOM Ha npJ1tDilTaIOIl\YIDC.H J\0J1l0 "M.YU-\eCTBa, OCTaBLUYIOC.H nOCJ1e
JII1KB L\1111 aKLIl10HepHoro 06ll.1ecrna» 55 TaI<oti .me n0311Q1-fl1 06 OOR-
3aTeJ1bCTBE'HHOlI npl1po,!\e npaBa Ha 'laCTb 110XO,!\OB (,!\I1Bu,IleH,!\) J1 npa-
Ba Ha JII1KB»,!\aW'lOHHyID KBOTY np»,!\ep:)Kl1BaeTC.H" Me. KopafuIeBa. 5G
AJ1 KaMI1HKa BblCKa3aJ1 MHeHI1e, 'ITO npaBa aKlU'lOHepoB «npe,!\-
CTaBJ1.HKYI' cBoeoopa3Hb1e oco6eHllOC'Tlf CpaBHJ1TeJ1bHO C CTPYKTYPOi1
OO.H3aTe.JIbCT&'HH:bDnpaB, OHJ1 HOC.HTCn€l<J$tqec-
KyID KopnopaTJ1BHyID oKpacK)', cyW,HOCTb KOTOpoti: 3aKJIlO'laeTCR B
3JIeMeH'l'€ rcJCllOJIC'IB8. KOMIIaHmI, EaK T3KQBoii, Ha)J; OTJ\eJlbHblMJll ee
yqaCTHI1KaMI1».57
,lJ;.B. JIoMaKI1H nOJIaraer. 'ITO cy&beKllIhlii COCTaB aKqJ:1IJHepHOro
npasOo::rI1IDlIleHJIH He C'I'pOIITC.H no MOJ\eJll1 OO.H3aTeJ1bCTSeHHoro. IIpa-
BOBaR CBR3b B03H11KaeT 3,!J;eCb Mem;Jy MHIDKeCTBOM yqacTHl1KOB. IIpo-
J1:3lJO,l(tI:He OT aKl\110HepHOro IIJEBOOTHOlll€HlIH OO.H3aTeJIbCTBeHHOro
xapaKTepa, CTpO.HllU1eC.H no cxeMe J\OmKHl1K - Kp€)J;JiITop J1 B03Hl1KalO-
ll{I1e IIp>'! BblIlJIaTe I«JHKP€THOJI ,!\eHemHoi1 CYMMbI B Bl1,!\e JJ:l1BI'JJIeH)\OB
"lIp>'! no.ny'-l€HHI1 JII1KBIf,l\a.lU1IJHHOi;i KBOTbI, TaKme "MeeT MeCTO B aK-
QI10HepHOM OOmeCTse. Otrn xapaKTepl13ylOTC.H npOCTbIM cy15"heKTHbIM
COCTaBOM. B Ka'leCTBe ,l\OJI:>KID1Ka 3,!\eCb BblcrynaeT aKqI1(IIeproe 06-
meCTBo, a Kpe,!J;l1TopaMH HBJIJIIOTCH aKW10Hepbl. 5U
YI\a3aIlHbIi1aBTopBbl,!\eJIJIeT roJaB O)J;HCMMeHHbIX npaB: npaBOHa
1J:I1BI1,ZJ;eH,!\J1JD 1OHH)'lOKBOT.YKaK3JIeMeHTbl aKql1-
OH€J:fJUI'O npaBOO'I'HOllleHJ1R " npaso Ha ]:1J1BJ1,l\eH,!\ J1 JD-fKBJJ,!\alU1OHH)'IO
KEary KaK ::IJ1eMeHTbI CO,!J;epmaHJ1J1 OO.H3aTeJ1bCTBelllioro npaBOOTHOWe-
HJ1R. B03H11KalOIl\ero Mem,zry aKql10HepoM J1 OOll\ecrnoM. B nOCJle,n;HeM
CJ1)"-Jae 11JIJ1 nOJlBJ1eHJ1R Ha3BaHHbIX npaB Hap C 4>axraMJ1, ycraHaB-
JD1BaIOLqI-iMJ1'U1eHCTBO, H)'mHhI AfJIOJ1II1'fI'€ ecIDle Q-JaKTbI,
HaIIpJ1Mt:'p, pewefD1e o6merocoopaHJ1R O DI 06ll\eCTBa. 59 IIpJ1
STOM ,lJ;.B. JIoMaKJ1H npaBOOT1IOIlJ2I KaK
IOpI CM3b, B03H11KalOlltYlOB MOMeHTrocy,!\aJX."ffi€ll1lOi pern-
CTpaLJ;J1l1 aK OHepHoro 06mecTBa Ha acHoBe HOpM npaBa "CBOOo)J;HOro
CornaWeHJ1R Me yqacrHJ1l\aMJ1 ro OTHJllieIDIJ1, KaKO-
BblMl1 BblC-rynaIOT caMO 06ll\eCTBo, aKQl10HepbI, TpeTbJ1.JI1143., He HBJlJUO-
ll{I1eCR aKQWOHepaMJ1, " BN B HaJiWII1J1 Y aKql10Hepos
cy1)"heKTI1BHblX npaB, B e,!I;l1HOM npase 'UleHCTBa, a
T3.KmeBH3.JIWillJIIY HOr006mecTBa"-rp€ThJ1XJlJ1l.IIOpJ1,l\Wlec-
-28-
KI1X 06H3aHHocreH no urHoweHHIO KBK4HOHepaM, KDppecrIOHJJ:I(J>YlOLIJ;MX
3TOMY npasy.60
IJpe.llCTaBJUleTCH, 'no C TaKOH "IpillITOBE'OH aRqMOHepHOro OTHowe-
HnF! cor.nacnTbCF! HeB03M())!Q1().. Bo-nepsblx, XOTF!6bIn01'OM)', '1TOaK4H-
OHepbl He TOJIbKO JlMeKYI' npaBa no 0TII0llleHW0 K TpeTbl1M .nJlQaM JI aK-
ql1OHepHOMY 06ll-\ecTBY, HO JI HeCYT nepe,!\ HI1MI1 OOH3aHHOCTI1.
BO-BTOPbD{, HeKO'IOpble OTHOWeHWF! Mem,lly OOll-\eCTBOM 11 aKL\J10Hepa-
MI1, CKJ1a,lJ;blBaIOecH:no nOBOJIY oC maKL\J10HepaMl1 CSOMX
npaB, crpOHTCH no Mo,!\enl1 OOH3aTeJlbCTBeHHbIX (HanpI1Mep, DTHDwe-
HJlF! B CSH3n C peaJll-13aL\IIw npaBa B.KL\I«iH€PB Ha l1OJ1)"I€ffi'Ie JlH4>oP-
MaL\I1I1 Jl3 peecTpa HepoB)
IIoMHeHI1KJH.J1.MMp<XlIHI1KOBOii.OTHOWf'HJ1R, MeiK-
11Y KOpr1Opaqneii JI ee )"UlCTID1KaMI1, l1MeKYI' KOpnOpaTl1BH)'JO npnpo.l\Y
11 He B paMJ(l1 OOH3a'I€JIl:C'IE€HHbIX npa
ABrop AeJIaeT BbIBO.l\., <rro «eCJIl1 OTHOWeHI1H 'lJleHa (yqacTHMKa) KOp-
nopaql1l1 He HBJIHlOTCH OOH3aTeJIbCTBeHHo-npaBOBbIMl1, TO C Hel130eMC-
HOCTbKJ CJle.n;yeT BbIBO,lJ; 0 TOM, 'ITO 31'0 BHYTPl1KOpnopaTl1BHble OTHO-
llleHM. <no> B nOJlb3y KopnopaTIIBHOK llp1pOAb1 paCCMaTpl1BaeMbIX
urHOIlIEHIDI roBOpHT JI CJIe.n;yIOIII;I1e apryMeHTbL CBH3b yqaCTHI1Ka C
KopnOpaTI1BHbIM oIh.e,IJ;I1HeHl1eM B03HHKaeT = B MOMeHT ee 06pa30-
MHM, JlJIl1 cnoc0611M11, )'Ka3aHHbIMl1 B 31iIWHOJlaTeJIbCTBe, Kor,l\a IWp-
nopaql1H cy:IL\eCTBYeT KaK ropM.l\WlecKoe nID.\0. BHYTPM KopnOpaI\l-1>1
CKJIa):\bIBalOTCH OTHOllIeHI1H pa3HOOTpaCJleBble. Hanpl1Mep, no nOBOJIY
yqacTI1H B ynpaBJIemm, O3HBl«JMJIeHl1.H C JIOK)'MeHTaI:(lteif, no noBOJIY
4JillIaHCOB l1.11PYJ'i'1e. 3To He I1CKJIKNaeT TOro, 'ITO B pe3YJIbTBTe TaKMX
arnollll2Hl'1i-f MOryr B03IDIKHYTh OOR3aTeJJb(."l'B€HH()-npaBOBbI€ CBJ1311,
HO OHM B03ID1KaIOT Y:tKe B CI1.ny p;pyrl1X ropn.!I;u<IeCKKX Q:lBK1'OB. ECJIl1 Ta-
KI1X rop qmKTOB HeT, TO OTlDUEHJ1R Mem,lly yqacTHnKoM Ii
KopnOpaTl>1BHbIM OO"beAWHeHl1eM He BbIXOJIRT 31i paMKl1 KOpnopaTI1BHO-
npaBOBOH CIDI311 <no> 06pa'I1ffilllllCb K 3aKOHY «06 aKL\I10HepHbIX 06-
ll-\eCTBaX», MbI HafJ,!l;eM B HeM nJXYI'HE!OlX"IK, KOTOpble cytJ.\eCTB}'101'
TOJJbKO n01'OM)', '1TO 0TH0ll1eH11Sl aKL\IfCHepa JI aKL\I1CHepHOJ'O 06ll.1ecTBa
IlblTalOTCR BTI1CHyrb B O.I\HY 113 Mo,!\eJleH - OOR3aTeJlbCTBeHHo-npaBO-
BYKJ, '1TO Be.AeT K HCKameIDDO npMpO,lJ;b1 aKL\I1fi:, a TalCKe He OTpamaeT
JlCTl1HHOro xapaKTepa KopnOpaTl1BHbIX OTHollIemm:... 61
OM PO.I\HOBa TaICKe B eJlReT ocoo)'JO IpyIITIY KDpnOpaTl1BHbIX
npaB, IWTOpble He OTHOCJlTCF! HI1 K Bell-\HbIM, HJI K 06R3aT€.11bC'I'BeHHb1M.
IIpl1 3TOM, no ee MHeHl1KJ, KopnqJaTMBHOM)' IIpaBY npl1cYll-\I1 xapaK-
TepHble TOJlbKO,lJ,JlJ'I Hero CJJeJIYKJW,i1e np113HaKI1.
IIepBbIi1: 113 HI1X - rocII1J,l:\CTBO BOJII1 aKqHOHepHoro 06ll.1ecTBa lIpl1
ycrnHOBJIeHmI Ct¥\E'PJKaHJ1H ro BKL{I10HepHOro npaBa. Ta-
KOH BblBO.AaBTDp .n;eJIaeT Ha TOM OCHOBaHl1l1, '11'0 6o.rrbllIl1HCTBO Iwpno-
-29-
paTl1BHbIX npaB B03HI1KaeT 113 perneHill1 o6r.u;ero C06paHI1R aKL\I1OHe-
PC)B, rfJ.e fJ.etfCTBYeT He np>fffi\illJ efJ.l1HornaC>fJ1, a np>fHl -m 60J1bIlI!1HCT-
sa. AKQMoHepbl, OCTaBlillIecH B MeHblIII1HCTBe, 06J1::mHbI m CJ1
BOJ1e 6oJ:IbWJ1HCTBa.
Bropoi1 npl13HaK, OTJ1I-f'1alOr.u;IDi KoprropaTI1BHOe npaBO OT 06J13a-
TeJlbCTBellliOro, 06yCJ10BJIeH TeM, 'ITO a OHep -:;ITO yqacTIDIK 06r.u;e-
CTBa, 'laCTb lje..1roro. n03TOMY 06"beM 11 co.n;epmaInfe npaB, npl1l1a,!tJ1e-
maIqIDC a oHepy, ::mm-IC>fT He TOJlbKO OT BOJUI6aJn,unDICTBa, HO 11 OT
pe3YJlbTaTOB,/J;eHTe.1IbHOCTi{, CY,/J;b6b! npt' KOTOpaJ1, no MHe-
HJ.UOaBTOpa, J-IMeeTCT0J1b 3Ha'leHJ-Ie, 'ITO, npe,!J;onpe,/J;e-
JUleT CO,/J;epmaH1'1e KopnOpaTl1BHbIX npaB
RpoMe Taro, HeOTbeMJ!eMotf COC'I'aBHOJi: 'iaCTbKJ npaBOBOI'O CTaTYca
aKW-IOHepa .RBJlIIeTCJ1 npaBO }"JaCTI-IJ1 ero B ynpaBJ1€HJBI ,/J;e.naM>f altl.lI-I-
OHepHoro 06r.u;ecTBa, 113 'iero J-I BbITeKa€T 'I'p€'TIni npl13HaK, Koropbrn 0'1'-
JlWIaeT y-'l3.CTHJIKa 06r.u;ecTBa OT ero Kpe,lJ;!1Topa, KOpnOpaTl-IBHoe npaBO
OT 06J13aTeJIbCTBeHHoro. TaKaSI Cl1T)'aQ!1H, KaK y:m:e )'Ka3bma.rrOCb, He-
T11IIWlHa .wrn rprot<,l\8HCKO-npaBOBoro pery.JIi'1}X>B8HlfH
TaK!1M 06pa30M, 3m xapaKTepHble oc06€HHocrn npas, B03H11Ka1O-
Il{I1X Ha OCHOBaHI:DI 'lJIeHCTBa aKW10HepB B 06Il\€CTB€ 11 ,l\OnOJlH!11'€J1b-
HbIX 1X cpaRTOB, n03BOJ1J1IOT, no MHeIDHO aBTOpa, rOBOpI-ITh
o C I CaM()(.'"l"Q.HT€1 rpyrIIIbI Cy6"b€K'IHBHbIX npaB -
KopnopaTI-IBHbIX. 62
RA BeJ10B 11 ER IIecT€peBa yKa3bmalOT, "ITO «npasa, B03H!1K3.IO-
LIJ;Me 113 cpaRTa y.mCT!1.fI B pMJqXEalll--IJf J-IMYIlI;eCTsa X03mlcT-
BeHHoro 06r.u;eCTBa, B .ID1TepaT)'pe npl-IHm'o J-IMeHOBaTb npasaMJ-I ymc-
T!1J1 (B fJ.e.nax 11 Kan!1Tanax), 1-IJ1I-I KopnOpaT!1BHbIMI--I npasal'orn. IIpasa
Y'ffiCTWI B ,l\e.nax 11 KaID:!TanaX epHOro 06r.u;eCTBa Hepe,!\KO Ha-
3bIBaKYl' TalOKe HUMJI npasaMl1».63
IlB. CTenaHOB onpe,!J;eMeT KOpnOpaTMBHble OTHOIIIeHWI KaK BHyr-
pemrne OTHOllleHWI (fJ'IH{Ill('ffi1fl BH)'TpI-I opraID13alt!rn). KOTOpble CBJ13a-
HbICpea.n1-£3a1UretiJ-I rroj,j:npaByqaCTIU-IKa I-IJ1>f,.l\PY-
rnr.rn CJ1OBaMI--I, KoprropaT!1BHbIX npas. IIp!1 3TOM aB'I'Op Be,I\eT pe'ib 0
T8.KMX npasax, KOTopble nf,€,IJ;UCTaB.JIffi cyD'b€RTy KaK )"ffiC'lH11Ky
opraHJ13aLtl1l1. Taro-IM!1 npaBaM!1, no era MHeHJ1IO, .RBJ1J1IOTCJ1 npaBO Ha
yqaCTI>-Ie B ynpaBJ1eHID-l, npaBO Ha nlJJlY"eInfe J-IHtiJopMaQID:I 0 ,l\emeJIb-
HOCT!10pr8HJ13aW1K, npaBOHa IX::IJ1y"Iame'iaCTI1J1M)'1l1€CTBanp>f.mncs!1-
opraHJ13arv-n-I, npaBO Ha nlJJlY"eInfe 1JaCT1--I npH6u.rn1 OT ,l\eETeJIb-
HOCT!1 op1:IHI13alum:, npaBO Ha nOJ1b30BaH!1e yc.nyral'orn OpratD13aL[J:Dl,
BIUlKJ'-jaJI npaso Ha 06par.u;eH!1e K opraHJ13aq!1J-I.wrn 3aLIJ;!1'TbI CBO!1X cym,-
eK"n1BHbIX npaB. Co,l\ep:m:aID:!eM Kopnq:JaT!1BHbIX OTHoIlIeHJoJii: BblC1}'Illi.-
lOT He TOJIbKO KOprropaTJ-1BHb!e npasa, HO 11 Kopr:ropaTJ-1BHble 06J13aHHOC-
TIt. Ha 'iJleHe OpraHl13aL[!DI .ne>KJ1T no 0!1JIa:re cBoero
-30-
'lJIeHCTBa, ofiH3BHHOCTb no Hepa:3rJIaIIIeHIDO KOH4>U,I\eHqJ:ffiJIbH[D1 11H-
q>opMaQM11 0 AeflTenbHOCTI-f opraHl13aQM11. CJ1e,lJ;OBaTenbHO, KopnopaTMB-
Hble OTHOIIIeID1H - :no TOJIbKO TaKJ-Ie BH.YTpeHID:!e OTHOllleml.H., KOTOpble
CBJI3BHbIC J-f3alltItTOiiBJ1Y'T'PIDpram cnoco-
6a J-f cpe,I\CTBaMJ1 KOpnopaT£1BHbIX IIpaB J-f C l4CIIOJ1HeIDleM Kopnopa-
TMBHbIX ofiH:3aHHocTeJ"i. IIpI1:nOM fiR C-reIJaHOB COBepIIIeHHo BepHO no-
mraer, '1TO KopnopaTl-fBHbIe OTHcnremtfl KaK OTHOIIIeID1H BHyrpeHHJ1e
npe,I\CTaBJlmOT co60A OTHOIIIeID1H c yqacThieM 'lJIeHOB KOpnOpaTJ1BHOH
opraHH38IUtJI, TO ecTb B H8.IIIeM CJIy'lae, 8Kl<I10HepoB.64
J1, HalWHeQ, YRa3BHHbIi1 aBTop q>opMynJ1pyeT c.ne;:J;y1<I1t€€ onpe.n;e-
neHJ1e KOpr1Opan1BHbIX OTHOIIIemor: 370 003 MemJI,Y Kopno-
pa'I'i'lBHOit: opratm38W1eH, ee 'lJIeHaWII1 TpeTbJ1MJ1 IDI MJ1 (ynpaBJIJ'f-
IO MI-f) opraHl13al\l-'lOHHbIe OTHOIIIeHJ1J'f J1MYlL\€CTBeHlloro xapaK'l'epa,
CBJ13aHHb!e c KOpnopaTMBHblX IIpaB 11 J1X 3arqw:TOA BH)'T-
p:vlOpraHlf3aQ1'10HHUMU CJXJC06aM>I J1 Cpe,lJ;CTSaMl1, 8 TaKme C I1CflOJIHe-
Hi'leM KoprropaT£1BHblX 06Ji3aHHOCTeJL 6S
nOCRD.nbKy, RaK yme6bLJIo nOKa3aHO, fiB. 0renaHOB OTHOCWl'K Kop-
mpaTI1BHb!M npasaM Bce OCHOBHble npaBa aKl\l10Hepa - npaBO Ha AMBI-f-
,/J;eHA, JIMKBMJ<al\l-'l0HHYID KBOT)'I-f yqac-rne B 061l\eM c06paHID!, TO clJaKTI-f-
'1ecKJ-I OH OTHOCIIT K KDpnopaTJ1BHbIM Bce CTrHOIll€HI1Ji, B03IDfK8IO e
MemJI,YaK4J10HepaMl'l I-fc6ll\8C'fB8MK HeJIb3R cor.naCI:ITbCfI CTaKOif TO'-{-
KOH 3peID1H, IIC:JCIOCJJIbK} OTHOIIIeHi'lJI, B03HJ1KaKlll\l-'le no nOBO.n;y no.rryqe-
ID1H,[J;I1Bl1)J;eH,lJ;8 I-fJlJolKB aW10HHOHKBarblnp>fH3.J!WIl1i'Iorrpe,/J;eJ:!eHHbIX
1Op:1J,r I1'£'CK11X clJaKTOB, HBJlIDOTCH 06Ji3aTeJIbCTBBW1 (B 6oJn,lIIJ1HCTBe
c.rryqaeB ,/J;eHemHb=).
IToMMMO 3701'0, fiB. OreIJaHOB ymt3hmaeT B CBoeM onpe,lJ;eJ1eHW1,
'1TO KOprropaTl-fBHbIe OTHOIIIeID1H - 3TO TBKJ1e, KOTophle CB.fI3BHbI C 3B-
lltJ1'I'(ii:i KOpnOpaTJ1BHbIX npaB B1JY'I'PMOPraID13a1V1CIJI1HMJ1 cnoc:of5aMJl J-f
cpe,r:\C'I'B<lM <{BHe opraHl-f3aQM11 TalWro paM OnIOll1£ffiUI He nepeCTa-
K1l' 6bITb OTHc:IlleIDUIMJt: no 3BIQI1Te IIpaB 'lJIeHOB, RaK, HBnpJolMep, OTHO-
llleHJ1fl, CBI!3aI1IIlie C 06panteID1eM B IOpl-fC,IJ;J1KLt"OHllbIe OpraHbi]J,JlJl3a-
IQI1TbI CBOI-fX npas. Ho TaKJ1e OTHOOIeIDUI yme HeJIb3Ji paCCMBTpI-fBaTb
RaK Kopnopa-nmHbJe, nOCKOJIbKY AJlJi 3B TbI npBsa I1CrrOJlb3yKYrCfl
yme ,lIpyrl1e, He KOpnopaTl1BHhle cnoc06hI J-f cpe.n;CTaa».e6
HeJIb3RcornacJ1ThCflI-f C 3TI-fM nOCKOJIbRynpBauuxpa-
Hl1T€J1bHbIe OTHOW€HJ1fl, B03HlfKaICU ne npl1 DI B -
OHHbIe OpraHh! 3B 3Bl1tI1TOA npaaa, He nepeCTalOT OT 3TOI'O 6blTh OTHOIIIe-
Hl1JIMI.1 M aK!U10HepBMl>1 J106Il\€CTBOMC npl-fcyr.u;ei1J1MCI1€I<!K}MKmi.
ITpe,lJ,C'f8BJlF!€T, '1TO CBM no ceoe KplITepIDi, n0J10m€HHbIi1 B OCHO-
ey BbJ):\eJ1eHIrn KoprrqJaTJ1BHbIX UIHII1€Hlm: - "BHYTPI1 OOll\eCTBa» He
HBJ1JieTCHcrtpe,/J; BHyrpl-f06ll\ecTBaI1BCB.fl3J1C
npas, nOH11MaeMbIX BBTOpOM KaK KapnopaTI1BHbIe, MOryr CKJIB;:\bIBBTb-
-31-
CJI If L6.H3aTeJIbCTBeHHble OTHOilieHIDI. Qn;Hmw CaM 8BTOp J1X pa:3rpaHl1-
'1l1BaeT, yml3bIBaJ1, '1TO KopnopaTI1BHble OTHOIIIem-1.A: CtpORTCR He no
cxeMe «.IIOJDKHHK-KpeJJ;Jrrop», a nocxeMe «Y'"I3-C1HI!IK 1H».67
.lIyMaeTCR, '1TO e 06R3aTenbCTBeHHblX If KOpnOpaTJ1B-
HbIX OTHOI1l€Hlrn Mem;:I,Y aKltl10HepHbIMl1 06I.qeCTBaMH 11 aKltl10HepaMI1
H)'mHO IIpOBOWlTb l1MeHHO no c4Jepe CJI ()TlDIl1ffDOC
KopnopaTJ1BHble OTHOWeHJ1R CBR3aHbI c ynpaBJIeHJ.-IeM aKqI10HepHbIM
of5ntec"rnoM- CaMO no ce6e nOlUITl1e ynpaBJIeHJ1R yme Henpl1MeHJ1MO K
CKJIIiAbIBaKJU<J1MCR M aKLI110HepaMJ.-I 11 'I1!aMJo1 06R3aTeJIbCT-
BeHHb1MJ.-I OTHOWeWUIMJ.-I. Be,!!,b 06R3aTeJ1bCTBO B ero rpam,!\aHCKO-npa-
BOBOM CMbICJ1e nOCTpoeHO l1MeHHO ua paBeHCTBe ero CTOpOH, B TO Bpe-
MR KaK paBeHCTBO CTOpoB KOpnOpaTI1BHbIX OTHOilieHIDI 113Haqam,HO
""""""""0.
J1MeHHo npl1cyrCTBl1e ynpaBJIeWieCKOro 3JIeMelITa, HeTImWlH0e AID!
HHbIX rpam,D;aHCKO-npaSOBbIX 0TID.I:I€HJrli, B HeKOTOpOH
CTeneID1 npmirrIDKa€T J1X K npe,!{Mery npaaa. 0):1-
HaKO BCe:1Ke B Hero yKa3aHHble OTHOWeHIDI BXO.n;l1Tb He MOryr.
KaK OTMe<ia1OT yqeHble - npe.D;C73SI1'reJIJ1 HayKi1 a,D,MJ1HIICTpaTl1B-
HOro npaaa, S'laCTHOCTJ1, E.H. ra6 , A.r. pHRBCKJrn - a)\!\0111-
HI1CTpaTI1BHO-npasoBble OTHOIIIeHJ1R uaIIpHM)'lO CBJI3aHbI c npaKn-I'-Ie-
CKOM peaJllf3aql1eM 3a,Qa'l, c}wHKQI1M 11 nOJIHOMO'lI>-IM J1CnOJIllJITeJIbHOM
BJIacT>'I. OTClO a J1X nyfi.m1'iHbrli xapaKTep. BbIpIDK€HHIilll B HJ1X rocy-
pCTBeHHbm J1HT€pec. 6B
)J;.M. OBCHHKO C'illTaeT, 'lT0 «a.,n;MJ1IDICTpaTl1BH0e npaBO - O,qHa J'!3
CaMOCTOJITeJIbHbIX OTpaCJIeM npaaa, npe CTaBJIHlOll-\8H co60M COBOK)'II-
HOCTb npaBoBbIX HOpM, perynHp)'10111;I1x 06I1teCTB€HHble OTHOIIIeHJ1R B
c J'!CIIO.IIlIWlEmM BJIaCTI1 (rocy apCTBeHlIOro ynpaBJIeHl1H)>>.69
JIJI IIonos npRMo yml3b1Ba€T, 'ITO He Bce 06Il.\E:'C'IB€11Hble OTHOIIIe-
H11.R, no CBoeM npMpo e ynpaaJIeH'leCKl1MJ.-1, MOryr 6b1Tb
OTHeceHb1 K npe,!{MeTY a.qMI1IDfCTpaTI1BHOro npaaa. B'lliCTHOCn-l, ::ITO OT-
HOIII€HJ1R, re B CBR3J.-1 C clJ)'HK-WIaDlpOBaHJreM HeroCY,lIapCT-
BeHHbIX 1 (o6r.qecTaeuHbIX ofu,ep;Jrnamfl, KOMMep'leCKMX
CTpyKTYPI1TOMY oe). TaR, Ha3Ha'leHl1e
BHyrpJ1!lapn:rtiHHx If nQZI,06HbIX 11M ynpaBJ.!€fl'II2CI(J.1X 0'I'1D1IeHJ1ft CO-
CTOl1T He B Sbipamemrn J1HTepeCOB rocY,QapCTaa, a S o6ecnE"l€HJ1J1 He06-
Xo,D,J1MGl CaMOO 11 (opraHl13aJ.<l1l1 cOOCTBeHHbIX .r:\en)?O
)J;.H Eaxpax no.nara€T, 'iTO npe,!1;MeTOM a.qMl1IDfc'IpaTI1BHoro npaaa
HBJIJI!OTCH« Kcrropb1eB03HJ1KalOTB 4>oPMJ.-I-
posaHl1H 11 lpOaaH11.R rocy,D.apCTBffiHoi1 3,AMHHJICTpaLPDI (38
eM Tex, KOTOpble pery.ID1J>YIOTCH HOpMa!\oll1 J1HbIX O"rpaCJIeH
npasa), a TaKme 011I0IlIeID1H, B03HJo1KaKn!I1e np>f npMMeHeHIDI nrob1M11
yrDJIIiOMJ"i€HHbIMJ1 npasoM cy6DeKTaMJI Mep Cl,IClUIHI1C1paTJ1BHO-npaBO-
-32-
BOro npl1H)')K)J;eHI1R, I1HbIX Mep a;:J;MJ1ID1crpaTl1BHoro paC-
CMOTpemrn BO BHecy;qe6HoM nop e ma.rrOO rpa H».71
KaK npe;qcTaBJI.HeT KOpnopaTl1BHble OTHOIlIeID1fl J1MeKYI' CXO,[\CTBO C
oT;qenbHbIMJ1 BJf,!\aMJ1 X03J'1ficTBeHHbIX OOH3aTeJIbCTB. TpeX'1JIeHlIaR
KJUK'C1'Xl:mtal-tllJl OOR3aTeJJbCTB fibUla 11,aHa B pafure
JtLA TaJf'fj'K, B.IT EqJI1MO'lIDffia, T.E. A60BOfi «XO:3RrK'TB('HHbE ofuI3a-
TeJlbCTBa» B Ul70 r
ABTOpbl nO,1lpa3,[\eJllfJllf X03ffiiic'rBemn 06J'13aTeJIbCTBa Ita Tpl1
rpylIllbl:
- OOR3aTeJIbCTBa TOBapHo-;qeHemHoro xapaKTepa I1JII1 ofuI3aTeJ1b-
crna Me npe.r\IIpKRTIIJIMJI;
- BHYIP CTBeHHble OOR3aTeJIbCTBa;
- X03J'1ficTBemD-ynpaBJ1eH'I€CKl1e 06J!:3aTeJ1bCTBa.
npl1 3TOM, QJ:J;HaKO, aBTOpbl orosapl1BaJIJ1, 'ITO OTHOIIIeHJ1H, pery.ID1py-
cprnH> ;qeRTeJlbHOC'Ib, 33.KOHo,[\a:reJlb perJla-
MeHTl1J>YeT KaK OOH3ffTeJlbCTBa, IIOCKOJIbK)' npl13HaeT :no LleJJec006pa3-
HbIM. Bno,[\06HbIXCJl.Y'I2RXIIpOl1CxO):J}ITHepaCIIIl1pemec4JepbIl\f'I"icTBID!
HOpM f'})a'IWHCKOro 33.KOHO,!(aT€JIbCTBa, a I1CIDJ1b30Balme cpoPMbl, CJ10-
B 06.rracrn Ipa:!K,!\aHcKOro npana 11 IIOJI)"-II1BIlIei1: OTHOCMTeJlb-
H)'IO K3Koco6ofinpaBOBOtiKaT8'CIU1l172
ee I13)"leIDI€ X03HI"icTBeHHbIX OOR3aTeJlbCTB 6bUIO npo.!\OJImE'HO
B.C. MapTeMbRHOBbIM, ;qonOJIHJ1Blill1Mnpe)J.JlOmeHH)'lO paHe€TpeX'L1IEH-
H)'IO KJIaCCII4»IKaL\IDO, KOTOpaJ'l CTaJIa BbIr.mv:\eTb CJ1ep;yK>III;I1M 06pa30M:
- onepaTI1BHO- X03.HifcrneHHble ofuI3aTeJlbCTBa;
- crneHHbleo6J!:3aTeJIbCTBa;
- HlD-ynpaBJ1€H'll2CKl1e0fuI3aTeJ1bCTBa;
- Teppl1'"I'qJHaJ1bHO- X03.Hi«:rneHHble ofuI3aTeJlbCTBa. 73
OrHoweHW!, 1eCfI B npol.\ecce Bocnpi)l13BO.I\CTBa B
paMKaX oT;qeJlbHoro npe.nnpI1J'1T11J'1 Me ero BHyrpemUIMJ1 nO,1lpa3-
;qeneHl1HMl1, no.qsepraIOTCH perYJIl1py1Ow;eM)' Bl:W\eHC'TBI1JO IIpaBOBbIX
HOpM J1 npl1H1fMaIOT q:.opMY BH)'TpJ1Xo3RticTBeHHbIX npaBoOTHoIlIeHidi
Cyfu.eKTaMMBHY"'PI OTHOIl1eIDIfiBbicrynalOTnpe.!\-
I1pJl.fI'T]:le B LleJ10M 11 era cTpyK'Typflbre 3BeHb./i, o 11 Be)I.y-
lltI1e x03.ll:ficrneHl1)'1O;qeHTeJ1bl1OCTb. Bo3H11KaJOJ.ltI1e Me ID1MI1 OTHO-
llleIDIJ'l MO:1KHO nop;paa.n:eJ1l1Tb lta;qBe rpyrun.l:
a) OTHOIlIeHl1H, CKJIa,QblBaJOJ.ltI1eCR no Be})Tl1KaJ111 B npOl,\ecce pyKO-
BOJ-\CTBa "W3.RiiCTBeHHOf!: ,l-\eHTeJ1bHOCT Mem)I.y conOJ-\'-umeHHbIMH
JlI160 no ropJ130HTaJ1H Me*J-\Y HeCOIIQl:{'II1H€HHbIMR cy&b-
eKTaMM, ffi\I1PI'1M€p, J-IBYMH opraHaMl1 :xo3HioICTBeHHOro pyROBO.!\CTsa;
6) OTHOllIeHWl, CKJIa)J;blBaJOJ.ltI1eCH no ropH30HTaJlH Me*J-\Y BHYTpeH-
HI1MM IIOJ-\pa3J],eJ!eIDlHMH npe}J;!IpIDITI1H B npoL\ecce CJCyII-\€CTBJI€m1H
X03HiicTBeHHOti .!\eRTeJ1bHOCTJ1.
-33-
BBepn1K8.JIbHbIX06H3aTeJIbCTBaXnpemIplf.R"l'Irl;i:l1l1X nO.IlP m:
xapaKTE'pHO AJlfl nOKa3a'1'e.116ll\oropblX
OHO ,lJ;OIDl\HO ,lJ;0CTIf'Ib, a AJlfl ,lJ;pyroti CTOpoHbI - OIIp"'AeJIHllM;' He06xo -
MbIX,IJ,J1J'I ,lJ;0C'IWKeHJ.-1R nD1\a3aTeJJeii Ma.'re B1>IX npe,I\O-
CTaBJ1e!ll1ti, o6ecne<Iem1E' ycJIJI3Hi-f AJlfl npDI13BOJ1CTBa, nop B3IDfMO-
JJ' C,lIpYJ11Mi'lyqaCTHJ1fl'aMJil npOIJ;ecca.
.lLIDI: ropI-f3OHTaJlbHbIX ofuI3aTeJ1bCTB (rpynna 6) B3aHMoAeAcTByKi-
lltHX IIIJJ1P<i.3,Qe.neHHit:, CBJ13aHHbIX JlayxaJIpeCHblM I1J1aHOBbIM al\TOM I1J1H
.n;OroBopDM Will o oBpeMeHHo TeM 11 ,/:\pyrillM, xapaKTepRbIM HBJ:IHeTCH
AJlfl OJJ;HOii C'lOpCIHbI OOJ13aHHOCTb nepe '1H Ul, BbUnIIHE'Inf.fI
pa6OT, OKa3aHWI YCJ1yr B nOJ1b3Y ,lIpyroti CTOpOHbI, a ,lVI.I1,l1pyroti - 06ec-
neQeHJ1e)'CJlOBl'rli AJl.fII1X BbillOJIHeHHH.
J1CTO'llD1KaMJI npaBoBoro peryJIHpOBal1H.II 06.113aTeJ1bCTBel1Horo
B HHOI'O B3aHMO.n;eiic'rBl1H .llBJlJUOTC.II JIOKaJIbHbre HOp-
MaTI1BHble aK'Tbl npe.D.IIpWlTlrli.
lID CBOei1l\OHCTpyK IWpnopaTIIBHbIE' 0TH01IIEHIf.II MeJoK,lly 06!l\e-
CTBOM l1 paMJII BecbMa CXO)KJII C BepTJiIK3.JIbRbIMl1 BH)"I'pHX03JIt-
CTBeHHblMJIICYI'HOW6DIfIM>I no pyKOBOAC1'BY ,lJ;eHTeJIbHO-
CTbIO. KopnopaTHBHble OTHOllleHJ1R TaR:IKe J1MeIDT cpe,lJ;!1 J1CTD'lHI1KOB
lIpaBOBoro peryJIHpOBaHJ1R JIOKaJIbHbIe HOpMaTI1BHble 8I(Tbl, 11 cpe,ll;Jll
HI1X, npe:tK,!\e Bcero, l\OHe>ffiO, YCTaB. Bo3trnKalOT IWpnopaTHBHble OTHO-
I1Ieffi:1H TalOKe MeJoK,lly C[I1(),l('-IJt:HeHHbIMJ1 cy&beK'TaMJ1 - MeJoK,lly aKW1O-
HepaMJil, 06pa3ylOIIJ;JIIMH B CBoeti COBOKynHOCTJII 06ll\ee c06paHJlle (Bble-
IID-ItiDpraHynpaBJ!eHW1 ),J1cal\oD1M06!l\eCTBOM. ecro1
:1Ke IOOpnopaTJ1BHbre OTHOlileHIDI MOryr B03trnKaTb no BOJIe OT,lJ;eJIbHblX
l\OH1'pO.mq>y1O!l\MX 06!l\eCTBO 3T0 IIpIMC'IDJ1IIT B TOM CJ1y-
'lae,l\or HeKOTOpbleaK OHepbIBblH.Y:tK,!\eHbInO,!J;'-lrnmThCRpellleID1lD
05!l\ero co6paHJl.II J1 BOJ1.II BJ1a;:J;elO!l\MX KDH'IpDJ1bI1bIM naKeTOM aK!U'lJ:i
OHepoB DKa3bmaeTC.II peIIIaIO!l\eti np" npHH.R'I'IfiI pellleHHH.
Ec.m-i CJ1e,lJ;OBaTb JIOrJllKe, J136pallllOti nepe<rnCJ1eHHbIMl1 aBTOpaMJII
OI X03.I'BIC'IBE'HHbIX 06.113aTeJIbCTB, TO M<»KHO J1CnOJ1b30BaTb
CJ1COKJ11BllI)'KICfl B rpa»WHCKQM npase 4xJPMY ofuI3aTeJIbCTBa J1 AJ1.II 060-
3Ha'ieHl1.Fll<opnopaTI1BRbIX D'rHOIlEHJorli. O aKO 3TO He 6y,/:\eT KJIaCCWle-
CKOe npaBoBoe 06R3aTeJIbCTBO B TOM CMblCJ1e, lOOTOpHii
BK.I1aAbIBaeT B Hero CT. 307 rK P<P. IIp" paccMoTpeHID1lOOpnopaTI1BHbIX
OTHOlileIDUi, CHMeJoK,llyaro.p1DHeptIbIM 06ll\ecTBOM11 aK-
ltJIIoHepaMJ1 no nOBoJIY }"IacTJ1..I1 IJ'JCJ1e,XI;HJIX B ynpaBJ1eID1J1
.n;eijCIElITeJll:H) BMJJ;HO, 'ITO Otrn, TaK:1Ke KaK 11 06.113aTeJIbCTBa, npe,!J;CTas-
JIHIDT co60ti 0'!1f0C:I1TeJIb llpaBOByID CBR3b Me:)K,!!y yKa3aHHbIMI1 .1111-
J.laMI1. IIpl1 3TOM 05Hapy»omaeTC.II, '1TO oHep, l1Mefl npaBa B (YI'HO-
I1IeHI1I1 05!l\eCTBB 11 .llBJlHHCb ern KpeWlTopoM no o6H3aTeJlbCTsy,
(a al<Q!10HepHoe 06ll\eCTBo COCTI'BE:'TCTBe, ,lJ;OJ1mHV!KOM), MD>K£'T noTpe-
-34-
60BaTb ecJIJ1 He BOCC'"ffiHOBJIeHIDI ero KOHKpeTHOro HapyIIIeHHoro npaJ3a,
TO, no KpaiiHefi Mepe. npl13Ha1ll-ffi pewemrn o6mero co6pamrn He;:tei1CT-
m-rreJIhHbIM.
Oro6H3aTenbCTBa B CMblcne CTaTbl1307 rK P<P KOpnOpaTJ1BHOe OT-
HOllleHl1e KOpellllbIM oopa30M OTJ1I1'faeT J1MeHHO Ta cq:.epa, B lID1'OpOfi
OHO CKJI !BaeTCH - cq:.epa yrrpaBJIemm. YnpaBnemfe caMO no ce6e
npe.IU1OJ13la€T Ha.I1JI'IHI2.JU3yx nQIJ;CJICTeM - ynpaBJIJ'lJOll\ei1 J-f ynpaBJIF!-
eMoi1 - TO eCTb cym,eKTa 11 o&beKTB yrrpaBJIeHI1.fI. IIo::YroMY, KaK yme
yKa3bIBaJlOCb, CyD'beKTbI KOpnopanfBHbIX 01'H0IlleHIrli: "3HaqaJlbHO He
Moryr HaXQIJ;JITbC'JI B paBHOM nOnOiKeHJ1I1, KOTOpoe CBOficTBemJ'J rpam-
AaHCKO-npaBOBblM OOF!3aTeJ1bCTBaM.
Rax OTMeqa€T E.A CyxaHOS, B npo1'J'IBOIIOJlOCTb ST0M)' «B OOF!-
3aT€J1bCTB€fIHOM npaBe c 1JB.J1fu.nbwei1 c 1J1OA I1pOHII.IUI€TCH CI1eLtJicpWKa
Ipa)K,l\aHCKo-npaBosoro pery m. 3.n;eCb Hal160nee HarJIH,lI;HO
npcmBJJHe'rCfI JOpl1,JJ;WleCKOe paseHCTBo c-ropOH-TOBaJXlB.1lS.A€.1IbI.\eB, ca-
MOCTOHTeJIbHO OIIp"',l\e.JlJllOlW'IX xapaKTep "co.n;ep:aGnrne CBOI1X B3ffi1-
MOCBH3eH».7 4
Yn:paBJI€fl'leCK1eOTHOrnemrnnocBoei1cyrWHBJIHRJI'CHUl"HOrneHJ1liMJ1
oprnHJ: o.A.KpacaIRl1KOBorrpe)J;e.lliIeT
CYrHoweHIDiKaK 'TaKlte noCTpOeHHbleHaHaqa.naX J1JIIiIcy6-
opp;l1lffiQIDl CIDI3I1,ROTOpbleHaIIpaBJIeHblHaynop.H,lp'I:elDre
(HOpMamI3aI mo) JfHbIX 06ll\ecTBeHHbIX Ul"HOWeHl1M, ,l\eikTmnl JfX yqacr-
HI1KOBJIJ1\5oHa COl{J1aJIbHbIX ...75
KopnOpaTIfBHble OTHowemrn - onKUIeHWl, B03HI MeJii,l\)'
aK4l10HepHbIM 06ll{eCTBOM "aK4l10HepoM B CBR311 C yqaCTIfeM nocne)\-
Hero B yrrpaBJIemrn a OHepHbIM 06r.qeCTBOM - 6e3YCJ10BHO BRJ11Ot{aJOT
B ce6R 0IIpeJ:\eJIEHHb 3JIeMeHTbl cy6o f. 0Ha IIpoHBJUIeTCJI
npem,l:te Bcero B TOM, 'ITO oor.qeCTBO B IIeJ10M ,!:\OJ1mHO I1O,I];'n1HJ1TbCJI BOJ1e
aKl.\I10Hepos, Bbipa6aThlBaeMOi'i Ha oor.qeM c.o6pamm, KaK BOJ1e JII1Il, Ha-
XOAHLqI1XCH Ha nOJIOmemUf X03Hes oor.qec-rsa. IIO,IJ;'IJ1HJ1ThCH BOJIe KOH-
TpOJ1l1pytOJ.JJ;I1X oor.qeCTBO aKL\I10HepOB KaK Bone oor.qeCTBa BblHym,l:teH J-f
aKl.\I10Hep, He cor.naCHblli c 06 MHeH11eM J-f He J1MelOLqMM B03MomHO-
CTJ1 B03.n;eHCTBOBBTb HB npJ1HJITJ1e pellleHIDI co6paHJ1H a OHepoB "3-
3a He,!:\OCTaTO'UJoro KOJnf'J"ecTsa aKlV'lli. 3.n;eCb TaKme .HaHO npocne:>ID:I-
saeTCR 3JleMeHT cy6oP HaQIDf.
Ell.\e AJ-lRaMJ1HKa OTM€"laJl, 'ITO B aKLIJ10HepHOM 06ll.\ecTBe npaSB
J-f o6&3aHHocTn KOpnOpaIll'IJf IIpOJICTeRaKYI' J13 oTHowem'lli, B KOTOpbIX
HaXO)J;J1TCH COJ03HaH JIWlHOCTb (KOprrOpal{l1.R), KaK 1\enoe K OT,l\eJlbHblM
ID1I\BM JfJIJ1 COlO3HblM JlwrnOCTHM, KBK CBOJ1M qJleHaM. iJcHosHal npl1H-
J.IKII STI1X OTHOllleHHH- STO HepaseHCTBO WIOOHoit: .JII1'iHOCTJ1 J1 OT,l\eJIb-
HbIX ee COCTBBJlffIOlI\HX JIJ1I<. I-1 RBK HJ1 BeJlWKa B 3TOM OTHOIlIE'HlUI: pa3-
I-1I11\B Me I'OCY,!:\BpCTBOM, C OllHoH CTOPOHbl. " BKI\lIOHepHoti
-35-
KIJMII3HHEi.i:, C J\pyroti, ecTByeT BCe JKe aHaJIOnUl MeJoK,lly rocYAap-
CTBem10ff BJlaCTbIO, npHC)'11Ieti nepBOfi, H KOpno 1()HH()Il BJlaCTbIO,
CH 11 BO BTOpJH. 76 KaK yme OTMeqaJIQCh Bblllle, Ha BJJRC'"flIblti
xapaKTep OTHOWeHID1B 06lJ.!€CTBt' J-Io.M Po.lI;HoBa.
Ee3)'t'J1OBlD, :yKa3aHHafl CneQIIIc}:mKa B aKQl-10HepHbIX ()TI1()IlHlHJIX
IIpHCyrcTByeT. IIp rocnW\CTBa BOJThI 6(1.]IblIDllicTBa Ha OOll\eM CQ-
6paHJ1Jf 3aKpeJ1J1eH J-I Ha 3a ypoBHe (cr. 49, 58 3aKOHa
«06 aKJ..tI'DH€PHbIX OOll\ecTBax»), H YCTaBaMJ-I aRqlKlHepHHX OOll\ecTB.
O,!{H3.KO 3TO BJIJ1.IIHHe 06ll\eCTBa Ha He UJIHOC'I'OpOHH€, 8
B3aHMHoe, I1OCJ\'OJ1bIo/ J-I CaMJ1 aKlVrtHepbl HaXO)J.R'I'CJI, no Bblpa»{6DOO
B.II. M030JH-rna, Ha 1I()J1())I\{'H1fi1 X03fleB OOlJ..!eCTBa, a He nOCTOpJHHI1X
.rotq. SOJlee m,lJJ)06H03TOT Bonpoc 6yAeTOCBell\eH B pa3,!J;eJIe, nOCB.FIlL\eH-
HOMnpaBY aKWIOHepOB Ha yqacrJ1e B ynpaBJ1eHlOC
BTOmeBpeMJI caMa noce6enpoQe a npl1HHTI1RpeWeHID! co6pa-
HHeM IIpe)J;llOJIaraeT HeROe cornacosaHJ1e BOJib OT,!J;eJlbHblX 8KQllIOHepoB.
TaK, B npoQecce IIpOSe,l(eHID! o51L\ero 06ll\eIIpJ1HRTbIM HBJIH-
eTCH 06cy)K)J;eHHe BbIHOCJIMbIX Ha roJlOcosaHl1e BOnpoCOS. B cnyqaE'
BOOHJntHOBeHWI MeJoK,lly OT,D;€JIl>HbIM11 8KQllIOHepaMJ1 J1JII1 HX rpynnaMJ1
KoprropaTJ1BHbIX KOH KTOS 4'IKIJ;B B KoJ\eKce KopIX)paTHBHOIU no-
BeJ\eHWI peKOM€H,/:\OBa.rra opraHaM aKQllIOHepHoro 06ll\eCTBa IIpOBO)J;l1Th
cneQJmJllillY10 pa60TY no HX npep;ynpemJ\eIUOO H ypery.lli1pOsaHHIO.
KpoMe TOro, aKQJ10Hep He 06H3aH 6eayCJlOBHO ocrasaTbCH B 'illCJle
yqacTHHKOB 06mecTBa B TOM cnyqae, eCJIJ1 IIpI1HJITble 06LW1M co6pa.HI'I-
eM peweID1fl He OTBe'laIOT ero JIJ1tIHbIM I1HTepecaM. TaK, B c.rryqaHX pe-
opraHJ13aQID-I 05meCTBa I1JIJ1 COBepweHHH KpyrnlOti C)\eJIKH, perneHl1e
06 0J\o6pelUII-f KOTOpOti IIpI1HHMaeTCH 06 co6paH B COOTSE'TCT-
BID'! C 3aKOHOM «06 aKQIfOHepHbIX 06mecTBax», a TaIDKE' BHeceHHH 113-
MeH€Hm1: J.-I JI()I1OJ1HeHll B YCTas 06mecTBa KJ1J.-1 yrsep)K)J;eHWI YCTasa
06mecTBa B Hosoff peJl<lRQllIH, orpaHJ1tUffialOlQHX IIpaBa aKQllIOHepa, OH
l1MeeT IIpaso nOTpeOOsaTb OT 06lJ..!eCTBa BbIRyrIa npJ1HaAITemalQHX eMY
aRQllIti B cnyqae, eCJ1H OH I'OJ1ocosaJ1 nponm npJ1H.11TJ.-1f1 CO<YmE"I'CTB}'
lQero pewemffi 1-1J1I-f He IIpI1HHMaJ1 yqaCTHH B I'OJIOCOBaHWI (n 1 CT. 75
yKa3aHHoro 3aKOHa).
TaKJ1M 06pa30M, O'IeBH,!UIO, 'ITO IOCIpnopaTHBHb1e OTHOWeHWI c'I'pOJIT-
C$1 Ha npilllQl!!llaX KaK 11Wl-tI1H, TaR HID Koop,!J;11HaQIDL
IIpeJ\cTaBJLlleTCfl B03MmKHbIM ccpopM)'J1J1posaTb cJle,!l)'lOll\ee onpe-
J\eJleHHe KOpnopaT11BHbIX npaBOCYI'HCl1leHloc 3T0 npaBOOTHOrneHJ1f1,
B03HJ1AAIOLWIe no nOBo.n;y yqacn-m aKIU1oHepoB B ynpaBJIeHJ1J1 aKQllIO-
HepHblM YKa3aHHbie npasooTHoweHl1f1 CBfl3aHbl c yqaCTH-
eMaKIV1OHepoB B pa6crre o51l\ero c06paHWI, KOH'IpOJleM aKQJ10HepOS 3a
J\eJITeJlbHOCTblO 06mecTBa 11 no.nyqeHHeM HHct>opMaQIIIH 0 J\eJlTeJlbHOC-
TI1 06u.(eCTBa, a TalOf{e c 3cuwrroii npaB aRI.<I10Hepos Ha yqaCTl1e B yn-
-36-
paBJIeHIDI 06Il-\eCTBOM. Pa:3rpaHl1qeHl1e KOprropaTI1BHbIX 11 06H3aTeJIb-
CTBellllbIX OTHcrueHWi MO»mO IIpoB€CTI'I IIO c4Jepe B03HIfKHOBE'ID1H OT-
HOllIeHID1- c4Jepe ynpaBJIeHIDI BKQHOHepHbIM 06il.\ecTBOM. CocrrrercT-
BeHHO B CB.II3H C peaJ1Jl3alU1efi ynpaBJ1eHIJeCKI-IX 4:JytJK!.tI1ti aK1V10Hepbl
06J1a,QalOT oco6bl1'o'! npaBOB1>IM CTarycoM - CTaTYCOM cy6'beKTa ynpaB-
neHIDI no OTHOIIIeHHIO II: epHOMy 06Il-\ecTBY_
J1.J1.lIb111IKI1H IIpe,lVlroKl-lJl ,lJ;ame ,lVIR o603HaIJeHJ1.II KOprrOpaTJ1BHbIX
npaB TepMI1H «KOHTpoJ1bHo-ynpaBJ1€H'lecKHe npaBa>}, TaK ItaR Bce OHH
TaR 11J111 J1H8.Qe CBH3aHb! C ynpaBJIeHl1eM o6il.\ecTBoM. B '1'0 :lKe BpeMH
,D;aHllUfi TepMI1H, no ero MHeHl-OO, I103BOJ1R€TOTrpaID1qI1Th TaKl1e npaBa
OT HHblXnpaB aKqI10Hepa.77
lo.A. M€T€J1eBa onpe.n;eJIHeT xapaKTep CBH311 aKLplOH€p3. C 06il.\ecT-
80M Ita1\: «'lJIeHCKOe npaBOO'THOIlJ€HHe, CM3b Ha OCHOBe 'lJIeHCTBa B 06-
Il-\eCTBe I1JIJ1 ('IT{) TO:1K€ cBMoe) HB OCHOBaHI1Jo1 yqaCTJ1.II B HeM, talK 3'1'0
onpe.n;eneHO B q. I CT. 96 rK 1'4>>>.7 8
MHorne yqeHbIe Bbl)J;eJIm<Yr ocoooe nOHRTI1e 'lJIeHCTBa B aR:W10HepHOM
06il.\ecrne, XOTR npl13TOM rl1 BKJI3,!J;blBaeT B Hero CBOe3H8.-qeID1e.
TaK, .!LR JIOMBKI1H no,lJ; 'lJ1eHCTBOM nOHl1MaeT «KOMI1J1eKC CBH3efi
yq3.CTHI1KOB opraHH3aQID1 RBK MeJoK,lly cd50ii, TaK 11 C caMoM oprBHH3a-
QMefi, 'IT{) IIpOHBJ1H€TCR B HaJIWIJIII1 Y HI1X npaB 11 06H-
3BHHoCTeti:, TO eCTb 'lJIeHCKoe npaBOOTHOllIeID:!e».7 9 TaKI1M 06pa:30M,
nOH.HThlR 'lJIeHCTBa 11 'lJIeHCKOro npaBOOTHOIlIeHl1R BBTopoM OTmKUe-
CTBJlHIOTCH.
IIo MHeHHIOymt3BlllIOl'OaIJ"ropa, nOHRTI1e «qJJeHCKOro» HID'! KOpnopa-
TImHOro npaBOarHOIIJeHHH cyrqecTayeT RBK PO.l\OBoe rreJIbH) K
npaBOOTHOllleIDl. B03II1'1KaI(Ul:1M He TOJThKO B aKLp1Oll€pHbIX 06il.\eCT-
aax, HO 11 B npO'illX op l1MelOlQI1X 'lJIeHCTBO, HanpMMep, B
APyrJ.-IX BJ1,!I,aX 06il.\ecTB, B ::«>3HiicTBeHHbIx TOBapl1lll;e-
CTBaX, BIIJXlI13BO,l1CTBellllOMI1 KOOIIepaTHBe.nOHJ1Tl1e
:IKe aKQJtOHepH£ID npaBOOTIIOllIemm no OTiiOllIemoo K WJYM BblllleYJffi-
3BHHbIMHBJUIE."I'CJIB1-1,ZJ;OBb1M. KaK C erOTO'lKOn3peHJ1.II
O(':()()THJl1€Hl nOHJ1TID1 ROpnopaTI1IlHoro 11 npaBOOTHO-
IlIeHH.H H)'iKHO cornaCI1TbCfL
COBepweHHO APyroe 3Ha-qeHl1e "MeeT, no MHeID1IO.!LR JIOMaKl1Ha,
TepMHH «npaBO 'lJIeHCTBa». 1I0Jl 1IOCJ1€,1J;H11M OH nOHl1Ma€T COBORyn-
HOCTh npaB, KO'IOpbBW HS,AeJlH€TCH BKL\I1CHep B 06MeH HB c.D,eJIaHHl:rli
B3HOC B YCTaBHbrl1 KBIIHTaJ1 06il.\eCTBa. 80 liB. f'I€Ba TalOKe IIOID1-
MaeTnpaBO QJleHCTBB ItaK E!)J;!nfbDi KOMlIJleKC npaB BKQI10HepoB.B1
OM PO,!J;Hosa nOJl QJ1eHCTBOM IIOHI1MaeT IIpJIHB,l(JI€)KHOCTb K opra-
HI13BQHI1, npH3HaBaeMofi I'paJKJI.aHCKl1M aaKOHOJ\aTeJIbCTBOM npaBO-
06pa30BaHl1eM, oTBe<ialOil.\ei1:TPe60BaHIDlM, yKB3aHHbIM B
3BKOHe, I1HbIX HOpMaTI1BHbIX BKTaX 11 yCTase llpl1 3TOM OHa
-37-
OTJrn'IaeT 'lJIeHCTBO talK ,wUnn;eeCH npaBOOTHOIIIeHHe OT npaBa 'lJIeHCT-
aa KaK B03MO)1\.H()(.'TIt: IIpMHa,!VIemciTb K cOCTaay KopnopaIJ;M11. TaK!1M:
06pa3OM, npaBO 'lJIeHCTB1l Y Hee - ::rr0 npaBO BXO,WfTh B COCTaB yqaCT-
HI1KOB IOpl1,!U1'-JeCKoro JII1n;a. OTBe'lalOll\ero TpeOOBaHI1RM 3aROHa " YC-
TaBa. 82 IIpe.l\CTaBJLfleTC.f1, '1TO 3,I\eCb npaBO '1JIeHCTBa nOID1MaeTCH talK
Op;l>-IH "3 3JIeMeHTOB npaBocy6'beRTHOCTIf BKLlI10Hepa. B TO :me BpeMfi
aBTOpOM I1CnOJIb3YeTCJ'! " ,lIpyroe 3Ha'1eHi1e npaaa 'lJIeHCTBa (talK COBO-
KynHOC'rn npaB): «XCiR J1 J11000e cyD"beKTMBHoe npaBO, npaBO 'lJIem:rna
COCTOI1T 113 npaBOMO'll1R aKu;J1OHt:'pa Ha CBOI1 Aet1CTBMJi 11 npaBOMO'lJ1H
Ha 'lynme ,!J;etiCTBI1Ji - Ha,!J;E1icTBI-m BKL\I-'IOHepHoro 06ll\ecTB1l no COOJIlO-
AeHIDQ npe,lJ;'bJiBJUleMbIX TpeOOB1lHi1H».B3
o.R BenOycOB nOHJ1M3.eT DO,!J; '1JIeHCTBOM S OTKpbITOM 8.Kl<I'1O
eCTBe npas 1--1 06R3aHHOCTeA aJa:CID1epa no ornowe-
HIDO K 06ll\ecrny, B03HMKalOllI.)lIO J13 ycraBa nocne C03)IaHHH 06ru;ecTB1l}).84
He803MmKHOCOrJIaCJ1TbCRC 3T!1M:MHeHHeM, npaBa aKW'i-
OHepOB He B03HI1KaKIT 1--13 YCTaBa. Hanpl1l\l!ep, paCCMOTpMM Cl1'ryaql1IO,
Kor aKL\I-'IOHepnp:V106peTaeTBCeaKlU1I106meCTBanO,l\orosopyK)'IIJ1l1-
npOA3,)KH, J-1 6y,!J;eT H:8J1HTbCR, TalU1M ofpa30M, era e,D;I1HC1'BeHHbIM yqa-
CTHI1KOM, '1TOIIOBJIe<leT 3Bco6oA H3MeHEH]:m YCTaBa 06-
ll\ecTBa, nOCKOJIbKY e)J;>1HCTBeHHbrn yq3.CTH11K 06meCTBa ,n;OJDKeH 6bITI:.
nOMMeHOBaH B YCTaBe. ECJII1 CJIe,!J;OBaTb J10rnxe o.R EeJIOYCOBa, TO ,!J;O
TOra MOMeHTa, norta J13MeHeHHH YCTaBa He npolILJD1 rocy.l\BpCTBeHH)110
pEl'HC'lpaQJ:oo, DH He MO:>KeT HBJIffThCJi aKqMOHepoM 06meCTBa. O,l\HaKO,
::rro, lI'OHe'ffiO, He TaR, J10YJIY'II1 BHeCeHHbIM B peeCTp BKqMOHepoB 06:w;e-
CTBa, OH BIlOJIHe MmKeT Ocy:Il\eCTBJUlTb Bce npaBa J1 HeCTI1 ace 06H3aH-
HOCTI1 aKltIlOHepB eme,!J;o MOMeHTa 8HeCeHI1f[ 113MeHeH1'1ii 8 YCTaB.
IIpe,!\CTaBJUleTCH B03MO:IKHhIM c4JopMYJ1I1poBaTb CJIe}J;,)'IOIu;ee nOHH-
me '1JIeHCTBa. YJneHCTBO J1J111 yqacme B aKL\I-'IOHepHOM OOll\eCTBe -
CJIO:>KHbrn KOMI1J1eKC npas 11 OOR3aHHOCTeA aKL\I-'IOHepoB, a TalOKe KOp-
pecnoH,llMp :I1M npaB J1 06H3aHHOcreH aKqI1OHepHoro 06ll\eCTBa,
:I1MelOll\I1X KaK KOpnoparnBl!hrn. TaR" 06H3aTeJlhCTBelll1blA xapaRTep
3T0 KOMIlJleRC arHJrnemrn, CBR3eti, CKJIBAhmalOll\I1XCfl Me*.l\Y 06ll\eCT-
BBMH 11 aKW'iOHepaMI1" l1IVIelOll\I1x CMewalll1yID IIpl1po,!\y
OntOCI1TeJ1bHO KJIaCCJH}mKan;MI1 npaBOOTHOI1EHJ1ji, 803Hl1KalOll\I1X
Me*.l\Y BKqOOHepaMR" BKu;I-roHepHbIM ofuQecTBoM. no 06ll\enpI1HHTOMY
KpWrepl1lO« - H€HMyllI;€C'IEeHbIe» B HByKe TaIOKe He
CJ1(:I)IDfJ1()C e,!!,l-fHoro MHeHI-iR. RaK npe,!J;CTaB.J1ReTCH, B npoQecce 83al1-
MO;:J;eHCTBIDI 06meCTB I1I1X yqaCTHI1KDS CKJIa,n;bIBaIOT 11 T€, J1 ,l\pyrne
Eme E.IO BOJIbcp C'Il1TaJI, '1TO aKW'iOHepHOe npaBOO'IEOweHl1e no-
pmK.!IBeT PHA OT,l\eJIhHbIX npaBOMO'll1ti BKqI10Hepa, HOC KaK I1MY-
Il\eCTBeHHbrn, TaK J1 H€lIMYIl\eCTS€HHbIii: xapaKTep.85 3Tot1:me n0311IJ;1111
1BaeTCR J1 HE. t1>oMI1'1eea. I<OTOpaH C'lI1TaeT. 'lTO «B npa80
-38-
'lJIeHCTBa BKJII{)-qeHbI pa:3HbIe no xapaKTepy npaBa, KO"IUpbIt' MO:>KHO
pa 1ThHa CTBeIllib1eI1HeI b1e(nI1'lHbIe)npaBa.
3ro Hm160Jree pacnpocTpaHeHHmI RJIaCCl lfI npaB aKQJ1:0HepoB.
CpeJU-I npaB Ha3b1BaKJTCT.IE' 1e npaBa: Ha nOJ1Y-
'1eH11e 'laCTI1 npfiuII1 06Il\ecma, Ha n0J1Y'leH11e <mCTH I-iM CTBa npH
DlOOIl\eCTBa (npaBoHa HH)'lOKBOTY), CBOOO.n;HOro
pacnopHmeID1F! aKW1HMl-f, 'Ip€6oBamm OT' ooIl\ecTBa BblKyna I1pI1H3,lI.JI€-
)!(al1till'-l-iMa .< ..>K npaB(lMOTHOCmnpaBOHa
yq8.CTI1e B ynpo.BJIeHID1 8K'-<I1OHepHbIM npaBO Ho. KOH1pOJIb
3a,lI,E'H're11b1! ao OOIl\eCTBa 1'1 npaBO Ha nOJ1yqeH11e J1H-
q,opMaQIDI 00 OOIl\eCTBe».86
.Its. JIoM3.KI1H npl13HaeT e Hern-.l)'lL\eC'I'BeHHbIX OTHO-
ll1eH11 Mem.I\Y aKLtl-fOHepaMl-f 1'1 OOlL\eCTBOM. H€JfM}'l1lf2CTB€ble npaBa
aKQJIJ:OHepoB olIocpe,nyKJT I1X .JIWIHOe yqacTHe B JJ;€HTeJIbHOC'I'J'1 06r.q,eCT-
Ba.. «He Bb13bIBa.€'T COMHeH11J'1 TOT o.KT, 'ITO I1X HeJIb3J'l OT'HeCTII K KaT€-
rap= HHHX npaB, II1JCKOJIbItY TaKHe npaBa, talK npaBO Ha
yqac-rne B ynpaBJIeHID1 aKQJIJ:OHepHb!M 06lL\€CTBOM, Ho. KOH1pOJIb 3a ero
, npaBO Ho. J1Hq,opMo.Ql1KJ, B03Hrn<aKJT He no nOBO)Iy
HHblX6JIar. CJ\pyroti CTOpOHbI, oHMHeno)J;XO}:UITI1 IIO)J;RJIaC-
CWleCKoe onpe.v,e.netrne JIWlHbIX HeI1M)'IQ€CTB€HHbIX npaB, KOTOpble He-
pa3pblBHO CBfl3aHbl C JU1'lliOCThIQ ynpo.BOMOqelllioro CyD'beKTo., B CI1.IIY
'1eroH€MOIYf O-rqyJK,1WTbCJIJ1HbINlJU1L{aM. AKLtl-fOHep, HanpDTl1B, MmKeT
nepeMB3.Tb CBOH H€UMylQ€CTB€lllible npaBa, Ho.np>1Mep, npo.BO l'OJioco..
IIo3TOMY nepe)J;a'la He BeHHbIX npo.B COIIpOBom,!\aeTCfl I1X
ymI3KOti C I npo.BaMJ1116e3 3TOro HeBa3MIJJKHa».87
B '--I€J10M me, talK nOJ1o.ro.€T aBTOp, aKLIHOHepHoe npo.BOOTHcrueml€
HOCIIT rn-.I)'IL\eCTBeHHbIi1 xapo.KTep. 3'1'0 06ycn0B.neHO TeM, '1TO J1H'--I0,
I1pIW6peoraH aKQJIJ:H Ho. B03M€3,11,HOfi: OCHOBe, pacc<MI'bIBaeT no I'ICTe'-le-
H11H oopeJ1eJ1€HHOI'O nepl10,11a Bp€MeH>f Ha nOJ1yq€HH€ '1aCT>f npl15b1J1H
OT A€HTeJlbHOCTIf 06Il\€CTBa B BM)J;€ J\lffiK,D;e OB. 06 HMy:Il\ecTBeHHOM
B03M€Il\€HIO'Ipe'-lbl1)J;eTl'lnpHJ!1IIKB '--\I1l-faKLtI10HepHoro aa
B3fJ1J1.I1b1 )J;.B. JIoMaKillffi 0 npeOOJ1a,11aIOlL\€M I xapaK-
repe aKW1oHepHoro npaBOOTHCUl€Hlm pa e.JIHeT 11 lOA. MeTen€Bo.. 89
E.A CyxaHOB, HaIIpO'T'HB, C'-II1TaeT, '1TO KopnopaTl1BHb1e OT'HOUleID1R
l-iM€lOT '1eTKYJO €CTBeHH)'1O mmpaBJ1eHHOCTh, 05ycJDBJIeHHyro ca-
MI1MxapaKTepoMJ\eHTeJIbHOCTl1cp.dID lJIKaK 90
C.H. Bl-fHOBOti npMCOeJllfHJl€TCfl K MHeHJ1IO E.A Cyxo.HOBa, C'Il1'1'o.lO-
llIel'O npaBa H 06fl3aHHOCTI1, CCCTaElJlfilOll(J1€ CO)J;ef»KBHHe KOprrOpaTI1B-
Hb1X npaBOOTHmlIE'lDDl, I1Myw;eCTBeHHbIMH. J1CXO.LI,fl113 STOro n0J10)K€-
H11fl aBTOp no.rrara€'T HeyMeCTHbIM npDBOAHTb KJlaccrn}mKaql1lO npaB
aKlU10Hepa Ho. JlJ:M)lllJ;eCTBeHHble JIJ: HeJIJ:M)'IQ€CTB€H.g1
-39-
Bn CreIIaHOB TaK:lKe ymep:1K,l\aeT, 'ITO KOprropan1BHble OTHOilIe-
H11fl, .fIBJ1flflCb OprnIDl3altI«JHlIbIM, OTHOCflTC,fI K RaTeropW11 HMJ'll-\eCT-
BeHHbIX. ApryMeHTawrn ero CBO)J;l1TCI1 K CJ1ep;yIOIIJ;eM)'. OH nOJIaraeT,
'ITO B OCROBe I«IpnopaTJ1BHbDl: OTHOilIeI:1m1: J1emaT <!KOlIOMK'1€CIDIe OT-
HOilIeHtffi HOIi co6cTBeIrnocnf, TO eCTb OTHOlllemfJl no npl1-
CBoeIDnO MaTepJffiJIbHbIX 6Jrarll'lJJ1JleKTl1B yqaCTIDI B
ynpaBJ1eHI1I1 KOprropaTJ1B1JoA opraHI13aQl1eA J-f nOJ1Y'1eHl1e -
QJ111 0 ee ,lJ;emeJ1bHOCTI1 'lJIeHaMl1 .fIBJ1fleTC,fI Hl1'-IeM IfiIbIM, RaK cneQI1-
4>WIecKMM IIpOHBJIeHI1eM 3I<OHI':JMWIeCKI1X 0THIJllEHJ1ii: KOJLJieKTI1BHOA
COOCTBeHHOCTl1. l1MeHHo n03TOMY. RaK npe,IICTcIB.l1fleTCfl }'Ka3aHH0M)'
asTOpy, MOmHO C,IJ;eJIaTb BhIBO,IJ; 00 npl1po):\e MHHbIX
OTHoweH11J:i,92
O,!!,HaKO Bce:me KameTCIl, 'ITO}'Ka3aHHoe COBepWeH-
HO HeCBJ 06 HHOCTi'1 yKa3aHHbIX CITHOIIIeIDDl,
a I'OBOplITJ1I1llIb 0 TOM, 'ITOOrrnTeCHOCBH3aHb!C OT-
HOWeHIDIl\rn no IIpI1CBOeIDnO MaTepIffiJIbHbIX omI'. Pa:3YMeeTCH, aKWlO-
Hepb! yqacTByIOT B pa6crre 06rqero c06paHl1JI He noTOMY', 'ITO ynpaBJ1e-
Hl1e 06I.qeCTBOM fiSJ1ReTCfl ATIR HI1X CSMOI.\€.JIbIO. ROHe'lHOW QeJ1b1O
RBJUIeTC,fI l1MeHHO no.rryqerrne OT 06I.qeCTBa J1MYII-\eCTBeHHbIX 6JrarB BI1-
Ae ,IJ;I1Bl1,JJ;eH,LIOB I1.1IW\E1J,l1,8WtOHHC.-i KBOTbI. TaIrnM ofpa30M, yqacme 3,K-
QJ10HepoBByrrpaBJIeHIDlOOI.qeCTBOMTecHOCB.R3aHOC 1
UI'H1JllIEH]:1.fIMI( no nOJIY'leIDnO 11 'IaCTI1 J1M.YII-\eCTBa JII1KBI1-
,ll}tpyeMoroo eCTBa, O;:J;HaKO, KOHe'lHaH L<eJIb, npec.rre.QyeMaH aKqI10He-
paMJ1 IIpI1 BC1}'IIJlemrn: I1MI1 B npaBOOTH£IIlEHI no ynpaBJIeHHlO06w;eCT-
BOM, HeM01'KeTCBI eTe.JIbC'l'B(E8TbOCaMoMI MxapaKTE:pe
TaID1X OTHOllEHIrli
Ha OC06eHHOCTh Henocpe):\C'IBeHHOO L<eJIl1 opraID13aL<110HHbIX OTHO-
weW1A }'Ka3b1BaJ1 ellle OA RpacaB'OO«)B. OH OopaIQaJ1 BHl1Maffife. 'ITO
OpraHl13awrn RaK q>oPMa ,l:\eflTeJIbHOCTH JllO,IJ;eJ:i He .fIBJIfleTCfl caMou;e-
J1bIO; DHa Ram,qbrn pa3 no CBoeMY' co.n;epmaffiflO H 4JopMaM pea.m13aIU1H
eJLReTCR CO,lJ;epmaHt1eMTeX LteJ1eA, K ,l:\OCTl11'KeW1lO I«1IOpH'C
ycrpeMJ1fIE'T CSOlO ,lJ;emeJ1bHOCTb 'IeJ10SeK J1J111 COQl1aJ1bHDe oopa30sa-
W1e. BMeCTe C TeM opramJ:3aWloHHoe OTHoweHl1e o6J1<l):\ae-r CBOeJ:i c06-
CTBeHHoA LteJ1blO - ynop,HAO'lE'HIJ2, opraml3OBaHHOC'rb, HOpMaJ1J13aQl1.f1
OpraHI13yeMbIX OTIICIl1eHRii Co.n;epmaHJre J-f 4>opMb1 ynopsr.n;O'leHWI
BC€I.1;eJ10 no.n;'U1HeHbI TOMY, 'ITO ynopRAO'fV!SaeTCH, H n03TOMY opraHI1-
3yeMoe 11 O 1OHHO€' OTHOWeHl1e l1MelOT O)J;Hy H Ty:me LteJ1b, 110
3'1'0 He 11CRJJIO'meT HaJIWffiH Henocp€,JJ;CTBeHHOA (i5.mDKaHweA) LteJIl1 op-
ramI3aWIOHHoro oTHoweHl1Ji. 93
IIocKOJIbKY o&betcruM KopiiopaTI1BHoroo afH1JIUOTHOWe-
W1H .flBJlJieTCH opraID13allJ1,H Jlpyrl1X OTHollIeW1w, TO ,IJ,yMaeTCH, 'ITO H B
3'I'0M HymHO npl1COeJIHHI1TbC.fI K MHeHrnD o.A RpaCaB'lI1KOSa 0 TOM,
-40-
'ITO OpraHJ13aqllOHHbIE' UfH1)IIIeHWI no CBOeH cyrn HBJIHlOTCH Hel1MYll-1e-
CTBelll1b1M11.
)J;ei1:C'"I'BI'ITeJIbHO, eCJII1 paccMcrrpeTb, Hanpl1Mep, KopnopaTl1BHble
no nOBOAY coooILIeln'lJ:) aKL\I-'IOHepaM 0
C03bme J1X oOILIero c06pamU1 l1JII1 no nOBOAY J1X npaBa rQJIOCOBaTb J1I1-
60 J130:MpaTb onpeJIeJIeHlThlX B opraHbI oo:w;ecrna, TO BM,D;HO, 'ITO
}'Ka3aHHble 0'I'H0Wel1J1.II He HOW CBJl3i1 C i1 He
J1MelOT J1 nooTOM)' He Moryr 6bITb OTHeCeHbI R KaTeropl1l1 J1MYll-\eCTBeH-
HbIX. Ha 3TO OOpaU<3-lOT BHl1MaHl1e MHorne aBTOpbL TaR, II.B. CTenaHOB
}'Ka3bIBaeT. 'l'I'O cneQJ1 i1Ka npaBa Ha Y'-JaCTl1e B ynpaBneHi1J1 COCTOJ1T
B TOM, 'lT0 OHO J1I1llleHO CO,1\epmaHJ1.IL YKa3alll1oe
lIpaBO J1Mee-r 'iI1CTO opra xapaKTep. IIpaBo H3. ynpaBJIe-
HJ1e, B OTJiI1'-Jl1e OT OpraHJ13yeMbIX C ero mMWU>IQ (11'HOweHroJ:, npe;zJ;-
CTaBJIHeT lIpaBO HenMyll{eCTB€HHoe J1 HeJIWIHOe. 94
JUt TaKme C'rnTaeT, 'ITO BHyTpI'1KOpnopaTl1BHble
OTHoweHIDI HOCHT BbIpa)K€HHbIi1:He HHbIi1: xapaKTep J1 pery-
.1illpyKYrCH c nOMOIl\blO HOpM KopnopaTl1BHoro npasa. 1I5
C.IiBpaTyCb,OTHeCH OTHOWeHWIR
BeHHblM, pacc)'iK,DPJICJle)IylOIl\I1M oopa30M. «Pa3Jllf'-JIDI MeJii,llJ opraIrn-
3aQJ10HHblMl1 J1 J1M)'llI;eCTBeHHbIMJil 0'I1I0lIIeHI1HM np0I1CTeKalOTJ13 TOro,
'ITO lIpoQeccy Henocp pacIlllfpE'HHfJO ICTII'-JeCIOC)I'
n:pm I1TeMCaMblMnpoQeccyHenocpe,!\CTBeHHOW X03IDICTBeH-
How,!\eHTeJIbHX:TII lIpe,!\llIecrnyeT ,lIeHl€JIbHOCTb noop STOro
lIpoQecca. 3ro - HeoTb€MJIel\olbrlf IIpI13H3.K IIJIaROBOro X03SIiiCTBa.
OpraH"-3aql10HHaH,l\eHTeJIbH0CTb MO:1KeT 6bITb pa3JIWlHaJI - no py-
KOBO,1\CTBY X03HHCTBOM. no PYKOBO,!\CTBY COltl18JIbHO-ityJibTypHbIM
CT}JfJIfl'eJIbC To, 'ITO ORa HanpaBneHa Ha I I.1;em:r, Ha
TO, 'IT06bl C03,!\aTb ycJ.I<EHR, e X03HiicT-
Belll1yrol1emenbHoCTb, C KOTOpOH CB.IL3aHbI B nepl1o,!\ J1MY-
Il\ecrneHHble fJ'IH(IlleHlIR MeJii,llJ ee Henocpe,!\CTBeHHbIMl1 yqaCTHI1Ka-
MJ1, He 03Ha'IaeT. 'ITO opraI1J13<\lU'IoHHble (11'HOWeHIDI, B03HJ1Ka1OlltI1e
MeJii,llJ peryJ1l1pyIOIQI1MI-f OpraHaWf, CTaHOBJlTCJ1 J1MY1I-1eCTBeHHbIMl1 (11'-
HOWeHI1HMI1. .. 1OHHbIe 0TH0WeHI1fI - J1HOW, 'IeM J1MYll-\eCT-
selll1bleBI1,ZJ; OTHOWeHHW>.96
Eonee Taro, C.R BpaTyCb OTHec IWpnopaTIfBHble npaBa K JIJf'-JHblM
HeMMyIQ€CTBeHHItIM nOTOMY, 'ITO OHI1, no ero MHeHJ1lO, «Heo'f'-1Y'K,!\ae-
MbI, HeOTl1em:rMbI (11' 'lJIeHa opraHU3alU61 narOMY 3m npasa yrpa'lJ1Ba-
IOTCH IIpI1 BbIXo,!\e 113 Hee}).97
OAH8KO, ,llJ'Ma€TCH, 'ITO no 3TOM)' KpI1Tepl1lO l-mpnopaTl1BHble, :J1JIJ1, no
TepMl1Honornl1 )'K3.3aHHoro aBTopa, 'lJIeHCKl1e OTHOWeHWI, EaK pa3
HeJIb3HOTHeCTI1KJlI1'-JHbIMH CTb I CT. 150 I'K pcp
YCTaHaBJII1sa€T. 'iT0 JlWlHble Hft1M)'1ll€CTBEf1Hble npaBa J1 ,!\pyT'Vle HeM8-
-41-
TepuaJIbHbIt' 6JIara H eMbII1Hen€peMB3.eMbIJ\pyrMMl'IXX.'I:i5oM.
B OTJJWU1e err ID1X KOpnopaTl1BHbIe rrpaBa MOryr OT'Iym,IlaTbCJ1 nocpe):\-
CTBOM OTqym',[\eHIDI aRqIrn. I\poMe TOro, Iffi-K }'K1i3bIBaer MH. Marreillffi,
BamHblMnpH3fIal«JMJJ1.f'IHbIXHe rrpaBRBJ!RerCRI1XHa-
rrpan.neHHOCTh Ha Bb1.f1BJJeffi1e 11 pa3BlfTl1e 11H.IJ;rmlJ,! yaJThHOCTI1 JIM'IHOC-
TI1. KopIlOpaTI1BHble rrpaBa TaKOM HaIIpaBJIeHHJJCTH He l1MelOT.
o.Al\paCaB'II1KOBoo.upa3,D,€J1l1JI npaBOBl>leHeI1M)'llIe-
CTBelll1ble OTHOIIIeID1.f1 Ha JIM'IHbIe HelIMyIII;€CTBE'HlIbIe, OTHOlIIeHl1.f1,
CKJI3A!>IBaKJU<I1eC.fI no nOBO.n;y 00beKT0B TBopqeCKoti J\eHT€.JIbHUC'I1t: 11
OpraHJI3alV'JQHHble 0'I'I101lleHJ1. TaKI1M 06paaoM, o.A KpacaB'OO«JB 01'-
Hec npaBa, BXOJ1 e B CQlWpma1I1'1e OTHOllIeHl1ti, C.fI
no nOBO.n;y 06'b€K'TOB TBOpqecmii: J\e.flTeJIbHOCTI1I1 o
OTHOWeID1fi,K 99
CpeAl1 O'IECUIeHRii, B03H11KaKJIqI1X Me*.l\Y <lKllI10H€pHbIMI1 06rqecT-
BaMl1 11 aKllI10H€paMI1, MOiKHO HaWrI1 11 OTHOW€ID1.f1 l1M)'llI;eCTseHHbIe.
IiecoMHeHHO, 06.f1:3aTeJIbCTBelll1bIe OTHOllieHillI, CBR3aHHble c npaBOM
aK!{l10HepaHaIn1Iy'I€tme J\I1BJiI)J;elV\aI1JIJ (HHQjiiKBOTbI,HQC.RT
BbIpaiKeHHbrn MMyweCTBeHHbIti xapaKTep.
I\poMe TOm, KOpIIOpaTJilBHoe n:paBOOTH:IIIefle, Iffi-K 11 06H3aTeJIbCT-
B€HHOe, HBJl.IIeTC.fI 0IE00IeHJteM, l1Me OTI£)CJrreJIktibIti xaprocrep,
IIOClW.IIbKY ClI'.II1JJ1bIBaeTCfl OHoscerM Me*.l\YROHKpeTHbIMJiI cy6'heKTaMJil.
PaCCMaTpl1Nm arHcrIIeHJIH Me*.l\Y 8K!{110HepaMH 11 06:w;€CrnaMJil,
HeJIb3.f1 He KOCHyrbCH 11 Bonpoca 0 cywecTBOBaHJ1}1 npaBOBOii CBR3Ji1
Me*.l\Y caMl1Ml1 epaMl'1 06:w;€Crna, ROTOpbrn TafQK€ HBJUIeTC.fI
CnOpHbIM 11 TeCHO CBR3aH C BOrrpOCOM 0 npl13H3Hm1 aK!{l10HepHom 06-
llIeCTBa o!TI,eJ\l1HeID1eM KaI1I1TaJ1(lB JJI1I5o c6be)1HH€HI'1I2M J11>-IQ.
'1'paJ1rn!:r1OHHO B TeOpJ1}1 aKqI1OHepHoe 06rqecTBO OTHOCl1TCH K 06'b€-
JII1HeHl11O Ka!1I1TaJIOB" C'lJiITaeTCR, '1'!'0 J1W1HOCTb aKLUfOHepoB He J1MeeT
3Ha'IeHWlI1"X ,ID1'IHoe yq3.CTl1e B AemeJ1bHOC'TIf o6rqeCTBa He TPe6yeT-
C.fI. TaKl1e B3rJ1HJ1b1 6bIJI11 BbICK1l3aHbI erqe HeMeqKIlM yqeHb1M PeHO
(Renaud), KOTOpbIti C'IJTIaJI, 'ITQ OT,lIeJIbHble aKQl10HepbI He CBR3aHbI
Me*.l\Y co60:M IIJiI npaBaMJ1, IIJiI o6sI3amrocTmrn, a nOToMY J1WfHOCTb ar-
AeJIbHbIX aKl[I10Hepos He I1MeeT HI1K1lKOro 3Ha'IeHIDI. 1OO
3T11X)KeB3r.IDUJ;OB Hrr.H.ryccaKOIlC1\.Jdt,nOJ1araR,
'ITQ J1I1'lliOCTb a.KLUfOH€poB He "MeeT lIJiIK1iKoro 3Ha'iemm, CJIe,llOBa-
T€JIbHO, oco6etnrocTI, aKl[I1OHepHbIX 061l.\€Crn, 11J!JiI, MK OH elL\e I1X Ha-
3bIBaeT, TOBapHllteCTB, «OT,ID1<JaIOll.\<lRI1X 01' Bcex J\Pyrnx BJ.1,!\OB TOBa-
pJilrqecTB, 3aKJIIO'iaeTCR B "X 6e3JIVI'IHOCTJiI, "JIJiI aIiOlDlMHOCTH,
I1X Hal160JIee cosepweHHOIO opMOIO TOB3.pl1Il\eCTB AJ1R
O eHJmnpe , paCC'lJilTaHHbIXHa ,IJ;OJITOBpmeHHOe"X
c eCTBOBaHl1e}).101 IIo,n;06HH€ B3rJJJ'I,W>I 06 arcyrcrnJilJ1 KaKl1X 6bI TO
HI1 6bIJIO KJp Wl'-Jecro1X OTHoweHHi1 Mem.Qy aKQIWHepaMI1 BbICI<a3bIBa-
-42-
.ID1Cb J1 IIJX$ecoopoM JI.J1.Ile-rprotull.{Kl1M. 102 J10cmp BpaYAe c'UfTaJI,
'1TO nwmoe y<mCTl1e B OOl1-\e( rBe nO'lTI1 mcy'T'C'I13yeT.103
qTO RacaeTCR COBpeMeHHbIX yqeHbIX, TO OM PO,!\HOBa TaIOKe
npl-f,!\epiKl1BaeTCR no,!\ooHofi: IID3H1U1JI104, o.B. BeJ1oycoB me c'-JJ1TaeT,
'1TO'lJleHCKHe npaBa J1 06.R3aHHOCTJI no OTHOllleHJ11O K 1q):yntM aK'-tJ10-
HepaM OTcyrCTByroT y aKQl'1OHepoB .ID1lllb B OTKpbITOM aK'-tJ10HepHOM
OOlL\l2CTBE'-10S
BMecTe C'reM, yqeHblMJ1 BbICKa3hlBcUOTC.R J1,l:\1'J8.MeIpaJ npcrrl1-
BOI1OJICOKHbIe B3rJ:l.R,D;b!. TaK, AJ1. RaMJ1HKa BbICKa3aJI CJ:!epYlOw;yJO
TO'-!KY 3peID1R: «p.R,!\OM, C nOJ!HblM npJ13I1aHJ1eM TOro rocnO,!\CTBytOl1-\ero
3Ha'lelillIl, KOTOpoe B aKQI10HepHh1X KOMnaID1SIX npWHa,!\J!e)IDfT RaIrn-
TaJJy, 6bLJIO 6bl, OAHaKO, HeIIpaBJLIIhHO npJ1 onpe.iJ,e.J!eHIDI 3TO" 4>oPMbi
npe.iU1pI-UITJ1R ynyCKaTb J13 BI1,!Iy, '1TO OHa np J13 ceOR He
Mep1'Bbri1KaJU1TaJ!,aCOI03.J111:!I;,HBJ1IDOll{I1XCH 3TOro
RaffilTaJ1a».108
nOJ\OOHbIX B3rJ:lH,l\OB npJ1,n;epml1BaeTCH J1 .D..B. JIoMaKJ1H: «B paM-
RaX aKLlJ10HepHoro npaBOOTHOrneHJ1R npaBOBaR CBR3b, BNpaJKaIOll\f:I.-
HCR S HanJ1'1J111 cy6'beKT11SHbIX npas J1 tOpl1,!\I1'1eCKI1X 06J13aHHoCTe",
S03HI1KaeT He TOJ!bKO Me)f\',l\)' aKQI10HepHbiM 06l1-\ecTBOM J1 ero '1J1eHa-
MI1, HO Tal0Ke J1 Henocpe,n;cTBeHHo M€JfiJJ.Y CaMl1MI1 aKQI10HepaMI1 61"3
yqaCTI1R tOpI1,!\I1'1eCKoro J:lI1Qa. OTO 06ycJIOBJ1eHO TeM, '1TO B paMKax
aKqlIOH€pHoro npaBooTHOllIeHI1R '1aCTO npOI1CXOJ\I1T OTOJi(JleCTBJle-
Hl1e opraHJ13aQID:! J1 1"1" '1J1eHOB. 0CYll\eCTBJlHH CBOI1 '1J1eHCKl1e npaBa,
aKQI10Hepbl 4>OpMI1PYIOT €JII1HYIO BOJno opramf.3a:rvuf, KOTOpaH nOflB-
JIHeTCR BO BHe npH yqacTI>fl1 aKlVioHepHoro 06LQeCTBa B rpaJK)\aHCKOM
06opOTe. B nepJ-fo,lJ; 4>opMl1pOBaHJ-fR €JIIfH(Jd BOJIH 06LQecTBo He B1,I-
CTynaeT no OTHOlneHl1lO K CBOJ-fM '1J1eHaM B Ka'leCTBe caMQC'"I'()HT€JIb-
HOro cy6'beKTa aRQJ10HepHOro npaBOOTHOllleHJ1R. B STOM c.rry'-Jae aR-
QJ10Hepbl BCTyrralOT B aKTI1BH1,le B3aIIMOO'I1IQIll€ID1.I11q)yr C 1q)yroM,
CJIe,lJ;CTBl1eM '1ero, RaR npaBJ1JIO, flBJlHeTCR ROI$nm:T If X IfHTepe-
COB» 107 Era TO'lKY 3peHJ1R pa3,!\en.ReT lo.A MeTeJ1esa J1 C'-JJ1TaE'T, 'iTO
nw-mOCTb aKQJ10Hepa MomeT J1MeTb oco60e 3Ha'leHI1e RaR l1.JIR 0011-\1"-
CTBa, TaK If J\JlH ,lJ;I1HaMI1KI1 aKQI10HepHoro npaBOUrHOwt:'HI1H. 10B
C'IJ1TalO, 'lTO HeKOTOpbri1 JUj'lIlbri14>aKTOP B aR.QJ10HepHoMOOLQeCTBe
RaK opralrn3a Bce me npl1CyrCTBY€T, OAHaRO, lWll€'lliO, He B TaRO"
CTeneHl1, RaK, Hanpl1Mep, B npml3BO,l:\CTB€'HHOM KoonepaTl1Be. Oc06eHHo
3Ha'llfM nl1'-JH1,ri1 4>aKTOp B 3aKpblTblX aR.QJ10HepliblX 06l1-\ecTBaX J1 06-
LQecTBaX c He60nMrnIM KOmI'l€CTBOM yqacTllMKOB. COBepllleHHO BepHO B
31'0" CBJ1311IJO)\Mt:"l€HO ,n:.B. JIoMaKl1HbIM: «KJlaccl1<}:1l1KaQ!1H opraHl13a-
QMOHHo-npaBOBbIX 4JoPM npe;:u:rpl1HMMa-reJIbCKOii,n;eJITe.JIbHC:JCr Ha TO-
sapl1Il\ecrsa J1 , J1CXO)\H J13 c-reneID1 3Ha'il1MOCTl1 JIWlHOro
4>aKTOpa, B 3Ha'il1TeJIbHoii Mepe HOCl1T )'CJJJBHbrii xapaKT€p. HeJlb3.R
-43-
yrnep:IK,IWTb, '1TO 06r.u;ecTBa - 3TO 1'1CKJIl(J<ll:ITE'JIbH() cnoc06 KOHIJ;eHTpB-
l1ID1KaIII1TaJ10B, a TOBapl11l\eCTBOTOJ1blOOCOI03 JII1q».10S1
O KO 3Ha'll1MOCTb JII1'-IHoro rpBKTopa B 3KqHOHepHOM OOIl\eCTBE'
11 rop>1,!\WI€CKl1e CBH311 MeJfiJJ.Y 3Kql1oHepaMI1 - nOHRT:mI He TO)f(,l\eCT-
BeHHble qTO KaCa€TCR nOCJ1e,,!\H€ro, TO CJ1e}:ly€T npl13HaTb, 'ITO B 8K-
LlI10HepHOM OOIlteCTBe HI1KaI<l1X IOpl1,!I,11'1eCKJ1X CBR3e Me)!\,!\)' aKLtI10-
Hep3MI1 He 05pa3yeTcR, nOMI1MO CI1TyaLtl1 , Kor]1a B03HI1K31OT
npaBOOTHOllIeHl1H, CRH3aHHble C HIllilM npaBOM npl1oo-
peTeHI1R 3Kl\1m. OT'1)'iK.l13€Mbrx 8KqI10HepaMl1 aaKpbIToro o6r.u;ecTBB,
B CBR311 C aaI1HT€peCOBaHHOCTbKJ B nOMepJKaHl1l1l1OCTOHHHOro COCTa-
Ba 3Ki.\I1OHepoB.
B 3aKJIKJ'IeHl1e MUmBO (',!1enaTb BbmOJJ; U TOM, 'ITO Me)!\,!\)' 3KqI10H\:'p-
HbIMl1 J1 3KqI10HepaMI1 CK.I1aJI.bIBIDOH KaK KopnopaTIfB-
Hble, TaK J1 06H33TeJIbCTBeHHbIe UI'HIJIlleHWL EOJIe€ II1J,II;po6Ho BI1J];bI
06J'I33TeJIbCTBeHHbrx J1 KopnopaTI1BHbIX npaBOOniorneHl'rli:, J1X ocooeH-
HOCTI1 5y,nyr paCCMOTpeHbI B rnaBe 2 HaCTORWej:i pa60TbL
3. CTPYKTypa KopnOpaTI1BHblX 11 06A3aTenbCTBeHHblx
npaBOOTHOWeHI1M Me)f("Q)' aKLIHOHepHblMI1 06111eCTBaMI1
11 aKLlI10HepaMI1
,1J;Jm ]:\e'ffiJIbH0I'0 paCCMOTpeHl1H OTHOllIE'HI1ff, CKJIa,l{bIB3IOI1XCH
Me)!\,!\)' 8KQI1OH€paMI1I1 3Kl1110HepHbIMI1 Cli5LQ:ecTBaMil, npe)f\,l\e BCerD,
He06xQll;>1MO BbI,D;eJ1l11'b J1 npoaHaJDI3 osaTb SJIeMeHTb13T11X OTHOllIe-
IDIA: cy6'beKToo. B HID: Y'1aCTByroIl\WX, 05"beKTbI, no nOBO)J;)' IOCJ'l"O}JH"-
CKJIa)J;bmaIOTCR:IT11 ()"fiI()Ill('l1R, J1 Henocpe)J;C"IBeHHO J1X COJJ;epmaHl1e-
npBBa 11 o6HaaHHocrn J1X yqaCTID1K{)B.
Cy6"b€KTaMl1 CKJI3,!\bIBaIOIl{I1XCJ'I onrolJEHMiii HBJIJUOTCH, C o,,!\Hofi
CTOpoHbI, aKQ;110HepbI, C .opyroii - 3Ki.\110HepHbIe OOLIJ;eCTsa. CTaTbR 2
3aKOHa «06 aKl\I'IOHepHblX 06Il\eCTBax» onpe,!J;eJUleT aKl\I«)HepHOe 06-
r.u;eCTBO RaK KOMMep'leCKyro opramf3aLtl1KJ, YCT3BHbIi1 KaII11Tan :I1:0TO-
paf;i paa,!\E'neH HB onpe,!\eneHHoe 'lI1CJ10 aKQMii, y,ll1JCTlJBepHIDlQItX OOR-
aaTeJIbCTBeHHbre npaBa yq8CTHI1KOS OOIl\eCTSa (3KQ;l1oHepos) no
OTHoweHJ1JO K OOLIJ;eCTsy,
'!aCTb 1 CT. 96 ill pq:. cOJJ;epmwT cneJJ;y1OIl\€e onpeJJ;eJIel!Jfe 3Kl\1-fO-
HepHoro 06Il\ecTBa:
- 3KI1110HepHbIM 06LIJ;E'CTBOM np113H1leTCH 06Il\€CTBo, YCT3BHbrn Ka-
II11TaJI KOTOporo pa3,!\eJIeH Ha oope.n;e.neHHOe 'mcno yqaCTHI1KI1
aKQ;I10HepHoro 00lqecTB3. (SKi.\110HepbI) He OTBe'laIDT no ero 06J'I3aTenb-
CTBaMI1Hecyrpl>1CKyfJbITKOB, CBJ3:3aHHbIXC 06r.u;ecTBa.
B npe.a;e.nax C'IOI1MOC'I'H npJ1Ha,ll,lle)fCa JlX I>1M aK H.
C>r1pe]Ie.nemm APyroti CTOpoHbI npmoarnomemm - aKQl-fOHepoB
:yKa3aHHble HopMaTIfBHble aKTbl He CO.I\epiKaT; 113 npl>1Be.a;eHHbIX onpe-
J11>111Ib CJ1eAYeT. 'lTO I1IIrn .f1BJU1IOTCII Y'laCTlllUGf aRWlOHepHbIX
06tqecTB.
Y'1aCTHI>1KaMI1 aRIuwHepHoro 06tqeCTBa CTaHOB.f1TCfl ero }"-Jpe,!1,l1Te-
ror, nOCKOJ1bKY npl1 Y'lpem.a;emrn 06ll.\ecTBa Bce ero aKL\1-fI1 ,IJ;OJ1mHbl
6bITb cpeW1 (n. 2 CT. 253aKoHa «06aKqVlo-
HepHb1X ofuuecmax,,), a TalOKe APyme J111l,\a, KO'I'Opble npl-106peJ11>1 aK-
l.\IDI 06r.u;ecTBa. O.I\HaKO 3,l:\eCb IMO TO'lliO 0603Ha'1W1'b MOMeHT.
C KO'I'Oporo yKa3aHHbIe J1 npJ106peTalOT CTaTYc aKWlOHepoB 06ll.\e-
CTsa. RaK yme 6blJ10 YKa3aHO, AJlR I1pJ106peTe1JJ1H cTaTyca aKl-IJK!Hepa
He06xo)J;IDl! oc06bIti cocmB KlpUmI'leCtGlX c}mKTOB. C MOMeHTa cOBep-
WeHI1H c.a;eJlKJ1 no nepexo.D;y npaBa COt5cTBeHHOCTi1 Ha aK YI npJ106pe-
TaTeJ1b HeceT 06J'13aHHOCTb 11 O;:J;HospeMeHHo l1MeeT npaBO Ha BHeceHHe
B peeCTpaKqVlOHepOB 06tqeCTBa, o,!J;HaKO IDlKffiGte ;Qpyme npaBa. CBOi1:-
CTBeHHbIe cTaTycy aKl.\YlOHepa, OH npYl06peTaTb He Mome-r.
KpoMe TOro, B paCCMaTpl1BaeMbIX npaBOOTHOIIIeHlfJIX yqacTBJIOT 11
I1Hble J1Y1L\3.. RaK yme}'Ka3blB:a.J!OC nOMl1MO aKL\YlOHepOB 11 aKL\I'IOHep-
HbIX o6tqecTB B OTHOlllemmx HenocpeACTBeHHOe yqaCTIle MOryT npl1-
HI1MaTb 11 TaKJ1e cyD'beKTbI, RaK CrreL\l1B-ID13Y1pOBaHHaH opraHl13awuI -
,n;epmaTeJ1b peeCTpa. IIOMJ'1Ha.JIbHb ;Qepma-reJ1b aKIU1ti, ;QoBepJITeJ1b-
Hbrn ynpaBJlmoLqIDJ:, -rpaHCQ:lep-areHT. ;QeII03ItTapIDJ: 11 11JJyme. 3T0 xa-
paKTepHO,IJ.JlJ'lKOpnopaTIfBHblXnpaBOOTHC:I1IeHIDI, B aK-
qYloHepHblX 06J.11€C'I'B<iX. a TaIOKe AJlR 06H3aTeJ1bCTBeHHblx. 11 He
npOTI1BOpe'1Y1T nOHHTi11O 06H3aTeJ1bCTBa. RaK OHO npl>1MeHHeTCII B
aroMKo,n;eKCe pq:..
TaK. npaBQC)'ffiornemrn, CK.J1a.IIbIMI01112C.f1 B CBR3I1 C Be.I\eHJ1eM peec-
"Ip3 aKl-IJB:llIEpJB 06tqeCTBa, MOryI' KaR JK118. rnaTbCJI B npocTyIO CXeMY
06tqeCTBO - aKL\YIOHep, TaR J1 B03HJ1:Ka'Ib Mem.I\Y 6oJn,lllJ1M I«:JJnf'ieC1'B(M
Cy6'beKTOB. PaCCMOTpI>1MCJIO:)KHbIenocsoetiCTpYRType -
Able OTHornemrn, B03HJ:IKaK::IQIte no nOBOJ\Y ocyw:eCTBJlemrn KOMILJ1eKCa
npaB aKlUroHepa, CSR3aHHbIX C Be,QeIDfeM peecrpa B TOM CJ1}"-Jae. KOl';I\a
pemCTpaTOpoM .f1BJ1ReTCII He aKltIUlEpHOE' 06tqeCTBO, a
BaHHafI opraHJ13aQl1.li. CaMOCTOHTeJlbHble npaBOUl1lO11leHYl B03H11KalOT B
3TOM CJ1yqae MeiK,!IY aKItMOHepoM J1 pemCTpaTOpoM J1 Mem.I\Y aKL\YIOHe-
poM 11 aKWIDHepHbIM 06tqecTBOM. IIpWieM 3Th! OTHornemrn C"rpOJITCJ1 no
CJ10>KHo!1 CXeMe TaK Ha3bIBaeMbIX ,IJ;ByCTOpoHHJ1X OOJ'l3aTeJ1bCTB.
MHome)"-leHbIepa3rpaHl1<-nmalOT,IJ;ByCTOpOI111J1
06J'13aTeJlbCTBa 110 IIpJ1 :'ITOM B ;QsyCTDpoHIDfX npaBOOTH01II€HI1J'IX )"-Ia-
-45-
CTB)'lOT ,D;Be CTopoHbI II! Ka:lfi,!\aH JI!3 HI1X 06JIa)\aeT npaBaMJl! II! 06H3aHHO-
CTflMH B OTHJIll€IDIIt: 11P}'TOft.. B QI:IHOCTOPOHHJI orHoIlleHtffiX TaIOKe I1H-
npaBOMO'lHblit: 11 06H3aHHbIi1 cy6'beKTbI, II! npll!
STOM O)J;J1H 113 miX HeCeT 06J'I3aHHOCTb nepe)J;,DpyTJ1M. a ;Qpyro HMeeT
npaBO Ha I1C11OJ1Hemle 3TOti o6.A3aHHocTI:l B CBOlO nOJIb3Y. TaKJ1M 06pa-
30M, CT. 307 I1\ p.p COJleJ»Kl1T cupeJleJIeIDre O;QHOCTOpoHIfero 06H3a-
TeJibCTBa, a ynoMHHaHHe 0 .n;BycropoHIDIX OOH3aTe11bC'IBa"( cO)J;epmI1T-
Cfl B 'l. 2 CT. 308 I1\ pcp; ec.m;: Ka:lfi,!\aJ1113 CTOpC)H no ;qOroBOpy HeceT
06H3aHHOCTb B nOJIb3y ;Qpyroi1 CTOpOHbI, OHa C'IJ1Tae-TCJ1 ;QOJVKHHKOM
Aj)yroi1 CTOpoHbI B TOM, 'lTO 06H3aHa C)J;eJiaTb B ee nOJ1b3Y, 11 O)J;HOBpe-
MemIO ee Kpep;wrOpOM B TOM, 'lT0 HMeeT npaso or Hee Tpe60BaTb.
HaH60JIee 'laCTO CyO'beKTaMl1, BcrynalOIIJ;V1MJ-'I B 0"I'H0IlEHIDf, CKJia-
;QbmaJOI1U-'1eCfl Mem,Ily oUI.qeCTBOM 11 aKQJ10HepOM, HBJIJ1JOTCJ1 mM1fl1aJIb-
Hbrn ;Qep:1KaTeJib II! ;Q£JBepUT€JIbHNJ1 ynpaBJlJiKllI{lfii
Aep:1KaTeJIb L\eHHbIX 6yMar - JII1L\O, 3aperHcrpI1po-
murnoe B CHCTeMe Be)\eIDIfl peeCTpa. B TOM "lJ1CJIe HBJImOLqeeCfl ,/J;erro-
HeHTOM ;Qeno&rrn.p:v:!J1, H He HBJIfl10LqeecH B OTHOllIeHYIIIJ
STJI!X L\eHHbIX 6)'Mar (n. 2 CT. 8 3aKoHa «0 pb1HKe L\eHHbIX 6yMar ).
B KaqeCTBe HIJMJfiIaJIbHhI ;QepmaTBJIflI L\eHHbIX 6)lMar MOryI' BbI-
cTynaTb npocl:>eccuOHaJIbHbIe Y"8CTHHKJ1 pbIHKa L\eHHbIX 6yMar. ,lJ;eno-
3J1TapIDJ: MmKE'T 6b1Tb 38.pelHCTpll!pOBB.H B Ka'leCTBe HDMIUIaJIbHOrO
Aep:1KaTeJUI qeHHbIX 6yMar B COOTBeTCTBIUI C ,l\el103liITapHbIM ;QOroBO-
pDM. BpoKep MmKeT 6b1Tb 3aperJl!CTpI1poBaH B Ka'leCTBe HOMJUIaJIbHOl'O
AepmaTeJUI L\eHHbIX 6)lMar B COO'I'B('TC'fIJ C ,/J;orOBOpoM, Ha OCHDBaHIIJH
KOTOparo OH 06CJI.YiKl1BaeT KJIJI!eHTa.
HOMMHaJlbHbrn ,/J;epmaTeJlb L\eHHbIX 6)lMar MmKE'T ocYII--lecTBJUITb
npaBa. 3aKpenJieHHbIe L\eHHOif 6)'Maroif. TOJlbKO B cnyqae nOJI.Y"leIDIH
coarBeTCTByroll\eronOJIHOMO'UlJJ1OT
ynpaBJIJ1JOIL\IDi-mw npeAIIpIlJIDfMa-
TeJlb IIJJll1lOC1MMepqecKaH OprnHl131IL\IDI. ocyru;eCTBJImoIl\llil yrrpaBJIeHHe
aK1U1HM1IJ B coarBeTCTBJDIJ C ;qOroBOpoM ,D;OBe})JrreJIbHOI"O ynpaBJieIDlfl, 3a-
KJilO'IeHHbIM Mem.r:\Y ynpaBJImo IIJ aKL\IUlI:pOM- OrHollIeHtffi MemI1Y
aKL\I1OHepOM IIJ ;QOBepI1TeJlbHbIM ynpaBJUIlOllI;ffiV! perynI1pylOTcH HopMa-
MJ1 I1\ pq:. II! 3aKOHa «0 pbIHKe L\eHHbIX 6)'Mar», a TaJOKe nO)J;3aKOHHbIMJIJ
HopWrrnBHbIMIIJ amaMJ1 4I:EC£J;B IIJ 4>C<PP PCP
B np6£1()()'I'}K)W€HIIJR Mem,Ily 0611\ecTBaMJ1 II! MI1 MOryr
BCTynaTb IIJ ,/J;eIJ'J3J1TapJofilI. )J;errl3JlTapJlJeM HBJIJ1eTCJ1 npac}>ecCJ10HaJIb-
Hbrn Y'laCTHHK pbIHKa qeHHblx 6yMar. o ;QerI03lrrn.p-
HYlO ,/J;eRTeJlbHOCTb. ,lJ;eno3JrrapJlJeM MOiKeT 6bITb TOJibKO JOpn.! K'l€Cl<Oe
.11IIJQO. )J;eno3IIJTapHofl;qe.RTeJlbHOCTb1O npIlJ3HaeTCJ1 OKa3aHtfe YCJiyr no
xpaHeIDIlO CepTIlJtPHKaTOB qeHHbIX 6)'Mar IIJ/IIJJIIIJ y<reTy IIJ nepexo.D;y
npaB Ha L\eHHble 6)'Marn
-46-
Cne IOTHOIlIeHl1ff, B03HJ1KaIOIW1XMem.r:\Y3KqMoHepHbIMM06-
ll1.ecTBaMM 11 paMH. RBJUIeTCJ1 TO, 'lTO B HWX MOmeT BCTynaTb 11
roCYM- OpraHI1CJX)JIID1'IeJHB.rraCTIfnO pblHK)'qeHHbIXOY-
Mar -4>e,n;epa.:rIbHaJI c.nym6a no $maHCOB1>IM pbIHKaM pq:. (4)C4IP pq:.).
Ha ()('HOI!alll-1I CT. 44 3aKOHa «0 pblHKe U€HHbIX o)'Mar» 4>C4IP P4I.
B '1aCTHOCTl1, BnpaBe:
- KBaJll-1,pl1LtJ1poBaTb qeHHble 6}'Maru 1-1 onpe,n;€J1J::rTb I-1X Bl1,!J;bI B co-
0TBeTCTBI1It: C 3aROHO,lJ.aT€J1bCTBOM POCCl1fiCKOU: 4>e,n;epaqmr;
- YCTaHaB.ID1B8.Tb nOpH,!\OK npose,!\eHHH nposepoK 3MRTeHTOB, ocY-
llIeCTBJ1f1Tb caMOCTOflTeJlbHO KJ11-1 COBMeC'IHO C COOTBeTCTB)'1OI q:.e-
,n;epa.11bHbIM> opraHro.rn I1CI1OJ1HJrreJ1bHOH BJIaCTH nposepKH ,n;€flTeJ1b-
HOCTI'! 3MJITeHTOB;
- HanpaBJUITb 3MH'I'e11'mMJ1l1J:XXPecc1I01JaJ1bHbIMyqaCTHI1KaM PblH-
Ka qeHHbIX o}'Mar, a TalOK€ J1X caMoperYJlY!pyeMbIM OprnHJl3aL\l1-HM
npe.II.mtCa1D1fI, 06J'13aTeJ1bHble,n;JUi I1CnOJ1HeHYIJ::r, a TalOK€ Tpe60saTb OT
HI1X npeJ:\CTaBJIeHHJI JlUl:)'MeJfI'OB, He06xo$1MbIX,l\JUI perneHl1H BOnpO-
COB, HaXO)/,HIIJ;I1XCH B KOMII€TeHL{JI!Y! panbHOI'O opraHa I1cnomrn:-
'I'eJIbHofi BJIaCTI-I 110 pbIHKy LleHHbIX O)'Mar;
- HanpaBJIJITb MaTepl1aJIb1 B IIpaSOOXpaHI'ITt'JIbHbI€ opraHbI 11 o6pa-
ll¥lTbCHC J1CKaMMB cYlJ.(a cy,r() nOBonpOC3M, OTHeCeHHb!M
K 1 clJe,n;epaJIbHoro opraHa 11CIIOJIlIK'feJI BJ1aCTI-I 110
PbIHKY qeHHbIX 6yMar (BKJlIO"IaH Hen.ei1cmJITeJIbHOCTb c.ueJlOK C ueH-
HbIMJll6)'M8.raMJII);
- YCTaHaBJIl1BaTb HOpMaTl1Bbl, 06H3aTeJIbHbie AJlH c06J1IO.uemrn
3Ml1TeHIaMR I1:eHHbIX 6yMar. 11 npaSYIJIa I1X npl1MeHeHI1H.
IIpl1 3TOM CJ1e,rr;yeT OTMeTI-lTb, '1TO 4>C4IP P4I BCTynaeT TOJIbKO B OX-
paHH'I'B1IhIIbI (YrHOilieIDfJI, 1eCH Mem.r:\YaKQ>f(EepHhIM06-
llIecTBOM 1-1 aKWnrepaMJ'J B CJ1)"-Jae HapywelU1J'l HOpM TeJ1bCT-
sa. B HOpMaJ1bHO npctreKaIOll\.l1e peryJ1SlTHBllble OTHOllleIDfJI 4>C4IP P4I
BCT)'IffiTb He MomeT.
IIplt6.mvK.aHcb K BOIIPOCY 06 06'beKTe 06H3aTeJlbCTBeHHbIX J1IWprlO-
paTIlBHbIX npaBOOTIIolllemrif, npemJIe Beero IMO 0603Ha'il1Tb
ero 06ll.\enpasoBoe nOHHTI1e, IXJCIIDJIbKy cpeW'! yqeHbIX cyr.u,ecTByroT
1aMe'I'paJIbHJ npcrrJ1B£I1()J)'J)KHb1 IX!3InnoI, KacaIOll.\l1eCJ1 onpe,!J;eJle-
HI1.R oO"beK'l'a npaBOOTIICUIemm: Boootqe, a TaIOKe onpe]:\eJ1Jf'I'bC5l C Tep-
Mi'1HOJIOI11t'H, nOCKOJlbKY MHorue CIJeQMaJIIICTbI l1cn0JIb3yroT nOHJITWe
«npe,!J;MeT 06J'13aTeJIbCTBa». nO,!UdeWI.fI11M nOHHTI-le 06'beKTa. KoHe'1HO,
60nee npaBI1JIbHO 6bLIIO 6bl ynoTpe6JUiTb nOHJITl1e «o6'beKT 06J'13aTeJlb-
CTBa», KOTOpoe RBJIReTCR 06u.\enpUHflTbIM B TeOpWl1 npasa, a He nOHJ::r-
TIle «npe.D;MeT>. J1CI1OJ1b3VeMoe MHorl1MM aBTopaMlf, O,D;HaKO B ,lIaJ1bHei'i-
llIeM no TeKCTY pa60Tbi Oyl\Y np",l:\ep*"BaTbcH npl1HHToi'i I1MY!
TepMJlIiO.1I<nIH.
Tpa,!{MW'!OHHiUI 4mJIoco4>cKaH "IpaKTOBKa o&beKTa - lIpO"TIfBOnOC-
TaBJ1em-le ero cyD"beKTY 11 mHHMaIDle no)1 o&beKTOM H€'lTO TaKOro, Ha
'1TO HanpaBJIeHa )1eHTeJIhHOCTh cy6"beKTa.
c.c. AneKceeB C'IJ1TaeT. '1TO o&beKT npaBOOTHOilleID1R - :;ITO «Te flB-
J1eHI1J1 (npeAMeThl) HaC MIt:!pa, Ha KOTOphie HanpaBJIeHbI
cyUbeK'I11B1lli1e KJpl1Jl)1'leCKI1e npaBa 11 06R3aHHOCTl1... 0606W;eHHO 1'0-
8OpJ'l. :no pa3Ho06pa3Hhle MaTepl1aJlhHhle 11 HeMaTepl1aJIhHhIe 6JIara,
cnoc06Hb1e YAOBJIeTBOpsrrb CyD"beKTOB, TO eCTh I1HTepec
ynpaBOMO'-leHHoro".111
IIoMtleHI1KJ AC. IIJ1roJ1KI1Ha, «nO)1 o&beKTOM npaBoBoroOTHOW€ffif.fI
CJIe,rr;yeT nOHI1IIffiTb Te MaTepl1aJ1hHble 11 J1YXoBHhle 6J1ara, npe.D1JC'ffiB-
neHl1eM 11 I1CllOJIb3OBaHl1eM KOTopbIX y,/:\OBJIeTBOpHKJTCR I1HTepeCbI
npaBOM'J'IlIOit CTOpoHhI npaBOOTHOWeHJ1R"."2
npcmlBCUO.OOJKHaflTO'lKa 8peHl1fl Ha o&beKTnpaBO-
oTHoweHl1fl 6hIJIa BbICKa38Ha B.J1. Cewun.u;eBhlM. IOCYIOFuii: C'-Il1'TaeT, 'lI'O
n0311qm1 pa3.Illi'-IHblX aBTopoB «He B nOJllIOM Mepe )"-IMTbIBalOT l1MeHHO
npaBOBoe }ffi"Iano. npaSOB)'KI cyDcraHQmO B np:lBOOTHOlIJeHlm. ... aBTO-
pbl KOHQf2HI'PJIpOBaJDI CBOI1 yCJ1.lIl1.!'l Ha OTbICKaHJII1 CBOMcrB OO'b€f(Ta
nJEBOOTHDllleHJUI Y 06"beKTl1BHO 11 He3aIDfCI1MO or npasa cy:ru;eCTByro-
Il{J1X flBJ1eHJ1ti: BHelIIHero MI1pa, B TO BpeM.fl KaK B npaBOOTHOllIeHJIIM CJIe-
TI;jeT '1eTKO pa3Jlli'-1aTh IIJIaCT npaBOBOIO perYJI OBaIDIR 11 n.rraCT BHe-
npaBOBOM ,IJ;eMCTBHTeJIbHOCTl1. cy:ru;eCTBYKJll\eM He3aBJICJIMO OT
HaJll1'1ID1 J1JII1 OTCyTCTBnJ'I TOro I1JIJIIl1Horo npaBoBoro peryID1pOBaHl1R
(TO eCTh caMO 061l\€CTBeHHoe OTHOllIeHl1e). KaK npe)J;CTaBJIJ'leTCR. 06"b-
eKT IplJfIJIHHCKOI1J npaBOOTHOIIIeHlUI CJ1e;:JyeT I1CKaTb I1MeHHO B npaBO-
80M cpe3E' J1I060ro npaBOOTIDWeHI'U1, a He B p;pyrofl ero '1acrl1. 06"beKT
npaBoBolO OTHOIlIemm ,IJ;OJDKeH ObITb ,IJ;ocTyneH l1MeHHO npaBOBOM)'
icTBJoo. ,IJ;OJ!:>KeH OTBe'-IaTb Ha npaBoBoe B03,IJ;61:cI'BJle, a CJ1e,IJ;OBa-
TeJ1hHO, OO'beKTOM npanoarnoweIrnJI He MomeT 6bITh MaTepMaJIbllbDii
OO'beKT W111 nOB€J1eID1e 06H38HH01U JII1q3. . . TOJIhKO npaB080M peml1M
HeKoero .fIBJ1eID1J'1 OO'be1cr'l1BHOii , KaKOBhIM MruKeT
6bITh Belltb, ,l\et1CTBIDI,,l\eHbl'I1, qeHHble 6YMarl111 T.n., MruKeT OTBe'ffiTb
npasoBOM)' B03,/:\eiicrBmo, TO eCTb MomeT 6bITh OO'beKTOM rpa:>K,!\aHCKO-
1'0 npaBOOTHOWeHl1R.".'13 EeccnopHO, ,lIallHaR n0311Lt11J'111MeeT npaBO Ha
CyuI,f2CTBOBaHI' 11 He J1I1llIeHa CMbICJ1a, OJ1HaKO I1OClIDJ1bKy I1CCJ1e,l\OBa-
HI1e OO'beKTa npaBoBoro OTHOllIeHJ1R He HBJlReTCJ'I qeJ1bKJ ,lIaHHOM pa60-
TbI, B ,lIaJlbHeflweM 6y.DY npl1)J;ep:>KJ1BaThCR 'I'p3,l\InnroHHhIX B3I'JUI,!\OB
Ha OO'beKT npaSDOTHOllleHJII.R Bo06w;e 11 06J'13aTeJIhCTBeHHoro OTHOllIe-
HI1J'1B'-I3C'JHOCTJI.
BCBOeMMOHorpa4>ID:! «06J'13aTeJlbcTBonOCOBeTCKOM)'
MY npaBY" M.M ArapKoB yKa3hIBaJI, 'lTO «SO 11:IDe>KaHl1e JIYTI':lHIfW>I
.nyqwe 6hlJlO 6hl paqJ:KUIaJIII3JlpoBaTh TepMHHOJJOn:uo 11 C'llITaTb 06"b-
-48-
eKTOM np8Ba TO, H8 'ITO HanpaBJIeHO nose,l\eHJ1e 06J'13aHHOro .ffi1I\a,
npemJIe Bcero BeLqb ...; mne,l\ellJle me OOJi3aHHOroJillQa, xapaKTepH3Y-
eMoe TeMl>-! Jf.Iill J1HbIMJ1 npl>13HaKaMJ1 (nepe,!\8'la Berql>-!, ynJillT8 .rIeHer,
I1pOJf3BCI.rIC' onpe,!\e.neHHoi1 pa60Tbl, B03.r1epil<aHl1e OT nOC'JlraTeJ1bCT-
Ba Ha BeLqb...) Ha3blBaTb co.n;epmaHJ1eM npanoonrorneID1J1».114
1I0 MHeHI1IO lOR TQJlCTOro 11 All CepreeBa, «no B Ra'lecrne 06'beK-
Ta rpa)l(,!laHCKoro IlpaBOOTHOWellJ1J'I Bb1CTynaeT nOBe.rleHHe ero CyD'beK-
TOB, HanpaBJ1eHHoe Ha pa.3J1H'IHoro pOM MaTep Hble 11 HeMaTepM-
aJ1bHb1e 6.nara... IIpJ1 3TOM He06xo,1\I1MO pa3J1I1'1aTb nOSe,1\eHHe
cyfueKTOB rpa:>K,!\aHcKoro npaBOO'I'H01ll€lH B npou;ecce J1X B3aMMO-
AeJIC'I'BJUI Mem.r:\Y c060i111 J1X nose.rleHHe, HanpaSJleHHoe Ha MaTepM-
aJibHble 6J1ara. lIepBOe o6pa3yeT cO,1\ep>KaHl1e rpa:>K,!\aHcKOro I1M)'1L1e-
CTseHHoro npaBOO'I'HOlll€, a BTOpoe - ero 06'beKT».115
CpeM yq€HbIX He CJlO)K!1JlOCb e)J;l1Horo MHeID!J'I no Bonpocy 0606'h-
eKTe 06J'13aTeJlbCTBa. J1.B. HOBl1qKJm: IIpI13H3eT 06'beKTOM 06J'13aTeJlb-
crna JillllIb ,l\e a BeIW1 J'lBJ1J'1KJI'CH, no ero MHeHl1IO, npeAMeTOM
1tCIIO.JIHeffi1J'l. Gn D"i OTHOCm' .lI€iiCTBIDI ,lJ;OJIiKHl1Ka K co-
,lJ;epil<aID!KJ 06J'13aTeJlbCTSa, a K 06'beJcr'aM 06J'13aTeJIbCTBa - BelL[J1,
,n;eHbDI,ycJlyn1. 115
lIo MHeHl1IO r cP IIIepllleHesWla, cO,1\epil<aHl1e 06J'13areJIbCTBa, OHO
me o6'heKT o6J'13aTeJ1h(.'TB€HHfJI'O nJEBOOTHOlU:'lIJlR, - .r\B ICTBI1e, KOTOpoe
,lJ;OJDKHO 6bITb onpe,!\eJleHO HaCTQJlbKO, '1Mbl He B03HJ1KaJI0 COMHeHI1i1 B
TOM, 'ITO l\OJDKeH C)J;eJIaTb l\o.mtOO1K. .lI;eMCTBI'1e COCTOwr B CJle;:tyIOIIJ;€M:
nepe,!\8'1e Berql>-! B co6crBellHOCTb; npe,IJ;OCTaBJIeID11 O OMY
BeLql1, np ll\pyroMY, B 1DJIb3OBaHJ1e; cosepWeHID1JIW-1HbIX
YCJIYf B n0JTh3Y lIPyroro .ffi1I\a; B03.n;epmamrn: OT Tex A€HcTmm. I1CKJ1lO-
'lI1TeJlbHoe npaBO cosepweHllil KOTOpblX npl1Ha,!\Jle»GIT KpeJJ:l1TOpy.
B CMJIY 06J'13aTeJlbCTSa aK'l'J'IBHblii cy6'heKT npJ106peTaer npaso Ha
AeJIC'I'BJIe co CTOpoHb1 naCCHBHOl'O cy6'heKTa, a He npaBO Ha)1 ero J1I11tOM
I1JIJ1 Ha ero BOJlIO. «lIpaso Ha.!\ JlJlIIpM 03Ha'la.rrO 6blCTeCHelllte cso6o,!\bl,
a :3TO I1pJI6.11mKa.no 6b1 ero K nOJlOmeHI1IO pa6a, a 0'I'HI1l€HJ1e - K Bell{-
HOMY. IIpaso Ha BQJlKJ lIPyroro J111Qa HE'I303MCOKHO, nOTOMY 'iTO BOJUI, no
eaoei1 He.38BJ1CJIMOCTP, He MomeT 6blTb 06"beJcr'OM npasa».117
IIo MHeHJ1IO cpR CasJ1HbJi, 06'beKT 06J'13a'TeJ1bCTSa «COCTOm'"3 OT-
AeJ1bHb1XAeJfCTBWI.ffi1I\a, 113 OOnaCTH ero cB060):\b1" no,!\-
'lJ1HeHHbIX 'O"I'0i1 BOJIe: OID! COCTaBJLlllOT Yl\OBJ1eTsopeHJ1e (Leistung)
AOJI:>KHJ1Ka»,11B npJ1 :3TOM «TOJ1bKO Te.rleiic'rBID;: MOryr 6bl1'b n eTOM
06J'13aTeJlbcrn, KOTOpble cnoc06HbI BbipaJKaTbCJi BO BH€llIHefi cpopMe,
craHOBRCb, TaKI1IV! 06pa30M, nO,1\06Ho Be M, B nOl\'il1HeHJ1e 'O"I'ofi BOJIe;
np€,lI,IIOJIaraeTCJ'l eme, 'ITO .n;eitcTmrn :3TJ1 J1MeIDT J1M)llIJ;€CTBeHH)110 qeH-
HOCTb 11JIJ1 cnoc06HbI K l\eHe»aiofi OL\eHKe Hanpl1Mep, MOiKHO npe,!\c-ra-
BJ1Tbce6e cor.naweHJ1e HeCI«JJ1bKIIXJ1J1L\COCTIU!IDITb npaBJIJIbHbleco6pa-
-49-
HJ1R C qeJIblO ya:meprneHcrnOBaHHH B Ha)'K8.X II! II!cK)'ccrnax. XOTb 3TO CO-
rJ1allleHJl!e II! CDJro6uJ 06JIe'lbC,R BO BHelllH1010 CPOPMY .n;orosopa, HO 1I!3
Hero He MGm.eTB03l1Jlli'l1YTb OOJi3aTeJIbCTBa K ,D;eHTeJIbHOC-
TJ1 » 119 ,l{etiCTBMe C'1J1TaeT OObeKTOM 06Ji3aTeJIbCTBa II! E.B IIacceK. 120
HeKOTOpble y<1eHbIe BbICKa3bIBalOT MHeHJl!e. '1TO OO"beKTOM npaBOOT-
HOllIeHJ1R MO:IKeT 6bITb II!JIWlliOCTb ,npyroro.ID1qa. «HapJi.!ly C Be MJiI II!
.n;eticTBI1F!MJ1 npaBa JlBJIRKYT'CJi II! J1I--1qa. CospeMeHHoe npaoo,
pa3)'MeeTCR:, He .n;onyCKaeT TaKoro I'O('I1()J1CTBa npJ1 KOTOpoM O.n;HO J1J1-
qo HJ13BO,1J;1ITCH Ha creneHb BelL\l1 II! cpe.n;CTBa AJlJi qeJIeti ,npyraro JIJ1lla.
CoBpeMeHHOe npaBOMJ1pJ1TCJI TOJIbKO c TaKJ1M I'OCI1QI:IC'IBO O)J;Horo J1J1-
qa Ha.n; .n;pyrJ1M, npll! KOTOpoM coxpaIU1eTCJI CBooo.n;a o6cmx».121
RaK yrsep:)K,l:lae-r cp.K CaBHHbJI, «oOR3aTeJlbCTBO COCTOJ1T B rocno.n;-
CTBe Ha,lJ; 'l)':/KJ1M m1L\OM, HO He Ha)J; sceM J1J1L10M (l1Ha'ie OHO BeJ10 6bI K
Hl1lOJ1W1HOCTJ1), a TOJIbKO H3)\ O,D;J:1HO'IHbIMJI! eroJJ;etiCTBHHMJ1.
KOTOpble MOryr 6bITb npe,D;CTaBJ1eHbI ElbI,!J;e.neHHbIMJ1 1I!3 CBOOOAbI 3TOro
JIJ1lla II! IIO]J;'lHHeHHbIMI1 Halileti BOJIe. no B Ka»f,!\OM 06mmTeJIbcTBe Mbl
B>-w1M,n;s.a a. COCTORIIV1X B OTHOllIeHHJ1 HepaBeHCTBa C o.n;:mti CTO-
poHbI, J1W1HaJ'i CBOOO BblcTynaeT 1I!3 CBOJ1:X eCTeCTBeHHbIX npe.n;eJ10B B
CMblCJIe rocIIOJJ;CTBa Ha)J; qyJKOlO .JIWIHOCTb1O; C .lIPyroif - ecTeCTEeHHH1I
cBo60.n;a np OrpaHWIeHHOlO B CMbICJIe m,ll;'lllH€HKR J1JIJ1
npl1H)"KJl:emrn».122
o.C.IiIalxPe C"IJIITaeT. '1TO 06'beKTOM o6Ji3aTeJIbcTBa BblcTynaeT no-
Be.n;eHJ1e 06Ji3aHHOro a. npJ1'leM TaKOe nOBe.n;eHJ1e Mo:aceT 6bITb
TOJIbKOaRTIDllIbIM, COCTOHIl\eMBonpe.n;eJ1eHHbIX .n;eti-
CTBHHX: «1! OTJ1W1J1e OT npaBOOTHollIeHI1if naCCI1BHaJi
%'Hl\.LII1I1 miKor.n;a He eT Kplf,[\l'I'll2aWm OO"beKTa 06Ji3a-
TeJIbCTBa, a OObNHO BblcTynaeT B Ka'lecTBe pe3YJIbTaTa J1JUf .n;OIlOJIHe-
HJl!R K I1OJ1O)KJrreJlbHbIM ,n;ejicTsWRM ero CyD"beKTOB».123 IIpJl! :nOM MaTe-
pHaJIbHbIM 06"beKTOM HeKOTopbIX 06Ji3aTeJ1bCTB MOryT BbICTynaTb
onp€)\eJIeHHbIe BelL\M, a B pJi.!le OOR.3aTeJIbCTB TaKOif MaTepHaJIbllHJI
06'beKT Bo06lL1e mcyrcTByeT
IIpe.n;eJ1bHO IID1pOIW nOlUlThie npe,lJ;MeTa OOR3aTeJIbCTBa onpe,D;eJ1R:-
eTCH r. ,lJ;epH6yproM: «RaK npe.n;MeT 06Ji3aTeJIbCTBa paccMaTpllB8KYr.
CMO'IpJl no pa3J1H'lHbIM TO'lKaM 3peHJ1jI, J1J100,n;ejicTmre, KOTOpoe .n;OJ1m-
HO coseplillrn.cJi Ha OCHOBaHJl!JI! 06Ji3aTeJIbCTBa, J1J100 .ID1'lliOCTb .n;OJDK-
HJl!Ka.J1J16oeroBOJIKJHJIJ1 .J1J16o, HaKOHeLt,06'beKT, KOTOp1:rii
.n;OJDKeH 6blI'b IIpE'.Q'JCTcIBJ B CI1J1Y 06Ji3aTeJIbCTBa.... IIpJl! Bcex 06Ji3a-
T€JIbCTBaX 3EI€HTy3JIbHbIM npe,lJ;MeTOM JI!X 6blBaeT JJ;eHe:1KHOe B03Har-
pa:)K,l:leHJ1e (npe.n;MeT BCRKOro OOJi3aTeJ1bCTBa MOiKeT npespaTl1TbCJI B
,n;eHeJKHOe B03Harpam.n;eHJl!e). IIoc.ne,mree JJ;OJDKHO 6bITb npe.llOCTBBJIE-
HO Kpe.n;l1'Topy BCerJJ;3. B TOM cJIY"lae, eCJlJ1 He J1CllOJlHeHO TO, 'lTO CJie.n;y-
-50-
eT no 06J'13aTeJIbCTBy. 11 eCJIJ1 :3Toro I1CIIOJIHeHJUI HeJIb3J'111ID:! HeY,l\06HO
Bb1H)',l\WI'b».124
KaK BU)\HO, 11 B :aTOM Bonpoce cpeW1 yqeHblX HeT e,llHHO,lly1IIl1fL
IIpe,!l;CTaBJlJ'IeTCJ'I, '!TO 06'beKTOM Bce.me .RBJlJ'IeTCE TO, no nOBO)fj' '!ero
npaBOCYI'l1CUleHl1 CKJIa;:J;blBaeTCJ'I. A CKJIMbmaeTCJ'I OHO no nOBO)fj' ,l\eF!-
TeJIbHOCTII. onpe,l\eJ1eHHCl'O nOBe,l\eHJUI 06H38.HHblX JI I\poMe TOro,
i1Hor,lla npaBOOTHOWeJIl1e McmreT I1MeTb 11 MaTepl1a.nbHbili o6'beIa - on-
pe]1eJ1eHHble MaTepHaJ1bHble 6.rrara, BeJ1V1. Bbmo,lJ; 06 arneceHl-fi1 K o&b-
eKTaM 06H38.TeJIbCTBa seJ.qei'i B Ka'IeCTSe MaTepwaJlbHbIX 06'beKTOs HS-
J1HeTC.l'l .n;OCTaTO'lHO CIlOpHbIM. Bo3MOmHO, '!TO npaBl1J1bHee 6blJ10 6b.!
Ha3bmaTb )'Ka3<lHHbIi1 MaTepHaJ1bHbl11 06'beKT npe,!l;ME'TOM 06J'13aTeJ1b-
CTBa WlI1 npe,lJ;MeTOM I1CnOJIHeHI1J'I
O,!J;HaKO 3TO clmpee cnop 0 TepMl-l11OJ1()1'JUI, '!eM 0 cyrl1 oonpoca.
B€J\b HI1KTO He CMOJoKeT OTpMQaTb, 'ITO, Hanpl1Mep, 06J'13aTeJIbCTBeHHbIe
OTHOWeHI1J'I no nOBo;J;y npasa aKl[I10Hepa Ha nOJIy'-leHl1e ,IJ;I1BI1,1J;eH,D;a
CII'.IIa,l\bmaIOTCJ'lKaKnO nOBo.llY ,l\eJ'lTeJIbHOCTII pHOro 06w;ecTBa.
HanpaBJIeHHoi1 H3. Bbl,Aa-qy aKl[I10HepaM ,l\JIIBl1,l\eH,l\a (KaK OCHOBHOro
o6'beKTa), TaK J1 nonoBo;J;y ,/J;I1Bl1,!J;eH,l\a - KOHKpeTHoi'i cyMMbl
JII16oI1MYll-\ecTBa.
JIyMaeTC.H, 'ITO BbmO,lJ;O TOM, 'lT0 06'beKTOM npaSOOTHOWeHI1J'I HBJIJ'I-
eTCJ'I .n;eJ'ITeJIhHOCTb, O,l\JllHaKQBO npl1Melll1M 11 K 06J'13aTeJIbCTBeHHblM, 11
K KopnopaTI1BHbIM OTHOllieHIDIM B BKL{110HepHbIX
BI1pO'I'I1B«IO.1iOJKHOCTb 3TOM)' AM. MapTeMbHHOBa BblCKB33.JIa TOq-
ICy apeHJUl, 'lTO B CI1J1YCBoero cyw;HOCTHOro xapaKTepa opraHl138I\>fOH-
Hble OTHoweHl1FI He MOryr :I1MeTb caMlX"IUSITeJIbOl1) ofYbeKTa. J1x 06'b-
eKTOM Bb.!CTynaeT OO'beKT TOro OOlIteCTBeHHoro OTHOWeHIDI, KOTOpoe
B03Hl1KaeT 11 paammaeTCH no,l\ B03.n;ei1cnmeM opraHl13arv;:OHHoro (yn-
paBJI€H'IeCKOI'O) 0'I'I101lleIlI-12
C :aTI1M HeJ1b3$! cornacl1TbC$!, nOCKOJ1bKY. KaR COBeplI1eHHO BepHO
OTMe'lae-r B.IT. M030J111H, Ka:m.n;oe rpIDK,.!\aHCI« npaBOOTHOII1eID1e I1Me-
eT CBOn o&beKT. Be306'beImib1x npaBOOTlIilll€HI1ff He c)'Il\eCTByeT 126
KaK npe,l\C1'aBJ1.l1e opraIll13<U-tIUll1bIe OTHOlI1e:mrn HMelOT CBOn
HenOCpe,l\C'l1leHHl:D OObeKT. J1 HymHO nOJlHOCTbK) COrnaCWI'bCH C J13JIO-
m€HHOn BbIIIJe I103JIWIei1 0. A I\pacaB'lJIIKOBa 0 TOM, 'lT0 11M BbIcrynaeT
OpraIDf3yeMbIXOTIUIIeH1'1iiECJ1I1
OTHOWeHl1e 11 HanpaBJIeHO Ha onp€,IJ;eJIeHHbmo&beKTOpraHl13yeMOro J1M
OTHOlI1eHl1FI, TO JII1II1b KOCBeHHbIM 0\5paacM, nyr€M HeJ1O(.
yno roB03,l\BICTBI1HHa opaHI13yeMoeOTHOllleHl1e
qTO KacaeTCH 06'b€KTa KopnOpaTI1BHbIX OTHOWeIDUi. TO ,[IyMaeTCJ'I:,
11M HB.illIeTCH At'HTeJlbHOCTb BKW1oHepHoro 06w;ecTBa. ,lJ;ef1CTBl'ITeJIbHo,
IICIC:t«)JIbKy KopnOpaTI1BHbIe O'IHIDl€Hl1H eCTb OTHOlI1eH UI opraHl13al[l1-
OHHble. TO, KaK yKa3blBaJI OA. I\ mce, rIOC..JJe,l\1IJIf' I1MeKYr CBOJ1M
-51-
06'beKTOM ynOPfl,llO'leHHOCTb UI'HOIIIeHIDI. CBH3etf. :ifcTBJtjt: yqaCTHI1-
KOB opramf3yeMoro OTHOllieIDjJ1. 127
TaKafl ynopfl,!J;O'IeHHOCTb I1JII1 OTHollIeHI1ff, CBfl3ei1,
;n;ei1cTBl-fii MomeT npOflBJlllTbCH TonbKO B ,lJ;eJITeJ1blIOC'm ofuuec'rBa, Ha
KOTOpyroJ1HanpaBneHoyn IKX',r\eAcmlle C\I\.QIl'Jl1€pOB.
11J10CTl1raTbCR OHa '>HIHOCTb, opramI3aql>m) MomeT'lepe3 Jle-
HTe.I1bIIOCTl> ynpaBJ1J::rIOIltI1X Cy6'beKTOB - aRqI1OHepOB. TaKJ1M 00pa30M,
06'beKTOM KopnopaTI1BHhlX OTIIOIlIemm SlBJUleTCJ::r JlemeJIbHOCTh aKL\"-
oHepHoro , rIDCI«JJIbKy I1MeHHO Ha ynOpfl,lJ;DQeHl1e ero JleH-
TeJ1bIJ'JC'I1II HanpaBneHO caMO yqaCTl1e 8KL\I10HepOB B ynpaBJ1emll1 8K-
qI10HepHhIM 06ll\ecTBOM.
,ltB. JIoMaKI1H npJ1llIenKBbIBO , 'ITOoIYbeKTOM8KQJ10HepHOro npa-
BOOTHOUJeHl1J'!, KaK H BCJ!XOro JlPyroro npaBOBOl'O OTHoweHHH, HBJ1J'IeT-
Cfl ,l\€HTeJIbHOCTb 06fl3aHHh!X JII1Q. 128
Co,!\epmaHl1eM OTHOWeHl1ff, CltJIa,ru.IBaJOIltI1XCJ::r B aKL\l10HepHOM 06-
Il\eCTBe. HBJ1J'IlOTCH npaBa J1 o6H:3aHHc:x-rn CTOpOl1. Co.n;epmaHl1e 06fl3a-
TeJIbCTBa JlOJDKHO 6bITb onp€JJ.€JI€HHbIM 11JII1, no Kpai1Hei1: Mepe, onpe-
,lJ;em1MblM. l1.B. HOBYlLUUli1 o/:>PMYJD1pyeT 3TO TaK: «EeM a6COJllOTHO
HI1KaRJ1X rpaHl1IJ; o6.naaHHocTI1 ,/J;OJDtI'JillKa YCTaHoBI1Tb HeJIb3J::r, OTHO-
llIeHl1e He I1MeeT 3Ha'IeHl1fl 06fl3aTeJlbCTBa; HI1KTO He MomeT 6bITb o6J::r-
38H npeJlOC'ffiBl'IT Bee, 'ITO yrO,D;HO: ecnl1 ,/J;eno l1,!J;eTO npe,!\OCT8BneHl1I1
TOro, 'ITO yrO,D;HO JlOJDKHl1KY. TO B 3TOM HeT IIO,AJII1HHOH CIDl3aHH0C'fH,
XapaKTepHbrn npl13HaK 06fl3aTeJIbCTS8; eCJIJII-o npe-
.n;OCTaSneHID1 TOro, 'ITO yrO,D;HO Kp€,lJ;IfiUpy, JlOJI:IKID1K OKa3hIBaeTCfl B
Ka6ane, C TO'IK11 3peHIDI cospeMeHHoro -
IDfH.» 129 )trMaeTCH, 'ITO 3TI1 nOJlOmeHI1J'! 06 onpe,/J;eJIeHHOCTI1 11
Onp€J\€.1ll1MCJCTIf CQ.!\ep:lKaHIDI BIIOJIHe npJ1MeHI1MbII1 K KOpliOpaTI1BHbIM
iIpaBOO'I'HOl11€Hl1F!M B aK1U10HepHotII ofuuecTse-
B 3aKOHe {{06 aKQJ10HepHhlX 06ll\ecTBax» HeT cneqJffiJIbHOI'O pa3J1e-
J18, nOCBRIl\eHHoronpaBaM aKQJ10HepoB. 0cIlc:mJn.Je 113 HI1X co,!\epmaTcfl
BCT. CT. 31, 32, II. 1 CT. 89, CT. 91:yKa38H1J'Jro 3aKoHa, CT. 67 fKpq:.11 B
JlPyrl1X HOpMaTI1BHbIX aKTax.
B CT. 31 3aKOH3. «068KLD'lCIIepHbIX 06Il\etTBax» Ha3BaHhI CJle e
np8saa1(.ql>DlI:pCB-BJIaJ1eJ1l,u;eB : npasoyqaCTBo-
BaTh B 06ll\eM coopamrn aKIJ;11OH€(>OO C npaBOM ronoca no BCeM BOIIpocaM
ero rn; npasoHa nOJly'l€HY!e,D,lfil1 l1qac-mJ1MY1l.\e<:TBa
06uteCTBa B CJI)"-Jae era .JJro(I!JJ,!\aQJ'lII. IIpaBa HePJB -
np: HOCJITyceq€HHbrnxapaKTep, IIOCKOJIbK)'OHl1
He I1MelOT npaBa ronoca Ha 06Il\eM ool5J::amm mrepos. ecJIJ1l1Hoe He
ycraHEJJ€HJ 3aKOHOM «06aKIJ;Y!OHepHbIX .
,ltJm: peaJIl13aQID1 npaB aKQYlOHepa, KaK npaSI1JIO, HeolJxomlMbI aK-
TI1BHble ,lJ;eiiC'IBJ1f! co CropoHbl 06wecTBa. 06fl3aHHOCTI1 aKL\I10HepHoro
-52-
06r.u;ecTBa B aKlU1OHepHOM npaBOOTHlJlllflfID He OIp3HJ('ll'1BaIO"I'Cfl B03-
,nepmaID-IeM OT ,neJ1c'TmIfi, HapyrnalOLqI1X 'lJIeHCKl1e npaBa aKL\l10Hepa.
B CT. 31 3aKOHa nepe'lJfCJIeHbI TPM OCHOBHbIX BMJW npaB aKQ1IDHepoB.
O,D;HaKO )"-IeHble HaC'fWTblBalOT i1X ropa3.IJ;o 60JIbwe.
TaK, M.T. TapaCOB C'Il1'I'aJ1, '1TO npaBa aK.L\l10Hepa 3aKJllO'ffilOTCfl:
1) B lIpaBe Ha ,l\OJIIO aK.L\l10HepHOro K1HllITa.rra; 2) B npaBe Ha ,nOJIIO 1Ipi1-
6bl1111; 3) B npase Ha )"-IaCTi1e B ynpaBJ1emm; 4) B npase KOH'Tp011fl;
5) B npase ma.n:06b!, i1CKa i1npcrreCTa. IIoMl1Mo 3TOro, aK.L\l10Hepy 1\OJDK-
HO 6bITb lIpaBo IIpI1 113BeCTHbD:: yCJ10BI1HX Tpe60BaTb
mlKBlf,!\alVli1 (eCJ111 06r.u;ecTBO He Ha'lHeT CBOWX OO€paltJdi B T€'1eHl1e Lle-
norD ra,rw. co 1\1111 pen:1C'I}XlLll1M ero J1J111.me npepBeT Ha LleJIbIi1 rap; Ha'la-
'I'bIeyiKe onepal\l1l1, TO aKl\l10HepHMeeTlIpaBoT})e60BaTbJII1K-
BJf,!\aQJ1i1 OOlLleCTBa; TO'IHO TOro me OH snpaBe nurpe6oBaTb, eCJD1 OH
BI1,!\I1'I', 'ITO aKIU10HepHbrn KaIIJIITaJI )'MeHbWl1JlCH,no pa3MepOB, C KaKl1-
MI1 LleJlb oor.u;eCTBa He MO}f{€T 6brrb ,I:I;()C'I1Ir'H I1JII1 nallOJIOBJ1HY, lIpl1
3TOM HI1KaKl1e cne4J1B.JIbHbIe, npe HHbIe J1JII1I1CR'.JIlO'lI1TeJIb-
Hble npasa e)J;l1HWlHbIX aKW'lOHepoB, B OTJIwrne OT npaB OCTaJibHbIX aK-
LII10HepOB, HI1 B KaKOM cJly<Jae He IIpI13HalOTCJ'l). AKl\I10Hep, OT,neJlbHO
B3HTbrl1, KaK 'lJIeH B.Kl\110HepHorooor.u;eCTBa OOH3aH: 1) BbIIIJIaTIITb CBOlO
,nOJllO KaIIJIITa.na; 2) Bbm.na.Tl1'I'b ee cBoeBpeMeHHo 11 B yKa3aHHOM Mecre;
3) OTBe'ffiTb cBOei1J\OJIei1 KaIIJIITa.rra 3a J\O.lITIf 06r.u;ecTBa; 4) BOO6lL1e no,ll-
'lI1HMTbCH BceM IIOCTaHOBJIeHJ1HM YCTaBa. 130
RB. JIarneB, nOMl1Mo,IJ;BYX nep€'ll1CJIeHHbIX B 3aKOHe (npasa Ha J\11-
ID-IJIeH)J;I1JD KBOTY),K lIpaBaMB.Kl\110-
Hepa OTHOCUTTalOKe npeI npaBO nOKynKI1 B.Kl\IDI B c.rry-
'1aror, npepyCMOTpeHHblX 3aKOHOM; IIpI1 npo,!\ame B.Kl\IDI aRl\IWHepaM
"IpeTbl1M .J1I1LIB.M; IIpI1 JIOIJD.JIHJ'1TeJThlIOM BbmyCKe B.Kl\ID1:.131 )J;.B, JIoMa-
rom TalOKe, C'Ii1Tafl, '1ro 3TI1 npaaa f!BJ1f!lOTCf! I1M)'111;eCTBeHHltIMl1 no
CBoei1 npMpo)J;e, JI(I6aromeT K HI1M 11 npaBO T})e60BaTb OT aKJ.tI'1OH€pHOI'O
oor.u;ecTBa BbIKyna B.Kl\IDI, IIpIIHa,AJI B.KLII10HepaM. 132
IIo MHeHl110 RB. JIanTeBa, npaKTI1'IeCKI1 Bce HeJ
npaBa aKltJIOHepos npflMO J1J111 KOCBeHHO CBfl3aHbI C I!O:3MfJmHOCTbI
)"-IacTBOBaTb B ynpaBJ1eHI1I1 ,nenaMI1 06lL1ecTBa:
- npaBo Ha )"-Iacme B 06lL1eM c06paHJ.m;
- lIpaBO )"-IacTBOBaTb B ranOCOBaID!l1 IIpI1 pernemrn BOnpoCOB Ha 06-
lL\eM co6paHi1Jt;
- npaBO obrrb l136paHHbIM (Ha3HaqeHHbIM) B OpraHb1 ynpaBJ1eHMR
oOlL\ecTBa;
- IIpaBo BHeC1'11 B nOBecTKY ,llHfl npe.nC'IO.f!:Ill€«) c06paHl1J'I npe.QJ1o-
H\:eHIDI;
- IIpaBo T})e60BaTb C03bIBa BH€O'lE'pE',lI;HOrO COOpaHI1H;
- npaBO O3HaI«JMJI€HI1J'I co CIB1CI«)M aKl\l10HepOB;
-53-
- npaBO Tpe60BaTb OT JKaTeJlR npe.IIOCffiBJIE CB e-
H11f1. OTHOCmqwXC,R K11PyrI1M aKl.tI1OHepaM;
- npaBO Hano.rryqeHl1el1Jl<lxJPMaql1I10 06r.u;ecTBa;
- npaBO 06maJ1oBaTb B cY,lIe peWeHJ1.I'I 06ll.tJ"D{ co6paHi1 ;
- B HeKoropbIX CJ1:rIaflX aKQl10HepbllfMeIOT npaBO 06pawaTbCfl B
CYA C IfCKOM B J1HTepecax 06r.u;ecTBa.
06J'13aHHocTl1 aK1V«JH€POB. c<mTaeT )'R83aHHbn1: aBTOp, HeMHOn>-
'lI1CJ1eHHbL B OCHOBHOM OHI1 COCTOfiT B TOM, 'l'1'O aKQl10Hep ,lIOJImeH on-
na'I'l1Tb aKqJ1KJ If He pa3rnawaTb KO IfH4JopMaql1KJ 0
,lIeHTeJ1bHOCTI1 06r.u;eCTBa. I33
He Bee y-'leHbIe, O,lIHaKO, npK3HaIOT, «'ITO aKLtI1OHepHoe 06ll\ecmo KaK
If BCflKoe 11Pyroe TOB8.pi1lL\€CTBO eC'lb O'I1IOUEHII€ CTOpOHHee; n03TOM)-
y-'lacTI1e B HeM €CTb COBOK)'llHOCTb rrpaB 11 o6R3atnDcTeH. CM3alUlbIX
M c06mo B OJ{HO Hepa3,!\eJieHHoe OTHoweHJlle...Renaud... yrsep)K,[(a.-
er, 'ITO aKWrJ'l KaK )"-IacTl1e B KOMnaHl1J1, eC'lb OTHOweHJlle O,lIHOCTOpc:HH€€,
TOeC'lbcoCTOI1TTOJIbK()I13npaB,HoHeJ13 06J'13aHHoCTI1:Hre,
.nemaLql1e Ha aKQl10Hepe, Hanpl1Mep, 06J'13aHHOCTh BKJlaM, npe,1J;CTaBJlH-
lOT co6mo Ie OI'HoweHJ1.ll, He lfMeKJLqI1e C aKWreH IDIKaKOW
CIDI311. Renaud OCHOBbIBaer CHOM B3r.rur.n; Ha TOM coo6pameHl1l1, '<ITO aKQl1l1
I5e:3yc.noEK> eMbI; T3.KOM xapaKT€p no ero MHeHl1lO MOIyT J1M€Th
npaBa, HOHe06J'138.RHOCThI.OJ{HaKOOOJ'l3aHHOCTI1, CBR38.HHbIe C 06JIa H11-
eM sell{bJO I1JIH 1f3BecTHbIM npaBOM, Mble BMecTe C 3T11M 06na-
MHI1eM, He npe,1J;CTaBJlRKJT co6moHWIero H€BCI3lItCCtCHCI'.1S4
OJ{HaKO nO,llaBJIRIOll\ee 6oJ:rblill1HCTBO yqeHblx yDem,!\eHo, 'l'1'0 aKl\"-
OHep He TOJlbKO 06J1a;J;aer npaBaMl1, HO JII HeceT oEisI3aHHocTIt. 31'0 3a-
KpenJ1eHO If ,lI lMaKl\110HepHbIM 3aKOHOMTeJ1bCTBOM.
II.H. I'ycanroBCKtIii C'lMTaJI, 'lro Bce 06J'13aHHOCTl1 lmepoB no
OTHOWeHJ1KJ K aRLtI10HepHoMY 061l\€CTBY 3aKJI1OIJaIOTCf .nI1Wb B OrtnaTe
npl1 I1QIJ;llJICI\e Ha aKQl1I1 J1X Hapl1l\a'I'€JlbllOfi C'"l'OdMOC'I'JII35 IIo MHeHI1lO
AM. RaMl1HK11, JIIMYll--I€CTBeHHbIe oi'iH3aHHocTI1 aKl\110HepoB lfc<lepIIbI-
salOTCJ'I BHeCeHi1eM B KamrraJ1 aKQl10HepHoro o6r.u;ecTBa B3HJC0B.136
RR )J;OJ1MHCKaJ'I C'IJllTaeT, 'l'1'0 aKqIDI BO Bcex cJ1.Y'IaflX Ha.n;eJ1fflO'I"
06H3aHHOCTHMI1 no OTHoweHI1lO K (co6mo,u,aTb IIOJ!O)f(€HJIH
,lIOK)'MeHTOB; BHOCi1Th BKJIa)U>! B nopJ'l,!\Ke, pa3Mepe Ii
CITOCOC>C\MU, I1pE'JJyCMO"I'}lIHUMJ1 yqpep,l1T€JlbHbThrn JIOKYMeHTaMl1; IfC-
nOJlHJITb peweHJ1.ll opraHoB ynpas.neHJIIH aKQi10HepHoro ofuQecTsa.; He
pa3r.nawaTb KOH4Jl-f,!l.em.tll/aJ1bH)'1O HH£PopMalV'lKJ 0 ero ,lIeJITeJIbHOC'I'Jl
npl1 OKa3bIBaTb 06IQeCTB)'Co.n;eHCTBlI!e B ocyru,eCTBJIe-
H1111! JIM CBoet! ,l(eJITeJJbHOCTl1 J1 nOMO .n.pyr APYT'Y JII APYfI1e).131
TeM He MeHee, npasa aKQHOH€pOB no cpaBHeHI1lO C JIIX 06HaaHHOCTH-
MI1 06pa3yK7T ropa3.n;0 6oJ:ree MHOI'O'IlllCJ!eHHYKJ IJ>YITny- COOTBeTCTBeH-
HO, 06paTHaH cm CKJia;J;bIBa€TCJ'I ,l(JlJ'I , Ha KcrropOM no
OTHOilieHillO K8Kl\110HepaM neiKl1TI'Opa:3)J;D OoJIbilie 06m3aHHOC'l'61, 'leM
npaB Tpe60BaID1.f1 K aKQI10HepaM.
TaKOMY :aJleMemyCQIlepmaHWI npaBOOTHOIlIemrn KaK IIpaBa aKql10-
HepoB B pa3J1l1'1Hoe BpeM.II 6blJ1O nOCMlJ.\eHO MHDmeCTBO HaY'lHbIX TPY-
AOB, CQrlepmaHHe KOTOpbIX C13O,I:\I1J1OCb B OCJIOBHJ\'I K J1X OID1CaHI11O 11
KJ1aCCJ DlHaoCHoBepa3Jll1'lHbIXKpm'epJ1es.06 HB-
JlH.I10CbOTHeCeHi1enpaBKJ bIMnI16oHe HHbIM.
nOMJ1MO pa3AeneHl111 npaB Ha KaTeropl111 11 He-
l1M)'LlI;eCTB€HHbIX, cyw;ecrsylOT 11 APYfHe KJIaCCI14>I1K3. 11I1 npas, npl1-
Ha,I\Jle)l(8.lltI-1X aKQI10HepaM. tP)'H.!J;aMemaJ1bHal1 pa60Ta B 3TOti 'laC'l'I1
6bIJJa rrpD.n;eJIaHa llA PyJtHeSblM B eroTpyAe «AHaJ1l13 npas 11 06H3aH-
HOCrel1 aKl\110HepoB" (1927 r.).
llA PYAHeB OTMe'-JaeT, '!TO pacI1pO(."IpaHllliOti HYmHO npl1-
8HaTb IpyrrrIl1pOBKY, nO,i:i;pa8.L\eJIJlKlIL\YIO npasa Ha ooLll;l1e, TO eCTb Ta-
Ki1e, KCYrOpble SCTpe'lalOTCH so scex aKQJ10HepHbIX ooIl.\ecrBax, 11 «oco-
6ble" 11J111 «npeI1MYw;ecTseHHble", KOTopble nJBIH3,l\JIeHtaT TOJIbKO
HeKOTOpblM aKW10HepaM JI! BCTpe'-laIOTCR He so Bcex aKQI10HepHbIX
o6w;ecTBax. «npel1M)'Lll;eCTB€HHble" npasa, KOTopble HenpeMeHHO npl1-
H e)fffiT KaJ'fi,!\oMY aKLlJI!OHepy,I1Memw;eMY nplffiJl!JIenlpDBaHHble aK-
QID'I, Ha3bIBalOTCH «HeOT'beMJ1eMbIMl1"
npaSO Ha noJW'fj' I'OJ10ca Ha OOlL\eM co6paHiofif, npaso Ha nOJIy'leHl1e
,II;i'1BJ1A€H.!\8 JI! JJ;0J111 113 OCTIlSllIeroCR nOCJ1e JlI1KSM,1WqMI1 l1M)'LlI;eCTBa
TIA. PyJJ;HeB paCCMaTpI1Bae-r RaK HaTypaJibHble npasa, TO ecTb TaIDIe,
KOTOpble, no ero MHeHillO, BbiTeKaIOT 113 caMOI1 npl1pO,qb1 aKQI10HepHbIX
KHI1M npIl!MbIKaIOT npaBa , TaKl1e KaK npasoyq-
pe,I\Jl!TeJ1eti nOJtI1Il!C-aTbCH Ha KOJ1lNeCTBO aKLlID1I1 npaBO
Ha CTpOI'I'It'JIbHHe npOL\eHTbL
HaKOHeL\, no 11 coo6pamem1HM OH
nO,Ilpa3AeJ111eT npasa aKL\I'IOHepoB Ha «rJ1aSHble" JI! "BcnOMOraTeJ1b-
Hble,,: rnaBHbIMl1 npasaMJ1 C'iWTaJOTCfI Te, KOTopble 06b1'lHO aKqIIDHepbI
nOJ1y<Ia1OT s nepsyK> o'-JepeAb no BX())!Q:\€HJIJI I1X B aKLli10HepHOe
06w;ecTBo; BcnOMoraTeJIbHbIllrn me npaBaMJ1 6Y1\YT Te ):1OC"1'I1meHWI aK-
L{MOHepoB, KOTopbre Jl!MI1 HaMe'laKYrCfl s pe3yJlbTaTe
,IJ;e.RTeJlbHOC'l'H 06w;ecTsa. fmBHbIllrn npaBaMl1aKQJ10HepOB, Hanpl1Mep,
6y1\YT: npaso Ha IIOJIy<IeHl-fe ,l\0J1!t:! 113 JmKBIl!,!\aQJ1OIIHOl'O l1M)'LlI;ecTBa;
npaBO Ha nOJJy'-leHJ1e ,IJ;I1sl1,!J;eH,!I,a; npaBO Ha CTpOI1'I'eJibHble npOLleHTbf,
npaBO Ha nO,l\l1I-fCKY onpe,I\eJIellU'Jro KOJ1If'IeC'I'Ba aKL\IDI 11 npaso Ha
nOJIb30saHl1e onpe.l\e.n€'HHbIMi'l HHfIMI1; npaBO yqaCTID! B pe-
llleHID!X oow;ero C06paHl111 aKL\110HepOB 06W;eCTsa npl1 06CyiK.!1eHJ111
BCex BonpOCOB, nocraBJ1el1llbIX Ha ero paCCMO'lpeIDIe.
"BcnOMOraTeJ1bHbIMI1" npaBaMJ1 aKQJ10HepOB 6Y)J;)'T: npaBO Ha OT-
'!pK.D.eHl1e aKl<im ruu'! speMeHHoro CSl1,IJ;eTenbCTsa, npaSO Ha 3aHeCe-
-55-
HJ1e aKql1i1 JI BpEMeHHJl1J cSU)\eTeJIbCTSa B oc06yK> KHI1ry, npaso Ha IIO-
J1Y'IeHl-1e KOII!1i1 C 6anaHCa; IIpaBO Ha ocnaptfBaIDIe HeaaKfllIHl,IX 1I0CTa-
HOBJIeHJli1 06r.qero co6pam1H. 138
C I1pJ-fB€.I\eHH()jj: KJlaCC!1q:.l1KaQJI€i1 IIpaB aKlU10HepoB Ha rJ1aBHble Ii
BCnOMoraTenbHble He CornaCI1JICfI.n;. B. JIoMaKMH no TOtf rrpwnrne, "TO,
KaK OH C'iJlTaeT, BCIIOMoraTeJIbHble I1paBa B03ID1KaIQT O.qHOBpeMeHHO JII
B 1I0JlHOM 06'b€Me C rJ1aBJ1blMJL 139
II.A. PyAHeB, KpOMe TOro, BblJ\eJ1JLJJ oc06ylO KaTeropJlllO IIpaB aKL\JI-
OHepoB - BTopoCT€lIeHHble IIpaBa. HalIpJ1Mep, K HJ1M OH OTHOCI1JI npaBO
6eCIIJ1aTHOrO liCnoJ1b3OBaHJ1R IIpeJ:U1pJIJilHJI aKIV1oHepHoro 06r.q€CTBa
(6eClIJ1aTHoro IIOCeIl\emm 3aBeJ\eHW1 o6u..IecTBa. IIpoe3,!\a IIO mene:3HOii
Aopore, 3KclIJ1yaTI1py€Moi1 Ii T.,A.). TaKJ1e rrpaaa AOJI:1KHbI
YCTaHaBn!1BaTbCfI pewemleM 06r.qero c06paIDIJ'l. K :'!ToR:1K€ KaTeropJlJ1
npaB OHOTHOCI1Jl npaBo aKJU.-lOHepa Ha aaq€T eroTpe6oB3HJ1i1, Tpe60B3-
HJ1f1M, n K HeM)' OOlL\eCTBOM. 3KBJ1sa.netiTHOCTI> OOR33-
TeJlbCTB B 3TOM cnyqae TalOKe J\OJIiKHa yc-r-aHBBJIHBaTbCH perneHJ1eM
06r.qero C06paHI1H. 140
BID. BOJIbq:. flQIJpa3,l:I,emU1 npaBa aI-tW1OHt:'pUB Ha OT"beMJIeMbie JII
HeoT'beMJIeMbie. K IIOCJIe.IJ;HJ1M OH OTHocun TaKJ1e, KOTopblX aKqI10Hep
He MOJKeT 6blTb JIHIII€H IIO pelliemno 06r.qero c06paHI1H, HarrpJ1Mep,
npaBO Ha ,l\11B11,!\eH,D;, Ha J1J1RSJ1 4I10HH)'lO KBOTy.141
G.B. Eenoycos oco6o JIHeT TaK Ha3bIBaeMbIe IIpaBa aKU!10Hep-
HOro M€HbllIl1HCTBa:
- Tpe60BaTb npose,l\eIDm BHeo<iepe]:lHOrO 06r.qero co6paHmI;
- BHOCJ1Tb IIpeJJ..JIIDKeHlUI B IIOBeC'IKY ,l\HH 06r.qero cOCpaHJ1R;
- Tpe60B3Tb OT peml3JlOlIHOfi KOMJ1CCJ111 (peBtf3opa) JII aYAJllTOpa
npOSe,l\eHI1H nposepKJ1;
--rpe6oBaTbar06I.J.1ecrBaBblKynaa ,npJ1Ha,l\J1 aKU!-'lOHepy;
- Tpe60B3Tb OT JIHqa, KOTOpoe CaMOCTQfI'I'e.Jn,HO IfJllf CfJBMeCTHO co
CBOMM a JIHLIOM npJlOOpeno 30% JII Donee pa3MeIl\eH-
HbIX 06bIKHoBeHHbIX aK1U1ii 061L\ecTBa, BblKyna aKlV-'li1, -
lL\I1XaKlV-'lOHepy.142
IIocne]:lHlOK) KJIaca no npaB II}X>BOW"lJI elL\€ B H3'laJI€ XX B. JII
nA. Py.IJ;HeB, C'1J1TaJI, 'ITO «no cBOei1IOpJJ,!I,I-{'IeCKOi npJlpo,n;e rrpaaa a1(-
4I10HepoB pa3J1l1'ffilOTCR Ha TaID'le, KOTOpble MOryT Ocy1l\ecTBJlJITbCR
Ka:>K,!:{bIM aKWlOIIepoM, He3aBJ1CJ1MO OT,n;pyrnX poB, JII H3 TaID'le,
JJ)IJI oc)'LIl;€CTBJIeID-lJ'lKOTOpbIX 'I'pe6YeTCR, Hmp , J13-
BeCTHOi1 lpyrrIIb! 3KIU10HepOB; HO TaR K3K 3TJ1IIOCJl€)J;HJiIe rrpaaa CJJyJKaT
06bl'IHO L\enblO 3aIL\l1Tbl JlH'TepeCOB MeHbWI1HCTBa np01'J1B 6o.m.w::J:IHCTBa.
TO J1X er.qe He 6e3 OCHOBaID-lJ'l Ha3bffiaJOT «npasaMJ1MeHbllll1HCTBa».I43
J1CXO,l\JI J113 o6menpmDrroco B ): Ha)'Ke nOCTyn3Ta 0 TOM, ..TO
JlH'TepecbI onpE',IJ,€JDOOTCfI 06'b€ttrnBHblMH ycnoBI1HMJ1 >Kn3H11 JDO,J:\ftI,
-56-
r.Jl A;:wMOBI1'i npHIIleJI K BbmOJ\Y. "iTO OCHOBHbIM clJaKTOpoM, onpe,!\e-
JIffiOJ.1tI1M II03HJ1KHCi3€Hne y JIHqa J1H'TepeCOB, CBfl3aHHbIX C ero )"-Iacn-l-
eM B 8KqHOHepHOM 06:w;ecrne. HBJIjllOTCH co6crnemIO npaBa 8KlV-10Hepa
"Te clJaKTWleCKJle B03MOiKHocm, KOTOpbIe:am npaBa .
CneJtOBaTeJIbHO, CO,I\epmaJU1e :aTUX J1H'TepeCOB MOiKHO BbmeCTI-I Heno-
Cpe,lJ;CTBeHHO 1-13 OCHOBHbIX npaB 8KQ1-10Hepa. TaKI-IMI-I J>IlITepecaMI-I, no
MHeIDIiO 8BTOpa, HBJIffiO'I'CJI;
- I-IHTepec B nOJI.)"-!emm AOXOM H8 IIJ1roKeHHbljij Karn-rr8JI B q:.opMe
,D;I-IBI-I,IJ;eH)J;a;
- I-IHTepec B nOJI.)"-1eHI-II-f AOXO,I\a (YI' npOMmI-I aKQI-I ;
-I-IHTepeCBIIOJJY"IemD1l1M.)'ll1eCTBa06:w;eCTBanpl-leroJU
- I-IHTepec B.)"I3.C'nDlB ynp8BJIemBl M.l""
.lI;yMaE'Tc!'!, 'ITO c BbmO,!!,aMJ1. K KOTOpb1M npHIIleJI 8BTOp, ('JJeJ\YeT CO-
rJIaCI-IThC!'!. BcTynM B COCTaB )"-IaCTHi-lKOB 8KlV-10HepHOro oo:w;eCTBa, JII-I-
LlO pyKOBQI:\C'I'By€TCR TeMI-I MJ1, KOTOpble MOryTJ-IM6brTb
no.Jl.)"'eHbl B p(3)'JIbTIlTe peaJll13aI.\1-IJ'! npaB )"-IaCTHI1Ka 05Lq,ecTBa. A K
HI1M, HecOMHeHHO, (YI'HOC!'ITC!'! C'lp€MJl€:IDle I-13BJIe'lb l1M.)'llIeCTBeHH)l1O
BbIfOJ\Y or )"-IaCTWI B 06:w;ecTBe MK KOHe'IHbrH J>'!Tor 1-1 CTpeMJIemte BJU1-
HTb Ira ,l\eHTeJIbHOCTb oo:w;ecTBa nocpe,lJ;CTBOM )"-I8CTIffi B yrrpaBJIeID11-1
11M, OT KOToporo 1-1 3aBI-ICIIT B03MOiKHDCTb nOJIy'-IeID1!'! npl-l6b1JII-I.
Cne.qyeT OTMeTl-lTb, "ITO 31lliOHOMTeJIbCTBOM AOnyCK1HOTCII OT,qeJIb-
Rble orpaHl-l'leHI-IR npaB aKqI10HepOB. TaK, Hanpl-lMep, n. 3 CT. II 3aKOHa
«06 aKlV-lOHepHb1X oomecTBax» yCTaHOBJIeHO, 'lTD, ycTaBOM oo:w;ecrsa
MOIYT 6brTb BBe.r:\eHbI CII'p1IHH'IeIDLH KOJIHqeCTBa aKQIDi, npl-llla,!\Jlem:a-
lIV1X O;:J;HOM.)' aKL\J:1<Eepy, I-II-IX cyMMapHO H1JMI-IHa.JlbHaI CTOMMOCTI-I, a
TaIOKe MaRCHMaJIbH(I'() 'lI-ICJIa roJIOCOB, npe,I\OC'I'aBJUleMbIX OJtHoM.)' aK-
QI-IOHepy.
BecbMaHeraTJ1BHOKO orpaHl-l'leHW1MnpaB(YI'HOCI-IJI-
CJ1 M.T. TapacoB, KOTOpbill rOBOpl-lJI, 'iTO «aKlV'lOHep, He 1J1cR
aKqI«JHepHbIM npaBOM, C05CTBeHHO fOBDpJI, HeMbICJlJ1M, XOTH B npaKTI-I-
Ke " B 3aKOHO,I\aTeJIbCTBe H TaKOe aHOpMaJIbHae RBJIeID-Ie,
BCJ1e,I\CTBMe 'iero 6b1B8KIT, Hanpl-lMep, aKqJ:1OHepbl, KOTOpble He nOJ1b3Y-
KITC!'! npaBOM yqacTI-!!'I B o5:w;J-IX co5paID1!'!x, OOpa3y!'! J13 ce5!'! KaTeroprno
RaE'.6bI Heno.mronpaBHbIX aKqHOHepOB, KaKOBbI, Hanpl-lMep, .meHl.ltMHbI
no YCTaBaM HeKOTOpblX aKqI10HepHb1X KOMTIamrn, JIi'IL{a. IIJl8.A€ronv1l2 01'-
paHWleHHbIM'lJ-ICJIOM aKQffi1, ,IJ;oJIe aKQffi1 ..»14S
HeKOTopble mpaHll'-JeHi-lfl npaB aKqHOHepoB B03MOmHbl" B J1PyrI--IX
c.rry<Iam::, H3IIpJlM€p, B cJIyqae HaJID.meID1!'! apecTa Ha aKQ>1JL
Or,I\e.1lbHble npaBa 1-1 061I3aHHOCTM aKQJlOHepOB 1-1 aK1<J10HepHb1X 06-
llIeCTB 6yJ1YT 60JIee nOJlP06HO paCCMOTpeHbI B CJIeJIYlOIl\€'II r.naBe, no-
aHaJII-I3y OT,IJ;eJIbHblX BI-IJIOB npaBOOTHOllEHIDi, CKJ1a;:J;bma-
Mejf(,!lJ' aKQJIOHepHblllBI 06wecTBaMJ-I J1 aKL\i-lOHepaMI1.
-57-
rnaoa 2. OrAenbHble OHAbl KOpnOparHOHblX
M 06S13arenbCTBeHHb1X npaBOOTHOWeHMM
MelKAY aKljHOHepHblMH 06l11eCTOaMH
H HX y acTHHKaMH
o 1. npaBOOTHoweHHA. B03HMI<alOIQlte B CB$l3M C YliaCTlteM
aK4MOHepOB B 06aqeM co6paHMI1
IIpaBo aKqI10HepOB Ha ynpaBJIeHl1e a:ra.tHOHepHbIM 06ll\eCTBOM
nocpe,1J;CTBOM )"-lacTIm B paGOTe 06mero c06paHIDI 3aKpeIIJIeHO CT_ CT. 67.
103 rK PCP, CT. CT. 31, 32, 47-63 3aKoHa «06 al\.Ql-'lOHepHbIX OOll\ecTBaX»
B CoBeTcxoM :;lHql1K.JIOn eCKOM CJIoaape (J13)\aJ1HOM B Ha'laJle
1960-x ro,!JPB) ynpaBJieHi1e crtpe.n.eJIHe'l"Cf! RaK:meMeHT, CP}'HKlV'I.II pa3-
JIW'IHbIX opraIDl30BaHHbIX CHCTeM: COQl1aJlbHbIX, Tex-
Hi'l'lecRJ1X, 06eCneqJ.1BalOIqMX CDXpaHeID1e I1X OIIp€J\e.JIelllJU1 CTpYKTY-
pbl, nO.zu\epmaIDIe peiKlfMa ,lJ;eHT€J1bllOCTJ'J, peaJ1J13a1UOO J1X nporpaMM
JiI IteJ1eH. CoQruWIbHOe ynpan.rreIDle '1paKryeTCJ1 KaK TaKoe B03.n;eHcImfe
Ha . KOTopoe l1MeeT LleJiblO ero ynopH,QO'IeHl1e, coXpaHeHl1e
Ka'I€CTBellllOii cneLlI1c}JJ.-IK1II, cOBepweHCTBOBalUle J1 paamITlI€.
B OJ\HOM 113 nepBblX UI'e'lecTBeHHblX Y'le6m1KOB no HaY'lHbIM UCHO-
saM ynpaBJl€HJlH npOl-I3BO,p;CTBOM (1969 r.) ynpaBJIeID1e onpe.tI€JIHJIOCb
KaKqeneHaIIpaB.l1fl1110e HaKOJ1J1eK'I'J-1BJ1IO.n;efi]J.JlJlopra-
ID13iU-lID:! JII Koop,':\rniau;m-l MX .l\€HTeJIbHOCTH B npOl-leCCe np::u3BO.l\CTBa.
B Oi<ccpop.tlCKOM pyccKo-aHrJIm:ic:J«::M cJlosape (1994 r.) CJlOSO «yn-
paBJIeHl1e» nepeEO,l{I:ITCR Ha aHrJIJrl;icKID1:H3bIK TBKI1MI1 -repMl1HBMJ1 KBK
«management», «adminishation», «dlrectlon» (mrn paCCMBTpl1BBIOTCH
KBK CJ1HOHI1Mbl).
-58-
COJlep)fffiffi1e nOH1ITIDI MeHe,WKMeHT paCKpbmaeTCR nrnpOKO J1 MHO-
roCTopoHHe: MeHe,IPKMeHT KaK cnoc06 ynpaBJK'HWI, py1«)IIOJICTBa, Ha-
npaBJIeHIDI J1JUI 11:QHTpoJlfl; ::11'0 J1CKYCCTBO HanpaBJIeHIDI J1Jll1 ROH"IpOJIH.
3m .moJll-'l, KOHTpoJIl1pYKJJ.J.Ufe J1 HanpaBJUIIOJ.J.Ufe pa6crry OpraHlI3aIUfK.
a TaIOKe ynpaBJ1eIl'l€Cmnl: nepcomw:r. MeH€,IPKMeHT -::ITO
Hoe HCIIOJIh3()BaIDe I11OC)() TaKJilX pecypCOB ICaKJ1M)'Il1eCTBO J1
TpY,lJ;,lJ;JlfI AOCTJDKemf.fI 38J\aHHbIX J.t{'J1en c Mal\CJ1MaJ1bHO s4xj:leKTHB-
HOCTbKJ. TaKoeonpe.QeJIeHHe I1JMBOJ\1ITC.fI B MemJ:1YHapo)J;HOM cnpaBOq-
ffi1Ke no M , H3,!\3.HHOM B AHrID1Jil (International Dictionary
of Management Fourth Ed. By H Yohancen GB, 1990)146.
TaKIDf 06pa3oM, caMO no ce6e ynpaBJIeHHe - STO npoqecc PYKOBO,1l;-
CTBa, pernaMeHTaLlJill'l ICaKOH-.mroo ,/J;€RTeJIbHOCTI1. YnpaBJlfITb opraHJ1-
acunreii - 3HaQl1T, crtpe.I\emrrb OCHOBHble HanpaBJIeHWI ee pa3BJ1TJUi,
CTaBI1Tb nepe,':\HeHL\eJIJ1 H3a)J;a'illH Tb HX.l\OC'I'If)KeHiDO.
RIO. EaKlID1HCICaC C'MI'aeT, 'ITO ynpaBJ1€HJle aKLlHoHepHbIM o61L\€-
CTBOM CJIe,u;yeT paCCMaTpHBaTb ICaK «1<€JITeJIbH)C'Tb IKJ onp€,/J;e.neHIDO
nopR;J;Ka VlCn0JIb30BaHJ1R HM)'IlIeCTBa aKQJ1OHepHoro 06w;ecTBa J1 rpaK-
TWIecKoM)' ero HCnOJIb30BaHJn0>'.147 IIpe.D;CTaBJIHeTC, q'J'() npJilBe,lJ;eH-
Hoe aBTOpoM OIIp€,':\eJIeHVle ynpaBJIeHlliI He6e3YIIpe'lHo. B.IO. EaKlliI1H-
CICaC onpe,':\eJUIeT ynpaBJIeHJile CJIJ1llIKOM Y3KO, B€)J;b pellIeHJ1R 06lL\ero
c06paHIDI ,IIaJIeKO He BCer,lJ;a RaCaIOTCH l1M)'IlI;eCTBa aRqIroHepHOlO 06-
w;eCTBa.
KIT. ry6I1H no,/J; ynpaBJIeHJ1eM aKl\JilOHepHbIM 06IQecTBoM nOHJ1MaeT
MeXaIrn3M J1JIJ1 CJilCTeM)' roaJ1MOJI€HCTBJI.H yqaCTHJ1KOB 11 cnoc06bI, C no-
MOLqblO KOTOpbIX OHI1 npe,':\CTaBJIIDOT CHOI1 J1HTepeChi. ITo ern MHeHJ1R),
OfCTeMa KopnopaTI1BHOro ynpaBJIeHWI npeJ1C'l'8BJ1R€ co60tf opraHH3a-
qMOHHYIO MOJleJIb, C nOMOLqbKJ KOTOpOtf BKqI10HepHoe 06IQecTBo ,l];0JI:m-
HO npe.IIC'TBBJ1RT J1 3a Tb J1HTepeCbI CBOJ1X mmecropos.146
CR. BIlHOBOMOTMe<meT, 'lTO npaBo aKqI10Hepa Ha yqaCTHeBynpaB-
JIeIDrn 06IQecTBoM HBJlfIeTCR caMblM CJIO:IKHbIM no cBoe IOJM,!II1'-IecKOi1
I1pMpo,lI€. J1MeR J1MytlIecTBeHHbili xapaKTep, OHO xapaKTePJ'I3Y€'lUI
CBOHCTBOM J1M'IHO BJIaCTH, TO eCTb I303M())KHQCTbIO onp€,l\eJ1JI'Ib nOBe-
,lJ;eHl1e ,D;pyroro cy6'beKTa, a HMeHHO aKq;110HepHoro 061L\€CTBa. 149
KpOMe TOro, no Ha6.mo.r:\eHHRM MHOI11X yqeHbIX. rJ1aBHaR, a B 6oJ1b-
ImfHCTBe cnyqaeB ep;llliCTB€lllJafl, C'I'paTernqeCKaR qeJIb ofu.e,n;mIeHlliI
B aKl\J10HepHoe 06lL\eCTBO 3aKJiKJ'laeTCR B TOM, 'lT06bI IIOJIy'DITb 6oJ1b-
we npn6b1JIJ1 Ha Kam.Il}'lO €AI1HJ1L1Y ICamrra.na J1lli)o nO)\I"OTOBtfTb ycno-
BJilR,l:\JIH .l\OCTJDt\€HJIH ee B 6YllYLI.1;€M. B CBH3Ji1 C 3TI1M llplHL\lffibl nOCT-
poeHJ1f! H rpYRKLIJIOHKpOBaHJilJI aKq;woHepHoro 06Il.\ecTBa BCeL\eJ10
IIV{<IJlHeHbI =epecaM RaIDfTaJIa, "ITO Hal160Jree nOJIHO BbIpamaeTCH B
opraHJ13aQIDI CWCT€MbI ynpaBJI€HJ1R 06w;ecTBa, KOOpAJilHaL\11JiI ,l:\eRTeJIb-
liOCTJiI ero opraHoB. 150
-59-
()qeHb 'IaCTOBMecTO TepMMHa «ynpaBJletU1e» J1CIIOJIb3YeTCR TepllrnH
«IOOHTj)OJ1b». KoHTpoJ1h MOmHO nOHMMaTh RaK B03MOIKHOCTb nO;WMpaTh
(J1Jll1 OTBepraTh) Ra .QaTOB B COBeT WlJ)eRTOpoB OOIl\eCTBa. TaKOe on-
peAeJ1etJJ1€ .QaJ1J1 B Ha'laJ1e 1930-x IT aMepl1RaHCKJ1e SKOHOMJ1CThl
AA. Eep,J1J1 J1 r.MMH3, J1 OHO IIpJ1fOAHO, ecJllf B OCHOBe KOHTp0JIJ1JJe:>ID1T
I'ICKJII()'lJITJIbHO B.rra,n;eHMe aKQJ1flMJ1. AMepHKaHcmm :aKOHOMMCT
.u. ROTQ ;!IaJ1 HeCI\OJ1bI\O J1HOe on : KOmpOJ1h -:aTO B03MOm-
HOCTh Qx1pMUpOOaTb OOIQY1O I1OJ1I1'I1fKy PYKOBO,!\CTBa IWpnOpaQJ1eRl51
lo.A. Mere.nesa Bbl,ll;eJlHeT HeCKOJIbKO OCHOBHbIX TeC1pHii KOHTpoJ!J'1
B aKQI10HepHOM ofuQecTBe. n€pe'lJICJ1€HHbIX HJ1m€.
- TeOpM aKQI-10HepHoro KOHTpoJUI, B COOTBeTCTBI-fiI C IWTOpml KOH-
'IpOJIb B aKQJ10HepHOM OOIl\eCTBe €TCH 8KQJ10HepaMJ1, BJla-
;!IelOll.U1MJ1 onpeAeJ1eHHbIM KOJ1Jf'IeCTB()M aKQJ1A.
- TeopJ1Jl KOHTpoJIJ'i4JJ1HaHCOBblX UHCTIITyTOB. KoHTpDJIb CO CTOpO-
HblnOCJ1e X OCHOBhlBaeTCH HaBJIa.n;eHIDI aKW'iHMJ1 RaK Ha npaBec06-
CTBeHHOCTII, TaK J1 no IIqJyqeHJIIO J1 B J1HTepecax,lIp)TI1X JJMQ. RpOMe
TOro, OHJ1 MOryT KOH'IpOJIMpOB8Th 06Il\€CTBO KOCBE'HHbIM OOpa30M B CJ1-
Jfy cyw,eCTByK>LW'IX C ,IJ;OI'OBOpIIUX OTHOWetOOi TaK, OTMe-
'IaeT 8BTOp, I1CTO'-IHI1KOM BJIaCTJ1 cpJ1HBHCOBblX J1HCTHTyrOB MOmeT c.rry-
)KJ1Tb pOJIb 1K8 Kam-rraJla )J;JUI CJ6IQecrsa., KOTopoe nOJI)"IHJlO,
Hanpl1Mep. RpYI1Huii38€M I1Bh1Hym,iJ;eHoBcHJly:noro CJleAOBaTh onpe-
.n;eJleHHhIM npeMllICaHJmM nJIR TOro. 'ITOOhl oOecne'lJ1Tb B03BpaTHOCTb
C)'MMbI 38i1Ma.
- MeHe,n;mepI1C'I'CRaH TeopJ1Jl, 8BTOpallrn KOTOPOi1 6bLJlJ1 yme yno-
MJ1HaBIill1€CH AA. EepJrn J1 r. MJ1H3, OCHOBblBaeTCH Ha TOM, 'ITO KOH-
'IpOJIbBaKQJ10HepHoM06Il\€CTBe €TCfl€ro
(MeHe)\mepallrn). «OHl1 ecKI'I IIpJ1HJ1MIDOT pellleID1H 11, 6yJlY'lJ1
npe €HbJCaMI1MCeOe npl1 0'I't':yTCTBJ01 KOJ1TpOJIR COCTOPOHb1 aK-
Ql-fOHepOB, MOryr CTaTh IOCHIpOJ1Hpy1OIl\eA 1pynrnn:1, BJIa,!\efl HeOOJ1b-
IID1M IIaKeTOM 8KQI1i1. Bo:3Mt::oKHocTb KOHTpOJIR ynpaBJlHIOLW'IX Iffi.)\ IWp-
noparureR BbiTeRa€T J13 ill{ KOH'IpOJIR Ha,!\ npoQ I'O.I1OCOBa1fi-
aKW'iflMl1..lWyrJ1MnC'I'O'llllmOMBJlaCTJ1BblCllIJ1X HeJlO-
CTynHbIM ,lI;pyfJ1M lpynnaM, flBJlHIOTCH CneL{J18JlbHble 3H8H11H 06 onepa-
QI-f$IX KOpnOpaLtJDI».152
B HaCTO$1Il\ee BpeMH MEfl{',l\jKeplCTCKaH TeOpMH peaJIU3y€TCfl He
TOJIbKO B POCCJ1J1, HO J1 B f5o.1nowMHCTBe C'IpaH B KpynHblX JOOMrnIHJIHX C
paClIblJl£fJHOCTbK) KaIU1Ta.rra. 3aBJ1CJ1MOCTh ynpaBJIeIn.\eB or
c06CTBeHHHKOB B TalG1XKOMIIaHIDiX 38aya.J1J1pOB8Ha, 'ITO }],8J10 OCHOB8H11e
MHOfJ1M yqeHbIM (Hanp11M€p. MI-1. RyJIan-rny, RIO. EaKlIDIHCKaC)') C'IJ1-
TaTb, 'ITO B3aMeH BJIaCTJ1 co6cTseHHIUOCI! nOHBJIHeTCH HOB8H BJIaCTb -
BJIaCTb ynpaBJImOLW'IX, TO eeTb BJIaCTb 0e3 c:c6::TBeHHOCTII, a caMO nOHH-
we cofcraetrnocTIl IIpespaTl1.JIOCb B Kpl1 I'I€CKy1O $ IJ().153
-60-
CaM CIIoc06 qJraHJ:13aI.!Im BJIaCTI:! B aKQMOHepHOM 06w;eCTBe JIBJUIeT-
CJ1 Heo6br<mi-bIo npl1BJ1eKaTenbHhIM AJUI atX:TBelllIU1(()B KaID1Tana. Rna-
AeR KQlITpoJIbHbIMnaKeTOM aKQKi1, MQmHO, no cyrnAena. paCIIopIDKaTb-
CJ1 KallI1TaJlalwD-f, 80 MHOro pa3 np co6CTBeHHbn1: BKJIa;:J; B
ycraBHbli1 KaID1TaJI 06w;ecma. Teop€TI'I'feaaf IOCHI'pOJ1bHbIi naKeT aK-
QIDi paReH 51 Dh. Ha npaRTll«' me 6bIBae-r AOCTaTO'llIO MMeTb 10-15% Ka-
mrrana, 'lT06bl nOJ1HOCTblO onpe,!\eJ1$1'I'b 1l0Jnf1'J.-IKY 06IL1€CTBa " COCTaB
opraHoB ynpaBJ1E'HIfJL B 60J1blIDfX aKltI10HepHbIX 06r.qeCTBax, TAe 'l"'CJJO
)T'lacTHHKOB onp€,/J;€JlHeTC.fl ,IJ;€CHTKaMI1, a TO '" COTH.IIMYI TbICH"1, KOH-
'IpOJ1bIJl>Iii IJaKeT aK!V1ti Hepe,!\Ko MOmeT COCTaBJIRTb Bcero nl1Wb He-
CKOJIhKO npoQeHTOB OT 06w;e:i'i BeJlWUllibI aKQJ10HepHoro KaID1Tana.
B POCCID'! B Hac-rOHI.II;ee BpeMH CJl())KJm8.Cb TaKaH cl1T)'aQI1.II, 'lTO or-
poMHoe KOnl1'-J€CTBO lOHepHblX 06IL1eCTB 6b1J1O 003,D,aHO J1M€HHO B
IIpOl-leCC€ np"'BaTI13a4l111. Eo.m,uraJi 'laCTb aKqI1i1 3= 06IL1eCTB npl1-
Ha.r\J!€mI1T:I1X pa6arHJncaM, KaK p OBblM, TaK 11 OTHOCJ'J:w;I1MCR K pyKo-
8OJVlW;eM.Y cocTaBY. TO eCTh ynpaBneHqaM. IIpM 3TOM TpYJlOBbie Kon-
n€IITI1Bbl He O)J;HOPO)-lHbI no CBOI1M JllITepeCaM. li1HTepeCbl :I1X 'lJI€HOB,
KaK npaBHJ10, pa3MbrI'bI, 11 n03TOMY TpyAOBble KOJrJleKTl1Bb! He Mor)'T
oC)'ll-lec-rBlliITb KOH'I'pOJIb B aKqI10HepHbIX 06IL1ecmax.
rpyrma ynpaBJIeHI-leB J1Me€T ropa3J10 M€Hblll)'lO)-IOJIIO B B.K4I10Hep-
HOM KaIDITane 06w;eCTB, HO ee mrrepecu 'leTKO onpe,l\en€Hbl: coxpa-
HI1Tb KOHTpoJIb HaJ-I npe)-l!IpMHTI:!eM, KOTOpbli1 OHa J1Mena)-lO np"'BaTI1-
3aQI1J1. J1 €:i13TO Y)-Ia€TCJI. B HaCTOHILI€e BpeMH peaJIbHhn1: KOHTpoJIb H3):\
ofu-1ecrnoM HaXOJJ:!ITCH, KaK npaBI1JIO, B PYKaX ,mtpeXl\lD111 BO MHornx
c.rryqam:: He3aBI1CJ1MO OT TOro, lITO t:raHOBJITCH 4x:JPMaJIbHblM co6cmeH-
HI1KOM BKQI1i1. TaKl1M 06paaoM, Ha npaK'mKE', BCneACTBl1e 60JlhlllOiii
paCIIbLJIeHHOCTM aKQJIOHepHOro KaIII1Tana, peanM3YeTCH MeHe1J.'KE'-
pl-lC'1'CKaH TeOpl-lJI. 154
Oc06b1e IIpaBa AJUI yqaCTWI B ynpaBJIeHl111 aKQI-IOHepHbIM 06W;€CT-
80M AJUI POCCJ1iiicKoH 4le.r\epa4l111, ee CyD"beKTOB 11
M)'HJ'IlVtnanItHItIX 06PaaoBalOOi KaK aKltI10HepoB. TaK, HanpIDfep, Haoc-
HOBaHID1CT. 38 4IeJ-I€panbHOI'O 3aKoHa OT 21.12.01 I'M 7B-<P3 «Onpl1Ba-
TI13aQMl1 rocy,D,apCTBeliHoro 11 MY J1MY1-1\eCTBa" B QeJlHX
o6ecne'-l€HJ1.fI o6opoH0CIXJ00611OCT1-f CTpaHbI" 6e30nacHOCT'" rocY.l-l3pCT-
Ba, 3aJ1-lHTbl HpaBCTBeIiHOC'TIf, 311.OpOBbJI, npaB 11 3aKOHHbIX I11ITepeCOB
rpa H Pet> IIj:aBJrre.m.CTBO Pet> 11 opraHbI rOCYJlapCTBeHHoi1 BJIaCTI1
CyD"beKTOB Pet> MOryr npl1l1IDfaTb peWeHI-UI 06 I1C11OJ1b3(J331I1fJI cneQ"'-
3.JIbHOro npaBa Ha )T'lacTl1e COOTBeTCTBeHHO p 4>e)-lepaQMl1I1
cyD"beKTOB Pocc tiiicKm 4>e)-lepaQI1I1 B ynpaBJIeHl1I1 0'I'KpbI'INMJ1 aKQ110-
HepHhIl\rn 06w;ecTBaMl1 - 3TO cneQl1aJIbHoe npaoo «30J1OTaJI aKqwJI".
IJ;eJlh TaKora KOHTpoJUI HaJ-I o61l\eCmOM - coxpaHI1Tb ::I'm 06IL1€CTBa B
Ka'l€CTBe x03HfiCTBylOIl\I1X e:y&beKToB, npeAOTBpaTI1B I1X J1I1KBl-\.D.aql1lO
-61-
HOBbIMl1 co6CTBeHHMKallrn. peopreHl13illU11O. 3aK.JIl(N€HJ:le KPyrIHbIX p>t-
CKOBaHHbIX JI CfJMHIITeJIbHb! C,!J;eJ10K, a TaJOKe I1HbIX ,lJ;eifcrmdi, cnoc06-
HbIX npMBeCTII 06r.u;ecTBa K 6aHKpoTCTBY. CORpar.u;emno OfueMOBI1pO>f3-
BO;:J;CTBa, 'I11CJ1eHHOCrn 3aWlTbIX paOOTffi'lKOB JI TaK AaJ1ee.
YKa3alll1Oe npaBO ,n;aeT BC!3MCOlaIOC'I' npe,!\CTaB>tTeJl.l1M nepe'illC-
J1€HHbIX rryD.IDl'ffiO-rrpaBOBbIX o6pa mBamrl1: )"-IaCTBOBaTb B 06Il\eM co-
opam'!JI aKLtI10HepoB C npaBOM BeTO npJl paCCMO'IpeHJlJ1 OOl1tJlM co6pa-
H11eM onpe,!\eJ1eHHbIX BOnpOCOB.
,ltB. JIOMaKJIH n rpopMbl ynpaBJIeHI1H B aKLtI10HepHbIX
06utecrna"( Ha npaBOBble JI HeIIpaBOBI>Je. HenpaBOBbJe <PoPMb1 ynpaB-
J1eHJIJ1 - 3TO 0praIDI3al.{JlOIIHbIe ,n;edCTBJm, J1I1llIeHHhIe npaBOBoro 3Ha-
qeHJlJ'i, JII MaTepJlaJlbllU-T€XHWI€CKJre onepaQI1I1 (HanpJ1Mep, ,/:\eHTeJ1b-
HOCTb nOopraHJ13aLtl1tf I1J1amqx:mamr.J'l npotf3BO;:J;CTBa, emno
KOOp,lJ;l1H3qI1tf MeJfi,!:l)' CTPYKTYPHblMJl! nO;:qJa3,/:\eJlE'HlfHMi'l 06Il\eCTBa).
B 8KQI'ICHepHbIX ofuQecTsax ynJ:6BJI€HJ1€ BO BHenpaBOBbIX 4x:JpMaX
rJIaBHbIM 06pa30M OCYIl\eCTBJIH€TCR Ha Htf30BbIX C-ryn€HHX 8,l{MJ1HI'ICT-
paTI1BHOfi JIeCTH bL K npaBOBblM <PoPMaM OH OTHOCIIT ,n;eiic'rBJ1H yn-
paBOMO'ieHHbIX JIJ1:L\., BJreKyW;JiIe onpe,!\eJ1€HHb1e IlpaBOBble llOCJI€,l\CT-
BID!, a JllMeHHO: npl1HRrne npaBOBbIX alITOB, 3aKJllO'-IeHJ1e ,l\Ol'CIBOpOB.
COBE'prn€HIf€ J1Hb1X IOp eCKJ1 3Ha'll1MbIX,lJ;eifcTBJrl1. YnpaBJreH'-lec-
KaH ,lJ;eHTeJIbHOC'I'b Bbicillero opraHa ynpaBJ1eHID1 -OOIl\ero
Co6paHl1H - npaKIW-lecKl'l BCer,lJ;a JIIMeeT npaBOBHe 4x:JpMbI. I :I:I
'I'pa,roIL{a1HHO C'illTaeTCH, 'ITO npaBO aKL\J10Hepa Ha ynpaBJ1eHJle 06-
r.u;eCTBOM pea.ID13YeTCfI B CJ1e1JYlO1QI1X nHTh! npaBOMO'lJ1JIX:
- npaBO Tpe60BaTb C03bIBa OOIl\eroc06paHl1H aKW1oHepoB;
- IIIJ3Mf»!aIOCT )"-IaCTBOBaTb B I1O,lJ;I'OTOBKe npOBe,!\eH11R 06Il\ero co-
opamm aKqI10HepOB;
- npaBO Henocp€,l\CTBeHHOrO Y'ffiCTWI B caMOM COopaHJ1Jf;
- npaBO aKiV'lOHepoB OcyIl1eCTBJI.I1Tb CBoe BOJ1e emle nyreM
ro.rrOCOBaHIUI Ha co6pamm;
- npaBO ObITb J136paHHbIM JI WOtfpaTb B opraHb1 ynpaBJIeID1.ll 06Il\e-
CTBa.
06Il\eec06p6lme aKLtI10HepoB - opraH aKLtI10HepHOro 06Il\eCTBa, qe-
pe3 ;n;eHTeJIbHOC'I'b KOTOporo HeIlocpe,II.CTBeHHO PeaJ1J13Y€TCR npaBo aK-
qI10HepOB Ira ynpaBJ1eH11e.
IIo noBO;:I.Y 3HaqJ1MOCTI1 oOIl\ero c06paH11H,wrJ'i aKL\i10HepHoro 06Il\e-
CTBa II. !fuceMCKI1" rrncaJ1, 'lTO «oor.u;ee co6pa.HHeHe MOmeTObITb BnOJ1-
He yC'IpaHeHO 61"3 Jll3BpaIl\€HHH caMoro Cy:Il\eCTBa KOMnaHIDI KaK TOBa-
p:nQ€CTBa, O,/:\HaKO HWITO He nperuITCTByeT eM)' nepeJl8Tb J\PYI'OMY
opraHY HElIDTOpbI€ W CBOUX: IIOJIHOM()qJ,Ij,i».I56
-62-
OcymeCTBJIeffi:!eopraHa!\rn OOLqeCTlm.ynpaBJIeH'-E'CKOH
flBJ1.ReTCJ106'beIm-rn1IoHH YnpaBJ1effi:!eaK-
QlKIIeJEhlM06LqeCTBOM CJIy.I!G1TMHTepecaM OHepoB HllO CooeHCyrl1
CBO,!J;H'1'C.R K ynpaBJl.RK)ll\eMY aroumlEpOO KaK Cyfu.eKTOB
ynpaBJlemm Ha aKltI1OIIepHOe 06ll\ecTBO KaK 00bel\T ynpaBJ1eHWL Co)J;ep-
:HGlffi:!eM TaKOI'Q ynpaBJIJllOll\ero HB.IlfIeTC.R
Ae.RTeJ1bHOcrn 06I.I.\ec'I'B3.,o6ec!1e'leffi:!eero nn:lpo-
BaHI1..RB COOTBeTCTBI>1I>-I C mrrepecaMl1 H qeJ1.RMtf OHepoB.
IIoCKOJIbKy o6u.(ee co6paffi:!e HBJ1HeTC.R BbICWI1M OpraHOM ynpaBJle-
HWI 06ll\eCTBoM, RaK STO 33Rp€f1J1eIJ'J ll. 1 CT. 47 3aKoHa «06 a oHep-
HbIX OOll\E'CTBaX», 'TO OHO peaJU-l3YeT clJYHK co6c'memnma B a o-
HepHOM ciJrQeCTBe. «Dpl1 31'OM aKWtOHepU, He HBJLIUICb rpopMaJlbHO
(npaBOBbIMH) COOC'1'BeHHJ1RaMH cpe,!\CTB I1pOM3BO.II;CIBa, 4Jal\TWleCKH
ocYIl\eC'1'BJ1JllOT KOH"I'pOJIb Iffi)\ cpe,!J;CTBaMl1 IIpOI'13BO)J;CTB8. 06ll\ecTBa».157
06ll\ee coopaHl1e aKQ>10HepOB OO.JIa):$.eT BC€MI1 0CH0BHlDm: npl13Ha-
KaMl1 opraHa IOpl1,!{l1'leClwro .ID1l\a:
1) :'ITO HeKaH opraH113fU 110HHO oc}:J0pMJ1eHHaH 'ffi.CTb IOIH1,!J;WlecKo-
ro J111q8., npe,!\cTaBJ1eHHRR O)J;HJ1M .111100 HecKOJIbKJ1MJf clJI1311'1ecrou.m
.ID1qaMI1,
2) RaK opraH 8KQI10HepHoro OOIl\eCTBa ol5pa3yeTCH B COO'I13e'TCT-
BID! C nopR,!\KOM, onpe,ll;eJ1eHHhIM 3aKOHOM 11 Y'lpep,l1'TeJ1bHblMl1 ,lI;OKY-
MeHTaMl1;
3) H8,!:\eJ1eHO eHHbIMR nOJIHOMO'fJ1HMI1, K01'O-
phIX ocy1l\ecTBJIJleTCR B npe,!\e.rrax ero co6crBemroii KOMIIeTeHQIUt;
4) B0J1eo6pa30BaHMe 11 BOJ1el13'bRBJIeHMe ropn,ltK'IecKoro JII1Qa
oct>oPMJIJleTCJ1 nocpe,!\CTBOM npllliRTWI ClJeqwaJIbHbIX aKTQB oOIl\ero co-
5pamm-nparotaJJIOB. I58
AK1v1oHepbl MOryT ocyIQf2CTBJl.RT ynpaBJIeHl1ecK)'1O clJYHKl\MIO B
He60JIbilll-lX OOIl\eCTBax. B 'TOM me CJJY'Iae, Kor,!\a X0351i-fC'I1!eHHaR 11,eR-
TeJ1bHOCTh OOIl\eCTBa ,!\ocTi-iraer OIIpe,!\eJ1eHHbIX MaCIlITaOOB I1Jll1 KOr,!\a
KOJIJ1'-JeCTBO aRlVIDIIepOB HaCTOJIbKO BeJIHKO, 'ITQ 3TO 3aTpYAHReT 3c}:J-
4>eKTI1BHoe PYKOOO.l\CTBO Bcei1 ,!\eflTeJ1bHOCTblO 06Il\ecTBa, Ha6Jno,IlaeT-
CH nepe.n;a'Ia OT,!\eJIbHbIX ynpaBJ1eH'-JeCKI1X clJ)'HKQJ1i1 CI1eu;HaJ1bHO rpop-
MMpyeMbIM OpraHaM OOll\eCTBa. AK1V-10HepbI OCTaBJ1RIOT B CBOI1X PYK8X
,mmn, perneID-le HaWJOJIee BamHbIX BOTIpOCOB ynpaBJIeHI1R OOIl\eCTBOM.
J1 TeM He MeHee, ynpaBJ1eH'ie<:KCIl AeJIT€JIbHOCTJI aKQJ10HepOB CBOiicT-
BeHHbI Bce <PYHKLtl-1>1 ctIV1aJ1bHoro ynpaBJ1eHWI:
- IIJIaHHpOBaID-le (onpe.D;e.JJeHKe OCHOBHblX HaIIf:BBJJeHl1l-1 pa3B1-1TID1
J1,l(ewre..JibHOCTJl , a TalOKe cpe,!\CTB AJ1.R JIQC'I1Vt(eID1.H nOCTas-
JIeHHbIX qeJ1eH);
-63-
- opraHl ($JJJMI'IpOBaHi'lE'OpraHOB 06r.qecTBa JIE'lmeJ1X
);
- P)'ROBOJlCTBO (o603Ha'leH>1e nepe,[l 06r.qecTBoM B qeJIOM >1 ero op-
raHaMI1 KOHKpeTHbD!: 3a.I\aIJ, :BUIeJ<a}()lltI-1X 113 peaJ1H331Vnf 4>YHKLti'lJ1
IIJIalDtprmaHIffi);
- toolITpoJIh (noCTOmlHoe Ha6JllO,[IeIDfe 3a J\eHTeJIbHOCTblO 06r.qeCTBa),
- KOOp,!I,J.-IHaLtJ1R (06ecneIJeHJ1e ynop$l):\OIJemUl altl.\J10HepHoro 06r.qe-
CTBa KaK qeJ1OC'IHOii CI1CTeMhI, corJIaCOBaHHOCTH ,[IeWCTBI1i1 ero OpraHOB).
C.,n. :MonoureBClOrli I'1CIIOJIb3y€T AJlH 0603H3.'ieHIDI ynpaBJIeH'1ecKow
;n;eHTeJ1bHOCTJ1 opraHOB X03$!ti:cTBeHHbIX 06r.qecTB UleIVIaJIbHbIti: Tep-
MJ1H - KopnopaTMBHOe ynpa.MeH1f€- IIpJ13TOM no,!\ npo eCCOM KOpnopa-
TMBHOro ynpaBJIeHIDI OH nOHJ1Ma€T,IJ.eHTe.1IbHOC opraHOB X CJBeH-
HbIX 06r.qecTB no BbIpa6crme (nO,!\I'OTOBKe 11 npl-fHRTI1IO) lroHKpe'THOJ'O
ynpaBJIeWiecKoro peweHIDl, ero HCllOJIHeHmO (pea.ID13aQIm:) 11 IIpOBep-
Ke ero BbII101IH€IDI.H. 1S9 YKa3aHHOe onpeAeJI€lme KopnopaTI1BHOrO yn-
paBJIeHIDI nO)JJ(ep)fGffiaeTCH 11 I1CIIOJIbayeTCR l1,.A MaKapoBbIM. t60
C)'lWIOCTb 06r.qero co6paHIDI COCTOwr B TOM, 'ITO B IIpOLIecce IIpMHJITIDI
11M pelllftIIrii ocyw;ec'I'BJ1fleTCR BOJIB13'bRBJ1€HJte CI1p€.l(eJIeHHO KOJU-f'le-
CTBa.m:rn; - aKQJ:1OHeprn. B HeM yq:aCTIJYlOLqI1X. PeayJIbTaTOM aToro MO:IKeT
6bITb cor.nacOBaIDIe BMb 3TID!: .m:rn;JII-f6o KOHtP.rr= J1X l1HT€pecOBI1 H€)J;0-
C'I'11')KeIDfe e,!J;l1Horo MHeHIDI no BbIHeceHHbIM Ha 06cym,1\eIDfe BonpocaM.
En. ry611H nOHHMaeT no)]; l1HTepecOB TatOOe ynpaBJIe-
HYle aKWtOHepHbIM IIpI1 KcrropoM H3.pyrnaeTCH epapxl1H
KOpnopaTIffiHbIX llliTepecoB, KOr,I\a OT npi1qJIrreTa m,ffiopa BH)"IpHKOp-
nopaTI1BHbIX ynpaBJIetNecKl>1X pewetmi1 3aBMCHT co6mo)\eIDIe I1JIJ1 He-
co6Jno,!\eIDfe KopnopaTI1BHbIX WlTepecoB O'I';:J;eJIbHO B3f1TOro al\.ql10Hep-
HOro 06ll\eCTBa. KoH<P-m-ncr 11H"I'EpeC(E - 3TO cwryaql1.H BbI60pa Me:m,n;y
HH'I"epI2CaMI' KOpI1OpaLllfi1 B qeJ10M I-f I1HTepeCOM OT,IJ;eJIbHOii IpymIbl
cy6"beKTOB, yq:aCTBy1OllV>1X B al\.ql10HepHbIX OTHOllieHIDIx. 16t
B aToM CBfl311 .n;.J1. Mei1ep oI5"bfICIDIJI npC)I-IeCC $JpMMpoBaHl1.fl BOJIM
aKqI-fOHepHOro 061l.\eCTBa CJ1e;:Iy1OII.JWoI o6paacM «Ec.rn1 opraH 1OpJWI'£C-
KOroJIMQa - O,lJ;HO .mnw, TOBblp<l:ateIDfe BOJIIII ero coo6pa:3Ho
cyw;ecTBY 1'l€CKOCO JIMQa. Ho eCJIl1 opraH COCTOHT 113 H€C'IIO.1I:bKHX
q.rnl'leCRJ1X J1J1lt TO B KalroM c.nyqae BbrpameIDle BMM J1X MOmHO C'IJ1-
TaTbBbIpameID1eMBMM JIMQa,IIpe11P-o.narafl, pa3YMeeTCR,
11 B 3TOM CJJy'rae, 'ITO BOJLFi BbIpa:lKaeTCH COO6pa3HO cyw;ecTB)' IOpM,!J;WIe-
CKOro JIHl¥i? BoJu:J: €CTb IIpJIIIa,!-\.IJem11 CBoti:CTBOOT,IJ;eJ1bHoro 'iMOBe-
Ra, TaK 'iTO KaJtQJ;bD1 'ieJ10BeK J1MeeT CBOIO BOJIKJ. TO'IHO TaK JoKe 11 113 0'1'-
AeJIbHbIX 4>n3Il'J€CKHX JII1Q, cocraBJIJ'iIOll\I1X opraH lOpI ro JIMQa,
KaJtI:,1I;oe J1MeeT CBOlO BOJII{), KOTOpaR MO:lKeT COBIJa)-laTb C BOJIeti JIPYTI1X
.m1l-\ J1JIJ1 He COBna)laTb. IIooTOM)' I13aKOHOJ\aTeJIbCTBy IIp:WXO)J;l1TCH: IIpI1-
IDIMaTb B coo6pamemle BOJIIO OT,lJeJIbHblX 'iJIeHOB opraH3. lOpI\,!I;W£'CKOro
-64-
JD1l\8. JIIIDCTIUIDBIITb, 'lT06b! BOJIei1 KlpJ.Wf'iecKOm.Jrn:L\a C'lJIITa.IIaCb JIIJIJII
e)1l1HornacHa;:! BQJlR ero 'lJIeHOB, JIIJIJII BOJl.I1 fiom,unnICTBa».162
CnmKHyIO npou; ycor.naCOBaID1H BOJIb aKJJ;l-fOHepOB C.H EpaTYCb
CJ1e.z1Y1OIlI;I-1MOOpa30M: «t1>opMaJIbHOJlllrrepeC}"IaCTHI1KOB
TaKOroIOCJJJJJeKTHBa, Bewrnoi1u;eJI11, ,QJUI,D;OCTJoDKeIDffi KO-
TOPO:W OH opram:r30BaH, HBJIReTCH JIIX (Y'ffiCTHHKOB) OOlJJ;illlol JlllfI'epeCOM
PaBHbIM oOpa3oM, onpe,n;e.n!'!eMa!'!3TOi1 u;eJ1b1O BOJ1!'! }"IaCTHJllKOB 'IpaKT)'-
eTC$1 KaK JIIX OOJ.1t<l.fl BQJ1J1. HaxO}1,fll1\8.R CBoe Bbipamem:re B OI1pE',D;€11€HHOIl
,D;eHTe.JJ:bH0CTI11OC1.JI.JIeKTHB0cH0Boi13TOi1,1J.€:HTeJIbHOC
TJ1 .HBJlIIeTCR o6oco6n£tmoe ,D;JUI 3TOi1 u;eJUf JIIM)'11I;eCTBO. B CM311 C 3T11M
KOJlJ1eKTHB BblC'ryTIaer B rpam,n;aHCKJIIX npaBOOTHOlll€fflJlX He KaK npo-
CTaRcyMMa OT.AeJlbHbIX , HOKaKewrnCTBO, KaKOpraHJ1:33.-
ltWI, KaKcy6DeKT npaBJil ooH3aHHOC'I'eR.
B KaIDIT3.IDlC'nl'lecJa1X 1fIX pernalOmee 3Ha'Iem:re JllMeeT
BOJl.I1 KPynHbIX Bopoum Kamrra.na; Olm ,/J;MKT)'IOTCBOlO8O-
.mo, BbJ.!WBaH ee sa RopnopaTl1BH.}'lO BOJllO, TO ecTb HK06b! sa OOIl\YlO 80-
.mo BCex }"IaCTID1KOB OObewrneHJIIH» 163
3ranp.Xi.neMa nO)J;'IJllH€ID1HBOMOTAeJ1bHbIX 8KJJ;1-fOHepOBBOJIe 6oJlb-
IID1HCTBa Bcer]:\a BbI3brna.rra mrrepec y P<l3./]J1qHbIX yqeHbIX JII, ROHe'IHO,
JllMeJla BroKHoe npaKTW-IecKOe 3Ha'IeHYIe
TaR, .HpKMM npJIIMepoM MOmeT CJly.>KJIITb AeJlo a oHepHoro TOBa-
pIDl\eCTBa «II. MaJllOTJllH JII CbIHOBbH», paCCMaTpffi3aBllIeeCH B cy.n;e B
19091'.184 OnYCKaH IIOJ:IP06K>CT1I cy.n;eoHoro pa30"}JaTeJlbCTBa, npJIIBe-
1I3 JIJIIllIb Jll3BeCTHoro B Te ro,n;bla,n;BOKaTa B.A MaKJIa-
ROBa, KUI'OIHi1. paCCMaTpJllBaH .n;e.no SR'-IJilOHepHOro OOmeCTBa, npJII-
3HaJI, 'ITO AJlR pR,D;a KpIW JIJIIlt nOCTaHOBJ1eHJlle Oo.m,nnrncrna
Mo:meT 6bITb ECeClIJIbHblM, O)J;HaRO 31'0 KaCaeTCH, OTMeTJ1J1 OH, TOJlbKQ
lOpJll,ZU-{lleCKJIIX JlJllLtB 06.nacTJ1 ny6,mr1Horo npaBa. AKWKllieptne me 06-
llIeCTBO flBJIReTCH IOplf,lJ;lf'!€Cm1M JlJll'-\OM <mCTHOro npaBa. Ero ycTSB CO-
3,!\aeTCH 1I0roBopOM, OH caM no ceoe IIpe.lICTaB.1me coooi1 He 'ITO l1Hoe,
KaR 1I0roBOp, R01'OpI>rn JlJIIllIb yrBe eTCH B cxpmul8.JlbHbDl: BJ1aCT-
HbIX I1HCTSrmJll$1X. B CBJ13J11 C 3TJ11M, eCJ1J11 B a OHepHOM OOll\eCTBe pe-
WeHJlle 60nbwJIHCTBa OOH3aTeJlbHO ,wIH MeHbWJllHCTBa aKL(I1OHepos. -
TO 3TO npOJIICXO,!!,JIIT He B CJIIJ1Y BeJ1eHJ1.fI BJlaCTJII, He no npJIICytLleMY IpsO
facto6oJn,lIDIHCTsynpeMM)'llleCTBY, S nonpe.I1BaplrreJIbH OTOM CO-
rJlaWeHJIIIO KOH1})an'HTOB I3o.m.wmiCTBO TOJIbKO nOTOMY JII Mo:meT
npeJ1IIlICI;.I.B8Tb MeHbUIl1HCTBY pernaTb 3a Hero, 'lT0 npJII COCTaBJ1eBJIIJII
YCTasa y-qpe.D;I1T€JDI! 06 3TOM 3apaHee corJlaCJ1JIJIICb, JII 'lT0 BCHKIDt, 11.e-
.1laIOIL(IiHcH 'IJ1eHOM OOlL\eCTBa 'Iepe3 nOCpe.D;CTBO YCTasa, B 3TOM 11.0ro-
BOpe }"IaCTBYeT. Ho np le 6o.m,IID1HCTBa caMO no ce6e flBJIH-
eTCH I13'bHTJlleM Jl!3 Ha'laJl11.0rOBOpa, a nOTOMY JI! MOiKeT npl1MetfHTIoCH
-65-
TOJIbKO B TeX lI}X'.lIenax., B KOTOphIX 3'1'0 IIpeA,YCMO'I'pt!HO ,lIOroBOJXIM, TO
eCTb YCTaBOM.
3Ty npo5JIeM)' HeOWIOKpaTHO 3aTpanmaJI B CBOI1X TpY,llaX JII
llR. I'yccalOCJBC'JaOC TaR, OH 06paIQaJI B1BIMaIIIre, 'lT0 B cJI)"-Jae I'OJIOCO-
BaH11S1 aKl\l10HepOB, HaIIpl1Mep, no BOrrpOCY 061f3MeHeHl1JII ycraBa, KOH-
$rnKT Mem,ny l1HTepecaMJ1 a mHepoB HeMJIIHYeMO B03H11KaeT_ J16e-
3YCJIOBHoe BOCI1peLLJ;em:le 1f3MeHeHIfJ'! YCTaBa 6e3 CornaCJ1J'1 Ha TO Bcex
a.KL\l1oHepcJB, J1 eHJITbycTaBno I1OC'IIDJfJBJE'Hl1lO05LLJ;ero
c06paHl1J'1 BCmperm BOJIe O'I'AeJIbHbIX aK oHepoB B 0,l\KHaI0CJBCI1 Mepe
MOryr Hap)'1lli-lTb IfX npaBa If mrrepec1L B O;!UJOM cJI)"-Jae HapywalOTCJ'I
JllHTepecbI 3Ha'iWl'eJIbHoro 'lJ:ICJIa, Hepep;IW 6o.nbnnrnc-ma.
.m:I:WeHHbIX B03M())fQt()CTI1 C.LJ;eJIaTb He06xQlJ;>1MbI€ no IfX MHeHl1lO, npe06-
pa30BaHJUI YCTaBa, ,lIa5b1 npe.n;OTBpaTI1Tb, TaKJIIM 06pa30M, I1O'I'pf26HocTb
.m Tb ,lIeJIa 05meCTBa. B ,n;pyroM :1Ke c.nyqae HapyrnalOTCJ'I
npaBa MeHbWl1HCTBa aK oHepoB, KOTOpble BC.JJeAC'IBJ1e 1f3MeHetII1f1 yc-
TaBa CTaHOBHTCJI, BOIIpeKJ11fX BOJIe, yqac"I'HillalMJ1 TaKOra aKQMOHepHO-
ro o5meCTBa. B KOTOpoe OHl1 HI1Kor,lla He BC'I')'ID1.ID16b!, eC.ID'l6b1 OHl1 l1Me-
JD.I B B TaKOe J13MeHeHl1e YCTasa npl1 caMOfI m,!J;ID1CKe Ha aK I1I1J1J1
npl1l1X nOKynxe.
,ltrrH BbIXO,lla J113 CJIO)f(J1BllIei1cH cHTYaql1Jl! 8BTOp npe,l\JlaraeT CJie.l\Y-
IOmee: TOJIOCOB8Tb He 38 113MeH€HHe YCTasa, a no JlBYM BOllpocaM:
1) 0 lIpeKpaLqeHI1ll,n,a.JlbHel1mero BaHIDI06mecTBa Ha Tex Ha-
'1aJIax, KOTOpble yKa3aHb! B nepsoHa'laJIbHOM ero yCTaBe; 2) 06 00pa30-
BaHl1I1 06mecTBa Ha HOBhIX I1.ID1 BI1$)1f3M('lleHllb1X OCHOBaHJf.flX. B :nOM
c.nyqae. KOHe'IHO. 4>aKTIl'lecKoii .ID1KBI1)\aQl1J1 AeJI 06mecTBa He npo-
113OfiJ\eT, npOCTO aRqIKHep, He meJIalO111;I1A I'OJ1OC1JI3aTb 3a eHeHl1e
YCTasa, BlIpaBe BbIlnu If3 06mecTBa, nOTpe50BaB CBOIO ,lIOJIIO. 165
KaK COBepweHHO BepHO OTMe'-JaJI eLLJ;e MJ1. Ry.nan:IH, «B ROHe'-JHOM
C'-JeTe TOT, KTO pyt«JBO,l\l'IT 06 C06paHl1€M, pyROBOAJ-'lT 06ll\ecTBoM...
POJIb JII MeCTO o5mera co5pamm B CJIICTeMe opraHoB 8KQI10HepHoro 06-
LLJ;eCTBa HaJll60JIee HBCTBeHHO 06HapymJ1BaIOTCfI B KpJIITJII'-JeCKI1X CJIIrya-
QI1J'IX, If npem,Qe Bcero B nepl10.IJ;b1 «611TB 3a KOHTpOJIb+, Kor,lla K8IIJllTa-
.ID1CTbI1f3.l\PYfJ11XKOMIIaHIDII1J1J11I!>JIIHaHCOBHX rpymnlpOBOKnbITaKYrCH
npn06pecTJl KOHTpo.nbHbIA naKeT aKLtI,1i1 ,D;aHllOro a 110HepHoro 06ll\e-
CTBa. ECJIJIIIfM :;ITO YJlaeTCR, TO OHI1 IIOJIHOCTbIO «nepeTpSIXl1BaIOT» CO-
CTaB opraHOB ynpaBJ1eHl1Ji».168
CJIe;nyeT OTMeTI1Th, '-!TO aKQl10Hep - BJ1a.I\eneIt I'OJIOCym-
Il{>1X 8KLtI,1i1 JllMeeT npaBO Y'-J8CTBOsaTb B pa60Te 05mero co6paHIDI, 8 3TO
3Ha'-Jl1T. '1TO K8)t(,D;brH TaKOi1 aKLIJilOHep ClIoc05eH BJ1W1Tb Ha IIpJnnmae-
Mble 06 co6pIDfJlleM peweHl1R B 05'beMe. COOTBeTCTsyromeM era AO-
ne yqacTIDI B YCTaSHOM KaIDITaJIe aRqI1OHepHOro 051l\eCTBa. npJII :nOM
aK OHep MOiKer OKa3brBaTb pewalOll.\e€ B03;J;e:iicTBJlle sa ,Ae:flTeJIb-
-66-
HOCTb 06il-\ec-I'Ba, BJIa)\eH m>me He60JIbIID1M 1I8Ke"lOM aKqffit B TO me
BpeMH aKqwOHep. npmlllMaR }"tacTtfe B pa6crre 06il-\ero c06pamm, MO-
meT 1-'1 He yrrpaBJIHTb clmKTIf'lecKl1.ITpaBoHa }"taCTIleB 06-
llIeM co6pamWI ,JIaJ1eKO He BceI'm> Tl»K,!\eCTBeHHO npaBY aKWIOHepa yn-
paBJ1HTb 06ll1ecTBoM. 31'0 MOmHO npOI1J1JIlOCTpl-'lpOBaTb Ha qaCTO
Ha IIpaRTI-'IKe rrpIDllepe: aKWIOHep, BJI8J\eH naKeTOM
m, He)\OCTaTO'-IHblM ,JIM BJ1W1HWI Ha npUID!'me peweInfJ'l 061J.tJ1M
co6pamleM, BblHYm,IleH nO)\'-lillUITbCH pellieInflO aKqIfCEepoB, BJ1a,i:\elO-
ll.WIX KOH1'pOJIbHbIM naKeTOM aKWrli
Co 1aJ1bHOE' ynpaBJ1eInfe 6a3JrpyeTCH Ha onpe,I\eJ1elJ110n COnQJI;'B1-
HeHHOCTI1 BOJ1b J1lO,I\eiii - :y'W.CTHI1KOB ynpaBJ1elNeCKID!: 0TH0llleHIrn, TaR
RaR me 0'IH0WeHJiH IDIIeKYr C03HaTeJIbHO-EIOJIeBCJe onocpe.tIOBaHI'1e. BJ1a-
CTHO-BOJ1eOOA MOMeHT co ro ynpaBJ1eHWI 03HaqaeT. TITO cy&b-
eKT ynpaBJ1€H11H 4>oPMJ1PYeT 1-'1 peaJ11-'13yeT rOCIIOJ:IC'TBYIIIJYIO BOJIlO, a
ofueRT nO,!:{'rnHJ'leTCH eH. 187
YnpaBJIeHl1e aKQMOHepHbIMM 06il-\ecTBaMJ'! IIpYl05peTaeT Bce 5o.rree
OHaJIbHblAxapaKTep. Bpa3J1I-'1'-1HbIXCTpaHaxnpOCJI€»G1Bae-r-
CJ'I TefUl;€HL\i1H K cymeHl1lO nOJIHOMO'1YlA 06ll.{J1:X co6paHIDi, HeKO'IOpble
I1X 4>YHKu;m'! nepe,D;aI(JI"CH COBt"IBM l\IfP€K'"lUpoB, 'ITO n03BOJIHeT c.n;e-
JIaTb BbIBO)\ 0 CHI1JoKeHI1H 3Ha'1effiUI 06ll.{J1:X co6patndi B CMCTeMe ynpaB-
Jiemrn aKQYlOHepHbIM o6IIlecTBOM.
B coarneTC'IBJIlJI C .n;eACTIJYIOIIJ;IDII3aKOHQlIaTeJIbCTBOM IJHeO'-Ie])€,IJ;HOe
06Il\ee c06paHl1e aKr{l10HepOB npoBO,ll;l1TCH no pellIeHmO COB€Ta rotpeKTO-
pOB (Hafimo,!\1ITeJIbHOI'O COBeTa) 06ll1€CTBa Ha ()CIl(EaH1(J1 ero co6CTBeH-
HO" J1HI.1qMaTI1BbI, Tpe60BaHl1H IOHHOii I\Dl\oII>:ICCIDI (peEl-mopa) 06-
llIeCTBa, aYP.I-1TOpa o61l1ecTBa, a TaKiKe 8RQ1IDHeJXJB (aKQMOHepa),
J'IBJIJIIOll.{J1:XCH I He MeHee '1eM 10 npoQeHTOB l'OJIocyIOI1I;>1X
aKQJ1fi: 061l.\€CTB8 Ha,JIa'rynpe.zn,JIBJIeHi1H TpeOOBaHl1H (CT. 55 3aKOH3 «06
aK.QJ10HepHb!X ).
TaRI1M 06pa30M, .wm TOro, TIT06bI 6bITb npaBOMO'llibIM Tpe60BaTb
C03bIB3 co6paInfJ'l 8KLtI'IOHepy Hec{)xOJJ;J1MO BJIa,IJ;€Tb naKeTOM amum.
IMHeMeHee lou"OT061l1eroKOJ1I-f'IeCTBafOJIOcylOIl\I>1XaK-
LIIDi JiM60 o&be)J;l1H11TbCH C IIO)\OIDn,IMJII eM)' 8KQI10HepaMI-'I,/:\JIH .n;OCTJ1-
meHWI MX (aKWIti) 1<OJ1Jf'1ecTBa.
ITo :;rr0M)' BOrrpocy J1.T. TapacoB OTMe'm..n, '1TQ nOCKOJIbKY «npaBo
C03BaHWI OOll.{J1:X c06paHIDI BXO.n;J1T B COCTaB aKQl10HepHoro npaBa, aK-
LtJ-IOHepHbIM me npaBoM ,I\OJI:>KeH nOJIb30SaTbCJ'I aKQlilOHep,
CJIel\YeT H€I136eJKHo npl-'lWrn K 3aKJIlO'-IeHmO, '11'0 npaso C03BaHWI 06-
ll.WIX co5paHl1t1.AoJImHO np emaTb Kam,IlOMY aKQI10Hepy».160
n ThKEMCKlm: me, HaIIPOTYIB, c<rnTaJI, '-ITO 6bI..nO 6bI HeyiWoHO IIpe,!\O-
CTaBIITb 3TO npaBo Ra*JJ;oM)' aKUVIOHepy B arllE'JIbK.IC:m e I1X
MJDfO<J:JfCJIeHWCTt; C ,I:IpyT'O" CropOHbI, cosepwemro arnHTb y IDIX STO
-67-
npaBO 3Ha'illJIO 6bI JIJ1lillITb 06ll\ecTBO OJ{Hom J13 caMbIX ,l\I:iic'fBI'11'eJIbHbIX
cpelJ;CTB KOH'!'pOJUL IIo::rmMY 3aKOHO TeJThC'TBa J1 ycraBbI npeiWCTaBJIJI-
lO'f OT,l\eJIhHbIM aKqMOHepaMnpaBO -rpe6oBaTh C03BaIDfJI 06ll\emc06paIDfJI
llO,l\ ycnom1eM, 'l!'O OHJ1 oi'i.I1a,!\al()'!' J13BecTHh1M 'n-ICJ10M i. npe,lJ;C'raB-
.runo co6olO J13BE'crnyro 'ffiC1'h 06l1!eC1'BE'lllIom KaII11Ta.mL 169 llpe,lJ;-
CTaBJlfleTCR, 'tfl'O em n031>1QJ1H ffiufurree COOTBeTCTByeT ITeJIlH)C-
TJ1. Ec.rn1 npe,lIOC'I'al'IlTh mc60My aKlU-'IOHepy B03MOiKHOCTh C03bIBa 0611tero
c06paHl1J1, TO ill npaRTI1KE' 3TO MCPKeT npl>1BecTIf K 3Jloynoope6.rreHJ1lO npe-
,WJC1'aaneHHhIM npaBOM co CTOpoHbI He,!\06poCOBE'CTHbIX 8KL!I1UH€pUB
B Te'-JeHJ1e rufl'J1 ,lI,HeJ:i CO,l\HfI npe.z:l;'W!BneHJ1R Tpe60Baffif.fl 0 C03bIBe
BHeOqepe,lJ;Horo 0611tero c06paIDtil 8KQJ10HepoB COBE'TOM ,l\J1peKTOpoB
(Ha6.mo T€JlbHhIM COBeTOM) 0611tecTBa ,l\o.mKHO 6blTh npJ1HJITO pewe-
HJ1e 0 ero (03HBe J1WJO 06 O'1'Ka3e B ero C03bIBe. IIpWleM pewelDre 06 0'1'-
Ka3€ B C03bIBe BHeO'iepeJ{Horo o611tero co6paHIDI 8KQJ10HepOB no Tpe60-
BaHJ1lO BhWlenepe"lJ1CJleHHbIX MOm€T 6b!Th npJ1HJITO TOJ1hKO B
C.rry'-ffiHX,ec.ID'!:
- He C06JlKJ,l\eH )'C"ffiHOBJIeHHbIti 3aKOHOM nOpH,l\OK 1Ipe.l:t'1>HBJl€Hlm
Tpe60BaHJ1:JI 0 e03bIBE' e06paHJ1:JI;
- 8KqJ10Hephl (aKqJ10Hep), Tpe6yIoll\I1e C03hIBa BHeO'iepeJ{Horo 06-
Il\ero e06paHIDI 3JcrUIOHE'poB, He HBJUnOTCJI BJla.z:teJIbu;8MJ1 npe,lIyCMOT-
pellHOro ROJ1W1eCTBa f0J10cyrolltJ1X 3RqHJ:i 06ll\ecTBa.
- HJ1: O)CfH J13 BonpocOB. npe,IVIOmeHHhIX,IVIH BHeceHJ1H B IJOBeC"l'R)'
,ll;HH BHeO'iepeJ{Horo o6lQero e06paHIDI 8KqMOHepOB, He OTHeceH It era
I«IMIIeTE'Ill\IDI H (11J1J1) He COOTBeTCTsyeT Tpe60BaHIDIM npaBOBbIX aRTQB
P<P (n. 6 CT. 55 3aROHa ,,06 aKW10HepHhIX »>-
PerneHJ1e COBeTa ,lII1peKTOpoB (Ha6.moJl1iTeJ1hHoro cOBeTa) 06ll\eCTBa
06 0TRa3e B C03hIBe BHeO'iepe,!\HOro 06w;ero e06paHJ1H 3RqHOHepoB MO-
meT 6bITb 06iRaJ10BaHO B cy,!\ nyreM npe,!\'W!aneHIDI HCRa 0 npJ13Ha1OO1
ero
B cJly'me. ec.ID'! B Te"leID1e nHTIf ,!\HeJ:i C ,l\aTbI npe,q'bHBJleHJ1H Tpe60-
BaHJ1H 0 e03bIBe e06paIDI.fl eOBeTOM ,lI,J1peKTOpoB o61Q€CTBa He 6bLIIO
npJ1HJITO perneHJ1e 0 C03hIBe BHeO'lepe,l\HOro 06w;ero e06paID1J1 8KqHO-
HepOB I1JII1 npJ1HJITO perneHJ1e 06 0TKa3e B era e03hIBe, BHeo'-JepeJ{Hoe
0611tee eo5paHJ1e epoB M<»KeT 6bITb C03BaHO opraHaMJ11-:1 mu.\,a-
MJ1, 1MHerOCo3hIBa.llpJ1:;1TOMOpraHbII-:lJU-Il-I.8.
BHeO'iepeJ{HOe o6lQee e06paHJ1e 8KJ.<I10HepOB, 06Jl8)J,aKYr npe.IJ;yCMOT-
peHHbIMlf 3aKoHoM ,,06 aKiV'lOHepHbIX 06lJ.1€C'I'B8X» IIOJIHOMO'DIJn>OI,
He06xo.n;J:IMbIMJ:I A1IH C03bIBa J1 npoBe,!\€Hlm o6IQero co6paHIDI.
B 3TOM cJly'me paCXO,!J;bl Ha nO,l\l'OTOBKY J1 npoBe,l(€IDle 06IQero eo-
6paHIDI aKlV«)HepoB MorYT 6bITb B03ME'U.\,eHl;l no perneID1lO 06w;ero co-
6paID1H 8K1U1oHepoB 3a NeT cpe,!\CTB 06lQecTsa.
-68-
CJIe.n;yeT OTMeTIITb, 'ITO XOTH 3aKoH «06 8KqJ:1OHepHbIX OOmeCTBaX"
J1 ynoJIHOMO'lI-fl€T 8KQ.J10Hepos Ha caMIJC'I'OH'I'eHbrn C03bm c06pa-
HI1fl, B npaRThlKe 8pOJ1TpamHbIX cy,l\OB BCTpe'ffilQTCH c.rryqaJ1 npe,!\"WIB-
neHI1H aKI.tJ10HepaMJ1 J1CROB 0 nOHYm,lleHJ1J1 K c03bmy oor.qero co5}::aHM&
TaK, 000 «AHRen» 06paTJ1J1OCb B Ap6lnpa1KHb111 cY,l\ r. MOCKBbI C
J1CKOM 0 IJUIym.!leHHIl 3AO «AHKet1:jCMapT-TeXHOJIOrnJ1" K c03bmy
BHeO'l€pe)J;Horo C06paHl1H 8KL1110HepoB 3aKpUTOro aKUJ1OlrepHOrO 06-
l1I.eCTBa J1 paCCMOTpeID11O Ha HeM BOnpoca 0 J1I.1KBI1J\<U-\J111 o5mecrna-
Onpe)J;eneHl1eMOT 26.02.98 cyp,OTKa3aJI B npJ1HflTl1l1)J;aHHoro I1CKa K
paCCMoopeHl1lO, }'1\a3aB, 'lTO B CJ1J1Y CT. 22 AIIK PIP cnopbI
KaTeropl111 He OTHocmCH K I1O,l\BE'.l\OMCHHOCThl 8p6I1Tpa:mHbIX CY)J;OB.
Ane.rr.miQJlOHHaH I1HCTaHqwI nOCTaHOBJIeHI1eM OT 20.04.98 OCTaBJ1J1a
yxa3aHHOe onpe)J;eJIeHJ.-1e oe3 J13MetIeHJI&
O;:I;tiaKO KaCCaql10HHaH J1HCT3HQ11H npl1lilJI3. KJqJyrOM)' Bbmo.n;y JII OT-
MeHl1JIa nepe<llJCJIeHHble cYAe6HbIe 3KTbI.
Y,l\OBJIeTBDpJlfl Tpe6oBaID1H 000 «AHKen», CYA J1CXO,!l;l1JI 113 TOro.
'11'0 npaBO "lpe60BaTb npoBe)J;eHIDI BHeo'-lepe):\Horo c06paHI1.R 3KQ110He-
pOB 06mecTSa C onpe)J;eneHHOH mB€CTKOH npe)J;ocT3BJIeHO JIICT , HB-
nmDll\eMYCfI BJIaJIeJIbQeM 41l'"" 8K4I1H, n. 1, 2 CT. 55 rbe.r\epaJIbHOro 3a-
KOHa «06 3KQ110HepHbIX :.. Cy/1, B peWeHl1I1 OTMeTKn. '11'0
JIICmOM a6.m0JJ,eHa ycTaHOIJJIeHHaH n. 2. 3 CT. 55 Ha3B<illHOro 3aKOHa
4>oPMa npe,!\"bffiJJIeHIDl"lp€6oBaIDm 0 npoBeAeHID:! BHe<NepeJJ:H0I1J 06-
lI\ero c06paHI1.R 8KQJ;tQlIepoB (TpeOOBaHJlie H8IIpBBJlKJlOCb /1,Bam,llbl
e,lII'lHC'I'BeIIHOMY IIOC"lUHIIHO .n.eiiCIBYJOlI\eMY opraHY ynpaBJIeID:!JI OT-
BeT'-II1Ka - reH.!\l1peRTopy. TaK RaK COSeT /1,MpeK1'Opos B aTOM o6ll-\ecTBe
He C03,!\aBaJICfI). OrBe-r Ha MHHoe 'I}X'6oBaHHe paCQeHeH CY11.0M B Ka'le-
erne OTKaaa OT npOSe,l\eHl1fl co6paID:!H, npOI13Be,l\eHHOro C HapyrneIrneM
"lpeOOBaHJoIf-i n. 4 CT. 55 ynOMHlJ)'TOCO 3aKoHa TalOKe OTMe'-JeHO, '11'0 He-
}'1\aaaHl1e B YCTaBe onpe,l\eJIemmro JUlqa 1fJ1J1 opraHa oOlL\ecTSa. K01'O-
POM)' nepeMHbI 4JyHKQID1COBeTa,WIJJeK"lUpoB (B TOM 'II1CJIe no c03bmy
Co6paHW! aKLtJ10HepOB J1}"l'I1e1»1\.!emnD nOBeCTKJ-I .D.HH), He M<»KeT CJ1Y-
:HaITb OCHOBaHl1eM,l\M J1l1llIeHl1fl 8KQ110Hepa npeJIYCMOTpeHHbIX 3aKO-
HOM npaB Ha CPOpMi'1pOB<lHl1€ nOBeCTKi1 BHeO'lepe):\Horo coopaHW!.
He J1CI1O.11b3OBaHl'Je J1CTQOM (aKLtJ10HepoM) npe.n;ycMoTpeHHoro n 8
CT. 55 BblllIeHa3SaHHoro 3aKOHa npasa ill caMOC'I'OS1Te C03bIB JII
npoBe)J;eHl1e BHeO'lepe,!\Horo co6paHl1J1 3Kqi10HepOS, no MHeHI1tD CYM.
He Jll.-lwaeT aKQJ-(OHepa npaBa Ha cy,!\e6H)'1O 3alLtl-'1T)' CHOW!: mrrepeco1L
BnOCJ1e.n;<:TBI'Dl /1,eJ10 6blJI0 HanpaSJIeHO H8 HOBOe paCCMOTpeHl1e JII
no HeMY 6bLJ10 npl1HJlTO JqJyroe pewemle, O,l\HaKO BbIWeyKa3aHHblH
BblBO.rt KaCCaql10HHot:'i J1HCT8HQJ1J1 0 npase aKQHOHepos npe,!\"bJ'lSJ1RTb
JIICK 0 nOHYJi\,l\eHI1I1 K npoBe,n;eHl1tO oOll\ero COOpaHI1.R COMHeHl1tO He
no,!tsepraJ1CJ'I. 170
-69-
IIpaBo Ha yqaCTI1e B no,rouniBKe OOlL\ero c06paHHR BKJIIO'-IaeT B ce-
OR BHeCelille npe B I1OB€C'I'K}' ,D;HJ1 C06palillfllf KaHJ1l1J1aTOB
npJl! BbI60pax COBeTa AJl!PeKTOpoB, 1I'OJLJI{'IWl.JHbI]:11f e,n;KInIDf'IIlliIJ1:IfC-
nOJ1Hl1T€J1bIJl>Iti opraHbI, peBJI3IfOHH}'K) KOMHCCJOO (peBJl3Opbl) J1 C'-JeT-
HYIO KOMI-fCCWIO (CT. 53 3aKOHa «06 aKltIlOHepHbIX 06lL\eCTBax») ",l:\eA-
CTBHR Henocpe,ll('T13eHHO no C03bIB)' 061L\ero c06paHHR B TOM CJIy'-Jae.
eCJ1" COBeT ,l:\HpeKTOpOB He B3&J1 Ila Ce6fl3TI14>YHKQI1J1 B CJ1)"-Jae eroOT-
K<13a OTC03bma 06r.qero C06paHHR (CT. 541'1 n. 8 CT. 55 3aKOHa «06aKL\H-
oHepHb!X OOIl\ecTB8.x»).
npaBOM Ha BH,IJ;BJDKeHHe KaHJ\l1J1aTJP B :yKa3aHHble opraHbl H BHe-
ceH11e BorrpoCOB B nOBeCTKY ,AlIfl oOIl\ero C06paHHR 06.na,!W.1OT aKqIt:!OHep
..JDort5o aKQl10Hepbl, HBJ1flK)lL\HeCfi BJ1a,/:\eJlbllaMYI He MeHee 2% rOJlOCOB OT
06r.qero KOJIIrIecTBa r0J10cYlOlL\HX aKL\Hti: 06Il\eCTBa. B cJ1)"-Jae, eCJ1Y1
npe,!:\JIaraeMaH nOBeCTKa,D;HJ1 BHeO'-l€pe,a;Horo 06r.qero co6paHWI aK4JI!O-
HepOB co,!\ep)fOIT sonpoc 061f30paHYIYI 'LJIeHOB COBeTa .r\JI!peKTOpOB (Ha-
OJlIO,l\aTeJIbHoro cOBera) 06lL\ecTBa. aKqlI<JHepH (aK4Jl!OHep) 06lL\ecTBa.
HBJIHlOlL\HeCH B COBOKyIIHOCTII Bn8,l:(eJIbQaMR He MeHee 'IeM 2£'(, l'OJIocy-
IOlL\II!X aKL\Hti: 06lL\ecTBa, snpaBe npe,lViOiKl-ITb KaHJ(J1,l:\aTOB,!\J1R 1f30pa-
HJ1H B COBeT J\l1peKTopoB (Ha6.rrlO,l\aTeJlbHb1i1 COBeT) 06r.qeCTBa, 'illCJ10
KOropbIX He MOiKeT npeBbrnraTb IID.1IWI€CTI!eHHbrn cocraB COBera J\YI-
peRTOpoB (Hafimo,l\aTeJIbHoro COBeTa) 06r.qecTBa (CT. 53 3aKOHa ,,00 aK-
UI10HepHb!X 06r.qecTBax»).
Bonpoc, aKL{V:!OHepaMI-f (aK4Jl!OHepoM). nO,!\JIeiKIIIT
BRJlKNeHIDQB nc:mecI1<Y ,AlIH 06r.qero C06paHHR am.p:1OHepoB. paBHO KaK
Bb1)J;BJl!H)'TbleKa aTblnO,!\JI TBKJIIO'-leHWIOB cmICOKKaH,D;I1,W!TJP
,!\J1R ro.nocosammno Bb100paM B COOTBeTCTBYIO opraH 06r.qecTBa, 3a
I'1CE.IIIO'leIIleM CJIy'-Jaes, eCJlYI:
-aK1V1oHepaMH (aKJV«)Hepct.'I) He 30-,AlIeBHble CpOKJ1,
ycraHoBJIellllbie CT. 53 3aKOHa ,,00 epm.IX 06r.qeCTBax» ,!\JU1
BHeCeHlLH npeJlJlo:IKeHl1i1;
- aKlVlOI1epbl (aK4Jl!OHep) He .HBJI.A:IOTCH BJ1a,lJ;e.JU;QaMH I1pl'.rIyCMOT-
peI1Horo KOJIl1'JeCTBa rOJ1ocy1OIQMX 8K4JI!i1 06Il\eCTBa;
- npe,D,JIOiKeHJ1e He COOTBeTCTByer 'I'pe60BaHJ1HM, npeAyCMOTpeH-
HbIM n. 31'14 CT. 53 3aKOHa ,,00 aRlU'IOHepHbIX oor.qeCTBax»;
- Bonpoc, npe,!\J10meHHbIi1 ,!\J1R BHeCeID1H B nOBeCTKY AM 06r.qero
COOpaHWI aKL{V:!OHepOB 06lL\ecTBa. He aTH€CeH K ero KOMn 1 JII
("JI") He COOTBeTCTB}'eT rpe60BaHl1HM npaBOBbIX aKTOB POCCHfICKoA
4>eJ\epaLJ;ID1
PeweH"e COBeTa J\l1peKTOpoB (1la6.rrIO,l\aTeJlbHoro cOBeTa) 06lL\ecTBa
06 OTKa3e BO BKJllO'IeID11f sonpoca B nOBecTKY ,AlIR 06Il\€ro c06palillR
aKL{V:!OHepoBIfJlYlKa ara BCIDICOKKaH.WIAaTJPJ\JUlrOJlOCOBaHJ1.ll no
BbI60paM s coorseTCrsyKJ1Wrii opraH 06Il.\€CTB8, a TaIOKe yRJIOHelU1e
-70-
COBeTa AHpeKTOpOB (Ha6JIKJ TeJIbHoro COBeTa) 06r.qecTBa OT npMHRTIUI
pernemm MOryT 6bITb 06manOBaHbl B CY11.. OrneTQI1l\OM no TaKOM)' IfC-
RY TaK'lKe 6YAeT HBJIRThCJI 06r.qecTBo.
EcJ1lll aKqJ10Hep 6epeT Ha Ce6R nO,!!,I'OTOBK)' C03bIBa 06r.qero cOOpaID1R
B c..rryqae OTKa3a OT 3TOro COBE'Ta AHPeKTOpOB, OH Ha,I\eMeTCil nQJ1HOMO-
'lJ1.HMJ1 caMoro COBE'Ta 11.MpeKTOpC)B - opraHa ynpaBJIeHIDI 06r.qeCTBa.
IIpH3TOM OH MOmE'Tnpo11.0nmaTb BaTb H KaRaK1V10Hep, oC)'UIe-
CTBJl.I1J1 CBOM npaBa, Hanpl1Mep. BHI2CeHIfeM n HIDi B nOBeCTKY
1J,HH. B 31'0Ilol c..rryqae CKJIa):J;bIBaeTCR .mo60rIbITHaR CWI)'3.W1J1 - aKQJ10Hep
BpeMeHlJO lJ8.,11.eJllleTCR npaBaMH opraHa ynpaBJ1eHJ1fI 06r.qeCTBa.
RaR nOKa3bIBaeT npaK"f1>1Ra, <mIl\e Bcem HapyIIIalOTCR npaBa aKllMO-
HepOS MMeHHO H3. 3Tane C03bIBa If opra:mI3a.WDI C06paHIDl. JIbBV1H)T1D 11.0-
mo J'lCKOB aKLUfOHepclB R COCTaBJ1JiJOT tfMeHHO J'lCKJ1 0 npM-
3HamU1 He.n;ei1cTBJrreJIbHbIr.m peIlIE'HIflI 06Lq11X co6paHID! BKqMOHepOB,
npWleM HMeHHO no npWillHaM HeCoU.mo.n;eHJIH 06r.qeCTBaMYI npaBl1JI no
nO,!I,I'OTOBKe 11 opraHM3aI 06Lq11X CoopaHID!: aKI{I10HepbI He 1f3BeLqa-
IOTCH 11.OJDKHbIM 00pa30M 0 C03bIBe cOOpaHID'!. HM He npe.n;OCTasmnDTCH
6IOJ!JleTeID111.J1H roJJOCOBaHIU!: '" TOM)' nO.11.06Hoe.
TaR. O,,!\HHM 1f3 orpoMHoro K1JJDI'leC'TBa paCCMaTpMBaeMbIX B CBH3M C
HapyrneID1HMH 11.eJI HBJIHeTCH cnop Me)K,!J,y KOMIIaHJ1ei1
«pOJlJI TpaHc MeHeJ:\mMeHT (II:HmKeCTBO JII1XTeHllITeMH) If
OAO «BK «COI03TpaH3IfT". nocryrnlBllIlfit: Ha paccMOTpeHJ1e Ap6:WT-
paiKHOro cy1J.B r. MOCKBbI JII 11.011Ie,IJ;IlIJ1i1 BIlOCJIe)J;CTBnH 11.0 4>e.11.epaJIbHO-
ro ap6M1pamHoro CY11.a :MocKcmcIooro OKpyra. B CBoeM nOCTaHOBJIeHl1M
no 3T0M)' 11.e;rry 4>e.11.epaJIbHbD1 ap6M1pa)KHbIi1: CY11. MoclroBcKcru oKpyra
yxaaan, '11'0 BHeO'lepe.IJ;HOe 06Il\e€ c06paHtfe 1OHepoB 6blJIO npoBe-
,IJ;eHoc cyr.qeCTBeHHbIMHapymeHMeM 3aKOHa, a JlIMeHHO: CT.CT. 51-55, 57
tPe11.epaJIbHOro 3aKOHa «06 aKIV'IOHepHbIX 06Il\ecTBax». HapymeHJ1e
BbIpa:3KJIOCb B TOM, 'ITO JlICTeq, S1BnHlOLqMi1cfl 29% aKIV'IA
. He 6bLJI 1f3BeIl\eH 0 npoBe.l\eHIDI 06r.qero coopamm aKI!l1OHe-
pos, TaKJ1M 06pa30M, OH 6b!JIJ1I-1llIeH npaBa Ha YQaCTl1e B OOIl\eM coopa-
HJ1J1 aKQJ10HepoB, a TaIORE' yqBCTI1R B ynpaBJIemm 06Il\€CTBOM nyreM
M aTYP s ffiBHfi coseT 11.HpeKTDpos. Ha 0CH0BaHIDI
3TOro Ob!JIO I1pH3HaHO H bIM perneHJ1e COBeTa AHpeK1'O-
pos, COCTaB KOTOpOro If 6b!JI JlI30paH Ha OOIl\eM co6paID1H, IIpOBeJteHHOM
C H3.pyrneID1HMI1 3BROHa. 171
qTO KaCaeTCH npaBa BRqJ10Hepa Ha yqacme B oor.qeM c06paID111, TO
3)\€Cb Heo6xo.rtm.ro OTMeTMTb. '11'0 OHO TeCHeillirnM 00pa30M CBJI3BHO C
npaBOM lOHepa Ha JlIHt!JopMaW-lKJ. TaR, aKqJ10Hep 11.0JImeH 6bfI'b
yse.l\OMJIeH o6Il\eCTBOM 0 IIpIJBe.11.eHIm: oOIl\ero co6paHJfH, B TalOKe npo-
JlIHq:.opMi'1poBBH o6Il\eCTBOM 0 era pe3YJIbTaTax.
-71-
()qeHb '1aCTO 8Kl111!OHepbI, OCo6eHHOMeJIKJ1e. CKJIOHHbI npeHff>pefaTb
npeAOCTaBJIeHHbIM l1I'o'! npaBOM npl1lU1Tb y<mcTI1e B oOl1\eM cOOpamuL C
RpyIIHhIMI1 Aep:m.aTeJIJIMJ1 8RqI1ti T1lli'.I1X npo6JIeM He B03Hl1KaeT. no-
CKOJ1bKY y HJ1X eCTb MOTl1Bb1 HanpRM)'IO aKTI1BHO 3aHi1MaTbCR AeJ1aMi1
of5mecTBa. cocpeJP'IO'Dl'Tb B CBOMX p)'KaXBJ1aCTHble YHK . Heyqac-
Ti1e PflAOBbIX aKqI10HepOB B c06pmu1IIX 06YCJloBJIeHO p1IAOM 4>aKTOPOB.
TaK, no MHem.oo ro Klpi1CTa JK IIarnocco. a6ceHTen3M
aK.L\I10HepoBl1I'o'!eeT I1pI1'lI1Hb1. KMaTepl1&JIbHbIMnpM'IlIHaM
OHOTHOCIITHey Ci1CTeM)'onOBel1\eHI1RaKqI10HepOB
o npoBe.l\eJOO1 co6paHKfi, reorpaqm'1ecKyro OTAaJleHHOCTb MeCTa npoBe-
AeHl1J1 co6paHHi'i OT MeCTa mm'eJIbCTBa 1:pJB, 0'fCYI'CTBHe Bpe-
MeHI1 H cpeACTB y Y'l8CTHHKa AJl.H noe 11 H8 TaKoe 3aCe,!\aHl1e. IICI1Xo-
JronI'I€CKi1MH npH'Ii1HaMI1 naCCJIBHOCTH aKQI10HepOB JK lI3J1lOCCO
C'1I1TaeT J1X 'fj'BCTBa «l1OKOptroCTIl". «H8IO.JIHOqeHHOC"l'l1». « IJP.
KOTOpble, B CBOKI O'1epeAb, no J1X TeXHWI€C'IOCJit HJlI14>lIHaHco-
soti HeKOMTIeTeHTHOCTbKl. cJ1a6bIM I1HaHCOBbIM yqacTl1eM B OCHOBHOM
K8IDITaJIe 06I1\eCTBa. lIo 3TOM)' BOnpocy MJ1. KYJI8rnH OTMe'laeT, '1TO
a6ceHTeI13M pJ'I,D;OBbIX aKl<J1OHepoB HeJ136emeH, nOCKOJIbKy Bb1TeK8€T J13
caMoti cyrn;HOCTJ1 aKqI10HepHOro o6mecma KaK ofYbeAHHeHl1JI Karn-rra-
JIOB, a He JII1Q. 172
B CBJI311 C 3T11M '1acTO npJ1XOAl1TCR CTaJIRl1BaTbCH Ha IIpaEl'HKe C CI1-
ryaql1eti, KOf,lJ;a OOl1\ee coopaHl1e aKll110HepOB npl13HaeTCR HeCOCTOJIB-
IIll1MCH J13-;33. OTCyTCTBI1.fI KBOpyMa.
Jl.A MaRapOB BHec pe npe,w1UIKeIllle. KOTOpOe MOfJIO
Obi crroco6c-moBaTb npeo.m:tJIEHIno npo6J1eMbI Hey'UiCTI1H8Kl111!OHepoB B
06Lq11X COopam1JIx: BHeCTI1 B3aKOH «06a.RQI'DHepHbIX " no-
.JK»KeIDIe. pa3pernaKll1\ee npoBe.!\eHl1e 06Lq11X co6paHl1ti 8KQI10HepOB
nyreMBU,I:\ pemtI--Iti (npH HaJ1JI'IJIJ1 COOTBeTCTB}'1Ol1\etiTeXHI1'1e-
CKOti B03MCOKHOC.'TU). Mexam13M npOBeAemm 06l1\ero co6pamm 8KqI10-
HepOB B YK83alIHoti 4>opMe A0IDI«'H onpe.!\eJ1HTbCR YCTaBOM J1 BHyrpeH-
IDIMH WKyMeHTaMI-f aK1V10RepHOI'O OOl1\eCTBa.
KpoMe TOro, OR c<n1TaeT. '1TO B 3aKOH «00 al\.LlMOHeplibIX 06l1\ecT-
BaX» H€CfuroAHMU BKJIKI'1lITb TalOKe HopMY, COfJIaCHO KOTopoi1 aKqI10-
Repllble o6utecma. 3apemcTpl-fpOBaHHbIe Ha Teppmopm--l POCCHfICROti
p3l-tIm:, MOf)'T npoBOAl1Tb OOl1\l1e co6pamm TOJIbKO B npe.!\eJIaX
TeppJ1'l'OP'D'l POCCJm. J13 3TOro npaBJ1na MOryr 6bITb c.!\eJIaHbI J1CK.mO-
'1eHUR, eCJ11-f al\.LlMOHepbl, BJ1a.z:\€lOl1\I1e B COBORynHocrn 6oJ1ee '1eM 75'}\
I'OJIOcyKJIII;I1X al\.LlMi1: 06l1\ecTBa, JIBJIHKlTCH rpaJoKAaHaMl1 11H0CTpaHHOro
rocy.!\apCTsa. nOCTOHHHO HJlI1 HHO npmtGIB8IOT :I1J!J1
J1MeIOT MeCTO pemcrpaQWI SHe npe)\eJ10B TepplITOpID-I Pocam. 173
He<:oMHeHHO. 3T11 nOJiOJoKeHI1.fI cnoc:06c:TBosaml 6bI y.rryqweHl1IO CJ1-
TyaW1l1 C nOCelL\8eMOCTbIO ooepaMl1 OOIII;l1X COOpaHl1ti J1 ObIJI!'! 6bI
-72-
BeCbMa IIDJIe3HH J\JlR YCOSepIIIeHCTBOBaHlfiI 3aKOHa «05 8KqI10HepHbIX
<fu1ocrna
B C II. 1 cr. 58 3aKOHa «05 ID\':qI'IDHepHbIX06r.u;eCTBax»
061ltee c06paHi-fe aRQIlOHepOB npaBOMO'IHO ( MeeT KBOPYM), eCJm B HeM
npl1lUlJIH Y'l8CTJ-fe 8KltJ-'10Hepb1, e B CfJI3OKYI1HCiCT 60J1ee
'IeM IJOJJ(}BJIHoU: roJIOCOB p8SMer.u;eHHbIX I'OJ10CYIOLIJ;I'IX 8KI .d1 o6r.u;ecrna.
IIp IUIBlIDfM Y'l8crne B 06llteM c06paH J-f 8KlV-'10HepOB C'1J-fT8lOTCf! 8K-
QMOHepbI, sapemCTpI-'IpoBaBllrnecf!]1,JUl Y'l8cnm B HeM, JI 8KltJ-'10Hepbl,
610JlJIeTeHJI KOTOpblX nOJly'IeHbl He n03]:\He€ ABYX ,/:\Hef1 ,/:\0 J\aTbI npoBe-
,/:\eHJ1J::r 061lt€ro C06paHI1f! HepOB- IIpJ1HHBlillfMH Y'laCTl1e B 06llteM
co6pamrn: 8KqI10HepOB, npoBO,/J;I-fMOM B ij)opMe 3aO'llioro I'OJIOOOBaHJm,
C<JwralOTCH aKWtOH€pbl, 61OJIJIereHl-f KOTOpblX nOJlyqeHblJ\O ,lJ;3.TbI OKOH-
'IaHJtll lIpJIeMa 6IOJlI1eTel1ef1.
,naHHaH HOpMa HBJlH€TCH JlMlIepaTI1BHOf1 JI He MOJoKeT6bITb mM€H€-
Ha sycrase.CJleJ\OSaT€JlbHO, T})€6osaHV!eycrasao Ha-
Jllf'IJ1:H ]1,JUl KBDp)'M8 KBamuPD..{I1poB8HHOffi 60JIblIDlHCTsa JlJIDO npl-f-
c:ycc'l'EIm Bcex aKqI10HepOB HBJlR€TCH H€8aROHHHM.
J13 CMblCJIa yKa3aHHOf1 HOpMbJ CJ1e]:lyeT, 'iTO J\JUI nO,lJ;c<ieT8 KsopyMa
BaJoK€H l1MeHHO MOMeHT pe noCJIe Hero aKQ>1OHePb!MOlyr IIO
CEoeMY YCMarpeHmD npV!cyrcrnOBaTb ,lJ;3.JIee Ha co6pamm JlJIDO IIOKI1-
H)'Tb ero. Ec.ill1 Ha MOMeHT peI'l1CTpaI:(lm: npl1cyrCTBOB8JlO ,/:\OCTaTQ'llioe
KO.IIJ-f'1eCTBO 8KW1oHepoB WUI TOro, 'iTD6bl o61ltee c06pcume 6blJlO npl-f-
SHaHO npaBOMO'IHblM, TO era y}Ke HeJlb3H 6yJ\€T IIpl13HaTb HeCOCTOHB-
lill1MCH Jl3-3a TOro, 'lT0 BII()CJJe,QCTBIaKQ>IOHepbI He npillUlJIl1}"ffiCTl1e
BcaMoMronoa::JB.aHHJf.. O]:\H8KOB :3TOMCJI.Y'lae pewetme IIO BOlIPOCY, IIO-
craBJ1emroMY Ha roJ1OCosaHl1e, MOm€T 6bITb He npllliJITO Ji3-3a HeJ\O-
craTO'1HOCTI1 roJIOCOB 8KW10HepOB
TaK, IIocTaHoBJleHl-feM II Bblcwero ApfurrpamHOlO Cy-
11;1 p.p 6b1Jl npJ13HaH npaBOMepHblM OTKa3 MocRosawi-f 06JlacTHoA
pen oii :naJIaTbI B perl1C"rpa4ID1 ycrasa A03T «FeyTOBCKBR
Tmu,\KaJ'! (f:Ia6pl-'lKa" B CBJ'!311 C l1apyweHi-feM 'Ip€6oBaHJm II. 4 CT. 49 3a-
KOHa ...a5 aKQI'lOHepHbIX 06l1\€'C'l133X", B COOTBeTCTBIDI C KOTOpb!M pe-
lllelUle 06 yrsep:)K,D;€Hm-I lO3Oi1 pe,!J;aKQJiJI ycTaBa o6r.u;ecrna ,/:\OmKHO
npJ-fID-IMaTbcJ'! 6o.m.wJ.nrrsoM B TPJ-f 'IeTB€pni r0J10COB 8KqI10HepOB -
BJ1a,1J;eJlbQeB I'OJ1ocy xaKW1iii, IIpV!IDIMa xyqacrneB 06ll\eM co-
6paIDIV! aKqI10Hepos. IIpe3 1-f)'M Bblcwero A Cy,/:\a p.p
npV!3H8Jl He coorneTCTS}'1OIlteA 3aKOH)' CCb1J1KY JI Ha TO, 'lTO aKW1-
OHep o6r.u;ecrna TOO ..TeKCTIlJlb}) (BJ1a,1J;eJleQ 35 aKIU-lf1) 3apenIC'IT)Ji\-
posaBlllJICb ,lI,JIf! Y'lac'IW'I B c06pamm, 3aTeM IIOKV!H}'J1 ero JI B CEH3V! C
:3TJoIMnpV! KBOPYMaHaco6pamrnJ1'iJ-fcnar0J10COB, nO,lJ;aH-
HbIX 3a IIpJlHRTlte ycrasa B HOBOiii IH, c.nep;yeT J1CXO)J;IITb Jl3 KO-
JlWIecTsa rOJIOCOB, KOropoe np 1T ,QpyrOMY nfMCYI'CTBOB8B-
-73-
IlIeMY' aKIU10Hepy - AO «Jlro6epeQKl1e KOBpb!» (65% aKIU1i1). IIpe311,l\11-
YM BblcIlIero Ap611TpamHoroCYM p.p }'K8.3aJ1, 'ITO '1I1CJ10 Y"acTHI1KOB
06w;ero c06paIDIJI aK oHepoB onpe,IJ;eJlfleTCII Ha MOMelIT 38.BeplIleHl1H
pe I1X 1J.0 Ha'laJ1a co6paHJ1H, a He Ha MOMelIT I'OJ1OCOBaHJ1H. 174
MHorue Y"eHble BhlCKa3blBalOT TO'lKY 3peHJ1H, 'lTO AM nOBTOpHOro
co6paHllil aKQI10HepOB He HymHO YCTaHaBJllmaTb KBDp)'M, pa3Be '1TO
AM co6pamlH, C03BaHHOro,D,JIH p€IlIeHJ1H caMblX BamHbIX 1J.JlfI 06J.l1€(.'T-
Ba BOnpOCOB. J1 :;ITO paaYMHO, Be1J,b eCJThI aKIv:IOHepH no KaKJ.-IM-J1tWO
npWlI1HaM He :HCeJ1alOT Y'laCTBOB3.Tb B ynpaBJ1eHl1I1, TO 06w;ecTBo He MO-
:meT 6ecKoHe<mo C03b1BaTb IIOB'IOpHble COOpaHI1H B3aMeH HeCOCTOHB-
IlII1XCH. BeJtb y<m.CTl1e B pa60Te 06w;ero co6paHJ1H .J1BJIHeTCH npaBOM, a
He 06H3aHHocTbKJ 8KQ110Hepa. .lI;.n.H 06w;ecTBa BamHO J111lIlb CofurKJCTI1
nOpRlJ,OK yne.l\OMJ1€HJ1f! aKIv:roHepOB 0 C03bIBe C06paHl1H J1 BO MHOri1X
1OpIC'J\I1KW1HX ,IJ.JIJI nOBTDpHoro co6paIDIH, npci!O,IJ;I'1lIo1cr'( B CJIy'Iae He-
npaBOMO'lHOCTI1 nepsoro, 'I'pe60BaHl1e HaJDI'DIH KBop)'Ma OTCyTC'tByeT.
&v:Ia'la. oow;ero COopa.HI1H aKqMOHepOB mpaHW-rnBaeTCH 4>oPMl1pO-
B3.HI1eM BOJThl 06W;eCTB3. no BonpocaM, OTHeCeHHbIM K ero KOMIIeTetfIUIH.
IIepe<ieHb TaKl1X BOnpocoB yKa3aH HC'IepIIblBaIOlWlM 06pa30M B n. I
CT_ 48 3aKOHa «06 aKqMOHepHbIX oow;eCTBax». IIpWieM oow;ee c06paHl1e
He BIIpaBe paCCMaTplJBaTb 11 npl1IDiMaTb peweHl1.H no BDnpocaM, He OT-
HeCeHHbIMKeroI«JMIIeTeHQl'Dl3aKOHOM «06 oHepHbIX06w;ecTBax».
JJ;orryCKaeTCH nepe,!\a"ia BOnpocOB, IJXO,WIlIij:IX B RDMTIe'I'eHQ>lliJ 06w;€I'O
COOpaHl1H aKW1OH€poB. COBeTy AJ1PeKTopDB, HO TOJlbKO B TOM cJIY"ae.
eCJII13TO npHMO IIpE'JtVCMO'IP€HO B 3aKoHe «06 OOW;ecT-
BaX». Hanpl1Mep, CKJ,!\a OTHOCMTCH )lB€JIWleHRe YCTaBHoroKam-rraJ1a 06-
llIeCTBa nyreM pa.3M€l1I€H1'IH]:1On)J1IDITe11 aKI--tJ1i4, 06paaoBaHl1e IfC-
IDJIHJITeJIbH)1'O opraHa If ,l\ocpO'lHoe npeKp era n'i.
KcTaTJ1, IO.A MeTeJ1eBa cqJ1TaeT, '1TO oonpoc 06 :yBeJDf'-JeInfIf YCTaBHO-
ro KaIrnTaJIa He ,l\OJ1:meH aJ1bTepHaTJ1BHO nepe,!\aBaTbCHHa pewem1eco-
BeTa }J;I1peKTOpoB JII peIIIaTbCH TOJIbKO CaMI-IMH aRqJ10HepaMl>1, nOCKOJIb-
KY OH 3a'I'panmaeT Ba:HCHeiitmni J1HTepec aKlVIDHepOB - nO,!l,!\epmaHJ1e
paaMepa IfX lIOJ1en B YCTaBHOM KaIIHTaJ1e a.KqIroHepHOl'O 06w;ecTBa. 175
IIpJ1H.F1T11e OOJl.ll1M co6paHI1€M peWeHJIIH no BOOpoCy. KaropbD1 He
OTHOCJ1TCH K ero KOMileTeHLtJ>U1, paCCMaTpl1BaeTCH CY,llaMl>1 B Ka'leCTBe
C HHOI'O Hapywemm 3aKOHo,!\aTeJlbCTBa.
Pew€lH-Ie OOlL\ero co6paHJlH aRU;J10HepOB MO:1KeT 6bITb npl1lLlITo 6e3
npOBe1J.eHJ1H co6paHJ1H (COBMeCT1IDro nPJ'lCYI'C'!Ulf! aKQI10HepOB AM
OOcyJi\,l\eHJIIH BonpocOB OOBeCTIaIJ\H.FI J1 npl1HJITI1H p€weHIDi no BOnpO-
caM, nOCTaBJ1eHHblM Ha I'OJ1OCOBaHl1e) nyreM npDBeJ\em'IJ'!: 3aQ'IHOro ro-
J10COBaHllil (n. I CT. 50 3aKOHa «06 8KqMOHepHbIX 06w;ecTBax»).
lIo CMblC.ny CT. 32 3aKOHa «06 aKQJl!OHepHbIX .' 8KQJIIOH€-
phi, BJIa,!!,eKJlL\Me npJIIBI1J1€n1pOB8HHb!Ml1 aKQJIHMH, TalOKe BIIpaBe IIpl1-
cyTCTBOBaTb Ha 06!J.!eM co6pamu:! EO BCeX CJI)"IaHX, O.1I;tiaKO npaBOM 1'0-
J10Ca om-l 06J:Ia)1alOT TOJIbKO B CJJ yt<:a3aHHbIX 3TI-IM me 3aKOHOM.
IIpaBO Ha Y'lacTI-le B 06r.u;eM c06paHlofi-l 8KQI-IOHepOB OcyIl\eCTBJUleT-
CJ'I 81\lU1CIIepOM KaKJ1M'1HO, TaK l--I'iepe3 cBoero I1pl'.ZJ;CTaBKT€JIf! B CJ1Y-
'iae, eCJ1l-1aKQWlHaXOAI-ITCflBrfuQeJ1J\oJ1eBotf HecKOJ1b-
Kl-lXJ1I-IlI, TOnpaBOMO'IIDInoro.JIOCOBaH]:UOMOryTO .ID16o
O,!I,HJ-IM J-I3 Y'laCTtJI-IKOB ,lJ;OJ1€Botf C06crBeHHOCTJI, .m.roo J-IX 06llt1-1M
M,l\OTOpbItfMomeT6bITbl\aK8KQ1-10HepOM, TaKI-I-rpeTb-
!-!M J1I-1QOM.lIu.mroMo'lHH Ka:)KJJ;oro 1-13 3Tl-!X J1I-1Qp,OJVKHb! 6bITb H8J\Jle)f(3.-
lltI-IM 06pa30M Oc¥JpMJ1eHbL
M c¥JPMaJlbHO 6yJ\eT flBJ1$lTbCfl1-l aKQI-IOHep, npl-l06-
pe1UD1i1 8KQrnO nOCJ1e ,D,aTbI COCTaB.1leHJoLI CIII-ICKa J1 1MftOlL\I'1X I1paBO
Ha y<18CTJ1e B 06!J.!eM aJ6pamm, J-I,IJ;O J\aThI npOBe,!\eHWI 061L\ero c06paHWI
B CJIy'18e em .JIWIHOro Y'laCTWI B co6paHID-l. .llin.1:o, BKJllOqeHHoe B 3TOT
COI-lCOK (6uBunnl 8KQI-IOHep), 06R3aHO Bb1,Q8Tb npl-l06peTaTeJuo ,lJ;OBepeH-
HOCTb Ha roJIOCOBaHJ1eIfJillI'OJlOCOBaTh Ha 06r.u;eM co6paH1-11-1 B COOTBeTCT-
BI-IH C yKa33.HIDIMYI npl-l06peT8TeJm aKl!ffii B CBR31-1 C 3TJ1!M BOnpoCOM B n
5 CT. 513aKoHa «05 aKQI-IOHepHbIX 06lL\ecTBax» Qe.necoOCp83HO 6biJIO 6bl
BKJllO'IWTb ,lI{)I1OJIHJ('feJIbHoe OCHOBaHi-le ,l\JlR BHeceHWIl-l3MeHeHJu1 B CITI-I-
COK aKQI-IOHepOB - npl-lo\5pe'rflme .ID:!L\OM 8Krurn 06meCTB8.
BE. 363eeB npeAJl8raeT tPJpMMpOBaTb CIDICffi Y"8CTHI-IKOB 06mero
co6paHWI Ha,!:Wry He n03)J.Hee Tpex pa6o<mxJJ;Hetip,oero Ha'laJIa Ha oc-
HOaaHI-II-I A3,HHbIX peec-rpa. IIpl-l 3TOM, COXpaHI-lB,l\€iicTByKJIIJ;I-Ii1 nopH-
,lJ;OK npe)J;Bap:I-ITeJIbHoro )'Be,lJ;OMJ1eHWI 8KQ1-10HepoB 0 npoBeJJ;eHIUI 06-
mero C06paHWI, no ero MHeHl-IlO, !-!MeeT CMblCJI BKJilO'1I-ITb B 3aKOH
HOpMY, npe CMaTpl-lBalOwyro 06naaHHocTb oT'i)'m.n;aTeJU1 8KQ1-1f1, 1\0-
TOpbD1 06J:Ia)1aeT :J-IH4JOpMaQl-lei1 0 rOTOBRmeMCH C06paHI-II-I aKQmlli€poB,
c006UV1Tb I1pJmpeTaTeJllO aKQJlfl BCID JIMeIOl1tY1OCf! J-IH4JOpM8Q1-1ID 0
npe,!\cTOflLQeM 06r.u;eM co6paH1-11-1, a TaIOKe YCTaHOBI-ITb arneTCTBeH-
HOCTb 38 HeIJHII()JlHellHe :noi1 06naaHHocTII. 17G
IIpaBO }"18CTI-IR 8K1U10Hep8 B ynpaBJ1eHi-lI-l OCYIl.\€CTBJ1fleTCJ'I r.naB-
HetfIm-lM06pa30MB 06LQIDC co6pam1f1X nocpe,!\CTBOMn0J1b30BaID:!J1npa-
80M rOJloca.
UA. PYJJ;HeB OTHOCI--lJ1 npaBO H8 no,lJ;8'iY I'OJIoca Ha 06r.u;eM co6paH1-11-1,
T8IOKe l\8K JiI npaBa Ha nOJ1.Y'leHl-le W'lBl-I,!\eH,!\8 JiI JIJiIKBMJWI..\IDlIIOi1 p,0J11-1
JiI3 OCTaswerOCR JiIM)'1LIeCTBa K «Ha-rypaJIbHbIM npaBaM», TO eCTb T8KJ-IM,
l\OTOpbIe Bb!TE'KaIOT"3 C8MOfi npMpo.!U>1 8Kltl-lOHepIldX 06LQeCTB. He06-
XO)J;J1MblM yc.nDBueM ,n,eik:TBJm 8KW-10HepHoro npasa, no ero MHeHl-IlO,
R8J1HeTCR npl13HaHl-le, XOTR 6b! TOJ1bKO 38 o.1l;tioi1 rpynnoi1 8KW-10HepoB,
npaBa H8 no.I\8'l)' l'OJIoca Ha 06r.u;eM co6paHID-l, TaK KaK B npoTIlBHOM
c.rryqae 06mecTBo ,lJ;OJlJoKHO paccMaTpl-lBaTbCH KaK HIf€, 8 He
l\opnopaQI-IJ'i. I77
-75-
M.T. TapacoB yKa3bIBaJI, "ITO B COCTaB aKqI10H€pHOro npaBa BXOJ{IIT
KaK mrrerpa.1IbH8J1..aCTb npaBO roJIoca; CJIe)10BaTeJIbHO, HJ1KaIWM aKlti'l-
OHep, OCTaBa:flCb TaKOBbIM, He MomE'T 6bITb JD1llIeH nOJIb30BaJUlfI npaBOM
roJIOca, TaK KaK TaKJ1M J1JillleInfeM COBepweHHO npoM3BWIbHo Hapywa-
eTC.l1 era aKltImHepHOE' npaBO. Ha orOM OCHOBaHI>1J.1 CJ1e11YeT npH3HaTb
TaJOKe ('(JBeJJllieHHD HenpamfJIbHbIM 11 IIpOI13BOJIbIIbIM npl13HaID:!e 38-
HeKOTOpblMI1 aK1V10HepaMI1 TOJIbKO COBellla:reJ1bHOI'O rOJlOca 11J1J1 J1l1we-
Infe npaBa rOJIoca, Hanpl1MEp, .meHll\l1H, npe.D;bsmwreJIb-
CKi1X 8Kl<i1ii, 6aHKpOTOB. J1C1tJIKJ"IeHJ1:H 113 ororo npaBI1JI3. npl13HaBaJII1Cb
JiM J1J1Wb B HeCROJ1bIGIX cJI)"1aHX:
1) aKlt"OHep He MomeT nOJIb30BaTbCH npaBOM rQJ10ca npl1 06cYm,Ile-
HMI1 BOIIpOCOB. J1I1QHO era KaCalOll{I1XCH (HaIIpI1Mep, sonpoca ° nOKynKe
o6utec'moM y 3TOro aKLIl10Hepa J1MytIJ;eCTBa);
2)aK[{l10Hep, CBOI1 aK4I1I1, TaKme He AOJImeH nOJIb3O-
BaTbCJ'i np3.BOM ronoca )10 Tex nop, nORa aKqi1l1 ero 6yAYT HaxOJ\l1TbCH B
3aJIore, 11 3TO nOTOMY', "TO 3aJIOroM CBOI1X aK1V1ii aKl<i10Hep HaCTOJIbKO
oc.na6Jlff€T CB.H3b MeJti,!\)' ern l1HTepecaMl111 l1HTepecaMl1 06lQeCTBa, 'ITO
nOJIb30BaHMe JiM np3.BOM roJIoca, s ..eM npasoaKWID-
HepOS Ha yqacrne B ynpaBJI€HI1I1, np€.l\CTIlBJIHI He6e30IIaCHbIM.wm
o611\€CTBa 11 .wm OCTaJIbHbIX 8KqI10HepOS, 8K4I1I1 K01'OpblX He 3aJIomeHb1;
3) BpeMeHHoe JII1IlIeInfe npaBa roJIoca B03MOmHO B Bl1,!\e rol l-
HapHoro B3b1CKaJDfR. IIpI1 I13BeC'IHbIX YCJIOSI1HX. npen;yCMO'IpeHHblX
YCTaBoM. 178
B CQOTB€T('TBIDI C )1eiiCTBYlOll\I1M 3aKOHOM «05 aKl1l10HepHbIX 06-
llIeCTBaX» 3a I1CKJIlO'i€HItEM c.rryqaeB, YCTaHOBJI€HHbIX 4Je,lJ;epa1IbHblMl1
3aJIDH3MU, npaBOM rOJIoca Ha 06lQeM co6pamrn aKqI10HepC)B no BOIIpO-
caM, nOCTaBJIeHHbIM Ha 1'OJI000000000I€, o6.naJ:\aKrr:
- aKlVlOI1€pbI - SJIa)1eJIbJ.U>,l 06uKH00eHHbIX aKIUdi 06ll1eCTBa;
-aKLtI1OII€pbl-BJIa,lJ;eJIb'--1b1 aK1V1ii06IQE'CTBa
B c.rryqaHX, npe,DycMOTpeHHbIX TeM.me 3aKOHOM.
rOJ1000BaIDIe Ha 06lQeM co6paHIDL aKqI10HepOB cornaCHO CT. 59 3a-
KOHa «06 aKQ1WHepHbIX " oCYll\eCTBJUIeTCH no npl1H'--1l-my
«O.LJ;Ha roJIGCy1Ow,aJ'i 8KQi1R 06111eCTBa - O,!\11H roJIOC», 3a I1CKJIKJ'l€Hl1eM
IIpOse,!\em'!:fI KYMY.rurri1BHOrO I'O.I1OCOBaInUt
B 3Toii HopMe B0IIJ1011\eH AaBHO 113B€CTHbIif npJ1HIV1II 8KqI10HepHOra
npaBa, c4JOPMYJBIpOBaHHbIif n IfuCeMCKI1M CJIe)J;ylOll\I1M 06pa30M:
«TOsapl1ll1 B 31'0" KOMnaH1111 eCTb He aKLtI10Hep, 80 aKQKR" 179
rOJ:l ): 8KL1l1ei1: o611\€CTBa HBJIJleTCH 8KLtI1J1
11J1111lp11BJr.nernpoBamIaJ'i aKQKR, npe.AOCTaBJlJ'ltCUJ,aJl: aKqI10Hepy - ee
BJI8.)\eJIb'--1Y IIpaBo rOJIoca npl1 peilieHID:! BOnpoca, IIOCTaBJIeHHrIJ Ha ra-
JIOCOBaHMe (CT. 49 3aKOHa «05 8KL1110HepHbIX 06111€CTBax").
-76-
CornaCHO CT. 32 &Karla «06 8KQMOHepHbIX 06IQecTBax», B.rra.n;eJIb-
Qb! npmnmempoBaHHblX aKQl1fI cnpe]1€JIeIJHoro TIma npl106peTalOT
npaBo l'OJIoca no BceM BonpocaM KOMIIeTeHIVDI 06IQero co6pamm, eCJD1
He 6bL110 npl>1WlTO peWeHl1e 0 BblI1J1aT€ ,lUflUf,J:\enJJ;DB I1JIJ16bL110 npl>1WlTO
perneHl1e 0 HenQJ1Hot1 Bbm.naTe ,l];MBJ.-l,[IeH,lJ;OB no npmllJIenlprmaHHbIM
aKQI1.HM :aTOra Tl1IIa. IIpl1 pernemm BOnpoCOB 0 peopram 1 11 JrnR-
QI1I1 npaBOM rOJIOca o6na,D,aIoT BJ1a.z e.-'lbI I1pJlBnJIernpOBaHflblX
aKQl1fI.m060ro Tl1IIa. IIpI1 pernemrn BonpoCOB 0 BHereHJ1J1 J13MeHeHID1 J1
B yCT3.B o6IQecTB8., 0f'J::6HWlI1B8IOlWIX npaBa BJla)J;eJlbQeB
npl1Bl1JIempoBaHHHX aKQl1t1 onpe.l\eJ1eHHoro runa, npaBO rOJloca npe-
)J;OCTaBJIJ1eTCJ1 B.KQWOHepaM, BJJaJlelOIQMM am.(I1RMI1 TOro runa. npaBa no
KOTOpbllV! orpaHW-II1BalOTCJ1. B I1HblX CJ1y<1aJ1X npmcl1JIenq:JOBaHHbl{' aK-
J.tI--U1He.fZBJ1J1ZOTCJ11'OJ10 1MH.
IIepBoHa'laJIbHO npmcl1JIernposaHHble aKWfl1 nOHBI1JD1Cb B AHrJ1ID1.
HaXO,!I,RCb s aa-rpYAtUrreJIbHOM SI«JtfOMH'-IecKOM nOJlO<KeHI1J1, aHrJlID1-
CKI1e TpaHcnOpTHbIe KOMI1aHI1J1 C QeJlblO IIpHBJIe'I{'HJUI HOBOro KaID1Ta-
.na CTaJD1 BbmyCKaTb aKQI1I1, KOTopble ,l:\aaaJDil 60Jlbille
aKLI"OHepaM B <YrHOllIeHHl1 mJIy'-JeIDIfI,l:\l1Bl1,D;eJUJ;OB J1l1M)'1L1eCTBa JII1K-
BlI}];I1:PyeMoi1KOMI1aHIDInocpaBHeHMlOC aKQl1HMJ1, HO
He ,l:I3.BaJD1 npaBa l'OJIoca 180 B H8CTOHIQee BpeMH B AHrmrn: HeKOTOpble
KOMI1amUf BhIII.YCKalQT J1 HeroJIOC)'KIIV«' 06b1KH()B{'HHbIe aKQl1I1, no KO-
TOpbllV! npe.n;OCTaBJIJ1lOTCH Bce npaaa, 1 1eC.fZ Y c06CTBeHHl1KoB
ofuKHOB€HHItIX 8Kl<11i1, sa J1CKJIlOQeHJlleM npaBa l'OJIoca. ,lJ;eJIaeTCH 31'0 B
QeJlHX COCPeJ\01O'leHJm KOHTpoJifi B KOMrnlIlJlRX aa orpaHJII'leHHbIlV!
KpyroM 'IJIeHOB, Y KOTOpblX J1MelOTCH aKW1J1 c npaBOM rOJIOCOBaHJIIH.
4IoJUJ;oBaH 6"pm8 J1 4JI1lffiHCOBOe Co06IQecTBO AHrJllrn HeraTI1BHO <YrHO-
CflTCHK UOTaKJ1X8KQID1.18'
M11. KYJ1arJ1H6b1J1y6em,zJ;eH, '!TO eCJlI1 QeZU1aH 6)'Mara He,l:l3.eT npaBa
ro.noca, TO eCTb He npe.l\OCTaBJlIieT npaBOMO'IMJI yqaCTBOBaTb B ynpaBJIe-
HIDI,l:\eJIaMJil 8KQI1oHepHoro06LQeCTBa, TO, COrJ1aCHO np aMKJIaCCI1-
'Ieczroro aKQJ10HepHoro npaBa, ee BJ1a.rteJlbQa HeJlb3.!1 C'Il1TaTb yqacTHJII-
KQM. Ero npaBOBDE' nOJJomE'HJlle no cyrn He 6Y,l:\eT OTJ1J1<laTbC.fZ OT CTaTYca
Kpe,!J;IITOpa 06IQeCTB8.. Tal<oe 3aKOHO,l:\aT€JIbHDE' IIpn;UffiHlle 6e3ro.nocHx
aKQl1t1.fZBJIJ1eTCf! TaZOKe O;:uu-zM 113 MlI)J'()qJ1CJIeHHbIX 1l.0Ka3aTeJlbCTB TeH-
Ae cfummellJlR npaaOBOro nOJJO<KeIDfI! 8KQI1H J1 KOTQ-
paR o6Hapy)KJ1BaeTCH B C'OBpeM6lHOM aKl<l10HepHOM npaBe. 1B2
,lI;.B. JIOMaKl1H c<nrraeT, '!TO OMa,JJ,a'I{'JIb 6e3ro.noroii 8KQJ1W no c)'l1l;e-
CTBY HI1'leM He OT.JII1'I8eTCH OT 06b1KHO!1eHHCa'O Kpe,!J;IITopa 061l\€CTBa. Ec-
mt 06b1KHOBeHHaR 8Kl<I1J'1 nD,!!,TBepiK,!l;aeT HaJIl1'll1e aKl<l10HepHoro npaBO-
OTHOllleHIDI, TO 1pDB1lHH8R 8KQ11R Y,l:\OCTOBepJ'leT TOJIbKO npaBa
-rpe6oBaHWI, 11MetOli!I1€ 06J'13aTeJrbC'IBeHHbrn: xapaKTep. B.rra.n;eJIeQ, npl1-
BJ1JIempoB<lHooii8Kl<11I1 RaK KJIaCClf'I€Cro1J1 Kpe)J;m'Op snpase JIJ1Wb Tpe-
-77-
6!maTb onpe,!l;eJIeHHom IIDBe,l\EHIIR ur ,!I;OJDKHI1K1l - aK4MOHepHOm 06Il\e-
CTBaBCBJ13MC BhInJIaTOHnoCJIeJ\ID1M3apaHee 3a$ l1eHem-
HOH cyMMhI. ITo em MHeHMIO, €C.IDf 11 MomHO Ha3B1lTb TaKI1e OTHOlIIelll1fl
aK4MOHepl1hIMl1, TO TOJ1b1W C yn<YI'p€6JIeHJ1€M TepMl1Ha «RBa3I1». Tor
q><ucr, '1TO B pe,W\MX CJI;y'I1l$IX B.I18.J\eJThLT;hI lIpI1BI1.11eI'HpOB1
noJJY'ffi-lOT lIpaBO mJIOca, Irn B RaROH CTeneID1 He CTaBl1T nO,!\ COMHeHHe
RBa3J xapaKTepI1XOTI1OllleHJmC lOHI'2pHhlM 183
O,lJ;HaIW ecJ1I.1 BJI1lJ1eJThLT;hI npllBlU1m1JXlB1lHHblX aRqwH 11 flBJ1.1UOTCJ1
Rpem-rropallrn, TO cpe,!l;l1 HI1X TBKJle BKqJ10Heph! 3aHl1M3.lOT oco6oe Mec-
TO. J1x B3HOCh! 06paa)'1OT ycTcIB1IhIii KaIDITaJI HeplIDl"O 06Il\eCTBa.
a He 3aeMHhrn:, KaR l1eHemHhle cpe,JWTsa, I1OJ1.}"I€HHhIe OT ofi.nm'aQI1OII€-
pos 11,[ij)yI'11:X Kpe,WlTopoB. RpOMe TOro, lIpaBO Ha olIpe,!l;eJIeHHyKJ B yc-
TaBe ID1KBJJ,JJ;aQl10HH)'1O CTOI1MOCTh OCytII;eCTBJ1F!eTCJ1 TaRI1MI1 aKUHOH€-
pallrn nOCJIe y,!l;OBJIeTBopeID1.1! TpeOOBatmH OCTaJIhHhIX Rpe,D;l'1'I'OpOB" HO
nepe,lJ; c:06cTaeHHJIKaMI1 IX aKqMi1: 06Il\ecTBa.
IIpe}J.CT1lBJlHeTCJ 'ITa XOTE no 06Il\eMY npaIDfJI)' co6CTBeHHJ1Kl1 1Ip11-
a Heo6.rra$liOTHa06meMcofpaHIDJnpaBoMroJIO-
ca, HO 0ID1 MOryr llplCyTCTBOBaTh Ha coI:piHJDI- TaKm1: BhIBO,lJ; MOiKHO
c.n:eJIaTb H3 CMhICJIa CT. 32 3aKOHa «05 aKqJ10HepHhlX .
().u;HaKO, RaR OTMe'laeT 0.8. BeJloycoB, B OTIDI'lYie OT o6HKHOBeH-
HOH aRQI1YI npmHwenlplJB1lllHa.H IIpYi fOJIOCOBamUf MomeT npe.l\OCTaB-
.JIHTh llRQl10Hepy HeCKOJlhKO fOJlOCOB. I-1x KOJD1'leCTBO onpt'neJIHeTCE
noc}>opMYJIe
X-Y/Z,
f,/J;e X - I1CKOMoe 'lI1CJlO fOJIOCOB; Y - HOMIDlaJI npHBlfJlenlplJBaH-
HOH aKQYlYI, npl1H1lJVIemaIl\eH aKQIWHepy, Z - HOMI1HaJ1 06bIRHOBeH-
Hoi1aKl.\l1l1.
,UaHHaF! n03l1qwJ1 OCHOBhlBaeTCJ1 Ha npl1Hqwne COOTHeCeHH..l! 110J111
Y'laCTWI aKqwoHepa C em PI1CJOC)M, B COQrneTCTBI1YI C KOTOphlM Ka hIi1
aRQl10Hep l10JDKeH BJD1.1ITh Ha :maIDIe pernemm 06Il\ero co6paHl1R
TOJ1hKO B rtpe)J;€.11aX csoero Y'laCTWI B YCTaBHOM KarnrrllJ1e. IIpl1Bl1J1efl1-
posaHH)'1O llKQl1lO HeJIh3J1 pacCMaTPMBaTh B Ka'leCTBe MHOJ'OI'OJIOCOii,
nOTOM)' 'ITO lIpaBa rOJloca, npe.n;OC"faBJlHeMhle TaKOH aKl.\l1eii, CTaBHTCE
B 3aBi1C1-fMOCTh OT ee HOMKHaJ1a. ITOJ1Y'1eID1e:me HepOM H€CKOJIh-
KI1X I'OJIOCOB 6e0c:rrn0cHreJIhHO K HOIlrnHaJIy aKqwl1 He n03BOJU1eT cour-
HeCTYI BeJIWII1HY BHeCeHHoro KaIDrraJIa C pYlCKOM yqaCTIDI B aKqwOHep-
HOM 06Il\ecTBe, nO:n'QMY n0l106HaH npaKTJ1Ka He,D,Onyc'I'I1Ma-l84
IIOIlrnMO orpuRl'leHlrli B npaBe roJIoca eJIhLl€B IIpYIBI1JIe-I'I
BaHHblX a n1:, Ha npaKTI1Ke B03MOiKHb! 11 ,[ij)yfl1e orpaHl1'-JeID1H npasa
roJIOca, B TOM 'lI1CJIe 11 eJIhQeB 06hIKHOBeHHhIX llKqJ1H. TaK, n. 3
CT. 11 3aKoHa «05 aKW10HepHhIX o6Il\ecTBaxD np.I!Mo ycT1lIffiBJllJBaeT,
'ITO B YCTaBe o6Il\ecTBa MOryr CO,lJ;epmaThCJI orpaHl1'-JeHI1J1 KOJll1'leCTBa
-78-
aKqID1, npMHa,JJ.JIe;>KalQl1X 0.l{H0M)' aKL(I1OHepy. I1I1X cyMNIapHoi1 HOMJ1-
HaJIbHOlI CTOJIMOC'I'II, a TalOKe MaKCI1MaJ1bHoro 'lI1CJ1a roJ10COB, npe.no-
craB.JlfleMhIX 0.l{H0M)' aKqHOHepy.
R TaKi1M BC€f303M())KHbIM OIpaHH'IeIIMHM npaB a J'JHepOB KpaJiHe
HeraTI1BHO arnOCI1JICH n.R I'ycca1roBcmm, lIDTOpH11 nl1caJ1 no aTOM)' no-
BO,Qy CJ1ell;,)'IOIIJ;ee. «TaKOe CTpeMJIeHl1e, HaIIPaB.JieHIDe K oc.rra6.n:eIDfiQ B
aKL(I1CEepHb[X 06I11ecrBaX BJ1I1F!HI1F! KpyrrnbIX amuurnepoB B J1HTepeCaX
qeB HeOOJ1bllIoro 'lJ1CJ1a aRQIDi, He MOmeT ObITb onpaBJ1aHO .no-
CTaTO'lHO BecKI1MJ1 Co06pameHRHM1L B aKqHOHepHbIX TOBapl
J1MeeT 3Ha'leHJ1e pa3Mep OCHOBHoro KamrraJIa, coopaHHorO,llJIfl 3KCI1J1Y-
aTaQl1l1 pHOI'O npe.r:\llpJ1J1TMH, a He 'l11CJ10 aKqHOHepOB. .
npl106peTlID1e OOJ1bllIee 'lI1CJ10 8KqHi1 J1 TaKi1M 06pa30M B 6oJn,1lIeti Me-
pe cnocoI5cTBoBaBum CBOt1MH BKJIa,!!,aMJ1 06paaoBaHl1IO aKL(IlOHepHOrO
KaIDITaJIa, HecDMHeHHo, HBJIHIOTCH 6oJ1ee 3fmHTeperoBaHHbIMIl B yc-
neWHOM xo.n.e 8 10HepH1rO npeiUIpt1HT11f1, 'leM MeJlKl1e 8KWtQHepbL
IIpe.ncraBJ1.HeTCH no:ITVM)' BIIOJIHe eCTeCTBeHHbIM, 'lTV6bI creneHb BJD1-
J'IHIiIH, KOTOpoe MOI)'T OKa3bIBaTb OT.neJlbHble aKqHOHepbI Ha .ne.rra 06I11e-
CTBa, copa3MepHJIaCb J1CKJIIO'lI1TeJ1bHO c I«>JD'I'-J€CTBOM npI1H8Mema-
lIV1XJ1Ma m...II3
B .nop OM 3aKOHO,i:\aTeJIbCTBe. no CBHlle-
TeJ1bCTB)' llA Pyp;HeBa, B ycr8Bax Mor ObITb YCTaHOBJIeH MI1HJ1MYM
'lI1CJ1a aKqHi1: KaK ycJDBlle Ha.ID1'3J1R npaBa roJ1oca. 1-1,l{J1fl TOro, 'lTV6bI
CJI5oiiTI.!: 3TO ClpaHWIeHJt€ aKL{I1OHepbI, J1MelOIl{I1e aKqIDI MeHee, 'leM He-
c6xorolMO AJIH IIOJIy'IeHIIR npaBa roJIoca, m,rnymJIeHbI6bIJII1 IIpIIDeraTb
K COe}J;l1HeHI1lO no 06IIJ;eti .noBepeHHOCTI1 CBOI1X aKqHi1:.nJIR no.nyqeH!1H
npaBa Ha O IH 116oJ1ee roJ10COB. 1136
3aKOH «06aKqHOHepHbIX 06LqecTBax» cO,i:\ep:>Kl1T He TOJIbKO orpaHI1-
'leHl1H npaB KpynHbiX aKL(I10HepOB, HO 11 ,lWyrl1e HOpMbl, npl13BaHHbIe
cnoco6cTBOBaTb CJCY1QI2CTBJ1eHW1O npaB 8KQ110HepaMI1 - ,n;epmaTeJIRMI1
MeJIKl1Xnm<:eTOB aKql1i1. TaK, B 3aKOHenpe,n;ycMOTpeHMeXaHI13MK)'MY-
JIHTJ1BI1OI'O roJJ'JCOBaHJIR npH BbI60pax 'lJIeHOB COBeTa .lU-IpeKTOpOB.
)];.B. JIOMaKWH, npoCJleml1BaH I1CTOpl1lO cPJpMMpOBaHWI aTOro Mexa-
HI13Ma, npl1weJ1 K BblBOJIY, 'lT0 npoQe,IQ'Pa KYMYJlfITJIBHUI'O r()J10COBa-
HJ1H6bma3aJIMC'IBOBaI1a 3aKOH0.D.8TeJ1eMl13aKIVnrep-
HbIX 3aKOHOB aMepMKaHCKi1X llITaTOB. BnepBh1e OHa 6bma BBe,n;eHa B
U!'i'O T. B WTaTe J.1.rJ.mmoi,ic no 8HaJIOn:1JI C nponDpWrotIaJibHbIM npe,lJ;CTa-
BI1TeJ1bCTBOM J::a3.1III'1Hh1X rpynn Ha l1OJJH'IWIeCIWii CQeHe AMepJ1Kl1. 1137
RTI Mo3OJ1J1H B CBoei1 pa6are «Ropnoparurn. MOHOnOJlJ1H 11 npaBo B
CIIIA" npl1BOJJ.lIT MaTeMaTI1'leCKYJOcPJPM)'JIY, n03BOJiHlOll.(YKJonpe,n;e-
Jllf1'b, CKOJIbKO nOTpe6yeTCR roJIOCOB rpyrme aKqHOHepOB ,l{JIfl npoBe.n;e-
HI1H B COBer .nl1peKTOpoB CBOI1X Dpe,llC1'aBl1'reJIei1:
-79-
X=(YxN])";' (N+1) +1,
me X - KOnH'l€CTBO a J Heo6x(),l],llMbIX AJlR npOBe,!\eH11J1 B COBeT
JJ:I1peRTOpoB OnpE'JIe.n€HHOI'O 'ffiCJIa ,lJ)'1peIITOp<:E; N J -
'U-Icno ,D,J-IpeKTOpOB; Y - oOll.lee Ko.nWleCTBO aKlUm, ro.r.rocyK)ll.\HX Ha co-
opamrn; N - oOll.lee 'fficno IW1pa€MbIX B COBeT AJ1p€KTOpon.l88
TaRJ1M 06pa30M, MeHblillIHCTBO aRlV'lOHepoB TalOKe cnOCOOHO npo-
BeCTI-I HeOOXQD;I-IMbIX €MY l\aH;:tI-I,!!,aTOB npl-I BbrOopax B COBeT AI-fP€KT(>-
P()B, ocooeHHO €cnl-I KpyrmbIe aKql-IOHepb111onyCKaIOT npOC'leTbL
lo.A. Me-reneBa npe,!\nO)f\J1JJa €lI.Ie O,!\I-IH cnoc06, HalIp8BJleHHhrli H8.
3al/.ll-ITY npaB AepmaTen€ti: He6om.un-IX naKeTOB aKIV1ti: " I103BOJLHIO-
IqI-Iti: HM oI5'1.eroUllITb CBO" CW1b1 J-I npoBeCTJ-I CBoe pelll€HJ-I€ Ha 06l1.1eM
COOpaHID'I. OHa npe,!\JlaraeT BBeCTI'! B 3aKOHO,!I,aTenbCTBO corJIaW€lme
aKql-IOHepOB no I'OJ1OCOBaHIOO OHo 110J1iKHO 3aKJIlO'!aTbCR l1B)'MR J-InJ-I
oonee aKIV1oHepar.rn B nJ-ICbM€HHOii c}>opMe I-I cO,1:\epmaTb yxa3aHI-Ie 0
I'OJIOCOBaHJrn no TOM)' I-InJ-I I-IHOMY BOnpocy.1D9
Ha OCHOBaHID:! CT. 60 3aKoHa «05 aKIV1oHepHb1X 06l1.1eCTBa.x» roJIO-
COBaHIte no BonpocaM nOBeCTKI-I,lI;HH oOll.lero coopaH11J1 aKql-IOHepOB MO-
meT olOJ1J1eTeHHMJ-I MFi roJIOCOBaHi-iR. r0J10COBaHI-Ie
no BonpocaM IIOBeCTKIt:,wm oOll.lero coopaHIDI aKIV1oHepoB OOll.leCTBa C
'ffiCnOM aKW-IOHepOB - BJIa,/:\€JIbq€B ronocyIOIIJ;>-IX aKQJ-li1 60nee 100, a
TaIOKe ra.nocOBaIDle no BonpocaM IIJBeC'IID1]1HH oOll.lero COOpaHIDI aK-
Ql-IOHepoB. npOBOAHMOI'O B $JpMe 3aO'-lHOro roJIOCOBaHI-IH. ocyrueCTBJIH-
lOTCH TOJlbKO I5tan.ne-reHmrn ,lVLfI ra.nocOBaHlUL
IIpJ1 npoB€,!\eHI-IJ-I OOll.l€ro coopaH11J1 aKIV1oHe}XIB, 3a HCK.IIIO'leHJreM
OOll.l€ro co6paHI1H aKIV1oHepoB, npoBo.l{J:U. ro B c}>opMe 3aO'ilforo roJIO-
COBaHI1H, B ofutec"rnax. 1X HanpaBnemle (Bpy'-Iem:re)
OlOJIJleTeHeM IfJllf ony6mmoBam:re I1X 6JraHKOB B COIJTI3€'I'C1'B C n 2
CT. 60 3aKmra «05 aKLtl-IOHepHbIx OOll.leCTBax», nl-ILt8. BKJllO'IeHHbIe B
Cm-rCOK.mru;, JfMelOIIJ;>-IX npaBo Ha Y'lacT/lle B 06l1.1eM co6pamn13KQ11OH€-
pOB (:wx npeACTaBI-ITeJIJ-I). BnpaBe npl-IlHITb Y'laCTI'!e B TaKOM coopam:r11
.111100 HanpaBI-ITb 3anOJ1H€HHb1e 6lOJ1J1ereHI-I B o6IQeCTBO.
IIpJ-IB€11€Hll<l.H HOpMa 3aKOHa,!I,aJTa H€KOTapblM CJ1€l-tItaJ1I1C'ffiM OCHO-
BaHI-Ie,!\JIH ll1,IJp61f0ii $JpMbI J-ICnOnb30BaTb TepMI-IH "CMewaHHaH c}>op-
Ma npOB€,!\eHWI coopam:rR». lIo 3TOMY Bonpocy RH. ROH,!ij)aTOB C'IJ-ITa-
€T, J-I 3TO cne)JyE'T npI13HaTb npam1J1bHb1M, "TO npl1MeHem:re nO,1:\OOHOI'O
T€pMI-IHa HeAOIl)'CTlIMO. TaK RaK 3aKOH yrIOMJJHa€T TOJIbKO,JJ;Be c}>opMbl
npOBeA€HWI c06paHI-IFi. Ecnl-I C"I1TaTb, 'I'1'0 c)'1lI;ecTByeT oc06aFi CM€-
rnaHtraR c}>cpMa. TO aKIU'IOHepHbie OOll.leCTBa C "I1CnOM Y'laCTHI-IKOB 60-
Jlee 1000 BOOOll.le He MOryr npDEOJlll'Ib o6W11e COOpaHI1Fi B c}>opMe COB-
MeCTHOI'O npl1cyrCTBMH. I90
Ecnl-I oOll.lee coopcume 3aHBJ1eHO B c}>opMe COBM€CTHOI'O npl-IcyrCT-
BI-IH aKQJlOHepOB, 11 npl1 3TOM fuo.n.neTemr AJlFi I'OJIOCOBaHi-iR 6b1JII1 pa30-
-80-
CJIBHbI al\.Ql10HepBM, TO C'leTHaH KOMJ1CCIDI np11 IIO.l{Be,lJ;eHJ111 KrOmB 1'0-
J1OCOBaH11.l1110JIiKHa y<n1TbmBTh 11 ronoca no 6IOJ1J1eTeHJ1M, nOJ1Y'leHHbIM
oIiItecrnoM B COOTBeTCrBIDl C n. 2 CT. 58 3BKOHa «05 aKqMOHepHbIX
-=""
IIpooHaJ1I13l1pyeM OTHO!1I€IDIJ1, CKJIaAbmBlO eCJ1 npM peaJllf3aqMM
aKqMOHepOM npaBa fonoca Ha 06w;eM C06PBHID:! Me:ffi',!\)' aKQJ'[OHepoM 11
AKLtI-'IOHep BnpaBe nO,IlaTb CBoA ronoc 3a onpe,lJ;eneHHOe
perneHMe Ha C06paHl1I1, 11 oow;eCTBO OM3BHO npeAOCTaBI1Tb eMY ory
. O €HJIHCBoeranpaBaaKWIO-
HepOM MomeT HaCTyrII1Tb no,ll,BYM CJIe;:J;y1OlQI1M npl1'1I1HaM: ecnl1 6bl110
HapyrneHo era npBBO Ha Y'lacThle B 06w;eM co6paHl1M.mroo eCJrn HB CO-
6paHMe OH HBMJICH, HO eMY He 6bma npe,lJ;OCT3.BJI€Ha 0CTb npo-
ronocoBaTb. B 3TOM cn)"18e aKQJ'[OHep BnpaBe no CY11.Y Tpe60BaTb He
npe m eMY B03MOJKHOCT11 Y'laCTI1H B co6paHl1M J-1.ID1 npBBa
roJIoca, a npW3HaHJ1R pellIeHIDI C06paHI1R He.D,eii:CTBJITeJIbHbIM B CBR3W
ClIPnyIQeHHblMI:I Hapynrem1HMHnpMero eHlm.
qTO KaCaeTCH H I I npaBa I'OJ1oca npM HBKe
8.KQI10Hepa Ha coi:paHIre. TO CJIe;J;yeT OTMeTl1Tb, 'ITO Ha npaKTi1Ke B03HJ1-
KalOT c>f'IyaqI1l1, KOr,l\a a OHep I'OJ1ocye-r B c.nyqae IIJBlMeHeHJ1H K He-
MY npl>1H)'*.!\eHJ1H. 3,1J;ecb B03HMK3.e'f npofuJeMa HeBO.3l4JHCHCiCTJ OOifia-
JIOBaHl1JI perneHl1JI 06w;ero coopamm, Kor,l\a aKltIXJaep 6blJI BblH)'m.n;eH
npol'OJIOCOBaTh 3a paccMa"Ipl1BaeMbrn: BOlIpoc. Be.zu, IIO 3aKOHY 06mano-
BaTh p€lli€HJ1e oOlL\ero co6paHl1H OH MC»KeT JII1Illb B TOM CJIy'Iae, eCJrn OH
roJIOCOBaJI o<IIpOTIffiJo HB coopamrn. BhIXO,npM 3TQifll'OJlJll13l1JlIMorJIOObI
6bITb BHeCeHJle 113MeHeHJ1i:i: B 3aKOH «05 aKQJ'[OHepHbIX OOlL\ecTBax».
ID3I!OJUIIOIqI( OCIIOpl1Tb al\.Ql10Hepy pellleHMe 06w;ero c06paHl1JI He
"f()J1bRO B c.nyqae era rOJIOCOBaHMH «IIpoTI1B». HO TBfOKe 11 B ,n;p)'TI1X CI1Ty-
arvmx. 011HaKO 3TO I1pe.lIC'I'<IBJE HemenaTenbHblM, TaK KaK, Bo-nep-
BbIX, ,/:\aCT OCHOBaIDIe 11J1J1 MHOCCI'lI«'.J1eHHbIX 3J1Oynurpe61]€EI1fi: CO CTOpo-
lIbI IJ€11O\5poooBeCTHbIX aRltI1OHepoB, a BO-BTopbIX, pe3KO )'BeJill'lHT
OO"beM CY,lJ;eOHbIX Aen no ocnapl1BaIDOO p€Il16ndi 06llt11X coI:paHI1ii
)];yMaeTCJ1, 60J1ee IIpIIeMJ1eMblM SlBJJJ1eTCfl CJIe;J;y1OlQI1if BapMaHT:
JITb aKi.\MOHepy B03MOJoKHOCTb npn;;nIaHJm B cy,/:\e6HOM no-
pH,lJ;Ke H bHbIM C06CTBeHHOro perneHJ1H «38» IJOCTaBJ1eH-
lIbrn: HB I'OJIOOOBalII1e BOrrpOC RaK OOBeprneHHOro nOA npmtym,!\emleM, a
y>Ke 3aTeM 3TO nOBJIe'leT OOifiaJIOBaHWe pelll€H11R OOlL\ero cOOpa.IDJR.
IIpM'IeM 6peMR TOro, 'lTO aKlU'XE€P I'OJ10COBan no,!\ npM-
M, HymHOB03JIOJKm"b Ha Hero caMoro.
IIpaBO aKL\1'IOHepa 1136wpaTb J1 6bITb J130palillbiM flBAAeTCa HeOTb-
eMJIeMoif COCTaBJ1flIOw;eif 'iaCTblO npaBa Ha Y'laCTIle B 06w;eM C06paHl1M
aKL\1'IOHepOB.
-81-
nT. Tapacos C'MraJI, 'ITO «npaBO 6bITb u36paHHbIM B COCTaS ynpaBJIe-
mrn IWMIIaID-leff BXO)J;I1'I' B CocraB aKltI1OHeJ:EOI'O npaBa, a noTOMY He MO-
:mt'T6bITb ()'flUlT() ID1 Y K1lIroroaRqHOHepa, XOTH 6bI OH BJIa,!\eJI O.n;HOif TOJIb-
IW a e , e<'JIJ1 TOJlbKO B 06J.J.\eM 3aKOHO,IlaTeJlbCTBe He ycraHOBJJeHliI
K1lIGfe-H116y,D;b orpaID1'lemrn no 3TOMY npe,!\Me-ry B OTHowelillJf K JUIQaM.
JII1llIeHHbIM HeKOTOpblX npaB COCTOHID1fI, nopo'IHoro nOBeJ\emrn ...» 191
COrJ1aCHO .n;e C'TB}'1OIQeMY 3aKOH)' «05 aKWIOHepHbIX 061.J.1€CTBa"{'O
aKQI.-1QHep J1MeeT npaBO: 6bITb I'236paInndM B COCTaB COBeTa ,D;MpeKTopC)B
(Ha6JIKJJ\aTeJIbHoro COBeTa) 06LQeCTB3. (CT. 66); Ha3Ha'leHHbIM HCrIOJIHH-
roll.\!.-fM e,r:J;I-mo.mf'lHoroHCI1OJ1HJ1TeJ1bHoroopraHa06IQeCTB3.
(CT. 65, 69); Ha3HaqeHHblM Ha .n;OJDKHOCTb B J1CrIOJIHI1-
TeJIbHbrM opraH o6LQecTBa (cr. '70, 65); H30paHHbIM B peBK3UOHHyKJ KO-
MI1CC11KJ (peBJ-i3opooI) OOIQeCTBa (cr. 85); yrnepm.r:\eH 'lJIeHOM c<1€"IHOii
KOMI1CCIDI 06LQeCTB3. (cr. 56). Ha 3T11J\OJDKH0CTl1 aKl{l1-
OHep 11 MO:>KeT ObITb H30paH J1H60 Ha3Ha'ieH. BblTb H30paHHbIM ay,lJ;I1TO-
pOM 00ntecma aKqHOHep He MO:>KeT, IIJCIro.JIbKY npOBepKa BO-
xtJ3HticTBeHHoi J\eR"I\?JIbH)CTJ1 OOLQeCTBa npoBO,!\IITCR He3aBMCIfMbIM
npOc}:leCCI1OHaJibHbUo'! ay,lJ;l1TOpOM, He CBRaaHHhIM 11My11.\eCTBeHHbIMI1 UH-
TepecaMJil C OOLQeCTBOM I1JII1 era aRqHOHepaMJil.
o.R BeJIoyCOB no noBOJIY npaBa aKL{ItOHepa ObITb If36paHHhIM B op-
raHbI06LQeCTB3. SbICRa3aJl CJIep;yroIUylO n03 KJ, H, K11R npe,!\CTaBJIH-
eTCH, S :noM eCTb ]J;OJIR IICTIffibI. KaK C'II1TaeT )'Ka3aHHbrM BSTOP, cy&b-
eKTI1BHOe npaso aKQI10Hepa - 31'0 Mepa ero B03MOiKHOro nOBeJ\emrn.
EM)' ROPPecIIOlJJII1PyeT ropJf,!\J1'1ecKaH o6JI3aHHOCTb B cJlY-
'1ae Hel1CnOJIHeHIDI OOLQeCTBOM COOTBeTCTByroLQei1IOJBU{l1'IeCKOIi OOH-
3aHHOcrl1 aKQMOHep MOmeT 06paTI1TbcR B cy.n; AJUI 3al1tl1Tb1 cBoero
cy&beKTI:1BHDrO npasa. Ho HeJIb3J1 np!.-:!H)',!\I1Tb 06LQecTBo H30paTb aK-
ltI10Hepa B opraHbl ynpaBJIelU1Jl. TOMY MroKHO rOBOpl1Tb B J1)"-JweM
CJJy'Iae 0 cy6'beKTImHoM npase aRQI10Hepa npe,D;JIoml1Tb CBQlO KaHJ\I1-
MTYPY ,D;JIR n:IDpamrn B opraH yrrpaBJIelU1Jl OOIl\ec'fBB- 192
J];eifcrBmeJ1bHO, aKrtI10Hep J1MeeT npaso npe.n;JIO)IDITb CSOlO KaH,!\I1-
MTYPY ]J;JUI Jf36pamm B opraHbI ynpaBJIeID1R OOIQeCTBa. J];aJJee 06IQe-
CTBO B J111L\e OOlL\ero c06paHIDI aKQI10HepOB J1H60 COBern JJ:J1peKTopOB
BnpaBe H30pa'I'b !.-1J1I1 Ha3Ha'll1'1'b COOTBeTCTBYJ<Ilro aKWIOHepa Ha
.n;OJDKHOCTb. QHO J1I1llIb BnpaBe, HO He OM3aHO 3T0,!\eJlaTb.
B 3aKJIKNeHI1e HeoOxO,!\J:IMO nQlJ,blTCl)l<l1T Bce CKa3aHHoe BbUlle 0
npl1po,!\e npaBOO'IIJOllEID1i1:, CKJJaJ];bIBaKIltJ(XCR B CBR311 C }"!aCTl1eM a1(-
ltI10HepOB B pa60Te OOlL\ero c06paHIDI. YKa3aHHble npaBOOTHOllieHIDI He
nO,!\IIa,!\aJOT no)); onpeJ\eneHl1e OOH3aTeJlbCTBetlHblX, a RBJIRlOTCH KOp-
no nocBoej;inpHpo,!\e. 3ro06YCJIOBJIeHOHxc ecm;I-
MJiloc06eHHX:'rnl\o[Jf.
-82-
n e BCeI'O, paCCMaTpHBaeMbIe-e'fHOilIeffi1H CKJIa)J;bJBaIO"l'CRMeJfOJY
B3a11MfJ3aB11UfMblI1onf cy6'beKTaWf, 'lTO COBeprneHHO
He CBOtiCTBeHHO rpa:m,1I1iHCKO-npaBOBbIM OM38.TeJ1hCTBaM 11
$poti B03fIJfKHC1IJeHlfI - ynpaBJ1eHI1e aKWDEpibIM
06l1\E'CTBOM. B npoQecce p<6:m.I 06ll-\E'ro c06paIOO1 aKJ.tI1fJIIePbI BcryrtaKJI'
B IIpoQ€CC cor.nacOBaffi1H I1X BOJIb, pe3YJIbTaTOM Karoporo MO:IKeT .HBm'bCH
I<aKCOBMecrnoenpffiUITJ.1ecor.nacOBaHHoropeweHJ.UI, TaKI1KOH TI1H-
Tepecos aRLtI10HeJXIB B c..nyqae Heypery.ID1pOBCUlWI pa3HornaCMti no pac-
CMa-rpHBaeMOM)' co6paID1eM BOnpocy. HepbI, He cornaCHbie c BOJ:ieti
OOJn,IID1HCTBa, Bbmym.rJ;eHbI no,!J;'n-lW!TbC.II eti:. 8m MHeHHe OOI1bll1JflJ:.'TB 11
6y,!\e'I' SIBJUITbC$! BOJIeti caMOro aKLtID1epHJI'O 06ll-\E'(."rBa.
CneQM4JwreCKI1MI>-I oco6emt.'::crHMI1 o6.n3.,Aae-r J1 CY,/J;e6HaH 3a a
npaB 8KL{VIOHepos. BoMHorl1Xcn)"Ja..<IX np" uapyweHI-fH npaB aItqIW1!e-
pa, HaIlpJ1M€p, npaBa Ha JlHct>oPWHiIDO 0 npDBe,n;eHI-fI1 o5Il1ero co6pa-
HJ1R, npasa nporoJIOCOSaTb Ha 06Il1eM co5paHl"!J'I H TOMY nO,I\06HDe, aK-
QMOHep ynOJIHOMC:NeH nOTpe60saTb no cyP;y He BOCCTIlHOBJIeHWI ero
HapyrneHHHX npas, a 1H peIII€Hlut: o5Il1ero C05paHIDL TaK,
5eCCMblCJieHHO 5bIJIO 5bI 'Ip€6oBaHHe aKLiHoHepa 06 HHCPOPMHpOBaHlm
ero 06llj€CTBOM 0 npoB€,/J;eHIDI o6Il\ero cOOpaHJ1fI, 0 npe,!!ocTaBJIeHJ111
eM)' npasa l'OJIoca Ha)'*e npoWe,!!IIleM co6paHmt; SOBCex CJIyq3.HX aK-
QMOHep)'II)JIHOMO'l€H npe,l!"hflBl1Th 06Il\ecTSY I1CK 0 IIpl13lIBH1fH pewe-
HJ1H o6Il1ero C06paHI1R He,n;eikmwr€JIhHbIM.
Cy,n;e6Hoi1 3BIl!I11'€ KOpnopaTI1BHbIX npas aKQI10Hepa npl1c)'IQ3. H
eIl\e O,!\Ha 'lepTa - cy,n;MOOKeTocTaBI1Th 6e3 3aI.qI1TbI HapyweHHoenpa-
BO. 3To B03MO:IKHO, Kor,n;a HapyweHI1R, ,!!olI)'IIleHHbI€ B XO.lIe o5ll-\ero co-
6paHJ.UI He .HBJIj1lOTCfI cyrrIeCTBeHHbIllrn, npl1lU1'rhThrn pellleffifmrn He
npwnrneHbI y6hITK11 epy H OOJIOCOBBHi'1e a OHepB, 'lbl1 npasa
6h1J'IH HapyweHbI He Morno nOBJ1J.U1Th Ha pe3ynbTaTh1 J'OJ1OCOBBIDUL
KopnopaTI1BHbIM OTHOllIeID1$IM, I10IlrnMO :;rroro, CBOiicTBeHHa oco-
6eHHOCTb, HenpI1cyIQBH 06f13aTeJIbCTBBM, - JIOlIYC'I'HM nepexo,!! npas H
pacnpOCTpaHeHHe 06H3aHHOCTeA O.IIHOti: CTopoHh1IWpr1OpaTJlBHoro OT-
HOIIIemm Ha ApyrylO. TaI<afl CHryawrn B03MomHa, uanpWMep, TOr,n;a,
Kor,/J;a aKQI10HepbJ npHHWMalOT Ha ce6fl £PyHKlJ;I1I1 oprBHoBa oHepHo-
ro 06I11eCTSa no C03h1BY 06I11ero C06paHHfI npH OTKa3e OT C03bma
c06pamm COBeTa 1II1peKTOpOB 00iqecTBa.
t 2. npaBOoTHoweHMR, CBSl3aHHbie C cIJoPMMpoBaHMeM MM)'lL\eCTBa
aK4MoHepHoro 06aqecTBa M ero pacnpe,qeneHMeM
Me>KJW aK4MOHepaMM B np04'!Cce ,AeATenbHOCTM
M npM nMI<BM,Qa4MM 06l..ijecTBa
Oc1IomIm Y"IaCTID1KOB TOBapllli.\e-
CTBa J1JUf oOlllecTBa .RBJlJ'leTCf! OOH:3aHHOCTb BHOCWl'b BKJla;J;bl B nOpR,!I-
Re, B pa3Mepe, cnOCo6aWf H B CpOKI1, ROTOpbIe npeJ1,YcMOTpeHbl Y'fPe-
A\1T€.1Il>HbIMI,I:\OKYMeHTaWf.
B 3alWHO,D,aTeJlbCTBaX pa3J1I1'-JHbIX CTpaH npe.r:J;yCMUIpeHbI pa3J11-!'-I-
Hble MOJ\eJlI1 OIIJIaTbl YCTasHoro RaID1TaJla. B HeKOTopblX CTpaHaX cyM-
Ma, Heo6xQlJ;>1Ma.H AJlJ'I BHeC€HI1J'1 B )'CT8BHbIfi Kanl1TaJl, f!BJIJ'leTCR "U1CTO
CJ1MBOJ1J1"I€C1«)fi. TaK, nl1LlO, :meJlalOllIee OCHosaTb '-Iacmyro IWMnaHl1IO
B AHr=, J\OJDKHO BJlOiKl1Tb C)'MMY B 2 cpyrrra CTep,rrI1HI'a. TaROf! mE'
nOJ\xo,!\ K yCTaBHOM)' KaIIl1TaJJy J1CllOJIb3yeTCJ'I J1 B KlITae, TaK KaK ero
KoprropaTI1BHOe npaBO nOCTpOeHO no aHrJIHiicKoMy oopasQy. 193
Poc:cJrlfcKIDi no,!\xo,':\ COCTOI1T B YCTaHosJleHI1J1 aHa'illT€JIbHOH cyM-
MbI C IJ;eJlblO 3aI.W1TI>! Kpe,!ll1TOpOB, HO, no MHeHJ1lO MHOrl1X aBTopoB, S
,n;eHCTIJIfl'eJlbHOCT11 IDfTepecaM Kpe.l\WI'OpOB He npe.l\OCTIlBIlHeTCR HI1-
KaKOf! aall{l1Tbl.
TaR, :q.R :qepeHoB,C.A. Tpo eHKoc'lJITalOT, '-!TO «C KOf!
TO'-IKI1 3peHMH, ycraBtilill:i: KalIJilTaJI He BbillOJlHHeT H He .l\OJlmE'H BbIIIOJl-
HHTb IO 3aI.ql1Tbl JllfTepeCOB Kpe.l\WI'OpoS. Kpe.l\WI'opbl aK4I10-
HepHOro OOllleCTBa, KaK H Kpell,MTopbI HHbIX lI'UdMep<lecro1X opram13B.-
4I1f!, J1MelOT npaBo npeTeHJ\OBaTb HB Bce IOpU.lIH'-I€CRDro
JUfi.\B. DpI1 :;ITOM AJUI Kpe,!ll1TOpa npl-! BCTyIIJI€mDl B OM3BTeJlbCTBeH-
Hble 0TH0IlI€lII1JI C aKQI10HepHbIM 06ll1ecTBOM rJIaBHOe 3HaqeID1e J1MeIOT
cJle,!l)'1OILJ;I1e xapaKTepl-fCTHKH llOCJ1e.r:tHero:
- BeJll1'-Jl1HB H COCTas (TO eCTb .n11KBH,!1,11OCTb HJlI1 HeJ1WKBU,!J,H(CTb)
l1M)'llI;ecTBa;
- COCTas Kpe,!J;l1TOpOS oOlllecTsa (OIOWKeT, Tpy,!losoA KOJIJIeKTI-fB,
);
- B€JB1'DIH8 J1 xapaKrep OOH:3areJlbCTB aKLIl10HepHoro o6u.IeCTBa
(oOecne'1eHbIJII-f OOH:3aTeJlbCTBa J ).
BeJlJ1'1I1HB ycTaBIIOI'O RaIDITaJIa B 1\BHHblH nepe'1eHb He sxop;IlT».194
Y'iJilTbIBaR, '>TO KOHl.\elIQJ1J'1 yCTaBHOro KaIDITaJia npaKTll'1€CKH He
.n;eAC'1'syeT, }'KB3aHHbiM aSTopBM npe.l\CIaBJIJ'l€TCH lteneCOOOpB3HbIM
BHeCTI1 B aaKOHO.l\BTeJlbCTBO 113Me-H€HJm H llOI1OJIH€HIDf, e
KOHIJ;em,\11IO yCTasHoro KanIITaJIa BIlJIOTb 110 nOJIHot1 OTMeHbl -rpeoosa-
HJU[ 0 n JDK8HI'II'I pa3Mepa 'lJ1CTbIX aKTI1BOB Ha ypOBHe HeMeHee Be-
.JIWIl1Hbl yCTasHoro KaIDfTaJIB.
-84-
B POCCID:! :nuT BOnpoC TafOKe nO-paSHOM)' peIIJaJICJI B paSJD1'IHoe
BpeM.R, HO OO.R3aHHOCTb no OJIJIaTe ycTcIBHOI'O KaIlUTaJIa BCer,lla c eCT-
BOBa.rra. ITo CBIf.!\eTeJIbCTay J10CJf EpaYAe, B M nOCJIe
peBOJIJOI.ti'nf 3aKOHO TenbCTBe .J\onYCKaJIaCb OTCpO'-lKa no OnJIaTe yc-
TaBHOro Kanm-aJIa. CT. 327 rK PC<:PCP 1922 r. YCTaHaBJ1HBaJIa, 'lT0 ec-
JII1 B Te'-leHl1e 3 Mec eB COWI.Ronyfun-noosammoO yrn emrn YCTa-
sa He 6Y.J\eT CoOpaIIa 1,I40CHJBH0I'0 Kamrra.rra, TO oOll\€CTBO I1pJl3HaeTC.R
HeC0CT01IIIlIIKMCR. ECJ111 me B Te'-leHl1e cneJ1Y1OLqlfx 3 Mec eB He 6YAeT
CoOpalia CJIeJJ;Y1OID,aH '1eTBeprb OCHOBHOro KaID1TaJIa, a B Te'letrne yK3.-
3aHllOrO B YCTaBe CpoKa, KO'I"OpUfi. O.J\HaKO, He .J\OJDKeH npOCTJ1paTbC.R
.J\onee 1 ro.J\a co BpeMeHl1 OTKpbITI1J1 ):\e1lcTBml:, He OY.J\eT c06paHa oc-
TaJIbHa.R, csepx ABYX'IeTf epTeti:, QBCTb OCHOBHOro Kanl1TaJIa oOll\eCTBa.
TO oOut€CTBO J1I1KBI1,!U1PYeTC.R B Te'-leHl1e 3 MeC.RQeB, pa3se 6b1 C pa3pe-
llIeHYIH npaBl1TeJIbCTBB cpOK OnnBTbI aKWtti 6bLII npoMeH I1JII1 pa3Mep
OCHOSHoro KaIDrraJIa oOll\eCTBa 6bLII COOTSeTCTBeHHO )'MeHbweH.
1l.0 laKQI1OHepHII'006ll\ecTB3.m:3blBaJI]:1CblJ:B3.00Lql1XCO-
i5paHw18KWJOHepOS - npe,n;aapl1T€JIbHoe J1 yqp€rolTeJIbClOC>e. IIpe,lJ;B3.pl1-
TenbHOe oOll\ee C<:.I6paHJ1e C03HBaJIOCb no nocTyILJ1eHl1I1 He MeHee
1/4 OCHOSHOro Karnrrana. C06paHJ1e 31'0 3ac.rryIIIl1B8J10 l\OKJIa,ll yq:pe)J;l1Te-
neti: 0 xO)J;e Y'fP eHl1H J1 J136J1pa.oo KOMJ1:CCJ1K} l\.IUi npoBepKl1 OT'IeTa
yqpeJJ)'rre.nei1: J1l\aHHbIX, OTHOCJIll\MXC.R K OQeHKe BHeceHHoro J1MYIlI;ecTB3..
He n03l\Hee 1 MeCRl\a 11 He paHee 7 l\Heti: nOCJIe npel\sapITeJIbHOI'O
oOll\ero CoOpaHI1J1 aKICloHepoB C03bIB8JIOCb yq:pe,u;wreJIbCIOC:le co6paHI1e
11X. Ha HeM 3aCJI.YIID1B3JICH l\0KJIa,lJ; KOMJ:ICCW1, J136paHHOM ]])IJI nposep-
KJiI OT'-IeTa yqpe,wrre.rreii, IIpOIt:3BQl{I1JIBCb oqeHKa BHeceHHoro Ha onna-
ry aKWtti J1M eCTBa, BbIliOCHJlIXb nOCTaHOBJIeHHe 0 IIpJI3IIiUD'II' 06-
l1\eCTsa COCTOmillIJIMCH J1JII1 HeCOC'"IUHBlill1MCH, K30I1paJD1Cb 'UIeHbI
npaSJIeHI1J1, peml3J1OlJHOti: KOMJICCHIII, l\Pynfe opraHb1 ynpaBJ1emfJ'1 J1
pernaJD1Cb 0CTaJ1bHbIe .J\ena. 195
IJpI1 3TOM l\0 1J1 OOll\eCTBa yq:pe.wrreJUIMI1 BbJ,.!I,HB8JIMC
no,IUU1caB1l111MC.11: Ha aKWII-f npe,!U3a I1MeHllbIe pacnl1CKI1 0
I1CIJ1y"-IeHlflI B3HOCOS B onnary aKL{ID1:. YKa3BHHbIe npeAsa
J1MeHHble paCllI1CKI1 MOrnl1 6bITb YC'I)'naeMbI l\Pyn1IVI JIMllaM TOJIbKO C
cor.naCI1R npaBJ1€lDlfIofuQecma. ITonpI-13HaHl1l-1a 00ll\eCT-
sa IOpJf.lI:J1'-Ie1M .mmOM npe,!U3apHTeJ1bHble J1MeHHbIe pacnl1CKI1 OOMe-
HI1BaJII1Cb HB aKI.<H11 = SpeMeHHb1e CBIVJ;eTeJibCTBa 196
B3r11R,!\bI yq:eHbIX Ha ofiH3aHHocTb aKL\l-'lOHepoB no onnaTe}'CTaBl1o-
ro KBIDITaJIB MOJKHO eJiJ1Tb HB,Il,Be 6onbllll1e tpynIIbr. O,ll;H11 aSTopbI
(HanpI1Mep, AJ1. KaMI1HKa) C'lJITBmI BHeCeHl1e l\eHe:>KHbIX C)'MM 3B aK-
QID1 npaBoM epa. ECJD1 aKL\l-'lOHep He peanH:3OBaJI BOBpeMfl CSO-
era npaBa J1 He OnnaTI1JI aKL\l-'lI1, TO K HeM)' l\O./DKHbI 6bITb npHMeHeHbI
lieraTIlBHble MepbI B03,!J;eiicTBJlfI B Bl1,.!J;e nl1WeHI1R npaBa '-IJIetfCTBB B
-85-
aKW10H€pHOM 06ll-\€cTB€. )J;pyrl1€ aBTOpbl (x.a BaX'-II1Capai1Q€B,
B.IO. BoJ1b<p, MH.I13pa3JIl1T) nQJ18raJThl, '-lTO oruraTa aKQJ1f-i - HecYI"b€M-
neMa:fl OfuI38.HHOCTh aKqI10Hepa, npl1 HeBUIJOJIHeHI1H ROTOpoti o6pa:3o-
BaBW)'K>C:fI 3CU\OJDKeHHOCTb MomHO B3bICKaTb B CY;l\e6HOM nopJ'l e.
B HaCTOjUl.jee BpeMJ1 nOJI.)''ilfJIa npl13Ham-le 11 3<HWHOl1,3.TeJlbHOe 3a-
KpenJ1eID-Ie BTOpaH TO'-lRa 3peHHH. )J;eiicTIntTeJlbHo, eCJ111 6b1 aKW10Hep
Mor B .mo6oe BpeMJ1 OTKa3aTbCJ'I OT OnJIaTbi CBOI1X aKWBi. TO COMHJ.-I-
TeJ1bHbIM (',I1eJ1aJ10Cb 6b1 caMO cyll-\eCTBOBaHl1€ aKQJ.-IOHepHOro ofuQeCTBa
6e3 C03;1\aHHH AJ1:f13TOrO l1M)'lL\eCTBeHHoi1: 6a3bl- yCTaBHOro Kanl1TaJ1a
TIT. TapaCOB no.naraJ1, '1TO aJaU1CII€p ofuJ:3aH Bbll1J1aTl1Th CBOIO ;1\0-
J1lO KaIII-ITaJ1a B ;yKa3amlOe BpeMJ1 B YKa3aHHOM MecTe, :;rro BbITE'KaeT
npJ'lMO J13 cyw,HOCTI1I13Ha'1eHHH nO,!\III-ICKI'! Ha aKI<ID1 KaK ofuJ:3aTeJIbCT-
sa, KOTOpoe 6epeT Ha ce5J'1 nO,!\l1J.-1c'-JJ1K, a nOToM)' npJ.-l H€Bb1I1OJJH€l1HI
:;rroro ofuJ:3aTeJ1bCTBa nO,!\l1l1C<iJ-1K He TOJlbKO nO,!\BepraeTC:fI yrLII8Te Hey-
CTOfuo!, HO ,D;ame J1l1L1laeTCH J1Hor,!\a J1 npasa Ha aKQJrn, KOTOpHe Ha
:;rrOM MCe OCHOBaHlrn MOIyr 6bITb TOJIbKO HMeHHbIMI:Il1,O Tex nop, nOKa
06:f13aTenbCTBO He BbIIlOJ1HeHO, ]:Ia6bl He OTHRTb B03MO»CHOCTI1 Y
06ll-\eCTBa B3b1CKI-lBaTb C ofuJ:3aHHoro." 97
AKQI'!I-I, pa3Mew,aeMbIe npl1 y'-1pe:lK,!\eHl1l1 o6lQecTBa, J\0JDKHb1 6bITb
OnJlaqeHbI yqp€.D;I1TeJlRMJ1 B Te'-leHl1e I'OJ\a C MOMeHTa rocy,u,apcTBeHHoi1:
pernCTp1IQI1I1 06LqeCTBa. .lI:oroBOPOM 0 C 06IQecTBa, B KOTOJX!M 11
onpe,T:\eJlJIIOTC.R pa:3Mep J1nop.H.!\oKOllJIaTbi aKQHJ1::, MOiKeT 6bITb YCTaHOB-
neH MeHee npO,T:\OJDtG1TeJibHbrn cpOK onJlaTbL IIpl1 3TOM comaCHO afu 2
n 1 CT. 34 3aKOHa «05 aKl1I10HepHblX " B Te'-leID-le TpeX MeCH-
QeB C MOMeHTa rocy,T:\apcTB€HHm"i 111 06IQecTBa J\OJDKHO 6bITb
on.naqeHO He MeHee nOJ1OBl-IHb1 ycraBHoro KaI1I1Ta.I1a 06LqeCTBa.
CJ1e1J;YeT OTMeTl1Tb, '-lTO 3aKOH He CO,T:\ep:lKl1T"I}J€60BaHIUI 06 onnaTe
IDJIOBJlHbl CTOJ'IM)(."I1I aKQl1i1 Kam,IlblM 113 aKQl10HepOB. BamHo JlJ.-Illlb,
qT06b1 B o5lQeM 6b1J10 on.na'ieHO 5f)C(. YCTaBHoro KaTII1TIlJ1a. TalGlM o5pa-
30M, Ha npaKTIlKe '-laCTO CKJ1a)J;bma€TCII C1fT)'8Q11fl, KorJ\a H€ROTOpbI€ J13
aKQI10HepOB orura'-lJ1BalOT CTOI-IMOCTb 11pKHa,l\J.Iew.al!tRX J-IM aKQl1i1 nOJ1-
HOCTbIO, a HeKOTOpble He BHOCHT l1,eH€)KHblX cpe,!\CTB B on.na'l)' aIatHi1
,npI13TOM-rpt:'6oEaHl1e 3aKOHa O OnJ1aTbI51r{
YCTaBHoro Kant-ITaJIa co6.mo.zI.aeTCE.
PaCCMOTp1IM npaBOByronpl1po'!\YOTHOllIeHMi1, IXCH no
nOBo,!\)'oruraTbi yc-raBHOI'O Kanl1TaJ1a. CyfYbeKTIlMI1 n
CKJla;u.maIOIQJ.-IXCE no nOBO,!\)' OrlJ1aTbl yCTaBHOro KamrraJ1a, BblCTyna-
lOT, C o.Iu1oti: CTOpDHbr. , C ,upyroi1. - y<1pe.I11tT€.m1 J1 aKQmH€-
Pbl. IIoc.nel1,ID1e 05J'i3aHbI npoJ'!3BeCTI1 ero OnJIa'l)', a BnpaBe
Tpe&:maTb :;rroro. PaCCMaTpI1BaeMble OTHOllIeHl1H no,!\na,u,a1OT no,!\ on-
pe,!\eneHl1e ofuJ:3aTeJIbCTBa,l1,3.HHOe CT. 307 rK pcp
-86-
06R3aHHOCTb OIlJIaTIITb YCTaBHbrn KaillfTaJI CO):lep:>tGfTCR He TOJIbKO
B M KO):leKCe pcp J1 3aKoHe «06 aKLt£fOHepHbIX 06IL1ecT-
Bax», HO 1'1 B ,l\oroBope 0 COBMecIHOH,l\eHfeJIbHOCTl1, :;3aKJllO'ffieMOM yq-
pe,l\WfeJIRMH. O-JeBJUUIO, 'ITO HJ1 0;:uJa 1'13 crOpOH 3Toro ,l\o - HH
O,IJ;WR 1'13 yqpe.QWfeJIei1- He Bnpane Tpe&:maTb OT JlPyroro HCIIO.11lIeIJIf
ero cfin3aHHoc'I1'1 no BRecemno B B ycraBHbrn KaID1TaJI XOTH 6bI
noTOM)', 'I'1'0 OOH3aHIJOC'Tb JlPyroro Y'-1pe,l\J1'1'eJIF! He YCTaHaBJIJ1Ba€TCF! B
ero nOJIb3Y,I'I no::n'OM)' OR, O'-leBU,IlHO, He J1MeeTJ1HTepeCaB ee e-
HJ1M. 06R3aHROCTb 3Ta HERO YCTaHOBJIeHa B nOJIb3Y C03,!\aBaeMOro 06-
llIeCTBa HI'IMeHHO OHO BnpaBe Tpe60BaTb era HCJIOJ1I1€IDm TaID1M 06pa-
30M CJ1€J\YeT, '-1'1'0 ,lJ;OroBOp 0 ro3,lI.affiBi OOILIeCTBa BKJllO'la€T B ceOF!
3JJeMeHT ,l\OrOBOpa B nOJlb3y TpeTbero JII1Q8..
BbIBO,D; 06 06F!3aTeJIbCTBeHHOM xapaKTepe umowelU-lti: Mem,zIy OOILIe-
CTBOM " aK4MOHepaMJ'l B CEH3J1: C orura:roi1 YCTasHoro K{UII1TaJIa nO):l-
TBepm,D;a€TCR TalOKe TeM, q'J'{) OHM BbITeKalOT J'I3 ,lJ;OroBOpa 0 C'OBII£CTIIOi,i
JIbH1JC'TJt:(l1MelOT}J;oroBopHoe HJ1:f',KaKnpaBI1JIO,cBoi1-
C'rBeHHOe 06R3aTeJIbCTBaM). B CJIy'ffi.e HapyrneHl1Jl OOF!3aTeJIbCTBa 3KqI1-
OHepoM(.QO.1Dft!U11<OM) xapaKTep3a blnpaB06lL\eCTBa TalOKenpHCYW;
06H3aTeJIbCTBeHHblM urHOllJeHJ:1HM. B03MO:IKH0 npl1MeHeHJ1e onepaTIffi-
HbIX CaHK4IDI "nOHy;tq:\eHJ1e K "CnOJlHeHillO B CY,l\e6HOM nOpH.ll;Ke.
)];B.JIoMaKl4H,npH3HaBaHcfiH3aHHocTI,JThIQa, aK-
QID1, OIIJ1aTWfb"X B YCTaHOBJIeHHbre cpOKl4, OTMe<laJI, 'ITO 3Ta 06H3aH-
HOCTb He COCTaBJLlleT CO):lep)f(3HIDI aKlUlOHepHom npaBOOTHOllI€HJ1H.
OnnaTI1Tb aKQHl1 OOH3aH He aKQHOHep, a nOKynaTeJIb. CTaTb 'lJIeHOM
,/J;e11crsylO!l\ero MO:IKHO, He BHOCR HJ1KaKHX cpe.QCTB, nyreM
nOJlY'leHJ1H aK4MA no HaCJIe.QCTBY".Im no .QorOBOpy .QapeHJ1H, ,lJ;a " no
}J;OroBOpy KyrL/ll'I-npo,!ja:>KJ1: ,lJ;eHbn:! nOJIY'-li'lT He aKQJ1:0HepHoe 06IL1ecT-
80, a ero yqaC'1'HHK, npo.QaBlID1ti: CBOH aK4MI1. 1118
KaK npe.QCTaBJIJ1eTCfl, HeOf3xo.I:\11MO pa:3I'p<UI1NImaTb OTHOllIemm:,
CKJIa):\bIBaIDlQI1ecH Me:m,!ly 3KqI10HepHbIM 06IIJ;ecTBoM" aKQI'lmep:lM, "
ornoweHJ1F!, BUTeKaIOlQJ1e 1'13 ,lIOI'0B0pa. HanpJ1Mep, KynJIH-npO):lamH
aK4Mi1. KOTOpble CKJla)tbmalOTCR Mem,zIy aK4MOHepOM, OT'I}'m,D;alO!l\JfM
CEOJ1: aKQJ1:J1, " "X nOKynaT€JIeM. OnnaTa aKL(lrli HBJLII€TCH 06H3aHHoc-
Tb10 aKWKmepa nepe.Q 06IIJ;ecTBOM npH nepmrnJ()ji J1JIJ1 ,[fJIIOJ1HJrreJlb-
HoA ::IMJ1CCHI1 aKQMi1. IIpJ1 06pall\eRID1 aKQJ1:A Ra BWpJ1'-lHOM pblHKe npJ1-
06peTaT€JIb (6y,uyw;wi1 8.KL(Inrnep) HeC€T ofur3aHHocTb OIIJIaTbl
He nepe.n;06IIJ;ecTBoM, a nepe.QTpeTbJ1M.lmQOM(aKQJ1:0-
HepoM, 0T'IyiK.!ja1OlID1M CBOJI! aKIU1YJ). IIpJ1: nOJry'leHIDI aKWtti B nOpR)J;Ite
HaCJJe,l\OBaIDLFi J1JIJ1 ,Qapemm so061L\e HJ1KaKUJi onJlaTbi He TPe6yeTCH, "
B 3WM c.rryqae 06R3aHHOCTb no OlIJlaTe aKQl1i1 B03HHKaeT He nepe.ll aK-
QJ10HepHbIM o6Il\eCTBOM, a nepe.ll 0T'IyiK.!ja1OlID1M aKIU1YJ aKQHOHepOM.
-87-
IO.A MeTeJIeBa TafOKe BilOJIHe oOOCHOBaHHO nO,lJ;BeprJIa n0311QillO
JIB. JIoMaKJ1Ha Kpl1Tl1KE'.1911
AKQJ1.H, npl1Ha e:malQ8.:fI yqpe)J;l1Temo06lQecTBa, He npe.n;OCTaBJI:fI-
eTnpasa ronoca 11.0 MOMeHTa ee nOJIHoA onnaTbl, ecnl1 "HOe He npe.D:Yc-
MO'IpeHO YCTaBOM o6IQecTBa. KaK npam1JIO, B YCTasax aKQI>-IOHepHbIX
06lQeCTB npe.n;yCMaTpl1BaeTC:fI npaBO ronoca 11.0 MOMelITa nOJIHO:W: onna-
TblaKQl1ti:.
KpoMe TOro, B COOTBeTCTBl111 CO CT. 2 3aKOHa «06 aKQl10HepHbIx 06-
rqecTBax» a , He nOJIHOCTbKJ OnnaTI1BWI1e8KQ1111, HecyT conl1-
A8PHYKJ (YI'B€'I'(."I'HOCTb no 06&1aTenbcTBaM o6u¥2c'rna B npe.n;enax
HeOllJIa'l€HHOll '1aCTI1 CTOI1MOCTIf npI1Ha emalQID!: J1M aKQl1H.
Ha OCHOBaHI1I1 863. 4 n. I CT. 34 3aKoHa «06 aKQl10HepHbIX 06IQecT-
sax» B cny'-ffie Hel1OJ1Hofi OnJIaTbl 8KQ B Te'1eHJ1e ro,lI,a C MOMeH'Ta ro-
CYM-pcTBeHHOfi pemCTpaI!IDI npaBO c:06c:TBetnrocm Ha 8KQID:!, QeHa
pa3MerqeHI1fI KOTOpbIX COOTBeTCTByeT Heonna'i€HHOii c)'MMe (CTOI1MOC-
TI1 , He nepeJl8HHoro B oIInary aKQl1i1), nepexO,lJ;1IT K 06IQe-
CTay. ,n;OroBOpOM 0 C03,1I,aHID:! OOIQeCTB8 MO:1KeT 6bITb np€JIYCMO'IpE'HO
B3b1CKaHl1e H€)'C'I'OiiKK (w , neHI1) 38 H€I'1CIIOJIHeHlle OOH3aHHOCTI1
no OIIJIaTe aKQ .
OmOCJ:ITeJlbHO 3TOro c.B. Xap'leHKO C,IJ;eJIaJI BbIBO)J;, 'lTOT8KOe 113'b-
HTI:!e y H€,l\06pocoBeCTHhlX 8KQI>-IOHepOB Heorrna'leHHbIX aKQl1i1 MO:>KHO
oIIpe)\e.ID1Tb KaK Mepy onepaTl1BHoro B03,l\€i1c1m1H. IIpI1 :nOM no,lJ; Me-
paMl1 onepan1BHoro B03,1J;ei1CTBI1fI 8llTOp nOHl1MaeT HelOpMc,IJ;IIKl1iWH-
HYKJ q.oPMY 3a1Ql1Tb1 ipa:m,!\aHCRI1X npaB rnM()C'l'().HTehHhIMl1 11.ei1CTBI1-
HMI1 ynpaBOMO'l€HHOro JII1I\8 6e3 06palQeHIDI K rocYMpcTBeHHhIM J'I
I1HhlM yrn:J1I1OMO'l€H opraHaM.
Ha ()('H()BaffiBi 3Toro aBTOpoM 11.enaeTC:fI BhIBDJI 0 TOM, 'lTO B cny'-ffie
J:I3'bJ'1TJ.-IR Y aKQI>-IOHepa HeOnJIa'leHHblX aKQl1ti: J1MeeT MeeTO OTKa3 06-
rqecTBa OJ' npl1HflTIIR HeHa emalQero l1CI1OJ1JJeHlm co CTOpoHhI aKQI1-
OHepa ('l. 2 CT. 328 rK J><'tI), npI1 KOTOpOM o6IQeCTBO fJ'I1ffi3bIB8eTCS1 OT
Ha1OJ1H€lD-1R 11.0roBOpa KyrIJIJ.-I-npo;zJ;amH aKWtti, .fIBJlRIOIQerocR O;:uJJ:IM
113 OCHOsaHMi1 B03H1OO1OB€1ll1.R aKQIWHepHOro npaBOOTHOIllI2HID1, 11 TeM
caMblM CoorBeTCTB€HHO npeKpalQaeT STO OJ'HoWeHl1e. 200
lIo 3TOMY Bonpocy (1l'M€"I1fTb, '1TO OTHoweIDIe Mem,zIy
11 aKQI10HepoM B TaKOM cny'-ffie npeKpalQ8.eTC:fI A8JIeKO He
sc€r11.a, nOCKOJIbKy K 06lQecTBY nepexo.n;wr npaBo Co6cTBeHHOCTI1 JII1Wb
Ha Te aKQJ1J:I, Qeua pa3MeIQeHW'I KOTOpblX cocrrBeTCTByeT HeOnna'leH-
Hofi cyMMe.mrt5o C'I'OMMOCTII MMYIl\eCTBa, He nepeA3,HHoro B olIJIaT)' 8K-
LII1i1. lIo CMhICJIy HOpMhI a63. 4 n. I CT. 34 3aKoHa «06 aKQt10HepHbIX 06-
lQeCTBax» KOJll1'-{eCTBO nOJIHOCThKJ OIIJIa'leHHbIX aKQl1i1 a:JO'I'BeTC'IByeT
qeJIoMY '1l1cny, nOJJy'1aeMoM)' B pe3yJIhTaT€ 11.eJIeHW'I C)'MMhI, yn.rra-
'1eHHofi yqpe;:V'1TeJIeM, H8 qeuy pa3M€U.leHJ1$1 o,!!,Hofi 8KL\I1I1 OcTaJlbHble
-88-
aKqID:! C'iI1TaHITCJI onna'leHHbIMl>1 He nOJIHOCTbKJ. ,lI,pooHble aRI n13 eCb
He 06pa3)'1OTCJI, nOCKOJIbRY nepe'leHb Cny'IaeB I-1X 06paaoBamm ym13aH
BIL 3 CT. 25 3aKoHa «06 aRqI1oHepHbIX06Il\('CTBaX» 11 HBJIHeTCJI l1C'lep-
nhlBaKJLltHM, a,[laHHaH cl1'1'yaLlJ.UI B STOTnepe'!eHb He BXO,!J;WT. qTO Kaca-
eTCH B03M£»KHOC'T11 npHMeH€HWI '!. 2 cr. 328 rK, TO B 3TOn CI-1T)'aLti'lI1
m l-1MeeT MecTO npI-1OC'I'alIOBJl mroo OTKa3 OT I1cnOJI-
HeHJ1J'I OOH3aTeJIbcrBa I1OJ1HOCTl>IOmroo B 'IaCTI1, COOTBe'lCTB}'1On He-
npe,[lOC'l'aBJJ€HH I1cnOJIHeHI1J{).
n IIHc:eMcKnit: nOJiaraJi no STOM)' BOnpOCy. '!TO B CJIyqae H€OnnaTbI
aK «KOMnamu:r Bnpase Y,[IepmaTb 113 ,[\I1BJ , cne,!lJ1Ol.L\I1x aK-
Lti'lOHepy, CYMMY, paBHYKJ CJ1e,!lJ1OIl\eM)' C Hero B3HOCY. IIpaBO aTO,
IIpe.1I.C'r8BJlHff COOOKJ c.fuKH0B€HHbIJ13a'!e-r. npIIHa"U,ne1KI1T TalOKe KOM-
IIaHJ1i1 nOMI1MO BCRKOro YIIDMKHaIIJIR 0 HeM B YCTase. - B B X Cl1J1b-
H€iiirnero n06 eHIDI K CBoeBpeM€HHOJ1 yn.rraTe B3HOCOS YCTas Ha-
3Ha'laeT ,AJIH Hel1CnpaBHbIx ,AOJI)f\HI1KOB HeyCToHKY... B3bIcKaHI1e
Heyt'"IU11K11 JIHIIIaeT KOMIIaHl1KJ npasa B3blCKl1BaTb C HencnpaBHOro
1Ka HTbI, €CJII1, pa3)lMeeTCH, B YCTase He l1OC"IaH1BJI€HO
IlpOTIIBHOro.. . 0c0I5emn.n1 B Heyc'IOHKH, B 3al\:OHO-
,lWTeJIbCTBaX 11 YCTaBax aKl\110HepHbIX II'OMllaHJDl, COCTOJIIT B TOM, '11'0
H€Ha-IpaBHbIit: }J;0Ji)fQrnK yrpa'lI-1Ba€T npaso Ha ('JJ;€JIaHHbI€ 11M BKJIa;:J;bI;
aKqI1.H era ytIl1'ITomaeTCH, 11 B3aMeH 3TOn ymf<l'f(DKeHHOK aKQID1 06Il\e-
crBO MO:lKeT BbmyCTIITb HOBYKJ».201
AKwm, IIpaBO COOCTSeHHOCTI1 Ha KOTOpbIe nepE'llIJIO K 06Il\ecTSy, He
npe,[lOCTaBJIHlOT npasa roJIoca. He y<illTbIBaIOTCJI npl1 no.n;c'Ie-re roJ10-
COB, no HI1M He Ha'il1CJlHlOTCH HJ];bL
IIpl1 aTOM, RaK OTMe'la€T Q JIoM11,[\3e. oco6elIHOCTb npasoBora pery-
.mq>DBaHl1H nepexo,lW OMaaTeJIbCTBeHH(IIU npasa yq:ac"IW1Ka IOpl1,!J;W-
'IeCKoro JII1Qa K caMOMY lDpI-1,D,H'1ecmJMY JU1L1Y 3aKJIKJ'-JaeTCJI B TOM, 'ITO
TaRO" nepexo,[l He BJ1e'leT HeMeAJIeHHoro npeKpalL\eIDIJ1 OMaaTeJIbCT-
Ba no CT. 413 rK J>q;I B CBH311 C COBJJaJ:(eHIIeM.IJ,().mKHI(Ka 11 Kpe,!\l1'1'opa B
O,!!,HOM JD1L\€; YCTaHaBJIl1Ba€'l"Cf! OTCpO'lKa, B Te'leHJ1e KOTOpoti: npaBo
MDmeT Obrrb nepe,!\aHo,rq>yrnM yq:acrHl1KaM J11160 TpeTbI-1MJD1QaM. 202
.lI;yMae-rCJ1 Bce:me, 'ITO B 3TOM c.nyqae CTopoH06J13aT€JIb-
CTBa He rr, nOCKOJ1bK)' aKltIroHEplDE' 0611tecTBO He npl1oopera-
eT cra-ryca aKQJ:1OHej':a TaR, HanpHMep, HeB03MOmHa peaJIltl3aL\WI 0611te-
CTBOM npaBa Ha nOJIy'leHl1e,[ll'1BI1,IJ,€IW)B l1,Dpyrnx npaBa OHepa.
IIo 3TOM)' noBO;:Iy CB. Xap'leHlW C'IJ1TaeT. 'lT0 B pacCMa'IpI1BaeMOn
cmyaL\l1HI-1MeeTMecTonpItOCTIUIOBJIelme06J13aT€JIbC'lEeHHOrO I1paBOOT-
HOWeHl1H npl1l13"bHTIDI 06LI:lecTBOM , HO He Onna'leHHbIX
(He nOJIHOCTbKJ onna'!eHHbIX) aK4Mi1 IIpl13TOM npI1OC'ffiHOBJIEHi'1e PeaJIJ1-
3aQill1 He 03Ha'IaeT npe 1R 06J13aTeJibCTBeHHoro O11IOIIIeHI1H. 203
-89-
B Te'leHY!e 1'O):\a, KOrJW 8Kl\IDI npY!Ha)\JIe»ffiT 06w;ecTBY. OHM npo-
,lJ;OJDKalOTC'illT8TbCfl aKLtJ1flMY!. TmmeaK'--\Y!Y!,lJ;OJURHbI
6bITb pea.IDI3OBaHbI o6mec"rnoM no qeBe He HIDKE' I1X CTO-
J-IMOCTI1 He n03,!I;Hee o,!I;Horo rO,Aa nocne JfX npl106peTem-1F! 06utecTB0M, B
npm'Y!BIIu.I cnY"ae 06IqeCTBO 06J13aHO npY!HJ1Tb pellleHY!e 06 )'MeHbllle-
HJ1Y! cBoero YCTaBHOro 1I'1HIJITana. ECJH1 06w;eCTBO B pa:3yMlIbII:l cpmc HE'
npl1MeT peweHl1e 06 )'MeHbWel1JiIJ1 cBoero ycramroro Ranwrana, opraH,
OCYW;ecTBJUllOw;Y!fi rOCYJWpCTBeHHylO penlC'Tpill-tHlO lOp")J;l1'IeCK"X
JII1I.I, .mrt50 Y!Hb!e r0CyJWpcTBeHHbIe opraHbl J1JII1 opraHbI MeCTHoro caMO-
ynpaBJ1€HI1J1, KOTOpbIM npaBo Ha npe,A"bJlBJleHJ1e TaKOro Tpe60BaHJ1J1
npe,l\OC"ffiBJI€H CPeJ1€paJ1bHbIM 3a11:QHOM, nnpane npe,ll"WlB"Tb B cy,lJ;
Tpe&:maHJ1e 0 ID'!KB aL[ID'! 06w;eCTBa.
lIo MHeHJ1lO TOro me CB. Xap'leHKO, B qe.nJIX OXpaHbI JrnrepecoB ,lJ;0-
6pocoBecnfOfi qaCTJ1 8K'--\Y!OHepOB (OIlJIaTl>1BllII1X npJ106peTeHHble J1MJII
npJ1 pa3MeW;eHI1J1 8KW111) 3aKOHO,QaTeJlbHO yCT8.HOBI1Tb
06H3aHHOCTb 06w;eC"rBa npe,/J;ocTaBJUITb peDl:cTp1J>YlOLII;€M)' opraHY no
I1CTe'leHJ1J1 MeCHqa C MOMeHTa OKOH'1aHJ1J'l CpOKa pa3Mew;emm: aKWrl-1,
AOKyMeHTl:l, nOJlHoi1 orrnaTbl BbII1yCKa aKLlffii,
JiI.ID1 peIIleffi1e I«I\'!IIeTeHTHOl'O opraHa ynpaBJIeHIDI 06ll-\eCTsa 06 J13'bH-
TIm HeOrrnaqeHHbIX aKUffi1 J1 YAOCTOBepffiOwyR) 3TO BblIIJll:CKy 113 peeCT-
pa R I\poMe TOro, He06xo,gKMO TaIDKe . 'ITO
npl1 IIOAa'le B peDlC"IJ)JtpYKIL\i'nl opraH pellIeHI1H opraua ynpaBJIeHIDI
o6ll-\ecTBa 06 113'bHTIDI HeOrIJIa'leHHbIX aKUJ-li1 11 nOJ\TBepjKA8K>ll-\ei1 3TO
BHIIlICK11 JiI3 peeCTpa m::rv:xmepoB, eCJll1 npY! 3TOM,lJ;OJIJI Hepa3MeLqeHHbIX
aKLll1i1 npeSb!cwr COOTBeTCTB}'IOwyIO HopM)'. ycrnHOBJIeHHylO 4X:::P<fI
(J1JII1 perneHl1eM 0 pa3Mew;emrn J1 npocneKTOM MI1CCI-111), W1CCW1 aKLtJ1fi
MO:lKeT 6bITb npl13HaHa HeCOC"l'OHBlllCJI.:i04
lI)'HKT 4.1. IIo.oomemu:r 0 nopJ1,lJ;Ke npwJCTaHCBJl€Hlf 3MJ1CCJ1J1 J1 npJ1-
3HaHWI m.myCKa qeHHbIX 6YMar HecOCTQJIBlID1MCJ1 J-IJn1 H€,lJ;eI1cTm-ITeJn,-
HbIM 205 npeJIYCMaTpJ-IBaeTcpe)J;l1()(H)sammnpl3HaIDl.H m.myCKa aKLll1i1
J1 TaKJ1e, RaK Hepa3MeuteHJlI2 pe-
rneHJ1eM 0 BbII1yCKE' qeHHbIX 6yMar ,lJ;0JThI, npl1 Hepa3Mew;emrnlw'ropofi
J1X SblllyCK np:i3Ha£'TCHH€COCTOHBllDIMCH I1Hepa xorH6bIOJ\-
HoA I.t€HlDti 6YMaru Bb1I1YCKa. l'a3MeIL\€lD1I2 J1 J.13'bJITYlE'
o6IqecTsoM aKLtJ1fi ImR QClIOBaII1te JIJUI npl13HaHWI m.myCKa HeCOCTOflB-
WI1MCH HI1f,/J;e He ycTaIi(JBn€HO. CorJ1aCHO n. 6.11 "fOro me IIo.nC»KeHJ1.FI,
IIpJI3l1affi1e BblllycKa qeHHbIX 6YMaI' HeCOC'IOJIE!Il1Cf1 J1Jm He,lIeiicTmI-
TeJIbHbIlV!BJ1e'leT 1&'rbHTI1€ J13 06pall\eHIDI qeHHbIX 6)'Mffi' AaHHoro Bb1I1Y-
CRa J.1 B03BpaLlleHl1e JiIX BJ1aAem, M J BHeceHHoro B orIJlaTY
)'Ka3aHHbIX qeHHbIX 6YMar. IIo3TOM)' npeAJll:1ffiEHI,I€ CB. XapqeHKO He-
npJIMEHIIJIoI'), XCTrH 6b! nOTOM)', 'IT{) I1pJt3H8HR€ Bb!nyCKa aKLll1i1 HecOCTO-
flBll1I1MCH 3aTpOHeT J1 AOf:poCOBeC11lblX a 1Otfepos, nOJ1HOCTblO oI1Jla-
-90-
TImllIl1XCBOl1aKqJ1J1,:J1KJXlMeTOro, mITpe6yeTo ycJ1JIJ1i1OT
CaMoro 06J.1\eCTsa, Hanpl1Mep, norarnemrn :J1 ym1'-!TOiKeHWI cepnulnrna-
TOB a . JljMaeTCH, "TO Ic:MeHeIDre craTYca aKql10-
HeJXIB HeBO:3M»KHO no nplfiJ11Je J13'bJITJ1.II aKWtti Y Heon.naTI1BlIDD{ HX
_>rnepoR
rrem.Hb1e aKQIDI11 I1Hble ::IMHCCI1OlIlIb qeHHbIe 6yMarn 06-
llIeCTBa, pa3MeLLta€Mble nyreM I1QlI,I1I1(W-1. pa3MeLLtaIOTCR npl-f yt'J1iEMH
HX nOJ1HOM on.naTbL
Oru-raTa 8KQJ1i.i, pacnpe.n;eJlHeMl:IX cpe,!l;l1 o6Il\€CTBa
npl-fero , aKiV-'lM,pa3MeLLtaeMbDl:nOcpe,!\-
CTBOMnO,!J;Ill1CKI-f,MOiKeT RJ1eHbraMM, qeHHbIMl16YM8J'a-
MI1, J:\PYI'I'!MM BeIl\aMI-f I1J1W I-fM)'lLleCTBeHHbIMI1 npasaMM .mrt5o I1HbIMW
npasaMI-f, J1MelOIl.\I-fMI-f ,l:teHemH)'lO oLleHKY. ttJopMa OIlJ1aTbi aKiV-'lM 06Il\e-
CTBa npwero 1iI'D:I onpe,!\e.mJeTCJi ,IJ;OroBOpOMO C03l\IUiJUI 06Il\e-
CTBa, a,l\Ol1OnHlrreJiltHb1XaKWBi -perneHl1eM0611X pa3MelL\eID1J1. Oru-ra-
TaJ1HbIX3MRCCHI:Illib1XLleHHbDl:6)'Mffi'MmKeT TOJIbKO
,IJ;eHbraMM (n. 2 CT 34 3aKoHa «05 aKqIlOHepHbIX ).
BHaCTOJ'li.Llee BpeMJ'I TaKaR EI03M())KH()C'f OnJIaTbI yCTasHOro KCUlI1Ta-
.na H cpe,!\CTBaIlrn He Bbl3brnaeT COMHeHMi1, O,WiaKO TaR 6bI-
m He BcerJ1a lI!J1aJKe H3B€C'I1IbE yqeHble BeCbM3. HeraTI1BHO 0TIIDCJ1J1JtCb
R TaKOM B()3M():IRHOCTIf. TaK, J1.T. TapaCOB nOJIaraJI, 'lTO aKQID1 MOryT 11
,IJ;0JDKHhI6bITb on.na..l1BaeMbI TOJIbKO J1eHbraMM, a Ha 3TIf ,!\eHbrn YJKe MO-
lYI' 6bITb npl-'lCx:peTaeMbI,!\JUI KOMII3.HJI!I1 pa3JlWIHoro po,!\3. np€,!\MeTb!, B
CQO'I'Be'IC'T1J C ee qelliIMJ'! J1 mITpe6HOCTRMI1. npw :aTOM OH ,l\8.JKe
npm'iera.n R CJIep;yIOIl\eMY 06pa3HOMY cpaBHeHl11O: «,l\onyCKaJI B03MOJi(-
HOCTb OTIJ1aTbIaK!!l1i1,MOmHOnpeJ1C'I<iBll'Ice6eal\.LlWOHep-
H)'lO R()MIW.HillO B ROTOJXli1:JIemaT aKLIID1, 11 Ra rW no)!;Xo-
AI-fT K:aTOM Kq:I3InJe, KIIa,!\eT B Hee KTO crapblecanorn, KTO npmHJ1E:fioo.,
RTO MeJ1b II! TOMY no,!\06Hoe, B3aMeH JKe nOJIDmeHHOro 6epeT ce6e
aKqJ1J1...».206 fiR TaIOKe BeCbMa HeraTI1BHO OTHOCI1J1CR R
BH€CeHJ1lOaKL\If(JHepaMH B1\.J18..,!\a O)J,HaKO npl-f :aTOM nOHJ1-
MaJ1, 'l'TO:aTa nOTpe6HOCTb BbI3BaHa R m113HJ111€O\'ixoJ\:r1M)CTbl{). 2fJ7
no BO!lpoCy IpOBaHJLFIyCTasHOro KaIDITa.na o6Il\€CTBa Bl:lCllDle
CY.JIe6HbIe J1HCTaHLIID1pa3"bRCID1.I1J.-I, 'lT0 npwpaapeweHt1J1 cnopoB nono-
BO)JJ' J1M.Yll-\eCTBa, B03ID IXMe 06Il\€CTBOMI1€ro yqpe,!\l1T€J1R-
MI1 (yqaCTllJoIKaMI1), Cy,l\8.M CJIeAYeT HCXQIJ;>ITb 113 TOro, ..TO J1M)'1LIeCTBO B
HaType, BlieceHHoe nOCJ1e,!U1J1Ml-l B YCTaBHbrW KanJ1Ta.n ofuQecma, npl-f-
Ha;vreJiClITnOCJ1e,l\HeM)'Ha IIpaBeco6c:TseHHoc:TIL COCTaB-
mUOT J111lllb CJJy'la11, KOf,!\a B yqpe,!\J1TeJlbHb!X ,IJ;OK)'MeHTaX aKQJ10HepHO-
ro 06Il\eCTBa CO,!\epJfffiTCJ:! IDJIo:if\EHHH., CBIfJleTeJIbCTIJYIOll.\I-fe 0 TOM, 'lTO
B y<:'I3BHbrli KaIDITaJ1 yqp€,!I;I1T€J1eM (yqacTHI1KOM) nepe.I¥:lB8.J1OCb He
-91-
ecTBO BHaType, BJIJ1llIbnpaSa BJIa)\eHIDIJ1(I1JIJ1) nOJIb30SaHIDICO-
0TBe'IC'l'EI}'I1M J1M eCTBOM2OB
EcJrnpeIlIeIDIe,JIBJlHlCJ1Q('eCHfJCII(II3allIte1J.,llHpa J\onOJI-
HJI'I'eJ1bHHX BK1V1fi, npe CMaTpHBaeT J1XOI1JIary He,!\eHemHbIMJ1 Cpe.z:t-
CTBaMJ1,JIJ1qa,oc npe npaBonpJ106pe-
TeHIDI aK1V1fi, npeJJyCMO"IpE'HHOe CT. 40 3aKoHa, BIIpaBe no csoeM)'
YCMOTpeHJ1JO OnJIaTJ1Tb J1X J\eHbraMJ1 (n. 2 cr 41 3aKoHa «05 aKL\I10Hep-
HbIXOOl1t€C'I'BIDO').
HaOCHOBaHJ1J1'L2 cr. 99 rKP<'tIHe,AO!l)'CKaeTCH €Hli:leaK1V1-
oHepa OT 06R3aHHOCTJ1 OnJIaTbI aKltIW 06lL\ecTBa, B TOM IJJ1CJIe oC:IlCJ6om-
J\eIDIe ero OT 3'l'oi-f OO$l3allliOCTtf nyr€M 3aIJeTa 'Ip€6cBaHID1 K OOr.qecTBY.
HeKOTOpb!e 8B1'Opbl BblCTynalOT 3a Bl\3MO)f\HOC'rb OIIJIaTbI aK1V1i1
11f,l\eJ1OBHMl'l KaIJeCTBaMJ1 IJeJIOBeKa. HeCMOTp.fl
Ha TO, 'ITO B H€lroTOpbIX CTpaH8X pa3perneHa OlIJIaTa 8KW1i1,l\€J1OBI:lMI'I
Ka'l€C'TB8MJ1 .miLIa, BBe.JJ;eHJ1e B poCCHfiCKOe 38K0H0JJ,8T€JIbCTBO TaKofi
4JoPMb! OlIJIaTbl, ]JyMaeTC.fI, 6bJJ1o 6b! npe:lK,!\espeMeHHbIM, TaR KaR B Ha-
CTo ee speMH npJ1 0TCyI'CTBIm: B 3aKoHe «06 8Rq!WHepHbIX 06lL\eCT-
sax» OTBeTCTB€HHOCTI-I Y"ipe,lJ;J1TeJIeii 3a OI.1;eHKy BKJIa.JJ;OB, BHOCJ1MbIX B
ycraEHbIiii RaIDITaJl, 3TO MO:1KeT IIpHBeCTI'I R 3JIoynmpefineHIDIM. 209
Ha npaKTJ1Ke B03H11KaeTBonpoc 0 TOM, MOryr JIJ1 OrmaIJHBaTbCH 8K-
U1 opra 1OHHhIMi'I pacxO.JJ;aW:! no yqpe:lK,!\eID1lO 8KL\I10HepHoro
06r.qeCTBa. ,lIyMaeTCH, IJ1'O 31'0 B03MO:>KH0 J1 3TO ,AocraTO'ilfO pacnpoCT-
paHeHHoe HBJIeHJ1e Ha npaKTJ1Ke. IIpJ1 3TOM IO.A M€TeJIeBa C'U1Tae-r,
IJ1'O TaKaH rlxJPMa OIIJlaTbI B03MO:>KHa c O)l.ID:!M YCJIOBJ1eM: ::rrn paCXO.qb1
He ,AOJI:>KHbl )'MeHbIIJaTb Ram-rra.rr 06lL\eCTBa HIDKe MJ1HJ1-
MaJIbHOro pa3Mepa, CT. 26 3aKOHa «05 8KL\I10Hep-
HbIX 06l1t£'CTBaX».21o
He.JJ;eHemHa.fl 4xJpMa OnJIaTbl ycTaB1Joro KanJ1TaJIa B03M<»KHa ny-
TeM mreceHWI B ycramn,n:l EaID1TaJI eCTBa,
npas J1JIJ1IfHbIX npas, J1MeJOLqJ1X ,l\eHemHYJO OLleHKY. B CBH3J1 C 3TI1M
HYiKHO }"'J1TblBaTb pa3'bHCHeHJ1e, ,!\aHHoe BbICllli1MJ1 cY,l\e6HbIMJ1 1fH-
CTaImHRIIrn 0 TOM, 'iT{) BKJla)\OM B yc'ffiBHbl11 EaID1Ta.rr He MomeT 6bITb
ofueKT 1IHTe.1U!€Itty8JIbHOiico6cTseHHoc:Tn = «Hoy-xay». BKaqecme
Talwro BKJla,!\a MomeT 6bITb I1pJ13H8J1() npaso nOJIb30saHJ1.fI TaKJ1M ofu-
eK1'OM, nepe.z:tasaeMoe 06r.qecTSY B COO'I'1'IE'TC'Im:cm 11,O-
rDSOpOM, KOTOpblfi ,l:\OmKeH 6bITb 3apel'i'1C'TpHpoBaH B nopH,!!,Ke, npe.!\y-
CMOTpeHIJ'JM 3aKOHO)I,a:reJlbCmoM. 211
B COO'I'BeTCTB1U1 ca63. 2 n. 2 CT. 34 3aKoHa «05 aKL\I10HepHbIX ooILIe-
CTBax» ycraB 06IL1€CTBa MDmeT co,!\epmaTb orpaHWleHl1H Ha BI1,!IbI J1MY-
r.qeCTsa, R01'OpbIM MOryr 6bITb oruraIJeHbI aKL\I1J1 J11J:PyrJ1e QeHHble 6y-
MarJ1 06IL1eCTs8. B OTHOllIeHJ1J1 Kpe,D,11THNX opraHJ13aQl1fi TaKJ1e
-92-
orpaHl1qeHmI YCTaHOBJIeHbI HopMan1BHbThrn a:EITaMJ1 IJ;eHTpaJIbHoro
EaHl\.8.pcp.212
)J;eHemHaH oQeHKa J1M.YU--\eCTBa, BHOCKMoro B OIIJIaTY aKQl1i1 I1pJ1 yq-
pem,zJ;emrn OOIQeCTBa, npoJ--1:3l\OAltI'CH no cornawemno Me yqpe.I\l1-
TeJU1MJ1. IIp''' OIIJIaTe .I\onOJ1H1ITeJlbIIbIX aKQl1i1 He.I\eHemHblMJ1 Cpe.I\CT-
HaMJ1 .I\eHemmm oQeHKa J1MYIQeCTBa, BHOCJ1MOro B ollJlaTY BKQMi1,
npoH3BO;IUI'1'CfI COBeTOM .I\"'peKTOpOB (Ha6,mO,!\aTeJIbHblM COBeTOM) 06-
lQeCTBa B COOTBe'I'C'113H co CT. 77 3aKOHa «06 BKQI10HepHbIX 06IQecT-
sax" (n, 3 CT. 34 TOro:IKe 3aKOHa),
IIp''' onnaTe aKQJm H cpe.D;CTBaMu ,l\J1H o!1pe,!J;eneID1J::r
phIHO'BIOii CTOI1MOC'TII TaKOro J1MYIQeCTBa ,!J;OJDKeH np"'BJIeKaTbC$1 He3a-
Bl-'ICI1Mbrn OQeHlQVlK, eCJU'l miOe He yc'ItIH1BJIf'HO clJe,lJ;ep3.JIbHbIM 3aKO-
HOM. TaKI1M o6pa3oM. cornaweIDfe yqpe,IU1Tenei1 OOIQeCTBa J1 peweHl1e
COBeTa ,lCIpeKTOpoB 06 OlleHKe J1M.YU--\ecTBa ,n;OJ1mHO CJle)J;OBaTb nOCJIe
OlleHKJ1 ero He3aBHCIIMbIM Oll€Hll<J1KOM J1 OCHOBbIBaTbCH H3. ero OT'-IeTe
06 OlleHKe axJTBe"IC"IB)'lOLIJ;ero J1MYIQeCTBa. Benw-rnHa J\eHemHoi1 OlleH-
KJ1J1M)'IlleCTBa, 06IQecTBa J1 COBeTOM
AMpeKTOpoB (Ha6nKJJ\aTeJIbHbIM cOBeToM) 06Il.\ecrBa, He MomeT 6bITb
BbIlile BeJIW.ll1Hbl OQeHKII, I1pOlf:3Be,/J;eHHOJI He31lmlrnMbIM OQeHLIJ;I1KOM.
Ha.n;e.mul yqpeMITeJIei1 npaBOM OlleHKI1 BeLIJ;HbIX BKJI3.AOB, 3aKoH
«06 aKql10HeplibIX 06IQecTBax" He YCTaHaBmmaeT HI1KaKOi1 OTBeTCT-
BeHHOCTl1 3a MX HeI1paBMJIbH)TIO OQeHKY. IIpe,llC'TaBJmeTCH, 'ITO YILlep6,
IIpWIIIH€HHbIi1 aKIU10HepHOMY 06LIJ;eCTBY 3aBbIllIeHHoi1 oQeHKOit: CTOI1-
MOCTI1 npe,!\OCTaBJlHeMoro3a BKQID1, I1pJ1,!J;OIJOJlH]f'TeJIblIOii
:3MJ1CCID1 aKQl1i1 MOmHO B3bICKaTb C 'lJIeHOB COBeTa ,lCIpeKT0poB Ha oc-
HOBaHIrn n. 5 CT. 71 3aKoHa «06 aKQI10HepHbIX OOIQeCTBax".
RIO. EaKllIl1HCKaCOM 6bLJIO BbICKa3aHO MHeIDfe 0
pa3,!J;eneHW! JII1Q, yqacTBy10lltliX B YQpem,l:\eHlli1 aKQMOHepHoro 06IQe-
CTBa Ha yqperoneneii, yqacTB)'lOLIJ;J1X B 3aKJIlOQeHirn JlOroBOpa 0 C03,Ita-
HI1'" o6LIJ;ecTBa (c06cTBeHHO YQperorre.neii) J1 yqpe,wrrenei1, He yqacT-
BYKJIJ.J;I1X B nOCJ1e;zuJeM ( HepOB). OH CQI1TaeT, QTO, nOCl\OJIbK}' B
COOTBeTCTBIDI C 'i. 2 CT. 98 rK pcp J1 n 3 CT. 10 3aKoHa «06 aKQMOHep-
IIbIX OOIQeCTBax" yqpe.IJ;i'IT€JDI HecYT COJ1J1,!\apHyKJ 0TBeTCTBeHH0CTb no
06H31lTeJIbCTaaM, CB.R3aHHblM C C03,l\a1JJ'JEM 06IQeCTBa, B03HJIKaI01QJ1M
11P ero rocy,lWpc-rneHHOi1: perncrpa , ,lJ;orOBOp 0 COBMeCTHJU J1.en-
'I'eJIbHOC'nI,l:\OJl>KHa 3aKJiKJIIaTb TOJibKO ..aCTb Y'-IpeJII'ITeJIeii, HenOCpe,lJ;-
CTBeHHO 3aHJ [xcH eM OOIQeCTBa Pac Ha
aceXJIJ-IQ, yqacTByKJLIJ;J1X B Y'-Ip€»GJ;eHIrn o6LIJ;eCTBa, cTaTyca rre-
JIei1 C03,!J;aeT B03l\f())fQI()C,l\J1H 3JIOynorpe6neHJ1H AOaepJ1eM. Ha npaK-
TJ-IKe B03MomHO Y'-Ipem,rJ;eH"'e OOIQeCTBa C QeJlblO B03J1())I(E'HII,H Ha 0]1.H0-
ro J13 yqpe):\J1T€JIeii o6LIJ;eCTBa O'I'BeTCTB€HHOc'nl no o6H3aTeJlbCTBaM
APyroI'O yqpe.D,JrreJ1H.
-93-
Cne)\OBaTeJIbHO, np" HIDI 8K4MOHepHOro o6r.u;eCTBa B03HJ1-
KalOT pa3J1I1'rnhIXKOMI1J1eKCa - noco 06-
r.u;eCTBa J1 no q.opMI1pOBaHl>no ero yc'ffiBHOCO KaIDfraJIa. <PopMaJlbHhIM
pa3JIl1'-Jl-feM Me Y'-lP rreJl.II:MJ'J I-f aK1V10HepaMl-f .J\OJImHa CTaTb npa-
BOBaflnpl-fpoM 3aKJllO'-IaeMbIX J1Nm.J\oroBOpOB: Y"PE')1; 'lTeJnf 3aKJllO'-IalOT
Mem,zry co6oti./WroBOP 0 C03MID-lli o6r.u;eCTBa, 8 8K'-t"OHepbI 3aKJllO'-IalOT
C Y'-I!x'wrre..1I.IIMH.J\oroBOP IIfI«)6pe'T'€1U-U1 aKWIft 213 1o.A MeTeJleBa nOJi-
HOCTblOpa3,i:\eJlJ1eT3Tyn03 J1C'-1Jt1TaeT BqeJlflXyno-
pH,!:\O'-leHHH OTHOweHJ1i.i, B03frnKalOlL{MXnp"Y'-IPe:)K,!J;eHID'la pHOI'O
06r.u;ecTBa, BBeCm ee WI'()I"(El>E J1OJ)())KeIJJVI B 214
B 3TOM eCTb CMbICJl, nOCKOJibKY nOJl06Hoe l1OBOBEI€,l\€H1'Ie He n03BQJ1J1T
paCIIpOCTJ:l8IDITb Ha )"-IaCTByIOlLJ;I1X JU1Wb B c}xIPMI1pOBaHID1 yCTan-
HOro KanJ1TaJIa 06r.u;eCTBa 0'IB€'TC'I'BeHl no 06J'13aTeJ1bCTBaM, CBfl3aH-
HbIM C C03J1aID:!eM 06r.u;eCTBa.
B npoIJ;ecce ,AeJITeJlbHOCm 06r.u;ecTBa Me IrJCJI€AH>1M J1 ero )"-Ia-
CTHJ1KaMl-f MOryT B03HJ1KaTb, J1, EaK npaBlUIO. B03HI1II'BIOT. npaBOOTHo-
llIeHIDl, CBJ'I3aHHbIe C pacnpe,i:\eJleH"eM <mCT" J1M)'IlJ;eCTBa 06r.u;eCTBa
cpe,i:\w aKQJ1:0HepoB. qacTb J1JIIIyr.u;eCTBa aKLI"OHepHoro 061l1eCTBa nepe-
pacnpe,i:\eJlHeTCRMe o6r.u;eCTBOMJ1 8KQJ1:0HepaMl-f nyTeM oCyrIJ;ecTB-
neHIDIIIOCJIe.D;HI1MJ1 yC'mHOBJleHHOl'O aaKOHO,i:\3.TeJIbCTBOM npaBa Ha no-
J1Y'-IeID:!e
IIpaBO Ha nOJI.Y'-leHJ1€ ,i:\m3"",eH,I\OB, 6e3 COMH€HJ1.R, €CTb caMoe CTa-
pWHHoe J1 cyw;ecTBeHHoe npaso 8KQJ1:0Hepa. HapRJIY C npaBoM H3. nO,i:\a-
qyroJIocaH3.001lleMco6paHIDf J1no.rry'-lelme HHoit:J\OJllf J13
OCTaBllIerOCH nocJle JIJ1KB".!\aw-rnJ-lM)'IlJ;eCTBa. npaso Ha lIIJJI)"J€HIl€ J\"-
BM,ZJ;eH,I\OB, EaK OTMe'-l8.J1 nA Py)J.HeB, OTHOCJ-ITCR K «HaTypaJIbHbIM
npaBaM», TO eCTbTaKl1M, KOTopbIe BbITeIffilOT J13CaMoti npMpOAbI8KL1"-
OHepHblX 06r.u;eCTB. rnaBHaJ'l J1 cyr.u;eCTBeHHaR 'IaCTb B ,lU1Bl-1,!\eH,I\HOM
npaBe, EaK OH yKa3bIB8JI, 3aKJIIO'-IaeTCR B B03Harpam.1l€IDm aKqI1OH€-
pOB 3a BJIO:IKeHHbrn: nOCJIe]:\HJ1MM EaIDIT8JI B npeJIIIPIDITIle. 215
Cor.naCHO n. 1 IIOJiOiKeHIDI «0 llOp.R:.J\Ke BbIllJIaTbI.JU no
8KiV'1RM J1 npou;eHTOB no O 216 JtI'1BI'fJ1€IJ. SlBJU1eTCR <mCTb
'IJlCTOii IIpIJfu.mJI aKQJ1:0HepHOro 061l1ecTBa, IIO,iJ,JI pacnpe,i:\eJle-
ID:!IO cpe,i:\11 aKl.\WJHepOB. npJ CfI Ha 0.IlH)' npoCTytO KJ1Jf npJ-lBJ1-
J1€I1IpoBaHHyIO 8KQillO.
Ha OCHOsaHJ1J1 8HaJl"3a MHeHJ1ti pa3Jm'-lHblX aBropoB B OTHOW€HJ1"
co.n.epmamm npasa H3..JUfBI1.lI€H.D. r.JI. A.D,aMoBJI'-I C.I\eJIaJI BbIBO.II 0 TOM,
'ITO npaBO Ha m:1BJ1lIE'H,IJ" npillwl€HJt'I'€.nbH1 K aKW'lOHepy. npaBKJIbHee
KBam$lqwpoBaTb RaK np"3H3.BaeMbrn: rOcy,AapCTBOM 3al«)JJm:riiJ1HTe-
pee 8KqI10Hepa B no.rry'-leHID:! J\OXO,M OT ,i:\eJITeJlbHOCTJ-I 06r.u;eCTBa B
c}xIpMe J];J1IIIf,l\eH,l\a. pea.1I113aQHR J1 3all\l1T8 KOTopOro rapaHTI1pyKYrCR
JIJ1Wb B onpe,o;eJIftUloii CTeneIDI J1 np" onpe,i:\eJIeHHbIX yCJIOBKRX ('ITO
-94-
no cy:Il\ecTBY aHa.JI()fi1'!HO IfCl1O.JIb3OBaHl1Kl MHorIDfi'l BBTOpar.rn nmrn:-
TIfJ1 «aEic1paK'rHoro-, «ycJ1OBHoro'" npaBa). 217
B COOTBeTC'I'BWI c n 1 cr. 42 3aKoHa «06 aRqIWHepHbIX 06r.u;ecraax»
06r.u;ecTBo BnpaBe no pe3YJ1bTaTaM nepBoro 1\BapTaJ1a, nOJ1yroJUUl, JJ,e-
MTI1 M€Cfl'-leB q.I1HaHCOE1CITJ ro,lta If (IfJ1l1) no pe3YJ1bTaTaM $rnaHCOBO-
ro ro,!¥i npl1lD1MaTb pewem-lfl (o&wrnJIHTb) 0 BblIIJIaTe WUJlJ.!IeH,!\OB no
pa3Mell\eHHbIM aKl.tl1flM, eCJ1I1 J1HOe He YCTaHOBJ1eHO TeM me 3aI<omM.
PeweHl1e 0 BbIIlJ1aTe (o6'Lmu1emm) JJ.MB1-f]J,eH.I no pe3YJ1bTaTaM nep-
8Oro KBapraJIa, llOJIyIU,/J;I!H J1 AeBJITI1 MecHqeB q.11ti3.HCOBOro ro,l\a MO-
:meT 6b1Tb npl1HF!TO B TelleHl1€ Tpex MecflqeB nOCJ1e 01\OHllaHI1$I COOT-
BE"fCTBY101QE'ronepl1o,!ta
PeweHJ1H 0 BbII1JIaTe (06'b.IIBJIeHl1J1) ,/J;I1Bl1,!\el\!\OB, B TOM 'lI1CJIe pewe-
HJ1H 0 pa3Mepe ]J,I1Bl1,!\eH,I\a If $JpMe ero BblJ1J1aTbl no aKl.tl1flM l\am,!\oA
KaTeropl1l1 (TIilla), npl1lD1MaKYrCH 06LIJ;WM oo6paHJ1€M aKQMOHepoB. Pa3-
Mep ,!\MBI1,!\eI\!\OB He M<»KeT 6bITb OOm.we petroM€H,!I,CSaHHOfO COBeTOM
1J:I1PeKTopOB (Ha6J1IOMTeJlbHbIM COBeTOM) 06r.u;ecrBa TaKl1M 06pa30M,
€C.ID1 COBeT 1J:I1PeKTopoB npe)J,JIOJta1JI He BbllIJla'Il1BaTb ,/J;I1Bl1,!\eH,D;bl, TO 06-
ll\e€ cOOpaHl1e al\J.tl10HepoB He MD:>KeT npl1HJITb peweHl1e 06 J1X BbIDJ1aTe.
)J)m11,!\eHJ{b! Bb!l1Jla'Il1BaKITCH J13 'lJ1CTOi1: npl16bLID1 06r.u;€CTl3a. )J;11B11-
,IJ;eH,lJ;b1 no IpOBaHHbIM aKJt!1HM OIIpeJJ.€'JIeHHbIX TI1IlOB TalOKe
MOryr BbllIJIa'lI1BaTbCH 3a C'leT paHee cq.opMl1poBaHHbIX.nIDI:ilTI1X qe-
Jlei1: cneqwaJIbHbIX $JH.!IOB o6r.u;eCTBa KaK npaBI1JIO, no o6bIKHoBeHHbIM
aKQIDIM BbllIJIa'lliBaKITCH 60nee Bb1COKt1\? ,l\l1Bl1,!\eH,lJ;bl, 'leM no IlpiBILIIE'-
I11pOBaHHblM. IIpl1BJ1Jl€n1p(E3lIHH€ aK'-\ID1 OTJII1<IalOTCH OT ofu,nrnoB€fJ-
HbIX TeM, 'lTO pa3Mep JI;ImImeHJJ.B. no HI1M 06bl'lH0 qnlKCl1pyeTCH B ycra-
BeJ1He3aBl1cI1TOTI3€JIK'D1HbI 06l1\€cTBoMnpI16bLID1.KpoMe
TOro, B 3aKOHe IIpeJJ;yCM:YIpe B03MOmHOCTb BbIlI.YCKa n:pI1BIfJI€nq>D-
BaHHbIX aK1V1t1, pa3Mep ,/J;I1Bl1,!\eH,!I;DB no KOTOpbIM He yt"I'aR)BJ1€H YCTa-
80M J1 J1X BJIa,I\eJlb'-\bl n0JJY'i3.KIT ]J,I1BI1,!\eH,It HapaBHe C BJIaJ\eJlbqaMI1
aK1V1i1.
CJ1eAYeT OTMeTI1Tb, 'lTO 06utee c06palD1e J1J1I1 COBeT 1J:I1PeKTopoB
mtpaBe BbIHeCTI1 peweHJ1e 0 HanpaBJ1eH11l1 scei1: npl16blJrn: 06r.u;eCTBa Ha
pa3BJmlerrpm13BU,IJ;CTBa,CCQJ ,lIOKpb1TJle
Henpe,lUll1,!\eHHbIX y6b1TKOB J1APyrne qeJ1I1, a He Ha BbIIIJIary 1BJ1,!J;eIWJB.
B pOCCJ1I1CItOM 3aKOHO,!WTeJIbCTBe npaBO 'I'pe60BaTb BbIIlJ1aTbl He-
o&bHBJIeHHbIX npHMO He np€.IJ;yCM.1'IpHO. O,l\Ha1\O al\J.tl10-
Hep BnOJ1He MC»KeT 00maJ10BaTb ItaK peweH£fe COBeTa JJ.I1peKTOpoB, ec-
JlI1 0$1 C'lI1TaeT. '1TO COBeT ,IJ;l1peKTopoB Heo6ocHOBaHHO npHHHJI
peweHl1e 0 HeBbIDJIaTe ,lJ,HBJl,!\fti,I:\OB, Tate J1 peweHl1e 06ll.\ero co6J:6HJUL.
II03TOMY aKIVlOHepa B STOM eJ1Y'13€ ,IJ;0J1:>KHbI6b1Tb cJ1e,Il}'lO-
Il.{!1M11: 06fl3aTb COBeT 1J:I1PeKTopOB pac<:MO'I'peTb yKa3aHHbrn: Bonpoc 0
-95-
BbIIIJIaTe ,W1Bl1,!\eH)J;OB, B YJKe 3aTeM, B c.nyqae npIHHI'KH JiM:peIIl€ffiUI
06 OTKa3e B BbII1JlaTe. OOmaJIOBaTb ero.
llcxoJI.H J13 JJ.JlH ooecne'lemrn 3arqwThI I1HTepecOB aK-
LtHOHepOB J.I('J1€(.'OO6po 3al<pffD1Tb B YCTaBe o6ll1ecTBa l1OJ)())f(€fBI€,
06J13b1BalOllIee COBeT l1"})eKTOpoB paCCMaTPI-1BaTb " mlHOCI'1Th Ha pe-
rneID1e o6ll1ero c06paID1J1 a pC)B Bonpoc 0 BbillJIaTe ,W1Bl1,!\eH,!\OB
no J1CTe'leHJ1J1 onpe,lJ;eneHHOro cpoKa. IIpJII HapyweHJlIJ1 o6IQeCTBOM Ta-
KOro CpOKa aKQl-fOHepbI nOJ1Y'ffi1OT BOOMOm11OCTb 06paTJ1Tbcfl B cY,IJ;.
B 3aKOH0l1aTeJIbCTBaX iJoJa.wJmcTsa 3apy6eiKHbIX C1p8.H npaao H3.
,W1BJ1,!\eH;J,b1 nl160 B006ll1e He 3aKpl'llJ1€HO. nl160 npe.nycMOTpeHbl 803-
MDmHOCTI'l AJ1J1 ero orpaID1'-1eID1Il pernemleM c06paID1fl arotIf(IlJepOB. IIo
3aKOHOl1aTeJIbC'TBY p C1p8.H TaKoe pern€Hi-'Ie, 8 T8lCKe OTKa3 COB€'Ta
1\I-'IpeKTOpoB o&wmJ1Tb BbII1Jlary ,lI,IfBIf,!\eIJOB MOryr 6bITb OcnOpeHbI B
CYl1e. HaJlI60JIee Ha)J;e*Ho 3all\l-fi-ll;eHbI HHTepecbI BKrC10HepOB B IIopry-
I'aJIID-I, rl1e perneID1e 0 HeBbII1JlaTe rO,!J;oBbIX ,IJ;I1BJ1.lI;eH,!J;OB MDm€T npl1HJII-
MaTbCH TOJIbKO KBaJII 1JXEaHHbIM 6o.rrbIllI1HCTBOM rOJIOCOB, B fep-
MaHID-I, rJJ;e 3aKOHo,!J;aTeJIbCTBO rapaHTl-1pyeT aKi{YIOHepaM nOJIy'-IeHJII:e
Ai-1Bl1,!\eH,!\OB B pa3Mepe He M€Hee 4% CTOIIMOC'I1I aKW1Ji, a TalOfCe B III:se-
QID1" I"bJ1HJIHH,l{J:U1, me aKl{JUJHepbI, npe lO%I'IJJIJCyID-
rqwx 8Kq1-1M, MOryr ncrrpe60BaTb pa B KaqeCTBe }J;IIBII)J.E!H-
AOB nQJ10BMHbI npl16bIJIJ1 06ll1eCTBa (HO He 6<JJ1ee 5"(. ero KanJ1TaJla).2tO
B qeJUIX o6ecne<relDlH rapaHTlfJXEillilfOC npasa BKQl-fOHepOB Ha
Ai-1Bl1,!\eH,!\ r.Jl MaMOBWI npe)J.Jl8ra€T BHeCTJI! B 3aKOH «068Ku;J1oHep-
HbIXo "I13MeH€HlliI, npe,D;yCMaTpJlIBalOll\I-'!enpHMoe31IKp€IIJIe-
HJ1e B HeM MJ1HI-IMa.JIbH: pa3Mepa ,W1Bl1,!\eH,!\OB (B npoQeHTax OT 'l!:1ClUit:
npJlI6bIJIJII OOllleCTBa), nO,lVlemalII;JlIX BbIIIJ1aTe npJl! HaJIJlI'lJIIJII Y oOlllecTBa
'lJ1CT(JII npJlI6bIJIJII " J1HbIX OO'beKTI1BHbIX 4nrnaHcoBbIX nOKa3aTeJIeM.
O&bJmJIeHJ1e B B TaKOM pa3M€p€ ,lJ;0J1*H0 npai3OO.Z1.I1TbCJI Ha
oOllleM ro,!J;OBOM c06paH11JlI aKi{YIOHepoB no TPe50BaIDOO aKQl-fOHepoB,
BJIa,ZJ;elOlII;JIIX B COBOKJflIHOCTII aKWIHMJI!, aJCTaBJIJIl(]II CBbIllIe 1% yc-
TaaHoro Ka!1HTaJIa, .mroo aBTOMa'IWleCKJ1. B OTHOrneHJ1J1 npJ1BJ1I1eI'I1pO-
BallllbIX aKQl-fM, pa3Mep ,W1BJ1,!\eH,!\OB no KOTOpbIM B YCTaae,
CJie.LIYeT. no ero MH€HJDO. )'CT<\IICI3J1Tb. 'ITO pEUIeHJI!e 0 HeBbII1JlaTe JlIJIJI!
HenOJIHoti: BbIll.I1aTe ,W1BJ1,!\eH,!\OB M<»KeT 6bITb npHHF!TO J!IIIWb B cnyqae
O'K')'TC"IEIIH I-fJllf He,!J;OCTaTKa 'lJ1CTOM IIplroblJ1H, KOTOpafl M<»KeT 6bITb B
COO'I'I!eTCTBJIJII C 3aKOHOM pacnpe,!\eneHa B Ka'iecTBe AI- 219
OmOCJI!TeJlbHO np"poAbI npaaa aKIVIDHepa Ha ,lJ;JlIBJ1,!\eH,Zl; 0.M PO,lJ;-
HOBa BbICK83aJIa MHeHJ1e, 'ITO OHO 06n8):\aeT OTnWlJlIT€nbHbIMl-1 npJl!3Ha-
KaMJI!, KOTopbIe He n03BOJ1J'JlOT paCCMaTpJlIBaTb ero KaK OOJ13aTeJlbCT-
Belllloe. ORo B03HI-1KaeT J13 peWeHJIIH o6ll1ero co6pamrn BKu;J10HepoB,
8Ku;J10Hep MOJKeT 6bITb He cornaceH c pa3MepOM ,!\I'1BJ1)J.€H.!J;OB. CpOKOM
J1X Bb!ILJ1aTbI, C i¥JPMOM HX BbillnaTbJ. O,!J;HaKO npaso Oy,ueT COO'IBe'TC'T-
-96-
BOBaTb He BOJIe aKQI'X)HE'pa, a BOJIe 6o.m.nmHcTsa, nporo.rrOCOBaBiliero
3a peilielille. AEQlKHeP He BCerAa l1MeeT npaBO TpeOOBaTb Bb!I1J1aTbl
A<l'KE' o6'hHBJIemroro ,[I11B11,!\eH,!\a. Cy,w,6a aKqMOHepHOro npaBa 3aBMCwr
OT pe3YJ1bTaTOB ,[IewreJ1bHOCrn M cy,l:tb6b1 npeJ: npmrI'Jff!.220
)J;.B. JIoMaKIDI COBepiliemIQ cnpaBe,[\Jll'lBO no.naraeT, 'ITO npaBO Ha
,[\I1BM,!I;eH,!\ cyrn;eCTnyeT 11 ,[10 o&bsm.rremm ,wmJf.!\eH,,!l;OB, HO RaK npaBO
000601'0 pO,!!,a - '1JIeHCKOe J1J111 KopnopamBHoe npaBO, KOTopoe HeJIb3.R
OTH€CTM 1111 K BeIqHbINI, HM K OOR3a'reJIbCTBE'HHbl npaBaM. TOJIbKO no-
TOM)', 'ITO aKqwOH€p MMeeT KopnopaTI1BHOe npaso Ha ,[\J1BI1,[\€H,[I, snoc-
ne.r:\C'TBlfJl OH MruKeT npM06peCTM If o,r:J;lJOIfMeHHOe 06R3aTeJ1bCTB€HHoe
npaBO. CYIl\ecTBye-r T8KiKE' lIpOI13I3O,lJ;HOE' OT Hero npaBo Ha ,[\I1Bl1,!\eHA
DBo 503lillKaeT C MOMeina yrBep)K,D;elillR oOlL{IoIM c06paHl1eM KOHKpe-r-
Horo pa3Mepa J1 i¥JpMb1 ,[\I1Bl1,!\eH;:J;OB. IIocJIe 31'Oi'0 YaKlV-foHepa B03I111-
MeT OOR3aTeJIbCTBeHHOe npaBO Tpe60BaHIDI BblIIJIaTbi KOHKpeTHOi111.e-
H€)KH()ji C)'MMb!. IIpaso Ha W B aTOM CJI.Y'lae MO::ttHO Ha3BaTb
Kpe.l\IITOpCKl1MI1JIJ1 M3J13JI»f\'EHHOI8BTop,[le.naeT
BbIB011., 'lTO, nOCKOnbKy cyrn;eCTByKlT TJ.Ba B O)J;HOMMeHHblX npas Ha
,[\I1BM,!I;eH,!\ - aKqwOHepHO€ (11JIJ1 KopnOpaTJ1BHOe, QJIeHCKoe) M OOR3a-
TeJIbCTBeHHOe, TO M peaJll13yK1TCR OHJ1 B paMKaX 1l{I1X
npaElOOTHOOIeHJrli - aKLII10HepHoro M oOH3aTeJ1bCTSeHHoro. 221
RaK npe.l\CTaBJlJleTCH, ,[10 MOMelITa OO'bJlBJleHl1.H 061l\ecTSOM 0 BbIIIJIa-
Te ,[\I1Bl1,[\eH,!\OB npaso 8KW1oHepa Ha ,[\I1Bl1,[\eH,!\ IIpeJ:J;C"ffiBJ co60i1 He
'lT0 ","De, RaK npaso Ha pEllIelille Ha oOll\eM co6paHIDI aKQrroHepOB 50-
npoca 0 pac.npep;e.neHIDl npl>16blJUf OOll\ecTBa. YlGl3aHHOMY npaBY KOppe-
CIIoH,l{!1JJYeT OOH31lHHOCTb oOmecTBa Bb1HeCTI:! paCClOO"rpeHJ:le Bonpoca Ha
oOll\€€ co6paIDIe. TarofM oOpa30M, npaso Ha 1J:illllfJ1eHJ111.0 MOMelITa 061,-
HBJIeHIDI 0 ero Bb!I1J1aTe CBJl38HO C ynpaB.JIEHR£!I' aKQI1Oll€PHblNl 061l\ecT-
BOM If I€ S'I'Oro HOCIIT KDpJ1OpaTJofBliblfl xapaKTep. 06"b€KTOM
malO CfI KOpIICpa"I11BHb1X OTHorneHIDi HBJIfleTCfI ynopMO<J€H-
HDCTb, IR D"IEIXIEHui1no BbIIlJ1aTe 06Il\ecTSOM,WmI1,[\€H,!\OB.
.npyroe 11.eJIO, €Cm-I oOll\€€ co6paInfe npl1lliLl1o COOTBeTCTByKlll.\€e pe-
IlIeIDIe J1 061l\€CTBO ofuJrnJ1J10 0 BbllIJ1aTe ,[I11B1f,!1,€E,11p3.. TOI118 CKJIa,JJ;bIBa-
IOll\eeCfI Me1i\,l:\y 061l\eCTBOM VI aKL(!WHepOM npaBO(1I'HOlIl€le HBJl./ieTCJ'I
IM npJ1M€poM 06R3aTE'JIbCTBa. AKlV'IOHep l1MeeT npaso Tpe-
60BaTb OT 061l\€CTBa BbIIIJIaTbl 06"bHBJ1eHHbIX TJ.IffiI 061l\€CTBO
06H3aHo J1X SbllL!1aTI1Tb; B CJIy<Jae, €CJII1 OHO 31y 06H3aHHOCTb He VICIIOJI-
HfIeT, 8KQI10Hep BnpaBe TpeOOBaTb Bb!I1J1aTbi B B CY;zJ;e6HOM
nOpR.ll;Ke. KcTaTIl, B CBH311! C aTl1M E.E. ,nOJIJI!HCKaJI OTMe<JaeT, 'ITO nORa
ell\e ,[\I1CKyTl1py€TC.II Bonpoc 0 npaBOBOM 0CI0:!aIDIJ1 TaKoro VICKa: OTHO-
CJITCfI m-I oH K J1CTpeOOBaffi1]() J1MYI--II;eCTBa J13 qymoro He3aK1JHH:I'O BJIa-
,IJ;eHl1.H (CT. 301 I'R P )11JIJ13TOHE' O)J;HOCTOpoHHeroOTKa-
3a ar JIC'IDnH€IDIR 06R3aTeJIbCTBa (CT. 310 I'R P ). 222
-97-
0fu.eKrnMH: OO.R:3aTeJIbCTBeHHOrO OTHOilieffi1.R:6yiJYf }J,eiiC'TBIUl oprn-
HOB OOll\ecTBa Henocp€1J;CTB€HHO no BhlI1.11a:re ,D;I-fIDfJ];€H,.!\OB (HaIlpIIMep.
n€ 1('.JI{'lIJI£' cyMMhl B pa3M€P€ Ha3Ha'l€HHOro K Bh1IIJIaTe ,[I11BM,[\€H,!\a
Ha 6aJnroBClGfi,i C'-J€T aK1U10Hepa - IOpu,IU1'1€CKOrO JllllQa) JI ,[\€H€:>KHhI€
Cp€,[\CTBa B BI1J\€ BhII1Jla'lMBa€Moro ,lI;Mmf,ZJ;€H,[\a.
B paCCMaTp>maeMOM CJI.Y'lae KOpIIopaTI1BHOe JI OO.R:3aTt'JlbC'I'lJ€HH
OmOIlI€HJ1.II, 1eCF! 110 noBO)Iy npaBa aKIVIOHepa Ha nOJ1Y-
'1€Hl-1€,l];MBIq\eH,D;a. COOTHCiCffi'C51 M€:lKJ\Yco60i1 KaKOpraHl JI
opraHM3Y€MO€ OTHOIlleHIIK.
Ha OOJ'l3aT€JIbCTB€HHhIi1 xapaKT€p 0TII0Il1€f001 B JI ofJIl,\€-
CTBaCMOM€HTa ID1J1,lJ;MBJ1,11;eHJ10BYR<i3bIBa€THB.IlM030J111H.223
IT.A. PY,/J;H€B TalOKe C'fMTaJi, 'ITO «C MOMeHTa yreep:)K,!J;eHHH 6aJiaH-
ca opr3HaMH TOBapJ1I.J.\eCTBa JI pacnpe,ll;eJ1€HJ1.II,lIJIBJ1,l!;eH,l\a K 113
aKIU10Hepos nOJ1y'-IaeT npaso, pasHoe Kpe,ll;J1TopcKOM)'. Ha npeTeH3illO
K TOS3pl1Lll;eCTBy Ha onpe.D;e.TIeHH)'JO C)'MMY npWllITalOll\erOCR Ha ero
,lI;OJlIO ,w1BI1,!\eH,D;a, HO npaBO 3TO OTJrn'laeTCR OT Kpe}J.MTopcRoro TeM, 'ITa
B.m060e BP€M.R: MOJoKeT 6hITh ClCyIQ€CTBJI€HO. KpoMe CJI.Y'laeB, KOr,[la no-
CTaHOBJI€HI1€ 06ll\ero coopaHJIF! J1J111 .D;pyroro opraH3 TOBapl1Lll;€CTBa, B
Be)\eHID1 KOTVporo HaXOJ(J1TCR pacnpe,ll;eJ1eHl1e IIpIwnli. OTJlmtOIT Ha
JI3BeC'I'1ftdi CpOK BhII1Jl3TY ,[IJIIBl1,!\eH.Q3.; npaBO 3KIU10Hepa Ha HeOIIJIa-
'1eHHhIi1 ,[\J1B11,!\€H,IJ; :HBJ1jIeTCH npaBOM Kpe,[\J1TOpCIU1M, He MQm.eT OhITh
3HHYJlI1poBaHO ,[\ajK€ npl1 O&hJm.neHJ:BI KOHKypca JI ,[IOJDKHO nO,1VleJKaTb
y,l\OBJI€TBOp€H11IO He nocne. a HapH.Qy co BCeMJII llpo'il1MJ11 Kpe,[\J1TapaMJII
TOBapl1ll\€CTBa».224
RaK Kpe,ll;J1Topa OOll\eCTBa, OOJl3JJ;iI1:I1Q€1'O npaBOM Ha ID.JIY'IeHMe
m OO COOpam-l€M ,lI;J1B11,!\€H,IJ;a, KOTDpOM)' B I1OJ1Y'I€HIDl
,w1Bl1,!\eH,!\a H€ MD:lKeT OhITh OTKa3aHO BCJle,ll;CTBl1e OTCyrcTBIDI CP€,!\CTB
Y OOIl\€CTBa. paCCMaTpHSaJi aKI.\MOH€pa TaKiK€ 11 J1. BpaY,ll;e 225
CpOR If nopMOR BhII1JlaTbI,ll;l-fBlf,ll;€ onp€,lI;€J1.moTCfI ycT3BOM 06-
Il\€CTSa IfIDI p€IlIeID:!€M OOIl\€ro coopamrn aKQI«JH€POB 0 BbIIIJlaT€ ,[111-
BJ1;:J;eH,.!\OB.
3aKOHOM «06 aKQIJOHepHhIX 06IQecTBax» H€ onp€,!\eJlJieTc.R: MecTO
BhII1JlaThl ,[\IIBJI,I:\€H)J;OB. ,UyMa€TCR, 'ITa B 3TOM CJI.Y'lae MO:)KHO J1CUOJlh-
30BaTh HOpMhl CT. 316 fK p 0 M€CT€ J1cnOJ1HeHJfF! OO.R:3aT€JlbCTBa
)J;Mm OOhI'lHO Bhmna'lMBalOTCH A€HhraMJ1; HO, KaK CBMJle-
TeJlhCTByeT IT.A. Py,;u;HeB, «03Ha'leHHbrl1 nOpJ'l,!\OK CJX»KI1JICfI He cpaay:
B CTapl1HHhrx al\1-IJ10H€pHhlX KOr.maIDI.R:X ,D;I-fBI1,!\€H,lI; BhIIIJIa'lMBaJiC.R: Ha-
TYPoi1:, C ,[IeH€>KHcli OQE'HKOII, B KaKOBOi1: cYMMe OR llJXII-I3BO}J;J:1JICH no
6aJ1aHcy IIp{'AllpnHTIUi, H3 OCHOBaIDnI onpe,!\eJ1eHJ1R 'lJ1croi1: ero IIpI1-
6hlJIJ13a COOrneTCTB)'KIIIJ;ID1 ollepaqJ1OHHIilll ro,!\».226
BhIIIJ1aThl AI1BMeH,l\OB He}J.€HhffilVlJl BCTpe'-1alOTC.R: He 'l3CTO J1 MOryr
npOI-lCXO,D;l-fTh no pa3HhlM npWlI-lHaM. HeyCT0I1'-1HBocT1-I 4>I-IHaHCOBOro
-98-
no.rrO:IKeHI1H 061l1eCTBa, HeOOXO,/J;l'1Ml:CTH wm 061l1eCTBa HepaCnpe;n;e-
nemlOtf npl16b!J1I1, meJlaHl1$1061l1eCTBa Ha)1eJIl1Tb pa60THl11WB aEQl15IMH
J1 TaK ,lWJIee. B.m060M c.nyqae, BfJ3MCQKH0CTb BbIIIJIaTbl ro:lBKJW OB B
TaROii clxJPMe AOJDKHa 6bITb n B YCTaBe 061l1eCTBa.
Hil Mo3o.rr"'H OTMe'laeT, "'TO C KOHOMM'leCKot1 TO'lKI1 3peHM,WI-
ID1,ZI;eH,!{bi, BbIIIJIa'lliBaeMbieBclxJPMeaKIVrl1,]J;I BCo6cTBE'IJ-
HOM CMbICJIe CJIOBa He f!BJ1J'IIOTC$I, TaR KaR OH'" npe,!\OCTaBJ1J'IIOT aKWIO-
HepaM n"'IIIb npaBO Ha no.rrY'IeH"'e 6y IIJIaTemei-i 227
Cne,DyeT OTM€TIITb, 'ITO J1 4:lK1$ p He p€I\OM€H,.I:J;OB8JIa 8KW10Hep-
HbIM 06ll1ecTBaM BblIIJ1a"lI1BaTb 1BHlt€HlI.bI nyreM H8J1.eneHJ1J'I aRlU'ICEe-
pcm aKQMIIMl>1, ,l\OI1OJ1lI11'T BbmyCKaeMbIMI>1 06l1\eCTBoM J1 OIIJIa'lJ1-
naeMbIMI1 3a C'I€'T 'lI1CTOi1 lIpIffu.Lmi. C yqeTOM ID1KBI1,JJ;HOCTI1 3TI1X
aKlIl1i1, J1X pbI1D'llIOfi C'IOJ1MOCTJ1 J1 CBR3a.1IIWX C HJ1M11 06$13aTeJIbCTB no-
.ny'-IeHl1e Talrnx aKW1i1 MO:IKeT He I1pl1BeCTI1 K yBeJIll'ieHIDO furarOCOCTO-
RHJ1H aK OHepa. KpoMeTOro, B TOMc.nyqae OH, nocyrn:, nl1LIIaeTCH ca-
M1JC"IOH'I'eJIbH(X;ll1pl1npl1H.H= pellleIDdi.IIo:ITOMY
061l1eCTBY HE' CJIe)J;yeT paCCMa"I'pI1BaTb KaK BbIILmuy ]J;IlBu.n;€H,!J;OB 11p11-
HRTI1e peW€H11H ° HanpaBJIeHl1J1 ,!\eHemHbrx cpeACTB, npe.I\Ha3HaQeH-
HbIX WIH Bb!ILJlaTbi JJ;Imlf,l\€H}J,()B, Ha )'B€JiJ'I'I€HJI€ pa3Mepa YCTaBHoro Ka-
IDITana nYTeM }J.OIIOJIHI1T€JbHOrO BbIIIyCKa J1 pa3MeIQeHJIH cpe;n;11
aKW1oHepoB 8KqID1: Ha CYMMY IIpI1'rnTalOll\I1XCH J1M P,I1BJ1,!1;eH,r\OB (n. 2.1.2
fJL 9 KO;n;eKC8 KopnOpaTI1BHoro nOBe)\eHIDI ).228
KaK OTM€'iaeT T.B. KawaID1Ha, Ha 8KW1oHepe ne:>Kl1T npe;:J;npmrn:-
Ma-re.YThCK11if pI1CK, IX)ClI'OJIbKY ypoBeHb wmI1,!\eH,!I;1l no 8KQlli1M Mo:meT
OKa3aTbCH HI1:IKe ypoBHH ;D;OXO,!\a aJIbTepHaTI1BHbIX clxJPM nOMemeHl1H
Kam-rraJIa. 229
)J;ei1CTBI'IT€JIbHO, C TI1M CJI€JIYeT corJlaCI1TbCH, IIOCB'OJIbKY pa3Mep
ro: nOJUlOCTblO 3aB1CJ'JT OT pe3YJibTaTOB ;D;eJffeJ1bHOCTU J1 yc-
MOTpeHJ1J'I B cI1J1Y TOro, "'TO MillIJ1MaJIbHbll1 pa3Mep ,WIBI1-
;D;eHJIOB 3aKOHO)\aTeJIbHO He YCTaHOBJIE'IJ, Bee norn.rrKI1 aKQI10HepOB
06$13aTb 061l.\€CTBO K ynJIaTe onpe,!l;eJleHHoro pa3Mepa AJ.1B>1,ZJ;eH,r\OB 6e-
3ycnenrnbI, "IeMY B ap6wIpamHoi1: npaKTWKe J1MeeTCfI ;D;OCTaTO'IHO MHO-
ro l1pJ1MepOB.
TaR, OAO «CTaHKoarperaT» 06paTJ-IJ10Cb B A cy,!\ ro-
po,!\a MOCKBbI C I1CKQM R 3AO o<TexocHaCTKa» ° B3UCKaHID:I C OTBeT'rn-
Ka B nOJIb3y "'CTL\8 3a,!\OJDKeHHOCT'" no BbiliJIaT€' ,D,IlBIi,IJ;{'H)J;OB no npl1Bl1-
JlempOBaHHbIM aK1V-'1$1M 3a nep"'o,!\ oKT.H6pb-,!\eKa6pb 1998 ro,!\a B
cYMMe 9077 ;D;OJIJIapoB CIlIA, 'ITO B py6,rreBoM 3KBI1BaJi€HT€ COCTaBJIH-
no 266 319 py6. 18 ROIl.
PeIIIeHl>1€M Ap6IITpIDKHOro CY,!l;1l ropo,!\a MocKBbi OT 18.10.2001, OCTaB-
neHHbIM fie3 I13M€HeHIDI nOCTaHOBJIeHI1eM &:I€J1.JIJIIUtCHHCH IIHCI'aIiWDI
roro:Hre CY1J.a OT 24.122001 no 1J.e.Try NQ A40-33. ' }88jOl-23-421, B I1CKe
-99-
DAG .. o c3AG..aeXOCHac=»9077110JlJl
CIllA 6W1O arKa3aHO.
He corJIaCmmrnCb c pellieIDIeM OT 18.10.2001 H lIOC'ffiHOBJI€lll'1eM OT
24.12.2001 DAD «CTaHlwarperaT» 06paTJ1J10Cb BtPellelx\.-'1bJ1b] ap6I-fT-
pamHbrn: cy,!!; MOCKOBCKOro oKpyra c KaccaIV1OHHoo . B KOTO-
JXJ:M npoCWlO y<ta3aHHble aKTbl OTMeHm'b J1 B3blCKaTb C OT-
BeT'IHKa B nOJIb3Y HCTLta 3a,D,OJI)1«'HR no BbmJIaT€ ,lI,I1m1,!J;eH,!\OB no
npl'DocrrerllpOBaHHbIM 8KltW1M 3a nepHO,!!; OK'I'H6pb-lIeKa6pb ISJ9a ro,zw B
c)'MMe 9077 1I0JlJI. CIlIA
0rKa3bIBaF! B YlIOBJIeTBOpemlJ1 3aF!BJ1eHHoro I-1CRa, CYlI nepBo HH-
CTaHqI-fH )'R83aJ1. 'ITO I1CTeLt flBJIF!eTCF! co6cTBemnmoM 10 npIffiIt.rrempO-
saHHbIX 8KW1:M OTBeT'Il1Ka HOMJni8.1IbHoK CTOIIMOC"IbIO 58929 py6.
60 Kon. Kam,!\8F!I1BCOOTBeTCTBJ1I.-I C n. 117 YCTasa 3AG «TexoCHaCTRa»
B.II8)J.eJIbQaM npl1BI1JIel11pOBaHHb!X 8KLtHi1 E?KeMeCWfHO BbIILJIa'll1B8eTCJ'I
lIWB"lIeH;J; B pa3Mepe 500 1I0JIJI. CIllA 3a OllH)' 8KqJOO. DlIHaKO arBeT'-J11K
npe)J;CTaBI1JI npOTOKOJI o6ll-\ero cd'paIDm8KW1oHepoB OT 15.12.1998, co-
r.naCHO Karop0M)' OllJ1aTa l\I'1BIl)J.€HJ:\OB 1lpCB:13BO,JJ;iITCJI B pa3Mepe 500 y.e.
no KypCy 8 py6. 3a OllH)' yCJ10BH)'K) e.JU1mw.y. YKa3aHHoe peweHl'ie co-
6paHI'iJ'I 8K4110HepOB He 0CIq)€ID B YCTaHOBJreHRIl'l nOpR.D;Ke.
IIoBTOpHO paCCMlnpllBAA lIeJIO, CYll aneJlJIJiLtItOHH HHCTaHLtID'l OT-
KJI0Hl'iJ1110BOlIbl "CTIW- J1 np:I13HaJI BepHbIM npl'iMeHelllfe CYllOM nepsoii
HHCTaHLtID'lHOpMMaTepI1a.JIbHoronpaBa.Ka I1HCTaHql1J'ITaK-
me OCT8BI1JIa >Ka.IIo6y DAD «CTaHKOaiperaT» 6ea YlIOBJI€TBopeHI'iJ'I.230
CillfCOK.lII>-ll-\, l'iMe1Oll-\MX np8BO nOJIy'-JeHI'iJ'I l\I COCTaB,lliIeT-
CH Ha ,zwTY COCT8BJIeHI'iJ'I CITJ1CKa .JIJ1II;, l'iMe1Oll-\MX np8BO )"-JaCTBOBaTb B
06ll-\eM co6pamrn: aKLtJ10H€JXJB, Ha KOTOpOMnpHH11M8eTCH pellleID-Ie 0 Bbl-
ruJaTe COOTBeTCTBY1Oll-\MX ,lI,I ,lJ;.mI COCTaBJ1eHI'iJ'I CIll1CKa .lII>-ll-\,
1X npaso no.ny'!€lDm ,lI,I{m1,!J;€lW)B. HOMIfH8J1bHb1ft lIepiKaTeJ1b
aKqwH npe,!!;CTaBJUleT lIIDIHbIe 0 JllfLt8X, B HH'I'epecax KOTOpbIX OH BJ18,1J;e-
€T8KqI1JIMM (003. 2 IL 4 CT. 42 3aKOHa «06 8KLtJ10HepHbIX 06ll-\ecrnax»).
B cJIY'Iae, eCIDI OT'-JYm,!\eHHe 8KlV'D-'1 npOHCXO.JU1T nOCJ1e npHWITl-fJ'I
penreHl1J'I 0 BbIITJ1aTe l\IU!lfl\€HJ1OB, 11 COOTBeTCTBeHHO. COCT8BJ1elllfJ'I
CmlCKa Jll1L\, I npaBo Ha nOJI)"-JeHJ1e lIWBI1,IJ;eH;J;OB, npJ106peTa-
TeJIb 8KL\J1tf no CMblCJIY 3aKOHa He nOJ'l}"-JaeT BMecT€ C 8K1V1efi npas.a sa
nOJly'-JeID-Ie ,D;J:1BI1,!J;eH.Zta. Dp;H8KO 3TO IIpOnmope<n1T lIIJJ1())K{'IDUIM 'I. 1
CT. 142 fK p , COrJIaCHO KOTOP0M)' C nepe)J;a'le:M LteHHO:M 6)'M8rn nepe-
XOWlT Bce YlIoCTOBepJ'IeMble e10 npasa B COBOK)'TIHOCTJ1. A YiKe npO,!I,8B-
llll1:M caOJ1 8KqJ1J16bIBIIDri1 8KLtJ10Hep TepJ'IeT npaBo H8 nOJl)"-JeHJ1e 1IJ1-
Bl1,JJ;eH;J;a B CJ1J1Y TOro, '1TO nepecTaeT 6bITb )"-JaCTHI1KOM 8KL[!100epHoro
06ll-\eCTBa. ,lJ;.mI npeo):\OJIeHI'iJ'I 3TOro npOTI-lBope'll1R Heo6xo.JU1MO BHeCTJ1
B 3aKOH «06 8KW10HepHbIX 06ll-\eCTBax» ,
-100-
BHeCeHl1e J13MeHeHJdi B CrrnCOK JII1IJ;, J1MelOlI{I1X npaBO Ha nOJIY'leHl1e
--
BceM BJIa.n;eJIbLjaM 8Ku;ID1. nOIIaBllll1M B crmcOK 8Ku;J10He}:X:IB, J1MelO-
lltI1X npaBO Ha,lJ;JfBJf,!\€H,!1.. npW'UrraeTCH ,lII1Bu,IleH,D; B O.n;l1HaKOBOM pa3-
Mepe Ha aKLtMlO O)J;lIOi1 KaTerop1111 J1 n-ma, He3aB1«:J1MO OT TOro. KaKDe
BpeMJIOlD1 I.HBJlflJII1CbaKqHOHepaMl1.
B cn)"-Jae, ec.nJ1 YCTaBOM OOI1leCTBa CpOK BblIlJ1aTbI ,lUfBl1,!J;elJ,!J;OB He
onpe,lleneH, CpoK J1X BblI1J1aTb! He ,lJ;OJDKeH npeBb!llIaTb 60 AHei1 CO.AllJ1
npI1HHTI1R}X'Wt:'HlI.HOBbIIIJIaTe (n4cT.423aKoHa «068K-
ltI10HepHbIX diIuec'max»).
YCTaHOBJIelD1e 3aKOHOM «06 aKu;J10HepHbIX oOI1lecTBax» J1 YCTaBoM
npe.n;e.JrbHUI'O CpOKa BbU1J!aTbl,wIBI1,!\eH,!:\OB ,i:\3.eT 8Ku;J10HepaM B03MO:>K-
HOCTh npl1 HeBl>JI1011HeHII OOI1leCTBOM CBOefi 06R3aHH0CTI1 B CpOK Tpe-
60BaTb B3bICKaHJm C 06I11eCTBa He TOJIbKO OCHOBHOII cyMMbl.n;OJiI'a, HO J1
npOQeHTOB 3a npocpO'-JKY J1CfiOJiHeHl1H .n;eHeiKHoro OOJ13aTeJ1bCTBa Ha
0CH0BaHIDI CT. 395 rK P<1:I
EcJUr 06ll\ecTBo He BbIlIJla'illBaeT 8KW10Hepy ,n:IfBJ E'H,!:J;H, TO nOMM-
MO npe.n;'bJIBJleHl1H Tpe60BaHl1H 0 B3b1CKaHl1l1 npou;eHTOB 3a npocpo'IKy
no CT. 395 rK P<1:I, 8Kl\110Hep TalOKe BIIpaBe 06paTl1TbCH B CYA C 3a.HB-
neHl1eM 0 npl13H8H1111 8Kq1(CtiE'pHOrO OOI1leCTBa 08HKpDTOM. TaK)'ID :1Ke
n0311IJ;111O 3aHI1MaeT J1 RB. JIoMarorn. ROHe'-JHo, :ilTO B03MO:>KHO TOJIbKO
.IVIJI c.nyq:aeB, He YR8-3aHHbIX B CT 43 3aKOHa «06 aKW'lOHepHbIX o6ll\e-
CTBax», KO!1\8 06ll\eC"rBo He BnpaBe BblI1J1a'lliBaTb ,II.I1Bl1)J;elJ,!J;bl, K01'O-
pble ym.e oUI..Hs.rreHbL IIono.meHl1£' «0 nopH,!I;Ke BblI1J!aTbl ,lII1BI1AeHJ\0B
no aKqHHM J1 npOQeHTOB no OOJll1I'altl1HM» TaIOKe YCTaHaBID1BaeT, 'I1'O B
CJ1Y'18e OTKa3a OOl1\eCTBa OT BbIIlJIaTb!.AI nOCJ1e,IJ;Hee ,lIOJDKHO
ObITb 06'bHBJleHo HennaTe J1 nOJ\Jle:IKMT JDlKBIl)J;aql1l1 B
ycraHOBJ1eH110M 3aKOHO,llaTeJibCTBOM nOp.H.D;Ke.
OM POJtHOBa, H8npDTl1B, CKJlOHHeTCJ1 K MHelD1lO 0 KDpI1Op8TIIBHOii
npl1po.n;e npaB 8KQ110HepoB, J1 n03ToMY, no ee MHeHI1lO, CTaT)'c nocJle.n;-
ID1X He MO:>KeT 6b1Tb l1pJtpaB1IeH It CTaTYCY Kpt'.lUfiOpOB OOl1\eCTBa J1 8K-
ltI10HepbI He MOryr ObITb Ha,I\eJ1eHbI npaBOM B030y:ac,QaTb B cy,lle npo-
Llecc 0 HecocTU.HTe.JIbH 8KL[I10HepHOro ofuQrersa. 231
IIoCKOJIbKY HapywelD1e 8KIv«nIepm,lM 06$13aIDIoCTi1 no
BbIllJIaTe .Al1BI CYllIeC"rBeHHO nOJ\PblBaeT ,lIOBE'pl1e K OOI1lecTBY,
'L 3 I'Ji. 9 Ko.n;eKca KopuopaTl1BHoro l1Ctie,/:\€IlllH peKOM oBaHo 3aKpeU-
J1HTb B ycraBe 06l1\ecTBa ,l\OIIOJIHJfI'e I1OJ1COKeH11E', B COCYI'BeTCTBI1tf C
KOTDpblM COBeT ,II;I1peK1'OpoB 061l\eCTB8 J1JII1 peBJ&3JIDHHaJI IOCI\mCCIm B
TaKi1X CJIy'-J8RX J1Mena Obi npaso )'MeHbWl1Tb pa3Mep
l'eHepaJlbHOM)' .wq>eR:TOPY J1 'LIIeHaM np8BJ1eHIDI.mIDo OCs060.l{l1Tb J1X OT
HCnOJiHE'HHH 06.H3aHHOCTei1. Ee3yCJiOBHO, TaKaH HOpMa 6blJl8 Obi BecbMa
llOJle3Hoi1 ,l\JUII1CKJiKJ'-JelD1H 113 Up8lITl1KI1 f1C>,AO&illx HapyurHlui.
-101-
CTaTbH 43 3aKoHa «06 aKI{l10HepHbIX OOmeCTBax» co):\ep:1KlIT nepe-
'leHb CJ1yqaeB, KorAa OOIl\E'CTBO He B!1paBe o&w1BJUlTb 0 BbII1J1aTe JV1BH-
AeH,D;OB Ii BbII1J1a'lJ1BaTb ym.e ofu,JrnJIeHHbIe no aKiV'1HM JV1B"'AeH,!\bL IIe-
pe'-leHb CJ1yqaeB, KOr,D;a OOIl\E'CTBO He Bnpaae o&bJmmrrb JI BbII1J1a'lHBaTb
A11BU,!\eH./J;b1, co):\epmJITC.l1 TaKme B 'l. 3 CT. 102 rK P , npWleM OH 3Ha-
'lJ1TeJIbHO OT.ID1tffieTCH OT nepe'-IHH, IOC!TOpblll)'CTaHOB.JIeH CT. 43 3axoHa
«06 aRIUfOlIeplIbrt 06utecmax».
oHepbI 3<urnTepecOBaHbIB BbII1J1aTe HM n03TOMY
Ha npaRTI1Ke OHl1 CKJiOHHbI I1THopwpoBaTb OI'JISHWIeHllJI. ycraHOSJIeH-
RbIe 3aKOHo):\aTeJ1bCTBOM, Tpe6Yf! BbI!1J1aTbl A11BJ1,l\eI1,D,OO HeB3HpaH Ha
I1IJJ1O)R{'IDIf! 3aKOHa. TaK, OAD d14'K «11H(ppacTpYKrypa» oopaTH-
JIOCb B Ap6mpamHb1ii cy):\ r. C.-IIeTep6ypra J1 JIemnn'pa,D;CKoi1 ofuJac-
m C IiCKOM K AOcrr «:KHpmmrneo/reOPrcl-lllTe3» 0 B3bICKaHJ.-U1 ,[ij--IBH-
p;eH,I\OB 3a 1995 I'D)]; B pa3Mepe 6o.JJee O):\HOro MJ1JIJll1ap,D;a py6JIei1.
PeWeHHeM cy,l:l3. B IiCKe OTKa3aHO. IIocraHOBJIeHHeM aneJlJIHl<lWH-
HOW J1HcraHW1:J.1 peweHHe OC'TciBJIeHO 6e3 J13MeHeHl1H.
M3 MaT€pHaJIDB )];eJIa YCMaTpMBaeTCH, '1TO peweHHe 0 H€BbII1J1aTe
AHBV1AetUI;OB 6bIJIO npHHHTO 06Jl1:J1M coopaHl1eM aKLIHoHepoB 30 anpeJiH
1996 r. no pe COBeTa ,D;I1peKTOpOB OOmeCTBa B CER3:J.1 C H€-
Y.l\OBJI CTpYKTYPOW OaJIaHCa, "ITO HBJIHeTCH O):\HI1M 113
IIpH3HaKOB HeCOCTO.HTeJIbHOCTH npep;rrplUlT11JL
B COOTBeTCTBlDI co CT 43 3aKOHa ,,06 aKqI10H€pHbIX I:£mecrnax.o
B 'laCTHDCUI, He Bnpase npJ1HHMaTb peweHJIIe 0 BbII1J1aTe
AHB"'AetUI;OB, eCJIH Ha .r\eHbnpl1HHTIffiTaKOro pernemlJI OOIl\E'CTBO OTBe-
'1aeT IIpH3HaKaM HecocrOJITeJIbHOCm (6aHKpaTCTBa) B COOTBeTCTBI1Jt: C
3aKOHO,D;aTeJIbCTBOM 0 IJe<OC'TCIS1TeJIbIJO(.'Tlt: (6alllq)OTCTBe) 1iJll1 eCJIH
YR8-<3aHHbIe IIpH3HaKJ1 nOHBIlTCH y OOmeCTBa B peayJIbTaTe BbIILJIaTbI
.lU'IBl1,ZJ;etUI;Oa.
B CBH3H C ::ITI1M 4'eAepaJIbHbrn: apfunpa)f(Hbli;i CY.r\ Ceaepo-3anaJ:\-
HOro OKpyra nOCTaHOB:J.1JI: peweHHe Ap6wrpa'Hllioro cy,Qa r. C.-IIerep-
oypra JI JIem-mrpa.n;CKOW 06.nacrH OT 16.08.96 no AeJIY N2 6800/96 JI
I1OC'1'aHOBJ1€H1I€ ane1JJ1JlQKOHllOif J1HCTaHqI1:J.1 TOro me CY.r\a OT 01.10.96
OCTaBi-'lTb 6e3 Jl3Mf'HeHJIIH, a KaCCalU'lOHH)'ID :lKaJIoOy OAD «Jt[4'K «J1H-
iPpaC'rp)'ETypa» 6e3 Y.r\oBJIeTBopeHJ1H. 232
HepeJtKQIi AlIBIfJI€HAblBbII1J1a'lJ1BalOTCH BOOXOJl ycra-
HOBJIeHHbIX 3aKOHOM orpaHWleHHM. II)'HKTOM 4 YKa3a IIpE'3IVJ;€HT8 P
OT 18 aBl)'cTa 1996 r. N21210 «0 Mepax no 3aI1U'1Te npaB aK1V-10Hepos JI
oOecne'l€HJlIH J1HTepecDB rocY.r\apcTBa KaK c06cTB€HHJlIKa JI aKQHDHepa»
yCTaHaSJII1BaeTCH, "ITO B cJIY'ICi€ HapyweHJIIH 3T11X CIplliH'IftiHM Ha BbI-
IIJJaT.Y (E:
- JI:J.1P€KTOp (ero1HOJDf'lHblii HffiOJIHJITeJJbHblit: opraH aKl<IlOHE'pHoro
), a TalOKe JIl1Qa, «crropbIe IiMelOT npaBD ,l:I3.BaTb 06H3aT€JIb-
-102-
HbIe .wm 3TOrO 06IIJ;ecrna )'KaBaHmI HID:! I1HbIM 06pa3oM ollpe,/J;eJIHTb era
.neHc'rmm. Hecyr YCTaHOBJIeHHyro3aKOHOM ;
- C'TaIJI'1TeJiJ' racy,1IPpCTBa B opraHax ynpaBJIeHHfI BKQWOHep-
HOro 06IIJ;ecrna, He MeHee Ute I'OJ10cyJ0IJJ;IIX BKlUfii IWTOporo HaXQD,I1T-
CJ1 B rocY,/J;apcTBelllW C06CTBeHHOC'rn, 06J13BHbI ncrrpe60BaTb oTMeHbI
I1JII1 H3MeHeHJlR paHee npillIHTOro perneHmI 06 06"bHBJIelIID1 JJ:I1BlmeH-
AOB, a TaIOKe npeRpaIQeHKH nOJ1HOMO'-JJ1:fi: PYlwBOIUfTeJIH (e.r:tl-'lHOJ1W1HO-
ro :WCl1OJ1I1JrreJIbHOI'O opraHa 06IIJ;eCTBa) :w(Jf.ID1) I303.JX»!(€IU' Ha Hero
y<:T8HOBJ1€HHffil 3aKOHOM OTB€TCTBt:'HHOCTI1.
EcJIJ1 BCe-TBK.I1 npoMC'«)JJ;l1T HeIIpaBOMepHaH BbmJIaTa
TOHaJ1.JlemIT TbCHn.6IIo.rromemm«OnOPMKeBbII1JIa-
TbI €H,!I;UB no aKQJ1.fIM 11 npOl.,eHTOB no OOJIJ1TaqIDIM". B cJI)l'-I3.e
BblI1JIaTbl aKQWOHepaM K3JIJIWHI1X ,/J;tfBl-I,rIeH)J;DB MomeT 3a-
'1eCTbM3JII1llIHIOIOBblIIJIaTYBC"IeT 1X IIJIaTemeJ:iI1.JIliInpeA-
nmtrnTb aKQJ10HepaM sepHyTb ee Ha 0CH0BaID1i'l peweHIDI 06IIJ;ero co-
OpaHIDI. IIp:w 3TOM 06IIJ;eCTBO He BllpaBe np:WIIy.lK.1WTb BKW10HepOB K
B03BpaTY l13JIJ1llIHe yn.na'leHHbIX cyMM:.
.!LB. JIOMaKJ1H C'-JJ1:TaeT, '1TO ,/J;aHHoe nOJIU:>KeHJ1e MO;KHO npJ1MeHHTb
TOJIbKO K BKQI10HepaM, HBJIHIOLqJ1MCH ,/J;06pOC1JBeCTHblMlI npJ106peTaTe-
JIHM]I! ,11I50 ,/J;eHbrJ1 He Mor)'T 6bITb I1c'Ipe60BaHbI OT ,/J;06po-
coBeCTHoro nplroOpe-raTeJIH ('I.. 2 CT. 302 rR P ). HeJIb3H ero npJ1Me-
HHTb K BKqJ:KE€p8M - 'lJIeHaM COBeTa ,/J;l1peKTOpoB 11Jll1 npaBJIeHJ1R
06IIJ;ecrna, ,/J;ei1cTBmmm: KOTOpbIX B HapyrneHJ1e ,/J;eJ:icTB)'IOIIJ;ero 3aKO-
HO TeJIbCTBa 6bIJia 06ycmBJl('Ha BbII1JIaTa 113J111IlIH11X ]J;HBJI]J;€H.!\OB,
nOCKOJIbKYB,/J;aHHOM c.rryqae Ha HJ1XB03JIaraeTCH ar-
BE'TCTBeHHOCTb B nopH,!\Ke CT. 71 3aKOHa «06 aKW10HepHbIX 06IIJ;ecT-
BaX", a TaKme K KPYIIHbIM aKqJ10HepaM, 11C11fJJ1b3(1BaB1lll CBoe nOJlo-
:m€HJ1e ,/J;JIH npJ1ID1Tlli! peweHWI 0 BbmJIaTe ]J;J1B eH,!\OB. B Ka'-IeCTBe
onpe,/J;eJIeHJ1H,Q06JX'COB€CTHOCT1' OH npe,I\JlaraeT dCI1OJ1l>3O-
BaTb OCBe]\a.rneHlIDCTb aRlVfOHepoB 06 I1CTI1HHOM C(E(IM nOJlo-
:m€HJ.-D-f aKqJ10HepHOro 061l.1eCTBa, I1OCI{()J1bK)' He Bce, a KaK npaBJ1JJJ,
TQJ1bKO KpynHbIe a oHepbI, Mor)'T 06JIaJIBTb I1H pMaQWen 06
3TOM. 233 IIpeACTaBJIHeTCH, '1TO B 3TOM C HJ1M Hy>KHO COrJIaCIITbCH.
B'IOMCJIy<tae, ecJII1JJ:11Bl1,IJ;e HeBOC'Ipe60BaHb1aKWDEpOMl1JII1ero
npaoorrpeeMffi1KOM B Te'-leHJ1e cpoKa JCroI!Oi( ,/J;aBHQCTI1 (3 ro.na), 'IO 00-
r.nacHOn.20 «OnopH,LJ;KeBbrn.naTbl,D;J: nOa 11
I1p)QeHTOBnO OHi13a'-{J1C'.JtHIQI'CHB,/J;oxo.I\6IoWKeTaf'tP.
Ha npDTIDKeHl1J1l1cTOpJ1]l! pOCCID1cKOM)' npaBY 6bLlIJ1 U3B€CTHbI TaK
Ha3bIBaeMbIe crpOVl'r€JIbHbI€ npoQeHTbI, KOTopbIe 6bLlIJ1 paCl1pOC'I1:6He-
HbI B I1paKTIlKe pocat:it:CKlIX BKQJ10HepHbIX 06ll.1ecrn,/J;o P€BOJIlOQffif, a
TalOKe B nepBbIX COB€TCKI1X aKQJ10HepHbIX OOll.leCTBax. 0rp0HTe.JIbHbIe
npoQelITbIBbIILJIa'IJJBaJil1Cb 3a Bce BpeMR no,lJ;rO'I'C1Blfl.1IblllO; TexIDI'-Je-
-103-
CKI1X pa60T, He06XOJJ,JIMbJX AJlH mocnnyaTa:q>fI1 aKQI10HepHOrO
of5ntec"rna (CT. 342 rK PCcfJCP 1922 r).
II.A. Py1J:HeB OTHOCI1JI npaBO Ha nOJIy'leHl1e crpOHTeJIbHUX npOL{eH-
TOB K HeoT'beMJIeMblM npaBaM, n03TOMY, no ero MHeHJ1K), HeJIb3H JII1-
maTb 8KLt110HepOB TaKoro npaBa I1J1I1 YMeHbllIaTb pa3Mep C'Ip(MTE'JIb-
HbIX npOL{eHTOB nyreM IIJC"ffiHOBJIeHHH 60JIblllI1HCTBa 8KLt110HepOB Ha
061lteM co6paHJrn. OR nOJIaraJI, '1TO npaBa aKL\I10Hepa Ha nOJlyqeHJ1e
crpOJf'I('J1bHblX TOBnOCBoei1npl1po,!\eHe cnpa-
BaMl1 Kpe,!\I1TOpa Ha 1l0JIy'leHJ1e npoIJ;eHTOB 3a Ccy>KeHHbrn nOCJIe,!\H11M
Kanl1TaJI, TaK KaK Kpt'.IUnop J1MeeT npaBO Tpe60BaHW! He TOJ1bIW npo-
qeRTOB, HO J1 Kalll1Tana; ec.m;: Ha,I\ 061ltecTBOM Y'lPe?1W.E'TCfI KOHKypC,
TO 8KL1110HepbI y,/J;OBJl€'rBOpHK)TCH CTpol1TeJIbHb!Ml1 npoIJ;€HTaMl1 nOCJIe
y,I:P Kpt'.IU'J"IOpOAameJ1nOTaKl1M06&1aTeJIbCTB8M, CpoK
IIJI8Te»ui KOI1M eIl\e He HaCTynl1J1. 234
J1T. TapacOB, HanpOTl1B, OTHOCJ1JJCfI K crpOHTeJIbHbIM npoIJ;eHT8M
(Bauzmsen) Kpai1He HeraTI1BHO, nOCKOJIbKY C'lliTaJI, <ITO mill «MOryT
6bITb Bb B8eMbI He l1H8'Ie teaK B yrnepO 8KQI10HepHOM)' Kamrra.ny. TaK
teaK J13 Hero HMeHHO OHl1 Bb ; noroMY ,!\OIl)TJl.\eHJ1eM T8K11X npo-
qeHTOB HapyrnaeTCH KopeHHoe Ha'IaJlO aK4l10HepHbIX KOMIlaHJ1i:i:, 38-
KJnO<I8K1lltEeCflBnOCTOHHCTBeI1 KaID1-
TaJIa 11 B onpe,!l{'JIeHIIUe qeJIJ1, AJlH KOTOpUX KamnaJI 3TOT
npeIJ;tffi3Ha'IeH. qeJIb:me 3Ta. O'leBI11IHO. He MOJKeT 38KJIIO'ffiTbCH B Bbwa-
'Ie npoU;eHTOB 113 Kamrrana...,,235
IIocyrn:me,npoQeHTbl3TI1:J1MeJIl1CXOJJ:HYlOC IlPI1po-
JJ3 11 flBJUlJII1Cb HeKOTopoi1 KOMIleHCaQl1eM8KL!IIDHepaM o6LQecTBa, KO-
TOpoe TQJIbKO Ha'IillI8JIO CBOKI ,!IeS1TeJ1hHOCT 11 no:;rroMY He I1MeJIO
npltfudJm.8 CJIeAOBaTeJlhHO,1f BfJ3I'4»I{H()C BblIlJla'Il1BaTb CBOI1M yqa-
CTHHKaM ,lU1Bl1)J;eH,l\bL COBpeMeHHoe poCCHi1CKoe 3aKOHO,Z1,aTeJ1bCTBO
KaKOI'O-J1I16o 8lffiJ10ra crpOirreJ1bHblX npoIJ;eHTOB He 3lffieT.
PacnpeJ:leneHl1e l1M.YlQeCTBa 8KQI10HepHoro o6LQecTBa npol1cxo,!\11T
TaJOKe npH ero JIJ1KBu,Ila'--\l1H nocpeACTBOM peaJ1lf381V(l1 npaBa aK'--\l10-
HepoB lffi OHHy1OKBary.
IIpaBo 8KJJ;WOHepOB H8 JlJIKBJJ,D.aQl10HH)'1D KBOTy ,[<8JIOOCHUBaHl'le He-
KOTOpbIM yqeHblM C'Ii1TaTb. 'ITO aKL\I10Hepb1l1MelOT npaso co6cTBeJmo-
CTI1 Ha J1MYlQeCTBO of:utec"rna- TaR, TIfIIl1'lHbIM npe,ll;CTaBl1TeJ1eM BeLQ-
HO-npaBOBOro B3rJ1 a 6blJl II. IIl1ceMCKIoc llIHpoKO J13B€CTH() ero
BbICKa3b1BaHtfe 0 TOM, 'lT0 B ,ll;ei1CTBl1TenbHOCTJ1 co I1MY-
Il\eCTB8 06Il\ecTB8 HBJI.RlOTCH 8KQI10HepbI 11 J1X npaBa {(C nepexo,!\oM
HM)TJl.\eCTB8 B c06CTBeHHOCTb KOMll8H1111 He npeKp8lQ8lOTCH, HO nOKOHT-
CH <...> IIocneToro, KaKIOpJf,lJ;WiecKOeurHOrnem1e, 06
-104-
3TO COCTOmrne, npeKpa"I1'JJXJCb, npaBO He B03HMKaeT BHOBb, HO npo6yJoK-
;naeTCfl K cyrn,ec'I'I3OB<_ 236
KoHe'lHO, npaBa aKQl-fOHepoB He np06YJoK,!:jaIOTC:fI K
J-I aKIqlOHepb1 He non)"-JalOT '1aCTb l1MyuJ;eCTBa BCJ1 TOro, 'ITO
J13Ha'1aJ1bHO SlBJ1ffiOTCfl ero c06CTBeHHI>-IK,uwl. OHM nonY'ffi1OT 'laCTb 113
J1M.}'ll\eCTBa JrnKB»JVIpyeMoro o6IIJ;ecTBa B CMJIY TOro, 'lTO COCTOHT ero
Y'ffiCTHJ1KaMJ1.
BAeHCTsyKJil-\eM3CUWHOMTeJThCTBecT. 313aKOHa «06aKQl-foHepHblX
06lL\ecTBax" ycraHaBJlJolB3.E'T npaBO - BJI3.):\eJThL\eB 06bIKHO-
BeHHb1X aRlU-'Iii 06lL\ecTBa Ha nOJ1)"-JeHJ1e 'IaCTJII J1M.}'ll\ecTBa 06il-\eCTBa B
CJ1yqae nocneAHero.Aro..\J1oHepbl-BJIa.n; lnpmll.J1em-
posaHHb1X 8.KQJ1i106ll\ecrea. MKnpaBJ1.J10, l1MeKn' npaBo Ha BbIrlJlaT)' 11M
.m CTOJ1MOCTl-lnonpJ J-IMaK .
B.rra.IleJThU;b! HHblX 3Kq>m: 06JraAalOT 3TI1M npaBoM B
pa3HOH CTen€HJ1 B 3aBI1CJ1MOCTIi OT Tl1na J1X aKL(!ul. TaK, OHM Moryr
6bITb.mt60 Boo61L\e ero JlllliIEHbJ, eCJIJ1 YCTaBOM He yc"ffiHOBJIeH pa:3Mep
J1JUt nOp:fl,!l;OK onpe,!l;eneHIDI CTOHMOCTJ1, JIJ1\5o Moryr
06na,QaTb 11M .AaJoKe B 6o.nbweH: CreneHJ1, 'leM aKQJ10Hepbl, BJla.A€IOlL\ne
0BeHHbIMM 8KIU1HMM.
CorJIaCHO n. 2 CT 32 TOro)K€ 3aKoHa, B YCTaBe o6IIJ;ecTBa AOJ1JoKHbI
6bITb onpe,lJ;eneHbl pa3Mep ,lJ;J1IU1,IJ;eMa J1 (J1.ID1) CTfJJDOOCTb, BbIIIJIa'll1Ba-
eMaH npJ1 .ID1KB11):\aqID1 06ll\ecrna (JIHKBU.!I8l-{IWHHaSI CTOIIMOCTb) no
IIpIUIWIE'I11pOBaHHblM 8KL\IDiM KaJoKJ:IOrO nrna. Pa3Mep ,IJ;I1BJ1,!1;eMa J1
J1MKBI SI CTOI1MOCTb onpe,n;eJlfllOTCfl B TBEP.l\O:W: AEHemHo:w:
cyMMe J1Jll1 B npoL\eHTax K HOMJ1HaJIbH)M C'IUI1MOC'"I11 npl1Bl1Jlen:IpOBaH-
HbIX aKqIDi Pa3Mep ,lJ;J1BMAeH,I\a J1 J111KBJf,I\a.ltJ1OIIHa1I CTOJ1MOCTb no npJ1-
BH.YIen1pOBaHHblM 8KQ1-fHM C'fl1TalOTCH OIlpEJIeJ!EHHbIMJ1 TaKmE, ECnJ1
YCTaBOM OOil-\eCTBa YCTaHOBJieH nOpfl,!l;OK J1X onpe.lI€J!eIDIH.
TaKMM oopa30M, B03MOmHh! cne.n;yrolL\l-le cnOCOOb1 onpe,n;enemffl
pa:3MEpa JlltKBIlML\J10HHOii CTOI1MOCTI1 11 ,lJ;I-IIDf,!\EH,I\OB B YCTaBe: B 4JMK-
rnpoBaHHoH ,D;eHe.mHoA cYMMe, B npou;eHTax K HOMHl1aJ1bHOH CTOI-IMOC-
TI1 npI1BI1JIeT'I1}JOBaHHb1X aKQJ1i.f, nyreM yro138HJ1fl nopillU\8 J1X onpep;e-
nEHJ1H. EcnM yCTaBUM 06ll\ecrna pa3Mep JDIKBI 1UHHOH CTDMMOCTJ1
no I1p11BJ'JJ!eI1'IJXE8HHblM aKQl-fHM He onpe,!\eneH, TO 3T0 03Ha'laeT, 'ITO
npaBO Ha ee IIOJ1y'I€HJIE Y TaKJ1X eJXE OTcyrcTBYeT. B TaKOM
CJlJ'l8e OHJ1 J1MelOT npaBO TOJrbKO Ha nOJl)"leHJ1e ,D;J:1BI1,I:\€H,!!,8 no CBOI1M
aKL\IDiM, pa3Mep KOTOporo ,n;OJiJoKeH 6b1Tb onpeAEJIEH B YCTaBe.
Henocpe.I\CTBEHHItIi nopHAOK BbmJlaTbI JII1KBI L\I10HHoii KBOTbl
aKqJ10HEpaM pernaMeHTI1pOBaH CT. 23 3aKOHa «{)(i 3Kq>tOHepHbIX 06-
ll\eCTBaX". OCTaBweecH nocne 3aBepWemm pac'-JeTOB C KpeAtf"fOP8MH
J1 ocyrn;eCTBJieHJ1H BbmJlaT no aKIU1HM, KOTOpble ,n;OJDKHb16bITb BbIKyn-
neHbl, BCOC!TEIeTCTBI1JICOCT. 75 )'K83aHHOrO 3aKoHa HMyuJ;e<:TBO nHKBH-
-105-
,D;I1pyeMom 06IIJ;ecTBa pacnpeAeJJHeTCH JIHKm oii: IIDMKCCIreH
MemJl)' aKI-tJIDHE'paMH B CJ1e,rr;ylOIIJ;eti rNepep;HOCTlt: CHatIaJ1a OC eCTB-
JlHlQTCJI BbIIIJIaTbI Ha<rn:CJIeHHbIX, HO He BbIILJla'<leHHbIX p)1Bl1,D;eH,1J;OB no
HHbIM aK1V1RM J-I OrIpe,1J;€J1eHHoti: YCTaBOM o6IIJ;ecTBa
0lIHfJii CTOMMOCTI4 no npmI1J1ernpoBaHHbTh'! aKltWlM; 3aTeM
TCH pacnpeJIe.nemre J1MYI--II;eCTBa JIJ1KBMJefPY€MOm 06IIJ;e-
CTBa M€mJI)' aMI--I - BJIa.l\ MI1 06bIKHOBeHHbIX araum J-I
BCex Tl--lnOB npmI1.I1eI'dpOBaHHbIX aIt.QIDi.
M€}fi,!I;y 8KQ110HepaMJ1 ocyw.eCTBJIHeTCH pa3,1J;eJ1€1rn€ scem 11M)'llI€-
CTBa o6IIJ;ecTBa: l\aK J-IMelOlltI-1XCJI Y 06IIJ;eCTBa ,lIeHemHbDI: Cpe,1J;CTB, TaR J-I
APYTom l1M)'llIeCTBa. ITa 3TOMY BOnpOcy n lIHceMcro:1ii C'ill'TaJ1, '1TO «B
CyIQ€CTBe TOaapl1Lll;€CTBa Boo6IIJ;e J1e:>Kl1T TO . 'ITO pa3,!J;eJ1
J-IM)'1LI€CTBa era in natlU'a ,1J;OJ1iKE'H 6bITb YCTpaHeH. ITpl--l pa3,1J;eJ1e 11M)'llI€-
CTBa in natlU'a paBeHCTBo MeJfi,!:Iy TOsaPIDQaWJ MO:1KeT 6bITb lIOC'rnTH)'TO
JrnWb np:1fimI3JITe.IIbHO. Ho CBepx STOro HeYll06CTBa pa3,!J;eJ1 ill natura
J1MeeT eIIJ;e TO II>CJIe)J;C'flJlte. '1TO MmKeT YMeHblill1Tb L\eHHOCTb l1M)'llIeCT-
B3. TOsapl1IIJ;eCTBa BC.TIel\CTBHE' ero pa3.n;po6JIeHl1H»237. IIo3TOM)' Bce HMY-
1LIeCTBO 06IIJ;ecTBa B BI1.DY pa3,D;eJ1a ,lIOJ1mHO npO,D;aBaTbCR H BblPY'l€HH3.R
cYMMa lIe.ID1TbCJI MeJfi,!:IyaKQl10HepaMI--I. XurR OH H ,1J;onyCKaJI, 'ITO no yc-
MOTpeHIDO aKWIoHepoB MOiKeT 6bITb yC'ffiHCB:IJIE'H H ,n;pyroi1 cnoc06 pa3-
AeJIa J1M.YII-\ecTBa, Karophli1 11M nOKa:1KeTCR H13J160Jlee Bbrro
OcHOSHO€ npaBKIIO npl1 pa3J\eJ1e 06IIJ;eCTBeHHOm l\aIll1'TaJIa. no era
MHeHI1K>, lIOJ1iRHO COCTOHTb S TOM, '1TO l\a::ti,!:\brn nOJI)"Ia€T 06paTHo CHOi1
B:K.JI8J\; Bce me, '1TO OCTaeTCJI CBepX TOra, paccMaTp>rnaeTCH l\aK npl1-
6bLJlb 1--1 pacnpe,!\eJIH€TCH M€mJI)' aKW10HepaMH no TeM JKe npaBKllaM.
no KOTOpblM Mem,ny HJ1MJ-f Boo6IIJ;e pacnpeJteJI1le'ICH IIpJ16b1J1b. 238
PacnpeJ:le.neHl--le J1MYI--II;eCTBa Ra::ti,!:\oi1 O'lepe,D;11 ocyw.ecTBJIHeTCH no-
CJ1e nOJ1Horo pacllpe,D;€J1eHI-U! I1M)'1QE.'CTBa npe,l:tbl,!I.y1l.\ei1 o'-l€pe,D;l--I. Bbl-
I1J1aTa 001LIec'r0cM onpe,lleJ1eHHoi1ycTasoM 06IIJ;eCTBa J111KB"'JIaiV'loHHoA
CTOI'lMOCTH no DpI1BHJIernposaHHbIM aKQI-U!M onpeJIe.neHlDI'O TIDm ocy-
lI.\€C'I'BJlH€T nOCJ1e nOJllIOA BblI1JIaTbl onp€,l\€JIeHHoA YCT8BOM 06IIJ;e-
CTBa JIJ-lKBI--lAaIv:lOHHoU: CTOMMOC'l11 no n:pMBIfJ1€I11pO aKiV'I.IIM
npe,!l;bI,JJ;yIIJ;ei10<iepe.D;>1.
EcJ1J1 JiMelOIIJ;eroCH y 061l1€CTBa 1--IM)'LQ€cTBa He,l\OCTaTO'-IHO ,l\J1H Bbl-
I1J1aTbIHa<nfCJIeHHbIX, HOHeBbllIJ1a'leHHbIX HJ11JIHonpe,D;eJ1eHHoi1
yC'faBOM o6IIJ;ecTBa JIHKBI HHOfr CTOMMOC'l11 sceM aKQl10HepaM -
BJ1a,!\eJ1bQaM IIpI-1BI-fJIeIJIpOB8.HHbIX 8.KQJ1i1 O,l\Horo TJ1I1a, TO J1M)'1Q€CTBO
paCIIp€A€JIH€TCH MeJfi,!:Iy aKW10HepaMJ1- BJIa.n,eJ1bQ13.WJ 3TOro TIma DpI1-
BWIernposaHHN:X aKL(Im II}XJnopW1OHaJIbHO KOmI'-l€CTB)' DpJ1Htl)],J1eiRa-
lQI1X 11M aKql1i1: 3TOro TI1II1l (n. 2 CT. 23 3aKOHa «06 aKQl10HepHbIX
06IIJ;ecTBax}) ).
-106-
B :nOM 11 COCTOMT pMCK aKql10Hepa - nOCJIe J]J1Km 1 06IIJ;ecrna
OH MomeT He TOJJbKQ He IDJ1Y'DITb l1M)'1l\eCTBa 06IIJ;ecrna, HO,l:\am€ 11 He
BePHY'fb ce6e l1M.}'ll\ecrna B pa3Mepe 11M BHeCeHHOro BKJIaJW B YCTaB-
Hbl Kani-lTaJI. KaK BblCKa3aJICR no :noM)' nOBO,!\}' J1.T. TapacoB, «aKql1-
OHep o6J13aH OTBetJaTb cBOei1,lJ;OJJei13a KOMnaHl-flO, BCJ1eJ1CTBJ1e 'lera aK-
QI>10Hep He MQm.eT nOJIy'lliTb CBOIO ,lJ;OJIIO KaIUITaJIa 06paTHo I1Haqe KaK
B nopR,!U<e, :yKa3aHHOM B YCTaBe 113aKoHe».239 IIo.J1)"1a-eT me aKLUfOHep
IIpM J]J I 06IIJ;ecrna He Ha3a)1 CBOIO ,lJ;OJIIO, BHeceHHYID 11M B YC-
TaBHbrn KaIUITaJI, a 'laCTb HMyw;eCTBa 06IIJ;ecrna. Ha :no B CBoe BpeMH
)'Ka3bIBaJI ellle A.J1. KaMI1HKa. 240
q'I'D RacaeTCR CO):1ep»Glffifjl IX Me 06IIJ;ecTBOM 11 aR-
QI>10HepOM 'I'D Cy6'b€IITHBHOMY npaBY 8KL[IKJH€J::e H3. qacTb
HM.}'ll\eCTBa 06ll1eCTBa I10CJIe era JlHKBl1,!I,altI,m KOppec.rIDl1J1JrpyeT 06R3aH-
HOCTb 06ll1eCTBa BbV:j€IDITb eM)' m:y 'ffiCTb, HO 'I'DJIbKO IIpH HaJIWlID1 HMY-
lL\eCTBa KaK TaKOsoro, nOCJIe 3aBepweHJ1R paC'-leTOB co BCeMJII yCTaHOB-
neHHblMJ1 3aKOHOM JI:JrQaMJII ITpH HeHCnOJIHeHID1 :n'Oti o
0611\€CTBOM aKql10Hep MOm€T -rpe60BaTb ee J1CInJIHeHJ1H no CYlJ;;f nyreM
o peweIDm: IOHHOii: IWMI1CCI1I1. B CJ1)"-Jae:me <:r!'-
cyrcrnWI J1MYI-U;€Crna K MOMerrry)'llOBJIeTBopeffifjl Tpe6000HJ1i.1 aKql1OHe-
pa., OH He J1M€eT npaBa Tpe6000Tb, nOCKOJIbKy 3.n;eCb l1MeeT M€CTO H€B03-
MroKHOCTb I1cnOJllieffifjl ofu13aTeJibCTBa. CJ1TY8. Ta me, 'ITO 11 B CJ1)"-Jae
OTCyr<:TBWI 'lJ1CTOti npllWJIlI,IJ.JlH Bbll1JlaTbI ,IJ;I1BM,D;eH.n;OB. AKLUfOHep 1I0JI-
:meH lIOBOJIbCTBOBaTbCR TeM, 'ITO 0611\€CTSO cnocc6HO eM)' Bbv:(€JIJITb.
TaKl>1M 06p33oM, C npaBOM am:v:K>Sepa Ha IOHHYID KBOTY
CJITya CKJI rnaeTCH aHaJIOrl1tJHBHToti, KOTOpaH B03HIDrneT B CBR3M
cnpaBOMaKiV'lOHepa Ha ,IJ;I1BM,I\eHAJJ:oTOrO, RaKE 06l1\eCT-
Be Ha'laTa IIJ)()I.W1JJ'P8- .1lltKBIJJ\ffitI'1X, OHep l1MeeT KOpnopaTI1BHoe
IIpaSO Ham KBury, KOTOpoeRBJlIIeTCRHJ!'-JeMHlJblMl\aK
npaBOM aKiV'lOHepa Ha perneID1e Ha 06tqeM co6pam-rn BOnpoCOB 0 JU-iKBM-
1IP1-{ID1aKql1oHepHoro06tqecTBa 1106YTBeJ»lI',lJ;€HII 11
OKOH'laTeJIbHOrO Horo 6aJIaHCOB. Roppecnol1.-!UfpYIDllI.eA
06.1i3aHHOCTbIO 6Y,lJ;eT, COO'I'BeTCTBtHH 06113aHHOCTb 06tqecTBa BbIHecTM
pernefD1e 3TI1X BonpoCOB H3. paCCMO'I'peHJ1e 06l1\ero c06pafD1H. B CJ1)"-Jae
npI1HF!TlliIHao6utJ.txc06pammxI1OJJ'J)KJJTeJ1bHbIXpewemwn0Bb1HeceH-
HbIM Ha paccMOTPE'HIf€ BonpocaM 11 HaJII1tJW1 J1MYIIJ;€CTBa Y OOl1\eCTBa
JIIIKBJ KOMJIICCl1.IilIpl1HJ1MaeTperneHJ1eO 1aKW10-
HepaM 'laCTH l1M)'1LIecTBa B Bl>1,!:\e KBOTbL J1 0611\€CTSO
06H3aHo 6YlleT ee np€]:IOCTaBJITb, OJJ;HaKO 3Ta ofu13aHHOCTb y*€ 6y)J;eT
cy:w;eCTBOBaTb B paMKax ofu13aTeJlbCTB€HHOro OTHOWeHJ1R.
AS. JIOMaKHlJ C'lliTaeT, 'lTO, TaKme RaK JIJ: npaso Ha ,IJ;I1BM)J;eHJt npa-
EO Ha JU-iKBI1,!I,aQl>10HH)'JO KBOTY eCTBY€T B KaqeCTBe KopnopaTI1BHO-
ro I1JIH qJIeHCKOro npaBa 11 B Ka'leCTBe Kpe,U;lIT0pCI«)fO. RopnopanfBHoe
-107-
npaBO nOHBJIHeTCH B MOMeHT BlJ3HJ1KHOBeffiUI qneHCKDIU npalJ[OTHIJIllI"-
H11.Hl1npo,I\onmaeT Tbp.oeronpeKpaIlleIl1'UKpeAlrI'OJXKOE'
npaBO Ha IOHHYJO KBOTY B03HHRaeT nOCJle ymepm,l\eH1'1H 06-
lltWM co6pa1nfeM aK1V10HepoB 110 COrJ1aCI1IO C OpraHOM. fM
roCY.I\8.pCTBelll1)'lO pen1C'l'p&tl'1lO J1MKBI1JWPyeMOro 06mecTB3. JII1KBU,Ila-
QWOlll1oro 6a.mrnca. IIpaBo Tpe60BaffiUl,lJ;OJ1J1 B J1MYII-\eCTBe IOpM,D;l1'lec-
ROro J1I1Lta nOH3JIReTCH B MOMeHT onpe,I\eJ1eHi1H J1I1KBU,IlaLtJ:IOHIJOt1: RO-
MI1CCl1en Ha ()Cl1OI!aI1Wf,llaHHbIX 6ammca noPJ1.I1Ra
pacnpe,QeJIeHJffi l1M)'lLIeCTBa 06mecTB3. Mem,ny aKWiOHepar.rn, pa3Mepa
J-I epolOClB BbII1J1aTb1 JlIIIKB LtJ:IOHHOO RBOTb!. ,UpyrnMI1 ('JJOBaMI-f, B MO-
MeHT npe,I\MeTa ofur3aTeJ1bCTEa. 241
t 3. COOTHoweHMe KopnopaTMBHblX H 06s:13aTel1bCTBeHHblX
npaBooTHoweHMM, B03HHKalOI..ijItX no nDBOAY
HH$opMaLlMH M KOHTpOI1A B aKL(MOHepHblx 06aqeCTBaX
C npaBOM 8KWiOHepOB Ha y-'laCTI1e B 06meM C05paHI1I1 TecHei1:IrrnM
06pa:3DM CBH3aHO npaBO aKlU10Hepa Ha I1Hct>oPwu,t>oo. IIpaBD Ha J1H-
4JoPMaQil106bIJIO HOCTaeTCH O.n;IillMI£3 BamHeMrrrnx B <n1CJIe HeI1MYIIJ;e-
CTBeHHbIX npaB aKLpw)Hepa. Ero 3HaqeHl1e TPY,I\HO nepeo:u;eHl1Tb.
Bo-nepBhlx, oc:yru;eCTBJleHl1e aKQI1DHepoM ern npaBa Ha yqaCTl1e B
06meM c06paHl1l1 B03MOmHO TOJIhKO npl1 J1H4JopMIt:!prJB8llID1 ero 06me-
CTBOM; BO-BTOPbIX, npaBO Ha KOHTpOJIh 3a ,l:\eJITeJINiOCTblO 06meCTBa
MOmeT OCYII-\eCTBJIRTbCII 8KWiOHepOM TOJlbKO B CKJIY ofina):J.amrn HM
I1Hct>oP 1 o TaKOneroJ\em'('.JIbl1()CTH
Eme llA PyJ\HeB O'1'MelJaJ1, '1TO XOTJI npaBo aKL\I10Hepa Ha nOJ1)"re-
H11e H npilMO 3alWHOM He YCTaHOBJ1eHO, HO B CKJIY eBOeA
3Ha<n1MOCTI1 OHO, HeCOMHeHHO, npJ1HBAITe>!urr Ka)lI')J;OM)' aKWioHepy: «B
HaweM COBeTCI«JM fK PCOCP XOTH 11 He J-IMeeTCH onpe,I\eneHHoro YR8-
3aHi1H Ira npaBo 8KWiOHepa Ha nO.ny'-leHl1e ROIII1I1 e 6anaHca, HO 31'0
npaBO HecOMHeHHO IIpI Kam.ctOM)' aKlU10Hepy 11 Bl>IEIO,WITCH
m CT. 357, RoeA 'IpE'6oBaHJre Be,I\eHl1HnpaBl1J1bHoro
C'le"fCJBOJJ;CTBa J-I OT'feTlJOCTH 0 A61cTBIITeJ1bHOM JIM)'lIJ;eCTBeHH nOJIO-
:!KeHI1I1 TOBapI1l1,\eCTBa - HarJ1H,JJ.HO, J\OCTynHO 11 nOHHTHO; CTaTbI1 OT'-Je-
Ta H 6anaHca ,I\OJDKHbI conpOBOm,I\aTbCH nMCHI1TeJlbHbIMl1 3aMe'JaHi1H-
MI1, Bnony.IDlpHon4JoPMe».242
B H3B€CTH0M npe:u;e.n;eHTHOM cYJ\e6HoM peweHl1l1 III re Humes Ltd
(1987 c_) 0 IIpJ1:3HaHID1 npaB aKql10HepoB Ha J\oCT)'II K 0'1"-IETHJC111 KOpno-
par.u-rn HeDTb€MJleMM npUH8.D,Jl€»Q{OCTb 3TOro npaaa 8KlU10HepaM 6bJJl8
o60cHoBaHa cJ1e.D;y1Oll-\I"!M o6pa30M. «ByM8Il1 I1I1MYII-\eCTBO KDpnOpal.(IDI
-108-
peaJIbHO IIpIHa}])IeJt\aT 8KQI10HepaM, If 3Ta peanbHoc-rb He MmKeT fibITb
onpOBeprnyra ij $1K1Wefi: I npaBocy6"beKT-
HOCThlROpnopaQID1Hee 0T,lJ;eJIbHOOTee'lJleHOB»243
06J!:3aHHOCTb ofimecTB3. no npe,lJ;OCTaBneHi-flO IfH4JopMaJUnf 3aKpen-
nella 3aIroHO]:\aTeJIbHO B rpam,!\aHCKOM KO,lJ;eKCe P<P (CT. 67 1197); 3alOO-
He «06 8KQI10HepHbIX OfimeCTBaX» (CT. CT. 52, 88, 90, 91, 92) H 3aKoHe
«0 pb1HKe LteHHbIX 6YMar» (CT. CT. 8, 19, 22, 23, 25, rnaBa 7 «0 pacKpbl-
Tm1 HHtPopMaQl1Jf 0 LtellllbIX fiyMarax»). Cne,QyeT OTMeTm'b, <tTO XOT$1
npaBo y<taCTHJllKa X03JnIcTBeHHOIO ofimecTB3. Ha lfH4Jo oo 0 p,eH-
TeJ1bH0C'rn o6I.J.teCTBa J1 npRMo :yKa3aHo B CT. 67 rK P<P, IJ'J.lI06me npa-
EO B nepe'leHb npaB 8KLtI10HepoB B CT. 31 H 32 3aKOlla «06 8KQI10Hep-
HbIX » nO<ieM)'-TO He BOWJIO.
Y<teHble Bb1,!\eMIOT pa3J1W1HbIe iPopMb1 npe emmI-:lH<¥JPMa-
QI1I1 8KQI10HepHbIM O TaK, lOA. Me-re.rresa C'll-ITaeT, 'ITO aK-
L{I10HepHbIM 06mecTBoM HHclx>PMawm 8KQI10HepaM MOiKeT npe,lJ;OCTaS-
.mITbCfl B CJI€JIYlOllI}1X 4q::JMax:
- nyfurn'llfoe npe,!\ocTaSJleHJlle HHc}xpMaQl1l1 - nyfurnKaql1Jl HH-
4JoPMaL\I1I1OTKpbITbIMl1 aKQI10HepHb1Ml1
- npep,OC"ffiBJIeHJ:1e HHclx>PMaL\11I1 npl1 IIO,IJ;IU'ftJBII:e K co6pamllo aK-
L{I1OHepOS;
- npe,lJ;OCT8BJlem:re HH<¥JPMaL{l1M no JUI'IHOM)' <.mnpocy aEQlK)He-
pa. 244
.n. B. JIoMaKHH TaKiKe no,!\pa3,lJ;eJUleT 06H3aHHOCTII ofimecTB3., KOp-
pecnOH,!\l1pyrollJ)1e npaBY OHepOB Ha IrntlJoP Ha p,Be 6oJn,-
IID1€IpynIIbI:
1) rfu1:3aHHocTn OOLqeCTBa no npe,lJ;OCTaBJ1eHJllIO 6eaap,pecHJfi: 11H-
4Jo 1 (Hanpl1Mep, nyfurnKaLtJ-ffi B cpep,cTBax MaccoBoi1 HH<¥JpMa-
ltI1H, ,lJ;OCTyn K onpep,eJ1eHlDMy n. 1 CT. 91 3aKOHa «00 aKQI10HepHbIX
nepe'lIDOJIOK)'M€HTOB);
2) ofifl3aHHOCTI1 no IIpeJlOCTaBJIeHHIO ap;pecHOIl J1H4JopMaIJ,l1l1 (Ha-
npHMep, ofu!3amncon, 110 YBe,!\OMJ1eHJllIO 0 npoBe,!\eHHH oomero cofipa-
HJIIfl nyreM mmpaBJleHWI B <V1Pec 8l\.Q110Hepa 3aKa3Horo IThICbMa).245
D6H3amroc-m: no npe,!\ocTaBJleHl1KJ Jrn4Jo 1I1 MOiKHO
ycnoBHo pa3,!\€JDrTh Ha <teTbipe 6oJIbllll1e IpynIIbI. K nepBoA rpynne
McmaIOOTHeCTH oOH3aHHocTH 06meCTBa no pacKpbl'TlOO HHtPoPMaIJ,l1l1 B
CJIJ'l3.HX, YCTaOOBJIetrnb1XS nep€"ilIC.JJeHHb1X 3aKOHax 11 p,pymx HopMa-
TJmHbIX amax.
CornaCHO CT. 30 3aKOHa «0 pblHKe LjeHHbIX 6)'Maf}) no,!\ paCKpbITI1:-
eM J1H4>OpMaLlml nOHl1MaeTCJ'I 06ecne<reHl1e ee AOCTYfIHOCTJI BceM 3a-
I'1HTepecoBaHHbIM B 3TOM JII1QaM H€3aBMCMMO OT LjeJlei1 nOJlyq:eHllil
p,3.HHOi1 HH4JoPMaQI111 no npoQe,nype, fapaHn'lpyro:w;eti ee HaXO:1K,!:\e-
I-me H nonY'leHl1e.
-109-
PaClCpbITlJli mut>o ei1 Ha PbIHK€ q€HHbIX 6yMar npM3HaeTCH
HHct>oPMa'-!l1H, B O'I'l1CfileHmI KOTOpoiil npoB€,!\€HbI '!\€i1CTBI1H no ee pac-
KpbITI1lO.
B COOTBe'I'C'l'BJ-f co CT 92 3aKoHa «0:5 aKLUfoHepHblx oolltec'lBa."{'O
ompbIToe aKql10HepHOe rollleC1'BO o6.I13aHo paCKpbIBaTb cnellYlOLqy1O
HHC}X>PMalJ)1Kl:
- ro,!\oBOt1: oneT oOllteCTBa, ro.r:toBYIO 6yxraJITepcKYlO OT'IeT-
HOCTb;246
- npocneKT SMJIICCJIIJII aKQJ1i1 0611tecTB3. B CJ1J'13.HX, n -
HbIX npasoBbIMl-'l aR'I'aMJII P4J;
- cocfuqeHJre 0 npoBeAemm oolltero coopamm aKql10HepOB B no-
pH,!U\e. npe.lIyCMOTpeHHOM yKa3aHHbIM 3aKOHOM;
- J1HbIe CBE'.r:temm, onpeAeJIReMble clJeAepa.nbHblM opraHoM J1cnon-
HJIITeJIbH)ii BJIaCn-I no PbIHKY LjeHHbIX 6yMar. 247
o:5H3aTeJlbHOe paCKpbITl1e 1JII aKql10HepHbIM 06lL\ecT-
80M, BKJllO'ffiH 3aKpblTOe OOIl\€CTBO, B c.rryqae ny6JIJ1'-{Horo pa3M€m;eID1H
JIM 06m1I1:iq>lii J1JIJII J1HbIX LjeHHbIX O)'Mffi' O B OObeMe J1
nopH,!U\e, KOTOpble YCTaHOBJIeHbJ 4>e,!\epaJIbHbII\l! opraHOM JICJIOJIHJI-
TeJIbHOi1 BJIaCn-I no PbIHKY Lj€HHbIX 6yMar.2 48
ComaCHo CT. 16 3aKoHa «0 6yxramepCKoM yqeT€» ny6,m.-1KaL{l1H I'OJ\D-
BOi16yxramepcKoi1 OT'-leTHOCTI1 IIJXIC3BOJIKTCH He n03AHee II110IDI ro;:ta,
CJ1€J1Y1OIl\€ro 38. 0T'-IeTHbIM. ny6.mI'IHOCTh 6yxra.mepcK0i1 OT'-IeTHOCTI:! 38.-
l\.mO'I3.eTCH B ee ony\5.Irn:KcBaH B ra3eT3.X J1 )KypHa.nax, AOCTYJIHbIX
noJIb30BaTeJIHM, .m16o pac1IpCX'TpaH€H1 cpe.1\I1H11X 6pollIIOp, O)'KJIeTOB J1
JJ:PyrnxJ CO.1\eJDKalL\l1X6yxramepcK)'ID 0'I'"Ie'fH)CTh
J1H(POPMaLUffl 0 BbmycKe 3MRCCJI()HHbIX qeHHbIX O}'Mar paCKpbIBa-
eTCH npl1 OCYll eefB.JIeHIDl 06lL\ecTBoM IIpoLleAYPbI ::tIlrnCCID1 qeHHblx
6)'Mar Ha OCHOBaHl1I-f CT. CT. 19, 22, 23,30 3aKoHa «0 pbIHKe qeHHbIX 6y-
Mar» B CJIyqae. eCJllf rocy,!\apcTBeHlffiR pernC'rpa 1H BbmyCKa Conpo-
BOOK)\aeTCH p reH npocneKTa SMHCCI1I1. IIpI1 STOM cy6'heKTaMJII
- BJ\PecaTaMJII HHct>oPMaLU1Jl, iCR B npocneKTe aMHCCJBI,
Moryr 6bITb He TOJIbKO aKLIMoHepbI, 80 J1 J1IOObie 3aWHTepecoBallHUe B
STOM IDIqa H€3aBhCJ1MO OT Ljt:'.neii nOJIy<leHI>1.H sroMI1Hq:.opMaLUfM.
KpoMe TOro, B cn)"'ae pemcrpaLUfM npocneKTa qeHHblx 6}'Mar ::tMM-
TeHT OOR3aH OcyrQeCTBJ1m'b paClCpume J1H<P:>PMaLUfM B tPoPMe'
- eJi<eKBap-raJIbHoro OT'-IeTa 311rnTelITa SIWICOICEHbIX qeHHbIX 6yMar;
- Co06lL\€HI>1.H 0 cytJ.\ecTBeHHbIX clJaKTax (cct'i1.rmRx, '!\eAcTBUHX), 38-
'Iparl1B8lOlL\I1X XffiHiiiCTBeHHYJO A€flTe,nbHOCTb 3M1IT€HTa
SMHCCJlOHHbIX qeHHbIX 6yMar (CT. 30 3aKoHa «0 PbIHK€ LjeHHbIX 6)'M8r" ).
Oco6eHHOC'ThIO npaso::rI'HOllIE no o6.I13a'TeJIbHOM)' paCKpbITl1IO HH-
4Jq:JMawrn: HBJlH€TCJI IIpJICyTC'I'Bne B OTHOIlleHJffiX CJllJIbHOro ny6JIWfHO-
npaBOBOro 3JJeMeHTa XOTJ'i aKl{>1OHeJ:IID€ 06Il\€CTBO 06J'i3aHO npe,lJ;OCTa-
-110-
BIITb J1H4JopMalJ}1lO 3aI-1HT€peCOBaHHbIM .JrnQaM, )'Ka3aHHaH OM311HHOCTb
OOllleCTBa YCTaHaBJIMBaeTUI He no cornarneH11lO CTOp:m, a B l1MI1EpaTlIB-
HOM IIOpR,IJ;Ke, B liMeHHO B pe3YJIhTBre :mecTKOro pery.mfJXJBaID1f! co CTO-
poHbl rocYAapCTBeHHbIX opraHOB. KpoMe TOro, paCCMaTpl1BaeMbIe OTHO-
llleID1f! HaxOAfl'I'CJ1 nO)J; noCTO$IHHblM KQHT})oneM q..ccpp PCP. TaK11M
OOpa30M, B aTI1X OTHorneHl1JIX npI1CyrcTBYeTny6JIWfHO-npaBOBBJI CIIeqI1-
4>m(8..HeCBOiicTBeHHa.ll 06.II3BTeJ1bCTBaMBCI-fJ1Y
3TOro om;: CKopee HaIIOMlliIalOT B,IJ;MI>-IIDICTpaTl1BHhIe npaBOO'I'HOlllEfflJL
Ko BTOPOM rpyrrne MO}f\HO OTHeCTI1 o6H3aHHucnr 06mecTBB no npe-
;n;OCTaBneHI1IO 11H4JoPMaLU-1H, CM3aHHbie C He06xo,J:uIMOCTblO Be.I\eID1R
peeCTpa BEQl'DHeJX'B- B 3TOM CJ1yqae np€J\OCTaBJ1.I1e'fC.
OrpaHW-IeHHOM)' KPyry ID1LI.
Tal\:, B COOTBeTC'I'BIDI CO CT. 8 3aKOHa «0 pblHKe lteHHbIX 6}'Mar» .I\ep-
:1K3.TeJIh peecTpa (a HM MO:1K€T ObITb 11 caMO aKl\110HepHoe 06meCTBo)
06J'i311H no -rpe6oBaHmo BJJaAt'JlbQB "JlI1 nl1L\a, A€HC1'ByIOIl<ero OT ero
liMeHl1, B TalOKe HOMl>1HaJIbHOro J\epitffiTenJ'i lteHHbIX 6yMar npeJ\ocTa-
BI1Th Bbilll1CK)' 113 CI1CTeMb! B€J\etrnJ'i peecTpa no ero ID1LIeB0M)' cqe-ry B
Te<leHl1e IUlTI1 pafXN"X ,lJ;HeM.
I3HrnICKOii 113 ClICTeMbI B eID1R peeCTpa HBJlReTCJ'i .IJ;OK)'MeHT. Bbl)]p-
BaeMbrnJ\epitffiTeneMpeeCTpa C )'K3.3atrneM BJIa.n;eJIhu;aJIJII Boro CqeTB.
KOJIWIecTBa I.1;eHHb!X o)'Mar Ka»Q:\oro BbmycKB, 'ffiCJIJIl1\MXUI lIB 3TOM
C"Ie-re B MOMeHT Bbl)]p'ffi BbIill1C1U1, 4>a=B I1X 06peMeHEffiIH 06.H311TeJlb-
CTBar.rn. B TBIOKe J1HOMI1HC}XPMBIU1JI!, OTHOCJ'll11:eHCff I{ 3TI1M 6yMaraM.
KpoMe TOro, B 06J'i3BHH0CTl1 pen1C'"I}JaTopa BXOJUfT npe.IJ;1JC'"ffiBJIemte
3aperHC'"I1Jl1pOEaHHblM B CI1CTeMe Be)\elmJ'i peeCTpa BJIa.n;eJlbLIBM 11 .110-
MillIaJ1bHblM .IJ;epitffiTenJ'iM lteHHbIX 6YMar. BJIa.n;eIO 60nee lC1, rono-
CYIOIQMX aKl\ID1 3MJ:ITeH'TB, J\aHHbIX 113 peecTpa 06 liMeHl1 (Hal1MeHU3a-
ImH) 3BpeIJIC'I'PMPOBBHHbIX B peecTpe Bna.n;eJIbLleB H 0 KonH'IeCTBe,
KaTeropHH 11 l1OMHHaJ1bHOii C'TOJIMOCTIf npl1HB,IJ;J1emal1\l1X HM lteHHbIX
fiyMar, a TalOKE' I1Hc}x>pMJqJOBBlllIe 3aperHCTpHpoBaHHbIX B CHCTeMe Be-
;n;eHJ1J'i peecrpa BJ1B;D;€J1bI.teB 11 HOMHHanbHb!X .IJ;epmaTeJ1eii lteHHb!X 6y-
Mal' 0 npaBax, 3BRpenJJeHHldX lteHHbIMH 6:yMaraMl>1, 11 0 cnocof3ax 11 no-
pJi,!U\e ocy:w:eCTBneHIDI 3= npaB. EcJIJII pt'I11CTpaTOpOM HBJlH€TCH He
caMO ct'iIuec'mo, a cne IaJ1JI3I1pOB3.HHaJ'i opraHH3B1V1H, TO OHa nOMI1MO
3TOro OM3aHa .IJ;OBO)J;11Tb .IJ;O 3BPffI'lC'IPHpOBBHHbIX J1ffit Irn4xJPMBl\illO,
M)'I03M1rreHTOM.
KaK yme YKB3bmanOCb paHee, OTHorneHl1H, no
nOBo.ny 1rn4JoPMBL\HI1I13 peecTpB B1«!11OHepOB Me:1KJ]y 06Il\eCTBoM 11 aK-
L{I10HepaMV!, C'IPOJ'iTCJ'i no MO.I\eJlI1 06.H311TenbCTseHHbIX OTHorneHIDI.
IIpl1QeM JJ.JI.II mIX xapaKTepHa M1J())IOC'CTB€HOCTb cy6'beKTOB: cneltHa-
ml3l HHBH opraffi13aIJ;IDI, BbICTynaIOmBH .IJ;epmaTeneM peeCTpa.
liOMI1HBJlbHble .I\epmaTeJlI1 BKL\I1MI1 Tal{ ltaJIee.
K TpeTbeH caMOCTlJH'I'e.JIb I'pyIIrre CJIe;:JyeT OTHecThl o6.RaBHHOCThI
06mecTB3., re JI3 HeOfixoJ:tJIMOCTH coo6nJ.emm:3KL1UOHepaM 0
npOSe,lJ;eHlffi oomero cOOpam1H.
TaKOe CooOll\eHUe ,lJ;OJDKHO ObITb C,!:\eJ1aHO B Onpe.r:te.TIf2IiHblti CpoK - He
n03,IJ;Hee 'leM 3a 20 ):\He", 3 COCJfiIQemre 0 npose,lJ;emm oomero rof5pamm
aKQI10Hepos, nOBecTKa ,IJ;IDI KOTOporo CO,!:\epmJfT BOnpOC 0 peopraID13a-
ltI-'IU 06ll\ecTBa, - He n03):\Hee 'leM 3a 30 ):\He",IJ;o,l\aTbl ero npoae.r:temv:r.
B CJ1yqae, eCJllf noseCTKa ,lJ;HII coopaIDtl1 co,!:\epml1T BOnpoC 00 113-
OpaHI1J1 'UleHOB COBeTa .r:\I1p€KTOpoB (H3.fuJKJ,l\aTeJlbHOrO coBeTa), co06-
meHJ1e 0 npoBe,!J;eHJ1J1 BHeO'lepe,!J;Horo oOll\ero COOpaHJ1R aRQIlOHepOB
AOJDKHO ObITb C,IJ;eJUiHO He n03,lJ;Hee 'leM 3a 50 AHe" AO AaTbi ero npoBe-
AeHI1H (CT. CT. 52, 53 3aKoHa «0:5 aKlJ;110HepHblX »).
B }'Ka3aHHble CpoKJ1 coofuu;emre 0 npOBe,!:\eHJ1IIt 06ll\ero C06paHJ1R aK-
ltI-'IOHepOB .r:\OJDKHO ObITb HanpaBJleHO Kam,lJ;0MY IDJlIJT, yK83aHHOMY B
cnWCKe JIJ1l4 l1MeKJLW1X npaBO H8 yqacThle B 06meM c06p3.H11J1 <iKWrot£-
pOB (a 11M MOmeT ObITb He TOJIbKO 3KQI10Hep), 3aKa3HbIM ID1CbMOM, eCJlJ1
yCTaBoM o61l\ecrea He npeJ1YCMO"Ip€H WlO" CIloc06 H8npaBJIeIDIH 3TOro
coo6ll\eIDIH B nJ1CbMeHHow 4xJPMe, J1JIW spyqeHo I<a OMY 113 yK833.H-
HbIX.mfi.\nO.r:\pOCIIJ1Cb.mtDo, eCJIJ13TO YCTaBOM06meCT-
sa, Ony6Jn1KOBaHO B .r:\OCT)'IIHOM AJlH Bcex aKQJ1DHepoB 06mecTB3. ne'laT-
HOM 1 1, onp€,/:\eJIeHHOM YCTaBOM 06ll\ecTsa. 06ll\ecTBO BIIpaBe
.iIJIIDJlHlfieJIbHO HH4x>JJMi'IIXE8Tb aKQI10HepoB 0 npOBe)J;eHID1 o6mero
c06paHHH aKqI10HepOB '1epe311Hble cpe)J;cTBa MaeCOBOW Wlct>oPMalU1J1.
II.YHKT 3 CT. 52 3aKOlJa «0:5 8KQJ10HepHbIX 06mecTB3.x» crIpeJleJlJleT
nepe'leHb I1:H4JoPMaqIrn, nO)J.JIe:1Kamew npe,l:\OC"ffiBJIeHHKJ BblllleyKa-
3aHHbIM Jll1QaM npJ1 I1QIVOTCJBRe K IIpOBe.J1€HlOO oomero COOpaHiUl. 3Ta
WlC}X>PMaQIDI B Te'leHl1e 20 ):\He", a B cnyqae npoBe)J;emm 06ll\ero co-
6paHI1H a IDHepoB, nOBeCTKa.lU1H KOTOporo CO,lJ;ep:>KJ1T Bonpoc 0 peop-
raHl13aQID1 00mec'ma. B TeqeHUe 30 AHe" AO npoBeAeH11J1 06ll\ero co-
6pamrn aKQI10HepoB )J;OJIJroJa ObITb )J;ocryJIHa JlJ1'--\8M, I1MelOJl\I1M npaBo
Ha yqacThle B HeM,.IJ,J1H 03H3.K0MJ1eHJ1J1 B nOMemeHl1I1l1U1O.11111fTeJ1bHoro
opraHa OOll\eCTSa I1I1HbIX M€CTax, <v\peca KOTOpblX yK83aHbI B CooOll\e-
HHJ1 0 npuBe.r:\eID1U 06ll\ero crl5paHmL YI\a3aHHaH ln$JPMaltl-'lH (MaTe-
pJ1aJ1b1) AOJDKHa 6bITb .n;OCTynH3. J1I1'--\8M, npUHJ1MaJO yq8CTJ1e B 06-
meM coopaHl1U 8KQJ10HepOB, TaIOKe JiI BO BpeMfl ero npoBe.J1€HlUL
o:5ll\ecTBO 06fl3aHO no "Ipe60saHioo JlJ1u;8, I1MelOLll,ero npaBO H3. yqac-
me B 06ll\eM c06paHIDI <iKWurepoB, npe.JlOCTClBl'lTb eMY KOIIID1 yK83aH-
HbIX ,l:\oK)'MeHTOB. llnaTa, B3J1M8eMaH 06mecTBOM 3a OCTI':IBJIE'HJ:Ie
,l\aHHbIX KOID-li1, He MomeT npeBbIW8Tb 3a"IpaTbl Ha HX Jil3I'0TOBJleIDIe.
IIytIKTOM 3.8 IIonomeHl1fl 0 ,l:IOII).I1ID1T '1'pE'6c.ea1mfl It nopR.wq
nQJJ;rOTOBKJ1, C03bIBa U npoBe.ll£HiUl 06mero coI5paHl1H
I«>HKpeTlf3lIpOBaHO, 'ITO KOmDI .n;OJl}KJJbl 6bITb npe,!:\OCTaBJIeHbI IDJlIJT s
-112-
Te'leHHe 5 }];Heti C J\aTbI IIOC'"l)lIIJIEH B 06ll-\ecTBo Tpe60muillR, ecJIJ160-
nee RO CpOK He npe,ll.)'CMOTpeH YCTaBOM oOll-\eCTBa IfJI11 BHYI'peH-
HI1M peryJIHpyIOIII;illIoI,l\£'H'l'eJIhRXoOtqeroc06paHl15L
ComaCHO n. 4 CT. 51 3aRoHa «06 aKl.tHOHepHbIX oOtqecTBax» ('IBIC(E
J1Mll, J1MelOLJtI1X npaBO Ha yqaCTJ1e B OOl1\eM coopamm aKJtI10HepoB.
npeJ\ocTaBJlfIeTCH oOtqeCTBoM JI.IlH 03HaKOMJIeHlliI no -rpe6oBaHmo .ID1Q,
BI\J1lO'1€HHldX B:oITOT CIlHCOK J1 He MeHee ..eM lC1.rOJ1ocoB.
IIpJ1 :oITOM ]:\aHHble ,QOKyMeHTOB J1 I1O'ITOBbl11 a;:q>ec 4>113J1'1ecKHX .ID1Q,
BKJnO'IeHHbIX B :oIT0T CIIJ1COK, npe.n;ocTaBJLIIIOTCR TOJIbKO C cornaclliI
:iTJ1X nHQ. IIo Tpe6oBaHJ1IO .mo6oro 3aHHrepecoBaHHoro J1HQa ootqecTBo
B Te'leH11e TpeX }];Hen oOH3aHO npe.r\OC'ICIBI1 eMY BbIIIJ1CKY J13 CIll1CKa
JIHQ., J1MeIOLJtI1X npaBo Ha y<Jacn!e B OOl1\eM C06paHI1I1 aRQJ10HepoB, co-
;ztepmaI1.fj'1O ;ztaHHbIe 06 STOM nJ1Qe, I1J!1II cnpaBKY 0 TOM, 'ITO OHO He
BKJIIO'IeHO B CnJ1COK.1ll1:Q, J1MeIOLJtI1X npaBO Ha y<JaCTJ1e B OOl1\eM co6pa-
HI1J1 aKQJ1OHepoB.
HecBoespeMeHHoe I13BffIt€HHe JII160 H613EJelIt€IDft! aK.QJ10Hepa 0 A8-
Te IIpOBeJ\€Hl1R 06tqero co6paHlU! J1 H€IIpe]:\OC'l3BJ11?Hlte
03HaROMJIeHJ1$1 C HeoI5.xo,wlMOii In<<}x:pMaQReii: MOryr Cny)KJ1Tb OCHOBa-
HlU!MYI}J)UI npl13HaHlU! perneHlliI 06mero co6paHlU! He,n;efICTBJ1TeJIbHbIM.
J1 TaKl1e cnopbI 0 npl13HaHJ1J1 perneHl1i1: 06LJt11X co6paHJriii He,n;eHcTmt:-
TeJIbHbIMH J1MeHHO no MOTI>1BaM HeJ1:3BeII{ellJ1R J1ID1 HeCBOespeMeHHoro
J13SemeHlliI aKQI10HepOS I1JII1 Henpe.u;ocraBJIeHl1H B03MI:DKHIJCTII 03HaKO-
MJ1TbCff C J1H4>oPMaI<l1eti: J1 COCTaBJIHK1r 6o.JrbllIJ1HCTBO B
06tqeti: Macce J1CKOB 0 IIpJI3II3HID'1 He,n;eUCTBJITeJIbHblMl( pellEHlm: 06-
LJtI1X co6paHl1i1:.
TaR, KOMTIamm «Mera-Tpetf.1:1 IInf JIT;zt» 06paTJ1J1aCb B ap6J1Tpam-
Hbrn cy,n; C J1CKOM R A03T «Mera-M» (s HaCTOHIQe€ BpeMR OAO «Me-
1'8- M») 0 I1pJI3HaHJ1J1 He;ztei1cTBMTeJIbHbIM peWelnfR BHeO'lepe.n;Horo 06-
llIero c06paH11fl 8KqJ:1OHepOB A03T «Mera-M» or 22 oKTmpn200l r.O
npo.!\ame He}J.BIDKJ1MOro , paCnOJ1illKeHHoro no 8,n;pecy:
MocKBa, YJl CpeTeHKa,,n;. 13/26, cTp.l J1 yn. XMenesa,,n;. 26, cTp.4, J1 06
yrsepm,!\emrn pHHO'BIOii CTOI1MOCTIf OT'IYm,!\aeMoro lfMYll-IeCTBa, B
o60cHoBaHJ1e CBOI1X Tpe60saHJ1ti CCbIJIaHCb Ha TO, 'ITO J1CTeQ He 6bIJI J13-
BeIQeH 0 npose.!\eHI-fH co6paHl1Jl, HeCMO'IpR Ha TO, 'ITO BJla,!teeT 50"h aR-
QIDi ootqeCTsa, '1eM 6bIJII-f HapyrneHbI ero IIpaBa.
Y,IJ.OEI.11€TBOpHH J1CIWBbIe 'I'pe60saHJ1R, nepsaR J1 aneJLIIHQI10HHaJ'l J1H-
craHQJ1J1 Ap6Krpa»auo CYA8 r. MocKSbl J1CXO,!tl-fJ1l-f J13 TOro, 'ITO npaBa
J1CTQa 6blJill HapyrneHb!, IIIJCKO.JIbKy OH He 6bIJI J13aeIl\eH O]:\aTe npDae-
;zteHWI BHeO'lepe.!\Horo 06ll.\€ro 006paHW1 aKQJ10HepOB, no noao,ll.)' KOTO-
poro B03HJ1KCnOp.JJ;aHHbrnq>aKT nO,!lTBepm,!\eHMaTe-
pna.TIaW1 ,!lena. Y HHoe HapyrneHlfe c6ocHosaHHO IIplf3HaHO CYAOM
-113-
cyIQECTBeHHHM, TaK KaK IfcreD; BJIaJJ;eeT 5U'b aKWrl1 oDIl\eC"I'Ba, If IIpIf
yqacTI111 B rQJ10COBaID11f OR Mor IIOBJIImn. Ha pe3ynhTaTbI ronOCCl3aHJ1fL
llcxoJI.H If3 :noro, <PeJlepaJIbHbrn ap:iInpamm.n1 cy,l\ MOCKOBCKOro
oKpyra OCTaBIUI CY,l\eDHbIe aKTbI, BhIHeCeHHble npeJlb J1I1HC1'aH-
QJ1J1M11 De3 Jl3MeHemrn. 250
PaCCMaTpmmeM1UI rpyniia OTHOlliemfii, no nOBOJ\Y
l1H,popMalUBI, HaCTOnhKO 6.n KO npJ1MhIKaeT K OTIJOweHI1J1M, CBJ'l3aH-
HbIMCyqac'I'deM poBBODll-!eMCODpaID1lf, "TOn He-
OT,l\eJIJ1Ma OT HI1X, JI B CB.fI31f C 3T11M HOCIfT KoprIOpaTI'1BHWl xapaKTep,
KaK JI caMIf OTHOWeHI1J1, CB.II3aHHbIe C yqacrneM B 06Il\eM co6pamU'L
II nOCJ1e,l\HIOIO, ..eTBepT)'IO rpyrmy 06H3aHHOCTeif aK:qI10HepHoro 06-
lL\eCTBa no lIpe,l\OCTaBneHlOO l1H,popMaW1l1 COCTaBJIHIOT c.fur3atnrocTp
no npe,!J;OCTaBneHI1IO aK:ql10HepaM ,l\OK)'MeHTOB o6JuecTBa. nepe'leHb
KOropbIX onpe,!J;eneH CT_ 89 3aKoHa «06 aK:qI10HepHbIX ODIl\ecTBax»
CornaCHO CT. 91 3aKOHa «06 aK:u;J10HepfiblX 06lL\t:'CTB8X". oDlL\eCTBO
06H3aHo oDecne<rnTb aK4lfOHepBM ,l\OCTyn K ,l\OK)'MeHTaM, npe.l\YCMOT-
peHHbIM n. 1 CT_ 89 3roro JKe 3aKoHa. IIpe}J,CmBJlReTCH, 'ITO 3.K1U«H€pbI
HMelOT ,l\oCTyl1 It ,l\OK)'MeHTaM He TOJIbKO TeK)'lLI€ro ro,u,a, HO If 1Ip0WJIhIX
neT, KOTOpble B coarBeTCI'BI1Jl CO CT_ 89 3aKOHa oDlL\eCTBO OM3aHO xpa.-
IDITb. K ,l\OK)'MeHTaM 6yxranTepcKOro yqe'I'a JI npoTOKOJraM 33.ce.n;aID-1i1
KOJIJII2['ItaJIHOro HCIIJJllIH1'eJl opraHa HMelOT npaBO ,l\OCT)'II1i aK:ql1-
OHepbI (aK:qI1OHep), JlMeKIl!I1e B He MeHee 25lD ro.rrocym-
ll{I1X aKW1i1 06Il\ecTBa. am nonomeHJIIe n. 1 CT. 91 3aKOHa He npOTlfBope-
'lIIT CT_ 67 rK p . cornaCHO KOTOpOif yqacTIrnKI>1 X03HikmeIilDl'O
TOBapl1II.\ecTBa I1Jll1 ODIl\ecTBa BnpaBe IIOJI)"-ffiTb I1H,poPMaWfiO 0 ,l\eH-
TeJIbHOCTJ1 TOBapl1II.\ecTBa I1Jll1 06Il\eCTBa, B TOM 'lI1CJIe 3HaKOM11TbCH C
ero6yxra.n-repcRl(MIKH11I'aMI>1IfMHotillOK)'MelffiIQJ1eti B
yqpe.lU1Te.I1bJIbIMJ:1 ,l\OK)'MeHTaMl1 nOpH;zu<e,1IiCR011bI\Y He npeIIJITCTByeT
peaJThl31ilV'fi'I npaBa aK:u;I-10Hepa Ha MHtPJpMa:qIDO, a JII1llTh YCTaHaRID1Ba-
eT orpaHWIeHl1J1. ManmoMycw.HOBJIeID1HTaKI1X orpa.-
ml'lE:'fllfA HBJI.IIe'I'CJ'l33.lJ.tI1Ta KOH:}:> JIH$JpMawm 06Il.\€CT-
B<L TaK, ec.m;: Dbi He OhLl1 ycraHOBJ1eH MtfH11MYM B 2ff'c ronoc)'IOIl\11X
aKWm. I,[J,JlH ,I:\OCTynaK,I:\OKyMeHTaM6yxran-
TepcKoro yqe'I'a, yre'lKa O,l\eJ!'I'eJ1bHOC'IJ 06Il\ecTBa Ob1J1a
Dbi B03MOmHa B cJI.Y'lae np]IJoope-reffi1H, uaIIpI-fMep, KOHKYJIE'H'I"OM, He-
3Ha'JJIT€.JlND'O'lI1CnaaK:u;l1tiJlInonyqeHJIIHHM,I:\OCTyna K
B TO JKe BpeMJ'l II. 4 CT_ 3aKOHa «0 6yxramepcKoM yqeTe»
yCTaIiDBJI€HO, 'ITocQ.I\ep ffi1e pernCTpOB 6yxramepcKOroyqe'I'a JII BHY-
Tpelllieti 6yxraJrreJxKofI crrqernocrn HBJIHeTCR TaibKn:l
JlJ1::u;a, IIO.ITy'IJIIBIl1elloCTynKJIII1$JJ:MCIQI1I1, B::m1X,l\O-
KyMeHTaX, ODH3aHb! XpaHlITb KOMMep<reCKyKJ TaitHy
-114-
C,lIpyroif CTOpOHbI, )'KR38.HHOe RDJIIf'-IeCTIJeHHOe orpmrnqeffi1e MmKeT
J1MeTb CJI OIpaIDf'leHl1e,llpyI'l1X npaB, YCnDBl1eM ocy1QE'C'I'BJ1(
HI1.H KOTOpbIXSIB,lliIeTCII 06JI Hl1e J1H4x:JpMaW'Ieif. TaK, OIpaHI1'fl1B1HQT-
CfI B03Moma>cTH aE1VI<EepOB, BJ111,!J;elOlLtI1X I naKeTallrn 3K-
J.tI1M, AJUI npHBJJe'leIDm It arneTCTBeH1IOC' 11CIDJ1lI1'1'T(' opraHOB
OOIl\ecrBa, ]:\eiiic::rm'1H KOTOpbIX npl1'lJ1IDfJIl1 y6bITKI1 noc.rre}J;HeM)'.
B CJI)"-Jae J1cnOJIb30BaHI1J1 B OTHOWeHIlII OT1q>bITOI'O OOIl\ecTBa cne-
QI-faJIbIU'O npmm Ha )"-JacTI1e POCCI1rrlCl\fJii aQlnr. cy6"beKTa POC-
CJorlicJ«JH CPe.n;epau;mt J1JI11 MYHJ:n RII3J]bHYO 06pa30Baffi1J1 B yrrp3.BJIe-
HI--II-f YKa3aHHblM 06ll\ecTBoM (<<3OJ10Taf1 3KL\I1J1») TaKOe 06ll\ecTBo
06ecIle'll1Bae-r npe.l\CTaBJITeTI.f1M POCC!1tfCKOi1 4Ie.n;epau;mt, cy&beKTa
PoccIDic:I«Jji cpe.n;epaLJ;ID1 J1IDI M)'HVlLU--lIlaJIbHOrO 06pa30BaHHH .n;ocr)'II ItO
seeM CBOJ1M.n;OK)'MeHTaM. TaKI1M oopaaOM, CJIe;JyeT BbIBO):t '1TO I1yfuIJ1'-I-
Ho-npaBOBbJe OOpa30BaHIDI, TaKl1e, KaK POCCfl:iiCRaJI cpe.n;epaIJ;l1J1, ee
cy6"beKTbI J1 M)'HIIW1fIaJIbHb1e 06pa3OB8.llRfI, XOTJlI1 BbICT)'IIaIOT HaK 3R-
QIfOHepbI HapaBHe C cy6"beKTIlMl1'1aCTHoro npaBa, see JKe I1MelOT 3Ha'll1-
TeJibHOe B npaBe Ha .n;ocr)'II K ,n;OK)'MeHT3M 06 CTBa,
'1TO, 6e3yCJ1CEHO. He COOTBeTCTByeT IJPI'1Hl<IIIiaJ'II 3KQJ10HepHOro npaBa.
CornaCHO n. 2 CT. 88 3aKOHa «06 3KQJ10HepHbIX ofuq:c-rnax» OTBeT-
CTBeHHOCTb 3a o uo, ff.ICTOHHIte 11 ,n;oCToBepHOCTb oyxra.n-rep-
CKOro yqeTa B , 3 TaIDKe CBe]:IelIIrlio.n;eHTeJIbHoCTI106 CTBa,
npe}J;C'"ffiBJIHeM aKLIIWJHepaM, Kpe}J;l'ITOpaM 11 B cpe.n;CTBa MaccoBoi1
I1Hct>oPMaQm1, HeceT 11CI1O.JIHIfi"e opraH OOIl\ecTBa B COOTBeTCT-
BI1I1 C TeM JKe 3aKOHOM, I1HbIM11 rrpaBOBbIMI1 aKTaMl1 POCCIID::I«JJI cpe,n;e-
pau;mt11 YCTaBOM OOmeCTBa.
IIoMMl'o'IO nepe'LIlU1 CBe)J;eHIdi, YCTaHOBJIeH1lOro B n 1 CT. 89 3aKOHa
«06 3KQJ10HepHbIX 06ll\ec'fB1lX , OOIl\eCTBO MO:meT aK-
QIfOHepy l1,l1pyrue CBe,I\eHIDI. BMecTe C TeM aKL\I1UIepaM He Mor)'T npe-
,n;OCT3BJIJITbCJlcneJ1eHW1, roCY,IlapCTBeHH)'IOTaAHy.
Jl)UI MaKCl--lMaJIbHOro 06ecrre'leHIDI IIpaBa aKL\l10HepCm Ha .n;ocr)'II K
I1Hct>oPMaLJ;ID1 0 ,I\emeJIbHOCTl1 OOIl\ecTBa IJ'JCJIe,J:UlJ1M ;zJ;OJDKHbI paapa6a-
TbmaTbCJ1BH)'TpE'HIDleHOpMaTl1BHbre OOll\e-
CTBO MO:>KE'T pa3pa5o-raTb lJOm.l)J-(ft{Jf 0 KOMMep"lecKOi1"l3MHe. B KOTopoM
on 1Cb 6bJ CBe,I\eHl1.H, It Heti: onIoc eCJI J1 He nO,!tJ1e:>Ka e
npe.Jlf)CTaBJ1E'H lillf}JOKOM)' KpYI'Y 3KL\I10HepoB.
IIepe'l€Hb CBe.n;eHID1, COCTaBJlffiOlL\IlX KOMMepqeCKyKJ TaAHy, AJUI
Kai1\,ZJ;oro 3KL\110HepHoro 06Il\€cTBa MC»KeT Obrrb pa3HbIM. Ho OObI'lHO OH
BKJIICI'Ia€T CBe,n;eH UI TeXffi1'leCKOrO, rrpoH3E1O,I\C'l'B€HHOro (qepreJiG1:,
Mo.n;eJU1, peL\efITbI, WT3MIIbI) 11 ,I\eJIOBoro xapaKTepa (K1maJibI IIOt"'IaBKR
J1 CObrra, cmlCOK KJIl1eHTOB, TeKCTbI ,I\oroBopcm), J1MelOll\I1e Ba%HOe 3Ha-
'leffi1e )J;JIJI ofJecneqeHIDI rrpel1M)'llJ;eCTB OOIl\ecTBa B KOHKypeHTHOi1
60pb6e Ha pbIHKe 2S1
-115-
HeCMOTpHHa npHMOe )'KB.3aHl1e 3aKOHa ,,06sKl\l1oHepHbIX06ll-\ecT-
BaX» Ha npaKTl1Ke AOSOJ1hHO 'laCTO SCTpe'lalOTCH CJ1)"lIDf YKJlOHemm
06r.u;ecTB OT npeAOC"ffiBJ1eHI1H Heo6xo 1X aRqI>-IOHepaM,l:PR}'MelITOB.
TaR, 06ll-\ecTBo «Hi1MeraH Tpeti;:tl-fm JII1MJ1'I'€,!\», RaR aKL\I10Hep OAO
"PATEll», 06paTMJIOCb B Ap6wrpamHbli-f cY11. MociooBcIoc:i-f o6J1aCTI1 C
I1CKOM K GAO "PATEll» 06 06H3aHIDI OTBeT'IKKa npeAOCTaBl1Th ,!\OKY-
Membl, Racarouvl€Cfl era 11.eHTeJ1HJOCTJ'J RaKaKIV10HepHoro 06IL1eCTsa B
COO"l13eTCTI3Jfi1 COCT. 67 rKP<:p, CT. CT. 89-91 cpe.n;epaJ1hHoro 3aKOHa ({06
8KL\I10HepHbIX 06ll-\eCTBaX» 11 CT. 23 cpe.n;ep8J1bHoro 38KOHa ,,0 pbIHKe
LleHHblX 5)'Mar».
PerneHl1eM Ap6:W1'pamHoro CYfllllv1ocKonclroJl o6J1acTltI OT 19 asryc-
T3. 2002 1'. OTBeT'il-'lK 06R3aH npeAOCT8ElITb HC'r1.\Y 33, ruraT)' B AeCJi'TI1-
AHeBHb1J:i CpOK C MOMema BCTyru:reHW! perneHI--1R B 3aKaJHY1O CJ.-IJ1Y Ha,II-
.neJKaLql1M 06paaoM aaBepeHHbIe Komrn cJ1e)J;y}OLqI1x ,n;oK)'MeHTOs:
YCT3.s0AO "PATEll» co BCeMl1l13MetIeIDlHMJll1 1 Ha
TeKyruJ'IO flllTY; perneHl1e 0 em coa.n;amrn; CBIf,l\eTeJIbCT 0 rocy,n;apCT-
B€HHOJ:i pel'l1C'rpaL{V:!11 OAO "PATEl!»; ,n;oK)'MeHTbI, m,IJ;'l'Be
npaBa o61l\ecTBa Ha J1M)'1Q€CTBO, Ha em 63.JIaHCe; mJJ!o-
:HreHl1e 06 06ll-\eM co6paHl1Y! aKL\I10HepOB, nOJ1mKeH11e 0 COBere ,D;YIp€K-
TOpoB GAO "PATEl!»; n0J10:1KeHl1e 0 npaBJIeHl1I1 GAG "PATEll»,
IDJIfJ)R'eIIJfe 0 PeBlf3J1()HH)if I«)MJK'CY!IIGAO"PATEII»; ro.n;OBo:i4f}JI1HaH-
COBbrn: OT'-Ie'f 3a 2000-2001 IT.; npocneKT ccm:1 aKW1i1 OAO "PA-
TEll»; CID1COKactxPI1JIJllpoBaHHbIXJll1QGAO «PATEl!» C )'KB.33.HI1eMRa-
reropJIIJII(TI1IIa) npl1HaMeJKalQY!X 11M aKW1i1; aaKITIO'lem1e pml1314OHHOii
KOMJ'ICCIDI GAG «PATEn K ro.n;OBOM)' C06paHl1IO 2000-2001 IT; npOTO-
Kon 06IL1ero co6pamm aKIV1oHepos GAO "PATEll}} OT 24 MaR 2002 1'_,
5IOJIJIeTeHl1 aKl1IWJHepcl3, I'OJIOC(IJaBlIIIX Iffi 06r.u;eM co6pamrn aKIV10He-
pos GAG "PATEII» 24 MaR 2002 r.; ,lJ;OsepeHHOCTI1,1J;JIJ'I I'OJIiCOBa1OO'I
(KOmrn: AosepeHHocTeA) Ha yqacTltle B 06r.u;eM c06paHl111/ aKqJ:1OHepOB
GAG «PATEll» 24 MaH 2002 1'.; CID1COK JIHQ, II/MelOLW1X npaBO Iffi yqac-
me B 06ll-\eM co6pamrn aKQJ«JHepoB GAG "PATEII» 24 MaR 2002 r.; 33,-
KJllO'IeHl1e aYJP1TOpa GAG "PATEll» K m,!\OBOM)' 06ll-\eMY co6paHl1IO
8KIV10HepoS OAO "PATEII» 24 MaR 2002 1'.
llOCT3.HOBJleHl1eM aneJ1.JUIQIf()I I1HCTaHQJ1JI Ap6l1TpamHOra cy1J.8
1v1ocKoocKoJ1 06JIaCTI1 OT 15 H0JI6pH 2002 1'. perneH11e OT 19 aarycra 2002 1'.
OCT8BJ1eHO 6e31131\112HeHWL
Y,lJ;OBJ1e'I'BOpRH I1CKOBbIe Tj)e60saH11R, c nepBOA 11/ aneJ1.J1RQI10H-
ICQJ:i I1HCT8HlUfit: H J13 TOro, 'lTO I1CTeQ HBJlHeTCR 3KIV10HepOM
GAO "p ATEII» 11 OTBeT'IlI/X 06R3aH B CI1J1y npHMoro yKa3aHl1R 3aKOHa
npe,l\CT8B11Tb €MY UC'I'pe6yeMbie 11M ,lJ;OK)'MeHThI, 0"rn('J('.J'ill-\Jr K ,lJ;eE-
T€JJbHQCTI1 3KQJ110HepHOro 06ll-\eCTBa. KpoMe TOro, I1CTQOM,,IJ;O paccMOT-
peHM HaCTORll\eI'O cnopa, 6bWla onna'ieHa C'IOHMOCll> I13TOTOSJI€HI1R
-116-
3U1X JJPK)'MetITOR O,D;HatOO OTBeT'rnK )'KJIOHReTCR OT J1X nepe,!\a'II1I1CT-
10'. BMeCTe C TeM, OTKa3blBaR B Y,lI1JUlemopemrn I1CKOBhlX 'I'j)e600a.mDi
B '<IaCTh! nepe,lW'lli I1CTIU' nOJIO:m:eID1R 0 l.{eHlIhIX 6yMarax 06r.qeCTBa 11
I1pO'I'OR011a c'Iemow KOMI1CCJn1 06 JI'IOI'a" I'OJ1OCOBaID-1R Ha 06ll\eM co-
6pam1l1 aKI.tJlOHepoB OAG «PATEll» 24 Mct11 2002 r., CY,lJ;h! neJEOii 11
ane.JI.JIHql(fJlHOJll1HCTalll.{I'm: npMllIJIl1 K BhffiO,D;y, 'ITO npeAOC"ffiBJIeHJte
yKa3aHHhIX ,lJ;OK)'MeHTOB He .fIB.IDleTCR 06fi3a1!HCIC'I'bK) O'I'BeT'-Ji1Ka B CI1J1Y
cr. 89 3aKOHa «06 al\.Ql10HepHbIX of3IQecTBax».
CY'leTOMI13JIO:>KeHHoroCPe)J;epa.m:Hltlii:a cyp,MoCKoB-
CKOro oKpyra OCTaBI1J1 6e3 113MeHeHJ1R cyp,e6Hb1e aKTb1 npe,!I,b1,!\ytWtX
UHCTalJ1tIJiii, a KaCCal.{l1Olrnyro ma.rr06y 6e3 YP,OBJIE'TBope:m1R. 252
XapaKT€pl13yHIIOCJI€p,H!OK)rpynnyOTHoWeHl1W,
no nOBo,!ly non)"leHl-1R aKQJ«JHepaMi1 P.OK)'M€H'IOB 06ll\ecTBa, onpe,lJ;e-
neHHblX CT. 89 3aKoHa «06 aKl!l10HepHbIx Cifur{ecTBax», cne,!lyeT CKa-
3aTb, '<ITO OHl1 HBJIHIOTCR KOpnOpaTl1BHblMl1 no CBOeH KI
npl1po,!\e. Peanl13YRcBoe npaBOHa no.rryqeHl1eJ f, aKl.{I10Hep
sblcrynaeT S Ka'<leCTBe cy6'beKTa ynpaBneHJilR no OTHOllleHillO K aKl!l1-
oHepHoMY OOll\eCTBY, nocKOJlhKY ynpaBJIeHl1e 06'beKTOM HeMhlCJ1I1MO
6e3 pMal.{I11iI 0 HeM.
B cct>epe OTHOllleHJl!i1, CKJIap,blBaKlll\l1XCH no nOBo,!ly npas aKl.{l10He-
poB Ha I1H4JoPMal.{l11O, nocnep,Hlle He TOJlbKO l1MelOT J1hBJ1HYlO JlOJ1lO
npaB B cpaBHeHID:! C o6nrecTBOM. HO 11 HecyT 06H3aHHocTI1 no npellC'ItiB-
J1eHJOO I1H4JoPMaIJ;Jrn.
HaOCHOBaRJornIL 5 cr.443aKOHa «06aKQWoHepHb1X ,JIillJ;O,
3aperl1CTp1:pOO1lHtU€ B peecTpe aK!!JWHEPOB 06ll\ecTBa, 06H3aHO CBOeape-
MelillO l1H<lJopr.rnpoBaTh ,lJ;epmaTeJU1 peecrpa HE'poB 06ll\ecTBa 06
ICM£HeHIfi:! CBOI1X ,lWHHbIX. B c.rryqae HBIpeJIC'ffiBJI€HJU 11M I1lI4JoPMal.{Ml1
06l13MEfJerom: CBOI1X ,lI,aHHhlX 061l\€C'I'B0 11 perncrpaTOp He HecyrOTBeTCT-
BE'HHOCTh! 3a npl1'll1HeHHble B CM311 C 3TI1M y6hITKJ1. CorJIaCHO n. :3
cr. 8 3aKOHa «0 pbIHKe l.{eHHhIX 6yMar» JII1l.{Y, HeHa.!lJle-
:mallIee I«.'IJ'JJIHE:f nopR,!!,Ka n 1R CI1CTeMbI BE',lJ;eHl1F! 11 cocraB-
neH11l1 peecrpa 11 Hap)'llleHl1e 4xJPM OT<!eTHOCI'I-f (3IDl"remy, pernCTpaTO-
Py, p,en03I1TapJ1lO, BJI3,/:\eJlIt4y), MO:>KeT 6hITh npe,!\'bHBJ1eH I1CK 0
t}'lll;ep6a(BKJIJO'IaRynyIL\eHHYKJBb1I"O;Iy),B03HI1KllIeroI13He-
B03MO:>KHOCTI1 OCYll\eCTBl1Th IIpaBa, 3aKpeIIJ1eHHble l.{eHHblMl16yMaraMl1.
COrJIaCHO CT. 82 3aKOHa «06 aKL[ltOtlt:'pIltlX ,,» J1l1Qa, yKa-
3aHHble B CT. 81 3TOro 3aKoHa (a cpe,!\11 Hi1X ct>JnypMpyIOT 11 al\.Ql10Hepbl
06Il\eCTBa, J1M€ICU{Ite COBMeCTHO C a4x}:!nm1}XJBaHHb1MJ:1 .JIJ1I<aMl1 20 11
60JIee IIpOQftITOB ronoCyKJll\I1X aKQwi1 ofuQecTsa), ofu:!3aHItJ:,n;oBeCTI1,lJ;O
CBe;:J;eHIDI COBE'Ta Jll1peKTopoB (Hafimo,!\aTeJlbHOro cOBeTa) 06ll\ecTBa,
peBu3l1OHHoi1 KOMItCCIDI (peBI130pa) o61l\ecma 11 aYJII1Topa o61l\ecma
I1H4JoPMaL\I1IO'
_117_
- 0 rop IX.ID1QaX, B KOTOpbIX OHM BJIa)\eIOTCaMOCTOJITeJIbH)
I1J1I1 COBMeCTHO CO CBOI1M b!M ..Tllfi.\OM (J1I1'--!aMI1) 20 :J1J111
60JIee npou;eHTaMl1 1XaKQI1i1 (AOJIeii, naeB);
- 0 IDpUJ];l('I€CKl1X J1J.-1Qax, B opraHax ynpaBJ1eHJ.-1F! KOTOPbIX OHJ.-I 3a-
H11MalOT
- 06 H3BeCTHbIX 11M cOBepWaeMbIX J1ID1 npep;no.narneMbIX
B IWTOpblX OHJ1 Moryr 5brrb npJ.-l3HaHbl 3aJ.-lHTepeCOBaHHblMJ.-I J1JIQaMH.
KpoMe TOro, Ha OCHOBaHH11 CT. 93 TOro me 3aKoHa a -
Hble..Tllfi.\a o51l\ecma ofu!3aHu B IDICbM€HHOi1 $:JpMe yse,!\oMl1Tb 06ll\e-
CTBOO nPJIHa,l\JIe.»\a1.I..\J.-lX 11M aKLtI-'Iffi{ 06ll\ecTBa C YKa3aHJ1eM J1X IwnJ.-l-
'1eCTBa 11 KaTeropJ1tf (TI1IIOB) He n03JtHee 10 ,WIen CO,WIfl nplf06peTeHW1
8KLtI-'Ii1. B CJ1)"'1ae, eCJiH B pe3YJlbT8Te HI1.FI no BJ1He a4J-
iPl1J1J1poBaHHOro J1J.-1Qa yxaaaHHoi1I1H4JopMa m J1J1J1 HeCBoeBpeMeHHo-
ro €e npe,!\OCTaBJIeHMH 051l\€CTBy npWlliHeH J1M)'1l1eCTBeHHbm yll\ep6,
aqxp:UUIpOBaHHOe J1I1I.\O HeC€T nepe,!\ 06ll\eCTBoM OTBeTC'I'BeHHOCTb B
pa:3Mepe npWlI1HeHHoro YIl\ep6a.
B CBH3J1 C pac<:MOTpeHiteM npaB 8KLtI-'IOHepa Ha J1H4JoPMal{J1lO Hel13-
6e:>KH0 3aTparnsaeTCH JfM 1 orpOMHoe 3Ha'leHl1e Ha npaKTI1Ke BO-
npoc 06 06H3aHHOCTl1 aKLtI-'IOHepa no KOmtnfAeHiU'ffiJIbHOH
-
'laCTb 2 CT. 67 rR Pg:. 05H3b1BaeT Y"!aCTHI1KOB XfJ3.flfw::rneHHblX "1'0-
sapID1J;eCTB J1 06ll\eCTB nOMl1MO BHeceHWI BKJla.n;a B YCTaBHbm KalIl1TaJI
He pa3r.naW8Tb 1IDt«PQ:\€IflU(aJIbH)'KJ J1HclJopMaUyno 0 JJ;eHTeJlbHOCTlli
"I'OBapl1ll\eCTBa J1ID:! 061l\eCTBa.
KaK COBeplllEHHO BepHo OTMe'-Ia€T .n.B. JIOMaKl1H, 3TY 06H3aHHocTh
HecyT He "I'OJ1bKO aKQl10Hepbl, a Bce JIMlIa, KOTOpbIM TaKafl J1HtPoPMaLtl-'lfl
CTaJ1a I13BeCTHa B CJ1JiY I1X paDOTb! J1JIJ1 'lJIeHCrna B aKQl10HepHOM 06-
ll\eCTBe. 3To MOryT 5brrb J1 Je JJ;OJDKHOCTHbIe J1l1L1a, J1 J1HQJ,
npO,!\aBweeCBOM aKlti"fi'l,06fl3aHHOe TbCIlOT pa3rJ1arnemm
no.rryqeHHbIX paHee CBeJlemdi, TaK KaK:J1X 06Hapo,!\OBam:re MO:IKeT no-
BJ1e'-Jb 3a c060n Ylllep6 AJlfl 06I.I.\€CTBa. II03ToMYo6H3a1mocTb no coxpa-
HeHIDQ IIDm}:I.me Hon 11H4JoPMaL\IDI 06 061l\eCTBe He .J1BJ1I1eTCfl
Co.n;epiKam:r€M aKLtI-'IOH€pHoro I1pG.BCXJ'IH1W€HWi, a 06yc.mJB.Jnma€TCfl
.Iq)yrJ1MJll iPaKTOpaMJ.-I. 253
lo.A. MeTenesa TIlIOKE' pa3,1J;eJ1ReT 3TY"l'O<m:y 3peHJ1JI:J1 C'll1TaeT, '1TO
OJtHOTOJlbIW HaJIWiJ.-leaKLIJ.-lOHepHbIXnpaElOOTIlC1l1eHi'lii Me JlI1QOM J1
o6utec'moM caMO no ce6e He J!BJ1ReTCH OCH'JBaHJreM AJlfl nOJ1)"-1effiifl
nepBbIM KrH}:>H,l\€HQt18.IIbHml J1HtPoPMaW-m 0 BTOpOM. TaKl1M 06pa30M,
06fl3aHJ1e 8KLIJ.-IOHepOB K Hepa3rJIaWemno IIDt«PUI.€HL[I13JIbHOi1 J1HclJop-
Mau;m:I 06 eM He CTaBJlReTC.J1 ollpas,!\aHHbIM. B CBfl311 C
3TI1M oHa npe,l\Jlarae-r }J;3.:lKe J1CKJilO'll1Tb J13 I'paJK,J:(aHCKOro KoJ\eKca
HopM)' n. 2 CT 67 284
-118-
RaK COaepWeHHO npamlJIbHO OTMeqalOT )'KR3aHHbIe aBTOpu. KOH£PI1-
AeHql1aJ1bHMI1H4JoPMaQW1 MOmeT CTaTb 11, KaK npamlJIO, C'IaHJmTCfI,
Aoc'fYIIHOif HeTOJIbKO aKqI10HepaM. O;:UIaIW nocKOJIbKy HepaMOHa
MOmeT craTb JIOC'I'Y11IiCH l1MeHHO B CI1J1Y TOI'O, '1'ID OHJ1 .HBJIf!lOTC'JI cy6'b-
eKTaMI1 ynpaBJ1eID1J1 no OTHOWeHl11O K OOtqecTBY, TO, ,D;yMaeTCiI, '1TO Ta-
R1HIHX OOfl3aHHOCTbnOCOXpaHeHI1IOJ1H4JopMa 6YAeTHOClITbKOpII0-
paTJlBHbIJixapaKTep. HaM6o.I1€e B€pOHTHO. 'lT0
6yAYT pacno.rrara'I'b 'lJIeHb1 opraHOB yn}'XlBJJeHIUI rfuQecTBa, aY,D;J1TOpbI 11
APYrl1e JIl1L\a, KOTOpbIM KO HaH I1H£PCPMaL{l1H 6y,lJ;eT ,lJ;0-
crY!1Ha B CI1J1Y ocyIL\ecTBJIeID1J111X TpYAOBbIX 06H3amr0cTeti:. CCKYrBeTcr-
BE'HHO, TaKaJlI1Hq:.opMa.1V'U1 OYAeT .HBJU1TbCII ,l\J1J1 YK<J3aHHhIX JI11L1 CJIy-
1, '1'ID 11 OTpa>KeHO B oIIpe,lJ;eJIeHI1J1 c.nyme6Hm1 II1,
AaHHOM cr. 31 3aJ«>Ha «0 pb[HKe LleHHbIX 6yMar>o. B 000TBeTCTBIDI C Heti:
M m«PopMaIUteMJlJlJlLleJleH3aKOHanp:vJ3HaeTCJiJIK.rnUlHe HB-
Jlf!lOU,JaHCH mt:lxJpMaLlJUI oo3W'!TeH'Te 11 Bbmyw:eHHhIX
I1M LleHHbIXOYM8-raX,KuropaHcraB:vJT.JIJ1II;,OOJI alOLqJ1XB
CJ1JIY CBOeI'O CJl)'iKe6HOro TPYllOBbIX o6H3aHHocreU J1JII1l10-
I'OBOpa, 3aKJ!IO'leIIHOI'O C 3MJITeHTOM, TaIwif muixPMaWrefI, B npeHMY-
ll\ecTBeHHoe nOJIIDKeHI1e no cpaBHeHIDO C }JJ)yrJ1M11 cyD'beKTaMl1 pbIHKa
LleHHbIX 6)'Mar
CTaTbJI 33 3Toro :me 3aKOHa COAepJrofT 3alIpeT Ha 11CIIfJJIb3OBHHI
TaKOif I1H$:JPMHIU1Jt: Ha pbIHKe LlelIHbIX 6)'Mar 11 OTCbIJI0'3HYlO HOpMY' 00
OTSeTCTB€HHOCTII IIO 3aKOHO TeJIbCTBY Po::cJ.rlk:Koii cpellepaL\l1I1 JII1Q,
HapyIilllBIIDlX 3anpeT.
AKQI10Hepbl, KaK npaBI1J10, nOJ\,IJ;eiicTmte 3= HOpM He nOJUIaJlalOT,
TaK KaK OObNHO He COCTOJIT C OOIl\eCTBOM B TPYJ10BbIX J1JII1
OTHOWeIIIDIX. O)J;llaKO B CJ1JIY11X y<ffiCTI1fI B ynpaBJIeHID:! OOIl\eCTBOM KOH-
I1H4JoPMaltJ1J'l nOTeH1UffiJIbHOI1MMOm€T6brrbl13BeCTHa.
B CBIl3J1 C 3T11M, J1.YM<lE'TCj1, HCKJT1CI'l£HI1e J13 rpam.MHCKoro KOJ\eKca Pg:.
HOpMblOOofuIaaHHOCTIf coxpaHeHIDI aToif JnI4JopMa BCe me.RBJIHeTCR
pa3HhIM. J16oJIeeTOI'O, He06xo;:uIMOTaIOKe BK.JIlO'!I1TbaHaJiO-
rwrnyIO HOpMY AJU10bIBIID1X aKQI10HE'pOB - JlliL\, KOTOpbIe no KaKMM-J11>1i5o
npWIJ:IH3M Bbrob!JII1 J13 COCTaBa yq8C'IHHKOB OOlL\ecTBa, OJJ;HaKO 3a BpeMH
csoeI'O 'lJieHCTBa B OOtqecTBe I1MeJ1H AOCT)'1l K I«:'H}:> 11H-
4xJpMaqJ1H H olirra.AaJIl1 TaKOBOft
J1 B 3aKJIlO'leHJ1e paCClVIO'I'peHI1I'I OTHOllEHIrlt:, CKJIBAb!BalOLqJ1XCH B
CBR311 C 0CV1Qf2C'I'BJ1e npaB aRl\I1arep8 Ha 11H4JoPMBW1lO, He<fixo-
,IJ;I1M0 BNA€JII1Tb ClIe WI€CRlle '1epTbI, npl1cyIII;11e 3= OTHoweH:vJ-
HM. HeCOMHeHHO, 3TI1 OTHOweHI1.FI He BIIJ1Cb!BalOTCR IIOJIHOCTbIO B CI1C-
reM}' OOJl3a'I'€J1bC'I'EleH TaK, OTHOWeHl1.FI, B03HHKalOUV1e no noBOJIY
ny15JW!'IHoro paCKpbITIDI I1H$:JpMaL\l1I1, HaXO)\HTCJI IIOJ\ oc06bIM KOH1'pO-
JieM opraHa I1CIIOJIHJrrE'JIbH)ll BJ1aCTI1. peryJ!l1p)'lOIl\ero pbIHOK L\€HHbIX
-119-
6yMar -4>(:cbp Pcb, KOTDpbrli B pH,!\e CJI.Y<laeB TaKme MO:IKeT BXO.l{MTb B
cy6"beKTHbllf cocTaBO"m01lleHJdi,1f npMMbIK.aJOTK n1BHbIM:
OTHOIlIeID1RM. B oTHoIlIemrnx, CBH3aHHbIX C paCKpbITI:!eM IfH4>opMa 11
K8.K Hl1rAe I1pJIcy'T'CTBy€T ny6mrrno-npaooooR a.JIeMeHT, CBH3aHHbIti C
oc:06bIM KOIITpOJ1eM rocYAapc-rneHHblX opraHOB-
OrnoIlIeID1fl, CBH3alllible C npeJlOC'ffiBJl('HJteM: J1H4>oPMa 0 np:lBe-
AeHI1Jf 06I.J.1eTO co6pamlH, K8.K J1 BCe KOpnOpaTl1BHble 1-iJ1J1 pHbIe
0'I'II0llJ.:ffi CKJIa,JJ;bIBaIOTCH no noBO)J;y Y"acTl-UI aKLtJ10HepOB B ynpan.JIe-
HIDlI1 11M Cl!C.HcTBeH oc06bllf nOpRADK ocy:w;ecrBJI€ID1fI J1 3aILWITbI npaB
TaK,Bcn}"laeH€npe,ll;O(."I'aBJE06ll\eC'IBOM n1o
H11I-f 06I.J.1eTO c06paHl1H, aKLtJ10Hep He yno.J1HOMJ'l£H 3aKOHOM nOTpe60BaTb
np€AOCTaBJIeHl1R 3T0i1 L KoH€'IHO, OH MO:>K€T 3T0 CJJ;eJIaTb,
OAHaKO BpRA 111131'0 ecoo6}:a:3Ho nOCJ1e TOro, K8.K c06patnie aKWKHe-
pem COCTOHJIOCb. B 3TOM cJI.Y<lae 3a.Il\I1Ta era IipaBa 6y,I\eT cpa3y 06ecne-
'lMBaTbCJ'l B03M())f{H()CTb LII HCKa 0 IIp'13HaHJIJ'l peweHl1H
06ll\ero cdipmnm He,n;ei1cTmrre.m.HbI O)J;tffiKO npe,!\"bJIBJIeHI1e TaKOro
HCKa BOBce He 03Ha'iaeT, 'I1'O,I\aJKe npl1 yCTaHOBJIeHID:! CYAOM cpaKTa Ha-
Py1ll€Hl1fI npaB 81iW1OH€'p<\ OHl16y,DyT 13alW1lL\ffil:l. TaK,
eCJill ,n;OII)'IlleHHbIe HapyweID1flB Bl1,IJ;e He)'B€ aKqI10Hepao co-
3b!B€ 06Il\ero co6paHl1.fI He HBJlIiIOTC.R C)lIlIecTBelllibIMJ1:, I'OJiOCOBaHHE'
HCTqa He MorJIO nOBJIlliITh IJa pe3YJIbTaThI I'OJIOCOBaID1fl H peIlIeHHe He
nOBJIeKJIO npI1'iIlH€HJ:1H HCTu;yy6bITKOB. TO cy,I\ OCTaBIIT06JfGlnyeMoe pe-
llIeHHe 06Il\ero co6paHJm B cl1JIe.
KopnOpaTI1BH)'lO npJoqXJ,IT;y, KaK 6bLJIO nOKa3aHO, J1MelOT TaKme OTHO-
llIeHHH nonpe,lXJC"ffiBJIeHl1lOaK OHepaM J1H<lXJpMa 110,n;eH'I'e.lIbHO
OJ!)lalW OTHOllleHl1.fI no noBOJJ;,)' J1H<lxJpMa MOIyr J1 nOJIHOCThlO
IIO,!I,I1a,!I.aTb no,D; e OM3aTeJ1hCTBa. 8m B IIOJIlJOA M€pe O'JHO-
CJ1TCH K npaBOO'I'H(III€ CBH3aHHhIM C aKIV'IOHe-
paM J1H4>oPMa 1'13 peeCTpa aKL(IK»IEpJB 06I.J.1eCTBa. EcJill paCCMOT-
pe'1'h, HanpJ1Mep, onyatVlJO, KOTAa aKLtJ10Hep Tpe6yeT y 061l\eCTBa
BhlIDfCK)' J13 peeCTpa TO 3TJ1CYrHOllIeHJ1J1 fIBJlII1{ITCH KJIaCCJ1-
'I€CKI1M npl1MepOM 06.H3aT€JIbCTBa. B aTOM CJi.)"Ia€ 06Il\€CTBO 06H33.HO
np€,D;OCTaBI1Tb J1H4>oPMaWIID 1'13 peecrpa, npl1'-leM B Te'lelll1e 5 ,lJ;H€ti:. IIpJ1
3TOM aKLtJ10Hep BnpaBe Tpe60BaTb OT 06ll\eCTBa JICIDJIIIelll-ff ero 06H3aH-
HOCTI1 H MO:>KeT 06paTIITbCH 3a 3aU<l1TOi1 HapYW€HHOI'O npasa B CYlJ..
IIpaBCICYI'I101ll no noBO)J;y mupopMalVW T€CHetiuJl1M 06pa30M ne-
peIlJIeTeHbI C 0TH0lIJ€ID1HMI1, B03HI npl1 KOH'I'pOJIe aKI<110He-
pem 3a ,lJ;eHTeJIbHOC'I1>IO aKLtJ10HepHoro 06Il\ecTBa.
BoJIhllll1HCTBO OTeqeCTBeHHhlX aB1'Opem, H cpe,D;J1 HHX TaKJ1e BI1,ZI,HbIE'
yqeHble KaK J1.T TapacoB, MH. KYJI8fJ1H, II. IhIC€MCKIm, .n: B JIoMa-
KI1:H, Sbl,lJ;€nRlOT TaKoe npaso 8KWloHepa KaK npaBO IJa KOHTpOJIb.
-120-
IIpe)K,!\e Bcero, npMCTynaH K paCCMarpeHillO :noro npasa BKW10Hepa.
CJ1e.r\YeT OTMeTl1Tb, 'iTO KOHTpoJ1b 3,1J;eCb yIIO'Ip€fin.ReT B CMbICJ1e B03-
MOmHOCTI1 np:lBeplGl JJ;eJITeJIbHOCTIl 06IL1ecTBa. a He B
CMbICJ1e OKa3aHW! BKW10HepaMM pewaKJlltero B03,1J;eACTBW! Ha ]J,efl-
TeJIbHOC'Ib 06r.qeCTBa.
Jl:.B. JIOMaKI1H onpe,ll;eJIHeTcy&heKrJmHoe npaBO BKQMOHepa Ha KOH-
TpOJ1b KaK «ycTaHOBJIE'HHYKJ HOpMa'mB1lUMJl aKTaMM, B TOM 'iMCJ1e J-I YC-
TaBOM aKqlKHepHOI'O 06IL1ecTsa, B03MfJ)KH(Cn, aKLtMOHepoB OCYlL\eCTB-
Jl.fITb ,/J;eilcTBMH no nposepKe ,lJ;eHTeJ1bHOCTM opraHOB ynpaBJleHMH
aKLI"OHepHoro 06ll1eCTsa C LleJlbKJ YCTaHOBJIeInfH iPaKTa HaJ1M'1W! J-IJ1M
arcyrCTSW! HapyweInfH npaB KaK CaMoro of3IQecTBa. TaK J-I OT,lI;eJ1bHbIX
ero 'iJ1eHOB co CTOpOHbI yKa38.HHblX opraHOB".2SS 03HaQeHHbrn aSTOp
COBepWeHHO BepHO OTMe'laeT TeCHeJ:iwym CBH3b npaBa aKW10H€pa Ha
KOHTpDJIb c npaBOM Ha J-IH4x:>PMaQIDO. )J;eHCTBW! aKW10Hepa npM pea-
IDI3al.\l1M J-IM npaBa Ha KOHTpDJIb J-I npasa Ha rn«PoPMaL\11IO Mor)'T COB-
IIaMTb IIp>'! :3TOM pa3J1J1'3:W! Me)K):ly :3TMMJ1,wJyMH npasaMJ1 CJI€}J;)'€'T.
no MHeHillO BBTopa. IIpOBOJ:V:ITb no CJIeJlYlOIL\I1M npM3HaKaM. Bo-nep-
BblX, B J-IX OCHOBe J1e:«aT pa3HU€ I1HTepecw: ecm! npaBO Ha J-IH4x:>PMa-
QIDO ocyIl\ecTBJIHeTCH BKW10HepoM C qeJ1blO Y.IJ;OBJIeTBOpeHl1R CBOeH
IIO'Ipe6HocTIoI B cseJ\eHI1RX o}J,€fITeJIbHOCTIIi o6ll\ecTBa. TO npaBO Ha KOH-
TpOJIb - C qeJ1b1O 06HapymeHI1R HeJ\OCTaTKOB B .IJ;eJITeJ1bHOCTH 06IL1ecT-
sa. BO-BWPblX, npaBOHa KOHTpDJIb ropa3,!1;On0lill1pe eJDKillfJUO. TaK
KaK.IJ;aeT BO:3MmtI:tIDC:n> IIp>1MeHeHI1R CIIeL{KBJibHbIX Cpe,!l;CTS, cpe,!C1 KO-
TOpblX npoBepKa peBM3HOHlIOii KOMJ1CCMeif .IJ;eHTeJIbHOCTlI
E--Ipen.J1X, KOHTpDJIb 1lHE'TCH HaJI XD3JD"icTBeH-
HOti ,lI;eHTeJlhHOCTbIO 06IL1ecTBa, B TO BpeMH KaK IfH4x:>pMal.\l1R MomE'T
KaCaTbCH I1I1HbIX BOnpoCOB. 256
KpJ1TJ1Ke nO]J,Bepr J-I3J10iKeHHyro oo O-B. Eenoycos. KOTOpblJ:i:
C'I11TaeT Heqeneco06pa3HblM Bbl,lJ;eJ1mb npaBO Ha KOHTpDJIb B Ka'ieCT-
Be oT.IJ;eJIbHoro cy&beKTImHOID npalJa aKLplOHepa no CJl CO-
06paiKeHW!M.
IIpe)K,!\e Bcero, OHOTMe<J:aeT, 'lT0, onpe.IJ;eJ1J1J1 nOlUlTIle cyfh.eKTl1BHD-
ro npasa Ha KOH'I'pOJIb, Jl:.B. JIoM3.Kr1H He orpaHi'I'DIBaeT B03M())f(H()CTI BK-
1.\I10Hepa TOJIbKO nposepKoJ:i iPJ1HaHroBO-
06ll\ecrna, 'iTO Cpa3y CTaBIIT nOJ\ COMHeInfe eroTpeTIDi «apryMeHT".
KpOMe TOro, o.B. EeJ1oycoB OTMe'laeT. 'iTO 1IOJiHOMO'n1H p€BM311OH-
HOti KOMI1CCJonf (peBM30pa) 06ll1eCTBa Ha npoBe,!\eHMe nposeplGl iPI-lHaH-
COBO-X03Hti:CTBeHHOi1 .IJ;emeJIbHOCTM o61l\ecTBa HJIIKBK HeJIb3JI OTHeCTM
K cy6DeKTI1BHbIM npaBaM aKq;I-IOHepa. OJIHaKO, npe,!l;CTaBJrHeTCH. 'iTO
)J;.B. JIOMaKI1H 11 He OTHOCJ1T npOBepKY peBM3MoHHoi1 IIDMJtCCHeH J1,eH-
T€JIbHOCTII K cy6'beK"TI1BHblM npaBaM, npoCTO OH yKa3bIBaeT, 'ITO B PH-
_121_
l1.e CJI.Y<la€B, 8KW'10Hep BIIpaBe BOCIIDJIb:3OBaTbCJI npl1-
BJ1e'leHl1Jl IOCJMHCCInf K OCV1Qf2C'I'BJ1eH lOCJII'I'j)OJ1&
qro me IGlcaerCJI pa3rpaHJ1'leHl1Jl npasa Ha KOH'I]X)JIb 11 npaaa Ha
HIJ:lx!pMalVIlO no J1X L1enl1, TO caruM aB1'Op cor.nawaeTCJI, 11 OTMe'laeT,
'11'0 eCJ111 OCHOBbmaTbCJI Ha a1'OM, TO npu,n;eTCE np113HaTb, 'lTO IIpaBO Ha
I1H<l:xJPMa OT.IDf'laeTCJI OT npaaa Ha KOH'I]X)JIb TOJIbKO qeJIblO, pa.D;I1
aKL\OOH€P nOJ1)"1aer Jnup:pMaL\l'llO. Ho I1OCI\OJ1bRY qeJIb He HB-
JIJIe'1'CJI onpe npi13HaKOM cyfu.eImmHoro npaBa 111Op1Wt'f€-
CKaH 06J133.HHOCTb ncnumurre.JJ:bK)ro opraHa aKW'lOHepHoro OOIl\ecTBa
no npe,!J;OCTaBneHl1lO JnKlx! BI OT aKLII-'IOHepa He 6y,lJ;e'1' Me-
ILfITbCJI, TO, no ern MHeHIDO, BbIJ\eMTb npaBO aK-LtMOHepa Ha KOHTpDJ1b
HeQe.JJec006pa3HO. TaRoe npaBO B aKQMOHepHOM OOIl\ecTB€ rn-;reKYr 06-
IL\ee coopaHl1e a , COBeT ,lU1pl'K'I'()JX::B (HaOJ1lO,D;aTeJ1bHbili co-
BeT), p OHHaR KOMl1CCIDJ: (peBl130p) OOIl\ecTBa, HO He aK1U10Hep.251
IT. ThIC€lllC'KIDI IlpI'13H3B<UI 3a aKL<I10HepaMl1 TaKoe npaBO, HO npl1
:3TOM C'illTan, '1TO OOIl\ee co6plllfl1e He clIoc06HO K ,lIefICTBlITeJIbH0MY
KOHTpDJIlO; n03TOMY BeCbMa 6naropa3)'MH0 Y9P€)J;JiITb ,l\JlR 31'0i1 qenl1
oco61:rli opraH. 11 '!TOObl KOHTponb OblJ1 ,IJ;€I1cTBJITe.neH, HeOOXO,l\JlMO CO-
6.mo,u;eHlie cneJJ;YRJIL\I'IX yc.JIOIMii: 'lJIeHbI 3TIfX opraHOB,lIOJDKHhI H3011-
paTbCJI 8KLIMOHepaMl1113 8KW'10HepCJB me; 11M ,lIOJDKHa 6bITb npe,!J;OCTaB-
.neHa nOJ1HafI CBo60,!\a B fJ3HaKOMJ1eHWl co BceM XO,!\OM ,lien OOIl\ecTBa;
11M ,lIOJDKHO 6bITb npE,l\OCTIlBJI€HJ npaBo C03bmaTb oOIl\ee aJ6paHne,
KOr,l\8 OHl1 HatWyT 3TO H)'iKHblM; HaKOHeq, OHl1 ,lIOJDKHbI6bITb OTB€TCT-
BeHHbI 3a HeJlCIIOJIHeHHe CBO= 06H38.HHocTeit 258
11.T. TapacoBnonarnn, 'lTOBCBH3HCTeM, '11'Onpe,!\'bRBJIeHHenOTpe-
60BaHl11O Kam.r:\oro npl1l1le,!\lllero aK-LtMOHepa Bcex KHI1T 11 ,lJ;oK)'MeHTOB
06Il\€cTBa HBbJ.!l8'1a J13 HI1X BbIIllfCOK J1JIJ1l1,a'la o&bJIcHeHJrlt no HI1M MO-
ryr c,!\enaTb Bce ynpaBJ1eHHe 061l.\€CTBOM H , OTHHMaJl y
BCex ,lJ;OJDKHOCTHbIX JIH'--1 Bce BpeMJI Ha 0)V10 TOJIbKO :3T0 3aHJlTHe; KpoMe
TOro, IIJCKOJIbK}' HeKOTOpble o6opoTbI OOIl\ecTBa BC.JIe)J;C'IBfe oco60ro
xapaKTepa npe,IUlpJ1Jl'1'HJ'I MOryr Tpe60BaTb oco6eHHoi1 TaJi:Hb111 ,lJ;OJ1m-
IIbI 6brrb He,lJ;OCT)'IIHbI ,lJ;J1J1 ep;mrn'IHblX aKW'lOHepOB, npaBo KOH1pDJU1
e,!\J1Hfl'fHoro aKQMOHepa B yKa33.HHOi1 4q>Me ,lI0J1:)KH0 6brrb orpaHW-leHO
ITpJ1'leM HaJiru :3TY rpaHl He npe,!\CTaBJlJ'leT oc06biX 3aTpY,IJ;HeHl1fI,
eCJ111 JiMeTb B BU,!Iy, '!TO B OCHOBaHHM :3Toro npasa J1emHT 1fCKJIIO'lH'l'eJIb-
HO :xo3JIiiC'rBeHHbIi1 11HT€p€C aKWIoHepa, 3aKJiIO nicR TOJ1bKO B
npaBe nOJ1)"1eHl1Jl ,lJ;I1BI1,!\eH,Il,a H nOJ1)"1eHl1Jl 06pa'ffio cBoeA ,lJ;OJ1H KaIDI-
TaJla npl1 J111KB 11 06Il\€CTBa. Ha 3TOM OCHOsaHl111 npaBO KOH'IpOJIJI
e,D;iIHWIHOrO aKLIl10Hepa ,lIOJDKHO OrpaliJl'R1TbCH JIl1Wb npaBOM npOBepKl1
6anaHca JIII1HBeHTapH B TOi1 Mepe, B KaKOi1 npoBepKa:3Ta HaXO,l\JITCJI B
-122-
npmmti CBH3M C npaBoMero Ha no.rryqeHJ'!e ,W1Bl>1}:\eH,1IP 11 Ha Tpe60BaHne
.mIKmfJ1<U--t11l1 06ll\ecTBa J+!Ifl nOJJ,)"-IeHWI 06paTHo CBOetil1OJnf Kani'ITana.
]J,aJIee, no eroMHeID1lO, cor.naCHO Ha'lanaM C'IporoticnpaBeJJ.JIlffi
He06XO,lJ;l1MO YCTaHOBI1Tb oc06yro TaKCY. no lID'T'OpOii aRlUlOHepbl 06fl3a-
IIbI IUIaTl-rTb 3a 06peMeHeID1e ynpaBJIeHJ'!fl pa3HblMl1 cnpaBl I\rn, c KO-
TOpblMl1 CBfl3aH JIWffibI]:IIfi1Tepec caMOro aKql10Hepa,
HaEO,l:1JUUeI'O cnpaB1GI. YC'I'aH(EJ1€HMe TaKoA TaKCb! TeM 60JIee He06xo-
1\I'IM0. 'lTO mill MomeT B 3Ha'llrreJIbllOif CTeneID1 CJ1YmJ1Tb rapaH'fl'leii
npOTI1B nerKOMblCJ1eHHoro 06peMeHeHIDI ynpaBJIeHJ1H 06ll\ecTBa He-
HYmHbIMJ1 J1 6ecnoJIe3HwI\rn cnpaBKaMJL TaKca aTa, pa3YMeeTcfI,
110JIiKHa 6bITb copa3MepHa c xapaKTepoM TPe60BaHMSi, TO eCTb 110JDKHO
6bITb C.IJ;eJIaHO pa3mPIJre Me : a) npe)J;bRBJIeHMeM 6aJIaHCa J1 HHBeH-
Tapfl, 6) npe,!J;"bRBJIeHMeMKHMrM B) Aa,'leti YCTHblXo&bJ::J:C-
HeHI1i1 HJIJ1 cnpaBOK B,l\OllO.JIH€HIt K 6aJIaHcy H I1HBeHTaplO H r) l\a'lei1:
IDICbMeHHbIX <:.6'hRcHeHHii: HJIM cnpaSOK. 259
ITo MOeM)' MHeID1lO, 311 aJl':WlOHepoM cOSepWeHHO He06XO}J;lIMO npM-
SHaTb npaso Ha KOHTp0JIb. Rro KaK He aKQJIIOHep, OC06eHHO ,n;epmaTeJIb
KpyrrnOro naKeTa aKQ>1ti, 3aHHTepecoBaHH1:rli S 6.T!aroIIOJIy'1HOM MCXO,D;e
npeWIPIDITIDI, B KOTopoe DB BJIOmI1JI CHOM cpe,!\CTBa,I\OJDKeH KOHTpO-
IDIpOBaTb ero 1\€flTeJIbHOCTb? C I\pyroti CropOHbI, J1M€HH0 nyr€M HC-
IIG.JIb:3OEallJlR npaBa Ha KOHTpoJIb Ha npaKTl1Ke AOBOJIbHO 'laCTO ocy1l\e-
CI1HlReTCH BMernaTeJIbCTBO B pa6oT)' 06ll\ecTBa. RaK pB3 nosTOMY
,n;OJVKHO 6bITb orpaHW-leHO npaSO Ha KOH"ipOJIb co CTOpOHhI OT,n;eJIbHbIX
MeJIKI1X a OHepOB XOTH 6w 1J.J1H TOro, 'IT06w He AonyCKaTb )'T€qKM
H,l\eHL[l1aJlbH()JIHH4x:JpMaQIDI.Arrfl aTOro Bo6mecTBe 4>YHKQ>10HJ'!-
pyeT cne KOHTpOJIIIIPYKiI_Qnii opraH 11, KpOMe TOro, YCTaHOB-
JIeHb! OIpaHINemm Ha AocryTI K lfiI pMar-ll1l-1 IIpaBo aKql10Hepa Ha
KOH1'p0J1b TeCHefullJ1M 06pa30M CB$I3aHO H pea.JU13)'eTCfi B npaBe mroo-
pa 'UIeHOB peBl'i3Jfcmroii KfJM]:ICOIJI, B npaBe caMOMY 6brTb H36paHHb!M
Bee COCTaB. qTO KaCaeTCfl BCI:3MQ:IKHOC'" npl1BJIeqeHIDI ynoJIHOMO'leH-
IIbDl: rocYl1apcTBeHHbDl:OpraHOB11Jlfi IDIKOHTpoJ1J'l, TOaTO-
ro MmKeT nmpe60saTb He TOJIbKO a OHep, HO H, HanpHMep, Al1peK-
TOp (€I\JfiIUJIWIHblii VlCnOJIHI1T€JIbHbIti opraH) 06mecTBa, eCJIM eMY B
CMJIY HCnOJ1HeHWI ero CJIyme6HbIX 06J13aHHOC'I'eJi CTaJn'! H3BeCTHbI on-
pe.l\eJ1eIIHa€ tlJaKTbl, CBlf.,!J;€TeJIbCTBylO e a npaBOHapywemmx.
Cy&beKTI1BHOe npaso aKQJIOHepa Ha KOH"ipOJIb MmKeT pea.nH3OBbI-
BaTbCfi B paMKax pa3J!W1HbIX npaBOCYl'HOWemrn, sanpl1Mep. B paMKaX
OTHOIlleHJfit:nonpe}J;OCTaBJIeHmoV!H4JopMaL1ID1 amOllleHJfit:
no peam13alU'D1 npaBa aKQJJ.1Hep:i n3mq::aTb M 6bITb H30paHHbIM. IIpM-
po,!\a 3TI1X UIHOIIIeIfHti HaMJ1 YJKe paCCMaTpl1BaJIaCb.
PaCCMOTpHM 011IDIIEHJ0Iff, CKJJa,1:J;bIBaK1£'C.II no nosoJJ\Y npaBa aKWlO-
Hepa nOTpe6osaTb np0sepKM peEl13J1OHHOii f«)MJlccneii ,lJ;eJ'lTeJJbHOC'l11 06-
-123-
Il\ecTBa. npaB08KqMOHepa, BJIa.l\eIDLIJ;ero B He MeHee 100/<
roJIocymIl\l-iX 06Il\ecTBa, nOTpe60BaTh B mo6oe BpeMJI peBJI3l-fi1
4JI1HaHCOBO-X03ID1:CTBeHllOif ,l\eRTeJIbHOCTII 06LqeCTBa 3illI'f6IJI1'HO n. :3
CT. 85 3aroJHa «05 OHepHh!X . RpoMe TOro, a63. 2 'I. 5
CT. 103 rK P<P YCTaHaBJrnBaeT, 'ITO COBOKynHaii ,l\0J1.f1 KOTO-
pbIX B YCTaBHOM KaIDITaJIe COCTaBJUlE-"f 10 J1Jrn: 60Jree lI}X>QeHTOB, BIIpaBe
'Ipe60BaTb B nK60e BpeMJI npoBe,!J;eID-1.fl aYJllrropa«>A IIpOBeplGf ,!J;eRTeJIb-
HOCTJ1 oOIl\ecTBa. YKa3aHHbIM npaBaM aKqMOHepa KOppecrDH..lJ;J:rpyeToO.fI-
3aHHOCTb 06Il\eCTBa B .III1L\e peBJ!3W::HHCH KOMJ1CCI1I1 06Il\eCTBa I1pOBecTJ1
pE£!If31-OO JD160 e6roaHHOCTb aY,D,I-tTOpa npoBec-m nPJBepKY. Ay,[ij--lTOp
CM3aH ,rwroBOPJM, Ha OCHOBaHIDI KOTOPJro If nPJBOrorrcR npOBeplGf C aK-
QYloHepHbIM06I.J.<eCTBOM, a He C OHepaW1, J1J1MeHHo06Il\ecTBo nOOTO-
MY BnpaBe 'Ipe60Ba'Ib OT Hero IfcnoJ1HeIDfR c6.fI3aHHOCTeti: no ,rwroBOPY.
AKQYlOHep Ha 3TO npOCTO He ynpaBOMOqeH. B CJIy'-Iae YKJIOHeHW! aY)J;IITQ-
pa err IIpOBe.JJ;€HJlH nposeplG1 HenOli.flTeH MexafD13M 3aIl\m'bI npaB aKqMO-
Hepa - err KOro JKe BCe-TaKI1 TpeOoBaTb ee npoBe1<ElDfR. Tpe60BaTh ur 06-
Il\€CTBa 3TOro HeJlb3Z, TaK RaK OHO He HBJlffeTCH 06.H3aHHbIM JillQOM, a
'Ipe60BaTh OT ay,[ij--lTOpa aK Hep He MO:>KeT. Ec.m1 JKe peBI'13IlOHHaR 100-
MJ1CCIDI He npOBO)J;IIT peI31illiIDO, TO, 1JYMaeTCR, 'ITO aKQJ:1OHep M<»KE-"f 06pa-
T1ITbCH B CY,l\ C J1CKOM K 06Il\ecTsy (nOC:KOJIhKy KOMJIICCIDI
HBJIfIeTCII ero OpraHOM) 0 emm: K npC)Be,!J;emno peBH:3lfH, xarJI H.a
3aKOHO):\aTeJIhHOM ypoBHe 3'1'0 He ypery.1ll1pOBaHO.
RaK npe,!J;CTaBJUleTCH, npaBO aKqMOHepoB H3. KOH'IpOJIb BXO)J}1T B CO-
CTas npaBa Ha ynpaBJIeHJle, IIfJrnDJIhK}' KOHTpoJIb JIBJifleTCR WHKQJ'!ei1
co ro ynpaBJJeHIfR. CJIeJ\OBaTeJIbHO, oCYIl\ecTBJIIDI npaso Tpe-
50BaTh npoBeAeHIDI aYA1TI'OJ:>CKCM nPJBeplGl HJIJ4 peB ID1, aKIV-10Hep
peaID:!3yeT WHKQYlJ1 cy&beKTa ynpaBJIeHJ1Il no OTHOllIeID:!IO K aKQYlO-
HepHoMY06Il.\€C'iBY. IIooTOMy,IffD1IV-1J1PY.fl peBJ13mo HJIJ4 aY,l\l'lTOpcK)'IO
npoBepKY, aKQJ'!OHep Aei1CTByeT B paMKaX RopnopanmHOro npaBOOT-
HOlilemUL
Cne;nyeT OTMeTl-fTb, 'ITO npaBO aKIV-10Hepa Ha npJ1BneQeHJ1e AJI.fI
npoBeAeHIDI npOBeplGl aY,l\l1Topa BO MHorOM HQCJ1T AeKJ1apaTl1BllbDi
xapaKrep, nocKOJIhKy He IIpe.IJ;yCMO'JpH MexaHJ13M €ro 3aIl\J"!Thl. B 3a-
KOH€ «06 aKIVJ"JH€pHbIX ofuQecTBax» 0 npaBe aKQJ'!OHepOB Tpe60BaTb
npoBeA€HIDI aYJll1'I'OpCKCi-f npoBepKJ1 HeT ynOMllliamm Boo6ll.\€.
TaKJ1€ HOpMhl CJIe,!J;OBaJIO fib! BSeCTJ1 B 3aKoH XOTH fib! nOTOMY, '1TO
06Il\J"!€ non<»K€ID1J1 ° npase aKQJ10Hepa npJ1BJIe'lli]J,JUI KOHTpOJUI aYAJ1-
TOpa co):\epJKaTCH B rpa)K,l:(3.HCKOM Ko,lJ;eKCe P<P, nOJIO)K€HIDI KOToporo
3aKOH «05 a 1OH€ptfbIX CJfuQecTaax» IIpJ13SaH IWHKpeTl13J1PJBaTh.
t 4. HHble 06J13aTenbCTOeHHble 11 KOpnOpaTI1BHble
npaBOOTHOWeHI1A, B03HI1KalOl1Il1e
MeH<AY aKLlI10HepHblMI1 061..ijeCTBaMI111 aKLlMOHepaMI1
'qaCTO B aKQWOHepHbIX 06ll\ecTBax CKJlaN>!BCUOTCfl npaBOOTHOIIIe-
HI1H, CBH3aHHbIeC H OCOnpaBanp 106pe-
TeHl1fl aKLlJ1f!, KOTOpoe 06ecne'-JJ1BaeT 60.nee J1J1'" MeHee nOCTOHHHblA
COCTaB aKLIIK)HepoB 06'-L1eCTBa, COOTHOllleHl1e AOJJei-f I1X Y'ffiCT"'-.I1 B YC-
TaBHOM KaIU1TaJIe I1TeM caMbIM COXpaHeH",e 8KlU10He-
pOB BJI"'-.I1Tb H8 IlO.I1I1TJIKY o6'-L1ecTBa
HeKOTOpble )"-1eHble BblCKa3bmaIOT MHeID1e, 'iT0 np8BOOTHOllIeH"'-.I1,
3aKJIKJqa:IO'-Lll1e B CBOeM CO.n;epiKaHl1J.-1 npeJlMYIQ€C1'B€HHb1e "paBa, CO-
CT8BJ1f1lOT oco6yro rpynny, IDC1OC!.I1bK}' OHJ.-I BbiXO)J;j'lT 38 p8MKi-'1 "P"'HWI-
na paBeHCTBa cyfu,eIm:m rpa:1KWlHCKJ1X npaBOO'1'HOllI€HI1i1. 260
npenMJI.II;eCTB€HHOe npaBO npmJ6pereHI1fI aKLlJ1f! MO>KeT 6bITb I1C-
nOJlb30BaHO aKQWOHep8MJ.-1 B .n;BYX CJIY'-laHX:
- B CJlY'-Ja€ OT'-JY:1K,IJ;eHJ.-IH 8KLlJ.-IM 8KLlJ.-IOHepOM 3aKpblToro 06ll\eCT-
sa (Ha OCHOSaH"'J.-I a63. 4 n. :3 CT. 7 3aKOHa «05 aKi.\J10HepHblx o6ll\e-
CTBax» );
- npll! A01ID1IHIrre.1il>HOii 3MJ.-1CCJ.-IJ.-I aKW1M :II! wynrx :q:eHHbIX 6JM3.r
(Ha OCHOBaHJut: CT. CT. 40, 41 YKa3aHHOro 3aKOHa).
npl16J111:1KaihueM paCCMOTpeHID1 HopMbI a63. 4 n.:3 CT. 7 3aKOHa Bbl-
HCHH€TCH, 'ITO OHa He HOCWI' J1MIIepaTJ.-IBHoro xapaKTepa, nOCKOJIbKy
l1MeeT CJleAYJOll\YlO 4JoPMYID:!POBKY' «AKQWOHephI 3aKpbrroro 06ll\ecT-
sa nOJ1b3)'IOTCH bIM npaBOM 11pJ'!06peTeHlli! aKqlu\
npOWlBaeMblX APYI'11MIt:! aKLllDIepaMi-'l3TOro 06'-L1eCTBa, no '--IeHe npeA-
JlmKeIDm TpeTb€M)' JlilltY nponop:q:l1OHaJ1bHO KOJIIf'-J€CTB)' aKI.II1i1, npll!-
Ha.n;.nemal.ltl-1X KaiK,!\OMY Jf3 IDIX, ec.n", ycrasOM 06'-L1eCTBa He npe,!\YCMO-
TpeH l1Hofii nopfl,I\OK OCyn\eCTBJleHHfl ,!\aHHoro npaBa. YCTaBOM
3illqJbITOIU 06'-L1eCTBa MO>KeT 6bITb npe,!lyCMOTpeHO npeHMY1I--\ecTBE'fj-
Hoe "paso np"'06peTeHl1fl 06IQeCTE!()M aKWIti, npDAaBaeMf,fi ero aKWIo-
HepaMH, ecJIJ'! aKLIHOHephI He HCIlOJ1b3fJBaJ1H CBoe HHoe
npaBO I1pIWI5pe-reHlli! aKLlJ1f!».
n oe npaBO npl-W6peTeHKfl AM caMoro 06ll\ecTBa
8006'-L1e MomeT 6bITb He 1IJX'AYCMfJTIX' YCTasOM, a B IICIJ1IJ7KeHIDI, pac-
C'-Jl1T8HHOM Ha aKLIHOHepoB, JlCIIUJIb3y€TCH4JOpMy.1ll-lpOBKa «eCJIJ.-I YCTa-
80M 06ll\ecTBa He npe.r:J;yCMOTp€". O,I\HaKO B03MroKJ1OC1'b Hel1CllOJIb-
30BaHl1H npeI1MyIL\eCTB€ro npaBa npn06peT€HJUI npDTJ.-IBOp€'lHT
IlpJIpOJ1€ a8KpbIToro aKW10HepHoro 06'-L1ecrBa. T8KJ1M: 06pa3CZ1. MOmHO
npe)J;llOJJO)KJ.-1Tb, 'iTO npeHM)'Il\eCTBeHHOe npaBO npIID6peTeHIDI YCTa-
HOBJI€HO B l1M1lepaTIlBHOM nOpH,i:\Ke, )J;JllCII03I'111IBHOCTb npHMeHl1Ma
-125-
JIilllIb K CaMOM)' nopRAKyero m, K01'Opbrl1 ,n;OnmeH ObITb
perJ1aM€HTHPOBIDl yCTaSOM.
)];nR TOro, 'ITOObI yKa3aHlIOe np npaSO 6bIJIO ocy-
I.I.IecTBJ1eHO, aKWIOHep .J\OJDKeH nJ1CbMeHHO )'Be.[PMJ1'Th 0 HeM OCTaJlb-
HbIX aKltJ10HepoB J1 06!l,\eCTBo, K01'Opoe c.aMOCTO.fl'"feHO OCYJ.II;eCTBJUleT
nepSbIX. PernaMeHTIIqMJ1 ::rroif 06R3aHHOCTJ1 aKqIroHeJJHOro
oOtqeCTBa B 3alWHe He CO;:J;epml-fTCF!.
IIpem.r:\e scero H OTMeTMTb, '11'0 B::rrID!: O'I'lroIIIeIDLfIX aK-
qMOHepHe sbIcTynaeT nOOTHowem:noK8KQMOHepHOMy06l.J.1ecTBYB Ka-
'IeCTBe CyD"beKTa ynpaBJ1eHJ1F!
HBJU1eTCR JlJ1 ::rro OTHJlllE'HI1I2 06m3aTeJlbCTBOM? OrBeTJ1Tb Ha 3TOT
80npDC MO:>KHO, eCJIJ1 CUIIOCTaBJITb em C onp€,!\€JIeHJ1€M o6H3aTeJIbCTB3.,
):IaHHbIM CT. 307 fK pq:.. J];OJDKlUfK 3.J\eCb - Hep. I-fMelO fi HaMe-
peHJ1e npO,JIaTb CBOJ1 aKWfJ1, Kpe,!\m'DpaMl1, O'-les>1,1J,HO, BbIcTynalOT oc-
TaJIbHbI€ bI, nOCKOJIbKY ,AeiicrBHe no J13BeLq€Hmo J1X 0 B03-
HJ1KHOSeHJ1J1 y HJ1X npenMyIl\eCTseHHoro npaBa npJ106peTeHJ1H
HanpaBJIeHO B J1X nOJIb3y. RaKyIO pOJIb BItIl1DnHJIeT 3;:J;eCb aKIJ;J10HepHoe
'lep€3 KOTopoe J1 ,AOJDKHO nOCJ1e,lJ;OBaTb yae.a;OMJTeHJ1e aKi.\J1-
oHepoB? ECJIJ1 nOIIbITaTbCH npe,!\CTaBJ1Tb UIEOllleHI1H., B
3aKpbITOM aKIU10HepHOMOOIl\eCTBe npJ1 B03HJ1KHOBeID'IJ1
BeHlIOfO npaBa np>f06peTeHMH KaK 06F!38.T€'JIbCTSeHHble. TO 06Il\€cTBo, C
o;:J;Hoif CTOpoHbI, BbIcTynaeT KaK Kpe,ro.-I"rop, nOCKOJIbKY HMeHHO eM)'
06H3aH C006LWITb aKqI10Hep. HaMepeaalOIl{J1i1CH npD,JIaTb CEOJ1 aKi.\11J1 J1,
803MO:>KH0, B ero nOJIb3Y. eCJIJ1 npeJlM)'lQeCTB£'HHOE' npaBO IIpIr06pe-re--
HJ1H 06I1-\ecTBa IlpeJJ;yCMO"IJJ yc c ,n;pyroif CTOpOHbI, 06I1-\eCTBo
BblCTynaeT KaK .J\OJDKHWK, nOClWJ1bKY ):IaJ1ee o6roaHHc:crh no 11.0Be,!\e-
HJ1IO empo 0 IIpeIIM)'IIJ;€<-'T13HllOM npase npH06peTem1H OT-
'Iym;:J;aeMbIX aKIJ;11fI OCTaJ1bllbIMJ1 aK1U10HepaMJ1 B03JIaI'aeTCf! I-fMeHHO
Ha CJf3LqecToo.. TaKJ1M oopaaoM, B ::rroif nOCJ1e11.0aaTeJIbHO
CK.JIa)J;bIBaIOTCR /1,Ba o6H3aTBJIbC'l'BeHHbl UIH:II1eHIfH. CHa'ffiJIa OTHO-
weHMH «aKWIDHep, HMelO A HaMepeHlfe npD,JIaTb aK1U1J1, - 06I1-\ecT-
80», 3aTeM - «06I1-\eCTBo - 0CTaJIbHb1€ a.KL\IfCH€PbI}}.
3aJ1HT€pecOBaHHOCTbaK1U1oHepoB, CH nOTeHQI(B.JibHbIMH
nOKynaTeJUlMJ1, " ootqeCTBa B TalWM I-13Be1IJ;€IUDI co C1'OpoHbI OT'-Iym.n;a-
lOII-\ero caOJ1 aKi.\IDI aKltJ10Hepa Q''-IeBJ1,!I;Ha.
Kpe,!\I1Top B COOTBeTCTBlDI co CT. 307 fK Pet> HMeeT npaBo Tpel5o-
BaTb OT .J\OJImID-IKa I-fCnOJIHeH11F! ero oG.R3aJmOCTl1- 3aKoHoM «05 aKQJ10-
HepHbIX 06I1-\ecTBax» npe B03MOiKHOCTb B cny<:!ae, KOf,!\a
aKqI1J1 C HapyweHJ1eM npeJ1M)'LII;eCTSeHHoro npaBa npno6peTemlfI n€-
petllJ1J1 K HOBOMY cOOCTBeHHJ1KY. llCrrpeOOBaTb B cY.J\e6HoM nopR,Wre ne-
peso;:J;a npas J1 06F!3aHHOCTeii nOKynaTeJIH Ha ce6n, npWIeM B cneQJ1-
aJIbHbrn CpoK HCI«JBOJi ,l:\aBHOCTII - B T€'i€HJ1e 3 MeCRQeB C MOMeHTa.
-126-
KOrt\a aK4HOHep I1.IDf 06!l,\eCTBo Y3Ha.ID1 J1.ID1 t\OJDKHbI 6bIID1 Y3HaTb 0
HapYllleHI1J1 J1X npas.
MHlIJ1MaJIbHbIif cpOK ,l\JlH OcyIl\eCTBJIeHI1H npe ro
npaBa - lOt\Heti, Ma -2 MeCHLla Ecnl1 cne,!J;OBaTb nonroKe-
ID1HM CT. 316 rK P4J, TO J1cnOJ1HeHJ1e 1\OJDKHO 6b1Tb npol13Be1\61O B Me-
ere )KJ1TeJIbCTBa J1.ID1 B MeCTe HaXO:m,1\eID1H t\OJImHl1Ka. OJJ;HaIW J13
CMbICJ1a CT. 7 3aKoHa .fIBCTBYeT npOTI1BiI1O.1X»Kl£1e - «J13BeILIeHl1e aK-
QI10HepOB OC '1epe3 06l1\eCTBo». TaKI-fM06pa30M, J133TO-
ro cnet\YeT, '1TO aKql10Hep 06H3aH,IJ;OI!t:'C'm J1H<i:lopMaQl1IO 0 CBoeM Ha-
MepeHtfJ1 J1MeHHO 1\0 06ll1.ecTBa J1J160 F!BI1BlllJ1Cb B MeCTO ero
HaXO:m,1\eIDfflccoorBeTCTByrolL\l1M .rn16onyreMnO'lTO-
BOra OTilpaBJI€HHH B a.zwec
B nepBoM cny'-Jae Te'leIDfe CpOKa, ycraHOOJ1€HHora 3aKOHOM ,l\JlH
oc:y:Il\€C:TB.JIeHJm npeJlM)'IlI€CTB€HHOro npaBa, Ha'lJ1HaeTCH COOTB€TCT-
BeHHO C MOMeHTa no..n;a'll1 B 06IL1eCTBO IDIC:'bI\fHHOI' J13BeILIeHl1fl, a BO
BTOpOM cny<:!ae. eCJill OB HaIIpaBJIHeT ero no nO'ITe. - c MOMeBTa C)\a'll1 B
opraIDf3tU OO CBH311. Ecnl1 cne)J;OBaTb IIpasl1J1)' 'l. 2 CT 194 rK Pct>, TO
a.KQJ10Hep ,D;OJDKeH JIl1lllb CJ\aTb J13BeILIeHl1e B OpraHl'13t\l.!nlO CBfl311, 11 C
3TOro MOMeHTa DB C'lliTaeTCH J1CIIOJIHI1Bllll1M CBOID o6H3aHHocTh no coo6-
llIeHl1IO 06IL1eCTBy 0 csoeM HaMepeHID:! npotlaTb aKl{ID!. CpoK OC)'IlI€CTS-
neHI1H npeI.1MyIL\eCTBHHOTQ npasa, npe YCTaBOM 06l1\e-
CTBa, l\OJI:1KeH 6bITb He MeBee 10 l\He:M co rom HHR aKlU'KJHepal1,
HaMepeHHbIM npotlaTb CBOI1 al\W1l1 TpeTbeM)'.JIJ1IUT. OCTaJibHbIX aKQ110-
HepoB J1 06l1\eCTBa. CoorneTcmeHHO 3TOT r.mIDIMaJIbHhIi J\eC B-
Hbrn CpoK Ha'll1HaeT Te9b)'iK€ C ,/J;aTbI, I Ha IIITeMIlene 1I0'lT0-
BOro arnpaBJ1eHI1H opram13aQl1eii CM3I1. O,D;HaKO TaKCM MI1HI1Ma.I1bHbD
CpoK B YCTaBe )'Ka3bIBaTb H€L\enec006pa300, IlOCK().JlbR}' TOJIbIOO ,l\JlH
MOCKBbI CpoK 06paILIeHI1fl nO'lTOBOra OT!1paBJ1eHl1fl OT OT!1paBl1TeJlll1\O
a,D;pecaTa MOiKeT COCTamITb 10 JtHe:M, '1'1'0 me Tor,n;a rOBopl1Tb 06 aKQ110-
Hepax, HHJro.WIllI.MXCHC B pa3HbIXropo,n;ax.
B cny'-Jae 1\OnOJ1Hl1TeJIbHoro BbmYCKa B.KIV-di J1 3MI1CCJ'JCIIHbD LteH-
HbIX 6yMar. KOHBeJYI'HPyeMllX B al\W1l1 (Ha 0CID33HIDI CT. 40, 413aKoHa
«OS aKL[I1UH€pHbIX ) npaBo IIpeHMyILleCTBei 1I0KynKI1
B03ID1KaeT TOJ1bKO,l\JlH aKql10HepoB, HO He,l\JlH 06l1\eCTBa, KaK B nepBOM
c.nyqae. KpoMe TOro, OHO MOmeT 6b1Tb pea.m13OI3<lHO He BCeMl1 1CHe-
paMl1, a TOJIbKO aKqJ10B€paMI1 OTKpbITbIX o6Il\ecTB, pa3MeIl.l8-KJW,i1X a1\:-
LtI--U1 nocpl'1ICTBOM 0TKpU'I'0ii nO)I,lll1CKW J1 aKJV40HepaMI1 06IL1eCTB, rono-
COBaSIIll1M11 npO"I'HB J1JIJIJ: He npUHI1M3B1IIi'1MH y<:!aCTI1H B I'OJ1OCOBaIDfI1 110
BOnpocy 0 pa3MeILl€HJDI nOCpe,lJ;CTBOM 3aKpbI"IOii IIO,J:J;IIi'1CKJI aKWiH J1
SMI1CCI10H11bJX lteIDlbIX 6)'Mar, KOHBepnipyeMbIX B al\W1l1.
-127-
YKa3aHHoe npaBO He pacrIpOCTpaliHeTCH Ha pa3Mer.u;elu:!e aKW'l" J'!
I1HhlX 3M11CC110HHblX qeHHhIx 6YMar, KOHBePTl1pyeMhix B aKL\ffif, ocy-
IQ('CTBJlReMOe nocpe,lJ;CTBOM 3aKph1TfJiI nOJlID:!CKI1 TOJIhKQ cpeW1 BKQI10-
HepOB, eCJ111 npl1 3TOM aKIV«JHePbI I1MelOT B03M())KIJ()C'I I1pJl06pecT1l
qeJ10e 'lI1CJ10 pa3MeIqaeMhIX BKW'Ii11f I1HhlX 3MI1CCI10HHhIX qelllihlX 6y-
Mar, KOHBepTI:!pyeMhIX B aRqIrn, nponopl.\l10llaJlhHO KOJII1'{eCTBY npl1-
HaJ\J1emall\l-1X IfM BKW'Ii1 CUOTBeTC'IByroIJJ;eA KaTeropl1J.-I (TJma) (n. 1
CT. 40 3aKOHa «05 HepHbIX OOll-\eCTBax»)
IIepBoHa'l8.JlhHO HHoe npaBo npl106pereHl1H 6hLJ1o
3aKpelIJ1eHO 3a BKQI10HepaMI1 B 3aKOHO,!\aTeJ1hCTBax CTpaH C iCH-
cTeMoi1 npaBa.B3aTeMnOJ1Y'illJ1olll1-lpoKOepa IfB KOH-
'I'llH€HT8.JIbHOM npaBe. 2fl1
IIpeI-:!M npaBY npl106pereHJ1HBKLlffii:J-II1HhlX LleHHb1X
6yMar Koppecn0H.D:I1PYeT 06H3aHHOCTh aKqi'IOHepoB, OT'I.)'JRM,IOIl-\I1X aK-
LII1J.'I, 11 aKQ>1OHepHOro 061L\e<:TBa no yBe.l(OMJI€HHIO aRQI10HepoB, J:!MelO-
LIJ;I1X npel1M)'Il\ecTBeHHoe npaBO npKJ6pt"reHIDL .JlliLta, BKJIIOqeHHhle B
CID:!COK JIJ-II\, HMelOll\I-1X npe oe npaBo np:v!06pe-reHIDI /1.0-
m.JIHWIeJIbHhI: aKW'li1 J'! SMHC:01OHHh1X I.1;eHHhIX 6yMar, KOHBepTl1pye-
MbIX B BKQJrn OOll-\eCTBa, fJ.OJDKHbl 6bITb YB€,l\OMJI€Hb1 0 B03I\:!illKHOCT
€C'I'BJJ€ffi1H J-IMI1 npe HHOCO CT. 40 3aKOHa npel1M)'lll;ecT-
BeHHoronpasa Bnop e, npel1;.)'CMOTpeHHOMHM AJIHCfJlJ6memrn onpo-
Be/1.eHJrn o61L\ero co6paHillI aKLII'IOHepoB.
B Te-qeHl1e cpoKa ,n;eiic:TBHR npeJ'!Myw;eCTBeHHOro npasa SMI1TI1pO-
Balllihie oor.u;eCTBOM aKqI1I1 J:! KOHBepTl1pyeMble B BKQJrn qeHHhle 6)'Ma-
rn nOMemaT pa3M TOJIbKO cpe,D;l1 BKW'IOHepOB, IIO,IJ,aBIlII1X B
rnlCbMeHHOe 3aflBJleHJ'!e onpJ'!06peTemrnBKLlffii: J:!3M1-1CCHOH-
HhIX qeHHhlX 6yMar, KOHBepTI:!pyeMbIX B aKW'l", J'! OlIJ1aTI1BIill-IX npH06-
peTBeMb1e qeHHhIe 6YMarH B COO'JBeTC'I'BIfI C Tpe60sam-:!F!MI1 CT 41 3a-
ROlla «06aKW'lOHepHhlX . TaKl1M 06Pa30M, Ha
OT'I.)'JRM,lOllI;I1X BKQI1H, J'! 06r.u;ecTBe, nOMHMO ofiH3aJnmc'm;: )'Be,n;OMJIe-
IDIH 0CTaJ1bHb1X aRl.\I1CIIepoB 0 HaMepemll--l npo,!\aTb BKQI1J-1 J-I HaJD--I'IHH
yaKLll'DHepoB npeHMylL\eCTBeHHOrO npaaa, J1em11T TalOKe 06H3aHHOCTb
B03fJ.ep:)Kl1BaTbCH OT fJ.ei1CTBffii: no OT'lY'f\,!\eHl-110 8KQIrli J1l1QaM, He J'!Me-
IOIl-\I-IM npaBaI1pl106peTeHJ1H.
On.naTa aKI.tI--IfI 06IL1eCTBa. pB3MeIqaeMhlX no-
cpe,n;cTBOM nO)J;llHCKl1, oCYlL\eCTBJIHeTCH no LleHe, Onpe,ll;e.1lf!eMOH cose-
TOM ,lIJ--IpeKTOpOB (Ha6.mo.D,aTe.m.EbIM COBeTOM) 06ll-\eCTBa B COOTBeTCT-
BID'! CO CT. 77 3aKoHa «05 aKQI10HepHhlxo6r.u;eCTBax», HO He HI-I:?Ke J'!X
HOMIrnaJibHOi1 CTOm.fOCTII. KoHe'lHO, Tpy,llHO onpe.iJ.eJiJITb pbIHO'lH)'lO
CTIJI'1MOCTb BKW'Ii1 npl1 J'!X OlIJ1aTe, TeM 60J1ee eCJIH aKqI1I-I He Rafl1poBa-
..ID:ICb Ha CPOH,!\OBOi16I1p*e HID:! He 06pauuunfCb Ha He611p*eBOM pblHKe.
3T0 06cToHTeJlbCTBo C03,n;aeT ,AOIIDJIIDITeJ1bHble Tpy,l\HOCTI1,l1JIH Cy,llOB.
-128-
B COOTBeTCTBJIJI C n 2 cr. 36 3aKOHa «05 8KW'10HepHbIXoor.u;ecrBax»
qeHa pa3MenteHWI ,lJ;onQJ1HtfTenbHhlX 8KW'1i1 8RJ.-tl10HepaM 05r.u;eCTBa
npJl! ocytIt2CTBJ1eIllm m.rn: npeJ npaBa lIpJ106peTemrn
MOiKeT6hIThHJ1:me qeHhI pa3Mer.u;emm MHhlMnl1qaM, HO He 6anee
'1eMHa 10",,- Bcny<1aeHapyrnemmnpe cm npaaa nptf06-
peTeHllii npilllJITtfeM COBe1'OM P.JI!PeKTOpoB pernemm 06 onp('J\eJIeIDm
CTOJIMOCTJI qeHHhlX 6yMar C HapyrnemleM 3aRoHa, aKWIO-
Hep anpaae ocnapmmTh TaROe perneID1e B cy,lJ;e c 'Ip€fioBaH1'1eM npJl!-
3HaTb ero He,lJ;eii:CTBJITeJIbHbIM. 262
10. AH,rij)eea C'U-fTaeT, '1TO a cny'-Jae uapyrnemm I1peJ HO-
ro npaBa npro5peTeIDIJI ,lJ;onOJIffifTeJ1hHhlXaRLlffii:JUThI npJl!pa3Ml'l.qeIDm
,lJ;(XIOJIHJJTeJIbHbIX aKWIi1 no LleH3.M, He COOTBeTCTByK!1W1M 7pe60aaID1HM
CT. CT 36, 37 3aKOHa «05 8RLltfOHepHhIX 05r.u;eCTBaX», -
Hbrn aKLltfOHep BnpaBe nOTpe60BaTb '1epe3 CYA IIpII3HaIDDI c,!:\eJIKJil He-
,D;ei1C'rBJ:rreJIbHOi,i: J1J1J1! J13MeHemrn I.1;eHbL 263
O,!:\HaRO HeCMOTpJl Ha TO, '1TO YKa3aHHbIe OTHI:iIlIEHJ1JI CTpOHTCJI no
MQJ:IeJIJI 06J13aTeJ1bCTB€HHblX, OID1 06.JIa.n;aeT c:npeAe.IIeHHoi1 cneqJl!4JJI!-
ROi1, 06yc.nce.neHHOi1 TeM, '1TO peanJ13yeTCJI B aRl.\MOHepHoM 06lL\eCTSe
J1 TeCHO nepen.neT8eTcJI C B03ID1KaIDIqI1MJ1 TaM KopnopaTillIHbIMJ1 O7HO-
rneHIDIMI1, J1MeKYr oco6oe co,!:\epJKaHtfe VI nOpJl,i:\OK pea.m13aqJl!J1.
3aKOH «05 8KL\VlOHepHblx 06r.u;ecTaax» He co,!:\ep:mJI!T npHMOro YKa-
aaHllii 0 BIJ3M1:DKHOCTII O7'\)')f\',!\eHIDI :3TOro npasa, B TO BpeMH KaR B
CT. 7 yKa33.HHOro 3aKOHa, pernaMeHTIlpyrolL\eA BOnpOCb! pea.1IJ138I1IUt
npe11MYJ--II;eCTBeHHoro npaaa npVl06peTeHlliI 8KL1ID1, npO,!\aBaeMhIX 8K-
I:IJI!OHepaMJ1, npJlMO CKaaaHO, '1TO YCT)'IIKa YKaaaHHoro IIpeHMyw;eCT-
BeHHoro npaBa He ,lJ;onYCK8eTCfl. CrreJ1YeT JU1 OTCyrc'I'We TaRoro npH-
Moro YKaaaHlliI 0 HeB YCTyrrKJI! B CT. 40 11 41 3aKOHa
nOHtfMaTb KaR,lJ;03BOJ1eHVle (no nptflUltfny «pa3peIl1eHo Bce, '11'0 He 3a-
nper.u;eHO 3aROHOM»)? BtfJltfMO, CJJeJ1YeT cornaCtfTbCJI C IO.A. MeTene-
BOM B TOM, '1TO TaRoe npaao HBJIJleTCJI HeDT'i.Y:tK,!\aeMbIM, J1 ecnJl! 8RI:IJI!-
OHep He .menaeT npVl06peTaTh HOBbie 8RLltfJ1, ero npaBa He 5Y.lIYT
peaJlJ130BaHbi Boo5lL\e. 264
3a pyfie:moM HHb!e npaBa nORynRJI! ,/:\01IOJIHJrrem.-
HbIX aKlV'lA, RaR npaBHJ1o, HBJIJIKYrCJI oT'-JYm,!\aeMblMtf. EcnVl 8KL\ID1 KQ-
TI1pyroTCH Ha 6J1!p:me, TO 11 npe HHble npaBa KOTItpyKYI'CJI Ha
6J1!piKe.05b!,{HOHOBbJeaKWIVl aKlV'lOHepaMBKOm1'l€C'T-
Be, npcrIDpI:lJl!(lHaJ1bHC I1X ,[lone B YCTaBHOM K8ID1Tane. Y
CepTI:!4JJI!K3TOB, y,/:\OC'JOBepmolWlX npt?J1M)'I1I;eCTBeHHoe npaBO npVl06-
peTeHI1R,eCTh SOCIIOJIb3OBaTbCHCBOJl!MnpaBOM11nOAJlI1-
caTbCJI Ha aKLlJI!J1 HOBora BbIIIYCKa; npo,[\aTb 3TI1 CepTIl4J:I1K1lTbI; He
npe,[\!Ipl1ID1MaTb HHKaKlIX ,D;eiiC'l1 JD"i J1 Jti,Q8Tb, KOr,D;a J1CTe'-leT cpOR ,!:\ei1:-
CTBJI!H 3TJI!X CepTI:!4JJI!K3ToB.,lI;..rrH nOBb!llIeHVlH 3aUH"I€peCoBaHHOCTI1 a1\:-
-129-
QnOHepc:m B nOKyrrKe HOBbIX aKLpm 05meCTBO YCTaHaBJrnBaeT CKMJ];KY C
I1X TeK)'ll-\ei-f pbllJO'BIOi-f qeHhL
I'occJdicKoe 38.KOHO):jaTeJIbCTBO, RaK J1 3aKOHO,!\aTeJIhCTBO MHornX
CTpaH, npe.r:JyCMaTp maeT B03MOOK1!OCTb YBenl1'1eHI1J1 YCTaBHoro Kam-I-
TaJJa 3a C'IeT BltyrpemlJ1X cpe):\CTB aKL fOHepHoro , npIl!KOTO-
paM IIpCII'1CX(VJ.J1T 6ecIIJIaTHoe paCIIJX'-):\€JIeIe 8KQWi1 Mempy npemHII!-
Mil! aKLV-IOHepaMI1 nponoplU'JOIk\J1b1Jo J1X ,lJ;o.nJlM B npemHeM ycTcIB1IOM
Ram-rra.ne.
AKQV!OHephl ofu:rap;aKYr TaKme II! npaBOM BhIKyIIa lI{I-IX
J-IMaKLV-Iti:.
Ha OCHJBaHIDI CT. 75 3aKOHa «05 aKqIt:ooepHbIX CJf3mec'rnax" aKL\lI!-
oHephl - BJI3JJ;eJIbQbll'OJIOCyICIQ>IX 8KW-IW BilpaBe 'Ipe60BaTb BbIKyna
o6utec"moM Bcex J-IJIJI! 'Iacm np x II!M 8K14I1A B cJ1yqa.Rx:
- peopraHY:!3aqI-IJl! 05meCTBa I-IJIJiI cOBepweHWI KPymlOi1 c.n;emm, pe-
weHi-ie 06o,D;05peHJ-IJ1 KOTOpOi1 npl1HJ1Ma€TC.II 05lI{1-IM c06paHY:!eM aKQV!O-
HepDB B COOTBeTC'IBIDI C n. 2 CT. 79 )'Ka3fUIHOro 3aKOHa, eCJ111 OHI1I'OJIO-
COBaJll1 npOTl1B npl-IHJI'"IUJI pellIeHI1J'1 0 ero peopraHH3aL\I1I1, I1J1I1
o,wJ6peHJm )'Ka38HHOW C,D;eJIKJ-I nl150 He npJ-IHJ-IMam-I yqac'IW'I B I'OJIOCO-
BaHJl!lI!nO:31'11M BorrpocaM;
- BHeceHI-IJ'I H3l\o!€HeHI1M: J1 AOIIQ.JIH€HI1ii B ycTaB o51l\ecTBa I-IJIJiI YT-
Bepm,D;eHWIycraBa 05meCTBa B HOBOWpe,D;aKQWI1, OIp J1X
npasa, eCJ111! OHl1I'OJIOCOBam-I npOTl1B IIpI-IHHTIUI COOTBeTCTByrolIlero pe-
llIeHl1H I1J1I1 He npl1Hl1lV!aJiI1 )"IaCTI-IJ'I B I'OJIOCOBaHI-I11.
CYIL\HOCTb ::rroro npaBa COCTOI1T B TOM, 'ITO npll! IIpIIHm'IDI 061l\J1!M
co5paHl1eM 3Ha'll1MhlX J\JlR .IJ;aJJbHei1:wei1 CY,D;h5hl 051l\eCTBa pelIleHl1W
8KlV'10Hepb1, He cor.naCHhlec pemem-IeM06ll-\eroc06paHI-I.R, nO)J;'ll1lU1KYr-
CJ'I BOJle 6o.rrbnn-IHCTBa., np<Jl1).lIOC(JB3BWeI'O 3a npllHm'J-Ie pemeHl-IJ'I, HO
npeKpall.\81OT J1J111 YMeHbwalOT CBJI3h C 06 KOTOpoe ,lJ;aJlee 5y-
11.eT CHltp:JBaTb B COOTBeTCTIIJ1I- C pellleHl1eM co5pamffi Ha 113-
MeHelllibIX Ha'la.rrax. )J;aHHoe I1paBO MOOKHO paCCMaTpl1BaTb RaK cBOe06-
pa3Hb1tf cnoc05 3a1lV1Tb1 'lJleHCKI1X npaB aKLUlOHepa.
Jl:.B. JIOMaKrnI TaKme paCCMa"Ipl1BaeT:31'O npaBO RaK cnoco5 3alI{l-I-
TbI npaB aKW-IOHepa, npl1 :31'OM C'IITIaH, 'ITO ero HeJlh3J'l WHeCTI1 HI1 K
ol1,HoA 113 o51l\enpl1WlTbIX rpynn B03MroKHOCTei1,
ynpaBO JIJ-Iqy npaBoM Ha 3alI{W'TY. «OH He J'lBJ1.ReTCJI CIIOCO-
60M CaM03alL\l1Tb1 'LJIeHCKJ-I:X npaB, IIOCKOJIbKy ynpaBOMO'IeHHO€ nl1L\O
l1,JlH3aILtJ-IThICBoero npaBa HeCOBeJ:lll<l-€T )J;eACTBWi no-
pJ'l)J;Ka He np: ,D;aHHbrn cnoco6J1 K MepaMoilepaTJl!BHOrOB03-
11.ewCTBI1F!, TaKI1M 06paaOM,l1,JlH ero peaJIH3aL!>11-I Tpe5yKrrCJ'I He TOJlhKO
1OpI-f.IJ;JI!'I€CKJ1 3Ha'lJ-lMb1e l1,efiCTEW! 8KlV-'10Hepa, HO 11 KoppecnOH,W!pyro-
Il{JI!€ J-IM JJ;eH:CTBI1H 8KLIMOHepHOro 06u..J€CTBa. B ,D;allliOM cJ1Y'Iae H€Jlh3J'1
06HapymnTh 11 Mep 1'0cy,D;apCTBeHHoro npl1lfY'K)J;€HJ1F!, 11150 aKQV!OHephl
-130-
He 06palIlpIOTCR 311 31llql1TOM cBoe1'O npaBa K KOMIIeTeHfHbIM roCYMP-
CTBelll1b1M opraHaM. TaMe 06paI.qemle IIIJ3Mf»KH() n03me. B CJ1)"ffie OT-
Ka31l 05r.qeCTBa OT BbIKyrra ».265
.lI;yMae'I'CJI, 'ITO 3TOT cnoc06 BnOJ1He MOmHO 0THeC'D1 K O,!UJOMY 1'13 ne-
pe'-l CJ1elll1bIX CT. 12 rK P<P cnoco6oB 3alql1TbI rpa»Q¥lHCKI1X npaB -
npeKpar.qemno J1.ID11f3MeHeIDfi(I IIplBOOTHOllIeHIDl.
Tpe60BaTb BbIKyna aK1U-di Mor)'T TOJ1bKO aKl.t OHepb!, He npI1WlB-
nrne Y'ffiCTWI B roJJOOOBaHMIf J11160 npl1HJlBllIl1e, HO nporoJJOOOEaBl1D1E'
«lIJXITI1B». ECJ111 aKWiOHep 3apernCTpl1pOBaJICH AJlH )"I3.CTI1.FI B c05pa-
HI1I1, HO He nporo.nocoBaJI, TO OH He J1MeeT npaaa TpeOOBaTb BblKyna aK-
QI1i1. He If MeeT npaBa Tpe50BaTb BbJKYI1a If aKQWOHep. 51OJ1J1eTeHb KQ-
TOp01'o ,wIR lOJIOCOBaHJlH npl13HaH He,lJ;eMCTBWreJIbHbIM. )J;.rrR TOro,
'IT05bI Y .HBl-IBWerocH Ha c06paHI1e aKlV'IOHepa nORBI1JIOCb npaBo 'Ipe50-
BaTb BbIKyna, Heo6xo.Iu:1MO em BOneK3'bHBJ1eHJle, KOTO}X>e 0)J;H03Ha"fH0
MOmHO l1,JJ;eHTH tpOBaTb ltaK fOJIOC, nO,QaHHbrn npon1B BbIHeCelll10-
1'0 Ha r0J10COBaHl1e pellIeHI1H.
B cJIY"ae H3J1If'UtH y 8Kl\110Hepa npaaa 'IpeOOBaTb BbIKyna aKL!ffii: 11
npe.In>fIBJIft1 TaKoro 'I'p€6oBamm B CpOK 11 B nOpR,ltKe, yCTaHOBJIeH-
HOM 3aKoHoM «06 aKlV'IOHepHbIX06IItecTBax», 05IIteCTBO ofuI3aHo npo-
113B€CTI1 BbIKyrr npJl! y<:J1OBJBI co5mo.l\eHWI OrpaHWIeHIDf, yCTaHoBJIeH-
Horo CT. 76 3aKOHa: o5r.qaR cyMMa cpe,i:(CTB, HaIIpaBJI.HeMb1 06il.\ecTBOM
Ha BbIKyrr aKqI1M, He MomeT npeBbIIIIaTb 10''h C'"ItlliMOCTI1 'lI1CTbIX aKTJl!-
BOB 06il.\eCTBa Ha ,QaTY npl1HHTI1.FI peweHl1H, KOTopoe nOBJ1eKJ10 B03H11K-
HOBeHl1e y aKqI10HepOB npaBa Tpe50BaTb BbIKyrra 06IItecrBoM npl1Ha,i:(-
.nemaIl{Jl!X 11M aKL!ffii:. ECJ111 Y 06il.\ecTBa HeT 'tI1CTbIX aKTI1BOB, TO
06l1\eCTBo 06R3aHO HaIIpam1Tb cpe,i:(CTBa pe.aepeHOrO q.oH.!\a .!IJ1$I T01'O,
'1Mb! BbIKyrraTb aKlV'I".
B CJ1}"1ae €C.n11 06il.\ee KOJIl1'IecTBO aKqI1fi, B arH!IIIE.flHI1 KOTOpbIX 38-
RBJIeHbI 'Ipe50BaHWI 0 BbIKyne, npeBbIIIIaeT KOJII1'IecTBO aKI.IJI!fi:, KOTO}X>e
MO:IKeT 6bITbBbIKyrLJIeHO 06IIteCTBOM C yqeorOM ycTIllIOBJIeHHOI'O OIpaHl1-
'1eHJ1fI, aKWtM BbIKyrraIOTCR Y aKLIIDJepoB nponopLtl«UIaJllom 3CI1IBJ1eH-
HbIM Tpe50BCLHWIM. TaKI-{M 05pa30M. COBeJXIIeHHO He q.aKT, 'lTO aK1tJl!OHe-
PY Y.AaCTCH npD.AaTb Bce CHOI1 8.I\W1I1 06IIteCTBY, O)J;HaKO, no Rpa:iim:ii
Mepe, KaK)'IO-TO 'IacTb aKL!ffii: o6nJ:'croo BbfKYI1I1Tb Y aKLtJ10Hepa 6YAeT
06R3aHo, B CJIy'Iae HaJIJl!'-ll1R q:Je,i:(CTB B pe3epl3HOM 4>oH,I\e. B CJIy'Iae, ec-
J1I1 cpe.QcTBa 4>0H,Q3. )"Ire n3pacxD.1:J.(EaHb HanpJ1Mep, Ha IIUKpbITJJe
y6b1TKOB 06I.J.1€CTBa, TO aKLtJ1Jf Y aKLtl-'lOHepoB BbIKynaThCR He 6y,lJ;JT.
.lI;yMae'I'CJI, 'lT0 DTHOllIeHl1R Mem.ny oI5utec-moM If 8KQJ1!DHepaMJl! no
nOBo)Jy ocYJl.\€CTBJIeHWI JlMI1 npaaa BbIKyrra CTpORTCJ'! no MO,JJ;€JBI 0611-
31lTt'J1bCTBE'IlI1hIX. XOTR If CBR3aHbI C npaBoM aK1tJl!OHepOB Ha )"I3.cTI1e B
06IIteM C06paHJI!J1. IIocJ1e rOJIOCOBaHI1.H {(npOTl1B» no paccMa'IpI1BaeMO-
My co6paHI1eM BOnpOCY aKW10Hep B Te'-leHl1e onpe,!J;eJ1eHHoro 3aKOHoM
-131-
CpoKa BIIpaBe HailpaBMTb 06meCTBY Tpe60murne 0 BbIKyne aKQIDL
J1MeHlIO C MOMeHTa mmpaBJ1eHtUI 06mecrny 'Ipe60BaH11J11f B03Hl1KaeT
paCCMaTpI1BaeMOe 06H3aTeJIbCTBeIllIOe 0TH0lIJeIlI'Ie. 06I1-\ecrno (AOJIm-
IDIK) 06H3aHO OC)'U*'CTBJ1Tb BbJKYI1 aKLlffii: (XOTfi 6b! '1acTI1'1Hb! , B CJ1Y-
'1ae HaJ1J1t1J1j111J1fl 3TOro q:Je,!\CTB), a aKJ-ti-'IOHep (Kpep;l1TOp) BIIpaBe ::ITO-
ro Tpe60BaTb, B TOM 'lI1CJ1e If no cy _ CYAb! B c.rryqae Y,ll(lB.JleTB(pe
J1CKOa aKLIl10HepoB no TaKI1M cnopaM B CBOJ1X peweHJL'IX 06 06J13a1IHJ1
aKLlI'lOHepHoro 05meCTBa m,mym1Tb aKLtID'! )'Ka3bIBaJOT KO.lll1'leCTBO J1
TIm (KaTeropl1KJ)aKLlffii:, n BbIKyny.
10Hepb! Moryr 'Ipe60BaTb BbIKyna 1Ipi1Ha,!I,J1ema1Ltl1X 11M aKJ-ti-'I
TaKmE' J1 B c.rryqae, €CJ1I1 aKqJ1J1 J13Ha'laJIbHO pa3M€ILI<lJII1Cb
KaK IIpI1BMJIerl1poBaHHbIe B03apaTHble, TO eCTb TaKwe, KO-
TOpb!e nO)I.J1emaT BbIKyny ofuLtec'rooM '1epe3 onpe,!\eneHHoe BpeMH 11J111
IIpI1 HacrYIIJIeHJ1JII OIIpell.€.IIE'HHbIX yCJlOBJ1iii. XonI nepe'-leHb cJIY'-laes,
Kor,!\a aKLIl10Hepb! J1MelOT npaBO 'Ipe60BaTb BbIKyIIa aKLlffii: 06lI.\€CTE1OM,
J1 onpe,/J;eJJeH B 3aKOHe HC'le OOpB30M, HO eCIDf 06I1-\eCTBo
06fl3aJIOCb nepe,lJ; aKW10HepaMM BbIK)'III1Tb aKQID1 'lepe3 KaKOe-TO Bpe-
MH nyreM 3aKpenJ1eHHJ'! 3TOro B yCTaae, TO OHO, 6e3yCJ10BHO, 06J'!3aHo
3T0 C)\eJIaTb, a aKQnOHepbI BlIpaBe 3TOI'O Tpe50BaTb. B :;!TOM cJIY'-lae
o6fl3aT€JIbHbrl1 BbIKyn He 6Yl\eT BbICTynaTb CIIoco60M 3aII-\HTbI npaB
aKJ-ti-'IOHepOB. 06Il\ee 006pam1€ 06I1-\ecTBa 05J13aHO IIpJ1lUITb pelIIeHHe 0
BbIKyne aKLlffii:. B 3TOM c.nyqae aKW10Hepb! He TOJIbKO l1MeIOT npaBO
Tpe60BaTb BbIKyna 06Il\eCTBOM TaKJ1X aKLIffii:, HO VI O.n;HOBpeMeHHO 06J'!-
3aHbI npO,!\aTb I1X 06mecTBY, Kor,lla 06I1-\eCTBo o&wISJIJ1eT 0 BbIKyne.
B c.nyqae HapyrneHHfl KaKOM-.ID16o 1'13 CTOpoH CBOI1X 06J'!3aHHOCTeH
.r:q>yraJ1cTOpOHa Brrpase 06paTI1TbCfl B CYA C IfCKOM oIKJHY7K,ll;emm.r:q>y-
roM CTOpOHbI K IfCrrOJIHeID11O pelIIemm o5mero co6paID1fl 0 BbIKyne aK-
ltI-'I .OrnolIIellJ1.ll, 1€Cf! Mem,!\Jo6utecmoMJ1aKlV10Hepa-
MIf no nOBOAY BbIKyna aKlV1i1. .fIBJ1J1lOTCfl o6fl3aTeJIbCTBeHHbIMI1.
IIo CBJJ.!Iere.JIbCrBy MH. J13pa:3JIl1Ta, 1\0 p€BG.JIlOQlflf If B COBeTCKoe
BpeMfI,D,JIF!Bb]Kyna I1pMM€HJIJIJfCbTJ.-IpamJ1aMOj)TJ.-I-
3aQJ1j1. Mx 11CIIOJ1h3OBaIDIe o6fl3aTeJIbHO 1\0J1mHO 6bIJIO 6b!Tb 05YCJ10B-
.neHO B yCTaae 06I1-\eCTBa. IIo.n; 8McpT113aW1e IIOIImIf3JIOCb nOCTeII€H-
Hoe norau:reHHe aKLlffii: nYTeM J1X OMaTbl. AMopTH3aLIWI 06bIKHOBeHHO
npOMCXO,!I;l1J1a nYTeM Tl1pama, TO eCTh 113BJ1e'leJrnj! no mpe511KJ J13BeCT-
BOro '-IWCJIa aKQJrli, KaKOBb!e 11 ytDI'l'"I'O)KamlCb C Bb!Il.ffinoii I1X c06CT-
BeHHHKY lIeHbI aKlV1fi. AMOj)TH3al\J1j1 npollC"«J,J:UiJ1a J1J1H 3a C'IeT :yMeHb-
IIIeHl1.H OCHOSHOro KaIDnaJIa, J1J111 sa C'leT 'lHCToif npl16b!JIH. B3aMeH
aMoj)TI13I1pOBaHHbIX aKWrii aK1<JIOHep<\M MOrJII1 BbWBaTbCJ'l 1IOJIb3()Ba,-
TeJ1bCKJ1e aKLtJ1If, no KQTOpblM l\epmaTeJIH I1X yrpa'1HBaJlJ1 npaso Ha
KaIDfTaJi 06meCTBa, HO coxpaHHJIIl npaBo Ha 1\I1BI11\eH.l\- 266
-132-
CTaTbH 67 rR Pcb coJ\epJKUT IIOJImKeIille 0 TOM, '1TO Y'lliCTHJI!KI1 XO-
3S1iic'meHHh1x TOBapl1 eCTB J1 06 eCTB MOryr HeCT nOMl1MO 06J13aH-
HOCre" no BHecemno BKJI1l)Ia B ycTaBIIbli1 KaIIJ1TaJI J1 Hepa3rnallieHIDI
l<oH4JJ1,I\eHUMaJIbHoR J1Hi¥>pMalUI1f J1 .I\PYfI1e 06J13aHllOCTJl, KOTOpble
npeJJyCMOTpeHbI J1X Y'lpe ,D.OJ<YMeH'1'8MI'L TaKJiM 00pa30M,
aKqI10HepbI Moryr BCT}'IIaTb J1 B HeKOTVpbIe .I\Pyr e KopilopaTI1BHble
J1J1J.-1 o6JI3aTenbCTBeHHbIe npaBOO'I'HOlll€ B CO,1J;epmaID1e 1<0TOpblX
BXO,1J;J1T ooroaHHocT£f, ,l\OII01IHH'I'eJ1bHO npe.lI.yCMO'I'p YCTaBOM.
O,IJ;HaKO IO.A. Mere.neBa BI>ICKa3aJla cJleA)'lOUJ;yIO II03UL,Wo. «B CBJ1-
3 C TeM, '1TO K)HepHoe 06 ecTBO .fIBJIReTCJ::r o&be.D;JlH€1JJI€M Kan -
TaJIOB, aKQJ10Hep, KpOMe II€pe'lI'1CJ1€HHl> He McmreT J1MeTb .I\PyrMX
06J13aHHOCTeH. OR He 06J13aH BHOCJITb ,lJ.OII(\JlHI'1ble B3HOCbI CBepx
OIIJIaTbl CBOJ.-lX aKIV-Iti, He 06J:J:3aH Y'lliCTBOBaTb J1W1HbIM Tpy;n;OM B ]J,eJ::r-
TeJIbHOCTII o6 ecTsa, KaK STO OIIp€.l:IeJIeHO B YCTaBax HeKOTopblX aKQl1-
OHepHbIX 06lL\ecTB. Ec.TIH aKqI10Hep nOJIHOCTblO OIIJiaTJ1J1 CBO aKL,Jm,
OH He MO:1KeT 6blTh HCK./llO'IeH H3 aKQl10HepHoro o6 ecTsa no KaKI1II'I 6bI
TO HJ16bIJlOOCHOsaHJ1J1M...,,267
no MHeHHIO .lI;.R.IToMarorn.:\, B CJ1J1Y cn€Wl$oo1 aKW\UHepHOW $:Jp-
Mbl npe.wrpHIHlMaTeJlbCKOW J\eJITeJIbHOCTII HeB03MO:>KH0
C03J\aTb MexaHJ13M Ha)lJIeiKalL\ero J1CIIOJIHeHHH ,IJ;OIIO.JIHJIT 06H-
38.HHoCTeti: aKqI1OH€pOB, YCTaHaBmmaeMbIX B xO,1J;e nOKaJlbHoro HOpMO-
TBop'leCTBa, nOCKOJlbKY no J\ei1CTIJYIO eMY 3aKoHo)\aTeJlbCTB}' aK4I10-
HepHoe 06LQ,€CTBO B nill.le CBOJ1X opraHOB He OOn:Mae-r B OTHOllleHHH
CBOHX 'lJIeHOB BJIaCTHb!M1f IIOJIIIOMO'lI1HMJL CpeJll1 06H;3aHHoCTei1aKQl1-
OHepoB He C)'ILIeCTB}'eT 06peMeHeHJffi BbillOJIHHTb paCIJopH:1KeHJ1H opra-
HOB aKI..P1OHepHOro 06 eCTsa.266
BE. .lI;OJIIDICKaJ1, HaIIpOTJ1B, cturraeT, 'ITO «aKQffi:!... BO Bcex c.nyqaJIX
Ha,1J;eJlHIOT06J13aIlliOCTHMJ1 no OTHOIlIeHHIO K 06 eCTBY (CoOnlCJ,1J;aTb mJ1O-
m€ID-I$! Y'lPero-rreJlbHblX J\otcyMeHTOB; BHOCJ1Tb I B nopH,1J;Ke, pa3-
Mepe J1 cnocd5aMJl, npelJ:YCMarpeHHb!M1f yqpe,u;I1TE'.JIbHbIMH J\oKYMelITa-
MJ1; J1CnOJ1ltJ::rTb pewelU1f! opraHOB ynpaBJIeHJ1.fI 06w,ecma;
Hepa3I'J1aI1l8.Tb J1Hi¥>pMaI-\JOOOeroAemeJIbHOC'I']:t;
npl1 1MOC'rnoKa3bIBaTb06lL\€CTBy B
J-IM Cooei1]J,eJlTeJ1bHOCTH J1 nOMOlLtb,llpyr,llpyry J1,l1pyrne)>>.269
J];.B. JIOMaKJ1H nOW3epr KpJITJ1Ke STy nOOI1L\HIO Ha TOM OCHOBaHJBI,
'1TO, no ero MHeHJ1IO, aKL\HH y,lJ;OCTOBepJ1eT J1MeHHO KOMIIJleKC npaB,
'lJIeHCTBO B 06 eCTBe, a He OT;n;eJ1bHble npasa aKqJ10Hepa, J1 «Y'* KQ-
He<iHO He ero IID1Q>Wl€CRJJe 06J:J:3aHHOCTJ1 no OTHOllleHJ11O K aKQl10HepHO-
My 06lL\eCTB}', KaK OlllH60'IHO nOJIaraKfr HeKOTOpbIe aBTOpb!.270
OR CtlJITae-r, 'ITO OCHOBHbI€ 06H3aHHocTJ1 cyD'beKTOB aRl\I«IH€pHOl'O
npaElOO1'HCUleHW'! 3aKJI}()qaKYrCH B TOM, 'IT06bI He HapyIIIaTb npaBa
JrnblX yqacnmKOB STOro npaBOOTHOllleHJ1J::r. npH HeHCIIOJ1HeHJ1H 3TOW
-133-
06H:3aHH0cmnoc .mlIJpMmKeToopanITbCJI3a Ha-
pVUIeHIUO npaBa. IIpI4 3TOM B03ID1KaeT OXpaHJrreJ1bHoe npanOCYrHO-
rneID1e C ROHKpeTHbIM CyO'beKTHbIM COCTaBOM, HOCHIl\ee 06H3aTeJ1hCT-
B€'HHbI :xapaKTep. !71
IIpe.I1cTaBJ1J1eTCJI, '1TO RaK pa3 o6.f!3aHHJcrI, ThCH OT
HapyrneHJ1Il npaB IfHhIX yqaCTlillKOB aKQI40HepHoro npaBOOTIl<Ill£'HWI
He MOiKeT BXQZI,J1Tb B COCTaB nOCJ1e,D;HeI'O. TaKaR 06R3aHH0C'rb He 3a-
RpenJ1eHa HOpMaWl OHepHOCO npaBa I4 cYIl\eCTByeT Ha OCHOBe 06-
ll{J1X nOJ1mKeHV! rp8)fi,!\8HCIDI npaBa. He TOJ1hKO aKWtOHep, HO J1 100-
ooe A])yroe n111.10, RaK I3J1'1eCKOe, TaK J!1Op , 06H3aHhI He
npenSITCTBOBaTb lUno CHOI4X npaB 1\P)'TIfMJ1 cy6'heRTaWl, a
T3.KiKe H€ 3JIoynOTpe6JIJITh npaBaMI1
II.R I'yccaKOscroIii C'II1TaJI, '1'1'0 Bce 06R3aHHOCTl-f aRlU-'IooepoB no
OTHOIlIeHJIIKJ R aKQl10HepHOM)' 06Il\€CTBY 3aKJIlO'ffiKITCR.JIJ1llIh B OIIJIaTE'
npl1 nO.LJ;III1CKe Ha aKWtI1 J1X Hapl1L\a:renUfOH CTOI1MOCTI1. 272
P. CaBaThe nOJIaraJI, '1'1'0 rm-CTH= aKQl10HepHoro 06llteCTBa npl1-
HJIIMalOT Ha ce6R 06R3aHHOCTb pa60T3.Th COBMeCTIfO.273 C 3=, KOHe'l-
HO, HeJlh3R COrnaCI1ThCR.
YCT3.BbI HElIDTOphIX aKQl10HepHhIX 06Il\€CTB Moryr Y£-"ffiH8BJIHB8Tb
HeKOTopble ,l\OI1O.JIHIfl"JIhHhle BeChMa meI1H$Jqe<:KMe 06R3aHHOCTI1
1J.IDI aKQl10HeJX>B. Ha 3TOT KTOOpallt8-J1 BlUlMaHHE' eIl\e J1.T. TapacoB,
ROTOphill nl1caJI, '1'1'0, «HaIIJMM€P, YCTaBaWl HeKUIUphIX CBeKJIOcaxap-
HhIX aKQl10HepHbIX KOMJIaHI4i1 Ha aKQmJHepOB 3T11X JOCJMIJaHJUt: HOMO-
meHa 06R3aHHOCTb saceBaTh Jf ,lI;ocraBJ1J1Th Ha 6p11RY Jf3BeCTIIOe
'lJIICJIO CBeKJIbi npoIDpIUlOHaJIbHO 'lI1cny BJJa,l:\eeMhIX aKqI1 .)Jjm:noro
onpe.lI€JUIeTCR npOCTpaHCTBO saceBa, cnOCOObi oopa5oT-
KI1, CpoR,IWCTIlBKK, qeHa If T.n., sa H€11CJDJIH{'HJ1e me YCJIomdi BhITOBa-
pI4BaeTCR O HHaR HeycroiiKa».274
)t>MaeTCR, 'lTO YCTaHOBJIeIDte pa3J1WlHhIX 06R-
}J.JUI aKQl10HeJX>B RBJ1jJeTCH npaBOMepHhIM B CBH311 C npH-
MhIM }'Ka3aHlieM 'I. 2 CT. 67 rR Pcb
CJ1e.nyeT OTMeTHTh, 'lTO 06R3aHHOCTI1 aKQI40HepOB onpe,ll;eJ1marCR
He TOJ1hKO I'pa:>KABHCIOIM Ro,ll;eKCOM Pcb 113aKOHOM «06 aKqI10HepHhIX
06utecma"(», HOJ! co.n;ep:>Ka.TCR B ,lQ)yrl1X HOpMaTWBHhIX aRTax; TaK, Ha-
npl1Mep, CT_ B 3aKOHa «0 phIHKe qeHHhIX oYM8r» YCTaHaBID'IBaeT, '1'1'0
BJ18)J;eJ1hL\hlI1 HOMI1HBJIhHble ,lI;ep:>Ka.TeJII1 qeHHhIX 6YM8r 06R3aHbI co-
OJIKJ,!\aTb npaBI4J1a J!Hi¥>pMaL\J1Jf B ClIC'I"eM)' Be.n;elUiR
peecrpa. JII1LIY, MYHeH8,JJ,JI I1CIIOJIHeHI4e nopH,D;Ka
nOAD;ep:>KalUiR CI4CTeMbI Be.n;€ID1.II J1 COCTaBJieIDm pe€CTpa 11 HapyweHJ1e
i¥>PM 0T'if'TH0CTH (3MJ1TeHTY, perncTpaTOpy, .n;eII03HTapl1IO, Bna.n;eJ1h-
qy), MmKeT 6hITb npt=',lI:hRBJle I1CK 0 B03MellteHIDI ywep6a. (BKmo'laH
-134-
yrryr.u;eHHYID BbIro.I\Y), BG3HI'1KIlleI'O 113 HeB03MmKHOCTH ocy:Il\eCTBI1Tb
npaBa, 3aRpen.rreHHhIe l\eHHblMJ16yMara.MlL
HeKOTOpble 8BTOpbI SbI,!\E'.JlfIKYI' 11 OT.r\eJIbHbIe ]:IOIX)JIHi'1Te npa-
sa 8Kl\110HepoB. TaR, RB. tPoMw-teBa Bbl,!\eJLlleT B cJI)"-Iae .nI1KB L(J1H
061l\eCTBa TaKl1e npaBa 8RqI10HepoB, KaK npaBo y«aCTBOBaTb B Ka'IeCT-
Be 06LqeCTBa, Ha3Ha'IeHHoro06Lq11Mc06paID1eM 8Kl\HO-
HepoB, B paccMYIpeHHl-f ,lJ;eJ1a 0 6aHKpoTCTBe; COBMecmo
C Kpe npOBE'pKH C)'MM 'Ipf26osamrn, npOBE'pRTb J1OKYM€HThI,
e BKa'IeCTBeo6ocHoBaHI1R 06ll\e-
crsa, }"IacTBOBaTb B C06paHI1H Kpe.lUI'OOpOB 6e3 npaBa npHHRTlliI pewe-
HI1JI. 275 II 'ITO:':I'm npasa BbrreKaIOT 113 paccMarpeHHbIX
npasa aRqI10HepOB }"IaCTBOB3.Tb B ynpasJ1eHJ1J.1 06ll\eCTBoM 11 npasa Ha
J1H<PoPMal\J1lO.
IIepeqeHb npaB 8Kl1110HepOB, )'CT8HOBJ1€HHb1ti 3aKOHOJ\aTeJIbCTBOM,
He HOCI1T J1C'1epIibiBaIDll\ero xapaKTepa; yqaCTHI1KH OOI.J.<eCTBa MoryT
l1MeTb J1 1I:Pyrl1e npasa, npep;yCMOTpeHHble yqperorreJlbHblMR J\OKY-
MeHTaMl1 o6ll\ecTBa.
IIo 3TOMY Bonpocy J1.T. Tapacus, Hanpl1Mep, IDICa.n: «RpuMe }J;i1BI1-
,lJ;eH,!\a, 8Kl\110Hep MmKeT nOJIb30BaTbCR ell-\e 11 J\p)'ThlMl1 BbIrO)\aMl1,
BXOJIHIl\I1M11 B COCTaB ero aKICloHepHoro npasa 11 sallJlCHMbIM>l OT xa-
paKTepa npeJlllPJIJI"IUfI; TaK, Hanpl1Mep, YCTaBaMl1 HeKOTOpbIX KOMIIa-
HI1i1 WUI YCTpoi1CTBa 3OOJIOJUqecKI1X J1JIJ1 60TaHJl'IecKl1X ca)\OB sa 8K-
l\110HepaMI1 npl13HaeTCH npaao 6eCllJIaTHOrO nOCell\eHI1.fI 3TI1X
yqpem,lleHl1i1, TaKme - SKOMIIaHI1JI AJlH)'CI1X1i1CTBa pa3HbIX YBeceJ1l1-
TeJIbHbIX 3aBe,n;eHMi1, paSHO KaK l1Hor)\a 3a 8Kl\110HepaMl1 J\opooKHbIX
KOMIIaHl1M npH3HaeTCR npaSO 6eCllJlaTHoro npoe3,n;a ...»276
bHO, C yqeTOM OCOOeHHOcreH Kam,!\oro
I«JHIqX:'THOlO aKlU1OHepIOI'O 06lL\12CTB3. Mem,rIy HI1M 11 ero 8K,WDHepaMH
MoryT 4>opMI1pOsaTbCH OT,n;eJIbHble OTHJIlIE'HI'UI, I1Me-
IOIqI1eCBoeco,n;epmaIIJ«'.
rnaBa 3. 3alllHTa npaB aKljHOHepHblX o6111ecTB
H HX YLiaCTHHKOB
f 1. Cnoc06b13atqItTbl npaB aK ItOHepHbIX 06IQeCTB M MX )'4aCTHItKOB
B .mnepaType npaIJO Ha 3arqwTY Tpa omiO paCCMaTpl1BaeTCH
KaK :3JIeMeHT BCJlKOrD cy&beKTI1BHoro npaBa. B.II. I'pIlDaHOB IDfCaJI, 'ITO
«IIpaBD Ha 3alWlT)' B era MaTepl>1aJIbHO-npaBOBOM 3HaQeHIH1, TO eCTb
roue 0J\HOro 113 npaBOMO'liDl caMOro cy&I.eIcrmrnoro rpamJlPHCEOIQ npa-
Ba, npe a:J6ofiBO:3Ml:»t<HOCTnpHMeHEHJ1RBarHOllIeHID1npa-
BOHapynrnTeJ1J1 Mep npI1HY,lJ;wreJ1bHoro ficTBHf1». O,l:\HaKO n03 ee
OR OTMeTIfJI, <!:TO «B YCJIOIDHIX npaBOBOro roCY.1lPpcma npaBO Ha 3aLql1-
TY MO:IKHO paCCMa7pi1BaTb J1 KaK caMocTowreJIbHOe CyD'beKTI1BHoe npa-
BO, CIJe1tI IMCOJ\epmaHl1eM».277
CJIe1J;YeT DTMeTl1Tb, 'ITO B CIDI)' cn 1EK aKQI10HepHbIX 05LqeCTB
cy6'beKTbl OTHOWeH . CKJla,!U>IBalOllV'IXCR B B3a lM
mm 05LqeCTB If IfX y-'laCTHMKOB, HYm,IlalOTCfl B ycImJOBJ1eHKII JlonOJ1HI1-
T€JIbHbIX Cpe,!\CTB, I103EIOJlRtOlWI rapaHTl'1}XJBaTb 3alWlT)' MX npaB. Ha
STy oc06eHHocTb oopmuanl-l BHJ1Mcmi1e €ILIe TaKl1e If3B€CTllbIe }"IeHble,
KaK J1.T. TapaCOB, II. Ib1ceMcroBi, MM. KYJ1anrn.
«tI>opMa aKQJiOHf'pHOro 05IL1eCTBa, - OTMe<laJl B 1894 r. PYcclU1w
npaBoBe;n; Ii IIOJIE'TaeB, - ,D;aJ1a B03MOmHOCTb coeJ\I1HJ1Tb orpoMHble Ka,-
IIJ1TaJibl, He e WIH OrpoMHbIX npe,!\lIpJ1JITI1i1. 3To BaJKHaH JH1-
LleSaJI, IIOJl())KjITe.1JbHafI cropOHa aKWIoHepHblx 06ll.\ecTB. R coma.ne-
HJ1J{), 3TW IIOCJIe,mDte MMeIDT Ta1I::1Ke CBOW OTpMl\aTeJIbHble CTOpoHbI,
Ba:1KHbl€ Hey,n;06cTBa. YCJIOBWI., IIpW KcrropblX aKQWoHepHble o61l.\eCTBa
06pa3yKJTCH W .n;ei1crsyKJT, TaKOBbi. 'l'I'O 3JJ;eCb HBJ1HeTCH 60J1bwaa, 'leM
-136-
r,l\e-JIH60, BO:3MIDKHOCTb pa:3Hoo6pa3HbIX o6M3HHbIX KoM6I1HaL\I1i1:,
npaKTIIK}'eMbIX OCHOBaTeJUIMI1I1 aAMl1Hl1CTpaTOpaMI1 06r.qeCTB EO Bpe,l\
aKqI10HepoB J1 Kpe,llWI'OpOB. 3aKoHO)\aTeIDI Bcex C"IpaH ycwnmaIO'fCH
npe,lIyI1p€.lI;Trb J1J1I1 CTeC11Jrrb 3TI1 06MaHbI; HO ,l\enbLlbI, 6oJ1ee nOBKl1e,
'leM 3aKOHO)J;aTeJ1l1, YMemr 11.0 CI1X nop ycKOJ1l>3aTb OT TJ,{'iicTmm 3aKO-
HO)\aTeJIbHbIX Mep, nO-BI1.qJ1MOM)', HaWlyqIlIl1M 06pa:30M npl1,llyMaH-
HbIX. J13)J;aIOTCJl3aK0Hb1,I1pOTI1B011.eitcTBy1<n1u-fec CJI J13Be-
crnblMl1 o6MaHaM, a 11.eJIbLlbl J1306peTaIOT yme HOBbIe npl1eMbI, He
npeAyCMOTpeHHble eILIe 33.KOHOM». 278
RaM: nOKa3bIBaeT npaRTJlI<a, MOmBO BbI,!\enl1Tb HeCROJ1bI\O OCHOBHb1X
rpynn pl1CKOB 11 CBR3aHHbIX C lD1MI1 HapyrnE'Hl'lii npaB aKLtl10HepOB B
cJI)"-Iae noJYi1Penwroro JIHBeC'I'HpOBaHJ1.FI B aKqi111 poccIDicKI1X KOMIla-
lD1A (l\JIaCCJupuKaLtJ1R npHBO.r:tl1TCfI Ha OCHOBe MaTepJlaJ10B Brunswick
Warburg: Measuring Corporate Governance Risk m Russia J1JKypHa-
na "PbIHOK LleHHblX 6yMar»):
- pl1C:K'Jf HenOJIHOIUJ1JII1 paoqJblTJUI 11H4JopMal!J1l1;
- pl1CK,I:(OIII)JIIDfI'€JIbHHX "pa3MblBaIOJ.l » 3MJ«:CID"i;
- pl1CK "yBo,!\a» aKTI1BOB J1 T})aHc<pepTHoro LleHoo6pa30BaHJm (MHU-
ro npMMepoB ,l\aeT He4rrHHoti 6113Hec);
-pI1C:K'Jf, lenpYlpeo J13-3a
OTCyfCTBI1.H pa:3Bl1TOro npaBOBOro perynl1pOBaHl1.H B XO,l\e CJ1I1flH11i:i J1
norJIOIQeRJdi: 'laCTO HapyrnaIOTcR npaaa aKlIl10HepOB:
- pl1C:K'Jf 6aHKpOTCTBa;
- pl1C:K'Jf 3JIOynurpe6.JreIrni npYl pefl1 m npaB tU5c'me1lHOCTJ'1
HaaKL\l1l1;
- pl1C:K'Jf eMJ1eHI1.H npaB OT11.eJIbHhIX KaTeropIDi aKqI10HepoB npJ1
yqacTIDIBynpaBJ1eID1I1 ;
- pl1CK HenpocpecaIDHaJ1bHoro ynpaBJ1eHJ1F! 279
B CBR311 C 3T11M 3aKOHOM «06 aKL\llOHepndX » npeAYCMO-
T})eHhI pa:3J1l1'llibIe cpe,n;CTBa, l103I3OJIJIIOIqle o6ecne'll1Tb nOBblllleHHYID
33.l1tI1TY npaa a Hep<II J1 caMOro 06r.qeCTBa. R HI1M OTHOC'JITCfl KaK
Cpe11.CTBa C)'Ae6Hm1 3aLql1TbI, TaK J1 BHeCYJ\e6Hb1e cnoc06bI 33.mm'bl
npaBa. RpoMeTOro, HOpMbl3aKOHa «06aKqi1oHepHblx npe-
;nycMaTpl1BalOT pa:3J1I1'-JHb1e MeXaHJI3MbI, HanpaBJIeHHhle Ha He,!\on)'ILIe-
lD1e IIpaBOHapyrneHl1i-f J1 ml16oJ:iee nOJ1H.YIO pea.ill13a1.tJ11Q npaB yqaCTHI1-
KOB OTHOWeHIDi; OC06eHHO 31'0 KaCae-rCH aKL[IlOHepOB - ,l\ep T€J1eH
Me.ma-o: naKeTOB aK1U1A, TaK Ha3biBaeMbIX MI1HOpl1TapHhIX aKL[IlOHepOB.
CneLtJ14>J1Ka J1X n0J10JoKeHI1.H COC1'OI1T B TOM, 'ITO DHI1 HBJl.HK7rCR YJ'l3BI1-
MbIMI1 nepe.n; OT I aKqi10HepaMl1- .n;ep»<.aT€JlRMJ1 KpynHblX na-
KeTOB aKLII'OC RpOMe TOm, B cIDI)' Ofura.1:\aHl1H He3Ha'lJITeJIbHbIM KOJII1'{e-
CTBOM aKI<I1i1 OID1 J1MeK7r ropa3,l\O MeHbwe B03MJJKHOCTeH,l:\JlH 3aIlliITbi
CBOI1X npaa, nOCKOJlbKY B 3aKoHe «06 aKLtJ10HepHbIX 06ll.\€CTBa.V' B03-
-137-
MO:1KHOCTb ocyIQECTBJIeHWI MHOrl1X npaBOM()qJ1M CIDI3 Uffi C 06JJa)\atrneM
t.nfIrnMaJIbHbIMJOC}J1Jl'I€CTBOMal\.Lt1-fi1.
3aLqJ1Ta J1HTepeCOB MJ1HoptfTapHbIX aKqYlOHepaB .r\OJDKlffi COCTOJITh
B o6ecne'leIDII-f ro paBeHCTB<l aKlUIOHepoB, no.r\ KOTOpbIM
CJ1e,rr;yeT nomfMaTb paBeHCTBO npaB, "CJ1 Ha paBHOe KOJ1I-f-
'leCTBO aKQIDi O)\HOM K1ITeropID1 J1 TJ-lilll lIpM co6J1IO)\em-rn nponopQWO-
HaJ1bHOCTJ1 BblI'O)I, nOJ1yqaeMbD<: OT 06ll1ecTBa, HOMMHaJIbHOi1 CTOJ.-IMOC-
TI-I nplrna.rlJ1emall X aKQI'X)Hepy al\.Lt1-fi1.
TaR, HanpMMep, MO:1KHO Bbl,!l;eJ1MTh cne,DyKJw;I1e OCHOBHble n0J10:)Ke-
IDI.II 3aKOIffi «06 aKIV«JHePHbIX 061l1ecTBax», HanpaBJ1eHHble Ha 6oJ1ee
o emteJ13aUtl'1TynpaBaIatHOHepoa::
- n.l cT.583aKOHaCO)J;ep:>KIIT HIt€O Ha.nYl-
'lYlJ'l KBOPYMa (6oJ1ee 'leM n0J10BI1Ha TOJIOCOB pa3MellteHHbIX I'OJIocyro-
lltYIX 3KqY1M 06ll1ecTBa) .rIJ1H npaBOMO'IHOC'I'J'1 06lltero c06paHl1H 3KQWo-
HepOB; B OT.r\eJlbHbD<: CJ1yqa.fIX.rIJ1J'1 IIpI1H.!ITYlH peweHYIJ'l no HeKOTopbIM
BOlIpOcaM He06XOJ11:IMO npYlcyrcTBYle Jf TOJIOCOBaHYIe 6oJ1billero 'D1cna
aIatHOHepoB (HanpYIMep, ,IVIJI IIpI1H.!ITYlH peweHYIJ'I 0 peopraHYl3aL{JIIYl 06-
llteCTBa nyreM npeo0pa30BaHJ1R B HeKoMMepqecKoe napTHepcTBO Tpe-
6yeTCH eAYlHOr.JJaCHoe pernelDle Bcex aKJtll!OHepOB - a63. 2 n. 1 CT. 20);
D..lYIJXB3.HHoe 60J1bIIlHHCTBO (-rpYi 'leTBepTI-l) I'OJ1OCOB aKQMOHe-
pOB - IJ..JIa)\eJIbQe roJ10cyIOlltI1X aKW1i1, npillU1:M.8.lOlltI1X yqaCTYIe B 06-
llteM co6paHJDI aKQYlOHepoB, He06xo,ll;i'1MO ,IVIJI npYlHHTI1.fI pewetnm 0
npe06pa:3CB33IDm B OCTaJlbHblX CJ1yqa.fIX - n. 4 CT. 49 3aKOHa
- CT. 75 3aKOHa YCTaHaBJ1l1Baer npaBO aKqHOHepa npe)J;'bJIBm'b 06-
lltecTsy TpeOOsaID1e 0 BblKyrre 3KqY1M B cJI)"IasJx peopralD13alUDI 06llte-
CTBa IfJIYI COBeplIIeHWl KpyI1HOii c.n;eJ1lG1, peweHl>-!e 06 o.r\06peHID1 KOTO-
pai1 npl>-!HI1MaerCH 06rQMM c06paHl1eM aKQI>-!OHepaB B c:DOTBe'ICTBIDI co
CT. 79 aTOro me 3aKoHa, ecnl>-! OHI>-! roJlOCOBaJll>-! npcrrJ1B I1pJ1HHTMH pewe-
1111.11 0 ero peopraH113aQI-rn J1J11>-! 0A00pemD1 YK<l3aHHoi1 c.r\eJIKM.mroo He
IIpI1lIYIMa.JiJ'1 Y'ffiCTI-IH B roJJOCOBaHi'Dl nO:3TMM BonpocaM; BHeCeID1H 113-
MeHell11i1 I>-! ;:J;OI1OJ1H€fUd;J: B YCTaB 06llteCTBa J1J11>-! yrsep:>K,IJ;eHYIJ'I ycrasa
06llteCTBa B HOBOi1 pe.n;aKQWI>-!, orpaIDf'IHBalOlltI1X I1X IIpaBa, ecJrn OHI>-!
I'OJIOCUBaJiJI npOTI1B IIpI1H.!ITI>-!H ro peweHJ1H J1J1Y1 He
I1pJDUIMaJIH yqacTi-iR B roJriCOBalDIJ1;
- n. 8 CT_ 55 3aKOHa npepyCMaTpMImeT J303M())KH0CTb C03b1Ba 06llte-
roc06paHl1H JDIQ8.MH. Tpe6ylOw;I1MI>-! eronpoBe,!\eID1J'1 B CJJy'Iae 0TKa3a B
C03bIBe COBeTa ,!\l1peKTOpoB I>-! B03MellteID1R paCXO.r\OB,
nO)\lOTOBKOH I>-! n HI1eM BHeO'-Iepe;:J;Horo o6lltero co-
6pa1D1H aKQMOHepOB, JlMQaM, Tpe6yrow;l1M ero C03b1sa;
- Ha 3aw;l1TY npaB aKqHOHepOB uaITpaBJleHbI I1()J1())Kel1Jf 3aKOHa
«06 3Kl!MOHepHbIX 06ll1ecTBaxD 0 COBeTe ,II;I1peKTopoB; TaK, B COOTBeT-
CTBHI>-! co CT. 66 3aKoHa qneHbl COBeTa .r\I1peRTOpOB nepen36l1paKlTCH
-138-
e:IKerO;:J;HO Ha rO;:J;OBOM 06Il\eM co6paHJH1, 'ITO n03BOJIReT aKqImHepaM He
nepen::li1q)aTb IOCJI'O-mroo. KTO He cnpaBWlCfl co CBOIIWf 06H3aHHOCT$l-
MI>1; IIOJlIIOMO'lJ1H 'lJIeHOB COBeTa p,I1peKTOpoB Mor)'T EibITb ]:\ocpo'lHO
npeKpaIl\eHbI no pewemuo BH€O'lepe;:J;Horo o6Il\ero coEipaHl1fl; 'lJIeHbI
coseTa 1\11peKTOpoB 1f3Eil1palOTCfl nyreM KYMYJ1J1'I'IfBIIOI' I'OJIoroBaHJ1.R,
KOTOpoe n03BOJUleT M€lIblillIHCTBY aKqI10HepOB J136paTb CBoero npe,/J;-
craBI1Te.nfl B COCTaB 'lJIeHOB COBeTa ,/J;l1peKTOpoB; 'lJIeHbI l<OJ1J1enranbHO-
ro HaIOJ1lI1'1TeJ1hHOro opraHa He Mor)'T COCTaBJ1$lTb fioJ1ee O,!I;HOt1 "IeTBep-
TI'i'lJleHOB COB€Ta J1TaK,IJ;anee;
- <t>e,!J;epaJIbHbJi:i 3aKOH(Y1' 2 ,/J;eKa6p$l 2004 r. J\M53-q:.3 "OBl1€C€fUBI
J13MeHemrn B CTaTblO 68 3aKOHa «06 aK.J.V:lOIIepHhIX 06-
Il\e<:TB3.X» BBeJI , pacIID1p.lllOIl\ee Kpyr Cyfu,eKTOB, J1M€IOIl\I>1X
npaBO 06ma.nOB3.Th He3aKOHHble peW€1lJ1fI COBeTa ,/J;l1peKTOpoB (Ha6Jno-
,WlT€JIbHOro COBeTa) 06ll1€CTBa" 'ITO Ha npaKTI1K€ 6yl\eT cnoc06CTBOB3.Tb
06ecne<leHJfiOaa npaB Tenepb 'lJIeHCOBeTa,/J;l1peKTO-
pOB(Ha6.moJ\aTeJIbHo1'O COBeTa) 06Il\e<:TBa, He )"ffiCTBOBaBIlII1if B rOJIOCO-
BaHI1I1 J1JIJ1 rOJIOCOB3.BIlII1if npOTI1B peweHIDI, npl1turroro COB€TOM I\JIP€K-
TOpoS (Ha6.moJ\aTeJIbHbIM coseTOM) 06Il\e<:TB3., B HapYW€HI1€ nopJ'I,Q;Ka,
YCTaHOBJ1eHHo1'O 3aKOHOM ,,06 1OHepHHX OOIl\e<:Tsax», J1HbIMJ1 npa-
BOBbIMJII BKTaMl>1, yCTaBoM 06Il\e<:TB3., BIIpaBe 06:/K8J10B3.Tb B CYI\ )'K3.3aH-
Hoe peweHl1€ B CJIY'la€, €CJU1 3TI1M peWeHl1€M HBpynr€HbI 1"1'0 npaIJa J1
aaKOHHble J1H'I'epeChl;
- n. 3 CT. 11 3aKOHa ,,06 BKIU10HepHbIX o6Il\ecTB3.x» yCTaH3.Bm1B3.eT
BO:3MCOKHOCTb orpaHWI€mrn YCTaBOM 06Il\€CTB3. KOJIWleCTBa aKqI1ti,
I1pI1Ha,WIeJKaIql1X aKW10Hepy, J1XcyMMapHoti HOMI1HaJIbII(J1 C1U1MJCTi'1,
MBKCHMaJ1hl1«"mCnaroJ1OCOB, O,!I;HOMYBKqI10Hepy;
- n. 4 CT. 32 3aKOH3. 00,!J;ep»G1T HOpMY' 0 pa3,!J;€JIbHOM nO,!J;C'IeT€ I'OJIO-
COB no rpyrmaM B cJIY'lae npI1H.!ITIDI pellleHIDI 06 orpaHWleHJ'IIIJ npaB
BJ1a,D;€JlbQes 1lpJ1BHJJ€TJ'iposaHHbIX aK ;
- n. 2 CT. 80 3aKoHa «06 lOIIepHbIX 06Il\€CTBax» 06fl3blBaeT JllIJ-
1\0, HBMepesalCUt€€Cf! caMOC'I'OHI'€J1l1JJI11J co CBOlfM acpcpllJJUlJpOB3.H-
HbIM JrnltOM IIpHOOpr2CTI'130 J1 EiOJIee npoQelITOB aKQIIJt:i 06ll1€CTBa npe,/J;-
nO)JUITb a npo,!J;aTb np 1H8,IJ,.1Ie)fCall JIeJ1MaKQJ'IJ'IJ'ITaK,/:\3.JIee.
3aKOH cO,!J;ep)1G1T eIl.\€ MH01'O I1fJ.11IDKeHJm, npl-l3BaHHbIX cnOc06CTBO-
BaTh HaH60nee nOJIHOMY DCylL\€C'I'EIJI J1 OOIl\eCTBOM
J1X npaB. O,lJ;H8KO II aT01'O HBHO H€,!\OCTaTO'lHO. TaK, MHome yq€HbJe (Ha-
I1pllJMep, B.B. J];OJ1I1JHCKa.R, RIO. BaKIlIJIJHCKac) BbICKa3b1BalO'I'C.l'l 0 SBe,!J;e-
HID1B3aKOHHOpMbI, Myqp€.lJ;IIJTE'neiiorpaHWMrbJ1XnpaBo
pacnopJ'!:>KeID1$l BKQllJJ'lMI1 nyreM YCTaHOBJIemrn aanpeTa sa J1X OT'lym-
,/J;eH1lJe no KpaAHei:! Mepe B Te'leIDle onp€.[\€J1€Hl1Cl BpeMeIDI C MOMeHTa.
06Il\ecTB3.. TaKoenpeMO:/K€HJ'Ie6bIJIOBHeCeHoIlH ['ycca-
I<OSCKilJM €Il\e B Ha"laJie XX B. DR C'IlITan, 'lT0 AT1J'I TOro, 'lT06bI no B03-
-139-
MO:1KHOCTYI npeAOTBpaTIITb B03HHKHi:IBeHHe 6e3Ha.1\e:1KHbIX BKQYIOHep-
HhIX ,Y'lPem,n;eHHbIXC CTIeKYJl.l1'TI1B-
HhIMYI qeJI.HMJ1, «CY1l\eCTBellllbIM npe,!\CTaBJJJIeTCH ycraHUBJIeHJre TaKYIX
llJXIBItJI, KOTOPbl€ CBH3bIBaJIJ1 6bI c YCTpOeHHhlM I1MYI
np€W1pl1$lTYleM HaCTOJIblOCl llpD'lliO, <rro6b1 nOCJJe;:ryro11\3.l1 ero CY,D;b6a aI'-
pamaJIaCb 11 Ha J1X J1MYII-\eCTBeIDIOM 6narococTOflHI1M. ,lJ;.rr.H ycTaHOBJIemm
TaKoR CM3Y1 Hf206xo.D.I-mro O,!\HaKO, He TOJ1bKO06H3aTb oc-
TaBl-fTb 3a c06cuo onpe,!\e.nemryro 'ffiCTb npeAJIQm€HHbIX K BbmyCKY aK-
1..IYIi1, HOI1 = J1X BMeCTeC TeM npaB3. crrqym,D;aTb 3TI1 aKWrn B Te"le-
HJ.1e onpe,r:J;€J1€HHoro cpoKa. T€M H€ M€Hee, 'mCJ1O aKr..tIDi, KOTOPbl€
J"Ipe,!\J1TeJ1Yl 06fl3aHbl OCTaBJ.-ITb 3a c06OlO, He 110J1:1KHO 6hITb CJ1illllKOM
3Ha'JJ11'€'JIbHhIM. <no> C JJPYrOw CTOpOHbI, CPOK, B Te"l€HI1e KOTOpOro y<I-
pe,!I,J.1TeJ1YlHeBnpaBeUI"JYm,D;aTbCBOI-I €aRL\J1J1, Hel1OJ1-
:1K€H 6hITb c.mmnroM KpaTIU1M».280
3alLP"IT€ npaB npYl06peTaTe.neH aKQYIw npYl3BaHa CIIOC<.6C'rsosaTb 11
HopMa n. 2 CT. 5 4Ie.l\epaJlbHoro 3aKOHa OT 5 MapTB 1999 r. N!'46-4I3
«0 3all{MTe npaB 11 3aKOHHbIX I1HTepecoB I1HBecTOpoB Ha pblHKe L\eHHhIX
6yMar» (,QaJ1ee - 3aKoH «0 3all{MTe npas 11 3aKOHHbIX nH'I€pecos I1HBe-
CTopOB Ha pbIHKe qeHHbIX 6yMar»), KOTOpaH yc-raHaBJIMBaeT 3aIIpeT Ha
COBepWeHYIe BJJ3,/J;€JIbL\eM l.leHHblX 6yMar .mo6bIX C.l\eJ10K C IIpYlHa.QJIe-
m.1ilL\MMH eM;! qeHHblMM 6YMaraMM AO I1X TIOJIROH OlIJlaTbl11 pernC'rpa-
n1 OT"leTa 06 I>:!Torax I1X BblIlYCKa 3To mpaID1"Ieffile, RaK )'Ka3aHo B
IfucbMe 4>KIU3 OT 26 anpeJUI 1999 r. N2 ME-2171 ,,0 pa3'bRCHeHYIYI
nyHKTa 2 craTbYl5 4Ie.l\epaJlbHoro 3aKOHa OT 05.03.99 N24643 «03a-
lL\I'IT€ npaB 11 3aKOHHbIX I1HTepecoB MHB€C'TOp(E Ha pbIHKe qeHHbIX 6y-
Mar», HanpaBJ1eHO Ha 3al1tYlTy I1HBeCTopoB OT pYlCKa npmmamm Bbmy-
CRa qeHHbIX 6)'M3r HeCQCTOHBIIDIMCH B cJI)"-Iae OTKa3a B pernC'TpaI.{lD1
O'I"-JeTa 06 YlTOrax BbII1)'CKa qeHHhIX 6YMar. H J1e )'Ka3aHHOro
Tpe6c)Bamm MomeT nOBJ1e"lb npu'lIrneHll€ y6b1TKOB I'1IIII€CTOpaM, KOTO-
pbIMYI qeHHble 6)'M3rt1 6bLJIYI np:l-!o6peTeHbI Ha BTOpINlDM pblRKe. Ta-
KJ1M I1HBeCTOpaM MDmeT 6b1Tb He J13BeC'mO, 'ITO qeHHble 6)'MarYi npYl I1X
pa:3M€I1I€ID'1i He 6b1J1Y1 nQJIHOCTblO OTIJ1a'IeHbI, a TaIOKe, '1TO npoqecc
3MYlCCJ1J1 TaKV!X l.leHHblX 6)'Mar eILIe H€ 3aBepweH, J1 BblIlyCK L\eHHhIX
6YMar B (.()()'I'B€T(.'I C 3aKOHO,!\aTeJ1bCTBOM PocCYIticlwR 4Ie,!\epaLll'IYI
MOmeT 6b1Tb IIpYl3HaH 'IOflBllIHMCJl.
II. II:HceMcKHM 3'rOT BOnpoc 0 BCJ3M())KH0CTi'I nepe.l\a<m He nOJIHOCTbIO
ollJla<teHl1Oii aKLIJ.-n:! peUJaJ1cJI CJ1e;:ryroJ.LJ;l-1M oopaaoM. IIo ero MHeHJ1lO,
K3Jfi,!:\brn HOBbIi1 IIpw>6peTaTeJlb aKL\YIYl CTaHOB:HJIC.II OTBeTCTBeHeH 3a
yTlJIaTY BKJia;J;a, HO 3T1-1M eILIe He peWaJJCR BOnpoc 0 TOM, npo.l\OJ1:>KaeT
.Jill, HeCMOTpH Ha nepeM'l)' BKQI-I:H, 6b1Tb aI'SeTCTSeHeH 3a :ny yrLIIBTY
npeJKHlul BKLlMOHep. Bonpoc 3TOT CqJ.-ITaJiCH 11M O)J;tf:HM 113 caMblX cnop-
HblX BO seeM y<IeHYIJ1. «IIaM KameTCR. '1TO C TO"IKI13peHYlR,AOroSOpa, 3a-
-140-
KJIlO'laeMoroMem,rIy KOMrunrneM J1 no,lJ;rmC'lJ1K()M, JJ;OJDKHOnpl13Ha'Tb 60-
J1eenpaBl1J1bHblM MHem-re, 1IDJJ:l1I1C'll!IKa, nepeMBlIIero
CBOlO aKQIDI), OT 06H3alllioCTJ1 yrLII1lTbI. IIpcrrl1B aTOm MHemfJI rOBOp:fIT,
'ITO.J\OJDKHJ1K He MDmeT TbCE OTCBOI-IX 06f.!3am0C1'ett, nepe-
AaB I1X APYJ'OMY, eCJ1J1 Kpe)J;J1TOp He AM Ha 31'0 CBoero corJ1acWI. <.n>
Bc.neJ:\cTmIe eMOCTI1 aKQJ1l1 AOJDKHO npJ13HaTb, 'IT{) KOMIIBlIJIIH
3apallee,D,aJ1a CormCJ1e Ha nepeMeHY CBOI1X ,D;0JDK1n1KOB» 281
M.T. TBpaCOB.me, HanpCYI'l1B, C'fwraJ1, 'lT0 TOJ1bKQnOJllIaROrtnaTB aR-
LIIDi MO::tC€T OCBOOO)J;H:Tb nO)J;llJ1C'1J1K3. OT B3RTOro J1M Ha ceOH OOH3BTeJIb-
CTaB BHeCTI1.J\OJ1lO aKI.U'IOHepHoro KanwraJ1a, COCYI'aeTCTByro 'fJ1CJ1Y
nOJly'leHHbIX J1M al\.Ql-1M, BCJ1e,l\C'I131le <iero npO,Qa::teeM 1\PyroMY J1It1l\Y
BpeMeHHbIX CBIV\€'reJIbCTB, nOJIyqeHHbIx J1M HB Bl\.QI-1l1, OH He ocso6o::tC-
ABeT ceOH OT 3TOro 06H3BTeJ1bCTBa. IIpl1 STOM OH OTMe'1BJ1, <iTO «BBI1)Iy
TBKOro pa3peWeHl1H BOnpoCB ,l:\em€TCH ECHbrM, JJ;O KaKOM CT€n€ID1 H€O-
CHOBaTeJIbHO J1 BMeCTe C TeM onaCHO JJ;03BOJUITb Bb a'lY BpeMeHHbIX
rnlV\eTeJIbCTBHB He BTIOJIH€OnJIa'1eHHbreaKQJ1l1, IIpM06 3HB-
'1em-r€ U;eHHbIX 6YMBr,IJ;I1PKYJ1Hpy}(Jru;>1X HB OI1p::tCe, TO[',[13. KaK npillfaA-
ne::tCHOCTb aKL\J1i.i J1 ,l\OJIeBaR O£1JIaTB I1X MOryr 6bfTb y;D;OCTOS€p€Hbl aK-
LD10HepHOM KHillOM J1 perY!CTpaqI1eH».=
Ha 3arwrry npaB Bl\.QI-10HepOB - BJI3,IJ;€JIbU;eB BKu;IDj:, BbITl)'lIJ;€HHbIX B
AOK)'MeHTapHoi1 4JoPMe, HBnpaBJIeHbr TBIOKe 1H nOCJ1e,l:\Hero
aooaqa CT. IB 3BKOHa «0 pbIHKe u;eHHbIX 6yMBr», KOTopbfe YCTaHaBJlJi[-
BaIOT, 'lTOBCJI)"-Iae Me:1fQJ;yTeKCTOMpeW€HWlOBbllI)'CK€
u;eHHbIX 6)'MBr 11 ,l:\BHHhIMI1, npl1BeAeHHbrMl1 B CepTl14JJ1K3.Te 3MI'X'CJWH-
Hoi1u;eHHoi16)'MBnr, B.JJa,l(eJ1eLlJ1MeeTnpaBoTpe60BBTb
npaB, 3BXpeI1JI€HHbIX 3TOi-f qeHHOfi 6;yMBroi-f, B 06"beMe, YCTal1lJBJ1eHHOM
CepTltQ:HKaTOM, a 3MWTeHT HeceT OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a HeCOBIJHA€HHe
ABHllbIX, co,!:tep::tearu;>1XCE B cepTl1c}:1l1KaT€ 3MHCC1-1OHHOi-f Lt€HHOii 6)'M3.I1f,
C ABHHbIMI1, B pellleH1111 0 BbllI)'CK€ 1teHHbIX 6YMar, B
COOTBeTC"IBIDI C 3aKOHO,QaTeJIbCTBOM Pcb
BMeCTe C TeM, B 3aKOHO,QaTeJIbCTBO 6b1J10 6br J.I('J1€OOd5pa:3lID BBeCTl1
efl\e HOpMbI, KOTopbre CIDIX6cTBoBa.mf OC.Y1-1tE'CTBJIe-
HmO npaB aKQ>IUHt:'pOB J1 o6u.(eCTBa. TaK, HBllpl1M€p, KaK)'::tee yK3.3bIBa-
noCb, Heo6xQzJ;IIM) 3BKperIJ1Tb npaBO al\.Ql-1OHe}XIB '1p€6oBaTb 1H
aYJJ:Y!TOpCKOi-f n}XIBepKY!, ycmH013J1E'HHOE rpa>K,!\BHCKYIM
Ko,l:\eKCOM Pcb, B 3aKOHe «06 aKQJWHepIbIX 06fl\ecTBBx», a TalOKe l1pe,JJ;y-
CMO'Ip€Tb J1 OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3B ero HapyrneH1iH.
Ha npI':lKTIIK€TBlOKe cifl)'Bl!I'DI, KorAB C'ieTHbre KIJMi'1CCIUt:
o6fl\ecTB )'MbIlWIeHHo JUroo HeyMbIlllJIeHHO J1CKa::teaKTr pe3yJ1bTBTbl ro-
J10COBBmrn HB 06fl\eM c06paH1D1 aKQJ10HepOB. B CBH311 C 31'11IVI1t€J1ec:Dd)-
pa3HO ,l:\onOJIHm'b CT. 56 3BKOHa «06 BKIJ;I10HepHbrx o6fl\€cTBax» nOJlo-
:1KEHIDIMIl, YCTaHaBJIMBalOLqI1MJ1 OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb "lJIeHOB C'3:eTHOf1 100-
MJICCHI!I 3a npaBW1bH()CTb nO;:W'3:eTa pe3YJ1hTaTOB I'()J1()('()BaI
3To J1J1llIh HeKOTOIJIole nOJI<»KeID1H, KOrophlMJil CJIe,!\OBaJIO 6h1,!\onOJI-
HJ.-ITh 3aKOH «06 aKLIJ.-lOHepHhlX 06ll1ecTBax» B LleJ10M:me IIE:'06:xo;:uIM
rrrMeTl1Th, 'ITO aKl\l10HepHOe 3aKOHo,!\aTeJ1hCTBO l1,I\eT no nyrtf nOCTe-
neHHorOCOBep J.-I :3Ton03BOJUIeTH8.,!\eHTbCH, 'lronpaBO-
BO MeXam-I3M ocyIQf2CTBJ1eI!l-1H npaB al\lU10He}XIB nOJ1y<nfT CBOe ,JIaJ1h-
HeJ1rnee pa:3l!lfi'de.
KpOMe TOfO, B Hac-rDHI..qee BpeMH B POCCID-I A€MCTByIOT pa3J1W1Hhle
06utec'meHHi>-roCY,llapcme1Jl1hle q:.oH,JIhI no 3autJ.-lTe npaB BKJla,!\'lJ1KOB
11 aKl\l10Hepcm. Mx OCHOBH<UI 4JYfiKI-V'IH - l\CMII TO eCTh
BOCCTaHUBJIame HapyweHHhIX J1M)'IQ€CTB€HHhIX npaB BKJla,!\'3:J1KOB
(aKLIJlOHepcm) nOCpe,JICTBOM BhlllJIaT 3a C'leT I1pJ1BJ1e<JeHHbIX 11 c06cT-
BeHHhlX cpe,':\CTB.
Ha ypOBHe Pocc rlicmj,i 4Ie,JIepaLlJ1V! C03,!\aH 11 cpyHKlJ;>10H"pyeT t1Je-
,JIepaJlbHhrn OOIQECTB€HHO-rocy,JIapcTBellHblK 4>otm no 3aIWIT€ npaB
BKJla;:J;'rnKOB 11 aKIU10HepOB, KOTOphl 6h!JI oopa30BaH B COOTBeTCTBlI!1I! C
YKa30M IIpe3J1,!\eHTa P OT IB.l1.95 .N'91157 «0 H€I«nOp:iX Mepax no
3aLql1Te npaB BKJlap;<III!KOB 11 al\lU10HepOB».
OcHDBHhlM1I! L\eJIHMJiI ,JIeHT€.JIhHOC'm 4Jo HBJIfflOTCH:
- oCYllleCTBJIeHlI!e l\'OMlIeHCaL\I1OHHbIX BhlllJIaT J111!u;aM, KOTOphIM
6hLJI IIpIll'rnHeH y:Il\ep6 Ha 4J1I! 11 4>oH,1J;OBOM pbIHKaX Pcb, 3a
C"IeT cpe.n;cTB, HanpaBJIHeMhIX B 4JofV\, a TaKJoKe aa C'3:eT nplllpall\eHHO-
rol 4JoH.n;a;
- 4x1>MI:IpOBaHlreI1H 6a3bI.n;aHHhIXI1B€J\eHlllepeec-
'I'pa BK.JIaJrII'1KOB 11 C\I\.IJ;HOHepoB. 'lhI-f npaBa 6hLJIII! HapymeHhI Ha q>l1HaH-
COBOM 11 4>oH,!\OBOM pbIHKaX;
- samre I1H4JopMaLti'lOHHO 6a3bI .D;aHllhlX 11 Be,JIeIDIe peec-
'I'pa IOplJ,! NeCKII!X J111!-L\ 11 rpam.n;aH-npe)J.I1pIl!IDIMaT€J1e , HapyrnalOLqI1X
npaBQBhle aKThI, perYJ1I11pYIOLIJ;I1e ,QeSITeJ1hH0CTb Ha 4>II!HaHCOBOM 11
4>oH,!\OBOM phlHKaX P4>;
- xpaHeIDIe, ynpaBJ1eHllle 11 Y'ffiCTI:!e B peaJI11."3aLlll!lll!MYlllecTBa IfJ111
roecn€"l€IDle KOHIpOJIH 3a c06JIlO,!\€IDleM yc.rDBIIIl xpaHeHWI 11
peaJ1ll!3aLll-1J1 J1M)'1.L\€CTBa, IIp€JlHa3Ha'IeHHoro AJlH y,JIOBJ1€TBOpetniH J1MY-
ll\ecTBeHHhIX npaB BKJ1a;:J;"1I1KOB II! aKu;110HepoB, HapyrneHHhIX B pe3YJ1hTa-
ore npcm1BorrpaBHhIX ,n;eiicrBIDl Ha 4»IHa1JC(E()M 11 4>oH,JJ;OBOM phlHKaX Pcb,
a TalOKe ooecne'l€Hll!e pacnp B COOI'BE"I"CTB C LleJtHMJ.-I 4JoH,ll,a
Cpe,1J;CTB, nOJI)"IeHHhIX OT peaJIi13alJ;11!11! yKa3aHHOro 1I!MYllIE'CTBa, a T3.1OK€
11H0ro nepe,1J;aHHoro 4JoH,,!ly B)'C'1'CUiOBJI€H nopJ'i,D;Ke J1M)'ILIecTBa.
ITo ,lIaHHhIM Ha 2002 r KfJIIIIIE'IlCCIL\l1J1 113 cpe,':\CTB 4IOH,!¥i yme nOJIY-
'lIIIJI1I! 60nee 4BO ThICWI BRJIa,l:{'U1KOB II! aKIJ;II!OHepOB, npOJofmBa:IOIW1X B
7B cym,eKTax PoccIDiCKO 4Ie.!\epawrn, Ha cyMMY OK0J10 300 MJlH py6-
-142-
JIeM, 'ITO n03BOJlJ1JIO CHI13WTb COqMaJIbHYID HHIIpIDKeHHXTb B 06ll-\ecT-
BE'.2B3 O,I\HaKO, KaK OTMe<ffilOT ,lJ;enyraTbI fOcy,I\apCTBE'IlliOfi JtrMhl, 3TMX
yuLJIIri,i HEHO He,I\OCTaTO'IHO. 4I0HJ1 BhlCTynaeT CO Pa3-
J1I1'1Hb[x peruOHaJ1hHbIX J-I MeCTHh[X clJOH,!:\OB no 3aL\.tI'ITe npaB BKJIa;:I;'ItI-
lWBJ-I
Pa6oTalOT OHl1 Bce B pa3JIWlHb[X YCJlOBIDIX. Ho B qeJ10M J1X clJIDillHCO-
BaF! 6a3a HaXO,J:Ufi'CfI B nna'1eBHOM COCTORfnfJ1. OCTaBJIRlOT :me.naTb JIY"I-
lllero J1MaTe yc.nOBlltf1J1X paoOTbl.C.na6aTaKme
J1HJPopMaW10HHaH 6a3a - JIJ1Wb JIBe T})eTJ1 clJOHAOB ocy-
llIecTBJ1RlOT Y"I€T BKJ13,lJ;'IHI«, nOCTp BlID1X (IT ,I\eRTeJ1b1DCTH clJJ1-
HaHCOBh[X KOMTIaID1i1:, JIJ1llIb TpeTb y<illThma€T OCHOBHb1e CBeJlemrn 0
KOMrIamrnx. IIpaltIWi€CKJ1 ID1 OJ1l1H clJoHA He SeJleT CHCTeM3.TI13Mp)E3H-
Hbrn Y"I€T CBe,I\eHIdi 0 1HX pa3.TJWtHbIX opraHOB B0Tl101llelIJ1I-I lIe-
,lJ;o6poc:oBe<:THHx RDMIJaHiOC
Cna6aR aKTI1BHOCTh yKa3aHHb[x CTpyx-ryp o6yc.nOBJ1eHa TeM, 'ITO iJ,e-
HTeJlbHOCTb TaKID:: opraHl13aL\Ki1: B HallleM CTpaHe Ha'ffiJIaCh OTHOCMTeJlb-
HO He)J;2BHO J1, KpoMemro, Hep;OCTaTO'IHOM3a rocy-
iJ,apCTBa B J1X pa6OTe. 3a rpaHHLleH .me nO,I\OOHbl€ OpraHI13aqJDI
cjJyHKrI;I1OHHp)'IOT ,I\aBHO J1 IBHO: B AscrpaJlJ1H- HmutoHaJIbillLii
rapaIrl'IDlHhlii: 4>otW, ynpaBJI.FleMbIi1: rapaHlWflmM Kopx>paQH€Ii clJoH-
,I\OBbIX OHp:>KJ1 J1Ba YPOBIDl3all\l1Thl Ha CI-1)J;IJeiiCKOit:6I-1pme - 4lirnaHCO-
BbrnrapmmliiHhDi4:J0H,!\ Ina.rraTblJ1,n;osepHTeJIbHbl]:'i4:J0H,!\
6I-1p:>KI-1; B :E\a.HaJ1e - 4>oH,!\ 3aJ.W1Tbll1HBeCTOpDS; BO 4>paHIJ;ID1 - rapaH-
TIfi"im,n'i clJoH,!\; B Be.mnro6pWTamrn - 4:J0H,!\ He C03MH, HO fJ,ei4CTByeT
CxeMa I«JMIIeHCaI:{lut: I1HB€CTopaM, KOTOpaH 4:JI1HaHCI1pyeTCH 3a C'-IeT
c60POB, B311MaeMblX co BCex nOKphIBaeMbIX em; B CIllA-
KopnopaQIDl3alL\l1TbI I1HB€CTOpoB B qeHHble 6)'M8.ru. 284
JLm:r KOOp,!J;l-lHaLlJ.-D-f,D,eR'I'e11bH)C «PeJ1epaJlbHW!: opraHos JICI1OJ1ln1-
TeJ1bHOO BJlaCTI-f, peryJ1I-1pytOll-\IDC clJI-rnaHCOBbIH J1 'i phlHKI-1
PoccJnl, J1 npaBOOXpaIDrreJIbHbIX opraHoB np:w IIpe3I-1AeHTe PcP C03M-
lIa 1\au1CCJ1R no 3aILtI--lTe npas JIHBeCTOpOB Ha J-I clJOH,IJ;O-
BOM pbIHKaX. 285
B POCCI1H ,I\eHTeJlbHOCTb no 3alWITe npas 8KL\I10HepoS J1 J1PyrJ1X J1H-
BE'CTOpoB TaKme 'IaCTI1'IHO S3RJI1-f Ha ce6R caMoperyJ1tIpyeMhIe opraHJ1-
3aLIIDI, cjJyHKL\I'Io e Ha phnIKE' qeHHhIX oYMar. KpyrrneHnraflI13
caMopery.mtpyeMbIXOpraID13awmHa phlHKeL\el!Hb[Xf)yMar- HAY4>OP.
Em npllilJITa cnewtaJ1bHaR «IIporpaMM3. no e npas J-I 3aKOHHbIX
l1HTepecoB 11HBeCTOpOB- , S paMK8X KO'ropoii: 3aHBJIeHO HaMepetm€ cno-
Co6crsOBaTh II01'UIlJt:'HmO ,I\OBepMR MHBeCTOpoS. C nOMOll\hKJ HAY4>OP
6blJl C03J\aH KOOPJ1l1H8L\HOHHhIii qeHTp no 3alWITe npas J1 3aKOHHb!X J1H-
T€pecoB 1'1HB€CTOpDB. HAy4JQP Bep;eTCH pciXrra no cosepllleHcTBOsa-
HI1IO CJICTeMbl pacKphrrnR J1HJ¥JpMaL\H11 iJ,JUI TOro, 'ITD6hl J1HJ¥JpMaqrno
-143-
no aKU;110HepHbIM 05LQeCTBaM - 3M11TeHTaM BceM POCCID1 co6paTb BO-
e;vrno 11 npe.IJ1JC'I'<iB AOCTyn K Hen BceM 3aJnrreperoI33HHbIM.11MQaM.
TaIDKe npl1HI1MaIQTCR Mephl 0TH0CI'1TeJIhH) CTBI'1H l1HBeCTOpaM no
aI'C"IaJfBaHJOO HapyweHHbIX npaa B CYAaX.
OCTpbIMM npolineMaMl1 OCTalOT('J1 He,!\oc-raTO"1Ha.R KOMIJeT€HI'HOCT
cYJ\ei1BBOnpocaXKOpnopaTl1BHoro ynpaBJIemm, ypoBeHbKOP-
pynQl1l1, a TaJOKe I1OI1bI'I1aI "l1OBJ1JI.RTb'"" Ha cy.n;e6Hble peweIDtJ'!. II03TQ-
MY 'ffiCTO, .n;a:me l1Me.R Bce OCHOBaH11H AJUI 3a11tJ1Tb1 CBOI1X npaB 'lepe3
CYA, a oHepbl B pH,D;e CJJy'raeB npep,IIU'ill'I' H€ AeJ:iaTb 3TCJro, H€ Be-
PJ'I B peaJIbH)'KI B03M())!aDCTb npi1Bne'tb KOT'BeTY Kpymn.Ie KOMJJaIOOl 286
IIpaoo OHepoB Ha CYJ\e5H)'1O 38.lqWI'J flBJIJIeTCJ1 IroHKpeTI H
KOHCTJ npaBa f(3.}fi,!J;ororpam,QafD1Ha Ha cy,lJ;€6H)'1O 3all\l1'TY.
Hal15oJ:Iee pacnpoCTpaHeHHbIM 11 1lVfOIJHbIM jIBJI.Re'I'C'JI npe;n.-
jIBJI€HJ'I€ I1CM B CYA or I1M€HI1 8KqI1CHE'pa. KOTophIi1 no.1¥l€'rC.R B 3all\lITY
era npaB, - TaK Ha3bIBa€Mbrn IlpH1IK)fi I1CR. B 3aKOH€ «06 aKql10HepHbIX
06LQecrnax» npep,ycIIIDI'pE cne.n;yIOlQI1e crryqal1 wm npeJJ:bHBJIEffiUI
TaKl1XI1CKOB.
Il3 CT. ? 3aKUHa npeA)'CMB"IpJoIBaeT B03MUJtCHOCTb npe.Q"l>RBJ1eHl1.R I1C-
f(3.caMl1M Bcrryqae.ecJII1npMnpo}:\roKeaKqI1i16b1J10HapyIlle-
Ho npaBOnpMo6peTeH11H.AIa{I10HepbIBnpaBenpeA"b-
HBm'b I1CK 0 nepeBO.!\e Ha ID1X npaB 11 ofur3aHHOCTei1 nOK)'IIaTenfl B
Te'leHl1e"1p€x MeameB C MOMeHTa. KOrp,a OHl1 )'3H8JIH.m16o AOJDKHbI6bLID1
y3HaTb 0 T3.KOM HapyweHHH. TaKJ1MJll:lRe npaBaMl1 H8 npe,!\"bm!JI€HI1€ HC-
f(3. 06.na.!\aeT 11 aKql10HepHoe 06LqeCTBO, ecJII1 YCTaooM 06LQeCTBa npe.n;yc-
MmpeHo npaBOnpM06peTeH11H06ll1€CTBOMaKIU1i-i
K TaKOMY cnoc06y 3alQl1Tbi KaK npl13H3.Hl1e npaBa OTHOCI1TC.R
npe,l\"hflBJleHMe I1CKa K Aep:m.aTeJllO peeCTpa aKql10HepoB o6nleCTBa 0
€1Dnf npaBa Ha 8KLtI-'II1 nyreM B ql1 BhIrufCKi11-f3 peec"Ipa
aKltl10HepoB 06LQeCTBa.
A63aQeM 2 n. 2 CT. 45 3aKOHa «06 aKltl10HepHbIX 06LQecTaax» 3aKpen-
neHO npaBO 8KlU-'10Hepa Ha ofuKaJIooaIDre B cyA OTKa3a or BHeCeIDtJ'! 3a-
rrnCI1 B peeCTp 81\.QMOHepoB. IIo peweHl1IO cY.1¥l Aep:m.aTeJ1b peeC'rpa aK-
lIIWHepoB 06LQecrna 06H3BH BHec-r11 B peec-rp cooTBeTcrnyKJLQylO 3aIIl1Cb.
Ec.m-I Be,!\eHl1e peeC'rpa nopyqeHo (ne1V18JIJrnIpOB8IlHOMy peri1CTpaTO-
py, B f(3.'lec-rBe oraeT'rnKOB no AeJry IIpI1BJ1eK3IO"I f(3.K pemcrpaTOp,
TaR 11 aKQl10HepHOe ofuQecrro :8JJa.D.e.naI aKQJ1i1 BnpaBe O(paTHTbCH C
'rp€'60aaHJ'leM 06 06.A:3BHID1 8KLtI-'IOHepHoro 06LQecrna (.r:tep:m.aTeJlfl peeCT-
pa) BHec'J'll! aarrnCb 0 HeM B peec-rp aKQJIIOH€poB 11 B TOM crryqae, eCJII1 B
3aXOHOM «06 IO O Cpo1\: T8M.R
3aIIl1Cb He BHeceHa 11 Aep:m.aTeJlb peeCTpa He HanpBBI1JI aKQI10Hepy B IDI-
Tlf,lI;HeBHbrli CpOK nocJle no.nyqeHIDI OT Hero 3BflBJ1€H11H yse.l\OMJEHIre C
yK3.3BIDIa'Il MOTI1BOB 0TKa3a OT BHeCeID1.R ero B peeC1'p. Cy.r:t B cJJy'lae He-
urKa3a JfJill)'KJIOHeHillIl(ep:m.aTeJIH peeCTpaOT BHece-
IDIJ1 B Hero ii3ar1I1CJl/ no Tpe60B<UI11lO3K1_tI'-'!OHepaofu1-
3bmaeT ,n;ep:m.a.I'eJIH peecrpa BHecTI1 He06xoJJ:l1MYlO 38.illfCb C TOM ,lWTbI, C
I<OTOpoti OHa ;zJ;OJDKHa 6blJ1a 6blTb BH€CeHa B c0arBeTCTBJ01 C 3aKOHOM
«06 "»_
IIoMHMO ::rroro, Ha OCHOaaHID'! a63. 4 n 3 CT_ 8 3aKQHa «0 pbIHKE' qeH-
HbIX6)'Mar».mfltY,AOJ1YC111B11IE:'MY JrI1OJ1H€I1Henop
no)J.I1epmam1fl CHCTeMbl Be,lJ;eHWII1 COCTaBJ1eID1.l1 peec-rpa If HapyrneID1e
4q>M DT'leTHOCTJII (3Mm'eHTY. perncrpaTOpy, ,/:\en03wrapmo, BJIaAeJIbLliY),
MIDKeT Ohm. npe,!:\'WlBJ1eH J1CK 0 EI03ME'UtE:'tn1 yw;ep6a (BKJOO'IaH yny-
llIeHH)'lO BhII"OJ1Y), B03HMKllIero J13 H€E03MJ)KHfJ('T npaBa,
L\eHHbIMJ1: 6)'M3.raW1. IIpe,!J;bRBJIeIDle yKa3aHHbIX HCROB
OCyw;ecTBJllleTC.R: B paMK8.X npaBOOXpamrreJlbHb1X CIIIJ()Il1'HJOC
ReI>. IIonoH,!\onyJIo IIp=eJI K BbIBO)1y. 'ITO B cJJy'lae aHOlIffiJIbHOI'
pa3Blmm rpa HcKOro IIp8.BOO'IHOWeHWI (HeCOO'I'B€TC'TBH. 1J,l1HaMJ1-
KJiI KUtIKpt>rHoro rproKJJ.aHCKOIU npaBOOTHOllieHIDI IIpaBOBbIM HopMaM)
q:.opMOti pea.Jrn3alU111 Mep OTBeTCTBeHHOCTI1 BC€rA8- HBJIHeTCH npaBo-
OXp8HJ1TeJIbHDe OOJ13aT€JlbCTBeHHOe OTHOWeHJ1e. IIpl13TOM B03IDIKWee
npa 06J13aTeJIbCTBO-3TOHeHoBoe, HOJ1HeTOJtl',1l;eCT-
B€HHoe peryJl.flTI1BHoM)' OOJ13aTeJIbCTBO, a npeoopaaOBaHHOe B eBoeM
co,!\epmaHi'DIJ10CJIo:tImemlOe BOBhIM: COJlepmaHMeM caMoe HapyrnemlOe
peryJIRTItBHOe npaBOOTHOIIJeHIte. fpa)K,l\aHCKaH UI'lJe'l'C'I'BeHHOCTb -
«3TQ H€ TOJIbKO oco6oe IIOCJIep;CTBMe 3HOlIoIa.JIbHOi JJ;l1HaM>OO1lpa H-
CKOro npaBOOTHOllI€mm 11 p€aJIJ13YlOl1\€€CR COJl€pmam:re npaBooxpa-
Hi'IT€JIbHoro ofu1:3aTeJIbCTBa (oc050ro OTHOllIeHHR 0TBeTCTBeHH0C'"fH), HO
B onpeJI€JJ€HHhIX eJIY'ffiflX 11 OCHOBaHI1€ J1aJIbH€fi.llI€ HOpMCIJIbHJi-f,WI-
HaMI1KI1 IpIDKJIHHCKoro npaBOIJTHOllIeHl1H. B m>CJIep;H€M CBoeM 3Ha'le-
HI1110Ha HanpaBJI€Ha Ha BbmpCWJI€HI1€ a cra,wIl1,lI,1f1JaMHKJ1
lpam.I1aHcKoro npaBCOTHOllI€mm, Ha ncnpan.nem;:e B03ID1KllI€ro H€HOP-
MalIbHOro nOJI<nKeIDm.»287
IIpl1 3TOM, yqHTblBa.H 3Ha'lHMOCTb npaBOOXpaHJ1'1'eJ1b11bIX 05J13aTeJlb-
cmeHHbIX 0'l'lDIlIelIIDi OH npe,!\JIO»GfJ1 pacnpe,lJ;eJ1I1'I'b 05rq11€ nQJ1Om€H11II
OHJ1:X (onp€JJ;€JI€HJ1€, OCHOB3.H11II B03mIKHOBeIDlH. , nOpH,!\OK
11 cnxoGbi J-fCIDJ1H£fIHH, np€Kpal1\€H11III1 T.n.) CP€,!J;I1 CJll\€CTB}'KIl1\I1X 05-
l1\I1X HOpM 05J13aTeJIbCTB€lllIoro npana. B 'laCTHOCTI:!, ,lJ;OJDKHO 6bITb OTpa-
:HreHOflOJIOmem:r€ OTOM, 'ITO npJ1 Hapyw€mrn rpamJlaH<:KI1X npaBB03ID1-
KaeTnpaBOOXpaIDITe11blJ'JE' rpam)J;aHCKOE' , KO'I'Opo€, no
05l1\€MY npaBJ1JIY, HBJIJI€TCH 05J13a"f€JJbCTB€tiHbl11 RaK TaKOBO€ xapap;:-
T€pI3y€'TCR CJ1€JIYIOIl.\I1M CO,lJ;€pmaHH€M: yrIJIaTO IX J1€-
HeJKHbIX cyMM, COCTaBJImOl1\I1X caHK4HJ1, I1I'1C1IJJ1HeH1te HapyIII€HHOro
HcKoronpaBOOTHOllI€mm B HaTYP€ (ecJIHTaKOBO€ B03MOJiCHO).
-145-
.lI;yMaeTCR BCe:Hre, «TO B B.KlUtIJH€pHbIX OOll-\ecrnax MOr)'T B03HMKaTb
He TOJJbKO 05J13aTe.JIhC'I'BellH, HO 11 KOpnopaTl1BHhle arnOllIeH11.R npa-
BOOXj')ffiIM1'eHOrO xapaKTepa. $K<recKJ:1e OCo6eHHOCTI1 nOCJle,Q-
HI1X He n03BOJJJ11OT I1X OTHeCTi1 K 06r0aTeJlbC'l'-
BeHHbIM OTHOllIeHl1.RM. 0cH0BJI0ii xapaKTepHfJit: «eprot1 )'1\a3aHHbIX
OTHOllIemrl1HBJ1J1eTCI1 I1 11X
npi1 STOM aK1V10Hepbl coxpaH.llJOT CTaTYC CyD"beKTOB ynpaB-
J1eH11.R, 'lTO CCEeJXII€HHO He cnm:1cTBeHHo r HcKo-npaBoBbIM06J13a-
TeJibCTB3.M, cy6"beKrbl KOTOpblX HBJlJ1KTrC.11 paBHh1Ml111 HeaamtCl1MblMl1.
J13 TaKO B3aI1MOCBH3aHHOCTI1 i1 E!3aJfJOO3aBI1Ci1MOCTi1 BbITeKaeT
BIJ3MO)KH()(.'T CO 1j1 B HeKOTOpblX Cny'laflX JUITepeam cyD"beK-
TOB yK8.3aHHbIX OTHOllieHIDI - aKqJ10HepHOro 05ll-\eCTB8 11 aKW10HepOB
TaR, B CI1JIY B3aJIM()('Bfl38HHOCTi1 JUJT€pecoB 06llt/2CTB8 H ero Y'18CTHI1-
KOB nocJle)J.ffi1e yrIO.1IHDM)'I€HbI npe,!\"bm!JUlTb B cY JIICKI1 B 38J.WITY 06-
lL\eCTB8 - TaK H83blBaeMbie KOCB€HHbI€ JllJlI1 11}XI13BO,[(HbIf' I1CKI1. Ha
npaKTl1Ke TaKl1e H= HHor,!\a JIIMeH)'lOTCR TalOKe I1CKaMl1
Ba aKlll10HepoB 2B83aKoH0)J;8TeJlbHO YCTaHOBJIeHa TalOKe B03MOJiCHOCTb
pacnpoc-rpaHeHJl!fl OTBeTCTB€HHOCTi1 aKW1oHepoB no 06H3aTeJlbc-rBaM
caMoro B STI1X CJI.Y'laRX Ha5JllO,!\aeTcJI nepexo,!\ npaB 11 pac-
npoc-rpaHeHl1e ofuI:3aHHOCTei1: 0,!\H11X cyth.eKToB yK8.3aHHblX OTHOllIe-
HI1i1 HaJIPyrnx - pu CTaHOBJITCJI npaBQMO'llibIMR ,lI;ei1cmoBa.Tb
OT I1MeHl1 06ll-\eCTBa B nepBoM CJI.Y'lae H o6J13aHHb!l\rn OTSe'-laTb 3a 06-
lL\eCTSO so BTOpOM.
Oc06eHHOCTbIO B03HI'llI'.aIOl npalJ()()Xj)8HHTeJIbHbIX UI'HOllIemul
HBJIJIeTCJI cne CKI:DI xapaKTep 3alL\l1TbI npaB aK4l10Hepos, CBJI-
3aHHhIX C Y"aCTl1eM B ynpas.nemut: TaK, BO MHornx cny'la-
JIX npJ1 HapyrneHl1M npaB 8K1V1oHepa, HaIIpMMep, npaBa Ha HH<P:JpMa-
ltI1100 npoBe;:J;em1l1 06lltero cOOpaHWI, npaBa nporo.11OOOBaTb Ha 06llteM
co6palll1l1, aKQJ10Hep ynoJ1HOMO'I€H ncnpe60saTb no CY11Y He BOCCTa-
HOBJIeID1JI em HapyrneHHhIX npaB, K1lK STO 6bIBaeT npJ1 HapyrnemUI
05J13aTeJ1bCTBeHHbIX npaB, a 06maJlOBaHJtfI pellIeHJ1 06lltero co6pa-
ID1JI. EeCCMbICJ1eHHO 5b!J10 5b! Tpe60BaHJ1e aKQJ10Hepa 05 m$pMMpO-
BaffiU'! ero 0 npuse,lI.emm o6lL\ero C05pa:HJ-IH, 0 npe,!\ocT8s-
J1eHI1I1 eM)' npaBa rOJIOca Ha yme I1pOille;:J;llEM c06paHl-1J1; BO Bcex
CJ1Y'ffiJIX B.KqI10Hep ynoJ1HOMO'l€H np 06ll-\ecTBY I1CK 0 npJ1-
3Ha:HJ-IJII peweHI1JI o6lL\ero co5pam'!H He,!\eHCTBl1T€.IIbIIbIM.
CY,lI€6HOii 3alL\l1Te KOpnopaTi1BHblX npas aK1V1oHepa npi1CytUa H
ellte O,!\Ha 'lepra - cY'!\ MomeTOCTaSlITb 6ea 3all-\l1Tbi HapyrneHHoe npa-
BO, a 06ll-\ec-rso, ,D;OIIyCTi'1BW€€ Hapyw€HJl!e, MOiKeT He nOHeCTI1 OTseT-
CTBeHHOCTIL S03MOJiCHO, eCJII1 rOJlOCosaID1e aKQI1IJHepa Ha 06llteM
c06paHI1I1 He MOrJlO nOBJll1JITb Ha peaYJlbTaTbI rOnOCOBa:HJ-IJI, ,lI;ony!L\€H-
Hble Hapyw€HI1H He HBJlHIOTCR cyweCTBeHHblM1111 pew€HJI!e He nOBJIeK-
-146-
.no np:WllmeHI1R y6bITKOB aRqMOHepy. B 3TOM c.J1y'Iae CYABnpaBe cyqe-
TOM BCeX oficTome.m,cm l1eJIa OCTaBJITb peweHJIe B CMe.
TaRMM 06pa30M, He06XOWiMO npl13HaTb cyIQeCTOOBaJrne He TOJIbKO
o6H3aTeJlbCTBeHHbIX npaBOOXpaHJTI'e..J1bI1H"{, HO If IwpnopaT"'BHblX
npaBOOXpaHJ1TeJ1bHbIX OTHOllIem-rn.
Jl:.rrH a!peJ\eJI5D1H npl1pOp;bI B03H=ero npaBOOXpamrrem.HCI'O OT-
Howem-iH He06xo.rJ;i.IMO onpel1enl--lTb npl--lpO.r\Y HapYI1IeH-
HOro peryJUITlIBHOl'O urncrueHI1JL CneLtI-'l C OCTb perynH-
TI1BHOrO KopnopaTl1BHoro npaBOOTHOWeHHJi H8XO,lJ;J1T MecTO H B
COOTBeTCTByroWeM npaBooxp:t1IJI'I'e.l1HIOM OTHOWeW1I--I, I1OCI\OJ1bI\}' a1\:-
QMOHepbl, BCTYIIafl B npanooxpaHlITeJ1hllble KOJIDOPa"I11BH1oIe OTHowe-
HJ1.FI, np0,!J;OJImliKTr COXpaHHTb cTaTYc cy&beKTOB ynpaBJIeHJ1.Fl.
Bo3BpaI.l.\aflCb K BOnpocy 0 HapYI1IeID1F!x npaB aKlU'lOIIep:l. CBR3aH-
HbIX C peec'I'pa, Heo6xo,IJ;l'1MO OTMeTJ1Tb, 'ITO, nOCKOJIbK)'pery-
AATI1BHble npaBOOTHOW€HIU!, B03HJfKaIOlWI€ B CBH311 -
HblMnpaBOM aKqltUrepc:EHa np"'o5peTeHJIe aKQl1i1 HC HetJ6xo.n.:J1MOC'TblO
B€,IJ;eHI1R peecrpa 8KW'10HepOB 8KW'10HepHbIM o no cBOefi
npnpo11€ JlBJUiKTrCJ'i 06J'i3aTe.1lbC'I'£leHH TO 'I'aI«J£IbIMn KBJlH!GI'CH If
B03ID1KalOlWle B c.II)"lliJIX HapyweHl1fi np'" pea.IDC3aQJ1H 3TI1X OTHowe-
HI1fi 11 amollEHlm: npaBOOXp8HJITeJIbHOrO xapaKTepa.
KJXlMe :noro, a n:paB aK4J10HepoB B03MOm1ffi If B a;:J;Millillc"Ipa-
TImHOM nopR.JJ;Ke TaK, B CourBeTCTBID1CnO)J;lI. 5.3.11 IIOJIO'IKeHJ1H 0 4>e;:J;e-
panbHofi CJIyiK6e no J1HaHCOBblMpbIHK3. KnOJiHOMlYlliHM4>CtPPf'q>
B'laCTHOCTJ1OTHOClITCJlp8CCMO'rpEHlt:el1eJ1oo CTpaTIffiHbIXnpaao-
HapyweHJ1HX, OTHeceHHbIX B COOTBeTCTBJ1I1 C Ko,lJ;eKCOM f'q> 00 a)J;MI1HI1CT-
p<m1BHbIX KKm.meTeHqJ1J-f pa.71bH(I'OOpraHaI1C-
IIJJIHJITe.JlhlDI BJIaCTI1, eHIIOI'O B 06.rraCTI1 pbIHKa qeHllbIX
6)'Mar, a TalO!re npl1MeHeHl--le Mep OI'Be'I"C'I'Be, ycraHOBJ1eHl!b1X a,!\-
MJ 3aKOHOMTE'JIbCTBOM
)J;OBOJIbHO 'ffiCTO I1CKI1 B 3aIWlTY n:paB 8KW'10HepOB nO,!\1llOTCH 11 ynon-
IJOMO'reHHbIMJ' roCYl1apcTB£flHltlMJl OpraHar.nf. YKa38HHble IfCKI1 npeJrb-
JIBJ1JI1O'I'Cfl B paMRax npaBOOXpaIDrreJ1bHblX OTHoweHl>-lli, B03HMRa1OLqMX
B cJlyqae 06HapymeHl1H KOFfI]XJJIIIpyIOIIJ;J1M11 OpraHaMJ1 Hapywt:'HJ1ii
npaBaKIV«>HepC& BCOOTBeTC'I'BHI- C 3aKOHOM «0 pblHKeqeHllbIX6:yMar
4Jel1epaJlhHbrn: opraH HClDJIIDrreJ1bH()J1 BJ1acTI'! no pbJHKy qeHllbIX 6yMar
KOH"IpCUBIpOB8Tbco6.nlO)J;eHI1e r06Il\eCTaa-
MJ13aKOHOMTeJlbCTBa np'" npoBel1eHID1 3M",ccw-raKQl1i1. ComacHO CT. 26
3aKOH8 BbmyCK 3MJ:tCCI1OHIIbIX qeHIIbIX6)'M3.r MOiKeT6bITb I1pnOCTIUt)B-
.neH I1JIJ1 npl13H8H HecOCTORBWJ1MCH npJ1 06HapyiKeHJ1J1 p€I11C'Ipnpyro-
JIV.1M oprnHOM cn€J\YlOlL\I1X Hap)'I1IeHl1i1:
- HapyweHwe 3MJ1TeHTOM B xO,lJ;e 3MJ1CCJ1W -rpe60a8H1--1fi 38K0H)A8-
TeJlbCTSa Poccm1CKOJI4:1e,lJ;epaL\ID!;
-147-
- ofHffip)'iKeHJ1e B ,l\oK)'MeHTaX, Ha ()(E()BaHlD1 KOTopbIX 6b1JI :aape-
I'I«.'TpJ1pOBaH BbITlYCK I.teHHbIX 6YMar. He,lIOC'IOBepHOi I1H4xJPMa'--ti'fi'l.
B c.nyqae npl13HaBIDI BbInyCKa 311rnCCI10HHbIX I.teHHbIX 6)'M3.r He,l\ei1-
CTBI-I'I'€J1bHlDII see I.teHHble 6:yMaru ,l\aHHoro BbmYCKa nO;:vIemaT B03-
BpaTY:3MI1Temy,a Cpe,l\CTBa, 3MHTeHTOMarpa3MeI1-l€lll-U
BbIII)'CKa I.teHHbIX 6:yMar. IIpI13HaHHOro He,l\eUcrBHTeJIblIbIM, ,l\OJDKHbI
6b1Tb B03Bpall.leHb1 BJIa.r1eJ1bLtaM. tt>e,l\epaJ1bHbli1 opraH I-fCnOJ1Hl-fTeJ1b-
HOn BJIaCTI1 no pbJHKy I.teHHbIX 6:yMar AJ1$I B03BpaTa Cpe,l\CTB BJIa,lJ;eJ1b-
L\3.M BnpaBe 06paTl"ITbCfI B CY,l\.
CTaTbJ'l12 fK f'q> OTHOCJ1T K cnocooaM 3aI1tJ1Tbl rpamAaHCKi-'lX npaa
I-f npM3HaHI1e :IIe,lJ;eiic'"rnIITeJ1bm aKTa rOCY.QapCTBeHHoro opraHa 1fJ111
opraHa MecTHoro caMoynpaBJleHI1.fI. AKI.<I10HepbI B LleJLllx 3alltl1Tb! CBO-
J1X npaa J1H60 npaa aKlVlOHepHOro o6IQecTaa. KaK I-f caMO B
3alltl1TY CBOI1X npaB, Mor)'T oapall\aTbCH B cy,l\ C IfCKaIlrn 0 npJ13HaHJ111
He,lJ;eflCTBJITeJIbHbIMI1 aRTOB 4>C p P<P.
XOTH B03Mo:IKHOCTb 06m.a.rrOBaHl1H aKTOB, npl1HRTbIX OpraHallrn lOpl1-
rol'l€C:KnX JII1Q, If, B 'ffiCTH0CTI1. aKq!10HepHbIX o6ll\ecTB, CT. 12 fK f'q> cpe-
Ai1 cnoco6oB 3alltl1TbI npaa He yrIOMJIH8€TCR, O,lJ;HaKO Ha OCHOBaIDDI
n 7 CT. 49 3aKoHa «05aKlU'lOHepHbIX 06ll\ecTBax» aK4I10Hep BIIpaae06ma-
msaTb B cYfJ. peweHl1e, npl1HRTOe 06Lq11M c06paHl1eM 8KWlOHepOB C Hapy-
IlIeHl1eM"Ip€6oBamdi yxa3aHHOT03aKOHa, I1HbIX npaBOBbIX 8KTQB f'q>, yc-
Tasa 06ll\ecrBa, B CJI.Y'laE, ecJII1 OR He npMHMMaJI y«aCTl1H B 06LqeM
coEipaHl1l1 8KW'JOHepOB I1JII1 fOJIOCOB3.JI IIpOTI1B npl1H.lITl1ff TaKaro peweHl1H
11 ytca3aRHb1M perneHl1eM HapyrneHb1 ero npaBa I13aKOHHhle l1lITepeCbL
3.n;eCb B03H11KaeT BOIIJXJC - KaKI1e HOpMaTI1BHble 8KTbi H)'iKHO IIOHl1-
MaTb nWl «MHb1l'orn npaBOBbIllrn aKTaIlrn PCP»? 11x nOHHTHe MOmBO Bbmec-
TI1113 CMblCJIa 'l. 6 CT.:3 fK PCP, KD"IDpaH YCTaHaBJIl1BaeT, 'lTO I1MI1 HBJ1H-
1OTCf! ytca3bI IIpe3JJ,D;€fJTa f'q> I-f IIpamrreJ1l,C'l'Ba f'tP.
IIo3TOM)' ec.rr116;yKBaJThHO TOJIKOBaTb HopMb! I'pam,1i.aHCKOro Ko,l\eKCa f'Itt
11 3aKaHa «06 aKlVKlllE'pHbIX 06ll\ecTBax». TO HapyrneHl1H OCTaJThHbIX
HOpMaTIfBHbIX aKTOB, ,lJ;onyLl\elU!bIe npH npJ1HllTI1I1 a£pam1eM 1OHe-
pOBperneHl1H, HeMoryrCJ1Yml1TbClCl1CElalllreMAM'-npJ13HammeroHe,lJ;efl-
EcJ1J1 CJ1€,l\OBaTb J1orl1KE', TO HapyrneHHe npH npoBe.n;eW!I1 c06paIDf$I
8Kq!10HepOB, Hanpl1Mep, IIoJICOKeHJm O,l\OllOJIHl1'IeJ1bHbIX Tpe6oBaHi'UIX
K nop$IAKY IIOfJ.I'()'f()B C03b!Ba 11 npoEl€,l:\ftilffi 06Lqero c06paHl1$I 8KL\11-
oHepoB 290 TaIOKe He MOiKeT .RBJ1$ITbCH OCHOBaHtfeM,l\JLII npi13HaIDf$I pe-
IlIeBIDI o6Lq€l'O c06paHl1$I He,l\eM:CTBWreJIbHbIJ\o TaKoi1: IIO,lJ;XO,l\ K pewe-
HI1KJ Bonpoca HeJIb3R npM3HaTb YfJ.OBJleTBOpl1T€.IIl>HItIM. 3a'ieM TOrfJ.a
4>e,l\epaJIbHOM)' opraH)' HCnOJIHJfT€JIblll:xt: BJIac-rn no pbJHKy qeHHb1X
6yMar Boo6ll\e npl1Hl1MaTb HOpMaTI1BHble 8KTbl. ROmqJ€TI13ItpyKJlltI1e
I1C\JI())j{ft1J 3aKOHa «06 8KI.<I10HepHbIX '(». eCJII1TpeOOBaHI1Ji,
-148-
yc-rn.HOB.JJEHHHe B HM>::, MOr)'T MrHOpl1jXIBaTbCR 113-311 TOro, 'lTOHe B.ID:!-
moT Ha ,l:\eiic7mrreJn,HC!C'tt> pernem1H OOll\ero co6pamm?
B o, 3aROH «06 aRQI10HepHbIX OOll\eCTBaX» IiCnOJIb3)'eT nOHR-
me JfHbIX npaBOIlHX alcr'OB P4> B 60JIe€ WlfpolWM CMbICJle, HemeJlJ.-l
I'pam.rr.aHcmm Ko,lJ;eRC, liB Hero BXO,lJ;RTTaIOKe HOpMaTI1BHbIe alcr'hlMl1-
HI1CTepcTB I1l1HhIX 4>e,!\epaJlhHhIX opraHOB HCIIfJJIHI'1'T€rn BJiaCTIf.
3m ,l:\aJ10 OCHOBaHJ1e HeKOTOpbIM aBTOpaM, HaI1pHM€p, o.B. Be.noyco-
BY, A CamfK{)By. 291 c<u-rraTh, '11'0 B aTOM BOnpoce B 3aKOHe «06 aKLtI10-
HepHbIX o 11 HCKOM Ko)J;eKce P4>C)'lLIe<:TByeT npcrrn-
BOpe'nfe.J1aTo TaK. 'tJaCTb6CT 3 CKOroKo)J;eKca
JIJlliIh nepe'nfCJ1ReT HOpMaTI1BHbIe aKThl, ROTOpwe.f1BJlRK)TCjl «11Hh1-
MI1npaBOBhlMl1alITaMl1», npl1:91'OMHe '1ronepeqeHb:9TOT
J1C'Ie A BOTn. 7 roJ:imeCTaTbJ.-l yme aBTOMaTIf'lecKJ1IiCKJlIO-
'laeT aRThl. Hanpl1Mep, cpccpP P4> . J13 nOHHTI1R I1HhIX HopMaTl1BHhlX aK-
roB, nOCKOJIbKy TaM ycT8H(EJlftfO, <no «MrnrncTepCTsa VI IfHhle clJe,!\e-
panbHhIt' opraHbI I1CII1JJIHItTeJlbHOti BJiaCTI>:r MOryr 1i3,!\aBaTb 8RThl.
CO,!\ep:1t(fUl l1e HopMhI Ipam.!l3.HCKorO npasa. B CJIy<lfiRX Ii B npe,!\eJIaX,
npe.i:IyCMOTp€H HaCTOR:ll\l1M :I\o,-QeKcoM. A})yTrnm1 3aI«:EBMn 11 IfHhIMJI!
npaBOBhlMJilaRTaMJiI».II 'lToHffJ6xo.lu1M>ycTpaHJ1ThII]XJ-
TJ1BOpe'nfe.mt60 nyreM onpe,JJ;eJIeHl1ff B 3aKOHe «06 aKQIIOHE'pHbIX 06ll\€-
CTBaX» nOllJITJilR I1HhIX HopMaTI1BHhlX aKTOB, .mt6o nyreM BHeCeHl1ff 1i3Me-
HeHJ1ti B CT. 3rRPcf!.IIpl1'-leMnoCJIe;:J;Hee .nocKOJIbKY
4oPMYJlI1pOBKa. 'l. 6 Ii 7 CT. 3 fK P4> HBJIR€TC.FI Hey,!\3.'lHOi1.
O;:J;HOBpeMeHHo C HapyrneHl1eM HOpMaTl1BHhIX aKTOB 06ma.rryeMhIM
aK4Jl!OHepoM perneIDIeM )J;OJDKHbI HapyillilTbCR em npasa Ii saKoHHhIe
IfHTE'peCbl. C npaBaMI1 aK4Jl!OHepOB Bce nOHRTHO - OHl1 aaKpellJleHhl B
HopMaTI1BHbIX aKTax. A BOT nOHRTIfe lfHTepeCOB 8K4110HepOB He clJl1IJ'-
PI1PYeT HJ1!',l:\e. IIpe.r\C'!'CIBJ1R <no oxpaHFIeMbIM aaKOHOM wrrepecoM
a.KLtI10HepoB flBMeTCRwrrepeCB m 1OIIaJ1hHOI'O KO-
JII1'{eCTBYlinmy aKLtI10Hepy ,p
Bb1fO)J; OT ,l:\eH'I'eJJlHJC1'H aKQIlOHepHom 06ll\eCTBa. O,I:tHaKO B CJ.1J1Y TOro,
'lT0 TaKOro nolUlTMR B crn.qJ:lOIIepHOM aaKOHO)J;aTeJlhCTBe BeT, CY,!1aM, B
cJJy'lae paCCM<Yrp€Hl1.FlI1CKOB aKLtI1OHepOBO npn3HaIDm pEUlf'HJIII 06ll\€-
roro6pamm npIDW.r\J"fI'CRCaMJ1M$>pMYJnfpoBaTb
AMI CeOR 3'1'0 1DU1T11e. B CBR311 C 3T11M B03MOmHhl CI1"fYlli--\1111, KOrA<l aK-
QI10HepaM 6y,!\eT ,u;OKa3hIBaTh Cy,!laM clJaKT Hapyw€Hl1R pe-
llleIDIeM 06ll\ero c05paHHR J1X JfHTepeCOB, <no C03.n;aeT ,lIOIDJIlDtTe.IIbHbIe
yCJ!OBHR MR YCMOTpeHIDI cy,!\eti.
TaK, m YsapOB HA KaK aKL\I10Hep 3AO «ArpoKOMIlJIeKC
«fOpKI1-2» OOpaTI1J1CRBO.r\JlHlJ)IJCIDmrop0.r\CKOt:i: cYJJ. 06-
JIaCTI1 C JlICKOM K 3AO «ArpoKOMnJIeKC «fopKl1-2». rpa HaM Km1-
HOBCKOMY TT., ,naJiraTOBy AT. TpollIKOBy MB., (XX) «TpHHl1TJI» 0
-149_
IIpM3HaHIDJ He,l\e peweHl1i1 COBeTa rotpeKTOpoB 3AD
«ArpoKOMI1JleKC «fopl\Jll-2» OT 7 C€HHIOp$12001 r.113aO'lHoro coopaHl1$1
B OHepOB 3AD «A1poKoMn.neKC «fopl\Jll-2» ar 25 OKTOOpR 2001 r.
JJ.o I1pJffiHTJUl peweHl1$1 UCTIPM AonOJlHeHbI HCKOBHe Tpe60BaHWI 0
IIpM3HaHIDJ iic'rnwreJn,HblM nepexoAa IIpaBa coocTBeHHOCTII Ha
B MSAO «ArpoIroMn.neKC «fopl\Jll-2» K IproK.!\3.HaM: JJ.a.rrraTosy Af_,
KJ1J.-lHOBCKOMY TT. U (XX) «TpUHUTII»
Cnop 1\oweJJ 1\0 paCCMOTpeHl1$1 <PeAepaJIbHoro ap6wrpamHoro cy,l:1a
MocKOBCKOrO oKpyra. IIDrOpbDI: yxaaaJJ, 'lTO, o6paw;:t$1Cb C UexOM, UC-
Tell 06J'13aH 6blJJ }'Ka3aTb, Ralme UMeHHO ero npaBa U 3aKOHHble UHTe-
peCbl HapyweHbl ofuKanyeMIn.mUM peweHl1.IIMH 06ll-\ero coopaHl1$1 BK-
LlHoHepoB OT 25 OKHropH 2001 r. 11 COBeTa AHpeKTOpOB OT 7 CeH'TOOpH
2001 r. 3AD «Ar]X:UroMI1J1eKC «fOpKJ1_2».292
3aHBJIeHl1e BKLlJ10Hepa 0 npJ13HaHJ1l1 pellleHJ1.H COOpaHJ1.H 3KQMOHe-
pOB HeAeMC'TBJ1TeJIbHbIM MO:>KeT 6blTb no,!\aHO B CYA B Te'-leHJ1e 6 Mec.H-
LIes CO.IJ.HH, KOrJla BKl1Y!OHep Y3HaJJ I1JDiI ]];OJI:>KeH 6blJJ Y3HaTb 0 IIpMHH-
TOM perueHJ1JI!.
A CaBJ1KOB c'nrraer, '-IW,1IOCRJ:JJIbEy npoMeMa IIpJ11iY'KAeHl1H K ro-
JIOCOSaffiUO I1Jm onG13a OT I1JJIIJCOBaHJ1.H BK-ryaJJbHa, TpeOOBaHMe 3aKO-
Ha 0 TOM, '-!TOOOJ13aTeJIbHblMyCJrOBMeMH peweHl1H
HBJlHeTCH roJlCJCOBaHJre 11 -aKL(I1OHepa npDTI1B oo:m.a,rryeMoro penre-
HI1H, JlOJDKHO 6bITb CKDppeKTJIpoBaHO. 293 O,!\HaKO, RaK )'iKe )'Ka3blBa-
JIOCb, 31'0 npe,lJ;CTaBJIHeTCH HemeJJaTeJIbHblM, TaK RaK, Bo-nepBbIX, ]];BCT
0CII0BallI1e AJIH MH(II"()'lJtCJIHHhIX 3.IIOyrrurpe6.rreHm1 co C1'OpOHbl He,!\o-
6p<:xxmecTIn.Ix BKl1Y!OHepoB, B BO-BTDpbIX, pe3KO YBeJJWmT OO'beM cy-
AeOHbIX 1\eJJ no ocnapl1BaHl1lO parremo:l 06ll-\>fX co6palD1ii
06:m.aJJoBaTb peweHl1e 06ll-\ero c06paIDUl MO:>KeT TOJIhRO .ID1l\0. 100-
TOpoe .flBJlHJ10Cb aKLtJ10HepoM OOll-\eCTBa Ha MOMeHT I1pOBl'.lI€IDUl coopa-
H11H 11 He nepeCTaJJO 11M 6bITb K MOMeHTY npeJl'bHBJIeH11H I1CKa, TaK RaK
3aKOH «06 aKL(llOHepHblX 06ll-\ecrnax» rOBOpl1T. '-!TO oo:m.aJJOBaTb pe-
WeHJ1e MO:>KeT TOJlbKO aKLtJ10Hep.
BooaparqaJlCb K 3a"IJXll1Y'1'Oii TeMe 3J1OyIIO'Ip€6.rrli He,n;06poC<JBe-
CTHbLX aKLtJ10HepOB, CJre)J;yeT OTMeTI1Tb, 'iTO TaKJ1e CJIy'-laM Ha npaKTl1Ke
Hepe.!U'J1. TaK, HaI1J:UMeP, no uexy SAO «COBpeMeHHaJI ecRa$1
TaKTKKB» K DAG «BoCKpece " 0 npJ13HaHmf HeJleUCTBJI'reJIb-
HblM pewem1J! ro,!\oaoro crl5paHwI: aKl<l1OHepOB DAG «BoCl<peceHCI<Lle-
MeHT» OT 21.06.2001 U J1I1KBI1,!1,aL\HJtOTBeT'-II1Ka, paL'CMO'I'JX'HI KOTopora
]];OillJIO]];O <Pe.IJ;epanbHOI'O ap6u:'IJIDKHOI'O cYJla MocRoBCROrO oKpyra. no-
CJIe]:\HIrii YCTaHoBMJI clJaKT 3JrDyno1pe6JJeHJ1J1 I1CTL\OM npe]J;OC"raBJJetI-
HblM eM)' 3aKOHOM npaaoM. ITo MHeHHIO CYllP-, COOTHOllIeHJ1e IIpaB l1CTL\a
KtlK MI1HOpMTapHOro aKL1I10Hepa C era:me ]J;€IICTBIUIMI1 ,I:1aeT OCHOBaHJ1e
KBa.m$n HpoaaTb J1X RaK no,n; npn3HBKH CT. 10 fK P4>.
-150-
xapaKTepHbre }J)UI C.J1y'IaeB 3JIoynarpe6.rreHIDI npaBaMM.llcreD; 3JIoyno-
'Ipeol1J1 q:.OpMaJIhHhIM npaBOM MI-rnOpl1TapHoro aRqI10Hepa o5paTI-fThC$!
B ap6H1pIDKHhrli cy,!!; C "Ipe60BaImeM 0 JIJ1KB QI-fI1 OOIl\eCTBa, TaK KaK
J-ICTeD; 21.09.2001 r. 26 aKlU'lJ:i c:rrBe'!"n1Ka, '!TO COCTaSJlIIeT OI<OJI() O,01ct.
YCTasHoro Kanl1Ta.rra oOIl\eCTBa, 26.09.2001 r. nOJIy<n1J1 ahmJ-lCKY J-I3 pe-
eCTpa J-I cpa3}' oopanwCJI a cy 28.09.2001 r. C J-ICKOM, XOTSI cornaCHO
CT. 10 rKf'q>He SI,lI,6icTmlSlrpam,!\aHJ-IlOplW1'JeCKWXnl1D;,
eMhJe C HaMepelDteM npl1'lWH11Th ape,!!;
A!>yroMY JIJ1qy, 3 T310Ke 3JIoynmpefureHI1€ npaBOM B HHbIX $:JpMaX. Ha
ocmBa1OOf:¥!'Oro J-ICTLtY a Y,llOBJI€TBOpemlJ1 Kacca1V1(EH()ji ma.rr06hI Ohl-
JI00'I'Ka3aHo. 294
B n. 6 CT. 33 SaKoHa «06 3Kw-IOHepHhIX oOIl\ecTBax» )'1\3.3aHo, 'ITO
pewem-Ie COB€Ta ,lIl1peKTOpOB (IJaOJIIO,lIaTeJIhHoro cOBeTa) OOIl\eCTBa 00
0TKa3e BO BKJiKJ'leHl'1l-I Bonpoca B nOBeCTKy ,IJ;H.R oomero coopaHllil aK-
L{I10HepOB wrn KaH,!J;J-I,JJ;aTa B cmlCOK KaH;J;J1,!!;aTyp A1!H ranocoBaHJm: no
BhIDopaM B COIJTB€TCTBYJOIIJ;I-ri1: opraH oOIl\eCTBa, a TalOKe )'KJIOHeHHe
COBeTa ro:tpeK'I'Op(E (Hafuoo):(3.TeJlhHoro COBeTa) OOIl\eCTBa OT npYlHHThlH
peweHIDI MoryT 6h1Th ofuKa.nosmn:l B cy,ll.
IIyrncT 7 CT. 33 3aKOHa «06 3KW'10HepHhIX oOIl\ecTBax» YCTaHaSID:!-
saeT, 'ITO B cy,[l MOJKeT 6hITh OOJKaJIOBaHO H pellIeHYIe COBeTa ,IJ;I1peKTO-
pOB (sa6J1IOJlaTeJlhHoro COBeTa) OOIl\eCTBa 00 OTlffi3e B C03bIBe BHeo'!e-
peJlHOro o6mero co5paHIDI 3KW'10HepoB.
B n. 1211HcpopMllIUWHHOrO IDIChMa Ilpe:llI,! RyMa Bhlcwero Ap6Y1T-
pamHoro cy,lla P<'POT 21 3npeJlfllg9S r. NQ33 «0630p npaK"I1-IK1-Ipa3pe-
llIeHIDI cnopOB no C)\eJIKaM, CBH3aHHhlNl C p83MeIl\eHYIeM H o6paIl\eHYI-
eM 3RD;Yltf» T3Kme YKa3hlBaeTCfl, '!TO MomeT 6hlTh ocnopeHO B
CY,lJ;e6HOM nOpH,lJ;Ke J'! pernelllfe COBeTa ,IJ;I1peRTOpoB (Hafuoo):(3.TeJlbHOro
coseTa) 3 mJePHOrO OOIl\eCTBa 00 onpe,lleJleHHH CTOJ.-IMOCTH J-IM)'1lIe-
CTBa (BKJIlO'ffifl C'OOIIMOCTh 3KW'1J:i), npHHflTOe H3 OCHOSalrnH CT. 77 3a-
KOHa «06 aKqJ:IOHepHbIX OOIl\eCTB3X», eCID:! COBeTOM ,IJ;I1peKTOpoB npM
ero BhIHeCeJ1ID'! ,!J;O!1)'1l1eHo HapyrneHHe 'I'pE:'6osa.HKj, npe.nyCMOTpeH-
HbIX 3aKOHOM.
KpoMe TOro, peweHHe COBeTa AJ-IPeKTopoB nl160 VlCIJOmfJ'1'TeJIb
opraHa aKW'lOHepHoro OOIl\eCTBa MruKeT 6h1Th ocnopeHo 3KqI10HepOM B
CY,lJ;e6HOM nOpH,lJ;Ke nyreM npe,!\"bJIBJIemm HCKa 0 np:W3HaHID'! ero He-
,D;eMCTEKTe.nhHhIM KaK B CJIY"I3RX, KOr,[\8 B03MOmHOCTh ocnapVlBaHIDI
S 3aRoHe «06 aKW'lOHepHhIX OOIl\eCTB3X», TaK 11 npH
OTCyTCTBID'! COOTBeTCTBYJOmero )'1\3.3aIDIfl, eCID:! npYlHHTOe pewelllfe He
OTBe<iaeT TpeOOsaHIDIM 3aKOHa 11 HHhIX HopMaTIlBHbIX 3KTOB VI uapy-
llIaeT npasa 11 oxpaHReMhIe 3aKOHOM HHTepeChl a OHepa. OrBeT'D:!-
100M no TaKOMY l1.e;rry 6y,[leT HBJUIThCfl aKLtHOHepHoe oOmeCTBo.
-151-
IIpM TOM CJIe)lyeT yqMTbIBaTb CJIe)JyIOIl\ee pa:3'bRCHeHl1e. ,AaHHOe
IlneHYMOM BepxoBHOOO Cy,Aa : np>1 paCCMOTpeHIDI fJ.eJI 00 06ma..rro-
BaID1>1 perneHHi{ OpraROB yrrpaBJIeID1fl BKqI10HepHOro OOIl\eCTBa cy,w,H
J-IJI>1 cYfJ. He BnpaBe 3BnpelJ.\aTb npOBefJ.eH>1e OOIl\ero COOpaRJ1H BK1V10-
HepOB, I10ClIDIIbKY am npcrr!1BOpe t [!'IT CT. 31 KOHCTI-fTYQM11 , rapaH-
"I1IpylOIQeH rpa:m,!\aHaM CROii 4lefJ.epaQM11 npaBO CoO"P1lTbCH
M>1pHO, 6e3 0PYilGffl, npOBOIU'ITb C06paHJ1H >1 fJ.eMOHCTpal.!!1>1, WeCTB>1H
11 rnfKE'=pOBaID1H, a TaKme HapyIIJaeT npaBO aK'-\I10HepOB, He 06maJlY-
IOIL{>1X peweHl1i1 opraHOB ynpaSJleHJ1H aKW'lOHepHoro 06Il\eCTBa, H8.
yqacT>1e B OOIl\eM co6pamDi aKLI!10Hep0B. npe,lI,OCTaBJ1eHHOe JiM tPe)I.e-
paJlhHbIM 3aKOHOM «06aKLlJ1oHepHhIX .295
BCt:O'I1IeTC'rBJcn.6cT. 793aKOHa «06 o
KpynHaH C)I.eJlKa, cosepWeHHafl C HapyweHl1eM 7pE:'6oBaIndi HaC'I'OHll!€ii
CTaTbl1, MOiKeT 6bITb npl13HaHa HeAeiicT131l'renbHOii no J1CKy 06Il\eCTBa
I1JIJ1 8KL1J1OHepa. OAHaKO OHa MO:>KeT 6bITb npl13HaHa CYAOM 11MeK)Il\eH
lOpIf,lCf'Ia:xyID CJ1JIY Ji WIR OOIl\eCTBa 113 Hee
npasa 11 06H3aHHx:ll1, eCJIl1npl1 paCCMJ'Ipetum: cnopa 6y,[leT yCTaHOBJIe-
HO, <no B 1I0000e)1yK)Il\eM TJ.aHHaJ'l C.D.eJuca 6bIJIa o.D.o6peHa COOTBeTCTBeHHO
COBeTOM wrpeKTOpOB nl160 OOIl\l1M coopaID1eM aK4l10HepoB 06Il\eCTBa.
II)'HKT 1 CT 84 3aICOHa «06 aKql1oHepHbIX06mecTBax» y<:TIUI8BJInBa-
eT. 'ITO CJI.eJIKa, B CUJepllElllm: IWTOJ>OM l1MeeTCH 38JIlfI'ePI2COBHHOCTb,
caJEpIUeHHaHC HapyIlIeID1eM KC)\eJ1Ke, npe
yAA.33.HHbIM 3aKOHOM, TalOKe MO:>KeT 6bITb npl13H3.Ha HE',[\€UC'I1!KTeJlbHOii
IIO l1CKY OOIl\eCTBa J-IJI118Kl!OOHep8- B OCHOBe npl13Hamm ee B'llK C)\eJ1lill, B
caJEpIlleHIDI KOTOpoM l1MeeTCH 3aIDITepecoBaHHOCTb, neJfGIT npl1Hll;mI
IIO)I.'JJ1Hemm JnNHbIX rnrrepeCOB aKI-tHOHepoB 06Il\eM)' I1H'I'€p€cy aKql10-
HepHOro 06Il\eCTBa. RaK COBepllIeHHO BepHO OTMetffieT fiB. CTelIaHOB, 11H-
1CfIlIld: IIpJ1H'-\I111 Jn1'IHblX rurrepeCOB }"-JaCTHJ.-IKOB
KOpnopaTl1BHOH m 06Il\eM)'KOpnopaTl1BHoMYHHTepecy06yc-
JIOBJIeH npJ1Hl!IDIOM OlITl1MaJIbHoro COQeTaHl1.H 06Il\ecT-
BeHRbIX, KOJIJIeIm1BHblX Ji J1WIHbIX J1HTepecOB cy6oeKTOB npaBa, 1I0.ny-
'lMBIlIero urpam€H11e B HopMe ao3. 2 ..:. 2 CT. 1 I'K . IIpl1 :;rrQM ecJ111
npl1HU,illl OCHOBbIBaeTCH Ha ElU3M())fQt()CTlorpaHWIeHl1H
npaB B J1HT€pecax OOI.J.l€CTBa J-IJI>1 ,lIpyr'l1X JIJ1l!, TO npJ.1Hl!ill1 nO,lJ;'II-rnemm
J1I1'IHbIX I1HT€peCOB oomeMY KOpnopaTMBHOM)' rurrepecy 03Ha'iaeT 803-
MOiKHOCTb orpaHWIeHl1.H peaJrJ133. npaBOT,[IeJlbHbIX}"-JaCTHl1KOB, KOr-
,Aa era ..T!I1'UJb]j;Il111T€pec npe06J1a,!I,aeT H8JI. ero l1HTE'pecoM RaK yq.ac'I1lI1Ka
lCopnopaTl1BHOH opraHH3aQM11 11, CJ1€J\OBaTeJIbHO, He OrpaHWll1B8eT npaB
teaK y<iaCTHI1Ka KOpnopa'I'l1BHOii CPrawi38Wm:.296
II.YHKTI71 IDfCbMalIpe3 BblcweroAp611-
'I'paJKHoro cy,l:\3. f'q> OT 13 MafITa 2001 r. NQ 62 yCTaHaBmD3aeT, ..:TO opra-
HH3aL\l1fl, He }"-JaCTBYJOIl.\8H B C,lJeJIKe (npe,lICT8BJlH£'TC.II. ":TO 31'0 B!lOJIHe
-152-
MO:1KHO pacnpocrpaHJITb II! Ha rpmtGWHJI!Ha), B roB€pIIIeHJm: KOTOpOi1
Jl!MeeTCR 3CU1HTepeCOBaHHOCTbJJillt Ha3BaHHhIX B 3aKOHe, He BnpaBE' OC-
napJ.-maTb:;nYC,QeJIRYB CY,Qe6HoMnOpSI,D;K€, aIL 18 Torome Jfiupop -
OHHOro m-ICbMa Ha,!J;eJIReT I1paBoM I1p€.!n>$J1eHWI JIICKa 0 I1pJI!3HaHJnI He-
11€11CTBHTeJ1bHJi1 c,QeJIKJl! JII npoKypOpa
qTOKaCaeTCflcoBepweHWI oHepHbIM KpyIIHbIX c,Qe-
mK, TO Mem,[ly HJI!M JII aKlUIOHepoM B aTOM eJlJ'1ae KOp-
nopaTIfBHble arnoweHWI, nOCKQJ1bl\Y npaBO a.KQWOHepOB pacCMOTpeTb JII
npilli.flTb Ha oor.qeM afjpaHIm peWeHII!e 0 COBepweHIDI 3TOi1 C.LJ;eJlKJII
BXO,QJ1T B COCTaB npaBa OHepCJB Ha ynpaBJIeInfe. OmoweHWI Mem-
lI3 JII al\:QWOHepaMI1 no nOBO,rr;y aaKJIlO'IeHI1J1 (',I\eJ1Kl1, B KOTO-
poi1 Jl!MeeTC./i aamrrepecuBaHHOeTb, T3.1OKe KaK II! no nOBO.n;y aaKJOO'Ie-
HWI KpyrIHon (',I\eJlKJII, HOCRT KopnOpaTMBHbrfI xapaKTep, J1CJcr\OJ1bKY
Hepa3pbIBHO CBJl3aHbI C ynpaBJI€tMeM aKWIOHepaMl1 06mecTBOM.
IIpl1 COBepweHIDI T8IOCJii (',I\eJlKJII aK OHep 06H3aH ,lJ;OseCTl1 ,lJ;O 06-
Il\eCTBa Irn4>cJpMaIUfiO 0 rnoeii aamrre B COBepWeHl1I1
(',I\e.mot. 06mecTso BilpaBe Tpe60BaTb OT aKL{ItOH€pa npeAocraBJleHWI
TaIOC)Jil1H4>cJPMa . 06r.qe<:TBOTaKme 06R3aHoco6mocTnyCTaHOBJIeH-
HbrfI nOpH.LJ;OK O.LJ;06peHl1H TaKOM C)\eJlKI1.
B CJlyqae me HapyrneHHH IIpeJJ;yCMOTpeHoro 3aKOHOM «06 aKql10-
HepHbIX 06mec"rnax» nopH)J;K1i COBepweHWI KPyrrHbIX C,QeJlOK JII C,QeJlOK
C 3alUITepea:EaHHOCTbro Me»I'JJ:Y aKqI10HepHbIM OOmeCTSOM JII aKl{110He-
poM MomeT B03HnKHyIb KopilOpaTl1BHOe npaBooxpaHI1T€JlbHoe OTHO-
llIeHl1e, KOTopoe peaJll13)'eTCfI B cJI.Y'I8e npelJ;'hHBJlemffi JIICKa B CYA aR-
Q>IOHepoM 0 IIpJl!3HaH]:I11 COBepIll€HHOii C.LJ;eJllU1 He,l\eMCTBwreJIbHaH.
ITpoI1::!I3O,l\IIbI€ JllJII1 KOCBE'HHble JIICKI1, TO eCTb npe,l\'hRBJlHeMble or
Jl!MeHI1 aKWIoHepos, HO B 3alQl1TY Jl!HTepecoB 06ll\ecTBa 0 B3bICK1lliI'D'1
y6bITKOB OOll\eCTBa npeAYCMO'IpeHbl 3aKOHOM «06 aKlU10HepHb1X 06-
Il\ecrBax» JII B 1J.Byx cJleJlY1OIJ.-V1X CJI.Y'I8flX. Ha OCHOBaHI111 n. 3 CT. 63a-
KOlla aK OHepbl AO'lepHero 06ll\ecTBa BilpaBeTpe60saTb B03MeLqemrn
OCHOBHbIM oUll.\€CTBOM (TOBapl ) y61.rrKoB. npwIllHeHHbIX no
era BI1He ,l\O'lepHeM)' 06r.qecTBY.
Ha OCHOBaHIDI n 5 CT. '71 3aKolla MJlI1 aKl{110Hep (aKql1o-
Hepbl), BJla,zJ;erol.J..ll1fi S COOOK}'!1HOCTI1 He MeHe€ 'IeM 1"0 pa3Mell\eHHbIX
00uKH0BeHHbIX aK " OOll\eCTBa, BilpaBe 06paTl1TbCH B cyJt C JIICKOM II:
'lJIeHY COBeTa AI1peKTOpDB (Ha6.mo.LJ;aTeJlbHoro COBeTa) 06ll.\ecTBa. e,l\l1-
HOJlJ1'IHOMY JICIJOJIIIII'I'e opraHY 06ll\ecTBa (Ai1peKToPY. reHe-
paJlbHOM)' ,n;I1peKTopy). 'lJIeHY KOJIJlelWUIbHOro IfCIIO.JIHHTeJIboro op-
mHa (npasJleHl1J1, Al1peKQJ1I1), a pasHo K ynpaBJIRIOr.qeH
opram13arvm JllJnI ynpaBJlJ'llOIl\eMY 0 y6bITKOB, npwlJ1-
HeHHbIX 06ll\ecTBY. B CJJy'Iae. eCJll1 OHI1 IIpl'ilrneHbl JI!X BI1HOBHHMI1
AeJ1C'1BmMJ1 (6ea,neiicTBJreM), eCJII1l1Hble OCHOBaHI1R If pa3Mep OTSeT-
-153-
CTBeHHOCTII He YCTaHOBJIeHbl 4Je,n;epa.rrbHbIMM 3aKOHaMM. IIpJ1 TOM B
COBeTe .AJ1peKTOpoB (Ha6J110,I\aTenbHOM COBeTe) 00iQecTBa. lOC!Jl.neIHaJIb
HOMJ1CIIOJIHI1TeJIbHOM opraHe 06ll-\ecTBa (npaBJIemm" .m I) He He-
cyr 0TBe'TCTBeHH0CT '1neHbI, J'OJ1OCOBaBIlDIe npO'I1fB pewemm, KOTO-
poe nOBneMO IIpwumemie 06l1lecTBY y5uTKoB. I1.ID1 He IIplnBlMaBIllI1€
yqaCTWI B ro.m:x:oBaHltJ'l.
Cne;nyeT OTMeTJIITb, 'lT0 IWHCTPYKJJ;H.fI np0J13BO,I\HbIX J1CKOB J1MeeT
KaK CBOMX IIpJ1BepmermeB, TaK J1 1IfXJT11BHHKOB. TaK, ,l{.B. JIoMaW1H.
lo.A. MeTeJIeBa, nIL CblpD.n;DeBa OTHOCJITCRKcy:w:eCT-
BOBam-liO YKaaaHHO 1OCIIIC'TpyKlUI1-i KaK K ,D;OIIDJIHJ1TeJ1bHOMY cpe.n;CTBY,
HanpaBJIemwM)' Ha CJ6ecneqemle npaB aIatHOHepos J1 caMoro 06ll-\eCTBa
r. OCOKJ1Ha, HanpOTJ1B, BeCbMa KaTeropwlHO B1:lCKa3HB8eTCH npO'I1fB
Hee, C'1J1TaR, 'lT0 caMa no ceoe KOHCTPYKQJm, HecMOTpR Ha CBOIO BHew-
HIOIO IIpJ1BJIeKaTeJIbHOCTb, KpaflH€ HeJIOrWlHa, B cJ1JIY '1ero n T
60JIbWe BonpocoB, '1eM ,n;aeT OTBeTOB.
TaR, Yl\'a3aHHbD1 aBTOp nO)J;HJ1MaeT BOnpDC (CKopee npoJJ;eccyaJIbHoro
xapaR-repa) 0 B03l\oID1Ktt1CT I1p€,rn..fIBJJeHJ1R TaKWX J1CKOB I':lKJJ;l10HepaMJ1
RaKJ1CT , SCBR3J1C TeM, '1TOnopocCHficKoMy 3aKOHO,I\aTeJIbCTBy nJ1-
qa, Ie OT l1MeHl1 J1 B I1HTepecax ,n;pyroro cy&beKTa IIpaBa,
l1MeH)'KTI'CH 1103TOM)' rpyrrna I':lKLtI-'IOHepoB (aKWIo-
Hep), npeA"bJIBJIHIOI1W-flIiCK B nopfl,rr;Ke IL 5 CT 713aKOHa «06aIatHoHep-
HbIX 06lI(eCTBaXD, BbICT)'IIa.eT B Ka'1eCTBe 3aKOHHOro npe,!\CTamrreJUi
liCT - 8KW1DH€pHOrO 06lI(ecTBa. TaKl1X aaKOHHbIX npe,!\cTaBJ1T€JIeH, no
MHeHJ1lO YIffi38-HHOro aBTOpa, LleJIecoo6pa3Ho l1MeHOBaTb KOpnopanm-
HbIMJ1npe,n;crnB11TeJUIMK. OrneT'lliKOM( I)noTaKOM)'J1C-
KY 6Y,I\eT.J1BJIJ1TbCR ,I\OJDKHOCTHOe JrnQO (JlH1¥l) c6ll-\ecTBa, OTBeTCTBeH-
HOCTb KD"IUJlliIX CTpOJ1TCR Ha Ha'1alIaX BilllliI (n. 2 CT. 71 Yl\'a3aHHOro
3aKOHa). IIpJ1 3TOM opeMR ,lJ;OKa3b1BaHWI OOcTORTeJIbCTB, C KOTOpbIMJ1
3aKOH CBR3bIBaeT HaC'IJ'ILI1eHJ1e OTBeTCTBeHHOC'rn COOTBeTCTByro
J1I1ll; nepe,lJ; OOll-\eCTBOM, B03JIaraeTCR Ha caMO aK4MOHepHOe OOll-\eCTBO
J1Jn1 ero aKWD1epOB, T}X:'6yKntIIX B03M€t1teIDI-R y6b1TIWB.
110MMMO ;,lToro, B CJ1JIy CIIapUpl1lG'l KopnopaTIffiHbIX arnornemrn BO-
06ll-\e J1 8KLlJ10HepHbIX B '1aCTHoc'rn, 8Kl<J:rotIep:l, no MHeHl1IO 8BTOpa,
J13Ha'1aJIbHO He lIpe,lJ;llOnaralOTCR cy&beKTaMJ1 TOro npaBOOTHOI1I:'ID1R,
113 KOTOporo B03HJ1RaeT Tpe60BaHJ1e 0 IICI3MeLqeHIDI y6b1TKOB, npw.m-
HeHHbIX aKJJ;J10HepHOMY06ll-\eCTsyno BHHe ero .n;OmKHOCTHbIX JlJ1JJ;. 110-
CIWJIbKY CyD"beKTal;n1 cnopHoro MaTepHaJ1bH()l'{) npaBOOTHOWemm Bbl-
cTynalOT I':lKI1:J10HepHoe OOlI(eCTBO J1 ero ,n;OJIJoKHOCTHble JlJ1ll1':l, TO
e,!U1HCTBeHHbIM HaATIeJoKaIl.\J1M J1CTLlOM no TaKOM)' J1CRy HBJUieTCR 06we-
CTBO RaIl: ynpaIlOMO'K'HHbD1 cy6'beKT cnopHOro npaBOOTHOIlI:'H11JL
TaKl1M 06paaoM, r OCOKJ1Ha IIpWXO,!J;J1T K saKJIIO'IeHillO, 'ITO KDHCT-
PyKLlJ1flnpDll3BQl:{HOl'ClJ1CKa, HBJ1AACb'iJ1CTO f.)'M03pIrreJIb-
HO KOHCTp)'KQHeH, He l1MeeT npo'-IHoro Teope-mqecKlIU a
TalOKE' BbIXOAa B oonaCTb npromf'-jecKOrO npaoonp:I1MeHeHWI, a nOTOMY
IIpe.l\CTaBJlHeT co6oi1 TYIDII{(}BbIi,i nyTb pa3B11TI>1H TeOpl1Jtl If npaRTIfIU1 IfC-
IWBOfi: 4>oPMhI 3allV1TbI npaB J1 3aKOHHbIX mrrepecoB. 297
)J;ei1CTBl>1TeJIbHO, comaCHO n 2 CT. 44 ApfuorrpamHoro IIpoQeccyaJIb-
HOro Ko eKca P<P I1CTqaMM HBJIJlIOTCR oprnHl13aI\ID'1 11 rp aHe,
npe.l\'b.HBMBWMe J1CII: B 3alltl-'lT)' CBOJ1X npaR J13aKOHHbIX mrrepecoB. Ax.-
QMOHepblmeeCJIM 11 Moryr npeA"bflBMTb nO,lJ;06Hblli I1CK, TOTOJIbKO B HH-
repecax 06JQecTBa. n03ToM)' I1CTqOM B .mo6oM cJIyqae .r:\OJDKHO BblCTY-
naTbCaMO
KpoMe TOro, B03MCOKHOCTIIJtJU1 I1fJ)J;diHoro I1CRa aK-
L{MOHepar.rn3Ha'lI1TeJlbHoC)l'K8.IOTCHl1nCYrOM)', 'ITOAJIH
TaKoro l1CKa II: 'iJleHaM COBeTa Al-IpeKTopoB J1Jlli IWJ1J1erJ.-JaJlbHOrO I1cnOJI-
HltT€JIbHOOO opraHa aKQHOHepbI ,n;OJDKHbl o6J1ft)J;aTb npaBoM 03HaK0MJIe-
HJ1R C IlpOTOI«)Jl<\MI 3aCe,lJ;aHJ1t1 COOTBeTCTByIOwero opraHa, Ha KOTO-
pbIX 6bIJIH npHHHTbI perneHlIH, nOBJIeKlill1e I1J)I'1'lI'ffi€IDle 06 w ecmy
y6bITKOB, BeAl> TOJIbKO TaK B03MOiKHO YCTaHOBJleHl1e cy&beKTOB OTBeT-
CTBeHHOC'I11 - nl"W, I'OJIOCOBaBllIM 3a IlpI1HRTJI€ peWeHJ1R J1JThI B03,1J;ep-
:1KaBlill1XCH OT rOJIOCOBaHI1R. GJJ;HaKO n. 1 CT. 91 3aKOHa «06 aKQHOHep-
HbIX 06meCTBax» yc'IIDfOBJl€HO, '1TO npaBo Ha JJ;ocT)'T! K nptJ'IOKOJJaM
33ceJ!,aIrn:ii KOJIJIeI'ltaJIbHOOO I1C1JOJ1111f'"I"{ opraHa €CTb nl1IlIb y aR-
QMOHepOB (aKQMOHepa), B roBOK)'IIHOCTI1 He MeHee '1eM
2 v ra.nocyKIlUfX aKwrl1: 06u..Jecrsa, '1TO C03,QaeT "Tpy,!I;HOCTII ,lVIJi ocy-
fi\€CTBII€IDIH I3()3M{»I{lDC' Me,ma;:x aEQHOHepOB no 1Ip11BJI€'1eHl1lO II:
OTBeTCmeHHOCTIf BlIHOBHbIX Jlill.j.
TeM He MeHee, HeCMOTpR Ha BbllIIeyP:a3aHHble TPYAHOCTI1 BTeOpI1H.
1OCIlC'"Ip 1H KOCBeHIIbIX I1CKOB BIIOJllie peaID:!3}'eTCR Ha npaKTIfKe,
HeCMOTpR Ha npO'I11Bope'lI1R HOpM 3aKOHa «06 aKLtJ«iH€pHbIX OOIL\€CT-
sax» 11 ApfurrpamHOI'O IIpoQeccya.m.HOI'O KOAeKca P4:>.
TaR, aKQl10Hep GAG «c:PapMcHaoc6brr» CMI1pHOB AB., 06paTI1J1CH
21 aBrycTa 2002 r B ApOI1TpaiKHbaJ: cyA MocKOscIwti ofutaCTI1 C I1CKOM
o npH3HaH111'1 HeJ1,efic'mwrem,HbIM (HJ1'lTOiKHblM) J!,OroBOpa 1OC!MHCCI111 OT
B cpeSpa.riR 1999 rO)J;a .N'9 7C, 33KJIKJ'IeHHOro Me:>tQ:\y GAD «AU. CI1 3H
GKT.ROpb» J1 GAG «c:PapMcHa6c6wT» C HapYW€Hi1eM CT.CT. BI-B4
413 «06aKL\110HepHb1X >_
Oripe,!\eneHJ1eM OT 4 OKTROpR 2002 r. no .r:\e;rry .N'9 A41- KI-13175 /02,
OCTaBJI€HHblM 6e3 I13M€HeHI1R nOCTaHOBJleHl1€M an€J1JIJ'IQHOHHoti mJ-
CTa 1I1 OT 12 HOJI6pR 2002 r., Ap5mpaJKHIDi CYII Moc:IroscKoii ofutac-
TI1 np0l13BO,lJ;CTBO no iJ,eJly npeKpaTl1Jl no MOTl1By OTcyrCTBI1H Y I1CTL\a
co6CTBeHHOro BelWloro I1lITepeCa B ocnapl1BaHl1I1 C,IJ;eJlKl-l aKQl10HepHO-
ro 06meCTBa ClImpmBl:lJ'll AB. B Ka'leCTBe aKQl10Hepa 3TOro 06IQ€CTBa.
-155-
He corJIaCl1BllIJ1Cb C lIaHHbINU1 cYAeOHbIMM aKTaMJ1, CMJ1pHOB A.B.
OOpaTI1JICR B pa31l>ffilfi: apfunpamm.ni CYll MoclOC!IIClroI'O oKpyra C
KaccaQJlOmrit: :ma..oo6oJl, B KOTOpoi1 npoCI1T BbllIIe)'Ka3aHHble orrpe.n;e-
JIeHl1e OT 4 OKTROpR 2002 r. 11 nOCTaHOBJIem1e ane.. JrnC1'aH-
QI1I1 OT 12 HoR6pR2002 r. no iJ,eJiy .N'9A41-KI-13175/020TMeH11Tb 11 Ha-
npaBI1Tb iJ,eJIO Ha HOBoe pacCMOTpeHl1e B TOT me CYJI.
CYlI KaCCaLll1oHHoi1 I1HCTa.HQI1I1 nOCQU'Ian B03MroKHbIM yllOBJ1E'TBO-
pI-fTb KaCC<lQJlOmryro manooy, 06manyeMbie CYlleOHbIe 8KTbl np"3HaTb
nOllJIemaU<J1M11 OTMeHe C HanpaBJIameM lIeJ18 ,IJ,Jl.fI paccMUrpeHKH no
c)'11I;eCTBy B nepBym JIHC'Ia1JLII1lO ApfuitpamHoro CY1l8 MOCKOBCKOi1 06-
.Y1aCTI1, B CBR31f co cJIeJ1Y1OU<i1M
ComaCHo CTBeHHocrn lIeJI ap6l1TpamHbIM
Cy;qaM, ycT8I10BJ1eHHOti n. 4 IJ. 1 CT 33 AIIK F4:>, apfurrpamHblE' CyJlbI
paCCM8"TpI1BaIOT AeJI8 no cnopaM Me:>tQ:\y 8KL1110HepOM 11 al(L!lWHepHbIM
, I1HbIX XooIDicTBeHHbIX TOSapl1LII;eCTB 11 06-
Il\eCTB, BbITeKalOIl\l1M11 113 JleHTeJIbHOCTI:! xomdiCTBeHHl:lX TOBapJ1-
Il\eCTB 11 OOIl\eCTB, sa I1CKJOOIJeHl1eM TpYlIOBbIX cnopoB.
IIoHRTl1e «AeJITeJlbHOCTb OOlL\eCTsa» I1SHa'laJibHO I1CKJIKJ'IaeT yqac-
Tl1e OTlIeJIbHbIX ero8KQI10HepOB B Heif, nOCKOJIbKY JleHTeJIbHOCTbaKQI1-
oHepHoro OOlL\eCTSa C>CyIQeCTBJlReTCH B COOTBe'fCTBID1 co CT. CT. 53, 103
rK p era opraHat.rn, Jlei1cTsyIOlL\I1MI1 B COIJ"IB€"IC'"IB C 38ROHOM,
J1HbIMM npaBOBbIMJ1 aKTaMl1I1 yqpe,IJ;i'ITeJIbHblMJI JlOKYMelITat.rn.
J1a3Toro,nOMHeHJ1lOCYM, CJie,n;yeT, 'ITOnpaBOHa06pall meCI1CKOM
CMI1pHOSY AB npe.r:\OCTaBJI€HO HopMaMl1 IIpOQI2CCy3JIbInpasa
IIocKOJIbKY'I. 1 CT. 84 3aKOHa «06 aKQl(c:EepHbIX » npe-
1IYcMOTpeHo, '1TO CAeJIKa, B COBeprn€m-rn KOTOpoi1 lfMeeTCR 38I1HTepe-
COBaHHOCTb, COBepIlIeHHaH C IffipYIIIeHl1eM Tpe6oBaHw1 K C)\eJIKe, npe-
A,YCMOTpeHHbIX IffiCTOJlllV1M tPe;:J;epaJIbHbIM 3aKOHOM, MrnKeT 6bITb
npl13HaHa HOti no I1CKY 06lL\ecTBa I1JII1 aKLll10Hepa, TO
npaBO CMI1pHOBa AB. Iffi 06pall\ffme C JiCROM B Ap&1TpIDKHbIti CYA
1brnoBCKOii oOJ18crn OCHOsaHO 11 Ha HopMax MaTepl18J1bl1O('() npaBa
TaKl1M 06pa30M, HenpamfJIbHoe nplfMeHeHI-fe JiI1CTOJIKOBam:r€ HOpM
MaTepmlJIbHOr() 11 npoQeccyaJIbHOrO npaBa npl1BeJIo K npl1H.11T11lO He-
npaBI1J1bHbIX onpe;qenelD-fR CYlIa nepsoM J1HCTaHQIDII1 nOCTaHOBJIem:rR
CYM aIIeJIJJ.JIqIWHH I1HCTaHQI1I-f, B CBH311 C '1eM TpeooBam:rR
ClIuIJlliCl!8 AB. nOAJIemaT paccMarpeHJ1lO no c)'1l.\ecTBY CYJlOM nepBoi1
HHCTaHQJDl 298
IIpMBe,!\€HHbrn C)'AeOHbrn npe:u;e.r:\elIT JlJ1J1KIC'IpnpyeT TO, KaK C)'AOM
6bIJIOOTlIaHO npe,!\I1O'ITelll1e HopMaM CT. 33 AIIR F4:>o IIO,J:$€J\OMCTBeH-
HOCTl1l1e.rr ap6l1Tpa:lKHbIM CY,lIaMnep€,!\ HOpMOi1 IL 2 CT. 44 AIIRP4:I, co-
Aepmamei1 onpe,!\en€m:re I1CTQa. 4:>aKTIf'I€CKJI CYJlbI nepBoi1 11 aneJIJIJ1-
L(I10HHoii I1HCTaHWffi npaBl1JIbHO IlpJIMeHl1JII1 HOPMY, YCTaHOBJIeHH)'lO
-156-
cr. 44 AIIK P4:1, HO TeM caMbIM .ID1Illlf.Jill 8KqI10Hepa BO:3MC:»KHOCTH
npe.D;hRBI1Tb KQCBeHHbrM HCKB &UltwryHlITepeCOB pHQI'006we-
crna. 1iI:n0 HeJIb3H nocrnBI1Tb HM B mrny, nOCKOJIbK)' cyltbI JIillllb OYK-
BaJ1bHO cne,!:\OBaJ1W HOpMaM CT. 44 ATIK P4:>. 3Ta arryawm. B03ID1KWaF.!
onaro,!:\aPJ1 npcmmope'ill1OMem,ll.J;yRa3aHHbIMJ.1HOp-
MaMM, JlOJDKHa ObITb pa3pellieHa Ha 3aKOHO,!:\aTeJIbHOM ypoBHe J1JIW xarH
6w Ha ypoBHe BwcIIIero ApGwrpamHoro CY,lIa P4:>, I<O'I'OpWi ,lIOJDKeH
AaTb CyAaM HHCTaHWffi PYKoBO,!\.l1 e pa3'b.11CHeID1J1,
oOH3b1Ba e CYJlbl rIpn3H8.BaTb aRQMOHepos, no,!\alOUI;VlX KOCBeHHbIe
HCKJ1B3a11tJ1Tynpas HHHTepeCOBOOl1\eCTsa, IHCTr.taMl-f
O,!tHaKO TaKJ1e CJ1Y'ffiJ1 HeTaK'laCTO B npaKTl1Ke apoJ1-
'fP3.'KHbIXCYJlos. KaKnpaSMJlO, HCKI-'!, K01'OpbIeMOrJIJ16wno 3aKouy «06
06lJ.!€C'1'B8X» npe.D;'b$JlHTb aItlV-IoHepl;l, no,!\aK11'CR B cy-
,IJ;bI caMJ1MM 8K[{Y10HepHbIM>1 06l1\ecrsaMi-f. B mo6oM cnyqae OTHmlleffiIH
Me:>K,D;y aKl\HOHepHbIM>1 OOl1\ecTBaMJ1 H a B03HIIKaIOIQ>le s
CER3H C npe,!:\'bHBJIeHI1eM aKQ>10HepaMJ1 B aarqwry J1HrepecoB 06l1\ecTBa
KOCBeHHbIX HCKOS, He Moryr crpoJlITbCH no Mo,!:\eJIH 06HsaTe.JIbC'l'BeHHb
I1OCI«JJIbKy s 3TJ1X OTHDWeHJ1RX, so-nepSbIX, 8RQMOHepbI COXpaHffiOT
craryc cy6'beKTOB ynpaBJIeID1J1, 8, BG-BTDpbIX, HeB03lIfC:»KHO nO;:J;pa3,!:\e-
JIJ1Tb crapoHbI Ha OOR3aHH)'ID H ynpaBOMO'IeHHyK>, KaK 31'0 xapaKTepHO
AJ1H 06H3STeJIbCTB. I\poMe TOrD, aKQI«JliefH BCT)'IffiIOT B amouremm no
co6c-rneHHOO HHJ1qJ1aTIffie H npe,!\"bHBJIHIOT HCK B aarqwry IlHTepecoB He
CBOIDI:, 8 OOl1\eCTSa; TaROe CMerneID1e H B3aHM03aBItCJ1MOCTb J1HTepeCOB
xapaETepHO JmH KDprropaTIffiHbIX OTHOllIem-rn. IIo CyrH, JIJ1'lliOCTb aK-
Q>fOHepOB H 061QEC"IE8 B 3TOM cJ1Y'ffie C TO'fKJiI 3p€ID1J1 CYJlS COBrraIlae-r,
TaRKBKBKLtI'DHepbInpM3HaIOTCH IHCTr.taMJj.
3aKOH «06 aKQ>fOHeplIblX YCTaHSBmmse-r cneQ>fSJIb-
HbIe CpOKlf Haroaoii ,!:\aBHOCTJ1: 3 MeCRLla - AJ1H npe,!:\'b.I1Snem1R J1CKa 0
nepeso,!\e HS cefu1 npas H ooH3aHHOC'l'eA nOKynaTenfl B cJ1Y'ffie, IWr,lla
aEltIlOHep HJIJ106I1\€CTBO}'3IffiJD1 0 HapyrneHl1H J1X npe CTseHHo-
ronpasanpJ106peTemm8RQMJ:i(n. 3 CT. 7 3aIWHa) H6 MeCRLles - ,!\J1R06-
maJlosaID1J1 B CYJl pellIeID1fl 06r.qero c06pamm (n. 7 CT. 49 3SKOlW.). YKB-
aaHHbIe cpoM Ha'lHHaIOT Te'lb C MOMelIT8, KDr,Aa 8KWlOHep (WIJ1
06r.qecTBo) Y3HaJUf IfJIW ,lI0JDKHb1 6b1J!111 Y3lW.Tb 0 HapyweID1J.-1 J.-IX npe-
HIU'O npasa npJ106peTemm H KorAa aKI-t"OHep Y3lW.n J1J1J.-1
AOmKeH 6blJI yaHaTb 0 IIpItHffIOM 06UI;V1M c06paHI«'M pellieIDrn COOTSeT-
crneHHO.
Ewe 60JIee COKpSIl\eHHbrn CpoK nClOCJBOi!: l\BBHOCThI - 1 MeeHL{ - YCTa-
HOSneH,WiR ofuKaJIoBam1R B CYA qJIeHOM cosern ,IJ;J1})€KTOpOB (uaOJIlO,!:\a-
TeJlbHOro COBeTS) OOIl\ec'1'Ba peweID1J1, npl1HRTOro COSeTOM,lJ;IfpeKTOpOB s
HapyrneID1e ycraHOBJI€HHoro nopH.!\KB. 3a.RBJIeID1e 0 npH3HaIDrn pellIe-
ID1J1 He,!\ei1CTBlrr€JIbHb1M MomeT 6blTb nO,!:\aHO B cy,lI; B TeqeID1e OJ\Horo
_157_
MeCRqa CO.wrn, KOrw -qJJeH COSeTa ,lI;I1perITOpOB (Ha6.mo,!:\aTeJIbHoro coae-
Ta) OOI1lecrBa Y3HaJllfJI11 AOJDKeH 6bIJ1 Y3HaTb 0 np"lUITOM pernemrn.
'qaCTb 2 CT_ 181 rK f'4I ycraHaBJIJ1BaeTTatoKE' cneqlta.JIbHbIit: CpoK HC-
I«JBO ,D,TIJ'lI1pJ13ILllJJLllocr1OJ::&lMbIXc,!:\eJ1ORHeAejiC'T'BJrreJ1HIbI-
MJ1-1 ro)J;CoAlUI 1f1HaCI-UIW1lfJI11yrpo3b1,nOABJ1WIH11eMI«J-
TOpbIX 6bLJIa coaeprneHa c,n;eJIKa, .m1I5o co .wrn, KOr,D;a HCTeQ y:3HaJlIfJI11
AOJImt'H 6bLJIY3HaTb06HHbIX o6cTwrrenbcTsax HBJ1jOO CROCOOBaHH-
eM AM npl13HalllU1 c,n;eJIKH HeAE'f1CTI!H'l'E'JThH IIymcr 1 pa3J1. 20630pa
npaK"l11Kl1 paccMOTpeHIDi cnopoB, CB.FI33.HHbIX C npl1MeHeHHeM CT. CT. 78,
79, 81, 83 3aKOHa OT 26 AeKaopJ'l1995 r..N'9 208-tP3 «06
aKqHOHepHbIX 06I11ecTBaX»299 npflMO ymi3bIBaeT, 'lTO c,n;e.ma;:, 3aI\JIlO'-{eH-
Hbre .Jrnqa.MH,HBJlJ'IIOTCHOCIIOpIIMl:IM>L
B OCTaJlbHbIX I1€pE."llfCJ1eHHbIX c..nyqaJ'IX, BJf,!\1-1M0, npMMeIJHM i
qJexro)J;l1'lHbrn CpoK ,lIaBHOCTI1.IO.A MeTeJieBa C'MraeT, 'ITO K
CJIy'l8.KJ,yKa3aHHOM)'BIL2 CT. 45 3aKOHa ,,06a OHepHbIX061l.\eCTBax»,
"Ipe60B1ilille 00 HCROBOii ,lIaBHOCThI B(U01l.\e He AOJDKHO npl1MeHHTbCR B CO-
CfIBeTCTB1D1C'I.5CT 208rKP<p..naHHMCTBTbJI Ko,!:\eKca
msopMT 0 TOM, 'lTO I1CKOBaJ'i ,n;BSHOCTb He pacnpoCTpaHJ'leTCR ua Tpe60Ba-
HIDi co6cTBeHHI1Ka IfJI1111H0m eJIb'--\B 06 yc:rpaHeHill1 BCHKJ1X Hapy-
llleHHi1 em npasa, XOTJ'l6bl3T11 HapyweHIDI He 6bLIDI coe,lJ;l1HeHbl C JH1IlIe-
H"eM B.JIaAeHlIH (HeraTopHbrn: HCR). OrKB3 peeCTpo,lJ;epmaTeJlH OT
BHE'CeffiLII 3BIIJI!CM B peecrp KBK pa3 nOJ{XO}J;IIT nQl\:n:y HopM)'. IIocKOJIbtcy
COrJIaCHO CT. 29 3aKOHa «0 pblHKe L\,€HHbIX 6yMar» BHeceHJ1e B peecrp HE-
JlReTC.H 3BBepwaKJLU;MM 3TaIIOM c,n;eJlKH C BKQIDIMH 11 nepexo.!\ npaBa coO--
CTBeHHOCTIf ua BK4ID1 npol'!rXQll;l:1T B MOMeHT BHeceHl1H l1MeHJ1 npm£pe-
TaTeJ1J1 B peecrp, TO urKa3 OT BIJeCeH11f1 TaKO
3BIIJI!C" B peecrp BJle'leT HeB03MomHOCTh AM B.JIa)J;eJlhQB B.KQI1i1 CTaTb J1X
co6cTBemnu<oM. CJ:ieAOBaTeJIbHO, em qJe60saIDIe 6Y,lJ;eT TpefioB1ililleM m
ycrpaHeHmf uapyrneHWI em npasa. 3OCI
AKQ>:rOHep MillKeT npe.!\"bHBJ1J1Tb" KOJIJIeK'DlBHble "C:K'Jf, TO eCTb "C-
IDI B 3alQHT)' He TOJIbKO Ce6H, HO" ;n;pyrJ1X aKQJ10HepOB, HaX 1XCfI
B I1O,lJ;fJI5WM nOJlomE'IDI". 8Ta npoQe,lJ;ypa HCI1OJ1h3yeTCl1 B TOM c.rry'lBe,
Kor,/J;a 38TpoHyrbll1HrepeCbl CTOJib MHornx aKl<i'1OH€poB, 'Iro npJ1BJ1e<ie-
IDle JIIX BCex It yqaCTJ1KJ B ,lJ;eJle C03AaJlO 6b1 TPY,lJ;HOCTJ1 AJ1J1 CYAeoHoro
paaO"PBTeJIbCTBa.
2, OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb aK ItOHepHblx 06aqeCTB
It ItX y..aCTHltKOB
RaK 113BeCTHO, Mepa npHH)'iK,D:eHJUl, ycraHOBJI€HHaH aa HeJfCi1OJIHE'-
IDle I'Ip3B(EOP: HOpMbI, MeeT orpOMHoe 3Ha'IeHJ1e. «Ee3 HBJlBJoKeHHOiiI
cncn>MblIOpJwl'J€Cf«)fi OTseTCTSeHHOCTI1 npaBO CTaHOBl1TCH OeCCJ1J1b-
-158-
HbIM 11 HeHa.n;e»I:HbIM, He onpaB)J;bmaIOrqwM B03JIBraeMbIX lIB. Hero COQI1-
aJlbHbIX IIpaaOBbie HOpMbl, a paBHO npol1CTeKalOll-tJ1e 113
HHX npaBa 11 06H38HHOCT1'1 'lJIeHOB OOI1leCTBa npeBpaI1VlIO'fCH B 6JIarl1e
ncmrenalU1H, ecnl1 BJ1aCTb He cnoc06Ha. opraHU3OBaTb BOCCTaHOBJIeHl1e
HapYllleHHbIXnpaB, KI1CnOJlHeHJ1IOOO$13aHHOC'Teii ...»301
YKa3amIOe B nOJlHoif Mepe OTIIOCMTCH 11 K 06R3aTeJIbCTBaM, KOTO-
pbIe, RaK yme ynOMJ1HaJlOCb, IIpOJI3OWJ1H 113 ,lJ;eJlI1KTOB. CJie.I\OBaTenb-
HO, OHI1I13I1B.'1anbHO CaMbIM TeCHbIM OOpa30M 6bLITI1 CBH3aHbI C l1,IJ;eeA
OTBeTCTBeHHOCTI1.
J1,!J;eH OTBeTCTBeHHOCTJI RaK HeOT'beMJ1eMoro Ilpl13Ha.Ka OOH3aTenb-
CTBa Cb eIl\e B pl1MCKOM npase, EaK UfMe'laeT Qe3ape
CaH4»r.mmno: «...COBpeMeHHH8.H H8.yKa npilllIna K nOCT-
poeHtflO, He J1l1llleHHOMY TO'1eK conpmrocHOBE'ffi1.fl C pJIMCKI-fMII npe,!!;-
CTaBJIeHl1HMJ1, OTO)K,l\eCTBJIHlOI1IeM)'ero C,IJ;BYMH cne;:J;y1OIII;J1MYI MOMeH-
TaMP-I: «,I\OJIr», nOHWMaeMbIi1 RaK I1MYlL\eCTBemlOe npaBOBOe ())f\JUI,aHJle
Kpe,!\JoITOpa, 11 «OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb», IIOHl1MaeMaH KaK nOCJIeJ\CTBI1e, Ha-
crynalOI1Iee,l\JlH 1I0000000000, ROTOpbrli He l\3.eT YIIOBJleTBOpeHI1.FI O:1K\1-
,D;aHJ1HM Kpe.I\J1Topa».302
IIptf paCCM:YIpeIDDI OOH3aTeJIbC'l'BeHH1:lX OTHOllleHID1 H. IIJarm OT-
MeqaeT, '1TO «B03HMKaeT BOnpoC B:vIHbI .m-w;a, KOTopoe C'IaHOBm'CH
,lJ;OJDK1U!KOM. IIptfHHTOe IIOHHTIle OOH3aTeJIbC'"I'BeHHoro OTHOllleHtfH
(Schuldverhaltnis - (HeM.) 06H3aTeJlbCTBe1fHOe OTHOlllerrn:e; Schuld -
(HeM.) Billfa; lIeHeiKHbrn 1I000r, 06R3aTeJlbCTBO)303 lIaeT B03MOiKHOCTb
pacCMaTptfBaTb TaKOro po,D;a «B>rny" OOH3aHHOro J1i1qa B Ka'leCTBe CBae-
OOpa3HOro HJWa OOH3aTe.JlbCTBeHHc:IU OTHOllleHHf!. OrcID):\a B03HJ1KaeT
BOIIpoc 06 aHanolWf C yronOBHbIM npaBOM, f.I\e H8.3Ha'leHtfe HaKa3aIDU!
CBH3aHOCID1HoifnpeC1}'lIlU1Ka».804J1,!J;eRSl1Hbl JD1L\3l1MeeT,
6e3yc.ooBHO, 6o.m.urJe 3Ha'leHJ1e, XOTH B Ka)K,l\OM OT):\enbllOM cnJ'lae H
He HHaJ1I.-I'rn$1Bl-fHblKaK AJUlcoorBeTCTByroll\e-
ro Uf1IOIIIeHIUL
O,lJ;H3KO OTMeTJ1Tb, '1TO HCIIOJ1b3yeMoe IIJannoM nOHH-
TIle Schuld :!1MeeT 11 ,D;pyroe, nptft,!eM YXO,lJ;Hllwe no CBOeM)' npotfcxom-
,IJ;eHI1lO elL\e B ,DpeBH€e BpeMH, CO,I\epmaHl1e - ,IJ;0JIr. TaK, IiLA IIOKpOB-
CKtfA OTMe'1aer, '1TO so BpeMeHa aapom,IleHl1H OOH3aTeJ1bCTBeHHblX
O"IHJllII2ID'1if 113 ,!\eJrnKTOB 11, BcneJlCTBl1e ;,lToro, KposHoA MeCTl1, «nOHR-
TIle ,/J;onra (Schuld) noHBWlOCb He cpaay, eM)' npe,/J;lllK"I'BOB8 nOHH-
TIle OTBeTCTBeHHocrn (Haftung)>>.305 IIpl1 3TOM, KaK YKa3bIBaeT
MM. ArapKoB, JJ;OJlI' 11 0TBe'I'CTBeHH0CTb HBJlmoTCH He pa3JIWIHbIMI1I1
He HeaaBI1CI1MbIMI1,Dpyr OT,D;pyra 3JleMeHTaMI1 06RaaTeJlbCTBa. a nl1lllb
,IJ;BYMH acneKTaMM O;:J;Horo 11 TOro me OTHOllleHl1f!.306
DrBeTCTBeHHOCTb CJle,nyeT onpe,!\eJrnTb KaK camw;l1lO, npl1MeHHe-
MyIO K flpasOHapyIIIJoITenID B Bl1)le B03JI(»K'€1BlR liB. Hero ,!\onOOHHreJlb-
-159-
HOM 06H3aHHoc"rn I1.ID1 JD1IlIeHMH npHHa.IIlI ro eM)' npaBa 307 JImJo
RaK «BI>-I,ZJ; He6JlaronpWHTHbIX I1()('.J1('J1CTB1ni, 3aK.I1I<1'mlCf.1lJ:rneJI B JIllliIe-
HI1I1 npaBOHapyuIl1TeJIH (113"bHTI'D1 y Hero) S TaKme B 3a-
npellleInfI1, npeKpallleHJ1I1 npaBa Ha np€,IUJpIf11HMa-
TeJIbCKOA ,lJ;el1TeJlbHOCTI1, npl1HY,lJ;I1TeJlbHoti peOprSHl13a1IH11 I1JII1
1Opup;K'lecKOro.JIJ1l-1;B».306
C nOHH"rneM OTBeTCTBeHHOC"rn TeCHO CBH3BHO nOHHTl1e Ca.HK1V'II1.
Ca.mcr.ti1R B IIpaBOO'I'HOlll('fll111MeeT BamHoe 3Ha'leHl1e: Ha CTa,zv.-rn: Ha;:vIe-
:lK3.llIerOBbIIlOJIHeHl1.fl CTopoHaMl1 OHa HanpaBJreH3. Ha npe-
;nynpem,zJ;eHl1e np B Ha CTa,D;I1I1 HapyIl1'1OO'I npc&1CXO,ZJ;I1T
ee peBJU13a1V1H, cnoc06cTByroIIJ,aJI BOCCTaHCEJ1elll-fiO HapyrneHHbIX npaB.
3,!\eCb BO;UrnKaeT BOnpoC 0 COO'IH1weHIDI IIOHRTIdi "OTBeTCTBeH-
HOCTb» J1 «CBHKWlH», npl1t;eM Ha 3TOT C'1eT y aBTopoB HeT O,!J;H03HB'lHO-
ro MHeIDIH. HeKOTOpble CKJlOHHbI OTO)K,1I;eCTBJIHTb 3Th! nOHHT11.II, 6oJJb-
WI1HCTBO .me aBTOpoB, Hao6opOT, 'leTKO"X pa31'p8HWD1B81OT
IIoMHeHI1IO B.4>. IIOIIOHJIOnyJIO, «caHKIU1H B 06H3aTeJIbCTBe onpe)J;e-
.JIffeTCH RaK)'CT8HCB.JIeHH3.H r HCKI1M 3aKOHOM I1.ID1 COrJ13.IIIetrneM
CTOpOH KOHKpeTHaH B03MO)JQJOCTb nplM€HeIDIfI Mepbl rocy,llapCTBemlO-
m 1IpI (YJP03a HacTyrureHMH onpe,n;eJIeHHbIX OTpI1IWTeJIb-
HbIXllX:JIe,!\CTB"ii:) xapaKTepa Hac.rryqa.i1HeJ1CIIOJIHe-
HI1H I1.ID1 HeHa)\JI llIero I1CIIQJIHemm 06H3aTeJIbcTBB».309 J1HbrMI1
CJIOBaMl1, SBTOp HCXOJIIIT 113 "IpeX'1JJ€HHOlI CTpYKrypbI HOpM l'pa)K,1l;aH-
CKOro npaBa, 06H3aTeJIbHO BKJOO'1alO B CBOi1 COCT3.B TBKOi1: 3JIeMeHT
RaK caHKQI1JI, TaK RaK UfcyrC"fBlle )'Ra3BHI1H B npaBOBoi1 HopMe Ha 803-
MO:1KH)'IO Mepy rocy,n;apCTBeHHoro npillfY)K,!\eHIDI npeBpaIl-\aeT npaso-
B)'lO HOpMY B 1aJ1bIIYKl 0meTcTBe1rn0cTb .me RaK TaKOBaJl - 31'0
npl1M£'HeHl1e (B03.1I(OlIEHI1e Ha ,n;0JDKID1Ka J1 nperepnE'BaHlte 11M) MepbI,
npJ.-IBO,!l.Hl1J;ee K peaJibHOM)' HaCTyrureHl1IO npe.D:YCMO'IpeJ1HbIX He6naro-
npWHTHbIX IIOCTIeJ1CTBln"i 0r8e'rememr0cTh, l1MeIOIl-\8J1 MeCTO Ha ypoBHe
npaB<XYIHIIIeHI1fI (B paMKaX npaBOOXpaHIITeJIbIIOI'O 06H3aTeJIbCTBB),
C)'Tb pea.71Il3a1UtH CTaTil'-Jeaoofi: 0TBeTCTBeHH0CTH npoJIBJlIUOIl-\eA ce6H
Ha HO-HOpMaTl1BHOM YPOBH€-
OA. RpacaB'-UIKOB no,n; CaHKJ.<I1eH IIOHl1M8.eT Mepy l1Myw;eCTBeHHbIX
"J1HbIX npaBOBbIX HeBblro,!UIbIX,D,JIJlJI n KOTOpaJl np"'-
MeHHeTCH K HeM)' B c.rryqae COBepmelDUI npaBOHapyIII1'1T€JIbHb ,lJ;eti-
CTBHi1, RaK-TO: HeYlCllOJIHeHHH 06H3aTeJIbCTB, npll'DIHt:'HWH spe,lla I1JII1
np'" HaJiI1'lJ1l1I1Hb1X npe,!lyCMOTpeHHbIX 3aKOHOM OCHOBaHI1A. 31D
O)J;H03Ha'lHOrO MHetrnH cpe}J;l1 )"-IeHbIX no BOnpocy 0 MeCTe OTBeTCT-
BeHHOCTI1 " caHKUI1I1 B CTpyKrype 06H3aTeJIbCTBeHHoro npasa He
C$JpMl1poBaJIOCb.
ell. ACKHB3ID1, pa3)J;emUI npaBOBble J1HCTIfTY"I'bI Ha .ABa BI1)J;B:
1) cJIymalll;l1e lVIH 3aKp€IIJIetrnH TInIJl'-llibIX ,D,JIJI CI1CTeMbI npaBOBU'(
-160-
UI'HOllleHIDI - MaTepHHJIbHO-npaBOsbIe; 2) 3aKpeIIJlJIIOll(l1e, I'JIaSHbIM
o6pa30M, MeTOAhI 11 cnoc06b1 co CTOpoHb! I'OcYl1apCTBa.
ROr]11i HapyrnaeTCfl HOpMaJIl>IIbIit XO.n; TI1IIJ1'IHblX 0'TII00IeIIHif - BcnOMO-
I'aTeJJbHbIe J1JIJ1 BcrDl«II'aTeJIbHO-npasoBbIe, O1'HOCI1T K IIiCJle,IJ;HJIM If 01'-
BE'TCTSellllOCTb 3a HapyrneID1e .QOI"OI3Opa- TaKI1M 06paaoM, no MHeH11IO
c.J1 ACKHa3lli1, 0TBe'I"C'T1JeH1 HBJmeTCfl caMOCTOHTeJIbHbIM J1HCTH-
T)'TOM npasa. 311
P. CaBaTbe TalOKe npl13HaeT O1'.n;eJIbHbIM, npH<'!eM seCbMa Sa:IKHbIM
J1HCTHT)'TOM, rpa:)K,lJ;aHcKyKJ 0TBeTCTBE'HHUCT 312
IIo MHeHHIO .me D.C. 110cpcpe. caHKLlHIO - TY Mepy npJ1Hym;zJ;eHlliI,
KOTOpaJI 6y;zJ;eT npHMeHeHa K HapYllnne.mo 0611aaTeJIbCTBa, CJle.n;yeT
B006I.qe O1'HOCHTb K ::meMeHTaM 06fl3aTeJlbcTBa. HaPJI,LJ;y C OObeKTOM.
cy&beKTOM. 313 TaKoro me MHeHlliI 0 CaHKLll1l-1 RaK COCTaSHOM 3J1eMeHTe
o6flsaTeJIbCTBa npH.n;epJoKHBaeTCfl 11 KK flWlKOS B CBOe" CTaTbe «CHC-
TeMa o6flsaTeJIbcTs 113 npWlI1HeHl1fl Bpe.n;a B COBeTCKOM npase» (np'"
370M nOHJITlliI 0TIJe'ICfBeHH0C'"I1'1 If caHKlU1H HM ()'f()]fI'JIecTBJlHlOTCfl).314
TIo MHeHillO D.C. J1oc:pcpe, np", OTCyrCTBIDI I1cnOJI-
HeIDIe o6H3aTe..nbcTsa caHKqID'! OHO TepfleT CBOIO CHJ1y.113 3TOtO 11M .n;eJ!a-
eTCfl ,l\OCTaTO'lHO .mo6olIbITHbrn 11 BnOJIHe JIOI'H'IHbrn BbIBO,l\. «Henocpe.r:t-
CTBeHHbIMcnoc06oMnpHBe,l\€HlUiB,l\B'ic:TImecaHKWfi1,o6ecne>n1Ba
11Cll()JlHelIJ1e 06fl3aTeJIbCTBa, HBJmeTCJI rpa:m,1JPHCKI'IiIIiCK Ho C IiCTe<'!e-
HI1eM ,lIaBHOCTI1 npaBO Ha liCK norawaeTCfl, a 3Ha'llIT B TOT .me caMbrn MO-
MeHT OM3aTe.1IbCTBO yrpa'll1BaeT CBCik:TBeHHyKJ eM)' caJiKUI1IO. TIOCKQJIb-
KY me 6ea caHK4l1H OM3aTeJIbCTBO cyru;eCTBOBaTb He MOmeT. HB.!\JIemwr
npMi-frn: K BbIBOJJY, 'ITO OHO npeKpall\BeTCfl cpaKTOM I1CTe'leHWII1Cl«JBOii
11,aBHOCTI1.»315 Taro1X .me B3I'J1J1,I10S 0 npeKpa elll1l1 06H3aTeJIbCTBa IiCTe-
'1eID1eM HCKOBOii11,aBHOCTIf nplWJ:»roIBB.Jll1Ch cP.M. raB3e. JJ:J1. Meiiep.
O,rr;HaKO I1.B. HosJauaUi c<'!HTaeT, 'lT0 06flsaTeJlbCTBO, JIl-IWeHHOe IfC-
KOBO" CI>-IJ1bI, Bce .me HeJIb3II C'ilfTaTb npeKpa eHHbIM:, TaK RaIl: TO 0611-
3BTeJIbCTBO Tome cHafuKeHO caJIKql(eii. HO «ooJlee cJla60t1:» Ii OHa «Bbl-
pamaeTCH JUfllib B TOM, '!TO IfU1OJ1HeIDIe no TaROMY 06flsaTeJIbCTBY
HMeeT lOpU1t11'lecKy1O CHJ1Y» (He MomeT 6bITb I'Icrpe6osaHO 06paTHo).316
Ho B03ID1RaeTBOnpoC -MmKHOJII1C'1HTaTb caHKl.\l1ei1 IIOCJIe,JJ;CTBI'Ie. KO-
TOpoe peaJIJ13yeTcl1 He B cJI}"1ae Hel-iCnOJlHeJlI1JI o6flsaTeJ1bcTBa, a B TOT
MOMeHT. Korp,a OHO 11CIIOJIHReTCH?
Ha MOM B3r.1lJlA KOHe<iHO, o6flsaTeJlbCTBO RaIl: TaKOsoe He npeKpa-
llIBeTCH, nOCKOJlbIl:Y 11CTe'IeHJ1e CpOIta p,aBHOCTl-I He HBJ1.f1eTCfl cnOCOOOM
npeKpameID:!fl o6fl3BTeJIbcTsa. TaKoe 06flsaTeJIbCTBO JIl1llib nepexo)J;HT
B pa3PH,D; TaK HaTypaJlbHbIX o6fl3BTeJIbcTs. Kor)J;a o6H-
3BHHOCTb ,l\OJDKHHKa nepe,!\ Kpe,!\HTOpOM He npeKpaI4BeTCH, HO Kpe,l{l1-
TOp He MOJiteT npe,lI"bflBIITb K,l\OJDKtiliKYIiCK06 IicnOJIHeHI1l1.
_161_
,[(eiic"fB)'HJlIJ;l1i1 fpam,!\aHcKJ-rl;i Ko,i:\eRC P4:I npe,n;yCMaTpHBaeT pa:3-
J1W1Hhle 4>oPMhI OTBE"I'CTBelll1OCTI1. 0me-remeIrn0CTb MOmE'T HacrynaTb
B 4>oPMe B03Mell\ffiJfH yDbITKOB (CT. 15 rK P4:1), yn.rraTbi
(cT.330 rKP4:», yn.rraTblnpOl,\eHTOB3anOJlb3OBaHJle ,i:\ ICpe,l:\-
CTBaMtf B COOTBeTC'I13IDI co CT. 395 rK P4:> If TaR AaJlee. HeIOCYI'OpUe J13
nepeoruCJleHHhIX 4>oPM arBeTCTBeHlIOCT yme 6bIJllf 3aTPOH)'Tbl B npe-
Abl,!lJll\eM naparpaq:.e, I1OCt\OJ1bK}' CT. 12 I'K P4:> OTHOCJ.1T TaIDIe q:.opMbl
OTBeTCTBeHHOCTJ.1 KaK yDbITKOB If yn.rnrry HeycToiiIa'! If K
cI!OCOOaM3a bl C»iXnp3.B.
Cpe,!J;l1 nepetn1CJEHHhIX 4>oPMOTBeTCTBeI1lJJC occ6oe MecTO 3aIDtMa-
eT BOOMern;eID1e yDbITKOB. 06yc..0cI!.neH0 3TO TeM, 'l!'O HID16o.nee CJll.\E'CT-
BeHHbIlV! If pacnpoc'I'paHeHHbIM HapyweHJ1H OOH3f«eJ1bCTB
RB.I1HlOT('JI y6b1TID1 BI311,!Iy 3TOro ;IJ,aHllaH 4>oPMa OTBeTCTBeIDIOCTl-f IDfeeT
oOl.I.\ee 3Ha'leHl1e If np!1M:eHHeTCJI BO Bcex CJIy'1aHX HapyrneHJ1H oM3a-
TeJlbCTB, ecJU1 3aKOHOM I1J1I1 ,W)fOBOpOM He npe.i:IyCMO'Ipe lfHoe (CT. 15
rKP4:I), TOrJ-l1l KaKJq>yTI1e 4>qJMhIOTBeTCTBeHHOCTI1IfC!lOJ1b3JIOTCH JIilllIb
B CJIy'laHX, npJIMO npe.n;yCMOTpeHHbIX 3aKOHOM J1.ID1 ,l.\OroBOpoM, J1 nOOTOM)'
BOOMelL\eHl1e yDbITKOB lW1pOKO paCIIpClCTpaHeHO TaIOKe J-I B c.rryqae Hapy-
IlIeHJ1fl KOpIIq)3TIIBHbIX OTHOllieHID1.
YCTaHOBJIeHlt:e oOH3aHHoCThl B03Mel.I.\€HIDI yDbrrKOB npeCJIe,n;y€T
IfBOCID1TaTeJ1bH.YlOL\eJlJ1.l\oMneHcaI.{l1OHHRHCOCTO-
1fT B B03MelqEHID'1 cTopoHe HaHeCeHHOllJ YILlep5a nyreM BOCCTaHOBJ1e-
HID! HapYW€HHbIX I!paB If IlH'!"epecoB. a BOCIDITaT€JlbHaH no\5ym,[laeT K
ce:6.mcJ.l.\eJIIUO X03SII"ic-rneHHJii ,[IIt:!cqmIJrnHbl
O,i:\HaKO, KaK C'-Il1TaeT B.4> IIonoHJ.\onyJlo, «:3Ta caHKL\I1H He BCer,l.\a
3cjxpeK'TImHa, I1OCl\OJ1bKY He BCHKoe H3pyrneHl1e OOH3aTeJlbCTBa npJ.1-
BO).\WI' K B03H1'1KHOBeH1flO y6brrKOB, a Hepe,l:\lOO B03IDIKIlII1e BCJle,lJ;CTBYle
HapyrneHJ.1H OOH3aTeJlbCTBa yDbITIDI He nO lOTCH TO'-JHOMY onpe,l:\e-
Jlem-no. IIpJ1 TaKl1X I1OCJIeJ1C'!'BH Hapyrnemrn oOH3aTeJlbCTBO OKa3bl-
BaeTCH HI1'-JeM IfHbIlV! He 06ecne'leHO KpoMe KaK IJ03MC:»KlI)CT rocy-
AaPCTBeHHoron KJK'I!OJ1HeIDIlOeroBHaType.»317
IIo,lJ; y6bITKaMlf nOIDIMalOTCR KOTOpbIe JiIfQO, 'Ibe np3BO
HapyrneHo, npoII3BeJIO I1J1I1 AOJI:)KHO 6YAeT np<M3BeCTI1 AJlH Bocc-raHOB-
JleHIDI HapymeH1J'Jro npaBa, YTpaTa 11J1Y1 nOBpem,l:\eHl1e ero JlMYILIeCTBa
(peaJlbHbIi1 YILlep6), 3 T3roKe HenOJ1Y'-1ellllbIe ,lJ;OXO,l:\bl, KOTOpbIe 3TO JiI1-
1.\0 I1O.JIy'IIIJ!O 6bl npl1 ofJu'-JHux yCJlOBIDIX rp3m,!.\3.HCKOro o60para. eCJlI1
6bI ero npaBO He 6blJ10 HapyrneHo (ynyw,emIaR BbII'O,IJ;a)
rpaJKA3HCKI1i1 KO,i:\eKC 3aKpel!JlHeT npl1Hl.\11TI nOJIHOrO BG3MeII.\eIfWI
yDbl'rKOB. Ho H J1CKJ!IO'<i€HMe VI3 3TOro npaBI1JIa - B03MO:>K-
HOCTb ycT8HOBJIeHWI 3aKOHOM IfJIJ1 ,l.\OroBOpOM I3O:3M€IQeIlliH yDbITKOB B
orpaHWleHHoM pa3Mepe. IIpaso Ha nOJIHOe B03M€lI\€HI'Ie yDbITKOB MO-
:JKeT 6blTb 0Ip3HI1'IE'H0 nyreM:
-162-
a) YCTaHOBJIeHI-IH J1CKJllO'lJITeJIbHoi1: HeycIUiUrn:, CBepx KOTDpofi
y6bITlGf 6bITb B3blOGlHbI He Moryr;
6) OrpaIDNeHWI pa3Mepa 0"I13eTC'fBelIH CWm!OCTblO npep;MeTa
;D;oroBopa (CTO 1MOCTbIO roD'I'BeTC'l'B)i1: ycnyrl-l);
B) orpaHI1'IeIDlfl y6bITKOB TOJIbKO peanbHbIM yrnep-
6oMJ1 B3bICKaIDfHyrrylL\eHllOfiBbITO,qbI;
r) BBe;!J;eHJ1eM onpe.J:J;E'JIeHlloro cyMMOBOI'O npe;D;ena 0TBeTCTBeHH0C-
TJ1, KOTOpbrn: YCTaHaBm-maeTCR no-pa3HOM)'
B aK OHepHbIX 'ialL\e BCero II: cy&beKTaM npaBOOTHO-
llleHJ.-ri1: npHMeHReTCH HMeHHO OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb B IPoPMe B03M J.-1R
y6bITKOB, npH'1eM HaW5OJ1ee pacnpOCTpaHeHbI B cyJ!€6Hoi1 npaKTIiKE'
J'lCKJ1 II: 'LIIeHaM COBeTa AI1PeKWPOB, ew-rHOJIJ1'llfoM)' J1CrI01IHJ1TeJIbHOMY
opra11Y. BpeM€HHOMY €;!J;l1HOlIJf'II1C1M}' Hcr1O.1JHJ'JT€JIbHOMY opraHY, 'lJI€-
HaM KOJIJIeI'l18JIbHoro HCrlOJIHJtTeJIbHOIO opraHa 06lL\€CTBa. yrIpaBJIJIK)-
lL\ei1: OpI'aHH3aL(l1HHnJ1 MY Ha OCHOBaHl1H CT. 71 3aKOHa
«06 aKW10HepHbIX . YKa3aHHble JIJ1Q8 ,l\OJDKHbI ,l\eiiCTBO-
BaTb B J1HTepecax 06lL\€CTBa. ocyw,eCTB.IDITb CBOH npaBa J'I J1CIIOJiHJITb
06J'I3aHHOCTJ1 A06pocoBec1m J'I pa3yMHO
TpY,l\OBOi1: Ko.n;eKc P<1:I OT 30 ,l\eKaOpH 2001 r. NQ 197-413 (]J;anee -
TK P<1:I) TalOKe ycraHaBJIi'1Bae MaTepJ1aJibH)'lO OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb py-
KfJI30WrreJIH OpraID:I3aL(l1J1. B COOTBeTCTBIDI co CT. 277 TK P<1:I PYKOBO-
,IJ;I1'Tenb opraID:I3aQJ1J1 HeceT nOJIHYID MaTepJ1aJibH)'lO OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb
sa npIDmfi,l\e YIl\ep6, npWIHH€HHblii: orraHl13aQIDl
B CJI)"IaHx, n:pep;ycMOTpeHHhIX 4Je.n;epanbHbIM 3aKOHOM, PYKOBO)J;M-
TeJIb o(I'8 B03Mell.\8eT opraHJ13aQJ1J1 y6bITKJ1, nplI'DtHeHHbIf'
eromlHOOllhlM1f .r\effcTBI.u1MH. IIpJ13WM paC'1eTy6bITlWB -
eTCH B COOTBeTCTBJ111 C HOpMaI\rn. Ipa:m,!\aHCKm!
IIpJ1 OIIp".r\€JIf'HJfiI OCHOBaIIHff J1 pa3Mepa OTBeTCTBeHHOCTI1 'UleHQB CO-
BeTa ,lII1peKTOpoB (Ha6.rrlOJl8Te.lIbHoro COBeTa), e)\I1fID.III>1'ffioro J1CIIOJIHJ1-
TeJIbHDrOopraHa 06IQeCTBa (,D;I1p€KTOpa, reH€paJlbHoro)J;l-lpeKTOpa) 11 (J1J1III)
'UleHOB 1\TJJ1.I1(flraJIbH(I'() J1CIT()J1IDIT€JIbHOI'O opraHa OOl1\€CTBa (npaBJleIDIJ1,
,D;upe m), a paBHO ynp opaHJ13aWIR Jf.III1 ynpa ero
;D;0JDKHb! 6bITb npl-fHRTb1 so BllI1Malll1e OOb!'lHb1€ yc.noBJ.-1R .r\eJIOBOro o6opo-
Ta J1 Jrnbleo6cTOsrreJIbCTBa, m! e 3Ha'leHl1e AJUI.r\e.na.
IIo 3TOMY BOIIpOcy J1. EpaY,l\e IIOJJaraJI, 'iTO HeIIpaBJlJIbHoe Y'!J1TbI-
BaHJ1e 6y KOMMep'IecROj:f ROIJ'HOmaypH caMO no ce6e He MO-
:IKeT 6bITb OTHeceHO K H€,l\OCTaTO'iHOJI aa60TJD1BOCTH 11 He MOJoKeT no-
Me'll> OTBeTCTS€HHOCTJ1 3a np 1'llmeHHbI€ 3TIiM y6bITKJ1, O;!J;HaKO
He;!J;OCTaTO'1HOe 3HaIDI€ .r\eJIa J1 HeOllb1THOCTb He 0CB<:J6rJm.n;ar (Y1' OT-
BeTCTB€HHOCTIi.:B1B
-163-
H€JJ;OIlYCTHMO B03JImKeHll€ OTSeTCTB€HHOC'n1 Ha n€pe'fl1CJleHHbIX
Jll1lI 3a TaRot:!: y ep6, KOTOpbIf! OTHOCl1TC.R K KaTeropl1l1 HOpMaJlhHoro
npe}J;IIpI1HI1IIffiTeJIhCKOro pl1CKa.
YI1J1aTa HeycroRroi TaIOKe fIBJI.ReTCJ'I o.n;HOii 1-13 caMbIX pacnpOCTpa-
HelllihIX 4>oPM 0TBe'I'CTI!eHHf B rpam.rw.HCKOM 06opcrre. Heycrru:1:locJjj
(nrrpa4JoM, neHet:!:) npl13HaeTCH onp eHHaH 3aROHOMJ1IDI ,l:\OrooopOM
,l:\eHemHaJ'I C)'MMa, KOTOPYID ,l:\OJImHJ1K 06.R3aH yrmaTJ1Th Kpe;zu.-rropy B
CJ1y«aeHe:!1CnOJ1Hem1Hl1Jm :!1CIIOJIHeIBlHof5roaTe.m,cr-
113., B '1aCTHOCTi-'I, B CJ1y«ae npocpo'lKI1I1CllOJIH€ffiIR. no 'I'peOOBaHI1IO 06
yrmaTe Heycrotba1 Kpe,l:\I1TOp He 06.R3aH ,l:\OKa3b1BaTb npW1M1!eHJle €MY
y6hlTKOB('1.1 CT. 330 rK P<1:I)
HeyCTOfuta npe,!\CTaBJIJ'leT co60i1: .r:\eHemHyKJ c)'MMY, I1C'illC.J!€HH)
CJle,nyroILU1M cnoco6oM:
a)nyreMOIIpe.l:\e.nemm OTHOllleHl1HKcyMMeHeJl!CnOJl-
HeHHoro Jl!J1I1 HeHa,JJ,.1Iemall{e J1CnOJlHeHHoro OOH33.TeJIhCTBa;
6) nyreM YCTaHOBJIeID1H npcm;errr3 OT cyMMbI H€CBO€BpeM€HHOro J1C-
nOJlH€HWI OOH33.T€JIhCTBa 3a .r:\eHb npocpo'lKJ1.
B llOC.J1€,I:I,HeM CJIy«ae OO'beM B3b1CKaHWI onpe,!\enJ'leTCH nOJlHhlM
CpoKOM npocpo'IXl1 BIIJIOTb 11.0 HB)I)I€:1Kall\ero J1CnOJIH€HWI OOH33.TeJlb-
cTsaJIJ1f'io 33.KOHOM I1JII1,l\oroBOpoM TCHnpe11.eJlbH3.H cyM-
Ma B3hICKaHJ1fl.
CJI€,n;y€T pa3JIl1'IaTb cnoc06b1 B3b1CKaHWI HeycTOflKl'l. 00IW1M HBJIH-
eTCH npeTeH3110HHO-J1CKOBOi'i cnoc06, T.€. B3bICKaHJf€ nyreM HanpaBJIe-
HI1.R npeTeH3ill1, a 3aTeM npe,q'bHBJleHJ1fl J1CKa. Ho B C.rry<mHX, npHMO
np€.!IYCMurpeHHbIX aaKOHOM, 11.OnyCKaeTCH 6ea:n:JpHOe B3b1CKaHl1€ H€-
YCTOMKI-1 CTOpOIIOfi no 11.OfOBOpy nyreM HaIIpaBJleHI-1H 'I'pE'6cmaHIm B
oalIK. OopaTHoe B3HCJI'.alrne Henpam1J1bHO Cnl1CaHHOM Heycrotirol B Ta-
ID1X CJlyqa.RX eTCf! B cy,l\eOHOM nOp.R,!\Ke.
HID16oJ1ee pacnpocTpaHeHHhIM BI1,I10M HeycwHrol .fIBJ1J1eTCJ'I 3a'leT-
HaR HeyCTOfuta, Korl1,a y6bITK11 B3b1CKI1BaIaI'CH B 'laCTI1, He IIOIqJblTIJii
H€}'C'I'OiiKofi (ao33.l.Il 'I. 1 CT. 394 rKP<1:I). 3alwHoM I1JII1,l\oroBopcNTaK-
me MOfyr OhITb npeJ1YCMOTpeHhI CJIy«aJl!'
- KOr,/:\3. ,IJPnyCKa€TCH B3bICKaHJ1e TOJlbKO Heycroiim, HO He yUbITKOB
(JI!CKJlIO'II1TeJlhHaR HeycroiiKa);
-rwfJt<l yUbITKI1 MOryr OhITb B3HCIGUlliI B nQJIHUM cyMMe CBepxHey-
c'IOibm (llrrpa4>HaH Jl!J1I1 K)'MY.mrIHBHafI HeycTOfuta);
- Kor,l\a no BhlDOPY Kpe,!\I1TOpa MOfyr OhITb JIJ1f'i0 Hey-
CTOllm, JIJ1f)o yUbITKI1 (aJlbTepHaTI1BH8.H HeyC1'Ofuta).
YILJ1aT3 HeycroiiKI1 B aKQJWHepHOM npase npl1MeHJ'leTC.R, eCJ111 31'0
I1p.RMO VCMOTp€HO ,lJ;OroBOpoM 0 C03,I\aHIOf 06 ecTBa npJl! Hel1C-
nOJlHeHJl!l106.H3aHHOCTet:!: nOonJlaT€ aKJ:U1i'i aKJ:U10Hepa m. TepMI1H «He-
ycroima» BCTpe'lae1'CJ'I B 3aKoHe «00 aKl,U'IOH€PHbIX 06JQeCTBaX» Bcero
-164-
O.n;l1H pa3 - B CT. 34 3aKoHa, KOTOpaH YCTaHaBJIMBaeT ee HMeHHO B)'Ka-
aaHHOM CJI)"Iae. IIpe;:1C'T8BJ1RE'TC51, 'lTO I'ICIIDJ1h3OBaHilIe 3T0i14x:JPMbl OT-
BeTCTBeHHOC'"IH B03MO:IKHO J1 B J1HblX cJIY'ffiHx, npe.n;YCMOTpeHHblX YCTa-
80M 06.[4€CTBa JIHfjo APyrnMI-I J:I<Ea11bHbIMI-f HOpMaTJfBI1HMH aKTaMI-I.
CJIepYeT OTMeTWI'b, 'ITO O'!eHb CXOmyro C JreYCTOI1Rm1 npl'lpo.n;y J1Me-
wr npoQelITbI, Ha.'lJ1CJIHeMbIe B ('()()'fIJe'l'C1 CO CT. 395 rR P<P. 3T0 on-
pe.n;eJIHeTCH pH.n;OM cJIe,II}'KIJ.J.tI-IX npH'!J1H.
B COOTBE'TCTBID'! C n. 7 IIoCTaHOBJIeH11H lI.n:eH)'Ma I3epxtmHcru cYl1ll J1
lI.n:eH)'M3. BblCwero Ap6wrpa:lKHoro CYl1ll P<1:I OT 8 oKTmpH 1998 r.
N213j14, €CJD1 onp COrJ:IaCHO CT. 395 rR P<1:I pa3Mep (CTaBl<a)
npoQeH'fOB, ynJIa'll1BaeMbIXnpl1Hei1UIOJIH€H1'D'1l1J1tf npocpo<rne J1cnOJIHe-
HI1H ,/J;eHe:IKHoro 06J13aT€JIbCTBa, HEHO HeCOpa3M€p€H TDCJIe,J:I;CTEI'IHM npo-
cpo'lKJ:! ilICllOJ1HeHI1.fI ,lJ;eHemHoro 06J13areJIbcTBa, cy11., )"IJ1TbIBaH KOr.meH-
cawroHH)'lO npl1po.n;y npoQeHTOB, IlfI'1MEHJITeJIbHO K CT. 333 :E\o.n;eKca
BnpaBe )'MeHbIlMl'b CTaBKy npOl-\eHTOB, B31>K'KJIBaeMbIX B CBR3I1 C npo-
cpo'lKOi1l1clIOJIHeHI1H 06H3aTeJIbCTBa. 3)-\ecb HaJII1QO IIpl1Me-
HeHJlle CT. 333 rRP<1:I no aHaJIOri1l1, B COOTBeTCTBJ1JII C KOTOpoi1 npeJJYCMa-
'IpI1BaeTCJ1 npaso CYAa Ha )'MeHbWeHl1e HeCOpa3M€pHOi111OC.1"1e,QCTBJ
HapYWeHl1H 06H3aTeJIbCTB Heyc'IU'lKx
B COOTB€TCTBIDI C 'I. 2 CT. 330 rK P<1:I Kpe,!\WI'op He BlIpase -rpe6oBaTb
ynJIaTbi H€ycTOI1KI1, eCJIl1 ,/J;OJI:lKHMK He HeceT 0TBeTCTBeHH0CTI aa He-
I1CnOJIHeHl'le I1JII1 HeHa)\JIe)tGllQee I1cnoJIHeH1te 06H3aTeJIbCTBa. ECJD1 me
)'Ka3aHHaH s ,/J;orOBope C)'MMa npeJ:lCTaBJIHe'f c06oi1 npOl-\eHTbl no
CT_ 395 rR P<1:I, TO B <.mKOHe HeT OTseTa Ha BOIIpOC 0 ee B3bICKaHl111 lIpl1
OTCYTCTBI1I1 OTBeTCTBeHHl:Jcr'l1 ,/J;OJDKHI1Ka. CornaCHO n. 5 BbIIlIeynoMH-
HYToro IIOCTaHOBJ1€HI1H lI.n:eHYMa CYAaM cJIeA)'eT )"II1TbmaTb, '1TO B CO-
fJTI3eTC"IBIfil C n. 3 CT. 401 rR P<1:I OTcyTC"IBl1e Y ,/J;0JI»crrnKa ,/J;eHemHbIX
cpe,!\cTB, He06xo.zI,1fMHX,IJ;JIH ynJIaTb! ,/J;OJIra no 06J13aTeJIbCTBY, CBH3aH-
HOMY C 0cytl-\t'CTBJI€H1I2M11M npep;npl1Hl1MaT€J1bCKOJI A€fl'I'{'JlbHCiC'I'>'!, He
HBJIHeTCH OCHOBaHl1eM tIJIH IH ,/J;0JDKHI1Ka OT ynJIaTbi npo-
QeHTOB, npe CT. 395 rR P<1:I. TaKJ1M 06pa30M, BblCWl1e
cY,lJ;e6Hble J1HCTaHQI1I1 CO'Ul11 B03MOmHbIM lIpl1 B3bICK8.H1'III npoQeHTOB
no CT. 395 rR P<1:I IIpI1MeHI1Tb IIpI1HL\mI, n3J1O)f(€HHbrl1: B n. 3 CT. 401, - B
06J13aTeJIbcTBax, B03IDIKl1IdX J13 npe.r:u1pHHHMaTeJIbClWA AeHTeJIbHOC-
TI1, ,/J;OJDKHl1K lIpl1 CJI)"IatbioM HeJICIIOJ1HeHID:! 06J13aTeJIbCTBa 06H3aH
ynna'lI1BaTb npoQelITbI. A 31'0 03Ha'iaeT, '1TO B TaKI1X 06R3aTeJlbCTBax
AOJDKHl1K He 06H3aH ynna'll1BaTb npOQeHTbI, eCJ1J1 06J13aTeJlbCTBO He
ItCIIOJIHeHO BCJIe.l-\CTBl1e HenpeD.l\OJIIDIIii CI1JIbI, a B 06J13aTeJIbCTBaX,
B03IDIKWIIX He )13 npep;npJ1HilIMaTeJlbCKi1X OTHOWeHmt, AOJI:>K!U1:K He
06fl3aH ynna'll1BaTb npoQeHTbI, ecJIiII 06J13aTeJIbCTBO He HCnOJIHeHO He
no erDBI1He J13Bb1IlJ€J HHoro CJIe.n;yeTBbIBO)-\, '1TOecJD1 AOJImHl1K
-165-
He HeCeT OTBeTCTBeHHOCTI1 no CT. 401 fRP<1:I, TV HI1 HeyCTOfuta,1ill npo-
lIeHTbI no CT. 395 fK P<1:I B3bICKaHI-fi{) He nO,IJ.JIemaT.
BOOOTBeTCTBItJ'Icn.6II II.rreH)'M8.NQI3/14BJJ;eHem-
HbIX 06H3aTeJ1bCTBaX, B03H KWI1X Jl3 AorOBopOB, B 'IaCTHOCTJI. npe.D:Yc-
Ma'IplffiIDOl1V1X 06fl3allllocTb AOJJmHl1Ka nprn:13BeCTIf or1J1aTY TOsapoB,
paEioT = YCJIy1' JIJ1fj0 yn.rraTl1Tb narryqellllble Ha ycJ10BIUIX B03BpaTa
AeHemHbIe cpe,!\CTBa, Ha npOCpO'leHH}'1O yn.naTO C)'MMY nO,IVIe:maT Ha-
'fI1CJ1eHH1O IIpOQeH'IH Ha OCHOBaH1'DI CTaTbliJ 395 Ko,!\ero:a. 3aKoHoM nliJ-
60 cornaUEHJIeM CropOH MomeT 6bITb npe.D:YcMo'IpeHa 06J'f3allllOCTb
AOJD1\.lfillKa yn.na'IIiJBaTb Heycrotmy (neHIiJ) npliJ npocpo'lKe HCI1OJ1Hemf.fI
AeHemHoro 06H3aTeJlbCTsa. B nOJl06HbIX cJlyqaJIX cY11Y CJ1ep;yeT cxo-
AJilTb 3 TOro, 'ITO Kpe,!\I1TOp BnpaBe npE'JJ:l>HBI'ITb -rpe6uBamle 0 npliJMe-
Hem-1M OJUIOti J13 3T1iJX Mep, He AOKa3bIBaH iPaKT8 1-'1 pa3Mepa yfu.rrJooB.
nOHeceHHbIX 11M npliJ HeJ1:CIIOJiHeHI1JI! JJ;eHemHoro 06J'f3aTeJibCTBa, eCJIJII
HHoe npJ'IMO He npeJIyCMO"Ip€HO 3aKOHOM J1JIJ1 JJ;orOBopoM. TaKJ1M 06pa-
30M, HaJlIiJL\O CXO.I\CTBO CO CT. 330 fK P<1:I, YCTaHaBJlJlIBalOIl\ei1, 'ITO no
'I'pe60BaHl1IO 06 yruraTe HeycTOfurn Kpe,lJ;l1'rop He 06H3aH JJ;OKa3bIBaTb
l1pWDIH€Hl1e eM)' y15bITKOB.
O;:J;HaKO B HaCTOHIl\ee BpE'MH 3T1iJ npoL\eHTbI no CT. 395 fR P<1:I He
npliJ3HaHbI pa3HOBJ Heyc-roihaL 319
YIIJIaTaIIpoL\elITOBnOCT.395rKP<P3aHeHCJI)JIlI£ffi!eJJ;eHemHoroofuI-
3aTeJIbCTBa 06bI'IHO IIpMMeHHeTCH B c.rry'-ffie HEl1CII0JIHEHI1H aKL\I1OHepHbIM
06mecrnoMBcpoKo6.H3aHHDcrI1nOBbIIIJI3.Te aMAI'1EI
B CJIyqae Hel1cnpaSHOCTI1 aK4J1OHepa B 06J'f3aTeJlbCrne no OIIJI3Te
aKL\l1 06meCTBOM npl1MeHHIOTCH 11 onepaTImHble caHKL\I1IiJ B B>1)\e 113'b-
RTI1H H€OIlJ13'IeHHbIX aKL\l1 y aKL\l10Hepa, 'ITO BJleqeT:J13MeHeH e ntroo
npeKpameHliJe OTHOIIIemrn C HI1M. 3Ta Mepa npeJIyCM01J>E'Ha CT. 34 3a-
KOHa «06aKl1JlOHepHbIX ».
KpoMe TOro, CT. 2 3aKOHa {{06 aKLIl10HepHbIX o6Il\ecrnax» YCTaHaB-
.mrnaeT, 'ITO a eJThl, He nOJiHOCTbIO OIlJ13TIfBllII1e aKL\I1H, Hecyr CO-
pHYJOorneTCTBeHHOCTb n006H3aTenbCTBaM CTsa Bnpe,lJ;enax
Heonna<i€HHOJ1'lacn1 CTOI1MOCTIf npl1HaAJIemaIql1X 11M aKL\l1H.
B J1I1TepaType JJ;aBHO Be;:J;yTCH CIIopbJ O'I'HOCI'1TeJIbO OAHOro 113 OC-
HOBHbIX IIpJIHl\l1I1OB aKL\l10HepHOro npasa - orpaHWlellllO (YI'BeTCT-
BeH1IO('TI:l aKL\l10HepOB no AOJlraM TaR, saIIpIiJMep, eme
nIL fyccaI«>BCKI1ii npeAJIaraJl Henpl1MeHHTb 3TOTnpI1HL\I1IIK06meCT-
saM C MaJlbIM KOJlJ1'IeCTBOM aKlIJK!HepoB (5 MeHee). OH nOJlaraJI, 'ITO
npliJ CTOJib OIpaHWIeHHOM COCTaBe K3:!K,l1;bli1113 aKllMOHepOB He MmKeT
He IlpIIHI'1M8Tb J:J;eHreJlbHOrO yqaCTIlJ'f B 3aBeJI;bIBaHI1JI! 11 ynpaBJI€HI1J1
n:peJIIIPlm'I'I'1eM I1JUI JKe B Ha6.mo.n;eHIDl 3a era pa3Bl1TliJeM 11 HaIIpaBJIe-
HI1eM. Ko.nb CROpO JKe BCH He60JJbIlJaH fpyniia 3KL\110HepOB, npeACT3a-
JIJ'fIOI.l\l1X C06010 aKL[IIOHepHoe ofuJecrso, IlpHHJ1M3eT HerJOcpeACTBeH-
-166-
Hoe yqacTl1e B ynpaBJIeHl1J1 yc-rpOeHHbIM I1IIrn npeWIPl1HTl1eM. TO WUI
ycraHOBJIeHlm CI'p<i.HIf"IeHHOti I1X 0'IBE'TC'113eHH1 no OOH3aTeJIbCTBaM
l1MeeTCR CTOJib me MaJIO OCHOBaHl1ti, EaK J1 .wm ycTaHfJBJIeHl1H TaIWti
:me OrpaHJrIeHHOti OTBeTCTBeHHocrn Bcex OT,IJ;eJlbHbDI: npe,lJ;!1pI1ID1MaTe-
Jleft ABTOp BeChMa HeraTIfBHO arnocJfJ1Cf1 K 06ntecTBaM C TaKI1M MaJibIM
'lJ1CJIOM aRqMOHepCJE, C<rnTaH. 'ITOaKQl10HepHhle OOIIleCTBa co CneKYJlH-
TIfBHbIMI-I LleJ1JlMi1 KaK pa3 J1 C03,!\alOTCf! B TaROM cocraBe. 06II1ecma
:me, Y"pemAa,eMhle 1J,JIR OOl1teCTBeHHoti nOJIh3hI. no em MHeIDIlO, ,lJ;OJIm-
HbI 6bITb MHOI'O'II1CJIeHHbL 320
IIo.zJJ6m,re CJIy<Iai1 cy6CI-W--IapHoti 0TBeTCTBeHH0CTH aKLIHOHepOB
co,!\epmaTCR B n :3 CT. :3 3aKOHa «00 aKqMOHepHbDI: », CO-
I'JlaCHO IID'IOpOii eCJII1 HeCOCTOJITeJibHo:.-n. (6aHKpoTCTBO) 06II1€Cma BhI-
3BaHa,lJ; ( ) ero aKqMOHepOB J1J1i1.J\PYrl"IXJli1L1,
KOTOpbIe l1MelOT npaBO ,l\aBaTh WIH 06meCTBa yKa3aIDIH
JIHfjo HHhIM 06pa30M l1MelOT onpe.D;e.mITb 1"1'0 AefiCTBml,
TO Ha )'Ktl3aHHbDI: aKLIHoHepoB JfJ1J1,l1pyrJ1X JlI1IJ; B CJI)"Iae He,!\OCTaTOq-
HOCrn J1MYI1I;eCTBa 06Il\ecTBa MOmeT 6bITb B03JIC:DKeHa c:yt5ormrapHaH
OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb no 1"1'0 061133.TeJlbCTBaM. K 'II1CJly JII1Ll, Ha KOTOpbIX
MomeT 6bITb B03JI1:Dt!EHB Cy6Cl1,!J;I1apHaR OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb no 001133.-
TeJlbCTBaM IlJ!I'13H8HHOI' H€COCTOJITeJIbH Kl(nWrIeCKOI'O .JIJma" OT-
HOCIITCfI, B 'laCTHOCTI1, JI1111P, l1MelOIl\ee B cd5c'rBeHHocnI J1Jll1 ,l\OBepM-
TeJIbHOM ynpaBJIeHl111 ROH"1pOJIbHbIit: IIaKeT aKUl1ti aKlll10HepHOro
06meCTBa 11 TOM)' Hb1€.S21
B HaCTomu;ee BpeMii B03MomHOCTh nOJilIOro Henpl1MeHeHJ1jJ np -
na 06 mpaHK<IeHHoK 0TBeTCTBeHH0CTJ mcqMOHepOB 113BeCTHa npaKTHKe
aHTJIO-aMeP CI1CTeMhI npaBa J1 HMeHYeTCfI OHa «piercing the
corporate veil», «lifting the veil», 'ITO ,lJ;0CJ10BHO 03Ha'laer «ClUITl1e KOp-
mpaTJ1BHoti: BYaJIl1» 322 tPaK'l'l1'1ecRJI npl1 npHMeHelDlJ13TOti: npol\e hI
HI'HOpJrpye'TCJ1lOp ecK<U1 JII1'IHOCTh KOMIIamrn, ee caMOCTOf!'I'eJI
HI1e RaK cy&beKTa nproJa. 3m IIpJIJ;e.nypa «nOJIIDITIDI KOp-
mpaTJ1BHoti: BYaJIl1» J1CI1OJlh3}'€'I 06h1'n10 B CJIe;:Iy1Olll;l1X CJIJ'laRX:
- Kor,!\a cy,lJ; npl1 pernemrn Bonpoca 06 0TBe'I'C'I'BEfl J1rH0PHJ>Y-
eT oUocoI'ineHHbrl1: npaBoBoiil xapaRTep lOpIl,l\I'1'i€CKKX JlWL(, BXO,D,HlQ>IX B
XOJ1)I,l1HI' J1J1i1 KopnopaqMlO, J1CXOWl J13 npi1Hl\J1!1a «e.zU1Hoti: :3IWlIDMIf'1€-
CKOtie J1B03JIaraeTCYfBE'TCTBeHHOCThcaMOCTOf!'l'eJIHOrolOpM-
AWIeCIWI'O Jll1L\a Ha ,l\pyrn:e lOpl1,!\WIeCKI1e JII1lla, KOTOpbIe BXO,!\HT B
yKa3BHHoe o6pa30BaIDIe;
- Kor,!\a cy,l\ npl1 perneHI1I1 BOnJX>Ca 06 0TBeTCTBeHH0CTH KlpJIJ:v:I'Je-
CKOro JII1lla CYfCTynaeT CYf AOK'i'pI1HbI Orpa1iWi€HJIfI OTBeTCmeHHOCTI1
)"-ffiCTIDIKOB 11 B03JIaraeT OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb no ,!\OJITaM IqJJfJ];W-IeCKOfO
.JIJma,Haero)"JB.CTHI1KOB;
-167-
- KOr.r<a cy,l:\ npl1 perneHI1I1 BOnpOCa 06 OTBeTCTBeHHOCTI1 IDpJI,l:\INe-
CKOro ..rnma B03naraeT OTBeTCrneHHOCTb Ha ero OpraHbl ynpaBJleHl1.f1,
KOTOpbIe Mor)'Tcyrn;eCTBOBaTb KaK ID:!Qa - pyKOBOJJ;I1TeJI
TaK I1lOp1f.!1;K'1ecKJJe JI - ynpaBJ1.fIJOll.\I1e OpraHJ13aLlI1l1. 323
B 3TI1X CJ1y<ffi.fIX cy11. MDmeT npol1rHopl1pOBaTb OOl1\eCTBO KaK cy6'b-
eKT npaBa 11 B03J10:tKl1Th OTBeTCTBeHHOCTh 3a yObITKI1 opraHI13arvrn Ha
:yKa3aHHbIX cyf)'beKTOB KnaCCl1'IeCKI1M npHMepoMCTaJl cy,D,e6HWi npe-
Lle,!\eHT Jones v. Lipman324, Cyrb KOTOporo COCTO.flJ1a B cJle,!l)'1Ol1\eM.
HeKTO JII1IIMaH 3aKmO'II1J1 C ,l{moHCOM ,l:\OroBOp KynJlI1-nIXJ.JJ .*JI 3eM-
J1J1, a 3aTeM nonbITaJlC.fI }'KJ10Hl1TbC.fI (IT U<.'f1OJIH€l1KfI OO.fl3aTeJIbCTB no
AOroBOpy nYTE'M pen 1 IWMnaHl1I1 J1 nepe,lla'Uf en TIfTYJIa Ha
3eMJUO. CY,l:\ BbIHec peweHI1e 0 IIpI1CY*lleHl1I1 J1CIIUJIH€lU1H B HaType
npOTl-1B JIJ1nMam J1 KOMnaHI1I1, nOCTaHOBI1B, 'l'I'0 co6cTBeHHHK He MO-
:1KeT 1136eiK3.Tb JICIIO.JIH€HI1H OO.fl3aTeJIbCrna nyreM nepe,lla'ffi 3eMJIlil B
KOMilaHmo, K01'OpylO DH KOHTpOJII1pyeT. AneJ1.JLllLll10HHbD1: cyA yK3.3aJ1,
'11'0, KorM npe,!\nOJIafaeTCH HaJIIII<II1£> «4>aca.n:a» MOTHBbI ero «apXl1'1'€K-
TOpOB» MOf)'T J1MeTb 60JIbwoe 3HaqeHI1e J1 'l'I'0 ,l:\DIcrpJ1Ha KopnopaTI1B-
HOn ByaJlH MOJoKeT 6bITb npl1MeHeHa B OTHOweHJm JII1Ila, IIDmpomtpy-
ml1\ero KOMIIaHl1IO, HE'3aBJlCJ1MJ OT TOro, HBJUleTC.fI OHO 4>l13l1'1eCKI1M
J1JIl1mp JII1L\OM.
XOT.fI Hallie 3aKOHO,l:\aTeJlbCTBO J1 co pmJ:n' HeI«JTOpbIe HopMbl,
aHaJIOn1'lHble nOJIOJKeHl1.fIM aHfJIOCaKCOHCKOro 3aKOHOMTeJIbCTBa 0
pacnpOCTpaHeIDIH OTBeTCTBeHHOC'I'l1 06l1\ecTBa Ha ero yqaC"J'HlnroB,
IIpHMeHSleMble npH yKa38HHOl1 npoLle,!\ype «CHJITH.fI KopnopaTHBHOn
ByaJIl1», O,l:\HaKO npH J1X IIpI1MeHeHHH pocclDlcKl1e cy,l:\bl He snpase J1f-
HOpMpOBaTb mpu,I\I1'1ecKYIO J1I1'1HOCTb al\.ltl10HepHoro oOl1\ecrna B OT-
J1J1'1l1e OT aHrJIl1nCKI1X J1 aMepJIIffi.HCK11X cy,!\OB.
B p.fl,!l,e cnY'laeB cornaCHO 3aKOHY «06 aKLIJK!HepHHX
B03MOmHO pacnpoCTpaHeHl1e 0'I'B€'I'CTBeHH0CTJI:! aKL\l-fOHeproro 06l1\ecT-
sa Ha aKLII10HepOB J1JII1 J1HbIX JII1Il (HaIIpl1Mep, n. 3 CT. 3 3aKOHa). O,l:\Ha-
KO 1J,J1.fI 3TOro Heo6xo,!:ulM p.fl,!\ ycnOBHti::
- Hanl1'1l1e y nl1L1a npaBa 11.aBaTb OO.fl3aTenbHbIe 11.n.fl oOlL\€CTB8
yKa3aHI1H jlIJlI1 BO J1HbIM 06pa30M onpe,JJ;enHTb ero ,l:\enCT-
B"".
..: cOBepllJeHl1e COOTBeTCTBymIl.\l1X AeHCTBJDl (6e3'!\eifc'rnIDi), KOTO-
pbIe CBJJ,Af'Te.JrbCTBO 6bl 06 J1X B03Mt.OKHOCTH onpe,JJ;eJUlTb A€iicT-
BI1F! aKlV-fOHepHoro 0611\€CTBa;
- )'MbIcen Ha COBepllJeHl1e 06l1\eCTBoM,n;eHCTBI1H, KOTOpble IIpMBeJIJII
6bl ero K H€COC'I01ITeJIbI1 (6aHKpOTCTBY);
- Hanl1'1l1e npt'lI-1HID-CJ1e.zI,CTBeHR:1ff CB.R311 Mem)Iy B03MCOK11OCTbIO
aKlU'lOHepOB J1JII1l1HblX nl1Ll onpe,!\eJlHTb ,l:\eHCTBI1J1 0611\eCTBa H ,l:\enCT-
-168-
BI1HMJ1 caMoro 06meCTBa, CJIe,I:J;CI'lli KOTDpbIX If HBIDIaC10 HeCOCTOH-
TeJ1bI1OC'Tb (6amq:xrrCTBO), '1TO .fIBJUleTCH 06J'f3aTeJlhH1oIM;
- AJlH IIpIfBJJ€"leHI K OTBeTCTBeHllOCTl1 aKQl10HepoB IfJlJ'! JIPYIHX
JII1It JIMeI<I1tI1X npaBo ,[IaBaT1o 06H3aTenbH1ole,[lJIH 06meCTBa :yKa3aHJ1H,
He06xo He,lJ;OCTaTO'lHOCT1o lfMymecTBa 06IIIeCTBa 1IJ1J1 paC'IeTOB C
paMH.325
nOJlOmeHl1H n. 3 cr. 3 3aKOHa «06 aKlUfOIEPHbIX 0611teCTBax», npe c-
Ma'Ip e B BI>-I,!\e JK.K.I1K1'lE:HH J13 0611tero npam-lJ1a B03MomHOCTb
pac:npocrpatf€HHa a HepoBJII,I:Ip)'I'l1X.IIML\..lfMeIOIQHXnp8BO,u,aBaTb
o6H3aTeJlbHbIe AJIH 0611tecTBa }'1\83aHJIIH JIIJ1JII J-IHbIM 06pa3OM B03MomHOCTb
ollpE',lI;eJUlTh ero,J1ef1cTmm, OCHOBb!B81{JI'CJ1 Ira HOpMax CT. 10 I'K P<P 0 He-
3JIoyrrO'l'p€\5JIeHJllHnpaBOM. TOmeBIIOJIHOWMepeO'lHOCI1T-
CR JII K HOpMaM CT. 63aKOHa «06 06meCTBax», npe.!IYCMaT-
p: B03JIOJKeHl1e CTrBeTCTBeHHOCT }fa OCHOBHoe 0611tecTBO no
QJ.eJiKaM AO'-IepHero, 33.KJOO'IeHHbIM nOCJIe;J;HJ1M BO JIIC!lOJIHeHl1e y1Ca3aH:I>rli
OCHOBHOro 0611tecTBa JII B c.rryqae HECOCTOHTe.JIbH (6aHKpo1'C1'Ba) 11,0-
'1epHero 06meCTBa no BillIe OCHDBHDrO 06mecTBa.
O,lI;HaKO, HecMOTpa Ha TO, '1TO 3aKOHQlIa'I'eJ1bCTB(] npe CM3.TpHBaeT
TaKl1e c.rryqal1 cy6af.n,l1apHow Ul'Be"I'C'TBeHH npaKTI1Ka npl1Bne'le-
HI1H OCHOBHbIX 061l\eCTB K 0'I'B€TC'1'BeHH no 11,0Jll'8M 11,O'IepHI1X B
POCCJ-rn IIpaRnl'lecKl'1 0"I'C)"I'CTBye. 3To CBH3aHO B nepBYJO O'lep€',w, C
He:3alnITepea:E8HHOCTbIO aK4HOHepOB 11,O'IepHI1X 061l-\eCTB JilIIl1poKOW
np8RTI1KOW pacnpoc'IpaHeHl1H TaK H83bIB8eMbIX cxeM «B1oI8011,a aKTH-
BOB» 06Il-\eCTB.
no BOnpocy 0 B03MOJKHOCTI1 npllMeHeHl1H caHK-
QIDi 33. HapyrneHI-UI ell-\e 11.A. noKpOBCKlfl1 OTMe'laJl, '1TO 'lI1CTO JIIMJ'll-1e-
CTBeHllOe B31oICK:nrne He eCTh eJlI1HCTBeHHaH npl1 O B03MO:iK-
lJaa caHKQi1a 06$13aTeJl1oCTBa: «,IJ;eHe»moe B3blCKaHJlle HBnJ'!eTCR
npHMbIM Y eM Kpe,lJ;l1TOpa J11lliIb B TeX cnyqa$IX, r,[le CO-
,lI;epmaHl1e 06R3aTeJlbCTBa COCTOHJIO B onpe.r:\eJleHlIOW .r:\eHeJKHOW cyM-
Me; BO Bcex me OCTan1oH101X OHO CJ1ym11T JII11lJb KOCBeHHbIM cpe,!\CTBOM
AJIH n06Ym.I1emm ,[IOJDKHI-fKa If cypporaTOM IfCI1OJ1HeIDm AJlR Kpe,lJ;l1TO-
pa. ECJ1I1 06H3aTeJl1oCTBO eCT10 np8BO H8 11,61C'rBHe 11,OJI:>KHI1Ka, KOTDpoe
He MomeT COBepIlD1TbC.fI nOMlfMO erOBOnl1, TO BI10JlHe MbICni1M1oI 11 pa3-
Hble APyn-fe cpe,!\CTBa, KOTOp1ole Moryr OKa3aT1o BJllfffiUfe Ira:;rry BOJ1lO
MbiCJUfM8 yrpo38 urrpa$:JM, J1WJHbIM apeCTOM...»326
qTO KaCaeTCF! 06paIJJ;eHl1H B31oICKaHl1H 33. lEItU1OJIl1eHi1e 06J'f3aTeJIhCTB
JII HapyrneHl1e KOpnopaTl1BHbIX OfuI3aHHOC'I'eW }fa JIWlHOCTb 11,D.IIJKlrnKa B
COBpeMeHHOM np8Be, TO TaKaH B03MOiKHOC1'1o CyIQeCTByer JII B HaC"I'OJ'lI.q€e
BpeMH.I\oHe'IHO, HopMbI Ipa:IK,!\aHCKOI'O JII npewIPDnlMaTe.JIbCK1I'O 33.KO-
H011,8TeJIbCTBa He npe.u;y<:Ma'IpIBaKYr JIWlHDW Cfl'BeTCTBeHHOCTI111,OJDKHJ1-
Ka, HeJlCJJOJIHJlBWffO 06H3aTeJIbcTBo, a TalO!re ,QOCJyCTIIBUEro JllHbIe H8py-
-169-
IlIeHWI, o.WIaKOTaKI1e caHK4ID1, npe}:\)'CMaTp: oOpall\eHYIeOTBeT-
CTBeHHOCTI1 HaJIWIHOCTb,lJ;o.nmHI1l\a, CO)1epmaTC$lB HOpMaX -
TIffiHOro H yrorrOBHOro npaBa. 1\ cyfu,eKTaM, )10nyCTmJIID1M HapyrneHYIe
CBOHX B03M»!aD 1e He TOJIbKO rpam,IlaHCKO-
HO Ha.lJ;r'U-IID-ICTpaTImHOflH yroJDI!IDiiorBeTCTBeHHOCTI1.
TaR, nOMMMQ B03M<»KHOCTI:! B3bICKaHIDI yDbITKOB, npwnrneHHbIX aK-
LtI-IDHe(H>MY 06Il\ecTBY I-ICI1OJIIDt'I' opraHOM, CT. 14.211\oAII pop
npe.II.yCMa'Ipl--lBBeT 0TIIE'TC'I'BEff0CTb I1OCJ1e)1Hero B BI-I,t:\e nnpatlJa B pa3-
Mepe )10 )1eCRTI-I MHHI1M8JIbHbIX. pa3M€poB OrIJI3.TbI TPYJ13. H.ID:I ,lJ;I-ICKBaJIY!-
4>I--IKaQWIO Ha CpOKJJ,O TPex JleT 3a HeHaAJ1emaIl\ee ynpaBJIeID1e IOPI-WI-
'leclGlM Jli'lLjOM. IIo)!; TaKI--IM HeH8JtJ1ema ynpaBJIeHYIeM nOll11MaeTCJI
l1On:HOMU'lJ1itnoynpaBJIeHYIlOopraHJ-I3aWleiiBonpeKl-lee
3aKOHHb1M TepecaM H (J-IJIH) 3aKOHHb1M MHTepecaM ee KPe,IU-lTOpa, no-
BJIeKIIIee YMeHbIlIeHJl!e co6c-rBeHHoro Kaill-lTaJIa opraHYI3al{lrn H (H.ID:I)
B03HJt:KHOBeHJt y1)bITKOB. Cyfu,eKTOM HapyIIIeHYIJl MroKeT BbICTynaTb
$13Iif'IecROe JIJ1LIO, 3aID1MaI(Il{ee pyKOBO)J.Hw;yKIlIOJDKHOCTb B KOJIJIern-
8.JIbHOM ItCllO.1IHIITeJ opraHe ynpaBJIeHIDI, ,n;I1peKTDp, yrtpaBJ11nO-
lQI-rl1IOpH.!nI'!eCIDIMJIYIi.IOM, 'lJIeHCOBeTa
I\poMe TOro, CT. 201 YrOJIOBHoro I\OJleKCa pop OT 13 Ifi{)HJI 1996 r.
NQ 63-tt>3 (aooyncnpe6.neHl'1e nOJIHOMO'lllilI\orn) Tpl-lBaeT OT-
BeTCTBeHHOCTb B BI-I,t:\e llITpa4Ja, 061133.TeJIbHbIX pa6oT, I'IcnpaBlrreJIb-
HbIX pa6ur. apecTa J1.ID-I JlI-IllIeHI-IR CBo6o)\bI 3a J]JlIJPM,
BNIIOIIIiHKUDIM ynpasJIeWieCKi-le B KOMMep'-l€CKoii Jf.ID1 HHoii
opraHYI3al{lrn. CBOHX IIOJIHOMQ'lJ:IH BOIlpeKI-I 3aKOHHbIM :YIHTepecaM ::rroii
opraHl13alUU1 B LleJIHX H3BJIe'leHWI BbIrOJI H npeHM)'IlIeCTB,l{JUI ce6H J-IJIY!
APY=.mn.tJIJ1f)oHaHeCeID-I11BpeJta, APYJ'YIMJI M, eCJ1H TO)!;effiIY!e IIO-
BJIeKJIO npYI'D-IHeID:le HlDl'() Bpe)l;a npaBaM 1t3aIWHHbIM J1HT€-
pecaM rpam,Il.aH J-IJIJ-I OpraID-I3aLtIDJ: JlJ-I6o oxpaHHeMb1M 3aKOHm'! ItHTepe-
caM 06Il\€CTBa Jf.ID1 rocYJ13.pCTBa.
BbllIOJIIDIIOIl\YIM ynpaIJ..JIeH<;eCKI:1e 4>)'HKll:I-IJ1 B KOMMep'lecKOll ItJIY!
HHOii opraHJ-I3aLlHI--I B CTaTbe IIpl-l3HaeTCJI J1I--ILlO, IIOCTOJlHHO, BpeMeHHO
JIHfjo IIocneQWaJIbHOM.YIIOJ1HOMO'lIno eOpralBl3al.t1'lOHHO-
pacnOpH,!J;I1T€JIbHbIe = 8,D,MJIHHC'I'pB.TI-IBHO-X03HJICTBt:'HHble 061133.H-
HOCTH B KOMMep'-leCKOfi OpraHJ13aLlI-IJ-I He3aBJICHMO (Y1' GxJPMbI C06CTBeH-
HOCTY!, a TaKmE' B HeIWMMep'-IecKOJl oprnH1 . He .J1BJUlIOIl\et1CJI
I'OcYJ13.pc-rB€HHbIM opratnf, opraHOM MeCTHOrO caMoynpaBJIeHJ-IJi, 1'0-
cyJ13.pcTBeHHbIM J1.ID-I M)'HJ1W1IIaJlbHbIM emleM
OrseTCTBetfHOCTb 3a HapyIIIeHI-IR npaBa aKqIlOHepDB Ha ItH4>oPMa-
LlI-lIO TalOKe yCTaHoMeHa HopMaMY! Ko)!;eKCa 06 a.D,MIfHYIC"11XI.TY!BHb1X
npaBOHapyrneHJ1.RX pltJ It YrOJlOBHOro Ko)!;eKCa pop (J13.JIee YRPltJ).
TaR, CT 15.191\oAII pop npe,nyCMaTpY!BaeTO'IEt?TCTB€HHOC 3a Ha-
pyrnetfl-le Tpe60BaHuJ:1 3aI«JtJ.1,/:\aTeJlbCTBa, KaCaIOlW1XCH npe,!J;cTaBJ1e-
-170-
HI1R 11 paCKpbITl1.H I1Ht}:>o DI Ha pbIHK€ LleHHbIX 6)'Mar. CJ6'beKTIffi-
H)'IO CTOpOlry 3TOro npaBOHapyrnemrn 05pa:3)'1OT H e
3!1rnTelITOM I1JThI yqacrHHROM pbIHRa LleHHbIX 5y-
Mar I1HBeCTOPY no era TJJ€OOBamoo npe,D;ycMOTpeHHoti 3aKOI1O,ZI,aTeJlbCT-
BOMIn$JpMaIVnIJI1.160 lIIe HeJ1OCTOBE'pHOi1I1Ht}x>pMaqID1 III
HapyIIIeHl1e 3MMTeHTOM, yqaC"IW1:KOM pbIHRa LlE'H-
HbIX 6)'Mar J1JIIII JlI1L10M, OKa3bIBaKJlJ.tI1M YeJlym no nyfiml'IHOM)' npe,D;-
craBJIemoo paCKpblNleMOM l1Ht}x>pMar.vrn, nopMKa paCKpbITl1.H I1HQJOP-
MaW1ilI H3. pbIHK€ LleHHbIX 6yMar, 06Ji3aHHOCTb no paCKpbITIOO KUI'OpUi1
npe.IIyCMOTpl'H 3aKOHO,!!,aTeJlbCTBOM. YKa3aHHble mpyweHI1J'I HaKa3bl-
BaIOTC$1 a)\MI1ffifCTpaTI1BHbIMIli nrrpaQ-JaMi-f.
CTaTb.Fl185.1 YRP<1:I (3J10CTHoe yKJIoH€HilIe OTnpe.n;oCT8BJ1eHl1Ji iIIH-
secropy J1JIIII KOlITp0J1IfpyroIJJ;eMY opraH)' I1Ht}x>PMaW1ilI, O!1pe
3aIOCIHO,lI,aTeJibCTBOM P<1:I 0 LleHHbIX 6)'Marax) YCTaHOBilIJla OTBeTCTBeH-
HOC'I'b 3a 3Jlocmoe yKJIoHeHwe OT npeAOCT8SJleHl1Ji I1Ht}x>PMaLlI1l1, co-
Aep:lKall\ei1J1aHHble 003M11T€HTe, o era qn1HHHC(E()-XD3RiiCTB€lIll1:M Ae-
HTeJlbHOCTYI III LleHHblX 6YMar8x, c.n;eJlKaX III IIIHbIX onepaWlHx C
LleHHblMw6yMaraMw JlI1I.\8. o6fI3aHHOrO 06ecne'il1Tb yKa3aHHoi1 IIIH4Jop-
MaLl"ei1 MHBeC'I'Op8 IIIJHf IIDHTjJOlllqJ 1 opraH, JIJ1fjo IIpeAQCTaBJIe-
HI1e 3aS€)J;OMO H€IIOJIHOit: I1JThI J10)f{Hoi1I1Ht}xpMl':lq>m. ecJIH 3111 JleHHIDI
npU'fInD1JIH Kpymnill1 Yll\ep6 rpam,AaHaM, opraID:!3aL\l1m11 J1JIH rocy-
A8pCTsy, Hacrynarow;yIO S mUle llITpa4m. OOH3aTeJlbHbIX pa6ur. JIJ1fjo
J1cnpaBlIT€JIbHbIX pa6ur.
Ha 06ecne'leJlll€ ocyIl\eCTBJ1eHl1R aKL\IWHepaMYI npaBa Ha ynpaBJ1e-
HilIe 06meCTBoM HaIIpaBJIeHbl HopMbI CT. 15.20 KoAIT P<1:I. KOTopaH YCTa-
Has.rnmaeT 0"l13eTC'!13eHH B Bl1J\e mJlomeHl1R a)\MI1ffifCTpaTI1BHoro
llITpa4m Ha JlOJDKHOCTHbIX J1 IOpYl]J;l1'-{ecKJ1X J111L\ 3a BOClIp€IIHTCTBO-
HI1e oc}'llleCTBJleID1IO I-IHB€CTOpi)M IIpaB no ynpaBJIeID1IO -
HbIM 06ll{ecTBOM. Cy6'beKTaMJ1IIpaBOHapyrneHl1f1 HBJU110TCH 3Mm'eHT J1
pernCTpa-rop.
BoClIpEf1fITCTB(EaHllie 3M11TeHTOM J1JII1 penJCTIXI.TOpoM oC}'llIeCTBJIe-
ID1IOIIHB€CTOJXIM IIpaBIIoynpaBJIeHl11O OOmeCTBOMMO-
:lK€TBbip3.*aTbCHBCJie.n;yKJIl\I1X ( ):H€BKJIKJ-
'leHilIe B CIDICOK J111J.l, J1MeJOIl\I1X npaBo ill yqacTllie B 06IJJ;eM ufipaHJm
aI\.LIIfCHepoB; HeCOO6ur,eIDI€ 0 IIpOBeJ:\eIDDf oomero C05paHl1H 8KLlWOHe-
pOB B IIOpH,JJ;Ke, YCTaHOBJleHHOM .n;ei1cTB)'JOlWIM 3aKOHO,!!,aTeJlbCTBOM J1
ycraBoM 8KL\1fOH€pHOrO 001l\eCTsa; J1Hb1e HapyweIDtR IIO no):UX)-
TOSKM, C03bIBa J1 IIpCEe.J:J;eHIm 06mero co6paHl1R aKW'lOHepos
Cpa3y H€CI<OJIbI«) cTaTei1 KOJleKCa 06 a)\MI1H11CTpaTI1BHbIX npaso-
Hapywem-mx IIOCBJnl\eHO mpyrneHilImII, CBfl3aHHbIM C BeJleHllieM peec-
TP8 aKL\I10H€poB.
-171_
CTaTbR 15.22 KoAIIP<1:I BBeJIa O'I'BeTCTBeHHOCTb B mr.n;e llITpa4m 3a
HapyrneH11e npamfJJ Be,lJ;eHl1J1 peecTpa BJIa,JJ;eJlhQeB QeHHbIX 6YMar: He-
3aKOHHbIi1 OTKa3 I1JThI YKJIOHeH11e OT BHeCeHl1J1 3aIDw::eH B CJ-ICTeM)' Be-
,lJ;eHi1F! peecTpa BJIa.r\eJIbQeB QeHHblX 6YMar, JIHfjo BHeceIDIe B peecTp
BJla.r\eJIbu;eB QeHHbIX 6YM8r He,D;OCTOBepIbIX CBe):1elIJm no mme ,lJ;epma-
TeJUI peecTpa, JIJ1f)o HapynreIDIe CpOKOB BbI)\a'ffi BbIIDlCKM If3 Cl1C'T{'MbI
Be,lJ;eHWI peeCTpa BJ1a,lJ;eJ1bQeB QeHHbIX 6:yMar, a paBHO HeBl>IT1OJ1HeHJ1e
I1JIM HeHaAl1emar.qee BbIIIOJIHeHMe ,lJ;epmaTeneM peeCTpa IrnblX 3aKOH-
HbIX -rpe6oBamrli BJla;J;eJlhQ3. LleHHbIX 6yMar J1ID'! nMqa, AeiilCTayKJlL\ero
OT ero em-I, a TalOKe mMJ1HaJIbHOI'O AepmaTeJ1.fI QeHHbIX 6:yMar.
CTaTbR 15.23 RoAII P<1:I (YKJIOHeH11e OT nepeM'ffi pen:IC'T'J'XlTOPY
Be,lJ;eHWI peeCTpa BJla;J;eJIbQeB I.1;eHHbIX 6yMar) npe,DyCMaTpJ1Bae-r OT-
BeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a }'RJDHemie OT nepe,!l.a'm J1JIM mpyweIDIe CpOKa ne-
peM'ffi perMc1p1lTopy J1HiPopMaQI-IM J1 ltoK)'MeHTOB, COCTaBJIJIK)ll '-IX
CJ1CTeM)' Be,AeHMJ'! peeCTpa BJ1a,lJ;€JIbQ€B LleHHblX 6:yMar, B cJIy'laRX, yc-
TaHOBJIeHHbIX 3aKOHO)\aTeJIbCTBOM. 0Ha npe.!lYCMaTpillJaeT HaJImKeHMe
8){MJiIH11CTpaTI1BHOrO llITpa4>a KaK Ha ,I\OJDKHOC'I'HHX nMU;, TaK J1 Ha
IOpl,lJ;Wle<:KItX JrnL\. J1CXO,AR maHaJIJ13a,Wl(.'II()3HQJm KOMMeH'I'JIpyeMOH
CTaTbM, MO:IKHO npe.r:cno.m::DK, '11'0 cyO'beK1'OM npaBoHapyIlIem1JI MO-
:1KeT6bITbK8K3apeI'nCT IDJI.1;O, TaKJ13r.rnTelIT.
TaKMM 06pB3oM, WIE npaBOO'I'HfJIIElH, B03IDIlffi Me:IKJIY <lK4M0-
HepHbIMJ106lI.\ecTBar.rnJ1 <lK4MOHepar.rn, TI1IIW3HbIM HBJIReTCRnpHMEtiEHlIE'
qx:pMrpAA\.!I3.HCKO-npaBOBOiiI CTrBeTCTBeHHOCTl, J1, np€JK.!Ie acero, - B4Jop-
MeB03Mer.qeHllilyDhITKOB.O,!I.HaKOBcwry I4»mu: -IXC.fI
IJ'l'HIIIIEHJrl J1 oco6oro KOHTpOJUI 3a HJ1I\olli co cropOHbI rocyA8pcTB€HHbIX
opraHoB B03MIDKHO He TOJThKO npaBOBoM, HO
TIHOKe J1 Mep a,n;MM1IJ'!CTpaTI-lBHoiil J1 l(a:lKe yroJIOBHoM OTBeTCTBeHHQCTI:!.
OrBeTCTBeHHOCTb B npaBe xapcllcrepJl3yeTcfI TaIOKe J1
TeM, 'lT0 B03MDmHO ee pacnpOCTpaHeH11e B cnpeJ1eneHHblX CJI.Y'ffiJIX He
TOJIbKO Ha aKQI>-lOHepHoe oor.qeCTBO, HO J1 Ha era aK4I10HepoB, OCHOBHoe
(MaTepMHCKOe) aKWDJEPme 06lI.\ecTBo J1 Ha ,[IpyrJ-IX JIHQ; npl1MepoM 3T0-
M)'MO:lKeT.fIBJ1J1TbCSI paccMOTpE'HHbill CJ1}"lafi B03J1roKeID1l1 cyf5cI-I,[ll-IaPHOA
0TBe'I'C'I'BeHH Ha aKQJ10Hepa no 06J'f3aTeJIbC'TBaM HeCOCTOHTe1IbIf
06IQeCTBa. Cy6'beKTar.rn OTBeTCTBeHHOCTI--I MOryr 6brI'b H J1Hb1e.11HI¥i, Ko-
TOpble Moryr J1 He .fIBJ1J1TbCSI CyD"b€K'I'aWf paCCMaTpl1BaeMbIX npaBOO'l'Ho-
llIeHIDi. TaK, B COO'I'E!eTCTBIm C n 3 CT. 22.l3aKOHa «0 pbIHKe qeHHbIX 6y-
Mar» Jn1u;a, m.AID-IcaBllll-ie npocneKT Qel!HbIX 6yMar (a It IDIM OTI1()('JfI'CR
€)J;J1HOJIWIHbD1 J1CIIOJIHJITeJIbHblii: opraH o6mecTBa, era rJIaBHbD1 6yxraJI-
T€P, ay,I\I-ITOp, B HeKOTOpbIX CJIy'I8RX HffiaBI-IC'HMbI OL\€HiqI-IK J1$JHaHCO-
Shill KOHCYJIbTaHT), npu HaJIJ-I'OO-f J1X BJ1Hb1 HecyrCOJn1,ll,apHO Me<1\!IY cc60fi
cy6cI1,I\J13.pHyJO C 3MJ-ITeHTOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a ymep6, IIfWllIH€HHbIR
BJi8)J.eJIbUYLleHHbIX 6yMarBCJIf;'J1CTBJIe('(),D;e iCH B )'K83aHHOMnpO-
-172-
CIIeKTe He)\OCTOBepHoi1:, HeInIIHOJI J1/= BBO H B eHl1e 11H-
BE'CTOpa I'nK}x::pMaltiIlI, I1OJI:I'BE'pm,.!I€HlUl I1M11. CT 30 3aKOHa «0 pblHKE'
LleHHbIX 6)'M1ll'» ycTaHaBJll1BaeT, '<ITO e:meKBapT1l.IIbHhIi1: OT'IeT aMIITeHTa
;zJ;OJDKeH 6brrb TIO;zJ;IDICaH JD-fl-lOM, OCYJl.\ecTBJIfOOw;HM q:.}'HKl-Iffi1 e,!UfHOJIWI-
HOro HCI1OJ1IDITeJ1b opraHa ::IMWrE'HTa, ero rnaBHbIM 6yxraJ1TepoM
(J1Hb1M .ID1l.\OM, BbillOJlHmOll.\HM ero 4J ), rnv:rme 1 TeM
caMblM,lIOCTOBepHOCTb Bcefi CQIJ; B HeM L JlJ-IQa,
Ie emeKBapTaJThHbrn: OT'leT, Hecyr OTBeTCTBelll1OCTb 3a nOJl-
Hmy J1,J:\UC'1OBepHOC co06J.qeHHbIX B HeM CBe,lJ.eHJrn.
KpOMe TOro, B CJ1.J1y BaaJ.-lMOCBJI3aI1HOC'1'I-1 mrrepecDB CyD"beKTOB
Kopnopan1BHblX IIpaBOOTHOIII€IDrn: - aIa-l"OHepa J1 06J.qecTBa (B HOp-
M3.JIbHOM MJ'I 06J.qeCTBa) B03MO:>KHO
J1CKOB B 3aU-IJ.-ITY npaB O,!I,H11MJ.-I cyfueKTaMJ.-I (al\.QJlOHepaMJ1) B J1HTE'pe-
cax lIJIyrll!: (06J.qeCTBa).
IIpJ1 ::ITOM H€06xQD,mOO CYrMeTJ1Tb CJIe.ztYIOlL\YKJ o::oi5eH:HocTh, xapax-
TepH)110 WIH aaLqMTb! :J1MeHHO KOpnOpaTI1BHbIX npaB aIa-l"OHepoB. B PH-
l1.e c.nyqaeB, HanpI1Mep, npJ1 HapyrneID-1I1 npaaa aKlU10Hepa Ha y-qacTJlle
B oOJ.qeM CoOpaHJIIJ1, ero HapyweHliOe npaBO M<»K€T Bo06J.qe OCTaTbCH
6e3 3all-!J1Tb!, a 06Il\eCTBO, ,l\OnYC"lJlBlIle€ Hapynretrne, MO:IKeT He nOHec-
TI1 OTBeTCTBeHHOCTJII. O,!I,HaKO 3)J;eCb lIonyCTJllMa BblCOKaH CTeneHb cy-
lIe6Horo ycMUTpE'IDIH, 'lTO, KOHe'IHO, Ha npaRDlK€ MO:>KeT npJIIBeCTIf K
HeB03M1:DKtKJCT 3aIl\MTbl aKlU10HepaMJII CBOll!: npaB. TaK, ap&rIpaJKHOit:
npaKTHKe H3B€CTHbI CJIy'laVl, KOma CYlIOM Cb HeCYJl.\eCT-
BeHHblMVl TaKJlle HapyrneHl1.H, IGIK, HallpJ1Mep, .ID1II1eHl1e
npJIIHRTb yqacTJlle B 06J.qeM Co6paHJIIJ1 aKQJ10HepoB, IX KPyn-
HbIMJ1naKeTaMJ.-I . BTOmeBpeMH CY11.BnpaBe, HOHe06H3aH OCTaB-
,lliITb B cl1.Jle pellEHl1e 06J.qero c06paHl1.H, noSTOMY 1J.a:>Ke
eCJ1V1 HapyrneInfH He RBJIHIOTCH CYJl.\ecTBeHHbIMVl, cy11. Bee .me MO:>KeT
npll3HaTh pellIeHl1e 06Il\ero c06paHl1.H TalGlM 06-
pa30M, 3aKOH0NtTeJIbHOe pery.ID1pomHrne BceqeJIO OTlIae-r pellIeHJlle
3TJ1XBOIIpOOOBHa cYAa.
npMMe aHMR
1 CM. JlOMB""H.Q.B.AI< PHoenpaBOOTHOl1le....e -M. o01apK>o 1991 C.55-59.
2 CM: Eipay,QB III AK oHepHblB 06wecrBB 11 TOBajJI1LL1BCTBa B ToprOBJle 11 I1pOMbIW-
l1eHHOCTI1.-M "¥\BTeJ1bCTBO..npaBOI-!)I( 3Hb»,1926.C.7
31lI1ceMCK iilll. KOMnaH"I-!CTO KI13peHIo1SI npaBB.-M
T"norpa<fl"Rrpa eualll.K.1876.C 57
4 CM r IlH BonpocblBK OHepHOronpaBB -lle-rporpa,i:\.CeHaTCKBSI
T"norpacl:>l1R, 1915.C 28.
5TapaC08I11.T.Y4eH"eoti -M..nCra-ryr.,2000.C 365.
eCM.:KaWBHI1HaT.B npaBO{npaeo TOeapl1w,ecrn"
CJI5uWcrn) )'\.<e6H"KW\ BY305. - M: It13liaTBnbCi<B<' rpynnaHopM8MH<ppa-M. 1999
C.418-419
7 CM' Eienoycos O.B AK " npaBaa.K oHepall3aKoHQD,aJBnbCTBo. 1999. W6
C.28.
8CM..Kynar\<1HM.lt1rOCY Kan an I-!KJPi'I.!\I'I4ec-
KOBI1"uolllib6wHHblBTPY.D.bI -M:..C"nvr', 1997 C 94-
9l\1o1Tno:JlOMBK"H.nBAI< PHoe -M:oCnap"".1997C-111
10 AoJl"HCKaR B.B AK oHepHOB npaBo: Y<ie6H"K I OrB PBA- A,IQ. Ka6anKI1H. - M
IOpl-1,O,.I1I1T.,1997C.111.
11"'BTBBP">OOBBIO.It1.AK oHepHbIBOT1iOWeH"RBycnoB"RxnepexOJlBKpblHKY'
AI1C KaH.!l.3KOH HaYK.-M.1994.C 15
12 kapKOB M.M. y.,eH"e 0 IJBHHblX 6yMarax. - M.- ctIlo1HaHcoBOB 113,1J,aTBnbCTIro HKo:!:>
CCCP,1927 C 7
13MI1pOWH"K0B8H.III. npaBOBOe KOpnoparnBHblXOTHO_
weH"" II o.epKIol no ToprOBOMY npaBY CO. HaY". lP./ IlQII pe.o., EA I(paWBH"HH"-
KOIIa SIpoCJ1BBnb 1997 Bbln 4.C102
141lyHKT 43 1l000O>KeH" '<06 aKU' 06weCTBaX. (YI1!. llocTBHoeneH"BM
CMPC4>CPOT251290N 601)
15 CM Bepw"H"HA,1l np<lB,y blxLleHHbIM,,6yMBraMI1I1
o.epKIol no roproBOMY np<IBY' CO. HaY" yp. IIlo;:J. pw\. E.A, KpaweH"HH"KOBB -
Slvocnallllb.1997 Bbln.4.C.39
16 TaM )!(B.C 43.
17 CM IloMBK"HIlB AKLJ.I'IOHBpHOB npaOOOTHOweHI-1e. - M oOlapK-, 1997 C.69
18 kapKOB M M. )l\<eH"e 0 IJBHHblX 6yMarax. - M' ctI HaHcoBOB I13JJ,i!TBIlbGTBO HKo:!:>
CCCP.1927.C.11.
19TapacoBI-1.T. )l\<BHl1e06 KOMnaH"SIX. -M.:«CTa-ryr., 2000. C. 409
201l0CTaHOlllleHL<1ecbe;J.epanbHoroap6l1Tpa:t<HoroCYMMOCKQBCKoroOKpyraOT26CBH-
T1'16ps:12002r.N2Kr-A41J6548-02
21 CM' BonbIP B 10. OCHOBbly.<eH" OTOeap"laBCTBax" aKW1oHepl-lbIX06wec-raax _
M.c])I1HBHooBOBI1 nbCTBo1927.C.85.
22 kapKOB M M Y BHIo18 0 LlBHHbOl6yMarax _ M.: ctI HaHC06QB I13JJ,i!TBJ1bGTBO HKo:!:>
CCCP 1927 C 62
23 Il.AK oHepl-lbIBKOMnaHI-!"CTO'lK"3peHIIIR npaea-M.
T"norpacl:>I1Rrpa BeaIllK 1876 C.65
24C.....6eJ1OYCOBO.B.AK l1npaBaaK oHBpal/ bCTBO.1999.N26.
C.28-30.
25 Tapaooalll . T )l\<eHOIB06BK411OHejJHbIXKCNIlBH......-M. ..cra-ryr.,2000.C 367--a;s
26L\11T.no JlCNBKI1H.Q.B.AK4I1oHepHOBrpaIIOOI"H!IlJE-M....cnapK..I9R C.59.
27 Ta ...",e C.56-59
28 CM : WanK Ha r C. Hav6OJ1ee Ba>KHble ""'MBHeHI1R BPOCClo1"CKOMiIKI.J.I'I[IHBp 33-
KOHG.!I8TB1lbG1BB/I PocClo1i:1cKO rB3BTbl.2002Bbln.N!7C.211
29TapacoBI-1.T.)I\<BHl1e()6 KtM'liiH'!RX._M:.<CTa-ryr.,2000 C.368
3DCM. M03On"HB.Il..IO,l:\BHKOBA.1l K4IBMpanbHCIMY3BKOHY..()(iaK-
4"oHepH"",()6 .-M.It1Hof>pa-M.2002C.13-14
31 CM' lloMaK"H.QB- AKLJ.I'IOHBpHOB npaOOOTHClWeHI-1e - M «CnapK..1997 C.64
32PyAHeBIl.A,AHan"3npaBI1 BK OHepOB.-M I113liaH"eaBTOpa,
1927 c.n.
33CM.:1II3pB311I1TMH A/::4I1CIHBpHbIB . -M It1MBTerH:T80
>KI13Hb>,1927.C.43,CrenaHoenB.KopnopaTl1BttiBOTHCILJJBH""8KO......ep-IBCKi'lXOpra-
H RXKaI(COCTaBIi1liI"BCTbnpeJJ,MeTBIJ)iDK,!J,3HCKOronpaea.,AI1C..KaJ1I1.KlP"A-HB-
yx.-M., 199fJ.C. 112-n3.,[Ipn"HCKaRB.B. epHoenpaao, Y«e6HI1K/Ore. pep,.
klO.KaI5anKlo1H.-M:IOpI1,!\.IlI<T.1997C161-162
34TapaCOBIt1.T Y eH"e06 KCMlBH>!AX--M .<CTa-ryr',2000 C.
35 CM' ,[I,011"HCKBR B.B AKLJ.I'IOHBpHOB npaoo: Y'<e6H"K lOrn. PBA A.IO. Ka6anKI1H -
M. IOpl-1,O,.I1"T..1997.C 146.
36 TaM >Ke.C.15O.
37 TaM "'B C.151-152
38 1t13Pa3J1 I<TMH 06U1BCTBB. M:It1'3ABJBnbCTBO
:IKL<13Hb>o,1927.C.35.
39 TaM "'B.C 33.
40 Il.AK oHepHbIBKOMnaHI-!I1CTO'iKI13peH"" np<lea-M.
T"norpacl:>l1R rpa Bealll K, 1876. C. 62.
41r iilnH Bonpocbl npaBB.-lle-rporpa,i:\.CeHaTCKBRTl1no-
rpacl:>"R,1915.C.38
42 CM . MaxapoufJ.-A. MI-!OI5LllBCTBBM,,'AnTO.oe4>.lII<C
KaHJ:L.lOpl-1,O,.HaYK M.2002.C 10
43 CM . llL>ICeMcKI1 nhLa1OHepHbleKoMnaH""CTO KI13PBH"Rr)Ja)l'Jl,ilHcKOronpaea.-
M..T..norpa4>l<Rrpa euaIt1K.,1676.C.58-59
44 TBM )I(B.C 59.
45 TaM ",e.C.153_156
46 TaM ",e C. 151-152
47TapacoBIt1.T. Y eH"eo6 KCMlBI-HIX--M .CTa-ryr', 2000 C.483
48IlYHKT17 ll;JeHYMa8epxouHc:lnJCYfJ/'JPCPl1ll;JeHYMaBblcwero1\SJ-
6 paJKHoroCYfJ/'JPCPoT111IOnRI996r N26/B.{)HeKOTOpblXBOl1JJocax,C8R3aHHbIX
c np MBHeH"eM ..acrn l1epBoOl rCBJKlI.BHCKoro KOJ\BKCa Po:t>"
49 CM' JlOMI-1,O,38 O. llepexOA oI5R3aTenbCTOOHHbOl np<IB Y"BCTH"KOB IOP'l!l" ecK"X
l1"uIlPoccl1ii1cKa lOCm 1999.N 10C.17
SO CM.: ,[I,011"HCKBR B.B AKL.\OOHSPHOS npaeo: y..s6H"K / Ora. PeA, A.IO. Ka6anK"H. -
M.lOpl-1,O,.I1I1T.,1997.C.12
51 Ct.ol. POJ\HOBB Q.M.npl'lpo,o,a npaB, np HMI18)KBl1\I'IX aKl! OHepy 1!1Op1'l,lJ,l1 ecK"e
3Bnl1cK"SlpocnaBCKororOCYA3pcTaeHHoroYH "M.Il.r,[l,eMI-1,O,OBa/IlO.l1
peA. B H KaprawoBa, ll.n. Kpyrl1"KOBa, B.B. 6yYHsna - S'lpOCJ1aBnb, 2000. Bbln. 4.
C.150
52M0301l"HB.Il.,IQI:\eHKOBA,1l KOMMe>fTBP"iilK4 IJ,epam'Hor"'Y3BKOHy..05aKlJ)'lOHBj)Hb'"
o6uIecrnax...-M.IIIHrPPa-M.2002.C.13-14.
53kapKOBMM Y eH"eoueHHblx6yMarax -M. ctII1HaHCOBOBI13JJ,aTBJlbGTooHK<t>
CCCP.1927 C 69-90.
54 rpa>K,lJ,BHCKOBnp<Iuo. B2T TOM 1 Y eI5H"K/IlOJJ.PBJ\. E.A. CyxaHOBB. -M. 6EK
2000 C.103
S5KawaH''HaTB. npaBO(npaBO HblX l1015_
I.I\I!CTB) Y'Ie6H"K,IJ,I1R 8y:30B - M.: 1II3,lJ,aTSnbCKa!1 rpynna l-1oPMB-I>1H<ppa-M, 1999
C 419
S6 CM Kopal511eea MC. rpa>K,lJ,BHCK"" 11pa8. HOBbie acneKTbl I! AKryanbHble
npo6nBMblrpa:«,lJ,aHCKoronpaBa/IlO.l1pBA-M.It1 -MIII3.I1-Bo.c-ra-
TYT',1998 C.76-77.
57 KaM"HKaA.1t1 o.epKl< TOproeoro npana. - M.. AO LleHTp IOpIt1HcpoP>, 2002 C. 398
saCM: JlOMBKI1H,[I,.B AKuotoHBPHoenpaBOOTHOllIBl-u.e. _M.: o01apK>o, 1997 C.52-53
59 TBM )I(B.C 'Zl.
!SOCM IloMBK"H,[I,.B AKLJ.I'IOHBpHOBnpaBOOlHOUlBl-MenOHRT"e, , -
eKTbl ,AI1c. KaH.!I.lOpl-1,O,.Hayx -M.1996 C.13-14
-176-
61MI1POWH"KOBaH.III.l-1oPMBTI1BHo-npaBOBoe KopnopaTl1BHblXOTHO-
weH"iillI O1ept<11 no TOprOSOMY npasy: C5 HaY'!. TP /1l0.l1pep,. E.A. KpaiJJEI-HH1-
KOBa -Slpocnallllb.1997 Bbln.4.C.101-102
52 CM. Pot\HOBa O.M.Ilp"po,o,a npaB,l1p!<HaJ\IleJKBll\I'IX aKW10Hepy /l1Op"iJ.l< ecK"e
3BnI1CK/o1S1pocnaBCKororocyABPC'IB8MHOroYH "M.Il.r.neMI-1,O,Oea/1l0.l1
peA. B.H. KapTBWOBa, Jl.Il. Kpyrn"Koea, B.B. 6yYHeea. - SIpocJ1allllb, 2000. Bbln. 4.
C 153-155
636enoBB.A.,llecTepeeaEB o6wecrna -M'AO,"-!efITPlOpV1H(jxJP,.
2OO2.C 125.
64CM.CrenaHOBnB. OTHOWeHL<1 B OpraHI13aLl,l1RX
KaKCOCTBBHaR..aCTbnpe/1MBTarpa.>i(,!laHCKOronpaBa./JJ>tC. KaH,D,.lOp"1l.Hay<-
M.,1999.C.50-53.
65 TaM :lKe.C.82
66 TaM :lKB.C.54.
67CM'CrenaHoBIl.B. oTHOWeH"jlB opraHI13BU,I1j1X
KaX COCTaBHB!I 'IBCTb npBAMeTa rpa.>i(,!laHCKOro npasa ABTOpeq:.. ,QI<C. . KBHJ\.
IOp"A. Hay< - M., 1999 C. 13
6BCM ra6pL<1 "lI3eEi.H. A.r .<W.M"H"CTpaTI1BHoenpaao
epaLl,l1I1:}l<je6HI1K.A/1R8yaoB.-M .1II:?J],aTeJ1bCTBO..,!J,en0IilCepBl<1c",2001.C.48.
69 0ecRHKO ,D,.M.I\D,M"HI1CTpaTl1BHOBnpaBO:}l<je6Hoenoco6l18-M ICpL<1CT, 2OOO.C. 7.
70CM. npaBo.}l<je5HI1K/Il0JJ.pet\.Jl.Il.llonoBa._M. ICpL<1CT,
2002 C.36
71£;axpaJ<,D,.H np<lBOPocc""'Y eI5H"K.A/1RByaoB.-M'HOpMB,
It1H4Jpa-M,2000 C.20
72CM.:TaH'iYKIt1.A.,E<PL<1MO'IK/o1HBIl.,AOOeaTE, oOO3arBnbCTea -M
oIOpI'l,lJ,l1'<BCKBRI1..-repa-rypa..1970.C 19
73 CM .. MapTBM HOBB.C npaBO. TOMI.06UJ)1e . Kypc
l1eK iiI-M..1II3,O,8renbCTBoEiEK,1994,C.44-51
74 rpa:+:;o,aHc><oe npaso. B 2-x TOMBX. TOM 2: Y e6H"K/llo.l1pep,. E,ACyxaHoBa _ M.:
EEK,1993C.6
75 Kpac8B "KOU O.A. rpa>K,!\BHCK"e opraH"38 OHHo'npaBoBbie 0iH'JUJEH-'I!I II
COeeTcKoe l1npaBo.1966.N 10 C56
76001.' KaML<1HKaA.1t1 O1ept<I1Toproooro npaea - M.' AO '''-!efITP IOplt1H<tKJP>o, 2002.
C.389-390.
T7CM:llbIWKL<1H"'It1. l-Inp06nBM KOHTpoJ1lo1-iO-)11'P!B-
l1eH'lBCK""npauaKlll1oHepooll 2003 W3.C7
7BMe-reJ1esalO.A.llpaBOBOBllC\f1CI>KetMeaK oHepa8 06U1BCTBa.-M.
..Crarayr.,1999 C.43
7911oMBKI1H,[),.BAKLJ.I'IOHBPHoe -M.:..cmpx...1997 C.15
80TaM_.C.14-15.
-177-
81 CM.: ctIoMI1'fB6a H.B llpaeaaKLa'IOHepoBl-Il1Xaal!!l1TaIlHoBoepoco;l1 CKOBrp<t)l(,!laH-
CKOB l1np<1KrnKaero C60pH"KH!lY'lHblXcTaTe!il/llqo,
pe,!\.3.1t1 CapaTou:crAn, 1998.C.59
82 CM. POJIHOBa O.M.np"pop,a npaB, I1p1<1HM/IB)KBll\I'IX 2K4\<10Hepy /l1Op"iJ.l< ecK"e
3Bn"cK"SlpocnaBCKororOCYABpcTIleHHoroYH "M.Il.r.neMI-1,O,OBa/llqo,
peA. B H Kapyawoea, Jl.ll. l<pyrl1"KOea, B.B. 6yYHsBa. - S'lpOCJ1aBnb, 2000. Bbln. 4.
C.152-153
83 TaM >Ke.C.153
84 Eenoycou O.B. AKW1 11 npaua aK oHepal/ 3aKoHOABTenbCTBO 1999. N 6. C 28
85CM'Bonb<PB.IO.OcHoBblY'"eH"RoToeap"U<BCTB<IXI1 06U<BCTB<IX.-
M. ctI11HBHOOeOBI13,O,BTenbCTeO 1927.C.131
8611>oM"4eeaHB.llpaea2K4\<10HepoBI111X3Bll\I1TaI/HOBoepocC1<1!i1c><oerpa>KABH-
cKoe3BKOHO,!I8TBJlbG16Ol1npaKTI1KaeronpI1MBHeH"R"C60pH"KH!lY"HbIXcTare 1
Ilqo,pBlI.3111 LJ,bIf:IyneI-w.-CapaTOB,crAn, 1998.C 59.
8711oMBKI1H,[),.B AK oHepHoe -M.:<OlapK...1997 C.119
88 TaM >Ke.C.12-13.
89 CM MSTeJ1Sea IOAIlpaBoBOB nOJK»l(eHl1eBKLa'IOHeoa 8B1Cl1V1OHE!pH(H 06wecTBe.-
M: Cratayr 1999.c.43
90CM. rpBJlQ],BHCKoenpauo B2T TOM1.Y e6H" /OTB.pe,D,.npo41 E.A.CyxaHOB.-
M.I-13)J,B.TBI1bCTB06EK,2000.C.30.
91 CM B\<1HOBOi< C.H Ilpaooooe perynl1poeaHVlBABRTBnbHOC1I1 C!KUI10HBp-IblX 06wecrn
BCOBBTCKO PoccI1I111922-1927rrl AiITOPB<t>,JI,Io1c.. KaH.!l. KJDIoUI. Hayx. CraBpO-
nonb,2001 C.19.
92CM.CrenBHoBIl.B oTHOWeHI1 8KOMMBp-1ecKl<1X KaK
cOCTauHaR....CTbnpBllMBTarpaJK,O,aHCKorOl1jJaea',AI1c. KaH.!l.KJPI-1,O"H!lyx.-M'
1999.C.28
93 CM . OArpBJlQ],BHcK"e np<lBOBbIBOTHoweH" /I
CoBBTcKoeroCYfJ/'JPCTB0l1npaBO.1966.N!IO C.55-56
94 CM . CTenaHOB nB KopnopaTl1BHble OTHoweH"R B KOMMBp-IeCKl<1X opraH\<13BU,lIIRx
K8KcocTBBHaR..acTbnpei:\MBTarpa.>i(,!laHCKoronp8ua,,AI1c. KaH,IJ..lOpl-1,O,.HaYK-
M.,1999.C.83.
95CM: H.III.l-1oPM8l1'lBHO-np<IBOBOBperynl1poeaHI1BKopnoparI1BHbIX
oTHoweH"" II o.epKl< nOToprOBOMynp<lBY' C6. H!ly'< Tp./IlQ!\pe,D" E.A, KpaweH"H-
H"Koea -S1pocnallllb, 1997 -Bbn 4.-C.101
96 6parycb C.H. Ilpep,MeT 11 CI1CTeMa COBBTCKoro rpa>KABHCKoro npaBa - M. IOpl-1,O,.
I1"T., 1963. C. 46.
97 TBM )I(B.C 74.
98 CM .: rpa!l(,lJilHCKOB npaBO. '-IaClbnB)JBaR: Y'fBIiH"K/OIB. PBA B.Il. M03011 , A.1t1 Mac-
I1RBB.-M.IOp\<CT,2000C.231
99 CM.. CoBBTCKOB rpa!l(,lJilHcKOB npaBO. Y e6H1<1K. B 2-XTOMax. T. 1/rbJ1pBA Q.A. Kpa-
caB'i"Koea.-M. BblCWBRwKOna, 1985.C.12-16
-178-
100 CM . KaM"HKaA,It1.o.epl<l< npaua.-M. AQcLl,eHTplOpItlH<PoP',2002.
C.378.
101 r Il.H. BonpocblaK OHBpHoronpaaa -lle-rporpa,i:\.CeHaTCKaRTI1-
norpa<fl"R,1915.C 23
102 eM. KaM"HKaA.It1. o.epKI1 roproEICIfU npBea. _ M.. AO cLl,eHTp IOpItlHOPOP" 2002.
C 365
103 CM. EpayIJ,e III. AKW10HePHblec(ill\BCTBB 111CiBBpW11BC1BB D Toproene.. npoMblW-
l1eHHQCTI1.-M. I-I3liaTeJ1bCTBO l'lpaBO,,)!(1'I3Hb', 1926. C. 7.
104 CM.: PoAHoBBO.MIlpl'l1JO,!lB npae. npl1HiUl,llB)KaUll1>CaKUl1oHepy 1/ 1Op11,!J,lo1'IBCK11B3B-
n"c""S1pocnaBCKOI"O YH"BBpc:..-re-ra"Mll.r.AeMI-1,O,OBB/IloJ\PBA
B.H Kap-ralllQ8B, Jl.n I(pyrn"KOBB, B.B. Eymeua. - S1pocnaIlIlb, 2000. Bbln. 4. C. 150
105o...:5enoycoeO.B.AKUYlfll-\rpaeaaJ<Ul1QHBPBlI3aK0HQIJ,aTeJ1bCTBO.1999.W6.C,28.
106 KaMI1HKaA.III. Oiepxl'lroprtJBOrol1J)B8B. _ M: AOcUeH1P ICdiHboP '. 2002. C. 362.
10711oMBK"H,[),.BAKLJ.I'IOHBPHOB _M'«CnapK..1997 C.50
108CM.:MBTBJ1eealO.A.llpaBoBOBnono)!(eH"eaKLI"oHepaB 06L11BCT-
ee.-M'«CTaryr.,1999 C.43
109JlOMBK"H,[\.BAKLJ.I'IOHBPHOB -M....(;napK...1997C.39
110CM 06u.ia- Teop"RnpaBB Y e6H"KA/l IOP"Jl."'<eCK""ey30B/IOA,[),M..-.pl1Bu,
It1 CXI Ka3bM"H B B lla38Pea 11,Qp; 1l0,!! 06L11- PBA A.C. Ill'lrOJlK"Ha. - M. 1113.iJ,a-
TeJ1bCTBOMnYI1M H.8.EaYMBHa, 1995. C. 238.
111 Ai1eKCeBBC.C.OOw.a>neop" npaBB.KypclleKW1O\B2T. T 2 -M, 1982.C.154.-157
112 06 UtB>1TOOp"Rnpaea Y4e6HI-IK.o.n 1CIpW1114ecKl'I)(ayaoe/IOA.J],M"Tpl1Be,IIIc]).
KB3bMI1H. B.B lla38Pea 11,Qp ; Ilqo, 06u.l, pejj. A.C. ll"rOnKlo1Hi!. - M : I113.iJ,aTBllbGTBO
MrTY "M. H:3 5aVMaHi! 1995. C 249.
113CeH411L11BBBIII 06bBKTrpa:llJl,BHCKClnpaBOOTHoweH"R 06ll\BBnOHRTl1e/lAY.-
ryanbHblenp06neMbll'paJIIJJ,aHCJ<npaBB/llo,o,pe,o,.MIII EpanH:Ja:Iro.-M.
cCnnyr", 1998.C 156-157
114 ArapKoe M.M 06R3BTeJ1bCTBOnocoaeTcKOMYrpa>KABHCKOMYnpaay. -M.: IOp113-
,lJ,BT,1940C.23
115 rpa>KAaHCKoe npaao. 'iaCTb I: Y«OOH"K/lloJl. PBA IO.K. TonCToro, A,1l CeprBe"8.
-M' lt13.iJ,aTenbQTBoTEItiC. 1996.C 78
116 CM .: rall3Btt> 1II.0003BT8J1bCT8BHHOBnpaBO(OOll\l1eI1OJlOJKBH""J. MI1HCK, TeJ1b-
CTBoErY"M BIII.JleHI1Ha,1968 C.7
117WepUlBHeBl1 rctlY«e6HI'IKIJVCCKororp<t)l(,!laHCKoronpaBB(no H"101907r.l_
M.:oOlapx'.1995.C.266.
118 Cae I'1HbI-1Q).K.06R3aTeJ1bCTBBHHoenpaBO./llep CHeMe4l(.B Q)yKcI'IH Mal1Q-
po._M.T A.B.Ky 1876.C.203
119TaMIKe C.8
120 CM.: llaceeK E.B. Hel1MYW,BCTBBlflbl I-IHTepec B OOR3BTI!I1bCTBB. IOpbBB: Tl1norpa-
,p., K.MaTl1ceHB,1893.C.3
-179-
121 Tpy6eu,Ko E,H. 3H KI10IleJl,lo1RnpaBa. -Cn6.: lt1auaTBJ1bGTIIOoJ1aHb>, 1998. C. 168.
122Ca6l<H""o:1:>K npaBO./llep.CHBMB4K.B.$yKCI1HMaf\IJjXI-
M.: T"norpa$lR A.B. KYAPRB'--IB8Qi<, 1876, C. 5.
123 1110 <P<PeO.C O6 npaao.-M:lOpl-1,O,.J1w ,1975.C 6.
124,D,ePHlSyprr.llaH,lJ,BKTIoI.06R3aTeJ1bGTBBHHoenpaeo./llep nOJJ.PYKOBOJI.11 pep,.
npoq,.n .-M. 1900.C.80.
125 CM . MapTeMbRHOuaA.M.OI5-..eKTOpraH /lllpo-
6neMbl npaea c60pH"KHaY"HbOlTfY'iJJ.ou/Pe-
,lJ,aKTOP H.H. CTenaHOBa. - CaepAl1OB<:K, 1989. C. 72.
126 CM .: rpaJKJJ.aHCKOBnpaBO, 'jBCTbn . Y'le6HI1K/Oia.P8A.B.Il. M03OJ1I1H,A.1t1 !vIa-
CI1 eB-M 1Op0lCT,2000C-95
127CM' OArpB)l(JJ.8HCK..u HO---f1JBB(&>IBOTHOWeHI1Rf/
Cwetaoe rOCYfJ/'JpcTBO" I1paBO. 1966. N 10. C 55
128 CM :JlOMBKI1H,D,.B AKLJ.I'IOHBpHOBI"pBEIOOIHOUIBH.-M :.CnapK , 1997 C.25
129 HOBI1I.U«'1t1It1.Ei D6R3anJJlbCTBeHHOB 11,0080.1 O6L11"ellOlGlHMR. - M. .1t1;wrenb-
CTIlOcIlpaBO">K"3Hb ,1925.C.19.
130 CM' TapacoB lilT Y eH"e 06 KOMlaK-IRX - M' «Cra-.yr.. 2000
C 411-416
131 CM.: 11arTTBII B.B. OI!8P!1oe npaso. - M.: IOpI1,l1. cJ> PMB oKoHlJ)BKT>o, I>1H(j>pa-M
1999.C.70.
132 CM . JloMa""HAB. -M. .CnapK ,1997.C103
133 CM. Jlarnee B.B. AI::4otoHBpHOB npaBO. - M IOpI1,l1. cJ>"PMB Ko-npaKr..; 1t1H<Ppa-M.
1999.C.74
134 Il. KOMnaHI1I1CT04K 3peHl-'lRrpB)l(JJ.8HCKoronpaea.-
M. Tl'\norpacJ>"Rrpa eBalll K.1876.C 57-58.
135cM:r Il.H.Bonpocbl npaBB -lleTporpa,ll,CeHarCKa
T"norpacl:>I1R.1915.C 22.
136 CM . KaM"HKa A.III O<ep"" rq:roacro I1paBB - M AO cl\eHTP IOpItIH<PoP 2002
C 366
137 CM ,Aonl1HCKBfI B B. AKLJ.I'IOHBpHOB npaao: Y e6H"K/OrB. pe,o,. A 1O.l<a6anK H.-
M.lOpl-1,O,.I1I1T.,1997C.140
138 CM. PyJJ,HeB IlA AHaJ1"3 np<IB 11 06R3aHHOCTe aKW1oHepoB. - M. It13liaH"e aBTO-
pa,1927.C 4-fi
139 CM . JloMaK HA.B.AKLIooHePHOel"p'JflOOTHDlll -M. .CnapK ,1997.C.172.
140 CM . PyJJ,HeBIl.A,AHBn"3npaB.. aKW1oHepoB.-M. It13liaHl'1eaBTO-
pa,1927.C 33.
141 CM. BOJ1b(j)B 10 OCHOBbly.ieHI1R OlOll8pKll8CfB<l..aK OHBPHblX06u.<ecTBBX.-
M. ,1927C.132
142(M EeJ10yc0Bo.B. l'\npanaBl<W'lOHepall 1999.N!!6.C.35.
-180-
143 PyAHeB 1l.A. AHBn"3 np<IB 11 OI5sl3aHHOCTe'" aK OHepoB - M. I113.!\BH..u aBTOpa,
1927.C.6
144 CM . ALiaMOBI'I r.n 06eCne<ieHl'le I-IHTepecoB MBI-tiIH-CJBa aK oHBpoB B npaue
Pocc"""CTJ)aH COI03B:ABTope<P,QI<c.KaI1!l,KJPI1A-HaYK.M,
2002 C.12
145 TapacoB lilT Y eH"e 06 aKUIo'OHepHblX KOMnaH"",X. - M. «Craryr..2000 C
405-406
146 CM . Yr'J>aBneIMeOpraH"aa4l1BI'i: Y<ie6HI'IK/IlOJlpe.o,.llopwHeeaA r., PyM HL<B-
BOI'i 3.1l., COnOMaTh1,"a H.A. - M.: 1t1,"<ppa-M, 2000. C 13.
147Eaxuu-o<acB 10 AK4I10HBpHoeOOU\BCTBOKaKnpaBOBBSI<PoPMa HBH"RKa-
n"TBnOB.fJI,<C. KBHlI.lOpl1,Q,HaYK.M.1997C.16
148 CM.. Yr'paBIIeHI1e 11 BHbll'i KOHTponb B aK41'10HepHOM otiU\BCTBe:
IlpaKTI1 ecKoenoc06l1e/IlOJJ.pe/l.B.1l r'l'6I1Ha --M:lOpl1cT.1999 C.17
149 CM .: BI1HOBo CH.llpaBOBOe aK oHBpH"'XOO-
U\BCTB 8 COBBTC><ol'i Pocc"" (1922-1927rr.I:ABTope<P.I\I<C... KBI1,O,. IOpl-1,O" HaYK.
2001.C19-20.
150 CM .,HBnp.,'iernepi'''(OealO.1t1 epHble01HOWBH" Bycnou"""nepe><OABKpbIH-
xy;fJI,<c. Kaf-\,!\, KJPI'I,!\, Hay!(. M., 1994.C, 17; 6aKwI'lHCKaCB.IO.AI<41'1QH8pHOBo6ujBCT-
BOKaKnpaBOBB!1q>opMa06bep,1<HBHI'I Kan..-ranoe: ...Kaf-\,!\.IOpI'\l\.HaYK,M.,1997
C 1B7;lloMBKMH,[I,.a.AK4I'IoHBPHoenpaeocrrnoWBHI1B -M .oOlapK', 1997C.20.
151 CM.' MeTeneeaIOA.llpaooBoellC\r'O>l<EHEaK4"OHBPBBax oHepHOM06U1BCTBB _
M.:.CraT)'T".1999.C48.
152 TaMJKB C.49
153CM..KynarI1HM.It1.r Kanl'lTanI13MI11Opi'\!1,i'14e_
CKOB 11"40 IIIt1a6paHHble TpyJJ,bl - M: _Craryr.. 1997 C. 97; EaKW"HCl\BC B.IO AI<-
4I'IOHepHoeo6laecrnoKaKnpaBoeaHQxJpMa06 HeH"HKanl1TBl1oB' K3HA.
IOPI-1,O,.HCIyI< M.,1997C.207-208.
154 CM MBTeJ1eea 1O.A.IlpaBOBOB nOlK»KE!Hl'leBK4I'IQIiepa B 8K4"OHepHOM 06U1BCT8e.-
M.:.CrafYT', 1999. C. 52-54.
155CM.:lloMBKI1H,[I,.BAK4I10HBPHoe :noHRrnB, ,cyfi1o_
BKTbI fJl,<c. KaI1A.IOpI'l,lJ" HayK. M, 1996. C 187-188, 1l0MaKI'I," ,[I,.B. AK4"OIiepHoe
"e-M.o01apK-.1997C120
156 Il KOMnBH""CTO K"3peH"Rrpa>K,!\BHCKoron,oaua _
M. Tl'lnorpacl:>I1Rrpa BBaIllK, 1876.C.160.
157 CaKWI1HC><ac B 10 AK4"OIiepHoeooweCTBo KaK npaBOBBSlQxJpMaoo1oBl4l1HBH"H Ka-
n"TBnOB,IJ,i'IC.. KaHJJ,,!OPI1A-Hayx.M 1997C 196.
158 CM' Mor-w1eBcKvM C.,[I,. OpraHbJ ynpaBneH" X03 "cTueHHblM" OI5U!BC'1B3M'"
IlpaBoBO"'aCneKT -M.....neno.,2001 C 107
159 TBM )I(eC 147,160
160CM. MaKapoe,[l,.A. Ynpa8J1eHl1e OOll\BCTBBMI-I: ABTope<p. ,QI<C. .
KBHJJ,.lOpl-1,O,.HaYK -M., 2002 C.18
_181_
161CM" I-!KOpnOpaT BHbl"KOHTpo.nbB o6uieCIBe:IlpaKTI1_
"BGKoonocofil1e/llqo,PeA.B.1l ry6"Ha.-M:lOpI1C1".1999 C.19
162Me"ep.I:I.It1.PycCKOerpa>i<,tlBHcKoenpaBO(82.xr.'iaCl"bll.IlO "
AOIlO11HeHHOMys-...YI-\3A,1902.-M .<Cra-.yr', 1997 C.129-130
163EparycbC.H.Cy5'bBKTbl npaaa._M .rOClOpl13liaT, 1950.C 148
164CM:TOMC"HOBB.A.llpc(ineMbI npaeaB-.-pYJ\B><PYCCK"xnpaBOue-
AOBBTopo" XlXHa a.na)()(B.f T.oeTbRIII
1998.N29.C 82.
165cM.r IlH.Bonpocbl npaea lle-rporpa,ll.CeHaTCKBSI
T"norpacl:>I1R.1915.C 61-63
166Kynarl1HMIt1 rocy,[l!ipcreeHHO- Kanl1TBl1"aMI1IOPI1Al'l BGKOe
I1"LloIlIil36patH,laTpyp,bI.-M :.CTa-ryr.. 1997 C.108
167 CM..Jl,D,MIH1C1pIIDIEI-fO npaElO: Y'IB6H"x/llqo,peA Jl.J1.IlOnoBB -M. lOpl1aT>o,
2OO2.C.19-20
168TapacoeIt1T.Y'lI!Hl1Boo KoMnBHI1RX,-M:.craTYT",2000.C,441-442.
169CM.:IlI1CBMCKI>Il<n AK'-WIOHepHble cTOYKI13peHI1Rrpa>i<,tlBHCKoronpaea.-
M.:Tl1no.-pa<PI'IRrpa eBaIt1 K,1876.C.163
170 o:t>e.D,epanbHOrOapfimpa>i<HOrOCYIJ.BMOCKOOCKOrOOKpyra.0T16AB-
KafipR1998r N2KA-A40j3094-98.
171 IlOCTaH0W18H"eo:t>e.D,epallbHoroapfimpa>i<HorOCYM MocI<oncromm:pyraor 15an-
pe",,2002r N2Kr-A40f2-C$U2.
172 CM . KynarnHMIII rOCYMpcreeHHO- eK""KanI<TB/1Io<3MI1IOP"lll' e-
CKOO 111-!L.LO 1111136paHHble TPY.r:lbl. - M.: «Craryr., 1997. C. 105
173 CM. MBKBpOB/J"A. BK oHepHblMI'I 06ll\BGTBBMI'I. ABTope<p. ,QI<C. .
KaHAlOpl>\I\.Hayx M,2002.C 11
174 Ilc:craHoB.neK< Bblcwero Apfi"TproKHOro CYIJ.B P<tI or 08.09.98
N 5167/98I1BeCl"HI1KBACP<tl.1998 N 12.C 57-58.
175 CM .: MeTeJ18naIOA.llpaooBooI10J10_I1BBXW10H8pa B 8f<LII1O HB pHOM06L4BG19B.-
M.:.CTa-ryr..1999.C.117.
176 CM . 363eeaE.E Y aCTl<e 06lljeCTB8rpa>i<,tlBHCKOMo6opoTB. AErro-
pe4).,QI<c. ...KaI\D,.KJPI'\I\.H!iYX M., 2001. C. 10.
177 CM. Py,I:IHeB Il A AHBnl'l3 I1P8B 11 o6oI3aHHocTe iI/<1WIOH8PW - M. 1t13,11aH"e !iBTO-
pa.1927.C 5-6.
178 CM: TapacoB It1.T. Y 8HI1B ofi KOMnaHI1RX - M.: .CTa-ryr., 2OCiO
C 427-428
179 n KOMn!iH""CTO KI13peH"HrpWKJJ,aHCKoronpana -
M. Tl'lnorpacl>I1Rrpa BBaIllK., 1876.C.166.
180 CM .: M030nI1HB.Il. Kopnopa ", MOHOnOnl1"'" np<IBOBCWA. -M.: I113liaTeJ1bCTBO
M\xJ<cJfIc:1<J: ,1966.C206.
-182-
181CM:lle-.pou" euaIOB. AHrn"""Pocc""cpau-
H"TenbHO-npaBOBOO\aHanI13.M. ..j-JOpMa»,2002C.84-86
182 CM KYJ1an1HMIII.r L<1CTI14BCKI<I;;jKanL<1TanL<13M11KJP1'\!\1'14ec-
KOell"40lIliI36paHHblBTPYPPO -M. «CraTyT' 1997C.104
183c...:110MaKl<lH,A,B OHBpHoenpaBOOnmWBHVoe. -M.: oOlapK», 1997.C.64-65.
1B4 CM ' 5enoycooO S. AK 11 npaua aKL.I,IMJHepall3aKoHoABTenbCTBo 1999 N 6
C.30-31
185r Il.H.BonpOCbl npaBB -lleTporpMCeHa-rCKa T,,-
norpa I1R,1915.C.73
186 CM . PyAHeBIl.A.AHanI13np<1BI1 -M'III3lIaH"eaBTO-
pa,1927 C 8-9
187 CM. 110MaKI1H ,A,s. AKI.II1QI-IBPI-JO npaBOOHlOweH"e' nOHIITI1e, COJJ.BpJKaH"e,
Cy!)beKTbl.J:\L<C.. .KaHA, IOPI1,I1. Hayx.-M., 1996.C. 191-192
188c... M030n"HB Il Kopnopa ". MOHonon""" npaOOBCWA. -M '1II3.!iBTB11bCTBO
MocJwocKoruYH"oopc"TBTa,1966.C 256-257
189 CM . Iv\eTeneBa lOA I'lpaBOBOenOl1O>KBHVoe axu...OHepa" aKL\I10HBpHoMoeiw.ecrne.-
M: ..1999C.133
190 CM KOH,lJ,OBTOBH.H.Co6paH"ea"""'OHeOOB.npo6enbl lI3aKo-
HQ.lJ.BTBnbCTUO 1998 N 9.C 23
191TapacoBIII.T.Y'leH"eOOaKu.>IOHepHblX _M.:«CTa1YT",2000 C.438-439.
192CM.:5enoYCOOOB.AK Rl1npaeaaKL.I,IMJHepall 1999 N 6.
C3'
193c.. lle-.poBl1 eBBIO.B.h oHepHOe3BKOHQ!lBJenbCT8oAHrnIII-1Pocc"" (:paB-
HL<1T8J1 aHBl1L>13.-M.:I'I3.!IBTI!J1bGT80..t--iopMBo>.2002IX.
194L1epeHoBLI,B.,Tpo'--IBHKOC.A. KOH'--IBnl(I1R Kan..ranaI!3a-
KOHOlIiITI!J1bGT60.1999 N!!6.C.4S--46.
195(M Epay/J,elll. AKw<oHBjJHblB06U1BCTB8I1TOBBPI1LJ.J,eCTBaBTOprOBIle" npoMblwneH-
HOCT...-M.. I13.!IBTBnbC1BO llpawl1_b>,1926.C.12-17
196 CM . 1t13pB31lL<1T M.H AK oHepHble oeiw.ecrne. _ M.: lt1:?J],aTenbC1BO 3KOHOM"'BCKaR
JKI13Hb>, 1927 C.41-42
197 CM TapacoBIIIT Y eH"eol5 KOMnaH"RX.-M «CraTYT",2000 C.412.
198 CM . JlOM8X"HJJ,.B Al<4L<OHBjJHOO.--paoor:rniOlJ.-M. .cnapK', 1997 C 23-24
199 CM .: MeTeneBBIOA IlpawEIOBnWlo)!(IJHl1eaKl(lo1oHBpaBaKUI1QHepHOM06L41JCHle.-
M.:«CrBJYT', 1999.C. 185-186
200 CM . Xap'<€HKO C.B rpa>KJJ,aHCKo-npaBOBa oxpaHa np<IB aKL.LI'IOHBjJOU np" COBep-
WeH"I-!C,!\enoKcaK RM"OTJ(JJbJTblXaK OHBPHblXo6U<BCTB,ABTOpe<P AI1C. KaIUl.
1Op"JJ..Hayx M,2001.C 8-9
201 Il KoMnaH""CTQ K..apeH"Rrpa>KJJ,aHCKOronpaBB _
M. T"norpa I1R rpa4eBalll K, 1876. C. 137-138.
202 CM . JloMl'\IJ,3eO.llepexoJJ. blxnpaBY"BCTH"KOBICJPOWNBO<I1X
l1"u!lPocCI1 KaflIOCTI< .1999.N 10C.16
-183-
203CM.:)(apieHKoc.B.r I'1JBI!OI!aROxpaHanpaBClKW10HBjJOBnp"COOOpwe-
H""CJ1iII10KCClKW1 M"OTKPblfblXaKW10HePHblX06LJ.I!!CTB:J\sroJJB<lJ ,II,Io1C. ..Kal<,ll,.
IOj)I-1,O"Hayx.M,2001 C.9
204 TaM )KB C.10
205 YTB .IlocIattI:EneHI-1eMIl>Kl\EiOT3112Yl N245.
206TapaCOOlt1T Y eH"eo5 KOMIlBH" X -M. «Cra:ryr-.2000.C 314
207 CM . r IlH Bonpocbl npaea -1le-r.oorpa,u"CeHarCKa
T"norpa I1R,1915.C 29-31.
208IlYHKT17 llneHYMaBepxoeHoroCy,QaP<tl"llneHYMaBblCwero1\SJ-
6..rrpaJl<Horo CyfJ/'J Po:t> OT 01 "!CInR 1996 r. N2 6/8 «0 HeKoropbIx nollpOcax, CBR3BH-
Hblxc ..aCT"nepuoO\rpB>KABHcKoroKoAeKCaPo:t>-
209CM.' MEffeneealOA llpaooooenOJlo)!(BHOIBClKW1oHBjJaBiiKUI'\OHepHOM06U2CTOO -
M..«CraTyT-, 1999.C. 180-181
210 TaM )KB C.182
211IlYHKT17 llneHYMa CyfJ/'JP<tI"llneHYMaBblCwe.-o1\SJ-
6..rrpaJl<Horo CyfJ/'J P<tIOT 1111011 1996 r 6/8 O HBKOTOpblX BOnpocax, CBR3BHHbIX
cnpI1MBHeH"eM..acrnnepuoO\r KOABKcaPct:J.
212 CM ,Hanp., YKB3aHI-!BbaHKaPocC....OT31.12.98 474-Y.{) I-!..yc-
TauHoroxan..rranaI<pe,!J,l1THOO\opraH "" M"CpeACTBBMIo1»
213 CM: baKW"HCKaC B.IO. Al<4L<OHBjJHOO 061l\BCTBO KaK npaeoua 4>OpMa ol5hBJ\l<He-
H" Kan"TanoB',AL<c. xaHJJ.IOP'llJ.-H8YK.M.1997C 9-10
214 CM. MBTeJ1BeaIOA IlpaBOBoe nonQ;l(l!H"B aKW10HBpa 8 aKl1I10HBpHOM 06UjBCTB1!. _
M.: "CraTyTo, 1999. C 177-178.
215 CM . Py,I:IHeBIlA AHan''3npaBl106R3aHHOCTB iII<UIIOHEIJW -M. 1t13.IiBH"eClBTo-
pa,1927.C 5-6,17,19
216 yTB . MI-!H3KOHOM"KI1" HaHco P<tI10 HBapR 1992 r.
217 CM 'A.r:iaMOBI1 r 11 06eCne<ieHl1eI-!HTepecoB aK OHepoBBnpaBe
PoCC"""CTP'IH COI038.,J\srope<P1\I'Ic.KaI<,ll"KJPI1,I1.Hay M
2002 C.14
218 CM . 3aL1jl1TaMenl(lo1XaK OHe.ooB IIllpaBO 11 npep.npI1HI1MarBnbCTBo(3apy6e)KHbl
onblT).C6.0fu0poe..pe4>epaTOB/PAH It1HLilOH,A<PaHBCbE!eaEr (OTe. PBJ1,-coCT.)
"JJP.M.2003C-49
219 CM 'A.r:iaMOBI1 r.n 06ec.--eHl1eI-!HTepecoB ClK OHBjJOBBnpaBe
Pocc",,"crpaHEBpc:nei'icKorOCOICl3B.J\srOpe<p 1\I'IC.. KaI1D,.!OP"A Hay .M,
2002 C.10
220 CM PQl:J,HoeaO.M IIp,,pop,anpae,rp1HB,1:\11B;t<all\l'lXaKW1oHepyl/lOpl-1,O,I< ec,,,,e33-
n"CK" pocnaeCKororOCYAaPCfBBHHorOYH"eepcKTBTaI1M.ll.r ,[IeMl1,IJ,Oua/llQ!\PBJJ,
B.H Kapyawoaa, 11.11. Kpyrm'lKoua B.B. EyrHBua - pocnallllb. 2000. Bbln. 4. C. 156.
221 CM . 1loMaKI1H ,[\.B Pl(4I10HepttOBnpaBOOTHOIlJeHOIB -M «CnapK', 1997 C.53,73, 104
222 CM . ,Aon"Hcxas<B-B Al<4L<OHBjJHoonpaoo:Y-<e6H"K/OrB PBJJ,.A.IO.K86anK"H-
M.ICJp\-1A.I1I1T.,1997C.175
223 CM . M03OJl"HBllllpaooooe l1peAnpI1H" "
OCHOBHble TBHJlBH'--I"" pa3B"T" 3aKoH 0 Kopnopa,--\l1 x B CWA.
AnTOpeq:..1\I'IC .,AOKT IOP"A,HaYK.-M,1976.C 18.
-184-
224 Pyt\Heu Il.A. AHan"3 np<Iu 11 OO<!3aHHOCTe>; aK oHBpou - M 11131\BH..e aBTOpa,
1927 C.25.
225 CM . Epay/J,eIll.AKw<OHBjJHblBo6ujecrnaI1TOBB,O\'IU\BCTBB8TOproBJ1B"IIpOMbilIJ/I8I1-
"OCTI1.-M' I13liaTenbCTBO_llpaBOI1>K"3Hb»1926.C.24
226 PyAHeBIl.A.AHan"3npaBI1 aK OHBpoB -M. 11131\BH..eaBTOpa,
1927 C.24
227 CM' M03OJl"H B. n IlpaBOBOB nQJ10)KeH..e npe.o.npI1H"MaTenbCK"X KOjJnopa .. I-!
OCHOBHble TBHMH'--I"" pa3B"T" 3aKoH 0 KopnOpa'--lI1RX B CWA.
AnTOpeq:..,QI<C .I\OKT IOP"ll,HaYK.-M,1976.C 18
228YrB. Io1BMtt>KLl6oT04anpeJ1 2002r.N"-421/p.
229 CM . KawaH"Ha T B. KopnoparnBHoe np<IBO (npaBO x03RO\cTBeHHbIX TOBap"w,BCTB
,,06ll\BCTU) Y e6H"K I\I1R ByBOB - M. l113liarenbCKa rpynna HopMa41H<ppa-M,
1999.C.419
23°r\ocTaHoBrletMe41<MepallbHQl"Oapt'iorrpa;t<HoroCYABMOCKOBCKOroOxpyraor 11 MOP-
Ta2002r N Kr-J\40J1145-02
231 CM Po;I,HoBBO.M.Ilp"pop,a I1pBB, nplo1HB,Q,ITB>KallJ,m(aK'--l"OHepy II IOpl-1,O,l< ec""e 33-
n"CK"S1pocnaBCKororocyABpcTEIBHHorOYH"sepcl1TBTa"M.nr J],eMl1,D,08B/lloJIpeA.
B.H Kaprawoea. Jl.n. Kpyrm'lKOBa, B.B. EyniBBa - S1pocnallllb, 2000. Bbln. 4. C. 156.
232ApXI1B epanbHoro CyfJ/'J OI:PYT"B.Kacca _
OHHOBAenoN!1664}96
233 CM . JlOMBKIo1HJ].8.AKw<oHepHoon,oa8OOTHOU.OBH"e.-M:.cnap",. 1997 C. 109-110
234 CM .: PyAHBB Il A. AHanl13 npaBl1o&13aHHocTBlila oHepoB. -M I113liaH"eaBTo-
pa,1927.C 30
235TapacoolllT Y eH"e06 KoMIlaH"RX -M _Cra-.yr". 2000. C 417
236 ll"ceMCKI1 Il AK oHepHble KOMIlaHI1" c TQ K" apeH"" rpa!K,lJ,aHCKOrO npaBa _
M. TI1norpa I1Rrpa4eBalll K.,1876.C.220-221.
237 TaM >KB C.222
238 TaM >KB C.222-223
239TapacooIt1T.Y eH"e06 -M. «CraTYT", 2000. C 483.
240 CM. KaMI1HKaA.1II o.ePK"TOPI"OBOronpaBa. -M. AO LleHTP 2002.
C 360
241CM.:JlOMaKl1H.o.,B J\j(L.I"OHepHoenpa8OOTHOU.OBH"e.-M.: , 1997 C.111-118.
242 PyAHBB Il.A. AHanl13 npaB 11 06f13BHHocTBi'l aK OHBpoB _ M.: I113liaHI>IB aBTopa,
1927 C.17
243 Xl1I1n,I],JK. O6pa3bl aK oHepallllpaBol1 BnbCTBo(3apy6e)KHbli:1
onbIT). C6. ofuopoBI1 peq,ePBTOBI PAH IIIHIttOH I AdlaHac:bE!BB E.r COTB CBJI.-cocT1
"JJP.M.2003C-33
244 CM .: MeT8J1eBBIO.A.IlpaBOBOBnOJ1o)K8Hl1Ba oHBpaBaK'--IOOHepHOMo6ujecrna.-
M:'<Cra-.yr..1999.C-141
24500.1 IlOMaKl1H.o.,B.AKL.II'KJHepHoe 'noHflTl1B,CQ!J,BP)KBHI1B,C)Ifibe1<-
Tbl KBHA IOP"A- HaY". M., 1996 C 212
-185-
246 CM .: llopIw,oKn'J6n KaIJ,l1" ro.!IO!IO Ol'iernocrnon<pblTbIM"aKUl'lO-
HepHbll\IO>I06U\i!CTBBMI1, np Ka30MMI1I$11HP<tIor28HORt5pn1996r.
N2 10; OC06eHHocrn ny6n"KaIJ,l1" rQ!\OBot:16yxranrepcl<O OT'-fBTHocrn crpaxOBblM
CprWII<3BIJ.""MI1.YTBBP>KABHHblBf1JJ"Ka30MM"H<p"HaP<tloT214>eepanR 1997r N 17
247 CM . OpacKpblTl<""H pM(lU,l<..o6 blXI1"4B><OTKpbl-
TbOlaKIJ)'IOHepHblxol5w.ecrn,ymeP>KJ:IBHHOe c])KLj6PQ:1m1anpe-
11 2003 r. Ne03-19/nc; OIl0!10nHmeJ1bHblXCBf!lJ!H'AX. KOropbl8 OTKpbITOeaK O-
HepHoe06l1\BCTBoolS 3BHo BcpBACTBaxMacooBOO\I-!H<PoPMaLWI".
c])KLj6P<t1OT6MaR1996rN 9
248 1l0pRAOK ,,06'beM,,H<3XJpMau,I1I1,KOTopylO8Kl111oHepHoe06l1\BCTBooOO3BHol1\'6nI1KO-
BBThBCJlfIBen;.6nI14Horopa3 I1RI1MOOJ1"rBL1l'lO\I-!"HblXL4BHHbI)(r5yMar,onpe-
ABneHlloCTaH08l1BHI1BMc])KLj6P<t1m7 MaR 1996 r N!!8 1l0J10)KBH"e0 nopR.!1K8"
oobBMepaexpblTl1RI1H(jxJPMaLJ,l-'ll1on<pb1TbIM,,axLWKJHepHbIMl106!aeCTBBMl1np11pa3-
Mel1\BH""BKIJ)'I""'--LBHH""'r5yMar, BaKUl'l",ymeP>KABHollo(aaHOU-
l1eH"BMc])KLj6oT20anpeI1 1998r N 9
249YTB.llocTaHOlllleHI-1eMa>KL\6or310S.o2MI7/rr:;
250 1locra-tc:&1etMct>e;J,epal1bHoroap6&<Tp<1>KHoro CYM l\iIocKoBc><cIrot<pyrnor 4HO-
fl6p 2002rN!!Kr-A40/7395-02
251 CM.. MeTeJ1eBBIO.A.IlpaBOBoeI1OJ1o)KBHl1BaKUl'loHBpaB HepHOMooIljBCTBe.-
M.:"CHlJyr', 1999.C. 151.
252IlOCTBHORIIBHl1ect>Mepanbl.mroap6l1TpBJKHOroCYMMOCKOBCKOrOOl:pyra0T4Map.
ra2003r.N2Kr-A41J4n-Q3.
253CM.:JlOMBKI1H.o.,B AKW1oH8PHoe -M. <>CnapK', 1997 C 22-23.
254 CM.. MeTeJ1eea 1O.A.IlpaBOBDBI10J10*BHl1BaKUl'lOHBpa B at<4"OHepHOM OOIljBCTBe.-
M.:"CHlJyr', 1999.C. 187.
255JloMaKI1HJ:\.BAKUI'IOHepHDBI"J'BIIOOTHOO-!Hl1e.nOHRrne, C')6beKTbl
,lI,1.1c .KaHJ\.IOPI-1,O,.HBYK.M., 1996 C.210
256 TaM )I(8 C.210-212
257(M 6eJlOYCOBO.B.hIJ,l1Rl1npaBaa oHepa!l 1999 N!!6.C.33.
258(M Ill>ICeMC"""n AKW10HBjJHbIBKOMnaH""CTCI'!K"3peH"Rrpa>K,lJ,BHCKOronpaea _
M:T"norpa<P"Rrpa eealt1K.1B76.C, 160-161
2590,.. Tapacoult1 T Y4eHI1BOOaKUJ<CHBp-IblXKOMnaHI1RX.-M..<Crmyr.,2000,C.444-445
260CM'rpa>K,O,aHc><oenpaeo.B2T TOM 1 Y e6H"K/Il0)J,pe,u,.E-A CyxaHOBa.-M
lt1:3,IJ,BTenbCTBoEiEK, 2000 C.103-104.
261 CM. JloMaKI-IH.o., B.AKl1I1OHepHDB "8.-M. <>CnapK>, 1997.C 113.
262IlyHKT121t1 Il"CbMall,oe3l-1,O,1fyMaBACOT21anpenR1998r N233
.0000pnpaKrnK pa3peweH" CIlopoBno KBM,CBR3BHHblMC "
oI5paujeH11BM8Kl111I)i.
263 CM . Al-uvJeeelO. cnopblcy.<aCT"eMaK oHBpoBI!Pocc""cKaSl
1OCT" R.1998 N!!4.C 30.
264 CM.: MeTeJ1eea 1O.A.IlpaBOBDBI1OJ1o:1<BHl1BaKl1l1oHBpa B aK4"OHepHOM 06ujecrna._
M...CraTYf., 1999.C. 110.
265 JlOMaK H.o.,B.AK OHepHOB "8.-M <>Cnapx>, 1997.C. 115.
-186-
266 CM 1t13pa3l1"TM H AKw<OHBjJHblB . _M.: lt1:?J],aTenbCTBO 3KOHOM"'ecxa..
JKI13Hb>o, 1927 C.43.
267 MeTeneBalO.A.Ilpa Boel1C\f1Cl>KetME!aKL\I1oHepaBaK4L'1OHepHoMooIl\E!CTBe -M.
-CraJYT>, 1999.C 187
268CM.:JlOMBKIo1HL\.B. 1"J)BB(J()THWJ -M.:..cnapx> 1997.C.20.
269 Acm"HCKB B B. AKL\I10HepHOB npaBO. Y e6H"K I Ora. pet\. A.IO. Kal5anK"H _ M .
IOpl-1,O,.l1Irr.1997C.I40
270JloMaK Hf:J.,B.AK OHepHoe ._M....cnapx>, 1997.C.69.
271 TaMJKB C.52-53
272 CM . r IlH Bonpocbl npaBa -lleTporpa,!!,'CeHBTcKa
T"norpa I1R.1915.C 22
273 CM . CaBaTbBP. Teop">'Io&i3aTeJ1bC1B.lOpl<,lJ,lll ecKlo1"" K"t:1o epK.-
M. Ilporpecc.1972.C 34.
274Tapacoe1llT Y eH"eo6aKL\I10HepHblxKoMnaH"Rx -M ..Cra-.yr», 2000. C 413
275 CM.: ctIoM..,eea HB rJpana aK4L'10HepoB I-! I1X3BL4I1Ta /I Hoaoe POCCI1 KOB f"pa)K-
ABHCKOe3BKOHOJ\BTenbCTBOl1npBKn<KBeronp"MBHeH" 'C60pH"KHBy-<HbOlCTa-ret:11
1l0llpet\.3.1t1 CapaTOU:crAll, 1998 C,63
276TapacoeIllT.Y eH"e06 -M. «CraTYT", 2000. C 424.
2T7L1w ncrJloMaK"Hf:J.,B. oe:nOHRHle.COABjJ)K8HI<IB,
Cyfu.eKTbl.f:J.L<C... KaI1Q,IOpI1,l1.HayK.M,1996.C.116.
278l\m ncrToMC"HOBBA.llpol5neMbI npaaaBTPYA8XPYCcK"xnpaBo-
BBJ:IOBBTOpo,, XlXHa an8)()(B.1I3aKOHOJ\BTBnbCTBO 1998 N 7C 81
279 CM : )(poMyuJl1H III. KaK nOM"PI1Tb PblHOK 11 I1PiiBO? IB 3aLW1TVI1PiiB aKL\I10HepOB) II
PblHOKIJBHHblxr5yMar.1999 N 24.C.22
280r IlH.Bonpocbl onpaBa -lleTporpa,!!,.CeHaTCKa!1TI1-
norpa I1R,1915.C 46
281 Il KOMnaH""CTO K"3peH" rpB>K,!\BHCKoron,oaua _
M. T norpa I1R rpa eBB III K, 1876. C. 145.
282TapacoelllT Y eHIo1B06aK oHepHblx -M. _CraJYT>,2000.C 264.
283llapnaMBHTCK Gi3Bnpoc 11,De.r:\cMaTBJ1lOllpaBKTenbCTBB P<tIM M.KaCbSIHOey..Q6yJ1Y'1-
WBH "'OprBH pa!5cm,ll1>MepanbHOf"O 4>J11!\B
n03BW,l1TBnpaBI!KIIB!I""KOB"at<UI10HepoB>lrJJI1HflTnocraHOB1IBHVoBMrocy,!IBpCIB6H-
HoGi,[l,yMblttle;\epanbHQl"oCOOpaHVlRP<tIOT30oKrn6PR2002r.N!3225-lIlrJJ,J.
284 CM .: ctIoH,O,bln03BU$lTenp<lBBKI1M "KOBl1a OHBpOB. -M. It1:v\BTBnbC1B04!y1.,
2851 ; : e3I-1,O,eHTa P<tI OT21.03.96 N!408 ..Q6yrBep)l(,lJ.BH"1-!
nporpaMMbI...epno npaUBKI18J\ "KOB"aKL\I10HePOU'''YKB3IlpB3''-
ABHTaP<tlor160797N!730.{)rOCYABpcrneHHOHKOM"cc""n03BlW<TE!npaBI1H-
BBCTOpoBHa I-!4>JHAOBOMpbIHKaXPOCCl>lI-!'
286 CM . )(poMyuJl1H III. KaK nOM"p..-rb PblHOK 11 npauo? (B 3BUJ)fl)fnpau aKL\I10Hepou) II
PblHOKIJBHHblX6YMar 1999.N 24.C.23-25
_187_
287 B.4J.[I"HaM"Ka HoronpaBOOTHOWeHI<IR..rpa>K,lJ,BH_
CKO-npaBOBa o-mercmeo<HOCTb.AEITOpe<P A"C.KBHJ\.IOPI-1,O,.HBYK.Jl.1981 C 17
288 CM : M030nl1HB Il 1(0pnopaLll1", MOHonon111111 np<IBOBCWA -M: 1II3.!lilTeJ1bGTOO
1\r1cM:J<oIIcI< ,1966.C266.
289 Yrn .I"bctaHceneo<I1BMllpau..-renbCTBBP<tIor3011IOHR2CK)4r N!317
290YTB. o1>KU5or31 Ma 2002r N'117/nc.
291 CM . EenoycoBOB AK "npaeaaK4l10Hepa! 1999.N26C.32;
CaBI1KouAO HBt<:DJqJbIX npo6.neMBX, CBR3BHHbIX C npIo13HBH"eM peweH" o6laero CQ-
6paH" aKW1oHepos MIIXo:Yl CTBOl1npaBo.2000.N'19.C.70-72.
292IlocTaHOaneH"ectleJ:iepanbHQroap6..,-paJKHOrOCY/JiJ,MOCKOBCKCIroOK,Oyraor12Ma<1
2003r.N Kr-A41/2519--03
293 CM . CaBI1KOBA.O HeKOTopbIXnp06nBM8X, C8!13aHHbOlC np\<13HBH\<1eM peweH\<1 OOIljl'!-
rocc(i.oaH"RBK4L<OHBpOB IIX03I'IO\cTe0l1n.oaElO.2000.N 9.C.73
294 ctleJ:iepanbHoroap6..,-paJKHOrOCYA8- OKJI'j{Gor11(jJe_
BpanR2002r.N'1Kr-A41/195-02
295 1l0000HOlllleH"e IlneHYMB Bepto&toro CyfJ/'J OT 10.10.01 N2 12..0 aonpoce, B03-
H"KweMnpl1f1P1'1MeHeH""ctleJ:iepanbHoro3aKoHB 06 06LIIBCTBaX',
296CrenaHoBIlB.Ilp"HLlI1nbl KOpnooarI1BHblXUTHoweHI1 IIXoo!l CT-
B0l1nDauo.2002 N24C.86-87
297 OCOK"Ha r I<o<:EE»tiB I1CI<I< peanbHoCTb 1Nl" 4>"K R IIXooRi'iCTBOI1 np<Iuo. 2001
M1.C.84-87.
298 ctleJ:iepanbHOroap6I1TPBJKHOroCYfJ/'JMocKoIIct«JroOKpyrBOT15 H-
BBP!'2003r N Kr-A41J8615-02
2ggy,-8 1lpe3lo1.UJ.'lYMactleJ:iepanbHoroap6I'fTP<VKHoroCYfJiJMOCKOB-
cKorOOKpyraor23MBj)Ta2000r N 3
300 CM.. MeTeJ1eea 1O.A.IlpaBOBDBn0l10:oKBHl1BaK4"OHBPB B aK4"OHepHOM otillJecrne.-
M.: ..Cnnyr., 1999. C 158.
301Ilpo6neMbITeoPI1I1 l1npaBa.Y e6Hoenoc06\<1e./1l0)J,pep,.MH.Map-
..eHKO._M."npocneKT', 1999 C.469
302 C8H<pIUI"nno "Ie3BPB. Kypc pl1MCKoro ..acrnoro np<Iea Y-<e6H"K IIlQlJ, PE\O.. .[I.B
,IJ,o>I:Aesa -M..III3liaTBnbCTB06EK,2000.C.211
303 IOPI-1,O,...,ecKI1"cnoeapb.-M.PycC><"""3b1K, 1985.C 414,416
304 Wann R OcHOBbi rpa>K,lJ,BHcKoro npaaa repMaHI<II<I. Y4e5HI1K. _ M. I113liaTeJ1bCTBO
EEK, 1996 C.39
305 1l0KjXluc><"i'i III A. OCHOBHble npo6JJeMbi rPBi'<ABHC npaea. _ M «Cra:ryr.
1998. C. 236
306 CM.. ArapxOB M M. O&I3a.TenbCTeo no COBBTCKOMY rpaJK,O,BHc><oMY npaey. _ M
1Op"3,O,aT,1940.C.44
307 CM rpaJK,O,BHCKOenp<luo. '1aCTbl Y e6H"K/IlO)J,pw\.IO.K TonCToro,A.1l CBpre-
eaa -M. It13JJ,BTBJ1bGTOOTEIiIC, 1996 C.480
-188-
308IlPBAIlPI1HI1M!ITBnbGKOB (X03 t:1CT8eHHOe) npaBO Y e6HI1K B 2T. T. 11 Ore. pep,.
OM Onet:1HI1K-M IOpI1CT,1999.C.461
3091l0ll0l1lJ.0!lYnoB.ctI.,AI1HaMI1Ka npaBOOTHOU.!eHI1 I1rp<t)l(,!laHCKO-
npaeosa OJBeTCJ8eHHOCTb,J\srope4>.AI1C...Kaf\l\.KJPI1,I1.Ha'J1<.Jl., 1981.C.I1. 13.
310CM COBeTCKoerpa.>i(,!laHCKoenpaWY«e(5HI1K B2-XTT 1/1l0)J,00lI.OAKpacaB-
I-!KOBa. - M . BblCWafI WKOJ1a, 1985. C. 423
311 CM S1" KOU K.K CI1CTeM8 06 3aTenbCTu np" "HeH" IIpeAa B COBerCI<OM np<I-
Bell BonpoCbl rpa>K,O,aHCKoro np8ea' C60PH"K CTaTet:1/lloA PBlI. nJJ04>. It1 E Ho-
BI141(Oro -M.. MocKOBCKorO ,1957.C 148.
312 CM C8u8n,eP Teop""06 3aTe/lbC1B.I(JpI>vJ,oI ecK,,t:1I1 o epK-
M 1t13l1aTeJ1bG1BO"rlporpecc». 1972.C 305
313 CM . lt1octxt>eO.C npaBO.-M IOpl-1,O,.n"T., 1975 C.16
314 CM . S1" KOBK K c..CTeM8o6 3aTenbGTB BJ)elIaBcoeeTQj(oMnpa-
BeIlBonpOCbl npaBa'C60pH"KCTaTeO\/llo.l1 pet\.nJJ04>.It1.E Ho-
B"4Koro -M. MocKoBc YH"eepc"TeT8,1957.C 146-154.
315It1octxt>eOC. npauo.-M'lOpl-1,O,.nlfT.1975.C 16
316u...T.no.raB3ec]).III. npaBO(o6lU)<eI'1ClflCl>l<eK1J.-MI1HCK:
III3lIaTeJ1bCTBOEI"YI1M BIt1 JleH"H8, 1968 C.10
3171l0noHJ\OnynoB.o:1:>.CaHK R8 / roc.YH_T_Bna_
,QI<BOCTQK, 1983 22c.PyKon"CbAen BIIIHIt10HAHCCCP10.0583;N 12921 C.12
318(M 'Epay/J,e1t1 AKl.U'IOHepHblB06wecrnal-!roeap"w.ecrnaBToprollllel1 wnett-
HOCTI1. - M.: KoonepamBHOe 11:?J],aTeJ1bCTBO ..rJpaBO 11 >KI13Hb», 1926. C. 29.
319 CM. Epar..HCK"t:1 M.III. BI<lpRHC""" B.B ,/J,oroBcIpHoe npaoo. KH"ra nepea 06-
lI1"el1ClJ'1Dl4e.-.m.-M,'<Cra-.yr.,200I.C676-694;raBpl1l1088.l-Ietvropt.IeacneK-
TbIClT8e1CT8etHJCT3aHBpyweHI-1eA€H8JKHbOlo&l3a TeJ1bCT8 I1 X o:YlO\cTBOl1npaeo.
2001 N 9C 00-00
320cM.r Il.H.Bonpocbl npaea._lleTporpBA.CeHBTcKBSI
T .1915.C66-70
321IlYHKT22 IlneHYMa8epxJaHoroCyfJ/'JP<tII-!IlneHYMaBblCUJero1\SJ-
6l1'T"p11:1(Horocyp,aPo:1:>m1 I-!IOI1R 1996r N26/8-DHeI<OTtJPbIXBOnpocax,CBR3BHHblX
cn "acmnepBO"rpaJK,lJ,BHCKoroKOJJ.BKcaPo:t>o
322CM.: ,RObertW ThBlawofcopm3limsinanulshel1 SI. Paul, Minn West
Publishing CO. 1996.P 98-101
323CM:llonoeaE.llonoBE. ByanbI!X03R CTBOl1npaBO 2002 12
C.62
324 Jones v Upman (1962) 1 W. A L 832 (CM: IlonoBa E ,llonoB E. KOpnopaTl1BHBfI
ByanbllXo3mcyooI1 npaBO. 2002 N 12C. 69)
325 CM 'Mo30n"HBIl..IOJ:ieHKOBA.1l K4>eJJ,epanbHOMY3BKOHy..ooBK-
W10HBPHblXo6laecTBaX» -M. IIIH<Ppa-M 2002 C.21
326 Iloo<poocK1-tM iliA QcHouHble npo&1eMbi rpa>KABHCKoro np<Iua - M. «Cra:ryr-,
1998 C.243
-189-